This is a modern-English version of The History of Rome, Books 09 to 26, originally written by Livy. It has been thoroughly updated, including changes to sentence structure, words, spelling, and grammar—to ensure clarity for contemporary readers, while preserving the original spirit and nuance. If you click on a paragraph, you will see the original text that we modified, and you can toggle between the two versions.

Scroll to the bottom of this page and you will find a free ePUB download link for this book.

 

 


 

 

 

THE HISTORY
OF ROME.

BY
TITUS LIVIUS.

BOOKS NINE TO TWENTY-SIX.

LITERALLY TRANSLATED,
WITH NOTES AND ILLUSTRATIONS,
BY
D. SPILLAN AND CYRUS EDMONDS.

1868.




       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK IX.
B.C. 321-304


Titus Veturius and Spurius Postumius, with their army, surrounded by the Samnites at the Caudine forks; enter into a treaty, give six hundred hostages, and are sent under the yoke. The treaty declared invalid; the two generals and the other sureties sent back to the Samnites, but are not accepted. Not long after, Papirius Cursor obliterates this disgrace, by vanquishing the Samnites, sending them under the yoke, and recovering the hostages. Two tribes added. Appius Claudius, censor, constructs the Claudian aqueduct, and the Appian road; admits the sons of freedom into the senate. Successes against the Apulians, Etruscans, Umbrians, Marsians, Pelignians, Aequans, and Samnites. Mention made of Alexander the Great, who flourished at this time; a comparative estimate of his strength, and that of the Roman people, tending to show, that if he had carried his arms into Italy, he would not have been as successful there as he had been in the Eastern countries.

       *        *        *        *        *


1

This year is followed by the convention of Caudium, so memorable on account of the misfortune of the Romans, the consuls being Titus Veturius Calvinus and Spurius Postumius. The Samnites had as their commander that year Caius Ponius, son to Herennius, born of a father most highly renowned for wisdom, and himself a consummate warrior and commander. When the ambassadors, who had been sent to make restitution, returned, without concluding a peace, he said, "That ye may not think that no purpose has been effected by this embassy, whatever degree of anger the deities of heaven had conceived against us, on account of the infraction of the treaty, has been hereby expiated. I am very confident, that whatever deities they were, whose will it was that you should be reduced to the necessity of making the restitution, which had been demanded according to the treaty, it was not agreeable to them, that our atonement for the breach of treason should be so haughtily spurned by the Romans. For what more could possibly be done towards appeasing the gods, and softening the anger of men, than we have done? The effects of the enemy, taken among the spoils, which appeared to be our own by the right of war, we restored: the authors of the war, as we could not deliver them up alive, we delivered them dead: their goods we carried to Rome, lest by retaining them, any degree of guilt should remain among us. What more, Roman, do I owe to thee? what to the treaty? what to the gods, the guarantees of the treaty? What arbitrator shall I call in to judge of your resentment, and of my punishment? I decline none; neither nation nor private person. But if nothing in human law is left to the weak against stronger, I will appeal to the gods, the avengers of intolerant arrogance, and will beseech them to turn their wrath against those for whom neither the restoration of their own effects nor additional heaps of other men's property, can suffice, whose cruelty is not satiated by the death of the guilty, by the surrender of their lifeless bodies, nor by their goods accompanying the surrender of the owner; who cannot be appeased otherwise than by giving them our blood to drink, and our entrails to be torn. Samnites, war is just to those for whom it is necessary, and arms are clear of impiety for those who have no hope left but in arms. Wherefore, as in every human undertaking, it is of the utmost importance what matter men may set about with the favour, what under the displeasure of the gods, be assured that the former wars ye waged in opposition to the gods more than to men; in this, which is now impending, ye will act under the immediate guidance of the gods themselves."

This year is marked by the convention of Caudium, memorable for the misfortunes faced by the Romans, with the consuls being Titus Veturius Calvinus and Spurius Postumius. The Samnites were led that year by Caius Ponius, son of Herennius, who came from a family known for its wisdom, and he himself was a skilled warrior and commander. When the ambassadors sent to negotiate a settlement returned without securing peace, he said, "So you don't think our mission was pointless, whatever anger the gods had against us for breaking the treaty has been addressed. I'm confident that whatever gods required your restitution according to the treaty wouldn’t have wanted us to be so arrogantly rejected by the Romans when trying to atone for our breach of trust. What more could we have done to appease the gods and calm human anger? We returned the spoils of war that were rightfully ours. We couldn’t hand over the war’s creators alive, but we delivered their dead bodies. We took their possessions to Rome so that we wouldn’t hold onto anything that might imply guilt. What more do I owe you, Romans? What more to the treaty? What more to the gods, who uphold the treaty? What judge can I ask to evaluate your anger and my punishment? I refuse none; neither country nor individual. But if there’s nothing left in human law to protect the weak against the stronger, I will turn to the gods, the avengers of intolerable arrogance, and ask them to direct their anger at those who cannot be satisfied with the return of their own possessions or the addition of others'; whose cruelty isn’t satisfied by the death of the guilty, nor by handing over their lifeless bodies or their possessions; who can only be appeased by drinking our blood and tearing out our entrails. Samnites, war is justified for those who need it, and fighting is free of impiety for those with no hope left but in battle. So, as with every human endeavor, it's crucial to consider what favor we have with the gods in our actions; you should know that your previous wars were against the gods more than against men; in this impending conflict, you will be guided by the gods themselves."

2

After uttering these predictions, not more cheering than true, he led out the troops, and placed his camp about Caudium as much out of view as possible. From thence he sent to Calatia, where he heard that the Roman consuls were encamped, ten soldiers, in the habit of shepherds, and ordered them to keep some cattle feeding in several different places, at a small distance from the Roman posts; and that, when they fell in with any of their foragers, they should all agree in the same story, that the legions of the Samnites were then in Apulia, that they were besieging Luceria with their whole force, and very near taking it by storm. Such a rumour had been industriously spread before, and had already reached the Romans; but these prisoners increased the credit of it, especially as they all concurred in the same report. There was no doubt but that the Romans would carry succour to the Lucerians, as being good and faithful allies; and for this further reason, lest all Apulia, through apprehension of the impending danger, might go over to the enemy. The only point of deliberation was, by what road they should go. There were two roads leading to Luceria, one along the coast of the upper sea, wide and open; but, as it was the safer, so it was proportionably longer: the other, which was shorter, through the Caudine forks. The nature of the place is this: there are two deep glens, narrow and covered with wood, connected together by mountains ranging on both sides from one to the other; between these lies a plain of considerable extent, enclosed in the middle, abounding in grass and water, and through the middle of which the passage runs: but before you can arrive at it, the first defile must be passed, while the only way back is through the road by which you entered it; or if in case of resolving to proceed forward, you must go by the other glen, which is still more narrow and difficult. Into this plain the Romans, having marched down their troops by one of those passes through the cleft of a rock, when they advanced onward to the other defile, found it blocked up by trees thrown across, and a mound of huge stones lying in their way. When the stratagem of the enemy now became apparent, there is seen at the same time a body of troops on the eminence over the glen. Hastening back, then, they proceed to retrace the road by which they had entered; they found that also shut up by such another fence, and men in arms. Then, without orders, they halted; amazement took possession of their minds, and a strange kind of numbness seized their limbs: they then remained a long time motionless and silent, each looking to the other, as if each thought the other more capable of judging and advising than himself. After some time, when they saw that the consul's pavilions were being erected, and that some were getting ready the implements for throwing up works, although they were sensible that it must appear ridiculous the attempt to raise a fortification in their present desperate condition, and when almost every hope was lost, would be an object of necessity, yet, not to add a fault to their misfortunes, they all, without being advised or ordered by any one, set earnestly to work, and enclosed a camp with a rampart, close to the water, while themselves, besides that the enemy heaped insolent taunts on them, seemed with melancholy to acknowledge the apparent fruitlessness of their toil and labour. The lieutenants-general and tribunes, without being summoned to consultation, (for there was no room for either consultation or remedy,) assembled round the dejected consul; while the soldiers, crowding to the general's quarters, demanded from their leaders that succour, which it was hardly in the power of the immortal gods themselves to afford them.

After making these predictions, which were more discouraging than truthful, he led the troops out and set up camp around Caudium where it was as hidden as possible. From there, he sent ten soldiers dressed as shepherds to Calatia, where he had heard the Roman consuls were camped. He instructed them to keep some cattle grazing in various locations not too far from the Roman posts and to stick to the same story when encountering Roman foragers: that the Samnite legions were in Apulia, besieging Luceria with their full force and close to capturing it. This rumor had been actively spread before and had already reached the Romans; however, these soldiers added to its credibility, especially since they all reported the same thing. There was no doubt the Romans would rush to help the Lucerians, who were good and loyal allies, and also because they wanted to prevent all of Apulia from fearing the impending danger and joining the enemy. The only thing left to figure out was the best route to take. There were two roads leading to Luceria: one along the coast of the upper sea, which was wide and open but longer due to its safety; the other was shorter but passed through the Caudine Forks. The area was characterized by two deep, wooded gorges connected by mountains on both sides. Between them was a large, grassy plain with plenty of water, but to reach it, they had to pass through the first gorge, with the only way back being the road they had taken; if they decided to continue forward, they would have to go through the other gorge, which was even narrower and more challenging. As the Romans marched their troops down one of those paths through a rocky cleft towards the other gorge, they found it blocked by fallen trees and a mound of large stones. Once the enemy's tactic became clear, they saw troops stationed on the ridge above the gorge. Hurriedly, they turned around to retrace the road they had come in on, only to find that shut off by another barricade and armed men. Without orders, they halted; amazement took over, and a strange numbness gripped their limbs. They stood motionless and silent for a long time, each looking at the others, as if they thought someone else might have a better idea. After a while, noticing that the consul's tents were being set up and that some were preparing tools for construction, they realized that although it seemed foolish to attempt building a fortification in such a dire situation, doing something was necessary since almost all hope was lost. Without anyone advising or ordering them, they all began working earnestly to enclose a camp with a rampart close to the water, even as the enemy taunted them and they recognized the apparent futility of their efforts. The lieutenants general and tribunes, without being called for a meeting (for there was no room for either discussion or solution), gathered around the despondent consul, while the soldiers swarmed to the general's tent, pleading for help that even the immortal gods could barely provide.

3

Night came on them while lamenting their situation rather than consulting, whilst they urged expedients, each according to his temper; one crying out, "Let us go over those fences of the roads;" others, "over the steeps; through the woods; any way, where arms can be carried. Let us be but permitted to come to the enemy, whom we have been used to conquer now near thirty years. All places will be level and plain to a Roman, fighting against the perfidious Samnite." Another would say, "Whither, or by what way can we go? Do we expect to remove the mountains from their foundations? While these cliffs hang over us, by what road will you reach the enemy? Whether armed or unarmed, brave or dastardly, we are all, without distinction, captured and vanquished. The enemy will not even show us a weapon by which we might die with honour. He will finish the war without moving from his seat." In such discourse, thinking of neither food nor rest, the night was passed. Nor could the Samnites, though in circumstances so joyous, instantly determine how to act: it was therefore universally agreed that Herennius Pontius, father of the general, should be consulted by letter. He was now grown feeble through age, and had withdrawn himself, not only from all military, but also from all civil occupations; yet, notwithstanding the decline of his bodily strength, his mind retained its full vigour. When he heard that the Roman armies were shut up at the Caudine forks between the two glens, being consulted by his son's messenger, he gave his opinion, that they should all be immediately dismissed from thence unhurt. On this counsel being rejected, and the same messenger returning a second time, he recommended that they should all, to a man, be put to death. When these answers, so opposite to each other, like those of an ambiguous oracle, were given, although his son in particular considered that the powers of his father's mind, together with those of his body, had been impaired by age, was yet prevailed on, by the general desire of all, to send for him to consult him. The old man, we are told, complied without reluctance, and was carried in a waggon to the camp, where, when summoned to give his advice, he spoke in such way as to make no alteration in his opinions; he only added the reasons for them. That "by his first plan, which he esteemed the best, he meant, by an act of extraordinary kindness, to establish perpetual peace and friendship with a most powerful nation: by the other, to put off the return of war to the distance of many ages, during which the Roman state, after the loss of those two armies, could not easily recover its strength." A third plan there was not. When his son, and the other chiefs, went on to ask him if "a plan of a middle kind might not be adopted; that they both should be dismissed unhurt, and, at the same time, by the right of war, terms imposed on them as vanquished?" "That, indeed," said he, "is a plan of such a nature, as neither procures friends or removes enemies. Only preserve those whom ye would irritate by ignominious treatment. The Romans are a race who know not how to sit down quiet under defeat; whatever that is which the present necessity shall brand will rankle in their breasts for ever, and will not suffer them to rest, until they have wreaked manifold vengeance on your heads." Neither of these plans was approved, and Herennius was carried home from the camp.

Night fell on them as they mourned their situation rather than seeking advice, while they proposed solutions, each according to their nature; one shouted, "Let's go over those road barriers;" others suggested, "over the hills; through the woods; any way where we can bear arms. Just let us reach the enemy, whom we’ve been used to beating for almost thirty years. Every place will be manageable for a Roman fighting against the treacherous Samnite." Another remarked, "Where can we go? How will we get there? Do we expect to move the mountains? With these cliffs looming over us, what path do you plan to take to the enemy? Whether we are armed or unarmed, brave or cowardly, we are all, without exception, trapped and defeated. The enemy won't even show us a weapon to die with honor. He'll end the war just by sitting tight." In this conversation, with no thought for food or rest, the night passed. The Samnites, despite their fortunate situation, couldn't immediately decide what to do: it was agreed by everyone that Herennius Pontius, the general's father, should be consulted by letter. He had grown weak with age and had withdrawn from all military and civil duties; however, despite his physical decline, his mind was still sharp. When he learned that the Roman armies were trapped at the Caudine Forks between two valleys, and was consulted by his son's messenger, he advised that they should be sent away unharmed. When this suggestion was rejected, and the messenger returned again, he recommended that they all be executed. When these contrary responses, like an ambiguous oracle, were given, although his son believed his father's faculties had weakened with age, he was convinced by the general consensus to call him for consultation. The old man complied willingly and was brought to the camp in a cart, where, when asked for his advice, he expressed his views without changing them; he just added his reasoning. He said that "by his first plan, which he deemed the best, he aimed to establish lasting peace and friendship with a powerful nation; by the other, to delay the return of war for many ages, during which the Roman state, after the loss of those two armies, would struggle to regain its strength." There was no third option. When his son and the other leaders asked if "a middle ground could be considered; that they both could be sent away unharmed while also imposing terms on them as if they had lost," he replied, "That, indeed, is a plan that neither gains friends nor eliminates enemies. Just be careful not to anger those you would mistreat. The Romans do not know how to quietly accept defeat; whatever the current crisis brands them will fester in their hearts forever, pushing them to seek revenge on you." Neither of these plans was accepted, and Herennius was taken home from the camp.

4

In the Roman camp also, when many fruitless efforts to force a passage had been made, and they were now destitute of every means of subsistence, forced by necessity, they send ambassadors, who were first to ask peace on equal terms; which, if they did not obtain, they were to challenge the enemy to battle. To this Pontius answered, that "the war was at an end; and since, even in their present vanquished and captive state, they were not willing to acknowledge their situation, he would send them under the yoke unarmed, each with a single garment; that the other conditions of peace should be such as were just between the conquerors and the conquered. If their troops would depart, and their colonies be withdrawn out of the territories of the Samnites; for the future, the Romans and Samnites, under a treaty of equality, shall live according to their own respective laws. On these terms he was ready to negotiate with the consuls: and if any of these should not be accepted, he forbade the ambassadors to come to him again." When the result of this embassy was made known, such general lamentation suddenly arose, and such melancholy took possession of them, that had they been told that all were to die on the spot, they could not have felt deeper affliction. After silence continued a long time, and the consuls were not able to utter a word, either in favour of a treaty so disgraceful, or against a treaty so necessary; at length, Lucius Lentulus, who was the first among the lieutenants-general, both in respect of bravery, and of the public honours which he had attained, addressed them thus: "Consuls, I have often heard my father say, that he was the only person in the Capitol who did not advise the senate to ransom the state from the Gauls with gold; and these he would not concur in, because they had not been enclosed with a trench and rampart by the enemy, (who were remarkably slothful with respect to works and raising fortifications,) and because they might sally forth, if not without great danger, yet without certain destruction. Now if, in like manner as they had it in their power to run down from the Capitol in arms against their foe, as men besieged have often sallied out on the besiegers, it were possible for us to come to blows with the enemy, either on equal or unequal ground, I would not be wanting in the high quality of my father's spirit in stating my advice. I acknowledge, indeed, that death, in defence of our country, is highly glorious; and I am ready, either to devote myself for the Roman people and the legions, or to plunge into the midst of the enemy. But in this spot I behold my country: in this spot, the whole of the Roman legions, and unless these choose to rush on death in defence of their own individual characters, what have they which can be preserved by their death? The houses of the city, some may say, and the walls of it, and the crowd who dwell in it, by which the city is inhabited. But in fact, in case of the destruction of this army, all these are betrayed, not preserved. For who will protect them? An unwarlike and unarmed multitude, shall I suppose? Yes, just as they defended them against the attack of the Gauls. Will they call to their succour an army from Veii, with Camillus at its head? Here on the spot, I repeat, are all our hopes and strength; by preserving which, we preserve our country; by delivering them up to death, we abandon and betray our country. But a surrender is shameful and ignominious. True: but such ought to be our affection for our country, that we should save it by our own disgrace, if necessity required, as freely as by our death. Let therefore that indignity be undergone, how great soever, and let us submit to that necessity which even the gods themselves do not overcome. Go, consuls, ransom the state for arms, which your ancestors ransomed with gold."

In the Roman camp, after many unsuccessful attempts to break through and running low on food, they were forced by necessity to send ambassadors. Their first request was for peace on equal terms; if that wasn’t granted, they were prepared to challenge the enemy to a fight. Pontius responded that "the war is over; and since, even in their defeated and captured state, they refuse to acknowledge it, I’ll send them under the yoke, unarmed, each dressed in just one garment. The other terms of peace will reflect what is fair between the conquerors and the conquered. If their troops pull back and their colonies leave Samnite territory, then the Romans and Samnites can live by their own laws under a treaty of equality in the future. On these terms, I’m open to negotiating with the consuls; but if any of this is rejected, I won’t see the ambassadors again." When this message was delivered, widespread mourning broke out, and sorrow overwhelmed them, so much so that if they had been told they would all die then and there, they couldn’t have felt more grief. After a lengthy silence, the consuls couldn’t say a word, either in favor of such a disgraceful treaty or against such a necessary one. Finally, Lucius Lentulus, the leading lieutenant-general for his bravery and public honors, spoke up: "Consuls, I often heard my father say he was the only one in the Capitol who didn’t advise the Senate to pay the Gauls in gold to free the state because they hadn’t been surrounded by a trench and walls by the enemy, who were remarkably lazy when it came to building defenses. They could have charged down from the Capitol, just like besieged men sometimes rush out against their besiegers. If we could fight the enemy, whether on even or uneven ground, I wouldn’t shy away from expressing my opinion with the same courage my father had. I acknowledge that dying for our country is highly noble; I’m ready to sacrifice myself for the Roman people and the legions or to throw myself into the fray. But right here is my homeland, and right here are all the Roman legions. Unless they choose to face death out of a sense of personal honor, what do they have left to protect by dying? Some might say the city’s houses, its walls, and the people living in it. But if this army is destroyed, all of that is lost, not saved. Who is going to protect them? A defenseless and unarmed crowd? Just like they defended themselves against the Gauls? Will they call for an army from Veii, led by Camillus? Right here, I say again, are all our hopes and strength; by preserving them, we save our country; by surrendering them to death, we abandon and betray our country. But surrender is shameful and disgraceful. True, but our love for our country should be so strong that we’re willing to save it through our own dishonor if that’s necessary, just as freely as we would through our death. So let us bear that indignity, however great, and accept that necessity which even the gods cannot overcome. Go, consuls, ransom the state for weapons, just as your ancestors did with gold."

5

The consuls having gone to Pontius to confer with him, when he talked, in the strain of a conqueror, of a treaty, they declared that such could not be concluded without an order of the people, nor without the ministry of the heralds, and the other customary rites. Accordingly the Caudine peace was not ratified by settled treaty, as is commonly believed, and even asserted by Claudius, but by conventional sureties. For what occasion would these be either for sureties or hostages in the former case, where the ratification is performed by the imprecation, "that whichever nation shall give occasion to the said terms being violated, may Jupiter strike that nation in like manner as the swine is struck by the heralds." The consuls, lieutenants-general, quaestors, and military tribunes, became sureties; and the names of all these who became sureties are extant; where, had the business been transacted by treaty, none would have appeared but those of the two heralds. On account of the necessary delay of the treaty six hundred horsemen were demanded as hostages, who were to suffer death if the compact were not fulfilled; a time was then fixed for delivering up the hostages, and sending away the troops disarmed. The return of the consuls renewed the general grief in the camp, insomuch that the men hardly refrained from offering violence to them, "by whose rashness," they said, "they had been brought into such a situation; and through whose cowardice they were likely to depart with greater disgrace than they came. They had employed no guide through the country, nor scouts; but were sent out blindly, like beasts into a pitfall" They cast looks on each other, viewed earnestly the arms which they must presently surrender; while their persons would be subject to the whim of the enemy: figured to themselves the hostile yoke, the scoffs of the conquerors, their haughty looks, and finally, thus disarmed, their march through the midst of an armed foe. In a word, they saw with horror the miserable journey of their dishonoured band through the cities of the allies; and their return into their own country, to their parents, whither themselves, and their ancestors, had so often come in triumph. Observing, that "they alone had been conquered without a fight, without a weapon thrown, without a wound; that they had not been permitted to draw their swords, nor to engage the enemy. In vain had arms, in vain had strength, in vain had courage been given them." While they were giving vent to such grievous reflections, the fatal hour of their disgrace arrived, which was to render every circumstance still more shocking in fact, than they had preconceived it in their imaginations. First, they were ordered to go out, beyond the rampart, unarmed, and with single garments; then the hostages were surrendered, and carried into custody. The lictors were next commanded to depart from the consuls, and the robes of the latter were stripped off. This excited such a degree of commiseration in the breasts of those very men, who a little before, pouring execrations upon them, had proposed that they should be delivered up and torn to pieces, that every one, forgetting his own condition, turned away his eyes from that degradation of so high a dignity, as from a spectacle too horrid to behold.

The consuls went to meet with Pontius, and when he spoke like a conqueror about a treaty, they pointed out that such an agreement couldn't be made without the people's approval, nor without the heralds' involvement and the usual rituals. So, the Caudine peace wasn't formally ratified through a treaty, as many think—including Claudius—but through agreed-upon guarantees. Why would there even be guarantees or hostages in this case if the ratification was done with the curse, "May Jupiter strike whichever nation causes these terms to be violated, just like the heralds strike the swine"? The consuls, generals, quaestors, and military tribunes acted as guarantors, and all their names are recorded; if this had been a formal treaty, only the heralds' names would’ve been noted. Due to the necessary delay in the treaty, they demanded six hundred horsemen as hostages, who would be executed if the agreement wasn't honored. A timeline was then set for handing over the hostages and disarming the troops. When the consuls returned, it reignited the general sorrow in the camp, to the point that the men barely held back from attacking them, blaming their "recklessness" for putting them in such a situation and accusing them of cowardice that would lead them to leave in even more disgrace than they arrived. They hadn’t used any guides through the territory or sent out scouts; they had been sent out blindly, like animals into a trap. They exchanged looks, closely examined the weapons they were about to surrender, while knowing their fates were now in the enemies' hands. They imagined the oppressive yoke, the mocks from the conquerors, their arrogant gazes, and ultimately, how they would march disarmed through the midst of an armed foe. In short, they envisioned in horror the pathetic journey of their dishonored group through the allied cities and their return to their homeland, to their families, where they and their ancestors had triumphed so many times before. They realized that "they had been defeated without a fight, without throwing a weapon, without a single wound; they hadn’t even been allowed to draw their swords or confront the enemy. Their arms had been useless, their strength wasted, and their courage in vain." As they expressed these heavy thoughts, the moment of their disgrace arrived, which would turn out to be even more shocking in reality than they had imagined. First, they were ordered to step outside the ramparts unarmed and in just their tunics; then the hostages were handed over and taken into custody. The lictors were told to leave the consuls, and their robes were stripped away. This stirred such pity in the very men who had moments before raged against them and suggested they be handed over to be torn apart that everyone, forgetting their own plight, turned their eyes away from the degradation of such high office, as if it were a sight too dreadful to witness.

6

First, the consuls, nearly half naked, were sent under the yoke; then each officer, according to his rank, was exposed to disgrace, and the legions successively. The enemy stood on each side under arms, reviling and mocking them; swords were pointed at most of them, several were wounded and some even slain, when their looks, rendered too fierce by the indignity to which they were subjected, gave offence to the conquerors. Thus were they led under the yoke; and what was still more intolerable, under the eyes of the enemy. When they had got clear of the defile, they seemed as if they had been drawn up from the infernal regions, and then for the first time beheld the light; yet, when they viewed the ignominious appearance of the army, the light itself was more painful to them than any kind of death could have been; so that although they might have arrived at Capua before night, yet, uncertain with respect to the fidelity of the allies, and because shame embarrassed them, in need of every thing, they threw themselves carelessly on the ground, on each side of the road: which being told at Capua, just compassion for their allies got the better of the arrogance natural to the Campanians. They immediately sent to the consuls their ensigns of office, the fasces and lictors; to the soldiers, arms, horses, clothes, and provisions in abundance: and, on their approach to Capua, the whole senate and people went out to meet them, and performed every proper office of hospitality, both public and private. But the courtesy, kind looks, and address of the allies, could not only not draw a word from them, but it could not even prevail on them to raise their eyes, or look their consoling friends in the face, so completely did shame, in addition to grief, oblige them to shun the conversation and society of these their friends. Next day, when some young nobles, who had been sent from Capua, to escort them on their road to the frontiers of Campania, returned, they were called into the senate-house, and, in answer to the inquiries of the elder members, said, that "to them they seemed deeply sunk in melancholy and dejection; that the whole body moved on in silence, almost as if dumb; the former genius of the Romans was prostrated, and that their spirit had been taken from them, together with their arms. Not one returned a salute, nor returned an answer to those who greeted them; as if, through fear, they were unable to utter a word; as if their necks still carried the yoke under which they had been sent. That the Samnites had obtained a victory, not only glorious, but lasting also; for they had subdued, not Rome merely, as the Gauls had formerly done, but what was a much wore warlike achievement, the Roman courage." When these remarks were made and attentively listened to, and the almost extinction of the Roman name was lamented in this assembly of faithful allies, Ofilius Calavius, son of Ovius, a man highly distinguished, both by his birth and conduct, and at this time further respectable on account of his age, is said to have declared that he entertained a very different opinion in the case. "This obstinate silence," said he, "those eyes fixed on the earth,--those ears deaf to all comfort,--with the shame of beholding the light,--are indications of a mind calling forth, from its inmost recesses, the utmost exertions of resentment. Either he was ignorant of the temper of the Romans, or that silence would shortly excite, among the Samnites, lamentable cries and groans; for that the remembrance of the Caudine peace would be much more sorrowful to the Samnites than to the Romans. Each side would have their own native spirit, wherever they should happen to engage, but the Samnites would not, every where, have the glens of Caudium."

First, the consuls, almost completely undressed, were sent under the yoke; then each officer, depending on his rank, experienced shame, followed by the legions one after the other. The enemy stood on both sides with weapons drawn, taunting and mocking them; many had swords pointed at them, several were injured, and some were even killed, as their fierce expressions, made more intense by the humiliation they were enduring, offended the conquerors. Thus, they were marched under the yoke, which was even more unbearable because it was done in front of the enemy. When they finally got out of the narrow pass, it felt as if they had been pulled up from the depths of hell and were seeing the light for the first time; however, when they saw the shameful state of their army, the light itself felt more painful than any kind of death could have been. Even though they could have reached Capua before nightfall, uncertainty about the loyalty of their allies and the weight of their shame made them collapse on the ground beside the road. When this was reported in Capua, the natural arrogance of the Campanians was overcome by compassion for their allies. They immediately sent the consuls their symbols of office, the fasces and lictors, and provided the soldiers with weapons, horses, clothes, and plenty of supplies. As they approached Capua, the entire senate and populace went out to meet them, extending all the proper hospitality, both public and private. But the kindness, warm looks, and attention from their allies could not prompt any response from them; they didn't even lift their eyes to face their comforting friends, so deeply did shame, alongside grief, compel them to avoid any interaction with those they considered allies. The next day, when some young nobles had been sent from Capua to guide them along the road to the borders of Campania, they were called into the senate-house. In response to the elder members' inquiries, they reported that "they seemed deeply lost in sadness and low spirits; the entire group moved in silence, almost as if they were mute; the former spirit of the Romans was broken, and it seemed their courage had been stripped away along with their weapons. Not one person responded to greetings; it was as if, out of fear, they couldn't speak at all; their necks still seemed to carry the yoke under which they had been sent. The Samnites had won not only a glorious victory but one that was also enduring; they had conquered not just Rome as the Gauls had previously done but achieved a far more significant victory—defeating the Roman spirit." After these observations were made and carefully listened to, with the near extinction of the Roman identity mourned in this gathering of loyal allies, Ofilius Calavius, son of Ovius, a man well-respected for both his lineage and actions, and even more so due to his age at this time, is said to have expressed a very different view. "This stubborn silence," he said, "those eyes fixed on the ground—those ears deaf to any comfort—with the shame of seeing the light—are signs of a spirit summoning forth its deepest reserves of anger. Either he is unaware of Roman resolve, or that silence will soon lead to cries and moans among the Samnites; for the memory of the peace of Caudium will bring much more sorrow to the Samnites than to the Romans. Each side carries their own inherent spirit, no matter where they may engage, but the Samnites won't always have the valleys of Caudium."

7

Their disaster was, by this time, well known at Rome also. At first, they heard that the troops were shut up; afterwards the news of the ignominious peace caused greater affliction than had been felt for their danger. On the report of their being surrounded, a levy of men was begun; but when it was understood that the army had surrendered in so disgraceful a manner, the preparations were laid aside; and immediately, without any public directions, a general mourning took place, with all the various demonstrations of grief. The shops were shut; and all business ceased in the forum, spontaneously, before it was proclaimed. Laticlaves [1] and gold rings were laid aside: and the public were in greater tribulation, if possible, than the army itself; they were not only enraged against the commanders, the advisers and sureties of the peace, but detested even the unoffending soldiers, and asserted, that they ought not to be admitted into the city or its habitations. But these transports of passion were allayed by the arrival of the troops, which excited compassion even in the angry; for entering into the city, not like men returning into their country with unexpected safety, but in the habit and with the looks of captives, late in the evening; they hid themselves so closely in their houses, that, for the next, and several following days, not one of them could bear to come in sight of the forum, or of the public. The consuls, shut up in private, transacted no official business, except that which was wrung from them by a decree of the senate, to nominate a dictator to preside at the elections. They nominated Quintus Fabius Ambustus, and as master of the horse Publius Aelius Paetus. But they having been irregularly appointed, there were substituted in their room, Marcus Aemilius Papus dictator, and Lucius Valerius Flaccus master of the horse. But neither did these hold the elections: and the people being dissatisfied with all the magistrates of that year, an interregnum ensued. The interreges were, Quintus Fabius Maximus and Marcus Valerius Corvus, who elected consuls Quintus Publilius Philo, and Lucius Papirius Cursor a second time; a choice universally approved, for there were no commanders at that time of higher reputation.

Their disaster was well known in Rome by this point. At first, they heard that the troops were trapped; later, the news of the shameful peace caused even greater distress than their previous danger. After hearing that the army was surrounded, a recruitment of men began, but when it became clear that the army had surrendered in such an embarrassing way, those plans were quickly abandoned. Without any official announcement, a widespread mourning took place, with all the usual signs of grief. Shops closed, and all activity in the forum halted spontaneously, even before it was officially declared. Laticlaves [1] and gold rings were put away, and the public was in even deeper despair than the army itself; they were not only furious with the commanders and the advisers who had pushed for peace but also held the innocent soldiers in contempt, insisting they should not be allowed back into the city or its homes. However, their anger subsided somewhat upon the return of the troops, which sparked sympathy even among the furious; the soldiers entered the city, not as men coming home safely, but like captives, late in the evening. They hid themselves so well in their homes that for the next few days, none of them could bear to show their faces in the forum or in public. The consuls, confined to private quarters, conducted no official business except for what they were forced to do by a decree from the senate, which was to appoint a dictator to oversee the elections. They named Quintus Fabius Ambustus, and Publius Aelius Paetus as master of the horse. However, since their appointment was irregular, they were replaced by Marcus Aemilius Papus as dictator and Lucius Valerius Flaccus as master of the horse. But even they did not hold the elections, and the people, unhappy with all the magistrates that year, found themselves in an interregnum. The interreges were Quintus Fabius Maximus and Marcus Valerius Corvus, who elected consuls Quintus Publilius Philo and Lucius Papirius Cursor for a second time; this choice was widely approved, as there were no commanders with a better reputation at that moment.

8

They entered into office on the day they were elected, for so it had been determined by the fathers. When the customary decrees of the senate were passed, they proposed the consideration of the Caudine peace; and Publilius, who was in possession of the fasces, said, "Spurius Postumius, speak:" he arose with just the same countenance with which he had passed under the yoke, and delivered himself to this effect: "Consuls, I am well aware that I have been called up first with marked ignominy, not with honour; and that I am ordered to speak, not as being a senator, but as a person answerable as well for an unsuccessful war as for a disgraceful peace. However, since the question propounded by you is not concerning our guilt, or our punishment; waving a defence, which would not be very difficult, before men who are not unacquainted with human casualties or necessities, I shall briefly state my opinion on the matter in question; which opinion will testify, whether I meant to spare myself or your legions, when I engaged as surety to the convention, whether dishonourable or necessary: by which, however, the Roman people are not bound, inasmuch as it was concluded without their order; nor is any thing liable to be forfeited to the Samnites, in consequence of it, except our persons. Let us then be delivered up to them by the heralds, naked, and in chains. Let us free the people of the religious obligation, if we have bound them under any such; so that there may be no restriction, divine or human, to prevent your entering on the war anew, without violating either religion or justice. I am also of opinion, that the consuls, in the mean time, enlist, arm, and lead out an army; but that they should not enter the enemy's territories before every particular, respecting the surrender of us, be regularly executed. You, O immortal gods! I pray and beseech that, although it has not been your will that Spurius Postumius and Titus Veturius, as consuls, should wage war with success against the Samnites, ye may yet deem it sufficient to have seen us sent under the yoke; to have seen us bound under an infamous convention; to have seen us delivered into the hands of our foes naked and shackled, taking on our own heads the whole weight of the enemy's resentment. And grant, that the consuls and legions of Rome may wage war against the Samnites, with the same fortune with which every war has been waged before we became consuls." On his concluding this speech, men's minds were so impressed with both admiration and compassion, that now they could scarce believe him to be the same Spurius Postumius who had been the author of so shameful a peace; again lamenting, that such a man was likely to undergo, among the enemy, a punishment even beyond that of others, through resentment for annulling the peace. When all the members, extolling him with praises, expressed their approbation of his sentiments, a protest was attempted for a time by Lucius Livius and Quintus Maelius, tribunes of the commons, who said, that "the people could not be acquitted of the religious obligation by the consuls being given up, unless all things were restored to the Samnites in the same state in which they had been at Caudium; nor had they themselves deserved any punishment, for having, by becoming sureties to the peace, preserved the army of the Roman people; nor, finally, could they, being sacred and inviolable, be surrendered to the enemy or treated with violence."

They took office the day they were elected, as it had been decided by the founders. When the usual decrees from the senate were passed, they suggested discussing the peace treaty made at Caudine. Publilius, who held the fasces, said, "Spurius Postumius, speak." He got up with the same expression he had when he passed under the yoke and said this: "Consuls, I know that I have been called first with clear shame, not with honor; and that I am expected to speak, not as a senator, but as someone responsible for both a failed war and a shameful peace. However, since your question isn't about our guilt or punishment; setting aside a defense that wouldn’t be too hard before people who understand human circumstances, I will briefly share my opinion on the matter at hand. This opinion will reveal whether I meant to protect myself or your legions when I acted as a guarantor for the agreement, whether it was dishonorable or necessary: by which, however, the Roman people are not bound, since it was made without their consent; nor is anything owed to the Samnites because of it, except for us. So, let us be handed over to them by the heralds, stripped and in chains. Let’s free the people from any religious obligation if we have imposed one on them, so there are no divine or human restrictions preventing you from waging war again, without violating either religion or justice. I also believe that the consuls should, in the meantime, enlist, arm, and lead an army; but they shouldn't enter enemy territory until everything regarding our surrender is properly executed. O immortal gods! I pray and beg you, although it has not been your will for Spurius Postumius and Titus Veturius, as consuls, to wage a successful war against the Samnites, may it be enough for you to have seen us sent under the yoke; to have seen us bound by a shameful agreement; to have seen us handed over to our enemies naked and in chains, bearing the full burden of the enemy's wrath. And grant that the consuls and legions of Rome may fight against the Samnites with the same success as every war before we became consuls." When he finished speaking, people were so moved with admiration and compassion that they could hardly believe he was the same Spurius Postumius who had initiated such a disgraceful peace; they lamented that such a man was likely to face a punishment from the enemy far worse than others, due to resentment for breaking the peace. As all the members praised him and approved of his views, Lucius Livius and Quintus Maelius, tribunes of the commons, tried to protest, claiming that "the people can't be freed from their sacred obligation just by handing over the consuls unless everything is restored to the Samnites as it was at Caudium; nor did they deserve any punishment for becoming guarantors of the peace to protect the Roman army; finally, they cannot, being sacred and inviolable, be surrendered to the enemy or treated violently."

9

To this Postumius replied, "In the mean time surrender us as unsanctified persons, which ye may do, without offence to religion; those sacred and inviolable personages, the tribunes, ye will afterwards deliver up as soon as they go out of office: but, if ye listen to me, they will be first scourged with rods, here in the Comitium, that they may pay this as interest for their punishment being delayed. For, as to their denying that the people are acquitted of the religious obligation, by our being given up, who is there so ignorant of the laws of the heralds, as not to know, that those men speak in that manner, that they themselves may not be surrendered, rather than because the case is really so? Still I do not deny, conscript fathers, that compacts, on sureties given, are as sacred as treaties, in the eyes of all who regard faith between men, with the same reverence which is paid to duties respecting the gods: but I insist, that without the order of the people, nothing can be ratified that is to bind the people. Suppose that, out of the same arrogance with which the Samnites wrung from us the convention in question, they had compelled us to repeat the established form of words for the surrendering of cities, would ye, tribunes, say, that the Roman people was surrendered? and, that this city, these temples, and consecrated grounds, these lands and waters, were become the property of the Samnites? I say no more of the surrender, because our having become sureties is the point insisted on. Now, suppose we had become sureties that the Roman people should quit this city; that they should set it on fire; that they should have no magistrates, no senate, no laws; that they should, in future, be ruled by kings: the gods forbid, you say. But, the enormity of the articles lessens not the obligation of a compact. If there is any thing in which the people can be bound, it can in all. Nor is there any importance in another circumstance, which weighs, perhaps, with some: whether a consul, a dictator, or a praetor, be the surety. And this, indeed, was what even the Samnites themselves proved, who were not satisfied with the security of the consuls, but compelled the lieutenants-general, quaestors, and military tribunes to join them. Let no one, then, demand of me, why I entered into such a compact, when neither such power was vested in a consul, and when I could not either to them, insure a peace, of which I could not command the ratification; or in behalf of you, who had given me no powers. Conscript fathers, none of the transactions at Caudium were directed by human wisdom. The immortal gods deprived of understanding both your generals and those of the enemy. On the one side we acted not with sufficient caution in the war; on the other, they threw away a victory, which through our folly they had obtained, while they hardly confided in the places, by means of which they had conquered; but were in haste, on any terms, to take arms out of the hands of men who were born to arms. Had their reason been sound, would it have been difficult, during the time which they spent in sending for old men from home to give them advice, to send ambassadors to Rome, and to negotiate a peace and treaty with the senate, and with the people? It would have been a journey of only three days to expeditious travellers. In the interim, matters might have rested under a truce, that is, until their ambassadors should have brought from Rome, either certain victory or peace. That would have been really a compact, on the faith of sureties, for we should have become sureties by order of the people. But, neither would ye have passed such an order, nor should we have pledged our faith; nor was it right that the affair should have any other issue, than, that they should be vainly mocked with a dream, as it were, of greater prosperity than their minds were capable of comprehending, and that the same fortune, which had entangled our army, should extricate it; that an ineffectual victory should be frustrated by a more ineffectual peace; and that a convention, on the faith of a surety, should be introduced, which bound no other person beside the surety. For what part had ye, conscript fathers; what part had the people, in this affair? Who can call upon you? Who can say, that he has been deceived by you? Can the enemy? Can a citizen? To the enemy ye engaged nothing. Ye ordered no citizen to engage on your behalf. Ye are therefore no way concerned either with us, to whom ye gave no commission; nor with the Samnites, with whom ye transacted no business. We are sureties to the Samnites; debtors, sufficiently wealthy in that which is our own, in that which we can offer--our bodies and our minds. On these, let them exercise their cruelty; against these, let them whet their resentment and their swords. As to what relates to the tribunes, consider whether the delivering them up can be effected at the present time, or if it must be deferred to another day. Meanwhile let us, Titus Veturius, and the rest concerned, offer our worthless persons, as atonements for the breaking our engagements, and, by our sufferings liberate the Roman armies."

To this, Postumius replied, "In the meantime, surrender us as unholy individuals, which you can do without offending religion; those sacred and untouchable people, the tribunes, you can hand over later as soon as they leave office. But if you listen to me, they should be punished first with rods here in the Comitium, so they can pay interest for their delayed punishment. As for their claim that the people are released from their religious obligations by our surrender, who is so ignorant of the herald's laws as to think they speak like that to protect themselves rather than because it's actually the case? Still, I don't deny, conscript fathers, that agreements based on sureties are just as sacred as treaties in the eyes of everyone who values fidelity between men as much as they value duties to the gods. But I insist that nothing can be binding on the people without the people's approval. Suppose, out of the same arrogance with which the Samnites forced us into this arrangement, they had demanded we repeat the official language for surrendering cities. Would you, tribunes, say that the Roman people had been surrendered? And that this city, these temples, and consecrated lands, these waters, had become property of the Samnites? I'm not going to say more about the surrender, because our becoming sureties is the main point here. Now, suppose we acted as sureties for the Roman people leaving this city; that they should set it on fire; that they should have no magistrates, no senate, no laws; that they should be ruled by kings in the future: gods forbid, you’d say. But the seriousness of the agreements doesn’t lessen the obligation of a contract. If there’s anything the people can be bound by, it can be all things. And it doesn’t matter whether the surety is a consul, a dictator, or a praetor. This was something the Samnites proved themselves, as they were not satisfied with the consuls' security but forced the lieutenants, quaestors, and military tribunes to join them. So don't ask me why I entered such an agreement when a consul had no power to promise peace that couldn’t be ratified, or on your behalf when you hadn’t given me any authority. Conscript fathers, none of what happened at Caudium was guided by human wisdom. The immortal gods robbed both your generals and those of the enemy of understanding. On one side, we acted without sufficient caution in the war; on the other, they threw away a victory that we foolishly gave them, even while they hardly trusted the places that had led to their triumph. They were eager to disarm men born to fight. If they had reason, wouldn't it have been easy during the time they spent sending for old men to advise them to send ambassadors to Rome and negotiate a peace and treaty with the Senate and the people? It would have been a journey of just three days for quick travelers. In the meantime, things could have stayed under a truce until their ambassadors brought back either certain victory or peace. That would have truly been an agreement based on sureties, as we would have become sureties by the people's order. But you wouldn’t have passed such an order, nor would we have committed ourselves; nor was it right that the affair should have turned out any differently than to have them mocked with an illusion of prosperity beyond their understanding, and that the same fate that ensnared our army should free it; that an ineffective victory would be undone by an even more ineffective peace; and that an agreement based on surety would be introduced that didn’t bind anyone but the surety. So what role did you, conscript fathers, what role did the people have in all this? Who can ask for your accountability? Who can say they've been misled by you? Can the enemy? Can a citizen? You committed nothing to the enemy. You ordered no citizen to represent you. Thus you have no involvement with us, to whom you granted no authority; nor with the Samnites, with whom you conducted no transactions. We are sureties to the Samnites; we owe debts, but we are well off in what is ours—our bodies and our minds. Let them unleash their cruelty on these; let them sharpen their anger and swords against these. As for the tribunes, consider whether handing them over can be done now, or if it must wait for another day. Meanwhile, let us, Titus Veturius and the others involved, present our worthless selves as atonement for breaking our commitments, and through our suffering, free the Roman armies."

10

Both these arguments, and, still more, the author of them, powerfully affected the senators; as they did likewise every one, not excepting even the tribunes of the commons who declared, that they would be directed by the senate. They then instantly resigned their office, and were delivered, together with the rest, to the heralds, to be conducted to Caudium. On passing this decree of the senate, it seemed as if some new light had shone upon the state: Postumius was in every mouth: they extolled him to heaven; and pronounced his conduct as equal even to the devoting act of the consul Publius Decius, and to other illustrious acts. "Through his counsel, and exertions," they said, "the state had raised up its head from an ignominious peace. He now offered himself to the enemy's rage, and to torments; and was suffering, in atonement for the Roman people." All turned their thoughts towards arms and war, [and the general cry was,] "When shall we be permitted with arms in our hands to meet the Samnites?" While the state glowed with resentment and rancour, the levies were composed almost entirely of volunteers. New legions, composed of the former soldiers, were quickly formed, and an army marched to Caudium. The heralds, who went before, on coming to the gate, ordered the sureties of the peace to be stripped of their clothes, and their hands to be tied behind their backs. As the apparitor, out of respect to his dignity, was binding Postumius in a loose manner, "Why do you not," said he, "draw the cord tight, that the surrender may be regularly performed?" Then, when they came into the assembly of the Samnites, and to the tribunal of Pontius, Aulus Cornelius Arvina, a herald, pronounced these words: "Forasmuch as these men, here present, without orders from the Roman people, the Quirites, entered into surety, that a treaty should be made, and have thereby rendered themselves criminal; now, in order that the Roman people may be freed from the crime of impiety, I here surrender these men into your hands." On the herald saying thus, Postumius gave him a stroke on the thigh with his knee, as forcibly as he could, and said with a loud voice, that "he was now a citizen of Samnium, the other a Roman ambassador; that the herald had been, by him, violently ill-treated, contrary to the law of nations; and that his people would therefore have the more justice on their side, in waging war."

Both of these arguments, and especially the person making them, strongly impacted the senators; it also influenced everyone else, including the tribunes of the commons, who said they would follow the senate's lead. They immediately resigned their positions and were handed over, along with the others, to the heralds, to be taken to Caudium. Upon the senate passing this decree, it felt like a new light had shone on the state: Postumius was on everyone's lips; they praised him immensely and claimed his actions were as heroic as those of Consul Publius Decius and other famous deeds. "Through his advice and efforts," they said, "the state had lifted itself from a shameful peace. He now offered himself to the enemy's wrath and suffering, atoning for the Roman people." Everyone's thoughts shifted towards warfare, with the common cry being, "When will we be allowed to face the Samnites with weapons in hand?" As the state bubbled with anger and bitterness, the military drafts were nearly all made up of volunteers. New legions, formed from former soldiers, were quickly organized, and an army marched to Caudium. The heralds, leading the way, instructed that the sureties of the peace be stripped of their clothes and their hands bound behind their backs. When the apparitor, out of respect for his position, was loosely tying Postumius, he said, "Why don’t you tighten the cord so that the surrender is done properly?" When they arrived at the assembly of the Samnites and the tribunal of Pontius, Aulus Cornelius Arvina, a herald, declared: "Since these men present, without any instruction from the Roman people, the Quirites, entered into surety for a treaty, they have made themselves guilty; now, so that the Roman people may be free from the guilt of impiety, I hereby hand these men over to you." After the herald finished speaking, Postumius struck his thigh with his knee as hard as he could and said loudly, that "he was now a citizen of Samnium, while the other was a Roman ambassador; that the herald had been violently mistreated by him, against international law; and thus, his people would have greater justice on their side in waging war."

11

Pontius then said, "Neither will I accept such a surrender, nor will the Samnites deem it valid. Spurius Postumius, if you believe that there are gods, why do you not undo all that has been done, or fulfil your agreement? The Samnite nation is entitled, either to all the men whom it had in its power, or, instead of them, to a peace. But why do I call on you, who, with as much regard to faith as you are able to show, return yourself a prisoner into the hands of the conqueror? I call on the Roman people. If they are dissatisfied with the convention made at the Caudine forks, let them replace the legions within the defile where they were pent up. Let there be no deception on either side. Let all that has been done pass as nothing. Let them receive again the army which they surrendered by the convention; let them return into their camp. Whatever they were in possession of, the day before the conference, let them possess again. Then let war and resolute counsels be adopted. Then let the convention, and peace, be rejected. Let us carry on the war in the same circumstances, and situations, in which we were before peace was mentioned. Let neither the Roman people blame the convention of the consuls, nor us the faith of the Roman people. Will ye never want an excuse for not standing to the compacts which ye make on being defeated? Ye gave hostages to Porsena: ye clandestinely withdrew them. Ye ransomed your state from the Gauls, for gold: while they were receiving the gold, they were put to the sword. Ye concluded a peace with us, on condition of our restoring your captured legions: that peace ye now annul; in fine, ye always spread over your fraudulent conduct some show of right. Do the Roman people disapprove of their legions being saved by an ignominious peace? Let them have their peace, and return the captured legions to the conqueror. This would be conduct consistent with faith, with treaties, and with the laws of the heralds. But that you should, in consequence of the convention, obtain what you desired, the safety of so many of your countrymen, while I obtain not, what I stipulated for on sending you back those men, a peace; is this the law which you, Aulus Cornelius, which ye, heralds, prescribe to nations? But for my part, I neither accept those men whom ye pretend to surrender, nor consider them as surrendered; nor do I hinder them from returning into their own country, which stands bound under an actual convention, formally entered into carrying with them the wrath of all the gods, whose authority is thus baffled. Wage war, since Spurius Postumius has just now struck with his knee the herald, in character of ambassador. The gods are to believe that Postumius is a citizen of Samnium, not of Rome; and that a Roman ambassador has been violated by a Samnite; and that therefore a just war has been waged against us by you. That men of years, and of consular dignity, should not be ashamed to exhibit such mockery of religion in the face of day! And should have recourse to such shallow artifices to palliate their breach of faith, unworthy even of children! Go, lictor, take off the bonds from those Romans. Let no one delay them from departing when they think proper." Accordingly they returned unhurt from Caudium to the Roman camp, having acquitted, certainly, their own faith, and perhaps that of the public.

Pontius then said, "I won't accept that surrender, and neither will the Samnites see it as valid. Spurius Postumius, if you believe in the gods, why don't you undo everything that has happened, or stick to your agreement? The Samnite people are entitled to either all the men they had in their power or, instead, peace. But why do I address you, who, as much as you can show loyalty, surrender yourself as a prisoner to the conqueror? I speak to the Roman people. If they are unhappy with the agreement made at the Caudine Forks, let them replace the legions in the narrow pass where they were trapped. There should be no deception on either side. Let everything that has happened be wiped clean. Let them take back the army they surrendered under the agreement; let them return to their camp. Whatever they owned the day before the meeting, let them have it again. Then let’s adopt war and firm strategies. Let’s reject the agreement and peace. Let’s carry on the war in the same circumstances as before peace was mentioned. Let neither the Roman people criticize the consuls' agreement nor we criticize the Roman people's loyalty. Will you always need an excuse to avoid honoring the agreements you make when you suffer defeat? You handed over hostages to Porsena, then sneakily withdrew them. You ransomed your state from the Gauls for gold: while they were taking the gold, they were slaughtered. You made peace with us on the condition that we return your captured legions; now you annul that peace. In short, you constantly wrap your deceitful actions in a pretense of right. Do the Roman people disapprove of their legions being saved by an embarrassing peace? Let them have their peace and return the captured legions to the conqueror. This would be consistent with loyalty, treaties, and the laws of heralds. But that you should get what you wanted due to the agreement—the safety of so many of your countrymen—while I don’t receive what I was promised for sending those men back, a peace; is this the standard that you, Aulus Cornelius, and you, heralds, set for nations? As for me, I neither accept those men you claim to surrender, nor do I see them as surrendered; nor do I stop them from returning to their own country, which is bound by an actual agreement, formally made, carrying with it the anger of all the gods, whose authority is thus ignored. Wage war, since Spurius Postumius just struck the herald, acting as ambassador. The gods will think that Postumius is a citizen of Samnium, not Rome; and that a Roman ambassador has been harmed by a Samnite; and therefore, a just war has been declared against us by you. How can men of age and consular rank not be ashamed to show such mockery of religion in broad daylight? And resort to such shallow tricks to excuse their breach of faith, unworthy even of children! Go, lictor, remove the bonds from those Romans. Let no one stop them from leaving when they choose." Accordingly, they returned unharmed from Caudium to the Roman camp, having certainly upheld their own honor, and perhaps that of the public.

12

The Samnites finding that instead of a peace which flattered their pride, the war was revived, and with the utmost inveteracy, not only felt, in their minds, a foreboding of all the consequences which ensued, but saw them, in a manner, before their eyes. They now, too late and in vain, applauded the plans of old Pontius, by blundering between which, they had exchanged the possession of victory for an uncertain peace; and having lost the opportunity of doing a kindness or an injury, were now to fight against men, whom they might have either put out of the way, for ever, as enemies; or engaged, for ever, as friends. And such was the change which had taken place in men's minds, since the Caudine peace, even before any trial of strength had shown an advantage on either side, that Postumius, by surrendering himself, had acquired greater renown among the Romans, than Pontius among the Samnites, by his bloodless victory. The Romans considered their being at liberty to make war, a certain victory; while the Samnites supposed the Romans victorious, the moment they resumed their arms. Meanwhile, the Satricans revolted to the Samnites, who attacked the colony of Fregellae, by a sudden surprise in the night, accompanied, as it appears, by the Satricans. From that time until day, their mutual fears kept both parties quiet: the daylight was the signal for battle, which the Fregellans contrived to maintain, for a considerable time, without loss of ground; both because they fought for their religion and liberty; and the multitude, who were unfit to bear arms, assisted them from the tops of the houses. At length a stratagem gave the advantage to the assailants; for they suffered the voice of a crier to be heard proclaiming, that "whoever laid down his arms might retire in safety." This relaxed their eagerness in the fight, and they began almost every where to throw away their arms. A part, more determined, however, retaining their arms, rushed out by the opposite gate, and their boldness brought greater safety to them, than their fear, which inclined them to credulity, did to the others: for the Samnites, having surrounded the latter with fires, burned them all to death, while they made vain appeals to the faith of gods and men. The consuls having settled the province between them, Papirius proceeded into Apulia to Luceria where the Roman horsemen, given as hostages at Caudium were kept in custody: Publilius remained in Samnium, to oppose the Caudine legions. This proceeding perplexed the minds of the Samnites: they could not safely determine either to go to Luceria, lest the enemy should press on their rear or to remain where they were, lest in the mean time Luceria should be lost. They concluded, therefore, that it would be most advisable to trust to the decision of fortune, and to take the issue of a battle with Publilius: accordingly they drew out their forces into the field.

The Samnites realized that instead of getting a peace that boosted their pride, the war had flared up again, more intense than ever. They not only sensed the impending consequences in their minds but also saw them unfolding before their eyes. Now, too late and in vain, they praised the strategies of old Pontius, which had led them to trade the assurance of victory for an uncertain peace; having missed the chance to either do a favor or cause harm, they now had to fight against men they could have either permanently defeated as enemies or made lifelong friends. This change in people's attitudes had occurred since the Caudine peace, even before any contest of strength had shown an advantage for either side. Postumius gained more fame among the Romans by surrendering himself than Pontius did among the Samnites with his non-violent victory. The Romans viewed their ability to wage war as a sure path to victory, while the Samnites believed the Romans were victorious the moment they took up arms again. Meanwhile, the Satricans defected to the Samnites, who launched a surprise nighttime attack on the colony of Fregellae, apparently accompanied by the Satricans. From that moment until dawn, mutual fear kept both sides quiet; the daylight signaled the start of battle, which the Fregellans managed to sustain for quite a while without losing ground because they fought for their faith and freedom, and many who couldn’t fight supported them from the rooftops. Finally, a trick gave the advantage to the attackers; they allowed a herald to announce that "anyone who laid down their arms could leave safely." This relaxed their intensity in battle, and many began throwing down their weapons. However, a more resolute group, keeping their arms, charged out through the opposite gate, and their bravery brought them greater safety than the fear that made the others gullible. The Samnites, having surrounded the latter with fires, burned them alive while they futilely called on the gods and men for help. After dividing the province, Papirius moved to Apulia to Luceria, where the Roman horsemen held as hostages at Caudium were kept, while Publilius stayed in Samnium to counter the Caudine legions. This situation confused the Samnites; they couldn't safely decide whether to go to Luceria, fearing an enemy attack from behind, or to stay where they were, fearing Luceria could fall in the meantime. They concluded that it would be best to leave it to chance and face Publilius in battle. Therefore, they mobilized their forces into the field.

13

When Publilius was about to engage, considering it proper to address his soldiers first, he ordered an assembly be summoned. But though they ran together to the general's quarters with the greatest alacrity, yet so loud were the clamours, demanding the fight, that none of the general's exhortations were heard: each man's own reflections on the late disgrace served as an exhortation. They advanced therefore to battle, urging the standard-bearers to hasten; at rest, in beginning the conflict, there should be any delay, in wielding their javelins and then drawing their swords, they threw away the former, as if a signal to that purpose had been given, and, drawing the latter, rushed in full speed upon the foe. Nothing of a general's skill was displayed in forming ranks or reserves; the resentment of the troops performed all, with a degree of fury little inferior to madness. The enemy, therefore, were not only completely routed, not even daring to embarrass their flight by retreating to their camp but dispersing, made towards Apulia in scattered parties: afterwards, however, collecting their forces into one body, they reached Luceria. The same exasperation, which had carried the Romans through the midst of the enemy's line, carried them forward also into their camp, where greater carnage was made, and more blood spilt, than even in the field, while the greater part of the spoil was destroyed in their rage. The other army, with the consul Papirius, had now arrived at Arpi, on the sea-coast, having passed without molestation through all the countries in their way; which was owing to the ill-treatment received by those people from the Samnites, and their hatred towards them, rather than to any favour received from the Roman people. For such of the Samnites as dwelt on the mountains in separate villages, used to ravage the low lands, and the places on the coast; and being mountaineers, and savage themselves, despised the husbandmen who were of a gentler kind, and, as generally happens, resembled the district they inhabited. Now if this tract had been favourably affected towards the Samnites, either the Roman army could have been prevented from reaching Arpi, or, as it lay between Rome and Arpi, it might have intercepted the convoys of provisions, and utterly destroyed them by the consequent scarcity of all necessaries. Even as it was, when they went from thence to Luceria, both the besiegers and the besieged were distressed equally by want. Every kind of supplies was brought to the Romans from Arpi; but in so very scanty proportion, that the horsemen had to carry corn from thence to the camp, in little bags, for the foot, who were employed in the outposts, watches, and works; and sometimes falling in with the enemy, they were obliged to throw the corn from off their horses, in order to fight. Before the arrival of the other consul and his victorious army, both provisions had been brought in to the Samnites, and reinforcements conveyed in to them from the mountains; but the coming of Publilius contracted all their resources; for, committing the siege to the care of his colleague, and keeping himself disengaged, he threw every difficulty in the way of the enemy's convoys. There being therefore little hope for the besieged, or that they would be able much longer to endure want, the Samnites, encamped at Luceria, were obliged to collect their forces from every side, and come to an engagement with Papirius.

When Publilius was about to engage, he thought it was right to speak to his soldiers first, so he ordered an assembly to be called. Even though they rushed to the general's quarters as quickly as possible, the shouts calling for battle were so loud that none of his speeches could be heard; each soldier’s own feelings about their recent defeat acted as motivation. They rushed into battle, urging the standard-bearers to speed up; as they began the fight, there was no delay in throwing their javelins and then drawing their swords. They discarded the javelins as if a signal had been given and, drawing their swords, charged at full speed toward the enemy. No tactical skill was displayed in forming ranks or reserves; the soldiers' anger drove them on with a fury that was almost insane. As a result, the enemy was not only completely defeated but didn't even dare to retreat to their camp, scattering in different directions toward Apulia. Later, however, they regrouped and made their way to Luceria. The same rage that had propelled the Romans through the enemy's line also drove them into the camp, where they caused more slaughter and spilled more blood than in the battlefield, with much of the loot destroyed in their fury. Meanwhile, the other army, led by Consul Papirius, had reached Arpi on the coast, passing through all the territories without any disturbances. This was due more to the bad treatment those people had received from the Samnites and their hatred for them than any goodwill from the Romans. The Samnites living in the mountains in isolated villages would raid the lowlands and coastal areas, and being mountain dwellers themselves, they looked down on the gentler farmers, who, as is often the case, resembled the land they lived in. If this area had been sympathetic to the Samnites, the Roman army could have been stopped from reaching Arpi, or could have intercepted supply convoys between Rome and Arpi and completely cut them off due to the resulting scarcity of supplies. Even so, when they left there for Luceria, both the besiegers and the besieged faced a lack of resources. Various supplies were brought to the Romans from Arpi, but in such limited amounts that the cavalry had to carry grain in small bags to the camp for the foot soldiers on sentry duty and performing other tasks; and when they sometimes ran into the enemy, they had to drop the grain from their horses in order to fight. Before the other consul and his victorious army arrived, the Samnites had received supplies and reinforcements from the mountains; however, with Publilius's arrival, their resources dwindled. He left the siege in his colleague’s hands while staying free to disrupt the enemy's supply lines. With little hope left for the besieged, and knowing they couldn’t endure the shortage much longer, the Samnites camped at Luceria were forced to gather their forces from all around and engage in battle with Papirius.

14

At this juncture, while both parties were preparing for an action, ambassadors from the Tarentines interposed, requiring both Samnites and Romans to desist from war; with menaces, that "if either refused to agree to a cessation of hostilities, they would join their arms with the other party against them." Papirius, on hearing the purport of their embassy, as if influenced by their words, answered, that he would consult his colleague: he then sent for him, employing the intermediate time in the necessary preparations; and when he had conferred with him on a matter, about which no doubt was entertained, he made the signal for battle. While the consuls were employed in performing the religious rites and the other usual business preparatory to an engagement the Tarentine ambassadors put themselves in their way, expecting an answer: to whom Papirius said, "Tarentines, the priest reports that the auspices are favourable, and that our sacrifices have been attended with excellent omens: under the direction of the gods, we are proceeding, as you see, to action." He then ordered the standards to move, and led out the troops; thus rebuking the exorbitant arrogance of that nation, which at a time when, through intestine discord and sedition, it was unequal to the management of its own affairs, yet presumed to prescribe the bounds of peace and war to others. On the other side, the Samnites, who had neglected every preparation for fighting, either because they were really desirous of peace, or it seemed their interest to pretend to be so, in order to conciliate the favour of the Tarentines, when they saw, on a sudden, the Romans drawn up for battle, cried out, that "they would continue to be directed by the Tarentines, and would neither march out, nor carry their arms beyond the rampart. That if deceived, they would rather endure any consequence which chance may bring, than show contempt to the Tarentines, the advisers of peace." The consuls said that "they embraced the omen, and prayed that the enemy might continue in the resolution of not even defending their rampart." Then, dividing the forces between them, they advanced to the works; and, making an assault on every side at once, while some filled up the trenches, others tore down the rampart, and tumbled it into the trench. All were stimulated, not only by their native courage, but by the resentment which, since their disgrace, had been festering in their breasts. They made their way into the camp; where, every one repeating, that here was not Caudium, nor the forks, nor the impassable glens, where cunning haughtily triumphed over error; but Roman valour, which no rampart nor trench could ward off;--they slew, without distinction, those who resisted and those who fled, the armed and unarmed, freemen and slaves, young and old, men and cattle. Nor would a single animal have escaped, had not the consuls given the signal for retreat; and, by commands and threats, forced out of the camp the soldiers, greedy of slaughter. As they were highly incensed at being thus interrupted in the gratification of their vengeance, a speech was immediately addressed to them, assuring the soldiers, that "the consuls neither did nor would fall short of any one of the soldiers, in hatred toward the enemy; on the contrary, as they led the way in battle, so would they have done the same in executing unbounded vengeance, had not the consideration of the six hundred horsemen, who were confined as hostages in Luceria, restrained their inclinations; lest total despair of pardon might drive on the enemy blindly to take vengeance on them, eager to destroy them before they themselves should perish." The soldiers highly applauded this conduct, and rejoiced that their resentment had been checked, and acknowledged that every thing ought to be endured, rather than that the safety of so many Roman youths of the first distinction should be brought into danger.

At this moment, while both sides were getting ready for battle, ambassadors from Tarentum intervened, asking both the Samnites and Romans to stop the war. They threatened that “if either side refused to agree to a ceasefire, they would team up with the other side against them.” Papirius, upon hearing their message, seemed influenced by their words and said he would consult his colleague. He then called for him and used the time to prepare. After discussing a matter that everyone agreed on, he gave the signal to fight. While the consuls were busy carrying out the religious rites and other usual tasks before a battle, the Tarentine ambassadors approached them, waiting for a response. Papirius told them, “Tarentines, the priest says the omens are good, and our sacrifices have had excellent signs: guided by the gods, we are moving forward to action.” He then ordered the standards to advance and led out the troops, pushing back the arrogant assumptions of that nation, which, amidst its internal strife, thought it could dictate the terms of peace and war to others. On the other hand, the Samnites, who had not prepared for battle—either because they genuinely wanted peace or thought it was in their interest to pretend to want it to win the Tarentines' approval—when they suddenly saw the Romans lined up for battle, exclaimed that “they would continue to follow the Tarentines and would neither march out nor take their weapons beyond the fortifications. If deceived, they would rather face any consequences that came than show disrespect to the Tarentines, the advocates of peace.” The consuls said they welcomed the omen and hoped the enemy would stick to their decision of not even defending their fortifications. Then, splitting their forces, they moved toward the fortifications, attacking from all sides at once. While some filled in the trenches, others tore down the rampart and tossed it into the ditch. Everyone was driven not just by their natural bravery but also by the anger they had been harboring since their disgrace. They broke into the camp, where they all exclaimed that this time was not like Caudium, nor the forks, nor the impassable ravines where cleverness had arrogantly triumphed over error; this was Roman courage, which no fortification or trench could hold off. They killed indiscriminately those who resisted and those who ran, the armed and unarmed, free and slave, young and old, men and livestock. Not a single animal would have escaped if the consuls hadn’t signaled for retreat, forcing out the eager soldiers, hungry for slaughter. Since they were furious at being interrupted in their quest for revenge, a speech was quickly made to them, assuring the soldiers that “the consuls would not lag behind any soldier in their hatred for the enemy; in fact, as they led in battle, they would have unleashed complete vengeance, had it not been for the six hundred horsemen held as hostages in Luceria, which held them back; fearing that total despair of mercy might push the enemy to take revenge recklessly, trying to annihilate them before they themselves met their fate.” The soldiers applauded this approach and were glad their desire for revenge had been restrained, agreeing that everything should be tolerated rather than risk the safety of so many distinguished Roman youths.

15

The assembly being then dismissed, a consultation was held, whether they should press forward the siege of Luceria, with all their forces; or, whether with one of the commanders, and his army, trial should be made of the Apulians, a nation in the neighbourhood still doubtful. The consul Publilius set out to make a circuit through Apulia, and in the one expedition either reduced by force, or received into alliance on conditions, a considerable number of the states. Papirius likewise, who had remained to prosecute the siege of Luceria, soon found the event agreeable to his hopes: for all the roads being blocked up through which provisions used to be conveyed from Samnium, the Samnites, who were in garrison, were reduced so low by famine, that they sent ambassadors to the Roman consul, proposing that he should raise the siege, on receiving the horsemen who were the cause of the war, to whom Papirius returned this answer, that "they ought to have consulted Pontius, son of Herennius, by whose advice they had sent the Romans under the yoke, what treatment he thought fitting for the conquered to undergo. But since, instead of offering fair terms themselves, they chose rather that they should be imposed on them by their enemies, he desired them to carry back orders to the troops in Luceria, that they should leave within the walls their arms, baggage, beasts of burthen, and all persons unfit for war. The soldiers he would send under the yoke with single garments, retaliating the disgrace formerly inflicted, not inflicting a new one." The terms were not rejected. Seven thousand soldiers were sent under the yoke, and an immense booty was seized in Luceria, all the standards and arms which they had lost at Caudium being recovered; and, what greatly surpassed all their joy, recovered the horsemen whom the Samnites had sent to Luceria to be kept as pledges of the peace. Hardly ever did the Romans gain a victory more distinguished for the sudden reverse produced in the state of their affairs; especially if it be true, as I find in some annals, that Pontius, son of Herennius, the Samnite general, was sent under the yoke along with the rest, to atone for the disgrace of the consuls. I think it indeed more strange that there should exist any doubt whether it was Lucius Cornelius, in quality of dictator, Lucius Papirius Cursor being master of the horse, who performed these achievements at Caudium, and afterwards at Luceria, as the single avenger of the disgrace of the Romans, enjoying the best deserved triumph, perhaps, next to that of Furius Camillus, which had ever yet been obtained; or whether that honour belongs to the consuls, and particularly to Papirius. This uncertainty is followed by another, whether, at the next election, Papirius Cursor was chosen consul a third time, with Quintus Aulus Ceretanus a second time, being re-elected in requital of his services at Luceria; or whether it was Lucius Papirius Mugillanus, the surname being mistaken.

The assembly was then dismissed, and a consultation took place to decide whether they should continue the siege of Luceria with all their forces, or if they should send one of the commanders with his army to test the loyalty of the Apulians, a neighboring nation that was still uncertain. Consul Publilius set out to travel through Apulia and managed, on that expedition, to either conquer by force or gain the alliance of a significant number of the states. Papirius, who stayed behind to continue the siege of Luceria, soon found things turning out as he hoped: with all the routes through which supplies used to travel from Samnium blocked, the Samnites in garrison faced such severe starvation that they sent ambassadors to the Roman consul, suggesting he lift the siege in exchange for the horsemen who had caused the war. Papirius replied that they should have consulted Pontius, son of Herennius, whose advice had led them to submit the Romans to yoke; he asked what treatment he thought was fitting for the conquered. But since they chose to accept terms imposed on them by their enemies instead of offering reasonable ones, he instructed them to return to the troops in Luceria with orders to leave their arms, baggage, pack animals, and all non-combatants within the walls. He would send the soldiers under the yoke in simple clothing, retaliating for the previous disgrace rather than inflicting a new one. The terms were accepted. Seven thousand soldiers were sent under the yoke, and an immense amount of spoils was seized in Luceria, including all the standards and arms lost at Caudium, and, even more importantly, they recovered the horsemen whom the Samnites had sent to Luceria as hostages for peace. The Romans hardly ever achieved a victory that was more striking for the sudden turnaround in their circumstances; especially if it's true, as mentioned in some records, that Pontius, son of Herennius, the Samnite general, was sent under the yoke along with the others to make up for the humiliation of the consuls. It seems rather odd that there should be any doubt about whether it was Lucius Cornelius, acting as dictator, while Lucius Papirius Cursor was master of the horse, who accomplished these feats at Caudium and then at Luceria, as the sole avenger of Roman disgrace, earning a triumph that may have been second only to that of Furius Camillus; or if that honor goes to the consuls, particularly to Papirius. This ambiguity is followed by another: at the next election, was Papirius Cursor elected consul for a third time, alongside Quintus Aulus Ceretanus for a second time, in recognition of his services at Luceria; or was it Lucius Papirius Mugillanus, with the surname mistaken?

16

From henceforth, the accounts are clear, that the other wars were conducted to a conclusion by the consuls. Aulius by one successful battle, entirely conquered the Forentans. The city, to which their army had retreated after its defeat, surrendered on terms, hostages having been demanded. With similar success the other consul conducted his operations against the Satricans; who, though Roman citizens, had, after the misfortune at Caudium, revolted to the Samnites, and received a garrison into their city. The Satricans, however, when the Roman army approached their walls, sent deputies to sue for peace, with humble entreaties; to whom the consul answered harshly, that "they must not come again to him, unless they either put to death, or delivered up, the Samnite garrison:" by which terms greater terror was struck into the colonists than by the arms with which they were threatened. The deputies, accordingly, several times asking the consul, how he thought that they, who were few and weak, could attempt to use force against a garrison so strong and well-armed: he desired them to "seek counsel from those, by whose advice they had received that garrison into the city." They then departed, and returned to their countrymen, having obtained from the consul, with much difficulty, permission to consult their senate on the matter, and bring back their answer to him. Two factions divided the senate; one that whose leaders had been the authors of the defection from the Roman people, the other consisted of the citizens who retained their loyalty; both, however, showed an earnest desire, that every means should be used towards effecting an accommodation with the consul for the restoration of peace. As the Samnite garrison, being in no respect prepared for holding out a siege, intended to retire the next night out of the town, one party thought it sufficient to discover to the consul, at what hour, through what gate, and by what road, his enemy was to march out. The other, against whose wishes defection to the Samnites had occurred, even opened one of the gates for the consul in the night, secretly admitting the armed enemy into the town. In consequence of this twofold treachery, the Samnite garrison was surprised and overpowered by an ambush, placed in the woody places, near the road; and, at the same time, a shout was raised in the city, which was now filled with the enemy. Thus, in the short space of one hour, the Samnites were put to the sword, the Satricans made prisoners, and all things reduced under the power of the consul; who, having instituted an inquiry by whose means the revolt had taken place, scourged with rods and beheaded such as he found to be guilty; and then, disarming the Satricans, he placed a strong garrison in the place. On this those writers state, that Papirius Cursor proceeded to Rome to celebrate his triumph, who say, that it was under his guidance Luceria was retaken, and the Samnites sent under the yoke. Undoubtedly, as a warrior, he was deserving of every military praise, excelling not only in vigour of mind, but likewise in strength of body. He possessed extraordinary swiftness of foot, surpassing every one of his age in running, from whence came the surname into his family; and he is said, either from the robustness of his frame, or from much practice, to have been able to digest a very large quantity of food and wine. Never did either the foot-soldier or horseman feel military service more laborious, under any general, because he was of a constitution not to be overcome by fatigue. The cavalry, on some occasion, venturing to request that, in consideration of their good behaviour, he would excuse them some part of their business, he told them, "Ye should not say that no indulgence has been granted you,--I excuse you from rubbing your horses' backs when ye dismount." He supported also the authority of command, in all its vigour, both among the allies and his countrymen. The praetor of Praeneste, through fear, had been tardy in bringing forward his men from the reserve to the front: he, walking before his tent, ordered him to be called, and then bade the lictor to make ready his axe, on which, the Praenestine standing frightened almost to death, he said, "Here, lictor, cut away this stump, it is troublesome to people as they walk;" and, after thus alarming him with the dread of the severest punishment, he imposed a fine and dismissed him. It is beyond doubt, that during that age, than which none was ever more productive of virtuous characters, there was no man in whom the Roman affairs found a more effectual support; nay, people even marked him out, in their minds, as a match for Alexander the Great, in case that, having completed the conquest of Asia, he should have turned his arms on Europe.

From now on, the records show that the other wars were wrapped up by the consuls. Aulius, after one decisive battle, completely defeated the Forentans. The city they retreated to after their loss surrendered under specific conditions, including the handover of hostages. Similarly, the other consul managed his campaign against the Satricans, who, despite being Roman citizens, had revolted to the Samnites after the defeat at Caudium and had allowed a garrison into their city. However, when the Roman army came near, the Satricans sent envoys to plead for peace, begging humbly; the consul harshly replied that “they should not return unless they either executed or turned over the Samnite garrison,” instilling even greater fear in the colonists than the threat of arms. The deputies then repeatedly asked the consul how they, being few and weak, could possibly fight against such a powerful and well-equipped garrison. He told them to “consult with those who advised them to bring that garrison into the city.” They left and returned to their people, managing with great difficulty to get permission from the consul to discuss the matter with their senate and to return with their response. The senate was split into two factions; one led by those who had instigated the betrayal of the Roman people, and the other composed of loyal citizens. Both factions, however, genuinely wanted to find a way to negotiate peace with the consul. As the Samnite garrison, unprepared to withstand a siege, planned to sneak out of the town the next night, one faction believed it was enough to inform the consul about the time, the gate, and the route their enemy would take. The other faction, opposed to the initial defection to the Samnites, even opened one of the gates for the consul at night, secretly allowing the armed enemy into the town. Because of this double betrayal, the Samnite garrison was ambushed and defeated in the wooded areas near the road; simultaneously, a shout rose up in the city, which was now filled with the enemy. In just over an hour, the Samnites were slaughtered, the Satricans were taken prisoner, and everything came under the consul’s control. He then investigated how the revolt had occurred, whipping and beheading those he found guilty, and after disarming the Satricans, placed a strong garrison in the city. Historians state that Papirius Cursor went to Rome to celebrate his triumph, mentioning that under his command, Luceria was recaptured, and the Samnites were forced to submit. He was undoubtedly worthy of all military praise, excelling not only in his mental acuity but also in physical strength. He was extraordinarily quick on his feet, outpacing everyone his age in running, which is how his family received their nickname. It’s said that due to either his robust build or extensive practice, he could digest a large quantity of food and wine. No infantry or cavalry ever felt military service was more demanding under any general, as he had a constitution that could withstand fatigue. Once, when the cavalry, having performed well, asked to be excused from some duties, he told them, “You shouldn’t say that no leniency has been given—you’re excused from grooming your horses when you dismount.” He also upheld the authority of his command vigorously among both allies and his fellow citizens. The praetor of Praeneste, out of fear, had hesitated to bring his men from the reserve to the frontline: while walking in front of his tent, he called for the praetor and ordered the lictor to prepare his axe. The Praenestine, terrified, stood there nearly paralyzed as he said, “Here, lictor, chop off this stump, it’s a nuisance to people as they walk by,” and, after alarming him with the threat of severe punishment, imposed a fine and let him go. It’s undeniable that during that time, which produced countless virtuous individuals, no one was a more effective support for Roman affairs; people even considered him a potential rival to Alexander the Great, in case he should turn his attention to Europe after conquering Asia.

17

Nothing can be found farther from my intention, since the commencement of this history, than to digress, more than necessity required, from the course of narration; and, by embellishing my work with variety, to seek pleasing resting-places, as it were, for my readers, and relaxation for my own mind: nevertheless, the mention of so great a king and commander, now [editorial note: there is reason to believe that one or two lines of text might be missing at this point] calls forth to public view those silent reflections, whom Alexander must have fought. Manlius Torquatus, had he met him in the field, might, perhaps, have yielded to Alexander in discharging military duties in battle (for these also render him no less illustrious); and so might Valerius Corvus; men who were distinguished soldiers, before they became commanders. The same, too, might have been the case with the Decii, who, after devoting their persons, rushed upon the enemy; or of Papirius Cursor, though possessed of such powers, both of body and mind. By the counsels of one youth, it is possible the wisdom of a whole senate, not to mention individuals, might have been baffled, [consisting of such members,] that he alone, who declared that "it consisted of kings," conceived a correct idea of a Roman senate. But then the danger was, that with more judgment than any one of those whom I have named he might choose ground for an encampment, provide supplies, guard against stratagems, distinguish the season for fighting, form his line of battle, or strengthen it properly with reserves. He would have owned that he was not dealing with Darius, who drew after him a train of women and eunuchs; saw nothing about him but gold and purple; was encumbered with the trappings of his state, and should be called his prey, rather than his antagonist; whom therefore he vanquished without loss of blood and had no other merit, on the occasion, than that of showing a proper spirit in despising empty show. The aspect of Italy would have appeared to him of a quite different nature from that of India, which he traversed in the guise of a traveller, at the head of a crew of drunkards, if he had seen the forests of Apulia, and the mountains of Lucania, with the vestiges of the disasters of his house, and where his uncle Alexander, king of Epirus, had been lately cut off.

Nothing could be further from my intention, since the beginning of this history, than to stray more than necessary from the narrative; and, by adding variety to my work, to seek out enjoyable pauses for my readers, and breaks for my own mind. Nevertheless, the mention of such a great king and commander now brings to light those unspoken thoughts about whom Alexander must have faced. Manlius Torquatus, if he had encountered him on the battlefield, might have conceded to Alexander in performing military duties in battle (for these also make him no less remarkable); and so might Valerius Corvus; both were distinguished soldiers before they became commanders. The same could be said of the Decii, who, after dedicating themselves, charged into the enemy; or of Papirius Cursor, despite his impressive physical and mental abilities. With the advice of one youth, it’s possible that the wisdom of an entire senate, not to mention individuals, could have been challenged, as he alone, who claimed that “it consisted of kings,” had a clearer grasp of the Roman senate. But then the risk was that, with more insight than any of those I mentioned, he might choose the battlefield wisely, secure supplies, guard against tricks, recognize the right moment to fight, form his battle line, or properly bolster it with reserves. He would have realized he was not facing Darius, who was followed by a procession of women and eunuchs; saw nothing in front of him but gold and purple; was weighed down by the trappings of his state, and should be considered his prey rather than his rival; whom he therefore defeated without shedding blood and had no greater achievement on that occasion than demonstrating the right attitude in dismissing empty displays. The landscape of Italy would have seemed entirely different to him than that of India, which he crossed as a traveler, leading a group of drunks, if he had seen the forests of Apulia and the mountains of Lucania, with the remnants of his family's tragedies, and where his uncle Alexander, king of Epirus, had recently been killed.

18

We are now speaking of Alexander not yet intoxicated by prosperity, the seductions of which no man was less capable of withstanding. But, if he is to be judged from the tenor of his conduct in the new state of his fortune, and from the new disposition, as I may say, which he put on after his successes, he would have entered Italy more like Darius than Alexander; and would have brought thither an army that had forgotten Macedonia, and were degenerating into the manners of the Persians. It is painful, in speaking of so great a king, to recite his ostentatious change of dress; of requiring that people should address him with adulation, prostrating themselves on the ground, a practice insupportable to the Macedonians, had they even been conquered, much more so when they were victorious; the shocking cruelty of his punishments; his murdering his friends in the midst of feasting and wine; with the folly of his fiction respecting his birth. What must have been the consequence, if his love of wine had daily become more intense? if his fierce and uncontrollable anger? And as I mention not any one circumstance of which there is a doubt among writers, do we consider these as no disparagements to the qualifications of a commander? But then, as is frequently repeated by the silliest of the Greeks, who are fond of exalting the reputation, even of the Parthians, at the expense of the Roman name, the danger was that the Roman people would not have had resolution to bear up against the splendour of Alexander's name, who, however, in my opinion, was not known to them even by common fame; and while, in Athens, a state reduced to weakness by the Macedonian arms, which at the very time saw the ruins of Thebes smoking in its neighbourhood, men had spirit enough to declaim with freedom against him, as is manifest from the copies of their speeches, which have been preserved; [we are to be told] that out of such a number of Roman chiefs, no one would have freely uttered his sentiments. How great soever our idea of this man's greatness may be, still it is the greatness of an individual, constituted by the successes of a little more than ten years; and those who give it pre-eminence on account that the Roman people have been defeated, though not in any entire war, yet in several battles, whereas Alexander was never once unsuccessful in a single fight, do not consider that they are comparing the actions of one man, and that a young man, with the exploits of a nation waging wars now eight hundred years. Can we wonder if, when on the one side more ages are numbered than years on the other, fortune varied more in so long a lapse of time than in the short term of thirteen years? [2] But why not compare the success of one general with that of another? How many Roman commanders might I name who never lost a battle? In the annals of the magistrates, and the records, we may run over whole pages of consuls and dictators, with whose bravery, and successes also, the Roman people never once had reason to be dissatisfied. And what renders them more deserving of admiration than Alexander, or any king, is, that some of these acted in the office of dictator, which lasted only ten, or it might be twenty days, none, in a charge of longer duration than the consulship of a year; their levies obstructed by plebeian tribunes; often late in taking the field; recalled, before the time, on account of elections; amidst the very busiest efforts of the campaign, their year of office expired; sometimes the rashness, sometimes the perverseness of a colleague, proving an impediment or detriment; and finally succeeding to the unfortunate administration of a predecessor, with an army of raw or ill-disciplined men. But, on the other hand, kings, being not only free from every kind of impediment, but masters of circumstances and seasons, control all things in subserviency to their designs, themselves uncontrolled by any. So that Alexander, unconquered, would have encountered unconquered commanders; and would have had stakes of equal consequence pledged on the issue. Nay, the hazard had been greater on his side; because the Macedonians would have had but one Alexander, who was not only liable, but fond of exposing himself to casualties; the Romans would have had many equal to Alexander, both in renown, and in the greatness of their exploits; any one of whom might live or die according to his destiny, without any material consequence to the public.

We are now talking about Alexander, who had not yet been overwhelmed by success—something no one was less equipped to resist. But if we judge him based on how he behaved in his newfound fortune and the change in his attitude after his victories, he would have entered Italy more like Darius than Alexander. He would have brought an army that had forgotten Macedonia and was adopting Persian ways. It’s frustrating to discuss such a great king’s showy changes in attire and his demands for people to praise him, bowing down to the ground, a practice that was unbearable for the Macedonians, even if they had been defeated, let alone when they were winning—along with his shocking cruelty in punishments, murdering his friends amid feasts and drinking, and the foolishness of his claims about his origins. What would have happened if his love for wine intensified day by day? Or if his fierce and uncontrollable anger grew? And since I’m not mentioning any questionable incidents among writers, should we not see these as flaws in a leader’s qualities? Yet, as the least wise among the Greeks often say, eager to boost the reputation of even the Parthians while diminishing the Roman name, there was a concern that the Roman people wouldn't have the determination to stand up against the glory of Alexander’s name, which, in my view, they didn’t even know well. While in Athens, a city weakened by Macedonian forces, which at that time could see Thebes in ruins nearby, people still had the boldness to speak freely against him, as evidenced by the preserved speeches; we are led to believe that none of the many Roman leaders would dare express their opinions. No matter how great we think this man's greatness might be, it is still just the greatness of an individual, built on the successes of just over ten years. Those who elevate it because the Roman people have faced defeats—not in a full war but in several battles—while Alexander was never unsuccessful in a single fight fail to recognize they are comparing the deeds of one young man against the achievements of a nation engaged in wars for nearly eight hundred years. Is it surprising that, when you have more centuries accounted for on one side than years on the other, fortune would fluctuate much more over such a lengthy span than within a brief period of thirteen years? [2] But why not compare the success of one general to another? How many Roman commanders can I name who never lost a battle? In the records, we can find entire pages filled with the names of consuls and dictators, whose courage and successes never gave the Roman people a reason to complain. What makes them more admirable than Alexander or any king is that some of these men served as dictator for only ten, maybe twenty days, none in a role lasting longer than a year in the consulship; their campaigns often hindered by plebeian tribunes, frequently delayed in taking action, called back early for elections, and amidst critical campaign efforts, their year of service ended. Sometimes their colleague’s rashness or stubbornness caused setbacks or losses, and they often took over a challenging situation with an army of inexperienced or poorly trained soldiers. Conversely, kings were free from all kinds of obstacles, masters of circumstances and timing, manipulating everything to serve their plans, not being controlled by anyone. So, an unconquered Alexander would face unconquered commanders, with equally significant stakes at risk. In fact, the danger on his side would have been greater; the Macedonians would have had only one Alexander, who was not only vulnerable but also inclined to put himself in risky situations, while the Romans would have had many who equaled Alexander in fame and achievement; anyone of whom could live or die based on their fate without significantly impacting the public.

19

It remains that the forces be compared together, with respect to their numbers, the quality of the men, and the supplies of auxiliaries. Now, in the general surveys of the age, there were rated two hundred and fifty thousand men, so that, on every revolt of the Latin confederates, ten legions were enlisted almost entirely in the city levy. It often happened during those years, that four or five armies were employed at a time, in Etruria, in Umbria, the Gauls too being at war, in Samnium, in Lucania. Then as to all Latium, with the Sabines, and Volscians, the Aequans, and all Campania; half of Umbria, Etruria, and the Picentians, Marsians, Pelignians, Vestinians, and Apulians; to whom may add, the whole coast of the lower sea, possessed by the Greeks, from Thurii to Neapolis and Cumae; and the Samnites from thence as far as Antium and Ostia: all these he would have found either powerful allies to the Romans or deprived of power by their arms. He would have crossed the sea with his veteran Macedonians, amounting to no more than thirty thousand infantry and four thousand horse, these mostly Thessalians. This was the whole of his strength. Had he brought with him Persians and Indians, and those other nations, it would be dragging after him an encumbrance other than a support. Add to this, that the Romans, being at home, would have had recruits at hand: Alexander, waging war in a foreign country, would have found his army worn out with long service, as happened afterwards to Hannibal. As to arms, theirs were a buckler and long spears; those of the Romans, a shield, which covered the body more effectually, and a javelin, a much more forcible weapon than the spear, either in throwing or striking. The soldiers, on both sides, were used to steady combat, and to preserve their ranks. But the Macedonian phalanx was unapt for motion, and composed of similar parts throughout: the Roman line less compact, consisting of several various parts, was easily divided as occasion required, and as easily conjoined. Then what soldier is comparable to the Roman in the throwing up of works? who better calculated to endure fatigue? Alexander, if overcome in one battle, would have been overcome in war. The Roman, whom Claudium, whom Cannae, did not crush, what line of battle could crush? In truth, even should events have been favourable to him at first, he would have often wished for the Persians, the Indians, and the effeminate tribes of Asia, as opponents; and would have acknowledged, that his wars had been waged with women, as we are told was said by Alexander, king of Epirus, after receiving his mortal wound, when comparing the wars waged in Asia by this very youth, with those in which himself had been engaged. Indeed, when I reflect that, in the first Punic war, a contest was maintained by the Romans with the Carthaginians, at sea, for twenty-four years, I can scarcely suppose that the life of Alexander would have been long enough for the finishing of one war [with either of those nations]. And perhaps, as both the Punic state was united to the Roman by ancient treaties, and as similar apprehensions might arm against a common foe those two nations the most potent of the time in arms and in men, he might have been overwhelmed in a Punic and a Roman war at once. The Romans have had experience of the boasted prowess of the Macedonians in arms, not indeed under Alexander as their general, or when their power was at the height, but in the wars against Antiochus, Philip, and Perses; and not only not with any losses, but not even with any danger to themselves. Let not my assertion give offence, nor our civil wars be brought into mention; never were we worsted by an enemy's cavalry, never by their infantry, never in open fight, never on equal ground, much less when the ground was favourable. Our soldiers, heavy laden with arms, may reasonably fear a body of cavalry, or arrows; defiles of difficult passage, and places impassable to convoys. But they have defeated, and will defeat a thousand armies, more formidable than those of Alexander and the Macedonians, provided that the same love of peace and solicitude about domestic harmony, in which we now live, continue permanent.

It’s important to compare the forces based on their numbers, the quality of the troops, and the support from allies. At that time, there were about two hundred and fifty thousand men rated, so during every revolt of the Latin confederates, ten legions were raised mostly from the city. It often happened in those years that four or five armies were deployed at a time, in Etruria, in Umbria, with the Gauls also at war, in Samnium, and in Lucania. Then, concerning all of Latium, the Sabines, the Volscians, the Aequans, and all of Campania; half of Umbria, Etruria, along with the Picentians, Marsians, Pelignians, Vestinians, and Apulians; not to mention the whole coast of the lower sea, controlled by the Greeks, from Thurii to Neapolis and Cumae; and the Samnites stretching from there to Antium and Ostia: all these would have either been strong allies for the Romans or weakened by their arms. He would have brought with him his seasoned Macedonians, totaling only thirty thousand infantry and four thousand cavalry, mostly from Thessaly. This was his entire strength. If he had included Persians, Indians, and other nations, it would have created a burden rather than support. Additionally, the Romans, being at home, would have readily available recruits: Alexander, fighting in a foreign land, would have seen his army worn out from long service, as later happened to Hannibal. As for weapons, theirs were a shield and long spears; while the Romans had shields that protected their bodies more effectively, and javelins, which were much stronger weapons than spears, for both throwing and striking. The troops on both sides were trained for close combat and maintaining their formations. However, the Macedonian phalanx was less agile and uniform throughout; the Roman line, being less compact and consisting of various components, could easily be divided as needed and just as easily rejoined. So, what soldier could match the Roman in fortifying positions? Who could endure fatigue better? If Alexander lost one battle, he would lose the war. The Roman, who wasn’t defeated at Claudium or Cannae, what battle line could defeat him? In fact, even if circumstances had favored him initially, he would often wish for the Persians, Indians, and the less robust tribes of Asia as his opponents; and would have realized that his wars were fought against easy targets, which Alexander, king of Epirus, reportedly remarked after sustaining his fatal injury, when comparing his own wars with those that this very youth fought in Asia. Indeed, when I think about how, in the first Punic War, the Romans engaged the Carthaginians at sea for twenty-four years, I can scarcely believe that Alexander's life would have been long enough to finish a single war with either of those nations. And perhaps, since the Punic state was historically linked to Rome through ancient treaties, a similar fear might unite those two powerful nations against a common enemy, which could have overwhelmed him in both a Punic and Roman war simultaneously. The Romans have experienced the famed military skill of the Macedonians, not under Alexander as their commander or when their power was at its peak, but in the wars against Antiochus, Philip, and Perseus; and not only did they not suffer any losses, but they faced no danger. Please let my words not cause offense, nor bring our civil wars into discussion; we were never defeated by the cavalry of our enemies, nor by their infantry, nor in open combat, nor on equal ground, much less when the ground was advantageous. Our soldiers, heavily armed, may justly fear a cavalry charge or arrows; difficult terrain and impassable paths might cause concern. But they have defeated, and will defeat, a thousand armies—more formidable than those of Alexander and the Macedonians—if we continue to uphold the same love for peace and commitment to domestic harmony that we currently enjoy.

20

Marcus Foslius Flaccinator and Lucius Plautius Venno were the next raised to the consulship. In this year ambassadors came from most of the states of the Samnites to procure a renewal of the treaty; and, after they had moved the compassion of the senate, by prostrating themselves before them, on being referred to the people, they found not their prayers so efficacious. The treaty therefore, being refused, after they had importuned them individually for several days, was obtained. The Teaneans likewise, and Canusians of Apulia, worn out by the devastations of their country, surrendered themselves to the consul, Lucius Plautius, and gave hostages. This year praefects first began to be created for Capua, and a code of laws was given to that nation, by Lucius Furius the praetor; both in compliance with their own request, as a remedy for the disorder of their affairs, occasioned by intestine dissensions. At Rome, two additional tribes were constituted, the Ufentine and Falerine. On the affairs of Apulia falling into decline, the Teatians of that country came to the new consuls, Caius Junius Bubulcus, and Quintus Aemilius Barbula, suing for an alliance; and engaging, that peace should be observed towards the Romans through every part of Apulia. By pledging themselves boldly for this, they obtained the grant of an alliance, not however on terms of equality, but of their submitting to the dominion of the Roman people. Apulia being entirely reduced, (for Junius had also gained possession of Forentum, a town of great strength,) the consuls advanced into Lucania; there Nerulum was surprised and stormed by the sudden advance of the consul Aemilius. When fame had spread abroad among the allies, how firmly the affairs of Capua were settled by [the introduction of] the Roman institutions, the Antians, imitating the example, presented a complaint of their being without laws, and without magistrates; on which the patrons of the colony itself were appointed by the senate to form a body of laws for it. Thus not only the arms, but the laws, of Rome became extensively prevalent.

Marcus Foslius Flaccinator and Lucius Plautius Venno were the next to be appointed as consuls. That year, ambassadors from most of the Samnite states came to seek a renewal of their treaty. They tried to appeal to the senate's compassion by bowing down before them, but when their request was taken to the people, it wasn’t as effective as they had hoped. As a result, after begging the senators one by one for several days, they eventually got what they wanted. Similarly, the Teaneans and Canusians from Apulia, exhausted by the devastation of their lands, surrendered to the consul, Lucius Plautius, and offered hostages. This year marked the first creation of praefects for Capua, and Lucius Furius the praetor provided a set of laws for that nation, fulfilling their request as a remedy for the chaos caused by internal conflicts. In Rome, two new tribes were established: the Ufentine and the Falerine. As the situation in Apulia declined, the Teatians from that region approached the new consuls, Caius Junius Bubulcus and Quintus Aemilius Barbula, asking for an alliance, promising to maintain peace with the Romans throughout Apulia. By boldly committing to this, they secured an alliance, but not as equals; they had to submit to the authority of the Roman people. With Apulia fully conquered (as Junius had also seized Forentum, a strongly fortified town), the consuls moved into Lucania, where the consul Aemilius surprised and captured Nerulum in a swift attack. When news spread among the allies about how solidly the situation in Capua had been stabilized by the Roman institutions, the Antians, following their lead, complained about their lack of laws and magistrates. Consequently, the senate appointed the colony's patrons to draft a set of laws for them. Thus, not just the military strength, but also the laws of Rome became widely adopted.

21

The consuls, Caius Junius Bubulcus and Quintus Aemilius Barbula, at the conclusion of the year, delivered over the legions, not to the consuls elected by themselves, who were Spurius Nautius and Marcus Popillius, but to a dictator, Lucius Aemilius. He, with Lucius Fulvius, master of the horse, having commenced to lay siege to Saticula, gave occasion to the Samnites of reviving hostilities. Hence a twofold alarm was occasioned to the Roman army. On one side, the Samnites having collected a numerous force to relieve their allies from the siege, pitched their camp at a small distance from that of the Romans: on the other side, the Saticulans, opening suddenly their gates, ran up with violent tumult to the posts of the enemy. Afterwards, each party, relying on support from the other, more than on its own strength, formed a regular attack, and pressed on the Romans. The dictator, on his part, though obliged to oppose two enemies at once, yet had his line secure on both sides; for he both chose a position not easily surrounded, and also formed two different fronts. However, he directed his greater efforts against those who had sallied from the town, and, without much resistance, drove them back within the walls. He then turned his whole force against the Samnites: there he found greater difficulty. But the victory, though long delayed, was neither doubtful nor alloyed by losses. The Samnites, being forced to fly into their camp, extinguished their fires at night, and marched away in silence; and renouncing all hopes of relieving Saticula, sat themselves down before Plistia, which was in alliance with the Romans, that they might, if possible, retort equal vexation on their enemy.

The consuls, Caius Junius Bubulcus and Quintus Aemilius Barbula, at the end of the year, handed over command of the legions, not to their elected successors, Spurius Nautius and Marcus Popillius, but to a dictator, Lucius Aemilius. He, along with Lucius Fulvius, the master of the horse, started to lay siege to Saticula, which prompted the Samnites to revive hostilities. This created a twofold threat for the Roman army. On one side, the Samnites gathered a large force to relieve their allies from the siege and set up camp not far from the Romans. On the other side, the Saticulans suddenly opened their gates and rushed toward the enemy in a chaotic frenzy. Subsequently, each side relied on support from the other more than on their own strength, organized an attack, and pushed against the Romans. The dictator, although facing two enemies at once, ensured his lines were secure on both flanks; he chose a position that was hard to surround and established two separate fronts. However, he focused his main efforts against those who had charged out of the town and, with little resistance, forced them back inside the walls. He then redirected his entire force toward the Samnites, where he encountered more resistance. Yet, the victory, although delayed, was clear and without significant losses. The Samnites, driven back to their camp, extinguished their fires at night and left quietly; abandoning all hopes of relieving Saticula, they settled before Plistia, which was allied with the Romans, in hopes of inflicting similar frustration on their enemy.

22

The year coming to a conclusion, the war was thenceforward conducted by a dictator, Quintius Fabius. The new consuls, Lucius Papirius Cursor and Quintus Publilius Philo, both a fourth time, as the former had done, remained at Rome. Fabius came with a reinforcement to Saticula, to receive the army from Aemilius. For the Samnites had not continued before Plistia; but having sent for a new supply of men from home, and relying on their numbers, had encamped in the same spot as before; and, by provoking the Romans to battle, endeavoured to divert them from the siege. The dictator, so much the more intently, pushed forward his operations against the fortifications of the enemy; considering that only as war which was directed against the city, and showing an indifference with respect to the Samnites, except that he placed guards in proper places, to prevent any attempt on his camp. The more furiously did the Samnites ride up to the rampart, and allowed him no quiet. When the enemy were now come up close to the gates of the camp, Quintus Aulius Cerretanus, master of the horse, without consulting the dictator, sallied out furiously at the head of all the troops of cavalry, and drove back the enemy. In this desultory kind of fight, fortune worked up the strength of the combatants in such a manner, as to occasion an extraordinary loss on both sides, and the remarkable deaths of the commanders themselves. First, the general of the Samnites, indignant at being repulsed, and compelled to fly from a place to which he had advanced so confidently, by entreating and exhorting his horsemen, renewed the battle. As he was easily distinguished among the horsemen, while he urged on the fight, the Roman master of the horse galloped up against him, with his spear directed, so furiously, that, with one stroke, he tumbled him lifeless from his horse. The multitude, however, were not, as is generally the case, dismayed by the fall of their leader, but rather raised to fury. All who were within reach darted their weapons at Aulius, who incautiously pushed forward among the enemy's troops; but the chief share of the honour of revenging the death of the Samnite general they assigned to his brother; he, urged by rage and grief, dragged down the victorious master of the horse from his seat, and slew him. Nor were the Samnites far from obtaining his body also, as he had fallen among the enemies' troops: but the Romans instantly dismounted, and the Samnites were obliged to do the same; and lines being thus formed suddenly but, at the same time, untenable through scarcity of necessaries: "for all the country round, from which provisions could be supplied, has revolted; and besides, even were the inhabitants disposed to aid us, the ground is unfavourable. I will not therefore mislead you by leaving a camp here, into which ye may retreat, as on a former day, without completing the victory. Works ought to be secured by arms, not arms by works. Let those keep a camp, and repair to it, whose interest it is to protract the war; but let us cut off from ourselves every other prospect but that of conquering. Advance the standards against the enemy; as soon as the troops shall have marched beyond the rampart, let those who have it in orders burn the camp. Your losses, soldiers, shall be compensated with the spoil of all the nations round who have revolted." The soldiers advanced against the enemy with spirit inflamed by the dictator's discourse, which seemed indication of an extreme necessity; and, at the same time, the very sight of the camp burning behind them, though the nearest part only was set on fire, (for so the dictator had ordered,) was small incitement: rushing on therefore like madmen, they disordered the enemy's battalions at the very first onset; and the master of the horse, when he saw at a distance the fire in the camp, which was a signal agreed on, made a seasonable attack on their rear. The Samnites, thus surrounded on either side, fled different ways. A vast number, who had gathered into a body through fear, yet from confusion incapable of fleeing, were surrounded and cut to pieces. The enemy's camp was taken and plundered; and the soldiers being laden with spoil, the dictator led them back to the Roman camp, highly rejoiced at the success, but by no means so much as at finding, contrary to their expectation, every thing there safe, except a small part only, which was injured or destroyed by the fire.

As the year came to an end, the war was now led by a dictator, Quintius Fabius. The new consuls, Lucius Papirius Cursor and Quintus Publilius Philo, both in their fourth term like the former, stayed in Rome. Fabius arrived with reinforcements at Saticula to take over the army from Aemilius. The Samnites had not stayed in front of Plistia; instead, they called for more men from home and, confident in their numbers, set up camp in the same spot as before. By provoking the Romans for a battle, they tried to distract them from the siege. The dictator, more determined than ever, ramped up his efforts against the enemy's fortifications, seeing it as real warfare focused on the city, while showing indifference towards the Samnites, only placing guards in strategic spots to prevent any attacks on his camp. The Samnites aggressively approached the rampart, not allowing him any peace. When the enemy got close to the camp gates, Quintus Aulius Cerretanus, the cavalry commander, charged out aggressively at the head of all the cavalry without consulting the dictator and pushed back the enemy. In this chaotic fight, fortune amplified the combats' intensity, leading to significant losses on both sides, including the notable deaths of their commanders. First, the Samnite general, frustrated at being pushed back and forced to flee from a position he had confidently advanced to, rallied his horsemen to renew the battle. As he stood out among the cavalry urging them on, the Roman cavalry commander rode up to him, spear aimed so fiercely that with one thrust, he knocked him lifeless off his horse. Yet, unlike what often happens, the troops weren't demoralized by their leader’s fall; instead, they became furious. Those close by hurled their weapons at Aulius, who recklessly advanced among the enemy. The primary credit for avenging the Samnite general’s death went to his brother, who, driven by anger and sorrow, pulled down the victorious cavalry commander and killed him. The Samnites almost seized his body, as he had fallen among their ranks, but the Romans immediately dismounted, forcing the Samnites to do the same; they quickly formed lines, though these were not sustainable due to a lack of supplies. "The surrounding area from which provisions could come has revolted; besides, even if the locals wanted to help us, the land is not suitable. I won’t mislead you into thinking you can retreat here as you did before without securing a victory. Fortifications should be protected by arms, not arms by fortifications. Let those keep camp and retreat whose goal is to prolong the war; we must eliminate any prospects except for winning. Advance the standards against the enemy; as soon as the troops move beyond the rampart, those given orders should burn the camp. Your losses, soldiers, will be made up for with the spoils of all the revolting nations." The soldiers charged toward the enemy, fueled by the dictator's speech, which indicated a dire necessity, along with the sight of the camp burning behind them (only the closest part was set on fire, as the dictator had ordered) serving as further motivation. So, like wild men, they disrupted the enemy’s formations right from the start; and when the cavalry commander saw the fire in the camp, which was an agreed signal, he launched a timely attack on their rear. The Samnites, caught between the two sides, fled in different directions. Many, having gathered out of fear, yet confused and unable to escape, were surrounded and slaughtered. The enemy’s camp was captured and looted, and as the soldiers returned to the Roman camp laden with plunder, the dictator was thrilled not only with the success but also to find, against their expectations, that everything there was safe with just a few things slightly damaged or burned.

24

They then marched back to Sora; and the new consuls, Marcus Poetelius and Caius Sulpicius, receive the army from the dictator Fabius, discharging a great part of the veteran soldiers, having brought with them new cohorts to supply their place. Now while, on account of the dire situation of the city, no certain mode of attack could be devised, and success must either be distant in time, or at desperate risk; a deserter from Sora came out of the town privately by night, and when he had got as far as the Roman watches, desired to be conducted instantly to the consuls: which being complied with, he made them an offer of delivering the place into their hands. When he answered their questions, respecting the means by which he intended to make good his promise, appearing to state a project by no means idle, he persuaded them to remove the Roman camp, which was almost close to the walls, to the distance of six miles; that the consequence would be that this would render the guards by day, and the watches by night, the less vigilant. He then desired that some cohorts should post themselves the following night in the woody places under the town, and took with himself ten chosen soldiers, through steep and almost impassable ways, into the citadel, where a quantity of missive weapons had been collected, larger than bore proportion to the number of men. There were stones besides, some lying at random, as in all craggy places, and others heaped up designedly by the townsmen, to add to the security of the place. Having posted the Romans here, and shown them a steep and narrow path leading up from the town to the citadel--"From this ascent," said he, "even three armed men would keep off any multitude whatever. Now ye are ten in number; and, what is more, Romans, and the bravest among the Romans. The night is in your favour, which, from the uncertainty it occasions, magnifies every object to people once alarmed. I will immediately fill every place with terror: be ye alert in defending the citadel." He then ran down in haste, crying aloud, "To arms, citizens, we are undone, the citadel is taken by the enemy; run, defend it." This he repeated, as he passed the doors of the principal men, the same to all whom he met, and also to those who ran out in a fright into the streets. The alarm, communicated first by one, was soon spread by numbers through all the city. The magistrates, dismayed on hearing from scouts that the citadel was full of arms and armed men, whose number they multiplied, laid aside all hopes of recovering it. All places are filled with terror: the gates are broken open by persons half asleep, and for the most part unarmed, through one of which the body of Roman troops, roused by the noise, burst in, and slew the terrified inhabitants, who attempted to skirmish in the streets. Sora was now taken, when, at the first light, the consuls arrived, and accepted the surrender of those whom fortune had left remaining after the flight and slaughter of the night. Of these, they conveyed in chains to Rome two hundred and twenty-five, whom all men agreed in pointing out as the authors, both of the revolt, and also of the horrid massacre of the colonists. The rest they left in safety at Sora, a garrison being placed there. All those who were brought to Rome were beaten with rods in the forum, and beheaded, to the great joy of the commons, whose interest it most highly concerned, that the multitudes, sent to various places in colonies should be in safety.

They then marched back to Sora, and the new consuls, Marcus Poetelius and Caius Sulpicius, took over the army from the dictator Fabius, letting go of many veteran soldiers while bringing in new cohorts to take their place. Since the city's situation was desperate, no clear plan of attack could be made, and success would either be a long way off or come with great risk. A deserter from Sora sneaked out of the town at night and, once he reached the Roman guards, asked to be taken immediately to the consuls. Once he was brought to them, he offered to surrender the town into their hands. When he answered their questions about how he planned to keep his promise and explained what seemed like a solid plan, he convinced them to move the Roman camp, which was almost at the city walls, back six miles. This would make the guards less vigilant during the day and the watches at night. He then asked for some cohorts to position themselves in the wooded areas below the town the next night and took ten carefully chosen soldiers through steep, almost impassable paths to the citadel, where there was a large stockpile of weapons that was greater than the number of men they had. There were also stones scattered everywhere, as is typical in rocky areas, as well as piles intentionally made by the townspeople to enhance the security of the place. After assigning the Romans here and showing them a steep, narrow path leading from the town to the citadel, he said, "Even three armed men could fend off any crowd from this ascent. You are ten in number; what's more, you are Romans and the bravest among them. The night is on your side, and the uncertainty it brings makes everything seem larger to those who are alarmed. I will quickly create terror everywhere: be ready to defend the citadel." He then hurried back down, shouting, "To arms, citizens, we are doomed, the enemy has taken the citadel; run to defend it." He repeated this as he passed the homes of prominent citizens, to everyone he encountered, and to those who fled in fear into the streets. The alarm, initially spread by one person, quickly grew as more joined in throughout the city. The magistrates, alarmed by reports from scouts that the citadel was filled with weapons and armed men—whom they imagined to be many—abandoned all hope of recapturing it. Panic filled the streets: the gates were broken open by people who were half-asleep and mostly unarmed, through one of which the Roman troops, awakened by the chaos, rushed in and killed the terrified townspeople who tried to fight back in the streets. Sora was captured, and when the first light of day came, the consuls arrived to accept the surrender of those whom fate had allowed to survive the night’s flight and slaughter. Of these, they took two hundred and twenty-five in chains back to Rome, identified by everyone as the instigators of the revolt and the brutal massacre of the colonists. They left the rest safe in Sora, establishing a garrison there. All of those taken to Rome were beaten with rods in the forum and executed, much to the delight of the common people, who had a vested interest in ensuring the safety of the many colonists sent to various locations.

25

The consuls, leaving Sora, turned their warlike operations against the lands and cities of the Ausonians; for all places had been set in commotion by the coming of the Samnites, when the battle was fought at Lautulae: conspiracies likewise had been formed in several parts of Campania; nor was Capua itself clear of the charge: nay, the business spread even to Rome, and inquiries came to be instituted respecting some of the principal men there. However, the Ausonian nation fell into the Roman power, in the same manner as Sora, by their cities being betrayed: these were Ausona Minturnae, and Vescia. Certain young men, of the principal families, twelve in number, having conspired to betray their respective cities, came to the consuls; they informed them that their countrymen, who had for a long time before honestly wished for the coming of the Samnites, on hearing of the battle at Lautulae, had looked on the Romans as defeated, and had assisted the Samnites with supplies of young men and arms; but that, since the Samnites had been beaten out of the country, they were wavering between peace and war, not shutting their gates against the Romans, lest they should thereby invite an attack; yet determined to shut them if an army should approach; that in that fluctuating state they might easily be overpowered by surprise. By these men's advice the camp was moved nearer; and soldiers were sent, at the same time, to each of the three towns; some armed, who were to lie concealed in places near the walls; others, in the garb of peace, with swords hidden under their clothes, when, on the opening of the gates at the approach of day, were to enter into the cities. These latter began with killing the guards; at the same time, a signal was made to the men with arms, to hasten up from the ambuscades. Thus the gates were seized, and the three towns taken in the same hour and by the same device. But as the attacks were made in the absence of the generals, there were no bounds to the carnage which ensued; and the nation of the Ausonians, when there was scarcely any clear proof of the charge of its having revolted, was utterly destroyed, as if it had supported a contest through a deadly war.

The consuls, leaving Sora, directed their military efforts against the lands and cities of the Ausonians; all areas had been thrown into turmoil by the arrival of the Samnites, especially after the battle fought at Lautulae. Conspiracies had also formed in various parts of Campania, and even Capua was not free from suspicion. In fact, the situation extended all the way to Rome, leading to investigations into some of the city's top officials. However, the Ausonian nation fell to Roman control in the same way as Sora, through the betrayal of their cities: Ausona, Minturnae, and Vescia. Twelve young men from prominent families conspired to betray their cities and approached the consuls. They informed them that their fellow citizens, who had long hoped for the coming of the Samnites, believed the Romans were defeated after the battle at Lautulae and had supported the Samnites with young men and weapons. But now that the Samnites had been chased out, they were unsure whether to choose peace or war, keeping their gates open to the Romans to avoid provoking an attack, yet ready to shut them if an army approached. In this uncertain state, they could easily be caught off guard. Following the advice of these men, the camp was moved closer, and soldiers were sent to each of the three towns. Some were armed and concealed near the walls, while others, dressed as peacemakers with swords hidden under their clothes, were to enter as soon as the gates opened at dawn. The latter started by killing the guards, and simultaneously, a signal was given to the armed men to rush in from their hiding spots. This way, the gates were taken, and the three towns were captured in the same hour and by the same tactic. However, since the attacks happened in the absence of the generals, the ensuing slaughter was unchecked, and the Ausonian nation, with little clear evidence of their supposed rebellion, was completely wiped out, as if they had engaged in a brutal war.

26

During this year, Luceria fell into the hands of the Samnites, the Roman garrison being betrayed to the enemy. This matter did not long go unpunished with the traitors: the Roman army was not far off, by whom the city, which lay in a plain, was taken at the first onset. The Lucerians and Samnites were to a man put to the sword; and to such a length was resentment carried, that at Rome, on the senate being consulted about sending a colony to Luceria, many voted for the demolition of it. Besides, their hatred was of the bitterest kind, against a people whom they had been obliged twice to subdue by arms; the great distance, also, made them averse from sending away their citizens among nations so ill-affected towards them. However the resolution was carried, that the colonists should be sent; and accordingly two thousand five hundred were transported thither. This year, when all places were becoming disaffected to the Romans, secret conspiracies were formed among the leading men at Capua, as well as at other places; a motion concerning which being laid before the senate, the matter was by no means neglected. Inquiries were decreed, and it was resolved that a dictator should be appointed to enforce these inquiries. Caius Maenius was accordingly nominated, and he appointed Marcus Foslius master of the horse. People's dread of that office was very great, insomuch that the Calavii, Ovius and Novius, who were the heads of the conspiracy, either through fear of the dictator's power, or the consciousness of guilt, previous to the charge against them being laid in form before him, avoided, as appeared beyond doubt, trial by a voluntary death. As the subject of the inquiry in Campania was thus removed, the proceedings were then directed towards Rome: by construing the order of the senate to have meant, that inquiry should be made, not specially who at Capua, but generally who at any place had caballed or conspired against the state; for that cabals, for the attaining of honours, were contrary to the edicts of the state. The inquiry was extended to a greater latitude, with respect both to the matter, and to the kind of persons concerned, the dictator scrupling not to avow, that his power of research was unlimited: in consequence, some of the nobility were called to account; and though they applied to the tribunes for protection, no one interposed in their behalf, or to prevent the charges from being received. On this the nobles, not those only against whom the charge was levelled, but the whole body jointly insisted that such an imputation lay not against the nobles, to whom the way to honours lay open if not obstructed by fraud, but against the new men: so that even the dictator and master of the horse, with respect to that question, would appear more properly as culprits than suitable inquisitors; and this they should know as soon as they went out of office. Then indeed Maenius, who was more solicitous about his character than his office, advanced into the assembly and spoke to this effect, "Romans, both of my past life ye are all witnesses; and this honourable office, which ye conferred on me, is in itself a testimony of my innocence. For the dictator, proper to be chosen for holding these inquiries, was not, as on many other occasions, where the exigencies of the state so required, the man who was most renowned in war; but him whose counsel of life was most remote from such cabals. But certain of the nobility (for what reason it is more proper that ye should judge than that I, as a magistrate, should, without proof, insinuate) have laboured to stifle entirely the inquiries; and then, finding their strength unequal to it, rather than stand a trial have fled for refuge to the stronghold of their adversaries, an appeal and the support of the tribunes; and on being there also repulsed, (so fully were they persuaded that every other measure was safer than the attempt to clear themselves,) have made an attack upon us; and, though in private characters have not been ashamed of instituting a criminal process against a dictator. Now, that gods and men may perceive that they to avoid a scrutiny as to their own conduct, attempt even things which are impossible, and that I willingly meet the charge, and face the accusations of my enemies, I divest myself of the dictatorship. And, consuls, I beseech you, that if this business is put into your hands by the senate, ye make me and Marcus Foslius the first objects of our your examinations; that it may be manifested that we are safe from such imputations by our own innocence, not by the dignity of office." He then abdicated the dictatorship, as did Marcus Foslius, immediately after, his office of master of the horse; and being the first brought to trial before the consuls, for to them the senate had committed the business, they were most honourably acquitted of all the charges brought by the nobles. Even Publilius Philo, who had so often been invested with the highest honours, and had performed so many eminent services, both at home and abroad, being disagreeable to the nobility, was brought to trial, and acquitted. Nor did the inquiry continue respectable on account of the illustrious names of the accused, longer than while it was new, which is usually the case; it then began to descend to persons of inferior rank; and, at length, was suppressed, by means of those factions and cabals against which it had been instituted.

During this year, Luceria was captured by the Samnites after the Roman garrison was betrayed. The traitors didn’t go unpunished for long: the Roman army was nearby and quickly took the city, which was located in a plain. The Lucerians and Samnites were all killed, and the anger was so intense that when the Senate in Rome discussed sending a colony to Luceria, many voted to demolish it. Their hatred was particularly strong against a people they had already had to defeat in battle twice; the long distance also made them reluctant to send their citizens to live among such hostile nations. Nonetheless, the decision to send colonists was made, and 2,500 people were sent there. This year, as discontent with the Romans was spreading, secret plots began forming among the leaders in Capua and other places. When this was brought to the Senate’s attention, it wasn’t ignored. Inquiries were ordered, and a dictator was appointed to carry them out. Caius Maenius was appointed, and he named Marcus Foslius as his master of the horse. Fear of this position was widespread, and the Calavii, Ovius, and Novius—the leaders of the conspiracy—either out of fear of the dictator’s power or guilt, chose to avoid a formal trial by taking their own lives. With the inquiry in Campania thus resolved, investigations shifted to Rome. The Senate’s order was interpreted to mean that inquiries should be made regarding anyone who had conspired against the state, not just those in Capua, since conspiracies aimed at gaining honors were against state law. The inquiry widened in scope concerning both the nature of the offenses and the individuals involved, with the dictator not hesitating to claim he had unlimited investigative power. As a result, some nobles were brought to account, and although they sought protection from the tribunes, no one intervened on their behalf to block the charges. In response, the nobles, not just those directly accused but collectively, insisted that such accusations should not be aimed at the nobility, who could achieve honors if not obstructed by dishonesty, but rather at the new men. Thus, the dictator and the master of the horse appeared more like culprits than appropriate investigators in this situation. They would realize this as soon as they left office. Maenius, who was more concerned about his reputation than his position, then spoke to the assembly, saying, "Romans, you are all witnesses to my past conduct; this honorable office you have given me is proof of my innocence. The appropriate dictator for these inquiries should not, as has often been the case when the state’s needs required it, be someone renowned in battle, but rather someone whose life has been far from such conspiracies. However, certain nobles—it's better you judge their motives than I accuse them without proof—have tried to completely shut down the inquiries. Then, finding their strength lacking, rather than face a trial, they sought refuge with their enemies, appealing to the support of the tribunes. After being rejected there as well, fully convinced that any other option was safer than attempting to clear their names, they attacked us, and even as private citizens, they shamefully initiated criminal proceedings against a dictator. Now, may the gods and men see that to avoid scrutiny of their own actions, they pursue even impossible means, and I willingly confront the charges and accusations made against me. Therefore, I renounce the dictatorship. And I ask you, consuls, that if the Senate puts this matter in your hands, you first examine me and Marcus Foslius, so it can be shown that we are innocent, not because of our positions but because of our character." He then resigned the dictatorship, followed by Marcus Foslius stepping down as master of the horse, and they were the first to be tried before the consuls, who had been charged with this matter by the Senate. They were honorably acquitted of all accusations brought by the nobles. Even Publilius Philo, who had often held the highest honors and had performed many distinguished services at home and abroad, faced trial and was acquitted as well—despite being disliked by the nobility. The inquiry maintained its importance because of the prestigious names involved only as long as it was new, which is often the case; it then shifted to those of lower rank and eventually was suppressed by the very factions against which it had been initiated.

27

The accounts received of these matters, but more especially the hope of a revolt in Campania, for which a conspiracy had been formed, recalled the Samnites, who were turning towards Apulia, back to Caudium; so that from thence, being near, they might, if any commotion should open them an opportunity, snatch Capua out of the hands of the Romans. To the same place the consuls repaired with a powerful army. They both held back for some time, on the different sides of the defiles, the roads being dangerous to either party. Then the Samnites, making a short circuit through an open tract, marched down their troops into level ground in the Campanian plains, and there the hostile camps first came within view of each other. Trial of their strength in slight skirmishes was made on both sides, more frequently between the horse than the foot; and the Romans were no way dissatisfied either at the issue of these, or at the delay by which they protracted the war. The Samnite generals, on the contrary, considered that their battalions were becoming weakened daily by small losses, and the general vigour abated by prolonging the war. They therefore marched into the field, disposing their cavalry on both wings, with orders to give more heedful attention to the camp behind than to the battle; for that the line of infantry would be able to provide for their own safety. The consuls took post, Sulpicius on the right wing, Poetelius on the left. The right wing was stretched out wider than usual, where the Samnites also stood formed in thin ranks, either with design of turning the flank of the enemy, or to avoid being themselves surrounded. On the left, besides that they were formed in more compact order, an addition was made to their strength, by a sudden act of the consul Poetelius; for the subsidiary cohorts, which were usually reserved for the exigencies of a tedious fight, he brought up immediately to the front, and, in the first onset, pushed the enemy with the whole of his force. The Samnite line of infantry giving way, their cavalry advanced to support them; and as they were charging in an oblique direction between the two lines, the Roman horse, coming up at full speed, disordered their battalions and ranks of infantry and cavalry, so as to oblige the whole line on that side to give ground. The left wing had not only the presence of Poetelius to animate them, but that of Sulpicius likewise; who, on the shout being first raised in that quarter, rode thither from his own division, which had not yet engaged. When he saw victory no longer doubtful there, he returned to his own post with twelve hundred men, but found the state of things there very different; the Romans driven from their ground, and the victorious enemy pressing on them thus dismayed. However, the arrival of the consul effected a speedy change in every particular; for, on the sight of their leader, the spirit of the soldiers was revived, and the bravery of the men who came with him rendered them more powerful aid than even their number; while the news of success in the other wing, which was heard, and after seen, restored the fight. From this time, the Romans became victorious through the whole extent of the line, and the Samnites, giving up the contest, were slain or taken prisoners, except such as made their escape to Maleventum, the town which is now called Beneventum. It is recorded that thirty thousand of the Samnites were slain or taken.

The reports about these events, especially the hope for a rebellion in Campania due to a conspiracy, brought the Samnites, who were heading towards Apulia, back to Caudium. They wanted to stay close by in case any disturbances gave them a chance to seize Capua from the Romans. The consuls also moved to the same location with a strong army. For a while, both sides held back in the dangerous passes. Then the Samnites took a quick route through an open area and marched their troops onto the flat terrain of the Campanian plains, where the opposing camps first saw each other. Both sides engaged in minor skirmishes, mostly between the cavalry rather than the infantry, and the Romans were satisfied with the outcomes and the delay in the war. On the other hand, the Samnite generals worried that their forces were weakening daily due to small losses, and they feared that prolonging the war would diminish their overall strength. So, they positioned their cavalry on both flanks, instructing them to focus more on protecting their camp than on the battle itself, believing their infantry could ensure their own safety. The consuls took their positions, with Sulpicius on the right and Poetelius on the left. The right flank was spread out wider than usual, while the Samnites were arranged in thin lines, either to outmaneuver the enemy's flank or to avoid being surrounded. On the left, where the Samnites were more tightly packed, Poetelius made a sudden move by bringing up the auxiliary cohorts typically held back for prolonged fights and launched a full-force attack right away. As the Samnite infantry began to falter, their cavalry moved in to support them; but when they charged obliquely between the two lines, the Roman cavalry surged in at full speed, disrupting their infantry and cavalry formations, causing them to retreat. The left flank not only had Poetelius there to encourage them but also Sulpicius, who, hearing the cheers from that side, rode over from his own unit that hadn’t yet engaged. Once he saw that victory was no longer in doubt in that area, he returned to his position with twelve hundred men, only to find a very different situation: the Romans had been pushed back, and the victorious enemy was pressing in on them. However, the arrival of the consul quickly changed everything; seeing their leader reignited the soldiers' spirit, and the courage of those who accompanied him proved more helpful than just their numbers. Meanwhile, news of the success on the other wing reached them, reinvigorating the fight. From that point, the Romans prevailed across the entire line, forcing the Samnites to surrender, with many being killed or captured, except for those who managed to flee to Maleventum, now known as Beneventum. It is recorded that thirty thousand Samnites were either killed or taken prisoner.

28

The consuls, after this important victory, led forward the legions to lay siege to Bovianum; and there they passed the winter quarters, until Caius Poetelius, being nominated dictator, with Marcus Foslius, master of the horse, received the command of the army from the new consuls, Lucius Papirius Cursor a fifth, and Caius Junius Bubulcus a second time. On hearing that the citadel of Fregellae was taken by the Samnites, he left Bovianum, and proceeded to Fregellae, whence, having recovered possession of it without any contest, the Samnites abandoning it in the night, and having placed a strong garrison there, he returned to Campania, directing his operations principally to the recovery of Nola. Within the walls of this place, the whole multitude of the Samnites, and the inhabitants of the country about Nola, betook themselves on the approach of the dictator. Having taken a view of the situation of the city, in order that the approach to the fortifications may be the more open, he set fire to all the buildings which stood round the walls, which were very numerous; and, in a short time after, Nola was taken, either by the dictator Poetelius, or the consul Caius Junius, for both accounts are given. Those who attribute to the consul the honour of taking Nola, add, that Atina and Calatia were also taken by him, and that Poetelius was created dictator in consequence of a pestilence breaking out, merely for the purpose of driving the nail. The colonies of Suessa and Pontiae were established in this year. Suessa had belonged to the Auruncians: the Volscians had occupied Pontiae, an island lying within sight of their shore. A decree of the senate was also passed for conducting colonies to Interamna and Cassinum. But commissioners were appointed, and colonists, to the number of four thousand, were sent by the succeeding consuls, Marcus Valerius and Publius Decius.

The consuls, after this major victory, led the legions to lay siege to Bovianum, where they spent the winter. Caius Poetelius was appointed dictator, along with Marcus Foslius, the master of the horse. They took command of the army from the new consuls, Lucius Papirius Cursor, serving a fifth term, and Caius Junius Bubulcus, serving a second term. When he heard that the Samnites had captured the citadel of Fregellae, he left Bovianum and headed to Fregellae. He quickly took it back without any conflict, as the Samnites abandoned it during the night. After placing a strong garrison there, he returned to Campania, focusing mainly on regaining Nola. The entire population of Samnites and local residents took refuge inside Nola as the dictator approached. After assessing the city’s layout to make the attack on the fortifications easier, he set fire to all the surrounding buildings, which were numerous. Shortly afterward, Nola was captured, either by dictator Poetelius or consul Caius Junius, as both accounts exist. Those who credit the consul with the capture of Nola also claim that Atina and Calatia fell to him, while Poetelius was appointed dictator due to an outbreak of disease, mainly to take charge. The colonies of Suessa and Pontiae were established this year. Suessa had belonged to the Auruncians, while the Volscians had claimed Pontiae, an island visible from their shore. The senate also passed a decree to send colonies to Interamna and Cassinum. However, it was the following consuls, Marcus Valerius and Publius Decius, who appointed commissioners and sent a total of four thousand colonists.

29

The war with the Samnites being now nearly put an end to, before the Roman senate was freed from all concern on that side, a report arose of an Etrurian war; and there was not, in those times, any nation, excepting the Gauls, whose arms were more dreaded, by reason both of the vicinity of their country, and of the multitude of their men. While therefore one of the consuls prosecuted the remains of the war in Samnium, Publius Decius, who, being attacked by a severe illness, remained at Rome, by direction of the senate, nominated Caius Junius Bubulcus dictator. He, as the magnitude of the affair demanded, compelled all the younger citizens to enlist, and with the utmost diligence prepared arms, and the other matters which the occasion required. Yet he was not so elated by the power he had collected, as to think of commencing offensive operations, but prudently determined to remain quiet, unless the Etrurians should become aggressors. The plans of the Etrurians were exactly similar with respect to preparing for, and abstaining from, war: neither party went beyond their own frontiers. The censorship of Appius Claudius and Caius Plautius, for this year, was remarkable; but the name of Appius has been handed down with more celebrity to posterity, on account of his having made the road, [called after him, the Appian,] and for having conveyed water into the city. These works he performed alone; for his colleague, overwhelmed with shame by reason of the infamous and unworthy choice made of senators, had abdicated his office. Appius possessing that inflexibility Of temper, which, from the earliest times, had been the characteristic of his family, held on the censorship by himself. By direction of the same Appius, the Potitian family, in which the office of priests attendant on the great altar of Hercules was hereditary, instructed some of the public servants in the rites of that solemnity, with the intention to delegate the same to them. A circumstance is recorded, wonderful to be told, and one which should make people scrupulous of disturbing the established modes of religious solemnities: for though there were, at that time, twelve branches of the Potitian family, all grown-up persons, to the number of thirty, yet they were every one, together with their offspring, cut off within the year; so that the name of the Potitii became extinct, while the censor Appius also was, by the unrelenting wrath of the gods, some years after, deprived of sight.

The war with the Samnites was almost over, and before the Roman senate could relax, news came of a war with the Etruscans. At that time, there was no nation, except for the Gauls, whose military was more feared due to their proximity and their large numbers. While one of the consuls continued the war in Samnium, Publius Decius, who was seriously ill and stayed in Rome at the senate’s request, appointed Caius Junius Bubulcus as dictator. He, recognizing the seriousness of the situation, required all the younger citizens to enlist and worked urgently to prepare weapons and other necessities. However, he wasn’t overly confident in his power and decided it was wise to stay defensive unless the Etruscans took the initiative. The Etruscans had similar plans regarding preparing for war while avoiding aggression; neither side crossed their borders. The censorship of Appius Claudius and Caius Plautius this year was notable, but Appius’s name became more famous because of the road he built, known as the Appian Way, and for bringing water into the city. He accomplished these projects alone because his colleague, shamed by the poor selection of senators, resigned from his position. Appius, known for his strong will, continued his role as censor on his own. Under Appius’s direction, the Potitian family, who had a hereditary role as priests for the great altar of Hercules, taught some public servants the rituals associated with that duty, intending to pass it on to them. A remarkable thing happened that should make people think twice about interfering with established religious practices: although there were at that time twelve branches of the Potitian family, all adults, totaling thirty individuals, every one of them and their descendants were wiped out within a year. As a result, the Potitii name disappeared, and years later, Appius, due to the relentless anger of the gods, also lost his sight.

30

The consuls of the succeeding year were, Caius Junius Bubulcus a third time, and Quintus Aemilius Barbula a second. In the commencement of their office, they complained before the people, that, by the improper choice of members of the senate, that body had been disgraced, several having been passed over who were preferable to the persons chosen in; and they declared, that they would pay no regard to such election, which had been made without distinction of right or wrong, merely to gratify interest or humour: they then immediately called over the list of the senate, in the same order which had existed before the censorship of Appius Claudius and Caius Plautius. Two public employments, both relating to military affairs, came this year into the disposal of the people; one being an order, that sixteen of the tribunes, for four legions, should be appointed by the people; whereas hitherto they had been generally in the gift of the dictators and consuls, very few of the places being left to suffrage. This order was proposed by Lucius Atilius and Caius Marcius, plebeian tribunes. Another was, that the people likewise should constitute two naval commissioners, for the equipping and refitting of the fleet. The person who introduced this order of the people, was Marcus Decius, plebeian tribune. Another transaction of this year I should pass over as trifling, did it not seem to bear some relation to religion. The flute-players, taking offence because they had been prohibited by the last censors from holding their repasts in the temple of Jupiter, which had been customary from very early times, went off in a body to Tibur; so that there was not one left in the city to play at the sacrifices. The religious tendency of this affair gave uneasiness to the senate; and they sent envoys to Tibur to endeavour that these men might be sent back to Rome. The Tiburtines readily promised compliance, and first, calling them into the senate-house, warmly recommended to them to return to Rome; and then, when they could not be prevailed on, practised on them an artifice not ill adapted to the dispositions of that description of people: on a festival day, they invited them separately to their several houses, apparently with the intention of heightening the pleasure of their feasts with music, and there plied them with wine, of which such people are always fond, until they laid them asleep. In this state of insensibility they threw them into waggons, and carried them away to Rome: nor did they know any thing of the matter, until, the waggons having been left in the forum, the light surprised them, still heavily sick from the debauch. The people then crowded about them, and, on their consenting at length to stay, privilege was granted them to ramble about the city in full dress, with music, and the licence which is now practised every year during three days. And that licence, which we see practised at present, and the right of being fed in the temple, was restored to those who played at the sacrifices. These incidents occurred while the public attention was deeply engaged by two most important wars.

The consuls for the following year were Caius Junius Bubulcus for the third time and Quintus Aemilius Barbula for the second. At the start of their term, they expressed to the people their dissatisfaction that the senate had been dishonored due to poor selections, as many qualified candidates had been overlooked in favor of those chosen. They stated they would disregard such elections, which were made without any proper consideration of right or wrong, merely to serve personal interests or whims. They then promptly reviewed the list of senators in the same order that existed before the censorship of Appius Claudius and Caius Plautius. This year, two public positions related to military matters were opened up for the people to decide; one was a decree allowing the appointment of sixteen tribunes for four legions by the citizens, whereas previously these positions had mostly been controlled by dictators and consuls, with very few left for popular vote. This proposal was brought forward by Lucius Atilius and Caius Marcius, who were plebeian tribunes. The other motion was for the people to also choose two naval commissioners responsible for equipping and repairing the fleet. This initiative was introduced by Marcus Decius, another plebeian tribune. There was another event this year that might seem trivial, but it appeared to have religious significance. The flute players, upset because the last censors had banned them from having their meals in the temple of Jupiter—a long-standing custom—left en masse for Tibur, leaving no one to perform during the sacrifices in the city. The senate took this matter seriously and sent envoys to Tibur to urge the return of the musicians to Rome. The Tiburtines readily agreed to help and first called the musicians into the senate house, encouraging them to go back to Rome. When they wouldn’t budge, the Tiburtines used a clever tactic suited to the musicians: on a festival day, they invited them into their homes under the pretense of enhancing their celebrations with music and then plied them with wine, which they loved, until they passed out. In that state, they loaded them into wagons and took them back to Rome, unaware of what was happening until the wagons halted in the forum and they were awoken, still groggy from their indulgence. The people then gathered around them, and after they finally agreed to stay, they were allowed to dance around the city in full costume, with music—a privilege that is now celebrated every year for three days. That same privilege, along with the right to be fed in the temple, was restored to those who played at the sacrifices. These events took place while the public was intensely focused on two significant wars.

31

The consuls adjusting the provinces between them, the Samnites fell by lot to Junius, the new war of Etruria to Aemilius. In Samnium the Samnites had blockaded and reduced by famine Cluvia, a Roman garrison, because they had been unable to take it by storm; and, after torturing with stripes, in a shocking manner, the townsmen who surrendered, they had put them to death. Enraged at this cruelty, Junius determined to postpone every thing else to the attacking of Cluvia; and, on the first day that he assaulted the walls, took it by storm, and slew all who were grown to man's estate. The victorious troops were led from thence to Bovianum; this was the capital of the Pentrian Samnites, by far the most opulent of their cities, and the most powerful both in men and arms. The soldiers, stimulated by the hope of plunder, for their resentment was not so violent, soon made themselves masters of the town: where there was less severity exercised on the enemy; but a quantity of spoil was carried off, greater almost than had ever been collected out of all Samnium, and the whole was liberally bestowed on the assailants. And when neither armies, camps, or cities could now withstand the vast superiority of the Romans in arms; the attention of all the leading men in Samnium became intent on this, that an opportunity should be sought for some stratagem, if by any chance the army, proceeding with incautious eagerness for plunder, could be caught in a snare and overpowered. Peasants who deserted and some prisoners (some thrown in their way by accident, some purposely) reporting to the consul a statement in which they concurred, and one which was at the same time true, that a vast quantity of cattle had been driven together into a defile of difficult access, prevailed on them to lead thither the legions lightly accoutred for plunder. Here a very numerous army of the enemy had posted themselves, secretly, at all the passes; and, as soon as they saw that the Romans had got into the defile, they rose up suddenly, with great clamour and tumult, and attacked them unawares. At first an event so unexpected caused some confusion, while they were taking their arms, and throwing the baggage into the centre; but, as fast as each had freed himself from his burden and fitted himself with arms, they assembled about the standards, from every side; and all, from the long course of their service, knowing their particular ranks, the line was formed of its own accord without any directions. The consul, riding up to the place where the fight was most warm, leaped from his horse, and called "Jupiter, Mars, and the other gods to witness, that he had come into that place, not in pursuit of any glory to himself, but of booty for his soldiers; nor could any other fault be charged on him, than too great a solicitude to enrich his soldiers at the expense of the enemy. From that disgrace nothing could extricate him but the valour of the troops: let them only join unanimously in a vigorous attack against a foe, already vanquished in the field, beaten out of their camps, and stripped of their towns, and now trying their last hope by the contrivance of an ambuscade, placing their reliance on the ground they occupied, not on their arms. But what ground was now unsurmountable to Roman valour?" The citadel of Fregellae, and that of Sora, were called to their remembrance, with many other places where difficulties from situation had been surmounted. Animated by these exhortations, the soldiers, regardless of all difficulties, advanced against the line of the enemy, posted above them; and here there was some fatigue whilst the army was climbing the steep. But as soon as the first battalions got footing in the plain, on the summit, and the troops perceived that they now stood on equal ground, the dismay was instantly turned on the plotters; who, dispersing and casting away their arms, attempted, by flight, to recover the same lurking-places in which they had lately concealed themselves. But the difficulties of the ground, which had been intended for the enemy, now entangled them in the snares of their own contrivance. Accordingly very few found means to escape; twenty thousand men were slain, and the victorious Romans hastened in several parties to secure the booty of cattle, spontaneously thrown in their way by the enemy.

The consuls dividing the provinces between them saw that the Samnites were assigned to Junius and the new war in Etruria to Aemilius. In Samnium, the Samnites had surrounded and starved the Roman garrison at Cluvia, unable to capture it by force; and after brutally torturing the townspeople who surrendered, they executed them. Angry at this cruelty, Junius decided to focus solely on attacking Cluvia. On the first day he assaulted the walls, he captured it and killed all the adult men. The victorious troops then moved on to Bovianum, the capital of the Pentrian Samnites, which was the richest and most powerful of their cities in terms of people and military strength. Motivated by the prospect of plunder, the soldiers—whose anger had lessened—quickly took control of the town, exercising less brutality against the enemy but carrying away a vast amount of loot, greater than what had ever been collected from all of Samnium, which was generously shared among the attackers. When neither armies, camps, nor cities could withstand the Romans' overwhelming military might, the attention of all the leading men in Samnium turned to finding a cunning plan to catch the Roman army off guard as they eagerly pursued loot. Some deserters and prisoners—some who happened to be in their way and some thrown purposely into the mix—convinced the consul with a true report that a large herd of cattle had been gathered in a difficult-to-reach pass. This persuaded him to lead the legions lightly equipped for looting into the area. A large enemy army had secretly positioned themselves at all the passes, and as soon as they saw the Romans enter the defile, they suddenly sprang up in a loud and chaotic attack. Initially, the surprise caused some confusion as the Romans grabbed their weapons and stashed their bags in the center; but as soon as each soldier discarded his burden and armed himself, they rallied around the standards from all sides, forming lines instinctively based on their long service, without needing any orders. The consul rode up to the center of the fiercest fighting, leaped from his horse, and called upon Jupiter, Mars, and the other gods to witness that he had come there not for his own glory but to secure loot for his soldiers; the only fault he could admit was being overly eager to enrich his men at the enemy's expense. He knew he could only be saved from disgrace by the courage of his troops: if they could unite in a strong attack against an enemy already defeated in battle, driven from their camps, stripped of their towns, and now relying on a last-ditch ambush rather than their arms, then what ground could withstand Roman valor? The citadel of Fregellae and that of Sora were recalled, along with many other places where challenges posed by terrain had been overcome. Inspired by these words, the soldiers pressed forward against the enemy lines positioned above them, encountering some fatigue as they climbed the steep slope. But as soon as the first battalions gained a foothold on the summit and realized they were now on even ground, the panic shifted to the ambushers, who scattered and discarded their weapons, attempting to flee back to the hiding spots where they had recently concealed themselves. However, the very difficulties of the terrain meant to trap the Romans ended up ensnaring the attackers. Consequently, very few managed to escape; twenty thousand men were killed, and the victorious Romans rushed in groups to collect the cattle loot offered up by the enemy.

32

While such was the situation of affairs in Samnium, all the states of Etruria, except the Arretians, had taken arms, and vigorously commenced hostilities, by laying siege to Sutrium; which city, being in alliance with the Romans, served as a barrier against Etruria. Thither the other consul, Aemilius, came with an army to deliver the allies from the siege. On the arrival of the Romans, the Sutrians conveyed a plentiful supply of provisions into their camp, which was pitched before the city. The Etrurians spent the first day in deliberating whether they should expedite or protract the war. On the day following, when the speedier plan pleased the leaders in preference to the safer, as soon as the sun rose the for battle was displayed, and the troops marched out to the field; which being reported to the consul, he instantly commanded notice to be given, that they should dine, and after taking refreshment, then appear under arms. The order was obeyed; and the consul, seeing them armed and in readiness, ordered the standards to be carried forth beyond the rampart, and drew up his men at a small distance from the enemy. Both parties stood a long time with fixed attention, each waiting for the shout and fight to begin on the opposite side; and the sun had passed the meridian before a weapon was thrown by either side. Then, rather than leave the place without something being done, the shout was given by the Etrurians, the trumpets sounded, and the battalions advanced. With no less alertness do the Romans commence the fight: both rushed to the fight with violent animosity; the enemy were superior in numbers, the Romans in valour. The battle being doubtful, carries off great numbers on both sides, particularly the men of greatest courage; nor did victory declare itself, until the second line of the Romans came up fresh to the front, in the place of the first, who were much fatigued. The Etrurians, because their front line was not supported by any fresh reserves, fell all before and round the standards, and in no battle whatever would there have been seen less disposition to run, or a greater effusion of human blood, had not the night sheltered the Etrurians, who were resolutely determined on death; so that the victors, not the vanquished, were the first who desisted from fighting. After sunset the signal for retreat was given, and both parties retired in the night to their camps. During the remainder of the year, nothing memorable was effected at Sutrium; for, of the enemy's army, the whole first line had been cut off in one battle, the reserves only being left, who were scarce sufficient to guard the camp; and, among the Romans, so numerous were the wounds, that more wounded men died after the battle than had fallen in the field.

While this was happening in Samnium, all the states of Etruria, except for the Arretians, had taken up arms and aggressively started fighting by laying siege to Sutrium. This city, allied with the Romans, acted as a barrier against Etruria. The other consul, Aemilius, came with an army to rescue the allies from the siege. When the Romans arrived, the Sutrians brought a large supply of food into their camp, which was set up outside the city. The Etrurians spent the first day deciding whether to speed up the war or prolong it. The next day, when the quicker option appealed to the leaders more than the safer one, as soon as the sun rose, the orders for battle were raised, and the troops marched out into the field. When the consul heard this, he promptly instructed that they should eat, and after refreshing themselves, they should come ready for battle. The order was followed, and once the consul saw they were armed and ready, he had the standards taken beyond the rampart and positioned his men not too far from the enemy. Both sides stood in concentrated anticipation for a long time, waiting for the other to start the fight; it was after noon before anyone threw a weapon. Rather than leave without engaging, the Etrurians shouted, the trumpets sounded, and the battalions moved forward. The Romans responded with equal urgency: both sides charged into battle with fierce intensity; the enemy had the advantage in numbers, while the Romans had the edge in courage. The battle was uncertain, causing heavy casualties on both sides, especially among the bravest fighters; victory wasn’t decided until the second line of Romans came up fresh to take the place of the fatigued first line. The Etrurians fell before and around the standards because their front line wasn’t supported by fresh reserves. In any other battle, there would have been less inclination to flee and a greater spill of blood, had it not been for the night that covered the Etrurians, who were resolutely prepared to face death; thus, the victors were the first to stop fighting, not the defeated. After sunset, the order to retreat was given, and both sides returned to their camps during the night. For the rest of the year, nothing noteworthy occurred at Sutrium; the entire enemy front line had been wiped out in that one battle, leaving only the reserves, who were barely enough to defend the camp. Among the Romans, the number of wounded was so high that more of them died after the battle than had fallen in the field.

33

Quintus Fabius, consul for the ensuing year, succeeded to the command of the army at Sutrium; the colleague given to him was Caius Marcius Rutilus. On the one side, Fabius brought with him a reinforcement from Rome, and on the other, a new army had been sent for, and came from home, to the Etrurians. Many years had now passed without any disputes between the patrician magistrates and plebeian tribunes, when a contest took its rise from that family, which seemed raised by fate as antagonists to the tribunes and commons of those times; Appius Claudius, being censor, when the eighteen months had expired, which was the time limited by the Aemilian law for the duration of the censorship, although his colleague Caius Plautius had already resigned his office, could not be prevailed on, by any means, to give up his. There was a tribune of the commons, Publius Sempronius; he undertook to enforce a legal process for terminating the censorship within the lawful time, which was not more popular than just, nor more pleasing to the people generally than to every man of character in the city. After he frequently appealed to the Aemilian law, and bestowed commendations on Mamercus Aemilius, who, in his dictatorship, had been the author of it, for having contracted, within the space of a year and six months, the censorship, which formerly had lasted five years, and was a power which, in consequence of its long continuance, often became tyrannical, he proceeded thus: "Tell me, Appius Claudius, in what manner you would have acted, had you been censor, at the time when Caius Furius and Marcus Geganius were censors?" Appius insisted, that "the tribune's question was irrelevant to his case. For, although the Aemilian law might bind those censors, during whose magistracy it was passed,--because the people made that law after they had become censors; and whatever order is the last passed by the people, that is held to be the law, and valid:--yet neither he, nor any of those who had been created censors subsequent to the passing of that law, could be bound by it."

Quintus Fabius, the consul for the coming year, took over command of the army at Sutrium, with Caius Marcius Rutilus as his colleague. On one side, Fabius brought reinforcements from Rome, while on the other, a new army had been requested and arrived from home to support the Etrurians. Many years had passed without any conflicts between the patrician magistrates and the plebeian tribunes, when a new struggle emerged from a family that seemed destined to challenge the tribunes and the common people of that time. Appius Claudius, the censor, after the eighteen-month term established by the Aemilian law expired, refused to step down from his position even though his colleague Caius Plautius had already resigned. There was a tribune of the commons, Publius Sempronius, who sought to enforce a legal process to end the censorship within the appropriate timeframe, which was neither particularly popular nor widely appreciated by the people or respectable individuals in the city. After he frequently referenced the Aemilian law and praised Mamercus Aemilius for having shortened the censorship from five years to a year and a half during his dictatorship—an action that addressed the tyranny often associated with prolonged power—he said, "Tell me, Appius Claudius, how would you have acted as censor when Caius Furius and Marcus Geganius were censors?" Appius argued that "the tribune's question is irrelevant to his situation. For, while the Aemilian law may apply to those censors who held office when it was enacted—since the people established that law only after they had taken office, and the most recent order passed by the people is treated as the law and valid—neither he nor any of the censors appointed after the law was passed could be bound by it."

34

While Appius urged such frivolous arguments as these, which carried no conviction whatever, the other said, "Behold, Romans, the offspring of that Appius, who being created decemvir for one year, created himself for a second; and who, during a third, without being created even by himself or by any other, held on the fasces and the government though a private individual; nor ceased to continue in office, until the government itself, ill acquired, ill administered, and ill retained, overwhelmed him in ruin. This is the same family, Romans, by whose violence and injustice ye were compelled to banish yourselves from your native city, and seize on the Sacred mount; the same, against which ye provided for yourselves the protection of tribunes; the same, on account of which two armies of you took post on the Aventine; the same, which violently opposed the laws against usury, and always the agrarian laws; the same, which broke through the right of intermarriage between the patricians and the commons; the same, which shut up the road to curule offices against the commons: this is a name, more hostile to your liberty by far, than that of the Tarquins. I pray you, Appius Claudius, though this is now the hundredth year since the dictatorship of Mamercus Aemilius, though there have been so many men of the highest characters and abilities censors, did none of these ever read the twelve tables? none of them know, that, whatever was the last order of the people, that was law? Nay, certainly they all knew it; and they therefore obeyed the Aemilian law, rather than the old one, under which the censors had been at first created; because it was the last order; and because, when two laws are contradictory, the new always repeals the old. Do you mean to say, Appius, that the people are not bound by the Aemilian law? Or, that the people are bound, and you alone exempted? The Aemilian law bound those violent censors, Caius Furius and Marcus Geganius, who showed what mischief that office might do in the state; when, out of resentment for the limitation of their power, they disfranchised Mamercus Aemilius, the first man of the age, either in war or peace. It bound all the censors thenceforward, during the space of a hundred years. It binds Caius Plautius your colleague, created under the same auspices, with the same privileges. Did not the people create him with the fullest privileges with which any censor ever was created? Or is yours an excepted case, in which this peculiarity and singularity takes place? Shall the person, whom you create king of the sacrifices, laying hold of the style of sovereignty, say, that he was created with the fullest privileges with which any king was ever created at Rome? Who then, do you think, would be content with a dictatorship of six months? who, with the office of interrex for five days? Whom would you, with confidence, create dictator, for the purpose of driving the nail, or of exhibiting games? How foolish, how stupid, do ye think, those must appear in this man's eyes, who, after performing most important services, abdicated the dictatorship within the twentieth day; or who, being irregularly created, resigned their office? Why should I bring instances from antiquity? Lately, within these last ten years, Caius Maenius, dictator, having enforced inquiries, with more strictness than consisted with the safety of some powerful men, a charge was thrown out by his enemies, that he himself was infected with the very crime against which his inquiries were directed;--now Maenius, I say, in order that he might, in a private capacity, meet the imputation, abdicated the dictatorship. I expect not such moderation in you; you will not degenerate from your family, of all others the most imperious and assuming; nor resign your office a day, nor even an hour, before you are forced to it. Be it so: but then let no one exceed the time limited. It is enough to add a day, or a month, to the censorship. But Appius says, I will hold the censorship, and hold it alone, three years and six months longer than is allowed by the Aemilian law. Surely this is like kingly power. Or will you fill up the vacancy with another colleague, a proceeding not allowable, even in the case of the death of a censor? You are not satisfied that, as if a religious censor, you have degraded a most ancient solemnity, and the only one instituted by the very deity to whom it is performed, from priests of that rite who were of the highest rank to the ministry of mere servants. [You are not satisfied that] a family, more ancient than the origin of this city, and sanctified by an intercourse of hospitality with the immortal gods, has, by means of you and your censorship, been utterly extirpated, with all its branches, within the space of a year, unless you involve the whole commonwealth in horrid guilt, which my mind feels a horror even to contemplate. This city was taken in that lustrum in which Lucius Papirius Cursor, on the death of his colleague Julius, the censor, rather than resign his office, substituted Marcus Cornelius Maluginensis. Yet how much more moderate was his ambition, Appius, than yours! Lucius Papirius neither held the censorship alone, nor beyond the time prescribed by law. But still he found no one who would follow his example; all succeeding censors, in case of the death of a colleague, abdicated the office. As for you, neither the expiration of the time of your censorship, nor the resignation of your colleague, nor law, nor shame restrains you. You make fortitude to consist in arrogance, in boldness, in a contempt of gods and men. Appius Claudius, in consideration of the dignity and respect due to that office which you have borne, I should be sorry, not only to offer you personal violence, but even to address you in language too severe. With respect to what I have hitherto said, your pride and obstinacy forced me to speak. And now, unless you pay obedience to the Aemilian law, I shall order you to be led to prison. Nor, since a rule has been established by our ancestors, that in the election of censors unless two shall obtain the legal number of suffrages, neither shall be returned, but the election deferred,--will I suffer you, who could not singly be created censor, to hold the censorship without a colleague." Having spoken to this effect he ordered the censor to be seized, and borne to prison. But although six of the tribunes approved of the proceeding of their colleague, three gave their support to Appius, on his appealing to them, and he held the censorship alone, to the great disgust of all ranks of men.

While Appius pushed these ridiculous arguments that held no weight, the other speaker said, "Look, Romans, at the descendant of Appius, who, after being appointed decemvir for one year, named himself for a second; and who, during a third year, without being appointed either by himself or anyone else, seized the fasces and the government as a private citizen; and did not stop holding office until the poorly acquired, poorly managed, and poorly maintained government brought him down in destruction. This is the same family, Romans, that forced you to exile yourselves from your homeland and take refuge on the Sacred Mount; the same family for which you established tribunes to protect yourselves; the same family that caused two of your armies to occupy the Aventine; the same family that violently resisted laws against usury and always opposed agrarian laws; the same family that broke the right of intermarriage between the patricians and the commons; the same family that blocked the commons from access to curule offices: this name is far more hostile to your freedom than the Tarquins. I ask you, Appius Claudius, even though it has been a hundred years since the dictatorship of Mamercus Aemilius, and despite the many men of the highest character and ability who have served as censors, did none of them ever read the Twelve Tables? Did none of them know that whatever was the last order from the people is what becomes law? Surely they all knew it; and that’s why they adhered to the Aemilian law rather than the older law under which the censors were first created; because it was the last order; and because when two laws are at odds, the new one always supersedes the old. Are you claiming, Appius, that the people are not bound by the Aemilian law? Or that the people are bound, and you are the only exception? The Aemilian law bound those reckless censors, Caius Furius and Marcus Geganius, who demonstrated what havoc that office could wreak in the state; when, out of resentment for the limits placed on their power, they stripped Mamercus Aemilius, the greatest man of the time, of his rights, whether in war or peace. It bound all the censors that followed for a hundred years. It binds your colleague Caius Plautius, who was appointed under the same auspices and with the same privileges. Did not the people appoint him with the fullest privileges any censor has ever been appointed with? Or is your case an exception, one that stands out on its own? Should the person you appoint as king of the sacrifices, grasping at sovereignty, say that he was appointed with the fullest privileges any king has ever held in Rome? Who, then, do you think would settle for a dictatorship of six months? Who would eagerly accept the role of interrex for just five days? Who would you confidently appoint as dictator to nail something down or to oversee games? How foolish and stupid do you think those must seem to this man, who after providing significant services, stepped down from the dictatorship on the twentieth day; or those who, having been ineffectively appointed, resigned their position? Why should I pull instances from the distant past? Recently, in these last ten years, Caius Maenius, a dictator who enforced inquiries with a stricter approach than was safe for some powerful people, faced accusations from his enemies that he was himself guilty of the very crime he was investigating; now Maenius, I say, in order to address that accusation privately, stepped down from the dictatorship. I do not expect such restraint from you; you will not descend from your family lineage, the most domineering and overbearing of all; nor will you resign your office a day, or even an hour, before you have to. So be it: but then let no one exceed the time limit. It’s enough to extend the censorship by a day, or a month. But Appius says, I will hold the censorship, and I will hold it alone, for three years and six months longer than allowed by the Aemilian law. Surely this is like exercising kingly power. Or will you fill the vacancy with another colleague, which is not allowed even in the case of a censor's death? You are not satisfied, having degraded a most ancient solemnity, the only one set up by the deity it is performed for, from high-ranking priests to mere servants. You are not satisfied that a family older than the founding of this city and honored by a connection with the immortal gods has been completely wiped out under your censorship within a year, unless you want to drag the whole state into terrible wrongdoing, a thought that horrifies me to even consider. This city was taken during the lustrum in which Lucius Papirius Cursor, upon the death of his colleague Julius, the censor, rather than resigning, substituted Marcus Cornelius Maluginensis. Yet how much more moderate was his ambition, Appius, than yours! Lucius Papirius did not hold the censorship alone, nor beyond the time set by law. Yet still, he found no one willing to follow his example; all later censors, upon the death of a colleague, stepped down. As for you, neither the end of your censorship, nor the resignation of your colleague, nor the law, nor shame restrains you. You redefine courage as arrogance, boldness, and contempt for both gods and men. Appius Claudius, considering the dignity and respect owed to the office you have held, I would regret not only to personally harm you but even to speak to you too harshly. Regarding what I have said so far, your pride and stubbornness compelled me to speak. And now, unless you comply with the Aemilian law, I will have you taken to prison. Also, since it has been established by our ancestors that in the election of censors, if two do not achieve the required number of votes, neither shall be appointed, and the election will be postponed,--I will not permit you, who could not be appointed censor alone, to hold the censorship without a colleague." After saying this, he ordered that the censor be seized and taken to prison. But even though six of the tribunes supported their colleague's action, three stood by Appius, responding to his appeal, allowing him to hold the censorship alone, much to the frustration of all classes of people.

35

While such was the state of affairs at Rome, the Etrurians had laid siege to Sutrium, and the consul Fabius, as he was marching along the foot of the mountains, with a design to succour the allies, and attempt the enemy's works, if it were by any means practicable, was met by their army prepared for battle. As the wide-extended plain below showed the greatness of their force, the consul, in order to remedy his deficiency in point of number, by advantage of the ground, changed the direction of his route a little towards the hills, where the way was rugged and covered with stones, and then formed his troops, facing the enemy. The Etrurians, thinking of nothing but their numbers, on which alone they depended, commence the fight with such haste and eagerness, that, in order to come the sooner to a close engagement, they threw away their javelins, drew their swords, rushing against the enemy. On the other side, the Romans poured down on them, sometimes javelins, and sometimes stones which the place abundantly supplied; so that whilst the blows on their shields and helmets confused even those whom they did not wound, (it was neither an easy matter to come to close quarters, nor had they missive weapons with which to fight at a distance,) when there was nothing now to protect them whilst standing and exposed to the blows, some even giving way, and the whole line wavering and unsteady the spearmen and the first rank, renewing the shout, rush on them with drawn swords. This attack the Etrurians could not withstand, but, facing about, fled precipitately towards their camp; when the Roman cavalry, getting before them by galloping obliquely across the plain, threw themselves in the way of their flight, on which they quitted the road, and bent their course to the mountains. From thence, in a body, almost without arms, and debilitated with wounds, they made their way into the Ciminian forest. The Romans, having slain in many thousands of the Etrurians, and taken thirty-eight military standards, took also possession of their camp, together with a vast quantity of spoil. They then began to consider of pursuing the enemy.

While this was happening in Rome, the Etruscans had laid siege to Sutrium. Consul Fabius, while marching along the foot of the mountains to help the allies and attempt to breach the enemy's defenses if possible, encountered their army ready for battle. The expansive plain below revealed the size of their forces, so the consul aimed to level the playing field by changing his route slightly toward the hills, where the terrain was rough and rocky, and then positioned his troops to face the enemy. The Etruscans, focused solely on their numbers, which was all they relied on, rushed into battle with such speed and eagerness that they discarded their javelins, drew their swords, and charged at the Romans. In response, the Romans hurled javelins and stones from the abundant supplies around them; the sound of blows on their shields and helmets confused even those who weren't hit. It was challenging to close in on the enemy, and without ranged weapons to fight from a distance, they found themselves unprotected and exposed to the incoming attacks. Some began to falter, and the entire line became shaky and unsteady. The spearmen in the front ranks renewed their battle cry and charged at the Etruscans with drawn swords. The Etruscans couldn’t withstand this assault and quickly turned to flee toward their camp. The Roman cavalry intercepted them by racing diagonally across the plain, blocking their escape, causing them to abandon the road and head toward the mountains. From there, almost unarmed and weakened by injuries, they made their way into the Ciminian forest. The Romans, having killed thousands of Etruscans and captured thirty-eight military standards, took control of their camp, along with a huge amount of spoils. They then began to consider pursuing the enemy.

36

The Ciminian forest was in those days deemed as impassable and frightful as the German forests have been in latter times; not even any trader having ever attempted to pass it. Hardly any, besides the general himself, showed boldness enough to enter it; the others had not the remembrance of the disaster at Caudium effaced from their mind. On this, of those who were present, Marcus Fabius, the consul's brother, (some say Caeso, others Caius Claudius, born of the same mother with the consul,) undertook to go and explore the country, and to bring them in a short time an account of every particular. Being educated at Caere, where he had friends, he was perfectly acquainted with the Etrurian language. I have seen it affirmed, that, in those times, the Roman youth were commonly instructed in the Etrurian learning, as they are now in the Greek: but it is more probable, that there was something very extraordinary in the person who acted so daringly a counterfeit part, and mixed among the enemy. It is said, that his only attendant was a slave, who had been bred up with him, and who was therefore not ignorant of the same language. They received no further instructions at their departure, than a summary description of the country through which they were to pass; to this was added the names of the principal men in the several states, to prevent their being at a loss in conversation, and from being discovered by making some mistake. They set out in the dress of shepherds, armed with rustic weapons, bills, and two short javelins each. But neither their speaking the language of the country, nor the fashion of their dress and arms, concealed them so effectually, as the incredible circumstance of a stranger's passing the Ciminian forest. They are said to have penetrated as far as the Camertian district of the Umbrians: there the Romans ventured to own who they were, and being introduced to the senate, treated with them, in the name of the consul, about an alliance and friendship; and after being entertained with courteous hospitality, were desired to acquaint the Romans, that if they came into those countries, there should be provisions in readiness for the troops sufficient for thirty days, and that they should find the youth of the Camertian Umbrians prepared in arms to obey their commands. When this information was brought to the consul, he sent forward the baggage at the first watch, ordering the legions to march in the rear of it. He himself staid behind with the cavalry, and the next day, as soon as light appeared, rode up to the posts of the enemy, which had been stationed on the outside of the forest; and, when he had detained them there for a sufficient length of time, he retired to his camp, and marching out by the opposite gate, overtook the main body of the army before night. At the first light, on the following day, he had gained the summit of Mount Ciminius, from whence having a view of the opulent plains of Etruria, he let loose his soldiers upon them. When a vast booty had been driven off, some tumultuary cohorts of Etrurian peasants, hastily collected by the principal inhabitants of the district, met the Romans; but in such disorderly array, that these rescuers of the prey were near becoming wholly a prey themselves. These being slain or put to flight, and the country laid waste to a great extent, the Romans returned to their camp victorious, and enriched with plenty of every kind. It happened that, in the mean time, five deputies, with two plebeian tribunes, had come hither, to charge Fabius, in the name of the senate, not to attempt to pass the Ciminian forest. These, rejoicing that they had arrived too late to prevent the expedition, returned to Rome with the news of its success.

The Ciminian Forest was considered impassable and terrifying back then, just like the German forests are seen today; no traders had ever tried to cross it. Hardly anyone, except for the general himself, had the courage to enter; the memory of the disaster at Caudium was still fresh in their minds. Among those present, Marcus Fabius, the consul's brother (some say Caeso, while others claim Caius Claudius, who was born of the same mother as the consul), decided to go and explore the area and report back to them soon. Having been educated in Caere, where he had friends, he was well-versed in the Etruscan language. It's said that, during that time, Roman youths were typically taught Etruscan knowledge, just as they are now taught Greek. However, it's likely that there was something quite extraordinary about the person who dared to play such a risky role and mingle among the enemy. It’s reported that he was accompanied only by a slave who had grown up with him and was familiar with the same language. They received no further instructions at their departure, apart from a brief overview of the territory they would pass through, along with the names of the key figures in the various states to avoid any confusion in conversation and prevent being discovered from making a mistake. They set out dressed as shepherds, armed with rustic weapons, including sickles and two short javelins each. However, neither their fluency in the local language nor their shepherd-like attire and weaponry could disguise them as effectively as the astonishing fact that a stranger was traversing the Ciminian Forest. They are said to have traveled as far as the Camertian district of the Umbrians; there, the Romans revealed their identity, were introduced to the senate, and negotiated an alliance and friendship in the consul's name. After being warmly welcomed, they were informed that if the Romans came to their land, provisions would be prepared for their troops for thirty days, and the youth of the Camertian Umbrians would be ready in arms to obey their orders. When this news reached the consul, he sent the baggage ahead at first light, ordering the legions to follow behind. He himself stayed back with the cavalry and the next day, as soon as daylight broke, approached the enemy posts positioned outside the forest. After keeping them occupied for a sufficient amount of time, he returned to his camp and marched out through the opposite gate, catching up with the main army before night fell. At dawn the next day, he had reached the peak of Mount Ciminius, from where he could see the rich plains of Etruria and sent his soldiers down upon them. After a massive haul of plunder was gathered, some hastily assembled groups of Etruscan peasants, gathered by the local leaders, engaged the Romans, but in such disorganized fashion that these would-be rescuers were nearly overrun themselves. Those who were not killed or routed allowed the Romans to devastate a large part of the countryside before returning to camp victorious, laden with various spoils. During this time, five delegates, along with two plebeian tribunes, arrived to instruct Fabius, on the senate's behalf, not to attempt crossing the Ciminian Forest. They, realizing they were too late to stop the expedition, returned to Rome with news of its success.

37

By this expedition of the consul, the war, instead of being brought nearer to a conclusion, was only spread to a wider extent: for all the tract adjacent to the foot of Mount Ciminius had felt his devastations; and, out of the indignation conceived thereat, had roused to arms, not only the states of Etruria, but the neighbouring parts of Umbria. They came therefore to Sutrium, with such a numerous army as they had never before brought into the field; and not only ventured to encamp on the outside of the wood, but through their earnest desire of coming to an engagement as soon as possible, marched down the plains to offer battle. The troops, being marshalled, stood at first, for some time, on their own ground, having left a space sufficient for the Romans to draw up, opposite to them; but perceiving that the enemy declined fighting, they advanced to the rampart; where, when they observed that even the advanced guards had retired within the works, a shout at once was raised around their generals, that they should order provisions for that day to be brought down to them: "for they were resolved to remain there under arms; and either in the night, or, at all events, at the dawn of day, to attack the enemy's camp." The Roman troops, though not less eager for action, were restrained by the commands of the general. About the tenth hour, the consul ordered his men a repast; and gave directions that they should be ready in arms, at whatever time of the day or night he should give the signal. He then addressed a few words to them; spoke in high terms of the wars of the Samnites, and disparagingly of the Etrurians, who "were not," he said, "as an enemy to be compared with other enemies, nor as a numerous force, with others in point of numbers. Besides, he had an engine at work, as they should find in due time; at present it was of importance to keep it secret." By these hints he intimated that the enemy was circumvented in order to raise the courage of his men, damped by the superiority of the enemy's force; and, from their not having fortified the post where they lay, the insinuation of a stratagem formed against them seemed the more credible. After refreshing themselves, they consigned themselves to rest, and being roused without noise, about the fourth watch, took arms. Axes are distributed among the servants following the army, to tear down the rampart and fill up the trench. The line was formed within the works, and some chosen cohorts posted close to the gates. Then, a little before day, which in summer nights is the time of the profoundest sleep, the signal being given, the rampart was levelled, and the troops rushing forth, fell upon the enemy, who were every where stretched at their length. Some were put to death before they could stir; others half asleep, in their beds; the greatest part, while they ran in confusion to arms; few, in short, had time afforded them to arm themselves; and these, who followed no particular leader, nor orders, were quickly routed by the Romans and pursued by the Roman horse. They fled different ways; to the camp and to the woods. The latter afforded the safer refuge; for the former, being situated in a plain, was taken the same day. The gold and silver was ordered to be brought to the consul; the rest of the spoil was given to the soldiers. On that day, sixty thousand of the enemy were slain or taken. Some affirm, that this famous battle was fought on the farther side of the Ciminian forest, at Perusia; and that the public had been under great dread, lest the army might be enclosed in such a dangerous pass, and overpowered by a general combination of the Etrurians and Umbrians. But on whatever spot it was fought, it is certain that the Roman power prevailed; and, in consequence thereof, ambassadors from Perusia, Cortona, and Arretium, which were then among the principal states of Etruria, soliciting a peace and alliance with the Romans, obtained a truce for thirty years.

By the consul's expedition, the war was instead dragged out further rather than being wrapped up: the area around the foot of Mount Ciminius had suffered his destruction; and from the anger that arose because of it, not only the states of Etruria but also the neighboring regions of Umbria were stirred to arms. They marched to Sutrium with a larger army than they had ever previously assembled; and not only set up camp outside the woods but, eager to engage as soon as possible, advanced into the plains to challenge the Romans to battle. The troops lined up initially on their own turf, leaving enough space for the Romans to form their ranks opposite them; but when they noticed that the enemy was avoiding a fight, they moved to the barricade. Seeing that even the front guards had retreated within the fortifications, a shout went up around their generals, demanding that provisions for the day be brought to them: "They were determined to stay there ready for battle; either under the cover of night or, at the very least, at dawn, they would attack the enemy's camp." The Roman troops, eager for action themselves, were held back by their general's orders. Around the tenth hour, the consul commanded his men to eat and instructed them to be ready for battle at any time of day or night he chose to signal. He then spoke a few words to them, praised the wars against the Samnites, and spoke lowly of the Etrurians, stating they "were not to be compared to other foes and didn't match others in numbers." He also indicated that he had something in play, which they would learn about in time; for now, keeping it a secret was crucial. These hints suggested that the enemy was caught off guard to boost the spirits of his men, who were discouraged by the enemy's strength; and their lack of fortification where they camped made the idea of a trap even more believable. After resting, they were quietly stirred around the fourth watch and took up arms. Axes were distributed to the servants accompanying the army to tear down the barricade and fill in the ditch. The line was formed inside the fortifications, with some chosen cohorts stationed close to the gates. Then, just before daylight, which in summer nights is the time of deepest sleep, the signal was given, the barricade was flattened, and the troops burst out, attacking the enemy, who were sprawled everywhere. Some were killed before they even had a chance to move; others, half asleep in their beds; most, while scrambling to arm themselves; few, if any, had sufficient time to get ready; and those who didn't have specific leaders or orders were quickly defeated by the Romans and chased by the Roman cavalry. They fled in several directions; some to the camp and others to the woods. The latter provided a safer escape; the former, located in a flat area, was taken on the same day. The gold and silver were sent to the consul; the rest of the loot was given to the soldiers. On that day, sixty thousand enemies were either killed or captured. Some claim this famous battle took place on the far side of the Ciminian forest, at Perusia; and the public had been greatly worried that the army might become trapped in such a perilous situation and overwhelmed by a united front of the Etrurians and Umbrians. But regardless of where it was fought, it is certain that Roman power prevailed; as a result, ambassadors from Perusia, Cortona, and Arretium, which were among the main states of Etruria at the time, sought peace and an alliance with the Romans, securing a truce for thirty years.

38

During these transactions in Etruria, the other consul, Caius Marcius Rutilus, took Allifae by storm from the Samnites; and many of their forts, and smaller towns, were either destroyed by his arms, or surrendered without being injured. About the same time also, the Roman fleet, having sailed to Campania, under Publius Cornelius, to whom the senate had given the command on the sea-coast, put into Pompeii. Immediately on landing, the soldiers of the fleet set out to ravage the country about Nuceria: and after they had quickly laid waste the parts which lay nearest, and whence they could have returned to the ships with safety, they were allured by the temptation of plunder, as it often happens, to advance too far, and thereby roused the enemy against them. While they rambled about the country, they met no opposition, though they might have been cut off to a man; but as they were returning, in a careless manner, the peasants overtook them, not far from the ships, stripped them of the booty, and even slew a great part of them. Those who escaped were driven in confusion to the ships. As Fabius' having marched through the Ciminian forest had occasioned violent apprehensions at Rome, so it had excited joy in proportion among the enemy in Samnium: they talked of the Roman army being pent up, and surrounded; and of the Caudine forks, as a model of their defeat. "Those people," they said, "ever greedy after further acquisitions, were now brought into inextricable difficulties, hemmed in, not more effectually by the arms of their enemy, than by the disadvantage of the ground." Their joy was even mingled with a degree of envy, because fortune, as they thought, had transferred the glory of finishing the Roman war, from the Samnites to the Etrurians: they hastened, therefore, with their whole collected force, to crush the consul Caius Marcius; resolving, if he did not give them an opportunity of fighting, to proceed, through the territories of the Marsians and Sabines, into Etruria. The consul met them, and a battle was fought with great fury on both sides, but without a decisive issue. Although both parties suffered severely, yet the discredit of defeat fell on the Romans, because several of equestrian rank, some military tribunes, with one lieutenant-general, had fallen; and, what was more remarkable than all, the consul himself was wounded. On account of this event, exaggerated by report as is usual, the senate became greatly alarmed, so that they resolved on having a dictator nominated. No one entertained a doubt that the nomination would light on Papirius Cursor, who was then universally deemed to possess the greatest abilities as a commander: but they could not be certain, either that a message might be conveyed with safety into Samnium, where all was in a state of hostility, or that the consul Marcius was alive. The other consul, Fabius, was at enmity with Papirius, on his own account; and lest this resentment might prove an obstacle to the public good, the senate voted that deputies of consular rank should be sent to him, who, uniting their own influence to that of government, might prevail on him to drop, for the sake of his country, all remembrance of private animosities. When the deputies, having come to Fabius, delivered to him the decree of the senate, adding such arguments as were suitable to their instructions, the consul, casting his eyes towards the ground, retired in silence, leaving them in uncertainty what part he intended to act. Then, in the silent time of the night, according to the established custom, he nominated Lucius Papirius dictator. When the deputies returned him thanks, for so very meritoriously subduing his passion, he still persevered in obstinate silence, and dismissed them without any answer, or mention of what he had done: a proof that he felt an extraordinary degree of resentment, which had been suppressed within his breast. Papirius appointed Caius Junius Bubulcus master of the horse; and, as he was proceeding in an assembly of the Curiae [3] to get an order passed respecting the command of the army, an unlucky omen obliged him to adjourn it; for the Curia which was to vote first, happened to be the Faucian, remarkably distinguished by two disasters, the taking of the city, and the Caudine peace; the same Curia having voted first in those years in which the said events are found. Licinius Macer supposes this Curia ominous, also, on account of a third misfortune, that which was experienced at the Cremera.

During these events in Etruria, the other consul, Caius Marcius Rutilus, captured Allifae from the Samnites, and many of their forts and smaller towns were either destroyed by his forces or surrendered without damage. Around the same time, the Roman fleet, commanded by Publius Cornelius, who had been given charge of the coastline by the senate, arrived at Pompeii. As soon as they landed, the sailors set out to plunder the area around Nuceria. After quickly ravaging the nearby regions, which would have allowed them to return safely to their ships, they were tempted by the lure of more loot, as often happens, and went too far, stirring the enemy against them. While they wandered through the countryside, they faced no resistance, even though they could have been easily trapped; however, as they returned carelessly, the local peasants caught up with them, took back their stolen goods, and killed many of them. Those who managed to escape fled in disarray to the ships. Just as Fabius' march through the Ciminian forest had caused great fear in Rome, it brought joy to the Samnite enemy: they believed the Roman army was trapped and surrounded, and viewed the Caudine Forks as a model of their defeat. They said, "These people, always greedy for more land, have now fallen into an inescapable situation, surrounded not only by their enemies' forces but also by the unfavorable terrain." Their joy was tinged with envy, as they thought that luck had shifted the honor of finishing the Roman war from the Samnites to the Etrurians: they quickly gathered their entire force to crush consul Caius Marcius, deciding that if he did not give them a chance to fight, they would push through the territories of the Marsians and Sabines into Etruria. The consul confronted them, resulting in a fierce battle on both sides, but without a clear winner. Both sides suffered heavy losses, but the shame of defeat fell on the Romans, as several equestrians, some military tribunes, and one lieutenant-general had been killed; even more notably, the consul himself was wounded. Due to this incident, which was exaggerated in reports as is often the case, the senate became quite alarmed, resolving to appoint a dictator. Everyone expected Papirius Cursor, who was widely regarded as the most capable commander at that time, to be chosen; however, they were uncertain if a message could safely reach Samnium, where hostilities were rampant, or if consul Marcius was still alive. The other consul, Fabius, had personal animosity toward Papirius; and to prevent this resentment from hindering the public good, the senate decided to send consular-level deputies to him, hoping to combine their influence with that of the government to persuade him to set aside personal grievances for the sake of his country. When the deputies approached Fabius and presented the senate's decree, along with arguments appropriate for their mission, the consul looked down, remained silent, and left them uncertain about his intentions. Then, in the stillness of the night, following customary practice, he appointed Lucius Papirius as dictator. When the deputies thanked him for having remarkably controlled his emotions, he continued to remain silent and dismissed them without any response or mention of his actions, indicating an extraordinary level of suppressed resentment. Papirius appointed Caius Junius Bubulcus as master of the horse; and as he was about to address an assembly of the Curiae [3] regarding the command of the army, an unfortunate omen forced him to postpone it, as the first Curia to vote happened to be the Faucian, which was notably marked by two disasters: the capture of the city and the Caudine peace; this same Curia had voted first during the years these events occurred. Licinius Macer also viewed this Curia as ominous due to a third misfortune, the one that happened at the Cremera.

39

Next day the dictator, taking the auspices anew, obtained the order, and, marching out at the head of the legions, lately raised on the alarm occasioned by the army passing the Ciminian forest, came to Longula; where having received the old troops of the consul Marcius, he led on his forces to battle; nor did the enemy seem to decline the combat. However, they stood drawn up for battle and under arms, until night came on; neither side choosing to begin the fray. After this, they continued a considerable time encamped near each other, without coming to action; neither diffident of their own strength, nor despising the adversary. Meanwhile matters went on actively in Etruria; for a decisive battle was fought with the Umbrians, in which the enemy was routed, but lost not many men, for they did not maintain the fight with the vigour with which they began it. Besides this the Etrurians, having raised an army under the sanctions of the devoting law, each man choosing another, came to an engagement at the Cape of Vadimon, with more numerous forces, and, at the same time, with greater spirit than they had ever shown before. The battle was fought with such animosity that no javelins were thrown by either party: swords alone were made use of; and the fury of the combatants was still higher inflamed by the long-continued contest; so that it appeared to the Romans as if they were disputing, not with Etrurians, whom they had so often conquered, but with a new race. Not the semblance of giving ground appeared in any part; the first lines fell; and lest the standards should be exposed, without defence, the second lines were formed in their place. At length, even the men forming the last reserves were called into action; and to such an extremity of difficulty and danger had they come, that the Roman cavalry dismounted, and pressed forward, through heaps of arms and bodies, to the front ranks of the infantry. These starting up a new army, as it were, among men now exhausted, disordered the battalions of the Etrurians; and the rest, weak as their condition was, seconding their assault, broke at last through the enemy's ranks. Their obstinacy then began to give way: some companies quitted their posts, and, as soon as they once turned their backs, betook themselves to more decided flight. That day first broke the strength of the Etrurians, now grown exuberant through a long course of prosperity; all the flower of their men were cut off in the field, and in the same assault their camp was seized and sacked.

The next day, the dictator, consulting the omens again, received the order and, leading the legions, recently raised due to the alarm from the army passing through the Ciminian forest, arrived at Longula. There, after receiving the veteran troops of Consul Marcius, he advanced his forces to battle; the enemy showed no signs of shying away from the fight. However, both sides remained armed and ready for battle until night fell, with neither choosing to initiate combat. They stayed encamped close to each other for a significant time without engaging, neither doubting their own strength nor underestimating the opponent. Meanwhile, active developments were occurring in Etruria; a decisive battle was fought with the Umbrians, where the enemy was defeated but didn’t suffer heavy losses, as they couldn't maintain the initial vigor of their attack. Additionally, the Etruscans raised an army under the devoting law, where each person selected another, and engaged in combat at the Cape of Vadimon with larger forces and greater spirit than they had ever displayed before. The battle was fought with such intensity that neither side threw javelins; they relied solely on swords, and the ongoing struggle further ignited the fighters’ fury, making it seem to the Romans as if they were battling not Etruscans, whom they had often conquered, but a new tribe altogether. There was no sign of retreat anywhere; the front lines fell, and to protect the standards from being left defenseless, the second lines took their place. Eventually, even the reserve troops were called to action; they had reached such a point of difficulty and danger that the Roman cavalry dismounted and pushed forward through piles of weapons and bodies to the front ranks of the infantry. This sudden surge created what seemed like a new army among the exhausted fighters, disrupting the Etruscan battalions; despite their weakened condition, they followed the assault and finally broke through the enemy’s lines. The Etruscans’ stubbornness began to fade: some units abandoned their positions, and once they turned to flee, a full retreat ensued. That day marked the beginning of the downfall of the Etruscans, once bolstered by a prolonged period of prosperity; many of their best men were killed on the battlefield, and their camp was captured and looted in the same assault.

40

Equal danger, and an issue equally glorious, soon after attended the war with the Samnites; who, besides their many preparations for the field, made their army to glitter with new decorations of their armour. Their troops were in two divisions, one of which had their shields embossed with gold, the other with silver. The shape of the shield was this; broad at the middle to cover the breast and shoulders, the summit being flat, sloping off gradually so as to become pointed below, that it might be wielded with ease; a loose coat of mail also served as a protection for the breast, and the left leg was covered with a greave; their helmets were adorned with plumes, to add to the appearance of their stature. The golden-armed soldiers wore tunics of various colours; the silver-armed, of white linen. To the latter the right wing was assigned; the former took post on the left. The Romans had been apprized of these splendid accoutrements, and had been taught by their commanders, that "a soldier ought to be rough; not decorated with gold and silver, but placing his confidence in his sword. That matters of this kind were in reality spoil rather than armour; glittering before action, but soon becoming disfigured amid blood and wounds. That the brightest ornament of a soldier was valour; that all those trinkets would follow victory, and that those rich enemies would be valuable prizes to the conquerors, however poor." Cursor, having animated his men with these observations, led them on to battle. He took post himself on the right wing, he gave the command of the left to the master of the horse. As soon as they engaged, the struggle between the two armies became desperate, while it was no less so between the dictator and the master of the horse, on which wing victory should first show itself. It happened that Junius first, with the left wing, made the right of the enemy give way; this consisted of men devoted after the custom of Samnites, and on that account distinguished by white garments and armour of equal whiteness. Junius, saying "he would sacrifice these to Pluto," pressed forward, disordered their ranks, and made an evident impression on their line: which being perceived by the dictator, he exclaimed, "Shall the victory begin on the left wing, and shall the right, the dictator's own troops, only second the arms of others, and not claim the greatest share of the victory?" This spurred on the soldiers: nor did the cavalry yield to the infantry in bravery, nor the ardour of lieutenants-general to that of the commanders. Marcius Valerius from the right wing, and Publius Decius from the left, both men of consular rank, rode off to the cavalry, posted on the extremities of the line, and, exhorting them to join in putting in for a share of the honour, charged the enemy on the flanks. When the addition of this new alarm assailed the enemies' troops on both sides, and the Roman legions, having renewed the shout to confound the enemy, rushed on, they began to fly. And now the plains were quickly filled with heaps of bodies and splendid armour. At first, their camp received the dismayed Samnites; but they did not long retain even the possession of that: before night it was taken, plundered, and burnt. The dictator triumphed, in pursuance of a decree of the senate; and the most splendid spectacle by far, of any in his procession, was the captured arms: so magnificent were they deemed, that the shields, adorned with gold, were distributed among the owners of the silver shops, to serve as embellishments to the forum. Hence, it is said, arose the custom of the forum being decorated by the aediles, when the grand processions are made on occasion of the great games. The Romans, indeed, converted these extraordinary arms to the honour of the gods: but the Campanians, out of pride, and in hatred of the Samnites, gave them as ornaments to their gladiators, who used to be exhibited as a show at their feasts, and whom they distinguished by the name of Samnites. During this year, the consul Fabius fought with the remnants of the Etrurians at Perusia, which city also had violated the truce, and gained an easy and decisive victory. He would have taken the town itself (for he marched up to the walls,) had not deputies come out and capitulated. Having placed a garrison at Perusia, and sent on before him to the Roman senate the embassies of Etruria, who solicited friendship, the consul rode into the city in triumph, for successes more important than those of the dictator. Besides, a great share of the honour of reducing the Samnites was attributed to the lieutenants-general, Publius Decius and Marcius Valerius: whom, at the next election, the people, with universal consent, declared the one consul, the other praetor.

Equal danger, and an equally glorious issue, soon followed the war with the Samnites, who, in addition to their many preparations for the battlefield, decorated their army with shiny new armor. Their troops were organized into two divisions, one with shields embossed in gold, the other in silver. The shape of the shield was broad in the center to cover the chest and shoulders, flat at the top, sloping down to a point at the bottom for ease of handling; a loose coat of mail also protected the chest, and the left leg was covered with a greave. Their helmets were adorned with plumes to enhance their stature. The soldiers with golden armor wore tunics of various colors, while those with silver armor wore white linen. The silver-armed troops were assigned to the right wing, and the gold-armed troops took their position on the left. The Romans had been informed about these impressive decorations and had learned from their commanders that "a soldier should be rough; not adorned with gold and silver, but placing his confidence in his sword. Such decorations are actually spoils rather than armor; they look good before battle but quickly become disfigured by blood and wounds. The true ornament of a soldier is valor; those trinkets will follow victory, and those wealthy enemies will be valuable prizes to the conquerors, no matter how impoverished." Cursor, having motivated his men with these remarks, led them into battle. He took his place on the right wing and gave command of the left to the master of the horse. Once they engaged, the fight between the two armies became fierce, as did the struggle between the dictator and the master of the horse, over which wing would achieve victory first. It turned out that Junius, with the left wing, was the first to push the enemy's right back; these troops were devoted, following Samnite tradition, and thus identified by their white garments and equally white armor. Junius, declaring "he would sacrifice these to Pluto," pressed forward, disarrayed their ranks, and made a clear impact on their line. When the dictator noticed this, he exclaimed, "Shall victory begin on the left wing, while my own troops on the right merely support others' efforts and do not claim the greatest share of the victory?" This drove the soldiers onward; neither did the cavalry fall behind the infantry in courage, nor did the enthusiasm of the lieutenants-general lag behind that of the commanders. Marcius Valerius from the right wing and Publius Decius from the left, both men of consular rank, rode to the cavalry stationed at the ends of the line and encouraged them to join in earning their share of glory, attacking the enemy's flanks. When this new threat overwhelmed the enemy forces on both sides, and the Roman legions renewed their battle cry to disorient the enemy, they began to flee. Now, the plains were quickly filled with piles of bodies and shining armor. Initially, the frightened Samnites retreated to their camp, but they couldn't hold on to it for long: by nightfall, it was captured, looted, and burned. The dictator celebrated a triumph, following a decree from the senate, and the most impressive part of his procession was the captured weapons: so majestic were they considered that the gold-adorned shields were given to the owners of silver shops to beautify the forum. Thus, it is said, the custom of decorating the forum arose, thanks to the aediles during grand processions held for major games. The Romans indeed dedicated these extraordinary weapons to the honor of the gods: but the Campanians, out of pride and a grudge against the Samnites, gave them as decorations to their gladiators, who were displayed as entertainment at their banquets, and whom they called Samnites. During this year, Consul Fabius fought the remnants of the Etrurians at Perusia, which had also violated the truce, and achieved an easy and decisive victory. He would have taken the city itself (he approached the walls), but envoys came out and negotiated a settlement. After placing a garrison at Perusia and sending ahead to the Roman senate the envoys from Etruria who sought friendship, the consul rode into the city in triumph, for achievements that were more significant than those of the dictator. Additionally, a large share of the credit for subduing the Samnites was given to the lieutenants-general, Publius Decius and Marcius Valerius, who were, at the next election, universally declared by the people as one consul and the other praetor.

41

To Fabius, in consideration of his extraordinary merit in the conquest of Etruria, the consulship was continued. Decius was appointed his colleague. Valerius was created praetor a fourth time. The consuls divided the provinces between them. Etruria fell to Decius, Samnium to Fabius. The latter, having marched to Nuceria, rejected the application of the people of Alfaterna, who then sued for peace, because they had not accepted it when offered, and by force of arms compelled them to surrender. A battle was fought with the Samnites; the enemy were overcome without much difficulty: nor would the memory of that engagement have been preserved, except that in it the Marsians first appeared in arms against the Romans. The Pelignians, imitating the defection of the Marsians, met the same fate. The other consul, Decius, was likewise very successful in his operations: through terror he compelled the Tarquinians to supply his army with corn, and to sue for a truce for forty years. He took several forts from the Volsinians by assault, some of which he demolished, that they might not serve as receptacles to the enemy, and by extending his operations through every quarter, diffused such a dread of his arms, that the whole Etrurian nation sued to the consul for an alliance: this they did not obtain; but a truce for a year was granted them. The pay of the Roman army for that year was furnished by the enemy; and two tunics for each soldier were exacted from them: this was the purchase of the truce. The tranquillity now established in Etruria was interrupted by a sudden insurrection of the Umbrians, a nation which had suffered no injury from the war, except what inconvenience the country had felt in the passing of the army. These, by calling into the field all their own young men, and forcing a great part of the Etrurians to resume their arms, made up such a numerous force, that speaking of themselves with ostentatious vanity and of the Romans with contempt, they boasted that they would leave Decius behind in Etruria, and march away to besiege Rome; which design of theirs being reported to the consul Decius, he removed by long marches from Etruria towards their city, and sat down in the district of Pupinia, in readiness to act according to the intelligence received of the enemy. Nor was the insurrection of the Umbrians slighted at Rome: their very threats excited tears among the people, who had experienced, in the calamities suffered from the Gauls, how insecure a city they inhabited. Deputies were therefore despatched to the consul Fabius with directions, that, if he had any respite from the war of the Samnites, he should with all haste lead his army into Umbria. The consul obeyed the order, and by forced marches proceeded to Mevania, where the forces of the Umbrians then lay. The unexpected arrival of the consul, whom they had believed to be sufficiently employed in Samnium, far distant from their country, so thoroughly affrighted the Umbrians, that several advised retiring to their fortified towns; others, the discontinuing the war. However, one district, called by themselves Materina, prevailed on the rest not only to retain their arms, but to come to an immediate engagement. They fell upon Fabius while he was fortifying his camp. When the consul saw them rushing impetuously towards his rampart, he called off his men from the work, and drew them up in the best manner which the nature of the place and the time allowed; encouraging them by displaying, in honourable and just terms, the glory which they had acquired, as well in Etruria as in Samnium, he bade them finish this insignificant appendage to the Etrurian war, and take vengeance for the impious expressions in which these people had threatened to attack the city of Rome. Such was the alacrity of the soldiers on hearing this, that, raising the shout spontaneously, they interrupted the general's discourse, and, without waiting for orders, advanced, with the sound of all the trumpets and cornets, in full speed against the enemy. They made their attack not as on men, or at least men in arms, but, what must appear wonderful in the relation, began by snatching the standards out of the hands which held them; and then, the standard-bearers themselves were dragged to the consul, and the armed soldiers transferred from the one line to the other; and wherever resistance was any where made, the business was performed, not so much with swords, as with their shields, with the bosses of which, and thrusts of their elbows, they bore down the foe. The prisoners were more numerous than the slain, and through the whole line the Umbrians called on each other, with one voice, to lay down their arms. Thus a surrender was made in the midst of action, by the first promoters of the war; and on the next and following days, the other states of the Umbrians also surrendered. The Ocriculans were admitted to a treaty of friendship on giving security.

To Fabius, recognizing his outstanding achievement in conquering Etruria, the consulship was extended. Decius was appointed as his colleague. Valerius was made praetor for the fourth time. The consuls divided the provinces between them. Etruria went to Decius, and Samnium to Fabius. The latter, after marching to Nuceria, turned down the request from the people of Alfaterna, who then sought peace, because they had previously rejected it when it was offered, and forced them into surrender. A battle was fought with the Samnites; the enemy was defeated fairly easily: and the memory of that engagement might have faded, except that it was the first time the Marsians fought against the Romans. The Pelignians, following the Marsians' lead, met a similar fate. The other consul, Decius, also had great success in his efforts: through intimidation, he forced the Tarquinians to provide his army with grain and to ask for a truce for forty years. He took several forts from the Volsinians in assault, some of which he destroyed so they couldn't be used by the enemy, and by extending his operations throughout the area, he instilled such fear of his forces that the entire Etrurian nation sought an alliance with the consul: this was denied; however, a truce for a year was granted. The payment for the Roman army that year was provided by the enemy, who were required to supply two tunics for each soldier: this was the cost of the truce. The peace established in Etruria was suddenly disrupted by an insurrection from the Umbrians, a people who hadn't been harmed by the war, except for the inconveniences the army's passage caused. By mobilizing all their young men and forcing many of the Etrurians to take up arms again, they assembled such a large force that with arrogant pride they claimed they would leave Decius behind in Etruria and march to besiege Rome. When this plan was reported to the consul Decius, he marched long distances from Etruria toward their territory and set up camp in the district of Pupinia, ready to act according to the intel about the enemy. The insurrection of the Umbrians was taken seriously in Rome: their threats brought tears to the people, who had felt the insecurity of their city during the devastation from the Gauls. Therefore, deputies were sent to consul Fabius with orders that, if he had any break from the Samnite war, he should quickly lead his army into Umbria. The consul complied and rushed to Mevania, where the Umbrian forces were stationed. The surprise arrival of the consul, whom they believed was too busy in Samnium and far from their territory, terrified the Umbrians, causing several to suggest retreating to their fortified towns; others urged to end the war. However, one area they called Materina persuaded the rest not only to keep their arms but to engage immediately. They attacked Fabius while he was fortifying his camp. When the consul saw them rushing toward his rampart, he called his men away from their work and organized them as best as the location and circumstances allowed; encouraging them by highlighting, in respectable and fair terms, the glory they had gained in both Etruria and Samnium, he urged them to finish this minor extension of the Etrurian war and get revenge for the cruel threats the Umbrians had made against the city of Rome. The soldiers responded with such enthusiasm upon hearing this that they spontaneously shouted, interrupting the general's speech, and without waiting for orders, charged at the enemy with the sound of trumpets and horns, moving swiftly. They attacked not as they would against men, or at least men in arms, but in a truly astonishing manner, by grabbing the standards from the hands that held them; the standard-bearers were then pulled to the consul, and the armed soldiers were swapped from one line to the other; wherever there was resistance, it was dealt with not so much with swords, but with their shields, using the shields' bosses and elbow thrusts to overpower the foe. The prisoners outnumbered the slain, and throughout the line, the Umbrians called on each other, in unison, to lay down their arms. Thus, a surrender was made amidst the battle by the primary instigators of the war; in the next days, the other Umbrian states also surrendered. The Ocriculans were allowed to enter into a friendship treaty upon providing security.

42

Fabius, successful in a war allotted to another, led back his army into his own province. And as, in the preceding year, the people had, in consideration of his services so successfully performed, re-elected him to the consulship, so now the senate, from the same motive, notwithstanding a warm opposition made by Appius, prolonged his command for the year following, in which Appius Claudius and Lucius Volumnius were consuls. In some annals I find, that Appius, still holding the office of censor, declared himself a candidate for the consulship, and that his election was stopped by a protest of Lucius Furius, plebeian tribune, until he resigned the censorship. After his election to the consulship, the new war with the Sallentine enemies being decreed to his colleague, he remained at Rome, with design to increase his interest by city intrigues, since the means of procuring honour in war were placed in the hands of others. Volumnius had no reason to be dissatisfied with his province: he fought many battles with good success, and took several cities by assault. He was liberal in his donations of the spoil; and this munificence, engaging in itself, he enhanced by his courteous demeanour, by which conduct he inspired his soldiers with ardour to meet both toil and danger. Quintus Fabius, proconsul, fought a pitched battle with the armies of the Samnites, near the city of Allifae. The victory was complete. The enemy were driven from the field, and pursued to their camp; nor would they have kept possession of that, had not the day been almost spent. It was invested, however, before night, and guarded until day, lest any should slip away. Next morning, while it was scarcely clear day, they proposed to capitulate, and it was agreed, that such as were natives of Samnium should be dismissed with single garments. All these were sent under the yoke. No precaution was taken in favour of the allies of the Samnites: they were sold by auction, to the number of seven thousand. Those who declared themselves subjects of the Hernicians, were kept by themselves under a guard. All these Fabius sent to Rome to the senate; and, after being examined, whether it was in consequence of a public order, or as volunteers, that they had carried arms on the side of the Samnites against the Romans, they were distributed among the states of the Latins to be held in custody; and it was ordered, that the new consuls, Publius Cornelius Arvina and Quintus Marcius Tremulus, who by this time had been elected, should lay that affair entire before the senate: this gave such offence to the Hernicians, that, at a meeting of all the states, assembled by the Anagnians, in the circus called the Maritime, the whole nation of the Hernicians, excepting the Alatrians, Ferentines, and Verulans, declared war against the Roman people.

Fabius, who had been successful in a war assigned to someone else, returned his army to his own province. Just as the previous year the people re-elected him to the consulship in recognition of his well-executed services, the senate, motivated by the same reasoning, extended his command for the next year despite strong opposition from Appius, during which Appius Claudius and Lucius Volumnius served as consuls. According to some records, Appius, still serving as censor, announced his candidacy for the consulship and was blocked from being elected by a protest from Lucius Furius, a plebeian tribune, until he stepped down from the censors. After being elected consul, while his colleague was assigned the new war against the Sallentine enemies, he stayed in Rome, aiming to build his influence through city politics, since opportunities for military glory were given to others. Volumnius had no complaints about his province: he won several battles and captured many cities through assaults. He generously shared the spoils of war, and his giving nature, combined with his friendly demeanor, motivated his soldiers to face hardships and danger eagerly. Quintus Fabius, the proconsul, fought a major battle with the Samnite armies near the city of Allifae. The victory was decisive. The enemy was driven from the battlefield and pursued back to their camp; they likely would have lost that too if the day hadn’t nearly ended. However, it was surrounded before nightfall and secured until morning to prevent any escape. The next morning, barely at dawn, they proposed to surrender, and it was agreed that those who were natives of Samnium would be released wearing only simple clothing. All of them were sent under the yoke. No measures were taken for the Samnites’ allies: they were sold at auction, numbering seven thousand. Those who claimed to be subjects of the Hernicians were kept separately under guard. Fabius sent all of these people to Rome for the senate's consideration; once examined to determine if they had fought on the side of the Samnites against the Romans due to a public order or voluntarily, they were assigned to the Latin states for custody. It was decided that the newly elected consuls, Publius Cornelius Arvina and Quintus Marcius Tremulus, should present the entire matter to the senate. This decision greatly outraged the Hernicians, leading the entire Hernician nation, except for the Alatrians, Ferentines, and Verulans, to declare war against the Roman people during a meeting of all the states convened by the Anagnians in the circus known as the Maritime.

43

In Samnium also, in consequence of the departure of Fabius, new commotions arose. Calatia and Sora, and the Roman garrisons stationed there, were taken, and extreme cruelty was exercised towards the captive soldiers: Publius Cornelius was therefore sent thither with an army. The command against the new enemy (for by this time an order had passed for declaring war against the Anagnians, and the rest of the Hernicians) was decreed to Marcius. These, in the beginning, secured all the passes between the camps of the consuls, in such a manner, that no messenger, however expert, could make his way from one to the other; and each consul spent several days in absolute uncertainty regarding every matter and in anxious suspense concerning the state of the other. Apprehensions for their safety spread even to Rome; so that all the younger citizens were compelled to enlist and two regular armies were raised, to answer sudden emergencies. The conduct of the Hernicians during the progress of the war afterwards, showed nothing suitable to the present alarm, or to the ancient renown of that nation. Without ever venturing any effort worth mentioning, being stripped of three different camps within a few days, they stipulated for a truce of thirty days, during which they might send to Rome, to the senate, on the terms of furnishing two months' pay, and corn, and a tunic to every soldier. They were referred back to Marcius by the senate, whom by a decree they empowered to determine regarding the Hernicians, and he accepted their submission. Meanwhile, in Samnium, the other consul, though superior in strength, was very much embarrassed by the nature of his situation; the enemy had blocked up all the roads, and seized on the passable defiles, so that no provisions could be conveyed; nor could the consul, though he daily drew out his troops and offered battle, allure them to an engagement. It was evident, that neither could the Samnites support an immediate contest, nor the Romans a delay of action. The approach of Marcius, who, after he had subdued the Hernicians, hastened to the succour of his colleague, put it out of the enemy's power any longer to avoid fighting: for they, who had not deemed themselves a match in the field, even for one of the armies, could not surely suppose that if they should allow the two consular armies to unite, they could have any hope remaining: they made an attack therefore on Marcius, as he was approaching in the irregular order of march. The baggage was hastily thrown together in the centre, and the line formed as well as the time permitted. First the shout which reached the standing camp of Cornelius, then the dust observed at a distance, excited a bustle in the camp of the other consul. Ordering his men instantly to take arms, and leading them out to the field with the utmost haste, he charged the flank of the enemy's line, which had enough to do in the other dispute, at the same time exclaiming, that "it would be the height of infamy if they suffered Marcius's army to monopolize the honour of both victories, and did not assert their claim to the glory of their own war." He bore down all before him, and pushed forward, through the midst of the enemy's line, to their camp, which, being left without a guard, he took and set on fire; which when the soldiers of Marcius saw in flames, and the enemy observed it on looking about, a general flight immediately took place among the Samnites. But they could not effect an escape in any direction; in every quarter they met death. After a slaughter of thirty thousand men, the consuls had now given the signal for retreat; and were collecting, into one body, their several forces, who were employed in mutual congratulations, when some new cohorts of the enemy, which had been levied for a reinforcement, being seen at a distance, occasioned a renewal of the carnage. On these the conquerors rushed, without any order of the consuls, or signal received, crying out, that they would make these Samnites pay dearly for their introduction to service. The consuls indulged the ardour of the legions, well knowing that the raw troops of the enemy, mixed with veterans dispirited by defeat, would be incapable even of attempting a contest. Nor were they wrong in their judgment: all the forces of the Samnites, old and new, fled to the nearest mountains. These the Roman army also ascended, so that no situation afforded safety to the vanquished; they were beaten off, even from the summits which they had seized. And now they all, with on voice, supplicated for a suspension of arms. On which, being ordered to furnish corn for three months, pay for a year, and a tunic to each of the soldiers, they sent deputies to the senate to sue for peace. Cornelius was left in Samnium. Marcius returned into the city, in triumph over the Hernicians; and a decree was passed for erecting to him, in the forum, an equestrian statue, which was placed before the temple of Castor. To three states of the Hernicians, (the Alatrians, Verulans, and Ferentines,) their own laws were restored, because they preferred these to the being made citizens of Rome; and they were permitted to intermarry with each other, a privilege which they alone of the Hernicians, for a long time after, enjoyed. To the Anagnians, and the others, who had made war on the Romans, was granted the freedom of the state, without the right of voting; public assemblies, and intermarriages, were not allowed them, and their magistrates were prohibited from acting except in the ministration of public worship. During this year, Caius Junius Bubulcus, censor, contracted for the building of a temple to Health, which he had vowed during his consulate in the war with the Samnites. By the same person, and his colleague, Marcus Valerius Maximus, roads were made through the fields at the public expense. During the same year the treaty with the Carthaginians was renewed a third time, and ample presents made to their ambassadors who came on that business.

In Samnium, following Fabius's departure, fresh disturbances broke out. Calatia and Sora, along with the Roman troops stationed there, were captured, and the captured soldiers faced extreme cruelty. Publius Cornelius was sent there with an army. The command to handle the new enemy (since a declaration of war had been made against the Anagnians and the rest of the Hernicians) was assigned to Marcius. At first, they secured all the passes between the consuls’ camps so that no messenger, no matter how skilled, could get through; each consul spent days in complete uncertainty and worry about the other's situation. Fears for their safety spread even to Rome, forcing many young citizens to enlist and raising two regular armies for sudden emergencies. The Hernicians' conduct during the course of the war did not reflect the current alarm or the historical reputation of the nation. Without any significant efforts, they lost three different camps in a matter of days and requested a truce of thirty days. They wanted to send terms to Rome, seeking two months' pay, grain, and a tunic for each soldier. The senate referred them back to Marcius, whom they empowered to decide the Hernicians' fate, and he accepted their surrender. Meanwhile, in Samnium, the other consul, despite having an advantage in strength, faced significant challenges due to his situation; the enemy had blocked all the roads and taken control of the passable routes, preventing any supplies from getting through. Although the consul frequently drew out his troops and offered battle, he could not entice the enemy into a fight. It was clear that neither the Samnites could handle an immediate battle, nor the Romans could afford any delays. The arrival of Marcius, who had just defeated the Hernicians and rushed to help his fellow consul, took away the enemy's option to avoid combat; they realized that if they allowed the two Roman armies to unite, they would have no hope left. Consequently, they attacked Marcius while he was approaching in disarray. The baggage was quickly gathered in the center, and a line was formed as best as possible given the time. Initially, the shout that reached Cornelius’s camp, followed by a dust cloud in the distance, caused a stir in the other consul’s camp. He ordered his men to arm up immediately and rushed them to the battlefield, striking the enemy's flank, which was already occupied in another conflict, shouting that it would be shameful to allow Marcius's army to claim both victories without them claiming glory in their own war. He charged forward, pushing through the enemy lines to their camp, which was left unguarded; he took it and set it on fire. When Marcius's soldiers saw their camp ablaze and the enemy noticed it, panic spread among the Samnites. They tried to escape but found death at every turn. After thirty thousand of them had been killed, the consuls signaled for retreat and began consolidating their forces, who were engaged in mutual congratulations, when new cohorts of the enemy, raised as reinforcements, appeared in the distance, sparking a renewed slaughter. The victors charged at these Samnites without waiting for orders or signals, shouting that they would make these enemies pay severely for joining the fight. The consuls encouraged the enthusiasm of the legions, knowing well that the inexperienced enemy troops, mixed with veterans disheartened by their defeat, wouldn’t be able to put up any resistance. They were correct: all the Samnite forces, both old and new, fled to the nearest mountains. The Roman army also climbed up, leaving no safe place for the defeated; they were driven off even from the heights they had occupied. At this point, they all, in unison, begged for a ceasefire. They were ordered to supply grain for three months, pay for a year, and a tunic to each soldier, and they sent delegates to the senate to seek peace. Cornelius remained in Samnium while Marcius returned to the city, celebrating his victory over the Hernicians. A decree was passed to erect an equestrian statue in his honor in the forum, placed in front of the temple of Castor. The three Hernician states (the Alatrians, Verulans, and Ferentines) had their own laws restored because they preferred this over becoming Roman citizens, and they were allowed to intermarry, a privilege enjoyed solely by them among the Hernicians for a long time. The Anagnians and others who waged war against the Romans were granted state freedom without voting rights; they were not allowed public assemblies or intermarriages, and their magistrates could only serve in public worship. During this year, Caius Junius Bubulcus, the censor, began constructing a temple to Health, which he had vowed to build during his consulship in the war with the Samnites. His colleague, Marcus Valerius Maximus, and he also constructed roads through the fields at public expense. In the same year, the treaty with the Carthaginians was renewed for the third time, and generous gifts were given to their ambassadors who came for that purpose.

44

This year had a dictator in office, Publius Cornelius Scipio, with Publius Decius Mus, master of the horse. By these the election of consuls was held, being the purpose for which they had been created, because neither of the consuls could be absent from the armies. The consuls elected were Lucius Postumius and Titus Minucius; whom Piso places next after Quintus Fabius and Publius Decius, omitting the two years in which I have set down Claudius with Volumnius, and Cornelius with Marcius, as consuls. Whether this happened through a lapse of memory in digesting his annals, or whether he purposely passed over those two consulates as deeming the accounts of them false, cannot be ascertained. During this year the Samnites made incursions into the district of Stellae in the Campanian territory. Both the consuls were therefore sent into Samnium, and proceeded to different regions, Postumius to Tifernum, Minucius to Bovianum. The first engagement happened at Tifernum, under the command of Postumius. Some say, that the Samnites were completely defeated, and twenty thousand of them made prisoners. Others, that the army separated without victory on either side; and that Postumius, counterfeiting fear, withdrew his forces privately by night, and marched away to the mountains; whither the enemy also followed, and took possession of a stronghold two miles distant. The consul, having created a belief that he had come thither for the sake of a safe post, and a fruitful spot, (and such it really was,) secured his camp with strong works. Furnishing it with magazines of every thing useful, he left a strong guard to defend it; and at the third watch, led away the legions lightly accoutred, by the shortest road which he could take, to join his colleague, who lay opposite to his foe. There, by advice of Postumius, Minucius came to an engagement with the enemy; and when the fight had continued doubtful through a great part of the day, Postumius, with his fresh legions, made an unexpected attack on the enemy's line, spent by this time with fatigue: thus, weariness and wounds having rendered them incapable even of flying, they were cut off to a man, and twenty-one standards taken. The Romans then proceeded to Postumius's station, where the two victorious armies falling upon the enemy, already dismayed by the news of what had passed, routed and dispersed them: twenty-six military standards were taken here, and the Samnite general, Statius Gellius, with a great number of other prisoners, and both the camps were taken. Next day Bovianum was besieged, and soon after taken. Both the consuls were honoured with a triumph, with high applause of their excellent conduct. Some writers say, that the consul Minucius was brought back to the camp grievously wounded, and that he died there; that Marcus Fulvius was substituted consul in his place, and that it was he who, being sent to command Minucius's army, took Bovianum. During the same year, Sora, Arpinum, and Censennia were recovered from the Samnites. The great statue of Hercules was erected in the Capitol, and dedicated.

This year had a dictator in office, Publius Cornelius Scipio, with Publius Decius Mus, the master of the horse. They were responsible for holding the election of consuls, which was their main purpose since neither of the consuls could be absent from the armies. The consuls elected were Lucius Postumius and Titus Minucius; Piso places them next after Quintus Fabius and Publius Decius, skipping the two years during which I noted Claudius with Volumnius, and Cornelius with Marcius, as consuls. Whether this was due to a lapse of memory in compiling his records or whether he intentionally left out those two consulates because he considered their accounts false, we cannot be sure. During this year, the Samnites invaded the district of Stellae in the Campanian territory. As a result, both consuls were sent to Samnium and went to different regions, with Postumius heading to Tifernum and Minucius to Bovianum. The first battle occurred at Tifernum, led by Postumius. Some report that the Samnites were completely defeated, resulting in twenty thousand prisoners. Others say that the two armies parted without a clear victory; and that Postumius, pretending to be afraid, secretly withdrew his troops at night and marched them to the mountains, where the enemy also followed and took over a stronghold two miles away. The consul, having created the impression that he had gone there seeking a secure position and productive land (which it actually was), fortified his camp with strong defenses. He stocked it with everything useful and left a strong guard to protect it; then, at the third watch, he led his lightly equipped legions along the shortest route to join his colleague, who faced his enemy. There, with Postumius's advice, Minucius engaged the enemy; and after the battle remained uncertain for a large part of the day, Postumius, with his fresh legions, launched an unexpected attack on the enemy's line, which by this time was worn out from fatigue: thus, exhaustion and injuries made them unable to even flee, and they were completely cut down, with twenty-one standards captured. The Romans then advanced to Postumius's location, where both victorious armies, taking advantage of the enemy's fear from the recent events, routed and scattered them: twenty-six military standards were taken, and the Samnite general, Statius Gellius, along with a significant number of other prisoners, was captured, along with both camps. The following day, Bovianum was besieged and soon taken. Both consuls were honored with a triumph, receiving high praise for their excellent leadership. Some writers claim that consul Minucius returned to camp seriously wounded and died there; that Marcus Fulvius was appointed consul in his place, and that he was the one who, after being sent to command Minucius's army, took Bovianum. During the same year, Sora, Arpinum, and Censennia were reclaimed from the Samnites. A large statue of Hercules was erected and dedicated in the Capitol.

45

In the succeeding consulate of Publius Sulpicius Saverrio and Publius Sempronius Sophus, the Samnites, desirous either of a termination or a suspension of hostilities, sent ambassadors to Rome to treat of peace; to whose submissive solicitations this answer was returned, that, "had not the Samnites frequently solicited peace, at times when they were actually preparing for war, their present application might, perhaps, in the course of negotiating, have produced the desired effect. But now, since words had hitherto proved vain, people's conduct must be guided by facts: that Publius Sempronius the consul would shortly be in Samnium with an army: that he could not be deceived in judging whether their dispositions inclined to peace or war. He would bring the senate certain information respecting every particular, and their ambassadors might follow the consul on his return from Samnium." When the Roman army accordingly marched through all parts of Samnium, which was in a state of peace, provisions being liberally supplied, a renewal of the old treaty was, this year, granted to the Samnites. The Roman arms were then turned against the Aequans, their old enemies, but who had, for many years past, remained quiet, under the guise of a treacherous peace, because, while the Hernicians were in a state of prosperity, these had, in conjunction with them, frequently sent aid to the Samnites; and after the Hernicians were subdued, almost the whole nation, without dissembling that they acted by public authority, had revolted to the enemy; and when, after the conclusion of the treaty with the Samnites at Rome, ambassadors were sent to demand satisfaction, they said, that "this was only a trial made of them, on the expectation that they would through fear suffer themselves to be made Roman citizens. But how much that condition was to be wished for, they had been taught by the Hernicians; who, when they had the option, preferred their own laws to the freedom of the Roman state. To people who wished for liberty to choose what they judged preferable, the necessity of becoming Roman citizens would have the nature of a punishment." In resentment of these declarations, uttered publicly in their assemblies, the Roman people ordered war to be made on the Aequans; and, in prosecution of this new undertaking, both the consuls marched from the city, and sat down at the distance of four miles from the camp of the enemy. The troops of the Aequans, like tumultuary recruits, in consequence of their having passed such a number of years without waging war on their own account, were all in disorder and confusion, without established officers and without command. Some advised to give battle, others to defend the camp; the greater part were influenced by concern for the devastation of their lands, likely to take place, and the consequent destruction of their cities, left with weak garrisons. Among a variety of propositions, one, however, was heard which, abandoning all concern for the public interest, tended to transfer every man's attention to the care of his private concerns. It recommended that, at the first watch, they should depart from the camp by different roads, so as to carry all their effects into the cities, and to secure them by the strength of the fortifications; this they all approved with universal assent. When the enemy were now dispersed through the country, the Romans, at the first dawn, marched out to the field, and drew up in order of battle; but no one coming to oppose them, they advanced in a brisk pace to the enemy's camp. But when they perceived neither guards before the gates, nor soldiers on the ramparts, nor the usual bustle of a camp,--surprised at the extraordinary silence, they halted in apprehension of some stratagem. At length, passing over the rampart, and finding the whole deserted, they proceeded to search out the tracks of the enemy. But these, as they scattered themselves to every quarter, occasioned perplexity at first. Afterwards discovering their design by means of scouts, they attacked their cities, one after another, and within the space of fifty days took, entirely by force, forty-one towns, most of which were razed and burnt, and the race of the Aequans almost extirpated. A triumph was granted over the Aequans. The Marrucinians, Marsians, Pelignians, and Ferentans, warned by the example of their disasters, sent deputies to Rome to solicit peace and friendship; and these states, on their submissive applications, were admitted into alliance.

In the next consulate of Publius Sulpicius Saverrio and Publius Sempronius Sophus, the Samnites, wanting either to end or pause hostilities, sent ambassadors to Rome to discuss peace. In response to their humble requests, the answer was that, “if the Samnites hadn’t repeatedly sought peace while actually gearing up for war, their current request might have, during negotiations, had a chance of success. But now, since words had proven useless so far, actions must guide people's decisions: Publius Sempronius, the consul, would soon be in Samnium with an army, and he wouldn’t be fooled into thinking whether they leaned toward peace or war. He would bring back definite information on all matters, and their ambassadors could follow him when he returned from Samnium.” As the Roman army marched through peaceful Samnium, receiving abundant supplies, the old treaty was renewed with the Samnites that year. The Roman forces then turned against the Aequans, their long-time enemies, who had remained quiet in a deceitful peace for many years; while the Hernicians thrived, the Aequans often supported the Samnites. After the Hernicians were defeated, nearly the entire Aequan nation openly revolted against Rome, claiming, when diplomats were sent to demand reparations, that “this was merely a test, expecting that fear would force them to accept Roman citizenship. But they learned from the Hernicians how desirable that condition was, as the Hernicians had preferred their own laws over the freedom of the Roman state. For those desiring the liberty to choose what they found preferable, the obligation to become Roman citizens felt like a punishment.” Angered by these public statements in their assemblies, the Roman populace declared war on the Aequans. Following this new campaign, both consuls left the city and set up camp four miles away from the enemy. The Aequans, like disorganized recruits after years without battling on their own, were in chaos with no proper leaders or order. Some suggested fighting, while others recommended defending the camp; most were worried about the ravaging of their lands and the potential destruction of their cities, which had weak garrisons. Among various suggestions, one stood out that shifted everyone’s focus from public safety to personal interests. It proposed that at the first watch, they should leave the camp by different paths to move their belongings into the cities and secure them with the fortifications; everyone agreed with this idea. When the enemy dispersed throughout the area, the Romans marched out at dawn and arranged themselves for battle. Seeing no opposition, they quickly advanced toward the enemy's camp. But when they found no guards at the gates, no soldiers on the ramparts, and no usual camp activity, they were surprised by the unusual silence and halted, suspecting a trap. Eventually, after crossing the rampart and finding the area completely abandoned, they began searching for the enemy's trails. As the enemy scattered in every direction, it initially caused confusion. However, after discovering their plans through scouts, the Romans attacked their towns one by one, capturing forty-one cities in just fifty days, most of which were destroyed and burned, nearly wiping out the Aequans. A triumph was held over the Aequans. The Marrucinians, Marsians, Pelignians, and Ferentans, learning from the Aequans' fate, sent envoys to Rome seeking peace and friendship, and these states were accepted into an alliance in response to their earnest requests.

46

In the same year, Cneius Flavius, son of Cneius, grandson of a freed man, a notary, in low circumstances originally, but artful and eloquent, was appointed curule aedile. I find in some annals, that, being in attendance on the aediles, and seeing that he was voted aedile by the prerogative tribe, but that his name would not be received, because he acted as a notary, he threw down his tablet, and took an oath, that he would not, for the future, follow that business. But Licinius Macer contends, that he had dropped the employment of notary a considerable time before, having already been a tribune, and twice a triumvir, once for regulating the nightly watch, and another time for conducting a colony. However, of this there is no dispute, that against the nobles, who threw contempt on the meanness of his condition, he contended with much firmness. He made public the rules of proceeding in judicial causes, hitherto shut up in the closets of the pontiffs; and hung up to public view, round the forum, the calendar on white tablets, that all might know when business could be transacted in the courts. To the great displeasure of the nobles, he performed the dedication of the temple of Concord, in the area of Vulcan's temple; and the chief pontiff, Cornelius Barbatus, was compelled by the united instances of the people, to dictate to him the form of words, although he affirmed, that, consistently with the practice of antiquity, no other than a consul, or commander-in-chief, could dedicate a temple. This occasioned a law to be proposed to the people, by direction of the senate, that no person should dedicate a temple, or an altar, without an order from the senate, or from a majority of the plebeian tribunes. The incident which I am about to mention would be trivial in itself, were it not an instance of the freedom assumed by plebeians in opposition to the pride of the nobles. When Flavius had come to make a visit to his colleague, who was sick, and when, by an arrangement between some young nobles who were sitting there, they did not rise on his entrance, he ordered his curule chair to be brought thither, and from his honourable seat of office enjoyed the sight of his enemies tortured with envy. However, a low faction, which had gathered strength during the censorship of Appius Claudius, had made Flavius an aedile; for he was the first who degraded the senate, by electing into it the immediate descendants of freed men; and when no one allowed that election as valid, and when he had not acquired in the senate-house that influence in the city which he had been aiming at, by distributing men of the meanest order among all the several tribes, he thus corrupted the assemblies both of the forum and of the field of Mars; and so much indignation did the election of Flavius excite, that most of the nobles laid aside their gold rings and bracelets in consequence of it. From that time the state was split into two parties. The uncorrupted part of the people, who favoured and supported the good, held one side; the faction of the rabble, the other; until Quintus Fabius and Publius Decius were made censors; and Fabius, both for the sake of concord, and at the same time to prevent the elections remaining in the hands of the lowest of the people, purged the rest of the tribes of all the rabble of the forum, and threw it into four, and called them city tribes. And this procedure, we are told, gave such universal satisfaction, that, by this regulation in the orders of the state, he obtained the surname of Maximus, which he had not obtained by his many victories. The annual review of the knights, on the ides of July, is also said to have been instituted by him.

In the same year, Cneius Flavius, son of Cneius and grandson of a freedman, who started off in a humble position but was clever and articulate, became a curule aedile. I found in some records that while attending the aediles, he saw that he was elected aedile by the privileged tribe but that his name wouldn't be accepted because he worked as a notary. He threw down his tablet and swore that he would no longer pursue that profession. However, Licinius Macer argues that he had quit being a notary some time before, having already served as a tribune and twice as a triumvir, once for organizing the night watch and another time for overseeing a colony. Regardless, it's clear that he stood his ground against the nobles, who looked down on his lowly background. He made public the rules for legal proceedings, which had previously been kept secret by the pontiffs, and displayed the court calendar on white tablets around the forum so everyone could see when court business could take place. To the great annoyance of the nobles, he dedicated the temple of Concord in the area of Vulcan's temple, and the chief pontiff, Cornelius Barbatus, was forced by the people's demands to tell him the words to use, even though he insisted that traditionally, only a consul or military commander could dedicate a temple. This led to a law being proposed by the senate that no one could dedicate a temple or altar without permission from the senate or a majority of the plebeian tribunes. The next incident I'm about to mention might seem trivial on its own, but it shows how plebeians pushed back against noble pride. When Flavius visited a sick colleague and the young nobles sitting there didn’t stand up when he entered, he had his curule chair brought in and from his respected position enjoyed watching his enemies squirm with envy. A low faction, which had gained power during Appius Claudius' censorship, had elected Flavius as aedile; he was the first to bring down the senate by electing the direct descendants of freedmen into it. When nobody accepted that election as valid and he failed to gain the influence he sought in the senate through distributing people of the lowest class among all the tribes, he undermined the assemblies in both the forum and the Campus Martius. The outrage over Flavius’ election was so great that most of the nobles removed their gold rings and bracelets. From that point on, the state was divided into two factions. The honest part of the population, who supported the good, took one side; the faction of the common people took the other, until Quintus Fabius and Publius Decius became censors. To promote unity and prevent elections from falling into the hands of the lowest citizens, Fabius purged the other tribes of all the common people from the forum and organized them into four city tribes. This change was reportedly so well-received that he earned the title of Maximus, which he hadn't achieved through his numerous victories. He is also credited with establishing the annual review of the knights on the ides of July.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK X.
B.C. 303-293


Submission of the Marcians accepted. The college of Augurs augmented from four to nine. The law of appeal to the people carried by Valerius the consul. Two more tribes added. War declared against the Samnites. Several successful actions. In an engagement against the combined forces of the Etruscans, Umbrians, Samnites, and Gauls, Publius Decius, after the example of his father, devotes himself for the army. Dies, and, by his death, procures the victory to the Romans. Defeat of the Samnites by Papirius Cursor. The census held. The lustrum closed. The number of the citizens two hundred and sixty-two thousand three hundred and twenty-two.

       *        *        *        *        *

1

During the consulate of Lucius Genucius and Servius Cornelius, the state enjoyed almost uninterrupted rest from foreign wars. Colonies were led out to Sora and Alba. For the latter, situated in the country of the Aequans, six thousand colonists were enrolled. Sora had formerly belonged to the Volscian territory, but had fallen into the possession of the Samnites: thither were sent four thousand settlers. This year the freedom of the state was granted to the Arpinians and Trebulans. The Frusinonians were fined a third part of their lands, because it was discovered that the Hernicians had been tampered with by them; and the heads of that conspiracy, after a trial before the consuls, held in pursuance of a decree of the senate, were beaten with rods and beheaded. However, that the Romans might not pass the year entirely exempt from war, a little expedition was made into Umbria; intelligence being received from thence, that excursions of men, in arms, had been made, from a certain cave, into the adjacent country. Into this cave the troops penetrated with their standards, and, the place being dark, they received many wounds, chiefly from stones thrown. At length the other mouth of the cave being found, for it was pervious, both the openings were filled up with wood, which being set on fire, there perished by means of the smoke and heat, no less than two thousand men; many of whom, at the last, in attempting to make their way out, rushed into the very flames. The two Marci, Livius Denter and Aemilius, succeeding to the consulship, war was renewed with the Aequans; who, being highly displeased at the colony established within their territory, as if it were a fortress, having made an attempt, with their whole force, to seize it, were repulsed by the colonists themselves. They caused, however, such an alarm at Rome, that, to quell this insurrection, Caius Junius Bubulcus was nominated dictator: for it was scarcely credible that the Aequans, after being reduced to such a degree of weakness, should by themselves alone have ventured to engage in a war. The dictator, taking the field, with Marcus Titinius, master of the horse, in the first engagement reduced the Aequans to submission; and returning into the city in triumph, on the eighth day, dedicated, in the character of dictator, the temple of Health, which he had vowed when consul, and contracted for when censor.

During the consulship of Lucius Genucius and Servius Cornelius, the state experienced almost constant peace from foreign wars. Colonies were established in Sora and Alba. For Alba, which was in Aequan territory, six thousand colonists were registered. Sora had previously been part of Volscian land but had fallen into the hands of the Samnites; four thousand settlers were sent there. This year, the Arpinians and Trebulans were granted freedom. The Frusinonians were fined a third of their land because it was discovered that they had influenced the Hernicians; the leaders of that plot, after a trial before the consuls, as required by a senate decree, were punished with rods and executed. However, to ensure that the Romans didn’t spend the year completely free of conflict, a small expedition was launched into Umbria after reports of armed raids from a cave nearby. The troops advanced into this cave under their standards, and in the dark, they sustained many injuries, mostly from thrown stones. Eventually, they found the other opening of the cave, which was accessible, and they blocked both entrances with wood, which they then set on fire, causing the death of no less than two thousand men due to smoke and heat; many of them, in their desperation to escape, ran straight into the flames. When the two Marci, Livius Denter and Aemilius, took over the consulship, war with the Aequans resumed; they were extremely upset about the colony established in their territory, viewing it as a fortress, and attempted to seize it with their entire force but were pushed back by the colonists. This caused a great alarm in Rome, prompting the appointment of Caius Junius Bubulcus as dictator to address the uprising, as it was hard to believe that the weakened Aequans would dare to go to war on their own. The dictator, along with Marcus Titinius, the master of the horse, went to battle and quickly subdued the Aequans; returning to the city in triumph on the eighth day, he dedicated the temple of Health, which he had vowed when he was consul and contracted for when he was censor.

2

During this year a fleet of Grecians, under the command of Cleonymus, a Lacedaemonian, arrived on the coast of Italy, and took Thuriae, a city in the territory of the Sallentines. Against this enemy the consul Aemilius was sent, who, in one battle, completely defeated them, and drove them on board their ships. Thuriae was then restored to its old inhabitants, and peace re-established in the country of the Sallentines. In some annals, I find that Junius Bubulcus was sent dictator into that country, and that Cleonymus, without hazarding an engagement with the Romans, retired out of Italy. He then sailed round the promontory of Brundusium, and, steering down the middle of the Adriatic gulf, because he dreaded, on the left hand, the coasts of Italy destitute of harbours, and, on the right, the Illyrians, Liburnians, and Istrians, nations of savages, and noted in general for piracy, he passed on to the coasts of the Venetians. Here, having landed a small party to explore the country, and being informed that a narrow beach stretched along the shore, beyond which were marshes, overflowed by the tides; that dry land was seen at no great distance, level in the nearest part, and rising behind into hills, beyond which was the mouth of a very deep river, into which they had seen ships brought round and moored in safety, (this was the river Meduacus,) he ordered his fleet to sail into it and go up against the stream. As the channel would not admit the heavy ships, the troops, removing into the lighter vessels, arrived at a part of the country occupied by three maritime cantons of the Patavians, settled on that coast. Here they made a descent, leaving a small guard with the ships, made themselves masters of these cantons, set fire to the houses, drove off a considerable booty of men and cattle, and, allured by the sweets of plunder, proceeded still further from the shore. When news of this was brought to Patavium, where the contiguity of the Gauls kept the inhabitants constantly in arms, they divided their young men into two bands, one of which was led towards the quarter where the marauders were said to be busy; the other by a different route, to avoid meeting any of the pirates, towards the station of the ships, fifteen miles distant from the town. An attack was made on the small craft, and the guards being killed, the affrighted mariners were obliged to remove their ships to the other bank of the river. By land, also, the attack on the dispersed plunderers was equally successful; and the Grecians, flying back towards their ships, were opposed in their way by the Venetians. Thus they were enclosed on both sides, and cut to pieces; and some, who were made prisoners, gave information that the fleet, with their king, Cleonymus, was but three miles distant. Sending the captives into the nearest canton, to be kept under a guard, some soldiers got on board the flat-bottomed vessels, so constructed for the purpose of passing the shoals with ease; others embarked in those which had been lately taken from the enemy, and proceeding down the river, surrounded their unwieldy ships, which dreaded the unknown sands and flats more than they did the Romans, and which showed a greater eagerness to escape into the deep than to make resistance. The soldiers pursued them as far as the mouth of the river; and having taken and burned a part of the fleet, which in the hurry and confusion had been stranded, returned victorious. Cleonymus, having met success in no part of the Adriatic sea, departed with scarce a fifth part of his navy remaining. Many, now alive, have seen the beaks of his ships, and the spoils of the Lacedaemonians, hanging in the old temple of Juno. In commemoration of this event, there is exhibited at Patavium, every year, on its anniversary day, a naval combat on the river in the middle of the town.

During this year, a fleet of Greeks, led by Cleonymus, a Spartan, arrived on the coast of Italy and took Thuriae, a city in the Sallentine territory. The consul Aemilius was sent against this enemy and, in one battle, completely defeated them, forcing them onto their ships. Thuriae was then returned to its original inhabitants, and peace was restored in the Sallentine region. Some historical records state that Junius Bubulcus was sent as dictator to that area, and that Cleonymus, avoiding a clash with the Romans, retreated from Italy. He then sailed around the Brundusium promontory and navigated straight down the Adriatic because he feared the unprotected Italian coasts on his left and the Illyrians, Liburnians, and Istrians on his right, groups known for piracy. He continued on to the Venetian coasts. There, he disembarked a small group to scout the area and learned that a narrow beach ran along the shore, with marshes that flooded during high tide; dry land was visible a short distance away, flat at the closest point and rising into hills beyond which flowed the mouth of a very deep river, where ships were known to dock safely (this river was Meduacus). He ordered his fleet to sail into the river and travel upstream. Since the channel couldn't accommodate the heavy ships, the troops transferred to lighter vessels, reaching an area occupied by three coastal districts of the Patavians. They landed, leaving a small guard with the ships, took control of these districts, set fire to houses, captured a significant amount of livestock and people, and, enticed by the allure of loot, ventured even further from the shore. When word of this reached Patavium, where the close proximity of the Gauls kept the people constantly armed, they divided their young men into two groups: one headed to confront the marauders, and the other took a different route to avoid any pirates, heading toward the ships stationed fifteen miles from the town. They attacked the small boats, killing the guards, forcing the panicked crew to move their vessels to the opposite bank of the river. On land, they successfully attacked the scattered looters as well; the Greeks, fleeing towards their ships, were met by the Venetians. Caught between both sides, they were decimated; some captured individuals revealed that Cleonymus and his fleet were only three miles away. The captives were sent to the nearest district under guard, while some soldiers boarded flat-bottomed vessels specially designed for shallow waters, and others took those recently seized from the enemy. They proceeded down the river, surrounding Cleonymus's unwieldy ships, which feared the unknown sands and shallows more than the Romans, showing a greater desire to escape into the deeper waters than to resist. The soldiers chased them to the river mouth; having seized and burned part of the fleet, which had run aground in the chaos, they returned victorious. Cleonymus, having faced failure throughout the Adriatic, left with barely a fifth of his navy remaining. Many people alive today have seen the prows of his ships and the spoils of the Spartans displayed in the old temple of Juno. To commemorate this event, a naval battle is held every year in Patavium on the anniversary of the event in the town's river.

3

A treaty was this year concluded at Rome with the Vestinians, who solicited friendship. Various causes of apprehension afterwards sprung up. News arrived, that Etruria was in rebellion; the insurrection having arisen from the dissensions of the Arretians; for the Cilnian family having grown exorbitantly powerful, a party, out of envy of their wealth, had attempted to expel them by force of arms. [Accounts were also received] that the Marsians held forcible possession of the lands to which the colony of Carseoli, consisting of four thousand men, had been sent. By reason, therefore, of these commotions, Marcus Valerius Maximus was nominated dictator, and chose for his master of the horse Marcus Aemilius Paullus. This I am inclined to believe, rather than that Quintus Fabius, at such an age as he then was, and after enjoying many honours, was placed in a station subordinate to Valerius: but I think it not unlikely that the mistake arose from the surname Maximus. The dictator, having set out at the head of an army, in one battle utterly defeated the Marsians, drove them into their fortified towns, and afterwards, in the course of a few days, took Milionia, Plestina, and Fresilia; and then finding Marsians in a part of their lands, granted them a renewal of the treaty. The war was then directed against the Etrurians; and when the dictator had gone to Rome, for the purpose of renewing the auspices, the master of the horse, going out to forage, was surrounded by an ambuscade, and obliged to fly shamefully into his camp, after losing several standards and many of his men. The occurrence of which discomfiture to Fabius is exceedingly improbable; not only because, if in any particular, certainly, above all, in the qualifications of a commander, he fully merited his surname; but besides, mindful of Papirius's severity, he never could have been tempted to fight, without the dictator's orders.

A treaty was signed this year in Rome with the Vestinians, who sought friendship. Various concerns later arose. News came that Etruria was in rebellion; the uprising had started due to quarrels among the Arretians. The Cilnian family had become extremely powerful, and a faction, envious of their wealth, attempted to force them out using arms. Reports also stated that the Marsians had taken control of the lands designated for the colony of Carseoli, which consisted of four thousand men. Because of these disruptions, Marcus Valerius Maximus was appointed dictator, and he chose Marcus Aemilius Paullus to be his master of the horse. I believe this is more likely than the claim that Quintus Fabius, given his age and many past honors, was put in a subordinate position to Valerius; I think the mix-up probably stems from the surname Maximus. The dictator, leading an army, decisively defeated the Marsians in one battle, forcing them into their fortified towns. In the following days, he captured Milionia, Plestina, and Fresilia, and then, encountering Marsians in part of their lands, renewed the treaty with them. The focus then shifted to the Etrurians; however, when the dictator returned to Rome to renew the auspices, the master of the horse, while going out to forage, was ambushed and forced to retreat back to his camp, losing several standards and many men. It seems very unlikely that this setback happened to Fabius, not only because he truly deserved his title, especially in regard to his skills as a commander, but also because, mindful of Papirius's strictness, he would never have been tempted to fight without the dictator's orders.

4

The news of this disaster excited at Rome an alarm greater than suited the importance of the affair; for, as if the army had been destroyed, a justitium was proclaimed, guards mounted at the gates, and watches set in every street: and armour and weapons were heaped on the walls. All the younger citizens being compelled to enlist, the dictator was ordered to join the army. There he found every thing in a more tranquil state than he expected, and regularity established through the care of the master of the horse, the camp removed to a place of greater safety, the cohorts, which had lost their standards, left without tents on the outside of the ramparts and the troops ardently impatient for battle, that their disgrace might be the sooner obliterated. He therefore immediately advanced his camp into the territory of Rusella. Thither the enemy also followed, and although, since their late success, they entertained the most sanguine hopes from an open trial of strength, yet they endeavoured to circumvent the enemy by a stratagem which they had before practised with success. There were, at a small distance from the Roman camp, the half-ruined houses of a town which had been burnt in the devastation of the country. A body of troops being concealed there, some cattle was driven on, within view of a Roman post, commanded by a lieutenant-general, Cneius Fulvius. When no one was induced by this temptation to stir from his post, one of the herdsmen, advancing close to the works, called out, that others were driving out those cattle at their leisure from the ruins of the town, why did they remain idle, when they might safely drive them through the middle of the Roman camp? When this was interpreted to the lieutenant-general, by some natives of Caere, and great impatience prevailed through every company of the soldiers, who, nevertheless, dared not to move without orders, he commanded some who were skilled in the language to observe attentively, whether the dialect of the herdsmen resembled that of rustics or of citizens. When these reported, that their accent in speaking, their manner and appearance, were all of a more polished cast than suited shepherds, "Go then," said he, "tell them that they may uncover the ambush which they vainly conceal, that the Romans understand all their devices, and can now be no more taken by stratagem than they can be conquered by arms." When these words were heard, and carried to those who lay in ambush, they immediately arose from their lurking place, and marched out in order into the plain which was open to view on every side The lieutenant-general thought their force too powerful for his small band to cope with. He therefore sent in haste to Valerius for support, and in the mean time, by himself, sustained the enemy's onset.

The news of this disaster caused more panic in Rome than the situation warranted; it was as if the entire army had been wiped out. A justitium was declared, guards were stationed at the gates, and watchmen were set up on every street. Weapons and armor were piled on the walls. All the younger citizens were forced to enlist, and the dictator was ordered to join the army. When he arrived, he found everything calmer than expected, with order restored thanks to the master of the horse. The camp had been moved to a safer location, and the cohorts that had lost their standards were left without tents outside the ramparts, while the troops were eager for battle, wanting to erase their shame as quickly as possible. So, he immediately moved his camp into the territory of Rusella. The enemy followed him and, despite their recent victory fueling their confidence for an open confrontation, they tried to trick the Romans using a tactic that had worked for them before. Nearby were the half-destroyed buildings of a town that had been burned during the devastation of the area. A group of soldiers hid there while some cattle were driven into view of a Roman outpost commanded by the lieutenant-general, Cneius Fulvius. When nobody was tempted to leave their post, one of the herdsmen approached close to the fortifications and shouted that others were leisurely driving cattle out from the ruins of the town and asked why they were just sitting there when they could easily drive the cattle through the middle of the Roman camp. Some locals from Caere interpreted this for the lieutenant-general, and a wave of impatience swept through the soldiers, who still hesitated to move without orders. He commanded some men who knew the language to listen closely and determine whether the herdsmen spoke like rural villagers or urban citizens. When they reported that the herdsmen's accent, manner, and appearance were more refined than was typical for shepherds, he said, "Go tell them that we know about their hidden ambush and that Romans are no longer fooled by tricks than they can be beaten by arms." When these words reached the ambushers, they quickly emerged from their hiding place and marched out into the open plain. The lieutenant-general considered their numbers too strong for his small force, so he urgently sent for reinforcements from Valerius while he held off the enemy's attack by himself.

5

On receiving his message, the dictator ordered the standards to move, and the troops to follow in arms. But every thing was executed more quickly, almost, than ordered. The standards and arms were instantly snatched up, and they were with difficulty restrained from running impetuously on, both indignation at their late defeat stimulated them, as well as the shouts striking their ears with increasing vehemence, as the contest grew hotter They therefore urged each other, and pressed the standard-bearers to quicken their pace. The dictator, the more eagerly he saw them push forward, took the more pains to repress their haste, and ordered them to march at a slower rate. On the other side, the Etrurians, putting themselves in motion, on the first beginning of the fray had come up with their whole force, and several expresses came to the dictator, one after another, that all the regions of the Etrurians had joined in the fight, and that his men could not any longer withstand them: at the same time, he himself saw, from the higher ground, in how perilous a situation the party was. Confident, however, that the lieutenant-general was able, even yet, to support the contest, and considering that he himself was at hand to rescue him from defeat, he wished to let the enemy be fatigued, as much as might be, in order that, when in that state, he might fall on them with his fresh troops. Slowly as these marched, the distance was now just sufficient for the cavalry to begin their career for a charge. The battalions of the legions marched in front, lest the enemy might suspect any secret or sudden movement, but intervals had been left in the ranks of the infantry, affording room for the horses to gallop through. At the same instant the line raised the shout, and the cavalry, charging at full speed, poured on the enemy, and spread at once a general panic. After this, as succour had arrived, almost too late, to the party surrounded, so now they were allowed entire rest, the fresh troops taking on themselves the whole business of the fight. Nor was that either long or dubious. The enemy, now routed, fled to their camp, and the Romans advancing to attack it, they gave way, and are crowded all together in the remotest part of it. In their flight they are obstructed by the narrowness of the gates, the greater number climbed up on the mounds and ramparts, to try if they could either defend themselves with the aid of the advantageous ground, or get over, by any means, and escape. One part of the rampart, happening to be badly compacted sunk under the weight of the multitude who stood on it, and fell into the trench. On which, crying out that the gods had opened that pass to give them safety, they made their way out, most of them leaving their arms behind. By this battle the power of the Etrurians was, a second time, effectually crushed, so that, engaging to furnish a year's pay, and corn for two months, with the dictator's permission, they sent ambassadors to Rome to treat of peace. This was refused, but a truce for two years was granted to them. The dictator returned into the city in triumph. I have seen it asserted, that tranquillity was restored in Etruria by the dictator, without any memorable battle, only by composing the dissensions of the Arretians, and effecting a reconciliation between the Cilnian family and the commons. Marcus Valerius was elected consul, before the expiration of his dictatorship, many have believed, without his soliciting the office, and even while he was absent; and that the election was held by an interrex. In one point all agree, that he held the consulship with Quintus Appulcius Pansa.

Upon receiving his message, the dictator ordered the standards to move and the troops to follow in arms. However, everything was done almost faster than ordered. The standards and arms were quickly grabbed, and they were barely held back from charging forward, both angered by their recent defeat and urged on by the escalating cheers as the battle intensified. They encouraged each other, pushing the standard-bearers to speed up. The dictator, seeing their eagerness to charge, worked harder to slow them down and instructed them to march at a more measured pace. Meanwhile, the Etrurians, moving forward as the battle started, had brought their entire force into the fray, with several messages arriving one after another to tell the dictator that all the Etrurian regions had joined the fight and that his men could no longer hold out against them. At the same time, he could see from a higher ground just how precarious their situation was. However, confident that the lieutenant-general could still hold the line, and knowing he was close to providing support, he wanted to tire out the enemy as much as possible. This way, when they were exhausted, he could launch his fresh troops at them. As slowly as his troops marched, the distance was just enough for the cavalry to prepare for a charge. The battalions of the legions advanced first to prevent the enemy from sensing any sudden movement, while gaps were left in the infantry ranks to allow the horses to dash through. At the same moment, a shout went up from the line, and the cavalry charged full speed into the enemy, creating immediate chaos. After this, with reinforcements arriving, albeit almost too late, the surrounded troops were given full rest, with the fresh soldiers taking over the fighting. It didn’t take long, nor was it uncertain. The enemy, now defeated, fled to their camp, and as the Romans advanced to attack, they gave way, crowding together at the far end of it. In their flight, they were hindered by the narrow gates; many climbed onto the mounds and ramparts, hoping to defend themselves with the high ground or escape in any way they could. One part of the rampart, being poorly built, collapsed under the weight of those standing on it and fell into the trench. Upon this, they cried out that the gods had opened a path for their safety and managed to escape, most of them leaving their weapons behind. This battle effectively crushed the power of the Etrurians a second time, so they committed to providing a year's worth of pay and two months' worth of grain; with the dictator's permission, they sent ambassadors to Rome to negotiate peace. This was denied, but a two-year truce was granted. The dictator returned to the city in triumph. I have heard it said that tranquility was brought back to Etruria by the dictator without a significant battle, simply by resolving the disputes among the Arretians and reconciling the Cilnian family with the commons. Marcus Valerius was elected consul before his dictatorship ended, many believe without him seeking the position, and even while he was away; the election was conducted by an interrex. Everyone agrees that he held the consulship jointly with Quintus Appulcius Pansa.

6

During this consulate of Marcus Valerius and Quintus Appulcius, affairs abroad wore a very peaceable aspect. Their losses sustained in war, together with the truce, kept the Etrurians quiet. The Samnites, depressed by the misfortunes of many years, had not yet become dissatisfied with their new alliance. At Rome, also, the carrying away of such multitudes to colonies, rendered the commons tranquil, and lightened their burthens. But, that things might not be tranquil on all sides, a contention was excited between the principal persons in the commonwealth, patricians on one hand, and plebeians on the other, by the two Ogulnii, Quintus and Cneius, plebeian tribunes, who, seeking every where occasions of criminating the patricians in the hearing of the people, and having found other attempts fruitless, set on foot a proceeding by which they might inflame, not the lowest class of the commons, but their chief men, the plebeians of consular and triumphal rank, to the completion of whose honours nothing was now wanting but the offices of the priesthood, which were not yet laid open to them. They therefore published a proposal for a law, that, whereas there were then four augurs and four pontiffs, and it had been determined that the number of priests should be augmented, the four additional pontiffs and five augurs should all be chosen out of the commons. How the college of augurs could be reduced to the number of four, except by the death of two, I do not understand: for it is a rule among the augurs, that their number should be composed of threes, so that the three ancient tribes, the Ramnes, Titienses, and Luceres, should have each its own augur; or, in case there should be occasion for more, that each should increase its number of augurs, in equal proportion with the rest, in like manner as when, by the addition of five to four, they made up the number nine, so that there were three to each tribe. However, as it was proposed that they should be chosen out of the commons, the patricians were as highly offended at the proceeding, as when they saw the consulship made common; yet they pretended that the business concerned not them so much as it did the gods, who would "take care that their own worship should not be contaminated; that, for their parts, they only wished that no misfortune might ensue to the commonwealth." But they made a less vigorous opposition, as being now accustomed to suffer defeat in such kind of disputes; and they saw their adversaries, not, as formerly, grasping at that which they could scarcely hope to reach, the higher honours; but already in possession of all those advantages, on the uncertain prospect of which they had maintained the contest, manifold consulships, censorships, and triumphs.

During the time of the consuls Marcus Valerius and Quintus Appulcius, international affairs seemed very peaceful. The Etrurians were quiet due to their losses in war and the truce. The Samnites, having suffered for many years, were still not unhappy with their new alliance. In Rome, the mass relocation of people to colonies helped keep the common folks calm and eased their burdens. However, to ensure that not everything was calm, a conflict arose between prominent members of society, with patricians on one side and plebeians on the other, instigated by the two Ogulnii, Quintus and Cneius, who were plebeian tribunes. They sought out every opportunity to criticize the patricians in front of the people and, after failing in other attempts, initiated a movement to stir up not the lowest class of commoners but their leaders, the plebeians of consular and triumphal rank, who only lacked the priesthood offices that were still closed off to them. They therefore proposed a law stating that, since there were then four augurs and four pontiffs and it had been decided to increase the number of priests, the four extra pontiffs and five augurs should all be chosen from the common people. I don't understand how the number of augurs could be brought down to four except by the death of two, because it’s a rule among augurs that their total should be in threes, ensuring that each of the three ancient tribes—the Ramnes, Titienses, and Luceres—has its own augur; or, if more were needed, that each tribe could add augurs in equal measure, just as when five were added to four to make nine, so that there were three for each tribe. Nevertheless, since it was proposed that they would be selected from the commons, the patricians were as outraged by this as when they saw the consulship made available to everyone; yet they pretended that this issue was more about the gods, who would "ensure their own worship was not tainted; that, as far as they were concerned, they only hoped no misfortune would befall the commonwealth." However, they opposed it less vigorously, as they had become used to losing in such disputes; and they recognized that their opponents were not, as before, reaching for something they could barely grasp—higher honors—but were already enjoying the various advantages, such as multiple consulships, censorships, and triumphs, which had fueled their previous struggles.

7

The principal struggle, however, in supporting and opposing the bill, they say, was between Appius Claudius and Publius Decius Mus. After these had urged nearly the same topics, respecting the privileges of patricians and plebeians, which had been formerly employed for and against the Licinian law, when the proposition was brought forward of opening the consulship to plebeians, Decius is said to have drawn a lively description of his own father, such as many then present in the assembly had seen him, girt in the Gabine dress, standing on a spear, in the attitude in which he had devoted himself for the people and the legions, and to have added, that the consul Publius Decius was then deemed by the immortal gods an offering equally pure and pious, as if his colleague, Titus Manlius, had been devoted. And might not the same Publius Decius have been, with propriety, chosen to perform the public worship of the Roman people? Was there any danger that the gods would give less attention to his prayers than to those of Appius Claudius? Did the latter perform his private acts of adoration with a purer mind, or worship the gods more religiously than he? Who had any reason to complain of the vows offered in behalf of the commonwealth, by so many plebeian consuls and dictators, either when setting out to their armies, or in the heat of battle? Were the numbers of commanders reckoned, during those years since business began to be transacted under the conduct and auspices of plebeians, the same number of triumphs might be found. The commons had now no reason to be dissatisfied with their own nobility. On the contrary, they were fully convinced, that in case of a sudden war breaking out, the senate and people of Rome would not repose greater confidence in patrician than in plebeian commanders. "Which being the case," said he, "what god or man can deem it an impropriety, if those whom ye have honoured with curule chairs, with the purple bordered gown, with the palm-vest and embroidered robe, with the triumphal crown and laurel, whose houses ye have rendered conspicuous above others, by affixing to them the spoils of conquered enemies, should add to these the badges of augurs or pontiffs? If a person, who has rode through the city in a gilt chariot; and, decorated with the ensigns of Jupiter, supremely good and great, has mounted the Capitol, should be seen with a chalice and wand; what impropriety, I say, that he should, with his head veiled, slay a victim, or take an augury in the citadel? When, in the inscription on a person's statue, the consulship, censorship, and triumph shall be read with patience, will the eyes of readers be unable to endure the addition of the office of augur or pontiff? In truth (with deference to the gods I say it) I trust that we are, through the kindness of the Roman people, qualified in such a manner that we should, by the dignity of our characters, reflect back, on the priesthood, not less lustre than we should receive; and may demand, rather on behalf of the gods, than for our own sakes, that those whom we worship in our private we may also worship in a public capacity."

The main conflict, though, in supporting and opposing the bill, they say, was between Appius Claudius and Publius Decius Mus. After both discussed almost the same topics regarding the rights of patricians and plebeians, which had previously been argued for and against the Licinian law, when the proposal to open the consulship to plebeians was introduced, Decius is said to have painted a vivid picture of his own father, similar to how many in the assembly had seen him, dressed in the Gabine attire, standing on a spear, in the position he took when he devoted himself for the people and the legions. He added that consul Publius Decius was then seen by the immortal gods as a sacrifice just as pure and pious as if his colleague, Titus Manlius, had been devoted. And couldn’t the same Publius Decius have been suitably chosen to perform the public worship of the Roman people? Was there any risk that the gods would listen to his prayers less attentively than those of Appius Claudius? Did Appius perform his personal acts of worship with a purer mind or honor the gods more devoutly than he? Who could complain about the vows made for the commonwealth by so many plebeian consuls and dictators, whether when departing to their armies or in the heat of battle? If you counted the number of leaders during those years when things started being handled under the guidance and auspices of plebeians, you would find an equal number of triumphs. The commons had no reason to be unhappy with their own nobility. On the contrary, they were fully convinced that if a sudden war broke out, the senate and the people of Rome would not trust patrician commanders more than plebeian ones. "Given this," he said, "what god or man could think it improper if those whom you have honored with curule chairs, the purple-bordered gown, the palm-vest and the embroidered robe, the triumphal crown and laurel, whose homes you have made stand out by placing the spoils of conquered enemies on them, should also add the symbols of augurs or pontiffs? If someone, who has paraded through the city in a gilded chariot and adorned with the insignia of Jupiter, the supremely good and great, has ascended the Capitol, should be seen holding a chalice and wand; what’s improper, I ask, about him veiling his head to slay a victim or take an augury in the citadel? When, in the inscription on a person's statue, the consulship, censorship, and triumph can be read without issue, will the eyes of readers really not be able to handle the addition of the title of augur or pontiff? Honestly (with all due respect to the gods), I believe that we are, thanks to the goodwill of the Roman people, so qualified that we should, through the dignity of our positions, reflect back on the priesthood not less glory than we receive; and we may demand, rather on behalf of the gods than for our own sakes, that those whom we honor in private we may also honor in a public role."

8

"But why do I argue thus, as if the cause of the patricians, respecting the priesthood, were untouched? and as if we were not already in possession of one sacerdotal office, of the highest class? We see plebeian decemvirs, for performing sacrifices, interpreters of the Sibylline prophecies, and of the fates of the nation; we also see them presidents of Apollo's festival, and of other religious performances. Neither was any injustice done to the patricians, when, to the two commissioners for performing sacrifices, an additional number was joined, in favour of the plebeians; nor is there now, when a tribune, a man of courage and activity, wishes to add five places of augurs, and four of pontiffs, to which plebeians may be nominated; not Appius, with intent to expel you from your places; but, that men of plebeian rank may assist you, in the management of divine affairs, with the same zeal with which they assist you in matters of human concernment. Blush not, Appius, at having a man your colleague in the priesthood, whom you might have a colleague in the censorship or consulship, whose master of the horse you yourself may be, when he is dictator, as well as dictator when he is master of the horse. A Sabine adventurer, the first origin of your nobility, either Attus Clausus, or Appius Claudius, which you will, the ancient patricians of those days admitted into their number: do not then, on your part, disdain to admit us into the number of priests. We bring with us numerous honours; all those honours, indeed, which have rendered your party so proud. Lucius Sextius was the first consul chosen out of the plebeians; Caius Licinius Stolo, the first master of the horse; Caius Marcius Rutilus, the first dictator, and likewise censor; Quintus Publilius Philo, the first praetor. On all occasions was heard a repetition of the same arguments; that the right of auspices was vested in you; that ye alone had the rights of ancestry; that ye alone were legally entitled to the supreme command, and the auspices both in peace and war. The supreme command has hitherto been, and will continue to be, equally prosperous in plebeian hands as in patrician. Have ye never heard it said, that the first created patricians were not men sent down from heaven, but such as could cite their fathers, that is, nothing more than free born. I can now cite my father, a consul; and my son will be able to cite a grandfather. Citizens, there is nothing else in it, than that we should never obtain any thing without a refusal. The patricians wish only for a dispute; nor do they care what issue their disputes may have. For my part, be it advantageous, happy, and prosperous to you and to the commonwealth, I am of opinion that this law should receive your sanction."

"But why do I argue like this, as if the patricians' claim to the priesthood is untouched? As if we don't already hold one of the highest priestly offices? We see plebeian decemvirs conducting sacrifices, interpreting the Sibylline prophecies, and determining the nation's fate; we also see them leading Apollo's festival and other religious events. No injustice was done to the patricians when another group was added to the two sacrificial commissioners for the plebeians; nor is there any injustice now when a tribune, a man of courage and action, wants to add five more augurs and four pontiffs to which plebeians can be nominated. This isn't about expelling you from your positions, Appius, but about allowing people of plebeian rank to help you manage divine matters with the same dedication they show in human affairs. Don't be embarrassed, Appius, about having a colleague in the priesthood who could also be a colleague in the censors or consul. You could be the master of the horse when he is dictator, just as he could be dictator when you are master of the horse. A Sabine outsider, whether Attus Clausus or Appius Claudius, was the first of your noble blood, and ancient patricians welcomed him into their ranks; so don't look down on us as we seek a place in the priesthood. We come with plenty of honors— all those honors that have made your party so proud. Lucius Sextius was the first consul from the plebeians; Caius Licinius Stolo, the first master of the horse; Caius Marcius Rutilus, the first dictator and also censor; Quintus Publilius Philo, the first praetor. Time and again, the same arguments were repeated: that the right to auspices belonged to you; that you alone had ancestral rights; that you alone were legally entitled to the supreme command and the auspices in both peace and war. The supreme command has always been, and will continue to be, equally successful in plebeian hands as in patrician. Have you never heard that the first created patricians weren't divine beings, but just free-born men who could trace their ancestry? I can now cite my father, a consul; and my son will be able to cite his grandfather. Citizens, the only real issue is that we should never receive anything without a fight. The patricians only want a dispute, regardless of its outcome. For my part, I hope this law proves beneficial, fortunate, and successful for you and the commonwealth, and I believe it deserves your approval."

9

The people ordered that the tribes should be instantly called; and there was every appearance that the law would be accepted. It was deferred, however, for that day, by a protest, from which on the day following the tribunes were deterred; and it passed with the approbation of a vast majority. The pontiffs created were, Publius Decius Mus, the advocate for the law; Publius Sempronius Sophus, Caius Marcius Rutilus, and Marcus Livius Denter. The five augurs, who were also plebeians, were, Caius Genucius, Publius Aelius Paetus, Marcus Minucius Fessus, Caius Marcius, and Titus Publilius. Thus the number of the pontiffs was made eight; that of the augurs nine. In the same year Marcus Valerius, consul, procured a law to be passed concerning appeals; more carefully enforced by additional sanctions. This was the third time, since the expulsion of the kings, of this law being introduced, and always by the same family. The reason for renewing it so often was, I believe, no other, than that the influence of a few was apt to prove too powerful for the liberty of the commons. However, the Porcian law seems intended, solely, for the security of the persons of the citizens; as it visited with a severe penalty any one for beating with stripes or putting to death a Roman citizen. The Valerian law, after forbidding a person, who had appealed, to be beaten with rods and beheaded, added, in case of any one acting contrary thereto, that it shall yet be only deemed a wicked act. This, I suppose, was judged of sufficient strength to enforce obedience to the law in those days; so powerful was then men's sense of shame; at present one would scarcely make use of such a threat seriously. The Aequans rebelling, the same consul conducted the war against them; in which no memorable event occurred; for, except ferocity, they retained nothing of their ancient condition. The other consul, Appuleius, invested the town of Nequinum in Umbria. The ground, the same whereon Narnia now stands, was steep (on one side even perpendicular); this rendered the town impregnable either by assault or works. That business, therefore, came unfinished into the hands of the succeeding consuls, Marcus Fulvius Paetinus and Titus Manlius Torquatus. When all the centuries named Quintus Fabius consul for that year though not a candidate, Macer Licinius and Tubero state that he himself recommended them to postpone the conferring the consulship on him until a year wherein there might be more employment for their arms; adding, that, during the present year, he might be more useful to the state in the management of a city magistracy; and thus, neither dissembling what he preferred, nor yet making direct application for it, he was appointed curule aedile with Lucius Papirius Cursor. Piso, a more ancient writer of annals, prevents me from averring this as certain; he asserts that the curule aediles of that year were Caius Domitius Calvinus, son of Cneius, and Spurius Carvilius Maximus, son of Caius. I am of opinion, that this latter surname caused a mistake concerning the aediles; and that thence followed a story conformable to this mistake, patched up out of the two elections, of the aediles, and of the consuls. The general survey was performed, this year, by Publius Sempronius Sophus and Publius Sulpicius Saverrio, censors; and two tribes were added, the Aniensian and Terentine. Such were the occurrences at Rome.

The people immediately called for the tribes, and it looked like the law would be accepted. However, it was postponed for that day due to a protest, which the tribunes were discouraged from addressing the next day; it ultimately passed with a large majority in favor. The newly appointed pontiffs were Publius Decius Mus, who supported the law; Publius Sempronius Sophus, Caius Marcius Rutilus, and Marcus Livius Denter. The five augurs, who were also plebeians, included Caius Genucius, Publius Aelius Paetus, Marcus Minucius Fessus, Caius Marcius, and Titus Publilius. This brought the total number of pontiffs to eight and augurs to nine. In the same year, Marcus Valerius, the consul, managed to get a law passed regarding appeals, which was enforced more strictly with additional penalties. This was the third time this law had been introduced since the kings were expelled, always by the same family. The frequent renewal of the law was likely because the influence of a few could become too strong against the freedom of the common people. However, the Porcian law seemed aimed solely at protecting citizens' rights; it imposed severe penalties on anyone who whipped or executed a Roman citizen. The Valerian law not only prohibited a person who had appealed from being beaten or executed but also declared that if anyone acted contrary to this, it would merely be considered a wicked act. This was likely seen as strong enough to ensure compliance with the law at the time; people were then more concerned about their reputations than they are today, when such threats are rarely taken seriously. When the Aequans rebelled, the same consul led the war against them, but nothing significant happened; aside from their brutality, they had lost their former strength. The other consul, Appuleius, besieged the town of Nequinum in Umbria. The ground, where Narnia now stands, was steep—almost vertical on one side—making the town hard to attack or to capture through building works. Therefore, this task was left unfinished for the next consuls, Marcus Fulvius Paetinus and Titus Manlius Torquatus. When all the centuries elected Quintus Fabius consul for that year, even though he was not a candidate, Macer Licinius and Tubero reported that he suggested they delay his election until there would be more military engagements. He added that he could be more useful to the state in managing a city position that year; thus, without pretending otherwise or directly asking for it, he was appointed curule aedile alongside Lucius Papirius Cursor. However, more ancient chronicler Piso challenges this as a certainty; he claims that the curule aediles that year were Caius Domitius Calvinus, son of Cneius, and Spurius Carvilius Maximus, son of Caius. I believe that the latter name may have caused confusion regarding the aediles, leading to a narrative that merged details from both elections of the aediles and the consuls. This year, a general census was conducted by censors Publius Sempronius Sophus and Publius Sulpicius Saverrio, adding two tribes: the Aniensian and Terentine. Such were the events in Rome.

10

Meanwhile, after much time had been lost in the tedious siege of Nequinum, two of the townsmen, whose houses were contiguous to the wall, having formed a subterraneous passage, came by that private way to the Roman advanced guards; and being conducted thence to the consul, offered to give admittance to a body of armed men within the works and walls. The proposal was thought to be such as ought neither to be rejected, nor yet assented to without caution. With one of these men, the other being detained as an hostage, two spies were sent through the mine, and certain information being received from them, three hundred men in arms, guided by the deserter, entered the city, and seized by night the nearest gate, which being broken open, the Roman consul and his army took possession of the city without any opposition. In this manner came Nequinum under the dominion of the Roman people. A colony was sent thither as a barrier against the Umbrians, and called Narnia, from the river Nar. The troops returned to Rome with abundance of spoil. This year the Etrurians made preparations for war in violation of the truce. But a vast army of the Gauls, making an irruption into their territories, while their attention was directed to another quarter, suspended for a time the execution of their design. They then, relying on the abundance of money which they possessed, endeavour to make allies of the Gauls, instead of enemies; in order that, with their armies combined, they might attack the Romans. The barbarians made no objection to the alliance, and a negotiation was opened for settling the price; which being adjusted and paid, and every thing else being in readiness for commencing their operations, the Etrurians desired them to accompany them in their march. This they refused, alleging that "they had stipulated a price for making war against the Romans: that the payment already made, they had received in consideration of their not wasting the Etrurian territory, or using their arms against the inhabitants. That notwithstanding, if it was the wish of the Etrurians, they were still willing to engage in the war, but on no other condition than that of being allowed a share of their lands, and obtaining at length some permanent settlement." Many assemblies of the states of Etruria were held on this subject, and nothing could be settled; not so much by reason of their aversion from the dismemberment of their territory, as because every one felt a dread of fixing in so close vicinity to themselves people of such a savage race. The Gauls were therefore dismissed, and carried home an immense sum of money, acquired without toil or danger. The report of a Gallic tumult, in addition to an Etrurian war, had caused serious apprehensions at Rome; and, with the less hesitation on that account, an alliance was concluded with the state of the Picentians.

Meanwhile, after a lot of time was wasted in the boring siege of Nequinum, two of the townspeople, whose homes were next to the wall, created an underground tunnel and used it to reach the Roman advance guards; after being taken to the consul, they offered to let a group of armed men into the works and walls. The suggestion was seen as something that should neither be rejected nor agreed to without caution. With one of these men, the other being held as a hostage, two spies were sent through the tunnel, and after getting certain information from them, three hundred armed men entered the city, led by the deserter, and seized the nearest gate at night. Once the gate was broken open, the Roman consul and his army took control of the city without any resistance. This is how Nequinum came under the control of the Roman people. A colony was sent there as a buffer against the Umbrians, and it was named Narnia, after the river Nar. The troops returned to Rome with plenty of loot. This year, the Etruscans started preparing for war, breaking the truce. But a massive Gaul army invaded their lands while they were focused elsewhere, temporarily halting their plans. Then, relying on their substantial wealth, they tried to make the Gauls allies instead of enemies; this way, with their combined forces, they could attack the Romans. The Gauls had no problem with the alliance, and discussions began to settle the terms; once this was agreed upon and the payment made, and everything else prepared for their actions, the Etruscans asked them to join in their march. The Gauls refused, claiming that "they had agreed to a price for going to war against the Romans: the payment already received was for not damaging Etruscan land or attacking the locals. Nevertheless, if the Etruscans wanted, they were still willing to fight, but only on the condition that they would share in the land and eventually secure some kind of permanent settlement." Many meetings among the Etruscan states were held on this topic, but nothing could be decided; not mainly due to their reluctance to give up their territory, but because everyone feared having such a savage group living so close by. The Gauls were thus sent away, taking home a huge amount of money earned without effort or danger. The news of a Gallic uprising in addition to the Etruscan war caused serious worries in Rome; and, with less hesitation on that account, an alliance was made with the Picentians.

11

The province of Etruria fell by lot to the consul Titus Manlius; who, when he had but just entered the enemy's country, as he was exercising the cavalry, in wheeling about at full speed, was thrown from his horse, and almost killed on the spot; three days after the fall, he died. The Etrurians, embracing this omen, as it were, of the future progress of the war, and observing that the gods had commenced hostilities on their behalf, assumed new courage. At Rome the news caused great affliction, on account both of the loss of such a man and of the unseasonableness of the juncture; insomuch that an assembly, held for the purpose of substituting a new consul, having been conducted agreeably to the wishes of people of the first consequence, prevented the senate from ordering a dictator to be created. All the votes and centuries concurred unanimously in appointing Marcus Valerius consul, the same whom the senate would have ordered to be made dictator. They then commanded him to proceed immediately into Etruria, to the legions. His coming gave such a check to the Etrurians, that not one of them dared thenceforward to appear on the outside of their trenches; their own fears operating as a blockade. Nor could the new consul, by wasting their lands and burning their houses, draw them out to an engagement; for not only country-houses, but numbers of their towns, were seen smoking and in ashes, on every side. While this war proceeded more slowly than had been expected, an account was received of the breaking out of another; which was, not without reason, regarded as terrible, in consequence of the heavy losses formerly sustained by both parties, from information given by their new allies, the Picentians, that the Samnites were looking to arms and a renewal of hostilities, and that they themselves had been solicited to join therein. The Picentians received the thanks of the state; and a large share of the attention of the senate was turned from Etruria towards Samnium. The dearness of provisions also distressed the state very much, and they would have felt the extremity of want, according to the relation of those who make Fabius Maximus curule aedile that year, had not the vigilant activity of that man, such as he had on many occasions displayed in the field, been exerted then with equal zeal at home, in the management of the market, and in procuring and forming magazines of corn. An interregnum took place this year, the reason of which is not mentioned. Appius Claudius, and, after him, Publius Sulpicius, were interreges. The latter held an election of consuls, and chose Lucius Cornelius Scipio and Cneius Fulvius. In the beginning of this year, ambassadors came from the Lucanians to the new consuls to complain, that "the Samnites, finding that they could not, by any offers, tempt them to take part in the war, had marched an army in a hostile manner into their country, and were now laying it waste, and forcing them into a war; that the Lucanian people had on former occasions erred enough and more than enough; that their minds were so firmly fixed that they thought it more endurable to bear and suffer every hardship, rather than ever again to outrage the Roman name: they besought the senate to take the people of Lucania into their protection, and defend them from the injustice and outrage of the Samnites; that although fidelity on their part to the Romans would now become necessary, a war being undertaken against the Samnites, still they were ready to give hostages."

The province of Etruria was assigned to Consul Titus Manlius, who, shortly after entering enemy territory and while maneuvering the cavalry at full speed, was thrown from his horse and nearly killed on the spot; he died three days later. The Etrurians interpreted this event as a sign of their favorable prospects in the war, believing the gods had started fighting on their side, which gave them new courage. In Rome, the news caused significant distress due to the loss of such an important leader and the unfortunate timing of it all. As a result, an assembly convened to select a new consul, aligned with the wishes of prominent citizens, prevented the senate from appointing a dictator. All the votes unanimously approved Marcus Valerius as consul, the very person the senate had considered for the dictatorship. They ordered him to immediately head to Etruria to join the legions. His arrival intimidated the Etrurians so much that none dared to emerge from their trenches; their own fears acted as a blockade. The new consul couldn’t lure them into battle even by destroying their lands and burning down their houses; we saw not only rural homes but also many towns in flames all around. While this war progressed more slowly than anticipated, news arrived of another conflict emerging, which was viewed as frightening due to the heavy losses both sides had suffered before. The Picentians, their new allies, informed them that the Samnites were preparing for battle and inviting them to join. The state thanked the Picentians, and the senate shifted much of its focus from Etruria to Samnium. The rising cost of food also troubled the state greatly, and they would have faced severe shortages, according to reports from those who made Fabius Maximus a curule aedile that year, if not for his vigilant efforts, previously shown in battle, being applied equally at home to manage the market and secure grain supplies. An interregnum occurred this year, although the reasons weren’t stated. Appius Claudius, followed by Publius Sulpicius, served as interreges. The latter conducted consul elections, appointing Lucius Cornelius Scipio and Cneius Fulvius. At the start of this year, ambassadors arrived from the Lucanians to the new consuls, complaining that “the Samnites, finding it impossible to entice us into the war through offers, had marched an army into our land with hostility, destroying it and forcing us into conflict; that the Lucanian people had already made enough mistakes in the past; that we were so determined that we would rather endure any hardship than dishonor the Roman name again: we request the senate to protect Lucania and shield us from the Samnite aggression; although loyalty to the Romans will now be essential with war against the Samnites on the table, we are still ready to provide hostages.”

12

The deliberation of the senate was short. They all, to a man, concurred in opinion, that a compact should be entered into with the Lucanians, and satisfaction demanded from the Samnites: accordingly, a favourable answer was returned to the Lucanians, and the alliance concluded. Heralds were then sent, to require of the Samnites, that they should depart from the country of the allies, and withdraw their troops from the Lucanian territory. These were met by persons despatched for the purpose by the Samnites, who gave them warning, that "if they appeared at any assembly in Samnium, they must not expect to depart in safety." As soon as this was heard at Rome, the senate voted, and the people ordered, that war should be declared against the Samnites. The consuls, then, dividing the provinces between them, Etruria fell to Scipio, the Samnites to Fulvius; and they set out by different routes, each against the enemy allotted to him. Scipio, while he expected a tedious campaign, like that of the preceding year, was met near Volaterra by the Etrurians, in order of battle. The fight lasted through the greater part of the day, while very many fell on both sides, and night came on while it was uncertain to which side victory inclined. But the following dawn showed the conqueror and the vanquished; for the Etrurians had decamped in the dead of the night. The Romans, marching out with intent to renew the engagement, and seeing their superiority acknowledged by the departure of the enemy, advanced to their camp; and, finding even this fortified post deserted, took possession of it, evacuated as it was, together with a vast quantity of spoil. The consul then, leading back his forces into the Faliscian territory, and leaving his baggage with a small guard at Falerii, set out with his troops, lightly accoutred, to ravage the enemy's country. All places are destroyed with fire and sword; plunder driven from every side; and not only was the ground left a mere waste to the enemy, but their forts and small towns were set on fire; he refrained from attacking the cities into which fear had driven the Etrurians. The consul Cneius Fulvius fought a glorious battle in Samnium, near Bovianum, attended with success by no means equivocal. Then, having attacked Bovianum, and not long after Aufidena, he took them by storm.

The Senate's discussion was brief. Everyone agreed that a deal should be made with the Lucanians and that they should demand compensation from the Samnites. So, they responded positively to the Lucanians and established an alliance. Messengers were sent to demand that the Samnites leave the allies' territory and withdraw their troops from Lucanian lands. These messengers were met by representatives sent by the Samnites, who warned them that "if they showed up at any meeting in Samnium, they shouldn't expect to leave safely." Once this news reached Rome, the Senate voted, and the people decided to declare war on the Samnites. The consuls then divided the territories between them: Scipio took Etruria, and Fulvius took the Samnites, and they set out on different routes to confront their assigned enemies. Scipio, expecting a long campaign like the previous year, encountered the Etrurians near Volaterra, ready for battle. The fight lasted most of the day, with many casualties on both sides, and night fell while the outcome remained uncertain. However, the next morning revealed the victor and the defeated, as the Etrurians had slipped away during the night. The Romans, intending to renew the fight, saw the enemy's retreat as a sign of their victory and advanced to their camp. Discovering this fortified position abandoned, they took control of it, along with a substantial amount of loot. The consul then led his forces back into Faliscian territory, leaving his supplies guarded in Falerii. He set out with his troops, lightly equipped, to raid the enemy’s lands. They devastated everything with fire and sword; plundering from all sides, leaving the enemy's land utterly destroyed, and setting fire to their forts and small towns. He chose not to attack the cities, where the Etrurians had fled in fear. Consul Cneius Fulvius fought a significant battle in Samnium, near Bovianum, achieving a highly successful outcome. After successfully attacking Bovianum, he quickly followed up with an assault on Aufidena and captured it as well.

This year a colony was carried out to Carseoli, into the territory of the Aequicolae. The consul Fulvius triumphed on his defeat of the Samnites.

This year, a settlement was established in Carseoli, in the land of the Aequicolae. The consul Fulvius celebrated a triumph after defeating the Samnites.

13

When the consular elections were now at hand, a report prevailed, that the Etrurians and Samnites were raising vast armies; that the leaders of the Etrurians were, in all their assemblies, openly censured for not having procured the aid of the Gauls on any terms; and the magistrates of the Samnites arraigned, for having opposed to the Romans an army destined to act against the Lucanians. That, in consequence, the people were rising up in arms, with all their own strength and that of their allies combined; and that this affair seemed not likely to be terminated without a contest of much greater difficulty than the former. Although the candidates for the consulship were men of illustrious characters, yet this alarming intelligence turned the thoughts of all on Quintus Fabius Maximus, who sought not the employment at first, and afterwards, when he discovered their wishes, even declined it. "Why," said he, "should they impose such a difficult task on him, who was now in the decline of life, and had passed through a full course of labours, and of the rewards of labour? Neither the vigour of his body, nor of his mind, remained the same; and he dreaded fortune herself, lest to some god she should seem too bountiful to him, and more constant than the course of human affairs allowed. He had himself succeeded, in gradual succession, to the dignities of his seniors; and he beheld, with great satisfaction, others rising up to succeed to his glory. There was no scarcity at Rome, either of honours suited to men of the highest merit, or of men of eminent merit suited to the highest honours." This disinterested conduct, instead of repressing, increased, while in fact it justified their zeal. But thinking that this ought to be checked by respect for the laws, he ordered that clause to be read aloud by which it was not lawful that the same person shall be re-elected consul within ten years. The law was scarcely heard in consequence of the clamour; and the tribunes of the commons declared, that this "decree should be no impediment; for they would propose an order to the people, that he should be exempted from the obligation of the laws." Still he persisted in his opposition, asking, "To what purpose were laws enacted, if they eluded by the very persons who procured them? The laws now," he said, "instead of being rulers, were overruled." The people, nevertheless, proceeded to vote; and, according as each century was called in, it immediately named Fabius consul. Then at length, overcome by the universal wish of the state, he said, "Romans, may the gods approve your present, and all your future proceedings. But since, with respect to me, ye intend to act according to your own wills, let my interest find room with you, with respect to my colleague. I earnestly request, that ye will place in the consulship with me Publius Decius; a man with whom I have already experienced the utmost harmony in our joint administration of that office; a man worthy of you, worthy of his father." The recommendation was deemed well founded, and all the remaining centuries voted Quintus Fabius and Publius Decius consuls. This year, great numbers were prosecuted by the aediles, for having in possession larger quantities of land than the state allowed; and hardly any were acquitted: by which means, a very great restraint was laid on exorbitant covetousness.

When the consular elections were approaching, a report circulated that the Etrurians and Samnites were gathering large armies. The leaders of the Etrurians faced criticism in all their meetings for not securing the help of the Gauls under any conditions, while the magistrates of the Samnites were blamed for directing an army against the Romans to fight the Lucanians. Consequently, the people were rising up in arms, combining their strength with that of their allies. This situation seemed unlikely to end without a conflict much more challenging than previous ones. Although the candidates for the consulship were highly regarded individuals, this alarming news shifted everyone's focus to Quintus Fabius Maximus, who initially did not seek the position and later declined it when he realized their intentions. "Why," he said, "should they assign such a tough task to someone who is now in the twilight of life, having already gone through extensive labor and enjoyed the rewards of that labor? Neither my physical nor my mental strength is what it used to be, and I fear fortune herself, lest she appear too generous toward me and more consistent than fate allows." He had gradually succeeded to the honors held by his predecessors and took great satisfaction in watching others rise to inherit his glory. There was no shortage in Rome of honors appropriate for the most deserving individuals, nor of capable men deserving of the highest honors. This selfless attitude didn't suppress their enthusiasm; instead, it justified it. Believing this should be tempered by respect for the laws, he had the law read aloud stating that no one could be re-elected consul within ten years. The law was barely audible amid the uproar, and the tribunes of the commons declared that this "decree should pose no barrier; they would propose to the people that he be exempt from the law's requirements." Yet he continued to resist, asking, "What purpose do laws serve if they can be bypassed by those who enacted them? The laws now," he said, "are no longer rulers, but rather are being overruled." Nonetheless, the people moved forward to vote; as each century was called, they promptly named Fabius consul. Finally, overwhelmed by the collective will of the state, he stated, "Romans, may the gods bless your current and future actions. But since you wish to proceed according to your desires regarding me, I ask that you consider my interests in relation to my colleague. I sincerely request that you appoint Publius Decius as my co-consul; a man with whom I have already shared great harmony in our joint administration of that office; a man worthy of you and of his father." This recommendation was viewed favorably, and all the remaining centuries elected Quintus Fabius and Publius Decius as consuls. That year, many were prosecuted by the aediles for possessing more land than the state allowed, and hardly anyone was acquitted, thereby imposing significant restrictions on excessive greed.

14

Whilst the new consuls, Quintus Fabius Maximus a fourth, and Publius Decius Mus a third time, were settling between themselves that one should command against the Samnites, and the other against the Etrurians; and what number of forces would be sufficient for this and for that province; and which would be the fitter commander in each war; ambassadors from Sutrium, Nepete, and Falerii, stating that the states of Etruria were holding assemblies on the subject of suing for peace, they directed the whole force of their arms against Samnium. The consuls, in order that the supply of provisions might be the more ready, and to leave the enemy in the greater uncertainty on what quarter the war would fall, Fabius led his legions towards Samnium through the territory of Sora, and Decius his through that of Sidicinum. As soon as they arrived at the frontiers of the enemy, both advanced briskly, spreading devastation wherever they came; but still they explore the country, to a distance beyond where the troops were employed in plundering. Accordingly the fact did not escape the notice of the Romans, that the enemy were drawn up in a retired valley, near Tifernum, which, when the Romans entered, they were preparing to attack them from the higher ground. Fabius, sending away his baggage to a place of safety, and setting a small guard over it, and having given notice to his soldiers that a battle was at hand, advanced in a square body to the hiding-place of the enemy already mentioned. The Samnites, disappointed in making an unexpected attack, determined on a regular engagement, as the matter was now likely to come to an open contest. They therefore marched out into the plain; and, with a greater share of spirit than of hopes, committed themselves to the disposal of fortune. However, whether in consequence of their having drawn together, from every state, the whole of the force which it possessed, or that the consideration of their all being at stake, heightened their courage, they occasioned, even in open fight, a considerable alarm. Fabius, when he saw that the enemy in no place gave way, ordered Marcus Fulvius and Marcus Valerius, military tribunes, with whom he hastened to the front, to go to the cavalry, and to exhort them, that, "if they remembered any instance wherein the public had received advantage from the service of the horsemen, they would, on that day, exert themselves to insure the invincible renown of that body; telling them that the enemy stood immovable against the efforts of the infantry, and the only hope remaining was in the charge of horse." He addressed particularly both these youths, and with the same cordiality, loading them with praises and promises. But considering that, in case that effort should also fail, it would be necessary to accomplish by stratagem what his strength could not effect; he ordered Scipio, one of his lieutenants-general, to draw off the spearmen of the first legion out of the line; to lead them round as secretly as possible to the nearest mountains; and, by an ascent concealed from view, to gain the heights, and show himself suddenly on the rear of the enemy. The cavalry, led on by the tribunes, rushing forward unexpectedly before the van, caused scarcely more confusion among the enemy than among their friends. The line of the Samnites stood firm against the furious onset of the squadrons; it neither could be driven from its ground, nor broken in any part. The cavalry, finding their attempts fruitless, withdrew from the fight, and retired behind the line of infantry. On this the enemies' courage increased, so that the Roman troops in the van would not have been able to support the contest, nor the force thus increasing by confidence in itself, had not the second line, by the consul's order, come up into the place of the first. These fresh troops checked the progress of the Samnites, who had now began to gain ground; and, at this seasonable juncture, their comrades appearing suddenly on the mountains, and raising a shout, occasioned in the Samnites a fear of greater danger than really threatened them; Fabius called out aloud that his colleague Decius was approaching; on which all the soldiers, elated with joy, repeated eagerly, that the other consul was come, the legions were arrived! This artifice, useful to the Romans, filled the Samnites with dismay and terror; terrified chiefly lest fatigued as they were, they should be overpowered by another army fresh and unhurt. As they dispersed themselves in their flight on every side, there was less effusion of blood than might have been expected, considering the completeness of the victory. There were three thousand four hundred slain, about eight hundred and thirty made prisoners, and twenty-three military standards taken.

While the new consuls, Quintus Fabius Maximus for the fourth time and Publius Decius Mus for the third time, were deciding who would lead the fight against the Samnites and who would command against the Etrurians, and determining how many troops were needed for each province and which commander would be best for each war, ambassadors from Sutrium, Nepete, and Falerii reported that the Etruscan states were holding meetings about seeking peace. They decided to focus their military efforts on Samnium. To make sure supplies were readily available and to keep the enemy guessing about where the attack would happen, Fabius led his legions toward Samnium through Sora's territory, while Decius took his through Sidicinum's lands. Once they reached the enemy’s borders, they advanced quickly, causing destruction wherever they went, but also scouting the area beyond where their troops were looting. The Romans noticed that the enemy had gathered in a secluded valley near Tifernum and were preparing to attack from higher ground. Fabius, after sending his baggage to a safe location and placing a small guard over it, informed his soldiers that a battle was imminent and moved in formation toward the hidden enemy. The Samnites, disappointed at missing a surprise attack, opted for a regular engagement since it seemed a direct confrontation was inevitable. They marched out into the open with more spirit than hope, putting themselves in the hands of chance. However, whether due to rallying their entire force from all states or the weight of their situation boosting their courage, they caused considerable alarm even in open battle. When Fabius saw that the enemy was not retreating at any point, he ordered military tribunes Marcus Fulvius and Marcus Valerius, who he rushed to the front, to rally the cavalry, urging them to remember any instances where their actions had benefitted the public, and to strive that day to secure their unit's legendary status, noting that the enemy stood firm against the infantry, and that their only hope lay in a cavalry charge. He specifically praised these two young men, showering them with encouragement and promises. However, recognizing that if this effort also failed, they would need to achieve victory by cunning, he instructed Scipio, one of his lieutenants-general, to discreetly withdraw the spearmen from the first legion and lead them as quietly as possible to the nearest mountains. He wanted them to scale the heights undetected and appear suddenly behind the enemy. The cavalry, led by the tribunes, charged forward unexpectedly and caused chaos among both the enemy and their own troops. The Samnite line held firm against the furious assault of the cavalry; it could not be pushed back or broken. Finding their attempts futile, the cavalry retreated behind the infantry line. Inspired by this, the enemy grew more courageous, and the Roman infantry in the front would have struggled to withstand the fight if the second line had not been ordered to support them. These fresh troops halted the Samnites’ progress as they began to gain ground, and just at that critical moment, their comrades suddenly appeared on the mountains and raised a shout, instilling in the Samnites a fear of greater danger than they faced. Fabius shouted that his colleague Decius was approaching, causing all the soldiers to cheer excitedly that the other consul had arrived and the legions were here! This trick, beneficial for the Romans, filled the Samnites with fear, mainly worried that they, already exhausted, would be overwhelmed by another fresh and unscathed army. As they scattered in their retreat, there was less bloodshed than one might expect given the extent of the victory. There were three thousand four hundred slain, about eight hundred thirty taken prisoner, and twenty-three military standards captured.

15

The Apulians would have joined their forces to the Samnites before this battle, had not the consul, Publius Decius, encamped in their neighbourhood at Maleventum; and, finding means to bring them to an engagement, put them to the rout. Here, likewise, there was more of flight than of bloodshed. Two thousand of the Apulians were slain; but Decius, despising such an enemy, led his legions into Samnium. There the two consular armies, overrunning every part of the country during the space of five months, laid it entirely waste. There were in Samnium forty-five places where Decius, and eighty-six where the other consul, encamped. Nor did they leave traces only of having been there, as ramparts and trenches, but other dreadful mementos of it--general desolation and regions depopulated. Fabius also took the city of Cimetra, where he made prisoners two thousand four hundred soldiers; and there were slain in the assault about four hundred and thirty. Going thence to Rome to preside at the elections, he used all expedition in despatching that business. All the first-called centuries voted Quintus Fabius consul. Appius Claudius was a candidate, a man of consular rank, daring and ambitious; and as he wished not more ardently for the attainment of that honour for himself, than he did that the patricians might recover the possession of both places in the consulship, he laboured, with all his own power, supported by that of the whole body of the nobility, to prevail on them to appoint him consul along with Quintus Fabius. To this Fabius objected, giving, at first, the same reasons which he had advanced the year before. The nobles then all gathered round his seat, and besought him to raise up the consulship out of the plebeian mire, and to restore both to the office itself, and to the patrician rank, their original dignity. Fabius then, procuring silence, allayed their warmth by a qualifying speech, declaring, that "he would have so managed, as to have received the names of two patricians, if he had seen an intention of appointing any other than himself to the consulship. As things now stood, he would not set so bad a precedent as to admit his own name among the candidates; such a proceeding being contrary to the laws." Whereupon Appius Claudius, and Lucius Volumnius, a plebeian, who had likewise been colleagues in that office before, were elected consuls. The nobility reproached Fabius for declining to act in conjunction with Appius Claudius, because he evidently excelled him in eloquence and political abilities.

The Apulians would have joined forces with the Samnites before this battle if the consul, Publius Decius, hadn’t camped nearby at Maleventum. By finding a way to engage them, he routed them. Here, there was more of a flight than bloodshed. Two thousand Apulians were killed, but Decius, looking down on such an enemy, led his legions into Samnium. There, the two consular armies, ravaging every part of the land for five months, completely devastated it. In Samnium, Decius camped in forty-five places, while the other consul camped in eighty-six. They didn’t just leave behind signs of their presence, like ramparts and trenches, but also left behind terrible reminders—general destruction and depopulated regions. Fabius also captured the city of Cimetra, where he took two thousand four hundred soldiers prisoner; around four hundred and thirty were killed in the assault. After that, he headed to Rome to oversee the elections, rushing to finish that task. All the first-called centuries voted for Quintus Fabius as consul. Appius Claudius, a candidate of consular rank, was bold and ambitious. He desired not only the honor for himself but also wanted the patricians to regain both consul positions, so he worked hard, backed by the entire nobility, to have them choose him as consul alongside Quintus Fabius. Fabius opposed this, initially giving the same reasons he’d stated the year before. The nobles then gathered around him, urging him to elevate the consulship from the plebeian muck and restore the original dignity of both the office and the patrician rank. Fabius then called for silence, calming their fervor with a measured speech, saying that if he had seen any intention to appoint anyone other than himself to the consulship, he would have made sure that two patricians' names were considered. As things stood, he wouldn’t set a bad precedent by including his name among the candidates, as that would go against the laws. Following this, Appius Claudius and Lucius Volumnius, a plebeian who had also been a colleague in that office before, were elected consuls. The nobility criticized Fabius for refusing to work with Appius Claudius, as he was clearly superior in eloquence and political skills.

16

When the election was finished, the former consuls, their command being continued for six months, were ordered to prosecute the war in Samnium. Accordingly, during this next year also, in the consulate of Lucius Volumnius and Appius Claudius, Publius Decius, who had been left consul in Samnium by his colleague, in the character of proconsul, ceased not to spread devastation through all parts of that country; until, at last, he drove the army of the Samnites, which never dared to face him in the field, entirely out of the country. Thus expelled from home, they bent their route to Etruria; and, supposing that the business, which they had often in vain endeavoured to accomplish by embassies, might now be negotiated with more effect, when they were backed by such a powerful armed force, and could intermix terror with their entreaties, they demanded a meeting of the chiefs of Etruria: which being assembled, they set forth the great number of years during which they had waged war with the Romans, in the cause of liberty; "they had," they said, "tried to sustain, with their own strength, the weight of so great a war: they had also made trial of the support of the adjoining nations, which proved of little avail. When they were unable longer to maintain the conflict, they had sued the Roman people for peace; and had again taken up arms, because they felt peace was more grievous to those with servitude, than war to free men. That their one only hope remaining rested in the Etrurians. They knew that nation to be the most powerful in Italy, in respect of arms, men, and money; to have the Gauls their closest neighbours, born in the midst of war and arms, of furious courage, both from their natural temper, and particularly against the people of Rome, whom they boasted, without infringing the truth, of having made their prisoners, and of having ransomed for gold. If the Etrurians possessed the same spirit which formerly Porsena and their ancestors once had, there was nothing to prevent their obliging the Romans, driven from all the lands on this side of the Tiber, to fight for their own existence, and not for the intolerable dominion which they assumed over Italy. The Samnite army had come to them, in readiness for action, furnished with arms and pay, and were willing to follow that instant, even should they lead to the attack of the city of Rome itself."

When the election was over, the former consuls, whose term was extended for six months, were ordered to continue the war in Samnium. So, during the following year, in the consulship of Lucius Volumnius and Appius Claudius, Publius Decius, who had been left as consul in Samnium by his colleague in the role of proconsul, kept causing destruction throughout the region until he finally drove the Samnite army, which never dared to confront him in battle, completely out of the territory. Driven from their homeland, they headed to Etruria and thought that the matters they had unsuccessfully tried to resolve through diplomatic means might now be addressed more effectively with the support of such a strong military force, combining fear with their requests. They called for a meeting of the Etruscan leaders. When they gathered, the Samnites presented the long years they had fought against the Romans for their freedom; they claimed they had tried to handle the burden of such a massive war on their own. They also sought the help of neighboring nations, which proved to be of little help. When they could no longer continue the fight, they had sought peace with the Roman people; yet, they had taken up arms again because they believed that living in peace under oppression was more unbearable than fighting as free men. Their only remaining hope rested with the Etruscans. They recognized that this nation was the most powerful in Italy regarding military strength, manpower, and resources; they had the Gauls as their closest neighbors, known for their fierce courage, both from their nature and especially against the Romans, whom they claimed, without exaggeration, to have captured and ransomed for gold. If the Etruscans had the same resolve as Porsena and their ancestors once did, nothing could stop them from forcing the Romans, pushed out from all the lands on this side of the Tiber River, to fight for their survival instead of for the intolerable control they exerted over Italy. The Samnite army had come ready for action, equipped with weapons and pay, and was willing to follow immediately, even if it meant attacking the city of Rome itself.

17

While they were engaged in these representations, and intriguing at Etruria, the operations of the Romans in their own territories distressed them severely. For Publius Decius, when he ascertained through his scouts the departure of the Samnite army, called a council, and there said, "Why do we ramble through the country, carrying the war from village to village? Why not attack the cities and fortified places? No army now guards Samnium. They have fled their country; they are gone into voluntary exile." The proposal being universally approved, he marched to attack Murgantia, a city of considerable strength; and so great was the ardour of the soldiers, resulting from their affection to their commander, and from their hopes of richer treasure than could be found in pillaging the country places, that in one day they took it by assault. Here, two thousand one hundred of the Samnites, making resistance, were surrounded and taken prisoners; and abundance of other spoil was captured. Decius, not choosing that the troops should be encumbered in their march with heavy baggage, ordered them to be called together, and said to them, "Do ye intend to rest satisfied with this single victory, and this booty? or do ye choose to cherish hopes proportioned to your bravery? All the cities of the Samnites, and the property left in them, are your own; since, after so often defeating their legions, ye have finally driven them out of the country. Sell those effects in your hands; and allure traders, by a prospect of profit, to follow you on your march. I will, from time to time, supply you with goods for sale. Let us go hence to the city of Romulea, where no greater labour, but greater gain awaits you." Having sold off the spoil, and warmly adopting the general's plan, they proceeded to Romulea. There, also, without works or engines, as soon as the battalions approached, the soldiers, deterred from the walls by no resistance, hastily applying ladders wherever was most convenient to each, they mounted the fortifications. The town was taken and plundered. Two thousand three hundred men were slain, six thousand taken prisoners, and the soldiers obtained abundance of spoil. This they were obliged to sell in like manner as the former; and, though no rest was allowed them, they proceeded, nevertheless, with the utmost alacrity to Ferentinum. But here they met a greater share both of difficulty and danger: the fortifications were defended with the utmost vigour, and the place was strongly fortified both by nature and art. However, the soldiers, now inured to plunder, overcame every obstacle. Three thousand of the enemy were killed round the walls, and the spoil was given to the troops. In some annals, the principal share of the honour of taking these cities is attributed to Maximus. They say that Murgantia was taken by Decius; Romulea and Ferentinum by Fabius. Some ascribe this honour to the new consuls: others not to both, but to one of these, Lucius Volumnius: that to him the province of Samnium had fallen.

While they were busy with these negotiations in Etruria, the Romans were causing them serious trouble back home. Publius Decius, after learning from his scouts that the Samnite army had left, called for a council and said, "Why are we wandering around the countryside, taking the war from one village to another? Why not attack the cities and strongholds? No army is guarding Samnium. They have abandoned their land; they are in voluntary exile." His proposal received unanimous approval, and he set out to attack Murgantia, a strong city. The soldiers, motivated by their love for their commander and the promise of greater treasure than what they could find by looting the countryside, captured it in one day. Here, two thousand one hundred Samnites who resisted were surrounded and taken prisoner, and they collected a large amount of loot. Decius, not wanting the troops to be weighed down with heavy baggage, gathered them together and said, "Are you satisfied with just this one victory and this loot? Or do you want to aim for even greater rewards based on your bravery? All the cities of the Samnites and the property left in them are yours; after repeatedly defeating their legions, you have finally driven them from their country. Sell what you have, and entice traders with the promise of profit to follow you on your march. I will periodically provide you with goods to sell. Let’s head to the city of Romulea, where you'll find less effort but greater reward." After selling the captured goods and fully supporting the general's plan, they proceeded to Romulea. There, without the need for siege works or machines, as soon as the battalions arrived, the soldiers quickly used ladders at the easiest spots and climbed the walls. The town was taken and looted. Two thousand three hundred men were killed, six thousand were captured, and the soldiers gained a lot of spoils. They had to sell this loot just like the last, and even without rest, they continued eagerly to Ferentinum. However, this city presented greater challenges and dangers: the fortifications were defended fiercely, and the location was strongly fortified by both nature and design. Yet, the soldiers, now accustomed to plunder, overcame every obstacle. Three thousand enemies were killed around the walls, and the spoils were given to the troops. In some records, the credit for capturing these cities is mainly given to Maximus. They say Decius captured Murgantia; Fabius took Romulea and Ferentinum. Some attribute this honor to the new consuls; others, not both but just one of them, Lucius Volumnius, who was assigned the province of Samnium.

18

While things went on thus in Samnium, whoever it was that had the command and auspices, powerful combination, composed of many states, was formed in Etruria against the Romans, the chief promoter of which was Gellius Egnatius, a Samnite. Almost all the Etrurians had united in this war. The neighbouring states of Umbria were drawn in, as it were, by the contagion; and auxiliaries were procured from the Gauls for hire: all their several numbers assembled at the camp of the Samnites. When intelligence of this sudden commotion was received at Rome, after the consul, Lucius Volumnius, had already set out for Samnium, with the second and third legions, and fifteen thousand of the allies; it was, therefore, resolved, that Appius Claudius should, at the very earliest opportunity, go into Etruria. Two Roman legions followed him, the first and fourth, and twelve thousand allies; their camp was pitched at a small distance from the enemy. However, advantage was gained by his early arrival in this particular, that the awe of the Roman name kept in check some states of Etruria which were disposed to war, rather than from any judicious or successful enterprise achieved under the guidance of the consul. Several battles were fought, at times and places unfavourable, and increasing confidence rendered the enemy daily more formidable; so that matters came nearly to such a state, as that neither could the soldiers rely much on their leader, nor the leader on his soldiers. It appears in three several histories, that a letter was sent by the consul to call his colleague from Samnium. But I will not affirm what requires stronger proof, as that point was a matter of dispute between these two consuls of the Roman people, a second time associated in the same office; Appius denying that the letter was sent, and Volumnius affirming that he was called thither by a letter from Appius. Volumnius had, by this time, taken three forts in Samnium, in which three thousand of the enemy had been slain, and about half that number made prisoners; and, a sedition having been raised among the Lucanians by the plebeians and the more indigent of the people, he had, to the great satisfaction of the nobles, quelled it by sending thither Quintus Fabius, proconsul, with his own veteran army. He left to Decius the ravaging of the enemy's country; and proceeded with his troops into Etruria to his colleague; where, on his arrival, the whole army received him with joy. Appius, if he did not write the letter, being conscious of this, had, in my opinion, just ground of displeasure; but if he had actually stood in need of assistance, his disowning it, as he did, arose from an illiberal and ungrateful mind. For, on going out to receive him, when they had scarcely exchanged salutations, he said, "Is all well, Lucius Volumnius? How stand affairs in Samnium? What motive induced you to remove out of your province?" Volumnius answered, that "affairs in Samnium were in a prosperous state; and that he had come thither in compliance with the request in his letter. But, if that were a forged letter, and that there was no occasion for him in Etruria, he would instantly face about, and depart." "You may depart." replied the other; "no one detains you: for it is a perfect inconsistency, that when, perhaps, you are scarcely equal to the management of your own war, you should vaunt of coming hither to succour others." To this Volumnius rejoined, "May Hercules direct all for the best; for his part, he was better pleased that he had taken useless trouble, than that any conjuncture should have arisen which had made one consular army insufficient for Etruria."

While things were happening like this in Samnium, whoever was in charge and had the omens, a powerful alliance made up of several states formed in Etruria against the Romans, with Gellius Egnatius, a Samnite, as the main instigator. Almost all of Etruria joined this war. The neighboring states of Umbria were caught up in it, and they even brought in mercenaries from the Gauls; all their forces gathered at the Samnite camp. When news of this sudden activity reached Rome, after the consul, Lucius Volumnius, had already left for Samnium with the second and third legions and fifteen thousand allies, it was decided that Appius Claudius should head to Etruria as soon as possible. He was followed by two Roman legions, the first and fourth, along with twelve thousand allies; they set up camp not far from the enemy. His early arrival helped in one way: the fear of the Roman name kept some Etruscan states in check that were inclined to fight, more than any clever or successful action taken by the consul. Several battles were fought at unfavorable times and places, and the enemy grew more confident daily, making them increasingly formidable; the situation almost reached a point where neither the soldiers trusted their leader nor the leader had confidence in his soldiers. It is noted in three different accounts that the consul sent a letter requesting his colleague come from Samnium. However, I won't assert what needs stronger evidence, as this was a contentious issue between the two consuls of the Roman people who were serving together again; Appius denied sending the letter, while Volumnius claimed he came because of a letter from Appius. By this time, Volumnius had captured three forts in Samnium, killing three thousand enemies and capturing about half that number. A revolt had broken out among the Lucanians led by the plebeians and the poorer class, and he successfully quelled it, much to the satisfaction of the nobles, by sending Quintus Fabius, proconsul, with his own veteran army. He left Decius in charge of ravaging the enemy's territory and headed with his troops to Etruria to join his colleague, where, upon arriving, the entire army greeted him joyfully. Appius, whether he wrote the letter or not, had just reason to be displeased; but if he truly needed help, his denial stemmed from a petty and ungrateful mindset. When he went out to greet Volumnius, they had barely exchanged pleasantries when he asked, "Is everything okay, Lucius Volumnius? How are things in Samnium? What made you leave your province?" Volumnius replied that "things in Samnium were going well, and he had come here at the request in the letter. But if that was a fake letter and he was not needed in Etruria, he would turn around and leave immediately." "You can leave," replied Appius; "no one is stopping you. It's quite absurd that, perhaps, you can hardly manage your own war and yet you brag about coming here to assist others." To this, Volumnius responded, "May Hercules guide everything to a good outcome; for his part, he was glad to have taken unnecessary trouble rather than having any situation arise that would make one consular army insufficient for Etruria."

19

As the consuls were parting, the lieutenants-general and tribunes of Appius's army gathered round them. Some entreated their own general that he would not reject the voluntary offer of his colleague's assistance, which ought to have been solicited in the first instance: the greater number used their endeavours to stop Volumnius, beseeching him "not, through a peevish dispute with his colleague, to abandon the interest of the commonwealth; and represented to him, that in case any misfortune should happen, the blame would fall on the person who forsook the other, not on the one forsaken; that the state of affairs was such, that the credit and discredit of every success and failure in Etruria would be attributed to Lucius Volumnius: for no one would inquire, what were the words of Appius, but what the situation of the army. Appius indeed had dismissed him, but the commonwealth, and the army, required his stay. Let him only make trial of the inclinations of the soldiers." By such admonitions and entreaties they, in a manner, dragged the consuls, who almost resisted, to an assembly. There, longer discourses were made to the same purport, as had passed before in the presence of a few. And when Volumnius, who had the advantage of the argument, showed himself not deficient in oratory, in despite of the extraordinary eloquence of his colleague; Appius observed with a sneer, that "they ought to acknowledge themselves indebted to him, in having a consul who possessed eloquence also, instead of being dumb and speechless, when in their former consulate, particularly during the first months, he was not able so much as to open his lips; but now, in his harangues, even aspired after popularity." Volumnius replied, "How much more earnestly do I wish, that you had learned from me to act with spirit, than I from you to speak with elegance: that now he made a final proposal, which would determine, not which is the better orator, for that is not what the public wants, but which is the better commander. The provinces are Etruria and Samnium: that he might select which he preferred; that he, with his own army, will undertake to manage the business either in Etruria or in Samnium." The soldiers then, with loud clamours, requested that they would, in conjunction, carry on the war in Etruria; when Volumnius perceiving that it was the general wish, said, "Since I have been mistaken in apprehending my colleague's meaning, I will take care that there shall be no room for mistake with respect to the purport of your wishes. Signify by a shout whether you choose that I should stay or depart." On this, a shout was raised, so loud, that it brought the enemy out of their camp: they snatched up their arms, and marched down in order of battle. Volumnius likewise ordered the signal to be sounded, and the standard to be advanced from the camp. It is said that Appius hesitated, perceiving that, whether he fought or remained inactive, his colleague would have the victory; and that, afterwards, dreading lest his own legions also should follow Volumnius, he also gave the signal, at the earnest desire of his men. On neither side were the forces drawn up to advantage; for, on the one, Gellius Egnatius, the Samnite general, had gone out to forage with a few cohorts, and his men entered on the fight as the violence of their passions prompted, rather than under any directions or orders. On the other, the Roman armies neither marched out together, nor had time sufficient to form: Volumnius began to engage before Appius came up to the enemy, consequently the engagement commenced, their front in the battle being uneven; and by some accidental interchange of their usual opponents, the Etrurians fought against Volumnius; and the Samnites, after delaying some time on account of the absence of their general, against Appius. We are told that Appius, during the heat of the fight, raising his hands toward heaven, so as to be seen in the foremost ranks, prayed thus, "Bellona, if thou grantest us the victory this day, I vow to thee a temple." And that after this vow, as if inspirited by the goddess, he displayed a degree of courage equal to that of his colleague and of the troops. The generals performed every duty, and each of their armies exerted, with emulation, its utmost vigour, lest victory should commence on the other side. They therefore routed and put to flight the enemy, who were ill able to withstand a force so much superior to any with which they had been accustomed to contend: then pressing them as they gave ground, and pursuing them closely as they fled, they drove them into their camp. There, by the interposition of Gellius and his Samnite cohorts, the fight was renewed for a little time. But these being likewise soon dispersed, the camp was now stormed by the conquerors; and whilst Volumnius, in person, led his troops against one of the gates, Appius, frequently invoking Bellona the victorious, inflamed the courage of his men, they broke in through the rampart and trenches. The camp was taken and plundered, and an abundance of spoil was found, and given up to the soldiers. Of the enemy seven thousand three hundred were slain; and two thousand one hundred and twenty taken.

As the consuls were leaving, the lieutenant generals and tribunes of Appius's army gathered around them. Some urged their general not to turn down the voluntary offer of help from his colleague, which should have been requested from the start. The majority tried to convince Volumnius, pleading with him “not to let a petty disagreement with his colleague endanger the commonwealth; and they pointed out that if something went wrong, the blame would fall on the one who abandoned the other, not on the one who was abandoned; that the current situation was such that the success or failure in Etruria would be attributed to Lucius Volumnius: no one would ask what Appius had said, only about the state of the army. Appius may have dismissed him, but the commonwealth and the army needed him to stay. He should just test the soldiers' feelings.” Through such urgings and appeals, they virtually dragged the consuls, who were nearly resisting, to a meeting. There, longer discussions were held, echoing what had been said earlier in front of only a few. And when Volumnius, who had the upper hand in the debate, proved himself good at speaking despite his colleague’s impressive eloquence, Appius sneered, saying “they should be thankful to him for having a consul who could speak well, instead of being mute and speechless, as he had been during his earlier term, especially in the first months, when he couldn’t even manage to say a word; but now, in his speeches, he was actually trying to gain popularity.” Volumnius responded, “I wish even more that you had learned from me to act decisively than I from you to speak eloquently: now I'm making a final offer, which will determine not who is the better speaker—because that’s not what the public cares about—but who is the better commander. The territories are Etruria and Samnium: choose which one you prefer; I, with my army, will take care of the situation either in Etruria or in Samnium.” The soldiers then loudly demanded that they fight together in Etruria; when Volumnius saw that this was what everyone wanted, he said, “Since I misunderstood my colleague’s intentions, I will ensure there’s no misunderstanding about what you want. Shout out whether you want me to stay or go.” At this, a shout arose so loud that it drew the enemy out of their camp: they grabbed their weapons and formed up for battle. Volumnius also ordered the signal to be sounded and the standard raised from the camp. It’s said that Appius hesitated, realizing that whether he fought or did nothing, his colleague would come out ahead; and later, fearing that his own legions might follow Volumnius, he too signaled to advance, at the strong request of his men. Neither side had their forces positioned well; on one side, Gellius Egnatius, the Samnite general, had gone out to forage with a few cohorts, and his troops engaged in the fight fueled by passion rather than orders. On the other side, the Roman armies neither marched out together nor formed properly in time; Volumnius began to engage before Appius arrived at the enemy, thus the battle began with an uneven front; and due to some accidental exchanges of their usual opponents, the Etrurians fought against Volumnius; and the Samnites, after delaying due to their general’s absence, faced Appius. It’s reported that during the heat of the battle, Appius raised his hands to heaven, making himself visible among the front lines, and prayed, “Bellona, if you grant us victory today, I vow to build you a temple.” After this vow, seemingly inspired by the goddess, he showed a level of courage equal to that of his colleague and the troops. The generals performed all their duties, and each of their armies exerted their utmost strength, eager not to let victory favor the other side. Therefore, they defeated and routed the enemy, who were poorly equipped to handle such a superior force: then pressing hard as the enemy retreated, they chased them back into their camp. There, with Gellius and his Samnite cohorts intervening, the fighting resumed briefly. But these were soon scattered as well, and the camp was stormed by the victors; as Volumnius personally led his troops against one of the gates, Appius, often calling on Bellona the victorious, rallied his men, and they broke through the walls and trenches. The camp was captured and looted, and ample spoils were found and given to the soldiers. Seven thousand three hundred of the enemy were killed, and two thousand one hundred twenty were taken prisoner.

20

While both the consuls, with the whole force of the Romans, pointed their exertions principally against the war in Etruria, a new army which arose in Samnium, with design to ravage the frontiers of the Roman empire, passed over through the country of the Vescians, into the Campanian and Falernian territories, and committed great depredations. Volumnius, as he was hastening back to Samnium, by forced marches, because the term for which Fabius and Decius had been continued in command was nearly expired, heard of this army of Samnites, and of the mischief which they had done in Campania; determining, therefore, to afford protection to the allies, he altered his route towards that quarter. When he arrived in the district of Gales, he found marks of their recent ravages; and the people of Gales informed him that the enemy carried with them such a quantity of spoil, that they could scarcely observe any order in their march: and that the commanders then directed publicly that the troops should go immediately to Samnium, and having deposited the booty there, that they should return to the business of the expedition, as they must not commit to the hazard of an engagement an army so heavily laden. Notwithstanding that this account carried every appearance of truth, he yet thought it necessary to obtain more certain information; accordingly he despatched some horsemen, to seize on some of the straggling marauders; from these he learned, on inquiry, that the enemy lay at the river Vulturnus; that they intended to remove thence at the third watch; and that their route was towards Samnium. On receiving this intelligence, which could be depended upon, he set out, and sat down at such a distance from the enemy, that his approach could not be discovered by his being too near them, and, at the same time, that he might surprise them, as they should be coming out of their camp. A long time before day, he drew nigh to their post, and sent persons, who understood the Oscan language, to discover how they were employed: these, mixing with the enemy, which they could easily do during the confusion in the night, found that the standards had gone out thinly attended; that the booty, and those appointed to guard it, were then setting out, a contemptible train; each busied about his own affairs, without any concert with the rest, or much regard to orders. This was judged the fittest time for the attack, and daylight was now approaching; he gave orders to sound the charge, and fell on the enemy as they were marching out. The Samnites being embarrassed with the spoil, and very few armed, some quickened their pace, and drove the prey before them; others halted, deliberating whether it would be safer to advance, or to return again to the camp; and while they hesitated, they were overtaken and cut off. The Romans had by this time passed over the rampart, and filled the camp with slaughter and confusion: the Samnite army, in addition to the disorder caused by the enemy, had their disorder increased by a sudden insurrection of their prisoners; some of whom, getting loose, set the rest at liberty, while others snatched the arms which were tied up among the baggage, and being intermixed with the troops, raised a tumult more terrible than the battle itself. They then performed a memorable exploit: for making an attack on Statius Minacius, the general, as he was passing between the ranks and encouraging his men; then, dispersing the horsemen who attended him, they gathered round himself, and dragged him, sitting on his horse, a prisoner to the Roman consul. By this movement the foremost battalions of the Samnites were brought back, and the battle, which seemed to have been already decided, was renewed: but they could not support it long. Six thousand of them were slain, and two thousand five hundred taken, among whom were four military tribunes, together with thirty standards, and, what gave the conquerors greater joy than all, seven thousand four hundred prisoners were recovered. The spoil which had been taken from the allies was immense, and the owners were summoned by a proclamation, to claim and receive then property. On the day appointed, all the effects, the owners of which did not appear, were given to the soldiers, who were obliged to sell them, in order that they might have nothing to think of but their duty.

While both consuls focused their efforts mainly on the war in Etruria, a new army from Samnium emerged with plans to raid the borders of the Roman Empire. They crossed through the territory of the Vescians and entered Campania and Falernum, causing significant destruction. Volumnius, hurrying back to Samnium with forced marches because the command term for Fabius and Decius was about to expire, learned about this Samnite army and the damage they inflicted on Campania. Determined to protect the allies, he changed his route towards that area. When he reached the Gales region, he found evidence of their recent devastation, and the people of Gales informed him that the enemy was carrying so much loot that they could barely maintain order in their march. Their commanders had publicly instructed the troops to head straight to Samnium to drop off the plunder and then return to their mission, as they couldn’t risk engaging in battle with such a heavily loaded army. Although this report seemed credible, Volumnius felt it was necessary to gather more accurate information. He dispatched some horsemen to capture some of the wandering marauders, who revealed that the enemy was camped by the river Vulturnus and planned to leave around the third watch, heading towards Samnium. After receiving this reliable intelligence, he set out and positioned himself far enough from the enemy to avoid detection while still being close enough to catch them off guard as they left their camp. Just before dawn, he approached their position and sent men familiar with the Oscan language to see what the enemy was doing. These men blended in easily during the night’s chaos and discovered that the enemy standards were thinly attended, that the loot and the guards were just beginning to depart—a small group that was scattered and focused on their own tasks without coordination or much attention to orders. This was judged to be the perfect moment for an attack, and as daylight broke, he ordered the charge and struck the enemy as they were leaving. The Samnites, encumbered by their spoils and with very few armed, struggled with confusion; some hurried along, driving the plunder ahead of them, while others hesitated, debating whether to proceed or retreat to the camp. While they faltered, the Romans closed in and wreaked havoc, spilling over the rampart and filling the camp with chaos and carnage. The disorder among the Samnite forces was worsened by a sudden uprising of their prisoners, some of whom escaped and freed the rest, while others grabbed the weapons stashed among the baggage and mingled with the troops, creating a turmoil more frightening than the battle itself. They then achieved a remarkable feat: they attacked Statius Minacius, the general, as he moved between the ranks encouraging his men; after scattering the horsemen with him, they surrounded him and dragged him, still sitting on his horse, to the Roman consul. This action rallied the front lines of the Samnites, and the fight, which seemed to be over, reignited; however, they could not sustain it for long. Six thousand were killed, and two thousand five hundred were captured, including four military tribunes and thirty standards; more importantly, seven thousand four hundred prisoners were rescued, which brought the victors greater joy than anything else. The loot taken from the allies was substantial, and a proclamation was issued for the owners to come and reclaim their property. On the designated day, any possessions whose owners did not show up were given to the soldiers, who were required to sell them so that they could focus solely on their duties.

21

The depredations, committed on the lands of Campania, had occasioned a violent alarm at Rome, and it happened, that about the same time intelligence was brought from Litruria, that, after the departure of Volumnius's army, all that country had risen up in arms, and that Gellius Egnatius, the leader of the Samnites, was causing the Umbrians to join in the insurrection, and tempting the Gauls with high offers. Terrified at this news, the senate ordered the courts of justice to be shut, and a levy to be made of men of every description. Accordingly not only free-born men and the younger sort were obliged to enlist, but cohorts were formed of the elder citizens, and the sons of freed-men were incorporated in the centuries. Plans were formed for the defence of the city, and the praetor, Publius Sempronius, was invested with the chief command. However, the senate was exonerated of one half of their anxiety, by a letter from the consul, Lucius Volumnius informing them that the army, which had ravaged Campania, had been defeated and dispersed whereupon, they decreed a public thanksgiving for this success, in the name of the consul. The courts were opened, after having been shut eighteen days, and the thanksgiving was performed with much joy. They then turned their thoughts to devising measures for the future security of the country depopulated by the Samnites, and, with this view, it was resolved, that two colonies should be settled on the frontiers of the Vescian and Falernian territories, one at the mouth of the river Liris, which has received the name of Minturnae, the other in the Vescian forest, which borders on the Falernian territory, where, it is said, stood Sinope, a city of Grecians, called thenceforth by the Roman colonists Sinuessa. The plebeian tribunes were charged to procure an order of the commons, commanding Publius Sempronius, the praetor, to create triumphs for conducting the colonies to those places. But persons were not readily found to give in their names, because they considered that they were being sent into what was almost a perpetual advanced guard in a hostile country, not as a provision from concord between consuls, and the evils arising from their disagreement in the conduct of military affairs; at the same time remarking, "how near the extremity of danger matters had been brought, by the late dispute between his colleague and himself." He warmly recommended to Decius and Fabius to "live together with one mind and one spirit." Observed that "they were men qualified by nature for military command: great in action, but unpractised in the strife of words and eloquence; their talents were such as eminently became consuls. As to the artful and the ingenious lawyers and orators, such as Appius Claudius, they ought to be kept at home to preside in the city and the forum; and to be appointed praetors for the administration of justice." In these proceedings that day was spent, and, on the following, the elections both of consuls and praetor were held, and were guided by the recommendations suggested by the consul. Quintus Fabius and Publius Decius were chosen consuls; Appius Claudius, praetor; all of them absent; and, by a decree of the senate, followed by an order of the commons, Lucius Volumnius was continued in the command for another year.

The damage done to the lands of Campania had caused a major panic in Rome, and around the same time, news arrived from Litruria that, after Volumnius's army left, the entire region had risen up in arms. Gellius Egnatius, the leader of the Samnites, was getting the Umbrians to join the uprising and was luring the Gauls with tempting offers. Alarmed by this news, the senate ordered the courts to close and called for a draft of people from all walks of life. Consequently, not only free-born men and younger individuals were required to enlist, but cohorts were also formed from older citizens, and the sons of freedmen were included in the centuries. Plans were made to defend the city, and the praetor, Publius Sempronius, was given overall command. However, the senate breathed easier when they received a letter from the consul, Lucius Volumnius, informing them that the army that had devastated Campania had been defeated and scattered. Following this, they declared a public thanksgiving for this victory in the consul's name. After being closed for eighteen days, the courts reopened, and the thanksgiving was celebrated with great joy. They then focused on devising strategies for the future protection of the country affected by the Samnites and decided to establish two colonies on the borders of the Vescian and Falernian territories—one at the mouth of the river Liris, named Minturnae, and the other in the Vescian forest, adjacent to the Falernian territory, where the city formerly known as Sinope, which was later called Sinuessa by the Roman colonists, once stood. The plebeian tribunes were tasked with getting the commons to order Publius Sempronius, the praetor, to organize triumphs for leading the colonies to those locations. However, it was difficult to find people willing to sign up because they thought they were being sent to what felt like an almost permanent frontline in a hostile area, rather than being part of a unified effort by the consuls, while also reflecting on "how close they had come to the brink of disaster due to the recent disagreements between him and his colleague." He strongly advised Decius and Fabius to "work together with one mind and spirit." He noted that "they were men naturally suited for military command: impressive in action, but inexperienced in verbal disputes and rhetoric; their skills were perfectly suited to the role of consuls. As for the crafty and clever lawyers and orators, like Appius Claudius, they should stay in the city and manage affairs in the forum, serving as praetors for the administration of justice." The day was spent on these matters, and the following day, elections for both consuls and the praetor took place, guided by the consul's recommendations. Quintus Fabius and Publius Decius were elected as consuls; Appius Claudius was named praetor; all absent; and by a senatorial decree followed by an order from the commons, Lucius Volumnius was approved to remain in command for another year.

23

During that year many prodigies happened. For the purpose of averting which, the senate decreed a supplication for two days: the wine and frankincense for the sacrifices were furnished at the expense of the public; and numerous crowds of men and women attended the performance. This supplication was rendered remarkable by a quarrel, which broke out among the matrons in the chapel of patrician chastity, which stands in the cattle market, near the round temple of Hercules. Virginia, daughter of Aulus, a patrician, but married to Volumnius the consul, a plebeian, was, because she had married out of the patricians, excluded by the matrons from sharing in the sacred rites: a short altercation ensued, which was afterwards, through the intemperance of passion incident to the sex, kindled into a flame of contention. Virginia boasted with truth that she had a right to enter the temple of patrician chastity, as being of patrician birth, and chaste in her character, and, besides, the wife of one husband, to whom she was betrothed a virgin, and had no reason to be dissatisfied either with her husband, or his exploits or honours: to her high-spirited words, she added importance by an extraordinary act. In the long street where she resided, she enclosed with a partition a part of the house, of a size sufficient for a small chapel, and there erected an altar. Then calling together the plebeian matrons, and complaining of the injurious behaviour of the patrician ladies, she said, "This altar I dedicate to plebeian chastity, and exhort you, that the same degree of emulation which prevails among the men of this state, on the point of valour, may be maintained by the women on the point of chastity; and that you contribute your best care, that this altar may have the credit of being attended with a greater degree of sanctity, and by chaster women, than the other, if possible." Solemn rites were performed at this altar under the same regulations, nearly, with those at the more ancient one; no person being allowed the privilege of taking part in the sacrifices, except a woman of approved chastity, and who was the wife of one husband. This institution, being afterwards debased by [the admission of] vicious characters, and not only by matrons, but women of every description, sunk at last into oblivion. During this year the Ogulnii, Cneius and Quintus, being curule aediles, carried on prosecutions against several usurers; whose property being fined, out of the produce, which was deposited in the treasury, they ordered brazen thresholds for the Capitol, utensils of plate for three tables in the chapel of Jupiter, a statue of Jupiter in a chariot drawn by four horses placed on the roof, and images of the founders of the city in their infant state under the teats of the wolf, at the Ruminal fig-tree. They also paved with square stones the roads from the Capuan gate to the temple of Mars. By the plebeian aediles likewise, Lucius Aelius Paetus and Caius Fulvius Corvus, out of money levied as fines on farmers of the public pastures, whom they had convicted of malpractices, games were exhibited, and golden bowls were placed in the temple of Ceres.

During that year, many extraordinary events occurred. To address this, the senate declared a two-day supplication: the public covered the cost of wine and frankincense for the sacrifices, and large crowds of men and women gathered for the event. This supplication became notable due to a dispute that broke out among the matrons in the chapel of patrician chastity, located in the cattle market near the round temple of Hercules. Virginia, the daughter of Aulus, a patrician but married to Volumnius the consul, who was a plebeian, was excluded by the matrons from participating in the sacred rites because she had married outside the patrician class. A brief argument followed, which later ignited into a fierce contention due to the passionate nature of the women involved. Virginia rightly asserted her right to enter the temple of patrician chastity because of her patrician heritage and her chaste character; moreover, she was married to one husband, to whom she had been betrothed as a virgin, and she had no reason to be unhappy with her husband or his achievements. To emphasize her bold statement, she took an extraordinary step. In the long street where she lived, she partitioned off part of her house, creating a small chapel, and there she built an altar. Then she gathered together the plebeian matrons and complained about the disrespectful behavior of the patrician ladies, stating, "This altar I dedicate to plebeian chastity, and I urge you that the same level of competition seen among the men in terms of valor should be mirrored by the women concerning chastity; and that you give your utmost effort to ensure that this altar is seen as more sacred and attended by purer women than the other, if possible." Solemn rites were performed at this altar under similar rules to those of the more ancient one; no one was permitted to participate in the sacrifices except a woman of proven chastity who was married to one husband. However, this institution later declined due to the inclusion of immoral characters, and eventually, it fell into obscurity as women of all kinds, not just matrons, participated. During this year, the curule aediles, Cneius and Quintus Ogulnii, prosecuted several usurers; the fines collected from them were used to fund brazen thresholds for the Capitol, silver utensils for three tables in the temple of Jupiter, a statue of Jupiter in a chariot drawn by four horses placed on the roof, and statues of the city's founders as infants under the she-wolf's teats at the Ruminal fig tree. The plebeian aediles, Lucius Aelius Paetus and Caius Fulvius Corvus, also organized games funded by fines levied on the farmers of public pastures whom they had convicted of wrongdoings, and golden bowls were placed in the temple of Ceres.

24

Then came into the consulship Quintus Fabius a fifth time, and Publius Decius a fourth. They had been colleagues from the censorship, and twice in the consulship, and were celebrated not more for their glorious achievements, splendid as these were, than for the unanimity which had ever subsisted between them. The continuance of this feeling I am inclined to think was interrupted by a jarring between the [opposite] orders rather than between themselves, the patricians endeavouring that Fabius should have Etruria for his province, without casting lots, and the plebeians insisting that Decius should bring the matter to the decision of lots. There was certainly a contention in the senate, and the interest of Fabius being superior there, the business was brought before the people. Here, between military men who laid greater stress on deeds than on words, the debate was short. Fabius said, "that it was unreasonable, after he had planted a tree, another should gather the fruit of it. He had opened the Ciminian forest, and made a way for the Roman arms, through passes until then impracticable. Why had they disturbed him, at that time of his life, if they intended to give the management of the war to another?" Then, in the way of a gentle reproof, he observed, that "instead of an associate in command, he had chosen an adversary; and that Decius thought it too much that their unanimity should last through three consulates." Declaring, in fine, that "he desired nothing further, than that, if they thought him qualified for the command in the province, they should send him thither. He had submitted to the judgment of the senate, and would now be governed by the authority of the people." Publius Decius complained of injustice in the senate; and asserted, that "the patricians had laboured, as long as possible, to exclude the plebeians from all access to the higher honours; and since merit, by its own intrinsic power, had prevailed so far, as that it should not, in any rank of men, be precluded from the attainment of honours, expedients were sought how not only the suffrages of the people, but even the decisions of fortune may be rendered ineffectual, and be converted to the aggrandizement of a few. All the consuls before him had disposed of the provinces by lots; now, the senate bestowed a province on Fabius without lots. If this was meant as a mark of honour, the merits of Fabius were so great towards the commonwealth, and towards himself in particular, that he would gladly second the advancement of his reputation, provided only its splendour could be increased without reflecting dishonour on himself. But who did not see, that, when a war of difficulty and danger, and out of the ordinary course, was committed to only that one consul, the other would be considered as useless and insignificant. Fabius gloried in his exploits performed in Etruria: Publius Decius wished for a like subject of glory, and perhaps would utterly extinguish that fire, which the other left smothered, in such a manner that it often broke out anew, in sudden conflagrations. In fine, honours and rewards he would concede to his colleague, out of respect to his age and dignified character: but when danger, when a vigorous struggle with an enemy was before them, he never did, nor ever would, willingly, give place. With respect to the present dispute, this much he would gain at all events, that a business, appertaining to the jurisdiction of the people, should be determined by an order of that people, and not complimented away by the senate. He prayed Jupiter, supremely good and great, and all the immortal gods, not to grant him an equal chance with his colleague, unless they intended to grant him equal ability and success, in the management of the war. It was certainly in its nature reasonable, in the example salutary, and concerned the reputation of the Roman people, that the consuls should be men of such abilities, that under either of them a war with Etruria could be well managed." Fabius, after requesting of the people nothing else than that, before the tribes were called in to give their votes, they would hear the letters of the praetor Appius Claudius, written from Etruria, withdrew from the Comitium, and with no less unanimity of the people than of the senate, the province of Etruria was decreed to him without having recourse to lots.

Then Quintus Fabius became consul for the fifth time, and Publius Decius for the fourth. They had been colleagues since their time as censors and had served together twice as consuls. They were known not just for their impressive achievements, which were indeed remarkable, but also for the strong agreement that had always existed between them. I believe that this unity was disturbed more by the conflicting interests of different groups than by any personal disagreement between them, with the patricians pushing for Fabius to receive Etruria as his province without a lottery, while the plebeians insisted that Decius should leave it up to chance. There was definitely a dispute in the senate, and with Fabius having a strong support there, the issue was brought before the people. In this setting, with military leaders who valued actions over words, the discussion was brief. Fabius stated, "It's unreasonable for someone to enjoy the fruits of a tree I planted. I opened the Ciminian forest and created a path for the Roman army through routes that were previously impassable. Why disturb me at this point in my life if you're planning to hand the war over to someone else?" Then, gently chiding, he remarked that "instead of having a partner in command, Decius had chosen to see him as a rival; as if Decius thought it was too much for their agreement to last through three consulships." He concluded by saying that "all he wanted was, if they considered him qualified for the command in that province, to send him there. He had submitted to the senate's judgment and would now accept the will of the people." Publius Decius expressed his grievances about the injustice in the senate, arguing that "the patricians had tried for as long as they could to keep plebeians from reaching higher honors; and since merit itself had forced its way through and wasn't excluded from any rank's chances of attaining honors, strategies were being devised to undermine the people's votes, turning them into tools for the benefit of just a few. All prior consuls handled provinces by lottery; now the senate was giving a province to Fabius without lots. If this was intended as an honor, Fabius's contributions to the state and to him specifically were so significant that he would gladly support his reputation, as long as it didn’t diminish his own. But who couldn't see that when a challenging and risky war was assigned to only one consul, the other would appear useless and irrelevant? Fabius took pride in his achievements in Etruria while Decius sought similar glory and might extinguish the very fire Fabius had left simmering, which often flared up again in unexpected ways. Ultimately, he would concede honors and rewards to his colleague, out of respect for his age and status; however, during moments of crisis and fierce battles, he had never, nor would he ever, willingly step aside. Regarding the current dispute, he intended to ensure that this matter, falling under the people's authority, would be decided by that authority and not be dismissed by the senate. He prayed to Jupiter, the supreme good and great, and all the immortal gods, not to give him a chance equal to Fabius’s unless they also granted him equal abilities and success in managing the war. It was only reasonable, and a good precedent, concerning the Roman people's reputation, that the consuls should be capable men, so that either of them could effectively handle a war with Etruria." Fabius, after asking the people to listen to the letters from the praetor Appius Claudius, written from Etruria, withdrew from the Comitium, and with unanimous support from both the people and the senate, Etruria was assigned to him without a lottery.

25

Immediately almost all the younger citizens flocked together to the consul, and readily gave in their names; so strong was their desire of serving under such a commander. Seeing so great a multitude collected round him, he said, "My intention is to enlist only four thousand foot and six hundred horse: such of you as give in your names to-day and to-morrow, I will carry with me. I am more solicitous to bring home all my soldiers rich, than to employ a great multitude." Accordingly, with a competent number of men, who possessed greater hopes and confidence because a numerous army had not been required, he marched to the town of Aharna, from which the enemy were not far distant, and proceeded to the camp of the praetor Appius. When within a few miles of it, he was met by some soldiers, sent to cut wood, attended by a guard. Observing the lictors preceding him, and learning that he was Fabius the consul, they were filled with joy and alacrity; they expressed their thanks to the gods, and to the Roman people, for having sent them such a commander. Then as they gathered round to pay their respects, Fabius inquired whither they were going, and on their answering they were going to provide wood, "What do you tell me," said he, "have you not a rampart, raised about your camp?" When to this they replied, "they had a double rampart, and a trench, and, notwithstanding, were in great apprehension."

Almost all the younger citizens quickly gathered around the consul, eager to sign up; their desire to serve under such a leader was strong. Seeing such a large crowd around him, he said, "My goal is to recruit only four thousand infantry and six hundred cavalry: those of you who sign up today and tomorrow will come with me. I care more about bringing home all my soldiers wealthy than about having a massive army." So, with a sufficient number of men who felt more hopeful and confident since a large army wasn’t needed, he marched to the town of Aharna, close to where the enemy was, and made his way to the camp of the praetor Appius. When he was a few miles away, some soldiers tasked with gathering firewood, accompanied by a guard, met him. Seeing the lictors in front and learning that he was Fabius the consul, they were filled with joy and excitement; they thanked the gods and the Roman people for sending them such a commander. As they gathered around to show their respect, Fabius asked where they were headed, and when they replied they were going to get wood, he said, "What are you telling me? Don't you have a rampart built around your camp?" When they answered that they had a double rampart and a trench, yet still felt very anxious, he listened carefully.

"Well then," said he, "you have abundance of wood, go back and level the rampart." They accordingly returned to the camp and there levelling the rampart threw the soldiers who had remained in it, and Appius himself, into the greatest fright, until with eager joy each called out to the rest, that, "they acted by order of the consul, Quintus Fabius." Next day the camp was moved from thence, and the praetor, Appius, was dismissed to Rome. From that time the Romans had no fixed post, the consul affirming, that it was prejudicial to an army to lie in one spot, and that by frequent marches, and changing places, it was rendered more healthy, and more capable of brisk exertions, and marches were made as long as the winter, which was not yet ended, permitted. Then, in the beginning of spring, leaving the second legion near Clusium, which they formerly called the Camertian, and giving the command of the camp to Lucius Scipio, as propraetor, he returned to Rome, in order to adjust measures for carrying on the war, either led thereto by his own judgment, because the war seemed to him more serious than he had believed, from report, or, being summoned by a decree of the senate, for writers give both accounts. Some choose to have it believed, that he was forced back by the praetor, Appius Claudius, who, both in the senate, and before the people, exaggerated, as he was wont in all his letters, the danger of the Etrurian war, contending, that "one general, or one army, would not be sufficient to oppose four nations. That whether these directed the whole of their combined force against him alone, or acted separately in different parts, there was reason to fear, that he would be unable to provide against every emergency. That he had left there but two Roman legions; and that the foot and horse, who came with Fabius, did not amount to five thousand. It was, therefore, his opinion, that the consul, Publius Decius should, without delay, set out to his colleague in Etruria, and that the province of Samnium should be given to Lucius Volumnius. But if the consul preferred going to his own province, that then Volumnius should march a full consular army into Etruria, to join the other consul." When the advice of the praetor influenced a great part of the members, they say that Publius Decius recommended that every thing should be kept undetermined, and open for Quintus Fabius; until he should either come to Rome, if he could do so without prejudice to the public, or send some of his lieutenants, from whom the senate might learn the real state of the war in Etruria; and with what number of troops, and by how many generals, it should be carried on.

"Well then," he said, "you have plenty of wood, so go back and level the rampart." They went back to the camp and started leveling the rampart, which scared the soldiers left there, including Appius himself, until everyone joyfully shouted to each other that they were acting on the consul, Quintus Fabius's orders. The next day, the camp was moved, and the praetor, Appius, was sent back to Rome. From then on, the Romans didn't have a fixed camp because the consul believed it was harmful for an army to stay in one place; he said that frequent marches and changing locations kept the army healthier and more ready for action. They continued marching as long as winter, which was still ongoing, allowed. Then, at the beginning of spring, they left the second legion near Clusium, which they used to call the Camertian, and gave the camp command to Lucius Scipio, acting as propraetor, while he returned to Rome to plan strategies for the war. This was either due to his own judgment, as he realized the war was more serious than he initially thought, or because he was summoned by a senate decree; both accounts are reported by historians. Some assert that he was forced back by praetor Appius Claudius, who, both in the senate and in public, exaggerated the threat of the Etrurian war, claiming that "one general, or one army, would not be enough to face four nations. Whether they directed their full combined forces against him or acted separately, there was a real risk that he wouldn't be able to handle every situation. He had only left two Roman legions there; the foot and cavalry that came with Fabius didn’t number more than five thousand. Therefore, he thought the consul, Publius Decius, should quickly head to his colleague in Etruria, and that the Samnium province should be assigned to Lucius Volumnius. But if the consul preferred to go to his own province, then Volumnius should lead a full consular army into Etruria to join the other consul." When the praetor's advice swayed many members, they say that Publius Decius suggested keeping everything uncertain and open for Quintus Fabius until he could either come to Rome without affecting public affairs or send some of his lieutenants to inform the senate about the actual situation of the war in Etruria, including the number of troops and the generals leading them.

26

Fabius, as soon as he returned to Rome, qualified his discourses, both in the senate and when brought before the people, in such a manner as to appear neither to exaggerate or lessen, any particular relating to the war; and to show, that, in agreeing to another general being joined with him, he rather indulged the apprehensions of others, than guarded against any danger to himself, or the public. "But if they chose," he said, "to give him an assistant in the war, and associate in command, how could he overlook Publius Decius the consul, whom he had tried during so many associations in office? There was no man living whom he would rather wish to be joined in commission with him: with Publius Decius he should have forces sufficient, and never too many enemies. If, however, his colleague preferred any other employment, let them then give him Lucius Volumnius as an assistant." The disposal of every particular was left entirely to Fabius by the people and the senate, and even by his colleague. And when Decius declared that he was ready to go either to Etruria or Samnium, such general congratulation and satisfaction took place, that victory was anticipated, and it seemed as if a triumph, not a war, had been decreed to the consuls. I find in some writers, that Fabius and Decius, immediately on their entering into office, set out together for Etruria, without any mention of the casting of lots for the provinces, or of the disputes which I have related. Others, not satisfied with relating those disputes, have added charges of misconduct, laid by Appius before the people against Fabius, when absent; and a stubborn opposition, maintained by the praetor against the consul, when present; and also another contention between the colleagues, Decius insisting that each consul should attend to the care of his own separate province. Certainty, however, begins to appear from the time when both consuls set out for the campaign. Now, before the consuls arrived in Etruria, the Senonian Gauls came in a vast body to Clusium, to attack the Roman legion and the camp. Scipio, who commanded the camp, wishing to remedy the deficiency of his numbers by an advantage in the ground, led his men up a hill, which stood between the camp and the city but having, in his haste, neglected to examine the place, he reached near the summit, which he found already possessed by the enemy, who had ascended on the other side. The legion was consequently attacked on the rear, and surrounded in the middle, when the enemy pressed it on all sides. Some writers say, that the whole were cut off, so that not one survived to give an account of it, and that no information of the misfortune reached the consuls, who were, at the time, not far from Clusium, until the Gallic horsemen came within sight, carrying the heads of the slain, some hanging before their horses' breasts, others on the points of their spears, and expressing their triumph in songs according to their custom. Others affirm, that the defeat was by Umbrians, not Gauls, and that the loss sustained was not so great. That a party of foragers, under Lucius Manlius Torquatus, lieutenant-general, being surrounded, Scipio, the propraetor, brought up relief from the camp, and the battle being renewed, that the Umbrians, lately victorious, were defeated, and the prisoners and spoil retaken. But it is more probable that this blow was suffered from a Gallic than an Umbrian enemy, because during that year, as was often the case at other times, the danger principally apprehended by the public, was that of a Gallic tumult, for which reason, notwithstanding that both the consuls had marched against the enemy, with four legions, and a large body of Roman cavalry, joined by a thousand chosen horsemen of Campania, supplied on the occasion, and a body of the allies and Latin confederates, superior in number to the Romans, two other armies were posted near the city, on the side facing Etruria, one in the Faliscian, the other in the Vatican territory. Cneius Fulvius and Lucius Postumius Megellus, both propraetors, were ordered to keep the troops stationed in those places.

Fabius, as soon as he got back to Rome, framed his speeches, both in the senate and when addressing the public, in a way that made it seem like he neither exaggerated nor downplayed anything related to the war. He wanted to show that by agreeing to have another general join him, he was more accommodating the concerns of others than protecting himself or the public from any danger. "But if they want to give him an assistant in the war and share command," he said, "how could I overlook Publius Decius the consul, someone I've worked with in so many roles? There's no one I’d rather have as a partner. With Publius Decius, I’d have enough forces and never too many enemies. However, if my colleague prefers someone else, then let them appoint Lucius Volumnius as an assistant." The people, the senate, and even his colleague gave complete control of every decision to Fabius. When Decius said he was ready to go to either Etruria or Samnium, there was such widespread joy and satisfaction that victory seemed certain, and it felt like a triumph had been promised to the consuls, not a war. Some writers say that Fabius and Decius, right after they took office, headed out for Etruria together, without mentioning any drawing of lots for provinces or the disputes I’ve mentioned. Others, unhappy with just telling about those disputes, have also included accusations of misconduct made by Appius against Fabius while he was absent, and a stubborn opposition put up by the praetor against the consul when present, along with another disagreement between the colleagues, with Decius insisting that each consul should handle their own province. However, clarity starts to emerge from the moment both consuls set out for the campaign. Before they arrived in Etruria, the Senonian Gauls came en masse to Clusium to attack the Roman legion and camp. Scipio, who was in charge of the camp, wanting to make up for his lack of numbers with a strategic position, led his men up a hill between the camp and the city. However, in his haste, he failed to assess the area and reached near the top, only to find it already occupied by the enemy, who had climbed up from the other side. The legion was thus attacked from behind and surrounded in the middle as the enemy pressed in on all sides. Some writers claim that everyone was killed, leaving no survivors to report on it, and that the consuls, who were not far from Clusium at the time, only learned of the disaster when they saw Gallic horsemen approaching with the heads of the dead—some hanging before their horses and others on the ends of their spears—expressing their victory in song, as was their custom. Others say that the defeat was caused by Umbrians, not Gauls, and that the loss wasn’t as significant. They mention that a group of foragers under Lucius Manlius Torquatus, the lieutenant-general, got surrounded, but Scipio, the propraetor, brought reinforcements from the camp, and after renewing the battle, the recently victorious Umbrians were defeated, with prisoners and spoils being recovered. However, it seems more likely that this blow came from a Gallic enemy rather than an Umbrian one because, that year, just like at other times, the main danger feared by the public was a Gallic uprising. That’s why, despite both consuls marching against the enemy with four legions and a large contingent of Roman cavalry, plus a thousand elite horsemen from Campania, and an allied and Latin force outnumbering the Romans, two additional armies were stationed near the city, facing Etruria—one in the Faliscian territory and the other in the Vatican territory. Cneius Fulvius and Lucius Postumius Megellus, both propraetors, were tasked with keeping the troops stationed in those areas.

27

The consuls, having crossed the Apennines, came up with the enemy in the territory of Sentinum, their camp was pitched there at the distance of about four miles. Several councils were then held by the enemy, and their plan of operations was thus settled: that they should not encamp together, nor go out together to battle; the Gauls were united to the Samnites, the Umbrians to the Etrurians. The day of battle was fixed. The part of maintaining the fight was committed to the Samnites and Gauls; and the Etrurians and Umbrians were ordered to attack the Roman camp during the heat of the engagement. This plan was frustrated by three Clusian deserters, who came over by night to Fabius, and after disclosing the above designs, were sent back with presents, in order that they might discover, and bring intelligence of, any new scheme which should be determined on. The consuls then wrote to Flavius and Postumius to move their armies, the one from the Faliscian, the other from the Vatican country, towards Clusium; and to ruin the enemy's territory by every means in their power. The news of these depredations drew the Etrurians from Sentinum to protect their own region. The consuls, in their absence, practised every means to bring on an engagement. For two days they endeavoured, by several attacks, to provoke the enemy to fight; in which time, however, nothing worth mention was performed. A few fell on each side, but still the minds [of the Romans] were irritated to wish for a general engagement; yet nothing decisive was hazarded. On the third day, both parties marched out their whole force to the field: here, while the armies stood in order of battle, a hind, chased by a wolf from the mountains, ran through the plain between the two lines: there the animals taking different directions, the hind bent its course towards the Gauls, the wolf towards the Romans: way was made between the ranks for the wolf, the Gauls slew the hind with their javelins; on which one of the Roman soldiers in the van said, "To that side, where you see an animal, sacred to Diana, lying prostrate, flight and slaughter are directed; on this side the victorious wolf of Mars, safe and untouched, reminds us of our founder, and of our descent from that deity." The Gauls were posted on the right wing, the Samnites on the left: against the latter, Fabius drew up, as his right wing, the first and third legions: against the Gauls, Decius formed the left wing of the fifth and sixth. The second and fourth were employed in the war in Samnium, under the proconsul, Lucius Volumnius. In the first encounter the action was supported with strength so equal on both sides, that had the Etrurians and Umbrians been present, either in the field or at the camp, in whichever place they might have employed their force, the Romans must have been defeated.

The consuls, after crossing the Apennines, engaged the enemy in the area of Sentinum, setting up their camp about four miles away. Several meetings were held by the enemy to plan their strategy: they decided not to camp together or go into battle together; the Gauls aligned with the Samnites, and the Umbrians partnered with the Etrurians. The battle day was set. The responsibility of fighting was assigned to the Samnites and Gauls, while the Etrurians and Umbrians were instructed to attack the Roman camp during the heat of the battle. This plan was disrupted by three deserters from Clusium, who came to Fabius at night, revealed the enemy's strategy, and were sent back with gifts so they could report any new plans. The consuls then wrote to Flavius and Postumius to move their armies—one from the Faliscian territory, the other from the Vatican area—toward Clusium, and to devastate the enemy's land by any means. The news of these raids prompted the Etrurians to leave Sentinum to defend their own territory. In their absence, the consuls tried every tactic to provoke a battle. For two days, they made various attacks to provoke the enemy to fight; during this time, however, not much of note occurred. A few casualties were sustained on both sides, but the Romans were still eager for an all-out battle; yet nothing decisive was risked. On the third day, both sides deployed their full forces to the field: as the armies stood ready for battle, a deer, chased by a wolf from the mountains, dashed through the plains between the two lines. The animals split off in different directions, with the deer heading towards the Gauls and the wolf towards the Romans: the ranks parted for the wolf, while the Gauls killed the deer with their spears. One of the Roman soldiers in the front line remarked, "To that side, where you see an animal, sacred to Diana, lying dead, are directed flight and slaughter; on this side, the victorious wolf of Mars, safe and unharmed, reminds us of our founder and our descent from that deity." The Gauls were stationed on the right wing, the Samnites on the left: against the latter, Fabius positioned the first and third legions as his right wing, while Decius arranged the left wing with the fifth and sixth legions against the Gauls. The second and fourth legions were engaged in the war in Samnium under the proconsul, Lucius Volumnius. In the first clash, both sides fought with equal strength, and if the Etrurians and Umbrians had been present, either on the field or in the camp, wherever they might have deployed their forces, the Romans would have likely been defeated.

28

However, although the victory was still undecided, fortune not having declared in favour of either party, yet the course of the fight was by no means similar on both right and left wings. The Romans, under Fabius, rather repelled than offered assault, and the contest was protracted until very late in the day, for their general knew very well, that both Samnites and Gauls were furious in the first onset, so that, to withstand them would be sufficient. It was known, too, that in a protracted contest the spirits of the Samnites gradually flagged, and even the bodies of the Gauls, remarkably ill able to bear labour and heat, became quite relaxed, and although, in their first efforts, they were more than men, yet in their last they were less than women. He, therefore, reserved the strength of his men as unimpaired as possible, until the time when the enemy were the more likely to be worsted. Decius, more impetuous, as being in the prime of life and full flow of spirits, exerted whatever force he had to the utmost in the first encounter, and thinking the infantry not sufficiently energetic, brought up the cavalry to the fight. Putting himself at the head of a troop of young horsemen of distinguished bravery, he besought those youths, the flower of the army, to charge the enemy with him, [telling them] "they would reap a double share of glory, if the victory should commence on the left wing, and through their means." Twice they compelled the Gallic cavalry to give way. At the second charge, when they advanced farther and were briskly engaged in the midst of the enemy's squadrons, by a method of fighting new to them, they were thrown into dismay. A number of the enemy, mounted on chariots and cars, made towards them with such a prodigious clatter from the trampling of the cattle and rolling of wheels, as affrighted the horses of the Romans, unaccustomed to such tumultuous operations. By this means the victorious cavalry were dispersed, through a panic, and men and horses, in their headlong flight, were tumbled promiscuously on the ground. Hence also the battalions of the legions were thrown into disorder, through the impetuosity of the horses, and of the carriages which they dragged through the ranks, many of the soldiers in the van were trodden or bruised to death, while the Gallic line, as soon as they saw their enemy in confusion, pursued the advantage, nor allowed them time to take breath or recover themselves. Decius, calling aloud, "Whither were they flying, or what hope could they have in running away?" strove to stop them as they turned their backs, but finding that he could not, by any efforts, prevail on them to keep their posts, so thoroughly were they dismayed, he called on his father, Publius Decius, by name. He said, "Why do I any longer defer the fate entailed on my family? It is destined to our race, that we should serve as expiatory victims to avert the public danger. I will now offer the legions of the enemy, together with myself, to be immolated to Earth, and the infernal gods." Having thus said, he commanded Marcus Livius, a pontiff, whom, at his coming out to the field, he had charged not to stir from him, to dictate the form of words in which he was to devote himself, and the legions of the enemy, for the army of the Roman people, the Quirites. He was accordingly devoted with the same imprecations, and in the same habit, in which his father, Publius Decius, had ordered himself to be devoted at the Veseris in the Latin war. When, immediately after the solemn imprecation, he added, that "he drove before him dismay and flight, slaughter and blood, and the wrath of the gods celestial and infernal, that, with the contagious influence of the furies, the ministers of death, he would infect the standards, the weapons, and the armour of the enemy, and that the same spot should be that of his perdition, and that of the Gauls and Samnites." After uttering these execrations on himself and the foe, he spurred forward his horse, where he saw the line of the Gauls thickest, and, rushing upon the enemy's weapons, met his death.

However, even though the victory was still undecided and fate hadn’t chosen a side, the battle was going quite differently on the right and left wings. The Romans, led by Fabius, were more focused on defending than attacking, and the conflict dragged on until late in the day, since their general understood that both the Samnites and Gauls were fierce in their initial attacks, so merely holding them off would be enough. It was also known that in a prolonged fight, the spirits of the Samnites would gradually weaken, and the Gauls, who were notably unable to endure labor and heat, would become quite exhausted; though they fought valiantly at first, they would falter in the end. Therefore, he conserved his men's strength as much as possible until the time when the enemy was more likely to be defeated. Decius, being more impulsive due to his youth and high spirits, pushed all his forces in the first encounter, and seeing the infantry not energetic enough, he brought in the cavalry. Leading a group of young and valiant horsemen, he urged them to charge the enemy with him, telling them that they would gain double glory if the victory started on the left wing thanks to their efforts. Twice, they forced the Gallic cavalry to retreat. In the second charge, when they advanced further and engaged vigorously in the midst of the enemy's formations, they were thrown into confusion by a fighting style unfamiliar to them. A number of enemies, riding in chariots and carts, approached with such a tremendous noise from the stampede of the animals and the rumbling of wheels that it terrified the Roman horses, who were not used to such chaotic scenes. This caused the victorious cavalry to scatter in panic, tumbling men and horses to the ground in a wild escape. As a result, the legion formations were also thrown into disorder by the wildness of the horses and the carts they pulled through the ranks; many of the soldiers at the front were trampled or injured fatally, and as soon as the Gallic soldiers saw their enemies in disarray, they pressed the attack and didn’t give them a moment to catch their breath. Decius shouted, “Where are you running to, or what hope can you find in fleeing?” He tried to stop them as they turned their backs, but finding he couldn’t make them hold their ground due to their dread, he called out to his father, Publius Decius. He said, “Why do I wait any longer to face the fate that awaits my family? It is our destiny to serve as sacrifices to avert public danger. I will now devote both the enemy's legions and myself to be offered to Earth and the underworld gods.” Having said this, he instructed Marcus Livius, a priest he had asked to stay close, to recite the words in which he would devote himself and the enemy’s legions for the Roman people, the Quirites. He was devoted with the same words and in the same attire in which his father, Publius Decius, had devoted himself during the Latin war at Veseris. Immediately after the solemn prayer, he added that he would drive before him panic and flight, slaughter and blood, and the anger of the heavenly and underworld gods, that with the poisonous influence of the furies, the messengers of death, he would taint the enemy’s standards, weapons, and armor, and that the same spot would be his doom as well as the doom of the Gauls and Samnites. After uttering these curses upon himself and the enemy, he spurred his horse towards the thickest part of the Gaul line and charged into the enemy's weapons, meeting his death.

29

Thenceforward the battle seemed to be fought with a degree of force scarcely human. The Romans, on the loss of their general, a circumstance which, on other occasions, is wont to inspire terror, stopped their flight, and were anxious to begin the combat afresh. The Gauls, and especially the multitude which encircled the consul's body, as if deprived of reason, cast their javelins at random without execution, some became so stupid as not to think of either fighting or flying, while on the other side, Livius, the pontiff, to whom Decius had transferred his lictors, with orders to act as propraetor, cried out aloud, that "the Romans were victorious, being saved by the death of their consul. That the Gauls and Samnites were now the victims of mother Earth and the infernal gods. That Decius was summoning and dragging to himself the army devoted along with him, and that, among the enemy, all was full of dismay, and the vengeance of all the furies." While the soldiers were busy in restoring the fight, Lucius Cornelius Scipio and Caius Marcius, with some reserved troops from the rear, who had been sent by Quintus Fabius, the consul, to the support of his colleague, came up. There the fate of Decius is ascertained, a powerful stimulus to brave every danger in the cause of the public. Wherefore, when the Gauls stood in close order, with their shields formed into a fence before them, and but little prospect of success appeared from a close fight, the javelins, which lay scattered between the two lines, were, therefore, by order of the lieutenants-general, gathered up from the ground, and thrown against the enemy's shields, and as most of them pierced the fence, the long pointed ones even into their bodies, their compact band was overthrown in such a manner, that a great many, who were unhurt, yet fell as if thunderstruck. Such were the changes of fortune on the left wing of the Romans; on the right, Fabius had at first protracted the time, as we mentioned above, in slow operations, then, as soon as he perceived that neither the shout, nor the efforts of the enemy, nor the weapons which they threw, retained their former force, having ordered the commanders of the cavalry to lead round their squadrons to the flank of the Samnites, so that, on receiving the signal, they should charge them in flank, with all possible violence, he commanded, at the same time, his infantry to advance leisurely, and drive the enemy from their ground. When he saw that they were unable to make resistance, and that their exhaustion was certain, drawing together all his reserves, whom he had kept fresh for that occasion, he made a brisk push with the legions, and gave the cavalry the signal to charge. The Samnites could not support the shock, but fled precipitately to their camp, passing by the line of the Gauls, and leaving their allies to fight by themselves. These stood in close order under cover of their shields. Fabius, therefore, having heard of the death of his colleague, ordered the squadron of Campanian cavalry, in number about five hundred, to fall back from the ranks, and riding round, to attack the rear of the Gallic line, then the chief strength of the third legion to follow, with directions that wherever they should see the enemy's troops disordered by the charge, to follow the blow, and cut them to pieces, when in a state of consternation. After vowing a temple and the spoils of the enemy to Jupiter the Victorious, he proceeded to the camp of the Samnites, whither all their forces were hurrying in confusion. The gates not affording entrance to such very great numbers, those who were necessarily excluded, attempted resistance just at the foot of the rampart, and here fell Gellius Egnatius, the Samnite general. These, however, were soon driven within the rampart; the camp was taken after a slight resistance; and at the same time the Gauls were attacked on the rear, and overpowered. There were slain of the enemy on that day twenty-five thousand: eight thousand were taken prisoners. Nor was the victory an unbloody one; for, of the army of Publius Decius, the killed amounted to seven thousand; of the army of Fabius, to one thousand two hundred. Fabius, after sending persons to search for the body of his colleague, had the spoils of the enemy collected into a heap, and burned them as an offering to Jupiter the Victorious. The consul's body could not be found that day, being hid under a heap of slaughtered Gauls: on the following, it was discovered and brought to the camp, amidst abundance of tears shed by the soldiers. Fabius, discarding all concern about any other business, solemnized the obsequies of his colleague in the most honourable manner, passing on him the high encomiums which he had justly merited.

From then on, the battle felt like it was fought with a level of force barely human. The Romans, facing the death of their general—a situation that typically instilled fear—stopped their retreat and were eager to resume the fight. The Gauls, especially the crowd surrounding the consul's body, seemed almost insane, throwing their javelins randomly and ineffectively; some were so dazed that they couldn't think about either fighting or fleeing. Meanwhile, Livius, the pontiff, to whom Decius had assigned his lictors with instructions to act as propraetor, shouted that "the Romans were victorious, saved by the death of their consul. The Gauls and Samnites were now victims of the earth and the underworld. Decius was calling forth the army devoted to him, and among the enemy, confusion reigned along with the wrath of all the furies." While the soldiers tried to regroup and restore the fight, Lucius Cornelius Scipio and Caius Marcius, along with some reserve troops from the rear sent by Quintus Fabius, the consul, to support his colleague, arrived. The fate of Decius fueled their courage to face every danger for the public good. Therefore, when the Gauls stood tightly packed, their shields forming a barrier, and the chances of success in close combat were slim, the javelins scattered between the two lines were collected by order of the generals. They were thrown against the enemy's shields, with many piercing the defenses—some even hitting their bodies—causing their tightly packed formation to collapse, leading many who weren’t hurt to fall as if struck by lightning. Such were the shifts in fortune on the left side of the Romans; on the right, Fabius had initially prolonged the fight, as mentioned earlier, with slow tactics. Then, as soon as he noticed that the enemy's shouts, efforts, and thrown weapons lacked their previous strength, he commanded the cavalry commanders to maneuver their squadrons to flank the Samnites. When they received the signal, they charged with all their might, while he instructed his infantry to advance steadily and push the enemy from their position. Observing their inability to resist and their inevitable exhaustion, he gathered all his reserves, kept fresh for this moment, made a strong push with the legions, and signaled the cavalry to charge. The Samnites could not withstand the assault and fled in disarray to their camp, leaving their allies to fend for themselves. The Gauls continued to stand close together behind their shields. Hearing of his colleague's death, Fabius ordered about five hundred Campanian cavalry to fall back from the ranks, ride around, and attack the rear of the Gallic line. Then, the main force of the third legion was directed to follow up wherever they saw the enemy's troops faltering due to the assault, to pursue and cut them down while they were in a state of panic. After vowing a temple and the enemy's spoils to Jupiter the Victorious, he advanced toward the Samnite camp, where all their forces were rushing in chaos. With the gates unable to accommodate such a large number of people, those who couldn’t enter attempted to resist at the base of the rampart, where Samnite general Gellius Egnatius fell. They were quickly driven back within the walls; the camp was taken after minimal resistance, and at the same time, the Gauls were attacked from behind and overpowered. That day, twenty-five thousand enemies were killed; eight thousand were captured. The victory wasn’t without bloodshed; seven thousand from Publius Decius's army were killed, and one thousand two hundred from Fabius's army. After sending people to search for his colleague's body, Fabius collected the spoils of the enemy into a pile and burned them as an offering to Jupiter the Victorious. Decius's body couldn't be located that day, buried under a heap of slain Gauls; it was found and brought to the camp the next day, amidst many tears from the soldiers. Fabius, putting aside all other concerns, honored his colleague's funeral in the most dignified manner, praising him with the high accolades he justly deserved.

30

During the same period, matters were managed successfully by Cneius Fulvius, propraetor, he having, besides the immense losses occasioned to the enemy by the devastation of their lands, fought a battle with extraordinary success, in which there were above three thousand of the Perusians and Clusians slain, and twenty military standards taken. The Samnites, in their flight, passing through the Pelignian territory, were attacked on all sides by the Pelignians; and, out of five thousand, one thousand were killed. The glory of the day on which they fought at Sentinum was great, even when truly estimated; but some have gone beyond credibility by their exaggerations, who assert in their writings, that there were in the army of the enemy forty thousand three hundred and thirty foot, six thousand horse, and one thousand chariots, that is, including the Etrurians and Umbrians, who [they affirm] were present in the engagement: and, to magnify likewise the number of Roman forces, they add to the consuls another general, Lucius Volumnius, proconsul, and his army to the legions of the consul. In the greater number of annals, that victory is ascribed entirely to the two consuls. Volumnius was employed in the mean time in Samnium; he drove the army of the Samnites to Mount Tifernus, and, not deterred by the difficulty of the ground, routed and dispersed them. Quintus Fabius, leaving Decius's army in Etruria, and leading off his own legions to the city, triumphed over the Gauls, Etrurians, and Samnites: the soldiers attended him in his triumph. The victory of Quintus Fabius was not more highly celebrated, in their coarse military verses, than the illustrious death of Publius Decius; and the memory of the father was recalled, whose fame had been equalled by the praiseworthy conduct of the son, in respect of the issue which resulted both to himself and to the public. Out of the spoil, donations were made to the soldiers of eighty-two asses [4] to each, with cloaks and vests; rewards for service, in that age, by no means contemptible.

During the same time, Cneius Fulvius managed things well as propraetor. He caused significant losses to the enemy through the destruction of their lands and fought a remarkably successful battle, where over three thousand Perusians and Clusians were killed, and twenty military standards were captured. The Samnites, while fleeing through Pelignian territory, were attacked on all sides by the Pelignians, resulting in one thousand of their five thousand being killed. The glory of the battle at Sentinum was impressive, but some writers exaggerated their accounts, claiming that the enemy had forty thousand three hundred and thirty foot soldiers, six thousand cavalry, and one thousand chariots, including the Etrurians and Umbrians who were purportedly present during the fight. To further inflate the number of Roman troops, they included another leader, Lucius Volumnius, proconsul, with his army alongside the consul’s legions. Most historical records attribute the victory solely to the two consuls. Meanwhile, Volumnius was engaged in Samnium, where he pushed the Samnite army to Mount Tifernus and, undeterred by the tough terrain, defeated and scattered them. Quintus Fabius, after leaving Decius’s army in Etruria, returned with his own legions to the city, triumphing over the Gauls, Etrurians, and Samnites. His soldiers celebrated him during his triumph. The victory of Quintus Fabius was praised in their rough military verses just as much as the heroic death of Publius Decius; they remembered his father, whose reputation his son matched through his commendable actions, which benefited both himself and the public. From the spoils, the soldiers received donations of eighty-two asses [4] each, along with cloaks and vests; rewards for service that were definitely significant for that time.

31

Notwithstanding these successes, peace was not yet established, either among the Samnites or Etrurians: for the latter, at the instigation of the Perusians, resumed their arms, after his army had been withdrawn by the consul; and the Samnites made predatory incursions on the territories of Vescia and Formiae; and also on the other side, on those of Aesernia, and the parts adjacent to the river Vulturnus. Against these was sent the praetor Appius Claudius, with the army formerly commanded by Decius. In Etruria, Fabius, on the revival of hostilities, slew four thousand five hundred of the Perusians, and took prisoners one thousand seven hundred and forty, who were ransomed at the rate of three hundred and ten asses [5] each. All the rest of the spoil was bestowed on the soldiers. The legions of the Samnites, though pursued, some by the praetor Appius Claudius, the others by Lucius Volumnius, proconsul, formed a junction in the country of the Stellatians. Here sat down the whole body of the Samnites; and Appius and Volumnius, with their forces united in one camp. A battle was fought with the most rancorous animosity, one party being spurred on by rage against men who had so often renewed their attacks on them, and the other now fighting in support of their last remaining hope. Accordingly, there were slain, of the Samnites, sixteen thousand three hundred, and two thousand and seven hundred made prisoners: of the Roman army fell two thousand and seven hundred. This year, so successful in the operations of war, was filled with distress at home, arising from a pestilence, and with anxiety, occasioned by prodigies: for accounts were received that, in many places, showers of earth had fallen; and that very many persons, in the army of Appius Claudius, had been struck by lightning; in consequence of which, the books were consulted. At this time, Quintus Fabius Gurges, the consul's son, having prosecuted some matrons before the people on a charge of adultery, built, with the money accruing from the fines which they were condemned to pay, the temple of Venus, which stands near the circus. Still we have the wars of the Samnites on our hands, notwithstanding that the relation of them has already extended, in one continued course, through four volumes of our history, and through a period of forty-six years, from the consulate of Marcus Valerius and Aulus Cornelius, who first carried the Roman arms into Samnium. And, not to recite the long train of disasters sustained by both nations, and the toils which they underwent, by which, however, their stubborn breasts could not be subdued; even in the course of the last year, the Samnites, with their own forces separately, and also in conjunction with those of other nations, had been defeated by four several armies, and four generals of the Romans, in the territory of Sentinum, in that of the Pelignians, at Tifernum, and in the plains of the Stellatians; had lost the general of the highest character in their nation; and, now, saw their allies in the war, the Etrurians, the Umbrians, and the Gauls, in the same situation with themselves; but, although they could now no longer stand, either by their own or by foreign resources, yet did they not desist from the prosecution of hostilities. So far were they from being weary of defending liberty, even though unsuccessfully: and they preferred being defeated to not aspiring after victory. Who does not find his patience tired, either in writing, or reading, of wars of such continuance; and which yet exhausted not the resolution of the parties concerned?

Notwithstanding these successes, peace had not yet been achieved, either among the Samnites or Etrurians. The latter, urged on by the Perusians, resumed fighting after the consul had pulled back his army. The Samnites launched raids into the territories of Vescia and Formiae, as well as into Aesernia and areas near the river Vulturnus. To address this, praetor Appius Claudius was sent with the army previously led by Decius. In Etruria, when hostilities flared up again, Fabius killed four thousand five hundred Perusians and captured one thousand seven hundred and forty, who were ransomed for three hundred and ten asses [5] each. The rest of the spoils were given to the soldiers. The Samnite legions, even while being pursued—some by praetor Appius Claudius and others by Lucius Volumnius, proconsul—united in the land of the Stellatians. Both groups of Samnites then established a camp together, and Appius and Volumnius joined their forces into one camp. A fiercely contested battle took place, with one side driven by rage against their frequent attackers, while the other fought for their last remaining hope. Consequently, sixteen thousand three hundred Samnites were killed, and two thousand seven hundred were taken prisoner; two thousand seven hundred from the Roman army died. This year, despite successes in military operations, was marked by distress at home due to a plague, along with anxiety caused by omens, as reports came in that showers of earth had fallen in many areas, and many in Appius Claudius's army had been struck by lightning, prompting a consultation of the sacred texts. During this time, Quintus Fabius Gurges, the consul's son, brought some matrons before the people on charges of adultery and used the fines they were ordered to pay to build the temple of Venus near the circus. We still face the Samnite wars, even though the account of them has already spanned four volumes of our history over a period of forty-six years, dating back to the consulate of Marcus Valerius and Aulus Cornelius, who first took Roman arms into Samnium. Without recounting the long series of disasters experienced by both nations and the struggles they endured, which nevertheless could not break their stubborn spirits; even last year, the Samnites, both separately and alongside forces from other nations, were defeated by four Roman armies and generals in the regions of Sentinum, Pelignians, Tifernum, and the plains of the Stellatians; they lost their most respected general and now saw their allies—the Etrurians, Umbrians, and Gauls—in the same predicament as themselves. Yet, even though they could no longer rely on their own or foreign resources, they did not give up on fighting. Far from being tired of defending their freedom, even if unsuccessfully, they preferred being defeated to not striving for victory. Who doesn’t get weary, either from writing or reading about wars that seem to drag on forever, yet fail to exhaust the resolve of those involved?

32

Quintus Fabius and Publius Decius were succeeded in the consulship by Lucius Postumius Megellus and Marcus Atilius Regulus. The province of Samnium was decreed to both in conjunction; because intelligence had been received that the enemy had embodied three armies; with one that Etruria was to be recovered; with another the ravages in Campania were to be repeated; and the third was intended for the defence of their frontiers. Sickness detained Postumius at Rome, but Atilius set out immediately, with design to surprise the enemy in Samnium, before they should have advanced beyond their own borders; for such had been the directions of the senate. The Romans met the enemy, as if by mutual appointment, at a spot where, while they could be hindered, not only from ravaging, but even from entering the Samnite territory, they could likewise hinder the Samnites from continuing their progress into the countries which were quiet, and the lands of the allies of the Roman people. While their camps lay opposite to each other, the Samnites attempted an enterprise, which the Romans, so often their conquerors, would scarcely have ventured to undertake; such is the rashness inspired by extreme despair: this was to make an assault on the Roman camp. And although this attempt, so daring, succeeded not in its full extent, yet it was not without effect. There was a fog, which continued through a great part of the day, so thick as to exclude the light of the sun, and to prevent not only the view of any thing beyond the rampart, but scarcely the sight of each other, when they should meet. Depending on this, as a covering to the design, when the sun was scarcely yet risen, and the light which he did afford was obscured by the fog, the Samnites came up to an advanced guard of the Romans at one of the gates, who were standing carelessly on their post. In the sudden surprise, these had neither courage nor strength to make resistance: an assault was then made, through the Decuman gate, in the rear of the camp: the quaestor's quarters in consequence were taken, and the quaestor, Lucius Opimius Pansa, was there slain; on this a general alarm was given to take up arms.

Quintus Fabius and Publius Decius were followed in the consulship by Lucius Postumius Megellus and Marcus Atilius Regulus. The province of Samnium was assigned to both of them together because news had come in that the enemy had gathered three armies: one to reclaim Etruria, another to devastate Campania again, and the third to defend their borders. Postumius was ill and stayed in Rome, but Atilius left immediately, intending to catch the enemy off guard in Samnium before they moved past their own borders, as directed by the senate. The Romans met the enemy at a spot where they could not only stop them from raiding but also prevent the Samnites from advancing into peaceful territories and the lands of Roman allies. While their camps faced each other, the Samnites attempted a bold move that even the Romans, their usual conquerors, would have hesitated to make; this was to attack the Roman camp. Although this daring attempt did not fully succeed, it still had an impact. A thick fog hung over the area for much of the day, blocking out sunlight and making it difficult to see anything beyond the rampart, and even hard to see one another when they encountered each other. Taking advantage of this cover, just as the sun was barely rising and the light was obscured by the fog, the Samnites approached an unsuspecting Roman guard at one of the gates, who were standing relaxed at their post. In the sudden surprise, they lacked the courage and strength to resist: an assault was launched through the Decuman gate, at the back of the camp. The quarters of the quaestor were captured, and the quaestor, Lucius Opimius Pansa, was killed there; this triggered a general alarm for everyone to take up arms.

33

The consul, being roused by the tumult, ordered two cohorts of the allies, a Lucanian and Suessanian, which happened to be nearest, to defend the head-quarters, and led the companies of the legions down the principal street. These ran into the ranks, scarcely taking time to furnish themselves with arms; and, as they distinguished the enemy by their shout rather than by sight, could form no judgment how great their number might be: thus, ignorant of the circumstances of their situation, they at first drew back, and admitted the enemy into the heart of the camp. Then when the consul cried out, asking them, whether they intended to let themselves be beaten out beyond the rampart, and then to return again to storm their own camp, they raised the shout, and uniting their efforts, stood their ground; then made advances, pushed closely on the enemy, and having forced them to give way, drove them back, without suffering their first terror to abate. They soon beat them out beyond the gate and the rampart, but not daring to pursue them, because the darkness of the weather made them apprehend an ambush, and content with having cleared the camp, they retired within the rampart, having killed about three hundred of the enemy. Of the Romans, including the first advanced guard and the watchmen, and those who were surprised at the quaestor's quarters, two hundred and thirty perished. This not unsuccessful piece of boldness raised the spirits of the Samnites so high, that they not only did not suffer the Romans to march forward into their country, but even to procure forage from their lands; and the foragers were obliged to go back into the quiet country of Sora. News of these events being conveyed to Rome, with circumstances of alarm magnified beyond the truth, obliged Lucius Postumius, the consul, though scarcely recovered from his illness, to set out for the army. However, before his departure, having issued a proclamation that his troops should assemble at Sora, he dedicated the temple of Victory, for the building of which he had provided, when curule aedile, out of the money arising from fines; and, joining the army, he advanced from Sora towards Samnium, to the camp of his colleague. The Samnites, despairing of being able to make head against the two armies, retreated from thence, on which the consuls, separating, proceeded by different routes to lay waste the enemy's lands and besiege their towns.

The consul, disturbed by the noise, ordered two battalions of allies—a Lucanian and a Suessanian, which were the closest—to defend the headquarters and led the legion companies down the main street. They ran into formation, barely taking the time to grab their weapons, and since they recognized the enemy more by their shouts than by sight, they couldn’t gauge how many there were. Unsure of their situation, they initially fell back and allowed the enemy to penetrate deep into the camp. Then, when the consul shouted at them, asking if they intended to let themselves be pushed out beyond the rampart and come back to attack their own camp, they raised their voices and combined their efforts to hold their ground. They moved forward, pressed the enemy closely, and, keeping their initial fear in check, pushed them back. They soon forced them out beyond the gate and the rampart but didn't dare to chase them because the darkness raised concerns about an ambush. Satisfied with having cleared the camp, they retreated behind the rampart after killing about three hundred of the enemy. Among the Romans, including the first advance guard, the watchmen, and those caught off guard at the quaestor's quarters, two hundred and thirty were killed. This somewhat successful act of bravery boosted the morale of the Samnites so much that they not only prevented the Romans from advancing into their territory but also from gathering supplies from their lands, forcing the foragers to retreat to the peaceful area of Sora. When news of these events reached Rome, exaggerated for effect, it compelled Lucius Postumius, the consul, who was still recovering from his illness, to leave for the army. Before departing, he announced that his troops should gather at Sora and dedicated the temple of Victory, which he had funded when he was a curule aedile with money from fines. Joining the army, he moved from Sora towards Samnium to his colleague's camp. The Samnites, realizing they couldn’t stand against the two armies, retreated from there, prompting the consuls to split up and take different paths to devastate the enemy’s lands and besiege their towns.

34

Postumius attempted to make himself master of Milionia, at first by storm and an assault; but these not succeeding, he carried his approaches to the walls, and thus gained an entrance into the place. The fight was continued in all parts of the city from the fourth hour until near the eighth, the result being a long time uncertain: the Romans at last gained possession of the town. Three thousand two hundred of the Samnites were killed, four thousand seven hundred taken, besides the other booty. From thence the legions were conducted to Ferentinum, out of which the inhabitants had, during the night, retired in silence through the opposite gate, with all their effects which could be either carried or driven. The consul, on his arrival, approached the walls with the same order and circumspection, as if he were to meet an opposition here equal to what he had experienced at Milionia. Then, perceiving a dead silence in the city, and neither arms nor men on the towers and ramparts, he restrains the soldiers, who were eager to mount the deserted fortifications, lest they might fall into a snare. He ordered two divisions of the confederate Latin horse to ride round the walls, and explore every particular. These horsemen observed one gate, and, at a little distance, another on the same side, standing wide open, and on the roads leading from these every mark of the enemy having fled by night. They then rode up leisurely to the gates, from whence, with perfect safety, they took a clear view through straight streets quite across the city. They report to the consul, that the city was abandoned by the enemy, as was plain from the solitude, the recent tracks on their retreat, and the things which, in the confusion of the night, they had left scattered up and down. On hearing this, the consul led round the army to that side of the city which had been examined, and making the troops halt at a little distance from the gate, gave orders that five horsemen should ride into the city; and when they should have advanced a good way into it, then, if they saw all things safe, three should remain there, and the other two return to him with intelligence. These returned and said, that they had proceeded to a part of the town from which they had a view on every side, and that nothing but silence and solitude reigned through the whole extent of it. The consul immediately led some light-armed cohorts into the city; ordering the rest to fortify a camp in the mean time. The soldiers who entered the town, breaking open the doors, found only a few persons, disabled by age or sickness; and such effects left behind as could not, without difficulty, be removed. These were seized as plunder: and it was discovered from the prisoners, that several cities in that quarter had, in pursuance of a concerted plan, resolved on flight; that their towns-people had gone off at the first watch, and they believed that the same solitude they should find in the other places. The accounts of the prisoners proved well-founded, and the consul took possession of the forsaken towns.

Postumius tried to take control of Milionia first with an attack, but when that failed, he moved closer to the walls and managed to break in. The battle raged throughout the city from around 10 AM to nearly 2 PM, with the outcome remaining uncertain for a long time, but eventually, the Romans seized the town. They killed 3,200 Samnites and captured 4,700, along with other loot. After that, the legions moved to Ferentinum, where the inhabitants had quietly fled through the opposite gate during the night, taking whatever they could carry or drive. When the consul arrived, he approached the walls with the same caution as if he expected strong resistance like he had at Milionia. Noticing the eerie silence in the city with no weapons or soldiers on the towers, he held back his eager soldiers from climbing the abandoned fortifications to avoid falling into a trap. He sent two groups of allied Latin cavalry to circle the walls and investigate. They found one gate, and not far away, another one wide open, along with clear signs that the enemy had fled during the night. They then rode slowly to the gates, where they safely got a clear view of the straight streets across the city. They reported back to the consul that the enemy had abandoned the city, evident from the emptiness, the tracks of their retreat, and the items left scattered in the confusion of the night. Upon hearing this, the consul brought the army to that side of the city they had examined and had the troops halt a bit away from the gate. He ordered five horsemen to enter the city; if they found everything safe, three would stay there while two would return to inform him. The two returned and said they had checked a part of the town where they could see in all directions, and it was completely silent and deserted. The consul immediately led some light-armed troops into the city while ordering the rest to set up camp. The soldiers who entered broke open doors and found only a few people, either too old or sick to leave, and items that were too difficult to take. They seized what they could as plunder and learned from the prisoners that several cities in the area had planned to escape; their residents had left at the first watch, and they believed they would find the same emptiness in those places. The information from the prisoners turned out to be accurate, and the consul took control of the abandoned towns.

35

The war was by no means so easy with the other consul, Marcus Atilius. As he was marching his legions towards Luceria, to which he was informed that the Samnites had laid siege, the enemy met him on the border of the Lucerian territory. Rage supplied them, on this occasion, with strength to equal his: the battle was stubbornly contested, and the victory doubtful; in the issue, however, more calamitous on the side of the Romans, both because they were unaccustomed to defeat, and that, on leaving the field, they felt more sensibly, than during the heat of the action, how much more wounds and bloodshed had been on their side. In consequence of this, such dismay spread through the camp, as, had it seized them during the engagement, a signal defeat would have been the result. Even as the matter stood, they spent the night in great anxiety; expecting, every instant, that the Samnites would assault the camp; or that, at the first light, they should be obliged to stand a battle with a victorious enemy. On the side of the enemy, however, although there was less loss, yet there was not greater courage. As soon as day appeared, they wished to retire without any more fighting; but there was only one road, and that leading close by the post of their enemy; on their taking which, they seemed as if advancing directly to attack the camp. The consul, therefore, ordered his men to take arms, and to follow him outside the rampart, giving directions to the lieutenants-general, tribunes, and the praefects of the allies, in what manner he would have each of them act. They all assured him that "they would do every thing in their power, but that the soldiers were quite dejected; that, from their own wounds, and the groans of the dying, they had passed the whole night without sleep; that if the enemy had approached the camp before day, so great were the fears of the troops, that they would certainly have deserted their standards." "Even at present they were restrained from flight merely by shame; and, in other respects, were little better than vanquished men." This account made the consul judge it necessary to go himself among the soldiers, and speak to them; and, as he came up to each, he rebuked them for their backwardness in taking arms, asking, "Why they loitered, and declined the fight? If they did not choose to go out of the camp, the enemy would come into it; and they must fight in defence of their tents, if they would not in defence of the rampart. Men who have arms in their hands, and contend with their foe, have always a chance for victory; but the man who waits naked and unarmed for his enemy, must suffer either death or slavery." To these reprimands and rebukes they answered, that "they were exhausted by the fatigue of the battle of yesterday; and had no strength, nor even blood remaining; and besides, the enemy appeared more numerous than they were the day before." The hostile army, in the mean time, drew near; so that, seeing every thing more distinctly as the distance grew less, they asserted that the Samnites carried with them pallisades for a rampart, and evidently intended to draw lines of circumvallation round the camp. On this the consul exclaimed, with great earnestness, against submitting to such an ignominious insult, and from so dastardly a foe. "Shall we even be blockaded," said he, "in our camp, and die, with ignominy, by famine, rather than bravely by the sword, if it must be so? May the gods be propitious! and let every one act in the manner which he thinks becomes him. The consul Marcus Atilius, should no other accompany him, will go out, even alone, to face the enemy; and will fall in the middle of the Samnite battalions, rather than see the Roman camp enclosed by their trenches." The lieutenants-general, tribunes, every troop of the cavalry, and the principal centurions, expressed their approbation of what the consul said; and the soldiers at length, overcome by shame, took up their arms, but in a spiritless manner; and in the same spiritless manner, marched out of the camp. In a long train, and that not every where connected, melancholy, and seemingly subdued, they proceeded towards the enemy, whose hopes and courage, were not more steady than theirs. As soon therefore as the Roman standards were beheld, a murmur spread from front to rear of the Samnites, that, as they had feared, "the Romans were coming out to oppose their march; that there was no road open, through which they could even fly thence; in that spot they must fall, or else cut down the enemy's ranks, and make their way over their bodies."

The war was far from easy for the other consul, Marcus Atilius. As he was leading his legions towards Luceria, where he had been told the Samnites were laying siege, the enemy confronted him at the edge of Lucerian territory. Rage fueled them this time, giving them strength equal to his: the battle was fiercely contested, and the outcome uncertain. However, the Romans suffered more calamities in the end, not only because they were unaccustomed to defeat but also because, as they left the battlefield, they felt more acutely than during the heat of the fight how many wounds and how much blood had been shed on their side. As a result, a wave of dismay swept through the camp. If this fear had seized them during the battle, it could have led to a complete rout. Even as it was, they spent the night in great anxiety, anticipating that the Samnites would attack their camp or, at dawn, they would have to fight a battle with a victorious enemy. On the enemy’s side, although they had suffered less, their courage did not increase. As soon as day broke, they wanted to retreat without further fighting, but there was only one road, which ran right by their enemy’s position; taking that road made it look like they were directly advancing to attack the camp. Therefore, the consul ordered his men to arm themselves and follow him outside the rampart, giving instructions to the lieutenants-general, tribunes, and the praefects of the allies on how each should act. They all assured him that they would do everything possible, but that the soldiers were genuinely demoralized; they had spent the entire night without sleep, exhausted by their wounds and the groans of the dying. They said that if the enemy had approached the camp before dawn, the troops were so afraid that they would have surely deserted their standards. “Even now, they are held back from fleeing only by shame, and in all other respects are no better than defeated men.” This account made the consul feel it was necessary to speak directly to the soldiers. As he approached each one, he scolded them for their hesitance to take up arms, asking, “Why are you dragging your feet and avoiding the fight? If you don’t want to leave the camp, the enemy will come in; you’ll have to defend your tents if you won’t defend the rampart. Men with weapons in their hands, fighting their foe, always have a chance at victory; but the man who waits unarmed for his enemy is destined for either death or slavery.” To these reprimands, they replied that they were worn out from the previous day's battle, having no strength or even blood left; plus, the enemy looked more numerous than before. Meanwhile, the opposing army drew closer, and as the distance shrank, they saw more clearly that the Samnites were carrying stakes for a barricade and clearly intended to surround the camp. This prompted the consul to passionately exclaim against enduring such disgraceful insult from such a cowardly foe. “Shall we really be blockaded in our camp, dying in shame from starvation rather than bravely by the sword if it comes to that? May the gods be favorable! Let everyone act in the way they think is right. I, consul Marcus Atilius, will go out even alone to face the enemy; I would rather fall in the midst of the Samnite battalions than see the Roman camp surrounded by their trenches.” The lieutenants-general, tribunes, every cavalry unit, and the leading centurions showed their support for what the consul said. Finally, the soldiers, overcome by shame, picked up their arms, but they did so without enthusiasm, marching out of the camp in a lifeless manner. In a long, scattered line, looking melancholy and seemingly subdued, they advanced toward the enemy, whose hopes and courage were no steadier than theirs. As soon as the Roman standards came into view, a murmur spread among the Samnites, confirming their fears that “the Romans were coming out to block their march; there was no escape route, and they must either fall there or cut through the ranks of their enemies to make their way over their bodies.”

36

They then threw the baggage in a heap in the centre, and, with their arms prepared for battle, formed their line, each falling into his post. There was now but a small interval between the two armies, and both stood, waiting until the shout and onset should be begun by their adversary. Neither party had any inclination to fight, and they would have separated, and taken different roads, unhurt and untouched, but that each had a dread of being harassed, in retreat, by the other. Notwithstanding this shyness and reluctance, an engagement unavoidably began, but spiritless, and with a shout which discovered neither resolution nor steadiness; nor did any move a foot from his post. The Roman consul, then, in order to infuse life into the action, ordered a few troops of cavalry to advance out of the line and charge: most of whom being thrown from their horses and the rest put in disorder, several parties ran forward, both from the Samnite line, to cut off those who had fallen, and from the Roman, to protect their friends. In consequence the battle became a little more brisk, but the Samnites had come forward with more briskness, and also in greater numbers, and the disordered cavalry, with their affrighted horses, trod down their own party who came to their relief. Flight commencing in this quarter, caused the whole Roman line to turn their backs. And now the Samnites had no employment for their arms but against the rear of a flying enemy, when the consul, galloping on before his men to the gate of the camp, posted there a body of cavalry, with orders to treat as an enemy any person who should make towards the rampart, whether Roman or Samnite; and, placing himself in the way of his men, as they pressed in disorder towards the camp, denounced threats to the same purport: "Whither are you going, soldiers?" said he; "here also you will find both men and arms; nor, while your consul lives, shall you pass the rampart, unless victorious. Choose therefore which you will prefer, fighting against your own countrymen, or the enemy." While the consul was thus speaking the cavalry gathered round, with the points of their spears presented, and ordered the infantry to return to the fight. Not only his own brave spirit, but fortune likewise aided the consul, for the Samnites did not push their advantage; so that he had time to wheel round his battalions, and to change his front from the camp towards the enemy. The men then began to encourage each other to return to the battle, while the centurions snatched the ensigns from the standard-bearers and bore them forward, pointing out to the soldiers the enemy, coming on in a hurry, few in number, and with their ranks disordered. At the same time the consul, with his hands lifted up towards heaven, and raising his voice so as to be heard at a distance, vowed a temple to Jupiter Stator, if the Roman army should rally from flight, and, renewing the battle, cut down and defeat the Samnites. All divisions of the army, now, united their efforts to restore the fight; officers, soldiers, the whole force, both of cavalry and infantry; even the powers of heaven seemed to have looked, with favour, on the Roman cause; so speedily was a thorough change effected in the fortune of the day, the enemy being repulsed from the camp, and, in a short time, driven back to the spot where the battle had commenced. Here they stopped, being obstructed by the heap of baggage, lying in their way, where they had thrown it together; and then, to prevent the plundering of their effects, formed round them a circle of troops. On this, the infantry assailed them vigorously in front, while the cavalry, wheeling, fell on their rear: and, being thus enclosed between the two, they were all either slain, or taken prisoners. The number of the prisoners was seven thousand two hundred, who were all sent under the yoke; the killed amounted to four thousand eight hundred. The victory did not prove a joyous one, even on the side of the Romans: when the consul took an account of the loss sustained in the two days, the number returned, of soldiers lost, was seven thousand three hundred. During these transactions in Apulia, the Samnites with the other army having attempted to seize on Iteramna, a Roman colony situated on the Latin road, did not however obtain the town; whence, after ravaging the country, as they were driving off spoil, consisting of men and cattle, together with the colonists whom they had taken, they met the consul returning victorious from Luceria, and not only lost their booty, but marching in disorder, in a long train, and heavily encumbered, were themselves cut to pieces. The consul, by proclamation, summoned the owners to Interamna, to claim and receive again their property, and leaving his army there, went to Rome to hold the elections. On his applying for a triumph, that honour was refused him, because he had lost so many thousands of his soldiers; and also, because he had sent the prisoners under the yoke without imposing any conditions.

They then tossed the baggage into a pile in the center, and with their arms ready for battle, formed their line, each taking his position. There was now just a small gap between the two armies, and both stood, waiting for their opponent to make the first move with a shout and attack. Neither side wanted to fight, and they could have split up and taken different paths, unharmed and untouched, if they hadn't feared being chased by the other side in retreat. Despite this hesitance and unwillingness, a battle inevitably began, but it was lifeless, with a shout that showed neither determination nor confidence; none moved a step from their position. The Roman consul then, to inject some energy into the action, ordered a few cavalry troops to advance out of line and charge: most were thrown from their horses and the rest were disordered, prompting several groups to rush forward, both from the Samnite line to take out the fallen, and from the Roman side to protect their comrades. As a result, the battle picked up a bit, but the Samnites pressed forward with more enthusiasm and greater numbers, and the disorganized cavalry, along with their scared horses, trampled their own allies rushing to help. The flight that began in this section caused the entire Roman line to turn and run. Now, the Samnites had no target for their weapons except the back of a fleeing enemy, when the consul, riding ahead of his men to the camp gate, stationed a body of cavalry there, instructing them to treat anyone approaching the rampart, whether Roman or Samnite, as an enemy; and, placing himself in front of his men as they hurriedly moved toward the camp, he shouted threats that carried the same message: "Where are you going, soldiers?" he asked; "you will find both men and arms here; and as long as your consul is alive, you will not pass the rampart without victory. So choose whether you want to fight against your fellow countrymen or the enemy." While the consul was talking, the cavalry gathered around, with their spear points aimed, and commanded the infantry to return to the fight. Not only his own brave spirit, but also luck helped the consul since the Samnites did not pursue their advantage; thus, he had time to reposition his battalions and turn his front from the camp toward the enemy. The men then encouraged each other to return to battle, while the centurions seized the standards from the standard-bearers and held them forward, indicating to the soldiers the enemy, who were rushing in, few in number, and disorganized. At the same time, the consul, raising his hands toward heaven and raising his voice to be heard from a distance, vowed to build a temple to Jupiter Stator if the Roman army could rally from flight and defeat the Samnites. All sections of the army then combined efforts to restore the fight; officers, soldiers, the entire force, both cavalry and infantry; even the powers of heaven seemed to favor the Roman cause; so quickly was a complete change made in the day's fortune, the enemy being pushed back from the camp, and soon forced back to where the battle had started. Here they halted, blocked by the pile of baggage they had thrown together; and then, to prevent their belongings from being plundered, they formed a circle of troops around it. Consequently, the infantry aggressively attacked them from the front while the cavalry wheeled around to hit them from behind: thus trapped between the two, they were either killed or captured. The total number of prisoners amounted to seven thousand two hundred, all sent under the yoke; the dead numbered four thousand eight hundred. The victory was not a joyous one, even for the Romans: when the consul took stock of the losses over the two days, the number of soldiers lost was seven thousand three hundred. During this time in Apulia, the Samnites, with another army, attempted to seize Iteramna, a Roman colony located on the Latin road, but did not succeed in taking the town; consequently, after plundering the area, as they were carrying off spoils of men and livestock, along with the colonists they had captured, they encountered the victorious consul returning from Luceria, and not only lost their loot but, marching in disarray in a long line, heavily burdened, were themselves slaughtered. The consul, by proclamation, summoned the owners to Iteramna to reclaim their property, and leaving his army there, went to Rome to hold the elections. When he applied for a triumph, that honor was denied him due to the large number of soldiers he had lost; also, because he had sent the prisoners under the yoke without any conditions.

37

The other consul, Postumius, because there was no employment for his arms in Samnium, having led over his forces into Etruria, first laid waste the lands of the Volsinians; and afterwards, on their marching out to protect their country, gained a decisive victory over them, at a small distance from their own walls. Two thousand two hundred of the Etrurians were slain; the proximity of their city protected the rest. The army was then led into the territory of Rusella, and there, not only were the lands wasted, but the town itself taken. More than two thousand men were made prisoners, and somewhat less than that number killed on the walls. But a peace, effected that year in Etruria, was still more important and honourable than the war had been. Three very powerful cities, the chief ones of Etruria, (Volsinii, Perusia, and Arretium,) sued for peace; and having stipulated with the consul to furnish clothing and corn for his army, on condition of being permitted to send deputies to Rome, they obtained a truce for forty years, and a fine was imposed on each state of five hundred thousand asses,[6] to be immediately paid. When the consul demanded a triumph from the senate, in consideration of these services, rather to comply with the general practice, than in hope of succeeding; and when he saw that one party, his own personal enemies, another party, the friends of his colleague, refused him the triumph, the latter to console a similar refusal, some on the plea that he had been rather tardy in taking his departure from the city; others, that he had passed from Samnium into Etruria without orders from the senate; he said, "Conscript fathers, I shall not be so far mindful of your dignity, as to forget that I am consul. By the same right of office by which I conducted the war, I shall now have a triumph, when this war has been brought to a happy conclusion, Samnium and Etruria being subdued, and victory and peace procured. With these words he left the senate." On this arose a contention between the plebeian tribunes; some of them declaring that they would protest against his triumphing in a manner unprecedented; others, that they would support his pretensions, in opposition to their colleagues. The affair came at length to be discussed before the people, and the consul being summoned to attend, when he represented, that Marcus Horatius and Lucius Valerius, when consuls, and lately Caius Marcus Rutilus, father of the present censor, had triumphed, not by direction of the senate, but by that of the people; he then added that "he would in like manner have laid his request before the public, had he not known that some plebeian tribunes, the abject slaves of the nobles, would have obstructed the law. That the universal approbation and will of the people were and should be with him equivalent to any order whatsoever." Accordingly, on the day following, by the support of three plebeian tribunes, in opposition to the protest of the other seven, and the declared judgment of the senate, he triumphed; and the people paid every honour to the day. The historical accounts regarding this year are by no means consistent; Claudius asserts, that Postumius, after having taken several cities in Samnium, was defeated and put to flight in Apulia; and that, being wounded himself, he was driven, with a few attendants, into Luceria. That the war in Etruria was conducted by Atilius, and that it was he who triumphed. Fabius writes, that the two consuls acted in conjunction, both in Samnium and at Luceria; that an army was led over into Etruria, but by which of the consuls he has not mentioned; that at Luceria, great numbers were slain on both sides; and that in that battle, the temple of Jupiter Stator was vowed, the same vow having been formerly made by Romulus, but the fane only, that is, the area appropriated for the temple, had been yet consecrated. However, in this year, the state having been twice bound by the same vow, it became a matter of religious obligation that the senate should order the temple to be erected.

The other consul, Postumius, since there was no opportunity for his troops in Samnium, moved his forces into Etruria. He first devastated the lands of the Volsinians; and later, when they marched out to defend their territory, he scored a decisive victory over them just outside their city walls. Two thousand two hundred Etrurians were killed; the closeness of their city saved the others. The army then entered the territory of Rusella, where not only were the lands destroyed, but the town itself was captured. More than two thousand men were taken prisoner, and a little less than that number were killed on the walls. However, a peace agreement made that year in Etruria was even more significant and honorable than the war had been. Three powerful cities, the main ones in Etruria (Volsinii, Perusia, and Arretium), sought peace; and after agreeing with the consul to provide clothing and grain for his army, in exchange for being allowed to send representatives to Rome, they secured a truce for forty years, with each state paying a fine of five hundred thousand asses, to be paid immediately. When the consul asked the senate for a triumph in recognition of these achievements, it was more to follow the usual procedure than out of hope for success. When he saw that one group, his personal enemies, and another, the friends of his colleague, denied him the triumph—some claiming he had delayed leaving the city and others saying he moved from Samnium to Etruria without the senate’s orders—he replied, “Conscript fathers, I won't be so concerned with your dignity that I forget I am consul. By the same authority I used to lead the war, I will now have a triumph, since this conflict has ended successfully, with Samnium and Etruria subdued, and victory and peace achieved.” With that, he left the senate. This sparked a debate among the plebeian tribunes; some declared they would oppose his triumph as unprecedented, while others pledged to support his claim against their colleagues. The matter was eventually discussed in front of the people, and when the consul was summoned, he argued that Marcus Horatius and Lucius Valerius, when consuls, and recently Caius Marcus Rutilus, the father of the current censor, had triumphed not by the senate's direction, but by the people's. He added that “he would have sought public approval in the same way if he hadn’t known that some plebeian tribunes, who were subservient to the nobles, would block the law. The collective support and will of the people should count as much as any order.” Therefore, the next day, with the backing of three plebeian tribunes, against the objections of the other seven and the declared stance of the senate, he triumphed; and the people honored the day. The historical accounts concerning this year vary significantly; Claudius claims that Postumius, after capturing several cities in Samnium, was defeated and routed in Apulia. He states that, wounded, he was forced to retreat to Luceria with just a few attendants. According to him, Atilius conducted the war in Etruria and was the one who triumphed. Fabius writes that the two consuls acted together, both in Samnium and at Luceria, and that an army was sent into Etruria, although he does not specify which consul led it; he notes that many were killed on both sides at Luceria and that in that battle, a vow was made to dedicate a temple to Jupiter Stator, a vow previously made by Romulus, but only the site for the temple had been consecrated. However, in this year, since the state had been twice bound by the same vow, it became a religious obligation for the senate to order the construction of the temple.

38

In the next year, we find a consul, distinguished by the united splendour of his own and his father's glory, Lucius Papirius Cursor, as also a war of vast importance, and a victory of such consequence, as no man, excepting Lucius Papirius, the consul's father, had ever before obtained over the Samnites. It happened too that these had, with the same care and pains as on the former occasion, decorated their soldiers with the richest suits of splendid armour; and they had, likewise, called in to their aid the power of the gods, having, as it were, initiated the soldiers, by administering the military oath, with the solemn ceremonies practised in ancient times, and levied troops in every part of Samnium, under an ordinance entirely new, that "if any of the younger inhabitants should not attend the meeting, according to the general's proclamation, or shall depart without permission, his head should be devoted to Jupiter." Orders being then issued, for all to assemble at Aquilonia, the whole strength of Samnium came together, amounting to forty thousand men. There a piece of ground, in the middle of the camp, was enclosed with hurdles and boards, and covered overhead with linen cloth, the sides being all of an equal length, about two hundred feet. In this place sacrifices were performed, according to directions read out of an old linen book, the priest being a very old man, called Ovius Paccius, who affirmed, that he took these ceremonials from the ancient ritual of the Samnites, being the same which their ancestors used, when they had formed the secret design of wresting Capua from the Etrurians. When the sacrifices were finished, the general ordered a beadle to summon every one of those who were most highly distinguished by their birth or conduct: these were introduced singly. Besides the other exhibitions of the solemnity, calculated to impress the mind with religious awe, there were, in the middle of the covered enclosure, altars erected, about which lay the victims slain, and the centurions stood around with their swords drawn. The soldier was led up to the altars, rather like a victim, than a performer in the ceremony, and was bound by an oath not to divulge what he should see and hear in that place. He was then compelled to swear, in a dreadful kind of form, containing execrations on his own person, on his family and race, if he did not go to battle, whithersoever the commanders should lead; and, if either he himself fled from the field, or, in case he should see any other flying, did not immediately kill him. At first some, refusing to take the oath, were put to death round the altars, and lying among the carcasses of the victims, served afterwards as a warning to others not to refuse it. When those of the first rank in the Samnite nation had been bound under these solemnities, the general nominated ten, whom he desired to choose each a man, and so to proceed until they should have called up the number of sixteen thousand. This body, from the covering of the enclosure wherein the nobility had been thus devoted, was called the linen legion. They were furnished with splendid armour and plumed helmets, to distinguish them above the rest. They had another body of forces, amounting to somewhat more than twenty thousand, not inferior to the linen legion, either in personal appearance, or renown in war, or their equipment. This number, composing the main strength of the nation, sat down at Aquilonia.

In the following year, we see a consul, marked by the combined brilliance of his and his father's achievements, Lucius Papirius Cursor. There is also a war of great significance and a victory of such importance that no one, except Lucius Papirius, the consul's father, had ever before achieved against the Samnites. The Samnites, with the same care and effort as before, outfitted their soldiers in the finest armor. They also invoked the gods' support, initiating the soldiers by administering the military oath through the solemn ceremonies practiced in ancient times and gathering troops from all over Samnium under a completely new rule that stated "if any young citizens failed to attend the meeting according to the general's proclamation, or left without permission, his life would be dedicated to Jupiter." Orders were then given for everyone to gather at Aquilonia, and the entire force of Samnium assembled, totaling around forty thousand men. There, a piece of land in the center of the camp was enclosed with hurdles and boards and covered with linen cloth, with all sides being equal in length, about two hundred feet. In this spot, sacrifices were conducted according to instructions read from an ancient linen book by a very old priest named Ovius Paccius. He claimed he was following the ancient rituals of the Samnites, the same practices their ancestors had used when they secretly planned to take Capua from the Etruscans. After the sacrifices were completed, the general commanded a messenger to summon all of those distinguished by their birth or deeds: they were brought in one by one. In addition to the various displays of the ceremony that instilled religious awe, altars were erected in the middle of the covered area, with the slain victims around them and centurions standing by with drawn swords. The soldier was led to the altars more like a victim than a participant in the ceremony and was bound by an oath not to reveal what he would see or hear there. He was then made to swear, in a terrifying manner, with curses upon himself, his family, and his lineage if he did not go to battle wherever the commanders led; and if he fled from the battlefield or saw another fleeing, he had to kill that person immediately. Initially, some who refused to take the oath were executed around the altars, their bodies lying among the victims, serving as a warning to others not to refuse it. Once the highest-ranking members of the Samnite nation had taken these oaths, the general selected ten men to each choose another until they had reached a total of sixteen thousand. This group, derived from the enclosure's nobility, was known as the linen legion. They were given splendid armor and feathered helmets to set them apart from the others. There was another force of slightly more than twenty thousand, equal to the linen legion in appearance, military reputation, and equipment. This number formed the main strength of the nation and settled in Aquilonia.

39

On the other side, the consuls set out from the city. First, Spurius Carvilius, to whom had been decreed the veteran legions, which Marcus Atilius, the consul of the preceding year, had left in the territory of Interamna, marched at their head into Samnium; and, while the enemy were busied in their superstitious rites, and holding their secret meeting, he took by storm the town of Amiternum. Here were slain about two thousand eight hundred men; and four thousand two hundred and seventy were made prisoners. Papirius, with a new army, which he raised in pursuance of a decree of the senate, made himself master of the city of Duronia. He took fewer prisoners than his colleague; but slew much greater numbers. Rich booty was acquired in both places. The consuls then, overrunning Samnium, and wasting the province of Atinum with particular severity, arrived, Carvilius at Cominium, and Papirius at Aquilonia, where the main force of the Samnites were posted. Here, for some time, there was neither a cessation of action, nor any vigorous effort. The day was generally spent in provoking the enemy when quiet, and retiring when they offered resistance; in menacing, rather than making an attack. By which practice of beginning, and then desisting, even those trifling skirmishes were continually left without a decision. The other Roman camp was twenty miles distant, and the advice of his absent colleague was appealed to on every thing which he undertook, while Carvilius, on his part, directed a greater share of his attention to Aquilonia, where the state of affairs was more critical and important, than to Cominium, which he himself was besieging. When Papirius had fully adjusted every measure, preparatory to an engagement, he despatched a message to his colleague, that "he intended, if the auspices permitted, to fight the enemy on the day following; and that it would be necessary that he (Carvilius) should at the same time make an assault on Cominium, with his utmost force, that the Samnites there might have no leisure to send any succour to Aquilonia." The messenger had the day for the performance of his journey, and he returned in the night, with an answer to the consul, that his colleague approved of the plan. Papirius, on sending off the messenger, had instantly called an assembly, where he descanted, at large, on the nature of the war in general, and on the present mode of equipment adopted by the enemy, which served for empty parade, rather than for any thing effectual towards insuring success; for "plumes," he said, "made no wounds; that a Roman javelin would make its way through shields, however painted and gilt; and that the army, refulgent from the whiteness of their tunics, would soon be besmeared with blood, when matters came to be managed with the sword. His father had formerly cut off, to a man, a gold and silver army of the Samnites; and such accoutrements had made a more respectable figure, as spoils, in the hands of the conquering foe, than as arms in those of the wearers. Perhaps it was allotted, by destiny, to his name and family, that they should be opposed in command against the most powerful efforts of the Samnites; and should bring home spoils, of such beauty, as to serve for ornaments to the public places. The immortal gods were certainly on his side, on account of the leagues so often solicited and so often broken. Besides, if a judgment might be formed of the sentiments of the deities, they never were more hostile to any army, than to that which, smeared with the blood of human beings mixed with that of cattle in their abominable sacrifice, doomed to the twofold resentment of the gods, dreading on the one hand the divinities, witnesses of the treaties concluded with the Romans, on the other hand the imprecations expressed in the oath sworn in contradiction to those treaties, swore with reluctance, abhorred the oath, and feared at once the gods, their countrymen, and their enemies."

On the other side, the consuls left the city. First, Spurius Carvilius, who had been assigned the veteran legions that Marcus Atilius, the consul from the previous year, had left in the territory of Interamna, marched at their head into Samnium. While the enemy was preoccupied with their superstitious rituals and secret meetings, he stormed the town of Amiternum. About two thousand eight hundred men were killed, and four thousand two hundred seventy were captured. Papirius, with a new army raised following a decree from the senate, took control of the city of Duronia. He took fewer prisoners than his colleague but killed many more. Rich loot was gained in both places. The consuls then, sweeping through Samnium and severely ravaging the province of Atinum, arrived, Carvilius at Cominium, and Papirius at Aquilonia, where the main force of the Samnites was stationed. Here, for a time, there was neither a break in action nor any strong effort. The day was mostly spent taunting the enemy when they were quiet and retreating when they resisted; they threatened rather than attacked. This tactic of starting and then stopping left even those minor skirmishes unresolved. The other Roman camp was twenty miles away, and they consulted his absent colleague about everything he undertook, while Carvilius focused more on Aquilonia, where the situation was more critical and important, than on Cominium, which he was besieging. When Papirius had completely arranged all plans for battle, he sent a message to his colleague, saying that "he intended, if the omens allowed, to fight the enemy the following day; and that it would be necessary for him (Carvilius) to simultaneously launch an assault on Cominium with all his strength, so the Samnites there would have no time to send help to Aquilonia." The messenger had the day to carry out his mission, returning at night with an answer from the consul that his colleague approved of the plan. After sending off the messenger, Papirius immediately called an assembly, where he elaborated on the nature of the war in general and the current equipment used by the enemy, which was more for show than for anything effective to ensure victory; for "feathers," he said, "don't cause wounds; a Roman spear can pierce shields, no matter how painted and gilded; and the army, shining in their white tunics, would soon be covered in blood when it came to fighting with swords. His father had once completely defeated a gold and silver army of the Samnites; and such gear looked better as trophies in the hands of the victors than as weapons worn by the soldiers. Perhaps destiny had decreed that his name and family would face the strongest efforts of the Samnites and bring home spoils so beautiful that they would decorate the public spaces. The immortal gods were certainly on his side due to the alliances that had so often been sought and so often broken. Moreover, if one could judge the feelings of the gods, they had never been more hostile to any army than to the one, smeared with human blood mixed with that of cattle in their vile sacrifices, facing the wrath of both the gods—witnesses to the treaties made with the Romans—and the curses expressed in the oaths sworn against those treaties, swearing reluctantly, loathing the oath, and fearing simultaneously the gods, their fellow countrymen, and their enemies."

40

When the consul had recounted these particulars, ascertained from the information of the deserters, to the soldiers already enraged of themselves, they then, filled with confidence in both divine and human aid, with one universal shout, demanded the battle; were dissatisfied at the action being deferred to the following day; they are impatient under the intended delay of a day and a night. Papirius, at the third watch, having received his colleague's letter, arose in silence, and sent the keeper of the chickens to take the auspices. There was no one description of men in the camp who felt not earnest wishes for the fight: the highest and the lowest were equally eager; the general watching the ardour of the soldiers, and the soldiers that of the general. This universal zeal spread even to those employed in taking the auspices; for the chickens having refused to feed, the auspex ventured to misrepresent the omen, and reported to the consul that they had fed voraciously.[7] The consul, highly pleased, and giving notice that the auspices were excellent, and that they were to act under the direction of the gods, displayed the signal for battle. Just as he was going out to the field, he happened to receive intelligence from a deserter, that twenty cohorts of Samnites, consisting of about four hundred each, had marched towards Cominium. Lest his colleague should be ignorant of this, he instantly despatched a messenger to him, and then ordered the troops to advance with speed, having already assigned to each division of the army its proper post, and appointed general officers to command them. The command of the right wing he gave to Lucius Volumnius, that of the left to Lucius Scipio, that of the cavalry to the other lieutenants-general, Caius Caedicius and Caius Trebonius. He ordered Spurius Nautius to take off the panniers from the mules, and to lead them round quickly, together with his auxiliary cohorts, to a rising ground in view; and there to show himself during the heat of the engagement, and to raise as much dust as possible. While the general was employed in making these dispositions, a dispute arose among the keepers of the chickens, about the auspices of the day, which was overheard by some Roman horsemen, who, deeming it a matter not to be slighted, informed Spurius Papirius, the consul's nephew, that there was a doubt about the auspices. The youth, born in an age when that sort of learning which inculcates contempt of the gods was yet unknown, examined into the affair, that he might not carry an uncertain report to the consul; and then acquainted him with it. His answer was, "I very much applaud your conduct and zeal. However, the person who officiates in taking the auspices, if he makes a false report, draws on his own head the evil portended; but to the Roman people and their army, the favourable omen reported to me is an excellent auspice." He then commanded the centurions to place the keepers of the chickens in the front of the line. The Samnites likewise brought forward their standards; their main body followed, armed and decorated in such a manner, that the enemy afforded a magnificent show. Before the shout was raised, or the battle begun, the auspex, wounded by a random cast of a javelin, fell before the standards; which being told to the consul, he said, "The gods are present in the battle; the guilty has met his punishment." While the consul uttered these words, a crow, in front of him, cawed with a clear voice; at which augury, the consul being rejoiced, and affirming, that never had the gods interposed in a more striking manner in human affairs, ordered the charge to be sounded and the shout to be raised.

When the consul recounted these details, gathered from the deserters’ information, to the already angry soldiers, they were filled with confidence in both divine and human support. With one loud shout, they demanded to fight and were unhappy about having to wait until the next day; they were restless about the delay of a whole day and night. At the third watch, after receiving a letter from his colleague, Papirius got up silently and sent someone to check the omens. There wasn’t a single group in the camp that didn’t eagerly want to fight: everyone, from the highest to the lowest rank, was enthusiastic; the general noted the soldiers' eagerness, and the soldiers watched their general’s passion. This collective fervor even reached those checking the omens; when the chickens refused to eat, the augur chose to misinterpret the sign and reported to the consul that they had fed well. The consul, pleased and declaring that the omens were excellent, announced that they would act under the gods' guidance and signaled for battle. Just as he was heading out to the battlefield, he got word from a deserter that twenty cohorts of Samnites, each about four hundred strong, were moving toward Cominium. To ensure his colleague was informed, he quickly sent a messenger and ordered the troops to move swiftly, having already assigned each part of the army its position and appointed officers to lead them. He put Lucius Volumnius in charge of the right wing, Lucius Scipio in charge of the left, and assigned the cavalry to the other two senior officers, Caius Caedicius and Caius Trebonius. He instructed Spurius Nautius to remove the packs from the mules and quickly lead them, along with his auxiliary cohorts, to a visible high ground and to make himself known during the battle, raising as much dust as possible. While the general was organizing these arrangements, a dispute arose among the chicken keepers about the omens of the day, which was overheard by some Roman horsemen. Thinking it was significant, they informed Spurius Papirius, the consul's nephew, about the uncertainty regarding the omens. The young man, raised in a time when such teachings didn’t encourage disrespect for the gods, investigated the matter so he wouldn’t bring an uncertain report to the consul and then informed him of his findings. The consul replied, "I truly appreciate your conduct and enthusiasm. However, the individual responsible for interpreting the omens faces the consequences if they present false news; but the favorable sign given to me is a good omen for the Roman people and their army.” He then ordered the centurions to place the keepers of the chickens at the front of the line. The Samnites also brought forward their standards; their main force followed, armed and adorned in a way that made for a stunning display. Before the shout was raised or the battle commenced, the augur was struck by a stray javelin and fell in front of the standards. When the consul was informed, he said, “The gods are present in the battle; the guilty have received their punishment.” As the consul spoke, a crow cawed loudly in front of him; delighted by this omen, he declared that the gods had never intervened in such a remarkable way in human affairs and ordered the charge to be sounded and the shout to be raised.

41

A furious conflict now ensued, but with very unequal spirit [in the combatants]. Anger, hope, and ardour for conquest, hurried on the Romans to battle, thirsting for their enemy's blood; while the Samnites, for the most part reluctantly, as if compelled by necessity and religious dread, rather stood on their defence, than made an attack. Nor would they, familiarized as they were to defeats, through a course of so many years, have withstood the first shout and shock of the Romans, had not another fear, operating still more powerfully in their breasts, restrained them from flying. For they had before their eyes the whole scene exhibited at the secret sacrifice, the armed priests, the promiscuous carnage of men and cattle, the altars besmeared with the blood of victims and of their murdered countrymen, the dreadful curses, and the direful form of imprecation, drawn up for calling down perdition on their family and race. Prevented by these shackles from running away, they stood, more afraid of then countrymen than of the enemy. The Romans pushed on both the wings, and in the centre, and made great havoc among them, stupified as they were, through their fears of the gods and of men. A faint resistance is now made, as by men whom fear alone prevented from running away. The slaughter had now almost reached to their standards, when, on one side, appeared a cloud of dust, as if raised by the marching of a numerous army: it was Spurius Nautius, (some say Octavius Metius,) commander of the auxiliary cohorts: for these raised a greater quantity of dust than was proportioned to the number of men, the servants of the camp, mounted on the mules, trailing boughs of trees, full of leaves, along the ground. Through the light thus obscured, arms and standards were seen in front; behind, a higher and denser cloud of dust presented the appearance of horsemen bringing up the rear. This effectually deceived, not only the Samnites, but the Romans themselves: and the consul confirmed the mistake, by calling out among the foremost battalions, so that his voice reached also the enemy, that "Cominium was taken, and that his victorious colleague was approaching," bidding his men "now make haste to complete the defeat of the enemy, before the glory should fall to the share of the other army." This he said as he sat on horseback, and then ordered the tribunes and centurions to open passages for the horse. He had given previous directions to Trebonius and Caedicius, that, when they should see him waving the point of his spear aloft, they should incite the cavalry to charge the enemy with all possible violence. Every particular, as previously concerted, was executed with the utmost exactness. The passages were opened between the ranks, the cavalry darted through, and, with the points of their spears presented, rushed into the midst of the enemy's battalions, breaking down the ranks wherever they charged. Voluminius and Scipio seconded the blow, and taking advantage of the enemy's disorder, made a terrible slaughter. Thus attacked, the cohorts, called linteatae, regardless of all restraints from either gods or men, quitted their posts in confusion, the sworn and the unsworn all fled alike, no longer dreading aught but the enemies. The body of their infantry which survived the battle, were driven into the camp at Aquilonia. The nobility and cavalry directed their flight to Bovianum. The horse were pursued by the Roman horse, the infantry by their infantry, while the wings proceeded by different roads; the right, to the camp of the Samnites; the left to the city. Volumnius succeeded first in gaining possession of the camp. At the city, Scipio met a stouter resistance; not because the conquered troops there had gained courage, but because walls were a better defence against armed men than a rampart. From these they repelled the enemy with stones. Scipio, considering that unless the business were effected during their first panic, and before they could recover their spirits, the attack of so strong a town would be very tedious, asked his soldiers "if they could endure, without shame, that the other wing should already have taken the camp, and that they, after all their success, should be repulsed from the gates of the city?" Then, all of them loudly declaring their determination to the contrary, he himself advanced, the foremost, to the gate, with his shield raised over his head: the rest, following under the like cover of their shields conjoined, burst into the city, and dispersing the Samnites who were near the gate, took possession of the walls, but they ventured not to push forward into the interior of the city in consequence of the smallness of their number.

A fierce battle broke out, but the two sides had very different levels of motivation. The Romans charged into combat filled with anger, hope, and a fierce desire to conquer, eager for their enemy's blood. On the other hand, most Samnites fought reluctantly, as if they were forced by necessity and a deep fear of the gods, opting to defend rather than attack. Having experienced numerous defeats over the years, they would not have held their ground against the initial cry and impact of the Romans, if not for an even greater fear that kept them from fleeing. They vividly recalled the disturbing scene from a hidden sacrifice: the armed priests, the brutal slaughter of both people and cattle, the blood-soaked altars, the terrible curses, and the horrifying imprecations aimed at calling down destruction upon their families and descendants. These fears paralyzed them, making them more afraid of their own people than of the enemy. The Romans pressed forward on both flanks and in the center, causing significant damage to the paralyzed Samnites, who were struck dumb by their fears of both the gods and men. The Samnites put up only a weak resistance, held back from fleeing solely by their fear. The slaughter was nearing their standards when, suddenly, a cloud of dust appeared, suggesting a large army was approaching. It was Spurius Nautius (some say Octavius Metius), the commander of the auxiliary cohorts. They kicked up more dust than would be expected for their number, as camp servants on mules dragged leafy branches across the ground. Through this haze, weapons and standards could be seen ahead, while a thicker cloud of dust suggested cavalry was following behind. This effectively tricked both the Samnites and the Romans. The consul further fueled the confusion by loudly declaring to the front line, so that even the enemy could hear, that "Cominium has fallen, and my victorious colleague is on the way," urging his troops to hurry and defeat the enemy before the glory went to the other army. He spoke from horseback, then ordered the tribunes and centurions to clear a path for the cavalry. He had already instructed Trebonius and Caedicius to spur the cavalry to charge at the enemy with full force as soon as he waved his spear aloft. Every detail of their plan was executed flawlessly. The paths between the ranks were opened, the cavalry surged through, weapons raised, crashing into the heart of the enemy's formations, breaking their lines wherever they struck. Voluminius and Scipio followed up on the attack, taking advantage of the enemy’s disarray to inflict devastating losses. With such a sudden attack, the cohorts known as linteatae, disregarding any fear of gods or men, abandoned their positions in chaos, with everyone fleeing regardless of rank. The surviving infantry retreated to their camp at Aquilonia, while the nobles and cavalry made their escape toward Bovianum. The Roman cavalry pursued their horsemen, while infantry chased down the fleeing infantry, with the right wing moving toward the Samnite camp and the left toward the city. Volumnius was the first to reach the camp. Scipio faced stiffer resistance at the city, not because the defeated soldiers had suddenly found courage, but because the walls provided better protection against armed men than trenches. They defended themselves by throwing stones at the enemy. Scipio realized that if they didn’t act quickly during the first panic and before the defenders regained their composure, it would be challenging to take such a stronghold, so he asked his soldiers, "Can you stand it, without shame, if the other wing captures the camp, while after all our success we are turned away at the city gates?" All of them firmly expressed their disagreement, so he stepped forward, leading the charge toward the gate with his shield raised high. The others followed, shields locked together, bursting into the city. They scattered the nearby Samnites and secured the walls, but they didn’t dare venture deeper into the city due to their small numbers.

42

Of these transactions the consul was for some time ignorant; and was busily employed in calling home his troops, for the sun was now hastening to set, and the approach of night rendered every place suspicious and dangerous, even to victorious troops. Having rode forward a considerable way, he saw on the right the camp taken, and heard on the left a shouting in the city, with a confused noise of fighting, and cries of terror. This happened while the fight was going on at the gate. When, on riding up nearer, he saw his own men on the walls, and so much progress already made in the business, pleased at having gained, through the precipitate conduct of a few, an opportunity of striking an important blow, he ordered the troops, whom he had sent back to the camp, to be called out, and to march to the attack of the city: these, having made good their entrance on the nearest side, proceeded no farther, because night approached. Before morning, however, the town was abandoned by the enemy. There were slain of the Samnites on that day, at Aquilonia, thirty thousand three hundred and forty; taken, three thousand eight hundred and seventy, with ninety-seven military standards. One circumstance, respecting Papirius, is particularly mentioned by historians: that, hardly ever was any general seen in the field with a more cheerful countenance; whether this was owing to his natural temper or to his confidence of success. From the same firmness of mind it proceeded, that he did not suffer himself to be diverted from the war by the dispute about the auspices; and that, in the heat of the battle, when it was customary to vow temples to the immortal gods, he vowed to Jupiter the victorious, that if he should defeat the legions of the enemy, he would, before he tasted of any generous liquor, make a libation to him of a cup of wine and honey. This kind of vow proved acceptable to the gods, and they conducted the auspices to a fortunate issue.

The consul was unaware of these events for some time and was busy calling his troops back, as the sun was setting and night was making every place seem risky and dangerous, even for victorious soldiers. After riding a good distance, he saw the camp on the right and heard shouting from the city on the left, along with the chaotic sounds of fighting and cries of fear. This was happening while the battle was ongoing at the gate. When he rode closer, he saw his men on the walls, and noticing the significant progress made, he felt pleased that the hasty actions of a few had created an opportunity for a crucial attack. He ordered the troops he had sent back to camp to be called out and march to assault the city. They successfully entered from the nearest side but didn't go further because night was coming. However, before morning, the enemy abandoned the town. That day, at Aquilonia, thirty thousand three hundred and forty Samnites were killed; three thousand eight hundred and seventy were captured, along with ninety-seven military standards. One notable detail about Papirius is mentioned by historians: he was rarely seen in the field without a cheerful expression, whether due to his natural disposition or his confidence in winning. His steady mindset also meant he didn’t let the argument over auspices distract him from the war. In the heat of battle, when it was customary to vow temples to the immortal gods, he promised Jupiter the Victor that if he defeated the enemy legions, he would make a libation of wine and honey before drinking any fine liquor. This kind of vow was pleasing to the gods, and they guided the auspices to a successful outcome.

43

Matters were conducted with the same success by the other consul at Cominium: leading up his forces to the walls, at the first dawn, he invested the city on every side, and posted strong guards opposite to the gates to prevent any sally being made. Just as he was giving the signal, the alarming message from his colleague, touching the march of the twenty Samnite cohorts, not only caused him to delay the assault, but obliged him to call off a part of his troops, when they were formed and ready to begin the attack. He ordered Decius Brutus Scaeva, a lieutenant-general, with the first legion, ten auxiliary cohorts, and the cavalry, to go and oppose the said detachment; and in whatever place he should meet the foe, there to stop and detain them, and even to engage in battle, should opportunity offer for it; at all events not to suffer those troops to approach Cominium. He then commanded the scaling ladders to be brought up to the walls, on every side of the city; and, under a fence of closed shields, advanced to the gates. Thus, at the same moment, the gates were broken open, and the assault made on every part of the walls. Though the Samnites, before they saw the assailants on the works, had possessed courage enough to oppose their approaches to the city, yet now, when the action was no longer carried on at a distance, nor with missile weapons, but in close fight; and when those, who had with difficulty gained the walls, having overcome the disadvantage of ground, which, they principally dreaded, fought with ease on equal ground, against an enemy inferior in strength, they all forsook the towers and walls, and being driven to the forum, they tried there for a short time, as a last effort, to retrieve the fortune of the fight; but soon throwing down their arms, surrendered to the consul, to the number of eleven thousand four hundred; four thousand three hundred and eighty were slain. Such was the course of events at Cominium, such at Aquilonia. In the middle space between the two cities, where a third battle had been expected, the enemy were not found; for, when they were within seven miles of Cominium, they were recalled by their countrymen, and had no part in either battle. At night-fall, when they were now within sight of their camp, and also of Aquilonia, shouts from both places reaching them with equal force induced them to halt; then, on the side of the camp, which had been set on fire by the Romans, the wide-spreading flames indicating with more certainty the disaster [which had happened], prevented their proceeding any farther. In that same spot, stretched on the ground at random under their arms, they passed the whole night in great inquietude, at one time wishing for, at another dreading the light. At the first dawn, while they were still undetermined to what quarter they should direct their march, they were obliged to betake themselves hastily to flight, being descried by the cavalry; who having gone in pursuit of the Samnites, that left the town in the night, saw the multitude unprotected either by a rampart or advanced guard. This party had likewise been perceived from the walls of Aquilonia, and the legionary cohorts now joined in the pursuit. The foot were unable to overtake them, but about two hundred and eighty of their rear guard were cut off by the cavalry. In their consternation they left behind them a great quantity of arms and eighteen military standards: they reached Bovianum with the rest of their party in safety, as far as could be expected after so disorderly a rout.

Matters were handled just as successfully by the other consul at Cominium: bringing his troops to the city walls at dawn, he surrounded the city on all sides, and stationed strong guards at the gates to stop any attempts to break out. Just as he was about to give the signal, an urgent message from his colleague about the march of twenty Samnite cohorts not only made him postpone the attack but forced him to pull back some of his troops, even though they were formed and ready to engage. He ordered Decius Brutus Scaeva, a lieutenant-general, along with the first legion, ten auxiliary cohorts, and the cavalry, to go confront the incoming detachment; and wherever he encountered the enemy, he was to block and hold them back, and even engage in battle if the opportunity arose; in any case, he must not let those troops approach Cominium. Then he commanded the scaling ladders to be brought up to the walls on every side of the city; and, under cover of closed shields, advanced to the gates. At that moment, the gates were broken open, and an assault was launched on every part of the walls. Although the Samnites, before seeing the attackers on the walls, had enough courage to oppose their advance on the city, now, when the battle was no longer from a distance, nor with thrown weapons, but in close combat; and when those who had with difficulty gained the walls fought on equal ground against an enemy weaker than them, they all abandoned the towers and walls, and being pushed back to the forum, they tried briefly, as a last effort, to turn the tide of battle; but soon dropping their weapons, they surrendered to the consul, totaling eleven thousand four hundred; four thousand three hundred and eighty were killed. This was how events unfolded at Cominium, and similarly at Aquilonia. In the area between the two cities, where a third battle was anticipated, the enemy was not found; for, when they were seven miles from Cominium, they were called back by their fellow citizens, and played no part in either battle. At dusk, when they were now in sight of their camp, as well as Aquilonia, shouts from both places reached them with equal intensity, prompting them to stop; then, on the side of the camp, which had been set ablaze by the Romans, the spreading flames clearly indicated the disaster that had occurred, preventing their advance any further. In that spot, lying on the ground under their arms, they spent the entire night in great unease, sometimes wishing for, at other times fearing, the dawn. At first light, while they were still unclear about where to march, they had to flee in haste, having been spotted by the cavalry; who, having pursued the Samnites who left the town in the night, saw the crowd unprotected by a wall or advance guard. This group was also seen from the walls of Aquilonia, and the legionary cohorts joined in the chase. The foot soldiers could not catch up to them, but about two hundred and eighty of their rear guard were taken out by the cavalry. In their panic, they left behind a large amount of weapons and eighteen military standards: they reached Bovianum safely with the rest of their group, as far as could be expected after such a chaotic retreat.

44

The joy of both Roman armies was enhanced by the success achieved on the other side. Each consul, with the approbation of his colleague, gave to his soldiers the plunder of the town which he had taken; and, when the houses were cleared, set them on fire. Thus, on the same day, Aquilonia and Cominium were both reduced to ashes. The consuls then united their camps, where mutual congratulations took place between them and between their soldiers. Here, in the view of the two armies, Carvilius bestowed on his men commendations and presents according to the desert of each; and Papirius likewise, whose troops had been engaged in a variety of actions, in the field, in the assault of the camp, and in that of the city, presented Spurius Nautius, Spurius Papirius, his nephew, four centurions, and a company of the spearmen, with bracelets and crowns of gold:--to Nautius, on account of his behaviour at the head of his detachment, when he had terrified the enemy with the appearance as of a numerous army; to young Papirius, on account of his zealous exertions with the cavalry, both in the battle and in harassing the Samnites in their flight by night, when they withdrew privately from Aquilonia; and to the centurions and company of soldiers, because they were the first who gained possession of the gate and wall of that town. All the horsemen he presented with gorgets and bracelets of silver, on account of their distinguished conduct on many occasions. As the time was now come for withdrawing the army out of Samnium, the expediency was considered, as to whether they should withdraw both, or at least one. It was concluded, that the lower the strength of the Samnites was reduced, the greater perseverance and vigour ought to be used in prosecuting the war, so that Samnium might be given up to the succeeding consuls perfectly subjected. As there was now no army of the enemy which could be supposed capable of disputing the field, there remained one mode of operations, the besieging of the cities; by the destruction of which, they might be enabled to enrich their soldiers with the spoil; and, at the same time, utterly to destroy the enemy, reduced to the necessity of fighting, their all being at stake. The consuls, therefore, after despatching letters to the senate and people of Rome, containing accounts of the services which they had performed, led away their legions to different quarters; Papirius going to attack Saepioura, Carvilius to Volana.

The joy of both Roman armies was boosted by the success achieved on the other side. Each consul, with his colleague's approval, gave his soldiers the loot from the town they had captured, and after clearing the houses, set them on fire. Thus, on the same day, Aquilonia and Cominium were both turned to ash. The consuls then combined their camps, where they exchanged congratulations with each other and with their soldiers. In front of both armies, Carvilius praised his men and gave out awards based on their merit. Papirius also honored those in his command, who had been involved in various actions, whether in the field, during the camp assault, or the attack on the city. He presented Spurius Nautius, Spurius Papirius (his nephew), four centurions, and a group of spearmen with gold bracelets and crowns: Nautius, for his leadership of his detachment, which had scared the enemy with the illusion of a large army; young Papirius, for his enthusiastic efforts with the cavalry, both in battle and in harassing the Samnites during their nighttime retreat from Aquilonia; and the centurions and soldiers, because they were the first to take over the gate and wall of that town. He awarded all the horsemen with silver gorgets and bracelets for their outstanding conduct on several occasions. As the time to withdraw the army from Samnium approached, they considered whether to pull back both armies or at least one. It was decided that the more the Samnites were weakened, the more determination and energy should be used to continue the war, so that Samnium could be handed over to the next consuls fully subdued. With no enemy army left that could contest the field, the only option was to besiege the cities; by destroying them, they could enrich their soldiers with the spoils and completely crush the enemy, forced to fight for everything they had. Therefore, the consuls, after sending letters to the senate and people of Rome detailing their achievements, led their legions to different locations: Papirius heading to attack Saepioura, and Carvilius to Volana.

45

The letters of the consuls were heard with extraordinary exultation, both in the senate-house and in the assembly of the people; and, in a thanksgiving of four days' continuance, the public rejoicings were celebrated with zeal by individuals. These successes were not only important in themselves to the Roman people, but peculiarly seasonable; for it happened, that at the same time intelligence was brought that the Etrurians were again in arms. The reflection naturally occurred to people's minds, how it would have been possible, in case any misfortune had happened in Samnium, to have withstood the power of Etruria; which, being encouraged by the conspiracy of the Samnites, and seeing both the consuls, and the whole force of the Romans, employed against them, had made use of that juncture, in which the Romans had so much business on their hands, for reviving hostilities. Ambassadors from the allies, being introduced to the senate by the praetor Marcus Atilius, complained that their countries were wasted with fire and sword by the neighbouring Etrurians, because they had refused to revolt from the Romans; and they besought the conscript fathers to protect them from the violence and injustice of their common enemy. The ambassadors were answered,

The letters from the consuls were received with great excitement, both in the senate chamber and in the public assembly; and during a four-day celebration of thanks, the people enthusiastically took part in the festivities. These victories were not only significant for the Roman people but also very timely, as news arrived that the Etrurians were once again preparing for battle. People naturally wondered how they could have dealt with the Etrurian threat if anything had gone wrong in Samnium, especially since the Etrurians, encouraged by the Samnite conspiracy and aware that both consuls and the entire Roman force were occupied, had chosen this moment of Roman distraction to restart their attacks. Ambassadors from the allies, presented to the senate by the praetor Marcus Atilius, reported that their lands were being ravaged by the neighboring Etrurians because they had refused to betray their allegiance to the Romans. They appealed to the senate to protect them from the aggression and injustice of their common enemy. The ambassadors received a response,

that "the senate would take care that the allies should not repent their fidelity." That the "Etrurians should shortly be in the same situation with the Samnites." Notwithstanding which, the business respecting Etruria would have been prosecuted with less vigour, had not information been received, that the Faliscians likewise, who had for many years lived in friendship with Rome, had united their arms with those of the Etrurians. The consideration of the near vicinity of that nation quickened the attention of the senate; insomuch that they passed a decree that heralds should be sent to demand satisfaction: which being refused, war was declared against the Faliscians by direction of the senate, and order of the people; and the consuls were desired to determine, by lots, which of them should lead an army from Samnium into Etruria. Carvilius had, in the mean time, taken from the Samnites Volana, Palumbinum, and Herculaneum; Volana after a siege of a few days, Palumbinum the same day on which he approached the walls. At Herculaneum, it is true, the consul had two regular engagements without any decisive advantage on either side, and with greater loss on his side than on that of the enemy; but afterwards, encamping on the spot, he shut them up within their works. The town was besieged and taken. In these three towns were taken or slain ten thousand men, of whom the prisoners composed somewhat the greater part. On the consuls casting lots for the provinces, Etruria fell to Carvilius, to the great satisfaction of the soldiers, who could no longer bear the intensity of the cold in Samnium. Papirius was opposed at Saepinum with a more powerful force: he had to fight often in pitched battles, often on a march, and often under the walls of the city, against the eruptions of the enemy; and could neither besiege, nor engage them on equal terms; for the Samnites not only protected themselves by walls, but likewise protected their walls with numbers of men and arms. At length, after a great deal of fighting, he forced them to submit to a regular siege. This he carried on with vigour, and made himself master of the city by means of his works, and by storm. The rage of the soldiers on this occasion caused the greatest slaughter in the taking of the town; seven thousand four hundred fell by the sword; the number of the prisoners did not amount to three thousand. The spoil, of which the quantity was very great, the whole substance of the Samnites being collected in a few cities, was given up to the soldiers.

that "the senate would ensure that the allies wouldn’t regret their loyalty." That the "Etrurians would soon find themselves in the same position as the Samnites." Despite this, the situation regarding Etruria would have been handled with less urgency if it hadn't been reported that the Faliscians, who had maintained friendly relations with Rome for many years, had joined forces with the Etrurians. The proximity of that nation heightened the senate's concern; so they issued a decree to send heralds to demand satisfaction. When this was denied, the senate decided to declare war against the Faliscians, following the will of the people; and the consuls were instructed to draw lots to decide which of them would lead an army from Samnium into Etruria. Meanwhile, Carvilius had taken Volana, Palumbinum, and Herculaneum from the Samnites; Volana after a siege of just a few days, and Palumbinum on the very day he approached the walls. At Herculaneum, it’s true the consul had two formal battles with no decisive outcome for either side, suffering greater losses than the enemy; however, after setting up camp at the site, he effectively trapped them within their fortifications. The town was besieged and captured. In these three towns, around ten thousand men were either captured or killed, with the majority of the latter being prisoners. When the consuls drew lots for the provinces, Etruria went to Carvilius, much to the soldiers' relief, as they could no longer withstand the harsh cold in Samnium. Papirius faced a stronger force at Saepinum: he frequently engaged in pitched battles, confrontations on the march, and skirmishes near the city walls against enemy attacks; he couldn’t besiege or fight them on equal footing, as the Samnites not only fortified themselves but also defended their walls with a large number of troops and weapons. Eventually, after a great deal of fighting, he compelled them to submit to a regular siege. He pursued this with determination and captured the city through his work and assaults. The fury of the soldiers during this event led to a significant massacre during the city's capture; seven thousand four hundred were killed, while the number of prisoners didn’t reach three thousand. The enormous spoils, accumulated from the wealth of the Samnites concentrated in a few cities, were awarded to the soldiers.

46

The snow had now entirely covered the face of the country, and they could no longer dispense with the shelter of houses: the consul therefore led home his troops from Samnium. While he was on his way to Rome, a triumph was decreed him with universal consent; and accordingly he triumphed while in office, and with extraordinary splendour, considering the circumstances of those times. The cavalry and infantry marched in the procession, adorned with presents. Great numbers of civic, vallar, and mural crowns were seen.[8] The spoils of the Samnites were inspected with much curiosity, and compared, in respect of magnificence and beauty, with those taken by his father, which were well known, from being frequently exhibited as ornaments of the public places. Several prisoners of distinction, renowned for their own exploits and those of their ancestors, were led in the cavalcade. There were carried in the train two millions and thirty-three thousand asses in weight.[9] This money was said to be produced by the sale of the prisoners. Of silver, taken in the cities, one thousand three hundred and thirty pounds. All the silver and brass were lodged in the treasury, no share of this part of the spoil being given to the soldiers. The ill humour in the commons was further exasperated, because the tax for the payment of the army was collected by contribution; whereas, said they, if the vain parade of conveying the produce of the spoil to the treasury had been disregarded, donations might have been made to the soldiers out of the spoil, and the pay of the army also supplied out of that fund. The temple of Quirinus, vowed by his father when dictator, (for that he himself had vowed it in the heat of battle, I do not find in any ancient writer, nor indeed could he in so short a time have finished the building of it,) the son, in the office of consul, dedicated and adorned with military spoils. And of these, so great was the abundance, that not only that temple and the forum were decorated with them, but some were also distributed among the allies and colonies in the neighbourhood, to serve as ornaments to their temples and public places. Immediately after his triumph, he led his army into winter quarters in the territory of Vescia; because that country was harassed by the Samnites. Meanwhile, in Etruria, the consul Carvilius having set about laying siege to Troilium, suffered four hundred and seventy of the richest inhabitants to depart; they had paid a large sum of money for permission to leave the place: the town, with the remaining multitude, he took by storm. He afterwards reduced, by force, five forts strongly situated, wherein were slain two thousand four hundred of the enemy, and not quite two thousand made prisoners. To the Faliscians, who sued for peace, he granted a truce for a year, on condition of their furnishing a hundred thousand asses in weight,[10] and that year's pay for his army. This business completed, he returned home to a triumph, which, though it was less illustrious than that of his colleague, in respect of his share in the defeat of the Samnites, was yet raised to an equality with it, by his having put a termination to the war in Etruria. He carried into the treasury three hundred and ninety thousand asses in weight.[11] Out of the remainder of the money accruing to the public from the spoils, he contracted for the building of a temple to Fors Fortuna, near to that dedicated to the same goddess by king Servius Tullius; and gave to the soldiers, out of the spoil, one hundred and two asses each, and double that sum to the centurions and horsemen, who received this donative the more gratefully, on account of the parsimony of his colleague.

The snow had completely covered the landscape, and they could no longer do without the shelter of houses. So, the consul led his troops home from Samnium. While he was on his way to Rome, a triumph was unanimously approved for him, and he celebrated it while in office, with extraordinary splendor, considering the times. The cavalry and infantry marched in the parade, adorned with gifts. Many civic, vallar, and mural crowns were displayed. The spoils of the Samnites were examined with great interest and compared in terms of magnificence and beauty to those taken by his father, which were well-known from being frequently exhibited in public places. Several distinguished prisoners, famous for their own achievements and those of their ancestors, were included in the procession. They carried a total of two million and thirty-three thousand asses in weight. This money was said to come from the sale of the prisoners. From the silver taken in the cities, there was one thousand three hundred and thirty pounds. All the silver and brass were put into the treasury, with no share of this part of the spoils given to the soldiers. The discontent among the common people grew because the tax for paying the army was collected through contributions; they stated that if the unnecessary show of transporting the spoils to the treasury had been ignored, donations could have been made to the soldiers from those spoils, and the soldiers’ pay could have been covered from that fund. The temple of Quirinus, which had been vowed by his father when he was dictator (as it couldn’t have been vowed by him amidst the heat of battle in such a short time), was dedicated by the son while serving as consul and decorated with military spoils. The abundance was so great that not only the temple and the forum were adorned with them, but some were also distributed among the neighboring allies and colonies to beautify their temples and public spaces. Shortly after his triumph, he led his army into winter quarters in the territory of Vescia, as that region was troubled by the Samnites. Meanwhile, in Etruria, consul Carvilius began besieging Troilium, allowing four hundred and seventy of the wealthiest inhabitants to leave; they had paid a large sum for permission to do so. He captured the town, taking the remaining population by force. He then conquered five heavily fortified forts by force, killing two thousand four hundred enemies and capturing nearly two thousand. To the Faliscians, who sought peace, he granted a truce for a year, on the condition that they provide a hundred thousand asses in weight, along with that year's pay for his army. Once this was done, he returned home for a triumph which, while less illustrious than that of his colleague regarding his role in defeating the Samnites, was elevated to an equal standing due to his ending of the war in Etruria. He took three hundred and ninety thousand asses in weight to the treasury. From the remaining public spoils, he financed the building of a temple to Fors Fortuna, near the one dedicated to the same goddess by King Servius Tullius, and he gave the soldiers one hundred and two asses each from the spoils, while the centurions and cavalry received double that amount, which they appreciated all the more because of his colleague's stinginess.

47

The favour of the consul saved from a trial, before the people, Postumius; who, on a prosecution being commenced against him by Marcus Scantius, plebeian tribune, evaded, as was said, the jurisdiction of the people, by procuring the commission of lieutenant-general, so the indictment against him could only be held out as a threat, and not put in force. The The year having now elapsed, new plebeian tribunes had come unto office; and for these, in consequence of some irregularity on their appointments, others had been, within five days after, substituted in their room. The lustrum was closed this year by the censors Publius Cornelius Arvina and Caius Marcius Rutilus. The number of citizens rated was two hundred and sixty-two thousand three hundred and twenty-two. These were the twenty-sixth pair of censors since the first institution of that office; and this the nineteenth lustrum. In this year, persons who had been presented with crowns, in consideration of meritorious behaviour in war, first began to wear them at the exhibition of the Roman games. Then, for the first time, palms were conferred on the victors according to a custom introduced from Greece. In the same year the paving of the road from the temple of Mars to Bovillae was completed by the curule aediles, who exhibited those games out of fines levied on the farmers of the pastures. Lucius Papirius presided at the consular election, and returned consuls Quintus Fabius Gurges, son of Maximus, and Decius Junius Brutus Scaeva. Papirius himself was made praetor. This year, prosperous in many particulars, was scarcely sufficient to afford consolation for one calamity, a pestilence, which afflicted both the city and country: the mortality was prodigious. To discover what end, or what remedy, was appointed by the gods for that calamity, the books were consulted: in the books it was found that Aesculapius must be brought to Rome from Epidaurus. Nor were any steps taken that year in that matter, because the consuls were fully occupied in the war, except that a supplication was performed to Aesculapius for one day.

The consul's favor saved Postumius from a trial by the people; he avoided being judged when plebeian tribune Marcus Scantius started a prosecution against him by securing the position of lieutenant-general. This meant the charges against him could only be used as a threat, not acted upon. A year has passed, and new plebeian tribunes took office; due to some irregularities in their appointments, others were substituted just five days later. The lustrum was completed this year by censors Publius Cornelius Arvina and Caius Marcius Rutilus. The number of citizens counted was two hundred sixty-two thousand three hundred twenty-two. This was the twenty-sixth pair of censors since the office was first established, and this marks the nineteenth lustrum. This year, for the first time, individuals were honored with crowns for their brave actions in war, wearing them at the Roman games. It was also the first time palms were awarded to the winners, a custom borrowed from Greece. Additionally, the curule aediles completed paving the road from the Temple of Mars to Bovillae, showcasing games funded by fines collected from the pasture farmers. Lucius Papirius led the consular elections, appointing Quintus Fabius Gurges, son of Maximus, and Decius Junius Brutus Scaeva as consuls. Papirius was made praetor. Despite being a favorable year in many aspects, it offered little comfort for one disaster: a plague that struck both the city and the countryside, resulting in a staggering death toll. To find out what remedy the gods provided for this disaster, the sacred books were consulted and it was revealed that Aesculapius needed to be brought from Epidaurus to Rome. However, no action was taken on this matter that year since the consuls were preoccupied with the war, other than a one-day supplication to Aesculapius.

       *        *        *        *        *

Here ten books of the original are lost, making a chasm of seventy-five years. The translator's object being to publish the work of Livy only, he has not thought it his duty to attempt to supply this deficiency, either by a compilation of his own, or by transcribing or translating those of others. The leader, however, who may be desirous of knowing the events which took place during this interval, will find as complete a detail of them as can now be given, in Hooke's or Rollin's Roman History.The contents of the lost books have been preserved, and are as follows--

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XI.

[Y.R. 460. B.C. 292.] Fabius Gurges, consul, having fought an unsuccessful battle with the Samnites, the senate deliberate about dismissing him from the command of the army; are prevailed upon not to inflict that disgrace upon him, principally by the entreaties of his father, Fabius Maximus, and by his promising to join the army, and serve, in quality of lieutenant-general, under his son: which promise he performs, and the consul, aided by his counsel and co-operation, obtains a victory over the Samnites, and a triumph in consequence. C. Pontius, the general of the Samnites, led in triumph before the victor's carriage, and afterwards beheaded. A plague at Rome. [Y.R. 461. B.C. 291.] Ambassadors sent to Epidaurus, to bring from thence to Rome the statue of Aesculapius: a serpent, of itself, goes on board their ship; supposing it to be the abode of the deity, they bring it with them; and, upon its quitting their vessel, and swimming to the island in the Tiber, they consecrate there a temple to Aesculapius. L. Postumius, a man of consular rank, condemned for employing the soldiers under his command in working upon his farm. [Y.R. 462. B.C. 290] Curius Dentatus, consul, having subdued the Samnites, and the rebellious Sabines, triumphs twice during his year of office. [Y.R. 463. B.C. 289.] The colonies of Castrum, Sena, and Adria, established. Three judges of capital crimes now first appointed. A census and lustrum: the number of citizens found to be two hundred and seventy-three thousand. After a long-continued sedition, on account of debts, the commons secede to the Janiculum: [Y.R. 466. B.C. 286.] are brought back by Hortensius, dictator, who dies in office. Successful operations against the Volsinians and Lucanians, [Y.R. 468. B.C. 284.] against whom it was thought expedient to send succour to the Thuringians.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XII.

[Y.R. 469. B.C. 283.] The Senonian Gauls having slain the Roman ambassadors, war is declared against them: they cut off L. Caecilius, praetor, with the legions under his command, [Y.R. 470. B.C. 282.] The Roman fleet plundered by the Tarentines, and the commander slain: ambassadors, sent to complain of this outrage, are ill-treated and sent back; whereupon war is declared against them. The Samnites revolt; against whom, together with the Lucanians, Bruttians, and Etruscans, several unsuccessful battles are fought by different generals. [Y.R. 471. B.C. 281.] Pyrrhus, king of Epirus, comes into Italy, to succour the Tarentines. A Campanian legion, sent, under the command of Decius Jubellius, to garrison Rhegium, murder the inhabitants, and seize the city.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XIII.

[Y.R. 472. B.C. 280.] Valerius Laevinus, consul, engages with Pyrrhus, and is beaten, his soldiers being terrified at the unusual appearance of elephants. After the battle, Pyrrhus, viewing the bodies of the Romans who were slain, remarks, that they all of them lay with their faces turned towards their enemy. He proceeds towards Rome, ravaging the country as he goes along. C. Fabricius is sent by the senate to treat for the redemption of the prisoners: the king, in vain, attempts to bribe him to desert his country. The prisoners restored without ransom. Cineas, ambassador from Pyrrhus to the senate, demands, as a condition of peace, that the king be admitted into the city of Rome: the consideration of which being deferred to a fuller meeting, Appius Claudius, who, on account of a disorder in his eyes, had not, for a long time, attended in the senate, comes there; moves, and carries his motion, that the demand of the king be refused. Cneius Domitius, the first plebeian censor, holds a lustrum; the number of the citizens found to be two hundred and seventy-eight thousand two hundred and twenty-two. A second, but undecided battle with Pyrrhus. [Y.R. 473. B.C. 279.] The treaty with the Carthaginians renewed a fourth time. An offer made to Fabricius, the consul, by a traitor, to poison Pyrrhus; [Y. R. 474. B. C. 278.] he sends him to the king, and discovers to him the treasonable offer. Successful operations against the Etruscans, Lucanians, Bruttians, and Samnites.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XIV.

Pyrrhus crosses over into Sicily. [Y. R. 475. B. C. 277.] Many prodigies, among which, the statue of Jupiter in the Capitol is struck by lightning, and thrown down. [Y. R. 476. B. C. 276.] The head of it afterwards found by the priests. Curius Dentatus, holding a levy, puts up to sale the goods of a person who refuses to answer to his name when called upon. [Y. R. 477. B. C. 275.] Pyrrhus, after his return from Sicily, is defeated, and compelled to quit Italy. The censors hold a lustrum, and find the number of the citizens to be two hundred and seventy-one thousand two hundred and twenty-four. [Y. R. 479. B. c. 273.] A treaty of alliance formed with Ptolemy, king of Egypt. Sextilia, a vestal, found guilty of incest, and buried alive. Two colonies sent forth, to Posidonium and Cossa. [Y. R. 480. B. C. 272.] A Carthaginian fleet sails, in aid of the Tarentines, by which act the treaty is violated. Successful operations against the Lucanians, Samnites, and Bruttians. Death of king Pyrrhus.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XV.

The Tarentines overcome: peace and freedom granted to them. [Y. R. 481. B. C. 271.] The Campanian legion, which had forcibly taken possession of Rhegium, besieged there; lay down their arms, and are punished with death. Some young men, who had ill-treated the ambassadors from the Apollonians to the senate of Rome, are delivered up to them. Peace granted to the Picentians. [Y. R. 484. B. C. 268.] Two colonies established; one at Ariminum in Picenum, another at Beneventum in Samnium. Silver coin now, for the first time, used by the Roman people. [Y. R. 485. B. C. 267.] The Umbrians and Sallentines subdued. The number of quaestors increased to eight.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XVI.

[Y. R. 488. B. C. 264.] Origin and progress of the Carthaginian state. After much debate, the senate resolves to succour the Mammertines against the Carthaginians, and against Hiero, king of Syracuse. Roman cavalry, then, for the first time, cross the sea, and engage successfully, in battle with Hiero; who solicits and obtains peace. [Y.R. 489. B.C. 263.] A lustrum: the number of the citizens amounts to two hundred and ninety-two thousand two hundred and twenty-four. D. Junius Brutus exhibits the first show of gladiators, in honour of his deceased father. [Y.R. 490. B.C. 262.] The Aesernian colony established. Successful operations against the Carthaginians and Vulsinians. [Y.R. 491. B.C. 261.]

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XVII.

[Y.R. 492. B.C. 260.] Cneius Cornelius, consul, surrounded by the Carthaginian fleet; and, being drawn into a conference by a stratagem, is taken. [Y.R. 493. B.C. 259.] C. Duilius, consul, engages with and vanquishes the Carthaginian fleet; is the first commander to whom a triumph was decreed for a naval victory; in honour of which, he is allowed, when returning to his habitation at night, to be attended with torches and music. L. Cornelius, consul, fights and subdues the Sardinians and Corsicans, together with Hanno, the Carthaginian general, in the island of Sardinia. [Y.R. 494. B.C. 258.] Atilius Calatinus, consul, drawn into an ambuscade by the Carthaginians, is rescued by the skill and valour of M. Calpurnius, a military tribune, who making a sudden attack upon the enemy, with a body of only three hundred men, turns their whole force against himself. [Y.R. 495. B.C. 257.] Hannibal, the commander of the Carthaginian fleet which was beaten, is put to death by his soldiers.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XVIII.

[Y.R. 496. B.C. 256.] Attilius Regulus, consul, having overcome the Carthaginians in a sea-fight, passes over into Africa: kills a serpent of prodigious magnitude, with great loss of his own men. [Y.R. 497. B.C. 255.] The senate, on account of his successful conduct of the war, not appointing him a successor, he writes to them, complaining; and, among other reasons for desiring to be recalled, alledges, that his little farm, being all his subsistence, was going to ruin, owing to the mismanagement of hired stewards. [Y.R. 498. B.C. 254.] A memorable instance of the instability of fortune exhibited in the person of Regulus, who is overcome in battle, and taken prisoner by Xanthippus, a Lacedaemonian general. [Y. R. 499. B. C. 253.] The Roman fleet shipwrecked; which disaster entirely reverses the good fortune which had hitherto attended their affairs. Titus Corucanius, the first high priest chosen from among the commons. [Y. R. 500. B. C. 252.] P. Sempronius Sophus and M. Yalerius Maximus, censors, examine into the state of the senate, and expel thirteen of the members of that body. [Y. R. 501. B. C. 251.] They hold a lustrum, and find the number of citizens to be two hundred and ninety-seven thousand seven hundred and ninety-seven. [Y. R. 502. B. C. 250.] Regulus being sent by the Carthaginians to Rome to treat for peace, and an exchange of prisoners, binds himself by oath to return if these objects be not attained; dissuades the senate from agreeing to the propositions: and then, in observance of his oath, returning to Carthage, is put to death by torture.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XIX.

[Y. R. 502. B. C. 250.] C. Caecilius Metellus, having been successful in several engagements with the Carthaginians, triumphs with more splendour than had ever yet been seen; thirteen generals of the enemy, and one hundred and twenty elephants, being exhibited in the procession, [Y. R. 503. B. C. 249.] Claudius Pulcher, consul, obstinately persisting, notwithstanding the omens were inauspicious, engages the enemy's fleet, and is beaten; drowns the sacred chickens which would not feed: recalled by the senate, and ordered to nominate a dictator; he appoints Claudius Glicia, one of the lowest of the people, who, notwithstanding his being ordered to abdicate the office, yet attends the celebration of the public games in his dictator's robe. [Y. R. 504. B. C. 248.] Atilius Calatinus, the first dictator who marches with an army out of Italy. An exchange of prisoners with the Carthaginians. Two colonies established at Fregenae and Brundusium in the Sallentine territories. [Y. R. 505. B. C. 247.] A lustrum; the citizens numbered amount to two hundred and fifty-one thousand two hundred and twenty-two. [Y. R. 506. B. C. 246.] Claudia, the sister of Claudius, who had fought unsuccessfully, in contempt of the auspices, being pressed by the crowd, as she was returning from the game, cries out, I wish my brother were alive and had again the command of the fleet: for which offence she is tried and fined. [Y. R. 507. B. C. 245.] Two praetors now first created. Aulus Postumius, consul, being priest of Mars, forcibly detained in the city by Caecilius Metellus, the high priest, and not suffered to go forth to war, being obliged by law to attend to the sacred duties of his office. [Y.R. 508. B.C. 244.] After several successful engagements with the Carthaginians, Caius Lutatius, consul, puts an end to the war, [Y.R. 509. B.C. 243.] by gaining a complete victory over their fleet, at the island of Aegate. The Carthaginians sue for peace, which is granted to them. [Y.R. 510. B.C. 242.] The temple of Vesta being on fire, the high priest, Caecilius Metellus, saves the sacred utensils from the flames. [Y.R. 511. B.C. 241.] Two new tribes added, the Veline and Quirine. The Falisci rebel; are subdued in six days.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XX.

A colony settled at Spoletum. [Y.R. 512. B.C. 240.] An army sent against the Ligurians; being the first war with that state. The Sardinians and Corsicans rebel, and are subdued. [Y.R. 514. B.C. 238.] Tuccia, a vestal, found guilty of incest. War declared against the Illyrians, who had slain an ambassador; they are subdued and brought to submission. [Y.R. 515. B.C. 237.] The number of praetors increased to four. The Transalpine Gauls make an irruption into Italy: are conquered and put to the sword. [Y.R. 516. B.C. 236.] The Roman army, in conjunction with the Latins, is said to have amounted to no less than three hundred thousand men. [Y.R. 517. B.C. 235.] The Roman army for the first time crosses the Po; fights with and subdues the Insubrian Gauls. [Y.R. 530. B.C. 222.] Claudius Marcellus, consul, having slain Viridomarus, the general of the Insubrian Gauls, carries off the spolia opima. [Y.R. 531. B.C. 221.] The Istrians subdued; also the Illyrians, who had rebelled. [Y.R. 532. B.C. 220.] The censors hold a lustrum, in which the number of the citizens is found to be two hundred and seventy thousand two hundred and thirteen. The sons of freed-men formed into four tribes; the Esquiline, Palatine, Suburran, and Colline. [Y.R. 533. B.C. 219.] Caius Flaminius, censor, constructs the Flaminian road, and builds the Flaminian circus.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXI.
B.C. 219-218


Origin of the second Punic war. Hannibal's character. In violation of a treaty, he passes the Iberus. Besieges Saguntum, and at length takes it. The Romans send ambassadors to Carthage; declare war. Hannibal crosses the Pyrenees: makes his way through Gaul; then crosses the Alps; defeats the Romans at the Ticinus. The Romans again defeated at the Trebia. Cneius Cornelius Scipio defeats the Carthaginians in Spain, and takes Hanno, their general, prisoner.

       *        *        *        *        *


1

I may be permitted to premise at this division of my work, what most historians [12] have professed at the beginning of their whole undertaking; that I am about to relate the most memorable of all wars that were ever waged: the war which the Carthaginians, under the conduct of Hannibal, maintained with the Roman people. For never did any states and nations more efficient in their resources engage in contest; nor had they themselves at any other period so great a degree of power and energy. They brought into action too no arts of war unknown to each other, but those which had been tried in the first Punic war; and so various was the fortune of the conflict, and so doubtful the victory, that they who conquered were more exposed to danger. The hatred with which they fought also was almost greater than their resources; the Romans being indignant that the conquered aggressively took up arms against their victors; the Carthaginians, because they considered that in their subjection it had been lorded over them with haughtiness and avarice. There is besides a story, that Hannibal, when about nine years old, while he boyishly coaxed his father Hamilcar that he might be taken to Spain, (at the time when the African war was completed, and he was employed in sacrificing previously to transporting his army thither,) was conducted to the altar; and, having laid his hand on the offerings, was bound by an oath to prove himself, as soon as he could, an enemy to the Roman people. The loss of Sicily and Sardinia grieved the high spirit of Hamilcar: for he deemed that Sicily had been given up through a premature despair of their affairs; and that Sardinia, during the disturbances in Africa, had been treacherously taken by the Romans, while, in addition, the payment of a tribute had been imposed.

I’d like to start this part of my work by stating what many historians have mentioned at the beginning of their projects: I’m about to recount one of the most memorable wars ever fought—the conflict that the Carthaginians, led by Hannibal, waged against the Roman people. Never before had states and nations so rich in resources engaged in battle, nor had they ever experienced such power and energy. They utilized no new tactics of war, only those proven in the first Punic War. The fortunes of this conflict were so varied and the outcome so uncertain that even those who won faced significant risks. The animosity with which they fought was almost stronger than their resources; the Romans were outraged that the conquered would take up arms against their victors, while the Carthaginians believed that their subjugation had been marked by arrogance and greed. Additionally, there’s a story that when Hannibal was about nine years old, he pleaded with his father Hamilcar to take him to Spain (after the African war had ended, and Hamilcar was preparing to sacrifice before moving his army there). He was brought to the altar, and after placing his hand on the offerings, he vowed to become an enemy of the Roman people as soon as he could. Hamilcar was deeply troubled by the loss of Sicily and Sardinia; he thought Sicily had been lost due to premature despair and that Sardinia had been deceitfully taken by the Romans during the chaos in Africa, along with the imposition of a tribute.

2

Being disturbed with these anxieties, he so conducted himself for five years in the African war, which commenced shortly after the peace with Rome, and then through nine years employed in augmenting the Carthaginian empire in Spain, that it was obvious that he was revolving in his mind a greater war than he was then engaged in; and that if he had lived longer, the Carthaginians under Hamilcar would have carried the war into Italy, which, under the command of Hannibal, they afterwards did. The timely death of Hamilcar and the youth of Hannibal occasioned its delay. Hasdrubal, intervening between the father and the son, held the command for about eight years. He was first endeared to Hamilcar, as they say, on account of his youthful beauty, and then adopted by him, when advanced in age, as his son-in-law, on account of his eminent abilities; and, because he was his son-in-law, he obtained the supreme authority, against the wishes of the nobles, by the influence of the Barcine faction, [13] which was very powerful with the military and the populace. Prosecuting his designs rather by stratagem than force, by entertaining the princes, and by means of the friendship of their leaders, gaining the favour of unknown nations, he aggrandized the Carthaginian power, more than by arms and battles. Yet peace proved no greater security to himself. A barbarian, in resentment of his master's having been put to death by him, publicly murdered him; and, having been seized by the bystanders, he exhibited the same countenance as if he had escaped; nay, even when he was lacerated by tortures, he preserved such an expression of face, that he presented the appearance of one who smiled, his joy getting the better of his pains. With this Hasdrubal, because he possessed such wonderful skill in gaining over the nations and adding them to his empire, the Roman people had renewed the treaty, [14] on the terms, that the river Iberus should be the boundary of both empires; and that to the Saguntines, who lay between the territories of the two states, their liberty should be preserved.

Being troubled by these worries, he managed his affairs for five years in the African war, which started soon after the peace with Rome, and then spent nine years expanding the Carthaginian empire in Spain. It was clear that he was thinking about a larger conflict than the one he was currently involved in; and if he had lived longer, the Carthaginians under Hamilcar would have attacked Italy, which they eventually did under Hannibal's command. The untimely death of Hamilcar and Hannibal's youth delayed this. Hasdrubal, positioned between father and son, led for about eight years. He was first favored by Hamilcar for his youthful looks, and later adopted as his son-in-law because of his remarkable skills; and because he was Hamilcar’s son-in-law, he gained supreme power, despite the nobility's objections, thanks to the support of the powerful Barcine faction, which had strong backing among the military and the public. Pursuing his goals through cunning rather than brute force, by entertaining local leaders and befriending leaders of unknown nations, he increased Carthaginian power more through diplomacy than warfare. Still, peace did not provide him with greater security. A barbarian, angry over his master’s execution at Hasdrubal's hands, openly murdered him; and when captured by bystanders, he maintained such an expression as if he had escaped; even when tortured, he retained a face that seemed to smile, his joy overcoming his suffering. With this Hasdrubal, due to his extraordinary talent for winning nations over to his side, the Roman people renewed the treaty, on the terms that the river Iberus would be the boundary of both empires and that the Saguntines, located between the two states, would keep their freedom.

3

There was no doubt that in appointing a successor to Hasdrubal, the approbation of the commons would follow the military prerogative, by which the young Hannibal had been immediately carried to the praetorium, and hailed as general, amid the loud shouts and acquiescence of all. Hasdrubal had sent for him by letter, when scarce yet arrived at manhood; and the matter had even been discussed in the senate, the Barcine faction using all their efforts, that Hannibal might be trained to military service and succeed to his father's command. Hanno, the leader of the opposite faction, said, "Hasdrubal seems indeed to ask what is reasonable, but I, nevertheless, do not think his request ought to be granted." When he had attracted to himself the attention of all, through surprise at this ambiguous opinion, he proceeded: "Hasdrubal thinks that the flower of youth which he gave to the enjoyment of Hannibal's father, may justly be expected by himself in return from the son: but it would little become us to accustom our youth, in place of a military education, to the lustful ambition of the generals. Are we afraid that the son of Hamilcar should be too late in seeing the immoderate power and splendour of his father's sovereignty? or that we shall not soon enough become slaves to the son of him, to whose son-in-law our armies were bequeathed as an hereditary right? I am of opinion, that this youth should be kept at home, and taught, under the restraint of the laws and the authority of magistrates, to live on an equal footing with the rest of the citizens, lest at some time or other this small fire should kindle a vast conflagration."

There was no doubt that when choosing a successor to Hasdrubal, the support of the public would follow the military decision, which is why the young Hannibal was quickly brought to the praetorium and welcomed as general, amid loud cheers and general agreement. Hasdrubal had called for him by letter when he was barely an adult; the issue had even been debated in the senate, where the Barcine faction worked hard to ensure that Hannibal would receive military training and take over his father's command. Hanno, the leader of the opposing faction, stated, "Hasdrubal seems to be asking for something reasonable, but I still believe his request should not be granted." After capturing everyone's attention with this surprising statement, he continued: "Hasdrubal thinks that the youth he dedicated to Hannibal's father should rightfully expect the same from the son. But it would be inappropriate for us to train our youth for military service only to foster the ambitious desires of generals. Are we worried that Hamilcar's son will be too late to realize the excessive power and glory of his father's rule? Or that we won't soon become subservient to the son of the man to whom our armies were passed down as an inherited right? I believe this young man should stay at home, and be taught, under the guidance of laws and the authority of officials, to live alongside other citizens, so that this small spark doesn’t grow into a massive inferno."

4

A few, and nearly every one of the highest merit, concurred with Hanno; but, as usually happens, the more numerous party prevailed over the better. Hannibal, having been sent into Spain, from his very first arrival drew the eyes of the whole army upon him. The veteran soldiers imagined that Hamilcar, in his youth, was restored to them; they remarked the same vigour in his looks and animation in his eye the same features and expression of countenance; and then, in a short time, he took care that his father should be of the least powerful consideration in conciliating their esteem. There never was a genius more fitted for the two most opposite duties of obeying and commanding; so that you could not easily decide whether he were dearer to the general or the army: and neither did Hasdrubal prefer giving the command to any other, when any thing was to be done with courage and activity; nor did the soldiers feel more confidence and boldness under any other leader. His fearlessness in encountering dangers, and his prudence when in the midst of them, were extreme. His body could not be exhausted, nor his mind subdued, by any toil. He could alike endure either heat or cold. The quantity of his food and drink was determined by the wants of nature, and not by pleasure. The seasons of his sleeping and waking were distinguished neither by day nor night. The time that remained after the transaction of business was given to repose; but that repose was neither invited by a soft bed nor by quiet. Many have seen him wrapped in a military cloak, lying on the ground amid the watches and outposts of the soldiers. His dress was not at all superior to that of his equals: his arms and his horses were conspicuous. He was at once by far the first of the cavalry and infantry; and, foremost to advance to the charge, was last to leave the engagement. Excessive vices counterbalanced these high virtues of the hero; inhuman cruelty, more than Punic perfidy, no truth, no reverence for things sacred, no fear of the gods, no respect for oaths, no sense of religion. With a character thus made up of virtue and vices, he served for three years under the command of Hasdrubal, without neglecting any thing which ought to be done or seen by one who was to become a great general.

A few, and almost all of the most respected individuals, agreed with Hanno; but, as is often the case, the larger group won out over the more qualified. Hannibal, after being sent to Spain, instantly caught the attention of the entire army upon his arrival. The veteran soldiers thought they were seeing a young Hamilcar restored to them; they noted the same energy in his appearance and spark in his eyes, the same features and expressions; and soon after, he made sure that his father's influence held minimal importance in gaining their respect. There has never been a talent more suited for the two opposing roles of obeying and commanding; it was hard to tell whether he was more cherished by the general or the troops. Hasdrubal never preferred giving command to anyone else when courage and swift action were needed; nor did the soldiers experience more confidence and bravery under any other leader. His fearlessness in facing danger, along with his caution in the midst of it, was remarkable. His body could withstand any strain, and his mind was unbreakable under pressure. He could handle both heat and cold equally well. His food and drink were based on his body's needs, not his enjoyment. He didn’t maintain any regular schedule for sleeping and waking that was dictated by day or night. The time left after handling tasks was devoted to rest, but that rest didn’t rely on a comfy bed or silence. Many witnessed him wrapped in a military cloak, lying on the ground among the soldiers' watches and outposts. His clothing was no better than that of his peers; his weapons and horses stood out. He was clearly the best of both cavalry and infantry, always the first to charge and the last to retreat. Yet, excessive vices offset these great virtues of the hero; he displayed inhumane cruelty, more than Punic treachery, no honesty, no respect for the sacred, no fear of the gods, no regard for oaths, no sense of faith. With a character made up of both virtues and vices, he served under Hasdrubal for three years, without neglecting anything that a future great general was expected to do or observe.

5

But from the day on which he was declared general, as if Italy had been decreed to him as his province, and the war with Rome committed to him, thinking there should be no delay, lest, while he procrastinated, some unexpected accident might defeat him, as had happened to his father, Hamilcar, and afterwards to Hasdrubal, he resolved to make war the Saguntines. As there could be no doubt that by attacking them the Romans would be excited to arms, he first led his army into the territory of the Olcades, a people beyond the Iberus, rather within the boundaries than under the dominion of the Carthaginians, so that he might not seem to have had the Saguntines for his object, but to have been drawn on to the war by the course of events; after the adjoining nations had been subdued, and by the progressive annexation of conquered territory. He storms and plunders Carteia, a wealthy city, the capital of that nation; at which the smaller states being dismayed, submitted to his command and to the imposition of a tribute. His army, triumphant and enriched with booty, was led into winter-quarters to New Carthage. Having there confirmed the attachment of all his countrymen and allies by a liberal division of the plunder, and by faithfully discharging the arrears of pay, the war was extended, in the beginning of spring, to the Vaccaei. The cities Hermandica and Arbocala were taken by storm. Arbocala was defended for a long time by the valour and number of its inhabitants. Those who escaped from Hermandica joining themselves to the exiles of the Olcades, a nation subdued the preceding summer, excite the Carpetani to arms; and having attacked Hannibal near the river Tagus, on his return from the Vaccaei, they threw into disorder his army encumbered with spoil. Hannibal avoided an engagement, and having pitched his camp on the bank, as soon as quiet and silence prevailed among the enemy, forded the river; and having removed his rampart so far that the enemy might have room to pass over, resolved to attack them in their passage. He commanded the cavalry to charge as soon as they should see them advanced into the water. He drew up the line of his infantry on the bank with forty elephants in front. The Carpetani, with the addition of the Olcades and Vaccaei amounted to a hundred thousand, an invincible army, were the fight to take place in the open plain. Being therefore both naturally ferocious and confiding in their numbers; and since they believed that the enemy had retired through fear thinking that victory was only delayed by the intervention of the river, they raise a shout, and in every direction, without the command of any one, dash into the stream, each where it nearest to him. At the same time, a heavy force of cavalry poured into the river from its opposite bank, and the engagement commenced in the middle of the channel on very unequal terms; for there the foot-soldier, having no secure footing, and scarcely trusting to the ford, could be borne down even by an unarmed horseman, by the mere shock of his horse urged at random; while the horseman, with the command of his body and his weapons, his horse moving steadily even through the middle of the eddies, could maintain the fight either at close quarters or at a distance. A great number were swallowed up by the current; some being carried by the whirlpools of the stream to the side of the enemy, were trodden down by the elephants; and whilst the last, for whom it was more safe to retreat to their own bank, were collecting together after their various alarms, Hannibal, before they could regain courage after such excessive consternation, having entered the river with his army in a close square, forced them to fly from the bank. Having then laid waste their territory, he received the submission of the Carpetani also within a few days. And now all the country beyond the Iberus, excepting that of the Saguntines, was under the power of the Carthaginians.

But from the day he was named general, it was as if Italy had been assigned to him as his territory, and he had been entrusted with the war against Rome. Thinking there should be no delay, fearing that if he hesitated, unexpected events might thwart him as they had done his father Hamilcar and later Hasdrubal, he decided to go to war against the Saguntines. Knowing that attacking them would certainly provoke the Romans to arms, he first led his army into the land of the Olcades, a group beyond the Iberus, more within the borders than under the control of the Carthaginians. This way, he wouldn’t appear to be targeting the Saguntines directly but rather following the course of events as neighboring nations were defeated and territories anexed. He stormed and plundered Carteia, a rich city and the capital of that nation; this frightened the smaller states into submitting to his rule and paying tribute. His victorious army, now wealthy with spoils, was brought to winter quarters at New Carthage. There, he secured the loyalty of all his countrymen and allies by generously sharing the loot and clearing up any overdue pay. At the start of spring, the war spread to the Vaccaei. The cities of Hermandica and Arbocala were taken by assault. Arbocala held out for a long time thanks to the bravery and numbers of its inhabitants. Those who escaped from Hermandica joined forces with the exiles of the Olcades, a nation conquered the previous summer, and rallied the Carpetani to arms. They attacked Hannibal near the Tagus River as he was returning from the Vaccaei, disrupting his army weighed down by loot. Hannibal avoided direct conflict and set up camp on the riverbank. Once the enemy fell quiet, he crossed the river and made room for them to follow over, planning to strike during their crossing. He instructed the cavalry to charge as soon as they saw the enemy enter the water. He positioned his infantry along the bank with forty elephants in front. The Carpetani, joined by the forces of the Olcades and Vaccaei, numbered a hundred thousand—an invincible force on open ground. Naturally fierce and confident in their numbers, they believed that the enemy had retreated out of fear, thinking victory was merely blocked by the river. They shouted and rushed into the stream from all directions, each charging in wherever it was closest. Simultaneously, a strong cavalry force surged into the river from the opposite bank, and the battle began mid-stream on very uneven terms; foot soldiers, lacking solid footing and scarcely trusting the ford, could be easily overwhelmed by even an unarmed horseman charging wildly. Meanwhile, the horsemen, in control of their bodies and weapons, could maintain the fight either close up or from a distance, even navigating through the swirling water. Many were swept away by the current; some were carried by the whirlpools to the enemy's side, where they were trampled by the elephants. As those who found it safer to retreat to their bank gathered after their various panics, Hannibal, before they could recover from their fear, entered the river with his army in a tight formation and forced them to flee the bank. He then ravaged their land and quickly received the surrender of the Carpetani. Now, almost all the territory beyond the Iberus, except for that of the Saguntines, was under Carthaginian control.

6

As yet there was no war with the Saguntines, but already, in order to a war, the seeds of dissension were sown between them and their neighbours, particularly the Turetani, with whom when the same person sided who had originated the quarrel, and it was evident, not that a trial of the question of right, but violence, was his object, ambassadors were sent by the Saguntines to Rome to implore assistance in the war which now evidently threatened them. The consuls then at Rome were Publius Cornelius Scipio and Tiberius Sempronius Longus, who, after the ambassadors were introduced into the senate, having made a motion on the state of public affairs, it was resolved that envoys should be sent into Spain to inspect the circumstances of the allies; and if they saw good reason, both to warn Hannibal that he should refrain from the Saguntines, the allies of the Roman people, and to pass over into Africa to Carthage, and report the complaints of the allies of the Roman people. This embassy having been decreed but not yet despatched, the news arrived, more quickly than any one expected, that Saguntum was besieged. The business was then referred anew to the senate. And some, decreeing Spain and Africa as provinces for the consuls, thought the war should be maintained both by sea and land, while others wished to direct the whole hostilities against Spain and Hannibal. There were others again who thought that an affair of such importance should not be entered on rashly; and that the return of the ambassadors from Spain ought to be awaited. This opinion, which seemed the safest, prevailed; and Publius Valerius Flaccus, and Quintus Baebius Tamphilus, were, on that account, the more quickly despatched as ambassadors to Hannibal at Saguntum, and from thence to Carthage, if he did not desist from the war, to demand the general himself in atonement for the violation of the treaty.

As of now, there wasn't a war with the Saguntines, but the groundwork for conflict was already being laid between them and their neighbors, especially the Turetani. When the same individual who started the dispute took sides, it became clear that his goal was not to settle the matter peacefully but to use violence. The Saguntines sent ambassadors to Rome to seek help against the impending war. The consuls in Rome at that time were Publius Cornelius Scipio and Tiberius Sempronius Longus. After the ambassadors were introduced in the Senate and a discussion on public affairs took place, it was decided that envoys should be sent to Spain to assess the situation of the allies. If they found sufficient reason, they were to warn Hannibal to stay away from the Saguntines, who were allies of the Roman people, and then proceed to Carthage to report on the grievances of the allies. Although this mission had been approved, it hadn't been dispatched yet when news unexpectedly arrived that Saguntum was under siege. The matter was then brought back to the Senate, where some proposed that Spain and Africa be considered provinces for the consuls and believed the war should be fought on both land and sea, while others felt that efforts should focus solely on Spain and Hannibal. Meanwhile, there were those who argued that such an important issue shouldn't be rushed and that they should wait for the ambassadors to return from Spain. This cautious approach, which seemed the safest, prevailed. As a result, Publius Valerius Flaccus and Quintus Baebius Tamphilus were quickly sent as ambassadors to Hannibal at Saguntum, and from there, they would go to Carthage to demand accountability from the general for breaching the treaty if he did not back down from the war.

7

While the Romans thus prepare and deliberate, Saguntum was already besieged with the utmost vigour. That city, situated about a mile from the sea, was by far the most opulent beyond the Iberus. Its inhabitants are said to have been sprung from the island Zacynthus, and some of the Rutulian race from Ardea to have been also mixed with them; but they had risen in a short time to great wealth, either by their gains from the sea or the land, or by the increase of their numbers, or the integrity of their principles, by which they maintained their faith with their allies, even to their own destruction. Hannibal having entered their territory with a hostile army, and laid waste the country in every direction, attacks the city in three different quarters. There was an angle of the wall sloping down into a more level and open valley than the other space around; against this he resolved to move the vineae, by means of which the battering-ram might be brought up to the wall. But though the ground at a distance from the wall was sufficiently level for working the vineae, yet their undertakings by no means favourably succeeded, when they came to effect their object. Both a huge tower overlooked it, and the wall, as in a suspected place, was raised higher than in any other part; and a chosen band of youths presented a more vigorous resistance, where the greatest danger and labour were indicated. At first they repelled the enemy with missile weapons, and suffered no place to be sufficiently secure for those engaged in the works; afterwards, not only did they brandish their weapons in defence of the walls and tower, but they had courage to make sallies on the posts and works of the enemy; in which tumultuary engagements, scarcely more Saguntines than Carthaginians were slain. But when Hannibal himself, while he too incautiously approached the wall, fell severely wounded in the thigh by a javelin, such flight and dismay spread around, that the works and vineae had nearly been abandoned.

While the Romans were preparing and discussing their plans, Saguntum was already being besieged with great intensity. That city, located about a mile from the sea, was by far the wealthiest area beyond the Iberus. Its residents are said to have originated from the island of Zacynthus, and some of the Rutulian people from Ardea also mixed in with them; however, they had quickly accumulated significant wealth through their earnings from both the sea and land, or due to their growing population, or their strong principles, which led them to keep their promises to their allies, even at their own peril. When Hannibal entered their territory with a hostile army and devastated the countryside in every direction, he attacked the city at three different points. There was a section of the wall that sloped down into a flatter and more open valley than the surrounding areas; against this, he decided to set up the vineae, allowing the battering-ram to be brought to the wall. But although the ground farther from the wall was fairly level for the vineae, their efforts did not succeed well when it came to achieving their goal. A massive tower overshadowed it, and the wall in that vulnerable spot was built higher than in any other area; a select group of young men provided a stronger resistance where the greatest danger and exertion were evident. At first, they drove back the enemy with projectile weapons and ensured no area was secure for those working on the tasks; later, not only did they defend the walls and tower with their weapons, but they also bravely launched counterattacks against the enemy’s posts and operations, resulting in chaotic skirmishes where nearly as many Saguntines as Carthaginians fell. However, when Hannibal himself approached the wall too carelessly and was seriously injured in the thigh by a javelin, panic and fear spread so quickly that the works and vineae were almost abandoned.

8

For a few days after, while the general's wound was being cured, there was rather a blockade than a siege: during which time, though there was a respite from fighting, yet there was no intermission in the preparation of works and fortifications. Hostilities, therefore, broke out afresh with greater fury, and in more places, in some even where the ground scarcely admitted of the works, the vineae began to be moved forward, and the battering-ram to be advanced to the walls. The Carthaginian abounded in the numbers of his troops; for there is sufficient reason to believe that he had as many as a hundred and fifty thousand in arms. The townsmen began to be embarrassed, by having their attention multifariously divided, in order to maintain their several defences, and look to every thing; nor were they equal to the task, for the walls were now battered by the rams, and many parts of them were shattered. One part by continuous ruins left the city exposed; three successive towers and all the wall between them had fallen down with an immense crash, and the Carthaginians believed the town taken by that breach; through which, as if the wall had alike protected both, there was a rush from each side to the battle. There was nothing resembling the disorderly fighting which, in the storming of towns, is wont to be engaged in, on the opportunities of either party; but regular lines, as in an open plain, stood arrayed between the ruins of the walls and the buildings of the city, which lay but a slight distance from the walls. On the one side hope, on the other despair, inflamed their courage; the Carthaginian believing that, if a little additional effort were used, the city was his; the Saguntines opposing their bodies in defence of their native city deprived of its walls, and not a man retiring a step, lest he might admit the enemy into the place he deserted. The more keenly and closely, therefore, they fought on both sides, the more, on that account, were wounded, no weapon falling without effect amidst their arms and persons. There was used by the Saguntines a missile weapon, called falarica, with the shaft of fir, and round in other parts except towards the point, whence the iron projected: this part, which was square, as in the pilum, they bound around with tow, and besmeared with pitch. It had an iron head three feet in length, so that it could pierce through the body with the armour. But what caused the greatest fear was, that this weapon, even though it stuck in the shield and did not penetrate into the body, when it was discharged with the middle part on fire, and bore along a much greater flame, produced by the mere motion, obliged the armour to be thrown down, and exposed the soldier to succeeding blows.

For a few days afterward, while the general’s wound was healing, it was more of a blockade than a siege. During this time, although there was a break from fighting, preparations for fortifications and defenses continued without pause. Consequently, hostilities flared up again with even greater intensity and in more locations, even in areas where the terrain barely allowed for construction. The siege towers were pushed forward, and the battering ram was advanced to the walls. The Carthaginians had a huge number of troops; it’s believed there were as many as one hundred fifty thousand armed soldiers. The townspeople found themselves overwhelmed, trying to manage their various defenses while keeping an eye on everything; they weren't up to the task since the walls were being battered by the rams, with many sections crumbling. One part of the wall collapsed under continuous strikes, leaving the city exposed; three towers and the wall between them fell with a massive crash, and the Carthaginians thought the town was theirs through that breach. As if the wall had protected both sides equally, there was a rush to battle from both sides. The fighting was not the chaotic kind typically seen during a city’s storming, but instead, organized lines stood facing each other in open ground between the ruined walls and the buildings just a short distance away. On one side was hope, and on the other, despair; the Carthaginians believed that with just a bit more effort, the city would be theirs, while the Saguntines fought fiercely to defend their hometown, with nobody retreating a step for fear of letting the enemy in. The more intensely both sides fought, the greater the number of wounds inflicted, as no weapon went unused amidst the chaos. The Saguntines used a type of missile weapon called a falarica, made of fir, round except near the tip where the iron jutted out. This part, which was square like a pilum, was wrapped in tow and coated with pitch. It had an iron head three feet long, allowing it to pierce through armor. What caused the most fear was that this weapon, even if it lodged in a shield and didn’t penetrate the body, when fired with its midsection aflame, created a much larger flame from the motion, forcing soldiers to drop their shields and leaving them vulnerable to subsequent attacks.

9

When the contest had for a long time continued doubtful, and the courage of the Saguntines had increased, because they had succeeded in their resistance beyond their hopes, while the Carthaginian, because he had not conquered, felt as vanquished, the townsmen suddenly set up a shout, and drive their enemies to the ruins of the wall; thence they force them, while embarrassed and disordered; and lastly, drove them back, routed and put to flight, to their camp. In the mean time it was announced that ambassadors had arrived from Rome; to meet whom messengers were sent to the sea-side by Hannibal, to tell them that they could not safely come to him through so many armed bands of savage tribes, and that Hannibal at such an important conjuncture had not leisure to listen to embassies. It was obvious that, if not admitted, they would immediately repair to Carthage: he therefore sends letters and messengers beforehand to the leaders of the Barcine faction, to prepare the minds of their partisans, so that the other party might not be able in any thing to give an advantage to the Romans.

When the contest had been uncertain for a long time and the Saguntines had gained confidence because they had resisted beyond their expectations, the Carthaginian felt defeated since he hadn't conquered. Suddenly, the townspeople shouted and pushed their enemies back to the ruins of the wall; from there, they forced them back while they were confused and unorganized. Ultimately, they sent them running, defeated and in flight, back to their camp. In the meantime, it was announced that ambassadors had arrived from Rome. Hannibal sent messengers to the coast to inform them that they could not safely come to him through so many armed bands of hostile tribes and that he didn't have time to listen to embassies at such an important moment. It was clear that if they were not received, they would immediately go to Carthage. Therefore, he sent letters and messengers ahead to the leaders of the Barcine faction to prepare their supporters so that the other side couldn't give any advantage to the Romans.

10

That embassy, therefore, excepting that the ambassadors were admitted and heard, proved likewise vain and fruitless. Hanno alone, in opposition to the rest of the senate, pleaded the cause of the treaty, amidst deep silence on account of his authority, and not from the approbation of the audience. He said: that he had admonished and forewarned them by the gods, the arbiters and witnesses of treaties, that they should not send the son of Hamilcar to the army; that the manes, that the offspring of that man could not rest in peace, nor ever, while any one of the Barcine name and blood survived, would the Roman treaties continue undisturbed. "You, supplying as it were fuel to the flame, have sent to your armies a youth burning with the desire of sovereign power, and seeing but one road to his object, if by exciting war after war, he may live surrounded by arms and legions. You have therefore fostered this fire, in which you now burn. Your armies invest Saguntum, whence they are forbidden by the treaty: ere long the Roman legions will invest Carthage, under the guidance of those gods through whose aid they revenged in the former war the infraction of the treaty. Are you unacquainted with the enemy, or with yourselves, or with the fortune of either nation? Your good general refused to admit into his camp ambassadors coming from allies and in behalf of allies, and set at nought the law of nations. They, however, after being there repulsed, where not even the ambassadors of enemies are prohibited admittance, come to you: they require restitution according to the treaty: let not guilt attach to the state, they demand to have delivered up to them the author of the transgression, the person who is chargeable with this offence. The more gently they proceed,--the slower they are to begin, the more unrelentingly, I fear, when they have once commenced, will they indulge resentment. Set before your eyes the islands Aegates and Eryx, all that for twenty-four years ye have suffered by land and sea. Nor was this boy the leader, but his father Hamilcar himself, a second Mars, as these people would have it: but we had not refrained from Tarentum, that is, from Italy, according to the treaty; as now we do not refrain from Saguntum. The gods and men have, therefore, prevailed over us; and as to that about which there was a dispute in words, whether of the two nations had infringed the treaty, the issue of the war, like an equitable judge, hath awarded the victory to the party on whose side justice stood. It is against Carthage that Hannibal is now moving his vineae and towers: it is the wall of Carthage that he is shaking with his battering-ram. The ruins of Saguntum (oh that I may prove a false prophet!) will fall on our heads; and the war commenced against the Saguntines must be continued against the Romans. Shall we, therefore, some one will say, deliver up Hannibal? In what relates to him I am aware that my authority is of little weight, on account of my enmity with his father. But I both rejoice that Hamilcar perished, for this reason, that, had he lived we should have now been engaged in a war with the Romans; and this youth, as the fury and firebrand of this war, I hate and detest. Nor ought he only to be given up in atonement for the violated treaty; but even though no one demanded him, he ought to be transported to the extremest shores of earth or sea, and banished to a distance, whence neither his name nor any tidings of him can reach us, and he be unable to disturb the peace of a tranquil state. I therefore give my opinion, that ambassadors be sent immediately to Rome to satisfy the senate; others to tell Hannibal to lead away his army from Saguntum, and to deliver up Hannibal himself, according to the treaty to the Romans; and I propose a third embassy to make restitution to the Saguntines."

That embassy, then, even though the ambassadors were allowed in and heard, turned out to be useless and pointless. Hanno alone, against the rest of the senate, argued for the treaty, during a heavy silence due to his authority, not because the audience agreed with him. He said that he had warned them by the gods, the arbiters and witnesses of treaties, not to send the son of Hamilcar to the army; that the spirits of the deceased, and the offspring of that man could not find peace, nor would the Roman treaties be respected, as long as anyone of the Barcine name and blood was alive. "You, feeding the fire, have sent a young man eager for power to your armies, seeing only one way to achieve his goal, which is to create war after war, living surrounded by arms and legions. You have therefore stoked this fire, in which you are now burning. Your armies are surrounding Saguntum, which the treaty forbids: soon the Roman legions will surround Carthage, guided by those gods who assisted them in the previous war when they sought justice for breaking of the treaty. Are you unfamiliar with the enemy, yourselves, or the outcome for both nations? Your good general refused to allow ambassadors from allies into his camp, disregarding the law of nations. However, after being rejected there, where even the ambassadors of enemies aren’t prohibited, they now come to you: they want restitution according to the treaty: don't let guilt fall on the state; they demand the delivery of the person responsible for this offense. The more gently they act,—the slower they are to start, the more relentless they will likely be when they do begin to show their resentment. Consider the Aegates and Eryx islands, everything you have suffered for twenty-four years by land and sea. It wasn't this boy who led the charge, but his father Hamilcar himself, like a second Mars, as these people would claim: yet we didn’t refrain from Tarentum, meaning from Italy, as we now do not refrain from Saguntum. Therefore, the gods and men have prevailed against us; and as to the dispute over whether either nation infringed the treaty, the result of the war, like a fair judge, has given the victory to the side that represented justice. Hannibal is now directing his siege equipment and towers against Carthage: it is the wall of Carthage he is shaking with his battering ram. The destruction of Saguntum (oh that I could be proven wrong!) will fall back on us; and the war that started against the Saguntines must be continued against the Romans. So, someone might ask, shall we hand over Hannibal? Regarding him, I know my opinions carry little weight because of my hatred for his father. But I’m glad that Hamilcar is dead, for if he were alive we would already be at war with the Romans; and I hate and detest this young man, the spark and instigator of this war. He should not only be handed over as atonement for the violated treaty; even if no one demanded him, he should be banished to the furthest edge of the earth or sea, to a place where neither his name nor any news of him can reach us, preventing him from disrupting the peace of a tranquil state. Therefore, I propose that we send ambassadors immediately to Rome to satisfy the senate; others to tell Hannibal to lead his army away from Saguntum, and to hand over Hannibal himself to the Romans, according to the treaty; and I suggest a third embassy to make restitution to the Saguntines."

11

When Hanno had concluded, there was no occasion for any one to contend with him in debate, to such a decree were almost all the senators devoted to Hannibal; and they accused Hanno of having spoken with more malignity than Flaccus Valerius, the Roman ambassador. It was then said in answer to the Roman ambassadors, "that the war had been commenced by the Saguntines, not by Hannibal; and that the Roman people acted unjustly if they preferred the Saguntines to the most ancient [15] alliance of the Carthaginians." Whilst the Romans waste time in sending embassies, Hannibal, because his soldiers were fatigued with the battles and the works, allowed them rest for a few days, parties being stationed to guard the vineae and other works. In the mean time he inflames their minds, now by inciting their anger against the enemy, now with the hope of reward. But when he declared before the assembled army, that the plunder of the captured city should be given to the soldiers, to such a degree were they all excited, that if the signal had been immediately given, it appeared that they could not have been resisted by any force. The Saguntines, as they had a respite from fighting, neither for some days attacking nor attacked, so they had not, by night or day, ever ceased from toiling, that they might repair anew the wall in the quarter where the town had been exposed by the breach. A still more desperate storming than the former then assailed them; nor whilst all quarters resounded with various clamours, could they satisfactorily know where first or principally they should lend assistance. Hannibal, as an encouragement, was present in person, where a movable tower, exceeding in height all the fortifications of the city, was urged forward. When being brought up it had cleared the walls of their defenders by means of the catapultae and ballistae ranged through all its stories, then Hannibal, thinking it a favourable opportunity, sends about five hundred Africans with pickaxes to undermine the wall: nor was the work difficult, since the unhewn stones were not fastened with lime, but filled in their interstices with clay, after the manner of ancient building. It fell, therefore, more extensively than it was struck, and through the open spaces of the ruins troops of armed men rushed into the city. They also obtain possession of a rising ground; and having collected thither catapultae and ballistae, so that they might have a fort in the city itself, commanding it like a citadel, they surround it with a wall: and the Saguntines raise an inner wall before the part of the city which was not yet taken. On both sides they exert the utmost vigour in fortifying and fighting: but the Saguntines, by erecting these inner defences, diminish daily the size of their city. At the same time, the want of all supplies increased through the length of the siege, and the expectation of foreign aid diminished, since the Romans, their only hope, were at such a distance, and all the country round was in the power of the enemy. The sudden departure of Hannibal against the Oretani and Carpetani [16] revived for a little their drooping spirits; which two nations, though, exasperated by the severity of the levy, they had occasioned, by detaining the commissaries, the fear of a revolt, having been suddenly checked by the quickness of Hannibal, laid down the arms they had taken up.

When Hanno finished speaking, no one dared to challenge him in debate; almost all the senators were loyal to Hannibal. They accused Hanno of being more malicious than Flaccus Valerius, the Roman ambassador. In response to the Roman ambassadors, it was stated that the Saguntines started the war, not Hannibal, and that the Roman people were being unfair if they favored the Saguntines over the long-standing alliance with the Carthaginians. While the Romans were busy sending embassies, Hannibal, recognizing that his soldiers were tired from battle and their work, granted them a few days of rest, with parties assigned to guard the vines and other projects. In the meantime, he stoked their emotions, provoking their anger against the enemy while also instilling hope for rewards. When he announced to the assembled army that the loot from the captured city would be given to the soldiers, their excitement peaked to the point that, if the battle signal had been given immediately, they could have overwhelmed any opposing force. The Saguntines, having a break from fighting, didn't engage in attacks for several days, yet they worked tirelessly day and night to repair the wall in the area where it had been breached. They faced an even more aggressive assault than before; amidst the chaos and noise from all sides, they couldn't determine where to provide help first. Hannibal, to encourage them, personally oversaw the approach of a mobile tower, taller than any city fortification. Once it was positioned against the walls and cleared them of defenders using catapults and ballistae from all its levels, Hannibal seized the opportunity and sent about five hundred Africans with pickaxes to undermine the wall. The task wasn't difficult, as the uncut stones weren't secured with lime but were packed with clay, typical of ancient construction. The wall collapsed more significantly than it was struck, and through the gaps, armed troops surged into the city. They also captured a high ground, collecting catapults and ballistae there to establish a stronghold within the city, fortifying it like a citadel, surrounding it with a wall. Meanwhile, the Saguntines erected an inner wall before the section of the city that was still unbroken. Both sides exerted the utmost effort in fortifying their positions and fighting; however, the Saguntines, by constructing these inner defenses, gradually reduced the size of their city. At the same time, the lack of supplies grew worse as the siege dragged on, and the hope for foreign assistance dwindled since the Romans, their only hope, were far away, and the surrounding area was under enemy control. Hannibal's sudden march against the Oretani and Carpetani briefly lifted their spirits. Although these two nations faced the harsh consequences of the draft by holding up the supply officers, the fear of rebellion had been quickly quelled by Hannibal's swift actions, forcing them to lay down the arms they had taken up.

12

Nor was the siege of Saguntum, in the mean time, less vigorously maintained; Maharbal, the son of Himilco, whom Hannibal had set over the army, carrying on operations so actively that neither the townsmen nor their enemies perceived that the general was away. He both engaged in several successful battles, and with three battering-rams overthrew a portion of the wall; and showed to Hannibal, on his arrival the ground all covered with fresh ruins. The army was therefore immediately led against the citadel itself, and a desperate combat was commenced with much slaughter on both sides, and part of the citadel was taken. The slight chance of a peace was then tried by two persons; Alcon a Saguntine, and Alorcus a Spaniard. Alcon, thinking he could effect something by entreaties, having passed over, without the knowledge of the Saguntines, to Hannibal by night, when his tears produced no effect, and harsh conditions were offered as from an exasperated conqueror, becoming a deserter instead of an advocate, remained with the enemy; affirming that the man would be put to death who should treat for peace on such terms. For it was required that they should make restitution to the Turdetani; and after delivering up all their gold and silver, departing from the city each with a single garment, should take up their dwelling where the Carthaginian should direct. Alcon having denied that the Saguntines would accept such terms of peace, Alorcus, asserting that when all else is subdued, the mind becomes subdued, offers himself as the proposer of that peace. Now at that time he was a soldier of Hannibal's, but publicly the friend and host of the Saguntines. Having openly delivered his weapon to the guards of the enemy and passed the fortifications, he was conducted, as he had himself requested, to the Saguntine praetor; whither when there was immediately a general rush of every description of people, the rest of the multitude being removed, an audience of the senate is given to Alorcus; whose speech was to the following effect:

Nor was the siege of Saguntum, in the meantime, any less intensely pursued; Maharbal, the son of Himilco, whom Hannibal had put in charge of the army, was so active in operations that neither the townspeople nor their enemies noticed that their general was absent. He fought several successful battles and, using three battering rams, tore down part of the wall; he showed Hannibal, upon his arrival, the grounds littered with fresh ruins. The army was then immediately directed against the citadel itself, and a fierce battle began with heavy casualties on both sides, resulting in part of the citadel being captured. At that point, a slim chance for peace was attempted by two individuals: Alcon, a Saguntine, and Alorcus, a Spaniard. Alcon, believing he could achieve something through pleas, secretly crossed over to Hannibal at night without the Saguntines' knowledge. When his tears had no effect, and harsh conditions were presented as if from an enraged conqueror, he became a deserter instead of a negotiator, staying with the enemy and claiming that anyone who negotiated for peace under such terms would be executed. They were required to compensate the Turdetani and, after surrendering all their gold and silver, leave the city with only one garment each, living wherever the Carthaginian commanded. Alcon denied that the Saguntines would accept such peace terms. Alorcus, asserting that when everything is subdued, the mind also submits, offered himself as the one to propose that peace. At that moment, he was a soldier under Hannibal but publicly a friend and host of the Saguntines. He openly handed over his weapon to the enemy guards and passed through the fortifications, as he had requested, being taken to the Saguntine praetor; once there, he immediately attracted a crowd of various people. After the majority was cleared away, he was given an audience with the senate; his speech was as follows:

13

"If your citizen Alcon, as he came to implore a peace from Hannibal, had in like manner brought back to you the terms of peace proposed by Hannibal, this journey of mine would have been unnecessary; by which circumstance I should not have had to come to you as the legate of Hannibal, nor as a deserter. Since he has remained with your enemies, either through your fault or his own, (through his own, if he counterfeited fear; through yours, if among you there be danger to those who tell the truth,) that you may not be ignorant that there are some terms of safety and peace for you, I have come to you in consideration of the ancient ties of hospitality which subsist between us. But that I speak what I address to you for your sake and that of no other, let even this be the proof: that neither while you resisted with your own strength, nor while you expected assistance from the Romans, did I ever make any mention of peace to you. But now, after you have neither any hope from the Romans, nor your own arms nor walls sufficiently defend you, I bring to you a peace rather necessary than just: of effecting which there is thus some hope, if, as Hannibal offers it in the spirit of a conqueror, you listen to it as vanquished; if you will consider not what is taken from you as loss, (since all belongs to the conqueror,) but whatever is left as a gift. He takes away from you your city, which, already for the greater part in ruins, he has almost wholly in his possession; he leaves you your territory, intending to mark out a place in which you may build a new town; he commands that all the gold and silver, both public and private, shall be brought to him; he preserves inviolate your persons and those of your wives and children, provided you are willing to depart from Saguntum, unarmed, each with two garments. These terms a victorious enemy dictates. These, though harsh and grievous, your condition commends to you. Indeed I do not despair, when the power of every thing is given him, that he will remit something from these terms. But even these I think you ought rather to endure, than suffer, by the rights of war, yourselves to be slaughtered, your wives and children to be ravished and dragged into captivity before your faces."

"If your citizen Alcon, when he came to ask Hannibal for peace, had similarly returned to you with the terms proposed by Hannibal, my journey would have been unnecessary. In that case, I wouldn't have had to come to you as Hannibal's envoy or as a defector. Since he has chosen to stay with your enemies, either because of your fault or his own—his own if he faked fear, yours if there's danger in speaking the truth among you—I’ve come to remind you that there are terms of safety and peace available. I’m here because of the long-standing bond of hospitality between us. To prove that I speak solely for your sake and no one else’s: while you were strong enough to resist on your own, and while you hoped for help from the Romans, I never mentioned peace to you. But now that you have no hope from the Romans, and neither your own weapons nor your walls can protect you, I bring you a peace that is more necessary than just. There is some hope for it if, as Hannibal presents it like a conqueror, you receive it as those who are defeated. Consider not what you’re losing but what remains as a gift. He is taking your city, which is mostly in ruins and almost entirely under his control; he is leaving you your land, planning to designate an area for a new town; he commands that all public and private gold and silver be handed over to him; and he will protect you, your wives, and your children, as long as you agree to leave Saguntum unarmed, each person carrying only two garments. These terms are dictated by a victorious enemy. Though they are harsh and painful, your situation demands that you consider them. I don't lose hope that, given his power, he might ease some of these terms. But even these conditions are better to endure than to face the horrors of war, where you would be slaughtered and your wives and children would be violated and taken into captivity in front of you."

14

When an assembly of the people, by the gradual crowding round of the multitude, had mingled with the senate to hear these proposals, the chief men suddenly withdrawing before an answer was returned, and throwing all the gold and silver collected, both from public and private stores, into a fire hastily kindled for that purpose, the greater part flung themselves also into it. When the dismay and agitation produced by this deed had pervaded the whole city, another noise was heard in addition from the citadel. A tower, long battered, had fallen down; and when a Carthaginian cohort, rushing through the breach, had made a signal to the general that the city was destitute of the usual outposts and guards, Hannibal, thinking that there ought to be no delay at such an opportunity, having attacked the city with his whole forces, took it in a moment, command being given that all the adults should be put to death; which command, though cruel, was proved in the issue to have been almost necessary. For to whom of those men could mercy have been shown, who, either shut up with their wives and children, burned their houses over their own heads, or abroad in arms made no end of fighting, except in death.

When a gathering of people, gradually forming a crowd, mixed with the senate to hear these proposals, the leaders suddenly withdrew before a response was given. They threw all the gold and silver collected from both public and private sources into a fire quickly set for that purpose, and many of them jumped in as well. When the fear and turmoil caused by this action spread throughout the entire city, another commotion was heard from the citadel. A tower, which had been battered for a long time, collapsed; and when a Carthaginian cohort rushed through the breach and signaled to the general that the city was lacking its usual outposts and guards, Hannibal, believing there should be no delay at such a moment, attacked the city with all his forces and captured it instantly. He ordered that all the adults be killed; although this command was brutal, it turned out to be almost necessary. For whom among those men could have been spared mercy, who either, trapped with their wives and children, burned their own houses over their heads, or were out fighting relentlessly, only finding peace in death?

15

The town was taken, with immense spoil. Though the greater part of the goods had been purposely damaged by their owners, and resentment had made scarce any distinction of age in the massacre, and the captives were the booty of the soldiers; still it appears that some money was raised from the price of the effects that were sold, and that much costly furniture and garments were sent to Carthage. Some have written that Saguntum was taken in the eighth month after it began to be besieged; that Hannibal then retired to New Carthage, into winter quarters; and that in the fifth month after he had set out from Carthage he arrived in Italy. If this be so, it was impossible that Publius Cornelius and Tiberius Sempronius could have been consuls, to whom both at the beginning of the siege the Saguntine ambassadors were despatched, and who, during their office, fought with Hannibal; the one at the river Ticinus, and both some time after at the Trebia. Either all these events took place in a somewhat shorter period, or Saguntum was not begun to be besieged, but taken at the beginning of the year in which Publius Cornelius and Tiberius Sempronius were consuls. For the battle at Trebia could not have been so late as the year of Cneius Servilius and Caius Flaminius, since Flaminius entered on the office at Ariminum, having been created by the consul Tiberius Sempronius; who, having repaired to Rome after the battle at Trebia for the purpose of creating consuls, returned when the election was finished to the army into winter quarters.

The town was captured, with great loot. While most of the goods had been intentionally damaged by their owners, and anger eliminated any distinction of age during the massacre, the captured were the spoils of the soldiers. Still, some money was made from selling the items, and a lot of expensive furniture and clothing were sent to Carthage. Some sources claim that Saguntum was taken in the eighth month after the siege began; Hannibal then retreated to New Carthage for the winter; and five months after leaving Carthage, he arrived in Italy. If this is accurate, it was impossible for Publius Cornelius and Tiberius Sempronius to have been consuls, to whom the Saguntine ambassadors were sent at the start of the siege, and who fought Hannibal during their term—one at the Ticinus River, and both later at Trebia. Either all these events happened in a shorter time frame, or Saguntum was besieged and captured at the beginning of the year when Publius Cornelius and Tiberius Sempronius were consuls. The battle at Trebia couldn't have happened as late as the year of Cneius Servilius and Caius Flaminius, since Flaminius took office at Ariminum after being appointed by consul Tiberius Sempronius; who, after returning to Rome following the battle at Trebia to appoint consuls, came back to the army for winter quarters once the elections were over.

16

Nearly about the same time, both the ambassadors who had returned from Carthage brought intelligence to Rome that all appearances were hostile, and the destruction of Saguntum was announced. Then such grief, and pity for allies so undeservingly destroyed, and shame that aid was withheld, and rage against the Carthaginians, and fear for the issue of events, as if the enemy were already at the gates, took at once possession of the senators, that their minds, disturbed by so many simultaneous emotions, trembled with fear rather than deliberated. For they considered that neither had a more spirited or warlike enemy ever encountered them nor had the Roman state been ever so sunk in sloth, and unfit for war: that the Sardinians, the Corsicans, the Istrians, and the Illyrians, had rather kept in a state of excitement than exercised the Roman arms; and with the Gauls it had been more properly a tumult than a war. That the Carthaginian, a veteran enemy, ever victorious during the hardest service for twenty-three years among the tribes of Spain, first trained to war under Hamilcar, then Hasdrubal, now Hannibal, a most active leader, and fresh from the destruction of a most opulent city, was passing the Iberus; that along with them he was bringing the numerous tribes of Spain, already aroused, and was about to excite the nations of Gaul, ever desirous of war; and that a war against the world was to be maintained in Italy and before the walls of Rome.

Around the same time, both ambassadors who returned from Carthage brought news to Rome that everything seemed hostile, and the destruction of Saguntum was reported. This news filled the senators with grief, pity for their allies who were so unjustly destroyed, shame for not providing assistance, anger towards the Carthaginians, and fear about what was to come, as if the enemy were already at their gates. They were overwhelmed by so many intense emotions that they were more paralyzed by fear than able to think clearly. They realized that they had never faced a more spirited or warlike enemy and that the Roman state had never been so lazy and unprepared for war. The Sardinians, Corsicans, Istrians, and Illyrians had kept the Roman troops in a state of restlessness rather than actively engaged, and their encounters with the Gauls had been more like riots than actual warfare. The Carthaginian, a seasoned foe, had been victorious for twenty-three years among the tribes of Spain, first training for war under Hamilcar, then Hasdrubal, and now Hannibal, a highly energetic leader fresh from the destruction of a wealthy city, was crossing the Iberus. Along with him came the many tribes of Spain, already riled up, and he was about to stir the nations of Gaul, who were always eager for conflict. They recognized that a war against the world was about to be fought in Italy and at the gates of Rome.

17

The provinces had already been previously named for the consuls; and having been now ordered to cast lots for them, Spain fell to Cornelius, and Africa with Sicily to Sempronius. Six legions were decreed for that year, and as many of the allies as should seem good to the consuls, and as great a fleet as could be equipped. Twenty-four thousand Roman infantry were levied, and one thousand eight hundred horse: forty thousand infantry of the allies, and four thousand four hundred horse: two hundred and twenty ships of three banks of oars, and twenty light galleys, were launched. It was then proposed to the people, "whether they willed and commanded that war should be declared against the people of Carthage;" and for the sake of that war a supplication was made through the city, and the gods were implored that the war which the Roman people had decreed might have a prosperous and fortunate issue. The forces were thus divided between the consuls. To Sempronius two legions were given, (each of these consisted of four thousand infantry and three hundred horse,) and sixteen thousand of the infantry of the allies, and one thousand eight hundred horse: one hundred and sixty ships of war, and twelve light galleys. With these land and sea forces Tiberius Sempronius was despatched to Sicily, in order to transport his army to Africa if the other consul should be able to prevent the Carthaginian from invading Italy. Fewer troops were given to Cornelius, because Lucius Manlius, the praetor, also had been sent with no weak force into Gaul. The number of ships in particular was reduced to Cornelius. Sixty of five banks of oars were assigned to him, (for they did not believe that the enemy would come by sea, or would fight after that mode of warfare,) and two Roman legions with their regular cavalry, and fourteen thousand of the infantry of the allies, with one thousand six hundred horse. The province of Gaul being not as yet exposed to the Carthaginian invasion, had, in the same year, two Roman legions, ten thousand allied infantry, one thousand allied cavalry, and six hundred Roman.

The provinces had already been named after the consuls; and now they were ordered to draw lots for them. Spain went to Cornelius, while Africa along with Sicily went to Sempronius. Six legions were authorized for that year, along with as many allies as the consuls deemed appropriate, and as large a fleet as could be assembled. Twenty-four thousand Roman infantry were recruited, along with one thousand eight hundred cavalry: forty thousand allied infantry and four thousand four hundred allied cavalry: two hundred and twenty warships with three banks of oars, and twenty light galleys were launched. It was then proposed to the people, "Do you agree and command that war should be declared against the people of Carthage?" A public prayer was made throughout the city, asking the gods for a successful and favorable outcome for the war that the Roman people had decided upon. The forces were divided between the consuls. Sempronius received two legions (each consisting of four thousand infantry and three hundred cavalry), along with sixteen thousand allied infantry and one thousand eight hundred allied cavalry: one hundred sixty warships and twelve light galleys. Tiberius Sempronius was sent to Sicily with these land and sea forces to transport his army to Africa if the other consul could hold off the Carthaginians from invading Italy. Cornelius received fewer troops because Lucius Manlius, the praetor, was also sent to Gaul with a substantial force. Specifically, Cornelius was given a reduced number of ships. He was assigned sixty warships with five banks of oars (since they did not believe the enemy would approach by sea or fight in that manner), along with two Roman legions and their regular cavalry, fourteen thousand allied infantry, and one thousand six hundred allied cavalry. Since Gaul was not yet at risk of a Carthaginian invasion, it received two Roman legions, ten thousand allied infantry, one thousand allied cavalry, and six hundred Roman cavalry that same year.

18

These preparations having been thus made, in order that every thing that was proper might be done before they commenced war, they send Quintus Fabius, Marcus Livius, Lucius Aemilius, Caius Licinius, and Quintus Baebius, men of advanced years, as ambassadors into Africa, to inquire of the Carthaginians if Hannibal had laid siege to Saguntum by public authority; and if they should confess it, as it seemed probable they would, and defend it as done by public authority, to declare war against the people of Carthage. After the Romans arrived at Carthage, when an audience of the senate was given them, and Quintus Fabius had addressed no further inquiry than the one with which they had been charged, then one of the Carthaginians replied: "Even your former embassy, O Romans, was precipitate, when you demanded Hannibal to be given up, as attacking Saguntum on his own authority: but your present embassy, though so far milder in words, is in fact more severe. For then Hannibal was both accused, and required to be delivered up: now both a confession of wrong is exacted from us, and, as though we had confessed, restitution is immediately demanded. But I think that the question is not, whether Saguntum was attacked by private or public authority, but whether it was with right or wrong. For in the case of our citizen, the right of inquiry, whether he has acted by his own pleasure or ours, and the punishment also, belongs to us. The only dispute with you is, whether it was allowed to be done by the treaty. Since, therefore, it pleases you that a distinction should be made between what commanders do by public authority, and what on their own suggestion, there was a treaty between us made by the consul Lutatius; in which, though provision was made for the allies of both, there is no provision made for the Saguntines, for they were not as yet your allies. But in that treaty which was made with Hasdrubal, the Saguntines are excepted; against which I am going to say nothing but what I have learned from you. For you denied that you were bound by the treaty which Caius Lutatius the consul first made with us, because that it had neither been made by the authority of the senate nor the command of the people; and another treaty was therefore concluded anew by public authority. If your treaties do not bind you unless they are made by your authority and your commands, neither can the treaty of Hasdrubal, which he made without our knowledge, be binding on us. Cease, therefore, to make mention of Saguntum and the Iberus, and let your mind at length bring forth that with which it has long been in labour." Then the Roman, having formed a fold in his robe, said, "Here we bring to you peace and war; take which you please." On this speech they exclaimed no less fiercely in reply: "he might give which he chose;" and when he again, unfolding his robe, said "he gave war," they all answered that "they accepted it, and would maintain it with the same spirit with which they accepted it."

These preparations having been made so that everything proper could be done before they started the war, they sent Quintus Fabius, Marcus Livius, Lucius Aemilius, Caius Licinius, and Quintus Baebius, older men, as ambassadors to Africa to ask the Carthaginians if Hannibal had besieged Saguntum with public authority. If they admitted it, which seemed likely, and justified it as an official act, they would declare war against the Carthaginians. After the Romans reached Carthage and were given an audience with the Senate, Quintus Fabius only asked the question he was instructed to ask. One of the Carthaginians replied: "Your earlier embassy, Romans, was rash when you demanded Hannibal's surrender as he attacked Saguntum on his own authority; but this current embassy, though phrased more mildly, is in reality more harsh. For then, Hannibal was both accused and asked to be handed over; now you expect us to admit wrongdoing and, as if we’ve admitted it, you immediately demand restitution. But I believe the real question is not whether Saguntum was attacked by private or public authority, but whether it was right or wrong. The right to investigate whether our citizen acted on his own or with our approval, and the right to punish, belong to us. The only issue for you is whether it was permitted by the treaty. Since you want a distinction between what commanders do with public authority and what they do on their own initiative, there was a treaty made by consul Lutatius; this treaty provided for the allies of both sides, but did not include the Saguntines, as they were not your allies at that time. In the treaty made with Hasdrubal, however, the Saguntines are specifically mentioned; about which I will only repeat what I learned from you. You claimed you were not bound by the treaty made by Caius Lutatius, because it was not authorized by the Senate or mandated by the people; thus, a new treaty was made with public authority. If your treaties don’t bind you unless they are made with your authority and commands, then neither can Hasdrubal's treaty bind us, as it was made without our consent. Therefore, stop mentioning Saguntum and the Iberus, and let your mind finally produce what it has long been struggling with." Then the Roman, folding his robe, said, "Here we present you peace and war; choose which you prefer." The Carthaginians responded fiercely, saying, "He may give whichever he pleases;" and when he opened his robe again, saying, "I give war," they all replied that "they accepted it and would fight with the same spirit with which they accepted it."

19

This direct inquiry and denunciation of war seemed more consistent with the dignity of the Roman people, both before and now, especially when Saguntum was destroyed, than to cavil in words about the obligation of treaties. For if it was a subject for a controversy of words, in what was the treaty of Hasdrubal to be compared with the former treaty of Lutatius, which was altered? Since in the treaty of Lutatius, was expressly added, "that it should only be held good if the people sanctioned it;" but in the treaty of Hasdrubal, neither was there any such exception; and that treaty during its life had been so established by the silence of so many years, that not even after the death of its author was any change made in it. Although even were they to abide by the former treaty, there had been sufficient provision made for the Saguntines by excepting the allies of both states; for neither was it added, "those who then were," nor "those who should afterwards be admitted." and since it is allowable to admit new allies, who could think it proper, either that no people should be received for any services into friendship? or that, being received under protection, they should not be defended? It was only stipulated, that the allies of the Carthaginians should not be excited to revolt, nor, revolting of their own accord, be received. The Roman ambassadors, according as they had been commanded at Rome, passed over from Carthage into Spain, in order to visit the nations, and either to allure them into an alliance, or dissuade them from joining the Carthaginians. They came first to the Bargusii, by whom having been received with welcome, because they were weary of the Carthaginian government, they excited many of the states beyond the Iberus to the desire of a revolution. Thence they came to the Volciani, whose reply being celebrated through Spain, dissuaded the other states from an alliance with the Romans; for thus the oldest member in their council made answer: "What sense of shame have ye, Romans, to ask of us that we should prefer your friendship to that of the Carthaginians, when you, their allies, betrayed the Saguntines with greater cruelty than that with which the Carthaginians, their enemies, destroyed them? There, methinks, you should look for allies, where the massacre of Saguntum is unknown. The ruins of Saguntum will remain a warning as melancholy as memorable to the states of Spain, that no one should confide in the faith or alliance of Rome." Having been then commanded to depart immediately from the territory of the Volciani, they afterwards received no kinder words from any of the councils of Spain: they therefore pass into Gaul, after having gone about through Spain to no purpose.

This direct questioning and condemnation of war seemed more in line with the dignity of the Roman people, both then and now, especially after the fall of Saguntum, than just arguing about the obligations of treaties. If it was just a matter of verbal debate, how could the treaty with Hasdrubal be compared to the earlier treaty with Lutatius, which was changed? Because in the treaty with Lutatius, it was specifically stated, "it should only be valid if the people approved it;" whereas in the treaty with Hasdrubal, there was no such clause, and that treaty was upheld for so long, even remaining unchanged after its author's death. Even if they held to the previous treaty, sufficient provision was already made for the Saguntines by excluding the allies of both states; there was no mention of "those who were there at the time" or "those who would join later." Since it is permissible to accept new allies, who could think it appropriate for no one to be welcomed into friendship for any services? Or that those who were granted protection should not be defended? It was only agreed that the allies of the Carthaginians should not be incited to rebel, nor should they be accepted if they revolted on their own. The Roman ambassadors, following their orders from Rome, moved from Carthage to Spain to visit the nations, trying to either attract them into an alliance or discourage them from joining the Carthaginians. They first arrived at the Bargusii, who welcomed them since they were tired of Carthaginian rule, encouraging many states beyond the Iberus to desire change. From there, they went to the Volciani, whose response echoed throughout Spain, dissuading the other states from allying with the Romans; for this was how the oldest member in their council replied: "What shame do you, Romans, have to ask us to choose your friendship over that of the Carthaginians, when you, their allies, betrayed the Saguntines more cruelly than the Carthaginians, their enemies, destroyed them? You should seek allies where the massacre of Saguntum is unknown. The ruins of Saguntum will serve as a sad yet memorable warning to the states of Spain, that no one should trust in the faith or alliance of Rome." After being ordered to leave the Volciani’s territory immediately, they received no better responses from any councils in Spain; they thus moved to Gaul after having traveled through Spain in vain.

20

Among the Gauls a new and alarming spectacle was seen, by reason of their coming (such is the custom of the nation) in arms to the assembly. When, extolling in their discourse the renown and valour of the Roman people, and the wide extent of their empire, they had requested that they would refuse a passage through their territory and cities to the Carthaginian invading Italy; such laughter and yelling is said to have arisen, that the youths were with difficulty composed to order by the magistrates and old men. So absurd and shameless did the request seem, to propose that the Gauls, rather than suffer the war to pass on to Italy, should turn it upon themselves and expose their own lands to be laid waste instead of those of others. When the tumult was at length allayed, answer was returned to the ambassadors, "that they had neither experienced good from the Romans, nor wrong from the Carthaginians, on account of which they should either take up arms in behalf of the Romans, or against the Cathaginians. On the contrary, they had heard that men of their nation had been driven from the lands and confines of Italy by the Roman people, that they had to pay a tribute, and suffered other indignities." Nearly the same was said and heard in the other assemblies of Gaul; nor did they hear any thing friendly or pacific before they came to Marseilles. There, every thing found out by the care and fidelity of the allies was made known to them--"that the minds of the Gauls had been already prepossessed by Hannibal, but that not even by him would that nation be found very tractable, (so fierce and untameable are their dispositions,) unless the affections of the chiefs should every now and then be conciliated with gold, of which that people are most covetous." Having thus gone round through the tribes of Spain and Gaul, the ambassadors return to Rome not long after the consuls had set out for their provinces. They found the whole city on tiptoe in expectation of war, the report being sufficiently confirmed, that the Carthaginians had already passed the Iberus.

Among the Gauls, a new and alarming sight appeared as they showed up armed for the assembly, which is a custom of their nation. While praising the reputation and bravery of the Roman people and the vastness of their empire, they asked to deny the Carthaginians passage through their territory and cities as they invaded Italy. The laughter and shouting that followed were so loud that the magistrates and elders struggled to restore order among the youth. It seemed utterly ridiculous and shameless to suggest that the Gauls should take on the war rather than allow it to pass to Italy, putting their own lands at risk instead of other people's. Once the uproar finally settled, the ambassadors were told, "We have not benefited from the Romans nor been wronged by the Carthaginians. So why should we fight for the Romans or against the Carthaginians? In fact, we’ve heard that our people have been driven from their lands in Italy by the Romans, forced to pay tribute, and subjected to other humiliations." Almost the same sentiments were expressed in the other assemblies throughout Gaul, and they heard nothing positive or peaceful before reaching Marseilles. There, they learned from the allies that the Gauls had already been influenced by Hannibal, but even he wouldn't find them easy to handle due to their fierce and uncontrollable nature, unless their leaders were occasionally appeased with gold, which they are very greedy for. After visiting the tribes of Spain and Gaul, the ambassadors returned to Rome shortly after the consuls had departed for their provinces. They found the entire city buzzing with anticipation of war, as the reports of the Carthaginians crossing the Iberus were already widely confirmed.

21

Hannibal, after the taking of Saguntum, had retired to New Carthage into winter quarters; and there, having heard what had been done and decreed at Rome and Carthage, and that he was not only the leader, but also the cause of the war, after having divided and sold the remains of the plunder, thinking there ought to be no longer delay, he calls together and thus addresses his soldiers of the Spanish race: "I believe, tribes, that even you yourselves perceive that, all the tribes of Spain having been reduced to peace, we must either conclude our campaigns and disband our armies, or transfer the war into other regions: for thus these nations will flourish amid the blessings not only of peace, but also of victory, if we seek from other countries spoils and renown. Since, therefore, a campaign far from home soon awaits you, and it is uncertain when you shall again see your homes, and all that is there dear to you, if any one of you wishes to visit his friends, I grant him leave of absence. I give you orders to be here at the beginning of spring, that, with the good assistance of the gods, we may enter on a war which will prove one of great glory and spoil." This power of visiting their homes, voluntarily offered, was acceptable to almost all, already longing to see their friends, and foreseeing in future a still longer absence Repose through the whole season of winter, between toils already undergone and those that were soon to be endured, repaired the vigour of their bodies and minds to encounter all difficulties afresh. At the beginning of spring they assembled according to command. Hannibal, when he had reviewed the auxiliaries of all the nations, having gone to Gades, performs his vows to Hercules; and binds himself by new vows, provided his other projects should have a prosperous issue. Then dividing his care at the same time between the offensive and defensive operations of the war, lest while he was advancing on Italy by a land journey through Spain and Gaul, Africa should be unprotected and exposed to the Romans from Sicily, he resolved to strengthen it with a powerful force. For this purpose he requested a reinforcement from Africa, chiefly of light-armed spearmen, in order that the Africans might serve in Spain, and the Spaniards in Africa, each likely to be a better soldier at a distance from home, as if bound by mutual pledges. He sent into Africa thirteen thousand eight hundred and fifty targetteers, eight hundred and seventy Balearic slingers, and one thousand two hundred horsemen, composed of various nations. He orders these forces partly to be used as a garrison for Carthage and partly to be distributed through Africa: at the same time having sent commissaries into the different states, he orders four thousand chosen youth whom they had levied to be conducted to Carthage, both as a garrison and as hostages.

Hannibal, after capturing Saguntum, had retreated to New Carthage for the winter. There, after hearing about what had been decided in Rome and Carthage—and realizing that he was not just the leader but also the reason for the war—he divided and sold off the remaining spoils. Believing there should be no more delays, he gathered his Spanish soldiers and addressed them: "I believe, tribes, that you can see for yourselves that, with all the tribes of Spain subdued, we must either end our campaigns and disband our armies or take the war into other lands. This way, these nations will thrive not just in peace but also in victory if we seek riches and glory from other countries. Therefore, since a campaign far from home is ahead of you and it’s uncertain when you'll return to your homes and what you hold dear, any of you who wants to visit friends can take leave. I expect you back at the start of spring so that, with the help of the gods, we can begin a war that will bring us great glory and loot." This offer to visit their homes was welcomed by almost everyone, as they were eager to see their friends and were anticipating a longer absence in the future. Resting throughout the winter, between the hardships they had faced and those to come, refreshed their bodies and minds to face new challenges. At the beginning of spring, they gathered as commanded. Hannibal reviewed the auxiliary troops from all nations and then went to Gades to fulfill his vows to Hercules; he made new vows, hoping his other plans would succeed. At the same time, he divided his focus between the offensive and defensive aspects of the war, worried that as he advanced towards Italy overland through Spain and Gaul, Africa might be left vulnerable to Roman attacks from Sicily. He decided it was essential to strengthen Africa with a significant force. To do this, he requested reinforcements from Africa, primarily light-armed spearmen, so that the Africans could fight in Spain and the Spaniards in Africa, both likely to be better soldiers when away from home, as if bound by mutual promises. He sent to Africa 13,850 targeteers, 870 Balearic slingers, and 1,200 horsemen from various nations. He ordered these troops to serve both as a garrison for Carthage and to be spread out across Africa. At the same time, he dispatched officers to the different territories, instructing them to send 4,000 selected youths they had recruited to Carthage, to serve as both a garrison and hostages.

22

Thinking also that Spain ought not to be neglected (and the less because he was aware that it had been traversed by the Roman ambassadors, to influence the minds of the chiefs,) he assigns that province to his brother Hasdrubal, a man of active spirit, and strengthens him chiefly with African troops: eleven thousand eight hundred and fifty African infantry, three hundred Ligurians, and five hundred Balearians. To these forces of infantry were added four hundred horsemen of the Libyphoenicians, a mixed race of Carthaginians and Africans; of the Numidians and Moors, who border on the ocean, to the number of one thousand eight hundred, and a small band of Ilergetes from Spain, amounting to two hundred horse: and, that no description of land force might be wanting, fourteen elephants. A fleet was given him besides to defend the sea-coast, (because it might be supposed that the Romans would then fight in the same mode of warfare by which they had formerly prevailed,) fifty quinqueremes, two quadriremes, five triremes: but only thirty-two quinqueremes and five triremes were properly fitted out and manned with rowers. From Gades he returned to the winter quarters of the army at Carthage; and thence setting out, he led his forces by the city Etovissa to the Iberus and the sea-coast. There, it is reported, a youth of divine aspect was seen by him in his sleep, who said, "that he was sent by Jupiter as the guide of Hannibal into Italy, and that he should, therefore, follow him, nor in any direction turn his eyes away from him." At first he followed in terror, looking no where, either around or behind: afterwards, through the curiosity of the human mind, when he revolved in his mind what that could be on which he was forbidden to look back, he could not restrain his eyes; then he beheld behind him a serpent of wonderful size moving along with an immense destruction of trees and bushes, and after it a cloud following with thunderings from the skies; and that then inquiring "what was that great commotion, and what the cause of the prodigy," he heard in reply: "That it was the devastation of Italy: that he should continue to advance forward, nor inquire further, but suffer the fates to remain in obscurity."

Thinking that Spain shouldn’t be overlooked (especially since he knew it had been visited by Roman ambassadors to sway the chiefs’ opinions), he assigned that region to his brother Hasdrubal, a proactive guy, and reinforced him mainly with African troops: eleven thousand eight hundred and fifty African infantry, three hundred Ligurians, and five hundred Balearians. In addition to these infantry forces, there were four hundred horsemen from the Libyphoenicians, a mixed race of Carthaginians and Africans; one thousand eight hundred Numidians and Moors who lived by the ocean; and a small group of two hundred Ilergetes from Spain who were cavalry. To ensure he had a full range of land forces, he also brought along fourteen elephants. He was additionally given a fleet to protect the coastline (since it was expected that the Romans would fight using the same tactics they had previously used to win), consisting of fifty quinqueremes, two quadriremes, and five triremes: however, only thirty-two quinqueremes and five triremes were properly outfitted and manned with rowers. He returned from Gades to the army's winter quarters in Carthage; then set out, leading his forces through the city of Etovissa to the Iberus and the coast. There, it’s said that he had a dream where he saw a youth of divine appearance who told him, “I was sent by Jupiter to guide Hannibal into Italy, so you should follow me without looking away.” Initially, he followed in fear, not daring to look around or behind him: but later, driven by human curiosity and wondering what it was that he wasn’t supposed to look back at, he couldn’t resist turning his gaze. He saw behind him a massive serpent causing incredible destruction of trees and bushes, followed by a cloud with thunder rumbling from the sky; when he asked what that great disturbance was and what the phenomenon meant, he was told, “That is the devastation of Italy. Keep moving forward and don’t question it further; just let fate remain mysterious.”

23

Cheered by this vision, he transported his forces in three divisions across the Iberus, having sent emissaries before him to conciliate by gifts the minds of the Gauls, in the quarter through which his army was to be led, and to examine the passes of the Alps. He led ninety thousand infantry and twelve thousand cavalry across the Iberus. He then subdued the Ilergetes, the Bargusii, the Ausetani, and that part of Lacetania which lies at the foot of the Pyrenaean mountains; and he placed Hanno in command over all this district, that the narrow gorges which connect Spain with Gaul might be under his power. Ten thousand infantry, and a thousand cavalry, were given to Hanno for the defence of the country he was to occupy. After the army began to march through the passes of the Pyrenees, and a more certain rumour of the Roman war spread through the barbarians, three thousand of the Carpetanian infantry turned back: it clearly appeared that they were not so much swayed by the prospect of the war as by the length of the journey and the insuperable passage of the Alps. Hannibal, because it was hazardous to recall or detain them by force, lest the fierce minds of the rest might also be irritated, sent home above seven thousand men, whom also he had observed to be annoyed with the service, pretending that the Carpetani had also been dismissed by him.

Cheered by this vision, he moved his forces in three divisions across the Iberus, having sent messengers ahead to win over the Gauls with gifts in the area where his army was to pass, and to scout the Alpine passes. He led ninety thousand infantry and twelve thousand cavalry across the Iberus. He then conquered the Ilergetes, the Bargusii, the Ausetani, and that part of Lacetania at the base of the Pyrenees; he appointed Hanno to oversee this region so that the narrow passes connecting Spain with Gaul would be under his control. Hanno was given ten thousand infantry and a thousand cavalry to defend the territory he was to occupy. Once the army started to move through the Pyrenean passes and rumors of the Roman war spread among the tribes, three thousand Carpetanian infantry turned back: it became clear that they were more deterred by the long journey and the daunting crossing of the Alps than by the war itself. Hannibal, knowing it was risky to force them to stay and possibly anger the rest of his troops, sent home over seven thousand men, whom he noticed were also unhappy with their service, claiming that the Carpetani had been dismissed by him as well.

24

Then, lest delay and ease might unsettle their minds, he crosses the Pyrenees with the rest of his forces, and pitches his camp at the town Illiberis. The Gauls, though they had heard that the war was directed against Italy, yet because there was a report that the Spaniards on the other side of the Pyrenees had been reduced by force, and that strong forces had been imposed on them, being roused to arms through the fear of slavery, assembled certain tribes at Ruscino. When this was announced to Hannibal, he, having more fear of the delay than of the war, sent envoys to say to their princes, "that he wished to confer with them; and that they should either come nearer to Illiberis, or that he would proceed to Ruscino, that their meeting might be facilitated by vicinity: for that he would either be happy to receive them into his camp, or would himself without hesitation come to them: since he had entered Gaul as a friend, and not as an enemy, and would not draw the sword, if the Gauls did not force him, before he came to Italy." These proposals, indeed, were made by his messengers. But when the princes of the Gauls, having immediately moved their camp to Illiberis, came without reluctance to the Carthaginian, being won by his presents, they suffered his army to pass through their territories, by the town of Ruscino, without any molestation.

Then, to avoid any delays or distractions that could upset their plans, he crossed the Pyrenees with the rest of his troops and set up camp in the town of Illiberis. Although the Gauls had heard that the war was aimed at Italy, they were alarmed by news that the Spaniards on the other side of the Pyrenees had been defeated and were facing strong oppression. This fear of enslavement drove them to gather several tribes at Ruscino. When Hannibal learned about this, he was more worried about the delay than the conflict, so he sent envoys to speak to their leaders, saying he wanted to meet with them. He suggested they either come closer to Illiberis or that he would go to Ruscino to make the meeting easier, stating he would be happy to welcome them into his camp or come to them himself. He emphasized that he had entered Gaul as a friend, not as an enemy, and that he wouldn’t draw his sword unless forced to before reaching Italy. These messages were indeed delivered by his messengers. However, when the Gallic leaders quickly moved their camp to Illiberis and met with the Carthaginian without hesitation, encouraged by his gifts, they allowed his army to pass through their lands by Ruscino without any interference.

25

In the mean time no further intelligence had been brought into Italy to Rome by the ambassadors of Marseilles than that Hannibal had passed the Iberus; when the Boii asked if he had already passed the Alps, revolted after instigating the Insubrians; not so much through their ancient resentment towards the Roman people, as on account of their having felt aggrieved that the colonies of Placentia and Cremona had been lately planted in the Gallic territory about the Po. Having therefore, suddenly taken up arms, and made an attack on that very territory, they created so much of terror and tumult, that not only the rustic population, but even the Roman triumvirs, Caius Lutatius, Caius Servilius, and Titus Annius, who had come to assign the lands, distrusting the walls of Placentia, fled to Mutina. About the name of Luttius there is no doubt: in place of Caius Servilius and Titus Annius, some annals have Quintus Acilius and Caius Herenrius; others, Publius Cornelius Asina and Caius Papirius Maso. This point is also uncertain, whether the ambassadors went to expostulate to the Boii suffered violence, or whether an attack was made on the triumvirs while measuring out the lands. While they were shut up in Mutina, and a people unskilled in the arts of besieging towns, and, at the same time, most sluggish at military operations, lay inactive before the walls, which they had not touched, pretended proposals for a peace were set on foot; and the ambassadors, being invited out to a conference by the chiefs of the Gauls, are seized, not only contrary to the law of nations, but in violation of the faith which was pledged on that very occasion; the Gauls denying that they would set them free unless their hostages were restored to them. When this intelligence respecting the ambassadors was announced, and that Mutina and its garrison were in danger, Lucius Manlius, the praetor, inflamed with rage, led his army in haste to Mutina. There were then woods on both sides of the road, most of the country being uncultivated. There, having advanced without previously exploring his route, he fell suddenly into an ambuscade; and after much slaughter of his men, with difficulty made his way into the open plains. Here a camp was fortified, and because confidence was wanting to the Gauls to attack it, the spirit of the soldiers revived, although it was sufficiently evident that their strength was much clipped. The journey was then commenced anew; nor while the army was led in march through open tracts did the enemy appear: but, when the woods were again entered, then attacking the rear, amid great confusion and alarm of all, they slew eight hundred soldiers, and took six standards. There was an end to the Gauls of creating, and to the Romans of experiencing terror, when they escaped from the pathless and entangled thicket; then easily defending their march through the open ground, the Romans directed their course to Tanetum, a village near the Po; where, by a temporary fortification, and the supplies conveyed by the river, and also by the aid of the Brixian Gauls, they defended themselves against the daily increasing multitude of their enemies.

In the meantime, the only news brought to Rome from the ambassadors of Marseilles was that Hannibal had crossed the Iberus River. The Boii asked if he had passed the Alps yet, and they revolted after inciting the Insubrians. This wasn't just because of their long-standing resentment towards the Romans, but also because they were upset about the recent establishment of the colonies of Placentia and Cremona in their territory around the Po. Suddenly, they took up arms and attacked that very area, causing so much fear and chaos that both the local population and the Roman officials, Caius Lutatius, Caius Servilius, and Titus Annius, who had come to distribute the land, fled to Mutina, doubting the safety of Placentia's walls. It's certain about Lutatius, but there are different names in some records for Caius Servilius and Titus Annius, such as Quintus Acilius and Caius Herenrius, or even Publius Cornelius Asina and Caius Papirius Maso. It's also unclear whether the ambassadors were sent to confront the Boii and were attacked, or if the triumvirs were assaulted while measuring out the lands. While they were trapped in Mutina, and the Gauls, who were inexperienced in besieging towns and not very proactive in military actions, sat idle outside the walls, pretending to propose peace, the ambassadors were invited for talks with the Gallic leaders. They were captured, which was not only against international law but also a violation of the trust established in that meeting; the Gauls refused to release them unless their hostages were returned. When news about the ambassadors and the danger surrounding Mutina reached him, Lucius Manlius, the praetor, filled with rage, quickly marched his army to Mutina. The area had woods on both sides of the road, mostly uncultivated land. Without scouting his path first, he unexpectedly walked into an ambush; after suffering heavy losses, he managed to reach the open plains but with great difficulty. Here, he set up a fortified camp, and since the Gauls lacked the confidence to attack it, the morale of his soldiers lifted, even though it was clear they were significantly weakened. The journey resumed, and while moving through open territory, the enemy did not appear; however, once they entered the woods again, they launched an attack from behind, causing great confusion and fear, killing eight hundred soldiers and capturing six standards. The fear ended for the Gauls, and the Romans were no longer terrified when they emerged from the tangled thicket. Once in the open ground, the Romans easily defended their march toward Tanetum, a village near the Po; there, with a temporary fortification and supplies brought by the river, as well as help from the Brixian Gauls, they defended themselves against the ever-growing number of enemies.

26

When the account of this sudden disturbance was brought to Rome, and the senators heard that the Punic had also been increased by a Gallic war, they order Caius Atilius, the praetor, to carry assistance to Manlius with one Roman legion and five thousand of the allies, enrolled in the late levy by the consul: who, without any contest, for the enemy had retired through fear, arrived at Tanetum. At the same time Publius Cornelius, a new legion having been levied in the room of that which was sent with the praetor, setting out from the city with sixty ships of war, by the coast of Etruria and Liguria, and then the mountains of the Salyes, arrived at Marseilles, and pitched his camp at the nearest mouth of the Rhone, (for the stream flows down to the sea divided into several channels,) scarcely as yet well believing that Hannibal had crossed the Pyrenaean mountains; whom when he ascertained to be also meditating the passage of the Rhone, uncertain in what place he might meet him, his soldiers not yet being sufficiently recovered from the tossing of the sea, he sends forward, in the mean time, three hundred chosen horses, with Massilian guides and Gallic auxiliaries, to explore all the country, and observe the enemy from a safe distance. Hannibal, the other states being pacified by fear or bribes, had now come into the territory of the Volcae, a powerful nation. They, indeed, dwell on both sides of the Rhone: but doubting that the Carthaginian could be driven from the hither bank, in order that they might have the river as a defence, having transported almost all their effects across the Rhone, occupied in arms the farther bank of the river. Hannibal, by means of presents, persuades the other inhabitants of the river-side, and some even of the Volcae themselves, whom their homes had detained, to collect from every quarter and build ships; and they at the same time themselves desired that the army should be transported, and their country relieved, as soon as possible, from the vast multitude of men that burthened it. A great number, therefore, of ships and boats rudely formed for the neighbouring passages, were collected together; and the Gauls, first beginning the plan, hollowed out some new ones from single trees; and then the soldiers themselves, at once induced by the plenty of materials and the easiness of the work, hastily formed shapeless hulks, in which they could transport themselves and their baggage, caring about nothing else, provided they could float and contain their burthen.

When the news of this sudden disturbance reached Rome and the senators learned that the Punic threat had also escalated due to a Gallic war, they ordered Caius Atilius, the praetor, to send aid to Manlius with one Roman legion and five thousand allied troops, recently recruited by the consul. Without any opposition, since the enemy had retreated in fear, he arrived at Tanetum. At the same time, Publius Cornelius, having raised a new legion to replace the one sent with the praetor, set out from the city with sixty warships, traveling along the coasts of Etruria and Liguria, then through the mountains of the Salyes, eventually reaching Marseilles. He set up camp at the nearest mouth of the Rhône River (which flows into the sea through several channels), still struggling to believe that Hannibal had crossed the Pyrenees. Once he confirmed that Hannibal was planning to cross the Rhône as well, uncertain of where he might encounter him and with his soldiers still recovering from their rough sea journey, he sent ahead three hundred selected cavalrymen, with guides from Massilia and Gallic reinforcements, to scout the area and observe the enemy from a safe distance. Hannibal, having pacified other states through fear or bribes, had now entered the territory of the Volcae, a powerful tribe. They lived on both sides of the Rhône but, fearing that the Carthaginian could be driven from the near bank, decided to move almost all their belongings across the river to use it as a defense, and they armed themselves on the far side. Hannibal, through gifts, convinced the local inhabitants along the river and even some of the Volcae, who were kept home by their ties, to gather materials and build ships. They also wanted the army to be transported quickly and relieve their land from the overwhelming number of troops. Consequently, a large number of ships and rudimentary boats were assembled for local transport, and the Gauls initially started by hollowing out new boats from single trees. Then the soldiers, encouraged by the abundance of materials and simplicity of the task, quickly constructed roughly made vessels just large enough to carry themselves and their gear, caring for nothing else as long as they could float and hold their load.

27

And now, when all things were sufficiently prepared for crossing, the enemy over against them occupying the whole bank, horse and foot, deterred them. In order to dislodge them, Hannibal orders Hanno, the son of Bomilcar, at the first watch of the night, to proceed with a part of the forces, principally Spanish, one day's journey up the river; and having crossed it where he might first be able, as secretly as possible, to lead round his forces, that when the occasion required he might attack the enemy in the rear. The Gauls, given him as guides for the purpose, inform him that about twenty-five miles from thence, the river spreading round a small island, broader where it was divided, and therefore with a shallower channel, presented a passage. At this place timber was quickly cut down and rafts formed, on which men, horses, and other burthens might be conveyed over. The Spaniards, without making any difficulty, having put their clothes in bags of leather, and themselves leaning on their bucklers placed beneath them, swam across the river. And the rest of the army, after passing on the rafts joined together, and pitching their camp near the river, being fatigued by the journey of the night and the labour of the work, are refreshed by the rest of one day, their leader being anxious to execute his design at a proper season. Setting out next day from this place, they signify by raising a smoke that they had crossed, and were not far distant; which when Hannibal understood, that he might not be wanting on the opportunity, he gives the signal for passing. The infantry already had the boats prepared and fitted; a line of ships higher up transporting the horsemen for the most part near their horses swimming beside them, in order to break the force of the current, rendered the water smooth to the boats crossing below. A great part of the horses were led across swimming, held by bridles from the stern, except those which they put on board saddled and bridled, in order that they might be ready to be used by the rider the moment he disembarked on the strand.

And now, when everything was ready for crossing, the enemy across the river occupying the entire bank, both cavalry and infantry, held them back. To drive them out, Hannibal ordered Hanno, the son of Bomilcar, to move a portion of his forces, mainly Spanish troops, one day’s journey up the river during the first watch of the night. He was to cross where it was easiest and as quietly as possible to lead his forces around, so when the time came, he could strike the enemy from behind. The Gauls assigned as guides told him that about twenty-five miles away, the river spread around a small island, wider where it split, and thereby had a shallower channel, which made for a crossing. At this spot, timber was quickly cut down, and rafts were made to transport men, horses, and other loads across. The Spaniards had no trouble; they put their clothes in leather bags and swam across the river leaning on their shields placed beneath them. The rest of the army crossed on the joined rafts and set up camp near the river. Tired from the night’s journey and the labor, they rested for a day while their leader was eager to execute his plan at the right time. The next day, after leaving that place, they signaled by raising a smoke that they had crossed and were nearby. When Hannibal learned this, wanting to seize the opportunity, he gave the signal to pass. The infantry had already prepared and equipped the boats; a line of ships further up was transporting mostly the cavalry, with the horses swimming alongside them to break the current, making the water calmer for the boats to cross below. Many of the horses were led across swimming, held by bridles from the back, except for those placed on board saddled and bridled, so they would be ready for the rider as soon as he landed on the shore.

28

The Gauls run down to the bank to meet them with various whoopings and songs, according to their custom, shaking their shields above their heads, and brandishing their weapons in their right hands, although such a multitude of ships in front of them alarmed them, together with the loud roaring of the river, and the mingled clamours of the sailors and soldiers, both those who were striving to break through the force of the current, and those who from the other bank were encouraging their comrades on their passage. While sufficiently dismayed by this tumult in front, more terrifying shouts from behind assailed them, their camp having been taken by Hanno; presently he himself came up, and a twofold terror encompassed them, both such a multitude of armed men landing from the ships, and this unexpected army pressing on their rear. When the Gauls, having made a prompt and bold effort to force the enemy, were themselves repulsed, they break through where a way seemed most open, and fly in consternation to their villages around. Hannibal, now despising these tumultuary onsets of the Gauls, having transported the rest of his forces at leisure, pitches his camp. I believe that there were various plans for transporting the elephants; at least there are various accounts of the way in which it was done. Some relate, that after the elephants were assembled together on the bank, the fiercest of them being provoked by his keeper, pursued him as he swam across the water, to which he had run for refuge, and drew after him the rest of the herd; the mere force of the stream hurrying them to the other bank, when the bottom had failed each, fearful of the depth. But there is more reason to believe that they were conveyed across on rafts; which plan, as it must have appeared the safer before execution, is after it the more entitled to credit. They extended from the bank into the river one raft two hundred feet long and fifty broad, which, fastened higher up by several strong cables to the bank, that it might not be carried down by the stream they covered, like a bridge, with earth thrown upon it, so that the beasts might tread upon it without fear, as over solid ground. Another raft equally broad and a hundred feet long, fit for crossing the river, was joined to this first; and when the elephants, driven along the stationary raft as along a road had passed, the females leading the way, on to the smaller raft which was joined to it, the lashings, by which it was slightly fastened, being immediately let go, it was drawn by some light boats to the opposite side. The first having been thus landed, the rest were then returned for and carried across. They gave no signs of alarm whatever while they were driven along as it were on a continuous bridge. The first fear was, when, the raft being loosed from the rest, they were hurried into the deep. Then pressing together, as those at the edges drew back from the water, they produced some disorder, till mere terror, when they saw water all around, produced quiet. Some, indeed, becoming infuriated, fell into the river; but, steadied by their own weight, having thrown off their riders, and seeking step by step the shallows, they escaped to the shore.

The Gauls rushed down to the bank to greet them with loud cheers and songs, according to their custom. They were shaking their shields over their heads and waving their weapons in their right hands, even though the sight of so many ships in front of them was intimidating, along with the loud roar of the river and the mixed shouts of the sailors and soldiers—those struggling against the current and those on the opposite bank encouraging their comrades to cross. While they were already shaken by this chaos in front, even scarier shouts from behind hit them, as Hanno had taken their camp; soon enough, he himself appeared, and they were surrounded by a double fear: the large number of armed men landing from the ships and this unexpected army pressing in from the rear. When the Gauls, after making a quick and brave attempt to push back the enemy, were repelled, they broke through where it looked clear and fled in panic to their nearby villages. Hannibal, now dismissing these chaotic charges from the Gauls, leisurely moved the rest of his forces and set up camp. I believe there were different plans for transporting the elephants; at least, there are various stories about how it was done. Some say that after the elephants were gathered at the bank, the fiercest of them, provoked by his keeper, chased him as he swam for safety across the water, drawing the rest of the herd along; the strength of the current pushing them to the other side, once they lost their footing and were scared of the depth. However, it's more likely that they were transported on rafts; this method, which seemed safer before it was carried out, is more credible after the fact. They built a raft that extended two hundred feet long and fifty feet wide from the bank into the river, secured higher up with several strong cables to keep it from being swept downstream. They covered it like a bridge with earth, so the animals could cross without fear, as if on solid ground. Another raft of the same width and a hundred feet long, suitable for crossing, was attached to the first one; and when the elephants, led by the females, walked across the stationary raft as if it were a road onto the smaller raft, the bindings that held it were released, and it was pulled by some light boats to the opposite side. Once the first group was landed, the rest were quickly brought back and taken across. They showed no signs of fear while being led along what felt like a continuous bridge. Their initial fear came when the raft was detached, and they were suddenly in deep water. Then, pressed together, as those at the edges pulled back from the water, they created a bit of chaos, until sheer terror, seeing water all around, made them calm down. Some, indeed, became frantic and fell into the river, but, balanced by their own weight, they threw off their riders and, taking steps towards the shallows, managed to reach the shore.

29

Whilst the elephants were conveyed over, Hannibal, in the mean time, had sent five hundred Numidian horsemen towards the camp of the Romans, to observe where and how numerous their forces were, and what they were designing. The three hundred Roman horsemen sent, as was before said, from the mouth of the Rhone, meet this band of cavalry; and a more furious engagement than could be expected from the number of the combatants takes place. For, besides many wounds, the loss on both sides was also nearly equal: and the flight and dismay of the Numidians gave victory to the Romans, now exceedingly fatigued. There fell of the conquerors one hundred and sixty, not all Romans, but partly Gauls: of the vanquished more than two hundred. This commencement, and at the same time omen of the war, as it portended to the Romans a prosperous issue of the whole, so did it also the success of a doubtful and by no means bloodless contest. When, after the action had thus occurred, his own men returned to each general, Scipio could adopt no fixed plan of proceeding, except that he should form his measures from the plans and undertakings of the enemy: and Hannibal, uncertain whether he should pursue the march he had commenced into Italy, or fight with the Roman army which had first presented itself, the arrival of ambassadors from the Boii, and of a petty prince called Magalus, diverted from an immediate engagement; who, declaring that they would be the guides of his journey and the companions of his dangers, gave it as their opinion, that Italy ought to be attacked with the entire force of the war, his strength having been no where previously impaired. The troops indeed feared the enemy, the remembrance of the former war not being yet obliterated; but much more did they dread the immense journey and the Alps, a thing formidable by report, particularly to the inexperienced.

While the elephants were being transported, Hannibal had sent five hundred Numidian horsemen towards the Roman camp to scout their numbers and plans. The three hundred Roman horsemen that had come from the mouth of the Rhone encountered this cavalry, resulting in a fiercer battle than expected considering the numbers involved. Both sides suffered many wounds, and the casualties were nearly equal; however, the retreat and fear of the Numidians gave victory to the already exhausted Romans. One hundred and sixty of the victors fell, not all of them Romans but also some Gauls; the defeated lost more than two hundred. This clash, marking the start of the war, suggested a favorable outcome for the Romans, yet it also foreshadowed a difficult and bloody struggle ahead. After the battle, each general's troops returned, and Scipio couldn’t come up with a solid strategy, deciding instead to adapt his plans based on the enemy's actions. Hannibal, uncertain whether to continue his march into Italy or confront the Roman army that had just appeared, was diverted from immediate combat by the arrival of ambassadors from the Boii and a minor prince named Magalus. They offered to guide him on his journey and share in his dangers, suggesting that he should launch a full-scale attack on Italy, as his strength had not been diminished. The troops indeed feared the enemy; the memories of the previous war were still fresh, but they were even more intimidated by the long journey and the Alps, which were daunting mainly to those who lacked experience.

30

Hannibal, therefore, when his own resolution was fixed to proceed in his course and advance on Italy, having summoned an assembly, works upon the minds of the soldiers in various ways, by reproof and exhortation. He said, that "he wondered what sudden fear had seized breasts ever before undismayed: that through so many years they had made their campaigns with conquest; nor had departed from Spain before all the nations and countries which two opposite seas embrace, were subjected to the Carthaginians. That then, indignant that the Romans demanded those, whosoever had besieged Saguntum, to be delivered up to them, as on account of a crime, they had passed the Iberus to blot out the name of the Romans, and to emancipate the world. That then the way seemed long to no one, though they were pursuing it from the setting to the rising of the sun. That now, when they saw by far the greater part of their journey accomplished, the passes of the Pyrenees surmounted, amid the most ferocious nations, the Rhone, that mighty river, crossed, in spite of the opposition of so many thousand Gauls, the fury of the river itself having been overcome, when they had the Alps in sight, the other side of which was Italy, should they halt through weariness at the very gates of the enemy, imagining the Alps to be--what else than lofty mountains? That supposing them to be higher than the summits of the Pyrenees, assuredly no part of the earth reached the sky, nor was insurmountable by mankind. The Alps in fact were inhabited and cultivated;--produced and supported living beings. Were they passable by a few men and impassable to armies? That those very ambassadors whom they saw before them had not crossed the Alps borne aloft through the air on wings; neither were their ancestors indeed natives of the soil, but settling in Italy from foreign countries, had often as emigrants safely crossed these very Alps in immense bodies, with their wives and children. To the armed soldier, carrying nothing with him but the instruments of war, what in reality was impervious or insurmountable? That Saguntum might be taken, what dangers, what toils were for eight months undergone! Now, when their aim was Rome, the capital of the world, could any thing appear so dangerous or difficult as to delay their undertaking? That the Gauls had formerly gained possession of that very country which the Carthaginian despairs of being able to approach. That they must, therefore, either yield in spirit and valour to that nation which they had so often during those times overcome; or look forward, as the end of their journey, to the plain which spreads between the Tiber and the walls of Rome."

Hannibal, having firmly decided to continue his march into Italy, called a meeting and motivated his soldiers in various ways, using both criticism and encouragement. He expressed disbelief at the sudden fear that seemed to have taken hold of hearts that had previously shown no fear. He reminded them that for many years they had fought and won battles, and they had not left Spain until all the nations between the two seas were under Carthaginian control. He pointed out that they had crossed the Iberus River to erase the Romans’ name from history and to liberate the world. At that time, no one had thought the journey was too long, even though they were traveling from the setting sun to the rising sun. Now, with most of their journey behind them—having conquered the Pyrenees, crossed the mighty Rhone River despite thousands of Gauls opposing them, and with the Alps in view, beyond which lay Italy—should they really stop out of exhaustion right at the gates of the enemy, thinking of the Alps as just tall mountains? Even if the Alps seemed higher than the Pyrenees, nothing on earth was unreachable or insurmountable for humanity. The Alps were populated and cultivated; they produced and sustained life. Were they passable for a few individuals but impossible for entire armies? He reminded them that the ambassadors they faced had not flown over the Alps on wings, nor were their ancestors native to the land; they had moved to Italy from foreign lands and had often crossed those same Alps in large numbers, along with their families. What was actually impassable for a soldier equipped only for war? He recalled how they had endured dangers and hardships for eight months to take Saguntum. Now, with their goal being Rome, the capital of the world, could anything be more dangerous or difficult than to delay their mission? He noted that the Gauls had once captured the very land that the Carthaginian now feared to approach. Therefore, they had to either surrender to the spirit and bravery of a nation they had frequently overcome or look ahead to the plain that lay between the Tiber River and the walls of Rome.

31

He orders them, roused by these exhortations, to refresh themselves and prepare for the journey. Next day, proceeding upward along the bank of the Rhone, he makes for the inland part of Gaul: not because it was the more direct route to the Alps, but believing that the farther he retired from the sea, the Romans would be less in his way; with whom, before he arrived in Italy, he had no intention of engaging. After four days' march he came to the Island: there the streams of the Arar and the Rhone, flowing down from different branches of the Alps, after embracing a pretty large tract of country, flow into one. The name of the Island is given to the plains that lie between them. The Allobroges dwell near, a nation even in those days inferior to none in Gaul in power and fame. They were at that time at variance. Two brothers were contending for the sovereignty. The elder, named Brancus, who had before been king, was driven out by his younger brother and a party of the younger men, who, inferior in right, had more of power. When the decision of this quarrel was most opportunely referred to Hannibal, being appointed arbitrator of the kingdom, he restored the sovereignty to the elder, because such had been the opinion of the senate and the chief men. In return for this service, he was assisted with a supply of provisions, and plenty of all necessaries, particularly clothing, which the Alps, notorious for extreme cold, rendered necessary to be prepared. After composing the dissensions of the Allobroges, when he now was proceeding to the Alps, he directed his course thither, not by the straight road, but turned to the left into the country of the Tricastini, thence by the extreme boundary of the territory of the Vocontii he proceeded to the Tricorii; his way not being any where obstructed till he came to the river Druentia. This stream, also arising amid the Alps, is by far the most difficult to pass of all the rivers in Gaul; for though it rolls down an immense body of water, yet it does not admit of ships; because, being restrained by no banks, and flowing in several and not always the same channels, and continually forming new shallows and new whirlpools, (on which account the passage is also uncertain to a person on foot,) and rolling down besides gravelly stones, it affords no firm or safe passage to those who enter it; and having been at that time swollen by showers, it created great disorder among the soldiers as they crossed, when, in addition to other difficulties, they were of themselves confused by their own hurry and uncertain shouts.

He tells them, inspired by these calls to action, to rest and get ready for the journey. The next day, moving up the bank of the Rhone, he heads towards the interior of Gaul: not because it was the most direct path to the Alps, but because he believed that the further he went from the sea, the less the Romans would interfere; he had no intention of confronting them before reaching Italy. After four days of marching, he arrived at the Island: there, the Arar and the Rhone rivers, coming down from different branches of the Alps, blend together after covering a large area. The name of the Island refers to the plains situated between them. The Allobroges lived nearby, a nation that was, even back then, among the most powerful and renowned in Gaul. At that time, they were in conflict. Two brothers were fighting for control. The elder, named Brancus, who had previously been king, was ousted by his younger brother and a group of younger men, who, despite having less claim, had more power. When the resolution of this dispute was conveniently brought to Hannibal, who was chosen to mediate, he restored the kingship to the elder brother, as this was the opinion of the senate and the leading figures. In appreciation for this help, he received a supply of provisions and all necessary items, especially clothing, which was essential due to the extreme cold of the Alps. After settling the disputes among the Allobroges, as he continued toward the Alps, he did not take the direct route but turned left into the territory of the Tricastini, then along the far edge of the Vocontii's land he made his way to the Tricorii; there were no obstacles until he reached the river Druentia. This river, also originating in the Alps, is by far the hardest to cross of all the rivers in Gaul; for although it carries a huge volume of water, it cannot accommodate ships because it has no banks, flows through various and often changing channels, and continually forms new shallows and whirlpools, making crossing uncertain even for a person on foot. As it rolled with gravelly stones, it offered no firm or safe passage to those entering it; and having been swollen by recent rain, it caused great chaos among the soldiers during the crossing, especially since their own rush and uncertain shouts only added to the confusion.

32

Publius Cornelius the consul, about three days after Hannibal moved from the bank of the Rhone, had come to the camp of the enemy, with his army drawn up in square, intending to make no delay in fighting: but when he saw the fortifications deserted, and that he could not easily come up with them so far in advance before him, he returned to the sea and his fleet, in order more easily and safely to encounter Hannibal when descending from the Alps. But that Spain, the province which he had obtained by lot, might not be destitute of Roman auxiliaries, he sent his brother Cneius Scipio with the principal part of his forces against Hasdrubal, not only to defend the old allies and conciliate new, but also to drive Hasdrubal out of Spain. He himself, with a very small force, returned to Genoa, intending to defend Italy with the army which was around the Po. From the Druentia, by a road that lay principally through plains, Hannibal arrived at the Alps without molestation from the Gauls that inhabit those regions. Then, though the scene had been previously anticipated from report, (by which uncertainties are wont to be exaggerated,) yet the height of the mountains when viewed so near, and the snows almost mingling with the sky, the shapeless huts situated on the cliffs, the cattle and beasts of burden withered by the cold, the men unshorn and wildly dressed, all things, animate and inanimate, stiffened with frost, and other objects more terrible to be seen than described, renewed their alarm. To them, marching up the first acclivities, the mountaineers appeared occupying the heights over head; who, if they had occupied the more concealed valleys, might, by rushing out suddenly to the attack, have occasioned great flight and havoc. Hannibal orders them to halt, and having sent forward Gauls to view the ground, when he found there was no passage that way, he pitches his camp in the widest valley he could find, among places all rugged and precipitous. Then, having learned from the same Gauls, when they had mixed in conversation with the mountaineers, from whom they differed little in language and manners, that the pass was only beset during the day, and that at night each withdrew to his own dwelling, he advanced at the dawn to the heights, as if designing openly and by day to force his way through the defile. The day then being passed in feigning a different attempt from that which was in preparation, when they had fortified the camp in the same place where they had halted, as soon as he perceived that the mountaineers had descended from the heights, and that the guards were withdrawn, having lighted for show a greater number of fires than was proportioned to the number that remained, and having left the baggage in the camp, with the cavalry and the principal part of the infantry, he himself with a party of light-armed, consisting of all the most courageous of his troops, rapidly cleared the defile, and took post on those very heights which the enemy had occupied.

Publius Cornelius, the consul, arrived at the enemy’s camp about three days after Hannibal left the bank of the Rhone, with his army lined up in formation, ready to fight without delay. However, when he found the fortifications deserted and realized he couldn’t catch up to them so far ahead, he returned to the sea and his fleet to prepare for a safer confrontation with Hannibal when he came down from the Alps. To ensure that Spain, the province he had been assigned, wouldn’t lack Roman support, he sent his brother Cneius Scipio with most of his forces against Hasdrubal, not only to protect old allies and win new ones but also to drive Hasdrubal out of Spain. He himself returned to Genoa with a very small force, planning to defend Italy with the army positioned around the Po. Meanwhile, Hannibal reached the Alps from the Druentia via a mostly flat road without any trouble from the local Gauls. Even though the challenges ahead had been somewhat anticipated from reports, which often exaggerate uncertainties, the sight of the towering mountains up close, the snow nearly blending with the sky, the shabby huts perched on the cliffs, the animals and pack beasts struggling against the cold, and the unruly, unkempt men, all frozen in the harsh climate—everything, both living and not, added to the terrifying atmosphere. As they climbed the initial slopes, the mountaineers appeared to be occupying the heights above them; if they had been hiding in the more concealed valleys, a sudden attack could have caused significant chaos and panic. Hannibal ordered his men to stop and sent some Gauls ahead to scout the terrain. Finding no passage that way, he set up camp in the broadest valley he could locate, surrounded by rugged and steep places. After gathering information from the Gauls, who spoke a similar language and shared customs with the mountaineers, he learned that the pass was only guarded during the day and that at night the locals returned to their homes. So, at dawn, he moved towards the heights as if he intended to openly break through the pass during the day. As the day progressed with a feigned attempt to distract from his real plans, he fortified the camp where they had halted. Once he noticed that the mountaineers had descended from their heights and their guards had left, he lit more fires than necessary to give the impression of a larger camp, while leaving behind the baggage, cavalry, and most of the infantry. He then took a small group of the bravest light-armed troops and swiftly moved through the pass, occupying the very heights that the enemy had held.

33

At dawn of light the next day the camp broke up, and the rest of the army began to move forward. The mountaineers, on a signal being given, were now assembling from their forts to their usual station, when they suddenly behold part of the enemy overhanging them from above, in possession of their former position, and the others passing along the road. Both these objects, presented at the same time to the eye and the mind, made them stand motionless for a little while; but when they afterwards saw the confusion in the pass, and that the marching body was thrown into disorder by the tumult which itself created, principally from the horses being terrified, thinking that whatever terror they added would suffice for the destruction of the enemy, they scramble along the dangerous rocks, as being accustomed alike to pathless and circuitous ways. Then indeed the Carthaginians were opposed at once by the enemy and by the difficulties of the ground; and each striving to escape first from the danger, there was more fighting among themselves than with their opponents. The horses in particular created danger in the lines, which, being terrified by the discordant clamours which the groves and re-echoing valleys augmented, fell into confusion; and if by chance struck or wounded, they were so dismayed that they occasioned a great loss both of men and baggage of every description: and as the pass on both sides was broken and precipitous, this tumult threw many down to an immense depth, some even of the armed men; but the beasts of burden, with their loads, were rolled down like the fall of some vast fabric. Though these disasters were shocking to view, Hannibal however kept his place for a little, and kept his men together, lest he might augment the tumult and disorder; but afterwards, when he saw the line broken, and that there was danger that he should bring over his army, preserved to no purpose if deprived of their baggage, he hastened down from the higher ground; and though he had routed the enemy by the first onset alone, he at the same time increased the disorder in his own army: but that tumult was composed in a moment, after the roads were cleared by the flight of the mountaineers; and presently the whole army was conducted through, not only without being disturbed, but almost in silence. He then took a fortified place, which was the capital of that district, and the little villages that lay around it, and fed his army for three days with the corn and cattle he had taken; and during these three days, as the soldiers were neither obstructed by the mountaineers, who had been daunted by the first engagement, nor yet much by the ground, he made considerable way.

At dawn the next day, the camp packed up, and the rest of the army started moving forward. The mountaineers, upon receiving a signal, were gathering from their fortifications to their usual spot when they suddenly saw part of the enemy above them, back in their former position, while others were passing along the road. These two sights hit them at the same time, leaving them frozen for a moment; but when they later noticed the chaos in the pass and that the marching group was thrown into disarray by the uproar it created, particularly because the horses were spooked and thinking that whatever fear they added would ensure the enemy's destruction, they scrambled along the treacherous rocks, being used to navigating both rough and winding paths. In that moment, the Carthaginians faced both the enemy and the challenges of the terrain, and in their attempt to escape the danger, they ended up fighting each other more than their foes. The horses, in particular, added to the danger in the ranks, terrified by the clashing sounds that echoed through the groves and valleys, which caused confusion; if they happened to be struck or injured, they panicked, resulting in significant losses of both men and various supplies. Since the pass was chaotic and steep on both sides, this uproar sent many tumbling down into a great depth, including some of the armed men; the pack animals, with their loads, fell like the collapse of a massive structure. Although these disasters were horrifying to witness, Hannibal held his position for a while to keep his men together, aiming to avoid adding to the chaos and disorder. But later, when he saw the line breaking and realized that bringing his army over would be pointless if they were stripped of their supplies, he quickly descended from the higher ground; and even though he had defeated the enemy with just the initial assault, he simultaneously increased the disorder within his own ranks. However, that chaos settled quickly once the mountaineers fled and the roads were cleared; soon the whole army passed through not only without disturbance but almost in silence. He then captured a fortified location that was the capital of that area, along with the nearby villages, and supplied his army for three days with the grain and livestock he had seized; during these three days, since the soldiers were neither hindered by the mountaineers, who had been intimidated by the first battle, nor significantly by the terrain, they made substantial progress.

34

He then came to another state, abounding, for a mountainous country, with inhabitants; where he was nearly overcome, not by open war, but by his own arts of treachery and ambuscade. Some old men, governors of forts, came as deputies to the Carthaginian, professing, "that having been warned by the useful example of the calamities of others, they wished rather to experience the friendship than the hostilities of the Carthaginians: they would, therefore, obediently execute his commands, and begged that he would accept of a supply of provisions, guides of his march, and hostages for the sincerity of their promises." Hannibal, when he had answered them in a friendly manner, thinking that they should neither be rashly trusted nor yet rejected, lest if repulsed they might openly become enemies, having received the hostages whom they proffered, and made use of the provisions which they of their own accord brought down to the road, follows their guides, by no means as among a people with whom he was at peace, but with his line of march in close order. The elephants and cavalry formed the van of the marching body; he himself, examining every thing around, and intent on every circumstance, followed with the choicest of the infantry. When they came into a narrower pass, lying on one side beneath an overhanging eminence, the barbarians, rising at once on all sides from their ambush, assail them in front and rear, both at close quarters and from a distance, and roll down huge stones on the army. The most numerous body of men pressed on the rear; against whom the infantry, facing about and directing their attack, made it very obvious, that had not the rear of the army been well supported, a great loss must have been sustained in that pass. Even as it was they came to the extremity of danger, and almost to destruction: for while Hannibal hesitates to lead down his division into the defile, because, though he himself was a protection to the cavalry, lie had not in the same way left any aid to the infantry in the rear; the mountaineers, charging obliquely, and on having broken through the middle of the army, took possession of the road; and one night was spent by Hannibal without his cavalry and baggage.

He then arrived in another state, which was rich in mountainous terrain and inhabited by people; where he was almost defeated, not by open warfare, but by his own methods of deception and ambush. Some elderly men, leaders of forts, approached the Carthaginian as messengers, claiming, "Having learned from the unfortunate experiences of others, we would prefer to know your friendship rather than face your enmity: we will therefore do as you command, and we ask that you accept our offer of supplies, guides for your journey, and hostages to assure the honesty of our promises." Hannibal, responding to them kindly, believed that they should neither be trusted too easily nor entirely dismissed, lest they turn against him if rejected. After accepting the hostages they offered and utilizing the supplies they voluntarily brought to the road, he followed their guides, not as if among a peaceful people, but with his troops in close formation. The elephants and cavalry led the march; he himself, assessing everything around and focused on every detail, followed with the best of the infantry. When they reached a narrower pass, nestled beneath an overhanging hill, the locals suddenly emerged from their hiding spots and attacked them from both the front and back, in close range and from a distance, rolling down large stones upon the army. The largest group of attackers pressed against the rear; against them, the infantry turned and fought back, clearly demonstrating that if the rear of the army hadn't been well supported, they would have suffered significant losses in that pass. Even then, they reached the brink of danger and nearly faced destruction: because while Hannibal hesitated to send his division into the narrow path, knowing that although he himself could protect the cavalry, he had not provided similar support for the infantry in the back; the mountaineers charged from the side, breaking through the middle of the army and seized control of the road; and Hannibal spent one night without his cavalry and supplies.

35

Next day, the barbarians running in to the attack between (the two divisions) less vigorously, the forces were re-united, and the defile passed, not without loss, but yet with a greater destruction of beasts of burden than of men. From that time the mountaineers fell upon them in smaller parties, more like an attack of robbers than war, sometimes on the van, sometimes on the rear, according as the ground afforded them advantage, or stragglers advancing or loitering gave them an opportunity. Though the elephants were driven through steep and narrow roads with great loss of time, yet wherever they went they rendered the army safe from the enemy, because men unacquainted with such animals were afraid of approaching too nearly. On the ninth day they came to a summit of the Alps, chiefly through places trackless; and after many mistakes of their way, which were caused either by the treachery of the guides, or, when they were not trusted, by entering valleys at random, on their own conjectures of the route. For two days they remained encamped on the summit; and rest was given to the soldiers, exhausted with toil and fighting: and several beasts of burden, which had fallen down among the rocks, by following the track of the army arrived at the camp. A fall of snow, it being now the season of the setting of the constellation of the Pleiades, caused great fear to the soldiers, already worn out with weariness of so many hardships. On the standards being moved forward at daybreak, when the army proceeded slowly over all places entirely blocked up with snow, and languor and despair strongly appeared in the countenances of all, Hannibal, having advanced before the standards, and ordered the soldiers to halt on a certain eminence, whence there was a prospect far and wide, points out to them Italy and the plains of the Po, extending themselves beneath the Alpine mountains; and said "that they were now surmounting not only the ramparts of Italy, but also of the city of Rome; that the rest of the journey would be smooth and down-hill; that after one, or, at most, a second battle, they would have the citadel and capital of Italy in their power and possession." The army then began to advance, the enemy now making no attempts beyond petty thefts, as opportunity offered. But the journey proved much more difficult than it had been in the ascent, as the declivity of the Alps being generally shorter on the side of Italy is consequently steeper; for nearly all the road was precipitous, narrow, and slippery, so that neither those who made the least stumble could prevent themselves from falling, nor, when fallen, remain in the same place, but rolled, both men and beasts of burden, one upon another.

The next day, the attackers came rushing in between the two divisions. Though slightly less intense, the forces came together again, and they managed to pass through the narrow pass, though not without some losses, but with a larger loss of pack animals than of men. From that point on, the mountain folk attacked in smaller groups, more like robbers than soldiers, sometimes hitting the front lines, other times the rear, depending on where the terrain gave them an advantage or where stragglers had wandered or dawdled. Even though the elephants were led through steep and narrow paths, causing delays, wherever they went, they kept the army safe from the enemy because people unfamiliar with these animals were afraid to get too close. On the ninth day, they reached the top of the Alps, mainly through unmarked paths; after many wrong turns caused either by the dishonesty of the guides or, when not trusted, randomly entering valleys based on their guesses of the route. They stayed camped at the summit for two days, allowing the soldiers, worn out from the hard work and fighting, to rest. Several pack animals that had fallen among the rocks managed to follow the trail of the army and reached the camp. As the Pleiades constellation was setting, a snowfall struck, adding to the soldiers' fears, already worn down by so many hardships. When the standards were raised at dawn and the army began to slowly move through places completely covered in snow, fatigue and despair were visible on everyone's faces. Hannibal, moving ahead of the standards, ordered the soldiers to stop on a high point where they could see far and wide, pointing out Italy and the plains of the Po stretching below the Alpine mountains. He told them that they were now overcoming not just the barriers of Italy, but also those of Rome itself; that the remainder of the journey would be easy and downhill; and that after one, or at most two battles, they would control and possess the capital and stronghold of Italy. The army began to move forward, as the enemy made no attempts beyond petty thefts as opportunities arose. However, the journey turned out to be much more challenging than the ascent, as the slope of the Alps on the Italian side was generally shorter and therefore steeper; almost the entire path was steep, narrow, and slippery, so that even those who stumbled slightly couldn’t stop themselves from falling, and once fallen, couldn’t stay put but ended up rolling down, both men and pack animals, on top of one another.

36

They then came to a rock much more narrow, and formed of such perpendicular ledges, that a light-armed soldier, carefully making the attempt, and clinging with his hands to the bushes and roots around, could with difficulty lower himself down. The ground, even before very steep by nature, had been broken by a recent falling away of the earth into a precipice of nearly a thousand feet in depth. Here when the cavalry had halted, as if at the end of their journey, it is announced to Hannibal, wondering what obstructed the march that the rock was impassable. Having then gone himself to view the place, it seemed clear to him that he must lead his army round it, by however great a circuit, through the pathless and untrodden regions around. But this route also proved impracticable; for while the new snow of a moderate depth remained on the old, which had not been removed, their footsteps were planted with ease as they walked upon the new snow, which was soft and not too deep; but when it was dissolved by the trampling of so many men and beasts of burden, they then walked on the bare ice below, and through the dirty fluid formed by the melting snow. Here there was a wretched struggle, both on account of the slippery ice not affording any hold to the step, and giving way beneath the foot more readily by reason of the slope; and whether they assisted themselves in rising by their hands or their knees, their supports themselves giving way, they would stumble again; nor were there any stumps or roots near; by pressing against which, one might with hand or foot support himself; so that they only floundered on the smooth ice and amid the melted snow. The beasts of burden sometimes also went into this lower ice by merely treading upon it, at others they broke it completely through, by the violence with which they struck in their hoofs in their struggling, so that most of them, as if taken in a trap, stuck in the hardened and deeply frozen ice.

They then reached a much narrower rock, made of steep ledges, that a lightly equipped soldier could only lower himself down with great difficulty, carefully holding onto bushes and roots. The ground, already steep by nature, had been recently eroded, creating a cliff nearly a thousand feet deep. When the cavalry stopped here, as if they had reached the end of their journey, Hannibal was informed that the rock was impassable, leaving him puzzled about what was blocking their march. After he personally inspected the area, he realized he would have to lead his army around it, no matter how far they had to go, through uncharted and rugged terrain. However, this route also turned out to be unmanageable; while new snow of moderate depth lay on the old, untouched snow, their footsteps easily sank into the soft, shallow fresh snow. But when it was crushed by the weight of so many men and pack animals, they found themselves walking on bare ice and in the muddy water created by melting snow. This was a miserable struggle, with the slippery ice offering no grip and giving way beneath their feet due to the slope. Whether they tried to rise on their hands or knees, their supports would collapse, causing them to stumble again. There were no stumps or roots nearby to help them balance. They just floundered on the smooth ice and in the melted snow. The pack animals also occasionally slipped onto the lower ice by simply stepping on it, and other times they broke through completely from their forceful movements, causing many to become stuck in the hardened, deeply frozen ice as if they were trapped.

37

At length, after the men and beasts of burden had been fatigued to no purpose, the camp was pitched on the summit, the ground being cleared for that purpose with great difficulty, so much snow was there to be dug out and carried away. The soldiers being then set to make a way down the cliff by which alone a passage could be effected, and it being necessary that they should cut through the rocks, having felled and lopped a number of large trees which grew around, they make a huge pile of timber; and as soon as a strong wind fit for exciting the flames arose, they set fire to it, and, pouring vinegar on the heated stones, they render them soft and crumbling. They then open a way with iron instruments through the rock thus heated by the fire, and soften its declivities by gentle windings, so that not only the beasts of burden, but also the elephants could be led down it. Four days were spent about this rock, the beasts nearly perishing through hunger: for the summits of the mountains are for the most part bare, and if there is any pasture the snows bury it. The lower parts contain valleys, and some sunny hills, and rivulets flowing beside woods, and scenes more worthy of the abode of man. There the beasts of burden were sent out to pasture, and rest given for three days to the men, fatigued with forming the passage: they then descended into the plains, the country and the dispositions of the inhabitants being now less rugged.

At last, after the men and animals had been exhausted for no reason, the camp was set up on the summit, with the ground cleared for that purpose with great effort due to the heavy snow that had to be dug out and removed. The soldiers were then assigned to create a path down the cliff, which was the only way to do it, and since they needed to cut through the rocks, they chopped down several large trees in the area to make a huge pile of timber. Once a strong wind picked up, suitable for starting a fire, they set the pile ablaze and poured vinegar on the heated stones to make them soft and crumbly. They then used iron tools to carve a pathway through the rock, heated by the fire, and shaped its slopes with gentle curves so that not only the pack animals but also the elephants could pass through. Four days were spent working on this rock, and the animals nearly starved due to lack of food; the mountaintops are mostly barren, and any available pasture is covered by snow. The lower areas have valleys, some sunny hills, and streams flowing beside the woods—scenes more befitting human habitation. There, the pack animals were allowed to graze, and the men, worn out from creating the path, were given three days of rest before they descended into the plains, where the land and the habits of the people were much less harsh.

38

In this manner chiefly they came to Italy in the fifth month (as some authors relate) after leaving New Carthage, having crossed the Alps in fifteen days. What number of forces Hannibal had when he had passed into Italy is by no means agreed upon by authors. Those who state them at the highest, make mention of a hundred thousand foot and twenty thousand horse; those who state them at the lowest, of twenty thousand foot and six thousand horse. Lucius Cincius Alimentus, who relates that he was made prisoner by Hannibal, would influence me most as an authority, did he not confound the number by adding the Gauls and Ligurians. Including these, (who, it is more probable, flocked to him afterwards, and so some authors assert,) he says, that eighty thousand foot and ten thousand horse were brought into Italy; and that he had heard from Hannibal himself, that after crossing the Rhone he had lost thirty-six thousand men, and an immense number of horses, and other beasts of burden, among the Taurini, the next nation to the Gauls, as he descended into Italy. As this circumstance is agreed on by all, I am the more surprised that it should be doubtful by what road he crossed the Alps; and that it should commonly be believed that he passed over the Pennine mountain, and that thence [17] the name was given to that ridge of the Alps. Coelius says, that he passed over the top of Mount Cremo; both which passes would have brought him, not to the Taurini, but through the Salasian mountaineers to the Libuan Gauls. Neither is it probable that these roads into Gaul were then open, especially once those which, lead to the Pennine mountain would have been unlocked up by nations half German; nor by Hercules (if this argument has weight with any one) do the Veragri, the inhabitants of this ridge, know of the name being given to these mountains from the passage of the Carthaginians, but from the divinity, whom the mountaineers style Penninus, worshipped on the highest summit.

In this way, they arrived in Italy in the fifth month (as some authors say) after leaving New Carthage, having crossed the Alps in fifteen days. There’s no consensus among authors about the number of forces Hannibal had when he entered Italy. Those who estimate the highest mention a hundred thousand infantry and twenty thousand cavalry; those who estimate the lowest mention twenty thousand infantry and six thousand cavalry. Lucius Cincius Alimentus, who claims he was captured by Hannibal, would be the most credible source for me, if he didn’t mix up the numbers by including the Gauls and Ligurians. Including those (who, as is more likely, joined him later, as some authors assert), he says that eighty thousand infantry and ten thousand cavalry entered Italy; and that he heard from Hannibal himself that after crossing the Rhone, he lost thirty-six thousand men, along with a huge number of horses and other pack animals, among the Taurini, the next tribe after the Gauls, as he descended into Italy. Since this detail is agreed upon by everyone, I find it surprising that there is uncertainty about the route he took across the Alps; and that it is commonly believed that he crossed the Pennine mountain, which is where the name for that part of the Alps supposedly comes from. Coelius states that he crossed over the top of Mount Cremo; either of these routes would have brought him not to the Taurini, but through the Salasian mountain dwellers to the Libuan Gauls. It also seems unlikely that these paths into Gaul were open at that time, especially as those leading to the Pennine mountain would have been blocked by half-Germanic tribes; nor do the Veragri, who live in this region, claim that the name of these mountains comes from the Carthaginians’ passage, but rather from the deity they call Penninus, who is worshipped at the highest peak.

39

Very opportunely for the commencement of his operations, a war had broken out with the Taurini, the nearest nation, against the Insubrians; but Hannibal could not put his troops under arms to assist either party, as they very chiefly felt the disorders they had before contracted, in remedying them; for ease after toil, plenty after want, and attention to their persons after dirt and filth, had variously affected their squalid and almost savage-looking bodies. This was the reason that Publius Cornelius, the consul, when he had arrived at Pisa with his fleet, hastened to the Po, though the troops he received from Manlius and Atilius were raw and disheartened by their late disgraces, in order that he might engage the enemy when not yet recruited. But when the consul came to Placentia, Hannibal had already moved from his quarters, and had taken by storm one city of the Taurini, the capital of the nation, because they did not come willingly into his alliance; and he would have gained over to him, not only from fear, but also from inclination, the Gauls who dwell beside the Po, had not the arrival of the consul suddenly checked them while watching for an opportunity of revolt. Hannibal at the same time moved from the Taurini, thinking that the Gauls, uncertain which side to choose, would follow him if present among them. The armies were now almost in sight of each other, and their leaders, though not at present sufficiently acquainted, yet met each other with a certain feeling of mutual admiration. For the name of Hannibal, even before the destruction of Saguntum, was very celebrated among the Romans; and Hannibal believed Scipio to be a superior man, from the very circumstance of his having been specially chosen to act as commander against himself. They had increased too their estimation of each other; Scipio, because, being left behind in Gaul, he had met Hannibal when he had crossed into Italy; Hannibal, by his daring attempt of crossing the Alps and by its accomplishment. Scipio, however, was the first to cross the Po, and having pitched his camp at the river Ticinus, he delivered the following oration for the sake of encouraging his soldiers before he led them out to form for battle:

Very conveniently for the start of his plans, a war had erupted with the Taurini, the closest nation, against the Insubrians; but Hannibal couldn’t mobilize his troops to help either side, as they were mainly dealing with the problems they had previously faced. After their hard work, they were enjoying comfort, after facing hardship, they were experiencing abundance, and after being unkempt, they were tending to their hygiene, which had all affected their ragged and almost savage-looking bodies in various ways. This was why Publius Cornelius, the consul, when he arrived in Pisa with his fleet, rushed to the Po, even though the troops he received from Manlius and Atilius were inexperienced and disheartened by their recent defeats, so he could confront the enemy before they had fully recovered. However, when the consul reached Placentia, Hannibal had already moved from his position and had captured the capital city of the Taurini by storm, as they hadn’t willingly joined his alliance; and he would have won over the Gauls living by the Po, not only out of fear but also out of willingness, if the consul’s arrival hadn’t abruptly stopped them while they were looking for a chance to rebel. At the same time, Hannibal left the Taurini, believing that the Gauls, unsure of which side to choose, would follow him if he was present among them. The armies were now almost in sight of each other, and their leaders, though not yet well acquainted, met each other with a sense of mutual respect. The name of Hannibal was already quite renowned among the Romans, even before the fall of Saguntum; and Hannibal regarded Scipio as a formidable opponent simply because he had been specifically chosen to command against him. Their respect for each other had also grown; Scipio, because he had met Hannibal when he crossed into Italy after being left behind in Gaul; and Hannibal, because of his bold attempt to cross the Alps and succeeding in it. However, Scipio was the first to cross the Po, and after setting up camp at the river Ticinus, he gave the following speech to encourage his soldiers before leading them into battle:

40

"If, soldiers, I were leading out that army to battle which I had with me in Gaul, I should have thought it superfluous to address you; for of what use would it be to exhort either those horsemen who so gloriously vanquished the cavalry of the enemy at the river Rhone, or those legions with whom, pursuing this very enemy flying before us, I obtained in lieu of victory, a confession of superiority, shown by his retreat and refusal to fight? Now because that army, levied for the province of Spain, maintains the war under my auspices [18] and the command of my brother Cneius Scipio, in the country where the senate and people of Rome wished him to serve, and since I, that you might have a consul for your leader against Hannibal and the Carthaginians, have offered myself voluntarily for this contest, few words are required to be addressed from a new commander to soldiers unacquainted with him. That you may not be ignorant of the nature of the war nor of the enemy, you have to fight, soldiers, with those whom in the former war you conquered both by land and sea; from whom you have exacted tribute for twenty years; from whom you hold Sicily and Sardinia, taken as the prizes of victory. In the present contest, therefore, you and they will have those feelings which are wont to belong to the victors and the vanquished. Nor are they now about to fight because they are daring, but because it is unavoidable; except you can believe that they who declined the engagement when their forces were entire, should have now gained more confidence when two-thirds of their infantry and cavalry have been lost in the passage of the Alps, and when almost greater numbers have perished than survive. Yes, they are few indeed, (some may say,) but they are vigorous in mind and body; men whose strength and power scarce any force may withstand. On the contrary, they are but the resemblances, nay, are rather the shadows of men; being worn out with hunger, cold, dirt, and filth, and bruised and enfeebled among stones and rocks. Besides all this, their joints are frost-bitten, their sinews stiffened with the snow, their limbs withered up by the frost, their armour battered and shivered, their horses lame and powerless. With such cavalry, with such infantry, you have to fight: you will not have enemies in reality, but rather their last remains. And I fear nothing more than that when you have fought Hannibal, the Alps may appear to have conquered him. But perhaps it was fitting that the gods themselves should, without any human aid, commence and carry forward a war with a leader and a people that violate the faith of treaties; and that we, who next to the gods have been injured, should finish the contest thus commenced and nearly completed."

"If I were leading the army into battle that I had with me in Gaul, I wouldn’t have thought it necessary to speak to you; what would be the point of motivating those horsemen who bravely defeated the enemy cavalry at the river Rhone or those legions with whom I, while chasing this very enemy, secured a confession of our superiority through his retreat and refusal to fight? Now that the army raised for the province of Spain is fighting under my command and that of my brother Cneius Scipio, in the territory where the Senate and the people of Rome intended for him to serve, and since I have stepped up voluntarily to lead you against Hannibal and the Carthaginians, only a few words are needed from a new commander to soldiers who don’t know him. So you’re aware of the war and the enemy you’re up against, soldiers, you will be fighting those whom you previously defeated both on land and at sea; you have exacted tribute from them for twenty years; you hold Sicily and Sardinia as trophies of victory. In this current conflict, therefore, you and they will carry the emotions typical of victors and the vanquished. They are not fighting now because they are brave, but because they have no choice; can you really believe that those who avoided battle when their forces were intact would now feel more confident after losing two-thirds of their infantry and cavalry while crossing the Alps, with more having died than survived? Yes, some may argue they are few, but they are strong in both mind and body; their strength and power can barely be resisted. On the contrary, they are just shadows of men; they are exhausted from hunger, cold, dirt, and filth, and they’ve been beaten down among stones and rocks. Additionally, their joints are frostbitten, their sinews rigid from the snow, their limbs shriveled from the cold, their armor battered and broken, and their horses lame and weak. This is the cavalry and infantry you have to fight: you won’t truly face enemies, but rather their remnants. My greatest fear is that after you face Hannibal, the Alps may seem to have conquered him. But perhaps it was meant for the gods themselves to initiate and carry on a war against a leader and a people who break the faith of treaties; and we, who have suffered injuries second only to the gods, should bring this conflict to a close as it was begun and almost finished."

41

"I do not fear lest any one should think that I say this ostentatiously for the sake of encouraging you, while in my own mind I am differently affected. I was at liberty to go with my army into Spain, my own province, whither I had already set out; where I should have had a brother as the bearer of my councils and my dangers, and Hasdrubal, instead of Hannibal, for my antagonist, and without question a less laborious war: nevertheless, as I sailed along the coast of Gaul, having landed on hearing of this enemy, and having sent forward the cavalry, I moved my camp to the Rhone. In a battle of cavalry, with which part of my forces the opportunity of engaging was afforded, I routed the enemy; and because I could not overtake by land his army of infantry, which was rapidly hurried away, as if in flight, having returned to the ships with all the speed I could, after compassing such an extent of sea and land, I have met him at the foot of the Alps. Whether do I appear, while declining the contest, to have fallen in unexpectedly with this dreaded foe, or encounter him in his track? to challenge him and drag him out to decide the contest? I am anxious to try whether the earth has suddenly, in these twenty years, sent forth a new race of Carthaginians, or whether these are the same who fought at the islands Aegates, and whom you permitted to defeat from Eryx, valued at eighteen denarii a head; and whether this Hannibal be, as he himself gives out, the rival of the expeditions of Hercules, or one left by his father the tributary and taxed subject and slave of the Roman people; who, did not his guilt at Saguntum drive him to frenzy, would certainly reflect, if not upon his conquered country, at least on his family, and his father, and the treaties written by the hand of Hamilcar; who, at the command of our consul, withdrew the garrison from Eryx; who, indignant and grieving, submitted to the harsh conditions imposed on the conquered Carthaginians; who agreed to depart from Sicily, and pay tribute to the Roman people. I would, therefore, have you fight, soldiers, not only with that spirit with which you are wont to encounter other enemies, but with a certain indignation and resentment, as if you saw your slaves suddenly taking up arms against you. We might have killed them when shut up in Eryx by hunger, the most dreadful of human tortures; we might have carried over our victorious fleet to Africa, and in a few days have destroyed Carthage without any opposition. We granted pardon to their prayers; we released them from the blockade; we made peace with them when conquered; and we afterwards considered them under our protection when they were oppressed by the African war. In return for these benefits, they come under the conduct of a furious youth to attack our country. And I wish that the contest on your side was for glory, and not for safety: it is not about the possession of Sicily and Sardinia, concerning which the dispute was formerly, but for Italy, that you must fight: nor is there another army behind, which, if we should not conquer, can resist the enemy; nor are there other Alps, during the passage of which fresh forces may be procured: here, soldiers, we must make our stand, as if we fought before the walls of Rome. Let every one consider that he defends with his arms not only his own person, but his wife and young children: nor let him only entertain domestic cares and anxieties, but at the same time let him revolve in his mind, that the senate and people of Rome now anxiously regard our efforts; and that according as our strength and valour shall be, such henceforward will be the fortune of that city and of the Roman empire."

"I’m not worried that anyone might think I’m saying this just to motivate you while actually feeling differently inside. I could have gone with my army to Spain, my own province, where I had already set out; I would have had a brother to share my plans and dangers with, and Hasdrubal, not Hannibal, as my opponent, which would definitely have meant an easier war. Still, as I sailed along the coast of Gaul, I landed after hearing about this enemy and sent out the cavalry, then moved my camp to the Rhone. In a cavalry battle, which part of my forces got the chance to engage, I defeated the enemy; and because I couldn’t catch his fast-moving infantry army on land, I returned to the ships as quickly as I could. After covering such a distance on sea and land, I met him at the foot of the Alps. Do I seem to be avoiding the battle, only to have unexpectedly run into this feared foe, or did I challenge him to confront him in his path? I’m eager to see if the earth has suddenly produced a new generation of Carthaginians in these twenty years, or if these are the same ones who fought at the Aegates islands, and whom you allowed to win back from Eryx, valued at eighteen denarii each; and whether this Hannibal is, as he claims, a rival to Hercules’ adventures, or just a tributary left by his father, a taxed subject and slave of the Roman people. If it weren’t for his guilt at Saguntum driving him to madness, he would certainly reflect, if not on his conquered country, at least on his family, his father, and the treaties written by Hamilcar; who, at the command of our consul, removed the garrison from Eryx; who, indignant and grieving, submitted to the harsh conditions imposed on the defeated Carthaginians; who agreed to leave Sicily and pay tribute to the Roman people. Therefore, I want you to fight, soldiers, not just with the spirit you use against other enemies, but with a sense of anger and resentment, as if you saw your slaves suddenly picking up arms against you. We could have killed them when they were trapped in Eryx, suffering the worst torture of hunger; we could have sent our victorious fleet to Africa and destroyed Carthage in just a few days without any resistance. We granted them forgiveness when they begged; we lifted the blockade; we made peace with them after they were defeated; and we later considered them under our protection when they were oppressed by the African war. In return for these benefits, they come led by a reckless youth to attack our land. And I wish that for you, this battle was for glory, not survival: it's not about controlling Sicily and Sardinia, as it was before, but for Italy that you must fight. There isn't another army behind us that can resist the enemy if we don't win; there are no more Alps to cross where we can gather fresh troops; here, soldiers, we must stand our ground as if we’re fighting before the walls of Rome. Let everyone remember that by fighting, they’re defending not just themselves but their wives and young children; and let them not only focus on personal worries and fears, but also realize that the senate and people of Rome are now closely watching our efforts; and that depending on our strength and bravery, that will determine the future of that city and the Roman empire."

42

Thus the consul addressed the Romans. Hannibal, thinking that his soldiers ought to be roused by deeds rather than by words, having drawn his army around for the spectacle, placed in their midst the captive mountaineers in fetters; and after Gallic arms had been thrown at their feet, he ordered the interpreter to ask, "whether any among them, on condition of being released from chains, and receiving, if victorious, armour and a horse, was willing to combat with the sword?" When they all, to a man, demanded the combat and the sword, and lots were cast into the urn for that purpose, each wished himself the person whom fortune might select for the contest. As the lot of each man came out, eager and exulting with joy amidst the congratulations of his comrades, and dancing after the national custom, he hastily snatched up the arms: but when they fought, such was the state of feeling, not only among their companions in the same circumstances, but among the spectators in general, that the fortune of those who conquered was not praised more than that of those who died bravely.

So the consul spoke to the Romans. Hannibal, believing that his soldiers should be motivated by actions rather than words, gathered his army for a show and put the captured mountaineers in chains in front of them. After throwing Gallic weapons at their feet, he instructed the interpreter to ask if any of them would be willing to fight with a sword, on the condition that they would be freed from chains and given armor and a horse if they were victorious. When all of them eagerly agreed to the fight, lots were drawn from an urn for that purpose, and each one hoped to be the lucky one chosen for the battle. As each lot was pulled, those selected were filled with joy, celebrated by their comrades and dancing in their traditional style, quickly grabbing their weapons. But as they fought, the mood was such that the victories of those who triumphed were not celebrated more than the bravery of those who died in the fight.

43

When he had dismissed the soldiers, thus affected after viewing several pairs of combatants, having then summoned an assembly, he is said to have addressed them in these terms: "If, soldiers, you shall by and by, in judging of your own fortune, preserve the same feelings which you experienced a little before in the example of the fate of others, we have already conquered; for neither was that merely a spectacle, but as it were a certain representation of your condition. And I know not whether fortune has not thrown around you still stronger chains and more urgent necessities than around your captives. On the right and left two seas enclose you, without your possessing a single ship even for escape. The river Po around you, the Po larger and more impetuous than the Rhone, the Alps behind, scarcely passed by you when fresh and vigorous, hem you in. Here, soldiers, where you have first met the enemy, you must conquer or die; and the same fortune which has imposed the necessity of fighting, holds out to you, if victorious, rewards, than which men are not wont to desire greater, even from the immortal gods. If we were only about to recover by our valour Sicily and Sardinia, wrested from our fathers, the recompence would be sufficiently ample; but whatever, acquired and amassed by so many triumphs, the Romans possess, all, with its masters themselves, will become yours. To gain this rich reward, hasten, then, and seize your arms with the favour of the gods. Long enough in pursuing cattle among the desert mountains of Lusitania [19] and Celtiberia, you have seen no emolument from so many toils and dangers: it is time to make rich and profitable campaigns, and to gain the great reward of your labours, after having accomplished such a length of journey over so many mountains and rivers, and so many nations in arms. Here fortune has granted you the termination of your labours; here she will bestow a reward worthy of the service you have undergone. Nor, in proportion as the war is great in name, ought you to consider that the victory will be difficult. A despised enemy has often maintained a sanguinary contest, and renowned states and kings been conquered by a very slight effort. For, setting aside only the splendour of the Roman name, what remains in which they can be compared to you? To pass over in silence your service for twenty years, distinguished by such valour and success you have made your way to this place from the pillars of Hercules, [20] from the ocean, and the remotest limits of the world advancing victorious through so many of the fiercest nations of Gaul and Spain: you will fight with a raw army, which this very summer was beaten, conquered, and surrounded by the Gauls, as yet unknown to its general, and ignorant of him. Shall I compare myself, almost born, and certainly bred in the tent of my father, that most illustrious commander, myself the subjugator of Spain and Gaul, the conqueror too not only of the Alpine nations, but what is much more, of the Alps themselves, with this six months' general, the deserter of his army? To whom, if any one, having taken away their standards, should show to-day the Carthaginians and Romans, I am sure that he would not know of which army he was consul. I do not regard it, soldiers, as of small account, that there is not a man among you before whose eyes I have not often achieved some military exploit; and to whom, in like manner, I the spectator and witness of his valour, could not recount his own gallant deeds, particularized by time and place. With soldiers who have a thousand times received my praises and gifts, I, who was the pupil of you all before I became your commander, will march out in battle-array against those who are unknown to and ignorant of each other."

When he had sent away the soldiers, feeling deeply moved after watching several pairs of fighters, he called for a gathering and reportedly spoke to them in these words: "If, soldiers, as you reflect on your own situation, you can hold on to the emotions you felt a short while ago when witnessing the fate of others, we have already won; for that was not just a show, but a clear reflection of your own situation. And I wonder if fortune hasn’t placed even stronger chains and more pressing needs upon you than those experienced by your captives. To your right and left, two seas surround you, with not a single ship available for escape. The river Po encircles you, a river larger and more powerful than the Rhone, with the Alps behind you, scarcely crossed when fresh and strong, trapping you in. Here, soldiers, where you first confront the enemy, you must either conquer or die; and the same fortune that compels you to fight offers you, if victorious, rewards greater than what men typically desire, even from the immortal gods. If we were merely aiming to reclaim Sicily and Sardinia, taken from our ancestors, the reward would be significant enough; but everything the Romans possess, gained through many triumphs, will be yours, along with their masters. To achieve this grand reward, hurry, and take up your weapons with the favor of the gods. After long enough spent herding cattle in the desolate mountains of Lusitania and Celtiberia, you have seen no gain for your many efforts and dangers: it’s time to embark on profitable campaigns and earn the great rewards of your hard work, after such a long journey through so many mountains, rivers, and armed nations. Here, fortune has granted you the end of your struggles; here she will reward you fittingly for the service you have performed. Nor, just because the war is renowned, should you think that the victory will be hard to achieve. A despised enemy has often fought fiercely, and famous states and kings have been defeated with minimal effort. Setting aside the prestigious Roman name, what truly compares them to you? To omit mentioning your twenty years of dedicated service, marked by bravery and triumph, you have traveled from the pillars of Hercules, from the ocean, and the furthest reaches of the world, triumphantly pushing through numerous fierce nations in Gaul and Spain: you will fight against an inexperienced army that, just this summer, was beaten, conquered, and surrounded by the Gauls, still unfamiliar with its general and unaware of him. Should I compare myself, almost born and certainly raised in the tent of my father, that most distinguished commander, I the conqueror of Spain and Gaul, not only of the Alpine nations, but even the Alps themselves, with this six-month general, a deserter of his army? If anyone were to strip the standards from today’s Carthaginians and Romans, I’m sure he wouldn’t know which army he is leading. I don’t take lightly, soldiers, that there’s not a single person among you before whom I haven’t often achieved some military feat; and to whom, likewise, I, a spectator and witness of his courage, couldn’t recount his own brave deeds, detailed by time and place. With soldiers who have received my praises and gifts a thousand times, I, who was your student before becoming your commander, will march into battle against those who are strangers to one another.”

44

"On whatever side I turn my eyes I see nothing but what is full of courage and energy; a veteran infantry; calvary, both those with and those without the bridle, composed of the most gallant nations, you our most faithful and valiant allies, you Carthaginians, who are about to fight as well for the sake of your country as from the justest resentment. We are the assailants in the war, and descend into Italy with hostile standards, about to engage so much more boldly and bravely than the foe, as the confidence and courage of the assailant are greater than those of him who is defensive. Besides suffering, injury and indignity inflame and excite our minds: they first demanded me your leader for punishment, and then all of you who had laid siege to Saguntum; and had we been given up they would have visited us with the severest tortures. That most cruel and haughty nation considers every thing its own, and at its own disposal; it thinks it right that it should regulate with whom we are to have war, with whom peace: it circumscribes and shuts us up by the boundaries of mountains and rivers, which we must not pass; and then does not adhere to those boundaries which it appointed. Pass not the Iberus; have nothing to do with the Saguntines. Saguntum is on the Iberus; you must not move a step in any direction. Is it a small thing that you take away my most ancient provinces Sicily and Sardinia? will you take Spain also? and should I withdraw thence, you will cross over into Africa--will cross, did I say? they have sent the two consuls of this year one to Africa, the other to Spain: there is nothing left to us in any quarter, except what we can assert to ourselves by arms. Those may be cowards and dastards who have something to look back upon; whom, flying through safe and unmolested roads, their own lands and their own country will receive: there is a necessity for you to be brave; and since all between victory and death is broken off from you by inevitable despair, either to conquer, or, if fortune should waver, to meet death rather in battle than flight. If this be well fixed and determined in the minds of you all, I will repeat, you have already conquered: no stronger incentive to victory has been given to man by the immortal gods."

"Wherever I look, I see nothing but courage and energy; a seasoned infantry; cavalry, both bridled and unbridled, made up of the bravest nations, you, our loyal and brave allies, you Carthaginians, who are about to fight not only for your country but also out of rightful anger. We are the attackers in this war, heading into Italy with our hostile banners, ready to fight far more boldly and bravely than the enemy, as the confidence and courage of the attacker surpass those of the defender. Furthermore, suffering, injury, and humiliation stir our spirits: they first demanded me as your leader for punishment, and then all of you who had besieged Saguntum; had we surrendered, they would have subjected us to severe torture. That cruel and arrogant nation believes everything belongs to them and is theirs to control; they think it's right to dictate with whom we can wage war and with whom we can make peace: they confine us by mountains and rivers that we cannot cross, yet they do not adhere to those boundaries they established. Don't cross the Iberus; have nothing to do with the Saguntines. Saguntum is on the Iberus; you can't move even an inch in any direction. Is it not significant that you've taken my oldest provinces, Sicily and Sardinia? Will you take Spain too? And if I retreat from there, you'll invade Africa—invade, did I say? They have sent this year's two consuls; one to Africa and the other to Spain: we have nothing left in any direction, except what we can claim through force. Those may be cowards and weaklings who have something to return to; who, fleeing down safe and untouchable roads, their homeland will welcome them back. You must be brave; and since all that lies between victory and death is cut off from you by unavoidable despair, you must either conquer, or, if fortune falters, face death in battle rather than in flight. If this is firmly established in all your minds, I’ll say it again: you have already won; no greater motivation for victory has ever been given to man by the immortal gods."

45

When the minds of the soldiers on both sides had been animated to the contest by these exhortations, the Romans throw a bridge over the Ticinus, and, for the sake of defending the bridge, erect a fort on it. The Carthaginian, while the Romans were engaged in this work, sends Maharbal with a squadron of five hundred Numidian horse, to lay waste the territories of the allies of the Roman people. He orders that the Gauls should be spared as much as possible, and the minds of their chiefs be instigated to a revolt. When the bridge was finished, the Roman army being led across into the territory of the Insubrians, took up its station five miles from Victumviae. At this place Hannibal lay encamped; and having quickly recalled Maharbal and the cavalry, when he perceived that a battle was approaching, thinking that in exhorting the soldiers enough could never be spoken or addressed by way of admonition, he announces to them, when summoned to an assembly, stated rewards, in expectation of which they might fight. He promised, "that he would give them land in Italy, Africa, Spain, where each man might choose, exempt from all burdens to the person who received it, and to his children: if any one preferred money to land, he would satisfy him in silver; if any of the allies wished to become citizens of Carthage, he would grant them permission; if others chose rather to return home, he would lend his endeavours that they should not wish the situation of any one of their countrymen exchanged for their own." To the slaves also who followed their masters he promised freedom, and that he would give two slaves in place of each of them to their masters. And that they might know that these promises were certain, holding in his left hand a lamb, and in his right a flint, having prayed to Jupiter and the other gods, that, if he was false to his word, they would thus slay him as he slew the lamb; after the prayer he broke the skull of the sheep with the stone. Then in truth all, receiving as it were the gods as sureties, each for the fulfilment of his own hopes, and thinking that the only delay in obtaining the object of their wishes arose from their not yet being engaged, with one mind and one voice demanded the battle.

When the soldiers on both sides were fired up for the fight by these speeches, the Romans built a bridge over the Ticinus and set up a fort on it to defend it. While the Romans were busy with this, the Carthaginian general sent Maharbal with 500 Numidian cavalry to devastate the lands of Rome’s allies. He instructed that the Gauls should be spared as much as possible and that their leaders should be encouraged to revolt. Once the bridge was completed, the Roman army crossed into Insubrian territory and camped five miles from Victumviae. Hannibal was encamped at this location, and when he saw that a battle was imminent, he quickly summoned Maharbal and the cavalry back, believing that there was never enough encouragement for the soldiers. When he gathered them for a meeting, he announced specific rewards they could expect for fighting. He promised, "I will give you land in Italy, Africa, or Spain, wherever you choose, free from all burdens for you and your children. If anyone prefers money over land, I will provide them with silver. If any of the allies want to become citizens of Carthage, I will allow it; and if others would rather return home, I will make sure they don’t envy the circumstances of any of their fellow countrymen." He also promised freedom to the slaves who followed their masters and said he would give their masters two slaves for each one. To show that these promises were real, he held a lamb in his left hand and a flint in his right, praying to Jupiter and the other gods that if he were false to his word, they would kill him as he killed the lamb; then he smashed the sheep's skull with the stone. After this, everyone, seeing the gods as guarantors of their hopes, believed that the only reason they hadn’t received what they desired was that they hadn’t yet fought, and they all united in demanding battle.

46

By no means so great an alacrity prevailed among the Romans, who, in addition to other causes, were also alarmed by recent prodigies; for both a wolf had entered the camp, and having torn those who met him, had escaped unhurt; and a swarm of bees had settled on a tree overhanging the general's tent. After these prodigies were expiated, Scipio having set out with his cavalry and light-armed spearmen towards the camp of the enemy, to observe from a near point their forces, how numerous, and of what description they were, falls in with Hannibal, who had himself also advanced with his cavalry to explore the circumjacent country: neither at first perceived the other, but the dust arising from the trampling of so many men and horses soon gave the signal of approaching enemies. Both armies halted, and were preparing themselves for battle. Scipio places his spearmen and Gallic cavalry in front; the Romans and what force of allies he had with him, in reserve. Hannibal receives the horsemen who rode with the rein in the centre, and strengthens his wings with Numidians. When the shout was scarcely raised, the spearmen fled among the reserve to the second line: there was then a contest of the cavalry, for some time doubtful; but afterwards, on account of the foot soldiers, who were intermingled, causing confusion among the horses, many of the riders falling off from their horses, or leaping down where they saw their friends surrounded and hard pressed, the battle for the most part came to be fought on foot; until the Numidians, who were in the wings, having made a small circuit, showed themselves on the rear. That alarm dismayed the Romans, and the wound of the consul, and the danger to his life, warded off by the interposition of his son, then just arriving at the age of puberty, augmented their fears. This youth will be found to be the same to whom the glory of finishing this war belongs, and to whom the name of Africanus was given, on account of his splendid victory over Hannibal and the Carthaginians. The flight, however, of the spearmen, whom the Numidians attacked first, was the most disorderly. The rest of the cavalry, in a close body, protecting, not only with their arms, but also with their bodies, the consul, whom they had received into the midst of them, brought him back to the camp without any where giving way in disorder or precipitation. Coelius attributes the honour of saving the consul to a slave, by nation a Ligurian. I indeed should rather wish that the account about the son was true, which also most authors have transmitted, and the report of which has generally obtained credit.

By no means was there as much eagerness among the Romans, who, in addition to other reasons, were also worried about recent omens; a wolf had entered the camp and attacked those who encountered it but escaped unharmed, and a swarm of bees had settled on a tree above the general's tent. After these omens were dealt with, Scipio set out with his cavalry and light-armed spearmen toward the enemy's camp to get a closer look at their forces—how many there were and what kind they were. He ran into Hannibal, who had also come out with his cavalry to scout the surrounding area. At first, neither noticed the other, but the dust from all the men and horses soon signaled approaching enemies. Both armies stopped and prepared for battle. Scipio positioned his spearmen and Gallic cavalry at the front, while the Romans and his other allies stayed in reserve. Hannibal placed his cavalry in the center and reinforced his flanks with Numidians. As soon as the battle cry was raised, the spearmen retreated into the reserve to the second line. A fight began between the cavalry that was uncertain for a while, but later, due to the foot soldiers mixing in and creating chaos among the horses, many riders fell off their horses or jumped down to help their friends who were surrounded and struggling. Most of the battle was then fought on foot until the Numidians on the flanks made a small loop and appeared behind the Romans. That surprise rattled the Romans, and the consul's injury, nearly costing him his life—only averted by his son, who had just reached puberty—increased their fear. This young man would ultimately be credited with ending this war and earned the name Africanus because of his impressive victory over Hannibal and the Carthaginians. However, the first to flee were the spearmen, who were attacked by the Numidians in the most chaotic manner. The rest of the cavalry, formed closely together, protected the consul, who they had gathered around, and brought him back to camp without falling into disorder or panic. Coelius credits the saving of the consul to a slave of Ligurian descent. I would actually prefer that the story about his son were true, as most authors have conveyed, and the account has generally been accepted.

47

This was the first battle with Hannibal; from which it clearly appeared that the Carthaginian was superior in cavalry; and on that account, that open plains, such as lie between the Po and the Alps, were not suited to the Romans for carrying on the war. On the following night, therefore, the soldiers being ordered to prepare their baggage in silence, the camp broke up from the Ticinus, and they hastened to the Po, in order that the rafts by which the consul had formed a bridge over the river, being not yet loosened, he might lead his forces across without disturbance or pursuit of the enemy. They arrived at Placentia before Hannibal had ascertained that they had set out from the Ticinus. He took, however, six hundred of those who loitered on the farther bank, who were slowly unfastening the raft; but he was not able to pass the bridge, as the whole raft floated down the stream as soon as the ends were unfastened. Coelius relates that Mago, with the cavalry and Spanish infantry, immediately swam the river; and that Hannibal himself led the army across by fords higher up the Po, the elephants being opposed to the stream in a line to break the force of the current. These accounts can scarcely gain credit with those who are acquainted with that river; for it is neither probable that the cavalry could bear up against the great violence of the stream, without losing their arms or horses, even supposing that inflated bags of leather had transported all the Spaniards; and the fords of the Po, by which an army encumbered with baggage could pass, must have been sought by a circuit of many days' march. Those authors are more credited by me, who relate that in the course of two days a place was with difficulty found fit for forming a bridge of rafts across the river, and that by this way the light-armed Spanish cavalry was sent forward with Mago. Whilst Hannibal, delaying beside the river to give audience to the embassies of the Gauls, conveys over the heavy-armed forces of infantry, in the mean time Mago and the cavalry proceed towards the enemy at Placentia one day's journey after crossing the river. Hannibal, a few days after, fortified his camp six miles from Placentia, and on the following day, having drawn up his line of battle in sight of the enemy, gave them an opportunity of fighting.

This was the first battle with Hannibal, which clearly showed that the Carthaginian forces were superior in cavalry. For this reason, open plains, like those between the Po and the Alps, were not suitable for the Romans to conduct the war. That night, the soldiers were ordered to pack their things quietly, and the camp at the Ticinus broke up. They hurried to the Po so they could cross the river using the rafts the consul had built into a bridge, as they weren't yet untied; he wanted to lead his troops across without any trouble from the enemy. They reached Placentia before Hannibal realized they had left the Ticinus. However, he captured six hundred soldiers who were hanging back on the opposite bank, slowly untying the raft, but he couldn't cross the bridge since the entire raft floated downstream as soon as its ends were untied. Coelius says that Mago, with the cavalry and Spanish infantry, swam across the river right away, while Hannibal himself crossed the river at fords further up the Po, with elephants positioned against the current to lessen its force. These accounts are hard to believe for those familiar with that river; it seems unlikely that the cavalry could withstand the strong current without losing their weapons or horses, even if the Spaniards were transported by inflated leather bags. The fords of the Po that an army burdened with supplies could use would likely require a detour of several days' march. I believe the authors who claim it took two days to find a suitable spot to build a raft bridge across the river, and that through this route, the light-armed Spanish cavalry was sent ahead with Mago. While Hannibal delayed by the river to meet with Gallic ambassadors, he transported his heavily armed infantry across; meanwhile, Mago and the cavalry moved toward the enemy at Placentia one day after crossing the river. A few days later, Hannibal set up his camp six miles from Placentia, and the next day, he arranged his battle lines in view of the enemy, giving them the chance to fight.

48

On the following night a slaughter was made in the Roman camp by the auxiliary Gauls, which appeared greater from the tumult than it proved in reality. Two thousand infantry and two hundred horse, having killed the guards at the gates, desert to Hannibal; whom the Carthaginians having addressed kindly, and excited by the hope of great rewards, sent each to several states to gain over the minds of their countrymen. Scipio, thinking that that slaughter was a signal for the revolt of all the Gauls, and that, contaminated with the guilt of that affair, they would rush to arms as if a frenzy had been sent among them, though he was still suffering severely from his wound, yet setting out for the river Trebia at the fourth watch of the following night with his army in silence, he removes his camp to higher ground and hills more embarrassing to the cavalry. He escaped observation less than at the Ticinus: and Hannibal, having despatched first the Numidians and then all the cavalry, would have thrown the rear at least into great confusion, had not the Numidians, through anxiety for booty, turned aside into the deserted Roman camp. There whilst, closely examining every part of the camp, they waste time, with no sufficient reward for the delay, the enemy escaped out of their hands; and when they saw the Romans already across the Trebia, and measuring out their camp, they kill a few of the loiterers intercepted on that side of the river. Scipio being unable to endure any longer the irritation of his wound, caused by the roughness of the road, and thinking that he ought to wait for his colleague, (for he had now heard that he was recalled from Sicily,) fortified a space of chosen ground, which, adjoining the river, seemed safest for a stationary camp. When Hannibal had encamped not far from thence, being as much elated with the victory of his cavalry, as anxious on account of the scarcity which every day assailed him more severely, marching as he did through the territory of the enemy, and supplies being no where provided, he sends to the village of Clastidium, where the Romans had collected a great stock of corn. There, whilst they were preparing for an assault, a hope of the town being betrayed to them was held out: Dasius, a Brundusian, the governor of the garrison, having been corrupted for four hundred pieces of gold, (no great bribe truly,) Clastidium is surrendered to Hannibal. It served as a granary for the Carthaginians while they lay at the Trebia. No cruelty was used towards the prisoners of the surrendered garrison, in order that a character for clemency might be acquired at the commencement of his proceedings.

On the next night, the Roman camp experienced a massacre at the hands of the auxiliary Gauls, which seemed worse due to the chaos than it actually was. Two thousand infantry and two hundred cavalry killed the guards at the gates and then deserted to Hannibal. The Carthaginians, after treating them kindly and inspiring them with the promise of substantial rewards, sent each of them to different states to sway their fellow countrymen. Scipio, believing this slaughter signaled a revolt among all the Gauls and that they would rush to arms as if driven mad by guilt, decided to act despite still suffering from his wound. He silently set out for the River Trebia with his army in the fourth watch of the following night, moving his camp to higher ground that was more challenging for the cavalry. He avoided detection better than at the Ticinus, and Hannibal, after sending out the Numidians and then all the cavalry, could have caused significant confusion in the rear but the Numidians, eager for plunder, diverted to the abandoned Roman camp. There, while they carefully inspected the camp and wasted time with little reward for their delay, the enemy escaped from their grasp. When they finally saw the Romans already across the Trebia setting up their camp, they killed a few stragglers caught on that side of the river. Scipio, unable to bear the pain of his wound exacerbated by the rough terrain, decided to wait for his colleague (having heard he was recalled from Sicily) and secured a chosen area next to the river that seemed safest for a stationary camp. When Hannibal camped nearby, he felt as victorious from the success of his cavalry as he was anxious about the increasing scarcity of supplies. Marching through enemy territory with no provisions available, he sent men to the village of Clastidium, where the Romans had stored a large supply of grain. While preparing to storm the town, they were promised that it would be handed over to them. Dasius, a Brundusian and the governor of the garrison, was bribed with four hundred pieces of gold (a small amount, honestly), leading to Clastidium's surrender to Hannibal. It became a supply base for the Carthaginians while they were at Trebia. No cruelty was shown toward the captured soldiers to establish a reputation for mercy at the outset of his campaign.

49

While the war by land was at a stand beside the Trebia, in the mean time operations went on by land and sea around Sicily and the islands adjacent to Italy, both under Sempronius the consul, and before his arrival. Twenty quinqueremes, with a thousand armed men, having been sent by the Carthaginians to lay waste the coast of Italy, nine reached the Liparae, eight the island of Vulcan, and three the tide drove into the strait. On these being seen from Messana, twelve ships sent out by Hiero king of Syracuse, who then happened to be at Messana, waiting for the Roman consul, brought back into the port of Messana the ships taken without any resistance. It was discovered from the prisoners that, besides the twenty ships, to which fleet they belonged, and which had been despatched against Italy, thirty-five other quinqueremes were directing their course to Sicily, in order to gain over their ancient allies: that their main object was to gain possession of Lilybaeum, and they believed that that fleet had been driven to the islands Aegates by the same storm by which they themselves had been dispersed. The king writes these tidings, according as they had been received, to Marcus Aemilius the praetor, whose province Sicily was, and advises him to occupy Lilybaeum with a strong garrison. Immediately the lieutenants, generals, and tribunes, with the praetor, were despatched to the different states, in order that they might keep their men on vigilant guard; above all things it was commanded, that Lilybaeum should be secured: an edict having been put forth that, in addition to such warlike preparations, the crews should carry down to their ships dressed provisions for ten days, so that no one when the signal was given might delay in embarking; and that those who were stationed along the whole coast should look out from their watch-towers for the approaching fleet of the enemy. The Carthaginians, therefore, though they had purposely slackened the course of their ships, so that they might reach Lilybaeum just before daybreak, were descried before their arrival, because both the moon shone all night, and they came with their sails set up. Immediately the signal was given from the watch-towers, and the summons to arms was shouted through the town, and they embarked in the ships: part of the soldiers were left on the walls and at the stations of the gates, and part went on board the fleet. The Carthaginians, because they perceived that they would not have to do with an unprepared enemy, kept back from the harbour till daylight, that interval being spent in taking down their rigging and getting ready the fleet for action. When the light appeared, they withdrew their fleet into the open sea, that there might be room for the battle, and that the ships of the enemy might have a free egress from the harbour. Nor did the Romans decline the conflict, being emboldened both by the recollection of the exploits they had performed near that very spot, and by the numbers and valour of their soldiers.

While the land war was at a standstill near the Trebia, operations continued by land and sea around Sicily and the nearby islands of Italy, both under Consul Sempronius and before his arrival. The Carthaginians sent twenty quinqueremes with a thousand armed men to ravage the Italian coast; nine made it to the Liparae islands, eight reached Vulcan Island, and three were carried into the strait by the tide. When they were spotted from Messana, twelve ships dispatched by Hiero, king of Syracuse—who was at Messana waiting for the Roman consul—captured the ships without resistance and returned with them to Messana. From the prisoners, it was learned that, in addition to the original twenty ships, to which fleet they belonged and which had been sent against Italy, another thirty-five quinqueremes were heading to Sicily to rally their ancient allies. Their primary goal was to seize Lilybaeum, and they believed that the fleet had been pushed to the Aegates Islands by the same storm that had scattered them. The king sent these updates, as he received them, to Marcus Aemilius the praetor, who governed Sicily, advising him to station a strong garrison at Lilybaeum. Immediately, the lieutenants, generals, and tribunes, along with the praetor, were sent to various states to ensure their troops remained vigilant; above all, securing Lilybaeum was emphasized. An edict was issued that, in addition to military preparations, crews should stock their ships with provisions for ten days, so no one would delay in boarding when the signal was given, and those stationed along the coast were ordered to watch for the approaching enemy fleet from their watchtowers. The Carthaginians, therefore, intentionally slowed their ships so they could reach Lilybaeum just before dawn, but they were spotted before arriving because the moon shone all night and they approached with their sails up. As soon as they were sighted, the signal was raised from the watchtowers, and the call to arms echoed through the town as they boarded their ships: some soldiers were left on the walls and at the gate posts, while others joined the fleet. Knowing they would be up against a prepared enemy, the Carthaginians held back from the harbor until daylight, using that time to take down their rigging and prepare their fleet for battle. When morning came, they moved their fleet into open water to allow for battle and to give the enemy ships free passage from the harbor. The Romans did not shy away from the conflict, encouraged both by memories of their past victories in that very spot and by the strength and bravery of their soldiers.

50

When they had advanced into the open sea, the Romans wished to come to close fight, and to make a trial of strength hand to hand. The Carthaginians, on the contrary, eluded them, and sought to maintain the fight by art, not by force, and to make it a battle of ships rather than of men and arms: for though they had their fleet abundantly supplied with mariners, yet it was deficient in soldiers; and when a ship was grappled, a very unequal number of armed men fought on board of it. When this was observed, their numbers increased the courage of the Romans, and their inferiority of force diminished that of the others. Seven Carthaginian ships were immediately surrounded; the rest took to flight: one thousand seven hundred soldiers and mariners were captured in the ships, and among them were three noble Carthaginians. The Roman fleet returned without loss to the harbour, only one ship being pierced, and even that also brought back into port. After this engagement, before those at Messana were aware of its occurrence, Titus Sempronius the consul arrived at Messana. As he entered the strait, king Hiero led out a fleet fully equipped to meet him; and having passed from the royal ship into that of the general, he congratulated him on having arrived safe with his army and fleet, and prayed that his expedition to Sicily might be prosperous and successful. He then laid before him the state of the island and the designs of the Carthaginians, and promised that with the same spirit with which he had in his youth assisted the Romans during the former war, he would now assist them in his old age; that he would gratuitously furnish supplies of corn and clothing to the legions and naval crews of the consul; adding, that great danger threatened Lilybaeum and the maritime states, and that a change of affairs would be acceptable to some of them. For these reasons it appeared to the consul that he ought to make no delay, but to repair to Lilybaeum with his fleet. The king and the royal squadron set out along with him, and on their passage they heard that a battle had been fought at Lilybaeum, and that the enemy's ships had been scattered and taken.

As they sailed into the open sea, the Romans wanted to engage in close combat and test their strength in hand-to-hand fighting. The Carthaginians, however, avoided this and aimed to fight with strategy rather than brute force, making it a battle of ships instead of men and weapons. Although their fleet was well-stocked with sailors, they were short on soldiers, so when a ship was boarded, there was an unequal number of armed men fighting on board. Once the Romans noticed this, their larger numbers boosted their confidence, while the Carthaginians' weaker numbers dampened theirs. Seven Carthaginian ships were quickly surrounded, and the rest fled. A total of one thousand seven hundred soldiers and sailors were captured, including three prominent Carthaginians. The Roman fleet returned to port without any significant losses, with only one ship slightly damaged, which also made it back safely. After this fight, before those in Messana were aware of what had happened, Consul Titus Sempronius arrived in Messana. As he entered the strait, King Hiero brought out a fully equipped fleet to greet him. After moving from the royal ship to the general's vessel, he congratulated him on arriving safely with his army and fleet and wished for his mission in Sicily to be successful. He then updated Sempronius on the situation in the island and the Carthaginians' plans, promising that, just as he had helped the Romans in his youth during the previous war, he would now support them in his old age. He stated he would provide supplies of grain and clothing to the consul's legions and navy at no cost, adding that great danger loomed over Lilybaeum and the coastal territories, and a shift in power would be welcomed by some of them. For these reasons, the consul felt he should hurry to Lilybaeum with his fleet. The king and his royal squadron accompanied him, and during their journey, they learned that a battle had taken place at Lilybaeum and that the enemy's ships had been scattered and captured.

51

The consul having dismissed Hiero with the royal fleet, and left the praetor to defend the coast of Sicily, passed over himself from Lilybaeum to the island Melita, which was held in possession by the Carthaginians. On his arrival, Hamilcar, the son of Gisgo, the commander of the garrison, with little less than two thousand soldiers, together with the town and the island, are delivered up to him: thence, after a few days, he returned to Lilybaeum, and the prisoners taken, both by the consul and the praetor, excepting those illustrious for their rank, were publicly sold. When the consul considered that Sicily was sufficiently safe on that side, he crossed over to the islands of Vulcan, because there was a report that the Carthaginian fleet was stationed there: but not one of the enemy was discovered about those islands. They had already, as it happened, passed over to ravage the coast of Italy, and having laid waste the territory of Vibo, were also threatening the city. The descent made by the enemy on the Vibonensian territory is announced to the consul as he was returning to Sicily: and letters were delivered to him which had been sent by the senate, about the passage of Hannibal into Italy, commanding him as soon as possible to bring assistance to his colleague. Perplexed with having so many anxieties at once, he immediately sent his army, embarked in the fleet, by the upper sea to Ariminum; he assigned the defence of the territory of Vibo, and the sea-coast of Italy, to Sextus Pomponius, his lieutenant-general, with twenty-five ships of war: he made up a fleet of fifty ships for Marcus Aemilius the praetor; and he himself, after the affairs of Sicily were settled, sailing close along the coast of Italy with ten ships, arrived at Ariminum, whence, setting out with his army for the river Trebia, he joined his colleague.

The consul dismissed Hiero with the royal fleet and left the praetor to defend the coast of Sicily. He then traveled from Lilybaeum to the island of Melita, which was occupied by the Carthaginians. Upon his arrival, Hamilcar, the son of Gisgo, the commander of the garrison, surrendered the town and the island along with nearly two thousand soldiers. After a few days, he returned to Lilybaeum, where the prisoners taken by both the consul and the praetor, except for those of high rank, were sold publicly. Once the consul felt that Sicily was secure on that side, he crossed over to the islands of Vulcan, having heard reports that the Carthaginian fleet was stationed there. However, no enemies were found in those islands. They had already moved on to attack the coast of Italy and were laying waste to the territory of Vibo, threatening the city. News of the enemy's invasion of Vibonensian territory reached the consul as he was returning to Sicily, along with letters from the senate about Hannibal's crossing into Italy, instructing him to provide assistance to his colleague as soon as possible. Overwhelmed by so many concerns at once, he promptly sent his army, embarked in the fleet, by the upper sea to Ariminum. He assigned the defense of Vibo's territory and the Italian coastline to his lieutenant-general, Sextus Pomponius, with twenty-five warships. He prepared a fleet of fifty ships for Marcus Aemilius the praetor. After settling matters in Sicily, he sailed close along the coast of Italy with ten ships, arriving at Ariminum, from where he set out with his army for the river Trebia to join his colleague.

52

Both the consuls and all the strength of Rome being now opposed to Hannibal, made it sufficiently obvious that the Roman empire could either be defended by those forces, or that there was no other hope left. Yet the one consul being dispirited by the battle of the cavalry and his own wound, wished operations to be deferred: the other having his spirits unsubdued, and being therefore the more impetuous, admitted no delay. The tract of country between the Trebia and the Po was then inhabited by the Gauls, who, in this contest of two very powerful states, by a doubtful neutrality, were evidently looking forward to the favour of the conqueror. The Romans submitted to this conduct of the Gauls with tolerable satisfaction, provided they did not take any active part at all; but the Carthaginian bore it with great discontent, giving out that he had come invited by the Gauls to set them at liberty. On account of that resentment, and in order that he might at the same time maintain his troops from the plunder, he ordered two thousand foot and a thousand horse, chiefly Numidians, with some Gauls intermixed, to lay waste all the country straightforward as far as the banks of the Po. The Gauls, being in want of assistance, though they had up to this time kept their inclinations doubtful, are forced by the authors of the injury to turn to some who would be their supporters; and having sent ambassadors to the consul, they implore the aid of the Romans in behalf of a country which was suffering for the too great fidelity of its inhabitants to the Romans. Neither the cause nor the time of pleading it was satisfactory to Cornelius; and the nation was suspected by him, both on account of many treacherous actions, and though others might have been forgotten through length of time, on account of the recent perfidy of the Boii. Sempronius, on the contrary, thought that it would be the strongest tie upon the fidelity of the allies, if those were defended who first required support. Then, while his colleague hesitated, he sends his own cavalry, with about a thousand spearmen on foot in their company, to protect the Gallic territory beyond the Trebia. These, when they had unexpectedly attacked the enemy while scattered and disordered, and for the most part encumbered with booty, caused great terror, slaughter, and flight, even as far as the camp and outposts of the enemy; whence being repulsed by the numbers that poured out, they again renewed the fight with the assistance of their own party. Then pursuing and retreating in doubtful battle, though they left it at last equal, yet the fame of the victory was more with the Romans than the enemy.

Both the consuls and the full power of Rome were now against Hannibal, making it clear that the Roman empire could either be defended by those forces or had no other hope left. However, one consul, demoralized by the cavalry battle and his own injury, wanted to delay operations. The other consul, whose spirits remained unbroken and was therefore more aggressive, insisted there could be no delay. The area between the Trebia and the Po was inhabited by the Gauls, who, caught in the struggle between two powerful states, were clearly looking to align themselves with the winning side. The Romans accepted this stance from the Gauls with reasonable satisfaction as long as they didn’t actively participate, but the Carthaginian was very displeased, claiming that he had been invited by the Gauls to liberate them. Because of that resentment, and to keep his troops from raiding, he ordered 2,000 infantry and 1,000 cavalry, mostly Numidians with some Gauls mixed in, to devastate the land straight to the banks of the Po. The Gauls, needing help, despite their previous uncertain stance, were driven by their grievances to seek support from others, and they sent ambassadors to the consul, pleading for Roman assistance for a region suffering due to the strong loyalty of its inhabitants to Rome. Both the reason and the timing for such a plea didn’t sit well with Cornelius, who suspected the nation because of many past treacherous actions, and even though some might have been forgotten over time, the recent betrayal by the Boii weighed heavily on his mind. In contrast, Sempronius believed the best way to secure the loyalty of allies was to defend those who first sought help. While his colleague hesitated, he sent his own cavalry, along with about a thousand foot soldiers, to protect the Gallic territory beyond the Trebia. They unexpectedly attacked the enemy, who were scattered, disorganized, and mostly burdened with loot, causing significant terror, slaughter, and flight, reaching even to the enemy’s camp and outposts. They were pushed back by the overwhelming numbers that came out, but they renewed the fight with support from their own side. Thus, in a back-and-forth battle, even though it eventually ended in a stalemate, the Romans emerged with the greater reputation for victory.

53

But to no one did it appear more important and just than to the consul himself. He was transported with joy "that he had conquered with that part of the forces with which the other consul had been defeated; that the spirits of the soldiers were restored and revived; that there was no one, except his colleague, who would wish an engagement delayed; and that he, suffering more from disease of mind than body, shuddered, through recollection of his wound, at arms and battle. But others ought not to sink into decrepitude together with a sick man. For why should there be any longer protraction or waste of time? What third consul, what other army did they wait for? The camp of the Carthaginians was in Italy, and almost in sight of the city. It was not Sicily and Sardinia, which had been taken from them when vanquished, nor Spain on this side of the Iberus, that was their object, but that the Romans should be driven from the land of their fathers, and the soil in which they were born. How deeply," he continued, "would our fathers groan, who were wont to wage war around the walls of Carthage, if they should see us their offspring, two consuls and two consular armies, trembling within our camps in the heart of Italy, while a Carthaginian had made himself master of all the country between the Alps and the Apennine!" Such discourses did he hold while sitting beside his sick colleague, and also at the head-quarters, almost in the manner of an harangue. The approaching period of the elections also stimulated him, lest the war should be protracted till the new consuls were chosen, and the opportunity of turning all the glory to himself, while his colleague lay sick. He orders the soldiers, therefore, Cornelius in vain attempting to dissuade him, to get ready for an immediate engagement. Hannibal, as he saw what conduct would be best for the enemy, had scarce at first any hope that the consuls would do any thing rashly or imprudently, but when he discovered that the disposition of the one, first known from report, and afterwards from experience, was ardent and impetuous, and believed that it had been rendered still more impetuous by the successful engagement with his predatory troops, he did not doubt that an opportunity of action was near at hand. He was anxious and watchful not to omit this opportunity, while the troops of the enemy were raw, while his wound rendered the better of the two commanders useless, and while the spirits of the Gauls were fresh; of whom he knew that a great number would follow him with the greater reluctance the farther they were drawn away from home. When, for these and similar reasons, he hoped that an engagement was near and desired to make the attack himself, if there should be any delay; and when the Gauls, who were the safer spies to ascertain what he wished, as they served in both camps, had brought intelligence that the Romans were prepared for battle, the Carthaginian began to look about for a place for an ambuscade.

But to no one did it seem more important and fair than to the consul himself. He was overjoyed that he had triumphed with the forces that had previously led to the other consul's defeat; that the soldiers' spirits were lifted and rejuvenated; that there was no one, except for his colleague, who wanted to delay the fight; and that he, suffering more from mental distress than physical illness, recoiled, remembering his injury, at the thought of arms and battle. But others shouldn't grow feeble alongside a sick man. Why should they prolong or waste any more time? What third consul, what other army were they waiting for? The Carthaginian camp was in Italy, almost in sight of the city. It wasn’t about Sicily and Sardinia, which had been taken from them when they were defeated, nor Spain on this side of the Iberus, but about driving the Romans from their ancestral land and the soil where they were born. “How deeply,” he continued, “would our ancestors groan, who used to wage war around the walls of Carthage, if they were to see us, their descendants, two consuls and two consular armies, trembling in our camps in the heart of Italy, while a Carthaginian had taken control of all the land between the Alps and the Apennine!” He spoke these words while sitting beside his sick colleague, and also at headquarters, almost like a speech. The upcoming election period also motivated him, for he feared the war would drag on until the new consuls were chosen, which would diminish his chance to claim all the glory while his colleague lay ill. He therefore ordered the soldiers, despite Cornelius's futile attempts to dissuade him, to prepare for an immediate engagement. Hannibal, seeing what would be best for the enemy, initially had little hope that the consuls would act rashly or foolishly. However, when he realized that one consul, first through hearsay and later through experience, was eager and impulsive, and believed that it had become even more so after the successful skirmish with his raiding troops, he no longer doubted that an opportunity for action was approaching. He was anxious and vigilant not to miss this chance, while the enemy troops were inexperienced, while the injury of the better of the two commanders rendered him ineffective, and while the morale of the Gauls was high; he knew that many would follow him with increasing reluctance the farther they were drawn from home. Considering these reasons and more, he anticipated that a battle was near and wanted to launch the attack himself if there were any delay; and when the Gauls, who were the safest informants since they served in both camps, reported that the Romans were ready for battle, the Carthaginian began to look for a place to set an ambush.

54

Between the armies was a rivulet, bordered on each side with very high banks, and covered around with marshy plants, and with the brushwood and brambles with which uncultivated places are generally overspread; and when, riding around it, he had, with his own eyes, thoroughly reconnoitred a place which was sufficient to afford a covert even for cavalry, he said to Mago his brother: "This will be the place which you must occupy. Choose out of all the infantry and cavalry a hundred men of each, with whom come to me at the first watch. Now is the time to refresh their bodies." The council was thus dismissed, and in a little time Mago came forward with his chosen men. "I see," said Hannibal, "the strength of the men; but that you may be strong not only in resolution, but also in number, pick out each from the troops and companies nine men like yourselves: Mago will show you the place where you are to lie in ambush. You will have an enemy who is blind to these arts of war." A thousand horse and a thousand foot, under the command of Mago, having been thus sent off, Hannibal orders the Numidian cavalry to ride up, after crossing the river Trebia by break of day, to the gates of the enemy, and to draw them out to a battle by discharging their javelins at the guards; and then, when the fight was commenced, by retiring slowly to decoy them across the river. These instructions were given to the Numidians: to the other leaders of the infantry and cavalry it was commanded that they should order all their men to dine; and then, under arms and with their horses equipped, to await the signal. Sempronius, eager for the contest, led out, on the first tumult raised by the Numidians, all the cavalry, being full of confidence in that part of the forces; then six thousand infantry, and lastly all his army, to the place already determined in his plan. It happened to be the winter season and a snowy day, in the region which lies between the Alps and the Apennine, and excessively cold by the proximity of rivers and marshes: besides, there was no heat in the bodies of the men and horses thus hastily led out without having first taken food, or employed any means to keep off the cold; and the nearer they approached to the blasts from the river, a keener degree of cold blew upon them. But when, in pursuit of the flying Numidians, they entered the water, (and it was swollen by rain in the night as high as their breasts,) then in truth the bodies of all, on landing, were so benumbed, that they were scarcely able to hold their arms; and as the day advanced they began to grow faint, both from fatigue and hunger.

Between the armies was a small stream, flanked on both sides by very high banks, and surrounded by swampy plants, with the underbrush and thorns that typically cover wild areas. After circling it and thoroughly scouting a spot that could easily hide even cavalry, he said to his brother Mago, “This will be the position you need to take. Choose a hundred men each from the infantry and cavalry, and meet me at the first watch. It's time to recharge their strength.” The council was adjourned, and soon Mago returned with his selected men. "I see," Hannibal remarked, "the capabilities of the troops; to ensure you are strong not just in spirit but also in numbers, select nine men each from your units. Mago will guide you to the spot where you will lie in ambush. You will face an enemy unaware of these war tactics." A thousand cavalry and a thousand infantry, under Mago’s command, were dispatched. Hannibal instructed the Numidian cavalry to approach the enemy gates at daybreak after crossing the Trebia River, and to provoke a battle by throwing their javelins at the guards; then, as the fight began, to retreat slowly to lure them across the river. These orders were given to the Numidians; for the other infantry and cavalry commanders, it was directed that all their men should eat; then, fully armed and with their horses ready, they would await the signal. Sempronius, eager for battle, led out all the cavalry at the first disturbance caused by the Numidians, feeling confident in that part of his forces; then he sent out six thousand infantry, and finally his entire army, to the predetermined location. It happened to be winter, with a snowy day in the area between the Alps and the Apennines, extremely cold due to the nearby rivers and swamps. In addition, the men and horses lacked warmth, having rushed out without eating or taking any measures to fend off the cold; the closer they got to the icy winds from the river, the more intense the chill became. But when, chasing the fleeing Numidians, they entered the water (which had swollen from overnight rain to chest height), all of them truly became so numb upon landing that they could barely hold their weapons; and as the day wore on, they began to feel weak from exhaustion and hunger.

55

In the mean time the soldiers of Hannibal, fires having been kindled before the tents, and oil sent through the companies to soften their limbs, and their food having been taken at leisure, as soon as it was announced that the enemy had passed the river, seized their arms with vigour of mind and body, and advanced to the battle. Hannibal placed before the standards the Baliares and the light-armed troops, to the amount of nearly eight thousand men; then the heavier-armed infantry, the chief of his power and strength: on the wings he posted ten thousand horse, and on their extremities stationed the elephants divided into two parts. The consul placed on the flanks of his infantry the cavalry, recalled by the signal for retreat, as in their irregular pursuit of the enemy they were checked, while unprepared, by the Numidians suddenly turning upon them. There were of infantry eighteen thousand Romans, twenty thousand allies of the Latin name, besides the auxiliary forces of the Cenomani, the only Gallic nation that had remained faithful: with these forces they engaged the enemy. The battle was commenced by the Baliares; whom when the legions resisted with superior force, the light-armed troops were hastily drawn off to the wings; which movement caused the Roman cavalry to be immediately overpowered: for when their four thousand already with difficulty withstood by themselves ten thousand of the enemy, the wearied, against men for the most part fresh, they were overwhelmed in addition by a cloud as it were of javelins, discharged by the Baliares; and the elephants besides, which held a prominent position at the extremities of the wings, (the horses being greatly terrified not only at their appearance, but their unusual smell,) occasioned flight to a wide extent. The battle between the infantry was equal rather in courage than strength; for the Carthaginian brought the latter entire to the action, having a little before refreshed themselves, while, on the contrary, the bodies of the Romans, suffering from fasting and fatigue, and stiff with cold, were quite benumbed. They would have made a stand, however, by dint of courage, if they had only had to fight with the infantry. But both the Baliares, having beaten off the cavalry, poured darts on their flanks, and the elephants had already penetrated to the centre of the line of the infantry; while Mago and the Numidians, as soon as the army had passed their place of ambush without observing them, starting up on their rear, occasioned great disorder and alarm. Nevertheless, amid so many surrounding dangers, the line for some time remained unbroken, and, most contrary to the expectation of all, against the elephants. These the light infantry, posted for the purpose, turned back by throwing their spears; and following them up when turned, pierced them under the tail, where they received the wounds in the softest skin.

In the meantime, Hannibal's soldiers lit fires in front of their tents and were given oil to help relax their muscles. They savored their meals, and as soon as it was reported that the enemy had crossed the river, they eagerly grabbed their weapons and moved forward to fight. Hannibal lined up about eight thousand Balearic slingers and light infantry in front of the standards, followed by his main force of heavily armed infantry. On the flanks, he positioned ten thousand cavalry and stationed elephants at each end, divided into two groups. The consul placed cavalry on the sides of his infantry, recalling them after signaling a retreat since they were caught off guard by the Numidians during their hasty pursuit of the enemy. There were eighteen thousand Roman infantry and twenty thousand Latin allies, along with auxiliary troops from the Cenomani, the only Gallic nation that had stayed loyal; these forces engaged the enemy. The battle began with the Balearics, but when the legions fought back with stronger force, the light infantry quickly retreated to the wings, leading to the Roman cavalry being quickly overwhelmed. Their four thousand soldiers struggled to hold their ground against ten thousand of the enemy, and they were further battered by a barrage of javelins from the Balearics. To make things worse, the elephants, positioned at the ends of the wings, frightened the horses with their presence and strange smell, causing a widespread retreat. The battle between the infantry was more a test of courage than strength; the Carthaginians had their full numbers refreshed for the fight, while the Romans, already weakened by hunger and exhaustion and chilled by the cold, were numb. They would have stood their ground out of bravery if they only had to face the infantry. But the Balearics, after defeating the cavalry, rained down darts on their flanks, and the elephants had already breached the center of the infantry line. Meanwhile, Mago and the Numidians, springing up from their hiding place as the army passed by, caused significant chaos and panic. Despite the numerous threats surrounding them, the line held firm for a time, contrary to everyone's expectations, even against the elephants. The light infantry, positioned for this purpose, turned the elephants back by throwing their spears and pursued them when they turned, striking them under the tail, where their skin was the softest.

56

Hannibal ordered the elephants, thus thrown into disorder, and almost driven by their terror against their own party, to be led away from the centre of the line to its extremity against the auxiliary Gauls on the left wing. In an instant they occasioned unequivocal flight; and a new alarm was added to the Romans when they saw their auxiliaries routed. About ten thousand men, therefore, as they now were fighting in a circle, the others being unable to escape, broke through the middle of the line of the Africans, which was supported by the Gallic auxiliaries, with immense slaughter of the enemy: and since they neither could return to the camp, being shut out by the river, nor, on account of the heavy rain, satisfactorily determine in what part they should assist their friends, they proceeded by the direct road to Placentia. After this several irruptions were made in all directions; and those who sought the river were either swallowed up in its eddies, or whilst they hesitated to enter it were cut off by the enemy. Some, who had been scattered abroad through the country in their flight, by following the traces of the retreating army, arrived at Placentia; others, the fear of the enemy inspired with boldness to enter the river, having crossed it, reached the camp. The rain mixed with snow, and the intolerable severity of the cold, destroyed many men and beasts of burden, and almost all the elephants. The river Trebia was the termination of the Carthaginians' pursuit of the enemy; and they returned to the camp so benumbed with cold, that they could scarcely feel joy for the victory. On the following night, therefore, though the guard of the camp and the principal part of the soldiers that remained passed the Trebia on rafts, they either did not perceive it, on account of the beating of the rain, or being unable to bestir themselves, through their fatigue and wounds, pretended that they did not perceive it; and the Carthaginians remaining quiet, the army was silently led by the consul Scipio to Placentia, thence transported across the Po to Cremona, lest one colony should be too much burdened by the winter quarters of two armies.

Hannibal ordered the elephants, now in chaos and almost frightened into turning against their own side, to be moved away from the center of the line to the end against the auxiliary Gauls on the left. In no time, they caused a clear retreat, and the Romans panicked even more when they saw their allies fleeing. About ten thousand men, trapped in a circle and unable to escape, broke through the center of the African line, which was supported by the Gallic auxiliaries, resulting in massive casualties for the enemy. Since they couldn't return to the camp, blocked off by the river, and, due to the heavy rain, couldn't decide where to assist their friends, they took the direct route to Placentia. After that, there were several breakouts in all directions; those who tried to reach the river were either caught in its currents or cut off by the enemy as they hesitated to jump in. Some, who had scattered across the countryside in their flight, managed to follow the traces of the retreating army and arrived at Placentia; others, spurred by fear of the enemy, bravely entered the river and made it to the camp. The rain mixed with snow, and the unbearable cold killed many soldiers and pack animals, and almost all the elephants. The river Trebia marked the end of the Carthaginians' pursuit of the enemy; they returned to camp so frozen that they could barely feel joy for their victory. That night, while the camp guard and most of the remaining soldiers crossed the Trebia on rafts, they either didn't notice it because of the downpour or, too exhausted and injured to move, pretended they didn't see. The Carthaginians stayed quiet as the army was secretly led by the consul Scipio to Placentia and then transported across the Po to Cremona, to avoid overburdening one colony with the winter quarters of two armies.

57

Such terror on account of this disaster was carried to Rome, that they believed that the enemy was already approaching the city with hostile standards, and that they had neither hope nor aid by which they might repel his attack from the gates and walls. One consul having been defeated at the Ticinus, the other having been recalled from Sicily, and now both consuls and their two consular armies having been vanquished, what other commanders, what other legions were there to be sent for? The consul Sempronius came to them whilst thus dismayed, having passed at great risk through the cavalry of the enemy, scattered in every direction in search of plunder, with courage, rather than with any plan or hope of escaping, or of making resistance if he should not escape it. Having held the assembly for the election of the consuls, the only thing which was particularly wanting at present, he returned to the winter quarters. Cneius Servilius and Caius Flaminius were elected consuls. But not even the winter quarters of the Romans were undisturbed, the Numidian horse ranging at large, and where the ground was impracticable for these, the Celtiberians and Lusitanians. All supplies, therefore, from every quarter, were cut off, except such as the ships conveyed by the Po. There was a magazine near Placentia, both fortified with great care and secured by a strong garrison. In the hope of taking this fort, Hannibal having set out with the cavalry and the light-armed horse, and having attacked it by night, as he rested his main hope of effecting his enterprise on keeping it concealed, did not escape the notice of the guards. Such a clamour was immediately raised, that it was heard even at Placentia. The consul; therefore, came up with the cavalry about daybreak, having commanded the legions to follow in a square band. In the mean time an engagement of cavalry commenced, in which the enemy being dismayed because Hannibal retired wounded from the fight, the fortress was admirably defended. After this, having taken rest for a few days, and before his wound was hardly as yet sufficiently healed, he sets out to lay siege to Victumviae. This magazine had been fortified by the Romans in the Gallic war; afterwards a mixture of inhabitants from the neighbouring states around had made the place populous; and at this time the terror created by the devastation of the enemy had driven together to it numbers from the country. A multitude of this description, excited by the report of the brave defence of the fortress near Placentia, having snatched up their arms, went out to meet Hannibal. They engaged on the road rather like armies in order of march than in line of battle; and since on the one side there was nothing but a disorderly crowd, and on the other a general confident in his soldiers, and soldiers in their general, as many as thirty-five thousand men were routed by a few. On the following day, a surrender having been made, they received a garrison within their walls; and being ordered to deliver up their arms, as soon as they had obeyed the command, a signal is suddenly given to the victors to pillage the city, as if it had been taken by storm; nor was any outrage, which in such cases is wont to appear to writers worthy of relation, left unperpetrated; such a specimen of every kind of lust, barbarity, and inhuman insolence was exhibited towards that unhappy people. Such were the expeditions of Hannibal during the winter.

Such fear over this disaster spread to Rome, leading them to believe that the enemy was already approaching the city with their banners and that they had no hope or support to defend themselves from the attack at the gates and walls. One consul had been defeated at the Ticinus, the other had been recalled from Sicily, and now both consuls and their two consular armies had been defeated—who else could they send for? The consul Sempronius came to them while they were in this state of panic, having taken a big risk to get through the enemy's cavalry, which was scattered everywhere looking for loot, acting out of courage rather than any plan or hope of escaping or resisting if he didn't manage to escape. After holding an assembly to elect the consuls, which was the urgent need at that moment, he returned to the winter quarters. Cneius Servilius and Caius Flaminius were elected consuls. However, even the Romans' winter quarters were not safe, as the Numidian cavalry roamed freely, and where the ground was unsuitable for them, the Celtiberians and Lusitanians moved in. Thus, all supplies from every direction were cut off, except for what the ships could bring by the Po. There was a supply depot near Placentia, heavily fortified and secured by a strong garrison. Hoping to take this fort, Hannibal set out with the cavalry and light-armed troops, attacking it at night, counting on the concealment of his plans, but he didn't go unnoticed by the guards. A loud noise was raised that was heard even at Placentia. Therefore, the consul arrived with the cavalry at daybreak, having ordered the legions to follow in a tight formation. In the meantime, a cavalry battle started, in which the enemy, alarmed because Hannibal withdrew wounded from the fight, saw the fortress remarkably defended. After this, having rested for a few days, and before his wound had fully healed, he set out to lay siege to Victumviae. This depot had been fortified by the Romans during the Gallic war; later, a mix of inhabitants from nearby states had made the place populous, and at this time, the fear caused by the enemy's devastation had brought many people from the countryside together there. A large group, spurred by the news of the brave defense of the fortress near Placentia, armed themselves and went out to meet Hannibal. They clashed on the road more like marching armies than in battle; and since one side was just a disorganized crowd while the other had a confident general supported by his soldiers, around thirty-five thousand men were defeated by just a few. The next day, after a surrender took place, they welcomed a garrison into their walls; and after being ordered to hand over their arms, once they complied, a signal was suddenly given to the victors to loot the city, as if it had been captured in a storm; no form of violence, which is often reported in such cases, was left uncommitted; a display of every kind of lust, cruelty, and barbaric insolence was shown toward that unfortunate people. Such were Hannibal's campaigns during the winter.

58

For a short time after, while the cold continued intolerable, rest was given to the soldiers; and having set out from his winter quarters on the first and uncertain indications of spring, he leads them into Etruria, intending to gain that nation to his side, like the Gauls and Ligurians, either by force or favour. As he was crossing the Apennines, so furious a storm attacked him, that it almost surpassed the horrors of the Alps. When the rain and wind together were driven directly against their faces, they at first halted, because their arms must either be cast away, or striving to advance against the storm they were whirled round by the hurricane, and dashed to the ground: afterwards, when it now stopped their breath, nor suffered them to respire, they sat down for a little, with their backs to the wind. Then indeed the sky resounded with loud thunder, and the lightnings flashed between its terrific peals; all, bereft of sight and hearing, stood torpid with fear. At length, when the rain had spent itself, and the fury of the wind was on that account the more increased, it seemed necessary to pitch the camp in that very place where they had been overtaken by the storm. But this was the beginning of their labours, as it were, afresh; for neither could they spread out nor fix any tent, nor did that which perchance had been put up remain, the wind tearing through and sweeping every thing away: and soon after, when the water raised aloft by the wind had been frozen above the cold summits of the mountains, it poured down such a torrent of snowy hail, that the men, casting away every thing, fell down upon their faces, rather buried under than sheltered by their coverings; and so extreme an intensity of cold succeeded, that when each wished to raise and lift himself from that wretched heap of men and beasts of burden, he was for a long time unable, because their sinews being stiffened by the cold, they had great difficulty in bending their joints. Afterwards, when, by continually moving themselves to and fro, they succeeded in recovering the power of motion, and regained their spirits, and fires began to be kindled in a few places, every helpless man had recourse to the aid of others. They remained as if blockaded for two days in that place. Many men and beasts of burden, and also seven elephants, of those which had remained from the battle fought at the Trebia, were destroyed.

For a short time afterward, while the cold was unbearable, the soldiers got some rest. Setting out from their winter camp at the first uncertain signs of spring, he led them into Etruria, aiming to win that nation over to his side, like he had with the Gauls and Ligurians, either by force or kindness. While crossing the Apennines, a furious storm hit them, surpassing even the horrors of the Alps. As the rain and wind battered their faces, they initially paused, as they had to either drop their weapons or risk being thrown off balance and knocked down by the hurricane. Once the storm took their breath away and left them gasping, they sat down for a moment with their backs to the wind. Then, the sky erupted with loud thunder, and lightning flashed among its terrifying roars; everyone, blinded and deafened by fear, stood frozen. Eventually, when the rain finally stopped, the wind's fury intensified, making it necessary to set up camp right where the storm had caught them. But this marked the fresh start of their struggles; they couldn't spread out or secure any tents, and whatever had been set up was ripped away by the wind. Shortly after, when the wind carried the water up and froze it on the mountain peaks, a torrent of icy hail fell, forcing the men to drop everything and fall face down, more buried than sheltered by their gear. The cold was so intense that when they tried to lift themselves from that miserable pile of men and pack animals, they struggled for a long time because the cold had stiffened their muscles, making it hard to bend their joints. After a while, by moving around constantly, they managed to regain control of their bodies and rallied their spirits; in a few spots, fires began to be lit, and every helpless person sought the help of others. They remained stuck in that place for two days. Many men and pack animals, including seven elephants that had survived the battle at the Trebia, perished.

59

Having descended from the Apennines, he moved his camp back towards Placentia, and having proceeded as far as ten miles, took up his station. On the following day he leads out twelve thousand infantry and five thousand cavalry against the enemy. Nor did Sempronius the consul (for he had now returned from Rome) decline the engagement; and during that day three miles intervened between the two camps. On the following day they fought with amazing courage and various success. At the first onset the Roman power was so superior, that they not only conquered the enemy in the regular battle, but pursued them when driven back quite into their camp, and soon after also assaulted it. Hannibal, having stationed a few to defend the rampart and the gates, and having admitted the rest in close array into the middle of the camp orders them to watch attentively the signal for sallying out. It was now about the ninth hour of the day when the Roman, having fatigued his soldiers to no purpose, after there was no hope of gaining possession of the camp, gave the signal for retreat; which when Hannibal heard, and saw that the attack was slackened, and that they were retreating from the camp, instantly having sent out the cavalry on the right and left against the enemy, he himself in the middle with the main force of the infantry rushed out from the camp. Seldom has there been a combat more furious, and few would have been more remarkable for the loss on both sides, if the day had suffered it to continue for a longer time. Night broke off the battle when raging most from the determined spirit of the combatants. The conflict therefore was more severe than the slaughter: and as it was pretty much a drawn battle, they separated with equal loss. On neither side fell more than six hundred infantry, and half that number of cavalry. But the loss of the Romans was more severe than proportionate to the number that fell, because several of equestrian rank, and five tribunes of the soldiers, and three prefects of the allies were slain. After this battle Hannibal retired to the territory of the Ligurians, and Sempronius to Luca. Two Roman quaestors, Caius Fulvius and Lucius Lucretius, who had been treacherously intercepted, with two military tribunes and five of the equestrian order, mostly sons of senators, are delivered up to Hannibal when coming among the Ligurians, in order that he might feel more convinced that the peace and alliance with them would be binding.

Having come down from the Apennines, he moved his camp back towards Placentia, and after traveling about ten miles, set up his position. The next day, he deployed twelve thousand infantry and five thousand cavalry against the enemy. Sempronius, the consul (who had just returned from Rome), also accepted the challenge. On that day, there were three miles between the two camps. The following day, they fought with incredible bravery and mixed results. Initially, the Roman forces were so dominant that they not only defeated the enemy in the main battle but also chased them back to their camp, which they soon attacked. Hannibal, having stationed a few to guard the rampart and the gates, admitted the rest into the camp in tight formation and instructed them to watch carefully for the signal to charge out. It was around the ninth hour of the day when the Roman, having exhausted his soldiers to no avail and realizing there was no chance to take the camp, signaled for a retreat. When Hannibal heard this and saw that the attack was diminishing and his enemies were pulling back, he quickly sent out cavalry on both flanks against them while he led the main infantry force out from the camp. Seldom has there been a battle more intense, and few could claim a higher casualty count on both sides, if the day had allowed it to last longer. The night ended the fight while it was at its fiercest, driven by the determination of those involved. The conflict was harsher than the death toll suggested, and since it was essentially a stalemate, they parted with equal losses. No more than six hundred infantry fell on either side, and half that number of cavalry. However, the Roman losses were more significant than the numbers might indicate because several officers, five tribunes, and three prefects of allied forces were killed. After this battle, Hannibal withdrew to the territory of the Ligurians, and Sempronius went to Luca. Two Roman quaestors, Caius Fulvius and Lucius Lucretius, who had been treacherously captured, along with two military tribunes and five from the equestrian class, mostly sons of senators, were handed over to Hannibal when he was among the Ligurians, to ensure that he would feel more confident about the peace and alliance with them.

60

While these things are transacting in Italy, Cneius Cornelius Scipio having been sent into Spain with a fleet and army, when, setting out from the mouth of the Rhone, and sailing past the Pyrenaean mountains, he had moored his fleet at Emporiae, having there landed his army, and beginning with the Lacetani, he brought the whole coast, as far as the river Iberus, under the Roman dominion, partly by renewing the old, and partly by forming new alliances. The reputation for clemency, acquired by these means, had influence not only with the maritime states, but now also with the more savage tribes in the inland and mountainous districts; nor was peace only effected with them, but also an alliance of arms, and several fine cohorts of auxiliaries were levied from their numbers. The country on this side of the Iberus was the province of Hanno, whom Hannibal had left to defend that region. He, therefore, judging that he ought to make opposition, before every thing was alienated from him, having pitched his camp in sight of the enemy, led out his forces in battle-array; nor did it appear to the Roman, that the engagement ought to be deferred, as he knew that he must fight with Hanno and Hasdrubal, and wished rather to contend against each of them separately, than against both together. The conflict did not prove one of great difficulty; six thousand of the enemy were slain, and two thousand made prisoners, together with the guard of the camp; for both the camp was stormed, and the general himself, with several of the chief officers, taken; and Scissis, a town near the camp, was also carried by assault. But the spoil of this town consisted of things of small value, such as the household furniture used by barbarians and slaves that were worth little. The camp enriched the soldiers; almost all the valuable effects, not only of that army which was conquered, but of that which was serving with Hannibal in Italy, having been left on this side the Pyrenees, that the baggage might not be cumbrous to those who conveyed it.

While all this was happening in Italy, Cneius Cornelius Scipio was sent to Spain with a fleet and army. After leaving the mouth of the Rhone and sailing past the Pyrenees, he docked his fleet at Emporiae, where he disembarked his troops. Starting with the Lacetani, he brought the entire coastline up to the Iberus River under Roman control, partly by reestablishing old alliances and partly by creating new ones. His reputation for mercy helped him win over not only the coastal states but also the more aggressive tribes in the inland and mountainous areas. He achieved peace with them and formed military alliances, recruiting several strong auxiliary troops from their ranks. The territory on this side of the Iberus belonged to Hanno, whom Hannibal had left to defend that region. Realizing he needed to act before he lost everything, Hanno set up camp within sight of the enemy and arranged his forces for battle. The Roman leader understood that he had to fight Hanno and Hasdrubal and preferred to take them on one at a time rather than facing both at once. The battle turned out to be relatively easy; six thousand enemy troops were killed, and two thousand were captured, including the camp's guard. The camp was stormed, and the general and several top officers were taken prisoner. The nearby town of Scissis was also captured. However, the loot from the town was mostly worthless items like the household furniture of barbarians and low-value slaves. The camp itself brought wealth to the soldiers; nearly all the valuable possessions, not only from the defeated army but also from Hannibal's forces in Italy, had been left behind on this side of the Pyrenees to lighten the load for those transporting them.

61

Before any certain news of this disaster arrived, Hasdrubal, having passed the Iberus with eight thousand foot and a thousand horse, intending to meet the Romans on their first approach, after he heard of the ruin of their affairs at Scissis, and the loss of the camp, turned his route towards the sea. Not far from Tarraco, having despatched his cavalry in various directions, he drove to their ships, with great slaughter, and greater route, the soldiers belonging to the fleet and the mariners, while scattered and wandering through the fields (for it is usually the case that success produces negligence), but not daring to remain longer in that quarter, lest he should be surprised by Scipio, he withdrew to the other side of the Iberus. And Scipio, having quickly brought up his army on the report of fresh enemies, after punishing a few captains of ships and leaving a moderate garrison at Tarraco, returned with his fleet to Emporiae. He had scarcely departed, when Hasdrubal came up, and having instigated to a revolt the state of the Ilergetes, which had given hostages to Scipio, he lays waste, with the youth of that very people, the lands of the faithful allies of the Romans. Scipio being thereupon roused from his winter quarters, Hasdrubal again retires from in all the country on this side the Iberus. Scipio, when with a hostile army he had invaded the state of the Ilergetes, forsaken by the author of their revolt, and having driven them all into Athanagia, which was the capital of that nation laid siege to the city; and within a few days, having imposed the delivery of more hostages than before, and also fined the Ilergetes in a sum of money, he received them back into his authority and dominion. He then proceeded against the Ausetani near the Iberus, who were also the allies of the Carthaginians; and having laid siege to their city, he cut off by an ambuscade the Lacetani, while bringing assistance by night to their neighbours, having attacked them at a small distance from the city, as they were designing to enter it. As many as twelve thousand were slain; the rest, nearly all without their arms, escaped home, by dispersing through the country in every direction. Nor did any thing else but the winter, which was unfavourable to the besiegers, secure the besieged. The blockade continued for thirty days, during which the snow scarce ever lay less deep than four feet; and it had covered to such a degree the sheds and mantelets of the Romans, that it alone served as a defence when fire was frequently thrown on them by the enemy. At last, when Amusitus, their leader, had fled to Hasdrubal, they are surrendered, on condition of paying twenty talents of silver. They then returned into winter quarters at Tarraco.

Before any clear news of this disaster arrived, Hasdrubal, having crossed the Iberus with eight thousand infantry and one thousand cavalry, intending to meet the Romans at their first approach, turned his route toward the sea after hearing about their defeat at Scissis and the loss of the camp. Not far from Tarraco, after sending his cavalry in different directions, he attacked the fleet's soldiers and the sailors, inflicting heavy casualties as they scattered and wandered through the fields (since success often leads to carelessness). However, not wanting to stay in that area too long for fear of being taken by surprise by Scipio, he retreated to the other side of the Iberus. Scipio, quickly gathering his army upon hearing of new enemies, punished a few ship captains and left a moderate garrison at Tarraco before returning with his fleet to Emporiae. He had barely left when Hasdrubal arrived and incited a revolt among the Ilergetes, who had given hostages to Scipio, devastating the lands of the loyal Roman allies with the young men of that very people. Scipio, roused from his winter quarters, saw Hasdrubal retreating from the territory on this side of the Iberus. Scipio, with his hostile army, invaded the land of the Ilergetes, who were abandoned by their revolt's instigator, and besieged their capital, Athanagia. Within a few days, he demanded more hostages than before and fined the Ilergetes a sum of money, bringing them back under his authority and control. He then moved against the Ausetani near the Iberus, who were also allies of the Carthaginians. After laying siege to their city, he ambushed the Lacetani while they were bringing help to their neighbors, attacking them just outside the city as they tried to enter. Around twelve thousand were killed; nearly all the rest, unarmed, escaped home by scattering throughout the countryside. It was just the winter, which was harsh for the besiegers, that protected the besieged. The blockade lasted thirty days, during which the snow rarely lay less than four feet deep; it covered the Roman sheds and mantlets so much that it alone helped defend them when the enemy frequently threw fire at them. Finally, when their leader Amusitus fled to Hasdrubal, they surrendered on the condition of paying twenty talents of silver. They then returned to winter quarters at Tarraco.

62

At Rome during this winter many prodigies either occurred about the city, or, as usually happens when the minds of men are once inclined to superstition, many were reported and readily believed; among which it was said that an infant of good family, only six months old, had called out "Io triumphe" in the herb market: that in the cattle market an ox had of his own accord ascended to the third story, and that thence, being frightened by the noise of the inhabitants, had flung himself down; that the appearance of ships had been brightly visible in the sky, and that the temple of Hope in the herb market had been struck by lightning; that the spear at Lanuvium had shaken itself; that a crow had flown down into the temple of Juno and alighted on the very couch; that in the territory of Amiternum figures resembling men dressed in white raiment had been seen in several places at a distance, but had not come close to any one; that in Picenum it had rained stones; that at Caere the tablets for divination had been lessened in size; and that in Gaul a wolf had snatched out the sword from the scabbard of a soldier on guard, and carried it off. On account of the other prodigies the decemvirs were ordered to consult the books; but on account of its having rained stones in Picenum the festival of nine days was proclaimed, and almost all the state was occupied in expiating the rest, from time to time. First of all the city was purified, and victims of the greater kind were sacrificed to those gods to whom they were directed to be offered; and a gift of forty pounds' weight of gold was carried to the temple of Juno at Lanuvium; and the matrons dedicated a brazen statue to Juno on the Aventine; and a lectisternium was ordered at Caere, where the tablets for divination had diminished; and a supplication to Fortune at Algidum; at Rome also a lectisternium was ordered to Youth, and a supplication at the temple of Hercules, first by individuals named and afterwards by the whole people at all the shrines; five greater victims were offered to Genius; and Caius Atilius Serranus the praetor was ordered to make certain vows if the republic should remain in the same state for ten years. These things, thus expiated and vowed according to the Sibylline books, relieved, in a great degree, the public mind from superstitious fears.

During that winter in Rome, many strange events either happened around the city or, as often occurs when people are feeling superstitious, were reported and easily believed. For example, it was claimed that a six-month-old baby from a good family shouted "Io triumphe" in the herb market. There was also an account of an ox that on its own climbed to the third story of a building and then jumped down, frightened by the noise from the people. Additionally, ships were said to have appeared brightly in the sky, and lightning struck the temple of Hope in the herb market. A spear at Lanuvium reportedly shook by itself, a crow flew into the temple of Juno and landed on the couch, and in the territory of Amiternum, figures resembling men dressed in white were seen at a distance but didn’t approach anyone. In Picenum, it rained stones; in Caere, the divination tablets had shrunk in size; and in Gaul, a wolf snatched a sword from a soldier's scabbard and ran off. Because of these occurrences, the decemvirs were instructed to consult the sacred texts, and due to the stone rain in Picenum, a nine-day festival was announced, with most of the state engaged in purification rituals. The city was first cleansed, and large sacrifices were made to the gods designated in the rituals; a gift of forty pounds of gold was sent to the temple of Juno in Lanuvium; the matrons dedicated a bronze statue to Juno on the Aventine; a lectisternium was held in Caere, where the divination tablets had shrunk; a prayer to Fortune was offered at Algidum; in Rome, a lectisternium was also held for Youth, and a prayer at the temple of Hercules was conducted, first by named individuals and then by the entire population at all the shrines. Five large sacrifices were offered to Genius; and Caius Atilius Serranus, the praetor, was instructed to make certain vows if the republic remained stable for ten years. These actions, carried out as prescribed by the Sibylline texts, greatly eased the public's superstitious fears.

63

Flaminius, one of the consuls elect, to whom the legions which were wintering at Placentia had fallen by lot, sent an edict and letter to the consul, desiring that those forces should be ready in camp at Ariminum on the ides of March. He had a design to enter on the consulship in his province, recollecting his old contests with the fathers, which he had waged with them when tribune of the people, and afterwards when consul, first about his election to the office, which was annulled, and then about a triumph. He was also odious to the fathers on account of a new law which Quintus Claudius, tribune of the people, had carried against the senate, Caius Flaminius alone of that body assisting him, that no senator, or he who had been father of a senator, should possess a ship fit for sea service, containing more than three hundred amphorae. This size was considered sufficient for conveying the produce of their lands: all traffic appeared unbecoming a senator. This contest, maintained with the warmest opposition, procured the hatred of the nobility to Flaminius, the advocate of the law; but the favour of the people, and afterwards a second consulship. For these reasons, thinking that they would detain him in the city by falsifying the auspices, by the delay of the Latin festival, and other hinderances to which a consul was liable, he pretended a journey, and, while yet in a private capacity, departed secretly to his province. This proceeding, when it was made public, excited new and additional anger in the senators, who were before irritated against him. They said, "That Caius Flaminius waged war not only with the senate, but now with the immortal gods; that having been formerly made consul without the proper auspices, he had disobeyed both gods and men recalling him from the very field of battle; and now, through consciousness of their having been dishonoured, had shunned the Capitol and the customary offering of vows, that he might not on the day of entering his office approach the temple of Jupiter, the best and greatest of gods; he might not see and consult the senate, himself hated by it, as it was hateful to him alone; that he might not proclaim the Latin festival, or perform on the Alban mount the customary rights to Jupiter Latiaris; that he might not, under the direction of the auspices, go up to the Capitol to recite his vows, and thence, attended by the lictors, proceed to his province in the garb of a general; but that he had set off, like some camp boy, without his insignia, without the lictors, in secrecy and stealth, just as if he had been quitting his country to go into banishment; as if forsooth he would enter his office more consistently with the dignity of the consul at Ariminum than Rome, and assume the robe of office in a public inn better than before his own household gods."--it was unanimously resolved that he, should be recalled and brought back, and be constrained to perform in person every duty to gods and men before he went to the army and the province. Quintus Terentius and Marcus Antistius having set out on this embassy, (for it was decreed that ambassadors should be sent,) prevailed with him in no degree more than the letter sent by the senate in his former consulship. A few days after he entered on his office, and as he was sacrificing a calf, after being struck, having broken away from the hands of the ministers, sprinkled several of the bystanders with its blood. Flight and disorder ensued, to a still greater degree at a distance among those who were ignorant what was the cause of the alarm. This circumstance was regarded by most persons as an omen of great terror. Having then received two legions from Sempronius, the consul of the former year, and two from Caius Atilius, the praetor, the army began to be led into Etruria, through the passes of the Apennines.

Flaminius, one of the elected consuls, who was assigned the legions wintering in Placentia, sent an edict and letter to the consul, asking that those forces be ready in camp at Ariminum on the Ides of March. He planned to start his term in his province, recalling his past conflicts with the senators when he was a tribune of the people, and later as consul, first over his annulled election and then about a triumph. He was also disliked by the senators because of a new law that Quintus Claudius, a tribune of the people, had pushed through against the senate, with only Caius Flaminius supporting him, which stated that no senator, or anyone who had been the father of a senator, could own a ship for sea service that held more than three hundred amphorae. This amount was seen as enough for transporting their agricultural produce: any kind of trading was seen as inappropriate for a senator. This fierce opposition led to the nobility's hatred for Flaminius, the law's supporter, but he gained the favor of the people and later a second term as consul. For these reasons, believing that they would keep him in the city by messing with the omens, delaying the Latin festival, and other obstacles that could affect a consul, he pretended to travel and secretly departed for his province while still a private citizen. Once this became public knowledge, it sparked even more anger among the senators, who were already upset with him. They said that Caius Flaminius was waging war not only against the senate but also against the immortal gods; that having been made consul without the proper omens, he had disobeyed both the gods and people who wanted him back from the battlefield; and now, feeling dishonored, he had avoided the Capitol and the usual offerings so he wouldn’t have to approach the temple of Jupiter, the greatest of the gods, on the day he took office; that he didn’t want to see and consult the senate, which he hated and which hated him in return; that he didn’t want to declare the Latin festival, or perform the customary rites on the Alban Mount to Jupiter Latiaris; that he wouldn’t, following the auspices, go to the Capitol to present his vows, and from there, with his lictors, head to his province in military attire; but instead, he had left like a camp boy, without his insignia or lictors, sneaking away as if he were fleeing the country into exile; as if he believed it would be more proper to take office in Ariminum than in Rome, and to wear the consul's robe at a public inn rather than before his household gods." It was unanimously decided that he should be recalled and required to perform all his duties to the gods and people before heading to the army and province. Quintus Terentius and Marcus Antistius were sent on this mission (as it was determined that ambassadors should be sent) but had no more success with him than the letter the senate had sent during his previous consulship. A few days after he assumed office, while sacrificing a calf, he was struck and, breaking free from the attendants, splattered several bystanders with its blood. Panic and chaos erupted even more among those at a distance who didn't know what had caused the commotion. Most considered this event an ominous sign of great fear. Afterward, he received two legions from Sempronius, the consul from the previous year, and two from Caius Atilius, the praetor, and began leading the army into Etruria through the Apennine passes.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXII.
B.C. 217-216


Hannibal, after an uninterrupted march of four days and three nights, arrives in Etruria, through the marshes, in which he lost an eye. Caius Flaminius, the consul, an inconsiderate man, having gone forth in opposition to the omens, dug up the standards which could not otherwise be raised, and been thrown from his horse immediately after he had mounted, is insnared by Hannibal, and cut off by his army near the Thrasimene lake. Three thousand who had escaped are placed in chains by Hannibal, in violation of pledges given. Distress occasioned in Rome by the intelligence. The Sibylline books consulted, and a sacred spring decreed. Fabius Maximus sent as dictator against Hannibal, whom he frustrates by caution and delay. Marcus Minucius, the master of the horse, a rash and impetuous man, inveighs against the caution of Fabius, and obtains an equality of command with him. The army is divided between them, and Minucius engaging Hannibal in an unfavourable position, is reduced to the extremity of danger, and is rescued by the dictator, and places himself under his authority. Hannibal, after ravaging Campania, is shut up by Fabius in a valley near the town of Casilinum, but escapes by night, putting to flight the Romans on guard by oxen with lighted faggots attached to their horns. Hannibal attempts to excite a suspicion of the fidelity of Fabius by sparing his farm while ravaging with fire the whole country around it. Aemilius Paulus and Terentius Varro are routed at Cannae, and forty thousand men slain, among whom were Paulus the consul, eighty senators, and thirty who had served the office of consul, praetor, or edile. A design projected by some noble youths of quitting Italy in despair after this calamity, is intrepidly quashed by Publius Cornelius Scipio, a military tribune, afterwards surnamed Africanus. Successes in Spain, eight thousand slaves are enlisted by the Romans, they refuse to ransom the captives, they go out in a body to meet Varro, and thank him for not having despaired of the commonwealth.

       *        *        *        *        *

1

Spring was now at hand, when Hannibal quitted his winter quarters, having both attempted in vain to cross the Apennines, from the intolerable cold, and having remained with great danger and alarm. The Gauls, whom the hope of plunder and spoil had collected, when, instead of being themselves engaged in carrying and driving away booty from the lands of others, they saw their own lands made the seat of war and burdened by the wintering of the armies of both forces, turned their hatred back again from the Romans to Hannibal; and though plots were frequently concerted against him by their chieftains, he was preserved by the treachery they manifested towards each other; disclosing their conspiracy with the same inconstancy with which they had conspired; and by changing sometimes his dress, at other times the fashion of his hair, he protected himself from treachery by deception. However, this fear was the cause of his more speedily quitting his winter quarters. Meanwhile Cneius Servilius, the consul, entered upon his office at Rome, on the ides of March. There, when he had consulted the senate on the state of the republic in general, the indignation against Flaminius was rekindled. They said "that they had created indeed two consuls, that they had but one; for what regular authority had the other, or what auspices? That their magistrates took these with them from home, from the tutelar deities of themselves and the state, after the celebration of the Latin holidays; the sacrifice upon the mountain being completed, and the vows duly offered up in the Capitol: that neither could an unofficial individual take the auspices, nor could one who had gone from home without them, take them new, and for the first time, in a foreign soil." Prodigies announced from many places at the same time, augmented the terror: in Sicily, that several darts belonging to the soldiers had taken fire; and in Sardinia, that the staff of a horseman, who was going his rounds upon a wall, took fire as he held it in his hand; that the shores had blazed with frequent fires; that two shields had sweated blood at Praeneste; that redhot stones had fallen from the heavens at Arpi; that shields were seen in the heavens, and the sun fighting with the moon, at Capena; that two moons rose in the day-time; that the waters of Caere had flowed mixed with blood; and that even the fountain of Hercules had flowed sprinkled with spots of blood. In the territory of Antium, that bloody ears of corn had fallen into the basket as they were reaping. At Falerii, that the heavens appeared cleft as if with a great chasm; and, that where it had opened, a vast light had shone forth; that the prophetic tablets had spontaneously become less; and that one had fallen out thus inscribed, "Mars shakes his spear." During the same time, that the statue of Mars at Rome, on the Appian way, had sweated at the sight of images of wolves. At Capua that there had been the appearance of the heavens being on fire, and of the moon as falling amidst rain. After these, credence was given to prodigies of less magnitude: that the goats of certain persons had borne wool; that a hen had changed herself into a cock; and a cock into a hen: these things having been laid before the senate as reported, the authors being conducted into the senate-house, the consul took the sense of the fathers on religious affairs. It was decreed that those prodigies should be expiated, partly with full-grown, partly with sucking victims; and that a supplication should be made at every shrine for the space of three days; that the other things should be done accordingly as the gods should declare in their oracles to be agreeable to their will when the decemviri had examined the books. By the advice of the decemviri it was decreed, first, that a golden thunderbolt of fifty pounds' weight should be made as an offering to Jupiter; that offerings of silver should be presented to Juno and Minerva; that sacrifices of full-grown victims should be offered to Juno Regina on the Aventine; and to Juno Sospita at Lanuvium; that the matrons, contributing as much money as might be convenient to each, should carry it to the Aventine, as a present to Juno Regina; and that a lectisternium should be celebrated. Moreover, that the very freed-women should, according to their means, contribute money from which a present might be made to Feronia. When these things were done, the decemviri sacrificed with the larger victims in the forum at Ardea. Lastly, it being now the month of December, a sacrifice was made at the temple of Saturn at Rome, and a lectisternium ordered, in which senators prepared the couch and a public banquet. Proclamation was made through the city, that the Saturnalia should be kept for a day and a night; and the people were commanded to account that day as a holiday, and observe it for ever.

Spring was now approaching when Hannibal left his winter camp after having tried unsuccessfully to cross the Apennines due to the unbearable cold, and having stayed there with significant danger and distress. The Gauls, who had gathered in hopes of raiding and plundering, found themselves facing war in their own lands rather than taking spoils from others. This led them to turn their anger from the Romans back to Hannibal. Although their leaders frequently plotted against him, Hannibal was saved by their mutual treachery; they revealed their conspiracies with the same instability with which they had made them. By changing his clothing and hairstyles, he shielded himself from betrayal through trickery. However, this fear prompted him to leave his winter quarters sooner than planned. Meanwhile, Cneius Servilius, the consul, began his term in Rome on the Ides of March. After consulting the senate about the state of the republic, anger against Flaminius flared up again. They said, "They had indeed appointed two consuls, but they only had one; for what legitimate authority or auspices did the other have? Their officials received these from home, from their own protective deities and the state, after celebrating the Latin festivals; after completing the sacrifice on the mountain, and with their vows duly offered at the Capitol. Neither an unofficial person nor someone who left home without them could receive auspices for the first time on foreign soil." Prodigies reported from many places added to the fear: in Sicily, several soldiers' darts caught fire; in Sardinia, the staff of a horseman patrolling a wall ignited as he held it; the shores were ablaze with frequent fires; two shields sweated blood at Praeneste; red-hot stones fell from the sky at Arpi; shields appeared in the sky, and the sun was seen battling the moon at Capena; two moons rose in the daytime; the waters of Caere mixed with blood; and even the fountain of Hercules flowed with spots of blood. In the region of Antium, bloody ears of corn fell into the basket during the harvest. At Falerii, the sky appeared to split open, with a great light shining where it opened; prophetic tablets shrank spontaneously, and one fell out inscribed, "Mars shakes his spear." During this time, the statue of Mars on the Appian Way in Rome sweated at the sight of wolf images. At Capua, the heavens appeared to be on fire, and the moon seemed to fall amidst rain. After these, less significant prodigies were also believed, like certain goats producing wool, a hen transforming into a rooster, and a rooster becoming a hen. These reports were presented to the senate, and the individuals who reported them were brought into the senate chamber. The consul sought the opinions of the fathers regarding religious matters. It was decreed that these prodigies should be atoned for, partly with adult sacrifices and partly with suckling victims; and that there should be a supplication at every shrine for three days; that other actions should be taken according to what the gods would reveal through their oracles once the decemviri examined the sacred texts. Following the advice of the decemviri, it was decided that a golden thunderbolt weighing fifty pounds should be created as an offering to Jupiter; that silver offerings should be given to Juno and Minerva; that adult sacrifices should be made to Juno Regina on the Aventine and to Juno Sospita at Lanuvium; that matrons should contribute money as they could to be taken to the Aventine as a gift for Juno Regina; and that a lectisternium should be celebrated. Furthermore, even freed women should contribute money according to their means for a gift to Feronia. Once these actions were completed, the decemviri sacrificed larger victims in the forum at Ardea. Finally, in December, a sacrifice was performed at the temple of Saturn in Rome, and a lectisternium was ordered, where senators set up the couch and prepared a public feast. An announcement was made throughout the city that the Saturnalia would be celebrated for a day and a night; and the people were instructed to regard that day as a holiday and to observe it forever.

2

While the consul employs himself at Rome in appeasing the gods and holding the levy, Hannibal, setting out from his winter quarters, because it was reported that the consul Flaminius had now arrived at Arretium, although a longer but more commodious route was pointed out to him, takes the nearer road through a marsh where the Arno had, more than usual, overflowed its banks. He ordered the Spaniards and Africans (in these lay the strength of his veteran army) to lead, their own baggage being intermixed with them, lest, being compelled to halt any where, they should want what might be necessary for their use: the Gauls he ordered to go next, that they might form the middle of the marching body; the cavalry to march in the rear: next, Mago with the light-armed Numidians to keep the army together, particularly coercing the Gauls, if, fatigued with exertion and the length of the march, as that nation is wanting in vigour for such exertions, they should fall away or halt. The van still followed the standards wherever the guides did but lead them, through the exceeding deep and almost fathomless eddies of the river, nearly swallowed up in mud, and plunging themselves in. The Gauls could neither support themselves when fallen, nor raise themselves from the eddies. Nor did they sustain their bodies with spirit, nor their minds with hope; some scarce dragging on their wearied limbs; others dying where they had once fallen, their spirits being subdued with fatigue, among the beasts which themselves also lay prostrate in every place. But chiefly watching wore them out, endured now for four days and three nights. When, the water covering every place, not a dry spot could be found where they might stretch their weary bodies, they laid themselves down upon their baggage, thrown in heaps into the waters. Piles of beasts, which lay every where through the whole route, afforded a necessary bed for temporary repose to those seeking any place which was not under water. Hannibal himself, riding on the only remaining elephant, to be the higher from the water, contracted a disorder in his eyes, at first from the unwholesomeness of the vernal air, which is attended with transitions from heat to cold; and at length from watching, nocturnal damps, the marshy atmosphere disordering his head, and because he had neither opportunity nor leisure for remedies, loses one of them.

While the consul is busy in Rome appeasing the gods and organizing the military levy, Hannibal sets out from his winter quarters. He heard that Consul Flaminius has now arrived at Arretium. Although there was a longer but easier route suggested to him, he takes the shorter path through a marsh where the Arno has overflowed its banks even more than usual. He instructed the Spaniards and Africans—who made up the core of his veteran army—to lead the way, mixing their own baggage with them to ensure they had necessary supplies in case they had to stop. He ordered the Gauls to march next, placing them in the middle of the formation, while the cavalry followed behind. Mago, with the light-armed Numidians, was tasked with keeping the army together, especially urging the Gauls to keep moving, as they often needed motivation due to their fatigue from the long march. The front ranks followed the standards as the guides led them through the deep and nearly bottomless eddies of the river, struggling and sinking into the mud. The Gauls found it hard to support themselves when they fell, nor could they get back up from the water. They lacked energy and hope; some could barely drag their tired limbs along, while others died where they had collapsed, their spirits broken by exhaustion, among the animals that were also lying flat everywhere. What wore them out the most was the constant watch, which lasted for four days and three nights. With water covering everything, there was no dry spot to rest their weary bodies, so they laid down on their baggage, piled high in the water. The piles of animals scattered throughout the road provided a necessary makeshift bed for anyone seeking out a spot that wasn't submerged. Hannibal himself, riding the last remaining elephant to stay higher above the water, developed an eye condition, initially caused by the unhealthy spring air with its sudden shifts from heat to cold, and later from sleeplessness, damp nights, and the marshy atmosphere affecting his head. He ended up losing one of his eyes due to the lack of time or opportunity for treatment.

3

Many men and cattle having been lost thus wretchedly, when at length he had emerged from the marshes, he pitched his camp as soon as he could on dry ground. And here he received information, through the scouts sent in advance, that the Roman army was round the walls of Arretium. Next the plans and temper of the consul, the situation of the country, the roads, the sources from which provisions might be obtained, and whatever else it was useful to know; all these things he ascertained by the most diligent inquiry. The country was among the most fertile of Italy, the plain of Etruria, between Faesulae and Arretium, abundant in its supply of corn, cattle, and every other requisite. The consul was haughty from his former consulship, and felt no proper degree of reverence not only for the laws and the majesty of the fathers, but even for the gods. This temerity, inherent in his nature, fortune had fostered by a career of prosperity and success in civil and military affairs. Thus it was sufficiently evident that, heedless of gods and men, he would act in all cases with presumption and precipitation; and, that he might fall the more readily into the errors natural to him, the Carthaginian begins to fret and irritate him; and leaving the enemy on his left, he takes the road to Faesulae, and marching through the centre of Etruria, with intent to plunder, he exhibits to the consul, in the distance, the greatest devastation he could with fires and slaughters. Flaminius, who would not have rested even if the enemy had remained quiet; then, indeed, when he saw the property of the allies driven and carried away almost before his eyes, considering that it reflected disgrace upon him that the Carthaginian now roaming at large through the heart of Italy, and marching without resistance to storm the very walls of Rome, though every other person in the council advised safe rather than showy measures, urging that he should wait for his colleague, in order that, joining their armies, they might carry on the war with united courage and counsels; and that, meanwhile, the enemy should be prevented from his unrestrained freedom in plundering by the cavalry and the light-armed auxiliaries; in a fury hurried out of the council, and at once gave out the signal for marching and for battle. "Nay, rather," says he, "let him be before the walls of Arretium, for here is our country, here our household gods. Let Hannibal, slipping through our fingers, waste Italy through and through; and, ravaging and burning every thing, let him arrive at the walls of Rome; let us move hence till the fathers shall have summoned Flaminius from Arretium, as they did Camillus of old from Veii." While reproaching them thus, and in the act of ordering the standards to be speedily pulled up, when he had mounted upon his horse, the animal fell suddenly, and threw the unseated consul over his head. All the bystanders being alarmed at this as an unhappy omen in the commencement of the affair, in addition word is brought, that the standard could not be pulled up, though, the standard-bearer strove with all his force. Flaminius, turning to the messenger, says, "Do you bring, too, letters from the senate, forbidding me to act. Go, tell them to dig up the standard, if, through fear, their hands are so benumbed that they cannot pluck it up." Then the army began to march; the chief officers, besides that they dissented from the plan, being terrified by the twofold prodigy; while the soldiery in general were elated by the confidence of their leader, since they regarded merely the hope he entertained, and not the reasons of the hope.

Many men and cattle had been lost in this miserable way, and when he finally got out of the marshes, he set up camp as soon as he could find dry ground. Here, he learned from scouts that the Roman army was surrounding the walls of Arretium. He also figured out the consul’s plans and mindset, the landscape, the roads, the sources for supplies, and anything else useful to know through thorough investigation. The land was some of the most fertile in Italy, the Etrurian plain between Faesulae and Arretium, rich in corn, cattle, and everything else needed. The consul, proud from his previous consulship, showed little respect for the laws, the dignity of his elders, or even the gods. This arrogance, part of his nature, had been encouraged by a string of success in both civil and military affairs. It was clear that, disregarding gods and men, he would act with haughtiness and impulsiveness; to lead him into his typical mistakes, the Carthaginian began to annoy him. Leaving the enemy to his left, he took the route to Faesulae and marched through the heart of Etruria, intent on plundering, causing as much destruction as possible with fires and killings. Flaminius, who wouldn’t have rested even if the enemy had stayed still, was infuriated to see his allies’ property being stolen right in front of him. It was disgraceful that the Carthaginian was freely roaming through the middle of Italy, moving without any opposition to attack the very walls of Rome, even though everyone else in the council recommended safer, more cautious actions, suggesting he wait for his colleague so they could combine their armies and fight bravely together. They also advised that the enemy be kept from plundering by cavalry and light-armed allies, but in a rage, he stormed out of the council and immediately signaled for marching and battle. "No," he said, "let him be at the walls of Arretium; this is our homeland, our household gods are here. Let Hannibal, slipping through our fingers, ravage Italy completely; let him destroy everything and reach the walls of Rome. Let us move out until the elders summon Flaminius from Arretium, just like they did Camillus from Veii." As he berated them and ordered the standards to be raised quickly, he mounted his horse, but the horse suddenly fell, tossing the unseated consul off its back. All the onlookers were alarmed, seeing this as an ominous sign for the start of the battle. To make matters worse, word came that the standard couldn't be raised despite the standard-bearer’s best efforts. Flaminius turned to the messenger, saying, "Are you also bringing letters from the senate telling me to hold back? Go and tell them to dig up the standard if they’re so afraid that their hands are too stiff to lift it." Then the army began to march. The senior officers, fearful of the two unsettling signs, disagreed with the plan. Meanwhile, the soldiers, motivated by their leader’s confidence, focused solely on the hope he held, ignoring the reasons for concern.

4

Hannibal lays waste the country between the city Cortona and the lake Trasimenus, with all the devastation of war, the more to exasperate the enemy to revenge the injuries inflicted on his allies. They had now reached a place formed by nature for an ambuscade, where the Trasimenus comes nearest to the mountains of Cortona. A very narrow passage only intervenes, as though room enough just for that purpose had been left designedly; after that a somewhat wider plain opens itself, and then some hills rise up. On these he pitches his camp, in full view, where he himself with his Spaniards and Africans only might be posted. The Baliares and his other light troops he leads round the mountains; his cavalry he posts at the very entrance of the defile, some eminences conveniently concealing them; in order that when the Romans had entered, the cavalry advancing, every place might be enclosed by the lake and the mountains. Flaminius, passing the defiles before it was quite daylight, without reconnoitering, though he had arrived at the lake the preceding day at sunset, when the troops began to be spread into the wider plain, saw that part only of the enemy which was opposite to him; the ambuscade in his rear and overhead escaped his notice. And when the Carthaginian had his enemy enclosed by the lake and mountains, and surrounded by his troops, he gives the signal to all to make a simultaneous charge; and each running down the nearest way, the suddenness and unexpectedness of the event was increased to the Romans by a mist rising from the lake, which had settled thicker on the plain than on the mountains; and thus the troops of the enemy ran down from the various eminences, sufficiently well discerning each other, and therefore with the greater regularity. A shout being raised on all sides, the Roman found himself surrounded before he could well see the enemy; and the attack on the front and flank had commenced ere his line could be well formed, his arms prepared for action, or his swords unsheathed.

Hannibal devastates the area between the city of Cortona and Lake Trasimeno, causing widespread destruction to provoke the enemy into avenging the harm done to his allies. They arrive at a location that nature has shaped for an ambush, where the river Trasimeno comes closest to the mountains of Cortona. There is only a very narrow passage, almost as if it was deliberately left for that purpose; beyond that, a somewhat larger plain opens up, followed by a few hills. He sets up his camp there, out in the open, where he and his Spaniards and Africans can be stationed. He leads the Balearic slingers and his other light troops around the mountains; he positions his cavalry right at the entrance of the passage, with some higher ground conveniently hiding them. This way, when the Romans entered, the cavalry could advance, trapping them from all sides by the lake and the mountains. Flaminius, moving through the pass before dawn, failed to scout the area, even though he had arrived at the lake the previous evening at sunset. As his troops began to spread across the broader plain, he only noticed the part of the enemy directly in front of him; he overlooked the ambush behind and above him. Once the Carthaginian successfully cornered his enemy against the lake and the mountains, he signaled for a simultaneous charge. Each troop rushed down the closest path, and the element of surprise was heightened for the Romans by a fog rising from the lake, which settled thicker on the plain than on the mountains. Thus, the enemy troops descended from various heights, easily recognizing each other and acting more cohesively. A shout erupted from all sides, and the Romans found themselves surrounded before they could properly see the enemy. The attack on their front and flanks began before their formation could stabilize, their weapons readied, or their swords drawn.

5

The consul, while all were panic-struck, himself sufficiently undaunted though in so perilous a case, marshals, as well as the time and place permitted, the lines which were thrown into confusion by each man's turning himself towards the various shouts; and wherever he could approach or be heard exhorts them, and bids them stand and fight: for that they could not escape thence by vows and prayers to the gods but by exertion and valour; that a way was sometimes opened by the sword through the midst of marshalled armies, and that generally the less the fear the less the danger. However, from the noise and tumult, neither his advice nor command could be caught; and so far were the soldiers from knowing their own standards, and ranks, and position, that they had scarce sufficient courage to take up arms and make them ready for battle; and certain of them were surprised before they could prepare them, being burdened rather than protected by them; while in so great darkness there was more use of ears than of eyes. They turned their faces and eyes in every direction towards the groans of the wounded, the sounds of blows upon the body or arms, and the mingled clamours of the menacing and the affrighted. Some, as they were making their escape, were stopped, having encountered a body of men engaged in fight; and bands of fugitives returning to the battle, diverted others. After charges had been attempted unsuccessfully in every direction, and on their flanks the mountains and the lake, on the front and rear the lines of the enemy enclosed them, when it was evident that there was no hope of safety but in the right hand and the sword; then each man became to himself a leader, and encourager to action; and an entirely new contest arose, not a regular line, with principes, hastati, and triarii; nor of such a sort as that the vanguard should fight before the standards, and the rest of the troops behind them; nor such that each soldier should be in his own legion, cohort, or company: chance collects them into bands; and each man's own will assigned to him his post, whether to fight in front or rear; and so great was the ardour of the conflict, so intent were their minds upon the battle, that not one of the combatants felt an earthquake which threw down large portions of many of the cities of Italy, turned rivers from their rapid courses, carried the sea up into rivers, and levelled mountains with a tremendous crash.

The consul, while everyone else was in a panic, stayed remarkably composed even in such a perilous situation. He organized the disoriented troops as best as the circumstances allowed, guiding them despite the chaos caused by everyone reacting to the various cries around them. Wherever he could get close enough to be heard, he urged them to stand firm and fight, emphasizing that they couldn’t escape their fate by just praying to the gods but needed to take action and show courage. He reminded them that sometimes a path could be carved through the enemy ranks with a sword, and generally, less fear meant less danger. However, due to the noise and chaos, neither his advice nor orders could be heard. The soldiers were so confused that they could barely recognize their own standards, formations, or positions, lacking even the courage to prepare their weapons for battle. Some were caught off guard before they could ready themselves, feeling more weighed down than protected by their gear. In such darkness, they relied more on their hearing than their sight. They glanced in every direction toward the sounds of the wounded, the thuds of blows against bodies and armor, and the mixed shouts of those who were threatening and those who were scared. Some, while trying to escape, were blocked by other soldiers engaging in combat, and groups of fleeing men turned back toward the fight and diverted others. After failed attempts to charge in every direction and finding themselves surrounded by mountains and a lake on the sides and enemy lines both in front and behind, it became clear that their only chance of survival lay in taking action with their own strength and weapons. At that point, each soldier took it upon himself to lead and encourage his own efforts. A completely new kind of battle erupted, one without a structured formation of leaders, front lines, and support troops. No one fought in front of their standards, and soldiers were no longer grouped in their legions, cohorts, or companies; instead, they gathered into makeshift bands dictated by chance, with each man choosing his own position, whether at the front or the back. So intense was the fight, and so focused were they on the battle, that none of the fighters noticed the earthquake that caused large parts of many cities in Italy to collapse, redirected rivers from their courses, flooded streams with seawater, and brought down mountains with a tremendous roar.

6

The battle was continued near three hours, and in every quarter with fierceness; around the consul, however, it was still hotter and more determined. Both the strongest of the troops, and himself too, promptly brought assistance wherever he perceived his men hard pressed and distressed. But, distinguished by his armour, the enemy attacked him with the utmost vigour, while his countrymen defended him; until an Insubrian horseman, named Ducarius, knowing him also by his face, says to his countrymen, "Lo, this is the consul who slew our legions and laid waste our fields and city. Now will I offer this victim to the shades of my countrymen, miserably slain;" and putting spurs to his horse, he rushes through a very dense body of the enemy; and first slaying his armour-bearer, who had opposed himself to his attack as he approached, ran the consul through with his lance; the triarii, opposing their shields, kept him off when seeking to despoil him. Then first the flight of a great number began; and now neither the lake nor the mountains obstructed their hurried retreat; they run through all places, confined and precipitous, as though they were blind; and arms and men are tumbled one upon another. A great many, when there remained no more space to run, advancing into the water through the first shallows of the lake, plunge in, as far as they could stand above it with their heads and shoulders. Some there were whom inconsiderate fear induced to try to escape even by swimming; but as that attempt was inordinate and hopeless, they were either overwhelmed in the deep water, their courage failing, or, wearied to no purpose, made their way back, with extreme difficulty, to the shallows; and there were cut up on all hands by the cavalry of the enemy, which had entered the water. Near upon six thousand of the foremost body having gallantly forced their way through the opposing enemy, entirely unacquainted with what was occurring in their rear, escaped from the defile; and having halted on a certain rising ground, and hearing only the shouting and clashing of arms, they could not know nor discern, by reason of the mist, what was the fortune of the battle. At length, the affair being decided, when the mist, dispelled by the increasing heat of the sun, had cleared the atmosphere, then, in the clear light, the mountains and plains showed their ruin and the Roman army miserably destroyed; and thus, lest, being descried at a distance, the cavalry should be sent against them, hastily snatching up their standards, they hurried away with all possible expedition. On the following day, when in addition to their extreme sufferings in other respects, famine also was at hand, Maharbal, who had followed them during the night with the whole body of cavalry, pledging his honour that he would let them depart with single garments, if they would deliver up their arms, they surrendered themselves; which promise was kept by Hannibal with Punic fidelity, and he threw them all into chains.

The battle went on for almost three hours, with fierce fighting everywhere; around the consul, however, it was even more intense and desperate. The strongest of the troops, along with him, quickly rushed to help wherever he saw his men struggling and in distress. However, because of his unique armor, the enemy fiercely targeted him, while his countrymen defended him; until an Insubrian horseman named Ducarius, recognizing him by his face, shouted to his fellow countrymen, "Look, this is the consul who defeated our legions and destroyed our fields and city. Now, I will offer this victim to the spirits of my fallen countrymen;" and with that, he urged his horse forward through a thick crowd of enemies; first killing the armor-bearer who tried to block his path, he then ran the consul through with his lance; the triarii kept him at bay with their shields as he tried to loot the consul’s body. That was when the retreat of many began; and now neither the lake nor the mountains stopped their frantic flight; they ran through all the narrow and steep places as if they were blind, and arms and men piled on top of each other. A great number, when there was no more ground to flee, moved into the water through the shallows of the lake, submerging themselves as far as they could stand with their heads and shoulders above the surface. Some, gripped by reckless fear, tried to escape by swimming; but since that attempt was beyond reason and hopeless, they either drowned in the deep water, their courage failing them, or, exhausted for no reason, struggled back to the shallows, where they were cut down by the enemy's cavalry, which had entered the water. Nearly six thousand of the leading troops managed to fight their way through the enemy and, completely unaware of what was happening behind them, escaped from the narrow pass; after stopping on a small rise and only hearing the sounds of shouting and clashing weapons, they couldn’t see or tell, due to the mist, what had happened in the battle. Finally, once the outcome was clear and the mist lifted by the increasing heat of the sun, the devastation of the mountains and plains revealed the Roman army's miserable destruction; and so, to avoid being spotted from a distance and having cavalry sent after them, they quickly grabbed their standards and fled as fast as they could. The next day, after suffering greatly in many ways and facing hunger, Maharbal, who had followed them through the night with his entire cavalry force, promised he would let them leave with only their clothes if they surrendered their arms. They submitted, and Hannibal kept that promise with Punic fidelity, throwing them all into chains.

7

This is the celebrated battle at the Trasimenus, and recorded among the few disasters of the Roman people. Fifteen thousand Romans were slain in the battle. Ten thousand, who had been scattered in the flight through all Etruria, returned to the city by different roads. One thousand five hundred of the enemy perished in the battle; many on both sides died afterwards of their wounds. The carnage on both sides is related, by some authors, to have been many times greater. I, besides that I would relate nothing drawn from a worthless source, to which the minds of historians generally incline too much, have as my chief authority Fabius, who was contemporary with the events of this war. Such of the captives as belonged to the Latin confederacy being dismissed without ransom, and the Romans thrown into chains, Hannibal ordered the bodies of his own men to be gathered from the heaps of the enemy, and buried: the body of Flaminius too, which was searched for with great diligence for burial, he could not find. On the first intelligence of this defeat at Rome, a concourse of the people, dismayed and terrified, took place in the forum. The matrons, wandering through the streets, ask all they meet, what sudden disaster was reported? what was the fate of the army? And when the multitude, like a full assembly, having directed their course to the comitium and senate-house, were calling upon the magistrates, at length, a little before sunset, Marcus Pomponius, the praetor, declares, "We have been defeated in a great battle;" and though nothing more definite was heard from him, yet, full of the rumours which they had caught one from another, they carry back to their homes intelligence, that the consul, with a great part of his troops, was slain; that a few only survived, and these either widely dispersed in flight through Etruria, or else captured by the enemy. As many as had been the calamities of the vanquished army, into so many anxieties were the minds of those distracted whose relations had served under Flaminius, and who were uninformed of what had been the fate of their friends, nor does any one know certainly what he should either hope or fear. During the next and several successive days, a greater number of women almost than men stood at the gates, waiting either for some one of their friends or for intelligence of them, surrounding and earnestly interrogating those they met: nor could they be torn away from those they knew especially, until they had regularly inquired into every thing. Then as they retired from the informants you might discern their various expressions of countenance according as intelligence, pleasing or sad, was announced to each; and those who congratulated or condoled on their return home. The joy and grief of the women were especially manifested. They report that one, suddenly meeting her son, who had returned safe, expired at the very door before his face--that another, who sat grieving at her house at the falsely reported death of her son, became a corpse, from excessive joy, at the first sight of him on his return. The praetors detained the senators in the house for several days from sunrise to sunset, deliberating under whose conduct and by what forces, the victorious Carthaginians could be opposed.

This is the famous battle at Lake Trasimene, noted as one of the few disasters for the Roman people. Fifteen thousand Romans were killed in the battle. Ten thousand, scattered in their flight across all of Etruria, returned to the city via different routes. One thousand five hundred of the enemy fell in the battle; many on both sides later died from their wounds. Some authors claim that the bloodshed on both sides was much higher. I aim to share information from credible sources, avoiding the unreliable narratives that historians often lean towards, and my main reference is Fabius, who lived through this conflict. The captives from the Latin confederation were released without ransom, while the Romans were imprisoned. Hannibal ordered the bodies of his soldiers to be collected from the heaps of the fallen and buried: he could not find the body of Flaminius, despite searching diligently. Upon hearing of this defeat in Rome, a crowd of scared and troubled people gathered in the forum. The women wandered through the streets, asking everyone they met what sudden disaster had occurred and what had happened to the army. The crowd, like a full assembly, made their way to the comitium and senate-house, calling for the magistrates. Finally, just before sunset, Marcus Pomponius, the praetor, announced, "We have suffered a major defeat." Although he didn't provide more specific details, the crowd, filled with rumors they had shared among themselves, returned home with news that the consul had been killed along with many of his troops, with only a few surviving, either widely scattered in flight through Etruria or captured by the enemy. The fears of those whose loved ones had served under Flaminius multiplied, as they had no idea what had happened to their friends, leaving them uncertain about what to hope for or fear. In the following days, more women than men gathered at the gates, waiting for news of their loved ones, surrounding and questioning those they encountered: they could not be pulled away from familiar faces until they had thoroughly asked about everything. As they moved away from those providing information, you could see their faces change depending on whether the news was good or bad, as some celebrated or mourned their return home. The emotional responses of the women were particularly evident. It was said that one woman, suddenly encountering her son who had returned safely, collapsed and died right at the door in front of him; another woman, mourning at home over her son's reported death, dropped dead from overwhelming joy when she first saw him return. The praetors kept the senators in session for several days, from sunrise to sunset, discussing how to oppose the victorious Carthaginians and with what forces.

8

Before their plans were sufficiently determined another unexpected defeat is reported: four thousand horse, sent under the conduct of C. Centenius, propraetor, by Servilius to his colleague, were cut off by Hannibal in Umbria, to which place, on hearing of the battle at Trasimenus, they had turned their course. The report of this event variously affected the people. Some, having their minds preoccupied with heavier grief, considered the recent loss of cavalry trifling, in comparison with their former losses; others did not estimate what had occurred by itself, but considered that, as in a body already labouring under disease, a slight cause would be felt more violently than a more powerful one in a robust constitution, so whatever adverse event befell the state in its then sickly and impaired condition, ought to be estimated, not by the magnitude of the event itself, but with reference to its exhausted strength, which could endure nothing that could oppress it. The state therefore took refuge in a remedy for a long time before neither wanted nor employed, the appointment of a dictator, and because the consul was absent, by whom alone it appeared he could be nominated, and because neither message nor letter could easily be sent to him through the country occupied by Punic troops, and because the people could not appoint a dictator, which had never been done to that day, the people created Quintus Fabius Maximus pro dictator, and Marcus Minucius Rufus master of the horse. To them the senate assigned the task of strengthening the walls and towers of the city, of placing guards in such quarters as seemed good, and breaking down the bridges of the river, considering that they must now fight at home in defence of their city, since they were unable to protect Italy.

Before their plans were fully set, another unexpected defeat was reported: four thousand cavalry, sent by Servilius under the command of C. Centenius, were ambushed by Hannibal in Umbria after they changed course upon hearing about the battle at Trasimenus. The news of this incident affected people in different ways. Some, burdened by deeper grief, viewed the recent loss of cavalry as insignificant compared to their previous losses; others did not assess the event on its own but considered that, just like a body already suffering from illness would react more strongly to a minor issue than a strong body would, any negative event impacting the state in its weakened condition should be evaluated not by the size of the event itself, but in relation to its depleted strength, which could hardly handle additional burdens. Consequently, the state decided to use a remedy it had long avoided, the appointment of a dictator. However, since the consul was absent—who was the only one who could nominate a dictator—and because it was difficult to send messages or letters to him through the territory occupied by Punic troops, and since the people could not appoint a dictator, something that had never been done up to that point, the people appointed Quintus Fabius Maximus as pro dictator and Marcus Minucius Rufus as master of the horse. The senate assigned them the responsibilities of strengthening the city’s walls and towers, deploying guards in strategic locations, and destroying the bridges over the river, recognizing that they now had to defend their city at home, as they were unable to protect Italy.

9

Hannibal, marching directly through Umbria, arrived at Spoletum, thence, having completely devastated the adjoining country, and commenced an assault upon the city, having been repulsed with great loss and conjecturing from the strength of this one colony, which had been not very successfully attacked, what was the size of the city of Rome, turned aside into the territory of Picenum, which abounded not only with every species of grain, but was stored with booty, which his rapacious and needy troops eagerly seized. There he continued encamped for several days, and his soldiers were refreshed, who had been enfeebled by winter marches and marshy ground, and with a battle more successful in its result than light or easy. When sufficient time for rest had been granted for soldiers delighting more in plunder and devastation than ease and repose, setting out, he lays waste the territories of Pretutia and Hadria, then of the Marsi, the Marrucini, and the Peligni, and the contiguous region of Apulia around Arpi and Luceria. Cneius Servilius, the consul, having fought some slight battles with the Gauls, and taken one inconsiderable town, when he heard of the defeat of his colleague and the army, alarmed now for the walls of the capital, marched towards the city, that he might not be absent at so extreme a crisis. Quintus Fabius Maximus, a second time dictator, assembled the senate the very day he entered on his office; and commencing with what related to the gods, after he had distinctly proved to the fathers, that Caius Flaminius had erred more from neglect of the ceremonies and auspices than from temerity and want of judgment, and that the gods themselves should be consulted as to what were the expiations of their anger, he obtained a resolution that the decemviri should be ordered to inspect the Sibylline books, which is rarely decreed, except when some horrid prodigies were announced. Having inspected the prophetic books, they reported, that the vow which was made to Mars on account of this war, not having been regularly fulfilled, must be performed afresh and more fully; that the great games must be vowed to Jupiter, temples to Venus Erycina and Mens; that a supplication and lectisternium must be made, and a sacred spring vowed, if the war should proceed favourably and the state continue the condition it was in before the war. Since the management of the war would occupy Fabius, the senate orders Marcus Aemilius, the praetor, to see that all these things are done in good time, according to the directions of the college of pontiffs.

Hannibal, marching straight through Umbria, arrived at Spoletum. After completely destroying the surrounding area, he launched an attack on the city. He was repelled with heavy losses and speculated, based on the strength of this colony, which had not been very successfully attacked, about the size of the city of Rome. He then diverted into the territory of Picenum, which was abundant not only in various grains but also filled with loot that his greedy and needy troops eagerly grabbed. He camped there for several days, allowing his soldiers, weakened by winter marches and marshy conditions, to recuperate from a battle that was more favorable in outcome than light or easy. Once they had enough time to rest—preferably enjoying plunder and destruction rather than idleness—he set out, ravaging the territories of Pretutia and Hadria, then those of the Marsi, Marrucini, and Peligni, as well as the nearby region of Apulia around Arpi and Luceria. Cneius Servilius, the consul, having fought a few minor skirmishes with the Gauls and taken one insignificant town, upon hearing of his colleague’s defeat and the army’s loss, grew alarmed for the city’s defenses. He rushed back toward the city, determined not to be absent during such a critical time. Quintus Fabius Maximus, appointed dictator for a second time, convened the senate the very day he took office. Starting with matters concerning the gods, he clearly demonstrated to the senators that Caius Flaminius had made more mistakes due to neglecting rituals and signs than from recklessness and poor judgment. He emphasized that the gods themselves should be consulted regarding how to atone for their anger. This led to a decision that the decemviri should examine the Sibylline books, which is a rare occurrence usually reserved for significant prodigies. After reviewing the prophetic texts, they reported that the vow made to Mars for this war had not been properly fulfilled and needed to be repeated and expanded; that grand games should be vowed to Jupiter; temples built for Venus Erycina and Mens; and that a public supplication and lectisternium should be held, along with a commitment to a sacred spring, if the war continued favorably and the state remained in the same condition as before the conflict. Since managing the war would occupy Fabius, the senate instructed Marcus Aemilius, the praetor, to ensure that all these matters were executed in a timely manner, following the guidance of the college of pontiffs.

10

These decrees of the senate having been passed, Lucius Cornelius Lentulus, pontifex maximus, the college of praetors consulting with him, gives his opinion that, first of all, the people should be consulted respecting a sacred spring: that it could not be without the order of the people. The people having been asked according to this form: Do ye will and order that this thing should be performed in this manner? If the republic of the Roman people, the Quirites, shall be safe and preserved as I wish it may, from these wars for the next five years, (the war which is between the Roman people and the Carthaginian, and the wars which are with the Cisalpine Gauls), the Roman people, the Quirites, shall present whatsoever the spring shall produce from herds of swine, sheep, goats, oxen and which shall not have been consecrated, to be sacrificed to Jupiter, from the day which the senate and people shall appoint. Let him who shall make an offering do it when he please, and in what manner he please; in whatsoever manner he does it, let it be considered duly done. If that which ought to be sacrificed die, let it be unconsecrated, and let no guilt attach; if any one unwittingly wound or kill it, let it be no injury to him; if any one shall steal it, let no guilt attach to the people or to him from whom it was stolen; if any one shall unwittingly offer it on a forbidden day, let it be esteemed duly offered; also whether by night or day, whether slave or free-man perform it. If the senate and people shall order it to be offered sooner than any person shall offer it, let the people being acquitted of it be free. On the same account great games were vowed, at an expense of three hundred and thirty-three thousand three hundred and thirty-three asses and a third; moreover, it was decreed that sacrifice should be done to Jupiter with three hundred oxen, to many other deities with white oxen and the other victims. The vows being duly made, a supplication was proclaimed; and not only the inhabitants of the city went with their wives and children, but such of the rustics also as, possessing any property themselves, were interested in the welfare of the state. Then a lectisternium was celebrated for three days, the decemviri for sacred things superintending. Six couches were seen, for Jupiter and Juno one, for Neptune and Minerva another, for Mars and Venus a third, for Apollo and Diana a fourth, for Vulcan and Vesta a fifth, for Mercury and Ceres a sixth. Then temples were vowed. To Venus Erycina, Quintus Fabius Maximus vowed a temple; for so it was delivered from the prophetic books, that he should vow it who held the highest authority in the state. Titus Otacilius, the praetor vowed a temple to Mens.

After the senate passed these decrees, Lucius Cornelius Lentulus, the chief priest, along with the group of praetors consulting with him, expressed his opinion that the public should first be consulted regarding a sacred spring: it couldn’t happen without the people’s approval. The people were asked this question: "Do you agree and authorize that this be done this way?" If the Roman people, the Quirites, remain safe and protected for the next five years from these wars (the war between the Roman people and the Carthaginians, and the wars against the Cisalpine Gauls), the Roman people, the Quirites, will offer whatever the spring produces from their herds of swine, sheep, goats, and oxen that has not been dedicated, to be sacrificed to Jupiter, starting from the day the senate and the people decide. Let anyone who wishes to make an offering do so whenever and however they choose; however they do it, let it be considered properly done. If what is supposed to be sacrificed dies, let it be considered unconsecrated, and let no blame attach; if someone accidentally injures or kills it, let that person bear no guilt; if anyone steals it, let neither the people nor the thief be blamed; if someone unintentionally offers it on a restricted day, let it be viewed as properly offered, regardless of whether it’s day or night, or whether a slave or a free person performs it. If the senate and the people decide that it should be offered before anyone else does, let the people be released from responsibility. For this reason, grand games were promised, costing three hundred thirty-three thousand and one-third ass; additionally, it was decreed that a sacrifice should be made to Jupiter with three hundred oxen, and to many other deities with white oxen and other offerings. Once the vows were officially made, a public prayer was proclaimed; not only did the city’s residents attend with their wives and children, but also the local farmers, who owned property and cared about the state's welfare. Then a lectisternium was celebrated for three days, supervised by the decemviri for sacred matters. Six couches were visible: one for Jupiter and Juno, another for Neptune and Minerva, a third for Mars and Venus, a fourth for Apollo and Diana, a fifth for Vulcan and Vesta, and a sixth for Mercury and Ceres. Temples were then vowed. To Venus Erycina, Quintus Fabius Maximus vowed a temple; as it was stated in the prophetic books, he who holds the highest office in the state should vow it. Titus Otacilius, the praetor, vowed a temple to Mens.

11

Divine things having been thus performed, the dictator then put the question of the war and the state; with what, and how many legions the fathers were of opinion that the victorious enemy should be opposed. It was decreed that he should receive the army from Cneius Servilius, the consul: that he should levy, moreover, from the citizens and allies as many horse and foot as seemed good; that he should transact and perform every thing else as he considered for the good of the state. Fabius said he would add two legions to the army of Servilius. These were levied by the master of the horse, and were appointed by Fabius to meet him at Tibur on a certain day. And then having issued proclamation that those whose towns or castles were unfortified should quit them and assemble in places of security; that all the inhabitants of that tract through which Hannibal was about to march, should remove from the country, having first burnt their buildings and spoiled their fruits, that there might not be a supply of any thing; he himself set out on the Flaminian road to meet the consul and his army; and when he saw in the distance the marching body on the Tiber, near Ocriculum, and the consul with the cavalry advancing to him, he sent a beadle to acquaint the consul that he must meet the dictator without the lictors. When he had obeyed his command, and their meeting had exhibited a striking display of the majesty of the dictatorship before the citizens and allies, who, from its antiquity, had now almost forgotten that authority; a letter arrived from the city, stating that the ships of burden, conveying provisions from Ostia into Spain to the army, had been captured by the Carthaginian fleet off the port of Cossa. The consul, therefore, was immediately ordered to proceed to Ostia, and, having manned the ships at Rome or Ostia with soldiers and sailors, to pursue the enemy, and protect the coasts of Italy. Great numbers of men were levied at Rome, sons of freed-men even, who had children, and were of the military age, had taken the oath. Of these troops levied in the city, such as were under thirty-five were put on board ships, the rest were left to protect the city.

After completing the necessary rituals, the dictator then asked about the war and the state, specifically regarding how many legions the Senate believed should be used to confront the victorious enemy. It was decided that he should receive the army from Cneius Servilius, the consul; he was also allowed to gather as many cavalry and infantry from the citizens and allies as he deemed appropriate; and he could manage everything else as he thought was best for the state. Fabius mentioned he would add two legions to Servilius's army. These were recruited by the master of the horse and were scheduled by Fabius to meet him at Tibur on a specific day. He then announced that anyone whose towns or fortresses were unprotected should leave and gather in safe locations; that all the residents of the areas through which Hannibal would march should evacuate, burning their homes and destroying their crops first, so the enemy wouldn't have any supplies. He set off on the Flaminian road to meet the consul and his army, and when he spotted the marching troops near Ocriculum and the consul approaching with the cavalry, he sent a messenger to inform the consul that he should meet the dictator without his attendants. After following this instruction, their meeting showcased the power of the dictatorship to the citizens and allies, who, due to its long history, had nearly forgotten this authority. Shortly after, a letter arrived from the city reporting that the cargo ships transporting provisions from Ostia to Spain for the army had been captured by the Carthaginian fleet near the port of Cossa. Consequently, the consul was ordered to head to Ostia immediately, to crew the ships in Rome or Ostia with soldiers and sailors, to chase the enemy, and to guard the coast of Italy. A significant number of men were recruited in Rome, including freedmen’s sons who had children and were of military age, who all took the oath. Among those gathered in the city, individuals under thirty-five were assigned to the ships, while the others remained to defend the city.

12

The dictator, having received the troops of the consul from Fulvius Flaccus, his lieutenant-general, marching through the Sabine territory, arrived at Tibur on the day which he had appointed the new-raised troops to assemble. Thence he went to Praeneste, and cutting across the country, came out in the Latin way, whence he led his troops towards the enemy, reconnoitering the road with the utmost diligence; not intending to expose himself to hazard any where, except as far as necessity compelled him. The day he first pitched his camp in sight of the enemy, not far from Arpi, the Carthaginian, without delay, led out his troops, and forming his line gave an opportunity of fighting: but when he found all still with the enemy, and his camp free from tumult and disorder, he returned to his camp, saying indeed tauntingly, "That even the spirit of the Romans, inherited from Mars, was at length subdued; that they were warred down and had manifestly given up all claim to valour and renown:" but burning inwardly with stifled vexation because he would have to encounter a general by no means like Flaminius and Sempronius; and because the Romans, then at length schooled by their misfortunes, had sought a general a match for Hannibal; and that now he had no longer to fear the headlong violence, but the deliberate prudence of the dictator. Having not yet experienced his constancy, he began to provoke and try his temper, by frequently shifting his camp and laying waste the territories of the allies before his eyes: and one while he withdrew out of sight at quick march, another while he halted suddenly, and concealed himself in some winding of the road, if possible to entrap him on his descending into the plain. Fabius kept marching his troops along the high grounds, at a moderate distance from the enemy, so as neither to let him go altogether nor yet to encounter him. The troops were kept within the camp, except so far as necessary wants compelled them to quit it; and fetched in food and wood not by small nor rambling parties. An outpost of cavalry and light-armed troops, prepared and equipped for acting in cases of sudden alarm, rendered every thing safe to their own soldiers, and dangerous to the scattered plunderers of the enemy. Nor was his whole cause committed to general hazard; while slight contests, of small importance in themselves, commenced on safe ground, with a retreat at hand, accustomed the soldiery, terrified by their former disasters, now at length to think less meanly either of their prowess or good fortune. But he did not find Hannibal a greater enemy to such sound measures than his master of the horse, who was only prevented from plunging the state into ruin by his inferiority in command. Presumptuous and precipitate in his measures, and unbridled in his tongue, first among a few, then openly and publicly, he taunted him with being sluggish instead of patient, spiritless instead of cautious; falsely imputing to him those vices which bordered on his virtues; and raised himself by means of depressing his superiors, which, though a most iniquitous practice, has become more general from the too great successes of many.

The dictator, after receiving the consul's troops from Fulvius Flaccus, his lieutenant-general, marching through the Sabine territory, arrived at Tibur on the day he had designated for the newly raised troops to assemble. From there, he went to Praeneste and cut across the countryside, coming out on the Latin road, where he led his troops toward the enemy, carefully scouting the route, making sure not to put himself in danger unless absolutely necessary. On the day he first set up his camp within sight of the enemy, not far from Arpi, the Carthaginian quickly led out his troops and formed his line, offering a chance for battle. But when he noticed everything was quiet on the enemy side and his camp was calm and orderly, he returned to his camp, mockingly saying, "Even the spirit of the Romans, inherited from Mars, has finally been broken; they have been worn down and have clearly given up all claim to bravery and glory." However, he was inwardly seething with suppressed frustration because he was about to face a general who was nothing like Flaminius and Sempronius; the Romans, after being schooled by their misfortunes, had sought a general who could match Hannibal, and now he had to face not the reckless fury, but the careful strategy of the dictator. Having not yet tested his resolve, he began to provoke and challenge him by frequently moving his camp and ravaging the lands of the allies in plain view. Sometimes he would rush out of sight quickly, and other times he would halt suddenly, hiding himself in the winding road, hoping to catch him off guard as he descended into the plain. Fabius kept his troops moving along the high ground, staying at a reasonable distance from the enemy, not letting them get away completely but also avoiding direct confrontation. The troops largely stayed within their camp unless necessary needs forced them out, and they gathered food and firewood in organized groups. A cavalry and light infantry outpost, prepared for sudden emergencies, ensured safety for their own soldiers and posed dangers to the enemy's scattered foragers. His entire strategy wasn’t left to chance; while minor skirmishes of little significance began on secure ground with an easy retreat, they helped the soldiers—frightened by their previous defeats—begin to think more positively about their strength and luck. Yet, he found that Hannibal was not the only threat to such sound strategies; his horse commander posed a significant risk. Though he was held back from plunging the state into chaos due to his lower rank, he was arrogant and rash, quick to speak out. First among a few, then openly and publicly, he mocked him for being slow instead of patient, and timid instead of cautious, wrongly attributing to him the shortcomings that were actually flaws of his own virtues; he elevated himself by undermining those above him, a corrupt tactic that has become more common among those who have enjoyed too much success.

13

Hannibal crosses over from the Hirpini into Samnium; lays waste the territory of Beneventum; takes the town of Telesia; and purposely irritates the dictator, if perchance he could draw him down to a battle on the plain, exasperated by so many indignities and disasters inflicted on his allies. Among the multitude of allies of Italian extraction, who had been captured by Hannibal at the Trasimenus, and dismissed, were three Campanian horsemen, who had even at that time been bribed by many presents and promises from Hannibal to win over the affections of their countrymen to him. These, bringing him word that he would have an opportunity of getting possession of Capua, if he brought his army into the neighbourhood in Campania, induced Hannibal to quit Samnium for Campania; though he hesitated, fluctuating between confidence and distrust, as the affair was of more importance than the authorities. He dismissed them, repeatedly charging them to confirm their promises by acts, and ordering them to return with a greater number, and some of their leading men. Hannibal himself orders his guide to conduct him into the territory of Casinum, being certified by persons acquainted with the country, that if he seized that pass he would deprive the Romans of a passage by which they might get out to the assistance of their allies. But his Punic accent, ill adapted to the pronunciation of Latin names, caused the guide to understand Casilinum, instead of Casinum; and leaving his former course, he descends through the territory of Allifae, Calatia, and Cales, into the plain of Stella, where, seeing the country enclosed on all sides by mountains and rivers, he calls the guide to him, and asks him where in the world he was? when he replied, that on that day he would lodge at Casilinum: then at length the error was discovered, and that Casinum lay at a great distance in another direction. Having scourged the guide with rods and crucified him, in order to strike terror into all others, he fortified a camp, and sent Maharbal with the cavalry into the Falernian territory to pillage. This depredation reached as far as the waters of Sinuessa; the Numidians caused destruction to a vast extent, but flight and consternation through a still wider space. Yet not even the terror of these things, when all around was consuming in the flames of war, could shake the fidelity of the allies; for this manifest reason, because they lived under a temperate and mild government: nor were they unwilling to submit to those who were superior to them, which is the only bond of fidelity.

Hannibal crossed over from the Hirpini into Samnium, devastated the land of Beneventum, captured the town of Telesia, and intentionally provoked the dictator, hoping to lure him into a battle on the plain, riled up by the numerous insults and disasters suffered by his allies. Among the many Italian allies who had been captured by Hannibal at Trasimenus and later released were three Campanian horsemen, who at that time were already bribed with gifts and promises from Hannibal to win their fellow countrymen over to his side. They informed him that he could seize Capua if he moved his army into the Campanian area, which persuaded Hannibal to leave Samnium for Campania. However, he hesitated, torn between trust and doubt, as the situation was more significant than what the commanders might suggest. He dismissed them, repeatedly telling them to prove their promises through action, and ordered them to return with a larger group and some of their key leaders. Hannibal then directed his guide to take him into the territory of Casinum, having been assured by locals that seizing that pass would cut off the Romans' route for aiding their allies. But his Carthaginian accent, poorly suited for Latin names, led the guide to understand Casilinum instead of Casinum; consequently, he veered off course and traveled through the land of Allifae, Calatia, and Cales, reaching the plain of Stella. Upon seeing that the area was surrounded by mountains and rivers, he called the guide over and asked where they were. The guide replied that they would spend the night in Casilinum, at which point the mistake was identified, and it became clear that Casinum was far away in another direction. Angered, Hannibal punished the guide severely and executed him to instill fear in others. He then set up a fortified camp and sent Maharbal with the cavalry into the Falernian territory to raid. This raid reached as far as the waters of Sinuessa; the Numidians caused widespread devastation, but the panic and fear spread even further. Yet, even the terror of these events, with everything around engulfed in the flames of war, couldn't shake the loyalty of the allies. This was mainly because they were governed by a fair and gentle rule, and they were willing to submit to those who were stronger, which is the only true foundation of loyalty.

14

But when the enemy's camp was pitched on the Vulturnus, and the most delightful country in Italy was being consumed by fire, and the farm-houses, on all hands, were smoking from the flames, whilst Fabius led his troops along the heights of Mount Massicus, then the strife had nearly been kindled anew, for they had been quiet for a few days, because, as the army had marched quicker than usual, they had supposed that the object of this haste was to save Campania from devastation; but when they arrived at the extreme ridge of Mount Massicus, and the enemy appeared under their eyes, burning the houses of the Falernian territory, and of the settlers of Sinuessa, and no mention made of battle, Minucius exclaims, "Are we come here to see our allies butchered, and their property burned, as a spectacle to be enjoyed? and if we are not moved with shame on account of any others, are we not on account of these citizens, whom our fathers sent as settlers to Sinuessa, that this frontier might be protected from the Samnite foe: which now not the neighbouring Samnite wastes with fire, but a Carthaginian foreigner, who has advanced even thus far from the remotest limits of the world, through our dilatoriness and inactivity? What! are we so degenerate from our ancestors as tamely to see that coast filled with Numidian and Moorish foes, along which our fathers considered it a disgrace to their government that the Carthaginian fleets should cruise? We, who erewhile, indignant at the storming of Saguntum, appealed not to men only, but to treaties and to gods, behold Hannibal scaling the walls of a Roman colony unmoved. The smoke from the flames of our farm-houses and lands comes into our eyes and faces; our ears ring with the cries of our weeping allies, imploring us to assist them oftener than the gods, while we here are leading our troops, like a herd of cattle, through shady forests and lonely paths, enveloped in clouds and woods. If Marcus Furius had resolved to recover the city from the Gauls, by thus traversing the tops of mountains and forests, in the same manner as this modern Camillus goes about to recover Italy from Hannibal, who has been sought out for our dictator in our distress, on account of his unparalleled talents, Rome would be the possession of the Gauls; and I fear lest, if we are thus dilatory, our ancestors will so often have preserved it only for the Carthaginians and Hannibal; but that man and true Roman, on the very day on which intelligence was brought him to Veii, that he was appointed dictator, on the authority of the fathers and the nomination of the people, came down into the plain, though the Janiculum was high enough to admit of his sitting down there, and viewing the enemy at a distance, and on that very day defeated the Gallic legions in the middle of the city, in the place where the Gallic piles are now, and on the following day on the Roman side of Gabii. What many years after this, when we were sent under the yoke at the Caudine forks by the Samnite foe, did Lucius Papirius Cursor take the yoke from the Roman neck and place it upon the proud Samnites, by traversing the heights of Samnium? or was it by pressing and besieging Luceria, and challenging the victorious enemy? A short time ago, what was it that gave victory to Caius Lutatius but expedition? for on the day after he caught sight of the enemy he surprised and overpowered the fleet, loaded with provisions, and encumbered of itself by its own implements and apparatus. It is folly to suppose that the war can be brought to a conclusion by sitting still, or by prayers, the troops must be armed and led down into the plain, that you may engage man to man. The Roman power has grown to its present height by courage and activity, and not by such dilatory measures as these, which the cowardly only designate as cautious." A crowd of Roman tribunes and knights poured round Minucius, while thus, as it were, haranguing, his presumptuous expressions reached the ears of the common soldiers, and had the question been submitted to the votes of the soldiers, they showed evidently that they would have preferred Minucius to Fabius for their general.

But when the enemy set up camp by the Vulturnus River, and the most beautiful land in Italy was being burned, with farmhouses all around smoking from the flames, while Fabius led his troops along the heights of Mount Massicus, tensions almost flared up again. They had been quiet for a few days because the army had marched faster than usual, and they assumed this was to save Campania from destruction. However, when they reached the highest point of Mount Massicus and saw the enemy setting fire to the houses in the Falernian territory and of the settlers from Sinuessa, with no mention of battle, Minucius exclaimed, “Are we really here just to watch our allies get slaughtered and their property destroyed? If we aren't ashamed for others, aren't we ashamed for these citizens, whom our forefathers sent to settle in Sinuessa to protect this border from the Samnite enemy? Now, it's not the nearby Samnites who are burning these lands, but a foreign Carthaginian who has come all this way from the farthest corners of the world because of our laziness and inaction. What! Have we become so weak compared to our ancestors that we can just sit back and watch this coast filled with Numidian and Moorish enemies, where our forefathers thought it disgraceful for Carthaginian fleets to patrol? We, who just a while ago, outraged by the storming of Saguntum, appealed not only to men but to treaties and the gods, now witness Hannibal scaling the walls of a Roman colony without a care. The smoke from our burning farms and lands fills our eyes and faces; our ears ring with the cries of our weeping allies, pleading for our help more urgently than the gods, while we lead our troops like a herd of cattle through shady forests and lonely paths, lost in clouds and trees. If Marcus Furius had planned to recover the city from the Gauls by wandering through mountains and forests like this modern Camillus is trying to recover Italy from Hannibal, whom we have sought as our dictator in our distress because of his unmatched skills, Rome would have fallen to the Gauls. I worry that if we stay this slow, our ancestors will have saved it only for the Carthaginians and Hannibal. Yet that true Roman, on the very day he was informed at Veii that he was appointed dictator, with the authority of the elders and the people's endorsement, came down to the plains, even though the Janiculum was high enough for him to just sit there and watch the enemy from a distance. And on that very day, he defeated the Gallic legions in the heart of the city, where the Gallic piles now stand, and the next day on the Roman side of Gabii. Years later, when we were made to submit under the yoke at the Caudine forks by the Samnite enemy, what did Lucius Papirius Cursor do? Did he take the yoke from the Roman neck and place it on the proud Samnites by roaming through the heights of Samnium? Or was it by pressing and besieging Luceria and challenging the victorious enemy? Just recently, what brought victory to Caius Lutatius but his quick action? For on the day after he saw the enemy, he surprised and overwhelmed the fleet, weighed down by provisions and its own gear. It’s foolish to think that the war can end by sitting still or praying; the troops must be armed and led down into the plains to engage in battle. Roman power has grown to its current height through courage and action, not through the slow measures that only the cowardly label as cautious.” A crowd of Roman tribunes and knights gathered around Minucius as he spoke, and his bold words reached the ears of the common soldiers. Had the question been put to a vote, they clearly showed they would have preferred Minucius over Fabius as their general.

15

Fabius, keeping his attention fixed no less upon his own troops than on the enemy, first shows that his resolution was unconquered by the former. Though he well knew that his procrastination was disapproved, not only in his own camp, but by this time even at Rome, yet, inflexibly adhering to the same line of policy, he delayed through the remainder of the summer, in order that Hannibal, devoid of all hope of a battle, which he so earnestly desired, might now look out for a place for winter quarters, because that district was one of present, but not constant, supply, consisting, as it did, of plantations and vineyards, and all places planted luxurious rather than useful produce. This intelligence was to Fabius by his scouts. When he felt convinced that he would return by the same narrow pass through which he had entered the Falernian territory, he occupied Mount Callicula and Casilinum with a pretty strong guard. Which city, intersected by the river Vulturnus, divides the Falernian and Campanian territories. He himself leads back his troops along the same heights, having sent Lucius Hostilius Mancinus with four hundred of the allied cavalry to reconnoitre; who being one of the crowd of youths who had often heard the master of the horse fiercely haranguing, at first advanced after the manner of a scout, in order that he might observe the enemy in security; and when he saw the Numidians scattered widely throughout the villages, having gotten an opportunity, he also slew a few of them. But from that moment his mind was engrossed with the thoughts of a battle, and the injunctions of the dictator were forgotten, who had charged him, when he had advanced as far as he could with safety, to retreat before he came within the enemy's view. The Numidians, party after party, skirmishing and retreating, drew the general almost to their camp, to the fatigue of his men and horses. Then Karthalo, who had the command of the cavalry, charging at full speed, and having put them to flight before he came within a dart's throw, pursued them for five miles almost in a continuous course. Mancinus, when he saw that the enemy did not desist from the pursuit, and that there was no hope of escape, having encouraged his troops, turned back to the battle though inferior in every kind of force. Accordingly he himself, and the choicest of his cavalry, being surrounded, are cut to pieces. The rest in disorderly retreat fled first to Cales, and thence to the dictator, by ways almost impassable. It happened that on that day Minucius had formed a junction with Fabius, having been sent to secure with a guard the pass above Tarracina, which, contracted into a narrow gorge, overhangs the sea, in order that Hannibal might not be able to get into the Roman territory by the Appian way's being unguarded. The dictator and master of the horse, uniting their forces, lead them down into the road through which Hannibal was about to march his troops. The enemy was two miles from that place.

Fabius, focused on both his own troops and the enemy, demonstrated that his determination was still strong despite criticism. He was aware that people in his camp and even back in Rome disapproved of his delays. Nonetheless, he stuck to his strategy and held off for the rest of the summer, hoping that Hannibal, stripped of all hope for the much-desired battle, would start looking for winter quarters. This area provided temporary supplies, thanks to its farms and vineyards, but was not a reliable source of resources. His scouts provided Fabius with this information. When he was convinced that he would return through the same narrow pass he had used to enter the Falernian territory, he stationed a solid guard at Mount Callicula and Casilinum. This city, split by the Vulturnus River, separates the Falernian and Campanian regions. He then led his troops back along the same heights, sending Lucius Hostilius Mancinus with four hundred allied cavalry to scout ahead. Mancinus, a young officer who had often listened to the passionate speeches of the cavalry leader, initially approached cautiously to safely observe the enemy. When he noticed the Numidians scattered across the villages, he seized the opportunity and took out a few of them. However, from that point onwards, he became consumed by thoughts of battle and forgot the orders of the dictator, who had instructed him to retreat before getting within sight of the enemy. The Numidians, skirmishing and falling back one group after another, led Mancinus close to their camp, wearing down his men and horses. Then Karthalo, commanding the cavalry, charged at full speed and chased them off even before coming within throwing distance, pursuing them for nearly five miles. When Mancinus realized the enemy would not stop chasing and there was no escape in sight, he rallied his troops and turned back to fight, despite being outmatched. Ultimately, he and the best of his cavalry found themselves surrounded and were slaughtered. The rest fell back in a disorganized retreat first to Cales and then to the dictator, taking almost impassable routes. Meanwhile, Minucius had joined Fabius that day. He had been sent to secure the pass above Tarracina, which narrows into a gorge overlooking the sea, to prevent Hannibal from entering Roman territory via the unguarded Appian Way. The dictator and the cavalry commander combined their forces and led them down the road along which Hannibal was set to march. The enemy was only two miles away.

16

The following day the Carthaginians filled the whole road between the two camps with his troops in marching order; and though the Romans had taken their stand immediately under their rampart, having a decidedly superior position, yet the Carthaginian came up with his light horse and, with a view to provoke the enemy, carried on a kind of desultory attack, first charging and then retreating. The Roman line remained in its position. The battle was slow and more conformable to the wish of the dictator than of Hannibal. On the part of the Romans there fell two hundred, on the part of the enemy eight hundred. It now began to appear that Hannibal was hemmed in, the road to Casilinum being blockaded; and that while Capua, and Samnium, and so many wealthy allies in the rear of the Romans might supply them with provisions, the Carthaginian, on the other hand, must winter amid the rocks of Formiae and the sands and hideous swamps of Liternum. Nor did it escape Hannibal that he was assailed by his own arts; wherefore, since he could not escape by way of Casilinum, and since it was necessary to make for the mountains, and pass the summit of Callicula, lest in any place the Romans should attack his troops while enclosed in valleys; having hit upon a stratagem calculated to deceive the sight, and excite terror from its appearance, by means of which he might baffle the enemy, he resolved to come up by stealth to the mountains at the commencement of night. The preparation of his wily stratagem was of this description. Torches, collected from every part of the country, and bundles of rods and dry cuttings, are fastened before the horns of oxen, of which, wild and tame, he had driven away a great number among other plunder of the country: the number of oxen was made up to nearly two thousand. To Hasdrubal was assigned the task of driving to the mountains that herd, after having set fire to their horns, as soon as ever it was dark; particularly, if he could, over the passes beset by the enemy.

The next day, the Carthaginians filled the entire road between the two camps with their troops in marching order. Even though the Romans had positioned themselves right under their rampart, giving them a clearly superior position, the Carthaginian general sent in his light cavalry to provoke the enemy with a kind of hit-and-run tactic—charging first, then retreating. The Roman line held its ground. The battle progressed slowly, more in line with the dictator's preference than Hannibal's. The Romans lost two hundred men, while the enemy lost eight hundred. It soon became clear that Hannibal was cornered, as the road to Casilinum was blocked. Meanwhile, Capua, Samnium, and many wealthy allies behind the Romans could supply them with provisions, while the Carthaginian forces would have to winter among the rocky terrain of Formiae and the nasty swamps of Liternum. Hannibal also realized he was being targeted by his own tactics. Therefore, since he couldn't escape through Casilinum, and needed to head for the mountains, passing over Callicula's peak to avoid being attacked by the Romans in the valleys, he came up with a deception plan designed to mislead and instill fear in the enemy. He decided to move stealthily to the mountains at nightfall. His clever plan involved gathering torches from all around and attaching bundles of sticks and dry branches to the horns of nearly two thousand oxen, both wild and domesticated, which he had gathered from his plunder. Hasdrubal was tasked with driving that herd to the mountains after setting their horns on fire, especially if he could do so over the enemy-held passes, as soon as darkness fell.

17

As soon as it was dark the camp was moved in silence; the oxen were driven a little in advance of the standards. When they arrived at the foot of the mountains and the narrow passes, the signal is immediately given for setting fire to their horns and driving them violently up the mountains before them. The mere terror excited by the flame, which cast a glare from their heads, and the heat now approaching the quick and the roots of their horns, drove on the oxen as if goaded by madness. By which dispersion, on a sudden all the surrounding shrubs were in a blaze, as if the mountains and woods had been on fire; and the unavailing tossing of their heads quickening the flame, exhibited an appearance as of men running to and fro on every side. Those who had been placed to guard the passage of the wood, when they saw fires on the tops of the mountains, and some over their own heads, concluding that they were surrounded, abandoned their post; making for the tops of the mountains in the direction in which the fewest fires blazed, as being the safest course; however they fell in with some oxen which had strayed from their herds. At first, when they beheld them at a distance, they stood fixed in amazement at the miracle, as it appeared to them, of creatures breathing fire; afterwards, when it showed itself to be a human stratagem, then, forsooth, concluding that there was an ambuscade, as they are hurrying away in flight, with increased alarm, they fall in also with the light-armed troops of the enemy. But the night, when the fear was equally shared, kept them from commencing the battle till morning. Meanwhile Hannibal, having marched his whole army through the pass, and having cut off some of the enemy in the very defile, pitches his camp in the country of Allifae.

As soon as it got dark, the camp moved quietly; the oxen were driven a bit ahead of the standards. When they reached the base of the mountains and the narrow passes, the signal was immediately given to set fire to their horns and drive them forcefully up the mountains in front of them. The sheer terror caused by the flames, which lit up their heads and heated their horns, drove the oxen on as if they were crazed. This sudden panic set all the surrounding shrubs ablaze, making it seem like the mountains and woods were on fire; and the frantic tossing of their heads, which only fueled the flames, created an illusion of people running around everywhere. Those assigned to guard the wood’s passage, upon seeing fires atop the mountains and some directly above them, panicked, thinking they were surrounded, and abandoned their posts; they made for the mountaintops in the direction where there were the fewest fires, believing it was the safest route. However, they stumbled upon some oxen that had wandered away from their herds. At first, when they spotted them from a distance, they were frozen in awe at what seemed a miraculous sight of creatures breathing fire; but when they realized it was a human trick, they concluded there was an ambush, and in their hasty flight, they ran into the lightly armed troops of the enemy. But the nighttime, shared by everyone in fear, prevented them from starting a battle until morning. Meanwhile, Hannibal had led his entire army through the pass and had cut off some of the enemy right in the defile, setting up camp in the territory of Allifae.

18

Fabius perceived this tumult, but concluding that it was a snare, and being disinclined for a battle, particularly by night, kept his troops within the works. At break of day a battle took place under the summit of the mountain, in which the Romans, who were considerably superior in numbers, would have easily overpowered the light-armed of the enemy, cut off as they were from their party, had not a cohort of Spaniards, sent back by Hannibal for that very purpose, reached the spot. That body being more accustomed to mountains, and being more adapted, both from the agility of their limbs and also from the character of their arms, to skirmishing amid rocks and crags, easily foiled, by their manner of fighting, an enemy loaded with arms, accustomed to level ground and the steady kind of fighting. Separating from a contest thus by no means equal, they proceeded to their camps; the Spaniards almost all untouched; the Romans having lost a few. Fabius also moved his camp, and passing the defile, took up a position above Allifae, in a strong and elevated place. Then Hannibal, pretending to march to Rome through Samnium, came back as far as the Peligni, spreading devastation. Fabius led his troops along the heights midway between the army of the enemy and the city of Rome; neither avoiding him altogether, nor coming to an engagement. From the Peligni the Carthaginian turned his course, and going back again to Apulia, reached Geronium, a city deserted by its inhabitants from fear, as a part of its walls had fallen down together in ruins. The dictator formed a completely fortified camp in the territory of Larinum, and being recalled thence to Rome on account of some sacred rites, he not only urged the master of the horse, in virtue of his authority, but with advice and almost with prayers, that he would trust rather to prudence than fortune; and imitate him as a general rather than Sempronius and Flaminius; that he would not suppose that nothing had been achieved by having worn out nearly the whole summer in baffling the enemy; that physicians too sometimes gained more by rest than by motion and action. That it was no small thing to have ceased to be conquered by an enemy so often victorious, and to have taken breath after successive disasters. Having thus unavailingly admonished the master of the horse, he set out for Rome.

Fabius noticed the commotion but, thinking it was a trap and reluctant to engage in battle—especially at night—kept his troops inside the fortifications. At dawn, a battle broke out at the mountain's summit, where the Romans, significantly outnumbering the light-armed enemy, would have easily overwhelmed them, cut off as they were from their group, if not for a cohort of Spaniards that Hannibal had sent back for that very reason. These troops, being more familiar with mountainous terrain and better suited for skirmishing among the rocks and cliffs due to their agility and the design of their weapons, easily outmaneuvered an enemy that was heavily armed and used to combat on flat ground. After separating from such an unequal fight, they returned to their camps, with most of the Spaniards remaining unscathed and the Romans losing a few. Fabius also moved his camp and, after passing through the narrow pass, set up in a strong, elevated position above Allifae. Then Hannibal, pretending to march towards Rome through Samnium, turned back towards the Peligni, causing destruction along the way. Fabius led his troops along the heights, positioning them halfway between Hannibal’s army and Rome; he neither avoided him completely nor engaged in battle. From the Peligni, the Carthaginian changed direction and returned to Apulia, reaching Geronium, a city abandoned by its people out of fear, as part of its walls had crumbled into ruins. The dictator established a fully fortified camp in the Larinum area and, having been called back to Rome for some religious rites, urged the master of the horse not only as a leader but with advice and almost pleas to prioritize wisdom over luck; to follow his example as a general rather than emulate Sempronius and Flaminius; and not to underestimate the progress made by spending nearly the entire summer frustrating the enemy; that even doctors sometimes benefit more from rest than constant action. It was no small achievement to have stopped being defeated by an enemy that had been victorious so many times, and to have caught their breath after a series of misfortunes. After giving this advice to the master of the horse in vain, he set off for Rome.

19

In the beginning of the summer in which these events occurred, the war commenced by land and sea in Spain also. To the number of ships which he had received from his brother, equipped and ready for action, Hasdrubal added ten. The fleet of forty ships he delivered to Himilco: and thus setting out from Carthage, kept his ships near the land, while he led his army along the shore, ready to engage with whichever part of his forces the enemy might fall in with. Cneius Scipio, when he heard that the enemy had quitted his winter quarters, at first formed the same plan; but afterwards, not daring to engage him by land, from a great rumour of fresh auxiliaries, he advances to meet him with a fleet of thirty-five ships, having put some chosen soldiers on board. Setting out from Tarraco, on the second day, he reached a convenient station, ten miles from the mouth of the Iberus. Two ships of the Massilians, sent forward from that place reconnoitering, brought word back that the Carthaginian fleet was stationed in the mouth of the river, and that the camp was pitched upon the bank. In order, therefore, to overpower them while off their guard and incautious, by a universal and wide-spread terror, he weighed anchor and advanced. In Spain there are several towers placed in high situations, which they employ both as watch-towers and as places of defence against pirates. From them first, a view of the ships of the enemy having been obtained, the signal was given to Hasdrubal; and a tumult arose in the camp, and on land sooner than on the ships and at sea; the dashing of the oars and other nautical noises not being yet distinctly heard, nor the promontories disclosing the fleet. Upon this, suddenly one horseman after another, sent out by Hasdrubal, orders those who were strolling upon the shore or resting quietly in their tents, expecting any thing rather than the enemy and a battle on that day, immediately to embark and take up arms: that the Roman fleet was now a short distance from the harbour. The horsemen, despatched in every direction, delivered these orders; and presently Hasdrubal himself comes up with the main army. All places resound with noises of various kinds; the soldiers and rowers hurrying together to the ships, rather like men running away from the land than marching to battle. Scarcely had all embarked, when some, unfastening the hawsers, are carried out against the anchors; others cut their cables, that nothing might impede them; and by doing every thing with hurry and precipitation, the duties of mariners were impeded by the preparations of the soldiers, and the soldiers were prevented from taking and preparing for action their arms, by the bustle of the mariners. And now the Roman was not only approaching, but had drawn up his ships for the battle. The Carthaginians, therefore, thrown into disorder, not more by the enemy and the battle than by their own tumult, having rather made an attempt at fighting than commenced a battle, turned their fleet for flight; and as the mouth of the river which was before them could not be entered in so broad a line, and by so many pressing in at the same time, they ran their ships on shore in every part. And being received, some in the shallows, and others on the dry shore, some armed and some unarmed, they escaped to their friends, who were drawn up in battle-array over the shore. Two Carthaginian ships were captured and four sunk on the first encounter.

At the start of the summer when these events took place, the war began by land and sea in Spain as well. Hasdrubal, having received a number of ships from his brother, added ten more that were equipped and ready for action. He handed over the fleet of forty ships to Himilco and set out from Carthage, keeping his ships close to the shore while leading his army along the coast, prepared to engage whichever part of his forces encountered the enemy. Cneius Scipio, upon hearing that the enemy had left their winter quarters, initially devised a similar plan; however, after learning about rumors of fresh reinforcements, he decided not to engage on land. Instead, he advanced to meet the enemy with a fleet of thirty-five ships, sending some elite soldiers onboard. Departing from Tarraco, he reached a suitable spot ten miles from the mouth of the Iberus on the second day. Two ships from Massilia, sent ahead to scout, reported back that the Carthaginian fleet was stationed at the river's mouth and that the camp was set up on the bank. To catch them off guard and instill widespread fear, he weighed anchor and advanced. In Spain, there are several towers located in high positions used for both lookout and defense against pirates. From these towers, they first spotted the enemy's ships and signaled Hasdrubal, causing a commotion in the camp before the sounds of oars and other nautical noises were clearly heard or the fleet revealed itself. Consequently, Hasdrubal quickly sent out horsemen who ordered those strolling on the shore or relaxing in their tents—expecting anything but battle on that day—to immediately board the ships and prepare for action since the Roman fleet was now nearby. The horsemen spread these orders in all directions, and soon Hasdrubal himself arrived with the main army. There was a clamor of noise from all around; soldiers and rowers rushed to the ships, moving more like people fleeing land than marching to battle. Just as everyone was aboard, some untied the ropes and were pulled toward the anchors, while others cut their cables to avoid any delays. In the flurry, the mariners' tasks were hindered by the soldiers’ preparations, and the soldiers struggled to get ready for action due to the chaos among the mariners. Now, the Romans were not only approaching but had also formed their ships for battle. The Carthaginians, thus thrown into disarray—more by their own confusion than by the enemy or the conflict—attempted to fight but ultimately turned their fleet to retreat. Unable to enter the river’s mouth in such a broad line with so many pressing at once, they ran their ships aground everywhere. Some were received in shallow waters, others on dry land, some armed and some not, and they fled to their allies, who were drawn up in battle array along the shore. Two Carthaginian ships were captured, and four were sunk in the initial encounter.

20

The Romans, though the enemy was master of the shore, and they saw armed troops lining the whole bank, promptly pursuing the discomfited fleet of the enemy, towed out into the deep all the ships which had not either shattered their prows by the violence with which they struck the shore, or set their keels fast in the shallows. They captured as many as twenty-five out of forty. Nor was that the most splendid result of their victory: but they became masters of the whole sea on that coast by one slight battle; advancing, then, with their fleet to Honosca, and making a descent from the ships upon the coast, when they had taken the city by storm and pillaged it, they afterwards made for Carthage: then devastating the whole surrounding country, they, lastly, set fire also to the buildings contiguous to the wall and gates. Thence the fleet laden with plunder, arrived at Longuntica, where a great quantity of oakum for naval purposes had been collected by Hasdrubal: of this, taking away as much as was sufficient for their necessities, they burnt all the rest. Nor did they only sail by the prominent coasts of the continent, but crossed over into the island Ebusus; where, having with the utmost exertion, but in vain, carried on operations against the city, which is the capital of the island, for two days, when they found that time was wasted to no purpose upon a hopeless task, they turned their efforts to the devastation of the country; and having plundered and fired several villages, and acquired a greater booty than they had obtained on the continent, they retired to their ships, when ambassadors from the Baliares came to Scipio to sue for peace. From this place the fleet sailed back, and returned to the hither parts of the province, whither ambassadors of all the people who dwell on the Iberus, and of many people in the most distant parts of Spain, assembled. But the number of states who really became subject to the authority and dominion of the Romans, and gave hostages, amounted to upwards of one hundred and twenty. The Roman therefore, relying sufficiently on his land forces also, advanced as far as the pass of Castulo. Hasdrubal retired into Lusitania, and nearer the ocean.

The Romans, even though the enemy controlled the shore and saw armed troops lining the entire bank, quickly pursued the defeated enemy fleet, towing out into the deep all the ships that had not either damaged their prows from crashing into the shore or gotten stuck in the shallows. They captured about twenty-five out of forty. But that wasn’t even the best outcome of their victory: they took control of the entire sea along that coast with just one minor battle; then, with their fleet advancing to Honosca, they landed from their ships on the coast. After storming and looting the city, they headed towards Carthage. They devastated the entire surrounding area and eventually set fire to the buildings next to the wall and gates. From there, the fleet, loaded with loot, arrived at Longuntica, where a large amount of oakum for shipbuilding had been gathered by Hasdrubal. They took as much as they needed and burned the rest. They didn't just sail along the prominent coasts of the continent but crossed over to the island of Ebusus. After making a strenuous but unsuccessful effort to attack the city, which is the capital of the island, for two days, they realized they were wasting their time on a hopeless task. They then focused on ravaging the countryside, plundering and burning several villages, and collecting more loot than they had on the continent. They returned to their ships just as ambassadors from the Balearics came to Scipio seeking peace. From this place, the fleet sailed back and returned to the nearer parts of the province, where ambassadors from all the people dwelling along the Iberus and many from the farthest reaches of Spain gathered. However, the number of states that actually submitted to Roman authority and offered hostages was over one hundred and twenty. The Roman, therefore, feeling confident in his land forces as well, advanced as far as the pass of Castulo. Hasdrubal withdrew into Lusitania, closer to the ocean.

21

After this, it seemed probable that the remainder of the summer would be peaceful; and so it would have been with regard to the Punic enemy: but besides that the tempers of the Spaniards themselves are naturally restless, and eager for innovation, Mandonius, together with Indibilis, who had formerly been petty prince of the Ilergetes, having stirred up their countrymen, came to lay waste the peaceful country of the Roman allies, after the Romans had retired from the pass to the sea-coast. A military tribune with some light-armed auxiliaries being sent against these by Scipio, with a small effort put them all to the rout, as being but a disorderly band: some having been captured and slain, a great portion of them were deprived of their arms. This disturbance, however, brought back Hasdrubal, who was retiring to the ocean, to protect his allies on this side the Iberus. The Carthaginian camp was in the territory of Ilercao, the Roman camp at the New Fleet, when unexpected intelligence turned the war into another quarter. The Celtiberians, who had sent the chief men of their country as ambassadors to the Romans, and had given them hostages, aroused by a message from Scipio, take up arms and invade the province of the Carthaginians with a powerful army; take three towns by storm; and after that, encountering Hasdrubal himself in two battles with, splendid success, slew fifteen thousand and captured four thousand, together with many military standards.

After this, it seemed likely that the rest of the summer would be peaceful; and it probably would have been regarding the Punic enemy: but besides that, the temperaments of the Spaniards are naturally restless and eager for change. Mandonius, along with Indibilis, who had once been a petty prince of the Ilergetes, incited their fellow countrymen and came to raid the peaceful lands of the Roman allies after the Romans had retreated from the pass to the coast. A military tribune, sent by Scipio with some light-armed auxiliaries, quickly defeated them, as they were just a disorganized group: some were captured and killed, and a large portion lost their weapons. This disturbance, however, caused Hasdrubal, who was heading to the ocean, to return to defend his allies on this side of the Iberus. The Carthaginian camp was in the territory of Ilercao, while the Roman camp was at the New Fleet, when unexpected news shifted the war in another direction. The Celtiberians, who had sent their top leaders as ambassadors to the Romans and had given them hostages, were provoked by a message from Scipio. They took up arms and invaded the Carthaginian province with a strong army; they captured three towns in a furious assault and then faced Hasdrubal in two battles with great success, killing fifteen thousand and capturing four thousand, along with many military standards.

22

This being the state of affairs in Spain, Publius Scipio came into his province, having been sent thither by the senate, his command being continued to him after his consulate, with thirty long ships, eight thousand soldiers, and a large importation of provisions. That fleet, swelled to an enormous size by a multitude of transports, being descried at a distance, entered safe the port of Tarraco, to the great joy of the citizens and allies. Landing his troops there, Scipio set out and formed a junction with his brother, and thenceforward they prosecuted the war with united courage and counsels. While the Carthaginians, therefore, were occupied with the Celtiberian war, they promptly crossed the Iberus, and not seeing any enemy, pursue their course to Saguntum; for it was reported that the hostages from every part of Spain, having been consigned to custody, were kept in the citadel of that place under a small guard. That pledge alone checked the affections of all the people of Spain, which were inclined towards an alliance with the Romans; lest the guilt of their defection should be expiated with the blood of their children. One man, by a stratagem more subtle than honourable, liberated the Spaniards from this restraint. There was at Saguntum a noble Spaniard, named Abelux, hitherto faithful to the Carthaginians, but now (such are for the most part the dispositions of barbarians) had changed his attachment with fortune; but considering that a deserter going over to enemies without the betraying of something valuable, would be looked upon only as a stigmatized and worthless individual, was solicitous to render as great a service as possible to his new confederates. Having turned over in his mind, then, the various means which, under the favour of fortune, he might employ, in preference to every other, he applied himself to the delivering up of the hostages; concluding that this one thing, above all others, would gain the Romans the friendship of the Spanish chieftains. But since he knew that the guards of the hostages would do nothing without the authority of Bostar, the governor, he addresses himself with craft to Bostar himself. Bostar had his camp without the city, just upon the shore, in order to preclude the approach of the Romans from that quarter. He informs him, taken aside to a secret place, and as if uninformed, in what position affairs were: "That hitherto fear had withheld the minds of the Spaniards to them, because the Romans were at a great distance: that now the Roman camp was on this side the Iberus, a secure fortress and asylum for such as desired a change, that therefore those whom fear could not bind should be attached by kindness and favour." When Bostar, in astonishment, earnestly asked him, what sudden gift of so much importance that could be, he replied, "Send back the hostages to their states: this will be an acceptable boon, privately to their parents, who possess the greatest influence in their respective states, and publicly to the people. Every man wishes to have confidence reposed in him; and confidence reposed generally enforces the fidelity itself. The office of restoring the hostages to their homes, I request for myself; that I may enhance my project by the trouble bestowed, and that I may add as much value as I can to a service in its own intrinsic nature so acceptable." When he had persuaded the man, who was not cunning as compared with Carthaginian minds in general, having gone secretly and by night to the outposts of the enemy, he met with some auxiliary Spaniards; and having been brought by them into the presence of Scipio, he explains what brought him. Pledges of fidelity having been given and received, and the time and place for delivering the hostages having been appointed, he returns to Saguntum. The following day he spent with Bostar, in taking his commands for effecting the business; having so arranged it, that he should go by night, in order that he might escape the observation of the enemy, he was dismissed; and awakening the guards of the youths at the hour agreed upon with them, set out and led them, as if unconsciously, into a snare prepared by his own deceit. They were brought to the Roman camp, and every thing else respecting the restoration of the hostages was transacted as had been agreed upon with Bostar, and in the same course as if the affair had been carried on in the name of the Carthaginians. But the favour of the Romans was somewhat greater than that of the Carthaginians would have been in a similar case; for misfortune and fear might have seemed to have softened them, who had been found oppressive and haughty in prosperity. The Roman, on the contrary, on his first arrival, having been unknown to them before, had begun with an act of clemency and liberality: and Abelux, a man of prudence, did not seem likely to have changed his allies without good cause. Accordingly all began, with great unanimity, to meditate a revolt; and hostilities would immediately have commenced, had not the winter intervened, which compelled the Romans, and the Carthaginians also, to retire to shelter.

This being the situation in Spain, Publius Scipio arrived in his province, having been sent there by the Senate, with his command continuing after his consulate, along with thirty warships, eight thousand soldiers, and a large amount of supplies. That fleet, expanded to a huge size by many transports, was spotted from a distance as it safely entered the port of Tarraco, bringing great joy to the citizens and allies. After landing his troops there, Scipio set out to join his brother, and from then on they pursued the war with united courage and strategy. While the Carthaginians were preoccupied with the Celtiberian war, they quickly crossed the Iberus and, not seeing any enemy, made their way to Saguntum; reports indicated that hostages from all over Spain were being held in the citadel of that place under a small guard. This pledge alone kept the people of Spain, who were inclined to ally with the Romans, from fully embracing that alliance, fearing that their betrayal would cost their children’s lives. One man, using a more cunning than honorable trick, freed the Spaniards from this burden. At Saguntum, there was a noble Spaniard named Abelux, who had previously been loyal to the Carthaginians, but now (as is often the case with barbarians) had changed his allegiance with fortune; however, knowing that a deserter who crossed over to the enemy without betraying something valuable would be seen as a disgraceful and worthless person, he sought to provide the greatest service possible to his new allies. Considering various ways he could, with fortune’s favor, be of help, he decided to hand over the hostages, believing this action alone would win the Romans the friendship of the Spanish leaders. But since he knew that the guards of the hostages would do nothing without the authorization of Bostar, the governor, he cleverly approached Bostar himself. Bostar had his camp outside the city, right by the shore, to block the Romans' approach from that direction. In a private conversation, he informed him of the current state of affairs: "So far, fear has kept the Spaniards from you because the Romans were quite a distance away; but now, with the Roman camp on this side of the Iberus, there is a secure fortress and refuge for those who desire a change, so those whom fear cannot hold should be won over with kindness and favor.” When Bostar, confused, asked him what important gift he meant, he replied, "Send the hostages back to their homes: it will be a welcome favor, privately to their parents, who hold significant influence in their cities, and publicly to the people. Everyone wants to have trust placed in them; and trust usually encourages loyalty. I request the task of restoring the hostages myself to enhance my project through the effort involved, adding as much value as I can to a service that is already so beneficial." Once he had convinced Bostar, who was not particularly crafty compared to typical Carthaginian minds, he secretly and at night went to the enemy’s outposts and met with some Spanish auxiliaries; when they brought him before Scipio, he explained his purpose. After making pledges of loyalty and arranging the time and place for delivering the hostages, he returned to Saguntum. The next day he spent with Bostar, discussing the steps to accomplish the task; having planned to go at night to avoid enemy detection, he was sent off. When the time came, he woke the guards of the youths and led them, as if unaware, into a trap he had set himself. They were brought to the Roman camp, and everything regarding the return of the hostages was carried out as previously arranged with Bostar, proceeding as if the operation had been conducted in the name of the Carthaginians. But the Romans’ favor was greater than what the Carthaginians would have offered in similar circumstances; misfortune and fear might have caused the Carthaginians to soften, having been perceived as oppressive and prideful in times of success. The Romans, on the other hand, had made a first impression of clemency and generosity upon arriving, and Abelux, a wise man, didn’t seem likely to switch alliances without good reason. Consequently, everyone began, with great agreement, to think of a revolt; and hostilities would have soon started, had not winter intervened, forcing both the Romans and the Carthaginians to seek shelter.

23

Such were the transactions in Spain also during the second summer of the Punic war; while in Italy the prudent delay of Fabius had procured the Romans some intermission from disasters; which conduct, as it kept Hannibal disturbed with no ordinary degree of anxiety, for it proved to him that the Romans had at length selected a general who would carry on the war with prudence, and not in dependence on fortune; so was it treated with contempt by his countrymen, both in the camp and in the city; particularly after that a battle had been fought during his absence from the temerity of the master of the horse, in its issue, as I may justly designate it, rather joyful than successful. Two causes were added to augment the unpopularity of the dictator: one arising out of a stratagem and artful procedure of Hannibal; for the farm of the dictator having been pointed out to him by deserters, he ordered that the fire and sword and every outrage of enemies should be restrained from it alone, while all around were levelled with the ground; in order that it might appear to have been the term of some secret compact: the other from an act of his own, at first perhaps suspicious, because in it he had not waited for the authority of the senate, but in the result turning unequivocally to his highest credit, with relation to the exchange of prisoners: for, as was the case in the first Punic war, an agreement had been made between the Roman and Carthaginian generals, that whichever received more prisoners than he restored, should give two pounds and a half of silver for every man. And when the Roman had received two hundred and forty-seven more than the Carthaginian, and the silver which was due for them, after the matter had been frequently agitated in the senate, was not promptly supplied, because he had not consulted the fathers, he sent his son Quintus to Rome and sold his farm, uninjured by the enemy, and thus redeemed the public credit at his own private expense. Hannibal lay in a fixed camp before the walls of Geronium, which city he had captured and burnt, leaving only a few buildings for the purpose of granaries: thence he was in the habit of sending out two-thirds of his forces to forage; with the third part kept in readiness, he himself remained on guard, both as a protection to his camp, and for the purpose of looking out, if from any quarter an attack should be made upon his foragers.

The events unfolded similarly in Spain during the second summer of the Punic War. Meanwhile, in Italy, Fabius's cautious approach provided the Romans a brief respite from disasters. This strategy unsettled Hannibal, as it demonstrated that the Romans had finally chosen a general who would fight wisely rather than relying on luck. However, many of his countrymen, both in the camp and in the city, looked down on Fabius, especially after a battle had taken place during his absence due to the recklessness of the master of the horse, which, as I might describe it, turned out to be more fortunate than successful. Two factors compounded the dictator's unpopularity: one stemming from Hannibal's clever tactics; after deserters pointed out the dictator's farm, Hannibal commanded that it be spared from destruction while everything around it was laid to waste, making it seem like the result of a secret deal. The second cause arose from an action by Fabius himself, which was initially questioned because he hadn't waited for the senate's approval but ultimately turned out to be a smart move regarding the exchange of prisoners. Just like in the first Punic War, an agreement had been established between the Roman and Carthaginian generals that whoever took more prisoners than they returned would pay two and a half pounds of silver for each one. When the Romans ended up with two hundred forty-seven more prisoners than the Carthaginians, and the silver owed for them wasn’t provided swiftly since he hadn't consulted the senate, he sent his son Quintus to Rome and sold his farm, untouched by the enemy, to restore public trust at his personal expense. Hannibal had set up a solid camp outside the walls of Geronium, a city he had captured and burned, leaving only a few buildings for granaries. He regularly sent out two-thirds of his forces to gather supplies, while keeping one-third ready for defense, watching for any attacks on his foragers.

24

The Roman army was at that time in the territory of Larinum. Minucius, the master of the horse, had the command of it; the dictator, as was before mentioned, having gone to the city. But the camp, which had been pitched in an elevated and secure situation, was now brought down into the plain; plans of a bolder character, agreeably with the temper of the general, were in agitation; and either an attack was to be made upon the scattered foragers, or upon the camp now left with an inconsiderable guard. Nor did it escape the observation of Hannibal, that the plan of the war had been changed with the general, and that the enemy would act with more boldness than counsel. Hannibal himself too, which one would scarcely credit, though the enemy was near, despatched a third part of his troops to forage, retaining the remaining two-thirds in the camp. After that he advanced his camp itself nearer to the enemy, to a hill within the enemy's view, nearly two miles from Geronium; that they might be aware that he was on the alert to protect his foragers if any attack should be made upon them. Then he discovered an eminence nearer to, and commanding the very camp of the Romans: and because if he marched openly in the day-time to occupy it, the enemy would doubtless anticipate him by a shorter way, the Numidians having been sent privately in the night, took possession of it. These, occupying this position, the Romans, the next day, despising the smallness of their numbers, dislodge, and transfer their camp thither themselves. There was now, therefore, but a very small space between rampart and rampart, and that the Roman line had almost entirely filled; at the same time the cavalry, with the light infantry sent out against the foragers through the opposite part of the camp, effected a slaughter and flight of the scattered enemy far and wide. Nor dared Hannibal hazard a regular battle; because with so few troops, that he would scarcely be able to protect his camp if attacked. And now he carried on the war (for part of his army was away) according to the plans of Fabius, by sitting still and creating delays. He had also withdrawn his troops to their former camp, which was before the walls of Geronium. Some authors affirm that they fought in regular line, and with encountering standards; that in the first encounter the Carthaginian was driven in disorder quite to his camp; but that, a sally thence having been suddenly made all at once, the Romans in their turn became alarmed; that after that the battle was restored by the arrival of Numerius Decimius the Samnite; that this man, the first in family and fortune, not only in Bovianum, whence he came, but in all Samnium, when conducting by command of the dictator to the camp eight thousand infantry and five hundred horse, having shown himself on the rear of Hannibal, seemed to both parties to be a fresh reinforcement coming with Quintus Fabius from Rome; that Hannibal, fearing also some ambuscade, withdrew his troops; and that the Roman, aided by the Samnite, pursuing him, took by storm two forts on that day; that six thousand of the enemy were slain, and about five thousand of the Romans; but that though the loss was so nearly equal, intelligence was conveyed to Rome of a signal victory; and a letter from the master of the horse still more presumptuous.

The Roman army was then in the territory of Larinum. Minucius, the master of the horse, was in command since the dictator had gone to the city. However, the camp, which had been set up in a high and safe location, was moved down into the plain; the general was considering more daring plans, either to attack the scattered foragers or the camp that had only a small guard left. Hannibal noticed that the enemy's strategy had changed with their general and that they would act more boldly than wisely. Surprisingly, even with the enemy nearby, Hannibal sent a third of his troops out to forage, keeping the remaining two-thirds in camp. He then moved his camp closer to the enemy to a hill within their sight, about two miles from Geronium, to show he was ready to protect his foragers if they were attacked. Then he spotted a higher ground closer to and commanding the Roman camp; since marching openly during the day would alert the enemy, he secretly sent the Numidians to take control of it at night. The next day, in their overconfidence about their small numbers, the Romans moved their camp there. There was now very little space between the two camps, and the Roman line had almost completely filled it; at the same time, cavalry and light infantry sent out against the foragers managed to slaughter and chase off the scattered enemy. Hannibal did not dare risk a full battle because he had so few troops that he wouldn’t be able to defend his camp if it were attacked. He continued the war (since part of his army was away) by following Fabius's strategy of staying put and delaying. He also pulled his troops back to their original camp near the walls of Geronium. Some historians claim they fought in a regular formation, with standards facing each other; in the first clash, the Carthaginians were driven back to their camp in disorder. However, when they suddenly launched a counterattack from there, the Romans became alarmed. The battle was then stabilized by the arrival of Numerius Decimius the Samnite, a man of high standing and wealth not only in Bovianum, his hometown, but throughout all of Samnium. He had been sent by the dictator with eight thousand infantry and five hundred cavalry to the camp, and upon showing himself behind Hannibal’s forces, he appeared to both sides as a fresh reinforcement arriving from Quintus Fabius in Rome. Hannibal, fearing a trap, withdrew his troops, and the Romans, aided by the Samnites, pursued him, capturing two forts that day. About six thousand of the enemy were killed, and around five thousand Romans fell, but despite the near-equal losses, news of a significant victory reached Rome, along with an even more arrogant letter from the master of the horse.

25

These things were very frequently discussed, both in the senate and assemblies. When the dictator alone, while joy pervaded the city, attached no credit to the report or letter; and granting that all were true, affirmed that he feared more from success than failure; then Marcus Metilius, a Plebeian tribune, declares that such conduct surely could not be endured. That the dictator, not only when present was an obstacle to the right management of the affair, but also being absent from the camp, opposed it still when achieved; that he studiously dallied in his conduct of the war, that he might continue the longer in office, and that he might have the sole command both at Rome and in the army. Since one of the consuls had fallen in battle, and the other was removed to a distance from Italy, under pretext of pursuing a Carthaginian fleet; and the two praetors were occupied in Sicily and Sardinia, neither of which provinces required a praetor at this time. That Marcus Minucius, the master of the horse, was almost put under a guard, lest he should see the enemy, and carry on any warlike operation. That therefore, by Hercules, not only Samnium, which had now been yielded to the Carthaginians, as if it had been land beyond the Iberus, but the Campanian, Calenian, and Falernian territories had been devastated, while the dictator was sitting down at Casilinum, protecting his own farm with the legions of the Roman people: that the army, eager for battle, as well as the master of the horse, were kept back almost imprisoned within the rampart: that their arms were taken out of their hands, as from captured enemies: at length, as soon as ever the dictator had gone away, having marched out beyond their rampart, that they had routed the enemy and put him to flight. On account of which circumstances, had the Roman commons retained their ancient spirit, that he would have boldly proposed to them to annul the authority of Quintus Fabius; but now he would bring forward a moderate proposition, to make the authority of the master of the horse and the dictator equal; and that even then Quintus Fabius should not be sent to the army, till he had substituted a consul in the room of Caius Flaminius. The dictator kept away from the popular assemblies, in which he did not command a favourable hearing, and even in the senate he was not heard with favourable ears, when his eloquence was employed in praising the enemy, and attributing the disasters of the last two years to the temerity and unskilfulness of the generals; and when he declared that the master of the horse ought to be called to account for having fought contrary to his injunction. That "if the supreme command and administration of affairs were intrusted to him, he would soon take care that men should know, that to a good general fortune was not of great importance; that prudence and conduct governed every thing; that it was more glorious for him to have saved the army at a crisis, and without disgrace, than to have slain many thousands of the enemy." Speeches of this kind having been made without effect, and Marcus Atilius Regulus created consul, that he might not be present to dispute respecting the right of command, he withdrew to the army on the night preceding the day on which the proposition was to be decided. When there was an assembly of the people at break of day, a secret displeasure towards the dictator, and favour towards the master of the horse, rather possessed their minds, than that men had not sufficient resolution to advise a measure which was agreeable to the public; and though favour carried it, influence was wanting to the bill. One man indeed was found who recommended the law, Caius Terentius Varro, who had been praetor in the former year, sprung not only from humble but mean parentage. They report that his father was a butcher, the retailer of his own meat, and that he employed this very son in the servile offices of that trade.

These topics were often discussed in both the Senate and public assemblies. When the dictator, while the city was filled with joy, dismissed the report or letter without any regard; and even if all was true, declared that he feared success more than failure; Marcus Metilius, a Plebeian tribune, stated that such behavior was intolerable. He argued that the dictator, even when present, was an obstacle to effectively managing the situation, and even when absent from the camp, he still obstructed it after it was achieved; that he deliberately delayed his conduct of the war so he could stay in power longer and maintain sole command both in Rome and in the army. Since one of the consuls had died in battle and the other was away from Italy, supposedly chasing a Carthaginian fleet; and the two praetors were busy in Sicily and Sardinia, neither of which needed a praetor at that moment. Marcus Minucius, the master of the horse, was nearly kept under guard to prevent him from confronting the enemy and engaging in any military action. Therefore, it seemed that not only Samnium, which had now been surrendered to the Carthaginians as if it were land beyond the Iberus, but also the Campanian, Calenian, and Falernian regions had suffered devastation, while the dictator sat at Casilinum, protecting his own estate with the legions of the Roman people: that the army, eager for battle as well as the master of the horse, were essentially confined within their fortifications: that their weapons were taken from their hands, like those of defeated foes: finally, as soon as the dictator had departed, they marched beyond their defenses and routed the enemy, sending them into flight. Because of these circumstances, had the Roman citizens held onto their former spirit, he would have bravely proposed to them to revoke Quintus Fabius's authority; but now he would present a moderate proposal, to make the master of the horse's authority equal to that of the dictator; and even then, Quintus Fabius should not be sent to the army until he appointed a consul to replace Caius Flaminius. The dictator avoided popular assemblies, where he did not receive a favorable reception, and even in the Senate, he was not well-received when his speeches praised the enemy and blamed the generals for the disasters of the last two years; and when he stated that the master of the horse should be held accountable for acting against his orders. He declared, "If I were entrusted with the highest command and management of affairs, I would soon ensure everyone knows that for a good general, luck isn't crucial; that wisdom and strategy rule everything; that it is more honorable to have saved the army at a critical moment, without disgrace, than to have killed many thousands of the enemy." After such speeches proved ineffective, and with Marcus Atilius Regulus appointed consul, to avoid a dispute over the command, he retreated to the army on the night before the proposal was to be decided. When a public assembly gathered at dawn, a hidden discontent towards the dictator and support for the master of the horse filled their minds, rather than a lack of resolve to support a measure favorable to the public; and while support swayed the decision, there was not enough influence behind the bill. One man did arise in favor of the law, Caius Terentius Varro, who had been praetor the previous year, coming from not just humble but lowly origins. It is said that his father was a butcher, selling his own meat, and that he made this very son perform menial tasks associated with that trade.

26

This young man, when a fortune left him by his father, acquired in such a traffic, had inspired him with the hope of a higher condition, and the gown and forum were the objects of his choice, by declaiming vehemently in behalf of men and causes of the lowest kind, in opposition to the interest and character of the good, first came to the notice of the people, and then to offices of honour. Having passed through the offices of quaestor, plebeian, and curule aedile, and, lastly, that of praetor; when now he raised his mind to the hope of the consulship, he courted the gale of popular favour by maligning the dictator, and received alone the credit of the decree of the people. All men, both at Rome and in the army, both friends and foes, except the dictator himself, considered this measure to have been passed as an insult to him; but the dictator himself bore the wrong which the infuriated people had put upon him, with the same gravity with which he endured the charges against him which his enemies laid before the multitude; and receiving the letter containing a decree of the senate respecting the equalization of the command while on his journey, satisfied that an equal share of military skill was not imparted together with the equal share of command, he returned to the army with a mind unsubdued alike by his fellow-citizens and by the enemy.

This young man, having inherited a fortune from his father through such dealings, was filled with the hope of achieving a better status. He aimed for the toga and the courtroom, passionately advocating for individuals and causes of the lowest status, going against the interests and values of the good. This brought him to public attention and eventually to prestigious positions. After serving as quaestor, a plebeian aedile, and a curule aedile, and finally as praetor, he set his sights on the consulship. To gain public favor, he criticized the dictator and took sole credit for a decree from the people. Everyone, both in Rome and in the army—friends and enemies alike, except for the dictator himself—saw this move as an insult to him. However, the dictator accepted the slight from the angry populace with the same seriousness he showed towards the accusations his enemies made against him in front of the public. When he received a letter about a senate decree regarding the equal distribution of command on his journey, he understood that equal military skill did not come with equal command. He returned to the army, unshaken by either his fellow citizens or the enemy.

27

But Minucius, who, in consequence of his success and the favour of the populace, was scarcely endurable before now especially, unrestrained by shame or moderation, boasted not more in having conquered Hannibal than Quintus Fabius. "That he, who had been sought out in their distress as the only general, and as a match for Hannibal; that he, an event which no record of history contains, was by the order of the people placed upon an equal footing with himself,--a superior with an inferior officer, a dictator with a master of the horse,--in that very city wherein the masters of the horse are wont to crouch and tremble at the rods and axes of the dictator. With such splendour had his valour and success shone forth. That he therefore would follow up his own good fortune, though the dictator persisted in his delay and sloth; measures condemned alike by the sentence of gods and men." Accordingly, on the first day on which he met Quintus Fabius, he intimated "that the first point to be settled was the manner in which they should employ the command thus equalized. That he was of opinion that the best plan would be for them to be invested with the supreme authority and command either on alternate days, or, if longer intervals were more agreeable, for any determinate periods; in order that the person in command might be a match for the enemy, not only in judgment, but in strength, if any opportunity for action should occur." Fabius by no means approved of this proposition: he said, "that Fortune would have at her disposal all things which the rashness of his colleague had; that his command had been shared with him, and not taken away; that he would never, therefore, willingly withdraw from conducting the war, in whatever post he could with prudence and discretion: nor would he divide the command with him with respect to times or days, but that he would divide the army, and that he would preserve, by his own measures, so much as he could, since it was not allowed him to save the whole." Thus he carried it, that, as was the custom of consuls, they should divide the legions between them: the first and fourth fell to the lot of Minucius, the second and third to Fabius. They likewise divided equally between them the cavalry, the auxiliaries of the allies and of the Latin name. The master of the horse was desirous also that they should have separate camps.

But Minucius, who, thanks to his success and the support of the public, was now barely tolerable, especially unrestrained by shame or moderation, bragged as much about defeating Hannibal as Quintus Fabius did. "He, who had been sought out in their time of need as the only general who could match Hannibal; that he, in an event not recorded in any history, was placed on equal terms with himself by the people's order—like a superior standing with a subordinate, a dictator alongside a master of the horse— in the very city where horsemasters usually cower before the rods and axes of the dictator. His bravery and success shone so brightly. Therefore, he would follow up his own good fortune, even though the dictator continued to delay and slack off; actions condemned by both gods and men." So, on the first day he met Quintus Fabius, he suggested "the first issue to tackle was how they should manage their equal command. He thought it would be best if they took turns with the supreme authority, either on alternate days or, if longer periods were preferable, for set intervals; so that whoever was in charge could match the enemy not just in judgment but in strength, should any chance for action arise." Fabius did not agree at all with this idea; he stated, "that Fortune would manage everything that his colleague's recklessness had; that his command had been shared and not taken away; that he would never willingly step back from leading the war, no matter what position he could prudently and wisely hold: nor would he share command with him by times or days, but he would divide the army, preserving as much as he could by his own actions, since he could not save it all." Thus, he decided, as was customary for consuls, that they should split the legions: the first and fourth went to Minucius, the second and third to Fabius. They also equally shared the cavalry, the allies' auxiliaries, and the Latin troops. The master of the horse also wanted them to have separate camps.

28

From this Hannibal derived a twofold joy, for nothing which was going on among the enemy escaped him, the deserters revealing many things, and he himself examining by his own scouts. For he considered that he should be able to entrap the unrestrained temerity of Minucius by his usual arts, and that half the force of the sagacity of Fabius had vanished. There was an eminence between the camps of Minucius and the Carthaginians, whoever occupied it would evidently render the position of his enemy less advantageous. Hannibal was not so desirous of gaining it without a contest, though that were worth his while, as to bring on a quarrel with Minucius, who, he well knew, would at all times throw himself in his way to oppose him. All the intervening ground was at first sight unavailable to one who wished to plant an ambuscade, because it not only had not any part that was woody, but none even covered with brambles, but in reality formed by nature to cover an ambush, so much the more, because no such deception could be apprehended in a naked valley and there were in its curvatures hollow rocks, such that some of them were capable of containing two hundred armed men. Within these recesses, five thousand infantry and cavalry are secreted, as many as could conveniently occupy each. Lest, however, in any part, either the motion of any one of them thoughtlessly coming out, or the glittering of their arms, should discover the stratagem in so open a valley, by sending out a few troops at break of day to occupy the before-mentioned eminence, he diverts the attention of the enemy. Immediately, on the first view of them, the smallness of their number was treated with contempt, and each man began to request for himself the task of dislodging the enemy. The general himself, among the most headstrong and absurd, calls to arms to go and seize the place, and inveighs against the enemy with vain presumption and menaces. First, he despatches his light-armed, after that his cavalry, in a close body, lastly, perceiving that succours were also being sent to the enemy, he marches with his legions drawn up in order of battle. Hannibal also, sending band after band, as the contest increased, as aids to his men when distressed, had now completed a regular army, and a battle was fought with the entire strength of both sides. First, the light infantry of the Romans, approaching the eminence, which was preoccupied, from the lower ground, being repulsed and pushed down, spread a terror among the cavalry, which was marching up also and fled back to the standards of the legions: the line of infantry alone stood fearless amidst the panic-struck; and it appeared that they would by no means have been inferior to the enemy, had it been a regular and open battle, so much confidence did the successful battle a few days before inspire. But the troops in ambush created such confusion and alarm, by charging them on both flanks and on their rear, that no one had spirit enough left to fight, or hope enough to try to escape.

From this, Hannibal found a double joy, as he was aware of everything happening among the enemy—deserters revealed a lot, and he also examined things himself with his scouts. He believed he could trick Minucius, who was reckless, and noticed that Fabius’s cleverness was diminished. There was a hill between the camps of Minucius and the Carthaginians; whoever took it would clearly make their enemy's position less favorable. Hannibal wasn’t overly eager to take it without a fight, even though it would be worth his while, because he knew Minucius would always come to oppose him. At first glance, the ground between them seemed unsuitable for an ambush, as it had no woods or even thick brambles. However, nature had provided opportunities to hide a surprise, as the open valley had curves and hollow rocks, some capable of holding two hundred armed men. In these hiding spots, he concealed five thousand infantry and cavalry, as many as could comfortably fit. To prevent any movement or the shine of their weapons from revealing the plan in such an open valley, he sent out a few troops at dawn to capture the mentioned hill, diverting the enemy's attention. As soon as the enemy saw them, they dismissed their small numbers and each soldier wanted the task of dislodging them. The general, among the most reckless and foolish, called everyone to arms to seize the hill and loudly threatened the enemy. He first sent out his light infantry, then his cavalry in tight formation, and finally, noticing reinforcements heading towards the enemy, he marched his legions in battle order. Hannibal, sending in wave after wave of support as the battle intensified, had now assembled a full army, resulting in a clash with both sides at full strength. Initially, the Roman light infantry tried to approach the occupied hill from the lower ground but were pushed back, which spread panic among the advancing cavalry, causing them to flee to their standards. Only the infantry stood firm in the chaos, appearing no less capable than the enemy in a fair fight, inspired by their recent victory. But the ambushing troops caused such confusion and panic by attacking both flanks and the rear that no one had the spirit left to fight or the hope to escape.

29

Then Fabius, first having heard the shout of the terrified troops, and then having gotten a view of their disordered line, exclaims, "It is so; and no sooner than I feared, has adverse fortune overtaken temerity. Equalled to Fabius in command, he sees that Hannibal is superior to him in courage and in fortune. But another will be the time for reproaches and resentment. Now advance your standards beyond the rampart: let us wrest the victory from the enemy, and a confession of their error from our countrymen." A great part of the troops having been now slain, and the rest looking about for a way to escape; the army of Fabius showed itself on a sudden for their help, as if sent down from heaven. And thus, before he came within a dart's throw or joined battle, he both stayed his friends from a precipitate flight and the enemy from excessive fierceness of fighting. Those who had been scattered up and down, their ranks being broken, fled for refuge from every quarter to the fresh army; those who had fled together in parties, turning upon the enemy, now forming a circle, retreat slowly, now concentrating themselves, stand firm. And now the vanquished and the fresh army had nearly formed one line, and were bearing their standards against the enemy, when the Carthaginians sounded a retreat; Hannibal openly declaring that though he had conquered Minucius, he was himself conquered by Fabius. The greater part of the day having been thus consumed with varying success, Minucius calling together his soldiers, when they had returned to the camp, thus addressed them: "I have often heard, soldiers, that he is the greatest man who himself counsels what is expedient, and that he who listens to the man who gives good advice is the second, but that he who neither himself is capable of counselling, and knows not how to obey another, is of the lowest order of mind. Since the first place of mind and talent has been denied us, let us strive to obtain the second and intermediate kind, and while we are learning to command, let us prevail upon ourselves to submit to a man of prudence. Let us join camps with Fabius, and, carrying our standards to his pavilion, when I have saluted him as my parent, which he deserves on account of the service he has rendered us and of his dignity; you, my soldiers, shall salute those men as patrons, whose arms and right-hands just now protected you: and if this day has conferred nothing else upon us, it hath at least conferred upon us the glory of possessing grateful hearts."

Then Fabius, after hearing the shout of the terrified troops and seeing their disorganized line, exclaims, "It's true; and just as I feared, bad luck has struck because of our recklessness. Although I’m equal to Fabius in leadership, I can see that Hannibal is stronger than me in bravery and luck. But this isn’t the time for blame and anger. Let’s move our banners beyond the rampart: we must take the victory from the enemy and get an acknowledgment of their mistake from our fellow countrymen." A large part of the troops had been killed, and the rest were looking for a way to escape; suddenly, Fabius’s army appeared to help them, as if sent from heaven. Thus, before he could even throw a javelin or engage in battle, he managed to stop his friends from fleeing recklessly and to hold back the enemy from attacking fiercely. Those who had scattered, their ranks broken, fled for refuge from every direction to the fresh army; those who had escaped in groups, now turning on the enemy, slowly formed a circle, regrouping and standing firm. At this point, the defeated troops and the fresh army were almost in a single line, raising their standards against the enemy when the Carthaginians sounded a retreat; Hannibal publicly declared that although he had defeated Minucius, he was himself defeated by Fabius. After much of the day had been spent with mixed results, Minucius called his soldiers together when they returned to camp and addressed them: "I’ve often heard, soldiers, that the greatest person is the one who decides what is best for themselves, and that the one who listens to good advice is second, but that someone who can’t offer their own counsel and doesn’t know how to follow others is the lowest type of person. Since we’ve been denied the top spot in mind and talent, let’s strive to achieve the second and intermediate kind, and while we’re learning to lead, let’s commit to following a wise man. Let’s join forces with Fabius, and carrying our banners to his tent, when I greet him as my father, which he deserves for the service he has provided us and his honor; you, my soldiers, shall honor those men as protectors, whose arms and strength have just now safeguarded you: and if today has given us nothing else, at least it has granted us the glory of having grateful hearts."

30

The signal being given, there was a general call to collect the baggage: then setting out, and proceeding in order of march to the dictator's camp, they excited at once the surprise of the dictator himself and all around him. When the standards were planted before the tribunal, the master of the horse, advancing before the rest, having saluted Fabius as father, and the whole body of his troops having, with one voice, saluted the soldiers who surrounded him as patrons, said, "To my parents, dictator, to whom I have just now equalled you, only in name, as far as I could express myself, I am indebted for my life only; to you I owe both my own preservation and that of all these soldiers. That order of the people, therefore, with which I have been oppressed rather than honoured, I first cancel and annul, and (may it be auspicious to me and you, and to these your armies, to the preserved and the preserver,) I return to your authority and auspices, and restore to you these standards and these legions, and I entreat you that, being reconciled, you would order that I may retain the mastership of the horse, and that these soldiers may each of them retain their ranks." After that hands were joined, and when the assembly was dismissed, the soldiers were kindly and hospitably invited by those known to them and unknown: and that day, from having been a little while ago gloomy in the extreme, and almost accursed, was turned into a day of joy. At Rome, the report of the action was conveyed thither, and was afterwards confirmed, not less by letters from the common soldiers of both armies, than from the generals themselves, all men individually extolled Maximus to the skies. His renown was equal with Hannibal, and his enemies the Carthaginians and then at length they began to feel that they were engaged in war with Romans, and in Italy. For the two preceding years they entertained so utter a contempt for the Roman generals and soldiers, that they could scarcely believe that they were waging war with the same nation which their fathers had reported to them as being so formidable. They relate also, that Hannibal said, as he returned from the field that at length that cloud, which was used to settle on the tops of the mountains, had sent down a shower with a storm.

The signal was given, and there was a general call to gather the baggage. Then, setting out and proceeding in marching order to the dictator's camp, they immediately surprised both the dictator and those around him. When the standards were planted in front of the tribunal, the master of the horse stepped forward and, greeting Fabius as a father, the entire body of troops, in unison, greeted the soldiers surrounding him as protectors. He said, "To my parents, dictator, whom I have just now compared you to, only in name, as best as I could express, I owe my life solely to them; to you, I owe my survival and that of all these soldiers. Therefore, I first cancel and annul that order of the people, with which I have been oppressed rather than honored. And (may this be fortunate for you, me, and these armies, for the saved and the savior), I return to your authority and guidance, restore to you these standards and legions, and I ask you, in reconciliation, to allow me to keep the position of master of the horse, and for these soldiers to retain their ranks." After this, they joined hands, and when the assembly was dismissed, the soldiers received warm and friendly invitations from both acquaintances and strangers. That day, which had recently been incredibly gloomy and nearly cursed, turned into a day of joy. News of the event was reported to Rome and later confirmed, not only by letters from common soldiers of both armies but also from the generals, all of whom praised Maximus to the skies. His reputation was on par with Hannibal's, and his enemies, the Carthaginians, eventually began to realize they were at war with Romans in Italy. For the past two years, they had held such contempt for the Roman generals and soldiers that they could hardly believe they were fighting the same nation that their fathers had said was so formidable. They also reported that Hannibal said, as he returned from the battlefield, that at last that cloud, which used to settle on the mountain tops, had sent down a shower with a storm.

31

While these events occur in Italy, Cneius Servilius Geminus, the consul, having sailed round the coast of Sardinia and Corsica with a fleet of one hundred and twenty ships, and received hostages from both places, crossed over into Africa, and before he made a descent upon the continent, having laid waste the island of Meninx, and received from the inhabitants of Cercina ten talents of silver, in order that their fields too might not be burnt and pillaged, he approached the shores of Africa, and landed his troops. Thence the soldiers were led out to plunder, and the crews scattered about just as if they were plundering uninhabited islands and thus, carelessly falling upon an ambuscade, when they were surrounded--the ignorant of the country by those acquainted with it, the straggling by those in close array, they were driven back to then ships in ignominious flight, and with great carnage. As many as one thousand men, together with Sempionius Blaesus, the quaestor, having been lost, the fleet hastily setting sail from the shore, which was crowded with the enemy, proceeded direct for Italy, and was given up at Lilybaeum to Titus Otacilius, the praetor, that it might be taken back to Rome by his lieutenant, Publius Suia. The consul himself, proceeding through Sicily on foot, crossed the strait into Italy, summoned, as well as his colleague, Marcus Atilius, by a letter from Quintus Fabius, to receive the armies from him, as the period of his command, which was six months, had nearly expired. Almost all the annalists record that Fabius conducted the war against Hannibal, as dictator Caelius also writes, that he was the first dictator created by the people. But it has escaped Caelius and all the others that Cneius Servilius, the consul, who was then a long way from home in Gaul, which was his province, was the only person who possessed the right of appointing a dictator, and that as the state, terrified by the disasters which had just befallen it, could not abide the delay, it had recourse to the determination that the people should create a prodictator, that his subsequent achievements, his singular renown as a general, and his descendants, who exaggerated the inscription of his statue, easily brought it about that he should be called dictator, instead of prodictator.

While these events were happening in Italy, Cneius Servilius Geminus, the consul, had sailed around the coast of Sardinia and Corsica with a fleet of one hundred and twenty ships. He received hostages from both locations, crossed over into Africa, and before landing there, destroyed the island of Meninx. He also took ten talents of silver from the inhabitants of Cercina to spare their fields from being burned and looted. He then approached the shores of Africa and landed his troops. After that, the soldiers were sent out to loot, and the crews spread out as if they were raiding uninhabited islands. They carelessly fell into an ambush, getting surrounded—those unfamiliar with the area by those who knew it well, and the stragglers by those in formation. They were driven back to their ships in a shameful retreat, suffering significant losses. About one thousand men, along with Sempionius Blaesus, the quaestor, were lost. The fleet quickly set sail from the shore, which was filled with enemies, and made its way directly to Italy. It was handed over at Lilybaeum to Titus Otacilius, the praetor, so that it could be taken back to Rome by his lieutenant, Publius Suia. The consul himself traveled on foot through Sicily, crossed the strait into Italy, and was summoned, along with his colleague, Marcus Atilius, by a letter from Quintus Fabius, to receive the armies from him, since his six-month term of command was nearly over. Most historians record that Fabius led the war against Hannibal as dictator; Caelius also mentions that he was the first dictator elected by the people. However, Caelius and the others failed to note that Cneius Servilius, the consul, who was far away in Gaul—his province—was the only one with the authority to appoint a dictator. The state, terrified by recent disasters and unable to wait, decided to have the people create a prodictator. Fabius’s later achievements, his outstanding reputation as a general, and the exaggeration of his statue’s inscription by his descendants easily led to him being called dictator instead of prodictator.

32

The consuls, Atilius and Geminus Servilius, having received, the former the army of Fabius, the latter that of Minucius, and fortified their winter quarters in good time, (it was the close of the autumn,) carried on the war with the most perfect unanimity, according to the plans of Fabius. In many places they fell upon the troops of Hannibal when out on foraging excursions, availing themselves of the opportunity, and both harassing their march and intercepting the stragglers. They did not come to the chance of a general battle, which the enemy tried by every artifice to bring about. And Hannibal was so straitened by the want of provisions, that had he not feared in retiring the appearance of flight, he would have returned to Gaul, no hope being left of being able to subsist an army in those quarters, if the ensuing consuls should carry on the war upon the same plan. The war having been arrested in its progress at Geronium, the winter interrupting it, ambassadors from Naples came to Rome. They carried into the senate-house forty golden goblets, of great weight, and spoke to this effect. "That they knew the treasury of the Romans was exhausted by the war, and since the war was carried on alike in defence of the cities and the lands of the allies, and of the empire and city of Rome, the capital and citadel of Italy, that the Neapolitans thought it but fair that they should assist the Roman people with whatever gold had been left them by their ancestors as well for the decoration of their temples as for the relief of misfortune. If they had thought that there was any resource in themselves, that they would have offered it with the same zeal. That the Roman fathers and people would render an acceptable service to them, if they would consider all the goods of the Neapolitans as their own, and if they would think them deserving, that they should accept a present at their hands, rendered valuable and of consequence rather by the spirit and affection of those who gave it with cheerfulness, than by its intrinsic worth." Thanks were given to the ambassadors for their munificence and attention, and the goblet of least weight was accepted.

The consuls, Atilius and Geminus Servilius, received, the former the army of Fabius and the latter that of Minucius, and set up their winter quarters in good time (it was late autumn). They conducted the war with total agreement, following Fabius's strategies. In various places, they ambushed Hannibal's troops during their foraging missions, taking advantage of the situation by disrupting their movements and capturing stragglers. They avoided a general battle, which the enemy tried to create using every trick in the book. Hannibal was so pressed for supplies that if he hadn’t feared it would look like a retreat, he would have returned to Gaul, as there was no hope of sustaining his army there if the next consuls continued the war with the same approach. With the war stalled at Geronium due to winter, ambassadors from Naples arrived in Rome. They brought forty heavy golden goblets to the senate and stated: "We know the Roman treasury is drained by the war, and since the conflict concerns both the defense of our cities and lands as well as the empire and the city of Rome, the heart of Italy, we Neapolitans feel it’s only fair to support the Roman people with the gold our ancestors left us, both to beautify our temples and to aid in times of trouble. If we believed we had any resources of our own, we would have offered them with the same enthusiasm. The Roman fathers and people would do us a favor if they considered all the possessions of the Neapolitans as their own and accepted this gift, which holds significance more for the spirit and goodwill of the givers than for its actual value." The ambassadors were thanked for their generosity and thoughtfulness, and the goblet with the least weight was accepted.

33

During the same days a Carthaginian spy, who had escaped for two years, was apprehended at Rome, and his hands having been cut off, was let go: and twenty-five slaves were crucified for forming a conspiracy in the Campus Martius; his liberty was given to the informer, and twenty thousand asses of the heavy standard. Ambassadors were also sent to Philip, king of the Macedonians, to demand Demetrius of Pharia, who, having been vanquished in war had fled to him. Others were sent to the Ligurians, to expostulate with them for having assisted the Carthaginians with their substance and with auxiliaries; and, at the same time, to take a near view of what was going on amongst the Boii and Insubrians. Ambassadors were also sent to the Illyrians to king Pineus, to demand the tribute, the day of payment of which had passed; or if he wished to postpone the day, to receive hostages. Thus, though an arduous war was on their shoulders, no attention to any one concern in any part of the world, however remote, escapes the Romans. It was made a matter of superstitious fear also, that the temple of Concord, which Lucius Manlius, the praetor, had vowed in Gaul two years ago, on occasion of a mutiny, had not been contracted for to that day. Accordingly, Cneius Pupius and Caeso Quinctius Flaminius, created duumviri by Marcus Aemilius, the city praetor, for that purpose, contract for the building a temple in the citadel. By the same praetor a letter was sent to the consuls, agreeably to a decree of the senate, to the effect that, if they thought proper, one of them should come to Rome to elect consuls; and that he would proclaim the election for whatever day they might name. To this it was replied by the consuls, that they could not leave the enemy without detriment to the public; that it would be better, therefore, that the election should be held by an interrex, than that one of the consuls should be called away from the war. It appeared more proper to the fathers, that a dictator should be nominated by a consul, for the purpose of holding the election Lucius Veturius Philo was nominated, who chose Manius Pomponius Matho master of the horse. These having been created with some defect, they were ordered to give up their appointment on the fourteenth day; and the state came to an interregnum.

During those same days, a Carthaginian spy, who had escaped for two years, was caught in Rome. His hands were cut off, and he was released. Additionally, twenty-five slaves were crucified for plotting a conspiracy in the Campus Martius. The informer was given his freedom and twenty thousand asses of the heavy standard. Ambassadors were also sent to Philip, king of the Macedonians, to demand Demetrius of Pharia, who had fled to him after being defeated in battle. Others were dispatched to the Ligurians to confront them for aiding the Carthaginians with resources and troops. At the same time, they aimed to closely observe the situation among the Boii and Insubrians. Ambassadors were sent to the Illyrians to king Pineus, requesting the tribute, as the payment deadline had passed; if he wanted to delay, they asked for hostages. Thus, even with a tough war on their hands, the Romans didn't overlook any issue in any part of the world, no matter how far away. It also became a matter of superstitious concern that the temple of Concord, which Lucius Manlius, the praetor, had vowed to build in Gaul two years earlier during a mutiny, had not yet been constructed. Consequently, Cneius Pupius and Caeso Quinctius Flaminius, appointed as duumviri by Marcus Aemilius, the city praetor, were tasked with contracting the construction of the temple in the citadel. By the same praetor, a letter was sent to the consuls as per a decree from the senate, stating that if they deemed it appropriate, one of them should come to Rome to elect consuls; he would announce the election for whichever day they chose. The consuls replied that they couldn't leave the enemy unattended without risking public harm; therefore, it would be better for an interrex to conduct the election rather than pulling one of the consuls away from the war. The senate felt it was more fitting for a dictator to be appointed by a consul to oversee the election. Lucius Veturius Philo was nominated, and he selected Manius Pomponius Matho as master of the horse. These officials were appointed with some flaws, and they were instructed to relinquish their roles on the fourteenth day, leading the state into an interregnum.

34

To the consuls the authority was continued for a year longer. Caius Claudius Centho, son of Appius, and then Publius Cornelius Asina, were appointed interreges by the fathers. During the interregnum of the latter the election was held with a violent contest between the patricians and the people, Caius Terentius Varro, whom, as a man of their own order, commended to their favour by inveighing against the patricians and by other popular arts; who had acquired celebrity by maligning others, by undermining the influence of Fabius, and bringing into contempt the dictatorial authority, the commons strove to raise to the consulship. The patricians opposed him with all their might, lest men, by inveighing against them, should come to be placed on an equality with them. Quintus Boebius Herennius, a plebeian tribune, and kinsman of Caius Terentius, by criminating not only the senate, but the augurs also, for having prevented the dictator from completing the election, by the odium cast upon them, conciliated favour to his own candidate. He asserted, "that Hannibal had been brought into Italy by the nobility, who had for many years been desirous of a war. That by the fraudulent machinations of the same persons the war had been protracted, whereas it might have been brought to a conclusion. That it had appeared that the war could be maintained with an army consisting of four legions in all, from Marcus Minucius's having fought with success in the absence of Fabius. That two legions had been exposed to be slain by the enemy, and were afterwards rescued from absolute destruction, in order that that man might be saluted as father and patron, who had deprived them of victory before he delivered them from defeat. That subsequently the consuls, pursuing the plans of Fabius, had protracted the war, whereas it was in their power to have put a period to it. That this was an agreement made by the nobility in general; nor would they ever have the war concluded till they had created a consul really plebeian; that is, a new man: for that plebeians who had attained nobility were now initiated into the mysteries, and had begun to look down with contempt upon plebeians, from the moment they ceased to be despised by the patricians. Who was not fully aware that their end and object was, that an interregnum should be formed, in order that the elections might be under the influence of the patricians? That both the consuls had that in view in tarrying with the army: and that afterwards a dictator having been nominated to hold the election contrary to their wishes, they had carried it, as it were, by storm, that the augurs should declare the dictator informally elected. That they therefore had gotten an interregnum; but one consulate was surely in the hands of the Roman people. Thus the people would have that at their own unbiassed disposal, and that they would confer it on that man who would rather conquer in reality than lengthen the term of his command."

To the consuls, authority was extended for another year. Caius Claudius Centho, son of Appius, and then Publius Cornelius Asina, were appointed interreges by the senate. During Asina's interregnum, elections were held amid a fierce conflict between the patricians and the people. Caius Terentius Varro, a member of their class, was favored by the plebeians for his attacks on the patricians and other populist tactics. He gained notoriety by disparaging others, undermining Fabius's influence, and belittling the dictator's authority, as the common folks pushed for him to be elected consul. The patricians fought against him with all their strength, fearing that if others spoke out against them, they might be seen as equals. Quintus Boebius Herennius, a plebeian tribune and relative of Caius Terentius, gained support for his candidate by criticizing not just the senate but also the augurs for hindering the dictator from completing the election, generating public disdain towards them. He claimed, "Hannibal was brought into Italy by the nobility, who had long wanted war. Through their deceitful schemes, they extended the war when it could have been concluded. It was clear the war could have been sustained with only four legions, as shown by Marcus Minucius's successful campaign without Fabius. Two legions had been left vulnerable to destruction by the enemy but were later saved to ensure that the man who had denied them victory could be hailed as a father and protector for delivering them from defeat. Afterwards, the consuls, following Fabius's strategies, prolonged the war when they had the means to end it. This was a plan devised by the nobility at large; they would never end the war until they appointed a consul who was truly plebeian, a new man. Those plebeians who gained nobility entered the ranks and began to look down on the common folks, as soon as they no longer faced disdain from the patricians. Who was not aware that their aim was to create an interregnum to ensure that the elections were controlled by the patricians? Both consuls had that in mind by remaining with the army, and when a dictator was later appointed to conduct elections against their wishes, they had it rigged so the augurs would declare the dictator officially elected without proper procedure. They had thus created an interregnum; however, one consulship was undoubtedly in the hands of the Roman people. Thus, the people would keep that position within their own unprejudiced power and grant it to the person who would prefer to truly achieve victory rather than just extend his term."

35

When the people had been inflamed by these harangues, though there were three patrician candidates for the consulship, Publius Cornelius Merenda, Lucius Manlius Vulso, and Marcus Aemilius Lepidus, two of plebeian families, who had been ennobled, Caius Atilius Serranus and Quintus Aelius Paetus, one of whom was pontiff, the other an augur, Terentius alone was created consul, that the comitia for choosing his colleague might be in his own management. Then the nobles, finding that the competitors whom they had set up were not strong enough, though he strenuously refused for a long time, prevail upon Aemilius Paulus, who was strongly opposed to the people, to become a candidate. He had been consul before with Marcus Livius, and from the condemnation of his colleague, and almost of himself, had come off scathed. On the next day of the election, all who had opposed Varro withdrawing, he is given to the consul rather as a match to oppose him than as a colleague. Afterwards the assembly for the election of praetors was held, and Manius Pomponius Matho and Publius Furius Philus were chosen. The city lot for the administration of justice at Rome fell to the lot of Pomponius; between Roman citizens and foreigners, to Philus. Two praetors were added, Marcus Claudius Marcellus for Sicily, and Lucius Postumius for Gaul. These were all appointed in their absence; nor was an honour which he had not previously borne committed to any one of them, except the consul Terentius, several brave and able men having been passed over, because, at such a juncture, it did not appear advisable that a new office should be committed to any one.

When the people were stirred up by these speeches, even though there were three noble candidates for the consulship—Publius Cornelius Merenda, Lucius Manlius Vulso, and Marcus Aemilius Lepidus—two of them being plebeian families who had been elevated, Caius Atilius Serranus and Quintus Aelius Paetus, one a pontiff and the other an augur, only Terentius was elected consul so he could manage the election for his colleague. The nobles, realizing that their chosen competitors were weak, managed to convince Aemilius Paulus, who was firmly against the people, to run as a candidate despite his initial refusal. He had previously served as consul with Marcus Livius and had come out nearly unscathed from the condemnation of his colleague, and himself. On the next election day, after those opposed to Varro stepped back, he was elected more as a rival to Varro than as a collaborator. After that, the assembly for selecting praetors took place, and Manius Pomponius Matho and Publius Furius Philus were chosen. The city’s jurisdiction for justice in Rome went to Pomponius; that for disputes between Roman citizens and foreigners went to Philus. Two more praetors were appointed—Marcus Claudius Marcellus for Sicily and Lucius Postumius for Gaul. All these appointments were made in their absence, and no one was given an honor they hadn’t held before except for consul Terentius, as several brave and capable candidates were overlooked because it didn’t seem wise to assign a new office to anyone at that time.

36

The forces also were augmented. But how great was the augmentation of infantry and cavalry authors vary so much, that I scarcely dare positively assert. Some state, that ten thousand soldiers were levied as a reinforcement; others, four fresh legions, that there might be eight legions in service. It is said also, that the complement of the legion was increased in respect both to foot and horse, one thousand foot and one hundred horse being added to each, so that each might contain five thousand foot and three hundred horse; and that the allies furnished twice as many cavalry, and an equal number of infantry. Some authorities affirm that there were eighty-seven thousand two hundred soldiers in the Roman camp when the battle of Cannae was fought. There is no dispute, that the war was prosecuted with greater energy and spirit than during former years, because the dictator had given them a hope that the enemy might be subdued. Before, however, the new-raised legions marched from the city, the decemviri were ordered to have recourse to and inspect the sacred volumes, on account of persons having been generally alarmed by extraordinary prodigies; for intelligence was brought, that it had rained stones on the Aventine at Rome and at Aricia at the same time. That among the Sabines, statues had sweated blood copiously, and at Caere the waters had flowed warm, from a fountain. The latter prodigy excited a greater degree of alarm, because it had frequently occurred. In a street called the Arched Way, near the Campus Martius, several men were struck by lightning and killed. These prodigies were expiated according to the books. Ambassadors from Paestum brought some golden goblets to Rome; they were thanked, as the Neapolitans were, but the gold was not accepted.

The forces were also increased. But the exact number of extra infantry and cavalry is debated by historians, so I can’t say for sure. Some claim that ten thousand soldiers were raised as reinforcements; others say four new legions were added, bringing the total to eight legions in service. It’s also said that the size of the legions grew, with an addition of one thousand foot soldiers and one hundred cavalry to each, making each legion consist of five thousand foot and three hundred horse. The allies provided twice as many cavalry and an equal number of infantry. Some sources assert that there were eighty-seven thousand two hundred soldiers in the Roman camp when the battle of Cannae took place. There’s no doubt that the war was conducted with more energy and determination than in previous years because the dictator had inspired them with hope that they could defeat the enemy. However, before the newly raised legions departed from the city, the decemviri were instructed to consult and examine the sacred texts due to widespread public anxiety caused by unusual omens; reports had come in that it rained stones on the Aventine in Rome and at Aricia simultaneously. Among the Sabines, statues had bled profusely, and in Caere, warm water had flowed from a fountain. The latter omen caused more alarm since it had happened before. On a street known as the Arched Way, near the Campus Martius, several men were struck and killed by lightning. These omens were addressed according to the writings. Ambassadors from Paestum brought some golden goblets to Rome; they were thanked, just like the Neapolitans, but the gold was not accepted.

37

During the same time a fleet from Hiero arrived at Ostia with a large cargo of supplies. The Syracusan ambassadors, on being introduced into the senate, delivered this message: "That king Hiero was so much affected at the slaughter announced to him of Caius Flaminius the consul and his troops, that he could not have been more distressed at any disasters which could have befallen himself or his own kingdom; and accordingly, though he was well aware that the greatness of the Roman people was almost more admirable in adversity than prosperity, he had nevertheless sent every thing which good and faithful allies are wont to contribute to assist the operations of war, which he earnestly implored the conscript fathers not to refuse to accept. First of all, for the sake of the omen, they had brought a golden statue of Victory, of three hundred pounds' weight, which they begged them to accept, keep by them, and hold as their own peculiar and lasting possession. That they had also brought three hundred thousand pecks of wheat, and two hundred thousand of barley, that there might be no want of provisions, and that as much more as might be necessary they would convey, as a supply, to whatever place they might appoint. He knew that the Roman people employed no legionary troops or cavalry who were not Romans, or of the Latin confederacy, that he had seen foreign auxiliary as well as native light-armed troops in the Roman camps, he had, therefore, sent one thousand archers and slingers, a suitable force against the Bahares and Moors, and other nations which fought with missile weapons" To these presents they added also advice "That the praetor to whose lot the province of Sicily had fallen, should pass a fleet over to Africa, that the enemy also might have a war in their own country, and that less liberty should be afforded them of sending reinforcements to Hannibal" The senate thus replied to the king. "That Hiero was a good man and an admirable ally, and that from the time he first formed a friendship with the Roman people he had uniformly cultivated a spirit of fidelity, and had munificently assisted the Roman cause at all times and in every place. That this was, as it ought to be, a cause of gratitude to the Roman people. That the Roman people had not accepted gold which had been brought them also from certain states, though they felt gratitude for the act. The Victory and the omen," they said, "they would accept, and would assign and dedicate to that goddess, as her abode, the Capitol, the temple of Jupiter, the best and greatest of gods, hoping that, consecrated in that fortress of the city of Rome, she would continue there firm and immoveable, kind and propitious to the Roman people." The slingers, archers, and corn were handed over to the consuls. To the fleet which Titus Otacilius the proprietor had in Sicily, twenty-five quinqueremes were added, and permission was given him, if he thought it for the interest of the state to pass over into Africa.

During the same time, a fleet from Hiero arrived at Ostia with a large cargo of supplies. The Syracusan ambassadors, once introduced to the senate, delivered this message: "King Hiero was so deeply affected by the news of the slaughter of Consul Caius Flaminius and his troops that he felt more distressed than he would have at any disasters that could have happened to himself or his own kingdom. Therefore, even though he recognized that the greatness of the Roman people is almost more admirable in adversity than in prosperity, he nonetheless sent everything that loyal allies typically contribute to support war efforts, urging the conscript fathers not to refuse his offer. First of all, for the sake of the omen, they brought a golden statue of Victory weighing three hundred pounds, which they requested to be accepted, kept, and treated as their own lasting possession. They also brought three hundred thousand pecks of wheat and two hundred thousand of barley to ensure there were enough provisions, promising to deliver more if needed to any location the senate decided on. He knew that the Roman people did not use any legionary troops or cavalry that weren't Romans or part of the Latin confederacy; having seen both foreign auxiliary troops and local light-armed soldiers in Roman camps, he therefore sent one thousand archers and slingers, a suitable force against the Bahares, Moors, and other nations that fought with missile weapons." They also added advice: "The praetor assigned to the province of Sicily should send a fleet to Africa so that the enemy would also be engaged in a war on their own territory, thus limiting their ability to send reinforcements to Hannibal." The senate replied to the king: "Hiero is a good man and an amazing ally, and since he first formed a friendship with the Roman people, he has consistently shown loyalty and generously supported the Roman cause at all times and in every place. This is, as it should be, a source of gratitude for the Roman people. The Roman people did not accept gold that had been sent from certain states, even though they appreciated the gesture. They would accept the statue of Victory and the omen, assigning and dedicating it to that goddess, placing her in the Capitol, the temple of Jupiter, the greatest of gods, hoping that, consecrated in that stronghold of the city of Rome, she would remain steadfast, kind, and favorable to the Roman people." The slingers, archers, and grain were handed over to the consuls. To the fleet that Titus Otacilius the proconsul had in Sicily, twenty-five quinqueremes were added, and he was given permission to cross into Africa if he thought it was in the state's best interest.

38

The levy completed, the consuls waited a few days, till the allies of the Latin confederacy arrived. At this time the soldiers were bound by an oath, which had never before been the case, dictated by the military tribunes, that they would assemble at the command of the consuls, and not depart without orders; for up to that time the military oath only had been employed; and further, when the soldiers met to divide into decuries or centuries, the cavalry being formed into decuries and the infantry into centuries, all swore together, amongst themselves, of their own accord, that they would not depart or quit their ranks for flight or fear, except for the purpose of taking up or fetching a weapon, and either striking an enemy or saving a countryman. This, from being a voluntary compact among the soldiers themselves, was converted into the legal compulsion of an oath by the tribunes. Before the standards were moved from the city, the harangues of Varro were frequent and furious, protesting that the war had been invited into Italy by the nobles, and that it would continue fixed in the bowels of the state if it employed any more such generals as Fabius; that he would bring the war to conclusion on the very day he got sight of the enemy. His colleague Paulus made but one speech, on the day before they set out from the city, which was more true than gratifying to the people, in which nothing was said severely against Varro, except this only. "That he wondered how any general, before he knew any thing of his own army, or that of the enemy, the situation of the places, or the nature of the country, even now while in the city, and with the gown on, could tell what he must do when in arms, and could even foretell the day on which he would fight standard to standard with the enemy. That, for his own part, he would not, before the time arrived, prematurely anticipate those measures which circumstances imposed on men, rather than men on circumstances. He could only wish that those measures which were taken with due caution and deliberation might turn out prosperously. That temerity, setting aside its folly, had hitherto been also unsuccessful." This obviously appeared, that he would prefer safe to precipitate counsels; but that he might persevere the more constantly in this, Quintus Fabius Maximus is reported to have thus addressed him on his departure.

The levy was done, and the consuls waited a few days until the allies of the Latin confederacy showed up. At this point, the soldiers had to take an oath, which had never happened before, set by the military tribunes, promising to gather at the consuls’ command and not leave without orders; up until then, only the military oath had been used. Moreover, when the soldiers gathered to divide into groups, the cavalry into decuries and the infantry into centuries, everyone swore together, on their own, that they would not abandon their ranks out of fear or to flee, except to grab a weapon, either to fight an enemy or to protect a fellow soldier. This, originally a voluntary agreement among the soldiers, became a legal obligation through the tribunes’ oath. Before the banners were moved from the city, Varro frequently and passionately declared that the nobles had invited war into Italy and that it would continue to plague the state if they kept using generals like Fabius; he promised he would end the war the moment he saw the enemy. His colleague Paulus gave only one speech the day before they left the city, which was more honest than satisfying for the people. He didn’t criticize Varro severely, just expressing his confusion over how any general could know what to do in battle before understanding their own army, the enemy's, the terrain, or the situation, all while still in the city and dressed in a toga. He said he wouldn’t rush into decisions that circumstances would dictate when the time came. He simply wished that cautious and well-thought-out measures would lead to success. He noted that rashness, aside from its foolishness, had so far been unsuccessful. This clearly showed that he preferred careful planning over impulsive decisions. To reinforce this, Quintus Fabius Maximus is said to have spoken to him on his departure.

39

"If you either had a colleague like yourself, Lucius Aemilius, which is what I should prefer, or you were like your colleague, an address from me would be superfluous. For were you both good consuls, you would do every thing for the good of the state from your own sense of honour, even without my saying a word: and were you both bad consuls, you would neither receive my words into your ears, nor my counsels into your minds. As the case now is, looking at your colleague and yourself, a man of such character, my address will be solely to you; who, I feel convinced, will prove yourself a good man and a worthy citizen in vain, if the state on the other hand should halt. Pernicious counsels will have the same authority and influence as those which are sound. For you are mistaken, Lucius Paulus, if you imagine that you will have a less violent contest with Caius Terentius than with Hannibal. I know not whether the former, your opponent, or the latter, your open enemy, be the more hostile. With the latter you will have to contend in the field only; with the former, at every place and time. Hannibal, moreover, you have to oppose with your own horse and foot; while Varro will head your own soldiers against you. Let Caius Flaminius be absent from your thoughts, even for the omen's sake. Yet he only began to play the madman's consul, in his province, and at the head of the army. This man is raving before he put up for the consulship, afterwards while canvassing for it, and now having obtained it, before he has seen the camp or the enemy. And he who by talking largely of battles and marshalled armies, even now excites such storms among the citizens with their gowns on, what do you think he will effect among the youth in arms, where words are followed forthwith by acts? But be assured, if this man, as he protests he will, shall immediately engage the enemy either I am unacquainted with military affairs, with this kind of war, and the character of the enemy, or another place will become more celebrated than the Trasimenus by our disaster. Neither is this the season for boasting while I am addressing one man; and besides, I have exceeded the bounds of moderation in despising rather than in courting fame. But the case is really this. The only way of conducting the war against Hannibal is that which I adopted: nor does the event only, that instructor of fools, demonstrate it, but that same reasoning which has continued hitherto, and will continue unchangeable so long as circumstances shall remain the same. We are carrying on war in Italy, in our own country, and our own soil. All around us are countrymen and allies in abundance. With arms, men, horses, and provisions, they do and will assist us. Such proofs of their fidelity have they given in our adversity. Time, nay, everyday makes us better, wiser, and firmer. Hannibal, on the contrary, is in a foreign, a hostile land, amidst all hostile and disadvantageous circumstances, far from his home, far from his country; he has peace neither by land nor sea: no cities, no walls receive him: he sees nothing any where which he can call his own: he daily lives by plunder. He has now scarcely a third part of that army which he conveyed across the Iberus. Famine has destroyed more than the sword; nor have the few remaining a sufficient supply of provisions. Do you doubt, therefore, whether by remaining quiet we shall not conquer him who is daily sinking into decrepitude? who has neither provisions nor money? How long before the walls of Geronium, a miserable fortress of Apulia, as if before the walls of Carthage--? But not even in your presence will I boast. See how Cneius Servilius and Atilius, the last consuls, fooled him. This is the only path of safety, Lucius Paulus, which your countrymen will render more difficult and dangerous to you than their enemies will. For your own soldiers will desire the same thing as those of the enemy: Varro, a Roman consul, and Hannibal, a Carthaginian general, will wish the same thing. You alone must resist two generals: and you will resist them sufficiently if you stand firm against the report and the rumours of men; if neither the empty glory of your colleague, and the unfounded calumnies against yourself, shall move you. They say that truth too often suffers, but is never destroyed. He who despises fame will have it genuine. Let them call you coward instead of cautious, dilatory instead of considerate, unwarlike instead of an expert general. I would rather that a sagacious enemy should fear you, than that foolish countrymen should commend you. A man who hazards all things Hannibal will despise, him who does nothing rashly he will fear. And neither do I advise that nothing should be done; but that in what you do, reason should guide you, and not fortune. All things will be within your own power, and your own. Be always ready armed and on the watch, and neither be wanting when a favourable opportunity presents itself, nor give any favourable opportunity to the enemy. All things are clear and sure to the deliberate man. Precipitation is improvident and blind."

"If you had a colleague like yourself, Lucius Aemilius, which is what I would prefer, or if you were like your colleague, then my message would be unnecessary. If you were both good consuls, you would act for the good of the state out of your own sense of honor, without me needing to say anything. And if you were both bad consuls, you wouldn't listen to my words or take my advice. Given the current situation, looking at your colleague and yourself, a person of such character, I will address you alone; I am convinced you will strive to be a good person and a worthy citizen in vain if the state stumbles. Harmful advice will carry the same weight and influence as sound advice. You are mistaken, Lucius Paulus, if you believe you will have an easier fight with Caius Terentius than with Hannibal. I do not know which of the two is more hostile: your opponent or your open enemy. You will have to face the latter only in battle, while the former will confront you at every opportunity. You have to fight Hannibal with your own cavalry and infantry, while Varro will command your own soldiers against you. Forget about Caius Flaminius for now, even for the sake of the omen. He only began acting like a madman as consul in his province, at the army's head. This man is already raving before he even ran for consulship, while campaigning for it, and now that he has achieved it, even before he has seen the camp or the enemy. And if his grand talk of battles and organized armies is already stirring up trouble among the citizens, what do you think he will do among the armed youth, where words are quickly followed by actions? But rest assured, if this man, as he claims he will, engages the enemy right away, either I don't understand military matters or this place will become more notorious than Trasimenus because of our disaster. This is not the time for boasting while I’m addressing one person; furthermore, I have surpassed limits in disregarding fame rather than seeking it. The reality is this: the only way to conduct the war against Hannibal is the path I chose; and not only has the outcome, which teaches us all, shown this, but the reasoning that has existed until now will remain unchanged as long as circumstances stay the same. We are waging war in Italy, in our own country, on our own soil. Surrounding us are countrymen and allies in abundance. With arms, men, horses, and provisions, they assist us and will continue to do so. They have demonstrated their loyalty based on their actions during our hardships. Time, in fact, every day, strengthens us, makes us wiser, and more resilient. On the other hand, Hannibal is in a foreign, hostile land, under unfavorable conditions, far from home and his country; he has no peace on land or sea: no cities, no walls welcome him; he sees nothing anywhere that he can claim as his own; he survives through plunder. He now has barely a third of the army he brought across the Iberus. Famine has claimed more than the sword, and the few who remain do not have enough supplies. So why doubt that by staying calm, we won’t defeat him as he declines? Does he lack supplies and money? How long before the walls of Geronium, a miserable stronghold in Apulia, as if before the walls of Carthage—? But I won’t boast even in your presence. Look at how Cneius Servilius and Atilius, the last consuls, tricked him. This is the only safe route, Lucius Paulus, which your fellow citizens will make more complicated and perilous for you than your enemies will. For your own soldiers will want the same as those of the enemy: Varro, a Roman consul, and Hannibal, a Carthaginian general, will desire the same outcome. You alone must stand against two generals, and you will handle them well if you stand firm against the talk and rumors of men; if neither your colleague’s empty glory nor the unfounded slanders against you move you. They say the truth often suffers but is never destroyed. He who disregards fame will possess it sincerely. Let them call you a coward instead of cautious, slow instead of considerate, unmilitary instead of a skilled general. I would prefer that a clever enemy fear you rather than foolish countrymen praise you. A man who risks everything will be scorned by Hannibal; he will fear the one who acts wisely and does nothing rashly. And I don’t advise that nothing be done; rather, that reason guides your actions, not chance. Everything will be within your control and your own. Always be armed and vigilant, and don’t miss a favorable opportunity when it arises, nor grant the enemy any favorable opportunity. Everything is clear and certain to the careful person. Rashness is foolish and blind."

40

The address of the consul in reply was by no means cheerful, admitting that what he said was true, rather than easy to put in practice. He said, "That to him, as dictator, his master of the horse was unbearable: what power or influence could a consul have against a factious and intemperate colleague? That he had in his former consulate escaped a popular conflagration not without being singed: his prayer was, that every thing might happen prosperously; but if, on the contrary, any misfortune should occur, that he would rather expose his life to the weapons of the enemy, than to the votes of his incensed countrymen." Directly after this discourse, it is related that Paulus set out, escorted by the principal senators. The plebeian consul attended his own plebeian party, more distinguished by their numbers than respectability. When they had arrived at the camp, the old and new troops being united, they formed two distinct camps, so that the new and smaller one might be the nearer to Hannibal, and the old one might contain the greater part, and all the choicest of the troops. They then sent to Rome Marcus Atilius, the consul of the former year, who alleged his age in excuse. They appoint Geminus Servilius to the command of a Roman legion, and two thousand of the allied infantry and cavalry in the lesser camp. Hannibal, although he perceived that the forces of the enemy were augmented by one-half, was yet wonderfully rejoiced at the arrival of the consuls; for he had not only nothing remaining of the provisions which he daily acquired by plunder, but there was not even any thing left which he could seize, the corn in all the surrounding country having been collected into fortified cities, when the country was too unsafe; so that, as was afterwards discovered, there scarcely remained corn enough for ten days, and the Spaniards would have passed over to the enemy, through want of food, if the completion of that time had been awaited.

The consul’s response was far from cheerful, acknowledging that what he said was true, but difficult to implement. He stated, "For me, as dictator, my second-in-command is intolerable: what power or influence can a consul have against a rebellious and reckless colleague? I escaped a public disaster during my previous consulate without getting burned, and I pray that everything turns out well; but if, on the other hand, any misfortune occurs, I would rather face the enemy's weapons than the wrath of my angry countrymen." Immediately after this discussion, it's said that Paulus left, accompanied by the leading senators. The plebeian consul followed his own plebeian faction, which was more notable for their numbers than their reputation. Upon reaching the camp, the old and new troops combined to form two separate camps, so the smaller, newer one would be closer to Hannibal, while the larger one held the majority of the best troops. They then sent Marcus Atilius, the consul from the previous year, back to Rome, who cited his age as an excuse. They appointed Geminus Servilius to command a Roman legion and two thousand allied infantry and cavalry in the smaller camp. Hannibal, although he noticed that the enemies’ forces had increased by half, was nevertheless pleased by the consuls' arrival; he was running low on the supplies he usually gathered through plunder, and there was nothing left for him to seize since the grain in the surrounding area had all been stockpiled in fortified cities due to the unsafe conditions. As later discovered, there was barely enough grain left for ten days, and the Spaniards would have defected to the enemy out of hunger if time had allowed.

41

But fortune afforded materials also to the headstrong and precipitate disposition of the consul, for in checking the plundering parties a battle having taken place, of a tumultuary kind, and occasioned rather by a disorderly advance of the soldiers, than by a preconcerted plan, or by the command of the general, the contest was by no means equal with the Carthaginians. As many as one thousand seven hundred of them were slain, but not more than one hundred of the Romans and allies. The consul Paulus, however, who was in command on that day, (for they held the command on alternate days,) apprehending an ambuscade, restrained the victorious troops in their headstrong pursuit; while Varro indignantly vociferated, that the enemy had been allowed to slip out of their hands, and that the war might have been terminated had not the pursuit been stopped. Hannibal was not much grieved at that loss; nay, rather he felt convinced, that the temerity of the more presumptuous consul, and of the soldiers, particularly the fresh ones, would be lured by the bait; and besides, all the circumstances of the enemy were as well known to him as his own: that dissimilar and discordant men were in command; that nearly two-thirds of the army consisted of raw recruits. Accordingly, concluding that he now had both a time and place adapted for an ambuscade, on the following night he led his troops away with nothing but their arms, leaving the camp filled with all their effects, both public and private. His infantry drawn up he conceals on the left, on the opposite side of the adjoining hills; his cavalry on the right; his baggage in an intermediate line he leads over the mountains through a valley, in order that he might surprise the enemy when busy in plundering the camp, deserted, as they would imagine, by its owners, and when encumbered with booty. Numerous fires were left in the camp, to produce a belief that his intention was to keep the consuls in their places by the appearance of a camp, until he could himself escape to a greater distance, in the same manner as he had deceived Fabius the year before.

But luck also provided opportunities for the reckless and rash consul. When the plundering parties were confronted, a chaotic battle broke out, caused more by the soldiers' disorganized advance than by a planned strategy or the general's orders. The fight was far from even against the Carthaginians. About one thousand seven hundred of them were killed, while no more than one hundred Romans and their allies lost their lives. The consul Paulus, who was in charge that day (as they took turns commanding), fearing an ambush, held back the victorious troops from their reckless chase. Meanwhile, Varro angrily shouted that the enemy had been allowed to escape and that the war could have been ended if the pursuit hadn’t been halted. Hannibal was not very upset about that loss; instead, he was convinced that the boldness of the more arrogant consul and the soldiers, especially the new recruits, would tempt them into a trap. Moreover, he was well aware of all the enemy's circumstances, knowing them as well as his own: that they were led by differing and discordant leaders and that nearly two-thirds of the army were inexperienced recruits. Therefore, figuring he now had both the right time and place for an ambush, he moved his troops away that night with just their weapons, leaving the camp full of their belongings, both public and private. He concealed his infantry on the left, on the other side of the nearby hills; his cavalry on the right; and led the baggage through a valley in an intermediate line over the mountains, so he could surprise the enemy while they were busy looting the camp, which they would think was abandoned by its owners, and weighed down with spoils. Numerous fires were left in the camp to create the illusion that he intended to keep the consuls in place with the appearance of an active camp until he could escape to a safer distance, just as he had tricked Fabius the year before.

42

When it was day, the outpost withdrawn first occasioned surprise, then, on a nearer approach, the unusual stillness. At length, the desertion being manifest, there is a general rush to the pavilions of the consuls, of those who announced the flight of the enemy so precipitate, that they left their camp, with their tents standing; and, that their flight might be the more secret, that numerous fires were left. Then a clamour arose that they should order the standards to be advanced, and lead them in pursuit of the enemy, and to the immediate plunder of the camp. The other consul too was as one of the common soldiers. Paulus again and again urged, that they should see their way before them, and use every precaution. Lastly, when he could no longer withstand the sedition and the leader of the sedition, he sends Marius Statilius, a prefect, with a Lucanian troop, to reconnoitre, who, when he had ridden up to the gates, ordered the rest to stay without the works, and entered the camp himself, attended by two horsemen. Having carefully examined every thing, he brings back word that it was manifestly a snare: that fires were left in that part of the camp which faced the enemy: that the tents were open, and that all their valuables were left exposed: that in some places he had seen silver carelessly thrown about the passages, as if laid there for plunder. This intelligence, which it was hoped would deter their minds from greediness, inflamed them; and the soldiers clamorously declaring, that unless the signal was given they would advance without their leaders, they by no means wanted one, for Varro instantly gave the signal for marching. Paulus, whom, unwilling from his own suggestions to move, the chickens had not encouraged by their auspices, ordered the unlucky omen to be reported to his colleague, when he was now leading the troops out of the gate. And though Varro bore it impatiently, yet the recent fate of Flaminius, and the recorded naval defeat of Claudius, the consul in the first Punic war, struck religious scruples into his mind. The gods themselves (it might almost be said) rather postponed than averted the calamity which hung over the Romans; for it fell out by mere accident, that when the soldiers did not obey the consul who ordered them to return to the camp, two slaves, one belonging to a horseman of Formiae, the other to one of Sidicinum, who had been cut off by the Numidians among a party of foragers, when Servilius and Atilius were consuls, had escaped on that day to their masters: and being brought into the presence of the consuls, inform them that the whole army of Hannibal was lying in ambush on the other side of the adjoining mountains. The seasonable arrival of these men restored the consuls to their authority, when the ambition of one of them had relaxed his influence with the soldiers, by an undignified compliance.43. Hannibal, perceiving that the Romans had been indiscreetly prompted rather than rashly carried to a conclusion, returned to his camp without effecting any thing, as his stratagem was discovered. He could not remain there many days, in consequence of the scarcity of corn; and, moreover, not only among the soldiers, who were mixed up of the off-scouring of various nations, but even with the general himself, day by day new designs arose: for, first, when there had been murmuring of the soldiers, and then an open and clamorous demand of their arrears of pay, and a complaint first of the scarcity of provisions, and lastly of famine; and there being a report that the mercenaries, particularly the Spanish, had formed a plan of passing over to the enemy, it is affirmed that Hannibal himself too sometimes entertained thoughts of flying into Gaul, so that, having left all his infantry, he might hurry away with his cavalry. Such being the plans in agitation, and such the state of feeling in the camp, he resolved to depart thence into the regions of Apulia, which were warmer, and therefore earlier in the harvest. Thinking also, that the farther he retired from the enemy, the more difficult would desertion be to the wavering. He set out by night, having, as before, kindled fires, and leaving a few tents to produce an appearance; that a fear of an ambuscade, similar to the former, might keep the Romans in their places. But when intelligence was brought by the same Lucanian Statilius, who had reconnoitred every place on the other side the mountains, and beyond the camp, that the enemy was seen marching at a distance, then plans began to be deliberated on about pursuing him. The consuls persisted in the same opinions they ever entertained; but nearly all acquiesced with Varro, and none with Paulus except Servilius, the consul of the former year. In compliance with the opinion of the majority, they set out, under the impulse of destiny, to render Cannae celebrated by a Roman disaster. Hannibal had pitched his camp near that village, with his back to the wind Vulturnus, which, in those plains which are parched with drought, carries with it clouds of dust. This circumstance was not only very advantageous to the camp, but would be a great protection to them when they formed their line; as they, with the wind blowing only on their backs, would combat with an enemy blinded with the thickly blown dust.

When day broke, the first surprise at the outpost's abandonment turned into a realization of the unusual silence as they got closer. Eventually, seeing that the camp was clearly deserted, a rush began towards the consul's pavilions, with those announcing the enemy's hasty retreat noting that they had left their camp set up, including their tents, and numerous fires still burning to keep their departure secret. A loud call went up for the standards to be raised and for them to pursue the enemy and immediately loot the camp. The other consul behaved as if he were just a regular soldier. Paulus repeatedly insisted they should investigate the situation and take every precaution. Finally, when he could no longer resist the unrest and the instigator of the rebellion, he sent Marius Statilius, a prefect, with a troop from Lucania to scout ahead. Statilius ordered the rest to stay outside the fortifications while he entered the camp himself with two horsemen. After thoroughly inspecting everything, he returned with word that it was clearly a trap: the fires were left in the part of the camp facing the enemy, the tents were open, and valuables were left out in the open; he noted that he had seen silver scattered around the paths as if it had been left there for looting. This information, which was hoped would deter them from greed, only fueled their desire, with soldiers loudly declaring that unless the signal was given, they would move forward without their leaders, as they didn’t see a need for one—Varro quickly gave the signal to march. Paulus, reluctant to follow his own advice, noted that the omens from the chickens did not support the move and informed his colleague of this bad omen just as he was leading the troops out of the gate. Although Varro was impatient about it, the recent fate of Flaminius and Claudius’s naval defeat in the First Punic War weighed on his conscience. It seemed almost as if the gods themselves were more postponing than preventing the disaster over the Romans. This was highlighted by an incident where soldiers, disobeying the consul's order to return to camp, encountered two slaves—one belonging to a horseman from Formiae and the other to a man from Sidicinum—who had escaped after being captured by the Numidians while foraging during the consulate of Servilius and Atilius. These slaves informed the consuls that Hannibal's entire army was lying in wait on the other side of the nearby mountains. The timely arrival of these men restored the consuls' authority, which had been compromised by one consul's undignified yielding to ambition. Hannibal, realizing the Romans had impulsively acted rather than made a cautious decision, returned to his camp having accomplished nothing since his stratagem was uncovered. He couldn’t stay long due to the shortage of grain; not only among the soldiers—made up of remnants from different nations—but even the general himself faced new challenges daily: first there were murmurs among the soldiers, then open demands for their back pay, complaints about lack of supplies, and finally cries of starvation. Reports surfaced that the mercenaries, especially the Spanish, were planning to switch sides, and it was said that Hannibal himself sometimes considered fleeing to Gaul, intending to leave all his infantry and escape with his cavalry. With such plans brewing and the camp's sentiment at a low, he decided to move to Apulia, which was warmer and had an earlier harvest. He thought that the farther he moved from the enemy, the harder it would be for those wavering to desert. Under the cover of night, he again set fires and left a few tents standing to create the illusion of presence, hoping to keep the Romans wary of an ambush similar to the last. However, when Statilius, the Lucanian who had scouted the areas beyond the mountains and the camp, reported seeing the enemy marching in the distance, discussions began about pursuing them. The consuls held onto their usual views, but nearly everyone sided with Varro, with only Servilius, last year's consul, supporting Paulus. Following the majority's opinion, they set out, unwittingly marching towards a Roman disaster that would be etched into the history of Cannae. Hannibal had set up camp near that village, facing away from the wind Vulturnus, which carried dust clouds across the parched plains. This was not only highly beneficial for the camp, but also protected them during battle since they would be fighting an enemy blinded by the swirling dust that only hit their backs.

44

When the consuls, employing sufficient diligence in exploring the road in pursuit of the Carthaginian, had arrived at Cannae, where they had the enemy in the sight of them, having divided their forces, they fortify two camps with nearly the same interval as before, at Geronium. The river Aufidus, which flowed by both the camps, afforded approach to the watering parties of each, as opportunity served, though not without contest. The Romans in the lesser camp, however, which was on the other side the Aufidus, were more freely furnished with water, because the further bank had no guard of the enemy. Hannibal, entertaining a hope that the consuls would not decline a battle in this tract, which was naturally adapted to a cavalry engagement, in which portion of his forces he was invincible, formed his line, and provoked the enemy by a skirmishing attack with his Numidians. Upon this the Roman camp began again to be embroiled by a mutiny among the soldiers, and the disagreement of the consuls: since Paulus instanced to Varro the temerity of Sempronius and Flaminius; while Varro pointed to Fabius, as a specious example to timid and inactive generals. The latter called both gods and men to witness, "that no part of the blame attached to him that Hannibal had now made Italy his own, as it were, by right of possession; that he was held bound by his colleague; that the swords and arms were taken out of the hands of the indignant soldiers who were eager to fight." The former declared, "that if any disaster should befall the legions thus exposed and betrayed into an ill-advised and imprudent battle, he should be exempt from any blame, though the sharer of all the consequences. That he must take care that their hands were equally energetic in the battle whose tongues were so forward and impetuous."

When the consuls, working hard to find the route in pursuit of the Carthaginian, reached Cannae, where they could see the enemy, they divided their forces and built two camps at Geronium, spaced similarly to before. The river Aufidus, which ran by both camps, provided access for each side’s watering parties as opportunities arose, although it was competitive. The Romans in the smaller camp, located on the other side of the Aufidus, had more access to water since the opposite bank was unguarded by the enemy. Hannibal, hoping the consuls wouldn't shy away from a battle in this area, which was highly suitable for cavalry combat—his strongest unit—set up his line and taunted the enemy with skirmishes from his Numidians. As a result, the Roman camp became chaotic again due to tensions among the soldiers and disagreements between the consuls: Paulus pointed out the reckless actions of Sempronius and Flaminius to Varro, while Varro criticized Fabius as an example of a fearful and inactive general. Fabius then called upon both gods and men to bear witness that none of the blame was his for Hannibal now seemingly claiming Italy as his own; he felt he was bound by his colleague’s decisions and that the swords and arms had been taken from the hands of the angry soldiers eager to fight. Paulus asserted that if any disaster struck the legions exposed and misled into a rash and ill-advised battle, he would not take any blame, despite sharing in all the consequences. He insisted that those who were quick to speak must also be just as vigorous in battle.

45

While time is thus consumed in altercation rather than deliberating, Hannibal, who had kept his troops drawn up in order of battle till late in the day, when he had led the rest of them back into the camp, sends Numidians across the river to attack a watering party of the Romans from the lesser camp. Having routed this disorderly band by shouting and tumult, before they had well reached the opposite bank, they advanced even to an outpost which was before the rampart, and near the, very gates of the camp. It seemed so great an indignity, that now even the camp of the Romans should be terrified by a tumultuary band of auxiliaries, that this cause alone kept back the Romans from crossing the river forthwith, and forming their line, that the chief command was on that day held by Paulus. Accordingly Varro, on the following day, on which it was his turn to hold the command, without consulting his colleague, displayed the signal for battle, and forming his troops, led them across the river. Paulus followed, because he could better disapprove of the proceeding, than withhold his assistance. Having crossed the river, they add to their forces those which they had in the lesser camp; and thus forming their line, place the Roman cavalry in the right wing, which was next the river; and next them the infantry: at the extremity of the left wing the allied cavalry; within them the allied infantry, extending to the centre, and contiguous to the Roman legions. The darters, and the rest of the light-armed auxiliaries, formed the van. The consuls commanded the wings; Terentius the left, Aemilius the right. To Geminus Sevilius was committed the charge of maintaining the battle in the centre.

While time was wasted in arguments instead of discussions, Hannibal, who had kept his troops organized for battle until late in the day, led the rest of them back into the camp and sent Numidians across the river to attack a Roman watering party from the smaller camp. They scared off this disorganized group with noise and chaos before they had even reached the opposite bank, and advanced all the way to an outpost by the rampart, close to the very gates of the camp. It felt so humiliating for the Roman camp to be frightened by a chaotic group of allies that this alone held the Romans back from crossing the river immediately and forming their line, since the chief command was held by Paulus that day. The next day, when it was Varro's turn to command, he displayed the battle signal without consulting his colleague and led his troops across the river. Paulus followed, feeling it was better to disapprove of the move than to withhold his support. After crossing the river, they added to their forces those from the smaller camp; and thus formed their line, placing the Roman cavalry on the right wing next to the river; then the infantry behind them: at the far end of the left wing were the allied cavalry; alongside them the allied infantry extended to the center, next to the Roman legions. The skirmishers and other light-armed auxiliaries took the front. The consuls commanded the wings; Terentius the left, Aemilius the right. Geminus Sevilius was given the task of keeping the battle organized in the center.

46

Hannibal, at break of day, having sent before him the Baliares and other light-armed troops, crossed the river, and placed his troops in line of battle, as he had conveyed them across the river. The Gallic and Spanish cavalry he placed in the left wing, opposite the Roman cavalry: the right wing was assigned to the Numidian cavalry, the centre of the line being strongly formed by the infantry, so that both extremities of it were composed of Africans, between which Gauls and Spaniards were placed. One would suppose the Africans were for the most part Romans, they were so equipped with arms captured at the Trebia, and for the greater part at the Trasimenus. The shields of the Gauls and Spaniards were of the same shape; their swords unequal and dissimilar. The Gauls had very long ones, without points. The Spaniards, who were accustomed to stab more than to cut their enemy, had swords convenient from their shortness, and with points. The aspect of these nations in other respects was terrific, both as to the appearance they exhibited and the size of their persons. The Gauls were naked above the navel: the Spaniards stood arrayed in linen vests resplendent with surprising whiteness, and bordered with purple. The whole amount of infantry standing in battle-array was forty thousand, of cavalry ten. The generals who commanded the wings were on the left Hasdrubal, on the right Maharbal: Hannibal himself, with his brother Mago, commanded the centre. The sun very conveniently shone obliquely upon both parties; the Romans facing the south, and the Carthaginians the north; either placed so designedly, or having stood thus by chance. The wind, which the inhabitants of the district call the Vulturnus, blowing violently in front of the Romans, prevented their seeing far by rolling clouds of dust into their faces.

Hannibal, at daybreak, sent ahead the Balearic troops and other light infantry, crossed the river, and lined up his army for battle as he brought them over. He positioned the Gallic and Spanish cavalry on the left wing, facing the Roman cavalry, while the Numidian cavalry occupied the right wing. The center of the formation was made up of infantry, with Africans on both ends and Gauls and Spaniards in between. One might think the Africans were mostly Romans due to their gear, which was mostly taken from the battles at the Trebia and Trasimenus. The Gauls and Spaniards had similar shield designs but different swords; the Gauls wielded very long, pointed swords, while the Spaniards, who preferred stabbing over cutting, had shorter swords with pointed tips. The overall appearance of these nations was intimidating, both in their appearance and stature. The Gauls were bare-chested, while the Spaniards wore strikingly white linen tunics trimmed with purple. The total infantry was forty thousand, with ten thousand cavalry. The generals leading the wings were Hasdrubal on the left and Maharbal on the right, while Hannibal and his brother Mago commanded the center. The sun conveniently shone at an angle on both armies; the Romans faced south and the Carthaginians faced north, either by design or coincidence. The wind, known locally as the Vulturnus, blew forcefully at the Romans, creating clouds of dust that obscured their view.

47

The shout being raised, the auxiliaries charged, and the battle commenced in the first place with the light-armed troops: then the left wing, consisting of the Gallic and Spanish cavalry, engages with the Roman right wing, by no means in the manner of a cavalry battle; for they were obliged to engage front to front; for as on one side the river, on the other the line of infantry hemmed them in, there was no space left at their flanks for evolution, but both parties were compelled to press directly forward. At length the horses standing still, and being crowded together, man grappling with man, dragged him from his horse. The contest now came to be carried on principally on foot. The battle, however, was more violent than lasting; and the Roman cavalry being repulsed, turn their backs. About the conclusion of the contest between the cavalry, the battle between the infantry commenced. At first the Gauls and Spaniards preserved their ranks unbroken, not inferior in strength or courage: but at length the Romans, after long and repeated efforts, drove in with their even front and closely compacted line, that part of the enemy's line in the form of a wedge, which projected beyond the rest, which was too thin, and therefore deficient in strength. These men, thus driven back and hastily retreating, they closely pursued; and as they urged their course without interruption through this terrified band, as it fled with precipitation, were borne first upon the centre line of the enemy; and lastly, no one opposing them, they reached the African reserved troops. These were posted at the two extremities of the line, where it was depressed; while the centre, where the Gauls and Spaniards were placed, projected a little. When the wedge thus formed being driven in, at first rendered the line level, but afterwards, by the pressure, made a curvature in the centre, the Africans, who had now formed wings on each side of them, surrounded the Romans on both sides, who incautiously rushed into the intermediate space; and presently extending their wings, enclosed the enemy on the rear also. After this the Romans, who had in vain finished one battle, leaving the Gauls and Spaniards, whose rear they had slaughtered, in addition commence a fresh encounter with the Africans, not only disadvantageous, because being hemmed in they had to fight against troops who surrounded them, but also because, fatigued, they fought with those who were fresh and vigorous.

The shout went up, the auxiliaries charged, and the battle began first with the light-armed troops. Then the left wing, made up of Gallic and Spanish cavalry, faced off against the Roman right wing, but not in a traditional cavalry fight. They were forced to engage head-on; with the river on one side and infantry closing in on the other, there was no room to maneuver at their flanks, so both sides had to push straight ahead. Eventually, the horses came to a standstill, crowded together, and men grabbed each other, pulling opponents off their horses. The battle then shifted mostly to foot combat. Although intense, the fight did not last long; the Roman cavalry was pushed back and fled. Just as the cavalry confrontation began to settle, the infantry battle kicked off. At first, the Gauls and Spaniards held their ranks tightly, matching the Romans in strength and courage. But eventually, after relentless efforts, the Romans advanced with their solid, compact line and penetrated the part of the enemy's line that projected out in a wedge, which had become too thin and weak. Those men, now pushed back and retreating hastily, were closely pursued; as the Romans forced their way through the frightened mass, they first struck the enemy's center line, and with no opposition finally reached the African reserve troops. These troops had been stationed at the two ends of the line, where it dipped, while the center, occupied by the Gauls and Spaniards, protruded slightly. When the wedge penetrated, it initially leveled the line but then created a bulge in the center due to the pressure. The Africans, who had now formed flanking wings on either side, surrounded the Romans, who carelessly charged into the gap. Soon, as they extended their wings, they boxed in the enemy from behind as well. After this, the Romans, having failed to finish one battle, left the Gauls and Spaniards, whose rear they had just attacked, to engage in a new fight with the Africans. This was doubly disadvantageous, as they were trapped against troops that surrounded them, and they were fatigued while fighting fresh and vigorous opponents.

48

Now also in the left wing of the Romans, in which the allied cavalry were opposed to the Numidians, the battle was joined, which was at first languid, commencing with a stratagem on the part of the Carthaginians. About five hundred Numidians, who, besides their usual arms, had swords concealed beneath their coats of mail, quitting their own party, and riding up to the enemy under the semblance of deserters, with their bucklers behind them, suddenly leap down from their horses; and, throwing down their bucklers and javelins at the feet of their enemies, are received into their centre, and being conducted to the rear, ordered to remain there; and there they continued until the battle became general. But afterwards, when the thoughts and attention of all were occupied with the contest, snatching up the shields which lay scattered on all hands among the heaps of slain, they fell upon the rear of the Roman line, and striking their backs and wounding their hams, occasioned vast havoc, and still greater panic and confusion. While in one part terror and flight prevailed, in another the battle was obstinately persisted in, though with little hope. Hasdrubal, who was then commanding in that quarter, withdrawing the Numidians from the centre of the army, as the conflict with their opponents was slight, sends them in pursuit of the scattered fugitives, and joining the Africans, now almost weary with slaying rather than fighting the Spanish and Gallic infantry.

Now also in the left flank of the Romans, where the allied cavalry faced off against the Numidians, the battle began, initially slow, starting with a trick from the Carthaginians. About five hundred Numidians, who had swords hidden under their armor in addition to their usual weapons, left their group and approached the enemy pretending to be deserters, with their shields behind them. Suddenly, they jumped off their horses; after dropping their shields and javelins at the feet of their enemies, they were taken into the Roman ranks and led to the back, where they were told to stay until the battle became widespread. But later, when everyone's focus was on the fight, they grabbed the shields that were scattered among the fallen and attacked the rear of the Roman line, causing significant damage and even more panic and chaos. While terror and flight prevailed in one area, another part of the battle was fought stubbornly, albeit with little hope. Hasdrubal, who was in charge of that section, pulled the Numidians from the center of the army since their fight with the enemy was minimal, and sent them after the scattered runaways, joining the Africans, who were now almost exhausted from killing rather than actually fighting the Spanish and Gallic infantry.

49

On the other side of the field, Paulus, though severely wounded from a sling in the very commencement of the battle, with a compact body of troops, frequently opposed himself to Hannibal, and in several quarters restored the battle, the Roman cavalry protecting him; who, at length, when the consul had not strength enough even to manage his horse, dismounted from their horses. And when some one brought intelligence that the consul had ordered the cavalry to dismount, it is said that Hannibal observed, "How much rather would I that he delivered them to me in chains." The fight maintained by the dismounted cavalry was such as might be expected, when the victory was undoubtedly on the side of the enemy, the vanquished preferring death in their places to flight; and the conquerors, who were enraged at them for delaying the victory, butchering those whom they could not put to flight. They at length, however, drove the few who remained away, worn out with exertion and wounds. After that they were all dispersed, and such as could, sought to regain their horses for flight. Cneius Lentulus, a military tribune, seeing, as he rode by, the consul sitting upon a stone and covered with blood, said to him: "Lucius Aemilius! the only man whom the gods ought to regard as being guiltless of this day's disaster, take this horse, while you have any strength remaining, and I am with you to raise you up and protect you. Make not this battle more calamitous by the death of a consul. There is sufficient matter for tears and grief without this addition." In reply the consul said: "Do thou indeed go on and prosper, Cneius Servilius, in your career of virtue! But beware lest you waste in bootless commiseration the brief opportunity of escaping from the hands of the enemy. Go and tell the fathers publicly, to fortify the city of Rome, and garrison it strongly before the victorious enemy arrive: and tell Quintus Fabius individually, that Lucius Aemilius lived, and now dies, mindful of his injunctions. Allow me to expire amid these heaps of my slaughtered troops, that I may not a second time be accused after my consulate, or stand forth as the accuser of my colleague, in order to defend my own innocence by criminating another." While finishing these words, first a crowd of their flying countrymen, after that the enemy, came upon them; they overwhelm the consul with their weapons, not knowing who he was: in the confusion his horse rescued Lentulus. After that they fly precipitately. Seven thousand escaped to the lesser camp, ten to the greater, about two thousand to the village itself of Cannae who were immediately surrounded by Carthalo and the cavalry, no fortifications protecting the village. The other consul, whether by design or by chance, made good his escape to Venusia with about seventy horse, without mingling with any party of the flying troops. Forty thousand foot, two thousand seven hundred horse, there being an equal number of citizens and allies, are said to have been slain. Among both the quaestors of the consuls, Lucius Atilius and Lucius Furius Bibaculus; twenty-one military tribunes; several who had passed the offices of consul, praetor, and aedile; among these they reckon Cneius Servilius Germinus, and Marcus Minucius, who had been master of the horse on a former year, and consul some years before: moreover eighty, either senators, or who had borne those offices by which they might be elected into the senate, and who had voluntarily enrolled themselves in the legions. Three thousand infantry and three hundred cavalry are said to have been captured in that battle.

On the other side of the field, Paulus, despite being seriously injured by a sling at the start of the battle, often stood against Hannibal with a tight group of troops and managed to restore the fight in several places, protected by the Roman cavalry. Eventually, when the consul was too weak to even ride, the cavalry dismounted. When someone informed Hannibal that the consul had ordered the cavalry to get off their horses, it's said that he remarked, "I would much prefer he delivered them to me in chains." The fight from the dismounted cavalry was as expected, with victory clearly on the enemy's side. The defeated chose death over fleeing, while the victors, furious at the delay in their victory, slaughtered those they couldn't chase away. However, they eventually drove off the few who remained, exhausted from their efforts and injuries. Afterward, everyone dispersed, and those who could sought to find their horses to escape. Cneius Lentulus, a military tribune, rode by and saw the consul sitting on a stone, covered in blood. He said to him, "Lucius Aemilius! the only person the gods should consider blameless for today's disaster, take this horse while you still have strength left, and I’ll help you up and protect you. Don’t make this battle worse by dying as a consul. There’s already enough sorrow and grief without adding this." In response, the consul said, "You go on and succeed, Cneius Servilius, in your quest for virtue! But be careful not to waste the short chance to escape from the enemy in pointless sympathy. Go and tell the leaders publicly to strengthen and secure the city of Rome before the victorious enemy arrives, and tell Quintus Fabius individually that Lucius Aemilius lived and is now dying, remembering his directives. Let me die among these piles of my fallen troops, so I won’t be accused again after my consulship, or have to stand as the accuser of my colleague to defend my own innocence by blaming another." As he finished these words, a crowd of fleeing countrymen and then the enemy rushed upon them, overwhelming the consul with their weapons, not knowing who he was; in the chaos, his horse saved Lentulus. They then fled in panic. Seven thousand escaped to the smaller camp, ten to the larger camp, and about two thousand to the village of Cannae, where they were immediately surrounded by Carthalo and his cavalry, with no defenses protecting the village. The other consul, whether by design or luck, managed to escape to Venusia with about seventy horsemen, without mixing in with the fleeing troops. It's reported that forty thousand infantry and two thousand seven hundred cavalry were killed, including both consuls' quaestors, Lucius Atilius and Lucius Furius Bibaculus; twenty-one military tribunes; several who had held the offices of consul, praetor, and aedile, among them Cneius Servilius Germinus and Marcus Minucius, who had previously been master of the horse and consul several years earlier; in addition to eighty individuals who were either senators or held offices that could lead to senate election, having voluntarily joined the legions. Three thousand infantry and three hundred cavalry were reportedly captured in that battle.

50

Such is the battle of Cannae, equal in celebrity to the defeat at the Allia: but as it was less important in respect to those things which happened after it, because the enemy did not follow up the blow, so was it more important and more horrible with respect to the slaughter of the army; for with respect to the flight at the Allia, as it betrayed the city, so it preserved the army. At Cannae, scarcely seventy accompanied the flying consul: almost the whole army shared the fate of the other who died. The troops collected in the two camps being a half-armed multitude without leaders, those in the larger send a message to the others, that they should come over to them at night, when the enemy was oppressed with sleep, and wearied with the battle, and then, out of joy, overpowered with feasting: that they would go in one body to Canusium. Some entirely disapproved of that advice. "For why," said they, "did not those who sent for them come themselves, since there would be equal facility of forming a junction? Because, evidently, all the intermediate space was crowded with the enemy, and they would rather expose the persons of others to so great a danger than their own." Others did not so much disapprove, as want courage to fulfil the advice. Publius Sempronius Tuditanus, a military tribune, exclaims, "Would you rather, then, be captured by the most rapacious and cruel enemy, and have a price set upon your heads, and have your value ascertained by men who will ask whether you are Roman citizens or Latin confederates, in order that from your miseries and indignities honour may be sought for another? Not you, at least, if you are the fellow-citizens of Lucius Aemilius, the consul who preferred an honourable death to a life of infamy, and of so many brave men who lie heaped around him. But, before the light overtakes us and more numerous bodies of the enemy beset the way, let us break through those disorderly and irregular troops who are making a noise at our gates. By the sword and courage, a road may be made through enemies, however dense. In a wedge we shall make our way through this loose and disjointed band, as if nothing opposed us. Come along with me therefore, ye who wish the safety of yourselves and the state." Having thus said, he draws his sword, and forming a wedge, goes through the midst of the enemy; and as the Numidians discharged their javelins on their right side, which was exposed, they transferred their shields to the right hand, and thus escaped, to the number of six hundred, to the greater camp; and setting out thence forthwith, another large body having joined them, arrived safe at Canusium. These measures were taken by the vanquished, according to the impulse of their tempers, which his own disposition or which accident gave to each, rather than in consequence of any deliberate plan of their own, or in obedience to the command of any one.

Such is the battle of Cannae, as famous as the defeat at the Allia: but while it was less significant in terms of what happened afterward, since the enemy did not pursue their advantage, it was more critical and horrific regarding the slaughter of the army; for in the case of the flight at the Allia, it betrayed the city but saved the army. At Cannae, barely seventy men accompanied the fleeing consul: almost the entire army met the same fate as the one who died. The troops gathered in the two camps were a half-armed crowd without leaders, and those in the larger camp sent a message to the others, asking them to join them at night when the enemy was exhausted from battle and asleep, and then, in a fit of joy and celebration, they would head to Canusium together. Some completely disapproved of that suggestion. "Why," they asked, "didn't those who called them come themselves, since it would be just as easy to join forces? Clearly, the area in between was packed with the enemy, and they would rather put others at such great risk than themselves." Others didn’t so much disagree as lack the courage to follow through on the suggestion. Publius Sempronius Tuditanus, a military tribune, exclaimed, "Would you rather be captured by the most greedy and brutal enemy, have a price on your heads, and be valued by people who will ask if you are Roman citizens or Latin allies, all so that someone else can gain glory from your suffering and shame? Not if you are fellow citizens of Lucius Aemilius, the consul who chose an honorable death over a life of disgrace, and of all the brave men who lie dead around him. But before daylight catches us and more enemy forces block the way, let’s break through those disorganized and noisy troops at our gates. With sword and courage, we can create a path through even the densest enemy lines. We will push through this scattered crowd as if nothing stands in our way. So come with me, you who care about your safety and the state's.” Having said this, he drew his sword and formed a wedge, moving through the enemy; as the Numidians hurled their javelins at their exposed right side, they switched their shields to their right hands and escaped, numbering six hundred, to the larger camp; and setting out from there immediately, after another large group joined them, they safely reached Canusium. These actions were taken by the defeated, driven more by their emotions or circumstances than by any well-thought-out plan or in obedience to anyone's orders.

51

When all others, surrounding the victorious Hannibal, congratulated him, and advised that, having completed so great a battle, he should himself take the remainder of the day and the ensuing night for rest, and grant it to his exhausted troops; Maharbal, prefect of the cavalry, who was of opinion that no time should be lost, said to him, "Nay, rather, that you may know what has been achieved by this battle, five days hence you shall feast in triumph in the Capitol. Follow me: I will go first with the cavalry, that they may know that I am arrived before they know of me as approaching." To Hannibal this project appeared too full of joy, and too great for his mind to embrace it and determine upon it at the instant. Accordingly, he replied to Maharbal, that "he applauded his zeal, but that time was necessary to ponder the proposal." Upon this Maharbal observed, "Of a truth the gods have not bestowed all things upon the same person. You know how to conquer, Hannibal; but you do not know how to make use of your victory." That day's delay is firmly believed to have been the preservation of the city and the empire. On the following day, as soon as it dawned, they set about gathering the spoils and viewing the carnage, which was shocking, even to enemies. So many thousands of Romans were lying, foot and horse promiscuously, according as accident had brought them together, either in the battle or in the flight. Some, whom their wounds, pinched by the morning cold, had roused, as they were rising up, covered with blood, from the midst of the heaps of slain, were overpowered by the enemy. Some too they found lying alive with their thighs and hams cut who, laying bare their necks and throats, bid them drain the blood that remained in them. Some were found with their heads plunged into the earth, which they had excavated; having thus, as it appeared, made pits for themselves, and having suffocated themselves by overwhelming their faces with the earth which they threw over them. A living Numidian, with lacerated nose and ears, stretched beneath a lifeless Roman who lay upon him, principally attracted the attention of all; for when his hands were powerless to grasp his weapon, turning from rage to madness, he had died in the act of tearing his antagonist with his teeth.

When everyone around the victorious Hannibal congratulated him and suggested that he take the rest of the day and the upcoming night to rest, as well as let his weary troops do the same, Maharbal, the cavalry commander, who believed no time should be wasted, said to him, "No, instead, you should know what this battle has accomplished. In five days, you will celebrate triumphantly in the Capitol. Follow me: I will lead with the cavalry so that they know I've arrived before they even realize I'm coming." To Hannibal, this plan felt too overwhelming and joyful to grasp or decide on immediately. He responded to Maharbal, saying he appreciated his eagerness but that he needed time to think it over. Maharbal then remarked, "Truly, the gods haven’t given everything to one person. You know how to conquer, Hannibal, but you don’t know how to make the most of your victory." That day’s hesitation is believed to have saved the city and the empire. The following day, as soon as dawn broke, they began collecting the spoils and surveying the shocking carnage, which was even disturbing to the enemies. Thousands of Romans lay scattered, both foot soldiers and cavalry, mixed together as chance had brought them, whether in battle or in retreat. Some, awakened by their wounds and the morning chill, were trying to rise covered in blood from among the piles of the dead but were overpowered by the enemy. Others were found alive, their thighs and legs injured, who, exposing their necks and throats, begged to have the remaining blood drained from them. Some were discovered with their heads buried in the ground, having dug themselves pits, suffocating by covering their faces with the earth they had thrown over themselves. A living Numidian, with a torn nose and ears, lay beneath a dead Roman, drawing everyone's attention; for when his hands were too weak to hold his weapon, he had succumbed to madness and died while trying to tear his opponent apart with his teeth.

52

The spoils having been gathered for a great part of the day, Hannibal leads his troops to storm the lesser camp, and, first of all, interposing a trench, cuts it off from the river. But as the men were fatigued with toil, watching, and wounds, a surrender was made sooner than he expected. Having agreed to deliver up their arms and horses, on condition that the ransom of every Roman should be three hundred denarii, for an ally two hundred, for a slave one hundred, and that on payment of that ransom they should be allowed to depart with single garments, they received the enemy into the camp, and were all delivered into custody, the citizens and allies being kept separate. While the time is being spent there, all who had strength or spirit enough, to the number of four thousand foot and two hundred horse, quitted the greater camp and arrived at Canusium; some in a body, others widely dispersed through the country, which was no less secure a course: the camp itself was surrendered to the enemy by the wounded and timid troops, on the same terms as the other was. A very great booty was obtained; and with the exception of the men and horses, and what silver there was which was for the most part on the trappings of the horses; for they had but very little in use for eating from, particularly in campaign; all the rest of the booty was given up to be plundered. Then he ordered the bodies of his own troops to be collected for burial. They are said to have been as many as eight thousand of his bravest men. Some authors relate, that the Roman consul also was carefully searched for and buried. Those who escaped to Canusium, being received by the people of that place within their walls and houses only, were assisted with corn, clothes, and provisions for their journey, by an Apulian lady, named Busa, distinguished for her family and riches; in return for which munificence, the senate afterwards, when the war was concluded, conferred honours upon her.

After gathering the spoils for most of the day, Hannibal led his troops to attack the smaller camp. He first dug a trench to block it off from the river. However, since the men were exhausted from working, keeping watch, and nursing wounds, the enemy surrendered sooner than he anticipated. They agreed to hand over their weapons and horses, as long as the ransom was set at three hundred denarii for each Roman, two hundred for an ally, and one hundred for a slave. They also insisted that, after paying the ransom, they could leave with only their clothes. The enemy was allowed into the camp, and everyone was taken into custody, with citizens and allies kept apart. While waiting there, four thousand infantry and two hundred cavalry who had the strength or spirit managed to leave the larger camp and make it to Canusium, some together and others scattered throughout the countryside, which was also a safe option. The larger camp was then surrendered to the enemy by the wounded and cowardly troops, under the same conditions as the smaller camp. A huge amount of loot was seized; apart from the soldiers and horses and most of the silver that was primarily on the horse gear, they had very little available for food, especially during the campaign. Everything else was left for plundering. Hannibal then ordered the bodies of his own men to be collected for burial. It’s said that around eight thousand of his bravest soldiers fell. Some accounts claim that the Roman consul was also searched for and buried with care. Those who made it to Canusium were welcomed by the local people into their homes and were given corn, clothes, and supplies for their journey by a wealthy Apulian woman named Busa. In appreciation for her generosity, the senate later honored her after the war was over.

53

But, though there were four military tribunes there, Fabius Maximus of the first legion, whose father had been dictator the former year; and of the second legion, Lucius Publicius Bibulus and Publius Cornelius Scipio; and of the third legion, Appius Claudius Pulcher, who had been aedile the last year; by the consent of all, the supreme command was vested in Publius Scipio, then a very young man, and Appius Claudius. To these, while deliberating with a few others on the crisis of their affairs, Publius Furius Philus, the son of a man of consular dignity, brings intelligence, "That it was in vain that they cherished hopes which could never be realized: that the state was despaired of, and lamented as lost. That certain noble youths, the chief of whom was Lucius Caecilius Metellus, turned their attention to the sea and ships, in order that, abandoning Italy, they might escape to some king." When this calamity, which was not only dreadful in itself, but new, and in addition to the numerous disasters they had sustained, had struck them motionless with astonishment and stupor; and while those who were present gave it as their opinion that a council should be called to deliberate upon it, young Scipio, the destined general of this war, asserts, "That it is not a proper subject for deliberation: that courage and action, and not deliberation, were necessary in so great a calamity. That those who wished the safety of the state would attend him forthwith in arms; that in no place was the camp of the enemy more truly, than where such designs were meditated." He immediately proceeds, attended by a few, to the lodging of Metellus; and finding there the council of youths of which he had been apprized, he drew his sword over the heads of them, deliberating, and said, "With sincerity of soul I swear that neither will I myself desert the cause of the Roman republic, nor will I suffer any other citizen of Rome to desert it. If knowingly I violate my oath, then, O Jupiter, supremely great and good, mayest thou visit my house, my family, and my fortune with perdition the most horrible! I require you, Lucius Caecilius, and the rest of you who are present, to take this oath; and let the man who shall not take it be assured, that this sword is drawn against him." Terrified, as though they were beholding the victorious Hannibal, they all take the oath, and deliver themselves to Scipio to be kept in custody.

But even though there were four military tribunes present—Fabius Maximus of the first legion, whose father had been dictator the previous year; Lucius Publicius Bibulus and Publius Cornelius Scipio of the second legion; and Appius Claudius Pulcher of the third legion, who had been aedile the year before—everyone agreed that the supreme command should go to Publius Scipio, who was still very young, and Appius Claudius. While they were discussing their situation with a few others, Publius Furius Philus, son of a man of consular rank, brought news that their hopes were futile and that the state was seen as lost. He said that certain noble youths, especially Lucius Caecilius Metellus, were planning to abandon Italy for the sea and escape to some king. When this horrific and unprecedented news left them stunned and speechless, and those present suggested calling a council to discuss it, young Scipio, destined to be the general of this war, stated that deliberation was not appropriate: what was needed was courage and action in such a great crisis. He declared that those truly wishing for the state's safety should follow him immediately in arms, asserting that the enemy camp was most certainly where such plans were plotted. He then moved quickly, accompanied by a few, to Metellus's quarters, where he found the council of youths he had heard about. Drawing his sword over them as they deliberated, he said, "I swear with all my heart that neither will I abandon the cause of the Roman Republic, nor will I let any other citizen of Rome do so. If I knowingly break this oath, then, O Jupiter, most great and good, may you bring the most terrible destruction upon my home, my family, and my fortunes! I ask you, Lucius Caecilius, and all of you present, to take this oath; and anyone who refuses it should know this sword is drawn against him." Terrified, as if faced with the victorious Hannibal, they all took the oath and entrusted themselves to Scipio for safekeeping.

54

During the time in which these things were going on at Canusium, as many as four thousand foot and horse, who had been dispersed through the country in the flight, came to Venusia, to the consul. These the Venusini distributed throughout their families, to be kindly entertained and taken care of; and also gave to each horseman a gown, a tunic, and twenty-five denarii; and to each foot soldier ten denarii, and such arms as they wanted; and every other kind of hospitality showed them, both publicly and privately: emulously striving that the people of Venusia might not be surpassed by a woman of Canusium in kind offices. But the great number of her guests rendered the burden more oppressive to Busa, for they amounted now to ten thousand men. Appius and Scipio, having heard that the other consul was safe, immediately send a messenger to inquire how great a force of infantry and cavalry he had with him, and at the same time to ask, whether it was his pleasure that the army should be brought to Venusia, or remain at Canusium. Varro himself led over his forces to Canusium. And now there was some appearance of a consular army, and they seemed able to defend themselves from the enemy by walls, if not by arms. At Rome intelligence had been received, that not even these relics of their citizens and allies had survived, but that the two consuls, with their armies, were cut to pieces, and all their forces annihilated. Never when the city was in safety was there so great a panic and confusion within the walls of Rome. I shall therefore shrink from the task, and not attempt to relate what in describing I must make less than the reality. The consul and his army having been lost at the Trasimenus the year before, it was not one wound upon another which was announced, but a multiplied disaster, the loss of two consular armies, together with the two consuls: and that now there was neither any Roman camp, nor general nor soldiery: that Apulia and Samnium, and now almost the whole of Italy, were in the possession of Hannibal. No other nation surely would not have been overwhelmed by such an accumulation of misfortune. Shall I compare with it the disaster of the Carthaginians, sustained in a naval battle at the islands Aegates, dispirited by which they gave up Sicily and Sardinia, and thenceforth submitted to become tributary and stipendiary? Or shall I compare with it the defeat in Africa under which this same Hannibal afterwards sunk? In no respect are they comparable, except that they were endured with less fortitude.

During the time these events were happening at Canusium, around four thousand soldiers, both infantry and cavalry, who had scattered in their flight, arrived at Venusia to meet the consul. The people of Venusia took them in, providing hospitality and care. They gave each horseman a gown, a tunic, and twenty-five denarii, while each foot soldier received ten denarii along with whatever weapons they needed. They offered every kind of hospitality, both publicly and privately, trying hard to ensure that the people of Venusia wouldn’t be outdone by a woman from Canusium in their kindness. However, the large number of guests put a heavy strain on Busa, as they had now swelled to ten thousand men. Appius and Scipio, upon hearing that the other consul was safe, quickly sent a messenger to find out how many infantry and cavalry he had with him, and to ask whether he wanted the army to come to Venusia or stay in Canusium. Varro himself brought his forces to Canusium. Now there was a semblance of a consular army, and it seemed like they could defend themselves against the enemy behind walls, if not with arms. In Rome, news came that not even the remnants of their citizens and allies had survived; the two consuls, along with their armies, had been wiped out, and all their forces were annihilated. Never had there been such panic and confusion within the walls of Rome during a time of safety. I will therefore refrain from the task and not attempt to describe what I would have to diminish from reality. The consul and his army had been lost at Trasimenus the year before; they did not just receive one blow after another, but faced a multiplied disaster: the loss of two consular armies along with the two consuls. Now there was no longer any Roman camp, general, or soldiers left, and Hannibal had taken control of Apulia, Samnium, and nearly all of Italy. No other nation would surely have survived such a series of misfortunes. Should I compare this to the disaster the Carthaginians faced in a naval battle at the Aegates Islands, which demoralized them to the point of giving up Sicily and Sardinia, becoming tributary and subject going forward? Or should I compare it to the defeat in Africa under which Hannibal himself later fell? In no way are they comparable, except that they were endured with far less strength.

55

Publius Furius Philus and Manius Pomponius, the praetors, assembled the senate in the curia hostilia, that they might deliberate about the guarding of the city; for they doubted not but that the enemy, now their armies were annihilated, would come to assault Rome, the only operation of the war which remained. Unable to form any plan in misfortunes, not only very great, but unknown and undefined, and while the loud lamentations of the women were resounding, and nothing was as yet made known, the living and the dead alike being lamented in almost every house; such being the state of things, Quintus Fabius gave it as his opinion, "That light horsemen should be sent out on the Latin and Appian ways, who, questioning those they met, as some would certainly be dispersed in all directions from the flight, might bring back word what was the fate of the consuls and their armies; and if the gods, pitying the empire, had left any remnant of the Roman name where these forces were; whither Hannibal had repaired after the battle, what he was meditating; what he was doing, or about to do. That these points should be searched out and ascertained by active youths. That it should be the business of the fathers, since there was a deficiency of magistrates, to do away with the tumult and trepidation in the city; to keep the women from coming into public, and compel each to abide within her own threshold; to put a stop to the lamentations of families; to obtain silence in the city; to take care that the bearers of every kind of intelligence should be brought before the praetors; that each person should await at home the bearer of tidings respecting his own fortune: moreover, that they should post guards at the gates, to prevent any person from quitting the city; and oblige men to place their sole hopes of safety in the preservation of the walls and the city. That when the tumult had subsided the fathers should be called again to the senate-house, and deliberate on the defence of the city."

Publius Furius Philus and Manius Pomponius, the praetors, gathered the senate in the Curia Hostilia to discuss how to protect the city. They were sure that the enemy, now that their armies had been destroyed, would attack Rome, the only remaining objective of the war. Struggling to make a plan amidst such great misfortunes, which were both unfamiliar and undefined, and with the loud cries of women echoing around them, while families mourned both the living and the dead in almost every household, Quintus Fabius suggested, "We should send out light cavalry on the Latin and Appian roads to question anyone they encounter, as some would have scattered in all directions after the chaos. They could find out what happened to the consuls and their armies, and if the gods, in their mercy for the empire, spared any remnants of the Roman name where these forces are located; where Hannibal went after the battle, what he was planning, and what he was doing or about to do. Active young men should investigate these matters. It should be the responsibility of the elders, since there are not enough magistrates, to quell the panic in the city; to prevent women from appearing in public and make sure each stays inside their own home; to stop the family mourning; to restore silence in the city; to ensure that everyone bringing news is presented to the praetors; that each individual wait at home for news about their own situation. Additionally, they should set up guards at the gates to stop anyone from leaving the city and make sure people place their hopes for safety on protecting the walls and the city. Once the chaos has subsided, the elders should be called back to the senate house to discuss the defense of the city."

56

When all had signified their approbation of this opinion, and after the crowd had been removed by the magistrates from the forum, and the senators had proceeded in different directions to allay the tumult; then at length a letter is brought from the consul Terentius, stating, "That Lucius Aemilius, the consul, and his army were slain; that he himself was at Canusium, collecting, as it were after a shipwreck, the remains of this great disaster; that he had nearly ten thousand irregular and unorganized troops. That the Carthaginian was sitting still at Cannae, bargaining about the price of the captives and the other booty, neither with the spirit of a conqueror nor in the style of a great general." Then also the losses of private families were made known throughout the several houses; and so completely was the whole city filled with grief, that the anniversary sacred rite of Ceres was intermitted, because it was neither allowable to perform it while in mourning, nor was there at that juncture a single matron who was not in mourning. Accordingly, lest the same cause should occasion the neglect of other public and private sacred rites, the mourning was limited to thirty days, by a decree of the senate. Now when the tumult in the city was allayed, an additional letter was brought from Sicily, from Titus Otacilius, the propraetor, stating, "that the kingdom of Hiero was being devastated by the Carthaginian fleet: and that, being desirous of affording him the assistance he implored, he received intelligence that another Carthaginian fleet was stationed at the Aegates, equipped and prepared; in order that when the Carthaginians had perceived that he was gone away to protect the coast of Syracuse, they might immediately attack Lilybaeum and other parts of the Roman province; that he therefore needed a fleet, if they wished him to protect the king their ally, and Sicily."

Once everyone had shown their support for this opinion, and after the crowd had been cleared from the forum by the magistrates, the senators went their separate ways to help calm the uproar. Finally, a letter arrived from Consul Terentius, which stated, "Lucius Aemilius, the consul, and his army were killed; I am at Canusium, picking up the pieces after this terrible disaster; I have nearly ten thousand disorganized troops. The Carthaginian is just sitting at Cannae, negotiating the ransom for captives and the spoils, showing neither the spirit of a conqueror nor the style of a great general." The losses suffered by individual families were also made known throughout the city, and the entire city was so overwhelmed with grief that the annual sacred rite for Ceres was postponed, as it was inappropriate to hold it while mourning, and there wasn't a single matron present who wasn't in mourning. To prevent this grief from disrupting other public and private sacred rites, the senate decreed that the mourning period would last for thirty days. Once the chaos in the city had settled down, another letter arrived from Sicily, from Titus Otacilius, the propraetor, which said, "The Carthaginian fleet is ravaging the kingdom of Hiero. Wanting to help him as he requested, I learned that another Carthaginian fleet is stationed at the Aegates, fully equipped. If the Carthaginians realize I’ve left to defend the coast of Syracuse, they will likely attack Lilybaeum and other parts of the Roman province. Therefore, I need a fleet if we want to protect our ally, the king, and Sicily."

57

The letters of the consul and the propraetor having been read, they resolved that Marcus Claudius, who commanded the fleet stationed at Ostia, should be sent to the army to Canusium; and a letter be written to the consul, to the effect that, having delivered the army to the praetor, he should return to Rome the first moment he could, consistently with the interest of the republic. They were terrified also, in addition to these disasters, both with other prodigies, and also because two vestal virgins, Opimia and Floronia, were that year convicted of incontinence; one of whom was, according to custom, buried alive at the Colline gate; the other destroyed herself. Lucius Cantilius, secretary of the pontiff, whom they now call the lesser pontiffs, who had debauched Floronia, was beaten by rods in the comitium, by order of the chief pontiff, so that he expired under the stripes. This impiety being converted into a prodigy, as is usually the case when happening in the midst of so many calamities, the decemviri were desired to consult the sacred books. Quintus Fabius Pictor was also sent to Delphi, to inquire of the oracle by what prayers and offerings they might appease the gods, and what termination there would be to such great distresses. Meanwhile certain extraordinary sacrifices were performed, according to the directions of the books of the fates; among which a Gallic man and woman, and a Greek man and woman, were let down alive in the cattle market, into a place fenced round with stone, which had been already polluted with human victims, a rite by no means Roman. The gods being, as they supposed, sufficiently appeased, Marcus Claudius Marcellus sends from Ostia to Rome, as a garrison for the city, one thousand five hundred soldiers, which he had with him, levied for the fleet. He himself sending before him a marine legion, (it was the third legion,) under the command of the military tribunes, to Teanum Sidicinum, and delivering the fleet to Publius Furius Philus, his colleague, after a few days, proceeded by long marches to Cannsium. Marcus Junius, created dictator on the authority of the senate, and Titus Sempronius, master of the horse, proclaiming a levy, enrol the younger men from the age of seventeen, and some who wore the toga praetexta: of these, four legions and a thousand horse were formed. They send also to the allies and the Latin confederacy, to receive the soldiers according to the terms of the treaty. They order that arms, weapons, and other things should be prepared; and they take down from the temples and porticoes the old spoils taken from the enemy. They adopted also another and a new form of levy, from the scarcity of free persons, and from necessity: they armed eight thousand stout youths from the slaves, purchased at the public expense, first inquiring of each whether he was willing to serve. They preferred this description of troops, though they had the power of redeeming the captives at a less expense.

The letters from the consul and the propraetor were read, and they decided that Marcus Claudius, who was in command of the fleet stationed at Ostia, should be sent to the army at Canusium; and a letter should be written to the consul to inform him that, after handing over the army to the praetor, he should return to Rome as soon as it was in the best interest of the republic. They were also frightened not only by these disasters but also by other signs, and because two vestal virgins, Opimia and Floronia, were convicted of losing their vows that year; one was, according to tradition, buried alive at the Colline gate, while the other took her own life. Lucius Cantilius, the secretary of the pontiff, now called the lesser pontiffs, who had seduced Floronia, was beaten in the comitium by order of the chief pontiff until he died from the lashes. This act of impiety was regarded as an omen, as often happens during such calamities, prompting the decemviri to consult the sacred texts. Quintus Fabius Pictor was also sent to Delphi to ask the oracle how they could appease the gods with prayers and offerings and what the outcome of such enormous troubles would be. Meanwhile, specific extraordinary sacrifices were performed, following the guidelines from the Books of Fate; among which a Gallic man and woman, and a Greek man and woman, were lowered alive into a stone enclosure at the cattle market, a place already tainted by human sacrifices, which was not a Roman custom. Believing the gods had been suitably appeased, Marcus Claudius Marcellus sent 1,500 soldiers from Ostia to Rome as a garrison for the city, which he had recruited for the fleet. He himself dispatched a marine legion (the third legion) under military tribunes to Teanum Sidicinum and handed over the fleet to his colleague Publius Furius Philus, then, after a few days, made a long march to Canusium. Marcus Junius, appointed dictator by the senate, and Titus Sempronius, the master of the horse, called for a levy, enrolling younger men starting from age seventeen, including some who wore the toga praetexta: from these, four legions and a thousand cavalry were formed. They also sent messengers to the allies and the Latin confederacy to gather soldiers according to treaty agreements. They directed that arms, weapons, and other supplies be prepared; and removed old spoils taken from enemies from the temples and porticoes. They also introduced a new method of recruitment due to the shortage of free men and necessity: they armed 8,000 strong young men from among the slaves, purchased at public expense, first asking each one if he was willing to serve. They preferred this type of troop, even though they could redeem the captives at a lower cost.

58

For Hannibal, after so great a victory at Cannae, being occupied with the cares of a conqueror, rather than one who had a war to prosecute, the captives having been brought forward and separated, addressed the allies in terms of kindness, as he had done before at the Trebia and the lake Trasimenus, and dismissed them without a ransom; then he addressed the Romans too, who were called to him, in very gentle terms: "That he was not carrying on a war of extermination with the Romans, but was contending for honour and empire. That his ancestors had yielded to the Roman valour; and that he was endeavouring that others might be obliged to yield, in their turn, to his good fortune and valour together. Accordingly, he allowed the captives the liberty of ransoming themselves, and that the price per head should be five hundred denarii for a horseman, three hundred for a foot soldier, and one hundred for a slave." Although some addition was made to that sum for the cavalry, which they stipulated for themselves when they surrendered, yet they joyfully accepted any terms of entering into the compact. They determined that ten persons should be selected, by their own votes, who might go to Rome to the senate; nor was any other guarantee of their fidelity taken than that they should swear that they would return. With these was sent Carthalo, a noble Carthaginian, who might propose terms, if perchance their minds were inclined towards peace. When they had gone out of the camp, one of their body, a man who had very little of the Roman character, under pretence of having forgotten something, returned to the camp, for the purpose of freeing himself from the obligation of his oath, and overtook his companions before night. When it was announced that they had arrived at Rome, a lictor was despatched to meet Carthalo, to tell him, in the words of the dictator, to depart from the Roman territories before night.

For Hannibal, after such a huge victory at Cannae, focusing more on the responsibilities of a conqueror than on continuing the war, he brought forward the captives, separated them, and spoke kindly to the allies, just as he had done before at the Trebia and Lake Trasimene, then released them without any ransom. He also addressed the Romans who were called to him with gentle words: "I’m not waging a war of total destruction against the Romans, but fighting for honor and power. My ancestors accepted Roman bravery, and I am trying to make others yield to my good fortune and bravery in return." He then allowed the captives to pay for their freedom, setting the price at five hundred denarii for a cavalryman, three hundred for an infantryman, and one hundred for a slave. While they did add a bit to that amount for the cavalry, which they had requested when they surrendered, they gladly accepted the terms. They decided that ten of them would be chosen by popular vote to go to Rome to the senate, and no other guarantee of their loyalty was required other than their oath to return. Along with them was Carthalo, a noble Carthaginian, who could propose terms if they were leaning towards peace. After they left the camp, one of their group, a man who wasn’t very much like the typical Roman, came back to the camp under the pretense of forgetting something, intending to free himself from his oath, and caught up with his companions before nightfall. When it was reported that they had reached Rome, a lictor was sent to meet Carthalo and deliver the dictator's message that he should leave Roman territory before nightfall.

59

An audience of the senate was granted by the dictator to the delegates of the prisoners. The chief of them, Marcus Junius, thus spoke: "There is not one of us, conscript fathers, who is not aware that there never was a nation which held prisoners in greater contempt than our own. But unless our own cause is dearer to us than it should be, never did men fall into the hands of the enemy who less deserved to be disregarded than we do; for we did not surrender our arms in the battle through fear; but having prolonged the battle almost till night-fall, while standing upon heaps of our slaughtered countrymen, we betook ourselves to our camp. For the remainder of the day and during the following night, although exhausted with exertion and wounds, we protected our rampart. On the following day, when, beset by the enemy, we were deprived of water, and there was no hope of breaking through the dense bands of the enemy; and, moreover, not considering it an impiety that any Roman soldier should survive the battle of Cannae, after fifty thousand of our army had been butchered; then at length we agreed upon terms on which we might be ransomed and let off; and our arms, in which there was no longer any protection, we delivered to the enemy. We had been informed that our ancestors also had redeemed themselves from the Gauls with gold, and that though so rigid as to the terms of peace, had sent ambassadors to Tarentum for the purpose of ransoming the captives. And yet both the fight at the Allia with the Gauls, and at Heraclea with Pyrrhus, was disgraceful, not so much on account of the loss as the panic and flight. Heaps of Roman carcasses cover the plains of Cannae; nor would any of us have survived the battle, had not the enemy wanted the strength and the sword to slay us. There are, too, some of us, who did not even retreat in the field; but being left to guard the camp, came into the hands of the enemy when it was surrendered. For my part, I envy not the good fortune or condition of any citizen or fellow-soldier, nor would I endeavour to raise myself by depressing another: but not even those men who, for the most part, leaving their arms, fled from the field, and stopped not till they arrived at Venusia or Canusium; not even those men, unless some reward is due to them on account of their swiftness of foot and running, would justly set themselves before us, or boast that there is more protection to the state in them than in us. But you will both find them to be good and brave soldiers, and us still more zealous, because, by your kindness, we have been ransomed and restored to our country. You are levying from every age and condition: I hear that eight thousand slaves are being armed. We are no fewer in number; nor will the expense of redeeming us be greater than that of purchasing these. Should I compare ourselves with them, I should injure the name of Roman. I should think also, conscript fathers, that in deliberating on such a measure, it ought also to be considered, (if you are disposed to be over severe, which you cannot do from any demerit of ours,) to what sort of enemy you would abandon us. Is it to Pyrrhus, for instance, who treated us, when his prisoners, like guests; or to a barbarian and Carthaginian, of whom it is difficult to determine whether his rapacity or cruelty be the greater? If you were to see the chains, the squalid appearance, the loathsomeness of your countrymen, that spectacle would not, I am confident, less affect you, than if, on the other hand, you beheld your legions prostrate on the plains of Cannae. You may behold the solicitude and the tears of our kinsmen, as they stand in the lobby of your senate-house, and await your answer. When they are in so much suspense and anxiety in behalf of us, and those who are absent, what think you must be our own feelings, whose lives and liberty are at stake? By Hercules! should Hannibal himself, contrary to his nature, be disposed to be lenient towards us, yet we should not consider our lives worth possessing, since we have seemed unworthy of being ransomed by you. Formerly, prisoners dismissed by Pyrrhus, without ransom, returned to Rome; but they returned in company with ambassadors, the chief men of the state, who were sent to ransom them. Would I return to my country, a citizen, and not considered worth three hundred denarii? Every man has his own way of thinking, conscript fathers. I know that my life and person are at stake. But the danger which threatens my reputation affects me most, if we should go away rejected and condemned by you; for men will never suppose that you grudged the price of our redemption."

An audience of the Senate was granted by the dictator to the delegates of the prisoners. The leader of them, Marcus Junius, spoke: "There isn’t a single one of us, dear senators, who doesn’t realize that no nation has ever held prisoners in greater contempt than ours. But unless our own cause matters to us more than it should, we've never been in less deserving hands than we are now; we didn’t surrender our weapons in battle out of fear; we fought almost until nightfall, standing on heaps of our fallen countrymen, before we retreated to our camp. For the rest of that day and throughout the night, despite being exhausted from fighting and injuries, we defended our fortifications. The next day, surrounded by the enemy and cut off from water, with no hope of breaking through their dense ranks, and with the belief that no Roman soldier should survive the battle of Cannae after fifty thousand of our army had been slaughtered; that’s when we finally agreed to the terms for our ransom and surrendered our arms, which could no longer protect us. We had heard that our ancestors also redeemed themselves from the Gauls with gold, and even though they were strict about peace terms, they sent ambassadors to Tarentum to ransom the captives. Yet, both the battles at the Allia against the Gauls and at Heraclea against Pyrrhus were disgraceful, not just because of the loss but because of the panic and flight. Heaps of Roman bodies cover the plains of Cannae; and none of us would have survived the battle if the enemy hadn’t been too weak or lacking the will to kill us. Some of us didn’t even retreat on the battlefield; we were left to guard the camp and fell into the enemy's hands when it was surrendered. As for me, I don’t envy the good fortune of any citizen or fellow soldier, nor would I support myself by putting down another: but even those men who mostly fled the field, leaving their weapons behind and didn’t stop until they reached Venusia or Canusium; not even they, unless rewarded for their speed, could justly place themselves before us or claim they offer the state more protection than we do. But you will find them to be good and brave soldiers, and us even more determined, because you have shown us kindness by ransoming us and bringing us back to our country. You are recruiting from all ages and backgrounds: I hear that eight thousand slaves are being armed. We are no fewer in number; nor will the cost to redeem us be greater than that of buying these. If I were to compare ourselves with them, I would dishonor the name of Roman. I also think, dear senators, that in considering such a measure, it should be acknowledged (if you are inclined to be overly harsh, which you cannot do based on any faults of ours) what kind of enemy you would abandon us to. Is it to Pyrrhus, for instance, who treated us like guests when we were his prisoners; or to a barbarian and Carthaginian, whose greed and cruelty are hard to distinguish? If you were to see the chains, the filthy appearance, and the loathsomeness of your fellow countrymen, that sight would surely affect you as much, if not more, than witnessing your legions fallen on the plains of Cannae. You can see the worry and tears of our relatives standing in the lobby of your Senate, anxiously awaiting your response. When they are so anxious for us and for those who are absent, what do you think our own feelings must be, knowing our lives and freedom are at stake? By Hercules! even if Hannibal himself were to act kindly towards us, we wouldn’t value our lives anymore, since we seem unworthy of being ransomed by you. In the past, prisoners released by Pyrrhus, without ransom, returned to Rome; but they returned alongside ambassadors, the respected leaders of the state, sent to negotiate their ransom. Would I return to my country as a citizen, only to be considered worth less than three hundred denarii? Everybody has their own perspective, dear senators. I know my life and existence are at stake. But the threat to my reputation troubles me the most if we leave rejected and condemned by you; for people will never believe you regretted the cost of our redemption."

60

When he had finished his address, the crowd of persons in the comitium immediately set up a loud lamentation, and stretched out their hands to the senate, imploring them to restore to them their children, their brothers, and their kinsmen. Their fears and affection for their kindred had brought the women also with the crowd of men in the forum. Witnesses being excluded, the matter began to be discussed in the senate. There being a difference of opinion, and some advising that they should be ransomed at the public charge, others, that the state should be put to no expense, but that they should not be prevented redeeming themselves at their own cost; and that those who had not the money at present should receive a loan from the public coffer, and security given to the people by their sureties and properties; Titus Manlius Torquatus, a man of primitive, and, as some considered, over-rigorous severity, being asked his opinion, is reported thus to have spoken: "Had the deputies confined themselves to making a request, in behalf of those who are in the hands of the enemy, that they might be ransomed, I should have briefly given my opinion, without inveighing against any one. For what else would have been necessary but to admonish you, that you ought to adhere to the custom handed down from your ancestors, a precedent indispensable to military discipline. But now, since they have almost boasted of having surrendered themselves to the enemy, and have claimed to be preferred, not only to those who were captured by the enemy in the field, but to those also who came to Venusia and Canusium, and even to the consul Terentius himself; I will not suffer you to remain in ignorance of things which were done there. And I could wish that what I am about to bring before you, were stated at Canusium, before the army itself, the best witness of every man's cowardice or valour; or at least that one person, Publius Sempronius, were here, whom had they followed as their leader, they would this day have been soldiers in the Roman camp, and not prisoners in the power of the enemy. But though the enemy was fatigued with fighting, and engaged in rejoicing for their victory, and had, the greater part of them, retired into their camp, and they had the night at their disposal for making a sally, and as they were seven thousand armed troops, might have forced their way through the troops of the enemy, however closely arrayed; yet they neither of themselves attempted to do this, nor were willing to follow another. Throughout nearly the whole night Sempronius ceased not to admonish and exhort them, while but few of the enemy were about the camp, while there was stillness and quiet, while the night would conceal their design, that they would follow him; that before daybreak they might reach places of security, the cities of their allies. If as Publius Decius, the military tribune in Samnium, said, within the memory of our grandfathers; if he had said, as Calpurnius Flamma, in the first Punic war, when we were youths, said to the three hundred volunteers, when he was leading them to seize upon an eminence situated in the midst of the enemy: LET US DIE, SOLDIERS, AND BY OUR DEATHS RESCUE THE SURROUNDED LEGIONS FROM AMBUSCADE;--if Publius Sempronius had said thus, he would neither have considered you as Romans nor men, had no one stood forward as his companion in so valorous an attempt. He points out to you the road that leads not to glory more than to safety; he restores you to your country, your parents, your wives and children. Do you want courage to effect your preservation? What would you do if you had to die for your country? Fifty thousand of your countrymen and allies on that very day lay around you slain. If so many examples of courage did not move you, nothing ever will. If so great a carnage did not make life less dear, none ever will. While in freedom and safety, show your affection for your country; nay, rather do so while it is your country, and you its citizens. Too late you now endeavour to evince your regard for her when degraded, disfranchised from the rights of citizens, and become the slaves of the Carthaginians. Shall you return by purchase to that degree which you have forfeited by cowardice and neglect? You did not listen to Sempronius, your countryman, when he bid you take arms and follow him; but a little after you listened to Hannibal, when he ordered your arms to be surrendered, and your camp betrayed. But why do I charge those men with cowardice, when I might tax them with villany? They not only refused to follow him who gave them good advice, but endeavoured to oppose and hold him back, had not some men of the greatest bravery, drawing their swords, removed the cowards. Publius Sempronius, I say, was obliged to force his way through a band of his countrymen, before he burst through the enemy's troops. Can our country regret such citizens as these, whom if all the rest resembled, she would not have one citizen of all those who fought at Cannae? Out of seven thousand armed men, there were six hundred who had courage to force their way, who returned to their country free, and in arms; nor did forty thousand of the enemy successfully oppose them. How safe, think you, would a passage have been for nearly two legions? Then you would have had this day at Canusium, conscript fathers, twenty thousand bold and faithful. But now how can these men be called faithful and good citizens, (for they do not even call themselves brave,) except any man suppose that they showed themselves such when they opposed those who were desirous of forcing their way through the enemy? or, unless any man can suppose, that they do not envy those men their safety and glory acquired by valour, when the must know that their timidity and cowardice were the cause of their ignominious servitude? Skulking in their tents they preferred to wait for the light and the enemy together, when they had an opportunity of sallying forth during the silence of the night. But though they had not courage to sally forth from the camp, had they courage to defend it strenuously? Having endured a siege for several days and nights, did they protect their rampart by their arms, and themselves by their rampart? At length, having dared and suffered every extremity, every support of life being gone, their strength exhausted with famine, and unable to hold their arms, were they subdued by the necessities of nature rather than by arms? At sunrise, the enemy approached the rampart: before the second hour, without hazarding any contest, they delivered up their arms and themselves. Here is their military service for you during two days. When they ought to have stood firm in array and fight on, then they fled back into their camp; when they ought to have fought before their rampart, they delivered up their camp: good for nothing, either in the field or the camp. I redeem you. When you ought to sally from the camp, you linger and hesitate; and when you ought to stay and protect your camp in arms, you surrender the camp, your arms, and yourselves to the enemy. I am of opinion, conscript fathers, that these men should no more be ransomed, than that those should be surrendered to Hannibal, who sallied from the camp through the midst of the enemy, and, with the most distinguished courage, restored themselves to their country."

When he finished his speech, the crowd in the forum immediately let out loud cries and reached out to the Senate, begging them to bring back their children, brothers, and relatives. Their fears and love for their family also brought the women to join the men in the forum. With no witnesses allowed in, the Senate started discussing the matter. There were differing opinions; some suggested that the government should pay for their ransom, while others argued that the state shouldn’t spend any money, and that those who could should redeem themselves at their own expense. They also proposed that those who couldn’t afford it should get a loan from the public funds, with guarantees provided by their sureties and property. Titus Manlius Torquatus, known for his strictness, was asked for his opinion and reportedly said: “If the ambassadors had simply asked for help to ransom those in the enemy's hands, I would have briefly given my support without criticizing anyone. All that would have been necessary is to remind you to stick to the traditions passed down from our ancestors, which are crucial for military discipline. But now, since they almost boast about surrendering to the enemy and believe they should be prioritized not just over those captured in battle, but even over those who went to Venusia and Canusium, including Consul Terentius himself; I can’t let you stay unaware of what happened there. I wish I could present this before the army at Canusium, the best judge of every person's bravery or cowardice; or at least that Publius Sempronius were here. Had they followed him as their leader, they would today be soldiers in the Roman camp instead of prisoners of the enemy. Even though the enemy was worn out from fighting, celebrating their victory, and most of them had returned to their camp, they had the opportunity that night to make a breakout, with seven thousand armed troops that could have possibly forced their way through the enemy ranks, no matter how tightly packed; yet they neither tried to do this nor wanted to follow anyone who did. Throughout nearly the entire night, Sempronius kept advising and urging them when there were only a few enemy troops around the camp, when things were quiet, and the night would cloak their escape, to follow him so they could reach safe places, the towns of their allies, before dawn. If, as Publius Decius, the military tribune in Samnium said, during our grandfathers' time; or if he had said as Calpurnius Flamma did in the First Punic War, when he led three hundred volunteers to capture a hill amid the enemy: LET US DIE, SOLDIERS, AND BY OUR DEATHS RESCUE THE SURROUNDED LEGIONS FROM AMBUSCADE;--if Publius Sempronius had said something like this, he wouldn’t have considered you as Romans or even human if no one had stood by him in such a brave effort. He shows you the path leading to safety, not just glory; he offers you a return to your country, your parents, your wives, and your children. Are you lacking the courage to save yourselves? What would you do if it meant dying for your country? Fifty thousand of your fellow countrymen and allies lay slain around you on that very day. If that many examples of bravery don't move you, nothing will. If such great slaughter didn’t make life less precious, nothing ever will. While you are free and safe, show your love for your country; indeed, do this while you are still its citizens. It’s too late to show your loyalty now when you’ve been degraded, stripped of your rights as citizens, and become slaves to the Carthaginians. Are you going to buy back the status you lost through cowardice and neglect? You didn’t heed Sempronius, your countryman, when he urged you to take up arms and follow him; yet soon after, you listened to Hannibal when he ordered you to surrender your weapons and betray your camp. But why do I blame them for cowardice, when I could accuse them of treachery? They not only refused to follow the one giving wise advice but even tried to stop him, if not for some brave men who drew their swords and forced the cowards away. Publius Sempronius, I say, had to push through a crowd of his fellow citizens before breaking through the enemy’s lines. Can our country regret citizens like these? If they were all like them, she wouldn’t have a single citizen left from those who fought at Cannae. Out of seven thousand armed men, only six hundred had the courage to fight their way back, returning to their country armed and free; forty thousand of the enemy couldn’t stop them. How safe do you think a passage would have been for nearly two legions? You would have had, today at Canusium, twenty thousand bold and loyal men. But now how can these men be called loyal and good citizens, (since they don’t even call themselves brave,) unless one assumes they showed their worth when they tried to stop those seeking to break through the enemy? Or, unless one believes they don’t resent those who achieved safety and glory through bravery, when they must know their own fear and cowardice caused their disgraceful servitude? Hiding in their tents, they chose to wait for daylight and the enemy, even when they had a chance to rush out during the night's silence. But even if they didn’t have the courage to break from the camp, did they have the guts to defend it fiercely? After enduring a siege for several days and nights, did they defend their walls with their weapons and protect themselves with their rampart? Eventually, having faced every hardship, with all supplies gone, their strength depleted by hunger, unable to even hold their weapons, were they defeated by the demands of nature rather than by enemy arms? At sunrise, the enemy approached the wall: before the second hour, without putting up any resistance, they surrendered their weapons and themselves. Here’s their military record over two days. When they should have stood firm and fought, they ran back to the camp; when they should’ve fought at their wall, they abandoned their camp: useless in both battle and defense. I redeem you. When you should have attacked from the camp, you hesitated; and when you should have defended your camp with your weapons, you surrendered the camp, your weapons, and yourselves to the enemy. I believe, conscript fathers, that these men should not be ransomed any more than those who defied Hannibal while breaking through the enemy lines and bravely restored themselves to their country.”

61

After Manlius had thus spoken, notwithstanding the captives were related to many even of the senators, besides the practice of the state, which had never shown favour to captives, even from the remotest times, the sum of money also influenced them: for they were neither willing to drain the treasury, a large sum of money having been already issued for buying and arming slaves to serve in the war, nor to enrich Hannibal, who, according to report, was particularly in want of this very thing. The sad reply, that the captives would not be ransomed, being delivered, and fresh grief being added to the former on account of the loss of so many citizens, the people accompanied the deputies to the gate with copious tears and lamentations. One of them went home, because he had evaded his oath by artfully returning to the camp. But when this was known and laid before the senate, they all resolved that he should be apprehended and conveyed to Hannibal by guards, furnished by the state. There is another account respecting the prisoners, that ten came first, and that, the senate hesitating whether they should be admitted into the city or not, they were admitted, on the understanding that they should not have an audience of the senate. That when these staid longer than the expectation of all, three more came, Scribonius, Calpurnius, and Manlius. That then at length a tribune of the people, a relation of Scribonius, laid before the senate the redemption of the captives, and that they resolved that they should not be ransomed. That the three last deputies returned to Hannibal, and the ten former remained, because they had evaded their oath, having returned to Hannibal after having set out, under pretence of learning afresh the names of the captives. That a violent contest took place in the senate, on the question of surrendering them, and that those who thought they ought to be surrendered were beaten by a few votes, but that they were so branded by every kind of stigma and ignominy by the ensuing censors, that some of them immediately put themselves to death, and the rest, for all their life afterwards, not only shunned the forum, but almost the light and publicity. You can more easily wonder that authors differ so much than determine what is the truth. How much greater this disaster was than any preceding, even this is a proof, that such of the allies as had stood firm till that day then began to waver, for no other cause certainly but that they despaired of the empire. The people who revolted to the Carthaginians were these: the Atellani, Calatini, the Hirpini, some of the Apulians, the Samnites, except the Pentrians, all the Bruttians, and the Lucanians. Besides these the Surrentinians, and almost the whole coast possessed by the Greeks, the people of Tarentum, Metapontum, Croton, the Locrians, and all Cisalpine Gaul. Yet not even these losses and defections of their allies so shook the firmness of the Romans, that any mention of peace was made among them, either before the arrival of the consul at Rome, or after he came thither, and renewed the memory of the calamity they had suffered. At which very juncture, such was the magnanimity of the state, that the consul, as he returned after so severe a defeat, of which he himself was the principal cause, was met in crowds of all ranks of citizens, and thanks bestowed because he had not despaired of the republic, in whose case, had he been a Carthaginian commander, no species of punishment would have been spared.

After Manlius had spoken, even though the captives were related to many of the senators and the state's long-standing policy had never favored captives, the amount of money also played a role in their decision. They were not willing to drain the treasury, as a significant sum had already been spent on purchasing and arming slaves to fight in the war, nor did they want to enrich Hannibal, who reportedly was in dire need of that money. When the sad news that the captives would not be ransomed was delivered, it added fresh grief to the already deep sorrow over the loss of so many citizens. The people accompanied the deputies to the gate with many tears and lamentations. One of the deputies went home because he had avoided his oath by cleverly returning to camp. But when this was revealed to the senate, they all agreed he should be captured and handed over to Hannibal by state-provided guards. According to another version regarding the prisoners, ten were the first to arrive, and when the senate debated whether to admit them into the city, they were allowed entrance on the condition that they would not address the senate. As these captives stayed longer than expected, three more arrived: Scribonius, Calpurnius, and Manlius. Finally, a tribune of the people, who was related to Scribonius, presented the case for redeeming the captives, but the senate decided they should not be ransomed. The last three deputies returned to Hannibal, while the first ten remained because they had broken their oath by returning to Hannibal after claiming they needed to refresh their knowledge of the captives' names. A fierce debate ensued in the senate about whether to surrender them, and those in favor of surrendering lost by a narrow vote, but they were so stigmatized and shamed by the subsequent censors that some of them took their own lives, while the others avoided the forum for the rest of their lives, almost shunning light and public life altogether. It's easier to wonder why authors disagree so much than to determine what the truth is. That this was a greater disaster than any before is evidenced by the fact that the allies who had stayed loyal until that point began to falter, certainly because they despaired of the empire. The people who turned to the Carthaginians included the Atellani, Calatini, Hirpini, some Apulians, the Samnites (except the Pentrians), all the Bruttians, and all the Lucanians. In addition, the Surrentinians and nearly the entire coastline occupied by Greeks, the people of Tarentum, Metapontum, Croton, the Locrians, and all of Cisalpine Gaul joined them. Yet, even these losses and defections did not shake the resolve of the Romans enough for any talks of peace to arise among them, either before the consul arrived in Rome or after he came and reminded them of the calamity they had suffered. At that very moment, the consul, returning from such a severe defeat primarily caused by his own actions, was met by crowds of citizens from all walks of life, who expressed their gratitude for not giving up on the republic, for had he been a Carthaginian commander, he would have faced severe punishment.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXIII.
B.C. 216-215


The Campanians revolt to Hannibal. Mago is sent to Carthage to announce the victory of Cannae. Hanno advises the Carthaginian senate to make peace with the Romans, but is overborne by the Barcine faction. Claudius Marcellus the praetor defeats Hannibal at Nola. Hannibal's army is enervated in mind and body by luxurious living at Capua. Casilinum is besieged by the Carthaginians, and the inhabitants reduced to the last extremity of famine. A hundred and ninety-seven senators elected from the equestrian order. Lucius Postumius is, with his army, cut off by the Gauls. Cneius and Publius Scipio defeat Hasdrubal in Spain, and gain possession of that country. The remains of the army, defeated at Cannae, are sent off to Sicily, there to remain until the termination of the war. An alliance is formed between Philip, king of Macedon, and Hannibal. Sempronius Gracchus defeats the Campanians. Successes of Titus Manlius in Sardinia he takes Hasdrubal the general, Mago, and Hanno prisoners. Claudius Marcellus again defeats the army of Hannibal at Nola, and the hopes of the Romans are revived as to the results of the war.

       *        *        *        *        *

1

After the battle of Cannae, Hannibal, having captured and plundered the Roman camp, had immediately removed from Apulia into Samnium; invited into the territory of the Hirpini by Statius, who promised that he would surrender Compsa. Tiebius, a native of Compsa, was conspicuous for rank among his countrymen; but a faction of the Mopsii kept him down--a family of great influence through the favour of the Romans. After intelligence of the battle of Cannae, and a report of the approach of Hannibal, circulated by the discourse of Trebius, the Mopsian party had retired from the city; which was thus given up to the Carthaginian without opposition, and a garrison received into it. Leaving there all his booty and baggage, and dividing his forces, he orders Mago to receive under his protection the cities of that district which might revolt from the Romans, and to force to defection those which might be disinclined. He himself, passing through the territory of Campania, made for the lower sea, with the intention of assaulting Naples, in order that he might be master of a maritime city. As soon as he entered the confines of the Neapolitan territory, he placed part of his Numidians in ambush, wherever he could find a convenient spot; for there are very many hollow roads and secret windings: others he ordered to drive before them the booty they had collected from the country, and, exhibiting it to the enemy, to ride up to the gates of the city. As they appeared to be few in number and in disorder, a troop of horse sallied out against them, which was cut off, being drawn into an ambuscade by the others, who purposely retreated: nor would one of them have escaped, had not the sea been near, and some vessels, principally such as are used in fishing, observed at a short distance from the shore, afforded an escape for those who could swim. Several noble youths, however, were captured and slain in that affair. Among whom, Hegeas, the commander of the cavalry, fell when pursuing the retreating enemy too eagerly. The sight of the walls, which were not favourable to a besieging force, deterred the Carthaginian from storming the city.

After the battle of Cannae, Hannibal, after capturing and looting the Roman camp, quickly moved from Apulia to Samnium. He was invited into the territory of the Hirpini by Statius, who promised to hand over Compsa. Tiebius, a prominent local, was significant among his people, but a faction of the Mopsii, a powerful family favored by the Romans, kept him down. After news of the battle of Cannae and reports of Hannibal's approach spread through Trebius's talk, the Mopsian party left the city, allowing it to be surrendered to the Carthaginian without resistance, and a garrison was installed. Hannibal left behind all his plunder and baggage, divided his forces, and ordered Mago to protect any cities in the area that might rebel against the Romans and to lure those that were hesitant into joining. Hannibal himself, traveling through Campania, headed for the lower sea with plans to attack Naples to gain control of a port city. Once he entered the Neapolitan territory, he hid part of his Numidians in ambush wherever suitable; there are many hidden paths and winding roads. He also instructed others to drive the loot they had gathered from the countryside towards the city gates, presenting it to the enemy. When the enemy saw that they were outnumbered and disorganized, a group of cavalry charged out against them but was cut off, having been lured into an ambush by the others who fell back on purpose. None would have escaped had the sea not been nearby and some fishing boats spotted a short distance from shore provided a way out for those who could swim. However, several noble youths were captured and killed in this encounter, including Hegeas, the cavalry commander, who was slain while pursuing the retreating enemy too eagerly. The sight of the city's walls, which were not advantageous for a besieging force, dissuaded the Carthaginian from attacking.

2

Thence he turned his course to Capua, which was wantoning under a long course of prosperity, and the indulgence of fortune: amid the general corruption, however, the most conspicuous feature was the extravagance of the commons, who exercised their liberty without limit. Pacuvius Calavius had rendered the senate subservient to himself and the commons, at once a noble and popular man, but who had acquired his influence by dishonourable intrigues. Happening to hold the chief magistracy during the year in which the defeat at the Trasimenus occurred, and thinking that the commons, who had long felt the most violent hostility to the senate, would attempt some desperate measure, should an opportunity for effecting a change present itself; and if Hannibal should come into that quarter with his victorious army, would murder the senators and deliver Capua to the Carthaginians; as he desired to rule in a state preserved rather than subverted (for though depraved he was not utterly abandoned), and as he felt convinced that no state could be preserved if bereaved of its public council, he adopted a plan by which he might preserve the senate and render it subject to himself and the commons. Having assembled the senate, he prefaced his remarks by observing, "that nothing would induce him to acquiesce in a plan of defection from the Romans, were it not absolutely necessary; since he had children by the daughter of Appius Claudius, and had a daughter at Rome married to Livius: but that a much more serious and alarming matter threatened them, than any consequences which could result from such a measure. For that the intention of the commons was not to abolish the senate by revolting to the Carthaginians, but to murder the senators, and deliver the state thus destitute to Hannibal and the Carthaginians. That it was in his power to rescue them from this danger, if they would resign themselves to his care, and, forgetting their political dissensions, confide in him." When, overpowered with fear, they all put themselves under his protection, he proceeded: "I will shut you up in the senate-house, and pretending myself to be an accomplice in the meditated crime, I will, by approving measures which I should in vain oppose, find out a way for your safety. For the performance of this take whatever pledge you please." Having given his honour, he went out; and having ordered the house to be closed, placed a guard in the lobby that no one might enter or leave it without his leave.

Then he shifted his focus to Capua, which was enjoying a lengthy period of prosperity and the favor of fortune. Amid the widespread corruption, the most noticeable aspect was the extravagance of the common people, who exercised their freedom without restraint. Pacuvius Calavius had made the senate submissive to himself and the commons; he was both a noble and a popular figure, but he gained his power through dishonorable schemes. Holding the top position during the year of the defeat at Lake Trasimene, he feared that the commons, who had long been fiercely opposed to the senate, would try to take desperate action if an opportunity to initiate change arose, especially if Hannibal arrived with his victorious army, intending to kill the senators and hand Capua over to the Carthaginians. He wanted to lead a state that was maintained rather than destroyed (for he was corrupt but not entirely lost), and he believed no state could survive without its governing council. He devised a plan to safeguard the senate and make it subordinate to himself and the commons. After gathering the senate, he began by saying, "Nothing could make me agree to a plan to defect from the Romans unless it were absolutely necessary; I have children with the daughter of Appius Claudius, and a daughter married to Livius in Rome. However, there's a far more serious and urgent issue looming over us than any backlash from such a decision. The commons don’t intend to abolish the senate by switching allegiance to the Carthaginians; instead, they plan to kill the senators and leave the state vulnerable to Hannibal and the Carthaginians. I can save you from this threat if you put yourselves in my care, and, setting aside your political disagreements, trust in me." When they were overcome with fear and all placed themselves under his protection, he continued, "I will confine you in the senate house, and pretending to be involved in the plotted crime, I will approve of actions that I should otherwise oppose, finding a way to ensure your safety. For this, take whatever pledge you wish.” Having given his word, he left; then, he ordered the doors locked and stationed a guard in the entrance so that no one could enter or leave without his permission.

3

Then assembling the people, he thus addressed them: "What you have so often wished for, Campanians, the power of punishing an unprincipled and detestable senate, you now have, not at your own imminent peril, by riotously storming the houses of each, which are guarded and garrisoned with slaves and dependants, but free and without danger. Take them all, shut up in the senate-house, alone and unarmed; nor need you do any thing precipitately or blindly. I will give you the opportunity of pronouncing upon the life or death of each, that each may suffer the punishment he has deserved. But, above all, it behoves you so to give way to your resentment, as considering that your own safety and advantage are of greater importance. For I apprehend that you hate these particular senators, and not that you are unwilling to have any senate at all; for you must either have a king, which all abominate, or a senate, which is the only course compatible with a free state. Accordingly you must effect two objects at the same time; you must remove the old senate and elect a new one. I will order the senators to be summoned one by one, and I shall put it to you to decide whether they deserve to live or die: whatever you may determine respecting each shall be done; but before you execute your sentence on the culprit, you shall elect some brave and strenuous man as a fresh senator to supply his place." Upon this he took his seat, and, the names having been thrown together into an urn, he ordered that the name which had the lot to fall out first should be proclaimed, and the person brought forward out of the senate-house. When the name was heard, each man strenuously exclaimed that he was a wicked and unprincipled fellow, and deserved to be punished. Pacuvius then said, "I perceive the sentence which has been passed on this man; now choose a good and upright senator in the room of this wicked and unprincipled one." At first all was silence, from the want of a better man whom they might substitute; afterwards, one of them, laying aside his modesty, nominating some one, in an instant a much greater clamour arose; while some denied all knowledge of him, others objected to him at one time on account of flagitious conduct, at another time on account of his humble birth, his sordid circumstances, and the disgraceful nature of his trade and occupation. The same occurred with increased vehemence with respect to the second and third senators, so that it was evident that they were dissatisfied with the senator himself, but had not any one to substitute for him; for it was of no use that the same persons should be nominated again, to no other purpose than to hear of their vices, and the rest were much more mean and obscure than those who first occurred to their recollection. Thus the assembly separated, affirming that every evil which was most known was easiest to be endured, and ordering the senate to be discharged from custody.

Then gathering the people, he spoke to them: "What you've often wished for, Campanians, the ability to punish a corrupt and detestable senate, you now have, and you can do it without putting yourselves in danger by violently storming each of their houses, which are guarded by slaves and followers. Instead, you can act freely and without risk. Bring them all here, shut up in the senate-house, alone and unarmed; there's no need for you to act rashly or blindly. I'll give you the chance to decide their fate, so each one can face the punishment they deserve. But above all, remember that your own safety and wellbeing come first. I understand you despise these particular senators, but it's not that you want to do away with the senate entirely; you can either have a king, which everyone hates, or a senate, which is the only path to a free state. Therefore, you need to achieve two goals at the same time; you must remove the old senate and elect a new one. I'll have the senators brought in one by one, and you'll decide whether they deserve to live or die: whatever you decide for each one will be carried out; but before you execute your sentence, you must elect a brave and strong person to take their place." After that, he took his seat, and the names were put into an urn. He ordered the name that was drawn first to be announced and the person to be brought forward from the senate-house. When the name was announced, everyone loudly declared that he was a wicked and corrupt individual who deserved to be punished. Pacuvius then said, "I see the sentence that has been passed on this man; now choose a good and honorable senator to replace this wicked one." At first, there was silence, as they struggled to think of a better candidate; eventually, one of them, overcoming his shyness, suggested someone, which immediately caused a much greater uproar; some denied knowing him, others objected to him for his disgraceful actions, and yet others criticized his humble origins, his poor circumstances, and the shameful nature of his job. The same happened with even more intensity with the second and third senators, showing that while they were dissatisfied with the senators themselves, they had no one else to suggest in their place; it was pointless to keep nominating the same people only to hear their faults, and the others were much less noteworthy and unknown than those who first came to mind. The assembly then broke up, agreeing that the known evils were easier to bear and ordering the release of the senate from custody.

4

Pacuvius, having thus rendered the senators more subservient to himself than to the commons by the gift of their lives, ruled without the aid of arms, all persons now acquiescing. Henceforward the senators, forgetful of their rank and independence, flattered the commons; saluted them courteously; invited them graciously; entertained them with sumptuous feasts; undertook those causes, always espoused that party, decided as judges in favour of that side, which was most popular, and best adapted to conciliate the favour of the commons. Now, indeed, every thing was transacted in the senate as if it had been an assembly of the people. The Capuans, ever prone to luxurious indulgence not only from natural turpitude, but from the profusion of the means of voluptuous enjoyment which flowed in upon them, and the temptations of all the luxuries of land and sea; at that time especially proceeded to such a pitch of extravagance in consequence of the obsequiousness of the nobles and the unrestrained liberty of the commons, that their lust and prodigality had no bounds. To a disregard for the laws, the magistrates, and the senate, now, after the disaster of Cannae, was added a contempt for the Roman government also, for which there had been some degree of respect. The only obstacles to immediate revolt were the intermarriages which, from a remote period, had connected many of their distinguished and influential families with the Romans; and, which formed the strongest bond of union, that while several of their countrymen were serving in the Roman armies, particularly three hundred horsemen, the flower of the Campanian nobility, had been selected and sent by the Romans to garrison the cities of Sicily.

Pacuvius, by granting the senators more allegiance to himself than to the common people through the gift of their lives, ruled without using force, and everyone accepted this. From that point on, the senators, forgetting their status and independence, flattered the common folks; greeted them politely; invited them warmly; entertained them with lavish feasts; took up their causes, always siding with whichever party was most popular and likely to win the common people's favor. Everything in the Senate was now handled as if it were a gathering of the people. The Capuans, naturally prone to indulgence and surrounded by the abundance of luxury from both land and sea, became even more extravagant due to the nobles’ subservience and the unrestricted freedom of the commoners, leading to unchecked lust and wastefulness. Alongside their disregard for the laws, magistrates, and the Senate, a contempt for the Roman government emerged, which had previously commanded some respect. The only things preventing an outright rebellion were the intermarriages that had long linked many of their prominent and powerful families with the Romans, creating a strong bond. While several of their fellow citizens were serving in the Roman armies, particularly three hundred cavalrymen, the elite of the Campanian nobility, had been chosen and sent by the Romans to fortify the cities of Sicily.

5

The parents and relations of these men with difficulty obtained that ambassadors should be sent to the Roman consul. The consul, who had not yet set out for Canusium, they found at Venusia with a few half-armed troops, an object of entire commiseration to faithful, but of contempt to proud and perfidious allies, like the Campanians. The consul too increased their contempt of himself and his cause, by too much exposing and exhibiting the disastrous state of his affairs; for when the ambassadors had delivered their message, which was, that the senate and people of Capua were distressed that any adverse event should have befallen the Romans, and were promising every assistance in prosecuting the war, he observed, "In bidding us order you to furnish us with all things which are necessary for the war, Campanians, you have rather observed the customary mode of addressing allies, than spoken suitably to the present posture of our affairs; for hath anything been left us at Cannae, so that, as if we possessed that, we can desire what is wanting to be supplied by our allies? Can we order a supply of infantry, as if we had any cavalry? Can we say we are deficient in money, as if that were the only thing we wanted? Fortune has not even left us anything which we can add to. Our legions, cavalry, arms, standards, horses, men, money, provisions, all perished either in the battle, or in the two camps which were lost the following day. You must, therefore, Campanians, not assist us in the war, but almost take it upon yourselves in our stead. Call to mind how formerly at Saticula we received into our protection and defended your ancestors, when dismayed and driven within their walls; terrified not only by their Samnite but Sidicinian enemies; and how we carried on, with varying success, through a period of almost a century, a war with the Samnites, commenced on your account. Add to this, that when you gave yourselves up to us we granted you an alliance on equal terms, that we allowed you your own laws, and lastly, what before the disaster at Cannae was surely a privilege of the highest value, we bestowed the freedom of our city on a large portion of you, and held it in common with you. It is your duty, therefore, Campanians, to look upon this disaster which has been suffered as your own, and to consider that our common country must be protected. It is not a Samnite or Tuscan foe we are engaged with, so that the empire taken from us might still continue in Italy. A Carthaginian enemy draws after him from the remotest regions of the world, from the straits of the ocean and the pillars of Hercules, a body of soldiers who are not even natives of Africa, destitute of all laws, and of the condition and almost of the language of men. Savage and ferocious from nature and habit, their general has rendered them still more so, by forming bridges and works with heaps of human bodies; and, what the tongue can scarcely utter, by teaching them to live on human flesh. What man, provided he were born in any part of Italy, would not abominate the idea of seeing and having for his masters these men, nourished with such horrid food, whom even to touch were an impiety; of fetching laws from Africa and Carthage; and of suffering Italy to become a province of the Moors and Numidians? It will be highly honourable, Campanians, that the Roman empire, sinking under this disastrous defeat, should be sustained and restored by your fidelity and your strength. I conceive that thirty thousand foot and four thousand horse may be raised in Campania. You have already abundance of money and corn. If your zeal corresponds with your means, neither will Hannibal feel that he has been victorious, nor the Romans that they have been defeated."

The parents and relatives of these men struggled to get ambassadors sent to the Roman consul. They found the consul, who hadn't yet left for Canusium, at Venusia with a few poorly armed troops, evoking sympathy from loyal allies but disdain from proud and treacherous ones like the Campanians. The consul further fueled their contempt for him and his situation by excessively revealing the dire state of his affairs. When the ambassadors delivered their message, expressing that the Senate and people of Capua were distressed over any misfortune befalling the Romans and offering their full support in the war, he responded, "In asking us to order you to provide everything necessary for the war, Campanians, you are following the usual way of addressing allies rather than speaking appropriately to our current situation. Have we been left with anything at Cannae that we can claim as ours, so we can ask for what we lack from our allies? Can we request more infantry as if we have cavalry? Can we complain about a lack of money as if that's all we need? Fortune hasn't left us anything to build upon. Our legions, cavalry, weapons, standards, horses, men, money, provisions—all were lost either in the battle or in the two camps that fell the next day. Therefore, Campanians, you must not just assist us in the war but nearly take it on yourselves. Remember how at Saticula we took your ancestors under our protection and defended them when they were frightened and confined to their walls, terrified not just by their Samnite enemies but their Sidicinian ones too; and how we engaged in a war against the Samnites for almost a century, initiated on your behalf. Furthermore, when you surrendered to us, we offered you an equal alliance, allowing you your own laws. What would have been a valuable privilege before the disaster at Cannae, we granted to many of you: the freedom of our city shared with you. Thus, it is your responsibility, Campanians, to regard this disaster as if it were yours and to ensure our shared country is protected. We aren't facing a Samnite or Tuscan foe, with the possibility of continuing our empire in Italy. A Carthaginian enemy brings troops from the farthest corners of the world, from the straits of the ocean and the pillars of Hercules, consisting of soldiers who aren't even from Africa, entirely lacking in laws, civilization, and almost even language. Naturally cruel and savage, their general has made them even worse by using heaps of corpses to build bridges and fortifications; and, unspeakably, by teaching them to survive on human flesh. What man born anywhere in Italy would not find it horrifying to see and be ruled by these people, raised on such ghastly food, whom even touching would be a sacrilege; to take laws from Africa and Carthage; and to let Italy become a province of the Moors and Numidians? It would be a great honor, Campanians, if the Roman empire, sinking under this disastrous defeat, were upheld and restored by your loyalty and strength. I believe that thirty thousand infantry and four thousand cavalry can be raised in Campania. You already have plenty of money and grain. If your enthusiasm matches your resources, neither will Hannibal feel victorious, nor will the Romans consider themselves defeated."

6

After the consul had thus spoken, the ambassadors were dismissed; and as they were returning home, one of them, named Vibius Virius, observed, "that the time had arrived at which the Campanians might not only recover the territory once injuriously taken away by the Romans, but also possess themselves of the sovereignty of Italy. For they might form a treaty with Hannibal on whatever terms they pleased; and there could be no question but that after Hannibal, having put an end to the war, had himself retired victorious into Africa, and had withdrawn his troops, the sovereignty of Italy would be left to the Campanians." All assenting to Vibius, as he said this, they framed their report of the embassy so that all might conclude that the Roman power was annihilated. Immediately the commons and the major part of the senate turned their attention to revolt. The measure, however, was postponed for a few days at the instigation of the elder citizens. At last, the opinion of the majority prevailed, that the same ambassadors who had gone to the Roman consul should be sent to Hannibal. I find in certain annals, that before this embassy proceeded, and before they had determined on the measure of revolting, ambassadors were sent by the Campanians to Rome, requiring that one of the consuls should be elected from Campania if they wished assistance to the Roman cause. That from the indignation which arose, they were ordered to be removed from the senate-house, and a lictor despatched to conduct them out of the city and command them to lodge that day without the Roman frontier. But as this request is too much like that which the Latins formerly made, and as Coelius and other writers had, not without reason, made no mention of it, I have not ventured to vouch for its truth.

After the consul finished speaking, the ambassadors were sent away; and on their way home, one of them, named Vibius Virius, pointed out that the time had come when the Campanians could not only reclaim the land that the Romans had wrongfully taken but also gain control over all of Italy. They could negotiate a treaty with Hannibal on any terms they wanted, and it was clear that once Hannibal ended the war and returned to Africa with his troops, the control of Italy would fall to the Campanians. Everyone agreed with Vibius as he spoke, and they crafted their report from the embassy to make it seem like the Roman power was destroyed. Immediately, the common people and most of the senate began to consider rebellion. However, the plan was delayed for a few days at the urging of the older citizens. Eventually, the majority opinion was that the same ambassadors who had gone to the Roman consul should also be sent to Hannibal. I found in some records that before this embassy set off and before they finalized their decision to revolt, ambassadors were sent by the Campanians to Rome, demanding that one of the consuls be elected from Campania if they wanted support for the Roman cause. Due to the outrage that followed, they were ordered to leave the senate house, and a lictor was sent to escort them out of the city and instruct them to stay outside Roman territory for the day. However, since this request is very similar to one previously made by the Latins, and because Coelius and other writers justifiably did not mention it, I have not felt confident enough to confirm its accuracy.

7

The ambassadors came to Hannibal and concluded a treaty of peace with him on the terms, "That no Carthaginian commander should have any authority over a Campanian citizen, nor any Campanian serve in war or perform any office against his will: that Capua should have her own laws and her own magistrates: that the Carthaginian should give to the Campanians three hundred captives selected by themselves, who might be exchanged for the Campanian horse who were serving in Sicily." Such were the stipulations: but in addition to them, the Campanians perpetrated the following atrocities; for the commons ordered that the prefects of the allies and other citizens of Rome should be suddenly seized, while some of them were occupied with military duties, others engaged in private business, and be shut up in the baths, as if for the purpose of keeping them in custody, where, suffocated with heat and vapour, they might expire in a horrid manner. Decius Magius, a man who wanted nothing to complete his influence except a sound mind on the part of his countrymen, had resisted to the uttermost the execution of these measures, and the sending of the embassy to Hannibal, and when he heard that a body of troops was sent by Hannibal, bringing back to their recollection, as examples, the haughty tyranny of Pyrrhus and the miserable slavery of the Tarentines, he at first openly and loudly protested that the troops should not be admitted, then he urged either that they should expel them when received, or, if they had a mind to expiate, by a bold and memorable act, the foul crime they had committed in revolting from their most ancient and intimate allies, that leaving slain the Carthaginian troops they should give themselves back to the Romans. These proceedings, having been reported to Hannibal, for they were not carried on in secret, he at first sent persons to summon Magius into his presence at his camp, then, on his vehemently refusing to come, on the ground that Hannibal had no authority over a Campanian, the Carthaginian, excited with rage, ordered that the man should be seized and dragged to him in chains, but afterwards, fearing lest while force was employed some disturbance might take place, or lest, from excitement of feeling, some undesigned collision might occur, he set out himself from the camp with a small body of troops, having sent a message before him to Marius Blosius, the praetor of Campania, to the effect, that he would be at Capua the next day. Marius calling an assembly, issued an order that they should go out and meet Hannibal in a body, accompanied by their wives and children. This was done by all, not only with obedience, but with zeal, with the full agreement of the common people, and with eagerness to see a general rendered illustrious by so many victories. Decius Magius neither went out to meet him, nor kept himself in private, by which course he might seem to indicate fear from a consciousness of demerit, he promenaded in the forum with perfect composure, attended by his son and a few dependants, while all the citizens were in a bustle to go to see and receive the Carthaginian. Hannibal, on entering the city, immediately demanded an audience of the senate; when the chief men of the Campanians, beseeching him not to transact any serious business on that day, but that he would cheerfully and willingly celebrate a day devoted to festivity in consequence of his own arrival, though naturally extremely prone to anger, yet, that he might not deny them any thing at first, he spent a great part of the day in inspecting the city.

The ambassadors came to Hannibal and made a peace treaty with him on the terms that "no Carthaginian commander should have authority over a Campanian citizen, nor should any Campanian be forced to serve in battle or hold any office against his will; that Capua should have its own laws and magistrates; and that the Carthaginians would give the Campanians three hundred captives chosen by them, who could be exchanged for the Campanian horses serving in Sicily." Those were the terms, but in addition, the Campanians committed the following atrocities: the common people ordered that the prefects of the allies and other Roman citizens should be suddenly seized while some were handling military duties and others were engaged in private business, and they were locked up in the baths, supposedly for their own safety, where they could suffocate from the heat and steam in a horrible way. Decius Magius, a man who needed only the support of a sound mind from his fellow citizens to wield influence, fought hard against these actions and the sending of the embassy to Hannibal. When he heard that Hannibal had sent troops to remind them of the arrogant tyranny of Pyrrhus and the miserable slavery of the Tarentines, he initially protested loudly that the troops should not be allowed in. He then urged that they should either expel them after they arrived, or if they wanted to atone for the terrible crime of betraying their ancient allies, they should slay the Carthaginian troops and return to the Romans. These actions were reported to Hannibal, as they were not done secretly. He first sent messengers to summon Magius to his camp, but when Magius vehemently refused to come, claiming Hannibal had no authority over a Campanian, the furious Carthaginian ordered that Magius be seized and brought to him in chains. However, later, fearing that using force might cause some disturbance or unintended confrontation due to heightened emotions, Hannibal decided to leave the camp with a small group of troops, sending a message ahead to Marius Blosius, the praetor of Campania, that he would arrive in Capua the next day. Marius called an assembly and ordered everyone to go out and meet Hannibal as a group, along with their wives and children. They did so not only obediently but also enthusiastically, all eager to see the general who had achieved so many victories. Decius Magius neither went out to meet him nor secluded himself in a way that might suggest he was afraid due to his guilt; instead, he walked in the forum with complete calm, accompanied by his son and a few followers, while the rest of the citizens hurried to welcome the Carthaginian. Upon entering the city, Hannibal immediately requested a meeting with the senate. The prominent Campanian leaders begged him not to conduct any serious business that day, asking instead that he celebrate his arrival with a festive day. Even though he was naturally prone to anger, he didn’t want to deny them anything at first, so he spent a significant part of the day inspecting the city.

8

He lodged at the house of the Ninii Celeres, Stenius and Pacuvius, men distinguished by their noble descent and their wealth. Thither Pacuvius Calavius, of whom mention has already been made, who was the head of the party which had drawn over the state to the Carthaginian cause, brought his son, a young man, whom he had forced from the side of Decius Magius, in conjunction with whom he had made a most determined stand for the Roman alliance in opposition to the league with the Carthaginians; nor had the leaning of the state to the other side, or his father's authority, altered his sentiments. For this youth his father procured pardon from Hannibal, more by prayers than by clearing him. Hannibal, overcome by the entreaties and tears of his father, even gave orders that he should be invited with his father to the banquet; to which entertainment he intended to admit no Campanian besides his hosts, and Jubellius Taurea, a man distinguished in war. They began to feast early in the day, and the entertainment was not conformable to the Carthaginian custom, or to military discipline, but as might be expected in a city and in a house both remarkable for luxury, was furnished with all the allurements of voluptuousness. Perolla, the son of Calavius, was the only person who could not be won either by the solicitations of the masters of the house, or those which Hannibal sometimes employed. The youth himself pleaded ill health as an apology, while his father urged as an excuse the disturbed state of his mind, which was not surprising. About sunset, Calavius, who had gone out from the banquet, was followed by his son; and when they had arrived at a retired place, (it was a garden at the back part of the house,) he said, "I have a plan to propose to you, my father, by which we shall not only obtain pardon from the Romans for our crime, in that we revolted from them to the Carthaginian, but shall be held in much higher esteem, than we Campanians ever have been." When the father inquired with surprise what that plan could be, he threw back his gown off his shoulder and exposed to view his side, which was girt with a sword. "Forthwith will I ratify the alliance with Rome with the blood of Hannibal. I was desirous that you should be informed of it first, in case you might prefer to be absent while the deed is performing."

He was staying at the home of the Ninii Celeres, Stenius, and Pacuvius, men known for their noble lineage and wealth. There, Pacuvius Calavius, who had already been mentioned and was the leader of the faction that had aligned the state with the Carthaginian cause, brought his son, a young man he had pulled away from Decius Magius, with whom he had firmly stood for the Roman alliance against the league with the Carthaginians. Neither the state's shift in support nor his father's authority changed the young man's views. For this youth, his father sought forgiveness from Hannibal, more through pleading than by proving his son's innocence. Hannibal, moved by his father's pleas and tears, even ordered that they both be invited to the banquet; this event was only open to the hosts and Jubellius Taurea, a notable warrior. They began to feast early in the day, and the gathering was unlike typical Carthaginian customs or military discipline; true to a city and home known for luxury, it was filled with all the temptations of indulgence. Perolla, Calavius's son, was the only one who couldn't be persuaded by the requests of the hosts or even by Hannibal's occasional attempts. The young man himself claimed he was unwell as an excuse, while his father cited his troubled state of mind, which was understandable. Around sunset, Calavius, having left the banquet, was followed by his son, and when they reached a private area (a garden at the back of the house), he said, "I have a plan to share with you, my father, that will not only win us pardon from the Romans for switching sides to the Carthaginians but will also elevate our standing as Campanians more than ever." When the father, surprised, asked what that plan was, the son shrugged off his robe to reveal a sword at his side. "I will seal the alliance with Rome using Hannibal's blood. I wanted you to know first in case you'd rather not be present when it happens."

9

On hearing and seeing which the old man, as though he were actually present at the transactions which were being named to him, wild with fear, exclaimed, "I implore, I beseech you, my son, by all the ties which unite children to parents, that you will not resolve to commit and to suffer every thing that is horrible before the eyes of a father. Did we but a few hours ago, swearing by every deity, and joining right hands, pledge our fidelity to Hannibal, that immediately on separating from the conference we should arm against him the hands which were employed as the sacred pledges of our faith? Do you rise from the hospitable board to which as one of three of the Campanians you have been admitted by Hannibal, that you may ensanguine that very board with the blood of your host. Could I conciliate Hannibal to my son, and not my son to Hannibal? But let nothing be held sacred by you, neither our pledges, nor the sense of religion, nor filial duty; let the most horrid deeds be dared, if with guilt they bring not ruin upon us. Will you singly attack Hannibal? What will that numerous throng of freemen and slaves be doing? What the eyes of all intent on him alone? What those so many right hands? Will they be torpid amidst your madness? Will you be able to bear the look of Hannibal himself, which armed hosts cannot sustain, from which the Roman people shrink with horror? And though other assistance be wanting, will you have the hardihood to strike me when I oppose my body in defence of Hannibal's? But know that through my breast you must strike and transfix him. Suffer yourself to be deterred from your attempt here, rather than to be defeated there. May my entreaties prevail with you, as they did for you this day." Upon this, perceiving the youth in tears, he threw his arms around him, and kissing him affectionately, ceased not his entreaties until he prevailed upon him to lay aside his sword and give his promise that he would do no such thing. The young man then observed, "I will indeed pay to my father the debt of duty which I owe to my country, but I am grieved for you on whom the guilt of having thrice betrayed your country rests; once when you sanctioned the revolt from the Romans; next when you advised the alliance with Hannibal; and thirdly, this day, when you are the delay and impediment of the restoration of Capua to the Romans. Do thou, my country, receive this weapon, armed with which in thy behalf I would fain have defended this citadel, since a father wrests it from me." Having thus said, he threw the sword into the highway over the garden wall, and that the affair might not be suspected, himself returned to the banquet.

Upon hearing and seeing this, the old man, as if he were actually there for the events being described, filled with fear, exclaimed, "I beg you, my son, by all the bonds that connect children to their parents, please don’t decide to commit or endure anything horrific in front of your father. Just a few hours ago, swearing by every god and shaking hands, we pledged our loyalty to Hannibal, and now you plan to arm yourselves against him, with the very hands that sealed our promise? Are you getting up from the hospitable table, at which you were welcomed as one of the Campanians by Hannibal, only to stain that very table with the blood of your host? How can I win over Hannibal for my son, and not my son for Hannibal? But let nothing be sacred to you—neither our pledges, nor our sense of religion, nor your duty as a son; let the most terrible deeds be attempted, as long as they don’t end in our destruction. Are you planning to confront Hannibal alone? What will the crowd of freemen and slaves do? What will all those eyes focused solely on him do? What will those many right hands be doing? Will they remain inactive in your madness? Will you be able to face Hannibal himself, a sight that causes armed men to tremble, which terrifies the Roman people? And even if you lack other support, do you have the nerve to strike me when I stand in defense of Hannibal? But know that to reach him, you would have to go through me. It’s better to be dissuaded from your plan here than to be defeated there. May my pleas succeed with you, as they did for you today." Upon seeing the young man in tears, he embraced him and kissed him lovingly, continuing to plead until he convinced him to lay down his sword and promise not to do anything like that. The young man then said, "I will certainly owe my father the duty I have to my country, but I am saddened for you, bearing the guilt of betraying your country three times: once when you supported the revolt against the Romans; again when you advised the alliance with Hannibal; and a third time today, as you are now delaying the restoration of Capua to the Romans. Take this weapon, which I would have gladly used to defend this stronghold on your behalf, since a father takes it from me." With that, he threw the sword into the road over the garden wall, and to keep the matter from being suspected, he returned to the banquet.

10

The next day an audience of a full senate was given to Hannibal, when the first part of his address was full of graciousness and benignity, in which he thanked the Campanians for having preferred his friendship to an alliance with the Romans, and held out among his other magnificent promises "that Capua should soon become the capital of all Italy, and that the Romans as well as the other states should receive laws from it. That there was, however, one person who had no share in the Carthaginian friendship and the alliance formed with him, Decius Magius, who neither was nor ought to be called a Campanian. Him he requested to be surrendered to him, and that the sense of the senate should be taken respecting his conduct, and a decree passed in his presence." All concurred in this proposition, though a great many considered him as a man undeserving such severe treatment; and that this proceeding was no small infringement of their liberty to begin with. Leaving the senate-house, the magistrate took his seat on the consecrated bench, ordered Decius Magius to be apprehended, and to be placed by himself before his feet to plead his cause. But he, his proud spirit being unsubdued, denied that such a measure could be enforced agreeably to the conditions of the treaty; upon which he was ironed, and ordered to be brought into the camp before a lictor. As long as he was conducted with his head uncovered, he moved along earnestly haranguing and vociferating to the multitude which poured around him on all sides. "You have gotten that liberty, Campanians, which you seek; in the middle of the forum, in the light of day, before your eyes, I, a man second to none of the Campanians, am dragged in chains to suffer death. What greater outrage could have been committed had Capua been captured? Go out to meet Hannibal, decorate your city to the utmost, consecrate the day of his arrival, that you may behold this triumph over a fellow-citizen." As the populace seemed to be excited by him, vociferating these things, his head was covered, and he was ordered to be dragged away more speedily without the gate. Having been thus brought to the camp, he was immediately put on board a ship and sent to Carthage, lest if any commotion should arise at Capua on account of the injustice of the proceeding, the senate also should repent of having given up a leading citizen; and lest if an embassy were sent to request his restoration, he must either offend his new allies by refusing their first petition, or, by granting it, be compelled to retain at Capua a promoter of sedition and disturbance. A tempest drove the vessel to Cyrenae, which was at that time under the dominion of kings. Here flying for refuge to the statue of king Ptolemy, he was conveyed thence in custody to Alexandria to Ptolemy; and having instructed him that he had been thrown into chains by Hannibal, contrary to the law of treaties, he was liberated and allowed to return to whichever place he pleased, Rome or Capua. But Magius said, that Capua would not be a safe place for him, and that Rome, at a time when there was war between the Romans and Capuans, would be rather the residence of a deserter than a guest. That there was no place that he should rather dwell in, than in the dominions of him whom he esteemed an avenger and the protector of his liberty.

The next day, Hannibal addressed a full senate, where his initial comments were filled with kindness and goodwill. He thanked the Campanians for choosing his friendship over an alliance with the Romans and promised that "Capua would soon become the capital of all Italy, and that both Romans and other states would receive laws from it." However, he pointed out one individual who was not a part of the Carthaginian friendship or the alliance made with him, Decius Magius, who neither was nor should be considered a Campanian. Hannibal requested that he be handed over and that the senate should discuss his actions and pass a decree in his presence. All agreed with this suggestion, even though many felt he did not deserve such harsh treatment and saw this as a significant violation of their freedom. After leaving the senate chamber, the magistrate took his position on the sacred bench, ordered Decius Magius to be arrested, and brought him forward to plead his case. But Magius, maintaining his pride, argued that his arrest went against the terms of the treaty. As a result, he was shackled and taken to the camp under the watch of a lictor. As long as he walked with his head uncovered, he fervently spoke out to the crowd that gathered around him, saying, "You have gained the freedom you seek, Campanians; here in the forum, in broad daylight, I, a man equal to any Campanian, am dragged in chains to face execution. What greater injustice could occur if Capua had fallen? Go out to welcome Hannibal, decorate your city to the fullest, and celebrate his arrival so you can witness this triumph over a fellow citizen." As the crowd became more stirred by his words, his head was covered, and he was quickly ordered out through the gate. Once he arrived at the camp, he was immediately placed on a ship and sent to Carthage. This was done to prevent any potential unrest in Capua due to the perceived unfairness of the situation, as the senate might regret surrendering a prominent citizen. Additionally, if an embassy was sent to request his return, Hannibal would either upset his new allies by denying their first request or feel pressured to hold onto a potential troublemaker in Capua. A storm forced the ship to land in Cyrenae, which was then under the rule of kings. There, he sought refuge by the statue of King Ptolemy and was subsequently taken into custody to Alexandria. After explaining to Ptolemy how he had been unjustly imprisoned by Hannibal, he was freed and allowed to return to whichever place he chose, whether Rome or Capua. However, Magius felt that Capua wouldn’t be safe for him and believed that Rome, amid the ongoing conflict between Romans and Capuans, would feel more like a place for a deserter than a guest. He decided there was no better place for him to stay than in the land of the one he regarded as his avenger and protector of his freedom.

11

While these things were carrying on, Quintus Fabius Pictor, the ambassador, returned from Delphi to Rome, and read the response of the oracle from a written copy. In it both the gods were mentioned, and in what manner supplication should be made. It then stated, "If you do thus, Romans, your affairs will be more prosperous and less perplexed; your state will proceed more agreeably to your wishes; and the victory in the war will be on the side of the Roman people. After that your state shall have been restored to prosperity and safety, send a present to the Pythian Apollo out of the gains you have earned, and pay honours to him out of the plunder, the booty, and the spoils. Banish licentiousness from among you." Having read aloud these words, translated from the Greek verse, he added, that immediately on his departure from the oracle, he had paid divine honours to all these deities with wine and frankincense; and that he was ordered by the chief priest of the temple, that, as he had approached the oracle and performed the sacred ceremonies decorated with a laurel crown, so he should embark wearing the crown, and not put it off till he had arrived at Rome. That he had executed all these injunctions with the most scrupulous exactness and diligence, and had deposited the garland on the altar of Apollo at Rome. The senate decreed that the sacred ceremonies and supplications enjoined should be carefully performed with all possible expedition. During these events at Rome and in Italy, Mago, the son of Hamilcar, had arrived at Carthage with the intelligence of the victory at Cannae. He was not sent direct from the field of battle by his brother, but was detained some days in receiving the submission of such states of the Bruttii as were in revolt. Having obtained an audience of the senate he gave a full statement of his brother's exploits in Italy: "That he had fought pitched battles with six generals, four of whom were consuls, two a dictator and master of the horse, with six consular armies; that he had slain above two hundred thousand of the enemy, and captured above fifty thousand. That out of the four consuls he had slain two; of the two remaining, one was wounded, the other, having lost his whole army, had fled from the field with scarcely fifty men; that the master of the horse, an authority equal to that of consul, had been routed and put to flight; that the dictator, because he had never engaged in a pitched battle, was esteemed a matchless general; that the Bruttii, the Apulians, part of the Samnites and of the Lucanians had revolted to the Carthaginians. That Capua, which was the capital not only of Campania, but after the ruin of the Roman power by the battle of Cannae, of Italy also, had delivered itself over to Hannibal. That in return for these so many and so great victories, gratitude ought assuredly to be felt and thanks returned to the immortal gods."

While all this was happening, Quintus Fabius Pictor, the ambassador, returned from Delphi to Rome and read the oracle's response from a written copy. The response mentioned both gods and the way to offer supplication. It stated, "If you do this, Romans, your situation will improve and become less complicated; your state will progress more in line with your desires, and the victory in the war will favor the Roman people. Once your state has been restored to prosperity and safety, send a gift to Pythian Apollo from the profits you’ve gained, and honor him from the loot and spoils. Eliminate licentiousness from among you." After reading these words, translated from Greek verse, he added that right after leaving the oracle, he had honored all these deities with wine and frankincense. He was instructed by the chief priest of the temple that, since he had approached the oracle and performed the sacred ceremonies wearing a laurel crown, he should leave wearing the crown and not take it off until he arrived in Rome. He had followed all these instructions with utmost care and diligence and deposited the garland on Apollo's altar in Rome. The senate decreed that the sacred ceremonies and supplications should be performed as quickly as possible. During these developments in Rome and Italy, Mago, the son of Hamilcar, arrived in Carthage with news of the victory at Cannae. He was not sent directly from the battlefield by his brother but was delayed for several days receiving the submission of states in the Bruttii that had revolted. After speaking to the senate, he gave a comprehensive account of his brother's accomplishments in Italy: "He fought major battles against six generals, four of whom were consuls, and two were a dictator and master of the horse, with six consular armies; he killed over two hundred thousand enemies and captured more than fifty thousand. Of the four consuls, he killed two; of the remaining two, one was wounded and the other, having lost his entire army, fled the battlefield with barely fifty men; the master of the horse, an authority equal to that of a consul, was defeated and routed; the dictator, who never engaged in a major battle, was regarded as an exceptional general; the Bruttii, the Apulians, part of the Samnites, and part of the Lucanians had defected to the Carthaginians. Capua, which was not only the capital of Campania but also the center of Italy after the Roman defeat at Cannae, had surrendered to Hannibal. For all these significant victories, it’s only right to express gratitude and give thanks to the immortal gods."

12

Then, in proof of this such joyful news, he ordered the golden rings to be poured out in the vestibule of the senate-house, of which there was such a heap that some have taken upon themselves to say that on being measured they filled three pecks and a half. The statement has obtained and is more like the truth, that there were not more than a peck. He then added, by way of explanation, to prove the greater extent of the slaughter, that none but knights, and of these the principal only, wore that ornament. The main drift of his speech was, "that the nearer the prospect was of bringing the war to a conclusion, the more should Hannibal be aided by every means, for that the seat of war was at a long distance from home and in the heart of the enemy's country. That a great quantity of corn was consumed and money expended; and that so many pitched battles, as they had annihilated the armies of the enemy, had also in some degree diminished the forces of the victor. That a reinforcement therefore ought to be sent; and money for the pay, and corn for the soldiers who had deserved so well of the Carthaginian name." After this speech of Mago's, all being elated with joy, Himilco, a member of the Barcine faction, conceiving this a good opportunity for inveighing against Hanno, said to him, "What think you now, Hanno? do you now also regret that the war against the Romans was entered upon? Now urge that Hannibal should be given up; yes, forbid the rendering of thanks to the immortal gods amidst such successes; let us hear a Roman senator in the senate-house of the Carthaginians." Upon which Hanno replied, "I should have remained silent this day, conscript fathers, lest, amid the general joy, I should utter any thing which might be too gloomy for you. But now, to a senator, asking whether I still regret the undertaking of the war against the Romans, if I should forbear to speak, I should seem either arrogant or servile, the former of which is the part of a man who is forgetful of the independence of others, the latter of his own. I may answer therefore to Himilco, that I have not ceased to regret the war, nor shall I cease to censure your invincible general until I see the war concluded on some tolerable terms; nor will any thing except a new peace put a period to my regret for the loss of the old one. Accordingly those achievements, which Mago has so boastingly recounted, are a source of present joy to Himilco and the other adherents of Hannibal; to me they may become so; because successes in war, if we have a mind to make the best use of fortune, will afford us a peace on more equitable terms; for if we allow this opportunity to pass by, on which we have it in our power to appear to dictate rather than to receive terms of peace, I fear lest even this our joy should run into excess, and in the end prove groundless. However, let us see of what kind it is even now. I have slain the armies of the enemy, send me soldiers. What else would you ask if you had been conquered? I have captured two of the enemy's camps, full, of course, of booty and provisions; supply me with corn and money. What else would you ask had you been plundered and stripped of your camp? And that I may not be the only person perplexed, I could wish that either Himilco or Mago would answer me, for it is just and fair that I also should put a question, since I have answered Himilco. Since the battle at Cannae annihilated the Roman power, and it is a fact that all Italy is in a state of revolt; in the first place, has any one people of the Latin confederacy come over to us? In the next place, has any individual of the five and thirty tribes deserted to Hannibal?" When Mago had answered both these questions in the negative, he continued: "there remains then still too large a body of the enemy. But I should be glad to know what degree of spirit and hope that body possesses."

Then, to celebrate this joyful news, he ordered the golden rings to be poured out in the entrance of the senate house, creating such a pile that some claimed it measured three and a half pecks. However, it’s more likely that there were only about a peck. He then explained that the significant number of casualties showed that only knights, particularly the chief ones, wore those rings. The main point of his speech was that “the closer we get to ending the war, the more support Hannibal should receive because the war is far from home and deep in enemy territory. A lot of corn has been used and money spent; and the many battles fought that have destroyed enemy armies have also reduced our own forces to some extent. Therefore, we need to send reinforcements and provide funding for the pay, along with corn for the soldiers who have done so well for the Carthaginian cause.” After Mago’s speech, everyone was filled with joy, and Himilco, a member of the Barcine faction, saw this as a great moment to criticize Hanno. He said, “What do you think now, Hanno? Do you now regret going to war with the Romans? Now advocate for Hannibal to be handed over; let’s hear a Roman senator in the Carthaginian senate.” To this, Hanno replied, “I would have stayed silent today, fathers of the senate, so as not to ruin your happiness with any gloomy comments. But to answer a senator who asks whether I still regret going to war with the Romans, if I didn’t respond, I would seem either arrogant or subservient; the former is what someone forgetful of others' independence would do, the latter shows a lack of respect for one’s own. So I can tell Himilco that I still regret the war and will continue to criticize your unbeatable general until I see the war concluded on acceptable terms; nothing but a new peace will end my regret for the old one. Those victories Mago boasts about may bring Himilco and the others joy, but they might also bring me joy because successful warfare can lead us to a more fair peace; if we miss this chance to dictate rather than just accept terms of peace, I fear our joy could end up being misplaced in the end. Let’s see what the situation is now. I have defeated the enemy’s armies; send me soldiers. What more would you want if you had been defeated? I’ve taken two of the enemy’s camps, filled with loot and provisions; supply me with corn and money. What more would you want if you had been robbed and stripped of your camp? And since I shouldn’t be the only one confused, I would like either Himilco or Mago to respond, as it’s fair that I also ask a question since I’ve answered Himilco. Given that the battle at Cannae wiped out Roman power and Italy is in a state of rebellion, first, has any one of our Latin allies joined us? Secondly, has anyone from the thirty-five tribes deserted to Hannibal?” When Mago answered both questions negatively, he continued: “there is still a significant enemy force remaining. But I’d like to know what kind of spirit and hope that force possesses.”

13

Mago declaring that he did not know; "Nothing," said he, "is easier to be known. Have the Romans sent any ambassadors to Hannibal to treat of peace? Have you, in short, ever heard that any mention has been made of peace at Rome?" On his answering these questions also in the negative: "We have upon our hands then, said he, a war as entire as we had on the day on which Hannibal crossed over into Italy. There are a great many of us alive now who remember how fluctuating the success was in the former Punic war. At no time did our affairs appear in so prosperous a condition as they did before the consulship of Caius Lutatius and Aulus Posthumius. In the consulship of Caius Lutatius and Aulus Posthumius we were completely conquered at the islands Aegates. But if now, as well as then, (oh! may the gods avert the omen!) fortune should take any turn, do you hope to obtain that peace when we shall be vanquished which no one is willing to grant now we are victorious. I have an opinion which I should express if any one should advise with me on the subject of proffering or accepting terms of peace with the enemy; but with respect to the supplies requested by Mago, I do not think there is any necessity to send them to a victorious army; and I give it as my opinion that they should far less be sent to them, if they are deluding us by groundless and empty hopes." But few were influenced by the harangue of Hanno, for both the jealousy which he entertained towards the Barcine family, made him a less weighty authority; and men's minds being taken up with the present exultation, would listen to nothing by which their joy could be made more groundless, but felt convinced, that if they should make a little additional exertion the war might be speedily terminated. Accordingly a decree of the senate was made with very general approbation, that four thousand Numidians should be sent as a reinforcement to Hannibal, with four hundred elephants and many talents of silver. Moreover, the dictator was sent forward into Spain with Mago to hire twenty thousand foot and four thousand horse, to recruit the armies in Italy and Spain.

Mago said that he didn’t know; “Nothing,” he said, “is easier to know. Have the Romans sent any ambassadors to Hannibal to discuss peace? Have you, in short, ever heard any mention of peace in Rome?” When he answered these questions with a no: “We still have a war on our hands just like we did the day Hannibal crossed into Italy. Many of us alive now remember how unpredictable the outcome was during the previous Punic War. Our situation never seemed better than it did before the consulship of Caius Lutatius and Aulus Posthumius. During the consulship of Caius Lutatius and Aulus Posthumius, we were completely defeated at the Aegates Islands. But if now, just as then, (oh! may the gods prevent this omen!) fortune were to change, do you think you could get that peace after we are beaten that no one is willing to offer now that we are winning? I have an opinion that I would share if anyone consulted me about offering or accepting peace terms with the enemy; but concerning the supplies requested by Mago, I don’t think there’s any need to send them to a victorious army; and I think even less should be sent if they are misleading us with baseless and empty hopes.” However, few were swayed by Hanno's speech, as his jealousy towards the Barcine family made him a less influential authority; and people's minds, caught up in their current excitement, wouldn't listen to anything that could make their joy seem unfounded, believing instead that a bit more effort could quickly end the war. So, a decree from the senate was passed with wide approval to send four thousand Numidians as reinforcements to Hannibal, along with four hundred elephants and many talents of silver. Additionally, the dictator was sent ahead into Spain with Mago to recruit twenty thousand infantry and four thousand cavalry to strengthen the armies in Italy and Spain.

14

But these resolutions, as generally happens in the season of prosperity, were executed in a leisurely and slothful manner. The Romans, in addition to their inborn activity of mind, were prevented from delaying by the posture of their affairs. For the consul was not wanting in any business which was to be done by him; and the dictator, Marcus Junius Pera, after the sacred ceremonies were concluded, and after having, as is usual, proposed to the people that he might be allowed to mount his horse; besides the two legions which had been enlisted by the consuls in the beginning of the year, and besides the cohorts collected out of the Picenian and Gallic territories, descended to that last resort of the state when almost despaired of, and when propriety gives place to utility, and made proclamation, that of such persons as had been guilty of capital crimes or were in prison on judgment for debt, those who would serve as soldiers with him, he would order to be released from their liability to punishment and their debts. These six thousand he armed with the Gallic spoils which were carried in the procession at the triumph of Caius Flaminius. Thus he marched from the city at the head of twenty-five thousand men. Hannibal, after gaining Capua, made a second fruitless attempt upon the minds of the Neapolitans, partly by fear and partly by hope: and then marched his troops across into the territory of Nola: not immediately in a hostile attitude, for he did not despair of a voluntary surrender, yet intending to omit nothing which they could suffer or fear, if they delayed the completion of his hopes. The senate, and especially the principal members of it, persevered faithfully in keeping up the alliance with the Romans; the commons, as usual, were all inclined to a change in the government and to espouse the cause of Hannibal, placing before their minds the fear lest their fields should be devastated, and the many hardships and indignities which must be endured in a siege; nor were there wanting persons who advised a revolt. In this state of things, when a fear took possession of the senate, that it would be impossible to resist the excited multitude if they went openly to work, devised a delay of the evil by secret simulation. They pretended that they were agreeable to the revolt to Hannibal; but that it was not settled on what terms they should enter into the new alliance and friendship. Thus having gained time, they promptly sent ambassadors to the Roman praetor, Marcellus Claudius, who was at Casilinum with his army, and informed him what a critical situation Nola was in; that the fields were already in the possession of Hannibal and the Carthaginians, and that the city soon would be, unless succour were sent; that the senate, by conceding to the commons that they would revolt when they pleased, had caused them not to hasten too much to revolt. Marcellus, after bestowing high commendations on the Nolans, urged them to protract the business till his arrival by means of the same pretences; in the mean time, to conceal what had passed between them, as well as all hope of succour from the Romans. He himself marched from Casilinum to Calatia, and thence crossing the Vulturnus, and passing through the territories of Saticula and Trebula, pursuing his course along the mountains above Suessula, he arrived at Nola.

But these resolutions, as often happens in prosperous times, were carried out in a slow and lazy way. The Romans, in addition to their natural drive, were prevented from procrastinating by how things were going. The consul was fully engaged in his responsibilities, and the dictator, Marcus Junius Pera, after the sacred ceremonies were completed, and after asking the people, as is customary, for permission to mount his horse, along with the two legions raised by the consuls at the start of the year and the troops collected from the Picenian and Gallic territories, resorted to the last hope of the state when things seemed almost hopeless, where practicality takes precedence over propriety. He announced that those guilty of serious crimes or imprisoned for debt who were willing to fight as soldiers with him would be released from punishment and their debts. He armed these six thousand men with the Gallic spoils displayed during the triumph of Caius Flaminius. So, he marched out of the city at the head of twenty-five thousand men. Hannibal, after capturing Capua, made a second unsuccessful attempt to win over the Neapolitans, using both fear and hope: he then moved his troops into the territory of Nola, not immediately in a hostile manner, as he still hoped for a voluntary surrender, but he planned to exploit any suffering or fear they might experience if they delayed meeting his expectations. The senate, especially its leading members, remained committed to maintaining their alliance with the Romans, while the common people, as usual, were eager for a change in government and leaned towards Hannibal's cause, driven by the fear of their fields being destroyed and the many hardships and indignities that would come with a siege; there were also those who encouraged rebellion. In this situation, when the senate feared they would be unable to resist the agitated masses if they acted openly, they decided to buy time through secret deception. They pretended to agree with Hannibal's revolt but claimed they had not yet settled the terms of a new alliance and friendship. Thus, buying some time, they quickly sent ambassadors to the Roman commander, Marcellus Claudius, who was at Casilinum with his army, informing him of how dire the situation in Nola had become; that Hannibal and the Carthaginians had already taken control of the fields and that the city would soon follow unless help was sent; and that the senate, by allowing the common people to revolt whenever they wished, had caused them not to rush into rebellion. Marcellus, praising the Nolans highly, urged them to delay the matter until he arrived using the same cover, while also keeping their conversations and any hope of Roman assistance under wraps. He then marched from Casilinum to Calatia, crossed the Vulturnus, and passed through the territories of Saticula and Trebula, moving along the mountains above Suessula until he reached Nola.

15

On the approach of the Roman praetor, the Carthaginians retired from the territory of Nola and marched down to the sea close upon Naples, eager to get possession of a maritime town to which there would be a safe course for ships from Africa. But hearing that Naples was held by a Roman prefect, Marcus Junius Silanus, who had been invited thither by the Neapolitans themselves, he left Naples as he had left Nola, and directed his course to Nuceria, which he at length starved into capitulation, after having besieged it for a considerable time, often by open force, and often by soliciting to no purpose sometimes the commons, at other times the nobles; agreeing that they should depart with single garments and without arms. Then, as wishing to appear from the beginning to show lenity to all the inhabitants of Italy except the Romans, he proposed rewards and honours to those who might remain with him, and would be willing to serve with him. He retained none, however, by the hopes he held out; they all dispersed in different directions throughout the cities of Campania, wherever either hospitable connexions or the casual impulse of the mind directed them, but principally to Nola and Naples. About thirty senators, including as it happened all of the first rank, made for Capua; but being shut out thence, because they had closed their gates on Hannibal, they betook themselves to Cumae. The plunder of Nuceria was, given to the soldiery, the city sacked and burned. Marcellus continued to hold possession of Nola, relying not more from confidence in his own troops than from the favourable disposition of the leading inhabitants. Apprehensions were entertained of the commons, particularly Lucius Bantius, whose having been privy to an attempt at defection, and dread of the Roman praetor, stimulated sometimes to the betrayal of his country, at others, should fortune fail him in that undertaking, to desertion. He was a young man of vigorous mind, and at that time enjoying the greatest renown of almost any of the allied cavalry. Found at Cannae half dead amid a heap of slain, Hannibal had sent him home, after having had him cured, with the kindest attention, and even with presents. In gratitude for this favour, he had conceived a wish to put Nola under the power and dominion of the Carthaginian; but his anxiety and solicitude for effecting a change did not escape the notice of the praetor. However, as it was necessary that he should be either restrained by penal inflictions or conciliated by favours, he preferred attaching to himself a brave and strenuous ally, to depriving the enemy of him; and summoning him into his presence, in the kindest manner said, "that the fact that he had many among his countrymen who were jealous of him, might be easily collected from the circumstance that not one citizen of Nola had informed him how many were his splendid military exploits. But that it was impossible for the valour of one who served in the Roman camp to remain in obscurity; that many who had served with him had reported to him how brave a man he was, how often and what dangers he had encountered for the safety and honour of the Roman people; and how in the battle of Cannae he had not given over fighting till, almost bloodless, he was buried under a heap of men, horses, and arms which fell upon him. Go on then," says he, "and prosper in your career of valour, with me you shall receive every honour and every reward, and the oftener you be with me, the more you shall find it will be to your honour and emolument." He presented the young man, delighted with these promises, with a horse of distinguished beauty, ordered the quaestor to give him five hundred denarii, and commanded the lictors to allow him to approach him whenever he might please.

As the Roman praetor approached, the Carthaginians pulled back from the territory of Nola and headed towards the sea near Naples, eager to take control of a coastal town that would provide a reliable route for ships from Africa. However, upon learning that Naples was held by the Roman prefect Marcus Junius Silanus, who had been invited there by the Neapolitans themselves, he left Naples just as he had left Nola and set his sights on Nuceria. He eventually forced it to surrender after a lengthy siege, during which he often used open force and at other times attempted to persuade both the common people and the nobles, though to no avail. He offered them terms that included leaving with only the clothes on their backs and no weapons. Wishing to appear lenient towards all the inhabitants of Italy except the Romans, he promised rewards and honors to those who would stay and serve him. However, no one was convinced by his promises; they scattered in different directions throughout the cities of Campania, driven by either friendly connections or random impulses, mainly heading to Nola and Naples. About thirty senators, including all from the top rank, made for Capua, but when they were barred from entry after Capua closed its gates on Hannibal, they went to Cumae instead. The plunder from Nuceria was given to the soldiers, and the city was sacked and burned. Marcellus kept hold of Nola, relying not only on his confidence in his own troops but also on the favorable attitude of the prominent locals. There were concerns about the common people, particularly Lucius Bantius, who had been involved in a plot to defect. His fear of the Roman praetor sometimes pushed him towards betraying his country, and at other times, if his efforts failed, towards desertion. He was a young man with a strong mind and was at that time quite well-known among the allied cavalry. Found half-dead among a pile of corpses at Cannae, Hannibal had sent him home, caring for him with great kindness and even giving him gifts. Grateful for this favor, he wanted to put Nola under Carthaginian control; however, his eagerness didn’t go unnoticed by the praetor. As it was essential to either restrain him with punishment or win him over with favors, the praetor chose to take him as a strong ally rather than letting the enemy have him. Summoning him to his presence, he said kindly, "It’s clear that you have many countrymen who are jealous of you, especially since not a single citizen of Nola has told me about your brilliant military exploits. But it's impossible for the bravery of someone serving in the Roman camp to go unnoticed; many who fought alongside you have told me how courageous you are, how often you've faced danger for the safety and honor of the Roman people, and how at the battle of Cannae, you didn’t stop fighting until you were nearly bloodless and buried under a pile of men, horses, and weapons that fell on you. So, continue on, and succeed in your path of valor. With me, you’ll receive all the honors and rewards, and the more you are with me, the more you’ll find it to your benefit." He gifted the young man, who was thrilled with these promises, a beautiful horse, instructed the quaestor to give him five hundred denarii, and ordered his lictors to allow him to approach at any time he wished.

16

The violent spirit of the youth was so much soothed by the courteous treatment of Marcellus, that thenceforward no one of the allies displayed greater courage or fidelity in aiding the Roman cause. Hannibal being now at the gates, for he had moved his camp back again from Nuceria to Nola, and the commons beginning to turn their attention to revolt afresh, Marcellus, on the approach of the enemy, retired within the walls; not from apprehension for his camp, but lest he should give an opportunity for betraying the city, which too many were anxiously watching for. The troops on both sides then began to be drawn up; the Romans before the walls of Nola, the Carthaginians before their own camp. Hence arose several battles of small account between the city and the camp, with varying success, as the generals were neither willing to check the small parties who inconsiderately challenged the enemy, nor to give the signal for a general engagement. While the two armies continued to be thus stationed day after day, the chief men of the Nolans informed Marcellus, that conferences were held by night between the commons of Nola and the Carthaginians; and that it was fixed, that, when the Roman army had gone out at the gates, they should make plunder of their baggage and packages, then close the gates and post themselves upon the walls, in order that when in possession of the government and the city, they might then receive the Carthaginian instead of the Roman. On receiving this intelligence Marcellus, having bestowed the highest commendations on the senators, resolved to hazard the issue of a battle before any commotion should arise within the city. He drew up his troops in three divisions at the three gates which faced the enemy; he gave orders that the baggage should follow close by, that the servants, suttlers' boys, and invalids should carry palisades; at the centre gate he stationed the choicest of the legionary troops and the Roman cavalry, at the two gates on either side, the recruits, the light-armed, and the allied cavalry. The Nolans were forbidden to approach the walls and gates, and the troops designed for a reserve were set over the baggage, lest while the legions were engaged in the battle an attack should be made upon it. Thus arranged they were standing within the gates. Hannibal, who had waited with his troops drawn up in battle-array, as he had done for several days, till the day was far advanced, at first was amazed that neither the Roman army marched out of the gates, nor any armed man was to be seen on the walls, but afterwards concluding that the conferences had been discovered, and that they were quiet through fear, he sent back a portion of his troops into the camp, with orders to bring into the front line, with speed, every thing requisite for assaulting the city; satisfied that if he urged them vigorously while they were indisposed to action, the populace would excite some commotion in the city. While, in the van, the troops were running up and down in a hurried manner in discharge of their several duties, and the line was advancing up to the gates, suddenly throwing open the gate, Marcellus ordered that the signal should be given, and a shout raised, and that first the infantry and after them the cavalry should burst forth upon the enemy with all possible impetuosity. They had occasioned abundant terror and confusion in the centre of the enemy's line, when, at the two side gates, the lieutenant-generals, Publius Valerius Flaccus and Caius Aurelius, sallied forth upon the wings. The servants, suttlers' boys, and the other multitude appointed to guard the baggage, joined in the shout, so that they suddenly exhibited the appearance of a vast army to the Carthaginians, who despised chiefly their paucity of numbers. For my own part I would not take upon me to assert what some authors have declared, that two thousand eight hundred of the enemy were slain, and that the Romans lost not more than five hundred. Whether the victory was so great or not; it is certain that a very important advantage, and perhaps the greatest during the war, was gained on that day: for not to be vanquished by Hannibal was then a more difficult task to the victorious troops, than to conquer him afterwards.

The aggressive nature of the youth was greatly calmed by Marcellus's courteous treatment, so from that point on, none of the allies showed more courage or loyalty in supporting the Roman cause. With Hannibal now at the gates, having moved his camp back from Nuceria to Nola, and the common people starting to think about revolting again, Marcellus retired inside the walls as the enemy approached. He did this not out of fear for his camp but to prevent any chance of betraying the city, which too many were eager to do. The troops on both sides began to line up; the Romans positioned themselves in front of the walls of Nola, while the Carthaginians set up in front of their camp. This led to several minor skirmishes between the city and the camp, with mixed results since the generals were unwilling to stop the small groups that foolishly challenged the enemy or to signal for a full battle. As both armies remained in position day after day, the leading citizens of Nola informed Marcellus that discussions were happening at night between the commoners of Nola and the Carthaginians. It was agreed that when the Roman army left the gates, they would loot their supplies, then close the gates and take up positions on the walls so that they could hand over control of the city to the Carthaginians instead of the Romans. Upon hearing this news, Marcellus praised the senators highly and decided to risk a battle before any unrest could occur within the city. He positioned his troops in three divisions at the three gates facing the enemy, ordered that the baggage follow closely, and assigned servants, suttlers' boys, and invalids to carry palisades. At the central gate, he placed the best of the legionary troops and the Roman cavalry, while at the two side gates, he stationed recruits, light infantry, and allied cavalry. The Nolans were prohibited from approaching the walls and gates, and a reserve force was placed over the baggage to protect it from attack while the legions fought. Thus arranged, they stood inside the gates. Hannibal, who had waited with his troops in battle formation as he had for several days, was initially surprised that the Roman army didn't march out and no armed men were visible on the walls. Eventually, he concluded that the conferences had been discovered and that the Romans were quiet out of fear. He sent some of his troops back to camp with orders to quickly bring everything needed for an assault on the city to the front line, believing that if he pressed them while they were unwilling to fight, the populace would stir up some trouble in the city. As his troops were hurrying to carry out their duties and the line advanced toward the gates, Marcellus suddenly ordered the gate to be opened, signaling a shout, and then commanded that first the infantry and thereafter the cavalry should charge out against the enemy with maximum force. They caused significant fear and confusion in the center of the enemy's line when the lieutenant-generals, Publius Valerius Flaccus and Caius Aurelius, surged forth from the two side gates. The servants, suttlers' boys, and the other multitude designated to guard the baggage joined in the shout, creating the illusion of a large army to the Carthaginians, who primarily underestimated them due to their smaller numbers. For my part, I wouldn’t claim what some authors have said, that two thousand eight hundred of the enemy were killed and that the Romans lost no more than five hundred. Whether the victory was that grand or not, what is certain is that a major advantage, perhaps the greatest of the war, was secured that day: for at that time, it was more difficult for the victorious troops not to be beaten by Hannibal than it would be for them to conquer him later.

17

When Hannibal, all hope of getting possession of Nola being lost, had retired to Acerrae, Marcellus, having closed the gates and posted guards in different quarters to prevent any one from going out, immediately instituted a judicial inquiry in the forum, into the conduct of those who had been secretly in communication with the enemy. He beheaded more than seventy who were convicted of treason, and ordered their foods to be confiscated to the Roman state; and then committing the government to the senate, set out with all his forces, and, pitching a camp, took up a position above Suessula. The Carthaginian, having at first endeavoured to win over the people of Acerrae to a voluntary surrender, but finding them resolved, makes preparations for a siege and assault. But the people of Acerrae had more spirit than power. Despairing therefore, of the defence of the city, when they saw their walls being circumvallated, before the lines of the enemy were completed, they stole off in the dead of night through the opening in the works, and where the watches had been neglected; and pursuing their course through roads and pathless regions, accordingly as design or mistake directed each, made their escape to those towns of Campania which they knew had not renounced their fidelity. After Acerrae was plundered and burnt, Hannibal, having received intelligence that the Roman dictator with the new-raised legions was seen at some distance from Casilinum, and fearing lest, the camp of the enemy being so near, something might occur at Capua, marched his army to Casilinum. At that time Casilinum was occupied by five hundred Praenestines, with a few Romans and Latins, whom the news of the defeat at Cannae had brought to the same place. These men setting out from home too late, in consequence of the levy at Praeneste not being completed at the appointed day, and arriving at Casilinum before the defeat was known there, where they united themselves with other troops, Romans and allies, were proceeding thence in a tolerably large body, but the news of the battle at Cannae them back to Casilinum. Having spent several days there in evading and concerting plots, in fear themselves and suspected by the Campanians, and having now received certain information that the revolt of Capua and the reception of Hannibal were in agitation, they put the townsmen to the sword by night, and seized upon the part of the town on this side the Vulturnus, for it is divided by that river. Such was the garrison the Romans had at Casilinum; to these was added a cohort of Perusians, in number four hundred and sixty, who had been driven to Casilinum by the same intelligence which had brought the Praenestines a few days before. They formed a sufficient number of armed men for the defence of walls of so limited extent, and protected on one side by the river. The scarcity of corn made them even appear too numerous.

When Hannibal, realizing he could no longer take Nola, retreated to Acerrae, Marcellus closed the gates and set up guards in various locations to prevent anyone from leaving. He quickly started a judicial inquiry in the forum to investigate those who had been secretly communicating with the enemy. He executed more than seventy people found guilty of treason and ordered their property to be confiscated for the Roman state. After handing over control to the senate, he marched out with all his troops, set up camp, and positioned himself above Suessula. At first, Hannibal tried to persuade the people of Acerrae to surrender willingly, but when he realized they were determined to resist, he began preparing for a siege and attack. However, the people of Acerrae had more spirit than strength. Desperate to defend the city, they decided to sneak away in the dead of night through a gap in the fortifications, where the guards were lax. They made their escape through various paths, as they directed themselves either by plan or by accident, fleeing to towns in Campania that they knew remained loyal. After Acerrae was looted and set ablaze, Hannibal learned that the Roman dictator with the newly raised legions was spotted some distance from Casilinum, and worried that something might happen at Capua with the enemy camp so close, he marched his army to Casilinum. At that time, Casilinum was held by five hundred Praenestines, along with a few Romans and Latins, who had all come there after hearing about the defeat at Cannae. These men set out too late from home because the recruitment at Praeneste hadn't finished on schedule and arrived at Casilinum before the news of the defeat reached them. They joined forces with other troops, both Roman and allied, and were preparing to leave, but the news of the battle at Cannae forced them back to Casilinum. They spent several days there plotting and hiding, fearing for themselves and being suspicious in the eyes of the Campanians. After getting reliable information that Capua was revolting and welcoming Hannibal, they attacked the townspeople at night, seizing part of the town on the side of the Vulturnus River, which divided it. This was the garrison the Romans had at Casilinum; they added a cohort of four hundred and sixty Perusians, who had been driven to Casilinum by the same news that had reached the Praenestines a few days earlier. Together, they formed a sufficient number of armed men to defend such a small area, protected on one side by the river. The shortage of grain even made them seem too numerous.

18

Hannibal having now advanced within a short distance of the place, sent forward a body of Getulians under a commander named Isalca, and orders them in the first place, if an opportunity of parley should be given, to win them over by fair words, to open the gates, and admit a garrison; but, if they persisted in obstinate opposition, to proceed to action, and try if in any part he could force an entrance into the city. When they had approached the walls, because silence prevailed there appeared a solitude; and the barbarian, supposing that they had retired through fear, made preparation for forcing the gates and breaking away the bars, when, the gates being suddenly thrown open, two cohorts, drawn up within for that very purpose, rushed forth with great tumult, and made a slaughter of the enemy. The first party being thus repulsed, Maharbal was sent with a more powerful body of troops; but neither could even he sustain the sally of the cohorts. Lastly, Hannibal, fixing his camp directly before the walls, prepared to assault this paltry city and garrison, with every effort and all his forces, and having completely surrounded the city with a line of troops, lost a considerable number of men, including all the most forward, who were shot from the walls and turrets, while he pressed on and provoked the enemy. Once he was very near cutting them off, by throwing in a line of elephants, when aggressively sallying forth, and drove them in the utmost confusion into the town; a good many, out of so small a number, having been slain. More would have fallen had not night interrupted the battle. On the following day, the minds of all were possessed with an ardent desire to commence the assault, especially after a golden mural crown had been promised, and the general himself had reproached the conquerors of Saguntum with the slowness of their siege of a little fort situated on level ground; reminding them, each and all, of Cannae, Trasimenus, and Trebia. They then began to apply the vineae and to spring mines: nor was any measure, whether of open force or stratagem, unemployed against the various attempts of the enemy. These allies of the Romans erected bulwarks against the vineae, cut off the mines of the enemy by cross-mines, and met their efforts both covertly and openly, till, at last, shame compelled Hannibal to desist from his undertaking; and, fortifying a camp in which he placed a small guard, that the affair might not appear to have been abandoned, he retired into winter quarters to Capua. There he kept, under cover, for the greater part of the winter, that army, which, though fortified by frequent and continued hardships against every human ill, had yet never experienced or been habituated to prosperity. Accordingly, excess of good fortune and unrestrained indulgence were the ruin of men whom no severity of distress had subdued; and so much the more completely, in proportion to the avidity with which they plunged into pleasures to which they were unaccustomed. For sleep, wine, feasting, women, baths, and ease, which custom rendered more seductive day by day, so completely unnerved both mind and body, that from henceforth their past victories rather than their present strength protected them; and in this the general is considered by those who are skilled in the art of war to have committed a greater error than in not having marched his troops to Rome forthwith from the field of Cannae: for his delay on that occasion might be considered as only to have postponed his victory, but this mistake to have bereaved him of the power of conquering. Accordingly, by Hercules, as though he marched out of Capua with another army, it retained in no respect any of its former discipline; for most of the troops returned in the embrace of harlots; and as soon as they began to live under tents, and the fatigue of marching and other military labours tried them, like raw troops, they failed both in bodily strength and spirit. From that time, during the whole period of the summer campaign, a great number of them slunk away from the standards without furloughs, while Capua was the only retreat of the deserters.

Hannibal had now moved close to the city and sent a group of Getulians, led by a commander named Isalca, ahead. He instructed them to first try to negotiate; if they got a chance to talk, they should persuade the defenders with kind words to open the gates and let in a garrison. However, if the defenders remained stubbornly opposed, they were to take action and attempt to force their way into the city. As they got closer to the walls, the silence created an eerie atmosphere. The enemy, thinking the defenders had retreated in fear, prepared to break down the gates. Suddenly, the gates swung open, and two cohorts stationed inside charged out with a loud uproar, slaughtering the attackers. When the first group was pushed back, Maharbal was sent with a larger force, but he too couldn’t withstand the fierce counterattack from the cohorts. Ultimately, Hannibal set up camp directly in front of the walls, ready to assault the small city with all his might. He completely surrounded the city with his troops but lost a significant number of men, including many of his best soldiers, who were shot from the walls while he pressed the enemy. At one point, he almost trapped the defenders by sending in a line of elephants, driving them into the city in chaos and inflicting casualties. More would have died had night not interrupted the battle. The next day, the desire to launch an assault consumed everyone, especially after a golden crown was promised to the victor, and Hannibal had criticized the conquerors of Saguntum for taking too long to siege a little fort on flat ground, reminding them of their victories at Cannae, Trasimenus, and Trebia. They began to set up siege works and dig mines, deploying every measure of open force or strategy against the enemy's various attempts. The Roman allies built defenses against the siege works and used counter-mines to thwart the enemy’s efforts, engaging in both covert and open conflict until Hannibal was ultimately shamed into abandoning his assault. He then fortified a camp with a small guard to avoid appearing to have given up and retreated to winter quarters at Capua. There, he kept most of the army under cover for the winter, which, despite having faced numerous hardships, had never truly known success. This excess of good fortune and unrestricted indulgence became the downfall of men who had never been broken by difficulty, especially as they eagerly indulged in pleasures they were not used to. Sleep, wine, feasting, women, baths, and ease, which became increasingly tempting day by day, weakened both their minds and bodies to the extent that their previous victories, rather than their current strength, became their protection. Military experts consider Hannibal's error here even greater than his delay in marching on Rome right after the battle of Cannae; while that was merely a postponement of victory, this mistake deprived him of his ability to conquer. Thus, as if he left Capua with a brand-new army, it had lost all its former discipline. Most of the soldiers returned to the arms of prostitutes, and once they started living in tents and endured the fatigue of marching and military hardships, they lacked both physical strength and motivation. From then on, during the entire summer campaign, many of them deserted their ranks without permission, with Capua being the only refuge for the runaways.

19

However, when the rigour of winter began to abate, marching his troops out of their winter quarters he returned to Casilinum; where, although there had been an intermission of the assault, the continuance of the siege had reduced the inhabitants and the garrison to the extremity of want. Titus Sempronius commanded the Roman camp, the dictator having gone to Rome to renew the auspices. The swollen state of the Vulturnus and the entreaties of the people of Nola and Acerrae, who feared the Campanians if the Roman troops should leave them, kept Marcellus in his place; although desirous himself also to bring assistance to the besieged. Gracchus, only maintaining his post near Casilinum, because he had been enjoined by the dictator not to take any active steps during his absence, did not stir; although intelligence was brought from Casilinum which might easily overcome every degree of patience. For it appeared that some had precipitated themselves from the walls through famine and that they were standing unarmed upon the walls, exposing their undefended bodies to the blows of the missile weapons. Gracchus, grieved at the intelligence, but not daring to fight contrary to the injunctions of the dictator, and yet aware that he must fight if he openly attempted to convey in provisions, and having no hope of introducing them clandestinely, collected corn from all parts of the surrounding country, and filling several casks sent a message to the magistrate to Casilinum, directing that they might catch the casks which the river would bring down. The following night, while all were intent upon the river, and the hopes excited by the message from the Romans, the casks sent came floating down the centre of the stream, and the corn was equally distributed among them all. This was repeated the second and third day; they were sent off and arrived during the same night; and hence they escaped the notice of the enemy's guards. But afterwards, the river, rendered more than ordinarily rapid by continual rains, drove the casks by a cross current to the bank which the enemy were guarding; there they were discovered sticking among the osiers which grew along the banks; and, it being reported to Hannibal, from that time the watches were kept more strictly, that nothing sent to the city by the Vulturnus might escape notice. However, nuts poured out at the Roman camp floated down the centre of the river to Casilinum, and were caught with hurdles. At length they were reduced to such a degree of want, that they endeavoured to chew the thongs and skins which they tore from their shields, after softening them in warm water; nor did they abstain from mice or any other kind of animals. They even dug up every kind of herb and root from the lowest mounds of their wall; and when the enemy had ploughed over all the ground producing herbage which was without the wall, they threw in turnip seed, so that Hannibal exclaimed, Must I sit here at Casilinum even till these spring up? and he, who up to that time had not lent an ear to any terms, then at length allowed himself to be treated with respecting the ransom of the free persons. Seven ounces of gold for each person were agreed upon as the price; and then, under a promise of protection, they surrendered themselves. They were kept in chains till the whole of the gold was paid, after which they were sent back to Cumae, in fulfilment of the promise. This account is more credible than that they were slain by a body of cavalry, which was sent to attack them as they were going away. They were for the most part Praenestines. Out of the five hundred and seventy who formed the garrison, almost one half were destroyed by sword or famine; the rest returned safe to Praeneste with their praetor Manicius, who had formerly been a scribe. His statue placed in the forum at Praeneste, clad in a coat of mail, with a gown on, and with the head covered, formed an evidence of this account; as did also three images with this legend inscribed on a brazen plate, "Manicius vowed these in behalf of the soldiers who were in the garrison at Casilinum." The same legend was inscribed under three images placed in the temple of Fortune.

However, when the severity of winter started to ease, Marcellus marched his troops out of their winter quarters and returned to Casilinum. Even though there had been a pause in the assault, the ongoing siege had left the residents and the garrison in a dire state. Titus Sempronius was in charge of the Roman camp, as the dictator had gone to Rome to renew the auspices. The swollen Vulturnus River and the pleas from the people of Nola and Acerrae, who were worried about the Campanians if the Roman troops withdrew, kept Marcellus in place, even though he also wanted to assist those under siege. Gracchus remained near Casilinum to follow the dictator's orders not to take any action during his absence, despite receiving reports from Casilinum that could test anyone's patience. It was reported that some people had jumped from the walls due to starvation and that others were standing unarmed on the walls, exposing themselves to missile fire. Gracchus, saddened by the news but not daring to disobey the dictator's orders, knew he had to act if he openly tried to send in supplies and had no hope of getting them in secretly. Instead, he gathered grain from the surrounding area, filled several barrels, and sent a message to the magistrate in Casilinum, instructing them to catch the barrels that would be carried down by the river. The next night, while everyone was focused on the river and hopeful from the message from the Romans, the barrels floated down the center of the stream, and the grain was evenly distributed among them. This was repeated on the second and third days; the barrels were sent and arrived during the night, slipping past the enemy’s guards. However, the river, flowing faster than usual due to persistent rain, pushed the barrels across to the bank guarded by the enemy. There, they were discovered stuck among the willows growing along the banks, and when this was reported to Hannibal, tighter watches were enforced to ensure nothing sent to the city via the Vulturnus went unnoticed. Still, nuts from the Roman camp floated down the center of the river to Casilinum and were caught using hurdles. Eventually, they faced such extreme hunger that they began to chew on the thongs and skins they had torn from their shields after softening them in warm water, and they didn't hesitate to eat mice or any other small creatures. They even dug up all kinds of herbs and roots from the lowest parts of their walls, and when the enemy had plowed over all the grassy ground outside the walls, they tossed in turnip seeds, prompting Hannibal to exclaim, "Must I sit here at Casilinum until these grow?" Up until that point, he had refused to listen to any terms but eventually allowed negotiations concerning the ransom of free individuals. They agreed on a price of seven ounces of gold per person, and under the promise of protection, they surrendered. They were kept in chains until the entire amount of gold was paid, after which they were sent back to Cumae, fulfilling the promise. This account is considered more credible than the claim that they were killed by a cavalry unit sent to attack them as they left. Most of them were from Praeneste. Out of the five hundred and seventy in the garrison, nearly half perished from either sword or famine; the rest returned safely to Praeneste with their praetor Manicius, who had previously been a scribe. His statue, placed in the Praeneste forum, depicted him in chain mail, wearing a gown and covered head, serving as evidence of this account, as did three images with the inscription on a bronze plate, "Manicius vowed these on behalf of the soldiers who were in the garrison at Casilinum." The same inscription was placed under three images in the temple of Fortune.

20

The town of Casilinum was restored to the Campanians, strengthened by a garrison of seven hundred soldiers from the army of Hannibal, lest on the departure of the Carthaginian from it, the Romans should assault it. To the Praenestine soldiers the Roman senate voted double pay and exemption from military service for five years. On being offered the freedom of the state, in consideration of their valor, they would not make the exchange. The account of the fate of the Perusians is less clear, as no light is thrown upon it by any monument of their own, or any decree of the Romans. At the same time the Petelini, the only Bruttian state which had continued in the Roman alliance, were attacked not only by the Carthaginians, who were in possession of the surrounding country, but also by the rest of the Bruttian states, on account of their having adopted a separate policy. The Petelini, unable to bear up against these distresses, sent ambassadors to Rome to solicit aid, whose prayers and entreaties (for on being told that they must themselves take measures for their own safety, they gave themselves up to piteous lamentations in the vestibule of the senate-house) excited the deepest commiseration in the fathers and the people. On the question being proposed a second time to the fathers by Manius Pomponius, the praetor, after examining all the resources of the empire, they were compelled to confess that they had no longer any protection for their distant allies, and bid them return home, and having done every thing which could be expected from faithful allies, as to what remained to take measures for their own security in the present state of fortune. On the result of this embassy being reported to the Petelini, their senate was suddenly seized with such violent grief and dismay, that some advised that they should run away wherever each man could find an asylum, and abandon the city. Some advised, that as they were deserted by their ancient allies, they should unite themselves with the rest of the Bruttian states, and through them surrender themselves to Hannibal. The opinion however which prevailed was that of those who thought that nothing should be done in haste and rashly, and that they should take the whole matter into their consideration again. The next day, when they had cooled upon it, and their trepidation had somewhat subsided, the principal men carried their point that they should collect all their property out of the fields, and fortify the city and the walls.

The town of Casilinum was returned to the Campanians, protected by a garrison of seven hundred soldiers from Hannibal's army, to prevent the Romans from attacking once the Carthaginians left. The Roman senate awarded the Praenestine soldiers double pay and exempted them from military service for five years. When offered the freedom of the state for their bravery, they refused the exchange. The fate of the Perusians is less clear because there's no documentation from them or any Roman decree to shed light on it. Meanwhile, the Petelini, the only Bruttian state still allied with Rome, faced attacks not just from the Carthaginians, who controlled the surrounding area, but also from the other Bruttian states because they had pursued a separate policy. Overwhelmed by these challenges, the Petelini sent ambassadors to Rome for help. Their pleas and desperate cries (after being told they had to secure their own safety, they broke down in tears in the senate-house entrance) touched the hearts of the senate and the people. When the question was raised again by Manius Pomponius, the praetor, they acknowledged, after reviewing the empire’s resources, that they could no longer protect their distant allies, and told them to return home. They had done everything expected of loyal allies, and now it was up to the Petelini to ensure their own safety given their circumstances. When the outcome of this mission was reported back to the Petelini, their senate was suddenly overcome with intense grief and fear, leading some to suggest they should flee to any place they could find refuge and abandon the city. Others proposed that, having been abandoned by their old allies, they should join the other Bruttian states and surrender to Hannibal through them. However, the prevailing opinion was to avoid acting hastily and to reconsider the situation. The next day, after calming down and regaining some composure, the leaders decided they should gather all their belongings from the fields and fortify the city and its walls.

21

Much about the same time letters were brought from Sicily and Sardinia. That of Titus Otacilius the propraetor was first read in the senate. It stated that Lucius Furius the praetor had arrived at Lilybaeum from Africa with his fleet. That he himself, having been severely wounded, was in imminent danger of his life; that neither pay nor corn was punctually furnished to the soldiers or the marines; nor were there any resources from which they could be furnished. That he earnestly advised that such supplies should be sent with all possible expedition; and that, if it was thought proper, they should send one of the new praetors to succeed him.

Around the same time, letters were sent from Sicily and Sardinia. The one from Titus Otacilius, the propraetor, was the first to be read in the senate. It mentioned that Lucius Furius, the praetor, had arrived at Lilybaeum from Africa with his fleet. It stated that he himself had been seriously wounded and was in imminent danger of his life; that neither pay nor supplies of grain were provided on time to the soldiers or the marines; nor were there any resources available to provide them. He strongly recommended that these supplies be sent as quickly as possible and suggested that, if deemed appropriate, one of the new praetors should be sent to replace him.

Nearly the same intelligence respecting corn and pay was conveyed in a letter from Aulus Cornelius Mammula, the propraetor, from Sardinia. The answer to both was, that there were no resources from whence they could be supplied, and orders were given to them that they should themselves provide for their fleets and armies. Titus Otacilius having sent ambassadors to Hiero, the only source of assistance the Romans had, received as much money as was wanting to pay the troops and a supply of corn for six months. In Sardinia, the allied states contributed liberally to Cornelius. The scarcity of money at Rome also was so great, that on the proposal of Marcus Minucius, plebeian tribune, a financial triumvirate was appointed, consisting of Lucius Aemilius Papus, who had been consul and censor, Marcus Atilius Regulus, who had been twice consul, and Lucius Scribonius Libo, who was then plebeian tribune. Marcus and Caius Atilius were also created a duumvirate for dedicating the temple of Concord, which Lucius Manlius had vowed when praetor. Three pontiffs were also created, Quintus Caecilius Metellus, Quintus Fabius Maximus, and Quintus Fulvius Flaccus, in the room of Publius Scantinius deceased, and of Lucius Aemilius Paulus the consul, and of Quintus Aelius Paetus, who had fallen in the battle of Cannae.

Almost the same information about corn and payments was shared in a letter from Aulus Cornelius Mammula, the propraetor, from Sardinia. The response to both was that there were no resources available to supply them, and they were instructed to make provisions for their fleets and armies themselves. Titus Otacilius sent ambassadors to Hiero, the only source of support the Romans had, and received enough money to pay the troops and a supply of corn for six months. In Sardinia, the allied states generously contributed to Cornelius. The shortage of money in Rome was so severe that, at the suggestion of Marcus Minucius, the plebeian tribune, a financial triumvirate was established, consisting of Lucius Aemilius Papus, who had been consul and censor, Marcus Atilius Regulus, a two-time consul, and Lucius Scribonius Libo, who was then the plebeian tribune. Marcus and Caius Atilius were also appointed as a duumvirate to dedicate the temple of Concord, which Lucius Manlius had vowed when he was praetor. Three pontiffs were also appointed: Quintus Caecilius Metellus, Quintus Fabius Maximus, and Quintus Fulvius Flaccus, replacing the deceased Publius Scantinius, consul Lucius Aemilius Paulus, and Quintus Aelius Paetus, who had died in the battle of Cannae.

22

The fathers having repaired, as far as human counsels could effect it, the other losses from a continued series of unfortunate events, at length turned their attention on themselves, on the emptiness of the senate-house, and the paucity of those who assembled for public deliberation. For the senate-roll had not been reviewed since the censorship of Lucius Aemilius and C. Flaminius, though unfortunate battles, during a period of five years, as well as the private casualties of each, had carried off so many senators. Manius Pomponius, the praetor, as the dictator was now gone to the army after the loss of Casilinum, at the earnest request of all, brought in a bill upon the subject. When Spurius Carvilius, after having lamented in a long speech not only the scantiness of the senate, but the fewness of citizens who were eligible into that body, with the design of making up the numbers of the senate and uniting more closely the Romans and the Latin confederacy, declared that he strongly advised that the freedom of the state should be conferred upon two senators from each of the Latin states, if the Roman fathers thought proper, who might be chosen into the senate to supply the places of the deceased senators. This proposition the fathers listened to with no more equanimity than formerly to the request when made by the Latins themselves. A loud and violent expression of disapprobation ran through the whole senate-house. In particular, Manlius reminded them that there was still existing a man of that stock, from which that consul was descended who formerly threatened in the Capitol that he would with his own hand put to death any Latin senator he saw in that house. Upon which Quintus Fabius Maximus said, "that never was any subject introduced into the senate at a juncture more unseasonable than the present, when a question had been touched upon which would still further irritate the minds of the allies, who were already hesitating and wavering in their allegiance. That that rash suggestion of one individual ought to be annihilated by the silence of the whole body; and that if there ever was a declaration in that house which ought to be buried in profound and inviolable silence, surely that above all others was one which deserved to be covered and consigned to darkness and oblivion, and looked upon as if it had never been made." This put a stop to the mention of the subject. They determined that a dictator should be created for the purpose of reviewing the senate, and that he should be one who had been a censor, and was the oldest living of those who had held that office. They likewise gave orders that Caius Terentius, the consul, should be called home to nominate a dictator; who, leaving his troops in Apulia, returned to Rome with great expedition; and, according to custom, on the following night nominated Marcus Fabius Buteo dictator, for six months, without a master of the horse, in pursuance of the decree of the senate.

The leaders, having fixed, as much as human plans could achieve, the other losses from a string of unfortunate events, finally turned their attention to themselves, to the empty senate house, and the small number of people who gathered for public discussions. The senate roll hadn’t been updated since Lucius Aemilius and C. Flaminius were censors, even though unfortunate battles and individual losses over the last five years had taken many senators. Manius Pomponius, the praetor, brought forward a proposal about this issue, as the dictator had gone to the army after the loss of Casilinum, following the urgent request of everyone. When Spurius Carvilius, after lamenting in a long speech not only the lack of senators but also the few citizens eligible to join, suggested that two senators from each of the Latin states be granted citizenship if the Roman leaders deemed it appropriate in order to fill the gaps left by the deceased senators, the leaders reacted to this proposition with as much disapproval as they had when it was initially brought up by the Latins themselves. A loud expression of objection swept through the entire senate. Manlius especially reminded them that there was still a man from that lineage, from which the consul descended, who once threatened in the Capitol that he would personally kill any Latin senator he saw in that house. In response, Quintus Fabius Maximus stated that there had never been a more inappropriate time for such a matter to be brought up in the senate, as it would further agitate the allies, who were already uncertain about their loyalties. He insisted that the reckless suggestion of one individual should be silenced by the whole body, and that if there was ever a statement in that house that should be buried in deep and unbreakable silence, it was this one, which deserved to be forgotten and regarded as if it had never been said. This ended the discussion of the topic. They decided a dictator should be appointed to review the senate, specifically one who had previously been a censor and was the longest-serving living former censor. They also ordered that Caius Terentius, the consul, be called back to nominate a dictator; he quickly returned to Rome from Apulia, and that night, as was the custom, he appointed Marcus Fabius Buteo as dictator for six months, without a master of the horse, following the decree of the senate.

23

He having mounted the rostrum attended by the lictors, declared, that he neither approved of there being two dictators at one time, which had never been done before, nor of his being appointed dictator without a master of the horse; nor of the censorian authority being committed to one person, and to the same person a second time; nor that command should be given to a dictator for six months, unless he was created for active operations. That he would himself restrain within proper bounds those irregularities which chance, the exigencies of the times, and necessity had occasioned. For he would not remove any of those whom the censors Flaminius and Aemilius had elected into the senate; but would merely order that their names should be transcribed and read over, that one man might not exercise the power of deciding and determining on the character and morals of a senator; and would so elect in place of deceased members, that one rank should appear to be preferred to another, and not man to man. The old senate-roll having been read, he chose as successors to the deceased, first those who had filled a curule office since the censorship of Flaminius and Aemilius, but had not yet been elected into the senate, as each had been earliest created. He next chose those who had been aediles, plebeian tribunes, or quaestors; then of those who had never filled the office of magistrate, he selected such as had spoils taken from an enemy fixed up at their homes, or had received a civic crown. Having thus elected one hundred and seventy-seven senators, with the entire approbation of his countrymen, he instantly abdicated his office, and, bidding the lictors depart, he descended from the rostrum as a private citizen, and mingled with the crowd of persons who were engaged in their private affairs, designedly wearing away this time, lest he should draw off the people from the forum for the purpose of escorting him home. Their zeal, however, did not subside by the delay, for they escorted him to his house in great numbers. The consul returned to the army the ensuing night, without acquainting the senate, lest he should be detained in the city on account of the elections.

He climbed up to the platform with the lictors and declared that he didn’t approve of having two dictators at the same time, which had never happened before, nor did he agree with being appointed dictator without a master of the horse. He didn’t think it was right for the censorial authority to be held by one person, especially for a second time; nor did he believe that a dictator should be given command for six months unless he was appointed for active operations. He would keep those irregularities that arose from chance, current events, and necessity in check. He would not remove any of those whom the censors Flaminius and Aemilius had elected to the senate, but he would simply order their names to be copied and read aloud, so that no one man would have the power to decide and determine the character and morals of a senator. When electing replacements for deceased members, he would make sure that one rank appeared to be preferred over another, not one person over another. After reading the old senate-roll, he chose as successors to the deceased first those who had held a curule office since the censorship of Flaminius and Aemilius, but had not yet been elected to the senate, choosing them in the order they were created. Next, he selected those who had been aediles, plebeian tribunes, or quaestors; then, among those who had never held a magistrate position, he picked individuals who had spoils from an enemy displayed at their homes or who had received a civic crown. After electing one hundred and seventy-seven senators, with the full support of his fellow citizens, he immediately stepped down from his position, ordered the lictors to leave, and descended from the platform as a private citizen, blending in with the crowd busy with their own affairs, intentionally taking his time to avoid drawing the people away from the forum to escort him home. However, their enthusiasm didn’t wane with the delay, and they escorted him to his house in large numbers. The consul returned to the army the following night without informing the senate, so he wouldn’t be held up in the city due to the elections.

24

The next day, on the proposition of Manius Pomponius the praetor, the senate decreed that a letter should be written to the dictator, to the effect, that if he thought it for the interest of the state, he should come, together with the master of the horse and the praetor, Marcus Marcellus, to hold the election for the succeeding consuls, in order that the fathers might learn from them in person in what condition the state was, and take measures according to circumstances. All who were summoned came, leaving lieutenant-generals to hold command of the legions. The dictator, speaking briefly and modestly of himself, attributed much of the glory Of the campaign to the master of the horse, Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus. He then gave out the day for the comitia, at which the consuls created were Lucius Posthumius in his absence, being then employed in the government of the province of Gaul, for the third time, and Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus, who was then master of the horse and curule aedile. Marcus Valerius Laevinus, Appius Claudius Pulcher, Quintus Fulvius Flaccus, and Quintus Mucius Scaevola, were then created praetors. After the election of the magistrates, the dictator returned to his army, which was in winter quarters at Teanum, leaving his master of the horse at Rome, to take the sense of the fathers relative to the armies to be enlisted and embodied for the service of the year, as he was about to enter upon the magistracy after a few days. While busily occupied with these matters, intelligence arrived of a fresh disaster--fortune crowding into this year one calamity after another--that Lucius Posthumius, consul elect, himself with all his army was destroyed in Gaul. He was to march his troops through a vast wood, which the Gauls called Litana. On the right and left of his route, the natives had sawed the trees in such a manner that they continued standing upright, but would fall when impelled by a slight force. Posthumius had with him two Roman legions, and besides had levied so great a number of allies along the Adriatic Sea, that he led into the enemy's country twenty-five thousand men. As soon as this army entered the wood, the Gauls, who were posted around its extreme skirts, pushed down the outermost of the sawn trees, which falling on those next them, and these again on others which of themselves stood tottering and scarcely maintained their position, crushed arms, men, and horses in an indiscriminate manner, so that scarcely ten men escaped. For, most of them being killed by the trunks and broken boughs of trees, the Gauls, who beset the wood on all sides in arms killed the rest, panic-struck by so unexpected a disaster. A very small number, who attempted to escape by a bridge, were taken prisoners, being intercepted by the enemy who had taken possession of it before them. Here Posthumius fell, fighting with all his might to prevent his being taken. The Boii having cut off his head, carried it and the spoils they stole off his body, in triumph into the most sacred temple they had. Afterwards they cleansed the head according to their custom, and having covered the skull with chased gold, used it as a cup for libations in their solemn festivals, and a drinking cup for their high priests and other ministers of the temple. The spoils taken by the Gauls were not less than the victory. For though great numbers of the beasts were crushed by the falling trees, yet as nothing was scattered by flight, every thing else was found strewed along the whole line of the prostrate band.

The next day, following a suggestion from Manius Pomponius the praetor, the senate decided that a letter should be sent to the dictator, stating that if he thought it was in the state's interest, he should come, along with the master of the horse and the praetor, Marcus Marcellus, to oversee the election for the upcoming consuls, so that the senators could hear firsthand about the state of affairs and take appropriate actions. Everyone who was summoned attended, leaving lieutenants to command the legions. The dictator, speaking briefly and humbly about himself, credited much of the campaign's success to the master of the horse, Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus. He then announced the day for the elections, where the new consuls were Lucius Posthumius, elected in his absence as he was busy governing the province of Gaul for the third time, and Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus, who was the master of the horse and curule aedile at the time. Marcus Valerius Laevinus, Appius Claudius Pulcher, Quintus Fulvius Flaccus, and Quintus Mucius Scaevola were then elected as praetors. After the elections, the dictator returned to his army, which was in winter quarters at Teanum, leaving his master of the horse in Rome to gauge the senators' opinions regarding the armies to be recruited and organized for the year, as he was about to take on the magistracy in a few days. While engaged with these tasks, news arrived of another setback— fortune bringing one calamity after another this year—that Lucius Posthumius, consul-elect, along with his entire army, had been destroyed in Gaul. He was supposed to march his troops through a large forest, which the Gauls called Litana. On either side of his route, the locals had cut down trees in a way that they remained standing but would fall with minimal force. Posthumius had with him two Roman legions and, in addition, had gathered so many allies from along the Adriatic Sea that he was leading twenty-five thousand men into enemy territory. Once this army entered the forest, the Gauls, positioned around its outer edges, pushed down the outermost of the cut trees, which fell onto those next to them, causing a domino effect—crushing arms, men, and horses in a chaotic manner—so that hardly ten men survived. Most were killed by the falling trunks and branches, while the Gauls, surrounding the wood with weapons, killed the rest, panicked by such an unexpected disaster. A very small number who tried to escape via a bridge were captured as the enemy had already seized it. Here, Posthumius fell, fighting fiercely to avoid being taken. The Boii, having beheaded him, brought his head and the spoils they took from his body in triumph to their most sacred temple. Later, they cleaned the head in accordance with their customs, and after adorning it with gold, used it as a cup for libations at their religious festivals and as a drinking vessel for their high priests and other temple ministers. The spoils taken by the Gauls were equal to the victory. Although many animals were crushed by the falling trees, since nothing fled, everything else was found scattered along the entire line of the fallen forces.

25

The news of this disaster arriving, when the state had been in so great a panic for many days, that the shops were shut up as if the solitude of night reigned through the city; the senate gave it in charge to the aediles to go round the city, cause the shops to be opened, and this appearance of public affliction to be removed. Then Titus Sempronius, having assembled the senate, consoled and encouraged the fathers, requesting, "that they who had sustained the defeat at Cannae with so much magnanimity would not now be cast down with less calamities. That if their arms should prosper, as he hoped they would, against Hannibal and the Carthaginians, the war with the Gauls might be suspended and deferred without hazard. The gods and the Roman people would have it in their power to revenge the treachery of the Gauls another time. That they should now deliberate about the Carthaginian foe, and the forces with which the war was to be prosecuted." He first laid before them the number of foot and horse, as well citizens as allies, that were in the dictator's army. Then Marcellus gave an account of the amount in his. Those who knew were asked what troops were in Apulia with Caius Terentius Varro the consul. But no practicable plan could be devised for raising consular armies sufficient to support so important a war. For this reason, notwithstanding a just resentment irritated them, they determined that Gaul should be passed over for that year. The dictator's army was assigned to the consul; and they ordered such of the troops of Marcellus's army as had fled from Cannae, to be transported into Sicily, to serve there as long as the war continued in Italy. Thither, likewise, were ordered to be sent as unfit to serve with him, the weakest of the dictator's troops, no time of service being appointed, but the legal number of campaigns. The two legions in the city were voted to the other consul who should be elected in the room of Posthumius; and they resolved that he should be elected as soon as the auspices would permit. Besides, two legions were immediately to be recalled from Sicily, out of which the consul, to whom the city legions fell, might take what number of men he should have occasion for. The consul Caius Terentius Varro was continued in his command for one year, without lessening the army he had for the defence of Apulia.

The news of this disaster came while the state had been in such a panic for many days that the shops were closed as if the quiet of night had taken over the city. The senate instructed the aediles to go around the city, reopen the shops, and lift this sense of public sorrow. Then Titus Sempronius gathered the senate and reassured the members, urging, "Those who faced the defeat at Cannae with such courage shouldn’t be discouraged by lesser misfortunes now. If our forces succeed, as I hope they will, against Hannibal and the Carthaginians, we can temporarily put the war with the Gauls on hold without taking risks. The gods and the Roman people will have another chance to avenge the Gauls' betrayal. We should focus now on the Carthaginian enemy and the resources we need to continue this war." He first presented the number of foot soldiers and cavalry in the dictator's army, including both citizens and allies. Then Marcellus reported on the forces under his command. Those in the know were asked about the troops stationed in Apulia with Consul Caius Terentius Varro. However, no viable plan could be developed to raise sufficient consular armies for such a significant conflict. Therefore, even though they were justifiably angry, they decided to set aside the Gaul issue for that year. The dictator's army was assigned to the consul, and the troops from Marcellus’s army that had escaped from Cannae were ordered to be sent to Sicily, where they would remain for the duration of the war in Italy. The weakest soldiers from the dictator's army, deemed unfit for service, were also sent there without a specific time of service but just the required number of campaigns. The two legions in the city were allocated to the next consul who would be elected to replace Posthumius, and they resolved to elect him as soon as the auspices permitted. In addition, two legions were to be recalled from Sicily so that the consul who received the city legions could choose however many men he needed. Consul Caius Terentius Varro was confirmed in his command for another year without reducing the forces he had for the defense of Apulia.

26

During these transactions and preparations in Italy, the war in Spain was prosecuted with no less vigour; but hitherto more favourably to the Romans. The two generals had divided their troops, so that Cneius acted by land, and Publius by sea. Hasdrubal, general of the Carthaginians, sufficiently trusting to neither branch of his forces, kept himself at a distance from the enemy, secured by the intervening space and the strength of his fortifications, until, after much solicitation, four thousand foot and five hundred horse were sent him out of Africa as a reinforcement. At length, inspired with fresh hopes, he moved nearer the enemy; and himself also ordered a fleet to be equipped and prepared for the protection of the islands and sea-coasts. In the very onset of renewing the war, he was greatly embarrassed by the desertion of the captains of his ships, who had ceased to entertain a sincere attachment towards the general and the Carthaginian cause, ever since they were severely reprimanded for abandoning the fleet in a cowardly manner at the Iberus. These deserters had raised an insurrection among the Tartessians, and at their instigation some cities had revolted; they had even taken one by force. The war was now turned from the Romans into that country, which he entered in a hostile manner, and resolved to attack Galbus, a distinguished general of the Tartessians, who with a powerful army kept close within his camp, before the walls of a city which had been captured but a few days before. Accordingly, he sent his light-armed troops in advance to provoke the enemy to battle, and part of his infantry to ravage the country throughout in every direction, and to cut off stragglers. There was a skirmish before the camp, at the same time that many were killed and put to flight in the fields. But having by different routes returned to their camp, they so quickly shook off all fear, that they had courage not only to defend their lines, but challenge the enemy to fight. They sallied out, therefore, in a body from the camp, dancing according to their custom. Their sudden boldness terrified the enemy, who a little before had been the assailants. Hasdrubal therefore drew off his troops to a tolerably steep eminence, and secured further by having a river between it and the enemy. Here the parties of light-armed troops which had been sent in advance, and the horse which had been dispersed about, he called in to join him. But not thinking himself sufficiently secured by the eminence or the river, he fortified his camp completely with a rampart. While thus fearing and feared alternately, several skirmishes occurred, in which the Numidian cavalry were not so good as the Spanish, nor the Moorish darters so good as the Spanish targetteers, who equalled them in swiftness, but were superior to them in strength and courage.

During these dealings and preparations in Italy, the war in Spain was being fought just as vigorously, but so far it was going better for the Romans. The two generals had split their forces, with Cneius leading on land and Publius at sea. Hasdrubal, the Carthaginian general, didn’t fully trust either part of his army, so he kept his distance from the enemy, relying on the space between them and the strength of his fortifications. Eventually, after much persuasion, he received reinforcements of four thousand infantry and five hundred cavalry from Africa. Finally feeling more hopeful, he moved closer to the enemy and also ordered a fleet to be assembled to protect the islands and coastlines. At the start of this new phase of the war, he faced significant challenges because several ship captains had deserted him after being harshly criticized for their cowardice when they abandoned the fleet at the Iberus. These deserters incited unrest among the Tartessians, leading some cities to revolt, and they even captured one city by force. The war now shifted from the Romans to this region, and Hasdrubal entered it with hostile intent, planning to attack Galbus, a prominent general of the Tartessians, who was well entrenched with a strong army just outside a city recently taken by Hasdrubal’s forces. To provoke a battle, he sent his light troops ahead and dispatched some infantry to pillage the land and cut off stragglers. There was a skirmish in front of the camp, during which many were killed or put to flight in the fields. But after returning to their camp by various paths, they quickly shook off their fear and were motivated to defend their position and challenge the enemy. They burst out of the camp, dancing as per their tradition. This sudden boldness scared the enemy, who had just been the attackers. Hasdrubal then moved his troops to a somewhat steep hill secured further by a river separating him from the enemy. Here, he regrouped the light troops and scattered cavalry. Still not feeling safe enough, he fortified his camp with a complete rampart. While they alternated between fear and being feared, several skirmishes took place, where the Numidian cavalry was not as effective as the Spanish, and the Moorish skirmishers were equal in speed to the Spanish javelin throwers but outmatched them in strength and courage.

27

The enemy seeing they could not, by coming up to Hasdrubal's camp, draw him out to a battle, nor assault it without great difficulty, stormed Asena, whither Hasdrubal, on entering their territories, had laid up his corn and other stores. By this they became masters of all the surrounding country. But now they became quite ungovernable, both when on march and within their camp.

The enemy realized they couldn't lure Hasdrubal into battle by approaching his camp, nor could they attack it without significant trouble. So, they attacked Asena, where Hasdrubal had stored his grain and supplies upon entering their lands. This allowed them to seize control of the entire surrounding area. However, they soon became completely unruly, both when marching and while in their camp.

Hasdrubal, therefore, perceiving their negligence, which, as usual, was the consequence of success, after having exhorted his troops to attack them while they were straggling and without their standards, came down the hill, and advanced to their camp in order of battle. On his approach being announced in a tumultuous manner, by men who fled from the watchposts and advanced guards, they shouted to arms; and as each could get his arms, they rushed precipitately to battle, without waiting for the word, without standards, without order, and without ranks. The foremost of them were already engaged, while some were running up in parties, and others had not got out of their camp. However, at first, the very boldness of their attack terrified the enemy. But when they charged their close ranks with their own which were thin, and were not able to defend themselves for want of numbers, each began to look out for others to support him; and being repulsed in all quarters they collected themselves in form of a circle, where being so closely crowded together, body to body, armour to armour, that they had not room to wield their arms, they were surrounded by the enemy, who continued to slaughter them till late in the day. A small number, having forced a passage, made for the woods and hills. With like consternation, their camp was abandoned, and next day the whole nation submitted. But they did not continue long quiet, for immediately upon this, Hasdrubal received orders from Carthage to march into Italy with all expedition. The report of which, spreading over Spain, made almost all the states declare for the Romans. Accordingly he wrote immediately to Carthage, to inform them how much mischief the report of his march had produced. "That if he really did leave Spain, the Romans would be masters of it all before he could pass the Iberus. For, besides that he had neither an army nor a general whom he could leave to supply his place, so great were the abilities of the Roman generals who commanded there, that they could scarcely be opposed with equal forces. If, therefore, they had any concern for preserving Spain, they ought to send a general with a powerful army to succeed him. To whom, however prosperous all things might prove, yet the province would not be a position of ease."

Hasdrubal, noticing their carelessness, which was typical after a victory, encouraged his troops to attack while the enemy was scattered and disorganized. He descended the hill and advanced toward their camp in battle formation. As he approached, the alarm was raised by men who fled from the lookout posts and advanced guards, prompting a shout to arms. Each person grabbed whatever weapons they could find and rushed into battle without waiting for commands, standards, or any order. The front line engaged the enemy while some were still running to join, and others hadn't even left the camp. Initially, their boldness struck fear into the enemy. However, as they charged against the enemy’s solid ranks, which were weak in number, they found themselves unable to defend effectively. One by one, they began to seek support, but being repelled from all sides, they regrouped in a circle, huddled so closely that they had no space to swing their weapons. The enemy surrounded them and continued their slaughter until late in the day. A small group managed to break through and escaped into the woods and hills. In a similar panic, their camp was abandoned, and the next day the entire nation surrendered. But they didn’t remain quiet for long, as Hasdrubal soon received orders from Carthage to march into Italy as quickly as possible. News of this spread across Spain, leading almost all states to side with the Romans. He immediately wrote to Carthage to inform them of the trouble the news of his departure had caused, warning that if he truly left Spain, the Romans would take control of it all before he could cross the Iberus. He explained that he had neither an army nor a general to leave behind, as the Roman commanders there were so capable that they could hardly be opposed with equal forces. Thus, if they cared at all about retaining Spain, they needed to send a general with a strong army to succeed him. Regardless of how fortunate things might turn out, the province would not be a comfortable position.

28

Though this letter made at first a great impression on the senate, yet, as their interest in Italy was first and most important, they did not at all alter their resolution in relation to Hasdrubal and his troops. However, they despatched Himilco with a complete army, and an augmented fleet, to preserve and defend Spain both by sea and land. When he had conveyed over his land and naval forces, he fortified a camp; and having drawn his ships upon dry land, and surrounded them with a rampart, he marched with a chosen body of cavalry, with all possible expedition; using the same caution when passing through people who were wavering, and those who were actually enemies; and came up with Hasdrubal. As soon as he had informed him of the resolutions and orders of the senate, and in his turn been thoroughly instructed in what manner to prosecute the war in Spain, he returned to his camp; his expedition more than any thing else saving him, for he quitted every place before the people could conspire. Before Hasdrubal quitted his position he laid all the states in subjection to him under contribution. He knew well that Hannibal purchased a passage through some nations; that he had no Gallic auxiliaries but such as were hired; and that if he had undertaken so arduous a march without money, he would scarcely have penetrated so far as the Alps. For this reason, having exacted the contributions with great haste, he marched down to the Iberus. As soon as the Roman generals got notice of the Carthaginian senate's resolution, and Hasdrubal's march, they gave up every other concern, and uniting their forces, determined to meet him and oppose his attempt. They reflected, that when it was already so difficult to make head against Hannibal alone in Italy, there would be an end of the Roman empire in Spain, should Hasdrubal join him with a Spanish army. Full of anxiety and care on these accounts, they assembled their forces at the Iberus, and crossed the river; and after deliberating for some time whether they should encamp opposite to the enemy, or be satisfied with impeding his intended march by attacking the allies of the Carthaginians, they made preparations for besieging a city called Ibera, from its contiguity to the river, which was at that time the wealthiest in that quarter. When Hasdrubal perceived this, instead of carrying assistance to his allies, he proceeded himself to besiege a city which had lately placed itself under the protection of the Romans; and thus the siege which was now commenced was given up by them, and the operations of the war turned against Hasdrubal himself.

Though this letter made a strong impression on the senate at first, their primary concern was Italy, so they didn't change their decision regarding Hasdrubal and his troops at all. However, they sent Himilco with a full army and an increased fleet to protect and defend Spain both on land and at sea. Once he got his land and naval forces across, he set up a fortified camp; he pulled his ships ashore and surrounded them with a rampart, then quickly marched out with a select group of cavalry, being as careful as possible when passing through neutral and hostile territories, and confronted Hasdrubal. After informing him of the senate's decisions and orders, and receiving clear instructions on how to proceed with the war in Spain, he returned to his camp; his swift movement was crucial, as he left areas before the locals could band together against him. Before Hasdrubal left his position, he imposed tributes on all the regions under his control. He was well aware that Hannibal had to pay for passage through various nations, that he only had Gallic support from hired soldiers, and that if he had attempted such a challenging march without funding, he would barely have made it as far as the Alps. For this reason, after quickly collecting contributions, he moved down to the Iberus. Once the Roman generals learned of the Carthaginian senate's decision and Hasdrubal's march, they set aside everything else, combined their forces, and resolved to confront him and thwart his plans. They realized that it was already challenging to fend off Hannibal alone in Italy, and if Hasdrubal joined him with a Spanish army, it would mean the end of the Roman Empire in Spain. Filled with anxiety and concern for these reasons, they gathered their forces at the Iberus and crossed the river. After debating for a while whether to camp in front of the enemy or hinder his planned march by attacking the Carthaginian allies, they decided to prepare for the siege of a city called Ibera, which was wealthiest in the area at that time due to its location near the river. When Hasdrubal noticed this, rather than helping his allies, he went to lay siege to a city that had recently placed itself under Roman protection; as a result, the siege now underway was abandoned by them, and the focus of the war shifted to Hasdrubal himself.

29

For a few days they remained encamped at a distance of five miles from each other, not without skirmishes, but without going out to a regular engagement. At length the signal for battle was given out on both sides on one and the same day, as though by concert, and they marched down into the plain with all their forces. The Roman army stood in triple line; a part of the light troops were stationed among the first line, the other half were received behind the standards, the cavalry covering the wings. Hasdrubal formed his centre strong with Spaniards, and placed the Carthaginians in the right wing, the Africans and hired auxiliaries in the left. His cavalry he placed before the wings, attaching the Numidians to the Carthaginian infantry, and the rest to the Africans. Nor were all the Numidians placed in the right wing, but such as taking two horses each into the field are accustomed frequently to leap full armed, when the battle is at the hottest, from a tired horse upon a fresh one, after the manner of vaulters: such was their own agility, and so docile their breed of horses. While they stood thus drawn up, the hopes entertained by the generals on both sides were pretty much upon an equality; for neither possessed any great superiority, either in point of the number or quality of the troops. The feelings of the soldiers were widely different. Their generals had, without difficulty, induced the Romans to believe, that although they fought at a distance from their country, it was Italy and the city of Rome that they were defending. Accordingly, they had brought their minds to a settled resolution to conquer or die; as if their return to their country had hinged upon the issue of that battle. The other army consisted of less determined men; for they were principally Spaniards, who would rather be vanquished in Spain, than be victorious to be dragged into Italy. On the first onset, therefore, ere their javelins had scarcely been thrown, their centre gave ground, and the Romans pressing on with great impetuosity, turned their backs. In the wings the battle proceeded with no less activity; on one side the Carthaginians, on the other the Africans, charged vigorously, while the Romans, in a manner surrounded, were exposed to a twofold attack. But when the whole of the Roman troops had united in the centre, they possessed sufficient strength to compel the wings of the enemy to retire in different directions; and thus there were two separate battles, in both of which the Romans were decidedly superior, as after the defeat of the enemy's centre they had the advantage both in the number and strength of their troops. Vast numbers were slain on this occasion; and had not the Spaniards fled precipitately from the field ere the battle had scarce begun, very few out of the whole army would have survived. There was very little fighting of the cavalry, for as soon as the Moors and Numidians perceived that the centre gave way, they fled immediately with the utmost precipitation, leaving the wings uncovered, and also driving the elephants before them. Hasdrubal, after waiting the issue of the battle to the very last, fled from the midst of the carnage with a few attendants. The Romans took and plundered the camp. This victory united with the Romans whatever states of Spain were wavering, and left Hasdrubal no hope, not only of leading an army over into Italy, but even of remaining very safely in Spain. When these events were made generally known at Rome by letters from the Scipios, the greatest joy was felt, not so much for the victory, as for the stop which was put to the passage of Hasdrubal into Italy.

For a few days, they camped about five miles apart, exchanging skirmishes but avoiding a full battle. Eventually, both sides signaled for battle on the same day, and they marched into the plain with all their forces. The Roman army formed three lines; some light troops were positioned in the front line, while the rest were stationed behind the standards, with cavalry on the flanks. Hasdrubal built a strong center with Spaniards, placing the Carthaginians on the right wing and Africans and hired auxiliaries on the left. His cavalry was positioned in front of the wings, attaching Numidians to the Carthaginian infantry and the others to the Africans. Not all Numidians were on the right wing; those who took two horses into battle could frequently leap from a tired horse to a fresh one at the height of the fight, thanks to their agility and the trainability of their horses. While they stood ready, the hopes of the generals on both sides were relatively equal, as neither had a significant advantage in troop numbers or quality. However, the soldiers’ morale was quite different. Their generals had easily convinced the Romans that even though they were far from home, they were defending Italy and the city of Rome. As a result, they were determined to either win or die, as if their return home depended on the outcome of this battle. The opposing army, consisting mainly of Spaniards, was less committed; they would prefer to be defeated in Spain rather than win and be dragged into Italy. Thus, at the first charge, before their javelins had barely been thrown, the center broke, and the Romans, pressing forward fiercely, caused them to retreat. The battle on the wings was equally intense, with the Carthaginians on one side and the Africans on the other charging vigorously while the Romans, effectively surrounded, faced a dual assault. However, when the entire Roman force united in the center, they had enough strength to push the enemy wings back in different directions, resulting in two separate battles. In both, the Romans proved decisively superior, as they had the advantage in both number and strength after defeating the enemy's center. Many were killed that day, and had the Spaniards not fled so quickly before the battle had even begun, very few from their army would have survived. There was minimal cavalry engagement since the Moors and Numidians, noticing the center collapsing, immediately fled in panic, leaving the wings exposed and driving the elephants ahead. Hasdrubal, after waiting until the very end of the battle, escaped the carnage with a few followers. The Romans seized and plundered the camp. This victory united the wavering states of Spain with the Romans and left Hasdrubal with no hope of leading an army into Italy or even staying safely in Spain. When these events were reported back to Rome by letters from the Scipios, there was immense joy, not only for the victory but also for the halting of Hasdrubal's movement into Italy.

30

While these transactions were going on in Spain, Petilia, in Bruttium, was taken by Himilco, an officer of Hannibal's, several months after the siege of it began. This victory cost the Carthaginians much blood and many wounds, nor did any power more subdue the besieged than that of famine; for after having consumed their means of subsistence, derived from fruits and the flesh of every kind of quadrupeds, they were at last compelled to live upon skins found in shoemakers' shops, on herbs and roots, the tender barks of trees, and berries gathered from brambles: nor were they subdued until they wanted strength to stand upon the walls and support their arms. After gaining Petilia, the Carthaginian marched his forces to Consentia, which being less obstinately defended, he compelled to surrender within a few days. Nearly about the same time, an army of Bruttians invested Croton, a Greek city, formerly powerful in men and arms, but at the present time reduced so low by many and great misfortunes, that less than twenty thousand inhabitants of all ages remained. The enemy, therefore, easily got possession of a city destitute of defenders: of the citadel alone possession was retained, into which some of the inhabitants fled from the midst of the carnage during the confusion created by the capture of the city. The Locrians too revolted to the Bruttians and Carthaginians, the populace having been betrayed by the nobles. The Rhegians were the only people in that quarter who continued to the last in faithful attachment to the Romans, and in the enjoyment of their independence. The same alteration of feeing extended itself into Sicily also; and not even the family of Hiero altogether abstained from defection; for Gelo, his oldest son, conceiving a contempt for his father's old age, and, after the defeat of Cannae, for the alliance with Rome, went over to the Carthaginians; and he would have created a disturbance in Sicily, had he not been carried off, when engaged as arming the people and soliciting the allies, by a death so seasonable that it threw some degree of suspicion even upon his father. Such, with various result, were the transactions in Italy, Africa, Sicily, and Spain during this year. At the close of the year, Quintus Fabius Maximus requested of the senate, that he might be allowed to dedicate the temple of Venus Erycina, which he had vowed when dictator. The senate decreed, that Tiberius Sempronius, the consul elect, as soon as ever he had entered upon his office, should propose to the people, that they should create Quintus Fabius duumvir, for the purpose of dedicating the temple. Also, in honour of Marcus Aemilius Lepidus, who had been consul twice and augur, his three sons, Lucius, Marcus, and Quintus exhibited funeral games and twenty-two pairs of gladiators for three days in the forum. The curule aediles, Caius Laetorius, and Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus consul elect, who during his aedileship had been master of the horse, celebrated the Roman games, which were repeated for three days. The plebeian games of the aediles, Marcus Aurelius Cotta and Marcus Claudius Marcellus, were thrice repeated. At the conclusion of the third year of the Punic war, Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus the consul entered upon his office on the ides of March. Of the praetors, Quintus Fulvius Flaccus, who had before been consul and censor, had by lot the city jurisdiction; Marcus Valerius Laevinus, the foreign. Sicily fell to the lot of Appius Claudius Pulcher; Sardinia to Quintus Mucius Scaevola. The people ordered that Marcus Marcellus should be in command as proconsul, because he was the only Roman general who had been successful in his operations in Italy since the defeat at Cannae.

While these events were happening in Spain, Petilia, in Bruttium, was captured by Himilco, one of Hannibal's officers, several months after the siege began. This victory cost the Carthaginians a lot of blood and many injuries, and famine had an even greater impact on the besieged. After exhausting their food supplies from fruits and various meats, they were eventually forced to survive on scraps like leather found in shoemakers' shops, herbs, roots, tender tree bark, and berries picked from bushes. They finally surrendered when they were too weak to stand on the walls and fight back. After taking Petilia, the Carthaginian commander moved his troops to Consentia, which was less fiercely defended, and he forced it to surrender within a few days. Around the same time, an army of Bruttians laid siege to Croton, a once-powerful Greek city that had been greatly weakened by numerous disasters, leaving fewer than twenty thousand residents of all ages. The enemy easily took over a city that had no defenders, and only the citadel remained under siege, where some inhabitants fled during the chaos of the city's capture. The Locrians also switched sides, joining the Bruttians and Carthaginians after being betrayed by their leaders. The Rhegians were the only group in the area to remain loyal to the Romans and enjoy their independence. This shift in loyalty also spread to Sicily; even Hiero's family was not completely immune to defection. Gelo, his oldest son, dismissed his father's old age and the alliance with Rome following the defeat at Cannae, joining the Carthaginians. He would have caused significant unrest in Sicily if he had not unexpectedly died while trying to rally the people and seek support from allies, raising suspicions about his father's role in his death. These various events unfolded in Italy, Africa, Sicily, and Spain over the year. At the year's end, Quintus Fabius Maximus asked the senate for permission to dedicate the temple of Venus Erycina, which he had vowed to do when he was dictator. The senate decided that Tiberius Sempronius, the consul-elect, should propose to the people that they appoint Quintus Fabius as duumvir to dedicate the temple. In honor of Marcus Aemilius Lepidus, who had been consul twice and was an augur, his three sons—Lucius, Marcus, and Quintus—held funeral games and showcased twenty-two pairs of gladiators for three days in the forum. The curule aediles, Caius Laetorius and Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus, the consul-elect who had been master of the horse during his aedileship, organized the Roman games, which also lasted three days. The plebeian games organized by aediles Marcus Aurelius Cotta and Marcus Claudius Marcellus were held three times. By the end of the third year of the Punic War, Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus the consul took office on the Ides of March. Among the praetors, Quintus Fulvius Flaccus, who had previously been consul and censor, was assigned city jurisdiction; Marcus Valerius Laevinus was given foreign jurisdiction. Appius Claudius Pulcher received Sicily, while Sardinia went to Quintus Mucius Scaevola. The people decided that Marcus Marcellus should serve as proconsul since he was the only Roman general to achieve success in Italy since the defeat at Cannae.

31

The senate decreed, the first day they deliberated in the Capitol, that double taxes should be imposed for that year, one moiety of which should be immediately levied, as a fund from which pay might be given forthwith to all the soldiers, except those who had been at Cannae. With regard to the armies they decreed, that Tiberius Sempronius the consul should appoint a day for the two city legions to meet at Cales, whence these legions should be conveyed into the Claudian camp above Suenula. That the legions which were there, and they consisted principally of the troops which had fought at Cannae, Appius Claudius Pulcher, the praetor, should transport into Sicily; and that those in Sicily should be removed to Rome. Marcus Claudius Marcellus was sent to the army, which had been ordered to meet at Cales on a certain day, with orders to march the city legions thence to the Claudian camp. Titus Metilius Croto, lieutenant-general, was sent by Appius Claudius Pulcher to receive the old army and remove it into Sicily. People at first had expected in silence that the consul would hold an assembly for the election of a colleague, but afterwards perceiving that Marcus Marcellus, whom they wished above all others to be consul this year, on account of his brilliant success during his praetorship, was removed to a distant quarter, as it were on purpose, a murmuring arose in the senate-house, which the consul perceiving, said "Conscript fathers, it was conducive to the interest of the state, both that Marcus Marcellus should go into Campania to make the exchange of the armies, and that the assembly should not be proclaimed before he had returned thence after completing the business with which he was charged, in order that you might have him as consul whom the situation of the republic required and yourselves prefer." Thus nothing was said about the assembly till Marcellus returned. Meanwhile Quintus Fabius Maximus and Titus Otacilius Crassus were created duumvirs for dedicating temples, Otacilius to Mens, Fabius to Venus Erycina. Both are situated in the Capitol, and separated by one channel. It was afterwards proposed to the people, to make Roman citizens of the three hundred Campanian horsemen who had returned to Rome after having faithfully served their period, and also that they should be considered to have been citizens of Cumae from the day before that on which the Campanians had revolted from the Roman people. It had been a principal inducement to this proposition, that they themselves said they knew not to what people they belonged, having left their former country, and being not yet admitted into that to which they had returned. After Marcellus returned from the army, an assembly was proclaimed for electing one consul in the room of Lucius Posthumius. Marcellus was elected with the greatest unanimity, and was immediately to enter upon his office, but as it thundered while he entered upon it, the augurs were summoned, who pronounced that they considered the creation formal, and the fathers spread a report that the gods were displeased, because on that occasion, for the first time, two plebeians had been elected consuls. Upon Marcellus's abdicating his office, Fabius Maximus, for the third time, was elected in his room. This year the sea appeared on fire; at Sinuessa a cow brought forth a horse foal; the statues in the temple of Juno Sospita Lanuvium flowed down with blood; and a shower of stones fell in the neighbourhood of that temple: on account of which shower the nine days' sacred rite was celebrated, as is usual on such occasions, and the other prodigies were carefully expiated.

The Senate decided on the first day they met in the Capitol that double taxes would be imposed for that year, with one part to be collected immediately to provide pay right away to all soldiers, except those who had been at Cannae. Regarding the armies, they decided that Tiberius Sempronius, the consul, should set a date for the two city legions to gather at Cales, from where these legions would be sent to the Claudian camp above Suenula. The legions already there, mostly made up of troops from Cannae, would be transported into Sicily by Appius Claudius Pulcher, the praetor, while those in Sicily would be moved to Rome. Marcus Claudius Marcellus was sent to the army that was scheduled to meet at Cales on a certain day, with orders to march the city legions from there to the Claudian camp. Titus Metilius Croto, the lieutenant-general, was sent by Appius Claudius Pulcher to take the old army and move it to Sicily. Initially, people quietly expected that the consul would hold a meeting for the election of a colleague, but later, noticing that Marcus Marcellus, whom they most wanted to be consul this year due to his impressive success during his praetorship, was sent away to a distant place, murmurs arose in the Senatehouse. The consul, noticing this, said, "Conscript fathers, it is in the state's interest for Marcus Marcellus to go to Campania for the army exchange, and for the assembly not to be announced until he returns after finishing his mission, so that you can have as consul the person whom the situation of the Republic requires and whom you prefer." So, nothing was mentioned about the assembly until Marcellus returned. Meanwhile, Quintus Fabius Maximus and Titus Otacilius Crassus were appointed duumvirs to dedicate temples, with Otacilius dedicating to Mens and Fabius to Venus Erycina. Both temples are located in the Capitol and separated by one channel. It was later proposed to the people to grant Roman citizenship to the three hundred Campanian horsemen who had returned to Rome after serving their time faithfully and that they should also be recognized as citizens of Cumae from the day before the Campanians revolted against the Roman people. A significant reason for this proposal was that they stated they did not know which people they belonged to, having left their former country and not yet being accepted into the one they had returned to. After Marcellus came back from the army, an assembly was announced to elect one consul to replace Lucius Posthumius. Marcellus was elected with overwhelming support and was set to take office immediately; however, as he entered, there was thunder, prompting the augurs to be called, who deemed the election formal. The senators spread the word that the gods were displeased because, for the first time, two plebeians had been elected as consuls. After Marcellus stepped down from office, Fabius Maximus was elected in his place for the third time. That year, the sea appeared to be on fire; in Sinuessa, a cow gave birth to a horse foal; the statues in the temple of Juno Sospita in Lanuvium bled; and a rain of stones fell near that temple. Due to this shower, the nine-day sacred rite was performed as is customary in such cases, and the other ominous signs were carefully addressed.

32

The consuls divided the armies between them. The army which Marcus Junius the dictator had commanded fell to the lot of Fabius. To that of Sempronius fell the volunteer slaves, with twenty-five thousand of the allies. To Marcus Valerius the praetor were assigned the legions which had returned from Sicily. Marcus Claudius, proconsul, was sent to that army which lay above Suessula for the protection of Nola. The praetors set out for Sicily and Sardinia. The consuls issued a proclamation, that as often as they summoned a senate, the senators and those who had a right to give their opinion in the senate, should assemble at the Capuan gate. The praetors who were charged with the administration of justice, fixed their tribunals in the public fish market; there they ordered sureties to be entered into, and here justice was administered this year. Meanwhile news was brought to Carthage, from which place Mago, Hannibal's brother, was on the point of carrying over into Italy twelve thousand foot, fifteen hundred horse, twenty elephants, and a thousand talents of silver, under a convoy of sixty men of war, that the operations of the war had not succeeded in Spain, and that almost all the people in that province had gone over to the Romans. There were some who were for sending Mago with that fleet and those forces into Spain, neglecting Italy, when an unexpected prospect of regaining Sardinia broke upon them. They were informed, that "the Roman army there was small, that Aulus Cornelius, who had been praetor there, and was well acquainted with the province, was quitting it, and that a new one was expected. Moreover, that the minds of the Sardinians were now wearied with the long continuance of rule; and that during the last year it had been exercised with severity and rapacity. That the people were weighed down with heavy taxes, and an oppressive contribution of corn: that there was nothing wanting but a leader to whom they might revolt." This secret embassy had been sent by the nobles, Hampsicora being the chief contriver of the measure, who at that time was first by far in wealth and influence. Disconcerted and elated almost at the same time by these accounts, they sent Mago with his fleet and forces into Spain, and selecting Hasdrubal as general for Sardinia, assigned to him about as large a force as to Mago. At Rome, the consuls, after transacting what was necessary to be done in the city now prepared themselves for the war. Tiberius Sempronius appointed a day for his soldiers to assemble at Sinuessa; and Quintus Fabius also, having first consulted the senate, issued a proclamation, that all persons should convey corn from the fields into fortified towns, before the calends of June next ensuing: if any neglected to do so he would lay waste his lands, sell his slaves by auction, and burn his farm-houses. Not even the praetors, who were created for the purpose of administering justice, were allowed an exemption from military employments. It was resolved that Valerius the praetor should go into Apulia, to receive the army from Terentius, and that, when the legions from Sicily had arrived, he should employ them principally for the protection of that quarter. That the army of Terentius should be sent into Sicily, with some one of the lieutenant-generals. Twenty-five ships were given to Marcus Valerius, to protect the sea-coast between Brundusium and Tarentum. An equal number was given to Quintus Fulvius, the city praetor, to protect the coasts in the neighbourhood of the city. To Caius Terentius, the proconsul, it was given in charge to press soldiers in the Picenian territory, and to protect that part of the country; and Titus Otacilius Crassus, after he had dedicated the temple of Mens in the Capitol, was invested with command, and sent into Sicily to take the conduct of the fleet.

The consuls split the armies among themselves. The army that Marcus Junius, the dictator, had commanded was assigned to Fabius. Sempronius received the volunteer slaves along with twenty-five thousand allies. Marcus Valerius, the praetor, was given the legions returning from Sicily. Marcus Claudius, the proconsul, was sent to the army stationed above Suessula to protect Nola. The praetors headed for Sicily and Sardinia. The consuls announced that whenever they called a senate, the senators and those entitled to give their opinions should meet at the Capuan gate. The praetors tasked with administering justice set up their courts in the public fish market; there they ordered surety bonds to be filed, and justice was handled there this year. Meanwhile, news arrived in Carthage that Mago, Hannibal's brother, was about to transport twelve thousand foot soldiers, fifteen hundred cavalry, twenty elephants, and a thousand talents of silver to Italy, under the escort of sixty warships. They learned that the war efforts in Spain had not been successful and that almost all the inhabitants in that province had sided with the Romans. Some suggested sending Mago with that fleet and those forces to Spain instead of Italy, when they unexpectedly got the prospect of regaining Sardinia. They were informed that "the Roman army there was small, that Aulus Cornelius, the former praetor familiar with the province, was leaving, and a new one was expected. Moreover, the Sardinians were growing weary of the prolonged rule; and last year, it had been conducted with severity and greed. The people were burdened with heavy taxes and an oppressive grain contribution: all they lacked was a leader to whom they could revolt." This secret mission was launched by the nobles, with Hampsicora being the mastermind, who was then the wealthiest and most influential. Confused and excited simultaneously by these reports, they sent Mago with his fleet and forces to Spain and chose Hasdrubal as the general for Sardinia, assigning him about the same size force as Mago. In Rome, the consuls, after addressing necessary city affairs, prepared for war. Tiberius Sempronius set a date for his soldiers to gather at Sinuessa; Quintus Fabius also, after consulting the senate, announced that all individuals should move grain from the fields to fortified towns before the upcoming June. If anyone failed to do this, he would destroy their lands, auction off their slaves, and burn their farmhouses. Not even the praetors, who were established to administer justice, were exempt from military duties. It was decided that Valerius the praetor should head to Apulia to take over the army from Terentius, and upon the arrival of the legions from Sicily, he should primarily use them to protect that area. Terentius’s army was to be sent to Sicily with one of the lieutenant-generals. Twenty-five ships were assigned to Marcus Valerius to guard the coastline between Brundusium and Tarentum. The same number was given to Quintus Fulvius, the city praetor, to secure the coasts near the city. Caius Terentius, the proconsul, was tasked with recruiting soldiers in Picenian territory and safeguarding that part of the country. Titus Otacilius Crassus, after dedicating the temple of Mens in the Capitol, was given command and sent to Sicily to lead the fleet.

33

On this contest, between the two most powerful people in the world, all kings and nations had fixed their attention. Among them Philip, king of the Macedonians, regarded it with greater anxiety, in proportion as he was nearer to Italy, and because he was separated from it only by the Ionian Sea. When he first heard that Hannibal had crossed the Alps, as he was rejoiced that a war had arisen between the Romans and the Carthaginians, so while their strength was yet undetermined, he felt doubtful which he should rather wish to be victorious. But after the third battle had been fought and the third victory had been on the side of the Carthaginians, he inclined to fortune, and sent ambassadors to Hannibal. These, avoiding the harbours of Brundusium and Tarentum, because they were occupied by guards of Roman ships, landed at the temple of Juno Lacinia. Thence passing through Apulia, on their way to Capua, they fell in with the Roman troops stationed to protect the country, and were conveyed to Marcus Valerius Laevinus, the praetor, who lay encamped in the neighbourhood of Luceria. Here Xenophanes, who was at the head of the embassy, fearlessly stated, that he was sent by King Philip to conclude a treaty of alliance and friendship with the Roman people, and that he had commissions to the Roman consuls, senate, and people. The praetor, highly delighted with this new alliance with a distinguished potentate, amidst the desertions of her old allies, courteously entertained these enemies as guests, and furnished them with persons to accompany them carefully to point out the roads, and inform them what places, and what passes, the Romans or the enemy occupied. Xenophanes passing through the Roman troops came into Campania, whence, by the shortest way, he entered the camp of Hannibal, and concluded a treaty of alliance and friendship with him on the following terms: That "King Philip, with as large a fleet as he could, (and it was thought he could make one of two hundred ships,) should pass over into Italy, and lay waste the sea-coast, that he should carry on the war by land and sea with all his might; when the war was concluded, that all Italy, with the city of Rome itself, should be the property of the Carthaginians and Hannibal, and that all the booty should be given up to Hannibal. That when Italy was completely subdued they should sail into Greece, and carry on war with such nations as the king pleased. That the cities on the continent and the islands which border on Macedonia, should belong to Philip, and his dominions."

On this contest between the two most powerful leaders in the world, all kings and nations were focused on it. Among them, Philip, king of the Macedonians, watched with more anxiety, especially since he was closer to Italy and separated from it only by the Ionian Sea. When he first heard that Hannibal had crossed the Alps, he was pleased that a war had broken out between the Romans and the Carthaginians, but since their strength was still uncertain, he was unsure whom he wanted to win. However, after the third battle was fought and the Carthaginians claimed their third victory, he leaned toward fortune and sent ambassadors to Hannibal. These ambassadors, avoiding the harbors of Brundusium and Tarentum due to Roman naval patrols, landed at the temple of Juno Lacinia. From there, traveling through Apulia on their way to Capua, they encountered the Roman troops stationed to protect the area and were brought before Marcus Valerius Laevinus, the praetor, who had set up camp near Luceria. Here, Xenophanes, the leader of the delegation, boldly stated that he was sent by King Philip to form a treaty of alliance and friendship with the Roman people, and that he had commissions for the Roman consuls, senate, and people. The praetor, pleased with this new alliance with an important leader during the defection of her old allies, graciously hosted these ambassadors and provided them with guides to ensure they were safely directed along the roads, and to inform them of the locations held by Romans or the enemy. After passing through the Roman troops, Xenophanes reached Campania, and from there, by the quickest route, he entered Hannibal's camp to finalize a treaty of alliance and friendship with him based on the following terms: King Philip would send a fleet as large as he could muster (and it was thought he could arrange for two hundred ships), to cross into Italy and devastate the coastline, and he would wage war on both land and sea with all his strength. When the war concluded, all of Italy, including the city of Rome, would belong to the Carthaginians and Hannibal, and all the spoils of war would be handed over to Hannibal. Once Italy was fully conquered, they would sail into Greece and wage war against any nations the king chose. The cities on the mainland and the islands close to Macedonia would belong to Philip and his territories.

34

A treaty was concluded between the Carthaginian general and the ambassadors, upon nearly these terms; and Gisgo, Bostar, and Mago were sent as ambassadors with them to receive the ratification of the king in person. They arrived at the same place, near the temple of Juno Lacinia, where the vessel lay concealed in a creek. Setting out thence, when they had got into the open sea, they were descried by the Roman fleet, which was guarding the coasts of Calabria. Publius Valerius Flaccus having sent fly-boats to pursue and bring back the ship, the king's party at first attempted to fly; but afterwards, finding that they were overmatched in swiftness, they delivered themselves up to the Romans, and were brought to the commander of the fleet. Upon being asked by him who they were, whence they came, and whither they were going, Xenophanes, having once been pretty successful, made up a fictitious story and said, "that he was sent from Philip to the Romans; that he had succeeded in reaching Marcus Valerius, to whom alone he had safe access; that he was unable to make his way through Campania, which was beset with the troops of the enemy." But afterwards the Carthaginian dress and manners excited suspicions of the messengers of Hannibal, and when interrogated, their speech betrayed them; then on their companions being removed to separate places, and intimidated by threats, even a letter from Hannibal to Philip was discovered, and the agreement made between the king of the Macedonians and the Carthaginian. These points having been ascertained, the best course appeared to be, to convey the prisoners and their companions as soon as possible to the senate at Rome, or to the consuls, wheresoever they might be; for this service five of the fastest sailing vessels were selected, and Lucius Valerius Antias sent in command of them, with orders to distribute the ambassadors through all the ships separately, and take particular care that they should hold no conversation or consultation with each other. About the same time Aulus Cornelius Mammula, on his return from the province of Sardinia, made a report of the state of affairs in the island; that every body contemplated war and revolt; that Quintus Mucius who succeeded him, being on his arrival affected by the unwholesomeness of the air and water, had fallen into a disorder rather lingering than dangerous, and would for a long time be incapable of sustaining the violent exertion of the war; that the army there, though strong enough for the protection of a province in a state of tranquillity, was, nevertheless, not adequate to the maintenance of the war which seemed to be about to break out. Upon which the fathers decreed, that Quintus Fulvius Flaccus should enlist five thousand foot and four hundred horse, and take care that the legion thus formed should be transported as soon as possible into Sardinia, and send invested with command whomsoever he thought fit to conduct the business of the war until Mucius had recovered. For this service Titus Manlius Torquatus was sent; he had been twice consul and censor, and had subdued the Sardinians during his consulate. Nearly about the same time a fleet sent from Carthage to Sardinia under the conduct of Hasdrubal, surnamed the Bald, having suffered from a violent tempest, was driven upon the Balearian islands, where a good deal of time was lost in refitting the ships, which were hauled on shore, so much were they damaged, not only in their rigging but also in their hulls.

A treaty was made between the Carthaginian general and the ambassadors, on nearly these terms; and Gisgo, Bostar, and Mago were sent as ambassadors with them to get the king's approval in person. They reached the same place, near the temple of Juno Lacinia, where the ship was hidden in a creek. When they set out from there and got into the open sea, they were spotted by the Roman fleet, which was patrolling the coast of Calabria. Publius Valerius Flaccus sent fast ships to chase and bring back the vessel; at first, the king's crew tried to escape, but when they realized they couldn't outrun them, they surrendered to the Romans and were taken to the fleet's commander. When he asked them who they were, where they came from, and where they were headed, Xenophanes, having been somewhat successful before, made up a false story and said, "that he was sent from Philip to the Romans; that he managed to reach Marcus Valerius, to whom he had safe access; that he couldn’t pass through Campania, which was surrounded by enemy troops." However, the Carthaginian clothing and mannerisms raised suspicions that they were messengers from Hannibal, and when questioned, their speech gave them away; then, when their companions were taken to separate locations and intimidated with threats, a letter from Hannibal to Philip was discovered, along with the agreement made between the king of the Macedonians and the Carthaginian. Once these details were confirmed, the best move was to get the prisoners and their companions to the senate in Rome, or to the consuls, wherever they might be; for this task, five of the fastest ships were chosen, and Lucius Valerius Antias was sent to lead them, with orders to distribute the ambassadors among all the ships individually and ensure they couldn’t talk to each other. Around the same time, Aulus Cornelius Mammula, returning from Sardinia, reported on the situation on the island; he said that everyone was anticipating war and revolt; that Quintus Mucius, who succeeded him, was affected by the unhealthy air and water upon his arrival, and had fallen into a sickness that was more lingering than dangerous, which would keep him from handling the demanding work of the war for a long time; that the army there, while strong enough to protect a peaceful province, wasn’t capable of managing the war that seemed imminent. In response, the senate decided that Quintus Fulvius Flaccus should recruit five thousand infantry and four hundred cavalry, and ensure that this newly formed legion was transported to Sardinia as quickly as possible, and send whoever he thought fit to lead the war effort until Mucius recovered. For this mission, Titus Manlius Torquatus was selected; he had served as consul and censor twice and had defeated the Sardinians during his consulship. Almost at the same time, a fleet sent from Carthage to Sardinia under Hasdrubal, nicknamed the Bald, was caught in a fierce storm and was forced to land on the Balearic Islands, where a lot of time was wasted repairing the ships, which were pulled ashore due to significant damage, not just to their rigging but also to their hulls.

35

As the war was carried on in Italy with less vigour since the battle of Cannae, the strength of one party having been broken, and the energy of the other relaxed, the Campanians of themselves made an attempt to subjugate Cumae, at first by soliciting them to revolt from the Romans, and when that plan did not succeed, they contrived an artifice by which to entrap them. All the Campanians had a stated sacrifice at Hamae. They informed the Cumans that the Campanian senate would come there, and requested that the Cuman senate should also be present to deliberate in concert, in order that both people might have the same allies and the same enemies; they said that they would have an armed force there for their protection, that there might be no danger from the Romans or Carthaginians. The Cumans, although they suspected treachery, made no objection, concluding that thus the deception they meditated might be concealed. Meanwhile Tiberius Sempronius, the Roman consul, having purified his army at Sinuessa, where he had appointed a day for their meeting, crossed the Vulturnus, and pitched his camp in the neighbourhood of Liternum. As his troops were stationed here without any employment, he compelled them frequently to go through their exercise, that the recruits, which consisted principally of volunteer slaves, might accustom themselves to follow the standards, and know their own centuries in battle While thus engaged, the general was particularly anxious for concord, and therefore enjoined the lieutenant-generals and the tribunes that "no disunion should be engendered among the different orders, by casting reproaches on any one on account of his former condition. That the veteran soldier should be content be placed on an equal footing with the tiro, the free-man with the volunteer slave; that all should consider those men sufficiently respectable in point of character and birth, to whom the Roman people had intrusted their arms and standards; that the measures which circumstances made it necessary to adopt, the same circumstances also made it necessary to support when adopted." This was not more carefully prescribed by the generals than observed by the soldiers; and in a short time the minds of all were united in such perfect harmony, that the condition from which each became a soldier was almost forgotten. While Gracchus was thus employed, ambassadors from Cumas brought him information of the embassy which had come to them from the Campanians, a few days before, and the answer they had given them; that the festival would take place in three days from that time; that not only the whole body of their senate, but that the camp and the army of the Campanians would be there. Gracchus having directed the Cumans to convey every thing out of their fields into the town, and to remain within their walls, marched himself to Cumae, on the day before that on which the Campanians were to attend the sacrifice. Hamae was three miles distant from his position. The Campanians had by this time assembled there in great numbers according to the plan concerted; and not far off Marius Alfius, Medixtuticus, which is the name of the chief magistrate of the Campanians, lay encamped in a retired spot with fourteen thousand armed men, considerably more occupied in making preparation for the sacrifice and in concerting the stratagem to be executed during it, than in fortifying his camp or any other military work. The sacrifice at Hamae lasted for three days. It was a nocturnal rite, so arranged as to be completed before midnight. Gracchus, thinking this the proper time for executing his plot, placed guards at the gates to prevent any one from carrying out intelligence of his intentions; and having compelled his men to employ the time from the tenth hour in taking refreshment and sleep, in order that they might be able to assemble on a signal given as soon as it was dark. He ordered the standards to be raised about the first watch, and marching in silence, reached Hamae at midnight; where, finding the Campanian camp in a neglected state, as might be expected during a festival, he assaulted it at every gate at once; some he butchered while stretched on the ground asleep, others as they were returning unarmed after finishing the sacrifice. In the tumultuous action of this night more than two thousand men were slain, together with the general himself, Marius Alfius, and thirty-four military standards were captured.

As the war continued in Italy with less intensity since the battle of Cannae, the strength of one side was weakened and the energy of the other had faded. The Campanians decided to try to conquer Cumae, initially by encouraging them to rebel against the Romans. When that didn’t work, they came up with a trick to trap them. All the Campanians had a scheduled sacrifice at Hamae. They informed the Cumans that the Campanian senate would be there and requested that the Cuman senate also attend to discuss matters together, so both groups would have the same allies and enemies. They claimed they would have armed forces there for protection, ensuring there would be no threat from the Romans or Carthaginians. The Cumans, though suspicious of a trap, did not object, thinking it would help conceal the deception. Meanwhile, Tiberius Sempronius, the Roman consul, had purified his army at Sinuessa, where he had set a meeting date. He crossed the Vulturnus and set up camp near Liternum. With his troops idle, he forced them to drill frequently so that the recruits, mostly former slave volunteers, would get used to following the standards and know their units in battle. While doing this, the general was particularly focused on unity, instructing the lieutenant-generals and tribunes that “no division should arise among the different ranks by blaming anyone for their past status. Veterans should be treated equally with new soldiers, freed men with volunteer slaves; everyone should respect those to whom the Roman people entrusted their arms and standards. The measures that circumstances necessitated should also be supported.” This directive was carefully followed by the generals and observed by the soldiers, and soon everyone was united in such harmony that it was nearly forgotten from what status each had become a soldier. While Gracchus was engaged in this, ambassadors from Cumae informed him about the Campanian embassy that had visited them a few days earlier and the response they had given; that the festival would happen in three days, and that not only the entire senate, but also the Campanian army would attend. Gracchus instructed the Cumans to bring everything from their fields into the town and to stay within their walls. He made his way to Cumae on the day before the Campanians were to attend the sacrifice. Hamae was three miles from his position. By this time, the Campanians had gathered in large numbers according to their plan, and nearby, Marius Alfius, the chief magistrate of the Campanians, was camped with fourteen thousand armed men, more focused on preparing for the sacrifice and plotting their strategy than fortifying their camp or any military tasks. The sacrifice at Hamae lasted three days and involved a night ceremony, designed to finish before midnight. Gracchus, believing this was the right moment to execute his plan, stationed guards at the gates to stop anyone from revealing his intentions. He had his men rest and sleep from the tenth hour so they could assemble quietly at night. He ordered the standards to be raised during the first watch and moved silently towards Hamae, arriving at midnight. There, finding the Campanian camp in disarray, as expected during a festival, he attacked at every gate at once; some were slaughtered in their sleep, others were caught unarmed as they returned from the sacrifice. In the chaos of the night, over two thousand men were killed, including their general Marius Alfius, and thirty-four military standards were captured.

36

Gracchus, having made himself master of the enemy's camp with the loss of less than a hundred men, hastily returned to Cumae, fearful of an attack from Hannibal, who lay encamped above Capua on Tifata; nor did his provident anticipation of the future deceive him; for as soon as intelligence was brought to Capua of this loss, Hannibal, concluding that he should find at Hamae this army, which consisted for the most part of recruits and slaves, extravagantly elated with its success, despoiling the vanquished and collecting booty, marched by Capua at a rapid pace, ordering those Campanians whom he met in their flight to be conducted to Capua under an escort, and the wounded to be conveyed in carriages. He found at Hamae the camp abandoned by the enemy, where there was nothing to be seen but the traces of the recent carnage, and the bodies of his allies strewed in every part. Some advised him to lead his troops immediately thence to Cumae, and assault the town. Though Hannibal desired, in no ordinary degree, to get possession of Cumae at least, as a maritime town, since he could not gain Neapolis; yet as his soldiers had brought out with them nothing besides their arms on their hasty march, he retired to his camp on Tifata. But, wearied with the entreaties of the Campanians, he returned thence to Cumae the following day, with every thing requisite for besieging the town; and having thoroughly wasted the lands of Cumae, pitched, his camp a mile from the town, in which Gracchus had stayed more because he was ashamed to abandon, in such an emergency, allies who implored his protection and that of the Roman people, than because he felt confidence in his army. Nor dared the other consul, Fabius, who was encamped at Cales, lead his troops across the Vulturnus, being employed at first in taking new auspices, and afterwards with the prodigies which were reported one after another; and while expiating these, the aruspices answered that they were not easily atoned.

Gracchus, having taken control of the enemy's camp with fewer than a hundred casualties, quickly returned to Cumae, worried about a possible attack from Hannibal, who was camped above Capua on Tifata. His concerns proved valid; as soon as news of this defeat reached Capua, Hannibal, thinking he would find the army at Cumae—mostly made up of recruits and slaves—who were overly confident after their success, looting the defeated and gathering spoils, marched quickly past Capua. He ordered the fleeing Campanians he encountered to be escorted back to Capua and arranged for the wounded to be transported in carts. Upon reaching Cumae, he found the enemy's camp abandoned, with nothing left but the signs of recent slaughter and the bodies of his allies scattered everywhere. Some suggested he should take his troops directly to Cumae and attack the city. Hannibal greatly wanted to capture Cumae, as it was a coastal town, especially since he couldn't take Neapolis. However, since his soldiers had only brought their weapons during their hasty retreat, he went back to his camp on Tifata. Yet, after being worn down by the pleas from the Campanians, he returned to Cumae the next day, equipped with everything needed for a siege. After thoroughly ravaging the lands around Cumae, he set up his camp a mile from the town, where Gracchus had remained more out of embarrassment to abandon allies pleading for his protection and the Roman people's help than from confidence in his troops. The other consul, Fabius, who was stationed at Cales, did not dare lead his forces across the Vulturnus because he was first engaged in taking new omens, and later, dealing with the repeated prodigies being reported. While he performed the necessary rituals to soothe the gods, the soothsayers advised that these disturbances wouldn’t be easily resolved.

37

While these causes detained Fabius, Sempronius was besieged, and now works were employed in the attack. Against a very large wooden tower which was brought up to the town, the Roman consul raised up another considerably higher from the wall itself; for he had made use of the wall, which was pretty high of itself, as a platform, placing strong piles as supports. From this the besieged at first defended their walls and city, with stones, javelins, and other missiles; but lastly, when they perceived the tower advanced into contact with the wall they threw upon it a large quantity of fire, making use of blazing fire-brands; and while the armed men were throwing themselves down from the tower in great numbers, in consequence of the flames thus occasioned, the troops sallying out of the town at two gates at once, routed the enemy, and drove them back to their camp; so that the Carthaginians that day were more like persons besieged than besiegers. As many as one thousand three hundred of the Carthaginians were slain, and fifty-nine made prisoners, having been unexpectedly overpowered, while standing careless and unconcerned near the walls and on the outposts, fearing any thing rather than a sally. Gracchus sounded a retreat, and withdrew his men within the walls, before the enemy could recover themselves from the effects of this sudden terror. The next day Hannibal, supposing that the consul, elated with his success, would engage him in a regular battle, drew up his troops in battle-array between the camp and the city; but finding that not a man was removed from the customary guard of the town, and that nothing was hazarded upon rash hopes, he returned to Tifata without accomplishing any thing. At the same time that Cumae was relieved from siege, Tiberius Sempronius, surnamed Longus, fought successfully with the Carthaginian general, Hanno, at Grumentum in Lucania. He slew above two thousand of the enemy, losing two hundred and eighty of his own men. He took as many as forty-one military standards. Hanno, driven out of the Lucanian territory, drew back among the Bruttii. Three towns belonging to the Hirpinians, which had revolted from the Romans, were regained by force by the praetor, Marcus Valerius, Vercellius and Sicilius, the authors of the revolt, were beheaded; above a thousand prisoners sold by auction; and the rest of the booty having been given up to the soldiery, the army was marched back to Luceria.

While these issues held Fabius back, Sempronius was under siege, and efforts were now focused on the attack. Against a very tall wooden tower that was brought up to the town, the Roman consul built another tower that was even higher from the wall itself; he utilized the wall, which was already quite tall, as a platform, adding strong supports. Initially, the defenders used stones, javelins, and other missiles from this vantage point to protect their walls and city. However, when they saw that the tower had moved into contact with the wall, they unleashed a large amount of fire upon it, using blazing torches. As soldiers began jumping down from the tower in large numbers due to the flames, troops rushed out of the town through two gates simultaneously, defeating the enemy and pushing them back to their camp; that day, the Carthaginians were more like besieged individuals than besiegers. Around one thousand three hundred Carthaginians were killed, and fifty-nine were taken prisoner, caught off guard while they were standing relaxed and unsuspecting near the walls and on the outposts, fearing anything but a sudden attack. Gracchus called for a retreat and pulled his men back within the walls before the enemy could recover from this sudden horror. The next day, Hannibal, thinking the consul would want to fight him after his recent victory, positioned his troops for battle between the camp and the city. But when he noticed that no one had left the ordinary guard of the town and nothing was being risked on reckless hopes, he returned to Tifata without achieving anything. At the same time that Cumae was relieved from the siege, Tiberius Sempronius, nicknamed Longus, successfully fought the Carthaginian general Hanno at Grumentum in Lucania. He killed over two thousand of the enemy while losing two hundred and eighty of his own men, capturing forty-one military standards. Hanno, forced out of Lucanian territory, withdrew into Bruttii. The praetor, Marcus Valerius, recaptured three towns belonging to the Hirpinians that had revolted against the Romans; the instigators of the revolt, Vercellius and Sicilius, were executed; over a thousand prisoners were sold at auction; and the remaining spoils were given to the soldiers as the army made its way back to Luceria.

38

While these things were taking place in Lucania and Hirpinia, the five ships, which were conveying to Rome the captured ambassadors of the Macedonians and Carthaginians, after passing round the whole coast of Italy from the upper to the lower sea, were sailing by Cumae, when, it not being known whether they belonged to enemies or allies, Gracchus despatched some ships from his fleet to meet them. When it was ascertained, in the course of their mutual inquiries that the consul was at Cumae, the ships put in there, the captives were brought before the consul, and their letters placed in his hands. The consul, after he had read the letters of Philip and Hannibal, sent them all, sealed up, to the senate by land, ordering that the ambassadors should be conveyed thither by sea. The ambassadors and the letters arriving at Rome nearly on the same day, and on examination the answers of the ambassadors corresponding with the contents of the letters, at first intense anxiety oppressed the fathers, on seeing what a formidable war with Macedonia threatened them, when with difficulty bearing up against the Punic war; yet so far were they from sinking under their calamities, that they immediately began to consider how they might divert the enemy from Italy, by commencing hostilities themselves. After ordering the prisoners to be confined in chains, and selling their attendants by public auction, they decreed, that twenty more ships should be got ready, in addition to the twenty-five ships which Publius Valerius Flaccus had been appointed to command. These being provided and launched, and augmented by the five ships which had conveyed the captive ambassadors to Rome, a fleet of fifty ships set sail from Ostia to Tarentum. Publius Valerius was ordered to put on board the soldiers of Varro, which Lucius Apustius, lieutenant-general, commanded at Tarentum; and, with this fleet of fifty ships, not only to protect the coast of Italy, but also to make inquiry respecting the Macedonian war. If the plans of Philip corresponded with his letter, and the discoveries made by his ambassadors, he was directed to acquaint the praetor, Marcus Valerius, with it, who, leaving Lucius Apustius, lieutenant-general, in command of the army, and going to Tarentum to the fleet, was to cross over to Macedonia with all speed, and endeavour to detain Philip in his own dominions. The money which had been sent into Sicily to Appius Claudius, to be repaid to Hiero, was assigned for the support of the fleet and the maintenance of the Macedonian war. This money was conveyed to Tarentum, by Lucius Apustius, lieutenant-general, and with it Hiero sent two hundred thousand pecks of wheat, and a hundred thousand of barley.

While all this was happening in Lucania and Hirpinia, the five ships carrying the captured ambassadors of the Macedonians and Carthaginians were making their way to Rome. After sailing along the entire coast of Italy from the upper to the lower sea, they were passing by Cumae, and it was unclear whether they were from enemies or allies, so Gracchus sent some ships from his fleet to intercept them. Once they figured out through mutual inquiries that the consul was at Cumae, the ships docked there, and the captives were brought before the consul along with their letters. After reading the letters from Philip and Hannibal, the consul sent everything, sealed, to the senate by land, instructing that the ambassadors be transported there by sea. The ambassadors and the letters arrived in Rome almost on the same day, and upon review, the responses of the ambassadors matched the contents of the letters. Initially, the senate was filled with intense anxiety at the prospect of a serious war with Macedonia, especially while still struggling against the Punic war. However, rather than succumbing to their troubles, they immediately started planning how to distract the enemy from Italy by initiating hostilities themselves. After ordering the prisoners to be chained and selling their attendants at auction, they decided to prepare twenty additional ships, adding to the twenty-five ships that Publius Valerius Flaccus was set to command. With these ready and launched, plus the five ships that had brought the captive ambassadors to Rome, a fleet of fifty ships set sail from Ostia to Tarentum. Publius Valerius was instructed to board the troops commanded by Lucius Apustius, the lieutenant-general, at Tarentum, and with this fleet of fifty ships, he was tasked not only with protecting the coast of Italy but also with gathering intelligence on the Macedonian war. If Philip’s plans aligned with his letter and the findings from his ambassadors, he was to inform the praetor, Marcus Valerius, who would leave Lucius Apustius in charge of the army and hurry to the fleet at Tarentum to cross over to Macedonia as quickly as possible, attempting to keep Philip occupied in his own territory. The funds that had been sent to Appius Claudius in Sicily to be repaid to Hiero were allocated for the fleet's support and the expenses of the Macedonian war. This money was taken to Tarentum by Lucius Apustius, along with two hundred thousand pecks of wheat and one hundred thousand of barley sent by Hiero.

39

While the Romans were engaged in these preparations and transactions, the captured ship, which formed one of those which had been sent to Rome, made its escape on the voyage and returned to Philip; from which source it became known that the ambassadors with their letters had been made prisoners. Not knowing, therefore, what had been agreed upon between Hannibal and his ambassadors, or what proposals they were to have brought back to him, he sent another embassy with the same instructions. The ambassadors sent to Hannibal were Heraclitus, surnamed Scotinus, Crito of Beraea, and Sositheus of Magnesia; these successfully took and brought back their commissions, but the summer had passed before the king could take any step or make any attempt. Such an influence had the capture of one vessel, together with the ambassadors, in deferring a war which threatened the Romans. Fabius crossed the Vulturnus, after having at length expiated the prodigies, and both the consuls prosecuted the war in the neighbourhood of Capua. Fabius regained by force the towns Compulteria, Trebula, and Saticula, which had revolted to the Carthaginians; and in them were captured the garrisons of Hannibal and a great number of Campanians. At Nola, as had been the case the preceding year, the senate sided with the Romans, the commons with Hannibal; and deliberations were held clandestinely on the subject of massacring the nobles and betraying the city; but to prevent their succeeding in their designs, Fabius marched his army between Capua and the camp of Hannibal on Tifata, and sat down in the Claudian camp above Suessula, whence he sent Marcus Marcellus, the proconsul, with those forces which he had under him, to Nola for its protection.

While the Romans were busy with these preparations and dealings, the captured ship, which was one of those sent to Rome, managed to escape on its journey and returned to Philip. This led to the news that the ambassadors with their letters had been taken prisoner. Not knowing what had been agreed upon between Hannibal and his ambassadors or what proposals they were supposed to bring back to him, he sent another group of envoys with the same instructions. The ambassadors sent to Hannibal were Heraclitus, nicknamed Scotinus, Crito of Beraea, and Sositheus of Magnesia; they successfully completed their missions and brought back their messages, but the summer had passed before the king could take any action or make any attempt. The capture of one ship, along with the ambassadors, significantly delayed a war that threatened the Romans. Fabius crossed the Vulturnus after finally appeasing the omens, and both consuls continued the war near Capua. Fabius forcibly regained the towns of Compulteria, Trebula, and Saticula, which had defected to the Carthaginians; in those towns, they captured the garrisons of Hannibal and many Campanians. At Nola, as in the previous year, the senate sided with the Romans, while the common people supported Hannibal; secret discussions were held about massacring the nobles and betraying the city. To thwart these plans, Fabius marched his army between Capua and Hannibal’s camp at Tifata, setting up in the Claudian camp above Suessula, from where he sent Marcus Marcellus, the proconsul, with his available forces to protect Nola.

40

In Sardinia also the operations of the war, which had been intermitted from the time that Quintus Mucius, the praetor, had been seized with a serious illness, began to be conducted by Titus Manlius, the praetor. Having hauled the ships of war on shore at Carale, and armed his mariners, in order that he might prosecute the war by land, and received the army from the praetor, he made up the number of twenty-two thousand foot and twelve hundred horse. Setting out for the territory of the enemy with these forces of foot and horse, he pitched his camp not far from the camp of Hamsicora. It happened that Hampsicora was then gone among the Sardinians, called Pelliti, in order to arm their youth, whereby he might augment his forces. His son, named Hiostus, had the command of the camp, who coming to an engagement, with the presumption of youth, was routed and put to flight. In that battle as many as three thousand of the Sardinians were slain, and about eight hundred taken alive. The rest of the army at first wandered in their flight through the fields and woods, but afterwards all fled to a city named Cornus, the capital of that district, whither there was a report that their general had fled; and the war in Sardinia would have been brought to a termination by that battle, had not the Carthaginian fleet under the command of Hasdrubal, which had been driven by a storm upon the Balearian islands, come in seasonably for inspiring a hope of renewing the war. Manlius, after hearing of the arrival of the Punic fleet, returned to Carale, which afforded Hampsicora an opportunity of forming a junction with the Carthaginian. Hasdrubal, having landed his forces and sent back his fleet to Carthage, set out under the guidance of Hampsicora, to lay waste the lands of the allies of the Romans; and he would have proceeded to Carale, had not Manlius, meeting him with his army, restrained him from this wide-spread depredation. At first their camps were pitched opposite to each other, at a small distance; afterwards skirmishes and slight encounters took place with varying success; lastly, they came down into the field and fought a regular pitched battle for four hours. The Carthaginians caused the battle to continue long doubtful, for the Sardinians were accustomed to yield easily; but at last, when the Sardinians fell and fled on all sides around them, the Carthaginians themselves were routed. But as they were turning their backs, the Roman general, wheeling round that wing with which he had driven back the Sardinians, intercepted them, after which it was rather a carnage than a battle. Two thousand of the enemy, Sardinians and Carthaginians together, were slain, about three thousand seven hundred captured, with twenty-seven military standards.

In Sardinia, the war operations that had been on hold since Quintus Mucius, the praetor, fell seriously ill, resumed under Titus Manlius, the new praetor. He brought the warships ashore at Carale, armed his sailors to fight on land, and, after receiving the army from the praetor, gathered a total of twenty-two thousand infantry and twelve hundred cavalry. He marched towards enemy territory and set up camp not far from Hampsicora's camp. At that time, Hampsicora was with a group of Sardinians called the Pelliti, trying to recruit young fighters to strengthen his forces. His son, Hiostus, was in charge of the camp and, in his youthful confidence, engaged in battle, but was defeated and forced to retreat. During that battle, about three thousand Sardinians were killed and around eight hundred captured. The rest of the army initially scattered in their flight through fields and forests, eventually all fleeing to a city called Cornus, which was the capital of that area, where they believed their general had taken refuge. The war in Sardinia might have ended with that battle if not for the Carthaginian fleet led by Hasdrubal, which had been blown off course by a storm to the Balearic Islands but arrived just in time to spark hope of continuing the fight. After learning of the Punic fleet's arrival, Manlius returned to Carale, giving Hampsicora the chance to ally with the Carthaginians. After Hasdrubal landed his troops and sent his fleet back to Carthage, he set out with Hampsicora to raid the lands of the Roman allies; he would have advanced to Carale if Manlius, meeting him with his army, hadn't stopped him from widespread destruction. Initially, their camps were set up close to each other; later, skirmishes broke out with mixed success. Finally, they engaged in a full battle that lasted for four hours. The Carthaginians kept the battle in suspense, as the Sardinians typically surrendered easily; however, eventually, as the Sardinians fell and scattered, the Carthaginians were themselves routed. As they retreated, the Roman general maneuvered around the wing that had pushed back the Sardinians and cut them off, turning the situation into more of a slaughter than an actual battle. Two thousand enemy combatants, both Sardinians and Carthaginians, were killed, and about three thousand seven hundred were captured, along with twenty-seven military standards.

41

Above all, the general, Hasdrubal, and two other noble Carthaginians having been made prisoners, rendered the battle glorious and memorable; Mago, who was of the Barcine family, and nearly related to Hannibal, and Hanno, the author of the revolt of the Sardinians, and without doubt the instigator of this war. Nor less did the Sardinian generals render that battle distinguished by their disasters; for not only was Hiostus, son of Hampsicora, slain in the battle, but Hampsicora himself flying with a few horse, having heard of the death of his son in addition to his unfortunate state, committed suicide by night, lest the interference of any person should prevent the accomplishment of his design. To the other fugitives the city of Cornus afforded a refuge, as it had done before; but Manlius, having assaulted it with his victorious troops, regained it in a few days. Then other cities also which had gone over to Hampsicora and the Carthaginians, surrendered themselves and gave hostages, on which having imposed a contribution of money and corn, proportioned to the means and delinquency of each, he led back his troops to Carale. There launching his ships of war, and putting the soldiers he had brought with him on board, he sailed to Rome, reported to the fathers the total subjugation of Sardinia, and handed over the contribution of money to the quaestors, of corn to the aediles, and the prisoners to the praetor Fulvius. During the same time, as Titus Otacilius the praetor, who had sailed over with a fleet of fifty ships from Lilybaeum to Africa, and laid waste the Carthaginian territory, was returning thence to Sardinia, to which place it was reported that Hasdrubal had recently crossed over from the Baleares, he fell in with his fleet on its return to Africa; and after a slight engagement in the open sea, captured seven ships with their crews. Fear dispersed the rest far and wide, not less effectually than a storm. It happened also, at the same time, that Bomilcar arrived at Locri with soldiers sent from Carthage as a reinforcement, bringing with him also elephants and provisions. In order to surprise and overpower him, Appius Claudius, having hastily led his troops to Messana, under pretext of making the circuit of the province, crossed over to Locri, the tide being favourable. Bomilcar had by this time left the place, having set out for Bruttium to join Hanno. The Locrians closed their gates against the Romans, and Appius Claudius returned to Rome without achieving any thing, by his strenuous efforts. The same summer Marcellus made frequent excursions from Nola, which he was occupying with a garrison, into the lands of the Hirpini and Caudine Samnites, and so destroyed all before him with fire and sword, that he renewed in Samnium the memory of her ancient disasters.

Above all, the general, Hasdrubal, and two other noble Carthaginians were captured, making the battle glorious and unforgettable; Mago, from the Barcine family and closely related to Hannibal, and Hanno, who sparked the revolt of the Sardinians and was clearly the instigator of this war. The Sardinian generals also made the battle notable for their losses; not only was Hiostus, the son of Hampsicora, killed in the fight, but Hampsicora himself, fleeing with a few horsemen, learned of his son's death and, overwhelmed by his unfortunate situation, committed suicide at night to ensure no one would stop him. The city of Cornus provided refuge to the other fugitives, as it had previously, but Manlius, attacking it with his victorious troops, recaptured it in just a few days. Other cities that had allied with Hampsicora and the Carthaginians also surrendered, offering hostages. Manlius then imposed a financial and grain contribution based on each city’s ability and wrongdoing, before leading his troops back to Carale. There, he launched his warships, boarded the soldiers he had brought back, and sailed to Rome, where he reported the total conquest of Sardinia to the Senate and delivered the monetary contributions to the quaestors, the grain to the aediles, and the prisoners to the praetor Fulvius. At the same time, praetor Titus Otacilius, who had sailed over with a fleet of fifty ships from Lilybaeum to Africa and ravaged the Carthaginian territory, was returning to Sardinia, where it was reported that Hasdrubal had recently come over from the Baleares. He encountered Otacilius's fleet on its way back to Africa, and after a brief skirmish at sea, captured seven ships and their crews. Fear spread among the remaining ships as effectively as a storm. Simultaneously, Bomilcar arrived at Locri with soldiers sent from Carthage as reinforcements, along with elephants and supplies. To try to catch him off guard, Appius Claudius quickly led his troops to Messana, pretending to tour the province, then crossed over to Locri when the tide was in his favor. By that time, Bomilcar had already left for Bruttium to join Hanno. The Locrians shut their gates against the Romans, and Appius Claudius returned to Rome without achieving anything despite his best efforts. That same summer, Marcellus frequently raided from Nola, where he was stationed with a garrison, into the territories of the Hirpini and Caudine Samnites, devastating everything in his path with fire and sword, reminding Samnium of her ancient disasters.

42

Ambassadors were therefore despatched from both nations at the same time to Hannibal, who thus addressed the Carthaginian: "Hannibal, we carried on hostilities with the Roman people, by ourselves and from our own resources, as long as our own arms and our own strength could protect us. Our confidence in these failing, we attached ourselves to king Pyrrhus. Abandoned by him, we accepted of a peace, dictated by necessity, which we continued to observe up to the period when you arrived in Italy, through a period of almost fifty years. Your valour and good fortune, not more than your unexampled humanity and kindness displayed towards our countrymen, whom, when made prisoners, you restored to us, so attached us to you, that while you our friend were in health and safety, we not only feared not the Romans, but not even the anger of the gods, if it were lawful so to express ourselves. And yet, by Hercules, you not only being in safety and victorious, but on the spot, (when you could almost hear the shrieks of our wives and children, and see our buildings in flames,) we have suffered, during this summer, such repeated devastations, that Marcellus, and not Hannibal, would appear to have been the conqueror at Cannae; while the Romans boast that you had strength only to inflict a single blow; and having as it were left your sting, now lie torpid. For near a century we waged war with the Romans, unaided by any foreign general or army; except that for two years Pyrrhus rather augmented his own strength by the addition of our troops, than defended us by his. I will not boast of our successes, that two consuls and two consular armies were sent under the yoke by us, nor of any other joyful and glorious events which have happened to us. We can tell of the difficulties and distresses we then experienced, with less indignation than those which are now occurring. Dictators, those officers of high authority, with their masters of horse, two consuls with two consular armies, entered our borders, and, after having reconnoitred and posted reserves, led on their troops in regular array to devastate our country. Now we are the prey of a single propraetor, and of one little garrison, for the defence of Nola. Now they do not even confine themselves to plundering in companies, but, like marauders, range through our country from one end to the other, more unconcernedly than if they were rambling through the Roman territory. And the reason is this, you do not protect us yourself, and the whole of our youth, which, if at home, would keep us in safety, is serving under your banners. We know nothing either of you or your army, but we know that it would be easy for the man who has routed and dispersed so many Roman armies, to put down these rambling freebooters of ours, who roam about in disorder to whatsoever quarter the hope of booty, however groundless, attracts them. They indeed will be the prey of a few Numidians, and a garrison sent to us will also dislodge that at Nola, provided you do not think those men undeserving that you should protect them as allies, whom you have esteemed worthy of your alliance."

Ambassadors were sent from both nations at the same time to Hannibal, who addressed the Carthaginian: "Hannibal, we fought against the Romans using our own strength and resources for as long as we could defend ourselves. When our confidence started to wane, we allied with King Pyrrhus. After being abandoned by him, we accepted a peace treaty out of necessity, which we followed for almost fifty years, up until you arrived in Italy. Your bravery and good fortune, along with your exceptional humanity and kindness shown to our people, restoring our captured comrades, made us so loyal to you that while you were our friend, healthy and safe, we not only feared the Romans but even the wrath of the gods, if that's an acceptable way to put it. Yet, by Hercules, not only are you safe and victorious, but right here (while you could almost hear our wives and children screaming and see our buildings burning), we have suffered such repeated devastation this summer that it seems Marcellus, not Hannibal, was the victor at Cannae; while the Romans bragged that you had power only to make one move, and now lie dormant after leaving your sting behind. For nearly a century we waged war against the Romans, without any help from foreign generals or armies, except for two years when Pyrrhus added our troops to his forces rather than defending us. I won’t brag about our victories, like sending two consuls and two consular armies under the yoke or any other joyous and glorious events we had. We can recount our struggles and hardships back then with less indignation than what we are currently facing. Dictators, high-ranking officers, with their cavalry commanders, two consuls, and two consular armies entered our lands, scouted, set up reserves, and led their troops in formation to ravage our country. Now we are at the mercy of a single propraetor and a small garrison to defend Nola. They don’t even limit themselves to looting in groups; they raid our land from end to end, more casually than if they were wandering through Roman territory. And the reason for this is that you do not protect us yourself, and all our young people, who could defend us if they were home, are serving under your banners. We know nothing about you or your army, but it’s clear that the man who has defeated and scattered so many Roman armies could easily handle these roaming marauders of ours, who wander aimlessly wherever the promise of plunder, however false, draws them. They will surely fall prey to a few Numidians, and a garrison sent to us will also drive out the one at Nola, as long as you don’t think those men are unworthy of your protection as allies, whom you have deemed deserving of your alliance."

43

To this Hannibal replied, "that the Hirpini and Samnites did every thing at once: that they both represented their sufferings, solicited succours, and complained that they were undefended and neglected. Whereas, they ought first to have represented their sufferings, then to have solicited succours; and lastly, if those succours were not obtained, then, at length, to make complaint that assistance had been implored without effect. That he would lead his troops not into the fields of the Hirpini and Samnites, lest he too should be a burthen to them, but into the parts immediately contiguous, and belonging to the allies of the Roman people, by plundering which, he would enrich his own soldiers, and cause the enemy to retire from them through fear. With regard to the Roman war, if the battle of Trasimenus was more glorious than that at Trebia, and the battle of Cannae than that of Trasimenus, that he would eclipse the fame of the battle of Cannae by a greater and more brilliant victory." With this answer, and with munificent presents, he dismissed the ambassadors. Having left a pretty large garrison in Tifata, he set out with the rest of his troops to go to Nola. Thither came Hanno from the Bruttii with recruits and elephants brought from Carthage. Having encamped not far from the place, every thing, upon examination, was found to be widely different from what he had heard from the ambassadors of the allies. For Marcellus was doing nothing, in such a way that he could be said to have committed himself rashly either to fortune or to the enemy. He had gone out on plundering expeditions, having previously reconnoitred, planted strong guards, and secured a retreat; the same caution was observed and the same provisions made, as if Hannibal were present. At this time, when he perceived the enemy on the approach, he kept his forces within the walls, ordered the senators of Nola to patrol the walls, and explore on all hands what was doing among the enemy. Of these Herennius Bassus and Herius Petrius, having been invited by Hanno, who had come up to the wall, to a conference, and gone out with the permission of Marcellus, were thus addressed by him, through an interpreter. After extolling the valour and good fortune of Hannibal, and vilifying the majesty of the Roman people, which he represented as sinking into decrepitude with their strength; he said, "but though they were on an equality in these respects, as once perhaps they were, yet they who had experienced how oppressive the government of Rome was towards its allies, and how great the clemency of Hannibal, even towards all his prisoners of the Italian name, were bound to prefer the friendship and alliance of the Carthaginians to those of the Romans." If both the consuls with their armies were at Nola, still they would no more be a match for Hannibal than they had been at Cannae, much less would one praetor with a few raw soldiers be able to defend it. It was a question which concerned themselves more than Hannibal whether he should take possession of Nola as captured or surrendered, for that he would certainly make himself master of it, as he had done with regard to Capua and Nuceria, and what difference there was between the fate of Capua and Nuceria, the Nolans themselves, situated as they were nearly midway between them, were well aware. He said he was unwilling to presage the evils which would result to the city if taken by force, but would in preference pledge himself that if they would deliver up Nola, together with Marcellus and his garrison, no other person than themselves should dictate the conditions on which they should come into the friendship and alliance of Hannibal.

To this, Hannibal replied, "The Hirpini and Samnites are doing everything all at once: they’re showing their suffering, asking for help, and complaining about being unprotected and ignored. They should have first explained their suffering, then asked for help, and finally, if they didn’t receive it, complained that they had appealed in vain. I plan to lead my troops not into the lands of the Hirpini and Samnites, so I don’t become a burden to them, but into the areas right next to them, which belong to the allies of the Roman people. By plundering these areas, I’ll supply my soldiers and scare the enemy away. Regarding the Roman war, if the battle of Trasimenus was more glorious than the one at Trebia, and the battle of Cannae eclipsed Trasimenus, I aim to surpass Cannae with an even greater and more spectacular victory." With this response and generous gifts, he sent the ambassadors away. After assigning a sizable garrison in Tifata, he set out with the rest of his troops to Nola. Hanno arrived from the Bruttii with reinforcements and elephants brought from Carthage. After setting up camp nearby, everything was found to be very different from what he had been told by the allied ambassadors. Marcellus was doing nothing, so it could be said he had recklessly committed himself to luck or the enemy. He had gone out on looting missions after scouting the area, setting up strong guards, and ensuring a safe retreat; he took the same precautions as if Hannibal were right there. At this moment, when he noticed the enemy approaching, he kept his forces inside the walls, instructing the senators of Nola to patrol the walls and gather intelligence on the enemy's movements. Herennius Bassus and Herius Petrius were invited by Hanno, who approached the wall for a conference, and they went out with Marcellus's permission. Hanno addressed them through an interpreter, praising Hannibal's bravery and luck while belittling the Roman people’s majesty, which he claimed was declining with their strength. He said, "Even if they are equal in these respects, as they once might have been, those who have experienced Rome's oppressive government towards its allies and Hannibal's great mercy, even towards his Italian prisoners, should prefer an alliance with the Carthaginians over the Romans." Even if both consuls and their armies were at Nola, they would be no better match for Hannibal than they were at Cannae, let alone a single praetor with a few inexperienced soldiers being able to defend it. It was more their concern than Hannibal’s whether he captured Nola by force or it willingly surrendered, because he would certainly take control of it, just as he had done with Capua and Nuceria. The Nolans, positioned almost midway between them, were well aware of the differences in fate between Capua and Nuceria. He said he didn’t want to predict the disasters that would come to the city if it were taken by force, but instead would promise that if they surrendered Nola, along with Marcellus and his garrison, no one but themselves would set the conditions for entering into the friendship and alliance of Hannibal.

44

To this Herennius Bassus replied, that, "a friendship had subsisted now for many years between the Romans and the Nolans, which neither party up to that day regretted; and even had they been disposed to change their friends upon a change of fortune, it was now too late to change; had they intended to surrender themselves to Hannibal, they should not have called a Roman garrison to their aid: that all fortunes both were now and should to the last be shared with those who had come to their protection." This conference deprived Hannibal of the hope of gaining Nola by treachery; he therefore completely invested the city, in order that he might attack the walls in every part at once. Marcellus, when he perceived that he had come near to the walls, having drawn up his troops within the gate, sallied forth with great impetuosity; several were knocked down and slain on the first charge: afterwards the troops running up to those who were engaged, and their forces being thus placed on an equality? the battle began to be fierce; nor would there have been many actions equally memorable, had not the combatants been separated by a shower of rain attended with a tremendous storm. On that day, after having engaged in a slight contest, and with inflamed minds, they retired, the Romans to the city, the Carthaginians to their camp. Of the Carthaginians, however, there fell from the shock of the first sally not more than thirty, of the Romans not one. The rain continued without intermission through the whole night, until the third hour of the following day, and therefore, though both parties were eager for the contest, they nevertheless kept themselves within their works for that day. On the third day Hannibal sent a portion of his troops into the lands of the Nolans to plunder. Marcellus perceiving this, immediately led out his troops and formed for battle, nor did Hannibal decline fighting. The interval between the city and the camp was about a mile. In that space, and all the country round Nola consists of level ground, the armies met. The shout which was raised on both sides, called back to the battle, which had now commenced, the nearest of those cohorts which had gone out into the fields to plunder. The Nolans too joined the Roman line. Marcellus having highly commended them, desired them to station themselves in reserve, and to carry the wounded out of the field but not take part in the battle, unless they should receive a signal from him.

To this, Herennius Bassus replied, "A friendship has existed for many years between the Romans and the Nolans, and neither side has regretted it up to this day. Even if they wanted to change allies due to a shift in fortune, it’s too late for that now. If they had wanted to surrender to Hannibal, they wouldn't have called for a Roman garrison to help them. All fortunes will be shared with those who have come to their protection." This conversation dashed Hannibal's hopes of capturing Nola through treachery; he therefore completely surrounded the city to attack the walls from all sides at once. When Marcellus saw that he had gotten close to the walls, he organized his troops at the gate and charged out with great force; several enemies were knocked down and killed on the first assault. As the troops rushed to support those engaged, the forces became evenly matched, and the battle grew fierce. There might have been many memorable actions if the fighters hadn’t been separated by a downpour accompanied by a fierce storm. That day, after a brief skirmish and with heightened emotions, they withdrew— the Romans back to the city and the Carthaginians to their camp. However, among the Carthaginians, only about thirty were lost in the initial attack, while the Romans suffered no casualties. The rain continued without stopping throughout the night and into the early hours of the next day. Even though both sides were eager to fight, they stayed behind their defenses that day. On the third day, Hannibal sent part of his troops into Nolans' lands to raid. Observing this, Marcellus quickly led out his troops and prepared for battle, and Hannibal was ready to fight as well. The distance between the city and the camp was about a mile. In that open area, the armies faced off. The battle cries from both sides brought back the nearest cohorts that had gone out to plunder. The Nolans also joined the Roman line. Marcellus praised them and asked them to stay in reserve, carrying the wounded off the field, but not to engage in battle unless he signaled them to do so.

45

It was a doubtful battle; the generals exerting themselves to the utmost in exhorting, and the soldiers in fighting Marcellus urged his troops to press vigorously on men who had been vanquished but three days before, who had been put to flight at Cumae only a few days ago, and who had been driven from Nola the preceding year by himself, as general, though with different troops. He said, "that all the forces of the enemy were not in the field; that they were rambling about the country in plundering parties, and that even those who were engaged, were enfeebled with Campanian luxury, and worn out with drunkenness, lust, and every kind of debauchery, which they had been indulging in through the whole winter. That the energy and vigour had left them, that the strength of mind and body had vanished, by which the Pyrenees and the tops of the Alps had been passed. That those now engaged were the remains of those men, with scarcely strength to support their arms and limbs. That Capua had been a Cannae to Hannibal; that there his courage in battle, his military discipline, the fame he had already acquired, and his hopes of future glory, were extinguished." While Marcellus was raising the spirits of his troops by thus inveighing against the enemy, Hannibal assailed them with still heavier reproaches. He said, "he recognised the arms and standards which he had seen and employed at Trebia and Trasimenus, and lastly at Cannae; but that he had indeed led one sort of troops into winter quarters at Capua, and brought another out. Do you, whom two consular armies could never withstand, with difficulty maintain your ground against a Roman lieutenant-general, and a single legion with a body of auxiliaries? Does Marcellus now a second time with impunity assail us with a band of raw recruits and Nolan auxiliaries? Where is that soldier of mine, who took off the head of Caius Flaminius, the consul, after dragging him from his horse? Where is the man who slew Lucius Paulus at Cannae? Is it that the steel hath lost its edge? or that your right hands are benumbed? or what other miracle is it? You who, when few, have been accustomed to conquer numbers, now scarce maintain your ground, the many against the few. Brave in speech only, you were wont to boast that you would take Rome by storm if you could find a general to lead you. Lo! here is a task of less difficulty. I would have you try your strength and courage here. Take Nola, a town situated on a plain, protected neither by river nor sea; after that, when you have enriched yourselves with the plunder and spoils of that wealthy town, I will either lead or follow you whithersoever you have a mind."

It was a questionable battle; the generals were pushing themselves to the limit in encouraging their troops, and the soldiers were fighting hard. Marcellus motivated his troops to push forward against men who had been defeated just three days earlier, who had fled at Cumae only a few days ago, and who had been driven out of Nola the year before by him as a general, albeit with different forces. He stated, “Not all of the enemy’s forces are in the field; they are scattered across the countryside in looting squads, and even those engaged are weakened by Campanian excess, overwhelmed by drunkenness, lust, and all kinds of indulgence that they’ve been indulging in all winter. Their energy and stamina are gone, the mental and physical strength that once allowed them to cross the Pyrenees and the heights of the Alps is no longer present. Those now engaged are the remnants of those men, barely able to lift their arms and legs. Capua has been a disaster for Hannibal; there his bravery in battle, military discipline, the fame he had already achieved, and his hopes for future glory were extinguished.” While Marcellus was lifting the spirits of his troops by speaking out against the enemy, Hannibal hit back with even harsher criticism. He said, "I recognize the weapons and standards that I’ve seen and used at Trebia, Trasimenus, and most recently at Cannae; but I led one type of troops into winter quarters at Capua and brought another type out. You, who two consular armies could never defeat, are struggling to hold your ground against a Roman lieutenant-general and a single legion with some auxiliary forces? Does Marcellus, for a second time, boldly attack us with a unit of inexperienced recruits and Nolan auxiliaries? Where is that soldier of mine who decapitated Caius Flaminius, the consul, after dragging him off his horse? Where is the man who killed Lucius Paulus at Cannae? Has the steel lost its sharpness? Or have your right hands gone numb? What other miracle could it be? You, who when few, were used to overcoming larger numbers, now barely hold your ground against a smaller force. Only brave in words, you used to boast that you would storm Rome if you could find a general to lead you. Look! Here’s a task that is less difficult. I urge you to test your strength and courage here. Take Nola, a town situated on a plain, with no river or sea for protection; then, after you’ve enriched yourselves with the loot and treasures of that prosperous town, I will either lead or follow you wherever you want to go.”

46

Neither praises nor reproaches had any effect in confirming their courage. Driven from their ground in every quarter, while the Romans derived fresh spirits, not only from the exhortations of their general, but from the Nolans, who, by their acclamations in token of their good wishes, fed the flame of battle, the Carthaginians turned their backs, and were driven to their camp, which the Roman soldiers were eager to attack; but Marcellus led them back to Nola, amidst the great joy and congratulations even from the commons, who hitherto had been more favourable to the Carthaginians. Of the enemy more than five thousand were slain on that day, six hundred made prisoners, with nineteen military standards and two elephants. Four elephants were killed in the battle. Of the Romans less than a thousand were killed. The next day was employed by both parties in burying their dead, under a tacit truce. Marcellus burnt the spoils of the enemy, in fulfilment of a vow to Vulcan. On the third day after, on account of some pique, I suppose, or in the hope of more advantageous service, one thousand two hundred and seventy-two horsemen, Numidians and Spaniards, deserted to Marcellus. The Romans had frequently availed themselves of their brave and faithful service in that war. After the conclusion of the war, portions of land were given to the Spaniards in Spain, to the Numidians in Africa, in consideration of their valour. Having sent Hanno back from Nola to the Bruttians with the troops with which he had come, Hannibal went himself into winter quarters in Apulia, and took up a position in the neighbourhood of Arpi. Quintus Fabius, as soon as he heard that Hannibal was set out into Apulia, conveyed corn, collected from Nola and Naples, into the camp above Suessula; and having strengthened the fortifications and left a garrison sufficient for the protection of the place during the winter, moved his camp nearer to Capua, and laid waste the Campanian lands with fire and sword; so that at length the Campanians, though not very confident in their strength, were obliged to go out of their gates and fortify a camp in the open space before the city. They had six thousand armed men, the infantry, unfit for action. In their cavalry they had more strength. They therefore harassed the enemy by attacking them with these. Among the many distinguished persons who served in the Campanian cavalry was one Cerrinus Jubellius, surnamed Taurea. Though of that extraction, he was a Roman citizen, and by far the bravest horseman of all the Campanians, insomuch that when he served under the Roman banners, there was but one man, Claudius Asellus, a Roman, who rivalled him in his reputation as a horseman. Taurea having for a long time diligently sought for this man, riding up to the squadrons of the enemy, at length having obtained silence, inquired where Claudius Asellus was, and asked why, since he had been accustomed to dispute about their merit in words, he would not decide the matter with the sword, and if vanquished give him spolia opima, or if victorious take them.

Neither praise nor criticism had any effect on their courage. Driven from their positions in every direction, while the Romans gained new energy, not only from their general's encouragement but also from the Nolans, who cheered to show their support and stoke the fire of battle, the Carthaginians turned and retreated to their camp, which the Roman soldiers were eager to attack. However, Marcellus brought them back to Nola, amid great joy and congratulations even from the common people, who had previously been more supportive of the Carthaginians. More than five thousand of the enemy were killed that day, six hundred were captured, along with nineteen military standards and two elephants. Four elephants were killed in the battle. Fewer than a thousand Romans were killed. The next day, both sides spent the time burying their dead under an unspoken truce. Marcellus burned the enemy's spoils in fulfillment of a vow to Vulcan. On the third day after, possibly out of some slight or in hopes of better opportunities, one thousand two hundred and seventy-two horsemen, Numidians and Spaniards, deserted to Marcellus. The Romans had often relied on their brave and loyal service in that war. After the war was concluded, land was given to the Spaniards in Spain and the Numidians in Africa as a reward for their valor. Having sent Hanno back from Nola to the Bruttians with the troops he had brought, Hannibal himself went into winter quarters in Apulia, taking position near Arpi. As soon as Quintus Fabius heard that Hannibal had moved into Apulia, he transported grain collected from Nola and Naples into the camp above Suessula; and after reinforcing the fortifications and leaving a sufficient garrison to protect the area during the winter, he moved his camp closer to Capua and ravaged the Campanian lands with fire and sword. Eventually, the Campanians, though not very confident in their strength, were forced to come out of their gates and fortify a camp in the open space before the city. They had six thousand armed men, the infantry unfit for action. Their cavalry was stronger, so they harassed the enemy by launching attacks with them. Among the many notable individuals serving in the Campanian cavalry was one Cerrinus Jubellius, nicknamed Taurea. Although he was of that heritage, he was a Roman citizen and by far the bravest horseman among the Campanians, to the point that when he served under the Roman banners, there was only one other man, Claudius Asellus, a Roman, who matched his reputation as a horseman. Taurea, having long sought after this man, rode up to the enemy's squadrons and eventually gained their attention. He asked where Claudius Asellus was and questioned why, since they usually debated their merits verbally, he would not settle the matter with a sword, offering to give him spolia opima if he was defeated or to take them if he was victorious.

47

Asellus, who was in the camp, having been informed of this, waited only to ask the consul leave to depart from the ordinary course and fight an enemy who had challenged him. By his permission, he immediately put on his arms, and riding out beyond the advanced guards called on Taurea by name, and bid him come to the encounter when he pleased. By this time the Romans had gone out in large bodies to witness the contest, and the Campanians had crowded not only the rampart of the camp, but the walls of the city to get a view of it. After a flourish of expressions of mutual defiance, they spurred on their horses with their spears pointed. Then evading each other's attacks, for they had free space to move in, they protracted the battle without a wound. Upon this the Campanian observed to the Roman, "This will be only a trial of skill between our horses and not between horsemen, unless we ride them down from the plain into this hollow way. There, as there will be no room for retiring, we shall come to close quarters." Almost quicker than the word, Claudius leaped into the hollow way. Taurea, bold in words more than in reality, said, "Never be the ass in the ditch;" an expression which from this circumstance became a common proverb among rustics. Claudius having rode up and down the way to a considerable distance, and again come up into the plain without meeting his antagonist, after reflecting in reproachful terms on the cowardice of the enemy, returned in triumph to the camp, amidst great rejoicing and congratulation. To the account of this equestrian contest, some histories add a circumstance which is certainly astonishing, how true it is, is an open matter of opinion that Claudius, when in pursuit of Taurea, who fled back to the city, rode in at one of the gates of the enemy which stood open and made his escape unhurt through another, the enemy being thunderstruck at the strangeness of the circumstance.

Asellus, who was in the camp, having heard about this, just needed to ask the consul for permission to break from the usual routine and fight an enemy who had challenged him. With his consent, he quickly put on his armor and rode out beyond the front lines, calling out to Taurea by name, inviting him to come and fight whenever he wanted. By this time, many Romans had gathered to watch the contest, and the Campanians crowded not only the camp ramparts but also the city walls for a better view. After exchanging bold words of defiance, they urged their horses forward, spears ready. They dodged each other's attacks, having enough space to maneuver, extending the battle without landing a hit. On this, the Campanian commented to the Roman, "This will turn into just a test of our horses, not our skills as riders, unless we push them from the flat ground into this dip. There, with no room to retreat, we’ll have to fight up close." Almost before he could finish speaking, Claudius jumped into the dip. Taurea, bolder with his words than with his actions, said, "Never be the ass in the ditch," a saying that later became a common proverb among farmers. After riding back and forth in the dip for a while and not finding his opponent, Claudius, feeling disdain for the enemy's cowardice, returned triumphantly to the camp, greeted by great cheers and celebrations. Some historical accounts of this equestrian contest add an astonishing detail, though it's up for debate how true it is: Claudius, while pursuing Taurea, who had fled back to the city, rode through one of the open gates of the enemy and escaped unscathed through another, leaving the enemy astonished at the unusual turn of events.

48

The camps were then undisturbed, the consul even moved his camp back, that the Campanians might complete their sowing, nor did he do any injury to the lands till the blades in the corn-fields were grown sufficiently high to be useful for forage. This he conveyed into the Claudian camp above Suessula, and there erected winter quarters. He ordered Marcus Claudius, the proconsul, to retain at Nola a sufficient force for the protection of the place, and send the rest to Rome, that they might not be a burthen to their allies nor an expense to the republic. Tiberius Gracchus also, having led his legions from Cumae to Luceria in Apulia, sent Marcus Valerius, the praetor, thence to Brundusium with the troops which he had commanded at Luceria, with orders to protect the coast of the Sallentine territory, and make provisions with regard to Philip and the Macedonian war. At the close of the summer, the events of which I have described, letters arrived from Publius and Cneius Scipio, stating the magnitude and success of their operations in Spain, but that the army was in want of money, clothing, and corn, and that then crews were in want of every thing. With regard to the pay, they said, that if the treasury was low, they would adopt some plan by which they might procure it from the Spaniards, but that the other supplies must certainly be sent from Rome, for otherwise neither the army could be kept together nor the province preserved. When the letters were read, all to a man admitted that the statement was correct, and the request reasonable, but it occurred to their minds, what great forces they were maintaining by land and sea, and how large a fleet must soon be equipped if a war with Macedon should break out, that Sicily and Sardinia, which before the war had wielded a revenue, were scarcely able to maintain the troops which protected those provinces, that the expenses were supplied by a tax, that both the number of the persons who contributed this tax was diminished by the great havoc made in their armies at the Trasimenus and Cannae, and the few who survived, if they were oppressed with multiplied impositions, would perish by a calamity of a different kind. That, therefore, if the republic could not subsist by credit, it could not stand by its own resources. It was resolved, therefore, that Fulvius, the praetor, should present himself to the public assembly of the people, point out the necessities of the state, and exhort those persons who had increased their patrimonies by farming the public revenues, to furnish temporary loans for the service of that state, from which they had derived their wealth, and contract to supply what was necessary for the army in Spain, on the condition of being paid the first when there was money in the treasury. These things the praetor laid before the assembly, and fixed a day on which he would let on contract the furnishing the army in Spain with clothes and corn, and with such other things as were necessary for the crews.

The camps were left undisturbed, and the consul even moved his camp back so that the Campanians could finish their planting. He didn’t harm the land until the corn in the fields was high enough to be useful for fodder. He transported this to the Claudian camp above Suessula and set up winter quarters there. He instructed Marcus Claudius, the proconsul, to keep enough troops in Nola to protect the area and to send the rest back to Rome, so they wouldn’t be a burden to their allies or an expense to the republic. Tiberius Gracchus also, having moved his legions from Cumae to Luceria in Apulia, sent Marcus Valerius, the praetor, from there to Brundusium with the troops he commanded at Luceria. He was ordered to secure the coast of the Sallentine territory and make arrangements regarding Philip and the Macedonian war. By the end of the summer, after the events I’ve described, letters arrived from Publius and Cneius Scipio detailing the scale and success of their operations in Spain, but indicating the army was in need of money, clothes, and grain, and that their crews needed everything. Concerning payment, they mentioned that if the treasury was low, they would find a way to obtain funds from the Spaniards, but the other supplies definitely had to come from Rome, or the army couldn’t be sustained, nor could the province be protected. When the letters were read, everyone agreed that the situation was serious and the request was reasonable. However, they reflected on the large forces they were maintaining both on land and at sea, and that a substantial fleet would soon need to be assembled if a war with Macedon broke out. They noted that Sicily and Sardinia, which had previously generated revenue, could barely support the troops securing those provinces, and that the expenses were covered by a tax. The number of those contributing to this tax had decreased dramatically due to the heavy losses suffered in their armies at Trasimenus and Cannae, and the few survivors, if burdened with excessive taxes, would face a different kind of disaster. Thus, they concluded that if the republic couldn’t survive on credit, it couldn't rely on its resources. Consequently, it was decided that Fulvius, the praetor, should address the public assembly, highlight the state’s needs, and encourage those who had increased their wealth through managing public revenues to provide temporary loans to support the state that had made them prosperous, and agree to supply what was necessary for the army in Spain, on the condition that they would be paid first when funds returned to the treasury. The praetor presented these matters to the assembly and set a date to contract the supply of clothes, grain, and other essentials for the army in Spain.

49

When the day arrived, three companies, of nineteen persons, came forward to enter into the contract; but they made two requests: one was, that they should be exempt from military service while employed in that revenue business; the second was, that the state should bear all losses of the goods they shipped, which might arise either from the attacks of the enemy or from storms. Having obtained both their requests, they entered into the contract, and the affairs of the state were conducted by private funds. This character and love of country uniformly pervaded all ranks. As all the engagements were entered into with magnanimity, so were they fulfilled with the strictest fidelity; and the supplies were furnished in the same manner as formerly, from an abundant treasury. At the time when these supplies arrived, the town of Illiturgi was being besieged by Hasdrubal, Mago, and Hamilcar the son of Bomilcar, on account of its having gone over to the Romans. Between these three camps of the enemy, the Scipios effected an entrance into the town of their allies, after a violent contest and great slaughter of their opponents, and introduced some corn, of which there was a scarcity; and after exhorting the townsmen to defend their walls with the same spirit which they had seen displayed by the Roman army fighting in their behalf, led on their troops to attack the largest of the camps, in which Hasdrubal had the command. To this camp the two other generals of the Carthaginians with their armies came, seeing that the great business was to be done there. They therefore sallied from the camp and fought. Of the enemy engaged there were sixty thousand; of the Romans about sixteen; the victory, however, was so decisive, that the Romans slew more than their own number of the enemy, and captured more than three thousand, with nearly a thousand horses and fifty-nine military standards, five elephants having been slain in the battle. They made themselves masters of the three camps on that day. The siege of Illiturgi having been raised, the Carthaginian armies were led away to the siege of Intibili; the forces having been recruited out of that province, which was, above all others, fond of war, provided there was any plunder or pay to be obtained, and at that time had an abundance of young men. A second regular engagement took place, attended with the same fortune to both parties; in which above three thousand of the enemy were slain, more than two thousand captured, together with forty-two standards and nine elephants. Then, indeed, almost all the people of Spain came over to the Romans, and the achievements in Spain during that summer were much more important than those in Italy.

When the day came, three companies of nineteen people each stepped up to enter into the contract, but they had two requests: first, that they be exempt from military service while working in that revenue business; second, that the state cover any losses on the goods they shipped, whether caused by enemy attacks or storms. After getting both requests approved, they signed the contract, and state affairs were managed with private funds. This commitment and love for their country were seen across all levels. All agreements were made with generosity and fulfilled with the highest loyalty, with supplies provided just as before, from a well-stocked treasury. At that time, the town of Illiturgi was under siege by Hasdrubal, Mago, and Hamilcar, the son of Bomilcar, because it had allied with the Romans. Amid these three enemy camps, the Scipios managed to enter the town of their allies after a fierce battle with heavy losses for the enemy, bringing in some much-needed grain. After encouraging the townspeople to defend their walls with the same determination they had seen the Roman army display in their defense, they led their troops to assault the largest of the camps, where Hasdrubal was in command. The two other Carthaginian generals and their armies joined in, seeing that the main action was there. They then launched a surprise attack and engaged in combat. There were about sixty thousand enemy troops involved, compared to around sixteen Romans; however, the Romans had a decisive victory, killing more enemy soldiers than their own number and capturing over three thousand, along with nearly a thousand horses and fifty-nine military standards, while five elephants were killed in the battle. They gained control of all three camps that day. With the siege of Illiturgi lifted, the Carthaginian armies moved on to lay siege to Intibili; their forces were bolstered from that province, which was particularly enthusiastic about war, especially when there was loot or pay to be had, and at that time had plenty of young men available. A second major battle was fought, with similar outcomes for both sides; more than three thousand enemy troops were killed, over two thousand captured, along with forty-two standards and nine elephants. By then, almost all the people of Spain sided with the Romans, and the military successes in Spain that summer were far more significant than those in Italy.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXIV.
B.C. 215-213


Hieronymus, king of Syracuse, whose grandfather Hiero had been a faithful ally of Rome, revolts to the Carthaginians, and for his tyranny is put to death by his subjects. Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus, the proconsul, defeats the Carthaginians under Hanno at Beneventum chiefly by the services of the slaves in his army, whom he subsequently liberated. Claudius Marcellus, the consul, besieges Syracuse. War is declared against Philip, king of Macedon, he is routed by night at Apollonia and retreats into Macedonia. This war is intrusted to Valerius the praetor. Operations of the Scipios against the Carthaginians in Spain. Syphax, king of the Numidians, is received into alliance by the Romans, and is defeated by Masinissa, king of the Massillians, who fought on the side of the Carthaginians. The Celtiberians joined the Romans, and their troops having been taken into pay, mercenary soldiers for the first time served in a Roman camp.

       *        *        *        *        *

1

On his return from Campania into Bruttium, Hanno, with the assistance and under the guidance of the Bruttians, made an attempt upon the Greek cities; which were the more disposed to continue in alliance with the Romans, because they perceived that the Bruttians, whom they feared and hated, had taken part with the Carthaginians. The first place attempted was Rhegium, where several days were spent without effect. Meanwhile the Locrians hastily conveyed from the country into the city, corn, wood, and other things necessary for their use, as also that no booty might be left for the enemy. The number of persons which poured out of every gate increased daily, till at length those only were left in the city whose duty it was to repair the walls and gates, and to collect weapons in the fortresses. Against this mixed multitude, composed of persons of all ages and ranks, while rambling through the country, and for the most part unarmed, Hamilcar, the Carthaginian, sent out his cavalry, who, having been forbidden to hurt any one, only interposed their squadrons, so as to cut them off from the city when dispersed in flight. The general himself, having posted himself upon an eminence which commanded a view of the country and the city, ordered a cohort of Bruttians to approach the walls, call out the leaders of the Locrians to a conference, and promising them the friendship of Hannibal, exhort them to deliver up the city. At first the Bruttians were not believed in any thing they stated in the conference, but afterwards, when the Carthaginian appeared on the hills, and a few who had fled back to the city brought intelligence that all the rest of the multitude were in the power of the enemy, overcome with fear, they said they would consult the people. An assembly of the people was immediately called, when, as all the most fickle of the inhabitants were desirous of a change of measures and a new alliance, and those whose friends were cut off by the enemy without the city, had their minds bound as if they had given hostages, while a few rather silently approved of a constant fidelity than ventured to support the opinion they approved, the city was surrendered to the Carthaginians, with an appearance of perfect unanimity. Lucius Atilius, the captain of the garrison, together with the Roman soldiers who were with him, having been privately led down to the port, and put on board a ship, that they might be conveyed to Rhegium, Hamilcar and the Carthaginians were received into the city on condition that an alliance should be formed on equal terms; which condition, when they had surrendered, the Carthaginian had very nearly not performed, as he accused them of having sent away the Roman fraudulently, while the Locrians alleged that he had spontaneously fled. A body of cavalry went in pursuit of the fugitives, in case the tide might happen to detain them in the strait, or might carry the ships to land. The persons whom they were in pursuit of they did not overtake, but they descried some ships passing over the strait from Messana to Rhegium. These contained Roman troops sent by the praetor, Claudius, to occupy the city with a garrison. The enemy therefore immediately retired from Rhegium. At the command of Hannibal, peace was concluded with the Locrians on these terms: that "they should live free under their own laws; that the city should be open to the Carthaginians, the harbour in the power of the Locrians. That their alliance should rest on the principle, that the Carthaginian should help the Locrian and the Locrian the Carthaginian in peace and war."

On his return from Campania to Bruttium, Hanno, with the help and guidance of the Bruttians, attempted to take the Greek cities, which were more inclined to stay allied with the Romans because they realized that the Bruttians, whom they feared and disliked, had sided with the Carthaginians. The first target was Rhegium, where they spent several days without success. Meanwhile, the Locrians quickly moved corn, wood, and other essentials into the city from the countryside, so that there would be no spoils left for the enemy. The number of people pouring out of every gate grew daily until only those tasked with repairing the walls and gates, and gathering weapons in the fortresses, remained in the city. Against this mixed crowd, made up of people of all ages and backgrounds, while wandering through the countryside and mostly unarmed, Hamilcar, the Carthaginian, sent out his cavalry. They were instructed not to harm anyone, so they simply formed ranks to cut off the people from escaping back into the city when they scattered in flight. The general positioned himself on a high ground where he could see both the countryside and the city, ordered a group of Bruttians to approach the walls, call the leaders of the Locrians for a talk, and, promising them Hannibal's friendship, encouraged them to surrender the city. Initially, the Bruttians weren’t believed in what they said, but later, when the Carthaginian appeared on the hills and a few who had fled back to the city reported that the rest were under the enemy's control, fear overwhelmed them, and they said they would consult the people. An assembly was quickly called, during which the most indecisive among the inhabitants wanted a change of plans and a new alliance, and those whose friends were cut off by the enemy outside the city felt as if they had given hostages in their minds. Meanwhile, a few silently supported loyalty but didn't dare to voice their opinions; thus, the city was surrendered to the Carthaginians, seemingly with complete agreement. Lucius Atilius, the commanding officer of the garrison, along with the Roman soldiers with him, were secretly led down to the port and put on a ship to be taken to Rhegium. Hamilcar and the Carthaginians were admitted into the city under the condition that an alliance would be formed on equal terms; however, after the surrender, the Carthaginian nearly did not uphold this condition, claiming they had deceitfully sent away the Romans, while the Locrians argued that he had fled of his own accord. A cavalry unit pursued the fugitives in case the tide held them back in the strait or carried the ships to shore. They did not catch the people they were pursuing, but saw some ships crossing the strait from Messana to Rhegium. These carried Roman troops sent by the praetor, Claudius, to occupy the city with a garrison. Therefore, the enemy immediately retreated from Rhegium. Under Hannibal's orders, peace was established with the Locrians on these terms: that "they would live freely under their own laws; that the city would be open to the Carthaginians, but the harbor would remain under the control of the Locrians. Their alliance would be based on the principle that the Carthaginian would help the Locrians and the Locrians would help the Carthaginian in peace and war."

2

Thus the Carthaginian troops were led back from the strait, while the Bruttians loudly complained that Locri and Rhegium, cities which they had fixed in their minds that they should have the plundering of, they had left untouched. Having therefore levied and armed fifteen thousand of their own youth, they set out by themselves to lay siege to Croto, which was also a Greek city, and on the coast, believing that they would obtain a great accession to their power, if they could get possession of a city upon the sea-coast, which had a port and was strongly defended by walls. This consideration annoyed them, that they neither could venture on the business without calling in the Carthaginians to their assistance, lest they should appear to have done any thing in a manner unbecoming allies, and on the other hand, lest, if the Carthaginian general should again show himself to have been rather an umpire of peace than an auxiliary in war, they should fight in vain against the liberty of Croto, as before in the affair of the Locrians. The most advisable course, therefore, appeared to be, that ambassadors should be sent to Hannibal, and that a stipulation should be obtained from him that Croto, when reduced, should be in possession of the Bruttians. Hannibal replied, that it was a question which should be determined by persons on the spot, and referred them to Hanno, from whom they could obtain no decisive answer. For they were unwilling that so celebrated and opulent a city should be plundered, and were in hopes that if the Bruttians should attack it, while the Carthaginians did not ostensibly approve or assist in the attack, the inhabitants would the more readily come over to them. The Crotonians were not united either in their measures or wishes. All the states of Italy were infected with one disease, as it were, the commons dissented from the nobles, the senate favouring the Romans, while the commons endeavoured to draw the states over to the Carthaginians. A deserter announced to the Bruttii that such a dissension prevailed in the city, that Aristomachus was the leader of the commons, and the adviser of the surrender of the city, that the city was of wide extent and thinly inhabited, that the walls in every part were in ruins, that it was only here and there that the guards and watches were kept by senators, and that wherever the commons kept guard, there an entrance lay open. Under the direction and guidance of the deserter, the Bruttians completely invested the city, and being received into it by the commons, got possession of every part, except the citadel, on the first assault. The nobles held the citadel, which they had taken care beforehand to have ready as a refuge against such an event. In the same place Aristomachus took refuge, as though he had advised the surrender of the city to the Carthaginians, and not to the Bruttians.

So the Carthaginian troops were pulled back from the strait, while the Bruttians loudly complained that Locri and Rhegium, cities they had set their sights on for looting, were left untouched. They then gathered and armed fifteen thousand of their own young men and headed out on their own to lay siege to Croto, another Greek city located on the coast. They believed they would greatly strengthen their power if they could capture a coastal city that had a port and was fortified by strong walls. This situation frustrated them because they couldn't undertake the mission without involving the Carthaginians for help, fearing they would appear to act ungraciously as allies. On the other hand, they were also concerned that if the Carthaginian general showed up again as more of a peacemaker than a military ally, their efforts to fight for Croto's freedom would be in vain, as had happened with the Locrians. Therefore, it seemed best to send ambassadors to Hannibal and secure a promise from him that once Croto was conquered, it would belong to the Bruttians. Hannibal replied that the matter should be decided by those on the ground and referred them to Hanno, who offered no definite answer. They were reluctant to see such a renowned and wealthy city being plundered and hoped that if the Bruttians attacked while the Carthaginians did not openly support the assault, the people would be more willing to join them. The Crotonians were divided in both their actions and their desires. All the states of Italy seemed to be affected by a similar issue: the common people opposed the nobles, with the senate favoring the Romans, while the commoners tried to sway the states to the Carthaginian side. A deserter informed the Bruttians of the discord in the city, telling them that Aristomachus was leading the commoners and advising the city’s surrender, that the city was large but sparsely populated, that the walls were in ruins, and that guards and watches were only sporadically maintained by senators. The deserter guided the Bruttians to completely surround the city, and with the support of the commoners, they captured nearly every part of it, except for the citadel, in their first attack. The nobles held onto the citadel, which they had prepared as a safe haven against such an event. Aristomachus took refuge there, as if he had counseled the city’s surrender to the Carthaginians rather than to the Bruttians.

3

The wall of the city of Croto in circuit extended through a space of twelve miles, before the arrival of Pyrrhus in Italy. After the devastation occasioned by that war, scarcely half the city was inhabited. The river which had flowed through the middle of the town, now ran on the outside of the parts which were occupied by buildings, and the citadel was at a distance from the inhabited parts. Six miles from this celebrated city stood the temple of Juno Lacinia, more celebrated even than the city itself, and venerated by all the surrounding states. Here was a grove fenced with a dense wood and tall fir trees, with rich pastures in its centre, in which cattle of every kind, sacred to the goddess, fed without any keeper; the flocks of every kind going out separately and returning to their folds, never being injured, either from the lying in wait of wild beasts, or the dishonesty of men. These flocks were, therefore, a source of great revenue, from which a column of solid gold was formed and consecrated; and the temple became distinguished for its wealth also, and not only for its sanctity. Some miracles are attributed to it, as is generally the case with regard to such remarkable places. Rumour says that there is an altar in the vestibule of the temple, the ashes of which are never moved by any wind. But the citadel of Croto, overhanging the sea on one side, on the other, which looks towards the land, was protected formerly by its natural situation only, but was afterwards surrounded by a wall. It was in this part that Dionysius, the tyrant of Sicily, took it by stratagem, approaching by way of some rocks which faced from it. This citadel, which was considered sufficiently secure, was now occupied by the nobles of Croto, the Bruttians, in conjunction even with their own commons, besieging them. The Bruttians, however, perceiving at length that it was impossible to take the citadel by their own efforts, compelled by necessity, implored the aid of Hanno. He endeavoured to bring the Crotonians to surrender, under an agreement that they should allow a colony of Bruttians to settle there; so that their city, desolate and depopulated by wars, might recover its former populousness: but not a man besides Aristomachus did he move; they affirmed, that "they would die sooner than, mixing with Bruttians, be turned to the rites, manners, and laws, and soon the language also of others." Aristomachus alone, since he was neither able to persuade them to surrender, nor could obtain an opportunity for betraying the citadel as he had betrayed the city, deserted to Hanno. A short time afterwards ambassadors of Locri, entering the citadel with the permission of Hanno, persuaded them to allow themselves to be removed to Locri, and not resolve to hazard extremities. They had already obtained leave from Hannibal to do this, by ambassadors sent for this purpose. Accordingly, Croto was evacuated, and the inhabitants were conducted to the sea, where they embarked; and the whole multitude removed to Locri. In Apulia, Hannibal and the Romans did not rest even during the winter. The consul Sempronius wintered at Luceria, Hannibal not far from Arpi. Slight engagements took place between them, accordingly as either side had an opportunity or advantage; by which the Roman soldiery were improved, and became daily more guarded and more secure against stratagems.

The city walls of Croto stretched for twelve miles before Pyrrhus arrived in Italy. After the destruction caused by that war, barely half the city was inhabited. The river that used to flow through the middle of the town now ran outside the areas with buildings, and the citadel was far from the populated sections. Six miles from this famous city was the temple of Juno Lacinia, even more renowned than the city itself, and revered by all the neighboring states. There was a grove surrounded by dense woods and tall fir trees, with lush pastures in the center, where all kinds of cattle sacred to the goddess grazed without any shepherd; the flocks went out separately and returned to their pens without being harmed by wild beasts or dishonest men. These flocks were a significant source of revenue, which allowed for a solid gold column to be created and consecrated; the temple became notable for its wealth as well as its holiness. Some miracles were attributed to it, as is common with such remarkable places. It's said that there's an altar in the temple's entrance whose ashes are never stirred by the wind. However, the citadel of Croto, overlooking the sea on one side and the land on the other, was originally protected only by its natural location but was later surrounded by a wall. It was here that Dionysius, the tyrant of Sicily, captured it through a clever trick, approaching via the rocks facing away from it. This citadel, once thought secure, was now occupied by the nobles of Croto, with the Bruttians also joining their commoners to besiege them. The Bruttians, realizing it was impossible to take the citadel on their own, eventually turned to Hanno for help. He tried to persuade the Crotonians to surrender with the promise that a colony of Bruttians would settle there so that their war-ravaged city could regain its former population. But only Aristomachus was swayed; the others said they would rather die than mix with the Bruttians and adopt their customs, laws, and eventually their language. Since Aristomachus couldn't convince the others to surrender or find an opportunity to betray the citadel as he had betrayed the city, he defected to Hanno. Shortly afterward, ambassadors from Locri entered the citadel with Hanno's permission and convinced the inhabitants to relocate to Locri instead of risking dire consequences. They had already received permission from Hannibal to do this through ambassadors. As a result, Croto was evacuated, and the inhabitants were taken to the sea where they boarded ships, moving the entire crowd to Locri. In Apulia, Hannibal and the Romans didn't take a break even during winter. Consul Sempronius spent the winter in Luceria, while Hannibal was near Arpi. Minor skirmishes occurred between them whenever one side had an opportunity or advantage, which made the Roman soldiers more disciplined and increasingly cautious against tricks.

4

In Sicily, the death of Hiero, and the transfer of the government to his grandson, Hieronymus, had completely altered all things with regard to the Romans. Hieronymus was but a boy, as yet scarcely able to bear liberty, still less sovereign power. His guardians and friends gladly observed in him a disposition which might be easily plunged into every kind of vice; which Hiero foreseeing, is said to have formed an intention, in the latter part of his long life, of leaving Syracuse free, lest the sovereignty which had been acquired and established by honourable means, should be made a sport of and fall into ruin, under the administration of a boy. This plan of his his daughters strenuously opposed, who anticipated that the boy would enjoy the name of royalty, but that the administration of all affairs would be conducted by themselves and their husbands, Andranodorus and Zoippus, for these were left the principal of his guardians. It was not an easy task for a man in his ninetieth year, beset night and day by the winning artifices of women, to disenthral his judgment, and to consult only the good of the state in his domestic affairs. Accordingly, all he did was to leave fifteen guardians over his son, whom he entreated, on his death-bed, to preserve inviolate that alliance with the Romans, which he had himself cultivated for fifty years, and to take care that the young king should, above all things, tread in the steps of his father, and in that course of conduct in which he had been educated. Such were his injunctions. On the death of the king, the will was brought forward by the guardians, and the young king, who was now about fifteen, introduced into the public assembly, where a few persons, who had been placed in different parts on purpose to raise acclamations, expressed their approbation of the will; while all the rest were overwhelmed with apprehensions, in the destitute condition of the state, which had lost as it were its parent. The funeral of the king was then performed, which was honoured more by the love and affection of his citizens than the attentions of his kindred. Andranodorus next effected the removal of the other guardians, giving out that Hieronymus had now attained the years of manhood, and was competent to assume the government; and thus, by voluntarily resigning the guardianship which he shared with several others, united the powers of all in himself.

In Sicily, the death of Hiero and the transfer of power to his grandson, Hieronymus, completely changed everything for the Romans. Hieronymus was just a boy, barely able to handle freedom, let alone sovereign power. His guardians and friends noticed that he had a nature that could easily be led into all kinds of vices. Anticipating this, Hiero is said to have intended, towards the end of his long life, to leave Syracuse free, fearing that the sovereignty he had established honorably would be mismanaged and fall into chaos under a boy's rule. His daughters strongly opposed this plan, as they expected that while the boy would hold the title of king, they and their husbands, Andranodorus and Zoippus—his main guardians—would actually run the affairs. For a man in his nineties, constantly surrounded by persuasive women, it wasn’t easy to keep his judgment clear and focus solely on the state's good in domestic matters. Therefore, he left fifteen guardians for his son and, on his deathbed, urged them to maintain the alliance with the Romans that he had worked on for fifty years and to ensure that the young king followed in his father's footsteps and adhered to the principles he had been taught. Such were his instructions. After the king’s death, the guardians presented his will, and the now fifteen-year-old king was brought into the public assembly, where a few people placed there to cheer showed their support for the will, while the rest were filled with anxiety over the state’s loss, as if it had lost its parent. The king's funeral was held, honored more by the love and affection of his citizens than by his relatives' attention. Then Andranodorus managed to remove the other guardians, claiming that Hieronymus had reached adulthood and was fit to take charge. By stepping down from the shared guardianship, he consolidated all the power in himself.

5

It would scarcely have been easy even for any good and moderate king, succeeding one so deeply rooted in their affections as Hiero was, to obtain the favour of the Syracusans. But Hieronymus, forsooth, as if he was desirous of exciting regret for the loss of his grandfather by his own vices, showed, immediately on his first appearance, how completely every thing was changed. For those who for so many years had seen Hiero and his son Gelon differing from the rest of the citizens neither in the fashion of their dress nor any other mark of distinction, now beheld the purple, the diadem, and armed guards, and their king sometimes proceeding from his palace in a chariot drawn by four white horses, according to the custom of the tyrant Dionysius. This costliness in equipage and appearance was accompanied by corresponding contempt of everybody, capricious airs, insulting expressions, difficulty of access, not to strangers only, but even to his guardians also, unheard of lusts, inhuman cruelty. Terror so great took possession of every body therefore, that some of his guardians, either by a voluntary death, or by exile, anticipated the tenor of his inflictions. Three of those persons to whom alone belonged a more familiar access to the palace, Andranodorus and Zoippus, sons-in-law of Hiero, and one Thraso, were not much attended to upon other subjects, but the two former exerting themselves in favour of the Carthaginians, while Thraso argued for the Roman alliance, they sometimes engaged the attention of the young king by their zeal and earnestness. It was at this time that a conspiracy formed against the life of the tyrant was discovered by a certain servant, of the same age as Hieronymus, who from his very childhood had associated with him on entirely familiar terms. The informer was able to name one of the conspirators, Theodotus, by whom he himself had been solicited. He was immediately seized, and delivered to Andranodorus to be subjected to torture, when, without hesitation, he confessed as to himself, but concealed his accomplices. At last, when racked with every species of torture, beyond the power of humanity to bear, pretending to be overcome by his sufferings, he turned his accusation from the guilty to the innocent, and feigned that Thraso was the originator of the plot, without whose able guidance, he said, they never would have been bold enough to attempt so daring a deed, he threw the guilt upon such innocent men, near the king's person, as appeared to him to be the most worthless, while fabricating his story amid groans and agonies. The naming of Thraso gave the highest degree of credibility to the story in the mind of the tyrant. Accordingly he was immediately given up to punishment, and others were added who were equally innocent. Not one of the conspirators, though their associate in the plot was for a long time subjected to torture, either concealed himself or fled, so great was their confidence in the fortitude and fidelity of Theodotus, and so great was his firmness in concealing their secret.

It wouldn’t have been easy for any decent and fair king, succeeding someone as well-loved as Hiero, to win the favor of the Syracusans. But Hieronymus, wanting to stir up nostalgia for his grandfather's leadership with his own faults, quickly demonstrated how completely things had changed. Those who had watched Hiero and his son Gelon for years, who had stood out from the rest of the citizens by their simple dress and lack of distinction, now saw the purple robe, the crown, and armed guards, with their king sometimes leaving his palace in a chariot pulled by four white horses, just like the tyrant Dionysius. This opulence was matched by a blatant disregard for everyone, unpredictable behaviors, insulting remarks, and difficulty in accessing him, not just for strangers but even for his own guardians, alongside unbridled desires and inhumane cruelty. A deep terror gripped everyone, leading some of his guards to take their own lives or flee to avoid his wrath. Three individuals with more privileged access to the palace—Andranodorus and Zoippus, Hiero's sons-in-law, and Thraso—were often overlooked on various matters. However, the first two gained the young king's attention with their advocacy for the Carthaginians, while Thraso pushed for an alliance with the Romans. During this time, a conspiracy against the tyrant’s life was uncovered by a young servant who had grown up close with Hieronymus. This informant was able to name one of the conspirators, Theodotus, who had approached him for help. He was quickly captured and brought to Andranodorus for interrogation. He immediately confessed about himself but kept his accomplices hidden. Eventually, after enduring tortures that no one could survive, he pretended to yield to his pain, shifting the blame from his co-conspirators to the innocent, falsely claiming that Thraso had masterminded the plot, asserting that they wouldn't have dared to take such a risk without his guidance. He attributed the wrongdoing to those near the king who seemed worthless while fabricating his story amidst screams and agony. By naming Thraso, he lent undue credibility to his tale in the tyrant's eyes. Accordingly, Thraso was swiftly punished, and others who were equally innocent joined him. None of the conspirators, even though their fellow plotter endured torture for a long time, either hid or ran away, so confident were they in Theodotus's strength and loyalty, and so resolute was he in guarding their secret.

6

Thus on the removal of Thraso, who formed the only bond which held together the alliance with the Romans, immediately affairs clearly indicated defection. Ambassadors were sent to Hannibal, who sent back in company with a young man of noble birth named Hannibal, Hippocrates and Epicydes, natives of Carthage, and of Carthaginian extraction on their mother's side, but whose grandfather was an exile from Syracuse. Through their means an alliance was formed between Hannibal and the tyrant of Syracuse; and, with the consent of Hannibal, they remained with the tyrant. As soon as Appius Claudius, the praetor, whose province Sicily was, had received information of these events, he sent ambassadors to Hieronymus; who, upon stating that the object of their mission was to renew the alliance which had subsisted between the Romans and his grandfather, were heard and dismissed in an insulting manner, Hieronymus asking them sneeringly, "how they had fared at the battle of Cannae? for that the ambassadors of Hannibal stated what could hardly be credited." He said, "he wished to know the truth, in order that before he made up his mind, he might determine which he should espouse as offering the better prospect." The Romans replied, that they would return to him when he had learned to receive embassies with seriousness; and, after having cautioned, rather than requested him, not rashly to change his alliance, they withdrew. Hieronymus sent ambassadors to Carthage, to conclude a league in conformity with the alliance with Hannibal. It was settled in the compact, that after they had expelled the Romans from Sicily, (which would speedily be effected if the Carthaginians sent ships and troops,) the river Himera, which divides the island in nearly equal portions, should be the limit of the Carthaginian and Syracusan dominions. Afterwards, puffed up by the flattery of those persons who bid him be mindful, not of Hiero only, but of king Pyrrhus, his maternal grandfather, he sent another embassy, in which he expressed his opinion that equity required that the whole of Sicily should be conceded to him, and that the dominion of Italy should be acquired as the peculiar possession of the Carthaginians. This levity and inconstancy of purpose in a hot-headed youth, did not excite their surprise, nor did they reprove it, anxious only to detach him from the Romans.

Thus, after Thraso was removed—the only person keeping the alliance with the Romans intact—things quickly took a turn towards betrayal. Ambassadors were sent to Hannibal, who returned with a nobleman named Hannibal, along with Hippocrates and Epicydes, both from Carthage and of Carthaginian descent on their mother’s side, although their grandfather had been exiled from Syracuse. Through them, an alliance was formed between Hannibal and the tyrant of Syracuse. With Hannibal's approval, they stayed with the tyrant. When Appius Claudius, the praetor in charge of Sicily, learned about these events, he sent ambassadors to Hieronymus. When they explained that their mission was to renew the alliance that had previously existed between the Romans and his grandfather, they were dismissed in a disrespectful manner, with Hieronymus mockingly asking how they had fared at the battle of Cannae, given that Hannibal's ambassadors relayed information that seemed almost unbelievable. He remarked that he wanted to know the truth, so he could decide which side offered the better prospects before making his choice. The Romans replied that they would come back when he was ready to receive diplomatic missions seriously and, after cautioning him—rather than requesting him—not to rashly switch his allegiance, they left. Hieronymus then sent ambassadors to Carthage to finalize a treaty in line with the alliance with Hannibal. They agreed that after driving the Romans out of Sicily—something they believed could happen quickly if the Carthaginians provided ships and troops—the river Himera, which nearly divides the island in half, would mark the boundary between Carthaginian and Syracusan territories. Later, encouraged by those who reminded him not only of Hiero but also of King Pyrrhus, his maternal grandfather, he sent another diplomatic mission. In this, he argued that fairness required the entire island of Sicily to be granted to him and that the control of Italy should belong exclusively to the Carthaginians. This fickleness and indecisiveness in a hot-headed young man didn’t surprise them, nor did they criticize it; they were simply eager to win him away from the Romans.

7

But every thing conspired to hurry him into perdition. For having sent before him Hippocrates and Epicydes with two thousand armed men, to make an attempt upon those cities which were occupied by Roman garrisons, he himself also proceeded to Leontium with all the remaining troops, which amounted to fifteen thousand foot and horse, when the conspirators (who all happened to be in the army) took possession of an uninhabited house, which commanded a narrow way, by which the king was accustomed to go to the forum. The rest stood here prepared and armed, waiting for the king to pass by. One of them, by name Dinomenes, as he was one of the body-guards, had the task assigned him of keeping back the crowd behind in the narrow way, upon some pretext, when the king approached the door. All was done according to the arrangement. Dinomenes having delayed the crowd, by pretending to lift up his foot and loosen a knot which was too tight, occasioned such an interval, that an attack being made upon the king, as he passed by unattended by his guards, he was pierced with several wounds before any assistance could be brought. When the shout and tumult was heard, some weapons were discharged on Dinomenes, who now openly opposed them; he escaped from them, however, with only two wounds. The body-guard, as soon as they saw the king prostrate, betook themselves to flight. Of the assassins, some proceeded to the forum to the populace, who were rejoiced at the recovery of their liberty; others to Syracuse to anticipate the measures of Andranodorus and the rest of the royal party. Affairs being in this uncertain state, Appius Claudius perceiving a war commencing in his neighbourhood, informed the senate by letter, that Sicily had become reconciled to the Carthaginians and Hannibal. For his own part, in order to frustrate the designs of the Syracusans, he collected all his forces on the boundary of the province and the kingdom. At the close of this year, Quintus Fabius, by the authority of the senate, fortified and garrisoned Puteoli, which, during the war, had begun to be frequented as an emporium. Coming thence to Rome to hold the election, he appointed the first day for it which could be employed for that purpose, and, while on his march, passed by the city and descended into the Campus Martius. On that day, the right of voting first having fallen by lot on the junior century of the Anien tribe, they appointed Titus Otacilius and Marcus Aemilius Regillus, consuls, when Quintus Fabius, having obtained silence, delivered the following speech:

But everything worked against him, pushing him toward his downfall. After sending Hippocrates and Epicydes ahead with two thousand armed men to attack the cities held by Roman troops, he also moved to Leontium with the rest of his forces, which totaled fifteen thousand foot soldiers and cavalry. Meanwhile, the conspirators, who were all part of the army, took over an empty house that overlooked a narrow path the king typically used to reach the forum. They positioned themselves there, armed and ready, waiting for the king to pass by. One of them, named Dinomenes, who was one of the king’s bodyguards, was tasked with holding back the crowd in the narrow path under some pretext as the king approached the entrance. Everything went according to plan. Dinomenes delayed the crowd by pretending to adjust his foot and loosen a tight knot, creating just enough gap for them to launch an attack on the king as he walked by without his guards. He was struck with several wounds before anyone could come to his aid. As shouts and chaos erupted, some weapons were directed at Dinomenes, who had now openly opposed them; he managed to escape with only two wounds. Once the bodyguards saw the king down, they fled. Some of the assassins moved to the forum to join the people, who were thrilled at regaining their freedom; others rushed to Syracuse to preempt the actions of Andranodorus and the rest of the royal supporters. With things in disarray, Appius Claudius, noticing that a war was starting nearby, informed the senate via letter that Sicily had made peace with the Carthaginians and Hannibal. To disrupt the plans of the Syracusans, he gathered all his forces at the border between the province and the kingdom. At the end of that year, Quintus Fabius, acting on the senate's authority, fortified and garrisoned Puteoli, which had begun to serve as a trading hub during the war. Afterward, he traveled to Rome to hold elections, choosing the first possible day for them. During his journey, he passed by the city and went down into the Campus Martius. On that day, the right to vote fell to the junior century of the Anien tribe, who elected Titus Otacilius and Marcus Aemilius Regillus as consuls. Quintus Fabius then called for silence and delivered the following speech:

8

"If we had either peace in Italy, or had war with such an enemy that the necessity to be careful was less urgent than it is, I should consider that man as wanting in respect for your liberty, who would at all impede that zealous desire which you bring with you into the Campus Martius, of conferring honours on whom you please. But since during the present war, and with the enemy we have now to encounter, none of our generals have ever committed an error which has not been attended with most disastrous consequences to us, it behoves you to use the same circumspection in giving your suffrages for the creation of consuls, which you would exert were you going armed into the field of battle. Every man ought thus to say to himself I am nominating a consul who is to cope with the general Hannibal. In the present year, at Capua, when Jubellius Taurea, the most expert horseman of the Campanians, gave a challenge, Claudius Asellus, the most expert among the Roman horsemen, was pitted against him. Against the Gaul who at a former period gave a challenge on the bridge of the Amo, our ancestors sent Titus Manlius, a man of resolute courage and great strength. It was for the same reason, I cannot deny it, that confidence was placed in Marcus Valerius, not many years ago, when he took arms against a Gaul who challenged him to combat in a similar manner. In the same manner as we wish to have our foot and horse more powerful, but if that is impracticable, equal in strength to the enemy, so let us find out a commander who is a match for the general of the enemy. Though we should select the man as general whose abilities are greater than those of any other in the nation, yet still he is chosen at a moment's warning, his office is only annual; whereas he will have to cope with a veteran general who has continued in command without interruption, unfettered by any restrictions either of duration or of authority, which might prevent him from executing or planning every thing according as the exigencies of the war shall require. But with us the year is gone merely in making preparations, and when we are only commencing our operations. Having said enough as to what sort of persons you ought to elect as consuls, it remains that I should briefly express my opinion of those on whom the choice of the prerogative century has fallen. Marcus Aemilius Regillus is flamen of Quirinus, whom we can neither send abroad nor retain at home without neglecting the gods or the war. Otacilius is married to my sister's daughter, and has children by her, but the favours you have conferred upon me and my ancestors, are not such as that I should prefer private relationship to the public weal. Any sailor or passenger can steer the vessel in a calm sea, but when a furious storm has arisen, and the vessel is hurried by the tempest along the troubled deep, then there is need of a man and pilot We are not sailing on a tranquil sea, but have already well nigh sunk with repeated storms, you must therefore employ the utmost caution and foresight in determining who shall sit at the helm Of you, Titus Otacilius, we have had experience in a business of less magnitude, and, certainly you have not given us any proof that we ought to confide to you affairs of greater moment The fleet which you commanded this year we fitted out for three objects: to lay waste the coast of Africa, to protect the shores of Italy, but, above all, to prevent the conveyance of reinforcements with pay and provisions from Carthage to Hannibal. Now if Titus Otacilius has performed for the state, I say not all, but any one of these services, make him consul But if, while you had the command of the fleet supplies of whatever sort were conveyed safe and untouched to Hannibal, even as though he had no enemy on the sea, if the coast of Italy has been more infested this year than that of Africa, what can you have to urge why you should be preferred before all others as the antagonist of Hannibal? Were you consul, we should give it as our opinion that a dictator should be appointed in obedience to the example of our ancestors Nor could you feel offended that some one in the Roman nation was deemed superior to you in war It concerns yourself more than any one else, Titus Otacilius, that there be not laid upon your shoulders a burthen under which you would fall I earnestly exhort you, that with the same feelings which would influence you if standing armed for battle, you were called upon suddenly to elect two generals, under whose conduct and auspices you were to fight, you would this day elect your consuls, to whom your children are to swear allegiance, at whose command they are to assemble, and under whose protection and care they are to serve. The Trasimene Lake and Cannae are melancholy precedents to look back upon, but form useful warnings to guard against similar disasters Crier, call back the younger century of the Amen tribe to give their votes again"

"If we had peace in Italy or were at war with an enemy that didn’t require as much caution, I would think anyone who interfered with your strong desire to honor whomever you choose in the Campus Martius disrespects your freedom. But since we're currently at war and facing a formidable enemy, none of our generals have made a mistake that hasn’t led to disastrous outcomes for us. Therefore, you must be just as careful when voting for consuls as you would be if you were going into battle. Each of you should think, 'I am choosing a consul who must confront the general Hannibal.' This year, at Capua, when Jubellius Taurea, the best horseman of the Campanians, issued a challenge, Claudius Asellus, the top Roman horseman, was matched against him. When a Gaul once challenged our ancestors on the Amo bridge, they sent out Titus Manlius, a man of great courage and strength. This is also why confidence was placed in Marcus Valerius not long ago when he took up arms against a Gaul who challenged him similarly. Just as we want our infantry and cavalry to be strong, or at least equal to the enemy, we need to find a commander who can match the enemy’s general. Even if we choose the best candidate for general, he will be selected quickly, and his term is just one year. Meanwhile, he’ll have to face a veteran general who has been in command without interruption and without limitations on his authority to act according to the war's needs. In contrast, we spend our year preparing and just starting our operations. I’ve said enough about the type of people you should elect as consuls, so now I’ll briefly share my thoughts on those whom the prerogative century has considered. Marcus Aemilius Regillus is the flamen of Quirinus, whom we can neither send away nor keep here without failing the gods or the war. Otacilius is married to my sister's daughter and has children with her, but the favors you’ve granted me and my family are not enough for me to prioritize personal connections over the public good. Any sailor or passenger can navigate a ship in calm waters, but when a fierce storm arises and the ship is tossed around, that's when we need a skilled pilot. We are not on calm seas; we’re close to sinking after repeated storms, so we must be extremely careful and thoughtful about who will take the helm. We have experienced Titus Otacilius in a smaller matter, and you certainly have not shown us that you can handle greater issues. The fleet you commanded this year was set up for three purposes: to devastate the African coast, to protect Italy’s shores, and, most importantly, to prevent reinforcements with supplies from Carthage to Hannibal. If Titus Otacilius has done any of these for the state, I say make him consul. But if under your command, resources were successfully delivered to Hannibal as if he had no enemy at sea, and if the Italian coast was worse hit this year than Africa, why should you be preferred over others as Hannibal’s opponent? If you were consul, we would suggest appointing a dictator, following our ancestors' example. You shouldn’t feel offended if someone else among the Romans is considered superior to you in war. It’s more important for you, Titus Otacilius, that you do not carry a burden that could overwhelm you. I strongly urge you to approach this decision with the same mindset you would have if suddenly called to vote for two generals to lead you into battle. You would choose consuls today whom your children will pledge their allegiance to, whom they will assemble under, and for whom they will serve and be protected. The tragedies of Lake Trasimene and Cannae are reminders to avoid similar disasters. Crier, call back the younger century of the Amen tribe to vote again."

9

Titus Otacilius, vociferating in the most furious manner, that his object was to continue in the consulship, the consul ordered the lictors to go to him, and as he had not entered the city, but had proceeded directly without halting from his march to the Campus Martius, admonished him that the axes were in the fasces which were carried before him. The prerogative century proceeded to vote a second time, when Quintus Fabius Maximus for the fourth time, and Marcus Marcellus for the third time, were created consuls. The other centuries voted for the same persons without any variation. One praetor, likewise, Quintus Fulvius Flaccus, was re-elected; the other new ones who were chosen, were Titus Otacilius Crassus a second time, Quintus Fabius, son of the consul, who was at that time curule aedile, and Publius Cornelius Lentulus. The election of the praetors completed, a decree of the senate was passed, that Quintus Fulvius should have the city department out of the ordinary course, and that he in preference to any other should command in the city while the consuls were absent in the war. Great floods happened twice during this year, and the Tiber overflowed the fields, with great demolition of houses and destruction of men and cattle. In the fifth year of the second Punic war Quintus Fabius Maximus for the fourth time, and Marcus Claudius Marcellus for the third time, entering upon their office, drew the attention of the state upon them in a more than ordinary degree, for there had not been two such consuls now for many years. The old men observed, that thus Maximus Rullus and Publius Decius were declared consuls for conducting the Gallic war; that thus afterwards Papirius and Carvilius were appointed to that office against the Samnites, the Bruttians, and the Lucanian with the Tarentine people. Marcellus, who was with the army, was created consul in his absence; to Fabius, who was present and held the election himself, the office was continued. The critical state of affairs, the exigencies of the war, and the danger which threatened the state, prevented any one from looking narrowly into the precedent, or suspecting that the consul was actuated by an excessive love of command; on the contrary, they applauded his magnanimity in that when he knew the state was in want of a general of the greatest ability, and that he was himself confessedly such an one, he thought less of the personal odium which might arise out of the transaction, than of the good of the state.

Titus Otacilius, shouting furiously that his goal was to stay in the consulship, prompted the consul to send the lictors to him. Since he hadn’t entered the city but had gone straight to the Campus Martius without stopping, the consul reminded him that there were axes in the fasces carried before him. The centurion group voted a second time, re-electing Quintus Fabius Maximus for the fourth time and Marcus Marcellus for the third time as consuls. The other voting groups chose the same candidates without any changes. Additionally, one praetor, Quintus Fulvius Flaccus, was re-elected; the newly elected ones included Titus Otacilius Crassus for a second time, Quintus Fabius, the consul’s son, who was then curule aedile, and Publius Cornelius Lentulus. After the praetors were elected, the Senate passed a decree that Quintus Fulvius should manage the city matters out of the ordinary procedure and that he should have priority over anyone else to command the city while the consuls were away at war. There were major floods twice that year, with the Tiber overflowing the fields, causing significant damage to houses and loss of life among people and livestock. In the fifth year of the Second Punic War, Quintus Fabius Maximus was serving as consul for the fourth time, and Marcus Claudius Marcellus for the third, bringing significant attention to the state, as it had been years since there were two such consuls. The older members noted that Maximus Rullus and Publius Decius were previously elected consuls to lead the Gallic war; later, Papirius and Carvilius were chosen to fight against the Samnites, Bruttians, Lucanians, and the Tarentines. Marcellus was made consul while he was with the army, and Fabius, who was present and held the election himself, continued in office. The serious state of affairs, the needs of the war, and the threats facing the state prevented anyone from scrutinizing the precedent or suspecting that the consul was driven by a strong desire for power; instead, they praised his nobility in realizing that the state urgently needed a highly skilled leader, and even though he acknowledged he was that leader, he prioritized the state’s welfare over any personal backlash that might follow.

10

On the day on which the consuls entered on their office, the senate was assembled in the Capitol, and in the first place a decree was passed to the effect that the consuls should draw lots, and settle between themselves which should hold the election for the creation of censors, before they proceeded to join the army. Next, all those who had the command of armies were continued in their offices, and ordered to remain in their provinces; Tiberius Gracchus at Luceria, where he was with an army of volunteer slaves; Caius Terentius Varro in the Picenian, and Manius Pomponius in the Gallic territory. Of the praetors of the former year, it was settled that Quintus Mucius should have the government of Sardinia as propraetor, Marcus Valerius the command of the sea-coast near Brundusium, watchful against all the movements of Philip, king of the Macedonians. To Publius Cornelius Lentulus, the praetor, the province of Sicily was assigned. Titus Otacilius received the same fleet which he had employed the year before against the Carthaginians. Many prodigies were reported to have happened this year, which increased in proportion as they were believed by the credulous and superstitious. That crows had built a nest within the temple of Juno Sospita at Lanuvium; that a green palm-tree had taken fire in Apulia; that a pool at Mantua, formed by the overflowing of the river Mincius, had assumed the appearance of blood; that it had rained chalk at Cales, and blood at Rome in the cattle market; that a fountain under ground in the Istrian street had discharged so violent a stream of water, that rolling along with the impetuosity of a torrent, it carried away the butts and casks which were near it; that the public court in the Capitol had been struck by lightning; also the temple of Vulcan in the Campus Martius, a nut-tree in the Sabine territory, a wall and gate at Gabii. Now other miracles were published: that the spear of Mars at Praeneste moved forward of its own accord; that in Sicily an ox had spoken; that a child in the womb of its mother cried out Io Triumphe! in the country of the Marrucinians; at Spoletum, that a woman was transformed into a man; at Hadria, that an altar, with appearances as of men surrounding it in white clothing, was seen in the heavens. Nay, even in the city of Rome itself, after a swarm of bees had been seen in the forum, some persons roused the citizens to arms, affirming that they saw armed legions on the Janiculum; but those who were on the Janiculum at the time, declared that they had seen no person there besides the usual cultivators of the hill. These prodigies were expiated by victims of the larger kind, according to the response of the aruspices; and a supplication was ordered to all the deities who had shrines at Rome.

On the day the consuls took office, the senate gathered in the Capitol, and first, they passed a decree stating that the consuls should draw lots to decide who would oversee the election for the appointment of censors before they joined the army. Next, all those commanding armies were to keep their positions and remain in their provinces: Tiberius Gracchus in Luceria with an army of volunteer slaves; Caius Terentius Varro in Picenum; and Manius Pomponius in Gaul. Among the praetors from the previous year, it was decided that Quintus Mucius would govern Sardinia as pro-praetor, Marcus Valerius would command the coastline near Brundusium, keeping watch on any movements from Philip, the king of Macedon. Publius Cornelius Lentulus, the praetor, was assigned to the province of Sicily. Titus Otacilius retained the same fleet he had used the previous year against the Carthaginians. Many strange occurrences were reported this year, increasing in number as the superstitious and gullible began to believe them. Crows had nested in the temple of Juno Sospita at Lanuvium; a green palm tree caught fire in Apulia; a pool in Mantua, created by the overflow of the river Mincius, looked like blood; there was a rain of chalk at Cales, and blood in the cattle market in Rome; a fountain in the Istrian street erupted with such force that it swept away nearby barrels; the public court in the Capitol was struck by lightning, along with the temple of Vulcan in the Campus Martius, a nut tree in the Sabine territory, a wall, and a gate at Gabii. Other wonders were reported as well: the spear of Mars in Praeneste moved on its own; an ox in Sicily spoke; a fetus cried out "Io Triumphe!" in the Marrucinian territory; in Spoleto, a woman transformed into a man; at Hadria, an altar with figures that looked like men in white clothing was seen in the sky. Even in Rome, after a swarm of bees appeared in the forum, some stirred the citizens to arms, claiming they saw armed legions on the Janiculum; however, those on the Janiculum at that time reported seeing no one but the usual farmers on the hill. These omens were atoned for with large sacrifices, according to the instructions of the augurs; and a prayer was ordered to all the gods with shrines in Rome.

11

The ceremonies which were intended to propitiate the gods being completed, the consuls took the sense of the senate on the state of the nation, the conduct of the war, what troops should be employed, and where they were severally to act. It was resolved that eighteen legions should be engaged in the war; that the consuls should take two each; that two should be employed in each of the provinces of Gaul, Sicily, and Sardinia; that Quintus Fabius, the praetor, should have the command of two in Apulia, and Tiberius Gracchus of two legions of volunteer slaves in the neighbourhood of Luceria; that one each should be left for Caius Terentius, the proconsul, for Picenum, and to Marcus Valerius for the fleet off Brundusium, and two for the protection of the city. To complete this number of legions six fresh ones were to be enlisted, which the consuls were ordered to raise as soon as possible; and also to prepare the fleet, so that, together with the ships which were stationed off the coasts of Calabria, it might amount that year to one hundred and fifty men of war. The levy completed, and the hundred new ships launched, Quintus Fabius held the election for the creation of censors, when Marcus Atilius Regulus and Publius Furius Philus were chosen. A rumour prevailing that war had broken out in Sicily, Titus Otacilius was ordered to proceed thither with his fleet; but as there was a deficiency of sailors, the consuls, in conformity with a decree of the senate, published an order that those persons who themselves or whose fathers had been rated in the censorship of Lucius Aemilius and Caius Flaminius, at from fifty to one hundred thousand asses, or whose property had since reached that amount, should furnish one sailor and six months' pay; from one to three hundred thousand, three sailors with a year's pay; from three hundred thousand to a million, five sailors; above one million, seven sailors; that senators should furnish eight sailors with a year's pay. The sailors furnished according to this proclamation being armed and equipped by their masters, embarked with cooked provisions for thirty days. Then first it happened that the Roman fleet was manned at the expense of individuals.

The ceremonies meant to please the gods were finished, and the consuls consulted the senate about the state of the nation, the conduct of the war, which troops should be used, and where each should be deployed. It was decided that eighteen legions would be involved in the war; that each consul would take two; that two would be assigned to each of the provinces of Gaul, Sicily, and Sardinia; that Quintus Fabius, the praetor, would command two in Apulia, and Tiberius Gracchus would oversee two legions of volunteer slaves near Luceria; that one each would be allocated to Caius Terentius, the proconsul, for Picenum, and to Marcus Valerius for the fleet off Brundusium, with two designated for the protection of the city. To make up this number of legions, six new ones needed to be recruited, which the consuls were instructed to raise as soon as possible; and they were also tasked with preparing the fleet, so that, along with the ships stationed off the coasts of Calabria, it would total one hundred and fifty warships that year. Once the recruitment was completed, and the hundred new ships launched, Quintus Fabius conducted the election for new censors, and Marcus Atilius Regulus and Publius Furius Philus were chosen. With a rumor circulating that war had broken out in Sicily, Titus Otacilius was ordered to head there with his fleet; however, due to a shortage of sailors, the consuls, following a decree from the senate, issued a mandate that those individuals or their fathers who had been assessed during the censorship of Lucius Aemilius and Caius Flaminius at amounts from fifty to one hundred thousand asses, or whose property had since reached that value, were required to provide one sailor and six months' pay; those with property from one to three hundred thousand had to provide three sailors with a year’s pay; from three hundred thousand to a million, five sailors; over a million, seven sailors; and senators were to supply eight sailors with a year’s pay. The sailors provided under this proclamation were armed and equipped by their masters and set sail with provisions for thirty days. For the first time, the Roman fleet was manned at the expense of individuals.

12

These unusually great preparations alarmed the Campanians particularly, lest the Romans should commence the year's campaign with the siege of Capua. They therefore sent ambassadors to Hannibal, to implore him to bring his army to Capua, and tell him that new armies were levying at Rome for the purpose of besieging it; and that there was not any city the defection of which had excited more hostile feelings. As they announced this with so much fear, Hannibal concluded he must make haste lest the Romans should get there before him; and setting out from Arpi, took up his position in his old camp at Tifata, above Capua. Leaving his Numidians and Spaniards for the protection both of the camp and Capua, he went down thence with the rest of his troops to the lake Avernus on the pretence of performing sacrifice, but in reality to make an attempt upon Puteoli and the garrison in it. Maximus, on receiving intelligence that Hannibal had set out from Arpi, and was returning to Campania, went back to his army, pursuing his journey without intermission by night or by day. He also ordered Tiberius Gracchus to bring up his troops from Luceria to Beneventum, and Quintus Fabius the praetor, the son of the consul, to go to Luceria in the room of Gracchus. At the same time the two praetors set out for Sicily, Publius Cornelius to join his army, Otacilius to take the command of the sea-coast and the fleet; the rest also proceeded to their respective provinces, and those who were continued in command remained in the same countries as in the former year.

These unusually large preparations particularly alarmed the Campanians, who were worried that the Romans would start the year's campaign by laying siege to Capua. They sent ambassadors to Hannibal, asking him to bring his army to Capua, informing him that new troops were being raised in Rome to besiege the city and that no city had caused more hostility due to its defection. As they expressed their fear, Hannibal realized he needed to act quickly to get there before the Romans did. He left Arpi and set up camp again at Tifata, overlooking Capua. He left his Numidians and Spaniards to guard both the camp and Capua while taking the rest of his troops down to Lake Avernus under the pretense of making a sacrifice, but actually aiming to attack Puteoli and its garrison. Maximus, upon hearing that Hannibal had left Arpi and was heading back to Campania, returned to his army, traveling continuously day and night. He also instructed Tiberius Gracchus to move his troops from Luceria to Beneventum, and ordered Quintus Fabius, the praetor and son of the consul, to go to Luceria in Gracchus's place. At the same time, the two praetors departed for Sicily: Publius Cornelius to join his army, and Otacilius to take command of the coast and the fleet. The others also went to their respective provinces, and those who remained in command continued in the same locations as the previous year.

13

While Hannibal was at the lake Avernus, five noble youths came to him from Tarentum. They had been made prisoners partly at the lake Trasimenus, and partly at Cannae, and had been sent home by the Carthaginian with the same civility which he had shown towards all the Roman allies. They stated to him that, impressed with gratitude for his favours, they had succeeded in inducing a large portion of the Tarentine youth to prefer his alliance and friendship to that of the Romans; and that they were sent by their countrymen as ambassadors to request Hannibal to bring his forces nearer to Tarentum; that if his standards and camp were within sight of Tarentum, that city would be delivered into his hands without delay; that the commons were under the influence of the youth, and the state of Tarentum in the hands of the commons. Hannibal after bestowing the highest commendations upon them, and loading them with immense promises, bid them return home to mature their plans, saying that he would be there in due time. With these hopes, the Tarentines were dismissed. Hannibal had himself conceived the strongest desire of getting possession of Tarentum. He saw that it was a city opulent and celebrated, on the coast, and lying conveniently over against Macedonia. And that as the Romans were in possession of Brundusium, king Philip would make for this port if he crossed over into Italy. Having completed the sacrifice for which he came, and during his stay there laid waste the territory of Cumae as far as the promontory of Misenum, he suddenly marched his troops thence to Puteoli to surprise the Roman garrison there. It consisted of six thousand men, and the place was secured not only by its natural situation, but by works also. The Carthaginian having waited there three days, and attempted the garrison in every quarter, without any success, proceeded thence to devastate the territory of Naples, influenced by resentment more than the hope of getting possession of the place. The commons of Nola, who had been long disaffected to the Romans and at enmity with their own senate, moved into the neighbouring fields on his approach; and in conformity with this movement ambassadors came to invite Hannibal to join them, bringing with them a positive assurance that the city would be surrendered to him. The consul, Marcellus, who had been called in by the nobles, anticipated their attempt. In one day he had reached Suessula from Cales, though the river Vulturnus had delayed him crossing; and from thence the ensuing night introduced into Nola for the protection of the senate, six thousand foot and three hundred horse. The dilatoriness of Hannibal was in proportion to the expedition which the consul used in every thing he did in order to preoccupy Nola. Having twice already made the attempt unsuccessfully, he was slower to place confidence in the Nolans.

While Hannibal was at Lake Avernus, five young nobles came to him from Tarentum. They had been captured partly at Lake Trasimene and partly at Cannae, and the Carthaginian had sent them home with the same kindness he showed to all the Roman allies. They told him that, feeling grateful for his favor, they had convinced many of the Tarentine youth to prefer his alliance over that of the Romans. They were sent by their fellow countrymen as ambassadors to ask Hannibal to move his forces closer to Tarentum; they believed that if his banners and camp were visible from the city, it would quickly fall into his hands. The common people were influenced by the youth, and Tarentum's fate lay in the hands of those commoners. After praising them highly and promising them great rewards, Hannibal told them to return home and develop their plans, assuring them he would come at the right time. With these hopes, the Tarentines left. Hannibal himself was intensely eager to capture Tarentum. He recognized it as a wealthy and renowned city located on the coast, conveniently opposite Macedonia. Since the Romans had control of Brundusium, King Philip would likely aim for that port if he crossed into Italy. After completing the sacrifice for which he came and destroying the territory of Cumae up to the promontory of Misenum, he suddenly marched his troops to Puteoli to surprise the Roman garrison there. The garrison consisted of six thousand men and was fortified not only by its natural defenses but also by man-made ones. The Carthaginian waited there for three days, trying every tactic against the garrison without success, and then moved to ravage the territory of Naples, driven more by anger than hope of capturing the place. The common people of Nola, who had long been unhappy with the Romans and opposed to their own senate, moved to the nearby fields as he approached. Following this, ambassadors came to invite Hannibal to join them, bringing a firm assurance that the city would surrender to him. The consul, Marcellus, who had been called in by the nobles, anticipated their move. In one day, he reached Suessula from Cales, despite delays caused by the river Vulturnus, and that night brought six thousand infantry and three hundred cavalry into Nola for the protection of the senate. Hannibal's delay was proportional to the speed with which the consul acted to secure Nola. Having already tried and failed twice, he was more hesitant to trust the people of Nola.

14

During the same time, the consul, Fabius, came to attempt Casilinum, which was occupied by a Carthaginian garrison; and, as if by concert, Hanno approached Beneventum on one side from the Bruttians, with a large body of foot and horse, while on the other side Gracchus approached it from Luceria. The latter entered the town first. Then, hearing that Hanno had pitched his camp three miles from the city, at the river Calor, and from thence was laying waste the country, he himself marched without the walls, and pitching his camp about a mile from the enemy, harangued his soldiers. The legions he had consisted for the most part of volunteer slaves, who chose rather to earn their liberty silently by another year's service, than demand it openly. The general, however, on quitting his winter quarters, had perceived that the troops murmured, asking when the time would arrive that they should serve as free citizens. He had written to the senate, stating not so much what they wanted as what they had deserved; he said they had served him with fidelity and courage up to that day, and that they wanted nothing but liberty, to bring them up to the model of complete soldiers. Permission was given him to act in the business as he thought for the interest of the state, and, accordingly, before he engaged with the enemy, he declared that the time was now arrived for obtaining that liberty which they had so long hoped for; that on the following day he should fight a pitched battle on a level and open plain, in which the contest would be decided by valour only, without any fear of ambuscade. The man who should bring back the head of an enemy, he would instantly order to be set free; but that he would punish, in a manner suited to a slave, the man who should quit his post; that every man's fortune was in his own hands; that not he himself alone would authorize their enfranchisement, but the consul, Marcus Marcellus, and the whole body of the fathers, who, on being consulted by him on the subject, had left the matter to his disposal. He then read the letter of the consul and the decree of the senate, on which they raised a general shout of approbation, demanded to be led to battle, and vehemently urged him to give the signal forthwith. Gracchus broke up the assembly, after proclaiming the battle for the following day. The soldiers, highly delighted, particularly those whose enfranchisement was to be the reward of one day's prowess, employed the remaining time in getting ready their arms.

During the same time, the consul, Fabius, tried to take Casilinum, which was held by a Carthaginian garrison; and, almost as if it was planned, Hanno approached Beneventum from the Bruttians, with a large group of infantry and cavalry, while Gracchus came from Luceria on the opposite side. Gracchus entered the town first. After hearing that Hanno had set up camp three miles from the city, at the river Calor, and was ravaging the countryside, he marched outside the walls, pitched his camp about a mile from the enemy, and addressed his soldiers. Most of his legions were made up of volunteer slaves, who preferred to earn their freedom quietly by serving for another year rather than openly demanding it. However, after leaving his winter quarters, the general noticed that the troops were grumbling, asking when they would finally be able to serve as free citizens. He wrote to the senate, highlighting not what they wanted but what they had earned; he stated that they had served him faithfully and bravely up to that day and that all they desired was liberty to make them true soldiers. Permission was granted for him to proceed as he saw fit for the state's interests, and before he engaged with the enemy, he declared that the time had come to obtain the freedom they had long hoped for; that the next day he would fight a pitched battle on an open and level field, where the outcome would depend solely on courage, without any fear of ambush. He promised that anyone who returned with the head of an enemy would be set free immediately; however, he would punish anyone who abandoned their post as a slave would be punished, stressing that every person's fate was in their own hands. He stated that he alone wouldn't grant their freedom, but that the consul, Marcus Marcellus, and the entire senate had left the matter in his hands when he consulted them. He then read the consul's letter and the senate's decree, which made them all cheer in approval, as they urged him to lead them into battle and demanded he give the signal without delay. Gracchus ended the assembly after announcing the battle for the following day. The soldiers, especially those whose freedom would depend on one day's valor, eagerly prepared their weapons during the remaining time.

15

The next day, as soon as the trumpets began to sound, they were the first to assemble at the general's tent, armed and ready for action. When the sun had risen, Gracchus led out his troops to the field of battle; nor did the enemy delay to engage him. His troops consisted of seventeen thousand infantry, principally Bruttians and Lucanians, with twelve hundred horse, among which were very few Italians, almost all the rest being Numidians and Moors. The contest was fierce and protracted. For four hours neither side had the advantage, nor did any other circumstance more impede the Romans, than that the heads of their enemies were made the price of their liberty. For when each man had gallantly slain his enemy, first, he lost time in cutting off his head, which was done with difficulty amid the crowd and confusion, and secondly, all the bravest troops ceased to be engaged in fight, as their right hands were employed in holding the heads; and thus the battle was left to be sustained by the inactive and cowardly. But when the military tribunes reported to Gracchus that the soldiers were employed not in wounding any of the enemy who were standing, but in mangling those who were prostrate, their right hands being occupied in holding the heads of men instead of their swords, he promptly ordered a signal to be given that they should throw down the heads and charge the enemy; that they had given evident and signal proofs of valour, and that the liberty of such brave men was certain. Then the fight was revived, and the cavalry also were sent out against the enemy. The Numidians engaging them with great bravery, and the contest between the cavalry being carried on with no less spirit than that between the infantry, the victory again became doubtful; when, the generals on both sides vilifying their opponents, the Roman saying, that their enemies were Bruttians and Lucanians, who had been so often vanquished and subjugated by their ancestors; the Carthaginian, that the troops opposed to them were Roman slaves, soldiers taken out of a workhouse; at last Gracchus exclaimed, that his men had no ground to hope for liberty unless the enemy were routed and put to flight that day.

The next day, as soon as the trumpets started sounding, they were the first to gather at the general's tent, armed and ready for action. When the sun came up, Gracchus led his troops to the battlefield; the enemy wasted no time in engaging him. His army consisted of seventeen thousand infantry, mostly Bruttians and Lucanians, along with twelve hundred cavalry, which included very few Italians, almost all the rest being Numidians and Moors. The battle was intense and long. For four hours, neither side gained an advantage, and the only thing hindering the Romans more was the fact that the heads of their enemies were the price of their freedom. After each soldier bravely killed his opponent, he lost time trying to cut off the head, which was difficult amidst the chaos, and, furthermore, all the bravest troops stopped fighting, as their right hands were busy holding the heads; thus, the battle was left to be fought by those who were inactive and cowardly. When the military tribunes informed Gracchus that the soldiers were not wounding any of the standing enemies but were instead mutilating those who were down, with their right hands occupied holding heads instead of swords, he immediately ordered a signal to be given for them to drop the heads and charge the enemy; that they had already shown clear and strong evidence of bravery, and that the freedom of such courageous men was assured. The fight resumed, and the cavalry was also sent out against the enemy. The Numidians engaged them with great courage, and the clash between the cavalry was just as spirited as that of the infantry, making victory uncertain again; as the generals on both sides insulted each other, the Roman claimed their enemies were Bruttians and Lucanians, who had been defeated and dominated by their ancestors many times; while the Carthaginian stated that the troops facing them were Roman slaves, soldiers taken from a workhouse; finally, Gracchus shouted that his men had no reason to expect freedom unless the enemy was defeated and put to flight that day.

16

These words at length kindled their courage so effectually, and renewing the shout, as if suddenly changed into other men, they bore down upon the enemy with such impetuosity that they could not longer be withstood. First, of the Carthaginians who stood before the standards; then the standards were thrown into disorder; and lastly the whole line was compelled to give way. They then turned their backs downright, and fled precipitately to their camp with such terror and consternation, that not a man made stand in the gates or on the rampart; while the Romans, who pursued them so close as to form almost a part of their body commenced the battle anew, enclosed within the rampart of the enemy. Here the battle was more bloody as the combatants had less room to move, from the narrowness of the place in which they fought. The prisoners too assisted; for snatching up swords in the confusion, and forming themselves into a body, they slew the Carthaginians in the rear and prevented their flight. Thus less than two thousand men out of so large an army, and those principally cavalry, effected their escape with their commander, all the rest were slain or taken prisoners. Thirty-eight standards were taken. Of the victors about two thousand fell. All the booty except that of the prisoners was given up to the soldiery. Such cattle also as the owners should identify within thirty days was excepted. When they returned to their camp loaded with spoil, about four thousand of the volunteer slaves who had fought with less spirit, and had not joined in breaking into the enemy's camp, through fear of punishment, took possession of a hill not far from the camp. Being brought down thence the next day by a military tribune, it happened that they arrived during an assembly of the soldiers which Gracchus had called. At this assembly the proconsul, having first rewarded the veteran soldiers with military presents, according to the valour displayed, and the service rendered by each man in the engagement, then observed, with respect to the volunteer slaves, that he would rather that all should be praised by him whether deserving it or not, than that any one should be chastised on that day. I bid you, said he, all be free, and may the event be attended with advantage, happiness, and prosperity to the state and to yourselves. These words were followed by the most cordial acclamations, the soldiers sometimes embracing and congratulating one another, at other times lifting up their hands to heaven, and praying that every blessing might attend the Roman people, and Gracchus in particular; when Gracchus addressed them thus: "Before I had placed you all on an equal footing with respect to the enjoyment of liberty, I was unwilling to affix any marks by which the brave and dastardly soldier might be distinguished. But now the pledge given by the state being redeemed, lest all distinction between courage and cowardice should disappear, I shall order that the names of those persons be laid before me, who, conscious of their dastardly conduct in the battle, have lately seceded. I shall have them cited before me, when I shall bind them by an oath, that none of them, except such as shall have the plea of sickness, will, so long as they serve, take either meat or drink in any other posture than standing. This penalty you will bear with patience when you reflect that it is impossible your cowardice could be marked with a slighter stigma." He then gave the signal for packing up the baggage; and the soldiers, sporting and jesting as they drove and carried their booty, returned to Beneventum in so playful a mood, that they appeared to be returning, not from the field of battle, but from a feast celebrated on some remarkable holiday. All the Beneventans pouring out in crowds to meet them at the gate, embraced, congratulated, and invited the troops to entertainments. They had all prepared banquets in the courts of their houses, to which they invited the soldiers, and of which they entreated Gracchus to allow them to partake. Gracchus gave permission, with the proviso that they should feast in the public street. Each person brought every thing out before his door. The volunteers feasted with caps of liberty on their heads, or filletted with white wool; some reclining at the tables, others standing, who at once partook of the repast, and waited upon the rest. It even seemed a fitting occasion that Gracchus, on his return to Rome, should order a picture representing the festivities of that day to be executed in the temple of Liberty, which his father caused to be built on the Aventine out of money arising from fines, and which his father also dedicated.

These words ignited their courage so effectively that, renewing their shouts as if they had suddenly transformed into different people, they charged at the enemy with such force that they could no longer be stopped. First, they broke through the Carthaginians standing before the standards; then the standards were thrown into chaos; finally, the entire line was forced to retreat. They turned and fled back to their camp in such terror and panic that no one held their ground at the gates or on the ramparts. Meanwhile, the Romans pursued them so closely that they almost became one with the fleeing troops and began the battle again, now enclosed within the enemy's fortifications. The fight was more brutal here due to the confined space, which limited movement. The prisoners also joined the fray; seizing swords amidst the chaos, they formed a group and attacked the Carthaginians from behind, preventing their escape. Thus, fewer than two thousand men managed to escape from such a large army, most of them cavalry, alongside their commander, while the rest were killed or captured. They took thirty-eight standards. Among the victors, about two thousand were lost. All the loot, except for that of the prisoners, was given to the soldiers. Livestock that owners could identify within thirty days was also excluded from the spoils. When they returned to their camp laden with goods, about four thousand volunteer slaves who had fought less vigorously and did not participate in the assault on the enemy's camp, fearing punishment, took refuge on a nearby hill. The next day, a military tribune brought them down just in time for an assembly of the soldiers called by Gracchus. During this meeting, the proconsul first rewarded the veteran soldiers with military honors based on their displayed bravery and contributions during the battle. He then addressed the volunteer slaves, stating that he preferred to praise everyone, whether they deserved it or not, rather than punish anyone that day. "I decree that all of you are free," he said, "and may this event bring benefit, happiness, and prosperity to both the state and you." His words were met with enthusiastic cheers, with soldiers embracing and congratulating each other, sometimes raising their hands to the heavens in prayer for every blessing to be bestowed upon the Roman people and Gracchus in particular. Gracchus then continued, "Before I gave you all equal rights to liberty, I didn’t want to mark the brave and cowardly soldiers apart. But now that the state has honored its promise, to prevent the disappearance of distinction between courage and cowardice, I'll require that those who, ashamed of their cowardly actions in battle, have recently backed away from duty, present their names to me. I will summon them to take an oath that none of them, except those sick, will eat or drink in any position other than standing while they serve. You will endure this penalty patiently, knowing that it is a minor consequence for your cowardice." He then signaled for the soldiers to pack up the baggage, and as they joked and played while carrying their spoils, they returned to Beneventum in such a cheerful mood that it seemed as if they were coming back from a celebration rather than a battlefield. The Beneventans welcomed them at the gate in droves, embracing them, celebrating, and inviting the troops to their feasts. They had all prepared banquets in their courtyards and urged Gracchus to allow them to join. Gracchus consented, on the condition that they feast in the public street. Each person brought everything outside their door. The volunteers celebrated with liberty caps on their heads or braided with white wool; some reclined at the tables while others stood, enjoying the meals and serving the rest. It even seemed an appropriate moment for Gracchus, upon his return to Rome, to order a painting of the day's festivities to be created in the temple of Liberty, which his father had built on the Aventine using funds from fines, and which his father had also dedicated.

17

While these events occurred at Beneventum, Hannibal having laid waste the territory of Naples, moved his camp to Nola. The consul, as soon as he was aware of his approach, sent for Pemponius the propraetor, with the troops he had in the camp above Suessula; and then prepared to meet the enemy and to make no delay in fighting. He sent out Caius Claudius Nero in the dead of night with the main strength of the cavalry, through the gate which was farthest removed from the enemy, with orders to make a circuit so as not to be observed, and then slowly to follow the enemy as they moved along, and as soon as he perceived the battle begun, to charge them on the rear. Whether Nero was prevented from executing these orders by mistaking the route, or from the shortness of the time, is doubtful. Though he was absent when the battle was fought, the Romans had unquestionably the advantage; but as the cavalry did not come up in time, the plan of the battle which had been agreed upon was disconcerted and Marcellus, not daring to follow the retiring enemy, gave the signal for retreat when his soldiers were conquering More than two thousand of the enemy are said, however, to have fallen on that day; of the Romans, less than four hundred. Nero, after having fruitlessly wearied both men and horses, through the day and night, without even having seen the enemy, returned about sunset; when the consul went so far in reprimanding him as to assert, that he had been the only obstacle to their retorting on the enemy the disaster sustained at Cannae. The following day the Roman came into the field, but the Carthaginian, beaten even by his own tacit confession, kept within his camp. Giving up all hope of getting possession of Nola, a thing never attempted without loss, during the silence of the night of the third day he set out for Tarentum, which he had better hopes of having betrayed to him.

While these events were happening in Beneventum, Hannibal devastated the area around Naples and then moved his camp to Nola. As soon as the consul learned of his approach, he called for Pemponius the propraetor and the troops stationed at the camp near Suessula. He then got ready to confront the enemy without delay. He sent out Caius Claudius Nero late at night with the main cavalry through the gate farthest from the enemy, instructing him to take a circuitous route to avoid detection and then quietly follow the enemy; he was to attack their rear as soon as he saw the battle begin. It's unclear whether Nero got lost or if time was too short, but he didn’t execute these orders. Although the Romans had the upper hand during the battle, the cavalry did not arrive in time, disrupting their planned strategy. Marcellus, hesitant to pursue the retreating enemy, signaled a retreat while his soldiers were winning. It’s said that more than two thousand of the enemy fell that day, while the Romans lost fewer than four hundred. After exhausting both his men and horses throughout the day and night without even encountering the enemy, Nero returned around sunset. The consul criticized him harshly, claiming that he was the only reason they couldn’t retaliate against the enemy for the loss at Cannae. The next day, the Romans returned to the field, but the Carthaginian, admitting defeat, remained in his camp. Realizing he had no chance of taking Nola—something that always came at a cost—he set out for Tarentum under the cover of darkness on the third day, where he believed he had a better chance of receiving help.

18

Nor were the Roman affairs administered with less spirit at home than in the field. The censors being freed from the care of letting out the erection of public works, from the low state of the treasury, turned their attention to the regulation of men's morals, and the chastisement of vices which sprung up during the war, in the same manner as constitutions broken down by protracted disease, generate other maladies. In the first place, they cited those persons who, after the battle of Cannae, were said to have formed a design of abandoning the commonwealth, and leaving Italy. The chief of these was Lucius Caecilius Metellus, who happened to be then quaestor. In the next place, as neither he nor the other persons concerned were able to exculpate themselves on being ordered to make their defence, they pronounced them guilty of having used words and discourse prejudicial to the state, that a conspiracy might be formed for the abandonment of Italy. After them were cited those persons who showed too much ingenuity in inventing a method of discharging the obligation of their oath, namely, such of the prisoners as concluded that the oath which they had sworn to return, would be fulfilled by their going back privately to Hannibal's camp, after setting out on their journey. Such of these and of the above-mentioned as had horses at the public expense were deprived of them, and all were degraded from their tribes and disfranchised. Nor was the attention of the censors confined to the regulation of the senate and the equestrian order. They erased from the lists of the junior centuries the names of all who had not served during the last four years, unless they were regularly exempted, or were prevented by sickness. Those too, amounting to more than two thousand names, were numbered among the disfranchised, and were all degraded. To this more gentle stigma affixed by the censors, a severe decree of the senate was added, to the effect that all those whom the censor had stigmatized, should serve on foot, and be sent into Sicily to join the remains of the army of Cannae, a class of soldiers whose time of service was not to terminate till the enemy was driven out of Italy. The censors, in consequence of the poverty of the treasury, having abstained from receiving contracts for the repairs of the sacred edifices, the furnishing of curule horses, and similar matters, the persons who had been accustomed to attend auctions of this description, came to the censors in great numbers, and exhorted them to "transact all their business and let out the contracts in the same manner as if there were money in the treasury. That none of them would ask for money out of the treasury before the war was concluded." Afterwards the owners of those slaves whom Tiberius Sempronius had manumitted at Beneventum, came to them, stating that they were sent for by the public bankers, to receive the price of their slaves, but that they would not accept of it till the war was concluded. This disposition on the part of the commons to sustain the impoverished treasury having manifested itself, the property of minors first, and then the portions of widows, began to be brought in; the persons who brought them being persuaded, that their deposit would no where be more secure and inviolable than under the public faith. If any thing was bought or laid in for the widows and minors, an order upon the quaestor was given for it. This liberality in individuals flowed from the city into the camp also, insomuch that no horseman or centurion would accept of his pay, and those who would accept it were reproached with the appellation of mercenary men.

The Roman affairs were just as spirited at home as they were in the field. The censors, no longer focused on public works due to the treasury's lack of funds, shifted their attention to regulating morals and punishing the vices that had emerged during the war, similar to how a body weakened by a long illness develops other ailments. First, they summoned those individuals who supposedly plotted to abandon the republic and leave Italy after the Battle of Cannae. The main figure among them was Lucius Caecilius Metellus, who was then the quaestor. When neither he nor the other accused could clear themselves when asked to defend their actions, they were found guilty of making statements harmful to the state, showing intent to conspire to abandon Italy. Next, they called out those who cleverly tried to escape their oath, particularly the prisoners who believed they could fulfill their sworn duty to return by secretly going back to Hannibal's camp after leaving. Those among them and the previously mentioned individuals who had received public horses were stripped of them, and all were removed from their tribes and lost their voting rights. The censors didn’t stop with just the senate and the equestrian order. They removed from the lists of junior centuries all those who had not served in the last four years, unless they were formally exempted or unable to serve due to illness. This group, totaling over two thousand names, was also disenfranchised and demoted. To this lighter punishment from the censors, the senate added a harsh decree that required all those marked by the censors to serve on foot and be sent to Sicily to join what was left of the army from Cannae, a unit whose service would only end once the enemy was driven out of Italy. Due to the treasury's poverty, the censors refrained from accepting contracts for repairing sacred buildings, providing curule horses, and similar tasks. Many who usually attended these auctions approached the censors in large numbers, urging them to "go about their business and issue contracts as if there were money in the treasury, assuring them none would ask for funds before the war was over." Later, the owners of slaves manumitted by Tiberius Sempronius in Beneventum came to the censors, stating they were summoned by public bankers to collect the price for their slaves but refused to accept it until the war ended. This willingness among the common people to support the struggling treasury became evident as the property of minors and then the shares of widows began to be contributed, with the contributors believing their assets would be safest under public protection. If anything was purchased for the widows and minors, an order was given to the quaestor for it. This spirit of generosity from the citizens reached the camp as well, to the point where no horseman or centurion would accept their pay, and those who did were criticized as mercenaries.

19

Quintus Fabius, the consul, was encamped before Casilinum, which was occupied by a garrison of two thousand Campanians and seven hundred of the soldiers of Hannibal. The commander was Statius Metius, who was sent there by Cneius Magius Atellanus, who was that year Medixtuticus and was arming the slaves and people without distinction, in order to assault the Roman camp, while the consul was intently occupied in the siege of Casilinum. None of these things escaped Fabius. He therefore sent to his colleague at Nola, "That another army was requisite, which might be opposed to the Campanians, while the siege of Casilinum was going on; that either he should come himself, leaving a force sufficient for the protection of Nola, or if the state of Nola required him to stay there, in consequence of its not being yet secure against the attempts of Hannibal, that he should summon Tiberius Gracchus, the proconsul, from Beneventum." On this message, Marcellus, leaving two thousand troops in garrison at Nola, came to Casilinum with the rest of his forces; and at his arrival the Campanians, who were already in motion, desisted from their operations. Thus the siege of Casilinum was commenced by the two consuls. But as the Roman soldiers received many wounds as they rashly approached the walls, and as they did not succeed satisfactorily in their attempts. Fabius gave it as his opinion that this, which was a small matter, though as difficult as more important ones, should be abandoned, and that they should retire from the place, as affairs of greater moment were pressing. Marcellus, however, succeeded in persuading him that they should not go away with their object unaccomplished, observing that as there were many objects which great generals should not attempt, so when once attempted they should not be abandoned, because the mere report in either case would have important consequences. Upon this the vineae and all kinds of military works and engines were applied; in consequence of which, the Campanians entreated Fabius to allow them to retire to Capua in safety; when a few of them having come out of the town, Marcellus took possession of the gate through which they passed, and first slew all indiscriminately who were near the gate, and then rushing in, the slaughter commenced in the town also. About fifty of the Campanians, who at first came out of the city, having fled for refuge to Fabius, arrived safe at Capua under his protection. Thus Casilinum was captured on an accidental opportunity which occurred during the conferences and delay of those who were soliciting protection. The prisoners, both those who were Campanians and those who were Hannibal's soldiers, were sent to Rome, where they were shut up in a prison. The crowd of townsmen was distributed among the neighbouring people to be kept in custody.

Quintus Fabius, the consul, was camped outside Casilinum, which was held by a garrison of two thousand Campanians and seven hundred of Hannibal's soldiers. The commander was Statius Metius, appointed by Cneius Magius Atellanus, who that year was Medixtuticus and was arming slaves and people indiscriminately to attack the Roman camp, while the consul was focused on laying siege to Casilinum. Fabius noticed all of this. He then sent a message to his colleague at Nola, stating, "Another army is needed to counter the Campanians while we continue the siege of Casilinum; either come yourself, leaving enough troops to protect Nola, or if Nola needs you there because it isn't yet secure from Hannibal's attempts, summon Tiberius Gracchus, the proconsul, from Beneventum." In response to this message, Marcellus left two thousand troops stationed at Nola and joined his other forces at Casilinum; upon his arrival, the Campanians, who were already mobilizing, halted their efforts. Thus, the siege of Casilinum began with the two consuls together. However, because the Roman soldiers sustained many injuries as they recklessly approached the walls and did not achieve satisfactory results, Fabius suggested they abandon this minor but challenging task and withdraw, as more important matters required their attention. Marcellus, though, convinced him that they shouldn't leave without accomplishing their goal, pointing out that there are many tasks that great generals shouldn't attempt, but once they have begun, they shouldn't give up, because the mere attempt in either scenario can have significant repercussions. Following this, various military works and siege engines were deployed, prompting the Campanians to request Fabius allow them to leave for Capua safely; when a few of them exited the town, Marcellus seized the gate they used to escape, killing all nearby indiscriminately, and then rushed in, leading to a slaughter in the town as well. About fifty Campanians who initially fled to Fabius found refuge and made it safely to Capua under his protection. This is how Casilinum was captured during a chance moment that arose amid negotiations and the delays of those seeking protection. The prisoners, both Campanian and Hannibal's soldiers, were sent to Rome and locked up in a prison. The townspeople were distributed among the surrounding communities to be held in custody.

20

At the same time that the consuls retired from Casilinum, their object having been accomplished, Gracchus, who was in Lucania, sent, under a prefect of the allies, some cohorts which he had levied in that country to ravage the lands of the enemy. These, as they were straggling in a careless manner, Hanno surprising, retorted upon his enemy a defeat not much less disastrous than he had himself received at Beneventum, and then hastily retired to the territory of the Bruttians, lest Gracchus should overtake him. Of the consuls, Marcellus returned to Nola, whence he had come, Fabius proceeded to Samnium to waste the lands, and recover by force the cities which had revolted. The Samnites of Caudium suffered the severest devastation; their fields were laid waste by fire for a wide extent, and both men and cattle were conveyed away as booty. The towns of Compulteria, Telesia, Compsa, Melae, Fulfulae, and Orbitanium, were taken by storm. Blandae, belonging to the Lucanians, and Aecae to the Apulians, were taken after a siege. Twenty-five thousand of the enemy were captured or slain in these towns, and three hundred and seventy deserters recovered; who, being sent to Rome by the consul, were all of them beaten with rods in the comitium, and thrown down from the rock. Such were the achievements of Fabius within the space of a few days. Ill health detained Marcellus from active operations at Nola. The town of Accua also was taken by storm, during the same period, by the praetor Quintus Fabius, whose province was the neighbourhood of Luceria; he also fortified a stationary camp at Ardonea. While the Romans were thus employed in different quarters, Hannibal had reached Tarentum, utterly destroying every thing whichsoever way he went. In the territory of Tarentum, the troops at length began to march in a peaceable manner. There nothing was violated, nor did they ever go out of the road; it was evident that this was done not from the moderation of the soldiery, or their general, but to conciliate the affections of the Tarentines. However, on advancing almost close to the walls without perceiving any movement, which he expected would occur on the sight of his vanguard, he pitched his camp about a mile off the city. Three days before the arrival of Hannibal, Marcus Livius, who had been sent by Marcus Valerius, the propraetor, commanding the fleet at Brundusium, had enlisted the young nobility of Tarentum, and stationing guards at every gate, and round the walls, wherever circumstances made it necessary, had kept such a strict watch both by day and night, as to give no opportunity for making any attempt either to the enemy or doubtful allies. On this account several days were consumed there to no purpose, when Hannibal, as none of those who had come to him at the lake Avernus, either came themselves or sent any letter or message, perceiving that he had carelessly followed delusive promises, moved his camp thence. Even after this he did not offer any violence to the Tarentine territory, not quitting the hope of shaking their allegiance to the Romans, though his simulated lenity had hitherto been of no advantage to him; but as soon as he came to Salapia he collected stores of corn there from the Metapontine and Heraclean lands; for midsummer was now past, and the situation pleased him as a place for winter quarters. From hence the Moors and Numidians were detached to plunder the territory of Sallentum, and the neighbouring woods of Apulia, from which not much booty of any other sort was obtained, but principally droves of horses, four thousand of which were distributed among his horsemen to be broken.

At the same time the consuls left Casilinum, having achieved their goal, Gracchus, who was in Lucania, sent some cohorts he had raised in that area under an allied prefect to plunder enemy lands. Hanno surprised them while they were wandering carelessly and dealt a defeat on his enemy that was almost as disastrous as the one he had faced at Beneventum. He then quickly retreated to Bruttian territory to avoid being caught by Gracchus. Of the consuls, Marcellus returned to Nola, from where he had come, while Fabius went to Samnium to destroy lands and forcibly reclaim the cities that had revolted. The Samnites of Caudium faced the worst destruction; their fields were set on fire extensively, and both men and animals were taken as loot. The towns of Compulteria, Telesia, Compsa, Melae, Fulfulae, and Orbitanium were captured. Blandae, which belonged to the Lucanians, and Aecae, to the Apulians, were taken after being besieged. Twenty-five thousand enemies were either captured or killed in these towns, and three hundred seventy deserters were also recovered; they were sent to Rome by the consul, beaten with rods in the comitium, and thrown off the rock. Such were Fabius's accomplishments in just a few days. Marcellus couldn't take part in active operations at Nola due to ill health. During this time, the praetor Quintus Fabius also stormed the town of Accua, which was near Luceria, and he established a stationary camp at Ardonea. While the Romans were occupied in different areas, Hannibal reached Tarentum, completely destroying everything in his path. In the territory of Tarentum, the troops began to march peacefully. There was no destruction, and they kept to the road; it was clear this was not due to the soldiers' or their general’s moderation but to win over the Tarentines. However, when he got close to the walls and noticed nothing happening, which he had anticipated upon seeing his advance guard, he set up camp about a mile away from the city. Three days before Hannibal arrived, Marcus Livius, sent by Marcus Valerius, the propraetor in charge of the fleet at Brundusium, had recruited the young nobility of Tarentum. He positioned guards at every gate and around the walls wherever necessary, maintaining such a tight watch day and night that neither the enemy nor potential allies had any opportunity to make a move. Because of this, several days were wasted; when Hannibal noticed that none of those who had come to him at Lake Avernus either showed up or sent any messages, he realized he had foolishly followed false promises and moved his camp away. Even after this, he did not harm the Tarentine territory, still hopeful of winning their loyalty from the Romans, even though his feigned kindness had not benefited him so far; but as soon as he reached Salapia, he began gathering grain from the Metapontine and Heraclean lands since midsummer had passed and he deemed it a suitable spot for winter quarters. From there, he sent Moors and Numidians to raid the territory of Sallentum and the nearby woods of Apulia, where they didn’t gather much other loot but mainly captured horses, distributing four thousand of them among his cavalry to be trained.

21

The Romans, since a war by no means to be despised was springing up in Sicily, and the death of the tyrant had furnished the Syracusans with more enterprising leaders, rather than changed their attachment to the Carthaginian cause, or the state of their minds, decreed that province to Marcus Marcellus, one of their consuls. After the assassination of Hieronymus, at first a tumult had taken place among the soldiery in the territory of the Leontines. They exclaimed furiously that the manes of the king should be appeased with the blood of the conspirators. Afterwards the frequent repetition of the word liberty, which was restored to them, a word so delightful to the ear, the hopes they had conceived of largesses from the royal treasury, and of serving in future under better generals, the relation of the horrid crimes and more horrid lusts of the tyrant, effected such an alteration in their sentiments, that they suffered to lie unburied the corpse of the king, whom a little before they regretted. As the rest of the conspirators remained behind, in order to keep the army on their side, Theodotus and Sosis, mounted on the king's horses, rode off to Syracuse with all possible speed, that they might surprise the king's party, while unacquainted with all that had occurred. But they were anticipated not only by report, than which nothing is swifter in such affairs, but also by a messenger who was one of the royal servants. In consequence, Andranodorus had occupied with strong garrisons the Insula and the citadel, and every other convenient part which he could. After sunset, when it was now growing dark, Theodotus and Sosis rode in by the Hexapylum, and displayed the royal vest stained with blood, and the ornament of the king's head; then passing through the Tycha, and calling the people at once to liberty and arms, bid them assemble in the Achradina. Some of the multitude ran out into the streets, some stood in the porches of their houses, while others looked out from the roofs and windows, and inquired what was the matter. Every part of the city was filled with lights and noises of various kinds. Assemblies of armed men were formed in the open spaces. Those who had no arms tore down from the temple of the Olympian Jupiter the spoils of the Gauls and Illyrians, which had been presented to Hiero by the Roman people, and hung up there by him; at the same time offering up prayers to Jupiter, that he would willingly, and without feeling offence, lend those consecrated weapons to those who were arming themselves in defence of their country, of the temples of their gods, and their liberty. This multitude was also joined by the watches which were stationed through the principal quarters of the city. In the island, Andranodorus, among other places, secured the public granaries by a garrison. This place, which was enclosed by a wall of stones hewn square, and built up on high, after the manner of a citadel, was occupied by a body of youth, who had been appointed to garrison it, and these sent messengers to the Achradina, to give information that the granaries and the corn were in the power of the senate.

The Romans, faced with a war they couldn’t ignore that was brewing in Sicily, and with the death of the tyrant providing the Syracusans with more ambitious leaders, rather than shifting their loyalty from the Carthaginian cause or changing their mindset, assigned the province to Marcus Marcellus, one of their consuls. After Hieronymus was assassinated, a disturbance initially erupted among the soldiers in the Leontine territory. They furiously declared that the spirit of the king should be appeased with the blood of the conspirators. However, the repeated mention of the word freedom, which had been restored to them—a term so pleasing to the ear—along with their hopes of receiving riches from the royal treasury and serving under better generals in the future, and the account of the king's horrid crimes and even more horrid desires, shifted their feelings so much that they allowed the corpse of the king, whom they had recently mourned, to remain unburied. While the other conspirators stayed behind to keep the army on their side, Theodotus and Sosis, riding on the king's horses, quickly headed to Syracuse to catch the king’s supporters off guard, unaware of what had just happened. But they were beaten there not only by the speed of rumors, which travel fastest in situations like these, but also by a messenger who was one of the royal attendants. As a result, Andranodorus had stationed strong garrisons at the Insula, the citadel, and other strategic locations he could manage. After sunset, as darkness descended, Theodotus and Sosis entered through the Hexapylum, displaying the royal robe stained with blood and the king's crown. Then, moving through the Tycha, they called out to the people for freedom and arms, urging them to gather in the Achradina. Some of the crowd ran into the streets, some stood in their porches, and others peeked out from roofs and windows, all asking what was happening. Every part of the city filled with lights and noises of various kinds. Groups of armed men formed in the open spaces. Those without weapons tore down from the temple of Olympian Jupiter the trophies of the Gauls and Illyrians, given to Hiero by the Roman people and hung there by him; at the same time, they prayed to Jupiter to graciously lend these consecrated weapons to those gearing up to defend their country, their temples, and their freedom without taking offense. This crowd was also joined by the guards stationed throughout the city’s main quarters. On the island, Andranodorus secured the public granaries with a garrison. This location, surrounded by a high wall of squared stones built like a citadel, was occupied by a group of young men assigned to guard it, who sent messengers to the Achradina to report that the granaries and the food supply were under the control of the senate.

22

At break of day the whole populace, armed and unarmed, assembled at the senate-house in the Achradina: where from the altar of Concord, which stood there, one of the nobles, named Polyaenus, delivered a liberal and temperate address. He said, that "men who had experienced servitude and contumely, were enraged against an evil which was well known, but that the Syracusans had rather heard from their fathers than seen with their own eyes the disasters which civil discord introduces." He said, "he commended them for the alacrity with which they had taken arms; but that he should commend them more if they should abstain from using them unless compelled by extreme necessity. At present he advised that ambassadors should be sent to Andranodorus, to charge him to submit to the direction of the senate and the people, to throw open the gates of the island, and withdraw the garrison. If he resolved to usurp the sovereignty of which he had been appointed guardian, that he would recommend that their liberty be recovered more energetically from Andranodorus than it had been from Hieronymus." From this assembly ambassadors were despatched. The senate began now to meet, which though during the reign of Hiero it had continued to be the public council of the state, from the time of his death up to the present had never been assembled or consulted upon any subject. When the ambassadors came to Andranodorus, he was himself moved by the unanimous opinion of his countrymen, by their having possession of other parts of the city, and by the fact that the strongest part of the island was betrayed and placed in the hands of others; but his wife, Demarata, the daughter of Hiero, still swelling with the pride of royalty and female presumption, called him out from the presence of the ambassadors, and reminded him of the expression so often repeated by the tyrant Dionysius, "that a man ought only to relinquish sovereign power when dragged by the feet, and not while sitting on horseback. That it was an easy thing, at any moment one pleased, to give up possession of grandeur, but that to create and obtain them was difficult and arduous. That he should obtain from the ambassadors a little time to deliberate, and to employ it in fetching the soldiers from the Leontines; to whom, if he promised the royal treasure, every thing would be at his disposal." This advice, suggested by a woman, Andranodorus neither entirely rejected nor immediately adopted, considering it the safer way to the attainment of power to temporize for the present. Accordingly he told the ambassadors to carry word back, that he should act subserviently to the senate and the people. The next day, as soon as it was light, he threw open the gates of the island, and came into the forum of the Achradina; then mounting the altar of Concord, from which Polyaenus had delivered his harangue the day before, he commenced a speech by soliciting pardon for his delay. "He had kept the gates closed," he said, "not as separating his own from the public interest, but from fear as to where the carnage would stop when once the sword was drawn; whether they would be satisfied with the blood of the tyrant, which was sufficient for their liberty, or whether all who were connected with the court, by consanguinity, affinity, or any offices, would, as implicated in another's guilt, be butchered. After he perceived that those who had liberated their country were desirous of preserving it when liberated, and that the counsels of all were directed towards the public good, he had not hesitated to restore to his country his own person and every thing else which had been committed to his honour and guardianship, since the person who had intrusted him with them had fallen a victim to his own madness." Then turning to the persons who had killed the tyrant, and calling on Theodotus and Sosis by name, he said, "You have performed a memorable deed, but believe me, your glory is only beginning, not yet perfected; and there still remains great danger lest the enfranchised state should be destroyed, if you do not provide for its tranquillity and harmony."

At dawn, the entire population, both armed and unarmed, gathered at the senate house in Achradina, where one of the nobles, named Polyaenus, delivered a thoughtful and measured speech from the altar of Concord. He said that "people who have known servitude and shame are angry with a well-known evil, but that the Syracusans have mostly only heard about the disasters caused by civil strife from their ancestors rather than witnessing them firsthand." He praised them for their eagerness to take up arms but said he would praise them even more if they refrained from using them unless absolutely necessary. For now, he suggested sending ambassadors to Andranodorus, urging him to submit to the direction of the senate and the people, to open the gates of the island, and to withdraw the garrison. If he decided to seize the authority he was appointed to protect, he recommended that they work even harder to regain their liberty from Andranodorus than they had from Hieronymus. From this assembly, ambassadors were dispatched. The senate began to assemble, which, although it had served as the public council during Hiero's reign, had not met or been consulted on any matter since his death. When the ambassadors reached Andranodorus, he was swayed by the strong opinion of his fellow countrymen, their control of other parts of the city, and the fact that the strongest section of the island had been betrayed to others. However, his wife Demarata, daughter of Hiero, still full of royal pride and feminine bravado, called him out from the ambassadors' presence and reminded him of the often-repeated saying from the tyrant Dionysius, "A man should only give up power when he is dragged by the feet, not while riding a horse. It's easy to relinquish greatness whenever one wants, but gaining it is tough and laborious. He should ask the ambassadors for a little time to think over the matter, using it to bring in soldiers from the Leontines; if he promised them the royal treasure, he would have everything at his disposal." This advice, which came from a woman, Andranodorus neither fully rejected nor immediately accepted, thinking it safer to be cautious in pursuing power for the moment. So, he told the ambassadors to report back that he would act in accordance with the senate and the people. The next day, as soon as it was light, he opened the gates of the island and entered the Achradina forum. Then, standing on the altar of Concord, where Polyaenus had spoken the day before, he began his speech by asking for forgiveness for his delay. "I kept the gates closed," he said, "not to separate my interests from the public's, but out of fear of where the violence would end once the sword was drawn; whether you would be satisfied with the blood of the tyrant, which was enough for your freedom, or if everyone connected to the court through blood, marriage, or position would be slaughtered as well, implicated in their guilt. After seeing that those who had liberated their country wanted to maintain it once freed, and that everyone's thoughts were focused on the common good, I had no hesitation in returning myself and everything else entrusted to my honor and guardianship, since the person who entrusted them to me had fallen victim to his own madness." Then, turning to those who had killed the tyrant, naming Theodotus and Sosis specifically, he said, "You have done something remarkable, but believe me, your glory is just beginning, not yet complete; and there remains a great risk that the newly freed state could be destroyed if you don't ensure its peace and unity."

23

At the conclusion of this speech, he laid the keys of the gates and of the royal treasure at their feet; and on that day, retiring from the assembly in the highest spirits, they made supplication with their wives and children at all the temples of the gods. On the following day an assembly was held for the election of praetors. Andranodorus was created among the first; the rest consisted for the most part of the destroyers of the tyrant; two of these, Sopater and Dinomenes, they appointed in their absence. These, on hearing of what had passed at Syracuse, conveyed thither the royal treasure which was at Leontini, and put it into the hands of quaestors appointed for that purpose. The treasure also in the island and the Achradina was delivered to them, and that part of the wall which formed too strong a separation between the island and the other parts of the city, was demolished by general consent. Every thing else which was done was in conformity with this inclination of their minds to liberty. Hippocrates and Epicydes, on hearing of the death of the tyrant, which Hippocrates had wished to conceal even by putting the messenger to death, being deserted by the soldiery, returned to Syracuse, as that appeared the safest course under present circumstances; but lest if they appeared there in common they should become objects of suspicion, and looked upon as persons who were seeking an opportunity of effecting some change, they in the first place addressed themselves to the praetors and then through them to the senate. They declared, that "they were sent by Hannibal to Hieronymus, as to a friend and ally; that they had obeyed the orders of that man whom their general wished them to obey; that they desired to return to Hannibal; but as the journey would not be safe, as armed Romans were ranging at large through the whole of Sicily, that they requested to be furnished with some escort which might convey them in safety to Locri in Italy; and that thus they would confer a great obligation upon Hannibal, with little trouble." The request was easily obtained, for they were desirous of getting rid of these generals of the king, who were skilled in war, and at once necessitous and enterprising. But they did not exert themselves so as to effect what they desired with the requisite speed. Meanwhile these young men, who were of a military turn and accustomed to the soldiers, employed themselves in circulating charges against the senate and nobles, sometimes in the minds of the soldiers themselves, sometimes of the deserters, of which the greater part were Roman sailors, at other times of men belonging to the lowest order of the populace, insinuating, that "what they were secretly labouring and contriving to effect, was to place Syracuse under the dominion of the Romans with the pretence of a renewed alliance, and then that faction and the few promoters of the alliance would be supreme."

At the end of this speech, he placed the keys to the gates and the royal treasure at their feet; and that day, leaving the assembly in high spirits, they prayed with their wives and children at all the temples of the gods. The next day, an assembly was held to elect praetors. Andranodorus was chosen among the first; the rest mainly included those who had opposed the tyrant. Two of them, Sopater and Dinomenes, were appointed in their absence. Upon hearing what had happened in Syracuse, they brought the royal treasure from Leontini and handed it over to the quaestors designated for that purpose. The treasure on the island and in Achradina was also given to them, and a section of the wall that created too strong a division between the island and the rest of the city was torn down by common agreement. Everything else that was done aligned with their desire for freedom. Hippocrates and Epicydes, upon learning of the tyrant's death—which Hippocrates had tried to hide even by executing the messenger—were abandoned by their soldiers and returned to Syracuse, as that seemed the safest option given the circumstances. However, to avoid raising suspicion or being seen as plotting a change, they first approached the praetors and then, through them, the senate. They stated that "they were sent by Hannibal to Hieronymus, as a friend and ally; they had followed the orders of the man their general wanted them to obey; they wished to return to Hannibal; but since traveling would not be safe because armed Romans were roaming all over Sicily, they requested an escort to safely take them to Locri in Italy; and that way they would do Hannibal a great favor with little effort." Their request was quickly granted, as the authorities wanted to be rid of these royal generals who were both experienced in warfare and ambitious. However, they did not act with the speed necessary to fulfill their desires. In the meantime, these young military-oriented men, accustomed to soldiers, busied themselves spreading accusations against the senate and nobles, sometimes among the soldiers themselves, sometimes among the deserters, most of whom were Roman sailors, and at other times among those in the lower classes of the populace, suggesting that "what they were secretly working on was to put Syracuse under Roman control under the guise of a renewed alliance, making that faction and the few who supported the alliance supreme."

24

The crowds of persons disposed to hear and credit these insinuations which flowed into Syracuse from every quarter increased daily, and afforded hopes, not only to Epicydes but to Andranodorus also, of effecting a revolution. The latter, wearied at length by the importunities of his wife, who warned him, "that now was the favourable time for seizing the government, while every thing was in confusion in consequence of liberty being recent and not yet regularly established; while a soldiery supported by the royal pay was to be met with, and while generals sent by Hannibal and accustomed to the soldiery might forward the attempt;" he communicated his design with Themistus, who had married the daughter of Gelon, and a few days afterwards incautiously disclosed it to a certain tragic actor, named Ariston, to whom he was in the habit of committing other secrets. He was a man of reputable birth and fortune, nor did his profession disgrace them, for among the Greeks no pursuit of that kind was considered dishonourable. He therefore discovered the plot to the praetors, from a conviction that his country had a superior claim upon his fidelity. These having satisfied themselves that his statement was not false by indubitable proofs, took the advice of the elder senators, and with their sanction, having placed a guard at the doors, slew Themistus and Andranodorus as soon as they had entered the senate-house. A disturbance arising in consequence of this act, which, as none but the praetors knew the cause of it, wore an appearance of atrocity, the praetors, having at length procured silence, introduced the informer into the senate-house; and after he had in a regular manner detailed to the senate every particular, showing that the conspiracy owed its origin to the marriage of Harmonia, the daughter of Gelon, with Themistus; that the African and Spanish auxiliaries had been prepared to murder the praetors and others of the nobility; that it had been given out that their goods were to be the booty of the assassins; that already a band of mercenaries accustomed to obey the command of Andranodorus had been procured for the reoccupation of the island; and having then distinctly represented to them the several parts which the persons implicated in the transaction were performing, and having brought under their view the entire plot prepared for execution with men and arms; it seemed to the senate that they had fallen as justly as Hieronymus had. A shout was raised before the senate-house by a crowd of people variously disposed and uncertain of the facts; but as they were conducting themselves in a furious and menacing manner, the bodies of the conspirators in the vestibule of the senate-house restrained them with such alarm, that they silently followed the more discreet part of the commons to an assembly. Sopater was the person commissioned by the senate and his colleague to explain the affair.

The crowds of people eager to hear and believe these rumors flooding into Syracuse from all directions grew daily, giving hope not just to Epicydes but also to Andranodorus for a chance to start a revolution. Andranodorus, tired of his wife's nagging, who warned him that now was the right moment to seize control while everything was chaotic due to the recent shift in freedom that wasn’t yet stable—when they could count on soldiers supported by royal pay and generals sent by Hannibal who were familiar with military operations—shared his plan with Themistus, who was married to Gelon's daughter. A few days later, he carelessly revealed it to a tragic actor named Ariston, to whom he often confided other secrets. Ariston was from a respectable background and financially stable, and his profession didn’t tarnish that reputation since no such career was considered dishonorable among the Greeks. He then informed the praetors, believing that his loyalty to his country took precedence. After verifying that his claims were true with solid evidence, the praetors consulted with the senior senators and, with their approval, stationed guards at the doors and killed Themistus and Andranodorus as soon as they entered the senate-house. A disturbance ensued because of this action, which appeared brutal since only the praetors knew the cause. Once they managed to quiet the crowd, they brought the informer into the senate-house; he then properly detailed every aspect of the conspiracy, explaining that it originated from the marriage of Harmonia, Gelon's daughter, to Themistus. He revealed that African and Spanish auxiliaries had been prepared to assassinate the praetors and other nobles, that it was believed their assets would be the spoils for the attackers, and that a group of mercenaries loyal to Andranodorus had been gathered to retake the island. After clearly outlining the roles of those involved in the scheme and presenting the entire plot ready for execution with men and arms, the senate concluded that they had fallen justly, like Hieronymus had. A commotion erupted in front of the senate-house from a crowd of diverse opinions and uncertain facts, but as they acted in an angry and threatening manner, the sight of the conspirators' bodies in the vestibule of the senate-house startled them enough to lead them silently to a more prudent assembly. Sopater was the one chosen by the senate and his colleague to explain the situation.

25

Treating them as if they stood upon their trial, he began with their past lives; and insisted that Andranodorus and Themistus were the authors of every act of iniquity and impiety which had been perpetrated since the death of Hiero. "For what," said he, "did the boy Hieronymus ever do of his own accord? What could he do who had scarce as yet arrived at puberty? His tutors and guardians had ruled, while the odium rested on another. Therefore they ought to have been put to death either before Hieronymus or with him. Nevertheless those men, deservedly marked out for death, had attempted fresh crimes after the decease of the tyrant; first openly, when, closing the gates of the island, Andranodorus declared himself heir to the throne, and kept that as proprietor which he had held only in the capacity of guardian; afterwards, when betrayed by those who were in the island and blockaded by the whole body of the citizens who held the Achradina, he endeavoured to obtain, by secret and artful means, that sovereignty which he had in vain attempted openly; whom not even benefits and honorary distinction could move, for even this conspirator against the liberty of his country was created praetor among her liberators. But that wives of royal blood had infected them with this thirst for royalty, one having married the daughter of Hiero, the other the daughter of Gelon." On hearing these words, a shout arose from every part of the assembly, that "none of these women ought to live, and that not one of the royal family should be left alive." Such is the nature of the populace; they are either cringing slaves or haughty tyrants. They know not how with moderation to spurn or to enjoy that liberty which holds the middle place; nor are there generally wanting ministers, the panders to their resentment, who incite their eager and intemperate minds to blood and carnage. Thus, on the present occasion, the praetors instantly proposed the passing of a decree, which was consented to almost before it was proposed, that all the royal family should be put to death; and persons despatched for the purpose by the praetors, put to death Demarata, the daughter of Hiero, and Harmonia, the daughter of Gelon, the wives of Andranodorus and Themistus.

Treating them as if they were on trial, he began with their past actions; and insisted that Andranodorus and Themistus were responsible for every act of wrongdoing and sacrilege that had occurred since Hiero's death. "For what," he asked, "did the boy Hieronymus ever do on his own? What could he do at that age, barely past childhood? His teachers and guardians were in control while the blame fell on someone else. Therefore, they should have been executed either before Hieronymus or alongside him. Yet those men, justly marked for death, committed new crimes after the tyrant's passing; first openly, when Andranodorus closed off the island and claimed the throne, taking possession of what he had only held as a guardian; later, when betrayed by those on the island and surrounded by the entire body of citizens holding the Achradina, he sought to secure, through secret and cunning means, the power he had failed to obtain openly; he was unaffected even by privileges and honors, for this conspirator against his country’s freedom was made praetor among her liberators. But because royal women had infected them with this ambition for power, one marrying Hiero's daughter and the other marrying Gelon’s daughter." Upon hearing these words, a roar erupted from the assembly, demanding that "none of these women should survive, and that not one member of the royal family should be left alive." Such is the nature of the crowd; they become either submissive slaves or arrogant tyrants. They fail to grasp how to both reject or embrace liberty in a balanced way; typically, there are always agents—those who exploit their anger—who fuel their restless and reckless desire for violence and slaughter. Thus, in this instance, the praetors immediately proposed a decree, which was accepted almost before it was suggested, that all members of the royal family should be executed; and those sent by the praetors killed Demarata, the daughter of Hiero, and Harmonia, the daughter of Gelon, the wives of Andranodorus and Themistus.

26

There was a daughter of Hiero, named Heraclea, the wife of Zoippus, who, having been sent by Hieronymus as ambassador to king Ptolemy, had become a voluntary exile. As soon as she was apprized that they were coming to her also, she fled for refuge into the chapel to the household gods, accompanied by her two virgin daughters, with dishevelled hair, and other marks of wretchedness. In addition to this, she had recourse to prayers also; she implored them "by the memory of her father, Hiero, and her brother, Gelon, that they would not suffer her, a guiltless person, to be consumed by their hatred of Hieronymus. That all that she had derived from his reign was the exile of her husband. That neither did she enjoy the same advantages as her sister while Hieronymus was alive, nor was her cause the same as hers now he was dead. What? Though her sister would have shared the throne with Andranodorus, had he succeeded in his designs, she must have been in servitude with the rest. Can any one doubt, that if information should be conveyed to Zoippus that Hieronymus had been put to death, and that Syracuse was free, he would instantly embark and return to his native land. But how are all human hopes deceived! His wife and children are struggling for their lives in his native land, now blessed with liberty! In what manner standing in the way of liberty or the laws? What danger could arise to any one from them, from a solitary, and in a manner, widowed woman and girls living in a state of orphanage? But perhaps it will be granted that no danger is to be apprehended from them, but alleged that the whole royal family is detested. If this were the case, she entreated that they would banish them far from Syracuse and Sicily, and order them to be conveyed to Alexandria, the wife to her husband, the daughters to their father." Seeing that their ears and minds were unimpressed, and that certain of them were drawing their swords to prevent a fruitless consumption of time, she gave over entreating for herself, and began to implore them to "spare, at least, her daughters, at an age which even exasperated enemies spared." She entreated them "that they would not, in their revenge on tyrants, themselves imitate the crimes which were odious to them." While thus employed, they dragged her from the sanctuary and murdered her; and after that they fell upon the virgins, who were sprinkled with the blood of their mother; who, distracted alike by fear and grief, and as if seized with madness, rushed out of the chapel with such rapidity, that had there been an opening by which they might have escaped into the street, they would have filled the city with confusion. As it was, they several times made their escape through the midst of so many armed men with their persons uninjured in the contracted space which the house afforded, and extricated themselves from their grasp, though they had to disengage themselves from so many and such strong hands; but at length enfeebled by wounds, and after covering every place with blood, they fell down lifeless. This murder, piteous as it was in itself, was rendered still more so by its happening that a short time after it a message arrived that they should not be killed, as the minds of the people were now turned to compassion. This compassion then gave rise to a feeling of anger, because so much haste had been shown in carrying the punishment into effect, and because no opportunity was left for relenting or retracing the steps of their passion. The multitude therefore gave vent to their indignation, and demanded an election to supply the places of Andranodorus and Themistus, for both of them had been praetors; an election by no means likely to be agreeable to the praetors.

There was a daughter of Hiero named Heraclea, who was married to Zoippus. She became a voluntary exile after being sent as an ambassador to King Ptolemy by Hieronymus. As soon as she learned that they were coming for her as well, she fled for refuge into the chapel of the household gods, accompanied by her two virgin daughters, with disheveled hair and signs of distress. Besides this, she turned to prayers, begging them "by the memory of her father, Hiero, and her brother, Gelon, to not let her, an innocent person, be consumed by their hatred of Hieronymus. All she had gained from his rule was her husband’s exile. She neither enjoyed the same privileges as her sister while Hieronymus was alive, nor was her situation the same as hers now that he was dead. What if her sister had shared the throne with Andranodorus, had he succeeded in his plans? She would have been in servitude with everyone else. Can anyone doubt that if Zoippus heard news that Hieronymus had been executed and Syracuse was free, he would rush back home? But how quickly human hopes can be dashed! His wife and children are fighting for their lives in their homeland, now blessed with freedom! How could they be a threat to liberty or the laws? What danger could they pose, being just a lonely, effectively widowed woman and her daughters living orphaned? But perhaps it can be argued that while no immediate danger is seen from them, the entire royal family is despised. If that’s true, she pleaded that they send them far away from Syracuse and Sicily, taking the wife to her husband and the daughters to their father." Seeing that they were unmoved and that some were drawing their swords to avoid wasting time, she stopped pleading for herself and began to ask them to "at least spare her daughters, at an age that even hostile enemies would protect." She asked them "not to imitate the very wrongs they despised in their quest for revenge on tyrants." While she was saying this, they pulled her from the sanctuary and killed her; then they attacked the young women, who were drenched in their mother's blood. Distraught with fear and grief, and seeming almost mad, they rushed out of the chapel so quickly that had there been a way to escape into the street, they would have caused chaos in the city. As it was, they escaped several times through a throng of armed men, unharmed in the small space of the house, managing to break free from so many strong hands; but eventually, weakened by wounds and leaving a trail of blood everywhere, they collapsed lifeless. This murder, already tragic in itself, became even more so when word arrived shortly after that they should not have been killed, as the people’s minds were now leaning towards compassion. This compassion then turned into anger, realizing how hastily the punishment was carried out, leaving no chance for mercy or retraction of their fury. The crowd then expressed their outrage and demanded an election to fill the positions of Andranodorus and Themistus, since both had been praetors; an election that was unlikely to please the praetors.

27

The day was fixed for the election, when, to the surprise of all, one person from the extremity of the crowd nominated Epicydes, and then another from the same quarter nominated Hippocrates. Afterwards the voices in favour of these persons increased with the manifest approbation of the multitude. The assembly was one of a heterogeneous character, consisting not only of the commons, but a crowd of soldiers, with a large admixture even of deserters, who were desirous of innovation in every thing. The praetors, at first, concealed their feelings, and were for protracting the business; but at length, overcome by the general opinion, and apprehensive of a sedition, they declared them the praetors. These did not, however, immediately openly avow their sentiments, though they were chagrined that ambassadors had been sent to Appius Claudius to negotiate a ten days' truce, and that on obtaining this, others were sent to treat for the renewal of the old alliance. The Romans, with a fleet of a hundred ships, were then stationed at Murgantia, waiting the issue of the commotion raised at Syracuse by the death of the tyrants, and to what their recent acquisition of liberty would impel the people. Meanwhile, the Syracusan ambassadors were sent by Appius Claudius to Marcellus on his coming into Sicily, and Marcellus having heard the conditions of peace, and being of opinion that matters might be brought to a settlement, himself also sent ambassadors to Syracuse to treat with the praetors in person on the renewal of the alliance. But now by no means the same state of quiet and tranquillity existed there. Hippocrates and Epicydes, their fears being removed, after that intelligence had arrived that a Carthaginian fleet had put in at Pachynum, complained sometimes to the mercenary soldiers, at other times to the deserters, that Syracuse was being betrayed to the Romans. And when Appius began to station his ships at the mouth of the port, in order to inspire the other party with courage, their false insinuations appeared to receive great corroboration; and on the first impulse, the populace had even run down in a disorderly manner to prevent them from disembarking.

The day for the election had been set when, to everyone's surprise, someone from the back of the crowd nominated Epicydes, and then another person from the same area nominated Hippocrates. After that, the support for these two grew with the clear approval of the crowd. The assembly was a mixed group, including not just regular citizens but also a crowd of soldiers, and even some deserters who wanted change in everything. At first, the praetors hid their feelings and wanted to postpone the matter, but eventually, swayed by public opinion and fearing a riot, they declared Epicydes and Hippocrates the praetors. However, they did not immediately express their true feelings, even though they were frustrated that ambassadors had been sent to Appius Claudius to negotiate a ten-day truce, and that after this, more were sent to discuss renewing the old alliance. The Romans, with a fleet of a hundred ships, were positioned at Murgantia, waiting to see how the situation in Syracuse would play out after the tyrants' death and how the people's newfound freedom would affect them. Meanwhile, the Syracusan ambassadors were sent by Appius Claudius to Marcellus when he arrived in Sicily, and after hearing the peace terms, Marcellus believed a settlement could be reached and sent his own ambassadors to Syracuse to negotiate with the praetors in person about renewing the alliance. But the atmosphere there was anything but calm. With their fears eased after news came that a Carthaginian fleet had arrived at Pachynum, Hippocrates and Epicydes sometimes complained to the mercenary soldiers and at other times to the deserters that Syracuse was being betrayed to the Romans. When Appius started to position his ships at the entrance of the port to boost the morale of the other side, their false claims seemed to gain a lot of support, and initially, the crowd rushed down in a chaotic way to stop them from landing.

28

While affairs were in this unsettled state, it was resolved to call an assembly; in which, when some leaned to one side and some to the other, and an insurrection being on the point of breaking out, Apollonides, one of the nobles, delivered a speech fraught with salutary advice, considering the critical state of affairs: "Never," he said, "had a state a nearer prospect of safety and annihilation. For if they would all unanimously espouse the cause either of the Romans or the Carthaginians, there could be no state whose condition would be more prosperous and happy; but if they pulled different ways, the war between the Romans and Carthaginians would not be more bloody than that which would take place between the Syracusans themselves, in which both the contending parties would have their forces, their troops, and their generals, within the same walls. Every exertion ought therefore to be made that all might think alike. Which alliance would be productive of the greater advantages, was a question of quite a secondary nature, and of less moment; though the authority of Hiero ought to be followed in preference to that of Hieronymus in the selection of allies, and a friendship of which they had had a happy experience through a space of fifty years, ought to be chosen rather than one now untried and formerly unfaithful. That it ought also to have some weight in their deliberations, that peace with the Carthaginians might be refused in such a manner as not immediately, at least, to have a war with them, while with the Romans they must forthwith have either peace or war." The less of party spirit and warmth appeared in this speech the greater weight it had. A military council also was united with the praetors and a chosen body of senators; the commanders of companies also, and the praefects of the allies, were ordered to consult conjointly. After the question had been agitated with great warmth, at length, as there appeared to be no means of carrying on a war with the Romans, it was resolved that a treaty of peace should be formed, and that ambassadors should be sent with those from Rome to ratify the same.

While things were in this unsettled state, it was decided to call an assembly; where, as some leaned to one side and some to the other, and an uprising was about to break out, Apollonides, one of the nobles, gave a speech full of wise advice, considering the critical situation: "Never," he said, "has a state faced a closer chance of safety and destruction. If everyone would equally support either the Romans or the Carthaginians, there would be no state in better shape or happier; but if they pull in different directions, the war between the Romans and Carthaginians would not be more brutal than the one that would happen among the Syracusans themselves, where both sides would have their forces, their troops, and their generals within the same walls. Therefore, every effort should be made for everyone to think alike. Which alliance would bring greater benefits is a question of secondary importance; although the authority of Hiero should be preferred over that of Hieronymus when choosing allies, and a friendship that they have enjoyed for fifty years should be chosen instead of one that is untested and had been unfaithful before. It should also be considered in their discussions that peace with the Carthaginians might be refused in such a way that they wouldn't immediately, at least, plunge into war with them, while with the Romans they would have to pursue either peace or war right away." The less party spirit and fervor shown in this speech, the more weight it carried. A military council was also formed alongside the praetors and a select group of senators; commanders of companies and the praefects of the allies were ordered to consult together. After the issue had been discussed with great intensity, it was finally decided that there was no viable way to continue a war with the Romans, and that a treaty of peace should be created, with ambassadors sent alongside those from Rome to finalize it.

29

Not many days intervened before ambassadors came from the Leontines, requesting troops to protect their frontiers; an embassy which appeared to afford a very favourable opportunity for disencumbering the city of a turbulent and disorderly rabble, and for removing their leaders to a distance. The praetor, Hippocrates, was ordered to lead the deserters thither. Many of the mercenary auxiliaries accompanying them made them number four thousand armed men. This expedition gave great delight both to those who were sent and those who sent them, for to the former an opportunity was afforded of change which they had long desired, while the latter were rejoiced because they considered that a kind of sink of the city had been drained off. But they had, as it were, only relieved a sick body for a time, that it might afterwards fall into a more aggravated disease. For Hippocrates began to ravage the adjoining parts of the Roman province, at first by stealthy excursions, but afterwards, when Appies had sent a body of troops to protect the lands of the allies, he made an attack with all his forces upon the guard posted over against him, and slew many. Marcellus, when informed of this, immediately sent ambassadors to Syracuse, who said that the faith of the treaty had been broken, and that there would never be wanting a cause for hostilities, unless Hippocrates and Epicydes were removed not only from Syracuse, but far from all Sicily. Epicydes, lest by being present he should be arraigned for the offence committed by his absent brother, or should be wanting on his own part in stirring up a war, proceeded himself also to the Leontines; and seeing that they were already sufficiently exasperated against the Romans, he endeavoured to detach them from the Syracusans also. His argument was, that the terms on which they had formed a treaty of peace with the Romans were, that whatever people had been subject to their kings should be placed under their dominion; and that now they were not satisfied with liberty unless they could also exercise kingly power and dominion over others. The answer, therefore, he said, which they ought to send back was, that the Leontines also considered themselves entitled to liberty, either on the ground that the tyrant fell in the streets of their city, or that there the shout was first raised for liberty; and that they were the persons who, abandoning the king's generals, flocked to Syracuse. That, therefore, either that article must be expunged from the treaty, or that that term of it would not be admitted. They easily persuaded the multitude; and when the ambassadors of Syracuse complained of the slaughter of the Roman guard, and ordered that Hippocrates and Epicydes should depart either to Locri or any other place they pleased, provided they quitted Sicily, a reply was made to them in a haughty manner, "that they had neither placed themselves at the disposal of the Syracusans to make a peace for them with the Romans, nor were they bound by the treaties of other people." This answer the Syracusans laid before the Romans, declaring at the same time that "the Leontines were not under their control, and that, therefore, the Romans might make war on them without violating the treaty subsisting between them; that they would also not be wanting in the war, provided that when brought again under subjection, they should form a part of their dominion, agreeably to the conditions of the peace."

Not many days passed before ambassadors arrived from the Leontines, asking for troops to protect their borders; this seemed like a great chance to clear the city of a chaotic and unruly crowd, and to send their leaders far away. The praetor, Hippocrates, was instructed to take the deserters there. Many of the mercenary soldiers with them increased their numbers to four thousand armed men. This mission pleased both those who were sent and those who sent them, as the former saw a long-desired opportunity for change, while the latter were happy to think that they had rid the city of a kind of burden. However, they had merely provided temporary relief to a sick body that would soon face an even worse affliction. Hippocrates began to raid the neighboring areas of the Roman province, initially by stealth, but later, when Appies sent a group of soldiers to protect the allies' lands, he launched an all-out attack on the guards stationed against him, killing many. When Marcellus learned of this, he quickly sent ambassadors to Syracuse, stating that the treaty had been violated and that there would always be a reason for conflict unless Hippocrates and Epicydes were removed from Syracuse and far away from all of Sicily. Epicydes, fearing that being present would tie him to his brother's wrongdoing, or that he would be lacking in inciting war, went to the Leontines himself. Noticing their rising anger towards the Romans, he tried to sway them away from the Syracusans too. He argued that the terms of their peace treaty with the Romans stipulated that any people who had been under their kings should remain under their control, and that they were not satisfied with freedom unless they could also wield power over others. Therefore, he said, their response should be that the Leontines also believed they were entitled to freedom, either because the tyrant fell in their streets or because their shout for liberty began there; and that they were the ones who left the king’s generals to join Syracuse. Thus, either that clause should be deleted from the treaty, or that condition would not be accepted. They easily convinced the crowd, and when the Syracuse ambassadors complained about the killing of the Roman guards and demanded that Hippocrates and Epicydes leave for Locri or anywhere else as long as they departed from Sicily, the reply was made haughtily: "They had not surrendered themselves to the Syracusans to negotiate peace with the Romans nor were they bound by the treaties of others." This response was presented by the Syracusans to the Romans, asserting that "the Leontines were not under their control, and thus the Romans could wage war against them without breaching the existing treaty; furthermore, they would not shy away from the conflict, provided that, once subdued, the Leontines should be a part of their realm as per the peace agreement's terms."

30

Marcellus marched with his entire forces against Leontini, having sent for Appius also, in order that he might attack it in another quarter; when, such was the ardour of the troops in consequence of the indignation they felt at the Roman guards being put to the sword during the negotiations for a peace, that they took the town by storm on the first assault. Hippocrates and Epicydes, perceiving that the enemy were getting possession of the walls and breaking open the gates, retired with a few others into the citadel, from which they fled unobserved during the night to Herbessus. The Syracusans, who had marched from home with eight thousand troops, were met at the river Myla by a messenger, who informed them that the city was taken. The rest which he stated was a mixture of truth and falsehood; he said that there had been an indiscriminate massacre of the soldiers and the townsmen, and that he did not think that one person who had arrived at puberty had survived; that the town had been pillaged, and the property of the rich men given to the troops. On receiving such direful news the army halted; and while all were under violent excitement, the generals, Sosis and Dinomenes, consulted together as to the course to be taken. The scourging and beheading of two thousand deserters had given to this false statement a plausibility which excited alarm; but no violence was offered to any of the Leontine or other soldiers after the city was taken; and every man's property was restored to him, with the exception only of such as was destroyed in the first confusion which attended the capture of the city. The troops, who complained of their fellow-soldiers having been betrayed and butchered, could neither be induced to proceed to Leontini, nor wait where they were for more certain intelligence. The praetors, perceiving their minds disposed to mutiny, but concluding that their violence would not be of long continuance, if those who had led them on to such folly were removed, led the troops to Megara, whence they themselves with a few horsemen proceeded to Herbessus, under the expectation of having the city betrayed to them in the general consternation; but being disappointed in this attempt, they resolved to resort to force, and moved their camp from Megara on the following day, in order to attack Herbessus with all their forces. Hippocrates and Epicydes having formed the design of putting themselves into the hands of the soldiers, who were for the most part accustomed to them, and were now incensed at the report of the massacre of their comrades, not so much as a safe measure on the first view of it as that it was their only course, now that all hope was cut off, went out to meet the army. It happened that the troops which marched in the van were six hundred Cretans, who had been engaged in the service of Hieronymus under their command, and were under obligation to Hannibal, having been captured at the Trasimenus among the Roman auxiliaries, and dismissed by him. Hippocrates and Epicydes, recognising them by their standards and the fashion of their armour, held out olive branches, and the fillets usually worn by suppliants, and implored them to receive them into their ranks, protect them when received, and not betray them to the Syracusans, by whom they themselves would soon be delivered up to the Romans to be butchered.

Marcellus marched with his entire army against Leontini, having called for Appius too, so he could attack from another direction. The troops were fueled by anger after the Roman guards were killed during peace talks, so they stormed the town on their first attempt. Hippocrates and Epicydes, realizing the enemy was taking the walls and forcing the gates open, retreated with a few others to the citadel, where they escaped unnoticed during the night to Herbessus. The Syracusans, who had started out with eight thousand troops, were met at the Myla River by a messenger who informed them that the city had fallen. The rest of his message was a mix of truth and lies; he claimed that there had been a massacre of both soldiers and civilians, suggesting that not a single person who had reached adulthood had survived, that the town had been looted, and that the wealth of the rich had been given to the troops. Upon hearing such terrible news, the army stopped, and while everyone was filled with intense emotions, the generals, Sosis and Dinomenes, discussed their next steps. The flogging and execution of two thousand deserters made the false report more believable and raised alarm; however, no violence was directed at the Leontine or other soldiers after the city fell, and everyone got back their belongings, except for what had been destroyed in the initial chaos following the capture. The troops who complained about their fellow soldiers being betrayed and killed couldn't be persuaded to move toward Leontini or to wait for clearer information where they were. The praetors, noticing the troops were on the verge of rebellion but believing the unrest wouldn't last long if those who had led them into such madness were removed, took the army to Megara. They then proceeded with a few horsemen to Herbessus, expecting the city to be turned over to them due to the general panic; but when that plan failed, they decided to use force and moved their camp from Megara the next day to launch an attack on Herbessus with all their forces. Hippocrates and Epicydes planned to surrender themselves to the soldiers, who mostly knew them and were now furious about the reported massacre of their comrades. It wasn't so much a calculated risk as it seemed their only option now that all hope was lost, so they went out to meet the army. The front-line troops happened to be six hundred Cretans who had served under Hieronymus and were obligated to Hannibal, after being captured at Trasimenus among the Roman auxiliaries and then released by him. Hippocrates and Epicydes, recognizing them by their standards and armor style, offered olive branches and the ribbons typically worn by supplicants, pleading with them to accept them into their ranks, protect them, and not betray them to the Syracusans, who would soon hand them over to the Romans to be slaughtered.

31

But the Cretans with one accord called out to them to be of good courage; that they would share every fortune with them. During this conversation, the vanguard had halted, and the march was delayed; nor had the cause of the delay as yet reached the generals. After the report had spread that Hippocrates and Epicydes were there, and a voice was heard through the whole army, which showed evidently that the troops were pleased at their arrival, the praetors immediately gallopped to the front, and earnestly asked "what was the meaning of that violation of discipline, which the Cretans had committed in holding conference with the enemy, and allowing them to mingle with their ranks without the authority of the praetors." They ordered Hippocrates to be seized and thrown into chains. On hearing which such a clamour was raised, first by the Cretans and then by the rest, that it was quite evident if they proceeded farther that they would have cause to fear. In this state of anxiety and perplexity, they gave orders to march back to Megara, whence they had set out, and sent messengers to Syracuse, to give information of their present condition. Hippocrates added a deception, seeing that the minds of the troops were disposed to entertain every suspicion. Having sent some Cretans to lie in wait in the roads, he read a letter he pretended had been intercepted, but which he had written himself. The address was: "The praetors of Syracuse to the consul Marcellus." After the customary wishing of health, it stated "that he had acted duly and properly in sparing none of the Leontines, but that the cause of all the mercenary troops was the same, and that Syracuse would never be tranquil while there were any foreign auxiliaries in the city or in the army. That it was therefore necessary that he should endeavour to get into his power those who were encamped at Megara, with their praetors, and by punishing them, at length restore Syracuse to liberty." After this letter had been read, they ran to seize their arms in every direction, with so great a clamour, that the praetors, in the utmost consternation, rode away to Syracuse during the confusion. The mutiny, however, was not quelled even by their flight, but an attack was made upon the Syracusan soldiers; nor would any one have escaped their violence, had not Hippocrates and Epicydes opposed the resentment of the multitude, not from pity or any humane motive, but lest they should cut off all hope of effecting their return; and that they might have the soldiers, both as faithful supporters of their cause, and as hostages, and conciliate to themselves their relatives and friends, in the first place by so great an obligation, and in the next by reason of the pledge. Having also experienced that the populace could be excited by any cause, however groundless or trifling, they procured a soldier of the number of those who were besieged at Leontini, whom they suborned to carry a report to Syracuse, corresponding with that which had been falsely told at the Myla; and by vouching for what he stated, and relating as matters which he had seen, those things of which doubts were entertained, to kindle the resentment of the people.

But the Cretans all shouted together to encourage them to be brave, assuring them that they would share whatever fate awaited them. During this exchange, the advance guard had stopped, causing a delay in the march, and the generals still hadn’t learned the reason behind it. Once the news spread that Hippocrates and Epicydes were present, a voice echoed throughout the entire army, indicating that the troops were pleased with their arrival. The praetors immediately rode to the front and urgently asked about the breach of discipline by the Cretans, who had engaged in discussions with the enemy and allowed them to mingle with their ranks without permission. They ordered Hippocrates to be captured and put in chains. On hearing this, such an uproar arose, first from the Cretans and then from the others, that it became clear that if they pressed on further, they would have reason to be afraid. In a state of anxiety and confusion, they ordered a retreat back to Megara, from where they had set out, and sent messengers to Syracuse to inform them of their situation. Hippocrates then devised a ruse, knowing that the troops were inclined to entertain suspicions. He sent some Cretans to lie in ambush on the roads and pretended to read a letter that he claimed had been intercepted but was actually written by himself. The letter was addressed: "The praetors of Syracuse to the consul Marcellus." After the usual greetings, it stated that he had acted correctly and appropriately in sparing none of the Leontines, but that the cause of all the mercenary troops was the same, and Syracuse would never be at peace while there were any foreign auxiliaries in the city or army. It was therefore necessary for him to try to gain control of those encamped at Megara, along with their praetors, and by punishing them, ultimately restore Syracuse to freedom. After this letter was read, they rushed to grab their weapons in all directions, causing such a clamor that the praetors, in total panic, fled to Syracuse amidst the chaos. However, the mutiny did not subside even with their escape; instead, an attack was launched on the Syracusan soldiers. No one would have escaped their wrath if Hippocrates and Epicydes hadn’t intervened to curb the mob's anger, not out of compassion or kindness, but because they feared that this would eliminate all hope of retreat; they wanted the soldiers both as loyal supporters of their cause and as hostages, hoping to win over their relatives and friends through such a significant obligation and the ensuing pledge. They also realized that the populace could be incited by any reason, no matter how unfounded or trivial, so they found a soldier among those besieged in Leontini, whom they bribed to deliver a report to Syracuse that aligned with what had been falsely claimed at Myla; by backing up his statements and relaying supposed observations, they aimed to inflame the people’s anger.

32

This man not only obtained credit with the commons, but being introduced into the senate-house, produced an impression upon the senate also. Some men of no small authority openly declared, that it was very fortunate that the rapacity and cruelty of the Romans had been made apparent in the case of the Leontines; that if they had entered Syracuse, they would have committed the same or even more horrible acts, as there the temptations to rapacity would have been greater. All, therefore, advised that the gates should be closed and the city guarded, but not the same persons were objects of fear or hatred to all alike. Among the soldiers of every kind, and a great part of the people, the Roman name was hated. The praetors, and a few of the nobles, though enraged by the fictitious intelligence, rather directed their cautions against a nearer and more immediate evil. Hippocrates and Epicycles were now at the Hexapylum; and conversations were taking place, fomented by the relatives of the native soldiers who were in the army, touching the opening of the gates, and the allowing their common country to be defended from the violence of the Romans. One of the doors of the Hexapylum was now thrown open, and the troops began to be taken in at it, when the praetors interposed; and first by commands and menaces, then by advice, they endeavoured to deter them from their purpose, and last of all, every other means proving ineffectual, forgetful of their dignity, they tried to move them by prayers, imploring them not to betray their country to men heretofore the satellites of the tyrant, and now the corrupters of the army. But the ears of the excited multitude were deaf to all these arguments, and the exertions made from within to break open the gates, were not less than those without; the gates were all broken open, and the whole army received into the Hexapylum. The praetors, with the youth of the city, fled into the Achradina; the mercenary soldiers and deserters, with all the soldiers of the late king who were at Syracuse, joined the forces of the enemy. The Achradina also was therefore taken on the first assault, and all the praetors, except such as escaped in the confusion, were put to the sword. Night put an end to the carnage. On the following day the slaves were invited to liberty, and those bound in prison were released; after which this mixed rabble created Hippocrates and Epicydes their praetors, and thus Syracuse, when for a brief period the light of liberty had shone on it, relapsed into her former state of servitude.

This man not only gained the people's support, but after being introduced into the senate, he also made an impression on the senators. Some influential people openly stated that it was very fortunate that the greed and cruelty of the Romans were evident in the case of the Leontines; if they had entered Syracuse, they would have committed the same or even worse atrocities, as there the temptations of greed would have been greater. Therefore, everyone advised that the gates be closed and the city guarded, but not everyone feared or hated the same individuals. Among the soldiers and a large part of the population, the Roman name was despised. The praetors and a few nobles, although enraged by the false news, directed their concerns toward a more immediate danger. Hippocrates and Epicydes were now at the Hexapylum, and discussions fueled by the relatives of the native soldiers in the army were taking place about opening the gates and allowing their homeland to be defended from the Romans' violence. One of the doors of the Hexapylum was thrown open, and troops began to enter, but the praetors intervened; first with commands and threats, then with advice, trying to dissuade them from their plan, and finally, when all else failed, they implored them, forgetting their dignity, not to betray their country to those who had previously been the tyrant's henchmen and now were corrupting the army. But the excited crowd ignored all these arguments, and the attempts from within to keep the gates shut were no less vigorous than those from outside; the gates were eventually broken open, and the entire army poured into the Hexapylum. The praetors, along with the city's youth, fled to Achradina, while the mercenary soldiers, deserters, and all of the late king's soldiers in Syracuse joined the enemy's forces. Achradina was quickly taken in the first assault, and all the praetors, except for those who escaped in the chaos, were killed. Night ended the slaughter. The following day, the slaves were invited to freedom, and those imprisoned were released; afterward, this mixed crowd appointed Hippocrates and Epicydes as their praetors, and thus Syracuse, after a brief moment of liberty, fell back into its former state of servitude.

33

The Romans, on receiving information of these events, immediately moved their camp from Leontini to Syracuse. It happened at this time that ambassadors were sent by Appius in a quinquereme, to make their way through the harbour. A quadrireme was sent in advance, which was captured as soon as it entered the mouth of the harbour, and the ambassadors with difficulty made their escape. And now not only the laws of peace but of war also were not regarded, when the Roman army pitched their camp at Olympium, a temple of Jupiter, a mile and a half from the city. From which place also it was thought proper that ambassadors should be sent forward; these were met by Hippocrates and Epicydes with their friends without the gate, to prevent their entering the city. The Roman, who was appointed to speak, said that "he did not bring war, but aid and assistance to the Syracusans, not only to such as, escaping from the midst of the carnage, fled to the Romans for protection, but to those also, who, overpowered by fear, were submitting to a servitude more shocking, not only than exile, but than death. Nor would the Romans suffer the horrid murder of their friends to go unavenged. If, therefore, those who had taken refuge with them were allowed to return to their country with safety, the authors of the massacre delivered up, and the Syracusans reinstated in the enjoyment of their liberty and laws, there would be no necessity for arms; but if these things were not done, they would direct their arms unceasingly against those who delayed them, whoever they might be." Epicydes replied, that "if they had been commissioned with any message for them, they would have given them an answer; and when the government of Syracuse was in the hands of those persons to whom they were come, they might visit Syracuse again. If they should commence hostilities, they would learn by actual experience that it was by no means the same thing to besiege Syracuse and Leontini." With this he left the ambassadors and closed the gate. The siege of Syracuse then commenced by sea and land at the same time; by land on the side of the Hexapylum; by sea on the side of the Achradina, the wall of which is washed by its waves; and as the Romans felt a confidence that as they had taken Leontini by the terror they occasioned on the first assault, they should be able in some quarter to effect an entrance into a city so desert, and diffused over so large an extent of ground, they brought up to the walls every kind of engine for besieging cities.

The Romans, upon hearing about these events, quickly moved their camp from Leontini to Syracuse. At that time, Appius sent ambassadors in a quinquereme to navigate the harbor. A quadrireme was sent ahead but was captured as soon as it reached the harbor entrance, and the ambassadors barely escaped. Now, not just the laws of peace but also those of war were ignored when the Roman army set up camp at Olympium, a temple of Jupiter, a mile and a half from the city. From there, it was decided that ambassadors should be sent ahead; they were met by Hippocrates and Epicydes with their followers outside the gate to stop them from entering the city. The Roman designated to speak said that "he did not come to bring war, but help and support to the Syracusans, not just to those who escaped the violence and sought refuge with the Romans, but also to those who, overwhelmed by fear, were giving in to a servitude worse than exile and death. The Romans would not let the brutal murder of their friends go unpunished. If, therefore, those who had sought refuge with them could return home safely, the perpetrators of the massacre handed over, and the Syracusans restored to their freedom and laws, there would be no need for arms; but if these conditions were not met, they would relentlessly pursue those who delayed them, whoever they might be." Epicydes responded that "if they had been sent with any message for them, they would have given a reply; and since the government of Syracuse was in the hands of those they had come to see, they could visit Syracuse again. If they started hostilities, they would soon realize that besieging Syracuse was not the same as dealing with Leontini." With this, he dismissed the ambassadors and shut the gate. The siege of Syracuse then began by land and sea simultaneously; on land by the Hexapylum side and at sea by the Achradina side, which was lapped by waves. The Romans, confident that having taken Leontini by instilling fear during their first assault, expected to find a way into such a vast, empty city, brought all kinds of siege engines up to the walls.

34

And an attempt made with so much energy would have succeeded, had it not been for one person then at Syracuse. That person was Archimedes, a man of unrivalled skill in observing the heavens and the stars, but more deserving of admiration as the inventor and constructor of warlike engines and works, by means of which, with a very slight effort, he turned to ridicule what the enemy effected with great difficulty. The wall which ran along unequal eminences, most of which were high and difficult of access, some low and open to approach along level vales, he furnished with every kind of warlike engine, as seemed suitable to each particular place. Marcellus attacked from the quinqueremes the wall of the Achradina, which, as before stated, was washed by the sea. From the other ships the archers and slingers and light infantry, whose weapon is difficult to be thrown back by the unskilful, allowed scarce any person to remain upon the wall unwounded. These, as they required room for the discharge of their missiles, kept their ships at a distance from the wall. Eight more quinqueremes joined together in pairs, the oars on their inner sides being removed, so that side might be placed to side, and which forming as it were ships, were worked by means of the oars on the outer sides, carried turrets built up in stories, and other engines employed in battering walls. Against this naval armament, Archimedes placed on different parts of the walls engines of various dimensions. Against the ships which were at a distance he discharged stones of immense weight. Those which were nearer he assailed with lighter, and therefore more numerous missiles. Lastly, in order that his own men might heap their weapons upon the enemy, without receiving any wounds themselves, he perforated the wall from the top to the bottom with a great number of loop-holes, about a cubit in diameter, through which some with arrows, others with scorpions of moderate size, assailed the enemy without being seen. Certain ships which came nearer to the walls in order to get within the range of the engines, he placed upon their sterns, raising up their prows by throwing upon them an iron grapple, attached to a strong chain, by means of a tolleno which projected from the wall, and overhung them, having a heavy counterpoise of lead which forced back the lever to the ground; then the grapple being suddenly disengaged, the ship falling as it were from the wall, was, by these means, to the utter consternation of the mariners, dashed in such a manner against the water, that even if it fell back in an erect position it took in a great quantity of water. Thus the attack by sea was foiled, and their whole efforts were directed to an attack by land with all their forces. But on this side also the place was furnished with a similar array of engines of every kind, procured at the expense of Hiero, who had given his attention to this object through a course of many years, and constructed by the unrivalled abilities of Archimedes. The nature of the place also assisted them; for the rock which formed the foundation of the wall was for the most part so steep, that not only materials discharged from engines, but such as were rolled down by their own gravity, fell upon the enemy with great force; the same cause rendered the approach to the city difficult, and the footing unsteady. Wherefore, a council being held, it was resolved, since every attempt was frustrated, to abstain from assaulting the place, and keeping up a blockade, only to cut off the provisions of the enemy by sea and land.

And an attempt made with so much energy would have succeeded, if it hadn't been for one person in Syracuse. That person was Archimedes, a man with unmatched skill in observing the heavens and stars, but more admirable as the inventor and builder of war machines. With minimal effort, he ridiculed what the enemy accomplished with great struggle. The wall that ran along uneven heights, with most being high and hard to reach, and some low and accessible along flat valleys, he equipped with every kind of war engine that suited each specific location. Marcellus attacked the wall of the Achradina from the quinqueremes, which, as mentioned earlier, was next to the sea. From the other ships, the archers, slingers, and light infantry, whose weapons are difficult to deflect if you're not skilled, left hardly anyone on the wall uninjured. These soldiers needed space to launch their missiles, so they kept their ships back from the wall. Eight more quinqueremes were joined in pairs, with the oars on their inner sides removed, allowing them to sit side by side while being powered by the oars on the outer sides. They carried multi-storied towers and other devices used for battering walls. In response to this naval force, Archimedes set up various sized engines on different parts of the walls. He launched massive stones at the ships that were farther away and targeted those that were closer with lighter, more plentiful missiles. Lastly, to allow his men to fire at the enemy without being hit themselves, he drilled numerous holes through the wall from top to bottom, each about a cubit in diameter, through which some shot arrows while others used mid-sized scorpions to attack the enemy unseen. Certain ships that got closer to the walls to come within range of the engines found themselves caught by grappling hooks that were attached to strong chains. They raised their prows with an iron grapple launched from a projecting tolleno on the wall, which had a heavy lead counterweight that pushed the lever back down. Then, when the grapple was suddenly released, the ship, falling away from the wall, crashed into the water with such force that even if it landed upright, it took in a tremendous amount of water. Thus, the sea attack was thwarted, and all efforts were redirected to a land assault with their full force. But on that front too, the area was equipped with a similar lineup of engines of all kinds, supplied by Hiero, who had invested years in this project, constructed by the unmatched skills of Archimedes. The location itself was advantageous; the rock that formed the wall’s foundation was so steep that not only materials dropped from engines but also anything rolled down by gravity struck the enemy with great force. This same factor made approaching the city difficult and the ground slippery. As a result, a council was held, and it was decided, since every attempt had failed, to avoid assaulting the place and instead just maintain a blockade to cut off the enemy’s supplies by sea and land.

35

Meanwhile, Marcellus, who had set out with about a third part of the army, to recover the towns which, during the commotion, had gone over to the Carthaginians, regained Helorus and Herbessus by voluntary surrender. Megara, which he took by storm, he demolished and plundered, in order to terrify the rest, but particularly the Syracusans. Much about the same time, Himilco, who had kept his fleet for a long time at the promontory of Pachynus, landed twenty-five thousand infantry, three thousand horse, and twelve elephants, at Heraclea, which they call Minoa. This force was much greater than that which he had before on board his fleet at Pachynus. But after Syracuse was seized by Hippocrates, he proceeded to Carthage, where, being aided by ambassadors from Hippocrates, and a letter from Hannibal, who said that now was the time to recover Sicily with the highest honour, while his own advice given in person had no small influence, he had prevailed upon the Carthaginians to transport into Sicily as large a force as possible, both of foot and horse. Immediately on his arrival he retook Heraclea, and within a few days after Agrigentum; and in the other states which sided with the Carthaginians, such confident hopes were kindled of driving the Romans out of Sicily, that at last even those who were besieged at Syracuse took courage; and thinking that half their forces would be sufficient for the defence of the city, they divided the business of the war between them in such a manner, that Epicydes superintended the defence of the city, while Hippocrates, in conjunction with Himilco, prosecuted the war against the Roman consul. The latter, having passed by night through the intervals between the posts, with ten thousand foot and five hundred horse, was pitching a camp near the city Acrillae, when Marcellus came upon them, while engaged in raising the fortifications, on his return from Agrigentum, which was already occupied by the enemy, having failed in his attempt to get there before the enemy by expeditious marching, Marcellus calculated upon any thing rather than meeting with a Syracusan army at that time and place; but still through fear of Himilco and the Carthaginians, for whom he was by no means a match with the forces he had with him, he was marching with all possible circumspection, and with his troops so arranged, as to be prepared for any thing which might occur.

Meanwhile, Marcellus, who had set out with about a third of the army, to reclaim the towns that had sided with the Carthaginians during the chaos, regained Helorus and Herbessus through voluntary surrender. He captured Megara with force, destroyed it, and looted it to intimidate the others, especially the Syracusans. Around the same time, Himilco, who had kept his fleet at the promontory of Pachynus for a long time, landed twenty-five thousand infantry, three thousand cavalry, and twelve elephants at Heraclea, also known as Minoa. This force was much larger than what he had previously on board his fleet at Pachynus. But after Hippocrates took control of Syracuse, he went to Carthage, where, with the help of ambassadors from Hippocrates and a letter from Hannibal, who claimed that now was the perfect time to reclaim Sicily with honor, and given his personal advice, he secured the Carthaginians’ agreement to send as many troops as possible, both infantry and cavalry, to Sicily. As soon as he arrived, he retook Heraclea and just a few days later, Agrigentum; and in the other states allied with the Carthaginians, there was a surge of confidence about driving the Romans out of Sicily, so much so that even those besieged at Syracuse felt emboldened; believing that half their forces would suffice for the city's defense, they divided the war effort so that Epicydes oversaw the defense of the city, while Hippocrates worked with Himilco to wage war against the Roman consul. The latter, having passed through the night between the posts, with ten thousand infantry and five hundred cavalry, was setting up a camp near the city of Acrillae when Marcellus encountered them while they were busy building fortifications on his return from Agrigentum, which was already in enemy hands. After failing to reach it before the enemy by marching quickly, Marcellus expected anything but to face a Syracusan army at that moment and place; however, still wary of Himilco and the Carthaginians, against whom he was at a disadvantage with his current forces, he marched with utmost caution, arranging his troops to be ready for any situation that might arise.

36

It happened that the caution he had observed with intent to guard him against the Carthaginians, proved useful against the Sicilians. Having caught them in disorder and dispersed, employed in forming their camp, and for the most part unarmed, he cut off all their infantry. Their cavalry, having commenced a slight engagement, fled to Acrae with Hippocrates. This battle having checked the Sicilians in their purpose of revolting from the Romans, Marcellus returned to Syracuse, and a few days after Himilco, being joined by Hippocrates, encamped on the river Anapus, about eight miles distant from that place. Nearly about the same time, fifty-five ships of war of the Carthaginians, with Bomilcar as commander of the fleet, put into the great harbour of Syracuse from the sea, and a Roman fleet of thirty quinqueremes landed the first legion at Panormus; and so intent were both the contending powers upon Sicily, that the seat of war might seem to have been removed from Italy. Himilco, who thought that the Roman legion which had been landed at Panormus, would doubtless fall a prey to him on its way to Syracuse, was mistaken in his road; for the Carthaginian marched through the inland parts of the country, while the legion, keeping along the coast, and attended by the fleet, came up with Appius Claudius, who had advanced to Pachynum with a part of his forces to meet it. Nor did the Carthaginians delay longer at Syracuse. Bomilcar, who at the same time that he did not feel sufficient confidence in his naval strength, as the Romans had a fleet more than double his number, was aware that delay which could be attended with no good effect, would only increase the scarcity of provisions among the allies by the presence of his troops, sailed out into the deep, and crossed over into Africa. Himilco, who had in vain followed Marcellus to Syracuse, to see if he could get any opportunity of engaging him before he was joined by larger forces, failing in this object, and seeing that the enemy were secured at Syracuse, both by their fortifications and the strength of their forces, to avoid wasting time in sitting by as an idle spectator of the siege of his allies, without being able to do any good, marched his troops away, in order to bring them up wherever the prospect of revolt from the Romans might invite him, and wherever by his presence he might inspire additional courage in those who espoused his interest. He first got possession of Murgantia, the Roman garrison having been betrayed by the inhabitants themselves. Here a great quantity of corn and provisions of every kind had been laid up by the Romans.

It happened that the caution he had shown to protect himself from the Carthaginians ended up being useful against the Sicilians. He caught them off guard and scattered, busy setting up their camp and mostly unarmed, and he took out all their infantry. Their cavalry, after starting a brief skirmish, fled to Acrae with Hippocrates. This battle stopped the Sicilians from trying to revolt against the Romans, and Marcellus returned to Syracuse. A few days later, Himilco, who joined forces with Hippocrates, set up camp by the river Anapus, about eight miles away from that location. Around the same time, fifty-five warships from the Carthaginians, commanded by Bomilcar, arrived in the great harbor of Syracuse from the sea, while a Roman fleet of thirty quinqueremes landed the first legion at Panormus. Both sides were so focused on Sicily that it seemed like the battle had shifted away from Italy. Himilco, thinking that the Roman legion landed at Panormus would surely fall into his hands on its way to Syracuse, was wrong about his route; the Carthaginian forces moved through the countryside while the legion, sticking to the coast and escorted by the fleet, met up with Appius Claudius, who had advanced to Pachynum with part of his troops to greet them. The Carthaginians didn’t linger in Syracuse either. Bomilcar, who lacked confidence in his naval strength since the Romans had a fleet more than double his own, knew that staying put would only worsen the food shortages among his allies, so he set sail into the open sea and crossed over to Africa. Himilco, who had unsuccessfully followed Marcellus to Syracuse in search of an opportunity to engage him before larger forces arrived, realizing that the enemy was well-fortified in Syracuse and had strong defenses, decided not to waste time sitting around as a spectator during the siege of his allies without being able to help. He marched his troops away to seek opportunities for revolt against the Romans, where his presence could boost the courage of those supporting him. He first took control of Murgantia, as the Roman garrison had been betrayed by the local inhabitants. A large supply of corn and food of all kinds had been stored there by the Romans.

37

To this revolt the minds of other states also were stimulated; and the Roman garrisons were now either driven out of the citadels, or treacherously given up and overpowered. Enna, which stood on an eminence lofty and of difficult ascent on all sides, was impregnable on account of its situation, and had besides in its citadel a strong garrison commanded by one who was very unlikely to be overreached by treachery, Lucius Pinarius, a man of vigorous mind, who relied more on the measures he took to prevent treachery, than on the fidelity of the Sicilians; and at that time particularly the intelligence he had received of so many cities being betrayed, and revolting, and of the massacre of the garrisons, had made him solicitous to use every precaution. Accordingly, by day and night equally, every thing was kept in readiness, and every place furnished with guards and watches, the soldiery being continually under arms and at their posts. But when the principal men in Enna, who had already entered into a covenant with Himilco to betray the garrison, found that they could get no opportunity of circumventing the Roman, they resolved to act openly. They urged, that "the city and the citadel ought to be under their control, as they had formed an alliance with the Romans on the understanding that they were to be free, and had not been delivered into their custody as slaves. That they therefore thought it just that the keys of the gates should be restored to them. That their honour formed the strongest tie upon good allies, and that the people and senate of Rome would entertain feelings of gratitude towards them if they continued in friendship with them of their own free will, and not by compulsion." The Roman replied, that "he was placed there by his general to protect the place; that from him he had received the keys of the gates and the custody of the citadel, trusts which he held not subject to his own will, nor that of the inhabitants of Enna, but to his who committed them to him. That among the Romans, for a man to quit his post was a capital offence, and that parents had sanctioned that law by the death even of their own children. That the consul Marcellus was not far off; that they might send ambassadors to him, who possessed the right and liberty of deciding." But they said, they would certainly not send to him, and solemnly declared, that as they could not obtain their object by argument, they would seek some means of asserting their liberty. Pinarius upon this observed, "that if they thought it too much to send to the consul, still they would, at least, grant him an assembly of the people, that it might be ascertained whether these denunciations came from a few, or from the whole state." An assembly of the people was proclaimed for the next day, with the general consent.

To this revolt, the minds of other states were also stirred; and the Roman garrisons were now either expelled from the strongholds or deceitfully surrendered and overwhelmed. Enna, which was positioned on a high and difficult ascent from all sides, was virtually unassailable because of its location. It also had a strong garrison in its citadel led by Lucius Pinarius, a sharp-minded man who was unlikely to be outsmarted by treachery. He relied more on his own measures to prevent betrayal than on the loyalty of the Sicilians; and at that time, especially with reports of so many cities being betrayed, rebelling, and the massacre of the garrisons, he was particularly eager to take every precaution. So, both day and night, everything was kept ready, and each area was provided with guards and watches, with the soldiers always ready for action and at their posts. But when the leaders in Enna, who had already made a pact with Himilco to betray the garrison, realized they had no chance to trick the Roman, they decided to act openly. They argued that "the city and the citadel should be under their control, as they had formed an alliance with the Romans based on the understanding that they would be free and not given over as slaves. Therefore, they felt it was right for the keys of the gates to be returned to them. Their honor was a strong bond for good allies, and the people and senate of Rome would feel grateful towards them if they remained friends of their own free will and not under coercion." The Roman replied that "he was appointed by his general to protect the place; that he had received the keys of the gates and the custody of the citadel from him, and these trusts were not his to give up, nor that of the inhabitants of Enna, but belonged to the one who entrusted them to him. Among the Romans, leaving one's post was a serious crime, and parents had upheld that law even at the cost of their own children's lives. The consul Marcellus was nearby; they could send ambassadors to him, who had the right and freedom to make a decision." But they stated they would definitely not send to him, and solemnly declared that since they couldn’t achieve their goal through discussion, they would find another way to assert their freedom. Pinarius then noted, "If you think it's too much to send to the consul, at least allow him an assembly of the people, so we can find out if this outcry is from a few or the whole state." An assembly of the people was announced for the next day, with everyone's agreement.

38

After this conference, he returned into the citadel, and assembling his soldiers, thus addressed them: "Soldiers, I suppose you have heard in what manner the Roman garrisons have been betrayed and cut off by the Sicilians of late. You have escaped the same treachery, first by the kindness of the gods, and secondly by your own good conduct, in unremittingly standing and watching under arms. I wish the rest of our time may be passed without suffering or committing dreadful things. This caution, which we have hitherto employed, has been directed against covert treachery, but not succeeding in this as they wished, they now publicly and openly demand back the keys of the gates; but as soon as we shall have delivered them up, Enna will be instantly in the hands of the Carthaginians, and we shall be butchered under circumstances more horrid than those with which the garrison of Murgantia were massacred. I have with difficulty procured a delay of one night for deliberation, that I might employ it in acquainting you with the danger which threatens you. At daybreak they intend holding a general assembly for the purpose of criminating me, and stirring up the people against you; to-morrow, therefore, Enna will be inundated either with your blood, or that of its own inhabitants. If they are beforehand with you, you will have no hope left, but if you anticipate their proceedings, you will have no danger. Victory will belong to that side which shall have drawn the sword first. You shall all, therefore, full armed, attentively wait the signal. I shall be in the assembly, and by talking and disputing will spin out the time till every thing shall be ready. When I shall have given the signal with my gown, then, mind me raising a shout on all sides rush upon the multitude, and fell all before you with the sword, taking care that no one survive from whom either force or fraud can be apprehended. You, mother Ceres and Proserpine, I entreat, and all ye other gods, celestial and infernal, who frequent this city and these consecrated lakes and groves, that you would lend us your friendly and propitious aid, as we adopt this measure not for the purpose of inflicting, but averting injury. I should exhort you at greater length my soldiers, if you were about to fight with armed men, men unarmed and off their guard, you will slay to satiety. The consul's camp too is near, so that nothing can be apprehended from Himilco and the Carthaginians'."

After this conference, he went back to the citadel and gathered his soldiers, thus addressing them: “Soldiers, you must have heard how the Roman garrisons were betrayed and wiped out by the Sicilians recently. You’ve escaped that same trap, thanks first to the favor of the gods, and second, due to your own discipline in staying alert and ready. I hope the rest of our time here passes without us suffering or causing terrible things. The caution we’ve employed so far has been aimed at hidden treachery, but since they haven’t succeeded in that, they are now openly demanding the keys to the gates. But as soon as we hand those over, Enna will immediately fall to the Carthaginians, and we’ll be slaughtered in a way even worse than how the garrison at Murgantia was killed. I’ve managed to get a delay of one night for us to discuss this danger that threatens you. They plan to hold a general assembly at dawn to accuse me and stir the people against you; therefore, tomorrow, Enna will be flooded either with your blood or that of its own citizens. If they beat you to it, you will have no hope left, but if you act first, you will face no danger. Victory will belong to whichever side strikes first. So, all of you, fully armed, wait attentively for the signal. I will be at the assembly and will buy time by talking and debating until everything is ready. When I give the signal with my gown, remember to raise a shout and rush at the crowd, cutting down all in front of you with your swords, ensuring that no one survives from whom we could face force or deceit. You, mother Ceres and Proserpine, I plead with you, and all you other gods, heavenly and infernal, who watch over this city and these sacred lakes and groves, please lend us your friendly and favorable support, as we undertake this action not to inflict harm, but to prevent it. I would speak at greater length, my soldiers, if you were about to fight armed men; against unarmed and unsuspecting foes, you will slay to your heart’s content. The consul's camp is nearby, so we have nothing to fear from Himilco and the Carthaginians.”

39

Being allowed to retire immediately after this exhortation, they employed themselves in taking refreshment. The next day they stationed themselves some in one place and others in another, to block up the streets, and shut up the ways by which the townsmen might escape, the greater part of them stationing themselves upon and round the theatre, as they had been accustomed before also to be spectators of the assemblies. When the Roman praefect, having been brought into the presence of the people by the magistrates, said, that the power and authority of deciding the question appertained to the consul, and not to him, repeating for the most part what he had urged the day before, first of all a small number, and then more, desired him to give up the keys, but afterwards all with one consent demanded it, and when he hesitated and delayed, threatened him furiously, and seemed as though they would not further delay violent extremities then the praefect gave the signal agreed upon with his gown and the soldiers, who had been long anxiously waiting the signal, and in readiness, raising a shout, ran down, some of them from the higher ground, upon the rear of the assembly while others blocked up the passages leading out of the crowded theatre. The people of Enna thus shut up in the pit were put to the sword, being heaped one upon another not only in consequence of the slaughter, but also from their own efforts to escape, for some scrambling over the heads of others, and those that were unhurt falling upon the wounded, and the living upon the dead, they were accumulated together. Thence they ran in every direction throughout the city, when nothing was any where to be seen but flight and bloodshed, as though the city had been captured, for the rage of the soldiery was not less excited in putting to the sword an unarmed rabble, than it would have been had the heat of battle and an equality of danger stimulated it. Thus possession of Enna was retained, by an act which was either atrocious or unavoidable. Marcellus did not disapprove of the deed, and gave up the plunder of the place to the soldiery, concluding that the Sicilians, deterred by this example, would refrain from betraying their garrisons. As this city was situated in the heart of Sicily, and was distinguished both on account of the remarkable strength of its natural situation, and because every part of it was rendered sacred by the traces it contained of the rape of Proserpine of old, the news of its disaster spread though the whole of Sicily in nearly one day, and as people considered that by this horrid massacre violence had been done not only to the habitations of men, but even of the gods, then indeed those who even before this event were in doubt which side they should take, revolted to the Carthaginians Hippocrates and Himilco, who had in vain brought up their troops to Enna at the invitation of the traitors, retired thence, the former to Murgantia, the latter to Agrigentum. Marcellus retrograded into the territory of Leontium, and after collecting a quantity of corn and other provisions in his camp there, left a small body of troops to protect it, and then went to carry on the siege of Syracuse. Appius Claudius having been allowed to go from thence to Rome to put up for the consulship, he appointed Titus Quintus Crispinus to command the fleet and the old camp in his room. He himself fortified his camp, and built huts for his troops at a distance of five miles from Hexapylum, at a place called Leon. These were the transactions in Sicily up to the beginning of the winter.

Being allowed to retire right after this speech, they focused on taking a break. The next day, some positioned themselves in one spot while others took different positions to block the streets and prevent the townspeople from escaping. Most gathered around the theater, as they had done before when they came to watch the assemblies. When the Roman praefect was brought before the people by the magistrates, he stated that the authority to decide the matter belonged to the consul, not him, repeating much of what he had said the day before. At first, a small number of people asked him to hand over the keys, but soon everyone demanded it in unison, and when he hesitated, they threatened him furiously, seeming ready to take violent action. Then the praefect signaled with his gown, and the soldiers, who had been anxiously waiting, raised a shout and rushed in, some coming down from elevated positions to attack the back of the assembly, while others blocked the exits from the overcrowded theater. The people of Enna, trapped, were killed, piled on top of one another not only from the slaughter but also from their frantic attempts to escape, scrambling over each other, with the unhurt falling on the wounded and the living falling on the dead, becoming a chaotic heap. They then scattered in every direction throughout the city, where all that could be seen was panic and bloodshed, as if the city had been taken by force, with the soldiers fueled by rage against an unarmed crowd, just as they would have been during a fierce battle. Thus, Enna was taken through an act that was either dreadful or unavoidable. Marcellus did not condemn the act and allowed his soldiers to loot the place, believing that the Sicilians, struck by this example, would be dissuaded from betraying their garrisons. Being in the center of Sicily, known for its strategic location and its sacred ties to the ancient abduction of Proserpine, news of the massacre spread across Sicily in almost a day. People felt that this horrific slaughter had not only violated the homes of men but also the sanctuaries of the gods. Consequently, those who had been uncertain which side to support turned against the Carthaginians, Hippocrates and Himilco, who had previously brought their troops to Enna at the traitors' invitation and then retreated, the former to Murgantia and the latter to Agrigentum. Marcellus moved back into the territory of Leontium, gathered a supply of grain and other provisions for his camp, left a small unit to guard it, and continued his siege of Syracuse. Appius Claudius was allowed to leave for Rome to campaign for the consulship, appointing Titus Quintus Crispinus to command the fleet and the old camp in his place. He fortified his camp and built huts for his troops five miles from Hexapylum, at a site called Leon. These were the events in Sicily leading up to the start of winter.

40

The same summer the war with king Philip, as had been before suspected, broke out. Ambassadors from Oricum came to Marcus Valerius, the praetor, who was directing his fleet around Brundusium and the neighbouring coasts of Calabria, with intelligence, that Philip had first made an attempt upon Apollonia, having approached it by sailing up the river with a hundred and twenty barks with two banks of oars; after that, not succeeding so speedily as he had hoped, that he had brought up his army secretly to Oricum by night; which city, as it was situated on a plain, and was not secured either by fortifications or by men and arms, was overpowered at the first assault. At the same time that they delivered this intelligence, they entreated him to bring them succour, and repel that decided enemy of the Romans by land or by a naval force, since they were attacked for no other cause than that they lay over against Italy. Marcus Valerius, leaving Publius Valerius lieutenant-general charged with the protection of that quarter, set sail with his fleet equipped and prepared, having put on board of ships of burthen such soldiers as there was not room for in the men of war, and reached Oricum on the second day; and as that city was occupied by a slight garrison, which Philip had left on his departure thence, he retook it without much opposition. Here ambassadors came to him from Apollonia, stating that they were subjected to a siege because they were unwilling to revolt from the Romans, and that they would not be able any longer to resist the power of the Macedonians, unless a Roman force were sent for their protection. Having undertaken to perform what they wished, he sent two thousand chosen armed men in ships of war to the mouth of the river, under the command of Quintus Naevius Crista, praefect of the allies, a man of enterprise, and experienced in military affairs. Having landed his troops, and sent back the ships to join the rest of the fleet at Oricum, whence he had come, he marched his troops at a distance from the river, by a way not guarded at all by the king's party, and entered the city by night, so that none of the enemy perceived him. During the following day they remained quiet, to afford time for the praefect to inspect the youth of Apollonia, together with the arms and resources of the city. Having derived considerable confidence from a review and inspection of these, and at the same time discovering from scouts the supineness and negligence which prevailed among the enemy, he marched out of the city during the dead of night without any noise, and entered the camp of the enemy, which was in such a neglected and exposed state, that it was quite clear that a thousand men had passed the rampart before any one perceived them, and that had they abstained from putting them to the sword, they might have penetrated to the royal pavilion. The killing of those who were nearest the gate aroused the enemy; and in consequence, they were all seized with such alarm and dismay, that not only none of the rest attempted to take arms or endeavour to expel the enemy from the camp, but even the king himself, betaking himself to flight, in a manner half naked and just as he was when roused from his sleep, hurried away to the river and his ships in a garb scarcely decent for a private soldier, much less for a king. Thither also the rest of the multitude fled with the utmost precipitation. Little less than three thousand men were slain or made prisoners in the camp; considerably more, however, were captured than slain. The camp having been plundered, the Apollonians removed into their city the catapults, ballistas, and other engines which had been got together for the purpose of assaulting their city, for the protection of their walls, in case at any time a similar conjuncture should arise; all the rest of the plunder which the camp afforded was given up to the Romans. Intelligence of these events having been carried to Oricum, Marcus Valerius immediately brought his fleet to the mouth of the river, that the king might not attempt to make his escape by ship. Thus Philip, having lost all hope of being able to cope with his enemies by land or sea, and having either hauled on shore or burnt his ships, made for Macedonia by land, his troops being for the most part unarmed and despoiled of their baggage. The Roman fleet, with Marcus Valerius, wintered at Oricum.

The same summer, the war with King Philip, which had been anticipated, broke out. Ambassadors from Oricum came to Marcus Valerius, the praetor, who was managing his fleet around Brundisium and the nearby coasts of Calabria, with news that Philip had first attempted to seize Apollonia by sailing up the river with 120 ships that had double rows of oars. After not succeeding as quickly as he had hoped, he secretly brought his army to Oricum at night. This city, located on a plain and lacking both fortifications and a strong defense, was overwhelmed during the first attack. When they delivered this news, they begged him to provide support and push back this clear enemy of the Romans by land or naval force, since they were being attacked solely because they were situated across from Italy. Marcus Valerius, leaving Publius Valerius as lieutenant-general to protect the area, set sail with his well-prepared fleet. He loaded onto the transport ships the soldiers who couldn’t fit on the warships and arrived at Oricum on the second day. Since the city was held by only a small garrison Philip left behind, he retook it with little resistance. While there, ambassadors arrived from Apollonia, stating that they were under siege because they refused to rebel against the Romans and that they couldn't hold out against the Macedonians any longer without a Roman force for protection. Committing to help them, he sent 2,000 selected armed men in warships to the river's mouth, under the command of Quintus Naevius Crista, the commander of the allies, a man of initiative and military experience. After landing his troops and sending the ships back to join the rest of the fleet at Oricum, he marched his troops far from the river by a route not patrolled by the king's forces, and entered the city at night without being detected by the enemy. The following day, they remained quiet to give the commander time to assess the young men of Apollonia and the city's arms and resources. Gaining significant confidence from this inspection, and discovering from scouts the carelessness among the enemy, he stealthily left the city during the night and approached the enemy camp, which was in such a disordered and unguarded state that it was clear that a thousand men could have passed the rampart unnoticed, and had they chosen not to kill those nearby, they could have reached the royal tent. The killing of those closest to the gate startled the enemy, causing all of them to panic so that not only did the others fail to prepare for battle or try to drive the enemy from the camp, but even the king himself fled in a semi-naked state, just as he had been roused from sleep, rushing to the river and his ships in clothes hardly appropriate for a private soldier, let alone a king. The rest of the crowd fled in utter haste. Nearly 3,000 men were either killed or captured in the camp; however, considerably more were taken prisoner than killed. After plundering the camp, the Apollonians moved their catapults, ballistas, and other equipment intended for assaulting their city into their own fortifications, to protect their walls in case a similar situation arose in the future; all the other loot from the camp was handed over to the Romans. News of these events reached Oricum, prompting Marcus Valerius to bring his fleet to the river's mouth, ensuring the king couldn’t escape by ship. Thus, having lost all hope of facing his enemies on land or sea, and having either dragged ashore or burned his ships, Philip fled to Macedonia by land, with most of his troops unarmed and stripped of their supplies. The Roman fleet, led by Marcus Valerius, spent the winter at Oricum.

41

The same year the war was prosecuted in Spain with various success; for before the Romans crossed the Iberus, Mago and Hasdrubal had routed an immense army of Spaniards; and the farther Spain would have revolted from the Romans, had not Publius Cornelius, hastily crossing the Iberus with his army, given a seasonable stimulus to the wavering resolutions of his allies by his arrival among them. The Romans first encamped at a place called the High Camp, which is remarkable for the death of the great Hamilcar. It was a fortress strongly defended by works, and thither they had previously conveyed corn; but as the whole circumjacent country was full of enemy's troops, and the Roman army on its march had been charged by the cavalry of the enemy without being able to take revenge upon them, two thousand men, who either loitered behind or had strayed through the fields, having been slain, the Romans quitted this place to get nearer to a friendly country, and fortified a camp at the mount of Victory. To this place came Cneius Scipio with all his forces, and Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, and a third Carthaginian general, with a complete army, all of whom took up a position opposite the Roman camp and on the other side the river. Publius Scipio, going out with some light troops to take a view of the surrounding country, was observed by the enemy; and he would have been overpowered in the open plain, had he not seized an eminence near him. Here too he was closely invested, but was rescued from the troops which environed him by the arrival of his brother. Castulo, a city of Spain, so strong and celebrated, and so closely connected with the Carthaginians, that Hannibal had taken a wife from it, revolted to the Romans. The Carthaginians commenced the siege of Illiturgi, because there was a Roman garrison in it; and it seemed that they would carry the place, chiefly in consequence of a lack of provisions. Cneius Scipio, setting out with a legion lightly equipped, in order to bring succour to his allies and the garrison, entered the city, passing between the two camps of the enemy, and slaying a great number of them. The next day also he sallied out and fought with equal success. Above twelve thousand were slain in the two battles, more than a thousand made prisoners, and thirty-six military standards captured. In consequence of this they retired from Illiturgi. After this the siege of Bigerra, a city which was also in alliance with the Romans, was commenced by the Carthaginians; but Scipio coming up, raised the siege without experiencing any opposition.

The same year, the war in Spain saw mixed results. Before the Romans crossed the Iberus, Mago and Hasdrubal had defeated a massive Spanish army. Spain would have rebelled against the Romans even more if Publius Cornelius hadn’t hurried across the Iberus with his troops, boosting the uncertain morale of his allies with his presence. The Romans first set up camp at a place known as the High Camp, which is notable for the death of the great Hamilcar. It was a well-fortified stronghold where they had stocked up on grain. However, the surrounding area was filled with enemy troops, and while the Roman army was marching, they were attacked by enemy cavalry without a chance to retaliate. Two thousand soldiers who had fallen behind or wandered off were killed, prompting the Romans to leave this location in search of a more secure area and to build a camp at the Mount of Victory. Cneius Scipio arrived with all his forces, along with Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, and a third Carthaginian general, all with a full army, and they positioned themselves across from the Roman camp on the other side of the river. Publius Scipio went out with some light infantry to survey the surrounding area but was spotted by the enemy. He would have been overwhelmed in the open field if he hadn’t taken a higher ground nearby. He was also surrounded there but was saved by the arrival of his brother. Castulo, a well-fortified and renowned city in Spain that was closely tied to the Carthaginians—Hannibal had even taken a wife from there—defected to the Romans. The Carthaginians laid siege to Illiturgi, where there was a Roman garrison, believing they would capture it, particularly due to a lack of supplies. Cneius Scipio set out with a lightly equipped legion to provide support to his allies and the garrison. He entered the city, navigating between the two enemy camps, and killed a significant number of soldiers. The following day, he went out again and fought successfully. In the two battles, over twelve thousand were killed, more than a thousand captured, and thirty-six military standards taken. Consequently, the Carthaginians withdrew from Illiturgi. After that, they began the siege of Bigerra, another city allied with the Romans, but when Scipio arrived, he lifted the siege without facing any resistance.

42

The Carthaginians then removed their camp to Munda, whither the Romans speedily followed them. Here a pitched battle was fought, which lasted almost four hours; and while the Romans were carrying all before them in the most glorious manner, the signal for retreat was sounded, because the thigh of Cneius Scipio had been transfixed with a javelin. The soldiers round about him were thrown into a state of great alarm, lest the wound should be mortal. However, there was no doubt but that if they had not been prevented by the intervention of this accident, they might have taken the Carthaginian camp that day. By this time, not only the men, but the elephants, were driven quite up to the rampart; and even upon the top of it nine and thirty elephants were pierced with spears. In this battle, too, as many as twelve thousand are said to have been slain, nearly three thousand captured, with fifty-seven military standards. The Carthaginians retired thence to the city Auringis, whither the Romans followed them, in order to take advantage of their terror. Here Scipio again fought them, having been carried into the field in a small litter; the victory was decisive; but not half so many of the enemy were slain as before, because fewer survived to fight. But this family, which possessed a natural talent at renewing war and restoring its effects, in a short time recruited their army, Mago having been sent by his brother to press soldiers, and assumed courage to try the issue of a fresh struggle. Though the soldiers were for the most part different, yet as they fought in a cause which had so often been unsuccessful within the space of a few days, they carried into the field the same state of mind as those which had been engaged before, and the issue of the battle was similar. More than eight thousand were slain, not much less than a thousand captured, with fifty-eight military standards. The greater part of the spoils had belonged to the Gauls, consisting of golden chains and bracelets in great numbers. Also two distinguished Gallic petty princes, whose names were Moenicaptus and Civismarus, fell in this battle. Eight elephants were captured and three slain. When affairs went on so prosperously in Spain, the Romans began to feel ashamed that Saguntum, on account of which the war had originated, should continue for now the eighth year in the power of the enemy. Accordingly, having expelled by force the Carthaginian garrison, they retook that town, and restored it to such of the ancient inhabitants as had survived the fury of the war. The Turditanians also, who had been the cause of the war between that people and the Carthaginians, they reduced under their power, sold them as slaves, and razed their city.

The Carthaginians then moved their camp to Munda, where the Romans quickly followed them. A pitched battle was fought here, lasting almost four hours. While the Romans were achieving remarkable success, the signal for retreat was sounded because Cneius Scipio had been pierced in the thigh by a javelin. The soldiers around him fell into a panic, fearing the wound could be fatal. However, it was clear that if they hadn’t been interrupted by this accident, they could have taken the Carthaginian camp that day. By this time, not only the soldiers but also the elephants were pushed right up to the rampart; and even on top of it, thirty-nine elephants were speared. In this battle, around twelve thousand were killed, nearly three thousand were captured, along with fifty-seven military standards. The Carthaginians retreated to the city of Auringis, where the Romans pursued them to capitalize on their fear. Here, Scipio fought them again, being carried into battle on a small litter; the victory was decisive, but not as many of the enemy were killed as before since fewer were left to fight. However, this family had a natural talent for renewing war and rebuilding their forces, and they quickly replenished their army, with Mago sent by his brother to recruit soldiers, gathering the courage to attempt a new struggle. Though most of the soldiers were different, since they fought for a cause that had frequently failed in the days prior, they carried the same mindset into battle as those before them, and the outcome was similar. More than eight thousand were killed, nearly a thousand were captured, and fifty-eight military standards were taken. Most of the spoils belonged to the Gauls, including a large number of golden chains and bracelets. Two notable Gallic leaders, named Moenicaptus and Civismarus, were also killed in this battle. Eight elephants were captured and three were killed. As things were going so well in Spain, the Romans began to feel ashamed that Saguntum, the reason the war started, had remained in enemy hands for the eighth year. Therefore, they forcefully expelled the Carthaginian garrison, retook the town, and restored it to the surviving ancient inhabitants. They also defeated the Turditanians, who had caused the war between the Carthaginians and their people, reducing them to slavery and destroying their city.

43

Such were the achievements in Spain during the consulate of Quintus Fabius and Marcus Claudius. At Rome, as soon as the new plebeian tribunes entered upon their office, Lucius Metellus, a plebeian tribune, immediately appointed a day for impleading the censors, Publius Furius and Marcus Atilius, before the people. In the preceding year, when he was quaestor, they had deprived him of his horse, removed him from his tribe, and disfranchised him, on account of the conspiracy entered into at Cannae to abandon Italy. But being aided by the other nine tribunes, they were forbidden to answer while in office, and were discharged. The death of Publius Furius prevented their completing the lustrum. Marcus Atilius abdicated his office. An assembly for the election of consuls was held by Quintus Fabius Maximus. The consuls elected were Quintus Fabius Maximus, son of the consul, and Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus a second time, both being absent. The praetors appointed were Marcus Atilius, and the two curule aediles, Publius Sempronius Tuditanus and Cneius Fulvius Centumalus, together with Marcus Aemilius Lepidus. It is recorded, that the scenic games were this year, for the first time, celebrated for four days by the curule aediles. The aedile Tuditanus was the man who made his way through the midst of the enemy at Cannae when all the rest were paralysed with fear, in consequence of that dreadful calamity. As soon as the elections were completed, the consuls elect having been summoned to Rome, at the instance of Quintus Fabius, the consul, entered upon their office, and took the sense of the senate respecting the war, their own provinces as well as those of the praetors, and also respecting the armies to be employed, and which each of them was to command.

Such were the achievements in Spain during the consulate of Quintus Fabius and Marcus Claudius. In Rome, as soon as the new plebeian tribunes took office, Lucius Metellus, a plebeian tribune, quickly set a date for bringing the censors, Publius Furius and Marcus Atilius, before the people. The previous year, when he was quaestor, they had taken away his horse, removed him from his tribe, and stripped him of his voting rights, due to the conspiracy at Cannae to leave Italy. However, with support from the other nine tribunes, the censors were not allowed to respond while in office and were released. The death of Publius Furius prevented them from completing the lustrum. Marcus Atilius stepped down from his position. An assembly for electing consuls was held by Quintus Fabius Maximus. The consuls elected were Quintus Fabius Maximus, the son of the consul, and Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus for a second time, both of whom were absent. The appointed praetors were Marcus Atilius, along with the two curule aediles, Publius Sempronius Tuditanus and Cneius Fulvius Centumalus, along with Marcus Aemilius Lepidus. It’s noted that this year, the scenic games were held for the first time for four days by the curule aediles. Aedile Tuditanus was the one who fought through the enemy ranks at Cannae when everyone else was frozen with fear from that terrible disaster. Once the elections were wrapped up, the elected consuls were called to Rome. Following Quintus Fabius's initiative, they began their duties and consulted the senate about the war, their own provinces, the praetors' provinces, and the armies to be deployed, as well as who would command each.

44

The provinces and armies were thus distributed: the prosecution of the war with Hannibal was given to the consuls, and of the armies, one which Sempronius himself had commanded, and another which the consul Fabius had commanded, each consisting of two legions. Marcus Aemilius, the praetor, who had the foreign jurisdiction, was to have Luceria as his province, with the two legions which Quintus Fabius, then consul, had commanded as praetor, his colleague, Marcus Atilius, the city praetor, undertaking the duties of his office. The province of Ariminum fell to the lot of Publius Sempronius, that of Suessula to Cneius Fulvius, with two legions each likewise; Fulvius taking with him the city legions; Tuditanus receiving his from Manius Pomponius. The following generals were continued in command, and their provinces assigned to them thus: to Marcus Claudius, so much of Sicily as lay within the limits of the kingdom of Hiero; to Lentulus, the propraetor, the old province in that island; to Titus Otacilius, the fleet; no additional troops were assigned to them. Marcus Valerius had Greece and Macedonia, with the legion and the fleet which he had there; Quintus Mucius had Sardinia, with his old army, consisting of two legions; Caius Terentius, Picenum, with one legion which he then commanded. Besides, orders were given to enlist two legions for the city, and twenty thousand men from the allies. With these leaders and these forces did they fortify the Roman empire against the many wars which had either actually broken out, or were suspected at one and the same time. After enlisting the city legions and raising troops to make up the numbers of the others, the consuls, before they quitted the city, expiated the prodigies which were reported. A wall and a gate had been struck by lightning; and at Aricia even the temple of Jupiter had been struck by lightning. Other illusions of the eyes and ears were credited as realities. An appearance as of ships had been seen in the river at Tarracina, when there were none there. A clashing of arms was heard in the temple of Jupiter Vicilinus, in the territory of Compsa; and a river at Amiternum had flowed bloody. These prodigies having been expiated according to a decree of the pontiffs, the consuls set out, Sempronius for Lucania, Fabius for Apulia. The father of the latter came into the camp at Suessula, as his lieutenant-general; and when the son advanced to meet him, the lictors, out of respect for his dignity, went on in silence. The old man rode past eleven of the fasces, when the consul ordered the lictor nearest to him to take care and he called to him to dismount; then at length dismounting, he exclaimed, "I wished to try, my son, whether you were duly sensible that you are a consul."

The provinces and armies were organized like this: the war against Hannibal was assigned to the consuls. One army, led by Sempronius, and another led by consul Fabius, each consisted of two legions. Marcus Aemilius, the praetor responsible for foreign affairs, was given Luceria as his province, along with the two legions that the former consul Quintus Fabius had commanded. His colleague, Marcus Atilius, the city praetor, took on his official duties. Publius Sempronius was assigned the province of Ariminum, and Cneius Fulvius was given Suessula, each with two legions; Fulvius brought the city legions with him, while Tuditanus received his from Manius Pomponius. The following generals were kept in command with their provinces assigned as follows: Marcus Claudius had the part of Sicily that was in the kingdom of Hiero; Lentulus, the propraetor, managed the old province on that island; Titus Otacilius was in charge of the fleet, with no extra troops assigned to them. Marcus Valerius oversaw Greece and Macedonia, along with the legion and the fleet he had there; Quintus Mucius had Sardinia with his old army of two legions; and Caius Terentius was in Picenum, commanding one legion. Additionally, orders were given to recruit two legions for the city and twenty thousand men from the allies. With this leadership and these forces, they strengthened the Roman empire against the many wars that had either already started or were suspected to be imminent. After enlisting the city legions and bolstering the other numbers, the consuls, before leaving the city, addressed the reported prodigies. A wall and a gate had been struck by lightning, and even the temple of Jupiter at Aricia had been hit by lightning. Other visual and auditory illusions were also believed to be real. An illusion of ships was seen in the river at Tarracina when none were actually there. There was a noise of clashing arms in the temple of Jupiter Vicilinus in the territory of Compsa, and a river in Amiternum had flowed with blood. After these prodigies were expiated following a decree from the pontiffs, the consuls departed, with Sempronius heading for Lucania and Fabius going to Apulia. The father of the latter came into the camp at Suessula as his lieutenant-general; when the son went to welcome him, the lictors remained silent out of respect for his position. The old man passed by eleven fasces, and the consul instructed the nearest lictor to take care and asked him to dismount. Finally dismounting, he exclaimed, "I wanted to see, my son, if you were aware that you are a consul."

45

To this camp came Dasias Altinius of Arpi privately and by night, attended by three slaves, with a promise that if he should receive a reward for it, he would engage to betray Arpi to them. Fabius having laid the matter before a council, some were of opinion that "he ought to be scourged and put to death as a deserter, as a man of unstable mind, and a common enemy to both sides; who, after the defeat at Cannae, had gone over to Hannibal and drawn Arpi into revolt, as if it were right that a man's fidelity should vary according to the fluctuations of fortune; and who now, when the Roman cause, contrary to his hopes and wishes, was as it were rising up again, would seem to aggravate his baseness by recompensing those whom he had formerly betrayed, by fresh betrayal. That a man whose custom it was to espouse one side, while his heart was on another, was unworthy of confidence as an ally, and contemptible as an enemy; that he ought to be made a third example to deserters, in addition to the betrayers of Falerii and Pyrrhus." On the other hand, Fabius, the father of the consul, observed, that, "forgetful of circumstances, men were apt to exercise a free judgment on every question in the heat of war, as in time of peace; for though in the present instance that which ought rather to form the object of their endeavours and to occupy their thoughts, is by what means it may be brought about that none of the allies may revolt from the Roman people, yet that they never think of; but, on the contrary, they urge that an example ought to be made of any who might repent and look back upon their former alliance. But if it is allowable to forsake the Romans, and not allowable to return to them, who can doubt but that in a short time the Romans, deserted by their allies, will see every state in Italy united in leagues with the Carthaginians. Not, however, that he was of opinion that any confidence was to be reposed in Altinius, but he would invent some middle course of proceeding. Treating him neither as an enemy nor as a friend for the present, his wish was, that he should be kept during the war in some city whose fidelity could be relied on, at a short distance from the camp, in a state of easy restraint; and that when the war was concluded, they should then deliberate whether he more deserved to be punished for his former defection, or pardoned for his present return." The opinion of Fabius was approved of. Altinius was bound in chains and given into custody, together with his companions, and a large quantity of gold which he brought with him was ordered to be kept for him. He was kept at Cales, where, during the day, he was unconfined, but attended by guards who locked him up at night. He was first missed and inquired for at his house at Arpi. but afterwards, when the report of his absence had spread through the city, a violent sensation was excited, as if they had lost their leader, and, from the apprehension of some attempt to alter the present state of things, messengers were immediately despatched to Hannibal. With this the Carthaginian was far from being displeased, both because he had long regarded the man himself with suspicion, as one of doubtful fidelity, and because he had now been lucky enough to get a pretext for possessing himself of the property of so wealthy a person. But that the world might suppose that he had yielded to resentment more than to avarice, he added cruelty to rapacity; for he summoned his wife and children to the camp, and after having made inquiry, first, respecting the flight of Altinius, and then, touching the quantity of gold and silver which was left at his house, and informed himself on all these points, he burned them alive.

To this camp came Dasias Altinius from Arpi quietly at night, accompanied by three slaves, with a promise that if he got a reward, he would betray Arpi to them. Fabius presented the matter to a council, and some believed that "he should be whipped and executed as a deserter, as an unstable person and a common enemy to both sides; who, after the defeat at Cannae, had sided with Hannibal and incited Arpi to revolt, as if it was acceptable for a person's loyalty to change with fortune; and who now, when the Roman cause, contrary to his expectations, was rising again, would seem to worsen his betrayal by rewarding those he had previously betrayed, with fresh treachery. A person who switches sides while their heart is with another is untrustworthy as an ally and contemptible as an enemy; he should be made a third example for deserters, along with the betrayers of Falerii and Pyrrhus." On the other hand, Fabius, the consul's father, noted that "people, forgetting the context, often judge freely on every issue during wartime as they do in peace. Though what they should focus on is how to ensure that none of the allies revolt from the Roman people, they never consider that; instead, they argue that an example should be made of anyone who repents and tries to return to their previous allegiance. But if it’s acceptable to abandon the Romans and unacceptable to return to them, who can doubt that soon the Romans, abandoned by their allies, will see every state in Italy forming alliances with the Carthaginians? Nonetheless, he didn’t think any trust should be placed in Altinius, but he would seek a middle path. Treating him as neither a friend nor an enemy for now, he wanted him to be kept during the war in a city that could be trusted, close to the camp, under some easy restraint; and that after the war, they should consider whether he deserved punishment for his previous defection or mercy for his current return." Fabius's opinion was favored. Altinius was put in chains and handed over for custody, along with his companions, and a large amount of gold he brought was ordered to be kept for him. He was held at Cales, where during the day he was free but watched by guards who locked him up at night. He was first noticed missing and searched for at his home in Arpi, but later, as news of his absence spread through the city, a strong reaction was provoked, as if they had lost their leader. Fearing an attempt to change the current situation, messengers were quickly sent to Hannibal. The Carthaginian was quite pleased with this, as he had long viewed Altinius with suspicion due to his questionable loyalty, and now he had a reason to seize the assets of such a wealthy individual. To make it clear that he was acting out of more than just greed, he showed cruelty to his greed; he summoned Altinius's wife and children to the camp, and after inquiring about Altinius's flight and how much gold and silver was left in his house, he learned all these details and had them burned alive.

46

Fabius, setting out from Suessula, first set about the siege of Arpi; and having pitched his camp about half a mile from it, he took a near view of the site and walls of the city, and resolved to attack it, in preference, in that quarter where it was most secured by works, and where the least care was taken in guarding it. After getting all things together which could be of use in besieging a city, he selected the most efficient of the centurions out of the whole army, placing them under the command of tribunes of approved valour, and giving them six hundred soldiers, a number which was thought sufficient for the purpose. These he ordered to bring the scaling ladders to the place which he had marked out, as soon as the signal of the fourth watch had sounded. In this part there was a low and narrow gate, opening into a street which was little frequented, and which led through a deserted part of the city. He ordered them, after scaling the wall, to proceed to this gate, and break down the bars on the inside by force, and when they were in possession of that part of the city, to give a signal with a cornet, that the rest of the troops might be brought up, observing that he would have every thing prepared and ready. These orders were executed promptly, and that which seemed likely to impede their operations, served more than any thing to conceal them. A shower of rain, which came on suddenly at midnight, compelled the guards and watches to slip away from their posts and take shelter in the houses; and the noise of the shower, which was somewhat copious, at first prevented their hearing that which was made by the men in breaking open the gate. Afterwards, when it fell upon the ear more gently and uniformly, it lulled a great number of the men to sleep. After they had secured possession of the gate, they placed cornet-players in the street at equal distances, and desired them to sound, in order to call the consul. This being done according to the plan previously agreed upon, the consul ordered the troops to march, and a little before daylight entered the city through the broken gate.

Fabius, leaving Suessula, first started the siege of Arpi. After setting up his camp about half a mile away, he took a close look at the city's layout and walls, deciding to attack from the section that was best fortified but also least monitored. Once he gathered everything needed for the siege, he chose the most capable centurions from the whole army, putting them under the command of trusted tribunes and assigning them six hundred soldiers, a number deemed adequate for the task. He instructed them to bring scaling ladders to the designated spot as soon as the signal for the fourth watch was given. In this area, there was a low, narrow gate leading to a rarely used street that passed through an abandoned part of the city. He ordered them to scale the wall, head to this gate, and forcibly break the bars from the inside. Once they took control of that part of the city, they were to signal with a cornet so the rest of the troops could rush in, noting that he would have everything prepared and ready. These orders were carried out quickly, and what seemed likely to hinder their efforts actually helped conceal them. A sudden downpour at midnight caused the guards and sentries to leave their posts and seek shelter in the buildings; the sound of the heavy rain initially masked the noise of the men forcing open the gate. Later, as the rain softened and fell more steadily, it lulled many of the soldiers to sleep. After securing the gate, they positioned cornet players along the street at intervals and asked them to sound their instruments to summon the consul. Once this was done according to the earlier plan, the consul ordered the troops to advance, and just before dawn, they entered the city through the breached gate.

47

Then at length the enemy were roused, the shower was now subsiding, and daylight coming on. Hannibal had a garrison of about five thousand armed men in the city, and the inhabitants themselves had three thousand men in arms; these the Carthaginians placed in front against the enemy, to guard against any treachery on their rear. The fight was carried on at first in the dark, and in the narrow streets, the Romans having seized not only the streets, but the houses also nearest the gate, that they might not be struck or wounded by any thing discharged at them from above. Some of the Arpinians and Romans recognised each other, which led to conversations, in which the Romans asked them, what it was they meant? for what offence on the part of the Romans, or what service on that of the Carthaginians, they, who were Italians, made war in favour of foreigners and barbarians, against their ancient allies the Romans, and endeavoured to render Italy tributary and stipendiary to Africa? The Arpinians urged in excuse of themselves, that in ignorance of all the circumstances, they had been sold to the Carthaginians by their nobility, and that they were kept in a state of thraldom and oppression by the few. A beginning having been made, greater numbers on both sides entered into conversation; and at length the praetor of Arpi was brought by his countrymen before the consul, and after exchanging assurances in the midst of the standards and the troops, the Arpinians suddenly turned their arms against the Carthaginians, in favour of the Romans. Some Spaniards also, little less than a thousand in number, after only stipulating with the consul that the Carthaginian garrison might be allowed to march out unhurt, passed over to the consul. The gates were therefore thrown open for the Carthaginians; and being allowed to go out unmolested, in conformity with the stipulation, they joined Hannibal in Salapia. Thus was Arpi restored to the Romans, without the loss of a life, except that of one man, who was formerly a traitor, and recently a deserter. The Spaniards were ordered to receive a double allowance of provisions, and on very many occasions the republic availed itself of their brave and faithful services. While one of the consuls was in Apulia, and the other in Lucania, a hundred and twelve Campanian noblemen, having gone out of Capua, with the permission of the magistrates, under pretence of collecting booty from the enemy's lands, came into the Roman camp, which lay above Suessula. They told the soldiers, forming the vanguard, that they wished to speak with the praetor. Cneius Fulvius commanded the camp; who, on being informed of the circumstance, ordered ten of them to be brought into his presence unarmed; and after hearing their request, (and all they asked was, that when the Romans should recover Capua, their property might be restored to them,) they were all received under his protection. The other praetor, Sempronius Tuditanus, took by force the town of Aternum; more than seven thousand were captured, with a considerable quantity of coined brass and silver. A dreadful fire happened at Rome, which continued for two nights and a day; every thing was burnt to the ground between the Salinae and the Carmental gate, with the Aequimaelium and the Jugarian street. In the temples of Fortune, Mater Matuta, and Hope, which latter stood without the gate, the fire, spreading to a wide extent, consumed much both sacred and profane.

Then finally the enemy were stirred, the rain was fading, and daylight was coming in. Hannibal had a garrison of about five thousand armed men in the city, and the local inhabitants had three thousand men ready to fight; the Carthaginians positioned them at the front against the enemy to prevent any betrayal from behind. The battle began in the dark and in the narrow streets, with the Romans seizing not only the streets but also the nearby houses to avoid being hit or injured by anything thrown down from above. Some of the Arpinians and Romans recognized each other, leading to conversations where the Romans questioned them about their actions. They asked what the Arpinians were doing fighting for foreign barbarians against their old allies, the Romans, and trying to make Italy serve Africa. The Arpinians defended themselves, saying they had been sold to the Carthaginians by their leaders, and they were being oppressed by the few. Once the discussions started, more people from both sides began to talk; eventually, the praetor of Arpi was brought by his fellow citizens before the consul. After exchanging assurances amid the standards and troops, the Arpinians suddenly turned their weapons against the Carthaginians in support of the Romans. Some Spaniards, numbering nearly a thousand, after negotiating with the consul to allow the Carthaginian garrison to leave safely, switched sides to the consul. The gates were then opened for the Carthaginians, who were allowed to exit without harm, as promised, and they joined Hannibal in Salapia. Thus, Arpi was returned to the Romans without a single life lost, except for one man, a former traitor who had recently deserted. The Spaniards were ordered to receive double rations, and on many occasions, the republic benefited from their brave and loyal service. While one of the consuls was in Apulia and the other in Lucania, a hundred and twelve noblemen from Campania, having left Capua with the magistrates' permission under the guise of gathering loot from enemy lands, came into the Roman camp, which was positioned above Suessula. They told the soldiers in the vanguard that they wanted to speak with the praetor. Cneius Fulvius commanded the camp; upon being informed of the situation, he ordered ten of them to be brought to him unarmed. After hearing their request (all they wanted was to have their property returned once the Romans recaptured Capua), they were all placed under his protection. The other praetor, Sempronius Tuditanus, seized the town of Aternum by force, capturing more than seven thousand people and a significant amount of minted brass and silver. A terrible fire broke out in Rome, lasting for two nights and a day; everything was burned to the ground between the Salinae and the Carmental gate, including the Aequimaelium and Jugarian street. In the temples of Fortune, Mater Matuta, and Hope, the fire spread widely and consumed much that was both sacred and secular.

48

The same year, the two Cornelii, Publius and Cneius, as affairs were now in a prosperous state in Spain, and they had recovered many ancient allies, and attached fresh ones to them, extended their views even to Africa. Syphax was a king of the Numidians, who had suddenly become hostile to the Carthaginians; to him they sent three centurions as ambassadors, to form a treaty of friendship and alliance with him; and to promise, that, if he persevered in pressing the war against the Carthaginians, he would render an acceptable service to the senate and people of Rome, and they would endeavour to requite the favour with large additions, and at a seasonable time. This embassy was gratifying to the barbarian; and when conversing with the ambassadors on the art of war he heard the observations of those experienced soldiers, by comparing his own practice with so regular a system of discipline, he became sensible of how many things he himself was ignorant. Then he entreated them to give the first proof of their being good and faithful allies, "by letting two of them carry back the result of their embassy to their generals, while one remained with him as his instructor in military science, observing that the Numidian nation were unacquainted with the method of carrying on war with foot forces, being useful only as mounted soldiers. That it was in this manner that their ancestors had carried on war even from the first origin of their nation, and to this they were habituated from their childhood. But that they had to contend with an enemy who relied upon the prowess of their infantry; with whom, if they wished to be placed upon an equality in respect of efficient strength, they must also furnish themselves with infantry. That his dominions abounded with a large quantity of men fit for the purpose, but that he was unacquainted with the art of arming, equipping, and marshalling them; that all his infantry were unwieldy and unmanageable, like a rabble collected together by chance." The ambassadors answered, that they would comply with his request for the present, on his engaging to send him back immediately, if their generals did not approve of what they had done. The name of the person who staid behind with the king was Quintus Statorius. With the two other Romans, the Numidian sent ambassadors into Spain, to receive the ratification of the alliance from the Roman generals. He gave it in charge to the same persons, forthwith to induce the Numidians, who were serving as auxiliaries among the Carthaginian troops, to go over to the other side. Statorius raised a body of infantry for the king out of the large number of young men which he found; and having formed them into companies, in close imitation of the Roman method, taught them to follow their standards and keep their ranks when being marshalled, and when performing their evolutions; and he so habituated them to military works and other military duties, that in a short time the king relied not more on his cavalry than on his infantry; and in a regular and pitched battle, fought on a level plain, he overcame his enemies, the Carthaginians. In Spain also the arrival of the king's ambassadors was of the greatest advantage to the Romans, for at the news thereof the Numidians began rapidly to pass over. Thus the Romans and Syphax were united in friendship, which the Carthaginians hearing of, immediately sent ambassadors to Gala, who reigned in another part of Numidia, over a nation called Massylians.

The same year, the two Cornelii, Publius and Cneius, found themselves in a good position in Spain, having regained many old allies and formed new ones, and they set their sights on Africa. They sent three centurions as ambassadors to Syphax, the king of the Numidians, who had suddenly turned against the Carthaginians, to establish a treaty of friendship and alliance with him. They promised that if he kept fighting the Carthaginians, he would be doing a great service for the senate and people of Rome, and they would reward him generously at the right time. This mission pleased the king, and during discussions on military strategy, he realized how much he didn’t know compared to the disciplined approach of the Roman soldiers. He then asked them to show their loyalty by sending two of them back to inform their generals of their talks, while one stayed behind to teach him military tactics, pointing out that the Numidians only knew how to fight as cavalry and weren’t experienced with infantry. He explained that his ancestors had always fought this way and that they needed to adapt to compete against an enemy that relied on infantry. Though his territory had plenty of men suitable for infantry, he didn’t know how to arm, equip, and organize them, so they ended up being unruly and disorganized. The ambassadors agreed to his request, on the condition that if their generals didn’t approve of the arrangement, they would be sent back immediately. The Roman who stayed with the king was Quintus Statorius. The other two Romans sent ambassadors to Spain to get approval for the alliance from the Roman generals. They were also tasked with convincing Numidians fighting for the Carthaginians to switch sides. Statorius created an infantry for the king from the many young men he found, training them in companies similar to the Roman method, teaching them to follow their standards and keep in formation during maneuvers. He trained them in military practices and responsibilities so well that soon the king relied equally on both his cavalry and infantry, and in a regular battle on a flat field, he defeated his enemies, the Carthaginians. In Spain, the arrival of the king's ambassadors greatly benefited the Romans, as the Numidians quickly began to switch sides. Thus, the Romans and Syphax formed a friendship, and when the Carthaginians heard about this, they immediately sent ambassadors to Gala, who ruled another part of Numidia over a people called the Massylians.

49

Gala had a son named Masinissa, seventeen years of age, but a youth of such talents, that even at that time it was evident that he would render the kingdom more extensive and powerful than when he received it. The ambassadors represented that, "since Syphax had united himself with the Romans, that by their alliance he might strengthen his hands against the kings and nations of Africa, it would be better for Gala also to unite with the Carthaginians as soon as possible, before Syphax crossed over into Spain, or the Romans into Africa; that Syphax might be overpowered, while as yet he derived nothing from his league with the Romans but the name of it." Gala, his son claiming to be intrusted with the conduct of the war, was easily prevailed upon to send an army, which, joined by the legions of the Carthaginians, totally defeated Syphax in a great battle. In this thirty thousand men are said to have been slain. Syphax, with a few horsemen, fled from the field, and took refuge among the Maurusian Numidians, a nation dwelling at the extremity of Africa, near the ocean, and over against Gades. But the barbarians flocking to his standard from all sides, in consequence of his great renown, he speedily armed a very large force. Before he passed over with these forces into Spain, which was separated only by a narrow strait, Masinissa came up with his victorious army; and here he acquired great glory in the prosecution of the war with Syphax, in which he acted alone and unsupported by any aid from the Carthaginians. In Spain nothing worth mentioning was performed, except that the Romans drew over to their side the Celtiberian youth, by giving them the same pay which they had stipulated with the Carthaginians to pay them. They also sent above three hundred Spaniards of the greatest distinction into Italy, to bring over their countrymen, who served among the auxiliary troops of Hannibal. The only memorable circumstance of this year in Spain was, that the Romans then, for the first time, employed mercenary troops in their camp, namely, the Celtiberians.

Gala had a son named Masinissa, who was seventeen years old. He was so talented that even then it was clear he would make the kingdom larger and more powerful than when he inherited it. The ambassadors explained that since Syphax had aligned with the Romans to strengthen himself against the kings and nations of Africa, it would be wise for Gala to team up with the Carthaginians as soon as possible, before Syphax could move into Spain or the Romans into Africa. This way, Syphax could be defeated while he was still only benefiting from the alliance by name. Gala, with his son insisting on leading the war effort, was easily convinced to send an army, which, along with the Carthaginian legions, completely defeated Syphax in a major battle, where about thirty thousand men are said to have been killed. Syphax, with just a few horsemen, fled the battlefield and sought refuge among the Maurusian Numidians, a people living at the edge of Africa near the ocean, across from Gades. However, because of his great reputation, many barbarian warriors rallied to his side, and he quickly assembled a large force. Before he crossed over to Spain, which was just a narrow strait away, Masinissa caught up with his victorious army and earned significant glory in the ongoing war against Syphax, conducting it independently without assistance from the Carthaginians. In Spain, not much of note happened except that the Romans attracted the Celtiberian youth to their side by matching the pay that had been promised by the Carthaginians. They also sent over three hundred distinguished Spaniards to Italy to win over their countrymen who served in Hannibal's auxiliary troops. The only noteworthy event in Spain that year was that the Romans used mercenary troops in their camp for the first time, specifically the Celtiberians.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXV.
B.C. 213-212


Publius Cornelius Scipio, afterwards called Africanus, elected aedile before he had attained the age required by the law. The citadel of Tarentum, in which the Roman garrison had taken refuge, betrayed to Hannibal. Games instituted in honour of Apollo, called Apollinarian. Quintus Fulvius and Appius Claudius, consuls, defeat Hanno the Carthaginian general. Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus betrayed by a Lucanian to Mago, and slain. Centenius Penula, who had been a centurion, asks the senate for the command of an army, promising to engage and vanquish Hannibal, is cut off with eight thousand men. Cneius Fulvius engages Hannibal, and is beaten, with the loss of sixteen thousand men slain, he himself escapes with only two hundred horsemen. Quintus Fulvius and Appius Claudius, consuls, lay siege to Capua. Syracuse taken by Claudius Marcellus after a siege of three years. In the tumult occasioned by taking the city, Archimedes is killed while intently occupied on some figures which he had drawn in the sand. Publius and Cornelius Scipio, after having performed many eminent services in Spain, are slain, together with nearly the whole of their armies, eight years after their arrival in that country; and the possession of that province would have been entirely lost, but for the valour and activity of Lucius Marcius, a Roman knight, who, collecting the scattered remains of the vanquished armies, utterly defeats the enemy, storming their two camps, killing thirty-seven thousand of them, and taking eighteen hundred together with an immense booty.

       *        *        *        *        *

1

Hannibal passed the summer during which these events occurred in Africa and Italy, in the Tarentine territory, with the hope of having the city of the Tarentines betrayed to him. Meanwhile some inconsiderable towns belonging to them, and to the Sallentines, revolted to him. At the same time, of the twelve states of the Bruttians, which had in a former year gone over to the Carthaginians, the Consentians and Thurians returned to the protection of the Roman people. And more would have done the same, had not Titus Pomponius Veientanus, praefect of the allies, having acquired the appearance of a regular general, in consequence of several successful predatory expeditions in the Bruttian territory, got together a tumultuary band, and fought a battle with Hanno. In that battle, a great number of men, consisting, however, of a disorderly rabble of slaves and rustics, were slain or captured. The least part of the loss was, that the praefect himself was taken prisoner; for he was not only in the present instance guilty of having rashly engaged the enemy, but previously, in the capacity of farmer of the revenue, by iniquitous practices of every description, had shown himself faithless and injurious to the state, as well as the companies. Among the Lucanians, the consul, Sempronius, fought several small battles, but none worthy of being recorded, he also took several inconsiderable towns. In proportion as the war was protracted, and the sentiments no less than the circumstances of men fluctuated accordingly as events flowed prosperously or otherwise, the citizens were seized with such a passion for superstitious observances, and those for the most part introduced from foreign countries, that either the people or the gods appeared to have undergone a sudden change. And now the Roman rites were growing into disuse, not only in private, and within doors, but in public also; in the forum and Capitol there were crowds of women sacrificing, and offering up prayers to the gods, in modes unusual in that country. A low order of sacrificers and soothsayers had enslaved men's understandings, and the numbers of these were increased by the country people, whom want and terror had driven into the city, from the fields which were lain uncultivated during a protracted war, and had suffered from the incursions of the enemy, and by the profitable cheating in the ignorance of others which they carried on like an allowed and customary trade. At first, good men gave protest in private to the indignation they felt at these proceedings, but afterwards the thing came before the fathers, and formed a matter of public complaint. The aediles and triumviri, appointed for the execution of criminals, were severely reprimanded by the senate for not preventing these irregularities, but when they attempted to remove the crowd of persons thus employed from the forum, and to overthrow the preparations for their sacred rites, they narrowly escaped personal injury. It being now evident, that the evil was too powerful to be checked by inferior magistrates, the senate commissioned Marcus Atilius, the city praetor, to rid the people of these superstitions. He called an assembly, in which he read the decree of the senate, and gave notice, that all persons who had any books of divination, or forms of prayer, or any written system of sacrificing, should lay all the aforesaid books and writings before him before the calends of April; and that no person should sacrifice in any public or consecrated place according to new or foreign rites.

Hannibal spent the summer during which these events took place in Africa and Italy, specifically in the Tarentine region, hoping to have the city of Tarentum betray him. In the meantime, some minor towns owned by them and the Sallentines switched sides to him. At the same time, out of the twelve states of the Bruttians that had previously allied with the Carthaginians, the Consentians and Thurians returned to Roman protection. More would have followed suit if it weren't for Titus Pomponius Veientanus, a prefect of the allies, who gained a reputation as a regular general after several successful raids in Bruttian territory. He gathered a makeshift army and clashed with Hanno. In that battle, many men were killed or captured, although they were mostly a disorganized mix of slaves and peasants. The least of the losses was that the prefect himself was captured; he not only recklessly engaged the enemy but had also previously acted dishonestly as a tax farmer, harming both the state and the companies. Among the Lucanians, the consul Sempronius fought several minor battles, none significant enough to be noted, and captured several small towns. As the war dragged on, people's feelings and circumstances changed based on whether events were going well or poorly. Citizens became obsessed with superstitious practices, mostly imported from other countries, leading to a noticeable shift in either the people or the gods. Roman religious rituals were being neglected, not just in private but also in public; in the forum and Capitol, groups of women were making sacrifices and offering prayers in unfamiliar ways. A low class of sacrificers and soothsayers gained control over people's minds, and this group's numbers grew with the arrival of desperate country folks, driven into the city by the war's devastation and enemy raids, exploiting the ignorance of others as though it were a regular business. Initially, decent citizens expressed their outrage privately about these actions, but soon it became a public issue acknowledged by the leaders. The aediles and triumviri, responsible for punishing criminals, were harshly criticized by the senate for failing to curb these irregularities. However, when they tried to disperse the crowd engaged in these activities from the forum and dismantle their sacred setups, they narrowly avoided harm. It became clear that the issue was too big for lower officials to handle, so the senate appointed Marcus Atilius, the city praetor, to eliminate these superstitions. He called a meeting to read the senate's decree and announced that everyone with any books on divination, prayers, or any written instructions on sacrifices must present all these writings to him before the calends of April; and that no one should perform sacrifices in any public or sacred spaces using new or foreign rituals.

2

Several of the public priests too died this year: Lucius Cornelius Lentulus, chief pontiff, Caius Papirius Maso, son of Caius, a pontiff, Publius Furius Philo, an augur, and Caius Papirius Maso, son of Lucius, a decemvir for the superintendence of sacred rites. In lieu of Lentulus, Marcus Cornelius Cethegus, in lieu of Papirius Cnaeius, Servilius Caepio, were created pontiffs. Lucius Quinctius Flaminius was created augur, and Lucius Cornelius Lentulus decemvir for the superintendence of sacred rites. The time for the election of consuls was now approaching; but as it was not thought proper to call the consuls away from the war with which they were intently occupied, Tiberius Sempronius, the consul, nominated Caius Claudius Centho as dictator to hold the election. He appointed Quintus Fulvius Flaccus as his master of the horse. On the first day on which the election could be held, the dictator appointed as consuls, Quintus Fulvius Flaccus, his master of the horse, and Appius Claudius Pulcher, who had held the government of Sicily as praetor. The praetors created were Cneius Fulvius Flaccus, Caius Claudius Nero, Marcus Junius Silanus, Publius Cornelius Sulla. The election completed, the dictator retired from his office. This year, Publius Cornelius Scipio, afterwards surnamed Africanus, held the office of curule aedile, with Marcus Cornelius Cethegus; and when the tribunes of the people opposed his pretensions to the aedileship, alleging, that no notice ought to be taken of him, because he had not attained the legal age for candidateship, he observed, "if the citizens in general are desirous of appointing me aedile, I am old enough." Upon this the people ran to their respective tribes to give their votes, with feelings so strongly disposed in his favour, that the tribunes on a sudden abandoned their attempt. The largesses bestowed by the aediles were the following: the Roman games were sumptuously exhibited, considering the present state of their resources; they were repeated during one day, and a gallon of oil was given to each street. Lucius Villius Tapulus, and Marcus Fundanius Fundulus, the plebeian aediles, accused some matrons of misconduct before the people, and some of them they convicted and sent into exile. The plebeian games were repeated during two days, and a feast in honour of Jupiter was celebrated on occasion of the games.

Several public priests also died this year: Lucius Cornelius Lentulus, the chief pontiff; Caius Papirius Maso, son of Caius, a pontiff; Publius Furius Philo, an augur; and Caius Papirius Maso, son of Lucius, a decemvir responsible for overseeing sacred rites. In place of Lentulus, Marcus Cornelius Cethegus was appointed, and in place of Papirius Cnaeius, Servilius Caepio was appointed as pontiffs. Lucius Quinctius Flaminius became an augur, and Lucius Cornelius Lentulus became a decemvir for overseeing sacred rites. The time for electing consuls was approaching, but since it was considered inappropriate to pull the consuls away from the war they were focused on, Tiberius Sempronius, the consul, nominated Caius Claudius Centho as dictator to oversee the elections. He appointed Quintus Fulvius Flaccus as his master of the horse. On the first day when elections could be held, the dictator appointed Quintus Fulvius Flaccus, his master of the horse, and Appius Claudius Pulcher, who had governed Sicily as praetor, as consuls. The praetors elected were Cneius Fulvius Flaccus, Caius Claudius Nero, Marcus Junius Silanus, and Publius Cornelius Sulla. Once the election was completed, the dictator stepped down from his position. This year, Publius Cornelius Scipio, later known as Africanus, served as curule aedile alongside Marcus Cornelius Cethegus; when the tribunes of the people challenged his eligibility for the role, claiming he hadn't reached the legal age to run, he replied, "If the citizens want to elect me aedile, I'm old enough." The people then rushed to their respective tribes to cast their votes, feeling so strongly in his favor that the tribunes suddenly abandoned their challenge. The benefits provided by the aediles included lavish Roman games, given the current state of resources; they were held for one day, and each street received a gallon of oil. Lucius Villius Tapulus and Marcus Fundanius Fundulus, the plebeian aediles, accused some matrons of misconduct before the people, and some were convicted and exiled. The plebeian games were held for two days, and a feast in honor of Jupiter was celebrated on the occasion of the games.

3

Quintus Fulvius Flaccus, for the third time, and Appius Claudius entered upon the office of consuls. The praetors determined their provinces by lot. Publius Cornelius Sulla received both the city and the foreign jurisdiction, formerly allotted to two persons, Cneius Fulvius Flaccus, Apulia, Caius Claudius Nero, Suessula, and Marcus Junius Silanus, Tuscany. To the consuls the conduct of the war with Hannibal was decreed with two legions each, one taking the troops of Quintus Fabius, the consul of the former year, the other those of Fulvius Centumalus. Of the praetors, Fulvius Flaccus was to have the legions which were in Luceria under Aemilius the praetor, Nero Claudius those in Picenum under Caius Terentius, each raising recruits for himself to fill up the number of his troops. To Marcus Junius the city legions of the former year were assigned, to be employed against the Tuscans. Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus and Publius Sempronius Tuditanus were continued in command in their provinces of Lucania and Gaul with the armies they had, as was also Publius Lentulus in that part of Sicily which formed the ancient Roman province. Marcus Marcellus had Syracuse, and that which was the kingdom of Hiero. Titus Otacilius was continued in the command of the fleet, Marcus Valerius in that of Greece, Quintus Mucius Scaevola in that of Sardinia. The Cornelii, Publius and Cneius, were continued in the command of Spain. In addition to the armies already existing, two legions for the service of the city were levied by the consuls, and a total of twenty-three legions was made up this year. The levy of the consuls was impeded by the conduct of Marcus Posthumius Pyrgensis, almost accompanied with a serious disturbance. Posthumius was a farmer of the revenue, who, for knavery and rapacity, practised through a course of many years, had no equal except Titus Pomponius Veientanus, who had been taken prisoner the former year by the Carthaginians under the conduct of Hanno, while carelessly ravaging the lands in Lucania. As the state had taken upon itself the risk of any loss which might arise from storms to the commodities conveyed to the armies, not only had these two men fabricated false accounts of shipwrecks, but even those which had really occurred were occasioned by their own knavery, and not by accident. Their plan was to put a few goods of little value into old and shattered vessels, which they sank in the deep, taking up the sailors in boats prepared for the purpose, and then returning falsely the cargo as many times more valuable than it was. This fraudulent practice had been pointed out to Marcus Atilius, the praetor in a former year, who had communicated it to the senate; no decree, however, had been passed censuring it, because the fathers were unwilling that any offence should be given to the order of revenue farmers while affairs were in such a state. The people were severer avengers of the fraud; and at length two tribunes of the people, Spurius and Lucius Carvilius, being moved to take some active measure, as they saw that this conduct excited universal disgust, and had become notorious, proposed that a fine of two hundred thousand asses should be imposed on Marcus Posthumius. When the day arrived for arguing the question, the people assembled in such numbers, that the area of the Capitol could scarcely contain them; and the cause having been gone through, the only hope of safety which presented itself was, that Caius Servilius Casca, a tribune of the people, a connexion and relation of Posthumius, should interpose his protest before the tribes were called to give their votes. The witnesses having been produced, the tribunes caused the people to withdraw, and the urn was brought, in order that the tribes should draw lots which should give the vote first. Meanwhile, the farmers of the revenue urged Casca to stop the proceedings for that day. The people, however, loudly opposed it; and Casca happened to be sitting on the most prominent part of the rostrum, whose mind fear and shame were jointly agitating. Seeing that no dependence was to be placed in him for protection, the farmers of the revenue, forming themselves into a wedge, rushed into the void space occasioned by the removal of the people for the purpose of causing disturbance, wrangling at the same time with the people and the tribunes. The affair had now almost proceeded to violence, when Fulvius Flaccus, the consul, addressing the tribunes, said, "Do you not see that you are degraded to the common rank, and that an insurrection will be the result, unless you speedily dismiss the assembly of the commons."

Quintus Fulvius Flaccus, for the third time, and Appius Claudius began their term as consuls. The praetors drew lots to decide their provinces. Publius Cornelius Sulla was assigned both the city and foreign jurisdiction, which had previously been split between two people: Cneius Fulvius Flaccus in Apulia, Caius Claudius Nero in Suessula, and Marcus Junius Silanus in Tuscany. The consuls were given command of the war against Hannibal, each with two legions—one taking over the troops from Quintus Fabius, the consul from the previous year, and the other those from Fulvius Centumalus. Among the praetors, Fulvius Flaccus was allocated the legions stationed in Luceria under Aemilius the praetor, while Nero Claudius was assigned the ones in Picenum under Caius Terentius, with each tasked to recruit more soldiers to fill their ranks. Marcus Junius received the city legions from the prior year, to be used against the Tuscans. Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus and Publius Sempronius Tuditanus retained their commands in Lucania and Gaul with their existing armies, as did Publius Lentulus in the part of Sicily that was once the ancient Roman province. Marcus Marcellus was in charge of Syracuse and the former kingdom of Hiero. Titus Otacilius continued in command of the fleet, Marcus Valerius in Greece, and Quintus Mucius Scaevola in Sardinia. The Cornelii, Publius and Cneius, remained in charge of Spain. Besides the existing armies, the consuls raised two additional legions for city service, bringing the total to twenty-three legions this year. The consuls' recruitment efforts were hindered by the actions of Marcus Posthumius Pyrgensis, which nearly led to major unrest. Posthumius was a tax farmer whose long history of fraud and greed made him as notorious as Titus Pomponius Veientanus, who had been captured by the Carthaginians the previous year while carelessly pillaging in Lucania. The state accepted the risk of any losses from storms affecting goods sent to the armies; not only did these two men create false reports of shipwrecks, but even genuine losses were often caused by their own deceit rather than by chance. Their scheme involved placing a few worthless goods in old, damaged ships, which they sank, rescuing the sailors in boats they had prepared and then falsely claiming the cargo was worth much more than it actually was. This scam had been pointed out to Marcus Atilius, the praetor from the previous year, who informed the senate; however, no decree was passed to condemn it because the senators were reluctant to offend the tax farmers during such turbulent times. The public, however, were more severe in their demand for justice, and eventually, two tribunes of the people, Spurius and Lucius Carvilius, feeling compelled to take action because the fraud had become widely unpopular, proposed imposing a fine of two hundred thousand asses on Marcus Posthumius. When the day came for the debate, the crowd gathered in such great numbers that the area of the Capitol could barely hold them; after the case was presented, the only glimmer of hope for Posthumius was that Caius Servilius Casca, a tribune and relative of Posthumius, would intervene with a protest before the tribes were called to vote. Witnesses were brought forward, and the tribunes asked the crowd to withdraw while the urn was prepared for the tribes to draw lots for their voting order. Meanwhile, the tax farmers urged Casca to halt the proceedings for the day. However, the people strongly opposed it; Casca found himself sitting prominently on the rostrum, torn between fear and shame. Realizing he couldn’t be relied upon for support, the tax farmers banded together and charged into the space created by the withdrawing crowd to provoke chaos while arguing with both the people and the tribunes. Just as tensions were about to escalate into violence, Fulvius Flaccus, the consul, addressed the tribunes, saying, "Don’t you see that you are lowering yourselves to the level of commoners, and that an uprising will ensue if you don’t quickly disperse this assembly?"

4

The commons being dismissed, the senate was assembled, when the consuls proposed the consideration of the interruption experienced by the assembly of the commons, in consequence of the violence and audacity of the farmers of the revenue. They said, that "Marcus Furius Camillus, whose banishment was followed by the downfall of the city, had suffered himself to be condemned by his exasperated countrymen. That before him, the decemviri, according to whose laws they lived up to the present day, and afterwards many men of the first rank in the state, had submitted to have sentence passed upon them by the people. But Posthumius Pyrgensis had wrested from the Roman people their right of suffrage, had dissolved the assembly of the commons, had set at nought the authority of the tribunes, had drawn up a body of men in battle-array against the Roman people; and seized upon a post, in order to cut off the tribunes from the commons, and prevent the tribes being called to give their votes. That the only thing which had restrained the people from bloodshed and violence, was the forbearance of the magistrates in giving way for the moment to the fury and audacity of a few individuals, and suffering themselves and the Roman people to be overcome; and that no opportunity might be afforded those who were seeking an occasion of violence, in dissolving, agreeably to the wish of the defendant himself, that assembly which he was about to interrupt by force of arms." Observations of this kind having been urged with a warmth proportioned to the atrocity of the conduct which called them forth, by all the most respectable persons, and the senate having passed a decree to the effect that the violence offered was prejudicial to the state, and a precedent of pernicious tendency, immediately the Carvilii, tribunes of the people, giving up the action for a fine, appointed a day on which Posthumius should be tried capitally, and ordered, that unless he gave bail, he should be apprehended by the beadle, and carried to prison. Posthumius gave bail, but did not appear. The tribunes then proposed to the commons, and the commons resolved, that if Marcus Posthumius did not appear before the calends of May, and if on being cited on that day he did not answer, and sufficient cause were not shown why he did not, he would be adjudged an exile, his goods would be sold, and himself interdicted from water and fire. They then proceeded to indict capitally, and demand bail of each of the persons who had been the promoters of the disorder and riot. At first they threw into prison those who did not give bail, and afterwards even such as could; upon which the greater part of them went into exile, to avoid the danger to which this proceeding exposed them.

The commons having been dismissed, the senate convened, and the consuls brought up the issue of the disruption faced by the assembly of the commons, due to the violence and boldness of the tax collectors. They stated that "Marcus Furius Camillus, whose exile led to the city's downfall, allowed himself to be condemned by his angry fellow citizens. Before him, the decemviri, whose laws they still followed, as well as many prominent figures in the state, had accepted judgment from the people. But Posthumius Pyrgensis had taken away the Roman people's right to vote, had disbanded the commons assembly, ignored the authority of the tribunes, had gathered armed men against the Roman populace; and had seized a position to cut off the tribunes from the commons, preventing the tribes from being called to cast their votes. The only reason that the people refrained from bloodshed and violence was the restraint shown by the magistrates, allowing for the moment the rage and boldness of a few individuals to prevail over them and the Roman people; and that no opportunity should be given to those seeking violence by disbanding, as the defendant wished, the assembly he intended to disrupt with armed force." These points were passionately made by all the most respected individuals, and the senate issued a decree stating that the violence was harmful to the state and a dangerous precedent. Immediately, the Carvilii, tribunes of the people, opting to drop the action for a fine, set a date for Posthumius's capital trial, and ordered that if he did not provide bail, he should be apprehended by the beadle and taken to prison. Posthumius provided bail but failed to appear. The tribunes then proposed to the commons, and the commons agreed, that if Marcus Posthumius did not appear before the calends of May, and if on that day he did not respond, and did not show sufficient reason for his absence, he would be declared an exile, his property sold, and he would be banned from water and fire. They then proceeded to file capital charges and demand bail from each person who had instigated the disorder and riot. Initially, they imprisoned those who did not provide bail, and later even those who could; as a result, most of them went into exile to escape the risks posed by this process.

5

The knavery of the revenue farmers, and their subsequent audacious conduct to screen themselves from its effects, thus terminated. An assembly was then held for the creation of a chief pontiff. The new pontiff, Marcus Cornelius Cethegus, presided. The election was contested with the greatest obstinacy by three candidates, Quintus Fulvius Flaccus, the consul, who had been twice consul before and censor, Titus Manhus Torquatus, who had himself also been distinguished by two consulships and the censorship, and Publius Licinius Ciassus, who was about to stand for the office of curule aedile. In this contest, the last-mentioned candidate, though a young man, beat the others, who were his superiors in years, and had filled offices of honour. Before him there had not been a man for a hundred and twenty years, except Publius Cornelius Calussa, who had been created chief pontiff without having sat in the curule chair. Though the consuls found great difficulty in completing the levy, for in consequence of the scarcity of young men, it was not easy to procure enough for the two purposes of forming the new city legions, and recruiting the old ones, the senate forbade them to desist from the attempt, and ordered two triumvirates to be appointed, one of which within, the other without the fiftieth mile from the city, might ascertain the utmost number of free-born men which were to be found in the villages, and market towns, and hamlets, and enlist whom they thought strong enough to bear arms, though they had not attained the military age. That the tribunes of the people, if they thought proper, should propose to the people, that such as should take the military oath being under seventeen years, should be allowed to reckon their period of service in the same manner as if they had enlisted at seventeen or older. The two triumvirates, created agreeably to this decree of the senate, enlisted free-born men throughout the country. At the same time a letter from Marcellus from Sicily, respecting the petition of the troops who served with Publius Lentulus, was read in the senate. These troops were the relics of the disaster at Cannae, and had been sent out of the way into Sicily, as has been mentioned before, on an understanding that they should not be brought home before the conclusion of the Carthaginian war.

The dishonesty of the tax collectors and their bold actions to protect themselves from the fallout ultimately came to an end. An assembly was called to select a chief pontiff. The new pontiff, Marcus Cornelius Cethegus, took charge. The election saw fierce competition among three candidates: Quintus Fulvius Flaccus, the consul who had served as consul twice before and was also a censor; Titus Manhus Torquatus, who had also distinguished himself with two consulships and a censorship; and Publius Licinius Ciassus, who was running for the position of curule aedile. In this race, the youngest candidate, Ciassus, managed to outshine the others, who were older and had held prestigious positions. Before him, there hadn’t been anyone in over a hundred and twenty years, except for Publius Cornelius Calussa, who was appointed chief pontiff without ever having held the curule chair. The consuls were having a tough time with the draft because there was a shortage of young men, making it difficult to gather enough recruits for both the new city legions and the old ones. The senate insisted they continue, ordering two groups to be formed—one to operate inside the city and the other outside the fiftieth mile—to identify the maximum number of free-born men available in villages, market towns, and hamlets, and to enlist those considered strong enough for service, even if they hadn't reached the military age yet. The tribunes of the people were to propose to the citizens that those under seventeen who took the military oath should be allowed to count their service as if they had enlisted at seventeen or older. The two groups, formed as per the senate’s decree, recruited free-born men across the country. At the same time, a letter from Marcellus in Sicily regarding the requests from the troops who served with Publius Lentulus was read in the senate. These troops were remnants of the defeat at Cannae and had been sent to Sicily, as previously stated, under the condition that they would not return until the Carthaginian war was over.

6

With the permission of Lentulus, these men sent the most distinguished of the cavalry and centurions, and a select body of the legionary infantry, as ambassadors to Marcellus, to his winter quarters. Having obtained leave to speak, one of them thus addressed him: "We should have approached you, Marcus Marcellus, when consul in Italy, as soon as that decree of the senate was passed respecting us, which, though not unjust, was certainly severe, had we not hoped, that being sent into a province which was in a state of disorder in consequence of the death of its kings, to carry on an arduous war against the Sicilians and Carthaginians together, we should make atonement to the state by our blood and wounds, in the same manner as, within the memory of our fathers, those who were taken prisoners by Pyrrhus at Heraclea, made atonement by fighting against the same Pyrrhus. And yet, for what fault of ours, conscript fathers, did you then, or do you now, feel displeasure towards us; for when I look upon you, Marcus Marcellus, I seem to behold both the consuls and the whole body of the senate; and had you been our consul at Cannae, a better fate would have attended the state as well as ourselves. Permit me, I entreat you, before I complain of the hardship of our situation, to clear ourselves of the guilt with which we are charged. If it was neither by the anger of the gods, nor by fate, according to whose laws the course of human affairs is unalterably fixed, but by misconduct that we were undone at Cannae; but whose was that misconduct; the soldiers', or that of their generals? For my own part, I, as a soldier, will never say a word of my commander, particularly when I know that he received the thanks of the senate for not having despaired of the state; and who has been continued in command through every year since his flight from Cannae. We have heard that others also who survived that disaster, who were military tribunes, solicit and fill offices of honour, and have the command of provinces. Do you then, conscript fathers, pardon yourselves and your children, while you exercise severity towards such insignificant persons as we are? It was no disgrace to a consul and other leading persons in the state, to fly when no other hope remained; and did you send your soldiers into the field as persons who must of necessity die there? At the Allia nearly the whole army fled; at the Caudine Forks the troops delivered up their arms to the enemy, without even making an effort; not to mention other disgraceful defeats of our armies. Yet, so far from any mark of infamy being sought for, which might be fixed upon these troops, the city of Rome was recovered by means of those very troops who had fled to Veii from the Allia; and the Caudine legions, which had returned to Rome without their arms, being sent back armed to Samnium, brought under the yoke that very enemy who had exulted in the disgrace which, in this instance, attached to them. But is there a man who can bring a charge of cowardice or running away against the army which fought at Cannae, where more than fifty thousand men fell; from whence the consul fled with only seventy horsemen; where not a man survived, except perchance those whom the enemy left, being wearied with killing? When the proposal to ransom the prisoners was negatived, we were the objects of general commendation, because we reserved ourselves for the service of the state; because we returned to the consul to Venusia, and exhibited an appearance of a regular army. Now we are in a worse condition than those who were taken prisoners in the time of our fathers; for they only had their arms, the nature of their service, and the place where they might pitch their tents in the camp altered; all which, however, they got restored by one service rendered to the state, and by one successful battle. Not one of them was sent away into banishment; not one was deprived of the hope of completing the period of his service; in short, an enemy was assigned to them, fighting with whom they might at once terminate their life or their disgrace. We, to whom nothing can be objected, except that it is owing to us that any Roman soldier has survived the battle of Cannae, are removed far away, not only from our country and Italy, but even from an enemy; where we may grow old in exile, where we can have no hope or opportunity of obliterating our disgrace, of appeasing the indignation of our countrymen, or, in short, of obtaining an honourable death. We seek neither to have our ignominy terminated, nor our virtue rewarded, we only ask to be allowed to make trial of our courage, and to exercise our virtue. We seek for labour and danger that we may discharge the duty of men and soldiers. A war is carrying on in Sicily, now for the second year, with the utmost vigour on both sides. The Carthaginians are storming some cities, the Romans others, armies of infantry and horse are engaging in battle, at Syracuse the war is prosecuted by sea and by land. We hear distinctly the shout of the combatants, and the din of arms, while we ourselves lie inactive and unemployed, as if we had neither hands nor arms. The consul, Sempronius has now fought many pitched battles with the enemy with legions of slaves. They receive as the fruits of their exertion their liberty, and the rights of citizens. Let us at least be employed by you as slaves purchased for the service of this war, let us be allowed to combat with the enemy and acquire our freedom by fighting. Do you wish to make trial of our valour by sea, by land, in a pitched battle, or in the assault of towns? We ask as our portion all those enterprises which present the greatest difficulty and danger, that what ought to have been done at Cannae may be done as soon as possible, for the whole of our subsequent lives has been doomed to ignominy."

With Lentulus's permission, these men sent the most distinguished cavalry and centurions, along with a select group of legionary infantry, as ambassadors to Marcellus at his winter quarters. After receiving permission to speak, one of them addressed him: "We should have come to you, Marcus Marcellus, when you were consul in Italy, immediately after the Senate passed that decree about us, which, though not unjust, was definitely harsh. We hoped that being sent into a province in chaos due to the deaths of its kings, to fight a tough war against both the Sicilians and the Carthaginians, we could make amends to the state with our blood and wounds, just like those who were captured by Pyrrhus at Heraclea did, making amends by fighting Pyrrhus again. Yet, for what reason, honorable senators, did you then, or do you now, feel displeased with us? When I look at you, Marcus Marcellus, I see both the consuls and the entire Senate; had you been our consul at Cannae, a better fate would have awaited both the state and us. Please allow me, before I discuss the harshness of our situation, to clear ourselves of the blame we bear. If our defeat at Cannae was not due to the anger of the gods, nor by fate, which dictates the course of human affairs unchangeably, but by mistakes, who made those mistakes—the soldiers or their generals? Personally, as a soldier, I will never speak ill of my commander, especially knowing he received the Senate's praise for not giving up on the state and has remained in command every year since fleeing from Cannae. We have heard that others who survived that disaster, who were military tribunes, have sought and filled positions of honor and command of provinces. So, senators, do you pardon yourselves and your children while imposing harshness on insignificant individuals like us? It was not shameful for a consul and other leading figures in the state to flee when all hope was lost; did you send your soldiers into the field to die for certain? At the Allia, nearly the entire army fled; at the Caudine Forks, the troops surrendered their weapons to the enemy without even trying; not to mention other disgraceful defeats our armies suffered. Yet, instead of seeking marks of shame to attach to these troops, the city of Rome was recovered by those very troops who had fled to Veii from the Allia; and the Caudine legions, who returned to Rome without their arms, were sent back fully armed to Samnium, bringing under subjugation the very enemy that celebrated their disgrace. But is there anyone who can accuse the army that fought at Cannae of cowardice or running away, where over fifty thousand men fell; where the consul fled with only seventy horsemen; where no one survived, unless perhaps those whom the enemy spared out of exhaustion from killing? When the suggestion to ransom the prisoners was rejected, we were praised for reserving ourselves for the service of the state; because we returned to the consul in Venusia and presented ourselves as a proper army. Now we are worse off than those who were prisoners in times past; they only had their weapons taken, their roles altered, and the places where they could camp changed; yet they regained everything by one service to the state and one victorious battle. None of them were exiled; none were stripped of the hope of finishing their service; in short, they faced an enemy assigned to them, fighting whom they could end their lives or their shame. We, who can barely be blamed except for the fact that it is thanks to us that any Roman soldier has survived the battle of Cannae, are removed far away—not only from our country and Italy but even from an enemy—where we could grow old in exile, with no hope or chance of erasing our disgrace, appeasing our fellow countrymen's anger, or, ultimately, achieving an honorable death. We seek neither to have our disgrace erased nor our virtue recognized; we only ask to be allowed to test our courage and demonstrate our virtue. We seek work and danger to fulfill our duty as men and soldiers. A war is currently being waged in Sicily for the second year, with both sides fighting fiercely. The Carthaginians are attacking some cities, while the Romans are assaulting others; armies of infantry and cavalry are engaged in battle; at Syracuse, the war is being fought both by sea and by land. We clearly hear the shouts of the combatants and the clash of arms while we lie idle and unemployed, as if we have no hands or arms. The consul, Sempronius, has fought many pitched battles against the enemy with legions of slaves. They earn their freedom and the rights of citizens through their efforts. Let us at least be employed by you as slaves hired for this war; let us be allowed to fight the enemy and win our freedom through battle. Do you want us to prove our bravery at sea, on land, in pitched battles, or in town assaults? We want all those tasks that involve the greatest difficulty and danger so that what should have been done at Cannae may happen as soon as possible because the entirety of our future lives has been condemned to disgrace."

7

At the conclusion of this speech they prostrated themselves at the knees of Marcellus. Marcellus replied, that the question was neither within his authority nor his power, that he would, however, write to the senate, and be guided in every thing he did by the judgment of the fathers. This letter was brought to the new consuls, and by them read in the senate, and, on the question being put relative to this letter, they decreed, "that the senate saw no reason why the interests of the republic should be intrusted to the hands of soldiers who had deserted then comrades, in battle, at Cannae. If Marcus Marcellus, the proconsul, thought otherwise, that he should act as he deemed consistent with the good of the republic and his own honour, with this proviso, however, that none of these men should be exempt from service, nor be presented with any military reward in consideration of valour, or be conveyed back to Italy, while the enemy was in that country." After this, agreeably to the decree of the senate, and the order of the people, an election was held by the city praetor, at which five commissioners were created for the purpose of repairing the walls and turrets, and two sets of triumviri, one to search for the property belonging to the temples, and to register the offerings, the other for repairing the temples of Fortune and Mother Matuta within the Carmental gate, and also that of Hope without the gate, which had been destroyed by fire the year before. Dreadful storms occurred at this time. It rained stones for two days without intermission in the Alban mount. Many places were struck by lightning; two buildings in the Capitol, the rampart in the camp above Suessula in many places, and two of the men on guard were killed. A wall and certain towers at Cannae were not only struck with lightning, but demolished. At Reate, a vast rock was seen to fly about; the sun appeared unusually red and blood-like. On account of these prodigies there was a supplication for one day, and the consuls employed themselves for several days in sacred rites; at the same time there was a sacred rite performed through nine days. An accidental circumstance which occurred at a distance, hastened the revolt of Tarentum, which had now for a long time been the object of the hopes of Hannibal and of the suspicion of the Romans. Phileas, a native of Tarentum, who had been a long time at Rome under the pretence of an embassy, being a man of a restless mind, and ill brooking that inactive state in which he considered that his powers had been for too long a time sinking into imbecility, discovered for himself a means of access to the Tarentine hostages. They were kept in the court of the temple of Liberty, and guarded with less care, because it was neither the interest of themselves nor of their state to escape from the Romans. By corrupting two of the keepers of the temple, he was enabled to hold frequent conferences with them, at which he solicited them to come into this design; and having brought them out of their place of confinement as soon as it was dark, he became the companion of their clandestine flight, and got clear away. As soon as day dawned, the news of their escape spread through the city, and a party sent in pursuit, having seized them all at Tarracina, brought them back. They were led into the Comitium, and after being scourged with rods, with the approbation of the people, were thrown down from the rock.

At the end of this speech, they knelt before Marcellus. Marcellus responded that the matter was beyond his authority and capacity, but he would write to the Senate and would be guided in all his actions by the judgment of the elders. This letter was delivered to the new consuls, who read it in the Senate. When the question regarding the letter was raised, they declared, "The Senate sees no reason to entrust the interests of the republic to soldiers who abandoned their comrades in battle at Cannae. If Marcus Marcellus, the proconsul, thinks otherwise, he should act according to what he believes is in the best interest of the republic and his own honor, with the condition that none of these men would be exempt from service, nor receive any military rewards for bravery, or be sent back to Italy while the enemy remained in the country." Following this, according to the Senate's decree and the people's order, an election was held by the city praetor, creating five commissioners tasked with repairing the walls and towers, as well as two sets of triumviri—one to recover property belonging to the temples and to register the offerings, and the other dedicated to repairing the temples of Fortune and Mother Matuta at the Carmental gate, along with that of Hope outside the gate, which had been destroyed by fire the previous year. During this time, there were terrible storms. It rained stones for two days nonstop in the Alban mount. Many places were hit by lightning; two buildings in the Capitol, a rampart in the camp above Suessula in several spots, and two guards were killed. A wall and some towers at Cannae were not only struck by lightning but also destroyed. At Reate, a huge rock was seen flying around; the sun appeared unusually red and blood-like. Because of these omens, a day of supplication was called, and the consuls engaged in sacred rites for several days; at the same time, a sacred rite was performed over nine days. An incident occurring afar hastened the revolt of Tarentum, which had long been the target of Hannibal's hopes and the Romans' suspicions. Phileas, a native of Tarentum who had been in Rome under the pretense of an embassy, a restless man who couldn’t tolerate the inactivity that he felt was causing his abilities to waste away, found a way to access the Tarentine hostages. They were held in the courtyard of the temple of Liberty and were guarded less strictly, as it wasn’t in their or their state’s interest to escape from the Romans. By bribing two of the temple guards, he was able to have frequent meetings with them, where he urged them to join his plan. After bringing them out of confinement as soon as it got dark, he joined them in their secret escape and got away. When day broke, news of their escape spread throughout the city, and a party sent in pursuit caught them all at Tarracina and brought them back. They were led into the Comitium, and after being beaten with rods, were thrown from the rock with the people's approval.

8

The severity of this punishment exasperated the inhabitants of two of the most distinguished Greek states in Italy, not only publicly as communities, but privately as individuals, according as each was connected, either by relationship or friendship, with those who had been so disgracefully put to death. Of these about thirteen noble Tarentine youths formed a conspiracy, the chief of whom were Nico and Philemenus. Concluding that it would be right to confer with Hannibal before they took any step, they went to him, having been allowed to go out of the city by night on pretence of hunting. When they were now not far from the camp, all the rest hid themselves in a wood by the road side; but Nico and Philemenus, proceeding to the advanced guard, were seized, and at their own request brought before Hannibal. Having laid before him the motives of their plan, and the object they had in view, they received the highest commendation, and were loaded with promises; and that their countrymen might believe that they had gone out of the city to obtain plunder, they were desired to drive to the city some cattle of the Carthaginians which had been sent out to graze. A promise was given them that they might do this without danger or interruption. The booty of the young men attracted notice, and less astonishment was therefore felt that they should frequently repeat the attempt. At a second meeting with Hannibal they entered into a solemn engagement, that the Tarentines should be free, enjoying their own laws, and all their rights uninterfered with; that they should neither pay any tribute to the Carthaginians, nor receive a garrison against their will; that their present garrison should be delivered up to the Carthaginians. These points being agreed upon, Philemenus then began to repeat more frequently his customary practice of going out and returning to the city followed by his dogs, and furnished with the other requisites for hunting; for he was remarkable for his fondness of hunting; and generally bringing home something which he had captured or taken away from the enemy, who had purposely placed it in his way he presented it to the commander or the guards of the gates. They supposed that he preferred going and returning by night through fear of the enemy. After this practice had become so familiar, that at whatever time of the night he gave a signal, by whistling, the gate was opened, Hannibal thought that it was now time to put the plan in execution. He was at the distance of three days' journey, and to diminish the wonder which would be felt at his keeping his camp fixed in one and the same place so long, he feigned himself ill. Even to the Romans who formed the garrison of Tarentum, his protracted inactivity had ceased to be an object of suspicion.

The harshness of this punishment frustrated the people of two of the most distinguished Greek states in Italy, both publicly as communities and privately as individuals, depending on their connections, either through family or friendship, with those who had been shamefully executed. Around thirteen noble young men from Tarentum formed a conspiracy, with Nico and Philemenus as their leaders. Believing it was important to consult Hannibal before taking any action, they approached him under the guise of going out to hunt, having received permission to leave the city at night. As they got close to the camp, the others hid in a nearby forest, while Nico and Philemenus went to the front guard, where they were captured and, at their own request, brought before Hannibal. After explaining their motives and goals, they received high praise and were promised support. To make it seem like they had left the city to raid, they were asked to bring back some Carthaginian cattle that had been sent out to graze. They were assured they could do this without risk or disturbance. The young men's acquisition of loot drew attention, and it was less surprising that they would make similar attempts repeatedly. In a second meeting with Hannibal, they made a formal agreement that the Tarentines would be free, maintaining their own laws and rights without interference; that they wouldn’t have to pay tribute to the Carthaginians or accept an unwanted garrison; and that their current garrison would be handed over to the Carthaginians. After reaching this agreement, Philemenus began to frequently follow his usual routine of going out and returning to the city with his dogs and other hunting gear, as he was known for his love of hunting, often bringing back something he had captured or taken from the enemy that had been intentionally left for him, which he would present to the commander or the gate guards. They assumed he preferred traveling at night out of fear of the enemy. Once this routine became so familiar that the gate would be opened whenever he whistled at night, Hannibal thought it was time to execute the plan. He was three days’ journey away, and to reduce the suspicion around his camp remaining in one place for so long, he pretended to be sick. Even the Romans manning the Tarentum garrison no longer viewed his prolonged inactivity with suspicion.

9

But after he determined to proceed to Tarentum, selecting from his infantry and cavalry ten thousand men, whom, from activity of body, and lightness of arms, he judged best adapted for the expedition, he began his march in the fourth watch of the night; and sending in advance about eighty Numidian horsemen, ordered them to scour the country on each side of the road, and narrowly examine every place, lest any of the rustics who might have observed his army at a distance should escape; to bring back those who were got before, and kill those whom they met, that they might appear to the neighbouring inhabitants to be a plundering party, rather than a regular army. Hannibal himself, marching at a rapid pace, pitched his camp about fifteen miles from Tarentum; and without telling his soldiers even there, what was their destination, he only called them together and admonished them to march all of them in the road, and not to suffer any one to turn aside or deviate from the line; and above all, that they would be on the watch, so as to catch the word of command, and not do any thing without the order of their leaders; that in due time he would issue his commands as to what he wished to be done. About the same hour a rumour reached Tarentum, that a few Numidian horsemen were devastating the fields, and had terrified the rustics through a wide extent of country; at which intelligence the Roman praefect took no further step than to order a division of his cavalry to go out the following day at sunrise to check the depredations of the enemy; and so far was he from directing his attention to any thing else on this account, that on the contrary, this excursion of the Numidians was a proof to him that Hannibal and his army had not moved from his camp. Early in the night Hannibal put his troops in motion, and Philemenus, with his customary burden of prey taken in hunting, was his guide. The rest of the conspirators waited the accomplishment of what had been concerted; and the agreement was, that Philemenus, while bringing in his prey through the small gate by which he was accustomed to pass, should introduce some armed men, while Hannibal in another quarter approached the gate called Temenis, which faced the east, in that quarter which was towards the continent, near the tombs which were within the walls. When he drew near to the gate, Hannibal raised a fire according to agreement, which made a blaze; the same signal was returned by Nico, and the fires were extinguished on both sides. Hannibal led his troops on in silence to the gate. Nico suddenly fell upon the guards while asleep, slew them in their beds, and opened the gate. Hannibal then entered with his infantry, ordering his cavalry to stay behind, that they might be able to bring their assistance wherever it was required without obstruction. Philemenus also in another quarter approached the small gate by which he was accustomed to pass and re-pass. His voice, which was well known, for he said he could scarcely bear the weight of the huge beast he had gotten, and his signal, which had now become familiar, having roused the guard, the small gate was opened. Two youths carrying in a boar, Philemenus himself followed, with a huntsman, unencumbered, and while the attention of the guard was incautiously turned upon those who carried the boar, in consequence of its astonishing size, he transfixed him with a hunting spear. About thirty armed men then entering, slew the rest of the guards, and broke open the adjoining gate, when a body of troops, in regular array, instantly rushed in. Being conducted hence in silence to the forum, they joined Hannibal. The Carthaginian then sent the Tarentines, with two thousand Gauls formed into three divisions, in different directions through the city, with orders to occupy the most frequented streets. A confusion arising, the Romans were put to the sword on all hands. The townsmen were spared; but in order to insure this, he instructed the Tarentine youths, when they saw any of their friends at a distance, to bid them be quiet and silent, and be of good courage.

But after he decided to head to Tarentum, he chose ten thousand men from his infantry and cavalry, whom he believed were best suited for the mission because of their agility and light armor. He set out on his march in the fourth watch of the night. He sent about eighty Numidian horsemen ahead to scout the terrain on each side of the road and to closely check every area, so that no local peasants who might have seen his army from afar could escape. They were instructed to bring back those who had fled and kill anyone they encountered, making it seem to the nearby inhabitants like a raiding party rather than a regular army. Hannibal himself marched quickly and set up camp about fifteen miles from Tarentum. Without telling his soldiers their destination, he gathered them together and reminded them to march in a straight line, not to stray off the path, and most importantly, to stay alert for commands and not to act without their leaders’ orders. He promised that he would give instructions on what needed to be done in due time. Around the same time, news reached Tarentum that a few Numidian horsemen were raiding the fields and scaring the locals across a wide area; the Roman praefect responded by ordering a unit of his cavalry to go out at sunrise the next day to stop the enemy’s looting. He thought this raid was evidence that Hannibal and his army hadn't left their camp. Early in the night, Hannibal moved his troops, with Philemenus guiding them, carrying spoils from hunting as usual. The other conspirators waited for their plan to unfold, which involved Philemenus bringing his prey through the small gate he normally used while Hannibal approached the east-facing gate called Temenis, near the tombs within the walls. When he got close to the gate, Hannibal lit a fire as agreed, creating a big blaze. Nico responded with the same signal, and the fires were put out on both sides. Hannibal led his troops silently to the gate. Nico unexpectedly attacked the sleeping guards, killing them in their beds, and opened the gate. Hannibal then entered with his infantry, instructing his cavalry to stay back so they could assist wherever necessary without being in the way. Similarly, Philemenus approached the small gate he usually used. His familiar voice, saying he could barely manage the weight of the massive animal he had caught, and his now-familiar signal stirred the guard, and the small gate was opened. Two young men carrying a boar entered, followed closely by Philemenus and a huntsman, unburdened. While the guard was distracted by the boar's impressive size, he speared one of them with a hunting spear. About thirty armed men then entered, killed the rest of the guards, and forced open the nearby gate, allowing a group of troops to storm in quickly. They were silently led to the forum where they joined Hannibal. The Carthaginian then sent the Tarentines, along with two thousand Gauls divided into three groups, in various directions through the city, instructing them to take control of the busiest streets. As chaos broke out, the Romans were slain on all sides. The townspeople were spared; to ensure this, he told the Tarentine youths to quietly calm any friends they saw from a distance, encouraging them to be quiet and brave.

10

The tumult and clamour was now such as usually takes place in a captured city, but no man knew for certain what was the occasion. The Tarentines supposed that the Romans had suddenly risen to plunder the city. To the Romans it appeared, that some commotion had been set on foot by the townsmen with a treacherous design. The praefect, who was awakened at the first alarm, escaped to the port, whence getting into a boat he was conveyed round to the citadel. The sound of a trumpet also from the theatre excited alarm; for it was a Roman trumpet, prepared by the conspirators for this very purpose; and as it was blown unskilfully by a Grecian, it could not be ascertained who gave the signal, or to whom it was given. At dawn of the day, the Romans recognised the Carthaginian and Gallic arms, which removed all doubt; and the Greeks, seeing the bodies of slain Romans spread about in all directions, perceived that the city had been taken by Hannibal. When the light had increased, so that they could discriminate with greater certainty, and the Romans who survived the carnage had taken refuge in the citadel, the tumult now beginning to subside a little, Hannibal gave orders to assemble the Tarentines without their arms. All of them attended the assembly, except those who had accompanied the Romans in their retreat to the citadel, to share every fortune with them. Here Hannibal having addressed the Tarentines in terms of kindness, and appealed to the services he had rendered to those of their countrymen whom he had captured at the Trasimenus and at Cannae, and having at the same time inveighed against the haughty domination of the Romans, desired that they would every one of them retire to their respective houses, and inscribe their names upon their doors; declaring, that he should give orders that those houses which had not the names written upon them should be plundered. That if any man should write his name upon the house of a Roman, (and the Romans occupied houses by themselves,) he should treat him as an enemy. Having dismissed the assembly, and the names inscribed upon the doors having made it easy to distinguish the house of an enemy from that of a friend, on a signal given, the troops ran in every direction to plunder the lodgings of the Romans, and a considerable booty was found.

The noise and chaos were now like what usually happens in a city that has been captured, but no one knew for sure what had caused it. The Tarentines thought that the Romans had suddenly risen up to loot the city. For the Romans, it seemed that some disturbance had been stirred up by the townspeople with a sneaky intent. The praefect, who was woken up at the first alarm, escaped to the port, where he got into a boat that took him around to the citadel. The sound of a trumpet from the theater also caused alarm; it was a Roman trumpet, prepared by the conspirators for this very purpose, and since it was blown clumsily by a Greek, it wasn't clear who gave the signal or to whom it was for. At dawn, the Romans recognized the Carthaginian and Gallic arms, which cleared up all doubt, and the Greeks, seeing the bodies of slain Romans scattered everywhere, realized that Hannibal had taken the city. When there was enough light to see better, and the Romans who survived the massacre had taken refuge in the citadel, the noise started to calm down a bit. Hannibal ordered the Tarentines to gather unarmed. Everyone showed up for the meeting except those who had followed the Romans in their retreat to the citadel, wanting to share whatever fate awaited them. Hannibal spoke to the Tarentines kindly, reminding them of the help he had given to their fellow countrymen whom he had captured at Trasimenus and Cannae, while also denouncing the harsh rule of the Romans. He asked each of them to go back to their homes and write their names on their doors, stating that he would order that houses without names written on them be looted. He warned that anyone who wrote their name on a Roman's house (and the Romans lived in their own areas) would be treated as an enemy. After dismissing the assembly, with the names inscribed on the doors making it easy to tell friend from foe, a signal was given, and the troops ran in all directions to loot the Romans' homes, finding a substantial amount of treasure.

11

The next day he led his troops to assault the citadel; but seeing that it was protected by very high rocks towards the sea, which washed the greater part of it, and formed it into a sort of peninsula, and towards the city by a wall and ditch, and consequently that it could not be taken by assault or by works; lest the design to protect the Tarentines should detain him from the prosecution of more important objects, and lest the Romans should have the power of sallying from the citadel whenever they pleased against the Tarentines, if left without a strong protecting force, he resolved to cut off the communication between the citadel and city by a rampart; not without a hope that he might have an opportunity of fighting with the Romans, when attempting to obstruct the work; and if they should sally forth too eagerly, that by killing many of them the strength of the garrison would be so far reduced, that the Tarentines alone would be easily able to defend themselves from them. After they had begun, the Romans, suddenly throwing open the gate, rushed in upon the workmen. The guard stationed before the works allowed itself to be driven back, in order that their boldness might be increased by success, and that they might pursue them when driven back, in greater numbers, and to a greater distance. Then on a signal given, the Carthaginians, whom Hannibal kept in readiness for this purpose, sprang up on all sides; nor could the Romans sustain the attack, but were prevented from precipitate flight by the narrowness of the ground, by impediments occasioned in some places by the works already commenced, in others by the preparations for the work. Most of them were driven headlong into the ditch, and more were killed in the flight than in the battle. After this the work was commenced without any attempt to obstruct it. A large ditch was formed, within which a rampart was thrown up. He prepared also to add a wall at a small distance, and on the same side, that they might defend themselves from the Romans even without a garrison. He, however, left them a small force, at once for their protection and to assist in building the wall. The general himself, setting out with the rest of his forces, pitched his camp at the river Galaesus, five miles from the city. Returning from this position to inspect the work, which had gone on somewhat faster than he had anticipated, he conceived a hope that the citadel might even be taken by storm; for it was not protected by an elevated situation as the other parts were, but placed upon a plain, and separated from the city only by a wall and ditch. While subjected to an attack from every kind of military engine and work, a reinforcement sent from Metapontum inspired the Romans with courage to assault the works of the enemy, by a sudden attack, under cover of the night. Some of them they threw down, others they destroyed by fire, and thus there was an end to Hannibal's attempts against the citadel in that quarter. His only remaining hope was in a siege; nor did that afford a good prospect of success, because, occupying a citadel which was placed on a peninsula and commanded the entrance of the harbour, they had the sea open to them, while the city, on the contrary, was deprived of any supplies by sea: and thus the besiegers were in greater danger of want than the besieged. Hannibal assembled the chief men of the Tarentines, and laid before them all the present difficulties. He said, "That he could neither discover any method by which a citadel so well fortified could be taken, nor could he hope for any favourable result from a siege, while the enemy was master of the sea; but that if ships could be obtained, by which the introduction of supplies might be prevented, the enemy would either immediately evacuate it, or surrender themselves." The Tarentines agreed with him; but were of opinion, that "he who gave the advice ought also to assist in carrying it into execution; for if the Carthaginian ships were brought there from Sicily, they would be able to effect it; but by what means could their own ships, shut up as they were in a confined harbour, the mouth of which was in the command of the enemy, be brought out into the open sea." "They shall be brought out," said Hannibal. "Many things which are difficult in themselves, are easily effected by contrivance. You have a city situated upon a plain; you have level and sufficiently wide roads extending in every direction. By the road which runs through the midst of the city from the harbour to the sea I will convey your ships in waggons without any great difficulty, and the sea will be ours which the enemy now commands. We will invest the citadel on one side by sea, on the other by land; nay, rather, in a short time, we will take it either abandoned by the enemy, or with the enemy in it." This speech not only inspired hopes of accomplishing the object, but excited the greatest admiration of the general. Waggons were immediately collected from every quarter and joined together; machines were employed to haul the ships on shore, and the road was prepared, in order that the waggons might run more easily, and thus the difficulty of passing be diminished. Beasts of burden and men were next collected, and the work was actively commenced. After the lapse of a few days, the fleet, equipped and ready for action, sailed round the citadel, and cast anchor just before the mouth of the harbour. Such was the state of things at Tarentum, when Hannibal left it and returned to his winter quarters. Authors, however, are divided as to whether the defection of the Tarentines took place in the present or former year. The greater number, and those who, from their age, were more able to recollect these events, represent it to have occurred in the present year.

The next day, he led his troops to attack the citadel, but realizing it was protected by very high cliffs on the sea side, which surrounded most of it and formed a sort of peninsula, and on the city side by a wall and ditch, he saw that it couldn't be captured through a direct assault or by constructing siege works. To avoid letting the effort to protect the Tarentines hold him back from pursuing more critical objectives, and to prevent the Romans from launching attacks from the citadel whenever they wanted against the Tarentines, if left without a strong guard, he decided to cut off the connection between the citadel and the city by building a rampart. He hoped he might get a chance to fight the Romans while they tried to interrupt the work, and if they acted too hastily, by killing many of them, the strength of the garrison would be diminished enough for the Tarentines to defend themselves easily. After they started, the Romans suddenly burst through the gate and rushed at the workers. The guards stationed in front of the works allowed themselves to be pushed back so their boldness could grow from their success, enabling them to chase the Romans further. Then, at a given signal, the Carthaginians, whom Hannibal had on standby, sprang up from all sides. The Romans couldn't withstand the assault and were prevented from fleeing due to the narrow space and obstacles caused by the works already in progress. Most were forced into the ditch, with more casualties occurring during the retreat than in the fighting itself. After that, the construction continued without any more attempts to obstruct it. A large ditch was dug, and a rampart was raised within it. He also planned to add a wall a short distance away, on the same side, so they could defend themselves against the Romans even without a garrison. However, he left a small force there for protection and to help build the wall. The general himself set out with the rest of his troops and camped by the river Galaesus, five miles from the city. When he returned to check on the work, which was advancing quicker than he expected, he began to hope that the citadel might even be taken by storm; for it was not situated on elevated ground like other areas, but was on flat land, separated from the city only by a wall and ditch. While under constant attack from various military machines and operations, a reinforcement sent from Metapontum gave the Romans the courage to launch a surprise nighttime assault on the enemy’s works. They knocked down some, set others on fire, and thus ended Hannibal's attempts against the citadel from that side. His only remaining hope was to lay siege to it, though that offered little chance of success since the citadel was on a peninsula controlling the harbor’s entrance, while the city had no sea supplies. Consequently, the besiegers were at a greater risk of running low on supplies than the besieged. Hannibal called together the Tarentine leaders and laid out all the current challenges. He explained that he couldn't find any method to take such a strongly fortified citadel, nor could he expect any positive outcome from a siege while the enemy controlled the sea. However, he argued that if they could get ships to block supplies from reaching the Romans, the enemy would either leave the citadel immediately or surrender. The Tarentines agreed but believed that whoever made the suggestion should also help carry it out; they thought if Carthaginian ships were brought from Sicily, it could be done, but they couldn't see how their own ships could leave their confined harbor, which was controlled by the enemy. "We will get them out," said Hannibal. "Many things that seem difficult can be accomplished through clever planning. You have a city on flat ground; you have wide, level roads leading in all directions. I will transport your ships on wagons along the road that goes from the harbor to the sea without much trouble, and the sea will be ours, which the enemy currently controls. We will besiege the citadel from the sea on one side and from the land on the other; indeed, soon, we will take it either abandoned by the enemy or with the enemy still inside." His words not only raised hopes of achieving their goal but also earned him great admiration. Wagons were quickly gathered from everywhere and joined together; machines were set up to haul the ships ashore, and the road was prepared to make it easier for the wagons to pass. Beasts of burden and men were organized, and the work began in earnest. After a few days, the fleet, fully equipped and ready for action, sailed around the citadel and anchored right at the harbor's mouth. This was the situation in Tarentum when Hannibal left and returned to his winter quarters. However, historians disagree on whether the Tarentines' defection happened this year or the previous one. Most, especially those who could better remember the events due to their age, claim it occurred this year.

12

The Latin holidays detained the consuls and praetors at Rome till the fifth of the calends of May; on which day, having completed the solemnities on the mount, they proceeded to their respective provinces. Afterwards a new difficulty respecting religious matters arose out of the prophetic verses of Marcius, who had been a distinguished soothsayer; and on a search being made the year before, for books of this description, agreeably to a decree of the senate, these verses had fallen into the hands of Marcus Atilius, the city praetor, who had the management of that business, and he had immediately handed them over to the new praetor, Sulla. The importance attached to one of the two predictions of Marcius, which was brought to light after the event to which it related had occurred, and the truth of which was confirmed by the event, attached credence to the other, the time of whose fulfilment had not yet arrived. In the former prophecy, the disaster at Cannae was predicted in nearly these words: "Roman of Trojan descent, fly the river Canna, lest foreigners should compel thee to fight in the plain of Diomede. But thou wilt not believe me until thou shalt have filled the plain with blood, and the river carries into the great sea, from the fruitful land, many thousands of your slain countrymen, and thy flesh becomes a prey for fishes, birds, and beasts inhabiting the earth. For thus hath Jupiter declared to me." Those who had served in that quarter recognised the correspondence with respect to the plains of the Argive Diomede and the river Canna, as well as the defeat itself. The other prophecy was then read, which was more obscure, not only because future events are more uncertain than past, but also from being more perplexed in its style of composition. "Romans, if you wish to expel the enemy and the ulcer which has come from afar, I advise, that games should be vowed, which may be performed in a cheerful manner annually to Apollo; when the people shall have given a portion of money from the public coffers, that private individuals then contribute, each according to his ability. That the praetor shall preside in the celebration of these games, who holds the supreme administration of justice to the people and commons. Let the decemviri perform sacrifice with victims after the Grecian fashion. If you do these things properly you will ever rejoice, and your affairs will be more prosperous, for that deity will destroy your enemies who now, composedly, feed upon your plains." They took one day to explain this prophecy. The next day a decree of the senate was passed, that the decemviri should inspect the books relating to the celebration of games and sacred rites in honour of Apollo. After they had been consulted, and a report made to the senate, the fathers voted, that "games should be vowed to Apollo and celebrated; and that when the games were concluded, twelve thousand asses should be given to the praetor to defray the expense of sacred ceremonies, and also two victims of the larger sort." A second decree was passed, that "the decemviri should perform sacrifice in the Grecian mode, and with the following victims: to Apollo, with a gilded ox, and two white goats gilded; to Latona, with a gilded heifer." When the praetor was about to celebrate the games in the Circus Maximus, he issued an order, that during the celebration of the games, the people should pay a contribution, as large as was convenient, for the service of Apollo. This is the origin of the Apollinarian games, which were vowed and celebrated in order to victory, and not restoration to health, as is commonly supposed. The people viewed the spectacle in garlands; the matrons made supplications; the people in general feasted in the courts of their houses, throwing the doors open; and the day was distinguished by every description of ceremony.

The Latin holidays held the consuls and praetors in Rome until May 1st; on this day, after completing the rituals on the mountain, they went to their assigned provinces. Soon after, a new issue related to religious matters arose from the prophetic verses of Marcius, a well-known soothsayer. During a search the previous year for such texts, following a decree from the senate, these verses had been found by Marcus Atilius, the city praetor in charge of that task, who quickly passed them on to the new praetor, Sulla. The significance of one of Marcius's predictions, which became known after the event it referred to had happened and was verified by that event, lent credibility to the other prediction, whose time had not yet come. The first prophecy nearly predicted the disaster at Cannae with these words: "Roman of Trojan descent, avoid the river Canna, or foreigners will force you to battle in the plain of Diomede. But you won't believe me until the plain is filled with blood, and the river carries off many thousands of your slain countrymen into the sea from the fertile land, and your flesh becomes food for fish, birds, and beasts. For this is what Jupiter has revealed to me." Those who fought in that area recognized the connection to the plains of Diomede and the river Canna, as well as the defeat itself. The second, more obscure prophecy was then shared, not only because future events are more uncertain than past ones, but because of its complicated wording. "Romans, if you want to drive away the enemy and the affliction that has come from afar, I recommend vowing games to be held cheerfully every year for Apollo. When the citizens contribute a portion of money from the public treasury, then individuals should add their contributions according to their means. The praetor in charge of justice for the people should oversee these games. Let the decemviri conduct sacrifices with animals according to Greek tradition. If you perform these actions correctly, you will find joy, and your affairs will prosper, for that deity will destroy your enemies who currently peacefully graze upon your fields." They took a day to interpret this prophecy. The following day, the senate passed a decree for the decemviri to review the texts regarding the celebration of games and sacred rites for Apollo. After consulting them and reporting back to the senate, the senators agreed that "games should be vowed to Apollo and celebrated; and that after the games, twelve thousand asses should be given to the praetor to cover the costs of the sacred ceremonies, along with two larger sacrificial animals." A second decree was passed stating that "the decemviri should perform sacrifices in the Greek manner, using the following victims: a gilded ox and two white goats gilded for Apollo; and a gilded heifer for Latona." When the praetor prepared to hold the games in the Circus Maximus, he ordered that during the games, the people should contribute whatever amount they deemed appropriate for the service of Apollo. This is how the Apollinarian games originated, which were vowed and celebrated for victory, not for healing, as is often believed. The people watched the events wearing garlands; the matrons offered prayers; the general populace feasted in their courtyards with doors wide open, and the day was marked by all kinds of ceremonies.

13

While Hannibal was in the neighbourhood of Tarentum, and both the consuls in Samnium, though they seemed as if they were about to besiege Capua, the Campanians were experiencing famine, that calamity which is the usual attendant of a protracted siege. It was occasioned by the Roman armies' having prevented the sowing of the lands. They therefore sent ambassadors to Hannibal, imploring him to give orders that corn should be conveyed to Capua from the neighbouring places, before both the consuls led their legions into their fields, and all the roads were blocked up by the troops of the enemy. Hannibal ordered Hanno to pass with his army from Bruttium into Campania, and to take care that the Campanians were supplied with corn. Hanno, setting out from Bruttium with his army, and carefully avoiding the camp of the enemy and the consuls who were in Samnium, when he drew near to Beneventum, pitched his camp on an eminence three miles from the city. He next ordered that the corn which had been collected during the summer, should be brought from the neighbouring people in alliance with him, into his camp, assigning a guard to escort those supplies. He then sent a messenger to the Capuans, fixing a day when they should attend at his camp to receive the corn, bringing with them vehicles and beasts of every description, collected from every part of their country. The Campanians executed this business with their usual indolence and carelessness. Somewhat more than four hundred vehicles, with a few beasts of burden besides, were sent. After receiving a reproof from Hanno for this conduct, who told them, that not even hunger, which excited dumb animals to exertion, could stimulate them to diligence, another day was named when they were to fetch the corn after better preparation. All these transactions being reported to the Beneventans, just as they occurred, they lost no time in sending ten ambassadors to the Roman consuls, who were encamped in the neighbourhood of Bovianum. The consuls, hearing what was going on at Capua, arranged it so that one of them should lead an army into Campania; and Fulvius, to whose lot that province had fallen, setting out by night, entered the walls of Beneventum. Being now near the enemy, he obtained information that Hanno had gone out to forage with a portion of his troops; that the Campanians were supplied with corn by a quaestor; that two thousand waggons had arrived together with an undisciplined and unarmed rabble; that every thing was done in a disorderly and hurried manner; and that the form of a camp, and all military subordination, were destroyed by the intermixture of rustics out of the neighbourhood. This intelligence being sufficiently authenticated, the consul ordered his soldiers to get ready only their standards and arms against the next night, as he must attack the Carthaginian camp. They set out at the fourth watch of the night, leaving all their packages and baggage of every description at Beneventum; and arriving a little before daylight at the camp, they occasioned such a panic, that, had the camp been situated on level ground, it might doubtlessly have been taken on the first assault. The height of its situation and the works defended it; for they could not be approached on any side except by a steep and difficult ascent. At break of day a hot engagement commenced, when the Carthaginians not only defended their rampart, but having more even ground, threw down the enemy as they attempted to ascend the steep.

While Hannibal was near Tarentum and both consuls were in Samnium, seemingly ready to besiege Capua, the Campanians were facing a famine, a common consequence of a drawn-out siege. This situation arose because the Roman armies had prevented the sowing of crops. Consequently, they sent ambassadors to Hannibal, pleading for him to arrange for corn to be brought to Capua from nearby areas before the consuls led their legions into the fields and blocked all the roads with enemy troops. Hannibal instructed Hanno to move his army from Bruttium to Campania and ensure the Campanians received their corn. Hanno set out from Bruttium with his army, carefully avoiding the enemy's camp and the consuls in Samnium. Upon nearing Beneventum, he camped on a hill three miles from the city. He then ordered the corn collected during the summer to be transported from local allies to his camp, assigning guards to secure those supplies. He sent a messenger to the Capuans, scheduling a day for them to come to his camp to collect the corn, bringing along vehicles and animals of all kinds from across their region. The Campanians approached this task with their usual laziness and carelessness. They sent a little over four hundred vehicles, along with a few pack animals. After receiving a reprimand from Hanno for their behavior, who pointed out that not even hunger could spur them into action, another date was set for them to gather the corn with better organization. All these events were reported to the Beneventans as they unfolded, prompting them to quickly send ten ambassadors to the Roman consuls, who were camped near Bovianum. Once the consuls learned about the situation in Capua, they arranged for one of them to lead an army into Campania. Fulvius, who was assigned to that province, set out at night and entered Beneventum’s walls. Being close to the enemy now, he learned that Hanno had sent out part of his troops to forage, that a quaestor was supplying the Campanians with corn, that two thousand wagons had arrived along with an undisciplined and unarmed crowd, and that everything was being done in a chaotic and rushed manner, shattering any semblance of military order and discipline due to the presence of local farmers. With this crucial information confirmed, the consul instructed his soldiers to prepare only their standards and arms for the next night, as he intended to attack the Carthaginian camp. They set out just before dawn, leaving all their belongings at Beneventum, and reaching the enemy camp a little before daylight. They created such panic that, had the camp been on flat ground, it likely would have been overrun in the initial assault. However, the camp’s elevated position and defenses protected it, as it could only be approached by a steep and difficult incline. As dawn broke, a fierce battle erupted, with the Carthaginians not only defending their rampart but also, having the advantage of level ground, pushing back the enemy as they tried to climb the steep slope.

14

Persevering courage, however, at length prevailed over every impediment, and they made their way up to the ditch and rampart in several parts at the same time, but with many wounds and much loss of soldiers. The consul, therefore assembling the military tribunes, said they must desist from this inconsiderate enterprise; and that it appeared to him to be the safer course, that the troops should be led back to Beneventum for that day, and then on the following day to pitch his camp close to that of the enemy, so that the Campanians could not quit it, nor Hanno return to it; and in order that that object might be attained with the greater ease, that he should send for his colleague and his army; and that they would direct their whole force on that point. This plan of the general was disconcerted, after the signal began to sound for a retreat, by the clamours of the soldiery, who despised so pusillanimous an order. Nearest to the gate of the enemy's camp was a Pelignian cohort, whose commander, Vibius Accuaeus, seizing the standard, threw it over the rampart. Then pronouncing a curse upon himself and his cohort, if the enemy got possession of that standard, he rushed forward before the rest, and crossing the ditch and rampart, burst into the camp of the enemy. The Pelignians were now fighting within the rampart, when in another quarter Valerius Flaccus, a military tribune of the third legion, taunting the Romans with cowardice for conceding to allies the honour of taking the camp. Titus Pedanius, first centurion of the first century, snatched the standard out of the hands of the standard-bearer, and cried out, "Soon shall this standard, and this centurion, be within the rampart of the enemy; let those follow who would prevent the standard's being captured by the enemy." Crossing the ditch, he was followed first by the men of his own maniple, and then by the whole legion. By this time the consul also, changing his plan on seeing them crossing the rampart, began to incite and encourage his soldiers, instead of calling them off; representing to them, how critical and perilous was the situation of the bravest cohort of their allies and a legion of their countrymen. All, therefore, severally exerting themselves to the utmost, regardless whether the ground were even or uneven, while showers of weapons were thrown against them from all sides, the enemy opposing their arms and their persons to obstruct them, made their way and burst in. Many who were wounded, even those whose blood and strength failed them, pressed forward, that they might fall within the rampart of the enemy. The camp, therefore, was taken in an instant, as if it had been situated upon level ground, and not completely fortified. What followed was a carnage rather than a battle. The troops of both sides being huddled together within the rampart, above six thousand of the enemy were slain; above seven thousand, together with the Campanians who fetched the corn, and the whole collection of waggons and beasts of burden, were captured. There was also a great booty, which Hanno in his predatory excursions, which he had been careful to make in every quarter, had drawn together from the lands of the allies of the Romans. After throwing down the camp of the enemy, they returned thence to Beneventum; and there both the consuls (for Appius Claudius came thither a few days after) sold the booty and distributed it, making presents to those by whose exertions the camp of the enemy had been captured; above all, to Accuaeus the Pelignian, and Titus Pedanius, first centurion of the third legion. Hanno, setting off from Cominium in the territory of Cere, whither intelligence of the loss of the camp had reached him, with a small party of foragers, whom he happened to have with him, returned to Bruttium, more after the manner of a flight than a march.

Persevering courage ultimately overcame every obstacle, and they advanced to the ditch and rampart at several points simultaneously, though at the cost of many injuries and significant losses among the soldiers. The consul, therefore, gathered the military tribunes and said they needed to stop this reckless operation; he believed it would be wiser for the troops to retreat to Beneventum for the day and then set up camp close to the enemy's position the following day, so that the Campanians couldn't leave nor Hanno return. To achieve this more easily, he planned to summon his colleague and his army to concentrate their forces at that location. However, this strategy was disrupted when the signal for retreat sounded, met by the protests of the soldiers, who scorned such a cowardly command. Closest to the gate of the enemy's camp was a Pelignian cohort, whose commander, Vibius Accuaeus, grabbed the standard and hurled it over the rampart. Cursing himself and his cohort if the enemy captured it, he charged ahead of the others, crossing the ditch and rampart to invade the enemy's camp. The Pelignians were now engaged in fighting within the rampart when Valerius Flaccus, a military tribune of the third legion, mocked the Romans for allowing their allies to take credit for seizing the camp. Titus Pedanius, the first centurion of the first century, snatched the standard from the standard-bearer and shouted, "This standard, and this centurion, will soon be within the enemy's rampart; let those who wish to prevent its capture follow me." Crossing the ditch, he was initially followed by his own group and then by the entire legion. By this time, the consul had also changed his approach upon seeing them scale the rampart, beginning to motivate and encourage his soldiers instead of calling them back, emphasizing the dire and risky situation of their bravest allies and a legion of their own countrymen. All of them, therefore, exerted themselves to the utmost, regardless of the ground's levelness, as showers of weapons rained down from all sides, the enemy countering with both arms and bodies to block their advance, but they broke through. Many who were injured, even those losing blood and strength, pushed forward, determined to fall within the enemy's rampart. The camp was soon captured, as if it had been on flat land and not well-fortified. What followed resembled slaughter more than a battle. Troops from both sides were tangled together in the rampart, and over six thousand of the enemy were killed; more than seven thousand, including the Campanians who collected the grain, along with a host of wagons and pack animals, were captured. There was also a great haul of loot that Hanno had gathered during his raids across the lands of the Roman allies. After destroying the enemy's camp, they returned to Beneventum; there, both consuls (for Appius Claudius arrived a few days later) sold the spoils and distributed them, rewarding those whose efforts had led to the camp's capture, especially Accuaeus the Pelignian and Titus Pedanius, the first centurion of the third legion. Hanno, departing from Cominium in the territory of Cere, where he had learned about the loss of the camp, returned to Bruttium with a small group of foragers he happened to have with him, more in a flight than a march.

15

The Campanians, when informed of the disaster which had befallen themselves and their allies, sent ambassadors to Hannibal to inform him, that "the two consuls were at Beneventum, which was a day's march from Capua; that the war was all but at their gates and their walls; and that if he did not hasten to their assistance, Capua would fall into the power of the enemy sooner than Arpi had; that not even Tarentum itself, much less its citadel, ought to be considered of so much consequence as to induce him to deliver up to the Roman people, abandoned and undefended, Capua, which he used to place on an equal footing with Carthage." Hannibal, promising that he would not neglect the interest of the Campanians, sent, for the present, two thousand horse, with the ambassadors, aided by which, they might secure their lands from devastation. The Romans, meanwhile, among the other things which engaged their attention, had an eye to the citadel of Tarentum, and the garrison besieged therein. Caius Servilius, lieutenant-general, having been sent, according to the advice of the fathers, by Publius Cornelius, the praetor, to purchase corn in Etruria, made his way into the harbour of Tarentum, through the guard-ships of the enemy, with some ships of burden. At his arrival, those who before, having very slight hopes of holding out, were frequently invited by the enemy, in conferences, to pass over to them, now, on the contrary, were the persons to invite and solicit the enemy to come over to them; and now, as the soldiers who were at Metapontum had been brought to assist in guarding the citadel of Tarentum, the garrison was sufficiently powerful. In consequence of this measure, the Metapontines, being freed from the fears which had influenced them, immediately revolted to Hannibal. The people of Thurium, situated on the same coast, did the same. They were influenced not more by the defection of the Metapontines and Tarentines, with whom they were connected, being sprung from the same country, Achaia, than by resentment towards the Romans, in consequence of the recent execution of the hostages. The friends and relations of these hostages sent a letter and a message to Hanno and Mago, who were not far off among the Bruttii, to the effect, that if they brought their troops up to the walls, they would deliver the city into their hands. Marcus Atinius was in command at Thurium, with a small garrison, who they thought might easily be induced to engage rashly in a battle, not from any confidence which he reposed in his troops, of which he had very few, but in the youth of Thurium, whom he had purposely formed into centuries, and armed against emergencies of this kind. The generals, after dividing their forces between them, entered the territory of Thurium; and Hanno, with a body of infantry, proceeded towards the city in hostile array. Hanno staid behind with the cavalry, under the cover of some hills, conveniently placed for the concealment of an ambush. Atinius, having by his scouts discovered only the body of infantry, led his troops into the field, ignorant both of the domestic treachery and of the stratagem of the enemy. The engagement with the infantry was particularly dull, a few Romans in the first rank engaging while the Thurians rather waited than helped on the issue. The Carthaginian line retreated, on purpose that they might draw the incautious enemy to the back of the hill, where their cavalry were lying in ambush; and when they had come there, the cavalry rising up on a sudden with a shout, immediately put to flight the almost undisciplined rabble of the Thurians, not firmly attached to the side on which they fought. The Romans, notwithstanding they were surrounded and hard pressed on one side by the infantry, on the other by the cavalry, yet prolonged the battle for a considerable time; but at length even they were compelled to turn their backs, and fled towards the city. There the conspirators, forming themselves into a dense body, received the multitude of their countrymen with open gates; but when they perceived that the routed Romans were hurrying towards the city, they exclaimed that the Carthaginian was close at hand, and that the enemy would enter the city mingled with them, unless they speedily closed the gates. Thus they shut out the Romans, and left them to be cut up by the enemy. Atinius, however, and a few others were taken in. After this for a short time there was a division between them, some being of opinion that they ought to defend the city, others that they ought, after all that had happened, to yield to fortune, and deliver up the city to the conquerors; but, as it generally happens, fortune and evil counsels prevailed. Having conveyed Atinius and his party to the sea and the ships, more because they wished that care should be taken of him, in consequence of the mildness and justice of his command, than from regard to the Romans, they received the Carthaginians into the city. The consuls led their legions from Beneventum into the Campanian territory, with the intention not only of destroying the corn, which was in the blade, but of laying siege to Capua; considering that they would render their consulate illustrious by the destruction of so opulent a city, and that they would wipe away the foul disgrace of the empire, from the defection of a city so near remaining unpunished for three years. Lest, however, Beneventum should be left without protection, and that in case of any sudden emergency, if Hannibal should come to Capua, in order to bring assistance to his friends, which they doubted not he would do, the cavalry might be able to sustain his attack, they ordered Tiberius Gracchus to come from Lucania to Beneventum with his cavalry and light-armed troops and to appoint some person to take the command of the legions and stationary camp, for the defence of Lucania.

The Campanians, after hearing about the disaster that had struck them and their allies, sent envoys to Hannibal to inform him that "the two consuls were at Beneventum, just a day's march from Capua; the war was almost at their gates and walls; and if he didn't hurry to help them, Capua would fall to the enemy even faster than Arpi had. They argued that not even Tarentum itself, and certainly not its citadel, should be seen as so important that he would abandon the city of Capua, which he previously considered equal to Carthage, to the Romans, leaving it undefended." Hannibal, assuring them that he would not disregard the interests of the Campanians, sent two thousand cavalry with the ambassadors to help protect their lands from destruction. Meanwhile, the Romans were keeping an eye on the citadel of Tarentum and the garrison besieged there. Caius Servilius, the lieutenant-general, had been sent by Publius Cornelius, the praetor, to buy grain in Etruria and managed to enter the harbor of Tarentum through the enemy's guard ships with a load of cargo vessels. Upon his arrival, those who had previously doubted their ability to hold out and had often been tempted by the enemy to switch sides now found themselves inviting the enemy to join them. As soldiers from Metapontum were brought in to help defend the citadel of Tarentum, the garrison became strong enough to withstand a siege. As a result, the people of Metapontum, relieved of their fears, quickly defected to Hannibal. The people of Thurium, located along the same coast, did the same. They were influenced not just by Metapontine and Tarentine defection, as they shared a common origin from Achaia, but also by anger towards the Romans due to the recent execution of hostages. The friends and family of these hostages sent a letter and message to Hanno and Mago, who were nearby among the Bruttii, saying that if they brought their troops to the walls, they would hand the city over to them. Marcus Atinius was in charge at Thurium with a small garrison, whom they believed could easily be persuaded to engage in a reckless battle, not from any confidence in his troops, which were few, but in the youths of Thurium, whom he had organized into centuries and armed for emergencies. The generals, after splitting their forces, entered the territory of Thurium; Hanno, leading a group of infantry, marched toward the city for an attack. Hanno stayed back with the cavalry, hiding behind some hills that were perfect for an ambush. Atinius, having discovered only the infantry through his scouts, led his troops into the field, unaware of the domestic betrayal and enemy stratagem. The battle with the infantry was particularly uneventful, with a few Romans in the front line engaging while the Thurians mostly watched rather than helping. The Carthaginian line fell back, intentionally luring the unsuspecting enemy to the back of the hill where their cavalry lay in ambush. When they arrived, the cavalry suddenly charged out with a shout, sending the mostly untrained Thurians into a panic, as they were not strongly committed to the side they were fighting for. Despite being surrounded and pressured from both sides by the infantry and cavalry, the Romans managed to prolong the fight for a considerable time; ultimately, however, they had to turn and flee towards the city. There, the conspirators formed a solid body and welcomed their countrymen through open gates. But when they noticed the fleeing Romans rushing toward the city, they shouted that the Carthaginians were close behind, and the enemy would mix with them unless they quickly shut the gates. They closed the gates against the Romans, leaving them to be slaughtered by the enemy. Atinius and a few others were captured. Afterward, there was a brief division among them, with some arguing to defend the city and others believing they should submit to fate and surrender it to the conquerors. As often happens, fortune and poor counsel won out. They transported Atinius and his group to the sea and the ships, more out of a desire to ensure his safety due to his fair and just leadership than out of any regard for the Romans, and allowed the Carthaginians into the city. The consuls led their legions from Beneventum into the Campanian territory, intending not just to destroy the grain that was growing but also to lay siege to Capua, hoping to make their consulate renowned by defeating such a wealthy city and to erase the disgrace faced by the empire after a city so close had been left unpunished for three years. However, to ensure that Beneventum would not be left defenseless, and in case of an emergency, if Hannibal came to Capua to aid his allies—which they believed he would—the cavalry was ordered to sustain any attack, so they commanded Tiberius Gracchus to come from Lucania to Beneventum with his cavalry and light-armed troops and to appoint someone to take charge of the legions and the stationary camp for the defense of Lucania.

16

An unlucky prodigy occurred to Gracchus, while sacrificing, previous to his departure from Lucania. Two snakes gliding from a secret place to the entrails, after the sacrifice was completed, ate the liver; and after having been observed, suddenly vanished out of sight. The sacrifice having been repeated according to the admonition of the aruspices, and the vessel containing the entrails being watched with increased attention, it is reported that the snakes came a second, and a third time, and, after tasting the liver, went away untouched. Though the aruspices forewarned him that the portent had reference to the general, and that he ought to be on his guard against secret enemies and machinations, yet no foresight could avert the destiny which awaited him. There was a Lucanian, named Flavius, the leader of that party which adhered to the Romans when the others went over to Hannibal; he was this year in the magistracy, having been created praetor by the same party. Suddenly changing his mind, and seeking to ingratiate himself with the Carthaginians, he did not think it enough that he himself should pass over to them, or that he should induce the Lucanians to revolt with him, unless he ratified his league with the enemy with the head and blood of the general, betrayed to them, though his guest. He entered into a secret conference with Mago, who had the command in Bruttium, and receiving a solemn promise from him, that he would take the Lucanians into his friendship, without interfering with their laws, if he should betray the Roman general to the Carthaginians, he conducted Mago to a place to which he was about to bring Gracchus with a few attendants. He then directed Mago to arm his infantry and cavalry, and to occupy the retired places there, in which he might conceal a very large number of troops. After thoroughly inspecting and exploring the place on all sides, a day was agreed upon for the execution of the affair. Flavius came to the Roman general, and said, that "he had begun a business of great importance, for the completion of which, it was necessary to have the assistance of Gracchus himself. That he had persuaded the praetors of all the states which had revolted to the Carthaginians in the general defection of Italy, to return into the friendship of the Romans, since now the Roman power too, which had almost come to ruin by the disaster at Cannae. was daily improving and increasing, while the strength of Hannibal was sinking into decay, and was almost reduced to nothing. He had told them that the Romans would be disposed to accept an atonement for their former offence; that there never was any state more easy to be entreated, or more ready to grant pardon; how often, he had observed to them, had they forgiven rebellion even in their own ancestors! These considerations," he said, "he had himself urged, but that they would rather hear the same from Gracchus himself in person, and touching his right hand, carry with them that pledge of faith. That he had agreed upon a place with those who were privy to the transaction, out of the way of observation, and at no great distance from the Roman camp; that there the business might be settled in few words, so that all the Lucanian states might be in the alliance and friendship of the Romans." Gracchus, not suspecting any treachery either from his words or the nature of the proposal, and being caught by the probability of the thing, set out from the camp with his lictors and a troop of horse, under the guidance of his host, and fell headlong into the snare. The enemy suddenly arose from their lurking-place, and Flavius joined them; which made the treachery obvious. A shower of weapons was poured from all sides on Gracchus and his troop. He immediately leaped from his horse, and ordering the rest to do the same, exhorted them, that "as fortune had left them only one course, they would render it glorious by their valour. And what is there left," said he, "to a handful of men, surrounded by a multitude, in a valley hemmed in by a wood and mountains, except death? The only question was, whether, tamely exposing themselves to be butchered like cattle, they should die unavenged; or whether, drawing the mind off from the idea of suffering and anticipation of the event, and giving full scope to fury and resentment, they should fall while doing and daring, covered with hostile blood, amid heaps of arms and bodies of their expiring foes." He desired that "all would aim at the Lucanian traitor and deserter;" adding, that "the man who should send that victim to the shades before him, would acquire the most distinguished glory, and furnish the highest consolation for his own death." While thus speaking, he wound his cloak round his left arm, for they had not even brought their shields out with them, and then rushed upon the enemy. The exertion made in the fight was greater than could be expected from the smallness of the number. The bodies of the Romans were most exposed to the javelins, with which, as they were thrown on all sides from higher ground into a deep valley, they were transfixed. The Carthaginians seeing Gracchus now bereft of support, endeavoured to take him alive; but he having descried his Lucanian host among the enemy, rushed with such fury into their dense body that it became impossible to save his life without a great loss. Mago immediately sent his corpse to Hannibal, ordering it to be placed, with the fasces which were taken at the same time, before the tribunal of the general. This is the true account; Gracchus fell in Lucania, near the place called the Old Plains.

An unfortunate event befell Gracchus while he was performing a sacrifice before leaving Lucania. Two snakes emerged from a hidden spot and devoured the liver after the sacrifice was complete, then quickly disappeared. After the sacrifice was repeated, following the advice of the soothsayers, and with the entrails being watched closely, it’s said that the snakes returned a second and third time, tasting the liver but leaving it untouched. Though the soothsayers cautioned him that this omen pertained to the general and advised him to be wary of hidden enemies and plots, no amount of foresight could change the fate that awaited him. There was a Lucanian named Flavius, leader of the faction that sided with the Romans when the others switched to Hannibal. He was currently a magistrate, having been appointed praetor by the same group. Suddenly changing his mind, he sought to align himself with the Carthaginians, believing it wasn’t enough for him to join them alone, and he aimed to persuade the Lucanians to rebel alongside him, sealing his alliance with the enemy through the betrayal of the Roman general, despite having been his guest. He held a secret meeting with Mago, who commanded in Bruttium, and received a solemn promise that if he betrayed the Roman general to the Carthaginians, Mago would welcome the Lucanians into his alliance without interfering with their laws. Flavius then took Mago to a location where he planned to bring Gracchus with a small entourage. He instructed Mago to gather his infantry and cavalry and to occupy nearby hidden spots to conceal a large number of troops. After thoroughly scouting the area, they agreed on a day to carry out their plan. Flavius approached the Roman general and stated that he had initiated a significant endeavor requiring Gracchus’s personal involvement. He claimed he had convinced the praetors of all the states that had defected to the Carthaginians during Italy’s general defection to return to Roman allegiance, as the Roman power, which had nearly collapsed after the disaster at Cannae, was on the rise, while Hannibal's strength was diminishing and almost gone. He assured them that the Romans would be willing to grant amnesty for past offenses and highlighted how often they had forgiven rebellion, even in their ancestors. He argued that the Lucanians would prefer to hear this from Gracchus himself as a pledge of faith. He proposed that they meet in a discreet location, close to the Roman camp, to finalize the terms rapidly, ensuring all Lucanian states could join the Roman alliance. Gracchus, unsuspecting of any treachery from Flavius or the nature of the proposal, intrigued by its potential, left the camp with his lictors and a troop of horse, led by Flavius, and fell directly into the trap. The enemy suddenly emerged from their hiding spots, and Flavius joined them, revealing the betrayal. A barrage of weapons rained down on Gracchus and his men from all sides. He immediately dismounted and urged the others to do the same, encouraging them that, since fortune had left them only one option, they should make it glorious through their valor. He asked what remained for a small group of men surrounded by a multitude in a valley confined by woods and mountains, except death? The only choice was whether to passively await slaughter like cattle, dying without revenge, or to channel their fury and rage into action, falling while fighting, stained with enemy blood amidst heaps of arms and fallen foes. He insisted that everyone target the Lucanian traitor and deserter, adding that the man who could send that traitor to the afterlife would gain the greatest glory and the highest comfort for his own death. As he spoke, he wrapped his cloak around his left arm, since they hadn’t even brought their shields, and charged at the enemy. The effort displayed in the fight exceeded what could be expected from such a small number. The Romans were left vulnerable to javelins from above, which rained down upon them in the deep valley, piercing them. The Carthaginians, seeing Gracchus now isolated, tried to capture him alive; however, upon spotting his Lucanian host among the enemy, he charged with such intensity into their thick mass that it became impossible to save him without substantial losses. Mago promptly sent his corpse to Hannibal with orders for it to be displayed, along with the fasces captured at the same time, before the general’s tribunal. This is the true account; Gracchus fell in Lucania, near a place called the Old Plains.

17

There are some who have put forth an account, stating, that when in the territory of Beneventum, near the river Calor, having gone out from his camp with his lictors and three servants, for the purpose of bathing, he was slain while naked and unarmed, and endeavouring to defend himself with the stones which the river brought down, by a party of the enemy which happened to be concealed among the osiers which grew upon the banks. Others state, that having gone out five hundred paces from the camp, at the instance of the aruspices, in order to expiate the prodigies before mentioned on unpolluted ground, he was cut off by two troops of Numidians who happened to be lying in ambush there. So different are the accounts respecting the place and manner of the death of so illustrious and distinguished a man. Various also are the accounts of the funeral of Gracchus. Some say that he was buried by his own friends in the Roman camp; others relate, and this is the more generally received account, that a funeral pile was erected by Hannibal, in the entrance of the Carthaginian camp; that the troops under arms performed evolutions, with the dances of the Spaniards, and motions of the arms and body, which were customary with the several nations; while Hannibal himself celebrated his obsequies with every mark of respect, both in word and deed. Such is the account of those who assert that the affair occurred in Lucania. If you are disposed to credit the statement of those who relate that he was slain at the river Calor, the enemy got possession only of the head of Gracchus; which being brought to Hannibal, he immediately despatched Carthalo to convey it into the Roman camp to Cneius Cornelius, the quaestor, who buried the general in the camp, the Beneventans joining the army in the celebration.

Some people have told a story that when he was in the territory of Beneventum, near the river Calor, he left his camp with his lictors and three servants to go for a bath. He was killed while naked and unarmed, trying to defend himself with stones from the river, by a group of enemies hiding among the reeds on the banks. Others claim that after walking five hundred paces from the camp, following the advice of the aruspices to perform a ritual to cleanse the earlier omens on untouched ground, he was ambushed and killed by two units of Numidians. The details of the circumstances surrounding the death of such a distinguished man differ widely. There are also varying accounts of Gracchus's funeral. Some say he was buried by his friends in the Roman camp; others, which is the more widely accepted version, say that Hannibal built a funeral pyre at the entrance of the Carthaginian camp. The troops performed maneuvers with Spanish dances and movements typical of their various nations, while Hannibal paid his respects with all due honor, both in words and actions. This is the version from those who claim the event took place in Lucania. If you believe the accounts that he was killed at the river Calor, then the enemy only captured Gracchus's head. They brought it to Hannibal, who immediately sent Carthalo to take it to Cneius Cornelius, the quaestor, in the Roman camp, where the general was buried, with the Beneventans joining in the ceremonies.

18

The consuls having entered the Campanian territory, while devastating the country on all sides, were alarmed, and thrown into confusion, by an eruption of the townsmen and Mago with his cavalry. They called in their troops to their standards from the several quarters to which they were dispersed, but having been routed when they had scarcely formed their line, they lost above fifteen hundred men. The confidence of the Campanians, who were naturally presumptuous, became excessive in consequence of this event, and in many battles they challenged the Romans; but this one battle, which they had been incautiously and imprudently drawn into, had increased the vigilance of the consuls. Their spirits were restored, while the presumption of the other party was diminished, by one trifling occurrence; but in war nothing is so inconsiderable as not to be capable, sometimes, of producing important consequences. Titus Quinctius Crispinus was a guest of Badius, a Campanian, united with him by the greatest intimacy. Their acquaintance had increased from the circumstance of Badius having received the most liberal and kind attentions at the house of Crispinus, in a fit of illness, at Rome, before the Campanian revolt. On the present occasion, Badius, advancing in front of the guards, which were stationed before the gate, desired Crispinus to be called; and Crispinus, on being informed of this, thinking that a friendly and familiar interview was requested, and the memory of their private connexion remaining even amidst the disruption of public ties, advanced a little from the rest. When they had come within view of each other, Badius exclaimed, "I challenge you to combat, Crispinus; let us mount our horses, and making the rest withdraw, let us try which is the better soldier." In reply, Crispinus said, that "neither of them were in want of enemies to display their valour upon; for his own part, even if he should meet him in the field he would turn aside, lest he should pollute his right-hand with the blood of a guest;" and then turning round, was going away. But the Campanian, with increased presumption, began to charge him with cowardice and effeminacy, and cast upon him reproaches which he deserved himself, calling him "an enemy who sheltered himself under the title of host, and one who pretended to spare him for whom he knew himself not to be a match. If he considered; that when public treaties were broken, the ties of private connexion were not severed with them, then Badius the Campanian openly, and in the hearing of both armies, renounced his connexion of hospitality with Titus Quinctius Crispinus the Roman. He said, that there could exist no fellowship or alliance with him and an enemy whose country and tutelary gods, both public and private, he had come to fight against. If he was a man, he would meet him." Crispinus hesitated for a long time; but the men of his troop at length prevailed upon him not to allow the Campanian to insult him with impunity. Waiting, therefore, only to ask his generals whether they would allow him to fight, contrary to rule, with an enemy who had challenged him; having obtained their permission, he mounted his horse, and addressing Badius by name, called him out to the combat. The Campanian made no delay. They engaged with their horses excited to hostility. Crispinus transfixed Badius with his spear in the left shoulder, over his shield. He fell from his horse in consequence of the wound; and Crispinus leaped down to despatch him as he lay, on foot. But Badius, before his enemy was upon him, ran off to his friends, leaving his horse and buckler. Crispinus, decorated with the spoils, and displaying the horse and arms which he had seized together with the bloody spear, was conducted amid the loud plaudits and congratulations of the soldiery into the presence of the consuls, where he was highly commended, and was presented with gifts.

The consuls entered the Campanian territory, wreaking havoc on all sides, but were thrown into chaos by an attack from the townsmen and Mago with his cavalry. They called their dispersed troops back to their standards, but after barely forming their line, they were routed and lost over fifteen hundred men. This event fueled the Campanians' natural arrogance, which became excessive, leading them to challenge the Romans in many battles. However, this single, reckless encounter heightened the vigilance of the consuls. Their spirits were lifted, while the confidence of their opponents was reduced by a seemingly minor incident. In war, even the smallest events can lead to significant consequences. Titus Quinctius Crispinus was a guest of Badius, a Campanian, and they shared a close friendship. Their bond had grown when Badius received generous care at Crispinus's home during an illness in Rome, before the Campanian revolt. On this occasion, Badius stepped forward from the guards at the gate and asked for Crispinus to be called. Crispinus, thinking it was a friendly visit and recalling their private connection despite the current tensions, moved a bit closer. When they were in sight of each other, Badius shouted, "I challenge you to a duel, Crispinus; let’s mount our horses and, having sent the others away, see who is the better soldier." Crispinus replied that neither of them needed enemies to prove their bravery; even if they met in battle, he would avoid fighting Badius to not stain his hand with a guest's blood. He then turned to leave. However, Badius, growing bolder, accused him of cowardice and called him names that he himself deserved, saying he was "an enemy hiding behind the title of host, pretending to spare one he knows he can't match." Badius then declared before both armies that he renounced his hospitality towards Titus Quinctius Crispinus the Roman. He insisted there could be no friendship or alliance with an enemy who had come to fight against his country and gods. "If you’re a man, you’ll face me." Crispinus hesitated for a long time, but his men eventually encouraged him not to let the Campanian insult him without repercussions. He then asked his generals for permission to fight, stepping outside the usual rules to answer the challenge. Once he got their approval, he mounted his horse and called out Badius by name for the duel. There was no delay from the Campanian. They charged each other, their horses riled up for battle. Crispinus struck Badius with his spear in the left shoulder, above his shield. Badius fell from his horse, and Crispinus jumped down to finish him off as he lay on the ground. But before Crispinus could reach him, Badius fled to his friends, abandoning his horse and shield. Crispinus, adorned with the spoils of victory and displaying the horse and weapons he had taken along with the bloodied spear, was led back amid the cheers and congratulations of the soldiers to the consuls, where he received high praise and was awarded gifts.

19

Hannibal, having moved his camp from the territory of Beneventum to Capua, drew out his troops in order of battle the third day after his arrival; not entertaining the least doubt but that, as the Campanians had fought successfully a few days ago when he was absent, the Romans would be still less able to withstand him and his army, which had been so often victorious. After the battle had commenced, the Roman line was distressed chiefly from the attack of the cavalry, being overwhelmed with their darts, till the signal was given to the Roman cavalry to direct their horses against the enemy; thus it was a battle of the cavalry. But at this time the Sempronian army, commanded by Cneius Cornelius the quaestor, being descried at a distance, excited alarm in both parties equally, lest those who were approaching should be fresh enemies. As if by concert, therefore, both sounded a retreat; and the troops were withdrawn from the field to their camps, in an equal condition; a greater number, however, of the Romans fell in the first charge of the cavalry. The consuls, to divert the attention of Hannibal from Capua, departed thence on the following night in different directions, Fulvius into the territory of Cuma, Claudius into Lucania. The next day Hannibal, having received intelligence that the camp of the Romans was deserted, and that they had gone off in different directions in two divisions, doubtful at first which he should follow, commenced the pursuit of Appius; who, after leading him about whichever way he pleased, returned by another route to Capua. Hannibal, while in this quarter, had another opportunity of gaining an advantage. Marcus Centenius, surnamed Penula, was distinguished among the centurions of the first rank by the size of his person, and his courage. Having gone through his period of service, he was introduced to the senate by Publius Cornelius Sulla, when he requested of the fathers that five thousand men might be placed at his disposal. He said, that "as he was acquainted with the character of the enemy, and the nature of the country, he should speedily perform some service; and that he would employ those arts by which our generals and armies had been hitherto ensnared against the inventor of them." This was not promised more foolishly than it was believed; as if the qualifications of a soldier and a general were the same. Instead of five, eight thousand men were given him, half Romans, half allies. He himself also got together a considerable number of volunteers, in the country, on his march; and having almost doubled his force, arrived in Lucania, where Hannibal had halted after having in vain pursued Claudius. No doubt could be entertained of the issue of a contest which was to take place between Hannibal, as general on one side, and a centurion on the other; between armies, one of which had grown old in victory, the other entirely inexperienced, and for the most part even tumultuary and half-armed. As soon as the troops came within sight of each other, and neither of them declined an engagement, the lines were formed. The battle, notwithstanding the utter disparity of the contending parties, lasted more than two hours, the Roman troops acting with the greatest spirit as long as their general survived. But after that he had fallen, for he continually exposed himself to the weapons of the enemy, not only from regard to his former character, but through fear of the disgrace which would attach to him if he survived a disaster occasioned by his own temerity, the Roman line was immediately routed. But so completely were they prevented from flying, every way being beset by the cavalry, that scarcely a thousand men escaped out of so large an army; the rest were destroyed on all hands, in one way or other.

Hannibal, after moving his camp from Beneventum to Capua, organized his troops for battle three days after arriving. He had no doubt that, since the Campanians had fought successfully a few days earlier in his absence, the Romans would be even less able to resist him and his army, which had been victorious many times. Once the battle began, the Roman forces struggled mainly due to the cavalry's attacks, being overwhelmed by their projectiles, until the signal was given for the Roman cavalry to charge the enemy; thus, the battle became one primarily of cavalry. At this moment, the Sempronian army, led by Cneius Cornelius the quaestor, was seen in the distance, causing alarm for both sides as they feared fresh enemies were approaching. So, without any prior agreement, both sides sounded a retreat and pulled their troops back to their camps, each side in similar condition; however, more Romans were lost during the initial cavalry charge. The consuls, looking to distract Hannibal from Capua, left that night in different directions—Fulvius going to the territory of Cuma and Claudius heading into Lucania. The next day, Hannibal learned that the Romans had abandoned their camp and gone off in two different divisions, unsure at first which one to pursue. He started following Appius, who led him in circles before making his way back to Capua by another route. While in that area, Hannibal had another chance to gain an advantage. Marcus Centenius, nicknamed Penula, stood out among the top centurions for his size and bravery. After completing his service, he was introduced to the senate by Publius Cornelius Sulla, where he asked for five thousand men to be put at his disposal. He claimed that "since he understood the enemy's character and the terrain, he would quickly prove his worth, using the same tactics that had previously ensnared our generals and armies against their creator." This promise was as foolishly received as it was made, as if the skills of a soldier and a general were the same. Instead of five thousand, he was given eight thousand men, half Romans and half allies. He also gathered a significant number of volunteers during his march, nearly doubling his forces before arriving in Lucania, where Hannibal had stopped after unsuccessfully pursuing Claudius. There was no doubt about the outcome of the upcoming contest: Hannibal, a general on one side, and a centurion on the other; one army seasoned from victory and the other largely inexperienced and mostly unarmed. As soon as the troops spotted each other and neither side hesitated to fight, they formed their lines. The battle, despite the vast difference in strength, lasted over two hours, with the Roman troops fighting bravely while their general was still alive. But after he fell—having constantly put himself in harm's way not only due to his former reputation but also from the fear of being blamed for a disaster caused by his own recklessness—the Roman line quickly crumbled. So thoroughly were they cornered from fleeing, with cavalry blocking every escape, that barely a thousand men survived out of such a large army; the rest were destroyed from all sides.

20

The siege of Capua was now resumed by the consuls with the utmost energy. Every thing requisite for the business was conveyed thither and got in readiness. A store of corn was collected at Casilinum; at the mouth of the Vulturnus, where a town now stands, a strong post was fortified; and a garrison was stationed in Puteoli, which Fabius had formerly fortified, in order to have the command of the neighbouring sea and the river. Into these two maritime forts, the corn recently sent from Sicily, with that which Marcus Junius, the praetor, had bought up in Etruria, was conveyed from Ostia, to supply the army during the winter. But, in addition to the disaster sustained in Lucania, the army also of volunteer slaves, who had served during the life of Gracchus with the greatest fidelity, as if discharged from service by the death of their general, left their standards. Hannibal was not willing that Capua should be neglected, or his allies deserted, at so critical a juncture; but, having obtained such success from the temerity of one Roman general, his attention was fixed on the opportunity which presented itself of crushing the other general and his army. Ambassadors from Apulia reported that Cneius Fulvius, the praetor, had at first conducted his measures with caution, while engaged in besieging certain towns of Apulia, which had revolted to Hannibal; but that afterwards, in consequence of extraordinary success, both himself and his soldiers, being glutted with booty, had so given themselves up to licentiousness and indolence, that all military discipline was disregarded. Having frequently on other occasions, as well as but a few days ago, experienced what an army was good for, when conducted by an unskilful commander, he moved his camp into Apulia.

The siege of Capua was now resumed by the consuls with the utmost energy. Everything needed for the operation was sent there and prepared. A stockpile of grain was gathered at Casilinum; a stronghold was established at the mouth of the Vulturnus, where a town now exists; and a garrison was stationed in Puteoli, which Fabius had previously fortified, to control the nearby sea and river. The grain recently shipped from Sicily, along with what Marcus Junius, the praetor, had purchased in Etruria, was brought from Ostia to supply the army through the winter. However, in addition to the loss suffered in Lucania, the army of volunteer slaves, who had served loyally during Gracchus's life, abandoned their standards as if released from service by the death of their general. Hannibal didn’t want Capua to be neglected, nor his allies to be abandoned at such a critical time; however, after achieving success from the recklessness of one Roman general, he focused on the chance to crush the other general and his army. Ambassadors from Apulia reported that Cneius Fulvius, the praetor, initially acted cautiously while besieging certain towns in Apulia that had defected to Hannibal; but later, due to unexpected success, both he and his soldiers became so indulged in plunder that they embraced a lifestyle of excess and laziness, disregarding all military discipline. Having seen multiple times, just days earlier included, how ineffective an army could be under an inexperienced commander, he moved his camp into Apulia.

21

The Roman legions, and the praetor, Fulvius, were in the neighbourhood of Herdonia, where, receiving intelligence of the approach of the enemy, they had nearly torn up the standards and gone out to battle without the praetor's orders; nor did any thing tend more to prevent it than the assured hope they entertained that they could do so whenever they pleased, consulting only their own will. The following night, Hannibal having obtained information that the camp was in a state of tumult, and that most of the troops were in a disorderly manner urging the general to give the signal, and calling out to arms, and therefore feeling convinced that an opportunity presented itself for a successful battle, distributed three thousand light troops in the houses in the neighbourhood, and among the thorns and woods. These, on a signal being given, were to rise up from their lurking-place with one accord; and Mago, with about two thousand horse, was ordered to occupy all the roads in the direction in which he supposed their flight would be directed. Having made these preparations during the night, he led his troops into the field at break of day. Nor did Fulvius decline the challenge; not so much from any hope of success entertained by himself, as drawn by the blind impetuosity of his soldiers. Accordingly, the line itself was formed with the same want of caution with which they entered the field, agreeably to the whim of the soldiers, who came up as chance directed, and took their stations just where they pleased; which they afterwards abandoned, as fear or caprice suggested. The first legion and the left wing of the allied troops were drawn up in front. The line was extended to a great length, the tribunes remonstrating, that there was no strength in it, and that wherever the enemy made the charge they would break through it: but no salutary advice reached their minds, nor even their ears. Hannibal was now come up, a general of a totally different character, with an army neither similar in its nature, nor similarly marshalled. The consequence was, that the Romans did not so much as sustain their shout and first attack. Their general, equal to Centenius in folly and temerity, but by no means to be compared with him in courage, when he saw things going against him, and his troops in confusion, hastily mounting his horse, fled from the field with about two hundred horsemen. The rest of the troops, beaten in front, and surrounded on the flank and rear, were slaughtered to such a degree, that out of eighteen thousand men, not more than two thousand escaped. The enemy got possession of the camp.

The Roman legions, along with the praetor, Fulvius, were nearby Herdonia, where they received word of the enemy approaching. They almost pulled up the standards and rushed into battle without the praetor’s orders; the only thing that stopped them was their strong belief that they could act whenever they wanted, only considering their own will. That night, Hannibal learned that the camp was in chaos, with most of the troops disorderly, urging their general to signal for action and calling for arms. Believing this was a chance for a successful battle, he positioned three thousand light troops in nearby houses and among the thorns and woods. At the signal, they were to spring from their hiding spots together. Mago, with about two thousand cavalry, was assigned to block all routes where he thought the Romans might retreat. After preparing through the night, he led his troops into the field at dawn. Fulvius accepted the challenge, not because he thought he could win, but because his soldiers were blindly eager for battle. The formation was set up as recklessly as they entered the field, according to the soldiers’ whims, who came up as they wished and took positions that they later left as fear or impulse took hold. The first legion and the left wing of the allied troops were at the front. The line stretched out, with the tribunes warning that it was weak, and that the enemy could break through wherever they charged. However, their advice fell on deaf ears. Hannibal approached as a general of a completely different nature, with an army that was neither similar in character nor formation. As a result, the Romans could barely withstand the shouting and initial assault. Their general, as foolish and reckless as Centenius, but not as brave, saw things going badly for him and his troops in disarray. He quickly mounted his horse and fled the field with about two hundred cavalry. The rest of the soldiers, beaten at the front and encircled at the flanks and rear, suffered heavy losses; of the eighteen thousand men, only about two thousand escaped. The enemy took over the camp.

22

When these disastrous defeats, happening one upon another, were reported at Rome, great grief and consternation seized the city. But still, as the consuls had been hitherto successful when it was most important, they were the less affected by these disasters. Caius Lastorius and Marcus Metilius were sent as ambassadors to the consuls, with directions carefully to collect the remains of the two armies, and use every endeavour to prevent their surrendering themselves to the enemy, through fear or despair, (which was the case after the battle of Cannae,) and to search for the deserters from the army of volunteer slaves. Publius Cornelius was charged with the same business; to him also the levy was intrusted. He caused an order to be issued throughout the market and smaller towns, that search should be made for the volunteer slaves, and that they should be brought back to their standards. All these things were executed with the most vigilant care. The consul, Appius Claudius, having placed Decius Junius in command at the mouth of the Vulturnus, and Marcus Aurelius Cotta at Puteoli, with directions to send off the corn immediately to the camp, as each of the ships from Etruria and Sardinia arrived with it, returned himself to Capua, and found his colleague Quintus Fulvius at Casilinum, conveying every requisite thence, and making every preparation for the siege of Capua. Both of them then joined in besieging the city, summoning Claudius Nero, the praetor, from the Claudian camp at Suessula; who, leaving a small garrison there, marched down to Capua with all the rest of his forces. Thus there were three generals' tents erected round Capua; and three armies, applying themselves to the work in different parts, proceeded to surround the city with a ditch and rampart, erecting forts at moderate intervals. The Campanians attempting to obstruct the work, a battle was fought in several places at once; the consequence of which was, that at length the Campanians confined themselves within their gates and walls. Before, however, these works were carried quite round, ambassadors were sent to Hannibal to complain that Capua was abandoned, and almost given up to the Romans, and to implore him, that he would now, at least, bring them assistance, when they were not only besieged, but surrounded by a rampart. A letter was sent to the consuls from Publius Cornelius, the praetor, directing that before they completely enclosed Capua with their works, they should grant permission to such of the Campanians as chose to quit Capua, and take their property with them. That those should retain their liberty, and all their possessions, who quitted it before the ides of March, but that those who quitted it after that day, as well as those who continued there, would be considered as enemies. Proclamation was made to the Campanians to this effect, but it was received with such scorn, that they spontaneously used insulting language and menaces. Hannibal had marched his legions from Herdonea to Tarentum, with the hope of getting possession of the citadel of that place, by force or stratagem. But not succeeding there, he turned his course to Brundusium, thinking that town would be betrayed to him, but, while fruitlessly spending time there also, the Campanian ambassadors came to him with complaints and entreaties. Hannibal answered them in a proud manner, that he had before raised the siege of Capua, and that now the consuls would not sustain his approach. The ambassadors, dismissed with these hopes, with difficulty effected their return to Capua, which was by this time surrounded by a double trench and rampart.

When news of these disastrous defeats came into Rome, the city was gripped by great sadness and fear. However, since the consuls had been successful in crucial situations before, they were less shaken by these setbacks. Caius Lastorius and Marcus Metilius were sent as ambassadors to the consuls to carefully gather the remnants of the two armies and do everything possible to prevent them from surrendering to the enemy out of fear or despair, like what happened after the Battle of Cannae. They were also tasked with searching for deserters among the army of volunteer slaves. Publius Cornelius was assigned the same task and was put in charge of the recruitment. He ordered searches throughout the market and smaller towns for the volunteer slaves, instructing that they be brought back to their units. All these actions were carried out with great diligence. The consul, Appius Claudius, appointed Decius Junius to command at the mouth of the Vulturnus and Marcus Aurelius Cotta at Puteoli, directing them to immediately send grain to the camp as each ship from Etruria and Sardinia arrived. He then returned to Capua, where he found his colleague Quintus Fulvius in Casilinum, gathering necessary supplies and preparing for the siege of Capua. They both then joined forces to lay siege to the city, summoning Claudius Nero, the praetor, from the Claudian camp at Suessula. After leaving a small garrison there, he brought the rest of his forces down to Capua. Thus, three generals’ tents were set up around Capua, with three armies working in different areas to encircle the city with a ditch and rampart and building forts at regular intervals. The Campanians tried to disrupt the work, resulting in battles breaking out in several locations; ultimately, the Campanians retreated within their gates and walls. However, before these fortifications were completed, ambassadors were sent to Hannibal to complain that Capua was deserted and nearly surrendered to the Romans, begging him to provide assistance now that they were not just besieged, but completely surrounded by ramparts. A letter was sent to the consuls from Publius Cornelius, the praetor, requesting that before they fully enclosed Capua, they should allow any Campanians who wanted to leave with their belongings to do so. Those who left before the Ides of March would keep their freedom and possessions, while those who left after that date, along with those who stayed, would be considered enemies. This message was announced to the Campanians, but it was met with such scorn that they responded with insults and threats. Hannibal had moved his legions from Herdonea to Tarentum, hoping to take the citadel by force or trickery. When that failed, he turned towards Brundusium, thinking the town would betray him, but after wasting time there unsuccessfully, the Campanian ambassadors came to him with complaints and pleas. Hannibal replied arrogantly that he had previously lifted the siege of Capua and that now the consuls would not allow him to advance. The ambassadors, dismissed with these empty promises, had a hard time returning to Capua, which was by now surrounded by a double trench and rampart.

23

At the time when the circumvallation of Capua was carrying on with the greatest activity, the siege of Syracuse, which had been forwarded by intestine treachery, in addition to the efforts and bravery of the general and his army, was brought to a conclusion. For in the beginning of spring, Marcellus being in doubt whether he should direct the operations of the war against Himilco and Hippocrates at Agrigentum, or press the siege of Syracuse, though he saw that it was impossible to take the city by force, which, from its situation, both with respect to sea and land, was impregnable, nor by famine, as it was supported by an uninterrupted supply of provisions from Carthage, yet that he might leave no course untried, directed the Syracusan deserters (and there were in the Roman camp some men in this situation of the highest rank, who had been driven out of the city during the defection from the Romans, because they were averse to a change of measures) to sound the feelings of those who were of the same party in conferences, and to promise them, that if Syracuse was delivered up, they should have their liberty, and be governed by their own laws. There was no opportunity however, of having a conference; for as many were suspected of disaffection, the attention and observation of all were exerted, lest any thing of the kind should occur unknown to them. One of the exiles, who was a servant, having been allowed to enter the city in the character of a deserter, assembled a few persons, and opened a conversation upon the subject. After this, certain persons, covering themselves with nets in a fishing smack, were in this way conveyed round to the Roman camp, and conferred with the fugitives. The same was frequently repeated by different parties, one after another; and at last they amounted to eighty. But after every thing had been concerted for betraying the city, the plot was reported to Epicydes, by one Attalus, who felt hurt that he had not been intrusted with the secret; and they were all put to death with torture. This attempt having miscarried, another hope was immediately raised. One Damippus, a Lacedaemonian, who had been sent from Syracuse to king Philip, had been taken prisoner by the Roman fleet. Epicydes was particularly anxious to ransom this man above any other; nor was Marcellus disinclined to grant it; the Romans, even at this time, being desirous of gaining the friendship of the Aetolians, with whom the Lacedaemonians were in alliance. Some persons having been sent to treat respecting his ransom, the most central and convenient place to both parties for this purpose appeared to be at the Trogilian port, near the tower called Galeagra. As they went there several times, one of the Romans, having a near view of the wall, and having determined its height, as nearly as it could be done by conjecture, from counting the stones, and by forming an estimate, in his own mind, what was the height of each stone in the face of the work; and having come to the conclusion that it was considerably lower than he himself and all the rest had supposed it, and that it was capable of being scaled with ladders of moderate size, laid the matter before Marcellus. It appeared a thing not to be neglected; but as the spot could not be approached, being on this very account guarded with extraordinary care, a favourable opportunity of doing it was sought for. This a deserter suggested, who brought intelligence that the Syracusans were celebrating the festival of Diana; that it was to last three days, and that as there was a deficiency of other things during the siege, the feasts would be more profusely celebrated with wine, which was furnished by Epicydes to the people in general, and distributed through the tribes by persons of distinction. When Marcellus had received this intelligence, he communicated it to a few of the military tribunes; then having selected, through their means, such centurions and soldiers as had courage and energy enough for so important an enterprise, and having privately gotten together a number of scaling-ladders, he directed that a signal should be given to the rest of the troops to take their refreshment, and go to rest early, for they were to go upon an expedition that night. Then the time, as it was supposed, having arrived, when, after having feasted from the middle of the day, they would have had their fill of wine, and have begun to sleep, he ordered the soldiers of one company to proceed with the ladders, while about a thousand armed men were in silence marched to the spot in a slender column. The foremost having mounted the wall, without noise or confusion, the others followed in order; the boldness of the former inspiring even the irresolute with courage.

At the time when the wall around Capua was being built with great intensity, the siege of Syracuse, which had been fueled by internal betrayal, along with the efforts and bravery of the general and his army, came to an end. Early in the spring, Marcellus was uncertain whether to focus on the war against Himilco and Hippocrates at Agrigentum or to continue the siege of Syracuse. He recognized that taking the city by force was impossible due to its position, which made it defensible both from land and sea, and that starvation would not work either, as it received a steady supply of food from Carthage. However, he wanted to leave no stone unturned and instructed the Syracusan deserters (among whom were some high-ranking individuals who had been expelled from the city during the revolt against the Romans, due to their resistance to change) to gauge the sentiments of those loyal to their cause in secret discussions and to promise them that if they surrendered Syracuse, they would gain their freedom and be governed by their own laws. Unfortunately, there was no chance for such a meeting since many were suspected of being disloyal, and everyone was on high alert to prevent anything suspicious from happening unnoticed. One of the exiles, a servant, was allowed to enter the city disguised as a deserter and gathered a few people to discuss the issue. Subsequently, some individuals concealed themselves with nets in a fishing boat and managed to reach the Roman camp to meet with the deserters. This occurred repeatedly with different groups until they totaled eighty. However, after all the plans had been made to betray the city, the scheme was reported to Epicydes by a man named Attalus, who was upset that he had not been included in the secret; as a result, they were all executed under torture. After this failed attempt, another opportunity quickly emerged. A man named Damippus, a Spartan sent from Syracuse to King Philip, had been captured by the Roman fleet. Epicydes was particularly eager to ransom him above anyone else, and Marcellus was willing to consider it, as the Romans were keen on gaining the favor of the Aetolians, who were allies of the Spartans. When delegates were sent to discuss the ransom, Trogilian port, near the tower known as Galeagra, was chosen as the most suitable location for both parties. During their visits there, one of the Romans, while closely observing the wall and estimating its height by counting the stones and calculating the approximate size of each, concluded that it was much lower than he, and everyone else, had previously thought and that it could be scaled with reasonably sized ladders. He presented his findings to Marcellus. It seemed like something that shouldn’t be overlooked; however, since the site was heavily guarded, they sought a favorable moment to act. A deserter provided information that the Syracusans were celebrating the festival of Diana, which would last three days, and since supplies were low during the siege, the festivities would involve more wine than usual, distributed by Epicydes through distinguished individuals. Upon receiving this information, Marcellus shared it with a few military tribunes, then selected courageous centurions and soldiers for this important mission, quietly gathering a number of scaling ladders. He instructed the remaining troops to have their meals and go to bed early, as they were to embark on a night operation. Once the time was thought to be right, after the Syracusans had enjoyed a feast since midday, having indulged in wine and begun to doze, he ordered the soldiers of one company to bring the ladders while about a thousand armed men quietly marched to the location in a narrow column. The first troops climbed the wall quietly and without confusion, and the others followed suit; the bravery of the first group inspired even the hesitant to muster their courage.

24

The thousand armed men had now taken a part of the city, when the rest, applying a greater number of ladders, mounted the wall on a signal given from the Hexapylos. To this place the former party had arrived in entire solitude; as the greater part of them, having feasted in the towers, were either asleep from the effects of wine, or else, half asleep, were still drinking. A few of them, however, they surprised in their beds, and put to the sword. They began then to break open a postern gate near the Hexapylos, which required great force; and a signal was given from the wall by sounding a trumpet, as had been agreed upon. After this, the attack was carried on in every quarter, not secretly, but by open force; for they had now reached Epipolae, a place protected by numerous guards, where the business was to terrify the enemy, and not to escape their notice. In effect they were terrified; for as soon as the sound of the trumpets was heard, and the shouts of the men who had got possession of the walls and a part of the city, the guards concluded that every part was taken, and some of them fled along the wall, others leaped down from it, or were thrown down headlong by a crowd of the terrified townsmen. A great part of the inhabitants, however, were ignorant of this disastrous event, all of them being overpowered with wine and sleep; and because, in a city of so wide extent, what was perceived in one quarter was not readily made known through the whole city. A little before day, Marcellus having entered the city with all his forces, through the Hexapylos, which was forced open roused all the townsmen; who ran to arms, in order, if possible, by their efforts, to afford succour to the city, which was now almost taken. Epicydes advanced with a body of troops at a rapid pace from the Insula, which the Syracusans themselves call Nasos, not doubting but that he should be able to drive out what he supposed a small party, which had got over the wall through the negligence of the guards. He earnestly represented to the terrified inhabitants who met him, that they were increasing the confusion, and that in their accounts they made things greater and more important than they really were. But when he perceived that every place around Epipolae was filled with armed men, after just teasing the enemy with the discharge of a few missiles, he marched back to the Achradina, not so much through fear of the number and strength of the enemy, as that some intestine treachery might show itself, taking advantage of the opportunity, and he might find the gates of the Achradina and island closed upon him in the confusion. When Marcellus, having entered the walls, beheld this city as it lay subjected to his view from the high ground on which he stood, a city the most beautiful, perhaps, of any at that time, he is said to have shed tears over it; partly from the inward satisfaction he felt at having accomplished so important an enterprise, and partly in consideration of its ancient renown. The fleets of the Athenians sunk there, and two vast armies destroyed, with two generals of the highest reputation, as well as the many wars waged with the Carthaginians with so much peril arose before his mind; the many and powerful tyrants and kings; but above all Hiero, a king who was not only fresh in his memory, but who was distinguished for the signal services he had rendered the Roman people, and more than all by the endowments which his own virtues and good fortune had conferred. All these considerations presenting themselves at once to his recollection, and reflecting, that in an instant every thing before him would be in flames, and reduced to ashes; before he marched his troops to the Achradina, he sent before him some Syracusans, who, as was before observed, were among the Roman troops, to induce the enemy, by a persuasive address, to surrender the city.

The thousand armed men had now captured part of the city, when the others, using more ladders, climbed the wall at a signal from the Hexapylos. The first group had arrived there completely alone; most of them, having feasted in the towers, were either asleep from the wine or half-asleep and still drinking. However, they caught a few of them in their beds and killed them. They then began to break open a side gate near the Hexapylos, which required a lot of force; a signal was given from the wall by sounding a trumpet, as had been previously agreed. After this, the assault continued in every direction, not stealthily, but with open force; for they had now reached Epipolae, a place guarded by many sentries, where the aim was to scare the enemy rather than to stay unnoticed. And indeed, they were scared; as soon as the trumpet sounded and the shouts of the men who had taken the walls and part of the city echoed, the guards concluded that every area was lost, and some fled along the wall, others jumped down, or were thrown down by a crowd of frightened townspeople. However, many of the inhabitants were unaware of this disastrous event, all overwhelmed by wine and sleep; and because, in such a vast city, what was seen in one area wasn't quickly communicated throughout. A little before dawn, Marcellus, having entered the city with all his forces through the Hexapylos, which was forced open, roused all the townspeople; they ran to arms, hoping to support the city, which was now nearly captured. Epicydes hurried forward with a group of troops from the Insula, which the Syracusans themselves call Nasos, not doubting he could easily drive out what he thought was a small force that had scaled the wall due to the guards' negligence. He urgently told the terrified citizens around him that they were making the situation worse and exaggerating their accounts of it. But when he saw that every part around Epipolae was filled with armed men, after briefly teasing the enemy with a few missile shots, he retreated to the Achradina, not so much out of fear of the enemy's size and strength, but because he feared some internal betrayal could take advantage of the chaos, and he might find the gates of the Achradina and island shut on him in the confusion. When Marcellus entered the walls and viewed the city from the high ground where he stood, possibly the most beautiful city of the time, he is said to have shed tears over it; partly from the inner satisfaction of having accomplished such an important mission, and partly because of its historical significance. The fleets of the Athenians sunk there, two massive armies destroyed, along with two highly regarded generals, and the numerous wars fought against the Carthaginians, all came to his mind; the powerful tyrants and kings, especially Hiero, a king not only fresh in his memory but also notable for the exceptional services he had rendered to the Roman people, and for the virtues and good fortune he had displayed. All these thoughts struck him suddenly, and he reflected that in an instant, everything before him would be in flames and reduced to ashes; before marching his troops to the Achradina, he sent ahead some Syracusans, who, as previously mentioned, were among the Roman troops, to persuade the enemy to surrender the city.

25

The gates and walls of the Achradina were occupied principally by deserters, who had no hopes of pardon in case of capitulation. These men would neither suffer those who were sent to approach the walls, nor to address them. Marcellus, therefore, on the failure of this attempt, gave orders to retire to the Euryalus, which is an eminence at the extremity of the city, at the farthest point from the sea, and commanding the road leading into the fields and the interior of the island, and is conveniently situated for the introduction of supplies. This fort was commanded by Philodemus, an Argive, who was placed in this situation by Epicydes. Marcellus sent Sosis, one of the regicides, to him. After a long conversation, being put off for the purpose of frustrating him, he brought back word to Marcellus, that Philodemus had taken time to deliberate. This man postponing his answer day after day, till Hippocrates and Himilco should quit their present position, and come up with their legions; not doubting but that if he should receive them into the fort, the Roman army, shut up as it was within the walls, might be annihilated, Marcellus, who saw that the Euryalus would neither be delivered up to him, nor could be taken by force, pitched his camp between Neapolis and Tycha, which are names of divisions of the city, and are in themselves like cities; fearful lest if he entered populous parts of the city, he should not be able to restrain his soldiers, greedy of plunder, from running up and down after it. When three ambassadors came to him from Tycha and Neapolis with fillets and other badges of supplicants, imploring him to abstain from fire and slaughter, Marcellus, having held a council respecting these entreaties, for so they were, rather than demands, ordered his soldiers, according to the unanimous opinion of the council, not to offer violence to any free person, but told them that every thing else might be their booty. The walls of the houses forming a protection for his camp, he posted guards and parties of troops at the gates, which were exposed, as they faced the streets, lest any attack should be made upon his camp while the soldiers were dispersed in pursuit of plunder. After these arrangements, on a signal given, the soldiers dispersed for that purpose; and though they broke open doors and every place resounded in consequence of the alarm and confusion created, they nevertheless refrained from blood. They did not desist from plunder till they had gutted the houses of all the property which had been accumulated during a long period of prosperity. Meanwhile, Philodemus also, who despaired of obtaining assistance, having received a pledge that he might return to Epicydes in safety, withdrew the garrison, and delivered up the fortress to the Romans. While the attention of all was engaged by the tumult occasioned in that part of the city which was captured, Bomilcar, taking advantage of the night, when, from the violence of the weather the Roman fleet was unable to ride at anchor in the deep, set out from the bay of Syracuse, with thirty-five ships, and sailed away into the main without interruption; leaving fifty-five ships for Epicydes and the Syracusans; and having informed the Carthaginians in what a critical situation Syracuse was placed, returned, after a few days, with a hundred ships; having, as report says, received many presents from Epicydes out of the treasure of Hiero.

The gates and walls of Achradina were mainly held by deserters who had no hope of forgiveness if they surrendered. These men wouldn’t allow anyone sent to the walls to approach or speak to them. So, after this attempt failed, Marcellus ordered a retreat to Euryalus, a high point at the edge of the city, farthest from the sea, overseeing the road leading into the fields and the interior of the island, and conveniently located for supply deliveries. This fort was commanded by Philodemus, an Argive who had been placed there by Epicydes. Marcellus sent Sosis, one of the regicides, to him. After a long conversation meant to delay and frustrate him, Sosis reported back to Marcellus that Philodemus needed more time to think. Day after day, Philodemus postponed his answer, waiting for Hippocrates and Himilco to leave their current position and bring their legions; he believed that if he could admit them into the fort, the Roman army shut up inside the walls could be wiped out. Marcellus realized that he couldn’t take Euryalus by force nor would it be handed over to him, so he set up camp between Neapolis and Tycha—districts of the city that were like cities themselves—worried that if he entered the crowded areas of the city, he wouldn’t be able to control his soldiers, eager for loot, from running wild after it. When three ambassadors arrived from Tycha and Neapolis with garlands and other symbols of supplication, begging him to refrain from burning and killing, Marcellus, after discussing these pleas—which were more like requests than demands—with his council, instructed his soldiers, following the council's unanimous advice, not to harm any free person but allowed them to take everything else as plunder. With the walls of the houses providing cover for his camp, he stationed guards and troops at the exposed gates facing the streets to prevent any attack while his soldiers were scattered seeking loot. After making these arrangements, a signal was given, and the soldiers spread out for that purpose; even though they broke open doors and everything echoed with alarm and chaos, they refrained from killing. They continued to loot until they had taken all the wealth accumulated over a long period of prosperity from the houses. Meanwhile, Philodemus, who had given up on getting help, secured a promise that he could return to Epicydes safely, withdrew the garrison, and surrendered the fortress to the Romans. While everyone was focused on the chaos in the captured part of the city, Bomilcar took advantage of the night, when the Roman fleet couldn’t anchor due to bad weather, and set out from Syracuse bay with thirty-five ships, sailing away into open waters without any opposition; he left behind fifty-five ships for Epicydes and the Syracusans. After informing the Carthaginians of Syracuse’s precarious situation, he returned a few days later with a hundred ships, reportedly having received many gifts from Epicydes from Hiero's treasure.

26

Marcellus, by gaining possession of the Euryalus, and placing a garrison in it, was freed from one cause of anxiety; which was, lest any hostile force received into that fortress on his rear might annoy his troops, shut up and confined as they were within the walls. He next invested the Achradina, erecting three camps in convenient situations, with the hope of reducing those enclosed within it to the want of every necessary. The outposts of both sides had remained inactive for several days, when the arrival of Hippocrates and Himilco suddenly caused the Romans to be attacked aggressively on all sides; for Hippocrates, having fortified a camp at the great harbour, and given a signal to those who occupied the Achradina, attacked the old camp of the Romans, in which Crispinus had the command; and Epicydes sallied out against the outposts of Marcellus, the Carthaginian fleet coming up to that part of the shore which lay between the city and the Roman camp, so that no succour could be sent by Marcellus to Crispinus. The enemy, however, produced more tumult than conflict; for Crispinus not only drove back Hippocrates from his works, but pursued him as he fled with precipitation, while Marcellus drove Epicydes into the city; and it was considered that enough was now done even to prevent any danger arising in future from their sudden sallies. They were visited too by a plague; a calamity extending to both sides, and one which might well divert their attention from schemes of war. For as the season of the year was autumn, and the situation naturally unwholesome, though this was much more the case without than within the city, the intolerable intensity of the heat had an effect upon the constitution of almost every man in both the camps. At first they sickened and died from the unhealthiness of the season and climate; but afterwards the disease was spread merely by attending upon, and coming in contact with, those affected; so that those who were seized with it either perished neglected and deserted, or else drew with them those who sat by them and attended them, by infecting them with the same violence of disease. Daily funerals and death were before the eye; and lamentations were heard from all sides, day and night. At last, their feelings had become so completely brutalized by being habituated to these miseries, that they not only did not follow their dead with tears and decent lamentations, but they did not even carry them out and bury them; so that the bodies of the dead lay strewed about, exposed to the view of those who were awaiting a similar fate; and thus the dead were the means of destroying the sick, and the sick those who were in health, both by fear and by the filthy state and the noisome stench of their bodies. Some preferring to die by the sword, even rushed alone upon the outposts of the enemy. The violence of the plague, however, was much greater in the Carthaginian than the Roman army; for the latter, from having been a long time before Syracuse, had become more habituated to the climate and the water. Of the army of the enemy, the Sicilians, as soon as they perceived that diseases had become very common from the unwholesomeness of the situation, dispersed to their respective cities in the neighbourhood; but the Carthaginians, who had no place to retire to, perished, together with their generals, Hippocrates and Himilco, to a man. Marcellus, on seeing the violence with which the disease was raging, had removed his troops into the city, where their debilitated frames were recruited in houses and shade. Many however, of the Roman army were cut off by this pestilence.

Marcellus, by taking control of the Euryalus and placing a garrison there, was relieved of one source of worry: the fear that any enemy force based in that fortress might threaten his troops, who were trapped behind the walls. He then surrounded the Achradina, setting up three camps in strategic locations, hoping to force those trapped inside to run out of supplies. The outposts on both sides had been inactive for several days until the arrival of Hippocrates and Himilco suddenly led the Romans to be attacked from all sides. Hippocrates, after fortifying a camp at the main harbor and signaling those in the Achradina, attacked the old Roman camp commanded by Crispinus. Meanwhile, Epicydes launched an assault on Marcellus’s outposts, with the Carthaginian fleet approaching the shore between the city and the Roman camp, preventing Marcellus from sending help to Crispinus. The enemy created more chaos than real conflict; Crispinus not only pushed Hippocrates back from his positions but also chased him as he fled, while Marcellus forced Epicydes back into the city. It was thought that enough had been done to minimize any future threats from their sudden attacks. Both sides were also troubled by a plague, a disaster affecting everyone which could easily distract them from their war plans. Since it was autumn and the area was naturally unhealthy, particularly worse outside the city than inside, the extreme heat impacted nearly everyone in both camps. Initially, many became ill and died due to the season and climate; later, the disease spread simply by being around or touching those already infected. Consequently, those who fell ill either died alone and abandoned or infected those caring for them with the same severe sickness. Daily funerals and deaths were a constant sight, and cries of mourning were heard all day and night. Eventually, their feelings became so numb from the constant suffering that they not only stopped mourning their dead with tears and respectful sadness but also neglected to carry them away for burial. As a result, the bodies lay strewn about, visible to those waiting to meet the same fate; thus, the dead contributed to the demise of the sick, and the sick endangered the healthy, both through fear and the disgusting state and foul odor of the corpses. Some, preferring death by the sword, charged alone at the enemy outposts. However, the plague was much worse in the Carthaginian army than in the Roman one since the latter had been in Syracuse long enough to become more accustomed to the climate and water. The Sicilian soldiers in the enemy camp quickly dispersed to their nearby cities when they realized the prevalence of diseases caused by the unhealthy conditions. In contrast, the Carthaginians, who had nowhere to retreat, perished completely, including their leaders, Hippocrates and Himilco. Seeing how rampant the disease was, Marcellus moved his troops into the city, where they could recover in buildings and shade. Nonetheless, many in the Roman army were still affected by this plague.

27

The land forces of the Carthaginians being thus destroyed, the Sicilians, who had served under Hippocrates retired to two towns of no great size, but well secured by natural situation and fortifications; one was three miles, the other fifteen, from Syracuse. Here they collected a store of provisions from their own states, and sent for reinforcements. Meanwhile, Bomilcar, who had gone a second time to Carthage, by so stating the condition of their allies as to inspire a hope that they might not only render them effectual aid, but also that the Romans might in a manner be made prisoners in the city which they had captured, induced the Carthaginians to send with him as many ships of burden as possible, laden with every kind of provisions, and to augment the number of his ships. Setting sail, therefore, from Carthage with a hundred and thirty men of war and seven hundred transports, he had tolerably fair winds for crossing over to Sicily, but was prevented by the same wind from doubling Cape Pachynum. The news of the approach of Bomilcar, and afterwards his unexpected delay, excited alternate fear and joy in the Romans and Syracusans. Epicydes, apprehensive lest if the same wind which now detained him should continue to blow from the east for several days, the Carthaginian fleet would return to Africa, put the Achradina in the hands of the generals of the mercenary troops, and sailed to Bomilcar; whom he at length prevailed upon to try the issue of a naval battle, though he found him with his fleet stationed in the direction of Africa, and afraid of fighting, not so much because he was unequal in the strength or the number of his ships, for he had more than the Romans, as because the wind was more favourable to the Roman fleet than to his own. Marcellus also seeing that an army of Sicilians was assembling from every part of the island, and that the Carthaginian fleet was approaching with a great want of supplies, though inferior in the number of his ships, resolved to prevent Bomilcar from coming to Syracuse, lest, blocked up in the city of his enemies, he should be pressed both by sea and land. The two hostile fleets were stationed near the promontory of Pachynum, ready to engage as soon as the sea should become calm enough to admit of their sailing out into the deep. Accordingly, the east wind, which had blown violently for several days, now subsiding, Bomilcar got under sail first, his van seeming to make for the main sea, in order to double the promontory with greater ease; but seeing the Roman ships bearing down upon him, terrified by some unexpected occurrence, it is not known what, he sailed away into the main sea; and sending messengers to Heraclea, to order the transports to return to Africa, he passed along the coast of Sicily and made for Tarentum. Epicydes, thus suddenly disappointed in such great expectations, to avoid returning to endeavour to raise the siege of a city, a great part of which was already in the hands of the enemy, sailed to Agrigentum, intending to wait the issue of the contest, rather than take any new measures when there.

The Carthaginian ground forces were decimated, prompting the Sicilians who had served under Hippocrates to retreat to two small towns that were well-protected by their natural surroundings and fortifications; one was three miles and the other fifteen miles from Syracuse. Here, they gathered supplies from their own territories and called for reinforcements. Meanwhile, Bomilcar, who had returned to Carthage a second time, framed the situation of their allies in a way that sparked hope that they could provide effective support and potentially trap the Romans in the city they had taken. This convinced the Carthaginians to send him as many cargo ships as possible, fully loaded with various supplies, and to increase the number of his ships. Setting sail from Carthage with one hundred thirty warships and seven hundred transports, he initially enjoyed favorable winds for the crossing to Sicily but was later stalled by the same wind while rounding Cape Pachynum. The news of Bomilcar's approach and then his unforeseen delay caused alternating fear and relief among the Romans and the Syracusans. Epicydes, worried that if the east wind that was currently holding Bomilcar back continued for several days, the Carthaginian fleet would return to Africa, transferred control of Achradina to the generals of the mercenary troops and sailed to Bomilcar. Ultimately, he convinced Bomilcar to engage in a naval battle, despite finding him with his fleet facing Africa, hesitant about fighting not because he had fewer ships than the Romans—he had more—but because the wind favored the Roman fleet. Marcellus, seeing an army of Sicilians gathering from across the island and the Carthaginian fleet nearing with a significant lack of provisions, decided to prevent Bomilcar from reaching Syracuse. He wanted to avoid being cornered in the enemies’ city, vulnerable to attack from both land and sea. The two opposing fleets were positioned near the promontory of Pachynum, ready to fight as soon as the sea calmed enough for them to venture into open water. As the east wind, which had blown fiercely for several days, finally diminished, Bomilcar set sail first, seemingly aiming for the open sea to round the promontory more easily. However, upon seeing the Roman ships approaching, he panicked for an unknown reason and fled into the open sea. He sent messengers to Heraclea, instructing the transports to return to Africa, while he sailed along the coast of Sicily toward Tarentum. Epicydes, suddenly let down by these overwhelming expectations, opted to avoid returning to attempt to lift the siege of a city that was significantly under enemy control and instead sailed to Agrigentum, planning to wait for the outcome of the battle rather than taking any new actions.

28

Intelligence of these events having been carried into the camp of the Sicilians, that Epicydes had departed from Syracuse, that the island was deserted by the Carthaginians, and almost again delivered up to the Romans; after sounding the inclinations of the besieged in conferences, they sent ambassadors to Marcellus, to treat about terms of capitulation. They had not much difficulty in coming to an agreement, that all the parts of the island which had been under the dominion of their kings should be ceded to the Romans; that the rest, with their liberty and their own laws, should be preserved to the Sicilians. They then invited to a conference the persons who had been intrusted with the management of affairs by Epicydes; to whom they said, that they were sent from the army of the Sicilians, at once to Marcellus and to them, that both those who were besieged and those who were not might share the same fortune; and that neither of them might stipulate any thing for themselves separately. They were then allowed to enter, in order to converse with their relations and friends; when, laying before them the terms which they had made with Marcellus, and holding out to them a hope of safety, they induced them to join with them in an attack upon the prefects of Epicydes, Polyclitus, Philistion, and Epicydes, surnamed Sindon. Having put them to death, they summoned the multitude to an assembly; and after complaining of the famine, at which they had been accustomed to express their dissatisfaction to each other in secret, they said, that "although they were pressed by so many calamities, they had no right to accuse Fortune, because it was at their own option how long they should continue to suffer them. That the motive which the Romans had in besieging Syracuse was affection for the Syracusans, and not hatred; for when they heard that the government was usurped by Hippocrates and Epicydes, the creatures first of Hannibal and then of Hieronymus, they took arms and began to besiege the city, in order to reduce not the city itself, but its cruel tyrants. But now that Hippocrates is slain, Epicydes shut out of Syracuse, his praefects put to death, and the Carthaginians driven from the entire possession of Sicily by sea and land, what reason can the Romans have left why they should not desire the preservation of Syracuse, in the same manner as they would if Hiero were still lining, who cultivated the friendship of Rome with unequalled fidelity? That, therefore, neither the city nor its inhabitants were in any danger, except from themselves, if they neglected an opportunity of restoring themselves to the favour of the Romans; and that no so favourable a one would ever occur as that which presented itself at the present instant, immediately upon its appearing that they were delivered from their insolent tyrants."

Intelligence of these events reached the Sicilian camp, informing them that Epicydes had left Syracuse, that the island was abandoned by the Carthaginians, and was nearly returned to the Romans. After gauging the feelings of those under siege in discussions, they sent ambassadors to Marcellus to negotiate the terms of their surrender. They easily agreed that all parts of the island that were once under their kings' control should be handed over to the Romans, while the remainder, along with their freedom and laws, would remain with the Sicilians. They then invited those appointed by Epicydes to a meeting, telling them they were sent from the Sicilian army to both Marcellus and them, so that both the besieged and those not besieged would share the same fate and neither party could negotiate for themselves separately. They were allowed to enter in order to speak with their relatives and friends; after presenting the terms they had arranged with Marcellus and offering a chance for safety, they persuaded them to cooperate in attacking Epicydes' prefects: Polyclitus, Philistion, and Epicydes, known as Sindon. Having killed them, they called the people to an assembly; after voicing their frustrations about the famine they had secretly complained about, they said, "Even though we are burdened by so many misfortunes, we have no right to blame Fortune, as it is within our control how long we endure them. The reason the Romans besieged Syracuse was out of love for the Syracusans, not hatred. When they learned that the government was taken over by Hippocrates and Epicydes, servants first of Hannibal and then of Hieronymus, they took up arms to besiege the city, aiming not at the city itself, but at its cruel tyrants. Now that Hippocrates is dead, Epicydes is shut out of Syracuse, his prefects have been executed, and the Carthaginians are completely driven from Sicily by land and sea, what reason could the Romans have not to want to preserve Syracuse, just as they would if Hiero were still alive, who maintained his friendship with Rome with unmatched loyalty? Therefore, neither the city nor its people are in any danger, except from themselves, if they miss the chance to regain the Romans' favor; there will never be a more favorable opportunity than this one, especially now that they are freed from their tyrants."

29

This speech was received with the most unqualified approbation of all present. It was resolved, however, that praetors should be elected before the nomination of deputies; which being done, some of the praetors themselves were sent as deputies to Marcellus, the chief of whom thus addressed him: "Neither in the first instance did we Syracusans revolt from you, but Hieronymus, whose impiety towards you was by no means so great as towards us; nor afterwards was it any Syracusan who disturbed the peace established by the death of the tyrant, but Hippocrates and Epicydes, creatures of the tyrant; while we were overpowered, on the one hand by fear, and on the other by treachery. Nor can any one say that there ever was a time when we were in possession of our liberty, when we were not also at peace with you. In the present instance, manifestly, as soon as ever we became our own masters, by the death of those persons who held Syracuse in subjection, we lost no time in coming to deliver up our arms, to surrender ourselves, our city, and our walls, and to refuse no conditions which you shall impose upon us. To you, Marcellus, the gods have given the glory of having captured the most renowned and beautiful of the Grecian cities. Every memorable exploit which we have at any time achieved by land or sea accrues to the splendour of your triumph. Would you wish that it should be known only by fame, how great a city has been captured by you, rather than that she should stand as a monument even to posterity; so that to every one who visits her by sea or land, she may point out at one time our trophies gained from the Athenians and Carthaginians, at another time those which you have gained from us; and that you should transmit Syracuse unimpaired to your family, to be kept under the protection and patronage of the race of the Marcelli? Let not the memory of Hieronymus have greater weight with you than that of Hiero. The latter was your friend for a much longer period than the former was your enemy. From the latter you have realized even benefits, while the frenzy of Hieronymus only brought ruin upon himself." At the hands of the Romans all things were obtainable and secure. There was a greater disposition to war, and more danger to be apprehended among themselves; for the deserters, thinking that they were delivered up to the Romans, induced the mercenary auxiliaries to entertain the same apprehension; and hastily seizing their arms, they first put the praetors to death, and then ran through the city to massacre the Syracusans. In their rage they slew all whom chance threw in their way, and plundered every thing which presented itself; and then, lest they should have no leaders, they elected six praetors, so that three might have the command in the Achradina, and three in the island. At length, the tumult having subsided, and the mercenary troops having ascertained, by inquiry, what had been negotiated with the Romans, it began to appear, as was really the case, that their cause and that of the deserters were different.

This speech was received with complete approval from everyone present. It was decided, however, that praetors should be elected before naming deputies; once that was done, some of the praetors were sent as deputies to Marcellus, the main one addressing him: "We, the people of Syracuse, did not initially rebel against you; it was Hieronymus, whose wrongdoing towards you was not nearly as great as his wrongdoing towards us. Furthermore, it wasn't any Syracusans who disrupted the peace established by the tyrant's death, but Hippocrates and Epicydes, who were allies of the tyrant, while we were overpowered by fear on one hand and betrayal on the other. No one can claim there was ever a moment when we enjoyed our freedom without also being at peace with you. Clearly, as soon as we regained control, after the deaths of those who held Syracuse in submission, we quickly came forward to hand over our weapons, to surrender ourselves, our city, and our walls, and to accept any conditions you impose on us. To you, Marcellus, the gods have bestowed the honor of capturing one of the most notable and beautiful Greek cities. Every significant achievement we've made, whether by land or sea, adds to the glory of your triumph. Would you prefer that your victory is known only by reputation, rather than having the city stand as a testament for future generations; so that anyone visiting by sea or land can see our trophies from the Athenians and Carthaginians on one side, and your victories over us on the other; and that you should pass on Syracuse intact to your family, to be cared for under the protection of the Marcelli family? Let not Hieronymus’s memory weigh more with you than Hiero’s. The latter was your ally for much longer than the former was your adversary. From Hiero, you gained even advantages, while Hieronymus's madness brought only ruin upon himself." Under Roman rule, everything was attainable and secure. There was a greater inclination towards war and more danger within their own ranks; the deserters, believing they were betrayed to the Romans, influenced the mercenary troops to share the same fear; and quickly seizing their weapons, they first killed the praetors, then rampaged through the city to slaughter the Syracusans. In their fury, they killed anyone who came in their path and looted whatever they could find; and then, in case they would lack leaders, they elected six praetors, dividing the command so that three would rule in Achradina and three on the island. Eventually, as the chaos began to calm and the mercenary troops learned through inquiries what had been negotiated with the Romans, it started to become clear that their cause was different from that of the deserters.

30

The ambassadors returned from Marcellus very opportunely. They informed them that they had been influenced by groundless suspicions, and that the Romans saw no reason why they should inflict punishment upon them. Of the three praefects of the Achradina one was a Spaniard, named Mericus. To him one of the Spanish auxiliaries was designedly sent, among those who accompanied the ambassadors. Having obtained an interview with Mericus in the absence of witnesses, he first explained to him the state in which he had left Spain, from which he had lately returned: "That there every thing was in subjection to the Roman arms; that it was in his power, by doing the Romans a service, to become the first man among his countrymen, whether he might be inclined to serve with the Romans, or to return to his country. On the other hand, if he persisted in preferring to hold out against the siege, what hope could he have, shut up as he was by sea and land?" Mericus was moved by these suggestions, and when it was resolved upon to send ambassadors to Marcellus, he sent his brother among them; who, being brought into the presence of Marcellus, apart from the rest, by means of the same Spaniard, after receiving an assurance of protection, arranged the method of carrying their object into effect, and then returned to the Achradina. Mericus then, in order to prevent any one from conceiving a suspicion of treachery, declared, that he did not like that deputies should be passing to and fro; he thought that they should neither admit nor send any; and in order that the guards might be kept more strictly, that such parts as were most exposed should be distributed among the prefects, each being made responsible for the safety of his own quarter. All approved of the distribution of the posts. The district which fell to the lot of Mericus himself extended from the fountain Arethusa to the mouth of the large harbour, of which he caused the Romans to be informed. Accordingly, Marcellus ordered a transport with armed men to be towed by a quadrireme to the Achradina during the night, and the soldiers to be landed in the vicinity of that gate which is near the fountain of Arethusa. This order having been executed at the fourth watch, and Mericus having received the soldiers when landed at the gate, according to the agreement, Marcellus assaulted the walls of the Achradina with all his forces at break of day, so that he not only engaged the attention of those who occupied the Achradina, but also bands of armed men, quitting their own posts ran to the spot from the island, in order to repel the furious attack of the Romans. During this confusion, some light ships which had been prepared beforehand, and had sailed round, landed a body of armed men at the island; these suddenly attacking the half-manned stations and the opened door of the gate at which the troops had a little before run out, got possession of the island without much opposition, abandoned as it was, in consequence of the flight and trepidation of its guards. Nor were there any who rendered less service, or showed less firmness in maintaining their posts, than the deserters; for as they did not repose much confidence even in those of their own party, they fled in the middle of the contest. When Marcellus learnt that the island was taken, one quarter of the Achradina in the hands of his troops, and that Mericus, with the men under his command, had joined them, he sounded a retreat, lest the royal treasure, the fame of which was greater than the reality, should be plundered.

The ambassadors returned from Marcellus at just the right moment. They told them that they had been swayed by baseless suspicions, and that the Romans saw no reason to punish them. Of the three prefects of Achradina, one was a Spaniard named Mericus. One of the Spanish auxiliaries was intentionally sent to him among those who traveled with the ambassadors. When he got a chance to speak with Mericus alone, he first explained the situation in Spain, where he had just come from: "There, everything is under Roman control; it’s possible for you to gain respect among your people by helping the Romans, whether you want to serve alongside them or go back to your homeland. On the flip side, if you decide to resist the siege, what hope do you have, surrounded by sea and land?" Mericus was swayed by these thoughts, and when it was decided to send ambassadors to Marcellus, he sent his brother with them. After being introduced to Marcellus separately, thanks to the same Spaniard, and receiving assurances of safety, he arranged how to achieve their goal before returning to Achradina. Mericus then wanted to avoid any suspicion of betrayal, so he stated that he didn't like deputies coming and going; he believed they shouldn't send or receive any, and to keep the guards stricter, the most vulnerable areas should be assigned to the prefects, making each responsible for the safety of their own section. Everyone agreed with the distribution of the posts. The area that fell to Mericus extended from the Arethusa fountain to the entrance of the large harbor, of which he informed the Romans. So, Marcellus ordered a transport with armed men to be towed by a quadrireme to Achradina during the night, landing the soldiers near the gate by the Arethusa fountain. This was carried out in the early morning, and after Mericus received the soldiers at the gate as agreed, Marcellus attacked the walls of Achradina with all his forces at dawn, capturing not only the attention of those occupying Achradina but also drawing armed men from their posts on the island to repel the fierce Roman attack. Amid the chaos, some light ships that had been prepared beforehand arrived and landed a group of armed men on the island. They quickly charged the poorly manned stations and the open gate where troops had recently rushed out, taking control of the island with little resistance due to the retreat and panic of its guards. The deserters provided no better defense or showed less determination in holding their posts; lacking confidence even in their own side, they fled during the fight. When Marcellus found out that the island was secured, one quarter of Achradina was under his troops, and that Mericus and his men had joined them, he called for a retreat to prevent the royal treasure, which held more reputation than value, from being looted.

31

The impetuosity of the soldiers having been checked, time and opportunity to escape were given to the deserters in the Achradina; and the Syracusans, at length delivered from their fears, threw open the gates of the Achradina, and sent deputies to Marcellus, requesting only safety for themselves and children. Having summoned a council, to which the Syracusans were invited who were among the Roman troops, having been driven from home during the disturbances, Marcellus replied, "that the services rendered by Hiero through a period of fifty years, were not more in number than the injuries committed against the Roman people in these few years by those who had had possession of Syracuse; but that most of these injuries had justly recoiled upon their authors, and that they had inflicted much more severe punishment upon themselves for the violation of treaties, than the Roman people desired. That he was indeed now besieging Syracuse for the third year, but not that the Romans might hold that state in a condition of slavery, but that the ringleaders of the deserters might not keep it in a state of thraldom and oppression. What the Syracusans could do was exemplified, either by the conduct of those Syracusans who were among the Roman troops, or that of the Spanish general, Mericus, who had delivered up the post which he was appointed to command, or, lastly, by the late but bold measure adopted by the Syracusans themselves. That the greatest possible recompence for all the evils and dangers which he had for so long a time undergone, both by sea and land, around the walls of Syracuse, was the reflection, that he had been able to take that city." The quaestor was then sent with a guard to the island, to receive and protect the royal treasure. The city was given up to be plundered by the soldiery, after guards had been placed at each of the houses of those who had been with the Roman troops. While many acts exhibited horrid examples of rage and rapacity, it is recorded that Archimedes, while intent on some figures which he had described in the dust, although the confusion was as great as could possibly exist in a captured city, in which soldiers were running up and down in search of plunder, was put to death by a soldier, who did not know who he was; that Marcellus was grieved at this event, and that pains were taken about his funeral, while his relations also for whom diligent inquiry was made, derived honour and protection from his name and memory. Such, for the most part, was the manner in which Syracuse was captured. The quantity of booty was so great, that had Carthage itself, which was carrying on a contest on equal terms, been captured, it would scarcely have afforded so much. A few days before the taking of Syracuse, Titus Otacilius passed over from Lilybaeum to Utica with eighty quinqueremes, and entering the harbour before it was light, took some transports laden with corn; then landing, he laid waste a considerable portion of the country around Utica, and brought back to his ships booty of every description. He returned to Lilybaeum, the third day after he set out, with a hundred and thirty transports laden with corn and booty. The corn he sent immediately to Syracuse; and had it not been for the very seasonable arrival of this supply, a destructive famine threatened alike the victors and the vanquished.

The soldiers' rashness was held in check, giving the deserters in Achradina a chance to escape. The Syracusans, finally relieved from their fears, opened the gates of Achradina and sent envoys to Marcellus, asking only for safety for themselves and their children. After calling a council that included Syracusans who had been among the Roman troops, driven from their homes during the unrest, Marcellus said, "The services Hiero provided over fifty years are not as numerous as the injuries done to the Roman people in just a few years by those who held Syracuse. However, most of these injuries have rightly turned back on their authors, and they punished themselves much more harshly for violating treaties than the Romans wished to. Indeed, I have been besieging Syracuse for the third year, but not so the Romans could enslave the city, but so that the leaders of the deserters couldn't keep it in bondage and oppression. What the Syracusans can do is shown either by the actions of those Syracusans who are with the Roman troops or by the Spanish general, Mericus, who surrendered his command, or by the recent bold move by the Syracusans themselves. The greatest reward for all the hardships I've faced, both by sea and land, around the walls of Syracuse is knowing that I was able to capture that city." The quaestor was then sent with a guard to the island to collect and protect the royal treasure. The city was handed over to be looted by the soldiers after guards were posted at every house of those who had been with the Roman troops. While many actions displayed horrific examples of violence and greed, it was reported that Archimedes, while focused on some figures he had drawn in the dust amidst the chaos of a captured city, where soldiers were racing around seeking loot, was killed by a soldier who didn't recognize him. Marcellus was saddened by this event, and efforts were made for his funeral, while his family, for whom diligent search was made, gained honor and protection from his name and memory. This was mostly how Syracuse was captured. The amount of loot was so enormous that if Carthage itself, which was participating in an equal contest, had been captured, it would hardly have yielded so much. A few days before Syracuse fell, Titus Otacilius crossed from Lilybaeum to Utica with eighty quinqueremes, and arriving in the harbor before dawn, seized some ships loaded with grain; then after landing, he devastated a large portion of the land around Utica and brought back to his ships various kinds of loot. He returned to Lilybaeum three days after he set out, with one hundred thirty ships full of grain and loot. He immediately sent the grain to Syracuse; if it hadn't been for the timely arrival of this supply, a devastating famine would have threatened both the victors and the defeated.

32

Nothing very memorable had been done in Spain for about two years, the operations of the war consisting more in laying plans than in fighting; but during the same summer in which the events above recorded took place, the Roman generals, quitting their winter quarters, united their forces; then a council was summoned; and the opinions of all accorded, that since their only object hitherto had been to prevent Hasdrubal from pursuing his march into Italy, it was now time that an effort should be made to bring the war in Spain to a termination; and they thought that the twenty thousand Celtiberians, who had been induced to take arms that winter, formed a sufficient accession to their strength. There were three armies of the enemy. Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, and Mago, who had united their forces, were about a five days' journey from the Romans. Hasdrubal, son of Hamilcar, who was the old commander in Spain, was nearer to them: he was with his army near the city Anitorgis. The Roman generals were desirous that he should be overpowered first; and they hoped that they had enough and more than enough strength for the purpose. Their only source of anxiety was, lest the other Hasdrubal and Mago, terrified at his discomfiture, should protract the war by withdrawing into trackless forests and mountains. Thinking it, therefore, the wisest course to divide their forces and embrace the whole Spanish war, they arranged it so that Publius Cornelius should lead two-thirds of the Roman and allied troops against Mago and Hasdrubal, and that Cneius Cornelius, with the remaining third of the original army, and with the Celtiberians added to them, should carry on the war with the Barcine Hasdrubal. The two generals and their armies, setting out together, preceded by the Celtiberians, pitched their camp near the city Anitorgis, within sight of the enemy, the river only separating them. Here Cneius Scipio, with the forces above mentioned, halted, but Publius Scipio proceeded to the portion of the war assigned to him.

Nothing particularly memorable had happened in Spain for about two years; the war had mostly involved planning rather than actual fighting. However, during the same summer when the events described earlier took place, the Roman generals left their winter quarters and combined their forces. They called a council, and everyone agreed that since their main goal so far had been to stop Hasdrubal from advancing into Italy, it was now time to make an effort to end the war in Spain. They believed that the twenty thousand Celtiberians who had decided to fight that winter provided a significant boost to their strength. There were three enemy armies: Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, and Mago, who had joined forces, were about a five-day journey away from the Romans. Hasdrubal, son of Hamilcar, the veteran commander in Spain, was closer, stationed with his army near the city of Anitorgis. The Roman generals wanted to defeat him first and felt confident they had enough strength to do so. Their only concern was that the other Hasdrubal and Mago, fearing his defeat, might prolong the war by retreating into the dense forests and mountains. Therefore, they decided it would be best to split their forces and address the entire Spanish conflict. They arranged for Publius Cornelius to lead two-thirds of the Roman and allied troops against Mago and Hasdrubal, while Cneius Cornelius would take the remaining third of the original army, along with the Celtiberians, to engage the Barcine Hasdrubal. The two generals and their armies set out together, with the Celtiberians in the lead, and camped near the city of Anitorgis, directly across from the enemy, with the river separating them. Here, Cneius Scipio and his forces stayed, while Publius Scipio moved forward to carry out his assigned part of the campaign.

33

Hasdrubal perceiving that there were but few Roman troops in the camp, and that their whole dependence was on the Celtiberian auxiliaries; and having had experience of the perfidy of the barbarian nations in general, and particularly of all those nations among which he had served for so many years; as there was every facility of intercourse, for both camps were full of Spaniards, by secret conferences with the chiefs of the Celtiberians, he agreed with them, for a large consideration, to take their forces away. Nor did they conceive it to be any great crime; for the object was not that they should turn their arms against the Romans, while the reward which they were to receive to abstain from the war was large enough to remunerate them for their service in it. At the same time the mere rest from labour, the return to their homes, with the pleasure of seeing their friends and property, were pleasing to the generality. Accordingly, the multitude were prevailed upon as easily as their leaders. They had, moreover, nothing to fear from the Romans, in consequence of the smallness of their numbers, should they endeavour to detain them by force. It will indeed be the duty of all Roman generals to take care, and the instances here recorded should be considered as strong arguments, never to place so much confidence in foreign auxiliaries, as not to retain in their camps a preponderance of their own strength and of that force which is properly their own. The Celtiberians, suddenly taking up their standards, marched away, replying only to the Romans, who asked the cause of their departure and entreated them to stay, that they were called away by a war at home. Scipio seeing that his allies could be detained neither by prayers nor force, and that he was neither a match for his enemy without them, nor could again effect a junction with his brother, no other course which promised safety offering itself, resolved to retire as far as possible, carefully using every caution not to encounter the enemy any where on level ground. On his departing, the enemy, crossing the river, pursued him almost in his footsteps.

Hasdrubal noticed that there were only a few Roman soldiers in the camp and that their entire reliance was on the Celtiberian allies. Having experienced the deceitfulness of barbarian nations, especially those he had served with for so many years, he took advantage of the easy communication since both camps were full of Spaniards. Through secret meetings with the Celtiberian leaders, he made a deal with them for a significant payment to withdraw their forces. They didn’t see it as a serious betrayal because they wouldn’t be turning their weapons against the Romans, and the compensation for sitting out the fight was enough to justify their actions. Additionally, the chance to rest from battle and return home to see their friends and property was appealing to most of them. Consequently, the common soldiers were convinced as easily as their leaders. They had little to worry about from the Romans due to their small numbers if they tried to force them to stay. This situation should serve as a strong reminder to all Roman generals never to trust foreign allies too much and to maintain a significant presence of their own troops. The Celtiberians quickly raised their standards and left, telling the Romans who asked why they were going that they were needed for a war back home. Scipio realized he couldn’t convince his allies to stay, and with them gone, he was outmatched by the enemy and couldn’t reunite with his brother. With no other safe option available, he decided to retreat as far as possible, taking care to avoid any encounters with the enemy on flat ground. As he left, the enemy crossed the river and followed his trail closely.

34

During the same period an equal terror and a greater danger pressed upon Publius Scipio. Masinissa was a young man at that time an ally of the Carthaginians, whom afterwards the friendship of the Romans rendered illustrious and powerful. He not only opposed himself with his Numidian cavalry to Scipio on his approach, but afterwards harassed him incessantly day and night, so as both to cut off his stragglers, who had gone out to a distance from the camp in search of wood and forage, and riding up to the very gates of his camp, and charging into the midst of his advanced guards, to fill every quarter with the utmost confusion. By night also alarm was frequently occasioned in the gates and rampart by his sudden attacks. Nor was there any time or place at which the Romans were exempt from fear and anxiety; and driven within their rampart, and deprived of every necessary, they suffered in a manner a regular siege; and it appeared that it would have been still straiter, if Indibilis, who it was reported was approaching with seven thousand five hundred Suessetani, should form a junction with the Carthaginians. Scipio, though a wary and provident general, overpowered by difficulties, adopted the rash measure of going to meet Indibilis by night, with the intention of fighting him wherever he should meet him. Leaving, therefore, a small force in his camp, under the command of Titus Fonteius, lieutenant-general, he set out at midnight, and meeting with the enemy, came to battle with him. The troops fought in the order of march rather than of battle. The Romans, however, had the advantage, though in an irregular fight; but the Numidian cavalry, whose observation the general supposed that he had escaped, suddenly spreading themselves round his flanks, occasioned great terror. After a new contest had been entered into with the Numidians, a third enemy came up in addition to the rest, the Carthaginian generals having come up with their rear when they were now engaged in fighting. Thus the Romans were surrounded on every side by enemies; nor could they make up their minds which they should attack first, or in what part, forming themselves into a close body, they should force their way through. The general, while fighting and encouraging his men, exposing himself wherever the strife was the hottest, was run through the right side with a lance; and when the party of the enemy, which, formed into a wedge, had charged the troops collected round the general, perceived Scipio falling lifeless from his horse, elated with joy, they ran shouting through the whole line with the news that the Roman general had fallen. These words spreading in every direction, caused the enemy to be considered as victors, and the Romans as vanquished. On the loss of the general the troops immediately began to fly from the field; but though it was not difficult to force their way through the Numidians and the other light-armed auxiliaries, yet it was scarcely possible for them to escape so large a body of cavalry, and infantry equal to horses in speed. Almost more were slain in the flight than in the battle; nor would a man have survived, had not night put a stop to the carnage, the day by this time rapidly drawing to a close.

During the same time, Publius Scipio faced equal terror and greater danger. Masinissa, a young ally of the Carthaginians back then, later gained fame and power through his friendship with the Romans. He not only confronted Scipio with his Numidian cavalry as he approached, but also continually harassed him day and night, cutting off stragglers who had ventured far from the camp searching for wood and supplies. Masinissa rode right up to the camp gates and charged into the ranks of Scipio's advanced guards, creating utter chaos. At night, sudden attacks often caused alarm at the gates and ramparts. The Romans lived in constant fear and anxiety; confined within their ramparts and deprived of essentials, they effectively suffered a regular siege. It seemed the situation would get even tighter if Indibilis, reported to be approaching with seven thousand five hundred Suessetani, joined forces with the Carthaginians. Despite being a cautious and forward-thinking general, overwhelmed by difficulties, Scipio made the risky decision to confront Indibilis at night, planning to engage him wherever they met. So, he left a small force in his camp under the command of lieutenant-general Titus Fonteius and set out at midnight, encountering the enemy and engaging in battle. The troops fought in the order of their march rather than in battle formation. However, the Romans gained an advantage even in this irregular fight, but the Numidian cavalry, which Scipio thought he had evaded, suddenly surrounded his flanks, causing great panic. After entering into another fight with the Numidians, a third enemy appeared when the Carthaginian generals joined the fray. The Romans found themselves surrounded by foes on all sides, uncertain about whom to attack first or where to break through. The general, fighting and encouraging his men while exposing himself where the battle was fiercest, was struck on his right side by a lance. When the enemy, organized into a wedge, charged at the troops surrounding the general and saw Scipio fall lifeless from his horse, they rejoiced and called out the news throughout their ranks that the Roman general had fallen. This word spread quickly, making the enemy feel victorious and the Romans feel defeated. After losing their leader, the troops started to flee, and while it wasn't hard to break through the Numidians and other light-armed auxiliaries, escaping the larger body of cavalry and fast infantry was nearly impossible. More were killed in the flight than in the battle, and no one would have survived if night hadn’t halted the slaughter, as day was quickly coming to an end.

35

After this, the Carthaginian generals, who were not slow in following up their victory, immediately after the battle, scarcely giving their soldiers necessary rest, hurry their army to Hasdrubal, son of Hamilcar; confidently hoping, that after uniting their forces with his, the war might be brought to a conclusion. On their arrival, the warmest congratulations passed between the troops and their generals, who were delighted with their recent victory; for they had not only destroyed one distinguished general and all his men, but looked forward to another victory of equal magnitude as a matter of certainty. The intelligence of this great disaster had not yet reached the Romans; but there prevailed a kind of melancholy silence and mute foreboding, such as is usually found in minds which have a presentiment of impending calamity. The general himself, besides feeling that he was deserted by his allies, and that the forces of the enemy were so much augmented, was disposed from conjecture and reasoning rather to a suspicion that some defeat had been sustained, than to any favourable hopes. "For how could Hasdrubal and Mago bring up their troops without opposition, unless they had terminated their part of the war? How was it that his brother had not opposed his progress or followed on his rear? in order that if he could not prevent the armies and generals of the enemy from forming a junction, he might himself join his forces with his brother's." Disturbed with these cares, he believed that the only safe policy for the present was to retire as far as possible; and, accordingly, he marched a considerable distance thence in one night, the enemy not being aware of it, and on that account continuing quiet. At dawn, perceiving that their enemy had decamped, they sent the Numidians in advance, and began to pursue them as rapidly as possible. The Numidians overtook them before night, and charged; sometimes their rear, at other times their flanks. They then began to halt and defend themselves as well as they could; but Scipio exhorted them at once to fight so as not to expose themselves, and march at the same time, lest the infantry should overtake them.

After this, the Carthaginian generals, quick to build on their victory, immediately after the battle, barely giving their soldiers a needed rest, rushed their army to Hasdrubal, son of Hamilcar; confidently hoping that by joining forces with him, they could bring the war to an end. Upon arrival, there were warm congratulations exchanged between the troops and their generals, who were thrilled with their recent win; they had not only defeated a prominent general and all his men but were also anticipating another victory of the same scale as a certainty. The news of this significant disaster hadn't yet reached the Romans; however, there was a pervasive atmosphere of melancholy silence and unspoken dread, typical of those who sense impending disaster. The general himself, besides feeling abandoned by his allies and realizing the enemy's forces had increased, was led more by conjecture and reasoning to suspect that some defeat had occurred rather than to have any hopeful outlook. "How could Hasdrubal and Mago bring up their troops without facing opposition unless they had wrapped up their part of the war? Why hadn’t his brother confronted their advance or followed behind? If he couldn't stop the enemy armies and generals from joining together, he should have at least linked up with his brother." Disturbed by these worries, he thought the only safe strategy for now was to retreat as far as possible; accordingly, he marched a considerable distance overnight without the enemy noticing, which kept them unaware. At dawn, realizing their enemy had moved out, they sent the Numidians ahead and began to chase them as fast as they could. The Numidians caught up with them before nightfall and attacked, striking at their rear and sometimes at their flanks. The Romans then began to stop and defend themselves as best as they could; however, Scipio urged them to fight without exposing themselves and to keep moving simultaneously, so the infantry wouldn’t catch up with them.

36

But having made but little progress for a long time, in consequence of his making his troops sometimes advance and at others halt, and night now drawing on, Scipio recalled his troops from the battle, and collecting them, withdrew to a certain eminence, not very safe, indeed, particularly for dispirited troops, but higher than any of the surrounding places. There, at first, his infantry, drawn up around his baggage and cavalry, which were placed in their centre, had no difficulty in repelling the attacks of the charging Numidians; but afterwards, when three generals with three regular armies marched up in one entire body, and it was evident that his men would not be able to do much by arms in defending the position without fortifications, the general began to look about, and consider whether he could by any means throw a rampart around; but the hill was so bare, and the soil so rough, that neither could a bush be found for cutting a palisade, nor earth for making a mound, nor the requisites for making a trench or any other work; nor was the place naturally steep or abrupt enough to render the approach and ascent difficult to the enemy, as it rose on every side with a gentle acclivity. However, that they might raise up against them some semblance of a rampart, they placed around them the panniers tied to the burdens, building them up as it were to the usual height, and when there was a deficiency of panniers for raising it, they presented against the enemy a heap of baggage of every kind. The Carthaginian armies coming up, very easily marched up the eminence, but were stopped by the novel appearance of the fortification, as by something miraculous, when their leaders called out from all sides, asking "what they stopped at? and why they did not tear down and demolish that mockery, which was scarcely strong enough to impede the progress of women and children; that the enemy, who were skulking behind their baggage, were, in fact, captured and in their hands." Such were the contemptuous reproofs of their leaders. But it was not an easy task either to leap over or remove the burdens raised up against them, or to cut through the panniers, closely packed together and covered completely with baggage. When the removal of the burdens had opened a way to the troops, who were detained by them for a long time, and the same had been done in several quarters, the camp was now captured on all sides; the Romans were cut to pieces on all hands, the few by the many, the dispirited by the victorious. A great number of the men, however, having fled for refuge into the neighbouring woods, effected their escape to the camp of Publius Scipio, which Titus Fonteius commanded. Some authors relate that Cneius Scipio was slain on the eminence on the first assault of the enemy; others that he escaped with a few attendants to a castle near the camp; this, they say, was surrounded with fire, by which means the doors which they could not force were consumed; that it was thus taken, and all within, together with the general himself, put to death. Cneius Scipio was slain in the eighth year after his arrival in Spain, and on the twenty-ninth day after the death of his brother. At Rome the grief occasioned by their death was not more intense than that which was felt throughout Spain. The sorrow of the citizens, however, was partly distracted by the loss of the armies, the alienation of the province, and the public disaster, while in Spain they mourned and regretted the generals themselves, Cneius, however, the more, because he had been longer in command of them, had first engaged their affections, and first exhibited a specimen of Roman justice and forbearance.

But after making little progress for a long time because he would sometimes advance his troops and at other times have them halt, and with night approaching, Scipio called back his troops from the battle. He gathered them and moved up to a high point that wasn’t very safe, especially for dispirited troops, but was higher than anything around it. At first, his infantry, arranged around their baggage and with cavalry positioned in the center, easily repelled the charges from the Numidians. However, when three generals with three full armies approached together, it became clear that his men wouldn't be able to defend the position without fortifications. The general began to look around to see if he could somehow throw up a rampart, but the hill was so bare and the ground so rough that there were no bushes for cutting a palisade, no earth for making a mound, nor anything needed for a trench or any other kind of work; nor was the place steep or sharp enough to make it hard for the enemy to ascend, as it sloped gently all around. To create some sort of makeshift rampart, they used the panniers tied to their burdens, stacking them up to a reasonable height, and when they ran out of panniers, they presented a heap of all kinds of baggage against the enemy. The Carthaginian armies easily marched up the hill but were halted by the unusual sight of the fortification, which appeared almost miraculous. Their leaders yelled from all sides, asking why they were stopping and why they didn’t just tear down that feeble barrier, which was hardly strong enough to block women and children; they claimed that the enemy was hiding behind their baggage and could be easily captured. That was the scornful taunts from their leaders. But leaping over or removing the burdens piled against them, or cutting through the tightly packed and fully covered panniers, was no easy task. When the burdens were finally cleared enough for the troops to pass through, they opened a route after a long delay, and similar clearings happened in several places. The camp was now surrounded on all sides; the Romans were defeated all around them, outnumbered and demoralized by the victorious enemy. A large number of men, however, escaped to the nearby woods and made their way to the camp of Publius Scipio, which Titus Fonteius commanded. Some sources say that Cneius Scipio was killed on the hill during the enemy's first attack; others say he escaped with a few attendants to a castle near the camp, which was then surrounded by fire, leading to the consumption of the doors they couldn’t force open. This castle was taken, and everyone inside, including the general, was killed. Cneius Scipio died in the eighth year after his arrival in Spain, and twenty-nine days after his brother's death. In Rome, the grief over their deaths was just as intense as the sorrow felt throughout Spain. The sorrow of the citizens was somewhat divided by the loss of the armies, the alienation of the province, and the public disaster, while in Spain they mourned the generals themselves, especially Cneius, who had been in command longer, had first won their affection, and had shown a strong example of Roman justice and patience.

37

When it seemed that the Roman armies were annihilated, and Spain lost, one man recovered this desperate state of affairs. There was in the army one Lucius Marcius, the son of Septimus, a Roman knight, an enterprising youth, and possessing a mind and genius far superior to the condition in which he had been born. To his high talents had been added the discipline of Cneius Scipio, under which he had been thoroughly instructed during a course of so many years in all the qualifications of a soldier. This man, having collected the troops which had been dispersed in the flight, and drafted some from the garrisons, had formed an army not to be despised, and united it with Titus Tonteius, the lieutenant-general of Publius Scipio. But so transcendent was the Roman knight in authority and honour among the troops, that when, after fortifying a camp on this side of the Iberus, it had been resolved that a general of the two armies should be elected in an assembly of the soldiers, relieving each other in the guard of the rampart, and in keeping the outposts until every one had given his vote, they unanimously conferred the supreme command upon Lucius Marcius. All the intervening time, which was but short, was occupied in fortifying their camp and collecting provisions, and the soldiers executed every order not only with vigour, but with feelings by no means depressed. But when intelligence was brought them that Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, who was coming to put the finishing stroke to the war, had crossed the Iberus and was drawing near, and when they saw the signal for battle displayed by a new commander, then calling to mind whom they had had for their leaders a little while ago, relying on what leaders and what forces they used to go out to fight, they all suddenly burst into tears and beat their heads, some raising their hands to heaven and arraigning the gods, others prostrating themselves upon the ground and invoking by name each his own former commander. Nor could their lamentations be restrained, though the centurions endeavoured to animate their companies, and though Marcius himself soothed and remonstrated with them, asking them "why they had given themselves up to womanish and unavailing lamentations rather than summon up all their courage to protect themselves and the commonwealth together, and not suffer their generals to lie unavenged?" But suddenly a shout and the sound of trumpets were heard; for by this time the enemy were near the rampart. Upon this, their grief being suddenly converted into rage, they hastily ran to arms, and, as it were, burning with fury, rushed to the gates and charged the enemy, while advancing in a careless and disorderly manner. This unexpected event instantly struck terror into the Carthaginians, who wondering whence so many enemies could have sprung up so suddenly, as the army had been almost annihilated; what could have inspired men who had been vanquished and routed with such boldness and confidence in themselves; what general could have arisen now that the two Scipios were slain; who could command the camp, and who had given the signal for battle; in consequence of these so many and so unexpected circumstances, at first, being in a state of complete uncertainty and amazement, they gave ground; but afterwards, discomfited by the violence of the charge, they turned their backs; and either there would have been a dreadful slaughter of the flying enemy, or a rash and dangerous effort on the part of the pursuers, had not Marcius promptly given the signal for retreat, and by throwing himself in the way of the front rank, and even holding some back with his own hands, repressed the infuriated troops. He then led them back to the camp, still eager for blood and slaughter. When the Carthaginians, who were at first compelled to fly with precipitation from the rampart of their enemy, saw that no one pursued them, concluding that they had stopped from fear, now on the other hand went away to their camp at an easy pace, with feelings of contempt for the enemy. There was a corresponding want of care in guarding their camp; for though the enemy were near, yet it seemed that they were but the remains of the two armies which had been cut to pieces a few days before. As in consequence of this all things were neglected in the enemy's camp, Marcius having ascertained this, addressed his mind to a measure which on the first view of it might appear rather rash than bold: it was, aggressively to assault the enemy's camp, concluding that the camp of Hasdrubal, while alone, might be carried with less difficulty than his own could be defended, if the three armies and as many generals should again unite; taking into consideration also that either if he succeeded he would retrieve their prostrate fortune, or if repulsed, still, by making the attack himself, he would rescue himself from contempt.

When it seemed that the Roman armies were completely destroyed and Spain was lost, one man turned the situation around. There was a soldier named Lucius Marcius, the son of Septimus, a Roman knight—a resourceful young man who was far more capable than his humble beginnings. He had been trained under Cneius Scipio, where he learned all the skills needed to be a soldier over several years. This man gathered the troops scattered during the flight and recruited some from nearby garrisons, forming a respectable army and joining forces with Titus Tonteius, the lieutenant-general of Publius Scipio. Marcius was so respected and honored among the troops that when they decided to elect a general from both armies in an assembly, while taking turns guarding the rampart and keeping watch until everyone had voted, they unanimously chose Lucius Marcius as their leader. The short time leading up to this was spent fortifying their camp and gathering supplies, with the soldiers not only following orders with energy but also with high spirits. However, when they learned that Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, was coming to finish the war and had crossed the Iberus, and when they saw the battle signal raised by a new commander, they remembered their previous leaders and the forces they used to fight with. Suddenly, they broke down in tears, some beating their heads, others raising their hands to the sky, blaming the gods, while some fell to the ground calling out the names of their former commanders. Their cries couldn’t be silenced, despite the centurions trying to rally their troops and Marcius himself urging them to stop their useless weeping and instead summon their courage to defend themselves and their country, rather than let their generals go unavenged. But suddenly, they heard a shout and the sound of trumpets, as the enemy approached the rampart. In an instant, their sorrow turned to fury, and they rushed to arms, charging at the enemy in a reckless and disorganized manner. This unexpected move terrified the Carthaginians, who were confused about where so many enemies had suddenly come from, since the army had seemed nearly wiped out. They were left wondering what could inspire these defeated men with such boldness and confidence; who could possibly lead them now that the two Scipios were dead; who had given the signal for battle. In light of these surprising circumstances, the Carthaginians first hesitated in shock, then, overwhelmed by the ferocity of the charge, they turned and fled. Whether there would have been a terrible slaughter of the retreating enemy or a reckless and dangerous pursuit by their enemies, it wouldn't have happened had Marcius not quickly signaled for retreat, standing in front of the first rank and even holding some of them back with his own hands to calm down the frenzied troops. He then led them back to the camp, still eager for bloodshed. When the Carthaginians, who initially fled in a panic from their enemies’ rampart, saw no one was chasing them and assumed it was due to fear, they leisurely returned to their camp with a sense of contempt for their enemies. Their guard was slack as well, since even though the enemy was nearby, they thought it was just the remnants of the two armies that had been crushed a few days before. Because of this neglect in the enemy's camp, Marcius realized this and decided on a move that might seem rash at first glance: he planned to aggressively attack the enemy's camp, thinking it would be easier to take Hasdrubal’s camp while it was isolated than to defend his own if the three armies and generals joined forces again. He also considered that if he succeeded, he would restore their fortunes, and if he was turned back, at least by making the attack himself, he would avoid being looked down upon.

38

Lest, however, the suddenness of the affair, and the fear of night, should frustrate a measure which was in itself ill adapted to his condition, he thought it right that his soldiers should be addressed and exhorted; and having called an assembly, he discoursed as follows: "Soldiers, either my veneration for our late commanders, both living and dead, or our present situation, may impress on every one the belief that this command, as it is highly honourable to me, conferred by your suffrages, so is it in its nature a heavy and anxious charge. For at a time when I should be scarcely so far master of myself as to be able to find any solace for my afflicted mind, did not fear deaden the sense of sorrow, I am compelled to take upon myself alone the task of consulting for the good of you all; a task of the greatest difficulty when under the influence of grief. And not even at that critical moment, when I ought to be considering in what manner I may be enabled to keep together for my country these remains of two armies, can I divert my mind from the affliction which incessantly preys upon me. For bitter recollection is ever present, and the Scipios ever disturb me with anxious cares by day and dreams by night, frequently rousing me from my sleep, and imploring me not to suffer themselves nor their soldiers, your companions in war, who had been victorious in this country for eight years, nor the commonwealth to remain unrevenged; enjoining me also to follow their discipline and their plans; and desiring that as there was no one more obedient to their commands while they were alive than I, so after their death I would consider that conduct as best, which I might have the strongest reason for believing they would have adopted in each case. I could wish also that you, my soldiers, should not show your respect for them by lamentations and tears, as if they were dead; (for they still live and flourish in the fame of their achievements;) but that whenever the memory of those men shall occur to you, you would go into battle as though you saw them encouraging you and giving you the signal. Nor certainly could anything else than their image presenting itself yesterday to your eyes and minds, have enabled you to fight that memorable battle, in which you proved to the enemy that the Roman name had not become extinct with the Scipios; and that the energy and valour of that people, which had not been overwhelmed by the disaster at Cannae, would, doubtlessly, emerge from the severest storms of fortune. Now since you have dared so much of your own accord, I have a mind to try how much you will dare when authorized by your general: for yesterday, when I gave the signal for retreat while you were pursuing the routed enemy with precipitation, I did not wish to break your spirit, but to reserve it for greater glory and more advantageous opportunities; that you might afterwards, when prepared and armed, seize an occasion of attacking your enemy while off their guard, unarmed, and even buried in sleep. Nor do I entertain the hope of gaining an opportunity of this kind rashly, but from the actual state of things. Doubtless, if any one should ask even himself, by what means, though few in number and disheartened by defeat, you defended your camp against troops superior in number and victorious, you would give no other answer than that, as this was the very thing you were afraid of, you had kept every place secured by works and yourselves ready and equipped. And so it generally happens: men are least secure against that which fortune causes not to be feared; because you leave unguarded and exposed what you think is not necessary to be cared about. There is nothing whatever which the enemy fear less at the present time, than lest we, who were a little while ago besieged and assaulted, should aggressively assault their camp ourselves. Let us dare, then, to do that which it is incredible we should have the courage to attempt; it will be most easy from the very fact of its appearing most difficult. At the third watch of the night I will lead you thither in silence. I have ascertained by means of scouts that they have no regular succession of watches, no proper outposts. Our shout at their gates, when heard, and the first assault, will carry their camp. Then let that carnage be made among men, torpid with sleep, terrified at the unexpected tumult, and overpowered while lying defenceless in their beds, from which you were so grieved to be recalled yesterday. I know that the measure appears to you a daring one; but in difficult and almost desperate circumstances the boldest counsels are always the safest. For if when the critical moment has arrived, the opportunity of seizing which is of a fleeting nature, you delay ever so little, in vain do you seek for it afterwards when it has been neglected. One army is near us; two more are not far off. We have some hopes if we make an attack now; and you have already made trial of your own and their strength. If we postpone the time and cease to be despised in consequence of the fame of yesterday's irruption, there is danger lest all the generals and all the forces should unite. Shall we be able then to withstand three generals and three armies, whom Cneius Scipio with his army unimpaired could not withstand? As our generals have perished by dividing their forces, so the enemy may be overpowered while separated and divided. There is no other mode of maintaining the war; let us, therefore, wait for nothing but the opportunity of the ensuing night. Now depart, with the favour of the gods, and refresh yourselves, that, unfatigued and vigorous, you may burst into the enemy's camp with the same spirit with which you have defended your own." This new enterprise, proposed by their new general, they received with joy; and the more daring it was the more it pleased them. The remainder of the day was spent in getting their arms in readiness and recruiting their strength, the greater part of the night was given to rest, and at the fourth watch they were in motion.

Lest the abruptness of the situation and the fear of night should mess up a plan that wasn't well-suited to his state, he thought it was right to address and encourage his soldiers. He called an assembly and spoke as follows: "Soldiers, either my respect for our past commanders, both living and dead, or our current situation, may lead everyone to believe that this command, which is an incredible honor for me, conferred by your support, also comes with a heavy and anxious responsibility. At a time when I should barely have control over myself to find any comfort for my troubled mind, if fear didn't numb my sense of sorrow, I'm forced to take on the task of looking out for your well-being all on my own; a task that's incredibly difficult when overwhelmed with grief. And not even at this critical moment, when I should be figuring out how to unite these remnants of two armies for our country, can I shift my focus from the pain that constantly consumes me. Bitter memories are always present, and the Scipios constantly haunt me with worries by day and dreams by night, often waking me from my sleep, urging me not to let them or their soldiers, your fellow fighters who triumphed in this land for eight years, or the state remain unavenged. They also command me to follow their discipline and strategies; and they desire that, just as there was no one more obedient to their orders while they were alive than I, so after their death, I should consider that conduct as best which I have the strongest reason to believe they would have chosen in each case. I also wish that you, my soldiers, wouldn’t show your respect for them with lamentations and tears, as if they were truly dead; (for they still live and thrive in the glory of their achievements); but that whenever the memory of those men comes to mind, you would head into battle as if you could see them encouraging you and signaling you on. Nothing else could have allowed you to fight that memorable battle yesterday, proving to the enemy that the Roman name hadn't perished with the Scipios; and that the strength and courage of our people, which had not been crushed by the disaster at Cannae, would surely rise from the harshest storms of fortune. Now since you've dared so much on your own, I want to see how much you're willing to risk when backed by your general: for yesterday, when I signaled for a retreat while you were rushing after the fleeing enemy, I didn't intend to break your spirit but to save it for greater glory and better opportunities; so you could later, when prepared and equipped, take your chance to strike the enemy when they are off guard, unprepared, and perhaps even asleep. And I don’t expect to gain such an opportunity recklessly, but based on the actual circumstances. If anyone were to ask themselves how, despite being fewer in number and discouraged by defeat, you defended your camp against troops that were larger and victorious, you would answer that, because this was precisely what you feared, you had secured every place and prepared yourselves. And it usually happens that people are least protected against what fortune doesn't make them afraid of; because you leave unguarded and vulnerable those things you think don’t need attention. There is nothing the enemy fears less right now, than that we, who were just besieged and attacked, should launch our own assault on their camp. So let's be bold and try something that seems incredible for us to even attempt; it will be easier simply because it looks so challenging. At the third watch of the night, I will lead you there quietly. I've confirmed through scouts that they have no regular guard shifts and no proper sentries. Our shout at their gates, when heard, and the first attack will take their camp. Let that slaughter occur among men, sluggish with sleep, frightened by the unexpected noise, and overwhelmed while lying defenseless in their beds, from which you were so reluctant to be pulled away yesterday. I know this plan seems daring to you; but in tough and nearly desperate times, the boldest strategies are often the safest. For when the critical moment arrives, and the chance to take it is fleeting, if you hesitate even a little, you’ll find it’s gone when you look for it later. One army is close to us; two more aren’t far off. We have some hopes if we strike now; and you've already tested your strength against theirs. If we delay and lose the advantage from yesterday's attack, we risk all the generals and all the troops coming together. Will we really be able to withstand three commanders and three armies that Cneius Scipio couldn’t handle with his intact army? Just as our generals fell by splitting their forces, the enemy can be overwhelmed when separated and divided. There’s no other way to keep the war going; let’s therefore wait for nothing but the opportunity of the coming night. Now go, with the favor of the gods, and recover your strength, so that, fresh and vigorous, you can burst into the enemy's camp with the same spirit you used to defend your own." This new venture, suggested by their new general, was received with joy; and the more audacious it seemed, the more it thrilled them. The rest of the day was spent preparing their arms and regaining their energy, most of the night was for resting, and at the fourth watch, they were on the move.

39

At a distance of six miles beyond their nearest camp lay other forces of the Carthaginians. A deep valley, thickly planted with trees, intervened. Near about the middle of this wood a Roman cohort and some cavalry were placed in concealment with Punic craft. The communication between the two armies being thus cut off, the rest of the forces were marched in silence to the nearest body of the enemy; and as there were no outposts before the gates, and no guards on the rampart, they entered quite into the camp, as though it had been their own, no one any where opposing them. The signals were then sounded and a shout raised. Some put the enemy to the sword when half asleep; others threw fire upon the huts, which were covered in with dry straw; others blocked up the gates to intercept their escape. The enemy, who were assailed at once with fire, shouting, and the sword, were in a manner bereaved of their senses, and could neither hear each other, nor take any measures for their security. Unarmed, they fell into the midst of troops of armed men: some hastened to the gates; others, as the passes were flocked up, leaped over the rampart, and as each escaped they fled directly towards the other camp, where they were cut off by the cohort and cavalry rushing forward from their concealment, and were all slain to a man. And even had any escaped from that carnage, the Romans, after taking the nearer camp, ran over to the other with such rapidity, that no one could have arrived before them with news of the disaster. In this camp, as they were far distant from the enemy, and as some had gone off just before daylight for forage, wood, and plunder, they found every thing in a still more neglected and careless state. Their arms only were placed at the outposts, the men being unarmed, and either sitting and reclining upon the ground, or else walking up and down before the rampart and the gates. On these men, thus at their ease and unguarded, the Romans, still hot from the recent battle, and flushed with victory, commenced an attack; no effectual opposition therefore could be made to them in the gates. Within the gates, the troops having rushed together from every part of the camp at the first shout and alarm, a furious conflict arose; which would have continued for a long time, had not the bloody appearance of the Roman shields discovered to the Carthaginians the defeat of the other forces, and consequently struck them with dismay. This alarm produced a general flight; and all except those who were overtaken with the sword, rushing out precipitately wherever they could find a passage, abandoned their camp. Thus, in a night and a day, two camps of the enemy were carried, under the conduct of Lucius Marcius. Claudius, who translated the annals of Acilius out of Greek into Latin, states that as many as thirty-seven thousand men were slain, one thousand eight hundred and thirty made prisoners, and a great booty obtained; among which was a silver shield of a hundred and thirty-eight pounds' weight, with an image upon it of the Barcine Hasdrubal. Valerius Antias states, that the camp Of Mago only was captured, and seven thousand of the enemy slain; and that in the other battle, when the Romans sallied out and fought with Hasdrubal, ten thousand were slain, and four thousand three hundred captured. Piso writes, that five thousand were slain in an ambuscade when Mago incautiously pursued our troops who retired. With all, the name of the general, Marcius, is mentioned with great honour, and to his real glory they add even miracles. They say, that while he was haranguing his men a stream of fire poured from his head without his perceiving it, to the great terror of the surrounding soldiers; and that a shield, called the Marcian, with an image of Hasdrubal upon it, remained in the temple up to the time of the burning of the Capitol, a monument of his victory over the Carthaginians. After this, affairs continued for a considerable time in a tranquil state in Spain, as both parties, after giving and receiving such important defeats, hesitated to run the hazard of a general battle.

At a distance of six miles beyond their nearest camp lay other forces of the Carthaginians. A deep valley, thickly planted with trees, was in between. Around the middle of this forest, a Roman cohort and some cavalry were hiding, using Punic tactics. With the communication between the two armies cut off, the rest of the forces quietly marched to the nearest enemy position; since there were no outposts before the gates and no guards on the rampart, they entered the camp as if it were their own, with no one opposing them. The signals were then sounded, and a loud shout was raised. Some killed the enemy while they were still half asleep; others set fire to the huts, which were covered in dry straw; others blocked the gates to stop their escape. The enemy, attacked all at once with fire, shouting, and swords, were in shock and couldn’t hear each other or organize a defense. Unarmed, they found themselves surrounded by armed troops: some rushed to the gates; others, seeing the exits blocked, jumped over the rampart, but as each escaped, they fled straight to the other camp, where they were intercepted by the cohort and cavalry coming from their hiding spots, and they were all killed. Even if any had escaped that massacre, the Romans, having taken the nearer camp, quickly moved to the other one with such speed that no one could have alerted them about the disaster in time. In this camp, since they were far from the enemy and some had just gone out at daybreak to gather supplies and loot, everything was left in an even more neglected state. Only their weapons were at the outposts, while the men were unarmed, either sitting or walking around in front of the rampart and gates. The Romans, still hot from their recent victory, launched an attack on these relaxed and unguarded men; as a result, no effective resistance could be made at the gates. Inside the camp, the troops, having rushed together from all corners at the first sound of alarm, engaged in a fierce battle; this would have gone on for a long time if the bloody sight of the Roman shields hadn’t revealed to the Carthaginians the defeat of their other forces, which struck them with fear. This panic caused a mass flight; everyone except those who were caught and killed fled wherever they could find an opening, abandoning their camp. Thus, in just one night and a day, two enemy camps were taken under the leadership of Lucius Marcius. Claudius, who translated Acilius' annals from Greek into Latin, reports that around thirty-seven thousand men were killed, one thousand eight hundred and thirty were captured, and a large amount of loot was seized; among it was a silver shield weighing a hundred and thirty-eight pounds, featuring an image of Hasdrubal. Valerius Antias claims that only Mago’s camp was captured, with seven thousand enemy slain; and in the other battle, when the Romans charged out and fought Hasdrubal, ten thousand were killed and four thousand three hundred captured. Piso writes that five thousand were killed in an ambush when Mago foolishly pursued our retreating troops. Regardless, the name of the general, Marcius, is greatly honored, and to his real glory, even miracles are added. They say that while he was speaking to his men, a stream of fire poured from his head without him noticing, causing great fear among the surrounding soldiers; and that a shield, called the Marcian, with an image of Hasdrubal on it, remained in the temple up until the burning of the Capitol as a monument to his victory over the Carthaginians. After this, things stayed calm in Spain for a considerable time, as both sides, having suffered significant defeats, hesitated to risk a general battle.

40

During these transactions in Spain, Marcellus, after the capture of Syracuse, having settled the other affairs in Sicily with so much honour and integrity as not only to add to his own renown, but also to the majesty of the Roman people, conveyed to Rome the ornaments of the city, together with the statues and pictures with which Syracuse abounded. These were certainly spoils taken from enemies, and acquired according to the laws of war; but hence was the origin of the admiration of the products of Grecian art, and to that freedom with which at present all places, both sacred and profane, are despoiled; which at last recoiled upon the Roman gods, and first upon that very temple which was so choicely adorned by Marcellus. For foreigners were in the habit of visiting the temples dedicated by Marcellus near the Capuan gate, on account of their splendid ornaments of this description, of which a very small portion can be found. Embassies from almost all the states of Sicily came to him. As their cases were different, so were also the terms granted to them. Those who had either not revolted or had returned to the alliance before the capture of Syracuse, were received and honoured as faithful allies. Those who had been induced to submit through fear after the capture of Syracuse, as vanquished, received laws from the conqueror. The Romans, however, had still remaining a war of no small magnitude at Agrigentum, headed by Epicydes and Hanno, generals in the late war, and a third new one sent by Hannibal in the room of Hippocrates, a Libyphoenician by nation, and a native of Hippo, called by his countrymen Mutines; an energetic man, and thoroughly instructed in all the arts of war under the tuition of Hannibal. To this man the Numidian auxiliaries were assigned by Epicydes and Hanno. With these he so thoroughly overran the lands of his enemies, and visited his allies with such activity, in order to retain them in their allegiance, and for the purpose of bringing them seasonable aid as each required it, that in a short time he filled all Sicily with his fame, nor was greater confidence placed in any one else by those who favoured the Carthaginian interest. Accordingly the Carthaginian and Syracusan generals, who had been hitherto compelled to keep within the walls of Agrigentum, not more at the advice of Mutines than from the confidence they reposed in him, had the courage to go out from the walls, and pitched a camp near the river Himera. When this was announced to Marcellus, he immediately advanced and sat down at a distance of about four miles from the enemy, with the intention of waiting to see what steps they took, and what they meditated. But Mutines allowed no room or time for delay or deliberation, but crossed the river, and, charging the outposts of his enemy, created the greatest terror and confusion. The next day, in an engagement which might almost be called regular, he compelled his enemy to retire within their works. Being called away by a mutiny of the Numidians, which had broken out in the camp, and in which about three hundred of them had retired to Heraclea Minoa, he set out to appease them and bring them back; and is said to have earnestly warned the generals not to engage with the enemy during his absence. Both the generals were indignant at this conduct, but particularly Hanno, who was before disturbed at his reputation. "Is it to be borne," said he, "that a mongrel African should impose restraints upon me, a Carthaginian general, commissioned by the senate and people?" Epicydes, who wished to wait, was prevailed upon by him to agree to their crossing the river and offering battle; for, said he, if they should wait for Mutines, and the battle should terminate successfully, Mutines would certainly have the credit of it.

During these events in Spain, Marcellus, after taking Syracuse, having handled other matters in Sicily with such honor and integrity that it not only added to his own fame but also to the reputation of the Roman people, brought back to Rome the treasures of the city, along with the statues and paintings that Syracuse was known for. These were indeed spoils taken from enemies, obtained according to the rules of war; but this led to the admiration for the works of Grecian art, and to the unrestricted way in which today all spaces, both sacred and secular, are plundered; which ultimately fell back on the Roman gods, and first impacted that very temple which was so beautifully adorned by Marcellus. Foreigners often visited the temples dedicated by Marcellus near the Capuan gate due to their impressive decorative elements, of which only a very small part remains. Delegations from almost all the states of Sicily came to him. As their situations were different, so were the terms granted to them. Those who had either not rebelled or had returned to the alliance before the capture of Syracuse were welcomed and honored as loyal allies. Those who were forced to submit out of fear after the capture of Syracuse were treated as conquered and received laws from the conqueror. However, the Romans still faced a significant war in Agrigentum, led by Epicydes and Hanno, generals from the recent conflict, and a new leader sent by Hannibal to replace Hippocrates, a Libyphoenician from Hippo, known as Mutines; a determined man, well-versed in all the tactics of war taught by Hannibal. This man was given the Numidian auxiliaries by Epicydes and Hanno. With them, he aggressively ravaged the lands of his enemies and actively connected with his allies to maintain their loyalty and provide timely assistance as needed, so that in a short time he filled all of Sicily with his reputation, and those who supported the Carthaginian cause placed greater confidence in him than anyone else. Consequently, the Carthaginian and Syracusan generals, who had been forced to stay within the walls of Agrigentum, encouraged by Mutines and trusting in his leadership, dared to venture out of the walls and set up a camp near the river Himera. When this reached Marcellus, he quickly moved and positioned himself about four miles from the enemy, planning to observe their actions and intentions. But Mutines gave no time for hesitation or discussion; he crossed the river and attacked the enemy's outposts, causing significant panic and chaos. The next day, in an almost formal battle, he forced his opponents to retreat within their fortifications. He was then called away to address a mutiny of the Numidians that had erupted in the camp, with about three hundred of them fleeing to Heraclea Minoa; he went to calm them and bring them back, and was said to have earnestly warned the generals not to engage with the enemy while he was gone. Both generals were upset by this, especially Hanno, who was already troubled about his reputation. "Can we allow," he said, "a mixed-breed African to impose limitations on me, a Carthaginian general, appointed by the senate and people?" Epicydes, who wanted to hold off, was persuaded by him to agree to cross the river and fight; for, he said, if they waited for Mutines and the battle ended successfully, Mutines would certainly take the credit.

41

But Marcellus, highly indignant that he who had repulsed Hannibal from Nola, when rendered confident by his victory at Cannae, should succumb to enemies whom he had vanquished by sea and land, ordered his soldiers immediately to take arms and raise the standards. While marshalling his army, ten Numidians rode up rapidly from the enemy's line with information that their countrymen, first induced by the same causes which brought on the mutiny, in which three hundred of their number retired to Heraclea, and secondly, because they saw their commander, just on the approach of a battle, sent out of the way by generals who wished to detract from his glory, would not take any part in the battle. This deceitful nation made good their promise in this instance. Accordingly the spirits of the Romans were increased by the intelligence, which was speedily conveyed through the lines, that the enemy were abandoned by the cavalry, which the Romans principally feared; while at the same time the enemy were dispirited, not only because they were deprived of the principal part of their strength, but further, because they were afraid lest they should themselves be attacked by their own cavalry. Accordingly, there was no great resistance made: the first shout and onset determined the business. The Numidians who stood quiet in the wings during the action, when they saw their party turning their backs, accompanied them in their flight only for a short time; but when they perceived that they were all making for Agrigentum with the most violent haste, they turned off to the neighbouring towns round about, through fear of a siege. Many thousand men were slain and captured, together with eight elephants. This was the last battle which Marcellus fought in Sicily, after which he returned victorious to Syracuse. The year was now about closing; the senate therefore decreed that Publius Cornelius, the praetor, should send a letter to Capua to the consuls, with directions that while Hannibal was at a distance, and nothing of any great importance was going on at Capua, one of them, if they thought fit, should come to Rome to elect new magistrates. On the receipt of the letter, the consuls arranged it between themselves, that Claudius should hold the election, and Fulvius remain at Capua. The consuls created by Claudius were Cneius Fulvius Centumalus, and Publius Sulpicius Galba, the son of Servius, who had never exercised any curule magistracy. After this Lucius Cornelius Lentulus, Marcus Cornelius Cethegus, Caius Sulpicius, and Caius Calpurnius Piso, were created praetors. Piso had the city jurisdiction; Sulpicius, Sicily; Cethegus, Apulia; Lentulus, Sardinia. The consuls were continued in command for a year longer.

But Marcellus, furious that he had pushed Hannibal out of Nola, when he was feeling confident because of his victory at Cannae, should yield to enemies he had already defeated by land and sea, ordered his soldiers to grab their weapons and raise the standards. While organizing his army, ten Numidians rode up quickly from the enemy’s line with news that their fellow countrymen, first motivated by the same reasons that led to the mutiny—where three hundred of them retreated to Heraclea—and secondly, seeing their commander sidelined just before a battle by generals who wanted to steal his glory, would not take part in the fight. This deceptive nation kept their promise this time. As a result, the spirits of the Romans were lifted by the news, which spread quickly through the ranks, that the enemy had lost their cavalry, the part they feared the most; meanwhile, the enemy was demoralized, not only because they lost a major part of their strength but also because they were scared they might be attacked by their own cavalry. Thus, there wasn’t much resistance: the first shout and charge decided the outcome. The Numidians who stayed back during the fight, when they saw their side fleeing, followed them for a short distance; but when they noticed that everyone was rushing toward Agrigentum in a panic, they diverted to nearby towns out of fear of a siege. Many thousands were killed and captured, along with eight elephants. This was the last battle Marcellus fought in Sicily before he returned victorious to Syracuse. The year was coming to a close; therefore, the senate decided that Publius Cornelius, the praetor, should send a letter to Capua to the consuls, instructing that, while Hannibal was away and nothing major was happening in Capua, one of them, if they saw fit, should go to Rome to elect new magistrates. Upon receiving the letter, the consuls agreed that Claudius would conduct the election while Fulvius stayed in Capua. The consuls appointed by Claudius were Cneius Fulvius Centumalus and Publius Sulpicius Galba, the son of Servius, who had never held any curule magistracy. After that, Lucius Cornelius Lentulus, Marcus Cornelius Cethegus, Caius Sulpicius, and Caius Calpurnius Piso were named praetors. Piso was responsible for city jurisdiction; Sulpicius for Sicily; Cethegus for Apulia; and Lentulus for Sardinia. The consuls were allowed to remain in command for another year.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXVI.
B.C 212-211


Hannibal encamps on the banks of the Amo, within three miles of Rome. Attended by two thousand horsemen, he advances close to the Colline gate to take a view of the walls and situation of the city. On two successive days the hostile armies are hindered from engaging by the severity of the weather. Capua taken by Quintus Fulvius and Appius Claudius, the chief nobles die, voluntarily, by poison. Quintus Fulvius having condemned the principal senators to death, at the moment they are actually tied to the stakes, receives despatches from Rome, commanding him to spare their lives, which he postpones reading until the sentence is executed. Publius Scipio, offering himself for the service, is sent to command in Spain, takes New Carthage in one day. Successes in Sicily. Treaty of friendship with the Aetolians. War with Philip, king of Macedonia, and the Acarnanians.

       *        *        *        *        *

1

The consuls, Cneius Fulvius Centumalus and Publius Sulpicius Galba, having entered on their office on the ides of March, assembled the senate in the Capitol, and took the opinion of the fathers on the state of the republic, the manner of conducting the war, and on what related to the provinces and the armies. Quintus Fulvius and Appius Claudius, the consuls of the former year, were continued in command; and the armies which they before had were assigned to them, it being added that they should not withdraw from Capua, which they were besieging, till they had taken it. The Romans were now solicitously intent upon this object, not from resentment so much, which was never juster against any city, as from the consideration that as this city, so celebrated and powerful, had by its defection drawn away several states, so when reduced it would bring back their minds to respect for the former supreme government. Two praetors also of the former year, Marcus Junius and Publius Sempronius, were each continued in command of the two legions which they had under them, the former in Etruria, the latter in Gaul. Marcus Marcellus also was continued in command, that he might, as proconsul, finish the war in Sicily with the army he had there. If he wanted recruits he was to take them from the legions which Publius Cornelius, the propraetor, commanded in Sicily, provided he did not choose any soldier who was of the number of those whom the senate had refused to allow to be discharged, or to return home till the war was put an end to. To Caius Sulpicius, to whose lot Sicily had fallen, the two legions which Publius Cornelius had commanded were assigned, to be recruited from the army of Cneius Fulvius, which had been shamefully beaten, and had experienced a dreadful loss the year before in Apulia. To soldiers of this description the senate had assigned the same period of service as to those who fought at Cannae; and as an additional mark of ignominy upon both, they were not allowed to winter in towns, or to build huts for wintering within the distance of ten miles from any town. To Lucius Cornelius, in Sardinia, the two legions which Quintus Mucius had commanded were assigned; if recruits were wanted, the consuls were ordered to enlist them. To Titus Otacilius and Marcus Valerius was allotted the protection of the coasts of Sicily and Greece, with the legions and fleets which they had commanded. The Greek coast had fifty ships with one legion; the Sicilian, a hundred ships with two legions. Twenty-three legions were employed by the Romans in carrying on the war this year by land and sea.

The consuls, Cneius Fulvius Centumalus and Publius Sulpicius Galba, took office on the Ides of March and gathered the Senate at the Capitol to discuss the state of the republic, the conduct of the war, and issues related to the provinces and the armies. Quintus Fulvius and Appius Claudius, the consuls from the previous year, were kept in command, and they retained their armies with the added instruction that they should not leave Capua, which they were besieging, until it was captured. The Romans were intensely focused on this goal, not just from anger—which was fully justified against any city—but also because the defection of such a celebrated and powerful city had swayed several states, and recapturing it would restore respect for the former supreme government. Two praetors from the previous year, Marcus Junius and Publius Sempronius, were each retained to command the two legions they had, with Junius in Etruria and Sempronius in Gaul. Marcus Marcellus was also kept in command to finish the war in Sicily as proconsul with the army he had there. If he needed recruits, he was to take them from the legions commanded by Publius Cornelius, the propraetor, in Sicily, but he could not choose any soldiers who the Senate had forbidden to be discharged or to return home until the war was over. Caius Sulpicius, whose assignment was Sicily, received the two legions previously commanded by Publius Cornelius, to be reinforced by soldiers from Cneius Fulvius's army, which had suffered a significant defeat the year before in Apulia. The Senate assigned these soldiers the same length of service as those who fought at Cannae, and as an additional humiliation, they were not allowed to winter in towns or build huts within ten miles of any town. Lucius Cornelius, in Sardinia, received the two legions that Quintus Mucius had commanded, and if recruits were needed, the consuls were instructed to enlist them. Titus Otacilius and Marcus Valerius were assigned to protect the coasts of Sicily and Greece with the legions and fleets they had commanded. The Greek coast had fifty ships with one legion; the Sicilian coast had one hundred ships with two legions. This year, the Romans deployed twenty-three legions to conduct the war by land and sea.

2

In the beginning of the year, on a letter from Lucius Marcius being laid before the senate, they considered his achievements as most glorious; but the title of honour which he assumed (for though he was neither invested with the command by the order of the people, nor by the direction of the fathers, his letter ran in this form, "The propraetor to the senate") gave offence to a great many. It was considered as an injurious precedent for generals to be chosen by the armies, and for the solemn ceremony of elections, held under auspices, to be transferred to camps and provinces, and (far from the control of the laws and magistrates) to military thoughtlessness. And though some gave it as their opinion, that the sense of the senate should be taken on the matter, yet it was thought more advisable that the discussion should be postponed till after the departure of the horsemen who brought the letter from Marcius. It was resolved, that an answer should be returned respecting the corn and clothing of the army, stating, that the senate would direct its attention to both those matters; but that the letter should not be addressed to Lucius Marcius, propraetor, lest he should consider that as already determined which was the very point they reserved for discussion. After the horsemen were dismissed, it was the first thing the consuls brought before the senate; and the opinions of all to a man coincided, that the plebeian tribunes should be instructed to consult the commons with all possible speed, as to whom they might resolve to send into Spain to take the command of that army which had been under the conduct of Cneius Scipio. The plebeian tribunes were instructed accordingly, and the question was published. But another contest had pre-engaged the minds of the people: Caius Sempronius Blaesus, having brought Cneius Fulvius to trial for the loss of the army in Apulia, harassed him with invectives in the public assemblies: "Many generals," he reiterated, "had by indiscretion and ignorance brought their armies into most perilous situations, but none, save Cneius Fulvius, had corrupted his legions by every species of excess before he betrayed them to the enemy; it might therefore with truth be said, that they were lost before they saw the enemy, and that they were defeated, not by Hannibal, but by their own general. No man, when he gave his vote, took sufficient pains in ascertaining who it was to whom he was intrusting an army. What a difference was there between this man and Tiberius Sempronius! The latter having been intrusted with an army of slaves, had in a short time brought it to pass, by discipline and authority, that not one of them in the field of battle remembered his condition and birth, but they became a protection to our allies and a terror to our enemies. They had snatched, as it were, from the very jaws of Hannibal, and restored to the Roman people, Cumae, Beneventum, and other towns. But Cneius Fulvius had infected with the vices peculiar to slaves, an army of Roman citizens, of honourable parentage and liberal education; and had thus made them insolent and turbulent among their allies, inefficient and dastardly among their enemies, unable to sustain, not only the charge, but the shout of the Carthaginians. But, by Hercules, it was no wonder that the troops did not stand their ground in the battle, when their general was the first to fly; with him, the greater wonder was that any had fallen at their posts, and that they were not all the companions of Cneius Fulvius in his consternation and his flight. Caius Flaminius, Lucius Paullus, Lucius Posthumius, Cneius and Publius Scipio, had preferred falling in the battle to abandoning their armies when in the power of the enemy. But Cneius Fulvius was almost the only man who returned to Rome to report the annihilation of his army. It was a shameful crime that the army of Cannae should be transported into Sicily, because they fled from the field of battle, and not be allowed to return till the enemy has quitted Italy; that the same decree should have been lately passed with respect to the legions of Cneius Fulvius; while Cneius Fulvius himself has no punishment inflicted upon him for running away, in a battle brought about by his own indiscretion; that he himself should be permitted to pass his old age in stews and brothels, where he passed his youth, while his troops, whose only crime was that they resembled their general, should be sent away in a manner into banishment, and suffer an ignominious service. So unequally," he said, "was liberty shared at Rome by the rich and the poor, by the ennobled and the common people."

At the start of the year, when a letter from Lucius Marcius was presented to the senate, they viewed his accomplishments as highly admirable. However, the honorific title he claimed (even though he had not been given authority by the people or the senate, as his letter stated, "The propraetor to the senate") upset many. It was seen as a harmful precedent for generals to be appointed by their armies, moving the formal election process, traditionally held under auspices, to camps and provinces, beyond the reach of laws and magistrates, falling into military recklessness. Although some suggested that the senate should express its opinion on the matter, it was decided it would be better to postpone the discussion until after the horsemen who delivered Marcius's letter had left. They resolved to respond regarding the army's supplies and clothing, indicating that the senate would address both matters, but they would not address Lucius Marcius as propraetor, so he wouldn’t think that the very issue they wanted to discuss was already settled. After dismissing the horsemen, the first topic the consuls presented to the senate was that all members agreed the plebeian tribunes should swiftly consult the public about who to send to Spain to take command of the army that had been under Cneius Scipio. The plebeian tribunes acted accordingly, and the issue was announced. However, the public was already focused on another matter: Caius Sempronius Blaesus had put Cneius Fulvius on trial for the loss of the army in Apulia, attacking him with harsh words in public meetings. "Many generals," he repeated, "have put their armies in extremely dangerous positions due to carelessness and ignorance, but none, except Cneius Fulvius, have corrupted their legions with all kinds of excess before handing them over to the enemy; it could be truthfully said that they were doomed before they faced the enemy, defeated not by Hannibal, but by their own general. No one, when voting, took enough care to know whom they were trusting with an army. What a difference there was between this man and Tiberius Sempronius! The latter, entrusted with an army of slaves, managed, through discipline and authority, to ensure that not one of them remembered their origins in battle; they became a defense for our allies and a nightmare for our enemies. They had seemingly pulled back from the jaws of Hannibal and returned Cumae, Beneventum, and other towns to the Roman people. But Cneius Fulvius had contaminated an army of Roman citizens, from respectable backgrounds and quality education, with the traits of slaves, making them arrogant and unruly among their allies, and cowardly and ineffective against their enemies, unable to withstand not just the charge, but even the shouts of the Carthaginians. By Hercules, it was no surprise that the troops didn’t hold their ground in battle when their general was the first to flee; it was astonishing that anyone stayed at their posts and that they weren’t all following Cneius Fulvius in his panic and retreat. Caius Flaminius, Lucius Paullus, Lucius Posthumius, Cneius, and Publius Scipio preferred to die in battle rather than abandon their armies to the enemy. Yet Cneius Fulvius was practically the only one who returned to Rome to report the destruction of his army. It was a disgrace that the army from Cannae should be moved to Sicily because they fled from battle and not allowed to return until the enemy left Italy; that a similar decree had recently been made regarding Cneius Fulvius’s legions while he received no punishment for running away from a battle he caused through his own foolishness, able to live out his old age in the brothels where he spent his youth, while his troops, whose only fault was mirroring their general, were effectively exiled and forced into disgraceful service. So unfairly," he said, "is freedom distributed in Rome among the rich and the poor, the elite and the common people."

3

The accused shifted the blame from himself to his soldiers; he said, "that in consequence of their having in the most turbulent manner demanded battle, they were led into the field, not on the day they desired, for it was then evening, but on the following; that they were drawn up at a suitable time and on favourable ground; but either the reputation or the strength of the enemy was such, that they were unable to stand their ground. When they all fled precipitately, he himself also was carried away with the crowd, as had happened to Varro at the battle of Cannae, and to many other generals. How could he, by his sole resistance, benefit the republic, unless his death would remedy the public disasters? that he was not defeated in consequence of a failure in his provisions; that he had not, from want of caution, been drawn into a disadvantageous position; that he had not been cut off by an ambuscade in consequence of not having explored his route, but had been vanquished by open force, and by arms, in a regular engagement. He had not in his power the minds of his own troops, or those of the enemy. Courage and cowardice were the result of each man's natural constitution." He was twice accused, and the penalty was laid at a fine. On the third accusation, at which witnesses were produced, he was not only overwhelmed with an infinity of disgraceful charges, but a great many asserted on oath, that the flight and panic commenced with the praetor, that the troops being deserted by him, and concluding that the fears of their general were not unfounded, turned their backs; when so strong a feeling of indignation was excited, that the assembly clamorously rejoined that he ought to be tried capitally. This gave rise to a new controversy; for when the tribune, who had twice prosecuted him as for a finable offence, now, on the third occasion, declared that he prosecuted him capitally; the tribunes of the commons being appealed to, said, "they would not prevent their colleague from proceeding, as he was permitted according to the custom of their ancestors, in the manner he himself preferred, whether according to the laws or to custom, until he had obtained judgment against a private individual, convicting him either of a capital or finable offence." Upon this, Sempronius said, that he charged Cneius Fulvius with the crime of treason; and requested Caius Calpurnius, the city praetor, to appoint a day for the comitia. Another ground of hope was then tried by the accused, viz. if his brother, Quintus Fulvius, could be present at his trial, who was at that time flourishing in the fame of his past achievements and in the near expectation of taking Capua. Fulvius wrote to the senate, requesting the favour in terms calculated to excite compassion, in order to save the life of his brother; but the fathers replied, that the interest of the state would not admit of his leaving Capua. Cneius Fulvius, therefore, before the day appointed for the comitia arrived, went into exile to Tarquinii, and the commons resolved that it was a legal exile.

The accused shifted the blame from himself to his soldiers; he said, "that because they had so aggressively demanded to fight, they were taken into battle, not on the day they wanted, since it was already evening, but the next day; that they were assembled at a proper time and on favorable ground; but either the enemy’s reputation or strength was such that they couldn’t hold their ground. When they all fled in a hurry, he too was swept away with the crowd, just like Varro at the Battle of Cannae, and many other generals. How could he, standing alone, help the republic, unless his death would fix the public issues? That he was not defeated due to a lack of supplies; that he had not, due to carelessness, been drawn into a bad position; that he had not been ambushed because he hadn’t scouted his route, but had been beaten by open force, and by arms, in a fair fight. He didn’t control the minds of his own troops or those of the enemy. Courage and cowardice depended on each individual's natural make-up." He was charged twice, and the penalty was a fine. On the third charge, with witnesses presented, he was not only hit with numerous disgraceful accusations, but many swore that the panic started with the praetor, that the troops, abandoned by him and believing their general's fears were justified, turned to flee; when this stirred such strong indignation that the crowd loudly demanded he should face a capital trial. This led to a new debate; for when the tribune, who had previously charged him with a finable offense, now proclaimed he was charging him capitally; the tribunes of the commons, being consulted, said, "they would not stop their colleague from proceeding, as he was allowed by the tradition of their forefathers, in the way he deemed fit, whether by law or custom, until he reached a verdict on a private individual, either convicting him of a capital or finable offense." Upon this, Sempronius stated that he was accusing Cneius Fulvius of treason; and asked Caius Calpurnius, the city praetor, to set a date for the assembly. Another glimmer of hope arose for the accused, specifically if his brother, Quintus Fulvius, could attend his trial, who was at that time enjoying the reputation of his past successes and was close to capturing Capua. Fulvius wrote to the senate, making a heartfelt plea to save his brother’s life; but the senators replied that the needs of the state did not allow him to leave Capua. Cneius Fulvius, therefore, before the appointed day for the assembly came, went into exile to Tarquinii, and the commons decided that it was a lawful exile.

4

Meanwhile all the strength of the war was directed against Capua. It was, however, more strictly blockaded than besieged. The slaves and populace could neither endure the famine, nor send messengers to Hannibal through guards so closely stationed. A Numidian was at length found, who, on undertaking to make his way with it, was charged with a letter; and going out by night, through the midst of the Roman camp, in order to fulfil his promise, he inspired the Campanians with confidence to try the effect of a sally from every quarter, while they had any strength remaining. In the many encounters which followed, their cavalry were generally successful, but their infantry were beaten: however, it was by no means so joyful to conquer, as it was miserable to be worsted in any respect by a besieged and almost subdued enemy. A plan was at length adopted, by which their deficiency in strength might be compensated by stratagem. Young men were selected from all the legions, who, from the vigour and activity of their bodies, excelled in swiftness; these were supplied with bucklers shorter than those worn by horsemen, and seven javelins each, four feet in length, and pointed with steel in the same manner as the spears used by light-armed troops. The cavalry taking one of these each upon their horses, accustomed them to ride behind them, and to leap down nimbly when the signal was given. When, by daily practice, they appeared to be able to do this in an orderly manner, they advanced into the plain between the camp and the walls, against the cavalry of the Campanians, who stood there prepared for action. As soon as they came within a dart's cast, on a signal given, the light troops leaped down, when a line of infantry formed out of the body of horse suddenly rushed upon the cavalry of the enemy, and discharged their javelins one after another with great rapidity; which being thrown in great numbers upon men and horses indiscriminately, wounded a great many. The sudden and unsuspected nature of the attack, however, occasioned still greater terror; and the cavalry charging them, thus panic-struck, chased them with great slaughter as far as their gates. From that time the Roman cavalry had the superiority; and it was established that there should be velites in the legions. It is said that Quintus Navius was the person who advised the mixing of infantry with cavalry, and that he received honour from the general on that account.

Meanwhile, all the military efforts were focused on Capua. However, it was more effectively blockaded than actually besieged. The slaves and the local population could neither withstand the famine nor send messages to Hannibal through the closely posted guards. Eventually, a Numidian was found who agreed to carry a letter. Taking the risk, he snuck out at night through the Roman camp to fulfill his promise, boosting the Campanians' confidence to attempt a breakout from every direction while they still had some strength left. In the multiple skirmishes that followed, their cavalry generally performed well, but their infantry was defeated. Yet, it was far less satisfying to win than it was distressing to be beaten by an enemy that was nearly overpowered. A strategy was eventually devised to make up for their lack of strength through clever tactics. Young men were chosen from all the legions for their agility and speed; they were armed with shorter shields than those used by cavalry and given seven javelins each, about four feet long, tipped with steel like those used by light infantry. Each cavalryman took one of these young men on their horse, training them to ride behind and quickly jump down when signaled. After daily practice, they managed to execute this maneuver in an organized way and moved into the open ground between the camp and the walls against the Campanian cavalry, who were ready for battle. As soon as they came within range, the light troops jumped down at the signal, and a line of infantry suddenly charged the enemy cavalry, launching their javelins in rapid succession. The sheer number of javelins, thrown indiscriminately at men and horses alike, caused significant injuries. The unexpected nature of the attack induced even greater panic, and the cavalry, now frightened, chased them down with devastating losses all the way to their gates. From that point on, the Roman cavalry gained the upper hand, and it was decided to include velites in the legions. It is said that Quintus Navius was the one who suggested integrating infantry with cavalry, earning him recognition from the general for his idea.

5

While affairs were in this state at Capua, Hannibal was perplexed between two objects, the gaining possession of the citadel of Tarentum, and the retaining of Capua. His concern for Capua, however, prevailed, on which he saw that the attention of every body, allies and enemies, was fixed; and whose fate would be regarded as a proof of the consequences resulting from defection from the Romans. Leaving therefore, a great part of his baggage among the Bruttians, and all his heavier armed troops, he took with him a body of infantry and cavalry, the best he could select for marching expeditiously, and bent his course into Campania. Rapidly as he marched he was followed by thirty-three elephants. He took up his position in a retired valley behind Mount Tifata, which overhung Capua. Having at his coming taken possession of fort Galatia, the garrison of which he dislodged by force, he then directed his efforts against those who were besieging Capua. Having sent forward messengers to Capua stating the time at which he would attack the Roman camp, in order that they also, having gotten themselves in readiness for a sally, might at the same time pour forth from all their gates, he occasioned the greatest possible terror; for on one side he himself attacked them suddenly, and on the other side all the Campanians sallied forth, both foot and horse, joined by the Carthaginian garrison under the command of Bostar and Hanno. The Romans, lest in so perilous an affair they should leave any part unprotected, by running together to any one place, thus divided their forces: Appius Claudius was opposed to the Campanians; Fulvius to Hannibal; Caius Nero, the propraetor, with the cavalry of the sixth legion, placed himself in the road leading to Suessula; and Caius Fulvius Flaccus, the lieutenant-general, with the allied cavalry, on the side opposite the river Vulturnus. The battle commenced not only with the usual clamour and tumult, but in addition to the din of men, horses, and arms, a multitude of Campanians, unable to bear arms, being distributed along the walls, raised such a shout together with the clangour of brazen vessels, similar to that which is usually made in the dead of night when the moon is eclipsed, that it diverted the attention even of the combatants. Appius easily repulsed the Campanians from the rampart. On the other side Hannibal and the Carthaginians, forming a larger force, pressed hard on Fulvius. There the sixth legion gave way; being repulsed, a cohort of Spaniards with three elephants made their way up to the rampart. They had broken through the centre of the Roman line, and were in a state of anxious and perilous suspense, whether to force their way into the camp, or be cut off from their own army. When Fulvius saw the disorder of the legion, and the danger the camp was in, he exhorted Quintus Navius, and the other principal centurions, to charge the cohort of the enemy which was fighting under the rampart; he said, "that the state of things was most critical; that either they must retire before them, in which case they would burst into the camp with less difficulty than they had experienced in breaking through a dense line of troops, or they must cut them to pieces under the rampart: nor would it require a great effort; for they were few, and cut off from their own troops, and if the line which appeared broken, now while the Romans were dispirited, should turn upon the enemy on both sides, they would become enclosed in the midst, and exposed to a twofold attack." Navius, on hearing these words of the general, snatched the standard of the second company of spearmen from the standard-bearer, and advanced with it against the enemy, threatening that he would throw it into the midst of them unless the soldiers promptly followed him and took part in the fight. He was of gigantic stature, and his arms set him off; the standard also, raised aloft, attracted the gaze both of his countrymen and the enemy. When, however, he had reached the standards of the Spaniards, javelins were poured upon him from all sides, and almost the whole line was turned against him; but neither the number of his enemies nor the force of the weapons could repel the onset of this hero.

While things were happening in Capua, Hannibal was torn between two goals: capturing the citadel of Tarentum and holding onto Capua. However, his worry for Capua won out because he realized that everyone, both allies and enemies, was focused on it; its fate would be seen as a sign of what happens when one defects from the Romans. So, he left a significant amount of his baggage with the Bruttians, as well as all his heavier armed troops. He took with him a group of infantry and cavalry, the best he could find for a quick march, and headed toward Campania. Even as he marched quickly, he was followed by thirty-three elephants. He settled in a secluded valley behind Mount Tifata, which loomed over Capua. Upon his arrival, he captured Fort Galatia, forcing out the garrison there, and then turned his attention to those besieging Capua. He sent messengers to Capua to inform them of the time he would attack the Roman camp, so they could prepare to burst forth from all their gates simultaneously, creating maximum chaos. On one side, he launched a surprise attack, while on the other, the Campanians rushed out, both foot soldiers and cavalry, joined by the Carthaginian garrison led by Bostar and Hanno. The Romans, afraid of being caught off guard, divided their forces instead of gathering in one place: Appius Claudius faced the Campanians; Fulvius confronted Hannibal; Caius Nero, the propraetor, with the cavalry of the sixth legion, took position on the road to Suessula; and Caius Fulvius Flaccus, the lieutenant-general, was stationed opposite the river Vulturnus. The battle kicked off not just with the usual noise and chaos, but also added to the clamor of men, horses, and weapons, a crowd of Campanians who couldn’t bear arms shouted from the walls, banging on bronze vessels, making a noise similar to what is heard in the dead of night during a lunar eclipse, which distracted even the soldiers fighting. Appius easily pushed the Campanians back from the rampart. On the other side, Hannibal and the Carthaginians, with their larger force, pressed hard against Fulvius. The sixth legion faltered; after being pushed back, a Spanish cohort with three elephants broke through the Roman line. They faced the critical choice of either storming into the camp or getting cut off from their own army. When Fulvius saw the chaos in the legion and the peril the camp was in, he urged Quintus Navius and other key centurions to charge the enemy cohort near the rampart. He stated, "The situation is dire; we have to either retreat before them, which would let them into the camp far easier than they had breached our ranks, or we must take them down right here. It shouldn't take much, as they are few, cut off from their own troops, and if our line, which looks broken now while we're demoralized, suddenly turns on them, they would be trapped in the middle and be hit from both sides." Hearing the general’s words, Navius grabbed the standard of the second company from the standard-bearer and advanced against the enemy, threatening to toss it into their midst unless the soldiers quickly followed him into battle. He was of gigantic build, and his armor set him apart; the standard he held high caught the eyes of both his comrades and the enemy. However, when he reached the standards of the Spaniards, javelins rained down on him from all directions, and almost the entire line turned against him; but neither the number of foes nor the strength of their weapons could stop this hero's charge.

6

Marcus Atilius, the lieutenant-general, also caused the standard of the first company of principes of the same legion to be borne against a cohort of the Spaniards. Lucius Portius Licinus and Titus Popilius, the lieutenant-generals, who had the command of the camp, fought valiantly in defence of the rampart, and slew the elephants while in the very act of crossing it. The carcasses of these filling up the ditch, afforded a passage for the enemy as effectually as if earth had been thrown in, or a bridge erected over it; and a horrid carnage took place amid the carcasses of the elephants which lay prostrate. On the other side of the camp, the Campanians, with the Carthaginian garrison, had by this time been repulsed, and the battle was carried on immediately under the gate of Capua leading to Vulturnus. Nor did the armed men contribute so much in resisting the Romans, who endeavoured to force their way in, as the gate itself, which, being furnished with ballistas and scorpions, kept the enemy at bay by the missiles discharged from it. The ardour of the Romans was also clamped by the general, Appius Claudius, receiving a wound; he was struck by a javelin in the upper part of his breast, beneath the left shoulder, while encouraging his men before the front line. A great number, however, of the enemy were slain before the gate, and the rest were driven in disorder into the city. When Hannibal saw the destruction of the cohort of Spaniards, and that the camp of the enemy was defended with the utmost vigour, giving up the assault, he began to withdraw his standards, making his infantry face about, but throwing out his cavalry in the rear lest the enemy should pursue them closely. The ardour of the legions to pursue the enemy was excessive, but Flaccus ordered a retreat to be sounded, considering that enough had been achieved to convince the Campanians, and Hannibal himself, how unable he was to afford them protection. Some who have undertaken to give accounts of this battle, record that eight thousand of the army of Hannibal, and three thousand Campanians, were slain; that fifteen military standards were taken from the Carthaginians, and eighteen from the Campanians. In other authors I find the battle to have been by no means so important, and that there was more of panic than fighting; that a party of Numidians and Spaniards suddenly bursting into the Roman camp with some elephants, the elephants, as they made their way through the midst of the camp, threw down their tents with a great noise, and caused the beasts of burden to break their halters and run away. That in addition to the confusion occasioned, a stratagem was employed; Hannibal having sent in some persons acquainted with the Latin language, for he had some such with him, who might command the soldiers, in the name of the consuls, to escape every one as fast as he could to the neighbouring mountains, since the camp was lost; but that the imposture was soon discovered, and frustrated with a great slaughter of the enemy; that the elephants were driven out of the camp by fire. However commenced, and however terminated, this was the last battle which was fought before the surrender of Capua. Seppius Lesius was Medixtuticus, or chief magistrate of Capua, that year, a man of obscure origin and slender fortune. It is reported that his mother, when formerly expiating a prodigy which had occurred in the family in behalf of this boy, who was an orphan, received an answer from the aruspex, stating, that "the highest office would come to him;" and that not recognising, at Capua, any ground for such a hope, exclaimed, "the state of the Campanians must be desperate indeed, when the highest office shall come to my son." But even this expression, in which the response was turned into ridicule, turned to be true, for those persons whose birth allowed them to aspire to high offices, refusing to accept them when the city was oppressed by sword and famine, and when all hope was lost, Lesius, who complained that Capua was deserted and betrayed by its nobles, accepted the office of chief magistrate, being the last Campanian who held it.

Marcus Atilius, the lieutenant-general, also had the standard of the first company of principes from the same legion advance against a cohort of Spaniards. Lucius Portius Licinus and Titus Popilius, the lieutenant-generals in command of the camp, fought bravely to defend the rampart and killed the elephants as they were crossing it. The dead elephants filled the ditch, providing a passage for the enemy just as if earth had been thrown in or a bridge built over it; a brutal slaughter occurred among the carcasses of the fallen elephants. Meanwhile, the Campanians, along with the Carthaginian garrison, had been driven back on the other side of the camp, and the battle continued right under the gate of Capua leading to Vulturnus. The soldiers didn’t resist the Romans trying to break in as much as the gate itself did, equipped with ballistas and scorpions that kept the enemy at bay with the missiles fired from it. The general, Appius Claudius, also restrained the Romans' enthusiasm; he was wounded by a javelin in the upper part of his chest, beneath the left shoulder, while motivating his men in front of the line. However, many enemy soldiers were killed before the gate, and the rest were pushed back in chaos into the city. When Hannibal saw the destruction of the cohort of Spaniards and that the enemy’s camp was defended with great determination, he called off the attack, began to pull back his standards, turned his infantry around, but sent out his cavalry to the rear to prevent the enemy from following them closely. The legions were extremely eager to chase the enemy, but Flaccus ordered a retreat, believing that they had proven enough to the Campanians and to Hannibal himself how incapable he was of protecting them. Some accounts of this battle claim that eight thousand of Hannibal's army and three thousand Campanians were killed, that fifteen military standards were taken from the Carthaginians, and eighteen from the Campanians. In other sources, I find that the battle wasn’t nearly as significant and that there was more panic than fighting; a group of Numidians and Spaniards suddenly burst into the Roman camp with some elephants, and as the elephants trampled through the camp, they knocked down tents with a loud crash, causing the pack animals to break free and flee. Along with the chaos this caused, a trick was used; Hannibal sent in some people who spoke Latin, as he had some with him, to command the soldiers, in the name of the consuls, to flee to the nearby mountains since the camp was lost; but the deception was quickly uncovered, resulting in a massive slaughter of the enemy, and the elephants were driven out of the camp by fire. Regardless of how it started and how it ended, this was the last battle fought before the surrender of Capua. Seppius Lesius served as Medixtuticus, or chief magistrate of Capua, that year; he was a man of humble origins and little wealth. It is said that when his mother was previously making amends for a family prodigy concerning this boy, who was an orphan, she consulted an aruspex, who told her that "the highest office would come to him;" and not seeing any reason for such hope in Capua, she exclaimed, "the situation of the Campanians must be truly desperate if the highest office is to come to my son." Yet even this remark, which mocked the prophecy, turned out to be true, for those who had the background to pursue high positions refused to take them when the city was besieged by war and famine, and all hope was lost. Lesius, who lamented that Capua was abandoned and betrayed by its nobles, accepted the position of chief magistrate, becoming the last Campanian to hold it.

7

But Hannibal, when he saw that the enemy could not be drawn into another engagement, nor a passage be forced through their camp into Capua, resolved to remove his camp from that place and leave the attempt unaccomplished, fearful lest the new consuls might cut off his supplies of provision. While anxiously deliberating on the point to which he should next direct his course, an impulse suddenly entered his mind to make an attack on Rome, the very source of the war. That the opportunity of accomplishing this ever coveted object, which occurred after the battle of Cannae, had been neglected, and was generally censured by others, he himself did not deny. He thought that there was some hope that he might be able to get possession of some part of the city, in consequence of the panic and confusion which his unexpected approach would occasion, and that if Rome were in danger, either both the Roman generals, or at least one of them, would immediately leave Capua; and if they divided their forces, both generals being thus rendered weaker, would afford a favourable opportunity either to himself or the Campanians of gaining some advantage. One consideration only disquieted him, and that was, lest on his departure the Campanians should immediately surrender. By means of presents he induced a Numidian, who was ready to attempt any thing, however daring, to take charge of a letter; and, entering the Roman camp under the disguise of a deserter, to pass out privately on the other side and go to Capua. As to the letter, it was full of encouragement. It stated, that "his departure, which would be beneficial to them, would have the effect of drawing off the Roman generals and armies from the siege of Capua to the defence of Rome. That they must not allow their spirits to sink; that by a few days' patience they would rid themselves entirely of the siege." He then ordered the ships on the Vulturnus to be seized, and rowed up to the fort which he had before erected for his protection. And when he was informed that there were as many as were necessary to convey his army across in one night, after providing a stock of provisions for ten days, he led his legions down to the river by night, and passed them over before daylight.

But Hannibal, seeing that he couldn't lure the enemy into another fight, nor force a passage through their camp into Capua, decided to move his camp elsewhere and leave the attempt unfinished, worried that the new consuls might cut off his supply lines. As he anxiously thought about where to head next, he suddenly had the idea to attack Rome, the very source of the war. He admitted that the chance to achieve this highly desired goal, which came after the battle of Cannae, had been missed and was criticized by others. He believed there was some hope he could seize part of the city due to the panic and confusion that his unexpected arrival would cause, and that if Rome was threatened, either both Roman generals, or at least one of them, would quickly leave Capua; and if they split their forces, both generals becoming weaker would create a good opportunity for either him or the Campanians to gain an advantage. The only thing that troubled him was the fear that the Campanians might surrender the moment he left. With some gifts, he persuaded a Numidian, who was ready to take on any daring task, to carry a letter; and, posing as a deserter, to go out secretly on the other side and head to Capua. The letter was full of encouragement. It said that "his departure, which would benefit them, would draw off the Roman generals and armies from the siege of Capua to defend Rome. They must not let their spirits drop; with just a few days of patience, they could completely free themselves from the siege." He then ordered the ships on the Vulturnus to be seized and rowed up to the fort he had previously set up for his protection. When he learned there were enough ships to carry his army across in one night, he arranged a supply of provisions for ten days, led his legions down to the river at night, and crossed them before daylight.

8

Fulvius Flaccus, who had discovered from deserters that this would happen, before it took place, having written to Rome to the senate to apprize them of it, men's minds were variously affected by it according to the disposition of each. As might be expected in so alarming an emergency, the senate was immediately assembled, when Publius Cornelius, surnamed Asina, was for recalling all the generals and armies from every part of Italy to protect the city, disregarding Capua and every other concern. Fabius Maximus thought that it would be highly disgraceful to retire from Capua, and allow themselves to be terrified and driven about at the nod and menaces of Hannibal. "Was it probable that he, who, though victorious at Cannae, nevertheless dared not approach the city, now, after having been repulsed from Capua, had conceived hopes of making himself master of Rome? It was not to besiege Rome, but to raise the siege of Capua that he was coming. Jupiter, the witness of treaties violated by Hannibal, and the other deities, would defend the city of Rome with that army which is now at the city." To these opposite opinions, that of Publius Valerius Flaccus, which recommended a middle course, was preferred. Regardful of both objects, he thought that a letter should be written to the generals at Capua, informing them of the force they had at the city for its protection, and stating, that as to the number of forces which Hannibal was bringing with him, or how large an army was necessary to carry on the siege of Capua, they themselves knew. If one of the generals and a part of the army could be sent to Rome, and at the same time Capua could be efficiently besieged by the remaining general and army, that then Claudius and Fulvius should settle between themselves which should continue the siege of Capua, and which should come to Rome to protect their capital from being besieged. This decree of the senate having been conveyed to Capua, Quintus Fulvius, the proconsul, who was to go to Rome, as his colleague was ill from his wound, crossed the Vulturnus with a body of troops, to the number of fifteen thousand infantry and a thousand horse, selected from the three armies. Then having ascertained that Hannibal intended to proceed along the Latin road, he sent persons before him to the towns on and near the Appian way, Setia, Cora, and Lanuvium, with directions that they should not only have provisions ready in their towns, but should bring them down to the road from the fields which lay out of the way, and that they should draw together into their towns troops for their defence, in order that each state might be under its own protection.

Fulvius Flaccus, who had learned from deserters that this would happen, before it took place, wrote to the Senate in Rome to inform them about it. People's reactions varied based on their personal disposition. In such a serious situation, the Senate was quickly called together, and Publius Cornelius, nicknamed Asina, suggested recalling all the generals and armies from across Italy to defend the city, ignoring Capua and any other matters. Fabius Maximus believed it would be shameful to retreat from Capua and to be scared and pushed around by Hannibal. "Is it likely that he, despite winning at Cannae, still didn't dare to come near the city, and now, after being repelled from Capua, thinks he can take Rome? He's not here to besiege Rome but to lift the siege of Capua. Jupiter, who witnesses the treaties Hannibal has broken, and the other gods will protect the city of Rome with the army that is already here." To these opposing views, that of Publius Valerius Flaccus, advocating a balanced approach, was favored. He suggested writing a letter to the generals at Capua, informing them of the forces protecting the city and stating that they knew the number of troops Hannibal was bringing and how many were needed to continue the siege of Capua. If one of the generals and part of the army could be sent to Rome while the remaining general and army efficiently besieged Capua, then Claudius and Fulvius should decide who would continue the siege and who would go to Rome to protect the capital. After this decree from the Senate was sent to Capua, Quintus Fulvius, the proconsul, who was to go to Rome since his colleague was recovering from a wound, crossed the Vulturnus with fifteen thousand infantry and a thousand cavalry chosen from the three armies. After confirming that Hannibal intended to take the Latin road, he sent messengers ahead to the towns along and near the Appian Way—Setia, Cora, and Lanuvium—directing them to not only prepare provisions in their towns but also to bring them down from the fields off the main road, and to gather troops for their defense so that each state could protect itself.

9

On the day he crossed the Vulturnus, Hannibal pitched his camp at a small distance from the river. The next day, passing by Cales, he reached the Sidicinian territory, and having spent a day there in devastating the country, he led his troops along the Latin way through the territory of Suessa, Allifae, and Casinum. Under the walls of Casinum he remained encamped for two days, ravaging the country all around; thence passing by Interamna and Aquinum, he came into the Fregellan territory, to the river Liris, where he found the bridge broken down by the Fregellans in order to impede his progress. Fulvius also was detained at the Vulturnus, in consequence of Hannibal's having burnt the ships, and the difficulty he had in procuring rafts to convey his troops across that river from the great scarcity of materials. The army having been conveyed across by rafts, the remainder of the march of Fulvius was uninterrupted, a liberal supply of provisions having been prepared for him, not only in all the towns, but also on the sides of the road; while his men, who were all activity, exhorted each other to quicken their pace, remembering that they were going to defend their country. A messenger from Fregella, who had travelled a day and a night without intermission, arriving at Rome, caused the greatest consternation; and the whole city was thrown into a state of alarm by the running up and down of persons who made vague additions to what they heard, and thus increased the confusion which the original intelligence created. The lamentations of women were not only heard from private houses, but the matrons from every quarter, rushing into the public streets, ran up and down around the shrines of the gods, sweeping the altars with their dishevelled hair, throwing themselves upon their knees and stretching their uplifted hands to heaven and the gods, imploring them to rescue the city of Rome out of the hands of their enemies, and preserve the Roman mothers and their children from harm. The senate sat in the forum near the magistrates, in case they should wish to consult them. Some were receiving orders and departing to their own department of duty; others were offering themselves wherever there might be occasion for their aid. Troops were posted in the citadel, in the Capitol, upon the walls around the city, and also on the Alban mount, and the fort of Aesula. During this confusion, intelligence was brought that Quintus Fulvius, the proconsul, had set out from Capua with an army; when the senate decreed that Quintus Fulvius should have equal authority with the consuls, lest on entering the city his power should cease. Hannibal, having most destructively ravaged the Fregellan territory, on account of the bridge having been broken down, came into the territory of the Lavici, passing through those of Frusino, Ferentinum, and Anagnia; thence passing through Algidum he directed his course to Tusculum; but not being received within the walls, he went down to the right below Tusculum to Gabii; and marching his army down thence into the territory of the Pupinian tribe, he pitched his camp eight miles from the city. The nearer the enemy came, the greater was the number of fugitives slain by the Numidians who preceded him, and the greater the number of prisoners made of every rank and age.

On the day he crossed the Vulturnus, Hannibal set up camp a short distance from the river. The next day, after passing Cales, he entered Sidicinian territory and spent a day destroying the land. He then led his troops along the Latin way through the lands of Suessa, Allifae, and Casinum. He camped outside the walls of Casinum for two days, wreaking havoc on the surrounding area; after that, he passed by Interamna and Aquinum and entered Fregellan territory, arriving at the Liris River, where he discovered that the Fregellans had destroyed the bridge to slow him down. Fulvius was also stuck at the Vulturnus because Hannibal had burned his ships, and he struggled to find rafts to get his troops across the river due to a lack of materials. Once the army was transported across by rafts, Fulvius's march continued without interruption, as there was an abundant supply of provisions waiting for him in all the towns and along the roads. His men, full of energy, encouraged each other to hurry, knowing they were heading to defend their homeland. A messenger from Fregella, who had traveled day and night without stopping, arrived in Rome and caused great panic; the entire city was thrown into a frenzy as people rushed around, adding to the confusion that the original news had created. The cries of women could be heard not just from private homes, but also from matrons running into the streets, racing around the shrines of the gods, sweeping the altars with their unkempt hair, dropping to their knees and lifting their hands to heaven and the gods, begging them to save the city of Rome from their enemies, and protect Roman mothers and their children. The senate convened in the forum near the magistrates in case they needed to consult them. Some were taking orders and heading off to their own duties, while others volunteered wherever their help was needed. Troops were stationed in the citadel, the Capitol, on the walls surrounding the city, as well as on the Alban mount and the fort of Aesula. Amidst all this chaos, news came that Quintus Fulvius, the proconsul, had left Capua with an army; the senate then decided that he should have the same authority as the consuls so that his power wouldn't diminish upon entering the city. After devastating the Fregellan territory due to the broken bridge, Hannibal moved into the Lavici territory, passing through Frusino, Ferentinum, and Anagnia; then through Algidum, he headed towards Tusculum. However, since he wasn't welcomed within the walls, he went down past Tusculum to Gabii, and marched his army down into the territory of the Pupinian tribe, setting up camp eight miles from the city. As the enemy drew closer, the Numidians in front of him killed more fleeing individuals, and captured more prisoners of all ranks and ages.

10

During this confusion, Fulvius Flaccus entered the city with his troops through the Capuan gate, passed through the midst of the city, and through Carinae, to Esquiliae; and going out thence, pitched his camp between the Esquiline and Colline gates. The plebeian aediles brought a supply of provisions there. The consuls and the senate came to the camp, and a consultation was held on the state of the republic. It was resolved that the consuls should encamp in the neighbourhood of the Colline and Esquiline gates; that Caius Calpurnius, the city praetor, should have the command of the Capitol and the citadel; and that a full senate should be continually assembled in the forum, in case it should be necessary to consult them amidst such sudden emergencies. Meanwhile, Hannibal advanced his camp to the Anio, three miles from the city, and fixing his position there, he advanced with two thousand horse from the Colline gate as far as the temple of Hercules, and riding up, took as near a view as he could of the walls and site of the city. Flaccus, indignant that he should do this so freely, and so much at his ease, sent out a party of cavalry, with orders to displace and drive back to their camp the cavalry of the enemy. After the fight had begun, the consuls ordered the Numidian deserters who were on the Aventine, to the number of twelve hundred, to march through the midst of the city to the Esquiliae, judging that no troops were better calculated to fight among the hollows, the garden walls, and tombs, or in the enclosed roads which were on all sides. But some persons, seeing them from the citadel and Capitol as they filed off on horseback down the Publician hill, cried out that the Aventine was taken. This circumstance occasioned such confusion and terror, that if the Carthaginian camp had not been without the city, the whole multitude, such was their alarm, would have rushed out. They then fled for refuge into their houses and upon the roofs, where they threw stones and weapons on their own soldiers as they passed along the streets, taking them for enemies. Nor could the tumult be repressed, or the mistake explained, as the streets were thronged with crowds of rustics and cattle, which the sudden alarm had driven into the city. The battle between the cavalry was successful, and the enemy were driven away; and as it was necessary to repress the tumults which were arising in several quarters without any cause, it was resolved that all who had been dictators, consuls, or censors, should be invested with authority till such time as the enemy had retired from the walls. During the remainder of the day and the following night, several tumults arose without any foundation, and were repressed.

During this chaos, Fulvius Flaccus entered the city with his troops through the Capuan gate, passed through the city center and Carinae, and headed to Esquiliae. From there, he set up his camp between the Esquiline and Colline gates. The plebeian aediles brought a supply of food there. The consuls and the senate visited the camp, and a meeting was held about the situation of the republic. It was decided that the consuls should camp near the Colline and Esquiline gates; that Caius Calpurnius, the city praetor, should be in charge of the Capitol and the citadel; and that a full senate should be gathered continuously in the forum to consult them in case of sudden emergencies. Meanwhile, Hannibal moved his camp to the Anio, three miles from the city, and positioned himself there. He sent two thousand cavalry from the Colline gate to the temple of Hercules, getting as close a look as he could at the walls and layout of the city. Flaccus, furious that he was doing this so freely and comfortably, sent out a cavalry unit with orders to drive the enemy’s cavalry back to their camp. After the fighting began, the consuls ordered twelve hundred Numidian deserters stationed on the Aventine to march through the city to the Esquiliae, believing they were the best troops for fighting in the hollows, garden walls, tombs, and enclosed roads all around. But some people, seeing them from the citadel and Capitol as they rode down Publician hill, yelled that the Aventine had fallen. This caused such panic and fear that if the Carthaginian camp hadn’t been outside the city, the entire crowd would have rushed out in alarm. They fled for safety into their homes and onto their roofs, throwing stones and weapons at their own soldiers as they passed by, mistaking them for enemies. The chaos couldn’t be controlled, nor could the misunderstanding be clarified, as the streets were crowded with rural people and livestock, driven into the city by the sudden scare. The cavalry battle was successful, and the enemy was pushed back. Since it was necessary to manage the unrest occurring in various areas without cause, it was decided that anyone who had served as dictators, consuls, or censors should be granted authority until the enemy retreated from the walls. Throughout the rest of the day and into the following night, more unfounded disturbances broke out but were suppressed.

11

The next day Hannibal, crossing the Anio, drew out all his forces in order of battle; nor did Flaccus and the consuls decline to fight. When the troops on both sides were drawn up to try the issue of a battle, in which Rome was to be the prize of the victors, a violent shower of rain mingled with hail created such disorder in both the lines, that the troops, scarcely able to hold their arms, retired to their camps, less through fear of the enemy than of any thing else. On the following day, likewise, a similar tempest separated the armies marshalled on the same ground; but after they had retired to their camps the weather became wonderfully serene and tranquil. The Carthaginians considered this circumstance as a Divine interposition, and it is reported that Hannibal was heard to say, "That sometimes he wanted the will to make himself master of Rome, at other times the opportunity." Two other circumstances also, one inconsiderable, the other important, diminished his hopes. The important one was, that while he lay with his armed troops near the walls of the city, he was informed that troops had marched out of it with colours flying, as a reinforcement for Spain; that of less importance was, that he was informed by one of his prisoners, that the very ground on which his camp stood was sold at this very time, without any diminution in its price. Indeed, so great an insult and indignity did it appear to him that a purchaser should be found at Rome for the very soil which he held and possessed by right of conquest, that he immediately called a crier, and ordered that the silversmiths' shops, which at that time stood around the Roman forum, should be put up for sale. Induced by these circumstances he retired to the river Tutia, six miles from the city, whence he proceeded to the grove of Feronia, where was a temple at that time celebrated for its riches. The Capenatians and other states in the neighbourhood, by bringing here their first-fruits and other offerings according to their abilities, kept it decorated with abundance of gold and silver. Of all these offerings the temple was now despoiled. After the departure of Hannibal, vast heaps of brass were found there, as the soldiers, from a religious feeling, had thrown in pieces of uncoined brass. The spoliation of this temple is undoubted by historians; but Caelius asserts, that Hannibal, in his progress to Rome, turned out of his way to it from Eretum. According to him his route commenced with Amiternum, Caetilii, and Reate. He came from Campania into Samnium, and thence into Pelignia; then passing the town Sulmio, he entered the territory of the Marrucini; thence through the Alban territory he came to that of the Marsi, from which he came to Amiternum and the village of Foruli. Nor is this diversity of opinion a proof that the traces of so great an army could be confounded in the lapse of so brief a period. That he went that way is evident. The only question is, whether he took this route to the city, or returned by it from the city into Campania?

The next day, Hannibal crossed the Anio and deployed all his forces in formation for battle. Flaccus and the consuls were also ready to fight. As both sides prepared to face off, fighting for the prize of Rome, a violent storm of rain mixed with hail caused such chaos in the ranks that the troops, barely able to handle their weapons, retreated to their camps, not so much out of fear of the enemy as due to other circumstances. The next day, another similar storm separated the armies lined up in the same spot; however, once they retreated to their camps, the weather turned calm and clear. The Carthaginians viewed this as a sign from the divine, and it’s said that Hannibal remarked, "Sometimes I lack the desire to conquer Rome, at other times I lack the opportunity." Two other factors, one minor and the other significant, dampened his hopes. The significant one was that while he was encamped near the city walls, he learned that troops had marched out with banners flying as reinforcements for Spain; the less significant one was that he heard from one of his prisoners that the very land on which he had set his camp was being sold at that moment, without any decrease in its price. He found it such an insult and indignity that someone could be found in Rome to buy the land he had taken by conquest that he immediately called for a crier and ordered the silversmiths' shops around the Roman forum to be put up for sale. Driven by these events, he moved to the river Tutia, six miles from the city, and then headed to the grove of Feronia, where a temple known for its wealth stood. The Capenatians and nearby states kept the temple filled with gold and silver offerings according to their ability. This temple was now stripped of all its offerings. After Hannibal left, large piles of uncoined brass were found there, as the soldiers, out of a sense of reverence, had thrown in pieces of brass. Historians agree on the desecration of this temple; however, Caelius claims that Hannibal detoured to it from Eretum on his way to Rome. He states that Hannibal's route started with Amiternum, Caetilii, and Reate. He traveled from Campania into Samnium, then to Pelignia; after passing the town of Sulmio, he entered the territory of the Marrucini; from there, he moved through the Alban territory to the Marsi, then went to Amiternum and the village of Foruli. This difference of opinions doesn't prove that the traces of such a large army could be confused in such a short time. It’s evident he took that route. The only question is whether he used this path to the city or returned by it from the city to Campania.

12

With regard to Capua, Hannibal did not evince such obstinate perseverance in raising the siege of it as the Romans did in pressing it; for quitting Lucania, he came into the Bruttian territory, and marched to the strait and Rhegium with such rapidity, that he was very near taking the place by surprise, in consequence of the suddenness of his arrival. Though the siege had been urged with undiminished vigour during his absence, yet Capua felt the return of Flaccus; and astonishment was excited that Hannibal had not returned with him. Afterwards they learnt, by conversations, that they were abandoned and deserted, and that the Carthaginians had given up all hopes of retaining Capua. In addition to this a proclamation was made by the proconsul, agreeably to a decree of the senate, and published among the enemy, that any Campanian citizen who came over before a stated day should be indemnified. No one, however, came over, as they were held together by fear more than fidelity; for the crimes they had committed during their revolt were too great to admit of pardon. As none of them passed over to the enemy, consulting their own individual interest, so no measure of safety was taken with regard to the general body. The nobility had deserted the state, nor could they be induced to meet in the senate, while the office of chief magistrate was filled by a man who had not derived honour to himself from his office, but stripped the office of its influence and authority by his own unworthiness. Now none of the nobles made their appearance even in the forum, or any public place, but shut themselves up in their houses, in daily expectation of the downfall of their city, and their own destruction together. The chief responsibility in every thing devolved upon Bostar and Hanno, the praefects of the Punic garrison, who were anxious on account of their own danger, and not that of their allies. They addressed a letter to Hannibal, in terms, not only of freedom, but severity, charging him with "delivering, not only Capua into the hands of the enemy, but with treacherously abandoning themselves also, and their troops, to every species of torture;" they told him "he had gone off to the Bruttians, in order to get out of the way, as it were, lest Capua should be taken before his eyes; while, by Hercules, the Romans, on the contrary, could not be drawn off from the siege of Capua, even by an attack upon their city. So much more constant were the Romans in their enmity than the Carthaginians in their friendship. If he would return to Capua and direct the whole operations of the war to that point, that both themselves and the Campanians would be prepared for a sally. That they had crossed the Alps not to carry on a war with the people of Rhegium nor Tarentum. That where the Roman legions were, there the armies of the Carthaginians ought to be. Thus it was that victories had been gained at Cannae and Trasimenus; by uniting, by pitching their camp close to that of the enemy, by trying their fortune." A letter to this effect was given to some Numidians who had already engaged to render their services for a stated reward. These men came into the camp to Flaccus under pretence of being deserters, with the intention of quitting it by seizing an opportunity, and the famine, which had so long existed at Capua, afforded a pretext for desertion which no one could suspect. But a Campanian woman, the paramour of one of the deserters, unexpectedly entered the camp, and informed the Roman general that the Numidians had come over according to a preconcerted plan of treachery, and were the bearers of letters to Hannibal; that she was prepared to convict one of the party of that fact, as he had discovered it to her. On being brought forward, he at first pretended, with considerable pertinacity, that he did not know the woman; but afterwards, gradually succumbing to the force of truth, when he saw the instruments of torture called for and preparing, he confessed that it was so. The letters were produced, and a discovery was made of an additional fact, before concealed, that other Numidians were strolling about in the Roman camp, under pretence of being deserters. Above seventy of these were arrested, and, with the late deserters, scourged with rods; and after their hands had been cut off, were driven back to Capua. The sight of so severe a punishment broke the spirit of the Campanians.

Regarding Capua, Hannibal did not show the same stubborn determination in lifting the siege as the Romans did in pursuing it. After leaving Lucania, he entered Bruttium and hurried toward the strait and Rhegium with such speed that he nearly caught the city off guard due to the suddenness of his arrival. Although the siege was vigorously maintained during his absence, Capua was aware of Flaccus's return, and there was surprise that Hannibal had not come back with him. Later, they learned through conversations that they had been abandoned and that the Carthaginians had given up hope of holding Capua. Furthermore, a proclamation was made by the proconsul, following a decree from the senate, announcing among the enemy that any Campanian citizen who defected before a certain date would be granted immunity. However, no one defected, as fear bound them more than loyalty; the crimes they committed during their revolt were too severe to be forgiven. Since none of them crossed over to the enemy, putting their own interests first, no safety measures were taken for the larger group. The nobility had abandoned the state and could not be persuaded to gather in the senate, while the chief magistrate was someone who had not brought honor to his position but had instead stripped it of influence and authority through his own inadequacies. None of the nobles appeared in the forum or any public place; they remained confined in their homes, anticipating the fall of their city and their own destruction. The main responsibility fell to Bostar and Hanno, the commanders of the Punic garrison, who were more concerned about their own safety than that of their allies. They wrote to Hannibal, expressing their discontent not only with the loss of Capua to the enemy but also with his abandonment of them and their troops to various forms of suffering. They accused him of fleeing to the Bruttians to avoid witnessing Capua's capture while, ironically, the Romans were so determined that they even attacked his city without being deterred from the siege. They emphasized that the Romans were far more constant in their animosity than the Carthaginians were in their loyalty. They urged him to return to Capua and focus the entire war effort there so they and the Campanians would be ready for a counterattack. They had crossed the Alps not to wage war against the people of Rhegium or Tarentum; wherever the Roman legions were, that was where the Carthaginian forces should be as well. This strategy had proven effective in securing victories at Cannae and Trasimenus; by uniting and camped close to the enemy, they could test their fortune. A letter with this message was handed to some Numidians who had already agreed to assist for a specified reward. These men approached Flaccus’s camp under the guise of deserters, intending to slip away at an opportune moment, and the ongoing famine in Capua provided a cover for their desertion that wouldn't arouse suspicion. However, a Campanian woman, the lover of one of the deserters, unexpectedly entered the camp and told the Roman general that the Numidians had come over with a plan of treachery and were carrying letters for Hannibal; she was ready to expose one of them as he had revealed the plan to her. When brought forward, he initially denied knowing her, but eventually, as the threat of torture grew imminent, he confessed the truth. The letters were produced, uncovering an additional fact that had previously been hidden—that other Numidians were wandering in the Roman camp pretending to be deserters. Over seventy of them were captured and, along with the recent deserters, were whipped; and after their hands were cut off, they were sent back to Capua. The sight of such harsh punishment broke the spirit of the Campanians.

13

The people, rushing in crowds to the senate-house, compelled Lesius to assemble a senate, and openly threatened the nobles, who had now for a long time absented themselves from the public deliberations, that unless they attended the meeting of the senate, they would go round to their houses and drag them all before the public by force. The fear of this procured the magistrate a full senate. Here, while the rest contended for sending ambassadors to the Roman generals, Vibius Virrius, who had been the instigator of the revolt from the Romans, on being asked his opinion, observed, that "those persons who spoke of sending ambassadors, and of peace, and a surrender, did not bear in mind either what they would do if they had the Romans in their power, or what they themselves must expect to suffer. What! do you think," says he, "that your surrender will be like that in which formerly we placed ourselves and every thing belonging to us at the disposal of the Romans, in order that we might obtain assistance from them against the Samnites? Have you already forgotten at what a juncture we revolted from the Romans, and what were their circumstances? Have you forgotten how at the time of the revolt we put to death, with torture and indignity, their garrison, which might have been sent out? How often, and with determined hostility, we have sallied out against them when besieging us, and assaulted their camp? How we invited Hannibal to come and cut them off? And how most recently we sent him hence to lay siege to Rome? But come, retrace on the other hand what they have done in hostility towards us, that you may learn therefrom what you have to hope for. When a foreign enemy was in Italy, and that enemy Hannibal; when the flame of war was kindled in every quarter; disregarding every other object, disregarding even Hannibal himself, they sent two consuls with two consular armies to lay siege to Capua. This is the second year, that, surrounded with lines and shut up within our walls, they consume us by famine, having suffered in like manner with ourselves the extremest dangers and the severest hardships, having frequently had their troops slain near their rampart and trenches, and at last having been almost deprived of their camp. But I pass over these matters. It has been usual, even from of old, to suffer dangers and hardships in besieging an enemy's city. The following is a proof of their animosity and bitter hatred. Hannibal assaulted their camp with an immense force of horse and foot, and took a part of it. By so great a danger they were not in the least diverted from the siege. Crossing the Vulturnus, he laid waste the territory of Cales with fire. Such calamities inflicted upon their allies had no effect in calling them off. He ordered his troops to march in hostile array to the very city of Rome. They despised the tempest which threatened them in this case also. Crossing the Anio, he pitched his camp three miles from the city, and lastly, came up to the very walls and gates. He gave them to understand that he would take their city from them, unless they gave up Capua. But they did not give it up. Wild beasts, impelled by headlong fury and rage, you may divert from their object to bring assistance to those belonging to them, if you attempt to approach their dens and their young. The Romans could not be diverted from Capua by the blockade of Rome, by their wives and children, whose lamentations could almost be heard from this place, by their altars, their hearths, the temples of their gods, and the sepulchres of their ancestors profaned and violated. So great was their avidity to bring us to punishment, so insatiable their thirst for drinking our blood. Nor, perhaps, without reason. We too would have done the same had the opportunity been afforded us. Since, however, the gods have thought proper to determine it otherwise, though I ought not to shrink from death, while I am free, while I am master of myself, I have it in my power, by a death not only honourable but mild, to escape the tortures and indignities which the enemy hope to inflict upon me. I will not see Appius Claudius and Quintus Fulvius in the pride and insolence of victory, nor will I be dragged in chains through Rome as a spectacle in a triumph, that afterwards in a dungeon, or tied to a stake, after my back has been lacerated with stripes, I may place my neck under a Roman axe. I will neither see my native city demolished and burnt, nor the matrons, virgins, and free-born youths of Campania dragged to constupration. Alba, from which they themselves derived their origin, they demolished from her foundations, that there might remain no trace of their rise and extraction, much less can I believe they will spare Capua, towards which they bear a more rancorous hatred than towards Carthage. For such of you, therefore, as have a mind to yield to fate, before they behold such horrors, a banquet is furnished and prepared at my house. When satiated with wine and food, the same cup which shall have been given to me shall be handed round to them. That potion will rescue our bodies from torture, our minds from insult, our eyes and ears from seeing and hearing all those cruelties and indignities which await the vanquished. There will be persons in readiness who will throw our lifeless bodies upon a large pile kindled in the court-yard of the house. This is the only free and honourable way to death. Our very enemies will admire our courage, and Hannibal will learn that those whom he deserted and betrayed were brave allies."

The crowd, rushing to the senate house, forced Lesius to gather a senate and openly threatened the nobles, who had long been absent from public discussions, that if they didn't attend the senate meeting, they'd go to their homes and drag them out by force. The fear of this gave the magistrate a full senate. Here, while others argued for sending ambassadors to the Roman generals, Vibius Virrius, who had encouraged the revolt against the Romans, remarked that "those who talk about sending ambassadors, discussing peace, and surrender don’t remember what they would do if they had the Romans at their mercy or what they should expect to endure. What? Do you think your surrender will be like the one where we put ourselves and everything we had in the hands of the Romans just to get their help against the Samnites? Have you already forgotten why we revolted against the Romans and what their situation was? Have you forgotten how, at the time of our revolt, we tortured and killed their garrison that might have been sent out? How often, with determination, we attacked them while they besieged us and assaulted their camp? How we invited Hannibal to come and destroy them? And how most recently we sent him to lay siege to Rome? But let’s remember what they have done to us. When a foreign enemy, Hannibal, was in Italy, and the war raged everywhere, ignoring everything else, even Hannibal himself, they sent two consuls with two armies to lay siege to Capua. This is now the second year that, surrounded and confined to our walls, they are starving us, having suffered the same dangers and hardships, often losing their troops near their defenses. But I’ll skip over these details. It has always been common to face dangers and hardships while besieging an enemy city. Here’s proof of their animosity and deep hatred. Hannibal attacked their camp with a massive force and took part of it. Despite this danger, they were undeterred from the siege. Crossing the Vulturnus, he ravaged the territory of Cales with fire. Such disasters inflicted on their allies didn’t make them retreat. He ordered his troops to march against the very city of Rome. They ignored the storm that threatened them then too. Crossing the Anio, he camped three miles from the city and eventually approached the very walls and gates. He warned them that he would take their city if they didn’t abandon Capua. But they refused to give it up. Wild beasts, driven by rage, might be diverted from their prey if you try to approach their dens and their young. The Romans could not be deterred from Capua by the blockade of Rome, even with their wives and children’s cries almost audible from here, nor by their altars, hearths, the temples of their gods, and the graves of their ancestors desecrated and violated. So strong was their desire to punish us, insatiable their thirst for our blood. And maybe rightly so. We would have done the same if we had the chance. However, as the gods have decided otherwise, while I still have the freedom, while I am in control of myself, I can choose a death that is not only honorable but gentle, to escape the tortures and indignities that the enemy hopes to inflict on me. I won’t see Appius Claudius and Quintus Fulvius in the arrogance of their victory, nor will I be dragged in chains through Rome as a trophy in a triumph, only to end up in a dungeon, or tied to a stake, subject to wounds before having my neck put under a Roman axe. I won’t witness my hometown destroyed and burned, nor the matrons, virgins, and free-born youths of Campania taken for dishonor. They destroyed Alba, their own origin, so there would be no trace of their rise and history, so I can hardly believe they would spare Capua, which they hate even more than Carthage. Therefore, for those who are willing to accept fate before witnessing such horrors, a banquet is prepared at my house. Once filled with wine and food, the same cup I am given will be passed around to them. That drink will spare our bodies from torture, our minds from insult, our eyes and ears from witnessing and hearing all the cruelties and indignities that await the defeated. There will be people ready to place our lifeless bodies on a large pile set aflame in the courtyard of the house. This is the only free and honorable way to die. Even our enemies will admire our courage, and Hannibal will see that those he abandoned and betrayed were brave allies."

14

More of those who heard this speech of Virrius approved of the proposal contained in it, than had strength of mind to execute what they approved. The greater part of the senate being not without hopes that the Romans, whose clemency they had frequently had proof of in many wars, would be exorable by them also, decreed and sent ambassadors to surrender Capua to the Romans. About twenty-seven senators, following Vibius Virrius to his home, partook of the banquet with him; and after having, as far as they could, withdrawn their minds, by means of wine, from the perception of the impending evil, all took the poison. They then rose from the banquet, after giving each other their right hands, and taking a last embrace, mingling their tears for their own and their country's fate; some of them remained, that they might be burned upon the same pile, and the rest retired to their homes. Their veins being filled in consequence of what they had eaten, and the wine they drank, rendered the poison less efficacious in expediting death; and accordingly, though the greater part of them languished the whole of that night and part of the following day, all of them, however, breathed their last before the gates were opened to the enemy. The following day the gate of Jupiter, which faced the Roman camp, was opened by order of the proconsul, when one legion and two squadrons of allies marched in at it, under the command of Caius Fulvius, lieutenant-general. When he had taken care that all the arms and weapons to be found in Capua should be brought to him; having placed guards at all the gates to prevent any one's going or being sent out, he seized the Carthaginian garrison, and ordered the Campanian senators to go into the camp to the Roman generals. On their arrival they were all immediately thrown into chains, and ordered to lay before the quaestor an account of all the gold and silver they had. There were seventy pounds of gold, and three thousand two hundred of silver. Twenty-five of the senators were sent to Cales, to be kept in custody, and twenty-eight to Teanum; these being the persons by whose advice principally it appeared that the revolt from the Romans had taken place.

More people who heard Virrius's speech agreed with the proposal in it than had the courage to act on that agreement. Most of the senate, hopeful that the Romans—who had shown mercy in many wars—would be persuadable by them as well, decided to send ambassadors to surrender Capua to the Romans. About twenty-seven senators followed Vibius Virrius to his home and joined him for a banquet; after trying to numb their minds with wine to forget the looming disaster, they all took poison. They then stood up from the banquet, giving each other their right hands and sharing a final embrace, mixing their tears over their fate and that of their country. Some chose to stay behind to be burned on the same pyre, while the others returned home. Their bodies, filled with food and wine, reacted by delaying the poison's effectiveness in causing death; as a result, most of them suffered through the entire night and part of the following day but all died before the enemy entered. The next day, the gate of Jupiter, facing the Roman camp, was opened by the proconsul’s orders, allowing a legion and two squadrons of allies to march in under the command of Caius Fulvius, the lieutenant-general. After making sure all arms and weapons in Capua were gathered, he placed guards at all the gates to prevent anyone from leaving or sending messages, captured the Carthaginian garrison, and ordered the Campanian senators to report to the Roman generals. Upon their arrival, they were all immediately shackled and instructed to present an account of all their gold and silver to the quaestor. They had seventy pounds of gold and three thousand two hundred pounds of silver. Twenty-five senators were sent to Cales for custody, and twenty-eight to Teanum; these were the main people whose advice seemed to have led to the revolt against the Romans.

15

Fulvius and Claudius were far from being agreed as to the punishment of the Campanian senators. Claudius was disposed to grant their prayer for pardon, but Fulvius was more inclined to severity. Appius, therefore, was for referring the entire disposal of the question to the Roman senate. He thought it right also, that the fathers should have the opportunity of asking them whether any of the Latin confederates, or of the municipal towns, had taken part in these designs, and whether they had derived any assistance from them in the war. Fulvius, on the contrary, urged that they ought by no means to run the hazard of having the minds of faithful allies harassed by doubtful accusations, and subjected to informers who never cared at all what they did or what they said. For this reason he said that he should prevent and put a stop to any such inquiry. After this conversation they separated; Appius not doubting but that his colleague, though he expressed himself so warmly, would, nevertheless, wait for a letter from Rome, in an affair of such magnitude. But Fulvius, fearing that his designs would be frustrated by that very means, dismissed his council, and commanded the military tribunes and the praefects of the allies to give notice to two thousand chosen horsemen to be in readiness at the third trumpet. Setting out for Teanum with this body of cavalry, he entered the gate at break of day, and proceeded direct to the forum; and a number of people having flocked together at the first entrance of the horsemen, he ordered the Sidicinian magistrate to be summoned; when he desired him to bring forth the Campanians whom he had in custody. These were all accordingly brought forth, scourged, and beheaded. He then proceeded at full speed to Cales; where, when he had taken his seat on the tribunal, and while the Campanians, who had been brought forth, were being bound to the stake, an express arrived from Rome, and delivered to him a letter from Caius Calpurnius, the praetor, and a decree of the senate. A murmur immediately pervaded the whole assembly, beginning at the tribunal, that the entire question respecting the Campanians was referred to the decision of the fathers, and Fulvius, suspecting this to be the case, took the letter, and without opening it put it into his bosom, and then commanded the crier to order the lictor to do his duty. Thus punishment was inflicted on those also who were at Cales. The letter was then read, together with the decree of the senate, when it was too late to prevent the business which was already executed, and which had been accelerated by every means to prevent its being obstructed. When Fulvius was now rising from his seat, Jubellius Taurea, a Campanian making his way through the middle of the city and the crowd, called upon him by name, and when Flaccus, who wondered greatly what he could want, had resumed his seat, he said, "Order me also to be put to death, that you may be able to boast, that a much braver man than yourself has been put to death by you." Fulvius at first said, that the man could not certainly be in his senses, then, that he was restrained by a decree of the senate, even though he might wish it, when Jubellius exclaimed "Since, after the capture of my country, and the loss of my relations and friends, after having killed, with my own hand, my wife and children to prevent their suffering any indignity, I am not allowed even to die in the same manner as these my countrymen, let a rescue be sought in courage from this hated existence." So saying, he thrust a sword, which he had concealed under his garment, right through his breast, and fell lifeless at the general's feet.

Fulvius and Claudius did not agree at all on how to punish the Campanian senators. Claudius was inclined to grant their request for mercy, while Fulvius preferred a harsher approach. Therefore, Appius suggested that they pass the entire matter to the Roman senate. He believed it was also important for the senators to ask whether any of the Latin allies or municipal towns had participated in these actions, and whether they had provided any assistance in the war. Fulvius, however, argued that they should not risk disturbing the minds of loyal allies with unfounded accusations or informants who cared little for what they did or said. For this reason, he insisted that he would put a stop to any such inquiry. After this discussion, they parted ways; Appius was confident that his colleague, despite his passionate remarks, would still wait for a letter from Rome regarding such an important issue. But Fulvius, fearing that his plans would be thwarted by this very means, dismissed his council and ordered the military tribunes and the prefects of the allies to alert two thousand chosen horsemen to be ready at the third trumpet. He set out for Teanum with this cavalry, entered the gate at dawn, and headed straight for the forum. As a crowd gathered at the entrance of the horsemen, he ordered the Sidicinian magistrate to be summoned and asked him to bring forth the Campanians he had in custody. The Campanians were brought out, whipped, and executed. He then quickly proceeded to Cales; when he took his seat on the tribunal, and while the Campanians were being tied to the stake, a messenger arrived from Rome with a letter from Caius Calpurnius, the praetor, and a decree from the senate. A murmur spread through the assembly, starting from the tribunal, that the entire matter concerning the Campanians had been referred to the senate's decision, and Fulvius, suspecting this was the case, took the letter, placed it in his bosom without opening it, and ordered the crier to tell the lictor to carry out the punishment. Thus, punishment was also carried out on those present in Cales. The letter, along with the senate's decree, was read when it was too late to reverse what had already been done, and which had been rushed to avoid any delays. As Fulvius was about to leave his seat, Jubellius Taurea, a Campanian, made his way through the crowd and called out to him. When Flaccus sat down again, puzzled by what he wanted, Jubellius said, "Order me to be put to death too, so you can boast that a braver man than you has been killed by you." At first, Fulvius thought the man must be out of his mind, then stated he was restricted by a senate decree, even if he wished otherwise. Jubellius then exclaimed, "Since, after the capture of my country and the loss of my family and friends, after I killed my wife and children with my own hands to spare them from humiliation, I can't even die like these fellow countrymen, let me seek relief from this hated existence through courage." Saying this, he plunged a hidden sword into his chest and collapsed lifeless at the general's feet.

16

Because not only what related to the punishment of the Campanians, but most of the other particulars of this affair, were transacted according to the judgment of Flaccus alone, some authors affirm that Appius Claudius died about the time of the surrender of Capua, and that this same Taurea neither came to Cales voluntarily nor died by his own hand, but that while he was being tied to the stake among the rest, Flaccus, who could not distinctly hear what he vociferated from the noise which was made, ordered silence, when Taurea said the things which have been before related "that he, a man of the greatest courage, was being put to death by one who was by no means his equal in respect to valour." That immediately on his saying this, the herald, by command of the proconsul, pronounced this order. "Lictor, apply the rods to this man of courage, and execute the law upon him first." Some authors also relate, that he read the decree of the senate before he beheaded them, but that as there was a clause in it, to the effect, that if he thought proper he should refer the entire question to the senate, he construed it that the decision as to what was most for the interest of the state was left to himself. He returned from Cales to Capua. Atella and Calatia surrendered themselves, and were received. Here also the principal promoters of the revolt were punished. Thus eighty principal members of the senate were put to death, and about three hundred of the Campanian nobles thrown into prison. The rest were distributed through the several cities of the Latin confederacy, to be kept in custody, where they perished in various ways. The rest of the Campanian citizens were sold. The remaining subject of deliberation related to the city and its territory. Some were of opinion that a city so eminently powerful, so near, and so hostile, ought to be demolished. But immediate utility prevailed, for on account of the land, which was evidently superior to any in Italy from the variety and exuberance of its produce, the city was preserved that it might become a settlement of husbandmen. For the purpose of peopling the city, a number of sojourners, freed-men, dealers, and artificers, were retained, but all the land and buildings were made the property of the Roman state. It was resolved, however, that Capua should only be inhabited and peopled as a city, that there should be no body-politic, nor assembly of the senate or people, nor magistrates. For it was thought that a multitude not possessing any public council, without a ruling power, and unconnected by the participation of any common rights, would be incapable of combination. They resolved to send a praefect annually from Rome to administer justice. Thus were matters adjusted at Capua, upon a plan in every respect worthy of commendation. Punishment was inflicted upon the most guilty with rigour and despatch, the populace dispersed beyond all hope of return, no rage vented in fire and ruins upon the unoffending houses and walls. Together also with advantage, a reputation for clemency was obtained among the allies, by the preservation of a city of the greatest celebrity and opulence, the demolition of which, all Campania, and all the people dwelling in the neighbourhood of Campania, would have bewailed, while their enemies were compelled to admit the ability of the Romans to punish their faithless allies, and how little assistance could be derived from Hannibal towards the defence of those whom he had taken under his protection.

Because not only was the punishment of the Campanians decided solely by Flaccus, but most of the other details of this situation were handled by him as well, some authors claim that Appius Claudius died around the time Capua surrendered. They also say that Taurea neither came to Cales willingly nor took his own life. Instead, while he was being tied to the stake with the others, Flaccus, unable to clearly hear Taurea’s cries due to the noise, ordered silence. When Taurea declared, as previously mentioned, "that he, a man of great courage, was being executed by someone who was far inferior in bravery," the herald, at the proconsul's command, announced, "Lictor, apply the rods to this brave man and execute the law on him first." Some authors also mention that he read the senate's decree before beheading them, but there was a clause stating that he could refer the whole matter back to the senate if he saw fit, which he interpreted as meaning that the authority to decide what was best for the state rested with him. He returned from Cales to Capua. Atella and Calatia surrendered and were accepted. Here, the main instigators of the revolt were punished as well. In total, eighty prominent members of the senate were executed, and about three hundred Campanian nobles were thrown into prison. The rest were dispersed across various cities in the Latin confederacy, where they died in different ways. The remaining Campanian citizens were sold off. The next point of discussion was the city and its territory. Some believed that such a powerful, nearby, and hostile city should be destroyed. However, practical needs won out, as the land was clearly superior to any in Italy due to its diverse and abundant produce, so the city was preserved to become a settlement for farmers. To populate the city, many sojourners, freedmen, traders, and craftsmen were retained, but all the land and buildings were made property of the Roman state. It was decided that Capua would only be populated as a city, with no government, assembly of senate or people, nor magistrates. It was believed that a large group without any public council, ruling authority, or common rights would be incapable of organizing. They resolved to send a praefect from Rome each year to administer justice. Thus, matters at Capua were organized in a way that deserved commendation. The most guilty were punished swiftly and harshly, the populace was dispersed with no hope of return, and there was no destruction of innocent homes and walls. Additionally, this approach gained a reputation for clemency among the allies by preserving a city of great reputation and wealth, the destruction of which would have been mourned by all of Campania and those living nearby, while their enemies had to acknowledge the Romans' ability to punish their disloyal allies and how little help Hannibal could offer in defending those under his protection.

17

The Roman senate having gone through every thing which required their attention relative to Capua, decreed to Caius Nero six thousand foot and three hundred horse, whichever he should himself choose out of those two legions which he had commanded at Capua, with an equal number of infantry, and eight hundred horse of the Latin confederacy. This army Nero embarked at Puteoli, and conveyed over into Spain. Having arrived at Tarraco with his ships, landed his troops, hauled his ships ashore, and armed his mariners to augment his numbers, he proceeded to the river Iberus, and received the army from Titus Fonteius and Lucius Marcius. He then marched towards the enemy. Hasdrubal, son of Hamilcar, was encamped at the black stones in Ausetania, a place situated between the towns Illiturgi and Mentissa. The entrance of this defile Nero seized, and Hasdrubal, to prevent his being shut up in it, sent a herald to engage that, if he were allowed to depart thence, he would convey the whole of his army out of Spain. The Roman general having received this proposition gladly, Hasdrubal requested the next day for a conference, when the Romans might draw up conditions relative to the surrender of the citadels of the towns, and the appointment of a day on which the garrisons might be withdrawn, and the Carthaginians might remove every thing belonging to them without imposition. Having obtained his point in this respect, Hasdrubal gave orders that as soon as it was dark, and during the whole of the night afterwards, the heaviest part of his force should get out of the defile by whatever way they could. The strictest care was taken that many should not go out that night, that the very fewness of their numbers might both be more adapted to elude the notice of the enemy from their silence, and to an escape through confined and rugged paths. Next day they met for the conference; but that day having been spent, on purpose, in speaking and writing about a variety of subjects, which were not to this point, the conference was put off to the next day. The addition of the following night gave him time to send still more out; nor was the business concluded the next day. Thus several days were spent in openly discussing conditions, and as many nights in privately sending the Carthaginian troops out of their camp; and after the greater part of the army had been sent out, he did not even keep to those terms which he had himself proposed; and his sincerity decreasing with his fears, they became less and less agreed. By this time nearly all the infantry had cleared the defile, when at daybreak a dense mist enveloped the whole defile and the neighbouring plains; which Hasdrubal perceiving, sent to Nero to put off the conference to the following day, as the Carthaginians held that day sacred from the transaction of any serious business. Not even then was the cheat suspected. Hasdrubal having gained the indulgence he sought for that day also, immediately quitted his camp with his cavalry and elephants, and without creating any alarm escaped to a place of safety. About the fourth hour the mist, being dispelled by the sun, left the atmosphere clear, when the Romans saw that the camp of the enemy was deserted. Then at length Claudius, recognising the Carthaginian perfidy, and perceiving that he had been caught by trickery, immediately began to pursue the enemy as they moved off, prepared to give battle; but they declined fighting. Some skirmishes, however, took place between the rear of the Carthaginians and the advanced guard of the Romans.

The Roman Senate reviewed everything needing their attention regarding Capua and decided to allocate Caius Nero six thousand foot soldiers and three hundred cavalry, which he could choose from the two legions he had commanded at Capua, along with an equal number of infantry and eight hundred cavalry from the Latin allies. Nero embarked this army at Puteoli and transported them to Spain. After arriving at Tarraco with his ships, he landed his troops, hauled the ships ashore, and armed his sailors to boost his numbers. He then moved towards the river Iberus, where he received the army from Titus Fonteius and Lucius Marcius. He marched towards the enemy, Hasdrubal, son of Hamilcar, who was camped at the black stones in Ausetania, a location between the towns of Illiturgi and Mentissa. Nero seized the entrance to this pass, and Hasdrubal, to avoid being trapped in it, sent a herald to negotiate. He promised that if he was allowed to leave, he would take his entire army out of Spain. The Roman general was pleased with this proposal, and Hasdrubal requested a meeting for the next day to discuss terms regarding the surrender of the towns’ citadels and the schedule for withdrawing the garrisons, ensuring the Carthaginians could remove their belongings without interference. After securing this agreement, Hasdrubal ordered that as soon as night fell and throughout the night, the majority of his forces should escape through whatever means possible. They took great care to ensure only a few left that night, thinking that their small numbers would help them evade the enemy's notice due to their silence and make escaping through the narrow, rough paths easier. The next day, they met for the conference, but the day was intentionally spent discussing various unrelated topics, postponing the meeting until the following day. The additional night allowed Hasdrubal more time to sneak out even more troops, and the negotiations were still not finished the next day. Thus, several days passed with public discussions about terms while many nights were spent quietly moving the Carthaginian troops out of their camp. Once most of the army had been evacuated, Hasdrubal didn't stick to the terms he had proposed, as his sincerity diminished with his fears, causing the conditions to become less aligned. By this time, nearly all the infantry had exited the pass when, at dawn, a thick mist covered the entire pass and the surrounding plains. Hasdrubal noticing this sent a message to Nero asking to postpone the conference to the next day since the Carthaginians considered that day sacred for serious business. Even then, his deception wasn’t suspected. Hasdrubal, having obtained the delay he wanted for that day, immediately left his camp with his cavalry and elephants, escaping to safety without causing any alarm. Around the fourth hour, when the sun cleared the mist, the Romans discovered that the enemy's camp was deserted. Then Claudius recognized the Carthaginian treachery and realized he had been tricked, prompting him to pursue the retreating enemy, prepared to engage in battle; however, they refused to fight. Some skirmishes did occur between the retreating Carthaginians and the Roman vanguard.

18

During the time in which these events occurred, neither did those states of Spain which had revolted after the defeat that was sustained, return to the Romans, nor did any others desert them. At Rome, the attention of the senate and people, after the recovery of Capua, was not fixed in a greater degree upon Italy than upon Spain. They resolved that the army there should be augmented and a general sent. They were not, however, so clear as to the person whom they should send, as that, where two generals had fallen within the space of thirty days, he who was to supply the place of them should be selected with unusual care. Some naming one person, and others another, they at length came to the resolution that the people should assemble for the purpose of electing a proconsul for Spain, and the consuls fixed a day for the election. At first they waited in expectation that those persons who might think themselves qualified for so momentous a command would give in their names, but this expectation being disappointed, their grief was renewed for the calamity they had suffered, and then regret for the generals they had lost. The people thus afflicted, and almost at their wits' end, came down, however, to the Campus Martius on the day of the election, where, turning towards the magistrates, they looked round at the countenances of their most eminent men, who were earnestly gazing at each other, and murmured bitterly, that their affairs were in so ruinous a state, and the condition of the commonwealth so desperate, that no one dared undertake the command in Spain. When suddenly Publius Cornelius, son of Publius who had fallen in Spain, who was about twenty-four years of age, declaring himself a candidate, took his station on an eminence from which he could be seen by all. The eyes of the whole assembly were directed towards him, and by acclamations and expressions of approbation, a prosperous and happy command were at once augured to him. Orders were then given that they should proceed to vote, when not only every century, but every individual to a man, decided that Publius Scipio should be invested with the command in Spain. But after the business had been concluded, and the ardour and impetuosity of their zeal had subsided, a sudden silence ensued, and a secret reflection on what they had done, whether their partiality had not got the better of their judgment? They chiefly regretted his youth, but some were terrified at the fortune which attended his house and his name, for while the two families to which he belonged were in mourning, he was going into a province where he must carry on his operations between the tombs of his father and his uncle.

During the time these events took place, neither did those regions of Spain that had revolted after the defeat return to the Romans, nor did any others abandon them. In Rome, after recovering Capua, the focus of the senate and the people was equally on Italy and Spain. They decided to increase the army there and send a general. However, they weren't sure who to send, since two generals had fallen within thirty days, so they felt the need to choose the new one with extra care. Some suggested one candidate, while others proposed another, ultimately deciding that the people should gather to elect a proconsul for Spain. The consuls set a date for the election. At first, they hoped that those who believed they were fit for such an important command would come forward, but as this didn't happen, their sorrow over their recent loss returned, along with regret for the generals they had lost. The distraught people came to the Campus Martius on election day, where they looked at the magistrates and observed the most prominent men silently exchanging glances. They murmured bitterly that their situation was so dire and the state of the republic so desperate that no one dared to take on command in Spain. Suddenly, Publius Cornelius, the son of the Publius who had fallen in Spain, who was about twenty-four years old, declared himself a candidate and stood on a raised platform where everyone could see him. All eyes were on him, and there were cheers and expressions of support, signaling a hopeful and successful command for him. Orders were given to proceed to voting, and not only every century but every single person unanimously decided that Publius Scipio should be given command in Spain. But once the election concluded and the initial excitement faded, a sudden silence fell, leading to a quiet reflection on whether their bias had clouded their judgment. They mainly regretted his youth, while some were anxious about the fortune tied to his family name, considering that while the two families he belonged to were in mourning, he was heading into a province where he would have to operate between the graves of his father and uncle.

19

Perceiving the solicitude and anxiety which people felt, after performing the business with so much ardour, he summoned an assembly, in which he discoursed in so noble and high minded a manner, on his years, the command intrusted to him, and the war which he had to carry on, as to rekindle and renew the ardour which had subsided, and inspire the people with more confident hopes than the reliance placed on human professions, or reasoning on the promising appearance of affairs, usually engenders. For Scipio was not only deserving of admiration for his real virtues, but also for his peculiar address in displaying them, to which he had been formed from his earliest years;--effecting many things with the multitude, either by feigning nocturnal visions or as with a mind divinely inspired; whether it was that he was himself, too, endued with a superstitious turn of mind, or that they might execute his commands and adopt his plans without hesitation, as if they proceeded from the responses of an oracle. With the intention of preparing men's minds for this from the beginning, he never at any time from his first assumption of the manly gown transacted any business, public or private, without first going to the Capitol, entering the temple, and taking his seat there; where he generally passed a considerable time in secret and alone. This practice, which was adhered to through the whole of his life, occasioned in some persons a belief in a notion which generally prevailed, whether designedly or undesignedly propagated, that he was a man of divine extraction; and revived a report equally absurd and fabulous with that formerly spread respecting Alexander the Great, that he was begotten by a huge serpent, whose monstrous form was frequently observed in the bedchamber of his mother, but which, on any one's coming in, suddenly unfolding his coils, glided out of sight. The belief in these miraculous accounts was never ridiculed by him, but rather increased by his address; neither positively denying any such thing nor openly affirming it. There were also many other things, some real and others counterfeit, which exceeded in the case of this young man the usual measure of human admiration, in reliance on which the state intrusted him with an affair of so much difficulty, and with so important a command, at an age by no means ripe for it. To the forces in Spain, consisting of the remains of the old army, and those which had been conveyed over from Puteoli by Claudius Nero, ten thousand infantry and a thousand horse were added; and Marcus Junius Silanus, the propraetor, was sent to assist in the management of affairs. Thus with a fleet of thirty ships, all of which were quinqueremes, he set sail from the mouth of the Tiber, and coasting along the shore of the Tuscan Sea, the Alps, and the Gallic Gulf, and then doubling the promontory of the Pyrenees, landed his troops at Emporiae, a Greek city, which also derived its origin from Phocaea. Ordering his ships to attend him, he marched by land to Tarraco; where he held a congress of deputies from all the allies; for embassies had poured forth from every province on the news of his arrival. Here he ordered his ships to be hauled on shore, having sent back the four triremes of the Massilians which had, in compliment to him, attended him from their home. After that, he began to give answers to the embassies of the several states, which had been in suspense on account of the many vicissitudes of the war; and this with so great dignity, arising from the great confidence he had in his own talents, that no presumptuous expression ever escaped him; and in every thing he said there appeared at once the greatest majesty and sincerity.

Noticing the concern and anxiety among people after they had put so much effort into their tasks, he called for a meeting where he spoke in a noble and inspiring way about his age, the command given to him, and the war he needed to wage. His aim was to rekindle their enthusiasm and give them greater confidence than what usually comes from trusting human promises or reasoning based on a seemingly favorable situation. Scipio was not only respected for his genuine virtues but also for his unique ability to showcase them, which he honed from a young age—achieving many things with the public either by pretending to have prophetic dreams or by appearing as though divinely inspired. Whether he genuinely had a superstitious mindset or simply wanted them to execute his orders and follow his plans without question, it made them act as if his commands were based on oracular guidance. To prepare people's minds for this from the start, he never engaged in any public or private matters without first visiting the Capitol, entering the temple, and sitting there; he often spent significant time in solitude. This practice throughout his life led some to believe a notion, whether intentionally or not propagated, that he was of divine origin, reviving a similarly absurd and fictional rumor about Alexander the Great, that he was fathered by a giant serpent often seen in his mother’s room but vanished when anyone entered. He never ridiculed the belief in these miraculous stories; instead, they grew due to his demeanor, as he neither clearly denied nor confirmed them. There were also many other things, some real and some fabricated, that surpassed the usual expectations of human admiration regarding this young man, leading the state to entrust him with such a challenging and significant command at a relatively immature age. To the forces in Spain, which included remnants of the old army and reinforcements from Puteoli brought by Claudius Nero, he added ten thousand infantry and a thousand cavalry, and Marcus Junius Silanus, the propraetor, was sent to help manage affairs. Thus, with a fleet of thirty quinqueremes, he set sail from the mouth of the Tiber, navigating along the shores of the Tuscan Sea, the Alps, and the Gallic Gulf, before rounding the Pyrenees and landing his troops at Emporiae, a Greek city originally founded by Phocaea. After having his ships follow him, he marched overland to Tarraco, where he convened a meeting with delegates from all the allies, as messages had flooded in from every province about his arrival. Here, he ordered his ships to be pulled ashore and sent back the four triremes from the Massilians that had, in honor of him, accompanied him from home. Following that, he began responding to the embassies from the various states, which had been in suspense due to the many changes in the war, doing so with such dignity fueled by his strong confidence in his own abilities that nothing presumptuous escaped his lips; everything he said reflected both great authority and sincerity.

20

Setting out from Tarraco, he visited the states of his allies and the winter quarters of his army; and bestowed the highest commendations upon the soldiers, because, though they had received two such disastrous blows in succession, they had retained possession of the province, and not allowing the enemy to reap any advantage from their successes, had excluded them entirely from the territory on this side of the Iberus, and honourably protected their allies. Marcius he kept with him, and treated him with such respect, that it was perfectly evident there was nothing he feared less than lest any one should stand in the way of his own glory. Silanus then took the place of Nero, and the fresh troops were led into winter quarters. Scipio having in good time visited every place where his presence was necessary, and completed every thing which was to be done, returned to Tarraco. The reputation of Scipio among his enemies was not inferior to that which he enjoyed among his allies and countrymen. They felt also a kind of presentiment of what was to come, which occasioned the greater apprehension, the less they could account for their fears, which had arisen without any cause. They had retired to their winter quarters in different directions. Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, had gone quite to the ocean and Gades; Mago into the midland parts chiefly above the forest of Castulo; Hasdrubal, son of Hamilcar, wintered in the neighbourhood of Saguntum, close upon the Iberus. At the close of the summer in which Capua was recovered and Scipio entered Spain, a Carthaginian fleet, which had been fetched from Sicily to Tarentum, to cut off the supplies of the Roman garrison in the citadel of that place, had blocked up all the approaches to the citadel from the sea; but by lying there too long, they caused a greater scarcity of provisions to their friends than to their enemies. For so much corn could not be brought in for the townsmen, along the coasts which were friendly to them, and through the ports which were kept open through the protection afforded by the Carthaginian fleet, as the fleet itself consumed, which had on board a crowd made up of every description of persons. So that the garrison of the citadel, which was small in number, could be supported from the stock they had previously laid in without importing any, while that which they imported was not sufficient for the supply of the Tarentines and the fleet. At length the fleet was sent away with greater satisfaction than it was received. The scarcity of provisions, however, was not much relieved by it; because when the protection by sea was removed corn could not be brought in.

Setting out from Tarraco, he visited the territories of his allies and the winter quarters of his army, and he praised the soldiers highly because, despite suffering two devastating defeats in a row, they managed to keep control of the province. They didn’t let the enemy take advantage of their victories and completely kept them out of the area on this side of the Iberus, while also honorably defending their allies. Marcius stayed with him and was treated so respectfully that it was clear he wasn’t worried about anyone blocking his own path to glory. Silanus then replaced Nero, and the new troops were taken into winter quarters. Scipio, having visited all the places where his presence was needed and completed everything that needed to be done, returned to Tarraco. Scipio’s reputation among his enemies was just as strong as it was among his allies and fellow countrymen. They also had a strange feeling of what was to come, which made them even more anxious, as they couldn’t explain their fear, which had arisen for no clear reason. They had settled into their winter quarters in various locations. Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, had gone all the way to the ocean and Gades; Mago moved to the midlands, mostly above the forest of Castulo; Hasdrubal, son of Hamilcar, spent the winter near Saguntum, close to the Iberus. At the end of the summer when Capua was reclaimed and Scipio entered Spain, a Carthaginian fleet had been brought from Sicily to Tarentum to cut off the supplies to the Roman garrison in the citadel there; it blocked all sea access to the citadel. However, by staying there too long, they created more food shortages for their allies than for their enemies. Not enough grain could be brought in for the townspeople through the friendly coastlines and ports that the Carthaginian fleet protected, compared to the amount the fleet itself consumed, carrying a crowd of all kinds of people. Thus, the garrison of the small citadel could rely on their previous stock without needing to import new supplies, while what they did import wasn’t enough for the Tarentines and the fleet. Eventually, the fleet was sent away with more relief than it had brought upon arrival. However, the food scarcity didn’t improve much because once the naval protection was lifted, grain could no longer be brought in.

21

At the close of the same summer, Marcus Marcellus arriving at the city from his province of Sicily, an audience of the senate was given him by Caius Calpurnius, the praetor, in the temple of Bellona. Here, after discoursing on the services he had performed, and complaining in gentle terms, not on his own account more than that of his soldiers, that after having completely reduced the province, he had not been allowed to bring home his army, he requested that he might be allowed to enter the city in triumph; this he did not obtain. A long debate took place on the question, whether it was less consistent to deny a triumph on his return to him, in whose name, when absent, a supplication had been decreed and honours paid to the immortal gods, for successes obtained under his conduct; or, when they had ordered him to deliver over his army to a successor, which would not have been decreed unless there were still war in the province, to allow him to triumph, as if the war had been terminated, when the army, the evidence of the triumph being deserved or undeserved, were absent. As a middle course between the two opinions, it was resolved that he should enter the city in ovation. The plebeian tribunes, by direction of the senate, proposed to the people, that Marcus Marcellus should be invested with command during the day on which he should enter the city in ovation. The day before he entered the city he triumphed on the Alban mount; after which he entered the city in ovation, having a great quantity of spoils carried before him, together with a model of the capture of Syracuse. The catapultas and ballistas, and every other instrument of war were carried; likewise the rich ornaments laid up by its kings during a long continuance of peace; a quantity of wrought silver and brass, and other articles, with precious garments, and a number of celebrated statues, with which Syracuse had been adorned in such a manner as to rank among the chief Grecian cities in that respect. Eight elephants were also led as an emblem of victory over the Carthaginians. Sosis, the Syracusan, and Mericus, the Spaniard, who preceded him with golden crowns, formed not the least interesting part of the spectacle; under the guidance of one of whom the Romans had entered Syracuse by night, while the other had betrayed to them the island and the garrison in it. To both of them the freedom of the city was given, and five hundred acres of land each. Sosis was to have his portion in the Syracusan territory, out of the lands which had belonged either to the kings or the enemies of the Roman people, together with a house at Syracuse, which had belonged to any one of those persons who had been punished according to the laws of war. Mericus and the Spaniards who had come over with him were ordered to have a city and lands assigned to them in Sicily, which had belonged to some of those who had revolted from the Romans. It was given in charge to Marcus Cornelius to assign them the city and lands wherever he thought proper. In the same country, four hundred acres of land were decreed to Belligenes, by whose means Mericus had been persuaded to come over. After the departure of Marcellus from Sicily, a Carthaginian fleet landed eight thousand infantry and three thousand Numidian cavalry. To these the Murgantian territories revolted; Hybla, Macella, and certain other towns of less note followed their defection. The Numidians also, headed by Mutines, ranging without restraint through the whole of Sicily, ravaged with fire the lands of the allies of the Romans. In addition to these unfortunate circumstances, the Roman soldiers, incensed partly because they had not been taken from the province with their general, and partly because they had been forbidden to winter in towns, discharged their duties negligently, and wanted a a leader more than inclination for a mutiny. Amid these difficulties Marcus Cornelius, the praetor, sometimes by soothing, at other times by reproving them, pacified the minds of the soldiers; and reduced to obedience all the states which had revolted; out of which he gave Murgantia to those Spaniards who were entitled to a city and land, in conformity with the decree of the senate.

At the end of that summer, Marcus Marcellus arrived in the city from his province of Sicily. Caius Calpurnius, the praetor, arranged for him to speak before the senate in the temple of Bellona. After discussing the contributions he had made and gently complaining—not just on his own behalf but also for his soldiers—that he had completely subdued the province and wasn't allowed to bring his army home, he asked for permission to enter the city in triumph, which he was denied. A lengthy debate followed about whether it was more reasonable to deny him a triumph when he had been honored for his successes even in his absence, or to allow him to triumph as if the war had ended, despite his army being away, which would indicate that the triumph was either justified or not. As a compromise, it was decided that he would enter the city in an ovation. The plebeian tribunes, under the senate's direction, proposed to the people that Marcus Marcellus should be given command for the day he entered the city in ovation. The day before he entered the city, he triumphed on the Alban Mount; after that, he entered the city in ovation, with a large amount of spoils carried before him, including a model of the capture of Syracuse. They brought catapults, ballistae, and every other kind of war tool, along with the rich spoils collected by its kings during a long period of peace—a significant amount of silver and bronze items, fine clothing, and numerous famous statues that made Syracuse stand out among prominent Greek cities. Eight elephants were also paraded as a symbol of victory over the Carthaginians. Sosis, the Syracusan, and Mericus, the Spaniard, led the procession wearing golden crowns, adding to the spectacle; one of them had guided the Romans into Syracuse at night, and the other had betrayed the island and its garrison. Both were granted citizenship and five hundred acres of land each. Sosis's land was to be in the Syracusan territory, taken from the lands belonging to either the kings or the enemies of Rome, along with a house in Syracuse that had previously belonged to someone punished according to the laws of war. Mericus and the Spaniards who came with him were assigned a city and lands in Sicily, taken from those who had revolted against the Romans. Marcus Cornelius was tasked with assigning them the city and land wherever he deemed appropriate. In that same region, four hundred acres of land were given to Belligenes, who had helped persuade Mericus to join them. After Marcellus left Sicily, a Carthaginian fleet landed eight thousand infantry and three thousand Numidian cavalry. This prompted the Murgantian territories to rebel; towns like Hybla, Macella, and a few lesser-known locations followed suit. The Numidians, led by Mutines, roamed freely across Sicily, burning the lands of the Roman allies. Adding to these unfortunate events, the Roman soldiers grew frustrated, partly because they had not been taken from the province with their general and partly because they were prohibited from wintering in towns, leading them to neglect their duties and seek a leader more than planning a mutiny. In these challenging times, Marcus Cornelius, the praetor, calmed the soldiers' unrest through comforting them at times and reprimanding them at others; he brought all the states that had revolted back under control and granted Murgantia to those Spaniards entitled to a city and land according to the senate's decree.

22

As both the consuls had Apulia for their province, and as there was now less to be apprehended from Hannibal and the Carthaginians, they were directed to draw lots for the provinces of Apulia and Macedonia. Macedonia fell to the lot of Sulpicius, who succeeded Laevinus. Fulvius having been called to Rome on account of the election, held an assembly to elect new consuls; when the junior Veturian century, which had the right of voting first, named Titus Manlius Torquatus and Titus Otacilius. A crowd collecting round Manlius, who was present, to congratulate him, and it being certain that the people would concur in his election, he went, surrounded as he was with a multitude of persons, to the tribunal of the consul, and requested that he would listen to a few words from him; and that he would order the century which had voted to be recalled. While all present were waiting impatiently to hear what it was he was going to ask, he alleged as an excuse the weakness of his eyes; observing, that "a pilot or a general might fairly be charged with presumption who should request that the lives and fortunes of others might be intrusted to him, when in every thing which was to be done he must make use of other people's eyes. Therefore he requested, that, if it seemed good to him, he would order the junior Veturian century to come and vote again; and to recollect, while electing consuls, the war which they had in Italy, and the present exigencies of the state. That their ears had scarcely yet ceased to ring with the noise and tumult raised by the enemy, when but a few months ago they nearly scaled the walls of Rome." This speech was followed by the century's shouting out, one and all, that "they would not in the least alter their vote, but would name the same persons for consuls;" when Torquatus replied, "neither shall I as consul be able to put up with your conduct, nor will you be satisfied with my government. Go back and vote again, and consider that you have a Punic war in Italy, and that the leader of your enemies is Hannibal." Upon this the century, moved by the authority of the man and the shouts of admirers around, besought the consul to summon the elder Veturian century; for they were desirous of conferring with persons older than themselves, and to name the consuls in accordance with their advice. The elder Veturian century having been summoned, time was allowed them to confer with the others by themselves in the ovile. The elders said that there were three persons whom they ought to deliberate about electing, two of them having already served all the offices of honour, namely, Quintus Fabius and Marcus Marcellus; and if they wished so particularly to elect some fresh person as consul to act against the Carthaginians, that Marcus Valerius Laevinus had carried on operations against king Philip by sea and land with signal success. Thus, three persons having been proposed to them to deliberate about, the seniors were dismissed, and the juniors proceeded to vote. They named as consuls, Marcus Claudius Marcellus, then glorious with the conquest of Sicily, and Marcus Valerius, both in their absence. All the centuries followed the recommendation of that which voted first. Let men now ridicule the admirers of antiquity. Even if there existed a republic of wise men, which the learned rather imagine than know of; for my own part I cannot persuade myself that there could possibly be a nobility of sounder judgment, and more moderate in their desire of power, or a people better moralled. Indeed that a century of juniors should have been willing to consult their elders, as to the persons to whom they should intrust a command by their vote, is rendered scarcely probable by the contempt and levity with which the parental authority is treated by children in the present age.

As both consuls were assigned to Apulia and there was now less to fear from Hannibal and the Carthaginians, they were instructed to draw lots for the provinces of Apulia and Macedonia. Sulpicius drew Macedonia, taking over from Laevinus. Fulvius was called to Rome for the election and held an assembly to elect new consuls; the junior Veturian century, which had the right to vote first, chose Titus Manlius Torquatus and Titus Otacilius. A crowd gathered around Manlius, who was present, to congratulate him, and since it was clear the people would support his election, he went, surrounded by a multitude, to the consul’s tribunal and asked for a moment to speak; he also requested that the century which had voted be called back. While everyone waited eagerly to hear his request, he cited his poor eyesight as an excuse, stating that “a pilot or a general would be presumptuous to ask for the lives and wealth of others to be entrusted to him when he had to rely on someone else's sight for everything.” Therefore, he asked that, if it pleased him, the junior Veturian century be recalled to vote again, considering the war in Italy and the current state of affairs. He reminded them that their ears had barely recovered from the noise raised by the enemy, as just a few months ago they almost scaled the walls of Rome. Following this, the century shouted unanimously that “they wouldn’t change their vote at all and would name the same consuls;” to which Torquatus replied, “neither will I as consul tolerate your actions, nor will you be satisfied with my leadership. Go back and vote again, keeping in mind that there is a Punic war in Italy and your enemy's leader is Hannibal.” Moved by his authority and the cheers of those around him, the century asked the consul to summon the elder Veturian century; they wanted to discuss with someone older and choose the consuls based on their advice. Once the elder Veturian century was called in, they had time to consult among themselves in the ovile. The elders mentioned there were three candidates they should consider electing; two of them had already held all the honorable offices: Quintus Fabius and Marcus Marcellus. They suggested that if they wanted to elect someone new to fight against the Carthaginians, Marcus Valerius Laevinus had successfully campaigned against King Philip both at sea and on land. After proposing these three candidates for deliberation, the seniors were dismissed, and the juniors proceeded to vote. They elected Marcus Claudius Marcellus, who had just achieved glory from the conquest of Sicily, and Marcus Valerius, both while they were absent. All the centuries followed the recommendation of the one that voted first. Let people now mock the admirers of the past. Even if there were a republic of wise individuals, which scholars often imagine rather than actually know; for my part, I cannot believe that there could be a nobility with better judgment, more moderation in their desire for power, or a more morally upright populace. In fact, the idea that a group of younger citizens would seek advice from their elders regarding whom to trust with command by their vote seems highly unlikely, given the disdain and recklessness with which parental authority is treated by children today.

23

The assembly for the election of praetors was then held, at which Publius Manlius Vulso, Lucius Manlius Acidinus, Caius Laetorius, and Lucius Cincius Alimentus were elected. It happened that just as the elections were concluded, news was brought that Titus Otacilius, whom it seemed the people would have made consul in his absence, with Titus Manlius, had not the course of the elections been interrupted, had died in Sicily. The games in honour of Apollo had been performed the preceding year, and on the motion of Calpurnius, the praetor, that they should be performed this year also, the senate decreed that they should be vowed every year for the time to come. The same year several prodigies were seen and reported. At the temple of Concord, a statue of Victory, which stood on the roof, having been struck by lightning and thrown down, stuck among the figures of Victory, which were among the ornaments under the eaves, and did not fall to the ground from thence. Both from Anagnia and Fregellae it was reported that a wall and some gates had been struck by lightning. That in the forum of Sudertum streams of blood had continued flowing through a whole day; at Eretum, that there had been a shower of stones; and at Reate, that a mule had brought forth. These prodigies were expiated with victims of the larger sort, the people were commanded to offer up prayers for one day, and perform the nine days' sacred rite. Several of the public priests died off this year, and fresh ones were appointed. In the room of Manius Aemilius Numida, decemvir for sacred rites, Marcus Aemilius Lepidus was appointed; in the room of Manius Pomponius Matho, the pontiff, Caius Livius; in the room of Spurius Carvilius Maximus, the augur, Marcus Servilius. As Titus Otacilius Crassus, a pontiff, died after the year was concluded, no person was nominated to succeed him. Caius Claudius, flamen of Jupiter, retired from his office, because he had distributed the entrails improperly.

The assembly for the election of praetors was held, where Publius Manlius Vulso, Lucius Manlius Acidinus, Caius Laetorius, and Lucius Cincius Alimentus were elected. Just as the elections wrapped up, news came that Titus Otacilius, who seemed likely to be made consul in his absence, along with Titus Manlius, had died in Sicily because the elections were interrupted. The games in honor of Apollo were held the previous year, and following a suggestion from Calpurnius, the praetor, to hold them again this year, the senate decided they should be celebrated annually from now on. That same year, several prodigies were reported. At the temple of Concord, a statue of Victory on the roof was struck by lightning and fell among the figures of Victory that were part of the decorations under the eaves, instead of hitting the ground. Reports came from both Anagnia and Fregellae that a wall and some gates had been struck by lightning. In the forum of Sudertum, streams of blood flowed continuously for an entire day; at Eretum, there was a shower of stones; and at Reate, a mule gave birth. These prodigies were atoned for with larger victims, and the people were instructed to offer prayers for a day and perform a nine-day sacred rite. Several public priests died this year, and new ones were appointed. Marcus Aemilius Lepidus was appointed in place of Manius Aemilius Numida, the decemvir for sacred rites; Caius Livius took over from Manius Pomponius Matho, the pontiff; and Marcus Servilius replaced Spurius Carvilius Maximus, the augur. Since Titus Otacilius Crassus, a pontiff, died after the year ended, no one was chosen to succeed him. Caius Claudius, flamen of Jupiter, stepped down from his position because he mishandled the entrails.

24

During the same time Marcus Valerius Laevinus, having first sounded the intentions of the leading men by means of secret conferences, came with some light ships to a council of the Aetolians, which had been previously appointed to meet for this very purpose. Here having proudly pointed to the capture of Syracuse and Capua, as proofs of the success of the Roman arms in Sicily and Italy, he added, that "it was a custom with the Romans, handed down to them from their ancestors, to respect their allies; some of whom they had received into their state, and had admitted to the same privileges they enjoyed themselves, while others they treated so favourably that they chose rather to be allies than citizens. That the Aetolians would be honoured by them so much the more, because they were the first of the nations across the sea which had entered into friendship with them. That Philip and the Macedonians were troublesome neighbours to them, but that he had broken their strength and spirits already, and would still further reduce them to that degree, that they should not only evacuate the cities which they had violently taken from the Aetolians, but have Macedonia itself disturbed with war. And that as to the Acarnanians, whose separation from their body was a source of grief to the Aetolians, he would place them again under their ancient system of jurisdiction and dominion." These assertions and promises of the Roman general, Scopas, who was at that time praetor of the nation, and Dorymachus, a leading man among the Aetolians, confirmed on their own authority, extolling the power and greatness of the Roman people with less reserve, and with greater force of conviction. However, the hope of recovering Acarnania principally moved them. The terms, therefore, were reduced to writing, on which they should enter into alliance and friendship with the Roman people, and it was added, that "if it were agreeable to them and they wished it, the Eleans and Lacedaemonians, with Attalus, Pleuratus, and Scerdilaedas, should be included on the same conditions." Attalus was king of Asia; the latter, kings of the Thracians and Illyrians. The conditions were, that "the Aetolians should immediately make war on Philip by land, in which the Romans should assist, with not less than twenty quinqueremes. That the site and buildings, together with the walls and lands, of all the cities as far as Corcyra, should become the property of the Aetolians, every other kind of booty, of the Romans. That the Romans should endeavour to put the Aetolians in possession of Acarnania. If the Aetolians should make peace with Philip, they should insert a stipulation that the peace should stand good only on condition that they abstained from hostilities against the Romans, their allies, and the states subject to them. In like manner, if the Romans should form an alliance with the king, that they should provide that he should not have liberty to make war upon the Aetolians and their allies." Such were the terms agreed upon; and copies of them having been made, they were laid up two years afterwards by the Aetolians at Olympia, and by the Romans in the Capitol, that they might be attested by these consecrated records. The delay had been occasioned by the Aetolian ambassadors' having been detained at Rome. This, however, did not form an impediment to the war's proceeding. Both the Aetolians immediately commenced war against Philip, and Laevinus taking, all but the citadel, Zacynthus, a small island near to Aetolia, and having one city of the same name with the island; and also taking Aeniadae and Nasus from the Acarnanians, annexed them to the Aetolians; and also considering that Philip was sufficiently engaged in war with his neighbours to prevent his thinking of Italy, the Carthaginians, and his compact with Hannibal, he retired to Corcyra.

During the same period, Marcus Valerius Laevinus, after secretly assessing the intentions of the key leaders in private meetings, arrived with a few light ships for a council of the Aetolians, which had been organized specifically for this purpose. Here, he confidently highlighted the capture of Syracuse and Capua as evidence of the success of Roman forces in Sicily and Italy. He noted that "the Romans have a tradition passed down from their ancestors to respect their allies; some of whom they have welcomed into their state and granted the same privileges they enjoy, while others they have treated so favorably that those allies choose to remain allies rather than become citizens. The Aetolians would be honored even more because they were the first nation across the sea to establish friendship with them. He mentioned Philip and the Macedonians as bothersome neighbors, asserting that he had already weakened their power and morale, and would further diminish them to the point where they would not only leave the cities they had seized from the Aetolians but also suffer from war within Macedonia itself. Regarding the Acarnanians, whose separation had caused the Aetolians distress, he promised to restore them to their former governance and authority." These claims and promises from the Roman general were confirmed by Scopas, the praetor of the nation at that time, and Dorymachus, a prominent Aetolian leader, who spoke highly of the strength and greatness of the Roman people with greater conviction. However, the primary motivation for them was the hope of recovering Acarnania. Consequently, the terms of their alliance and friendship with the Roman people were put in writing, including the stipulation that "if agreeable to them, the Eleans and Lacedaemonians, along with Attalus, Pleuratus, and Scerdilaedas, should be included under the same conditions." Attalus was the king of Asia, while the others were kings of the Thracians and Illyrians. The terms specified that "the Aetolians should immediately wage war against Philip on land, with the Romans providing support using no less than twenty quinqueremes. That the site and structures, along with the walls and lands of all cities up to Corcyra, would belong to the Aetolians, with all other forms of plunder going to the Romans. That the Romans would work to help the Aetolians regain Acarnania. If the Aetolians made peace with Philip, they must include a clause that the peace would only hold if they did not engage in hostilities against the Romans, their allies, or the states under their control. Similarly, if the Romans allied with the king, they must ensure that he would not have the freedom to wage war against the Aetolians or their allies." These were the agreed terms; copies were made and stored—two years later by the Aetolians at Olympia and by the Romans in the Capitol—to be validated by these sacred records. The delay had resulted from the Aetolian ambassadors being held up in Rome. However, this did not stop the war from continuing. The Aetolians quickly declared war on Philip, while Laevinus captured almost all of Zacynthus, a small island near Aetolia with a city of the same name; he also took Aeniadae and Nasus from the Acarnanians, adding them to the Aetolians. Considering that Philip was already occupied with conflicts with his neighbors and would not be focused on Italy or his alliance with Hannibal, he withdrew to Corcyra.

25

To Philip intelligence of the defection of the Aetolians was brought while in winter quarters at Pella. As he was about to march an army into Greece at the beginning of the spring, he undertook a sudden expedition into the territories of Oricum and Apollonia, in order that Macedonia might not be molested by the Illyrians, and the cities bordering upon them, in consequence of the terror he would thus strike them with in turn. The Apollonians came out to oppose him, but he drove them, terrified and dismayed, within their walls. After devastating the adjacent parts of Illyricum he turned his course into Pelagonia, with the same expedition. He then took Sintia, a town of the Dardanians, which would have afforded them a passage into Macedonia. Having with the greatest despatch performed these achievements, not forgetting the war made upon him by the Aetolians and Romans in conjunction, he marched down into Thessaly through Pelagonia, Lyncus, and Bottiaea. He trusted that people might be induced to take part with him in the war against the Aetolians, and, therefore, leaving Perseus with four thousand armed men at the gorge, which formed the entrance into Thessaly, to prevent the Aetolians from passing it, before he should be occupied with more important business, he marched his army into Macedonia, and thence into Thrace and Maedica. This nation had been accustomed to make incursions into Macedonia when they perceived the king engaged in a foreign war, and the kingdom left unprotected. Accordingly, he began to devastate the lands in the neighbourhood of Phragandae, and to lay siege to the city Jamphorina, the capital and chief fortress of Maedica. Scopas, on hearing that the king had gone into Thrace, and was engaged in a war there, armed all the Aetolian youths, and prepared to invade Acarnania. The Acarnanian nation, unequal to their enemy in point of strength, and seeing that they had lost Aeniadae and Nasus, and moreover that the Roman arms were threatening them, prepare the war rather with rage than prudence. Having sent their wives, children, and those who were above sixty years old into the neighbouring parts of Epirus, all who were between the ages of fifteen and sixty, bound each other by an oath not to return unless victorious. That no one might receive into his city or house, or admit to his table or hearth, such as should retire from the field vanquished, they drew up a form of direful execration against their countrymen who should do so; and the most solemn entreaty they could devise, to friendly states. At the same time they entreated the Epirotes to bury in one tomb such of their men as should fall in the encounter, adding this inscription over their remains: HERE LIE THE ACARNANIANS, WHO DIED WHILE FIGHTING IN DEFENCE OF THEIR COUNTRY, AGAINST THE VIOLENCE AND INJUSTICE OF THE AETOLIANS. Having worked up their courage to the highest pitch by these means, they fixed their camp at the extreme borders of their country in the way of the enemy; and sending messengers to Philip to inform him of the critical situation in which they stood, they obliged him to suspend the war in which he was engaged, though he had gained possession of Jamphorina by surrender, and had succeeded in other respects. The ardour of the Aetolians was damped, in the first instance, by the news of the combination formed by the Acarnanians; but afterwards the intelligence of Philip's approach compelled them even to retreat into the interior of the country. Nor did Philip proceed farther than Dium, though he had marched with great expedition to prevent the Acarnanians being overpowered; and when he had received information that the Aetolians had returned out of Acarnania, he also returned to Pella.

To Philip, news of the Aetolians' defection reached him while he was wintering at Pella. As he was getting ready to lead an army into Greece at the start of spring, he launched a sudden campaign into the territories of Oricum and Apollonia to ensure Macedonia wouldn't be disturbed by the Illyrians and the nearby cities, aiming to instill fear in them. The people of Apollonia came out to confront him, but he drove them back, terrified and shaken, into their city. After ravaging the surrounding areas of Illyricum, he redirected his efforts to Pelagonia with the same force. He then captured Sintia, a town of the Dardanians, which would have given them a route into Macedonia. After quickly accomplishing these tasks, and mindful of the war against him by the Aetolians and Romans together, he marched down into Thessaly through Pelagonia, Lyncus, and Bottiaea. He hoped to convince the locals to join him in the war against the Aetolians, so he left Perseus with four thousand armed men at the narrow pass leading into Thessaly to block the Aetolians from getting through, before he engaged in more significant business. He then moved his army into Macedonia, and from there into Thrace and Maedica. This region had been known to raid Macedonia whenever they saw the king occupied with a foreign war and the kingdom left vulnerable. Accordingly, he started to devastate the lands near Phragandae and laid siege to the city of Jamphorina, the main stronghold of Maedica. Scopas, upon learning that the king had gone into Thrace and was involved in a war there, armed all the young Aetolians and prepared to invade Acarnania. The Acarnanians, not having the strength to match their enemy and seeing they had already lost Aeniadae and Nasus, coupled with the looming threat of Roman forces, prepared for war more out of anger than strategy. They sent their wives, children, and those over sixty to safer areas in Epirus, and everyone between the ages of fifteen and sixty swore an oath not to return unless victorious. They created a harsh curse against any countrymen who would take in the defeated, ensuring that no one would offer shelter or hospitality to those who retreated. They also made a solemn request to friendly states. At the same time, they asked the Epirotes to bury their fallen in a shared grave, with this inscription over their remains: HERE LIE THE ACARNANIANS, WHO DIED FIGHTING IN DEFENSE OF THEIR COUNTRY AGAINST THE VIOLENCE AND INJUSTICE OF THE AETOLIANS. With their spirits emboldened by these actions, they set up camp at the far edge of their territory in the path of the enemy. They sent messengers to Philip to inform him of their critical situation, forcing him to pause the campaign he was engaged in, even though he had captured Jamphorina by surrender and achieved other successes. The Aetolians' enthusiasm initially waned upon hearing of the Acarnanians' alliance, but later the news of Philip's approach made them retreat deeper into their territory. Philip did not advance beyond Dium, even though he had rushed to prevent the Acarnanians from being overwhelmed; and when he learned that the Aetolians had pulled back from Acarnania, he returned to Pella.

26

Laevinus set sail from Corcyra in the beginning of the spring, and doubling the promontory Leucate, arrived at Naupactus; when he gave notice that he should go thence to Anticyra, in order that Scopas and the Aetolians might be ready there to join him. Anticyra is situated in Locris, on the left hand as you enter the Corinthian Gulf. The distance between Naupactus and this place is short both by sea and land. In about three days after, the attack upon this place commenced on both elements. The attack from the sea produced the greatest effect, because there were on board the ships engines and machines of every description, and because the Romans besieged from that quarter. In a few days, therefore, the town surrendered, and was delivered over to the Aetolians, the booty, according to compact, was given up to the Romans. Laevinus then received a letter informing him, that he had been elected consul in his absence, and that Publius Sulpicius was coming as his successor. He arrived at Rome later than he was generally expected, being detained by a lingering illness. Marcus Marcellus, having entered upon the consulship on the ides of March, assembled the senate on that day merely for form's sake He declared, that "in the absence of his colleague he would not enter into any question relative to the state or the provinces." He said, "he well knew there were crowds of Sicilians in the neighbourhood of the city at the country-houses of those who maligned him, whom he was so far from wishing to prevent from openly publishing, at Rome, the charges which had been circulated and got up against him by his enemies, that did they not pretend that they entertained some fear of speaking of a consul in the absence of his colleague, he would forthwith have given them a hearing of the senate. That when his colleague had arrived, he would not allow any business to be transacted before the Sicilians were brought before the senate. That Marcus Cornelius had in a manner held a levy throughout all Sicily, in order that as many as possible might come to Rome to prefer complaints against him, that the same person had filled the city with letters containing false representations that there was still war in Sicily, in order to detract from his merit." The consul, having acquired on that day the reputation of having a well-regulated mind, dismissed the senate, and it appeared that there would be almost a total suspension of every kind of business till the other consul returned to the city. The want of employment, as usual, produced expressions of discontent among the people. They complained of the length of the war, that the lands around the city were devastated wherever Hannibal had marched his hostile troops; that Italy was exhausted by levies, and that almost every year their armies were cut to pieces, that the consuls elected were both of them fond of war, men over-enterprising and impetuous, who would probably stir up war in a time of profound peace, and therefore were the less likely to allow the state to breathe in time of war.

Laevinus set sail from Corcyra at the start of spring and, after rounding the promontory Leucate, arrived at Naupactus. There, he announced that he would be heading to Anticyra so that Scopas and the Aetolians could be prepared to join him. Anticyra is located in Locris, on the left side as you enter the Corinthian Gulf. The distance between Naupactus and this location is short, both by sea and land. About three days later, the attack on this place began from both land and sea. The assault from the sea had the most impact because the ships were equipped with various engines and machines, and the Romans attacked from that direction. Consequently, the town surrendered in just a few days and was handed over to the Aetolians, with the spoils, as agreed, given to the Romans. Laevinus then received a letter informing him that he had been elected consul while he was away and that Publius Sulpicius would be coming as his successor. He arrived in Rome later than expected due to a lingering illness. Marcus Marcellus, having taken on the consulship on the Ides of March, convened the Senate that day merely for formality. He stated that "in the absence of his colleague, he would not discuss any matters concerning the state or the provinces." He mentioned, "he was aware that there were many Sicilians near the city staying at the country houses of those who opposed him, and he didn’t want to stop them from publicly discussing the accusations made against him by his enemies. If they didn’t pretend to be afraid of speaking about a consul in the absence of his colleague, he would have immediately invited them to hear the Senate. When his colleague arrived, he would not allow any business to take place until the Sicilians were brought before the Senate. Marcus Cornelius had, in effect, conducted a levy throughout Sicily to ensure as many as possible came to Rome to complain about him; that the same individual had filled the city with letters falsely claiming there was still a war in Sicily to diminish his achievements." The consul, having gained a reputation that day for having a stable mind, dismissed the Senate, and it seemed that there would be an almost complete halt to all business until the other consul returned to the city. As usual, the lack of activity led to discontent among the people. They complained about the prolonged war, that the lands around the city were devastated wherever Hannibal's troops had gone, that Italy was worn out by military levies, and that nearly every year their armies were decimated. They expressed concern that both newly elected consuls were war-hungry, overly ambitious, and likely to incite conflict even in a time of peace, making it less probable that the state would have any respite during wartime.

27

A fire which broke out in several places at once in the neighbourhood of the forum, on the night before the festival of Minerva, interrupted these discourses. Seven shops, where five were afterwards erected, and the banks, which are now called the new banks, were all on fire at once. Afterwards the private dwellings caught, for there were no public halls there then, the prisons called the Quarry, the fish-market, and the royal palace. The temple of Vesta was with difficulty saved, principally by the exertions of thirteen slaves, who were redeemed at the public expense and manumitted. The fire continued for a day and a night. It was evident to every body that it was caused by human contrivance, because the flames burst forth in several places at once, and those at a distance from each other. The consul, therefore, on the recommendation of the senate, publicly notified, that whoever should make known by whose act the conflagration was kindled, should rewarded, if a free-man, with money, if a slave, with liberty. Induced by this reward, a slave of the Campanian family, the Calavii, named Mannus, gave information that "his masters, with five noble Campanian youths, whose parents had been executed by Fulvius, were the authors of the fire, and that they would commit various other acts of the same kind if they were not seized." Upon this they were seized, as well as their slaves. At first, the informer and his evidence were disparaged, for that "he had run away from his masters the day before in consequence of a whipping, and that from an event which had happened by mere chance, he had fabricated this charge, from resentment and wantonness." But when they were charged by their accusers face to face, and the ministers of their villanies begin to be examined in the middle of the forum, they all confessed, and punishment was inflicted upon the masters and their accessory slaves. The informer received his liberty and twenty thousand asses. The consul Laevinus, while passing by Capua, was surrounded by a multitude of Campanians, who besought him, with tears, that they might be permitted to go to Rome to the senate, so that if they could at length be in any degree moved by compassion, they might not carry their resentment so far as to destroy them utterly, nor suffer the very name of the Campanian nation to be obliterated by Quintus Flaccus. Flaccus declared, that "he had individually no quarrel with the Campanians, but that he did entertain an enmity towards them on public grounds and because they were foes, and should continue to do so as long as he felt assured that they had the same feelings towards the Roman people; for that there was no nation or people on earth more inveterate against the Roman name. That his reason for keeping them shut up within their walls was, that if any of these got out any where they roamed through the country like wild beasts, tearing and massacring whatever fell in their way. That some of them had deserted to Hannibal, others had gone and set fire to Rome; that the consul would find the traces of the villany of the Campanians in the half-burnt forum. That the temple of Vesta, the eternal fire, and the fatal pledge for the continuance of the Roman empire deposited in the shrine, had been the objects of their attack. That in his opinion it was extremely unsafe for any Campanians to be allowed to enter the walls of Rome." Laevinus ordered the Campanians to follow him to Rome, after Flaccus had bound them by an oath to return to Capua on the fifth day after receiving an answer from the senate. Surrounded by this crowd, and followed also by the Sicilians and Aeolians, who came out to meet him, he went to Rome; taking with him into the city as accusers of two men who had acquired the greatest celebrity by the overthrow of two most renowned cities, those whom they had vanquished in war. Both the consuls, however, first proposed to the senate the consideration of the state of the commonwealth, and the arrangements respecting the provinces.

A fire broke out in multiple locations around the forum on the night before the Minerva festival, interrupting important discussions. Seven shops, where five were later built, and what are now known as the new banks, were all ablaze at once. Eventually, private homes caught fire since there were no public halls at that time, along with the Quarry prisons, the fish market, and the royal palace. The temple of Vesta was barely saved, mainly due to the efforts of thirteen slaves who were redeemed with public funds and freed. The fire raged for a day and a night. It was clear to everyone that it was intentionally started because the flames erupted in several locations simultaneously, and they were far apart from each other. Therefore, the consul, upon the senate's advice, publicly announced that anyone who revealed how the fire started would be rewarded—free men would receive money while slaves would be granted freedom. Encouraged by this reward, a slave from the Campanian family, the Calavii, named Mannus, reported that "his masters, along with five noble Campanian youths whose parents had been executed by Fulvius, were responsible for the fire, and they would carry out other attacks if they weren't apprehended." As a result, they were captured, along with their slaves. Initially, the informant and his claims were dismissed because "he had fled from his masters the day before due to a beating, and he had fabricated this accusation out of spite and stubbornness from a random event." However, when the accused were confronted by their accusers in the forum, and the details of their crimes began to be investigated, they all confessed, and punishment was handed down to both the masters and their guilty slaves. The informant received his freedom and twenty thousand asses. While passing through Capua, Consul Laevinus was surrounded by a crowd of Campanians, who tearfully asked him to allow them to go to Rome to the senate so they could appeal for compassion and prevent their complete destruction and the erasure of the Campanian name by Quintus Flaccus. Flaccus stated that "he personally had no issue with the Campanians, but he held a public grudge against them as enemies, and would continue to do so as long as he believed they felt the same way about the Roman people, since no nation hated the Roman name more. His reason for keeping them confined was that if any of them escaped, they would rampage through the land like wild beasts, slaughtering whatever they came across. Some had deserted to Hannibal, while others had set fire to Rome; the consul would find evidence of the Campanians’ wrongdoing in the half-burnt forum. The temple of Vesta, the eternal fire, and the sacred trust for the continuation of the Roman empire kept in the shrine had all been targeted. In his view, it was extremely dangerous to allow any Campanians inside Rome's walls." Laevinus ordered the Campanians to follow him to Rome after Flaccus made them swear to return to Capua five days after receiving a response from the senate. Accompanied by this crowd, and followed by Sicilians and Aeolians who had come out to greet him, he went to Rome, bringing with him accusers of two men who had gained notoriety from the overthrow of two great cities—those whom they had defeated in battle. However, both consuls first presented the state of the commonwealth and the plans regarding the provinces to the senate.

28

On this occasion Laevinus reported the state of Macedonia and Greece, of the Aetolians, Acarnanians, and Locrians, and the services he had himself performed there on sea and land. That "Philip, who was bringing an army against the Aetolians, had been driven back by him into Macedonia, and compelled to retire into the heart of his kingdom. That the legion might therefore be withdrawn from that quarter, and that the fleet was sufficient to keep the king out of Italy." Thus much he said respecting himself and the province where he had commanded. The consuls jointly proposed the consideration of the provinces, when the senate decreed, that, "Italy and the war with Hannibal should form the province of one of the consuls; that the other should have the command of the fleet which Titus Otacilius had commanded, and the province of Sicily, in conjunction with Lucius Cincius, the praetor." The two armies decreed to them were those in Etruria and Gaul, consisting of four legions. That the two city legions of the former year should be sent into Etruria and the two which Sulpicius, the consul, had commanded, into Gaul; that he should have the command of Gaul, and the legions there whom the consul, who had the province of Italy, should appoint. Caius Calpurnius, having his command continued to him for a year after the expiration of his praetorship, was sent into Etruria. To Quintus Fulvius also the province of Capua was decreed, with his command continued for a year. The army of citizens and allies was ordered to be reduced, so that, out of two, one legion should be formed consisting of five thousand foot and three hundred horse, those being discharged who had served the greatest number of campaigns. That of the allies there should be left seven thousand infantry and three hundred horse, the same rule being observed with regard to the periods of their service in discharging the old soldiers. With Cneius Fulvius, the consul of the former year, no change was made touching his province of Apulia nor his army; only he was continued in command for a year. Publius Sulpicius, his colleague, was ordered to discharge the whole of his army excepting the marines. It was ordered also, that the army which Marcus Cornelius had commanded, should be sent out of Sicily as soon as the consul arrived in his province. The soldiers which had fought at Cannae, amounting to two legions, were assigned to Lucius Cincius, the praetor, for the occupation of Sicily. As many legions were assigned to Publius Manlius Vulso, the praetor, for Sardinia, being those which Lucius Cornelius had commanded in that province the former year. The consuls were directed so to raise legions for the service of the city, as not to enlist any one who had served in the armies of Marcus Claudius, Marcus Valerius, or Quintus Fulvius, so that the Roman legions might not exceed twenty-one that year.

On this occasion, Laevinus reported on the situation in Macedonia and Greece, specifically regarding the Aetolians, Acarnanians, and Locrians, as well as the efforts he had made there on both land and sea. He said that "Philip, who was leading an army against the Aetolians, had been pushed back by him into Macedonia and forced to retreat to the center of his kingdom. As a result, the legion could be pulled back from that region, as the fleet was enough to keep the king out of Italy." He shared this information about himself and the province where he had commanded. The consuls proposed discussing the provinces together, and the senate decided that "Italy and the war with Hannibal would be assigned as the province of one of the consuls; the other would oversee the fleet that Titus Otacilius had commanded, along with the province of Sicily, in partnership with Lucius Cincius, the praetor." The two armies assigned to them were in Etruria and Gaul, consisting of four legions. The two city legions from the previous year would be sent to Etruria, and the two commanded by Sulpicius, the consul, would go to Gaul; he would be in charge of Gaul and the legions there that the consul in charge of Italy would appoint. Caius Calpurnius, having his position extended for a year following his praetorship, was sent to Etruria. The province of Capua was also assigned to Quintus Fulvius, with his command extended for a year. The citizen and ally army was to be reduced, forming one legion from two, consisting of five thousand infantry and three hundred cavalry, discharging those who had served the longest. From the allies, seven thousand infantry and three hundred cavalry would remain, following the same guidelines for discharging the older soldiers. There was no change for Cneius Fulvius regarding his province of Apulia or his army; he was simply extended for another year in command. Publius Sulpicius was instructed to discharge his entire army except for the marines. It was also ordered that the army previously commanded by Marcus Cornelius would be taken out of Sicily as soon as the consul arrived in his province. The soldiers who fought at Cannae, totaling two legions, were assigned to Lucius Cincius, the praetor, for the occupation of Sicily. The same number of legions was assigned to Publius Manlius Vulso, the praetor, for Sardinia, those being the ones Lucius Cornelius commanded in that province the previous year. The consuls were instructed to raise legions for city service without enlisting anyone who had served in the armies of Marcus Claudius, Marcus Valerius, or Quintus Fulvius, ensuring that the Roman legions did not exceed twenty-one that year.

29

After the senate had passed these decrees, the consuls drew lots for their provinces. Sicily and the fleet fell to the lot of Marcellus; Italy, with the war against Hannibal, to Laevinus. This result so terrified the Sicilians, who were standing in sight of the consuls waiting the determination of the lots, that their bitter lamentations and mournful cries both drew upon them the eyes of all at the time, and afterwards furnished matter for conversation. For they went round to the several senators in mourning garments, affirming, that "they would not only abandon, each of them, his native country, but all Sicily, if Marcellus should again go thither with command. That he had formerly been implacable toward them for no demerit of theirs, what would he do now, when exasperated that they had come to Rome to complain of him? That it would be better for that island to be overwhelmed with the fires of Aetna, or sunk in the sea, than to be delivered up, as it were, for execution to an enemy." These complaints of the Sicilians, having been carried round to the houses of the nobility, and frequently canvassed in conversations, which were prompted partly by compassion for the Sicilians and partly by dislike for Marcellus, at length reached the senate also. The consuls were requested to take the sense of the senate on an exchange of provinces. Marcellus said, that "if the Sicilians had already had an audience of the senate, his opinion perhaps might have been different, but as the case now stood, lest any one should be able to say that they were prevented by fear from freely venting their complaints respecting him, to whose power they were presently about to be subject, he was willing, if it made no difference to his colleague, to exchange provinces with him. That he deprecated a premature decision on the part of the senate, for since it would be unjust that his colleague should have the power of selecting his province without drawing lots, how much greater injustice would it be, nay, rather indignity, for his lot to be transferred to him." Accordingly the senate, having rather shown than decreed what they wished, adjourned. An exchange of provinces was made by the consuls of themselves, fate hurrying on Marcellus to encounter Hannibal, that he might be the last of the Roman generals, who, by his fall, when the affairs of the war were most prosperous, might add to the glory of that man, from whom he derived the reputation of having been the first Roman general who defeated him.

After the senate passed these decrees, the consuls drew lots for their provinces. Marcellus got Sicily and the fleet, while Laevinus got Italy, along with the war against Hannibal. This terrified the Sicilians, who were watching the consuls and waiting for the results of the lots. Their bitter cries and wails caught everyone's attention and became a topic of conversation afterwards. They went around to various senators in mourning clothes, insisting that they would rather abandon not just their hometowns, but all of Sicily if Marcellus was given command there again. They claimed he had been relentless towards them without any wrongdoing on their part, and what would he do now, especially since they had come to Rome to complain about him? They said it would be better for their island to be engulfed by the fires of Aetna or sunk in the sea than to be handed over like a prisoner to an enemy. These complaints from the Sicilians spread to the homes of the nobility and sparked conversations fueled by both compassion for the Sicilians and frustrations with Marcellus, eventually reaching the senate. The consuls were asked to get the senate's opinion on swapping provinces. Marcellus stated that if the Sicilians had already addressed the senate, his opinion might have been different, but given the current situation, to avoid any claims that they were too scared to express their grievances against him, the person they were about to be under, he was willing to swap provinces with Laevinus if it was acceptable to him. He argued against a hasty decision from the senate, pointing out that while it would be unfair for his colleague to choose his province without a draw, it would be an even greater injustice, or rather an indignity, for his lot to be transferred to him. In the end, the senate hinted at their wishes without making any official decree and then adjourned. The consuls decided among themselves to exchange provinces, with fate pushing Marcellus to face Hannibal, ensuring he would be the last Roman general whose defeat would add to the glory of the man known for being the first Roman general to overcome him.

30

After the provinces had been exchanged, the Sicilians, on being introduced into the senate, discoursed largely on the constant fidelity of king Hiero to the Roman people, converting it into a public merit. They said, "that the tyrants, Hieronymus, and, after him, Hippocrates and Epicydes, had been objects of detestation to them, both on other accounts and especially on account of then deserting the Romans to take part with Hannibal. For this cause Hieronymus was put to death by the principal young men among them, almost with the public concurrence, and a conspiracy was formed to murder Epicydes and Hippocrates, by seventy of the most distinguished of their youth; but being left without support in consequence of the delay of Marcellus, who neglected to bring up his troops to Syracuse at the time agreed upon, they were all, on an indictment that was made, put to death by the tyrants. That Marcellus, by the cruelty exercised in the sacking of Leontini, had given occasion to the tyranny of Hippocrates and Epicydes. From that time the leading men among the Syracusans never ceased going over to Marcellus, and promising him that they would deliver the city to him whenever he pleased; but that he, in the first instance, was disposed rather to take it by force, and afterwards, finding it impossible to effect his object by sea or land, after trying every means, he preferred having Syracuse delivered to him by Sosis, a brazier, and Mericus, a Spaniard, to receiving it from the principal men of Syracuse, who had so often offered it to him voluntarily to no purpose; doubtless in order that he might with a fairer pretext butcher and plunder the most ancient allies of the Roman people. If it had not been Hieronymus who revolted to Hannibal, but the people and senate of Syracuse; if the body of the Syracusan people, and not their tyrants, Hippocrates and Epicydes, who held them in thraldom, had closed the gates against Marcellus; if they had carried on war with the Roman people with the animosity of Carthaginians, what more could Marcellus have done in hostility than he did, without levelling Syracuse with the ground? Nothing indeed was left at Syracuse except the walls and gutted houses of her city, the temples of her gods broken open and plundered; her very gods and their ornaments having been carried away. From many their possessions also were taken away, so that they were unable to support themselves and their families, even from the naked soil, the only remains of their plundered property. They entreated the conscript fathers, that they would order, if not all, at least such of their property as could be found and identified, to be restored to the owners." After they had made these complaints, Laevinus ordered them to withdraw from the senate-house, that the senate might deliberate on their requests, when Marcellus exclaimed, "Nay, rather let them stay here, that I may reply to their charges in their presence, since we conduct your wars for you, conscript fathers, on the condition of having as our accusers those whom we have conquered with our arms. Of the two cities which have been captured this year, let Capua arraign Fulvius, and Syracuse Marcellus."

After the provinces were exchanged, the Sicilians, when introduced to the senate, spoke extensively about King Hiero's unwavering loyalty to the Roman people, framing it as a public virtue. They expressed that the tyrants, Hieronymus, and afterward Hippocrates and Epicydes, were despised by them for various reasons, especially for betraying the Romans to ally with Hannibal. For this reason, Hieronymus was killed by the local youth, almost with the public's support, and a plot was formed to assassinate Epicydes and Hippocrates by seventy of their most prominent young men. However, when Marcellus delayed in bringing his troops to Syracuse as planned, they were left without support and ended up being executed by the tyrants following an indictment. They argued that Marcellus's brutality during the sacking of Leontini had contributed to the tyranny of Hippocrates and Epicydes. After that, the leading citizens of Syracuse continually approached Marcellus, assuring him they would hand over the city whenever he wanted. Initially, he seemed more inclined to take it by force, but after realizing he couldn't achieve his goal by sea or land despite trying every strategy, he opted to have Syracuse surrendered to him by Sosis, a brazier, and Mericus, a Spaniard, rather than accepting it from the prominent Syracusans who had offered it to him multiple times in vain; this was undoubtedly so he could have a better excuse to slaughter and plunder one of the Roman people’s oldest allies. If it had been the people and senate of Syracuse, rather than Hieronymus, who turned to Hannibal; if the Syracusans, instead of their tyrants Hippocrates and Epicydes, who had them oppressed, had shut their gates against Marcellus; if they had fought against the Romans with the same fury as the Carthaginians, what more could Marcellus have done in aggression than what he did, without completely destroying Syracuse? Indeed, nothing remained in Syracuse except for its walls and ravaged buildings, the temples of its gods broken into and looted; even its gods and their decorations had been taken away. Many had their possessions seized, rendering them unable to provide for themselves and their families, even from the bare land, the only remnants of their stolen property. They pleaded with the senate to order that at least some of their belongings that could be found and identified be returned to them." After voicing these complaints, Laevinus instructed them to leave the senate house so that the senate could consider their requests, when Marcellus interjected, "No, let them stay here so I can respond to their accusations directly, since we fight your wars, esteemed fathers, under the condition of facing our accusers, those we have defeated. Of the two cities captured this year, let Capua accuse Fulvius, and let Syracuse accuse Marcellus."

31

The deputies having been brought back into the senate-house, the consul said: "I am not so unmindful of the dignity of the Roman people and of the office I fill as consul, conscript fathers, as to make a defence against charges brought by Greeks, had the inquiry related only to my own delinquency. But it is not so much what I have done, as what they deserved to suffer, which comes into dispute. For if they were not our enemies, there was no difference between sacking Syracuse then, and when Hiero was alive. But if, on the other hand, they have renounced their connexion with us, attacked our ambassadors sword in hand, shut us out of their city and walls, and defended themselves against us with an army of Carthaginians, who can feel indignant that they should suffer the hostilities they have offered? I turned away from the leading men of the Syracusans, when they were desirous of delivering up the city to me, and esteemed Sosis and Mericus as more proper persons for so important an affair. Now you are not the meanest of the Syracusans, who reproach others with the meanness of their condition. But who is there among you, who has promised that he would open the gates to me, and receive my armed troops within the city? You hate and execrate those who did so; and not even here can you abstain from speaking with insult of them; so far is it from being the case that you would yourselves have done any thing of the kind. The very meanness of the condition of those persons, conscript fathers, with which these men reproach them, forms the strongest proof that I did not turn away from any man who was willing to render a service to our state. Before I began the siege of Syracuse I attempted a peace, at one time by sending ambassadors, at another time by going to confer with them; and after that they refrained not from laying violent hands on my ambassadors, nor would give me an answer when I held an interview with their chief men at their gates, then, at length, after suffering many hardships by sea and land, I took Syracuse by force of arms. Of what befell them after their city was captured they would complain with more justice to Hannibal, the Carthaginians, and those who were vanquished with them, than to the senate of the victorious people. If, conscript fathers, I had intended to conceal the fact that I had despoiled Syracuse, I should never have decorated the city of Rome with her spoils. As to what things I either took from individuals or bestowed upon them, as conqueror, I feel assured that I have acted agreeably to the laws of war, and the deserts of each. That you should confirm what I have done, conscript fathers, certainly concerns the commonwealth more than myself, since I have discharged my duty faithfully; but it is the duty of the state to take care, lest, by rescinding my acts, they should render other commanders for the time to come less zealous. And since, conscript fathers, you have heard both what the Sicilians and I had to say, in the presence of each other, we will go out of the senate-house together, in order that in my absence the senate may deliberate more freely." Accordingly, the Sicilians having been dismissed, he himself also went away to the Capitol to levy soldiers.

The deputies were brought back into the senate chamber, and the consul said: "I’m not so forgetful of the dignity of the Roman people and the office I hold as consul, conscript fathers, that I would defend myself against accusations from Greeks, if the inquiry were only about my own wrongdoing. But it’s not just about what I’ve done; it’s more about what they deserved to face. If they weren’t our enemies, there would be no difference between sacking Syracuse then and when Hiero was still alive. But if they have cut ties with us, assaulted our ambassadors with weapons, shut us out from their city and walls, and defended themselves against us with an army of Carthaginians, who can be surprised that they suffer the consequences of their actions? I turned away from the leading figures of the Syracusans when they wanted to hand over the city to me, and I considered Sosis and Mericus to be more suitable for such an important matter. Now, you are not the least of the Syracusans who criticize others for their lowly status. But who among you promised to open the gates for me and let my armed troops into the city? You detest and curse those who did; you can’t even refrain from insulting them here; it’s clear you would not have done anything of the sort. The very low status of those people, conscript fathers, which you criticize, proves that I did not turn away from anyone willing to help our state. Before I began the siege of Syracuse, I tried for peace, sometimes by sending ambassadors and other times by going to meet with them; yet they did not hesitate to attack my ambassadors, nor would they give me a response when I met with their key figures at their gates. Finally, after enduring many hardships at sea and on land, I took Syracuse by force. If they want to complain about what happened to them after their city was captured, they would have more right to do so to Hannibal, the Carthaginians, and those who were defeated alongside them than to the senate of the victorious people. If, conscript fathers, I meant to hide the fact that I had looted Syracuse, I wouldn’t have decorated the city of Rome with its spoils. Regarding what I either took from individuals or gave to them as a conqueror, I’m confident that I acted according to the laws of war and the merits of each. That you should endorse what I have done, conscript fathers, is certainly more important for the common good than for me, since I have fulfilled my duties with integrity; but it is the state’s responsibility to ensure that by overturning my actions, they don’t make future commanders less eager. And since, conscript fathers, you’ve heard the statements from both the Sicilians and me in each other’s presence, we will leave the senate house together so that in my absence, the senate may deliberate more openly." With that, the Sicilians were dismissed, and he also went to the Capitol to enlist soldiers.

32

The other consul then proposed to the fathers the consideration of the requests of the Sicilians, when a long debate took place. A great part of the senate acquiesced in an opinion which originated with Titus Manlius Torquatus, "that the war ought to have been carried on against the tyrants, the enemies both of the Syracusans and the Roman people; that the city ought to have been recovered, not captured; and, when recovered, should have been firmly established under its ancient laws and liberty, and not distressed by war, when worn out with a wretched state of bondage. That in the contest between the tyrants and the Roman general, that most beautiful and celebrated city, formerly the granary and treasury of the Roman people, which was held up as the reward of the victor, had been destroyed; a city by whose munificence and bounty the commonwealth had been assisted and adorned on many occasions, and lastly, during this very Punic war. Should king Hiero, that most faithful friend of the Roman empire, rise from the shades, with what face could either Syracuse or Rome be shown to him, when, after beholding his half-demolished and plundered native city, he should see, on entering Rome, the spoils of his country in the vestibule, as it were, of the city, and almost in the very gates?" Although these and other similar things were said, to throw odium upon the consul and excite compassion for the Sicilians, yet the fathers, out of regard for Marcellus, passed a milder decree, to the effect, "that what Marcellus had done while prosecuting the war, and when victorious, should be confirmed. That for the time to come, the senate would look to the affairs of Syracuse, and would give it in charge to the consul Laevinus, to consult the interest of that state, so far as it could be done without detriment to the commonwealth." Two senators having been sent to the Capitol to request the consul to return to the senate-house, and the Sicilians having been called in, the decree of the senate was read. The deputies were addressed in terms of kindness, and dismissed, when they threw themselves at the knees of the consul, Marcellus, beseeching him to pardon them for what they had said for the purpose of exciting compassion, and procuring relief from their calamities, and to receive themselves and the city of Syracuse under his protection and patronage; after which, the consul addressed them kindly and dismissed them.

The other consul then suggested to the senators that they consider the requests of the Sicilians, which led to a lengthy debate. A significant portion of the senate agreed with the viewpoint introduced by Titus Manlius Torquatus, stating that the war should have been fought against the tyrants, who were the enemies of both the Syracusans and the Roman people. The city should have been reclaimed, not seized, and once reclaimed, it should have been firmly established under its ancient laws and freedoms, rather than suffering from war while already in a terrible state of oppression. He noted that during the conflict between the tyrants and the Roman general, that once-beautiful and renowned city—previously the granary and treasury for the Roman people—had been destroyed. It had been a city that generously supported the commonwealth on many occasions, especially during the current Punic war. He questioned how King Hiero, the most loyal ally of the Roman empire, would react if he rose from the dead. What face could Syracuse or Rome show him when, after seeing his half-destroyed and plundered home, he entered Rome only to see the spoils of his country displayed in the entrance of the city, almost at its very gates? Although these and other similar remarks were made to shame the consul and evoke sympathy for the Sicilians, the senators, out of respect for Marcellus, passed a milder decree affirming that what Marcellus had done while waging the war and after achieving victory should be upheld. They decided that moving forward, the senate would attend to the matters of Syracuse and charge consul Laevinus with overseeing the state's interests, as long as it didn't harm the greater good of the commonwealth. Two senators were sent to the Capitol to ask the consul to return to the senate house, and the Sicilians were summoned. The senate's decree was read out loud. The deputies were addressed kindly and then dismissed, but they fell to their knees before Consul Marcellus, begging him to forgive them for what they had said to garner sympathy and seek relief from their suffering, and to accept them and the city of Syracuse under his protection. Afterward, the consul spoke to them kindly and let them go.

33

An audience of the senate was then granted to the Campanians. Their speech was more calculated to excite compassion, but their case less favourable, for neither could they deny that they deserved the punishment they had suffered, nor were there any tyrants to whom they could transfer their guilt. But they trusted that sufficient atonement had been made by the death of so many of their senators by poison and the hands of the executioner. They said, "that a few only of their nobles remained, being such as were not induced by the consciousness of their demerit to adopt any desperate measure respecting themselves, and had not been condemned to death through the resentment of their conquerors. That these implored the restoration of their liberty, and some portion of their goods for themselves and families, being citizens of Rome, and most of them connected with the Romans by affinity and now too near relationship, in consequence of intermarriages which had taken place for a long period." After this they were removed from the senate-house, when for a short time doubts were entertained whether it would be right or not to send for Quintus Fulvius from Capua, (for Claudius, the proconsul, died after the capture of that place,) that the question might be canvassed in the presence of the general who had been concerned, as was done in the affair between Marcellus and the Sicilians. But afterwards, when they saw in the senate Marcus Atilius, and Caius Fulvius, the brother of Flaccus, his lieutenant-generals, and Quintus Minucius, and Lucius Veturius Philo, who were also his lieutenant-generals, who had been present at every transaction; and being unwilling that Fulvius should be recalled from Capua, or the Campanians put off, Marcus Atilius Regulus, who possessed the greatest weight of any of those present who had been at Capua, being asked his opinion, thus spoke: "I believe I assisted at the council held by the consuls after the capture of Capua, when inquiry was made whether any of the Campanians had deserved well of our state; and it was found that two women had done so; Vestia Oppia, a native of Atella and an inhabitant of Capua, and Faucula Cluvia, formerly a common woman. The former had daily offered sacrifice for the safety and success of the Roman people, and the latter had clandestinely supplied the starving prisoners with food. The sentiments of all the rest of the Campanians towards us had been the same," he said, "as those of the Carthaginians; and those who had been decapitated by Fulvius, were the most conspicuous in rank, but not in guilt. I do not see," said he, "how the senate can decide respecting the Campanians who are Roman citizens, without an order of the people. And the course adopted by our ancestors, in the case of the Satricani when they had revolted, was, that Marcus Antistius, the plebeian tribune, should first propose and the commons make an order, that the senate should have the power of pronouncing judgment upon the Satricani. I therefore give it as my opinion, that application should be made to the plebeian tribunes, that one or more of them should propose to the people a bill, by which we may be empowered to determine in the case of the Campanians." Lucius Atilius, plebeian tribune, proposed to the people, on the recommendation of the senate, a bill to the following effect: "Concerning all the Campanians, Atellanians, Calatinians, and Sabatinians, who have surrendered themselves to the proconsul Fulvius, and have placed themselves under the authority and dominion of the Roman people; also concerning what things they have surrendered, together with their persons, both lands and city, divine or human, together with their utensils and whatsoever else they have surrendered; concerning these things, Roman citizens, I ask you what it is your pleasure should be done." The commons thus ordered: "Whatsoever the senate on oath, or the majority of those present, may determine, that we will and order."

An audience with the Senate was granted to the Campanians. Their speech was designed to evoke sympathy, but their situation was less favorable, as they could neither deny that they deserved the punishment they had received, nor could they shift the blame onto any tyrants. They hoped that the deaths of so many of their senators, due to poison and execution, were enough atonement. They stated that only a few of their nobles remained, those who weren’t driven by guilt to take desperate actions and had not been sentenced to death due to the anger of their conquerors. These individuals pleaded for the restoration of their freedom and part of their property for themselves and their families, as citizens of Rome, most of whom were connected to the Romans through long-standing intermarriages. After this, they were taken out of the Senate chamber, where there were briefly doubts about whether or not to summon Quintus Fulvius from Capua (since Claudius, the proconsul, had died after Capua's capture) so that the issue could be discussed in front of the general involved, as was done in the case between Marcellus and the Sicilians. However, once they saw in the senate Marcus Atilius, Caius Fulvius—Flaccus’s brother—and Quintus Minucius and Lucius Veturius Philo, who were also his lieutenant-generals and had been present at all the events, and being reluctant to call Fulvius back from Capua or delay the Campanians, Marcus Atilius Regulus, who held the most influence among those present from Capua, was asked his opinion and stated: “I remember being at the council held by the consuls after Capua was taken, when they asked if any Campanians had done well by our state, and it was found that two women had: Vestia Oppia, a native of Atella and resident of Capua, and Faucula Cluvia, who was previously a common woman. The former had regularly sacrificed for the safety and success of the Roman people, while the latter had secretly fed the starving prisoners. The feelings of all other Campanians towards us were the same as those of the Carthaginians, and those who had been executed by Fulvius were the highest in rank, but not in guilt. I don’t see how the Senate can make a decision regarding the Campanians who are Roman citizens without an order from the people. Our ancestors’ approach regarding the Satricani during their revolt was for Marcus Antistius, the plebeian tribune, to propose that the commons give the Senate the authority to judge the Satricani. Therefore, I suggest we request the plebeian tribunes to propose to the people a bill allowing us to make the decision about the Campanians.” Lucius Atilius, the plebeian tribune, proposed a bill to the people at the Senate's recommendation, stating: “Concerning all Campanians, Atellanians, Calatinians, and Sabatinians who have surrendered to proconsul Fulvius and placed themselves under the authority of the Roman people; also regarding what they have surrendered, both lands and cities, divine and human, along with their belongings and anything else they have yielded; about these matters, Roman citizens, I ask you what you wish to be done.” The commons then decided: “Whatever the Senate, under oath, or the majority of those present, determines, that we will agree to and order.”

34

The senate having taken the matter into their consideration in conformity with this order of the people, first restored to Oppia and Cluvia their goods and liberty; directing, that if they wished to solicit any other rewards from the senate, they should come to Rome. Separate decrees were passed respecting each of the Campanian families, all of which it is not worth while to enumerate. The goods of some were to be confiscated; themselves, their children, and their wives were to be sold, excepting such of their daughters as had married before they came into the power of the Roman people. Others were ordered to be thrown into chains, and their cases to be considered at a future time. They made the amount of income the ground on which they decided, whether the goods of the rest of the Campanians should be confiscated or not. They voted, that all the cattle taken except the horses, all the slaves except adult males, and every thing which did not belong to the soil, should be restored to the owners. They ordered that all the Campanians, Atellanians, Calatinians, and Sabatinians, except such as were themselves, or whose parents were, among the enemy, should be free, with a proviso, that none of them should become a Roman citizen or a Latin confederate; and that none of those who had been at Capua while the gates were shut should remain in the city or territory of Capua after a certain day. That a place should be assigned to them to inhabit beyond the Tiber, but not contiguous to it. That those who had neither been in Capua nor in any Campanian city which had revolted from the Romans during the war, should inhabit a place on this side the river Liris towards Rome; and that those who had come over to the Romans before Hannibal arrived at Capua, should be removed to a place on this side the Vulturnus, with a proviso, that none of them should have either land or house within fifteen miles of the sea. That such of them as were removed to a place beyond the Tiber, should neither themselves nor their posterity acquire or possess any property any where, except in the Veientian, Sutrian, or Nepetian territories; and, except on condition, that no one should possess a greater extent of land than fifty acres. That the goods of all the senators, and such as had been magistrates at Capua, Calatia, and Atella, should be sold at Capua; but that the free persons who were decreed to be exposed to sale, should be sent to Rome and sold there. As to the images and brazen statues, which were said to have been taken from the enemy, whether sacred or profane, they referred them to the college of pontiffs. They sent the Campanians away, considerably more grieved than they were when they came, in consequence of these decrees; and now they no longer complained of the severity of Quintus Fulvius towards them, but of the malignity of the gods and their own accursed fortune.

The Senate considered the issue according to the people's request, first restoring Oppia and Cluvia their property and freedom. They instructed that if they wanted to request more rewards from the Senate, they needed to come to Rome. Separate decisions were made regarding each of the Campanian families, which it's not necessary to list all. Some had their property confiscated; they, their children, and their wives were to be sold, except for any daughters who had married before coming under Roman control. Others were ordered to be imprisoned, with their situations to be reviewed later. They decided whether to confiscate the property of the rest of the Campanians based on their income. They voted that all livestock except horses, all slaves except adult males, and everything that wasn't land should be returned to the owners. They ruled that all Campanians, Atellanians, Calatinians, and Sabatinians, except those who were enemy combatants or whose parents were, would be free with the condition that none could become Roman citizens or Latin allies; and that none who had been in Capua when the gates were shut could stay in the city or its territory after a certain date. A location should be assigned for them to live beyond the Tiber, but not next to it. Those who had not been in Capua or any rebellious Campanian city during the war would live on this side of the Liris River towards Rome; and those who had defected to the Romans before Hannibal reached Capua would be relocated to this side of the Vulturnus, with the condition that none could own land or houses within fifteen miles of the sea. Those moved beyond the Tiber could not acquire or own property anywhere except in the Veientian, Sutrian, or Nepetian territories; and only if they owned less than fifty acres. The property of all senators and those who had been magistrates in Capua, Calatia, and Atella would be sold in Capua; however, free persons ordered for sale would be sent to Rome for sale there. Regarding the images and bronze statues reportedly taken from the enemy, whether sacred or profane, they were referred to the College of Pontiffs. The Campanians left feeling much more upset than when they arrived because of these decisions; they no longer blamed Quintus Fulvius for their harsh treatment, but rather lamented the cruelty of the gods and their own unfortunate fate.

35

After the Sicilians and Campanians were dismissed, a levy was made; and after the troops had been enlisted for the army, they then began to consider about making up the number of rowers; but as there was neither a sufficient supply of men for that purpose, nor any money at that time in the treasury by which they might be purchased or paid, the consuls issued an edict, that private persons should furnish rowers in proportion to their income and rank, as had been done before, with pay and provisions for thirty days. So great was the murmuring and indignation of the people, on account of this edict, that a leader, rather than matter, was wanting for an insurrection. It was said, that "the consuls, after having ruined the Sicilians and Campanians, had undertaken to destroy and lacerate the Roman commons; that, drained as they had been for so many years by taxes, they had nothing left but wasted and naked lands. That the enemy had burned their houses, and the state had taken away their slaves, who were the cultivators of their lands, at one time by purchasing them at a low rate for soldiers, at another by commanding a supply of rowers. If any one had any silver or brass it was taken away from him, for the payment of rowers or for annual taxes. That no force could compel and no command oblige them to give what they had not got. That they might sell their goods and then vent their cruelty on their persons, which were all that remained to them. That they had nothing even left from which they could be redeemed." These complaints were uttered not in secret, but publicly in the forum, and before the eyes of the consuls themselves, by an immense crowd which surrounded them; nor could the consuls appease them now by coercing nor by soothing them. Upon this they said that three days should be allowed them to consider of the matter; which interval the consuls employed in examining and planning. The following day they assembled the senate to consider of raising a supply of rowers; and after arguing at great length that the people's refusal was fair, they brought their discourse to this point, that whether it were just or unjust, this burden must be borne by private individuals. For from what source could they procure rowers, when there was no money in the treasury? and how, without fleets, could Sicily be kept in subjection, or Philip be prevented from entering Italy, or the shores of Italy be protected?

After the Sicilians and Campanians were sent home, a draft was initiated; and once the troops had been enlisted for the army, they started to think about recruiting enough rowers. However, there weren't enough men available for this, nor was there any money in the treasury to buy or pay them. The consuls issued a decree stating that private citizens should provide rowers based on their income and status, just like before, with pay and supplies for thirty days. The public was very upset and angry about this decree, and it seemed all that was needed for a rebellion was a leader. It was claimed that "the consuls, after ruining the Sicilians and Campanians, were now trying to destroy and exploit the Roman common people; that after being drained for so many years by taxes, they had nothing left but barren and empty lands. That the enemy had burned their homes, and the state had taken away their slaves, who worked on their lands, sometimes by buying them at low prices for soldiers, and other times by demanding a supply of rowers. If anyone had any silver or copper, it was taken for paying rowers or for yearly taxes. No force could compel them and no command could force them to give what they didn’t have. They could sell their possessions and then suffer further cruelty against themselves, which was all they had left. They didn’t even have anything left to redeem themselves." These complaints were voiced openly, not in secret, in the forum, in front of the consuls themselves, by a huge crowd surrounding them; the consuls could neither intimidate nor calm them down. In response, they decided to give the people three days to contemplate the matter; during this time, the consuls focused on examining and planning. The next day, they convened the senate to discuss finding a source for rowers; after long discussions acknowledging the fairness of the people's refusal, they concluded that, whether it was right or wrong, this burden had to fall on private individuals. For where could they find rowers when there was no money in the treasury? And how, without naval fleets, could they maintain control over Sicily, or prevent Philip from entering Italy, or protect the shores of Italy?

36

In this perplexing state of affairs, when all deliberation was at a stand, and a kind of torpor had seized on men's minds, Laevinus, the consul, observed, that "as the magistrates were more honoured than the senators, and the senators than the people, so also ought they to be the first in taking upon themselves every thing that was burdensome and arduous. If you would enjoin any duty on an inferior, and would first submit yourself and those belonging to you to the obligation, you will find everybody else more ready to obey; nor is an expense thought heavy, when the people see every one of their principal men taking upon himself more than his proportion of it. Are we then desirous that the Roman people should have and equip a fleet? that private individuals should without repugnance furnish rowers? Let us first execute the command ourselves. Let us, senators, bring into the treasury to-morrow all our gold, silver, and coined brass, each reserving rings for himself, his wife, and children, and a bulla for his son; and he who has a wife or daughters, an ounce weight of gold for each. Let those who have sat in a curule chair have the ornaments of a horse, and a pound weight of silver, that they may have a salt-cellar and a dish for the service of the gods. Let the rest of us, senators, reserve for each father of a family, a pound weight only of silver and five thousand coined asses. All the rest of our gold, silver, and coined brass, let us immediately carry to the triumviri for banking affairs, no decree of the senate having been previously made; that our voluntary contributions, and our emulation in assisting the state, may excite the minds, first, of the equestrian order to emulate us, and after them of the rest of the community. This is the only course which we, your consuls, after much conversation on the subject, have been able to discover. Adopt it, then, and may the gods prosper the measure. If the state is preserved, she can easily secure the property of her individual members, but by betraying the public interests you would in vain preserve your own." This proposition was received with such entire approbation, that thanks were spontaneously returned to the consuls. The senate was then adjourned, when every one of the members brought his gold, silver, and brass into the treasury, with such emulation excited, that they were desirous that their names should appear among the first on the public tables; so that neither the triumviri were sufficient for receiving nor the notaries for entering them. The unanimity displayed by the senate was imitated by the equestrian order, and that of the equestrian order by the commons. Thus, without any edict, or coercion of the magistrates, the state neither wanted rowers to make up the numbers, nor money to pay them; and after every thing had been got in readiness for the war, the consuls set out for their provinces.

In this confusing situation, when all discussion had come to a halt, and a sort of numbness had taken hold of people's minds, Laevinus, the consul, pointed out that "since the officials are more honored than the senators, and the senators are more honored than the common people, they should also be the first to take on all the burdens and hard tasks. If you want to assign a duty to someone lower in rank, first submit yourself and those close to you to that obligation, and you'll find everyone else more willing to comply; expenses don't seem heavy when the public sees that their leaders are taking on more than their fair share. Do we want the Roman people to have and equip a fleet? Should private citizens readily provide rowers? Let’s first take on the responsibility ourselves. Senators, let’s bring to the treasury tomorrow all our gold, silver, and minted brass, keeping only rings for ourselves, our wives, and children, and a bulla for our sons; and those with wives or daughters should keep an ounce of gold for each. Those who have sat in a curule chair should keep horse decorations and a pound of silver, so they can have a salt-cellar and a dish for the gods. The rest of us senators should reserve only a pound of silver and five thousand minted asses for each head of a family. Let’s immediately take all our gold, silver, and minted brass to the triumviri for banking affairs, without a prior decree from the senate; our voluntary contributions and eagerness to support the state should encourage the equestrian order to follow our lead, and then the rest of the community after them. This is the only plan we, your consuls, have come up with after much discussion. Adopt it, and may the gods favor the decision. If the state is preserved, it can easily protect the property of its individual members, but risking the public interest would be pointless for preserving your own." This proposal was received with such enthusiasm that thanks were spontaneously given to the consuls. The senate then adjourned, and each member brought their gold, silver, and brass to the treasury with such eagerness that everyone wanted their names to appear among the first on the public tables, to the point that the triumviri were overwhelmed with contributions and the notaries couldn't keep up with the records. The unity shown by the senate was mirrored by the equestrian order, and that by the common people. Thus, without any decree or pressure from the officials, the state had both enough rowers to meet the numbers and the funds to pay them; and after everything was prepared for war, the consuls set out for their provinces.

37

Nor was there ever any period of the war, when both the Carthaginians and the Romans, plunged alike in vicissitudes, were in a state of more anxious suspense between hope and fear. For on the side of the Romans, with respect to their provinces, their failure in Spain on the one hand, and their successes in Sicily on the other, had blended joy and sorrow; and in Italy, the loss of Tarentum was an injury and a source of grief to them, while the unexpected preservation of the citadel with the garrison was matter of joy to them. The sudden terror and panic occasioned by the siege and attack of Rome, was turned into joy by the capture of Capua, a few days after. Their affairs beyond sea also were equalized by a kind of compensation. Philip had become their enemy at a juncture somewhat unseasonable; but then the Aetolians, and Attalus, king of Asia, were added to their allies; fortune now, in a manner, promising to the Romans the empire of the east. The Carthaginians also set the loss of Capua against the capture of Tarentum; and as they considered it as glorious to them to have reached the walls of Rome without opposition, so they were chagrined at the failure of their attempt, and they felt ashamed that they had been held in such contempt, that while they lay under the walls of Rome, a Roman army was marched out for Spain at an opposite gate. With regard also to Spain itself, the greater the reason was to hope that the war there was terminated, and that the Romans were driven from the country, after the destruction of two such renowned generals and their armies, so much the greater was the indignation felt, that the victory had been rendered void and fruitless by Lucius Marcius, a general irregularly appointed. Thus fortune balancing events against each other, all was suspense and uncertainty on both sides, their hopes and their fears being as strong as though they were now first commencing the war.

There was never a time during the war when both the Carthaginians and the Romans, equally caught up in ups and downs, faced greater anxiety between hope and fear. For the Romans, regarding their territories, their losses in Spain contrasted with their wins in Sicily, mixing joy and sorrow; and in Italy, losing Tarentum was a blow and a cause of grief, while the unexpected safety of the citadel with its garrison brought them happiness. The sudden panic caused by the siege and attack on Rome turned into joy with the capture of Capua just a few days later. Their situations overseas also balanced out as a kind of compensation. Philip had become their enemy at a rather inconvenient time, but then the Aetolians and Attalus, king of Asia, joined their side; fortune seemed to promise the Romans control over the east. The Carthaginians balanced the loss of Capua against the capture of Tarentum; while they took pride in reaching the walls of Rome unopposed, they were frustrated by their failure to attack successfully and felt embarrassed that they were held in such low regard that, while they camped outside Rome, a Roman army was sent out to Spain from a different gate. Regarding Spain itself, although there was hope that the war there had ended and that the Romans had been expelled after the defeat of two well-known generals and their armies, there was even greater anger that the victory was rendered pointless and ineffective by Lucius Marcius, a general appointed irregularly. Thus, with fortune balancing events, both sides were filled with suspense and uncertainty, their hopes and fears as intense as if they were just beginning the war.

38

What grieved Hannibal more than any thing was the fact, that Capua having been more perseveringly besieged by the Romans than defended by him, had turned from him the regard of many of the states of Italy, and it was not only impossible for him to retain possession of all these by means of garrisons, unless he could make up his mind to tear his army into a number of small portions, which at that time was most inexpedient, but he could not, by withdrawing the garrisons, leave the fidelity of his allies open to the influence of hope, or subject to that of fear. His disposition, which was strongly inclined to avarice and cruelty, induced him to plunder the places he could not keep possession of, that they might be left for the enemy in a state of desolation. This resolution was equally horrid in principle and in its issue, for not only were the affections of those who suffered such harsh treatment alienated from him, but also of the other states, for the warning affected a greater number than did the calamity. Nor did the Roman consul fail to sound the inclinations of the cities, whenever any prospect of success presented itself. Dasius and Blasius were the principal men in Salapia, Dasius was the friend of Hannibal, Blasius, as far as he could do it with safety, promoted the Roman interest, and, by means of secret messengers, had given Marcellus hopes of having the place betrayed to him, but the business could not be accomplished without the assistance of Dasius. After much and long hesitation and even then more for the want of a better plan than from any hope of success, he addressed himself to Dasius; but he, being both adverse to the measure and also hostile to his rival in the government, discovered the affair to Hannibal. Both parties were summoned, and while Hannibal was transacting some business on his tribunal, intending presently to take cognizance of the case of Blasius, and the accuser and the accused were standing apart from the crowd, which was put back, Blasius solicited Dasius on the subject of surrendering the city; when he exclaimed, as if the case were now clearly proved, that he was being treated with about the betrayal of the city, even before the eyes of Hannibal. The more audacious the proceeding was, the less probable did it appear to Hannibal and those who were present. They considered that the charge was undoubtedly a matter of rivalry and animosity, and that it had been brought because it was of such a nature that, not admitting of being proved by witnesses, it could the more easily be fabricated. Accordingly the parties were dismissed. But Blasius, notwithstanding, desisted not from his bold undertaking, till by continually harping upon the same subject, and proving how conducive such a measure would be to themselves and their country, he carried his point that the Punic garrison, consisting of five hundred Numidians, and Salapia, should be delivered up to Marcellus. Nor could it be betrayed without much bloodshed, consisting of the bravest of the cavalry in the whole Punic army. Accordingly, though the event was unexpected, and their horses were of no use to them in the city, yet hastily taking arms, during the confusion, they endeavoured to force their way out; and not being able to escape, they fell fighting to the last, not more than fifty of them falling into the hands of the enemy alive. The loss of this body of cavalry was considerably more detrimental to Hannibal than that of Salapia, for the Carthaginian was never afterwards superior in cavalry, in which he had before been most effective.

What troubled Hannibal more than anything was that Capua, having been besieged by the Romans more persistently than defended by him, had caused many of the states in Italy to lose faith in him. It wasn't just impossible for him to keep all these places garrisoned unless he decided to break his army into several smaller groups, which was highly impractical at the time, but he also couldn’t withdraw the garrisons without risking the loyalty of his allies to hope or fear. His tendency toward greed and cruelty led him to plunder places he couldn’t hold, leaving them in ruins for the enemy. This decision was terrible both in principle and outcome because not only did it distance those who suffered from him, but it also alienated other states; the warning of such actions affected more people than the actual destruction. The Roman consul didn’t miss the chance to gauge the cities' feelings whenever a chance of success arose. Dasius and Blasius were the key figures in Salapia. Dasius was a friend of Hannibal, while Blasius, as safely as he could, supported the Roman side and had secretly given Marcellus hopes of betraying the city, but he needed Dasius’s help to pull it off. After much hesitation, more due to lack of a better plan than real hope for success, he approached Dasius. However, Dasius, opposing the plan and having a rivalry with Blasius, revealed everything to Hannibal. Both parties were called, and while Hannibal was handling some matters on his platform, intending to address the case of Blasius, who was standing apart from the crowd, Blasius urged Dasius about surrendering the city. Dasius then exclaimed that it was clear he was being discussed regarding the city’s betrayal, right in front of Hannibal. The more brazen the claim, the less probable it seemed to Hannibal and the others present. They considered it merely an expression of rivalry and resentment, brought forward because it couldn’t be easily proven with witnesses, making it simple to fabricate. Accordingly, the parties were dismissed. However, Blasius didn’t give up on his daring venture. By constantly discussing the benefits of such a move for themselves and their city, he convinced them to surrender the Punic garrison of five hundred Numidians and Salapia to Marcellus. The betrayal wouldn’t happen without a lot of bloodshed, as it involved the bravest cavalry in the entire Punic army. So, even though the event was unexpected and their horses were basically useless in the city, they hurriedly armed themselves and tried to fight their way out amidst the chaos. Unable to escape, they fought to the last, with fewer than fifty captured alive by the enemy. The loss of this cavalry unit was far more damaging to Hannibal than the loss of Salapia, as he never regained superiority in cavalry, in which he had previously excelled.

39

During this time the scarcity of provisions in the citadel of Tarentum was almost intolerable; the Roman garrison there, and Marcus Livius, the praefect of the garrison and the citadel, placing all their dependence in the supplies sent from Sicily; that these might safely pass along the coast of Italy, a fleet of about twenty ships was stationed at Rhegium. Decius Quinctius, a man of obscure birth, but who had acquired great renown as a soldier, on account of many acts of bravery, had charge of the fleet and the convoys. At first he had five ships, the largest of which were two triremes, given to him by Marcellus, but afterwards, in consequence of his spirited conduct on many occasions, three quinqueremes were added to his number, at last, by exacting from the allied states of Rhegium, Velia, and Paestum, the ships they were bound to furnish according to treaty, he made up a fleet of twenty ships, as was before stated. This fleet setting out from Rhegium, was met at Sacriportus, about fifteen miles from the city by Democrates, with an equal number of Tarentine ships. It happened that the Roman was then coming with his sails up, not expecting an approaching contest, but in the neighbourhood of Croto and Sybaris, he had supplied his ships with rowers, and had his fleet excellently equipped and armed for the size of his vessels, and it also happened, that just at the time when the enemy were in sight, the wind completely fell, so that there was sufficient time to furl their sails, and get their rowers and soldiers in readiness for the approaching action. Rarely elsewhere have regular fleets engaged with so much spirit, for they fought for what was of greater importance than the fleets themselves. The Tarentines, in order that, having recovered their city from the Romans after the lapse of almost a century, they might also rescue their citadel, hoping also to cut off the supplies of their enemy, if by a naval battle they could deprive them of the dominion of the sea. The Romans, that, by keeping possession of the citadel, they might prove that Tarentum was lost not by the strength and valour of their enemies, but by treachery and stealth. Accordingly, the signal having been given on both sides, they charged each other with the beaks of their ships, and neither did they draw back their own, nor allow the ships of the enemy with which they were engaged to separate from them, having thrown then grappling irons, and thus the battle was carried on in such close quarters, that they fought not only with missile weapons, but in a manner foot to foot even with their swords. The prows joined together remained stationary, while the sterns were moved round by the force of their adversaries' oars. The ships were crowded together in so small a compass, that scarcely one weapon fell into the sea without taking effect. They pressed front against front like lines of troops engaging on land, and the combatants could pass from one ship to another. But the contest between two ships which had engaged each other in the van, was remarkable above the rest. In the Roman ship was Quinctius himself, in the Tarentine, Nico, surnamed Perco, who hated, and was hated by, the Romans, not only on public grounds, but also personally, for he belonged to that faction which had betrayed Tarentum to Hannibal. This man transfixed Quinctius with a spear while off his guard, and engaged at once in fighting and encouraging his men, and he immediately fell headlong with his arms over the prow. The victorious Tarentine promptly boarded the ship, which was all in confusion from the loss of the commander, and when he had driven the enemy back, and the Tarentines had got possession of the prow, the Romans, who had formed themselves into a compact body, with difficulty defending the stern, suddenly another trireme of the enemy appeared at the stern. Thus the Roman ship, enclosed between the two, was captured. Upon this a panic spread among the rest, seeing the commander's ship captured, and flying in every direction, some were sunk in the deep and some rowed hastily to land, where, shortly after, they became a prey to the Thurians and Metapontines. Of the storeships which followed, laden with provisions, a very few fell into the hands of the enemy; the rest, shifting their sails from one side to another with the changing winds, escaped into the open sea. An affair took place at Tarentum at this time, which was attended with widely different success; for a party of four thousand men had gone out to forage, and while they were dispersed, and roaming through the country, Livius, the commander of the citadel and the Roman garrison, who was anxious to seize every opportunity of striking a blow, sent out of the citadel Caius Persius, an active officer, with two thousand soldiers, who attacked them suddenly when widely dispersed and straggling about the fields; and after slaying them for a long time on all hands, drove the few that remained of so many into the city, to which they fled in alarm and confusion, and where they rushed in at the doors of the gates, which were half-opened that the city might not be taken in the same attack. In this manner affairs were equally balanced at Tarentum, the Romans being victorious by land, and the Tarentines by sea. Both parties were equally disappointed in their hope of receiving provisions after they were within sight.

During this time, the lack of food in the citadel of Tarentum was almost unbearable; the Roman garrison there, along with Marcus Livius, the praefect of the garrison and the citadel, relied entirely on the supplies sent from Sicily. To ensure these could safely travel along the coast of Italy, a fleet of about twenty ships was stationed at Rhegium. Decius Quinctius, a man of humble origins who gained significant recognition as a soldier due to his many brave deeds, was in charge of the fleet and the convoys. Initially, he had five ships, the largest being two triremes given to him by Marcellus. However, due to his courageous actions on numerous occasions, three quinqueremes were added to his fleet. Eventually, by demanding from the allied states of Rhegium, Velia, and Paestum the ships they were required to provide under treaty, he built up a fleet of twenty ships, as mentioned earlier. This fleet set sail from Rhegium and encountered an equal number of Tarentine ships at Sacriportus, about fifteen miles from the city. At that moment, the Roman fleet was coming with their sails up, not expecting an imminent battle. However, in the vicinity of Croto and Sybaris, he had prepared his ships with rowers and had them well-equipped and armed for their size. Coincidentally, just as the enemy was spotted, the wind died down completely, giving them enough time to lower their sails and ready their rowers and soldiers for the impending conflict. Rarely have organized fleets fought with such intensity, as they were fighting for something more significant than the fleets themselves. The Tarentines aimed to recover their city from the Romans after nearly a century, hoping to also reclaim their citadel, while also attempting to cut off supplies to their enemy by winning the naval battle and controlling the sea. The Romans, on the other hand, wanted to hold onto the citadel to prove that Tarentum was lost not through the strength and bravery of their enemies but due to treachery and deceit. Accordingly, when the signal was given on both sides, they charged at each other with the prows of their ships. Neither side withdrew nor allowed their engaging enemy ships to break away, having thrown grappling irons, making the battle so close that they fought not just with ranged weapons but also in hand-to-hand combat with swords. The ships, once joined, remained still while the sterns were maneuvered by the force of their adversaries' oars. The vessels were packed so tightly that scarcely any weapon fell into the sea without hitting something. They pressed against each other like troops in formation on land, and the combatants could easily move from one ship to another. However, the struggle between two ships that had engaged each other at the forefront was particularly notable. In the Roman ship was Quinctius himself, while in the Tarentine ship was Nico, nicknamed Perco, who despised the Romans and was equally despised by them, not just for political reasons but also personally, as he was part of the faction that had betrayed Tarentum to Hannibal. This man struck Quinctius with a spear while he was caught off guard and immediately engaged in fighting while rallying his men. Unfortunately, he fell over the prow. The victorious Tarentine quickly boarded the now-disordered ship, and after forcing the enemy back and taking control of the prow, the Romans, who had formed a tight defense at the stern, found themselves suddenly flanked by another trireme from the enemy. The Roman ship, trapped between the two, was captured. This development caused panic among the rest of the fleet, seeing their commander's ship taken, and they scattered in every direction. Some were sunk in the depths, while others rowed hastily to shore, where they soon fell prey to the Thurians and Metapontines. Of the supply ships that followed, only a few were captured by the enemy; the rest managed to escape into the open sea by shifting their sails with the changing winds. At the same time, an event unfolded in Tarentum that had very different results; a group of four thousand men had gone out to forage, and while they were scattered around the countryside, Livius, the commander of the citadel and the Roman garrison, keen to seize any opportunity to strike, sent out Caius Persius, an active officer, along with two thousand soldiers. They ambushed the foragers when they were scattered and vulnerable, killing many and driving the few survivors back into the city in a panicked rush, where they entered through the gates that were half-opened to prevent the city from being taken in the same surprise attack. In this way, the situation at Tarentum was balanced, with the Romans victorious on land and the Tarentines victorious at sea. Both sides were equally frustrated in their hopes of receiving supplies once they were within sight.

40

While these events were occurring, the consul, Laevinus, after a great part of the year had elapsed, having arrived in Sicily, where he had been expected by both the old and new allies, considered it his first and principal duty to adjust the affairs of Syracuse, which were still in a state of disorder, the peace being but recent. He then marched his legions to Agrigentum, the seat of the remaining part of the war, which was occupied by a strong garrison of Carthaginians; and here fortune favoured his attempt. Hanno was commander-in-chief of the Carthaginians, but their whole reliance was placed upon Mutines and the Numidians. Mutines, scouring the whole of Sicily, employed himself in carrying off spoil from the allies of the Romans; nor could he by force or stratagem be cut off from Agrigentum, or prevented from sallying from it whenever he pleased. The renown which he gained by this conduct, as it began now to eclipse the fame of the commander-in-chief, was at last converted into a source of jealousy; so that even now his successes were not as acceptable as they ought to have been, on account of the person who gained them. For these reasons Hanno at last gave his commission to his own son, concluding that by taking away his command he should also deprive him of the influence he possessed with the Numidians. But the result was very different; for their former attachment to him was increased by the envy incurred by him. Nor did he brook the affront put upon him by this injurious treatment, but immediately sent secret messengers to Laevinus, to treat about delivering up Agrigentum. After an agreement had been entered into by means of these persons, and the mode of carrying it into execution concerted, the Numidians seized on a gate which leads towards the sea, having driven the guards from it, or put them to the sword, and then received into the city a party of Romans sent for that purpose; and when these troops were now marching into the heart of the city and the forum with a great noise, Hanno, concluding that it was nothing more than a disturbance and secession of the Numidians, such as had happened before, advanced to quell the mutiny; but observing at a distance that the numbers were greater than those of the Numidians, and hearing the Roman shout, which was far from being new to him, he betook himself to flight before he came within reach of their weapons. Passing out of the town at a gate in the opposite quarter, and taking Epicydes to accompany him, he reached the sea with a few attendants; and having very seasonably met with a small vessel, they abandoned to the enemy Sicily, for which they had contended for so many years, and crossed over into Africa. The remaining multitude of Carthaginians and Sicilians fled with headlong haste, but as every passage by which they could escape was blockaded up, they were cut to pieces near the gates. On gaining possession of the town, Laevinus scourged and beheaded those who took the lead in the affairs of Agrigentum. The rest, together with the booty, he sold. All the money he sent to Rome. Accounts of the sufferings of the Agrigentines spreading through all Sicily, all the states suddenly turned to the Romans. In a short time twenty towns were betrayed to them, and six taken by storm. As many as forty put themselves under their protection, by voluntary surrender. The consul having rewarded and punished the leading men of these states, according to their several deserts, and compelled the Sicilians, now that they had at length laid aside arms, to turn their attention to the cultivation of their lands, in order that the island might by its produce not only maintain its inhabitants, but, as it had frequently done on many former occasions, add to the supplies of Rome and Italy, he returned into Italy, taking with him a disorderly multitude from Agathyrna. These were as many as four thousand men, made up of a mixed assemblage of every description of persons, exiles, bankrupts, the greater part of them felons, who had supported themselves by rapine and robbery, both when they lived in their native towns, under the restraint of the laws, and also after that a coincidence in their fortunes, brought about by causes different in each case, had congregated them at Agathyrna. These men Laevinus thought it hardly safe to leave in the island, when an unwonted tranquillity was growing up, as the materials of fresh disturbances; and besides, they were likely to be useful to the Rhegians, who were in want of a band of men habituated to robbery, for the purpose of committing depredations upon the Bruttian territory. Thus, so far as related to Sicily, the war was this year terminated.

While all this was happening, the consul, Laevinus, after most of the year had passed, arrived in Sicily, where both old and new allies were expecting him. He saw it as his main responsibility to sort out the troubles in Syracuse, which were still chaotic after the recent peace. He then marched his troops to Agrigentum, the center of the ongoing conflict, which was held by a strong garrison of Carthaginians. Fortune smiled on his efforts here. Hanno was the commander of the Carthaginians, but they relied heavily on Mutines and the Numidians. Mutines roamed across Sicily, stealing from the Roman allies, and he couldn't be stopped from accessing Agrigentum, either by force or trickery. His growing fame overshadowed the commander-in-chief, leading to jealousy. Even his successes were viewed with less favor because of who achieved them. Because of this, Hanno eventually handed over command to his own son, thinking that this would diminish the son's sway over the Numidians. However, the opposite happened; the envy only strengthened the Numidians' loyalty to him. He didn't take this slight lightly and quickly sent secret messages to Laevinus to negotiate the surrender of Agrigentum. Once an agreement was reached and how to execute it was planned, the Numidians took control of a gate leading to the sea, driving out or killing the guards, and let in a group of Romans sent for this purpose. As the Roman troops marched noisily into the city and the forum, Hanno, assuming it was just another Numidian disturbance as had happened before, went to quell the uprising. However, seeing from a distance that the numbers were greater than the Numidians and hearing the Roman battle cry he recognized well, he fled before they could reach him. Exiting through a gate on the opposite side, he took Epicydes with him and reached the sea with a few followers; they encountered a small ship just in time. They abandoned Sicily, which they had fought over for so many years, and crossed to Africa. The rest of the Carthaginians and Sicilians fled in a panic, but with all escape routes blocked, they were slaughtered near the gates. Upon taking the town, Laevinus punished and executed the leaders of Agrigentum. He sold the rest along with the plunder and sent all the money to Rome. News of the suffering of the Agrigentines spread throughout Sicily, causing all states to quickly align with the Romans. Soon, twenty towns betrayed them, and six were captured by force. Forty more voluntarily surrendered for protection. The consul rewarded and punished the leading figures of these states based on their actions, and he urged the Sicilians—now that they had laid down their arms—to focus on farming their lands, so the island could not only support its residents but also, as it had often done before, contribute to the supplies of Rome and Italy. He returned to Italy with a disorderly crowd from Agathyrna, totaling around four thousand men, including exiles, bankrupts, and mostly criminals who had lived by stealing, whether under laws in their home towns or after various misfortunes brought them to Agathyrna. Laevinus felt it was unsafe to leave them on the island, which was slowly settling into peace, as they could spark new troubles and could also serve the Rhegians, who needed a gang accustomed to theft to raid the Bruttian territory. Thus, the war in Sicily was concluded for that year.

41

In Spain, in the beginning of spring, Publius Scipio, having launched his ships, and summoned the auxiliary troops of his allies to Tarraco by an edict, ordered his fleet and transports to proceed thence to the mouth of the Iberus. He also ordered his legions to quit their winter quarters, and meet at the same place; and then set out from Tarraco, with five thousand of the allies, to join the army. On his arrival at the camp he considered it right to harangue his soldiers, particularly the old ones who had survived such dreadful disasters; and therefore, calling an assembly, he thus addressed them: "Never was there a new commander before myself who could, with justice and good reason, give thanks to his soldiers before he had availed himself of their services. Fortune laid me under obligations to you before I set eyes on my province or your camp; first, on account of the respect you have shown to my father and uncle, both in their lifetime and since their death; and secondly, because by your valour you have recovered and preserved entire, for the Roman people, and me their successor, the possession of the province which had been lost in consequence of so dreadful a calamity. But since, now, by the favour of the gods, our purpose and endeavour is not that we may remain in Spain ourselves, but that the Carthaginians may not; and not to stand on the bank of the Iberus, and hinder the enemy from crossing that river, but cross it first ourselves, and carry the war to the other side, I fear lest to some among you the enterprise should appear too important and daring, considering your late misfortunes, which are fresh in your recollection, and my years. There is no person from whose mind the memory of the defeats sustained in Spain could be obliterated with more difficulty than from mine; inasmuch as there my father and uncle were both slain within the space of thirty days, so that one death after another was accumulated on my family. But as the orphanhood and desolation of my own family depresses my mind, so both the good fortune and valour of our nation forbid me to despair of the safety of the state. It has happened to us by a kind of fatality, that in all important wars we have been victorious, after having been defeated. I pass over those wars of ancient date with Porsena, the Gauls, and Samnites. I will begin with the Punic wars. How many fleets, generals, and armies were lost in the former war? Why should I mention what has occurred in this present war? I have either been myself present at all the defeats sustained, or have felt more than any other those from which I was absent. What else are the Trebia, the Trasimenus, and Cannae, but monuments of Roman armies and consuls slain? Add to these the defection of Italy, of the greater part of Sicily and Sardinia, and the last terror and panic, the Carthaginian camp pitched between the Anio and the walls of Rome, and the victorious Hannibal seen almost in our gates. Amid this general ruin, the courage of the Roman people alone stood unabated and unshaken. When every thing lay prostrate on the ground, it was this that raised and supported the state. You, first of all, my soldiers, under the conduct and auspices of my father, opposed Hasdrubal on his way to the Alps and Italy, after the defeat of Cannae, who, had he formed a junction with his brother, the Roman name would now have been extinct. These successes formed a counterpoise to those defeats. Now, by the favour of the gods, every thing in Italy and Sicily is going on prosperously and successfully, every day affording matter of fresh joy, and presenting things in a better light. In Sicily, Syracuse and Agrigentum have been captured, the enemy entirely expelled the island, and the province placed again under the dominion of the Romans. In Italy, Arpi has been recovered and Capua taken. Hannibal has been driven into the remotest corner of Bruttium, having fled thither all the way from Rome, in the utmost confusion; and now he asks the gods no greater boon than that he might be allowed to retire in safety, and quit the territory of his enemy. What then, my soldiers, could be more preposterous than that you, who here supported the tottering fortune of the Roman people, together with my parents, (for they may be equally associated in the honour of that epithet,) when calamities crowded one upon another in quick succession, and even the gods themselves, in a manner, took part with Hannibal, should now sink in spirits when every thing is going on happily and prosperously? Even with regard to the events which have recently occurred, I could wish that they had passed with as little grief to me as to you. At the present time the immortal gods who preside over the destinies of the Roman empire, who inspired all the centuries to order the command to be given to me, those same gods, I say, by auguries and auspices, and even by nightly visions, portend entire success and joy. My own mind also, which has hitherto been to me the truest prophet, presages that Spain will be ours; that the whole Carthaginian name will in a short time be banished from this land, and will fill both sea and land with ignominious flight. What my mind presages spontaneously, is also supported by sound reasoning. Their allies, annoyed by them, are by ambassadors imploring our protection; their three generals, having differed so far as almost to have abandoned each other, have divided their army into three parts, which they have drawn off into regions as remote as possible from each other. The same fortune now threatens them which lately afflicted us; for they are both deserted by their allies, as formerly we were by the Celtiberians, and they have divided their forces, which occasioned the ruin of my father and uncle. Neither will their intestine differences allow them to unite, nor will they be able to cope with us singly. Only do you, my soldiers, favour the name of the Scipios, favour the offspring of your generals, a scion springing up from the trunks which have been cut down. Come then, veterans, lead your new commander and your new army across the Iberus, lead us across into a country which you have often traversed, with many a deed of valour. I will soon bring it to pass that, as you now trace in me a likeness to my father and uncle in my features, countenance, and figure, I will so restore a copy of their genius, honour, and courage, to you, that every man of you shall say that his commander, Scipio, has either returned to life, or has been born again."

In Spain, at the start of spring, Publius Scipio launched his ships and called the auxiliary troops of his allies to Tarraco through an edict. He instructed his fleet and transports to head from there to the mouth of the Iberus. He also ordered his legions to leave their winter quarters and gather at the same location; then he set out from Tarraco with five thousand allies to join the army. Upon arriving at the camp, he felt it was important to address his soldiers, especially the veterans who had endured such terrible disasters. Therefore, he called an assembly and said: "Never before me has a new commander justly thanked his soldiers before using their services. Fortune has put me in your debt before I even saw my province or your camp; first, because of the respect you’ve shown to my father and uncle, both in life and after their deaths; and secondly, because through your bravery, you’ve regained and preserved entirely for the Roman people and me, their successor, the province that was lost due to such horrific calamities. But now, thanks to the favor of the gods, our goal is not to stay in Spain ourselves, but to ensure the Carthaginians do not; not to stand on the banks of the Iberus and prevent the enemy from crossing, but to cross it ourselves first and bring the war to the other side. I worry that some of you might think this mission is too ambitious and bold, considering your recent misfortunes, which are still fresh in your minds, and my own youth. No one remembers the defeats suffered in Spain more acutely than I do; after all, my father and uncle were both killed within thirty days, so my family bore one loss after another. However, while the orphanhood and devastation of my family weighs heavily on me, both the good fortune and bravery of our nation prevent me from losing hope in the safety of the state. It seems that by some fate, in all significant wars we’ve emerged victorious after experiencing defeats. I’ll skip over the ancient wars with Porsena, the Gauls, and the Samnites. Let’s start with the Punic wars. How many fleets, generals, and armies were lost in the former conflict? Why dwell on what’s happened in this current war? I have either witnessed all the defeats firsthand or felt their impact more than anyone else from afar. What are the Trebia, the Trasimenus, and Cannae but reminders of Roman armies and consuls who fell? Add to that the defection of Italy, most of Sicily and Sardinia, and the last scare, with the Carthaginian camp set up between the Anio and the walls of Rome, while the victorious Hannibal was practically at our gates. Amidst this widespread disaster, the courage of the Roman people remained unbroken and unshaken. When everything lay flat on the ground, it was this spirit that lifted and sustained the state. You, my soldiers, under my father’s guidance, opposed Hasdrubal on his way to the Alps and Italy after the defeat at Cannae; had he joined forces with his brother, the Roman name would likely have vanished by now. These victories balanced out those defeats. Now, with the support of the gods, everything in Italy and Sicily is flourishing and successful, bringing us new joy every day, and showing us things in a more favorable light. In Sicily, Syracuse and Agrigentum have been taken, the enemy completely expelled from the island, and the province restored to Roman control. In Italy, Arpi has been recaptured and Capua taken. Hannibal has been pushed into the far corner of Bruttium, having fled there from Rome in total chaos; now he asks the gods for no greater favor than to be allowed to escape safely from enemy territory. So what, my soldiers, could be more absurd than for you, who sustained the shaky fortunes of the Roman people along with my parents (who also deserve to share in that honor), to feel disheartened now that everything is going well? I wish that the recent events had caused me as little grief as they have for you. Right now, the immortal gods who oversee the destiny of the Roman Empire, who inspired all the centuries to assign the command to me, those same gods, by omens and signs, and even through dreams, foretell complete success and joy. My own mind, which has been my most trustworthy prophet, predicts that Spain will be ours; that soon the entire Carthaginian name will be driven from this land and will fill both land and sea with shameful flight. What my mind anticipates with confidence is also backed by sound reasons. Their allies, weary of them, are sending ambassadors to implore our protection; their three leaders have quarreled to the point of nearly abandoning each other, splitting their army into three parts, each withdrawing to distant regions. The same fate now looms over them that just recently afflicted us; they are deserted by allies, just as we were by the Celtiberians, and they’ve divided their forces, which led to the downfall of my father and uncle. Their internal conflicts will prevent them from coming together, and they won't be able to stand against us separately. Only you, my soldiers, support the name of the Scipios, support the descendants of your generals, a branch sprouting from the stumps that have been cut down. So come, veterans, lead your new commander and your new army across the Iberus, guide us into a land you have often traversed in acts of valor. I will soon ensure that, just as you now see in me a resemblance to my father and uncle in my appearance, I will restore a reflection of their spirit, honor, and courage, so that each of you will say your commander, Scipio, has either come back to life or has been reborn."

42

Having animated his troops with this harangue, and leaving Marcus Silanus with three thousand infantry and three hundred horse, for the protection of that district, he crossed the Iberus with all the rest of his troops, consisting of twenty-five thousand infantry and two thousand five hundred horse. Though certain persons there endeavoured to persuade him that, as the Carthaginian armies had retired from each other into three such distant quarters, he should attack the nearest of them; yet concluding that if he did so there was danger lest he should cause them to concentrate all their forces, and he alone should not be a match for so many, he determined for the present to make an attack upon New Carthage, a city not only possessing great wealth of its own, but also full of every kind of military store belonging to the enemy; there were their arms, their money, and the hostages from every part of Spain. It was, besides, conveniently situated, not only for a passage into Africa, but also near a port sufficiently capacious for a fleet of any magnitude, and, for aught I know, the only one on the coast of Spain which is washed by our sea. No one but Caius Laelius knew whither he was going. He was sent round with the fleet, and ordered so to regulate the sailing of his ships, that the army might come in view and the fleet enter the harbour at the same time. Both the fleet and army arrived at the same time at New Carthage, on the seventh day after leaving the Iberus. The camp was pitched over against that part of the city which looks to the north. A rampart was thrown up as a defence on the rear of it, for the front was secured by the nature of the ground. Now the situation of New Carthage is as follows: at about the middle of the coast of Spain is a bay facing for the most part the south-west, about two thousand five hundred paces in depth, and a little more in breadth. In the mouth of this bay is a small island forming a barrier towards the sea, and protecting the harbour from every wind except the south-west. From the bottom of the bay there runs out a peninsula, which forms the eminence on which the city is built; which is washed in the east and south by the sea, and on the west is enclosed by a lake which extends a little way also towards the north, of variable depth according as the sea overflows or ebbs. An isthmus of about two hundred paces broad connects the city with the continent, on which, though it would have been a work of so little labour, the Roman general did not raise a rampart; whether his object was to make a display of his confidence to the enemy from motives of pride, or that he might have free regress when frequently advancing to the walls of the city.

Having fired up his troops with this speech, and leaving Marcus Silanus with three thousand infantry and three hundred cavalry to protect the area, he crossed the Iberus with the rest of his forces, totaling twenty-five thousand infantry and two thousand five hundred cavalry. Although some tried to convince him that, since the Carthaginian armies had scattered into three distant locations, he should attack the closest one, he felt that doing so could cause them to pool their forces together, and he wouldn’t stand a chance against so many. He decided, for now, to launch an attack on New Carthage, a city not only rich in its own resources but also stocked with all kinds of military supplies belonging to the enemy; their weapons, money, and hostages from across Spain were all there. Additionally, it was conveniently located for a route into Africa and near a port large enough for any fleet. It might even be the only port on the Spanish coast facing our sea. Only Caius Laelius knew where he was headed. He was sent around with the fleet, instructed to time the sailing of his ships so that the army would appear and the fleet would enter the harbor simultaneously. Both the fleet and army reached New Carthage on the seventh day after leaving the Iberus. The camp was set up opposite the part of the city facing north. A rampart was built for defense in the rear since the front was already protected by the terrain. Now, the layout of New Carthage is as follows: around the middle of the Spanish coast lies a bay mostly facing southwest, about two thousand five hundred paces deep and a little wider. At the mouth of this bay is a small island that acts as a barrier from the sea, shielding the harbor from all winds except the southwest. From the back of the bay extends a peninsula, which forms the elevated area where the city is built, washed by the sea on the east and south, and bordered by a lake to the west that stretches a bit toward the north, with its depth changing depending on the tides. An isthmus about two hundred paces wide connects the city to the mainland, and although it would have required minimal effort, the Roman general did not build a rampart there—perhaps to show off his confidence to the enemy out of pride, or so he could easily retreat when he often approached the city’s walls.

43

Having completed the other requisite works, he drew up his ships in the harbour, that he might exhibit to the enemy the appearance of a blockade by sea also; he then went round the fleet, and having warned the commanders of the ships to be particularly careful in keeping the night-watches, because an enemy, when besieged, usually tried every effort and in every quarter at first, he returned into his camp; and in order to explain to his soldiers the reason why he had adopted the plan of commencing the war with the siege of a city, in preference to any other, and also by exhortations to inspire them with hopes of making themselves masters of it, he summoned them to an assembly, and thus addressed them: "Soldiers, if any one among you suppose that you have been brought here to attack a single city, that man takes a more exact account of your present labour than of its profitable result from it. For you will in truth attack the walls of a single city, but in that single city you will have made yourselves masters of all Spain. Here are the hostages of all her most distinguished kings and states; and as soon as you shall have gained possession of these, they will immediately deliver into your hands every thing which is now subject to the Carthaginians. Here is the whole of the enemy's treasure, without which they cannot carry on the war, as they are keeping mercenary troops, and which will be most serviceable to us in conciliating the affections of the barbarians. Here are their engines, their arms, their tackle, and every requisite in war; which will at once supply you, and leave the enemy destitute. Besides, we shall gain possession of a city, not only of the greatest beauty and wealth, but also most convenient as having an excellent harbour, by means of which we may be supplied with every requisite for carrying on the war both by sea and land. Great as are the advantages we shall thus gain, we shall deprive our enemies of much greater. This is their citadel, their granary, their treasury, their magazine, their receptacle for every thing. Hence there is a direct passage into Africa; this is the only station for a fleet between the Pyrenees and Gades; this gives to Africa the command of all Spain. But as I perceive you are arrayed and marshalled, let us pass on to the assault of New Carthage, with our whole strength, and with undaunted courage." Upon this, they all with, one accord cried out that it should be done; and he led them to Carthage, and ordered that the assault should be made both by sea and land.

Having finished the necessary preparations, he lined up his ships in the harbor to create the impression of a naval blockade for the enemy. He then went around the fleet and advised the ship commanders to be particularly vigilant during the night watches, as an enemy under siege typically tries every tactic from various angles. After that, he returned to his camp and explained to his soldiers why he chose to start the war with the siege of a city rather than another approach. He aimed to inspire them with hopes of taking it over. He called them to an assembly and addressed them: "Soldiers, if anyone among you thinks you’ve come here just to take a single city, that person doesn’t fully grasp the significance of your current efforts. Yes, you will attack the walls of one city, but in doing so, you will gain control over all of Spain. Here are the hostages of its most notable kings and states; once you seize these, they will surrender everything currently under Carthaginian rule. Here lies the enemy's entire treasury, essential for their war effort since they rely on mercenary troops, and it will be invaluable for winning over the support of the local tribes. Here are their engines, weapons, supplies, and everything else needed for war; this will equip you while leaving the enemy powerless. Moreover, we will gain a city not only of great beauty and wealth but also with an outstanding harbor that can supply us with everything we need for conducting the war both by sea and land. The benefits we will gain are substantial, while we will take away even greater advantages from our enemies. This is their fortress, their food supply, their treasury, their storehouse for everything. From here, there is a direct route into Africa; it is the only strategic point for a fleet between the Pyrenees and Gades; this gives Africa control over all of Spain. But since I see you ready and organized, let us move forward to the assault on New Carthage, with all our strength and fearless resolve." At this, they all shouted in unison that it should be done; he led them to Carthage and ordered the assault to take place by both sea and land.

44

On the other side, Mago, the Carthaginian general, perceiving that a siege was being prepared for both by sea and land, himself also disposed his forces thus: he placed two thousand of the townsmen to oppose the enemy, on the side facing the Roman camp; he occupied the citadel with five hundred soldiers, and stationed five hundred on a rising ground, facing the east; the rest of his troops he ordered, intent on every thing that occurred, to hasten with assistance wherever the shout, or any sudden emergency, might call them. Then, throwing open the gate, he sent out those he had drawn up in the street leading to the camp of the enemy. The Romans, according to the direction of their general, retired a little, in order that they might be nearer to the reserved troops which were to be sent to their assistance during the engagement. At first they stood with pretty equal force, but afterwards the reserved troops, sent from time to time from the camp, not only obliged the enemy to turn their backs, but followed them up so close when flying in disorder, that had not a retreat been sounded, they seemed as though they would have rushed into the city together with the fugitives. The consternation in the field was not greater than in every part of the city; many of the outposts were abandoned in panic and flight; and the walls were deserted, as they leaped down each in the part nearest him. Scipio, who had gone out to an eminence called Mercury's hill, perceiving that the walls were abandoned by their defenders in many parts, ordered all his men to be called out of his camp and advance to take the city, and orders them to bring the scaling-ladders. The general himself, covered by the shields of three stout young men, (for now an immense number of missiles of every description were let fly from the walls,) came up to the city, cheered them on, and gave the requisite orders; and, what was of the utmost importance in exciting the courage of his men, he appeared among them a witness and spectator of the valour or cowardice of each. Accordingly, they rushed forward, amidst wounds and weapons; nor could the walls, or the armed troops which stood upon them, repel them from eagerly mounting them. At the same time an attack was commenced by the fleet upon that part of the city which was washed by the sea. But here the alarm occasioned was greater than the force which could be employed; for while they were bringing the boats to shore, and hastily landing the ladders and the men, each man pressing forward to gain the land the shortest way, they hindered one another by their very haste and eagerness.

On the other side, Mago, the Carthaginian general, seeing that a siege was being set up from both the sea and land, organized his forces as follows: he stationed two thousand townsmen to face the enemy near the Roman camp; he occupied the citadel with five hundred soldiers and positioned five hundred on a hill facing east; the rest of his troops were instructed to stay alert and rush to help wherever a shout or sudden emergency arose. Then, he opened the gate and sent out those he had lined up in the street leading to the enemy's camp. Following their general's orders, the Romans pulled back slightly to be closer to the reserve troops that would assist them during the fight. Initially, both sides had almost equal strength, but eventually, the reinforcements sent from the camp forced the enemy to retreat, pursuing them so closely that if a retreat hadn't been called, it seemed they would have burst into the city along with the fleeing soldiers. The panic in the field matched the chaos throughout the city; many outposts were abandoned in fear, and the walls were left empty as defenders jumped down from their positions. Scipio, who had gone up to a high point called Mercury's Hill, noticed that defenders had fled from many sections of the walls. He ordered all his men to leave the camp and advance to take the city, telling them to bring the scaling ladders. The general himself, shielded by three strong young men (as a huge number of missiles were being hurled from the walls), approached the city, encouraging them and giving necessary orders. To inspire his troops' courage, he actively participated as an observer of each soldier's bravery or cowardice. Consequently, they charged forward, despite injuries and attacks; the walls and the armed troops on them could not keep them from climbing eagerly. At the same time, an assault was launched by the fleet on the part of the city facing the sea. However, the fear created there was greater than the forces they could deploy; as they brought the boats ashore and quickly unloaded the ladders and men, the rush to reach the land resulted in them hindering one another with their impatience and eagerness.

45

In the mean time, the Carthaginians had now filled the walls again with armed men, who were supplied with a great quantity of missiles from the immense stores which they had laid up. But neither men nor missiles, nor any thing else, so effectually defended them as the walls themselves, for very few of the ladders were equal to the height of them, and all those which were longer than the rest were proportionably weaker. Accordingly, those who were highest being unable to mount from them, and being followed, nevertheless, by others, they broke from the mere weight upon them. Some, though the ladders stood, a dizziness having come over their eyes in consequence of the height, fell to the ground. And as men and ladders were every where tumbling down, while the boldness and alacrity of the enemy were increased by the mere success, the signal for retreat was sounded, which afforded hopes to the besieged, not only of present rest after such a laborious contest, but also for the future, as it appeared their city could not be taken by scalade and siege. To raise works they considered would be attended with difficulty, and would give time to their generals to bring them assistance. Scarcely had the first tumult subsided, when Scipio ordered other fresh and unfatigued troops to take the ladders from those who were tired and wounded and assault the city with increased vigour. Having received intelligence that the tide was ebbing, and having before been informed by some fishermen of Tarraco who used to pass through the lake, sometimes in light boats, and, when these ran aground, by wading, that it afforded an easy passage to the wall for footmen, he led some armed men thither in person. It was about mid-day, and besides that the water was being drawn off naturally, in consequence of the tide receding, a brisk north wind rising impelled the water in the lake, which was already in motion, in the same direction as the tide, and rendered it so shallow, that in some parts the water reached only to the navel, while in others it scarcely rose above the knees. Scipio, referring this discovery, which he had made by his own diligence and penetration, to the gods and to miracle, which had turned the course of the sea, withdrawn it from the lake, and opened ways never before trodden by human feet to afford a passage to the Romans, ordered them to follow Neptune as their guide, and passing through the middle of the lake, make good their way to the walls.

In the meantime, the Carthaginians had filled their walls again with armed men, who were supplied with a large amount of missiles from the vast stockpiles they had stored up. But neither the soldiers nor the missiles could defend them as effectively as the walls themselves, since very few of the ladders were tall enough to reach the top, and those that were longer were proportionately weaker. As a result, the men at the top, unable to climb onto the walls, were followed by others, and the sheer weight caused the ladders to break. Some men fell to the ground, even though the ladders were still standing, as they were overcome by dizziness from the height. With men and ladders tumbling everywhere, and the enemy's confidence growing from their success, the retreat signal was sounded, giving hope to those inside the city, not only for immediate relief after such a strenuous battle but also for their future, as it seemed that their city could not be taken by assault or siege. They thought that raising more fortifications would be difficult and would give their generals time to bring help. Hardly had the initial chaos settled down when Scipio ordered fresh and unweary troops to take the ladders from the tired and injured and attack the city with renewed vigor. Having learned that the tide was going out, and being informed by some fishermen from Tarraco who would sometimes navigate the lake in small boats, and when these ran aground, would wade through, that it provided an easy path to the wall for foot soldiers, he personally led some armed men to that location. It was around midday, and in addition to the naturally receding water due to the tide, a strong north wind was pushing the water in the lake, which was already moving, in the same direction as the tide, making it so shallow that in some areas the water reached only to the waist, while in others it barely reached the knees. Scipio attributed this discovery, which he had made through his own effort and insight, to the gods and to a miracle that had diverted the sea, drawn it away from the lake, and opened paths never before traveled by human feet to provide a passage for the Romans. He ordered them to follow Neptune as their guide and, passing through the middle of the lake, to make their way to the walls.

46

Those who renewed the assault by land experienced great difficulty; for they were baffled not only by the height of the walls, but also because they exposed the Romans, as they approached them, to the missiles of the enemy from different quarters, so that their sides were endangered more than the fronts of their bodies. But in the other quarter five hundred passed without difficulty through the lake, and then mounted the wall, for neither was it defended by any fortifications, because there they thought the city was sufficiently protected by the nature of the place and the lake, nor were there any outposts or guards stationed there, because all were engaged in bringing succour to that quarter in which the danger appeared. Having entered the city without opposition, they proceeded direct, with all possible speed, to that gate near which the contest was concentrated; and so intently occupied with this were not only the minds, but the eyes and ears of all, both of those who were engaged in fighting, and of those who were looking on and encouraging the combatants, that no one perceived that the city had been captured in their rear till the weapons fell upon their backs, and they had an enemy on both sides of them. Then, the defenders having been thrown into confusion through fear, both the walls were captured, and the gate began to be broken open both from within and from without; and presently, the doors having been broken to pieces by blows, in order that the way might not be obstructed, the troops rushed in. A great number had also got over the walls, but these employed themselves in putting the townsmen to the sword; those which entered by the gate, forming a regular body, with officers and in ranks, advanced through the midst of the city into the forum. Scipio then perceiving that the enemy fled in two different directions, some to the eminence which lay eastward, which was occupied by a garrison of five hundred men, others to the citadel, into which Mago himself also had fled for refuge, together with almost all the troops which had been driven from the walls, sent part of his forces to storm the hill, and part he led in person against the citadel. Not only was the hill captured at the first assault, but Mago also, after making an effort to defend it, when he saw every place filled with the enemy, and that there was no hope, surrendered himself and the citadel, with the garrison. Until the citadel was surrendered, the massacre was continued in every quarter throughout the city; nor did they spare any one they met who had arrived at puberty: but after that, on a signal given, a stop was put to the carnage, and the victors turned their attention to the plunder, of which there was an immense quantity of every description.

Those who renewed the land attack faced significant challenges; they were hindered not just by the height of the walls but also because their approach exposed them to projectiles from the enemy coming from various directions, putting their flanks at greater risk than their fronts. However, in another area, five hundred soldiers crossed the lake easily and then climbed the wall, as it wasn’t fortified—believing the city was well protected by the landscape and the lake. There were no outposts or guards there since everyone was busy aiding the part of the city that seemed in danger. Once they entered the city without any resistance, they rushed directly towards the gate where the battle was focusing. Both the fighters and the spectators were so engrossed in the clash that no one noticed the city had been taken from behind until they felt weapons striking their backs, finding themselves surrounded by enemies. This caused panic among the defenders, leading to the walls being breached, and the gate being forced open from both inside and outside. Soon, as the doors were smashed to clear the way, the troops poured in. Many had also climbed over the walls, but they focused on slaughtering the townspeople; those entering through the gate formed an organized unit, with leaders and in ranks, advancing through the city towards the forum. Scipio then noticed the enemy fleeing in two directions: some towards the hill to the east, which was held by a garrison of five hundred troops, and others to the citadel, where Mago himself had sought refuge along with most of the troops that had been driven from the walls. He dispatched part of his forces to attack the hill while leading the other part towards the citadel. Not only was the hill taken immediately, but Mago also, after trying to defend it, surrendered himself and the citadel, along with the garrison, when he realized there was no hope left. The massacre continued throughout the city until the citadel gave up; they spared no male who was of age. After a signal was given, the slaughter stopped, and the victors then turned their focus to the immense amount of plunder available in every possible form.

47

Of males of free condition, as many as ten thousand were captured. Of these he allowed to depart such as were citizens of New Carthage; and restored to them their city, and all their property which the war had left them. The artisans amounted to two thousand, whom he assigned to the Roman people as their property; holding out to them a hope of speedy emancipation, provided they should address themselves strenuously to the service of the war. Of the rest of the mass of inhabitants, the young men and able-bodied slaves he assigned for the service of the fleet, to fill up the numbers of the rowers. He had also augmented his fleet with five ships which he had captured. Besides this multitude, there remained the Spanish hostages, to whom as much attention was paid as if they had been children of allies. An immense quantity of military stores was also taken; one hundred and twenty catapultae of the larger size, two hundred and eighty-one of the smaller; twenty-three ballistae of the larger size, fifty-two of the smaller; an immense number of scorpions of the larger and smaller size, and also of arms and missile weapons; and seventy-four military standards. Of gold and silver, an immense quantity was brought to the general; there were two hundred and seventy-six golden bowls, almost all of them weighing a pound; of silver, wrought and coined, eighteen thousand three hundred pounds' weight; and of silver vessels an immense number. All these were weighed and reckoned to the quaestor, Caius Flaminius. There were twenty thousand pecks of wheat, and two hundred and seventy of barley. One hundred and thirteen ships of burden were boarded and captured in the harbour, some of them with their cargoes, consisting of corn and arms, besides brass, iron, sails, spartum, and other naval materials, of use in equipping a fleet; so that amid such large military stores which were captured, Carthage itself was of the least consideration.

Ten thousand free men were captured. Out of this number, he allowed those who were citizens of New Carthage to go home, restoring their city and all the property that the war had spared. There were two thousand artisans, whom he assigned to the Roman people as their property, offering them the hope of quick freedom if they worked hard in service of the war. The remaining young men and able-bodied slaves were assigned to the fleet to serve as rowers. He also boosted his fleet by capturing five ships. In addition to this group, there were Spanish hostages, treated with as much care as if they were the children of allies. A vast quantity of military supplies was seized: one hundred twenty large catapults, two hundred eighty-one smaller ones; twenty-three large ballistae, fifty-two smaller ones; an immense number of scorpions of various sizes, along with arms and missiles; and seventy-four military standards. A huge amount of gold and silver was taken to the general, including two hundred seventy-six golden bowls, most weighing about a pound; eighteen thousand three hundred pounds of worked and minted silver; and countless silver vessels. All of this was weighed and accounted for by the quaestor, Caius Flaminius. There were twenty thousand pecks of wheat and two hundred seventy of barley. One hundred thirteen cargo ships were boarded and captured in the harbor, some with their loads, including grain and weapons, as well as brass, iron, sails, spartan, and other materials needed for equipping a fleet. With such a large amount of military supplies captured, Carthage itself became of little importance.

48

Having ordered Caius Laelius with the marines to guard the city, Scipio led back his legions to the camp the same day in person; and as his soldiers were tired, as they had in one day gone through every kind of military labour; for they had engaged the enemy in the field, and had undergone very great fatigue and danger in taking the city; and after they had taken it had fought, and that on disadvantageous ground, with those who had fled to the citadel, he ordered them to attend to themselves. The next day, having assembled the land and naval forces, he, in the first place, ascribed praise and thanks to the immortal gods, who had not only in one day made him master of the wealthiest city in Spain, but had previously collected in it the riches of almost all Africa and Spain; so that while his enemy had nothing left, he and his army had a superabundance of every thing. He then commended in the highest terms the valour of his soldiers, because that neither the sally of the enemy, nor the height of the walls, nor the unexplored fords of the lake, nor the fort standing upon a high hill, nor the citadel, though most strongly fortified, had deterred them from surmounting and breaking through every thing. Therefore, though all credit was due to them all, he said that the man who first mounted the wall ought to be distinguished above the rest, by being honoured with a mural crown; and he desired that he who thought himself worthy of that reward would claim it. Two persons laid claim to it, Quintus Trebellius, a centurion of the fourth legion, and Sextus Digitius, a marine. Nor did these contest so fiercely as each excited the zeal of his own body of men. Caius Laelius, admiral of the fleet, patronized the marines, and Marcus Sempronius Tuditanus, the legionary troops. As this contest began almost to assume the character of a mutiny, Scipio having notified that he should appoint three delegates, who, after making themselves acquainted with the case, and examining the witnesses, might decide which had been the first to scale the wall and enter the town, added Publius Cornelius Caudinus, a middle party, to Laelius and Sempronius, the advocates of the two parties, and ordered these three delegates to sit and determine the cause. But as the contest was now carried on with increased warmth, because those high characters, who had acted more as moderators of the zeal of both than as advocates of any particular party, were withdrawn, Caius Laelius, leaving the council, went up to the tribunal of Scipio and informed him, "that the contest was proceeding without bounds or moderation, and that they had almost come to blows. But still, though no violence should take place, that the proceedings formed a most hateful precedent, for that the honours due to valour were being sought by fraud and perjury. That on one side stood the legionary troops, on the other the marines, ready to swear by all the gods what they wished, rather than what they knew, to be true, and to involve in the guilt of perjury not only themselves and their own persons, but the military standards, the eagles, and their solemn oath of allegiance. That he laid these matters before him, in accordance with the opinion of Publius Cornelius and Marcus Sempronius." Scipio, after highly praising Laelius, summoned an assembly, and then declared, "that he had ascertained satisfactorily that Quintus Trebellius and Sextus Digitius had mounted the wall at the same time, and that he presented them both with mural crowns in consideration of their valour." He then gave presents to the rest, according to the merit and valour of each. Above all he honoured Caius Laelius, the admiral of the fleet, by the placing him upon an equality with himself, and bestowing upon him every kind of commendation, and also by presenting him with a golden crown and thirty oxen.

Having assigned Caius Laelius and the marines to guard the city, Scipio personally led his legions back to camp the same day. His soldiers were exhausted after a day filled with various military tasks; they had fought the enemy in the field and endured great fatigue and danger while capturing the city. After taking it, they battled those who had sought refuge in the citadel, fighting on difficult ground. He instructed them to take care of themselves. The next day, once he gathered the land and naval forces, he first praised and thanked the immortal gods, who had made him the master of the wealthiest city in Spain in just one day, a city that had previously accumulated riches from much of Africa and Spain. While his enemy was left with nothing, he and his army had an abundance of everything. He then commended his soldiers for their bravery, noting that not even the enemy’s charge, the height of the walls, the unknown fords of the lake, the fortified high ground, or the stronghold had prevented them from overcoming every obstacle. Acknowledging that all the soldiers deserved credit, he said the person who first climbed the wall should be recognized above the rest with a mural crown and encouraged anyone who felt worthy to claim it. Two soldiers came forward, Quintus Trebellius, a centurion of the fourth legion, and Sextus Digitius, a marine. Their rivalry wasn't so intense as they both inspired their own troops. Caius Laelius, the fleet's admiral, supported the marines, while Marcus Sempronius Tuditanus represented the legionary troops. As the competition began to resemble a mutiny, Scipio announced he would select three delegates to investigate the situation and determine who had scaled the wall first. He included Publius Cornelius Caudinus as a neutral party along with Laelius and Sempronius, who advocated for the two claimants, and instructed them to sit and resolve the issue. As the contest heated up—because the esteemed figures had stepped back from advocating for any side—Caius Laelius approached Scipio's platform and informed him that the dispute was escalating without restraint, and they were close to fighting. He added that even without violence, the proceedings set a terrible precedent, as honors due to bravery were being sought through deceit and perjury. On one side, the legionary troops stood ready to swear by all the gods what they wished to be true rather than what was real, risking perjury not only for themselves but also for their standards, eagles, and solemn oaths. He presented these concerns in line with the views of Publius Cornelius and Marcus Sempronius. Scipio, praising Laelius, called for an assembly and announced that he had confirmed both Quintus Trebellius and Sextus Digitius had scaled the wall simultaneously, awarding both of them mural crowns for their valor. He then gave gifts to the others based on each person's merit and bravery. Above all, he honored Caius Laelius, the admiral of the fleet, by placing him on equal footing with himself, showering him with praise, and also presenting him with a golden crown and thirty oxen.

49

He then ordered the Spanish hostages to be summoned. What the number of these was I feel reluctant to state, because in some authors I find that it was about three hundred, in others seven hundred and twenty-five. There is the same difference between authors with regard to the other particulars. One writes that the Punic garrison consisted of ten thousand, another of seven, a third of not more than two thousand. In some you may find that ten thousand persons were captured, in others above twenty-five thousand. I should have stated the number of scorpions captured, both of the greater and smaller size, at sixty, if I had followed the Greek author, Silenus, if Valerius Antius, of the larger at six thousand, of the smaller at thirteen, so great is the extent of falsehood. Nor are they agreed even respecting the commanders, most say that Laelius commanded the fleet, but some say Marcus Junius Silanus. Valerius Antius says, that Arines commanded the Punic garrison, and was given up to the Romans; other writers say it was Mago. They are not agreed respecting the number of the ships taken, respecting the weight of gold and silver, and of the money brought into the public treasury. If we must assent to some of their statements, the medium is nearest to the truth. However, Scipio having summoned the hostages, first bid them all keep up their spirits observing, "that they had fallen into the hands of the Roman people, who chose to bind men to them by benefits rather than by fear, and keep foreign nations attached to them by honour and friendship, rather than subject them to a gloomy servitude." Then receiving the names of the states to which they belonged, he took an account of the captives, distinguishing the number belonging to each people, and sent messengers to their homes, to desire that they would come and take back their respective friends. If ambassadors from any of the states happened to be present, he delivered their countrymen to them in person, and assigned to them the quaestor, Caius Flaminius, the charge of kindly taking care of the rest. Meanwhile, there advanced from the midst of the crowd of hostages a woman in years, the wife of Mandonius, who was the brother of Indibilis, the chieftain of the Illergetians; she threw herself weeping at the general's feet, and began to implore him to give particularly strict injunctions to their guardians with respect to the care and treatment of females. Scipio replied, that nothing certainly should be wanting; when the woman rejoined: "We do not much value such things, for what is not good enough for such a condition? A care of a different kind disquiets me, when beholding the age of these females; for I am myself no longer exposed to the danger peculiar to females." Around her stood the daughters of Indibilis, in the bloom of youth and beauty, with others of equal rank, all of whom looked up to her as a parent. Scipio then said: "Out of regard for that discipline which I myself and the Roman nation maintain, I should take care that nothing, which is any where held sacred, should be violated among us. In the present case, your virtue and your rank cause me to observe it more strictly; for not even in the midst of misfortunes have you forgotten the delicacy becoming matrons." He then delivered them over to a man of tried virtue, ordering him to treat them with no less respect and modesty than the wives and mothers of guests.

He then ordered the Spanish hostages to be brought forward. I'm hesitant to state the exact number because, according to some sources, it was about three hundred, while others claim it was seven hundred and twenty-five. The same discrepancies exist among authors regarding other details. One claims the Punic garrison had ten thousand soldiers, another says seven thousand, and a third states it was no more than two thousand. Some sources report that ten thousand people were captured, while others say it was over twenty-five thousand. I would mention that the number of captured scorpions, both large and small, was sixty if I were following the Greek writer Silenus; Valerius Antius claims it was six thousand large scorpions and thirteen small ones, highlighting the extent of misinformation. They can't even agree on the commanders; most say Laelius commanded the fleet, but some say it was Marcus Junius Silanus. Valerius Antius claims Arines led the Punic garrison and was handed over to the Romans, while other writers say it was Mago. There’s disagreement on the number of ships captured, the amount of gold and silver, and the money taken into the public treasury. If we have to accept some of their reports, the median is likely closest to the truth. Nevertheless, after summoning the hostages, Scipio first encouraged them, saying that they had fallen into the hands of the Roman people, who preferred to bind individuals through benefits rather than fear, and keep foreign nations allied through honor and friendship rather than subject them to harsh servitude. Then, after recording the names of their states, he accounted for the captives, separating the numbers according to each group, and sent messengers to their homes, asking them to come and take back their friends. If ambassadors from any of the states were present, he handed their countrymen over to them directly and assigned the quaestor, Caius Flaminius, to take care of the rest compassionately. Meanwhile, a middle-aged woman came forward from the crowd of hostages, the wife of Mandonius, who was the brother of Indibilis, the chieftain of the Illergetians. She fell weeping at the general’s feet and began to plead with him to ensure that their guardians would take special care of the women. Scipio replied that he would certainly ensure nothing was lacking, to which the woman responded, “We don’t care much about those things because what’s not good enough for such a situation? What worries me is a different kind of concern, as I look at the age of these women; I’m no longer at risk from the dangers that affect women.” Surrounding her were Indibilis’s daughters, in the prime of their youth and beauty, along with others of equal status, all of whom looked up to her as a mother. Scipio then said: “Out of respect for the discipline that I and the Roman nation uphold, I will make sure that nothing regarded as sacred is violated among us. In this case, your virtue and your status require me to uphold it even more strictly; for even in the midst of misfortunes, you have not forgotten the dignity expected of matrons.” He then entrusted them to a man of proven virtue, instructing him to treat them with the same respect and modesty as the wives and mothers of guests.

50

The soldiers then brought to him a female captive, a grown-up virgin, of such exquisite beauty, that whichever way she walked she attracted the eyes of every body. Scipio, on making inquiries as to her country and parentage, heard, among other particulars, that she was betrothed to a young prince of the Celtiberians, named Allucius. He immediately, therefore, summoned from their abode her parents and lover, and having heard in the mean time that the latter was desperately enamoured of her, as soon as he arrived he addressed him in a more studied manner than her parents. "A young man myself," said he, "I address myself to a young man, and therefore there need be the less reserve in this conversation. As soon as your intended bride, having been captured by my soldiers, was brought into my presence, and I was informed that she was endeared to you, which her beauty rendered probable, considering that I should myself wish that my affection for my intended bride, though excessive, should meet with indulgence, could I enjoy the pleasures suited to my age, (particularly in an honourable and lawful love,) and were not my mind engrossed by public affairs, I indulge as far as I can your passion. Your mistress, while under my protection, has received as much respect as under the roof of her own parents, your father-in-law and mother-in-law. She has been kept in perfect safety for you, that she might be presented to you pure, a gift worthy of me and of you. This only reward I bargain for in return for the service I have rendered you, that you would be a friend to the Roman people, and if you believe that I am a true man, as these nations knew my father and uncle to have been heretofore, that you would feel assured that in the Roman state there are many like us, and that no nation in the world at the present time can be mentioned, with which you ought to be less disposed that you, or those belonging to you, should be at enmity, or with which you would rather be in friendship." The young man, overcome at once with joy and modesty, clung to Scipio's right hand, and invoked all the gods to recompense him in his behalf, since he himself was far from possessing means proportioned either to his own wishes or Scipio's deserts. He then addressed himself to the parents and relatives of the damsel, who, on receiving her back without any reward, whom they had brought a very large weight of gold to redeem, entreated Scipio to accept it from them as a present to himself; affirming, that if he would do so, they should feel as grateful for it as they did for the restoration of their daughter inviolate. As they were so earnest in their entreaties, Scipio promised to accept it, and ordered it to be laid at his feet. Then calling Allucius to him, he said: "To the dowry which you are about to receive from your father-in-law, let these marriage presents also from me be added;" bidding him take away the gold and keep it for himself. Delighted with these presents and honours, he was dismissed to his home, where he inspired his countrymen with the deserved praises of Scipio, observing, "that a most godlike youth had come among them, who conquered every thing, not only by arms, but by kindness and generosity." Accordingly, making a levy among his dependants, he returned to Scipio after a few days, with fourteen hundred chosen horsemen.

The soldiers then brought him a female captive, a grown virgin, whose beauty was so exceptional that wherever she walked, she caught everyone's attention. When Scipio asked about her background, he learned, among other details, that she was engaged to a young prince of the Celtiberians named Allucius. Immediately, he called for her parents and fiancé, and upon hearing that the latter was deeply in love with her, he spoke to him with more thoughtfulness than to her parents. "As a young man myself," he said, "I’m speaking to a young man, so we can be more open in this discussion. When your intended bride was captured by my soldiers and brought to me, I was told that she is dear to you, which her beauty suggests. If I were in your position and my feelings for my betrothed were strong, I'd hope for kindness in return, especially in a legitimate love, were it not for my obligations to public matters. I want to honor your affection as much as I can. While she has been under my care, she has been treated with as much respect as if she were in her own home with you and your parents. She has been kept safe for you, to present her to you pure, a gift worthy of both of us. In return for this service, I ask only that you be a friend to the Roman people. If you trust that I am sincere, as these nations knew my father and uncle to be, understand that there are many like us in the Roman state, and there's no nation you should be less inclined to oppose, or one you would prefer to be enemies with." The young man, overwhelmed with joy and humility, grasped Scipio's right hand and prayed to all the gods to reward him, since he lacked the means to offer anything befitting Scipio’s generosity. He then turned to the girl’s parents and relatives, who, having brought a large amount of gold to redeem her, begged Scipio to accept it as a gift. They promised that if he did so, they would feel just as grateful for him getting their daughter back unharmed. Seeing their sincerity, Scipio agreed to accept the gold and instructed that it be placed at his feet. Then he called Allucius over and said, "In addition to the dowry you’re about to receive from your father-in-law, let these marriage gifts from me be included," directing him to take the gold and keep it for himself. Overjoyed by these gifts and honors, Allucius was sent home, where he shared Scipio's rightful praise with his fellow countrymen, saying, "A truly godlike young man has come among us, one who conquers everything, not just with force, but with kindness and generosity." After a few days, he gathered his supporters and returned to Scipio with fourteen hundred elite horsemen.

51

Scipio kept Laelius with him until he had disposed of the captives, hostages, and booty, in accordance with his advice; but when all these matters were satisfactorily arranged, he gave him a quinquereme; and selecting from the captives Mago, and about fifteen senators who had been made prisoners at the same time with him, put them on board, and sent him to Rome with the news of his victory. He himself employed the few days he had resolved to stay at Carthage, in exercising his naval and land forces. On the first day the legions under arms performed evolutions through a space of four miles; on the second day he ordered them to repair and clean their arms before their tents; on the third day they engaged in imitation of a regular battle with wooden swords, throwing javelins with the points covered with balls; on the fourth day they rested; on the fifth they again performed evolutions under arms. This succession of exercise and rest they kept up as long as they staid at Carthage. The rowers and mariners, pushing out to sea when the weather was calm, made trial of the manageableness of their ships by mock sea-fights. Such exercises, both by sea and land, without the city prepared their minds and bodies for war. The city itself was all bustle with warlike preparations, artificers of every description being collected together in a public workshop. The general went round to all the works with equal attention. At one time he was employed in the dock-yard with his fleet, at another he exercised with the legions; sometimes he would devote his time to the inspection of the works, which were every day carried on with the greatest eagerness by a multitude of artificers both in the workshops, and in the armoury and docks. Having put these preparations in a train, repaired the walls in a part where they had been shattered, and placed bodies of troops to guard the city, he set out for Tarraco; and on his way thither was visited by a number of embassies, some of which he dismissed, having given them answers on his journey, others he postponed till his arrival at Tarraco; at which place he had appointed a meeting of all his new and old allies. Here ambassadors from almost all the people dwelling on this side the Iberus, and from many dwelling in the further Spain, met. The Carthaginian generals at first industriously suppressed the rumour of the capture of Carthage; but afterwards, when it became too notorious to be concealed or dissembled, they disparaged its importance by their language. They said, that "by an unexpected attack, and in a manner by stealth, in one day, one city of Spain had been snatched out of their hands; that a presumptuous youth, elated with the acquisition of this, so inconsiderable an advantage, had, by the extravagance of his joy, given it the air of an important victory; but that as soon as he should hear that three generals and three victorious armies of his enemies were approaching, the deaths which had taken place in his family would occur to his recollection." Such was the tone in which they spoke of this affair to the people, though they were, at the same time, far from ignorant how much their strength had been diminished, in every respect, by the loss of Carthage.

Scipio kept Laelius with him until he had taken care of the captives, hostages, and loot, following his advice; but when everything was settled, he gave him a quinquereme. He selected Mago and about fifteen senators who had been captured at the same time, put them on board, and sent him to Rome with news of his victory. Meanwhile, he spent the few days he planned to stay in Carthage training his naval and land forces. On the first day, the legions performed drills over a distance of four miles; on the second day, he had them repair and clean their weapons in front of their tents; on the third day, they practiced a mock battle with wooden swords, throwing javelins with the points covered in balls; on the fourth day, they rested; and on the fifth day, they again did drills. They maintained this cycle of exercise and rest as long as they stayed in Carthage. The rowers and sailors, venturing out to sea when the weather was calm, practiced their ship handling through mock sea-fights. These activities on both land and sea outside the city prepared their minds and bodies for war. The city itself buzzed with war preparations, as workers of all kinds gathered in a public workshop. The general inspected all the projects with equal diligence. At one point he was busy in the dockyard with his fleet, then he was training with the legions; sometimes he focused on checking the work, which was being carried out with great enthusiasm by a large number of workers in the workshops, armory, and docks. Having set these preparations in motion, repaired the walls where they had been damaged, and stationed troops to guard the city, he set off for Tarraco. On his way, he was met by several delegations, some of which he dismissed after providing answers on his journey, while others he postponed until his arrival in Tarraco, where he had arranged a meeting with all his new and old allies. Here, ambassadors from nearly all the peoples living on this side of the Iberus and from many in farther Spain gathered. The Carthaginian generals initially tried to downplay the rumors of Carthage's capture; however, when it became too obvious to hide, they downplayed its significance with their words. They claimed that "an unexpected attack, in a stealthy manner, had snatched a single city in Spain from them in one day; that an arrogant young man, thrilled by this insignificant victory, had exaggerated it into something important; but once he heard that three generals and three victorious armies of his enemies were coming, the deaths in his family would come to his mind." Such was the way they spoke of this situation to the people, even though they were well aware of how much their strength had diminished in every respect due to the loss of Carthage.

END OF VOL. II

FOOTNOTES

Footnote 1: In the original, lati clavi. The latus clavus was a tunic, or vest, ornamented with a broad stripe of purple on the fore part, worn by the senators; the knights wore a similar one, only ornamented with a narrower stripe. Gold rings were also used as badges of distinction, the common people wore iron ones.

Footnote 2: The duration of Alexander's military career.

Footnote 3: The comitia curiata, or assemblies of the curiae, alone had the power of conferring military command; no magistrate, therefore, could assume the command without the previous order of their assembly. In time, this came to be a mere matter of form; yet the practice always continued to be observed.

Footnote 4: 5s. 31d.

Footnote 5: £1.

Footnote 6: £1614. 11s 8d.

Footnote 7: When the auspices were to be taken from the chickens, the keeper threw some of them food upon the ground, in their sight, and opened the door of then coop. If they did not come out; if they came out slowly; if they refused to feed, or ate in a careless manner, the omen was considered as bad. On the contrary, if they rushed out hastily and ate greedily, so that some of the food fell from their mouths on the ground, this was considered as an omen of the best import; it was called tripudium solistinum, originally, terripavium, from terra, and pavire, to strike.

Footnote 8: These marks of honour were bestowed for having saved the lives of citizens, or for having been the first to mount walls or ramparts.

Footnote 9: £4940 13s.

Footnote 10: £322 18s. 4d.

Footnote 11: £1259 7s. 6d.

Footnote 12: Thucydides seems to be specially referred to.

Footnote 13: The Barcine faction derived its name from Hamilcar, who was surnamed Barca. Hanno appears to have been at the head of the opposite party.

Footnote 14: A.U.C. 526, thirteen years after the conclusion of the first Punic war, being the sixth treaty between the Carthaginians and Romans. The first was a commercial agreement made during the first consulate, in the year that the Tarquins were expelled from Rome; but is not mentioned by Livy. The second is noted by him, lib. vii. 27, and the third, lib. ix. 43. The fourth was concluded during the war with Pyrrhus and the Tarentines, Polyb. V. iii. 25: and the fifth was the memorable treaty at the close of the first war.

Footnote 15: Alluding to the first treaty made in the year that the kings were expelled from Rome.

Footnote 16: The Carpetani have already been mentioned, chap. v. The Oretani, then neighbours, occupied the country lying between the sources of the Baetis and the Anas, or what are now called the Guadalquiver and Guadiana. In a part of Orospeda they deduced their name from a city called Oretum, the site of which has been brought to light in a paltry village to which the name of Oreto still remains.--D'Anville.

Footnote 17: from Paenus, Carthaginian.

Footnote 18: Because Spain was his proper province as consul.

Footnote 19: The ancient name of Portugal.

 

 



Download ePUB

If you like this ebook, consider a donation!