This is a modern-English version of The History of Rome, Books 27 to 36, originally written by Livy. It has been thoroughly updated, including changes to sentence structure, words, spelling, and grammar—to ensure clarity for contemporary readers, while preserving the original spirit and nuance. If you click on a paragraph, you will see the original text that we modified, and you can toggle between the two versions.

Scroll to the bottom of this page and you will find a free ePUB download link for this book.



THE HISTORY
OF ROME.

BY
TITUS LIVIUS.

BOOKS TWENTY-SEVEN TO THIRTY-SIX.

LITERALLY TRANSLATED,
WITH NOTES AND ILLUSTRATIONS,
BY
CYRUS EDMONDS.

1850.




       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXVII.


Cneius Fulvius, proconsul, defeated by Hannibal and slain; the consul, Claudius Marcellus, engages him with better success. Hannibal, raising his camp, retires; Marcellus pursues, and forces him to an engagement. They fight twice; in the first battle, Hannibal gains the advantage; in the second, Marcellus. Tarentum betrayed to Fabius Maximus, the consul. Scipio engages with Hasdrubal, the son of Hamilcar, at Baetula, in Spain, and defeats him. Among other prisoners, a youth of royal race and exquisite beauty is taken; Scipio sets him free, and sends him, enriched with magnificent presents, to his uncle Masinissa. Marcellus and Quintus Crispinus, consuls, drawn into an ambuscade by Hannibal; Marcellus is slain, Crispinus escapes. Operations by Publius Sulpicius, praetor, against Philip and the Achaeans. A census held; the number of citizens found to amount to one hundred and thirty-seven thousand one hundred and eight: from which it appears how great a loss they had sustained by the number of unsuccessful battles they had of late been engaged in. Hasdrubal, who had crossed the Alps with a reinforcement for Hannibal, defeated by the consuls, Marcus Livius and Claudius Nero, and slain; with him fell fifty-six thousand men.

       *        *        *        *        *


1

Such was the state of affairs in Spain. In Italy, the consul Marcellus, after regaining Salapia, which was betrayed into his hands, took Maronea and Meles from the Samnites by force. As many as three thousand of the soldiers of Hannibal, which were left as a garrison, were here surprised and overpowered. The booty, and there was a considerable quantity of it, was given up to the troops. Also, two hundred and forty thousand pecks of wheat, with a hundred and ten thousand pecks of barley, were found here. The joy, however, thus occasioned, was by no means so great as a disaster sustained a few days afterwards, not far from the town Herdonea. Cneius Fulvius, the consul, was lying encamped there, in the hope of regaining Herdonea, which had revolted from the Romans after the defeat at Cannae, his position being neither sufficiently secure from the nature of the place, nor strengthened by guards. The natural negligence of the general was now increased by the hope that their attachment to the Carthaginians was shaken when they had heard that Hannibal, after the loss of Salapia, had retired from that neighbourhood into Bruttium. Intelligence of all these circumstances being conveyed to Hannibal by secret messengers from Herdonea, at once excited an anxious desire to retain possession of a city in alliance with him, and inspired a hope of attacking the enemy when unprepared. With a lightly equipped force he hastened to Herdonea by forced marches, so as almost to anticipate the report of his approach and in order to strike greater terror into the enemy, came up with his troops in battle-array. The Roman, equal to him in courage, but inferior in strength, hastily drawing out his troops, engaged him. The fifth legion and the left wing of the allied infantry commenced the battle with spirit. But Hannibal ordered his cavalry, on a signal given, to ride round as soon as the foot forces had their eyes and thoughts occupied with the contest before them, and one half of them to attack the camp of the enemy, the other half to fall upon their rear, while busily engaged in fighting. He himself, sarcastically alluding to the similarity of the name Fulvius, as he had defeated Cneius Fulvius, the praetor, two years ago, in the same country, expressed his confidence that the issue of the battle would be similar. Nor was this expectation vain; for after many of the Romans had fallen in the close contest, and in the engagement with the infantry, notwithstanding which they still preserved their ranks and stood their ground; the alarm occasioned by the cavalry on their rear, and the enemy shout, which was heard at the same time from their camp, first put to flight the sixth legion, which being posted in the second line, was first thrown into confusion by the Numidians; and then the fifth legion, and those who were posted in the van. Some fled precipitately, others were slain in the middle space, where also Cneius Fulvius himself, with eleven military tribunes, fell. Who can state with certainty how many thousands of the Romans and their allies were slain in this battle, when I find in some accounts that thirteen, in others that not more than seven, thousand were slain? The conquerors got possession of the camp and the spoil. Finding that Herdonea would have revolted to the Romans, and was not likely to continue faithful to him if he departed thence, he removed all its inhabitants to Metapontum and Thurium, and burnt it. He put to death the chief men who were found to have held secret conferences with Fulvius. Such of the Romans as escaped this dreadful carnage, fled half-armed, by different roads, into Samnium, to the consul Marcellus.

Such was the situation in Spain. In Italy, the consul Marcellus, after taking back Salapia, which was betrayed to him, seized Maronea and Meles from the Samnites by force. About three thousand of Hannibal's soldiers who were left as a garrison were caught off guard and overwhelmed. The spoils, which were quite significant, were handed over to the troops. Additionally, two hundred and forty thousand pecks of wheat and one hundred and ten thousand pecks of barley were discovered here. However, the joy from this victory was overshadowed by a disaster that occurred a few days later near the town of Herdonea. Cneius Fulvius, the consul, was camped there, hoping to reclaim Herdonea, which had revolted from the Romans after their defeat at Cannae. His position was not secure due to the terrain, nor was it adequately protected by guards. The general's natural negligence was heightened by the belief that the locals' loyalty to the Carthaginians had weakened upon hearing that Hannibal, after losing Salapia, had retreated to Bruttium. Secret messengers relayed these developments to Hannibal, igniting a keen desire to maintain control over a city allied with him, and instilling hope to strike at the enemy when they were unprepared. With a lightly equipped force, he made forced marches to Herdonea to arrive almost before word of his advance reached the enemy, rallying his troops in battle formation to instill greater fear. The Roman, brave but outmatched in numbers, quickly assembled his troops to face him. The fifth legion and the left flank of the allied infantry initiated the battle energetically. However, Hannibal signaled his cavalry to circle around as soon as the infantry were preoccupied with the fight, sending half to attack the enemy's camp and the other half to charge their rear while they were engaged in combat. He himself, sarcastically referencing the similarity of the name Fulvius since he had defeated Cneius Fulvius, the praetor, two years prior in the same region, expressed his belief that the outcome of this battle would be the same. And his expectation was not in vain; after many Romans fell in the intense fighting, they still held their ranks and stood firm. The panic caused by the cavalry attacking their rear, coupled with the enemy's shouts from their camp, first caused the sixth legion, stationed in the second line, to waver under the Numidian onslaught, followed by the fifth legion and those in the front. Some fled in a panic, others were killed in the chaos, including Cneius Fulvius himself and eleven military tribunes. It’s hard to say exactly how many thousands of Romans and their allies died in this battle, as some sources report thirteen thousand and others no more than seven thousand. The victors took control of the camp and the spoils. Realizing that Herdonea would likely defect to the Romans and wouldn’t stay loyal if he left, he relocated all its inhabitants to Metapontum and Thurium, and burned the city down. He executed the key figures found to have held secret meetings with Fulvius. Those Romans who survived this catastrophic slaughter fled half-armed down various routes to Samnium, to consul Marcellus.

2

Marcellus, who was not much discouraged at this so great a disaster, sent a letter to the senate at Rome, with an account of the loss of the general and army at Herdonea; observing, however, "that he who, after the battle of Cannae, had humbled Hannibal when elated with victory, was now marching against him, and that he would cause that his present joy and exultation should not continue long." At Rome, indeed, the grief occasioned by what had occurred, and the fears entertained for the future, were excessive. The consul passing out of Samnium into Lucania, pitched his camp at Numistro, on a plain within view of Hannibal, who occupied a hill. He added also another demonstration of his confidence; for he was the first to lead out his troops to battle, nor did Hannibal decline fighting when he saw the standards carried out from the gates. However, they drew up their forces so that the right wing of the Carthaginians was extended up the hill, while the left wing of the Romans was contiguous to the town. For a long time neither side had any advantage; but the battle having continued from the third hour till night, and the first lines, which consisted, on the part of the Romans, of the first legion and the right wing of the allied infantry, on the part of Hannibal, of the Spanish soldiers, the Balearic slingers, and the elephants, which were driven into the field after the commencement of the battle, being fatigued with fighting, the first legion was relieved by the third, and the right wing of allied infantry by the left; while on the part of the enemy fresh troops took up the battle in place of those who were tired. A new and desperate conflict suddenly arose, instead of that which was so feebly maintained, their minds and bodies being unimpaired by fatigue; but night separated the combatants while the victory was undecided. The following day the Romans stood drawn up for battle from sun-rise till late in the day; but none of the enemy coming out against them, they gathered the spoils at their leisure, and collecting the bodies of their own troops into a heap, burnt them. The following night Hannibal decamped in silence, and moved on into Apulia. As soon as daylight discovered the flight of the enemy, Marcellus, leaving his wounded under the protection of a small garrison at Numistro, in command of which he placed Lucius Furius Purpureo, a military tribune, commenced a close pursuit of Hannibal, and overtook him at Venusia. Here, during several days, parties of troops sallying from the outposts, battles took place between foot and horses promiscuously, rather irregular than important, but which for the most part were favourable to the Romans. The armies were marched thence through Apulia without any engagement worth recording; for Hannibal marched by night, seeking an opportunity for ambuscade, but Marcellus never followed him except in broad daylight, and after having explored the country.

Marcellus, who wasn't very discouraged by such a huge disaster, sent a letter to the Senate in Rome detailing the loss of the general and the army at Herdonea. He noted, though, "the one who had humbled Hannibal after the battle of Cannae, when he was feeling victorious, is now marching against him, and I'll make sure his current joy and triumph won't last long." In Rome, the grief caused by what had happened and the fears for the future were overwhelming. The consul, moving from Samnium into Lucania, set up camp at Numistro, in sight of Hannibal, who was on a hill. He also showed his confidence by being the first to lead his troops into battle, and Hannibal didn't back down when he saw the standards coming out of the gates. They arranged their forces so that the right wing of the Carthaginians was extended up the hill while the left wing of the Romans was next to the town. For a long time, neither side had the upper hand; however, as the battle raged from the third hour of the day until night, the first lines—comprising the first legion and the right wing of the allied infantry for the Romans, and Hannibal's Spanish troops, Balearic slingers, and elephants brought into the field after the fighting started—were worn out. The first legion was replaced by the third, and the right wing of the allied infantry was replaced by the left; meanwhile, fresh troops from the enemy took over the battle in place of their exhausted comrades. A new and fierce conflict erupted, replacing the initially weak skirmish, with both sides fresh and not hindered by fatigue. However, night fell before a victor could be determined. The next day, the Romans prepared for battle from sunrise until late in the day, but with no enemy showing up against them, they gathered the spoils at their leisure and piled the bodies of their troops for cremation. That night, Hannibal quietly broke camp and moved into Apulia. When daylight revealed the enemy's retreat, Marcellus, leaving his wounded troops under the guard of a small garrison at Numistro, which he had put under the command of Lucius Furius Purpureo, a military tribune, began to closely pursue Hannibal and caught up with him at Venusia. Here, over several days, skirmishes broke out between foot soldiers and cavalry, mostly irregular and not very significant but generally favorable to the Romans. The armies marched through Apulia without any notable encounters; Hannibal traveled at night, looking for ambush opportunities, while Marcellus only followed during the day after carefully scouting the area.

3

In the mean time, while Flaccus was detained at Capua in selling the property of the nobles, and letting out the land which had been forfeited, all of which he let for a rent to be paid in corn, lest occasions for exercising severity toward the Campanians should be wanting, a new piece of inquiry which had been ripening in secret, was brought out in evidence. He had compelled his soldiers, withdrawn from the houses, to build for themselves huts after the military manner, near the gates and walls; at once, that the houses of the city might be let and occupied together with the land, also through fear, lest the excessive luxury of the city should enervate his troops as it had those of Hannibal. Now many of these were formed of hurdles or boards, others of reeds interwoven, all being covered with straw, as if combustable materials had been employed on purpose. A hundred and seventy Campanians, headed by the Blosii who were fathers, had formed a conspiracy to set fire to all these at a late hour of the night; but information of the conspiracy having been given by one of the slaves of the Blosii, the gates were suddenly closed by the command of the proconsul, and all the soldiers had been assembled under arms, on a signal given all who were implicated in the guilt were seized, and, after rigorous examination, were condemned and executed, informers were rewarded with liberty and ten thousand asses each. The people of Nuceria and Acerra, who complained that they had no where to dwell, Acerra being partly burnt, and Nuceria demolished, Fulvius sent to Rome to the senate. Permission was given to the people of Acerra to rebuild what had been destroyed by fire. The people of Nuceria were removed to Atella, as they preferred; the people of Atella being ordered to migrate to Calatia. Among the many and important events, sometimes prosperous, sometimes adverse, which occupied men's thoughts, not even the citadel of Tarentum was forgotten. Marcus Ogulnius and Publius Aquillius went into Etruria as commissioners to buy up corn to be conveyed to Tarentum; and one thousand men out of the city troops, an equal number of Romans and allies, were sent to the same place, together with the corn, for its protection.

In the meantime, while Flaccus was held up in Capua selling off the property of the nobles and leasing out the forfeited land—letting it out for rent to be paid in grain to avoid having to deal harshly with the Campanians—another inquiry that had been brewing quietly came to light. He had forced his soldiers, who were away from their homes, to build huts for themselves in a military style near the city gates and walls; this was partly so the houses could be rented and occupied along with the land, and also to prevent the soldiers from getting soft due to the city's excessive luxury, like Hannibal's troops had. Many of these huts were made of hurdles or boards, while others were woven from reeds, all topped with straw, as if they were designed to catch fire easily. A plot was formed by 170 Campanians, led by the Blosii fathers, to set all these on fire late at night; however, one of the Blosii's slaves tipped off the authorities, leading the proconsul to quickly shut the gates. All the soldiers were assembled and, upon signaling, those involved in the plot were arrested, rigorously interrogated, and then condemned and executed. The informers were rewarded with freedom and ten thousand asses each. The people of Nuceria and Acerra complained they had nowhere to live, as Acerra was partially burned and Nuceria was destroyed, prompting Fulvius to send a message to the Senate in Rome. The Senate allowed the people of Acerra to rebuild what had been lost in the fire. The people of Nuceria were relocated to Atella, as they preferred, while the inhabitants of Atella were ordered to move to Calatia. Amid the many significant events, some favorable and others unfavorable, that occupied people's minds, even the citadel of Tarentum was not overlooked. Marcus Ogulnius and Publius Aquillius were sent to Etruria as commissioners to purchase grain for Tarentum, and one thousand men from the city troops, along with an equal number of Romans and allies, were sent there with the grain for its protection.

4

The summer was now on the close, and the time for the election of consuls drew nigh; but a letter from Marcellus, in which he stated, that it would not be for the interest of the state that he should depart a single step from Hannibal, whom he was severely pressing while retreating before him and evading an engagement, had excited anxiety, lest they must either recall the consul from the war at that time when he was most actively employed, or consuls should not be appointed for the year. The best course appeared to be to recall in preference the consul Valerius from Sicily, although he was out of Italy. A letter was sent to him by Lucius Manlius, the city praetor, by order of the senate, together with the letter of Marcus Marcellus, the consul, that he might learn from it what reason the senate had for recalling him from his province rather than his colleague. Much about this time ambassadors came to Rome from king Syphax with accounts of the successful battles which he had fought with the Carthaginians. They assured the senate that there was no people to whom the king was more hostile than the Carthaginians, and none to whom he was more friendly than the Romans. They said, that "he had before sent ambassadors into Spain, to Cneius and Publius Cornelius, the Roman generals, but that he was now desirous to solicit the friendship of the Romans, as it were, from the fountain-head itself." The senate not only returned a gracious answer to the ambassadors, but also sent as ambassadors to the king, with presents, Lucius Genucius, Publius Paetelius, and Publius Popillius. The presents they carried were a purple gown and vest, an ivory chair, and a bowl formed out of five pounds of gold. They received orders to proceed forthwith to other petty princes of Africa carrying with them as presents for them gowns bordered with purple, and golden bowls weighing three pounds each. Marcus Atilius and Manius Acilius were also sent as ambassadors to Alexandria, to king Ptolemy and queen Cleopatra, to revive and renew the treaty of friendship with them, carrying with them as presents a gown and purple tunic, with an ivory chair for the king, and an embroidered gown and a purple vest for the queen. During the summer in which these transactions took place, many prodigies were reported from the country and cities in the neighbourhood; at Tusculum it was said that a lamb was yeaned with its dug full of milk; that the roof of the temple of Jupiter was struck with lightning and almost stripped of its entire covering. Much about the same time it was reported that the ground in front of the gate at Anagnia was struck, and that it continued burning for a day and a night without any thing to feed the fire; that at Compitum in the territory of Anagnia, the birds had deserted the nests in the trees in the grove of Diana; that snakes of amazing size had leaped up, like fishes sporting, in the sea at Taracina not far from the port; at Tarquinii, that a pig was produced with a human face; that in the territory of Capena at the grove of Feronia, four statues had sweated blood profusely for a day and a night. These prodigies were expiated with victims of the greater kind, according to a decree of the pontiffs, and a supplication was fixed to be performed for one day at Rome at all the shrines, and another in the territory of Capena at the grove of Feronia.

The summer was coming to an end, and the time for electing consuls was approaching. However, a letter from Marcellus stated that it wouldn’t be in the state's best interest for him to move even one step away from Hannibal, whom he was strongly pursuing while trying to avoid a battle. This raised concerns about whether they would have to recall the consul from the war when he was most engaged, or if they wouldn’t appoint any consuls for the year. The best option seemed to be recalling consul Valerius from Sicily, even though he was outside of Italy. A letter was sent to him by Lucius Manlius, the city praetor, at the senate's request, along with Marcellus's letter, so he could understand why the senate wanted to recall him from his province instead of his colleague. Around this time, ambassadors arrived in Rome from King Syphax, reporting on his victories against the Carthaginians. They assured the senate that the Carthaginians were the king's greatest enemies and the Romans his closest allies. They mentioned that “he had previously sent ambassadors to Cneius and Publius Cornelius, the Roman generals in Spain, but now he wished to seek friendship with the Romans directly.” The senate not only replied graciously to the ambassadors but also sent Lucius Genucius, Publius Paetelius, and Publius Popillius as ambassadors to the king, bringing gifts of a purple gown and vest, an ivory chair, and a bowl made from five pounds of gold. They were instructed to immediately visit other minor princes in Africa, carrying gifts of purple-bordered gowns and three-pound gold bowls for them. Marcus Atilius and Manius Acilius were also sent as ambassadors to Alexandria to meet King Ptolemy and Queen Cleopatra, to renew their friendship treaty, bringing along a gown and purple tunic for the king, and an embroidered gown and purple vest for the queen. During the summer of these events, many strange occurrences were reported from the surrounding cities and countryside. In Tusculum, it was said that a lamb was born with a milk-filled udder; the roof of the temple of Jupiter was struck by lightning and almost completely stripped off. Around the same time, it was reported that the ground in front of the gate at Anagnia was struck, burning for a day and a night without anything to fuel the fire; that in Compitum, in the territory of Anagnia, birds had abandoned their nests in the grove of Diana; that massive snakes jumped out like fish frolicking in the sea near Taracina; that a pig was born with a human face in Tarquinii; and that in the Capena territory, in the grove of Feronia, four statues had sweated blood for a day and a night. These omens were atoned for with large sacrificial victims, as ordered by the pontiffs, and a day of public supplication was established to be performed in Rome at all the shrines, and another in Capena's territory at the grove of Feronia.

5

Marcus Valerius, the consul, having been summoned by letter, gave the command of the province and his army to Cincius the praetor, sent Marcus Valerius Messala, commander of the fleet, with half of the ships to Africa, at the same time to plunder the country and observe what the Carthaginians were doing, and what preparations they were making, and then set out himself with ten ships for Rome; where, having arrived in safety, he immediately convened the senate. Here he made a recital of his services. That "after hostilities had been carried on, and severe losses often sustained, both by sea and land, through a period of almost sixty years, he had completely terminated the business of the province. That there was not one Carthaginian in Sicily, nor one Sicilian absent of those who through fear had been compelled to go into exile and live abroad; that all of them were brought back to their cities and fields, and were employed in ploughing and sowing; that the land which was deserted was now again inhabited, not only yielding its fruits to its cultivators, but forming a most certain resource for the supply of provisions to the Roman people in peace and war." After this, Mutines and such others as had rendered any services to the Roman people were introduced into the senate, and all received honorary rewards in fulfilment of the consul's engagement. Mutines was also made a Roman citizen, a proposition to that effect having been made to the commons by a plebeian tribune, on the authority of the senate. While these things were going on at Rome, Marcus Valerius Messala, arriving on the coast of Africa before daylight, made a sudden descent on the territory of Utica; and after ravaging it to a great extent, and taking many prisoners, together with booty of every kind, he returned to his ships and sailed over to Sicily. He returned to Lilybaeum on the thirteenth day from the time he left it. From the prisoners, on examination, the following facts were discovered, and all communicated in writing to the consul Laevinus in order, so that he might know in what state the affairs of Africa were. That "five thousand Numidians, with Masinissa, the son of Gala, a youth of extraordinary spirit, were at Carthage, and that other troops were hiring throughout all Africa, to be passed over into Spain to Hasdrubal; in order that he might, as soon as possible, pass over into Italy, with as large a force as could be collected, and form a junction with Hannibal." That the Carthaginians considered their success dependent on this measure. That a very large fleet was also in preparation for the recovery of Sicily, which they believed would sail thither in a short time. The recital of these facts had such an effect upon the senate, that they resolved that the consul ought not to wait for the election, but that a dictator should be appointed to hold it, and that the consul should immediately return to his province. A difference of opinion delayed this, for the consul declared that he should nominate as dictator Marcus Valerius Messala, who then commanded the fleet in Sicily; but the fathers denied that a person could be appointed dictator who was not in the Roman territory, and this was limited by Italy. Marcus Lucretius, a plebeian tribune, having taken the sense of the senate upon the question, it was decreed, "that the consul before he quitted the city, should put the question to the people, as to whom they wished to be appointed dictator, and that he should nominate whomsoever they directed. If the consul were unwilling that the praetor should put the question, and if even he were unwilling to do it, that then the tribunes should make the proposition to the commons." The consul refusing to submit to the people what lay in his own power, and forbidding the praetor to do so, the plebeian tribunes put the question, and the commons ordered that Quintus Fulvius, who was then at Capua, should be nominated dictator. But on the night preceding the day on which the assembly of the people was to be held for that purpose, the consul went off privately into Sicily; and the fathers, thus deserted, decreed that a letter should be sent to Marcus Claudius, in order that he might come to the support of the state, which had been abandoned by his colleague, and appoint him dictator whom the commons had ordered. Thus Quintus Fulvius was appointed dictator by Marcus Claudius, the consul, and in conformity with the same order of the people, Publius Licinius Crassus, chief pontiff, was appointed master of the horse by Quintus Fulvius, the dictator.

Marcus Valerius, the consul, having received a letter summoning him, transferred command of the province and his army to Cincius the praetor. He sent Marcus Valerius Messala, the fleet commander, with half of the ships to Africa to raid the territory and observe what the Carthaginians were doing and preparing. He then set out with ten ships for Rome; upon arriving safely, he immediately convened the Senate. Here, he recounted his achievements, stating that "after nearly sixty years of ongoing hostilities and significant losses both at sea and on land, he had fully resolved the issues of the province. There wasn’t a single Carthaginian left in Sicily, nor was there a Sicilian who had been forced into exile living abroad; all had returned to their cities and fields, working their land again. The previously deserted land was now populated again, not only producing fruits for its cultivators but also providing a reliable source of provisions for the Roman people in times of peace and war." After this, Mutines and others who had served the Roman people were introduced into the Senate, and all received honors as promised by the consul. Mutines was also granted Roman citizenship, following a proposal made to the assembly by a plebeian tribune with the Senate's approval. While these events were unfolding in Rome, Marcus Valerius Messala arrived on the coast of Africa before dawn and launched a surprise attack on Utica's territory. After extensively pillaging it and capturing many prisoners along with various types of loot, he returned to his ships and sailed back to Sicily. He arrived back in Lilybaeum thirteen days after he left. From interrogating the prisoners, several important facts were revealed and communicated in writing to consul Laevinus so he could understand the state of affairs in Africa. Reports indicated that "five thousand Numidians, including Masinissa, son of Gala, a young man of exceptional courage, were in Carthage, and that other troops were being recruited throughout all of Africa to join Hasdrubal in Spain. This was so he could quickly make his way into Italy with as large a force as possible and unite with Hannibal." The Carthaginians believed their success relied on this strategy. Additionally, a significant fleet was being prepared to reclaim Sicily, which they expected to set sail soon. The Senate was greatly influenced by these reports, leading them to decide that the consul should not wait for elections but appoint a dictator to conduct them, and that the consul should immediately return to his province. However, a disagreement arose, as the consul suggested Marcus Valerius Messala, who was then commanding the fleet in Sicily, as dictator. The senators countered that someone outside Roman territory, which was restricted to Italy, could not be appointed as dictator. Marcus Lucretius, a plebeian tribune, sought the Senate's opinion on the matter, and it was decided that "before leaving the city, the consul should ask the people whom they wanted as dictator and nominate whoever they directed. If the consul didn’t want the praetor to ask, and even if he didn’t want to do it himself, then the tribunes should put the question to the assembly." When the consul refused to present what was in his power to the people and prevented the praetor from doing so, the plebeian tribunes raised the question, and the assembly declared that Quintus Fulvius, who was then in Capua, should be nominated as dictator. However, on the night before the assembly was set to take place for this purpose, the consul quietly left for Sicily. The senators, feeling abandoned, decided to send a letter to Marcus Claudius to come to the state’s aid, which had been deserted by his colleague, and appoint the individual the assembly had chosen as dictator. Consequently, Quintus Fulvius was appointed dictator by Marcus Claudius, the consul, and in accordance with the same directive from the people, Publius Licinius Crassus, the chief pontiff, was appointed master of the horse by Quintus Fulvius, the dictator.

6

After the dictator had arrived at Rome, he sent Cneius Sempronius Blaesus, who had acted under him as lieutenant general at Capua, into the province of Etruria, to take the command of the army there, in the room of the praetor, Caius Calpurnius, whom he had summoned by letter to take the command of Capua and his own army. He fixed the first date he could for the election: which, however, could not be brought to a conclusion, in consequence of a dispute which arose between the tribunes and the dictator. The junior century of the Galerian tribe, to whose lot it fell to give the votes first, had named Quintus Fulvius and Quintus Fabius as consuls; and the other centuries, on being called upon to vote according to their course, would have inclined the same way, had not the plebeian tribunes, Caius and Lucius Arennius interposed. They said, "that it was hardly constitutional that a chief magistrate should be continued in office but that it was a precedent still more shocking, that the very person who held the election should be appointed. Then therefore, if the dictator should allow his own name to appear they would interpose against the election; but if the names of any other persons besides himself were put up, they should not impede it." The dictator defended the election by the authority of the fathers, the order of the commons, and precedents. For, "in the consulate of Cneius Servilius, when the other consul, Caius Flaminius, had fallen at Trasimenus, it was proposed to the people on the authority of the fathers, and the people had ordered, that as long as the war continued in Italy, it should be lawful for the people to elect to the consulship whomsoever they pleased, out of those persons who had been consuls, and as often as they pleased. That he had a precedent of ancient date, which was to the point, in the case of Lucius Posthumius Megellus, who, while he was interrex, had been created consul with Caius Junius Bubulcus, at an election over which he himself presided; and a precedent of recent date, in Quintus Fabius, who certainly would never have allowed himself to be re-elected, had it not been for the good of the state." After the contest had been continued for a long time, by arguments of this kind, at length the tribunes and the dictator came to an agreement, that they should abide by what the senate should decide. The fathers were of opinion, that such was then the condition of the state, that it was necessary that its affairs should be conducted by old and experienced generals, who were skilled in the art of war; and, therefore, that no delay should take place in the election. The tribunes then withdrew their opposition, and the election was held. Quintus Fabius Maximus was declared consul for the fifth time, and Quintus Fulvius Flaccus for the fourth. The praetors were then created; Lucius Veturius Philo, Titus Quintus Crispinus, Caius Hostilius Tubulus, and Caius Aurunculeius. The magistrates for the year being appointed, Quintus Fulvius resigned the dictatorship. At the end of this summer, a Carthaginian fleet of forty ships, under the command of Hamilcar, passed over to Sardinia. At first it laid waste the territory of Olbia, and then Publius Manlius Vulso, with his army, making his appearance, it sailed round thence to the other side of the island, and devastating the territory of Caralis, returned to Africa with booty of every kind. Several Roman priests died this year, and others were substituted. Caius Servilius was appointed pontiff, in the place of Titus Otacilius Crassus. Tiberius Sempronius Longus, son of Tiberius, was appointed as augur, in the place of Titus Otacilius Crassus; and Tiberius Sempronius Longus, son of Tiberius, was appointed decemvir for the performance of sacred rites, in the room of Tiberius Sempronius Longus, son of Caius. Marcus Marcius, king of the sacred rites, and Marcus Aemilius Papus, chief curio, died; but no priests were appointed to succeed them this year. The censors this year were Lucius Veturius Philo, and Publius Licinius Crassus chief pontiff. Licinius Crassus had neither been consul nor praetor before he was appointed censor, he stepped from the aedileship to the censorship. These censors neither chose the senate, nor transacted any public business, the death of Lucius Veturius prevented it; on this Licinius also gave up his office. The curule aediles, Lucius Veturius and Publius Licinius Varus, repeated the Roman games during one day. The plebeian aediles, Quintus Catius and Lucius Porcius Licinius, furnished brazen statues for the temple of Ceres, out of the money arising from fines, and exhibited games with great pomp and splendour, considering the circumstances of the times.

After the dictator arrived in Rome, he sent Cneius Sempronius Blaesus, who had served as his deputy in Capua, to the province of Etruria to take command of the army there, replacing the praetor, Caius Calpurnius, whom he had summoned by letter to take charge of Capua and his own army. He set the earliest possible date for the election; however, it couldn't be wrapped up due to a dispute between the tribunes and the dictator. The junior century of the Galerian tribe, which was first to vote, chose Quintus Fulvius and Quintus Fabius as consuls, and the other centuries, when called to vote in turn, were likely to follow suit, if not for the intervention of the plebeian tribunes, Caius and Lucius Arennius. They argued that it was hardly constitutional for a chief magistrate to remain in office and that it was even more outrageous for the very person overseeing the election to be appointed. They declared that if the dictator allowed his own name to be listed, they would obstruct the election; but if other names were proposed, they would not interfere. The dictator defended the election by citing the authority of the senate, the people's order, and precedents. He referenced the consulate of Cneius Servilius, when the other consul, Caius Flaminius, was killed at Trasimenus, and it was ordered by the people, with the senate's backing, that as long as war continued in Italy, the people could elect anyone they wished from former consuls, as often as they liked. He pointed to an ancient precedent involving Lucius Posthumius Megellus, who, while acting as interrex, became consul alongside Caius Junius Bubulcus in an election he oversaw; and a more recent precedent involving Quintus Fabius, who would not have allowed himself to be re-elected if it hadn't been for the good of the state. After a lengthy debate with arguments like these, the tribunes and the dictator eventually agreed to accept whatever the senate decided. The senate concluded that due to the state of the nation, it was essential that experienced generals who understood warfare manage its affairs, thus there should be no delay in the election. The tribunes then retracted their opposition, and the election took place. Quintus Fabius Maximus was declared consul for the fifth time, and Quintus Fulvius Flaccus for the fourth. The praetors were appointed: Lucius Veturius Philo, Titus Quintus Crispinus, Caius Hostilius Tubulus, and Caius Aurunculeius. Once the magistrates for the year were selected, Quintus Fulvius stepped down from the dictatorship. By the end of that summer, a Carthaginian fleet of forty ships, led by Hamilcar, crossed over to Sardinia. Initially, they ravaged Olbia's territory, but when Publius Manlius Vulso and his army appeared, they sailed around to the other side of the island, pillaging Caralis's land, and returned to Africa with all kinds of loot. Several Roman priests died this year, and replacements were appointed. Caius Servilius became pontiff, taking over from Titus Otacilius Crassus. Tiberius Sempronius Longus, son of Tiberius, was made augur, also replacing Titus Otacilius Crassus; and Tiberius Sempronius Longus, son of Tiberius, was named decemvir to conduct sacred rites, replacing Tiberius Sempronius Longus, son of Caius. Marcus Marcius, the king of sacred rites, and Marcus Aemilius Papus, chief curio, both died; but no priests were appointed to replace them this year. The censors were Lucius Veturius Philo and Publius Licinius Crassus, the chief pontiff. Licinius Crassus had not previously been consul or praetor before becoming censor, moving directly from aedile to censor. These censors neither chose the senate nor carried out any public business, as the death of Lucius Veturius hindered it; Licinius also resigned his role. The curule aediles, Lucius Veturius and Publius Licinius Varus, held the Roman games for one day. The plebeian aediles, Quintus Catius and Lucius Porcius Licinius, provided bronze statues for the temple of Ceres using funds from fines and put on games with great splendor, considering the times.

7

At the close of this year, Caius Laelius, the lieutenant general of Scipio, came to Rome on the thirty-fourth day after he set out from Tarraco, and entering the city accompanied by a train of captives, drew together a great concourse of people. The next day, on being brought into the senate, he stated that Carthage, the capital of Spain, had been captured in one day, that several cities which had revolted were regained, and that fresh ones had been received into alliance. From the prisoners, information was gained, corresponding for the most part with what was contained in the letter of Marcus Valerius Messala. What produced the greatest effect upon the fathers, was the march of Hasdrubal into Italy, which was with difficulty resisting Hannibal and his forces. Laelius also, who was brought before the general assembly, gave a particular statement of the same things. The senate decreed a supplication for one day, on account of the successes of Publius Scipio, and ordered Caius Laelius to return as soon as possible to Spain, with the ships he had brought with him. I have laid the taking of Carthage in this year, on the authority of many writers, although aware that some have stated that it was taken the following year, because it appeared to me hardly probable that Scipio should have spent an entire year in Spain in doing nothing. Quintus Fabius Maximus for the fifth time, and Quintus Fulvius Flaccus for the fourth having entered on their offices of consuls on the ides of March, on the same day, Italy was decreed as the province of both, their command, however, was distributed to separate districts. Fabius was appointed to carry on the war at Tarentum; Fulvius in Lucania and Bruttium. Marcus Claudius was continued in command for the year. The praetors then cast lots for their provinces. Caius Hostilius Tubulus obtained the city jurisdiction; Lucius Veturius Philo the foreign, with Gaul; Titus Quinctius Crispinus, Capua; Caius Aurunculeius, Sardinia. The troops were thus distributed through the provinces: Fulvius received the two legions which Marcus Valerius Laevinus had in Sicily; Quintus Fabius, those which Caius Calpurnius had commanded in Etruria. The city troops were to succeed those in Etruria; Caius Calpurnius commanding the same province and the army. Titus Quinctius was to take the command of Capua, and the army which had served under Quintus Fulvius there. Lucius Veturius was to succeed Caius Laetorius, propraetor, in his province and the command of the army, which was then at Ariminum. Marcus Marcellus had the legions with which he had been successful when consul. To Marcus Valerius together with Lucius Cincius, for these also were continued in command in Sicily, the troops which had fought at Cannae were given, with orders to recruit them out of the surviving soldiers of the legions of Cneius Fulvius. These were collected and sent by the consuls into Sicily, and the same ignominious condition of service was added, under which the troops which had fought at Cannae served, and to those troops belonging to the army of Cneius Fulvius, the praetor, which had been sent thither by the senate through displeasure occasioned by a similar flight. Caius Aurunculeius was appointed to command, in Sardinia, the same legions with which Publius Manlius Vulso had occupied that province. Publius Sulpicius was continued in command for the year, with orders to hold Macedonia with the same legion and fleet. Orders were given to send thirty quinqueremes from Sicily to Tarentum, to the consul Fabius. With the rest of the ships, orders were given that Marcus Valerius Laevinus should either pass over himself into Africa to ravage the country, or send either Lucius Cincius or Marcus Valerius Messala. With regard to Spain, no alteration was made, except that Scipio and Silanus were continued in command, not for the year, but until they should be recalled by the senate. In such manner were the provinces and the commands of the armies distributed for this year.

At the end of this year, Caius Laelius, the lieutenant general of Scipio, arrived in Rome thirty-four days after leaving Tarraco, and as he entered the city with a group of captives, he attracted a large crowd. The following day, when he was brought before the senate, he reported that Carthage, the capital of Spain, had been captured in a single day, that several cities that had revolted were regained, and that new ones had joined as allies. From the prisoners, information was obtained that mostly matched what was in Marcus Valerius Messala's letter. The most shocking news for the senators was Hasdrubal's advance into Italy, which was making it difficult to resist Hannibal and his forces. Laelius also provided a detailed account of the same events to the general assembly. The senate declared a day of thanks for Publius Scipio's victories and instructed Caius Laelius to return to Spain as soon as possible with the ships he had brought. I have reported the capture of Carthage this year based on various sources, though I know some say it happened the following year, as it seemed unlikely that Scipio would have spent an entire year in Spain without significant action. Quintus Fabius Maximus began his fifth term, and Quintus Fulvius Flaccus his fourth, as consuls on the Ides of March, and on that same day, Italy was assigned as the province for both, but their commands were allocated to different regions. Fabius was appointed to carry on the war at Tarentum, while Fulvius took responsibility in Lucania and Bruttium. Marcus Claudius continued in command for the year. The praetors then drew lots for their provinces. Caius Hostilius Tubulus received the city jurisdiction; Lucius Veturius Philo the foreign, including Gaul; Titus Quinctius Crispinus, Capua; and Caius Aurunculeius, Sardinia. The troops were subsequently assigned to the provinces: Fulvius took the two legions that Marcus Valerius Laevinus had in Sicily; Quintus Fabius got those that Caius Calpurnius commanded in Etruria. The city troops would replace those in Etruria, with Caius Calpurnius remaining in command of that province and army. Titus Quinctius was to lead the forces in Capua, taking over the army that had served under Quintus Fulvius there. Lucius Veturius was to succeed Caius Laetorius in his province and command of the army stationed at Ariminum. Marcus Marcellus retained the legions with which he had succeeded as consul. The troops that had fought at Cannae were assigned to Marcus Valerius along with Lucius Cincius, who also continued in command in Sicily, with instructions to replenish them using the remaining soldiers from the legions of Cneius Fulvius. These soldiers were gathered and sent by the consuls to Sicily, and the same lowly terms of service were imposed as on the troops that had fought at Cannae, along with those from the army of Cneius Fulvius, the praetor, which had been sent there by the senate due to discontent over a similar retreat. Caius Aurunculeius was assigned to command the same legions in Sardinia that Publius Manlius Vulso had previously occupied. Publius Sulpicius was continued in command for the year, tasked with holding Macedonia with the same legion and fleet. Orders were issued to send thirty quinqueremes from Sicily to Tarentum, to consul Fabius. For the other ships, it was ordered that Marcus Valerius Laevinus should either go to Africa himself to raid the territory, or send either Lucius Cincius or Marcus Valerius Messala. As for Spain, there were no changes, except that Scipio and Silanus remained in command, not for the year, but until the senate recalled them. This is how the provinces and army commands were allocated for this year.

8

Amid concerns of greater importance, an old dispute was revived at the election of a chief curio, when a priest was appointed to succeed Marcus Aemilius; the patricians denying that Caius Mamilius Vitulus, who was a plebeian candidate, ought to be allowed to stand, because no one before his time had held that priesthood who was not a patrician. The tribunes, on being appealed to, referred the matter to the senate. The senate left it to the decision of the people. Thus Caius Mamilius Vitulus was the first plebeian created chief curio. Publius Licinius, chief pontiff, compelled Caius Valerius Flaccus to be inaugurated flamen of Jupiter, against his will. Caius Valerius Laetorius was created decemvir for the performance of sacred rites, in the room of Quintus Mucius Scaevola, deceased. I should willingly have passed over in silence the reason of a flamen's being compelled to be inaugurated, had he not become a good, from having been a bad character. In consequence of having spent his youth in idleness and debauchery, vices for which he had incurred the displeasure of his own brother, Lucius Flaccus, and the rest of his kinsmen, Caius Flaccus was chosen flamen by Publius Licinius, chief pontiff. As soon as his mind became occupied with the care of the sacred rites and ceremonies, he soon so completely divested himself of his former habits, that no one among all the youth was more esteemed, or enjoyed in a greater degree the approbation of the chief of the patricians, whether relations or aliens. Being raised by this generally good character to a proper confidence in himself, he claimed to be admitted into the senate; a thing intermitted for many years, on account of the worthlessness of former flamens. On entering the senate, Lucius Licinius, the praetor, led him out; on which the flamen appealed to the tribunes of the people. He demanded back the ancient privilege of his priesthood, which was given, together with the purple-bordered robe, and the curule chair, to the office of flamen. The praetor wished the question to rest not on the precedents contained in the annals, which were obsolete from their antiquity, but on the usual practice in all the cases of most recent date; urging, that no flamen of Jupiter, in the memory of their fathers or their grandfathers, had taken up that privilege. The tribunes giving it as their opinion, that justice required, that as the obliteration of the privilege was occasioned by the negligence of the flamens, the consequences ought to fall upon the flamens themselves, and not upon the office, led the flamen into the senate, with the general approbation of the fathers, and without any opposition, even from the praetor himself; while all were of opinion that the flamen had obtained his object more from the purity of his life, than any right appertaining to the priesthood. The consuls, before they departed to their provinces, raised two legions for the city, and as many soldiers as were necessary to make up the numbers of the other armies. The consul Fulvius appointed his brother, Caius Fulvius Flaccus, lieutenant-general, to march the old city army into Etruria, and to bring to Rome the legions which were in Etruria. And the consul Fabius ordered his son, Quintus Fabius Maximus, to lead the remains of the army of Fulvius, which had been collected, amounting to three thousand three hundred and thirty-six, into Sicily to Marcus Valerius, the proconsul, and to receive from him two legions and thirty quinqueremes. The withdrawing of these legions from the island did not at all diminish the force employed for the protection of that province, either in effect or appearance; for though, in addition to two veteran legions which were most effectively reinforced, he had a great number of Numidian deserters, both horse and foot, he raised also a body of Sicilian troops, consisting of men who had served in the armies of Epicydes and the Carthaginians, and were experienced in war. Having added these foreign auxiliaries to each of the Roman legions, he preserved the appearance of two armies. With one he ordered Lucius Cinctius to protect that portion of the island which had formed the kingdom of Hiero, with the other he himself guarded the rest of the island, which was formerly divided by the boundary of the Roman and Carthaginian dominions. He divided also the fleet of seventy ships, in order that it might protect the sea-coast, through the entire extent of its shores. He himself went through the island with the cavalry of Mutines to inspect the lands, observe those which were cultivated and those which were not, and, accordingly, either praise or reprove the owners. By this diligence so large a quantity of corn was produced, that he both sent some to Rome, and collected at Catana corn which might serve as a supply for the army, which was about to pass the summer at Tarentum.

Amid bigger concerns, an old dispute resurfaced during the election of a chief curio when a priest was chosen to succeed Marcus Aemilius. The patricians argued that Caius Mamilius Vitulus, a candidate from the plebeians, shouldn't be allowed to run since no one before him had held that priesthood unless they were a patrician. The tribunes, when consulted, brought the issue to the senate, which passed it on to the people. Consequently, Caius Mamilius Vitulus became the first plebeian appointed as chief curio. Publius Licinius, the chief pontiff, forced Caius Valerius Flaccus to take on the role of flamen of Jupiter against his will. Caius Valerius Laetorius was made decemvir for performing sacred rites, replacing the deceased Quintus Mucius Scaevola. I would have preferred to skip mentioning the reason why a flamen was pressured into the role, but he had transformed from a former bad character into a good one. After wasting his youth on idleness and debauchery—vices that displeased his brother Lucius Flaccus and the rest of his family—Caius Flaccus was appointed flamen by Publius Licinius, the chief pontiff. Once he focused on the sacred rites and ceremonies, he completely shed his old habits, gaining respect among the youth and earning praise from the chief patricians, whether they were related to him or not. With this newfound confidence, he sought admission to the senate, which had been denied to many flamens in the past due to their poor character. When he entered the senate, Lucius Licinius, the praetor, called him out, prompting the flamen to appeal to the tribunes. He requested the restoration of the ancient privileges associated with his priesthood, which included the purple-bordered robe and the curule chair. The praetor wanted to base the issue not on outdated precedents, but on recent practices, arguing that no flamen of Jupiter had claimed those privileges in living memory. The tribunes believed that fairness required that since the loss of the privilege was due to the negligence of the flamens, the consequences should fall on them, not the office itself. They led the flamen into the senate, where the patricians supported him without any opposition, even from the praetor. Everyone agreed that the flamen achieved his goal more because of his good character than any entitlement from his priesthood. Before leaving for their provinces, the consuls raised two legions for the city and recruited enough soldiers to bolster the other armies. Consul Fulvius appointed his brother, Caius Fulvius Flaccus, as lieutenant-general to lead the old city army into Etruria and bring back the legions stationed there. Meanwhile, Consul Fabius directed his son, Quintus Fabius Maximus, to escort the remaining 3,336 troops of Fulvius' army to Sicily to meet with proconsul Marcus Valerius and receive two legions and thirty quinqueremes. The withdrawal of these legions from the island did not reduce the military strength present there, either in reality or appearance; in addition to two well-reinforced veteran legions, there were many Numidian deserters, both cavalry and infantry, along with Sicilian troops experienced in warfare from serving with Epicydes and the Carthaginians. By integrating these foreign auxiliaries with each of the Roman legions, he maintained the appearance of two armies. He assigned Lucius Cinctius to protect the region of the island that used to belong to Hiero while he patrolled the remaining parts, which were previously divided along Roman and Carthaginian boundaries. He also divided his fleet of seventy ships to safeguard the entire coastline. He traveled across the island with the cavalry of Mutines to inspect the lands, making note of which were cultivated and which were not, and giving appropriate praise or reprimands to the owners. Through this effort, he managed to produce enough grain to send some to Rome and gather supplies in Catana for the army that was set to spend the summer in Tarentum.

9

But the transportation of the soldiers into Sicily, and they consisted chiefly of Latins and allies, had very nearly caused a serious commotion; from such trifling circumstances do events of great importance frequently arise. A murmuring arose among the Latins and allies at their meetings. They said, that "they had been drained by levies and contributions for ten years. That almost every year they fought with the most disastrous consequences. That some of them were slain in the field, others were carried off by disease. That a countryman of theirs who was enlisted by the Romans was more lost to them than one who was taken prisoner by the Carthaginians; for the latter was sent back to his country by the enemy without ransom, while the former was sent beyond the limits of Italy, into exile rather than military service. That the troops which fought at Cannae were growing old there, for eight years, and would die there before the enemy, who was now more than ever flourishing and vigorous would depart from Italy. If the old soldiers did not return to their country, and fresh ones were enlisted, that in a short time there would be no one left. That, therefore, they must refuse to the Roman people, before they came to utter desolation and want, what shortly their very condition would refuse. If the Romans saw their allies unanimous on this point that they would then certainly think of making peace with the Carthaginians; otherwise, Italy would never be without war while Hannibal was alive." Thus they discoursed in their meetings. The Roman people had at that time thirty colonies. Twelve of these, for they all had embassies in Rome, told the consuls that they had not whence to furnish either men or money. The twelve were Ardea, Nepete Sutrium, Alba, Carseoli, Cora, Suessa, Cerceii, Setia, Cales Narnia, Interamna. The consuls, astonished at this new proceeding, were desirous to deter them from so hateful a measure and, considering that they could effect this better by censure and remonstrance than by mild means, said that "they had dared to say to the consuls what the consuls could not bring their minds to declare in the senate; for that this was not refusal to perform military service, but an open defection from the Roman people. They desired, therefore, that they would return to their colonies speedily, and that, considering the subject as untouched, as they had only spoken of, but not attempted, so impious a business, they would consult with their countrymen. That they would warn them that they were not Campanians or Tarentines, but Romans; that from thence they derived their origin, and thence were sent out into colonies and lands captured from the enemy, for the purpose of increasing the population. That they owed to the Romans what children owed to parents, if they possessed any natural affection, or any gratitude towards their mother country. That they should, therefore, consider the matter afresh; for that certainly what they then so rashly meditated, was the betraying the Roman empire, and putting the victory in the hands of Hannibal." The consuls having spent a long time in exchanging arguments of this kind, the ambassadors, who were not at all moved by what they said, declared, that "they had nothing which they could carry home, nor had their senate any thing fresh to devise, having neither men to be enlisted, nor money to be furnished for pay." The consuls, seeing that they were inflexible, laid the matter before the senate; where the alarm excited in the minds of all was so great, that "the greater part declared it was all over with the empire; that the rest of the colonies would take the same course, and that all the allies had conspired to betray the city of Rome to Hannibal."

But moving the soldiers to Sicily, mostly Latins and allies, almost caused a serious uproar; often, significant events arise from seemingly trivial issues. There was grumbling among the Latins and allies in their gatherings. They said that "they had been drained by drafts and contributions for ten years. Almost every year, they fought with disastrous outcomes. Some were killed in battle, while others fell ill. A fellow countryman of theirs who was enlisted by the Romans was more lost to them than one captured by the Carthaginians; the latter was sent back home by the enemy without a ransom, while the former was sent far beyond Italy, into exile instead of military duty. The troops that fought at Cannae had been there for eight years and would die there before the enemy, who was now stronger and more vigorous than ever, would leave Italy. If the old soldiers didn’t return home and fresh ones were recruited, soon there would be no one left. Therefore, they must refuse the Roman people, before they fell into utter ruin and need, what soon their very situation would deny. If the Romans saw their allies united on this point, they would surely consider making peace with the Carthaginians; otherwise, Italy would never be free of war while Hannibal was alive." This is how they talked in their gatherings. At that time, the Roman people had thirty colonies. Twelve of these, all of which had representatives in Rome, told the consuls that they had no resources to provide either men or money. The twelve were Ardea, Nepete, Sutrium, Alba, Carseoli, Cora, Suessa, Cerceii, Setia, Cales, Narnia, Interamna. The consuls, shocked by this unexpected situation, tried to dissuade them from such a dreadful decision and thought it would be more effective to scold and admonish them than to use gentle approaches. They stated that "they had the audacity to say to the consuls what the consuls themselves could not bring themselves to declare in the senate; this was not a refusal of military service but a blatant defection from the Roman people. They urged them to return to their colonies quickly and to treat the topic as untouched, as they had only spoken about, but not attempted, such an impious act, and to consult with their fellow citizens. They should remind them that they were not Campanians or Tarentines but Romans; their origin came from there, and they were sent to colonies and lands seized from the enemy to increase the population. They owed to the Romans what children owe to parents, if they had any natural affection or gratitude toward their motherland. They should, therefore, reconsider the issue; for certainly, what they were recklessly contemplating was betraying the Roman empire and handing victory to Hannibal." After a long time of exchanging such arguments, the ambassadors, unfazed by what the consuls had said, declared, that "they had nothing to take back, and their senate had nothing new to propose, having neither soldiers to recruit nor funds to provide for pay." The consuls, seeing that they were stubborn, brought the matter before the senate; the alarm among everyone was so intense that "the majority declared it was the end for the empire; that the other colonies would follow suit, and that all the allies had conspired to betray the city of Rome to Hannibal."

10

The consuls endeavoured to encourage and console the senate, telling them that "the other colonies would maintain their allegiance, and continue in their former state of dutiful obedience, and that those very colonies who had renounced their allegiance, would be inspired with respect for the empire, if ambassadors were sent round to them to reprove and not entreat them." The senate having given them permission to do and to act as they might conceive best for the state; after sounding the intentions of the other colonies, the consuls summoned their ambassadors, and asked them whether they had their soldiers ready according to the roll? Marcus Sextilius of Fregellae replied, in behalf of the eighteen colonies, that "they both had their soldiers ready according to the roll, and if more were wanting would furnish more, and would perform with all diligence whatever else the Roman people commanded and wished; that to do this they wanted not means, and of inclination they had more than enough." The consuls, having first told them that any praises bestowed by themselves alone seemed too little for their deserts, unless the whole body of the fathers should thank them in the senate-house, led them before the senate. The senate, having voted an address to them conceived in the most honourable terms, charged the consuls to take them before the assembly of the people; and, among the many other distinguished services rendered to themselves and their ancestors, to make mention also of this recent obligation conferred upon the state. Nor even at the present day, after the lapse of so many ages let their names be passed over in silence, nor let them be defrauded of the praise due to them. They were the people of Signia, Norba, Saticulum, Brundusium, Fregellae, Lucerium Venusia, Adria, Firma, Ariminum; on the other sea, Pontius Paestum, and Cosa; and in the inland parts Beneventum, Aesernia, Spoletum, Placentia, and Cremona. By the support of these colonies the empire of the Roman people then stood; and the thanks both of the senate and the people were given to them. As to the twelve other colonies which refused obedience, the fathers forbade that their names should be mentioned, that their ambassadors should either be dismissed or retained, to be addressed by the consuls. Such a tacit reproof appears most consistent with the dignity of the Roman people. While the consuls were getting in readiness all the other things which were necessary for the war, it was resolved that the vicesimary gold, which was preserved in the most sacred part of the treasury as a resource in cases of extreme exigencies should be drawn out. There were drawn out as many as four thousand pounds of gold, from which five hundred pounds each were given to the consuls, to Marcus Marcellus and Publius Sulpicius, proconsuls, and Lucius Veturius, the praetor, who had by lot obtained Gaul as his province; and in addition, one hundred pounds of gold were given to the consul Fabius, as an extraordinary grant to be carried into the citadel of Tarentum. The rest they employed in contracts, for ready money, for clothing for the army which was carrying on the war in Spain, to their own and their general glory.

The consuls tried to encourage and reassure the senate, telling them that "the other colonies would stay loyal and continue to obey as they had before, and that even those colonies that had abandoned their loyalty would respect the empire if we sent ambassadors to scold them rather than beg them." The senate allowed the consuls to act as they saw fit for the state; after checking the intentions of the other colonies, the consuls called their ambassadors and asked if their soldiers were ready. Marcus Sextilius from Fregellae responded on behalf of the eighteen colonies, saying that "they had their soldiers ready and would provide more if needed, and would diligently do whatever the Roman people commanded and desired; they had no shortage of means and plenty of willingness." The consuls first told them that any praise they gave seemed insufficient unless the whole senate acknowledged them, then brought them before the senate. The senate voted to address them in the most honorable terms and instructed the consuls to present them to the assembly of the people, mentioning their recent contributions along with many other distinguished services to the state and their ancestors. Even today, after so many ages, let their names not be forgotten or denied the praise they deserve. They were from Signia, Norba, Saticulum, Brundusium, Fregellae, Lucerium, Venusia, Adria, Firma, Ariminum; on the other side, Pontius, Paestum, and Cosa; and in the interior, Beneventum, Aesernia, Spoletum, Placentia, and Cremona. With the support of these colonies, the Roman Empire stood strong at that time, and both the senate and the people thanked them. As for the twelve other colonies that refused to obey, the senate decided not to mention their names or to address their ambassadors. This silent reprimand seemed most fitting for the dignity of the Roman people. While the consuls prepared everything necessary for the war, it was decided to take out the extraordinary gold kept in the most sacred part of the treasury for emergencies. They withdrew four thousand pounds of gold, giving five hundred pounds each to the consuls, to Marcus Marcellus and Publius Sulpicius, proconsuls, and Lucius Veturius, the praetor assigned to Gaul; additionally, one hundred pounds were given to Consul Fabius as an extraordinary grant to take to the citadel of Tarentum. The rest was used for contracts to buy clothing for the army fighting in Spain, adding to their own and their general's glory.

11

It was resolved also, that the prodigies should be expiated before the consuls set out from the city. In the Alban mount, the statue of Jupiter and a tree near the temple were struck by lightning; at Ostia, a grove; at Capua, a wall and the temple of Fortune; at Sinuessa, a wall and a gate. Some also asserted, that water at Alba had flowed tinged with blood. That at Rome, within the cell of Fors Fortuna, an image, which was in the crown of the goddess, had fallen spontaneously from her head into her hands. At Privernum, it was satisfactorily established that an ox spoke, and that a vulture flew down into a shop, while the forum was crowded. And that a child was born at Sinuessa, of ambiguous sex, between a male and female, such as are commonly called Androgynes, a term derived from the Greek language, which is better adapted, as for most other purposes, so for the composition of words; also that it rained milk, and that a boy was born with the head of an elephant. These prodigies were then expiated with victims of the larger kind, and a supplication at every shrine and an offering up of prayers, was proclaimed for one day. It was also decreed, that Caius Hostilius, the praetor, should vow and perform the games in honour of Apollo as they had of late years been vowed and performed. During the same time, Quintus Fulvius, the consul, held an election for the creation of censors. Marcus Cornelius Cethegus, and Publius Sempronius Tuditanus, both of whom had not yet been consuls, were created censors. The question was put to the people on the authority of the fathers, and the people ordered that these censors should let to farm the Campanian lands. The choosing of the senate was delayed by a dispute which arose between the censors about the selection of a chief of the senate. The choice belonged to Sempronius; but Cornelius contended that the custom handed down by their fathers must be followed, which was, that they should choose him as chief of the senate who was first censor of those who were then alive; this was Titus Manlius Torquatus. Sempronius rejoined, that to whom the gods had given the lot of choosing, to him the same gods had given the right of exercising his discretion freely. That he would act in this affair according to his own free will, and would choose Quintus Fabius Maximus, whom he would prove to be the first man in the Roman state, even in the judgment of Hannibal. After a long verbal dispute, his colleague giving up the point, Quintus Fabius Maximus, the consul, was chosen, by Sempronius, chief of the senate. Another senate was then chosen, and eight names were passed over; among which was that of Lucius Caecilius Metellus, disrespected as the adviser of the abandonment of Italy, after the defeat at Cannae. In censuring those of the equestrian order, the same ground was acted upon, but there were very few to whom that disgrace belonged. All of the equestrian order belonging to the legions who had fought at Cannae, and were then in Sicily, were deprived of their horses. To this severe punishment they added another relating to time, which was, that the past campaign which they had served on horses furnished at the public expense should not be reckoned to them, but that they should serve ten campaigns on horses furnished at their own expense. They also searched for, and discovered, a great number of those who ought to have served in the cavalry; and all those who were seventeen years old at the beginning of the war and had not served, they disfranchised. They then contracted for the restoration of the seven shops, the shamble and the royal palace, situated round the forum, and which had been consumed by fire.

It was also decided that the prodigies needed to be atoned for before the consuls left the city. On the Alban Mount, the statue of Jupiter and a tree near the temple were struck by lightning; at Ostia, a grove; at Capua, a wall and the temple of Fortune; and at Sinuessa, a wall and a gate. Some claimed that water in Alba flowed as if it were mixed with blood. In Rome, within the cell of Fors Fortuna, an image that was part of the goddess's crown fell from her head into her hands on its own. At Privernum, it was confirmed that an ox spoke, and a vulture flew down into a shop while the forum was packed with people. Additionally, there was a child born at Sinuessa with an ambiguous sex, between male and female, often referred to as an Androgyn, a term derived from Greek. It was also reported that it rained milk and that a boy was born with the head of an elephant. These signs were then atoned for with sacrifices of larger animals, and a day of supplication and prayer was proclaimed at every shrine. It was also decided that Caius Hostilius, the praetor, should vow and run the games in honor of Apollo as had been done in previous years. At the same time, Quintus Fulvius, the consul, held an election to create censors. Marcus Cornelius Cethegus and Publius Sempronius Tuditanus, both of whom had not yet served as consuls, were appointed as censors. The question was put to the people based on the authority of the fathers, and the people directed that these censors should lease the Campanian lands. The selection of the senate was delayed due to a disagreement between the censors regarding who should be the chief of the senate. The choice was Sempronius's, but Cornelius argued that they should follow the custom passed down from their ancestors, which stated that the first censor among the living should be chosen as the chief of the senate; this was Titus Manlius Torquatus. Sempronius countered that whoever the gods had given the responsibility to choose was also granted the freedom to make a decision. He stated that he would act according to his judgement and choose Quintus Fabius Maximus, claiming he would prove to be the top man in the Roman state, even in Hannibal's opinion. After a lengthy verbal debate, and with his colleague conceding, Quintus Fabius Maximus, the consul, was chosen by Sempronius as the chief of the senate. Another senate was then appointed, and eight names were skipped, including that of Lucius Caecilius Metellus, who was looked down upon for advocating the abandonment of Italy after the defeat at Cannae. When criticizing those of the equestrian order, the same reasoning was applied, but very few were guilty of that disgrace. All equestrians from the legions that had fought at Cannae and were in Sicily at the time lost their horses. To this harsh punishment, they added another regarding time, stating that the last campaign they had served on horses provided by the state wouldn’t count for them, and they would have to serve ten campaigns on horses supplied at their own expense. They also searched for and found many who should have served in the cavalry; all those who were seventeen years old at the start of the war and had not served were stripped of their citizenship. They then contracted to rebuild the seven shops, the shambles, and the royal palace around the forum that had been destroyed by fire.

12

Having finished every thing which was to be done in Rome, the consuls set out for the war. Fulvius first went advance to Capua; in a few days Fabius followed. He implored his colleague in person, and Marcellus by a letter use the most vigorous measures to detain Hannibal, while he was making an attack upon Tarentum. That when that city was taken from the enemy, who had been repulsed on all sides and had no place where he might make a stand or look back up as a safe retreat, he would not then have even a pretext for remaining in Italy. He also sent a messenger to Rhegium, the praefect of the garrison, which had been placed there the consul Laevinus, against the Bruttians, and consisted eight thousand men, the greater part of whom had been brought from Agathyrna in Sicily, as has been before mentioned, and were men who had been accustomed to live by rapine. To these were added fugitives of the Bruttians natives of that country, equal to them in daring, and under an equal necessity of braving every thing. This band ordered to be marched, first, to lay waste the Bruttian territory, and then to attack the city Caulonia. After having executed the order, not only with alacrity, but avidity, and having pillaged and put to flight the cultivators of the land they attacked the city with the utmost vigour. Marcellus incited by the letter of the consul, and because he had made up his mind that no Roman general was so good a match for Hannibal as himself, set out from his winter quarters as soon as there was plenty of forage in the fields, and met Hannibal at Canusium. The Carthaginian was then endeavouring to induce the Canusians to revolt, but as soon as he heard that Marcellus was approaching, he decamped thence. The country was open, without any covers adapted for an ambuscade; he therefore began to retire thence into woody districts. Marcellus closely pursued him, pitched his camp close to his, and when he had completed his works, led out his troops into the field. Hannibal engaged in slight skirmishes, and sent out single troops of horse and the spearmen from his infantry, not considering it necessary to hazard a general battle. He was, however, drawn on to a contest of that kind which he was avoiding. Hannibal had decamped by night, but was overtaken by Marcellus in a plain and open country. Then, while encamping, Marcellus, by attacking the workmen on all hands, prevented the completion of his works. Thus a pitched battle ensued, and all their forces were brought into action; but night coming on, they retired from an equal contest. They then hastily fortified their camps, which were a small space apart, before night. The next day, as soon as it was light, Marcellus led out his troops into the field; nor did Hannibal decline the challenge, but exhorted his soldiers at great length, desiring them "to remember Trasimenus and Cannae, and thus quell the proud spirit of their enemies." He said, "the enemy pressed upon him, and trod upon their heels; that he did not allow them to pass unmolested, pitch their camp, or even take breath and look around them; that every day, the rising sun and the Roman troops in battle-array were to be seen together on the plains. But if in one battle he should retire from the field, not without loss of blood, he would then prosecute the war more steadily and quietly." Fired by these exhortations, and at the same time wearied with the presumption of the enemy, who daily pressed upon them and provoked them to an engagement, they commenced the battle with spirit. The battle continued for more than two hours, when the right wing of the allies and the chosen band began to give way on the part of the Romans; which Marcellus perceiving, led the eighteenth legion to the front. While some were retiring in confusion, and others were coming up reluctantly, the whole line was thrown into disorder, and afterwards completely routed; while their fears getting the better of their sense of shame, they turned their backs. In the battle and in the flight there fell as many as two thousand seven hundred of the citizens and allies; among which were four Roman centurions and two military tribunes, Marcus Licinius and Marcus Helvius. Four military standards were lost by the wing which first fled, and two belonging to the legion which came up in place of the retiring allies.

Having finished everything that needed to be done in Rome, the consuls set out for war. Fulvius went ahead to Capua, and a few days later, Fabius followed. He personally pleaded with his colleague and wrote to Marcellus to take strong actions to keep Hannibal occupied while he attacked Tarentum. He argued that once that city was taken from the enemy, who had been pushed back on all sides and had nowhere to go for safety, Hannibal would have no reason to stay in Italy. He also sent a messenger to Rhegium, to the commander of the garrison placed there by Consul Laevinus against the Bruttians, which consisted of eight thousand men, most of whom came from Agathyrna in Sicily, as previously mentioned, and were known for their pillaging. These soldiers were joined by Bruttian fugitives from the local area, equally brave and driven to face every challenge. This group was ordered to first ravage the Bruttian territory and then attack the city of Caulonia. After carrying out their orders with enthusiasm, they looted and chased away the local farmers before attacking the city with great intensity. Marcellus, motivated by the consul's letter and believing he was the best match against Hannibal, left his winter quarters as soon as there was enough fodder in the fields and encountered Hannibal at Canusium. The Carthaginian was trying to persuade the Canusians to revolt, but once he learned that Marcellus was approaching, he packed up and left. The area was open, with no cover for an ambush, so he retreated to wooded regions. Marcellus closely pursued him, set up camp near his, and when his fortifications were completed, he led his troops into the field. Hannibal engaged in minor skirmishes and sent out small groups of cavalry and infantry, avoiding a full-scale battle. However, he was eventually drawn into the kind of engagement he was trying to avoid. While night fell, Hannibal had moved camp, but Marcellus caught up with him in an open plain. As they were setting up camp, Marcellus attacked the workers, halting the completion of their fortifications. This led to a full battle, with both sides engaging, but as night approached, they withdrew from a balanced conflict. They quickly fortified their camps, which were not far apart, before night fell. The next day, as soon as it was light, Marcellus led his troops into the field; Hannibal did not shy away but gave an extended speech to his soldiers, urging them to "remember Lake Trasimene and Cannae, and to suppress the arrogance of their enemies." He said, “the enemy is closing in and pushing hard; he wouldn’t let them camp or even catch their breath; every day, the sunrise and the Romans were there together on the plains. But if he retreated from the battlefield in one fight, not without losing troops, he would then wage war more firmly and calmly.” Inspired by these words and worn down by the relentless enemy's pressure, they charged into battle with determination. The fight lasted more than two hours, during which the right flank of the allies and the elite troops began to falter on the Roman side. Noticing this, Marcellus brought the eighteenth legion to the front. As some soldiers fell back in panic and others hesitated to advance, the entire line fell into chaos and was ultimately routed; their fear overwhelming their shame, they fled. In the battle and subsequent escape, about two thousand seven hundred citizens and allies were lost, including four Roman centurions and two military tribunes, Marcus Licinius and Marcus Helvius. Four military standards were captured from the fleeing wing and two from the legion that replaced the retreating allies.

13

Marcellus, on his return to the camp, delivered an address to his soldiers so severe and acrimonious, that the words of their exasperated general were more painful to them than what they had suffered in the unsuccessful battle during the whole day. "I praise and thank the immortal gods," said he "that in such an affair the victorious enemy did not assail our very camp, when you were hurrying into the rampart and the gates with such consternation. There can be no doubt but you would have abandoned the camp with the same cowardice with which you gave up the battle. What panic was this? What terror? What sudden forgetfulness of who you are, and who the persons with whom you were fighting, took possession of your minds? Surely these are the same enemies in conquering and pursuing whom when conquered you spent the preceding summer; whom latterly you have been closely pursuing while they fled before you night and day; whom you have wearied by partial battles; whom yesterday you would not allow either to march or encamp. I pass over those things in which you might be allowed to glory; I will mention a circumstance which of itself ought to fill you with shame and remorse. Yesterday you separated from the enemy on equal terms. What alteration has last night, what on this day, produced? Have your forces been diminished by them, or theirs increased? I verily do not seem to be talking to my own troops, or to Roman soldiers. The bodies and the arms are the same. Had you possessed the same spirit, would the enemy have seen your backs? Would they have carried off a standard from any company or cohort? Hitherto he was wont to boast of having cut to pieces the Roman legions, but yesterday you gave him the glory, for the first time, of having put to flight an army." On this many soldiers began to call upon him to pardon them for that day, and entreat that he would now, whenever he pleased, make trial of the courage of his soldiers. "I will indeed make trial of you," said he, "and to-morrow I will lead you into the field, that in the character of conquerors, rather than conquered men, you may obtain the pardon you seek." To the cohorts which had lost their standards, he ordered that barley should be given. The centurions of the Campanians, whose standards were lost, he left to stand without their girdles and with their swords drawn; and gave orders that all, both horse and foot, should be ready under arms on the following day. Thus the assembly was dismissed; the soldiers confessing that they had been justly and deservedly rebuked; and that there was no one in the whole Roman army who had acquitted himself like a man, except the general, to whom they were bound to make atonement, either by their death or a glorious victory. The next day they appeared in readiness, according to the order, armed and equipped. The general praised them, and gave out, that "he should lead into the first line those who had commenced the flight on the preceding day, and those cohorts which had lost their standards. He now charged them all to fight and conquer, and exert every effort, one and all, that the intelligence of yesterday's flight might not arrive at Rome before that of this day's victory." They were then ordered to refresh themselves with food, in order that, if the fight should continue longer than might be expected, their strength might not fail. After every thing had been done and said, by which the courage of the soldiers might be roused, they advanced into the field.

Marcellus, upon returning to the camp, gave his soldiers a speech that was so harsh and bitter that his furious words hurt them more than the suffering they endured during the failed battle throughout the day. "I praise and thank the immortal gods," he said, "that in such a situation the victorious enemy did not attack our very camp while you were rushing into the rampart and the gates in a panic. There’s no doubt you would have fled the camp with the same cowardice you showed in the battle. What was this panic? What fear? What sudden forgetfulness of who you are and who you were fighting took over your minds? Surely, these are the same enemies you spent last summer defeating and pursuing; the same ones you’ve been chasing closely day and night; the ones you’ve exhausted with small battles; the ones you wouldn’t let either march or camp yesterday. I’ll skip over the things you might take pride in; I’ll mention something that should fill you with shame and guilt. Yesterday you engaged the enemy on equal ground. What changed overnight and today? Have your numbers decreased or theirs increased? It honestly doesn’t feel like I’m speaking to my own troops or to Roman soldiers. Your bodies and arms are the same. If you had the same spirit, would the enemy have seen your backs? Would they have taken a standard from any of your units? Until now, he would brag about having destroyed the Roman legions, but yesterday you gave him the honor, for the first time, of sending an army running." Hearing this, many soldiers began to ask him to forgive them for that day and plead that he would test their courage again whenever he chose. "I will indeed test you," he replied, "and tomorrow I will lead you into battle so that as conquerors, rather than the conquered, you may earn the forgiveness you seek." He ordered that barley be given to the cohorts that had lost their standards. The centurions of the Campanians, whose standards were lost, were left without their sashes and with their swords drawn; he commanded that everyone, both cavalry and infantry, should be ready for action the next day. Thus the assembly was dismissed; the soldiers admitted they had been rightly and deservedly scolded, and that no one in the entire Roman army had acted like a man except the general, to whom they owed atonement, either through their deaths or a glorious victory. The next day, they appeared ready, as ordered, armed and equipped. The general praised them and announced that he would place those who had fled the previous day and the cohorts that had lost their standards in the front line. He urged them all to fight and conquer and to make every effort so that the news of yesterday’s flight wouldn’t reach Rome before the news of today's victory. They were then instructed to refresh themselves with food so that, if the fight lasted longer than expected, their strength wouldn’t falter. After everything had been said and done to boost the soldiers' courage, they advanced into the field.

14

Hannibal, on receiving intelligence of this, said, "surely the enemy we have to do with can neither bear good nor bad fortune. If he is victorious, he fiercely pursues the vanquished. If conquered, he renews the contest with the victors." He then ordered the signal to be given, and led out his forces. The battle was fought on both sides with much more spirit than the day before. The Carthaginians exerting themselves to the utmost, to keep the glory they had acquired yesterday; the Romans, to remove their disgrace. On the side of the Romans, the left wing, and the cohorts which had lost their standards, fought in the first line, and the twentieth legion was drawn up on the right wing. Lucius Cornelius Lentulus and Caius Claudius Nero, lieutenant-generals, commanded the wings, Marcellus gave vigour to the centre by his presence, as an encourager and a witness. On the part of Hannibal, the Spaniards, who were the flower of his whole army, occupied the front line. After the battle had continued doubtful for a long time, Hannibal ordered the elephants to be advanced into the front line, if by that means any confusion or panic could be created. At first, they threw the troops into confusion and broke their ranks, and treading some under foot, and dispersing others who were round them by the alarm they created, had made an opening in one part of the Roman line; and the flight would have spread more widely had not Caius Decimus Flavius, a military tribune seizing the standard of the first maniple of the spearmen ordered that maniple to follow him. He led them to the spot where the elephants, collected in a body, were creating the greatest confusion, and ordered them to discharge their javelins at them. As there was no difficulty in hitting such bulky bodies at a short distance, and where so many were crowded together, all their javelins stuck in them. But they were not all wounded, so those in whose hides the javelins stuck, as that race of animals is not to be depended on, by taking themselves to flight, drove away those also which were untouched. At that moment not only one maniple, but all the soldiers who could but overtake the body of retreating elephants, threw their javelins at them, each man exerting himself to his utmost. With so much greater impetuosity did the animals rush upon their own men, and so much greater carnage did they make amongst them than they had made amongst their enemies, in proportion as the violence with which they are impelled, and the consternation produced by them when under the influence of fear, is greater than when they are ruled by their masters seated on their backs. The Roman infantry bore their standards against the line of the enemy when thrown into disorder by the elephants which had crossed over to them, and, thus scattered and confused, led them to flight without any great opposition. Marcellus sent his cavalry after them as they fled; nor did they desist from the pursuit till they were driven in consternation to their camp. For in addition to the other causes which occasioned terror and dismay, two elephants had fallen just by the gate, and the soldiers were compelled to rush into the camp over the ditch and rampart. Here the greatest slaughter of the enemy occurred. There fell as many as eight thousand men and five elephants. Nor did the Romans gain a bloodless victory; about seventeen hundred of the two legions, and thirteen hundred of the allies were slain; a great number of the Romans and allies were wounded. The following night Hannibal decamped. The great number of the wounded prevented Marcellus from following him, as he desired.

Hannibal, upon receiving this information, said, "Clearly, our enemy cannot handle either good or bad fortune. When he wins, he aggressively pursues the defeated. When he loses, he challenges the victors again." He then ordered the signal to be given and led out his troops. The battle was fought with much more intensity than the day before. The Carthaginians pushed themselves to the limit to maintain the glory they had won yesterday, while the Romans fought to redeem their honor. On the Roman side, the left wing and the cohorts that had lost their standards fought in the front line, and the twentieth legion was positioned on the right wing. Lucius Cornelius Lentulus and Caius Claudius Nero, the lieutenant-generals, commanded the wings, while Marcellus energized the center by being there as both a motivator and a witness. For Hannibal, the Spaniards, the best troops in his army, occupied the front line. After the battle stayed uncertain for a long time, Hannibal ordered the elephants to the front line, hoping to create some confusion or panic. Initially, they caused chaos and broke up the formation, trampling some soldiers and scattering others, creating a gap in the Roman line; the retreat might have spread further if not for Caius Decimus Flavius, a military tribune, who seized the standard of the first maniple of the spearmen and commanded that maniple to follow him. He led them to where the elephants were causing the most disruption and ordered them to throw their javelins at them. There was no trouble hitting such large animals at close range, and as they crowded together, all their javelins penetrated them. However, not all of the elephants were hurt, and those that were hit, being unreliable creatures, took off running and caused the unharmed ones to flee as well. At that moment, not just one maniple, but all the soldiers who could catch up to the retreating elephants threw their javelins at them, each soldier giving it their all. The elephants charged their own men with even greater force and caused more carnage among them than they had against their enemies, as the fear-driven chaos was greater than when they were controlled by their riders. The Roman infantry held their standards against the enemy line, which was thrown into disarray by the elephants that had crossed over to them, and, scattered and confused, they fled with little resistance. Marcellus sent his cavalry after them as they ran; they did not stop pursuing until the enemy was driven in panic back to their camp. Besides other factors inducing fear and panic, two elephants had fallen right by the gate, and the soldiers were forced to rush into the camp over the ditch and rampart. This was where the most significant slaughter of the enemy took place. As many as eight thousand men and five elephants fell. The Romans did not win without losses; about seventeen hundred from the two legions and thirteen hundred allies were killed, with many more wounded. The following night, Hannibal broke camp. The high number of wounded prevented Marcellus from pursuing him as he wanted.

15

TThe spies who were sent to watch his movements brought word back the next day that Hannibal was making for Bruttium. Much about the same time the Hirpinians, Lucanians, and Volcentes surrendered themselves to the consul, Quintus Fulvius, delivering up the garrisons of Hannibal which they had in their cities. They were mildly received by the consul, with only a verbal reproof for their past error. To the Bruttians also similar hopes of pardon were held out, when two brothers, Vibius and Pactius, by far the most illustrious persons of that nation, came from them to solicit the same terms of surrender which had been given to the Lucanians. Quintus Fabius, the consul, took by storm Manduria, a town in the territory of Sallentum, where as many as four thousand men were made prisoners, and much booty taken besides. Proceeding thence to Tarentum, he pitched his camp in the very mouth of the harbour: of the ships which Livius had employed for protecting convoys, some he loaded with engines and implements for attacking walls, others he furnished with machines for discharging missiles, and with stones and missiles of every kind; not only those which were impelled with oars, but the storeships also, in order that some might carry the engines and ladders to the walls, while others might wound the defenders of the walls by discharging missiles from the ships at a distance. These ships were fitted up and prepared to attack the town from the open sea; and the sea was free from the Carthaginian fleet, which had crossed over to Corcyra on account of Philip's preparing to attack the Aetolians. Meanwhile, those who were attacking Caulon, in the territory of Bruttium, fearful lest they should be overpowered, had retired on the approach of Hannibal to an eminence, secure from an immediate attack. While Fabius was besieging Tarentum, he received assistance in the accomplishment of that great object by a circumstance which in the mere mention, is unimportant. Tarentum was occupied by a garrison of Bruttians, given them by Hannibal and the commander of that garrison was desperately in love with a girl, whose brother was in the army of the consul Fabius. Being informed, by a letter from his sister, of the new acquaintance she had formed with a wealthy stranger and one so honoured among his countrymen, and conceiving a hope that the lover, by means of his sister, might be induced to any thing she pleased, he acquainted the consul with the hope he had formed. His reasoning appeared not altogether unfounded, and he was desired to go to Tarentum as a deserter and having gained the confidence of the praefect by means of his sister, he began by sounding his disposition in a covert manner, and then, having sufficiently ascertained his weakness, induced him, by the aid of female fascinations, to the betrayal of that custody of the place to which he was appointed. After the method to be pursued and the time for putting the plan into effect had been agreed upon, a soldier, who was sent out of the city by night clandestinely, through the intervals between the guards, related to the consul what had been done, and what had been agreed upon to be done. At the first watch, Fabius, on a signal given to those who were in the citadel, and those who had the custody of the harbour went himself round the harbour, and took up a position of concealment, on the side of the city which faced the east. Then the trumpets began to sound at once from the citadel, the harbour, and the ships which had been brought to the shore from the open sea, and a shout was purposely raised, accompanied with the greatest confusion, in whatever quarter there was the least danger. Meanwhile, the consul kept the men in silence. Democrates, therefore, who had formerly commanded the fleet, and happened to be in command in the quarter, seeing that all was quiet around him, while other parts of the city resounded with such a din that sometimes shout like that of a captured city was raised, and fearing loss while he hesitated, the consul should make some attack and advance his standards, led his party over to the citadel, from which the most alarming noise proceeded. Fabius, concluding that the guard was withdrawn, both from the time which had elapsed and from the silence which prevailed, for not a voice met the ear from a quarter where a little while ago the noise and bustle of men resounded, rousing and calling each other to arms, ordered the ladders to be carried to that part of the wall where the person who had contrived the plot for betraying the city, had informed him that the Bruttian cohort kept guard. The wall was first captured in that quarter, the Bruttians aiding and receiving the Romans; and here they got over into the city: after which the nearest gate was broken open in order that the troops might enter in a large body. Then raising a shout, they proceeded to the forum, where they arrived much about daybreak, without meeting a single armed man; and drew upon themselves the attention of all the troops in every quarter, which were fighting at the citadel and at the harbour.

The spies sent to monitor his movements reported back the next day that Hannibal was heading towards Bruttium. Around the same time, the Hirpinians, Lucanians, and Volcentes surrendered to the consul, Quintus Fulvius, handing over Hannibal’s garrisons from their cities. The consul received them kindly, only giving them a verbal reprimand for their previous mistake. The Bruttians were also offered similar hopes of mercy when two brothers, Vibius and Pactius, the most prominent leaders of their people, came to negotiate the same terms of surrender that the Lucanians received. Quintus Fabius, the consul, stormed Manduria, a town in the Sallentum region, capturing about four thousand men and seizing a considerable amount of loot. He then moved on to Tarentum, setting up camp right at the harbor entrance. From the ships that Livius had used to protect convoys, some were loaded with siege engines and tools for attacking walls, while others were equipped with launching machines and various missile supplies; not only those powered by oars but also the supply ships, so that some could transport the engines and ladders to the walls, while others could strike the defenders from a distance. These vessels were outfitted and readied to assault the city from the open sea, as the Carthaginian fleet had moved to Corcyra due to Philip’s preparations to attack the Aetolians. Meanwhile, those besieging Caulon in Bruttium, fearing they would be overwhelmed, withdrew to a high ground, safe from an immediate assault. While Fabius was laying siege to Tarentum, he received unexpected assistance from a seemingly trivial situation. Tarentum was held by a garrison of Bruttians appointed by Hannibal, and the commander of that garrison was infatuated with a girl whose brother served in Fabius’s army. After learning from a letter from his sister about her new acquaintance with a wealthy and respected stranger, and hoping that through her, he might persuade the lover to do what she wanted, he informed the consul of his hopes. His reasoning seemed valid, and he was instructed to go to Tarentum as a defector. Gaining the praefect’s trust through his sister, he began to explore his intentions subtly and, after confirming his weaknesses, influenced him—using the allure of romance—to betray his post. Once the methods and timing for executing the plan were settled, a soldier was secretly sent out of the city at night through openings in the guard lines to inform the consul of what had transpired and what was agreed upon. At the first watch, Fabius, upon receiving a signal from those in the citadel and the harbor guards, made his way around the harbor and concealed himself on the eastern side of the city. Then the trumpets sounded simultaneously from the citadel, the harbor, and the ships brought ashore from the open sea, and a deliberately raised shout created great confusion wherever there was even the slightest perceived danger. Meanwhile, the consul kept his men silent. Democrates, who had previously commanded the fleet and was currently in charge at that location, noticed that everything was quiet around him, while other parts of the city were filled with such noise that it sometimes resembled the uproar of a city being captured. Fearing what might happen as he hesitated, the consul might attack and advance his standards. So, he took his troops to the citadel, from where the most alarming sounds were coming. Fabius, concluding that the guard had been withdrawn based on the time that had passed and the prevailing silence—since there was no longer any noise from a section that had recently been bustling with activity, calling men to arms—ordered the ladders to be brought to the section of the wall where the person who had plotted the city’s betrayal had informed him that the Bruttian cohort was stationed. This part of the wall was captured first, with the Bruttians aiding the Romans, allowing them to enter the city. Then, they broke open the nearest gate for the troops to enter in large numbers. Raising a shout, they moved toward the forum, arriving just at daybreak without encountering a single armed man, drawing the attention of all the troops engaged in battles at the citadel and the harbor.

16

A battle was fought in the entrance of the forum, with greater impetuosity than perseverance. The Tarentines were not equal to the Romans in spirit, in their arms, in tactics, in activity or strength of body. Accordingly, having just discharged their javelins, they turned their backs almost before they had joined battle, and escaped in different directions through the streets of the city, with which they were acquainted, to their own houses and those of their friends. Two of their leaders, Nico and Democrates, fell while fighting bravely. Philomenus, who was the author of the plot for betraying the city to Hannibal, rode away from the battle at full speed. Shortly after, his horse, which was loose and straying through the city, was recognised, but his body could not be found any where. It was generally believed that he had pitched headlong from his horse into an open well. Carthalo, the praefect of the Carthaginian garrison, while coming to the consul unarmed, to put him in mind of a connexion of hospitality which subsisted between their fathers, was put to death by a soldier who met him. The rest were put to the sword on all hands, armed and unarmed indiscriminately, Carthaginians and Tarentines without distinction. Many of the Bruttians also were slain either by mistake or on account of an old grudge entertained against them, or else with a view to the report that the city was betrayed; in order that Tarentum might rather appear to have been captured by force of arms. The troops then ran off in all directions from the slaughter, to plunder the city. Thirty thousand slaves are said to have been captured; an immense quantity of silver, wrought and coined; eighty-three thousand pounds of gold; of statues and pictures so many that they almost equalled the decorations of Syracuse. But Fabius, with more magnanimity than Marcellus, abstained from booty of that kind. When his secretary asked him what he wished to be done with the statues of their gods, which are of immense size and represented as fighting, each having his peculiar habit, he gave orders that their angry gods should be left in the possession of the Tarentines. After this, the wall which separated the city from the citadel was razed and demolished. While things were going on thus at Tarentum, Hannibal, to whom the troops engaged in the siege of Caulonia had surrendered themselves, hearing of the siege of Tarentum, marched with the greatest expedition both night and day; but hearing that the city was taken, as he was hastening to bring assistance to it, he exclaimed, "the Romans too have their Hannibal. We have lost Tarentum by the same arts by which we took it." However, that he might not appear to have turned his army in the manner of a fugitive, he encamped where he had halted, about five miles from the city. After staying there a few days, he retired to Metapontum, from which place he sent two Metapontines with letters from the principal men in the state to Fabius at Tarentum, to the effect, that they would accept of his promise that their past conduct should be unpunished, on condition of their betraying Metapontum together with the Carthaginian garrison into his hands. Fabius, who supposed that the communication they brought was genuine, appointed a day on which he would go to Metapontum, and gave the letters to the nobles, which were put into the hands of Hannibal. He, forsooth, delighted at the success of his stratagem, which showed that not even Fabius was proof against his cunning, planted an ambuscade not far from Metapontum. But when Fabius was taking the auspices, before he took his departure from Tarentum, the birds more than once refused approval. Also, on consulting the gods after sacrificing a victim, the aruspex forewarned him to be on his guard against hostile treachery and ambuscade. After the day fixed for his arrival had passed without his coming, the Metapontines were sent again to encourage him, delaying, but they were instantly seized, and, from apprehension of a severer mode of examination, disclosed the plot.

A battle took place at the entrance of the forum, marked more by reckless energy than steady determination. The Tarentines were outmatched by the Romans in spirit, weaponry, tactics, agility, and physical strength. Having just thrown their javelins, they turned to flee almost before the battle even began, escaping in various directions through familiar streets to their homes and those of their friends. Two of their leaders, Nico and Democrates, were killed while fighting bravely. Philomenus, who had plotted to betray the city to Hannibal, fled the battle at full speed. Shortly after, his horse was spotted wandering through the city, but his body couldn’t be found anywhere. It was generally believed that he had fallen headfirst into an open well from his horse. Carthalo, the commander of the Carthaginian garrison, was killed by a soldier as he approached the consul unarmed to remind him of their fathers' bond of hospitality. The rest were slaughtered indiscriminately—armed and unarmed alike, Carthaginians and Tarentines without distinction. Many of the Bruttians were also killed, either by mistake or due to old grudges, or to support the story that the city had been betrayed so that Tarentum could be seen as captured by force. The troops then scattered from the massacre to loot the city. It’s said that thirty thousand slaves were captured, along with an enormous amount of silver, both worked and in coins, and eighty-three thousand pounds of gold; the number of statues and paintings was so vast that they nearly matched the decorations of Syracuse. But Fabius, showing greater nobility than Marcellus, refrained from such loot. When his secretary asked what he wanted to do with the massive statues of their gods, depicted in battle, each with their distinct attire, he ordered that their vengeful gods be left with the Tarentines. Afterward, the wall separating the city from the citadel was torn down. Meanwhile, Hannibal, who had received the surrender of the troops besieging Caulonia, upon hearing of the siege of Tarentum, marched day and night with all speed; but when he learned that the city had fallen just as he was rushing to help, he exclaimed, "The Romans have their own Hannibal. We’ve lost Tarentum through the same tricks we used to take it." However, to avoid appearing like a fleeing army, he set up camp about five miles from the city. After a few days, he moved to Metapontum, from where he sent two Metapontines with letters from the city's leaders to Fabius at Tarentum, offering to accept his assurance that their previous actions would go unpunished in exchange for betraying Metapontum along with the Carthaginian garrison. Fabius, believing the message was genuine, scheduled a day to go to Metapontum and handed the letters to the nobles, which ended up in Hannibal's hands. He was, of course, pleased with the success of his scheme, demonstrating that even Fabius could be outsmarted. He set an ambush not far from Metapontum. However, when Fabius was taking auspices before leaving Tarentum, the birds repeatedly failed to show approval. Additionally, after sacrificing a victim and consulting the gods, the seer warned him to be cautious of possible hostile treachery and ambush. When the day he was supposed to arrive had passed without him showing up, the Metapontines were sent again to encourage him, but they were immediately captured. Fearing harsher interrogation, they revealed the plot.

17

In the beginning of the summer during which these events occurred, after Publius Scipio had employed the whole of the winter in Spain in regaining the affections of the barbarians, partly by presents, and partly by sending home their hostages and prisoners, Edesco, a man distinguished among the Spanish commanders, came to him. His wife and children were in the hands of the Romans; but besides this motive, he was influenced by that apparently fortuitous turn in the state of feeling which had converted the whole of Spain from the Carthaginian to the Roman cause. The same motive induced Indibilis and Mandonius, who were undoubtedly the principal men in all Spain, to desert Hasdrubal and withdraw with the whole body of their countrymen to the eminences which overhung his camp, from which they had a safe retreat along a chain of hills to the Romans. Hasdrubal, perceiving that the strength of the enemy was increasing by such large accessions, while his own was diminishing, and that events would continue to flow in the same course they had taken, unless by a bold effort he effected some alteration, resolved to come to an engagement as soon as possible. Scipio was still more eager for a battle, as well from hope which the success attending his operations had increased, as because he preferred, before the junction of the enemy's forces, to fight with one general and one army, rather than with their united troops. However, in case he should be obliged to fight with more armies than one at the same time, he had with some ingenuity augmented his forces; for seeing that there was no necessity for ships, as the whole coast of Spain was clear of Carthaginian fleets, he hauled his ships on shore at Tarraco and added his mariners to his land forces. He had plenty of arms for them, both those which had been captured at Carthage, and those which he had caused to be made after its capture, so large a number of workmen having been employed. With these forces, setting out from Tarraco at the commencement of the spring, for Laelius had now returned from Rome, without whom he wished nothing of very great importance to be attempted, Scipio marched against the enemy. Indibilis and Mandonius, with their forces, met him while on his march; passing through every place Without molestation, his allies receiving him courteously, and escorting him as he passed the boundaries of each district. Indibilis, who spoke for both, addressed him by no means stupidly and imprudently like a barbarian, but with a modest gravity, rather excusing the change as necessary, than glorying that the present opportunity had been eagerly seized as the first which had occurred. "For he well knew," he said, "that the name of a deserter was an object of execration to former allies, and of suspicion to new ones; nor did he blame the conduct of mankind in this respect, provided, however, that the cause, and not the name, occasioned the twofold hatred." He then recounted the services they had rendered the Carthaginian generals, and on the other hand their rapacity and insolence, together with the injuries of every kind committed against themselves and their countrymen. "On this account," he said, "his person only up to that time had been with them, his heart had long since been on that side where he believed that right and justice were respected. That people sought for refuge, as suppliants, even with the gods when they could not endure the oppression and injustice of men. What he had to entreat of Scipio was, that their passing over to him might neither be the occasion of a charge of fraud nor a ground for respect, but that he would estimate their services according to what sort of men he should find them to be from experience from that day." The Roman replied, that "he would do so in every particular; nor would he consider those men as deserters who did not look upon an alliance as binding where no law, divine or human, was unviolated." Their wives and children were then brought before them and restored to them; on which occasion they wept for joy. On that day they were conducted to a lodging; on the following they were received as allies, by a treaty, after which they were sent to bring up their forces. From that time they had their tents in the same camp with the Romans, until under their guidance they had reached the enemy.

At the start of the summer when these events took place, after Publius Scipio had spent the entire winter in Spain rebuilding relationships with the local tribes, partly through gifts and partly by sending back their hostages and prisoners, Edesco, a notable Spanish commander, approached him. His wife and children were held by the Romans, but he was also influenced by the sudden shift in sentiment that had turned all of Spain from supporting the Carthaginians to backing the Romans. Similarly, Indibilis and Mandonius, who were the most prominent leaders in all of Spain, chose to abandon Hasdrubal and led their people to the high ground overlooking his camp, from where they could safely retreat to the Romans via a series of hills. Hasdrubal, noticing that the enemy's strength was growing with such significant additions while his own was dwindling, and realizing that if things continued on their current path without a bold change, he would need to engage soon. Scipio was even more eager for battle, encouraged by the success he had seen and preferring to face one general and one army before the enemy forces combined. However, anticipating the possibility of fighting multiple armies at once, he cleverly increased his forces; since there was no need for ships with the entire Spanish coast clear of Carthaginian fleets, he pulled his ships ashore at Tarraco and integrated his sailors into his ground troops. He had ample weapons for them, both from those captured at Carthage and the ones he had manufactured after its capture, thanks to the large number of workers employed. With these forces, Scipio set out from Tarraco at the beginning of spring, as Laelius had returned from Rome, and Scipio wanted nothing important to happen without him. While marching against the enemy, Indibilis and Mandonius met him with their forces; moving through each area without disturbance, they were warmly welcomed by his allies as he crossed territorial boundaries. Indibilis, speaking on behalf of both, addressed Scipio not foolishly or impulsively like a barbarian, but with humble seriousness, framing their change of allegiance as a necessity rather than boasting about seizing the first opportunity. “He understood,” he said, “that the term 'deserter' is despised by former allies and arouses suspicion among new ones; and while he did not blame people for this attitude, he hoped the cause, and not merely the name, would govern their judgment.” He then detailed the services they had provided to the Carthaginian generals, along with their greed and arrogance, as well as the various injuries inflicted upon themselves and their fellow countrymen. “For this reason,” he said, “only his body had been with the Carthaginians until now; his heart had long been with those who respect what is right and just. People turn to the gods for refuge as supplicants when they can no longer bear the oppression and injustice of men. What he asked of Scipio was that their alliance should not be seen as an act of treachery nor merit disdain, but that he would evaluate their contributions based on the kind of men he would discover them to be from that point onward.” The Roman responded that he would make that assessment in every aspect; nor would he regard those men as deserters who did not see an alliance as valid when no divine or human law had been violated. Their wives and children were then brought to them and returned, leading them to weep with joy. That day, they were housed together; the next day, they were accepted as allies through a treaty, after which they were sent to gather their forces. From that time on, they shared a camp with the Romans until, under their guidance, they reached the enemy.

18

The army of Hasdrubal, which was the nearest of the Carthaginian armies, lay near the city Baecula. Before his camp he had outposts of cavalry. On these the light-armed, those who fought before the standards and those who composed the vanguard, as they came up from their march, and before they chose the ground for their camp, commenced an attack in so contemptuous a manner, that it was perfectly evident what degree of spirit each party possessed. The cavalry were driven into their camp in disorderly flight, and the Roman standards were advanced almost within their very gates. Their minds on that day having only been excited to a contest, the Romans pitched their camp. At night Hasdrubal withdrew his forces to an eminence, on the summit of which extended a level plain. There was a river on the rear, in front and on either side a kind of steep bank completely surrounded its extremity. Beneath this and lower down was another plain of gentle declivity, which was also surrounded by a similar ridge equally difficult of ascent. Into this lower plain Hasdrubal, the next day, when he saw the troops of the enemy drawn up before their camp, sent his Numidian cavalry and light-armed Baleares. Scipio riding out to the companies and battalions, pointed out to them, that "the enemy having abandoned, beforehand, all hope of being able to withstand them on level ground, had resorted to hills: where they stood in view, relying on the strength of their position, and not on their valour and arms." But the walls of Carthage, which the Roman soldiers had scaled, were still higher. That neither hills, nor a citadel, nor even the sea itself, had formed an impediment to their arms. That the heights which the enemy had occupied would only have the effect of making it necessary for them to leap down crags and precipices in their flight, but he would even cut off that kind of retreat. He accordingly gave orders to two cohorts, that one of them should occupy the entrance of the valley down which the river ran, and that the other should block up the road which led from the city into the country, over the side of the hill. He himself led the light troops, which the day before had driven in the advanced guard of the enemy, against the light-armed troops which were stationed on the lower ridge. At first they marched through rugged ground, impeded by nothing except the road; afterwards, when they came within reach of the darts, an immense quantity of weapons of every description was showered upon them; while on their part, not only the soldiers, but a multitude of servants mingled with the troops, threw stones furnished by the place, which were spread about in every part, and for the most part convenient as missiles. But though the ascent was difficult, and they were almost overwhelmed with stones and darts, yet from their practice in approaching walls and their inflexibility of mind, the foremost succeeded in getting up. These, as soon as they got upon some level ground and could stand with firm footing, compelled the enemy, who were light-armed troops adapted for skirmishing, and could defend themselves at a distance, where an elusive kind of fight is carried on by the discharge of missiles, but yet wanted steadiness for a close action, to fly from their position; and, killing a great many, drove them to the troops which stood above them on the higher eminence. Upon this Seipio, having ordered the victorious troops to mount up and attack the centre of the enemy, divided the rest of his forces with Laelius; whom he directed to go round the hill to the right till he could find a way of easier ascent, while he himself, making a small circuit to the left, charged the enemy in flank. In consequence of this their line was first thrown into confusion, while they endeavoured to wheel round and face about their ranks towards the shouts which resounded from every quarter around them. During this confusion Laelius also came up, and while the enemy were retreating, that they might not be exposed to wounds from behind, their front line became disjoined, and a space was left for the Roman centre to mount up; who, from the disadvantage of the ground, never could have done so had their ranks stood unbroken with the elephants stationed in front. While the troops of the enemy were being slain on all sides, Scipio, who with his left wing had charged the right of the enemy, was chiefly employed in attacking their naked flank. And now there was not even room to fly; for parties of the Roman troops had blocked up the roads on both sides, right and left, and the gate of the camp was closed by the flight of the general and principal officers; added to which was the fright of the elephants, who, when in consternation, were as much feared by them as the enemy were. There were, therefore, slain as many as eight thousand men.

The army of Hasdrubal, which was the closest of the Carthaginian forces, was camped near the city of Baecula. In front of his camp, he had cavalry outposts. The light infantry, those who fought in front of the standards, and the vanguard, as they approached from their march and before they set up their camp, launched an attack with such arrogance that it was clear how much spirit each side had. The cavalry were driven back into their camp in disarray, and the Roman standards were advanced almost to their gates. That day, the Romans were fired up for battle, so they made their camp. At night, Hasdrubal moved his troops to a raised area, with a flat plain at the top. A river lay behind them, and in front and on either side were steep banks that completely surrounded the area. Below this was another flat plain that sloped gently, also encircled by a similar ridge that was hard to climb. The next day, when Hasdrubal saw the enemy troops arranged before their camp, he sent in his Numidian cavalry and the light-armed troops from the Balearic Islands. Scipio rode out to the companies and battalions and pointed out that "the enemy, having lost hope of being able to hold their ground on flat terrain, had taken to the hills: they stood visible, relying on their advantageous position rather than their bravery and arms." But the walls of Carthage, which the Roman soldiers had climbed, were even higher. Neither hills, nor a stronghold, nor even the sea had posed an obstacle to their forces. The heights occupied by the enemy would only force them to leap down cliffs and steep slopes in their retreat, and he intended to cut off that option. He therefore ordered two cohorts, one to secure the entrance of the valley where the river flowed, and the other to block the road leading from the city into the countryside, over the side of the hill. He himself led the light troops, who had driven back the enemy's advance guard the day before, against the light-armed soldiers stationed on the lower ridge. Initially, they moved through rough terrain, hindered only by the road; then, when they got within range of the darts, a huge barrage of weapons of all kinds was launched at them. On their part, not only the soldiers but also a crowd of attendants mingled with the troops, throwing stones easily found in the area, which were particularly suitable as projectiles. Despite the challenging ascent and being nearly overwhelmed with stones and darts, their experience in scaling walls and their unyielding mentality allowed the first ones to make it up. Once they reached some level ground where they could stand firm, they forced the enemy, who were light troops suited for skirmishing and able to fend off attacks from a distance but lacking the stability needed for close combat, to flee from their position; they killed many and drove them toward the troops stationed above on the higher ground. Following this, Scipio ordered the victorious troops to push up and attack the center of the enemy, while he divided the rest of his forces with Laelius, whom he instructed to find an easier ascent route around the hill to the right, while he himself made a slight detour to the left to flank the enemy. As a result, their line was thrown into disarray as they tried to turn and face the shouts coming from all around them. During this confusion, Laelius arrived as well, and as the enemy retreated to avoid being hit from behind, their front line became separated, allowing the Roman center to advance; they would not have been able to do so had the enemy's ranks remained intact with the elephants in front. As the enemy troops fell on all sides, Scipio, who had charged the enemy's right flank with his left wing, focused on attacking their exposed sides. There was no room left to escape; Roman troops had blocked the roads on both sides, right and left, and the gate of the camp was closed due to the general and leading officers fleeing, compounded by the panic of the elephants, who, when frightened, were as feared by their own troops as the enemy. Consequently, as many as eight thousand men were killed.

19

Hasdrubal, having seized upon the treasure before he engaged, now sent the elephants in advance, and collecting as many of the flying troops as he could, directed his course along the river Tagus to the Pyrenees. Scipio, having got possession of the enemy's camp, and giving up all the booty to the soldiers, except the persons of free condition, found, on counting the prisoners, ten thousand foot and two thousand horse. Of these, all who were Spaniards he sent home without ransom; the Africans he ordered the quaestor to sell. After this, a multitude of Spaniards, consisting of those who had surrendered to him before and those whom he had captured the preceding day, crowding around, one and all saluted him as king; when Scipio, after the herald had obtained silence, declared that "in his estimation the most honourable title was that of general, which his soldiers had conferred upon him. That the name of king, which was in other countries revered, could not be endured at Rome. That they might tacitly consider his spirit as kingly, if they thought that the highest excellence which could be attributed to the human mind, but that they must abstain from the use of the term." Even barbarians were sensible of the greatness of mind which could from such an elevation despise a name, at the greatness of which the rest of mankind were overawed. Presents were then distributed to the petty princes and leading men of the Spaniards, and out of the great quantity of horses which were captured, he desired Indibilis to select those he liked best to the number of three hundred. While the quaestor was selling the Africans, according to the command of the general, he found among them a full-grown youth remarkably handsome; and hearing that he was of royal blood, he sent him to Scipio. On being asked by Scipio "who he was, of what country, and why at that age he was in the camp?" he replied, "that he was a Numidian, that his countrymen called him Massiva; that being left an orphan by his father, he was educated by his maternal grandfather, Gala, the king of the Numidians. That he had passed over into Spain with his uncle Masinissa, who had lately come with a body of cavalry to assist the Carthaginians. That having been prohibited by Masinissa on account of his youth, he had never before been in battle. That the day on which the battle took place with the Romans, he had clandestinely taken a horse and arms, and, without the knowledge of his uncle, gone out into the field, where his horse falling forward, he was thrown headlong, and taken prisoner by the Romans." Scipio, having ordered that the Numidian should be taken care of, completed the business which remained to be done on the tribunal, and returning to his pavilion, asked him, when he had been called to him, whether he wished to return to Masinissa? Upon his replying, with tears of joy, that he did indeed desire it, he presented the youth with a gold ring, a vest with a broad purple border, a Spanish cloak with a gold clasp, and a horse completely caparisoned, and then dismissed him, ordering a party of horse to escort him as far as he chose.

Hasdrubal, having taken the treasure before engaging in battle, sent the elephants ahead and gathered as many of the fleeing troops as he could, making his way along the Tagus River to the Pyrenees. Scipio, having captured the enemy's camp and giving all the loot to the soldiers—except for free individuals—counted the prisoners and found ten thousand infantry and two thousand cavalry. He sent all the Spaniards home without asking for ransom; the African prisoners, he directed the quaestor to sell. After this, a crowd of Spaniards, made up of those who had surrendered to him earlier and those captured the day before, gathered around and greeted him as king. Scipio, once the herald had called for silence, stated that "the most honorable title in his eyes was general, a name his soldiers had given him. The title of king, which is respected in other lands, could not be tolerated in Rome. They could privately see his spirit as kingly if they believed it was the highest compliment for a human mind, but they must refrain from using the term." Even those from barbaric tribes recognized the greatness of spirit that could dismiss a title that others found intimidating. Gifts were then given to the minor princes and leaders of the Spaniards, and from the large number of captured horses, he asked Indibilis to pick three hundred that he liked the most. While the quaestor was selling the African prisoners as ordered by the general, he found a remarkably handsome young man among them; learning that he was of royal descent, he sent him to Scipio. When Scipio asked him "who he was, where he was from, and why he was at the camp at his age?" he replied, "I’m a Numidian, my countrymen call me Massiva; after being left an orphan, I was raised by my maternal grandfather, Gala, the king of the Numidians. I came to Spain with my uncle Masinissa, who recently arrived with a cavalry unit to assist the Carthaginians. Masinissa had forbidden me to fight because of my youth, so I had never been in battle before. On the day of the battle against the Romans, I secretly took a horse and arms and, without my uncle's knowledge, went out to the field, where my horse stumbled and I was thrown off, leading to my capture by the Romans." Scipio ordered that the Numidian be taken care of, finished the remaining business at the tribunal, and, returning to his tent, asked him if he wanted to go back to Masinissa. When he answered, with tears of joy, that he did indeed, Scipio gave the young man a gold ring, a vest with a wide purple trim, a Spanish cloak with a gold clasp, and a fully equipped horse, then dismissed him, ordering a cavalry unit to escort him wherever he wished.

20

A council was then held respecting the war; when some advised that he should endeavour to overtake Hasdrubal forthwith. But thinking that hazardous, lest Mago and the other Hasdrubal should unite their forces with his, he sent a body of troops to occupy the pass of the Pyrenees, and employed the remainder of the summer in receiving the states of Spain into his alliance. A few days after the battle of Baecula, when Scipio on his return to Tarraco had now cleared the pass of Castulo, the generals, Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, and Mago came from the farther Spain and joined Hasdrubal; a late assistance after the defeat he had sustained, though their arrival was somewhat seasonable, for counsel with respect to the further prosecution of the war. They then consulted together as to what was the feeling of the Spaniards in the quarters where their several provinces were situated, when Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, alone gave it as his opinion, that the remotest tract of Spain which borders on the ocean and Gades, was, as yet, unacquainted with the Romans, and might therefore be somewhat friendly to the Carthaginians. Between the other Hasdrubal and Mago it was agreed, that "Scipio by his good offices had gained the affections of all, both publicly and privately; and that there would be no end of desertions till all the Spanish soldiers were removed to the remotest parts of Spain, or were marched over into Gaul. That, therefore, though the Carthaginian senate had not decreed it, Hasdrubal must, nevertheless, march into Italy, the principal seat and object of the war; and thus at the same time lead away all the Spanish soldiers out of Spain far from the name of Scipio. That the army, which had been diminished by desertions and defeats, should be recruited by Spanish soldiers. That Mago, having delivered over his army to Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, should himself pass over to the Baleares with a large sum of money to hire auxiliaries; that Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, should retire with the army into the remotest part of Lusitania, and avoid an encounter with the Romans. That a body of three thousand horse should be made up for Masinissa, the flower of the whole cavalry; and that he, shifting about from place to place throughout hither Spain should succour their allies and commit depredations on the towns and lands of their enemies." Having adopted these resolutions, the generals departed to put in execution what they had resolved on. Such were the transactions in Spain of this year. At Rome the reputation of Scipio increased daily. The capture of Tarentum, though effected by artifice more than valour, was considered honourable to Fabius. The fame of Fulvius was on the wane. Marcellus was even under an ill report, not only because he had failed in his first battle, but further, because while Hannibal was going wherever he pleased throughout Italy, he had led his troops to Venusia in the midst of summer to lodge in houses. Caius Publicius Bibulus, a tribune of the people, was hostile to him. This man, ever since the time of his first battle which had failed, had in constant harangues made Claudius obnoxious and odious to the people; and now his object was to deprive him of his command. The connexions of Marcellus, however, then obtained leave that Marcellus, leaving a lieutenant-general at Venusia, should return to Rome to clear himself of the charges which his enemies were urging, and that the question of depriving him of his command should not be agitated during his absence. It happened that nearly at the same time, Marcellus, and Quintius Fulvius the consul, came to Rome, the former to exonerate himself from ignominy, the latter on account of the elections.

A council was held regarding the war, where some suggested that he should try to catch up with Hasdrubal immediately. However, considering it too risky, fearing that Mago and the other Hasdrubal would join forces with him, he sent a group of troops to take control of the Pyrenees pass. He spent the rest of the summer securing alliances with the states of Spain. A few days after the battle of Baecula, when Scipio was returning to Tarraco and had cleared the Castulo pass, the generals Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, and Mago came from further Spain to join Hasdrubal; their help came too late after his defeat, but it was still timely for discussing the next steps in the war. They talked about the sentiments of the Spaniards in their provinces, and Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, suggested that the farthest region of Spain near the ocean and Gades was still unfamiliar with the Romans and could be somewhat friendly to the Carthaginians. It was agreed between the other Hasdrubal and Mago that Scipio, through his good deeds, had won the loyalty of everyone, both publicly and privately, and that desertions would continue until all the Spanish soldiers were either sent far away within Spain or moved into Gaul. Therefore, even though the Carthaginian senate hadn't ordered it, Hasdrubal had to march into Italy, the main focus of the war, while also leading all the Spanish soldiers away from Scipio. The army, which had shrunk due to desertions and defeats, needed to be replenished with Spanish soldiers. Mago would hand over his army to Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, and then go to the Baleares with a large sum of money to hire reinforcements. Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, would retreat with the army to the most distant part of Lusitania and avoid a confrontation with the Romans. A cavalry unit of three thousand horsemen would be formed for Masinissa, the best of the cavalry, and he would move around Spain, supporting their allies and raiding enemy towns and lands. After making these plans, the generals left to implement their decisions. These were the events in Spain that year. In Rome, Scipio's reputation continued to rise. The capture of Tarentum, achieved more through cunning than bravery, was deemed an honor for Fabius. Fulvius's reputation was fading. Marcellus was under scrutiny, not just for losing his first battle, but also because while Hannibal roamed freely in Italy, he had led his troops to Venusia to stay in houses during the summer. Caius Publicius Bibulus, a tribune of the people, opposed him. Ever since Marcellus's unsuccessful battle, Bibulus had been making Claudius look bad to the public, aiming to strip him of his command. Marcellus's allies eventually arranged for him to leave a lieutenant-general at Venusia and go to Rome to defend himself against the accusations, ensuring that the issue of his command wouldn't be raised while he was away. Coincidentally, around the same time, Marcellus and Quintius Fulvius the consul arrived in Rome, the former to clear his name and the latter for the elections.

21

The question touching Marcellus's command was debated in the Flaminian circus, in the presence of an immense concourse of plebeians and persons of every rank. The plebeian tribune accused, not only Marcellus, but the nobility generally. "It was owing," he said, "to their dishonesty and dilatory conduct, that Hannibal occupied Italy, as though it were his province, for now ten years; that he had passed more of his life there than at Carthage. That the Roman people were enjoying the fruits of the prolonged command of Marcellus; that his army, after having been twice defeated, was now spending the summer at Venusia lodged in houses." Marcellus so completely destroyed the effect of this harangue of the tribune, by the recital of the services he had rendered, that not only the bill for depriving him of his command was thrown out, but the following day he was created consul by the votes of all the centuries with wonderful unanimity. Titus Quinctius Crispinus, who was then praetor, was joined with him as his colleague. The next day Publius Licinius Crassus Dives, then chief pontiff, Publius Licinius Varus, Sextus Julius Caesar, and Quintus Claudius Flamen were created praetors. At the very time of the election, the public were thrown into a state of anxiety relative to the defection of Etruria. Caius Calpurnius, who held that province as propraetor, had written word that the Arretians had originated such a scheme. Accordingly Marcellus, consul elect, was immediately sent thither to look into the affair, and if it should appear to him of sufficient consequence, to send for his army and transfer the war from Apulia to Etruria. The Tuscans, checked by the alarm thus occasioned, desisted. To the ambassadors of Tarentum, who solicited a treaty of peace securing to them their liberty and the enjoyment of their own laws, the senate answered, that they might return when the consul Fabius came to Rome. The Roman and plebeian games were this year repeated each for one day. The curule aediles were, Lucius Cornelius Caudinus and Servius Sulpicius Galba; the plebeian aediles, Caius Servilius and Quintus Caecilius Metellus. It was asserted that Servilius was not qualified to be plebeian tribune or aedile, because it was satisfactorily established that his father, who, for ten years, was supposed to have been killed by the Boii in the neighbourhood of Mutina, when acting as triumvir for the distribution of lands, was alive and in the hands of the enemy.

The question about Marcellus's command was debated in the Flaminian circus, in front of a huge crowd of common people and individuals from all ranks. The plebeian tribune accused not only Marcellus but the nobility as a whole. "It's because of their dishonesty and delay," he said, "that Hannibal has been treating Italy like it’s his own territory for the last ten years; he has spent more time there than in Carthage. The Roman people are enjoying the benefits of Marcellus's extended command; his army, after being defeated twice, is now spending the summer at Venusia, staying in houses." Marcellus completely countered this speech by highlighting the services he had provided, so not only was the proposal to strip him of his command rejected, but the next day he was elected consul by unanimous votes from all the centuries. Titus Quinctius Crispinus, who was then praetor, was appointed as his colleague. The following day, Publius Licinius Crassus Dives, the chief pontiff at the time, along with Publius Licinius Varus, Sextus Julius Caesar, and Quintus Claudius Flamen, were appointed praetors. At the time of the election, the public was anxious about a potential defection in Etruria. Caius Calpurnius, who was overseeing that province as propraetor, reported that the Arretians were behind a troubling scheme. As a result, Marcellus, who was elected consul, was immediately dispatched to investigate the situation, and if it seemed serious enough, to call in his army and shift the war from Apulia to Etruria. The Tuscans, alarmed by this development, backed down. To the ambassadors from Tarentum, who requested a peace treaty that would ensure their freedom and the right to govern themselves, the senate responded that they could return when consul Fabius came to Rome. The Roman and plebeian games were held again this year, each lasting one day. The curule aediles were Lucius Cornelius Caudinus and Servius Sulpicius Galba; the plebeian aediles were Caius Servilius and Quintus Caecilius Metellus. It was claimed that Servilius was unqualified to be a plebeian tribune or aedile because it was proven that his father, who had supposedly been killed by the Boii near Mutina while acting as a triumvir for land distribution, was actually alive and in enemy hands.

22

In the eleventh year of the Punic war, Marcus Marcellus, for the fifth time, reckoning in the consulate in which he did not act in consequence of an informality in his creation, and Titus Quinctius Crispinus entered upon the office of consuls. To both the consuls the province of Italy was decreed, with both the consular armies of the former year; (the third was then at Venusia, being that which Marcus Marcellus had commanded.) That out of the three armies the consuls might, choose whichever two they liked, and that the third should be delivered to him to whose lot the province of Tarentum and the territory of Sallentum fell. The other provinces were thus distributed among the praetors: Publius Licinius Varus had the city jurisdiction, Publius Licinius Crassus, chief pontiff, the foreign, and wherever the senate though proper. Sextus Julius Caesar had Sicily, and Quintus Claudius Flamen, Tarentum. Quintus Fulvius Flaccus was to continue in command for a year, and hold the province of Capua, which had been held by Titus Quinctius, with one legion. Caius Hostilius Tubulus was also continued in command, with orders to go into Etruria, in the capacity of propraetor, and succeed Caius Calpurnius in the command of the two legions there. Lucius Veturius Philo was also continued in command, to hold in the capacity of propraetor the same province of Gaul with the same two legions with which he had held it as praetor. The senate decreed the same with respect to Caius Aurunculeius, who, as praetor, had held the province of Sardinia with two legions, which it did in the case of Lucius Veturius, and the question of the continuation of his command was proposed to the people. He had in addition, for the protection of the province, fifty ships which Publius Scipio had sent from Spain. To Publius Scipio and Marcus Silanus, their present province of Spain and their present armies were assigned. Of the eighty ships which he had with him, some taken from Italy and others captured at Carthage, Scipio was ordered to send fifty to Sardinia, in consequence of a report that great naval preparations were making at Carthage that year; and that the intention of the Carthaginians was to blockade the whole coasts of Italy, Sicily, and Sardinia with two hundred ships. In Sicily also the following distribution was made: to Sextus Caesar the troops of Cannae were assigned; Marcus Valerius Laevinus, who was also continued in command, was to have the fleet of seventy ships which was at Sicily, adding to it the thirty ships which the preceding year were stationed at Tarentum. With this fleet of a hundred ships he was ordered to pass over into Africa, if he thought proper, and collect booty. Publius Sulpicius was also continued in command for a year, to hold the province of Macedonia and Greece, with the same fleet. No alteration was made with regard to the two legions which were at Rome. Permission was given to the consuls to enlist as many troops as were necessary to complete the numbers. This year the Roman empire was defended by twenty-one legions. Publius Licinius Varus, the city praetor, was also commissioned to repair the thirty old men of war which lay at Ostia, and to man twenty new ones with full complements, in order that he might defend the sea-coast in the neighbourhood hood of Rome with a fleet of fifty ships. Caius Calpurnius was ordered not to move his army from Arretium till his successor had arrived. Both he and Tubulus were ordered to be particularly careful, lest any new plots should be formed in that quarter.

In the eleventh year of the Punic War, Marcus Marcellus, for the fifth time—counting the consulate during which he didn’t serve due to an issue with his appointment—and Titus Quinctius Crispinus took up the position of consuls. Both consuls were assigned the province of Italy, along with the two consular armies from the previous year; the third was stationed at Venusia, commanded by Marcus Marcellus. The consuls were to choose any two from the three armies, while the third was assigned to whoever was designated for the province of Tarentum and the territory of Sallentum. The other provinces were allocated among the praetors: Publius Licinius Varus handled city jurisdiction, Publius Licinius Crassus, the chief pontiff, managed foreign matters, and other areas deemed appropriate by the senate. Sextus Julius Caesar was given Sicily, and Quintus Claudius Flamen took on Tarentum. Quintus Fulvius Flaccus would continue for a year in command of the province of Capua, which had previously been led by Titus Quinctius, with one legion. Caius Hostilius Tubulus was also kept in charge, ordered to head to Etruria as propraetor and take over from Caius Calpurnius in command of the two legions stationed there. Lucius Veturius Philo also remained in command as propraetor in the same Gaul province with the same two legions he had previously commanded as praetor. The senate made a similar decision regarding Caius Aurunculeius, who had also held the province of Sardinia with two legions, and the matter of extending his command was put before the people. Furthermore, he had fifty ships for the province's protection, which Publius Scipio had sent from Spain. Publius Scipio and Marcus Silanus were assigned their current province of Spain and their existing armies. Out of the eighty ships Scipio had—with some from Italy and others captured at Carthage—he was ordered to send fifty to Sardinia due to reports of significant naval preparations in Carthage that year, as the Carthaginians intended to blockade the entire coasts of Italy, Sicily, and Sardinia with two hundred ships. In Sicily, the following allocations were made: Sextus Caesar was assigned the troops from Cannae; Marcus Valerius Laevinus, who also continued in command, was to have the fleet of seventy ships based in Sicily, in addition to the thirty ships that had been stationed at Tarentum the previous year. With this fleet of a hundred ships, he was ordered to possibly sail over to Africa and gather plunder. Publius Sulpicius was also extended in command for a year to oversee the province of Macedonia and Greece with the same fleet. There were no changes regarding the two legions in Rome. The consuls were authorized to recruit as many troops as necessary to reach the required numbers. That year, the Roman Empire was defended by twenty-one legions. Publius Licinius Varus, the city praetor, was also tasked with repairing thirty old warships at Ostia and manning twenty new ones to establish a fleet of fifty ships for the defense of the coastline near Rome. Caius Calpurnius was instructed not to move his army from Arretium until his successor had arrived, and both he and Tubulus were directed to be especially vigilant to prevent any new schemes from arising in that area.

23

The praetors set out for their provinces. The consul were detained by religious affairs; for receiving intelligence of several prodigies, they could not easily obtain a favourable appearance from the victims. It was reported from Campania, that two temples, those of Fortune and Mars, and several sepulchres, had been struck by lightning. From Cumae, so does superstition connect the deities with the most trifling circumstances, that mice had gnawed some gold in the temple of Jupiter. That an immense swarm of bees had settled in the forum at Casinum. That at Ostia a wall and gate had been struck by lightning. At Caere, that a vulture had flown into the temple of Jupiter. That blood had flowed from a lake at Volsinii. On account of these prodigies, a supplication was performed for one day. For several days, victims of the larger kind were sacrificed without any favourable appearance, and for a long time the good will of the gods could not be obtained. The fatal event indicated by these portents pointed to the persons of the consuls, the state being unaffected. The Apollinarian games were first celebrated by Publius Cornelius Sulla, the city praetor, in the consulate of Quintus Fulvius and Appius Claudius; from that time all the city praetors in succession had performed them; but they vowed them for one year only, and fixed no day for their performance. This year a grievous pestilence attacked the city and the country; it showed itself, however, in protracted rather than fatal diseases. On account of this pestilence supplication was performed in every street throughout the city; and Publius Licinius Varus, the city praetor, was ordered to propose to the people a law to the effect, that a vow should be made to perform these games on a stated day for ever. He himself was the first who vowed them in this manner, and he celebrated them on the third day of the nones of July, a day which was henceforth kept sacred.

The praetors left for their provinces. The consuls were held up by religious matters; after getting word of several omens, they struggled to get a favorable sign from the victims. Reports came from Campania that two temples—those of Fortune and Mars—along with several tombs, had been struck by lightning. From Cumae, superstition linked the gods to the most trivial events, like mice gnawing some gold in the temple of Jupiter. An enormous swarm of bees had settled in the forum at Casinum, and in Ostia, a wall and gate had been hit by lightning. In Caere, a vulture flew into the temple of Jupiter, and at Volsinii, blood flowed from a lake. Due to these omens, a day of supplication was held. For several days, large victims were sacrificed without any favorable sign, and for a long time, the goodwill of the gods could not be won. The ominous events indicated something dire regarding the consuls, though the state itself remained unharmed. The Apollinarian games were first celebrated by Publius Cornelius Sulla, the city praetor, during the consulate of Quintus Fulvius and Appius Claudius; since then, all succeeding city praetors held them, but they vowed to do so for only one year and did not set a specific day for the events. This year, a severe plague struck the city and the countryside; however, it manifested more in prolonged rather than deadly illnesses. Because of this plague, supplication took place in every street across the city, and Publius Licinius Varus, the city praetor, was tasked with proposing a law to the people that a vow be made to hold these games on a designated day forever. He personally was the first to vow them in this manner, and he celebrated them on the third day of the nones of July, a day that has since been kept sacred.

24

The reports respecting the people of Arretium became daily more serious, and the anxiety of the fathers increased. A letter was therefore written to Caius Hostilius, directing him not to delay taking hostages from that people; and Caius Terentius Varro was sent, with a command, to receive from him the hostages and convey them to Rome. On his arrival, Hostilius immediately ordered one legion, which was encamped before the city, to march into it; and having posted guards in suitable places, he summoned the senate into the forum and demanded hostages of them. On the senate's requesting a delay of two days to consider the matter, he declared that they must themselves give them forthwith, or he would the next day take all the children of the senators. After this the military tribunes, the praefects of the allies, and the centurions, were ordered to keep watch at the gates, that no one might go out by night. This duty was not performed with sufficient care and attention, for seven of the principal senators, with their children, escaped before night, and before the guards were posted at the gates. The next day, as soon as it was light, the senate began to be summoned into the forum, when they were missed and their goods were sold. From the rest of the senators one hundred and twenty hostages, consisting of their own children, were taken and delivered over to Caius Terentius to be conveyed to Rome. Before the senate he made every thing more suspected than before. Considering, therefore, that there was imminent danger of a commotion in Tuscany, they ordered Caius Terentius himself to lead one of the city legions to Arretium, and to employ it for the protection of the city. It was also resolved, that Caius Hostilius, with the other army, should traverse the whole province, and use precautions, that no opportunity might be afforded to those who were desirous of altering the state of things. On his arrival at Arretium with the legion, Terentius asked the magistrates for the keys of the gates, when they declared they could not be found; but he, believing that they had been put out of the way with some bad intention rather than lost through negligence, took upon himself to have fresh locks put upon all the gates, and used diligent care to keep every thing in his own power. He earnestly cautioned Hostilius to rest his hope in this; that the Tuscans would remain quiet, if he should take care that not a step could be taken.

The reports about the people of Arretium became more serious every day, and the concern of the leaders grew. So, a letter was sent to Caius Hostilius, instructing him not to delay in taking hostages from that community; Caius Terentius Varro was dispatched with orders to receive the hostages from him and bring them to Rome. Upon his arrival, Hostilius immediately ordered one legion, which was camped outside the city, to march in; after positioning guards in appropriate locations, he called the senate to the forum and demanded hostages from them. When the senate asked for two days to think it over, he declared that they had to provide hostages immediately, or he would take all the children of the senators the next day. Following this, the military tribunes, the prefects of the allies, and the centurions were instructed to monitor the gates to ensure no one could leave at night. This duty was not carried out with enough diligence, as seven of the leading senators, along with their children, managed to escape before nightfall and before the guards were set at the gates. The next day, as soon as it was light, the senate began to be summoned to the forum, and they were soon missed, with their belongings sold. From the remaining senators, one hundred and twenty hostages, consisting of their own children, were taken and handed over to Caius Terentius to be transported to Rome. Before the senate, he raised more suspicion than before. Considering that there was a real risk of unrest in Tuscany, they ordered Caius Terentius himself to lead one of the city legions to Arretium to protect the city. It was also decided that Caius Hostilius, with the other army, should patrol the entire province and take precautions to prevent any chance for those wanting to change things. Upon his arrival in Arretium with the legion, Terentius asked the magistrates for the keys to the gates, but they claimed they could not be found. However, he believed they had been hidden with bad intent rather than lost through carelessness, so he decided to have new locks put on all the gates and worked diligently to keep everything under his control. He strongly advised Hostilius to place his hopes in this: that the Tuscans would remain calm if he ensured no one could make a move.

25

The case of the Tarentines was then warmly debated in the senate, Fabius being present, and himself defending those whom he had subdued by force of arms, while others entertained an angry feeling towards them; the greater part comparing them with the Campanians in guilt and punishment. A decree of the senate was passed conformably to the opinion of Manius Acilius, that the town should be guarded by a garrison, and that all the Tarentines should be kept within their walls; and further, that the question touching their conduct should be hereafter laid before the senate afresh when the state of Italy should be more tranquil. The case of Marcus Livius, praefect of the citadel of Tarentum, was also debated with no less warmth; some proposing a vote of censure against the praefect on the ground that Tarentum was betrayed to the enemy through his negligence, others proposing rewards for having defended the citadel for five years, and because Tarentum had been recovered chiefly by his single efforts; while some, adopting an intermediate course, declared that it appertained to the censors, and not to the senate, to take cognizance of his case; and of this latter opinion was Fabius, who added, however, "that he admitted that the recovery of Tarentum was owing to the efforts of Livius, as his friends openly boasted in the senate, but that there would have been no necessity for its recovery, had it not been lost." One of the consuls, Titus Quinctius Crispinus, set out for Lucania, with some troops to make up the numbers, to take the command of the army which had served under Quintus Fulvius Flaccus. Marcellus was detained by a succession of religious scruples, which presented themselves to his mind. One of which was, that when in the Gallic war at Clastidium he had vowed a temple to Honour and Valour, its dedication was impeded by the pontiffs, who said, that one shrine could not with propriety be dedicated to two deities; because if it should be struck with lightning or any kind of portent should happen in it, the expiation would be attended with difficulty as it could not be ascertained to which deity sacrifice ought to be made; nor could one victim be lawfully offered to two deities, unless in particular cases. Accordingly another temple to Virtue was erected with all speed. Nevertheless, these temples were not dedicated by Marcellus himself. Then at length he set out, with the troops raised to fill up the numbers, to the army he had left the preceding year at Venusia. Crispinus, who endeavoured to reduce Locri in Bruttium by a siege, because he considered that the affair of Tarentum had added greatly to the fame of Fabius, had sent for every kind of engine and machine from Sicily; he also sent for ships from the same place to attack that part of the city which lay towards the sea. But this siege was raised by Hannibal's bringing his forces to Lacinium, and in consequence of a report, that his colleague, with whom he wished to effect a junction, had now led his army from Venusia. He therefore returned from Bruttium into Apulia, and the consuls took up a position in two separate camps, distant from each other less than three miles, between Venusia and Bantia. Hannibal, after diverting the war from Locri, returned also into the same quarter. Here the consuls, who were both of sanguine temperament, almost daily went out and drew up their troops for action, confidently hoping, that if the enemy would hazard an engagement with two consular armies united, they might put an end to the war.

The situation with the Tarentines was hotly debated in the senate, with Fabius present, defending those he had defeated by force while others felt angry towards them; most compared their guilt and punishment to that of the Campanians. A decree was passed in line with Manius Acilius's opinion, stating that the town should be guarded by a garrison and that all Tarentines should remain within their walls. Additionally, the issue of their behavior would be reconsidered by the senate when Italy was more at peace. The case of Marcus Livius, the commander of the Tarentum citadel, was also discussed passionately. Some proposed a vote of censure against him for allowing Tarentum to fall to the enemy through negligence, while others recommended rewards for defending the citadel for five years and for mainly recovering Tarentum through his efforts. Some took a middle ground, saying it was up to the censors, not the senate, to handle his case; Fabius agreed with this but noted that while Livius deserved credit for the recovery of Tarentum, it wouldn't have needed to be recaptured if it hadn't been lost in the first place. One of the consuls, Titus Quinctius Crispinus, left for Lucania with some troops to take command of the army that had served under Quintus Fulvius Flaccus. Marcellus was held back by various religious concerns, one of which was that during the Gallic war at Clastidium, he had vowed a temple to Honour and Valour, but its dedication had been stalled by the pontiffs, who said that you can't dedicate one shrine to two deities. If the shrine were to be struck by lightning or something unusual happened, it would be complicated to determine which deity should receive a sacrifice, and you can't lawfully offer one victim to two gods unless under special circumstances. Therefore, another temple to Virtue was quickly constructed. However, Marcellus himself did not dedicate these temples. Eventually, he set out with the troops called up to fill the ranks to join the army he had left the previous year at Venusia. Crispinus, attempting to lay siege to Locri in Bruttium, thought that the recent events in Tarentum had greatly enhanced Fabius's reputation, so he called for all sorts of machinery and equipment from Sicily and also requested ships to attack the coastal part of the city. However, Hannibal lifted the siege by bringing his forces to Lacinium, following reports that his colleague, with whom he planned to unite, had moved his army from Venusia. He then returned from Bruttium to Apulia, and the consuls set up camp in two separate locations less than three miles apart, between Venusia and Bantia. After shifting the war away from Locri, Hannibal also returned to that area. Here, the consuls, both eager for action, nearly daily went out and organized their troops for battle, confidently hoping that if the enemy dared to engage with two united consular armies, they could end the war.

26

As Hannibal, who gained one and lost the other of the two battles which he fought the preceding year with Marcellus, would have equal grounds for hope and fear, should he encounter the same general again; so was he far from thinking himself a match for the two consuls together. Directing his attention, therefore, wholly to his own peculiar arts, he looked out for an opportunity for planting an ambuscade. Slight battles, however, were fought between the two camps with varying success. But the consuls, thinking it probable that the summer would be spun out in engagements of this kind, and being of opinion that the siege of Locri might be going on notwithstanding, wrote to Lucius Cincius to pass over to Locri with his fleet from Sicily. And that the walls might be besieged by land also, they ordered one half of the army, which formed the garrison of Tarentum, to be marched thither. Hannibal having found from certain Thurians that these things would be done, sent a body of troops to lie in ambush on the road leading from Tarentum. There, under the hill of Petelia, three thousand cavalry and two thousand foot were placed in concealment. The Romans, who proceeded without exploring their way, having fallen into the ambuscade, as many as two thousand soldiers were slain, and about twelve hundred made prisoners. The others, who were scattered in flight through the fields and forests, returned to Tarentum. There was a rising ground covered with wood situated between the Punic and Roman camps, which was occupied at first by neither party, because the Romans were unacquainted with its nature on that side which faced the enemy's camp, while Hannibal had supposed it better adapted for an ambuscade than a camp. Accordingly, he had sent thither, by night, several troops of Numidians, concealing them in the midst of the wood. Not one of them stirred from his position by day, lest their arms or themselves should be observed from a distance. There was a general murmur in the Roman camp, that this eminence ought to be occupied and secured by a fort, lest if it should be seized by Hannibal they should have the enemy, as it were, immediately over their heads. Marcellus was moved by this consideration, and observed to his colleague, "Why not go ourselves with a few horsemen and reconnoitre? The matter being examined with our own eyes, will make our measures more certain." Crispinus consenting, they set out with two hundred and twenty horsemen, of which forty were Fregellans, the rest Tuscans. Marcus Marcellus, the consul's son, and Aulus Manlius, military tribunes, together with two prefects of the allies, Lucius Arennius and Manius Aulius, accompanied them. Some historians have recorded, that Marcellus had offered sacrifices on that day, and that in the first victim slain, the liver was found without its head; in the second, that all the usual parts were present, and that there was also an excrescence in the head. That the aruspex was not, indeed, pleased that the entrails should first have appeared mutilated and foul, and then too exuberant.

As Hannibal, who won one battle and lost another against Marcellus the previous year, had both hope and fear about facing the same general again, he certainly didn't think he could take on both consuls together. Therefore, he focused solely on his own unique strategies and looked for a chance to set up an ambush. There were minor skirmishes between the two camps with mixed results. The consuls, anticipating that the summer would likely continue with such engagements and believing that the siege of Locri might still be in progress, wrote to Lucius Cincius to sail from Sicily to Locri with his fleet. To also lay siege from land, they ordered half of the army stationed in Tarentum to march there. Hannibal learned from some Thurians that this was happening and sent troops to ambush the road leading from Tarentum. Under the hill of Petelia, he concealed three thousand cavalry and two thousand infantry. The Romans, advancing without scouting the area, fell into the ambush and lost around two thousand soldiers, with about twelve hundred taken prisoner. The rest, scattered in flight through the fields and forests, returned to Tarentum. A wooded hill sat between the Punic and Roman camps, initially unoccupied by either side, as the Romans were unfamiliar with its terrain toward the enemy's camp, while Hannibal thought it was better suited for an ambush than for a camp. Thus, he sent several troops of Numidians there at night, hiding them in the thick woods. None of them moved during the day to avoid being spotted. A general chatter in the Roman camp suggested that this high ground should be secured with a fort, fearing that if Hannibal took it, the enemy would effectively be right above them. Marcellus was concerned about this and said to his colleague, "Why not go ourselves with a few horsemen and scout it out? Seeing it with our own eyes will make our plans more reliable." Crispinus agreed, and they set out with two hundred and twenty horsemen, forty of whom were from Fregella and the rest from Tuscany. Accompanying them were Marcus Marcellus, the consul's son, Aulus Manlius, military tribunes, and two prefects of the allies, Lucius Arennius and Manius Aulius. Some historians have recorded that Marcellus had offered sacrifices that day, noting that in the first victim, the liver was found beheaded, while in the second, all the usual parts were intact but there was also an abnormal growth on the head. The augur was troubled that the entrails first appeared mutilated and foul, then too plentiful.

27

But the consul Marcellus was influenced by so ardent a desire of engaging with Hannibal, that he never thought their camps close enough. At that time also, as he quitted the rampart, he gave orders that the troops should be ready when occasion required, in order that if the hill, which they were going to examine, were thought convenient, they might collect their baggage and follow them. Before the camp there was a small plain; the road thence to the hill was open and exposed to view on all sides. A watchman who was stationed, not under the expectation of so important an event, but in order that they might be able to intercept any stragglers who had gone too far from the camp in search of wood or forage, gave a signal to the Numidians to rise simultaneously one and all from their concealment. Those who were to rise from the very summit of the hill, and meet the enemy, did not show themselves until those whose business it was to intercept their passage in the rear, had gone round. Then they all sprang up from every side, and, raising a shout, commenced an attack. Although the consuls were in such a position in the valley that they could neither make good their way up the hill, which was occupied by the enemy, nor retreat as they were intercepted in the rear, yet the contest might have been continued longer had not a retreat, commenced by the Tuscans, dismayed the rest of the troops. The Fregellans, however, did not give over fighting, though deserted by the Tuscans, while the consuls, uninjured, kept up the battle by encouraging their men and fighting themselves. But when they saw both the consuls wounded, and Marcellus transfixed with a lance and falling lifeless from his horse, then they too, and but a very few survived, betook themselves to flight, together with Crispinus the consul, who had received two javelin wounds, and young Marcellus, who was himself also wounded. Aulus Manlius, a military tribune, was slain, and of the two praefects of allies, Manius Aulius was slain, Lucius Arennius made prisoner. Five of the consul's lictors fell into the enemy's hands alive, the rest were either slain or fled with the consul. Forty-three horsemen fell in the battle or in the flight, and eighteen were taken alive. An alarm had been excited in the camp, and the troops were hastening to go and succour the consuls, when they saw one of the consuls and the son of the other wounded, and the scanty remains of this unfortunate expedition returning to the camp. The death of Marcellus was an event to be deplored, as well from other circumstances which attended it, as because that in a manner unbecoming his years, for he was then more than sixty, and inconsistently with the prudence of a veteran general, he had so improvidently plunged into ruin himself, his colleague, and almost the whole commonwealth. I should launch out into too many digressions for a single event, were I to relate all the various accounts which authors give respecting the death of Marcellus. To pass over others, Lucius Caelius gives three narratives ranged under different heads; one as it is handed down by tradition; a second, written in the panegyric of his son, who was engaged in the affair; a third, which he himself vouched for, being the result of his own investigation. The accounts, however, though varying in other points, agree for the most part in the fact, that he went out of the camp for the purpose of viewing the ground; and all state that he was cut off by an ambuscade.

But Consul Marcellus was driven by such a strong desire to confront Hannibal that he never thought the camps were close enough. At that time, after leaving the rampart, he ordered the troops to be ready when needed so that, if the hill they were about to check out seemed suitable, they could gather their gear and follow him. In front of the camp, there was a small plain; the path to the hill was open and visible from all sides. A watchman was stationed not in anticipation of such an important event but to intercept stragglers who had wandered too far from camp in search of wood or forage. He signaled the Numidians to rise simultaneously from their hiding spots. Those who were to come up from the very top of the hill and engage the enemy didn’t reveal themselves until those tasked with blocking their retreat had made their way around. Then, they all jumped up from every direction, shouting as they launched an attack. Although the consuls were positioned in such a way in the valley that they couldn’t ascend the hill occupied by the enemy or retreat because they were blocked from behind, the fight could have continued longer had the retreat initiated by the Tuscans not frightened the rest of the troops. However, the Fregellans kept fighting, even though they had been abandoned by the Tuscans, while the consuls, unharmed, sustained the battle by encouraging their men and fighting themselves. But when they saw both consuls wounded, with Marcellus impaled by a spear and falling lifeless from his horse, those remaining—only a few—fled alongside Crispinus the consul, who had received two spear wounds, and young Marcellus, who was also wounded. Aulus Manlius, a military tribune, was killed; of the two praefects of allies, Manius Aulius was killed, and Lucius Arennius was captured. Five of the consul's lictors were taken alive by the enemy; the rest were either killed or fled with the consul. Forty-three horsemen fell in battle or during the retreat, and eighteen were captured alive. An alarm was raised in the camp, and the troops rushed to rescue the consuls when they saw one consul and the son of the other injured, along with the meager remnants of this unfortunate mission returning to the camp. The death of Marcellus was a tragedy, not only due to the circumstances but also because, at over sixty years old, it was unbecoming of his age and inconsistent with the wisdom of a seasoned general that he had recklessly led to the downfall of himself, his colleague, and almost the entire state. I would go off on too many tangents for a single event if I were to recount all the different stories authors tell regarding Marcellus's death. To skip over others, Lucius Caelius presents three accounts categorized under different headings: one as handed down by tradition, a second written in praise of his son, who was involved in the matter, and a third, which he personally verified, based on his own investigation. However, these accounts, while differing in other aspects, mostly agree on the fact that he went out of the camp to survey the area and that he was ambushed.

28

Hannibal, concluding that the enemy were greatly dismayed by one of their consuls being slain and the other wounded, that he might not be wanting on any opportunity presenting itself, immediately transferred his camp to the eminence on which the battle had been fought. Here he found the body of Marcellus, and interred it. Crispinus, disheartened by the death of his colleague and his own wound, set out during the silence of the following night, and encamped upon the nearest mountains he could reach, in a position elevated and secured on all sides. Here the two generals exerted their sagacity, the one in effecting, the other in guarding against, a deception. Hannibal got possession of the ring of Marcellus, together with his body. Crispinus, fearing lest any artifice should be practised by the Carthaginian's employing this signet as the means of deception, had sent round messengers to the neighbouring states, informing them, that "his colleague had been slain, and that the enemy were in possession of his seal, and that they must not give credit to any letters written in the name of Marcellus." This message of the consul arrived at Salapia a little before a letter was brought from Hannibal, written in the name of Marcellus, to the effect, that "he should come to Salapia on the night which followed that day; that the soldiers in the garrison should hold themselves in readiness, in case he might want to employ them on any service." The Salapians were aware of the fraud, and concluding that an opportunity for punishing them was sought by Hannibal, from resentment, not only on account of their defection, but also because they slew his horsemen, sent his messenger, who was a deserter from the Romans, back again, in order that the soldiers might do what was thought necessary, without his being privy to it, and then placed the townsmen in parties to keep guard along the walls, and in convenient parts of the city. The guards and watches they formed with extraordinary care for that night, and on each side of the gate at which they supposed the enemy would come, they opposed to them the choicest of the troops in the garrison. About the fourth watch, Hannibal approached the city. His vanguard was composed of Roman deserters, with Roman arms. These, all of whom spoke the Latin language, when they reached the gate, called up the guards, and ordered the gate to be opened, for the consul had arrived. The guards, as if awakened at their call, began to be in a hurry and bustle, and exert themselves in opening the gate, which was closed by letting down the portcullis; some raised this with levers, others drew it up with ropes to such a height that the men could come in without stooping. The opening was scarcely wide enough, when the deserters eagerly rushed through the gate, and after about six hundred had got in, the rope being let go by which it was suspended, the portcullis fell with a loud noise. Some of the Salapians fell upon the deserters, who were carrying their arms carelessly suspended upon their shoulders, as is customary after a march, as if among friends; others frightened away the enemy by discharging stones, pikes, and javelins from the tower adjoining the gate and from the walls. Thus Hannibal withdrew, having been caught by his own stratagem, and proceeded to raise the siege of Locri, which Cincius was carrying on with the greatest vigour, with works and engines of every kind, which were brought from Sicily. Mago, who by that time almost despaired of retaining and defending the town, derived his first gleam of hope on the death of Marcellus being reported. This was followed by a message, that Hannibal had despatched his Numidian cavalry in advance, and was himself following them with all possible speed with a body of infantry. As soon, therefore, as he was informed, by a signal displayed from the watch-towers, that the Numidians were drawing near, suddenly throwing open the gate he sallied out boldly upon the enemy, and at first, more because he had done it unexpectedly than from the equality of his strength, the contest was doubtful; but afterwards, when the Numidians came up, the Romans were so dismayed that they fled on all hands to the sea and their ships, leaving their works and the engines with which they battered the walls. Thus the siege of Locri was raised by the approach of Hannibal.

Hannibal, realizing that the enemy was greatly shaken by the death of one of their consuls and the injury of the other, didn’t want to miss any opportunity that came his way, so he quickly moved his camp to the hill where the battle had taken place. There, he found Marcellus's body and buried it. Crispinus, demoralized by his colleague's death and his own wounds, set out during the stillness of the following night and camped on the nearest mountains he could find, in a position that was high and well-protected. Here, the two generals used their cleverness—Hannibal in planning a deception and Crispinus in preventing it. Hannibal acquired Marcellus's ring along with his body. Crispinus, worried that the Carthaginian might use this signet as a deceptive trick, sent messengers to nearby states, informing them that "his colleague had been killed, that the enemy had his seal, and they should not trust any letters written in Marcellus’s name." This message reached Salapia just before a letter arrived from Hannibal, written in Marcellus's name, stating that "he would come to Salapia that night, and the soldiers in the garrison should be ready in case he needed to use them." The people of Salapia recognized the trick and concluded that Hannibal was looking for a chance to punish them out of spite, not only because they had defected but also because they had killed his horsemen. They sent his messenger, who was a Roman deserter, back, so that the soldiers could act without him knowing about it. They then organized the townspeople into groups to keep watch along the walls and in strategic parts of the city. They prepared the guards and sentries with great care for that night, and at the gate where they thought the enemy would approach, they positioned the best troops from the garrison. Around the fourth watch, Hannibal approached the city. His advance guard was made up of Roman deserters carrying Roman weapons. All of them spoke Latin, and when they reached the gate, they called out to the guards and ordered them to open the gate because the consul had arrived. The guards, seemingly awakened by their call, hurriedly started to open the gate, which had been secured by lowering the portcullis; some lifted it with levers, while others pulled it up with ropes high enough for the men to enter without bending down. The opening was barely wide enough when the deserters eagerly rushed through the gate, and after about six hundred had made it in, the rope holding the portcullis up was released, causing it to fall with a loud crash. Some of the Salapians attacked the deserters, who were carrying their weapons casually on their shoulders as if among friends; others frightened the enemies away by throwing stones, pikes, and javelins from the tower next to the gate and from the walls. Thus, Hannibal retreated, having fallen victim to his own trick, and moved to lift the siege of Locri, which Cincius was vigorously carrying on with various works and engines brought from Sicily. Mago, who by then had almost given up hope of holding and defending the town, felt a glimmer of hope when news of Marcellus's death reached him. Soon after, he received word that Hannibal had sent his Numidian cavalry ahead and was following closely with a body of infantry. As soon as he was alerted by a signal from the watchtowers that the Numidians were nearing, he suddenly opened the gate and boldly charged out against the enemy. Initially, because it was unexpected rather than due to equal strength, the battle was uncertain; but later, when the Numidians arrived, the Romans were so intimidated that they fled in all directions to the sea and their ships, abandoning their works and the engines they had used to bombard the walls. Thus, the siege of Locri was lifted due to Hannibal's approach.

29

When Crispinus found that Hannibal had gone into Bruttium, he ordered Marcus Marcellus, a military tribune, to march the army, which his colleague had commanded, to Venusia. Having set out himself with his own legions for Capua, though scarcely able to endure the motion of the litter, from the severity of his wounds, he sent a letter to Rome stating the death of his colleague, and in how great danger he himself was. He said, "it was impossible for him to go to Rome to hold the election, both because he did not think he could bear the fatigue of the journey, and because he was anxious about Tarentum, lest Hannibal should direct his course thither from Bruttium. That it was expedient that commissioners should be sent to him, men of sound judgment, with whom he might communicate, when he pleased, respecting the commonwealth." The reading of this letter excited great grief for the death of one of the consuls, and apprehension for the safety of the other. They therefore sent Quintus Fabius the younger to Venusia to the army; and to the consul three commissioners, Sextus Julius Caesar, Lucius Licinius Pollio, and Lucius Cincius Alimentus, though but a few days before he had returned from Sicily. These were directed to convey a message to the consul, to the effect, that if he could not himself go to Rome to hold the election, he should nominate a dictator within the Roman territory for that purpose. If the consul should have gone to Tarentum, that it was the pleasure of the senate that Marcus Claudius, the praetor, should march off his legions to that quarter in which he could protect the greatest number of the cities of the allies. The same summer Marcus Valerius crossed over from Sicily into Africa with a fleet of a hundred ships, and making a descent near the city Clupea, devastated the country to a wide extent, scarcely meeting with a single person in arms. Afterwards the troops employed in making these depredations were hastily led back to their ships, and a report had suddenly reached them that a Carthaginian fleet was drawing near. It consisted of eighty-three ships. With these the Romans fought successfully, not far from the city Clupea, and after taking eighteen and putting the rest to flight, returned to Lilybaeum with a great deal of booty gained both by land and sea. The same summer also Philip gave assistance to the suppliant Achaeans. They were harassed by Machanidas, tyrant of the Lacedaemonians, with a war in their immediate neighbourhood; and the Aetolians, having passed over an army in ships through the strait which runs between Naupactus and Patrae, called by the neighbouring people Rhion, had devastated their country. It was reported also, that Attalus, king of Asia, would pass over into Europe, because the Aetolians, in their last council, had offered to him the office of chief magistrate of their nation.

When Crispinus learned that Hannibal had moved into Bruttium, he ordered Marcus Marcellus, a military tribune, to lead the army, which his colleague had commanded, to Venusia. He set out himself with his own legions for Capua, despite barely being able to handle the movement of the litter due to the severity of his wounds. He sent a letter to Rome announcing the death of his colleague and explaining the great danger he was in. He said, "I can't go to Rome to hold the election, because I don't think I can handle the trip and I'm worried about Tarentum, fearing that Hannibal might head there from Bruttium. It would be wise for commissioners to be sent to me, men of good judgment, so I can discuss matters regarding the state with them whenever I need to." Reading this letter caused great sorrow over the loss of one of the consuls and concern for the safety of the other. As a result, they sent Quintus Fabius the younger to Venusia to join the army, and three commissioners—Sextus Julius Caesar, Lucius Licinius Pollio, and Lucius Cincius Alimentus—to the consul, even though he had just returned from Sicily a few days earlier. They were instructed to tell the consul that if he couldn’t go to Rome for the election, he should appoint a dictator within Roman territory for that purpose. If the consul had gone to Tarentum, the senate decided that Marcus Claudius, the praetor, should lead his legions to protect as many allied cities as possible. That same summer, Marcus Valerius sailed from Sicily to Africa with a fleet of a hundred ships, landing near the city of Clupea, and caused widespread devastation in the area, encountering hardly any armed resistance. Later, the troops involved in these raids were quickly returned to their ships upon hearing that a Carthaginian fleet was approaching, consisting of eighty-three ships. The Romans engaged in battle with these ships near Clupea, successfully capturing eighteen and forcing the rest to flee, before returning to Lilybaeum with a significant amount of loot from both land and sea. That same summer, Philip also provided help to the Achaeans who were pleading for aid. They were being troubled by Machanidas, the tyrant of the Lacedaemonians, with a nearby war, and the Aetolians had crossed over with an army in ships through the strait between Naupactus and Patrae, known as Rhion, causing devastation in their territory. It was also reported that Attalus, the king of Asia, planned to move into Europe, as the Aetolians had recently offered him the position of chief magistrate of their nation.

30

Philip, when marching down into Greece, for these reasons, was met at the city Lamia by the Aetolians, under the command of Pyrrhias, who had been created praetor that year jointly with Attalus, who was absent. They had with them also auxiliaries from Attalus, and about a thousand men sent from the Roman fleet by Publius Sulpicius. Against this general and these forces, Philip fought twice successfully, and slew full a thousand of his enemies in each battle. Whence, as the Aetolians were compelled by fear to keep themselves under the walls of Lamia, Philip led back his army to Phalara. This place is situated in the Malian bay, and was formerly thickly inhabited on account of its excellent harbour, the safe anchorage in its neighbourhood, and other conveniences of sea and land. Hither came ambassadors from Ptolemy, king of Egypt, the Rhodians, Athenians, and Chians, to put a stop to hostilities between the Aetolians and Philip. The Aetolians also called in one of their neighbours as a mediator, Amynander, king of the Athamanians. But all these were less concerned for the Aetolians, whose arrogance of disposition exceeded that of any other nation of Greece, than lest Philip and his empire, which was likely to prove injurious to the cause of liberty, should be intermixed with the affairs of Greece. The deliberations concerning a peace were put off, to a council of the Achaeans, for which a place and certain day were fixed upon; for the mean time a truce of thirty days was obtained. The king, setting out thence, went through Thessaly and Boeotia to Chalcis in Euboea, to prevent Attalus, who he heard was about to come to Euboea with a fleet, from entering the harbours and approaching the coasts. Leaving a force to oppose Attalus, in case he should cross over in the mean time, he set out thence with a small body of cavalry and light-armed troops, and came to Argos. Here the superintendence of the Heraean and Nemaean games having been conferred upon him by the suffrages of the people, because the kings of the Macedonians trace their origin from that state, after completing the Heraean games, he set out directly after the celebration for Aegium, to the council of allies, fixed some time before. Here measures were proposed for putting an end to the Aetolian war, in order that neither the Romans nor Attalus might have a pretext for entering Greece; but they were all upset by the Aetolians, before the period of the truce had scarcely expired, after they heard that Attalus had arrived at Aegina, and that a Roman fleet was stationed at Naupactus. For when called into the council of the Achaeans, where the same embassies were present which had negotiated for peace at Phalara, they at first complained of some trifling acts committed during the period of the truce, contrary to the faith of the convention; but at last they asserted, that it was impossible the war could be terminated unless the Achaeans gave back Pylus to the Messenians, unless Atintania was restored to the Romans, and Ardyaea to Scerdilaedus and Pleuratus. But Philip, conceiving it an indignity that the vanquished should presumptuously dictate terms to him the victor, said, "that he did not before either listen to proposals for peace, or agree to a truce, from any hope he entertained that the Aetolians would remain quiet, but in order that he might have all the allies as witnesses that he was desirous of peace, and that they were the occasion of this war." Thus, without effecting a peace, he dismissed the council; and leaving four thousand troops for the protection of the Achaeans, and receiving five men of war, with which, if he could have joined them to the fleet of the Carthaginians lately sent to him, and the ships which were coming from Bithynia, from king Prusias, he had resolved to challenge the Romans, who had long been masters of the sea in that quarter, to a naval battle, the king himself went back from the congress to Argos; for now the time for celebrating the Nemaean games was approaching, which he wished to be celebrated in his presence.

Philip, as he marched into Greece, was met at the city of Lamia by the Aetolians, led by Pyrrhias, who had been appointed praetor that year alongside Attalus, who was absent. They also had allies from Attalus and about a thousand men sent by the Roman fleet under Publius Sulpicius. Philip fought against this commander and these forces twice, winning both battles and killing around a thousand of his enemies in each fight. As the Aetolians, afraid, had to stay within the walls of Lamia, Philip took his army back to Phalara. This place is located in the Malian bay and used to be heavily populated due to its excellent harbor, safe anchorage nearby, and other sea and land conveniences. Ambassadors from Ptolemy, the king of Egypt, as well as representatives from Rhodes, Athens, and Chios arrived here to negotiate peace between the Aetolians and Philip. The Aetolians also called upon one of their neighbors for mediation, Amynander, the king of the Athamanians. However, these groups were more concerned about preventing Philip and his empire—which could threaten liberty—from interfering in Greek affairs than about the Aetolians, whose arrogance exceeded that of any other Greek nation. Discussions about peace were postponed to a council of the Achaeans, for which a location and date were scheduled; in the meantime, a thirty-day truce was granted. The king then traveled through Thessaly and Boeotia to Chalcis in Euboea, aiming to stop Attalus, who he heard was on his way to Euboea with a fleet, from entering the harbors and approaching the coasts. He left a force to oppose Attalus in case he crossed over in the meantime and set out with a small group of cavalry and light troops to Argos. Here, he was given the responsibility of overseeing the Heraean and Nemaean games by the people's vote, as the Macedonian kings trace their roots to that state. After completing the Heraean games, he headed straight for Aegium for the allies' council, which had been scheduled earlier. Here, plans were proposed to end the Aetolian war so that neither the Romans nor Attalus could have a reason to enter Greece. However, these plans were disrupted by the Aetolians before the truce had even expired, after learning that Attalus had arrived in Aegina and that a Roman fleet was stationed at Naupactus. When called to the council of the Achaeans, where the same embassies were present that had discussed peace at Phalara, the Aetolians initially complained about minor incidents that occurred during the truce, contrary to the agreed terms. Eventually, they claimed it was impossible to end the war unless the Achaeans returned Pylus to the Messenians, restored Atintania to the Romans, and returned Ardyaea to Scerdilaedus and Pleuratus. Philip, feeling it was an insult for the defeated to dictate terms to him as the victor, stated that he had not previously listened to peace proposals or agreed to a truce out of any hope that the Aetolians would stay quiet, but so that all the allies could see that he desired peace and that they were the cause of this war. Thus, without securing peace, he dismissed the council; after leaving four thousand troops to protect the Achaeans and receiving five warships, he planned to challenge the Romans, who had long dominated the sea in that area, to a naval battle if he could combine these ships with the fleet from Carthage and the vessels arriving from Bithynia from King Prusias. The king then returned from the congress to Argos, as the time for the Nemaean games was approaching, which he wanted to have celebrated in his presence.

31

While the king was occupied with the exhibition of the games, and was indulging himself during the days devoted to festivity with more freedom than in time of war, Publius Sulpicius, setting out from Naupactus, brought his fleet to the shore, between Sicyon and Corinth, and devastated without restraint a country of the most renowned fertility. Intelligence of this proceeding called Philip away from the games. He set out hastily with his cavalry, ordering his infantry to follow him closely; and attacking the Romans as they were scattered through the fields and loaded with booty, like men who feared nothing of the kind, drove them to their ships. The Roman fleet returned to Naupactus by no means pleased with their booty. The fame of a victory gained by Philip over the Romans, of whatever magnitude, increased the celebrity of the remaining part of the games. The festival was celebrated with extraordinary mirth, the more so as the king, in order to please the people, took the diadem off his head, and laid aside his purple robe with the other royal apparel, and placed himself, with regard to appearance, on an equality with the rest, than which nothing is more gratifying to free states. By this conduct he would have afforded the strongest hopes of the enjoyment of liberty, had he not debased and marred all by his intolerable lust; for he ranged night and day through the houses of married people with one or two companions, and in proportion as he was less conspicuous by lowering his dignity to a private level, the less restraint he felt; thus converting that empty show of liberty, which he had made to others, into a cover for the gratification of his own unbounded desires. For neither did he obtain his object in all cases by money or seductive arts, but he also employed violence in the accomplishment of his flagitious purposes; and it was dangerous both to husbands and parents to have presented any impediment to the gratification of royal lust, by an unseasonable strictness. From one man, Aratus, of the highest rank among the Achaeans, his wife, named Polycratia, was taken away and conveyed into Macedonia under the hope of a matrimonial connexion with royalty. After passing the time appointed for the celebration of the Nemaean games, and a few days more, in the commission of these profligate acts, he set out for Dymae to expel the garrison of the Aetolians, which had been invited by the Eleans, and received into the town. Cycliadas, who had the chief direction of affairs, met the king at Dymae, together with the Achaeans, who were inflamed with hatred against the Eleans, because they had disunited themselves from the rest of the Achaeans, and were incensed against the Aetolians, because they considered that they had stirred up a Roman war against them. Setting out from Dymae, and uniting their forces, they passed the river Larissus, which separates the Elean from the Dymaean territory.

While the king was busy with the games, enjoying himself during the festive days with more freedom than in wartime, Publius Sulpicius set sail from Naupactus and landed his fleet between Sicyon and Corinth, devastating a region known for its exceptional fertility. News of this forced Philip to leave the games behind. He quickly headed out with his cavalry, instructing his infantry to closely follow him, and attacked the Romans as they scattered through the fields, burdened with spoils, like people who weren’t cautious. He drove them back to their ships. The Roman fleet returned to Naupactus feeling very unsatisfied with their loot. Philip's victory over the Romans, regardless of its size, enhanced the reputation of the remaining festivities. The festival was celebrated with great joy, especially since the king, wanting to please the crowd, removed his crown, took off his purple robe along with his royal garments, and made himself look like everyone else, which was highly appreciated by free states. His actions would have offered great hope for the enjoyment of liberty had he not sullied everything with his unbearable lust; he wandered day and night into the homes of married people with one or two companions, and the more he diminished his status to mingle with commoners, the less restraint he felt; thus, he turned that superficial display of freedom he had created for others into a cover for indulging his own limitless desires. He often didn't achieve his aims solely through money or charm but also resorted to violence to fulfill his disgraceful intentions; it became dangerous for husbands and parents to try to obstruct the king’s desires with unnecessary strictness. From a notable man, Aratus, one of the highest-ranking Achaeans, his wife, Polycratia, was taken and brought to Macedonia with the promise of a royal marriage. After spending the designated time for the Nemaean games and a few more days engaged in these immoral acts, the king headed to Dymae to remove the Aetolian garrison that the Eleans had invited into the town. Cycliadas, who was in charge of affairs, met the king at Dymae, alongside the Achaeans, who were furious with the Eleans for breaking away from the rest of Achaeans and were upset with the Aetolians, believing they had sparked a Roman war against them. Setting out from Dymae and joining forces, they crossed the Larissus River, which separates the Elean territory from that of Dymae.

32

The first day on which they entered upon the enemy's confines, they employed in plundering. The following day they approached the city in battle-array, having sent their cavalry in advance, in order that, by riding up to the gates, they might provoke the Aetolians to make a sally, a measure to which they were naturally inclined. They were not aware that Sulpicius had passed over from Naupactus to Cyllene with fifteen ships, and landing four thousand armed men, had entered Elis during the dead of night, that his troops might not be seen. Accordingly, when they recognised the Roman standards and arms among the Aetolians, so unexpected an event occasioned the greatest terror; and at first the king had wished to withdraw his troops; but afterwards, an engagement having taken place between the Aetolians and Trallians, a tribe of Illyrians, when he saw his men hard pressed, the king himself with his cavalry charged a Roman cohort. Here his horse being pierced with a javelin threw the king, who fell over his head; when a conflict ensued, which was desperate on both sides; the Romans making a furious attack upon the king, and the royal party protecting him. His own conduct was highly meritorious, when though on foot he was obliged to fight among horsemen. Afterwards, when the contest was unequal, many were falling and being wounded around him, he was snatched away by his soldiers, and, being placed upon another horse, fled from the field. On that day he pitched his camp five miles from the city of the Eleans, and the next day led out all his forces to a fort called Pyrgus, whither he had heard that a multitude of rustics had resorted through fear of being plundered. This unorganized and unarmed multitude he took immediately on his approach, from the first effects of alarm; and by this capture compensated for the disgrace sustained at Elis. While engaged in distributing the spoil and captives, and there were four thousand men and as many as twenty thousand head of cattle of every kind, intelligence reached him from Macedonia that one Eropus had gained possession of Lychnidus by bribing the praefect of the citadel and garrison; that he held also certain towns of the Dassaretians, and that he was endeavouring to incite the Dardanians to arms. Desisting from the Achaean war, therefore, but still leaving two thousand five hundred armed troops of every description under the generals Menippus and Polyphantas for the protection of his allies, he set out from Dymae, and passing through Achaea, Boeotia, and Euboea, arrived on the tenth day at Demetrias in Thessaly.

The first day they entered enemy territory, they spent looting. The next day, they approached the city ready for battle, sending their cavalry ahead to provoke the Aetolians into a sortie, which they were naturally inclined to do. They didn’t realize that Sulpicius had crossed from Naupactus to Cyllene with fifteen ships, landing four thousand armed men who silently entered Elis in the dead of night to avoid being seen. When they recognized the Roman standards and armor among the Aetolians, the unexpected sight caused great panic; initially, the king wanted to withdraw his troops. But after a fight broke out between the Aetolians and the Trallians, an Illyrian tribe, and seeing his men under heavy pressure, the king charged a Roman cohort with his cavalry. During this, a javelin struck his horse, throwing him over its head; a desperate battle ensued on both sides, with the Romans launching fierce attacks on the king and his loyal followers defending him. He showed remarkable bravery, fighting on foot among horsemen. Eventually, as the battle turned against them, with many around him falling and getting wounded, his soldiers pulled him away and helped him onto another horse, allowing him to flee the battlefield. That day, he set up camp five miles from the city of the Eleans, and the following day, he took all his forces to a fort called Pyrgus, where he had heard a group of peasants gathered out of fear of being looted. He quickly captured this disorganized and unarmed crowd as they panicked, and this victory helped him recover some honor lost at Elis. While he was dividing the spoils and captives—four thousand men and about twenty thousand head of livestock—news reached him from Macedonia that a man named Eropus had taken control of Lychnidus by bribing the commander of the citadel and garrison and had also seized several towns of the Dassaretians, trying to incite the Dardanians to take up arms. Therefore, he pulled back from the Achaean war but left two thousand five hundred armed troops under generals Menippus and Polyphantas to protect his allies. He then departed from Dymae and, traveling through Achaea, Boeotia, and Euboea, arrived in Demetrias, Thessaly, on the tenth day.

33

Here he was met by other messengers with intelligence of still greater commotions; that the Dardanians, having poured into Macedonia, were in possession of Orestis, and had descended into the Argestaean plain; and that there was a general report among the barbarians that Philip was slain. In that expedition in which he fought with the plundering party near Sicyon, being carried by the fury of his horse against a tree, he broke off the extremity of one of the horns of his helmet against a projecting branch; which being found by a certain Aetolian and carried into Aetolia to Scerdilaedus, who knew it to be the ornament of his helmet, spread the report that the king was killed. After the king had departed from Achaea, Sulpicius, going to Aegina with his fleet, formed a junction with Attalus. The Achaeans fought successfully with the Aetolians and Eleans not far from Messene. King Attalus and Publius Sulpicius wintered at Aegina. In the close of this year Titus Quinctius Crispinus, the consul, after having nominated Titus Manlius Torquatus dictator for the purpose of holding the election and celebrating the games, died of his wound. Some say that he died at Tarentum, others in Campania. The death of the two consuls, who were slain without having fought any memorable battle, a coincidence which had never occurred in any former war, had left the commonwealth in a manner orphan. The dictator, Manlius, appointed as his master of the horse Caius Servilius, then curule aedile. On the first day of its meeting the senate ordered the dictator to celebrate the great games which Marcus Aemilius, the city praetor, had celebrated in the consulship of Caius Flaminius and Cneius Servilius, and had vowed to be repeated after five years. The dictator then both performed the games and vowed them for the following lustrum. But as the two consular armies without commanders were so near the enemy, disregarding every thing else, one especial care engrossed the fathers and the people, that of creating the consuls as soon as possible; and that they might create those in preference whose valour was least in danger from Carthaginian treachery; since, through the whole period of the war, the precipitate and hot tempers of their generals had been detrimental, and this very year the consuls had fallen into a snare for which they were not prepared, in consequence of their excessive eagerness to engage the enemy, but the immortal gods, in pity to the Roman name, had spared the unoffending armies, and doomed the consuls to expiate their temerity with their own lives.

Here he was met by other messengers with news of even greater chaos: the Dardanians had flooded into Macedonia, taken over Orestis, and moved into the Argestaean plain. There were widespread rumors among the barbarians that Philip was dead. During an expedition where he fought against a plundering party near Sicyon, he was thrown by his horse into a tree, breaking off the tip of one of the horns of his helmet against a branch. This piece was found by an Aetolian, who took it back to Scerdilaedus in Aetolia. Recognizing it as part of Philip's helmet, he spread the word that the king had been killed. After the king left Achaea, Sulpicius sailed to Aegina with his fleet and joined forces with Attalus. The Achaeans had a successful battle against the Aetolians and Eleans near Messene. King Attalus and Publius Sulpicius spent the winter at Aegina. At the end of this year, the consul Titus Quinctius Crispinus, after appointing Titus Manlius Torquatus as dictator to oversee the elections and games, died from his wounds. Some say he died in Tarentum, others in Campania. The deaths of the two consuls, who were killed without engaging in any significant battle—a situation that had never happened in previous wars—left the republic feeling orphaned. The dictator, Manlius, appointed Caius Servilius as his master of the horse, who was then a curule aedile. On the first day of its meeting, the senate instructed the dictator to celebrate the grand games that Marcus Aemilius, the city praetor, had promised during the consulship of Caius Flaminius and Cneius Servilius, and vowed to repeat after five years. The dictator then held the games and vowed to repeat them for the next lustrum. However, with the two consular armies leaderless and so close to the enemy, the primary focus of the senators and the people was to appoint new consuls as quickly as possible, choosing those whose bravery posed the least risk of falling prey to Carthaginian deceit. Throughout the war, the impulsive and hasty nature of their generals had been harmful, and this year, the consuls had walked into a trap due to their reckless eagerness to confront the enemy. Fortunately, the immortal gods, out of compassion for the Roman name, spared the unoffending armies, leaving the consuls to pay for their rashness with their lives.

34

On the fathers' looking round to see whom they should appoint as consuls, Caius Claudius Nero appeared pre-eminently. They then looked out for a colleague for him, and although they considered him a man of the highest talents, they also were of opinion that he was of a more forward and vehement disposition than the circumstances of the war, or the enemy, Hannibal, required, they resolved that it would be right to qualify the impetuosity of his temper by uniting with him a cool and prudent colleague. The person fixed upon was Marcus Livius, who, many years ago, was, on the expiration of his consulship, condemned in a trial before the people; a disgrace which he took so much to heart, that he retired into the country, and for many years absented himself from the city, and avoided all public assemblies. Much about the eighth year after his condemnation, Marcus Claudius Marcellus and Marcus Valerius Laevinus, the consuls, had brought him back into the city; but he appeared in a squalid dress, his hair and beard allowed to grow, and exhibiting in his countenance and attire the deep impression of the disgrace he had sustained. Lucius Veturius and Publius Licinius, the censors, compelled him to have his beard and hair trimmed, to lay aside his squalid garb, to come into the senate, and discharge other public duties. But even then he either gave his assent by a single word, or signified his vote by walking to one side of the house, till the trial of Marcus Livius Macatus, a kinsman of his, whose character was at stake, obliged him to deliver his sentiments in the senate upon his legs. On being heard in the senate on this occasion, after so long an interval, he drew the eyes of all upon him, and gave occasion to conversations to the following effect: "That the people had injuriously disgraced a man who was undeserving of it and that it had been greatly detrimental to the state that, in so important a war, it had not had the benefit of the service and counsels of such a man. That neither Quintus Fabius nor Marcus Valerius Laevinus could be given to Caius Nero as colleagues, because it was not allowed for two patricians to be elected. That the same cause precluded Titus Manlius, besides that he had refused a consulship when offered to him, and would refuse it. That they would have two most distinguished consuls if they should add Marcus Livius as a colleague to Caius Claudius." Nor did the people despise a proposal, the mention of which originated with the fathers. The only person in the state who objected to the measure was the man to whom the honour was offered, who accused his countrymen of inconstancy, saying, "that, having withheld their pity from him when arrayed in a mourning garment and a criminal, they now forced upon him the white gown against his will; that honours and punishments were heaped upon the same person. If they esteemed him a good man, why had they thus passed a sentence of condemnation upon him as a wicked and guilty one? If they had proved him a guilty man, why should they thus trust him with a second consulate after having improperly committed to him the first?" While thus remonstrating and complaining, the fathers rebuked him, putting him in mind, that "Marcus Furius too, being recalled from exile, had reinstated his country when shaken from her very base. That we ought to soothe the anger of our country as we would that of parents, by patience and resignation." All exerting themselves to the utmost, they succeeded in uniting Marcus Livius in the consulate with Caius Claudius.

As the leaders looked around to decide whom to appoint as consuls, Caius Claudius Nero stood out. They then searched for a colleague for him, and while they recognized his exceptional talents, they felt he was too impulsive and aggressive for the ongoing war against Hannibal. They believed it would be wise to temper his intensity by pairing him with a calm and sensible colleague. They chose Marcus Livius, who had been condemned by the people years earlier after his consulship; he took this disgrace so seriously that he withdrew to the countryside and stayed away from the city and public gatherings for many years. About eight years after his condemnation, consuls Marcus Claudius Marcellus and Marcus Valerius Laevinus brought him back to the city, but he showed up in ragged clothes, with unkempt hair and beard, reflecting the weight of his humiliation. Censors Lucius Veturius and Publius Licinius forced him to clean up, change out of his shabby attire, attend the senate, and fulfill other public responsibilities. Even then, he mostly just agreed with a word or indicated his vote by moving to one side of the house until he was compelled to express his views in the senate about the trial of Marcus Livius Macatus, a relative of his, whose reputation was at stake. After such a long absence, his presence in the senate attracted everyone's attention and sparked discussions like: “The people wronged a man who didn't deserve it, and it hurt the state that, in such a crucial war, it missed out on his service and advice. Neither Quintus Fabius nor Marcus Valerius Laevinus could serve as colleagues alongside Caius Nero because two patricians couldn't be elected together. The same reason excluded Titus Manlius, who had previously turned down a consulship and would likely do so again. They would have two outstanding consuls if they added Marcus Livius as a colleague to Caius Claudius." The people were not opposed to this suggestion, which originated from the leaders. The only person against it was the man being offered the position, who criticized his fellow citizens for their fickleness, saying, “You refused to pity me when I was dressed in mourning and branded a criminal, yet now you’re forcing me into the white toga against my will; you heap honors and punishments upon the same person. If you consider me a good man, why did you condemn me as a wicked and guilty one? If you have proven me guilty, why do you now trust me with a second consulship after carelessly giving me the first?" While he was voicing his objections, the leaders reminded him that "Marcus Furius, too, was recalled from exile and helped restore his country when it was on the verge of collapse. We should appease our country’s anger as we would our parents’ by being patient and accepting." In their determination, they successfully united Marcus Livius with Caius Claudius in the consulship.

35

The third day afterwards the election of praetors was held. The praetors created were, Lucius Porcius Licinus, Caius Mamilius, Aulus Hostilius Cato, and Caius Hostilius Cato. The election completed, and the games celebrated, the dictator and master of the horse abdicated their offices. Caius Terentius Varro was sent as propraetor into Etruria, in order that Caius Hostilius might quit that province and go to Tarentum to that army which Titus Quinctius, the consul, had commanded, and that Lucius Manlius might go as ambassador across the sea, and observe what was going on there; and at the same time, as the games at Olympia, which were attended by the greatest concourse of persons of any solemnity in Greece, were about to take place that summer, that if he could without danger from the enemy, he might go to that assembly, in order that any Sicilians who might be there, having been driven away by the war, or any Tarentine citizens banished by Hannibal, might return to their homes, and be informed that the Roman people would restore to them every thing which they had possessed before the war. As a year of the most dangerous character seemed to threaten them, and there were no consuls to direct the government, all men fixed their attention on the consuls elect, wishing them to draw lots for their provinces, as soon as possible, and determine beforehand what province and what enemy each should have. The senate also took measures, at the instance of Quintus Fabius Maximus, to effect a reconciliation between them. For the enmity between them was notorious; and in the case of Livius his misfortunes rendered it more inveterate and acrimonious, as he considered that in that situation he had been treated with contempt. He was, therefore, the more inexorable, and said, "that there was no need of a reconciliation, for that they would use greater diligence and activity in every thing they did for fear lest they should give their colleague, who was an enemy, an opportunity of advancing himself at their expense." However, the authority of the senate prevailed; and, laying aside their private differences, they conducted the affairs of the state in friendship and unanimity. Their provinces were not districts bordering upon each other, as in former years, but quite separate, in the remotest confines of Italy. To one was decreed Bruttium and Lucania, to act against Hannibal; to the other Gaul, to act against Hasdrubal, who, it was reported, was now approaching the Alps; and that he to whose lot Gaul fell should choose whichever he pleased of the two armies, one of which was in Gaul, the other in Etruria, and receive the city legions in addition; and that he to whose lot Bruttium fell, should, after enlisting fresh legions for the city, take the army of whichever of the consuls of the former year he pleased. That Quintus Fulvius, proconsul, should take the army which was left by the consul, and that his command should last for a year. To Caius Hostilius, to whom they had given the province of Tarentum in exchange for Etruria, they gave Capua instead of Tarentum, with one legion which Fulvius had commanded the preceding year.

The third day after the election of praetors took place. The newly elected praetors were Lucius Porcius Licinus, Caius Mamilius, Aulus Hostilius Cato, and Caius Hostilius Cato. Once the election was finished and the games were celebrated, the dictator and master of the horse stepped down from their positions. Caius Terentius Varro was appointed as propraetor in Etruria so that Caius Hostilius could leave that province and go to Tarentum to join the army led by Titus Quinctius, the consul, and so that Lucius Manlius could travel as an ambassador across the sea to observe what was happening there. At the same time, since the games at Olympia, which attracted the largest gathering for any event in Greece, were about to occur that summer, he was to attend the assembly if it was safe from the enemy. It was hoped that any Sicilians displaced by the war or any Tarentines exiled by Hannibal could return home and learn that the Roman people would restore everything they owned before the war. With a year of great peril ahead and no consuls to oversee the government, everyone focused on the newly elected consuls, hoping they would draw lots for their provinces as soon as possible and determine what province and enemy each would face. The senate also took steps, at the urging of Quintus Fabius Maximus, to reconcile them. The animosity between them was well-known, and Livius’s misfortunes made it more intense as he felt he had been treated with disdain. Therefore, he was more unyielding and stated that there was no need for reconciliation since they would work harder and more diligently to avoid giving their rival, who was their enemy, a chance to gain at their expense. Nevertheless, the senate's authority prevailed, and setting aside their personal differences, they managed state affairs cooperatively and harmoniously. Their provinces were not adjacent, as in previous years, but completely separate in the farthest reaches of Italy. One was assigned Bruttium and Lucania to confront Hannibal; the other was assigned Gaul to face Hasdrubal, who was reportedly approaching the Alps. The consul who drew Gaul could choose whichever of the two armies he preferred—one stationed in Gaul, the other in Etruria—and receive the urban legions in addition. The consul who drew Bruttium would enlist new legions for the city and take the army from whichever previous consul he chose. Quintus Fulvius, the proconsul, was to command the army left by the consul for a year. To Caius Hostilius, who was given the province of Tarentum in exchange for Etruria, they assigned Capua instead of Tarentum, along with one legion commanded by Fulvius the previous year.

36

The anxiety respecting the approach of Hasdrubal to Italy increased daily. At first, ambassadors from the Massilians had brought word that he had passed over into Gaul and that the expectations of the Gauls were raised by his coming, as he was reported to have brought a large quantity of gold for the purpose of hiring auxiliaries. Afterwards, Sextus Antistius and Marcus Raecius, who were sent from Rome, together with these persons, as ambassadors, to look into the affair, had brought word back that they had sent persons with Massilian guides, who, through the medium of Gallic chieftains connected with them by hospitality, might bring back all ascertained particulars; that they found that Hasdrubal, who had already collected an immense army, would cross the Alps the ensuing spring; and that the only cause which delayed him there was, that the passage of the Alps was closed by winter. Publius Aelius Paetus was created and inaugurated in the office of augur in the room of Marcus Marcellus and Cneius Cornelius Dolabella was inaugurated king of the sacred rites in the room of Marcus Marcius, who had died two years before. This same year, for the first time since Hannibal came into Italy, the lustrum was closed by the censors Publius Sempronius Tuditanus and Marcus Cornelius Cethegus. The citizens numbered in the census were one hundred and thirty-seven thousand one hundred and eight, a number considerably smaller than before the war. This year it is recorded that the Comitium was covered, and that the Roman games were repeated once by the curule aediles, Quintus Metellus and Caius Servilius; and that the plebeian games were repeated twice by Quintus Mamilius and Marcus Caecilius Metellus, plebeian aediles. The same persons also gave three statues for the temple of Ceres, and there was a feast in honour of Jupiter on occasion of the games. After this Caius Claudius Nero and Marcus Livius a second time entered upon their consulate; and as they had already, while consuls elect, drawn lots for their provinces, they ordered the praetors to draw lots for theirs. Caius Hostilius had the city jurisdiction, to which the foreign was added, in order that three praetors might go out to the provinces. Aulus Hostilius had Sardinia, Caius Mamilius, Sicily, Lucius Porcius, Gaul. The total amount of legions employed in the provinces was twenty-three, which were so distributed that the consuls might have two each; Spain, four; the three praetors in Sicily, Sardinia, and Gaul, two each; Caius Terentius, two in Etruria; Quintus Fulvius, two in Bruttium; Quintus Claudius two in the neighbourhood of Tarentum and the territory of Sallentum; Caius Hostilius Tubulus, one at Capua; and two were ordered to be enlisted for the city. For the first four legions the people elected tribunes, the consuls sent those for the rest.

Anxiety about Hasdrubal's approach to Italy grew every day. Initially, ambassadors from Massilia reported that he had crossed into Gaul and that the Gauls were excited by his arrival since he was said to have brought a large amount of gold to hire mercenaries. Later, Sextus Antistius and Marcus Raecius, who had been sent by Rome along with these ambassadors to investigate the matter, reported back that they had sent people with Massilian guides who, through Gallic chiefs they were connected to, might bring back all the details; they discovered that Hasdrubal, who had already gathered a massive army, would cross the Alps the next spring and that the only reason he was delayed was that the Alps were closed due to winter. Publius Aelius Paetus was appointed and inaugurated as augur in place of Marcus Marcellus, and Cneius Cornelius Dolabella was inaugurated as king of the sacred rites in place of Marcus Marcius, who had died two years earlier. This year, for the first time since Hannibal arrived in Italy, the censors Publius Sempronius Tuditanus and Marcus Cornelius Cethegus closed the lustrum. The number of citizens counted in the census was 137,108, a figure significantly smaller than before the war. This year it was recorded that the Comitium was covered, and that the Roman games were held once by the curule aediles, Quintus Metellus and Caius Servilius; and that the plebeian games were held twice by Quintus Mamilius and Marcus Caecilius Metellus, plebeian aediles. The same aediles also provided three statues for the temple of Ceres, and there was a feast in honor of Jupiter in connection with the games. Afterwards, Caius Claudius Nero and Marcus Livius began their consulate a second time; they had already, while consuls elect, drawn lots for their provinces, and they instructed the praetors to draw lots for theirs. Caius Hostilius had jurisdiction over the city, with foreign jurisdiction added so that three praetors could go to the provinces. Aulus Hostilius had Sardinia, Caius Mamilius had Sicily, and Lucius Porcius had Gaul. The total number of legions deployed in the provinces was twenty-three, distributed so that the consuls had two each; Spain had four; the three praetors in Sicily, Sardinia, and Gaul had two each; Caius Terentius had two in Etruria; Quintus Fulvius had two in Bruttium; Quintus Claudius had two near Tarentum and the territory of Sallentum; Caius Hostilius Tubulus had one at Capua; and two were ordered to be recruited for the city. The people elected tribunes for the first four legions, and the consuls appointed the rest.

37

Before the consuls set out, the nine days' sacred rite was performed, as a shower of stones had fallen from the sky at Veii. After the mention of one prodigy, others also were reported, as usual. At Minturnae, that the temple of Jupiter and the grove of Marica, and at Atella also that a wall and gate, had been struck by lightning. The people of Minturnae added what was more alarming, that a stream of blood had flowed at their gate. At Capua, a wolf, which had entered at the gate by night, had torn a watchman. These prodigies were expiated with victims of the larger kind, and a supplication for one day was made, according to a decree of the pontiffs. The nine days' sacred rite was then performed again, because a shower of stones had been seen to fall in the armilustrum. After the people's minds had been freed from superstitious fears, they were again disturbed by intelligence that an infant had been born at Frusino as large as a child of four years old, and not so much an object of wonder from its size, as that it was born without any certain mark of distinction whether it was male or female, which was the case two years before at Sinuessa. Aruspices, called in from Etruria, declared this to be indeed a foul and ill-omened prodigy, which ought to be removed out of the Roman territory, and, being kept far from coming in contact with the earth, to be plunged into the deep. They shut it up alive in a chest, and carrying it away, threw it into the sea. The pontiffs also decreed, that thrice nine virgins should go through the city singing a hymn. While in the temple of Jupiter Stator they were learning this hymn, which was composed by the poet Livius, the temple of Juno Regina, on the Aventine, was struck by lightning; and the aruspices, on being consulted, having replied that that prodigy appertained to the matrons, and that the goddess must be appeased by a present, such of the matrons as dwelt within the city and within the tenth milestone from it, were summoned to the Capitol by an edict of the curule aediles; when they themselves chose twenty-five out of their own body, to whom they paid a contribution out of their dowries, from which a golden basin was made, as a present, and carried to the Aventine, where a sacrifice was performed by the matrons in a pure and chaste manner. Immediately a day was given out by the decemviri for another sacrifice to the same goddess, which was performed in the following order: two white heifers were led from the temple of Apollo into the city through the Carmental gate; after these, two cypress images of Juno Regina were carried; after these went seven and twenty virgins, arrayed in white vestments, and singing in honour of Juno Regina a hymn, which to the uncultivated minds of that time might appear to have merit, but if repeated now would seem inelegant and uncouth. The train of virgins was followed by the decemvirs, crowned with laurel, and in purple-bordered robes. From the gate they proceeded by the Jugarian street into the forum: in the forum the procession stopped, and the virgins, linked together by a cord passed through their hands, moved on, beating time with their feet to the music of their voices. They then proceeded by the Tuscan street and the Velabrum, through the cattle market, up the Publician hill, and to the temple of Juno Regina; where two victims were immolated by the decemviri, and the cypress images carried into the temple.

Before the consuls set out, a nine-day sacred ritual was held because a shower of stones had fallen from the sky at Veii. After one strange event was noted, others were reported, as is often the case. At Minturnae, it was reported that the temple of Jupiter and the grove of Marica were struck by lightning, and at Atella, a wall and gate experienced the same fate. The people of Minturnae reported something more alarming: a stream of blood had flowed at their gate. In Capua, a wolf that had entered through the gate at night had attacked a watchman. These strange occurrences were atoned for with larger victims, and a day of supplication was held, as directed by the pontiffs. The nine-day sacred rite was performed again, as another shower of stones was seen during the armilustrum. After the people's superstitious fears were eased, they were disturbed again by the news that an infant had been born in Frusino, as large as a four-year-old. It was not just the size that shocked them, but that it had no clear sign of being male or female, similar to an occurrence two years before at Sinuessa. Aruspices from Etruria were called in and declared this to be an evil omen that should be removed from Roman territory; they suggested that it be placed in a chest and thrown into the sea. The infant was confined alive in a chest and thrown into the ocean. The pontiffs also decreed that thirty virgins should walk through the city singing a hymn. While they were learning this hymn, written by the poet Livius, in the temple of Jupiter Stator, the temple of Juno Regina on the Aventine was struck by lightning. When the aruspices were consulted, they said this omen pertained to the matrons and that the goddess needed to be appeased with a gift. The matrons living within the city and within ten miles of it were summoned to the Capitol through an edict from the curule aediles; they chose twenty-five from their ranks and contributed from their dowries to create a golden basin as an offering, which was then taken to the Aventine, where the matrons performed a pure and chaste sacrifice. Soon after, the decemviri announced a day for another sacrifice to the same goddess, which was conducted as follows: two white heifers were led from the temple of Apollo into the city through the Carmental gate; following them were two cypress images of Juno Regina; then came twenty-seven virgins dressed in white garments, singing a hymn in honor of Juno Regina that might have seemed impressive to the unsophisticated minds of that time, but now would appear clumsy and awkward. The group of virgins was followed by the decemvirs, crowned with laurel and wearing purple-bordered robes. They proceeded from the gate along Jugarian Street into the forum; in the forum, the procession halted, and the virgins, linked by a cord passed through their hands, moved together, keeping time with their feet to the rhythm of their singing. They then continued down Tuscan Street and Velabrum, through the cattle market, up Publician Hill, and to the temple of Juno Regina, where the decemviri offered two victims and brought the cypress images into the temple.

38

After the deities were appeased in due form, the consuls made the levy with greater diligence and strictness than any one remembered it to have been made in former years; for the war was now doubly formidable, in consequence of the advance of a new enemy into Italy, while the number of the youth from which they could enlist soldiers was diminished. They therefore resolved to compel the settlers upon the sea-coast, who were said to possess an exemption from service solemnly granted, to furnish soldiers; and on their refusing to do so, appointed that they should severally lay before the senate, on a certain day, the grounds on which they claimed exemption. On the appointed day the following people came to the senate: the people of Ostia, Alsia, Antium, Anxur, Minturnae, and Sinuessa, and, on the upper sea, Sena. After each people had stated their grounds of exemption, the exemption of none was allowed, as the enemy was in Italy, except those of Antium and Ostia, and of these colonies the young men were bound by oath that they would not lodge without the walls of their colony, while the enemy was in Italy, more than thirty days. Although it was the opinion of all that the consuls ought to proceed to the war as soon as possible, (for Hasdrubal ought to be met on his descent from the Alps, lest he might seduce the Cisalpine Gauls and Etruria, which was anxiously looking forward to a revolution; while it was necessary to occupy Hannibal with a war in his own quarters, lest he should emerge from Bruttium, and advance to meet his brother;) yet Livius delayed, not having sufficient confidence in the armies destined for his provinces. He said his colleague had his option to take which he pleased out of two excellent consular armies, and a third which Quintus Claudius commanded at Tarentum. He also made mention of recalling the volunteer slaves to their standards. The senate gave the consuls unrestricted liberty of filling up their numbers from what source they pleased, of selecting out of all the armies such as they liked, and of exchanging and removing from one province to another, as they thought conducive to the good of the state. In all these affairs the consuls acted with the most perfect harmony. The volunteer slaves were enlisted into the nineteenth and twentieth legions. Some authors state that very efficient auxiliaries were sent out of Spain also to Marcus Livius by Publius Scipio; namely, eight thousand Spaniards and Gauls, two thousand legionary soldiers, a thousand horse of Numidians and Spaniards together. That Marcus Lucretius brought these forces in ships, and that Caius Mamilius sent as many as four thousand bowmen and slingers out of Sicily.

After the gods were properly honored, the consuls conducted the recruitment drive with more urgency and strictness than anyone could remember from previous years. The war had become even more daunting because a new enemy had entered Italy, while the pool of young people available for enlistment had shrunk. So, they decided to force the coastal settlers—who claimed they had a formal exemption from service—to provide soldiers. When they refused, the consuls made them present their reasons for claiming exemption to the senate on an appointed day. On that day, representatives from Ostia, Alsia, Antium, Anxur, Minturnae, Sinuessa, and Sena arrived at the senate. After each group presented their reasons, none were granted exemption due to the presence of the enemy in Italy, except for Antium and Ostia. The young men from these colonies were bound by oath not to leave their city walls for more than thirty days while the enemy was in Italy. Although everyone believed the consuls should move quickly to confront the war (since Hasdrubal needed to be met as he descended from the Alps to prevent him from winning over the Cisalpine Gauls and Etruria, which were eagerly anticipating a change, and it was crucial to keep Hannibal occupied in his own territory to prevent him from advancing from Bruttium to join his brother), Livius hesitated, lacking confidence in the armies prepared for his provinces. He mentioned that his colleague had the option to choose from two excellent consular armies and a third led by Quintus Claudius at Tarentum. He also discussed the possibility of recalling the volunteer slaves to their posts. The senate gave the consuls full authority to recruit from any available source, select troops from any of the armies, and transfer units between provinces as they believed would benefit the state. The consuls coordinated these efforts seamlessly. The volunteer slaves were assigned to the nineteenth and twentieth legions. Some historians say that Publius Scipio sent effective reinforcements to Marcus Livius from Spain, including eight thousand Spaniards and Gauls, two thousand legionary soldiers, and a thousand cavalry made up of Numidians and Spaniards. Marcus Lucretius transported these forces by ship, while Caius Mamilius sent an additional four thousand archers and slingers from Sicily.

39

A letter which was brought out of Gaul from Lucius Porcius, the praetor, increased the alarm at Rome. It stated that Hasdrubal had quitted his winter quarters, and was now crossing the Alps; that eight thousand Ligurians had been enlisted and armed, which would join him when he had crossed over into Italy, unless some general were sent into Liguria to engage them with a war. That he would himself advance as far as he thought it safe with his small forces. This letter obliged the consuls hastily to conclude the levy, and go earlier than they had determined into their provinces, with the intention that each should keep his enemy in his own province, and not allow them to form a junction or concentrate their forces. This object was much aided by an opinion possessed by Hannibal; for although he felt assured that his brother would cross over into Italy that summer, yet when he recollected what difficulties he had himself experienced through a period of five months, first in crossing the Rhone, then the Alps, contending against men, and the nature of the ground, he was far from expecting that his transit would be so easy and expeditious, and this was the cause of his moving more slowly from his winter quarters. But all things were done by Hasdrubal with less delay and trouble than he himself or any others expected. For the Arverni, and after them the other Gallic and Alpine nations in succession, not only gave him a friendly reception, but followed him to the war; and not only had roads been formed during the passage of his brother in most of the countries through which he marched, and which were before impassable, but also as the Alps had been passable for a period of twelve years, he marched through tribes of less ferocious dispositions. For before that time, being never visited by foreigners, nor accustomed, themselves, to see a stranger in their country, they were unsociable to the whole human race. And at first, not knowing whither the Carthaginian was going, they had imagined that their own rocks and forts, and the plunder of their cattle and people, were his objects; but afterwards, the report of the Punic war with which Italy was being desolated for now ten years, had convinced them that the Alps were only a passage, and that two very powerful nations, separated from each other by a vast tract of sea and land, were contending for empire and power. These were the causes which opened the Alps to Hasdrubal. But the advantage which he gained by the celerity of his march he lost by his delay at Placentia, while he carried on a fruitless siege, rather than an assault. He had supposed that it would be easy to take by storm a town situated on a plain; and the celebrity of the colony induced him to believe that by destroying it he should strike great terror into the rest. This siege not only impeded his own progress, but had the effect of restraining Hannibal, who was just on the point of quitting his winter quarters, after hearing of his passage, which was so much quicker than he expected; for he not only revolved in his mind how tedious was the siege of towns, but also how ineffectual was his attempt upon that same colony, when returning victorious from the Trebia.

A letter that came out of Gaul from Lucius Porcius, the praetor, intensified the alarm in Rome. It said that Hasdrubal had left his winter quarters and was now crossing the Alps; that eight thousand Ligurians had been recruited and armed, ready to join him once he entered Italy unless a general was sent to Liguria to engage them in battle. He would advance as far as he deemed safe with his small forces. This letter forced the consuls to quickly wrap up the recruitment and head to their provinces earlier than planned, with the goal that each would keep his enemy in their own province, preventing them from joining forces. This aim was greatly aided by Hannibal's belief; while he was sure his brother would enter Italy that summer, he remembered the hardships he had faced over five months—first crossing the Rhone, then the Alps, battling both men and the challenging terrain—so he didn’t expect his brother’s passage to be easy or quick, which was why he moved more slowly from his winter quarters. However, Hasdrubal accomplished everything with less delay and trouble than anyone anticipated. The Arverni, followed by other Gallic and Alpine tribes, not only welcomed him but also joined him for war. Roads had been established during his brother’s journey through many of the regions he crossed, previously impassable, and since the Alps had been navigable for twelve years, he marched through tribes that were less aggressive. Before that time, these tribes had never encountered foreigners and were unaccustomed to seeing strangers in their land, so they were unfriendly to everyone. At first, without knowing where the Carthaginian was heading, they thought he was after their rocks and forts and the plunder of their livestock and people; but later, news of the Punic War that had ravaged Italy for ten years convinced them that the Alps were just a passage, and that two powerful nations, separated by a vast sea and land, were fighting for control. These factors opened the Alps to Hasdrubal. However, he lost the advantage gained by his swift march due to the delays at Placentia, where he conducted a fruitless siege instead of an assault. He thought it would be easy to capture a town on a plain quickly, and the fame of the colony led him to believe that destroying it would instill great fear in the others. This siege not only hindered his own progress but also restrained Hannibal, who was just about to leave his winter quarters after hearing about Hasdrubal's much quicker crossing than he expected; he contemplated the tediousness of besieging cities and how ineffective his own attempt on that same colony had been when he returned victorious from the Trebia.

40

The consuls, on departing from the city in different directions, had drawn the attention of the public, as it were, to two wars at once, while they called to mind the disasters which Hannibal's first coming had brought upon Italy, and at the same time, tortured with anxiety, asked themselves what deities would be so propitious to the city and empire as that the commonwealth should be victorious in both quarters at once. Hitherto they had been enabled to hold out to the present time by compensating for their misfortunes by their successes. When the Roman power was laid prostrate at the Trasimenus and at Cannae in Italy, their successes in Spain had raised it up from its fallen condition. Afterwards, when in Spain one disaster after another had in a great measure destroyed two armies, with the loss of two distinguished generals, the many successes in Italy and Sicily had, as it were, afforded a haven for the shattered state; and the mere interval of space, as one war was going on in the remotest quarter of the world, gave them time to recover their breath. Whereas now two wars were received into Italy; two generals of the highest renown were besetting the Roman city; while the whole weight of the danger and the entire burden pressed upon one point. Whichever of these generals should be first victorious, he would in a few days unite his camp with the other. The preceding year also, saddened by the deaths of two consuls, filled them with alarm. Such were the anxious feelings with which the people escorted the consuls on their departure to their provinces. It is recorded that Marcus Livius, still teeming with resentment against his countrymen, when setting out to the war, replied to Fabius, who warned him not rashly to come to an action till he had made himself acquainted with the character of his enemy, that as soon as ever he had got sight of the troops of the enemy he would engage them. When asked what was his reason for such haste, he said, "I shall either obtain the highest glory from conquering the enemy, or the greatest joy from the defeat of my countrymen, a joy which they have deserved, though it would not become me." Before the consul Claudius arrived in his province, Caius Hostilius Tubulus, attacking Hannibal with his light cohorts while marching his army through the extreme borders of the territory of Larinum into that of Sallentum, caused terrible confusion in his unmarshalled troops; he killed as many as four thousand, and captured nine military standards. Quintus Claudius, who had his camps distributed through the towns of the Sallentine territory, had quitted his winter quarters on hearing of the enemy; and Hannibal, fearing on that account lest he should have to engage with two armies at once, decamped by night, and retired from the Tarentine to the Bruttian territory. Claudius turned his army to the Sallentine territory. Hostilius, on his way to Capua, met the consul Claudius at Venusia. Here forty thousand infantry and two thousand five hundred horse were selected from both armies, with which the consul might carry on the war against Hannibal. The rest of the troops Hostilius was directed to march to Capua to deliver them over to Quintus Fulvius, proconsul.

The consuls, leaving the city in different directions, captured the public's attention by highlighting two wars at once. They remembered the disasters that Hannibal's arrival had caused in Italy and anxiously wondered which gods would be kind enough to ensure the city and empire would win in both conflicts at the same time. Up until now, they had managed to endure by counterbalancing their misfortunes with victories. When Roman power was brought low at Trasimenus and Cannae in Italy, their successes in Spain had lifted them back up. Later, when a series of defeats had largely wiped out two armies and taken the lives of two notable generals in Spain, their many achievements in Italy and Sicily provided refuge for the struggling state; the distance of one war happening far away allowed them time to regroup. But now, two wars were reaching into Italy; two renowned generals were threatening the Roman city, and all the danger was concentrated in one place. Whoever gained the upper hand first would quickly join forces with the other. The previous year had also been filled with dread due to the deaths of two consuls. This was the anxious mindset with which the people sent off the consuls to their provinces. It’s said that Marcus Livius, still filled with anger against his fellow countrymen, responded to Fabius—who cautioned him not to rush into battle until he understood his enemy—by saying that as soon as he saw the enemy troops, he would engage. When asked why he was in such a hurry, he replied, "I will either win great glory by defeating the enemy or find joy in the downfall of my countrymen, a joy they have earned, though it isn’t right for me to feel." Before Consul Claudius reached his province, Caius Hostilius Tubulus attacked Hannibal with his light troops while moving his army from the far corners of Larinum into Sallentum, causing chaos among his disorganized forces; he killed about four thousand and captured nine military standards. Quintus Claudius, who had his camps set up across the towns of the Sallentine area, left his winter quarters upon hearing about the enemy. Hannibal, fearing he might have to face two armies at once, stealthily broke camp at night and retreated from the Tarentine to the Bruttian territory. Claudius then redirected his army toward the Sallentine territory. On his way to Capua, Hostilius encountered Consul Claudius at Venusia. There, they selected forty thousand infantry and two thousand five hundred cavalry from both armies for the consul to continue the fight against Hannibal. The rest of the troops were to be marched to Capua to be handed over to Quintus Fulvius, the proconsul.

41

Hannibal, having drawn together his forces from all quarters, both those which he had in winter quarters, and those which he had in the garrisons of the Bruttian territory, came to Grumentum in Lucania, with the hope of regaining the towns which through fear had revolted to the Romans. To the same place the Roman consul proceeded from Venusia, exploring the way as he went, and pitched his camp about fifteen hundred paces from the enemy. The rampart of the Carthaginians seemed almost united with the walls of Grumentum, though five hundred paces intervened. Between the Carthaginian and Roman camps lay a plain; and overhanging the left wing of the Carthaginians and the right of the Romans were some naked hills, which were not objects of suspicion to either party, as they had no wood upon them, nor any hiding-places for an ambuscade. In the plain which lay between them skirmishes hardly worth mentioning took place between parties sallying from the outposts. It was evident that what the Roman aimed at was to prevent the enemy from going off, while Hannibal, who was desirous of escaping thence, came down with all his forces, and formed in order of battle. Upon this the consul, imitating the crafty character of his enemy, ordered five cohorts, with the addition of five maniples, to pass the summit by night and sit down in the valleys on the opposite side; a measure to which he was prompted the more strongly in proportion as he felt that there could exist no suspicion of an ambuscade in hills so uncovered. Of the time for rising up from their retreat and of falling upon the enemy he informed Tiberius Claudius Asellus, a military tribune, and Publius Claudius, praefect of the allies, whom he sent with them. The general himself, at break of day, drew out all his forces, both foot and horse, for battle. Shortly after, the signal for battle was given out by Hannibal, and a noise was raised in the camp, from the troops running hastily to arms; then both horse and foot eagerly rushed through the gates, and spreading themselves over the plain, hastened to the enemy. The consul perceiving them thus disordered, gave orders to Caius Aurunculeius, a military tribune of the third legion, to send out the cavalry of the legion to charge the enemy with all possible vehemence, for that the enemy had spread themselves like cattle in such disorder throughout the whole plain, that they might be knocked down and trampled under foot before they could be formed.

Hannibal, having gathered his forces from all directions, including those in winter quarters and those in the Bruttian garrisons, arrived at Grumentum in Lucania, hoping to reclaim the towns that had defected to the Romans out of fear. The Roman consul also moved from Venusia to the same location, scouting along the way, and set up camp about fifteen hundred paces from the enemy. The Carthaginian rampart seemed nearly connected to the walls of Grumentum, even though there were five hundred paces in between. A plain lay between the Carthaginian and Roman camps, and some bare hills overlooked the left flank of the Carthaginians and the right flank of the Romans. These hills posed no threat to either side as they lacked trees or hiding spots for ambushes. In the plain between them, skirmishes took place that weren't worth mentioning, with small groups breaking from their outposts. The Romans clearly aimed to prevent the enemy from retreating, while Hannibal, wanting to get away, gathered all his forces and arranged them for battle. In response, the consul, mirroring the cunning approach of his enemy, ordered five cohorts, along with five maniples, to cross the summit at night and position themselves in the valleys on the other side. This plan felt more feasible to him since there was no suspicion of an ambush in such exposed hills. He briefed Tiberius Claudius Asellus, a military tribune, and Publius Claudius, the praefect of the allies, about when to rise from their hiding spots and attack the enemy. At dawn, the consul mobilized all his troops, both infantry and cavalry, for battle. Shortly after, Hannibal signaled for battle, causing a commotion in the camp as troops hurried to arm themselves; then both cavalry and infantry rushed through the gates, spread out across the plain, and advanced toward the enemy. Seeing them in disarray, the consul instructed Caius Aurunculeius, a military tribune of the third legion, to send the legion's cavalry to charge the enemy with full force, as the enemy had scattered across the plain like livestock, allowing them to be overwhelmed and trampled before they could regroup.

42

Hannibal had not yet gone out of the camp, when he heard the shout of his troops engaged; and thus roused by the alarm, he hastily led his forces against the enemy. Already had the Roman horse spread terror through the Carthaginian van; the first legion also of the infantry and the right wing were commencing the action, while the troops of the Carthaginians, in disorder, engaged just as chance threw each in the way of horse or foot. The battle became more general by reinforcements, and the number of those who ran out to the combat. Hannibal, amid the terror and confusion, would have drawn up his troops while fighting, (which would not have been an easy task unless to a veteran general with veteran soldiers,) had not the shouts of the cohorts and maniples, running down from the hills, which was heard in their rear, created an alarm lest they should be cut off from their camp. After this they were seized with a panic, and a flight commenced in every part; but the number slain was less, because the nearness of the camp offered to the terrified troops a shorter distance to fly. For the cavalry hung upon their rear, and the cohorts, running down the declivities of the hills by an unobstructed and easy path, charged them transversely in flank. However, above eight thousand men were slain, above seven hundred made prisoners, and eight military standards taken. Of the elephants also, which had been of no use in such a sudden and irregular action, four were killed and two captured. The conquerors lost about five hundred Romans and allies. The following day the Carthaginian remained quiet. The Roman having led out his troops into the field, when he saw that no one came out to meet him, gave orders that the spoils of those of the enemy who were slain should be collected, and that the bodies of his own men should be gathered into one place and buried. After this, for several days following in succession, he came up so near the enemy's gates that he almost seemed to be carrying in his standards. But at length Hannibal at the third watch, leaving a number of fires and tents in that part of the camp which faced the enemy, and also a few Numidians who might show themselves in the rampart and the gates, decamped and proceeded towards Apulia. As soon as it dawned, the Roman army came up to the trenches, and the Numidians, according to the plan concerted, took care to show themselves for a little time on the rampart and in the gates; and having deceived the enemy for some time, rode off at full speed, and overtook their friends on their march. The consul, when all was silence in the camp, and he could now no where see even the few who at break of day had walked up and down, sent two horsemen in advance to reconnoitre; and after he had ascertained that all was safe enough, ordered his troops to march in; and after staying there only while his men distributed themselves for plunder, sounded a retreat and led back his forces long before night. The next day he set out as soon as it was light, and following the rumour and the track of the enemy by forced marches, came up with them not far from Venusia. Here also an irregular battle took place, in which two thousand of the Carthaginians were slain. The Carthaginian quitting this place made for Metapontum, marching by night and over mountainous districts in order to avoid a battle. Thence Hanno, who commanded the garrison of that place, was sent into Bruttium with a small party to raise a fresh army. Hannibal, after adding his forces to his own, went back to Venusia by the same route by which he came, and proceeded thence to Canusium. Nero had never quitted the enemy's steps, and when he himself went to Metapontum, had sent for Quintus Fulvius into Lucania, lest that region should be left without protection.

Hannibal had just stepped out of the camp when he heard the shout of his troops in battle. Alarmed by the noise, he quickly led his forces against the enemy. The Roman cavalry had already caused panic among the Carthaginian front line; the first infantry legion and the right wing were also starting to engage in combat, while the Carthaginian troops, thrown into disarray, fought as chance placed them in the path of horse or foot. The battle intensified with reinforcements arriving and more soldiers rushing to join the combat. In the midst of the chaos, Hannibal tried to organize his troops while they fought, which would have been a challenging task for anyone but a seasoned general with battle-hardened soldiers. However, the shouts of the cohorts and maniples coming down from the hills behind them created fear that they might be cut off from their camp. This led to panic, and a rout began in every direction; however, fewer were killed because the proximity of the camp provided the terrified troops a shorter escape route. The cavalry pursued them, while the cohorts charged down the hills from an open path, hitting them from the side. In the end, over eight thousand men were killed, more than seven hundred taken prisoner, and eight military standards captured. Among the elephants, which had been useless in such a sudden and chaotic fight, four were killed and two captured. The victors lost about five hundred Romans and allies. The following day, the Carthaginians remained quiet. The Romans brought their troops into the field, and when they saw no one coming to confront them, they ordered the spoils from the slain enemy to be collected and their own dead to be gathered and buried in one place. After this, for several consecutive days, they advanced so close to the enemy's gates that it almost seemed like they would bring their standards inside. Finally, at the third watch, Hannibal left several campfires and tents facing the enemy, as well as a few Numidians to appear at the ramparts and gates, before packing up and moving towards Apulia. Once dawn broke, the Roman army approached the trenches, and the Numidians, following the agreed plan, briefly showed themselves at the rampart and gates. After deceiving the enemy for a while, they quickly rode off and rejoined their allies on the march. The consul, noticing the silence in the camp and seeing that even the few who had been walking around at dawn were gone, sent two horsemen ahead to scout. Once he confirmed that it was safe, he ordered his troops to enter the camp and, after allowing them to distribute the spoils, called for a retreat and led his forces back long before nightfall. The next day, he set out at first light, following the rumors and trail of the enemy on forced marches, and caught up with them not far from Venusia. Another irregular battle ensued, where two thousand Carthaginians were killed. The Carthaginians abandoned this place, heading for Metapontum, marching at night over rough terrain to avoid another fight. From there, Hanno, who commanded the garrison, was sent into Bruttium with a small party to raise a new army. Hannibal, after bolstering his forces with those he had gathered, returned to Venusia by the same route he had taken and then moved on to Canusium. Nero had never left the enemy's trail and when he went to Metapontum, he called for Quintus Fulvius to come into Lucania to ensure that area would not be left unprotected.

43

Meanwhile four Gallic horsemen and two Numidians, who were sent to Hannibal with a letter from Hasdrubal, after he had retired from the siege of Placentia, having traversed nearly the whole length of Italy through the midst of enemies, while following Hannibal as he was retiring to Metapontum, were taken to Tarentum by mistaking the roads; where they were seized by some Roman foragers, who were straggling through the fields, and brought before the proprietor, Caius Claudius. At first they endeavoured to baffle him by evasive answers, but threats of applying torture being held out to them, they were compelled to confess the truth; when they fully admitted that they were the bearers of a letter from Hasdrubal to Hannibal. They were delivered into the custody of Lucius Virginius, a military tribune, together with the letter sealed as it was, to be conveyed to the consul Claudius. At the same time two troops of Samnites were sent with them as an escort. Having made their way to the consul, the letter was read by means of an interpreter, and the captives were interrogated; when Claudius, coming to the conclusion that the predicament of the state was not such as that her generals should carry on the war, each within the limits of his own province, and with his own troops, according to the customary plans of warfare, and with an enemy marked out for him by the senate, but that some unlooked for and unexpected enterprise must be attempted, which, in its commencement, might cause no less dread among their countrymen than their enemies, but which, when accomplished, might convert their great fear into great joy, sent the letter of Hasdrubal to Rome to the senate; and at the same time informed the conscript fathers what his intentions were; and recommended that, as Hasdrubal had written to his brother that he should meet him in Umbria, they should send for the legion from Capua to Rome, enlist troops at Rome, and oppose the city forces to the enemy at Narnia. Such was his letter to the senate. Messengers were sent in advance through the territory of Larinum, Marrucia, Frentana, and Praetutia, where he was about to march his army, with orders that they should all bring down from their farms and towns to the road-side provisions ready dressed for the soldiers to eat; and that they should bring out horses and other beasts of burden, so that those who were tired might have plenty of conveyances. He then selected the choicest troops out of the whole army of the Romans and allies, to the amount of six thousand infantry and one thousand horse; and gave out that he intended to seize on the nearest town in Lucania and the Carthaginian garrison in it, and that they should all be in readiness to march. Setting out by night he turned off towards Picenum, and making his marches as long as possible, led his troops to join his colleague, having left Quintus Catius, lieutenant-general, in command of the camp.

Meanwhile, four Gallic horsemen and two Numidians, who were sent to Hannibal with a letter from Hasdrubal after he pulled back from the siege of Placentia, traveled almost the entire length of Italy through enemy territory while following Hannibal as he retreated to Metapontum. They ended up in Tarentum by taking the wrong roads, where they were captured by some Roman foragers wandering through the fields. They were brought before Caius Claudius, the landowner. At first, they tried to mislead him with vague answers, but when he threatened them with torture, they were forced to tell the truth and admitted they were carrying a letter from Hasdrubal to Hannibal. They were handed over to Lucius Virginius, a military tribune, along with the sealed letter to be delivered to consul Claudius. At the same time, two groups of Samnites were sent along as an escort. Once they reached the consul, the letter was read with the help of an interpreter, and the captives were questioned. Claudius concluded that the situation of the state required a more creative approach rather than having each general fight within their own territory with their own troops, as was customarily done. Instead, an unexpected operation was necessary, one that could instill fear in their fellow countrymen as well as their enemies, but that could also turn that fear into joy once it succeeded. He sent Hasdrubal's letter to Rome for the senate and informed the senators of his plans. He proposed that, since Hasdrubal had instructed his brother to meet him in Umbria, they should summon the legion from Capua to Rome, recruit troops in Rome, and send forces to confront the enemy at Narnia. This was his letter to the senate. Messengers were dispatched through the territories of Larinum, Marrucia, Frentana, and Praetutia, where he planned to march his army, with orders for them to prepare ready-made food for the soldiers along the roadside; they were also to provide horses and other pack animals so that the weary could have ample transportation. He chose the best soldiers from the entire Roman and allied army, totaling six thousand infantry and one thousand cavalry, announcing his intention to capture the nearest town in Lucania and its Carthaginian garrison, urging everyone to be ready to march. Setting out at night, he headed toward Picenum, extending his marches as much as possible, leading his troops to join his colleague while leaving Quintus Catius, the lieutenant-general, in charge of the camp.

44

At Rome the alarm and consternation were not less than they had been two years before, when the Carthaginian camp was pitched over against the Roman walls and gates; nor could people make up their minds whether they should commend, or censure, this so bold march of the consul. It was evident that the light in which it would be viewed would depend upon its success; than which nothing can be more unfair. They said, "that the camp was left near to the enemy, Hannibal, without a general, and with an army from which all the flower and vigour had been withdrawn; and that the consul had pretended an expedition into Lucania, when he was in reality going to Picenum and Gaul, leaving his camp secured only by the ignorance of the enemy, who were not aware that the general and part of his army were away. What would be the consequence if that should be discovered, and Hannibal should think proper either to pursue Nero with his whole army, who had gone off with only six thousand armed men, or to assault the camp, which was left as a prey for him, without strength, without command, without auspices?" The disasters already experienced in the war, the deaths of two consuls the preceding year, augmented their fears. Besides, all these events had occurred "when there was only one general and one army of the enemy in Italy; whereas now they had two Punic wars, two immense armies, and in a manner two Hannibals in Italy, inasmuch as Hasdrubal was descended from the same father, Hamilcar, was a general equally enterprising, having been trained in a Roman war during so many years in Spain, and rendered famous by a double victory, having annihilated two armies with two most renowned generals. For he could glory even more than Hannibal himself, on account of the celerity with which he had effected his passage out of Spain, and his success in stirring up the Gallic nations to arms, inasmuch as he had collected an army in those very regions in which Hannibal lost the major part of his soldiers by famine and cold, the most miserable modes of death." Those who were experienced in the events which had occurred in Spain, added, that "he would not have to engage with Caius Nero, the general, as an unknown person, whom, when accidentally caught in a difficult defile, he had eluded and baffled like a little child, by drawing up fallacious terms of peace." Under the dictation of fear, which always puts the worst construction upon things, they magnified all the advantages which the enemy possessed, and undervalued their own.

At Rome, the panic and fear were just as intense as two years earlier when the Carthaginian camp was set up against the Roman walls and gates. People couldn't decide whether to praise or criticize this bold move by the consul. It was clear that how it was perceived would depend entirely on its outcome, which was incredibly unfair. They said, "The camp was left close to the enemy, Hannibal, without a general and with an army that had lost its best fighters and strength. The consul pretended to be headed to Lucania, but he was actually going to Picenum and Gaul, leaving his camp only safe because the enemy was unaware that the general and part of his army were gone. What would happen if this were discovered, and Hannibal decided to either chase after Nero with his entire army, who left with only six thousand armed men, or attack the camp, which was left vulnerable without defense, command, or guidance?" The disasters already faced in the war and the deaths of two consuls the previous year only heightened their fears. Moreover, all of this had happened "when there was only one enemy general and one army in Italy; now there were two Punic wars, two massive armies, and effectively two Hannibals in Italy since Hasdrubal came from the same father, Hamilcar, and was an equally adventurous general. He had been trained in warfare in Spain for many years and gained fame by annihilating two armies led by two renowned generals. He could take pride even more than Hannibal himself for the speed with which he crossed out of Spain and his success in rallying the Gallic nations to arms, having gathered an army in the very regions where Hannibal lost most of his soldiers to hunger and cold, the most miserable ways to die." Those who were familiar with the events that had taken place in Spain remarked that "he wouldn't be facing Caius Nero, the general, as a stranger. He had previously escaped and outsmarted him like a child caught in a tough spot by tricking him with false peace terms." Driven by fear, which always interprets things in the worst possible light, they exaggerated the enemy's advantages and downplayed their own.

45

45. When Nero had got such a distance from the enemy that his plan might be disclosed without danger, he briefly addressed his soldiers, observing, that "there never was a measure adopted by any general which was in appearance more daring than this, but in reality more safe. That he was leading them on to certain victory. For as his colleague had not set out to prosecute the war which he conducted, until forces both of horse and foot had been assigned to him by the senate to his own satisfaction, and those greater and better equipped than if he had been going against Hannibal himself, that they would, by joining him, however small the quantity of force which they might add, completely turn the scale. That when it was only heard in the field of battle (and he would take care that it should not be heard before) that another consul and another army had arrived, it would insure the victory. That rumour decided war; and that the most inconsiderable incidents had power to excite hope and fear in the mind. That they would themselves reap almost the entire glory which would be obtained if they succeeded, for it was invariably the case that the last addition which is made is supposed to have effected the whole. That they themselves saw with what multitudes, what admiration, and what good wishes of men their march was attended." And, by Hercules, they marched amid vows, prayers, and commendations, all the roads being lined with ranks of men and women, who had flocked there from all parts of the country. They called them the safeguards of the state, the protectors of the city and empire of Rome. They said that the safety and liberty of themselves and their children were treasured up in their arms and right hands. They prayed to all the gods and goddesses to grant them a prosperous march, a successful battle, and a speedy victory over their enemies; and that they might be bound to pay the vows which they had undertaken in their behalf; so that as now they attended them off with anxiety, go after a few days' interval they might joyfully go out to meet them exulting in victory. Then they severally and earnestly invited them to accept, offered them, and wearied them with entreaties, to take from them in preference to another, whatever might be requisite for themselves or their cattle. They generously gave them every thing in abundance, while the soldiers vied with each other in moderation, taking care not to accept any thing beyond what was necessary for use. They did not make any delay nor quit their ranks when taking food; they continued the march day and night, scarcely giving as much to rest as was necessary to the requirements of the body. Messengers were also despatched in advance to his colleague, to inform him of his approach, and to ask whether he wished that he should come secretly or openly, by day or night, whether they should lodge in the same or different camps. It appeared most advisable that they should come into the camp secretly by night.

45. When Nero had put enough distance between himself and the enemy so that he could share his plan without risk, he quickly addressed his soldiers, saying, “There has never been a move by any general that seemed as bold as this one, but is actually much safer. I’m leading you to certain victory. My colleague didn’t start his campaign until he had secured enough cavalry and infantry provided by the senate, better equipped than if he were facing Hannibal himself. By joining us, no matter how small your forces are, you will tip the balance completely. Once word gets out on the battlefield (and I’ll make sure it doesn’t leak out until then) that another consul and army have arrived, victory will be ensured. Rumors can decide the outcome of wars, and even the smallest events can spark hope and fear. You will share almost all the glory if we succeed because, typically, the last contribution is thought to have made the difference. You can see the massive crowds and the good wishes accompanying our march.” And, by Hercules, they marched with vows, prayers, and cheers, with the roads filled with men and women who had gathered from all over the country. They called them the protectors of the state, the defenders of Rome and its empire. They claimed that their safety and the freedom of their families were entrusted to their arms and hands. They prayed to all the gods and goddesses for a successful march, a victorious battle, and a quick defeat of their enemies; and that they would fulfill the vows made on their behalf, so that, while they left with worry today, in a few days they could joyfully meet them, celebrating their victory. Then they individually and earnestly invited the soldiers to take, offered them, and insisted they take whatever was needed for themselves or their animals. They generously provided everything in abundance, while the soldiers competed with each other to be moderate, making sure they only accepted what was necessary. They didn’t delay or break ranks to eat; they marched day and night, hardly allowing themselves the minimal rest required for their bodies. Messengers were also sent ahead to his colleague to inform him of their arrival and to ask if he preferred they come in secret or openly, during the day or night, and whether they should camp together or separately. It seemed best that they come into camp quietly at night.

46

A private signal was sent through the camp by the consul Livius, that each tribune should receive a tribune, each centurion a centurion, each horseman a horseman, each foot-soldier a foot-soldier; for it was not expedient that the camp should be enlarged, lest the enemy should discover the arrival of the other consul, while the crowding together of several persons, who would have their tents in a confined place, would be attended with less inconvenience, because the army of Claudius had brought with them on their expedition scarcely any thing except their arms. Claudius, on the very march, had augmented his numbers by volunteers; for not only veteran soldiers, who had completed their period of service, but young men also offered themselves without solicitation; and, as they vied with each other in giving in their names, he had enlisted those whose personal appearance and bodily strength seemed fit for military service. The camp of the other consul was near Sena, and Hasdrubal's position was about five hundred paces from it. Nero, therefore, when he was now drawing near, halted under cover of the mountains, in order that he might not enter the camp before night. Having entered when all was still, they were severally conducted into their tents by the men of their own description, where they were hospitably entertained with the utmost joy on the part of all. The next day a council was held, at which Lucius Porcius Licinus, the praetor, was present. He had his camp joined to that of the consuls, and before their arrival, by leading his army along the heights, sometimes occupying narrow defiles that he might intercept his passage, at other times harassing his troops while marching by attacking their flank or rear, he had baffled the enemy by all the arts of war. This man was, on the present occasion, one of the council. Many inclined to the opinion that an engagement should be deferred till Nero had recruited his soldiers, who were weary with marching and watching, and had employed a few days in acquiring a knowledge of his enemy. Nero urged, not only by persuasion, but with the most earnest entreaties, "that they would not render rash by delay that measure of his which despatch had made safe. That Hannibal, who lay in a state of torpid inactivity in consequence of a delusion which would not continue long, had neither attacked his camp, left as it was without a leader, nor had directed his course in pursuit of him. That the army of Hasdrubal might be annihilated, and he might retire into Apulia before he stirred a step. The man who by delay gave time to the enemy both betrayed the camp to Hannibal, and opened a way to him into Gaul, so that he might effect a junction with Hasdrubal at his leisure, and when he pleased. That they ought to give the signal for battle instantly, and march out into the field, and take advantage of the delusion of their enemies present and absent, while neither those were aware that they had fewer, nor these that they had more and stronger forces to encounter." On the breaking up of the council the signal for battle was displayed, and the troops immediately led into the field.

A private signal was sent through the camp by Consul Livius, instructing that each tribune should receive another tribune, each centurion another centurion, each horseman another horseman, and each foot-soldier another foot-soldier; it wasn’t practical to expand the camp, as that might alert the enemy to the arrival of the other consul. It would be less troublesome for everyone to be crowded together in a confined space since Claudius's army had brought almost nothing with them except their weapons. Claudius had increased his ranks with volunteers during the march; not only experienced soldiers who had completed their service but also young men offered to join without being asked, and as they competed to enlist, he took in those who looked fit for military service. The camp of the other consul was near Sena, and Hasdrubal's position was about five hundred paces from it. Therefore, Nero stopped under the mountains to avoid entering the camp before nightfall. Once they entered when all was quiet, they were each shown to their tents by men of their own rank, where they were warmly welcomed and celebrated by everyone. The next day, a council met, with Lucius Porcius Licinus, the praetor, in attendance. His camp was joined to that of the consuls, and before their arrival, he had led his army along the heights, sometimes taking narrow paths to block their advance, and at other times harassing his troops by attacking their flanks or rear, successfully outsmarting the enemy using various military strategies. He was one of the council members at this meeting. Many thought they should wait for Nero to rest his tired soldiers and give them a few days to assess their enemy before engaging. Nero urged them, both by persuasion and with heartfelt pleas, not to make his swift plan risky by delaying it. He mentioned that Hannibal, currently inactive due to a temporary misjudgment, had neither attacked his camp, left without a leader, nor pursued him. He could defeat Hasdrubal’s army and retreat to Apulia before moving. Those who delayed were aiding the enemy by giving Hannibal time to attack and open a path into Gaul to join Hasdrubal when he chose. They should signal for battle immediately, move into the field, and take advantage of their enemy’s confusion while neither side realized their true numbers and strengths. After the council broke up, the battle signal was raised, and the troops were quickly moved into the field.

47

The Carthaginians were already standing before their camp in battle-array. This circumstance delayed the battle: Hasdrubal, who had advanced before the line with a few horsemen, remarked some old shields among the enemy, which he had not seen before, and some horses leaner than the rest their numbers also appeared greater than usual. Suspecting therefore, what was really the case, he hastily sounded a retreat, and sent a party to the river from which they got their water, where some of them might be intercepted, and notice taken whether there were perchance any there whose complexions were more than ordinarily sun-burnt, as from a recent march. At the same time he ordered a party to ride round the camp at a distance, and note whether the rampart was extended in any part, and also observe whether the signal sounded once or twice. Having received a report of all these particulars, the fact of the camp's not being enlarged led him into error. There were now two camps, as there were before the other consul arrived, one belonging to Marcus Livius, the other to Lucius Porcius, and to neither of them had any addition been made to give more room for the tents. But the veteran general, who was accustomed to a Roman enemy, was much struck by their reporting that the signal sounded once in the praetor's camp, and twice in the consul's; there must therefore be two consuls, and felt the most painful anxiety as to the manner in which the other had got away from Hannibal. Least of all could he suspect, what was really the case, that he had got away from Hannibal by deceiving him to such an extent, as that he knew not where the general was, and where the army whose camp stood opposite to his own. Surely, he concluded, deterred by a defeat of no ordinary kind, he has not dared to pursue him; and he began to entertain the most serious fears that he had himself come too late with assistance, now that affairs were desperate, and lest the same good fortune attended the Roman arms in Italy which they had experienced in Spain. Sometimes he imagined that his letter could not have reached him, and that, it having been intercepted, the consul had hastened to overpower him. Thus anxious and perplexed, having put out the fires, he issued a signal at the first watch to collect the baggage in silence, and gave orders to march. In the hurry and confusion occasioned by a march by night, their guides were not watched with sufficient care and attention. One of them stopped in a place of concealment which he had beforehand fixed upon in his mind, the other swam across the river Metaurus, at a ford with which he was acquainted. The troops, thus deserted by their guides, at first wandered up and down through the fields; and some of them, overpowered with sleep, and fatigued with, watching, stretched themselves on the ground here and there, leaving their standards thinly attended. Hasdrubal gave orders to march along the bank of the river until the light should discover the road; but, pursuing a circuitous and uncertain course along the turnings and windings of that tortuous river, with the intention of crossing it as soon as the first light should discover a place convenient for the purpose he made but little progress; but wasting the day in a fruitless attempt to discover a ford, for the further he went from the sea the higher he found the banks which kept the river in its course, he gave the enemy time to overtake him.

The Carthaginians were already positioned in battle formation in front of their camp. This situation delayed the battle: Hasdrubal, who had moved ahead of the line with a few horsemen, noticed some old shields among the enemy that he hadn't seen before, and some horses that looked leaner than the others; their numbers also seemed larger than usual. Suspecting the truth, he quickly ordered a retreat and sent a team to the river where they sourced their water, hoping to intercept some of them and check if any had unusually sunburnt skin from a recent march. At the same time, he instructed a group to ride around the camp from a distance to see if the rampart was extended at any point and to watch for any signals that sounded once or twice. After receiving report on these matters, he was misled by the fact that the camp hadn't expanded. There were still two camps, as there had been before the other consul arrived, one for Marcus Livius and the other for Lucius Porcius, and neither had been extended to accommodate more tents. However, the experienced general, who was used to facing Roman enemies, was perturbed by the report that the signal sounded once in the praetor's camp and twice in the consul's; there must therefore be two consuls, and he felt intense anxiety about how the other had managed to escape from Hannibal. He could hardly suspect that he had eluded Hannibal by deceiving him to such a degree that Hannibal had no idea where he was or where the army with the camp opposite him was positioned. Surely, he thought, deterred by a significant defeat, he wouldn't dare to chase him; and he began to worry deeply that he had arrived too late with help, now that the situation was dire, and fearing that the Roman forces in Italy were experiencing the same fortune they had in Spain. Sometimes he wondered if his letter had even reached him, imagining that if it had been intercepted, the consul would rush to overpower him. Anxious and confused, after putting out the fires, he signaled at the first watch for the troops to gather their baggage quietly and gave the order to march. In the chaos and hurry of a nighttime march, their guides weren’t monitored closely enough. One guide halted at a spot he had previously chosen to hide, while the other swam across the river Metaurus at a familiar ford. The troops, thus abandoned by their guides, initially wandered through the fields; some, overwhelmed by sleep and exhaustion from watching, lay down on the ground here and there, leaving their standards poorly attended. Hasdrubal ordered them to march along the riverbank until daylight revealed the path; however, by taking a long and uncertain route along the twists and turns of the winding river, intending to cross it as soon as there was enough light to find a suitable spot, he made little headway. Instead, he wasted the day in a fruitless search for a ford; the further he moved from the sea, the higher the banks rose that confined the river, allowing the enemy to catch up with him.

48

First Nero arrived with the whole body of his cavalry, then Porcius came up with him, with the light infantry. And while these were harassing his weary troops on every side, and charging them, and the Carthaginian, stopping his march, which resembled a flight, was desirous of encamping on an eminence, on the bank of the river, Livius came up with all his foot forces, not after the manner of troops on march, but armed and marshalled for immediate action. When they had united all their forces, and the line was drawn out, Claudius took the direction of the battle in the right wing, Livius in the left; the management of the centre was given to the praetor. Hasdrubal, when he saw that an engagement was inevitable, giving over the fortification of a camp, placed his elephants in the front line, before the standards; on either side these he placed in the left wing the Gauls to oppose Claudius, not so much from any confidence he reposed in them, as because he believed them to be dreaded by the enemy; the right wing he took to himself against M. Livius, together with the Spaniards, in whom, as being veteran troops, he placed his greatest hopes. Behind the elephants, in the centre, the Ligurians were posted; but his line was rather long than deep. The Gauls were covered by a hill, which extended in front. That part of the line which was occupied by the Spaniards, engaged the left wing of the Romans, the whole of whose right wing, extending beyond the line of battle, was unengaged. The hill before them prevented their making an attack either in front or flank. Between Livius and Hasdrubal a furious contest arose, and the slaughter on both sides was dreadful. Here were both generals, here the major part of the Roman horse and infantry, here the Spaniards, veteran troops, and experienced in the Roman manner of fighting, and the Ligurians, a nation inured to war. The elephants were also driven to the same place which, on the first onset, disordered the van, and had made even dislodged the standards; but afterwards, the contest growing hotter, and the shout increasing, they became less submissive to their riders, and ranged to and fro between the two lines, as if not knowing to which side they belonged, like ships floating about without rudders. Claudius, when he had striven in vain to advance up the hill, repeatedly calling out to his soldiers, "To what purpose then have we performed so long a march with such expedition?" when he found it impossible to make his way to the enemy in that quarter, withdrawing several cohorts from the right wing, where he saw they would occupy an inactive station, rather than join in the fight, led them round the rear of the line, and, to the surprise not only of the enemy but his own party, charged their right flank; and such was their rapidity, that after showing themselves on their flank, they almost immediately made an attack on their rear. Thus on all sides, in front, flank, and rear, the Spaniards and Ligurians were cut to pieces; and now the carnage had even reached the Gauls. Here the least opposition was found; for a great number of them had quitted their standards, having slunk off during the night, and laid themselves down to sleep up and down the fields, while even those who were present, being tired with marching and watching, for their bodies are most intolerant of fatigue, could scarcely carry their arms upon their shoulders. And now it was mid-day, and thirst and heat gave them over to the enemy to be killed or captured in multitudes.

First, Nero arrived with all his cavalry, then Porcius came up with him, bringing the light infantry. While they harassed his tired troops from every direction, and the Carthaginian halted his retreat to camp on a high bank by the river, Livius arrived with all his foot soldiers, not in a marching formation but fully armed and ready for immediate battle. Once their forces combined and the line was formed, Claudius took command of the right wing, Livius the left; the praetor managed the center. When Hasdrubal saw that a fight was unavoidable, he abandoned building his camp, placing his elephants at the front line, in front of the standards. To oppose Claudius, he positioned the Gauls on the left wing, not out of trust in them, but because he thought they would intimidate the enemy; he reserved the right wing for himself against M. Livius, along with the veteran Spaniards, whom he counted on the most. Behind the elephants in the center, he stationed the Ligurians; however, his line was long rather than deep. The Gauls were protected by a hill in front of them. The Spaniards engaged the Roman left wing, while the entire Roman right wing extended beyond the battlefield and remained unused. The hill in front of them blocked any frontal or flank attacks. A fierce battle erupted between Livius and Hasdrubal, with heavy casualties on both sides. Here were both generals, most of the Roman cavalry and infantry, the battle-hardened Spaniards, and the seasoned Ligurians. The elephants were also driven into the fray, initially disturbing the front line and dislodging the standards; but as the battle intensified and the shouting grew louder, they became less compliant with their riders, wandering between the two lines as if confused about which side to join, like ships adrift without a captain. Claudius, after unsuccessfully trying to push up the hill and calling out to his soldiers, "What was the point of our long, hurried march?" realized he couldn’t reach the enemy that way. So, he withdrew several cohorts from the right wing, where they would have stayed inactive, and led them around the rear of the line. This caught both the enemy and his own men off guard as they charged the enemy’s right flank. They moved so quickly that after appearing on the flank, they nearly instantly attacked from the rear. Thus, all around, the Spaniards and Ligurians were slaughtered, and soon the carnage spread even to the Gauls. Resistance was minimal here since many had abandoned their standards during the night, having slipped off to rest in the fields, while those present were exhausted from marching and watching; their bodies could hardly bear their weapons. By now it was midday, and thirst and heat overwhelmed them, leaving them vulnerable to being killed or captured in large numbers.

49

More elephants were killed by their guides than by the enemy. They used to have with them a workman's knife, with a mallet. When these beasts began to grow furious, and attack their own party, the rider, placing this knife between the ears, just on the joint by which the neck is connected with the head, used to drive it in, striking it with all the force he could. This was found to be the most expeditious mode of putting these bulky animals to death, when they had destroyed all hope of governing them. This method was first practised by Hasdrubal, a general whose conduct both frequently on other occasions, and especially in this battle, deserved to be recorded. By encouraging the men when fighting, and sharing equally in every danger, he kept up the battle. Sometimes by entreating, at other times by rebuking, the troops, when tired and indisposed to fight from weariness and over-exertion, he rekindled their spirits. He called back the flying, and restored the battle in many places when it had been given up. At length, when fortune decidedly declared for the Romans, lest he should survive so great an army which had been collected under the influence of his name, he put spurs to his horse and rushed upon a Roman cohort, where he fell fighting, as was worthy of the son of Hamilcar and the brother of Hannibal. At no time during that war were so many of the enemy slain in one battle; so that a defeat equal to that sustained at Cannae, whether in respect of the loss of the general or the troops, was considered to have been retorted upon him. Fifty-six thousand of the enemy were slain, five thousand four hundred captured. The other booty was great, both of every other kind, and also of gold and silver. In addition to the rest, there were recovered above four thousand Roman citizens, who had been taken by the enemy, which formed some consolation for the soldiers lost in that battle. For the victory was by no means bloodless. Much about eight thousand of the Romans and the allies were slain; and so completely were even the victors satiated with blood and slaughter, that the next day, when Livius the consul received intelligence that the Cisalpine Gauls and Ligurians, who had either not been present at the battle or had made their escape from the carnage, were marching off in one body without a certain leader without standards, without any discipline or subordination; that if one squadron of horse were sent against them they might be all destroyed, he replied, "Let some survive to bear the news of the enemy's losses and of our valour."

More elephants were killed by their handlers than by the enemy. They used to carry a worker's knife and a mallet. When these animals became enraged and attacked their own team, the rider would place the knife between the ears, right at the joint connecting the head to the neck, and drive it in with as much force as possible. This was found to be the quickest way to put down these massive creatures when they had lost all hope of being controlled. This method was first used by Hasdrubal, a general whose actions on various occasions, especially in this battle, were noteworthy. He motivated the men while fighting and shared equally in every danger, keeping the battle alive. Sometimes he would encourage, and other times rebuke, the troops when they were exhausted and reluctant to fight. He rekindled their spirits, calling back those fleeing and restoring the battle in many areas where it seemed lost. Eventually, when fortune turned decisively in favor of the Romans, rather than survive the fall of such a vast army that had gathered under his name, he urged his horse and charged at a Roman cohort, where he fell fighting, as befit the son of Hamilcar and the brother of Hannibal. At no point during that war were as many enemy soldiers killed in a single battle; a defeat equivalent to that suffered at Cannae, in terms of both the general's loss and troop casualties, was believed to have been inflicted upon him. Fifty-six thousand enemy soldiers were killed, and five thousand four hundred were captured. The overall spoils were significant, including various types and also gold and silver. Additionally, over four thousand Roman citizens who had been captured by the enemy were recovered, which provided some consolation for the soldiers lost in that battle. However, the victory was far from bloodless. About eight thousand Romans and their allies were slain, and even the victors were so overwhelmed by bloodshed that the next day, when Livius the consul learned that the Cisalpine Gauls and Ligurians, who had either not participated in the battle or had escaped the slaughter, were retreating in a disorganized mass without a clear leader, standards, or any discipline; he remarked that if one unit of cavalry was sent against them, they could all be wiped out. He replied, "Let some survive to carry the news of the enemy's losses and our bravery."

50

Nero set out on the night following the battle, and marching at a more rapid rate than when he came, arrived at his camp before the enemy on the sixth day. As he was not preceded by a messenger, fewer people attended him on the march; but the joy felt was so great, that they were almost insane with delight. Neither state of feeling at Rome can be well described or told, whether that in which the citizens were when in doubtful expectation of the issue, or when they received the intelligence of victory. Every day, from the time that news arrived that the consul Claudius had set out, from sun-rise to sun-set, none of the senators ever quitted the senate-house, or did the people depart from the forum. The matrons, as they had themselves no means of affording assistance, had recourse to prayers and entreaties, and going about to all the temples, wearied the gods with vows and supplications. While the city was in this state of solicitude and suspense, a vague report first arrived that two Narnian horsemen had come from the field of battle into the camp which stood as a defence in the entrance to Umbria, with intelligence that the enemy were cut to pieces. At first they rather heard than credited this news, as being too great and too joyful for the mind to take in, or obtain a firm belief. Even the very rapidity with which it had arrived formed an obstacle to its reception; for it was stated that the battle took place two days before. After this a letter was brought which had been sent by Lucius Manlius Acidinus, from his camp, on the subject of the arrival of the Narnian horsemen. This letter being conveyed through the forum to the tribunal of the praetor, drew the senators out of the senate-house; and with such eagerness and hurry did the people crowd to the doors of the senate-house, that the messenger could not approach, but was dragged off by persons who asked him questions, and demanded vociferously that the letter should be read on the rostrum before it was read in the senate. At length they were put back and restrained by the magistrates; and thus the joy was gradually dispensed to their overpowered spirits. The letter was read first in the senate, and then in the assembly of the people. The effect was various, according to the difference in the cast of men's minds, some thinking that there were already sure grounds for rejoicing, while others would place no confidence in the news, till they listened to ambassadors, or a letter from the consuls.

Nero set out on the night after the battle and marched faster than when he had come, arriving at his camp before the enemy on the sixth day. Since he didn’t send a messenger ahead, fewer people joined him on the march, but the joy was so overwhelming that they were almost delirious with happiness. The feelings in Rome were beyond description, whether it was the anxious anticipation of the citizens or the moment they received news of victory. Every day, from the time they learned that Consul Claudius had set out, the senators never left the senate-house and the people didn’t leave the forum from sunrise to sunset. The women, unable to offer any direct help, turned to prayers and pleas, visiting all the temples and wearing the gods down with vows and requests. While the city was in such a state of worry and uncertainty, a vague report first came in that two horsemen from Narnia had reached the camp at the entrance to Umbria, bringing news that the enemy had been completely defeated. Initially, they heard this news rather than believed it, as it felt too overwhelming and joyous for them to fully grasp. The speed at which the information arrived also made it hard to accept, given that the battle had supposedly taken place two days earlier. Then, a letter was brought in from Lucius Manlius Acidinus, sent from his camp, regarding the arrival of the Narnian horsemen. This letter was relayed through the forum to the praetor's seat, pulling the senators out of the senate-house. The crowd surged toward the senate doors with such eagerness that the messenger couldn’t get close, and he was pulled away by people demanding that the letter be read aloud on the rostrum before it was read in the senate. Eventually, the magistrates had to hold them back, allowing the joy to be slowly shared among their overwhelmed spirits. The letter was read first in the senate and then in the assembly of the people. The reaction varied, depending on people's mindsets; some believed there were solid reasons to celebrate, while others refused to trust the news until they heard from ambassadors or received a letter from the consuls.

51
After this, news came that the ambassadors themselves were on the point of arriving. Then, indeed, people of all ages ran to meet them, each man being eager to be the first to receive an assurance of such joyful tidings, by the evidence of his eyes and ears. One continued train extended as far as the Mulvian bridge. The ambassadors, Lucius Veturius Philo, Publius Licinius Varus, and Quintus Caecilius Metellus, made their way into the forum, surrounded by a crowd of persons of every description; when some asked the ambassadors themselves, others their attendants, what had been done; and, as soon as each had heard that the army and general of the enemy had been cut off, that the Roman legions were safe, and the consuls unhurt, he immediately imparted the joyful intelligence to others, imparting to them the joy he felt himself. Having with difficulty made their way into the senate-house, and the crowd with still more difficulty being removed, that they might not mix with the fathers, the letter was read in the senate; after which the ambassadors were brought into the general assembly. Lucius Veturius Philo, after reading the letter himself, gave a more explicit account of all that had occurred, amidst great approbation, and at last of general shouting from the assembly, while their minds could scarcely contain their joy. They then ran off in various directions, some to the different temples of the gods, to return thanks, others to their homes, to impart the joyful intelligence to their wives and children. The senate decreed a supplication for three days, because Marcus Livius and Caius Claudius, the consuls, had cut off the general and legions of the enemy, their own army being safe. This supplication Caius Hostilius, the praetor, proclaimed in the assembly, and was celebrated both by men and women. During the whole three days all the temples were uniformly crowded, whilst the matrons, dressed in their richest robes, and accompanied by their children, just as though the war had been brought to a conclusion, and free from every apprehension, offered thanksgivings to the immortal gods. This victory produced an alteration also in the condition of the state, so that immediately from this event, just as though it had been a time of peace, men were not afraid to do business with each other, buying, selling, lending, and paying borrowed money. Caius Claudius, the consul, on his return to his camp, ordered the head of Hasdrubal, which he had carefully kept and brought with him, to be thrown before the advanced guards of the enemy, and the African prisoners to be shown to them bound just as they were. Two of these also he unbound, and bid them go to Hannibal and tell him what had occurred. Hannibal, smitten by such severe distress, at once public and domestic, is said to have declared that he recognised the destiny of Carthage; and decamping thence with the intention of drawing together into Bruttium, the remotest corner of Italy, all his auxiliaries which he could not protect when widely scattered, removed into Bruttium the whole state of the Metapontines, summoned away from their former habitations, and also such of the Lucanians as were under his authority.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXVIII.


Successful operations against the Carthaginians in Spain, under Silanus, Scipio's lieutenant, and L. Scipio, his brother; of Sulpicius and Attalus, against Philip, king of Macedonia. Scipio finally vanquishes the Carthaginians in Spain, and reduces that whole country; passes over into Africa, forms an alliance with Syphax, king of Numidia; represses and punishes a mutiny of a part of his army; concludes a treaty of friendship with Masinissa; returns to Rome, and is elected consul; solicits Africa for his province, which is opposed by Quintus Fabius Maximus; is appointed governor of Sicily, with permission to pass over into Africa.

       *        *        *        *        *

1

At the time when Spain appeared to be relieved in proportion to the degree in which the weight of the war was removed into Italy, by the passage of Hasdrubal, another war sprang up there equal in magnitude to the former. At this juncture, the Romans and Carthaginians thus occupied Spain: Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, had retired quite to the ocean and Gades; the coast of our sea, and almost the whole of that part of Spain which lies eastward, was subject to Scipio and the Romans. The new general, Hanno, who had passed over from Africa, to supply the place of the Barcine Hasdrubal, with a new army, and formed a junction with Mago, having in a short time armed a large number of men in Celtiberia, which lies in the midway between the two seas, Scipio sent Marcus Silanus against him, with no more than ten thousand infantry and five hundred horse. Silanus, by marching with all the haste he could, (though the ruggedness of the roads, and narrow defiles obstructed with thick woods, which are very frequent in Spain, impeded him,) yet being guided by deserters from Celtiberia, natives of that place, reached the enemy, anticipating not only messengers but even all rumour of his coming. From the same source he ascertained, when they were about ten thousand paces from the enemy, that they had two camps, one on each side of the road in which they were marching; that the Celtiberians, a newly-raised army, in number above nine thousand, were on the left, and that the Carthaginian camp was stationed on the right. The latter was secured and protected by outposts, watches, and every kind of regular military guard, while the former was disorderly and neglected, as belonging to barbarians, who were raw soldiers, and were under the less apprehension, because they were in their own country. Silanus, concluding that this was the camp to be attacked first, ordered the troops to march as much as possible towards the left, lest he should be observed from any point by the Carthaginian outposts, and sending scouts in advance, pushed on towards the enemy at a rapid pace.

When Spain seemed to be easing up as the pressure of the war shifted to Italy with Hasdrubal's move, another major conflict broke out there. At that moment, the Romans and Carthaginians held different parts of Spain: Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, had retreated to the ocean and Gades; meanwhile, Scipio and the Romans controlled the coast of our sea and almost the entire eastern part of Spain. The new general, Hanno, who had come from Africa to replace Hasdrubal Barcide with a fresh army, quickly teamed up with Mago and managed to gather a large force in Celtiberia, located between the two seas. In response, Scipio sent Marcus Silanus against him with only ten thousand infantry and five hundred cavalry. Silanus, marching as fast as he could—despite the difficult roads and narrow paths choked with dense woods common in Spain—was guided by deserters from Celtiberia and reached the enemy before any messengers or rumors of his arrival could spread. About ten thousand paces from the enemy, he learned from the same source that they had two camps, one on each side of the road they were taking; the Celtiberians, a newly raised army with over nine thousand troops, were on the left, while the Carthaginian camp was on the right. The Carthaginian camp was secured with outposts, sentries, and all kinds of regular military guards, while the Celtiberian camp was chaotic and poorly defended, as it belonged to inexperienced soldiers who felt safer in their own territory. Silanus decided to attack the Celtiberian camp first, ordering his troops to move as stealthily as possible toward the left to avoid detection by the Carthaginian outposts. He sent scouts ahead and pushed on toward the enemy quickly.

2

He was now about three thousand paces from the enemy, when as yet none of them had perceived him. The ground was covered with craggy places, and hills overgrown with bushes. Here in a hollow valley, and on that account unexposed to the view, he ordered his men to sit down and take refreshment. In the mean time the scouts returned, confirming the statements of the deserters. Then the Romans, collecting their baggage in the centre, took arms, and marched to battle in regular array. They were a thousand paces off when they were descried by the enemy, when suddenly all began to be in a state of hurry and confusion. At the first shout and tumult, Mago quitted the camp and rode up at full speed. As there were in the Celtiberian army four thousand targeteers and two hundred horsemen, this regular legion, as it formed the flower of his troops, he stationed in the first line; the rest, composed of light-armed, he posted in reserve. While he was leading them out of the camp thus marshalled, the Romans discharged their javelins at them before they had scarcely cleared the rampart. The Spaniards stooped down to avoid the javelins thrown at them by the enemy, and then rose up to discharge their own in turn; which the Romans having received according to their custom in close array, with their shields firmly united, they then engaged foot to foot, and began to fight with their swords. But the ruggedness of the ground, while it rendered ineffectual the agility of the Celtiberians who were accustomed to a skirmishing kind of battle, was at the same time not unfavourable to the Romans, who were accustomed to a steady kind of fight, except that the narrow passes and the bushes, which grew here and there, broke their ranks, and they were compelled to engage one against one and two against two, as if matched together. The same circumstance which obstructed the enemy's flight, delivered them up, as it were, bound for slaughter. And now when almost all the targeteers had been slain, the light-armed and the Carthaginians, who had come up to their assistance from the other camp, having been thrown into confusion, were put to the sword. Not more than two thousand of the infantry, and all the cavalry, fled from the field with Mago before the battle was well begun. The other general, Hanno, was taken alive, together with those who came up when the battle was now decided. Almost the whole of the cavalry and the veteran infantry, following Mago in his flight, came to Hasdrubal on the tenth day in the province of Gades. The newly-raised Celtiberian troops, stealing off to the neighbouring woods, fled thence to their homes. By this very seasonable victory, a stop was put to a war which was not by any means so considerable as that to which it would have grown, had the enemy been allowed, after having prevailed upon the Celtiberians to join them, to solicit other nations also to take up arms. Scipio, therefore, having liberally bestowed the highest commendations on Silanus, and entertaining a hope that he might bring the war to a termination, if he did not impede it by a want of activity on his own part, proceeded into the remotest part of Spain against Hasdrubal. The Carthaginian, who then happened to be encamped in Baetica, in order to prevent his allies from wavering in their allegiance, retired quite to the ocean and Gades, in a manner much more resembling a flight than a march. He was afraid, however; that while he kept his forces together, he should form the principal object of attack. Before he crossed the strait to Gades he sent them into different cities, that they might both provide for their own safety by the help of walls, and for that of the town by their arms.

He was now about three thousand steps away from the enemy, and none of them had noticed him yet. The ground was rough with rocks and hills covered in bushes. Here, in a hollow valley that was hidden from view, he ordered his men to sit down and rest. In the meantime, the scouts returned, confirming what the deserters had reported. The Romans then gathered their supplies in the center, armed themselves, and marched to battle in organized formation. They were a thousand paces away when the enemy spotted them, and chaos broke out immediately. At the first shout and commotion, Mago left the camp and rode up quickly. Since the Celtiberian army included four thousand skirmishers and two hundred cavalry, he positioned this elite legion at the front line, while the rest, made up of light infantry, were kept in reserve. As he led them out of the camp in this order, the Romans threw their javelins before the Celtiberians had even crossed the rampart. The Spaniards ducked to dodge the javelins from the enemy and then stood up to throw their own in return. The Romans, used to tightly formed ranks, received the incoming javelins with their shields locked together, then engaged in close combat, fighting with their swords. However, the rough terrain hindered the Celtiberians, who were more suited for skirmishing tactics, while it didn’t totally disadvantage the Romans, who preferred steady fighting. The narrow paths and scattered bushes disrupted their ranks, forcing them to engage one-on-one or two-on-two, as if they were paired off. This same situation that prevented the enemy's escape effectively bound them for slaughter. As the majority of the skirmishers were killed, the light troops and the Carthaginians, who had come to assist from the other camp, were thrown into chaos and slaughtered. No more than two thousand infantry and all the cavalry fled the field with Mago before the battle had fully started. The other general, Hanno, was captured along with those who arrived after the battle was already decided. Almost all the cavalry and veteran infantry that followed Mago in his retreat reached Hasdrubal in the province of Gades ten days later. The newly raised Celtiberian troops, sneaking away to the nearby woods, fled back home. This timely victory halted a conflict that could have escalated significantly if the enemy had managed to convince the Celtiberians to join them and sought to rally other nations to their cause. Therefore, Scipio, having generously praised Silanus and hopeful that he could bring the war to an end if he didn’t hinder it with inaction, moved into the far reaches of Spain against Hasdrubal. The Carthaginian, who was then encamped in Baetica, wanting to prevent his allies from wavering in their loyalty, retreated all the way to the ocean and Gades, resembling a flight more than a march. However, he was concerned that as long as he kept his forces together, he would become the main target. Before crossing the strait to Gades, he sent his troops into different cities to ensure their safety behind walls and to protect the towns with their weapons.

3

Scipio, seeing the enemy's forces thus distributed, and that to carry about his forces to each of the several cities would be rather tedious than important, marched his army back. Not to leave all that country, however, to the Carthaginians, he sent his brother, Lucius Scipio, at the head of ten thousand foot and one thousand horse, to besiege the most important city of that quarter, called by the barbarians Orinx, and situated on the borders of the Milesians, a nation of Spain so called. The soil is fertile, and even silver is dug out of it by the inhabitants. This place served as a fort to Hasdrubal, from which he might make incursions on the inland states. Scipio encamped near the city. Before he formed his lines round it, he sent to the gates to sound the inclinations of the inhabitants, by a direct interview, and persuade them to make trial of the friendship of the Romans rather than of their power. As they answered nothing of a friendly nature, he threw a double trench and rampart round the place, dividing his army into three parts, in order that one division might assault it while the other two rested. The first of these beginning the attack, a furious and doubtful contest ensued. It was by no means easy to approach and bring the ladders to the walls, on account of the weapons which fell upon them; and even of those persons who had raised them, some were thrown down with forks made for the purpose, others were in danger of being laid hold of by iron grapples, and dragged up hanging to the wall. Scipio, seeing that the contest was equalized owing to the fewness of his party, and that the enemy, fighting from the wall, were superior to him, called off the first division and attacked them with the two others together. This so terrified the besieged, who were already fatigued with fighting with the former, that not only the townsmen forsook the walls in sudden flight, but the Carthaginian garrison, fearing that the town had been betrayed, also quitted their posts and collected themselves into a body. Upon this the inhabitants began to be alarmed, lest if the enemy broke into the town they should kill all they met indiscriminately, Carthaginian or Spaniard. They therefore suddenly threw open the gates and rushed out of the town, holding their shields before them, lest any weapons should be cast at them from a distance, and stretching out to view their bare right hands, that it might be seen they had thrown away their swords. Whether this was not observed, in consequence of the distance, or whether some deception was suspected, is not known; but an attack was made on the deserters, and they were put to death as a hostile force. Through this gate the enemy marched into the city in battle-array. The other gates were cut through and broken down with axes and sledges; and as each horseman entered, he galloped off to seize the forum, as had been ordered. A body of veteran troops were also added to the horse to support them. The legionary troops spread themselves in every part of the city, but neither killed nor plundered any, except such as defended themselves with arms. All the Carthaginians were put under guard, with more than three hundred of the inhabitants, who had shut the gates. The rest had the town put into their hands, and their property restored. About two thousand of the enemy fell in the assault on this city, and not more than ninety of the Romans.

Scipio, noticing how the enemy's forces were spread out, and realizing that moving his troops to each of the various cities would be more tedious than useful, marched his army back. To avoid leaving all that area to the Carthaginians, he sent his brother, Lucius Scipio, with ten thousand foot soldiers and one thousand cavalry to lay siege to the most important city in that region, known to the locals as Orinx, located on the borders of the Milesians, a tribe in Spain. The land was fertile, and the locals even mined silver from it. This city had served as a stronghold for Hasdrubal, allowing him to launch attacks on the inland states. Scipio set up camp near the city. Before establishing his lines around it, he sent a message to the gates to gauge the residents' intentions through a direct conversation, hoping to persuade them to test the Romans' friendship rather than their might. When they didn't respond positively, he constructed a double trench and rampart around the city, dividing his army into three parts so that one group could attack while the others rested. The first group launched the assault, leading to a fierce and uncertain battle. It was quite difficult to approach and set up the ladders against the walls because of the weapons raining down on them; of those who managed to lift the ladders, some were knocked down with forks designed for that purpose, while others risked being grabbed by iron hooks and pulled up, hanging from the wall. Seeing that the battle was evenly matched due to his small numbers and that the enemy had the advantage fighting from the walls, Scipio pulled back the first division and launched an attack with the two remaining divisions combined. This terrified the besieged, who were already exhausted from fighting off the previous group, and not only did the townspeople flee from the walls in a panic, but the Carthaginian garrison, fearing that the town had been betrayed, also abandoned their positions and regrouped. The residents grew anxious that if the enemy entered the town, they would kill everyone indiscriminately, regardless of whether they were Carthaginian or Spanish. In response, they quickly opened the gates and rushed out, holding their shields in front of them to protect against any distant projectiles, and raising their bare right hands to show they had discarded their swords. Whether this gesture went unnoticed due to the distance or if it raised suspicions, is unclear; but an attack was launched on those fleeing, and they were killed as a hostile force. Through this gate, the enemy advanced into the city in battle formation. The other gates were breached with axes and sledges; as each cavalryman entered, he sped off to seize the forum, as instructed. A group of veteran soldiers was also added to support the cavalry. The legionary troops spread throughout the city but killed or looted only those who fought back. All the Carthaginians were captured, along with over three hundred residents who had fortified the gates. The remaining townspeople were given control of the city and their properties returned. About two thousand of the enemy fell during the assault on this city, while fewer than ninety Romans were lost.

4

As the taking of this town was a source of great joy to those who effected it, as well as to the general and the rest of the army, so their approach to their camp also presented a splendid spectacle, on account of the immense crowd of captives they drove before them. Scipio, having bestowed high commendations upon his brother, representing the capture of Orinx as equal in importance to the capture of Carthage by himself, led his forces back into hither Spain. He could not make an attempt on Gades, or pursue the army of Hasdrubal, now dispersed through all parts of the province, in consequence of the approach of winter. He therefore dismissed the legions into winter quarters, and sent his brother Lucius Scipio with Hanno, the enemy's general, and other distinguished prisoners, to Rome, while he retired himself to Tarraco. During the same year, the Roman fleet under Marcus Valerius Laevinus, the proconsul, sailing over from Sicily into Africa, devastated to a wide extent the fields about Utica and Carthage. They carried off plunder from the remotest borders of the Carthaginian territory around the very walls of Utica. On their return to Sicily they were met by a Carthaginian fleet of seventy ships of war, of which seventeen were taken and four sunk; the rest were dispersed and compelled to fly. The Romans, victorious both by land and sea, returned to Lilybaeum with immense booty of every kind. The ships of the enemy having thus been driven from the whole sea, large supplies of corn were conveyed to Rome.

As the capture of this town brought immense joy to those who achieved it, as well as to the general and the rest of the army, their return to camp was also a magnificent sight, thanks to the huge crowd of captives they brought with them. Scipio praised his brother highly, stating that the capture of Orinx was as significant as his own capture of Carthage, and he led his forces back into this part of Spain. He couldn't launch an attack on Gades or pursue Hasdrubal's army, which was scattered throughout the province due to the onset of winter. So, he sent the legions into winter quarters and sent his brother Lucius Scipio, along with Hanno, the enemy general, and other notable prisoners, to Rome, while he himself went to Tarraco. That same year, the Roman fleet commanded by Marcus Valerius Laevinus, the proconsul, crossed from Sicily to Africa, causing widespread devastation to the fields around Utica and Carthage. They plundered from the farthest reaches of Carthaginian territory, right up to the walls of Utica. On their way back to Sicily, they encountered a Carthaginian fleet of seventy warships, capturing seventeen and sinking four; the rest fled. The Romans, triumphant on both land and sea, returned to Lilybaeum with a massive haul of all kinds of loot. With the enemy's ships expelled from the entire sea, large quantities of grain were sent to Rome.

5

In the beginning of the summer in which these events occurred, Publius Sulpicius, proconsul, and king Attalus, having passed the winter at Aegina, as before observed, united their fleets, consisting of twenty-three Roman quinqueremes and thirty-five belonging to the king, and proceeded to Lemnos. Philip also, that he might be prepared for every kind of measure, whether it should be necessary to meet the enemy on land or sea, came down to the coast of Demetrias and appointed to his army a day on which to meet him at Larissa. On the news of the king's arrival, ambassadors from his allies came to Demetrias from all sides. For the Aetolians, inspirited both by their alliance with the Romans and the approach of king Attalus, were ravaging the neighbouring states; not only the Acarnanians, Boeotians, and Euboeans were very much alarmed, but the Achaeans also were kept in a state of terror, both by the hostile proceedings of the Aetolians, and also by Machanidas, tyrant of Lacedaemon, who had encamped at a short distance from the borders of the Argives. All of these stating the dangers which threatened their possessions, both by land and sea, entreated succour from the king. Philip received accounts even from his own kingdom, that things were not in a state of tranquillity; that both Scerdilaedus and Pleuratus were in motion, and that some of the Thracians, and particularly the Maedians, would certainly make incursions on the contiguous provinces of Macedonia, should the king be occupied with a distant war. The Boeotians, indeed, and the people inhabiting the inland parts of Greece, told him that the Aetolians had obstructed by a ditch and rampart the straits of Thermopylae, where the road is very narrow and confined, in order to prevent their passing to the assistance of the allied states. So many disturbances arising on all hands were sufficient to awaken an inactive general. He dismissed the ambassadors, promising to assist them all according as opportunity and circumstances allowed. For the present, he sent to Peparethus a body of troops to garrison the city, for this was the most urgent business, as information had been received thence that Attalus, crossing over to Lemnos, was devastating all the neighbouring country. He sent Polyphantas with a small detachment to Boeotia, and also Menippus, one of his guards, with one thousand targeteers (the target is not unlike the ordinary buckler) to Chalcis. Five hundred Agrianians were added, that every part of the island might be secured. He went himself to Scotussa, and ordered the Macedonian soldiers to be removed thither from Larissa. Here he heard that the Aetolians had been summoned to an assembly at Heraclea, and that king Attalus was to come and advise with them as to the conduct of the war. Determining to interrupt this meeting by his sudden approach, he led his troops by forced marches to Heraclea, where he arrived just after the assembly had broken up. However, he destroyed the crops, which were nearly ripe, particularly those round the Aenian bay. He then marched back to Scotussa, and leaving there the main army, retired to Demetrias with the royal guards. In order to be prepared against every attempt of the enemy, he sent persons hence to Phocis, Euboea, and Peparethus, to select elevated situations, from which fires lighted upon them might be seen from a distance. He fixed a watch-tower on Tisaeum, a mountain whose summit is prodigiously high, in order that when the enemy made any attempt he might instantly receive intimation of it by means of fires lighted up at a distance. The Roman general and king Attalus then passed over from Peparethus to Nicaea, and thence sailed to Orcus, the first city of Euboea, on the left as you proceed to Chalcis and the Euripus from the bay of Demetrias. It was agreed upon between Attalus and Sulpicius, that the Romans should attack the town on the side next the sea, and the king's forces on the land side.

In the beginning of the summer when these events took place, Publius Sulpicius, the proconsul, and King Attalus, who had spent the winter in Aegina, combined their fleets, which included twenty-three Roman quinqueremes and thirty-five belonging to the king, and headed to Lemnos. Philip, wanting to be ready for any situation, whether he had to confront the enemy on land or at sea, moved to the coast of Demetrias and set a date for his army to gather in Larissa. Upon hearing of the king's arrival, ambassadors from his allies came to Demetrias from all directions. The Aetolians, encouraged by their alliance with the Romans and the coming of King Attalus, were attacking nearby states; not only were the Acarnanians, Boeotians, and Euboeans very worried, but the Achaeans were also in a state of fear, both due to the aggressive actions of the Aetolians and because of Machanidas, the tyrant of Lacedaemon, who had camped not far from the borders of the Argives. All of them, detailing the threats to their territories by both land and sea, begged the king for help. Philip also received reports from his own kingdom indicating that things were not peaceful; both Scerdilaedus and Pleuratus were on the move, and some Thracians, particularly the Maedians, would likely raid the nearby provinces of Macedonia if the king was occupied with a distant war. The Boeotians and people from the inland parts of Greece informed him that the Aetolians had blocked the straits of Thermopylae with a ditch and rampart, where the road is very narrow, to prevent them from aiding the allied states. The numerous disturbances on all sides were enough to rouse a previously inactive general. He dismissed the ambassadors, promising to help them as circumstances allowed. For now, he sent a contingent of troops to Peparethus to garrison the city, as this was the most urgent task, given that news had arrived that Attalus, crossing over to Lemnos, was ravaging all the nearby areas. He sent Polyphantas with a small group to Boeotia, and also Menippus, one of his guards, with one thousand targeteers (the target is similar to a regular shield) to Chalcis. Five hundred Agrianians were added to secure all parts of the island. He went to Scotussa himself and ordered the Macedonian soldiers to be relocated there from Larissa. While there, he learned that the Aetolians had been summoned to a meeting at Heraclea, and that King Attalus was expected to consult with them about the conduct of the war. Deciding to disrupt this meeting with a sudden approach, he led his troops on forced marches to Heraclea, arriving just after the assembly had been disbanded. However, he destroyed the crops, which were almost ripe, especially those around the Aenian bay. He then marched back to Scotussa, leaving the main army there and retreating to Demetrias with the royal guards. To be prepared for any enemy attempts, he sent teams to Phocis, Euboea, and Peparethus to find elevated spots from which fires could be lit to signal from a distance. He set up a watchtower on Tisaeum, a very high mountain, so that he could immediately receive notice of any enemy actions through distant fires. The Roman general and King Attalus then crossed from Peparethus to Nicaea, and from there sailed to Orcus, the first city of Euboea, on the left as you head to Chalcis and the Euripus from the bay of Demetrias. It was agreed between Attalus and Sulpicius that the Romans would attack the town from the sea side, while the king's forces would approach from the land side.

6

Four days after the fleet arrived, they attacked the city. That time had been employed in private conferences with Plator, whom Philip had put in command of the place. The city has two citadels, one overhanging the coasts, the other in the middle of the town, from which there is a subterraneous passage to the ocean, whose entrance next the sea is defended by a strong fortification, a tower five stories high. Here the affair commenced with a most furious contest, the tower being furnished with all kinds of weapons, and engines and machines of every kind for the purpose of the assault having been landed from the ships. While the eyes and attention of all were turned to that quarter, Plator opened one of the gates and received the Romans into the citadel next the sea, which they instantly became masters of. The inhabitants, driven thence, fled to the other citadel in the middle of the city; but there had been troops posted there to shut the gates against them; so that, being thus excluded, they were surrounded and either slain or made prisoners. Meanwhile the Macedonian garrison stood under the wall of the citadel, formed into a compact body, neither confusedly attempting a retreat, nor obstinately engaging in a contest. These men Plator, after obtaining permission from Sulpicius, put on board ships and landed them at Demetrias in Phthiotis; he himself withdrew to Attalus. Sulpicius, elated with the success at Oreum, gained with so much ease, proceeded to Chalcis with his victorious fleet, where the issue by no means answered his expectations. The sea, which is wide on both sides, being here contracted into a narrow strait, might perhaps, at first view, exhibit the appearance of two harbours facing the two entrances of the Euripus. It would be difficult to find a station more dangerous for shipping; for not only do the winds come down with great violence from the high mountains on each side, but the strait itself of the Euripus does not ebb and flow seven times a day at stated times, as is reported, but the current changing irregularly, like the wind, now this way now that, is hurried along like a torrent rolling headlong down a steep mountain, so that no quiet is given to vessels there day or night. But not only did so perilous a station receive his ships, but the town was strong and impregnable, covered on one side by the sea, and very well fortified on the other towards the land, secured by a strong garrison, and above all, by the fidelity of the praefects and principal men, which was wavering and unsettled at Oreum. Though the business had been rashly undertaken, the Roman still acted with prudence, in so far as he speedily gave up the attempt, after he had seen all the difficulties which surrounded him, that he might not waste time, and passed his fleet over from thence to Cynus in Locris, the port of the town of Opus, which is one mile distant from the sea.

Four days after the fleet arrived, they attacked the city. During that time, they held private meetings with Plator, whom Philip had put in charge of the place. The city has two citadels, one overlooking the coast and the other in the center of town, connected to the ocean by an underground passage. The entrance by the sea is protected by a strong fortification, a tower five stories high. The battle started here with a fierce fight, as the tower was armed with all kinds of weapons, while supplies and siege engines had been unloaded from the ships. While everyone’s attention was focused on that area, Plator opened one of the gates and let the Romans into the citadel by the sea, which they quickly took control of. The inhabitants, forced out, ran to the other citadel in the center of the city, but troops had been stationed there to close the gates against them, so they were trapped and either killed or captured. Meanwhile, the Macedonian garrison stood under the citadel wall, grouped together, neither frantically trying to escape nor stubbornly engaging in battle. Plator, after getting permission from Sulpicius, put these men on ships and landed them at Demetrias in Phthiotis; he then withdrew to Attalus. Sulpicius, buoyed by the easy victory at Oreum, moved on to Chalcis with his successful fleet, where the outcome did not meet his expectations. The sea, which is wide on both sides, narrows into a strait here and might initially look like two harbors at the entrances of the Euripus. It's hard to find a more dangerous place for shipping; not only do strong winds sweep down from the high mountains on either side, but the Euripus itself does not have regular tides seven times a day, as is commonly said. Instead, the current changes erratically, like the wind, shifting this way and that, rushing along like a torrent down a steep mountain, providing no calm for vessels day or night. Not only did such a perilous location take in his ships, but the town was strong and impregnable, protected on one side by the sea and very well fortified on the land side, secured by a strong garrison and, above all, by the loyalty of the praefects and local leaders, which was uncertain back at Oreum. Even though the venture had been reckless, the Roman acted wisely by quickly abandoning the attempt after assessing the numerous difficulties surrounding him so he wouldn’t waste time. He moved his fleet from there to Cynus in Locris, the port for the town of Opus, which is one mile from the sea.

7

Philip had received notice of this from Oreum, by the signal fires; but through the treachery of Plator they were raised from the watch-tower at a later period. As he was not a match for the enemy's forces at sea, it was difficult for him to approach the island; and thus, by delay, the opportunity was lost. He moved with promptness to the assistance of Chalcis as soon as he received the signal. For although Chalcis is a city of the same island, yet it is separated from the continent by so narrow a strait, that they communicate by means of a bridge, and the approach to it is easier by land than by water. Philip therefore, going from Demetrias to Scotussa, and setting out thence at the third watch, dislodged the guard, put to flight the Aetolians who kept the pass of Thermopylae, and drove the enemy in confusion to Heraclea, marching in one day to Elatia in Phocis, a distance of above sixty miles. Almost on the same day the town of Opus was taken and plundered by Attalus. Sulpicius had given it up to the king because Oreum had been plundered a few days before by the Roman soldiers, the royal soldiers not having shared the booty. The Roman fleet having retired thither, Attalus, who was not aware of Philip's approach, wasted time in levying contributions from the principal inhabitants, and so sudden was his coming, that had he not been descried by some Cretans, who happened to go farther from the town than usual in quest of forage, he might have been surprised. He fled hastily to the sea and his ships, without arms, and in the greatest disorder. Just as they were putting off from the land Philip arrived, and even from the shore created much alarm among the mariners. He returned thence to Opus, accusing both gods and men, because he had lost an opportunity of so great importance, almost snatched from his hands. He also reproached the Opuntians with the like anger, because they had, immediately on sight of the enemy, made almost a voluntary surrender, though they might have prolonged the siege till his arrival. Having settled affairs at Opus, he proceeded thence to Thronium. Attalus, too, at first retired from Oreum; but there receiving intelligence that Prusias, king of Bithynia, had invaded his kingdom, he withdrew his attention from the Romans and the Aetolian war, and passed over into Asia. Sulpicius also withdrew his fleet to Aegina, from whence he had set out in the beginning of spring. Philip took Thronium with as little difficulty as Attalus had at Opus. It was inhabited by foreigners, fugitives from Thebes in Phthiotis, who, on the capture of their own town by Philip, had fled to the protection of the Aetolians, and received from them a city as a settlement which had been laid waste and desolated in a former war by the same Philip. Having recovered Thronium, as has been a little before mentioned, he set out thence; and having taken Tritonos and Drymae, inconsiderable towns of Doris, he came thence to Elatia, where he had ordered the ambassadors of Ptolemy and the Rhodians to wait for him. While consulting there as to the best method of bringing the Aetolian war to a conclusion, (for these ambassadors attended the late council of the Romans and Aetolians at Heraclea,) intelligence is brought that Machanidas intended to attack the Elians while busied in preparing for the celebration of the Olympic games. Thinking it his duty to prevent such an attempt, he dismissed the ambassadors with a gracious answer to the effect, that he had neither caused the war, nor would he be any obstacle to the restoration of peace, if it should be possible on equitable and honourable terms; then marching quickly through Boeotia he came down from Megara, and thence to Corinth, where receiving supplies of provisions, he went to Phlius and Pheneus. And now, when he had proceeded as far as Heraea, having received intelligence that Machanidas, terrified at the news of his approach, had retreated to Lacedaemon, he betook himself to Aegium, where the Achaeans were assembled in council, expecting at the same time to meet there a Carthaginian fleet, which he had sent for, in order that he might accomplish something by sea. But the Carthaginians had left a few days before, and were gone to the Oxean islands; and thence, hearing that the Romans and Attalus had left Oreum, to the harbours of the Acarnanians, for they feared that it was intended to attack them, and that they would be overpowered while within the straits of Rhium, which is the name of the entrance of the Corinthian bay.

Philip received news about this from Oreum through the signal fires, but due to Plator's betrayal, they were raised from the watchtower later. Since he couldn't match the enemy's naval strength, it was hard for him to get close to the island, and by delaying, the chance was lost. As soon as he got the signal, he quickly moved to help Chalcis. Although Chalcis is a city on the same island, it’s separated from the mainland by such a narrow strait that they communicate via a bridge, making it easier to reach by land than by sea. Therefore, Philip traveled from Demetrias to Scotussa and set out from there at the third watch, driving out the guard, forcing the Aetolians at the Thermopylae pass to flee, and causing chaos among the enemy as he marched to Heraclea, covering over sixty miles in one day to reach Elatia in Phocis. Almost on the same day, Attalus captured and plundered the town of Opus. Sulpicius had surrendered it to the king because Oreum had been raided a few days earlier by Roman soldiers, who didn't share the plunder with the royal forces. The Roman fleet had retreated there, and Attalus, unaware of Philip's approach, wasted time collecting tribute from the prominent residents. His arrival was so sudden that if not for some Cretans who had ventured further from town in search of forage, he might have been caught off guard. He fled hastily to the sea and his ships, unarmed and in total disarray. Just as they were leaving the shore, Philip arrived and created a lot of panic among the sailors. He then returned to Opus, cursing both gods and men for losing such a significant opportunity that was nearly within his grasp. He also scolded the Opuntians out of anger for almost voluntarily surrendering at the sight of the enemy, even though they could have prolonged the siege until he arrived. After settling matters in Opus, he headed to Thronium. Attalus initially retreated from Oreum, but upon learning that Prusias, king of Bithynia, had invaded his territory, he shifted his focus away from the Romans and the Aetolian war and crossed over to Asia. Sulpicius also pulled his fleet back to Aegina, from where he had initially departed in early spring. Philip took Thronium without much trouble, just as Attalus had at Opus. It was inhabited by foreigners—fugitives from Thebes in Phthiotis—who had fled to the Aetolians after Philip captured their town and were given a city that had been ruined in a previous war by Philip. After retaking Thronium, as mentioned earlier, he set out again, capturing the small towns of Tritonos and Drymae in Doris before arriving at Elatia, where he had instructed the ambassadors from Ptolemy and the Rhodians to wait for him. While consulting there on how to effectively conclude the Aetolian war (since these ambassadors had attended the recent Roman and Aetolian council at Heraclea), news arrived that Machanidas planned to attack the Elians while they were busy preparing for the Olympic games. Considering it his duty to prevent this, he dismissed the ambassadors with a polite response, stating that he neither caused the war nor would impede any restoration of peace, if it could be achieved on fair and honorable terms. He then swiftly marched through Boeotia, descending from Megara to Corinth, where he received supplies, and continued on to Phlius and Pheneus. By the time he reached Heraea and learned that Machanidas, frightened by his approach, had retreated to Lacedaemon, he headed to Aegium, where the Achaeans were gathered in council, also expecting to meet a Carthaginian fleet there that he had summoned to achieve something by sea. However, the Carthaginians had left a few days earlier for the Oxean islands; from there, hearing that the Romans and Attalus had left Oreum for the harbors of the Acarnanians—because they feared an impending attack—they worried about being overwhelmed while inside the straits of Rhium, the entrance to the Corinthian bay.

8

Philip was grieved and vexed when he reflected, that though he proceeded with the utmost speed on all occasions, yet he had not come up in time to accomplish any one object, and that fortune had frustrated his activity by snatching away every advantage from before his eyes. In the assembly, however, concealing his chagrin, he discoursed with elated spirits, calling gods and men to witness, that "he had never been wanting at any time or place, so as not to repair instantly wherever the enemy's arms resounded, but that it was difficult to calculate whether the war was carried on more boldly by him or more pusillanimously by the enemy. Such was the manner in which Attalus had slipped out of his hands from Opus; Sulpicius from Chalcis; and so, within these few days, Machanidas. That flight, however, was not always successful; and that that should not be esteemed a difficult war in which victory would be certain if the enemy could be brought to a regular engagement. He had already obtained one very great advantage, which was a confession on the part of the enemy themselves, that they were not a match for him; and in a short time," he said, "he would be in possession of undoubted victory; for that he would engage with him with a result no better than their expectations." The allies listened to the king with great satisfaction. He then gave up to the Achaeans Heraera and Triphylia. Aliphera he restored to the Megalopolitans, they having brought satisfactory proof that it belonged to their territories. Then having received some ships from the Achaeans, three quadriremes and three biremes, he sailed to Anticyra, whence with seven quinqueremes and more than twenty barks, which he had sent to the bay of Corinth to join the Carthaginian fleet, he proceeded to Erythrae, a town of the Aetolians near Eupalium, where he made a descent. He was not unobserved by the Aetolians; for all who were either in the fields or in the neighbouring forts of Potidania and Apollonia, fled to the woods and mountains. The cattle which they could not drive off in their haste they seized and put on board. He sent Nicias, praetor of the Achaeans, to Aegium with these and the other booty; and then going to Corinth, ordered his army to march by land through Boeotia, while he himself, sailing from Cenchreae along the coast of Attica, round the promontory of Sunium, reached Chalcis, having passed almost through the midst of the enemy's fleet. After commending in the highest terms their fidelity and bravery, as neither fear nor hope had influenced their minds, and after exhorting them to show the same fidelity in maintaining the alliance, he sailed to Oreum; and having placed such of the chief inhabitants as chose to fly, rather than surrender to the Romans, in the command of the city and the direction of affairs, he sailed over from Euboea to Demetrias, from which place he at first set out to succour his allies. After this, having laid the keels of one hundred ships of war at Cassandrea, and collected a large number of ship carpenters for the completion of that business, and as both the departure of Attalus and the seasonable assistance he had brought to his allies had tranquillized affairs in Greece, he retired into his own dominions, in order to make war upon the Dardanians.

Philip was upset and frustrated as he realized that even though he acted as quickly as possible, he still hadn't managed to achieve any goal in time, and luck had thwarted his efforts by taking away every opportunity right in front of him. In the meeting, however, hiding his disappointment, he spoke with high spirits, calling on gods and men to witness that he had always been ready to respond instantly whenever the enemy was engaged, but it was hard to tell whether he was fighting more bravely or the enemy was fighting more cowardly. Such was how Attalus had escaped from Opus; Sulpicius from Chalcis; and recently, Machanidas. However, not every escape was successful; it shouldn't be considered a difficult war where victory was assured if the enemy could be brought to a proper battle. He had already gained one significant advantage, which was the enemy's own admission that they were no match for him; in a short time, he said, he would secure undeniable victory, as he would engage them with results no better than their expectations. The allies listened to the king with great satisfaction. He then gave Heraera and Triphylia to the Achaeans. He returned Aliphera to the Megalopolitans, who had provided convincing proof that it belonged to their territory. After receiving ships from the Achaeans—three quadriremes and three biremes—he sailed to Anticyra, from where, with seven quinqueremes and more than twenty smaller ships he had sent to the Bay of Corinth to join the Carthaginian fleet, he moved to Erythrae, a town of the Aetolians near Eupalium, where he landed. The Aetolians noticed him; everyone in the fields or nearby forts at Potidania and Apollonia fled to the woods and mountains. They took as much cattle as they could grab in their rush and loaded it onto their ships. He sent Nicias, the praetor of the Achaeans, to Aegium with the loot and then went to Corinth, instructing his army to march overland through Boeotia while he himself sailed from Cenchreae along the coast of Attica, rounding the promontory of Sunium, to reach Chalcis, passing almost right through the enemy’s fleet. After highly praising their loyalty and courage, noting that neither fear nor hope had swayed them, and encouraging them to maintain that same loyalty in upholding the alliance, he sailed to Oreum. He placed those chief inhabitants who preferred to flee rather than surrender to the Romans in charge of the city and its affairs, then sailed from Euboea to Demetrias, from where he initially set out to assist his allies. Later, after laying down the keels for one hundred warships at Cassandrea and gathering many ship carpenters to complete the work, and since both Attalus’s departure and the timely aid he had provided to his allies had calmed the situation in Greece, he returned to his own territories to wage war against the Dardanians.

9

Just at the close of the summer during which these operations were carried on in Greece, when Quintus Fabius, son of Maximus, ambassador from Marcus Livius the consul, brought a message to Rome to the senate, to the effect, that the consul considered that Lucius Portius with his legions formed a sufficient protection for the province, that he might himself retire thence, and that the consular army might be withdrawn, the fathers directed that not only Livius should return to the city, but also his colleague, Caius Claudius. The only difference made between them in the decree was, that they ordered the army of Marcus Livius to be led back, and the legions of Nero to remain in their province opposed to Hannibal. The consuls agreed between themselves by letter, that as they had conducted the affairs of the commonwealth with unanimity, they should arrive at the city at the same time, though they came from different quarters. He who arrived first at Praeneste was enjoined to wait there for his colleague. It so happened that they both came to Praeneste on the same day, and thence, sending a proclamation before them, directing that there should be a full attendance of the senate at the temple of Bellona, three days after, they came up to the city, when they were met by the whole body of the inhabitants. Not only did the whole body pour around them and salute them, but each person individually, desiring to touch the victorious right hands of the consuls, some congratulated them, while others thanked them because by their services the state had been preserved. In the senate, when, having made a recital of their services according to the custom observed by all generals, they had requested, that "in consideration of the brave and successful conduct of the affairs of the commonwealth, honours should be paid to the immortal gods, and they themselves enter the city in triumph;" the fathers replied, that "they most willingly decreed those things which they requested in gratitude to the gods in the first instance, and, next to them, to the consuls." A supplication in the name of both, and a triumph to both of them, having been decreed, lest after having carried on the war with entire unanimity they should have a separate triumph, they made the following agreement; that "since both the service had been performed in the province of Marcus Livius, and he was in possession of the command on the day on which the battle was fought, and further, that as the army of Livius had been withdrawn and had come to Rome, while Nero's could not be withdrawn from the province, Marcus Livius should enter the city in a four-horse chariot and followed by the soldiers; Caius Claudius on horseback without soldiers." This plan of associating the generals in the triumph increased the glory of both, but particularly of him who had yielded to his colleague in the honours he received, as much as he surpassed him in merit. The people said, that "the general on horseback had traversed the whole length of Italy in the space of six days, and had fought a pitched battle with Hasdrubal in Gaul, on the very day on which Hannibal supposed that he was occupying a camp pitched in Apulia to oppose him. That thus one consul, acting in defence of either extremity of Italy against two leaders, had opposed against one his skill, against the other his person. That the name of Nero had been sufficient to confine Hannibal within his camp, while with regard to Hasdrubal, by what, but his arrival, had he been overwhelmed and annihilated? The other consul might move along raised aloft in a chariot, drawn if he pleased by a number of horses, but that the real triumph was his who was conveyed by one horse; and that Nero, though he should go on foot, would be immortalized, whether on account of the glory he had acquired in the war, or the contempt he had shown for it in the triumph." Such continual expressions of the spectators attended Nero all the way to the Capitol. The money they brought into the treasury was three hundred thousand sesterces, with eighty thousand asses of brass. Marcus Livius distributed among the soldiers fifty-six asses each. Caius Claudius promised the same sum to his absent troops when he returned to the army. It was observed that more verses were written by the soldiery upon Caius Claudius in their jocular style, than upon their own consul; that the horsemen highly extolled Lucius Veturius and Quintus Caecilius, lieutenant-generals, and exhorted the commons to create them consuls for the ensuing year; that the consuls added their authority to the recommendation of the knights, relating in the public assembly the following day with what courage and fidelity their two lieutenant-generals in particular had served them.

Just at the end of the summer during which these operations were carried out in Greece, Quintus Fabius, son of Maximus, an envoy from Consul Marcus Livius, brought a message to the Senate in Rome. The consul believed that Lucius Portius, with his legions, was enough protection for the province, allowing him to return and the consular army to be withdrawn. The senators decided that not only Livius should return to the city, but also his colleague, Caius Claudius. The only distinction made in the decree was that Marcus Livius's army would be sent back, while Nero's legions would stay in their province to face Hannibal. The consuls agreed through letters that since they had been working together for the common good, they would arrive in the city at the same time, even though they would be coming from different places. The first to arrive in Praeneste was instructed to wait there for his colleague. It turned out that they both arrived in Praeneste on the same day, and then, sending a notice ahead to ensure a full Senate attendance at the Temple of Bellona three days later, they continued on to the city, where they were welcomed by the entire population. Not only did the crowd gather around them to greet them, but each individual also sought to touch the victorious hands of the consuls, some congratulating them while others thanked them for preserving the state with their efforts. In the Senate, after recounting their accomplishments as is customary for all generals, they requested that "in recognition of their brave and successful management of public affairs, honors should be given to the immortal gods, and they themselves should enter the city in triumph." The senators responded they were more than willing to grant these requests in gratitude to the gods first, and then to the consuls. A supplication in the name of both consuls and a joint triumph were decreed, so that after conducting the war with complete unity, they would not have separate triumphs. They agreed that "since both services were completed in Marcus Livius's province, and he held the command on the day of the battle, plus since Livius's troops had returned to Rome while Nero's could not be withdrawn from the province, Marcus Livius would enter the city in a four-horse chariot followed by his soldiers, while Caius Claudius would ride on horseback without soldiers." This plan to share the triumph elevated the glory of both consuls, but especially for the one who graciously gave way to his colleague in the honors received. The people remarked that "the general on horseback had traveled the length of Italy in six days and fought a major battle with Hasdrubal in Gaul on the same day Hannibal thought he was setting up camp in Apulia to oppose him. Thus, one consul had defended both ends of Italy against two leaders, using his tactics against one and his presence against the other. The name of Nero had been enough to keep Hannibal confined to his camp, and it was by what, if not Nero's arrival, that Hasdrubal was overwhelmed and defeated? The other consul might ride in a chariot drawn by many horses, but the real triumph belonged to the one who was carried by a single horse; and Nero, even if he walked, would achieve immortality, either for the glory he earned in battle or for the disdain he showed toward it in the triumph." Such ongoing praise from the spectators followed Nero all the way to the Capitol. The money they brought into the treasury totaled three hundred thousand sesterces, along with eighty thousand brass asses. Marcus Livius distributed fifty-six asses to each soldier. Caius Claudius promised to give the same amount to his absent troops when he returned to the army. It was noted that more verses were written about Caius Claudius in a joking manner by the soldiers than about their own consul; that the horsemen praised Lucius Veturius and Quintus Caecilius, the lieutenant-generals, highly and urged the public to elect them as consuls for the following year; and that the consuls supported the knights' recommendation, detailing the bravery and loyalty of their two lieutenant-generals in a public gathering the next day.

10

When the time for the elections approached, and it was resolved that it should be held by a dictator, the consul Caius Claudius nominated as dictator his colleague Marcus Livius, who appointed Quintus Caecilius his master of the horse. Lucius Veturius and Quintus Caecilius were created consuls by Marcus Livius the dictator, the latter being then master of the horse. After this the election of praetors was held. The persons appointed were, Caius Servilius, Marcus Caecilius Metellus, Titus Claudius Asellus, and Quintus Mamilius Turinus, who was at that time plebeian aedile. When the elections were finished, the dictator, having abdicated his office and dismissed his army, set out for his province of Etruria, according to a decree of the senate, to make inquiry what states of the Tuscans and Umbrians had formed schemes of revolt from the Romans to Hasdrubal at the time of his approach, and what states had assisted him with auxiliaries, provisions, or succours of any kind. Such were the transactions this year at home and abroad. The Roman games were thrice repeated in full by the curule aediles, Cneius Servilius Caepio and Servius Cornelius Lentulus. In the same manner the plebeian games also were once repeated entire by the plebeian aediles, Manius Pomponius Matho and Quintus Mamilius Thurinus.

When election time came close and it was decided that a dictator would oversee it, the consul Caius Claudius nominated his fellow consul Marcus Livius as dictator, who then appointed Quintus Caecilius as his master of the horse. Lucius Veturius and Quintus Caecilius were made consuls by Dictator Marcus Livius, with the latter still serving as master of the horse. Following this, the election of praetors took place. The individuals chosen were Caius Servilius, Marcus Caecilius Metellus, Titus Claudius Asellus, and Quintus Mamilius Turinus, who was serving as plebeian aedile at that time. Once the elections were over, the dictator resigned from his position and dismissed his army, heading to his province of Etruria, per a Senate decree, to investigate which Tuscan and Umbrian states had plotted to rebel against the Romans alongside Hasdrubal as he approached, and which states had provided him with troops, supplies, or any kind of support. These were the events that unfolded this year both domestically and abroad. The Roman games were held three times in full by the curule aediles, Cneius Servilius Caepio and Servius Cornelius Lentulus. Likewise, the plebeian games were repeated in full once by the plebeian aediles, Manius Pomponius Matho and Quintus Mamilius Thurinus.

In the thirteenth year of the Punic war, when Lucius Veturius Philo and Quintus Caecilius Metellus were consuls, Bruttium was assigned to both of them, as their province, to carry on the war with Hannibal. The praetors then cast lots for their provinces: Marcus Caecilius Metellus had the city jurisdiction; Quintus Mamilius, the foreign; Caius Servilius, Sicily; Tiberius Claudius, Sardinia. The armies were distributed thus: to one of the consuls was given the army which Caius Claudius the consul of the former year, to the other that which Quintus Claudius the propraetor, had commanded, consisting of two legions each. It was decreed that Marcus Livius, proconsul, who was continued in command for the year, should take the two legions of volunteer slaves from Caius Terentius the propraetor, and that Quintus Mamilius, transferring his judicial business to his colleague, should occupy Gaul with the army which Lucius Porcius, the praetor, had commanded, with orders to lay waste the lands of those Gauls who had revolted to the Carthaginians on the approach of Hasdrubal. The protection of Sicily was assigned to Caius Servilius with the two legions which fought at Cannae, in the same manner as Caius Mamilius had held it. The old army which Aulus Hostilius had commanded was conveyed out of Sardinia, and the consuls enlisted a new legion, which Tiberius Claudius might take over with him. Quintus Claudius and Caius Hostilius Tubulus were continued in command for a year, that the former might hold Tarentum as his province, the latter, Capua. Marcus Valerius, the proconsul, to whom had been committed the protection of the sea-coast round Sicily, was ordered to deliver thirty ships to Caius Servilius, and return to the city with all the rest of the fleet.

In the thirteenth year of the Punic War, when Lucius Veturius Philo and Quintus Caecilius Metellus were consuls, Bruttium was assigned to both of them as their province to continue the war against Hannibal. The praetors then drew lots for their provinces: Marcus Caecilius Metellus had the jurisdiction over the city; Quintus Mamilius, the foreign affairs; Caius Servilius, Sicily; and Tiberius Claudius, Sardinia. The armies were distributed as follows: one of the consuls received the army that Caius Claudius, the consul from the previous year, had commanded, while the other received the one commanded by Quintus Claudius, the propraetor, each consisting of two legions. It was decided that Marcus Livius, the proconsul who remained in command for the year, should take two legions of volunteer soldiers from Caius Terentius, the propraetor, and that Quintus Mamilius, by transferring his judicial duties to his colleague, should occupy Gaul with the army that Lucius Porcius, the praetor, had commanded, with orders to ravage the lands of those Gauls who had allied with the Carthaginians upon Hasdrubal's approach. The protection of Sicily was assigned to Caius Servilius with the two legions that fought at Cannae, in the same way that Caius Mamilius had held it. The old army that Aulus Hostilius had commanded was moved out of Sardinia, and the consuls recruited a new legion for Tiberius Claudius to take with him. Quintus Claudius and Caius Hostilius Tubulus were retained in command for a year so that the former could govern Tarentum as his province and the latter, Capua. Marcus Valerius, the proconsul, who was responsible for protecting the coastline around Sicily, was ordered to hand over thirty ships to Caius Servilius and return to the city with the rest of the fleet.

11

In a state where the greatest anxiety prevailed, in consequence of the very critical situation in which the war stood, and where all events, prosperous or adverse, were attributed to the interposition of the gods, accounts of many prodigies were received; that the temple of Jupiter at Tarracina, and that of Mater Matuta at Satricum, had been struck by lightning. The people of Satricum were no less terrified by two snakes gliding into the temple of Jupiter by the very doors. A report was brought from Antium, that bloody ears of corn had been seen by the reapers. At Caere a pig with two heads had been littered, and a lamb yeaned which was both male and female. Intelligence was brought that two suns had been seen at Alba, and that light had suddenly appeared during night at Fregellae. An ox was reported to have spoken in the Roman territory. A copious perspiration was said to have exuded from the altar of Neptune, in the Flaminian circus; and the temples of Ceres, Safety, and Quirinus were said to have been struck by lightning. The consuls were directed to expiate these prodigies with victims of the larger sort, and to make a supplication for one day. These things were executed according to a decree of the senate. The extinction of the fire in the temple of Vesta struck more terror upon the minds of men than all the prodigies which were reported from abroad, or seen at home; and the vestal, who had the guarding of it for that night, was scourged by the command of Publius Licinius the pontiff. Although this event was not appointed by the gods as a portent, but had happened through human neglect, yet it was thought proper that it should be expiated with victims of the larger sort, and that a supplication should be made at the temple of Vesta.

In a time filled with anxiety due to the critical situation of the war, where every event, whether good or bad, was seen as influenced by the gods, many reports of strange occurrences were received. The temple of Jupiter in Tarracina and that of Mater Matuta in Satricum were struck by lightning. The people of Satricum were also terrified when two snakes slithered into the temple of Jupiter through the doors. Word came from Antium that the reapers had seen ears of corn stained with blood. At Caere, a pig was born with two heads, and a lamb was born that was both male and female. Reports emerged that two suns had been seen in Alba, and that light had suddenly appeared at night in Fregellae. An ox was said to have spoken in Roman territory. It was claimed that a copious sweat had poured from the altar of Neptune in the Flaminian circus, and the temples of Ceres, Safety, and Quirinus were said to have been struck by lightning. The consuls were ordered to appease these omens with larger sacrifices and to hold a day of supplication. These actions were carried out according to a decree from the senate. The extinguishing of the fire in the temple of Vesta caused even more fear among the people than all the prodigies reported from elsewhere or witnessed at home; the vestal in charge of it that night was punished by the command of Publius Licinius, the pontiff. Although this incident was not deemed a sign from the gods but rather a result of human negligence, it was still deemed necessary to appease it with larger sacrifices and to hold a supplication at the temple of Vesta.

Before the consuls set out for the campaign, they were cautioned by the senate to take care that the common people should be brought back into the country; for since, through the goodness of the gods, the war was removed from the city of Rome and Latium, the country might be inhabited without fear. That it was most inconsistent that greater care should be taken in cultivating Sicily than Italy. But it was a matter by no means easy for the people, the free labourers having been cut off by war, and there being a scarcity of slaves, their cattle having been carried off as booty, and the farmhouses pulled down or burnt. A large number, however, compelled by the authority of the consuls, returned into the country. The mention of this affair had been occasioned by ambassadors of Placentia and Cremona, who complained that their lands were being invaded and laid waste by the neighbouring Gauls; that a large portion of their settlers had dispersed; that their cities were thinly inhabited, and their lands devastated and deserted. Mamilius the praetor was charged with the protection of the colonies from the enemy. The consuls, in conformity with a decree of the senate, issued an edict that all who were citizens of Cremona and Placentia should return to those colonies before a certain day; after which, in the beginning of spring, they set out for the campaign. Quintus Caecilius, the consul, received the army from Caius Nero; Lucius Veturius received his from Quintus Claudius the propraetor, filling it up with new-raised soldiers, whom he had himself enlisted. The consuls marched their army into the territory of Consentia, and devastating the country on all hands, when the troops were loaded with plunder, they were thrown into such confusion by some Bruttians and Numidian spearmen, who attacked them in a narrow defile, that not only the booty but the troops were in danger. There was more of confusion, however than fighting; and sending the booty in advance, the legions themselves also escaped into a place free from danger. Proceeding thence into Lucania, the whole of that people returned, without a contest, into subjection to the Roman people.

Before the consuls headed out for the campaign, the senate warned them to ensure that the common people were brought back to the country. Thanks to the favor of the gods, the war had moved away from the city of Rome and Latium, allowing the countryside to be repopulated without fear. It was seen as highly inconsistent to put more effort into cultivating Sicily than Italy. However, it wasn’t easy for the people since the free laborers had been taken by war, there was a shortage of slaves, their livestock had been seized as loot, and their farmhouses had been destroyed or burned. Nonetheless, many were compelled by the consuls' authority to return to the countryside. This situation arose due to complaints from ambassadors of Placentia and Cremona, who reported that their lands were being invaded and ravaged by neighboring Gauls; a large part of their settlers had scattered, their cities were sparsely populated, and their lands were devastated and abandoned. Mamilius, the praetor, was tasked with protecting the colonies from the enemy. Following a senate decree, the consuls issued an edict for all citizens of Cremona and Placentia to return to their colonies by a certain date; after that, they set off for the campaign at the start of spring. Quintus Caecilius, the consul, took over the army from Caius Nero; Lucius Veturius took his from Quintus Claudius the propraetor, bolstering it with new soldiers he had personally recruited. The consuls led their army into the territory of Consentia, devastating the area as they went. However, they were thrown into confusion by a surprise attack from some Bruttians and Numidian spearmen in a narrow pass, putting both the loot and their troops at risk. There was more confusion than real fighting; they sent the loot ahead and managed to get the legions to safety in a secure place. After that, they moved into Lucania, where the entire population surrendered to the Roman people without a fight.

12

No action with Hannibal took place this year; for neither did he present himself after the public and personal calamity so recently inflicted, and the Romans did not provoke him while he remained quiet, such power did they consider that single general possessed, though every thing else around him was falling into ruin. Indeed I know not whether he was not more deserving of admiration in adversity than in prosperity; inasmuch as though he carried on a war in the territory of enemies through a period of thirteen years, at so great a distance from home, with varying success, and with, an army not composed of his own countrymen, but made up of the offscouring of all nations, without communion of laws, customs, or language, different in their appearance, their dress, their arms, their religious ceremonies and observances, and I had almost said, their gods; yet he so effectually united them by some one bond, that no disturbance ever arose either among the soldiers themselves, or between them and their general, though he often wanted money to pay them, and provisions, as being in a hostile country, through want of which, in the former Punic war, many dreadful transactions had occurred between the generals and their soldiers. But after the destruction of Hasdrubal and his army, in which all hopes of victory had been treasured up; and after retiring from the possession of every other part of Italy by withdrawing into Bruttium, one corner of it; to whom does it not appear wonderful that no disturbance arose in the camp? For to other circumstances this also was added, that he had no nope of subsisting his army, except from the lands of Bruttium, which, though they were all cultivated, would be very insufficient for the maintenance of so large an army. Besides, many of the youth were drawn off from the cultivation of the fields, and engaged in the war; and a custom also prevailed among the people of that nation, grafted on a naturally depraved inclination, of carrying on a predatory kind of warfare. Nor did he receive any supplies from home, where they were anxious about the retention of Spain, as if every thing was going on prosperously in Italy. In Spain the state of affairs was in one respect similar, but in another widely different; similar in that the Carthaginians, having been defeated with the loss of their general, had been driven to the remotest coast of that country, even to the ocean; but different, because Spain, both from the nature of the country and the genius of its inhabitants, was better adapted not only than Italy, but than any other part of the world, for renewing a war. And accordingly, therefore, though this was the first of the provinces on the continent which the Romans entered, it was the last which was at length reduced, in the present age, under the conduct and auspices of Augustus Caesar. Here Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, the greatest and most renowned general concerned in the war, next to the Barcine family, returning from Gades, and encouraged in his hopes of reviving the war by Mago, son of Hamilcar, by means of levies made throughout the Farther Spain, armed as many as fifty thousand foot and four thousand five hundred horse. With regard to his mounted force, authors are pretty much agreed, but some state that seventy thousand infantry were led to the city Silpia. Here the two Carthaginian generals sat down on open plains, with a determination not to avoid a battle.

No actions involving Hannibal happened this year; he didn’t show himself after the recent public and personal disaster, and the Romans didn’t provoke him while he stayed quiet, considering the immense power he possessed despite everything around him falling apart. I’m not sure if he was more admirable in defeat than in victory; after all, he managed a war in enemy territory for thirteen years, far from home, with mixed success, and he led an army made up not of his own countrymen but of the outcasts from all nations, lacking common laws, customs, or language. They were diverse in their appearance, clothing, weapons, and religious practices, almost different gods as well; yet he managed to unite them under one bond so effectively that no conflict arose among the soldiers or between them and their general, even though he often lacked money to pay them and food, being in a hostile territory, which previously led to many terrible situations in the former Punic war. But after the defeat of Hasdrubal and his army, where all hopes of victory had been stored, and after withdrawing from all other parts of Italy into Bruttium, a small corner of it, isn’t it amazing that no disturbances arose in the camp? On top of that, he had no hope to sustain his army except from the lands of Bruttium, which, even though cultivated, would still be insufficient for such a large force. Additionally, many young men were taken away from farming and engaged in the war, and a custom also existed among that people, stemming from a naturally flawed tendency, of carrying out predatory warfare. He also received no supplies from home, where they were concerned about holding onto Spain, as though everything was going fine in Italy. In Spain, the situation was somewhat similar but also very different; similar in that the Carthaginians, having suffered defeat and the loss of their general, were forced to the farthest coast of the country, even to the ocean; but different because Spain, due to its landscape and the nature of its people, was better suited than Italy, or any other part of the world, for resuming a war. Thus, even though this was the first province on the continent the Romans entered, it was the last to ultimately fall under the rule and leadership of Augustus Caesar in this era. Here, Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, the greatest and most notable general involved in the war after the Barcine family, returned from Gades, encouraged by Mago, son of Hamilcar, reviving the war through levies made throughout Further Spain, raising an army of fifty thousand foot and four thousand five hundred horse. Historians largely agree on his cavalry numbers, but some say that seventy thousand infantry were led to the city Silpia. Here, the two Carthaginian generals took position in open plains, determined not to shy away from battle.

13

When Scipio received an account of the collection of so large an army, he felt convinced that he would not be a match for so great a multitude with the Roman legions only, without making a show at least of the auxiliary troops of the barbarians; at the same time that he did not think it right that they should form so large a portion of his force as to occasion important consequences if they should change sides, which had brought ruin upon his father and his uncle. Therefore, sending forward Silanus to Colca, who was sovereign of twenty-eight towns, to receive from him the infantry and cavalry, which he promised to enlist during the winter, he himself set out from Tarraco; and collecting small bodies of auxiliaries from his allies, who lay near his road as he proceeded, he came to Castulo. To this place Silanus led the auxiliaries, consisting of three thousand infantry and five hundred horse. Thence he advanced to the city of Baecula, with his entire army of countrymen and allies, foot and horse, amounting to forty-five thousand. Mago and Masinissa attacked them with the whole body of their cavalry while forming their camp, and would have dispersed those engaged in the works, had not a party of horse, concealed by Scipio behind an eminence conveniently situated for the purpose, unexpectedly charged them when rushing on to the attack, and, ere the battle was well begun, routed all the most forward, both those who had advanced nearest the rampart, and those who were foremost in charging the very workmen. With the rest of the troops who came up with their standards, and in order of march, the contest lasted longer, and was for a considerable time doubtful. But when first the light cohorts from the outposts, and then the troops withdrawn from the works and ordered to take arms, came up, being more numerous than those which had been engaged, and fresh while they were fatigued, and now a large body of armed troops rushed from the camp to the battle, the Carthaginians and Numidians at once turned their backs. At first they moved off in troops without breaking their ranks, through fear or precipitation; but afterwards, when the Romans pressed furiously upon their rear, and they were unable to bear the violence of their attack, then at length, utterly regardless of order, they fled precipitately in every direction, as suited each man's convenience. And although, in consequence of this battle, the spirits of the Romans were considerably raised, and those of the enemy depressed, yet, for several days following, the horsemen and light-armed troops never ceased from skirmishes.

When Scipio heard about the gathering of such a large army, he was convinced that he couldn’t handle that many troops with just the Roman legions. He knew he needed to at least showcase some auxiliary troops from the barbarians. However, he didn’t want those troops to make up such a huge part of his forces that if they switched sides, it would have serious consequences—something that had cost his father and uncle dearly. So, he sent Silanus ahead to Colca, who ruled over twenty-eight towns, to recruit both infantry and cavalry that Silanus promised to raise during the winter. Meanwhile, Scipio left Tarraco and gathered small groups of auxiliary troops from nearby allies as he traveled, eventually reaching Castulo. Silanus brought the auxiliaries to this location, which included three thousand infantry and five hundred cavalry. From there, they moved to the city of Baecula, where their total army of local soldiers and allies, both foot and horse, numbered forty-five thousand. Mago and Masinissa attacked them with their full cavalry while they were setting up camp, and they might have thrown the workers into disarray if it hadn't been for a unit of cavalry that Scipio had hidden on a strategic hill. This unit charged unexpectedly as the Carthaginians rushed in, effectively routing the front lines—those closest to the rampart and the most aggressive against the workers. The fight continued longer with the rest of the troops that arrived in formation, making the outcome uncertain for a while. But when the fresh light units from the outposts and those pulled from the work assembled, they outnumbered the engaged troops and had the advantage of being rested against those who were tired. Soon, a large group of armed troops surged from the camp into battle, causing the Carthaginians and Numidians to suddenly retreat. At first, they withdrew in formation out of fear, but as the Romans pressed harder from behind, they couldn't withstand the attack any longer and broke ranks, fleeing in all directions as each man saw fit. Although this battle lifted the spirits of the Romans and lowered those of their enemies, for several days afterward, skirmishes continued among the cavalry and light troops.

14

After having made sufficient trial of their strength in these slight engagements, Hasdrubal first led out his forces for battle, and then the Romans also advanced. But both the armies stood drawn up before their ramparts; and as neither party began the attack, and the sun was now going down, the Carthaginian first, and then the Roman, led back his troops into the camp. The same occurred for several days. The Carthaginian was always the first to lead out his troops into the field, and the first to give the signal for retiring, when they were weary with standing. Neither party sallied from their posts, nor was a weapon discharged, or a word uttered. On one side the Romans occupied the centre, on the other, the Carthaginians and Africans together; the allies occupied the wings, which were composed of Spaniards on both sides. The elephants which stood before the Carthaginian line, appeared at a distance like castles. It was now commonly talked of in both camps, that they would fight in the order in which they had stood when drawn up, and that their centres, composed of Romans and Carthaginians, who were the principals in the war, would engage with equal courage and strength. When Scipio perceived that this was firmly believed, he studiously altered all his arrangements against the day on which he intended to fight. He issued orders through the camp at evening, that the men and horses should be refreshed and fed before daylight, and that the horsemen, armed themselves, should keep their horses bridled and saddled. When it was scarcely yet daylight, he sent all his cavalry, with the light troops, against the Carthaginian outposts, and then without delay advanced himself, at the head of the heavy body of the legions, having strengthened his wings with Roman soldiers, and placed the allies in the centre, contrary to the full anticipations of his own men and of the enemy. Hasdrubal, alarmed by the shout of the cavalry, sprang out of his tent, and, perceiving a tumult before the rampart, and his own troops in a state of hurry and confusion, the standards of the legions gleaming at a distance, and the plain filled with the enemy, immediately sent out the whole body of his cavalry against the horsemen of the enemy; marching himself out of the camp, at the head of the infantry, without departing at all from the usual arrangement in forming his line. The battle between the cavalry had continued for a long time doubtful; nor could they decide it themselves, because, when repulsed, which was the case in a manner alternately, they had a safe retreat upon the line of infantry. But when the armies were not more than five hundred paces distant from each other, Scipio, sounding a retreat and opening his files, received into the midst of them the whole body of his cavalry and light-armed troops; and dividing them into two parts, placed them in reserve behind the wings. After this, when it was now time to commence the battle, he ordered the Spaniards, who formed the centre, to advance at a slow pace; he himself sent a messenger from the right wing, for that he commanded, to Silanus and Marcius to extend the wing on the left in the same manner as they should see him extend that on the right, and engage the enemy with the light-armed of the horse and foot, before the two centres could meet. The wings being thus extended, they advanced against the enemy at a rapid pace, with three cohorts of infantry, and three troops of horse, each with the addition of skirmishers, the rest following them in an oblique line. There was a depression in the centre of the line, because the battalions of the Spaniards advanced slower than the rest, and the wings had already encountered the enemy, when the veteran Carthaginians and Africans had not yet come within distance to discharge their darts; nor dared they run in different directions to the wings to assist them when fighting, lest they should expose their centre to the enemy approaching over against them. The wings were hard pressed, by a twofold attack; the cavalry, the light-armed, and the skirmishers, wheeling round, charged their flanks, while the cohorts pressed them hard in front, in order to separate the wings from the rest of the line.

After testing their strength in these minor skirmishes, Hasdrubal first led out his troops for battle, and then the Romans advanced as well. However, both armies lined up in front of their fortifications, and since neither side initiated the attack and the sun began to set, the Carthaginians were the first to pull back, followed by the Romans. This routine continued for several days. Hasdrubal always led his troops into the field first and was the first to signal for retreat when they were exhausted from standing. Neither side left their positions, nor was a weapon fired or a word spoken. The Romans occupied the center while the Carthaginians and Africans were positioned on one side; the allies made up the wings, which were filled with Spaniards on both sides. The elephants at the front of the Carthaginian line looked like castles from a distance. Both camps were abuzz with speculation that they would fight in the formation they maintained, with the centers of Romans and Carthaginians—who were the main forces in the war—engaging with equal valor and strength. Once Scipio realized that this belief was firmly held, he carefully adjusted all his plans for the day he intended to fight. He ordered the camp in the evening that men and horses should be refreshed and fed before dawn, and that the cavalry, armed, should keep their horses bridled and saddled. As dawn broke, he sent all his cavalry along with the light infantry against the Carthaginian outposts, and then moved himself at the front of the heavy legions, bolstering his flanks with Roman soldiers and placing the allies in the center—disregarding the expectations of both his own men and the enemy. Alarmed by the cavalry's shout, Hasdrubal rushed out of his tent, saw the chaos at the rampart, and noticed his own troops in a flurry, with the standards of the legions shining from a distance and the plain filled with enemies. He immediately dispatched his entire cavalry against the enemy horsemen and marched out of the camp at the forefront of the infantry, maintaining the usual arrangement in forming his line. The battle between the cavalry was long and inconclusive; they couldn’t resolve it themselves since, when repelled—as happened alternately—they could safely retreat behind the infantry line. But when the armies were only five hundred paces apart, Scipio called a retreat, opened his ranks, and brought all his cavalry and light infantry into their midst, dividing them into two parts to reserve behind the wings. When it was time to start the battle, he ordered the Spaniards, who were in the center, to advance slowly; he sent a messenger from the right wing, which he commanded, to Silanus and Marcius to extend the left wing in the same manner he would extend the right and engage the enemy with the light troops before the two centers could meet. With the wings extended, they quickly moved towards the enemy with three cohorts of infantry and three cavalry units, each backed by skirmishers, while the rest followed in an oblique line. There was a dip in the center of the line because the Spanish battalions were advancing more slowly than the others, and the wings had already engaged the enemy while the seasoned Carthaginians and Africans had yet to come within range to throw their darts. They didn’t dare rush to the wings to support them in battle for fear of leaving their center exposed to the approaching enemy. The wings faced a double attack, with the cavalry, light infantry, and skirmishers circling around to hit their flanks, while the cohorts pressed hard against them from the front to separate the wings from the main line.

15

The battle was now extremely unequal in every part, both because an irregular band of Balearians and raw Spaniards were opposed to Roman and Latin soldiers, and further, because, as the day was now getting on, Hasdrubal's troops began to grow languid, having been dispirited by the alarm in the morning, and compelled to go out hastily into the field, without refreshing themselves with food. Scipio had designedly spun out the day, in order that the battle might take place at a late hour; for it was not until the seventh hour that the battalions of infantry charged the wings. It was considerably later before the battle reached the centres, so that the heat from the meridian sun, and the fatigue of standing under arms, together with hunger and thirst, enfeebled their bodies before they engaged the enemy. Thus they stood still, supporting themselves upon their shields. In addition to their other misfortunes, the elephants too, terrified at the tumultuous kind of attack of the cavalry, the skirmishers, and the light-armed, had transferred themselves from the wings to the centre. Fatigued therefore in mind and body, they gave ground, preserving their ranks, however, just as though the army were retreating entire at the command of their general. But when the victors, perceiving that the enemy had given way, charged them on all sides with increased vehemence on that very account, so that the shock could hardly be sustained, though Hasdrubal endeavoured to stop them and hinder them from retiring, vociferating, "that there were hills on their rear, and a safe refuge if they would retreat without precipitation;" yet, fear getting the better of their sense of shame, and all those who were nearest the enemy giving way, they immediately turned their backs, and all gave themselves up to disorderly flight. The first place they halted at was the foot of the hills, where they endeavoured to recall the soldiers to their ranks, the Romans hesitating to advance their line up the opposite steep; but afterwards, when they saw them push on briskly, renewing their flight, they were driven into their camp in extreme alarm. Nor were the Romans far from the rampart; and such was their impetuosity, that they would have taken their camp had not so violent a shower of rain suddenly poured down, while, as is usually the case, the solar rays darted with the greatest intensity between the clouds surcharged with water, that the victors with difficulty returned to their camp. Some were even deterred, by superstition, from making any further attempts that day. Though night and the rain invited the Carthaginians to take necessary rest, yet, as their fears and the danger would not allow them to delay, as it was expected that the enemy would assault their camp as soon as it was light, they raised their rampart by stones collected from the neighbouring valleys around them on all sides, with the determination to defend themselves by works, since there was but little protection in their arms. But the desertion of their allies made it appear safer to fly than stay. Attanes, prince of the Turdetani, began this revolt; he deserted at the head of a numerous band of his countrymen. Then two fortified towns, together with their garrisons, were delivered up by their praefects to the Romans. And, lest the evil should spread more widely, now that the disposition to revolt from the Carthaginians had evinced itself in one instance, Hasdrubal decamped during the silence of the ensuing night.

The battle was extremely unbalanced in every way, with a disorganized group of Balearians and inexperienced Spaniards facing off against seasoned Roman and Latin soldiers. As the day went on, Hasdrubal's troops became exhausted, having been demoralized by the morning's alarm and forced to rush into battle without eating. Scipio deliberately extended the day so that the fight would start later; it wasn't until the seventh hour that the infantry charged the flanks. It took even longer for the battle to reach the center, leaving the soldiers weakened from the midday sun, fatigue from standing ready, and hunger and thirst before they engaged the enemy. They stood, propping themselves up on their shields. To make matters worse, the elephants, scared by the chaotic attacks from the cavalry, skirmishers, and light troops, moved from the flanks to the center. Mentally and physically drained, they fell back while maintaining their formation, as if the entire army was retreating on command. However, when the victors saw the enemy yielding, they charged from all sides with renewed intensity, making it hard to hold their ground, even though Hasdrubal tried to rally them by shouting that there were hills behind them and a safe retreat if they fell back without haste. But fear overcame their shame, and as those closest to the enemy began to give ground, they turned and fled in chaos. They initially stopped at the base of the hills, trying to regroup, while the Romans hesitated to advance up the steep slope; but once they saw the Romans push forward vigorously, they broke into a panic and retreated into their camp in complete fear. The Romans were not far from the rampart, and their eagerness was so great that they likely would have taken the camp if not for a sudden downpour. As often happens, the sun's rays shone intensely between the rain-filled clouds, making it difficult for the victors to return to their camp. Some were even held back by superstition from attempting anything further that day. Although night and the rain should have allowed the Carthaginians to rest, their fears and the looming threat kept them from delaying. Expecting a Roman assault at dawn, they raised their rampart with stones gathered from the nearby valleys, deciding to defend themselves with fortifications since their arms offered little protection. But with their allies abandoning them, it seemed safer to flee than to stay put. Attanes, the leader of the Turdetani, kicked off this revolt by deserting with a large group of his countrymen. Soon after, two fortified towns and their garrisons surrendered to the Romans. To prevent the unrest from spreading further now that there was clear discontent among the Carthaginians, Hasdrubal decided to move under the cover of night.

16

The troops in the outposts having brought word, as soon as it was light, that the enemy had departed, Scipio, despatching his cavalry in advance, ordered the army to move forward; and so rapidly were they led, that had they directly followed the track of the fugitives, they would certainly have overtaken them; but they trusted to the report of their guides, that there was a shorter cut to the river Baetis, where they might attack them while crossing it. Hasdrubal, being precluded from passing the river, turned his course to the ocean; and they now advanced in disorder and in the manner of fugitives, so that the Roman legions were left considerably behind. The cavalry and light-armed, attacking sometimes their rear, and sometimes their flank, harassed and delayed them; and as they were obliged to halt, in consequence of these frequent annoyances, and engaged sometimes the cavalry, at other times the skirmishers and the auxiliary infantry, the legions came up. After this it was no longer a fight, but a butchering as of cattle, till the general himself, who was the first to run away, made his escape to the neighbouring hills with about six thousand men half armed; the rest were slain or made prisoners. The Carthaginians hastily fortified an irregular camp on the highest eminence, and from thence they defended themselves without difficulty, the enemy failing in his attempt to get at them, from the difficulty of the ascent. But a siege in a place bare and affording no means of subsistence, was hardly to be supported, even for a few days; the troops therefore deserted to the enemy. At last the general himself, having procured some ships, for the sea was not at a great distance, left his army by night and effected his escape to Gades. Scipio, having heard of the flight of the general of the enemy, left ten thousand foot and one thousand cavalry for Silanus to carry on the siege of the camp, and returned to Tarraco with the rest of the troops, after a march of seventy days, during which he took cognizance of the causes of the petty princes and states, in order that rewards might be conferred according to a just estimate of their merits. After his departure, Masinissa, having held a private conference with Silanus, passed over into Africa with a few of his countrymen, in order that he might induce his nation also to acquiesce in his new designs. The cause of this sudden change was not so evident at the time, as the proof was convincing which was afforded by his subsequent fidelity, preserved to extreme old age, that he did not on this occasion act without reasonable grounds. Mago went to Gades in the ships which had been sent back by Hasdrubal. Of the rest of the troops thus abandoned by their generals, some deserted and others betook themselves to flight, and in this manner were dispersed through the neighbouring states. There was no body of them considerable either for numbers or strength. Such were, as near as possible, the circumstances under which the Carthaginians were driven out of Spain, under the conduct and auspices of Publius Scipio, in the thirteenth year from the commencement of the war, and the fifth from the time that Publius Scipio received the province and the army. Not long after, Silanus returned to Tarraco to Scipio, with information that the war was at an end.

As soon as it got light and the outpost troops reported that the enemy had left, Scipio sent his cavalry ahead and ordered the army to advance. They moved so quickly that if they had directly followed the path of the fleeing enemy, they would have caught up with them for sure. However, they relied on their guides' information about a shorter route to the Baetis River, where they could attack the enemy while they were crossing. Hasdrubal, unable to cross the river, headed towards the ocean. The Carthaginians moved chaotically like fugitives, leaving the Roman legions far behind. The cavalry and lightweight soldiers harassed them from the rear and flanks, causing delays. Whenever they had to stop due to these continuous attacks and engaged with either the cavalry or the skirmishers, the legions were able to catch up. After that, it was no longer a battle, but more like a slaughter of cattle, until the general himself, the first to flee, escaped with about six thousand half-armed men to the nearby hills; the rest were killed or captured. The Carthaginians quickly built a makeshift camp on high ground and defended it easily, as the enemy struggled to reach them because of the steep climb. But a siege in a barren place with no food sources was hard to endure for even a few days, so the troops deserted to the enemy. Eventually, the general managed to get some ships—since the sea wasn’t far away—and left his army at night to escape to Gades. Scipio, hearing of the enemy general's flight, left ten thousand infantry and one thousand cavalry for Silanus to continue the siege and returned to Tarraco with the rest of the troops after a seventy-day march, where he addressed the issues of local princes and states to ensure rewards were given fairly according to their merits. After his departure, Masinissa held a private meeting with Silanus and then crossed to Africa with a few of his countrymen to convince his people to support his new plans. The reasons for this sudden change weren't clear at the time, but his later loyalty, which he maintained into old age, proved that he had sensible motives. Mago went to Gades on the ships that Hasdrubal had sent back. As for the other troops abandoned by their generals, some deserted, while others fled, scattering through the neighboring states without forming any significant group in numbers or strength. These were the circumstances under which the Carthaginians were driven out of Spain by Publius Scipio in the thirteenth year of the war and the fifth year since Publius Scipio took command of the province and army. Not long after, Silanus returned to Tarraco to inform Scipio that the war was over.

17

Lucius Scipio was sent to Rome to convey the news of the reduction of Spain, and with him a number of distinguished captives. While everybody else extolled this achievement as an event in the highest degree joyful and glorious, yet the author of it alone, whose valour was such that he never thought he had achieved enough, and whose search for true glory was insatiable, considered the reduction of Spain as affording but a faint idea of the hopes which his aspiring mind had conceived. He now directed his view to Africa and Great Carthage, and the glorious termination of the war, as redounding to his honour, and giving lustre to his name. Judging it therefore to be now necessary to pave the way to his object, and to conciliate the friendship of kings and nations, he resolved first to sound the disposition of Syphax, king of the Masaesylians, a nation bordering on the Moors, and lying for the most part over-against that quarter of Spain in which New Carthage is situated. The king was at the present juncture in league with the Carthaginians; and Scipio, concluding that he would not hold it as more binding and sacred than was customary with barbarians, sent Caius Laelius as envoy to him with presents. The barbarian, delighted with these, and seeing that the Roman cause was then successful in every quarter, but that the Carthaginians were unfortunate in Italy, and no longer existed in Spain, consented to accept the friendship of the Romans, but refused to give or receive a solemn ratification of it except the Roman general himself were present in person. This being the case, Laelius returned to Scipio, having received from the king merely an assurance of a safe journey. To one desirous of getting a footing in Africa, Syphax was of great importance, as he was the most powerful king in that country, had already had experience of the Carthaginians themselves in war, and the boundaries of his dominions lay very conveniently with respect to Spain, from which they are separated by a narrow strait. Scipio, therefore, considering it an object of sufficient importance to warrant his attempting it, notwithstanding the greatness of the danger which attended it, since he could not effect it otherwise, left for the protection of Spain Lucius Marcius at Tarraco, and Marcus Silanus at New Carthage, to which place he had gone on foot by long marches; and setting out himself in company with Caius Laelius, with two quinqueremes from Carthage, passed over into Africa, working the vessels with oars for the greatest part of the voyage, in consequence of the calmness of the sea, though sometimes they were assisted by a gentle breeze. It so happened, that just at that time Hasdrubal, having been driven out of Spain, had entered the harbour with seven triremes, and having cast anchor was mooring his ships. The sight of two quinqueremes, which it was the firm opinion of everybody belonged to the enemy, and might be overpowered by superior numbers before they entered the harbour, produced no other effect than a tumult and confusion among the soldiers and sailors, who endeavoured to no purpose to get their arms and ships ready; for their sails, impelled by a somewhat brisker gale from the sea, brought the quinqueremes into the harbour before the Carthaginians weighed their anchors, and no one dared make any further stir now that they were in the king's harbour. Thus Hasdrubal, who landed first, and Scipio and Laelius, who landed soon after, proceeded to the king.

Lucius Scipio was sent to Rome to deliver the news about the capture of Spain, along with a number of notable captives. While everyone praised this achievement as incredibly joyful and glorious, the one responsible for it felt that his bravery was such that he never thought he had done enough, and his quest for true glory was unending. He viewed the capture of Spain as just a small step toward the grand ambitions he had envisioned. He now shifted his focus to Africa and Great Carthage, seeking a glorious end to the war that would enhance his reputation and shine a light on his name. Believing it was necessary to prepare the ground for his goals and win the friendship of kings and nations, he decided to first gauge the attitude of Syphax, the king of the Masaesylians, a nation next to the Moors, situated mostly across from the part of Spain where New Carthage was located. At that moment, the king was allied with the Carthaginians; and Scipio, thinking that Syphax would not consider his alliance as binding as it typically was with barbarians, sent Caius Laelius as an envoy with gifts. The barbarian, pleased by these, saw that the Roman cause was thriving everywhere while the Carthaginians were struggling in Italy and no longer held any ground in Spain. He agreed to accept the Romans' friendship but refused to formalize it without the Roman general present. As a result, Laelius returned to Scipio, having only secured a promise of a safe journey from the king. For someone eager to establish a foothold in Africa, Syphax was crucial, being the most powerful king in the region, having already experienced conflict with the Carthaginians, and his lands were conveniently close to Spain, separated by a narrow strait. Therefore, Scipio, deeming it significant enough to pursue despite the risks involved, left Lucius Marcius in charge of Spain at Tarraco and Marcus Silanus in New Carthage, to which he had traveled on foot after a long march; and he set off himself with Caius Laelius, taking two quinqueremes from Carthage, crossing over to Africa, mostly rowing due to the calm sea, though occasionally aided by a light breeze. At that moment, Hasdrubal, having been forced out of Spain, had just entered the harbor with seven triremes, and while anchoring, he noticed two quinqueremes, which everyone believed belonged to the enemy and could be overwhelmed by greater numbers before they could reach the harbor. This sight created chaos and confusion among the soldiers and sailors, who rushed to ready their arms and ships without success; as the winds picked up just enough to push the quinqueremes into the harbor before the Carthaginians could weigh anchor, and no one dared to make another move now that they had entered the king's harbor. Thus, Hasdrubal disembarked first, and Scipio and Laelius followed soon after, proceeding to the king.

18

Syphax considered it highly honourable to him, as it really was, that generals of the two most powerful people of the age should come to him on the same day to solicit peace and friendship with him. He invited them both to become his guests; and, as it was the will of fortune that they should be under one roof, and under the protection of the same household gods, he endeavoured to bring them together to a conference, in order to put an end to the difference between them; when Scipio declared, that there was no personal enmity between the Carthaginian and himself which he might do away with by a conference, and that he could not transact any business relating to the republic with an enemy without the command of the senate. But the king being earnest in his endeavours to persuade him to come to the same entertainment, lest one of his guests should appear to be excluded, he did not withhold his assent. They supped together at the king's table, and Scipio and Hasdrubal even sat at meat on the same couch, because it was the king's pleasure. So courteous was the manner of Scipio, so naturally happy and universal was his genius, that by his conversation he gained the esteem not only of Syphax, a barbarian, and unused to Roman manners, but even of a most inveterate enemy, who openly avowed, that "he appeared to him more to be admired for the qualities he displayed on a personal interview with him, than for his exploits in war, and that he had no doubt that Syphax and his kingdom were already at the disposal of the Romans, such were the abilities that man possessed for gaining the esteem of others. That it, therefore, was incumbent upon the Carthaginians not more to inquire by what means they had lost Spain, than to consider how they might retain possession of Africa. That it was not from a desire to visit foreign countries, or to roam about delightful coasts, that so great a Roman captain, leaving a recently subdued province, and his armies, had crossed over into Africa with only two ships, entering an enemy's territory, and committing himself to the untried honour of the king, but in pursuance of a hope he had conceived of subduing Africa. That it had been long the object of his anxious solicitude, and had drawn from him open expressions of his indignation, that Scipio was not carrying on war in Africa in the same way as Hannibal was in Italy." Scipio, having formed a league with Syphax, set out from Africa, and, after having been tossed about during his voyage by variable and generally tempestuous winds, made the port of New Carthage on the fourth day.

Syphax thought it was a big honor, as it truly was, that the leaders of the two most powerful nations of the time came to him on the same day to seek peace and friendship. He invited both of them to be his guests, and since fate had brought them under one roof and the protection of the same household gods, he tried to bring them together for a meeting to resolve their differences. Scipio stated that there was no personal animosity between him and the Carthaginian that could be settled in a meeting, and he couldn’t discuss any matters regarding the republic with an enemy without the senate’s approval. However, the king was eager to persuade him to join the same gathering, so as not to make one of his guests feel excluded, and he agreed. They had dinner together at the king’s table, and Scipio and Hasdrubal even shared the same couch because the king wanted it that way. Scipio was so polite and naturally charming that through his conversation, he earned the respect not just of Syphax—a foreigner unfamiliar with Roman customs—but even of a fierce enemy, who openly admitted that "he seemed to him more admirable for the qualities he displayed in their personal meeting than for his military achievements, and that he believed Syphax and his kingdom were already at the mercy of the Romans, thanks to that man's skills in winning others' admiration. Therefore, it was crucial for the Carthaginians not to focus solely on how they lost Spain, but to consider how they could keep control of Africa. It wasn’t out of a desire to explore foreign lands or to wander along beautiful shores that such a great Roman leader, leaving a recently conquered province and his armies, crossed into Africa with only two ships, entering enemy territory and trusting the untested honor of the king, but rather in pursuit of a hope he had of conquering Africa. For a long time, he had been anxious about this, feeling frustrated that Scipio wasn’t waging war in Africa in the same way Hannibal was in Italy." Scipio, having formed an alliance with Syphax, left Africa, and after being tossed around by unpredictable and mostly stormy winds during his voyage, arrived at the port of New Carthage on the fourth day.

19

As Spain was undisturbed by a Carthaginian war, so it was evident that some of the states remained quiet more from fear, arising from a consciousness of demerit, than from sincere attachment. The most remarkable of them, both for their greatness and guilt, were Illiturgi and Castulo. Castulo had been in alliance with the Romans when in prosperity, but had revolted to the Carthaginians after the destruction of the Scipios and their armies. The Illiturgians, by betraying and putting to death those who fled thither after that calamity, had added villany to revolt. It would have been more deserved than expedient to have executed severe vengeance upon these people on his first arrival, while the affairs of Spain were in an uncertain state; but now, when all was tranquil, as the time for visiting them with punishment appeared to have arrived, he summoned Lucius Marcius from Tarraco, and sent him with a third of his forces to attack Castulo, and with the rest of the army he himself reached Illiturgi, after about five days' march. The gates were closed, and every arrangement and preparation made for repelling an attack; so completely had the consciousness of what they deserved produced the same effect as a declaration of war against them. From this circumstance Scipio commenced his exhortation to his soldiers: he said, that "by closing their gates the Spaniards had themselves shown what their deserts were by what they feared, and that therefore they ought to prosecute the war against them with much greater animosity than against the Carthaginians. For with the latter the contest was carried on for empire and glory almost without any exasperated feeling, while they had to punish the former for perfidy, cruelty, and villany. That the time had now arrived when they should take vengeance for the horrid massacre of their fellow soldiers, and for the treachery which was prepared for themselves, had they been carried in their flight to the same place; and by the severity of the punishment inflicted in the present instance, establish it as a law for ever, that no one should consider a Roman citizen and soldier, whatever his situation, a fit object for injurious treatment." Animated by this exhortation of their general, they distributed the scaling-ladders to men selected from each of the companies; and the army being divided into two parts, so that Laelius, as lieutenant-general, might command one, they attacked the city in two places at once; thus creating an alarm in two quarters at the same time. It was not by the exhortations of one general, nor of the several nobles who were present, that the townsmen were stimulated to a vigorous defence of the city, but by the fear which they themselves entertained; they bore in mind, and admonished each other, that the object aimed at was punishment, and not victory. That the only question for them was, where they should meet death, whether in the battle and in the field, where the indiscriminate chance of war frequently raised up the vanquished and dashed the victor to the ground; or whether, after a short interval, when the city was burnt and plundered, after suffering every horror and indignity, they should expire amid stripes and bonds before the eyes of their captive wives and children. Therefore, not only those who were of an age to bear arms, or men only, but women and children, beyond the powers of their minds and bodies, were there, supplying with weapons those who were fighting in defence of the place, and carrying stones to the walls for those who were strengthening the works; for not only was their liberty at stake, which excites the energies of the brave only, but they had before their eyes the utmost extremity of punishment, to be inflicted on all indiscriminately, and an ignominious death. Their minds were worked up to the highest pitch, both by emulation in toil and danger, and also by the mere sight of each other. Accordingly the contest was entered upon with such ardour, that the army which had subdued the whole of Spain was frequently driven back from the walls of one town, and exhibited such a want of resolution in the contest as was not very honourable to it. When Scipio perceived this, he was afraid lest, by the failure of his attempts, the courage of the enemy should be raised and his own troops be dispirited; and thinking it incumbent upon him to exert himself in person and share the danger, reproved his soldiers for their cowardice, and ordered the scaling-ladders to be brought, threatening to mount the wall himself, since the rest hesitated. He had now advanced near the walls with no small danger, when a shout was raised from all sides by the soldiers, who were alarmed at the danger their general was exposed to, and the scaling-ladders began to be reared in several places at once. Laelius too, in another quarter, pressed on vigorously. It was then that the energy of the townsmen was subdued, and those who defended the walls being beaten off, the Romans took possession of them. The citadel also was captured during the confusion on a side where it was thought impregnable.

As Spain was unaffected by a Carthaginian war, it was clear that some of the states remained quiet more out of fear, stemming from guilt, than out of genuine loyalty. The most notable among them, both for their power and their wrongdoing, were Illiturgi and Castulo. Castulo had allied with the Romans during their prosperous times but had turned to the Carthaginians after the fall of the Scipios and their armies. The Illiturgians, by betraying and executing those who fled there after that disaster, added treachery to their rebellion. It would have been more just than practical to impose harsh penalties on these people right after his arrival, when the situation in Spain was unstable; but now, when everything was calm, as the time for punishing them seemed appropriate, he called Lucius Marcius from Tarraco and sent him with a third of his forces to attack Castulo, while he himself made his way to Illiturgi with the rest of the army, after about five days of marching. The gates were shut, and every measure was taken to defend against an assault; so thoroughly had their awareness of their wrongdoing produced the same result as a declaration of war against them. From this situation, Scipio began his speech to his soldiers: he stated that "by closing their gates, the Spaniards had themselves revealed their guilt through their fear, and therefore they should wage war against them with much greater intensity than against the Carthaginians. For with the latter, the conflict was over power and glory, almost without any deep-seated resentment, while they were to punish the former for betrayal, cruelty, and wickedness. The time had now come to avenge the horrific slaughter of their fellow soldiers, and for the treachery that awaited them had they been forced to flee to the same place; and by imposing rigorous punishment right now, establish it as a principle that no one should ever consider a Roman citizen and soldier, regardless of his circumstances, a suitable target for abuse." Inspired by their general's speech, they distributed the scaling ladders among selected men from each company; and the army was divided into two parts so that Laelius, serving as lieutenant-general, could lead one while they attacked the city from two different points simultaneously, creating panic in both areas at once. It was not just the encouragement of one general, nor the various nobles present, that energized the townspeople to defend their city vigorously, but the fear they themselves felt; they remembered and reminded each other that their aim was punishment, not victory. The only question for them was where they would meet their end, whether on the battlefield, where the random chance of war often lifted the defeated and sent the victor crashing to the ground; or whether, after a brief moment, once the city was burned and looted, they would suffer every horror and humiliation, and then die in chains before the eyes of their captive wives and children. Thus, not only those old enough to bear arms, but also women and children, beyond their physical and mental capacities, were there, providing weapons to those fighting to defend the place and carrying stones to the walls for those reinforcing them; for it was not just their freedom that was at stake, which only inspires the brave, but they clearly faced the possibility of extreme punishment to be inflicted on all indiscriminately, and a disgraceful death. Their spirits were heightened by both the competition in effort and danger, as well as the sight of one another. Accordingly, the battle began with such enthusiasm that the army which had conquered all of Spain was often pushed back from the walls of one town, showing a lack of resolve in the fight that was quite dishonorable. When Scipio saw this, he feared that a failure in his efforts would embolden the enemy and demoralize his own troops; feeling it necessary to lead by example and share the risk, he scolded his soldiers for their cowardice and ordered the scaling ladders to be brought, threatening to climb the wall himself since the rest hesitated. He had now moved close to the walls amidst considerable danger, when a cheer arose from all sides as the soldiers, worried about the risk their general faced, began raising the scaling ladders in several locations at once. Laelius, in another area, also pressed forward with determination. It was then that the resolve of the townspeople weakened, and those defending the walls were pushed back, allowing the Romans to seize control. The citadel was also taken during the chaos on a side believed to be impenetrable.

20

Some African deserters, who were at that time among the Roman auxiliaries, while the townsmen were occupied in defending those quarters whence danger was apprehended, and the Romans were making approaches where they could gain access, observed that the most elevated part of the town, which was protected by a very high rock, was neither fortified by any work nor furnished with defenders. Being men of light make and nimble from being well exercised, they climbed up wherever they could gain access over the irregular projections of the rock, carrying with them iron spikes. If in any part they met with a cliff too steep and smooth, they fixed spikes at moderate intervals, and having thus formed a sort of steps, and those who were foremost pulling up those who followed, and those who were behind lifting up those before them, they succeeded in gaining the summit, whence they ran down with a shout into the city, which had already been taken by the Romans. Then it became manifest indeed that it was resentment and hatred which prompted the assault upon the city. No one thought of taking any alive, nor of booty, though every thing lay exposed to plunder. They butchered all indiscriminately, armed and unarmed, male and female. Their cruel resentment extended to the slaughter of infants. They then set fire to the houses, and pulled down those which could not be consumed by fire, so bent were they upon erasing even every vestige of the city, and blotting out the memory of their enemies. Scipio marched his army thence to Castulo, which was defended, not only by Spaniards who had assembled there, but also by the remains of the Carthaginian army, which had gone there from the various places to which they had been dispersed in their flight. But the news of the calamity of the Illiturgians had reached them before the arrival of Scipio; and in consequence of this, dismay and desperation had seized them; and as their cases were differently circumstanced, and each party was desirous of consulting its own safety independent of the other, at first secret jealousy, and then an open rupture, created a separation between the Carthaginians and Spaniards. Cerdubellus without disguise advised the latter to surrender. Himilco commanded the Carthaginian auxiliaries, which, together with the city, Cerdubellus delivered up to the Romans, having secretly obtained terms. This victory was attended with less cruelty; for not only was the guilt of this people less than the others, but their voluntary surrender had considerably mitigated resentment.

Some African deserters, who were at that time part of the Roman auxiliaries, noticed that while the townspeople were busy defending the areas they thought were at risk and the Romans were trying to approach where they could, the highest part of the town, backed by a very tall rock, was neither fortified nor had any defenders. Being agile and well-trained, they climbed up wherever they could find a way over the uneven edges of the rock, bringing iron spikes with them. If they encountered a section that was too steep and smooth, they set spikes at regular intervals to create makeshift steps, with those in front pulling up those behind, and those at the back lifting up the ones in front. They managed to reach the top, from where they rushed down into the city, which had already been taken by the Romans. It quickly became clear that it was resentment and hatred that motivated the attack on the city. No one thought of taking anyone alive or looting, even though everything was open for the taking. They killed everyone indiscriminately—armed and unarmed, male and female. Their brutal anger even extended to infants. They then set the houses on fire and tore down those that couldn’t be burned, determined to erase any trace of the city and wipe out the memory of their enemies. Scipio then marched his army to Castulo, which was defended not just by the Spaniards who had gathered there, but also by remnants of the Carthaginian army that had come together from various locations after their flight. However, the news of the disaster at Illiturgi had reached them before Scipio arrived, and as a result, fear and despair took hold. Since their situations were different and each group wanted to ensure its own safety without relying on the other, initial jealousy turned into an open conflict that caused a rift between the Carthaginians and the Spaniards. Cerdubellus openly advised the latter to surrender. Himilco commanded the Carthaginian auxiliaries, which, along with the city, Cerdubellus surrendered to the Romans after secretly negotiating terms. This victory was marked by less cruelty because the guilt of this people was less than that of the others, and their voluntary surrender greatly eased the anger.

21

Marcius was then sent against the barbarians, to reduce under the authority and dominion of the Romans such of them as had not yet been subdued. Scipio returned to Carthage, to pay his vows to the gods, and to exhibit a gladiatorial show, which he had prepared on account of the death of his father and uncle. This exhibition of gladiators was not formed from that description of men which the lanistae are accustomed to procure, such as slaves, or those who sell their blood. All the service of the combatants was voluntary and gratuitous; for some were sent by the petty princes, to show an example of the natural courage of their people; others came forward to fight, in compliment to their general; others were induced to give and accept challenges, by a spirit of emulation and a desire of victory. Some decided by the sword disputes which they either could not or were unwilling to determine by argument, with an agreement that the matter in question should be given up to the victor. Nor was it confined to men of obscure rank, but comprehended persons of distinction and celebrity; such were Corbis and Orsua, cousins-german, who, having a dispute about the sovereignty of a city called Ibis, declared that they would contest it with the sword. Corbis was the elder of the two. The father of Orsua was the last sovereign, having succeeded to that dignity on the death of his elder brother. When Scipio was desirous of settling the dispute by argument and allaying their irritation, they both declared that they had refused that to their mutual kinsmen, and that they would appeal to no other judge, whether god or man, than Mars. The elder presuming upon his strength, the younger on the prime of youth, each wished to die in the combat rather than become the subject of the other; and every effort failing to prevent their prosecuting their mad design, they exhibited to the army a most interesting spectacle, and a proof how great mischief is occasioned among men by a thirst for power. The elder, in consequence of his experience in arms and his address, easily mastered the unscientific efforts of the younger. To this show of gladiators were added funeral games, proportioned to the means possessed, and with such magnificence as the provinces and the camp afforded.

Marcius was then sent to deal with the barbarians, to bring under Roman control those who had not yet been conquered. Scipio returned to Carthage to pay his respects to the gods and to host a gladiatorial event he had organized in honor of his father and uncle’s deaths. This gladiatorial exhibition wasn’t made up of the usual fighters that trainers typically acquire, like slaves or those who fight for money. All the fighters volunteered their participation; some were sent by local leaders to showcase the bravery of their people, others stepped up to fight as a gesture of respect for their general, and some accepted challenges out of a spirit of competition and a desire for victory. Some settled disputes with swords that they could not or would not solve through discussion, agreeing that the winner would take whatever was in question. It wasn’t just common folks participating; notable individuals were also included, like Corbis and Orsua, cousins who had a disagreement over the rule of a city called Ibis and decided to settle it with a duel. Corbis was the older cousin. Orsua's father had been the previous ruler, taking the throne after the death of his older brother. When Scipio wanted to resolve their conflict through debate and quell their anger, they both insisted that they had refused that option to their family members and would appeal to no other authority, whether divine or human, than Mars. The elder cousin relied on his strength, while the younger relied on his youth, each preferring to die in battle rather than be dominated by the other. With every attempt to stop their reckless decision failing, they presented a fascinating spectacle to the army, demonstrating the tremendous harm that ambition can cause among people. The elder, with his combat experience and skill, easily overcame the younger's untrained efforts. The gladiatorial show also included funeral games, scaled to the available resources, featuring the grandeur that the provinces and the camp could provide.

22

Meanwhile the operations of the war were carried on with unabated activity by the lieutenant-generals. Marcius, crossing the river Baetis, which the natives call Certis, received the submission of two powerful cities without a contest. There was a city called Astapa, which had always sided with the Carthaginians; nor was it that which drew upon it the resentment of the Romans so much as the fact, that its inhabitants harboured an extraordinary animosity against them, which was not called for by the necessities of the war. Their city was not so secured by nature or art as to make their dispositions so fierce, but the natural disposition of the inhabitants, which took delight in plunder, had induced them to make excursions into the neighbouring lands belonging to the allies of the Romans, and to intercept such Roman soldiers, suttlers, and merchants as they found ranging about. They had also surrounded, by means of an ambuscade, and put to the sword on disadvantageous ground, a large company which was crossing their borders, for it had proved hardly safe to go in small parties. When the troops were marched up to assault this city, the inhabitants, conscious of their guilt, and seeing that it would be dangerous to surrender to an enemy so highly incensed, and that they could not hope to keep themselves in safety by means of their walls or their arms, resolved to execute upon themselves and those belonging to them a horrid and inhuman deed. They fixed upon a place in their forum, in which they collected the most valuable of their property, and having directed their wives and children to seat themselves upon this heap, they raised a pile of wood around it and threw on it bundles of twigs. They then ordered fifty armed youths to stand there and guard their fortunes, and the persons dearer to them than their fortunes, as long as the issue of the battle continued doubtful. If they should perceive that the battle went against them, and that it came to the point that the city must be captured, they might be assured that those whom they saw going out to engage the enemy would perish in the battle itself; but implored them by all the gods, celestial and infernal, that, mindful of their liberty, which must be terminated on that day either by an honourable death or ignominious servitude, they would leave nothing on which an exasperated enemy could wreak his fury; that they had fire and sword at their command, and it was better that friendly and faithful hands should destroy what must necessarily perish, than that enemies should insult it with haughty wantonness. To these exhortations a dreadful execration was added against any one who should be diverted from this purpose by hope or faint-heartedness. Then throwing open the gates, they rushed out at a rapid pace and with the utmost impetuosity. Nor was there any guard sufficiently strong opposed to them; for there could be nothing that was less apprehended than that they would have the courage to sally from their walls. A very few troops of horse, and the light-armed, hastily sent out of the camp for that purpose, opposed them. The battle was furious and spirited, rather than steady and regular in any degree. The horse, therefore, which had first encountered the enemy, being repulsed, created an alarm among the light-armed; and the battle would have been fought under the very rampart, had not the legions, which were their main strength, drawn out their line, though they had a very short time to form in. These too, for a short time, wavered around their standards, when the Astapans, blind with rage, rushed upon wounds and the sword with reckless daring; but afterwards the veteran soldiers, standing firm against their furious assaults, checked the violence of those that followed by the slaughter of the foremost. Soon after, the veteran troops themselves made an attempt to charge them, but seeing that not a man gave ground, and that they were inflexibly determined on dying each in his place, they extended their line, which the number of their troops enabled them to do with ease, and, surrounding their flanks, slew them all to a man while fighting in a circle.

Meanwhile, the war was being actively managed by the lieutenant-generals. Marcius, after crossing the Baetis River, which the locals call Certis, received the surrender of two powerful cities without a fight. One of these cities was Astapa, which had always sided with the Carthaginians. It wasn't just their alliance that drew the Romans' anger; it was the intense hatred the inhabitants had towards them, which wasn't warranted by the needs of the war. Their city wasn't particularly secure by nature or design, but the residents had a natural inclination towards plunder, prompting them to raid neighboring lands belonging to Roman allies and intercept any Roman soldiers, merchants, or suppliers they encountered. They also laid an ambush for and massacred a large group that was crossing their territory, finding it too risky to travel in smaller groups. When the troops approached to attack the city, the inhabitants, aware of their wrongdoing and realizing it would be dangerous to surrender to such an enraged enemy, and knowing they couldn't rely on their walls or weapons for safety, decided to carry out a horrific and inhumane act against themselves and their loved ones. They chose a spot in their forum, gathered their most valuable possessions, and instructed their wives and children to sit upon them. They then built a wooden pyre around this collection and placed bundles of twigs on top. They ordered fifty armed young men to stand guard over their property and loved ones as long as the outcome of the battle remained uncertain. If they saw that the battle was going poorly and the city would be captured, they could be sure that those heading out to fight would die in battle. They implored the gods, both heavenly and infernal, to remember their freedom, which could only end that day in either an honorable death or disgraceful captivity, and to leave nothing for a furious enemy to destroy; they had fire and sword at their disposal, and it was better for loyal hands to destroy what would inevitably be lost than to let the enemy enjoy it with arrogance. They also cursed anyone who would waver from this plan out of hope or cowardice. Then, throwing open the gates, they charged out quickly and with great force. No guard was strong enough to stop them; it was least expected that they would have the courage to break out from their walls. Only a few cavalry and light infantry, hastily sent from the camp, tried to stop them. The battle was intense and spirited, but not very steady or organized. The cavalry, first to face the enemy, were pushed back, causing alarm among the light infantry. The fight would have taken place right by the ramparts if the legions, their main strength, hadn't formed their lines, even with little time to do so. These soldiers hesitated briefly around their standards when the Astapans, blinded by rage, charged recklessly at wounds and swords. However, the veteran soldiers stood firm against their furious assaults, slowing down the attackers by killing the first wave. Soon after, the veteran troops attempted to charge, but seeing that no one was retreating and that every enemy was resolutely determined to die in place, they expanded their lines, which their numbers allowed, surrounding the Astapans and killing them all as they fought in a circle.

24

But these, however, were acts committed by exasperated enemies in the heat of battle, and executed, in conformity with the laws of war, upon men armed and most fiercely resisting; there was another more horrible carnage in the city, where a harmless and defenceless crowd of women and children were butchered by their own countrymen, who threw their bodies, most of them still alive, upon the burning pile while streams of blood damped the rising flame; and lastly, wearied with the piteous slaughter of their friends, they threw themselves, arms and all, into the midst of the flames. When the carnage was now completed the victorious Romans came up, and at the first sight of so revolting a transaction they stood for some time wrapt in wonder and amazement; but afterwards, from a rapacity natural to humanity, wishing to snatch out of the fire the gold and silver which glittered amid the heap of other materials, some were caught by the flames, others scorched by the hot blasts, as the foremost were unable to retreat, in consequence of the immense crowd which pressed upon them. In this manner was Astapa destroyed by the sword and fire, without affording any booty to the soldiers. After the rest of the people in that quarter, influenced by fear, had made submission to him, Marcius led his victorious troops to Scipio, at Carthage. Just at this same time deserters arrived from Gades, who promised to betray the town and Carthaginian garrison which occupied it, together with the commander and the fleet. Mago had halted there after his flight, and having collected some ships on the ocean, had got together a considerable number of auxiliaries from the coast of Africa, on the other side the strait, and also by means of Hanno the prefect from the neighbouring parts of Spain. After pledges had been exchanged with the deserters, Marcius and Laelius were sent thither, the former with the light cohorts, the latter with seven triremes and one quinquereme, in order that they might act in concert by land and sea.

But these were actions taken by frustrated enemies in the heat of battle, carried out according to the laws of war against armed men who were fiercely resisting; there was a more horrific slaughter in the city, where a defenseless crowd of women and children were killed by their own countrymen, who tossed their bodies, many still alive, onto the burning pile while streams of blood fed the rising flames; and finally, worn out by the tragic killing of their friends, they threw themselves, arms and all, into the flames. Once the massacre was over, the victorious Romans approached, and at the first sight of such a repulsive scene, they stood in stunned silence for some time; but later, driven by a greed natural to humanity, wanting to snatch the gold and silver that shimmered among the heap of other materials from the fire, some were caught by the flames, others scorched by the heat, as the front line was unable to retreat due to the massive crowd pushing behind them. This was how Astapa was destroyed by sword and fire, without providing any loot to the soldiers. After the remaining people in that area, gripped by fear, surrendered to him, Marcius led his victorious troops to Scipio at Carthage. At that same time, deserters arrived from Gades, promising to betray the town and the Carthaginian garrison there, along with the commander and the fleet. Mago had paused there after his escape, collecting some ships at sea, and had gathered a significant number of reinforcements from the African coast, across the strait, and also with the help of Hanno the prefect from nearby Spain. After exchanging pledges with the deserters, Marcius and Laelius were sent there, the former with the light cohorts and the latter with seven triremes and one quinquereme, so they could coordinate their efforts by land and sea.

24

In consequence of Scipio's being afflicted with a severe fit of illness, which rumour represented as more serious than it really was; for every one made some addition to the account he had received, from a desire inherent in mankind of intentionally exaggerating reports, the whole province, and more especially the distant parts of it, were thrown into a state of ferment; and it was evident what a serious disturbance would have been excited had he really died, when an unfounded report created such violent commotions. Neither the allies kept their allegiance, nor the army their duty. Mandonius and Indibilis, who were not at all satisfied with what had occurred, for they had anticipated with certainty that they would have the dominion of Spain on the expulsion of the Carthaginians, called together their countrymen the Lacetani, and summoning the Celtiberian youth to arms, devastated in a hostile manner the territories of the Suessetanians and Sedetanians, allies of the Romans. Besides, a mutiny arose in the camp at Sucro. Here were eight thousand men, stationed as a guard over the nations dwelling on this side the Iberus. It was not on hearing uncertain rumours respecting the life of the general that their minds were first excited, but previously, owing to the licentiousness which naturally results from long-continued idleness, and in some degree also owing to the restraint felt in time of peace by men who had been accustomed to live freely on what they gained by plunder in an enemy's country. At first they only discoursed in private, asking what they were doing among people who were at peace with them, if there was a war in the province? if the war was terminated and the province completely subdued, why were they not conveyed back into Italy? The pay also was demanded with more insolence than was customary or consistent with military subordination, and the guards cast reproaches upon the tribunes while going round to the watches. Some too had gone out by night into the neighbouring lands, belonging to persons at peace with the Romans, to plunder; but at last they quitted their standards in the day-time and openly without furloughs. Every thing was done according to the caprice and unrestrained will of the soldiers, and nothing according to rule and military discipline, or the orders of those who were in command. The form, however, of a Roman camp was preserved solely in consequence of the hopes they entertained that the tribunes, catching the spirit of insubordination, would not be averse from taking part in the mutiny and defection, on which account they suffered them to dispense justice in their courts, went to them for the watch-word, and served in their turn on the outposts and watches; and as they had taken away the power of command, so they preserved the appearance of obedience to orders, by spontaneously executing their own. Afterwards, when they perceived that the tribunes censured and reprobated their proceedings, endeavoured to counteract them, and publicly declared that they would not take any share in their disorderly conduct, the mutiny assumed a decided character; when, after driving the tribunes from their courts, and shortly after from the camp, the command was conferred by universal consent upon Caius Albius of Cales and Caius Atrius of Umbria, common soldiers, who were the prime movers of the sedition. These men were so far from being satisfied with the ornaments used by tribunes, that they had the audacity to lay hold even of the insignia of the highest authority, the fasces and axes, without ever reflecting that their own backs and necks were in danger from those very rods and axes which they carried before them to intimidate others. Their mistaken belief of the death of Scipio had blinded their minds, and they doubted not that, in a short time, when that event should be made generally known, all Spain would blaze with war; that during this confusion money might be exacted from the allies and the neighbouring cities plundered; and that in this unsettled state of affairs, when there was nothing which any man would not dare, their own acts would be less conspicuous.

Due to Scipio being hit with a serious illness, which rumors exaggerated to be worse than it actually was—since everyone adds their own spin to reports out of a natural tendency to inflate stories—the entire province, especially the more remote areas, was thrown into chaos. It was clear that if he had actually died, it would have caused serious unrest, considering how much turmoil was stirred up by this unfounded rumor. The allies didn't stay loyal, and the army was not dutiful. Mandonius and Indibilis, unhappy with the situation because they had expected to gain control of Spain after driving out the Carthaginians, gathered their fellow tribesmen from the Lacetani and called on the Celtiberian youth to arms, launching attacks on the lands of the Suessetanians and Sedetanians, who were Roman allies. Additionally, a mutiny broke out in the camp at Sucro, where eight thousand men were stationed to guard the nations living on this side of the Iberus. It wasn't just the uncertain rumors about the general's health that stirred their minds; it was also the restlessness that comes from prolonged idleness and the frustration of peace, especially for those used to the freedom of living off plunder from enemy territory. Initially, they only whispered among themselves, questioning why they were stationed in a peaceful territory when there was supposed to be a war in the province. If the war was over and the province was totally subdued, why weren't they sent back to Italy? They began to demand their pay more aggressively than was typical for military discipline, even insulting the tribunes while on watch. Some ventured out at night into nearby lands belonging to people at peace with Rome to steal, and eventually, they abandoned their standards in broad daylight without any leave. Everything was done according to the whims of the soldiers rather than military rules or commands from their leaders. However, they maintained the appearance of a Roman camp in hopes that the tribunes, sensing the rebellion, would not mind joining in. They let the tribunes handle justice, sought their passwords, and took turns on watch; even though they had taken away actual command, they pretended to obey orders by acting on their own. Once it became clear that the tribunes condemned their actions and tried to intervene, the mutiny took a definitive turn. After driving the tribunes out of their courts and then from the camp, they unanimously granted command to Caius Albius of Cales and Caius Atrius of Umbria, two common soldiers who were the ringleaders of the unrest. These men were so far from being satisfied with the symbols of the tribunes' authority that they had the nerve to seize the emblems of the highest power, the fasces and axes, without considering that their own safety was at risk from the very rods and axes they carried to intimidate others. Their mistaken belief in Scipio’s death blinded them, and they were sure that soon, when this news spread, all of Spain would erupt in war; that in the chaos, they could extort money from the allies and plunder nearby cities, and that in such an unstable situation, their actions would go unnoticed.

25

As they expected that other fresh accounts would follow those which they had received, not only of the death, but even of the burial, of Scipio, and yet none arrived; and as the rumour which had been so idly originated began to die away, the first author of it began to be sought out; and each backing out in order that he might appear rather to have inconsiderately credited than to have fabricated such a report, the leaders were forsaken, and began now to dread their own ensigns of authority, and to apprehend that, instead of that empty show of command which they wore, a legitimate and rightful power would be turned against them. The mutiny being thus paralysed, and credible persons bringing in accounts, first, that Scipio was alive, and, soon after, that he was even in good health, seven military tribunes were sent by Scipio himself. At the first arrival of these their minds were violently excited; but they were soon calmed by the mild and soothing language which they addressed to such of their acquaintance as they met with; for, going round first of all to the tents, and then entering the principia and the praetorium, wherever they observed circles of men conversing together, they addressed them, inquiring rather what it was that had occasioned their displeasure and sudden consternation, than taxing them with what had occurred. "That they had not received their pay at the appointed time," was generally complained; and "that although at the time of the horrid transaction of the Illiturgians, and after the destruction of two generals and two armies, the Roman cause had been defended and the province retained by their valour; the Illiturgians had received the punishment due to their offence, but there was no one found to reward them for their meritorious services." The tribunes replied, "that, considering the nature of their complaints, what they requested was just, and that they would lay it before the general; that they were happy that there was nothing of a more gloomy and irremediable character; that both Publius Scipio, by the favour of the gods, and the commonwealth, were in a situation to requite them." Scipio, who was accustomed to war but inexperienced in the storms of sedition, felt great anxiety on the occasion, lest the army should run into excess in transgressing, or himself in punishing. For the present he resolved to persist in the lenient line of conduct with which he had begun, and sending collectors round to the tributary states, to give the soldiers hopes of soon receiving their pay. Immediately after this a proclamation was issued that they should come to Carthage to receive their pay, whether they wished to do so in detached parties or all in a body. The sudden suppression of the rebellion among the Spaniards had the effect of tranquillizing the mutiny, which was by this time beginning to subside of itself; for Mandonius and Indibilis, relinquishing their attempt, had returned within their borders when intelligence was brought that Scipio was alive; nor did there now remain any person, whether countryman or foreigner, whom they could make their companion in their desperate enterprise. On examining every method, they had no alternative except that which afforded a retreat from wicked designs, which was not of the safest kind, namely, to commit themselves either to the just anger of the general, or to his clemency, of which they need not despair. For he had pardoned even enemies whom he had encountered with the sword; while they reflected that their sedition had been unaccompanied with wounds or blood, and was neither in itself of an atrocious character nor merited severe punishment. So natural is it for men to be over-eloquent in extenuating their own demerit. They felt doubtful whether they should go to demand their pay in single cohorts or in one entire body; but the opinion that they should go in a body, which they regarded as the safer mode, prevailed.

As they anticipated that more fresh news would come in, not only about Scipio's death but also about his burial, and yet none arrived, the initial rumor began to fade away. The person who started it became a target for blame, and everyone tried to distance themselves, wanting to seem like they had carelessly believed the story rather than made it up. The leaders felt abandoned and started to fear their own symbols of authority, worrying that what they thought was a hollow command could turn into a legitimate power against them. With the mutiny in a state of paralysis and reliable sources reporting first that Scipio was alive and soon after that he was in good health, seven military tribunes were sent by Scipio himself. When they first arrived, the soldiers were immediately agitated, but they soon calmed down due to the gentle and reassuring words of the tribunes. The tribunes visited the tents and then entered the main headquarters, approaching groups of men talking and instead of accusing them of anything, they asked what had caused their anger and shock. The soldiers generally complained that they hadn’t been paid on time and that, although their courage had defended the Roman cause during the horrific incident with the Illiturgians and after the loss of two generals and two armies, while the Illiturgians received punishment for their wrongdoing, no one had rewarded them for their bravery. The tribunes replied that given the nature of their complaints, what they were asking for was fair, and they would bring it to the general’s attention. They expressed relief that the situation wasn’t more dire and assured the soldiers that both Publius Scipio, with the gods’ favor, and the state were ready to reward them. Scipio, familiar with war but inexperienced with rebellions, felt very anxious, fearing the army might go too far in their actions or he himself might be too harsh in punishment. For the moment, he decided to stick with the gentle approach he had begun and sent out collectors to the tributary states to give the soldiers hope of soon receiving their pay. Shortly after, an announcement was made for them to come to Carthage to collect their pay, whether in small groups or all at once. The quick resolution of the rebellion among the Spaniards helped calm the mutiny, which was starting to settle on its own; Mandonius and Indibilis had given up their efforts and returned home when they heard that Scipio was alive. Now, there was no one left, whether native or foreign, for them to partner with in their desperate actions. After weighing their options, they realized their only choice was either to face the rightful anger of the general or to hope for his mercy, which they believed was possible since he had forgiven even those he had fought against. They figured that since their rebellion hadn’t involved violence or bloodshed and wasn’t particularly serious, they wouldn’t face harsh punishment. It’s so common for people to over-explain their own faults. They were unsure if they should approach to demand their pay in smaller groups or all together, but the idea of going as one group, which they saw as safer, won out.

26

At the same time, when they were employed in these deliberations, a council was held on their case at Carthage; when a warm debate took place as to whether they should visit with punishment the originators only of the mutiny, who were in number not more than thirty-five, or, whether atonement should be made for this defection, (for such it was rather than a mutiny,) of so dreadful a character as a precedent, by the punishment of a greater number. The opinion recommending the more lenient course, that the punishment should fall where the guilt originated, was adopted. For the multitude a reprimand was considered sufficient. On the breaking up of the council, orders were given to the army, which was in Carthage, to prepare for an expedition against Mandonius and Indibilis, and to get ready provisions for several days, in order that they might appear to have been deliberating about this. The seven tribunes who had before gone to Sucro to quell the mutiny, having been sent out to meet the army, gave in, each of them, five names of persons principally concerned in the affair, in order that proper persons might be employed to invite them to their homes, with smiles and kind words; and that, when overpowered with wine, they might be thrown into chains. They were not far distant from Carthage when the intelligence, received from persons on the road, that the whole army was going the following day with Marcus Silanus against the Lacetanians, not only freed them from all the apprehensions which, though they did not give utterance to them, sat heavy upon their minds, but occasioned the greatest transport, because they would thus have the general alone, and in their power, instead of being themselves in his. They entered the city just at sun-set, and saw the other army making every preparation for a march. Immediately on their arrival they were greeted in terms feigned for the purpose, that their arrival was looked upon by the general as a happy and seasonable circumstance, for they had come when the other army was just on the point of setting out. After which they proceeded to refresh themselves. The authors of the mutiny, having been conveyed to their lodgings by proper persons, were apprehended by the tribunes without any disturbance, and thrown into chains. At the fourth watch the baggage belonging to the army, which, as it was pretended, was about to march, began to set out. As soon as it was light the troops marched, but were stopped at the gate, and guards were sent round to all the gates to prevent any one going out of the city. Then those who had arrived the day before, having been summoned to an assembly, ran in crowds into the forum to the tribunal of the general, with the presumptuous purpose of intimidating him by their shouts. At the same time that the general mounted the tribunal, the armed troops, which had been brought back from the gates, spread themselves around the rear of the unarmed assembly. Then all their insolence subsided; and, as they afterwards confessed, nothing terrified them so much as the unexpected vigour and hue of the general, whom they had supposed they should see in a sickly state, and his countenance, which was such as they declared that they did not remember to have ever seen it even in battle. He sat silent for a short time till he was informed that the instigators of the mutiny were brought into the forum, and that every thing was now in readiness.

At the same time that they were engaged in these discussions, a council was convened in Carthage to address their situation. A heated debate occurred over whether to punish only the instigators of the mutiny, who numbered no more than thirty-five, or to impose a greater punishment as a way of atoning for this defection, which was really more of a rebellion, given its alarming implications as a precedent. The opinion that favored a more lenient approach, suggesting that punishment should only fall on those who were guilty, was accepted. A reprimand was deemed sufficient for the larger group. After the council adjourned, orders were issued to the army stationed in Carthage to prepare for an expedition against Mandonius and Indibilis, and to stock up on provisions for several days so it would seem like they had been contemplating this. The seven tribunes, who had previously gone to Sucro to address the mutiny, were sent to meet the army and each provided the names of five individuals closely involved in the incident, so that suitable people could be tasked with inviting them to their homes with smiles and friendly words. Once they were intoxicated, these individuals were to be captured and put in chains. They were not far from Carthage when they received news from travelers that the entire army was set to march the following day with Marcus Silanus against the Lacetanians. This news not only relieved them of the unspoken worries weighing on their minds but also filled them with great excitement, as they would have the general on his own, rather than being under his control. They entered the city just as the sun was setting and saw the other army getting ready for the march. Upon their arrival, they were welcomed with pretended enthusiasm, making it seem that the general considered their presence timely, especially since they had arrived just as the other army was about to leave. Afterward, they took time to refresh themselves. The leaders of the mutiny, escorted to their lodgings by the right people, were quietly apprehended by the tribunes and thrown into chains. During the fourth watch, the army's baggage, which was supposedly about to march, began to move out. As soon as day broke, the troops began their march but were halted at the gate, with guards dispatched to all exits to prevent anyone from leaving the city. Then, those who had arrived the day before were called to a gathering and rushed into the forum to confront the general with loud shouts aimed at intimidating him. When the general ascended the platform, armed troops that had been brought back from the gates formed a perimeter around the unarmed crowd. At that point, all their bravado vanished; they later admitted that they were most terrified by the unexpected strength and appearance of the general, whom they expected to be weak, and by his commanding presence, which they claimed they had never seen even during battles. He remained silent for a moment until he learned that the instigators of the mutiny had been brought into the forum and that everything was ready.

27

Then, a herald having obtained silence, he thus began: "I imagined that language would never fail me in which to address my army; not that I have ever accustomed myself to speaking rather than action, but because, having been kept in a camp almost from my boyhood, I had become familiar with the dispositions of soldiers. But I am at a loss both for sentiments and expressions with which to address you, whom I know not even by what name I ought to call. Can I call you countrymen, who have revolted from your country? or soldiers, who have rejected the command and authority of your general, and violated the solemn obligation of your oath? Can I call you enemies? I recognise the persons, faces, dress, and mien of fellow countrymen; but I perceive the actions, expressions, intentions, and feelings of enemies. For what have you wished and hoped for, but what the Ilergetians and Lacetanians did. Yet they followed Mandonius and Indibilis, men of royal rank, who were the leaders of their mad project; you conferred the auspices and command upon the Umbrian, Atrius, and the Calenian, Albius. Deny, soldiers, that you were all concerned in this measure, or that you approved of it when taken. I shall willingly believe, when you disclaim it, that it was the folly and madness of a few. For the acts which have been committed are of such a nature, that, if the whole army participated in them, they could not be expiated without atonements of tremendous magnitude. Upon these points, like wounds, I touch with reluctance; but unless touched and handled, they cannot be cured. For my own part, I believed that, after the Carthaginians were expelled from Spain, there was not a place in the whole province where, or any persons to whom, my life was obnoxious; such was the manner in which I had conducted myself, not only towards my allies, but even towards my enemies. But lo, even in my own camp, so much was I deceived in my opinion, the report of my death was not only readily believed, but anxiously waited for. Not that I wish to implicate you all in this enormity; for, be assured, if I supposed that the whole of my army desired my death, I would here immediately expire before your eyes; nor could I take any pleasure in a life which was odious to my countrymen and my soldiers. But every multitude is in its nature like the ocean; which, though in itself incapable of motion, is excited by storms and winds. So, also, in yourselves there is calm and there are storms; but the cause and origin of your fury is entirely attributable to those who led you on; you have caught your madness by contagion. Nay, even this day you do not appear to me to be aware to what a pitch of phrensy you have proceeded; what a heinous crime you have dared to commit against myself, your country, your parents, your children; against the gods, the witnesses of your oath; against the auspices under which you serve; against the laws of war, the discipline of your ancestors, and the majesty of the highest authority. With regard to myself, I say nothing. You may have believed the report of my death rather inconsiderately than eagerly. Lastly, suppose me to be such a man that it could not at all be a matter of astonishment that my army should be weary of my command, yet what had your country deserved of you, which you betrayed by making common cause with Mandonius and Indibilis? What the Roman people, when, taking the command from the tribunes appointed by their suffrages, you conferred it on private men? When, not content even with having them for tribunes, you, a Roman army, conferred the fasces of your general upon men who never had a slave under their command? Albius and Atrius had their tents in your general's pavilion. With them the trumpet sounded, from them the word was taken, they sat upon the tribunal of Scipio, upon whom the lictor attended, for them the crowd was cleared away as they moved along, before them the fasces with the axes were carried. When showers of stones descend, lightnings are darted from the heavens, and animals give birth to monsters, you consider these things as prodigies. This is a prodigy which can be expiated by no victims, by no supplications, without the blood of those men who have dared to commit so great a crime.

Then a herald, managing to quiet the crowd, began: "I thought I would have no trouble finding the right words to speak to my army. It's not that I've ever been someone who prefers to talk instead of act, but because I've been living in a camp since I was a kid, I've come to understand soldiers well. But now, I struggle to find the right feelings and words to address you, since I don't even know what to call you. Can I call you countrymen when you've turned against your homeland? Or soldiers, who have rejected the authority of your general and broken the promise you swore? Can I label you as enemies? I recognize your faces, your clothing, and your demeanor as those of fellow countrymen; yet I see actions, expressions, intentions, and feelings that belong to enemies. What have you wished for and hoped for except what the Ilergetians and Lacetanians sought? They followed leaders like Mandonius and Indibilis, men of noble birth, who led their reckless venture; you placed your hopes and command in the hands of the Umbrian, Atrius, and the Calenian, Albius. Deny it, soldiers, if you claim that you were not all involved in this plan, or that you didn’t support it. I’ll gladly believe you when you say it was the foolishness and madness of a few. The actions that have happened are so serious that if the whole army was involved, they could not be atoned for without immense sacrifices. I touch on these issues, like wounds, with reluctance; but unless addressed, they cannot heal. Personally, I thought that after the Carthaginians were driven from Spain, there was nowhere in this province where my life was at risk; I had treated not only my allies but even my enemies with care. But here I am, in my own camp, so misled was I that the news of my death was not only believed but eagerly anticipated. I don’t wish to accuse all of you of this wrongdoing; know this: if I thought my entire army desired my death, I would fall down dead before you now; I could not take joy in a life that was hated by my countrymen and soldiers. But every crowd behaves like the ocean, which, while inherently still, can be stirred by storms and winds. Within you all, there exists both calm and fury; but the root of your anger lies solely with those who led you astray; you've caught this madness like a contagion. In fact, even today, it seems you don’t realize how far gone you are in your frenzy; what a terrible crime you have committed against me, your homeland, your parents, your children; against the gods, who witnessed your oath; against the auspices under which you serve; against the laws of warfare, the discipline of your forebearers, and the authority at the highest level. As for me, I’ll say nothing more. You may have believed the rumors of my death more thoughtlessly than eagerly. Lastly, let’s say I’m someone who could honestly understand why my army might grow tired of my command—yet, what did your country ever do to you that you betrayed it by siding with Mandonius and Indibilis? What did the Roman people do when you took command from the tribunes chosen by your vote and handed it to mere private citizens? When you couldn’t even be satisfied with them as tribunes, you—a Roman army—gave the fasces of your general to men who had never commanded even one slave? Albius and Atrius made their camp within your general's pavilion. With them, the trumpet sounded, from them orders were given, they took their seats on Scipio's tribunal, where the lictor stood ready, the crowd parted for them as they walked, and before them, the fasces with axes were carried. When hailstones rain down, lightning strikes the earth, or animals give birth to monsters, you see those things as omens. But this is an omen that cannot be cleansed by any offering, no prayers can atone for it without the blood of those who dared to commit such a great offense."

28

"Now, though villany is never guided by reason, yet so far as it could exist in so nefarious a transaction, I would fain know what was your design. Formerly, a legion which was sent to garrison Rhegium, wickedly put to the sword the principal inhabitants and kept possession of that opulent city through a space of ten years; on account of which enormity the entire legion, consisting of four thousand men, were beheaded in the forum at Rome. But they, in the first place, did not put themselves under the direction of Atrius the Umbrian, scarcely superior to a scullion, whose name even was ominous, but of Decius Jubellius, a military tribune; nor did they unite themselves with Pyrrhus, or with the Samnites or Lucanians, the enemies of the Roman people. But you made common cause with Mandonius and Indibilis, and intended also to have united your arms with them. They intended to have held Rhegium as a lasting settlement, as the Campanians held Capua, which they took from its ancient Tuscan inhabitants; and as the Mamertines held Messana in Sicily, without any design of commencing without provocation a war upon the Roman people or their allies. Was it your purpose to hold Sucro as a place of abode? where, had I, your general, left you on my departure after the reduction of the province, you would have been justified in imploring the interference of gods and men, because you could not return to your wives and children. But suppose that you banished from your minds all recollection of these, as you did of your country and myself; I would wish to track the course of a wicked design, but not of one utterly insane. While I was alive, and the rest of the army safe, with which in one day I took Carthage, with which I routed, put to flight, and expelled from Spain four generals and four armies of the Carthaginians; did you, I say, who were only eight thousand men, all of course of less worth than Albius and Atrius, to whom you subjected yourselves, hope to wrest the province of Spain out of the hands of the Roman people? I lay no stress upon my own name, I put it out of the question. Let it be supposed that I have not been injured by you in any respect beyond the ready credence of my death. What! if I were dead, was the state to expire with me? was the empire of the Roman people to fall with me? Jupiter, most good and great, would not have permitted that the existence of the city, built under the auspices and sanction of the gods to last for ever, should terminate with that of this frail and perishable body. The Roman people have survived those many and distinguished generals who were all cut off in one war; Flaminius, Paulus, Gracchus, Posthumius Albinus, Marcus Marcellus, Titus Quinctius Crispinus, Cneius Fulvius, my kinsmen the Scipios; and will survive a thousand others who may perish, some by the sword, others by disease; and would the Roman state have been buried with my single corpse? You yourselves, here in Spain, when your two generals, my father and my uncle, fell, chose Septimus Marcius as your general to oppose the Carthaginians, exulting on account of their recent victory. And thus I speak, on the supposition that Spain would have been without a leader. Would Marcus Silanus, who was sent into the province with the same power and the same command as myself, would Lucius Scipio my brother, and Caius Laelius, lieutenant-generals, have been wanting to avenge the majesty of the empire? Could the armies, the generals themselves, their dignity or their cause, be compared with one another? And even had you got the better of all these, would you bear arms in conjunction with the Carthaginians against your country, against your countrymen? Would you wish that Africa should rule Italy, and Carthage the city of Rome? If so, for what offence on the part of your country?

"Now, even though evil is never driven by reason, I’d really like to know what your plan was in such a terrible situation. In the past, a legion sent to garrison Rhegium cruelly executed the main citizens and controlled that wealthy city for ten years; because of this atrocity, the whole legion, which had four thousand men, was executed in the forum at Rome. But they didn’t follow Atrius the Umbrian, who was barely worth more than a kitchen servant and whose name was even unlucky; instead, they reported to Decius Jubellius, a military tribune. They didn’t team up with Pyrrhus, or the Samnites or Lucanians, who were enemies of the Roman people. But you allied with Mandonius and Indibilis and were planning to join forces with them. They aimed to keep Rhegium as a permanent settlement, just like the Campanians did with Capua, which they took from its original Tuscan inhabitants, and like the Mamertines did with Messana in Sicily, without any intention of starting a war against the Roman people or their allies. Was your intention to hold Sucro as a place to live? If I, your general, had left you there after taking control of the province, you would have been right to ask for help from gods and men, as you wouldn't have been able to return to your wives and children. But imagine that you completely ignored those thoughts, as you did with your homeland and with me; I want to trace a wicked plan, but not one that is completely insane. While I was alive, and the rest of the army was intact, with which I captured Carthage in one day, and routed, chased away, and expelled four Carthaginian generals and four armies from Spain; did you really think, being only eight thousand men, and all clearly less valuable than Albius and Atrius, to whom you subordinated yourselves, that you could take the province of Spain from the Roman people? I won’t focus on my own name; let’s assume I haven’t been wronged by you other than your readiness to believe I was dead. What? If I were dead, would the state come to an end with me? Would the Roman people's empire collapse because of my death? Jupiter, the most good and great, would not have allowed the existence of a city, built under the guidance and approval of the gods to last forever, to end with this fragile, temporary body. The Roman people have outlasted many distinguished generals who were all lost in a single war: Flaminius, Paulus, Gracchus, Posthumius Albinus, Marcus Marcellus, Titus Quinctius Crispinus, Cneius Fulvius, my relatives the Scipios; and will outlive countless others who may die, some by the sword, others by disease; would the Roman state really have been buried with just my corpse? You all, right here in Spain, when your two generals, my father and my uncle, fell, chose Septimus Marcius as your general to oppose the Carthaginians, rejoicing over their recent victory. And thus I speak, assuming Spain would have been without a leader. Would Marcus Silanus, who was sent to the province with the same authority and command as I had, would Lucius Scipio my brother, and Caius Laelius, lieutenant-generals, have stood by and done nothing to defend the dignity of the empire? Could the armies, the generals themselves, their respect or their cause, even be compared? And even if you had defeated all of them, would you really ally with the Carthaginians against your own country, against your fellow citizens? Would you want Africa to rule Italy and Carthage to control the city of Rome? If so, for what crime against your homeland?"

29

"An unjust sentence of condemnation, and a miserable and undeserved banishment, formerly induced Coriolanus to go and fight against his country; he was restrained, however, by private duty from public parricide. What grief, what resentment instigated you? Was the delay of your pay for a few days, during the illness of your general, a reason of sufficient weight for you to declare war against your country? to revolt from the Roman people and join the Ilergetians? to leave no obligation, divine or human, unviolated? Without doubt, soldiers, you were mad; nor was the disease which seized my frame more violent than that with which your minds were affected. I shrink with horror from the relation of what men believed, what they hoped and wished. Let oblivion cover all these things if possible; if not, however it be, let them be covered in silence. I must confess my speech must have appeared to you severe and harsh, but how much more harsh, think you, must your actions be than my words! Do you think it reasonable that I should suffer all the acts which you have committed, and that you should not bear with patience even to hear them mentioned? But you shall not be reproached even with these things any further. I could wish that you might as easily forget them as I shall. Therefore, as far as relates to the general body of you, if you repent of the error you have committed, I shall have received sufficient and more than sufficient atonement for it. Albius the Calenian, and Atrius the Umbrian, with the rest of the principal movers of this impious mutiny, shall expiate with their blood the crime they have perpetrated. To yourselves, if you have returned to a sound state of mind, the sight of their punishment ought not only to be not unpleasant, but even gratifying; for there are no persons to whom the measures they have taken are more hostile and injurious than to you." He had scarcely finished speaking, when, according to the plan preconcerted, every object of terror was at once presented to their eyes and ears. The troops, which had formed a circle round the assembly, clashed their swords against their shields; the herald's voice was heard citing by name the persons who had been condemned in the council; the culprits were dragged naked into the midst of the assembly, and at the same time all the apparatus for punishment was brought forth. They were tied to the stake, scourged with rods, and decapitated; while those who were present were so benumbed with fear, that not only no expression of dissatisfaction at the severity of the punishment, but not even a groan was heard. They were then all dragged out, the place was cleared, and the men cited by name took the oath of allegiance to Scipio before the military tribunes, each receiving his full demand of pay as he answered to his name. Such was the termination and result which the insurrection of the soldiers, which began at Sucro, met with.

"An unfair sentence of condemnation and a painful, undeserved banishment pushed Coriolanus to fight against his own country; however, he was held back by personal duty from committing treason. What sorrow, what anger drove you? Was the delay of a few days in your pay during your general's illness a serious enough reason for you to declare war on your country? To turn against the Roman people and ally with the Ilergetians? To break every obligation, divine or human? Without a doubt, soldiers, you were out of your minds; the illness that afflicted my body was no more intense than the madness that affected your reasoning. I shudder at the thought of what people believed, what they hoped, and what they wished. Let those things be forgotten, if at all possible; if not, let them be left in silence. I must admit my words may have seemed harsh and severe to you, but how much harsher must your actions be compared to my words! Do you think it's fair that I should endure all the things you've done while you can't even bear to hear them mentioned? But from now on, I won't blame you for any of those things. I wish you could forget them as easily as I will. So, regarding the rest of you, if you regret the error you've made, I will consider it sufficient, even more than sufficient, atonement. Albius the Calenian, and Atrius the Umbrian, along with the other main instigators of this wicked mutiny, will pay for their crime with their blood. For yourselves, if you have returned to a clear state of mind, witnessing their punishment should not only be bearable but even satisfying; because no one is more hurt and affected by their actions than you are." He had barely finished speaking when, according to the prearranged plan, every terrifying sight and sound was suddenly thrust upon them. The troops, who had formed a circle around the assembly, clashed their swords against their shields; the herald's voice was heard naming those who had been condemned in the council; the culprits were dragged naked into the center of the assembly, and at the same time, all the tools for punishment were brought out. They were tied to the stake, whipped with rods, and executed; while those present were so paralyzed with fear that there was not a single expression of dissatisfaction with the severity of the punishment, not even a groan was heard. They were then all dragged out, the area was cleared, and the named men took the oath of allegiance to Scipio before the military tribunes, each receiving their full pay as they answered to their names. Such was the end result of the soldiers' uprising, which had started at Sucro.

30

During the time of these transactions, Hanno, the lieutenant-general of Mago, having been sent from Gades to the river Baetis with a small body of Africans, by tempting the Spaniards with money, armed as many as four thousand men; but afterwards, being deprived of his camp by Lucius Marcius, and losing the principal part of his troops in the confusion occasioned by its capture, and some also in the flight, for the cavalry pursued them closely while they were dispersed, he made his escape with a few attendants. During these transactions on the river Baetis, Laelius in the mean time, sailing out of the straits into the ocean, came with his fleet before Carteia, a city situated on the coast of the ocean, where the sea begins to expand itself, after being confined in a narrow strait. He had entertained hopes of having Gades betrayed to him without a contest, persons having come unsolicited into the Roman camp to make promises to that effect, as has been before mentioned. The plot was discovered before it was ripe, and all having been apprehended, were placed by Mago in the hands of Adherbal the praetor, to be conveyed to Carthage. Adherbal, having put the conspirators on board a quinquereme, sent it in advance, because it sailed slower than a trireme, and followed himself at a moderate distance with eight triremes. The quinquereme was just entering the strait, when Laelius, who had himself also sailed out of the harbour of Carteia in a quinquereme, followed by seven triremes, bore down upon Adherbal and his triremes, feeling assured that the trireme, when once caught in the rapid strait, would not be able to return against the opposing current. The Carthaginian, alarmed by the suddenness of the affair, hesitated for some little time whether he should follow the trireme, or turn his prows against the enemy. This very delay put it out of his power to decline an action, for they were now within a weapon's cast, and the enemy were bearing down upon him on all sides. The current also had rendered it impossible to manage the ships. Nor was the action like a naval engagement, inasmuch as it was in no respect subject to the control of the will, nor afforded any opportunity for the exercise of skill or method. The nature of the strait and the tide, which solely and entirely governed the contest, carried the ships against those of their own and the enemy's party indiscriminately, though striving in a contrary direction; so that you might see one ship which was flying whirled back by an eddy and driven against the victors, and another which was engaged in pursuit, if it had fallen into an opposite current, turning itself away as if for flight. And when actually engaged, one ship while bearing down upon another with its beak directed against it, assuming an oblique position itself, received a stroke from the beak of the other; while another which lay with its side exposed to the enemy, receiving a sudden impulse, was turned round so as to present its prow. While the triremes were thus engaged in a doubtful and uncertain contest, in which every thing was governed by chance, the Roman quinquereme, whether being more manageable in consequence of its weight, or by means of more banks of oars making its way through the eddies, sunk two triremes, and swept off the oars from one side of another, while sailing by it with great violence. The rest too, had they come in its way, it would have disabled; but Adherbal, with his remaining four ships, sailed over into Africa.

During this time, Hanno, the lieutenant-general of Mago, was sent from Gades to the Baetis river with a small group of African soldiers. By luring the Spaniards with money, he managed to recruit about four thousand men. However, he soon lost his camp to Lucius Marcius, and the chaos that followed led to the loss of most of his troops, with some fleeing under pressure from pursuing cavalry. Hanno barely escaped with a few attendants. Meanwhile, on the Baetis river, Laelius had set sail from the straits into the ocean and arrived with his fleet off Carteia, a city on the ocean coast where the sea begins to widen after passing through a narrow strait. He had hoped that Gades would be betrayed to him without a fight, as some individuals had approached the Roman camp uninvited to make such promises, as mentioned earlier. The conspiracy was uncovered before it could take effect, and all involved were captured and handed over by Mago to Adherbal the praetor, to be taken to Carthage. Adherbal placed the conspirators on a quinquereme, sending it ahead since it was slower than a trireme, and he followed at a moderate distance with eight triremes. As the quinquereme was entering the strait, Laelius, who had also left the harbor of Carteia in a quinquereme followed by seven triremes, charged at Adherbal and his triremes, confident that the triremes, once caught in the fast current of the strait, wouldn’t be able to return against it. Caught off guard by the sudden attack, Adherbal hesitated for a moment about whether to pursue the triremes or to face the enemy. This hesitation left him no choice but to engage, as they were now within range of weapons, and the enemy was closing in on him from all sides. The current made it impossible to maneuver the ships effectively. The action didn’t resemble a typical naval battle since it was dictated by the current and offered no opportunity for strategic skill. The strait and tide, which solely controlled the battle, swept both friendly and enemy ships indiscriminately, despite their efforts to move in opposite directions. You could see one ship trying to escape being swept back into the fray, while another chasing it might get caught in a conflicting current, causing it to turn away as if fleeing. When they were actually engaged, a ship that charged another with its prow aimed forward could get struck by the opposing ship’s prow due to its awkward angle, and another ship presenting its side to the enemy might get suddenly pushed into a position to face them. As the triremes fought in this confusing and uncertain battle, driven by chance, the Roman quinquereme, possibly because it was heavier and easier to manage, or thanks to its additional oars, sank two triremes and swept away oars from the side of one as it barreled past violently. It would have also disabled any other ships in its path, but Adherbal managed to sail his remaining four ships back to Africa.

31

Laelius returned victorious into Carteia; and hearing there what had occurred at Gades, that the plot had been discovered, the conspirators sent to Carthage, and that the hopes which had brought them there had been completely frustrated, he sent a message to Lucius Marcius, to the effect that, unless they wished to waste time uselessly in lying before Gades, they should return to the general; and Marcius consenting to the proposal, they both returned to Carthage a few days after. In consequence of their departure, Mago not only obtained a temporary relief from the dangers which beset him on all sides, both by sea and land, but also on hearing of the rebellion of the Ilergetians, conceived hopes of recovering Spain, and sent messengers to Carthage to the senate, who, at the same time that they represented to them in exaggerated terms both the intestine dissension in the Roman camp and the defection of their allies, might exhort them to send succours by which the empire of Spain, which had been handed down to them by their ancestors, might be regained. Mandonius and Indibilis, retiring within their borders, remained quiet for a little time, not knowing what course to take, till they knew what was determined upon respecting the mutiny; but not distrusting that if Scipio pardoned the error of his own countrymen, they also might obtain the same. But when the severe punishment inflicted came to be generally known, concluding that their offence also would be considered as demanding a similar expiation, they again summoned their countrymen to arms; and assembling the auxiliaries which had joined them before, they crossed over into the Sedetanian territory, where they had had a fixed camp at the beginning of the revolt, with twenty thousand foot and two thousand five hundred horse.

Laelius returned victorious to Carteia; and upon hearing what had happened in Gades—that the plot had been exposed, the conspirators sent to Carthage, and the hopes that brought them there had been completely dashed—he sent a message to Lucius Marcius, suggesting that unless they wanted to waste time idly in Gades, they should return to the general. Marcius agreed to the proposal, and they both returned to Carthage a few days later. Because of their departure, Mago not only experienced temporary relief from the dangers surrounding him both by sea and land, but upon hearing about the rebellion of the Ilergetians, he hoped to regain Spain and sent messengers to the Carthaginian senate. These messengers exaggerated the internal conflict in the Roman camp and the defection of their allies while urging them to send reinforcements to reclaim the empire of Spain, which had been handed down to them by their ancestors. Mandonius and Indibilis, retreating to their own territory, remained quiet for a while, uncertain about what to do until they learned the outcome regarding the mutiny; however, they still hoped that if Scipio forgave the mistakes of his own countrymen, they might receive the same mercy. But when the harsh punishment that had been carried out became widely known, they concluded that their own offense would also require similar atonement, so they summoned their countrymen to arms again. They gathered the auxiliaries who had previously joined them and crossed into the Sedetanian territory, where they had established a camp at the start of the revolt, with twenty thousand foot soldiers and two thousand five hundred cavalry.

32

Scipio having without difficulty regained the affection of his soldiers, both by his punctuality in discharging the arrears of pay to all, as well the guilty as the innocent, and particularly by the looks and language of reconciliation towards all, before he quitted Carthage summoned an assembly; and after inveighing at large against the perfidy of the petty princes who were in rebellion, declared "that the feelings with which he set out to take revenge for their villany were widely different from those with which he lately corrected the error committed by his countrymen. That on the latter occasion, he had with groans and tears, as though he were cutting his own vitals, expiated either the imprudence or the guilt of eight thousand men with the heads of thirty; but now he was going to the destruction of the Ilergetians with joyful and animated feelings: for they were neither natives of the same soil, nor united with him by any bond of society. The only connexion which did subsist between them, that of honour and friendship, they had themselves severed by their wicked conduct." When he looked at the troops which composed his army, besides that he saw that they were all either of his own country, or allies and of the Latin confederacy; he was also strongly affected by the circumstance, that there was scarcely a soldier in it who was not brought out of Italy into that country either by his uncle, Cneius Scipio, who was the first of the Roman name who had come into that province, or by his father when consul, or by himself. That they were all accustomed to the name and auspices of the Scipios; that it was his wish to take them home to their country to receive a well-earned triumph; and that he hoped that they would support him when he put up for the consulship, as if the honour sought were to be shared in common by them all. With regard to the expedition which they were just going to undertake, that the man who considered it as a war must be forgetful of his own achievements. That, by Hercules, Mago, who had fled for safety with a few ships beyond the limits of the world into an island surrounded by the ocean, was a source of greater concern to him than the Ilergetians; for in it there was both a Carthaginian general and a Carthaginian army, whatever might be its numbers; while here were only robbers and leaders of robbers, who, though they possessed sufficient energy for ravaging the lands of their neighbours, burning their houses, and carrying off their cattle, yet would have none at all in a regular and pitched battle; and who would come to the encounter relying more on the swiftness with which they can fly than on their arms. "Accordingly," he said, "that he had thought it right to quell the Ilergetians before he quitted the province, not because he saw that any danger could arise from them, or that a war of greater importance could grow out of these proceedings; but in the first place, that a revolt of so heinous a character might not go unpunished, and in the next place, that not a single enemy might be said to be left in a province which had been subdued with such valour and success. He bid them, therefore, follow him, with the assistance of the gods, not so much to make war upon, for the contest was not with an enemy who was upon an equality with them, but to take vengeance on the basest of men."

Scipio, having easily won back his soldiers' loyalty by promptly paying everyone what they were owed—both the guilty and the innocent—and especially by showing kindness and speaking words of reconciliation to all, called for a meeting before leaving Carthage. He passionately criticized the treachery of the petty kings rebelling against him and declared, "The emotions I felt when I set out to revenge their wrongdoing are completely different from those I felt when I recently corrected the mistakes of my fellow countrymen. In that situation, I mourned and cried as if I were cutting out my own insides, sacrificing the lives of thirty men to atone for the imprudence or guilt of eight thousand. But now, I’m heading to wipe out the Ilergetians with joy and determination because they are neither from the same land nor connected to me by any ties of community. The only connection we had—honor and friendship—they destroyed themselves through their evil actions." Looking at his troops, he saw that they were all either his own countrymen or allies from the Latin confederation. He was also deeply moved by the fact that almost every soldier in the army had come to this land from Italy, either through his uncle, Cneius Scipio, the first Roman to enter this province, or through his father when he was consul, or through him. They were all familiar with the name and leadership of the Scipios, and he wanted to take them home to celebrate a well-deserved triumph, hoping they would support him when he campaigned for the consulship as if the honor sought belonged to them as well. Regarding the mission they were about to undertake, he believed that anyone who saw it merely as a war must have forgotten their own accomplishments. "By Hercules," he said, "Mago, who fled with a few ships into an island surrounded by the ocean, is a bigger concern for me than the Ilergetians; for there lies a Carthaginian general and a Carthaginian army, no matter how small, while here we only face robbers and their leaders. They may be energetic enough to raid their neighbors’ lands, burn their houses, and steal their cattle, but they won’t stand up to a regular battle and will rely more on their ability to run away than on their weapons. Therefore," he continued, "I felt it necessary to deal with the Ilergetians before I leave the province, not because I saw any real danger from them or that a more significant war could emerge from this, but first to ensure such a grave rebellion did not go unpunished and second, so there would be no enemies left in a province that had been conquered with such bravery and success. So I urge you to follow me, with the gods' help, not so much to wage war, since we aren’t facing an equally matched enemy, but to take revenge on the most despicable of men."

33

After this harangue he dismissed them, with orders to get themselves in readiness in every respect for marching the next day; when, setting out, he arrived at the river Iberus in ten days. Then crossing the river, he, on the fourth day, pitched his camp within sight of the enemy. Before him was a plain enclosed on all sides by mountains. Into the valley thus formed Scipio ordered some cattle, taken chiefly from the lands of the enemy, to be driven, in order to excite the rapacity of the barbarians, and then sent some light-armed troops as a protection for them, directing Laelius to charge the enemy from a place of concealment when they were engaged in skirmishing. A mountain which projected conveniently concealed the ambuscade of the cavalry, and the battle began without delay. The Spaniards, as soon as they saw the cattle at a distance, rushed upon them, and the light-armed troops attacked the Spaniards while occupied with their booty. At first they annoyed each other with missiles; but afterwards, having discharged their light weapons, which were calculated to provoke rather than to decide the contest, they drew their swords, and began to engage foot to foot. The fight between the infantry would have been doubtful, but that the cavalry then came up, and not only, charging them in front, trod down all before them, but some also, riding round by the foot of the hill, presented themselves on their rear, so that they might intercept the greater part of them; and consequently the carnage was greater than usually takes place in light and skirmishing engagements. The resentment of the barbarians was rather inflamed by this adverse battle, than their spirits depressed. Accordingly, that they might not appear cast down, they marched out into the field the following day as soon as it was light. The valley, which was confined, as has been before stated, would not contain all their forces. About two-thirds of their foot and all their cavalry came down to the engagement. The remainder of their infantry they stationed on the declivity of the hill. Scipio, conceiving that the confined nature of the ground would be in his favour, both because the Roman troops were better adapted for fighting in a contracted space than the Spanish, and also because the enemy had come down and formed their line on ground which would not contain all their forces, applied his mind to a new expedient. For he considered that he could not himself cover his flanks with his cavalry, and that those of the enemy which they had led out, together with their infantry, would be unable to act. Accordingly he ordered Laelius to lead the cavalry round by the hills as secretly as possible, and separate, as far as he could, the fight between the cavalry from that between the infantry. He himself drew up the whole body of his infantry against the enemy, placing four cohorts in front, because he could not extend his line further. He commenced the battle without delay, in order that the contest itself might divert the attention of the enemy, and prevent their observing the cavalry which were passing along the hills. Nor were they aware that they had come round before they beard the noise occasioned by the engagement of the cavalry in their rear. Thus there were two battles; two lines of infantry and two bodies of horse being engaged within the space occupied by the plain lengthwise; and that because it was too narrow to admit of both descriptions of force being engaged in the same lines. When the Spanish infantry could not assist their cavalry, nor their cavalry the infantry, and the infantry, which had rashly engaged in the plain, relying on the assistance of the cavalry, were being cut to pieces, the cavalry themselves also, being surrounded and unable to stand the shock of the enemy's infantry in front, (for by this time their own infantry were completely overthrown,) nor of the cavalry in their rear, after having formed themselves into a circle and defended themselves for a long time, their horses standing still, were all slain to a man. Nor did one person, horse or foot, survive of those who were engaged in the valley. The third part, which stood upon the hill rather to view the contest in security than to take any part of it upon themselves, had both time and space to fly; among whom the princes themselves also fled, having escaped during the confusion, before the army was entirely surrounded.

After this speech, he dismissed them, telling them to get ready for marching the next day. They set out and reached the Iberus River in ten days. After crossing the river, on the fourth day, he set up camp within sight of the enemy. In front of him was a plain surrounded by mountains. Scipio ordered some cattle, mostly taken from enemy territory, to be driven into the valley to tempt the barbarian forces. He then sent out some light-armed troops to protect the cattle and instructed Laelius to ambush the enemy while they were distracted. A conveniently located mountain concealed the cavalry's ambush, and the battle began without delay. As soon as the Spaniards saw the cattle, they rushed towards them, and the light-armed troops attacked while they were preoccupied with their prize. At first, they exchanged missiles, but after using their light weapons, which only provoked rather than settled the fight, they drew their swords and engaged in close combat. The infantry battle could have gone either way, but the cavalry soon arrived, charging the enemy and trampling them down. Some cavalry also came around by the foot of the hill to cut off the enemy's escape, resulting in greater bloodshed than typical for light skirmishes. The barbarians were even more enraged by this setback than demoralized. Wanting to show that they weren’t defeated, they marched into the field the following morning at dawn. The confined valley could not hold all their forces, so about two-thirds of their infantry and all their cavalry engaged. The rest stationed on the hillside. Scipio believed the cramped terrain would work to his advantage, as Roman troops were better suited for close combat than the Spaniards, and since the enemy had set up on terrain that couldn't accommodate all their forces, he devised a new plan. He figured he couldn't protect his flanks with his cavalry, and that the enemy's cavalry and infantry would struggle to work together. He ordered Laelius to quietly lead the cavalry around the hills to separate the cavalry fight from the infantry battle. He organized his entire infantry against the enemy, placing four cohorts in front since he couldn't stretch his line further. He quickly initiated the battle to draw the enemy's attention and distract them from the cavalry flanking them. The enemy didn't realize they were in trouble until they heard the sounds of the cavalry battle behind them. Thus, there were two separate battles occurring, with two infantry lines and two cavalry groups engaged in the narrow plain, which couldn’t accommodate both types of forces in the same lines. When the Spanish infantry couldn’t support their cavalry, and the cavalry couldn’t help the infantry, those who carelessly engaged in the plain—counting on cavalry backup—were cut down. The cavalry, surrounded and unable to withstand the opposing infantry in front or the enemy cavalry behind, formed a circle to defend themselves for a long time but were ultimately all killed. No one, whether horse or foot, survived from those engaged in the valley. The third who stayed on the hill to watch rather than participate managed to flee safely, including their leaders, who escaped during the chaos before the army was completely surrounded.

34

The same day, besides other booty, the camp of the Spaniards was taken, together with about three thousand men. Of the Romans and their allies as many as one thousand two hundred fell in that battle; more than three thousand were wounded. The victory would have been less bloody had the battle taken place in a plain more extended, and affording facilities for flight. Indibilis, renouncing his purpose of carrying on war, and considering that his safest reliance in his present distress was on the tried honour and clemency of Scipio, sent his brother Mandonius to him; who, falling prostrate before his knees, ascribed his conduct to the fatal frenzy of those times, when, as it were from the effects of some pestilential contagion, not only the Ilergetians and Lacetanians, but even the Roman camp had been infected with madness. He said that his own condition, and that of his brother and the rest of his countrymen, was such, that either, if it seemed good, they would give back their lives to him from whom they had received them, or if preserved a second time, they would in return for that favour devote their lives for ever to the service of him to whom alone they were indebted for them. They before placed their reliance on their cause, when they had not yet had experience of his clemency, but now, on the contrary, placing no reliance on their cause, all their hopes were centred in the mercy of the conqueror. It was a custom with the Romans, observed from ancient times, not to exercise any authority over others, as subject to them, in cases where they did not enter into friendship with them by a league and on equal terms, until they had surrendered all they possessed, sacred and profane; until they had received hostages, taken their arms from them, and placed garrisons in their cities. In the present instance, however, Scipio, after inveighing at great length against Mandonius, who stood before him, and Indibilis, who was absent, said "that they had justly forfeited their lives by their wicked conduct, but that they should be preserved by the kindness of himself and the Roman people. Further, that he would neither take their arms from them, (which only served as pledges to those who feared rebellion,) but would leave them the free use of them, and their minds free from fear; nor would he take vengeance on their unoffending hostages, but upon themselves, should they revolt, not inflicting punishment upon a defenceless but an armed enemy. That he gave them the liberty of choosing whether they would have the Romans favourable to them or incensed against them, for they had experienced them under both circumstances." Thus Mandonius was allowed to depart, having only a pecuniary fine imposed upon him to furnish the means of paying the troops. Scipio himself, having sent Marcius in advance into the Farther Spain, and sent Silanus back to Tarraco, waited a few days until the Ilergetians had paid the fine imposed upon them; and then, setting out with some troops lightly equipped, overtook Marcius when he was now drawing near to the ocean.

The same day, along with other loot, the Spanish camp was captured, along with about three thousand soldiers. In that battle, around one thousand two hundred Romans and their allies were killed; more than three thousand were wounded. The victory would have been less bloody if the battle had taken place in a larger open area, which would have allowed for easier escape. Indibilis, deciding not to continue the war and believing that his safest option in his current situation was to rely on the proven honor and mercy of Scipio, sent his brother Mandonius to him. Mandonius fell to his knees and explained that his actions were due to the madness of the times, as if a deadly plague had spread, affecting not only the Ilergetians and Lacetanians but even the Roman camp with insanity. He stated that he and his brother, along with the rest of their people, were in a position where they could either give their lives back to the one from whom they received them or, if spared a second time, devote their lives forever to the service of the only one they owed their survival to. Previously, they had relied on their cause before knowing of Scipio's mercy; now, with little faith in their cause, all their hopes rested on the mercy of the conqueror. It was a long-standing Roman practice not to exert authority over others unless they established a friendship through a league on equal terms and secured full surrender of everything they held sacred or secular, including taking hostages, disarming them, and placing garrisons in their cities. In this case, however, after strongly criticizing Mandonius, who stood before him, and Indibilis, who was absent, Scipio stated that they had justly forfeited their lives due to their wrongdoing, but they would be spared by his kindness and that of the Roman people. He added that he would not disarm them, as doing so only served as a pledge to those who feared rebellion, but would allow them to keep their weapons and their minds free from fear; nor would he seek revenge against their innocent hostages, but rather against them if they rebelled, punishing an armed enemy instead of a defenseless one. He gave them the choice of whether they wanted the Romans as allies or enemies, for they had seen both sides. Thus, Mandonius was allowed to leave, with only a financial fine imposed to cover the troops' payment. Scipio himself, having sent Marcius ahead into Further Spain and Silanus back to Tarraco, waited a few days until the Ilergetians paid the imposed fine. Then, setting out with some lightly equipped troops, he caught up with Marcius as he neared the ocean.

35

The negotiation which had some time before commenced respecting Masinissa, was delayed from one cause after another; for the Numidian was desirous by all means of conferring with Scipio in person, and of touching his right hand in confirmation of their compact. This was the cause of Scipio's undertaking at this time a journey of such a length, and into so remote a quarter. Masinissa, when at Gades, received information from Marcius of the approach of Scipio, and by pretending that his horses were injured by being pent up in the island, and that they not only caused a scarcity of every thing to the rest, but also felt it themselves; moreover that his cavalry were beginning to lose their energy for want of employment; he prevailed upon Mago to allow him to cross over to the continent, to plunder the adjacent country of Spain. Having passed over, he sent forward three chiefs of the Numidians, to fix a time and place for the conference desiring that two might be detained by Scipio as hostages. The third being sent back to conduct Masinissa to the place to which he was directed to bring him, they came to the conference with a few attendants. The Numidian had long before been possessed with admiration of Scipio from the fame of his exploits; and his imagination had pictured to him the idea of a grand and magnificent person; but his veneration for him was still greater when he appeared before him. For besides that his person, naturally majestic in the highest degree, was rendered still more so by his flowing hair, by his dress, which was not in a precise and ornamental style, but truly masculine and soldier-like, and also by his age, for he was then in full vigour of body, to which the bloom of youth, renewed as it were after his late illness, had given additional fulness and sleekness. The Numidian, who was in a manner thunderstruck by the mere effect of the meeting, thanked him for having sent home his brother's son. He affirmed, that from that time he had sought for this opportunity, which being at length presented to him, by favour of the immortal gods, he had not allowed to pass without seizing it. That he desired to serve him and the Roman people in such a manner, as that no one foreigner should have aided the Roman interest with greater zeal than himself. Although he had long since wished it, he had not been so able to effect it in Spain, a foreign and strange country; but that it would be easy for him to do so in that country in which he had been born and educated, under the hope of succeeding to his father's throne. If, indeed, the Romans should send the same commander, Scipio, into Africa, he entertained a well-grounded hope that Carthage would continue to exist but a short time. Scipio saw and heard him with the highest delight, both because he knew that he was the first man in all the cavalry of the enemy, and because the youth himself exhibited in his manner the strongest proof of a noble spirit. After mutual pledges of faith, he set out on his return to Tarraco. Masinissa, having laid waste the adjacent lands, with the permission of the Romans, that he might not appear to have passed over into the continent to no purpose, returned to Gades.

The negotiation that had started some time ago regarding Masinissa was delayed for various reasons; the Numidian was eager to meet Scipio in person and touch his right hand as a way to confirm their agreement. This was the reason Scipio decided to take such a long journey into a distant area. While in Gades, Masinissa learned from Marcius that Scipio was coming, and by claiming that his horses were suffering from being confined on the island, which was causing shortages for everyone else and making his cavalry lose their energy from lack of use, he convinced Mago to let him cross over to the mainland to raid the nearby Spanish territory. Once he crossed over, he sent three Numidian leaders ahead to arrange a time and place for their meeting, asking that two of them be kept by Scipio as hostages. The third was sent back to bring Masinissa to the designated location for their meeting, where they arrived with a few attendants. Masinissa had long admired Scipio from stories of his achievements, and his imagination had created an image of a grand and impressive figure; but his admiration grew even more when he actually met him. Scipio’s naturally commanding presence was heightened by his flowing hair, his attire which was not overly elaborate but truly masculine and military, and his age, as he was in peak physical condition, with the glow of youth returning after his recent illness. Masinissa, somewhat in awe from the meeting, thanked Scipio for sending back his brother's son. He stated that he had been looking for this opportunity for a long time, and now, with the favor of the gods, he would not let it pass by. He expressed his desire to serve Scipio and the Roman people in such a way that no other foreigner could match his commitment to the Roman cause. Although he had wanted to do this in Spain, a foreign and unfamiliar land, he knew it would be easier in his home country, where he hoped to succeed his father's throne. If the Romans sent Scipio to Africa, he believed there was strong hope that Carthage wouldn’t last much longer. Scipio listened to him with great pleasure because he recognized that Masinissa was the top man in the enemy's cavalry and the young man himself demonstrated a strong noble spirit. After exchanging promises of loyalty, Scipio began his journey back to Tarraco. Masinissa, having ravaged the neighboring lands with the Romans' approval, so he wouldn’t seem to have crossed over for no reason, returned to Gades.

36

Mago, who despaired of success in Spain, of which he had entertained hopes, from the confidence inspired first by the mutiny of the soldiers, and afterwards by the defection of Indibilis, received a message from Carthage, while preparing to cross over into Africa, that the senate ordered him to carry over into Italy the fleet he had at Gades; and hiring there as many as he could of the Gallic and Ligurian youth, to form a junction with Hannibal, and not to suffer the war to flag which had been begun with so much vigour and still more success. For this object Mago not only received a supply of money from Carthage, but himself also exacted as much as he could from the inhabitants of Gades, plundering not only their treasury, but their temples, and compelling them individually to bring contributions of gold and silver, for the public service. As he sailed along the coast of Spain, he landed his troops not far from New Carthage, and after wasting the neighbouring lands, brought his fleet thence to the city. Here, keeping his troops in the ships by day, he landed them by night, and marched them to that part of the wall at which Carthage had been captured by the Romans; for he had supposed both that the garrison by which the city was occupied was not sufficiently strong for its protection, and that some of the townsmen would act on the hope of effecting a change. But messengers who came with the utmost haste and alarm from the country, brought intelligence at once of the devastation of the lands, the flight of the rustics, and the approach of the enemy. Besides, the fleet had been observed during the day, and it was evident that there was some object in choosing a station before the city. Accordingly, the troops were kept drawn up and armed within the gate which looks towards the lake and the sea. When the enemy, rushing forward in a disorderly manner, with a crowd of seamen mingled with soldiers, came up to the walls with more noise than strength; the gate being suddenly thrown open, the Romans sallied forth with a shout, and pursued the enemy, routed and put to flight at the first onset and discharge of their weapons, all the way to the shore, killing a great number of them; nor would one of them have survived the battle and the flight, had not the ships, which had been brought to the shore, afforded them a refuge in their dismay. Great alarm and confusion also prevailed in the ships, occasioned by their drawing up the ladders, lest the enemy should force their way in together with their own men, and by cutting away their halsers and anchors that they might not lose time in weighing them. Many, too, met with a miserable death while endeavouring to swim to the ships, not knowing, in consequence of the darkness, which way to direct their course, or what to avoid. On the following day, after the fleet had fled back to the ocean whence it had come, as many as eight hundred were slain between the wall and the shore, and two thousand stand of arms were found.

Mago, who had given up hope for success in Spain—initially inspired by the mutiny of the soldiers and later by Indibilis’s defection—received a message from Carthage while he was getting ready to head to Africa. The senate ordered him to take his fleet from Gades to Italy and to recruit as many Gallic and Ligurian young men as he could to join forces with Hannibal, ensuring that the war, which had started with so much energy and success, would not lose momentum. For this purpose, Mago not only received financial support from Carthage but also demanded as much as he could from the people of Gades, raiding their treasury and temples, and forcing them to contribute gold and silver to the war effort. As he sailed along the coast of Spain, he landed his troops near New Carthage. After ravaging the nearby lands, he brought his fleet to the city. There, he kept his troops on the ships during the day, landing them at night and marching them to the section of the wall where the Romans had taken Carthage. He believed the garrison defending the city was too weak and that some of the townspeople might be hopeful of a change. However, messengers arrived in a panic from the countryside, informing him of the land’s destruction, the flight of local farmers, and the enemy’s approach. Moreover, the fleet had been spotted during the day, indicating that they had a specific reason for stationing themselves outside the city. Thus, the troops prepared and armed themselves at the gate facing the lake and the sea. When the enemy charged up to the walls in disarray, with a mix of sailors and soldiers, the gate flew open suddenly, and the Romans rushed out with a shout, chasing the enemy in a disorganized retreat all the way to the shore, killing many. Not one of them would have escaped the battle and the flight had it not been for the ships that provided refuge in their panic. Chaos and fear also spread among the ships as they pulled up the ladders, worried that the enemy would break in alongside their own men, and cut loose their halyards and anchors to save time in weighing anchor. Many met a tragic end trying to swim to the ships, disoriented by the darkness, unsure of which way to go or what to avoid. The next day, after the fleet had fled back to the ocean from where it came, around eight hundred were killed between the wall and the shore, and two thousand pieces of armor were discovered.

37

Mago, on his return to Gades, not being allowed to enter the place, brought his fleet to shore at Cimbis, a place not far distant from Gades; whence he sent ambassadors with complaints of their having closed their gates upon a friend and ally. While they endeavoured to excuse themselves on the ground that it was done by a disorderly assembly of their people, who were exasperated against them on account of some acts of plunder which had been committed by the soldiers when they were embarking, he enticed their suffetes, which is the name of the chief magistracy among the Carthaginians, together with their quaestor, to come to a conference; when he ordered them to be lacerated with stripes and crucified. He then passed over with his fleet to the island Pityusa, distant about a hundred miles from the continent, and inhabited at that time by Carthaginians; on which account the fleet was received in a friendly manner; and not only were provisions liberally furnished, but also young men and arms were given them to reinforce their fleet. Rendered confident by these supplies, the Carthaginians crossed over to the Balearian islands, fifty miles distant. The Balearian islands are two in number; one larger than the other, and more powerful in men and arms; having also a harbour in which, as it was now the latter end of autumn, he believed he might winter conveniently. But here his fleet was opposed with as much hostility as he would have met with had the Romans inhabited that island. The only weapons they used at that time, and which they now principally employ, were slings; nor is there an individual of any other nation who possesses such a degree of excellence in the skilful use of this weapon, as the Balearians universally possess over the rest of the world. Such a quantity of stones, therefore, was poured like the thickest hail on the fleet, when approaching the shore, that, not daring to enter the harbour, they made off for the main. They then passed over to the lesser Balearian island, which is of a fertile soil, but not equally powerful in men and arms. Here, therefore, they landed, and pitched a camp in a strong position above the harbour; and having made themselves masters of the city and country without a contest, they enlisted two thousand auxiliaries, which they sent to Carthage, and then hauled their ships on shore for the winter. After Mago had left the coast of the ocean, the people of Gades surrendered to the Romans.

Mago, returning to Gades, was not allowed to enter the city. He docked his fleet at Cimbis, a nearby location, from where he sent ambassadors to complain about them shutting their gates on a friend and ally. They tried to defend themselves, claiming it was the action of a disorderly crowd upset due to some looting by soldiers during their departure. He persuaded their suffetes, the chief magistrates among the Carthaginians, along with their quaestor, to meet with him; then he ordered them to be whipped and crucified. He then sailed with his fleet to the island of Pityusa, about a hundred miles from the mainland, which was at that time inhabited by Carthaginians. As a result, the fleet was welcomed kindly, and they were generously supplied with food, young men, and weapons to strengthen their fleet. Feeling confident from these resources, the Carthaginians sailed to the Balearian islands, which are fifty miles away. The Balearian islands consist of two islands; one is larger and more powerful in terms of men and arms, and has a harbor where, since it was now late autumn, he thought he could winter comfortably. However, his fleet faced fierce resistance as if they were up against the Romans. The only weapons used at that time, which they still primarily use, were slings; no other nation has such skill in using this weapon as the Balearians do. As a result, a massive barrage of stones rained down on the fleet like thick hail when they approached the shore, causing them to retreat back to the open sea. They then moved on to the smaller Balearian island, which had fertile soil but was not as strong in terms of men and arms. Here, they landed and set up camp in a strong position above the harbor; they took control of the city and surrounding area without a fight, recruiting two thousand auxiliaries to send to Carthage, and then pulled their ships ashore for the winter. After Mago left the coast of the ocean, the people of Gades surrendered to the Romans.

38

Such were the transactions in Spain under the conduct and auspices of Publius Scipio. Scipio himself, having put Lucius Lentulus and Lucius Manlius Acidinus in charge of the province, returned to Rome with ten ships. Having obtained an audience of the senate without the city, in the temple of Bellona, he gave an account of the services he had performed in Spain; how often he had fought pitched battles, how many towns he had taken by force from the enemy, and what nations he had brought under the dominion of the Roman people. He stated that he had gone into Spain against four generals, and four victorious armies, but that he had not left a Carthaginian in that country. On account of these services he rather tried his prospect of a triumph, than pressed it pertinaciously; for it was quite clear, that no one had triumphed up to that time for services performed, when not invested with a magistracy. When the senate was dismissed he entered the city, and carried before him into the treasury fourteen thousand three hundred and forty-two pounds of silver, and a great quantity of coined silver. Lucius Veturius Philo then held the assembly for the election of consuls, when all the centuries, with the strongest marks of attachment, named Publius Scipio as consul. Publius Licinius Crassus, chief pontiff, was joined with him as his colleague. It is recorded, that this election was attended by a greater number of persons than any other during the war. People had come together from all quarters, not only to give their votes, but also for the purpose of seeing Publius Scipio. They ran in crowds, not only to his house, but also to the Capitol; where he was engaged in offering a sacrifice of a hundred oxen to Jupiter, which he had vowed in Spain, impressed with a presentiment, that as Caius Lutatius had terminated the former Punic war, so Publius Scipio would terminate the present; and that as he had driven the Carthaginians out of every part of Spain, so he would drive them out of Italy; and dooming Africa to him as his province, as though the war in Italy were at an end. The assembly was then held for the election of praetors. Two were elected who were then plebeian aediles, namely, Spurius Lucretius and Cneius Octavius; and of private persons, Cneius Servilius Caepio and Lucius Aemilius Papus.

Such were the events in Spain under the leadership of Publius Scipio. Scipio himself, after appointing Lucius Lentulus and Lucius Manlius Acidinus to oversee the province, returned to Rome with ten ships. He had a meeting with the senate outside the city, in the temple of Bellona, where he reported on the achievements he had made in Spain; detailing how many battles he fought, how many towns he captured from the enemy, and which nations he brought under Roman control. He stated he went into Spain facing four generals and four victorious armies, but he had not left a single Carthaginian in the country. Because of these accomplishments, he cautiously considered the possibility of a triumph instead of pushing for it aggressively, since it was clear that no one had triumphed for services rendered without holding a magistracy at that time. When the senate session ended, he entered the city, bringing with him to the treasury fourteen thousand three hundred and forty-two pounds of silver, along with a large amount of coined silver. Lucius Veturius Philo then conducted the assembly for the election of consuls, where all the centuries enthusiastically named Publius Scipio as consul. Publius Licinius Crassus, the chief pontiff, was appointed his colleague. This election reportedly attracted more people than any other during the war. People gathered from all over, not only to cast their votes but also to see Publius Scipio. They flocked to his house and the Capitol, where he was sacrificing one hundred oxen to Jupiter, a vow he made in Spain, believing that, just as Caius Lutatius ended the previous Punic war, so too would Publius Scipio end the current one; and that, just as Lutatius drove the Carthaginians out of every part of Spain, Scipio would remove them from Italy and reclaim Africa as his province, as if the war in Italy were already over. The assembly then convened for the election of praetors. Two were elected from the current plebeian aediles, Spurius Lucretius and Cneius Octavius, along with private citizens Cneius Servilius Caepio and Lucius Aemilius Papus.

In the fourteenth year of the Punic war, Publius Cornelius Scipio and Publius Licinius Crassus entered on the consulship, when the provinces assigned to the consuls were, to Scipio, Sicily, without drawing lots, his colleague not opposing it, because the care of the sacred affairs required the presence of the chief pontiff in Italy; to Crassus, Bruttium. The provinces of the praetors were then put to the determination of lots, when the city jurisdiction fell to Servilius; Ariminum, for so they called Gaul, to Spurius Lucretius; Sicily to Lucius Aemilius; Sardinia to Cneius Octavius. A senate was held in the Capitol, when, on the motion of Publius Scipio, a decree was made, that he should exhibit the games which he had vowed in Spain during the mutiny of the soldiers, out of the money which he had himself brought into the treasury.

In the fourteenth year of the Punic War, Publius Cornelius Scipio and Publius Licinius Crassus took office as consuls. Scipio was assigned Sicily without a lottery, as his colleague did not oppose it, since the chief pontiff needed to be in Italy for sacred matters. Crassus was assigned Bruttium. The provinces for the praetors were determined by drawing lots, with Servilius getting city jurisdiction; Spurius Lucretius receiving Ariminum, which they referred to as Gaul; Lucius Aemilius assigned Sicily; and Cneius Octavius getting Sardinia. A senate meeting was held on the Capitol, where, on Scipio's proposal, a decree was passed for him to hold the games he had vowed in Spain during the soldiers’ mutiny, funded by the money he personally brought into the treasury.

39

He then introduced into the senate the Saguntine ambassadors, the eldest of whom thus spoke: "Although there remains no degree of suffering, conscript fathers, beyond what we have endured, in order that we might keep our faith towards you to the last; yet such are the benefits which we have received both from yourselves and your generals, that we do not repent of the calamities to which we have ourselves been exposed. On our account you undertook the war, and having undertaken it, you have continued to carry it on for now the fourteenth year with such inflexible perseverance, that frequently you have both yourselves been reduced, and have brought the Carthaginians to the last extremity. At a time when you had a war of such a desperate character in Italy, and Hannibal as your antagonist, you sent your consul with an army into Spain, to collect, as it were, the remains of our wreck. Publius and Cneius Cornelius, from the time they entered the province, never ceased from adopting such measures as were favourable to us and detrimental to our enemies. First of all, they restored to us our town; and, sending persons to collect our countrymen, who were sold and dispersed throughout all Spain, restored them from a state of slavery to freedom. When our circumstances, from being wretched in the extreme, had nearly assumed a desirable state, your generals Publius and Cneius Cornelius fell more to be lamented by ourselves even than by you. Then truly we seemed to have been dragged back from distant places to our ancient abode, to perish again, and witness the second destruction of our country. Nor did it appear that there was any need forsooth of a Carthaginian army or general to effect our destruction; but that we might be annihilated by the Turdulans, our most inveterate enemies, who had also been the cause of our former overthrow. When suddenly, to our great surprise, you sent us this Publius Scipio, in seeing whom declared consul, and in having it in our power to carry word back to our countrymen that we have seen it, for on him our hopes and safety entirely rest, we consider ourselves the most fortunate of all the Saguntines. He, when he had taken a great number of the cities of your enemies in Spain, on all occasions separated the Saguntines out of the mass of captives, and sent them back to their country; and lastly, by his arms he reduced to so low a state Turdetania, which harboured such animosity against us, that if that nation continued to flourish it was impossible that Saguntum could stand, that it not only was not an object of fear to us, but, and may I say it without incurring odium, not even to our posterity. We see the city of those persons demolished, to gratify whom Hannibal destroyed Saguntum. We receive tribute from their lands, which is not more acceptable to us from the advantage we derive from it than from revenge. In consideration of these benefits, than which we could not hope or wish for greater from the immortal gods, the senate and people of Saguntum have sent us ten ambassadors to you to return their thanks; and at the same time to offer you their congratulations on your having carried on your operations in Spain and Italy so successfully of late years, that you have subdued by your arms, and have gotten possession of Spain, not only as far as the river Iberus, but also to where the ocean forms the limit of the remotest regions of the world; while in Italy you have left nothing to the Carthaginian except so much space as the rampart of his camp encloses. We have been desired, not only to return thanks for these blessings to Jove most good and great, the guardian deity of the capitoline citadel, but also, if you should permit us, to carry into the Capitol this present of a golden crown in token of victory. We request that you would permit us so to do; and, if you think proper, that you would, by your authority, perpetuate and ratify the advantages which your generals have conferred upon us." The senate replied to the Saguntines, "that the destruction and restoration of Saguntum would form a monument to all the nations of the world of social faith preserved on both sides. That, in restoring Saguntum, and rescuing its citizens from slavery, their generals had acted properly, regularly, and according to the wishes of the senate; and that, whatever other acts of kindness they had done to them, were in conformity with the wishes of the senate. That they gave them permission to deposit their present in the Capitol." Orders were then given to furnish the ambassadors with apartments and entertainment, and that not less than ten thousand asses should be given to each as a present. After this, the rest of the embassies were introduced and heard. On the request of the Saguntines that they might go and take a view of Italy as far as they could with safety, they were furnished with guides, and letters were sent to the several towns, requiring them to entertain the Spaniards kindly. The senate then took into consideration the state of public affairs, the levying troops, and the provinces.

He then brought the Saguntine ambassadors into the senate, and the eldest spoke: "Although we have endured every kind of suffering to remain loyal to you, conscript fathers, we do not regret the hardships we have faced because of the benefits we have received from you and your generals. You went to war for our sake, and you have fought on for fourteen years with such determination that you have both suffered and driven the Carthaginians to their limits. While you were engaged in a brutal war in Italy against Hannibal, you sent a consul with an army to Spain to gather what was left of us. Publius and Cneius Cornelius, once they entered the province, always took actions that benefited us and hurt our enemies. First, they restored our town and sent people to find our countrymen who had been sold and scattered throughout Spain, freeing them from slavery. When our situation improved from being dire to almost hopeful, we mourned the loss of your generals, Publius and Cneius Cornelius, even more than you did. It felt like we were being pulled back to our homeland just to suffer again and witness the second destruction of our city. It seemed unnecessary for a Carthaginian army to destroy us; we were at risk of being wiped out by the Turdulans, our bitter enemies who were responsible for our previous downfall. Then, unexpectedly, you sent us Publius Scipio, and seeing him as consul, knowing we could inform our fellow Saguntines of his presence—on whom our hopes and safety depend—made us feel like the luckiest Saguntines. He captured many enemy cities in Spain and consistently freed Saguntines from captivity, sending them back to their homeland. Ultimately, he defeated Turdetania, which harbored deep hatred for us, to the point that if that nation thrived, Saguntum could not survive. Now, we see their city in ruins, the same city for which Hannibal destroyed Saguntum. We gain tribute from their lands, which we appreciate both for what it brings us and for the revenge it represents. In light of these blessings, for which we could not hope for more from the gods, the senate and people of Saguntum have sent us ten ambassadors to express their gratitude and congratulate you on your successful campaigns in Spain and Italy, where you have subdued the Carthaginians and gained control of Spain all the way to the Iberus River and the ocean’s farthest reaches, leaving them with nothing in Italy except the territory within their camp's walls. We have been asked not only to thank Jupiter, the guardian of the Capitol, but also, if permitted, to bring a gift of a golden crown to the Capitol as a symbol of victory. We request your permission to do this, and if you agree, we would like you to formally recognize the benefits your generals have given us." The senate responded to the Saguntines, stating, "The ruin and restoration of Saguntum will serve as a testament to the loyalty maintained by both sides. By rebuilding Saguntum and freeing its citizens, your generals acted properly and in line with the senate's wishes. Their other acts of kindness have also been in accordance with our desires. You are permitted to present your gift at the Capitol." Orders were then given to accommodate the ambassadors and provide them with hospitality, granting each of them no less than ten thousand asses as a gift. After this, the rest of the embassies were introduced and heard. At the request of the Saguntines, who wished to explore Italy safely, guides were provided, and letters were sent to various towns, instructing them to treat the Spaniards well. The senate then considered the state of public affairs, troop levies, and provincial matters.

40

It being generally reported that Africa, as a new province, was destined for Publius Scipio without casting lots; and he himself, not content with any moderate share of glory, asserting that he had been declared consul, not only for prosecuting, but for finishing the war; that that object could not be accomplished by any other means than by his transporting an army into Africa; and himself openly declaring that he would do it through the people if the senate opposed him; the design by no means pleased the principal senators; and when the rest, either through fear or a wish to ingratiate themselves with him, only murmured, Quintus Fabius Maximus, being asked his opinion, thus spoke: "I know, conscript fathers, that by many of you the question which is this day agitated is considered as already determined; and that the man who shall deliver his sentiments on the subject of making Africa a province, as a new proposal, will speak to little purpose. But, in the first place, I cannot see how it can be considered as determined, that Africa shall be the province of the consul, that brave and active officer, when neither the senate have voted nor the people ordered that it should be constituted a province this year. In the next place, if it is determined, I think the consul is to blame, who, by pretending to consult the senate on a question already decided, insults that body, and not the senator only who delivers his sentiments in his place on the subject of deliberation. Now I am well aware, that by disapproving of this excessive eagerness to pass over into Africa, I subject myself to two imputations: one grounded on the caution inherent in my disposition, which young men may if they please call cowardice and sloth, so long as we have the consolation to reflect, that though hitherto the measures of others have always appeared on the first view of them the more plausible, mine on experience have proved the sounder. The other imputation is that of jealousy and envy towards the daily increasing glory of this most valiant consul. But if neither my past life and character, nor a dictatorship, together with five consulships, and so much glory acquired, both in peace and war, that I am more likely to loathe it than desire more, exempt me from such a suspicion, let my age at least acquit me. For what rivalry can there exist between myself and a man who is not equal in years even to my son? When I was dictator, when as yet in the possession of full vigour, and engaged in a series of affairs of the utmost magnitude, no one heard me, either in the senate or in the popular assembly, express any reluctance to have the command equally shared between myself and the master of the horse, at the time when he was maligning me; a proposition which no one ever heard mention of before. I chose to bring it about by actions rather than by words, that he who was placed on the same footing with me in the judgment of others, should soon by his own confession declare me his superior. Much less, after having passed through these honours, would I propose to myself to enter the lists of competition and rivalry with a man in the very bloom of youth. And that, forsooth, in order that Africa, if it shall have been denied to him, may be assigned as a province to me, who am now weary of life, and not merely of active employments. I must live and die with that share of glory which I have already acquired. I prevented Hannibal from conquering, in order that he might even be conquered by you, whose powers are now in full vigour.

It is generally understood that Africa, as a new province, was meant for Publius Scipio without a lottery deciding it; and he himself, not satisfied with just a moderate amount of glory, claimed that he had been elected consul not only to start but to finish the war; that this goal could only be achieved by leading an army into Africa; and he openly stated that he would pursue this with the support of the people if the senate opposed him. This plan did not sit well with the leading senators; and while the others either feared him or wanted to win his favor and only murmured, Quintus Fabius Maximus, when asked for his opinion, said: "I know, conscript fathers, that many of you believe the issue we are debating today is already decided; and that anyone who speaks on the proposal to make Africa a province is not going to be very effective. But first, I fail to see how it can be seen as settled that Africa will be the province of the consul, that brave and dynamic officer, when neither the senate has voted on it nor the people ordered it to be established as a province this year. Secondly, if it is settled, I believe the consul is at fault, who, by claiming to consult the senate on a question that is already resolved, insults that body, and not only the senator who expresses his opinion on the matter at hand. Now, I am well aware that by opposing this intense desire to head to Africa, I open myself up to two accusations: one based on my natural caution, which young people may label as cowardice and laziness, as long as we take comfort in knowing that while the actions of others may seem more appealing at first glance, mine have proven to be wiser through experience. The other accusation is jealousy and envy towards the growing fame of this most courageous consul. But if neither my past experiences and reputation, nor my status as a dictator alongside five consulships, and the significant glory I have gained in both peace and war, which makes me more likely to feel burdened by it than to seek more, exempt me from such suspicion, then let my age at least set me free from it. What competition could there be between myself and a man who is not even as old as my son? When I was a dictator, still in my prime, managing crucial affairs, no one heard me, in the senate or the popular assembly, voice any reluctance to share command equally with the master of the horse, at the time when he was attacking me; a suggestion no one had ever heard before. I chose to let my actions speak instead of words, so that the man deemed my equal by others would soon, by his own admission, recognize me as his superior. Much less would I, after achieving these honors, intend to compete against a man in the prime of his youth. And that, indeed, so that Africa, if it is denied to him, can be granted to me, who am now tired of life, not just of active roles. I must live and die with the share of glory I have already earned. I stopped Hannibal from conquering so that he could be defeated by you, whose strengths are now at their peak.

41

"It is but fair, Publius Cornelius, that you should pardon me, if I, who in my own case never preferred the honour of men to the interest of the state, do not place even your fame before the public good. Although, if there were either no war in Italy, or an enemy of such a description that no glory could be acquired from conquering him, the man who would retain you in Italy, though actuated by a desire to promote the public good, might appear to wish to deprive you of an opportunity of acquiring renown when he objected to your removing the war. But since Hannibal is our antagonist, who is besieging Italy for now the fourteenth year, with an army unimpaired, will you have reason to be dissatisfied, Publius Cornelius, with the glory you will acquire, if you in your consulate shall drive out of Italy an enemy who has been the cause of so many deaths and so many disasters to us, and if you should enjoy the distinction of having terminated this, as Caius Lutatius did the former Punic war? Unless either Hamilcar is a general more worthy of consideration than Hannibal, or a war in Africa of more importance, or a victory there greater and more glorious, (should it be our lot to be victorious while you are consul,) than one here. Would you rather have drawn away Hamilcar from Drepanum and Eryx than have expelled the Carthaginians and Hannibal from Italy? Although you naturally prize more highly the renown which you have acquired than that which you hope for, yet surely you would not boast more of having freed Spain from war than of having freed Italy. Hannibal is not as yet in such a state as that the man who prefers another war would not appear to have feared rather than to have despised him. Why then do you not apply yourself to this, and carry the war in a straightforward manner to the place where Hannibal is, rather than pursue that circuitous course, according to which you expect that when you shall have crossed over into Africa Hannibal will follow you thither? Do you seek to obtain the distinguished honour of having finished the Punic war? After you have defended your own possessions, for this is naturally the first object, then proceed to attack those of others. Let there be peace in Italy before war in Africa; and let us be free from fear ourselves before we bring it upon others. If it is possible that both objects may be accomplished under your conduct and auspices, having first conquered Hannibal here, then go and lay siege to Carthage; but if one or other of these conquests must be left for the succeeding consuls, the former is both the greater and more glorious, and also the cause of the second. For now indeed, besides that the treasury is not able to maintain two different armies, one in Italy and one in Africa; besides that we nave nothing left from which we may equip fleets or be able to furnish provisions, who knows not how great danger would be incurred? Publius Licinius will wage war in Italy, Publius Scipio in Africa. What if, (an omen which may all the gods avert, and which my mind shrinks back with alarm from mentioning,--but what has happened may happen again,--) what I say, if Hannibal, having gained a victory, should advance to the city? Shall we then at length send for you, our consul, out of Africa, as we formerly sent for Quintus Fulvius from Capua? What shall we say when we consider that in Africa also both parties will be liable to the chances of war? Let your own house, your father and your uncle, slain together with their armies within the space of thirty days, after that, having spent several years in the performance of the most important services, both by sea and land, they had inspired foreign nations with the highest reverence for the name of the Roman people and your family, be a warning to you. The day would fail me were I disposed to enumerate the kings and generals who have brought the most signal calamities upon themselves and their armies by rashly passing into the territories of their enemies. The Athenians, a state distinguished for prudence, leaving a war at home, sent a great fleet into Sicily at the instance of a youth equally enterprising and illustrious; but by one naval battle they reduced their flourishing republic to a state of humiliation from which she could never recover.

"It’s only fair, Publius Cornelius, that you forgive me if I, who have never valued personal glory over the state's interests, don’t prioritize your fame over the public good. However, if there were no war in Italy or an enemy who wouldn’t bring glory when defeated, the person keeping you in Italy to promote the public interest might seem to be denying you the chance to gain honor by opposing the war. But since Hannibal is our enemy, besieging Italy for the fourteenth year with an intact army, wouldn’t you be satisfied with the glory you’d earn if, during your consulate, you drive this enemy out of Italy—an enemy responsible for so much death and disaster for us—and enjoy the distinction of ending this conflict, just as Caius Lutatius did with the previous Punic War? Unless Hamilcar is a more significant general than Hannibal or a war in Africa of greater importance, or if there's a greater victory to be had there than here. Would you rather have distracted Hamilcar from Drepanum and Eryx than have expelled Hannibal and the Carthaginians from Italy? Though you naturally value the reputation you’ve earned more than the one you hope for, you surely wouldn’t brag more about freeing Spain from war than freeing Italy. Hannibal isn’t in a position where preferring a different war wouldn’t look like fear rather than disdain for him. So why don’t you focus on this and take the fight directly to Hannibal instead of taking a roundabout approach, hoping that he’ll follow you into Africa after you cross over? Do you aim to earn the distinguished honor of ending the Punic War? After defending your own territory, which should be your top priority, then move to attack others'. Let there be peace in Italy before there's war in Africa, and let us be secure ourselves before we bring danger to others. If both objectives can be achieved under your leadership—defeating Hannibal here first, then laying siege to Carthage—then great. But if one of these conquests must be left for future consuls, the first is the bigger and more glorious one and leads to the second. Right now, besides the treasury not being able to support two separate armies—one in Italy and one in Africa—and without resources to equip fleets or supply provisions, who doesn’t see the huge danger involved? Publius Licinius will fight in Italy, and Publius Scipio in Africa. What if, (may the gods prevent this omen, and it’s something I dread to even mention, yet what has happened could happen again)—what if Hannibal, after a victory, advances on the city? Will we then send for you, our consul, from Africa, as we once called Quintus Fulvius from Capua? What can we say when we consider that in Africa both sides would still face the risks of war? Let the deaths of your own father and uncle, killed along with their armies within thirty days after years of serving both at sea and on land, and having earned the highest respect from foreign nations for the Roman people and your family, serve as a warning. I would run out of time if I tried to list the kings and generals who faced terrible calamities for rushing into enemy territories. The Athenians, known for their cautiousness, left a war at home to send a large fleet to Sicily at the urging of a daring and well-known young man; but a single naval battle reduced their once-flourishing republic to a state of humiliation from which it could never recover."

42

"But I am adducing foreign and too remote examples. That same Africa, and Marcus Atilius, who was a signal example of both extremes of fortune, may form a warning to us. Without doubt, Publius Cornelius, when you shall have a view of Africa from the sea, the reduction of your province of Spain will appear to you to have been a mere matter of sport and pastime. For what similarity is there between them? After sailing along the coast of Italy and Gaul to Emporiae without any enemy to oppose you, you brought your fleet to land at a city of our allies. There landing your soldiers, you marched them through countries entirely secure from danger to Tarraco, to join the allies and friends of the Roman people. After that, from Tarraco you marched through places garrisoned by Roman troops. On the banks of the Iberus were the armies of your father and your uncle, rendered still more furious after the loss of their generals, even by the very calamity they had suffered. The general, indeed, Lucius Marcius, had been irregularly constituted and chosen for the time by the suffrages of the soldiers; but had he been adorned with noble birth and the regular gradation of preferment, he would have been equal to the most distinguished generals, from his skill in every art of war. You then laid siege to Carthage, quite at your leisure, not one of the three Punic armies coming to the defence of their allies. The rest of your achievements, nor do I wish to disparage them, are by no means to be compared with what you will have to do in a war in Africa, where there is not a single harbour open to receive our fleet, no part of the country at peace with us, no state in alliance, no king in friendship with us, no room in any part either to take up a position or to advance. Whichever way you turn your eyes, all is hostility and danger. Do you trust in the Numidians and Syphax? Let it suffice to have trusted in them once. Temerity is not always successful, and the fraudulent usually pave the way to confidence in small matters, that when an advantageous opportunity occurs, they may deceive with great gain. Your father and uncle were not cut off by the arms of their enemies till they were duped by the treachery of their Celtiberian allies; nor were you yourself exposed to so much danger from Mago and Hasdrubal, the generals of your enemies, as from Indibilis and Mandonius, whom you had received into friendship. Can you place any confidence in Numidians after having experienced a defection in your own soldiers? Syphax and Masinissa would rather that they themselves should have the rule in Africa than the Carthaginians, but that the Carthaginians should rather than any other state. At present emulation and the various causes of dispute existing between them incite them against each other, because the fear of any foreign enemy is remote. But show them the Roman arms and a body of troops, natives of another country, and they will run together as if to extinguish a common conflagration. These same Carthaginians defended Spain in a different manner from that in which they will defend the walls of their capital, the temples of their gods, their altars, and their hearths; when their terrified wives will attend them on the way to the battle, and their little children will run to them. What, moreover, if the Carthaginians, feeling sufficiently secure in the harmony subsisting in Africa, in the attachment of the sovereigns in alliance with them, and their own fortifications, should, when they see Italy deprived of the support of yourself and your army, themselves assuming an offensive attitude, either send a fresh army out of Africa into Italy, or order Mago, who, it is certain, having passed over from the Baleares, is now sailing along the coast of Liguria and the Alps, to form a junction with Hannibal. Without doubt, we should be thrown into the same state of alarm as we were lately, when Hasdrubal passed over into Italy; that Hasdrubal, whom you, who are about to blockade, not Carthage only, but all Africa with your army, allowed to slip out of your hands into Italy. You will say that he was conquered by you. For that very reason I should be less willing, not on account of the commonwealth only, but of yourself, that, after having been defeated, he should be allowed to march into Italy. Suffer us to ascribe to your prudence all the successful events which have happened to you and the empire of the Roman people, and to impute all those of an adverse nature to the uncertain chances of war and to fortune. The more meritorious and brave you are, so much the more do your country and all Italy desire to retain you as their protector. You cannot even yourself pretend to deny, that where Hannibal is, there is the head and principal stress of the war, for you profess, that your motive in crossing over into Africa is to draw Hannibal thither. Whether, therefore, here or there, it is with Hannibal that you will have to contend. Will you then, I pray, have more power in Africa and alone, or here, with your own and your colleague's army united? Is not the great difference which this makes proved to you even by the recent precedent of Claudius and Livius, the consuls? What! will Hannibal, who has now for a long time been unavailingly soliciting succours from home, be rendered more powerful in men and arms when occupying the remotest corner of the Bruttian territory, or when near to Carthage and supported by all Africa? What sort of policy is that of yours, to prefer fighting where your own forces will be diminished by one half, and the enemy's greatly augmented, to encountering the enemy when you will have two armies against one, and that wearied with so many battles, and so protracted and laborious a service? Consider how far this policy of yours corresponds with that of your parent. He, setting out in his consulship for Spain, returned from his province into Italy, that he might meet Hannibal on his descent from the Alps; while you are going to leave Italy when Hannibal is there, not because you consider such a course beneficial to the state, but because you think it will redound to your own honour and glory; acting in the same manner as you did when leaving your province and your army without the sanction of a law, without a decree of the senate, you, a general of the Roman people, intrusted to two ships the fortune of the commonwealth and the majesty of the empire, which were then hazarded in your person. In my estimation, conscript fathers, Publius Cornelius was elected consul for the service of the state and of us, and not to forward his own individual interest; and the armies were enlisted for the protection of the city and of Italy, and not for the consuls, like kings, to carry into whatever part of the world they please from motives of vanity."

"But I'm bringing up foreign and very distant examples. That same Africa, along with Marcus Atilius, who exemplifies the highs and lows of fortune, should serve as a warning to us. Without a doubt, Publius Cornelius, when you catch sight of Africa from the sea, the conquest of your province in Spain will seem like just a game. What similarities exist between them? After sailing along the coasts of Italy and Gaul to Emporiae without encountering any enemies, you landed your fleet at an allied city. There, you disembarked your soldiers and marched them through completely safe territories to Tarraco, to join the allies and friends of Rome. After that, from Tarraco you traveled through areas protected by Roman forces. Along the Iberus were the armies of your father and uncle, even more furious after losing their generals, fueled by their recent calamity. True, Lucius Marcius had been irregularly appointed and was chosen for the moment by the soldiers’ votes; but had he been of noble birth and risen through the ranks properly, he would have ranked among the greatest generals because of his skill in all aspects of warfare. You then laid siege to Carthage at your leisure, with none of the three Punic armies coming to defend their allies. As for your other achievements, I don’t intend to downplay them, but they cannot compare to what you will face in a war in Africa, where there isn't a single harbor available for our fleet, no part of the country is at peace with us, no state is allied with us, no king is on our side, and there is no place to establish a base or advance. Wherever you look, there is hostility and danger. Do you place your trust in the Numidians and Syphax? One instance of trust is enough. Recklessness doesn’t always pay off, and deceptive individuals often lead to confidence in small matters so that when an opportunity arises, they can deceive with significant gain. Your father and uncle were not defeated by enemy forces until they were betrayed by their Celtiberian allies; nor have you faced as much danger from Mago and Hasdrubal, your enemy's generals, as you have from Indibilis and Mandonius, whom you welcomed as friends. Can you trust the Numidians after experiencing a betrayal from your own soldiers? Syphax and Masinissa would rather rule Africa themselves than let the Carthaginians hold power, but they prefer the Carthaginians over any other state. Right now, competition and various disputes between them drive them against each other because the threat of a foreign enemy feels far away. But show them Roman arms and troops from another land, and they will rush together like it's an emergency. The Carthaginians defended Spain differently than they will defend the walls of their capital, the temples of their gods, their altars, and their homes; when their frightened wives follow them into battle, and their little children rush to them. Moreover, what if the Carthaginians, feeling secure in their harmony within Africa, in the loyalty of the allied kings, and their own fortifications, see Italy stripped of your presence and your army, and then take an offensive stance, sending a new army from Africa to Italy, or ordering Mago, who has certainly moved from the Baleares and is now along the coast of Liguria and the Alps, to join forces with Hannibal. We would undoubtedly be thrown into the same panic we felt recently when Hasdrubal crossed into Italy; that Hasdrubal whom you, intending to blockade not just Carthage but all of Africa with your army, let slip from your grasp into Italy. You will argue that he was defeated by you. For that very reason, I’m even less willing—out of concern for not only the state but for you—that after being defeated, he should be allowed to march into Italy. Let us attribute all your successful events and those of the Roman empire to your wisdom, and all adverse outcomes to the unpredictable nature of war and fortune. The more worthy and courageous you prove, the more your country and all of Italy wish to keep you as their protector. You cannot even deny that wherever Hannibal is, there lies the focus and main force of the war, for you claim that your reason for going to Africa is to bring Hannibal there. So whether it’s here or there, you’ll be contending with Hannibal. Tell me, will you have more power in Africa, alone, or here, with both your army and your colleague’s united? Isn’t the significant difference evident even from the recent example of Consuls Claudius and Livius? What? Will Hannibal, who has been fruitlessly seeking help from home for a long time, become stronger in men and arms while stuck in the farthest corner of Bruttian territory, or when he’s near Carthage supported by all of Africa? What kind of strategy is it to choose to fight where your forces will be halved and the enemy's greatly increased, rather than facing them when you’ll have two armies against one, and one that’s exhausted from so many battles and drawn-out service? Think about how this strategy aligns with your father’s. He, setting off in his consulship for Spain, returned from his province to Italy so he could confront Hannibal as he came down from the Alps; while you plan to leave Italy when Hannibal is there, not because you see this as beneficial for the state, but because you believe it will enhance your own honor and glory; acting in the same way you did when you left your province and your army without legal authority, without a decree from the senate, you, a general of the Roman people, entrusted the fate of the commonwealth and the honor of the empire, which were then at risk in your person, to two ships. In my view, conscript fathers, Publius Cornelius was chosen consul to serve the state and us, not to further his own personal interests; and the armies were raised to protect the city and Italy, not for the consuls, like kings, to take to whichever part of the world they please out of vanity."

43

Fabius having made a strong impression on a large portion of the senate, and especially those advanced in years, by this speech, which was adapted to the occasion, and also by his authority and his long-established reputation for prudence; and those who approved of the counsel of this old man being more numerous than those who commended the hot spirit of the young one; Scipio is reported thus to have spoken: "Even Quintus Fabius himself has observed, conscript fathers, in the commencement of his speech, that in the opinion he gave a feeling of jealousy might be suspected. And though I dare not myself charge so great a man with harbouring that feeling, yet, whether it is owing to a defect in his language, or to the fact, that suspicion has certainly not been removed. For he has so magnified his own honours and the fame of his exploits, in order to do away with the imputation of envy, that it would appear I am in danger of being rivalled by every obscure person, but not by himself, because, as he enjoys an eminence above every body else, an eminence to which I do not dissemble that I also aspire, he is unwilling that I should be placed upon a level with him. He has represented himself as an old man, and as one who has gone through every gradation of honour, and me as below the age even of his son; as if he supposed that the desire of glory did not exceed the limits of human life, and as if its chief part had not respect to memory and future ages. I am confident, that it is usual with all the most exalted minds, to compare themselves, not only with the illustrious men of the present, but of every age. For my own part, I do not dissemble that I am desirous, not only to attain to the share of glory which you possess, Quintus Fabius, but, (and in saying it I mean no offence,) if I can, even to exceed it. Let not such a feeling exist in your mind towards me, nor in mine towards those who are my juniors, as that we should be unwilling that any of our countrymen should attain to the same celebrity with ourselves; for that would be a detriment, not to those only who may be the objects of our envy, but to the state, and almost to the whole human race. He mentioned what a great degree of danger I should incur, should I cross over into Africa, so that he appeared solicitous on my account, and not only for the state and the army. But whence has this concern for me so suddenly sprung? When my father and uncle were slain; when their two armies were cut up almost to a man; when Spain was lost; when four armies of the Carthaginians and four generals kept possession of every thing by terror and by arms; when a general was sought for to take the command of that war, and no one came forward besides myself, no one had the courage to declare himself a candidate; when the Roman people had conferred the command upon me, though only twenty-four years of age; why was it that no one at that time made any mention of my age, of the strength of the enemy, of the difficulty of the war, and of the recent destruction of my father and uncle? Has some greater disaster been suffered in Africa now than had at that time befallen us in Spain? Are there now larger armies in Africa, more and better generals, than were then in Spain? Was my age then more mature for conducting a war than now? Can a war with a Carthaginian enemy be carried on with greater convenience in Spain than in Africa? After having routed and put to flight four Carthaginian armies; after having captured by force, or reduced to submission by fear, so many cities; after having entirely subdued every thing as far as the ocean, so many petty princes, so many savage nations; after having regained possession of the whole of Spain, so that no trace of war remains, it is an easy matter to make light of my services; just as easy as it would be, should I return victorious from Africa, to make light of those very circumstances which are now magnified in order that they may appear formidable, for the purpose of detaining me here. He says that there is no possibility of entering Africa; that there are no ports open. He mentions that Marcus Atilius was taken prisoner in Africa, as if Marcus Atilius had miscarried on his first access to Africa. Nor does he recollect that the ports of Africa were open to that very commander, unfortunate as he was; that he performed some brilliant services during the first year, and continued undefeated to the last, so far as related to the Carthaginian generals. You will not, therefore, in the least deter me by that example of yours. If that disaster had been sustained in the present, and not in the former war, if lately, and not forty years ago, yet why would it be less advisable for me to cross over into Africa after Regulus had been made prisoner there, than into Spain after the Scipios had been slain there? I should be reluctant to admit that the birth of Xanthippus the Lacedaemonian was more fortunate for Carthage than mine for my country. My confidence would be increased by the very circumstance, that such important consequences depended upon the valour of one man. But further, we must take warning by the Athenians, who inconsiderately crossed over into Sicily, leaving a war in their own country. Why, therefore, since you have leisure to relate Grecian tales, do you not rather set before us the instance of Agathocles, king of Syracuse, who, when Sicily was for a long time wasted by a Punic war, by passing over into this same Africa, removed the war to the country from whence it came.

Fabius made a strong impression on a big part of the senate, especially the older members, with his speech, which was suited for the occasion, as well as his authority and long-standing reputation for wisdom. Those who supported the advice of the old man outnumbered those who praised the fiery spirit of the younger one. Scipio is reported to have said: "Even Quintus Fabius himself noted, conscript fathers, at the start of his speech, that his opinion might be suspected of including some jealousy. And while I don’t dare to accuse such a great man of that feeling, whether it comes from a flaw in his wording or the fact that suspicion hasn’t really been cleared. He has boasted so much about his own honors and achievements to dismiss any idea of envy that it makes it seem I'm at risk of being outshined by everyone who's unknown, but not by him, since he holds a position higher than everyone else, a position that I won’t hide I also aspire to, and he doesn’t want me to be seen as his equal. He portrayed himself as an old man who has climbed every level of honor, and me as someone younger than even his son; as if he believed that the desire for glory was limited to one’s lifetime, and that its main part was about being remembered in future ages. I'm sure it’s common for the greatest minds to measure themselves against not just the famous people of today but of every era. For my part, I’m honest about wanting not just to achieve the same level of glory that you hold, Quintus Fabius, but if I can, even to surpass it. Let’s not harbor feelings towards each other, or towards those younger than us, that prevent any of our fellow citizens from reaching the same fame as us; that would harm not only those who might be the targets of our envy but also the state, and almost all of humanity. He talked about the significant danger I’d face if I went to Africa, so it seemed he was concerned for me and not just for the state and the army. But where did this sudden concern for me come from? When my father and uncle were killed; when their two armies were nearly wiped out; when Spain was lost; when four Carthaginian armies and four generals terrorized everything; when a general was needed to lead that war, and I was the only one willing to step up; when the Roman people gave me command, even though I was only twenty-four; why didn’t anyone mention my age, the strength of the enemy, the difficulty of the war, or the recent deaths of my father and uncle back then? Has any worse disaster happened in Africa now than what we faced in Spain then? Are there now bigger armies in Africa, or more competent generals, than there were in Spain at that time? Was I then more mature for leading a war than I am now? Can a war against the Carthaginians be fought more easily in Spain than in Africa? After defeating and routing four Carthaginian armies; after capturing or scaring so many cities into submission; after completely conquering all the way to the ocean, so many small kings, so many savage nations; after taking back all of Spain so that there's no trace of war left, it’s easy to downplay my efforts; just as easy as it would be, if I returned victorious from Africa, to downplay those very things that are now exaggerated to seem intimidating, to keep me here. He claims there’s no way to enter Africa; that all ports are closed. He mentions that Marcus Atilius was captured in Africa, as if Marcus Atilius had failed on his first attempt to get to Africa. He forgets that the ports of Africa were open to that commander, unfortunate as he was; that he had some impressive successes during the first year and remained undefeated until the end, at least when it came to the Carthaginian generals. You won’t deter me at all with that example. If that disaster had happened now, rather than in the previous war; if it had just happened, rather than forty years ago, why would it be less wise for me to go to Africa after Regulus was captured there than to go to Spain after the Scipios had been killed there? I can’t accept that the birth of Xanthippus the Lacedaemonian was luckier for Carthage than mine has been for my country. My confidence would actually grow from the fact that such important outcomes depend on the bravery of one person. Yet, we should also learn from the Athenians, who recklessly went to Sicily, leaving a war going on in their own territory. So why, since you have time to share Greek stories, don’t you instead tell us about Agathocles, king of Syracuse, who, when Sicily was devastated by a Punic war, crossed into this same Africa and brought the war back to where it started?"

44

"But what need is there of ancient and foreign examples to remind us what sort of thing it is boldly to carry terror against an enemy, and, removing the danger from oneself, to bring another into peril? Can there be a stronger instance than Hannibal himself, or one more to the point? It makes a great difference whether you devastate the territories of another, or see your own destroyed by fire and sword. He who brings danger upon another has more spirit than he who repels it. Add to this, that the terror excited by unknown circumstances is increased on that account. When you have entered the territory of an enemy, you may have a near view of his advantages and disadvantages. Hannibal did not expect that it would come to pass that so many of the states in Italy would come over to him as did so after the defeat at Cannae. How much less would any firmness or constancy be experienced in Africa by the Carthaginians, who are themselves faithless allies, oppressive and haughty masters! Besides, we, even when deserted by our allies, stood firm in our own strength, the Roman soldiery. The Carthaginians possess no native strength. The soldiers they have are obtained by hire;--Africans and Numidians--people remarkable above all others for the inconstancy of their attachments. Provided no impediment arises here, you will hear at once that I have landed, and that Africa is blazing with war; that Hannibal is preparing for his departure from this country, and that Carthage is besieged. Expect more frequent and more joyful despatches from Africa than you received from Spain. The considerations on which I ground my anticipations are the good fortune of the Roman people, the gods, the witnesses of the treaty violated by the enemy, the kings Syphax and Masinissa; on whose fidelity I will rely in such a manner as that I may be secure from danger should they prove perfidious. Many things which are not now apparent, at this distance, the war will develope; and it is the part of a man, and a general, not to be wanting when fortune presents itself, and to bend its events to his designs. I shall, Quintus Fabius, have the opponent you assign me, Hannibal; but I shall rather draw him after me than be kept here by him. I will compel him to fight in his own country, and Carthage shall be the prize of victory rather than the half-ruined forts of the Bruttians. With regard to providing that the state sustain no injury in the mean time, while I am crossing over, while I am landing my troops in Africa, while I am advancing my camp to the walls of Carthage; be not too sure that it is not an insult to Publius Licinius, the consul, a man of consummate valour, who did not draw lots for so distant a province merely that, as he was chief pontiff, he might not be absent from religious affairs, to say that he is unable to do that, now that the power of Hannibal is shaken, and in a manner shattered, which you Quintus Fabius, were able to effect when he was flying victorious throughout all Italy. By Hercules, even if the war would not be more speedily terminated by adopting the plan I propose, yet it were consistent with the dignity of the Roman people, and the high character they enjoy with foreign kings and nations, to appear to have had spirit not only to defend Italy, but also to carry hostilities into Africa; and that it should not be supposed and spread abroad that no Roman general dared what Hannibal had dared; that in the former Punic war, when the contest was about Sicily, Africa should have been so often attacked by our fleets and armies, and that now, when the contest is about Italy, Africa should be left undisturbed. Let Italy, which has so long been harassed, at length enjoy some repose; let Africa, in her turn, be fired and devastated. Let the Roman camp overhang the gates of Carthage rather than that we should again behold the rampart of the enemy from our walls. Let Africa be the seat of the remainder of the war. Let terror and flight, the devastation of lands, the defection of allies, and all the other calamities of war which have fallen upon us, through a period of fourteen years, be turned upon her. It is sufficient for me to have spoken on those matters which relate to the state, the war before us, and the provinces which form the subject of deliberation. My discourse would be tedious and uninteresting to you if, as Fabius has depreciated my services in Spain, I should also in like manner endeavour, on the other hand, to turn his glory into ridicule, and make the most of my own. I will do neither, conscript fathers; and if in nothing else, though a young man, I shall certainly have shown my superiority over this old man, in modesty and the government of my tongue. Such has been my life, and such the services I have performed, that I can gladly rest contented in silence with that opinion which you have spontaneously conceived of me."

"But what do we need ancient and foreign examples for to remind us of what it means to boldly bring fear to an enemy while keeping ourselves safe and putting someone else in danger? Is there a stronger example than Hannibal himself? It matters a lot whether you destroy another's land or see your own devastated. The person who puts someone else in danger shows more courage than the person who defends themselves. On top of that, fear caused by unknown circumstances can increase anxiety. When you invade enemy territory, you can clearly see their strengths and weaknesses. Hannibal didn’t expect so many states in Italy to join him after the defeat at Cannae. How much less stability would the Carthaginians show in Africa, being untrustworthy allies and arrogant masters! Besides, even when our allies abandon us, we, the Roman soldiers, remain strong. The Carthaginians lack any real strength. Their soldiers are mercenaries—Africans and Numidians—known for their fickle loyalties. As long as nothing unexpected happens, you will soon hear that I've landed and that Africa is in flames from war; that Hannibal is getting ready to leave this country, and that Carthage is under siege. Expect more frequent and more positive updates from Africa than you got from Spain. The grounds for my expectations are the good fortune of the Roman people, the gods—witnesses to the treaty broken by the enemy—and the kings Syphax and Masinissa, on whose loyalty I will rely to keep me safe from danger if they turn out to be untrustworthy. Many things we can’t see from afar will unfold in the war; and it’s the mark of a man and a general to seize opportunities when they arise and to shape outcomes to fit his plans. I will face the opponent you set for me, Hannibal; but I will lead him rather than be held back by him. I’ll force him to fight on his own soil, and Carthage will be the prize of victory rather than the half-destroyed forts of the Bruttians. Regarding ensuring that the state suffers no harm while I am crossing over, landing my troops in Africa, and moving my camp to the walls of Carthage; don’t assume that it’s insulting to Publius Licinius, the consul, a man of outstanding valor, just because he didn’t draw lots for such a distant province only to be present at religious events; it implies he’s incapable of acting now that Hannibal’s power is shaken and essentially broken, which you, Quintus Fabius, managed when he was triumphing throughout all Italy. By Hercules, even if my proposed plan doesn’t end the war any faster, it would still uphold the dignity of the Roman people and preserve their esteemed reputation with foreign kings and nations to appear spirited enough to not only defend Italy but also to take the fight to Africa; that it shouldn’t be assumed and spread that no Roman general dared what Hannibal did; that during the first Punic war, when the contest was over Sicily, Africa was attacked often by our fleets and armies, and now, with the struggle over Italy, Africa should be left untouched. Let Italy, which has suffered for so long, finally find some peace; let Africa, in turn, be set ablaze and destroyed. Let the Roman camp loom over the gates of Carthage rather than us seeing the enemy’s ramparts from our own walls. Let Africa be where the remainder of the war takes place. Let terror and flight, land devastation, ally defections, and all the other calamities of war that have befallen us over the past fourteen years be directed at her. It’s enough for me to have discussed matters related to the state, the war ahead, and the provinces under consideration. My speech would become tedious and uninteresting if, as Fabius has minimized my efforts in Spain, I tried to mock his accomplishments in return and boast of my own. I will do neither, esteemed senators; and if in no other regard, even though I am young, I will certainly show my superiority over this old man in humility and restraint. This has been my life, and this is the service I have rendered; I can gladly remain silent, content with the high regard you have formed of me."

45

Scipio was heard less favourably, because, a report had been spread that, if he did not prevail with the senate to have Africa decreed to him as his province, he would immediately lay the matter before the people. Therefore, Quintus Fulvius, who had been consul four times, and censor, requested of the consul that he would openly declare in the senate whether "he submitted to the fathers to decide respecting the provinces; and whether he intended to abide by their determination, or to put it to the people." Scipio having replied that he would act as he thought for the interest of the state, Fulvius then rejoined: "When I asked you the question I was not ignorant of what answer you would give, or how you would act; for you plainly show that you are rather sounding than consulting the senate; and, unless we immediately decree to you the province you wish, have a bill ready (to lay before the people). Therefore," said he, "I require of you, tribunes of the people, to support me in refusing to give my opinion, because, though my recommendation should be adopted, the consul is not disposed to abide by it." An altercation then arose, the consul asserting that it was unfair for the tribunes to interpose so as to prevent any senator from living his opinion in his place on being asked it. The tribunes came to the determination, "that if the consul submit to the senate the question relating to the provinces, whatever the senate decree we shall consider as final, nor will we allow a bill to be proposed to the people on the subject. If he does not submit it to them, we will support any one who shall refuse to deliver his sentiments upon the matter." The consul requested the delay of a day to confer with his colleague. The next day the decision was submitted to the senate. The provinces were assigned in this manner: to one of the consuls Sicily and thirty ships of war, which Caius Servilius had commanded the former year; he was also permitted to cross over into Africa if he conceived it to be for the advantage of the state. To the other consul Bruttium and the war with Hannibal were assigned; with either that army which Lucius Veturius or that which Quintus Caecilius commanded. The two latter were to draw lots, and settle between themselves which should act in Bruttium with the two legions which the consul gave up; and he to whose lot that province fell, was to be continued in command for a year. The other persons also, besides the consuls and praetors, who were to take the command of armies and provinces, were continued in command. It fell to the lot of Quintus Caecilius to carry on the war against Hannibal in Bruttium, together with the consul. The games of Scipio were then celebrated in the presence of a great number of persons, and with the approbation of the spectators. The deputies, Marcus Pomponius Matho and Quintus Catius, sent to Delphi to convey a present out of the spoils taken from Hasdrubal, carried with them a golden crown of two hundred pounds' weight, and representations of the spoils made out of a thousand pounds' weight of silver. Scipio, though he could not obtain leave to levy troops, a point which he did not urge with great eagerness, obtained leave to take with him such as volunteered their services; and also, as he declared that the fleet would not be the occasion of expense to the state, to receive what was furnished by the allies for building fresh ships. First, the states of Etruria engaged to assist the consuls to the utmost of their respective abilities. The people of Caere furnished corn, and provisions of every description, for the crews; the people of Populoni furnished iron; of Tarquinii, cloth for sails; those of Volaterrae, planks for ships, and corn; those of Arretium, thirty thousand shields, as many helmets; and of javelins, Gallic darts, and long spears, they undertook to make up to the amount of fifty thousand, an equal number of each description, together with as many axes, mattocks, bills, buckets, and mills, as should be sufficient for fifty men of war, with a hundred and twenty thousand pecks of wheat; and to contribute to the support of the decurios and rowers on the voyage. The people of Perusia, Clusium, and Rusella furnished firs for building ships, and a great quantity of corn. Scipio had firs out of the public woods. The states of Umbria, and, besides them, the people of Nursia, Reate, and Amiternum, and all those of the Sabine territory, promised soldiers. Many of the Marsians, Pelignians, and Marrucinians volunteered to serve in the fleet. The Cameritans, as they were joined with the Romans in league on equal terms, sent an armed cohort of six hundred men. Having laid the keels of thirty ships, twenty of which were quinqueremes, and ten quadriremes, he prosecuted the work with such diligence, that, on the forty-fifth day after the materials were taken from the woods, the ships, being fully equipped and armed, were launched.

Scipio was viewed less favorably because a rumor had spread that if he couldn't persuade the Senate to assign Africa as his province, he would immediately bring the matter before the people. Consequently, Quintus Fulvius, who had been consul four times and had served as censor, asked the consul to clearly state in the Senate whether "he was willing to let the fathers decide on the provinces and whether he intended to accept their decision or take it to the people." Scipio responded that he would act in what he believed was the best interest of the state. Fulvius then replied, "When I asked you that question, I was well aware of your answer and your actions; you clearly show you are more interested in testing the waters than genuinely consulting the Senate. Unless we promptly assign you the province you desire, you'll have a bill ready to bring before the people. Therefore," he said, "I ask you, tribunes of the people, to support me in refusing to give my opinion, because even if my recommendation is accepted, the consul isn’t going to follow it." A heated exchange ensued, with the consul arguing that it was unfair for the tribunes to intervene and prevent any senator from sharing his opinion when asked. The tribunes decided, "If the consul submits the question regarding the provinces to the Senate, we will consider whatever the Senate decides as final, and we will not allow a bill on the subject to be proposed to the people. If he does not submit it to them, we will support anyone who refuses to express their views on the matter." The consul requested a day’s delay to consult with his colleague. The following day, the decision was presented to the Senate. The provinces were assigned as follows: to one of the consuls, Sicily and thirty warships, which Caius Servilius had commanded the previous year; he was also allowed to cross into Africa if he thought it would benefit the state. The other consul was assigned Bruttium and the war against Hannibal, commanding either the army led by Lucius Veturius or the one led by Quintus Caecilius. The latter two were to draw lots to determine who would operate in Bruttium with the two legions that the consul relinquished; the person selected would remain in command for a year. Other individuals, besides the consuls and praetors, who were supposed to command armies and provinces were also continued in their roles. Quintus Caecilius was drawn to lead the war against Hannibal in Bruttium alongside the consul. Scipio's games were celebrated in front of a large crowd and received the approval of the spectators. The deputies, Marcus Pomponius Matho and Quintus Catius, sent to Delphi to deliver a gift from the spoils taken from Hasdrubal, brought with them a golden crown weighing two hundred pounds and representations of the spoils made from a thousand pounds of silver. Although Scipio could not get permission to enlist troops—a request he didn't push too hard—he was allowed to take volunteers and, stating that the fleet wouldn’t incur expenses for the state, to accept contributions from allies for building new ships. First, the states of Etruria pledged to assist the consuls to the best of their abilities. The people of Caere provided food and supplies for the crews; the people of Populonia supplied iron; Tarquinii contributed cloth for sails; Volaterrae provided planks for ships and grain; Arretium delivered thirty thousand shields and as many helmets; they also promised to produce up to fifty thousand javelins, Gallic darts, and long spears, as well as an equal number of axes, mattocks, bills, buckets, and mills sufficient for fifty warships, along with one hundred twenty thousand pecks of wheat, and to help support the soldiers and rowers during the voyage. The people of Perusia, Clusium, and Rusella supplied timber for shipbuilding and a large quantity of grain. Scipio also obtained fir trees from the public woods. The states of Umbria, along with those from Nursia, Reate, Amiternum, and all the Sabine territory, promised soldiers. Many from the Marsians, Pelignians, and Marrucinians volunteered to serve in the fleet. The Cameritans, being in equal alliance with the Romans, sent an armed cohort of six hundred men. After laying the keels for thirty ships—twenty quinqueremes and ten quadriremes—he worked so diligently that, on the forty-fifth day after the materials were sourced from the woods, the ships were fully equipped and armed, ready to be launched.

46

He set out into Sicily with thirty ships of war, with about seven thousand volunteers on board. Publius Licinius came into Bruttium to the two consular armies, of which he selected for himself that which Lucius Veturius, the consul, had commanded. He allowed Metellus to continue in the command of those legions which were before under him, concluding that he could act more easily with the troops accustomed to his command. The praetors also went to their different provinces. As there was a scarcity of money to carry on the war, the quaestors were ordered to sell a district of the Campanian territory extending from the Grecian trench to the sea, with permission to receive information as to what land belonged to a native Campanian, in order that it might be put into the possession of the Roman people. The reward fixed upon for the informer was a tenth part of the value of the lands so discovered. Cneius Servilius, the city praetor, was also charged with seeing that the Campanians dwelt where they were allowed, according to the decree of the senate, and to punish such as dwelt anywhere else. The same summer, Mago, son of Amilcar, setting out from the lesser of the Balearian islands, where he had wintered, having put on board his fleet a chosen body of young men, conveyed over into Italy twelve thousand foot, and about two thousand horse, with about thirty ships of war, and a great number of transports. By the suddenness of his arrival he took Genoa, as there were no troops employed in protecting the sea-coast. Thence he brought his fleet to shore, on the coast of the Alpine Ligurians, to see if he could create any commotion there. The Ingaunians, a tribe of the Ligurians, were at that juncture engaged in war with the Epanterians, a people inhabiting the mountains. The Carthaginian, therefore, having deposited his plunder at Savo, an Alpine town, left ten ships of war for its protection. He sent the rest to Carthage to guard the sea-coast, as it was reported that Scipio intended to pass over thither; formed an alliance with the Ingaunians, whose friendship he preferred; and commenced an attack upon the mountaineers. His army increased daily, the Gauls flocking to his standard from all sides, from the splendour of his fame. When the senate received information of these things, by a letter from Spurius Lucretius, they were filled with the most intense anxiety, lest the joy they had experienced on the destruction of Hasdrubal and his army, two years before, should be rendered vain by another war's springing up in the same quarter, equal in magnitude, but under a new leader. They therefore ordered Marcus Livius, proconsul, to march his army of volunteer slaves out of Etruria to Ariminum, and gave in charge to Cneius Servilius to issue orders, if he thought it necessary for the safety of the state, that the city legions should be marched out under the command of any person he thought proper. Marcus Valerius Laevinus led those legions to Arretium. About the same time, as many as eighty transports of the Carthaginians were captured, near Sardinia, by Cneius Octavius, who had the government of that province. Caelius states that they were laden with corn and provisions, sent for Hannibal; Valerius, that they were conveying the plunder of Etruria, and the Ligurian mountaineers who had been captured, to Carthage. In Bruttium scarcely any thing was done this year worth recording. A pestilence had attacked both Romans and Carthaginians with equal violence; but the Carthaginian army, in addition to sickness, was distressed by famine. Hannibal passed the summer near the temple of Juno Lacinia, where he erected and dedicated an altar with an inscription engraved in Punic and Greek characters, setting forth, in pompous terms, the achievements he had performed.

He set out for Sicily with thirty warships and about seven thousand volunteers on board. Publius Licinius arrived in Bruttium to join the two consular armies, choosing the one commanded by Lucius Veturius, the consul, for himself. He let Metellus continue in command of the legions he had previously led, believing it would be easier to work with troops familiar with his leadership. The praetors also went to their respective provinces. Since there was a shortage of funds to finance the war, the quaestors were ordered to sell a part of the Campanian territory stretching from the Grecian trench to the sea. They were allowed to gather information about any land owned by native Campanians, so it could be transferred to the Roman people. The reward for informing on such land was set at a tenth of its value. Cneius Servilius, the city praetor, was tasked with ensuring that the Campanians lived where they were permitted, according to the senate's decree, and to punish anyone found living elsewhere. That same summer, Mago, son of Amilcar, left the smaller Balearian islands, where he had wintered, and loaded his fleet with a select group of young men, bringing over to Italy twelve thousand infantry and about two thousand cavalry, along with around thirty warships and a large number of transport vessels. His sudden arrival allowed him to capture Genoa, as there were no troops stationed to guard the coastline. From there, he brought his fleet to the shore of the Alpine Ligurians to see if he could stir up any trouble. At that time, the Ingaunians, a tribe of the Ligurians, were at war with the Epanterians, a people living in the mountains. Having left his plunder at Savo, an Alpine town, the Carthaginian left ten warships to protect it and sent the rest back to Carthage to guard the coastline, as it was reported that Scipio planned to cross over there; he formed an alliance with the Ingaunians, whose friendship he valued, and launched an attack on the mountain tribes. His army grew daily, with Gauls coming to join him from all directions, drawn by his fame. When the senate learned about these developments through a letter from Spurius Lucretius, they were filled with anxiety, fearing that the joy they had felt over the destruction of Hasdrubal and his army two years earlier would be undermined by another war breaking out in the same region, as significant as before but under a new leader. Consequently, they ordered Marcus Livius, proconsul, to march his army of volunteer slaves from Etruria to Ariminum and instructed Cneius Servilius to give orders, if he deemed it necessary for the safety of the state, to mobilize the city legions under a commander of his choosing. Marcus Valerius Laevinus took those legions to Arretium. Around the same time, Cneius Octavius, who governed the province of Sardinia, captured eighty Carthaginian transports near Sardinia. Caelius reports that these ships were carrying corn and provisions for Hannibal, while Valerius claims that they were transporting spoils from Etruria and captured Ligurian mountaineers to Carthage. In Bruttium, very little of note occurred this year. A plague struck both Romans and Carthaginians with equal ferocity, but the Carthaginian army suffered not only from sickness but also from famine. Hannibal spent the summer near the temple of Juno Lacinia, where he built and dedicated an altar inscribed in both Punic and Greek, boasting about the victories he had achieved.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXIX.


In Spain, Mandonius and Indibilis, reviving hostilities, are finally subdued. Scipio goes over from Syracuse to Locri; dislodges the Carthaginian general; repulses Hannibal, and recovers that city. Peace made with Philip. The Idaean Mother brought to Rome from Phrygia; received by Publius Scipio Nasica, judged by the senate the best man in the state. Scipio passes over into Africa. Syphax, having married a daughter of Hasdrubal, renounces his alliance with Scipio. Masinissa, who had been expelled his kingdom by Syphax, joins Scipio with two hundred horsemen; they defeat a large army commanded by Hanno. Hasdrubal and Syphax approach with a most numerous force. Scipio raises the siege of Utica, and fortifies a post for the winter. The consul Sempronius gets the better of Hannibal in a battle near Croton. Dispute between Marcus Livius and Claudius Nero, censors.

       *        *        *        *        *


1

Scipio, after his arrival in Sicily, formed his volunteers into cohorts and centuries. Of these he kept about his person three hundred young men, in the bloom of their age and the prime of their strength, unarmed, and not knowing for what purpose they were reserved, as they were not included in the centuries, nor furnished with arms. He then selected out of the number of the youth of all Sicily three hundred horsemen, of the highest birth and fortune, who were to cross over with him into Africa, appointing a day on which they were to present themselves equipped and furnished with horses and arms. This severe service, far from their native land, appeared to them likely to be attended with many hardships, and great dangers, both by sea and land; nor did that anxiety affect themselves alone, but also their parents and relations. When the appointed day arrived, they exhibited their arms and horses. Then Scipio observed, "that an intimation had been conveyed to him that certain of the Sicilian horsemen felt a strong aversion to that service, as being severe and arduous. If there were any who entertained such a feeing, that he would rather they should then confess it to him, than, complaining afterwards, prove themselves slothful and useless soldiers to the state. He desired that they would openly avow their sentiments, for that he would hear them with kindly feeling." When one of the number took courage to declare, that if he were allowed the uncontrolled exercise of his will he certainly would not serve, Scipio replied to him thus: "Since then, young man, you have not dissembled your sentiments, I will furnish a substitute for you, to whom I request that you transfer your arms, your horse, and other appliances of war; and, taking him hence immediately to your house, train him, and take care that he is instructed in the management of his horse and arms." The youth accepted the terms joyfully, when Scipio delivered to him one of the three hundred whom he kept unarmed. The rest, seeing the horseman thus discharged without giving any offence to the general, began severally to excuse themselves and receive substitutes. Thus Roman horsemen were substituted for the three hundred Sicilian, without any expense to the state. The Sicilians had the care of instructing and training them, because the general had ordered that the man who should not do so, should serve himself. It is said that this turned out to be an admirable body of cavalry, and rendered effectual service to the state in many engagements. Afterwards, inspecting the legions, he chose out of them such soldiers as had served the greatest number of campaigns, particularly those who had acted under Marcellus; for he considered that they were formed under the best discipline, and also, from the long time in which they were engaged in the siege of Syracuse, were most skilled in the assault of towns: for his thoughts were now occupied with no small object, but the destruction of Carthage. He then distributed his army through the towns; ordered the Sicilian states to furnish corn, sparing that which had been brought from Italy; repaired his old ships, and sent Caius Laelius with them into Africa to plunder. His new ships he hauled on shore at Panormus, that they might be kept on land during the winter, as they had been hastily built of unseasoned timber.

Scipio, after arriving in Sicily, organized his volunteers into cohorts and centuries. He kept about three hundred young men close to him, who were in their youth and full of strength, unarmed and unaware of the purpose for which they were set aside, as they weren’t part of the centuries and didn’t have any weapons. He then chose three hundred horsemen from the youth of Sicily, who were of the highest rank and wealth, to accompany him to Africa, setting a date for them to show up equipped with horses and arms. This challenging mission, far from home, seemed likely to bring many hardships and great dangers, both at sea and on land; the anxiety affected not only them but also their parents and relatives. When the day arrived, they displayed their arms and horses. Scipio then remarked that he had heard that some Sicilian horsemen were strongly opposed to this service, viewing it as tough and demanding. He stated that if anyone felt that way, he would rather they confess it now instead of complaining later and becoming lazy, useless soldiers for the state. He asked them to openly share their thoughts, assuring them he would listen kindly. When one young man bravely stated that he wouldn’t serve if given the choice, Scipio replied, "Since you have been honest with your feelings, I will find a substitute for you. Please hand over your arms, horse, and other war gear to him, and take him home to train him, ensuring he learns to handle his horse and weapons." The young man accepted the arrangement happily when Scipio assigned him one of the three hundred who were unarmed. The others, seeing that this horseman was released without upsetting the general, began to excuse themselves one by one and accepted substitutes. This way, Roman horsemen replaced the three hundred Sicilian ones without costing the state anything. The Sicilians were responsible for instructing and training them, as the general ordered that anyone who failed to do so would have to serve himself. It’s said that this became an excellent cavalry unit and was highly effective in many battles. Later, while reviewing the legions, he chose soldiers who had served the most campaigns, particularly those who had fought under Marcellus, believing they were trained under the best discipline and became highly skilled in assaulting towns due to their long engagement in the siege of Syracuse. His focus was now set on a significant goal: the destruction of Carthage. He distributed his army across the towns, ordered the Sicilian states to supply grain, while conserving what had been brought from Italy; he repaired his old ships and sent Caius Laelius alongside them to raid Africa. He had his new ships pulled ashore at Panormus to be kept on land throughout the winter, since they had been hastily constructed from unseasoned timber.

When every thing was got in readiness for the war he came to Syracuse, which had hardly yet returned to a state of tranquillity, after the violent commotions of the war. The Greeks, demanding restitution of their property, which had been granted to them by the senate, from certain persons of the Italian nation, who retained possession of it in the same forcible manner in which they had seized it in the war, Scipio, who deemed it of the first importance to preserve the public faith, restored their property to the Syracusans, partly by proclamation, and partly even by judgments pronounced against those who pertinaciously retained their unjust acquisitions. This measure was acceptable not only to the persons immediately concerned, but to all the states of Sicily, and so much the more energetically did they give aid in the war. During the same summer a very formidable war sprang up in Spain, at the instance of Indibilis the Hergetian, from no other cause than the contempt he conceived for the other generals, in consequence of his admiration of Scipio. He considered "that he was the only commander the Romans had left, the rest having been slain by Hannibal. That they had, therefore, no other general whom they could send into Spain after the Scipios were cut off there, and that afterwards, when the war in Italy pressed upon them with increased severity, he was recalled to oppose Hannibal. That, in addition to the fact that the Romans had the names only of generals in Spain, their old army had also been withdrawn thence. That all the troops they had there were irresolute, as consisting of an undisciplined multitude of recruits. That there would never again occur such an opportunity for the liberation of Spain. That up to that time they had been the slaves either of Carthaginians or Romans, and that not to one or the other in turns, but sometimes to both together. That the Carthaginians had been driven out by the Romans, and that the Romans might be driven out by the Spaniards, if they would unite: so that Spain, for ever freed from a foreign yoke, might return to her native customs and rites." By these and other observations he stirred up not only his countrymen, but the Ausetanians also, a neighbouring nation, as well as other states bordering on his own and their country. Accordingly, within a few days, thirty thousand foot and about four thousand horse assembled in the Sedetanian territory, according to the orders which had been given.

When everything was ready for war, he arrived in Syracuse, which had barely returned to a peaceful state after the violent upheavals of conflict. The Greeks, seeking the return of their property that had been granted to them by the senate, were confronting certain individuals from the Italian nation who were still holding onto it in the same forceful way they had during the war. Scipio, who thought it was crucial to maintain public trust, returned the property to the Syracusans, partly through an official declaration and partly through rulings against those who stubbornly held onto their illegal gains. This decision was welcomed not only by those directly affected but by all the states of Sicily, and it encouraged their support in the war even more. That same summer, a serious conflict broke out in Spain, instigated by Indibilis the Hergetian, who felt contempt for the other generals due to his admiration for Scipio. He believed that Scipio was the only competent commander left for the Romans, as the others had been killed by Hannibal. He pointed out that there was no other general who could be sent to Spain after the Scipios had been eliminated there, and later, when the war in Italy intensified, Scipio was recalled to confront Hannibal. He noted that, apart from having only the names of generals in Spain, all their seasoned troops had also been removed. The forces still there were inexperienced, made up of a disorganized mass of new recruits. He argued that there would never be a better chance for Spain to liberate itself. Until then, they had been slaves to either the Carthaginians or the Romans, sometimes both. The Carthaginians had been expelled by the Romans, and the Romans could be driven out by the Spaniards if they united, thus allowing Spain to finally be free from foreign control and return to its own customs and traditions. With these points and others, he rallied not just his own people, but also the Ausetanians, a neighboring tribe, along with other states around them. As a result, within a few days, thirty thousand infantry and about four thousand cavalry gathered in Sedetanian territory, following the orders that had been given.

2

On the other side, the Roman generals also, Lucius Lentulus and Lucius Manlius Acidinus, lest by neglecting the first beginnings of the war it should increase in violence, having united their armies, and led their troops through the Ausetanian territory in a peaceable manner, as though it had been the territory of friends instead of enemies, came to the position of the enemy, and pitched their camp at a distance of three miles from theirs. At first an unsuccessful attempt was made, through ambassadors, to induce them to lay down their arms; then the Spanish cavalry making a sudden attack on the Roman foragers, a body of cavalry was sent to support them from the Roman outposts, when a battle between the cavalry took place with no memorable issue to either side. The next day, at sun-rise, the whole force displayed their line, armed and drawn out for battle, at the distance of about a mile from the Roman camp. The Ausetanians were in the centre, the right wing was occupied by the Ilergetians, the left by some inconsiderable states of Spain. Between the wings and the centre they had left intervals of considerable extent, through which they might send out their cavalry when occasion required. The Romans also, drawing up their army in their usual manner, imitated the enemy in respect only of leaving themselves also intervals between the legions to afford passages for their cavalry. Lentulus, however, concluding that the cavalry could be employed with advantage by those only who should be the first to send them against the enemy's line, thus broken by intervals, ordered Servius Cornelius, a military tribune, to direct the cavalry to ride at full speed into the spaces left in the enemy's line. Lentulus himself, as the battle between the infantry was somewhat unfavourable in its commencement, waited only until he had brought up from the reserve into the front line the thirteenth legion to support the twelfth legion, which had been posted in the left wing, against the Ilergetians, and which was giving ground. And when the battle was thus placed on an equal footing in that quarter, he came to Lucius Manlius, who was exhorting the troops in the foremost line, and bringing up the reserves in such places as circumstances required, and told him that all was safe in the left wing, and that Cornelius Servius, who had been sent by him for that purpose, would soon pour round the enemy a storm of cavalry. He had scarcely uttered these words, when the Roman horse, riding into the midst of the enemy, at once threw their line of infantry into disorder, and closed up the passage by which the Spanish cavalry were to advance. The Spaniards, therefore, giving up all thoughts of fighting on horseback, dismounted and fought on foot. When the Roman generals saw that the ranks of the enemy were in confusion, that they were in a state of trepidation and dismay, their standards moving to and fro, they exhorted and implored their men to charge them while thus discomfited, and not allow them to form their line again. So desperate was their charge that the barbarians could not have withstood the shock, had not the prince Indibilis in person, together with the discounted cavalry, opposed himself to the enemy before the front rank of the infantry. There an obstinate contest continued for a considerable time; but those who fought round the king, who continued his resistance though almost expiring, and who was afterwards pinned to the earth by a javelin, having at length fallen, overwhelmed with darts, a general flight took place; and the number slain was the greater because the horsemen were prevented from remounting, and because the Romans pressed impetuously upon the discomfited troops; nor did they give over until they had deprived the enemy of their camp. On that day thirteen thousand Spaniards were slain, and about eight hundred captured. Of the Romans and allies there fell a little more than two hundred, and those principally in the left wing. Such of the Spaniards as were beaten out of their camp, or had escaped from the battle, at first dispersed themselves through the country, but afterwards returned each to his own state.

On the other side, the Roman generals, Lucius Lentulus and Lucius Manlius Acidinus, knowing that neglecting the early stages of the war could lead to increased violence, united their armies and peacefully moved their troops through Ausetanian territory as if it were the land of friends instead of enemies. They positioned themselves at a campsite three miles away from the enemy. Initially, they tried unsuccessfully to persuade the enemy to lay down their arms through ambassadors. Then, when the Spanish cavalry launched a surprise attack on the Roman foragers, the Romans sent a cavalry unit from their outposts to support them, resulting in a cavalry battle that ended without a clear outcome for either side. The next day at sunrise, both forces lined up for battle about a mile away from the Roman camp. The Ausetanians formed the center, with the Ilergetians on the right and smaller Spanish states on the left. They left significant gaps between their center and wings to send out cavalry when needed. The Romans organized their army in their usual manner, also leaving gaps between their legions for their cavalry. However, Lentulus determined that the cavalry would be most effective if they were the first to charge through the gaps in the enemy's line, so he ordered Servius Cornelius, a military tribune, to lead the cavalry at full speed into these openings. Lentulus himself waited to bring the thirteenth legion up from the reserves to support the twelfth legion on the left wing, which was giving ground against the Ilergetians. Once the battle was more balanced in that area, he approached Lucius Manlius, who was encouraging the frontline troops and bringing up reserves as needed. He informed Manlius that everything was secure on the left flank and that Cornelius would soon unleash a wave of cavalry against the enemy. He had barely finished speaking when the Roman cavalry surged into the midst of the enemy, throwing their infantry line into chaos and blocking the route for the Spanish cavalry to advance. As a result, the Spaniards abandoned any hope of fighting on horseback, dismounted, and fought on foot. When the Roman generals saw that the enemy ranks were disordered and in a state of panic, with their standards moving erratically, they urged their troops to charge while they were unsteady and not let them regroup. The charge was so fierce that the barbarians could not withstand it, had it not been for King Indibilis himself, along with the discouraged cavalry, standing against the enemy before the front line of infantry. An intense struggle continued for a long time, but those fighting around the king, who kept resisting even when he was nearly defeated and later pinned to the ground by a javelin, eventually fell. Once he was overwhelmed with projectiles, a general retreat ensued; the death toll was higher because the cavalry couldn’t remount, and the Romans pressed aggressively against the beaten troops, not stopping until they captured the enemy's camp. On that day, thirteen thousand Spaniards were killed, and about eight hundred were captured. The Romans and their allies lost just over two hundred, primarily from the left flank. Those Spaniards who were driven from their camp or had escaped from the battle initially scattered throughout the countryside but later returned to their respective states.

3

They were then summoned to an assembly by Mandonius, at which, after complaining bitterly of the losses they had sustained, and upbraiding the instigators of the war, they resolved that ambassadors should be sent with proposals to deliver up their arms and make a surrender. These, laying the blame on Indibilis, the instigator of the war, and the other chiefs, most of whom had fallen in the battle, and offering to deliver up their arms and surrender themselves, received for answer, that their surrender would be accepted on condition that they delivered up alive Mandonius and the rest of the persons who had fomented the war; but if they refused to comply, that armies should be marched into the territories of the Ilergetians and Ausetanians, and afterwards into those of the other states in succession. This answer given to the ambassadors, was reported to the assembly, and Mandonius and the other chiefs were there seized and delivered up for punishment. Peace was restored to the states of Spain, which were ordered to pay double taxes that year, and furnish corn for six months, together with cloaks and gowns for the army; and hostages were taken from about thirty of the states.

They were then called to a meeting by Mandonius, where they expressed their deep frustration over the losses they had suffered and criticized those who had instigated the war. They decided that ambassadors should be sent with proposals to surrender and give up their weapons. These ambassadors blamed Indibilis, the one who started the war, along with other leaders, most of whom had been killed in battle, and offered to surrender themselves and hand over their weapons. They were told that their surrender would be accepted only if they delivered Mandonius alive along with the others who had stirred up the conflict; if they refused, armies would invade the lands of the Ilergetians and Ausetanians, and then move on to other states in order. This response was conveyed to the assembly, leading to the capture and punishment of Mandonius and the other leaders. Peace was restored in the regions of Spain, which were mandated to pay double taxes that year, provide grain for six months, and supply cloaks and gowns for the army; hostages were taken from around thirty of the states.

The tumult occasioned by the rebellion in Spain having been thus excited and suppressed within the space of a few days, without any great disturbance, the whole terror of the war was directed against Africa. Caius Laelius having arrived at Hippo Regius by night, at break of day led his soldiers and mariners in regular array to lay waste the country. As all the inhabitants were living unguardedly, as in a time of peace, great damage was done; and messengers, flying in terror, filled Carthage with alarm, by reporting that the Roman fleet and the general, Scipio, had arrived; for there was a rumour that Scipio had already crossed over into Sicily. Not knowing accurately how many ships they had seen, or how large a body of troops was devastating the country, they, under the influence of fear, which represented them as greater than they really were, exaggerated every thing. Accordingly, at first, terror and dismay took possession of their minds, but afterwards grief, when they reflected that their circumstances had undergone so great a change; that they, who lately as conquerors had an army before the walls of Rome, and, after having laid prostrate so many armies of the enemy, had received the surrender of all the states of Italy, either by force or choice, now, the war having taken an unfavourable turn, were destined to behold the devastation of Africa and the siege of Carthage, without any thing like the resources to enable them to bear up against those calamities which the Romans possessed. To the latter the Roman commons and Latium afforded a supply of young men, which continually grew up more vigorous and more numerous, in the room of so many armies destroyed, while their own people, both those in the city and those in the country, were unfit for military service; their troops consisted of auxiliaries, procured by hire from the Africans, a faithless nation, and veering about with every gale of fortune. Now too, with regard to the kings, Syphax was alienated from them since his conference with Scipio, and Masinissa, by an open defection, had become their most determined enemy. Wherever they turned their eyes there was no hope, no aid. Neither did Mago excite any commotion on the side of Gaul, nor join his forces with those of Hannibal; while Hannibal himself was now declining both in reputation and strength.

The chaos caused by the rebellion in Spain was stirred up and resolved within just a few days, without much disruption, and all the fear of war was then focused on Africa. Caius Laelius arrived at Hippo Regius under the cover of night and, at dawn, organized his soldiers and sailors to devastate the land. Since the locals were living carelessly, as if in a time of peace, significant damage was inflicted; terrified messengers filled Carthage with panic by reporting that the Roman fleet and General Scipio had arrived, as there were rumors that Scipio had already crossed into Sicily. Unclear about how many ships they had seen or how many troops were ravaging their land, fear distorted their perception, making the situation seem worse than it actually was. Initially, fear and dread overwhelmed them, but soon grief set in as they realized how drastically their situation had changed. They, who had recently been conquerors with an army outside the walls of Rome, having defeated so many enemy forces and received the surrender of all the states of Italy either by force or choice, were now facing the devastation of Africa and the siege of Carthage, lacking the resources to withstand the misfortunes that the Romans had. The Roman common people and Latium continuously provided a supply of young men, becoming more vigorous and numerous to replace the fallen armies, while their own people, both in the city and countryside, were unfit for military service. Their forces were made up of unreliable auxiliaries hired from the Africans, a treacherous nation that shifted with every change in fortune. Additionally, regarding the kings, Syphax had turned against them after his meeting with Scipio, and Masinissa had become their most determined enemy through an open defection. No matter where they looked, there was no hope, no help. Mago failed to stir any trouble in Gaul or join forces with Hannibal, and Hannibal himself was now declining in both reputation and strength.

4

Their minds, which had fallen into these melancholy reflections in consequence of the intelligence they had just received, were brought back by their immediate fears to deliberate how to oppose the instant danger. They resolved, that troops should be hastily levied both in the city and in the country; that persons should be sent to hire auxiliaries from the Africans; that the city should be fortified, corn collected, weapons and arms prepared, and ships equipped and sent to Hippo against the Roman fleet. But now, while engaged in these matters, news at length arrived that it was Laelius, and not Scipio; that the forces which he had brought over were only what were sufficient for making predatory incursions into the country, and that the principal stress of the war still lay in Sicily. Thus they were enabled to take breath, and they began to send embassies to Syphax and the other petty princes, for the purpose of strengthening their alliances. To Philip also ambassadors were sent, to promise him two hundred talents of silver, if he would cross over into Sicily or Italy. Ambassadors were also sent into Italy to the two generals, to desire them to keep Scipio at home by terrifying the enemy in every way they could. To Mago, not only ambassadors were sent, but twenty-five men of war, six thousand infantry, eight hundred horse, and seven elephants, besides a large sum of money to be employed in hiring auxiliaries, in order that, encouraged by these aids, he might advance his army nearer to the city of Rome, and form a junction with Hannibal. Such were the preparations and plans at Carthage. While Laelius was employed in carrying off an immense quantity of booty from the country, the inhabitants of which had no arms, and which was destitute of forces, Masinissa, moved by the report of the arrival of the Roman fleet, came to him attended by a small body of horse. He complained that "Scipio had not acted with promptness in this business, in that he had not already passed his army over into Africa, while the Carthaginians were in consternation, and while Syphax was entangled in wars with the neighbouring states, and in doubt and uncertainty as to the course he should take; that if time was allowed to Syphax to adjust his own affairs according to his mind, he would not in any thing keep his faith with the Romans inviolate." He requested that he would exhort and stimulate Scipio not to delay. Though driven from his kingdom, he said he would join him with no despicable force of foot and horse. Nor was it right, said he that Laelius should continue in Africa, for he believed that a fleet had set sail from Carthage, with which, in the absence of Scipio, it would not be altogether safe to engage.

Their minds, which had fallen into these gloomy thoughts because of the news they had just received, were quickly pulled back by their immediate fears to figure out how to tackle the urgent danger. They decided to quickly raise troops in both the city and the countryside; to send people to recruit allies from Africa; to fortify the city, collect grain, prepare weapons and armaments, and outfit ships to send to Hippo against the Roman fleet. However, while they were engaged in these matters, news finally arrived that it was Laelius, not Scipio, who was leading the forces he brought over, and that those forces were only enough for raiding the countryside, while the main focus of the war still lay in Sicily. This allowed them to catch their breath, and they began sending envoys to Syphax and other local leaders to strengthen their alliances. They also sent ambassadors to Philip, promising him two hundred talents of silver if he would come to Sicily or Italy. Envoys were also sent to Italy to the two generals, asking them to keep Scipio from coming home by intimidating the enemy in every way possible. They sent not only ambassadors to Mago but also twenty-five warships, six thousand infantry, eight hundred cavalry, and seven elephants, along with a large sum of money to hire additional troops, so that, encouraged by this support, he could move his army closer to Rome and join forces with Hannibal. These were the preparations and plans in Carthage. While Laelius was busy carrying off a massive amount of plunder from the unarmed territory, Masinissa, alerted by the news of the Roman fleet's arrival, came to him with a small group of cavalry. He expressed his frustration that "Scipio had not acted quickly enough, as he had not yet moved his army into Africa while the Carthaginians were in chaos and Syphax was entangled in wars with neighboring states, uncertain about what to do. If Syphax was given time to sort out his own affairs, he would not keep his promises to the Romans." He urged Laelius to encourage Scipio not to delay. Although he had been driven from his kingdom, he said he would join him with a respectable force of infantry and cavalry. He believed it was unwise for Laelius to remain in Africa, as he suspected a fleet had set sail from Carthage, and without Scipio, it wouldn’t be safe to engage with them.

5

After this discourse Masinissa departed. Laelius, the next day, sailed from Hippo with his ships loaded with booty, and returning to Sicily, delivered to Scipio the injunctions of Masinissa. About the same time the ships which were sent from Carthage to Mago touched at the country between the Albingaunian Ligurians and Genoa. Mago happened to be lying here with his fleet at this time. After hearing the message of the ambassadors, directing him to collect as great a number of troops as possible, he immediately held a council of the Gauls and Ligurians, for a great number of both those nations were there. He said that he was sent to restore them to liberty, and, as they themselves might see, succours were sent him from home; but that it depended upon them with how great forces and how large an army the war for that purpose was to be carried on. That the Romans had two armies in the field, one in Gaul and another in Etruria. That he was well informed that Spurius Lucretius would form a junction with Marcus Livius, and that they on their part must arm many thousands, in order to cope with two Roman generals and two armies. The Gauls replied, that they had the strongest possible inclination to this, but as the Romans had one army within their borders, and another in the neighbouring country of Etruria, almost within sight, if it should be known that they had supported the Carthaginians with auxiliaries, those would immediately invade their territories on both sides with determined hostility. They requested that he would ask of the Gauls such aids as they could afford in a covert manner. The purposes of the Ligurians, they said, were unrestrained, because the Roman troops were at a distance from their lands and cities; that it was fair that they should arm their youth and take upon themselves a portion of the war. The Ligurians did not dissent; they only requested the space of two months to make their levies. Having dismissed the Gauls, Mago in the mean time secretly hired soldiers through their country. Provisions also of every description were sent to him privately by the Gallic states. Marcus Livius led his army of volunteer slaves out of Etruria into Gaul, and having joined Lucretius, prepared to meet Mago in case he should move from Liguria nearer to the city; but intending, if the Carthaginian should keep himself quiet under the angle formed by the Alps, to remain himself also in the same quarter, near Ariminum, for the protection of Italy.

After this conversation, Masinissa left. The next day, Laelius set sail from Hippo with his ships full of loot and, upon returning to Sicily, delivered Masinissa's messages to Scipio. Around the same time, ships sent from Carthage to Mago landed in the region between the Albingaunian Ligurians and Genoa. Mago happened to be stationed there with his fleet. After hearing the ambassadors' message to gather as many troops as possible, he immediately called a meeting with the Gauls and Ligurians, since a large number of both groups were present. He told them he had come to restore their freedom and, as they could see, he was receiving support from home. However, he emphasized that it was up to them to decide how many troops they could muster for this purpose. He pointed out that the Romans had two armies in the field, one in Gaul and another in Etruria. He also informed them that Spurius Lucretius would join forces with Marcus Livius, meaning they would need to recruit many thousands of soldiers to fight against these two Roman generals and their respective armies. The Gauls replied that they were very eager to help, but since one Roman army was within their territory and another was nearby in Etruria, they feared that if it became known they were supporting the Carthaginians, the Romans would invade their lands with aggression. They asked Mago to request aid from the Gauls in a discreet way. They noted that the Ligurians were less constrained, as the Roman troops were far from their lands and cities, and it was reasonable for them to arm their young men and take on some of the war effort. The Ligurians agreed, but they requested two months to raise their forces. After sending off the Gauls, Mago secretly hired soldiers throughout their territory. Various supplies were also sent to him privately by the Gallic states. Marcus Livius led his army of volunteer slaves from Etruria into Gaul, and after joining Lucretius, he prepared to confront Mago if he moved from Liguria closer to the city. However, if the Carthaginian remained quiet near the Alps, Livius planned to stay in the same area near Ariminum to protect Italy.

6

After the return of Caius Laelius from Africa, though Scipio was goaded on by the exhortations of Masinissa; and the soldiers, on seeing the booty which was taken from the enemy's country landed from the whole fleet, were inflamed with the strongest desire to cross over as soon as possible; this important object was interrupted by one of minor consideration, namely, that of regaining the town of Locri, which at the time of the general defection of Italy had itself also gone over to the Carthaginians. The hope of accomplishing this object beamed forth from a very trifling circumstance. The war was carried on in Bruttium rather in a predatory than a regular manner, the Numidians having set the example, and the Bruttians falling in with that practice, not more in consequence of their connexion with the Carthaginians, than from their natural inclination. At last the Romans also, who now took delight in plunder by a sort of infection, made excursions into the lands of their enemies so far as their leaders would permit it. Some Locrians who had gone out of the town, were surrounded by them and carried off to Rhegium. Among the number of the prisoners were certain artisans, who, as it happened, had been accustomed to work for the Carthaginians in the city of Locri for hire. They were recognised by some of the Locrian nobles, who having been driven out by the opposite faction, which had delivered up Locri to Hannibal, had retired to Rhegium; and having answered their other questions relative to what was going on at home, questions which are usually put by such as have been long absent, they gave them hopes that, if ransomed and sent back, they might be able to deliver up the citadel to them; for there they resided, and among the Carthaginians they enjoyed unlimited confidence. Accordingly, as these nobles were at once tormented with a longing for their country, and inflamed with a desire to be revenged on their enemies, they immediately ransomed the prisoners and sent them back, after having settled the plan of operation, and agreed upon the signals which were to be given at a distance and observed by them. They then went themselves to Scipio to Syracuse, with whom some of the exiles were; and having, by relating to him the promises made by the prisoners, inspired the consul with hopes which seemed likely to be realized, Marcus Sergius and Publius Matienus, military tribunes, were sent with them, and ordered to lead three thousand soldiers from Rhegium to Locri. A letter was also written to Quintus Pleminius, the propraetor, with directions that he should assist in the business. The troops, setting out from Rhegium and carrying with them ladders to suit the alleged height of the citadel, about midnight gave a signal to those who were to betray it from the place agreed upon. The latter were ready and on the watch, and having themselves also lowered down ladders made for the purpose, and received the Romans as they climbed up in several places at once, an attack was made upon the Carthaginian sentinels, who were fast asleep, as they were not afraid of any thing of the kind before any noise was made. Their dying groans were the first sound that was heard; then, awaking from their sleep, a sudden consternation and confusion followed, the cause of the alarm being unknown. At length, one rousing another, the fact became more certain, and now every one shouted "To arms" with all his might; "that the enemy were in the citadel and the sentinels slain;" and the Romans, who were far inferior in numbers, would have been overpowered, had not a shout raised by those who were outside of the citadel rendered it uncertain whence the noise proceeded, while the terror of an alarm by night magnified all fears, however groundless. The Carthaginians, therefore, terrified and supposing that the citadel was already filled with the enemy, gave up all thoughts of opposition and fled to the other citadel; for there were two at no great distance from each other. The townsmen held the city, which lay between the two fortresses, as the prize of the victors. Slight engagements took place daily from the two citadels. Quintus Pleminius commanded the Roman, Hamilcar the Carthaginian garrison. They augmented their forces by calling in aids from the neighbouring places. At last Hannibal himself came; nor would the Romans have held out, had not the general body of the Locrians, exasperated by the pride and rapacity of the Carthaginians, leaned towards the Romans.

After Caius Laelius returned from Africa, even though Scipio was encouraged by Masinissa's shouts and the soldiers, fired up by the loot taken from the enemy's land brought in by the entire fleet, were eager to cross over as soon as possible, their main goal was interrupted by a less important matter: retaking the town of Locri, which had switched sides to the Carthaginians during the widespread defection in Italy. The hope for achieving this came from a seemingly minor detail. The war in Bruttium was being waged more through looting than organized fighting, as the Numidians had set this model, and the Bruttians adopted the practice not just because of their ties to the Carthaginians but also due to their own nature. Eventually, the Romans, who were now also enjoying a taste for plunder due to this influence, began raiding their enemies' lands as far as their leaders allowed. Some Locrians who had left the town were captured and taken to Rhegium. Among the prisoners were certain artisans who had been working for the Carthaginians in Locri for pay. They were recognized by some Locrian nobles who had been driven out by the opposing faction that had surrendered Locri to Hannibal and had retreated to Rhegium. After answering the usual questions about what was happening back home—questions typically asked by those who had been away for a long time—they gave the nobles hope that if they were ransomed and sent back, they could take control of the citadel since they lived there and had earned the complete trust of the Carthaginians. So, feeling both a longing for their homeland and a desire for revenge against their enemies, the nobles quickly ransomed the prisoners and sent them back after planning the operation and agreeing on signals to be used from a distance. They then went to Scipio in Syracuse, where some exiles were, and relayed the promises made by the prisoners, sparking hope in the consul that seemed achievable. Marcus Sergius and Publius Matienus, military tribunes, were sent with them and ordered to lead three thousand soldiers from Rhegium to Locri. A letter was also sent to Quintus Pleminius, the propraetor, instructing him to lend support in the mission. The troops set out from Rhegium, bringing ladders appropriate for the presumed height of the citadel, and around midnight, they signaled those who were meant to betray it from the agreed-upon spot. The traitors were ready and on alert, having lowered down ladders for this purpose, and received the Romans as they climbed up in several places simultaneously. They launched a surprise attack on the Carthaginian sentinels, who were fast asleep because they hadn’t anticipated an attack without prior noise. The first sound heard were the dying groans of the sentinels; then, awakening from their sleep, panic and confusion ensued as they did not know the cause of the alarm. Finally, as they stirred each other awake, it became clearer what was happening, and everyone shouted “To arms!” with all their might, reporting that the enemy was in the citadel and the sentinels slain. The Romans, despite being outnumbered, would have been overrun if not for a shout raised by those outside the citadel, which made it uncertain where the noise was coming from, while the fear that comes from a nighttime alarm amplified all their anxieties, no matter how unfounded. The Carthaginians, therefore, terrified and thinking the citadel was already filled with the enemy, abandoned all thoughts of resistance and fled to the other citadel; there were two citadels not far from each other. The townspeople retained control of the city situated between the two fortifications as the victors' prize. Small skirmishes occurred daily from the two citadels. Quintus Pleminius commanded the Roman garrison, and Hamilcar led the Carthaginian forces. They both bolstered their troops by calling in reinforcements from nearby areas. Eventually, Hannibal himself arrived; and the Romans would not have held their ground had it not been for the majority of the Locrians, who, angered by the arrogance and greed of the Carthaginians, leaned toward the Roman side.

7

When Scipio received intelligence that the posture of affairs at Locri had become more critical, and that Hannibal himself was approaching, lest even the garrison might be exposed to danger; for it was not an easy matter for it to retire thence; as soon as the direction of the tide in the strait had changed, he let the ships drive with the tide from Messana, having left his brother, Lucius Scipio, in command there. Hannibal also sent a messenger in advance from the river Butrotus, which is not far from the town of Locri, to desire his party to attack the Romans and Locrians at break of day in the most vigorous manner, while he on the opposite side assaulted the town, which would be unprepared for such a measure, as every one would have his attention occupied with the tumult created in the other quarter. But when, as soon as it was light, he found that the battle had commenced, he was unwilling to shut himself up in the citadel, where, by his numbers, he would crowd that confined place; nor had he brought with him scaling-ladders to enable him to mount the walls. Having, however, had the baggage thrown together in a heap, and displayed his line at a distance from the walls to intimidate the enemy, while the scaling-ladders and other requisites for an assault were preparing, he rode round the city with some Numidian horsemen, in order to observe in what quarter the attack might be best made. Having advanced towards the rampart, the person who happened to stand next him was struck by a weapon from a scorpion; and, terrified at an accident in which he had been exposed to so much danger, he retired, gave directions for sounding a retreat, and fortified a camp out of the reach of weapons. The Roman fleet from Messana came to Locri several hours before night. The troops were all landed and had entered the city before sun-set. The following day the fight began from the citadel on the part of the Carthaginians, and Hannibal, having now prepared ladders and all the other requisites for an assault, was coming up to the walls; when, throwing open the gate, the Romans suddenly sallied out upon him, Hannibal fearing nothing less than such a step. They slew as many as two hundred in the attack, having taken them by surprise. The rest Hannibal withdrew into the camp when he found the consul was there; and having despatched a messenger to those who were in the citadel, to desire them to take measures for their own safety, he decamped by night. Those who were in the citadel also, after throwing fire upon the buildings they occupied, in order that the alarm thus occasioned might detain their enemy, went away with a speed which resembled flight, and overtook the body of their army before night.

When Scipio learned that the situation in Locri had become more urgent and that Hannibal himself was getting closer, he felt the garrison might be in danger, especially since it would be difficult for them to retreat. As soon as the tide in the strait changed, he sent the ships from Messana, leaving his brother, Lucius Scipio, in charge there. Hannibal also sent a messenger ahead from the river Butrotus, near Locri, instructing his men to attack the Romans and Locrians at dawn with full force while he attacked the town from the other side, which would be caught off guard since everyone would be focused on the chaos elsewhere. However, when dawn broke and he saw that the battle had begun, he didn't want to lock himself in the citadel, where his numbers would crowd the confined space. He hadn't brought scaling ladders to climb the walls either. Instead, he had his baggage piled up and formed his line at a distance from the walls to intimidate the enemy while preparing the ladders and other supplies for an assault. He rode around the city with some Numidian horsemen to scout the best spot for an attack. As he approached the rampart, one of his men was hit by a projectile from a scorpion, and shaken by the unexpected danger, he retreated, ordered a retreat to be sounded, and set up a camp out of harm's way. The Roman fleet arrived from Messana at Locri several hours before nightfall. The troops were all landed and had entered the city before sunset. The next day, the Carthaginians began the fight from the citadel, and Hannibal, having readied ladders and needed supplies for an assault, approached the walls. Just then, the Romans burst out through the gate, catching Hannibal completely off guard. They killed about two hundred in the surprise attack. The rest of Hannibal's men fell back to camp when they realized the consul was there, and he quickly sent a message to those in the citadel to ensure their own safety before he retreated under the cover of night. The men in the citadel also set fire to their buildings to create an alarm that would delay the enemy and then fled quickly, catching up with the main army before nightfall.

8

Scipio, seeing that the citadel was abandoned by the enemy, and their camp deserted, called the Locrians to an assembly and rebuked them severely for their defection. He inflicted punishment on the persons principally concerned, and gave their effects to the leaders of the other party, in consideration of their extraordinary fidelity to the Romans. As to the Locrians in general, he said that he would neither grant them any thing, nor take any thing from them. They might send ambassadors to Rome, and they should experience that treatment which the senate thought proper to adopt. Of one thing, however, he said he was confident, which was, that although they had deserved ill at the hands of the Romans, they would be better off when subject to them, though incensed against them, than they had been when in the power of their friends the Carthaginians. Leaving Quintus Pleminius lieutenant-general, and the garrison which had taken the citadel to defend the city, the general himself crossed over to Messana with the forces he had brought with him. The Locrians had been treated with such insolence and cruelty by the Carthaginians since their revolt from the Romans, that they were able to endure severities of an ordinary kind not only with patience but almost willingness. But indeed, so greatly did Pleminius surpass Hamilcar, who had commanded the garrison, so greatly did the Roman soldiers in the garrison surpass the Carthaginians in villany and rapacity, that it would appear that they endeavoured to outdo each other, not in arms, but in vices. None of all those things which render the power of a superior hateful to the powerless was omitted towards the inhabitants, either by the general or his soldiers. The most shocking insults were committed against their own persons, their children, and their wives, For their rapacity did not abstain from the spoliation even of sacred things; and not only were other temples violated, but even the treasures of Proserpine, which had never been touched through all ages, excepting that they were said to have been carried away by Pyrrhus, who restored the spoils, together with a costly offering in expiation of his sacrilege. Therefore, as on the former occasion, the royal ships, wrecked and shattered, brought nothing safe to land, except the sacred money of the goddess, which they were carrying away; so now also, that same money, by a different kind of calamity, cast a spirit of madness upon all who were contaminated by this violation of the temple, and turned them against each other with the fury of enemies, general against general, and soldier against soldier.

Scipio, noticing that the citadel was deserted by the enemy and their camp was abandoned, called the Locrians to a meeting and strongly criticized them for their betrayal. He punished those primarily responsible and awarded their possessions to the leaders of the other side in acknowledgment of their remarkable loyalty to the Romans. As for the Locrians as a whole, he stated that he would neither grant them anything nor take anything from them. They could send ambassadors to Rome, where they would receive the treatment that the senate deemed appropriate. However, he was confident of one thing: despite their wrongdoings towards the Romans, they would be better off under their control, even if they were angry, than they had been under the influence of their allies, the Carthaginians. Leaving Quintus Pleminius as lieutenant-general, along with the garrison that had taken the citadel to protect the city, the general himself went to Messana with the forces he had brought. The Locrians had been subjected to such arrogance and cruelty by the Carthaginians since their defection from the Romans that they could endure regular hardships not only with patience but almost willingly. In fact, Pleminius was so much worse than Hamilcar, who had commanded the garrison, and the Roman soldiers in the garrison were so much more wicked and greedy than the Carthaginians, that it seemed they tried to outdo one another, not in battle, but in vice. Everything that makes the power of the powerful despised by the powerless was directed at the inhabitants, both by the general and his soldiers. The most horrifying insults were inflicted on them, their children, and their wives. Their greed did not stop at the plunder of even sacred objects; not only were other temples desecrated, but even the treasures of Proserpine, which had never been touched throughout the ages—except for the time they were said to have been taken by Pyrrhus, who returned the spoils along with a costly offering to atone for his sacrilege. Thus, as in the past, the royal ships, wrecked and broken, brought nothing ashore safe except for the sacred money of the goddess they were carrying away; this time, that same money, through a different kind of disaster, drove everyone contaminated by the violation of the temple into a frenzy, turning them against each other with the bitterness of enemies, generals against generals, and soldiers against soldiers.

9

Pleminius had the chief command; that part of the soldiers which he had brought with him from Rhegium were under his own command, the rest were under the command of the tribunes. One of Pleminius's men, while running away with a silver cup which he had stolen from the house of a townsman, the owners pursuing him, happened to meet Sergius and Matienus, the military tribunes. The cup having been taken away from him at the order of the tribunes, abuse and clamour ensued, and at last a fight arose between the soldiers of Pleminius and those of the tribunes; the numbers engaged and the tumult increasing at the same time, as either party was joined by their friends who happened to come up at the time. When the soldiers of Pleminius, who had been worsted, had run to him in crowds, not without loud clamouring and indignant feelings, showing their blood and wounds, and repeating the reproaches which had been heaped upon him during the dispute, Pleminius, fired with resentment, flung himself out of his house, ordered the tribunes to be summoned and stripped, and the rods to be brought out. During the time which was consumed in stripping them, for they made resistance, and implored their men to aid them, on a sudden the soldiers, flushed with their recent victory, ran together from every quarter, as if there had been a shout to arms against enemies; and when they saw the bodies of their tribunes now mangled with rods, then indeed, suddenly inflamed with much, more ungovernable rage, without respect, not only for the dignity of their commander, but of humanity, they made an attack upon the lieutenant-general, having first mutilated the lictors in a shocking manner; they then cruelly lacerated the lieutenant-general himself, having cut him off from his party and hemmed him in, and after mutilating his nose and ears left him almost lifeless. Accounts of these occurrences arriving at Messana, Scipio, a few days after, passing over to Locri in a ship with six banks of oars, took cognizance of the cause of Pleminius and the tribunes. Having acquitted Pleminius and left him in command of the same place, and pronounced the tribunes guilty and thrown them into chains, that they might be sent to Rome to the senate, he returned to Messana, and thence to Syracuse. Pleminius, unable to restrain his resentment, for he thought that the injury he had sustained had been treated negligently and too lightly by Scipio, and that no one could form an estimate of the punishment which ought to be inflicted in such a case, except the man who had in his own person felt its atrocity, ordered the tribunes to be dragged before him, and after lacerating them with every punishment which the human body could endure, put them to death; and not satisfied with the punishment inflicted on them while alive, cast them out unburied. The like cruelty he exercised towards the Locrian nobles, whom he heard had gone to Scipio to complain of the injuries he had done them. The horrid acts, prompted by lust and rapacity, which he had before perpetrated upon his allies, he now multiplied from resentment; thus bringing infamy and odium, not only upon himself, but upon the general also.

Pleminius was in charge; the soldiers he had brought with him from Rhegium were under his direct command, while the rest were led by the tribunes. One of Pleminius's men, while fleeing with a stolen silver cup from a local resident, ran into Sergius and Matienus, the military tribunes, who were pursuing him. After the cup was taken from him as the tribunes commanded, a lot of shouting and name-calling broke out, which eventually escalated into a fight between Pleminius's soldiers and those of the tribunes. The conflict grew as more people joined in from both sides. When Pleminius's soldiers, who were losing, crowded back to him, crying out and showing their injuries while voicing their grievances from the confrontation, Pleminius, filled with anger, rushed out of his house, called for the tribunes to be summoned and stripped, and ordered that the rods be brought out. While they were being stripped, as the tribunes resisted and pleaded with their troops for help, soldiers who were emboldened by their recent victory rushed in from all directions as if responding to a call to arms. When they saw their tribunes being beaten, their rage intensified, and without regard for either their commander’s authority or basic decency, they attacked the lieutenant-general and brutally assaulted the lictors. They then viciously attacked the lieutenant-general himself, isolating him from his men, and after mutilating his nose and ears, left him nearly lifeless. News of these events reached Messana, and a few days later, Scipio, sailing to Locri in a six-oared ship, investigated the situation concerning Pleminius and the tribunes. He cleared Pleminius of wrongdoing and allowed him to remain in command, while declaring the tribunes guilty and chaining them for transport back to Rome to face the Senate. He then returned to Messana and proceeded to Syracuse. Unable to control his anger, Pleminius felt that Scipio had dealt with his grievances too lightly and that only someone who had personally suffered could judge the proper punishment for such offenses. He ordered the tribunes to be brought before him, and after inflicting every kind of torture on them that a human body could endure, he executed them. Not content with their treatment while alive, he had their bodies discarded unburied. He showed similar cruelty towards the Locrian nobles who had gone to Scipio to complain about the wrongs he had committed against them. The horrific acts driven by his lust and greed, which he had previously inflicted on his allies, he now escalated out of revenge, bringing disgrace not only upon himself but upon the general as well.

10

The time of the elections was now drawing near, when a letter from the consul Publius Licinius arrived at Rome, stating that "he himself and his army were afflicted with a severe sickness, nor could they have stood their ground had not the malady attacked the enemy with the same or even greater violence. Therefore, as he could not come himself to the election, he would, with the approbation of the senate, nominate Quintus Caecilius Metellus dictator, for the purpose of holding the election. That it was for the interest of the state that the army of Quintus Caecilius should be disbanded; for that it could not be made any use of under present circumstances, for Hannibal had now withdrawn his troops into winter quarters; and so violent was the malady which had infected that camp, that unless it was speedily broken up, there would not survive one man out of the whole army." The senate left it to the consul to settle these matters, as he should deem consistent with the interest of the state and his own honour. The state was at this time suddenly occupied with a question of a religious nature, in consequence of the discovery of a prediction in the Sibylline books, which had been inspected on account of there having been so many showers of stones this year. It ran thus: "Whensoever a foreign enemy should bring war into the land of Italy, he may be driven out of Italy and conquered, if the Idaean Mother should be brought from Pessinus to Rome." This prophecy, discovered by the decemviri, produced the greater impression upon the senate, because ambassadors also, who had carried a present to Delphi, had brought word back, that they had both obtained a favourable appearance in sacrificing to the Pythian Apollo, and that a response was delivered from the oracle, to the effect, that a much greater victory than that from the spoils of which they now brought presents, awaited the Roman people. They considered the presentiment which existed in the mind of Publius Scipio, with regard to the termination of the war, when he claimed Africa as his province, as corroborating the same anticipation. In order, therefore, that they might the more speedily put themselves in possession of victory, which was portended to them by the fates, omens, and oracles, they began to think what method could be adopted for conveying the goddess to Rome.

As the election time approached, a letter from the consul Publius Licinius arrived in Rome, stating that "he and his army were suffering from a severe illness, and they wouldn't have been able to hold their ground if the enemy hadn't also been hit by the same or even worse sickness. Therefore, since he couldn’t attend the election himself, he planned to nominate Quintus Caecilius Metellus as dictator, with the senate's approval, to oversee the election. It was in the best interest of the state for Quintus Caecilius’s army to be disbanded because they couldn’t be useful under the current circumstances, as Hannibal had moved his troops into winter quarters. The illness that had infected that camp was so severe that if it wasn’t quickly resolved, not a single man from the whole army would survive." The senate left these decisions to the consul, trusting that he would act in a way that was consistent with the state's interests and his own honor. At this time, the state was also suddenly focused on a religious issue due to a prediction found in the Sibylline books, which had been consulted because of the numerous stone showers this year. The prediction stated: "Whenever a foreign enemy brings war to Italy, they can be driven out and defeated if the Idaean Mother is brought from Pessinus to Rome." This prophecy, discovered by the decemviri, had a significant impact on the senate, especially since ambassadors who had delivered a gift to Delphi reported back that they had received a favorable omen during their sacrifice to Pythian Apollo, and that the oracle had indicated a much greater victory awaited the Roman people than the spoils for which they had brought presents. They viewed the expectations of Publius Scipio concerning the end of the war, when he claimed Africa as his province, as supporting this same belief. Therefore, to more quickly secure the victory foretold by the fates, omens, and oracles, they began to consider how to transport the goddess to Rome.

11

As yet the Roman people had none of the states of Asia in alliance with them. Recollecting, however, that formerly Aesculapius, on account of a sickness among the people, was fetched from Greece, which was not then united with them by any treaty; recollecting, also, that a friendship had already commenced between them and king Attalus, on account of the war which they waged in common against Philip, and that he would do whatever he could to oblige the Roman people, they resolved to send, as ambassadors to him, Marcus Valerius Laevinus, who had been twice consul, and had carried on operations in Greece; Marcus Caecilius Metellus, who had been praetor; Servius Sulpicius Galba, who had been aedile; and two who had been quaestors, Caius Tremellius Flaccus and Marcus Valerius Falto. To these five quinqueremes were assigned, in order that, in a manner suitable to the dignity of the Roman people, they might visit those lands where it was important to gain respect for the Roman name. The ambassadors, on their way to Asia, having landed at Delphi, immediately approached the oracle, inquiring what hopes the deity held out to themselves and the Roman people, of accomplishing the business for which they had been sent from home. It is said that the answer given was, "that they would obtain what they were seeking by means of king Attalus. When they had conveyed the goddess to Rome, they must take care that the best man at Rome should receive her to his hospitality." They came to Pergamus to the king, who received the ambassadors graciously, and conducted them to Pessinus in Phrygia, and putting into their hands a sacred stone, which the inhabitants said was the mother of the gods, bid them convey it to Rome. Marcus Valerius Falto, who was sent in advance, brought word that the goddess was on her way, and that the most virtuous man in the state must be sought out, who might in due form receive and entertain her. Quintus Caecilius Metellus was nominated dictator for holding the elections, by the consul in Bruttium, and his army was disbanded. Lucius Veturius Philo was made master of the horse. The elections were held by the dictator; the consuls elected were Marcus Cornelius Cethegus and Publius Sempronius Tuditanus, who was absent, being engaged in his province of Greece. The praetors were then elected: Titus Claudius Nero, Marcus Marcius Ralla, Lucius Scribonius Libo, Marcus Pomponius Matho. On the conclusion of the elections, the dictator abdicated his office. The Roman games were repeated thrice, the plebeian seven times. The curule aediles were Cneius and Lucius Cornelius Lentulus: Lucius had the province of Spain; he was elected in his absence, and was absent while he filled the office. The plebeian aediles were Titus Claudius Asellus and Marcus Junius Pennus. Marcus Marcellus this year dedicated the temple of Virtue at the Porta Capena, in the seventeenth year after it had been vowed by his father during his first consulate at Clastidium in Gaul: also Marcus Aemilius Regillus, flamen of Mars, died this year.

As of now, the Roman people didn’t have any Asian states allied with them. However, they remembered that in the past, Aesculapius was brought from Greece due to an illness among the people, even though there was no treaty in place at that time. They also recalled that a friendship had already started between them and King Attalus because of the joint war they fought against Philip, and that he would do everything he could to help the Romans. They decided to send Marcus Valerius Laevinus, who had been consul twice and had conducted military operations in Greece; Marcus Caecilius Metellus, a former praetor; Servius Sulpicius Galba, a former aedile; and two former quaestors, Caius Tremellius Flaccus and Marcus Valerius Falto, as ambassadors to him. They assigned five quinqueremes to these ambassadors so they could travel to important regions and earn respect for the Roman name. On their way to Asia, the ambassadors stopped at Delphi and approached the oracle, asking what hopes the deity had for them and the Roman people regarding their mission. The oracle reportedly replied that they would succeed through King Attalus. Once they took the goddess to Rome, they must ensure that the best man in Rome welcomed her properly. They arrived in Pergamus, where the king graciously received the ambassadors and led them to Pessinus in Phrygia. He then handed them a sacred stone, which the locals claimed was the mother of the gods, and instructed them to take it to Rome. Marcus Valerius Falto, who was sent ahead, reported that the goddess was on her way and that they needed to find the most virtuous man in the state to receive and host her appropriately. Quintus Caecilius Metellus was appointed dictator to oversee the elections by the consul in Bruttium, and his army was disbanded. Lucius Veturius Philo became the master of the horse. The elections were held by the dictator, resulting in the selection of consuls Marcus Cornelius Cethegus and Publius Sempronius Tuditanus, who was absent as he was engaged in his province of Greece. The praetors elected included Titus Claudius Nero, Marcus Marcius Ralla, Lucius Scribonius Libo, and Marcus Pomponius Matho. Once the elections concluded, the dictator stepped down. The Roman games were held three times, while the plebeian games occurred seven times. The curule aediles were Cneius and Lucius Cornelius Lentulus; Lucius was in Spain and was elected while absent, continuing to be absent while in office. The plebeian aediles were Titus Claudius Asellus and Marcus Junius Pennus. This year, Marcus Marcellus dedicated the temple of Virtue at the Porta Capena, seventeen years after his father vowed it during his first consulate at Clastidium in Gaul. Additionally, Marcus Aemilius Regillus, the flamen of Mars, died this year.

12

For the last two years the affairs of Greece had been neglected. Accordingly, as the Aetolians were deserted by the Romans, on whom alone they depended for assistance, Philip compelled them to sue for and agree to a peace on whatever conditions he pleased. Had he not exerted himself to the utmost in expediting this measure, he would have been overpowered, while engaged in war with the Aetolians, by Publius Sempronius, the proconsul, who had been sent to succeed Sulpicius in the command, with ten thousand infantry and a thousand horse, together with thirty-five ships of war, a force of no small importance to bring to the assistance of allies. Ere the peace was well concluded, news was brought to the king that the Romans had arrived at Dyrrachium; that the Parthinians, and other bordering nations, were up in arms on seeing hopes of effecting a change; and that Dimallum was besieged. The Romans had turned their efforts to that quarter instead of assisting the Aetolians, for which purpose they had been sent, from resentment at the conduct of the Aetolians for making peace with the king without their sanction, contrary to the league. When Philip had received intelligence of these events, lest any greater commotion should arise in the neighbouring nations and states, he proceeded by forced marches to Apollonia, to which place Sempronius had retired, having sent Laetorius, his lieutenant-general, with a part of his forces and fifteen ships into Aetolia, to look into the state of affairs, and, if he could, dissolve the peace. Philip laid waste the lands of the Apollonians, and, advancing his troops to the tower, offered the Romans battle. But seeing that they remained quiet, only defending the walls, and not having sufficient confidence in his strength to assault the town, being desirous also of making peace with the Romans if possible, as he had with the Aetolians, or at least a truce, he withdrew into his own dominions, without further exciting their animosity by a fresh contest. During the same time the Epirots, wearied by the long continuance of the war, having first sounded the disposition of the Romans, sent ambassadors to Philip on the subject of a common peace; affirming that they were well satisfied that it might be arranged if he would come to a conference with Publius Sempronius, the Roman general. They easily prevailed on him to pass into Epirus, for neither were the king's own inclinations averse from this measure. Phoenice is a city of Epirus; here Philip first conferred with Aeropus Dardas and Philip, praetors of the Epirots, and afterwards met Publius Sempronius. Amynander, king of the Athamanians, and other magistrates of the Epirots and Acarnanians, were present at the conference. The praetor Philip spoke first, and requested at once of the king and the Roman general, that they would put an end to the war, and grant this boon to the Epirots. Publius Sempronius proposed as the conditions of the peace, that the Parthinians, and Dimallum, and Bargulum, and Eugenium, should be under the dominion of the Romans; that Atintania, if on sending ambassadors to Rome they could prevail upon the senate to acquiesce, should be added to the dominions of the Macedonian. The peace having been agreed upon on these terms, Prusias king of Bithynia, the Achaeans, the Boeotians, the Thessalians, the Acarnanians, and the Epirots, were included in the treaty by the king; by the Romans, the Ilians, king Attalus, Pleuratus, Nabis tyrant of the Lacedaemonians, the Eleans, the Messenians, and Athenians. These conditions were committed to writing and sealed; and a truce was agreed upon for two months, to allow time for ambassadors being sent to Rome, that the people might order the peace upon these terms. All the tribes agreed in ordering it, because now that the operations of the war were removed into Africa, they were desirous to be relieved for the present from all other wars. The peace being concluded, Publius Sempronius took his departure for Rome, to attend to the duties of his consulship.

For the last two years, Greece's issues had been ignored. As a result, the Aetolians, abandoned by the Romans, who were their only source of support, were forced to negotiate peace on whichever terms Philip chose. If he hadn’t worked tirelessly to speed up the process, he would have been overwhelmed during the war with the Aetolians by Publius Sempronius, the proconsul sent to take over after Sulpicius, who came with ten thousand infantry, a thousand cavalry, and thirty-five warships—a significant force to aid allies. Before the peace was fully established, word reached the king that the Romans had arrived at Dyrrachium; the Parthinians and other neighboring nations were rising up, sensing an opportunity for change; and Dimallum was under siege. The Romans had shifted their focus to that area instead of aiding the Aetolians, as they had been sent to do, due to their anger over the Aetolians making peace with the king without their approval, violating their agreement. Upon receiving these reports, Philip hurriedly marched to Apollonia to prevent further unrest in neighboring states. Sempronius had retreated there, having sent Laetorius, his lieutenant general, with part of his forces and fifteen ships to Aetolia to assess the situation and possibly disrupt the peace. Philip ravaged the land of the Apollonians and advanced his troops to the tower, challenging the Romans to battle. But when he saw they were only defending the walls and not willing to attack, and with his own confidence faltering, he chose to pull back into his territory rather than provoke them further, hoping to negotiate peace with the Romans as he had with the Aetolians. During this time, the Epirotes, tired of the prolonged war, after gauging the Romans' willingness, sent ambassadors to Philip to discuss a common peace, insisting that it could be arranged if he would meet with Publius Sempronius, the Roman general. They easily convinced him to go to Epirus, as he was not against this idea either. Phoenice, a city in Epirus, was where Philip first met with Aeropus Dardas and Philip, the praetors of the Epirotes, and later with Publius Sempronius. Amynander, king of the Athamanians, along with other magistrates from the Epirotes and Acarnanians, were present during the discussions. The praetor Philip spoke first, asking both the king and the Roman general to end the war and grant this favor to the Epirotes. Publius Sempronius suggested that the peace terms should be that the Parthinians, Dimallum, Bargulum, and Eugenium would fall under Roman control; that Atintania would be added to Macedonian territories if they could get the senate's approval in Rome. Once peace was reached on these terms, King Prusias of Bithynia, the Achaeans, the Boeotians, the Thessalians, the Acarnanians, and the Epirotes were included in the treaty by the king; the Romans included the Ilians, King Attalus, Pleuratus, Nabis the tyrant of the Lacedaemonians, the Eleans, the Messenians, and the Athenians. These terms were written down and sealed, and a two-month truce was agreed upon to allow time for ambassadors to be sent to Rome so the people could finalize the peace on these terms. All tribes were in favor of this arrangement, as, with the war operations now focused in Africa, they wanted to be relieved of all other conflicts for the time being. After the peace was settled, Publius Sempronius departed for Rome to fulfill his consul duties.

13

To Publius Sempronius and Marcus Cornelius, the consuls in the fifteenth year of the Punic war, the provinces assigned were, to Cornelius, Etruria, with the old army; to Sempronius, Bruttium, with directions to levy fresh legions. Of the praetors, to Marcus Marcius fell the city jurisdiction; to Lucius Scribonius Libo, the foreign, together with Gaul; to Marcus Pomponius Matho, Sicily; to Titus Claudius Nero, Sardinia. Publius Scipio was continued in command with the army and fleet which he had under him, as was also Publius Licinius, with directions to occupy Bruttium with two legions, so long as the consul should deem it for the advantage of the state that he should continue in the province with command. Marcus Livius and Spurius Lucretius were also continued in command, with the two legions with which they had protected Gaul against Mago; also Cneius Octavius, with orders that, after he had delivered up Sardinia and the legion to Titus Claudius, he should, with forty ships of war, protect the sea-coast within such limits as the senate should appoint. To Marcus Pomponius, the praetor in Sicily, the troops which had fought at Cannae, consisting of two legions, were assigned. It was decreed, that Titus Quinctius and Caius Tubulus, propraetors, should occupy, the former Tarentum, the latter Capua, as in the former year, each having his old army. With respect to the command in Spain, it was submitted to the people to decide on the two proconsuls to be sent into that province. All the tribes agreed in ordering that the same persons, namely, Lucius Cornelius Lentulus and Lucius Manlius Acidinus, should, as proconsuls, hold the command of those provinces as they had the former year. The consuls set about making the levies, both to raise new legions for Bruttium, and recruit the other armies; for so were they directed by the senate.

To Publius Sempronius and Marcus Cornelius, the consuls in the fifteenth year of the Punic War, the provinces assigned were as follows: Cornelius was given Etruria with the old army, and Sempronius received Bruttium, tasked with raising new legions. Among the praetors, Marcus Marcius managed city jurisdiction; Lucius Scribonius Libo oversaw foreign matters and Gaul; Marcus Pomponius Matho was assigned Sicily; and Titus Claudius Nero took charge of Sardinia. Publius Scipio continued to command the army and fleet he had, and so did Publius Licinius, who was directed to occupy Bruttium with two legions as long as the consul believed it was in the state's best interest for him to stay in the province. Marcus Livius and Spurius Lucretius also remained in command with the two legions that protected Gaul against Mago, as did Cneius Octavius, who was ordered, after handing over Sardinia and the legion to Titus Claudius, to safeguard the coastline with forty warships, within the boundaries set by the senate. Marcus Pomponius, the praetor in Sicily, was assigned the troops that had fought at Cannae, consisting of two legions. It was decided that Titus Quinctius and Caius Tubulus, as propraetors, would take charge of Tarentum and Capua, respectively, each with their previous army. Regarding the command in Spain, it was left to the people to choose the two proconsuls for that province. All the tribes agreed that the same individuals, Lucius Cornelius Lentulus and Lucius Manlius Acidinus, should serve as proconsuls in those provinces, just as they had in the previous year. The consuls began to organize recruitment efforts to raise new legions for Bruttium and to replenish the other armies, as directed by the senate.

14

Although Africa had not as yet been openly declared a province, the senate keeping it a secret, I suppose, lest the Carthaginians should get intelligence of it beforehand, nevertheless, the most sanguine hopes were entertained in the city, that the enemy would be vanquished that year in Africa, and that the termination of the Punic war was at hand. This circumstance had filled the minds of the people with superstitious notions, and they were strongly disposed to credit and propagate accounts of prodigies, and for that reason more were reported. It was said, "that two suns had been seen; that it had become light for a time during the night; that at Setia a meteor had been seen, extending from the east to the west; that at Tarracina a gate, at Anagnia a gate and the wall in many places, had been struck by lightning; that in the temple of Juno Sospita, at Lanuvium, a noise had been heard, accompanied with a tremendous crash." There was a supplication for one day for the purpose of expiating these, and the nine days' sacred rite was celebrated on account of a shower of stones. In addition to these cares, they had to deliberate about the reception of the Idaean Mother; for besides that Marcus Valerius, one of the ambassadors who had come before the rest, had brought word that she would be in Italy forthwith a recent account had arrived that she was at Tarracina. The senate was occupied with the determination of a matter of no small importance, namely, who was the most virtuous man in the state. Every one doubtless would wish for himself the victory in this contest, rather than any office of command, or any honours, which could be conferred by the suffrages either of the senate or the people. Publius Scipio, son of Cneius who had fallen in Spain, a youth not yet of the age to be quaestor, they adjudged to be the best of the good men in the whole state. Though I would willingly record it for the information of posterity, had the writers who lived in the times nearest to those events mentioned by what virtues of his they were induced to come to this determination, yet I will not obtrude my own opinion, formed upon conjecture, relative to a matter buried in the obscurity of antiquity. Publius Cornelius was ordered to go to Ostia, attended by all the matrons, to meet the goddess; to receive her from the ship himself, and, when landed, place her in the hands of the matrons to convey her away. After the ship arrived at the mouth of the Tiber, Scipio, according to the directions given him, sailed out into the open sea, and, receiving the goddess from the priests, conveyed her to land. The chief matrons in the state received her, among whom the name of Claudia Quinta alone is worthy of remark. Her fame, which, as it is recorded, was before that time dubious, became, in consequence of her having assisted in so solemn a business, illustrious for chastity among posterity. The matrons, passing her from one to another in orderly succession, conveyed the goddess into the temple of Victory, in the Palatium, on the day before the ides of April, which was made a festival, while the whole city poured out to meet her; and, placing censers before their doors, on the way by which she was conveyed in procession, kindled frankincense, and prayed that she would enter the city of Rome willingly and propitiously. The people in crowds carried presents to the goddess in the Palatium; a lectisternium was celebrated, with games called the Megalesian.

Although Africa had not yet been officially declared a province, with the senate keeping it a secret to prevent the Carthaginians from finding out, there were still very optimistic hopes in the city that the enemy would be defeated that year in Africa, and that the end of the Punic War was near. This situation had filled the people's minds with superstitious beliefs, leading them to strongly believe in and share stories of omens, resulting in more reports being made. It was said that "two suns had been seen; it had been light for a time during the night; a meteor had appeared at Setia, stretching from the east to the west; a gate at Tarracina and a gate and several sections of the wall at Anagnia had been struck by lightning; and in the temple of Juno Sospita at Lanuvium, a loud noise had been heard, followed by a tremendous crash." A day of supplication was held to atone for these events, and a nine-day sacred rite was celebrated due to a shower of stones. Alongside these concerns, they had to discuss the welcome of the Idaean Mother; since Marcus Valerius, one of the ambassadors who arrived first, had reported that she would soon be in Italy, and a recent update had come in stating she was at Tarracina. The senate was focused on deciding a matter of considerable importance: who was the most virtuous man in the state. Everyone certainly wished to win this recognition for himself rather than any military command or honors that could be awarded by the senate or the people. Publius Scipio, son of Cneius who had died in Spain, a young man not yet old enough to be a quaestor, was deemed the best of the virtuous men in the state. Though I would like to document this for the benefit of future generations, if the writers from that time had noted the specific virtues that led to this conclusion, I won't impose my own opinion based on speculation regarding a matter lost in the fog of history. Publius Cornelius was tasked with going to Ostia, accompanied by all the matrons, to meet the goddess; he was to receive her from the ship himself and, once she had landed, hand her over to the matrons to escort her away. When the ship arrived at the mouth of the Tiber, Scipio, following the given directions, sailed out into the open sea, received the goddess from the priests, and brought her to shore. The chief matrons of the state welcomed her, among whom Claudia Quinta stands out. Her reputation, previously somewhat questionable, became famous for her chastity after she participated in such a significant event. The matrons, passing her along one by one in an orderly manner, brought the goddess into the temple of Victory in the Palatium on the day before the Ides of April, which was celebrated as a festival, while the entire city gathered to greet her; placing censers before their doors along the procession route, they burned incense and prayed for her to enter the city of Rome graciously and favorably. Crowds of people brought gifts to the goddess in the Palatium; a lectisternium was held, along with the Megalesian games.

15

When the business of recruiting the legions in the provinces was under consideration, it was suggested by certain senators that now was the time, when, by the favour of the gods, their fears were removed, to put a stop to certain things, however they might have been tolerated in perilous circumstances. The senators, being intent in expectation, subjoined, that the twelve Latin colonies which had refused to furnish soldiers to the consuls, Quintus Fabius and Quintus Fulvius, were enjoying, for now the sixth year, exemption from military service, as though it had been granted to them a mark of honour and favour; while in the mean time their good and dutiful allies, in return for their fidelity and obedience to the Roman people, had been exhausted by continual levies every year. By these words the recollection of the senate was renewed touching a matter which was now almost obliterated, and their indignation equally excited. Accordingly, without allowing the consuls to lay any other business before the senate in priority, they decreed, "that the consuls should summon to Rome the magistrates, and ten principal inhabitants, from each of the colonies, Xepete, Sutrium, Ardea, Cales, Alba, Carseoli, Sora, Suessa, Setia, Circeii, Narnia, and Interamna; for these were the colonies implicated in this affair; and command them that each of those colonies should furnish double the greatest number of foot soldiers which they had ever provided for the Roman people since the enemy had been in Italy, and one hundred and twenty horsemen each. If any of them was unable to make up that number of horsemen, that it should be allowed to furnish three foot soldiers for every horseman deficient. That both the foot and horse soldiers should be chosen from the wealthiest of the inhabitants, and should be sent out of Italy wheresoever there was want of recruits. If any of them refused to comply, it was their pleasure that the magistrates and ambassadors of such should be detained; and that, if they requested it, they should not be allowed an audience of the senate till they had obeyed these orders. Moreover, that an annual tax should be imposed upon them, and collected after the rate of one as for every thousand; and that a census should be taken in those colonies, according to a formula appointed by the Roman censors, which should be the same which was employed in the case of the Roman people; and that a return should be made at Rome by sworn censors of the colonies, before they retired from their office." The magistrates and principal men of these colonies having been summoned to Rome, when the consuls imposed upon them the contribution of men, and the management of the tax, they vied with each other in making excuses, and remonstrating against it. They said "it was impossible that so large a number of men could be raised. That they could scarcely accomplish it, if even the simple contribution only, according to the established ratio, were required of them. They entreated and besought them that they might be allowed to appear before the senate and deprecate their resolution. They had committed no crime for which they deserved to be ruined; but, even if they were to be ruined, neither their own crime nor the resentment of the Roman people could make them furnish a greater number of soldiers than they had got." The consuls, persisting, ordered the ambassadors to remain at Rome, and the magistrates to go home to make the levies; observing, that "unless the amount of soldiers enjoined were brought to Rome, no one would give them an audience of the senate." All hope of appearing before the senate, and deprecating their decision, being then cut off, the levies were completed in the twelve colonies without difficulty, as the number of their youth had increased during their long exemption from service.

When the recruitment of legions in the provinces was being discussed, some senators suggested that now was the time, thanks to the favor of the gods removing their fears, to put an end to certain practices that had been tolerated in dangerous times. The senators, focused and expectant, added that the twelve Latin colonies, which had refused to provide soldiers to the consuls Quintus Fabius and Quintus Fulvius, had enjoyed six years of exemption from military service, as if it had been granted to them as a mark of honor and favor. Meanwhile, their loyal allies, for their fidelity and obedience to the Roman people, had been exhausted by continuous yearly levies. This reminded the senate of an issue that was almost forgotten, stirring their indignation. Consequently, without allowing the consuls to present any other business first, they decreed that the consuls should summon the magistrates and ten leading citizens from each of the colonies—Xepete, Sutrium, Ardea, Cales, Alba, Carseoli, Sora, Suessa, Setia, Circeii, Narnia, and Interamna—since these were the colonies involved. They ordered that each colony should provide double the greatest number of foot soldiers they had ever sent to the Roman people since the enemy appeared in Italy, plus one hundred and twenty horsemen each. If any colony couldn't provide that number of horsemen, they could supply three foot soldiers for every missing horseman. Both foot and horse soldiers were to be chosen from the wealthiest residents and sent out of Italy wherever recruits were needed. If any of them refused, the senators decided that the magistrates and ambassadors of those colonies should be detained, and that they wouldn’t be allowed to meet with the senate until they followed these orders. Additionally, there would be an annual tax imposed, collected at the rate of one as for every thousand, and a census would be taken in those colonies according to a method established by the Roman censors, the same used for the Roman people, with a report made in Rome by sworn censors of the colonies before they left office. After the magistrates and principal citizens of these colonies were summoned to Rome, when the consuls imposed the contribution of men and the management of the tax, they all competed to come up with excuses and protested against it. They argued that it was impossible to raise such a large number of men and that they could hardly manage even the minimal required contribution under the established ratio. They pleaded to be allowed to address the senate and appeal against the decision. They insisted they had committed no wrongdoing that warranted their destruction; but even if they were to be ruined, neither their own faults nor the resentment of the Roman people could force them to provide more soldiers than they had available. The consuls, however, were adamant, ordering the ambassadors to stay in Rome while the magistrates went back to gather the levies, stating that "unless the required number of soldiers was brought to Rome, no one would allow them an audience with the senate." With all hope of appearing before the senate to contest the decision cut off, the levies were completed in the twelve colonies without issue, as the number of young people had increased during their long exemption from service.

16

Another affair, likewise, which had been passed over in silence for an almost equally long period, was laid before the senate by Marcus Valerius Laevinus; who said, "that equity required that the monies which had been contributed by private individuals, when he and Marcus Claudius were consuls, should now at length be repaid. Nor ought any one to feel surprised that a case, where the public faith was pledged, should have engaged his attention in an especial manner; for, besides that the matter appertained, in some degree, peculiarly to the consul of that year in which the money was contributed, he was himself the author of the measure, as the treasury was drained, and the people unable to pay the taxes." This suggestion was well received by the senate, and, bidding the consuls to propose the question, they decreed, "that this money should be paid by three instalments; that the present consuls should make the first payment immediately, and the third and fifth consuls, from that time, the two remaining."

Another issue, which had also been ignored for a long time, was brought before the Senate by Marcus Valerius Laevinus. He stated that fairness required that the money contributed by private citizens when he and Marcus Claudius were consuls should finally be repaid. No one should be surprised that a case involving a public commitment caught his attention, especially since the matter was particularly relevant to the consul of the year the money was contributed. He was the one who proposed the measure because the treasury was empty, and the people couldn’t pay their taxes. The Senate received this suggestion positively and asked the consuls to present the question. They decided that this money should be repaid in three installments; the current consuls would make the first payment right away, and the third and fifth consuls thereafter would cover the remaining two payments.

After this, all their other cares gave place to one alone when the sufferings of the Locrians, of which they had been ignorant up to that day, were made known by the arrival of their ambassadors. Nor was it the villany of Pleminius so much as the partiality or negligence of Scipio in that affair, which excited the resentment of the people. While the consuls were sitting in the comitium, ten ambassadors of the Locrians, covered with filth, and in mourning, and extending branches of olive, the badges of suppliants, according to the Grecian custom, prostrated themselves on the ground before the tribunal, with loud lamentations. In answer to the inquiry of the consuls, they said, "that they were Locrians, who had suffered such things at the hands of Pleminius the lieutenant-general, and the Roman soldiers, as the Roman people would not wish even the Carthaginians to experience. They requested that they would allow them to appear before the senate, and complain of their sufferings."

After this, all their other worries were replaced by one thing when they learned about the suffering of the Locrians, which had been unknown to them until the arrival of their ambassadors. It wasn't so much the wrongdoing of Pleminius that stirred the anger of the people, but rather Scipio's favoritism or negligence in the matter. While the consuls were sitting in the comitium, ten ambassadors from the Locrians, covered in dirt and dressed in mourning, holding olive branches—the symbols of supplication according to Greek tradition—fell to the ground before the tribunal, crying out loudly in grief. In response to the consuls' inquiry, they said, "We are Locrians who have suffered such horrors at the hands of Pleminius the lieutenant-general and the Roman soldiers that the Roman people themselves would not wish even the Carthaginians to endure. We request permission to appear before the senate and voice our suffering."

17

An audience having been granted, the eldest of them thus spoke: "I know, conscript fathers, that the importance you will attach to the complaints we make before you must depend, in a very great degree, upon your accurately knowing the manner in which Locri was betrayed to Hannibal, and placed again under your dominion after the expulsion of his garrison. Inasmuch as if the guilt of defection does not rest upon the public, and it is made apparent that our restoration to your dominion was effected, not only in concurrence with our wishes, but by our own co-operation and valour, you will be the more indignant that such atrocious and shameful injuries should have been inflicted upon good and faithful allies by your lieutenant-general and soldiers. But I think it proper that the subject of our changing sides, in both instances, should be deferred to another time, on two accounts: first, that it may be discussed in the presence of Publius Scipio, who retook Locri, and who witnessed all our acts, both good and bad; and secondly, because, whatever we are, we ought not to have suffered what we have. We cannot conceal, conscript fathers, that when we had a Carthaginian garrison in our citadel we were exposed to many sufferings, of a shocking and shameful kind, from Hamilcar, the captain of the garrison, and the Numidians and Africans. But what are they compared with what we endure this day? I request, conscript fathers, that you will hear without offence what I am reluctant to mention. All mankind are now in a state of anxious suspense, whether they are to see you or the Carthaginians lords of the world. If an estimate is to be formed of the Roman and Carthaginian governments from what we Locrians have suffered from the Carthaginians on the one hand, or on the other, from what we are suffering, at the present time especially, from your garrison; there is no one who would not wish the Carthaginians to be his masters rather than the Romans. And yet observe what are the feelings which the Locrians have entertained towards you. When we were suffering injuries of much less magnitude from the Carthaginians, we fled for protection to your general; now we are suffering more than hostile indignities from your garrison, we have carried our complaints to no others than yourselves. Conscript fathers! either you will consider our forlorn condition or there is no other resource left us for which we can even pray to the immortal gods. Quintus Pleminius, the lieutenant-general, was sent with a body of troops to recover Locri from the Carthaginians, and was left there in command of the same as a garrison. In this your lieutenant-general there is neither any thing of a man, conscript fathers, but the figure and outward appearance, (for the extremity of our misery prompts me to speak freely,) nor of a Roman citizen, but the attire and dress, and the sound of the Latin language. He is a pest and savage monster, such as are fabled to have beset the strait by which we are separated from Sicily, for the destruction of mariners. And yet if he had been content to be the only person to vent his villany, his lust, and rapacity upon your allies, that one gulf, deep as it was, we would however have filled up by our patience. But the case is, he has made every one of your centurions and soldiers a Pleminius, so indiscriminately has he willed that licentiousness and wickedness should be practised. All plunder, spoil, beat, wound, and slay; all defile matrons, virgins, and free-born youths torn from the embraces of their parents. Our city is captured daily, plundered daily. Day and night, every place indiscriminately rings with the lamentations of women and children, seized and carried away. Any one, acquainted with our sufferings, might be astonished how it is that we are capable of bearing them, or that the authors of them are not yet satiated with inflicting such enormous cruelties. Neither am I able to go through with them, nor is it worth your while to listen to the particulars of our sufferings. I will embrace them all in a general description. I declare that there is not a house or a man at Locri exempt from injury. I say that there cannot be found any species of villany, lust, or rapacity which has not been exercised on every one capable of being the object of them. It would be difficult to determine in which case the city was visited with the more horrible calamity, whether when it was captured by an enemy, or when a sanguinary tyrant crushed it by violence and arms. Every evil, conscript fathers, which captured cities suffer, we have suffered, and do now as much as ever suffer. All the enormities which the most cruel and savage tyrants are wont to perpetrate upon their oppressed subjects, Pleminius has perpetrated upon ourselves, our children, and our wives.

Once the audience was gathered, the eldest among them spoke: "I know, honorable senators, that the importance you place on our complaints will largely depend on how well you understand how Locri was betrayed to Hannibal and restored to your control after his troops were expelled. If the blame for our defection does not fall on the public and it becomes clear that our return to your rule happened not only with our consent but also through our own efforts and bravery, you will be even more outraged that such horrific and shameful acts have been committed against loyal allies by your lieutenant-general and soldiers. However, I believe we should postpone discussing our change of sides for another time for two reasons: first, so we can have this discussion in front of Publius Scipio, who recaptured Locri and witnessed all our actions, both good and bad; and second, because regardless of who we are, we should not have had to endure what we have. We cannot hide, honorable senators, that when a Carthaginian garrison occupied our fortress, we faced numerous shocking and disgraceful sufferings at the hands of Hamilcar, the garrison commander, and the Numidians and Africans. But what does that compare to what we are experiencing today? I ask you, honorable senators, to hear without anger what I hesitate to say. Everyone is currently anxious, wondering whether they will see you or the Carthaginians as the rulers of the world. If you were to judge the Roman and Carthaginian governments based on what we Locrians have suffered from the Carthaginians, versus what we are currently enduring, especially now from your troops, no one would prefer Roman rule over Carthaginian. Yet, look at the feelings we Locrians have had towards you. When we were suffering far less from the Carthaginians, we sought protection from your general; now, when we’re experiencing more than just hostility from your garrison, we bring our complaints only to you. Honorable senators! Either you will take our desperate situation into account, or we have no other options left to even pray to the immortal gods. Quintus Pleminius, the lieutenant-general, was sent with troops to reclaim Locri from the Carthaginians and was left in command there. In this lieutenant-general, there is nothing of a man, honorable senators, but his appearance and attire, (for the depth of our misery compels me to speak plainly,) and nothing of a Roman citizen except for his clothing and the way he speaks Latin. He is a plague and a savage monster, like those monsters said to lurk in the strait separating us from Sicily, destroying sailors. Yet, if he had been satisfied to be the only one unleashing his depravity, desire, and greed upon your allies, we would have continued to endure that one deep pit with our patience. But the fact is, he has turned every one of your centurions and soldiers into a Pleminius, so indiscriminately has he encouraged lawlessness and wickedness. They all plunder, spoil, beat, wound, and kill; all violate matrons, virgins, and free-born youths torn from their parents' arms. Our city is attacked daily, looted daily. Day and night, every corner echoes with the cries of women and children, seized and taken away. Anyone who knows of our suffering might wonder how we can bear it, or why those causing it are not yet satisfied with inflicting such great cruelty. I cannot recount every detail, nor is it worthwhile for you to hear about the specifics. I will summarize our situation. I declare that not a single house or man in Locri is free from harm. I say that there is no kind of wickedness, lust, or greed that has not been inflicted on everyone who could be a victim. It would be hard to determine which scenario brought greater disaster to the city, whether when it fell to an enemy or when a bloodthirsty tyrant crushed it through violence and arms. We have experienced every suffering that captured cities endure, and continue to suffer as much as ever. All the atrocities that the most cruel and savage tyrants usually inflict upon their oppressed subjects, Pleminius has inflicted upon us, our children, and our wives."

18

"There is one circumstance, however, in complaining of which particularly we may be allowed to yield to our deeply-rooted sense of religion, and indulge a hope that you will listen to it; and, if it shall seem good to you, conscript fathers, free your state from the guilt of irreligious conduct. For we have seen with how great solemnity you not only worship your own deities, but entertain even those of foreign countries. We have a fane dedicated to Proserpine, of the sanctity of which temple I imagine some accounts must have reached you, during the war with Pyrrhus; who, when sailing by Locri, on his return from Sicily, among other horrid enormities which he committed against our state, on account of our fidelity towards you, plundered also the treasures of Proserpine, which had never been touched up to that day; and then, putting the money on board his ships, proceeded on his journey himself by land. What, therefore, was the result, conscript fathers? The next day his fleet was shattered by a most hideous tempest, and all the ships which carried the sacred money were thrown on our shores. That most insolent king, convinced by this so great disaster that there were gods, ordered all the money to be collected and restored to the treasures of the goddess. However, he never met with any success afterwards; but, after being driven out of Italy, he died an ignoble and dishonourable death, having incautiously entered Argos by night. Though your lieutenant-general and military tribune had heard of these, and a thousand other circumstances, which were related not for the purpose of creating increased reverence, but frequently experienced by ourselves and our ancestors, through the special interposition of the goddess, they had, nevertheless, the audacity to apply their sacrilegious hands to those hallowed treasures, and pollute themselves, their own families, and your soldiers, with the impious booty. Through whom we implore you, conscript fathers, by your honour, not to perform any thing in Italy or in Africa, until you have expiated their guilty deed, lest they should atone for the crime they have committed, not with their own blood only, but by some disaster affecting their country. Although, even now, conscript fathers, the resentment of the goddess does not tarry either towards your generals or your soldiers. Already have they several times engaged each other in pitched battles, one party headed by Pleminius, and the other by the two military tribunes. Never did they employ their weapons with more fury against the Carthaginians than when encountering each other; and they would have afforded Hannibal an opportunity of retaking Locri, had not Scipio, whom we called in, come in time to prevent it. But, by Hercules, is it that the soldiers are impelled by frenzy, and that the influence of the goddess has not shown itself in punishing the generals themselves? Nay, herein her interposition was manifested in the most conspicuous manner. The tribunes were beaten with rods by the lieutenant-general. Then the lieutenant-general, treacherously seized by the tribunes, besides being mangled in every part of his body, had his nose and ears cut off, and was left for dead. Then, recovering from his wounds, he threw the tribunes into chains; beat them, tortured them with every species of degrading punishment, and put them to death in a cruel manner, forbidding them to be buried. Such atonements has the goddess exacted from the despoilers of her temple; nor will she cease to pursue them, with every species of vengeance, till the sacred money shall have been replaced in the treasury. Formerly, our ancestors, during a grievous war with the Crotonians, because the temple was without the town, were desirous of removing the money into it; but a voice was heard from the shrine, during the night, commanding them to hold off their hands, for the goddess would defend her own temple. As they were deterred, by religious awe, from removing the treasures thence, they were desirous of surrounding the temple with a wall. The walls were raised to a considerable height, when they suddenly fell down in ruins. But, both now, and frequently on other occasions, the goddess has either defended her own habitation and temple, or has exacted heavy expiations from those who had violated it. Our injuries she cannot avenge, nor can any but yourselves avenge them, conscript fathers. To you, and to your honour, we fly, as suppliants. It makes no difference to us whether you suffer Locri to be subject to that lieutenant-general and that garrison, or whether you deliver us up for punishment to incensed Hannibal and the Carthaginians. We do not request that you should at once believe us respecting one who is absent, and when the cause has not been heard. Let him come; let him hear our charges in person, and refute them himself. If there is any enormity one man can commit against another which he has not committed upon us we do not refuse to suffer all the same cruelties over again, if it is possible we can endure them, and let him be acquitted of all guilt towards gods and men."

"There is one situation where we can, with a genuine sense of faith, hope that you will take notice of our complaint and, if you feel it is right, conscript fathers, free our state from the guilt of irreligious actions. We have witnessed how sincerely you worship your own gods and even those from other lands. We have a shrine dedicated to Proserpine, and I believe you must have heard some accounts regarding the sanctity of this temple during the war with Pyrrhus. When he was sailing past Locri on his return from Sicily, among the many horrible things he did to our state due to our loyalty to you, he also plundered the treasures of Proserpine, which had remained untouched until that day. After taking the money aboard his ships, he continued his journey overland. So, what was the outcome, conscript fathers? The next day, his fleet was wrecked by a terrible storm, and all the ships carrying the sacred funds were cast onto our shores. That arrogant king, realizing the severity of this disaster and the presence of gods, ordered all the money to be collected and returned to the goddess’s treasury. However, he faced no success after that; after being driven out of Italy, he died a shameful and dishonorable death for carelessly entering Argos at night. Although your lieutenant-general and military tribunes had heard about this and many other experiences, which were not told to create more reverence but were often personally witnessed by us and our ancestors due to the goddess’s special intervention, they still had the audacity to lay their sacrilegious hands on those sacred treasures, polluting themselves, their families, and your soldiers with the stolen goods. Through them, we implore you, conscript fathers, by your honor, not to take any actions in Italy or Africa until you have atoned for their guilt, lest they atone for their crime, not only with their own blood but through some disaster befalling their country. Even now, conscript fathers, the goddess's anger does not linger against your generals or soldiers. They have already clashed multiple times in battle, one side led by Pleminius and the other by the two tribunes. Never did they fight with more fury against the Carthaginians than when they faced each other; they nearly gave Hannibal the chance to retake Locri if Scipio, whom we called upon, hadn't arrived in time to stop it. But, by Hercules, is it that the soldiers are driven by madness, and that the goddess hasn't shown her wrath toward the generals? Indeed, her intervention was evident. The tribunes were beaten with rods by the lieutenant-general. Then, the lieutenant-general, treacherously captured by the tribunes, was brutally injured, had his nose and ears severed, and was left for dead. After recovering from his injuries, he imprisoned the tribunes, beat them, tortured them with all kinds of humiliating punishments, and killed them in a cruel way, forbidding them to be buried. Such atonements has the goddess demanded from those who desecrated her temple; and she will not cease to pursue them with vengeance until the sacred money is returned to the treasury. In the past, our ancestors, during a tough war with the Crotonians, wanted to move the money into the temple as it was outside the city. But a voice from the shrine was heard at night, commanding them to refrain because the goddess would protect her own temple. Being deterred by religious awe from moving the treasures, they decided to surround the temple with a wall. The walls were raised to a significant height when they suddenly collapsed. But, both now and on many other occasions, the goddess has either defended her dwelling and temple or has demanded severe expiations from those who violated it. Our injuries she cannot avenge, nor can anyone but you, conscript fathers, exact justice. We turn to you, as supplicants, seeking your honor. It doesn’t matter to us whether you let Locri remain under that lieutenant-general and garrison, or if you hand us over for punishment to the furious Hannibal and the Carthaginians. We do not ask you to believe us immediately regarding someone who is not present, especially when the issue has yet to be heard. Let him come; let him hear our accusations in person and refute them. If there is any atrocity one person can commit against another that he hasn’t inflicted on us, we don’t refuse to suffer the same cruelties again, if we can endure them, and let him be cleared of all guilt toward gods and men."

19

When the ambassadors had thus spoken, and Quintus Fabius had asked them whether they had carried those complaints to Publius Scipio, they answered, "that deputies were sent to him, but he was occupied with the preparations for the war, and had either already crossed over into Africa, or was about to do so within a few days. That they had experienced how highly the lieutenant-general was in favour with the general, when, after hearing the cause between him and the tribunes, he threw the tribunes into chains, while he left the lieutenant-general, who was equally or more guilty, in possession of the same power as before." The ambassadors, having been directed to withdraw from the senate-house, not only Pleminius, but even Scipio, was severely inveighed against by the principal men; but, above all, by Quintus Fabius, who endeavoured to show, "that he was born for the corruption of military discipline. It was thus," he said, "that in Spain he almost lost more men in consequence of mutiny than the war. That, after the manner of foreigners and kings, he indulged the licentiousness of the soldiers, and then punished them with cruelty." He then followed up his speech by a resolution equally harsh: that "it was his opinion, that Pleminius should be conveyed to Rome in chains, and in chains plead his cause; and, if the complaints of the Locrians were founded in truth, that he should be put to death in prison, and his effects confiscated. That Publius Scipio should be recalled, for having quitted his province without the permission of the senate; and that the plebeian tribunes should be applied to, to propose to the people the abrogation of his command. That the senate should reply to the Locrians, when brought before them, that the injuries which they complained of having received were neither approved of by the senate nor the people of Rome. That they should be acknowledged as worthy men, allies, and friends; that their children, their wives, and whatsoever else had been taken from them, should be restored; that the sum of money which had been taken from the treasures of Proserpine should be collected, and twice the amount placed in the treasury. That an expiatory sacred rite should be celebrated, first referring it to the college of pontiffs, to determine what atonements should be made, to what gods, and with what victims, in consequence of the sacred treasures' having been removed and violated. That the soldiers at Locri should be all transported into Sicily, and four cohorts of the allies of the Latin confederacy taken to Locri for a garrison." The votes could not be entirely collected that day in consequence of the warm feeling excited for and against Scipio. Besides the atrocious conduct of Pleminius, and the calamities of the Locrians, much was said about the dress of the general himself, as being not only not Roman, but even unsoldierlike. It was said, that "he walked about in the gymnasium in a cloak and slippers, and that he gave his time to light books and the palaestra. That his whole staff were enjoying the delights which Syracuse afforded, with the same indolence and effeminacy. That Carthage and Hannibal had dropped out of his memory; that the whole army, corrupted by indulgence, like that at Sucro in Spain, or that now at Locri, was more to be feared by its allies than by its enemies."

When the ambassadors finished speaking, Quintus Fabius asked them if they had taken their complaints to Publius Scipio. They replied, "We sent representatives to him, but he was busy preparing for war and had either already crossed over to Africa or was about to do so in a few days. We saw how much the lieutenant-general was favored by the general when, after hearing the case between him and the tribunes, he put the tribunes in chains while letting the lieutenant-general, who was just as guilty, keep the same powers as before." The ambassadors were told to leave the senate house, and not only Pleminius but also Scipio were harshly criticized by the prominent leaders, especially by Quintus Fabius, who tried to show that "he was meant to undermine military discipline. This way," he said, "he nearly lost more men to mutiny in Spain than to the enemy. Acting like foreign leaders and kings, he indulged the soldiers' bad behavior and then punished them cruelly." He followed up his speech with a similarly harsh resolution: "I believe Pleminius should be brought to Rome in chains to plead his case, and if the Locrians' complaints are true, he should be executed in prison and his property confiscated. Publius Scipio should be recalled for leaving his province without the senate's permission, and the plebeian tribunes should be asked to propose to the people that his command be revoked. The senate should tell the Locrians that their complaints of mistreatment were not supported by the senate or the people of Rome. They should be recognized as worthy men, allies, and friends; that their children, wives, and anything else taken from them should be returned; that the money taken from Proserpine's treasury should be gathered and doubled in the treasury. An expiatory sacred rite should be held, first referring it to the college of pontiffs to decide what atonements should be made, to which gods, and with what victims, due to the removal and violation of the sacred treasures. All soldiers in Locri should be moved to Sicily, and four cohorts from the Latin allies should be sent to Locri as a garrison." They couldn't collect all the votes that day because of the heated feelings for and against Scipio. Besides Pleminius's atrocious behavior and the Locrians' suffering, much was said about the general's attire, which was considered neither Roman nor soldierly. It was reported that "he walked around the gym in a cloak and slippers, spending his time on light reading and exercise. His entire staff enjoyed the pleasures of Syracuse with the same laziness and effeminacy. Carthage and Hannibal had seemingly slipped from his mind; the whole army, corrupted by indulgence, like that in Sucro, Spain, or currently in Locri, was more of a threat to its allies than to its enemies."

20

Though these charges, partly true, and partly containing a mixture of truth and falsehood, and therefore, probably, were urged with vehemence; the opinion, however, of Quintus Metellus prevailed, who, agreeing with Maximus on other points, differed from him in the case of Scipio. "For how inconsistent would it be," said he, "that the person whom the state a little while ago selected as their general, though a very young man, for the recovery of Spain; whom, after he had taken Spain out of the hands of their enemies, they elected their consul, for the purpose of putting an end to the Punic war; whom they marked out with the most confident anticipation as the person who would draw Hannibal out of Italy, and subdue Africa; how inconsistent would it be, that this man, like another Pleminius, condemned in a manner without a hearing, should suddenly be recalled from his province! when the Locrians asserted that the wicked acts which had been committed against them were done not even in the presence of Scipio, and no other charge could be brought against him, than that he spared the lieutenant-general, either from good nature or respect. He thought it advisable, that Marcus Pomponius the praetor, to whose lot the province of Sicily had fallen, should go to his province within the next three days; that the consuls should select out of the senate ten deputies, whomsoever they thought proper, and send them with the praetor, together with two tribunes of the people, and an aedile. That the praetor, assisted by this council, should take cognizance of the affair. If those acts of which the Locrians complained were committed at the command or with the concurrence of Scipio, that they should command him to quit the province. If Publius Scipio had already crossed over into Africa, that the tribunes of the people and the aedile, with two of the deputies, whom the praetor should judge most fit for it, should proceed into Africa; the tribunes and the aedile to bring Scipio back from thence, and the deputies to take the command of the army until a new general had come to it. But if Marcus Pomponius and the ten deputies should discover that those acts had been committed neither with the orders nor concurrence of Publius Scipio, that Scipio should then remain with the army and carry on the war as he had proposed." A decree of the senate having passed to this effect, application was made to the tribunes of the people to arrange among themselves, or determine by lot, which two should go with the praetor and the deputies. The advice of the college of pontiffs was taken on the subject of the expiations to be made, on account of the treasures in the temple of Proserpine, at Locri, having been touched, violated, and carried out of it. The tribunes of the people, who went with the praetor and ten deputies, were Marcus Claudius Marcellus and Marcus Cincius Alimentus. To these a plebeian aedile was given, whom, if Scipio, whether he was still in Sicily or had now crossed over into Africa, should refuse to obey the orders of the praetor, the tribunes might direct to apprehend him, and bring him home in right of their most sacred authority. The plan was, to go to Locri before they went to Messana.

Though these accusations were partly true and partly a mix of truth and lies, and were probably presented with a lot of intensity, Quintus Metellus's opinion won out. He agreed with Maximus on other points but disagreed concerning Scipio. "How inconsistent would it be," he said, "that the person the state recently chose as their general, despite being very young, to recover Spain; the one whom they elected consul after he freed Spain from their enemies, to end the Punic war; the one they confidently expected would draw Hannibal out of Italy and conquer Africa; how inconsistent would it be for this man to be suddenly recalled from his province like another Pleminius, condemned without a hearing! When the Locrians claimed that the terrible acts against them were done without even Scipio being present, and no other charge could be made against him except for sparing the lieutenant-general, whether out of kindness or respect. He suggested that Marcus Pomponius the praetor, who was assigned to the province of Sicily, should go there within the next three days; that the consuls should choose ten senators whom they thought suitable, and send them with the praetor, along with two tribunes of the people and an aedile. The praetor, aided by this council, would look into the matter. If it was discovered that the acts the Locrians complained about were ordered or approved by Scipio, they should command him to leave the province. If Publius Scipio had already crossed over into Africa, then the tribunes of the people and the aedile, along with two of the deputies whom the praetor deemed most suitable, should go to Africa; the tribunes and the aedile to bring Scipio back, and the deputies to take command of the army until a new general arrived. But if Marcus Pomponius and the ten deputies found that the acts had not been committed under the orders or with the agreement of Publius Scipio, then Scipio should remain with the army and continue the war as he intended." After the senate passed a decree to this effect, the tribunes of the people were asked to arrange among themselves or draw lots to determine which two would accompany the praetor and the deputies. The college of pontiffs was consulted regarding the expiations needed because the treasures in the temple of Proserpine at Locri had been touched, violated, and taken out. The tribunes of the people who went with the praetor and ten deputies were Marcus Claudius Marcellus and Marcus Cincius Alimentus. They were assigned a plebeian aedile, whom the tribunes could direct to arrest Scipio and bring him back if he refused to obey the praetor's orders, using their most sacred authority. The plan was to go to Locri before heading to Messana.

21

With regard to Pleminius, there are two different accounts. Some relate that, having heard what measures had been adopted at Rome, as he was going into exile to Naples, he accidentally fell in with Quintus Metellus, one of the deputies, by whom he was forcibly conveyed back to Rhegium. Others say, that Scipio himself sent a lieutenant-general with thirty of the most distinguished of the cavalry to throw Quintus Pleminius into chains, and with him the principal movers of the mutiny. All these, whether by the orders of Scipio before, or of the praetor now, were delivered over to the Rhegians to be kept in custody. The praetor and the deputies going to Locri, gave their attention first to the affair relating to religion, agreeably to their instructions; for, collecting all the sacred money, whether in the possession of Pleminius or the soldiers, they replaced it in the treasury, together with that which they had brought with them, and performed an expiatory sacred rite. The praetor then, summoning the soldiers to an assembly, ordered them to march out of the city, and pitched a camp in the plain, issuing an edict which threatened severe punishment to any soldier who either had remained behind in the city, or had carried out with him what did not belong to him. He gave permission to the Locrians to seize whatever each of them identified as his property, and demand restitution to be made of any thing which was concealed. Above all, he was resolved that the free persons should be restored to the Locrians without delay. That the man who did not restore them should be visited with no light punishment. He then held an assembly of the Locrians, and told them, that "the people and senate of Rome restored to them their liberty and their laws. That if any one was desirous of bringing charges against Pleminius, or any one else, he should follow them to Rhegium. If they were desirous of complaining, in the name of their state, of Publius Scipio, as having ordered and approved of the nefarious acts which had been committed at Locri against gods and men, that they should send deputies to Messana, where, with the assistance of his council, he would hear them." The Locrians returned thanks to the praetor and deputies, and to the senate and people of Rome, and said that they would go and bring their charge against Pleminius. That Scipio, though he had evinced too little sympathy in the injuries inflicted on their state, was such a man as they would rather have their friend than their enemy; that they were convinced that the many and horrid acts which had been committed were done neither by the orders nor with the approval of Publius Scipio; that he had either placed too much confidence in Pleminius, or too little in them; that the natural disposition of some men was such, that they rather were unwilling that crimes should be committed, than had sufficient resolution to punish them when committed. Both the praetor and his council were relieved from a burden of no ordinary weight in not having to take cognizance of charges against Scipio. Pleminius, and as many as thirty-two persons with him, they condemned and sent in chains to Rome. They then proceeded to Scipio, that they might carry to Rome a statement attested by their own observation relative to the facts which had been so generally talked of, concerning the dress and indolent habits of the general, and the relaxation of military discipline.

With respect to Pleminius, there are two different stories. Some say that after hearing about the measures taken in Rome, as he was heading into exile in Naples, he unexpectedly ran into Quintus Metellus, one of the deputies, who forcibly brought him back to Rhegium. Others claim that Scipio himself sent a lieutenant-general with thirty of the most distinguished cavalry to put Quintus Pleminius in chains, along with the main instigators of the mutiny. All of these individuals, whether under Scipio's orders before or the praetor's now, were handed over to the Rhegians for custody. The praetor and the deputies, traveling to Locri, first addressed the matter of religion as instructed; they gathered all the sacred money, whether held by Pleminius or the soldiers, returned it to the treasury, along with what they had brought, and conducted an expiatory sacred rite. The praetor then called the soldiers to an assembly, ordered them to leave the city, set up camp in the plain, and issued a notice threatening severe punishment to any soldier who either stayed behind in the city or took anything that did not belong to him. He authorized the Locrians to seize anything they identified as their property and demand the return of any hidden items. Above all, he insisted that free individuals should be promptly returned to the Locrians, and anyone who did not comply would face serious consequences. He then held a meeting with the Locrians and informed them that "the people and senate of Rome restored their freedom and laws. If anyone wanted to charge Pleminius or anyone else, they should follow them to Rhegium. If they wished to formally complain, on behalf of their state, about Publius Scipio for ordering and approving the terrible acts committed at Locri against gods and men, they should send representatives to Messana, where, with the help of his council, he would listen to them." The Locrians thanked the praetor and deputies, as well as the senate and people of Rome, stating that they would go and make their charges against Pleminius. They conveyed that Scipio, despite showing limited sympathy for the wrongs done to them, was someone they preferred as an ally rather than an adversary; they believed the many heinous acts committed were not done with the orders or consent of Publius Scipio; that he had either trusted Pleminius too much or underestimated them; and that some individuals are inclined not to want crimes to happen rather than having the resolve to punish them when they do. Both the praetor and his council were relieved from an unusual burden by not having to investigate charges against Scipio. They condemned Pleminius, along with thirty-two others, and sent them in chains to Rome. They then proceeded to Scipio to deliver a statement based on their observations regarding the widely discussed issues of the general's attire and sluggish habits, and the deterioration of military discipline.

22

While they were on their way to Syracuse, Scipio prepared to clear himself, not by words but facts. He ordered all his troops to assemble there, and the fleet to be got in readiness, as though a battle had been to be fought that day with the Carthaginians, by sea and land. On the day of their arrival he entertained them hospitably, and on the next day presented to their view his land and naval forces, not only drawn up in order, but the former performing evolutions, while the fleet in the harbour itself also exhibited a mock naval fight. The praetor and the deputies were then conducted round to view the armouries, the granaries, and other preparations for the war. And so great was the admiration excited in them of each particular, and of the whole together, that they firmly believed, that under the conduct of that general, and with that army, the Carthaginians would be vanquished, or by none other. They bid him, with the blessing of the gods, cross over, and, as soon as possible, realize to the Roman people the hopes they conceived on that day when all the centuries concurred in naming him first consul. Thus they set out on their return in the highest spirits, as though they were about to carry to Rome tidings of a victory, and not of a grand preparation for war. Pleminius, and those who were implicated in the same guilt with him, when they arrived at Rome, were thrown immediately into prison. At first, when brought before the people by the tribunes, they found no place in their compassion, as their minds were previously engrossed by the sufferings of the Locrians; but afterwards, being repeatedly brought before them, and the hatred with which they were regarded subsiding, their resentment was softened. Besides, the mutilated appearance of Pleminius, and their recollections of the absent Scipio, operated in gaining them favour with the people. Pleminius, however, died in prison, before the people had come to a determination respecting him. Clodius Licinius, in the third book of his Roman history, relates, that this Pleminius, during the celebration of the votive games, which Africanus, in his second consulate, exhibited at Rome, made an attempt, by means of certain persons whom he had corrupted by bribes, to set fire to the city in several places, that he might have an opportunity of breaking out of prison, and making his escape; and that afterwards, the wicked plot having been discovered, he was consigned to the Tullian dungeon, according to a decree of the senate. The case of Scipio was considered no where but in the senate; where all the deputies and tribunes, bestowing the highest commendations on the fleet, the army, and the general, induced the senate to vote that he should cross over into Africa as soon as possible; and that permission should be given him to select himself, out of those armies which were in Sicily, those forces which he would carry with him into Africa, and those which he would leave for the protection of the province.

While they were heading to Syracuse, Scipio prepared to clear his name, not with words but with actions. He ordered all his troops to gather there and got the fleet ready, as if a battle was about to happen that day with the Carthaginians, both on land and sea. On the day they arrived, he welcomed them warmly, and the next day showed them his land and naval forces, not just arranged in formation but the army also performing maneuvers, while the fleet in the harbor staged a mock naval battle. The praetor and the delegates were then taken on a tour to see the armories, granaries, and other war preparations. They were so impressed by each detail and the overall display that they firmly believed that with that general and that army, the Carthaginians would be defeated, and no one else could do it. They urged him, with the gods' blessing, to cross over and quickly fulfill the hopes of the Roman people that had begun on the day when all the centuries united in naming him first consul. They returned home in high spirits, as if they were bringing news of a victory rather than just a major war preparation. When Pleminius and his accomplices arrived in Rome, they were immediately thrown into prison. Initially, when brought before the people by the tribunes, they received no sympathy, as everyone was focused on the suffering of the Locrians; however, after being brought before them several times, their anger faded. Moreover, Pleminius's disfigured appearance and memories of the absent Scipio helped garner some favor with the crowd. Pleminius, however, died in prison before the people could make a decision about his fate. Clodius Licinius, in the third book of his Roman history, states that during the votive games held by Africanus in his second consulship in Rome, Pleminius tried to set fire to the city in various locations with the help of some bribed accomplices to create a diversion for his escape from prison; but after the sinister plot was uncovered, he was sent to the Tullian dungeon by a senate decree. Scipio’s case was discussed only in the senate, where all the deputies and tribunes praised the fleet, army, and general, persuading the senate to vote that he should cross over to Africa as soon as possible and allowing him to select forces from the armies in Sicily to take with him and those he would leave behind to protect the province.

23

While the Romans were thus employed, the Carthaginians, on their part, though they had passed an anxious winter, earnestly inquiring what was going on, and terrified at the arrival of every messenger, with watch-towers placed on every promontory, had gained a point of no small importance for the defence of Africa, in adding to their allies king Syphax, in reliance on whom chiefly they believed the Romans would cross over into Africa. Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, not only formed a connexion of hospitality with the before-named king, when Scipio and Hasdrubal happened to come to him at the same time out of Spain, but mention had also been slightly made of an affinity to take place between them, by the king's marrying the daughter of Hasdrubal. Hasdrubal, who had gone for the purpose of completing this business, and fixing a time for the nuptials, for the virgin was now marriageable, perceiving that the king was inflamed with desire, for the Numidians are, beyond all the other barbarians, violently addicted to love, sent for the virgin from Carthage, and hastened the nuptials. Among the other proofs of joy felt upon the occasion, and in order that a public connexion might be added to this private one, an oath was taken in confirmation of an alliance between the Carthaginian people and the king, and faith reciprocally pledged that they would have the same friends and enemies. But Hasdrubal, recollecting both the alliance which had been entered into by the king and Scipio, and how inconstant and changeable were the minds of the barbarians, was afraid that, if Scipio were to invade Africa, that marriage would prove but a slight bond of union, he therefore took advantage of the Numidian while under the influence of the first transports of love, and calling to his aid the caresses of the bride, prevailed upon him to send ambassadors into Sicily to Scipio, and by them to warn him "not to cross over into Africa in reliance upon his former promises. That he was united to the Carthaginians both by a marriage with a Carthaginian citizen, the daughter of Hasdrubal, whom he saw entertained at his house, and likewise by a public treaty. That his first wish was that the Romans would carry on the war with the Carthaginians at a distance from Africa, as they had hitherto done, lest he should be compelled to interfere with their disputes, and join one of the two contending parties, renouncing his alliance with the other. If Scipio should not keep away from Africa, and should advance his army to Carthage, it would be incumbent upon him to fight for the land of Africa, which gave him birth, and for the country of his spouse, for her parent, and household gods."

While the Romans were busy with their own matters, the Carthaginians, despite having a stressful winter filled with concerns about what was happening, were terrified with every new messenger they received. With watchtowers on every point, they had secured an important advantage for defending Africa by gaining the support of King Syphax, who they believed would be crucial if the Romans decided to invade Africa. Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, had formed a hospitality agreement with King Syphax when both he and Scipio arrived at the king's location from Spain. There was also a mention of a potential marriage between them, as Syphax might marry Hasdrubal's daughter. Hasdrubal, aiming to finalize this arrangement and set a date for the wedding—since the girl was now of age—noticed that the king was eager, as Numidians are known to be particularly passionate. He called for the girl from Carthage and expedited the marriage plans. Along with the other expressions of joy during this occasion, to formalize their public connection alongside this private one, an oath was taken to confirm an alliance between the Carthaginian people and the king, pledging mutual friends and enemies. However, Hasdrubal remembered both Syphax's prior alliance with Scipio and the unpredictable nature of the barbarians. He worried that if Scipio invaded Africa, that marriage would offer only a weak tie. Therefore, while the Numidian was still under the initial rush of love, Hasdrubal used the bride's charms to persuade him to send ambassadors to Sicily to Scipio, warning him "not to invade Africa based on earlier promises. He was now connected to the Carthaginians through a marriage with a Carthaginian citizen, Hasdrubal's daughter, who was currently being hosted at his residence, as well as through a public treaty. His primary desire was for the Romans to continue fighting the Carthaginians away from Africa, as they had done so far, to avoid being forced to choose sides and betray one ally for the other. If Scipio did not stay away from Africa and moved his army towards Carthage, he would have to fight for the land of Africa that was his birthplace, as well as for his wife’s homeland, parents, and household gods."

24

The ambassadors, sent to Scipio by the king with these instructions, met him at Syracuse. Scipio, though disappointed in an affair which was of the greatest importance with regard to his operations in Africa, and in the sanguine expectations he had formed from it, sent the ambassadors back into Africa speedily, before their business was made known, giving them letters for the king, in which he warned him over and over again "not to violate the laws of hospitality which bound them together; the obligation of the alliance entered into with the Roman people; nor make light of justice, honour, their right hands pledged, and the gods the witnesses and arbitrators of compacts." But, as the coming of the Numidians could not be concealed, for they lounged about the city, and had frequently appeared at the pavilion; and as, if nothing were said about the object of their visit, there was danger lest the truth, from the very circumstance of its being made a secret, should spontaneously spread the more; and, in consequence, the troops become alarmed lest they should have to wage war at once with the king and the Carthaginians, Scipio endeavoured to divert their attention from the truth by preoccupying their minds with false information; and, summoning his soldiers to an assembly, said, "that it was not expedient to delay any longer. That the kings, their allies, urged them to cross over into Africa with all speed. That Masinissa himself had before come to Laelius, complaining that time was consumed in delays, and that now Syphax sent ambassadors, expressing his astonishment on the same account, namely, what could be the cause of such long delay; and requesting either that the army would now at length be transported into Africa, or, if the plan was changed, that he might be informed so that he might himself take measures for the safety of himself and his dominions. Therefore, as every thing was now ready and prepared, and as the business admitted of no further delay, he was resolved, after having removed the fleet to Lilybaeum, and collected here all his forces of foot and horse, with the blessing of the gods to pass over into Africa the first day the ships could sail." He sent a letter to Marcus Pomponius, directing him, if he thought proper, to come to Lilybaeum, that they might consult together as to what legions, in preference to any others, and how large a number of soldiers, they should convey into Africa; he also sent round to every part of the sea-coast, with directions that all the ships of burthen should be seized and collected at Lilybaeum. When all the soldiers and ships in Sicily were assembled at Lilybaeum, and neither the city could contain the multitude of men, nor the harbour the ships, so ardent was the desire possessed by all of passing over to Africa, that they did not appear as if going to wage war, but to reap the certain rewards of victory. Particularly those who remained of the soldiers who had fought at Cannae felt convinced that under Scipio, and no other general, they would be enabled, by exerting themselves in the cause of the state, to put an end to their ignominious service. Scipio was very far from feeling contempt for that description of soldiers, inasmuch as he knew that the defeat sustained at Cannae was not attributable to their cowardice, and that there were no soldiers in the Roman army who had served so long, or were so experienced not only in the various kinds of battles, but in assaulting towns also. The legions which had fought at Cannae were the fifth and sixth. After declaring that he would take these with him into Africa, he inspected them man by man; and leaving those whom he considered unfit for service, he substituted for them those whom he had brought from Sicily, filling up those legions so that each might contain six thousand two hundred infantry and three hundred horse. The horse and foot of the allies, of the Latin confederacy, he also chose out of the army of Cannae.

The ambassadors sent to Scipio by the king with these instructions met him in Syracuse. Scipio, although let down by an issue that was crucial to his plans in Africa and by the hopeful expectations he had built around it, quickly sent the ambassadors back to Africa before their business could become public. He gave them letters for the king, repeatedly warning him "not to break the rules of hospitality that bound them together; not to disregard the obligations of the alliance made with the Roman people; and not to take justice, honor, their pledged hands, and the gods who witnessed and arbitrated their agreements lightly." However, the arrival of the Numidians couldn't be hidden; they loitered around the city and had often shown up at the pavilion. If nothing was said about the purpose of their visit, there was a risk that the truth, due to its secrecy, would spread even more broadly, causing the troops to panic at the thought of having to fight both the king and the Carthaginians immediately. Scipio tried to distract their minds from the truth by preoccupying them with false information. Calling his soldiers to a meeting, he said, "It’s no longer wise to wait. The kings, our allies, are urging us to cross over into Africa as soon as possible. Masinissa already came to Laelius, complaining about how much time has been wasted, and now Syphax has sent ambassadors expressing his surprise about the delay, asking what could be causing it. He requested either that the army would finally be sent to Africa or, if plans had changed, that he be informed so he could take care of himself and his lands. So, since everything is ready and there's no time for further delay, I plan to move the fleet to Lilybaeum and gather all my infantry and cavalry there. With the blessing of the gods, we will set sail for Africa on the first day the ships are able." He sent a letter to Marcus Pomponius, asking him to come to Lilybaeum if he thought it was a good idea so they could discuss which legions to take and how many soldiers to bring into Africa. He also instructed that all cargo ships along the coast be seized and brought to Lilybaeum. When all the soldiers and ships in Sicily gathered at Lilybaeum, the city couldn't hold the massive number of men nor the harbor the ships, as everyone was desperate to get to Africa. They didn’t seem like they were going to war, but rather to claim certain victory. In particular, the remaining soldiers who had fought at Cannae were convinced that under Scipio, not any other general, they could finally redeem themselves and end their shameful service. Scipio had great respect for these soldiers, knowing that the defeat at Cannae wasn't due to their cowardice and recognizing that no other soldiers in the Roman army had served as long or were as skilled, not only in various types of battles but in storming cities as well. The legions that fought at Cannae were the fifth and sixth. After declaring that he would take them into Africa, he personally inspected each one. He left behind those he deemed unfit for service and replaced them with soldiers he had brought from Sicily, filling these legions to contain six thousand two hundred infantry and three hundred cavalry each. He also selected the cavalry and infantry of the allies from the army at Cannae.

25

There is a wide difference among historians as to the number of men transported into Africa. In some I find ten thousand infantry and two hundred horse; in others, sixteen thousand infantry and sixteen hundred horse. In others, again, I find it stated that thirty-five thousand infantry and cavalry were put on board the fleet, making the number more than one half greater. Some have not added an account of the number; among whom, as the matter is doubtful, I should rather have myself ranked. Caelius, though he abstains from specifying the number, increases the impression of their multitude indefinitely. He says, that birds fell to the ground from the shout of the soldiers, and that so great a multitude went on board the fleet, that it seemed as if there was not a man left in Italy or Sicily. Scipio took upon himself the care of seeing that the soldiers embarked orderly and without confusion. The seamen, who were made to embark first, Caius Laelius, the admiral of the fleet, kept in order on board the ships. The task of the putting on board the provisions was assigned to Marcus Pomponius, the praetor. Food for forty-five days, of which enough for fifteen was cooked, was put on board. When they were all embarked, he sent boats round with directions that the pilots and masters, with two soldiers from each ship, should assemble in the forum to receive orders. After they had assembled, he first asked them whether they had put on board water for the men and cattle, sufficient to last as many days as the corn would. When they answered that there was water on board sufficient for five and forty days' consumption, he then charged the soldiers that, conducting themselves submissively, and keeping quiet, they would not make any noise or disturb the mariners in the execution of their duties. He informed them, that he himself and Lucius Scipio in the right wing, with twenty ships of war, and Caius Laelius, admiral of the fleet, together with Marcus Porcius Cato, who was then quaestor, with the same number of ships of war in the left wing, would protect the transports. That the ships of war should carry each a single light, the transports two each. That in the ship of the commander-in-chief there would be three lights as a distinction by night. He desired the pilots to make for Emporia, where the land is remarkably fertile; and on that account the district abounds with plenty of every thing, and the barbarous inhabitants are unwarlike, which is usually the case where the soil is rich. It was supposed that they might, therefore, be overpowered before assistance could be brought them from Carthage. After these commands were delivered, they were ordered to return to their ships, and the next day, with the blessing of the gods, on the signal being given, to set sail.

There is a significant disagreement among historians about how many men were taken to Africa. Some sources say there were ten thousand infantry and two hundred cavalry; others report sixteen thousand infantry and sixteen hundred cavalry. Additionally, some state that thirty-five thousand infantry and cavalry were loaded onto the fleet, which would be more than half greater than the previous figures. Some historians do not even attempt to provide a number, and I would prefer to put myself among them since the matter is uncertain. Caelius, while not specifying a number, suggests an immeasurable crowd. He states that birds fell from the sky due to the soldiers' shouting, and that the crowd boarding the fleet was so vast that it seemed like there wasn't a single person left in Italy or Sicily. Scipio took responsibility for ensuring that the soldiers boarded in an orderly and calm manner. The sailors were the first to embark, and Caius Laelius, the fleet's admiral, kept them organized on the ships. The responsibility for loading provisions fell to Marcus Pomponius, the praetor. They loaded enough food for forty-five days, cooking enough for the first fifteen. Once everyone was on board, he sent out boats instructing the pilots and masters, along with two soldiers from each ship, to gather in the forum for orders. When they assembled, he first asked if they had enough water for the men and animals, sufficient for as many days as their grain supply. After they confirmed they had enough water for forty-five days, he instructed the soldiers to behave respectfully and quietly, so they wouldn't disrupt the sailors as they worked. He informed them that he and Lucius Scipio on the right flank, with twenty warships, along with Caius Laelius, the fleet's admiral, and Marcus Porcius Cato, who was then quaestor, with the same number of warships on the left flank, would protect the transports. The warships would sail with one light each, while the transports would have two lights apiece. The flagship would have three lights for distinction at night. He asked the pilots to head towards Emporia, known for its fertile land, which leads to plenty of resources, and where the local inhabitants are usually not warlike, a common trait in regions with rich soil. It was believed that they could be overwhelmed before any help could arrive from Carthage. After giving these orders, they were told to return to their ships and prepare to set sail the following day, with the gods' blessing, at the signal.

26

Many Roman fleets had set sail from Sicily, and from that very harbour. But not only during this war, nor is that surprising, (for most of the fleets went out for the purpose of getting plunder,) but even in any former war, never did a fleet on setting out exhibit so grand a spectacle. And yet, if the estimate is to be formed with reference to the magnitude of the fleet, it must be owned that two consuls with their armies had passed from thence before, and there were almost as many ships of war in those fleets as the transports with which Scipio was crossing. For, besides fifty men of war, he conveyed his army over in four hundred transports. But what made the Romans consider one war as more formidable than the other, the second than the first, was, that it was carried on in Italy, and that so many armies had been destroyed, and their commanders slain. The general, Scipio, also, who enjoyed the highest degree of renown, partly from his brave achievements, and partly from a peculiar felicity of fortune, which conducted him to the acquisition of boundless glory, attracted extraordinary regard. At the same time, the very project of passing over into the enemy's country, which had not been formed by any general before during that war, had made him an object of admiration; for he had commonly declared, that he passed over with the object of drawing Hannibal out of Italy, of removing the seat of war into Africa, and terminating it there. A crowd of persons of every description had assembled in the harbour to view the spectacle; not only the inhabitants of Lilybaeum, but all the deputies from Sicily, who had come together out of compliment to witness the departure of Scipio, and had followed Marcus Pomponius, the praetor of the province. Besides these, the legions which were to be left in Sicily had come forth to do honour to their comrades on the occasion; and not only did the fleet form a grand sight to those who viewed it from the land, but the shore also, crowded as it was all around, afforded the same to those who were sailing away.

Many Roman fleets had set sail from Sicily, and from that very harbor. But not just during this war, and that's not surprising, (since most of the fleets left to plunder,) even in past wars, a fleet had never set out that looked so impressive. However, if we’re assessing the size of the fleet, it must be acknowledged that two consuls with their armies had departed from there before, and there were nearly as many warships in those fleets as there were transports when Scipio was crossing. In addition to fifty warships, he transported his army in four hundred transports. What made the Romans see one war as more serious than the other, the second compared to the first, was that it took place in Italy, and so many armies had been defeated, and their leaders killed. The general, Scipio, who was celebrated for his brave deeds and a unique stroke of luck that led him to great glory, drew particular attention. At the same time, the very plan to invade enemy territory, something no prior general had attempted during this war, made him an object of admiration; he had repeatedly stated that his goal was to draw Hannibal out of Italy, to shift the battleground to Africa, and to end it there. A crowd of people from all walks of life gathered in the harbor to witness the event; not only the locals of Lilybaeum but also all the representatives from Sicily, who had come out of courtesy to see Scipio off, and had followed Marcus Pomponius, the praetor of the province. Plus, the legions that were to stay in Sicily came out to honor their fellow soldiers on this occasion; and the fleet was not only a magnificent sight for those watching from land, but the shore, packed with people all around, offered the same view for those setting sail.

27

As soon as day appeared, silence having been obtained by a herald, Scipio thus spoke from the ship of the commander-in-chief: "Ye gods and goddesses who preside over the seas and lands, I pray and entreat you, that whatever things have been, are now, or shall be performed during my command, may turn out prosperously to myself, the state, and commons of Rome, to the allies and the Latin confederacy, and to all who follow my party and that of the Roman people, my command and auspices, by land, by sea, and on rivers. That you would lend your favourable aid to all those measures, and promote them happily. That you would bring these and me again to our homes, safe and unhurt; victorious over our vanquished enemies, decorated with spoils, loaded with booty, and triumphant. That you would grant us the opportunity of taking revenge upon our adversaries and foes, and put it in the power of myself and the Roman people to make the Carthaginian state feel those signal severities which they endeavoured to inflict upon our state." After these prayers, he threw the raw entrails of a victim into the sea, according to custom, and, with the sound of a trumpet, gave the signal for sailing. Setting out with a favourable wind, which blew pretty strong, they were soon borne away out of sight of the land; and in the afternoon a mist came over them, so that they could with difficulty prevent the ships from running foul of each other. The wind abated when they got into the open sea. The following night the same haziness prevailed; but when the sun rose it was dispelled, and the wind blew stronger. They were now within sight of land, and, not long after, the pilot observed to Scipio, that "Africa was not more than five miles off; that he could discern the promontory of Mercury, and that if he gave orders to direct their course thither, the whole fleet would presently be in harbour." Scipio, when the land was in sight, after praying that his seeing Africa might be for the good of the state and himself, gave orders to make for another place of landing, lower down. They were borne along by the same wind; but a mist, arising nearly about the same time as on the preceding day, hid the land from them; and the wind fell as the mist grew more dense. Afterwards, the night coming on increased the confusion in every respect; they therefore cast anchor, lest the ships should either run foul of each other, or be driven on shore. At daybreak the wind, rising in the same quarter, dispelled the mist and discovered the whole coast of Africa. Scipio asked what was the name of the nearest promontory, and, on being told that it was called the cape of Pulcher, he observed, "the omen pleases me, direct your course to it." To this place the fleet ran down, and all the troops were landed. I have adopted the accounts given by a great many Greek and Latin authors, who state that the voyage was prosperous, and unattended with any cause of alarm or confusion. Caelius alone, except that he does not state that the ships were sunk in the waves, says that they were exposed to all the terrors of the heavens and the sea, and that at last the fleet was driven by tempest from Africa to the island Aegimurus, from which, with great difficulty, they got into the right course; and that, the ships almost foundering, the soldiers, without orders from their general, got into boats, just as if they had suffered shipwreck, and escaped to land without arms, and in the utmost disorder.

As soon as day broke and silence was established by a herald, Scipio spoke from the ship of the commander-in-chief: "Gods and goddesses who oversee the seas and lands, I ask and plead with you that whatever happens during my command—whether it has already happened, is happening now, or will happen in the future—turn out well for me, for the state, and for the people of Rome, for our allies and the Latin confederacy, and for everyone who supports me and the Roman people, by land, sea, and rivers. Please lend your favorable aid to all our efforts and make them successful. Bring us, and these men, back to our homes safe and unharmed; victorious over our defeated enemies, adorned with spoils, laden with treasures, and triumphant. Grant us the chance to take revenge on our adversaries and enemies, and give me and the Roman people the power to make the Carthaginian state feel the severe consequences they tried to impose on us." After these prayers, he cast the raw entrails of a sacrifice into the sea, as was customary, and, with the sound of a trumpet, gave the signal to set sail. They set off with a strong favorable wind, quickly disappearing from sight of land. In the afternoon, a mist rolled in, making it difficult to prevent the ships from colliding with one another. The wind died down when they reached open water. The same hazy conditions persisted that night; but when the sun rose, the mist lifted and the wind picked up again. They were now in sight of land, and soon after, the pilot told Scipio, "Africa is only about five miles away; I can see the promontory of Mercury, and if you order us to head there, the entire fleet will soon be in harbor." With Africa in sight, Scipio prayed that seeing it would be good for the state and for himself, then ordered the fleet to head to a different landing spot further down. They continued with the same wind; but a mist, rising around the same time as the day before, obscured the land from view, and the wind dropped as the mist thickened. As night fell, confusion increased even more; so they dropped anchor to avoid collisions between ships or being driven ashore. At daybreak, the wind picked up from the same direction, clearing the mist and revealing the entire coast of Africa. Scipio asked the name of the nearest promontory, and when told it was called the Cape of Pulcher, he remarked, "I like this omen; steer your course toward it." The fleet sailed to that location, and all the troops disembarked. I have relied on the accounts of many Greek and Latin authors, who state that the voyage was successful and without any cause for alarm or confusion. Caelius alone, although he does not mention any ships sinking, claims that they faced all the terrors of the heavens and the sea, and that eventually, the fleet was forced by a storm from Africa to the island of Aegimurus, from where they struggled to get back on course; and that the ships almost foundered, with soldiers, without orders from their general, jumping into boats as if they had shipwrecked, and escaping to land without weapons and in complete disorder.

28

The troops being landed, the Romans marked out their camp on the nearest rising grounds. By this time, not only the parts bordering on the sea were filled with consternation and alarm, first in consequence of the fleet being seen, and afterwards from the bustle of landing, but they had extended to the cities also. For not only multitudes of men, mixed with crowds of women and children, had filled up all the roads in every direction, but the rustics also drove away their cattle before them, so that you would say that Africa was being suddenly deserted. In the cities, indeed, they occasioned much greater terror than they felt themselves. At Carthage, particularly, the tumult was almost as great as if it had been captured. For since the time of Marcus Atilius Regulus and Lucius Manlius, which was almost fifty years ago, the Carthaginians had seen no Roman armament, with the exception of fleets sent for plundering, from which troops had made descents upon the lands bordering on the sea, and after carrying away every thing which chance threw in their way, had always returned to their ships before their noise had collected the peasantry. For this reason the hurry and consternation in the city was, on the present occasion, the greater. And, by Hercules, they had neither an efficient army at home, nor a general, whom they could oppose to their enemy. Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, was by far the first man in their state in respect of birth, fame, opulence, and, at that time, also by reason of an affinity with the king. But they recollected that he had been routed in several battles and driven out of Spain by this very Scipio; and that therefore, as a general, he was no more a match for the general of the enemy than their tumultuary army was for that of the Romans. Therefore they shouted to arms, as if Scipio were coming immediately to attack the city; the gates were hastily closed, armed men placed upon the walls, guards and outposts stationed in different places, and the following night was spent in watching. The next day, five hundred horsemen, sent to the coast to reconnoitre and interrupt the enemy while landing, fell in with the advanced guards of the Romans; for by this time Scipio, having sent his fleet to Utica, had proceeded a short distance from the sea, and occupied the nearest heights. He had also placed outposts of cavalry in proper situations, and sent troops through the country to plunder.

The troops landed, and the Romans set up their camp on the nearest high ground. By this time, the areas along the coast were filled with panic and fear, first when the fleet was spotted and later because of the chaos of landing. This alarm spread to the cities as well. Not only were throngs of men, women, and children crowding all the roads in every direction, but the farmers were also driving their cattle away, making it seem like Africa was being suddenly abandoned. In the cities, they caused even more terror than they themselves felt. The chaos in Carthage, in particular, was nearly as intense as if it had been captured. Since the time of Marcus Atilius Regulus and Lucius Manlius, almost fifty years ago, the Carthaginians had not seen a Roman military force, except for fleets sent for looting, which had landed on the coastal lands, taken whatever they could find by chance, and always returned to their ships before enough noise gathered the local farmers. For this reason, the panic and urgency in the city were even greater this time. And, by Hercules, they had neither a strong army at home nor a general who could stand up to their enemy. Hasdrubal, son of Gisgo, was by far the most prominent figure in their state in terms of lineage, reputation, wealth, and at that time, also due to his connection to the king. But they remembered that he had been defeated in several battles and driven out of Spain by this very Scipio; therefore, as a general, he was no match for the enemy's general, just as their makeshift army was no match for the Romans. So they shouted for arms, as if Scipio were about to attack the city immediately; the gates were quickly closed, armed men were placed on the walls, and guards and outposts were set up in various locations, leading to a night spent in vigilance. The next day, five hundred horsemen sent to the coast to scout and disrupt the enemy while landing encountered the Roman advance guards; by this time, Scipio, having sent his fleet to Utica, had moved a short distance inland and occupied the nearest heights. He had also positioned cavalry outposts in suitable locations and sent troops into the countryside to loot.

29

These, engaging the body of Carthaginian horse, slew a few of them in the fight, and the greater part of them as they pursued them when they were flying; among whom was Hanno, their captain, a young man of distinction. Scipio not only devastated the lands in the country round him, but also took a very wealthy city of the Africans which lay nearest to him; where, besides other things which were immediately put on board the transports and sent into Sicily, eight thousand free persons and slaves were captured. But the most gratifying circumstance to the Romans was, the arrival of Masinissa just at the commencement of their operations. Some say that he came with not more than two hundred horse, but most authors say with a body of two thousand cavalry. But, as this man was by far the greatest king of his age, and rendered most essential service to the Romans, it seems worth while to digress a little, to give a full account of the great vicissitudes of fortune he experienced in the loss and recovery of his father's kingdom. While he was serving in Spain in the cause of the Carthaginians, his father, named Gala, died. The kingdom, according to the custom of the Numidians, came to Oesalces, the brother of the late king, who was very aged. Not long after, Oesalces also dying, the elder of his two sons, named Capusa, the other being quite a boy, succeeded to his father's kingdom. But, as he occupied the throne more by right of descent than from the esteem in which he was held among his countrymen, or the power he possessed, there stood forth a person named Mezetulus, not unrelated by blood to the kings, of a family which had always been hostile to them, and had continually contested the right to the throne with those who then occupied it, with various success. This man, having roused his countrymen to arms, over whom he possessed a great influence, from the hatred felt towards the kings, openly pitched his camp, and compelled the king to come into the field and fight for the throne. Capusa, with many of his nobles, falling in the action, the whole nation of the Massylians came under the dominion and rule of Mezetulus. He abstained, however, from assuming the title of king; and, contenting himself with the modest appellation of protector, gave the name of king to the boy Lacumaces, a surviving branch of the royal stock. In the hope of an alliance with the Carthaginians, he formed a matrimonial connexion with a noble Carthaginian lady, daughter of Hannibal's sister, who had been lately married to the king Oesalces; and, sending ambassadors for that purpose, renewed an old connexion of hospitality with Syphax, taking all these measures with a view to obtain assistance against Masinissa.

These forces, engaging the Carthaginian cavalry, killed a few in battle and captured most as they were fleeing; among them was Hanno, their distinguished young captain. Scipio not only laid waste to the surrounding lands but also captured a wealthy city of the Africans that was closest to him. Along with various other things that were immediately loaded onto ships and sent to Sicily, eight thousand free people and slaves were taken. However, what pleased the Romans the most was the arrival of Masinissa right at the start of their campaign. Some say he came with no more than two hundred horsemen, but most sources claim he arrived with around two thousand cavalry. Since he was undoubtedly the greatest king of his time and provided crucial support to the Romans, it’s worth taking a moment to recount the significant ups and downs he faced in losing and regaining his father’s kingdom. While serving in Spain for the Carthaginians, his father, Gala, passed away. According to Numidian tradition, the kingdom went to Oesalces, the late king's brother, who was quite old. Shortly after, Oesalces also died, and his elder son, Capusa, took the throne, while the younger was still a child. However, Capusa ruled more by heritage than by respect or power within his community. A man named Mezetulus, who was related to the royal family and had always opposed them, emerged as a challenger. He rallied his fellow citizens against the kings, leveraging his influence from their shared hatred, and openly set up camp, forcing Capusa to fight for his throne. After Capusa and many of his nobles were defeated in the battle, Mezetulus took control over the Massylians. However, he refrained from calling himself king and instead chose the modest title of protector, giving the title of king to Lacumaces, the surviving boy from the royal line. In hopes of forming an alliance with the Carthaginians, he married a noblewoman from Carthage, daughter of Hannibal's sister, who had recently married King Oesalces; he also sent ambassadors to renew an old alliance with Syphax, all aimed at gaining support against Masinissa.

30

Masinissa, hearing of the death of his uncle, and afterwards that his cousin-german was slain, passed over out of Spain into Mauritania. Bocchar was king of the Moors at that time. Applying to him as a suppliant, he succeeded, by means of the most humble entreaties, in obtaining from him four thousand Moors to escort him on his march, since he could not procure his co-operation in the war. With these, after sending a messenger before him to his own and his father's friends, he arrived on the frontiers of the kingdom, when about five hundred Numidians came to join him. Having, therefore, sent back the Moors to their king, as had been agreed, though the numbers which joined him were much less than he had anticipated, not being such as to inspire him with sufficient confidence for so great an attempt, yet, concluding that by action, and by making some effort, he should collect sufficient strength to enable him to effect something, he threw himself in the way of the young king Lacumaces, at Thapsus, as he was going to Syphax. The troops which attended him having fled back to the town in consternation, Masinissa took it at the first assault. Of the royal party, some who surrendered themselves he received, others he slew while attempting resistance. The greater part, with the young king himself, escaped during the confusion and came to Syphax, to whom they intended to go at first. The fame of this success, in the commencement of his operations, though of no great magnitude, brought the Numidians over to the cause of Masinissa; and the veteran soldiers of Gala flocked to his standard from all quarters, from the country and the towns, inviting the youth to come and recover his paternal dominions. Mezetulus had somewhat the advantage in the number of his soldiers, for he had himself both the army with which he had conquered Capusa, and also some troops who had submitted to him after the king was slain; and the young king Lacumaces had brought him very large succours from Syphax. Mezetulus had fifteen thousand infantry, and ten thousand cavalry. With these Masinissa engaged in battle, though he had by no means so many horse or foot. The valour, however, of the veteran troops, and the skill of the general, who had been exercised in the war between the Romans and Carthaginians, prevailed. The young king, with the protector and a small body of Massylians, escaped into the territories of the Carthaginians. Masinissa thus recovered his paternal dominions; but, as he saw that there still remained a struggle considerably more arduous with Syphax, he thought it advisable to come to a reconciliation with his cousin-german. Having, therefore sent persons to give the young king hopes, that if he put himself under the protection of Masinissa, he would be held in the same honour by him as Oesalces had formerly been by Gala; and to promise Mezetulus, in addition to impunity, a faithful restitution of all his property; as both of them preferred a moderate share of fortune at home to exile, he brought them over to his side, notwithstanding the Carthaginians studiously exerted every means to prevent it.

Masinissa, upon hearing about his uncle's death and later the news of his cousin's death, crossed over from Spain into Mauritania. At that time, Bocchar was the king of the Moors. Approaching him as a supplicant, Masinissa managed, through heartfelt pleas, to get four thousand Moors to accompany him on his journey since he couldn’t secure his help in the war. After sending a messenger ahead to inform his and his father's allies, he reached the borders of the kingdom, where about five hundred Numidians joined him. Therefore, he sent the Moors back to their king, as agreed, and although the number of reinforcements was much smaller than he expected, which didn’t give him enough confidence for such a significant endeavor, he decided that taking action and making an effort would help him gather enough strength to achieve something. He confronted the young king Lacumaces at Thapsus as he was heading to Syphax. When Lacumaces’s troops fled back to town in panic, Masinissa captured it on the first assault. He accepted some of the royal party who surrendered and killed others who tried to resist. Most, including the young king himself, escaped during the chaos and made their way to Syphax, which had been their intended destination. The news of this initial success, although small, attracted the Numidians to support Masinissa’s cause; veteran soldiers from Gala came to his side from everywhere, urging him to reclaim his ancestral lands. Mezetulus had an edge in numbers since he commanded the army that had conquered Capusa and also had some troops that had submitted to him after the king’s death, while the young king Lacumaces brought him significant reinforcements from Syphax. Mezetulus had fifteen thousand infantry and ten thousand cavalry. Masinissa engaged them in battle even though he had far fewer troops. However, the bravery of the veteran soldiers and the general’s experience in the war between the Romans and Carthaginians made all the difference. The young king, along with his protector and a small group of Massylians, fled to the realms of the Carthaginians. Thus, Masinissa reclaimed his ancestral lands, but recognizing that he faced a much tougher challenge from Syphax, he decided to seek reconciliation with his cousin. He sent messengers to give the young king hope that if he placed himself under Masinissa's protection, he would be honored in the same way that Oesalces had been by Gala; he also promised Mezetulus protection and the restoration of all his property. Since both preferred a moderate fortune at home over exile, he managed to sway them to his side, despite the Carthaginians doing everything they could to prevent it.

31

It happened that Hasdrubal was with Syphax at the time these things were taking place. He told the Numidian, who considered that it could make very little difference to him whether the government of the Massylians was in the hands of Lacumaces or Masinissa, that "he was very much mistaken if he supposed that Masinissa would be content with the same power which his father Gala or his uncle Oesalces enjoyed. That he possessed a much greater degree of spirit, and a more enterprising turn of mind, than had ever existed in any one of that race. That he had frequently, when in Spain, exhibited proofs to his allies, as well as to his enemies, of such valour as was rarely found among men. That both Syphax and the Carthaginians, unless they smothered that rising flame, would soon find themselves enveloped in a vast conflagration, when they could not help themselves. That as yet his strength was feeble, and such as might easily be broken, while he was trying to keep together a kingdom, which was not yet firmly cemented." By continually urging and goading him on, he succeeded in inducing him to lead an army to the frontiers of the Massylians, and to pitch his camp in a country for which he had not only disputed verbally, but had fought battles with Gala, as though it had been his own by uncontested right. He alleged, that "if any one should attempt to dislodge him, which was what he most wanted, he would have an opportunity of fighting; but, if the ground were given up to him through fear, he must march into the heart of the kingdom. That the Massylians would either submit to his authority without a contest, or would be inferior to him in arms." Syphax, impelled by these arguments, made war on Masinissa, and, in the first engagement, routed and put him to flight. Masinissa, with a few horsemen, effected his escape from the field to a mountain called by the natives Balbus. Several families, with their tents and cattle, which form their wealth, followed the king; the rest of the Massylian people submitted to Syphax. The mountain, which the exiles had seized, had plenty of grass and water; and, as it was well adapted for feeding cattle, afforded an abundant supply of food for men who live upon flesh and milk. From this place they infested all the surrounding country; at first with nightly and clandestine incursions, but afterwards with open depredations. The lands of the Carthaginians suffered the severest devastation, because there was not only a greater quantity of booty there than among the Numidians, but their plunder would be safer. And now they did it with so much boldness and defiance, that, carrying their booty down to the sea, they sold it to merchants, who brought their ships to land for that very purpose; while a greater number of Carthaginians were slain and made prisoners, than frequently happens in a regular war. The Carthaginians complained bitterly of these occurrences to Syphax, and urged him strongly to follow up this remnant of the war, though he was himself highly incensed at them. But he considered it hardly suitable to the dignity of a king to pursue a vagabond robber through the mountains.

It happened that Hasdrubal was with Syphax when these events occurred. He told the Numidian, who thought it wouldn't make much difference whether the Massylians were ruled by Lacumaces or Masinissa, that "he was very wrong if he believed that Masinissa would be satisfied with the same power his father Gala or his uncle Oesalces had. He had a much stronger spirit and a more adventurous mindset than anyone in that family. He had often shown, during his time in Spain, proof of bravery that was rarely seen in men. Both Syphax and the Carthaginians, unless they extinguished that growing fire, would soon find themselves caught in a major blaze they couldn't escape. His strength was weak right now, and easily breakable, while he was trying to hold together a kingdom that wasn't yet solidified." By continually pushing and motivating him, Hasdrubal managed to convince Syphax to lead an army to the borders of the Massylians and set up camp in an area he had not only verbally contested but had fought over with Gala as if it were rightfully his. He argued that "if anyone tried to force him out, which was what he wanted most, he would get a chance to fight; but if the land was given up to him out of fear, he would need to march into the heart of the kingdom. The Massylians would either submit to his rule without a fight or would be no match for him in battle." Driven by these arguments, Syphax went to war against Masinissa, and in the first battle, he routed and chased him off. Masinissa managed to escape to a mountain called Balbus with a few horsemen. Several families, with their tents and livestock, which constituted their wealth, followed the king; the rest of the Massylian people surrendered to Syphax. The mountain, occupied by the exiles, had plenty of grass and water, making it ideal for feeding livestock and providing ample food for those who lived on meat and milk. From this place, they raided the surrounding areas; initially with nighttime stealthy attacks, but later with open raids. The lands of the Carthaginians were the hardest hit because there was more booty to be found there than among the Numidians, and their plunder would be safer. They grew so bold and defiant that they would take their loot to the sea and sell it to merchants who brought their ships to shore for that purpose; during these raids, more Carthaginians were killed and captured than usually occurs in a regular war. The Carthaginians complained bitterly about these events to Syphax and urged him strongly to pursue this remnant of the conflict, even though he was infuriated by them. However, he felt it was beneath the dignity of a king to chase down a wandering thief through the mountains.

32

Bocchar, one of the king's generals, an enterprising and active officer, was chosen for this service. Four thousand infantry and two thousand cavalry were assigned him; and having been loaded with promises of immense rewards if he brought back the head of Masinissa, or if, which would be a source of incalculable joy, he took him alive; he unexpectedly attacked his party while dispersed and carelessly employed, and after cutting off an immense quantity of cattle and men from the troops which guarded them, drove Masinissa himself with a small body of attendants to the summit of the mountain. On this, considering the business as in a manner settled, he not only sent the booty of cattle and the prisoners he had made to the king, but also sent back a part of his forces, as being considerably more than were necessary to accomplish what remained of the war; and then pursuing Masinissa, who had come down from the top of the mountain with not more than five hundred foot and two hundred horse, shut him up in a narrow valley, both the entrances of which he blocked up. Here great slaughter was made of the Massylians. Masinissa, with not more than fifty horsemen, disengaged himself from the defile by passing through steep descents of the mountains, which were not known to his pursuers. Bocchar, however, followed close upon him, and overtaking him in the open plains near Clupea, so effectually surrounded him, that he slew every one of his attendants except four horsemen. These, together with Masinissa himself, who was wounded, he let slip, in a manner, out of his hands during the confusion. The fugitives were in sight, and a body of horse, dispersed over the whole plain, pursued the five horsemen of the enemy, some of them pushing off in an oblique direction, in order to meet them. The fugitives met with a very broad river, into which they unhesitatingly plunged their horses, as they were pressed by greater danger from behind, and carried away by the current were borne along obliquely. Two of them having sunk in the rapid eddy in the sight of the enemy, Masinissa himself was supposed to have perished; but he with the two remaining had emerged among the bushes on the farther bank. Here Bocchar stopped his pursuit, as he neither had courage to enter the river, nor believed that he now had any one to pursue. Upon this he returned to the king, with the false account of the death of Masinissa. Messengers were despatched to Carthage to convey this most joyful event, and all Africa rang with the news of Masinissa's death; but the minds of men were variously affected by it. Masinissa, while curing his wound by the application of herbs, was supported for several days in a secret cave by what the two horsemen procured by plunder. As soon as it was cicatrized, and he thought himself able to bear the motion, with extraordinary resolution he set out to recover his kingdom; and collecting not more than forty horsemen during his progress, when he arrived among the Massylians, where he now made himself known, he produced such a sensation among them, both by reason of their former regard for him, and also from the unhoped-for joy they experienced at seeing him safe whom they supposed to have perished, that within a few days six thousand armed foot and four thousand horse came and joined him; and now he not only was in possession of his paternal dominions, but was also laying waste the lands of the states in alliance with the Carthaginians, and the frontiers of the Massylians, the dominions of Syphax. Then, having provoked Syphax to war, he took up a position between Cirta and Hippo, on the tops of mountains which were conveniently situated for all his purposes.

Bocchar, one of the king's generals, a resourceful and active officer, was chosen for this mission. He was given four thousand infantry and two thousand cavalry, and was promised tremendous rewards for either bringing back Masinissa's head or, which would be even more joyful, capturing him alive. He unexpectedly attacked Masinissa's group while they were scattered and unguarded, cutting off a huge amount of cattle and men from the troops protecting them, and drove Masinissa himself, along with a small group of attendants, to the summit of a mountain. Considering the situation largely settled, he not only sent the cattle and prisoners he had captured to the king, but also sent back some of his troops, since he had way more than needed to finish the remaining tasks of the war. He then pursued Masinissa, who had descended the mountain with no more than five hundred foot soldiers and two hundred horsemen, and cornered him in a narrow valley, blocking both entrances. Here, significant slaughter occurred among the Massylians. Masinissa, with only about fifty horsemen, managed to escape the trap by navigating steep mountain paths that his pursuers were unaware of. However, Bocchar followed closely and caught up with him in the open plains near Clupea, effectively surrounding him and killing all but four of his attendants. Masinissa, who was injured, slipped away with those two remaining horsemen during the chaos. The fleeing group came across a wide river, which they boldly crossed as danger pursued them from behind, carried away by the current and pushed to the side. Two of them drowned in the rapid waters visible to their enemies, leading to the belief that Masinissa had perished; however, he and the two remaining horsemen emerged among the bushes on the opposite bank. Bocchar halted his pursuit, having neither the courage to enter the river nor believing there was anyone left to chase. He returned to the king with the false report of Masinissa’s death. Messengers were sent to Carthage to announce this supposedly joyous news, and all of Africa rang with the word of Masinissa's demise; but people's reactions varied widely. While treating his wound with herbs, Masinissa was hidden away for several days in a secret cave, helped by what the two horsemen scavenged. Once his wound healed and he felt ready to move, he boldly set out to reclaim his kingdom. Gathering no more than forty horsemen along the way, he reached the Massylians, where he revealed himself. His return sparked a strong reaction due to their previous loyalty to him and the unexpected joy of seeing him alive when they thought he was gone. Within a few days, six thousand armed foot soldiers and four thousand horsemen joined him. He not only regained control of his ancestral lands but also began ravaging the territories of the states allied with the Carthaginians and the borders of the Massylians under Syphax's rule. This led to Syphax declaring war, and Masinissa positioned himself between Cirta and Hippo, on mountains ideally suited for his plans.

33

Syphax, considering this an affair of too great importance to be managed by one of his generals, sent a part of his army with his son Vermina, a youth, with orders to march his troops round and attack the enemy in the rear, while he engaged their attention in front. Vermina set out by night, as he was to fall upon the enemy unawares; but Syphax decamped in the day-time and marched openly, intending to fight a pitched battle. When it was thought that sufficient time had elapsed for those who were sent round to have reached their destination, Syphax himself, relying upon his numbers and on the ambuscade prepared on the enemy's rear, led his troops up the mountain which lay before him, by a gentle acclivity which led towards the enemy. Masinissa, relying chiefly on the great superiority he would have over his opponents in respect of the ground, on his part also formed his troops. The battle was furious, and for a long time doubtful; Masinissa having the advantage in point of situation and the courage of his troops, and Syphax in respect of his numbers, which were much the greater of the two. His numerous troops, which were divided, some of them pressing upon the enemy in front, while others surrounded them on the rear, gave Syphax a decisive victory; and, enclosed as they were in front and rear, the enemy had not even a way to escape. Accordingly, all their troops, both horse and foot, were slain and made prisoners, except about two hundred horsemen, which Masinissa having collected round him in a compact body, and divided into three squadrons, ordered to force their way through, first naming a place where they were to meet after being separated in their flight. Masinissa himself escaped through the midst of the enemy's weapons in the quarter to which he had directed his course; two of the squadrons were unable to extricate themselves; one of them surrendered to the enemy through fear, the other, taking a more obstinate resistance, was overwhelmed with weapons and annihilated. Vermina followed Masinissa, treading almost in his steps; but he eluded him by continually turning out of one road into another, till at length he obliged him, wearied with the hopeless task, to desist from the pursuit, and arrived at the Lesser Syrtis with sixty horsemen. Here, in the country lying between the Carthaginian Emporia and the nation of the Garamantians, he passed all the time till the coming of Caius Laelius and the Roman fleet into Africa, with the proud consciousness of having made every exertion to recover his paternal dominions. These are the circumstances which incline me to the opinion, that afterwards also, when Masinissa came to Scipio, he brought with him a smallish rather than a large body of cavalry to succour him; for the large number would seem to suit only with the condition of a reigning king, while the small number corresponds with the circumstances of an exile.

Syphax, thinking this was too important for one of his generals to handle, sent part of his army with his son Vermina, a young man, with instructions to march his troops around and attack the enemy from behind while he held their attention in front. Vermina set out at night to catch the enemy by surprise, but Syphax moved during the day, marching openly and planning to fight a direct battle. Once enough time had passed for those who were sent around to reach their destination, Syphax led his troops up the mountain in front of him, moving toward the enemy. Masinissa, counting on the advantage of the ground he was fighting on, also arranged his troops. The battle was intense and uncertain for a long time; Masinissa had the advantage of position and the bravery of his troops, while Syphax had a much larger force. His numerous troops, split into groups attacking the enemy from the front and surrounding them from behind, gave Syphax a clear victory; trapped in both front and back, the enemy had no escape route. As a result, all their troops, both cavalry and infantry, were either killed or captured, except for about two hundred horsemen. Masinissa gathered these men around him, formed them into three squadrons, and ordered them to force their way through, first telling them where to meet after they separated in their flight. Masinissa himself escaped through the enemy's weapons in the direction he had planned; two of the squadrons couldn’t get away—one surrendered out of fear, while the other, fighting back fiercely, was overwhelmed and destroyed. Vermina pursued Masinissa closely, but Masinissa kept evading him by switching from one road to another until Vermina, exhausted from the fruitless chase, gave up and reached the Lesser Syrtis with sixty horsemen. There, in the area between the Carthaginian cities and the Garamantians, he waited for Caius Laelius and the Roman fleet to arrive in Africa, proud of having done everything he could to reclaim his family’s lands. These events led me to believe that when Masinissa later joined Scipio, he brought a relatively small number of cavalry to help him; a large number would seem more fitting for a reigning king, while a small number matched the situation of an exile.

34

The Carthaginians having lost a detachment of cavalry together with the commander, got together another body by means of a new levy, and gave the command of it to Hanno son of Hamilcar. They frequently sent for Hasdrubal and Syphax by letters and messengers, and lastly even by ambassadors, ordering Hasdrubal to bring assistance to his almost besieged country, and imploring Syphax to bring relief to Carthage, nay to all Africa. At that time Scipio had his camp about five miles from the city of Utica, having removed it from the sea, where he had continued encamped for a few days near the fleet. Hanno, having received the body of horse, which was far from being strong enough, not only to attack the enemy, but even to protect the country from devastation, made it his first business to augment the number of his cavalry by pressing; and though he did not despise the men of other nations, he enlisted principally from the Numidians, who are by far the first horsemen in Africa. He had now as many as four thousand horsemen, when he took possession of a town named Salera, about fifteen miles from the Roman camp. When Scipio was told of this, he said, "What! cavalry lodging in houses during the summer! Let them be even more in number while they have such a leader." Concluding that the more dilatory they were in their operations, the more active he ought to be, he sent Masinissa forward with the cavalry, directing him to ride up to the gates of the enemy and draw them out to battle; and when their whole force had poured out and pressed upon him with such impetuosity in the contest that they could not easily be withstood, then to retire by degrees, and he would himself come up and join in the battle in time. Waiting only till he thought he had allowed sufficient time for the advanced party to draw out the enemy, he followed with the Roman cavalry, proceeding without being seen, as he was covered by some rising grounds, which lay very conveniently between him and the enemy, round the windings of the road. Masinissa, according to the plan laid down, at one time as if menacingthe enemy, at another as if he had been afraid, either rode up to the gates, or else by retiring when his counterfeited fears had inspired them with courage, tempted them to pursue him with inconsiderate ardour. They had not as yet all gone out, and the general was wearying himself with various occupations, compelling some who were oppressed with sleep and wine to take arms and bridle their horses, and preventing others from running out at all the gates in scattered parties and in disorder, without keeping their ranks or following their standards. At first, those who incautiously rushed out were overpowered by Masinissa; but then a greater number pouring out of the gate at once in a dense body, placed the contest on an equal footing; and at last the whole of their cavalry coming up and joining in the battle, they could now no longer be withstood. Masinissa, however, did not receive their charge in hasty flight, but retired slowly, until he drew them to the rising grounds which covered the Roman cavalry. The Roman cavalry then rising up, their own strength unimpaired and their horses fresh, spread themselves round Hanno and the Africans, fatigued with the fight and the pursuit, and Masinissa, suddenly turning his horses round, came back to the battle. About a thousand who formed the first line and could not easily retreat, together with Hanno their general, were surrounded and slain. The victors pursuing the rest through a space of three miles, as they fled with the most violent haste, being terrified, principally on account of the death of their leader, either took or slew as many as two thousand horsemen more. It appeared that there were not less than two hundred Carthaginian horsemen among them, some of whom were distinguished by birth and fortune.

The Carthaginians, having lost a group of cavalry along with their commander, gathered another contingent through a new recruitment and put Hanno, son of Hamilcar, in charge. They often sent for Hasdrubal and Syphax through letters and messengers, and eventually even through ambassadors, instructing Hasdrubal to provide help to his nearly besieged territory and urging Syphax to come to the aid of Carthage, indeed to all of Africa. At that time, Scipio had set up his camp about five miles from the city of Utica, having moved it from the sea, where he had camped for a few days near the fleet. After receiving the cavalry unit, which was too weak to attack the enemy or defend the territory from destruction, Hanno's first action was to strengthen his numbers by conscripting more soldiers. Although he did not overlook men from other nations, he primarily recruited from the Numidians, who are the best horsemen in Africa. He had managed to gather four thousand horsemen by the time he took control of a town named Salera, about fifteen miles from the Roman camp. When Scipio heard this, he remarked, "What! Cavalry staying in houses during the summer? Let them increase in number under such a leader." Realizing that the longer they delayed their actions, the more proactive he should be, he sent Masinissa ahead with the cavalry, instructing him to ride up to the enemy's gates and lure them into battle. He intended for Masinissa to retreat gradually once the enemy had poured out in overwhelming force, allowing him to join the battle in time. After waiting long enough to ensure the advanced party had drawn out the enemy, he followed with the Roman cavalry, moving unseen thanks to some hills conveniently positioned between him and the enemy along the winding road. Masinissa, following the plan, alternately threatened the enemy and pretended to flee, either riding up to the gates or retreating to provoke them into an indiscriminate chase. Not all the enemy had yet exited, and their general was busy with various tasks, forcing some who had succumbed to sleep and wine to arm themselves and saddle their horses, while preventing others from leaving through the gates in disarray and without following ranks or standards. Initially, those who rushed out without caution were overpowered by Masinissa; but then a larger group charged out at once, equalizing the battle. Eventually, their entire cavalry joined the fight, and they could no longer be held back. However, Masinissa did not retreat in a panicked flight; instead, he withdrew slowly, drawing them toward the hills that concealed the Roman cavalry. The Roman cavalry then rose up, fresh and strong, surrounding Hanno and the exhausted Africans who had been worn down by the fight and pursuit. Masinissa swiftly turned his horses back to the battle. About a thousand men from the front line, unable to retreat quickly, along with their general Hanno, were surrounded and killed. The victors chased the rest for three miles, as they fled in sheer panic, especially fearful due to the death of their leader. They either captured or killed around two thousand more horsemen, including at least two hundred Carthaginian cavalry, some of whom were notable for their lineage and wealth.

35

It happened that the same day on which these events occurred, the ships which had carried the plunder to Sicily returned with provisions, as if divining that they came to take another cargo of booty. All the writers do not vouch for the fact that two generals of the Carthaginians bearing the same name were slain in the battles of the cavalry; fearing, I believe, lest the same circumstance related twice should lead them into error. Caelius, indeed, and Valerius, make mention of a Hanno also who was made prisoner. Scipio rewarded his officers and horsemen according to the service they had respectively rendered, but he presented Masinissa above all the rest with distinguished gifts. Leaving a strong garrison at Salera, he set out with the rest of his army; and having not only devastated the country wherever he marched, but taken some cities and towns, thus spreading the terrors of war far and wide, he returned to his camp on the seventh day after he set out, bringing with him an immense quantity of men and cattle, and booty of every description, and sent away his ships again loaded with the spoils of the enemy. Then giving up all expeditions of a minor kind, and predatory excursions, he directed the whole force of the war to the siege of Utica, that he might make it for the time to come, if he took it, a position from which he might set out for the execution of the rest of his designs. At one and the same time his marines attacked the city from the fleet in that part which is washed by the sea, and the land forces were brought up from a rising ground which almost immediately overhung the walls. He had also brought with him engines and machines which had been conveyed from Sicily with the stores, and fresh ones were made in the armoury, in which he had for that purpose employed a number of artificers skilled in such works. The people of Utica, thus beset on all sides with so formidable a force, placed all their hopes in the Carthaginians, and the Carthaginians in the chance there was that Hasdrubal could induce Syphax to take arms. But all their movements were made too slowly for the anxiety felt by those who were in want of assistance. Hasdrubal, though he had by levies, conducted with the utmost diligence, made up as many as thirty thousand infantry and three thousand horse, yet dared not move nearer to the enemy before the arrival of Syphax. Syphax came with fifty thousand foot and ten thousand horse, and, immediately decamping from Carthage, took up a position not far from Utica and the Roman works. Their arrival produced, however, this effect, that Scipio, who had been besieging Utica for forty days, during which he had tried every expedient without effect, left the place without accomplishing his object; and as the winter was now fast approaching, fortified a camp for the winter upon a promontory, which being attached to the continent by a narrow isthmus, stretched out a considerable way into the sea. He included his naval camp also within one and the same rampart. The camp for the legions being stationed on the middle of the isthmus, the ships, which were drawn on land, and the mariners occupied the northern shore, the cavalry a valley on the south inclining towards the other shore. Such were the transactions in Africa up to the close of autumn.

It just so happened that on the same day these events took place, the ships that had taken the loot to Sicily returned with supplies, almost like they knew they were there to pick up another load of treasure. Not all historians agree on the fact that two Carthaginian generals with the same name were killed in the cavalry battles; they seemed to worry that telling the same story twice might lead to mistakes. Caelius and Valerius do mention another Hanno who was captured. Scipio rewarded his officers and cavalry based on the service they had provided, but he gave Masinissa the most distinguished gifts above all. After leaving a strong garrison at Salera, he set out with the rest of his army; not only did he devastate the land wherever he marched, but he also captured some cities and towns, spreading the terror of war far and wide. He returned to his camp on the seventh day after departing, bringing with him a massive amount of men, livestock, and all kinds of loot, and he sent his ships back loaded with enemy spoils. Then, abandoning smaller expeditions and raids, he focused his entire war effort on the siege of Utica, intending that if he captured it, it would serve as a base for carrying out his future plans. At the same time, his naval forces attacked the city from the sea while the land troops advanced from an elevated position that overlooked the walls. He also brought along siege engines and equipment that had been transported from Sicily, and he had new ones built in the armory, employing numerous skilled artisans for that purpose. The people of Utica, surrounded by such a formidable force, placed all their hopes on the Carthaginians, while the Carthaginians relied on the chance that Hasdrubal could convince Syphax to take up arms. However, everything unfolded too slowly for those eagerly awaiting help. Hasdrubal, although he managed to raise around thirty thousand infantry and three thousand cavalry with exceptional effort, did not dare to approach the enemy until Syphax arrived. Syphax came with fifty thousand foot soldiers and ten thousand cavalry, and, immediately breaking camp from Carthage, set up a position close to Utica and the Roman encampments. However, their arrival led to Scipio, who had been besieging Utica for forty days and had tried every method without success, leaving without achieving his goal; with winter quickly approaching, he fortified a winter camp on a promontory that was connected to the mainland by a narrow isthmus, stretching significantly out into the sea. He included his naval camp within the same rampart. The camp for the legions was situated in the middle of the isthmus, while the ships, drawn ashore, and mariners occupied the northern shore, with the cavalry stationed in a valley on the southern side, sloping toward the opposite shore. Those were the events happening in Africa as autumn came to an end.

36

Besides the corn collected from all parts of the surrounding country by plunder, and the provisions imported from Italy and Sicily, Cneius Octavius, propraetor, brought a vast quantity out of Sardinia from Tiberius Claudius the praetor, whose province Sardinia was; and not only were the granaries already built filled, but new ones were erected. The army wanted clothing, and Octavius was instructed to consult with the praetor in order to ascertain if any could be procured and sent out of that province. This business was also diligently attended to. One thousand two hundred gowns and twelve thousand tunics were in a short time sent. During the summer in which these operations were carried on in Africa, Publius Sempronius, the consul, who had the province of Bruttium, fought an irregular kind of battle with Hannibal in the Crotonian territory while actually on march; they fought with their troops drawn more in order of march than of battle. The Romans were driven back, and as many as twelve hundred of the army of the consul were slain in this affair, which was more a tumult than a battle. They returned in confusion to their camp. The enemy, however, dared not assault it. But, during the silence of the following night, the consul marched away, and having sent a messenger before him to Publius Licinius, the proconsul, to bring up his legions, united his forces with his. Thus two generals and two armies returned to Hannibal. Nor did either party delay to fight, as the forces of the consul were doubled, and the Carthaginian was inspirited by recent victory. Sempronius led his legions into the front line; those of Licinius were placed in reserve. The consul, in the beginning of the battle, vowed a temple to Fortuna Primigenia if he routed the enemy that day, and he obtained the object of that vow. The Carthaginians were routed and put to flight; above four thousand armed men were slain, a little under three hundred taken alive, with forty horses and eleven military standards. Hannibal, dispirited by this adverse battle, led his troops away to Croton. At the same time, in another part of Italy, Etruria, almost the whole of which had espoused the interest of Mago, and had conceived hopes of effecting a revolution through his means, was kept in subjection by the consul Marcus Cornelius, not so much by the force of his arms as the terror of his judicial proceedings. In the trials he had instituted there, in conformity with the decree of the senate, he had shown the utmost impartiality; and many of the Tuscan nobles, who had either themselves gone, or had sent others to Mago respecting the revolt of their states, at first standing their trials, were condemned; but afterwards others, who, from a consciousness of guilt, had gone into voluntary exile, were condemned in their absence, and by thus withdrawing left their effects only, which were liable to confiscation, as a pledge for their punishment.

Besides the corn collected from all over the surrounding area through plunder, and the supplies imported from Italy and Sicily, Cneius Octavius, the propraetor, brought a large amount from Sardinia through Tiberius Claudius the praetor, who governed that province. Not only were the existing granaries filled, but new ones were built as well. The army needed clothing, and Octavius was ordered to check with the praetor to see if any could be obtained from that province. This task was also handled diligently. Within a short time, one thousand two hundred gowns and twelve thousand tunics were sent. During the summer when these operations took place in Africa, Publius Sempronius, the consul in charge of the province of Bruttium, engaged in an irregular battle with Hannibal in the Crotonian territory while he was on the march; they fought with their troops arranged more as if they were marching than in battle formation. The Romans were pushed back, resulting in the deaths of about twelve hundred of the consul's army in what was more of a riot than a proper battle. They returned in chaos to their camp. However, the enemy did not dare to attack it. Then, under the cover of night, the consul left camp, sending a messenger ahead to Publius Licinius, the proconsul, to bring up his legions and joined forces with him. Thus, two generals and two armies returned to face Hannibal. Neither side hesitated to engage, as the consul's forces had doubled, and the Carthaginian was emboldened by his recent victory. Sempronius positioned his legions in the front line, while Licinius's troops were held in reserve. At the start of the battle, the consul vowed to build a temple to Fortuna Primigenia if he defeated the enemy that day, and he succeeded in fulfilling that vow. The Carthaginians were routed and forced to flee; over four thousand armed men were killed, nearly three hundred were captured, along with forty horses and eleven military standards. Hannibal, disheartened by this defeat, withdrew his troops to Croton. Meanwhile, in another part of Italy, Etruria—where most had backed Mago and hoped to spark a revolution—was kept under control by consul Marcus Cornelius, not just through military strength but more so through the fear generated by his legal actions. In the trials he held there, following the senate's decree, he displayed complete fairness; many Tuscan nobles, who had either gone to Mago themselves or sent others regarding their states' rebellion, were initially tried and found guilty. Later, others who, feeling guilty, had fled into voluntary exile were convicted in their absence, leaving only their properties, which were subject to confiscation, as a guarantee for their punishment.

37

While the consuls were thus engaged in different quarters, in the mean time, at Rome, the censors, Marcus Livius and Caius Claudius, called over the senate roll. Quintus Fabius was again chosen chief of the senate; seven were stigmatized, of whom there was not one who had sat in the curule chair. They inquired into the business relating to the repair of public edifices with diligence and the most scrupulous exactness. They set by contract the making of a road out of the ox market to the temple of Venus, with public seats on each side of it, and a temple to be built in the palatium for the great mother. They established also a new tax out of the price of salt. Salt, both at Rome, and throughout all Italy, was sold at the sixth part of an as. They contracted for the supply of it at Rome at the same price, at a higher price in the country towns and markets, and at different prices in different places. They felt well convinced that this tax was invented by one of the censors, out of resentment to the people because he had formerly been condemned by an unjust sentence, and that in fixing the price of salt, those tribes had been most burdened by whose means he had been condemned. Hence Livius derived the surname of Salinator. The closing of the lustrum was later than usual, because the censors sent persons through the provinces, that a report might be made of the number of Roman citizens in each of the armies. Including these, the number of persons returned in the census was two hundred and fourteen thousand. Caius Claudius Nero closed the lustrum. They then received a census of the twelve colonies, which had never been done before, the censors of the colonies themselves presenting it, in order that there might appear registers among the public records, stating the extent of their resources, both in respect of furnishing soldiers and money. The review of the knights then began to be made, and it happened that both the censors had a horse at the public expense. When they came to the Pollian tribe, in which was the name of Marcus Livius, and the herald hesitated to cite the censor himself, Nero said, "Cite Marcus Livius;" and whether it was that he was actuated by the remains of an old enmity, or that he felt a ridiculous pride in this ill-timed display of severity, he ordered Marcus Livius to sell his horse, because he had been condemned by the sentence of the people. In like manner, when they came to the Narnian tribe, and the name of his colleague, Marcus Livius ordered Caius Claudius to sell his horse, for two reasons; one, because he had given false evidence against him; the other, because he had not been sincere in his reconciliation with him. Thus a disgraceful contest arose, in which each endeavoured to asperse the character of the other, though not without detriment to his own. On the expiration of the office, when Caius Claudius had taken the oath respecting the observance of the laws, and had gone up into the treasury, he gave the name of his colleague among the names of those whom he left disfranchised. Afterwards, Marcus Livius came into the treasury, and excepting only the Maecian tribe, which had neither condemned him nor made him consul or censor when condemned, left all the Roman people, four and thirty tribes, disfranchised, because they had both condemned him when innocent, and when condemned had made him consul and censor; and therefore could not deny that they had been guilty of a crime, either once in his condemnation, or twice at the elections. He said that the disfranchisement of Caius Claudius would be included in that of the thirty-four tribes, but that if he were in possession of a precedent for leaving the same person disfranchised twice he would have left his name particularly among the disfranchised. This contest between censors, endeavouring to brand each other, was highly improper, while the correction applied to the inconstancy of the people was suitable to the office of a censor, and worthy of the strict discipline of the times. As the censors were labouring under odium, Cneius Babius, tribune of the people, thinking this a favourable opportunity of advancing himself at their expense, summoned them both to trial before the people. This proceeding was quashed by the unanimous voice of the senate, lest in future this office of censor should become subject to the caprice of the people.

While the consuls were busy in different areas, back in Rome, the censors, Marcus Livius and Caius Claudius, went through the senate roll. Quintus Fabius was again chosen as the chief of the senate; seven senators were marked for disgrace, none of whom had held a curule chair. They diligently looked into the matters concerning the repair of public buildings. They contracted the construction of a road from the ox market to the temple of Venus, complete with public seating on each side, and a temple to be built in the Palatium for the Great Mother. They also introduced a new tax on the price of salt. Salt was sold at Rome and throughout Italy for one-sixth of an as. They arranged for its supply in Rome at the same price, but it was higher in country towns and markets, with varying prices in different locations. They believed this tax was created by one of the censors out of spite against the people because he had previously been wrongly condemned, and that the tribes that most suffered under this tax were those responsible for his condemnation. This led to Livius being nicknamed Salinator. The lustrum was closed later than usual because the censors sent people through the provinces to report on the number of Roman citizens in each army. Including these, the census tallied two hundred and fourteen thousand people. Caius Claudius Nero closed the lustrum. They then recorded a census of the twelve colonies, something that had never been done before, with the censors of those colonies presenting it so there would be public records showing the extent of their resources in terms of soldiers and money. The review of the knights began, and both censors had a horse at public expense. When they reached the Pollian tribe where Marcus Livius's name was, and the herald hesitated to call the censor himself, Nero said, "Call Marcus Livius;" and whether it was out of lingering resentment or a misguided sense of pride, he ordered Marcus Livius to sell his horse because he had been condemned by popular vote. Similarly, when they arrived at the Narnian tribe that included his colleague's name, Marcus Livius ordered Caius Claudius to sell his horse for two reasons: one, because he had given false testimony against him; the other, because he had not been genuine in reconciling with him. This sparked a disgraceful rivalry where each tried to tarnish the other's reputation, not without harming their own in the process. When their term ended, Caius Claudius took an oath to uphold the laws and went into the treasury, adding his colleague’s name to the list of those he left disfranchised. Later, Marcus Livius entered the treasury too, and except for the Maecian tribe, which had neither condemned him nor made him consul or censor when he was condemned, he left all the Roman people, thirty-four tribes, disfranchised because they had condemned him when he was innocent and had elected him consul and censor when he was condemned; thus, they could not deny their guilt, either for the initial condemnation or the subsequent elections. He stated that Caius Claudius's disfranchisement would be included among the thirty-four tribes, but if he had a precedent for leaving the same individual disfranchised twice, he would have specifically placed his name among those disfranchised. This rivalry between the censors, trying to incriminate one another, was inappropriate, while their efforts to correct the fickleness of the people were appropriate for a censor and in line with the discipline of the times. As the censors faced public resentment, Cneius Babius, a tribune of the people, saw this as a good opportunity to advance his own career at their expense and summoned both of them to trial before the people. This action was rejected by a unanimous vote of the senate, to prevent the office of censor from being subject to public whims in the future.

38

The same summer Clampetia in Bruttium was taken by the consul by storm. Consentia and Pandosia, with some other inconsiderable states, submitted voluntarily. As the time for the elections was now drawing near, it was thought best that Cornelius should be summoned to Rome from Etruria, as there was no war there. He elected, as consuls, Cneius Servilius Caepio and Caius Servilius Geminus. The election of praetors was then held. The persons elected were, Publius Cornelius Lentulus, Publius Quinctilius Varus, Publius Aelius Paetus, and Publius Villius Tappulus. The last two were plebeian aediles when elected praetors. The elections finished, the consul returned into Etruria to his army. The priests who died this year, and those who were put in their places, were Tiberius Veturius Philo, flamen of Mars, elected and inaugurated in the room of Marcus Aemilius Regillus, who died the year before: in the room of Marcus Pomponius Matho, augur and decemvir, were elected Marcus Aurelius Cotta, decemvir, and Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus, augur, being then a very young man; an instance of very rare occurrence in the disposal of the priests' offices in those times. Golden four-horsed chariots were placed this year in the Capitol by the curule aediles, Caius Livius and Marcus Servilius Geminus. The Roman games were repeated during two days. During two days also the plebeian games were repeated by the aediles, Publius Aelius and Publius Villius. There was likewise a feast of Jupiter on occasion of the games.

The same summer, the consul captured Clampetia in Bruttium after a siege. Consentia and Pandosia, along with a few other minor states, surrendered voluntarily. As the election season was approaching, it was decided that Cornelius should be called back to Rome from Etruria since there was no conflict there. He chose Cneius Servilius Caepio and Caius Servilius Geminus as consuls. Then, the election for praetors took place, resulting in the election of Publius Cornelius Lentulus, Publius Quinctilius Varus, Publius Aelius Paetus, and Publius Villius Tappulus. The last two were plebeian aediles when they were elected praetors. Once the elections were completed, the consul returned to Etruria to join his army. The priests who died this year and their replacements were Tiberius Veturius Philo, flamen of Mars, who was elected and inaugurated in place of Marcus Aemilius Regillus, who passed away the previous year. In place of Marcus Pomponius Matho, augur and decemvir, were elected Marcus Aurelius Cotta, decemvir, and Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus, augur, who was then very young; a rare occurrence for the appointment of priests' positions in those times. Golden four-horse chariots were placed in the Capitol this year by the curule aediles, Caius Livius and Marcus Servilius Geminus. The Roman games were held for two days, and the plebeian games were repeated for two days by the aediles, Publius Aelius and Publius Villius. Additionally, there was a feast for Jupiter in connection with the games.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXX.


Scipio, aided by Masinissa, defeats the Carthaginians, Syphax and Hasdrubal, in several battles. Syphax taken by Laelius and Masinissa. Masinissa espouses Sophonisba, the wife of Syphax, Hasdrubal's daughter; being reproved by Scipio, he sends her poison, with which she puts an end to her life. The Carthaginians, reduced to great extremity by Scipio's repeated victories, call Hannibal home from Italy; he holds a conference with Scipio on the subject of peace, and is again defeated by him in battle. The Carthaginians sue for peace, which is granted them. Masinissa reinstated in his kingdom. Scipio returns to Rome; his splendid triumph; is surnamed Africanus.

       *        *        *        *        *

1

Cneius Servilius and Caius Servilius Geminus, the consuls in the sixteenth year of the Punic war, having consulted the senate respecting the state, the war, and the provinces, they decreed that the consuls should arrange between themselves, or draw lots, which of them should have the province of Bruttium, to act against Hannibal, and which that of Etruria and Liguria; that the consul to whose lot Bruttium fell should receive the army from Publius Sempronius; that Publius Sempronius, who was continued in command as proconsul for a year, should succeed Publius Licinius, who was to return to Rome. In addition to the other qualifications with which he was adorned in a degree surpassed by no citizen of that time, for in him were accumulated all the perfections of nature and fortune, Licinius was also esteemed eminent in war. He was at once a man of noble family and great wealth; possessing a fine person and great bodily strength. He was considered an orator of the highest order, both in respect of judicial eloquence, and also when engaged in promoting or opposing any measure in the senate, or before the people. He was also accurately skilled in the pontifical law. In addition to all these recommendations, the consulship enabled him to acquire military glory. The senate adopted the same course in the decree with respect to the province of Etruria and Liguria as had been observed with regard to Bruttium. Marcus Cornelius was ordered to deliver his army to the new consul, and with continued command to hold himself the province of Gaul, with those legions which the praetor Lucius Scribonius had commanded the former year. The consuls then cast lots for their provinces: Bruttium fell to the lot of Caepio, Etruria to the lot of Servilius Geminus. The provinces of the praetors were then put to the lot. Paetus Aelius obtained the city jurisdiction; Publius Lentulus, Sardinia; Publius Villius, Sicily; Quinctilius Varus, Ariminum, with two legions which had served under Lucretius Spurius. Lucretius also was continued in command that he might complete the building of the town of Genoa, which had been destroyed by Mago the Carthaginian. Publius Scipio was continued in command for a period not limited in point of time, but the object he had to achieve, namely, till the war in Africa had been brought to a termination; and a decree was passed, ordering a supplication to be made that the circumstance of his crossing over into Africa might be beneficial to the Roman people, the general himself, and his army.

Cneius Servilius and Caius Servilius Geminus, the consuls in the sixteenth year of the Punic War, consulted the senate about the state of affairs, the war, and the provinces. They decided that the consuls should either make arrangements between themselves or draw lots to determine who would take charge of the province of Bruttium to confront Hannibal, and who would oversee Etruria and Liguria. The consul who drew the lot for Bruttium would receive the army from Publius Sempronius, who was to be retained as proconsul for a year, succeeding Publius Licinius, who would return to Rome. In addition to the other qualities he possessed, which surpassed those of any other citizen at that time—with all the natural and fortunate attributes combined—Licinius was also highly regarded as a military leader. He was both of noble birth and wealthy, with a striking appearance and considerable physical strength. He was considered a top-notch orator, excelling in judicial eloquence and when advocating for or against measures in the senate or before the public. He was also well-versed in pontifical law. All these accomplishments, combined with the consulship, helped him gain military glory. The senate followed the same procedure for the provinces of Etruria and Liguria as they did for Bruttium. Marcus Cornelius was instructed to hand over his army to the new consul, while he continued to command the province of Gaul with the legions that praetor Lucius Scribonius had led the previous year. The consuls then drew lots for their provinces: Bruttium went to Caepio, and Etruria to Servilius Geminus. Next, the provinces for the praetors were drawn. Paetus Aelius got the city jurisdiction; Publius Lentulus received Sardinia; Publius Villius was assigned Sicily; and Quinctilius Varus took Ariminum along with two legions that had served under Lucretius Spurius. Lucretius was also retained in command to finish the reconstruction of the town of Genoa, which had been destroyed by Mago the Carthaginian. Publius Scipio was kept in command for an open-ended term, with the mission of concluding the war in Africa; a decree was issued declaring a supplication for the success of his crossing into Africa for the benefit of the Roman people, the general himself, and his army.

2

Three thousand men were enlisted for Sicily, and lest any fleet should go thither from Africa, as all the efficient troops that province had possessed had been transported into Africa, it was resolved that the sea-coast of that island should be guarded with forty ships. Villius took with him into Sicily thirteen ships, the rest consisted of the old ones, which were repaired. Marcus Pomponius, the praetor of the former year, who was continued in command, having been placed at the head of this fleet, put on board the fresh soldiers brought from Italy. The senate assigned by a decree an equal number of ships to Cneius Octavius, who was also a praetor of the former year, with a similar privilege of command, for the protection of the coast of Sardinia. Lentulus the praetor was ordered to furnish two thousand soldiers to put on board it. The protection of the coast of Italy was assigned to Marcus Marcius, a praetor of the former year, with the same number of ships; for it was uncertain to what quarter the Carthaginians would send a fleet, though it was supposed that they would attack any quarter which was destitute of defence. The consuls, in conformity with a decree of the senate, enlisted three thousand soldiers for this fleet, and two city legions with a view to the hazards of war. The Spains were assigned to the former generals, Lucius Lentulus and Lucius Manlius Acidinus, who were continued in command, and retained their former armies. The operations of the war on the part of the Romans this year were carried on with twenty legions in all, and one hundred and sixty ships of war. The praetors were ordered to proceed to their provinces. Directions were given to the consuls, that before they left the city they should celebrate the great games which Titus Manlius Torquatus, when dictator, had vowed to exhibited in the fifth year, if the condition of the state remained unaltered. Accounts of prodigies brought from several places excited fresh superstitious fears in the minds of men. It was believed that crows had not only torn with their beaks some gold in the Capitol, but had even eaten it. At Antium mice gnawed a golden crown. An immense quantity of locusts filled the whole country around Capua, nor could it be made appear satisfactorily whence they came. At Reate a foal was produced with five feet. At Anagnia at first scattered fires appeared in the sky, afterwards a vast meteor blazed forth. At Frusino a circle surrounded the sun with a thin line, which was itself afterwards included within the sun's disc which extended beyond it. At Arpinum the earth sank into an immense gulf, in a place where the ground was level. When one of the consuls was immolating the first victim, the head of the liver was wanting. These prodigies were expiated with victims of the larger kind. The college of pontiffs gave out to what gods sacrifice was to be made.

Three thousand men were recruited for Sicily, and to prevent any fleet from coming from Africa—since all the effective troops that region had were sent there—it was decided that the coast of the island should be protected with forty ships. Villius took thirteen ships with him to Sicily, while the rest were older ships that were repaired. Marcus Pomponius, the praetor from the previous year who remained in command, led this fleet and took on board the fresh soldiers brought from Italy. The senate decreed that an equal number of ships should be assigned to Cneius Octavius, another praetor from the previous year, who had similar command for the protection of the coast of Sardinia. Praetor Lentulus was ordered to provide two thousand soldiers to be assigned to that fleet. The protection of the coast of Italy was given to Marcus Marcius, also a praetor from the previous year, with the same number of ships; it was unclear where the Carthaginians would send a fleet, but it was believed they would attack any area that was undefended. The consuls, following a decree from the senate, enlisted three thousand soldiers for this fleet and two city legions in preparation for the dangers of war. Spain was assigned to the former generals, Lucius Lentulus and Lucius Manlius Acidinus, who retained their previous command and armies. This year, Roman operations in the war involved a total of twenty legions and one hundred sixty warships. The praetors were instructed to head to their provinces. The consuls were directed to celebrate the great games that Titus Manlius Torquatus had vowed to hold in the fifth year, if the state remained stable, before leaving the city. Reports of omens from various locations sparked new superstitious fears among the people. It was said that crows had not only pecked at some gold in the Capitol but had even eaten it. In Antium, mice gnawed on a golden crown. A huge swarm of locusts covered the entire area around Capua, and it couldn't be determined satisfactorily where they had come from. In Reate, a foal was born with five feet. In Anagnia, scattered fires appeared in the sky, followed by a large meteor. In Frusino, a thin circle surrounded the sun, which was later included within the sun’s disc that extended beyond it. In Arpinum, the ground suddenly sank into a massive hole in an otherwise flat area. When one of the consuls was performing the first sacrifice, the liver's head was missing. These omens were atoned for with larger sacrificial animals. The college of pontiffs announced which gods required sacrifices.

3

After these matters were finished, the consuls and praetors set out for their provinces. All, however, made Africa the great object of their concern, as though it had been allotted to them; whether it was because they saw that the welfare of the state and the issue of the war turned upon the operations there, or that they might oblige Scipio, on whom the whole state was then intent. Accordingly, not only from Sardinia, as has been before mentioned, but from Sicily also and Spain, clothing and corn, and from Sicily arms also, together with every kind of stores, were conveyed thither. Nor did Scipio at any time during the winter relax in any of the various military operations in which he was engaged on all sides. He continued the siege of Utica. His camp was within sight of Hasdrubal. The Carthaginians had launched their ships, and had a fleet prepared and equipped to intercept his supplies. Amid these occupations he had not even lost sight of his endeavours to regain the friendship of Syphax, whose passion for his bride he thought might now perhaps have become satiated from unlimited enjoyment. From Syphax he received terms of peace with the Carthaginians, with proposals that the Romans should evacuate Africa, and the Carthaginians Italy, rather than any ground of hope that he would desert their cause if the war proceeded. For my part I am of opinion, and in this I am countenanced by the majority of writers, that these negotiations were carried on through messengers, rather than that Syphax himself came to the Roman camp to hold a conference, as Antias Valerius relates. At first the Roman general scarcely allowed these terms to be mentioned, but afterwards, in order that there might exist a plausible pretext for his emissaries to go frequently into the camp of the enemy, he rejected these same terms in a more qualified manner, holding out a hope that they might eventually come to an agreement by agitating the question on both sides. The winter huts of the Carthaginians, which were constructed from materials hastily collected out of the fields, were almost entirely of wood. The Numidians, particularly, lay for the most part in huts formed of interwoven reeds, and covered with mats, dispersed up and down without any regard to order; while some of them, having chosen the situations for their tents without waiting for orders, lay even without the trench and rampart. These circumstances having been reported to Scipio, gave him hopes that he might have an opportunity of burning the enemy's camp.

After these matters were settled, the consuls and praetors left for their provinces. However, everyone focused mainly on Africa as if it had been assigned to them; whether because they realized that the state's welfare and the outcome of the war depended on operations there, or to please Scipio, who was the center of attention for the entire state at the time. As a result, supplies such as clothing, grain, and even arms were sent from Sardinia, Sicily, and Spain. Scipio also didn't let up during the winter in his various military activities on all fronts. He continued the siege of Utica, keeping his camp within sight of Hasdrubal. The Carthaginians had launched their ships and prepared a fleet to cut off his supplies. Even with all these tasks, Scipio hadn't lost sight of his efforts to regain Syphax's friendship, thinking that Syphax's passion for his wife might now be satisfied after prolonged enjoyment. Syphax presented peace terms with the Carthaginians, suggesting that the Romans leave Africa and the Carthaginians leave Italy, rather than any likelihood of him abandoning their cause if the war went on. Personally, I believe, and many writers agree, that these negotiations happened through messengers instead of Syphax actually coming to the Roman camp for discussions, as Antias Valerius states. Initially, the Roman general barely considered these terms, but later on, so there would be a plausible reason for his envoys to frequently visit the enemy camp, he rejected the terms more diplomatically, suggesting there might still be a chance for agreement if both sides discussed it. The winter quarters of the Carthaginians, built from hastily collected field materials, were mostly made of wood. The Numidians, particularly, lived mostly in huts made of woven reeds and covered with mats, scattered without any clear organization; while some set up their tents in chosen locations without waiting for orders, even outside the trench and rampart. This information, reported to Scipio, gave him hope that he might have a chance to burn the enemy's camp.

4

In company with the ambassadors whom he sent to Syphax, he also sent some centurions of the first rank, of tried valour and prudence, dressed as servants, in lieu of soldiers' drudges; in order that, while the ambassadors were engaged in conference, they might ramble through the camp, one in one direction and another in another, and thus observe all the approaches and outlets, the situation and form both of the camp in general and of its parts; where the Carthaginians lay, where the Numidians, and what was the distance between the camp of Hasdrubal and that of the king; and that they might at the same time acquaint themselves with their customary mode of stationing outposts and watches, and learn whether they were more open to stratagem by night or by day. During the frequent conferences which were held, several different persons were purposely sent, in order that every circumstance might be known to a greater number. When the more frequent agitation of the matter had given to Syphax a daily increasing hope of peace, and to the Carthaginians through him, the Roman ambassadors at length declared that they were forbidden to return to their general unless a decisive answer was given, and that, therefore, if his own determination was now fixed, he should declare it, or if Hasdrubal and the Carthaginians were to be consulted, he should consult them. That it was time either that an accommodation should be settled or the war vigorously prosecuted. While Hasdrubal was consulted by Syphax, and the Carthaginians by Hasdrubal, the spies had time to inspect every thing, and Scipio to get together what was necessary for the accomplishment of his project. In consequence of the mention and prospect of a peace, neglect arose among the Carthaginians and Numidians, as is usually the case, to take precautions in the mean time that they might not suffer an attack of the enemy. At length an answer was returned; and as the Romans appeared excessively eager for peace, advantage was taken of that circumstance to add certain unreasonable conditions, which afforded Scipio a very seasonable pretext for putting an end to the truce according to his wishes; and telling the king's messenger that he would refer the matter to his council, he answered him the next day. He said, that while he alone had in vain endeavoured to restore peace, no one else had desired it. That he must, therefore, carry word back that Syphax must hope for peace on no other condition than his abandonment of the Carthaginians. Thus he put an end to the truce, in order that he might be free to execute his designs without breaking his faith; and, launching his ships, for it was now the beginning of spring, he put on board machines and engines, with the purpose of assaulting Utica from the sea. He also sent two thousand men to seize the eminence which commanded that place, and which he had before occupied, at once with the view of turning the attention of the enemy from the design he was endeavouring to effect to another object of concern, and to prevent any sally or attack which might be made from the city upon his camp, which would be left with a slight force to protect it, while he himself went against Syphax and Hasdrubal.

In addition to the ambassadors he sent to Syphax, he also dispatched some top-ranking centurions, known for their bravery and wisdom, disguised as servants instead of soldiers. This way, while the ambassadors were in meetings, these centurions could wander around the camp in different directions, observing all the entry and exit points, and examining both the overall layout of the camp and its individual sections. They kept an eye on where the Carthaginians and Numidians were stationed, as well as the distance between Hasdrubal's camp and the king's. They also aimed to understand the usual way of setting up outposts and watches, and to find out if they were more susceptible to surprise attacks at night or during the day. During the frequent meetings, various individuals were deliberately sent so that multiple people would be informed of everything happening. As discussions continued, Syphax grew more hopeful about peace each day, and the Carthaginians also gained confidence through him. Finally, the Roman ambassadors stated that they were instructed not to return to their general without a clear answer. They insisted that if Syphax had made a decision, he should share it, or if Hasdrubal and the Carthaginians needed to be consulted, he should do that. It was time to either establish a compromise or vigorously continue the war. While Syphax consulted Hasdrubal and Hasdrubal consulted the Carthaginians, the spies had a chance to observe everything, and Scipio was able to gather what he needed for his plan. Because of the talk and hopes for peace, the Carthaginians and Numidians began to neglect their defenses, which often happens in such situations, leaving them vulnerable to enemy attacks. Eventually, a response was provided; since the Romans seemed overly eager for peace, this was exploited to add some unreasonable conditions, giving Scipio a convenient pretext to end the truce as he wished. He told the king’s messenger that he would bring the matter to his council and responded the next day. He explained that although he had tried to secure peace alone, no one else had shown interest in it. Therefore, he needed to inform Syphax that peace could only be expected if he abandoned the Carthaginians. This declaration ended the truce, freeing him to pursue his plans without breaking his word. With spring now beginning, he launched his ships equipped with machines and engines to attack Utica by sea. He also sent two thousand men to take control of the high ground overlooking the city, which he had occupied before. This was intended both to redirect the enemy’s focus away from his actual plans and to prevent any sorties or attacks from the city on his camp, which would be left with a small force for protection while he went after Syphax and Hasdrubal.

5

Having made these preparations, he called a council and after ordering the spies to give an account of the discoveries they had made, and requesting Masinissa, who was acquainted with every circumstance relating to the enemy, to state what he knew, lastly, he himself laid before the council the plan proposed for the following night. He gave directions to the tribunes, that when, after the breaking up of the council, the trumpets had sounded, they should immediately march the legions out of the camp. Agreeably to his commands, the standards began to be carried out about sun-set. About the first watch they formed the troops in marching order. At midnight, for it was seven miles' march, they came up at a moderate pace to the camp of the enemy. Here Scipio assigned a part of his forces, together with Masinissa and the Numidians, to Laelius, ordering them to fall upon the camp of Syphax, and throw fire upon it. Then taking each of the commanders, Masinissa and Laelius, aside, he implored them separately to make up by diligence and care for the absence of that foresight which the night rendered it impossible to exercise. He said, that he should himself attack Hasdrubal and the Carthaginian camp; but that he should not begin till he saw the fire in that of the king. Nor did this delay him long; for when the fire thrown upon the nearest huts had taken effect, immediately communicating with all those which were within the shortest distance, and those connected with them in regular succession, it spread itself throughout the whole camp. The confusion and alarm which took place, in consequence of so widely extended a fire breaking out during the night, were as great as might naturally be expected; but as they concluded that it was the effect of chance, and not produced by the enemy, or connected with the war, they rushed out in a disorderly manner, without their arms, to extinguish the flames, and fell in with armed enemies, particularly the Numidians, who on account of their knowledge of the king's camp were placed by Masinissa in convenient places at the openings of the passes. Many perished in the flames in their beds while half asleep; and many, tumbling over one another in their haste to escape, were trampled to death in the narrow passages of the gates.

Having made these preparations, he called a meeting and after instructing the spies to report on what they had discovered, he asked Masinissa, who knew all the details about the enemy, to share his knowledge. Finally, he presented the plan for the following night to the council. He instructed the tribunes that once the meeting was over and the trumpets sounded, they should immediately march the legions out of the camp. Following his orders, the standards were taken out around sunset. At the first watch, they organized the troops for marching. At midnight, making a seven-mile trek at a steady pace, they arrived at the enemy's camp. Here, Scipio assigned part of his forces, along with Masinissa and the Numidians, to Laelius, instructing them to attack Syphax’s camp and set it on fire. Then he took each of the commanders, Masinissa and Laelius, aside and urged them to compensate for the lack of foresight that the night prevented them from having through their diligence and care. He indicated that he would personally attack Hasdrubal and the Carthaginian camp but wouldn’t start until he saw a fire in the king’s camp. This delay was not long; when the fire ignited the nearest huts, it quickly spread to all those nearby in a chain reaction, engulfing the entire camp. The chaos and panic caused by such a widespread fire breaking out at night were as intense as expected; however, since they believed it was a random occurrence and not an enemy attack, they rushed out in a disorganized manner without their weapons to put out the flames, encountering armed foes, especially the Numidians, whom Masinissa had placed strategically at the openings of the passes due to their knowledge of the king's camp. Many perished in the flames while still in bed; others, in their frantic attempts to escape, were trampled to death in the narrow passages of the gates.

6

When first the Carthaginian sentinels, and afterwards the rest, roused by the terrifying effects of a tumult by night, beheld the light emitted from the flames, they also, labouring under the same delusion, imagined that the fire had originated from accidental causes; while the shout raised amidst the slaughter and wounds, being of a confused kind, prevented their distinguishing whether it was occasioned by the trepidation of an alarm by night. Accordingly, rushing out one and all at every gate, each man taking the nearest road, without their arms, as not suspecting any hostile attack, and carrying with them only such things as might be useful in extinguishing the flames, they fell upon the Roman troops. After all these had been slain, not only with the animosity of enemies, but also that no one might escape as a messenger, Scipio immediately attacked the gates, which were unguarded in consequence of the confusion; and, having thrown fire upon the nearest huts, at first the flames blazed forth with great fury, in several places at once, in consequence of the fire having been applied to different parts, but afterwards extending themselves along the contiguous huts, they suddenly enveloped the whole camp in one general conflagration. Men and cattle scorched with the flames blocked up the passages of the gates, first in a terrible rush to escape, and afterwards with their prostrate bodies. Those who got out of the way of the fire were cut off by the sword, and the two camps were involved in one common destruction. The two generals, however, and out of so many thousand troops only two thousand foot and five hundred horsemen, escaped, half armed, a great many of them being wounded and scorched. Forty thousand men were either slain or destroyed by the flames, and above five thousand captured. Among the captured were many Carthaginian nobles, eleven senators, with a hundred and seventy-four military standards, above two thousand seven hundred Numidian horses, and six elephants. Eight elephants were destroyed either by fire or sword, and a great quantity of arms taken. All the latter the general dedicated to Vulcan and burnt.

When the Carthaginian guards, followed by the others, were jolted awake by the terrifying chaos at night and saw the light from the flames, they all, suffering from the same misconception, thought that the fire had started accidentally. The chaotic shouts amidst the slaughter made it hard for them to figure out whether it was a night alarm. So, everyone rushed out through every gate, each taking the quickest route, unarmed and unaware of any enemy attack, carrying only items they thought could help put out the fire. They stumbled upon the Roman troops. After all the Romans were killed, not only out of enemy hatred but also to ensure there were no survivors to report back, Scipio immediately attacked the gates, which were unguarded due to the confusion. He set fire to the nearest huts, and at first, the flames burst out violently in several areas because the fire was spread across different spots. But then the fire spread to the nearby huts, quickly engulfing the entire camp in one massive blaze. People and animals, scorched by the flames, blocked the gates first in a chaotic rush to escape and then with their fallen bodies. Those who got away from the fire were cut down by the sword, and both camps faced complete destruction. However, the two generals, along with only two thousand foot soldiers and five hundred horsemen out of so many thousands, managed to escape, many of them half-armed and wounded. Forty thousand men died or were consumed by the flames, and over five thousand were captured. Among the captives were many Carthaginian nobles, eleven senators, one hundred seventy-four military standards, more than two thousand seven hundred Numidian horses, and six elephants. Eight elephants were killed either by fire or sword, and a lot of weapons were seized. The general dedicated all of those to Vulcan and burned them.

7

Hasdrubal, in his flight, had made for the nearest city of the Africans, accompanied by a few attendants; and hither all those who survived, following the footsteps of their general had betaken themselves. But afterwards, fearing lest he should be given up to Scipio, he quitted that city. Soon after the Romans were received there with open gates; nor was any act of hostility committed, because the inhabitants had surrendered voluntarily. Shortly after, two other cities were captured and plundered. The booty found there, together with what had been rescued from the camps when burning, and from the flames, was given up to the soldiers. Syphax took up a position in a fortified place about eight miles off. Hasdrubal hastened to Carthage, lest the apprehensions occasioned by the recent disaster should lead to any timorous measures. So great was the consternation created there on the first receipt of the news, that it was fully anticipated that Scipio, suspending his operations against Utica, would immediately lay siege to Carthage. The suffetes, therefore, who form with them an authority similar to the consular, summoned the senate, when the three following opinions were given. The first proposed, that a decree should be passed to the effect, that ambassadors should be sent to Scipio to treat of peace; the second, that Hannibal should be recalled to defend his country from a war which threatened its annihilation; the third breathed the spirit of Roman constancy under adversity; it recommended that the losses of the army should be repaired, and that Syphax should be exhorted not to abandon the war. The latter opinion prevailed, because it was that which Hasdrubal, who was present, and all the members of the Barcine faction, preferred. After this, the levy commenced in the city and country, and ambassadors were despatched to Syphax, who was himself employing every effort to restore the war; for his wife had prevailed upon him, not, as heretofore, by caresses, powerful as they are in influencing the mind of a lover, but by prayers and appeals to his compassion, imploring him, with streaming eyes, not to betray her father and her country, nor suffer Carthage to be consumed by the same flames which had reduced the camps to ashes. In addition to this, the ambassadors informed him of a circumstance which had occurred very seasonably to raise their hopes; that they had met with four thousand Celtiberians in the neighbourhood of a city named Abba, a fine body of young men who had been enlisted by their recruiting officers in Spain; and that Hasdrubal would very soon arrive with a body of troops by no means contemptible. Accordingly, he not only returned a kind answer to the ambassadors, but also showed them a multitude of Numidian rustics, whom he had lately furnished with arms and horses; and at the same time assured them that he would call out all the youth in his kingdom. He said, he well knew that the loss sustained had been occasioned by fire, and not by battle, and that he was inferior to his adversary in war who was overcome by force of arms. Such was the answer given to the ambassadors; and, after a few days, Hasdrubal and Syphax again united their forces. This army consisted of about thirty-five thousand fighting men.

Hasdrubal, in his escape, headed for the nearest African city, accompanied by a few attendants; and all those who survived followed their general to that place. But later, fearing he might be handed over to Scipio, he left that city. Soon after, the Romans entered with open gates; no acts of hostility occurred because the inhabitants had surrendered willingly. Shortly after, two other cities were captured and looted. The spoils found there, along with what had been saved from the burning camps, were given to the soldiers. Syphax set up a position in a fortified location about eight miles away. Hasdrubal rushed to Carthage, worried that the recent disaster would lead to panic. So much fear erupted there upon receiving the news that it was expected Scipio would pause his operations against Utica to immediately lay siege to Carthage. The suffetes, who hold a role similar to consuls, called a senate meeting, where three opinions were presented. The first suggested a decree be made to send ambassadors to Scipio to negotiate peace; the second proposed recalling Hannibal to defend his country against a war that threatened its destruction; the third expressed Roman resilience in adversity, advocating for the restoration of the army's losses and urging Syphax not to abandon the fight. The last proposal won out because it was favored by Hasdrubal, who was present, and all the members of the Barcine faction. After this, recruitment began in the city and countryside, and ambassadors were sent to Syphax, who was doing everything he could to reignite the war; his wife had convinced him, not just with affectionate gestures, which often sway a lover's heart, but with pleas and appeals to his compassion, begging him, with tears in her eyes, not to betray her father and her country, or let Carthage be consumed by the same flames that had turned the camps to ash. Additionally, the ambassadors informed him of a timely circumstance that boosted their hopes: they had found four thousand Celtiberians near a city called Abba, a strong group of young men who had been recruited in Spain; and that Hasdrubal would soon arrive with a significant number of troops. Consequently, he not only responded kindly to the ambassadors but also showed them a large group of Numidian peasants he had recently armed and mounted; he assured them he would mobilize all the youth in his kingdom. He stated that he understood the loss had come from fire and not from battle, admitting he was outmatched by an enemy who was defeated by force. This was the reply given to the ambassadors; and after a few days, Hasdrubal and Syphax joined their forces again. This army totaled around thirty-five thousand soldiers.

8

Scipio, considering that Syphax and the Carthaginians could make no further efforts, gave his whole attention to the siege of Utica, and was now bringing up his engines to the walls, when he was diverted from his purpose by a report of the renewal of the war; and, leaving small forces merely to keep up the appearance of a siege by sea and land, he set out himself with the main strength of his army to meet the enemy. At first he took up his position on an eminence about five miles distant from the king's camp. The next day, coming down with his cavalry into a place called the great plains, which lay at the foot of that eminence, he spent the day in advancing up to the outposts of the enemy, and provoking them by skirmishing attacks. During the ensuing two days, irregular excursions were made by both sides alternately, but nothing worthy of notice was achieved. On the fourth day, both sides came down in battle-array. The Romans placed their principes behind the spearmen, which latter formed the front line, and the triarii they stationed in reserve; the Italian cavalry they opposed to the enemy in the right wing, the Numidians and Masinissa on the left. Syphax and Hasdrubal, placing the Numidians against the Italian cavalry, and the Carthaginians opposite to Masinissa, received the Celtiberians into the centre of their line, to face the Roman legions. Thus arranged, they then commenced the encounter. At the first charge, both the wings, the Numidians and Carthaginians, were together driven from their ground; for neither could the Numidians, who consisted principally of rustics, sustain the shock of the Roman cavalry, nor the Carthaginians, who were also raw soldiers, withstand Masinissa, who, in addition to other circumstances, was rendered formidable by his recent victory. The Celtiberian line, though stript of the support of both the wings, stood their ground; for neither did any hope of safety by flight present itself, as they were ignorant of the country, nor could they expect pardon from Scipio, against whom, though he had deserved well both of them and their nation, they had come into Africa to fight for hire. Surrounded therefore, on all sides by the enemy, they died with obstinate resolution, falling one upon another; and, while the attention of all was turned upon them, Syphax and Hasdrubal gained a considerable space of time to effect their escape. The victors, fatigued with the slaughter, which had continued for a greater length of time than the battle, were interrupted by the night.

Scipio, realizing that Syphax and the Carthaginians couldn't make any further moves, focused all his attention on the siege of Utica, and was setting up his siege engines against the walls when he heard news about the war restarting. Leaving small forces to maintain the appearance of a siege by sea and land, he personally took the main part of his army to confront the enemy. Initially, he positioned himself on a hill about five miles away from the king's camp. The next day, he came down with his cavalry to a place called the great plains, located at the base of that hill, and spent the day pushing toward the enemy's outposts and provoking them with skirmishes. Over the following two days, both sides made irregular attacks on each other, but nothing significant happened. On the fourth day, both armies formed battle lines. The Romans arranged their principes behind the spearmen, forming the front line, with the triarii held in reserve; they placed the Italian cavalry on the right wing against the enemy, while the Numidians and Masinissa took the left. Syphax and Hasdrubal positioned the Numidians against the Italian cavalry, and the Carthaginians opposite Masinissa, placing the Celtiberians in the center of their line to face the Roman legions. With their formations set, the battle began. At the first charge, both wings—the Numidians and Carthaginians—were driven back; the Numidians, mostly made up of farmers, couldn’t withstand the impact of the Roman cavalry, and the Carthaginians, also inexperienced soldiers, fell before Masinissa, who was especially tough because of his recent victory. The Celtiberian front line, lacking support from the wings, stood firm; they had no hope of escaping as they didn’t know the area, and they couldn’t expect mercy from Scipio, as they had come to Africa to fight for pay, despite his goodwill towards them and their people. Surrounded by enemies on all sides, they fought fiercely, falling upon one another; while all attention was focused on them, Syphax and Hasdrubal managed to buy themselves time to escape. The victors, exhausted from the slaughter, which lasted longer than the actual battle, were interrupted by nightfall.

9

The next day Scipio sent Laelius and Masinissa, with all the Roman and Numidian cavalry, and the light infantry, to pursue Syphax and Hasdrubal. He himself, with the main strength of the army, reduced the neighbouring towns, which were all subject to the Carthaginians, some by holding out hopes to them, some by threats, and others by force. At Carthage, indeed, the consternation was extreme; and it was fully anticipated there, that Scipio, who was carrying his arms to the different places around, would, after having rapidly subdued all the neighbouring parts, suddenly attack Carthage itself. Their walls were repaired and protected with outworks; and every man individually exerted himself to the utmost in collecting from the country the requisites for holding out against a protracted siege. Mention was seldom made of peace, but not so seldom of sending deputies to recall Hannibal. The majority of them urged that the fleet, which had been equipped to intercept the convoys of the enemy, should be sent to surprise the ships stationed near Utica, which were lying in an unguarded state. It was also urged that they might perhaps overpower the naval camp, which was left under the protection of a trifling force. They chiefly inclined to the latter plan, though they thought, nevertheless, that deputies should be sent to Hannibal; for should the operations of the fleet succeed in the highest degree, the siege of Utica would be partially raised, but they had no general remaining but Hannibal, and no army but his which could defend Carthage itself. The ships were therefore launched the following day, and, at the same time, the deputies set out for Italy; and, their position stimulating them, every thing was done with the greatest expedition; each man considering, that the safety of all was betrayed in whatever degree he remitted his own individual exertions. Scipio, who drew after him an army now encumbered with the spoils of many cities, sent his prisoners, and other booty, to his old camp at Utica, and, as his views were now fixed on Carthage, he seized on Tunes, which was abandoned in consequence of the flight of the garrison. This city is about fifteen miles distant from Carthage, being a place secured both by works, and also by its own natural position; it may be seen from Carthage, and itself affords a prospect both of that city and of the sea which washes it.

The next day, Scipio sent Laelius and Masinissa, along with all the Roman and Numidian cavalry and light infantry, to chase after Syphax and Hasdrubal. He himself focused on taking control of the nearby towns, all of which were under Carthaginian rule, using a mix of promises, threats, and force. Meanwhile, in Carthage, there was a state of panic; everyone there expected that Scipio, who was moving his troops around the area, would quickly conquer all the nearby regions and then launch a surprise attack on Carthage itself. They repaired their walls and fortified them with additional defenses, with each person doing their best to gather supplies needed for a prolonged siege. Peace was rarely mentioned, but discussions about sending envoys to recall Hannibal were common. Most agreed that the fleet, which had been prepared to intercept enemy supplies, should be sent to ambush the ships near Utica that were left unguarded. They also considered the possibility of overpowering the naval camp that was protected by only a small force. They mainly leaned towards this latter plan while still thinking it was important to send envoys to Hannibal, because even if the fleet's mission was extremely successful, it wouldn’t completely lift the siege of Utica, and they had no general but Hannibal, and no army but his, to defend Carthage itself. The ships were launched the next day, and at the same time, the envoys headed to Italy; motivated by their desperate situation, everything was done as quickly as possible, with each person recognizing that the safety of all depended on their individual efforts. Scipio, who was now leading an army weighed down by the spoils of many cities, sent his prisoners and other loot back to his old camp at Utica, and since his focus was now on Carthage, he took control of Tunes, which had been abandoned due to the flight of its garrison. This city is about fifteen miles away from Carthage, secured both by fortifications and its natural location; it can be seen from Carthage and provides a view of both that city and the sea washing up against it.

10

From this place the Romans, while diligently employed in raising a rampart, descried the fleet of the enemy, on its way to Utica from Carthage. Desisting from their work, therefore, orders for marching were given, and the troops began to move with the utmost haste, lest the ships which were turned towards the land, and occupied with the siege, and which were far from being in a condition for a naval battle, should be surprised and overpowered. For how could ships, carrying engines and machines, and either converted to the purposes of transports, or brought up to the walls so as to afford the means of mounting up, in lieu of a mound and bridges, resist a fleet, with nothing to impede its movements, furnished with every kind of naval implement, and prepared for action. Scipio, therefore, contrary to his usual practice in naval engagements, drew the ships of war, which might have been employed in defending the rest, into the rear, and formed them into a line near the land; opposing to the enemy a row of transports, four deep, to serve as a wall; and, lest these same transports should be thrown into disorder during the confusion of the battle, he bound them together by placing masts and yard-arms across them, from one vessel to the other; and, by means of strong ropes, fastened them together, as it were, by one uninterrupted bond. He also laid planks upon them, so as to form a free passage along the line, leaving spaces under these bridges of communication by which the vessels of observation might run out towards the enemy, and retreat with safety. Having hastily made these arrangements as well as the time would permit, he put on board the transports about a thousand picked men, to keep off the enemy, with a very large store of weapons, particularly missiles, that they might hold out, however long the contest lasted. Thus prepared, and on the watch, they waited the approach of the enemy. The Carthaginians, who, if they had made haste would, on the first assault, have surprised their adversaries while every thing was in a state of confusion, from the hurry and bustle attending the preparations, were so dismayed at their losses by land, and thereby had lost so much confidence even in their strength by sea, in which they had the advantage, that, after consuming the day, in consequence of the slow rate at which they sailed, about sun-set they put in to a harbour which the Africans call Ruscino. The following day, at sun-rise, they drew up their ships towards the open sea, as for a regular naval battle, and with the expectation that the Romans would come out to engage them. After they had continued stationary for some time, and saw that no movement was made on the part of the enemy, then, at length, they attacked the transports. The affair bore no resemblance to a naval fight, but rather had the appearance of ships attacking walls. The transports had considerably the advantage in respect of height; and as the Carthaginians had to throw their weapons upward, against a mark which was above them, most of them failed of taking effect; while the weapons thrown from the transports from above fell with increased force, and derived additional impetus from their very weight. The vessels of observation, and even the lighter kind of barks, which went out through the spaces left under the flooring, which formed a communication between the ships, were at first run down by the mere momentum and bulk of the ships of war; and afterwards they proved a hindrance to the troops appointed to keep the enemy off; for as they mixed with the ships of the enemy, they were frequently under the necessity of withholding their weapons for fear, by a misdirected effort, they should fall on their friends. At length, beams with iron hooks at their ends, called harpoons, began to be thrown from the Carthaginian upon the Roman ships; and, as they could not cut the harpoons themselves, nor the chains suspended by which they were thrown upon their ships, as each of the ships of war of the enemy, being pulled back, drew with it a transport, connected with it by a harpoon, you might see the fastenings by which the transports were joined together rent asunder, and in another part a series of many vessels dragged away together. In this manner chiefly were all the bridges of communication torn to pieces, and scarcely had the troops who fought in front time to leap to the second line of ships. About six transports were towed away to Carthage, where the joy felt was greater than the occasion warranted; but their delight was increased from the reflection, that, in the midst of so many successive disasters and woes, one event, however trifling, which afforded matter of joy, had unexpectedly occurred; besides which, it was manifest that the Roman fleet would have been well nigh annihilated, had not their own commanders been wanting in diligence, and had not Scipio come up to its assistance in time.

From this spot, the Romans, busy building a rampart, spotted the enemy's fleet heading to Utica from Carthage. They stopped their work, gave the order to march, and the troops rushed to move quickly, fearing that the ships, which were focused on the siege and not ready for a naval battle, would be caught off guard. How could those ships, equipped with engines and machinery, converted for transport or moved close to the walls to serve as a replacement for mounds and bridges, defend themselves against a fleet that had no obstacles and was equipped with every kind of naval tool and ready for action? Scipio, contrary to his usual tactics in naval confrontations, pulled the warships, which could have defended the others, to the back and lined them up near the shore; he positioned a row of transports, four deep, to act as a barrier. To prevent these transports from becoming disorganized during the chaos of battle, he connected them with masts and yardarms from one ship to another; and reinforced them with strong ropes to keep them together as one solid unit. He also placed planks across them to create a pathway along the line, leaving gaps under these bridges so that observation vessels could safely maneuver out towards the enemy and retreat when necessary. After quickly setting up these defenses, he loaded about a thousand elite troops onto the transports to fend off the enemy, along with a large supply of weapons, especially projectiles, to ensure they could hold out for as long as needed. So prepared and on alert, they awaited the enemy's approach. The Carthaginians, who, if they had rushed, might have caught their opponents off-guard during the confusion of their hurried preparations, were so shaken by their losses on land that they lost confidence even at sea, where they had an advantage. By the end of the day, due to their slow sailing, they docked at a harbor the Africans called Ruscino. The next day, at sunrise, they moved their ships toward the open sea, anticipating that the Romans would come out to fight. After remaining stationary for a while without any movement from the enemy, they finally attacked the transports. The confrontation resembled ships attacking walls more than a naval battle. The transports had a significant height advantage; as the Carthaginians had to throw their weapons upward, most missed their target, while the projectiles from the transports fell with greater force and momentum due to their weight. The observation vessels and even smaller boats that navigated through the gaps left under the flooring became initially overwhelmed by the mere force and size of the warships; later, they obstructed the troops designated to fend off the enemy, as they often had to hold back their attacks for fear of hitting their own side. Eventually, beams with iron hooks, known as harpoons, were thrown from the Carthaginian ships at the Romans; as they couldn’t sever the harpoons or the chains hanging from them, each time an enemy ship was pulled back, it dragged a transport along with it by the harpoon. You could see the connections that held the transports together tearing apart, and in other parts, groups of vessels being pulled away together. This was how most of the communication bridges were destroyed, and the troops in the front barely had time to leap to the second line of ships. About six transports were towed back to Carthage, where the joy felt was greater than the situation warranted; their excitement was heightened by the realization that, amidst so many successive disasters and hardships, one small event that brought them joy had unexpectedly occurred. Furthermore, it was clear that the Roman fleet would have been nearly obliterated if their own commanders hadn’t been careless, and if Scipio hadn’t arrived in time to assist them.

11

It happened about the same time, that Laelius and Masinissa having arrived in Numidia after a march of about fifteen days, the Massylians, Masinissa's hereditary kingdom, placed themselves under the protection of their king with the greatest joy, as they had long wished him among them. After the commanders and garrisons of Syphax had been expelled from thence, that prince kept himself within the limits of his original dominions, but without any intention of remaining quiet. Subdued by the power of love, he was spurred on by his wife and father-in-law; and he possessed such an abundance of men and horses, that a review of the resources of his kingdom, which had flourished for so many years, was calculated to infuse spirit into a mind even less barbarous and impetuous than his. Wherefore, collecting together all who were fit for service, he distributed among them horses, armour, and weapons. He divided his horsemen into troops, and his infantry into cohorts, as he had formerly learnt from the Roman centurions. With an army not less than that which he had before, but almost entirely raw and undisciplined, he set out to meet the enemy, and pitched his camp at a short distance from them. At first a few horsemen advanced cautiously from the outposts to reconnoitre, and being compelled to retire, from a discharge of javelins, they ran back to their friends. Then skirmishing parties were sent out from both sides, and the vanquished, fired with indignation, returned to the encounter with increased numbers. This is the usual incitement of battles between cavalry, when the victors are joined by more of their party from hope, and the vanquished from resentment. Thus, on the present occasion, the action commencing with a few, at last the whole body of the cavalry on both sides poured out to join in it from the zeal excited by the contest. While the cavalry only were engaged, it was scarcely possible to withstand the numbers of the Masaesylians, which Syphax sent out in immense bodies. But afterwards, when the Roman infantry, suddenly coming up between the troops of horse which made way for them, gave stability to their line, and checked the enemy, who were charging furiously, at first the barbarians slackened their speed, then halted, and were in a manner confounded at this novel kind of battle. At length, they not only retired before the infantry, but were unable to sustain the shock even of the cavalry, who had assumed courage from the support of the infantry. By this time the legions also were approaching; when, indeed, the Masaesylians not only dared not await their first charge, but could not bear even the sight of the standards and arms; so powerful was either the recollection of their former defeats, or their present fears.

It happened around the same time that Laelius and Masinissa, after a march of about fifteen days, arrived in Numidia. The Massylians, Masinissa's ancestral kingdom, joyfully placed themselves under the protection of their king, having long desired his presence among them. After Syphax's commanders and garrisons were expelled, he stayed within his original lands, but he had no intention of staying idle. Driven by love, he was motivated by his wife and father-in-law; he had so many men and horses that a review of his well-established kingdom could inspire even a less wild and impulsive mind than his. Therefore, he gathered all those fit for service, providing them with horses, armor, and weapons. He organized his cavalry into troops and his infantry into cohorts, as he had learned from the Roman centurions before. With an army as large as he had previously commanded, but mostly inexperienced and undisciplined, he set out to confront the enemy and camped a short distance away from them. Initially, a few horsemen cautiously advanced from the outposts to scout, but after being forced to retreat by a barrage of javelins, they hurried back to their comrades. Then skirmishing parties were sent out from both sides, and the defeated, stoked by anger, returned to the fight with greater numbers. This is typical in battles between cavalry, where the victors are reinforced by hope, while the defeated are driven by resentment. Thus, in this case, the initial skirmish involving just a few escalated to the entire cavalry on both sides rushing to join the fray fueled by the intensity of the conflict. While only the cavalry fought, it was nearly impossible to withstand the sheer numbers of the Masaesylians that Syphax unleashed in large groups. However, later, when the Roman infantry unexpectedly moved between the horse troops and solidified their line, it disrupted the fiercely charging enemy, causing the barbarians to initially slow down, then stop, bewildered by this new kind of combat. Eventually, they retreated not only from the infantry but also could not withstand the charge of the cavalry, who gained confidence from the infantry's support. By this time, the legions were also approaching; indeed, the Masaesylians couldn't even face their initial advance, let alone bear the sight of the standards and arms, so strong was either the memory of their past defeats or their current fears.

12

It was then that Syphax, while riding up to the troops of the enemy to try if, either by shame or by exposing his own person to danger, he could stop their flight, being thrown from his horse, which was severely wounded, was overpowered, and being made prisoner, was dragged alive into the presence of Laelius; a spectacle calculated to afford peculiar satisfaction to Masinissa. Cirta was the capital of the dominions of Syphax; to which a great number of men fled. The number of the slain in this battle was not so great as the victory was important, because the cavalry only had been engaged. Not more than five thousand were slain, and less than half that number were made prisoners in an attack upon the camp, to which the multitude, dismayed at the loss of their king, had fled. Masinissa declared that nothing could be more highly gratifying to him than, having gained this victory, to go now and visit his hereditary dominions, which he had regained after having been kept out of them so long a time; but it was not proper in prosperity any more than in adversity to lose any time. That if Laelius would allow him to go before him to Cirta with the cavalry and the captive Syphax, he should overpower the enemy while all was in a state of consternation and dismay; and that Laelius might follow with the infantry at a moderate rate. Laelius assenting, he advanced to Cirta, and ordered the principal inhabitants to be called out to a conference. But as they were not aware of what had befallen their king, he was unable to prevail upon them, either by laying before them what had passed, by threats, or by persuasion, until the king was presented to their view in chains. A general lamentation arose at this shocking exhibition, and while some deserted the walls in a panic, others, who sought to ingratiate themselves with the victor, suddenly came to an agreement to throw open the gates. Masinissa, having sent troops to keep guard near the gates, and at such parts of the wall as required it, that no one might have a passage out to escape by, galloped off to seize the palace. While entering the porch, Sophonisba, the wife of Syphax and daughter of Hasdrubal the Carthaginian, met him in the very threshold, and seeing Masinissa in the midst of the armed band, for he was distinguished both by his arms and also by his habiliments, she concluded, as was really the case, that he was the king; and, falling down at his knees, thus addressed him: "The gods, together with your own valour and good fortune, have given you the power of disposing of us as you please. But if a captive may be allowed to give utterance to the voice of supplication before him who is the sovereign arbiter of her life or death; if she may be permitted to touch his knees and his victorious right hand, I entreat and beseech, you by the majesty of royalty, which we also a short time ago possessed; by the name of the Numidian race, which was common to Syphax and yourself; by the guardian deities of this palace, (and O! may they receive you more auspiciously than they sent Syphax from it!) that you would indulge a suppliant by determining yourself whatever your inclination may suggest respecting your captive, and not suffer me to be placed at the haughty and merciless disposal of any Roman. Were I nothing more than the wife of Syphax, yet would I rather make trial of the honour of a Numidian, one born in Africa, the same country which gave me birth than of a foreigner and an alien. You know what a Carthaginian, what the daughter of Hasdrubal, has to fear from a Roman. If you cannot effect it by any other means, I beg and beseech you that you will by my death rescue me from the power of the Romans." She was remarkably beautiful, and in the full bloom of youth. Accordingly, while she pressed his right hand, and only implored him to pledge himself that she should not be delivered up to any Roman, her language assuming the character of amorous blandishment rather than entreaty, the heart of the conqueror not only melted with compassion, but, as the Numidians are an excessively amorous race, he became the slave of his captive; and giving his right hand as a pledge for the performance of her request, withdrew into the palace. He then set upon reflecting in what manner he could make good his promise; and not being able to hit upon any expedient, his passion suggested to him an inconsiderate and barefaced alternative. He ordered that preparations should be instantly made for celebrating the nuptials that very day; in order that he might not leave it at all open to Laelius, or Scipio himself, to adopt any measure respecting her as a captive who had become the wife of Masinissa. After the nuptials were concluded, Laelius came up: and so far was he from dissembling his disapprobation of the proceeding, that at first he would even have had her dragged from the marriage bed and sent with Syphax and the rest of the captives to Scipio: but afterwards, having been prevailed upon by the entreaties of Masinissa, who begged of him to leave it to Scipio to decide which of the two kings should have his fortunes graced by the accession of Sophonisba he sent away Syphax and the prisoners; and, aided by Masinissa, employed himself in reducing the rest of the cities of Numidia, which were occupied by the king's garrisons.

It was then that Syphax, while riding up to the enemy troops to see if he could stop their retreat by either shaming them or putting himself in danger, was thrown from his horse, which had been badly injured. He was overpowered and captured, dragged alive into the presence of Laelius; a sight that gave special satisfaction to Masinissa. Cirta was the capital of Syphax's territory, to which many people fled. The number of deaths in this battle wasn’t as high as the significance of the victory, since only the cavalry had engaged. No more than five thousand were killed, and less than half that number were taken prisoner in an attack on the camp, to which the crowd, frightened by the loss of their king, had fled. Masinissa stated that nothing would please him more than to claim this victory and then return to his ancestral lands, which he had been kept away from for so long; but he believed it was crucial, both in times of success and failure, not to waste any time. He asked Laelius if he could lead the cavalry and the captured Syphax ahead to Cirta, promising to take advantage of the enemy’s confusion, while Laelius could follow with the infantry at a more moderate pace. Laelius agreed, and Masinissa rode on to Cirta, calling for the prominent citizens to meet with him. However, since they were unaware of what had happened to their king, he found it difficult to convince them using threats or persuasion until Syphax was presented to them in chains. A great mourning broke out at this horrifying sight, and while some fled the walls in panic, others, eager to win favor with the victor, quickly agreed to open the gates. Masinissa then sent troops to guard the gates and sections of the wall that needed it, to prevent anyone from escaping, and rushed to seize the palace. As he entered the porch, Sophonisba, the wife of Syphax and daughter of Hasdrubal the Carthaginian, met him at the threshold. Recognizing Masinissa among the armed men, due to his distinctive armor and attire, she mistakenly assumed he was the king. Falling to her knees, she said: "The gods, along with your valor and good fortune, have given you the power to decide my fate. If a captive is allowed to speak before the one who holds her life or death in their hands; if she can touch your knees and victorious right hand, I plead with you by the majesty of kingship, which we once held; by the Numidian heritage shared by Syphax and yourself; by the guardian spirits of this palace, may they grant you a better welcome than they did Syphax; I ask you to consider whatever your inclination may suggest regarding your captive and not let me fall into the proud and merciless hands of any Roman. Even if I were merely the wife of Syphax, I would still prefer an honorable fate at the hands of a Numidian, born in the same land as I, rather than suffer under a foreigner and an outsider. You know well what a Carthaginian, and especially the daughter of Hasdrubal, has to fear from a Roman. If there is no other way, I beg you to save me from the Romans by taking my life." She was stunningly beautiful and in the prime of youth. As she held on to his right hand and pleaded, her words took on more of a sweet charm than desperation, making the heart of the conqueror soften with compassion. Given that the Numidians are known for their romantic nature, he became enamored with his captive. He promised her with his right hand that she would not be handed over to any Roman and then retreated into the palace. He then began to think about how he could keep his promise and, unable to find a solution, his passion led him to a reckless and bold decision. He ordered that preparations be made for a wedding that very day so he wouldn’t leave any room for Laelius, or even Scipio himself, to decide what to do with her after she had become Masinissa's wife. Once the wedding was completed, Laelius arrived; and he was so displeased with the situation that initially he even considered dragging her from the marriage bed to send her along with Syphax and the other captives to Scipio. But later, swayed by Masinissa’s pleas to leave the decision of who should have the fortune of marrying Sophonisba up to Scipio, he released Syphax and the prisoners; and, along with Masinissa, focused on capturing the remaining cities of Numidia that were still held by the king's garrisons.

13

When it was announced that Syphax was being brought into the camp, the whole multitude poured out, as if to behold a triumphal pageant. The king himself walked first in chains, and a number of Numidian nobles followed. On this occasion every one strove to the utmost to increase the splendour of their victory, by magnifying the greatness of Syphax and the renown of his nation. "That was the king," they said, "to whose dignity the two most powerful nations in the world the Roman and the Carthaginian, had paid so much deference, that their own general, Scipio, leaving his province of Spain and his army, sailed into Africa with only two quinqueremes to solicit his friendship; while Hasdrubal, the Carthaginian general, not only visited him in his dominions, but gave him his daughter in marriage. That he had in his power two commanders, one a Roman and the other a Carthaginian, at the same time. That as both the contending parties sought the favour of the immortal gods by the immolation of victims, so had they both equally solicited his friendship. That he had lately possessed such great power, that after expelling Masinissa from his kingdom, he reduced him to such a state, that his life was protected by a report of his death, and by concealment, while he supported himself in the woods on prey after the manner of wild beasts." Thus signalized by the observations of the surrounding multitude, the king was brought into the pavilion before Scipio, who was moved by the former condition of the man compared with his present, and particularly by the recollection of their relation of hospitality, his right hand pledged, and the public and private connexion which had been formed between them. These same considerations inspired Syphax also with confidence in addressing the conqueror; for when Scipio asked what had been his object in not only renouncing his alliance with the Romans, but in making war against them without provocation, he fully admitted "that he had indeed done wrong, and acted like a madman; but not at that time only when he took up arms against the Roman people; that was the consummation of his frenzy, not its commencement. Then it was that he is mad; then it was that he banished from his mind all regard for private friendship and public treaties, when he received a Carthaginian wife into his house. It was by the flames kindled by those nuptial torches that his palace had been consumed. That fury and pest had by every kind of fascination engrossed his affections and obscured his reason; nor had she rested till she had with her own hands clad him with impious arms against his guest and friend. Yet ruined and fallen as he was, he derived some consolation in his misfortunes when he saw that that same pest and fury had been transferred to the dwelling and household gods of the man who was of all others his greatest enemy. That Masinissa was neither more prudent nor more firm than Syphax; but even more incautious by reason of his youth. Doubtless he had shown greater folly and want of self-control in marrying her than he himself had."

When it was announced that Syphax was being brought into the camp, the whole crowd rushed out, as if to see a grand parade. The king himself walked in chains at the front, followed by several Numidian nobles. Everyone tried their best to make their victory even more impressive by emphasizing Syphax's importance and the reputation of his nation. "This was the king," they said, "to whom the two most powerful nations in the world, Rome and Carthage, showed such respect that their own general, Scipio, left his province in Spain and his army behind to sail to Africa with only two quinqueremes just to seek his friendship; while Hasdrubal, the Carthaginian general, not only visited him in his territory but also gave him his daughter in marriage. He had two commanders in his power at the same time, one Roman and one Carthaginian. Just as both sides offered sacrifices to the immortal gods for favor, they both sought his friendship equally. Recently, he had such great power that, after driving Masinissa from his kingdom, he reduced him to the point where his life was hidden under the rumor of his death, while he survived in the woods like a wild animal." Highlighted by the comments of the gathered crowd, the king was brought into the pavilion before Scipio, who was touched by the contrast between the man's former status and his current plight, especially remembering their previous hospitality, his right hand pledged in friendship, and the public and private connections they had formed. These same thoughts gave Syphax courage to speak to the conqueror; for when Scipio asked why he not only broke off his alliance with the Romans but also waged war against them without cause, he admitted, "I truly did wrong and acted like a madman; but not just at the moment I took up arms against the Roman people; that was the peak of my madness, not its starting point. It was then that I became crazy; it was then that I cast aside all thoughts of personal friendships and public treaties, when I brought a Carthaginian wife into my home. It was the flames from those wedding torches that destroyed my palace. That fury and plague had captured my heart and clouded my judgment in every way; she did not rest until she had armoured me against my guest and friend with her own hands. Yet, as ruined and fallen as I am, I found some comfort in my misfortunes when I saw that same plague and fury had also entered the home and household gods of the man who is my greatest enemy. Masinissa was no more prudent or steadfast than I; in fact, he was even more reckless because of his youth. He certainly showed greater folly and lack of self-control in marrying her than I did."

14

These words, dictated not merely by the hatred naturally felt towards an enemy, but also by the anguish of jealousy, on seeing the object of his affections in the possession of his rival, affected the mind of Scipio with no ordinary degree of anxiety. His accusations against Masinissa derived credibility from the fact of the nuptials having, been celebrated in the most violent hurry, almost amid the clash of arms, without consulting or waiting for Laelius, and with such precipitate haste, that on the very day on which he saw the captive enemy he united himself with her in matrimony, and performed the nuptial rite in the presence of the household gods of his enemy. This conduct appeared the more heinous to Scipio, because when a very young man in Spain he had not allowed himself to be influenced by the beauty of any captive. While ruminating on these circumstances, Laelius and Masinissa came up. Without making any distinction between them he received them both with a cheerful countenance, and having bestowed upon them the highest commendations before a full assembly of his officers, he took Masinissa aside and thus addressed him: "I suppose, Masinissa, that it was because you saw in me some good qualities that you at first came to me when in Spain, for the purpose of forming a friendship with me, and that afterwards in Africa you committed yourself and all your hopes to my protection. But of all those virtues, on account of which I seemed to you worthy of your regard, there is not one in which I gloried so much as temperance and the control of my passions. I could wish that you also, Masinissa, had added this to your other distinguished qualities. There is not, believe me, there is not so much danger to be apprehended by persons at our time of life from armed foes, as from the pleasures which surround us on all sides. The man who by temperance has curbed and subdued his appetite for them, has acquired for himself much greater honour and a much more important victory than we now enjoy in the conquest of Syphax. I have mentioned with delight, and I remember with pleasure, the instances of fortitude and courage which you displayed in my absence. As to other matters, I would rather that you should reflect upon them in private, than that you should be put to the blush by my reciting them. Syphax was subdued and captured under the auspices of the Roman people; therefore he himself, his wife his kingdom, his territories, his towns and their inhabitants, in short, every thing which belonged to him, is the booty of the Roman people, and it was proper that the king himself and his consort, even though she had not been a citizen of Carthage, even though we did not see her father commanding the armies of our enemies, should be sent to Rome, and that the senate and people of Rome should judge and determine respecting her who is said to have alienated from us a king in alliance with us, and to have precipitated him into war with us. Subdue your passions. Beware how you deform many good qualities by one vice, and mar the credit of so many meritorious deeds by a degree of guilt more than proportioned to the value of its object."

These words, driven not just by the natural hatred towards an enemy, but also by the pain of jealousy, as he watched the person he loved with his rival, deeply troubled Scipio. His accusations against Masinissa gained credibility because the wedding had been rushed, almost occurring in the midst of battle, without consulting or waiting for Laelius. In such a hasty manner, on the very day he saw the captured enemy, he married her, performing the ceremony in front of the household gods of his foe. This behavior seemed even more disgraceful to Scipio since, as a young man in Spain, he had never let himself be swayed by the beauty of any captive. While pondering these circumstances, Laelius and Masinissa approached. Scipio welcomed them both with a smile, praising them in front of a full assembly of his officers. He then took Masinissa aside and said, “I believe, Masinissa, that you reached out to me in Spain because you saw some good qualities in me and that later in Africa, you entrusted yourself and all your hopes to my protection. Among all those qualities that made you regard me, none do I take more pride in than my self-restraint and management of my desires. I wish you, too, had added this virtue to your other remarkable attributes. Trust me, there’s far more danger at our age from the pleasures that surround us than from armed enemies. A person who has restrained their desires through self-control has achieved a far greater honor and victory than we currently celebrate in the defeat of Syphax. I have joyfully recalled the moments of bravery and strength you showed in my absence. As for other matters, I prefer you think about them privately rather than me calling them out and embarrassing you. Syphax was defeated and captured under the authority of the Roman people; hence, everything he owned—his wife, his kingdom, his lands, his cities, and their people—belongs to the Roman people. It is fitting that both he and his consort, even though she wasn't a citizen of Carthage and even though we don't see her father leading our enemy's armies, should be sent to Rome. The Senate and the Roman people should judge her, as she is said to have turned a king allied with us against us and pushed him into war. Control your passions. Be careful not to tarnish many good qualities with a single vice, and don’t overshadow your numerous honorable deeds with a degree of guilt that far outweighs the worth of its cause.”

15

While Masinissa heard these observations, he not only became suffused with blushes, but burst into tears; and after declaring that he would submit to the discretion of the general, and imploring him that, as far as circumstances would permit, he would consider the obligation he had rashly imposed upon himself, for he had promised that he would not deliver her into the power of any one, he retired in confusion from the pavilion into his own tent. There, dismissing his attendants, he spent a considerable time amid frequent sighs and groans, which could be distinctly heard by those who stood around the tent. At last, heaving a deep groan, he called one of his servants in whom he confided, in whose custody poison was kept, according to the custom of kings, as a remedy against the unforeseen events of fortune, and ordered him to mix some in a cup and carry it to Sophonisba; at the same time informing her that Masinissa would gladly have fulfilled the first obligation which as a husband he owed to her his wife; but since those who had the power of doing so had deprived him of the exercise of that right, he now performed his second promise, that she should not come alive into the power of the Romans. That, mindful of her father the general, of her country, and of the two kings to whom she had been married, she would take such measures as she herself thought proper. When the servant came to Sophonisba bearing this message and the poison, she said, "I accept this nuptial present; nor is it an unwelcome one, if my husband can render me no better service. Tell him, however, that I should have died with greater satisfaction had I not married so near upon my death." The spirit with which she spoke was equalled by the firmness with which she took and drained the chalice, without exhibiting any symptom of perturbation. When Scipio was informed of this event, fearful lest the high-spirited young man should in the distempered state of his mind adopt some desperate resolution, he immediately sent for him, and at one time endeavoured to solace him, at another gently rebuked him for expiating one act of temerity with another, and rendering the affair more tragical than was necessary. The next day, in order to divert his mind from his present affliction, he ascended his tribunal and ordered an assembly to be summoned, in which having first saluted Masinissa with the title of king, and distinguished him with the highest encomiums, he presented him with a golden goblet, a curule chair, an ivory sceptre, an embroidered gown, and a triumphal vest. He increased the honour by observing, that among the Romans there was nothing more magnificent than a triumph; and that those who triumphed were not arrayed with more splendid ornaments than those with which the Roman people considered Masinissa alone, of all foreigners, worthy. He then bestowed the highest commendations upon Laelius also, and presented him with a golden crown, and gave presents to the other military characters proportioned to their respective merits. By these honours the king's mind was soothed, and encouraged to hope that he would speedily become master of all Numidia, now that Syphax was removed.

While Masinissa listened to these comments, he not only blushed deeply but also broke down in tears. He declared that he would leave it to the general's judgment and begged that, as much as possible, the general would consider the promise he had foolishly made, that he would not hand her over to anyone else. Embarrassed, he left the pavilion and went to his own tent. Once there, he dismissed his attendants and spent a long time sighing and groaning, which those outside the tent could clearly hear. Finally, after a deep sigh, he called one of his trusted servants, who held poison, as kings typically kept it as a remedy for sudden misfortunes. He instructed the servant to mix some into a cup and deliver it to Sophonisba, telling her that Masinissa would have gladly fulfilled his duty as her husband, but since those who had the power had taken that right from him, he was now honoring his second promise that she wouldn’t fall alive into Roman hands. He urged her to consider her father the general, her country, and the two kings she had been married to, and to take whatever action she deemed appropriate. When the servant arrived with this message and the poison, Sophonisba replied, "I accept this wedding gift; it is welcome, especially if my husband can offer me no better service. However, tell him I would have preferred to die before marrying so close to my death." She spoke with such spirit and took the chalice firmly, draining it without showing any signs of distress. When Scipio heard about this, worried that the passionate young man might make a desperate choice in his emotional state, he summoned him right away. Scipio first tried to comfort him and then gently scolded him for trying to remedy one reckless act with another, making the situation more tragic than necessary. The next day, to help distract him from his current pain, Scipio took his seat on the tribunal and called for an assembly. He greeted Masinissa with the title of king, praised him immensely, and presented him with a golden goblet, a curule chair, an ivory scepter, an embroidered gown, and a triumphal cloak. He emphasized that nothing among the Romans was more magnificent than a triumph, and that those who triumphed wore no finer decorations than those with which the Roman people deemed Masinissa alone, out of all foreigners, worthy. He then offered high praise to Laelius and gave him a golden crown, along with gifts to other military figures based on their achievements. These honors calmed the king and gave him hope that he would soon gain control over all of Numidia, now that Syphax was out of the picture.

16

Scipio, having sent Caius Laelius with Syphax and the rest of the prisoners to Rome, with whom went also ambassadors from Masinissa, led his troops back again to Tunes, and completed the fortifications which he had before begun. The Carthaginians, who had experienced not only a short-lived but almost groundless joy, from their attack upon the fleet, which, under existing circumstances, was tolerably successful, were so dismayed at the account of the capture of Syphax, in whom they reposed almost greater confidence than in Hasdrubal and his army, that now listening no longer to any who advocated war, they sent thirty of their principal elders as deputies to solicit peace. With them the council of elders is held in the highest reverence, and has supreme power even to control the senate itself. When they came into the Roman camp and entered the pavilion, they prostrated themselves after the manner of those who pay profound adoration to kings, adopting the custom, I suppose, from the country from which they derived their origin. Their language corresponded with such abject humiliation, for they did not endeavour to deny their guilt, but charged Hannibal and the favourers of his violent measures with being the originators of it. They implored pardon for their state, which had been now twice brought to the brink of ruin by the temerity of its citizens, and would again owe its safety to the indulgence of its enemies. They said, the object the Roman people aimed at in the subjugation of their enemies was dominion, and not their destruction; that he might enjoin what he pleased upon them, as being prepared submissively to obey. Scipio replied, "that he had come into Africa with the hope, and that hope had been increased by the success he had experienced in his operations, that he should carry home victory and not terms of peace. Still, though he had victory in a manner within his grasp, he would not refuse all accommodation, that all the nations of the world may know that the Roman people both undertake and conclude wars with justice." The terms of peace which he prescribed were these: "That they should restore the prisoners, deserters, and fugitives; withdraw their armies from Italy and Gaul; give up all claim to Spain; retire from all the islands between Italy and Africa; deliver up all their ships of war except twenty, and furnish five hundred thousand pecks of wheat, and three hundred thousand of barley." Authors are not agreed as to the sum of money he demanded. In some I find five thousand talents; in others five thousand pounds' weight of silver; in others, that double pay for the troops was required. "Three days," he said, "shall be allowed to deliberate whether you accept of peace on these terms. If you do accept it, make a truce within me, and send deputies to Rome to the senate." The Carthaginians being thus dismissed, as they thought it proper to accept of any conditions of peace, for their only object was to gain time for Hannibal to cross over into Africa, sent some ambassadors to Scipio to conclude a truce, and others to Rome to solicit peace; the latter taking with them a few prisoners, deserters, and fugitives, in order to facilitate the attainment of peace.

Scipio sent Caius Laelius along with Syphax and the other prisoners to Rome, accompanied by ambassadors from Masinissa. He then returned his troops to Tunes and finished the fortifications he had started earlier. The Carthaginians, having experienced a brief and almost unfounded joy from their attack on the fleet, which, under the circumstances, was somewhat successful, were so disheartened by the news of Syphax's capture—someone they believed in even more than Hasdrubal and his army—that they stopped listening to anyone who suggested continuing the war. Instead, they sent thirty of their leading elders as representatives to ask for peace. This council of elders was held in high regard and had the ultimate authority to even influence the senate. When they arrived at the Roman camp and entered the pavilion, they prostrated themselves in a way that showed deep respect, likely adopting this practice from their homeland. Their words matched their humble attitude; they didn't try to deny their wrongdoing but instead blamed Hannibal and his supporters for the situation. They begged for forgiveness for their state, which had already faced destruction twice due to the recklessness of its citizens and would rely on the kindness of their enemies for its survival. They stated that the Roman people's goal in defeating their enemies was to gain power, not to destroy them, and that they would willingly obey whatever terms were set. Scipio responded that he came to Africa with the hope, now strengthened by his successful efforts, of returning home with victory, not just peace terms. However, although victory seemed within reach, he wouldn’t refuse a reasonable settlement so that everyone would know the Roman people conduct and end wars justly. The conditions for peace he proposed were as follows: they must return the prisoners, deserters, and fugitives; remove their armies from Italy and Gaul; renounce all claims to Spain; withdraw from all islands between Italy and Africa; surrender all their warships except for twenty; and provide five hundred thousand pecks of wheat and three hundred thousand pecks of barley. There is some disagreement among historians regarding the exact sum of money he demanded. Some sources indicate five thousand talents, others mention five thousand pounds of silver, while still others claim that double pay for the troops was required. "You will have three days," he said, "to consider whether you will accept peace on these terms. If you agree, establish a truce with me and send representatives to Rome to the senate." The Carthaginians, realizing they should accept any peace conditions since their main aim was to buy time for Hannibal to return to Africa, sent some ambassadors to Scipio to arrange a truce and others to Rome to seek peace. The latter group took along a few prisoners, deserters, and fugitives to help facilitate their request for peace.

17

Laelius with Syphax and the principal Numidian prisoners arrived at Rome several days before, and laying before the senate all the transactions which had occurred in Africa in order, the greatest joy was felt for the present, and the most sanguine anticipations formed of the future. The sense of the senate being then taken upon the subject, they resolved that the king should be sent to Alba to be kept in custody, and that Laelius should be detained until the arrival of the Carthaginian ambassadors. A supplication for four days was decreed. The senate breaking up and an assembly of the people being then called, Publius Aelius the praetor accompanied by Caius Laelius, mounted the rostrum. There, on hearing that the armies of the Carthaginians had been routed, that a king of the greatest renown had been vanquished and made prisoner, that all Numidia had been overrun with brilliant success, the people were unable to refrain from expressing their delight, but manifested their transports by shouts and all the other means usually resorted to by the multitude. The praetor, therefore, immediately issued orders that the keepers should open all the temples throughout the city, and that the people should be allowed during the whole day to go round and make their adoration to the gods, and return their thanks. The next day he brought the ambassadors of Masinissa before the senate. They in the first place congratulated the senate on the successes of Scipio in Africa, and then thanked them, not only for having saluted him with the title of king, but for having made him one, by reinstating him in his paternal dominions, where, now that Syphax was removed, he would reign, if it was the pleasure of the senate, without fear or opposition. Next, for having bestowed upon him the highest commendations in the assembly, and decorated him with the most magnificent presents, of which Masinissa had endeavoured, and would in future endeavour, to render himself worthy. They requested that the senate would by a decree confirm the title of king with the other favours and benefits conferred by Scipio, and, if it were not troublesome, they said, that Masinissa further Requested that they would send home the Numidian captives who were detained at Rome; for that this boon would procure him the esteem and honour of his countrymen. On these points the senate replied to the ambassadors, "that they reciprocated the congratulations of the king on the successes in Africa. That Scipio was considered to have acted properly and regularly in saluting him with the title of king, and that the senate applauded and approved of every thing else he had done which was gratifying to Masinissa." They appointed by a decree what presents the ambassadors should carry to the king; they were, two purple cloaks, each having a golden clasp, and each accompanied with vests and broad purple borders, two horses arrayed with trappings, two suits of equestrian armour with coats of mail, together with tents and other military apparatus such as those usually provided for a consul. These the praetor was directed to send for the king. The ambassadors were severally presented with not less than five thousand asses, their attendants with one thousand. Two suits of apparel were presented to each of the ambassadors, and one to each of their attendants and to the Numidians, who were discharged from custody and given back to the king. In addition to these, dwellings, reserved by the state for such purposes, grounds, and entertainment, were assigned to the ambassadors.

Laelius, along with Syphax and the main Numidian prisoners, arrived in Rome several days earlier. Presenting to the Senate everything that had taken place in Africa, there was great joy about the current situation and optimistic hopes for the future. After the Senate discussed the matter, they decided to send the king to Alba for custody and to keep Laelius until the Carthaginian ambassadors arrived. They declared a four-day celebration. As the Senate adjourned and an assembly of the people was called, Publius Aelius the praetor, accompanied by Caius Laelius, went up to the platform. Upon hearing that the Carthaginian armies had been defeated, that a renowned king had been conquered and captured, and that all of Numidia had been successfully taken, the crowd couldn't help but express their excitement, cheering and using other typical expressions of joy. Therefore, the praetor immediately ordered that all the temples in the city be opened so that the people could spend the entire day worshipping the gods and giving thanks. The next day, he brought forward the ambassadors of Masinissa to the Senate. They first congratulated the Senate on Scipio's victories in Africa and then thanked them for not only acknowledging him as king but also restoring him to his ancestral lands, where, now that Syphax was out of the way, he could rule without fear or opposition, if the Senate wished it. Next, they expressed gratitude for the high praises he received in the assembly and the splendid gifts given to him, which Masinissa sought to deserve both now and in the future. They requested that the Senate confirm the title of king along with the other honors and benefits granted by Scipio, and if it wasn't too much trouble, they asked that Masinissa also be allowed to send home the Numidian captives held in Rome, as this favor would gain him respect and honor from his fellow countrymen. In response, the Senate told the ambassadors, "We reciprocate the king's congratulations on the successes in Africa. We believe Scipio acted correctly by addressing him as king, and we support everything else he has done to please Masinissa." They decreed what gifts the ambassadors should take to the king: two purple cloaks each with a golden clasp, accompanied by tunics and wide purple borders, two horses adorned with decorations, two sets of cavalry armor with chain mail, as well as tents and other military equipment typically provided for a consul. The praetor was instructed to send these to the king. Each ambassador was given no less than five thousand asses, and their attendants received one thousand. Each ambassador got two outfits, and each attendant, along with the Numidians released from custody, received one as well before being returned to the king. Additionally, the state allocated residences for the ambassadors, along with land and provisions for entertainment.

18

The same summer during which these decrees were passed at Rome, and these transactions took place in Africa, Publius Quinctilius Varus, the praetor, and Marcus Cornelius, the proconsul, fought a pitched battle with Mago the Carthaginian in the territories of the Insubrian Gauls. The legions of the praetor were in the first line; Cornelius kept his in reserve, riding forward into the front himself, and the praetor and proconsul, leading on the two wings, exhorted the soldiers to attack the enemy with the utmost vigour. Finding they produced no impression upon the enemy, Quinctilius said to Cornelius: "The battle, as you perceive, does not proceed with spirit, the enemy, having succeeded in their resistance beyond expectation, have become callous to fear, and there is danger lest it should be converted into boldness. We must stir up a tempest of cavalry if we wish to disorder and drive them from their ground; therefore, either do you sustain the fight in front, and I will lead the cavalry into the action; or else, I will act in the front line and you send out the cavalry of the four legions against the enemy." The proconsul offering to take whichever part of the service the praetor pleased, Quinctilius the praetor, with his son, surnamed Marcus, a spirited youth, went off to the cavalry, and desiring them to mount, instantly led them to the charge. The confusion on occasioned by these was increased by a shout raised by the legions; nor would the line of the enemy have stood unbroken, had not Mago, as soon as he saw the cavalry in motion, immediately brought into the action his elephants, which he kept in readiness. The horses were so terrified at the snorting, the smell, and appearance of these animals, that the aid of the cavalry was rendered ineffectual. As the Roman horseman had the advantage in point of efficiency in a close fight, when he could use his javelin and sword hand to hand, so the Numidians had the advantage when throwing their darts from a distance upon enemies borne away from them by their terrified horses. At the same time the twelfth legion, though a great number of them were slain, maintained their ground through shame rather than a reliance on their strength; but they would not have continued to do so longer, had not the thirteenth legion, brought up into the front line from the reserve, taken up the doubtful conflict. Mago, also, bringing up the Gauls from his reserve, opposed them to the fresh legion. The Gauls being routed without any great effort, the spearmen of the eleventh legion formed themselves into a circular body and charged the elephants, which were now disordering the line of infantry; and as scarcely one of the javelins which they threw upon them failed of taking effect, as they were close together, they turned them all upon the line of their own party. Four of them fell overpowered with wounds. It was then that the front line of the enemy gave ground, the whole body of the Roman infantry at the same time rushing forward to increase the panic and confusion, on seeing the elephants turn their backs. As long as Mago stood in front, the troops stepped back slowly, preserving their ranks and not relaxing their ardour in fighting; but when they saw him falling, from a wound in his thigh, which was transfixed, and carried off the field almost lifeless, in an instant they all betook themselves to flight. As many as five thousand of the enemy were slain, and twenty-two military standards captured on that day. Nor did the Romans obtain a bloodless victory. Two thousand three hundred of the army of the praetor, by far the greater part of whom belonged to the twelfth legion, were lost. Two military tribunes, Marcus Cosconius and Marcus Maenius, of the same legion; and of the thirteenth legion also, which joined in the action at its close, Cneius Helvius, a military tribune, fell in restoring the fight; and about twenty-two distinguished horsemen, together with several centurions, were trampled upon and killed by the elephants. The contest would have continued longer, had not the enemy conceded the victory, in consequence of the wound of their general.

The same summer that these decrees were passed in Rome and these events unfolded in Africa, Publius Quinctilius Varus, the praetor, and Marcus Cornelius, the proconsul, fought a fierce battle against Mago the Carthaginian in Insubrian Gaul. The praetor's legions were in the front line; Cornelius kept his in reserve, riding forward himself to the front, while the praetor and proconsul, leading on the two wings, urged the soldiers to attack the enemy with full force. When they saw their efforts weren't having much effect on the enemy, Quinctilius said to Cornelius: "The battle, as you can see, lacks energy; the enemy has withstood our attacks better than we expected and seems to have lost its fear, which is dangerous as it may lead to boldness. We need to unleash a cavalry charge if we want to disrupt them and drive them off their position; so, either you hold the line in front, and I will lead the cavalry into the fight; or I will fight in the front, and you send the cavalry from the four legions against the enemy." The proconsul offered to take whichever role the praetor wanted, and Quinctilius, along with his spirited son Marcus, went to the cavalry, telling them to mount up and immediately leading them into action. The confusion created by this was amplified by a shout from the legions; and the enemy line would have likely wavered, if Mago hadn’t immediately sent in his elephants, which he had ready. The horses were so startled by the elephants’ snorting, smell, and presence that the cavalry’s help was rendered ineffective. While Roman cavalry had the advantage in close combat with their javelins and swords, the Numidians had the edge when throwing their darts from a distance as their opponents were carried away by their frightened horses. At the same time, the twelfth legion, despite heavy losses, held their ground more out of shame than strength. However, they wouldn’t have lasted much longer if the thirteenth legion hadn’t been brought from the reserves to join the fight. Mago also brought up the Gauls from his reserves to face the fresh legion. The Gauls were quickly routed with little effort, and the spearmen of the eleventh legion formed a circle and charged at the elephants that were now disrupting the infantry line; nearly every javelin they threw struck true since they were so close, and they turned them all back toward their own line. Four of their men fell, overwhelmed by wounds. It was at that moment that the enemy’s front line began to retreat, while the entire Roman infantry surged forward to increase the panic and chaos as they saw the elephants turning away. As long as Mago was at the front, the troops stepped back slowly, maintaining their ranks and their fighting spirit; but when they saw him fall, wounded in the thigh and carried off the field almost lifeless, they instantly broke into flight. About five thousand enemy soldiers were killed that day, and twenty-two military standards were captured. The Romans didn’t win without cost, though: two thousand three hundred of the praetor’s army were lost, most of whom were from the twelfth legion. Two military tribunes, Marcus Cosconius and Marcus Maenius, from that legion, along with Cneius Helvius, a tribune of the thirteenth legion who had joined the fight near the end, fell while trying to restore order in the battle, and about twenty-two notable cavalrymen, along with several centurions, were trampled and killed by the elephants. The fight might have gone on longer had the enemy not conceded defeat due to their general's injury.

19

Mago, setting out during the silence of the succeeding night, and marching as far at a time as his wounds would allow him, reached the sea-coast in the territory of the Ingaunian Ligurians. Here ambassadors from Carthage, who had put into the Gallic bay a few days before, came to him with directions to cross over into Africa with all speed; informing him that his brother Hannibal, for to him also they said ambassadors had gone with similar directions, would do the same, for the affairs of the Carthaginians were not in a condition to admit of their occupying Gaul and Italy with armies. Mago, not only influenced by the command of the senate and the danger which threatened his country, but fearful also lest the victorious enemy should be upon him if he delayed, and lest the Ligurians themselves, seeing that the Carthaginians were leaving Italy, should pass over to those under whose power they were likely soon to be placed; at the same time hoping that his wound would be less irritated by the motion of sailing than marching, and that he would have greater facilities for the cure of it, put his troops on board and set sail. But he had scarcely cleared Sardinia when he died of his wound. Several also of his ships, which had been dispersed in the main sea, were captured by the Roman fleet which lay near Sardinia. Such were the transactions by sea and land in that part of Italy which is adjacent to the Alps. The consul, Caius Servilius, without having performed any memorable achievement in Etruria, his province, and in Gaul, for he had advanced thither also, but having rescued from slavery, which they had endured for now the sixteenth year, his father, Caius Servilius, and his uncle, Caius Lutatius, who had been taken by the Boians at the village of Tanetum, returned to Rome with his father on one side of him and his uncle on the other, distinguished, by family, rather than by public, honours. It was proposed to the people, that Caius Servilius should be indemnified for having filled the offices of plebeian tribune and plebeian aedile contrary to what was established by the laws, while his father, who had sat in the curule chair, was still alive, he being ignorant of that circumstance. This proposition having been carried, he returned to his province. The towns Consentia, Uffugum, Vergae, Besidiae, Hetriculum, Sypheum, Argentanum, Clampetia, and many other inconsiderable states, perceiving that the Carthaginian cause was declining, went over to Cneius Servilius the consul in Bruttium. The same consul fought a battle with Hannibal, in the territory of Croto. The accounts of this battle are not clear. Valerius Antias states that five thousand men were slain. But this is an event of such magnitude, that either it must be an impudent fiction, or negligently omitted. It is certain that nothing further was done by Hannibal in Italy; for ambassadors from Carthage, recalling him into Africa, came to him, as it happened, at the same time that they came to Mago.

Mago, setting out during the quiet of the following night and marching as far as his injuries would allow, reached the coastline in the territory of the Ingaunian Ligurians. Here, ambassadors from Carthage, who had arrived in the Gallic bay a few days earlier, met him with orders to hurry across to Africa; they informed him that his brother Hannibal, to whom ambassadors had also gone with similar orders, would do the same, as the situation for the Carthaginians did not permit them to maintain armies in Gaul and Italy. Mago, not only driven by the senate's command and the danger threatening his homeland, but also worried that the victorious enemy might catch him if he delayed, and that the Ligurians, seeing the Carthaginians leaving Italy, might switch sides to whoever would soon control them; at the same time hoping that sailing would irritate his wound less than marching and provide him with better chances for recovery, put his troops on board and set sail. But he had barely left Sardinia when he died from his wound. Several of his ships, scattered in the open sea, were captured by the Roman fleet that was positioned near Sardinia. These were the events by sea and land in that part of Italy adjacent to the Alps. The consul, Caius Servilius, having achieved nothing notable in Etruria, his province, and having moved into Gaul as well, but having rescued from captivity, which they had endured for the last sixteen years, his father, Caius Servilius, and his uncle, Caius Lutatius, who had been captured by the Boians at the village of Tanetum, returned to Rome with his father on one side and his uncle on the other, distinguished more by family ties than public honors. It was proposed to the people that Caius Servilius should be compensated for having held the positions of plebeian tribune and plebeian aedile in violation of the laws while his father, who had served in the curule chair, was still alive, and he being unaware of this fact. This proposal passed, and he returned to his province. The towns of Consentia, Uffugum, Vergae, Besidiae, Hetriculum, Sypheum, Argentanum, Clampetia, and many other minor states, noticing that the Carthaginian cause was waning, switched allegiance to Cneius Servilius, the consul in Bruttium. This same consul fought a battle with Hannibal in the territory of Croto. The details of this battle are unclear. Valerius Antias claims that five thousand men were killed. But this is such a significant event that it must either be a blatant lie or carelessly overlooked. It is certain that nothing further was accomplished by Hannibal in Italy; for ambassadors from Carthage, recalling him to Africa, arrived at the same time as they came to Mago.

20

It is said that when Hannibal heard the message of the ambassadors he gnashed with his teeth, groaned, and scarcely refrained from shedding tears. After they had delivered the commands with which they were charged, he said: "Those who have for a long time been endeavouring to drag me home, by forbidding the sending of supplies and money to me, now recall me, not indirectly, but openly. Hannibal, therefore, hath been conquered, not by the Roman people, who have been so often slain and routed, but by the Carthaginian senate, through envy and detraction; nor will Publius Scipio exult and glory in this unseemly return so much as Hanno, who has crushed our family, since he could not effect it by any other means, by the ruins of Carthage." Already had his mind entertained a presentiment of this event, and he had accordingly prepared ships beforehand. Having, therefore, sent a crowd of useless soldiers under pretence of garrisons into the towns in the Bruttian territory, a few of which continued their adherence to him, more through fear than attachment, he transported the strength of his army into Africa. Many natives of Italy who, refusing to follow him into Africa had retired to the shrine of Juno Lacinia, which had never been violated up to that day, were barbarously massacred in the very temple. It is related, that rarely any person leaving his country to go into exile exhibited deeper sorrow than Hannibal did on departing from the land of his enemies; that he frequently looked back upon the shores of Italy, and, arraigning both gods and men, cursed himself and his own head that he did not lead his troops, while reeking with blood from the victory at Cannae, to Rome. Scipio, who since his appointment to the office of consul had not looked at the Carthaginian enemy in Italy, had dared, he said, to go and attack Carthage, while he, after slaying a hundred thousand fighting men at Trasimenus and Cannae, had suffered his strength to wear away around Casilinum, Cumae, and Nola. Amid these reproaches and complaints he was borne away from his long occupation of Italy.

It’s said that when Hannibal heard the ambassadors' message, he gritted his teeth, groaned, and barely held back tears. After they delivered their orders, he said: "Those who have long tried to bring me home by blocking supplies and money are now recalling me, not subtly, but outright. Hannibal has been defeated, not by the Roman people, who have been killed and beaten many times, but by the Carthaginian senate, out of envy and malice; nor will Publius Scipio take as much pleasure in this disgraceful return as Hanno, who has destroyed our family because he couldn’t do it another way, through the ruins of Carthage." He had already sensed this outcome and had prepared ships in advance. So, he sent a bunch of useless soldiers under the pretense of garrisons to the towns in the Bruttian territory, a few of which still supported him, more out of fear than loyalty, and he moved the core of his army to Africa. Many locals from Italy who had refused to follow him to Africa and had taken refuge at the shrine of Juno Lacinia, which had never been violated until then, were brutally slaughtered right in the temple. It’s said that few people leaving their homeland for exile showed as much sorrow as Hannibal did when he left the land of his enemies; he often looked back at the shores of Italy, cursing both the gods and men and blaming himself for not leading his troops, still soaked in blood from the victory at Cannae, to Rome. Scipio, who since becoming consul had not faced the Carthaginian enemy in Italy, had the nerve to go and attack Carthage while he, after killing a hundred thousand soldiers at Trasimenus and Cannae, allowed his strength to dwindle around Casilinum, Cumae, and Nola. Amid these accusations and grievances, he was taken away from his long hold on Italy.

21

At the same time intelligence was brought to Rome that both Mago and Hannibal had taken their departure. But the delight occasioned by this twofold source of joy was diminished by the reflection that their commanders had wanted either spirit or strength sufficient to detain them, for they had been charged by the senate to do so; and also in consequence of the anxiety they felt for the issue of a contest, in which the whole weight of the war rested on the efforts of one general and his army. About the same time ambassadors from Saguntum arrived, bringing with them some Carthaginians who had crossed over into Spain for the purpose of hiring auxiliaries, having seized them and the money they had with them. They laid down in the vestibule of the senate-house two hundred and fifty pounds' weight of gold, and eight hundred of silver. After the men had been received and thrown into prison, and the gold and silver returned, the ambassadors were thanked, and received, besides, presents and ships to convey them back into Spain. Some of the older senators then observed, that men were less powerfully affected by prosperity than adversity. That they themselves remembered what terror and consternation had been occasioned by the passage of Hannibal into Italy; what disasters and what lamentations had followed that event. When the camp of the enemy was seen from their walls, what vows were poured forth by each and all! How often, extending their hands to heaven, exclamations were heard in their assemblies. Oh! will that day ever arrive when we shall behold Italy cleared of her enemies and enjoying the blessings of peace! The gods, they said, had at length, in the sixteenth year, granted that favour and yet there was no one who proposed that thanks should be returned to them for it. That if men received a present blessing so ungratefully, they would not be very mindful of it when it was past. In consequence of this a general shout was raised from every part of the senate-house, that Publius Aelius the praetor, should lay the matter before the senate, and a decree was passed, that a supplication should be performed at all the shrines for the space of five days, and that a hundred and twenty victims of the larger sort should be immolated. Laelius and the ambassadors of Masinissa having been by this time dismissed, and intelligence having arrived that ambassadors of the Carthaginians, who were coming to the senate to treat about peace, had been seen at Puteoli, and would proceed thence by land, it was resolved, that Caius Laelius should be recalled, that the negotiations respecting the peace might take place in his presence. Quintus Fulvius Gillo, a lieutenant-general of Scipio, conducted the Carthaginians to Rome; and as they were forbidden to enter the city, they were lodged in a country-house belonging to the state, and admitted to an audience of the senate at the temple of Bellona.

At the same time, news reached Rome that both Mago and Hannibal had left. However, the joy from this double victory was lessened by the realization that their leaders lacked the courage or strength to keep them there, despite being ordered by the senate to do so. There was also concern about the outcome of a conflict that depended entirely on the efforts of one general and his army. Around the same time, ambassadors from Saguntum arrived, bringing some Carthaginians who had crossed over into Spain to recruit soldiers but were captured along with their money. They laid down in the senate-house's entrance two hundred and fifty pounds of gold and eight hundred of silver. After the captured men were imprisoned and the gold and silver were returned, the ambassadors were thanked and given gifts, along with ships to take them back to Spain. Some older senators then remarked that people are affected more by hardship than by good fortune. They recalled the fear and panic caused by Hannibal's invasion of Italy, and the disasters and mourning that followed. When the enemy's camp was seen from their walls, everyone made vows! How many times, with hands raised to the heavens, were cries heard in their gatherings: "Oh! Will we ever see a day when Italy is free from her enemies and living in peace?" The gods, they said, had finally granted that favor in the sixteenth year, yet no one suggested offering thanks. They believed if people received a blessing so thoughtlessly, they wouldn't remember it once it was gone. This led to a loud shout from all parts of the senate-house that Publius Aelius the praetor should present this issue to the senate, and a decree was passed for a five-day public supplication at all the shrines, with a hundred and twenty larger victims to be sacrificed. After Laelius and the ambassadors of Masinissa had been dismissed, news came that Carthaginian ambassadors on their way to the senate to discuss peace had been seen at Puteoli and would travel by land from there. It was decided that Caius Laelius should be recalled so that the peace negotiations could happen in his presence. Quintus Fulvius Gillo, a lieutenant-general of Scipio, escorted the Carthaginians to Rome; and since they were not allowed to enter the city, they were hosted in a state-owned country house and granted an audience with the senate at the temple of Bellona.

22

They addressed the senate in nearly the same terms as they had employed before Scipio; laying the whole blame of the war upon Hannibal, and exculpating their state. They declared, that he had not only crossed the Alps, but the Iberus also, without the sanction of the senate; and that he had made war not only on the Romans, but previously on the Saguntines also, on his own individual responsibility. That, if the question were viewed in its proper light, it would be found that the league between the senate and people of Carthage and the Romans remained unbroken up to that day. Accordingly, all they had in charge to solicit was, that they might be allowed to continue in the enjoyment of that peace which was last entered into with the consul Caius Lutatius. When the praetor, according to the custom handed down from their ancestors, had given the fathers permission to ask the ambassadors any questions they might be pleased to put, and the older members who had been present at the making of the treaties had put some one question and others another, the ambassadors declared that they were not old enough to recollect, for they were nearly all of them young men. Upon this every part of the senate-house resounded with exclamations, that with Carthaginian knavery men had been chosen to solicit a renewal of the old peace who did not recollect its terms.

They spoke to the senate almost exactly as they had before Scipio, putting all the blame for the war on Hannibal and clearing their own state of responsibility. They stated that he had crossed not only the Alps but also the Iberus without the senate's approval, and that he had waged war not just against the Romans but also against the Saguntines, all on his own initiative. They argued that if the situation were looked at correctly, it would be evident that the alliance between the senate and the people of Carthage and the Romans remained intact up to that point. Therefore, all they requested was to be allowed to continue enjoying the peace that had been established with Consul Caius Lutatius. When the praetor, following the traditions passed down from their ancestors, allowed the senators to ask the ambassadors any questions they wanted, and the older members who had witnessed the treaties asked various questions, the ambassadors replied that they were too young to remember, as most of them were nearly all young men. This led to loud outcries throughout the senate chamber, condemning the choice of Carthaginian representatives to request a renewal of the old peace when they had no memory of its terms.

23

After this, the ambassadors having been removed out of the senate-house, the senators began to be asked their opinions. Marcus Livius recommended, that Caius Servilius, the consul nearest home, should be sent for, that he might be present at the proceedings relative to the peace; for as it was impossible that any subject of deliberation could occur of greater importance than the present, he did not see how it could be discussed, consistently with the dignity of the Roman people, in the absence of one or both of the consuls. Quintus Metellus, who three years before had been consul, and had filled the office of dictator, said that, since Publius Scipio, by destroying the armies and by devastating the lands of the enemy, had reduced them to such a state that they were compelled as supplicants to sue for peace; and as no one could estimate with more truth the intentions with which it was solicited, than he who was prosecuting the war before the gates of Carthage; the peace should be rejected or adopted on the advice of none other than Scipio. Marcus Valerius Laevinus, who had been twice consul, endeavoured to show that those who had come were spies, and not ambassadors; that they ought to be ordered to depart from Italy; that guards should be sent with them to their very ships, and that Scipio should be written to not to relax in prosecuting the war. Laelius and Fulvius added, that Scipio had grounded his hopes of effecting a peace on Hannibal and Mago not being recalled from Italy. He considered that the Carthaginians would practise every species of dissimulation, in expectation of the arrival of those generals and their armies, and then, forgetful of all treaties, however recent, and all gods, would proceed with the war. For these reasons they were the more disposed to adopt the opinion of Laevinus. The ambassadors were dismissed without having accomplished the peace, and almost without an answer.

After this, once the ambassadors were removed from the senate house, the senators began to share their opinions. Marcus Livius suggested that they call for Caius Servilius, the consul who was closest, to be present during the discussions about peace. He argued that there couldn't be a more important topic to discuss than this one, and it wouldn't be appropriate for the Roman people to deliberate on it without one or both of the consuls present. Quintus Metellus, a former consul and dictator from three years earlier, stated that since Publius Scipio had defeated the enemy's armies and ravaged their lands, they were now in such a desperate situation that they had to beg for peace. He emphasized that no one could better understand the motives behind the request for peace than Scipio, who was engaged in war right outside Carthage. Therefore, the decision to accept or reject the peace should rely solely on Scipio's advice. Marcus Valerius Laevinus, who had served as consul twice, argued that the visitors were spies rather than true ambassadors and proposed that they should be ordered to leave Italy, escorted to their ships, and that Scipio should be notified not to ease up on the war effort. Laelius and Fulvius added that Scipio's hopes for peace were based on the fact that Hannibal and Mago were not recalled from Italy. They believed the Carthaginians would use every sort of deception, waiting for those generals and their armies to arrive, and then, disregarding all recent treaties and the gods, would resume fighting. For these reasons, they were more inclined to support Laevinus's view. The ambassadors were dismissed without achieving peace and almost without a response.

24

About the same time Cneius Servilius, the consul, not doubting but that he should enjoy the glory of having restored Italy to a state of peace, pursued Hannibal, whom he considered had fled before him, and crossed over into Sicily, with the intention of proceeding thence into Africa. As soon as this became known at Rome, at first the fathers gave it as their opinion, that the praetor should inform the consul by letter that the senate thought it proper that he should return into Italy; but afterwards, the praetor declaiming that he would not heed his letter, Publius Sulpicius, who was created dictator for this very purpose, recalled the consul to Italy, in virtue of his superior authority. The remainder of the year he employed in conjunction with Marcus Servilius, his master of the horse, in going round to the cities of Italy, which had been alienated from the Romans during the war, and in taking cognizance of the cases of each. During the time of the truce, Lentulus the praetor sent over into Africa, from Sardinia, a hundred transports with stores, under a convoy of twenty ships of war, without meeting with any injury either from the enemy or storms. The same good fortune did not attend Cneius Octavius, while crossing over from Sicily with two hundred transports and thirty men of war. Having experienced a prosperous voyage until he arrived almost within sight of Africa, at first the wind dropped, but afterwards changing to the south-west, it dispersed his ships in every direction. He himself with the ships of war, having struggled through the opposing billows by the extraordinary exertions of his rowers, made the promontory of Apollo. The greater part of the transports were driven to Aegimurus, an island filling the mouth of the bay on which Carthage stands, and about thirty miles from the city; the rest were driven on shore directly opposite the city, near the warm baths. The whole occurrence was within sight of Carthage, and, accordingly, the people ran in crowds to the forum, from every part of the city. The magistrates summoned the senate, and the people were yelling in the vestibule of the senate-house, lest so great a booty should escape from their hands and their sight. Though some urged as an objection the obligation imposed upon them by having solicited peace, and others the restraint occasioned by the existence of a truce, the period of which had not yet expired, it was agreed in an assembly, made up almost of a mixture of the senate and people, that Hasdrubal should cross over to Aegimurus with fifty ships, and, proceeding thence, pick up the Roman ships scattered along the coasts and in the different ports. First the transports from Aegimurus, and then those from the baths, abandoned by the crews, were towed to Carthage.

About the same time, Cneius Servilius, the consul, confident that he would gain the glory of restoring peace to Italy, chased Hannibal, whom he believed had fled from him, and crossed over to Sicily, intending to move on to Africa. Once this news reached Rome, the senators initially suggested that the praetor should inform the consul by letter that the senate thought it wise for him to return to Italy. However, when the praetor declared he would ignore this letter, Publius Sulpicius, who was appointed dictator for this very reason, recalled the consul to Italy based on his higher authority. He spent the rest of the year working alongside Marcus Servilius, his master of the horse, visiting the cities in Italy that had turned away from the Romans during the war and addressing the cases in each city. During the truce, Lentulus the praetor sent a hundred supply ships from Sardinia to Africa, escorted by twenty warships, without encountering any harm from either the enemy or the weather. Cneius Octavius, however, did not have the same luck when crossing from Sicily with two hundred transports and thirty warships. After a smooth journey to almost the shores of Africa, the wind first died down, but then shifted to the southwest, scattering his ships in all directions. Despite this, he and the warships managed to navigate through the rough seas with the tremendous effort of the rowers and reached the promontory of Apollo. Most of the transports were forced to Aegimurus, an island at the mouth of the bay where Carthage is located, about thirty miles from the city, while the rest ended up just across from the city, near the hot springs. This entire event was visible from Carthage, and crowds quickly gathered in the forum from all parts of the city. The magistrates called the senate together, and the people shouted in the entrance of the senate house, fearing that such a great prize might slip away from them. Some argued against taking action due to their prior request for peace, while others pointed out the limitation posed by the existing truce, which had not yet expired. Nevertheless, it was decided in a gathering that was almost a mix of the senate and the populace that Hasdrubal should sail to Aegimurus with fifty ships and then collect the scattered Roman ships along the coasts and various ports. First, the transports from Aegimurus, and then those from the baths, abandoned by their crews, were towed to Carthage.

25

The ambassadors had not as yet returned from Rome, nor was it known whether the Roman senate had pronounced in favour of peace or war; nor as yet had the period of the truce expired. Scipio, therefore, considering that the malignity of their offence was heightened by the fact, that, though they had solicited peace and a truce, they had cut off all hopes of the former and violated the latter, immediately despatched Lucius Baebius, Lucius Sergius, and Lucius Fabius, as ambassadors to Carthage. These, having narrowly escaped violence from the assembled multitude, and perceiving that they would be exposed to similar danger on their return, requested of the magistrates, by whose aid they had been protected from violence, to send ships to escort them. Two triremes were assigned them, which, when they had come to the river Bagradas, whence the Roman camp could be seen, returned to Carthage. The Carthaginian fleet was stationed at Utica, and from this three quadriremes were despatched, which suddenly attacked the Roman quinquereme from the main sea, while doubling the promontory, either owing to a message sent from Carthage that this should be done, or that Hasdrubal, who commanded the fleet, perpetrated the atrocity without public connivance. But neither could they strike it with their beaks from the rapidity with which it evaded them, nor could the fighting men board the higher from lower vessels. The quinquereme was gallantly defended as long as their weapons lasted; but these failing, and there being now nothing which could save them but the nearness of the land, and the multitude which had poured out from the camp upon the shore, they communicated a rapid motion to the vessel by means of their oars, and running her against the shore with all the force they could, they escaped themselves without injury, and only lost the vessel. Thus when the truce had been unequivocally violated by repeated acts of villany, Laelius and Fulvius arrived from Rome with the Carthaginian ambassadors. Scipio told them, that although the Carthaginians had not only broken their faith pledged in the truce, but had also violated the laws of nations in the persons of his ambassadors, yet he would not in their case do any thing unworthy of the maxims of the Roman people or his own principles; after saying which, he dismissed the ambassadors and prepared for war. When Hannibal was now drawing near land, one of the sailors, who was ordered to climb the mast to see what part of the country they were making, said the prow pointed toward a demolished sepulchre, when Hannibal, recognising the inauspicious omen, ordered the pilot to steer by that place, and putting in his fleet at Leptis, landed his forces there.

The ambassadors hadn’t returned from Rome yet, and it was still unclear whether the Roman Senate had decided on peace or war; plus, the truce period hadn’t expired either. Scipio, realizing that their crime was worsened by the fact that, although they had asked for peace and a truce, they had dashed all hopes of the former and violated the latter, quickly sent Lucius Baebius, Lucius Sergius, and Lucius Fabius as ambassadors to Carthage. These ambassadors narrowly escaped violence from an angry crowd and, knowing they would face similar danger on their way back, asked the local officials, who had helped protect them, to send ships for their escort. They were assigned two triremes, which returned to Carthage after reaching the river Bagradas, where the Roman camp was visible. The Carthaginian fleet was stationed at Utica, from where three quadriremes were sent out to suddenly attack the Roman quinquereme from the open sea while rounding the promontory, either due to a command from Carthage or because Hasdrubal, who led the fleet, acted without public agreement. However, they couldn't hit the quinquereme as it quickly evaded them, and their soldiers couldn’t board it from their lower vessels. The quinquereme was bravely defended as long as their weapons lasted; but when they ran out, and with only the near land and the mass of troops rushing out from the camp offering hope of escape, they used their oars to power the vessel towards the shore as hard as they could. They managed to escape without injury, losing only the ship. Thus, once the truce was clearly broken by repeated acts of wrongdoing, Laelius and Fulvius arrived from Rome with the Carthaginian ambassadors. Scipio informed them that, even though the Carthaginians had not only broken their promise from the truce but also violated the laws of nations against his ambassadors, he would not act in a way that dishonored the principles of the Roman people or his own beliefs; after saying this, he dismissed the ambassadors and prepared for war. As Hannibal approached land, one of the sailors sent to climb the mast and check where they were headed reported that the ship was pointed toward a ruined tomb. Hannibal, recognizing this bad omen, ordered the pilot to steer toward that place and brought his fleet into Leptis, where he landed his forces.

26

Such were the transactions in Africa this year. Those which followed extended themselves into that year in which Marcus Servilius Geminus, who was then master of the horse and Tiberius Claudius Nero were consuls. However, at the close of the former year, deputies from the allied states in Greece having arrived with complaints that their lands had been devastated by the king's garrisons, and that their ambassadors, who had gone into Macedonia to demand restitution had not been admitted into the presence of Philip; and having also brought information that four thousand men were said to have been conveyed over into Africa, under the conduct of Sopater, to assist the Carthaginians, and that a considerable quantity of money had been sent with them; the senate resolved that ambassadors should be sent to the king to inform him that the fathers considered that these acts were contrary to the treaty. The persons sent were Caius Terentius Varro, Caius Mamilius, and Marcus Aurelius. Three quinqueremes were assigned to them. This year was rendered remarkable by a most extensive fire, by which the buildings on the Publician hill were burned to the ground, and by the greatness of the floods. But still provisions were cheap, not only because, as it was a time of peace, supplies could be obtained from every part of Italy, but also because Marcus Valerius Falto and Marcus Fabius Buteo, the curule aediles, distributed to the people, so much for each street, at the rate of four asses a bushel, a great quantity of corn which had been sent out of Spain. The same year died Quintus Fabius Maximus at an advanced age, if, indeed, it be true that he was augur sixty-two years, which some historians relate. He was a man unquestionably worthy of the high surname which he bore, even had it begun with him. He surpassed the honours of his father, and equalled those of his grandfather. His grandfather, Rullus, was distinguished by a greater number of victories and more important battles; but one antagonist like Hannibal is sufficient to counterbalance them all. He was esteemed rather cautious than spirited; and though it may be questioned whether he was naturally dilatory, or whether he adopted that kind of conduct because it was peculiarly suited to the war which he was carrying on, yet nothing can be more clear that he was that one man who by his delay retrieved our affairs, as Ennius says. Quintus Fabius Maximus, his son, was consecrated augur in his room. In the room of the same, for he held two priesthoods, Servius Sulpicius Galba was consecrated pontiff. The Roman games were repeated for one day, the plebeian were thrice repeated entire by the aediles, Marcus Sextius Sabinus and Cneius Tremellius Flaccus. Both these were elected praetors, and with them Caius Livius Salinator and Caius Aurelius Cotta. The difference in the accounts of historians renders it uncertain whether Caius Servilius the consul presided in the elections this year, or Publius Sulpicius, nominated dictator by him, because business detained him in Etruria; being engaged, according to a decree of the senate, in making inquisitions respecting the conspiracies of the principal inhabitants.

Such were the events in Africa this year. The following developments spanned into the year when Marcus Servilius Geminus, who was the master of the horse, and Tiberius Claudius Nero served as consuls. However, at the end of the previous year, representatives from the allied states in Greece arrived with complaints that their lands had been destroyed by the king's troops. They also reported that their ambassadors, who had gone to Macedonia to request reparations, had not been allowed to meet with Philip. Additionally, they brought word that four thousand men had reportedly been sent to Africa, led by Sopater, to support the Carthaginians, along with a significant amount of money. The senate decided to send ambassadors to the king to inform him that they believed these actions violated the treaty. The men chosen were Caius Terentius Varro, Caius Mamilius, and Marcus Aurelius. Three quinqueremes were assigned to them. This year was notable for a massive fire that destroyed the buildings on Publician Hill and for severe flooding. Yet, food prices remained low, not only because it was a time of peace, allowing supplies to come from all over Italy, but also because Marcus Valerius Falto and Marcus Fabius Buteo, the curule aediles, distributed a large amount of corn sent from Spain to the people at a rate of four asses per bushel. The same year saw the death of Quintus Fabius Maximus at an old age, if it is indeed true that he served as augur for sixty-two years, as some historians claim. He was undoubtedly worthy of the high title he held, even if it began with him. He surpassed his father's honors and matched those of his grandfather. His grandfather, Rullus, was noted for a greater number of victories and more significant battles; however, one opponent like Hannibal is enough to overshadow them all. He was considered more cautious than brave, and although it can be debated whether he was inherently slow or if he adopted such an approach because it suited the war he was waging, it is clear that he was the one who, through his delays, restored our situation, as Ennius puts it. His son, Quintus Fabius Maximus, was appointed as augur in his place. In the same role, as he held two priesthoods, Servius Sulpicius Galba was appointed as pontiff. The Roman games were held for one day, and the plebeian games were held three times entirely by the aediles, Marcus Sextius Sabinus and Cneius Tremellius Flaccus. Both were elected praetors, alongside Caius Livius Salinator and Caius Aurelius Cotta. The conflicting accounts among historians make it uncertain whether Caius Servilius, the consul, oversaw the elections this year or if Publius Sulpicius, whom he appointed as dictator, did so because he was occupied in Etruria, engaged in inquiries related to the conspiracies of the leading residents.

27

In the beginning of the following year, Marcus Servilius and Tiberius Claudius, having assembled the senate, consulted them respecting the provinces. As both were desirous of having Africa, they wished Italy and Africa to be disposed of by lots; but, principally in consequence of the exertions of Quintus Metellus, Africa was neither assigned to any one nor withheld. The consuls were ordered to make application to the tribunes of the people, to the effect, that, if they thought proper, they should put it to the people to decide whom they wished to conduct the war in Africa. All the tribes nominated Publius Scipio. Nevertheless, the consuls put the province of Africa to the lot, for so the senate had decreed. Africa fell to the lot of Tiberius Claudius, who was to cross over into Africa with a fleet of fifty ships, all quinqueremes, and have an equal command with Scipio. Marcus Servilius obtained Etruria. Caius Servilius was continued in command in the same province, in case the senate resolved that the consul should remain at the city. Of the praetors, Marcus Sextus obtained Gaul; which province, together with two legions, Publius Quinctilius Varus was to deliver to him; Caius Livius obtained Bruttium, with the two legions which Publius Sempronius, the proconsul, had commanded the former year; Cneius Tremellius had Sicily, and was to receive the province and two legions from Publius Villius Tappulus, a praetor of the former year; Villius, as propraetor, was to protect the coast of Sicily with twenty men of war, and a thousand soldiers; and Marcus Pomponius was to convey thence to Rome one thousand five hundred soldiers, with the remaining twenty ships. The city jurisdiction fell to Caius Aurelius Cotta; and the rest of the praetors were continued in command of the respective provinces and armies which they then had. Not more than sixteen legions were employed this year in the defence of the empire. And, that they might have the gods favourably disposed towards them in all their undertakings and proceedings, it was ordered that the consuls, before they set out to the war, should celebrate those games, and sacrifice those victims of the larger sort, which, in the consulate of Marcus Claudius Marcellus and Titus Quinctius, Titus Manlius, the dictator, had vowed, provided the commonwealth should continue in the same state for the next five years. The games were exhibited in the circus during four days, and the victims sacrificed to those deities to whom they had been vowed.

At the beginning of the next year, Marcus Servilius and Tiberius Claudius gathered the senate to discuss the provinces. Wanting Africa for themselves, they proposed to divide Italy and Africa by lots; however, mainly due to the efforts of Quintus Metellus, Africa was neither given to anyone nor held back. The consuls were instructed to ask the tribunes of the people to decide if they wanted the people to choose who would lead the war in Africa. All the tribes chose Publius Scipio. Nonetheless, the consuls put the province of Africa to the lot, as the senate had decided. Africa was assigned to Tiberius Claudius, who would go to Africa with a fleet of fifty quinquereme ships and share command with Scipio. Marcus Servilius got Etruria. Caius Servilius remained in charge of the same province in case the senate decided that the consul should stay in the city. Among the praetors, Marcus Sextus received Gaul, which Publius Quinctilius Varus would give to him along with two legions; Caius Livius received Bruttium, with the two legions that former proconsul Publius Sempronius had commanded the previous year; Cneius Tremellius was assigned Sicily and would take over the province and two legions from Publius Villius Tappulus, a praetor from last year; Villius, as propraetor, was to secure the coast of Sicily with twenty warships and a thousand soldiers; and Marcus Pomponius was to transport one thousand five hundred soldiers back to Rome with the remaining twenty ships. The city jurisdiction was assigned to Caius Aurelius Cotta, while the other praetors continued to oversee their respective provinces and armies. No more than sixteen legions were active this year for the defense of the empire. To ensure favorable support from the gods in all their plans and actions, it was decided that the consuls would celebrate games and sacrifice larger victims before heading to war, which Titus Manlius, the dictator, had vowed during the consulship of Marcus Claudius Marcellus and Titus Quinctius, provided the state remained stable for the next five years. The games took place in the circus over four days, and the promised victims were sacrificed to the deities they were dedicated to.

28

Meanwhile, hope and anxiety daily and simultaneously increased; nor could the minds of men be brought to any fixed conclusion, whether it was a fit subject for rejoicing, that Hannibal had now at length, after the sixteenth year, departed from Italy, and left the Romans in the unmolested possession of it, or whether they had not greater cause to fear, from his having transported his army in safety into Africa. They said that the scene of action certainly was changed, but not the danger. That Quintus Fabius, lately deceased, who had foretold how arduous the contest would be, was used to predict, not without good reason, that Hannibal would prove a more formidable enemy in his own country than he had been in a foreign one; and that Scipio would have to encounter not Syphax, a king of undisciplined barbarians, whose armies Statorius, a man little better than a soldier's drudge, was used to lead; nor his father-in-law, Hasdrubal, that most fugacious general; nor tumultuary armies hastily collected out of a crowd of half-armed rustics, but Hannibal, born in a manner in the pavilion of his father, that bravest of generals, nurtured and educated in the midst of arms, who served as a soldier formerly, when a boy, and became a general when he had scarcely attained the age of manhood; who, having grown old in victory, had filled Spain, Gaul, and Italy, from the Alps to the strait, with monuments of his vast achievements; who commanded troops who had served as long as he had himself; troops hardened by the endurance of every species of suffering, such as it is scarcely credible that men could have supported; stained a thousand times with Roman blood, and bearing with them the spoils not only of soldiers but of generals. That many would meet the eyes of Scipio in battle who had with their own hands slain Roman praetors, generals, and consuls; many decorated with crowns, in reward for having scaled walls and crossed ramparts; many who had traversed the captured camps and cities of the Romans. That the magistrates of the Roman people had not then so many fasces as Hannibal could have carried before him, having taken them from generals whom he had slain. While their minds were harassed by these apprehensions, their anxiety and fears were further increased from the circumstance, that, whereas they had been accustomed to carry on war for several years, in different parts of Italy, and within their view, with languid hopes, and without the prospect of bringing it to a speedy termination, Scipio and Hannibal had stimulated the minds of all, as generals prepared for a final contest. Even those persons whose confidence in Scipio and hopes of victory were great, were affected with anxiety, increasing in proportion as they saw their completion approaching. The state of feeling among the Carthaginians was much the same; for, when they turned their eyes on Hannibal, and the greatness of his achievements, they repented having solicited peace; but when again they reflected that they had been twice defeated in a pitched battle, that Syphax had been made prisoner, that they had been driven out of Spain and Italy, and that all this had been effected by the valour and conduct of Scipio alone, they regarded him with horror, as a general marked out by destiny, and born, for their destruction.

Meanwhile, hope and anxiety grew daily and at the same time; the people's minds couldn't settle on whether to celebrate Hannibal finally leaving Italy after sixteen years, allowing the Romans to reclaim it without interruption, or to feel more afraid since he had safely transported his army to Africa. They acknowledged that the battlefield had shifted, but not the threat. Quintus Fabius, who had recently passed away and had predicted how tough the struggle would be, warned that Hannibal would be even more dangerous in his own land than he had been in a foreign territory. Scipio would not be facing Syphax, the king of undisciplined soldiers led by Statorius, a man more fit for menial tasks than warfare; nor his father-in-law Hasdrubal, known for fleeing; nor hastily assembled troops of poorly armed farmers, but rather Hannibal himself—born amid the military lifestyle of his father, the bravest of generals, raised amidst conflict. Hannibal had served as a soldier as a boy and became a general before truly reaching adulthood; after aging with victories, he had filled Spain, Gaul, and Italy from the Alps to the strait with reminders of his great accomplishments. He commanded troops who had been with him just as long, hardened by suffering that seemed nearly unbelievable; stained countless times with Roman blood, they bore trophies not just from soldiers but from generals. Many who would face Scipio in battle had personally killed Roman praetors, generals, and consuls; many wore crowns for scaling walls and breaching defenses; many had swept through captured Roman camps and cities. The Roman magistrates didn't have as many fasces as Hannibal could carry, having taken them from the generals he had slain. While their minds were overwhelmed by these fears, their anxiety grew even more because, after several years of battling throughout Italy with waning hopes and no quick end in sight, Scipio and Hannibal energized everyone, like generals ready for a final showdown. Even those who firmly believed in Scipio's abilities and hoped for victory felt anxiety bubbling up as they anticipated the end. The mood among the Carthaginians was similar; as they looked at Hannibal and his grand achievements, they regretted seeking peace. Yet, when they remembered being defeated twice in major battles, Syphax's capture, and being pushed out of Spain and Italy—all due to Scipio's skill—they viewed him with dread, seeing him as a general seemingly destined for their ruin.

29

Hannibal had by this time arrived at Adrumetum; from which place, after employing a few days there in refreshing his soldiers, who had suffered from the motion by sea, he proceeded by forced marches to Zama, roused by the alarming statements of messengers, who brought word, that all the country around Carthage was filled with armed troops. Zama is distant from Carthage a five days' journey. Some spies, whom he sent out from this place, being intercepted by the Roman guard, and brought before Scipio, he directed that they should be handed over to the military tribunes, and after having been desired fearlessly to survey every thing, to be conducted through the camp wherever they chose; then, asking them whether they had examined every thing to their satisfaction, he assigned them an escort, and sent them back to Hannibal. Hannibal received none of the circumstances which were reported to him with feelings of joy; for they brought word that, as it happened, Masinissa had joined the enemy that very day, with six thousand infantry and four thousand horse; but he was principally dispirited by the confidence of his enemy, which, doubtless, was not conceived without some ground. Accordingly, though he himself was the originator of the war, and by his coming had upset the truce which had been entered into, and cut off all hopes of a treaty, yet concluding that more favourable terms might be obtained if he solicited peace while his strength was unimpaired, than when vanquished, he sent a message to Scipio, requesting permission to confer with him. I have no means of affirming whether he did this on his own spontaneous suggestion, or by the advice of his state. Valerius Antias says, that after having been beaten by Scipio in a battle, in which twelve thousand armed men were slain, and one thousand seven hundred made prisoners, he came himself with ten other deputies into the camp to Scipio. However, as Scipio did not decline the proposal for a conference, both the generals, by concert, brought their camps forward in order to facilitate their meeting by shortening the distance. Scipio took up his position not far from the city Naragara, in a situation convenient not only for other purposes, but also because there was a watering place within a dart's throw. Hannibal took possession of an eminence four miles thence, safe and convenient in every respect, except that he had a long way to go for water. Here, in the intermediate space, a place was chosen, open to view from all sides, that there might be no opportunity for treachery.

Hannibal had by this time reached Adrumetum; from there, after spending a few days refreshing his soldiers, who had suffered from the sea journey, he marched quickly to Zama, motivated by alarming reports from messengers that all the surrounding areas near Carthage were filled with armed troops. Zama is a five-day journey from Carthage. Some spies he sent out from there were intercepted by the Roman guard and brought before Scipio, who ordered them to be handed over to the military tribunes. After instructing them to freely observe everything, he allowed them to explore the camp wherever they wanted. He then asked if they had seen everything to their satisfaction and assigned them an escort to return them to Hannibal. Hannibal received the news with disappointment; they reported that Masinissa had joined the enemy that very day with six thousand infantry and four thousand cavalry. However, he was mostly disheartened by the confidence of his enemy, which surely had some justification. Even though he was the one who initiated the war, disrupting the truce that had been established and eliminating any hopes for a treaty, he figured that he might receive better terms if he sought peace while still strong rather than after being defeated. So, he sent a message to Scipio, asking for permission to meet with him. I can't confirm whether he did this on his own initiative or at the suggestion of his government. Valerius Antias claims that after being defeated by Scipio in a battle where twelve thousand armed men were killed and one thousand seven hundred captured, he came himself with ten other representatives to Scipio's camp. However, since Scipio did not refuse the proposal for a meeting, both generals agreed to move their camps closer together to make their meeting easier. Scipio positioned himself not far from the city of Naragara, a location convenient for various purposes, especially since there was a watering place within throwing distance. Hannibal occupied a hill four miles away, which was safe and suitable in every way, except that he had a long distance to travel for water. In the space between, a location was chosen that was visible from all sides, ensuring there was no chance for treachery.

30

Their armed attendants having retired to an equal distance, they met, each attended by one interpreter, being the greatest generals not only of their own times, but of any to be found in the records of the times preceding them, and equal to any of the kings or generals of any nation whatever. When they came within sight of each other they remained silent for a short time, thunderstruck, as it were, with mutual admiration. At length Hannibal thus began: "Since fate hath so ordained it, that I, who was the first to wage war upon the Romans, and who have so often had victory almost within my reach, should voluntarily come to sue for peace, I rejoice that it is you, above all others, from whom it is my lot to solicit it. To you, also, amid the many distinguished events of your life, it will not be esteemed one of the least glorious, that Hannibal, to whom the gods had so often granted victory over the Roman generals, should have yielded to you; and that you should have put an end to this war, which has been rendered remarkable by your calamities before it was by ours. In this also fortune would seem to have exhibited a disposition to sport with events, for it was when your father was consul that I first took up arms; he was the first Roman general with whom I engaged in a pitched battle; and it is to his son that I now come unarmed to solicit peace. It were indeed most to have been desired, that the gods should have put such dispositions into the minds of our fathers, that you should have been content with the empire of Italy, and we with that of Africa: nor, indeed, even to you, are Sicily and Sardinia of sufficient value to compensate you for the loss of so many fleets, so many armies, so many and such distinguished generals. But what is past may be more easily censured than retrieved. In our attempts to acquire the possessions of others we have been compelled to fight for our own; and not only have you had a war in Italy, and we also in Africa, but you have beheld the standards and arms of your enemies almost in your gates and on your walls, and we now, from the walls of Carthage, distinctly hear the din of a Roman camp. What, therefore, we should most earnestly deprecate, and you should most devoutly wish for, is now the case: peace is proposed at a time when you have the advantage. We who negotiate it are the persons whom it most concerns to obtain it, and we are persons whose arrangements, be they what they will, our states will ratify. All we want is a disposition not averse from peaceful counsels. As far as relates to myself, time, (for I am returning to that country an old man which I left a boy,) and prosperity, and adversity, have so schooled me, that I am more inclined to follow reason than fortune. But I fear your youth and uninterrupted good fortune, both of which are apt to inspire a degree of confidence ill comporting with pacific counsels. Rarely does that man consider the uncertainty of events whom fortune hath never deceived. What I was at Trasimenus, and at Cannae, that you are this day. Invested with command when you had scarcely yet attained the military age, though all your enterprises were of the boldest description, in no instance has fortune deserted you. Avenging the death of your father and uncle, you have derived from the calamity of your house the high honour of distinguished valour and filial duty. You have recovered Spain, which had been lost, after driving thence four Carthaginian armies. When elected consul, though all others wanted courage to defend Italy, you crossed over into Africa; where having cut to pieces two armies, having at once captured and burnt two camps in the same hour; having made prisoner Syphax, a most powerful king, and seized so many towns of his dominions and so many of ours, you have dragged me from Italy, the possession of which I had firmly held for now sixteen years. Your mind, I say, may possibly be more disposed to conquest than peace. I know the spirits of your country aim rather at great than useful objects. On me, too, a similar fortune once shone. But if with prosperity the gods would also bestow upon us sound judgment, we should not only consider those things which have happened, but those also which may occur. Even if you should forget all others, I am myself a sufficient instance of every vicissitude of fortune. For me, whom a little while ago you saw advancing my standards to the walls of Rome, after pitching my camp between the Anio and your city, you now behold here, bereft of my two brothers, men of consummate bravery, and most renowned generals, standing before the walls of my native city, which is all but besieged, and deprecating, in behalf of my own city, those severities with which I terrified yours. In all cases, the most prosperous fortune is least to be depended upon. While your affairs are in a favourable and ours in a dubious state, you would derive honour and splendour from granting peace; while to us who solicit it, it would considered as necessary rather than honourable. A certain peace is better and safer than a victory in prospect; the former is at your own disposal, the latter depends upon the gods. Do not place at the hazard of a single hour the successes of so many years. When you consider your own strength, then also place before your view the power of fortune, and the fluctuating nature of war. On both sides there will be arms, on both sides human bodies. In nothing less than in war do events correspond (with men's calculations). Should you be victorious in a battle, you will not add so much to that renown which you now have it in your power to acquire by granting peace, as you will detract from it should any adverse event befall you. The chance of a single hour may at once overturn the honours you have acquired and those you anticipate. Every thing is at your own disposal in adjusting a peace; but, in the other case, you must be content with that fortune which the gods shall impose upon you. Formerly, in this same country, Marcus Atilius would have formed one among the few instances of good fortune and valour, if, when victorious, he had granted a peace to our fathers when they requested it; but by not setting any bounds to his success, and not checking good fortune, which was elating him, he fell with a degree of ignominy proportioned to his elevation. It is indeed the right of him who grants, and not of him who solicits it, to dictate the terms of peace; but perhaps we may not be unworthy to impose upon ourselves the fine. We do not refuse that all those possessions on account of which the war was begun should be yours; Sicily, Sardinia, Spain, with all the islands lying in any part of the sea, between Africa and Italy. Let us Carthaginians, confined within the shores of Africa, behold you, since such is the pleasure of the gods, extending your empire over foreign nations, both by sea and land. I cannot deny that you have reason to suspect the Carthaginian faith, in consequence of their insincerity lately in soliciting a peace and while awaiting the decision. The sincerity with which a peace will be observed, depends much, Scipio, on the person by whom it is sought. Your senate, as I hear, refused to grant a peace in some measure because the deputies were deficient in respectability. It is I, Hannibal, who now solicit peace; who would neither ask for it unless I believed it expedient, nor will I fail to observe it for the same reason of expedience on account of which I have solicited it. And in the same manner as I, because the war was commenced by me, brought it to pass that no one regretted it till the gods began to regard me with displeasure; so will I also exert myself that no one may regret the peace procured by my means."

Their armed attendants having stepped back to a reasonable distance, they met, each accompanied by one interpreter. They were the greatest generals not only of their own times but of any found in the annals of history, and equal to any kings or generals of any nation. When they came within sight of each other, they stood silent for a moment, struck by mutual admiration. Finally, Hannibal spoke: "Since fate has brought us to this moment, I, who was the first to wage war against the Romans and who have come so close to victory many times, now come to seek peace. I am glad that it is you, above all others, to whom I turn for this. For you, amid the many remarkable events of your life, it will be a great honor that Hannibal, who the gods often favored over the Roman generals, should have submitted to you; that you have ended this war, which has been marked by your challenges before it was by ours. It seems that fortune enjoys playing with events, for it was during your father's time as consul that I first took up arms; he was the first Roman general I fought in a pitched battle, and now it is to his son that I come unarmed to request peace. It would have been ideal for the gods to have influenced our forefathers to be content with the realm of Italy while we took Africa. Even for you, Sicily and Sardinia are not worth the loss of so many fleets, armies, and distinguished generals. But it's easier to criticize what has happened than to change it. In our quest to acquire what belongs to others, we've had to fight to secure our own; you've fought a war in Italy, and we've fought one in Africa, while you have seen your enemies' standards and arms at your gates, and from the walls of Carthage, we can clearly hear the noise of a Roman camp. What we should earnestly seek to avoid, and what you should passionately desire, is happening right now: peace is being offered at a time when you hold the advantage. We who are negotiating it have the most at stake in its outcome, and our states will uphold whatever terms we agree upon. All we need is a willingness for peaceful discussions. Personally, time (as I return to a country I left as a boy) and the ups and downs of fortune have taught me to lean more towards reason than fate. But I worry that your youth and your continuous good fortune may lead to a level of confidence that isn't conducive to peaceful negotiations. Those who have never faced misfortune rarely consider the uncertainty of outcomes. What I was at Trasimenus and Cannae, you are today. You command forces before you've even reached full military age, with all your endeavors being bold, and in no instance has fortune abandoned you. In avenging the deaths of your father and uncle, you have turned the tragedy of your family into a testament of great valor and filial loyalty. You have reclaimed Spain after defeating four Carthaginian armies. When you were elected consul and others lacked the courage to defend Italy, you set sail for Africa, where you routed two armies, captured and burned two camps in a single hour, captured Syphax, a powerful king, and seized numerous towns belonging to him and us, driving me from Italy, which I had firmly held for sixteen years. Your mindset may be more inclined toward conquest than peace. I know the people of your country tend to aim for greatness rather than practicality. I, too, once enjoyed similar fortune. But if along with prosperity the gods also granted us sound judgment, we should not just think about what has happened but also what could happen. Even if you forget all others, I am a sufficient example of every twist of fortune. Not long ago, you saw me advancing my forces to the walls of Rome, after setting up camp between the Anio River and your city. And now you see me here, devoid of my two brothers—men of incredible courage and acclaimed generals—standing at the walls of my besieged homeland, pleading for mercy for my city after causing terror for yours. Always, the most prosperous fortunes are the least reliable. While your situation is favorable and ours precarious, granting peace would bring you honor and glory; for us, who seek it, it is a necessity rather than a point of pride. A guaranteed peace is better and safer than a potential victory; the former lies in your control while the latter relies on the whims of the gods. Don’t risk the success of so many years on the outcome of a single hour. When you weigh your own strength, remember to also consider the power of fortune and the unpredictable nature of war. Both sides will have weapons, both sides will have soldiers. In nothing less than war can outcomes align with human expectations. If you win a battle, the honor you could achieve by granting peace outweighs the honor you would gain if you win. A single hour's chance could overturn both your current honors and those you expect. Everything is negotiable in peace, but for the latter, you must accept the fortune the gods dictate. In this very region, Marcus Atilius could have been counted among the few with good fortune and valor, had he granted peace to our ancestors when they asked for it. But by failing to limit his successes and allow his good fortune to inflate his pride, he fell from grace. It is indeed the prerogative of the one granting peace to set its terms, rather than the one asking for it; however, we might be worthy of imposing some conditions. We do not refuse that all assets for which this war began should belong to you: Sicily, Sardinia, Spain, and all other islands in the sea between Africa and Italy. Let us, the Carthaginians, confine ourselves to Africa while you, as it pleases the gods, expand your empire over foreign lands, both by sea and by land. I cannot deny that you have reason to doubt the honesty of the Carthaginian commitment, given our recent duplicity in seeking peace while awaiting a decision. Whether this peace will be respected relies heavily, Scipio, on who seeks it. Your senate, I hear, refused peace partly because the envoys lacked stature. It is I, Hannibal, who now seek peace, and I wouldn’t do so unless I believed it was in my best interest, nor will I fail to honor it for the same reason that led me to ask for it. Just as I, having started this war, ensured nothing regrettable happened until the gods began to disfavor me, I will also ensure that nothing will mar the peace fostered by my actions."

31

In answer to these things the Roman general spoke nearly to the following effect: "I was aware that it was in consequence of the expectation of your arrival, that the Carthaginians violated the existing faith of the truce and broke off all hope of a peace. Nor, indeed, do you conceal the fact; inasmuch as you artfully withdraw from the former conditions of peace every concession except what relates to those things which have for a long time been in our own power. But as it is your object, that your countrymen should be sensible how great a burden they are relieved from by your means, so it is incumbent upon me to endeavour that they may not receive, as the reward of their perfidy, the concessions which they formerly stipulated, by expunging them now from the conditions of the peace. Though you do not deserve to be allowed the same conditions as before, you now request even to be benefited by your treachery. Neither did our fathers first make war respecting Sicily, nor did we respecting Spain. In the former case the danger which threatened our allies the Mamertines, and in the present the destruction of Saguntum, girded us with just and pious arms. That you were the aggressors, both you yourselves confess, and the gods are witnesses, who determined the issue of the former war, and who are now determining and will determine the issue of the present according to right and justice. As to myself, I am not forgetful of the instability of human affairs, but consider the influence of fortune, and am well aware that all our measures are liable to a thousand casualties. But as I should acknowledge that my conduct would savour of insolence and oppression, if I rejected you on your coming in person to solicit peace, before I crossed over into Africa, you voluntarily retiring from Italy, and after you had embarked your troops; so now, when I have dragged you into Africa almost by manual force, notwithstanding your resistance and evasions, I am not bound to treat you with any respect. Wherefore, if in addition to those stipulations on which it was considered that a peace would at that time have been agreed upon, and what they are you are informed, a compensation is proposed for having seized our ships, together with their stores, during a truce, and for the violence offered to our ambassadors, I shall then have matter to lay before my council. But if these things also appear oppressive, prepare for war, since you could not brook the conditions of peace." Thus, without effecting an accommodation, when they had returned from the conference to their armies, they informed them that words had been bandied to no purpose, that the question must be decided by arms, and that they must accept that fortune which the gods assigned them.

In response to these matters, the Roman general said something like this: "I understand that the Carthaginians broke the truce and ended any hopes of peace because they were expecting you to arrive. You don't hide this fact; you cleverly remove every concession from the previous peace agreement except those that have been in our hands for a long time. While you want your fellow citizens to recognize how much you have relieved them of, I must ensure that they don’t gain the concessions they once agreed to as a reward for their betrayal, by now excluding them from the peace terms. Even though you don’t deserve the same conditions as before, you still want to benefit from your dishonesty. Our ancestors didn’t start the war over Sicily, nor did we over Spain. In the former situation, we were justly armed due to the threat against our allies, the Mamertines, and now, it’s the destruction of Saguntum that justifies our actions. Both you and the gods testify that you were the aggressors, who have judged the outcome of the past war and will now judge this one based on fairness and justice. I am aware of how unpredictable human affairs can be and recognize the role of chance, knowing that our plans are subject to countless risks. However, I would acknowledge that it would be rude and oppressive of me to deny your request for peace when you came in person before I crossed to Africa, having voluntarily left Italy after you had moved your troops. Now, having essentially forced you into Africa despite your resistance, I’m not obligated to treat you with any respect. Therefore, if alongside the terms thought to be agreed upon for peace—which you’ve been informed about—you also propose compensation for seizing our ships and their supplies during a truce, and for the mistreatment of our ambassadors, then I’ll have something to present to my council. If this seems unfair as well, be ready for war, since you couldn’t accept the peace conditions." So, without reaching any agreement, when they returned from their meeting to their armies, they told them that their discussions were pointless, the decision would be made by combat, and they must accept whatever fate the gods would give them.

32

When they had arrived at their camps, they both issued orders that their soldiers should get their arms in readiness, and prepare their minds for the final contest; in which, if fortune should favour them, they would continue victorious, not for a single day, but for ever. "Before to-morrow night," they said, "they would know whether Rome or Carthage should give laws to the world; and that neither Africa nor Italy, but the whole world, would be the prize of victory. That the dangers which threatened those who had the misfortune to be defeated, were proportioned to the rewards of the victors." For the Romans had not any place of refuge in an unknown and foreign land, and immediate destruction seemed to await Carthage, if the troops which formed her last reliance were defeated. To this important contest, the day following, two generals, by far the most renowned of any, and belonging to two of the most powerful nations in the world, advanced, either to crown or overthrow, on that day, the many honours they had previously acquired. Their minds, therefore, were agitated with the opposite feelings of hope and fear; and while they contemplated at one time their own troops, at another those of their enemy, estimating their powers more by sight than by reason, they saw in them at once the grounds for joy and grief. Those circumstances which did not occur to the troops themselves spontaneously, their generals suggested by their admonitions and exhortations. The Carthaginian recounted his achievements in the land of Italy during sixteen years the many Roman generals and armies annihilated, reminding each individually of the honours he had acquired as he came to any soldier who had obtained distinction in any of his battles. Scipio referred to Spain, the recent battles in Africa and the enemy's own confession, that they could not through fear but solicit peace, nor could they, through their inveterate perfidy, abide by it. In addition to this he gave what turn he pleased to his conference with Hannibal, which was held in private, and was therefore open to misrepresentation. He augured success that the gods had exhibited the same omens to them on going out to battle on the present occasion, as they had to their fathers when they fought at the islands Aegates. He told them that the termination of the war, and their hardships, had arrived; that they had within their grasp the spoils of Carthage, and the power of returning home to their country, their parents, their children, their wives, and their household gods. He delivered these observations with a body so erect, and with a countenance so full of exultation, that one would have supposed that he had already conquered. He then drew up his troops, posting the hastati in front, the principes behind them, and closing his rear line with the triarii.

When they reached their camps, both leaders ordered their soldiers to get their weapons ready and mentally prepare for the final battle; if luck was on their side, they would be victorious not just for one day, but forever. "By tomorrow night," they declared, "we'll know whether Rome or Carthage will set the laws for the world; and that the prize of victory would not be just Africa or Italy, but the entire world. The dangers faced by those who lose are matched only by the rewards waiting for the victors." The Romans had no safe haven in a foreign land, and total destruction seemed to be imminent for Carthage if the troops who were their last hope were defeated. The following day, two of the most famous generals from two of the most powerful nations advanced to either claim or lose the numerous honors they had previously earned. Their minds were filled with the conflicting emotions of hope and fear; as they looked at their own troops and then at the enemy’s, weighing their strength more through sight than logic, they found both reasons for joy and sorrow within them. The generals prompted their troops with reflections and encouragements on things that the soldiers might not have noticed themselves. The Carthaginian general recounted his accomplishments in Italy over the past sixteen years, detailing how many Roman generals and armies he had destroyed, recalling individual honors for each soldier who had distinguished themselves in his battles. Scipio pointed to Spain, the recent battles in Africa, and their enemy's own admission that they were seeking peace out of fear and couldn't be trusted to keep it due to their long-standing treachery. He also shaped the narrative of his private meeting with Hannibal, since it could easily be misinterpreted. He predicted victory, noting that the gods had given them the same signs as they did to their ancestors before they fought at the Aegates Islands. He told them that the end of the war and their struggles was near; they were on the verge of seizing the spoils of Carthage and had the chance to return home to their country, their parents, their children, their wives, and their household gods. He spoke with such confidence and a triumphant expression that one might have thought he had already won. He then organized his troops, placing the hastati in front, the principes behind them, and the triarii forming the rear line.

33

He did not draw up his cohorts in close order, but each before their respective standards; placing the companies at some distance from each other, so as to leave a space through which the elephants of the enemy passing might not at all break their ranks. Laelius, whom he had employed before as lieutenant-general, but this year as quaestor, by special appointment, according to a decree of the senate, he posted with the Italian cavalry in the left wing, Masinissa and the Numidians in the right. The open spaces between the companies of those in the van he filled with velites, which then formed the Roman light-armed troops, with an injunction, that on the charge of the elephants they should either retire behind the files, which extended in a right line, or, running to the right and left and placing themselves by the side of those in the van, afford a passage by which the elephants might rush in between weapons on both sides. Hannibal, in order to terrify the enemy, drew up his elephants in front, and he had eighty of them, being more than he had ever had in any battle; behind these his Ligurian and Gallic auxiliaries, with Balearians and Moors intermixed. In the second line he placed the Carthaginians, Africans, and a legion of Macedonians; then, leaving a moderate interval, he formed a reserve of Italian troops, consisting principally of Bruttians, more of whom had followed him on his departure from Italy by compulsion and necessity than by choice. His cavalry also he placed in the wings, the Carthaginian occupying the right, the Numidian the left. Various were the means of exhortation employed in an army consisting of a mixture of so many different kinds of men; men differing in language, customs laws, arms, dress, and appearance, and in the motives for serving. To the auxiliaries, the prospect both of their present pay, and many times more from the spoils, was held out. The Gauls were stimulated by their peculiar and inherent animosity against the Romans. To the Ligurians the hope was held out of enjoying the fertile plains of Italy, and quitting their rugged mountains, if victorious. The Moors and Numidians were terrified with subjection to the government of Masinissa, which he would exercise with despotic severity. Different grounds of hope and fear were represented to different persons. The view of the Carthaginians was directed to the walls of their city, their household gods, the sepulchres of their ancestors, their children and parents, and their trembling wives; they were told, that either the destruction of their city and slavery or the empire of the world awaited them; that there was nothing intermediate which they could hope for or fear. While the general was thus busily employed among the Carthaginians, and the captains of the respective nations among their countrymen, most of them employing interpreters among troops intermixed with those of different nations, the trumpets and cornets of the Romans sounded; and such a clamour arose, that the elephants, especially those in the left wing, turned round upon their own party, the Moors and Numidians. Masinissa had no difficulty in increasing the alarm of the terrified enemy, and deprived them of the aid of their cavalry in that wing. A few, however, of the beasts which were driven against the enemy, and were not turned back through fear, made great havoc among the ranks of the velites, though not without receiving many wounds themselves; for when the velites, retiring to the companies, had made way for the elephants, that they might not be trampled down, they discharged their darts at them, exposed as they were to wounds on both sides, those in the van also keeping up a continual discharge of javelins; until, driven out of the Roman line by the weapons which fell upon them from all quarters, these elephants also put to flight even the cavalry of the Carthaginians posted in their right wing. Laelius, when he saw the enemy in disorder, struck additional terror into them in their confusion.

He didn't line up his troops closely but arranged each one near their respective standards, setting the companies apart to create gaps that the enemy's elephants could pass through without breaking ranks. Laelius, who had previously served as lieutenant-general and this year was appointed quaestor by a decree from the senate, was placed with the Italian cavalry on the left wing, while Masinissa and the Numidians were on the right. He filled the open spaces among the front companies with velites, the Roman light-armed troops, instructing them to either fall back behind the straight lines when the elephants charged or to move to the sides of the front troops to create a passage for the elephants to rush through safely. Hannibal, aiming to intimidate the enemy, positioned his eighty elephants at the front—the largest number he had ever assembled for battle—followed by his Ligurian and Gallic auxiliaries, mixed in with Balearians and Moors. In the second line, he deployed the Carthaginians, Africans, and a legion of Macedonians, and then, leaving a reasonable gap, he set up a reserve of Italian troops, mostly Bruttians, who had followed him out of necessity rather than choice. He placed his cavalry on the wings, with the Carthaginian cavalry on the right and the Numidians on the left. There were various motivational tactics used in this diverse army, which included soldiers of different languages, customs, laws, equipment, attire, and reasons for serving. The auxiliaries were tempted with the promise of their current pay and the chance to gain much more from the spoils. The Gauls were fueled by their deep-seated hatred for the Romans. The Ligurians were given the hope of leaving their harsh mountains for the fertile plains of Italy if they won. The Moors and Numidians were frightened by the prospect of harsh rule under Masinissa, who would be a despotic leader. Different hopes and fears were catered to different individuals. The Carthaginians were focused on their city walls, their household gods, the graves of their ancestors, and their families; they were warned that they faced either the destruction of their city and slavery or the chance to dominate the world, with no middle ground to cling to. While the general spoke with the Carthaginian troops and their leaders communicated with their own countries' men, often using interpreters among the mixed troops, the Roman trumpets and horns sounded. This created such a noise that the elephants, especially those on the left wing, turned back on their own troops, the Moors and Numidians. Masinissa quickly stoked the panic of the frightened enemy, depriving them of cavalry support on that side. However, a few of the elephants charged at the enemy and didn't retreat out of fear; they caused significant damage among the ranks of the velites, though they suffered many wounds themselves. As the velites fell back to let the elephants through, they hurled their darts at the exposed animals, who were vulnerable to attacks from both sides, while those at the front continued to throw javelins. Eventually, driven out of the Roman formation by the hail of weapons from all directions, these elephants even sent the Carthaginian cavalry on their right wing into a retreat. When Laelius saw the enemy's disarray, he further terrified them in their confusion.

34

The Carthaginian line was deprived of the cavalry on both sides, when the infantry, who were now not a match for the Romans in confidence or strength, engaged. In addition to this there was one circumstance, trifling in itself, but at the same time producing important consequences in the action. On the part of the Romans the shout was uniform, and on that account louder and more terrific; while the voices of the enemy, consisting as they did of many nations of different languages, were dissonant. The Romans used the stationary kind of fight, pressing upon the enemy with their own weight and that of their arms; but on the other side there was more of skirmishing and rapid movement than force. Accordingly, on the first charge, the Romans immediately drove back the line of their opponents; then pushing them with their elbows and the bosses of their shields, and pressing forward into the places from which they had pushed them, they advanced a considerable space, as though there had been no one to resist them, those who formed the rear urging forward those in front when they perceived the line of the enemy giving way; which circumstance itself gave great additional force in repelling them. On the side of the enemy, the second line, consisting of the Africans and Carthaginians, were so far from supporting the first line when giving ground, that, on the contrary, they even retired, lest their enemy, by slaying those who made a firm resistance, should penetrate to themselves also. Accordingly, the auxiliaries suddenly turned their backs, and facing about upon their own party, fled, some of them into the second line, while others slew those who did not receive them into their ranks, since before they did not support them, and now refused to receive them. And now there were, in a manner, two contests going on together, the Carthaginians being compelled to fight at once with the enemy and with their own party. Not even then, however, did they receive into their line the terrified and exasperated troops; but, closing their ranks, drove them out of the scene of action to the wings and the surrounding plain, lest they should mingle these soldiers, terrified with defeat and wounds, with that part of their line which was firm and fresh. But such a heap of men and arms had filled the space in which the auxiliaries a little while ago had stood, that it was almost more difficult to pass through it than through a close line of troops. The spearmen, therefore, who formed the front line, pursuing the enemy as each could find a way through the heap of arms and men, and streams of blood, threw into complete disorder the battalions and companies. The standards also of the principes had begun to waver when they saw the line before them driven from their ground. Scipio, perceiving this, promptly ordered the signal to be given for the spearmen to retreat, and, having taken his wounded into the rear, brought the principes and triarii to the wings, in order that the line of spearmen in the centre might be more strong and secure. Thus a fresh and renewed battle commenced, inasmuch as they had penetrated to their real antagonists, men equal to them in the nature of their arms, in their experience in war, in the fame of their achievements, and the greatness of their hopes and fears. But the Romans were superior both in numbers and courage, for they had now routed both the cavalry and the elephants, and having already defeated the front line, were fighting against the second.

The Carthaginian troops had lost their cavalry on both flanks when the infantry, who now couldn’t match the Romans in confidence or strength, engaged in battle. Additionally, there was a seemingly minor factor that had significant consequences for the outcome. The Romans shouted in unison, making their voices louder and more intimidating; on the other hand, the enemy’s shouts came from various nations speaking different languages, creating a dissonant noise. The Romans fought in a static formation, using their own weight and the weight of their weapons to push against the enemy. In contrast, the Carthaginians relied more on skirmishing and quick movements rather than sheer strength. As a result, on the first charge, the Romans quickly pushed back their opponents, using their elbows and the edges of their shields to gain ground as they advanced, effectively as if no one was resisting them. Those at the back encouraged those in front to push forward when they saw the enemy line falter, which only added to their strength in repelling the enemy. The second line of the enemy, made up of Africans and Carthaginians, didn’t support the first line when they began to falter; instead, they retreated, fearing that if too many of their comrades fell, the Romans would break through to their ranks. Consequently, the auxiliaries turned and fled, some running into the second line while others attacked those who didn’t let them join, having failed to support them earlier. Thus, there were effectively two battles happening at once: the Carthaginians were forced to fight both the Romans and their own fleeing comrades. Even then, they didn’t allow the terrified and frustrated troops into their ranks but closed their formations to push them away from the battlefield to the flanks and surrounding fields, avoiding mixing those demoralized soldiers with those who remained strong and fresh. The number of men and weapons blocking the area where the auxiliaries had just been made it almost harder to navigate than breaking through a line of troops. The spearmen in the front line went after the enemy as best they could through the pile of bodies and weapons, causing chaos among the battalions and companies. The standards of the principes began to falter when they saw the line before them driven back. Scipio, noticing this, quickly ordered the spearmen to fall back and moved his wounded to the rear, bringing the principes and triarii to the flanks to strengthen the center line of spearmen. Thus began a renewed battle, as they had reached their true opponents—men who were equal to them in weaponry, military experience, reputation, and the weight of their hopes and fears. However, the Romans held the advantage in both numbers and bravery, having already defeated the cavalry and elephants and now faced the second line of the enemy.

35

Laelius and Masinissa, who had pursued the routed cavalry through a considerable space, returning very opportunely, charged the rear of the enemy's line. This attack of the cavalry at length routed them. Many of them, being surrounded, were slain in the field; and many, dispersed in flight through the open plain around, were slain on all hands, as the cavalry were in possession of every part. Of the Carthaginians and their allies, above twenty thousand were slain on that day; about an equal number were captured, with a hundred and thirty-three military standards, and eleven elephants. Of the victors as many as two thousand fell. Hannibal, slipping off during the confusion, with a few horsemen came to Adrumetum, not quitting the field till he had tried every expedient both in the battle and before the engagement; having, according to the admission of Scipio, and every one skilled in military science, acquired the fame of having marshalled his troops on that day with singular judgment. He placed his elephants in the front, in order that their desultory attack, and insupportable violence, might prevent the Romans from following their standards, and preserving their ranks, on which they placed their principal dependence. Then he posted his auxiliaries before the line of Carthaginians, in order that men who were made up of the refuse of all nations and who were not bound by honour but by gain, might not have any retreat open to them in case they fled; at the same time that the first ardour and impetuosity might be exhausted upon them, and, if they could render no other service, that the weapons of the enemy might be blunted in wounding them. Next he placed the Carthaginian and African soldiers, on whom he placed all his hopes, in order that, being equal to the enemy in every other respect, they might have the advantage of them, inasmuch as, being fresh and unimpaired in strength themselves, they would fight with those who were fatigued and wounded. The Italians he removed into the rear, separating them also by an intervening space, as he knew not, with certainty, whether they were friends or enemies. Hannibal, after performing this as it were his last work of valour, fled to Adrumetum, whence, having been summoned to Carthage, he returned thither in the six and thirtieth year after he had left it when a boy; and confessed in the senate-house that he was defeated, not only in the battle, but in the war, and that there was no hope of safety in any thing but in obtaining peace.

Laelius and Masinissa, who had chased the fleeing cavalry over a significant distance, returned just in time to strike the back of the enemy’s line. This cavalry attack finally broke them. Many were surrounded and killed on the field; others, scattering in flight across the open plain, were slaughtered everywhere, as the cavalry controlled all areas. More than twenty thousand Carthaginians and their allies were killed that day; roughly the same number were captured, along with one hundred thirty-three military standards and eleven elephants. Among the victors, around two thousand lost their lives. Hannibal, slipping away during the chaos with a few horsemen, made his way to Adrumetum, not leaving the battlefield until he had tried every strategy both in the fight and before the engagement; according to Scipio and other military experts, he earned a reputation for skillfully organizing his troops that day. He placed his elephants at the front, aiming to disrupt the Romans' formations and prevent them from following their standards, which were crucial to their strategy. Then, he positioned his auxiliaries in front of the Carthaginian line so that these mercenaries, bound by profit rather than honor, wouldn’t have any escape route if they fled; this way, the initial fervor and aggression could be worn out on them, and if they offered no other benefit, they might dull the enemy's weapons by taking the hits. Next, he placed the Carthaginian and African soldiers—on whom he relied the most—so that they would have the upper hand against a tired and wounded enemy, as they themselves were fresh and strong. He kept the Italians at the back, separating them by a distance since he wasn’t sure if they were friends or foes. After completing this, which felt like his last act of bravery, Hannibal fled to Adrumetum, where he was called back to Carthage, returning there thirty-six years after he had left as a boy. He admitted in the senate that he was defeated not only in battle but in the war, and that there was no hope of safety except through seeking peace.

36

Immediately after the battle, Scipio, having taken and plundered the enemy's camp, returned to the sea and his ships, with an immense booty, news having reached him that Publius Lentulus had arrived at Utica with fifty men of war, and a hundred transports laden with every kind of stores. Concluding that he ought to bring before Carthage every thing which could increase the consternation already existing there, after sending Laelius to Rome to report his victory, he ordered Cneius Octavius to conduct the legions thither by land; and, setting out himself from Utica with the fresh fleet of Lentulus, added to his former one, made for the harbour of Carthage. When he had arrived within a short distance, he was met by a Carthaginian ship decked with fillets and branches of olive. There were ten deputies, the leading men in the state, sent at the instance of Hannibal to solicit peace; to whom, when they had come up to the stern of the general's ship, holding out the badges of suppliants, entreating and imploring the protection and compassion of Scipio, the only answer given was, that they must come to Tunes, to which place he would move his camp. After taking a view of the site of Carthage, not so much for the sake of acquainting himself with it for any present object, as to dispirit the enemy, he returned to Utica, having recalled Octavius to the same place. As they were proceeding thence to Tunes, they received intelligence that Vermina, the son of Syphax, with a greater number of horse than foot, was coming to the assistance of the Carthaginians. A part of his infantry, with all the cavalry, having attacked them on their march on the first day of the Saturnalia, routed the Numidians with little opposition; and as every way by which they could escape in flight was blocked up, for the cavalry surrounded them on all sides, fifteen thousand men were slain, twelve hundred were taken alive, with fifteen hundred Numidian horses, and seventy-two military standards. The prince himself fled from the field with a few attendants during the confusion. The camp was then pitched near Tunes in the same place as before, and thirty ambassadors came to Scipio from Carthage. These behaved in a manner even more calculated to excite compassion than the former, in proportion as their situation was more pressing; but from the recollection of their recent perfidy, they were heard with considerably less pity. In the council, though all were impelled by just resentment to demolish Carthage, yet, when they reflected upon the magnitude of the undertaking, and the length of time which would be consumed in the siege of so well fortified and strong a city, while Scipio himself was uneasy in consequence of the expectation of a successor, who would come in for the glory of having terminated the war, though it was accomplished already by the exertions and danger of another, the minds of all were inclined to peace.

Immediately after the battle, Scipio, having captured and looted the enemy's camp, returned to the sea and his ships with a huge amount of treasure. He learned that Publius Lentulus had arrived at Utica with fifty warships and a hundred transports filled with supplies. Believing he should bring everything that could increase the panic already felt in Carthage, he sent Laelius to Rome to report his victory and ordered Cneius Octavius to bring the legions there by land. He then set out from Utica with Lentulus's fresh fleet, added to his previous one, heading for the harbor of Carthage. When he got close, he was met by a Carthaginian ship adorned with ribbons and olive branches. Ten leading men from the state, sent by Hannibal to seek peace, approached, holding out tokens of supplication and begging for Scipio's protection and mercy. The only response they received was that they needed to come to Tunes, where he would move his camp. After surveying the site of Carthage—not so much to familiarize himself with it for any immediate purpose but to demoralize the enemy—he returned to Utica, having recalled Octavius to the same place. As they were heading to Tunes, they received word that Vermina, Syphax's son, with more cavalry than infantry, was coming to aid the Carthaginians. Part of his infantry, along with all the cavalry, attacked them on their march on the first day of the Saturnalia, quickly defeating the Numidians with little resistance. With all escape routes blocked by the cavalry surrounding them, fifteen thousand men were killed, twelve hundred were captured, along with fifteen hundred Numidian horses and seventy-two military standards. The prince himself fled from the battlefield with a few attendants amid the chaos. The camp was then set up near Tunes in the same location as before, and thirty ambassadors came to Scipio from Carthage. These ambassadors were even more desperate than the previous ones, but due to their recent betrayal, they were met with significantly less sympathy. In the council, although everyone felt justified in wanting to destroy Carthage, when they considered the scale of the undertaking and the long time it would take to besiege such a well-fortified city, and because Scipio was anxious about the arrival of a successor who might claim the credit for ending the war that had already been achieved through someone else's efforts and dangers, the group's sentiments shifted towards peace.

37

The next day the ambassadors being called in again, and with many rebukes for their perfidy, warned that, instructed by so many disasters, they would at length believe in the existence of the gods, and the obligation of an oath, these conditions of the peace were stated to them: "That they should enjoy their liberty and live under their own laws; that they should possess such cities and territories as they had enjoyed before the war, and with the same boundaries, and that the Romans should on that day desist from devastation. That they should restore to the Romans all deserters and fugitives, giving up all their ships of war except ten triremes, with such tamed elephants as they had, and that they should not tame any more. That they should not carry on war in or out of Africa without the permission of the Roman people. That they should make restitution to Masinissa, and form a league with him. That they should furnish corn, and pay for the auxiliaries until the ambassadors had returned from Rome. That they should pay ten thousand talents of silver, in equal annual instalments distributed over fifty years. That they should give a hundred hostages, according to the pleasure of Scipio, not younger than fourteen nor older than thirty. That he would grant them a truce on condition that the transports, together with their cargoes, which had been seized during the former truce, were restored. Otherwise they would have no truce, nor any hope of a peace." When the ambassadors who were ordered to bear these conditions home reported them in an assembly, and Gisgo had stood forth to dissuade them from the terms, and was being listened to by the multitude, who were at once indisposed for peace and unfit for war, Hannibal, indignant that such language should be held and listened to at such a juncture, laid hold of Gisgo with his own hand, and dragged him from his elevated position. This unusual sight in a free state having raised a murmur among the people, the soldier, disconcerted at the liberties which the citizens took, thus addressed them: "Having left you when nine years old, I have returned after a lapse of thirty-six years. I flatter myself I am well acquainted with the qualifications of a soldier, having been instructed in them from my childhood, sometimes by my own situation, and sometimes by that of my country. The privileges, the laws, and customs of the city and the forum you ought to teach me." Having thus apologized for his indiscretion, he discoursed largely concerning the peace, showing how inoppressive the terms were, and how necessary it was. The greatest difficulty was, that of the ships which had been seized during the truce nothing was to be found except the ships themselves: nor was it easy to collect the property, because those who were charged with having it were opposed to the peace. It was resolved that the ships should be restored, and that the men at least should be looked up; and as to whatever else was missing, that it should be left to Scipio to put a value upon it, and that the Carthaginians should make compensation accordingly in money. There are those who say that Hannibal went from the field of battle to the sea-coast; whence he immediately sailed in a ship, which he had ready for the purpose, to king Antiochus; and that when Scipio demanded above every thing that Hannibal should be given up to him, answer was made that Hannibal was not in Africa.

The next day, the ambassadors were called in again, and after being heavily rebuked for their betrayal, they were warned that, having learned from so many disasters, they would finally believe in the existence of the gods and the importance of an oath. The terms of the peace were laid out for them: "They would enjoy their freedom and live by their own laws; they would retain the cities and territories they had before the war, with the same boundaries, and the Romans would cease destruction that day. They would return all deserters and fugitives to the Romans, surrender all their warships except ten triremes, and give up any trained elephants, with a prohibition against training more. They would not engage in war in or out of Africa without the approval of the Roman people. They would make restitution to Masinissa and form an alliance with him. They would provide grain and pay for the auxiliaries until the ambassadors returned from Rome. They would pay ten thousand talents of silver in equal annual installments over fifty years. They would provide a hundred hostages, at the discretion of Scipio, ranging in age from fourteen to thirty. He would grant them a truce on the condition that the transports and cargoes seized during the previous truce were returned. Otherwise, they would have no truce or hope for peace." When the ambassadors who were tasked with delivering these conditions reported back in an assembly, Gisgo spoke up to discourage them from accepting the terms, and the crowd listened, being discontent with peace yet unprepared for war. Hannibal, frustrated that such words were being spoken at such a critical moment, seized Gisgo by the arm and pulled him down from his elevated spot. This unusual scene in a free state caused a stir among the people, and the soldier, taken aback by the citizens' outspoken nature, addressed them: "Having left you at nine years old, I have returned after thirty-six years. I believe I am well aware of what it means to be a soldier, having learned it from childhood, sometimes from my own experiences and sometimes from those of my country. You should teach me the rights, laws, and customs of the city and the forum." After apologizing for his earlier actions, he talked extensively about the peace, explaining how reasonable the terms were and how necessary it was. The biggest challenge was that of the ships seized during the truce; only the ships themselves were available, and gathering the property was difficult because those who had it were against the peace. It was decided that the ships should be returned, and that at least the crew should be found; regarding whatever else was missing, Scipio would determine its value, and the Carthaginians would compensate accordingly in money. Some say that Hannibal went from the battlefield to the coast, from where he immediately sailed in a ship he had ready to King Antiochus, and when Scipio insisted that Hannibal be handed over to him, he was told that Hannibal was not in Africa.

38

After the ambassadors returned to Scipio, the quaestors were ordered to give in an account, made out from the public registers, of the public property which had been in the ships; and the owners to make a return of the private property. For the amount of the value twenty-five thousand pounds of silver were required to be paid down; and a truce for three months was granted to the Carthaginians. It was added, that during the time of the truce they should not send ambassadors any where else than to Rome; and that, whatever ambassadors came to Carthage, they should not dismiss them before informing the Roman general who they were, and what they sought. With the Carthaginian ambassadors, Lucius Veturius Philo, Marcus Marcius Ralla, and Lucius Scipio, brother of the general, were sent to Rome. At the time in which these events took place, the supplies sent from Sicily and Sardinia produced such cheapness of provisions, that the merchant gave up the corn to the mariners for their freight. At Rome alarm was excited at the first intelligence of the renewal of hostilities by the Carthaginians; and Tiberius Claudius was directed to conduct the fleet with speed into Sicily, and cross over from that place into Africa. The other consul, Marcus Servilius, was directed to stay at the city until the state of affairs in Africa was ascertained. Tiberius Claudius, the consul, proceeded slowly with every thing connected with the equipment and sailing of the fleet, because the senate had decided that it should be left to Scipio, rather than to the consul, to determine the conditions on which the peace should be granted. The accounts also of prodigies which arrived just at the time of the news of the revival of the war, had occasioned great alarm. At Cumae the orb of the sun seemed diminished, and a shower of stones fell; and in the territory of Veliternum the earth sank in great chasms, and trees were swallowed up in the cavities. At Aricia the forum and the shops around it, at Frusino a wall in several places, and a gate, were struck by lightning; and in the Palatium a shower of stones fell. The latter prodigy, according to the custom handed down by tradition, was expiated by a nine days' sacred rite; the rest with victims of the larger sort. Amid these events an unusually great rising of the waters was converted into a prodigy; for the Tiber overflowed its banks to such a degree, that as the circus was under water, the Apollinarian games were got up near the temple of Venus Erycina, without the Colline gate. However, the weather suddenly clearing up on the very day of the celebration, the procession, which had begun to move at the Colline gate, was recalled and transferred to the circus, on its being known that the water had retired thence. The joy of the people and the attraction of the games were increased by the restoration of this solemn spectacle to its proper scene.

After the ambassadors returned to Scipio, the quaestors were instructed to provide an account, created from the public records, of the public property that had been on the ships; and the owners were to report their private property. A payment of twenty-five thousand pounds of silver was required immediately; and a three-month truce was granted to the Carthaginians. It was specified that during the truce, they could only send ambassadors to Rome; and that any ambassadors arriving in Carthage should not be sent away before informing the Roman general who they were and what they wanted. Along with the Carthaginian ambassadors, Lucius Veturius Philo, Marcus Marcius Ralla, and Lucius Scipio, the general's brother, were sent to Rome. At the time these events occurred, the supplies shipped from Sicily and Sardinia caused such a drop in food prices that merchants gave away corn to sailors in exchange for freight. In Rome, there was alarm at the first news of the Carthaginians renewing hostilities, and Tiberius Claudius was ordered to quickly take the fleet to Sicily and then cross over to Africa from there. The other consul, Marcus Servilius, was instructed to stay in the city until the situation in Africa was determined. Tiberius Claudius, the consul, proceeded slowly with everything related to preparing and launching the fleet, as the senate had decided that Scipio, rather than the consul, would set the terms for the peace. Reports of omens that coincided with the news of the war's resurgence also caused significant concern. In Cumae, the sun appeared to diminish, and a shower of stones fell; in the territory of Veliternum, the earth opened up with great fissures, swallowing trees. In Aricia, lightning struck the forum and surrounding shops, while in Frusino, several sections of a wall and a gate were hit; and in the Palatium, another shower of stones fell. This last omen was traditionally purified with a nine-day sacred ritual; the others were addressed with larger sacrificial animals. Amid these events, an unusually high rise in the waters was interpreted as an omen; the Tiber overflowed its banks so much that the circus was submerged, prompting the Apollinarian games to be held near the temple of Venus Erycina, outside the Colline gate. However, when the weather cleared on the very day of the celebration, the procession that had started moving at the Colline gate was called back and moved to the circus, as news came that the water had receded. The people's joy and the appeal of the games were heightened by the return of this solemn event to its intended location.

39

The consul Claudius, having set out at length from the city, was placed in the most imminent danger by a violent tempest, which overtook him between the ports of Cosa and Laurentum. Having reached Populonii, where he waited till the remainder of the tempest had spent itself, he crossed over to the island Ilva. From Ilva he went to Corsica, and from Corsica to Sardinia. Here, while sailing round the Montes Insani, a tempest much more violent in itself, and in a more dangerous situation, dispersed his fleet. Many of his ships were shattered and stripped of their rigging, and some were wrecked. His fleet thus weatherbeaten and shattered arrived at Carales, where the winter came on while the ships were drawn on shore and refitted. The year having elapsed, and no one proposing to continue him in command, Tiberius Claudius brought back his fleet to Rome in a private capacity. Marcus Servilius set out for his province, having nominated Caius Servilius Geminus as dictator, that he might not be recalled to the city to hold the elections. The dictator appointed Publius Aelius Paetus master of the horse. It frequently happened, that the elections could not be held on account of bad weather, though the days were fixed for them; and, therefore, as the magistrates of the former year retired from their offices on the day before the ides of March, and fresh ones were not appointed to succeed them, the state was without curule magistrates. Lucius Manlius Torquatus, a pontiff, died this year. Caius Sulpicius Galba was elected in his room. The Roman games were thrice repeated by the curule aediles, Lucius Licinius Lucullus and Quintus Fulvius. Some scribes and runners belonging to the aediles were found, on the testimony of an informer, to have privately conveyed money out of the treasury, and were condemned, not without disgrace to the aedile Lucullus. Publius Aelius Tubero and Lucius Laetorius, plebeian aediles, on account of some informality in their creation, abdicated their office, after having celebrated the games, and the banquet on occasion of the games, in honour of Jupiter, and after having placed in the Capitol three statues made out of silver paid as fines. The dictator and master of the horse celebrated the games in honour of Ceres, in conformity with a decree of the senate.

The consul Claudius, after a long journey from the city, found himself in serious danger due to a violent storm that struck him between the ports of Cosa and Laurentum. Once he reached Populonii, he waited until the storm calmed down before crossing over to the island Ilva. From Ilva, he traveled to Corsica, and then to Sardinia. While sailing around the Montes Insani, a far worse storm hit and scattered his fleet. Many of his ships were damaged and lost their rigging, and some were wrecked. His battered fleet eventually arrived at Carales, where winter set in as the ships were pulled ashore and repaired. After a year passed, and with no one offering to keep him in command, Tiberius Claudius returned his fleet to Rome as a private citizen. Marcus Servilius headed to his province, having appointed Caius Servilius Geminus as dictator to avoid being called back to the city for elections. The dictator named Publius Aelius Paetus as master of the horse. Often, elections could not be held due to bad weather, even though the dates were set, so when the previous year's magistrates stepped down the day before the Ides of March and no new ones were appointed, the state lacked curule magistrates. This year, Lucius Manlius Torquatus, a pontiff, died, and Caius Sulpicius Galba was elected to replace him. The Roman games were held three times by the curule aediles, Lucius Licinius Lucullus and Quintus Fulvius. Some scribes and runners working for the aediles were found, based on an informant's testimony, to have secretly taken money from the treasury, leading to their condemnation, which reflected poorly on aedile Lucullus. Publius Aelius Tubero and Lucius Laetorius, plebeian aediles, resigned from their positions due to some irregularity in their election, after hosting the games and a banquet honoring Jupiter, and after placing three silver statues made from fines in the Capitol. The dictator and master of the horse held games in honor of Ceres, following a decree from the senate.

40

The Roman, together with the Carthaginian ambassadors, having arrived at Rome from Africa, the senate was assembled at the temple of Bellona; when Lucius Veturius Philo stated, to the great joy of the senate, that a battle had been fought with Hannibal, which was decisive of the fate of the Carthaginians, and that a period was at length put to that calamitous war. He added what formed a small accession to their successes, that Vermina, the son of Syphax, had been vanquished. He was then ordered to go forth to the public assembly, and impart the joyful tidings to the people. Then, a thanksgiving having been appointed, all the temples in the city were thrown open, and supplications for three days were decreed. The ambassadors of the Carthaginians, and those of king Philip, for they also had arrived, requesting an audience of the senate, answer was made by the dictator, by order of the fathers, that the new consuls would give them an audience. The elections were then held. The consuls elected were Cneius Cornelius Lentulus and Publius Aelius Paetus. The praetors elected were Marcus Junius Pennus, to whose lot the city jurisdiction fell, Marcus Valerius Falto, who received Bruttium, Marcus Fabius Buteo, who received Sardinia, and Publius Aelius Tubero, who received Sicily. It was the pleasure of the senate that nothing should be done respecting the provinces of the consuls, till the ambassadors of king Philip and the Carthaginians had been heard; for they foresaw the termination of one war and the commencement of another. Cneius Lentulus, the consul, was inflamed with a strong desire to have the province of Africa, looking forward to an easy victory if there was still war, or, if it was on the point of being concluded, to the glory of having it terminated in his consulate. He therefore refused to allow any business to be transacted before the province of Africa was assigned him; his colleague, who was a moderate and prudent man, giving up his claim to it, for he clearly saw that a contest with Scipio for that honour would be not only unjust but unequal. Quintus Minucius Thermus, and Manius Acilius Glabrio, tribunes of the people, said that Cneius Cornelius was endeavouring to effect the same object which had been attempted in vain by the consul Tiberius Claudius the former year. That, by the direction of the senate, it had been proposed to the people to decide whom they wished to have the command in Africa, and all the thirty-five tribes had concurred in assigning that command to Publius Scipio. After many discussions, both in the senate and popular assembly, it was at length determined to leave it to the senate. The fathers, therefore, on oath, for so it had been agreed, voted, that as to the provinces, the consuls should settle between themselves, or determine by lots, which of them should have Italy, and which a fleet of fifty ships. That he to whose lot the fleet fell should sail to Sicily, and if peace could not be concluded with the Carthaginians, that he should cross over into Africa. That the consul should act by sea, and Scipio by land, with the same right of command as heretofore. If an agreement should be come to, as to the terms of the peace, that then the plebeian tribunes should consult the commons as to whether they ordered the consul or Publius Scipio to grant the peace; and if the victorious army was to be brought home out of Africa, whom they ordered to bring it. That if they ordered that the peace should be granted by Publius Scipio, and that the army should be brought home likewise by him, then the consul should not pass out of Sicily into Africa. That the other consul, to whose lot Italy fell, should receive two legions from Marcus Sextius the praetor.

The Roman and Carthaginian ambassadors arrived in Rome from Africa, and the senate gathered at the temple of Bellona. Lucius Veturius Philo announced, to the great joy of the senate, that a battle had taken place against Hannibal, which determined the fate of the Carthaginians, and that the disastrous war was finally coming to an end. He also added a minor success: that Vermina, the son of Syphax, had been defeated. He was then ordered to go to the public assembly and share the good news with the people. A period of thanksgiving was declared, opening all the temples in the city, and three days of prayer were scheduled. The Carthaginian ambassadors and the ambassadors from King Philip, who had also arrived, requested to meet with the senate. The dictator, acting on the fathers’ orders, replied that the new consuls would meet with them. The elections were held. The elected consuls were Cneius Cornelius Lentulus and Publius Aelius Paetus. The elected praetors were Marcus Junius Pennus, who received the city jurisdiction, Marcus Valerius Falto, who was assigned Bruttium, Marcus Fabius Buteo, who was assigned Sardinia, and Publius Aelius Tubero, who was assigned Sicily. The senate decided that no action would be taken regarding the provinces of the consuls until they had heard from the ambassadors of King Philip and the Carthaginians; they anticipated the end of one war and the start of another. Consul Cneius Lentulus was eager to obtain the province of Africa, hoping for an easy victory if war continued, or the honor of concluding it during his term. He thus refused to allow any other business to take place until Africa was assigned to him; his colleague, a moderate and prudent man, gave up his claim on it, recognizing that competing with Scipio for that honor would be both unjust and unfair. Tribunes Quintus Minucius Thermus and Manius Acilius Glabrio claimed that Cneius Cornelius was trying to do what had been unsuccessfully pursued by consul Tiberius Claudius the previous year. By the senate's direction, it had been proposed to the people to decide who they wanted in command in Africa, and all thirty-five tribes agreed to assign that role to Publius Scipio. After much debate in both the senate and the public assembly, it was finally determined to leave it up to the senate. The fathers, therefore, took an oath, as had been agreed, and voted that regarding the provinces, the consuls would settle among themselves or draw lots to determine who would have Italy and who would command a fleet of fifty ships. The consul who received the fleet was to sail to Sicily, and if peace could not be achieved with the Carthaginians, he was to cross over to Africa. The consul would operate at sea, while Scipio would handle land operations, holding the same command rights as before. If terms of peace were agreed upon, the plebeian tribunes would consult the commons about who should grant the peace: the consul or Publius Scipio, and if the victorious army should be brought home from Africa, who would be responsible for it. If they decided that Publius Scipio would grant the peace and bring home the army, then the consul would not go from Sicily to Africa. The other consul, who drew Italy, would receive two legions from praetor Marcus Sextius.

41

Publius Scipio was continued in command in the province of Africa, with the armies which he then had. To the praetor Marcus Valerius Falto the two legions in Bruttium, which Caius Livius had commanded the preceding year, were assigned. Publius Aelius, the praetor, was to receive two legions in Sicily from Cneius Tremellius. To Marcus Fabius was assigned one legion, which Publius Lentulus, propraetor, had commanded, to be employed in Sardinia; Marcus Servilius, the consul of the former year, was continued in command in Etruria, with his own two legions likewise. As to Spain, it appeared that Lucius Cornelius Lentulus and Lucius Manlius Acidinus had been there for now several years. It was resolved, therefore, that the consuls should make application to the plebeian tribunes to take the opinion of the people, if they thought proper, as to whom they ordered to have command in Spain; that the person so ordered should form one legion of Roman soldiers out of the two armies, and also fifteen cohorts of the allies of the Latin confederacy, with which he should occupy the province. That Lucius Cornelius Lentulus and Lucius Manlius Acidinus should convey the old soldiers into Italy. To Cornelius, the consul, was assigned a fleet of fifty ships formed out of the two fleets, one of which was under Cneius Octavius in Africa, the other employed in protecting the coast of Sicily, under Publius Villius. He was to select such ships as he pleased. That Publius Scipio should still have the forty ships of war which he before had, or if he wished that Cneius Octavius should command it, as he had commanded a fleet there before, that Octavius should be continued in command for a year as propraetor; but if he appointed Laelius to the command of it, Octavius should retire to Rome, and bring with him the ships which the consul did not want. To Marcus Fabius also ten men of war were assigned for Sardinia. The consuls were directed to enlist two city legions, so that the operations of the state might be carried on this year with fourteen legions, and one hundred men of war.

Publius Scipio remained in charge of the province of Africa, along with the armies he had at the time. The two legions in Bruttium, which Caius Livius had commanded the previous year, were assigned to the praetor Marcus Valerius Falto. The praetor Publius Aelius was set to receive two legions in Sicily from Cneius Tremellius. Marcus Fabius was assigned one legion, previously commanded by Publius Lentulus, for duty in Sardinia, while Marcus Servilius, the consul from the last year, continued to lead his two legions in Etruria. In Spain, Lucius Cornelius Lentulus and Lucius Manlius Acidinus had been there for several years. Therefore, it was decided that the consuls should approach the plebeian tribunes to seek the people's opinion on who should command in Spain; the chosen person would form one legion of Roman soldiers from the two armies and also gather fifteen cohorts of the allies from the Latin confederacy to occupy the province. Lucius Cornelius Lentulus and Lucius Manlius Acidinus would bring the veteran soldiers back to Italy. Consul Cornelius was assigned a fleet of fifty ships, made up of the two fleets: one under Cneius Octavius in Africa and the other protecting the Sicilian coast under Publius Villius. He could select whichever ships he preferred. Publius Scipio would maintain the forty warships he previously had, or if he preferred, Cneius Octavius could command them again as he had before; Octavius would continue in command for one year as propraetor. However, if Laelius was appointed to command, Octavius would return to Rome and bring back any ships the consul did not need. Marcus Fabius was also assigned ten warships for Sardinia. The consuls were instructed to recruit two city legions so that the state's operations could be conducted this year with a total of fourteen legions and one hundred warships.

42

Then the business relating to the ambassadors of Philip and the Carthaginians was considered. It was resolved that the Macedonians should be brought before the senate first. Their address comprehended a variety of subjects, being employed partly in clearing themselves from the charges relative to the depredations committed against the allies, which the deputies sent to the king from Rome had brought against them; and partly in preferring accusations themselves against the allies of the Roman people, but particularly against Marcus Aurelius, whom they inveighed against with much greater acrimony; for they said that, being one of the three ambassadors sent to them, he had staid behind, and levying soldiers, had assailed them with hostilities contrary to the league, and frequently fought pitched battles with their prefects; and partly in preferring a request that the Macedonians and their general, Sopater, who had served in the army of Hannibal for hire, and having been made prisoners were kept in bondage, should be restored to them. In opposition to these things Marcus Furius, who had been sent from Macedonia for the express purpose by Aurelius, thus argued: he said, "that Aurelius, having been left behind, lest the allies of the Roman people, wearied by devastations and injuries, should revolt to the king, had not gone beyond the boundaries of the allies; but had taken measures to prevent plundering parties from crossing over into their lands with impunity. That Sopater was one of those who wore purple, and was related to the king; that he had been lately sent into Africa with four thousand Macedonians and a sum of money to assist Hannibal and the Carthaginians." The Macedonians, on being interrogated on these points, proceeded to answer in a subtle and evasive manner; but without waiting for the conclusion of their reply they were told, "that the king was seeking occasion for war, and that if he persisted he would soon obtain his object. That the treaty had been doubly violated by him, both by offering insults to the allies of the Roman people, by assaulting them with hostilities and arms, and also by aiding their enemies with auxiliaries and money. That Publius Scipio was deemed to have acted properly and regularly in keeping in chains, as enemies, those who had been made prisoners while bearing arms against the Romans; and that Marcus Aurelius had consulted the interest of the state, and the senate were thankful to him for it, in protecting the allies of the Roman people by arms, since he could not do it by the obligation of the treaty." The Macedonian ambassadors having been dismissed with this unpleasant answer, the Carthaginian ambassadors were called. On observing their ages and dignified appearance, for they were by far the first men of the state, all promptly declared their conviction, that now they were sincere in their desire to effect a peace. Hasdrubal, however, surnamed by his countrymen Haedus, who had invariably recommended peace, and was opposed to the Barcine faction, was regarded with greater interest than the rest. On these accounts the greater weight was attached to him when transferring the blame of the war from the state at large to the cupidity of a few. After a speech of varied character, in which he sometimes refuted the charges which had been brought, at other times admitted some, lest by impudently denying what was manifestly true their forgiveness might be the more difficult; and then, even admonishing the conscript fathers to be guided by the rules of decorum and moderation in their prosperity, he said, that if the Carthaginians had listened to himself and Hanno, and had been disposed to make a proper use of circumstances, they would themselves have dictated terms of peace, instead of begging it as they now did. That it rarely happened that good fortune and a sound judgment were bestowed upon men at the same time. That the Roman people were therefore invincible, because when successful they forgot not the maxims of wisdom and prudence; and indeed it would have been matter of astonishment did they act otherwise. That those persons to whom success was a new and uncommon thing, proceeded to a pitch of madness in their ungoverned transports in consequence of their not being accustomed to it. That to the Roman people the joy arising from victory was a matter of common occurrence, and was now almost become old-fashioned. That they had extended their empire more by sparing the vanquished than by conquering. The language employed by the others was of a nature more calculated to excite compassion; they represented from what a height of power the Carthaginian affairs had fallen. That nothing, besides the walls of Carthage, remained to those who a little time ago held almost the whole world in subjection by their arms; that, shut up within these, they could see nothing any where on sea or land which owned their authority. That they would retain possession of their city itself and their household gods only, in case the Roman people should refrain from venting their indignation upon these, which is all that remains for them to do. When it was manifest that the fathers were moved by compassion, it is said that one of the senators, violently incensed at the perfidy of the Carthaginians, immediately asked with a loud voice, by what gods they would swear in striking the league, since they had broken their faith with those by whom they swore in striking the former one? By those same, replied Hasdrubal, who have shown such determined hostility to the violators of treaties.

Then the matter regarding the ambassadors from Philip and the Carthaginians was discussed. It was decided that the Macedonians should appear before the senate first. Their speech covered various topics, partly focused on defending themselves against the accusations related to the attacks on their allies, which the envoys sent to the king from Rome had raised against them; and partly on making accusations against the allies of the Roman people, particularly against Marcus Aurelius, whom they criticized with much greater intensity. They claimed that, as one of the three ambassadors sent to them, he had stayed behind, raised soldiers, and attacked them in violation of their treaty, often engaging in battles with their commanders; and they also requested that the Macedonians and their general, Sopater, who had fought for Hannibal as a mercenary and was then captured, should be returned to them. In response to these claims, Marcus Furius, who had been sent from Macedonia specifically by Aurelius, argued: he said that Aurelius, having stayed behind to ensure that the allies of the Roman people, exhausted by destruction and harm, would not turn to the king, had not crossed the borders of the allies; but had taken steps to prevent raiding parties from entering their lands without consequences. He stated that Sopater was one of those who wore the royal purple and was related to the king; that he had recently been sent to Africa with four thousand Macedonians and money to help Hannibal and the Carthaginians. When the Macedonians were questioned about these points, they answered in a clever and evasive way; but before they could finish their reply, they were told that the king was looking for a reason to go to war, and if he continued, he would soon get what he wanted. It was stated that the treaty had been broken twice by him: by insulting the allies of the Roman people through attacks and armed conflict, and also by supporting their enemies with troops and funds. Publius Scipio was considered to have acted justly in keeping in chains those who had been captured while fighting against the Romans; and that Marcus Aurelius had acted in the state's best interest, for which the senate was grateful, by protecting the allies of the Roman people with military force since he could not do so through treaty obligations. The Macedonian ambassadors were dismissed with this unpleasant response, and then the Carthaginian ambassadors were called in. Upon seeing their ages and dignified demeanor, as they were the leading figures of the state, everyone quickly agreed that they genuinely wanted peace now. Hasdrubal, nicknamed Haedus by his countrymen, who had consistently advocated for peace and opposed the Barcine faction, drew more attention than the others. For these reasons, he was given more weight in shifting the blame for the war from the entire state to the greed of a few. After a speech of mixed content, where he sometimes refuted the accusations and at other times admitted to some, in order not to make their forgiveness more difficult by shamelessly denying what was clearly true, and even advising the conscript fathers to act with decorum and moderation in their success, he said that if the Carthaginians had listened to him and Hanno, and had been willing to make proper use of the situation, they would have dictated the terms of peace themselves, rather than begging for it as they were now. He noted that it was rare for good fortune and sound judgment to occur together. Therefore, the Roman people were invincible, because when they succeeded, they did not forget the principles of wisdom and prudence; and it would indeed have been astonishing if they acted otherwise. He asserted that for those to whom success was new and unfamiliar, it led them to madness due to their uncontrolled excitement from not being used to it. For the Roman people, the joy that comes with victory was common and had almost become old-fashioned. They had expanded their empire more by sparing the conquered than through conquest. The speeches from the others were more likely to evoke sympathy; they described how far the Carthaginian situation had fallen from its former power. That nothing, besides the walls of Carthage, remained for those who not long ago held nearly the entire world under their control; that confined within those walls, they could see nothing on land or sea that acknowledged their authority. That they would only keep hold of their city and household gods, if the Roman people chose not to unleash their anger upon them, which is all that was left for them to do. When it became clear that the senators were moved by compassion, one of them, furious at the betrayal of the Carthaginians, loudly asked by which gods they would swear when forming a new alliance, since they had broken their vows with those by whom they swore when forming the previous one? By those same gods, replied Hasdrubal, who have shown determined hostility to those who break treaties.

43

The minds of all being disposed to peace, Cneius Lentulus, whose province the fleet was, protested against the decree of the senate. Upon this, Manius Acilius and Quintus Minucius, tribunes of the people, put the question to the people, whether they willed and ordered that the senate should decree that peace should be made with the Carthaginians? whom they ordered to grant that peace, and whom to conduct the army out of Africa? All the tribes ordered respecting the peace according as the question had been put. That Publius Scipio should grant the peace, and that he also should conduct the army home. Agreeably to this order, the senate decreed that Publius Scipio, acting according to the opinion of the ten deputies, should make peace with the Carthaginian people on what terms he pleased. The Carthaginians then returned thanks to the senate, and requested that they might be allowed to enter the city and converse with their countrymen who had been made prisoners and were in custody of the state; observing, that some of them were their relations and friends, and men of rank, and some, persons to whom they were charged with messages from their relations. Having obtained these requests, they again asked permission to ransom such of them as they pleased; when they were desired to give in their names. Having given in a list of about two hundred, a decree of the senate was passed to the effect, that the Carthaginian ambassadors should be allowed to take away into Africa to Publius Cornelius Scipio two hundred of the Carthaginian prisoners, selecting whom they pleased; and that they should convey to him a message, that if the peace were concluded, he should restore them to the Carthaginians without ransom. The heralds being; ordered to go into Africa to strike the league, at their own desire the senate passed a decree that they should take with them flint stones of their own, and vervain of their own; that the Roman praetor should command them to strike the league, and that they should demand of him herbs. The description of herb usually given to the heralds is taken from the Capitol. Thus the Carthaginians, being allowed to depart from Rome, when they had gone into Africa to Scipio concluded the peace on the terms before mentioned. They delivered up their men-of-war, their elephants, deserters, fugitives, and four thousand prisoners, among whom was Quintus Terentius Culleo, a senator. The ships he ordered to be taken out into the main and burnt. Some say there were five hundred of every description of those which are worked with oars, and that the sudden sight of these, when burning, occasioned as deep a sensation of grief to the Carthaginians as if Carthage had been in flames. The measures adopted respecting the deserters were more severe than those respecting the fugitives. Those who were of the Latin confederacy were decapitated; the Romans were crucified.

The minds of everyone ready for peace, Cneius Lentulus, the governor of the fleet, opposed the senate's decree. As a result, Manius Acilius and Quintus Minucius, tribunes of the people, asked the citizens if they wanted the senate to decide on making peace with the Carthaginians, who they directed to offer that peace and to bring the army back from Africa. All the tribes voted on the peace according to the question asked. They decided that Publius Scipio should negotiate the peace and lead the army home. Following this decision, the senate ordered that Publius Scipio, based on the opinion of the ten deputies, should make peace with the Carthaginian people on any terms he saw fit. The Carthaginians then thanked the senate and asked permission to enter the city and speak with their countrymen who had been captured and were in the state's custody, noting that some of them were relatives and friends, including notable individuals, and some had messages from their families. Once their requests were granted, they further requested permission to ransom those they chose, for which they were asked to provide names. After submitting a list of about two hundred, the senate passed a decree allowing the Carthaginian ambassadors to take two hundred Carthaginian prisoners to Publius Cornelius Scipio in Africa, picking whom they wanted; and they were instructed to tell him that if the peace was finalized, he should return them to the Carthaginians without ransom. The heralds were ordered to go to Africa to finalize the treaty, and at their request, the senate decreed that they should bring their own flint stones and vervain. The Roman praetor was to command them to finalize the treaty and to request herbs from him. The herbs typically given to the heralds are sourced from the Capitol. Therefore, the Carthaginians, having been allowed to leave Rome, went to Africa where Scipio finalized the peace on the previously mentioned terms. They surrendered their warships, elephants, deserters, fugitives, and four thousand prisoners, among whom was Quintus Terentius Culleo, a senator. He ordered the ships to be taken out to sea and burned. Some say there were five hundred of each type powered by oars, and the sudden sight of them burning caused as much grief to the Carthaginians as if Carthage itself had been set ablaze. The actions taken regarding the deserters were harsher than those for the fugitives. Those who were part of the Latin confederacy were executed; the Romans were crucified.

44

The last peace with the Carthaginians was made forty years before this, in the consulate of Quintus Lutatius and Aulus Manlius. The war commenced twenty-three years afterwards, in the consulate of Publius Cornelius and Tiberius Sempronius. It was concluded in the seventeenth year, in the consulate of Cneius Cornelius and Publius Aelius Paetus. It is related that Scipio frequently said afterwards, that first the ambition of Tiberius Claudius, and afterwards of Cneius Cornelius, were the causes which prevented his terminating the war by the destruction of Carthage. The Carthaginians, finding difficulty in raising the first sum of money to be paid, as their finances were exhausted by a protracted war, and in consequence great lamentation and grief arising in the senate-house, it is said that Hannibal was observed laughing; and when Hasdrubal Haedus rebuked him for laughing amid the public grief, when he himself was the occasion of the tears which were shed, he said: "If, as the expression of the countenance is discerned by the sight, so the inward feelings of the mind could be distinguished, it would clearly appear to you that that laughter which you censure came from a heart not elated with joy, but frantic with misfortunes. And yet it is not so ill-timed as those absurd and inconsistent tears of yours. Then you ought to have wept, when our arms were taken from us, our ships burnt, and we were forbidden to engage in foreign wars, for that was the wound by which we fell. Nor is it just that you should suppose that the measures which the Romans have adopted towards you have been dictated by animosity. No great state can remain at rest long together. If it has no enemy abroad it finds one at home, in the same manner as over-robust bodies seem secure from external causes, but are encumbered with their own strength. So far, forsooth, we are affected with the public calamities as they reach our private affairs; nor is there any circumstance attending them which is felt more acutely than the loss of money. Accordingly, when the spoils were torn down from vanquished Carthage, when you beheld her left unarmed and defenceless amid so many armed nations of Africa, none heaved a sigh. Now, because a tribute is to be levied from private property, you lament with one accord, as though at the funeral of the state. How much do I dread lest you should soon be made sensible that you have shed tears this day for the lightest of your misfortunes!" Such were the sentiments which Hannibal delivered to the Carthaginians. Scipio, having summoned an assembly, presented Masinissa, in addition to his paternal dominions, with the town of Cirta, and the other cities and territories which had passed from the kingdom of Syphax into the possession of the Romans. He ordered Cneius Octavius to conduct the fleet to Sicily and deliver it to Cneius Cornelius the consul, and directed the Carthaginian ambassadors to go to Rome, that the arrangements he had made, with the advice of the ten deputies, might be ratified by the sanction of the fathers and the order of the people.

The last peace with the Carthaginians was made forty years before this, during the consulate of Quintus Lutatius and Aulus Manlius. The war started twenty-three years later, in the consulate of Publius Cornelius and Tiberius Sempronius. It ended in the seventeenth year, in the consulate of Cneius Cornelius and Publius Aelius Paetus. It’s said that Scipio often remarked later that the ambitions of Tiberius Claudius and then Cneius Cornelius were what kept him from ending the war by destroying Carthage. The Carthaginians struggled to raise the initial amount of money they needed to pay, as their finances were drained from a long war, causing great sorrow and distress in the senate. It’s reported that Hannibal was seen laughing, and when Hasdrubal Haedus scolded him for laughing during a time of public mourning, especially since he was the cause of the tears, he replied: "If the expression on someone's face could reveal their true feelings as clearly as sight, you would realize that my laughter comes from a heart not filled with joy but overwhelmed by misfortune. And it's certainly not as misplaced as your ridiculous and contradictory tears. You should have cried when we were stripped of our weapons, our ships were burned, and we were forbidden from engaging in foreign wars, for those were the wounds that truly hurt us. It's also unfair for you to think that the Romans’ actions towards you stem from hostility. No great state can stay calm for long. If it has no external enemy, it creates one internally, just like strong bodies may seem safe from outside causes but are burdened by their own strength. We feel public losses when they hit our private lives, and nothing stings more than losing money. So when the spoils were taken from conquered Carthage, and you saw her left unarmed and defenseless among so many armed nations in Africa, no one sighed. Now, because a tax is to be imposed on private property, you all mourn as if it were a state funeral. I fear that soon you'll realize that today you wept for the least of your misfortunes!" These were Hannibal's thoughts directed at the Carthaginians. Scipio then called an assembly, presenting Masinissa with Cirta and the other cities and lands that had passed from Syphax’s kingdom to Roman possession. He instructed Cneius Octavius to take the fleet to Sicily and hand it over to Cneius Cornelius the consul, and directed the Carthaginian ambassadors to go to Rome, so the agreements he made with the ten deputies could be confirmed by the senate and the people's decree.

45

Peace having been established by sea and land, he embarked his troops and crossed over to Lilybaeum in Sicily; whence, having sent a great part of his soldiers by ships, he himself proceeded through Italy, which was rejoicing, not less on account of the peace than the victory; while not only the inhabitants of the cities poured out to show him honour, but crowds of rustics thronged the roads. He arrived at Rome and entered the city in a triumph of unparalleled splendour. He brought into the treasury one hundred and twenty-three thousand pounds of silver. He distributed to each of his soldiers four hundred asses out of the spoils. By the death of Syphax, which took place but a short time before at Tibur, whither he had been removed from Alba, a diminution was occasioned in the interest of the pageant rather than in the glory of him who triumphed. His death, however, was attended with circumstances which produced a strong sensation, for he was buried at the public expense. Polybius, an author by no means to be despised, asserts that this king was led in the triumph. Quintus Terentius Culleo followed Scipio in his triumph with a cap of liberty on his head, and during the remainder of his life treated him with the respect due to him as the author of his freedom. I have not been able to ascertain whether the partiality of the soldiers or the favour of the people fixed upon him the surname of Africanus, or whether in the same manner as Felix was applied to Sulla, and Magnus to Pompey, in the memory of our fathers, it originated in the flattery of his friends. He was, doubtless, the first general who was distinguished by a name derived from the nation which he had conquered. Afterwards, in imitation of his example, some, by no means his equals in his victories, affixed splendid inscriptions on their statues and gave honourable surnames to their families.

Once peace was established by land and sea, he boarded his troops and crossed over to Lilybaeum in Sicily. From there, he sent a large part of his soldiers by ship while he made his way through Italy, which was celebrating not just the victory but also the peace. The residents of the cities came out to honor him, and crowds of country folks filled the roads. He arrived in Rome and entered the city in an unmatched display of triumph. He brought 123,000 pounds of silver into the treasury and distributed 400 asses from the spoils to each of his soldiers. The death of Syphax, which had happened shortly before at Tibur, where he had been moved from Alba, caused more of a decline in interest in the spectacle than a decrease in glory for the triumphant leader. However, his death garnered significant attention since he was buried at public expense. Polybius, a respected author, claims that this king was led in the triumph. Quintus Terentius Culleo followed Scipio during his triumph wearing a liberty cap and treated him with the respect he deserved for granting him freedom for the rest of his life. I couldn’t determine whether the soldiers' favoritism or the people's support led to him being called Africanus, or if, similar to how Felix was used for Sulla and Magnus for Pompey in our fathers' memory, it was a flattering nickname from his friends. He was undoubtedly the first general to earn a name based on the nation he had defeated. Later, imitating his example, some, who were far from his level in victories, put grand inscriptions on their statues and gave their families honorable surnames.

47

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXXI.


Renewal of the war with Philip, king of Macedon. Successes of Publius Sulpicius, consul, who had the conduct of that war. The Abydenians, besieged by Philip, put themselves to death, together with their wives and children. Lucius Furius, praetor, defeats the Insubrian Gauls who had revolted; and Hamilcar, who stirred up the insurrection, is slain, with thirty-five thousand men. Further operations of Sulpicius, Attalus, and the Rhodians against Philip.

       *        *        *        *        *

1

It is delightful even to me to have come to the end of the Punic war, as if I myself had borne a share of the toil and danger. For though it by no means becomes a person, who has ventured to promise an entire history of all the Roman affairs, to be fatigued by any particular parts of so extensive a work; yet when I reflect that sixty-three years (for so many there are from the first Punic war to the end of the second) have occupied as many of my volumes, as the four hundred and eighty-seven years, from the building of the city to the consulate of Appius Claudius, who first made war on the Carthaginians, I plainly perceive that, like those who, tempted by the shallows near the shore, walk into the sea, the farther I advance, I am carried, as it were, into a greater depth and abyss; and that my work almost increases on my hands which seemed to be diminished by the completion of each of its earlier portions. The peace with Carthage was quickly followed by a war with Macedonia: a war, not to be compared to the former, indeed, either in danger, or in the abilities of the commander, or the valour of the soldiers; but almost more remarkable with regard to the renown of their former kings, the ancient fame of that nation, and the vast extent of their empire, in which they had formerly comprehended a large part of Europe, and the greater part of Asia. The contest with Philip, which had begun about ten years before, had been intermitted for the three last years; the Aetolians having been the occasion both of the war and the peace. The entreaties of the Athenians whom, having ravaged their lands, Philip had driven into their city, excited the Romans to a renewal of the war, left, as they were, disengaged by the Carthaginian peace, and incensed against him as well for his treacherous negotiation of peace with the Aetolians and the other allies in that region, as on account of the auxiliaries sent by him with money into Africa to Hannibal and the Carthaginians.

It’s even a pleasure for me to have reached the end of the Punic War, almost as if I had shared in the struggle and risk. Even though it’s not fitting for someone who has promised to tell the complete history of Roman affairs to feel exhausted by any single part of such a vast project, I can’t help but notice that sixty-three years (the time from the first Punic War to the end of the second) have filled as many volumes as the four hundred and eighty-seven years from the founding of the city to the consulate of Appius Claudius, who was the first to take on the Carthaginians. I can clearly see that, like those who are tempted by shallow waters and walk into the sea, the further I go, the more I’m drawn into deeper waters and an abyss; my work seems to grow even as I complete each earlier section. The peace with Carthage was soon followed by a war with Macedonia: a conflict that really can’t compare to the former one in terms of danger, leadership, or the bravery of the soldiers; yet it’s noteworthy because of the reputation of its earlier kings, the ancient glory of that nation, and the vastness of their empire, which once covered a large part of Europe and much of Asia. The fight with Philip, which had started about ten years earlier, had been paused for the last three years, with the Aetolians initiating both the war and the peace. The appeals from the Athenians, whom Philip had driven into their city after ravaging their lands, motivated the Romans to resume the war, especially since they were free after the peace with Carthage and angered at him for both his deceitful peace with the Aetolians and other local allies, as well as for sending support and money to Hannibal and the Carthaginians in Africa.

2

About the same time, ambassadors arrived both from king Attalus, and from the Rhodians, with information that the Macedonian was tampering with the states of Asia. To these embassies an answer was given, that the senate would give attention to the affairs of Asia. The determination with regard to the making war on him, was left open to the consuls, who were then in their provinces. In the mean time, three ambassadors were sent to Ptolemy, king of Egypt, namely, Caius Claudius Nero, Marcus Aemilius Lepidus, and Publius Sempronius Tuditanus, to announce their conquest of Hannibal and the Carthaginians; to give thanks to the king for his faithful adherence to his engagements in the time of their distress, when even the nearest allies of the Romans abandoned them; and to request that if, compelled by ill treatment, they should undertake a war with Philip, he would preserve his former disposition towards the Roman people. In Gaul, about this time, the consul, Publius Aelius, having heard that, before his arrival, the Boians had made inroads on the territories of the allies, levied two occasional legions on account of this disturbance; and adding to them four cohorts from his own army, ordered Caius Oppius, the praefect, to march with this tumultuary band through Umbria, (which is called the Sappinian district,) and to invade the territories of the Boians. He himself led his own troops thither openly, over the intervening mountains. Oppius, on entering the same, for some time committed depredations with tolerable success and safety. But afterwards, having pitched on a place near a fort called Mutilum, convenient enough for cutting down the corn, (for the crops were now ripe,) and setting out without having reconnoitred around, and without establishing armed posts of sufficient strength to protect those who were unarmed and intent on their work, he was suddenly surrounded, together with his foragers, by an unexpected invasion of the Gauls. On this, panic and flight seized even on those who were furnished with weapons. Seven thousand men, dispersed through the corn fields, were put to the sword, among whom was the commander himself, Caius Oppius. The rest were driven by terror into the camp; from whence, in consequence of a resolution of the soldiers, they set out on the following night, without any particular commander; and, leaving behind a great part of their baggage, made their way, through woods almost impassable, to the consul, who returned to Rome without having performed any thing in his province worth notice, except that he ravaged the lands of the Boians, and made a treaty with the Ingaunian Ligurians.

Around the same time, ambassadors arrived from King Attalus and the Rhodians, bringing news that the Macedonian was trying to influence the states of Asia. In response to these embassies, it was stated that the senate would consider the situation in Asia. The decision about going to war with him was left up to the consuls, who were in their provinces at the time. Meanwhile, three ambassadors were sent to Ptolemy, king of Egypt: Caius Claudius Nero, Marcus Aemilius Lepidus, and Publius Sempronius Tuditanus. They were to announce their victory over Hannibal and the Carthaginians, thank the king for his loyalty during their difficult times when even their closest allies had abandoned them, and ask that if they were forced into a war with Philip due to mistreatment, he would maintain his favorable attitude towards the Roman people. In Gaul, around this time, the consul Publius Aelius, upon learning that the Boians had attacked the territories of the allies before his arrival, raised two temporary legions because of this unrest. He added four cohorts from his own army and ordered Caius Oppius, the prefect, to lead this makeshift force through Umbria (known as the Sappinian district) to invade the lands of the Boians. He himself openly led his own troops over the mountains. However, when Oppius entered the area, he successfully conducted raids for a while. But later, after choosing a spot near a fort called Mutilum, which was suitable for harvesting the ripe crops, and setting out without scouting the area or establishing strong enough armed posts to protect the unarmed workers, he was suddenly surrounded by an unexpected attack from the Gauls. Panic and flight struck even those who were armed. Seven thousand men scattered across the fields were killed, including their commander, Caius Oppius. The others fled in terror to the camp and, after a decision by the soldiers, set out that night without a specific leader, abandoning much of their baggage, and made their way through nearly impassable woods to the consul, who returned to Rome without achieving anything noteworthy in his province other than ravaging the lands of the Boians and making a treaty with the Ingaunian Ligurians.

3

The first time he assembled the senate, it was unanimously ordered that he should propose no other business before that which related to Philip and the complaints of the allies. It was immediately taken into consideration, and a numerous senate decreed, that Publius Aelius, consul, should send such person as he might think proper, vested with command, to receive the fleet which Cneius Octavius was bringing home from Sicily, and pass over to Macedonia. Accordingly Marcus Valerius Laevinus, propraetor, was sent; and, receiving thirty-eight ships from Cneius Octavius, near Vibo, he sailed to Macedonia, where, when Marcus Aurelius, the ambassador, had come to him and informed him what numerous forces and what large fleets the king had prepared, and how he was arousing the inhabitants to arms, partly by visiting them himself and partly by ambassadors, not only through all the cities of the continent, but even in the islands, (Laevinus was convinced) that the war ought to be undertaken by the Romans with greater vigour; lest, if they were dilatory, Philip might attempt that which had been formerly undertaken by Pyrrhus, who possessed not such large dominions. He therefore desired Aurelius to convey this intelligence by letter to the consuls and to the senate.

The first time he called the senate together, it was agreed without objection that he should only discuss matters related to Philip and the complaints from the allies. It was immediately addressed, and a large senate decided that Publius Aelius, the consul, should send someone he deemed suitable, with authority, to receive the fleet that Cneius Octavius was bringing back from Sicily and to travel to Macedonia. As a result, Marcus Valerius Laevinus, the propraetor, was sent; and after receiving thirty-eight ships from Cneius Octavius near Vibo, he sailed to Macedonia. There, when Marcus Aurelius, the ambassador, arrived and informed him about the extensive forces and large fleets the king had prepared, and how he was rallying the locals to arms, both by visiting them personally and through ambassadors, not just across all the cities on the mainland but even in the islands, Laevinus was convinced that the Romans needed to pursue the war with greater determination; otherwise, if they hesitated, Philip might attempt what had previously been attempted by Pyrrhus, who did not have such vast territories. He therefore asked Aurelius to relay this information in a letter to the consuls and the senate.

4

Towards the end of this year the senate, taking into consideration the lands to be given to the veteran soldiers, who, under the conduct and auspices of Publius Scipio, had finished the war in Africa, decreed that Marcus Tunius, praetor of the city, should, if he thought proper, appoint ten commissioners to survey, and distribute among them, that part of the Samnite and Apulian lands which was the property of the Roman people. For this purpose were appointed, Publius Servilius, Quintus Caecilius Metellus, Caius and Marcus Servilius, both surnamed Geminus, Lucius and Aulus Hostilius Cato, Publius Villius Tappulus, Marcus Fulvius Flaccus, Publius Aelius Paetus, and Quintus Flaminius. At the same time, Publius Aelius presiding at the election of consuls, Publius Sulpicius Galba and Caius Aurelius Cotta were elected. Then were chosen praetors, Quintus Minucius Rufus, Lucius Furius Purpureo, Quintus Fulvius Gillo, Cneius Sergius Plancus. The Roman stage-games were exhibited, in a sumptuous and elegant manner, by the curule aediles, Lucius Valerius Flaccus, and Lucius Quintius Flaminius, and repeated for two days; and a vast quantity of corn, which Scipio had sent from Africa, was distributed by them to the people, with strict impartiality and general satisfaction, at the rate of four asses a peck. The plebeian games were thrice repeated entire by the plebeian aediles, Lucius Apustius Fullo, and Quintus Minucius Rufus; the latter of whom was, from the aedileship, elected praetor. There was also a feast of Jove on occasion of the games.

Towards the end of this year, the Senate, considering the lands to be allocated to the veteran soldiers who, under the leadership and protection of Publius Scipio, had completed the war in Africa, decided that Marcus Tunius, the city praetor, should, if he deemed it appropriate, appoint ten commissioners to survey and distribute among them that part of the Samnite and Apulian lands which belonged to the Roman people. For this purpose, the following were appointed: Publius Servilius, Quintus Caecilius Metellus, Caius and Marcus Servilius, both nicknamed Geminus, Lucius and Aulus Hostilius Cato, Publius Villus Tappulus, Marcus Fulvius Flaccus, Publius Aelius Paetus, and Quintus Flaminius. At the same time, Publius Aelius presided over the election of consuls, in which Publius Sulpicius Galba and Caius Aurelius Cotta were elected. Next, the praetors chosen were Quintus Minucius Rufus, Lucius Furius Purpureo, Quintus Fulvius Gillo, and Cneius Sergius Plancus. The curule aediles, Lucius Valerius Flaccus and Lucius Quintius Flaminius, presented the Roman stage games in a lavish and stylish manner, and they were held for two days. A large amount of grain sent from Africa by Scipio was distributed by them to the people with fairness and widespread approval, at the rate of four asses per peck. The plebeian games were held three times in full by the plebeian aediles, Lucius Apustius Fullo and Quintus Minucius Rufus, the latter of whom was elected praetor from the aedileship. There was also a feast for Jupiter in celebration of the games.

5

In the year five hundred and fifty-two from the building of the city, Publius Sulpicius Galba and Caius Aurelius being consuls, within a few months after the conclusion of the peace with the Carthaginians, the war was entered upon against king Philip. This was the first business introduced by the consul, Publius Sulpicius, on the ides of March, the day on which, in those times, the consulship commenced; and the senate decreed, that the consul should perform sacrifices with the greater victims, to such gods as they should judge proper, with prayers to this purpose,--that "the business which the senate and people of Rome had then under deliberation, concerning the state, and the entering on a new war, might issue prosperously and happily to the Roman people, the allies, and the Latin confederacy;" and that, after the sacrifices and prayers, they should consult the senate on the state of public affairs, and the provinces. At this time, very opportunely for exciting their minds to war, the letters were brought from Marcus Aurelius, the ambassador, and Marcus Valerius Laevinus, propraetor. A fresh embassy, likewise, arrived from the Athenians, to acquaint them that the king was approaching their frontiers, and that in a short time, not only their lands, but their city also, must fall into his hands, unless they received aid from the Romans. When the consuls had made their report, that the sacrifices had been duly performed, and that the gods had accepted their prayers; that the aruspices had declared that the entrails showed good omens, and that enlargement of territory, victory, and triumph were portended; the letters of Valerius and Aurelius were read, and audience given to the ambassadors of the Athenians. After which, a decree of the senate was passed, that thanks should be given to their allies, because, though long solicited, they had not, even when in fear of a siege, renounced their fidelity. With regard to sending assistance to them, they resolved, that an answer should be given as soon as the consuls should have cast lots for the provinces; and when the consul to whose lot Macedonia fell should have proposed to the people, that war should be declared against Philip, king of the Macedonians.

In the year 552 since the city's founding, with Publius Sulpicius Galba and Caius Aurelius as consuls, just a few months after peace was made with the Carthaginians, war was declared against King Philip. This was the first matter introduced by Consul Publius Sulpicius on the Ides of March, the day when consuls officially took office. The Senate decided that the consul should perform sacrifices with the larger offerings to the gods they deemed appropriate, with prayers for the success and prosperity of the situation at hand, concerning the state and the initiation of a new war, for the Roman people, their allies, and the Latin coalition. After the sacrifices and prayers, they would consult the Senate about public affairs and the provinces. At that moment, conveniently stimulating their desire for war, letters arrived from Marcus Aurelius, the ambassador, and Marcus Valerius Laevinus, the propraetor. A new delegation from the Athenians also arrived to inform them that the king was approaching their borders and that soon their lands and city would be at risk without Roman assistance. After the consuls reported that the sacrifices had been properly conducted and the gods had accepted their prayers, and that the diviners indicated favorable omens for expansion, victory, and triumph, the letters from Valerius and Aurelius were read, and the Athenian ambassadors were given an audience. Following this, the Senate passed a decree to thank their allies because, despite being under threat of siege, they had remained loyal. Regarding the need to send assistance, they decided to provide a response once the consuls had drawn lots for the provinces, and when the consul assigned to Macedonia proposed to the people a declaration of war against King Philip of the Macedonians.

6

The province of Macedonia fell by lot to Publius Sulpicius; and he proposed to the people to declare, "that they chose and ordered, that on account of the injuries and hostilities committed against the allies of the Roman people, war should be proclaimed against king Philip, and the Macedonians under his government." The province of Italy fell to the lot of the other consul, Aurelius. The praetors then cast lots: to Cneius Sergius Plancus fell the city jurisdiction; to Quintus Fulvius Gillo, Sicily; to Quintus Minucius Rufus, Bruttium; and to Lucius Furius Purpureo, Gaul. At the first meeting of the people, the proposal concerning the Macedonian war was rejected by almost all the tribes. This was done partly spontaneously, as the people were wearied by the length and severity of the late war, and disgusted with toils and dangers; and partly by Quintus Baebius, tribune of the people, who, pursuing the old practice of criminating the patricians, charged them with multiplying wars one after another, so that the people could never enjoy peace. This proceeding the patricians with difficulty brooked, and the tribune was severely reprehended in the senate; where each severally urged the consul to call a new assembly, for passing the proposal; to rebuke the backwardness of the people; and to prove to them how much loss and disgrace the delay of this war would occasion.

The province of Macedonia was assigned to Publius Sulpicius by lot, and he proposed to the people to declare, "that they choose and order that, due to the injuries and hostilities committed against the allies of the Roman people, war should be proclaimed against King Philip and the Macedonians under his rule." The province of Italy was assigned to the other consul, Aurelius. The praetors then cast lots: the city jurisdiction went to Cneius Sergius Plancus; Quintus Fulvius Gillo got Sicily; Quintus Minucius Rufus was assigned Bruttium; and Lucius Furius Purpureo received Gaul. At the first meeting of the people, the proposal regarding the Macedonian war was rejected by nearly all the tribes. This rejection was partly spontaneous, as the people were weary from the length and severity of the recent war and disillusioned by the endless struggles and dangers; and partly influenced by Quintus Baebius, the tribune of the people, who, following the old practice of criticizing the patricians, accused them of creating wars one after another, preventing the people from ever enjoying peace. The patricians found this hard to tolerate, and the tribune was harshly reprimanded in the senate, where each member urged the consul to call a new assembly to pass the proposal, to address the people's reluctance, and to demonstrate how much loss and disgrace the delay of this war would cause.

7

The consul, having assembled the people in the field of Mars, before he dismissed the centuries to the vote, required their attention, and addressed them thus: "Citizens, you seem to me not to understand that the question before you is not whether you choose to have peace or war: for Philip, having already commenced hostilities with a formidable force, both on land and sea, allows you not that option. The question is, Whether you must transport your legions to Macedonia, or admit the enemy into Italy? How important the difference is, if you never experienced it before, you certainly did in the late Punic war. For who entertains a doubt, but if, when the Saguntines were besieged, and implored our protection, we had assisted them with vigour, as our fathers did the Mamertines, we should have averted the whole weight of the war upon Spain; which, by our dilatory proceedings, we suffered to our extreme loss to fall upon Italy? Nor does it admit a doubt, that we confined this same Philip in Macedonia, (after he had entered into an engagement with Hannibal by ambassadors and letters, to cross over into Italy,) by sending Laevinus with a fleet to make war aggressively upon him. And what we did at that time, when we had Hannibal to contend with in Italy, do we hesitate to do now, after Hannibal has been expelled Italy, and the Carthaginians subdued? Suppose that we allow the king to experience the same inactivity on our part, while he is taking Athens, as we suffered Hannibal to experience while he was taking Saguntum: it will not be in the fifth month, as Hannibal came from Saguntum, but on the fifth day after he sets sail from Corinth, that he will arrive in Italy. Perhaps you may not consider Philip as equal to Hannibal; or the Macedonians to the Carthaginians: certainly, however, you will allow him equal to Pyrrhus. Equal, do I say? what a vast superiority has the one man over the other, the one nation over the other! Epirus ever was, and is at this day, deemed but an inconsiderable accession to the kingdom of Macedonia. Philip has the entire Peloponnesus under his dominion; even Argos itself, not more celebrated for its ancient glory than for the death of Pyrrhus. Now compare our situation. How much more nourishing was Italy, how much greater its strength, with so many commanders, so many armies unimpaired, which the Punic war afterwards consumed, when Pyrrhus attacked and shook it, and advanced victorious almost to the Roman capital! and not the Tarentines only, and the inhabitants of that tract of Italy which they call the greater Greece, whom you may suppose to have been led by the similarity of language and name, but the Lucanian, the Bruttian, and the Samnite revolted from us. Do you believe that these would continue quiet and faithful, if Philip should come over to Italy? They subsequently continued faithful, forsooth, during the Punic war! Be assured those states will never fail to revolt from us, except when there is no one to whom they can go over. If you had been annoyed at passing into Africa, you would this day have had Hannibal and the Carthaginians to contend with in Italy. Let Macedonia, rather than Italy, be the seat of war. Let the cities and lands of the enemy be wasted with fire and sword. We have already found by experience, that our arms are more powerful and more successful abroad than at home. Go to the vote with the blessing of the gods; and what the senate have voted, do you ratify by your order. This resolution is recommended to you, not only by your consul, but even by the immortal gods themselves; who, when I offered sacrifice, and prayed that the issue of this war might be happy and prosperous to me and to the senate, to you and the allies and Latin confederates, to our fleets and armies, portended all joyful and prosperous results."

The consul, after gathering the people in the field of Mars, asked for their attention before the vote and spoke to them like this: "Citizens, it seems you don't understand that the question isn’t about choosing peace or war. Philip has already started hostilities with a strong force, both on land and at sea, so that option isn't available. The real question is whether you will deploy your legions to Macedonia or let the enemy enter Italy. If you haven't experienced this difference before, you certainly did in the recent Punic war. Who doubts that, if we had vigorously supported the Saguntines when they were besieged and begging for our help, just as our ancestors did for the Mamertines, we could have prevented the full weight of the war from falling on Spain? Instead, due to our hesitation, we allowed it to come crashing down on Italy. There’s no doubt that we contained Philip in Macedonia (after he had communicated with Hannibal about invading Italy) by sending Laevinus with a fleet to attack him. What we did then, while we were also dealing with Hannibal in Italy, should we hesitate to do now that Hannibal has been expelled and the Carthaginians defeated? If we let the king experience the same inaction on our part while he captures Athens, as we did while Hannibal captured Saguntum, it won’t take him five months, as it did for Hannibal, but just five days after he sails from Corinth before he reaches Italy. You might not see Philip as being on the same level as Hannibal, or the Macedonians as being equal to the Carthaginians; however, you must agree that he is at least equal to Pyrrhus. Equal, I say? The difference between them is massive! Epirus has always been seen as a minor addition to the kingdom of Macedonia. Philip rules the entire Peloponnesus; even Argos, famous not only for its ancient glory but also for the death of Pyrrhus. Now compare our current situation. Italy was far more prosperous and strong, with so many leaders and armies that later got depleted during the Punic war, when Pyrrhus attacked and nearly succeeded in reaching the Roman capital! Not just the Tarentines and the people of that part of Italy they call greater Greece, led by their shared language and name, but also the Lucanians, Bruttians, and Samnites revolted against us. Do you think they'd stay loyal if Philip came to Italy? They remained faithful, of course, during the Punic war! Rest assured, those states will always rebel against us unless there’s no one else to turn to. If you had been concerned about invading Africa, you would still be facing Hannibal and the Carthaginians in Italy today. Let Macedonia be the battleground instead of Italy. Let the enemy’s cities and lands be devastated by fire and sword. We have already learned that our military success is greater abroad than at home. Go to the vote with the gods' blessing; and what the senate has decided, you should confirm with your own approval. This resolution comes recommended not just by your consul, but even by the immortal gods themselves, who, when I offered sacrifices and prayed for a favorable outcome to this war for me, the senate, you, and our allies and Latin confederates, indicated all positive and prosperous results."

8

After this speech of Sulpicius, being sent to give their votes, they declared for the war as he had proposed. On which, in pursuance of a decree of the senate, a supplication for three days was proclaimed by the consuls; and prayers were offered to the gods at all the shrines, that the war which the people had ordered against Philip might turn out well and happily. The consul Sulpicius inquiring of the heralds, whether they would direct the declaration of the war against king Philip to be made to himself in person, or whether it would be sufficient to publish it in the nearest garrison, within the frontiers of his kingdom, they answered, that they would do rightly whichever course they should adopt. The consul received authority from the senate to send any person whom he thought proper, not being a senator, as ambassador, to denounce war against the king. They then arranged for the armies of the consuls and praetors. The consuls were ordered to levy two legions, and to disband the veteran troops. Sulpicius, to whom the management of this new and highly important war had been decreed, was allowed permission to carry with him as many volunteers as he could procure out of the army which Publius Scipio had brought home from Africa; but he was not empowered to take with him any veteran soldier against his will. They ordered that the consul should give to the praetors, Lucius Furius Purpureo and Quintus Minucius Rufus, five thousand of the allies of the Latin confederacy; with which forces they should hold, one, the province of Gaul, the other, Bruttium. Quintus Fulvius Gillo was ordered, in like manner, to select out of the army which Publius Aelius, late consul, had commanded, such as had been the shortest time in the service, until he also made up five thousand of the allies and Latin confederates; that this was to be the protection of the province of Sicily. To Marcus Valerius Falto, who, during the former year, had held the province of Campania, as praetor, the command was continued for a year; in order that he might go over, as propraetor, to Sardinia, and choose out of the army there five thousand of the allies of the Latin confederacy, who had served the fewest campaigns. The consuls were at the same time ordered to levy two legions for the city, which might be sent wherever occasions should require; as there were many states in Italy infected with an attachment to the Carthaginians, which they had formed during the war, and, in consequence, swelling with resentment. The state was to employ during that year six Roman legions.

After Sulpicius's speech, when it was time to cast their votes, they supported the war he had proposed. As a result, following a decree from the senate, the consuls announced a three-day period of supplication; prayers were offered to the gods at all the shrines, asking for a successful and favorable outcome for the war that the people had decided on against Philip. Consul Sulpicius asked the heralds whether they should announce the declaration of war against King Philip directly to him or if it would be enough to publish it in the nearest garrison within his kingdom's borders. They replied that either choice would be correct. The consul received permission from the senate to send anyone he deemed appropriate, who was not a senator, as an ambassador to declare war against the king. They then organized the armies of the consuls and praetors. The consuls were instructed to raise two legions and disband the veteran troops. Sulpicius, who was assigned to manage this new and crucial war, was allowed to take as many volunteers as he could gather from the army that Publius Scipio had brought back from Africa; however, he was not allowed to take any veteran soldiers against their will. They ordered the consul to give praetors Lucius Furius Purpureo and Quintus Minucius Rufus five thousand troops from the Latin confederacy, so that one would hold the province of Gaul and the other Bruttium. Quintus Fulvius Gillo was similarly instructed to select from the army commanded by the late consul Publius Aelius those soldiers who had served the least amount of time, until he too assembled five thousand troops from the allies and Latin confederates to protect the province of Sicily. To Marcus Valerius Falto, who had served as praetor in Campania the previous year, the command was extended for another year so he could go, as propraetor, to Sardinia and choose five thousand troops from the allies of the Latin confederacy who had served the fewest campaigns. The consuls were also instructed to raise two legions for the city, which could be dispatched as needed; many states in Italy had developed ties to the Carthaginians during the war and were swelling with resentment. The state was to employ six Roman legions that year.

9

In the midst of the preparations for war, ambassadors came from king Ptolemy, who delivered a message; that "the Athenians had petitioned the king for aid against Philip; but that although they were their common allies, yet the king would not, except with the sanction of the Roman people, send either fleet or army into Greece, for the purpose of defending or attacking any person. That he would either remain quiet in his kingdom, if the Romans were at leisure to protect their allies; or, if more agreeable to them to be at rest, would himself send such aid as might easily secure Athens against Philip." Thanks were returned to the king by the senate, and this answer: that "it was the intention of the Roman people to protect their allies; that if they should have occasion for any assistance towards carrying on the war, they would acquaint the king; and that they were fully sensible, that the resources of his kingdom were the sure and faithful support of their own state." Presents were then, by order of the senate, sent to the ambassadors, of five thousand asses1 to each. While the consuls were engaged in the levy, and preparing what was necessary for the war, the people, prone to religious observances, especially at the beginning of new wars, after supplications had been already performed, and prayers offered up at all the shrines, lest any thing should be omitted that had ever been practised, ordered, that the consul who was to have the province of Macedonia should vow games and a present to Jove. Licinius, the chief pontiff, occasioned some delay to this public vow, alleging, that "it ought not to be fulfilled from promiscuous funds. For as the sum to be named should not be applied to the uses of the war, it should be immediately set apart, and not to be intermixed with other money; and that, unless this were done, the vow could not be properly performed." Although the objection and the author of it were influential, yet the consul was ordered to consult the college of pontiffs, whether a vow could be undertaken at an indeterminate expense? The pontiffs determined, that it could; and that it would be even more in order to do it in that way. The consul, therefore, repeating after the chief pontiff, made the vow in the same words in which those made for five years of safety used to be expressed; only that he engaged to perform the games, and make the offerings, at such expense as the senate should direct by their vote, at the time when the vow was performed. Before this, the great games so often vowed, were constantly rated at a certain expense: these first at an unspecified amount.

In the middle of the war preparations, ambassadors arrived from King Ptolemy with a message stating that "the Athenians had requested the king's help against Philip; however, even though they were mutual allies, the king would not send any fleet or army into Greece without the approval of the Roman people, either to defend or attack anyone. He would either stay quiet in his kingdom if the Romans had the time to protect their allies, or if it suited them to rest, he would send aid that would easily secure Athens against Philip." The Senate thanked the king and replied that "the Roman people intended to protect their allies; if they needed any help for the war, they would inform the king; and they were well aware that the resources of his kingdom were a reliable support for their own state." Subsequently, presents were sent to the ambassadors, amounting to five thousand asses1 each. While the consuls were busy with the recruitment and making necessary preparations for war, the people, inclined toward religious practices—especially at the start of new wars—after performing supplications and offering prayers at all the shrines to ensure nothing was overlooked, ordered that the consul who was to govern Macedonia should vow games and a gift to Jupiter. Licinius, the chief pontiff, caused some delays in this public vow, arguing that "it shouldn't be fulfilled with random funds. Since the promised amount shouldn't be used for war expenses, it should be set aside immediately and not mixed with other money; otherwise, the vow wouldn't be properly fulfilled." Although his objection and his status were significant, the consul was directed to ask the college of pontiffs whether a vow could be made with an unspecified amount. The pontiffs concluded that it could and that it would actually be better to do it that way. Therefore, the consul, following the chief pontiff's lead, made the vow in the same terms typically used for five years of safety; the only difference was that he promised to hold the games and make the offerings at whatever expense the Senate would decide with a vote at the time the vow was made. Previously, the major games that were often vowed were consistently assigned a specific cost; this was the first time a vow was made without specifying an amount.

10

While every one's attention was turned to the Macedonian war, and at a time when people apprehended nothing less, a sudden account was brought of an inroad of the Gauls. The Insubrians, Caenomanians, and Boians, having been joined by the Salyans, Ilvatians, and other Ligurian states, and putting themselves under the command of Hamilcar, a Carthaginian, who, having been in the army of Hasdrubal, had remained in those parts, had fallen upon Placentia; and, after plundering the city, and, in their rage, burning a great part of it, leaving scarcely two thousand men among the flames and ruins, passed the Po, and advanced to plunder Cremona. The news of the calamity which had fallen on a city in their neighbourhood, having reached thither, the inhabitants had time to shut their gates, and place guards on the walls, that they might, at least, be besieged before they were taken, and send messengers to the Roman praetor. Lucius Furius Purpureo, who had then the command of the province, had, in pursuance of the decree of the senate, disbanded the army, excepting five thousand of the allies and Latin confederacy; and had remained, with these troops, in the nearest district of the province about Ariminum. He immediately informed the senate, by letter, in what confusion the province was. That, "of the two colonies which had escaped in the dreadful storm of the Punic war, one was taken and sacked by the present enemy, and the other besieged. Nor was his army capable of affording sufficient protection to the distressed colonists, unless he chose to expose five thousand allies to be slaughtered by forty thousand invaders (for so many there were in arms); and by such a loss, on his side, to augment the courage of the enemy, already elated on having destroyed one Roman colony."

While everyone was focused on the Macedonian war, and at a time when people expected nothing less, a sudden report came in about an invasion by the Gauls. The Insubrians, Caenomanians, and Boians, joined by the Salyans, Ilvatians, and other Ligurian states, placed themselves under the command of Hamilcar, a Carthaginian who had previously served in Hasdrubal’s army. They attacked Placentia, plundering the city and, in their fury, burning a large part of it, leaving barely two thousand people amid the flames and ruins. They crossed the Po River and moved on to raid Cremona. Upon hearing about the disaster that had struck a nearby city, the inhabitants had enough time to close their gates and set up guards on the walls, ready to be besieged rather than taken without a fight, and they sent messengers to the Roman praetor. Lucius Furius Purpureo, who was in charge of the province at the time, had disbanded the army in accordance with the senate's decree, except for five thousand allies and members of the Latin confederacy. He remained with these troops in the region near Ariminum. He immediately wrote to the senate about the chaos in the province, stating that “of the two colonies that survived the devastating storm of the Punic war, one had been captured and sacked by the current enemy, while the other was under siege. His army could not provide adequate protection to the distressed colonists unless he was willing to risk the slaughter of five thousand allies at the hands of forty thousand invaders (as many were armed), which would only boost the enemy's morale after they had already destroyed one Roman colony.”

11

This letter having been read they decreed, that the consul Aurelius should order the army which he had appointed to assemble on a certain day in Etruria, to attend him on the same day at Ariminum; and should either go in person, if the public business would permit, to suppress the tumult of the Gauls, or write to the praetor Lucius Furius, that, as soon as the legions from Etruria came to him, he should send five thousand of the allies to guard that place in the mean time, and should himself proceed to relieve the colony from the siege. They also determined, that ambassadors should be sent to Carthage, and also into Numidia, to Masinissa: to Carthage, to announce that "their countryman, Hamilcar, having been left in Gaul, (either with a part of the army formerly commanded by Hasdrubal, or with that of Mago--they did not with certainty know which,) was waging war, contrary to the treaty. That he had excited the armies of the Gauls and Ligurians to arms against the Roman people. That, if they wished for peace, they must recall him, and give him up to the Roman people." They were ordered at the same time to tell them, that "all the deserters had not been sent back; that a great part of them were said to appear openly in Carthage, who ought to be sought after, and surrendered according to the treaty." Such was the message to the Carthaginians. To Masinissa they were charged with congratulations, on his "having not only recovered the kingdom of his father, but enlarged it by the acquisition of the most flourishing parts of Syphax's territories." They were ordered also to acquaint him, that "a war had been undertaken against Philip, because he had given aid to the Carthaginians, while, by the injuries which he offered to the allies of the Roman people, he had obliged them to send fleets and armies into Greece, while Italy was blazing with war; and that by thus making them separate their forces, had been the principal cause of their being so late passing over into Africa; and to request him to send to that war supplies of Numidian horsemen." Ample presents were given them to be carried to the king; vases of gold and silver, a purple robe, and a tunic adorned with palms of purple, an ivory sceptre, and a robe of state, with a curule chair. They were also directed to assure him, that if he deemed any thing further requisite to confirm and enlarge his kingdom, the Roman people, in return for his good services, would exert their utmost zeal to effect it. At this time, too, ambassadors from Vermina, son of Syphax, came to the senate apologizing for his mistaken conduct, on account of his youth and want of judgment, and throwing all the blame on the deceitful policy of the Carthaginians: adding, "that as Masinissa had from an enemy become a friend to the Romans, so Vermina would also use his best endeavours that he should not be outdone in offices of friendship to the Roman people either by Masinissa, or by any other; and requesting that he might receive from the senate the title of king, friend, and ally." The answer given to these ambassadors was, that "not only his father Syphax, from a friend and ally, had on a sudden, without any reason, become an enemy to the Roman people, but that he himself had made his first essay of manhood in bearing arms against them. He must, therefore, sue to the Roman people for peace, before he could expect to be acknowledged king, ally, and friend; that it was the practice of that people to bestow the honour of such title, in return for great services performed by kings towards them; that the Roman ambassadors would soon be in Africa, to whom the senate would give instructions to regulate conditions of peace with Vermina, if he would leave the terms of it entirely to the will of the Roman people; and that, if he wished that any thing should be added, left out, or altered, he must make a second application to the senate." The ambassadors sent to Africa on those affairs, were Caius Terentius Varro, Publius Lucretius, and Cneius Octavius, each of whom had a quinquereme assigned him.

This letter, after being read, led them to decide that Consul Aurelius should instruct the army he had planned to gather on a certain day in Etruria to meet him on the same day at Ariminum. He should either go himself, if public business allowed, to deal with the chaos caused by the Gauls, or write to Praetor Lucius Furius, telling him that once the legions from Etruria arrived, he should send five thousand allies to guard that location in the meantime and then go to relieve the colony from the siege. They also resolved to send ambassadors to Carthage and Numidia, to Masinissa: to Carthage, to inform them that "their fellow citizen, Hamilcar, who had been left in Gaul (either with a part of the army previously led by Hasdrubal or with that of Mago—they were not sure which) was waging war, against the treaty. He had rallied the armies of the Gauls and Ligurians against the Roman people. If they wanted peace, they needed to recall him and surrender him to the Roman people." They were also instructed to let them know that "not all the deserters had been returned; that many of them were said to be openly in Carthage and needed to be sought out and surrendered according to the treaty." This was the message to the Carthaginians. To Masinissa, they were sent with congratulations for "not only regaining his father's kingdom but also expanding it by acquiring the most prosperous parts of Syphax's territory." They were also tasked with informing him that "a war had been waged against Philip because he had assisted the Carthaginians, while the injuries he inflicted on the allies of the Roman people forced them to send fleets and armies into Greece, while Italy was engulfed in war; and that by separating their forces, he was primarily responsible for their delayed crossing into Africa; and to ask him to send supplies of Numidian cavalry for that war." They were given luxurious gifts to take to the king: gold and silver vases, a purple robe, a tunic adorned with purple palm leaves, an ivory scepter, a ceremonial robe, and a curule chair. They were also instructed to assure him that if he felt anything else was necessary to strengthen and expand his kingdom, the Roman people would do everything they could in return for his good services. At that time, ambassadors from Vermina, son of Syphax, came to the senate, apologizing for his misguided actions due to his youth and lack of judgment, placing all the blame on the deceitful tactics of the Carthaginians. He added, "Just as Masinissa changed from being an enemy to a friend of the Romans, I too will strive not to fall short in acts of friendship towards the Roman people, and I request that the senate grant me the title of king, friend, and ally." The response to these ambassadors was that "not only had his father Syphax, who was once a friend and ally, suddenly turned into an enemy of the Roman people without reason, but he himself had first shown his manhood by taking up arms against them. Therefore, he must seek peace from the Roman people before he could expect to be recognized as king, ally, and friend; that it was the custom of the Roman people to bestow such honors in return for significant services rendered by kings to them; that Roman ambassadors would soon arrive in Africa, and they would give instructions to negotiate the terms of peace with Vermina, as long as he agreed to leave the terms entirely to the will of the Roman people; and that if he wanted anything added, omitted, or changed, he must make a second appeal to the senate." The ambassadors sent to Africa for these matters were Caius Terentius Varro, Publius Lucretius, and Cneius Octavius, each assigned a quinquereme.

12

A letter was then read in the senate, from Quintus Minucius, the praetor, who held the province of Bruttium, that "the money had been privately carried off by night out of the treasury of Proserpine at Locri; and that there were no traces to those to whom the charge applied." The senate was highly incensed at finding that the practice of sacrilege continued, and that even the fate of Pleminius, an example so recent and so conspicuous both of the guilt and of the punishment, did not deter men from it. They ordered the consul, Cneius Aurelius, to signify to the praetor in Bruttium, that "it was the pleasure of the senate, that an inquiry be made concerning the robbery of the treasury, according to the method used by Marcus Pomponius, praetor, three years before; that the money which could be discovered should be restored, that what was not found should be made up, and that if he thought proper, atonements should be made for the purpose of expiating the violation of the temple, in the manner formerly prescribed by the pontiffs." At the same time, also, prodigies were announced as having happened in many places. It was said, that in Lucania the sky had been seen in a blaze; that at Privernum, in clear weather, the sun had been of a red colour during a whole day; that at Lanuvium, in the temple of Juno Sospita, a very loud noise had been heard in the night. Besides, monstrous births of animals were related to have occurred in many places: in the country of the Sabines, an infant was born whose sex was doubtful; and another was found, sixteen years old, of doubtful sex. At Frusino a lamb was born with a swine's head; at Sinuessa, a pig with a human head; and in Lucania, in the land belonging to the state, a foal with five feet. All these were considered as horrid and abominable, and as if nature were straying to strange productions. Above all, the people were particularly shocked at the hermaphrodites, which were ordered to be immediately thrown into the sea, as had been lately done with a production of the same monstrous kind, in the consulate of Caius Claudius and Marcus Livius. Notwithstanding they ordered the decemvirs to inspect the books in regard of that prodigy; and the decemvirs, from the books, directed the same religious ceremonies which had been performed on an occasion of the same kind. They ordered, besides, a hymn to be sung through the city by thrice nine virgins, and an offering to be made to imperial Juno. The consul, Caius Aurelius, took care that all these matters were performed according to the direction of the decemvirs. The hymn was composed by Publius Licinius Tegula, as a similar one had been, in the memory of their fathers, by Livius.

A letter was read in the Senate from Quintus Minucius, the praetor in charge of the province of Bruttium, stating that "money had been stolen from the treasury of Proserpine in Locri during the night; and there were no leads on who was responsible." The Senate was outraged to learn that sacrilege was still happening, and that even the recent and prominent case of Pleminius—showing both guilt and punishment—didn't stop people from committing such acts. They instructed the consul, Cneius Aurelius, to inform the praetor in Bruttium that "the Senate wanted an investigation into the theft of the treasury, using the same method that Marcus Pomponius, the praetor, used three years prior; that any recovered money should be returned, that any losses should be compensated for, and that if he deemed it necessary, atonements should be made to atone for the violation of the temple, in the manner specified by the pontiffs before." At the same time, prodigies were reported to have occurred in various places. It was said that in Lucania, the sky was seen ablaze; that at Privernum, on a clear day, the sun appeared red for an entire day; and that at Lanuvium, in the temple of Juno Sospita, a loud noise was heard during the night. Additionally, bizarre animal births were reported in several places: in Sabine territory, an infant of uncertain sex was born; and another, sixteen years old, was found, also of uncertain sex. In Frusino, a lamb was born with a pig's head; in Sinuessa, a pig was born with a human head; and in Lucania, on state-owned land, a foal was found with five feet. These events were considered horrifying and unnatural, as if nature was producing strange anomalies. The people were especially disturbed by the hermaphrodites, which were commanded to be thrown into the sea immediately, just like another monstrous being had been during the consulate of Caius Claudius and Marcus Livius. Nevertheless, they ordered the decemvirs to review the records related to that prodigy; and the decemvirs, based on those records, prescribed the same religious ceremonies that had been performed for similar occurrences. They also ordered a hymn to be sung throughout the city by thirty virgins, and an offering made to imperial Juno. The consul, Caius Aurelius, ensured that all these matters were carried out according to the decemvirs' instructions. The hymn was composed by Publius Licinius Tegula, similar to one created in the memories of their ancestors by Livius.

13

All religious scruples were fully removed by expiations; at Locri, too, the affair of the sacrilege had been thoroughly investigated by Quintus Minucius, and the money replaced in the treasury out of the effects of the guilty. When the consuls wished to set out to their provinces, a number of private persons, to whom the third payment became due that year, of the money which they had lent to the public in the consulate of Marcus Valerius and Marcus Claudius, applied to the senate. The consuls, however, declared that the treasury being scarcely sufficient for the exigencies of a new war, in which a great fleet and great armies must be employed, there were no means of paying them at present. The senate could not stand against them when they complained, that "if the state intended to use, for the purpose of the Macedonian war, the money which had been lent for the Punic war, as one war constantly arose after another, what would be the issue, but that, in return for their generosity, their property would be confiscated as for some crime?" The demands of the private creditors being equitable, and the state being in no capacity of discharging the debt, they decreed a middle course between equity and convenience; resolving that "whereas many of them mentioned that lands were frequently exposed to sale, and that they themselves wished to become purchasers, they should, therefore, have liberty to purchase any belonging to the public, and which lay within fifty miles of the city. That the consuls should make a valuation of these, and impose on each acre one as, as an acknowledgment that the land was the property of the public, in order that, when the people should become able to pay, if any one chose rather to have the money than the land, he might restore it." The private creditors accepted the terms with joy; and that land was called Trientius and Tabulius, because it was given in lieu of the third part of their money.

All religious concerns were completely resolved through atonements; at Locri, the issue of sacrilege had been thoroughly examined by Quintus Minucius, and the money had been restored to the treasury from the assets of the guilty parties. When the consuls were ready to head to their provinces, several private citizens, who were due a third payment that year for the money they had lent to the state during the consulate of Marcus Valerius and Marcus Claudius, approached the senate. However, the consuls stated that the treasury was barely enough to meet the demands of a new war, which required a large fleet and army, so they couldn't pay them at that moment. The senate struggled to oppose them when the private creditors argued that "if the state planned to use the money borrowed for the Punic war to fund the Macedonian war, since wars kept coming one after another, the result would be that, in return for their generosity, their property would be confiscated as if they had committed a crime." Given that the private creditors' demands were fair, and the state was unable to pay the debt, they decided on a compromise between fairness and practicality; resolving that "since many of them noted that lands were often up for sale, and that they wished to buy them, they should be allowed to purchase any public land within fifty miles of the city. The consuls should assess these lands and charge one as per acre as a recognition that the land belonged to the public, so that when the people were able to pay, anyone who preferred cash over land could return it." The private creditors happily accepted the terms; the land was referred to as Trientius and Tabulius since it was provided in place of a third of their money.

14

Publius Sulpicius, after making his vows in the Capitol, set out robed from the city with his lictors, and arrived at Brundusium; where, having formed into legions the veteran soldiers of the African army who were willing to follow him, and chosen his ships out of the fleet of the late consul, Cornelius, he crossed and arrived in Macedonia the day after he had set sail from Brundusium. There he was met by ambassadors from the Athenians, entreating him to relieve them from the siege. Immediately, Caius Claudius Centho was despatched to Athens, with twenty ships of war, and a thousand of land forces. For it was not the king himself who carried on the siege of Athens; he was at that time besieging Abydus, after having tried his strength in naval contests against Attalus, and against the Rhodians, without success in either engagement. But, besides the natural presumptuousness of his temper, he acquired confidence from a treaty which he had formed with Antiochus, king of Syria, in which they had divided the wealth of Egypt between them; on which, on hearing of the death of Ptolemy, they were both intent. The Athenians now had entangled themselves in a war with Philip on too trifling an occasion, and at a time when they retained nothing of their former condition but their pride. During the celebration of the mysteries, two young men of Acarnania, who were not initiated, unapprized of its being an offence against religion, entered the temple of Ceres along with the rest of the crowd: their discourse readily betrayed them, by their asking some absurd questions; whereupon, being carried before the presidents of the temple, although it was evident that they went in through mistake, yet they were put to death, as if for a heinous crime. The Acarnanian nation made complaint to Philip of this barbarous and hostile act, and prevailed on him to grant them some aid of Macedonian soldiers, and to allow them to make war on the Athenians. At first this army, after ravaging the lands of Attica with fire and sword, retired to Acarnania with booty of all kinds. This was the first provocation to hostilities. The Athenians afterwards, on their side, entered into a regular war, and proclaimed it by order of the state. For king Attalus and the Rhodians, having come to Aegina in pursuit of Philip, who was retiring to Macedonia, the king crossed over to Piraeus, for the purpose of renewing and confirming his alliance with the Athenians. On entering the city, the whole inhabitants received him, pouring forth with their wives and children to meet him; the priests, with their emblems of religion; and in a manner the gods themselves, called forth from their abodes.

Publius Sulpicius, after making his vows in the Capitol, left the city dressed in his formal robes, accompanied by his lictors, and arrived at Brundusium. There, he organized the veteran soldiers from the African army who were willing to follow him into legions and selected his ships from the fleet of the late consul, Cornelius. He set sail and reached Macedonia the day after leaving Brundusium. Upon his arrival, he was met by ambassadors from Athens, pleading for help against their siege. Immediately, Caius Claudius Centho was sent to Athens with twenty warships and a thousand ground troops. It wasn’t the king himself who was besieging Athens; he was currently laying siege to Abydus and had faced naval battles against Attalus and the Rhodians, failing in both. Besides his naturally arrogant personality, he gained confidence from a treaty with Antiochus, the king of Syria, where they divided the riches of Egypt between them, both eager upon hearing of Ptolemy's death. The Athenians had now embroiled themselves in a war with Philip over a trivial matter, holding onto nothing from their former glory except for their pride. During the mysteries celebration, two young men from Acarnania, not initiated and unaware they were committing a religious offense, entered the temple of Ceres with the crowd. Their foolish questions revealed their ignorance, and being brought before the temple's leaders, even though it was clear they entered out of mistake, they were executed as if they had committed a serious crime. The Acarnanian people complained to Philip about this cruel act and persuaded him to provide them with Macedonian soldiers and allow them to wage war against the Athenians. Initially, this army attacked the lands of Attica, looting and burning before returning to Acarnania with all kinds of spoils. This was the first provocation to hostilities. The Athenians then officially declared war, responding in kind. King Attalus and the Rhodians, having pursued Philip to Aegina as he retreated to Macedonia, crossed over to Piraeus to renew their alliance with the Athenians. Upon entering the city, all the residents came out to greet him, bringing their wives and children; the priests followed with their religious symbols, in a way even the gods seemed to be called forth from their homes.

15

Immediately the people were summoned to an assembly, that the king might treat with them in person on such subjects as he chose; but afterwards it was judged more suitable to his dignity to explain his sentiments in writing, than, being present, to be forced to blush, either at the recital of his favours to the state, or at the immoderate applause of the multitude, which would overwhelm his modesty with acclamations and other signs of approbation. In the letter which he sent, and which was read to the assembly, was contained first, a recapitulation of his acts of kindness to the state, as his ally; then, of the actions which he had performed against Philip; and lastly, an exhortation to "enter immediately on the war; while they had himself, the Rhodians, and the Romans also to assist them;" not omitting to warn them that "if they were backward now, they would hereafter wish in vain for the opportunity which they neglected." They then gave audience to the ambassadors of the Rhodians, to whom they were under a recent obligation for having retaken, and sent home, four of their ships of war, which had been lately seized by the Macedonians. War was determined upon against Philip with universal consent. Unbounded honours were conferred on king Attalus, and then on the Rhodians. At that time, mention was made of adding a tribe, which they were to call Attalus, to the ten ancient tribes; the Rhodian state was presented with a golden crown, as an acknowledgment of its bravery, and the freedom of the city was given to the inhabitants, in like manner as the Rhodians had formerly given it to the Athenians. After this, king Attalus returned to his fleet at Aegina. From Aegina, the Rhodians sailed to Cia, and thence to Rhodes, through the islands, all of which they brought to join in the alliance, except Andros, Paros, and Cythnus, which were held by Macedonian garrisons. Attalus, having sent messengers to Aetolia, and expecting ambassadors from thence, was detained at Aegina for some time in a state of inaction; failing also in his endeavours to excite the Aetolians to arms, for they were rejoiced at having made peace with Philip on any terms. Had Attalus and the Rhodians pressed Philip vigorously, they might have acquired the illustrious title of the deliverers of Greece, but by suffering him to pass over again into Hellespontus, and to strengthen himself by seizing the advantageous posts in Greece, they increased the difficulties of the war, and yielded up to the Romans the glory of having conducted and finished it.

Immediately, the people were called to a meeting so the king could discuss various topics with them directly; however, it was later deemed more dignified for him to express his thoughts in writing rather than to be present and risk feeling embarrassed, whether from recounting his contributions to the state or from the excessive praise of the crowd, which could overwhelm his modesty with cheers and other signs of approval. In his letter, which was read to the assembly, he first summarized his acts of kindness towards the state as their ally, then detailed the actions he had taken against Philip, and finally urged them to "start the war immediately while they had himself, the Rhodians, and the Romans to support them," cautioning that "if they hesitated now, they would regret missing the opportunity later." They then listened to the ambassadors from Rhodes, who had recently helped them by retrieving and returning four of their warships that had been seized by the Macedonians. A unanimous decision was made to go to war against Philip. King Attalus and the Rhodians received immense honors. At that time, there was a proposal to add a new tribe, to be named Attalus, to the ten original tribes; the Rhodian state was awarded a golden crown in recognition of its bravery, and its residents were granted the freedom of the city, just as the Rhodians had once done for the Athenians. Following this, King Attalus returned to his fleet at Aegina. From Aegina, the Rhodians sailed to Cia and then to Rhodes, passing through the islands, and brought almost all of them into the alliance, except for Andros, Paros, and Cythnus, which were occupied by Macedonian garrisons. Attalus, having sent messages to Aetolia and waiting for ambassadors from there, was stuck at Aegina for a while without taking action, also struggling to encourage the Aetolians to take up arms, as they were pleased with their peace agreement with Philip, regardless of the terms. If Attalus and the Rhodians had pressed Philip hard, they might have earned the proud title of the liberators of Greece, but by allowing him to return to Hellespont and strengthen his position by seizing key locations in Greece, they complicated the war and handed the glory of its leadership and resolution to the Romans.

16

Philip acted with a spirit more becoming a king; for, though he had found himself unequal to the forces of Attalus and the Rhodians, yet he was not dismayed, even by the Roman war with which he was threatened. Sending Philocles, one of his generals, with two thousand foot and two hundred horse, to ravage the lands of the Athenians, he gave the command of his fleet to Heraclides, to make for Maronea, and marched thither himself by land, with two thousand foot lightly equipped, and two hundred horse. Maronea he took at the first assault; and afterwards, with a good deal of trouble, got possession of Aenus, which was at last betrayed to him by Ganymede, the lieutenant of Ptolemy. He then seized on other forts, Cypselus, Doriscos, and Serrheus; and, advancing from thence to the Chersonesus, received Elaeus and Alopeconnesus, which were surrendered by the inhabitants. Callipolis also, and Madytos, were given up to him, with several forts of but little consequence. The people of Abydus shut their gates against him, not admitting the ambassadors. This siege detained Philip a long time; and it might have been relieved, had not Attalus and the Rhodians been dilatory. The king sent only three hundred men for a garrison, and the Rhodians one quadrireme from their fleet, although it was lying idle at Tenedos: and afterwards, when the besieged could with difficulty hold out any longer, Attalus, going over in person, did nothing more than show them some hope of relief being near, giving no assistance to these his allies either by land or sea.

Philip acted more like a king; even though he felt outmatched by the forces of Attalus and the Rhodians, he wasn't disheartened by the looming Roman war. He sent Philocles, one of his generals, with two thousand infantry and two hundred cavalry to raid Athenian lands, while he put Heraclides in charge of his fleet to head to Maronea. He then marched there himself overland with two thousand lightly equipped foot soldiers and two hundred cavalry. He captured Maronea on the first attempt and, after some effort, took Aenus, which was eventually betrayed to him by Ganymede, Ptolemy's lieutenant. He then took other forts, including Cypselus, Doriscos, and Serrheus. Moving onward to the Chersonesus, he received Elaeus and Alopeconnesus, which were surrendered by the locals. Callipolis and Madytos also gave in, along with several less significant forts. The people of Abydus locked their gates against him, refusing to let in the ambassadors. This siege kept Philip occupied for a long time; it could have been lifted if Attalus and the Rhodians had acted more quickly. The king only sent three hundred men as a garrison, and the Rhodians contributed just one quadrireme from their fleet, even though it was sitting idle at Tenedos. Later, when the besieged could barely hold on any longer, Attalus came in person but just offered them some false hope of relief without providing any real help either by land or sea.

17

At first the people of Abydus, by means of engines placed along the walls, not only prevented the approaches by land, but annoyed the enemy's ships in their station. Afterwards a part of the wall being thrown down, and the assailants having penetrated by mines to an inner wall, which had been hastily raised to oppose their entrance, they sent ambassadors to the king about the conditions of the surrender of the city. They demanded permission to send away the Rhodian quadrireme, with the crew, and the troops of Attalus in the garrison; and that they themselves might depart from the city, each with one suit of apparel. When Philip's answer afforded no hopes of accommodation, unless they surrendered at discretion, this repudiation of their embassy so exasperated them, at once through indignation and despair, that, seized with the same kind of fury which had possessed the Saguntines, they ordered all the matrons to be shut up in the temple of Diana, and the free-born youths and virgins, and even the infants with their nurses, in the place of exercise; the gold and silver to be carried into the forum; their valuable garments to be put on board the Rhodian ship, and another from Cyzicum, which lay in the harbour; the priests and victims to be brought, and altars to be erected in the midst. There they appointed a select number, who, as soon as they should see the army of their friends cut off in defending the breach, were instantly to slay their wives and children; to throw into the sea the gold, silver, and apparel that was on board the ships, and to set fire to the buildings, public and private: and to the performance of this deed they were bound by an oath, the priests repeating before them the verses of execration. Those who were of an age capable of fighting then swore that they would not leave their ranks alive unless victorious. These, regardful of the gods, (by whom they had sworn,) maintained their ground with such obstinacy, that although the night would soon have put a stop to the fight, yet the king, terrified by their fury, first desisted from the fight. The chief inhabitants, to whom the more shocking part of the plan had been given in charge, seeing that few survived the battle, and that these were exhausted by fatigue and wounds, sent the priests (having their heads bound with the fillets of suppliants) at the dawn of the next day to surrender the city to Philip.

At first, the people of Abydus used engines placed along the walls to not only block land approaches but also to harass the enemy's ships in position. After a section of the wall was taken down and the attackers broke through to an inner wall that had been quickly built to stop them, they sent ambassadors to the king to discuss the terms for surrendering the city. They asked for permission to send away the Rhodian quadrireme with its crew and the troops of Attalus stationed there, and they requested to leave the city with one outfit each. When Philip's response showed no chance of negotiation unless they surrendered completely, this rejection of their envoy angered them greatly, filling them with both outrage and despair. In a kind of frenzy similar to what the Saguntines had experienced, they ordered all the women to be locked up in the temple of Diana, along with the free-born youths, maidens, and even infants with their caregivers, in the gymnasium. They had the gold and silver taken to the forum, their valuable clothing loaded onto the Rhodian ship and another from Cyzicum docked in the harbor, and the priests and sacrificial animals brought forth, with altars built in the center. They chose a select group, who, as soon as they saw their friends' army cut off while defending the breach, were to kill their wives and children; toss the gold, silver, and clothing on the ships into the sea, and set fire to both public and private buildings. They took an oath to do this, with priests reciting curses before them. Those of fighting age then swore that they wouldn’t leave the battlefield alive unless they were victorious. These individuals, mindful of the gods (to whom they had sworn), held their position with such determination that, even though night was about to end the fighting, the king was first to pull back, fearful of their rage. The leading citizens, who had been entrusted with the more shocking part of the plan, recognized that few survived the battle and that those remaining were worn out from fatigue and injuries. The next day at dawn, they sent the priests (their heads bound with supplicant fillets) to surrender the city to Philip.

18

Before the surrender, one of the Roman ambassadors, who had been sent to Alexandria, Marcus Aemilius, being the youngest of them, on the joint resolution of the three, on hearing of the present siege, came to Philip, and complained of his having made war on Attalus and the Rhodians; and particularly that he was then besieging Abydus; and on Philip's saying that he had been forced into the war by Attalus and the Rhodians commencing hostilities against him,--"Did the people of Abydus, too," said he, "commence hostilities against you?" To him, who was unaccustomed to hear truth, this language seemed too arrogant to be used to a king, and he answered,--"Your youth, the beauty of your form, and, above all, the name of Roman, render you too presumptuous. However, my first desire is, that you would observe the treaties, and continue in peace with me; but if you begin an attack, I am, on my part, determined to prove that the kingdom and name of the Macedonians is not less formidable in war than that of the Romans." Having dismissed the ambassador in this manner, Philip got possession of the gold and silver which had been thrown together in a heap, but lost his booty with respect to prisoners: for such violent frenzy had seized the multitude, that, on a sudden, taking up a persuasion that those who had fallen in the battle had been treacherously sacrificed, and upbraiding one another with perjury, especially the priests, who would surrender alive to the enemy those persons whom they themselves had devoted, they all at once ran different ways to put their wives and children to death; and then they put an end to their own lives by every possible method. The king, astonished at their madness, restrained the violence of his soldiers, and said, "that he would allow the people of Abydus three days to die in;" and, during this space, the vanquished perpetrated more deeds of cruelty on themselves than the enraged conquerors would have committed; nor did any one of them come into his hands alive, except such as chains, or some other insuperable restraint, forbade to die. Philip, leaving a garrison in Abydus, returned to his kingdom; and, just when he had been encouraged by the destruction of the people of Abydus to proceed in the war against Rome, as Hannibal had been by the destruction of Saguntum, he was met by couriers, with intelligence that the consul was already in Epirus, and had drawn his land forces to Apollonia, and his fleet to Corcyra, into winter quarters.

Before the surrender, one of the Roman ambassadors, Marcus Aemilius, who was the youngest of the group sent to Alexandria, approached Philip upon hearing about the ongoing siege. He complained about Philip waging war against Attalus and the Rhodians, particularly noting that Philip was besieging Abydus. When Philip responded that he had been forced into the conflict because Attalus and the Rhodians had started hostilities against him, Aemilius retorted, "Did the people of Abydus start hostilities against you, too?" To someone unaccustomed to hearing the truth, this response seemed overly bold toward a king. Philip replied, "Your youth, good looks, and the fact that you’re Roman make you overly presumptuous. My main wish is for you to uphold the treaties and keep the peace with me. But if you launch an attack, I will show you that the kingdom and name of the Macedonians are just as fierce in battle as that of the Romans." After sending the ambassador away, Philip seized the gold and silver that had been gathered but lost his potential prisoners: the madness of the crowd had driven them to a sudden belief that those who died in battle were betrayed. They accused each other of treachery, especially the priests, who had devoted those individuals to death and would have surrendered them alive to the enemy. In a frenzy, they scattered to kill their wives and children and then ended their own lives by every means possible. The king, taken aback by their insanity, restrained his soldiers and declared that he would give the people of Abydus three days to die. During this time, the defeated committed more atrocities against themselves than the angry conquerors would have committed. None were taken alive, except those who were restrained by chains or other means. Philip, leaving a garrison in Abydus, returned to his kingdom. Just as he was inspired by the destruction of the people of Abydus to continue his war against Rome, similar to how Hannibal was inspired by the destruction of Saguntum, he received word from couriers that the consul was already in Epirus, having stationed his land forces at Apollonia and his fleet at Corcyra for the winter.

19

In the mean time, the ambassadors who had been sent into Africa, on the affair of Hamilcar, the leader of the Gallic army, received from the Carthaginians this answer: that "it was not in their power to do more than to inflict on him the punishment of exile, and to confiscate his effects; that they had delivered up all the deserters and fugitives, whom, on a diligent inquiry, they had been able to discover, and would send ambassadors to Rome, to satisfy the senate on that head." They sent two hundred thousand measures of wheat to Rome, and the same quantity to the army in Macedonia. From thence the ambassadors proceeded into Numidia, to the king; delivered to Masinissa the presents and the message according to their instructions, and out of two thousand Numidian horsemen, which he offered, accepted one thousand. Masinissa superintended in person the embarkation of these, and sent them, with two hundred thousand measures of wheat, and the same quantity of barley, into Macedonia. Their third commission was with Vermina. He advanced to meet them as far as the utmost limits of his kingdom, and left it to themselves to prescribe such conditions of peace as they thought proper, declaring, that "he should consider any peace with the Roman people as just and advantageous." The terms were then settled, and he was ordered to send ambassadors to Rome to procure a ratification of the treaty.

In the meantime, the ambassadors sent to Africa regarding Hamilcar, the leader of the Gallic army, received this response from the Carthaginians: "We can only exile him and confiscate his property; we’ve handed over all the deserters and fugitives we could find through diligent inquiry, and we will send ambassadors to Rome to update the senate on this matter." They sent 200,000 measures of wheat to Rome and the same amount to the army in Macedonia. From there, the ambassadors went to Numidia to meet the king, delivering presents and messages as instructed, and accepted 1,000 out of the 2,000 Numidian horsemen he offered. Masinissa personally oversaw the embarkation of these troops and sent them, along with 200,000 measures of wheat and the same quantity of barley, to Macedonia. Their third task was with Vermina. He came to meet them at the farthest edge of his kingdom and allowed them to propose any peace terms they deemed fit, stating that "he would view any peace with the Roman people as just and beneficial." The terms were agreed upon, and he was instructed to send ambassadors to Rome to secure the treaty's ratification.

20

About the same time, Lucius Cornelius Lentulus, proconsul, came home from Spain; and having laid before the senate an account of his brave and successful conduct, during the course of many years, demanded that he might be allowed to enter the city in triumph. The senate gave their opinion that "his services were, indeed, deserving of a triumph; but that they had no precedent left them by their ancestors of any person enjoying a triumph, who had not performed the service either of dictator, consul, or praetor; that he had held the province of Spain in quality of proconsul, and not of consul, or praetor." They determined, however, that he might enter the city in ovation. Against this, Tiberius Sempronius Longus, tribune of the people, protested, alleging, that such proceedings would be no more in accordance with the custom of their ancestors, or with any precedent, than the other; but, overcome at length by the unanimous desire of the senate, the tribune withdrew his opposition, and Lucius Lentulus entered the city in ovation. He carried to the treasury forty-four thousand pounds weight of silver, and two thousand four hundred pounds weight of gold. To each of the soldiers he distributed, of the spoil, one hundred and twenty asses.[2]

Around the same time, Lucius Cornelius Lentulus, the proconsul, returned from Spain. After presenting the senate with a summary of his brave and successful actions over the years, he asked to be allowed to enter the city in triumph. The senate agreed that his achievements were worthy of a triumph, but noted that there was no precedent from their ancestors for anyone receiving a triumph who hadn’t served as dictator, consul, or praetor. Lentulus had served as proconsul in Spain, not as a consul or praetor. They decided, however, that he could enter the city in an ovation. Tiberius Sempronius Longus, the tribune of the people, opposed this, arguing that such actions didn’t align with their ancestors’ customs or any precedent. Eventually, though, swayed by the unanimous desire of the senate, the tribune withdrew his opposition, and Lucius Lentulus entered the city in ovation. He brought to the treasury forty-four thousand pounds of silver and two thousand four hundred pounds of gold. He distributed one hundred and twenty asses of the spoils to each soldier.[2]

21

The consular army had, by this time, been conducted from Arretium to Ariminum, and the five thousand Latin confederates had crossed from Gaul into Etruria. Lucius Furius, therefore, advanced from Ariminum, by forced marches, against the Gauls, who were then besieging Cremona, and pitched his camp at the distance of one mile and a half from the enemy. Furius had an opportunity of performing a splendid exploit, had he, without halting, led his troops directly to attack their camp; scattered hither and thither, they were wandering through the country; and the guard, which they had left, was not sufficiently strong; but he was apprehensive that his men were too much fatigued by their hasty march. The Gauls, recalled from the fields by the shouts of their party, returned to the camp without seizing the booty within their reach, and, next day, marched out to offer battle. The Roman did not decline the combat, but had scarcely time to draw up his forces, so rapidly did the enemy advance to the fight. The right brigade (for he had the troops of the allies divided into brigades) was placed in the first line, the two Roman legions in reserve. Marcus Furius was at the head of the right brigade, Marcus Caecilius of the legions, and Lucius Valerius Flaccus of the cavalry; these were all lieutenant-generals. Two other lieutenant-generals, Cneius Laetorius and Publius Titinnius, the praetor kept near himself, that, with their assistance, he might observe and take proper measures against all sudden attempts of the enemy. At first, the Gauls, bending their whole force to one point, were in hopes of being able to overwhelm, and trample under foot, the right brigade, which was in the van; but not succeeding, they endeavoured to turn round the flanks, and to surround their enemy's line, which, considering the multitude of their forces, and the small number of the others, seemed easy to be done. On observing this, the praetor, in order to extend his own line, brought up the two legions from the reserve, and placed them on the right and left of the brigade which was engaged in the van; vowing a temple to Jupiter, if he should rout the enemy on that day. To Lucius Valerius he gave orders, to make the horsemen of the two legions on one flank, and the cavalry of the allies on the other, charge the wings of the enemy, and not suffer them to come round to his rear. At the same time, observing that the centre of the line of the Gauls was weakened, from having extended the wings, he directed his men to make an attack there in close order, and to break through their ranks. The wings were routed by the cavalry, and, at the same time, the centre by the foot; and suddenly, being worsted in all parts with great slaughter, the Gauls turned their backs, and fled to their camp in hurry and confusion. The cavalry pursued them as they fled; and the legions, coming up in a short time after, assaulted the camp, from whence there did not escape so many as six thousand men. There were slain and taken above thirty-five thousand, with seventy standards, and above two hundred Gallic waggons laden with much booty. Hamilcar, the Carthaginian general, fell in that battle, and three distinguished generals of the Gauls. The prisoners taken at Placentia, to the number of two thousand freemen, were restored to the colony.

The consular army had, by this time, moved from Arretium to Ariminum, and the five thousand Latin allies had crossed from Gaul into Etruria. Lucius Furius then advanced from Ariminum, making forced marches toward the Gauls, who were besieging Cremona, and set up his camp about a mile and a half from the enemy. Furius had the chance to perform a remarkable feat; if he had led his troops straight to attack their camp without stopping, they would have caught the enemy, who were scattered throughout the countryside, off guard, as the guard they had left was not strong enough. However, he worried that his men were too exhausted from their rapid march. The Gauls, called back by the shouts of their group, returned to the camp without taking the loot that was within reach, and the next day, they marched out to face them. The Romans did not shy away from the fight but had barely enough time to position their forces, as the enemy advanced quickly. The right brigade (the troops of the allies were divided into brigades) was placed in the front line, with the two Roman legions held in reserve. Marcus Furius led the right brigade, Marcus Caecilius commanded the legions, and Lucius Valerius Flaccus led the cavalry; all three were lieutenant-generals. Two other lieutenant-generals, Cneius Laetorius and Publius Titinnius, stayed close to the praetor so he could monitor and react to any sudden attacks from the enemy. Initially, the Gauls concentrated their entire force at one point, hoping to crush and overpower the right brigade at the front; but after failing, they tried to flank and encircle the Roman line, which seemed feasible given their numbers compared to the Romans. Noticing this, the praetor extended his line by bringing up the two legions from reserve to support the engaged brigade at the front, promising to dedicate a temple to Jupiter if he could defeat the enemy that day. He ordered Lucius Valerius to have the cavalry from the two legions attack one flank and the allied cavalry attack the other, preventing the enemy from encircling them. At the same time, seeing that the center of the Gallic line was weakened because they had spread their wings, he directed his men to launch a close-order attack there and break through their ranks. The cavalry routed the wings, while the infantry overwhelmed the center; suddenly, faced with heavy losses on all sides, the Gauls turned and fled in panic back to their camp. The cavalry pursued them; the legions soon followed, assaulting the camp, from which fewer than six thousand men escaped. Over thirty-five thousand were killed or captured, along with seventy standards and more than two hundred Gallic wagons filled with loot. Hamilcar, the Carthaginian general, died in that battle, along with three notable Gallic generals. The two thousand freemen captured at Placentia were returned to the colony.

22

This was an important victory, and caused great joy at Rome. On receipt of the praetor's letter, a supplication for three days was decreed. In that battle, there fell of the Romans and allies two thousand, most of them in the right brigade, against which, in the first onset, the most violent efforts of the enemy had been directed. Although the praetor had brought the war almost to a conclusion, yet the consul, Cneius Aurelius, having finished the business which was necessary to be done at Rome, set out for Gaul, and received the victorious army from the praetor. The other consul, arriving in his province towards the end of autumn, passed the winter in the neighbourhood of Apollonia. Caius Claudius, and the Roman triremes which had been sent to Athens from the fleet that was laid up at Corcyra, as was mentioned above, arriving at Piraeeus, greatly revived the hopes of their allies, who were beginning to give way to despair. For not only did those inroads by land cease, which used to be made from Corinth through Megara, but the ships of the pirates from Chalcis, who had been accustomed to infest both the Athenian sea and coast, were afraid not only to venture round the promontory of Sunium, but even to trust themselves out of the straits of the Euripus. In addition to these came three quadriremes from Rhodes, the Athenians having three open ships, which they had equipped for the protection of their lands on the coast. While Claudius thought, that if he were able with his fleet to give security to the Athenians it was as much as could be expected at present, a fortunate opportunity was thrown in his way of accomplishing a much more important enterprise.

This was a significant victory that brought great joy to Rome. After receiving the praetor's letter, a three-day celebration was ordered. In that battle, two thousand Romans and allies fell, mostly from the right brigade, which faced the brunt of the enemy's initial assault. Although the praetor had nearly wrapped up the war, consul Cneius Aurelius, after completing necessary tasks in Rome, headed for Gaul to take over the victorious army from the praetor. The other consul arrived in his province toward the end of autumn and spent the winter near Apollonia. Caius Claudius and the Roman triremes sent to Athens from the fleet at Corcyra, as mentioned earlier, reached Piraeus, greatly boosting the morale of their allies, who were starting to lose hope. Not only did the land raids from Corinth through Megara stop, but the pirate ships from Chalcis, which used to plague the Athenian sea and coast, were too scared to pass around the promontory of Sunium or even venture out of the Euripus strait. Additionally, three quadriremes from Rhodes arrived, while the Athenians had three open ships ready to protect their coastal lands. Claudius believed that if he could secure the Athenians with his fleet, that would be a considerable achievement for now, but then a lucky opportunity arose for him to undertake a much more significant mission.

23

Some exiles driven from Chalcis, by ill treatment received from the king's party, brought intelligence, that the place might be taken without even a contest; for that both the Macedonians, being under no immediate apprehension from an enemy, were straying idly about the country; and that the townsmen, depending on the Macedonian garrison, neglected the guard of the city. Claudius, on this authority, set out and though he arrived at Sunium early enough to have sailed forward to the entrance of the strait of Euboea, yet fearing that, on doubling the promontory, he might be descried by the enemy, he lay by with the fleet until night. As soon as it grew dark he began to move, and, favoured by a calm, arrived at Chalcis a little before day; and then, approaching the city, on a side where it was thinly inhabited, with a small party of soldiers, and by means of scaling ladders, he got possession of the nearest tower, and the wall on each side; the guards being asleep in some places, and in others no one being on the watch. Thence they advanced to the more populous parts of the town, and having slain the sentinels, and broke open a gate, they gave an entrance to the main body of the troops. These immediately spread themselves throughout the whole city, and increased the tumult by setting fire to the buildings round the forum, by which means both the granaries belonging to the king, and his armoury, with a vast store of machines and engines, were reduced to ashes. Then commenced a general slaughter of those who fled, as well as of those who made resistance; and after having either put to the sword or driven out every one who was of an age fit to bear arms, (Sopater also, the Acarnanian, who commanded the garrison, being slain,) they first collected all the spoils in the forum, and then carried it on board the ships. The prison, too, was forced open by the Rhodians, and those prisoners whom Philip had shut up there, as in the safest custody, were set at liberty. They next pulled down and mutilated the statues of the king; and then, on a signal being given for a retreat, re-embarked and returned to Piraeeus, from whence they had set out. If there had been so large a force of Roman soldiers that Chalcis might have been retained and the protection of Athens not neglected, Chalcis and Euripus might have been taken from the king;--a most important advantage at the commencement of the war. For as the pass of Thermopylae is the principal barrier of Greece by land, so is the strait of the Euripus by sea.

Some exiles, forced out of Chalcis due to mistreatment from the king's supporters, reported that the city could be easily taken without a fight. They claimed that the Macedonians were wandering around the countryside without any concern about an enemy, and that the townspeople, relying on the Macedonian garrison, were neglecting the city's defenses. Based on this information, Claudius set out. Although he reached Sunium early enough to sail directly to the entrance of the Euboean strait, he was worried that rounding the promontory might expose him to the enemy, so he waited with the fleet until nightfall. Once it got dark, he began to move and, benefiting from calm seas, arrived at Chalcis just before dawn. Moving towards the city on a less populated side, he and a small group of soldiers used scaling ladders to capture the nearest tower and the walls on either side, with the guards either asleep or absent in other spots. They then advanced into the busier areas of the town, killed the sentinels, and broke open a gate to let in the main contingent of troops. These soldiers quickly spread throughout the city, creating chaos by setting fire to the buildings around the forum, which destroyed both the king's granaries and his armory filled with weapons and machinery. Then a general massacre began, targeting those who tried to flee as well as those who resisted; everyone of fighting age was killed or driven out, including Sopater the Acarnanian, who was in charge of the garrison. They gathered all the spoils in the forum before loading them onto the ships. The Rhodians also broke open the prison, freeing the prisoners that Philip had securely locked up there. They then tore down and defaced the king's statues. After a signal was given for retreat, they re-embarked and returned to Piraeus, from where they had originally set out. If there had been a significant number of Roman soldiers to hold Chalcis and ensure Athens was protected, Chalcis and Euripus could have been taken from the king—a major advantage at the start of the war. Just as Thermopylae serves as a key land barrier of Greece, the Euripus strait is the main sea barrier.

24

Philip was then at Demetrias, and as soon as the news arrived there of the calamity which had befallen the city of his allies, although it was too late to carry assistance to those who were already ruined, yet anxious to accomplish what was next to assistance, revenge, he set out instantly with five thousand foot lightly equipped, and three hundred horse. With a speed almost equal to that of racing, he hastened to Chalcis, not doubting but that he should be able to surprise the Romans. Being disappointed in this expectation, and having arrived, with no other result than a melancholy view of the smoking ruins of that friendly city, (so few being left, that they were scarcely sufficient to bury those who had fallen in the conflict,) with the same rapid haste which he had used in coming, he crossed the Euripus by the bridge, and led his troops through Boeotia to Athens, in hopes that a similar issue would correspond to a similar attempt. And it would have corresponded, had not a scout, (one of those whom the Greeks call day-runners,[3] because they run through a journey of great length in one day,) descrying from his post of observation the king's army in its march, set out at midnight and arrived before them at Athens. The same sleep, and the same negligence, prevailed there which had proved the ruin of Chalcis a few days before. Roused, however, by the alarming intelligence, the praetor of the Athenians, and Dioxippus, commander of a cohort of mercenary auxiliaries, called the soldiers together in the forum, and ordered the trumpets to sound an alarm from the citadel, that all might be informed of the approach of the enemy. On which the people ran from all quarters to the gates, and afterwards to the walls. In a few hours after, and still some time before day, Philip approached the city, and observing a great number of lights, and hearing the noise of the men hurrying to and fro, as usual on such an alarm, he halted his troops, and ordered them to sit down and take some rest; resolving to use open force, since his stratagem had not succeeded. Accordingly he advanced on the side of Dipylos. This gate, being situated in the principal approach of the city, is somewhat larger and wider than the rest. Both within and without the streets are wide, so that the townsmen could form their troops from the forum to the gate, while on the outside a road of about a mile in length, leading to the school of the academy, afforded open room to the foot and horse of the enemy. The Athenians, who had formed their troops within the gate, marched out with Attalus's garrison, and the cohort of Dioxippus, along that road. Which, when Philip observed, thinking that he had the enemy in his power, and was now about to sate himself with their long wished for destruction, (being more incensed against them than any of the Grecian states,) he exhorted his men to keep their eyes on him during the fight, and to take notice, that wherever the king was, there the standards and the army ought to be. He then spurred on his horse against the enemy, animated not only with resentment, but with a desire of gaining honour, for he reckoned it a glorious thing to be beheld fighting from the walls, which were filled with an immense multitude, for the purpose of witnessing the engagement. Advancing far before the line, and with a small body of horse, rushing into the midst of the enemy, he inspired his men with great ardour, and the Athenians equally with terror. Having wounded many with his own hand, both in close fight and with missive weapons, and driven them back within the gate, he still pursued them closely; and having made greater slaughter among them while embarrassed in the narrow pass, rash as the attempt was, he yet had an unmolested retreat, because those who were in the towers withheld their weapons lest they should hit their friends, who were mingled in confusion among their enemies. The Athenians, after this, confining their troops within the walls, Philip sounded a retreat, and pitched his camp at Cynosarges, a temple of Hercules, and a school surrounded by a grove. But Cynosarges, and Lycaeum, and whatever was sacred or pleasant in the neighbourhood of the city, he burned to the ground, and levelled not only the houses, but sepulchres, nor was any thing either in divine or human possession preserved amidst the violence of his rage.

Philip was at Demetrias when he heard about the disaster that had struck his allies’ city. Even though it was too late to help those who were already lost, he wanted to achieve what was almost as good—revenge. He set off right away with five thousand lightly equipped infantry and three hundred cavalry. He quickly rushed to Chalcis, believing he could catch the Romans off guard. When he arrived, he was disappointed to find only the sad sight of the smoking ruins of that allied city, with so few survivors that they could barely bury the fallen. With the same speed he had used to arrive, he crossed the Euripus by the bridge and led his troops through Boeotia to Athens, hoping for a better outcome this time. It might have gone as planned if it weren't for a scout—one of those the Greeks call day-runners, because they cover great distances in a single day—who spotted the king's army on the march and hurried to Athens at midnight to warn them. The same complacency and lack of vigilance that had led to Chalcis's downfall a few days earlier was evident in Athens. However, alerted by the troubling news, the Athenians’ praetor and Dioxippus, commander of a cohort of mercenaries, gathered the soldiers in the forum and ordered the trumpets to sound an alarm from the citadel to inform everyone of the enemy's approach. People rushed from all around to the gates and then to the walls. A few hours later, still before daybreak, Philip neared the city. Noticing many lights and hearing the commotion of men moving about due to the alarm, he halted his troops and told them to rest, deciding to use direct force since his surprise tactic had failed. He advanced toward the Dipylos gate, which is the main entrance to the city and larger than the others. The streets inside and out were wide, allowing the townspeople to organize their troops from the forum to the gate, while a mile-long road leading to the academy provided clear space for foot soldiers and cavalry. The Athenians, having arranged their forces behind the gate, marched out with the garrison from Attalus and Dioxippus's cohort along that road. When Philip saw this, thinking he had the enemy at his mercy and could finally achieve his long-desired victory—having a particular grudge against them more than any other Greek city—he urged his men to keep their eyes on him during the battle and to remember that wherever the king was, that is where the standards and army should be. He then spurred his horse toward the enemy, motivated not only by anger but also by the desire for glory, as he considered it honorable to be seen fighting from the walls filled with crowds who had come to witness the battle. Leading his troops, he charged into the midst of the enemy, igniting enthusiasm among his men and terror among the Athenians. He personally wounded many with both close combat and thrown weapons, driving them back behind the gate. Continuing his pursuit, he caused even greater chaos and slaughter in the narrow passages, and despite the recklessness of his actions, he managed to retreat safely because those stationed in the towers held back their weapons for fear of hitting their own men who were mixed with the enemy. Afterward, the Athenians kept their troops inside the walls, and Philip sounded a retreat, setting up camp at Cynosarges, near a temple of Hercules surrounded by a grove. However, he burned down Cynosarges, Lycaeum, and all that was sacred or enjoyable near the city, demolishing not only the buildings but also the tombs, sparing nothing that was either divine or human from his wrath.

25

Next day, the gates having at first been shut, and afterwards suddenly thrown open, in consequence of a body of Attalus's troops from Aegina, and the Romans from Piraeeus, having entered the city, the king removed his camp to the distance of about three miles. From thence he proceeded to Eleusis, in hopes of surprising the temple, and a fort which overlooks and surrounds it; but, finding that the watches had not been neglected, and that the fleet was coming from Piraeeus to support them, he laid aside the design, and led his troops, first to Megara, and then to Corinth; where, on hearing that the council of the Achaeans was then sitting at Argos, he went and joined the assembly, unexpected by the Achaeans. They were at the time consulting about a war against Nabis, tyrant of the Lacedaemonians; who, on the command being transferred from Philopoemen to Cycliades, a general by no means his equal, perceiving that the confederates of the Achaeans were falling off, had renewed the war, was ravaging the territories of his neighbours, and had become formidable even to the cities. While they were deliberating what number of men should be raised out of each of the states to oppose this enemy, Philip promised that he would relieve them of that care, as far as concerned Nabis and the Lacedaemonians; and that he would not only secure the lands of their allies from devastation, but transfer the whole terror of the war on Laconia itself, by leading his army thither instantly. This discourse being received with general approbation, he added,--"It is but reasonable, however, that while I am employed in protecting your property by my arms, my own should not be deprived of protection; therefore, if you think proper, provide such a number of troops as will be sufficient to secure Orcus, Chalcis, and Corinth; that my affairs being in a state of safety behind me, I may without anxiety make war on Nabis and the Lacedaemonians." The Achaeans were not ignorant of the tendency of this so kind promise, and of his proffered assistance against the Lacedaemonians; that his purpose was to draw the Achaean youth out of Peloponnesus as hostages, in order to implicate the nation in a war with the Romans. Cycliades, the Achaean praetor, thinking that it was irrelevant to develope the matter by argument, said nothing more than that it was not allowable, according to the laws of the Achaeans, to take any matters into consideration except those on which they had been called together: and the decree for levying an army against Nabis being passed, he dismissed the assembly, after having presided in it with much resolution and public spirit, and until that day having been reckoned among the partisans of the king. Philip, disappointed in a high expectation, after having collected a few voluntary soldiers, returned to Corinth, and from thence into the territories of Athens.

The next day, after the gates were initially closed and then suddenly thrown open because a group of Attalus's troops from Aegina and the Romans from Piraeus had entered the city, the king moved his camp about three miles away. From there, he headed to Eleusis, hoping to catch the temple and a nearby fort by surprise. However, he realized the guards were alert and that the fleet was coming from Piraeus to support them, so he abandoned that plan and took his troops first to Megara and then to Corinth. When he learned that the Achaean council was meeting in Argos, he decided to join the assembly unexpectedly. They were discussing a war against Nabis, the tyrant of the Lacedaemonians, who, after the command shifted from Philopoemen to Cycliades—who was not nearly as capable—had noticed that the Achaean allies were losing support. He had reignited the war, was devastating the neighboring territories, and had become a threat even to the cities. While they debated how many troops each state should raise to counter this enemy, Philip offered to take that burden off their shoulders concerning Nabis and the Lacedaemonians. He promised not only to protect their allies' lands from destruction but also to redirect the war's threat onto Laconia itself by leading his army there immediately. This offer was well received, and he added, "However, it's only fair that while I am defending your property with my forces, my own should also have protection. So, if you agree, gather enough troops to secure Orcus, Chalcis, and Corinth, so my affairs are safe behind me, allowing me to wage war against Nabis and the Lacedaemonians without worry." The Achaeans were aware of the true intent behind this seemingly generous offer and his assistance against the Lacedaemonians; he aimed to take Achaean youth from Peloponnesus as hostages, which would drag them into conflict with the Romans. Cycliades, the Achaean praetor, believing it was not the time for long arguments, simply stated that it was against Achaean law to consider matters other than those for which they had gathered. After passing the decree to raise an army against Nabis, he closed the assembly, having led it with great resolve and public spirit, despite previously being viewed as a supporter of the king. Philip, disappointed with his high expectations and after gathering a few volunteers, returned to Corinth and then to the territories of Athens.

26

In those days in which Philip was in Achaia, Philocles, one of the king's generals, marching from Euboea with two thousand Thracians and Macedonians, in order to lay waste the territories of the Athenians, crossed the forest of Cithaeron opposite to Eleusis. Despatching half of his troops, make depredations in all parts of the country, he himself lay concealed with the remainder in a place convenient for an ambush; in order that, if any attack should be made from the fort at Eleusis on his men employed in plundering, he might suddenly fall upon the enemy unawares, and while they were in disorder. His stratagem did not escape discovery: wherefore calling back the soldiers, who had gone different ways in pursuit of booty, and drawing them up in order, he advanced to assault the fort at Eleusis; but being repulsed from thence with many wounds, he formed a junction with Philip on his return from Achaia. The storming of this fort was also attempted by the king in person: but the Roman ships coming from Piraeeus, and a body of forces thrown into the fort, compelled him to relinquish the design. On this the king, dividing his army, sent Philocles with one part to Athens, and went himself with the other to Piraeeus; that, while his general, by advancing to the walls and threatening an assault, might keep the Athenians within the city, he might be able to make himself master of the harbour, when left with only a slight garrison. But he found the attack of Piraeeus no less difficult than that of Eleusis, the same persons for the most part acting in its defence. He therefore hastily led his troops to Athens, and being repulsed by a sudden sally of both foot and horse, who engaged him in the narrow ground, enclosed by the half-ruined wall, which, with two arms, joins Piraeus to Athens, he desisted from the assault of the city, and, dividing his forces again with Philocles, set out to complete the devastation of the country. As, in his former ravages, he had employed himself in levelling the sepulchres round the city, so now, not to leave any thing unviolated, he ordered the temples of the gods, of which they had one consecrated in every village, to be demolished and burned. The country of Attica afforded ample matter for the exercise of this barbarous rage: being highly embellished with works of that kind, having plenty of indigenous marble, and abounding with artists of exquisite ingenuity. Nor was he satisfied with merely destroying the temples themselves, and overthrowing the images, but he ordered even the stones to be broken, lest, remaining whole, they should give stateliness to the ruins; and then, his rage not being satiated, but no object remaining on which it could be exercised, he retired from the country of the enemy into Boeotia, without having performed in Greece any thing else worth mention.

In those days when Philip was in Achaia, Philocles, one of the king's generals, marched from Euboea with two thousand Thracians and Macedonians to raid Athenian territories, crossing the forest of Cithaeron near Eleusis. He sent half of his troops to pillage various parts of the land while he hid with the rest in an area suitable for an ambush. His plan was to launch a surprise attack if anyone from the fort at Eleusis attempted to confront his men in the act of looting, hoping to catch the enemy off guard and disorganized. However, his scheme was discovered. Therefore, he summoned back the soldiers who had scattered for loot and lined them up, moving forward to attack the fort at Eleusis. He was, however, repelled and suffered many injuries, eventually joining Philip on his return from Achaia. The king also tried to storm this fort himself, but the Roman ships coming from Piraeus and troops sent to defend the fort forced him to abandon the plan. As a result, the king split his army, sending Philocles with one part to Athens while he took the other to Piraeus. His idea was that while his general threatened an assault at the city walls to keep the Athenians occupied, he could take control of the harbor when it was left with just a light garrison. However, he found the attack on Piraeus just as challenging as that on Eleusis, with largely the same defenders. He quickly redirected his troops to Athens but was driven back by a sudden attack from both infantry and cavalry, who engaged him in the narrow area surrounded by the half-ruined wall connecting Piraeus to Athens. Consequently, he abandoned the assault on the city and, once again splitting his forces with Philocles, set out to continue ravaging the countryside. Just as he had previously destroyed graves around the city, he now ordered the demolition and burning of the temples dedicated to the gods, of which there was one in every village. The region of Attica provided ample opportunity for this cruel destruction, richly adorned with such structures, abundant in local marble, and filled with skilled artisans. He wasn't satisfied with just destroying the temples and toppling the statues; he also ordered the stones to be broken so they wouldn't contribute to the grandeur of the ruins. With his rage still unsatisfied and nothing else left to destroy, he withdrew from enemy territory into Boeotia, having accomplished little else noteworthy in Greece.

27

The consul, Sulpicius, who was at that time encamped; on the river Apsus, between Apollonia and Dyrrachium, having ordered Lucius Apustius, lieutenant-general, thither, sent him with part of the forces to lay waste the enemy's territory. Apustius, after ravaging the frontiers of Macedonia, and having, at the first assault, taken the forts of Corragos, Gerrunios, and Orgessos, came to Antipatria, a city situated in a narrow gorge; where, at first inviting the leading men to a conference, he endeavoured to entice them to commit themselves to the good faith of the Romans; but finding that from confidence in the size, fortifications, and situation of their city, they paid no regard to his discourse, he attacked the place by force of arms, and took it by assault: then, putting all the young men to death, and giving up the entire spoil to his soldiers, he razed the walls and burned the city. This proceeding spread such terror, that Codrion, a strong and well-fortified town, surrendered to the Romans without a struggle. Leaving a garrison there, he took Ilion by force, a name better known than the town, on account of that of the same name in Asia. As the lieutenant-general was returning to the consul with a great quantity of spoil, Athenagoras, one of the king's generals, falling on his extreme rear, in its passage over a river, threw the hindmost into disorder. On hearing the shouting and tumult, Apustius rode back in full speed, ordered the troops to face about, and drew them up in order, arranging the baggage in the centre. The king's troops could not support the onset of the Roman soldiers, many of them were slain, and more made prisoners. The lieutenant-general, having brought back the army without loss to the consul, was despatched immediately to the fleet.

The consul, Sulpicius, who was then camped by the river Apsus, between Apollonia and Dyrrachium, sent Lucius Apustius, his lieutenant-general, with part of the forces to devastate the enemy's land. After pillaging the borders of Macedonia and capturing the forts of Corragos, Gerrunios, and Orgessos on his first assault, he reached Antipatria, a city situated in a narrow gorge. He initially invited the leading men to meet, trying to persuade them to trust the Romans, but realizing that their confidence in the city's size, defenses, and location made them dismiss his words, he attacked the city by force and captured it. He killed all the young men, gave the spoils to his soldiers, destroyed the walls, and burned the city. This act instilled such fear that Codrion, a strong and well-fortified town, surrendered to the Romans without a fight. After leaving a garrison there, he took Ilion by force, a name better known than the town itself because of the one in Asia. As the lieutenant-general was heading back to the consul with a large amount of loot, Athenagoras, one of the king's generals, launched a surprise attack on his rear as they crossed a river, causing chaos among the rear troops. Hearing the commotion, Apustius quickly rode back, ordered the troops to turn around, and organized them, placing the baggage in the center. The king's forces couldn't withstand the attack from the Roman soldiers; many were killed, and more were captured. The lieutenant-general returned to the consul with his army intact and was immediately dispatched to the fleet.

28

The war commencing thus brilliantly with this successful expedition, several petty kings and princes, neighbours of the Macedonians, came to the Roman camp: Pleuratus, son of Scerdilaedus, and Amynander, king of the Athamanians; and from the Dardanians, Bato, son of Longarus. This Longarus had, in his own quarrel, supported a war against Demetrius, father of Philip. To their offers of aid, the consul answered, that he would make use of the assistance of the Dardanians, and of Pleuratus, when he should lead his troops into Macedonia. To Amynander he allotted the part of exciting the Aetolians to war. To the ambassadors of Attalus, (for they also had come at the same time,) he gave directions that the king should wait at Aegina, where he wintered, for the arrival of the Roman fleet; and when joined by that, he should, as before, harass Philip with attacks by sea. To the Rhodians, also, an embassy was sent, to engage them to contribute their share towards carrying on the war. Nor was Philip, who had by this time arrived in Macedonia, remiss in his preparations for the campaign. He sent his son Perseus, then very young, with part of his forces to block up the pass near Pelagonia, appointing persons out of the number of his friends to direct his inexperienced age. Sciathus and Peparethus, no inconsiderable cities, he demolished, lest they should become a prey and prize to the enemy's fleet; despatching at the same time ambassadors to the Aetolians, lest that restless nation might change sides on the arrival of the Romans.

The war started off with a bang thanks to this successful expedition, and several minor kings and princes, neighbors of the Macedonians, approached the Roman camp: Pleuratus, son of Scerdilaedus, and Amynander, king of the Athamanians; along with Bato, son of Longarus, from the Dardanians. Longarus had previously waged war against Demetrius, the father of Philip, for his own reasons. In response to their offers of support, the consul stated that he would utilize the help of the Dardanians and Pleuratus when he moved his troops into Macedonia. He tasked Amynander with rallying the Aetolians for war. He also instructed the ambassadors from Attalus, who had come at the same time, to tell the king to wait at Aegina, where he was wintering, for the arrival of the Roman fleet; once they joined forces, he should continue to harass Philip with naval attacks as before. The Rhodians were also sent an embassy to encourage them to contribute to the war effort. Meanwhile, Philip, who had now returned to Macedonia, was not idle in his preparations for the campaign. He sent his young son Perseus with part of his troops to block the pass near Pelagonia and appointed trusted friends to guide him in his youth. He destroyed the cities of Sciathus and Peparethus, which were no small towns, to prevent them from falling into enemy hands. At the same time, he sent ambassadors to the Aetolians to ensure that this restless nation wouldn't switch sides when the Romans arrived.

29

The assembly of the Aetolians, which they call Panaetolium, was to meet on a certain day. In order to be present at this, the king's ambassadors hastened their journey, and Lucius Furius Purpureo also arrived, deputed by the consul. Ambassadors from the Athenians, likewise, came to this assembly. The Macedonians were first heard, as with them the latest treaty had been made; and they declared, that as no change of circumstances had occurred, they had nothing new to introduce: for the same reasons which had induced them to make peace with Philip, after experiencing the unprofitableness of an alliance with the Romans, should engage them to preserve it now that it was established. "Do you rather choose," said one of the ambassadors, "to imitate the inconsistency, or levity, shall I call it, of the Romans, who ordered this answer to be given to your ambassadors at Rome: 'Why, Aetolians, do you apply to us, when, without our approbation, you have made peace with Philip?' Yet these same people now require that you should, in conjunction with them, wage war against Philip. Formerly, too, they pretended that they took arms on your account, and in your defence against Philip: now they do not allow you to continue at peace with him. To assist Messana, they first embarked for Sicily; and a second time, that they might redeem Syracuse to freedom when oppressed by the Carthaginians. Both Messana and Syracuse, and all Sicily, they hold in their own possession, and have reduced it into a tributary province under their axes and rods. You imagine, perhaps, that in the same manner as you hold an assembly at Naupactus, according to your own laws, under magistrates created by yourselves, at liberty to choose allies and enemies, and to have peace or war at your own option, so the assembly of the states of Sicily is summoned, to Syracuse, or Messana, or Lilybaeum. No, a Roman praetor presides at the meeting; summoned by his command they assemble; they behold him, attended by his lictors seated on a lofty throne, issuing his haughty edicts. His rods are ready for their backs, his axes for their necks, and every year they are allotted a different master. Neither ought they nor can they, wonder at this, when they see all the cities of Italy bending under the same yoke,--Rhegium, Tarentum Capua, not to mention those in their own neighbourhood, out of the ruins of which their city of Rome grew into power. Capua indeed subsists, the grave and monument of the Campanian people, that entire people having been either cut off or driven into banishment; the mutilated carcass of a city, without senate, without commons, without magistrates; a sort of prodigy, the leaving which to be inhabited, showed more cruelty than if it had been utterly destroyed. If foreigners who are separated from us to a greater distance by their language, manners, and laws, than by the distance by sea and land, are allowed to get footing here, it is madness to hope that any thing will continue in its present state. Does the sovereignty of Philip seem in any degree incompatible with your freedom, who, at a time when he was justly incensed against you, demanded nothing more of you than peace; and at present requires no more than the observance of the peace which he agreed to? Accustom foreign legions to these countries, and receive the yoke; too late, and in vain, will you look for Philip as an ally, when you shall have the Roman as a master. Trifling causes occasionally unite and disunite the Aetolians, Acarnanians, and Macedonians, men speaking the same language. With foreigners, with barbarians, all Greeks have, and ever will have, eternal war: because they are enemies by nature, which is always the same, and not from causes which change with the times. My discourse shall conclude with the same argument with which it began. Three years since, the same persons, assembled in this same place, determined on peace with the same Philip, contrary to the inclinations of the same Romans, who now wish that the peace should be broken, after it has been adjusted and ratified. In the subject of your deliberation, fortune has made no change; why you should make any, I do not see."

The gathering of the Aetolians, which they call Panaetolium, was scheduled for a specific day. To attend it, the king's ambassadors hurried their journey, and Lucius Furius Purpureo also arrived, sent by the consul. Ambassadors from Athens also came to this assembly. The Macedonians were heard first since they had recently made a treaty; they stated that since nothing had changed, they had no new information to present. The same reasons that led them to make peace with Philip, after realizing that an alliance with the Romans was unproductive, should motivate them to maintain that peace now that it was established. "Would you rather," one of the ambassadors asked, "copy the inconsistency or shall I say, the fickleness of the Romans, who ordered this response to your ambassadors in Rome: 'Why, Aetolians, do you come to us when, without our approval, you've made peace with Philip?' Yet these same people now demand that you join them in waging war against Philip. Previously, they claimed they took up arms for you and to defend you against Philip: now they won't let you stay at peace with him. To help Messana, they first set sail for Sicily; and a second time, to free Syracuse when it was oppressed by the Carthaginians. Both Messana and Syracuse, and all of Sicily, they keep under their control, having turned it into a tribute-paying province under their authority. You may think that, like you hold an assembly at Naupactus under your own laws, with magistrates you chose, at liberty to pick allies and enemies, and to decide on peace or war as you wish, the assembly of the Sicilian states is similarly convened at Syracuse, Messana, or Lilybaeum. No, a Roman praetor runs the meeting; they gather at his command, and they see him, surrounded by his lictors, sitting on a high throne, issuing his orders. His rods are ready for their backs, his axes for their necks, and every year they are assigned a different master. They shouldn't be surprised when they see all the cities in Italy groaning under the same burden—Rhegium, Tarentum, Capua, not to mention those nearby, whose ruins allowed Rome to rise to power. Capua still exists, a grave and monument of the Campanian people, as that entire population has either been eliminated or forced into exile; a battered shell of a city, without a senate, without citizens, without magistrates; a sort of horror, leaving it inhabited displayed more cruelty than if it had been totally destroyed. If foreigners who are more separated from us by their language, customs, and laws than by the distance across land and sea are allowed to take hold here, it is crazy to expect that anything will remain the same. Does the power of Philip seem in any way incompatible with your freedom, when, at a time when he was understandably angry with you, he asked for nothing more than peace; and now only asks you to uphold the peace he agreed to? Get used to foreign troops in your lands and accept their dominance; too late, and in vain, will you wish for Philip as an ally, once you have the Romans as your masters. Minor issues often bring together and then separate the Aetolians, Acarnanians, and Macedonians, who speak the same language. With outsiders, with barbarians, all Greeks have, and will always have, a never-ending war: because they are natural enemies, which doesn’t change with the times. My speech will end the same way it began. Three years ago, the same people, gathered in the same place, decided on peace with the same Philip, against the wishes of the same Romans, who now want that peace to be broken after it has been established and ratified. In the issue you are discussing, fortune hasn’t changed anything; I don’t see why you should."

30

Next, after the Macedonians, with the consent and at the desire of the Romans, the Athenians were introduced; who, having suffered grievously, could, with the greater justice, inveigh against the cruelty and inhumanity of the king. They represented, in a deplorable light, the miserable devastation and spoliation of their fields; adding, that "they did not complain on account of having, from an enemy, suffered hostile treatment; for there were certain rights of war, according to which, as it was just to act, so it was just to endure. Their crops being burned, their houses demolished, their men and cattle carried off as spoil, were to be considered rather as misfortunes to the sufferer than as ill-treatment. But of this they had good reason to complain, that he who called the Romans foreigners and barbarians, had himself so atrociously violated all rights, both divine and human, as, in his former inroad, to have waged an impious war against the infernal gods, in the latter, against those above. That the sepulchres and monuments of all within their country had been demolished, the graves laid open, and the bones left unprotected by the soil. There had been several temples, which, in former times, when their ancestors dwelt in the country in their separate districts, had been consecrated in each of their little forts and villages, and which, even after they were incorporated into one city, they did not neglect or forsake. That around all these temples Philip had scattered his destructive flames, and left the images of the gods lying scorched and mutilated among the prostrated pillars of their fanes. Such as he had rendered the country of Attica, formerly opulent and adorned, such, if he were suffered, would he render Aetolia and the whole of Greece. That the mutilation of their own city, also, would have been similar, if the Romans had not come to its relief: for he had shown the same wicked rage against the gods who are the guardians of the city, and Minerva who presides over the citadel; the same against the temple of Ceres at Eleusis; the same against Jupiter and Minerva at Piraeeus. In a word, having been repelled by force of arms not only from their temples, but even from their walls, he had vented his fury on those sacred edifices which were protected by religion alone. They therefore entreated and besought the Aetolians, that, compassionating the Athenians, and with the immortal gods for their leaders, and, under them, the Romans, who, next to the gods, possessed the greatest power they would take part in the war."

Next, after the Macedonians, with the agreement and at the request of the Romans, the Athenians were brought forward. Having suffered greatly, they were in a better position to speak out against the cruelty and inhumanity of the king. They painted a grim picture of the terrible destruction and looting of their fields; adding that "they didn’t complain just because they endured hostile treatment from an enemy; there are certain rights of war that justify both actions and suffering. Their crops were burned, their houses destroyed, their men and livestock taken as spoils, which should be seen more as misfortunes for those who experienced them rather than as mistreatment. However, they had every reason to complain about the fact that a man who called the Romans foreigners and barbarians had himself so horribly violated all rights, both divine and human, that in his previous invasion, he waged an irreverent war against the gods of the underworld, and now, against those above. The tombs and monuments of all in their land had been destroyed, the graves opened, and the bones left exposed. There had been several temples that, in the past, when their ancestors lived in the area in separate districts, had been dedicated in each of their small forts and villages, which they continued to honor even after becoming one city. Around all these temples, Philip had unleashed his destructive flames, leaving the images of the gods scorched and mutilated among the toppled pillars of their shrines. Just as he had ruined the once prosperous and beautiful region of Attica, he would do the same to Aetolia and all of Greece if allowed. The destruction of their own city would have been similar if the Romans had not come to help; he had shown the same wicked rage against the gods who protect the city, and against Minerva, who oversees the citadel; the same against the temple of Ceres at Eleusis; and the same against Jupiter and Minerva at Piraeus. In short, having been driven away by force not only from their temples but even from their walls, he had unleashed his fury on those sacred buildings that were protected only by religion. They therefore pleaded with the Aetolians to show compassion for the Athenians, and with the immortal gods as their leaders, along with the Romans, who, next to the gods, held the greatest power, to join the war."

31

The Roman ambassador then replied: "The Macedonians first, and afterwards the Athenians, have obliged me to change entirely the method of my discourse. For, on the one hand, the Macedonians, by aggressively introducing charges against the Romans, when I had come prepared to make complaint of the injuries committed by Philip against so many cities in alliance with us, have obliged me to think of defence rather than accusation; and, on the other hand, what have the Athenians, after relating his inhuman and impious crimes against the gods both celestial and infernal, left for me, or any one else, which I can further urge against him. You are to suppose, that the same complaints are made by the Cianians, Abydenians, Aeneans, Maronites, Thasians, Parians, Samians, Larissenians, Messenians, on the side of Achaia; and complaints, still heavier and more grievous, by those whom he had it more in his power to injure. For as to those proceedings which he censures in us, if they are not deserving of honour, I will admit that they cannot be defended at all. He has objected to us, Rhegium, and Capua, and Syracuse. As to Rhegium, during the war with Pyrrhus, a legion which, at the earnest request of the Rhegians themselves, we had sent thither as a garrison, wickedly possessed themselves of the city which they had been sent to defend. Did we then approve of that deed? or did we exert the force of our arms against that guilty legion, until we reduced them under our power; and then, after making them give satisfaction to the allies, by their stripes and the loss of their heads, restore to the Rhegians their city, their lands, and all their effects, together with their liberty and laws? To the Syracusans, when oppressed, and that by foreign tyrants, which was a still greater indignity, we lent assistance; and after enduring great fatigues in carrying on the siege of so strong a city, both by land and sea, for almost three years, (although the Syracusans themselves chose to continue in slavery to the tyrants rather than be taken to us,) yet, becoming masters of the place, and by exertion of the same force setting it at liberty, we restored it to the inhabitants. At the same time, we do not deny that Sicily is our province, and that the states which sided with the Carthaginians, and, in conjunction with them, waged war against us, pay us tribute and taxes; on the contrary, we wish that you and all nations should know, that the condition of each is such as it has deserved at our hands: and ought we to repent of the punishment inflicted on the Campanians, of which even they themselves cannot complain? These men, after we had on their account carried on war against the Samnites for near seventy years, with great loss on our side; had united them to ourselves, first by treaty, and then by intermarriages, and the relationships arising thence; and lastly, by the right of citizenship; yet, in the time of our adversity, were the first of all the states of Italy which revolted to Hannibal, after basely putting our garrison to death, and afterwards, through resentment at being besieged by us, sent Hannibal to attack Rome. If neither their city nor one man of them had been left remaining, who could take offence, or consider them as treated with more severity than they had deserved? From consciousness of guilt, greater numbers of them perished by their own hands, than by the punishments inflicted by us. And while from the rest we took away the town and the lands, still we left them a place to dwell in, we suffered the city which partook not of the guilt to stand uninjured; so that he who should see it this day would find no trace of its having been besieged or taken. But why do I speak of Capua, when even to vanquished Carthage we granted peace and liberty? The greatest danger is, that, by our too great readiness to pardon the conquered, we may encourage others to try the fortune of war against us. Let so much suffice in our defence, and against Philip, whose domestic crimes, whose parricides and murders of his relations and friends, and whose lust, more disgraceful to human nature, if possible, than his cruelty, you, as being nearer to Macedonia, are better acquainted with. As to what concerns yourselves, Aetolians, we entered into a war with Philip on your account: you made peace with him without consulting us. Perhaps you will say, that while we were occupied in the Punic war, you were constrained by fear to accept terms of pacification, from him who at that time possessed superior power; and that on our side, pressed by more urgent affairs we suspended our operations in a war which you had laid aside. At present, as we, having, by the favour of the gods brought the Punic war to a conclusion, have fallen on Macedonia with the whole weight of our power, so you have an opportunity offered you of regaining a place in our friendship and alliance, unless you choose to perish with Philip, rather than to conquer with the Romans."

The Roman ambassador then replied: "The Macedonians first, and then the Athenians, have forced me to completely change how I speak. On one hand, the Macedonians, by boldly accusing the Romans when I came prepared to complain about Philip’s wrongdoings against so many cities allied with us, have made me focus on defense instead of accusation. On the other hand, after detailing his cruel and immoral crimes against both divine and human laws, what more do the Athenians leave for me, or anyone else, to argue against him? You should understand that the same complaints are voiced by the Cianians, Abydenians, Aeneans, Maronites, Thasians, Parians, Samians, Larissenians, and Messenians from Achaia; and even heavier and more serious complaints come from those who he could harm even more. As for the actions he criticizes in us, if they’re not deserving of praise, I’ll agree they can’t be defended at all. He has pointed out Rhegium, Capua, and Syracuse. Regarding Rhegium, during the war with Pyrrhus, a legion we sent there as a garrison at the Rhegians' urgent request wickedly took control of the city they were supposed to defend. Did we agree with that act? Or did we use our power against that guilty legion, until we brought them under our control, and then made them compensate the allies with their punishments and the loss of their heads, restoring the Rhegians their city, lands, effects, their freedom, and their laws? To the Syracusans, when oppressed by foreign tyrants, which was a worse dishonor, we offered help. After enduring great hardships for nearly three years to lay siege to such a strong city, both by land and sea (even though the Syracusans themselves chose to remain enslaved to the tyrants rather than join us), we eventually took control and freed the place, returning it to its inhabitants. At the same time, we do not deny that Sicily is our province, and that the states which allied with the Carthaginians and fought against us pay us taxes and tribute; on the contrary, we want you and all nations to know that each state’s condition reflects what it deserves from us: should we regret the punishment we imposed on the Campanians, which even they cannot complain about? These people, after we had waged war against the Samnites for nearly seventy years, suffering great losses, had allied with us first by treaty, then through intermarriages and the resulting connections, and finally by granting citizenship; yet, in our time of trouble, they were the first of all the states in Italy to revolt to Hannibal, having treacherously killed our garrison, and then in their anger at being besieged by us, sent Hannibal to attack Rome. If not a single one of them had been left alive, who could complain or think they were treated more harshly than they deserved? From feelings of guilt, more of them killed themselves than were punished by us. And while we took away their town and lands from the rest, we still left them a place to live, allowing the city that was not guilty to remain untouched; so that whoever sees it today would find no sign of it having been besieged or captured. But why do I bring up Capua when we even granted peace and freedom to the defeated Carthage? The greatest danger is that, by being too quick to forgive those we conquer, we might encourage others to test their luck against us. Let this suffice for our defense against Philip, whose domestic crimes, whose murders of family and friends, and whose lust, which is even more disgraceful to humanity than his cruelty, you are more familiar with, being closer to Macedonia. As for you Aetolians, we went to war with Philip for your sake: you made peace with him without consulting us. You might argue that while we were occupied with the Punic war, you were forced by fear to accept terms from him, who had the upper hand at the time; and that we were distracted by more pressing matters, leaving aside the war you had abandoned. Now, as we, thanks to the gods, have concluded the Punic war, we are turning our full power against Macedonia, this gives you a chance to regain your position in our friendship and alliance, unless you prefer to perish alongside Philip instead of triumphing with the Romans."

32

When these things had been said by the ambassador the minds of all leaning towards the Romans, Damocritus, praetor of the Aetolians, (who, it was reported, had received money from the king,) assenting in no degree to one party or the other, said,--that "in consultations of great and critical importance, nothing was so injurious as haste. That repentance, indeed, generally followed, and that quickly but yet too late and unavailing; because designs carried on with precipitation could not be recalled, nor matters brought back to their original state. The time, however, for determining the point under consideration, which, for his part, he thought should not be too early, might yet immediately be fixed in this manner. As it had been provided by the laws, that no determination should be made concerning peace or war, except in the Panaetolic or Pylaic councils; let them immediately pass a decree, that the praetor, when he chooses to treat respecting war and peace, may have full authority to summon a council, and that whatever shall be then debated and decreed, shall be, to all intents and purposes, legal and valid, as if it had been transacted in the Panaetolic or Pylaic assembly." And thus dismissing the ambassadors, with the matter undetermined, he said, that therein he had acted most prudently for the interest of the state; for the Aetolians would have it in their power to join in alliance with whichever of the parties should be more successful in the war. Such were the proceedings in the council of the Aetolians.

When the ambassador shared these points, those leaning towards the Romans, Damocritus, the praetor of the Aetolians (who, it was rumored, had taken money from the king), who didn’t side with either group, stated that “when it comes to decisions of great importance, nothing is more harmful than rushing. Regret usually follows, but too late to be useful; because hasty actions can’t be undone, nor can matters be returned to their original state. However, the time for making a decision on the issue at hand shouldn’t be too soon but can still be established right away. The laws stipulate that no decisions about peace or war should be made except in the Panaetolic or Pylaic councils. So, let’s immediately pass a decree that the praetor, when he wants to discuss war or peace, has the full authority to call a council, and whatever is debated and decided in that council shall be completely legal and valid, just as if it had taken place in the Panaetolic or Pylaic assembly.” And with that, he dismissed the ambassadors without a resolution, believing he had acted wisely for the state’s interests; because this way, the Aetolians could ally with whichever side was more successful in the war. That was how the council of the Aetolians proceeded.

33

Meanwhile Philip was making vigorous preparations for carrying on the war both by sea and land. His naval forces he drew together at Demetrias in Thessaly; supposing that Attalus, and the Roman fleet, would move from Aegina in the beginning of the spring. He gave the command of the fleet and of the sea-coast to Heraclides, to whom he had formerly intrusted it. The equipment of the land forces he took care of in person; considering that he had deprived the Romans of two powerful auxiliaries, the Aetolians on the one side and the Dardanians on the other, by making his son Perseus block up the pass at Pelagonia. The consul was employed, not in preparations, but in the operations of war. He led his army through the country of the Dassaretians, conveying the corn untouched which he had brought from his winter quarters, for the fields afforded supplies sufficient for the consumption of the troops. The towns and villages surrendered to him, some through inclination, others through fear; some were taken by assault, others were found deserted, the barbarians flying to the neighbouring mountains. He fixed a standing camp at Lycus near the river Bevus, and from thence sent to bring in corn from the magazines of the Dassaretians. Philip saw the whole country filled with consternation, and not knowing the designs of the consul, he sent a party of horse to discover whither he was directing his course. The same state of uncertainty possessed the consul; he knew that the king had moved from his winter quarters, but in what direction he had proceeded he knew not: he also had sent horsemen to gain intelligence. These two parties, having set out from opposite quarters, after wandering a long time among the Dassaretians, through unknown roads, fell at length into the same track. Neither doubted, as soon as the noise of men and horses was heard at a distance, that the enemy was approaching, therefore, before they came within sight of each other, they got their arms in readiness, nor, when they saw their foe, was there any delay in engaging. As they happened to be nearly equal in number and valour, being picked men on both sides, they fought during several hours with vigour, until fatigue, both of men and horses, put an end to the fight, without deciding the victory. Of the Macedonians there fell forty horsemen; of the Romans thirty-five. Still, however, neither did the one party carry back to the king, nor the other to the consul, any certain information in what quarter the camp of his enemy lay. But this was soon made known to them by deserters, whom their recklessness of disposition supplies in all wars in sufficient number to discover the affairs of the contending parties.

Meanwhile, Philip was actively preparing to continue the war both at sea and on land. He gathered his naval forces at Demetrias in Thessaly, anticipating that Attalus and the Roman fleet would set sail from Aegina at the start of spring. He assigned command of the fleet and the coastline to Heraclides, who he had trusted with it before. Philip personally managed the organization of the land forces, considering he had taken away two strong allies from the Romans: the Aetolians on one side and the Dardanians on the other, by having his son Perseus block the pass at Pelagonia. The consul was focused not on preparations, but on conducting military operations. He led his army through the territory of the Dassaretians, bringing along the untouched grain he had collected from his winter quarters, since the fields provided enough supplies for the troops. The towns and villages surrendered to him, some willingly and others out of fear; some were captured in battle, while others were abandoned as the locals fled to the nearby mountains. He established a permanent camp at Lycus near the Bevus River and sent out for grain from the storage facilities of the Dassaretians. Philip noticed that the entire region was filled with fear, and, unsure of the consul's intentions, he sent a group of horsemen to find out where he was heading. The consul was also in a state of uncertainty; he knew that the king had left his winter quarters but had no idea where he had gone, so he too dispatched horsemen to gather intelligence. These two groups set out from opposite directions, and after a long time wandering through unfamiliar paths among the Dassaretians, they eventually found themselves on the same route. As soon as they heard the sounds of men and horses in the distance, they both suspected that the enemy was near. So, before they came into view of each other, they readied their weapons, and when they finally saw their opponent, there was no hesitation in engaging. Since both sides had nearly equal numbers and valor, being elite troops, they fought fiercely for several hours until exhaustion, both from men and horses, ended the battle without a clear victor. Forty Macedonian horsemen were killed, along with thirty-five Romans. However, neither side returned to their respective leaders with any reliable information about the enemy's camp. This soon changed when deserters, who are always abundant in wars due to their reckless nature, revealed the situation to both parties.

34

Philip, judging that he should make some progress towards conciliating the affections of his men, and induce them to face danger more readily on his account, if he bestowed some pains on the burial of the horsemen who fell in that expedition, ordered them to be conveyed into the camp, in order that all might be spectators of the honours paid them at their funeral. Nothing is so uncertain, or so difficult to form a judgment of, as the minds of the multitude. That which seems calculated to increase their alacrity, in exertions of every sort, often creates in them fear and inactivity. Accordingly, those who, being always accustomed to fight with Greeks and Illyrians, had only seen wounds made with javelins and arrows, seldom even by lances, came to behold bodies dismembered by the Spanish sword, some with their arms lopped off, with the shoulder or the neck entirely cut through, heads severed from the trunk, and the bowels laid open, with other frightful exhibitions of wounds: they therefore perceived, with horror, against what weapons and what men they were to fight. Even the king himself was seized with apprehensions, having never yet engaged the Romans in a regular battle. Wherefore, recalling his son, and the guard posted at the pass of Pelagonia, in order to strengthen his army by the addition of those troops, he thereby opened a passage into Macedonia for Pleuratus and the Dardanians. Then, taking deserters for guides, he marched towards the enemy with twenty thousand foot and four thousand horse, and at the distance of somewhat more than a thousand paces from the Roman camp, and near Ithacus, he fortified a hill with a trench and rampart. From this place, taking a view of the Roman station in the valley beneath, he is said to have been struck with admiration, both at the general appearance of the camp, and the regular disposition of each particular part; then with the disposition of the tents, and the intervals of the passages; and to have declared, that, certainly, that could not be regarded by any as the camp of barbarians. For two days, the consul and the king, each waiting for the other's making some attempt, kept their troops within the ramparts. On the third day, the Roman led out all his forces, and offered battle.

Philip believed he should make some progress in winning over his men and encourage them to face danger more readily for his sake, so he took the time to arrange the burial of the horsemen who died in that mission. He ordered their bodies to be brought to the camp so everyone could witness the honors paid at their funeral. The mindset of the masses is incredibly unpredictable and challenging to gauge. What seems like it would motivate them to act often leads to fear and inaction instead. Thus, those who were used to fighting Greeks and Illyrians, having mostly seen injuries from javelins and arrows, were shocked to see bodies hacked apart by Spanish swords—some with arms chopped off, shoulders or necks completely severed, heads detached from their bodies, and entrails exposed, displaying horrific wounds. They were filled with dread at the sight of what weapons and men they were up against. Even the king felt fearful since he had never fought the Romans in a formal battle. Consequently, he called back his son and the guard stationed at the pass of Pelagonia to strengthen his army with those troops, unintentionally creating a route into Macedonia for Pleuratus and the Dardanians. Then, using deserting soldiers as guides, he advanced toward the enemy with twenty thousand infantry and four thousand cavalry. Just over a thousand paces from the Roman camp, near Ithacus, he fortified a hill with a trench and rampart. From there, observing the Roman encampment in the valley below, he was reportedly struck with awe at the overall appearance of the camp and the organized layout of its components, including the arrangement of the tents and paths. He remarked that this could not possibly be seen as the camp of barbarians. For two days, the consul and the king each kept their troops within their fortifications, waiting for the other to take action. On the third day, the Roman general brought out all his forces and offered battle.

35

But the king, not daring to risk so hastily a general engagement, sent four hundred Trallians, who are a tribe of the Illyrians, as we have said in another place, and three hundred Cretans; adding to this body of infantry an equal number of horse, under the command of Athenagoras, one of his nobles honoured with the purple, to make an attack on the enemy's cavalry. When these troops arrived within a little more than five hundred paces, the Romans sent out the light infantry, and two cohorts of horse, that both cavalry and infantry might be equal in number to the Macedonians. The king's troops expected that the method of fighting would be such as they had been accustomed to; that the horsemen, pursuing and retreating alternately, would at one time use their weapons, at another time turn their backs; that the agility of the Illyrians would be serviceable for excursions and sudden attacks, and that the Cretans might discharge their arrows against the enemy, as they advanced eagerly to the charge. But the onset of the Romans, which was not more vigorous than persevering, entirely disconcerted this method of fighting: for the light infantry, as if they were fighting with their whole line of battle, after discharging their javelins, carried on a close fight with their swords; and the horsemen, when they had once made a charge, stopping their horses, fought, some on horseback, while others dismounted and intermixed themselves with the foot. By this means neither were the king's cavalry, who were unaccustomed to a steady fight, a match for the others; nor were the infantry, who were only skirmishing and irregular troops, and were besides but half covered with the kind of harness which they used, at all equal to the Roman infantry, who carried a sword and buckler, and were furnished with proper armour, both to defend themselves and to annoy the enemy: nor did they sustain the combat, but fled to their camp, trusting entirely to their speed for safety.

But the king, not wanting to risk a major battle too quickly, sent four hundred Trallians, a tribe of the Illyrians, as we've mentioned elsewhere, along with three hundred Cretans. He also added the same number of cavalry, led by Athenagoras, one of his noblemen honored with the purple, to launch an attack on the enemy's cavalry. When these troops got within a little more than five hundred paces, the Romans sent out their light infantry and two cavalry cohorts, ensuring that both their cavalry and infantry matched the Macedonians in numbers. The king's troops expected the fighting style to be what they were used to: cavalrymen would alternate between charging and retreating, using their weapons and then turning their backs; they believed the Illyrians’ agility would help with quick strikes and sudden attacks, and that the Cretans would shoot their arrows as they eagerly charged forward. However, the Romans’ assault, which was less about brute force and more about persistence, completely disrupted this fighting method. The light infantry fought as if they were engaged in a full-scale battle, throwing javelins and then closing in with their swords. The cavalry, after charging, halted and fought—some on horseback while others dismounted and mingled with the foot soldiers. As a result, the king's cavalry, unaccustomed to facing a steady fight, were no match for the Romans; nor were the infantry, who were only skirmishers and irregular troops, and who were partially protected by their light armor, able to compete with the Roman infantry, armed with swords and shields, and equipped with proper armor to defend themselves and attack the enemy. They could not withstand the fight and fled back to their camp, relying solely on their speed for safety.

36

After an interval of one day, the king, resolving to make an attack with all his forces of cavalry and light-armed infantry, had, during the night, placed in ambush, in a convenient place between the two camps, a body of targeteers, whom they call Peltastae, and given orders to Athenagoras and the cavalry, if they found they had the advantage in the open fight, to pursue their success; if otherwise, that they should retreat leisurely, and by that means draw on the enemy to the place where the ambush lay. The cavalry accordingly did retreat; but the officers of the body of targeteers, by bringing forward their men before the time, and not waiting for the signal, as they ought, lost an opportunity of performing considerable service. The Romans, having gained the victory in open fight, and also escaped the danger of the ambuscade, retired to their camp. Next day the consul marched out with all his forces, and offered battle, placing his elephants in the front of the foremost battalions. Of this resource the Romans then for the first time availed themselves; having a number of them which had been taken in the Punic war. Finding that the enemy kept himself quiet behind his intrenchments, he advanced close up to them, upbraiding him with cowardice; and as, notwithstanding, no opportunity of an engagement was afforded, the consul, considering how dangerous foraging must be while the camps lay so near each other, where the cavalry were ready at any moment to attack the soldiers, when dispersed through the country, removed his camp to a place called Ortholophus, distant about eight miles, where by reason of the intervening distance he could forage with more safety. While the Romans were collecting corn in the adjacent fields, the king kept his men within the trenches, in order to increase both the negligence and confidence of the enemy. But, when he saw them scattered, he set out with all his cavalry, and the auxiliary Cretans, and marching with such speed that the swiftest footmen could, by running, but just keep up with the horse, he planted his standards between the camp of the Romans and their foragers. Then, dividing the forces, he sent one part of them in quest of the marauders, with orders to leave not one alive; with the other, he himself halted, and placed guards on the roads through which the enemy seemed likely to fly back to their camp. And now carnage and flight prevailed in all directions, and no intelligence of the misfortune had yet reached the Roman camp, because those who fled towards the camp fell in with the guards, which the king had stationed to intercept them, and greater numbers were slain by those who were placed in the roads, than by those who had been sent out to attack them. At length, a few effected their escape, through the midst of the enemy's posts, but were so filled with terror, that they excited a general consternation in the camp, rather than brought intelligible information.

After a day’s pause, the king decided to launch an attack with all his cavalry and light infantry. During the night, he positioned a group of targeteers, known as Peltastae, in an ambush between the two camps. He ordered Athenagoras and the cavalry to pursue the enemy if they gained the advantage in open combat; if not, they should retreat calmly to draw the enemy into the ambush. The cavalry did retreat, but the targeteers' officers jumped the gun and moved their men too soon, missing the chance to contribute significantly. The Romans emerged victorious in open battle and, having evaded the ambush, returned to their camp. The next day, the consul marched out with all his forces and offered battle, positioning his elephants at the front of the first battalions. This was the first time the Romans utilized this tactic, having acquired several elephants during the Punic War. When he noticed the enemy remaining behind their fortifications, he approached, taunting them with cowardice. However, since no engagement was forthcoming, the consul recognized that foraging was risky with the camps this close and moved to a location called Ortholophus, about eight miles away, where he could gather supplies more safely. While the Romans gathered grain in nearby fields, the king kept his troops inside the trenches to increase the enemy's carelessness and overconfidence. Once he saw them scattered, he charged out with all his cavalry and the Cretan allies, moving so quickly that only the fastest foot soldiers could keep pace with the horses. He placed his standards between the Roman camp and their foragers. Dividing his forces, he sent part of them after the marauders, ordering them to leave no one alive. With the other group, he set up guards on the roads where the enemy might attempt to retreat. Chaos and flight ensued all around, and the Roman camp had yet to learn of the disaster, as those fleeing towards the camp ran into the king's guards. More were killed by those blocking the roads than by those sent to pursue them. Eventually, a few managed to escape through the enemy's lines, but they were so terrified that they spread panic in the camp rather than delivering clear information.

37

The consul, ordering the cavalry to carry aid to those who were in danger, in the best manner they could, drew out the legions from the camp, and led them drawn up in a square towards the enemy. The cavalry, taking different ways through the fields, missed the road, being deceived by the various shouts raised in several quarters. Some of them met with the enemy, and battles began in many places at once. The hottest part of the action was at the station where the king commanded; for the guard there was, in numbers both of horse and foot, almost a complete army; and, as they were posted on the middle road, the greatest number of the Romans fell in with them. The Macedonians had also the advantage in this, that the king himself was present to encourage them; and the Cretan auxiliaries, fighting in good order, and in a state of preparation, against troops disordered and irregular, wounded many at a distance, where no such danger was apprehended. If they had acted with prudence in the pursuit, they would have secured an advantage of great importance, not only in regard to the glory of the present contest, but to the general interest of the war; but, greedy of slaughter, and following with too much eagerness, they fell in with the advanced cohorts of the Romans under the military tribunes. The horsemen who were flying, as soon as they saw the ensigns of their friends, faced about against the enemy, now in disorder; so that in a moment's time the fortune of the battle was changed, those now turning their backs who had lately been the pursuers. Many were slain in close fight, many in the pursuit; nor was it by the sword alone that they perished; several, being driven into morasses, were, together with their horses, swallowed up in the deep mud. The king himself was in danger; for his horse falling, in consequence of a wound, threw him headlong to the ground, and he very narrowly escaped being overpowered while prostrate. He owed his safety to a trooper, who instantly leaped down and mounted the affrighted king on his horse; himself, as he could not on foot keep up with the flying horsemen, was slain by the enemy, who had collected about the place where Philip fell. The king, in his desperate flight, rode about among the morasses, some of which were easily passed, and others not; at length, when most men despaired of his ever escaping in safety, he arrived in safety at his camp. Two hundred Macedonian horsemen perished in that action; about one hundred were taken: eighty horses, richly caparisoned, were led off the field; at the same time the spoils of arms were also carried off.

The consul ordered the cavalry to provide help to those in danger as best they could, then drew out the legions from the camp and led them into a square formation towards the enemy. The cavalry took different paths through the fields, got lost, and were confused by the various shouts from different directions. Some of them ran into the enemy, leading to battles breaking out in multiple places at once. The fiercest fighting was where the king commanded, as his guard, both horse and foot, was almost like a full army. Positioned in the middle of the road, this unit encountered the largest number of Romans. The Macedonians had the upper hand because the king himself was present to encourage them, and the Cretan auxiliaries were fighting effectively and prepared against disorganized and irregular troops, inflicting casualties from a distance where there was no immediate threat. If they had acted wisely during the pursuit, they could have gained a significant advantage, not just in terms of the glory from this battle, but for the overall war effort; however, eager for slaughter and too zealous in their chase, they clashed with the advancing Roman cohorts led by military tribunes. The fleeing horsemen, upon seeing their comrades’ banners, turned back against the now disordered enemy, causing a swift turnaround in the battle's fortunes, with those who had just been chasing now retreating. Many were killed in close combat, many during the chase; not all perished by the sword—many were driven into swamps and drowned in the deep mud with their horses. The king himself faced danger when his horse fell, injured, and threw him to the ground, putting him at risk of being overwhelmed while down. He was saved by a trooper who quickly jumped down and helped the frightened king onto his horse; unfortunately, the trooper, unable to keep pace with the fleeing horsemen on foot, was killed by the enemy gathered near where Philip fell. In his desperate flight, the king navigated through the marshes, some easy to cross and others not; finally, when most thought he would never escape safely, he made it back to his camp. Two hundred Macedonian horsemen were lost in that battle; about one hundred were captured; eighty richly adorned horses were taken off the field, along with a collection of weapons as spoils.

38

There were some who found fault with the king, as guilty of rashness on that day; and with the consul, for want of energy. For Philip, they say, on his part, ought to have avoided coming to action, knowing that in a few days the enemy, having exhausted all the adjacent country, must be reduced to the extremity of want; and that the consul, after having routed the Macedonian cavalry and light infantry, and nearly taken the king himself, ought to have led on his troops directly to the enemy's camp, where, dismayed as they were, they would have made no stand, and that he might have finished the war in a moment's time. This, like most other matters, was easier to be talked about than to be done. For, if the king had brought the whole of his infantry into the engagement, then, indeed, during the tumult, and while, vanquished and struck with dismay, they fled from the field into their intrenchments, (and even continued their flight from thence on seeing the victorious enemy mounting the ramparts,) the king might have been deprived of his camp. But as some forces of infantry had remained in the camp, fresh and free from fatigue, with outposts before the gates, and guard properly disposed, what would he have done but imitated the rashness of which the king had just now been guilty, by pursuing the routed horse? On the other side, the king's first plan of an attack on the foragers, while dispersed through the fields, would not have been a subject of censure, could he have satisfied himself with a moderate degree of success: and it is the less surprising that he should have made a trial of fortune, as there was a report, that Pleuratus and the Dardanians had set out from home with very numerous forces, and had already passed into Macedonia; so that if he should be surrounded on all sides by these forces, there was reason to think that the Roman might put an end to the war without stirring from his seat. Philip, however, considered, that after his cavalry had been defeated in two engagements, he could with much less safety continue in the same post; accordingly, wishing to remove from thence, and, at the same time, to keep the enemy in ignorance of his design, he sent a herald to the consul a little before sun-set, to demand a truce for the purpose of burying the horsemen; and thus imposing on him, he began his march in silence, about the second watch, leaving a number of fires in all parts of his camp.

Some people criticized the king, claiming he acted recklessly that day, and they criticized the consul for lacking decisiveness. They argued that Philip should have avoided engaging in battle, knowing the enemy would soon be weakened by depleting the surrounding area. They believed the consul, after defeating the Macedonian cavalry and light infantry and nearly capturing the king, should have led his troops straight to the enemy's camp, where the disheartened forces would have likely surrendered, allowing him to end the war quickly. However, this was easier said than done. If the king had committed all his infantry to the battle, then during the chaos, as the defeated and frightened troops fled to their strongholds—and even continued to escape upon seeing the victorious enemy scaling the walls—he might have lost his camp. But since some infantry remained in the camp, fresh and unexhausted, with sentinels at the gates and guards strategically placed, he would have only repeated the king's earlier recklessness by pursuing the scattered cavalry. On the other hand, the king's initial strategy of attacking the foragers spread out in the fields would not have drawn criticism if he had been content with a reasonable level of success. It's less surprising that he attempted to test his luck, considering reports that Pleuratus and the Dardanians had set out with large forces and had already entered Macedonia; if he were surrounded by these forces, there was a good chance the Romans could win the war without needing to move. However, Philip realized that after his cavalry had been defeated in two battles, it was much riskier for him to stay in the same position. Therefore, wanting to leave quietly and keep the enemy unaware of his plan, he sent a herald to the consul shortly before sunset to request a truce for burying the fallen horsemen. Deceiving him, he began his silent march around the second watch, leaving numerous fires burning throughout his camp.

39

The consul was now taking refreshment, when he was told that the herald had arrived, and on what business; he gave him no other answer, than that he should be admitted to an audience early the next morning: by which means Philip gained what he wanted--the length of that night, and part of the following day, during which he might get the start on his march. He directed his route towards the mountains, a road which he knew the Romans with their heavy baggage would not attempt. The consul, having, at the first light, dismissed the herald with a grant of a truce, in a short time after discovered that the enemy had gone off; but not knowing what course to take in pursuit of them, he remained in the same camp for several days, which he employed in collecting forage. He then marched to Stubera, and brought thither, from Pelagonia, the corn that was in the fields. From thence he advanced to Pluvina, not having yet discovered to what quarter the Macedonian had bent his course. Philip, having at first fixed his camp at Bryanium, marched thence through cross-roads, and gave a sudden alarm to the enemy. The Romans, on this, removed from Pluvina, and pitched their camp near the river Osphagus. The king also sat down at a small distance, forming his intrenchment on the bank of a river which the inhabitants call Erigonus. Having there received certain information that the Romans intended to proceed to Eordaea, he marched away before them, in order to take possession of the defiles, and prevent the enemy from making their way, where the roads are confined in narrow straits. There, with great haste, he fortified some places with a rampart, others with a trench, others with stones heaped up instead of walls, others with trees laid across, according as the situation required, or as materials lay convenient; and thus a road, in its own nature difficult, he rendered, as he imagined, impregnable by the works which he drew across every pass. The adjoining ground, being mostly covered with woods, was exceedingly incommodious to the phalanx of the Macedonians, which is of no manner of use, except when they extend their very long spears before their shields, forming as it were a palisade; to perform which, they require an open plain. The Thracians, too, were embarrassed by their lances, which also are of a great length, and were entangled among the branches that stood in their way on every side. The body of Cretans alone was not unserviceable; and yet even these, though, in case of an attack made on them, they could to good purpose discharge their arrows against the horses or riders, where they were open to a wound, yet against the Roman shields they could do nothing, because they had neither strength sufficient to pierce through them, nor was there any part exposed at which they could aim. Perceiving, therefore, that kind of weapon to be useless, they annoyed the enemy with stones, which lay in plenty in all parts of the valley: the strokes made by these on their shields, with greater noise than injury, for a short time retarded the advance of the Romans; but quickly disregarding these missiles also, some, closing their shields in form of a tortoise, forced their way through the enemy in front; others having, by a short circuit, gained the summit of the hill, dislodged the dismayed Macedonians from their guards and posts, and even slew the greater part of them, their retreat being embarrassed by the difficulties of the ground.

The consul was having a snack when he was informed that the herald had arrived and the purpose of his visit. He simply replied that the herald should be granted an audience the next morning. This delay allowed Philip to gain what he wanted: the entirety of that night and part of the following day to get a head start on his march. He chose a route toward the mountains, which he knew the Romans wouldn’t attempt due to their heavy baggage. At first light, the consul sent the herald away with a truce, but soon after realized that the enemy had left. Unsure of how to pursue them, he stayed in the same camp for several days, using the time to gather forage. He then marched to Stubera and brought back the corn from the fields in Pelagonia. From there, he moved on to Pluvina, still unaware of which direction the Macedonian had taken. Philip initially camped at Bryanium, then took cross-roads and launched a surprise attack on the enemy. In response, the Romans left Pluvina and set up camp near the river Osphagus. The king also encamped nearby, building fortifications on the bank of a river called Erigonus by the locals. After learning that the Romans planned to head to Eordaea, he left before them to secure the narrow passes, preventing the enemy from moving through the constrained routes. He quickly fortified certain areas with a rampart and others with trenches, piled up stones as makeshift walls, and laid down trees across the pathways, depending on the terrain and available materials. Thus, he aimed to make the naturally challenging route seem impregnable with his defenses blocking every pass. The surrounding area, mostly wooded, was very inconvenient for the Macedonian phalanx, which only worked effectively when they could stretch out their long spears before their shields to form a barrier; they needed open ground for this. The Thracians faced similar issues with their long lances, getting tangled in the branches obstructing them. Only the Cretans weren't completely helpless; however, even they could only shoot arrows effectively if the enemy was exposed to wounds, which was hard against the Roman shields, as they couldn’t pierce them and had no target to aim for. Realizing that their weapons were ineffective, they started throwing stones, which were abundant in the valley. The noise from the stones hitting the Roman shields was more startling than harmful, briefly slowing the advance of the Romans. But soon ignoring these projectiles, some Romans formed a shield wall like a tortoise and pushed through the enemy. Others managed to circle around and reach the top of the hill, forcing the disoriented Macedonians from their positions and killing many of them, with their retreat hampered by the rough terrain.

40

Thus, with less opposition than they had expected to meet, the defiles were passed, and they came to Eordaea; then, having laid waste the whole country, the consul withdrew into Elimea. From thence he made an irruption into Orestis, and attacked the city Celetrum, situated in a peninsula: a lake surrounds the walls; and there is but one entrance from the main land along a narrow isthmus. Relying on their situation, the townsmen at first shut the gates, and refused to submit; but afterwards, when they saw the troops in motion, and advancing in the tortoise method, and the isthmus covered by the enemy marching in, they surrendered in terror rather than hazard a struggle. From Celetrum he advanced into the country of the Dassaretians, took the city Pelium by storm, carried off the slaves with the rest of the spoil, and discharging the freemen without ransom, restored the city to them, after placing a strong garrison in it, for it was very conveniently situated for making inroads into Macedonia. Having thus traversed the enemy's country, the consul led back his forces into those parts which were already reduced to obedience near Apollonia, from whence the campaign had commenced. Philip's attention had been drawn to other quarters by the Aetolians, Athamanians, and Dardanians: so many were the wars that started up on different sides of him. Against the Dardanians, who were now retiring out of Macedonia, he sent Athenagoras with the light infantry and the greater part of the cavalry, and ordered him to hang on their rear as they retreated; and, by cutting off their hindmost troops, make them more cautious for the future of leading out their armies from home. As to the Aetolians, Damocritus, their praetor, the same who at Naupactum had persuaded them to defer passing a decree concerning the war, had in the next meeting roused them to arms, after the report of the battle between the cavalry at Ortholophus; the irruption of the Dardanians and of Pleuratus, with the Illyrians, into Macedonia; of the arrival of the Roman fleet, too, at Oreus; and that Macedonia, besides being beset on all sides by so many nations, was in danger of being invested by sea also.

Thus, with less resistance than they anticipated, they passed through the narrow passages and arrived at Eordaea. After devastating the entire region, the consul withdrew to Elimea. From there, he launched an attack on Orestis, targeting the city of Celetrum, which is located on a peninsula surrounded by a lake; there’s only one way in from the mainland via a narrow isthmus. Confident in their fortified position, the townspeople initially shut the gates and refused to surrender. However, when they saw the troops moving in a tight formation and the isthmus being covered by the advancing enemy, they surrendered in fear rather than risk a confrontation. After Celetrum, he moved into Dassaretis, captured the city of Pelium, and took the slaves as part of the spoil, releasing the free citizens without charging ransom, while stationing a strong garrison there since it was strategically useful for raids into Macedonia. Having traversed the enemy's territory, the consul led his forces back to the areas that had already submitted near Apollonia, where the campaign had started. Philip's attention was diverted by the Aetolians, Athamanians, and Dardanians, with so many conflicts erupting around him. He sent Athenagoras with light infantry and most of the cavalry against the Dardanians, who were retreating from Macedonia, instructing him to follow their rear during their withdrawal and to cut off the trailing troops to make future deployments more cautious. Regarding the Aetolians, their praetor Damocritus, who had previously convinced them to delay a decision about the war at Naupactum, rallied them to arms at their next meeting after reports of the cavalry battle at Ortholophus; news of the Dardanians and Pleuratus along with the Illyrians entering Macedonia; the arrival of the Roman fleet at Oreus; and the fact that Macedonia, besieged by various nations, was also at risk of being blockaded by sea.

41

These reasons had brought back Damocritus and the Aetolians to the interest of the Romans. Marching out, therefore, in conjunction with Amynander, king of the Athamanians, they laid siege to Cercinium. The inhabitants here had shut their gates, whether of their own choice or by compulsion is unknown, as they had a garrison of the king's troops. However, in a few days Cercinium was taken and burned; and after great slaughter had been made, those who survived, both freemen and slaves, were carried off amongst other spoil. This caused such terror, as made all those who dwelt round the lake Baebius abandon their cities and fly to the mountains: and the Aetolians, in the absence of booty, turned away from thence, and proceeded into Perrhaebia. There they took Cyretiae by storm and sacked it unmercifully. The inhabitants of Mallaea, making a voluntary submission, were received into alliance. From Perrhaebia, Amynander advised to march to Gomphi, because that city lies close to Athamania, and there was reason to think that it might be reduced without any great difficulty. But the Aetolians, for the sake of plunder, directed their march to the rich plains of Thessaly. Amynander following, though he did not approve either of their careless method of carrying on their depredations, or of their pitching their camp in any place which chance presented, without choice, and without taking any care to fortify it. Therefore, lest their rashness and negligence might be the cause of some misfortune to himself and his troops, when he saw them forming their camp in low grounds, under the city Phecadus, he took possession, with his own troops, of an eminence about five hundred paces distant, which could be rendered secure by a slight fortification. The Aetolians seemed to have forgotten that they were in an enemy's country, excepting that they continued to plunder, some straggling about half-armed, others spending whole days and nights alike in drinking and sleeping in the camp, neglecting even to fix guards, when Philip unexpectedly came upon them. His approach being announced by those who had fled out of the fields in a fright, Damocritus and the rest of the officers were thrown into great confusion. It happened to be mid-day, and when most of the men after a hearty meal lay fast asleep. Their officers roused them, however, as fast as possible; ordered them to take arms; despatched some to recall those who were straggling through the fields in search of plunder; and so violent was their hurry, that many of the horsemen went out without their swords, and but few of them put on their corslets. After marching out in this precipitate manner, (the whole horse and foot scarcely making up six hundred,) they met the king's cavalry, superior in number, in spirit, and in arms. They were, therefore, routed at the first charge; and having scarcely attempted resistance, returned to the camp in shameful flight. Several were slain; and some taken, having been cut off from the main body of the fugitives.

These reasons had rekindled the interest of the Romans in Damocritus and the Aetolians. So, teaming up with Amynander, the king of the Athamanians, they laid siege to Cercinium. The inhabitants had closed their gates, whether by choice or force is unclear, as they had a garrison of the king's troops. However, after a few days, Cercinium was captured and burned; and after a significant slaughter, the survivors, both free and enslaved, were taken away amongst the other spoils. This created such fear that everyone living around Lake Baebius fled their cities and ran to the mountains. With no loot to be had, the Aetolians moved on and headed into Perrhaebia. There, they stormed Cyretiae and mercilessly looted it. The residents of Mallaea, choosing to surrender, were taken into alliance. From Perrhaebia, Amynander suggested marching to Gomphi since that city was close to Athamania, and it seemed likely it could be taken without much trouble. But the Aetolians, eager for plunder, directed their march to the wealthy plains of Thessaly. Amynander followed them, disapproving of their careless way of raiding and their habit of setting up camp wherever they happened to be, without choosing or fortifying their location. To avoid their recklessness causing trouble for himself and his troops, when he saw them setting up camp in low ground near the city of Phecadus, he and his troops took control of a hill about five hundred paces away that could be easily fortified. The Aetolians appeared to have forgotten they were in enemy territory, except for their continued looting, with some half-armed, while others spent entire days and nights drinking and sleeping in camp, neglecting to even set guards. When King Philip suddenly attacked, those who fled from the fields alerted them, throwing Damocritus and the other officers into a panic. It was midday, and most men were fast asleep after a big meal. However, the officers quickly roused them, ordered them to arm themselves, and sent some to call back those wandering the fields looking for loot. In their frantic rush, many horsemen left without their swords, and very few put on their armor. After hastily marching out (the entire force of horse and foot barely numbering six hundred), they encountered the king’s cavalry, who had superior numbers, morale, and weaponry. They were thus routed at the first charge and barely put up any resistance before fleeing back to camp in disgrace. Several were killed, and some were captured after being separated from the main group of fugitives.

42

Philip, when his troops had advanced almost to the rampart, ordered a retreat to be sounded, because both men and horses were fatigued, not so much by the action, as at once by the length of their march, and the extraordinary celerity with which they had made it. He therefore despatched the horsemen by troops, and the companies of light infantry in turn, to procure water and take refreshment. The rest he kept on guard, under arms, waiting for the main body of the infantry, which had marched with less expedition, on account of the weight of their armour. As soon as these arrived, they also were ordered to fix their standards, and, laying down their arms before them, to take food in haste; sending two, or at most three, out of each company, to provide water. In the mean time the cavalry and light infantry stood in order, and ready, in case the enemy should make any movement. The Aetolians, as if resolved to defend their fortifications, (the multitude which had been scattered about the fields having, by this time, returned to the camp,) posted bodies of armed men at the gates, and on the rampart, and from this safe situation looked with a degree of confidence on the enemy, as long as they continued quiet. But, as soon as the troops of the Macedonians began to move, and to advance to the rampart, in order of battle, and ready for an assault, they all quickly abandoned their posts, and fled through the opposite part of the camp, to the eminence where the Athamanians were stationed. During their flight in this confusion, many of the Aetolians were slain, and many made prisoners. Philip doubted not that, had there been daylight enough remaining, he should have been able to make himself master of the camp of the Athamanians also; but the day having been spent in the fight, and in plundering the camp afterwards, he sat down under the eminence, in the adjacent plain, determined to attack the enemy at the first dawn of the following day. But the Aetolians, under the same apprehensions which had made them desert their camp, dispersed, and fled during the following night. Amynander was of the greatest service; for, by his directions, the Athamanians, who were acquainted with the roads, conducted them into Aetolia, whilst the Macedonians pursued them over the highest mountains, through unknown paths. In this disorderly flight, a few, missing their way, fell into the hands of the Macedonian horsemen, whom Philip, at the earliest dawn, on seeing the eminence abandoned, had sent to harass the marching body of the enemy.

Philip, when his troops had almost reached the rampart, ordered a retreat, because both the men and horses were tired—not just from fighting, but also from the long march and the speed at which they had covered it. He then sent out the cavalry in groups and the light infantry in shifts to fetch water and rest. The rest stayed on guard, armed and waiting for the main body of infantry, which had moved more slowly due to the heavy armor. As soon as they arrived, they were instructed to set up their standards, lay down their weapons, and grab food quickly, sending two or at most three from each unit to get water. Meanwhile, the cavalry and light infantry remained ready in case the enemy made any moves. The Aetolians, seemingly determined to defend their fortifications (the large number of soldiers that had been scattered in the fields had by now returned to the camp), stationed armed men at the gates and on the rampart, where they confidently watched the enemy as long as there was no movement. But as soon as the Macedonian troops began to advance towards the rampart in battle formation, they all quickly abandoned their positions and fled through the opposite side of the camp to the high ground where the Athamanians were stationed. In the chaos of their retreat, many Aetolians were killed, and many were captured. Philip had no doubt that if there had been enough daylight, he could have taken control of the Athamanean camp too; however, since the day had been spent in fighting and then plundering the camp, he settled down on the nearby plain, determined to attack the enemy at first light the next day. But the Aetolians, fearing the same things that had caused them to abandon their camp, scattered and fled during the night. Amynander was very helpful; following his instructions, the Athamanians, familiar with the roads, led them into Aetolia while the Macedonians chased them over the highest mountains along unfamiliar routes. In this chaotic retreat, a few Aetolians lost their way and fell into the hands of the Macedonian cavalry, which Philip had sent at dawn when he saw the high ground was empty, to harass the enemy’s retreat.

43

About the same time also Athenagoras, one of the king's generals, overtaking the Dardanians in their retreat homeward, at first threw their rear into disorder; but these unexpectedly facing about, and forming their line, the fight became like a regular engagement. When the Dardanians began again to advance, the Macedonian cavalry and light infantry harassed those who had no troops of that kind to aid them, and were, besides, burdened with unwieldy arms. The ground, too, favoured the assailants: very few were slain, but many wounded; none were taken, because they rarely quit their ranks, but both fight and retreat in a close body. Thus Philip, having checked the proceedings of those two nations by these well-timed expeditions, gained reparation for the damages sustained from the operations of the Romans; the enterprise being as spirited as the issue was successful. An occurrence which accidentally happened to him lessened the number of his enemies on the side of Aetolia. Scopas, a man of considerable influence in his own country, having been sent from Alexandria by king Ptolemy, with a great sum of gold, hired and carried away to Egypt six thousand foot and four hundred horse; nor would he have suffered one of the young Aetolians to remain at home, had not Damocritus, (it is not easy to say, whether out of zeal for the good of the nation, or out of opposition to Scopas, for not having secured his interest by presents,) by sometimes reminding them of the war which threatened them, at other times, of the solitary condition in which they would be, detained some of them at home by severe reproaches. Such were the actions of the Romans, and of Philip, during that summer.

Around the same time, Athenagoras, one of the king's generals, caught up with the Dardanians as they were retreating homeward. At first, he disrupted their rear, but they unexpectedly turned around and formed a line, making the fight resemble a proper battle. When the Dardanians started to advance again, the Macedonian cavalry and light infantry targeted those who didn’t have similar troops to support them and who were weighed down by heavy arms. The terrain also favored the attackers: very few were killed, but many were wounded; none were captured because they rarely left their ranks and fought or retreated in close formation. Philip, by launching these well-timed attacks, managed to deter those two nations and avenged the damages inflicted by the Romans, making his venture as bold as it was successful. An incident that occurred unexpectedly reduced the number of his enemies in Aetolia. Scopas, a man of significant influence in his own territory, was sent from Alexandria by King Ptolemy with a large sum of gold and recruited six thousand foot soldiers and four hundred cavalry to take back to Egypt; he would not have left any young Aetolians behind if not for Damocritus. It's hard to say if Damocritus was motivated by a genuine concern for his country or by rivalry with Scopas, whom he thought had failed to secure his interests with gifts. By reminding them of the looming war and the lonely fate that awaited them, he kept some from joining Scopas through harsh criticism. This was the situation with the Romans and Philip during that summer.

44

In the beginning of the same summer, the fleet under Lucius Apustius, lieutenant-general, setting sail from Corcyra, and passing by Malea, formed a junction with king Attalus, off Scyllaeum, which lies in the district of Hermione. The Athenian state, which had for a long time, through fear, restrained their animosity against Philip within some bounds, in the expectation of approaching aid afforded them, gave full scope to it all. There are never wanting in that city orators, who are ready on every occasion to inflame the people; a kind of men, who, in all free states, and more particularly in that of Athens, where eloquence flourishes in the highest degree, are maintained by the favour of the multitude. These immediately proposed a decree, and the commons passed it, that "all the statues and images of Philip, with their inscriptions, and likewise those of all his ancestors, male and female, should be taken down and destroyed; that the festal days, solemnities, and priests, which had been instituted in honour of him or of his predecessors, should all be abolished; and that even the ground where any such statue had been set up, and inscribed to his honour, should be held abominable." And it was resolved, that, "for the future, nothing which ought to be erected or dedicated in a place of purity should be there erected; and that the public priests, as often as they should pray for the people of Athens, for their allies, armies, and fleets, so often should they utter curses and execrations against Philip, his offspring, his kingdom, his forces by sea and land, and the whole race and name of the Macedonians." It was added to the decree, that, "if any person in future should make any proposal tending to throw disgrace and ignominy on Philip, the people of Athens would ratify it in its fullest extent: if, on the contrary, any one should, by word or deed, endeavour to lessen his ignominy, or to do him honour, that whoever slew him who should have so said or done, should be justified in so doing." Lastly, a clause was annexed, that "all the decrees, formerly passed against the Pisistratidae, should be in full force against Philip." Thus the Athenians waged war against Philip with writings and with words, in which alone their power consisted.

In the beginning of that same summer, the fleet led by Lucius Apustius, the lieutenant-general, set sail from Corcyra and, passing by Malea, joined forces with King Attalus off Scyllaeum, which is in the district of Hermione. The Athenian state, which had long held back its animosity against Philip out of fear, now unleashed all of it, anticipating help that was on the way. There are always orators in that city, eager to stir up the people at every opportunity; they thrive on the favor of the crowd, particularly in Athens, where eloquence is highly valued. These orators immediately proposed a decree, and the assembly passed it, stating that "all statues and images of Philip, along with their inscriptions, and those of all his ancestors, both male and female, should be taken down and destroyed; that the festivals, ceremonies, and priests dedicated to him or his predecessors should all be abolished; and that even the ground where any such statue had been erected in his honor should be considered cursed." It was decided that "from now on, nothing that should be set up or dedicated in a sacred place should be erected there; and that the public priests, whenever they prayed for the people of Athens, their allies, armies, and fleets, should also pronounce curses and condemnations against Philip, his descendants, his kingdom, his military forces, and the entire race and name of the Macedonians." The decree further specified that "if anyone in the future proposed something to disgrace Philip, the people of Athens would fully support it; if, on the other hand, anyone tried to lessen his disgrace or show him honor, whoever killed that person would be justified in doing so." Finally, it was added that "all previous decrees against the Pisistratidae would apply fully to Philip." Thus, the Athenians waged war against Philip with writings and words, the only means of power they possessed.

45

Attalus and the Romans, having, from Hermione, proceeded first to Piraeus, and staid there a few days, after being loaded with decrees of the Athenians, (in which the honours paid to their allies were as extravagant as the expressions of their resentment against their enemy had been,) sailed from Piraeus to Andros, and, coming to an anchor in the harbour called Gaureleos, sent persons to sound the inclinations of the townsmen, whether they chose voluntarily to surrender their city, rather than run the hazard of an assault. On their answering, that they were not at their own disposal, but that the citadel was occupied by the king's troops, Attalus and the Roman lieutenant-general, landing their forces, with every thing requisite for attacking towns, made their approaches to the city on different sides. The Roman standards and arms, which they had never seen before, together with the spirit of the soldiers, so briskly approaching the walls, were particularly terrifying to the Greeks. A retreat was immediately made into the citadel, and the enemy took possession of the city. After holding out for two days in the citadel, relying more on the strength of the place than on their arms, on the third both they and the garrison surrendered the city and citadel, on condition of their being transported to Delium in Boeotia, and being each of them allowed a single suit of apparel. The island was yielded up by the Romans to king Attalus; the spoil, and the ornaments of the city, they themselves carried off. Attalus, desirous that the island, of which he had got possession, might not be quite deserted, persuaded almost all the Macedonians, and several of the Andrians, to remain there: and, in some time after, those who, according to the capitulation, had been transported to Delium, were induced to return from thence by the promises made them by the king, in which they were disposed the more readily to confide, by the ardent affection which they felt for their native country. From Andros they passed over to Cythnus; there they spent several days, to no purpose, in assaulting the city; when, at length, finding it scarcely worth the trouble, they departed. At Prasiae, a place on the main land of Attica, twenty barks of the Issaeans joined the Roman fleet. These were sent to ravage the lands of the Carystians, the rest of the fleet lying at Geraestus, a noted harbour in Euboea, until the Issaeans returned from Carystus: on which, setting sail all together, and steering their course through the open sea, until they passed by Scyrus, they arrived at the island of Icus. Being detained there for a few days by a violent northerly wind, as soon as the weather was fair, they passed over to Sciathus, a city which had been lately plundered and desolated by Philip. The soldiers, spreading themselves over the country, brought back to the ships corn and what other kinds of provisions could be of use to them. Plunder there was none, nor had the Greeks deserved to be plundered. Directing their course thence to Cassandrea, they first came to Mendis, a village on the coast of that state; and, intending from thence to double the promontory, and bring round the fleet to the very walls of the city, a violent tempest arising, they were near being buried in the waves. However, after being dispersed, and a great part of the ships having lost their rigging, they escaped on shore. This storm at sea was an omen of the kind of success which they were to meet on land; for, after collecting their vessels together, and landing their forces, having made an assault on the city, they were repulsed with many wounds, there being a strong garrison of the king's troops in the place. Being thus obliged to retreat without accomplishing their design, they passed over to Canastrum in Pallene, and from thence, doubling the promontory of Torona, conducted the fleet to Acanthus. There they first laid waste the country, then stormed the city itself, and plundered it. They proceeded no farther, for their ships were now heavily laden with booty, but went back to Sciathus, and from Sciathus to Euboea, whence they had first set out.

Attalus and the Romans left Hermione and first went to Piraeus, where they stayed for a few days after receiving a bunch of decrees from the Athenians. These decrees were as extravagant in their honors for allies as they were harsh in their resentment toward enemies. They then sailed from Piraeus to Andros, anchoring in the harbor called Gaureleos. They sent people to gauge whether the townspeople wanted to surrender their city voluntarily instead of risking an assault. When the townsfolk replied that they couldn’t make that decision because the citadel was occupied by the king’s troops, Attalus and the Roman general landed their forces, equipped for an attack, and approached the city from different sides. The sight of the Roman standards and weapons, which the Greeks had never seen before, along with the soldiers' spirited advance toward the walls, was especially terrifying. The Greeks immediately retreated into the citadel, and the enemies took over the city. After two days of holding out in the citadel, relying more on its strength than their weapons, on the third day, both the defenders and the garrison surrendered the city and citadel, agreeing to be transported to Delium in Boeotia with each person allowed a single suit of clothing. The Romans gave the island to King Attalus and took the spoils and treasures from the city themselves. Wanting the island to be inhabited, Attalus convinced nearly all the Macedonians and several Andrians to stay. Later, those who had been taken to Delium were persuaded to return by the king's promises, which they were more inclined to trust because of their strong affection for their homeland. They then sailed from Andros to Cythnus, where they spent several fruitless days trying to attack the city before finally deciding it wasn't worth the trouble and leaving. At Prasiae, a place on the mainland of Attica, twenty ships from the Issaeans joined the Roman fleet. These ships were sent to raid the lands of the Carystians while the rest of the fleet waited at Geraestus, a well-known harbor in Euboea, until the Issaeans returned from Carystus. Once they all set sail together, they navigated through the open sea, passing by Scyrus, and arrived at the island of Icus. They were stuck there for a few days due to a strong northern wind, but as soon as the weather cleared, they crossed over to Sciathus, a city that had recently been pillaged and devastated by Philip. The soldiers spread out across the countryside, bringing back grain and other provisions to their ships. There were no spoils to be had, as the Greeks had not earned them. They then directed their course to Cassandrea, first stopping at Mendis, a village on the coast of that region. They planned to navigate around the promontory and bring the fleet close to the city walls, but a fierce storm nearly drowned them. After being scattered and losing much of their ships' rigging, they managed to reach shore. This storm was a sign of the troubles they would face on land, as after regrouping and landing their forces, they assaulted the city but were driven back with many injuries, facing a strong garrison of the king's troops. Forced to retreat without accomplishing their objective, they sailed to Canastrum in Pallene and then rounded the promontory of Torona to head to Acanthus. There, they first devastated the countryside, then stormed and looted the city itself. They did not go any further, as their ships were now heavily loaded with loot, and they returned to Sciathus and from there back to Euboea, where they had initially set out.

46

Leaving the fleet there, they entered the Malian bay with ten light ships, in order to confer with the Aetolians on the method of conducting the war. Sipyrrhicas, the Aetolian, was at the head of the embassy that came to Heraclea, to hold a consultation with the king and the Roman lieutenant-general. They demanded of Attalus, that, in pursuance of the treaty, he should supply them with one thousand soldiers, which number he had engaged for on condition of their taking part in the war against Philip. This was refused to the Aetolians, because on their part they had formerly showed themselves unwilling to march out to ravage Macedonia, at a time when Philip, being employed near Pergamus in destroying by fire every thing sacred and profane, they might have compelled him to retire from thence, in order to preserve his own territories. Thus, instead of aid, the Aetolians were dismissed with hopes, the Romans making them large promises. Apustius with Attalus returned to the ships, where they began to concert measures for the siege of Oreus. This city was well secured by fortifications; and also, as an attempt had formerly been made on it, by a strong garrison. After the taking of Andros, twenty Rhodian ships, all decked vessels, had formed a junction with them, under the command of Agesimbrotus. This squadron they sent to the station off Zelasium, a promontory of Isthmia, very conveniently situate beyond Demetrias, in order that, if the ships of the Macedonians should attempt any movement, they might act as a defensive force. Heraclides, the king's admiral, kept his fleet there, rather with a view of laying hold of any advantage which the negligence of the enemy might afford him, than with a design of attempting any thing by open force. The Romans and king Attalus carried on their attacks against Oreus on different sides; the Romans against the citadel next to the sea, the king's troops against the lower part of the town, lying between the two citadels, where the city is also divided by a wall. As their posts were different, so were their methods of attack: the Romans made their approaches by means of covered galleries, applying also the ram to the walls; the king's troops, by throwing in weapons with the balista, catapulta, and every other kind of engine, and stones also of immense weight. They formed mines, too, and made use of every expedient, which, on trial, had been found useful in the former siege. On the other side, not only did more Macedonians protect the town and the citadels, than on the former occasion, but they exerted themselves with greater spirit, in consequence of the reprimands which they had received from the king for the misconduct they had committed, and also from remembrance both of his threats and promises with regard to the future. Thus, when time was being consumed there, contrary to their expectation, and there was more hope from a siege and works than from a sudden assault, the lieutenant-general thought that in the mean time some other business might be accomplished; wherefore, leaving such a number of men as seemed sufficient to finish the works, he passed over to the nearest part of the continent, and, arriving unexpectedly, made himself master of Larissa, except the citadel,--not that celebrated city in Thessaly, but another, which they call Cremaste. Attalus also surprised Aegeleos, where nothing was less apprehended than such an enterprise during the siege of another city. The works at Oreus had now begun to take effect, while the garrison within were almost spent with unremitted toil, (keeping watch both by day and night,) and also with wounds. Part of the wall, being loosened by the strokes of the ram, had fallen down in many places; and the Romans, during the night, broke into the citadel through the breach which lay over the harbour. Attalus, likewise, at the first light, on a signal given from the citadel by the Romans, himself also assaulted the city, where great part of the walls had been levelled; on which the garrison and townsmen fled into the other citadel, and a surrender was made two days after. The city fell to the king, the prisoners to the Romans.

Leaving the fleet there, they entered the Malian bay with ten light ships to discuss with the Aetolians how to conduct the war. Sipyrrhicas, the Aetolian, led the delegation that came to Heraclea to consult with the king and the Roman lieutenant-general. They requested Attalus to provide them with one thousand soldiers as specified in the treaty, which he had agreed to on the condition that they join the fight against Philip. This request was denied to the Aetolians because they had previously been unwilling to march into Macedonia when Philip was busy destroying everything sacred and profane near Pergamus, and they could have forced him to retreat to protect his own territories. Instead of receiving aid, the Aetolians were sent away with promises, as the Romans made them generous offers. Apustius and Attalus returned to the ships, where they started planning the siege of Oreus. This city was well fortified and, having previously been targeted, had a strong garrison. After taking Andros, twenty Rhodian ships, all fully decked, joined them under the command of Agesimbrotus. This squadron was sent to Zelasium, a promontory of Isthmia, conveniently located beyond Demetrias, so they could act as a defensive force if the Macedonian ships attempted any maneuvers. Heraclides, the king's admiral, stationed his fleet there with the goal of exploiting any opportunities that the enemy's negligence might offer, rather than making any aggressive moves. The Romans and King Attalus launched their attacks on Oreus from different directions; the Romans targeted the citadel closest to the sea while the king's troops focused on the lower part of the town situated between the two citadels, which was also divided by a wall. Their positions influenced their methods of attack: the Romans used covered galleries and rams against the walls, while the king's troops utilized balistas, catapults, and other siege engines to bombard the walls, in addition to throwing heavy stones. They also dug tunnels and employed every tactic that had proven effective in previous sieges. Meanwhile, not only were there more Macedonians defending the town and citadels than before, but they also fought with increased determination due to reprimands from the king about their past failures, as well as memories of his threats and promises regarding their future performance. As time dragged on there unexpectedly, and hope for a breakthrough through siege tactics grew more promising than a sudden attack, the lieutenant-general believed it was possible to pursue another objective; thus, he left enough men to complete the siege works and crossed over to the nearest part of the mainland, unexpectedly taking control of Larissa, except for the citadel—not the famous city in Thessaly, but another one they called Cremaste. Attalus also captured Aegeleos, where no one expected such an operation while they were still besieging another city. The efforts at Oreus began to show results, and the garrison inside was nearly exhausted from continuous labor (keeping watch day and night) and injuries. Parts of the wall, weakened by the ram's strikes, had collapsed in many areas; and during the night, the Romans broke into the citadel through a breach near the harbor. At first light, after receiving a signal from the citadel by the Romans, Attalus himself attacked the city, where large sections of the walls had been demolished. Consequently, the garrison and the townspeople fled to the other citadel, and they surrendered two days later. The city was awarded to the king, and the prisoners to the Romans.

47

The autumnal equinox now approached, and the Euboean gulf, called Coela, is reckoned dangerous by mariners. Choosing, therefore, to remove thence before the winter storms came on, they returned to Piraeus, from whence they had set out for the campaign. Apustius, leaving there thirty ships, sailed by Malea to Corcyra. The king was delayed during the celebration of the mysteries of Ceres, that he might assist at the solemnities, immediately after which he also retired into Asia, sending home Agesimbrotus and the Rhodians. Such, during that summer, were the proceedings, by sea and land, of the Roman consul and lieutenant-general, aided by Attalus and the Rhodians, against Philip and his allies. The other consul, Caius Aurelius, on coming into his province and finding the war there already brought to a conclusion, did not dissemble his resentment against the praetor, for having proceeded to action in his absence; wherefore, sending him away to Etruria, he led on the legions into the enemy's country, and, by laying it waste, carried on the war with more spoil than glory. Lucius Furius, finding nothing in Etruria that could give him employment, and at the same time intent on obtaining a triumph for his success against the Gauls, which he considered would be more easily accomplished in the absence of the consul, who envied and was enraged against him, came to Rome unexpectedly, and called a meeting of the senate in the temple of Bellona; where, after making a recital of the services which he had performed, he demanded to be allowed to enter the city in triumph.

The autumn equinox was approaching, and sailors considered the Euboean Gulf, known as Coela, to be dangerous. So, they decided to leave before the winter storms hit and returned to Piraeus, where they had set out for the campaign. Apustius, leaving thirty ships there, sailed around Malea to Corcyra. The king was held up during the celebration of the mysteries of Ceres so that he could take part in the ceremonies, and right after that, he went back to Asia, sending Agesimbrotus and the Rhodians home. Such were the actions, both at sea and on land, of the Roman consul and lieutenant-general, supported by Attalus and the Rhodians, against Philip and his allies during that summer. The other consul, Caius Aurelius, arrived in his province and, finding the war already over, couldn't hide his anger towards the praetor for taking action while he was away. Therefore, he sent the praetor off to Etruria and led the legions into enemy territory, causing destruction in more of a spoil than glory. Lucius Furius found nothing to do in Etruria and was focused on securing a triumph for his success against the Gauls, thinking it would be easier to do so without the consul, who was jealous and furious with him. He unexpectedly arrived in Rome and called a senate meeting in the temple of Bellona, where he recounted his achievements and asked to be allowed to enter the city in triumph.

48

With a great part of the senate he prevailed, owing to private interest and the importance of his services. The elder part refused him a triumph, both "because the army, with which he had acted, belonged to another; and because he had left his province through an ambitious desire of snatching that opportunity of procuring a triumph,--but that he had taken this course without any precedent." The senators of consular rank particularly insisted, that "he ought to have waited for the consul; for that he might, by pitching his camp near the city, and thereby securing the colony without coming to an engagement, have protracted the affair until his arrival; and that, what the praetor had not done, the senate ought to do; they should wait for the consul. After hearing the business discussed by the consul and praetor in their presence, they would be able, more correctly, to form judgment on the case." Great part were of opinion, that the senate ought to consider nothing but the service performed, and whether he had performed it while in office, and under his own auspices. For, "when of two colonies, which had been opposed, as barriers, to restrain the tumultuous inroads of the Gauls, one had been already sacked and burned, the flames being ready to spread (as if from an adjoining house) to the other colony, which lay so near, what ought the praetor to have done? For if it was improper to enter on any action without the consul, then the senate had acted wrong in giving the army to the praetor; because, if they chose that the business should be performed, not under the praetor's auspices, but the consul's, they might have limited the decree in such a manner, that not the praetor, but the consul, should manage it; or else the consul had acted wrong, who, after ordering the army to remove from Etruria into Gaul, did not meet it at Ariminum, in order to be present at operations, which were not allowed to be performed without him. But the exigencies of war do not wait for the delays and procrastinations of commanders; and battles must be sometimes fought, not because commanders choose it, but because the enemy compels it. The fight itself, and the issue of the fight, is what ought to be regarded now. The enemy were routed and slain, their camp taken and plundered, the colony relieved from a siege, the prisoners taken from the other colony recovered and restored to their friends, and an end put to the war in one battle. And not only men rejoiced at this victory, but the immortal gods also had supplications paid to them, for the space of three days, on account of the business of the state having been wisely and successfully, not rashly and unfortunately, conducted by Lucius Furius, praetor. Besides, the Gallic wars were, by some fatality, destined to the Furian family."

With a large portion of the Senate on his side, he succeeded due to personal interests and the significance of his contributions. The older members denied him a triumph, saying "because the army he had served with belonged to someone else, and because he had left his province driven by a desire to seize the chance for a triumph—taking this course without any precedent." Senators of consular rank particularly argued that "he should have waited for the consul; by camping near the city, he could have secured the colony without engaging in battle, and delayed the situation until the consul's arrival; what the praetor hadn't done, the Senate should do; they should wait for the consul. After hearing the consul and praetor discuss the matter in their presence, they would be able to judge the situation more accurately." Many believed that the Senate should consider only the service rendered, and whether he had done so while in office and under his own authority. "When two colonies stood as barriers against the tumultuous invasions of the Gauls, and one had already been attacked and burned, with the flames nearly spreading to the other nearby colony, what should the praetor have done? If it was wrong to act without the consul, then the Senate was mistaken in giving the army to the praetor; because if they wanted the actions to be carried out not under the praetor's authority but the consul's, they could have limited the decree so that the consul would manage it instead of the praetor; or else the consul was wrong for not meeting the army at Ariminum after ordering it to move from Etruria into Gaul, to oversee the operations that couldn't happen without him. However, the demands of war don't wait for the delays of leaders; battles sometimes have to be fought, not because the leaders want to, but because the enemy forces them to. What should be focused on now is the battle itself and the outcome. The enemy was defeated and killed, their camp captured and looted, the colony freed from siege, the prisoners taken from the other colony rescued and returned to their friends, and the war ended in one battle. Not only did people celebrate this victory, but the immortal gods were also honored with supplications for three days due to the state business being wisely and successfully managed, rather than rashly and unfortunately, by Lucius Furius, the praetor. Additionally, the Gallic wars seemed destined by some misfortune for the Furian family."

49

By means of discourses of this kind, made by him and his friends, the interest of the praetor, who was present, prevailed over the dignity of the absent consul, and the majority decreed a triumph to Lucius Furius. Lucius Furius, praetor, during his office, triumphed over the Gauls. He carried into the treasury three hundred and twenty thousand asses,[4] and one hundred and seventy thousand pounds' weight of silver. There were neither any prisoners led before his chariot, nor spoils carried before him, nor did any soldiers follow him. It appeared that every thing, except the victory, belonged to the consul. The games which Publius Scipio had vowed when consul in Africa, were then celebrated, in a magnificent manner and with respect to the lands for his soldiers, it was decreed, that whatever number of years each of them had served in Spain or in Africa, he should, for every year, receive two acres; and that ten commissioners should distribute that land. Three commissioners were then appointed to fill up the number of colonists at Venusia, because the strength of that colony had been reduced in the war with Hannibal: Caius Terentius Varro, Titus Quintius Flamininus, Publius Cornelius, son of Cneius Scipio, enrolled the colonists for Venusia. During the same year, Caius Cornelius Cethegus, who in the capacity of proconsul commanded in Spain, routed a numerous army of the enemy in the territory of Sedeta; in which battle, it is said, that fifteen thousand Spaniards were slain, and seventy-eight military standards taken. The consul Caius Aurelius, on returning from his province to Rome to hold the elections, made heavy complaints, not on the subject on which they had supposed he would, that the senate had not waited for his coming, nor allowed him an opportunity of arguing the matter with the praetor; but, that "the senate had decreed a triumph in such a manner, without hearing the report of any one of those who had taken part in the war, except the person who was to enjoy the triumph: that their ancestors had made it a rule that the lieutenant-generals, the military tribunes, the centurions, and even the soldiers, should be present at the triumph, in order that the Roman people might ascertain the reality of his exploits, to whom so high an honour was paid." Now, of that army which fought with the Gauls, had any one soldier, or even a soldier's servant, been present, of whom the senate could inquire how much of truth or falsehood was in the praetor's narrative? He then appointed a day for the elections, at which were chosen consuls, Lucius Cornelius Lentulus and Publius Villius Tappulus. The praetors were then appointed, Lucius Quintius Flamininus, Lucius Valerius Flaccus, Lucius Villius Tappulus, and Cneius Baebius Tamphilus.

Through discussions like this, held by him and his friends, the praetor's interest, who was present, outweighed the absent consul's dignity, and the majority voted to award a triumph to Lucius Furius. Lucius Furius, as praetor, celebrated a triumph over the Gauls during his term. He brought three hundred and twenty thousand asses into the treasury, along with one hundred and seventy thousand pounds of silver. There were no prisoners paraded before his chariot, no spoils carried ahead of him, and no soldiers followed him. It seemed that everything, except for the victory, belonged to the consul. The games that Publius Scipio had promised when he was consul in Africa were celebrated in a grand fashion, and it was decided that each of his soldiers would receive two acres of land for every year they had served in Spain or Africa. Ten commissioners were to distribute that land. Three commissioners were appointed to help recruit colonists for Venusia, as the strength of that colony had been weakened during the war with Hannibal: Caius Terentius Varro, Titus Quintius Flamininus, and Publius Cornelius, son of Cneius Scipio, enlisted the colonists for Venusia. In the same year, Caius Cornelius Cethegus, who was serving as proconsul in Spain, defeated a large enemy army in the territory of Sedeta; it is said that fifteen thousand Spaniards were killed, and seventy-eight military standards were captured. The consul Caius Aurelius, returning to Rome from his province to hold elections, expressed serious complaints not about what they assumed he would address—that the senate had not waited for him or allowed him to discuss matters with the praetor—but about how "the senate had awarded a triumph without hearing from anyone involved in the war, except the person who was being honored. Our ancestors had established that the lieutenant-generals, military tribunes, centurions, and even soldiers should be present at the triumph, so the Roman people could verify the reality of the achievements that merited such a high honor." Now, from the army that fought the Gauls, was there any soldier, or even a soldier's servant, present whom the senate could ask about the truth or falsehood in the praetor's account? He then set a day for the elections, where Lucius Cornelius Lentulus and Publius Villius Tappulus were chosen as consuls. The praetors appointed were Lucius Quintius Flamininus, Lucius Valerius Flaccus, Lucius Villius Tappulus, and Cneius Baebius Tamphilus.

50

During that year provisions were remarkably cheap. The curule aediles, Marcus Claudius Marcellus and Sextus Aelius Paetus, distributed among the people a vast quantity of corn, brought from Africa, at the rate of two asses a peck. They also celebrated the Roman games in a magnificent manner, repeating them a second day; and erected in the treasury five brazen statues out of the money paid as fines. The plebeian games were thrice repeated entire, by the aediles, Lucius Terentius Massa, and Cneius Baebius Tamphilus, who was elected praetor. There were also funeral games exhibited that year in the forum, for the space of four days, on occasion of the death of Marcus Valerius Laevinus, by his sons Publius and Marcus, who gave also a show of gladiators, in which twenty-five pairs fought. Marcus Aurelius Cotta, one of the decemviri of the sacred books, died, and Manius Acilius Glabrio was substituted in his room. It happened that both the curule aediles, who had been created at the elections, were persons who could not immediately undertake the office: for Caius Cornelius Cethegus was elected in his absence, when he was occupying Spain as his province; and Caius Valerius Flaccus, who was present, being flamen Dialis, could not take the oath of observing the laws; and no person was allowed to hold any office longer than five days without taking the oath. Flaccus petitioned to be excused from complying with the law, on which the senate decreed, that if the aedile produced a person approved of by the consuls, who would take the oath for him, the consuls, if they thought proper, should make application to the tribunes, that it might be proposed to the people. Lucius Valerius Flaccus, praetor elect, was produced to swear for his brother. The tribunes proposed to the commons, and the commons ordered that this should be as if the aedile himself had sworn. With regard to the other aedile, likewise, an order of the commons was made. On the tribunes putting the question, what two persons they chose should go and take the command of the armies in Spain, in order that Caius Cornelius, curule aedile, might come home to execute his office, and that Lucius Manlius Acidinus might, after many years, retire from the province; the commons ordered Cneius Cornelius Lentulus and Lucius Stertinius, proconsuls, to command in Spain.

During that year, food prices were surprisingly low. The curule aediles, Marcus Claudius Marcellus and Sextus Aelius Paetus, distributed a huge amount of corn from Africa to the people for just two asses a peck. They also held the Roman games in grand style, repeating them for a second day, and set up five bronze statues in the treasury using money collected from fines. The plebeian games were held three times in full by the aediles, Lucius Terentius Massa and Cneius Baebius Tamphilus, who was elected praetor. Additionally, there were funeral games in the forum for four days in honor of Marcus Valerius Laevinus, hosted by his sons Publius and Marcus, who also organized a gladiator show with twenty-five pairs fighting. Marcus Aurelius Cotta, one of the decemviri of the sacred books, passed away, and Manius Acilius Glabrio was appointed to take his place. It turned out that both newly elected curule aediles were unable to take office immediately: Caius Cornelius Cethegus was elected while he was away in Spain, and Caius Valerius Flaccus, who was present, could not take the oath of office because he was flamen Dialis. No one was allowed to hold an office for more than five days without taking the oath. Flaccus asked to be excused from this requirement, so the senate decided that if the aedile could present someone approved by the consuls to take the oath for him, the consuls could ask the tribunes to propose this to the people. Lucius Valerius Flaccus, the elected praetor, was brought in to swear for his brother. The tribunes proposed this to the public, and the public agreed that it should be as though the aedile himself had sworn. A similar order was made regarding the other aedile. When the tribunes asked who should go take command of the armies in Spain so that Caius Cornelius, the curule aedile, could return to perform his duties and Lucius Manlius Acidinus could leave after many years in the province, the public voted to send Cneius Cornelius Lentulus and Lucius Stertinius, proconsuls, to command in Spain.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXXII.


Successes of Titus Quinctius Flamininus against Philip; and of his brother Lucius with the fleet, assisted by Attalus and the Rhodians. Treaty of friendship with the Achaeans. Conspiracy of the slaves discovered and suppressed. The number of the praetors augmented to six. Defeat of the Insubrian Gauls by Cornelius Cethegus. Treaty of friendship with Nabis, tyrant of Lacedaemon. Capture of several cities in Macedonia.

       *        *        *        *        *

1

The consuls and praetors, having entered upon office on the ides of March, cast lots for the provinces. Italy fell to Lucius Cornelius Lentulus, Macedonia to Publius Villius. Of the praetors, the city jurisdiction fell to Lucius Quinctius, Ariminum to Cneius Baebius, Sicily to Lucius Valerius, Sardinia to Lucius Villius. The consul Lentulus was ordered to levy new legions; Villius, to receive the army from Publius Sulpicius; and, to complete its number, power was given him to raise as many men as he thought proper. To the praetor Baebius were decreed the legions which Caius Aurelius, late consul, had commanded, with directions that he should keep them in their present situation, until the consul should come with the new army to supply their place; and that, on his arriving in Gaul, all the soldiers who had served out their time should be sent home, except five thousand of the allies, which would be sufficient to protect the province round Ariminum. The command was continued to the praetors of the former year; to Cneius Sergius, that he might superintend the distribution of land to the soldiers who had served for many years in Spain, Sicily, and Sardinia; to Quintus Minucius, that he might finish the inquiries concerning the conspiracies in Bruttium, which, while praetor, he had managed with care and fidelity. That he should also send to Locri, to suffer punishment, those who had been convicted of sacrilege, and who were then in chains at Rome; and that he should take care, that whatever had been carried away from the temple of Proserpine should be replaced with expiations. The Latin festival was repeated in pursuance of a decree of the pontiffs, because ambassadors from Ardea had complained to the senate, that during the said solemnity they had not been supplied with meat as usual on the Alban mount. From Suessa an account was brought, that two of the gates, and the wall between them, had been struck with lightning. Messengers from Formiae related, that the temple of Jupiter had also been struck by lightning; from Ostia, likewise, news came of the like accident having happened to the temple of Jupiter there; it was said, too, that the temples of Apollo and Sancus, at Veliternum, were struck in like manner; and that in the temple of Hercules, hair had grown (on the statue). A letter was received from Quintus Minucius, propraetor, from Bruttium, that a foal had been born with five feet, and three chickens with three feet each. Afterwards a letter was brought from Macedonia, from Publius Sulpicius, proconsul, in which, among other matters, it was mentioned, that a laurel tree had sprung up on the poop of a ship of war. On occasion of the former prodigies, the senate had voted, that the consuls should offer sacrifices with the greater victims to such gods as they thought proper. On account of the last prodigy, alone, the aruspices were called before the senate, and, in pursuance of their answer, the people were ordered by proclamation to perform a supplication for one day, and worship was solemnized at all the shrines.

The consuls and praetors, having taken office on the Ides of March, drew lots for their provinces. Italy went to Lucius Cornelius Lentulus, and Macedonia to Publius Villius. Among the praetors, Lucius Quinctius got the city jurisdiction, Cneius Baebius took Ariminum, Lucius Valerius was assigned Sicily, and Lucius Villius received Sardinia. Consul Lentulus was instructed to raise new legions; Villius was to take over the army from Publius Sulpicius and was given the authority to recruit as many men as he deemed necessary. Praetor Baebius was assigned the legions commanded by Caius Aurelius, the former consul, with instructions to keep them in their current location until the consul arrived with the new army to replace them. Once he reached Gaul, all soldiers who had completed their service were to be sent home, except for five thousand allies, enough to safeguard the province around Ariminum. The previous year's praetors retained their commands; Cneius Sergius was to oversee land distribution for veterans from Spain, Sicily, and Sardinia; and Quintus Minucius was to finish the investigations into the conspiracies in Bruttium, which he had managed diligently as praetor. He was also instructed to send those convicted of sacrilege, currently chained in Rome, to Locri for punishment and to ensure that anything taken from the temple of Proserpine was returned alongside proper expiations. The Latin festival was repeated following a decree from the pontiffs because ambassadors from Ardea complained to the senate that they hadn't received their usual food during the celebration on the Alban mount. Reports came from Suessa that two gates and the wall between them had been struck by lightning. Messengers from Formiae reported that the temple of Jupiter had also been hit by lightning; similar news arrived from Ostia about their temple of Jupiter; it was said that the temples of Apollo and Sancus at Veliternum experienced the same fate, and that hair had grown on the statue in the temple of Hercules. A letter was received from Quintus Minucius, propraetor in Bruttium, stating that a foal was born with five feet and three chicks, each with three feet. Later, a letter from Macedonia, from Publius Sulpicius, proconsul, mentioned, among other things, that a laurel tree had sprouted on the stern of a warship. Following the earlier prodigies, the senate decided that the consuls should offer sacrifices with larger victims to whatever gods they deemed appropriate. Because of the last prodigy, the aruspices were summoned to the senate, and based on their response, the people were ordered by proclamation to hold a day of supplication, with worship observed at all the shrines.

2

This year, the Carthaginians brought to Rome the first payment of the silver imposed on them as a tribute; and the quaestors having reported, that it was not of the proper standard, and that, on the assay, it wanted a fourth part, they made up the deficiency with money borrowed at Rome. On their requesting that the senate would be pleased to order their hostages to be restored to them, a hundred were given up, and hopes were held out with relation to the rest, if they remained in fidelity (to the treaty). They then further requested, that the remaining hostages might be removed from Norba, where they were ill accommodated, to some other place, and they were permitted to remove to Signia and Ferentinum. The request of the people of Gades was likewise complied with: that a governor should not be sent to their city; being contrary to what had been agreed with them by Lucius Marcius Septimus, when they came under the protection of the Roman people. Deputies from Narnia, complaining that they had not their due number of settlers, and that several who were not of their community, had crept in among them, and were conducting themselves as colonists, Lucius Cornelius, the consul, was ordered to appoint three commissioners to adjust those matters. The three appointed were, Publius and Sextus Aelius, both surnamed Paetus, and Caius Cornelius Lentulus. The favour granted to the Narnians, of filling up their number of colonists, was refused to the people of Cossa, who applied for it.

This year, the Carthaginians brought the first payment of the silver tribute they owed to Rome. The quaestors reported that it didn’t meet the proper standard and lacked a quarter of its value after being tested, so they covered the shortfall with borrowed money from Rome. When they asked the senate to return their hostages, a hundred were released, and there was hope for more if they remained loyal to the treaty. They also requested to move the rest of the hostages from Norba, where conditions were poor, to other locations, and they were allowed to relocate to Signia and Ferentinum. The request from the people of Gades was also met: they asked not to have a governor sent to their city, as it went against what Lucius Marcius Septimus had agreed to when they accepted Roman protection. Deputies from Narnia complained that they didn’t have enough settlers and that some outsiders were living among them as colonists. Lucius Cornelius, the consul, was ordered to appoint three commissioners to resolve these issues. The appointed commissioners were Publius and Sextus Aelius, both called Paetus, and Caius Cornelius Lentulus. The request from the Narnians to increase their number of colonists was denied to the people of Cossa, who had also applied for it.

3

The consuls, having finished the business that was to be done at Rome, set out for their provinces. Publius Villius, on coming into Macedonia, found the soldiers in a violent mutiny, which had been previously excited, and not sufficiently repressed at the commencement. They were the two thousand who, after Hannibal had been vanquished, had been transported from Africa to Sicily, and then, in about a year after, into Macedonia, as volunteers; they denied, however, that this was done with their consent, affirming, that "they had been put on board the ships, by the tribunes, contrary to their remonstrances; but, in what manner soever they had become engaged in that service, whether it had been voluntarily undertaken or imposed on them, the time of it was now expired, and it was reasonable that some end should be put to their warfare. For many years they had not seen Italy, but had grown old under arms in Sicily, Africa, and Macedonia; they were now, in short, worn out with labour and fatigue, and were exhausted of their blood by the many wounds they had received." The consul told them, that "the grounds on which they demanded their discharge, appeared to him to be reasonable, if the demand had been made in a moderate manner; but that neither that, nor any other ground, was a justifying cause of mutiny. Wherefore, if they were contented to adhere to their standards, and obey orders, he would write to the senate concerning their release; and that what they desired would more easily be obtained by moderation than by turbulence."

The consuls, having wrapped up their business in Rome, set off for their provinces. When Publius Villius arrived in Macedonia, he found the soldiers in a severe mutiny that had started earlier and had not been properly managed at the beginning. These were the two thousand men who, after Hannibal's defeat, had been moved from Africa to Sicily, and then about a year later to Macedonia as volunteers. However, they claimed that they were not on board the ships by their own choice, insisting that "the tribunes had forced them onto the ships against their protests. Regardless of how they ended up in this service, whether it was voluntary or imposed on them, their time had now run out, and it made sense to put an end to their fighting. They hadn’t seen Italy in many years and had grown old in Sicily, Africa, and Macedonia; they were now, in short, worn out from hard work and fatigue, and they were drained from the many wounds they had suffered." The consul told them that "the reasons for their request for discharge seemed reasonable to him, if they had been made in a calm manner; but neither that nor any other reason justified a mutiny. Therefore, if they were willing to stick to their standards and follow orders, he would write to the senate about their release, and what they wanted would be more easily achieved through calmness rather than chaos."

4

At this time, Philip was pushing on the siege of Thaumaci, with the utmost vigour, by means of mounds and engines, and was ready to bring up the ram to the walls, when he was obliged to relinquish the undertaking by the sudden arrival of the Aetolians, who, under the command of Archidamus, having made their way into the town between the posts of the Macedonians, never ceased, day or night, making continual sallies, sometimes against the guards, sometimes against the works of the besiegers. They were at the same time favoured by the very nature of the place: for Thaumaci stands near the road from Thermopylae, and the Malian bay as you go through Lamia, on a lofty eminence, hanging immediately over the narrow pass which the Thessalians call Caela.[5] After passing through the craggy grounds of Thessaly, the roads are rendered intricate by the windings of the valleys, and on the near approach to the city, such an immense plain opens at once to view, like a vast sea, that the eye can scarcely reach the bounds of the expanse beneath From this surprising prospect it was called Thaumaci.[6] The city itself is secured, not only by the height of its situation, but by its standing on a rock, the stone of which had been cut away on all sides. These difficulties, and the prize not appearing sufficient to recompense so much toil and danger, caused Philip to desist from the attempt. The winter also was approaching; he therefore retired from thence, and led back his troops into winter quarters, in Macedonia.

At this point, Philip was aggressively continuing the siege of Thaumaci using mounds and siege engines and was set to bring up the battering ram to the walls when he had to abandon the effort due to the unexpected arrival of the Aetolians. Under the leadership of Archidamus, they managed to slip into the town between the Macedonian outposts and kept launching attacks day and night, sometimes against the guards and other times against the siege works. They also benefited from the natural features of the area: Thaumaci is located near the road from Thermopylae and the Malian bay as you pass through Lamia, perched high on a cliff that overlooks the narrow pass known as Caela in Thessaly. After navigating the rugged terrain of Thessaly, the roads become complicated with the twists and turns of the valleys, and as one approaches the city, a vast plain suddenly opens up, resembling a huge sea that seems to stretch endlessly. This surprising view is what gave Thaumaci its name. The city itself is protected not only by its elevation but also by being situated on a rock that has been cut away on all sides. These challenges, combined with the prize not seeming to justify the effort and risk involved, led Philip to give up the siege. With winter approaching, he retreated and brought his troops back into winter quarters in Macedonia.

5

There, whilst others, glad of any interval of rest, consigned both body and mind to repose, Philip, in proportion as the season of the year had relieved him from the incessant fatigues of marching and fighting, found his care and anxiety increase the more, when he turned his thoughts towards the general issue of the war. He dreaded, not only his enemies, who pressed him hard by land and sea, but also the dispositions, sometimes of his allies, at others of his own subjects, lest the former might be induced, by hopes of friendship with the Romans, to revolt, and the Macedonians themselves be seized with a desire of innovation. Wherefore, he despatched ambassadors to the Achaeans, both to require their oath, (for it had been made an article of their agreement that they should take an oath prescribed by Philip every year,) and at the same time to restore to them Orchomenes, Heraea, and Triphylia. To the Eleans he delivered up Aliphera; which city, they insisted, had never belonged to Triphylia, but ought to be restored to them, having been one of those that were incorporated by the council of the Arcadians for the founding of Megalopolis. These measures had the effect of strengthening his connexion with the Achaeans. The affections of the Macedonians he conciliated by his treatment of Heraclides: for, finding that his having countenanced this man had been the cause to him of the utmost unpopularity, he charged him with a number of crimes, and threw him into chains, to the great joy of the people. It was now, if at any time, that he made preparations for the war with especial energy. He exercised both the Macedonian and mercenary troops in arms, and in the beginning of spring sent Athenagoras, with all the foreign auxiliaries and what light-armed troops there were, through Epirus into Chaonia, to seize the pass at Antigonia, which the Greeks called Stena. He followed, in a few days, with the heavy troops: and having viewed every situation in the country, he judged that the most advantageous post for fortifying himself was on the river Aous. This river runs in a narrow vale, between two mountains, one of which the natives call Aeropus, and the other Asnaus, affording a passage of very little breadth along the bank. He ordered Athenagoras, with the light infantry, to take possession of Asnaus, and to fortify it. His own camp he pitched on Aeropus. Those places where the rocks were steep, were defended by guards of a few soldiers only; the less secure he strengthened, some with trenches, some with ramparts, and others with towers. A great number of engines, also, were disposed in proper places, that, by means of weapons thrown from these, they might keep the enemy at a distance. The royal pavilion was pitched on the outside of the rampart, on the most conspicuous eminence, in order, by this show of confidence, to dishearten the foe, and raise the hopes of his own men.

There, while others, happy for any break to rest, gave both their bodies and minds a chance to relax, Philip, as the season changed and relieved him from the relentless exhaustion of marching and fighting, found his worries and anxieties only growing. He feared not just his enemies who were pressing him hard on land and sea, but also the actions of his allies and sometimes his own people. He worried that the allies might be tempted to turn against him, seeking friendship with the Romans, and that the Macedonians might become restless for change. So, he sent ambassadors to the Achaeans to demand their oath (as it was part of their agreement to take an oath from Philip every year) and at the same time to return Orchomenes, Heraea, and Triphylia to them. He also handed over Aliphera to the Eleans, who claimed it had never belonged to Triphylia but should be returned to them since it was one of the cities included by the Arcadian council for the foundation of Megalopolis. These actions helped strengthen his relationship with the Achaeans. He won over the Macedonians by dealing with Heraclides: realizing that supporting this man had made him extremely unpopular, he accused him of several crimes and imprisoned him, which made the people very happy. It was now more than ever that he prepared for war with great energy. He trained both the Macedonian and mercenary troops in combat and, at the start of spring, sent Athenagoras with all the foreign auxiliaries and any light-armed troops into Epirus towards Chaonia to secure the pass at Antigonia, known to the Greeks as Stena. He followed a few days later with the heavy troops; after surveying the region, he decided that the best location for fortifying himself was by the river Aous. This river flows through a narrow valley between two mountains, one of which the locals call Aeropus and the other Asnaus, allowing only a small passage along the bank. He instructed Athenagoras to take control of Asnaus and fortify it. He set up his camp on Aeropus. Places where the cliffs were steep were guarded by only a few soldiers, while the more vulnerable areas were reinforced with trenches, ramparts, and towers. Many machines were also positioned in suitable locations to keep the enemy at bay by launching projectiles from them. The royal tent was set up outside the rampart on the highest point to intimidate the enemy and boost the morale of his own soldiers.

6

The consul having received intelligence from Charopus of Epirus, on what pass the king had taken his position with his army, as soon as the spring began to open, left Corcyra, where he had passed the winter, and, sailing over to the continent, led on his army against the enemy. When he came within about five miles of the king's camp, leaving the legions in a strong post, he went forward in person with some light troops, to view the nature of the country; and, on the day following, held a council, in order to determine whether he should attempt a passage through the defiles occupied by the enemy, notwithstanding the great labour and danger which the proposal involved, or lead round his forces by the same road through which Sulpicius had penetrated into Macedonia the year before. The deliberations on this question had lasted several days, when news arrived, that Titus Quinctius had been elected consul; that he had obtained, by lot, Macedonia as his province; and that, hastening his journey, he had already come over to Corcyra. Valerius Antias says, that Villius marched into the defile, and that, as he could not proceed straight forward, because every pass was occupied by the king, he followed the course of a valley, through the middle of which the river Aous flows, and having hastily constructed a bridge, passed over to the bank where the king's camp was, and fought a battle with him; that the king was routed and driven out of his camp; that twelve thousand of the enemy were killed, and two thousand two hundred taken, together with a hundred and thirty-two military standards, and two hundred and thirty horses. He adds, that, during the battle, a temple was vowed to Jupiter in case of success. The other historians, both Greek and Latin, (all those at least whose accounts I have read,) affirm that nothing memorable was done by Villius, and that Titus Quinctius, the consul who succeeded him, received from him a war which had yet to be commenced.

The consul got word from Charopus of Epirus about where the king had set up his army. As soon as spring started, he left Corcyra, where he had spent the winter, and sailed to the mainland to lead his troops against the enemy. When he was about five miles from the king's camp, he left the legions in a strong position and went ahead with some light troops to scout the area. The next day, he held a meeting to decide whether he should try to get through the enemy-occupied passes, despite the significant challenges and risks involved, or take his forces along the same route Sulpicius had used to enter Macedonia the previous year. They debated this issue for several days when news came that Titus Quinctius had been elected consul, had drawn Macedonia as his province, and was hurriedly traveling, already making his way to Corcyra. Valerius Antias reports that Villius went into the pass and, unable to move straight ahead because every path was blocked by the king, followed the valley where the river Aous flows. He quickly built a bridge to cross to the bank where the king's camp was and fought a battle with him. The king was defeated and pushed out of his camp; twelve thousand enemy soldiers were killed, two thousand two hundred were captured, along with one hundred and thirty-two military standards and two hundred and thirty horses. He adds that during the battle, a temple was vowed to Jupiter if they were successful. Other historians, both Greek and Latin, (at least those whose accounts I’ve read) claim that Villius accomplished nothing significant and that Titus Quinctius, the consul who took over from him, inherited a war that had yet to begin.

7

During the time of these transactions in Macedonia, the other consul, Lucius Lentulus, who had stayed at Rome, held an assembly for the election of censors. Out of many illustrious men who stood candidates, were chosen Publius Cornelius Scipio Africanus and Publius Aelius Paetus. These, acting together in perfect harmony, read the list of the senate, without passing a censure on any one member; they also let to farm the port-duties at Capua, and at Puteoli, and of the fort situate were the city now stands; enrolling for this latter place three hundred colonists, that being the number fixed by the senate; they also sold the lands of Capua, which lie at the foot of Mount Tifata. About the same time, Lucius Manlius Acidinus, on his return from Spain, was hindered from entering the city in ovation by Marcus Portius Laeca, plebeian tribune, notwithstanding he had obtained permission of the senate: coming, then, into the city in a private character, he conveyed to the treasury one thousand two hundred pounds' weight of silver, and about thirty pounds' weight of gold. During this year, Cneius Baebius Tamphilus, who had succeeded to the government of the province of Gaul, in the room of Caius Aurelius, consul of the year preceding, having, without proper caution, entered the territories of the Insubrian Gauls, was surprised with almost the whole of his army. He lost above six thousand six hundred men,--so great a loss was received from a war which had now ceased to be an object of apprehension. This event called away the consul, Lucius Lentulus, from the city; who, arriving in the province, which was filled with confusion, and taking the command of the army, which he found dispirited by its defeat, severely reprimanded the praetor, and ordered him to quit the province and return to Rome. Neither did the consul himself perform any considerable service, being called home to preside at the elections, which were obstructed by Marcus Fulvius and Manius Curius, plebeian tribunes, who wished to hinder Titus Quinctius Flamininus from standing candidate for the consulship, after passing through the office of quaestor. They alleged, that "the aedileship and praetorship were now held in contempt, and that the nobility did not make their way to the consulship through the regular gradations of offices, thus affording a trial of themselves; but, passing over the intermediate steps, pushed at once from the lowest to the highest." From a dispute in the Field of Mars, the affair was brought before the senate, where it was voted, "that when a person sued for any post, which by the laws he was permitted to hold, the people had the right of choosing whoever they thought proper." To this decision of the senate the tribunes submitted, and thereupon Sextus Aelius Paetus and Titus Quinctius Flamininus were elected consuls. Then was held the election of praetors. The persons chosen were, Lucius Cornelius Merula, Marcus Claudius Marcellus, Marcus Porcius Cato, and Caius Helvius, who had been plebeian aediles. By these the plebeian games were repeated, and, on occasion of the games, a feast of Jupiter was celebrated. The curule aediles, also, Caius Valerius Flaccus, who was flamen of Jupiter, and Caius Cornelius Cethegus, celebrated the Roman games with great magnificence. Servius and Caius Sulpicius Galba, pontiffs, died this year; in their room were substituted Marcus Aemilius Lepidus and Cneius Cornelius Scipio, as pontiffs.

During the time of these events in Macedonia, the other consul, Lucius Lentulus, who stayed in Rome, called a meeting to elect censors. Among the many distinguished candidates, Publius Cornelius Scipio Africanus and Publius Aelius Paetus were chosen. Working together in perfect harmony, they reviewed the list of senators without criticizing any member; they also leased the port duties at Capua and Puteoli, as well as the fort where the city now stands, enrolling three hundred colonists, the number specified by the senate. They sold the lands of Capua at the base of Mount Tifata. Around the same time, Lucius Manlius Acidinus, returning from Spain, was prevented from entering the city in triumph by Marcus Portius Laeca, a plebeian tribune, even though he had received permission from the senate. Entering the city in a private capacity, he brought to the treasury one thousand two hundred pounds of silver and about thirty pounds of gold. This year, Cneius Baebius Tamphilus, who took over the rule of the province of Gaul from Caius Aurelius, the consul from the previous year, recklessly entered the territories of the Insubrian Gauls and was ambushed with almost his entire army. He lost over six thousand six hundred men – such a significant loss from a war that had now become less threatening. This incident prompted consul Lucius Lentulus to leave the city; upon arriving in the troubled province and taking command of the demoralized army, he sternly reprimanded the praetor and ordered him to leave the province and return to Rome. The consul himself didn’t accomplish much, as he was called back to oversee the elections, which were being obstructed by Marcus Fulvius and Manius Curius, plebeian tribunes, who wanted to prevent Titus Quinctius Flamininus from running for consul after serving as quaestor. They claimed that "the positions of aediles and praetors were now looked down upon, and the nobility were bypassing the usual steps to the consulship, rushing from the lowest positions straight to the highest." A dispute arose in the Field of Mars, and the matter was brought before the senate, which voted that "when someone applied for any position they were legally allowed to hold, the people had the right to choose whoever they thought was appropriate." The tribunes accepted this decision, leading to the election of Sextus Aelius Paetus and Titus Quinctius Flamininus as consuls. Then the election for praetors was held. The chosen ones were Lucius Cornelius Merula, Marcus Claudius Marcellus, Marcus Porcius Cato, and Caius Helvius, who had been plebeian aediles. They repeated the plebeian games, and in connection with the games, a feast for Jupiter was held. The curule aediles, Caius Valerius Flaccus, who was flamen of Jupiter, and Caius Cornelius Cethegus, celebrated the Roman games with great splendor. Servius and Caius Sulpicius Galba, pontiffs, died this year; Marcus Aemilius Lepidus and Cneius Cornelius Scipio were appointed as their replacements as pontiffs.

8

The new consuls, Sextus Aelius Paetus and Titus Quinctius Flamininus, on assuming the administration, convened the senate in the Capitol, and the fathers decreed, that "the consuls should settle between themselves or cast lots for the provinces, Macedonia and Italy. That he to whom Macedonia fell should enlist, as a supplement to the legions, three thousand Roman footmen and three hundred horse, and also five thousand footmen and five hundred horsemen belonging to the Latin confederacy." The army assigned to the other consul was to consist entirely of newly-raised men. Lucius Lentulus, consul of the preceding year, was continued in command, and was ordered not to depart from the province, nor to remove the old army, until the consul should arrive with the new legions. The consuls cast lots for the provinces, and Italy fell to Aelius, Macedonia to Quintius. Of the praetors, the lots gave to Lucius Cornelius Merula the city jurisdiction; to Marcus Claudius, Sicily; to Marcus Porcius, Sardinia; and to Caius Helvius, Gaul. The levying of troops was then begun, for besides the consular armies, the praetors had been ordered also to enlist men: for Marcellus, in Sicily, four thousand foot and three hundred horse of the Latin confederates; for Cato, in Sardinia, three thousand foot and two hundred horse of the same class of soldiers; with directions, that both these praetors, on their arrival in their provinces, should disband the veterans, both foot and horse. The consuls then introduced to the senate ambassadors from king Attalus. These, after representing that their king gave every assistance to the Roman arms on land and sea, with his fleet and all his forces, and had up to that day executed with zeal and obedience every order of the consuls, added, that "they feared it would not be in his power to continue so to do by reason of king Antiochus, for that Antiochus had invaded the kingdom of Attalus, when destitute of protective forces by sea and land. That Attalus, therefore, entreated the conscript fathers, if they chose to employ his army and navy in the Macedonian war, then to send a body of forces to protect his territories; or if that were not agreeable, to allow him to go home to defend his own possessions, with his fleet and troops." The following answer was ordered to be given to the ambassadors: that "it was a cause of gratitude to the senate that Attalus had assisted the Roman commanders with his fleet and other forces. That they would neither send succours to Attalus, against Antiochus, the ally and friend of the Roman people; nor would they detain the auxiliary troops longer than would be convenient to the king. That it was ever a constant rule with the Roman people, to use the aid of others so far only as was agreeable to the will of those who gave it; and even to leave the commencement and the termination of that aid at the discretion of those who desired that the Romans should be benefited by their help. That they would send ambassadors to Antiochus, to represent to him, that Attalus, with his fleet and army, were, at the present, employed by the Roman people against Philip, their common enemy; and that Antiochus would do that which was gratifying to the senate if he abstained from the kingdom of Attalus and desisted from the war; for that it was much to be wished, that kings who were allies and friends to the Roman people should maintain friendship between themselves also."

The new consuls, Sextus Aelius Paetus and Titus Quinctius Flamininus, took over the administration and called the senate to meet in the Capitol. The senators decided that "the consuls should either agree among themselves or draw lots for the provinces of Macedonia and Italy. The consul who received Macedonia should recruit an additional three thousand Roman foot soldiers and three hundred horsemen, along with five thousand foot soldiers and five hundred horsemen from the Latin confederacy." The army assigned to the other consul would be made up entirely of newly recruited soldiers. Lucius Lentulus, the consul from the previous year, was retained in command and ordered not to leave the province or disband the old army until the consul arrived with the new legions. The consuls drew lots for the provinces, and Aelius got Italy while Quintius got Macedonia. Of the praetors, the lots assigned Lucius Cornelius Merula to the city jurisdiction; Marcus Claudius to Sicily; Marcus Porcius to Sardinia; and Caius Helvius to Gaul. Recruitment for troops began, as the praetors were also directed to enlist soldiers: Marcellus in Sicily was to gather four thousand foot soldiers and three hundred horse from the Latin confederates, while Cato in Sardinia was to enlist three thousand foot soldiers and two hundred horsemen of the same type, with instructions for both praetors to disband the veterans, both foot and horse, upon their arrival in their provinces. The consuls then presented ambassadors from King Attalus to the senate. The ambassadors explained that their king had provided all possible support to the Roman military on land and sea, with his fleet and forces, and had diligently followed every order from the consuls up until that day. They expressed concern that he might not be able to continue doing so due to King Antiochus, who had invaded Attalus's kingdom when it was unprotected by land and sea forces. Attalus therefore requested the senate to either send troops to protect his territories if they intended to use his army and navy in the Macedonian war, or if that was not feasible, to allow him to return home to defend his own lands with his fleet and troops. The senate instructed that the following response be given to the ambassadors: "It is a matter of gratitude for the senate that Attalus has supported the Roman commanders with his fleet and other resources. We will neither send aid to Attalus against Antiochus, who is an ally and friend of the Roman people, nor will we keep the auxiliary troops longer than is convenient for the king. It has always been a fundamental principle of the Roman people to use the assistance of others only as long as it aligns with the will of those giving it, and to leave the timing of that aid to the discretion of those who wish for the Romans to benefit from their support. We will send ambassadors to Antiochus to inform him that Attalus, with his fleet and army, is currently engaged by the Roman people against Philip, our common enemy; and it would please the senate if he refrained from invading Attalus’s kingdom and ceased hostilities, as it is highly desirable that kings who are allies and friends of the Roman people maintain peace among themselves."

9

When the consul Titus Quinctius had finished the levies, in making which he chose principally such as had served in Spain or Africa, that is, soldiers of approved courage, and when hastening to set forward to his province, he was delayed by reports of prodigies, and the expiations of them. There had been struck by lightning the public road at Veii, a temple of Jupiter at Lanuvium, a temple of Hercules at Ardea, with a wall and towers at Capua, also the edifice which is called Alba. At Arretium, the sky appeared as on fire; at Velitrae, the earth, to the extent of three acres, sunk down so as to form a vast chasm. From Suessa Aurunca, an account was brought of a lamb born with two heads; from Sinuessa, of a swine with a human head. On occasion of these ill omens, a supplication of one day's continuance was performed; the consuls gave their attention to divine services, and, as soon as the gods were appeased, set out for their provinces. Aelius, accompanied by Caius Helvius, praetor, went into Gaul, where he put under the command of the praetor the army which he received from Lucius Lentulus, and which he ought to have disbanded, intending to carry on his own operations with the new troops, which he had brought with him; but he effected nothing worth recording. The other consul, Titus Quinctius, setting sail from Brundusium earlier than had been usual with former consuls, reached Corcyra, with, eight thousand foot and eight hundred horse. From this place, he passed over, in a quinquereme, to the nearest part of Epirus, and proceeded, by long journeys, to the Roman camp. Here, having dismissed Villius, and waiting a few days, until the forces from Corcyra should come up and join him, he held a council, to determine whether he should endeavour to force his way straight forward through the camp of the enemy; or whether, without attempting an enterprise of so great difficulty and danger, he should not rather take a circuitous and safe road, so as to penetrate into Macedonia by the country of the Dassaretians and Lycus. The latter plan would have been adopted, had he not feared that, in removing to a greater distance from the sea, the enemy might slip out of his hands; and that if the king should resolve to secure himself in the woods and wilds, as he had done before, the summer might be spun out without any thing being effected. It was therefore determined, be the event what it might, to attack the enemy in their present post, disadvantageous as it was. But they more easily resolved on this measure, than devised any safe or certain method of accomplishing it.

When consul Titus Quinctius finished recruiting soldiers, focusing mainly on those who had served in Spain or Africa—experienced fighters known for their bravery—and was preparing to head to his province, he was held up by reports of strange omens and the rituals needed to address them. A lightning strike had hit the public road at Veii, a temple of Jupiter at Lanuvium, a temple of Hercules at Ardea, as well as a wall and towers at Capua, along with a building known as Alba. At Arretium, the sky looked on fire; at Velitrae, three acres of land sunk down to create a large chasm. Reports came in from Suessa Aurunca about a lamb born with two heads and from Sinuessa about a pig with a human head. In response to these bad omens, a one-day supplication was held; the consuls focused on divine services, and once the gods were appeased, they set out for their provinces. Aelius, along with praetor Caius Helvius, traveled to Gaul, where he put the army he received from Lucius Lentulus under the command of the praetor instead of disbanding it, planning to conduct his own operations with the new troops he had brought, but he achieved nothing notable. The other consul, Titus Quinctius, departed from Brundusium earlier than previous consuls and arrived at Corcyra with eight thousand infantry and eight hundred cavalry. From there, he crossed over in a quinquereme to the closest part of Epirus and journeyed to the Roman camp. After dismissing Villius and waiting a few days for the forces from Corcyra to arrive, he held a council to decide whether to push directly through the enemy's camp or to take a safer, longer route into Macedonia via the territory of the Dassaretians and Lycus. He would have preferred the latter option if he hadn’t feared losing sight of the enemy by moving farther from the sea, and if the king decided to hide in the woods as before, they might spend the summer achieving nothing. It was therefore decided, regardless of the outcome, to attack the enemy at their current position, despite its disadvantages. However, they found it easier to agree on this plan than to come up with a safe or certain way to execute it.

10

Forty days were passed in view of the enemy, without making any kind of effort. Hence Philip conceived hopes of bringing about a treaty of peace, through the mediation of the people of Epirus; and a council, which was held for the purpose, having appointed Pausanias, the praetor, and Alexander, the master of the horse, as negotiators, they brought the consul and the king to a conference, on the banks of the river Aous, where the channel was narrowest. The sum of the consul's demands was, that the king should withdraw his troops from the territories of the several states; that, to those whose lands and cities he had plundered, he should restore such of their effects as could be found; and that the value of the rest should be estimated by a fair arbitration. Philip answered, that "the cases of the several states differed widely from each other. That such as he himself had seized on, he would set at liberty; but he would not divest himself of the hereditary and just possessions which had been conveyed down to him from his ancestors. If those states, with whom hostilities had been carried on, complained of any losses in the war, he was ready to submit the matter to the arbitration of any state with whom both parties were at peace." To this the consul replied, that "the business required neither judge nor arbitrator: for to whom was it not evident that every injurious consequence of the war was to be imputed to him who first took up arms. And in this case Philip, unprovoked by any, had first commenced hostilities against all." When they next began to treat of those nations which were to be set at liberty, the consul named, first, the Thessalians: on which the king, fired with indignation, exclaimed, "What harsher terms, Titus Quinctius, could you impose on me if I were vanquished?" With these words he retired hastily from the conference, and they were with difficulty restrained by the river which separated them from assaulting each other with missile weapons. On the following day many skirmishes took place between parties sallying from the outposts, in a plain sufficiently wide for the purpose. Afterwards the king's troops drew back into narrow and rocky places, whither the Romans, keenly eager for fighting, penetrated also. These had in their favour order and military discipline, while their arms were of a kind well calculated for protecting their persons. In favour of the enemy were the advantage of ground, and their balistas and catapultas disposed on almost every rock as on walls. After many wounds given and received on both sides, and numbers being slain, as in a regular engagement, darkness put an end to the fight.

Forty days went by in sight of the enemy, without making any attempt to engage. As a result, Philip started to hope for a peace treaty, with help from the people of Epirus; a council was held for this purpose, appointing Pausanias, the praetor, and Alexander, the master of the horse, as negotiators. They brought the consul and the king together for a meeting by the banks of the Aous River, where it was narrowest. The consul's main demands were that the king should pull his troops out of the territories of the various states, return any plundered property to those whose lands and cities he had raided, and assess the value of the rest through fair arbitration. Philip replied that "the situations of the various states were very different from one another. He was willing to release any territory he had taken, but he couldn't give up the lawful possessions passed down to him from his ancestors. If the states that had been at war with him complained about losses, he was ready to take the issue to an arbitration by any state with which both parties had peace." The consul responded that "the issue needed neither judge nor arbitrator: it was clear that all the damaging consequences of the war fell on the one who initiated the conflict. In this instance, Philip began hostilities against everyone without any provocation." When they started discussing which nations should be freed, the consul named the Thessalians first, to which the king, filled with anger, shouted, "What harsher terms, Titus Quinctius, could you place on me if I had been defeated?" With that, he abruptly left the meeting, and they were barely held back by the river from attacking each other with missiles. The next day, several skirmishes broke out between groups coming from the outposts, in an open area suitable for combat. Later, the king's forces retreated to narrow and rocky places, which the eager Roman soldiers quickly followed. The Romans had the advantage of order and military discipline, and their armor was well-suited for protection. The enemy had the advantage of terrain, along with their ballistae and catapults positioned on nearly every rock as if they were walls. After inflicting and receiving many wounds, and with many casualties on both sides, darkness brought the fighting to an end.

11

While matters were in this state, a herdsman, sent by Charopus, prince of the Epirots, was brought to the consul. He said, that "being accustomed to feed his herd in the forest, then occupied by the king's camp, he knew every winding and path in the neighbouring mountains; and that if the consul thought proper to send some troops with him, he would lead them by a road, neither dangerous nor difficult, to a spot over the enemy's head." When the consul heard these things, he sent to Charopus to inquire if he considered that confidence might be placed in the rustic in so important a matter. Charopus ordered an answer to be returned, that he should give just so much credit to this man's account, as should still leave every thing rather in his own power than in that of the other. Though the consul rather wished than dared to give the intelligence full belief, and though his mind was possessed by mingled emotions of joy and fear, yet being moved by the confidence due to Charopus, he resolved to put to trial the prospect that was held out to him. In order to prevent all suspicion of the matter, during the two following days he carried on attacks against the enemy without intermission, drawing out troops against them in every quarter, and sending up fresh men to relieve the wearied. Then, selecting four thousand foot and three hundred horse, he put them under the command of a military tribune, with directions to advance the horse as far as the nature of the ground allowed; and when they came to places impassable to cavalry, then to post them in some plain; that the infantry should proceed by the road which the guide would show, and that when, according to his promise, they arrived on the height over the enemy's head, then they should give a signal by smoke, but raise no shout, until the tribune should have reason to think that, in consequence of the signal received from him, the battle was begun. He ordered that the march should take place by night, (the moon shining through the whole of it,) and employ the day in taking food and rest. The most liberal promises were made to the guide, provided he fulfilled his engagement; he bound him, nevertheless, and delivered him to the tribune. Having thus sent off this detachment, the Roman general exerted himself only the more vigorously in every part to make himself master of the posts of the enemy.

While things were at this point, a herdsman sent by Charopus, the prince of the Epirots, was brought to the consul. He said that since he normally grazed his herd in the forest, which was currently occupied by the king's camp, he was familiar with every winding path in the nearby mountains. He offered to lead some troops to a safe and easy route that would take them above the enemy. When the consul heard this, he sent a message to Charopus to ask if he believed the herdsman could be trusted with such an important task. Charopus replied that the consul should give the herdsman some credit, but still keep control of the situation in his own hands. Although the consul wanted to believe the information but hesitated to fully trust it, and was filled with mixed feelings of joy and fear, he decided to explore the opportunity presented to him, partly due to his trust in Charopus. To avoid raising any suspicions, he launched attacks against the enemy for the next two days without pause, sending troops to engage from various positions and rotating fresh soldiers to replace the tired ones. Then, selecting four thousand infantry and three hundred cavalry, he placed them under the command of a military tribune, instructing him to send the cavalry as far as the terrain allowed, and to position them in the open when they reached impassable ground. The infantry was to follow the guide along the route he would show, and when they arrived at a vantage point over the enemy, they were to signal with smoke but refrain from shouting until the tribune felt that the battle had started. He ordered that the march should take place at night (with the moon shining the whole time) and that they should rest and eat during the day. Generous promises were made to the guide, as long as he fulfilled his promise; however, he was still bound and handed over to the tribune. After sending off this detachment, the Roman general threw himself into making every effort to take control of the enemy's positions.

12

On the third day, the Roman party made the signal by smoke, to notify that they had gained possession of the eminence to which they had been directed; and then the consul, dividing his forces into three parts, marched up with the main strength of his army, through a valley in the middle, and made the wings on right and left advance to the camp of the enemy. Nor did these advance to meet him with less alacrity. The Roman soldiers, in the ardour of their courage, long maintained the fight on the outside of their works, for they had no small superiority in bravery, in skill, and in the nature of their arms; but when the king's troops, after many of them were wounded and slain, retreated into places secured either by intrenchments or situation, the danger reverted on the Romans, who pushed forward, inconsiderately, into disadvantageous grounds and defiles, out of which a retreat was difficult. Nor would they have extricated themselves without suffering for their rashness, had not the Macedonians, first, by a shout heard in their rear, and then by an attack begun on that quarter, been utterly dismayed and confounded at the unforeseen danger. Some betook themselves to a hasty flight: some, keeping their stand, rather because they could find no way for flight than that they possessed spirit to support the engagement, were cut off by the Romans, who pressed them hard both on front and rear. Their whole army might have been destroyed, had the victors continued their pursuit of the fugitives; but the cavalry were obstructed by the narrowness of the passes and the ruggedness of the ground; and the infantry, by the weight of their armour. The king at first fled with precipitation, and without looking behind him; but afterwards, when he had proceeded as far as five miles, he began, from recollecting the unevenness of the road, to suspect, (what was really the case,) that the enemy could not follow him; and halting, he despatched his attendants through all the hills and valleys to collect the stragglers together. His loss was not more than two thousand men. The rest of his army, coming to one spot, as if they had followed some signal, marched off, in a compact body, towards Thessaly. The Romans, after having pursued the enemy as far as they could with safety, killing such as they overtook, and despoiling the slain, seized and plundered the king's camp; which, even when it had no defenders, was difficult of access. The following night they were lodged within their own trenches.

On the third day, the Roman party signaled with smoke to let everyone know they had taken control of the high ground they were aiming for. Then the consul split his forces into three groups and led the main part of his army through a valley in the center, while the wings on both sides moved towards the enemy camp. The enemy met them with equal eagerness. The Roman soldiers, fueled by their courage, fought fiercely outside their defenses for an extended time, as they had a notable advantage in bravery, skill, and weaponry. However, once the king's troops, having taken many injuries and losses, retreated to areas protected by fortifications or natural barriers, the danger shifted back to the Romans, who recklessly pushed into difficult terrain where retreat was challenging. They wouldn't have made it out without suffering consequences for their rashness if it hadn't been for the Macedonians, who, first startled by a shout from their rear and then attacked from that direction, were completely thrown off by the unexpected threat. Some fled in a panic, while others stood their ground not out of bravery but because they had no escape route, and they were cut off by the Romans, who pressed hard on them from both front and back. The entire army could have been defeated if the victors had continued chasing the fleeing troops, but the cavalry was hindered by narrow paths and rough terrain, while the infantry struggled under the weight of their armor. The king initially fled in a panic without looking back, but after traveling about five miles, he began to worry—given the uneven road—that the enemy could not follow him. So he stopped and sent his men throughout the hills and valleys to round up the stragglers. He lost no more than two thousand men. The rest of his army regrouped in one place, as if following some signal, and marched together toward Thessaly. The Romans pursued the enemy as far as it was safe, killing those they caught and stripping the dead, before seizing and looting the king's camp, which was still difficult to access even without defenders. That night, they settled down in their own trenches.

13

Next day, the consul pursued the enemy through the same defiles through which the river winds its way among the valleys. The king came on the first day to the camp of Pyrrhus, a place so called in Triphylia, a district of Melotis; and on the following day he reached Mount Lingos, an immense march for his army, but his fear impelled him. This ridge of mountains belongs to Epirus, and stretches along between Macedonia and Thessaly; the side next to Thessaly faces the east, that next to Macedonia the north. These hills are thickly clad with woods, and on their summits have open plains and perennial streams. Here Philip remained encamped for several days, being unable to determine whether he should continue his retreat until he arrived in his own dominions, or whether he might venture back into Thessaly. At length, his decision leaned to leading down his army into Thessaly; and, going by the shortest roads to Tricca, he made hasty excursions from thence to all the cities within his reach. The inhabitants who were able to accompany him he summoned from their habitations, and burned the towns, allowing the owners to take with them such of their effects as they were able to carry; the rest became the prey of the soldiers; nor was there any kind of cruelty which they could have suffered from an enemy, that they did not suffer from these their confederates. These acts were painful to Philip even while he executed them; but as the country was soon to become the property of the foe, he wished to rescue out of it at least the persons of his allies. In this manner were ravaged the towns of Phacium, Iresiae, Euhydrium, Eretria, and Palaepharsalus. On his coming to Pherae, the gates were shut against him, and as it would necessarily occasion a considerable delay if he attempted to take it by force, and as he could not spare time, he dropped the design, and crossed over the mountains into Macedonia; for he had received intelligence, that the Aetolians too were marching towards him. These, on hearing of the battle fought on the banks of the river of Aous, first laid waste the nearest tracts round Sperchia, and Long Come, as they call it, and then, passing over into Thessaly, got possession of Cymine and Angeae at the first assault. From Metropolis they were repulsed by the inhabitants, who, while a part of their army was plundering the country, assembled in a body to defend the city. Afterwards, making an attempt on Callithera, they were attacked by the townsmen in a like manner; but withstood their onset with more steadiness, drove back into the town the party which had sallied, and content with that success, as they had no prospect whatever of taking the place by storm, retired. They then took by assault and sacked the towns of Theuma and Calathas. Acharrae they gained by surrender. Xyniae, through similar apprehensions, was abandoned by the inhabitants. These having forsaken their homes, and going together in a body, fell in with a party which was being marched to Thaumacus for the purpose of protecting their foragers; all of whom, an irregular and unarmed multitude, incapable of any resistance, were put to the sword by the troops. The deserted town of Xyniae was plundered. The Aetolians then took Cyphara, a fort conveniently situated on the confines of Dolopia. All this the Aetolians performed within the space of a few days.

The next day, the consul chased the enemy through the same narrow paths where the river flows through the valleys. The king reached Pyrrhus's camp on the first day, a place located in Triphylia, a region of Melotis; then on the following day, he arrived at Mount Lingos, which was a significant march for his army, but fear drove him on. This mountain range is part of Epirus and runs between Macedonia and Thessaly; the side facing Thessaly looks east, while the side facing Macedonia looks north. These hills are densely wooded and have clearings and permanent streams at their peaks. Philip camped there for several days, unsure whether he should keep retreating until he reached his own territory or risk going back into Thessaly. Eventually, he decided to lead his army into Thessaly; taking the shortest routes to Tricca, he made quick forays into all the nearby cities. He called on the inhabitants who could join him to leave their homes and burned the towns, letting the owners take what they could carry; everything else was taken by the soldiers, who inflicted every kind of cruelty on these allies that they could have suffered from an enemy. These actions pained Philip even as he carried them out, but since the land was about to fall into enemy hands, he wanted to at least save the people who were still his allies. This is how the towns of Phacium, Iresiae, Euhydrium, Eretria, and Palaepharsalus were devastated. When he arrived at Pherae, the gates were locked against him. Realizing that forcing the entry would cause significant delays he couldn't afford, he abandoned the plan and crossed the mountains into Macedonia, having learned that the Aetolians were also on the move toward him. Upon hearing about the battle on the banks of the Aous River, they first ravaged the nearby areas around Sperchia and Long Come, then crossed into Thessaly and took Cymine and Angeae in the first attack. They were pushed back at Metropolis by the locals, who gathered to defend the city while part of their army was looting the countryside. Later, when they attacked Callithera, they were met with similar resistance; however, this time, they held their ground, pushed back the attackers, and, seeing no chance to take the town by storm, retreated. They then captured and plundered the towns of Theuma and Calathas and took Acharrae by surrender. The inhabitants of Xyniae abandoned their town out of fear. After leaving their homes and gathering together, they encountered a group being sent to Thaumacus to protect their foragers; this unarmed, untrained crowd was completely defeated by the troops. The deserted town of Xyniae was looted. The Aetolians then captured Cyphara, a strategically located fort on the borders of Dolopia. All of this was accomplished by the Aetolians within just a few days.

14

Nor did Amynander and the Athamanians, when they heard of the victory obtained by the Romans, continue inactive. Amynander, having little confidence in his own troops, requested a slight auxiliary force from the consul; and then advancing towards Gomphi, he stormed on his march a place called Pheca, situate between that town and the narrow pass which separates Thessaly from Athamania. He then attacked Gomphi, and though the inhabitants defended it for several days with the utmost vigour, yet, as soon as he had raised the scaling ladders to the walls, the same apprehension (which had operated on others) at length compelled them to surrender. This capture of Gomphi spread the greatest consternation among the Thessalians: their fortresses of Argenta, Pherinus, Thimarus, Lisinae, Stimon, and Lampsus surrendered, one after another, with several other garrisons equally inconsiderable. While the Athamanians and Aetolians, delivered from fear of the Macedonians, converted to their own profit the fruits of another's victory; and Thessaly, ravaged by three armies at once, knew not which to believe its foe or its friend; the consul marched on, through the pass which the enemy's flight had left open, into the country of Epirus. Though he well knew which party the Epirots, excepting their prince Charopus, were disposed to favour, yet as he saw that, even from the motive of atoning for past behaviour, they obeyed his orders with diligence, he regulated his treatment of them by the standard of their present rather than of their former temper, and by this readiness to pardon conciliated their affection for the future. Then, sending orders to Corcyra for the transport ships to come into the Ambrician bay, he advanced by moderate marches, and on the fourth day pitched his camp on Mount Cercetius. Hither he ordered Amynander to come with his auxiliary troops; not so much as being in want of his forces, as that he might avail himself of them as his guides into Thessaly. With the same purpose, many volunteers of the Epirots also were admitted into the corps of auxiliaries.

Amynander and the Athamanians didn’t just sit back when they heard about the Romans' victory. Amynander, lacking confidence in his own soldiers, asked the consul for a small support force. He then moved toward Gomphi and took a location called Pheca, which was situated between that town and the narrow pass separating Thessaly from Athamania. He attacked Gomphi, and although the residents defended it fiercely for several days, the moment he raised the scaling ladders against the walls, the same fear that had affected others eventually made them surrender. The capture of Gomphi caused a huge panic among the Thessalians: their fortresses at Argenta, Pherinus, Thimarus, Lisinae, Stimon, and Lampsus surrendered one after another, along with several other minor garrisons. As the Athamanians and Aetolians, freed from the fear of the Macedonians, took advantage of someone else's victory, Thessaly was devastated by three armies at once and didn’t know whether to trust its enemy or its friend. The consul marched through the pass that the enemy’s retreat had left open and into Epirus. Although he knew which side the Epirots, apart from their leader Charopus, were inclined to support, he saw that they were diligently following his orders, likely as a way to make up for past actions. So, he treated them based on their current attitude rather than their previous one, and this willingness to forgive won their future loyalty. He then sent orders to Corcyra for the transport ships to come to the Ambrician bay, advanced at a steady pace, and on the fourth day set up camp on Mount Cercetius. He asked Amynander to join him with his auxiliary troops, not so much out of necessity for their support, but so he could use them as guides into Thessaly. For this same reason, he also accepted many volunteers from the Epirots into the auxiliary forces.

15

Of the cities of Thessaly, the first which he attacked was Phaloria. The garrison here consisted of two thousand Macedonians, who at first resisted with the utmost vigour so far as their arms and fortifications could protect them. The assault was carried on without intermission or relaxation either by day or by night, because the consul thought that it would have a powerful effect on the spirits of the rest of the Thessalians, if the first who made trial of the Roman strength were unable to withstand it; and this at the same time subdued the obstinacy of the Macedonians. On the reduction of Phaloria, deputies came from Metropolis and Piera, surrendering those cities. To them, on their petition, pardon was granted: Phaloria was sacked, and burned. He then proceeded to Aeginium; but finding this place so circumstanced, that, even with a moderate garrison, it was safe, after discharging a few weapons against the nearest advanced guard he directed his march towards the territory of Gomphi; and thence descended into the plains of Thessaly. His army was now in want of every thing, because he had spared the lands of the Epirots; he therefore despatched messengers to learn whether the transports had reached Leucas and the Ambracian bay; sending the cohorts, in turn, to Ambracia for corn. Now, the road from Gomphi to Ambracia, although difficult and embarrassed, is very short; so that in a few days, provisions having been conveyed from the sea, his camp was filled with an abundant supply of all necessaries. He then marched to Atrax, which is about ten miles from Larissa, on the river Peneus. The inhabitants came originally from Perrhaebia. The Thessalians, here, were not in the least alarmed at the first coming of the Romans; and Philip, although he durst not himself advance into Thessaly, yet, keeping his stationary camp in the vale of Tempe, whenever any place was attempted by the enemy, he sent up reinforcements as occasion required.

Of the cities in Thessaly, the first one he attacked was Phaloria. The garrison consisted of two thousand Macedonians, who initially resisted with everything they had, relying on their weapons and fortifications for protection. The attack continued without pause or break, day and night, because the consul believed that it would greatly affect the morale of the other Thessalians if the first ones to test the strength of the Romans couldn’t hold out; this also helped break the stubbornness of the Macedonians. After Phaloria fell, envoys came from Metropolis and Piera, surrendering those cities. On their request, they were granted amnesty; Phaloria was plundered and burned. He then moved on to Aeginium, but finding the location secure even with a moderate garrison, he only launched a few assaults against their nearest outpost and then directed his march into the territory of Gomphi, eventually descending into the Thessalian plains. His army was now in dire need of supplies since he had spared the lands of the Epirots. He therefore sent messengers to check if the ships had arrived at Leucas and the Ambracian bay, also dispatching detachments to Ambracia for grain. The route from Gomphi to Ambracia, although challenging, was quite short; within a few days, provisions from the sea filled his camp with a good supply of everything essential. He then marched to Atrax, which is about ten miles from Larissa, located on the river Peneus. The inhabitants originally came from Perrhaebia. The Thessalians weren't at all frightened by the Romans' arrival; and although Philip did not dare to move into Thessaly himself, he maintained a stationary camp in the vale of Tempe, sending reinforcements whenever the enemy attacked a location.

16

About the time that Quinctius first pitched his camp opposite to Philip's, at the entrance of Epirus, Lucius, the consul's brother, whom the senate had commissioned both to the naval command and to the government of the coast, sailed over with two quinqueremes to Corcyra; and when he learned that the fleet had departed thence, thinking that no delay ought to be incurred, he followed, and overtook it at the island of Zama. Here he dismissed Lucius Apustius, in whose room he had been appointed, and then proceeded to Malea, but at a slow rate, being obliged, for the most part, to tow the vessels which accompanied him with provisions. From Malea, after ordering the rest to follow with all possible expedition, himself, with three light quinqueremes, hastened forward to the Piraeus, and took under his command the ships left there by Lucius Apustius, lieutenant-general, for the protection of Athens. At the same time, two fleets set sail from Asia; one of twenty-four quinqueremes, under king Attalus; the other belonging to the Rhodians, consisting of twenty decked ships, and commanded by Agesimbrotus. These fleets, joining near the island of Andros, sailed for Euboea, which was separated from them only by a narrow strait. They first ravaged the lands belonging to Carystus; but, judging that city too strong, in consequence of a reinforcement hastily sent from Chalcis, they bent their course to Eretria. Lucius Quinctius also, on hearing of the arrival of king Attalus, came thither with the ships which had lain at the Piraeus; having left orders, that his own ships should, as they arrived, follow him to Euboea. The siege of Eretria was now pushed forward with the utmost vigour; for the three combined fleets carried machines and engines, of all sorts, for the demolition of towns, and the adjacent country offered abundance of timber for the construction of new works. At the beginning the townsmen defended their walls with a good degree of spirit; afterwards, when they felt the effects of fatigue, a great many being likewise wounded, and a part of the wall demolished by the enemy's works, they became disposed to capitulate. But they had a garrison of Macedonians, of whom they stood in no less dread than of the Romans; and Philocles, the king's general, sent frequent messages from Chalcis, that he would bring them succour in due time, if they could hold out the siege. The hope of this, in conjunction with their fears, obliged them to protract the time longer than was consistent either with their wishes or their strength. However, having learned soon after that Philocles had been repulsed in the attempt, and forced to fly back, in disorder, to Chalcis, they instantly sent deputies to Attalus, to beg pardon and protection. While intent on the prospect of peace, they executed with less energy the duties of war, and kept armed guards in that quarter only where the breach had been made in the wall, neglecting all the rest; Quinctius made an assault by night on the side where it was least apprehended, and carried the town by scalade. The whole multitude of the townsmen, with their wives and children, fled into the citadel, but soon after surrendered themselves prisoners. The quantity of money, of gold and silver, taken was not great. Of statues and pictures, the works of ancient artists, and other ornaments of that kind, a greater number was found than was proportionate either to the size of the city, or its opulence in other particulars.

About the time Quinctius set up his camp in front of Philip’s at the entrance of Epirus, Lucius, the consul's brother, who the senate had assigned to lead both the naval fleet and the coastal administration, sailed over with two quinqueremes to Corcyra. When he found out that the fleet had left, he thought there shouldn’t be any delays, so he followed and caught up with it at the island of Zama. Here, he let go of Lucius Apustius, whom he had replaced, and then moved on to Malea, but at a slow pace since he had to tow the ships carrying provisions. From Malea, after instructing the others to follow as quickly as possible, he took off for the Piraeus with three light quinqueremes, taking command of the ships left there by Lucius Apustius, the lieutenant-general, to protect Athens. At the same time, two fleets set sail from Asia; one with twenty-four quinqueremes, led by King Attalus, and the other from the Rhodians, consisting of twenty decked ships, commanded by Agesimbrotus. These fleets met near the island of Andros and sailed to Euboea, which was separated from them only by a narrow strait. They initially plundered the lands of Carystus, but thinking that city was too strong due to quick reinforcements sent from Chalcis, they decided to head to Eretria instead. Lucius Quinctius, upon hearing about King Attalus's arrival, went there with the ships that had been at the Piraeus, leaving instructions for his own ships to follow him to Euboea as they arrived. The siege of Eretria was now being carried out with extreme fervor since the three combined fleets brought machines and equipment of all kinds for demolishing cities, and the surrounding areas provided plenty of timber for building new siege works. At first, the townspeople defended their walls quite bravely; however, as fatigue set in, many getting wounded, and one part of the wall damaged by enemy efforts, they started considering surrender. But they had a garrison of Macedonians whom they feared just as much as the Romans; Philocles, the king's general, regularly sent messages from Chalcis saying he would come to their aid if they could withstand the siege. This hope, alongside their fears, made them prolong their resistance longer than was reasonable for their wishes or strength. However, after they soon learned that Philocles had been repelled and forced to flee back to Chalcis in disarray, they quickly sent representatives to Attalus to seek forgiveness and protection. While they focused on the possibility of peace, they put less effort into their defenses, maintaining armed guards only at the breach in the wall and neglecting the rest. Quinctius launched a surprise night attack on the least expected side and captured the town by scaling the walls. The entire population, along with their wives and children, fled to the citadel but soon surrendered as prisoners. The amount of gold and silver taken was not significant. However, there was a greater number of statues and paintings, works by ancient artists, and other similar valuables than one might expect considering the size of the city and its wealth in other respects.

17

The design on Carystus was then resumed, and the fleets sailed thither; on which the whole body of the inhabitants, before the troops were disembarked, deserted the city and fled into the citadel, whence they sent deputies to beg protection from the Roman general. To the townspeople life and liberty were immediately granted; and it was ordered, that the Macedonians should pay a ransom of three hundred drachmas[7] a head, deliver up their arms, and quit the country. After being ransomed for the said amount, they were transported, unarmed, to Boeotia. The combined fleets having, in the space of a few days, taken these two important cities of Euboea, sailed round Sunium, a promontory of Attica, and steered their course to Cenchreae, the grand mart of the Corinthians. In the mean time, the consul found the siege of Atrax more tedious and severe than had been universally expected, and the enemy resisted in the way which they had least anticipated. He had supposed that the whole of the trouble would be in demolishing the wall, and that if he could once open a passage for his soldiers into the city, the consequence would then be, the flight and slaughter of the enemy, as usually happens on the capture of towns. But when, on a breach being made in the wall by the rams, and when the soldiers, by mounting over the ruins, had entered the place, this proved only the beginning, as it were, of an unusual and fresh labour. For the Macedonians in garrison, who were both chosen men and many in number, supposing that they would be entitled to extraordinary honour if they should maintain the defence of the city by means of arms and courage, rather than by the help of walls, formed themselves in a compact body, strengthening their line by an uncommon number of files in depth. These, when they saw the Romans entering by the breaches, drove them back, so that they were entangled among the rubbish, and with difficulty could effect a retreat. This gave the consul great uneasiness; for he considered such a disgrace, not merely as it retarded the reduction of a single city, but as likely to affect materially the whole process of the war, which in general depends much on the influence of events in themselves unimportant. Having therefore cleared the ground, which was heaped up with the rubbish of the half-ruined wall, he brought up a tower of extraordinary height, consisting of many stories, and which carried a great number of soldiers. He likewise sent up the cohorts in strong bodies one after another, to force their way, if possible, through the wedge of the Macedonians, which is called a phalanx. But in such a confined space, (for the wall was thrown down to no great extent,) the enemy had the advantage, both in the kind of weapons which they used, and in the manner of fighting. When the Macedonians, in close array, stretched out before them their long spears against the target fence which was formed by the close position of their antagonists' shields, and when the Romans, after discharging their javelins without effect, drew their swords, these could neither press on to a closer combat, nor cut off the heads of the spears; and if they did cut or break off any, the shaft, being sharp at the part where it was broken, filled up its place among the points of those which were unbroken, in a kind of palisade. Besides this, the parts of the wall still standing rendered both the flanks of the Macedonians secure, who were not obliged, either in retreating or in advancing to an attack, to pass through a long space, which generally occasions disorder in the ranks. An accidental circumstance also helped to confirm their courage: for as the tower was moved along a bank of not sufficiently solid soil, one of the wheels sinking into a rut, made the tower lean in such a manner that it appeared to the enemy as if falling, and threw the soldiers posted on it into consternation and affright.

The design on Carystus was then resumed, and the fleets sailed there; as a result, the entire population deserted the city and fled to the citadel before the troops disembarked. They sent representatives to ask the Roman general for protection. The townspeople were immediately granted life and freedom; it was decreed that the Macedonians should pay a ransom of three hundred drachmas[7] per person, surrender their weapons, and leave the country. After paying the ransom, they were transported, unarmed, to Boeotia. The combined fleets, having taken these two important cities of Euboea in just a few days, sailed around Sunium, a promontory of Attica, and headed towards Cenchreae, the main market of the Corinthians. Meanwhile, the consul found the siege of Atrax more tedious and challenging than everyone had anticipated, and the enemy resisted in unexpected ways. He had thought the main difficulty would be knocking down the wall, and once he opened a passage for his soldiers into the city, the enemy would flee or be slaughtered, as usually happens during the capture of towns. However, when a breach was made in the wall by the rams and the soldiers entered over the ruins, this only marked the beginning of a fresh and unusual challenge. The Macedonians in the garrison, composed of well-selected and numerous men, believed they would gain extraordinary honor by defending the city with arms and bravery rather than relying on the walls. They formed a tight formation, bolstering their lines with an unusual number of ranks. When they saw the Romans entering through the breaches, they pushed them back, causing entanglement among the rubble, making retreat difficult. This caused great concern for the consul; he viewed such a setback not just as delaying the reduction of a single city but as likely to seriously impact the entire war effort, which generally hinges on seemingly minor incidents. Therefore, after clearing the area piled with debris from the damaged wall, he brought up an exceptionally tall tower, filled with many soldiers. He also sent the cohorts in strong groups one after another, attempting to push through the wedge of the Macedonians, known as a phalanx. However, in such a confined space (since the wall had not been demolished extensively), the enemy had the advantage with their choice of weapons and fighting style. When the Macedonians, standing close together, extended their long spears against the shield wall formed by the tightly arranged shields of their opponents, and when the Romans, after throwing their javelins to no effect, drew their swords, they couldn't engage in close combat or cut off the spearheads. Even if they managed to sever or break any, the sharp broken ends only filled the space among the unbroken tips, forming a sort of palisade. Additionally, the remaining parts of the standing wall secured the flanks of the Macedonians, allowing them to retreat or advance without having to cover a long distance that could cause disarray in their ranks. An accidental event also boosted their morale: as the tower was moved along an unstable ground, one of the wheels sank into a rut, causing the tower to tilt in such a way that it appeared to the enemy to be falling, frightening the soldiers stationed on it.

18

As none of his attempts met any success, the consul was very unwilling to allow such a comparison to be exhibited between the two classes of soldiery and their respective weapons; at the same time, he could neither see any prospect of reducing the place speedily, nor any means of subsisting in winter, at such a distance from the sea, and in regions desolated by the calamities of war. He therefore raised the siege; and as, along the whole coast of Acarnania and Aetolia, there was no port capable of containing all the transports that brought supplies to the army, nor any place which afforded lodgings to the legions, he pitched on Anticyra, in Phocis on the Corinthian gulf, as most commodiously situated for his purpose. There the legions would be at no great distance from Thessaly, and the places belonging to the enemy; while they would have in front Peloponnesus, separated from them by a narrow sea; on their rear, Aetolia and Acarnania; and on their sides, Locris and Boeotia. Phanotea in Phocis he took without resistance at the first assault. The siege of Anticyra gave him not much delay. Then Ambrysus and Hyampolis were taken. Daulis, being situated on a lofty eminence, could not be reduced either by scalade or works: he therefore provoked the garrison, by missile weapons, to make sallies from out the town. Then by flying at one time, pursuing at another, and engaging in slight skirmishes, he led them into such a degree of carelessness, and such a contempt of him, that at length the Romans, mixing with them as they ran back, entered by the gates, and stormed the town. Six other fortresses in Phocis, of little consequence, came into his hands, through fear rather than by force of arms. Elatia shut its gates, and the inhabitants seemed determined not to admit within their walls either the army or the general of the Romans, unless compelled by force.

Since none of his attempts were successful, the consul was very reluctant to allow any comparison to be made between the two types of soldiers and their respective weapons. At the same time, he could see no chance of taking the place quickly, nor any way to sustain his forces in winter, given the distance from the sea and the areas devastated by the ravages of war. He therefore lifted the siege. Along the entire coast of Acarnania and Aetolia, there were no ports that could accommodate all the transports bringing supplies to the army, nor was there any place that could house the legions. He chose Anticyra, in Phocis on the Corinthian Gulf, as the most suitable location for his needs. There, the legions would be close to Thessaly and the territory of the enemy, while facing Peloponnesus, which was separated from them by a narrow sea; Aetolia and Acarnania would be behind them, and Locris and Boeotia would be on their sides. Phanotea in Phocis fell easily at the first attack. The siege of Anticyra didn’t take much time. Then he took Ambrysus and Hyampolis. Daulis, located on a high hill, couldn't be taken by a scaled attack or by siege works; he instead provoked the garrison with projectiles to make them come out of the town. By retreating at times, pursuing at others, and engaging in minor skirmishes, he led them into such carelessness and disregard for him that eventually the Romans, mixing with them as they fled, entered through the gates and stormed the town. Six other minor fortresses in Phocis surrendered to him more out of fear than force. Elatia barred its gates, and its inhabitants seemed determined not to let either the army or the general of the Romans inside without being forced.

19

While the consul was employed in the siege of Elatia, a prospect opened to him of effecting a business of much more importance; namely, of drawing away the Achaeans from their alliance with Philip to that of the Romans. Cycliades, the head of the faction that favoured the interest of Philip, they had now banished; and Aristaenus, who wished for a union between his countrymen and the Romans, was praetor. The Roman fleet, with Attalus and the Rhodians, lay at Cenchreae, and were preparing to lay siege to Corinth with their whole combined force. The consul therefore judged it prudent, that, before they entered on that affair, ambassadors should be sent to the Achaean state, with assurances, that if they came over from the king to the side of the Romans, the latter would consign Corinth to them, and annex it to the old confederacy of their nation. Accordingly, by the consul's direction, ambassadors were sent to the Achaeans, by his brother Lucius Quinctius, by Attalus, and by the Rhodians and Athenians--a general assembly being summoned to meet at Sicyon to give them audience. Now, the state of feeling of the Achaeans was by no means uniform. Nabis the Lacedaemonian, their constant and inveterate enemy, was the object of their dread; they dreaded the arms of the Romans; they were under obligations to the Macedonians, for services both of ancient and recent date; but the king himself, on account of his perfidy and cruelty, they looked upon with jealous fear, and not judging from the behaviour which he then assumed for the time, they knew that, on the conclusion of the war, they should find him a more tyrannical master. So that every one of them was not only at a loss what opinion he should support in the senate of his own particular state, or in the general diets of the nation; but, even when they deliberated within themselves, they could not, with any certainty, determine what they ought to wish, or what to prefer. Such was the unsettled state of mind of the members of the assembly, when the ambassadors were introduced and liberty of speaking afforded them. The Roman ambassador, Lucius Calpurnius, spoke first; next the ambassadors of king Attalus; after them those of the Rhodians; and then Philip's. The Athenians were heard the last, that they might refute the discourses of the Macedonians. These inveighed against the king with the greatest acrimony of any, for no others had suffered from him so many and so severe hardships. So great a number of speeches of the ambassadors succeeding each other took up the whole of the day; and about sun-set the council was adjourned.

While the consul was busy with the siege of Elatia, he saw a chance to achieve something much more significant: to persuade the Achaeans to switch their allegiance from Philip to the Romans. They had just banished Cycliades, the leader of the faction supportive of Philip, and Aristaenus, who was in favor of uniting his people with the Romans, was serving as praetor. The Roman fleet, along with Attalus and the Rhodians, was stationed at Cenchreae, preparing to lay siege to Corinth with their combined forces. Therefore, the consul thought it wise to send ambassadors to the Achaean state before they started that operation, assuring them that if they shifted their loyalty from the king to the Romans, the Romans would hand over Corinth to them and reintegrate it into their nation’s old alliance. Consequently, as directed by the consul, ambassadors were sent to the Achaeans through his brother Lucius Quinctius, Attalus, and representatives from the Rhodians and Athenians, with a general assembly summoned to meet at Sicyon to hear them. The Achaeans, however, had mixed feelings. They feared Nabis the Lacedaemonian, their relentless enemy, as well as the Roman forces; they felt indebted to the Macedonians for help both in the past and recently. Yet, because of Philip's treachery and brutality, they viewed him with suspicion and knew that after the war, he would likely be an even harsher ruler. As a result, each member was unsure of which side to support in their local senate or the broader national assemblies; even when they contemplated the situation individually, they struggled to determine what they should wish for or prefer. This was the uncertain mindset of the assembly members when the ambassadors were presented and given the opportunity to speak. The Roman ambassador, Lucius Calpurnius, spoke first, followed by the ambassadors from Attalus, the Rhodians, and then Philip’s. The Athenians were allowed to speak last so they could counter the Macedonian arguments. They criticized the king the most harshly, as no others had endured as many severe hardships at his hands. The series of speeches by the ambassadors lasted throughout the day, and around sunset, the council was adjourned.

20

Next day the council was convened again; and when the magistrates, according to the custom of the Greeks, gave leave, by their herald, to any person who chose to offer advice, not one stood forth; but they sat a long time, looking on each other in silence. It was no wonder that men, revolving in their minds matters of such contradictory natures, and who found themselves puzzled and confounded, should be involved in additional perplexity by the speeches continued through the whole preceding day; in which the difficulties, on all sides, were brought into view, and stated in their full force. At length Aristaenus, the praetor of the Achaeans, not to dismiss the council without any business being introduced, said:--"Achaeans, where are now those violent disputes, in which, at your feasts and meetings, whenever mention was made of Philip and the Romans, you scarcely refrained from blows? Now, in a general assembly, summoned on that single business, when you have heard the arguments of the ambassadors on both sides, when the magistrates demand your opinions, when the herald calls you to declare your sentiments, you are struck dumb. Although your concern for the common safety be insufficient for determining the matter, cannot the party zeal which has attached you to one side or the other extort a word from any one of you? especially when none is so obtuse as not to perceive, that the time for declaring and recommending what each either wishes or thinks most advisable, must be at the present moment; that is, before we make any decree. When a decree shall have been once passed, every man even such as previously may have disapproved the measure, must then support it as good and salutary." These persuasions of the praetor, so far from prevailing on any one person to declare his opinion, did not excite, in all that numerous assembly, collected out of so many states, so much as a murmur or a whisper.

The next day, the council met again. When the magistrates, following Greek tradition, allowed anyone to speak up through their herald, no one stepped forward. They sat in silence for a long time, just looking at one another. It was no surprise that the individuals, trying to sort through such conflicting issues, felt more confused after the long discussions from the previous day, which had laid out all the difficulties in detail. Finally, Aristaenus, the praetor of the Achaeans, wanting to ensure the council didn’t end without any discussion, spoke up: "Achaeans, where have those heated arguments gone, where during your feasts and gatherings, whenever Philip and the Romans were mentioned, you nearly came to blows? Now, in this general assembly, called for this specific issue, having heard the ambassadors' arguments on both sides, with the magistrates asking for your opinions and the herald calling for your thoughts, you all are silent. Even if your concern for our collective safety isn’t enough to make a decision, can’t your loyalty to one side or the other get one of you to say something? Especially when it's clear that the time to express and support what each of you either wants or thinks is best is now, before we make any decisions? Once a decision is made, every person, even those who previously disagreed, must then support it as good and beneficial." Despite the praetor's efforts, not a single person in that large assembly, gathered from so many different states, even murmured or whispered a response.

21

Then the praetor, Aristaenus, again spoke as follows:--"Chiefs of Achaea, you are not more at a loss for advice, than you are for words; but every one is unwilling to promote the interest of the public at a risk of danger to himself. Were I in a private character, perhaps I too should be silent; but, as praetor, it is my duty to declare, that I see evidently, either that an audience of the council ought not to have been accorded to the ambassadors, or that they ought not to be dismissed from it without an answer. Yet how can I give them an answer, unless by a decree of yours? And, since not one of you who have been called to this assembly either chooses or dares to make known his sentiments, let us examine (as if they were opinions proposed to our consideration) the speeches of the ambassadors delivered yesterday; supposing the speakers not to have required what was useful to themselves, but to have recommended what they thought most conducive to our advantage. The Romans, the Rhodians and Attalus, request an alliance and friendship with us; and they demand to be assisted by us in the war in which they are now engaged against Philip. Philip reminds us of our league with him, and of the obligation of our oath; he requires only, that we declare ourselves on his side; and says, he will be satisfied if we do not intermeddle in the operations of the war. Does not the reason occur to the mind of any one of you why those, who are not yet our allies, require more than he who is? This arises not from modesty in Philip, nor from the want of it in the Romans. It is fortune, which, while it bestows confidence to requisitions on one side, precludes it on the other. We see nothing belonging to Philip but his ambassador: the Roman fleet lies at Cenchreae, exhibiting to our view the spoils of the cities of Euboea. We behold the consul and his legions, at the distance of a small tract of sea, overrunning Phocis and Locris. You were surprised at Philip's ambassador, Cleomedon, showing such diffidence yesterday in his application to us to take arms on the side of the king against the Romans. But if we, in pursuance of the same treaty and oath, the sacredness of which he inculcated on us, were to ask of him, that Philip should protect us, both from Nabis and his Lacedaemonians, and also from the Romans, he would be utterly unable to find, not only a force with which to protect us, but even an answer to return. As much so in truth as was Philip himself, who endeavoured, by promises of waging war against Nabis, to draw away our youth into Euboea; but finding that we would neither decree such assistance to him, nor choose to be embroiled in a war with Rome, forgot that alliance on which he now lays such stress, and left us to Nabis and the Lacedaemonians to be spoiled and plundered. Besides, to me the arguments of Cleomedon appeared utterly inconsistent. He made light of the war with the Romans; and asserted, that the issue of it would be similar to that of the former, which they waged against Philip. If such the case, why does he, at a distance, solicit our assistance; rather than come hither in person, and defend us, his old allies, both from Nabis and from the Romans? Us, do I say? Why, on this showing, has he suffered Eretria and Carystus to be taken? Why so many cities of Thessaly? Why Locris and Phocis? Why does he at present suffer Elatia to be besieged? Did he, either through compulsion, or fear, or choice, quit the straits of Epirus, and those impregnable fastnesses on the river Aous; and why, abandoning the pass which he was occupying, did he retire altogether into his own kingdom? If of his own will he gave up so many allies to the ravages of the enemy, what objection can he make to these allies consulting for their own safety? If through fear, he ought to pardon the like fear in us. If he retired defeated by force of arms, let me ask you, Cleomedon, shall we, Achaeans, be able to withstand the Roman arms, which you, Macedonians, have not withstood? Are we to give credit to your assertion, that the Romans do not employ, in the present war, greater forces or greater strength than they did in the former, rather than regard the facts themselves? In the first instance, they aided the Aetolians with a fleet; they sent not to the war either a consul as commander, or a consular army. The maritime cities of Philip's allies were in terror and confusion; but the inland places were so secure against the Roman arms, that Philip ravaged the country of the Aetolians, while they in vain implored succour from those arms. Whereas, in the present case, the Romans, after bringing to a final conclusion the Punic war, which they had supported for sixteen years in the bowels, as it were, of Italy, sent not auxiliaries to the Aetolians in their quarrels, but, being themselves principals, made a hostile invasion on Macedonia with land and sea forces at once. Their third consul is now pushing forward the war with the utmost vigour. Sulpicius, engaging the king within the territory of Macedonia itself, has overthrown and put him to flight; and afterwards despoiled the most opulent part of his kingdom. Then, again, when he was in possession of the strait of Epirus, where, from the nature of the ground, his fortifications, and the strength of his army, he thought himself secure, Quinctius drove him out of his camp; pursued him, as he fled into Thessaly; and, almost in the view of Philip himself, stormed the royal garrisons and the cities of his allies. Supposing that there were no truth in what the Athenian ambassadors mentioned yesterday, respecting the cruelty, avarice, and lust of the king; supposing the crimes committed, in the country of Attica, against the gods, celestial and infernal, concerned us not all; that we had less to complain of than what the people of Cius and Abydos, who are far distant from us, have endured: let us then, if you please, forget even our own wounds; let the murders and ravages committed at Messana, and in the heart of Peloponnesus, the killing of his host Garitenes at Cyparissia, almost in the very midst of a feast, in contempt of laws divine and human; the murder of the two Aratuses of Sicyon, father and son, though he was wont to call the unfortunate old man his parent; his carrying away the son's wife into Macedonia for the gratification of his vicious appetites, and all his violations of virgins and matrons;--let all these, I say, be consigned to oblivion. Let us suppose our business were not with Philip, through dread of whose cruelty you are all thus struck dumb; for what other cause could keep you silent, when you have been summoned to a council? Let us imagine that we are treating with Antigonus, a prince of the greatest mildness and equity, to whose kindness we have all been highly indebted; would he require us to perform what at the time was impossible? Peloponnesus is a peninsula, united to the continent by the narrow passage of an isthmus particularly exposed and open to the attacks of naval armaments. Now, if a hundred decked ships, and fifty lighter open ones, and thirty Issean barks, shall begin to lay waste our coasts, and attack the cities which stand exposed, almost on the very shore, shall we then retreat into the inland towns, as if we were not afflicted with an intestine war, though in truth it is rankling in our very bowels? When Nabis and the Lacedaemonians by land, and the Roman fleet by sea, shall press us, whence must I implore the support due from the king's alliance, whence the succours of the Macedonians? Shall we ourselves, with our own arms, defend, against the Roman forces, the cities that will be attacked? Truly, in the former war, we defended Dymae excellently well! The calamities of others afford us abundant examples; let us not seek how we may render ourselves an example to others. Do not, because the Romans voluntarily desire your friendship, contemn that which you ought to have prayed for, nay, laboured with all your might to obtain. But, it is insinuated, that they are impelled by fear, in a country to which they are strangers; and that, wishing to shelter themselves under your assistance, they have recourse to your alliance in the hope of being admitted into your harbours, and of there finding supplies of provisions. Now, at sea they are absolute masters; and instantly reduce to subjection every place at which they land. What they request, they have power to enforce. Because they wish to treat you with tenderness they do not allow you to take steps that must lead you to ruin. Cleomedon lately pointed out, as the middle and safest way, to remain inactive, and abstain from taking up arms But that is not a middle way; it is no way at all. For, besides the necessity of either embracing or rejecting the Roman alliance, what other consequence can ensue from such conduct, than that, while we show no steady attachment to either side, as if we waited the event with design to adapt our counsels to fortune, we shall become the prey of the conqueror? Contemn not then, when it is spontaneously offered to your acceptance, what you ought to have solicited with your warmest prayers. The free option between the two, which you have this day, you will not always have. The same opportunity will not last long, nor will it frequently recur. You have long wished to deliver yourselves out of the hands of Philip, although you have not dared to make the attempt. Those have now crossed the sea, with large fleets and armies, who are able to rescue you to a state of freedom, without any trouble or danger to yourselves. If you reject such persons as allies, you can scarcely be of sane mind; but you must unavoidably have to deal with them, either as allies or as enemies."

Then the praetor, Aristaenus, spoke again: "Leaders of Achaea, you're just as lacking in advice as you are in words; yet everyone is hesitant to support the public interest if it means putting themselves at risk. If I were just a private citizen, I might also choose to remain silent; but as praetor, I must state that I clearly see we either shouldn't have listened to the ambassadors or we can't dismiss them without replying. How can I respond, though, without a decree from you? And since none of you present at this meeting is willing or able to share your thoughts, let’s review the speeches of the ambassadors from yesterday as if they were proposals for our consideration, assuming the speakers were not looking out for themselves, but for our benefit. The Romans, the Rhodians, and Attalus are asking for our alliance and friendship; they want our help in the war they're currently waging against Philip. Philip reminds us of our alliance with him and our oath; he only asks that we declare our support for him and assures us he will be content if we stay out of the war’s operations. Doesn't it strike any of you as odd that those who aren't our allies are making more demands than those who are? This isn't due to Philip's modesty or the Romans' lack of it. It's merely a matter of fortune, which grants boldness to one side while denying it to the other. The only thing we see of Philip is his ambassador: the Roman fleet is at Cenchreae, parading the spoils of Euboea. We see the consul and his legions, just a short distance across the sea, invading Phocis and Locris. You were surprised by Philip's ambassador, Cleomedon, showing such hesitation when asking us to support the king against the Romans. But if, according to the same treaty and oath that he stressed to us, we were to ask him for protection from both Nabis and his Lacedaemonians, as well as the Romans, he wouldn’t even have the means to do so, let alone a response. Just as Philip himself tried to entice our youth to Euboea with promises of fighting against Nabis, but when he saw we wouldn't offer assistance or engage in a war with Rome, he forgot the alliance he now emphasizes and left us at the mercy of Nabis and the Lacedaemonians. Moreover, I found Cleomedon's arguments to be completely inconsistent. He downplayed the war with the Romans and claimed the outcome would be like their previous war against Philip. If this is true, then why doesn’t he come here in person to defend us, his old allies, from both Nabis and the Romans? Why has he allowed Eretria and Carystus to be taken? Why so many cities in Thessaly? Why Locris and Phocis? Why is Elatia currently under siege? Did he, whether out of choice or fear, retreat from the narrow passages of Epirus and the strongholds along the river Aous? If he willingly sacrificed so many allies to the enemy’s destruction, what grounds does he have to criticize those allies for looking out for their own safety? If he did so out of fear, he should understand if we feel the same way. If he was defeated in battle, let me ask you, Cleomedon, can we, the Achaeans, withstand the Roman forces that you Macedonians could not? Should we trust your claim that the Romans are deploying the same level of strength in this war as they did in the past, rather than acknowledge the realities? In the earlier conflict, they supported the Aetolians with a fleet; they didn’t send a consul or a consular army to the war. The coastal cities of Philip's allies were terrified and confused, but the inland areas were so secure against the Romans that Philip was able to raid Aetolia while they cried out for help. Now, however, having concluded the Punic War, which they fought for sixteen years within Italy, they are not just sending auxiliaries to the Aetolians, but are themselves mounting a direct invasion of Macedonia with both land and sea forces. Their third consul is now aggressively pursuing the war. Sulpicius has engaged the king in Macedonia, defeated him, and later plundered the richest part of his kingdom. Moreover, when he was in control of the strait of Epirus, where he felt secure due to the terrain, his fortifications, and his army, Quinctius drove him out of his camp, chasing him into Thessaly, and almost in Philip’s line of sight, stormed his strongholds and the cities of his allies. Even if we ignore what the Athenian ambassadors said about the king's cruelty, greed, and lust, and pretend the wrongs done in Attica against both the divine and the dead have nothing to do with us; that we have less to complain about than the people of Cius and Abydos, who are far away from us: even then, let us forget our own wounds; forget the murders and destruction in Messana and the heart of Peloponnesus, the killing of his host Garitenes at Cyparissia during a feast, in violation of both divine and human laws, the murder of the two Aratuses of Sicyon, father and son, despite Philip calling the unfortunate old man his kin; his abduction of the son's wife into Macedonia for his vile desires, and all his assaults on virgins and matrons;—let’s forget all of that. Let’s pretend we are not dealing with Philip, from whom you all seem so afraid; for what other reason could possibly keep you silent when summoned to a council? Let’s imagine we are negotiating with Antigonus, a ruler known for his kindness and fairness, to whom we owe a great debt. Would he ask us to do what is currently impossible? Peloponnesus is a peninsula connected to the mainland by a narrow isthmus, vulnerable to naval attacks. Now, if a hundred warships, fifty smaller vessels, and thirty Issean boats start destroying our coasts and assaulting the cities almost directly on the shore, will we then retreat inland as if we are not suffering from a civil war that festers within us? When Nabis and the Lacedaemonians attack us by land, and the Roman fleet by sea, from where do I seek the support due from the king's alliance, where are the reinforcements from the Macedonians? Are we supposed to defend our cities against the Romans with our own arms? Indeed, in the last war, we did an excellent job defending Dymae! The plight of others provides us with ample examples; let’s not strive to make ourselves an example for others. Don't, just because the Romans seek your friendship, underestimate what you should have urgently sought after with all your strength. But, it is suggested they are motivated by fear in a land that isn't theirs; and that they wish to shield themselves under your protection, hoping to access your harbors and find supplies. But at sea they are completely dominant and can swiftly conquer any place they land. What they ask for, they can enforce. Because they want to treat you with kindness, they don’t let you take actions that could lead to your downfall. Cleomedon recently suggested that the best course of action is to remain passive and avoid taking up arms. But that isn't a middle ground; that's no ground at all. For along with the necessity of choosing whether to support or oppose the Roman alliance, what else can arise from such behavior, other than that we display no firm commitment to either side, as if we await the outcome to adjust our strategies accordingly, making us prey to the victor? Do not dismiss that which is offered to you freely and should have been fervently sought after. The choice between the two you've been presented with today won't always be available. This opportunity won’t last long, nor appear frequently. You have long desired to free yourselves from Philip's grasp, even if you haven't dared to act on it. Now those who have crossed the sea with large fleets and armies can grant you your freedom without any trouble or risk to yourselves. If you turn your back on such allies, it would be hard to argue that you're thinking clearly; you will inevitably have to face them, whether as allies or foes."

22

This speech of the praetor was followed by a general murmur; some declaring their approbation, and others vehemently rebuking those who did so. And now, not only individuals, but whole states were engaged in altercation among themselves; and at length among the magistrates, called Demiurgi, who are ten in number, the dispute was taken up with as much warmth as among the multitude. Five of them declared, that they would propose the question concerning an alliance with Rome, and would take the votes on it; while five insisted, that it had been provided by law that neither the magistrates should have power to propose nor the council to pass any decree injurious to the alliance with Philip. This day, also, was spent in contention, and there remained now but one day more of the regular time of sitting; for, according to the rule, the decree must be passed on the third day: and as that approached, the zeal of the parties was kindled into such a flame, that scarcely did parents refrain from offering violence to their own sons. There was present a man of Pallene, named Rhisiasus, whose son, Memnon, was a demiurgus, and was of that party which opposed the reading of the decree and taking the votes. This man, for a long time, entreated his son to allow the Achaeans to take proper measures for their common safety, and not, by his obstinacy, to bring ruin on the whole nation; but, finding that his entreaties had no effect, he swore that he would treat him, not as a son, but as an enemy, and would put him to death with his own hand. By these threats he forced him, next day, to join the party that voted for the question being proposed. These, having now become the majority, proposed the question accordingly, while almost every one of the states, openly approving the measure, showed plainly on which side they would vote. Whereupon the Dymaeans, Megalopolitans, with several of the Argives, rose up, and withdrew from the council; which step excited neither wonder nor disapprobation. For when, in the memory of their grandfathers, the Megalopolitans had been expelled their country by the Lacedaemonians, Antigonus had reinstated them in their native residence; and, at a later period, when Dymae was taken and sacked by the Roman troops, Philip ordered that the inhabitants, wherever they were in servitude, should be ransomed, and not only restored them to their liberty, but their country. As to the Argives, besides believing that the royal family of Macedonia derived its origin from them, the greater part were attached to Philip by personal acts of kindness and familiar friendship. For these reasons, when the council appeared disposed to order an alliance to be concluded with Rome, they withdrew; and their secession was readily excused, in consideration of the many and recent obligations by which they were bound to the king of Macedon.

This speech from the praetor was met with a general murmur; some expressed approval, while others strongly criticized those who did. Now, not just individuals, but entire states were arguing among themselves. Eventually, the debate reached the ten magistrates known as Demiurgi, and the discussion became as heated as it was among the crowd. Five of them stated they would propose the question of an alliance with Rome and conduct a vote on it, while the other five insisted that the law prohibited the magistrates from proposing anything that would harm the alliance with Philip. This day was spent in conflict, with only one day left in the regular session; according to the rules, the decree had to be passed on the third day. As that deadline approached, the fervor of both sides intensified so much that parents nearly resorted to violence against their own children. A man from Pallene, named Rhisiasus, had a son, Memnon, who was a demiurgus and belonged to the faction opposing the proposal. Rhisiasus pleaded with his son for a long time to let the Achaeans take the necessary actions for their collective safety and not to jeopardize the whole nation with his stubbornness. When his pleas fell on deaf ears, he swore that he would treat his son not as a son but as an enemy, and would kill him with his own hands. By resorting to these threats, he compelled Memnon the next day to align with those supporting the proposal. With this group now in the majority, they put the question forward, and nearly all states, showing their support for the measure, clearly indicated how they would vote. This prompted the Dymaeans and Megalopolitans, along with several Argives, to stand up and leave the council, a decision that drew neither surprise nor disapproval. Long ago, when the Megalopolitans had been expelled from their homeland by the Lacedaemonians, Antigonus had restored them to their home. Later, when Dymae was captured and plundered by Roman troops, Philip ordered that the inhabitants, no matter their status, should be freed and returned to their land. As for the Argives, they not only believed that the Macedonian royal family originated from them, but many were also personally connected to Philip through acts of kindness and friendship. For these reasons, when it seemed the council was leaning towards an alliance with Rome, they withdrew, a decision that was easily excused due to their numerous and recent commitments to the king of Macedon.

23

The rest of the Achaean states, on their opinions being demanded, ratified, by an immediate decree, the alliance with Attalus and the Rhodians. That with the Romans, as it could not be perfected without an order from the people, they deferred until such time as ambassadors could be sent to Rome. For the present, it was resolved, that three ambassadors should be sent to Lucius Quinctius; and that the whole force of the Achaeans should be brought up to Corinth, which city Quinctius, after taking Cenchreae, was then besieging. The Achaeans accordingly pitched their camp opposite to the gate that leads to Sicyon. The Romans made their approaches on the side of the city which faces Cenchreae; Attalus having drawn his army across the isthmus, towards Lechaeum, the port on the opposite sea. At first, they did not push forward their operations with any great degree of vigour, because they had hopes of a dissension breaking out between the townsmen and the king's troops. But afterwards, learning that they all were of one mind; that the Macedonians exerted themselves as if in defence of their common country; and that the Corinthians submitted to the orders of Androsthenes, commander of the garrison, as if he were their countryman, and elected by their own suffrages; the assailants had no other hopes but in force, arms, and their works. They therefore brought up their mounds to the walls, though by very difficult approaches. On that side where the Romans attacked, their ram had demolished a considerable part of the wall; and the Macedonians having run together to defend the place thus stripped of its works, a furious conflict ensued between themselves and the Romans. At first, by reason of the enemy's superiority in number, the Romans were quickly repulsed; but being joined by the auxiliary troops of Attalus and the Achaeans, they restored the fight to an equality; so that there was no doubt that they would easily drive the Macedonians and Greeks from their ground. But there were in the town a great multitude of Italian deserters; some of whom, having been in Hannibal's army, had, through fear of being punished by the Romans, followed Philip; others, having been sailors, had lately quitted the fleets, and gone over, in hopes of more honourable employment: despair of safety, therefore, in case of the Romans getting the better, inflamed these to a degree which might rather be called madness than courage. Opposite to Sicyon is the promontory of Juno Acraea, as she is called, stretching out into the main, the passage to Corinth being about seven miles. To this place Philocles, one of the king's generals, led, through Boeotia, fifteen hundred soldiers; and there were barks from Corinth ready to take these troops on board, and carry them over to Lechaeum. Attalus, on this, advised to burn the works, and raise the siege immediately; Quinctius was for persisting more obstinately in the attempt. However, when he saw the king's troops posted at the gates, and that the sallies of the besieged could not easily be withstood, he came over to the opinion of Attalus. Thus, their design proving fruitless, they dismissed the Achaeans, and returned to their ships. Attalus steered to Piraeus, the Romans to Corcyra.

The other Achaean states, when asked for their opinions, quickly approved the alliance with Attalus and the Rhodians through an immediate decree. The agreement with the Romans couldn’t be finalized without an order from the people, so they postponed it until ambassadors could be sent to Rome. For now, they decided to send three ambassadors to Lucius Quinctius and gather the entire Achaean force in Corinth, where Quinctius was besieging the city after capturing Cenchreae. The Achaeans set up their camp in front of the gate leading to Sicyon. The Romans approached from the side of the city facing Cenchreae, while Attalus moved his army across the isthmus toward Lechaeum, the port on the opposite sea. Initially, they didn’t push hard against the defenses because they hoped for a disagreement between the townspeople and the king's troops. However, they soon learned that everyone was united; the Macedonians were defending their homeland fiercely, and the Corinthians obeyed Androsthenes, the commander of the garrison, as if he were one of their own elected leaders. The attackers realized their only hope lay in strength, arms, and their fortifications. They therefore moved their siege engines closer to the walls, despite the difficult terrain. On the side where the Romans attacked, their battering ram had destroyed a significant portion of the wall, and as the Macedonians gathered to defend the weakened position, a fierce conflict broke out between them and the Romans. Initially, the Romans were quickly pushed back due to the enemy's larger numbers, but once they were joined by the auxiliary troops of Attalus and the Achaeans, they equalized the fight, making it clear they could drive the Macedonians and Greeks from their positions. However, inside the town were many Italian deserters; some, who had served under Hannibal, joined Philip out of fear of Roman punishment, while others, having been sailors, left the fleets for better opportunities. This despair of a loss if the Romans won drove them to a level of frenzy that could be considered madness rather than bravery. Across from Sicyon is the promontory of Juno Acraea, extending into the sea, with Corinth about seven miles away. To this spot, Philocles, one of the king's generals, led fifteen hundred soldiers through Boeotia, and small boats from Corinth were ready to transport these troops to Lechaeum. Attalus advised burning the siege works and lifting the siege immediately, while Quinctius wanted to continue the assault. However, upon seeing the king's troops at the gates and realizing that the attacks from the besieged couldn’t be easily countered, he agreed with Attalus. Therefore, as their plan turned out to be fruitless, they sent the Achaeans home and returned to their ships. Attalus sailed to Piraeus, while the Romans went to Corcyra.

24

While the naval forces were thus employed, the consul, having encamped before Elatia, in Phocis, first endeavoured, by conferring with the principal inhabitants, to bring them over, and by their means to effect his purpose; but on their answering that they had nothing in their power, because the king's troops were more numerous and stronger than the townsmen, he assaulted the city on all sides at once with arms and engines. A battering-ram having been brought up, shattered a part of the wall that reached from one tower to another, and this falling with a prodigious noise and crash, left much of the town exposed. On this a Roman cohort made an assault through the breach, while at the same time the townsmen, quitting their several posts, ran together from all parts to the place, which was endangered by the attack of the enemy. At the same time others of the Romans climbed over the ruins of the wall, and brought up scaling-ladders to the parts that were standing. As the conflict attracted the eyes and attention of the enemy to one particular spot, the walls were scaled in several places, by which means the soldiers easily entered the town. The noise and tumult which ensued so terrified the enemy, that quitting the place, which they had crowded together to defend, they all fled in panic to the citadel, accompanied by the unarmed multitude. The consul having thus become master of the town, gave it up to be plundered, and then sent messengers into the citadel, offering the king's troops their lives, on condition of their laying down their arms, and departing. To the Elatians he offered their liberty; which terms being agreed to, in a few days after he got possession of the citadel.

While the naval forces were busy, the consul set up camp outside Elatia in Phocis. He first tried to win over the leading citizens through discussions, hoping they would help him achieve his goals. But when they replied that they couldn’t because the king's troops were larger and stronger than the townspeople, he launched an attack on the city from all sides with weapons and siege engines. A battering-ram was brought in and smashed a section of the wall connecting two towers, creating a huge noise that exposed much of the town. At that moment, a Roman cohort charged through the gap, while the townspeople, leaving their posts, rushed from all directions to defend against the enemy's assault. Meanwhile, other Romans climbed over the wall's ruins and raised scaling ladders against the parts still standing. As the fighting drew the enemy's focus to one spot, Roman soldiers quickly scaled the walls in multiple places, easily entering the town. The ensuing chaos and uproar terrified the enemy, causing them to abandon the area they had gathered to defend and flee in panic to the citadel, along with the unarmed crowd. With control of the town now in his hands, the consul allowed it to be looted and then sent messengers to the citadel, offering the king's troops their lives if they laid down their arms and left. He promised the Elatians their freedom; with these terms accepted, he took possession of the citadel a few days later.

25

In consequence of Philocles, the king's general, coming into Achaia, not only Corinth was delivered from the siege, but the city of Argos was betrayed into his hands by some of the principal inhabitants, after they had first sounded the minds of the populace. They had a custom, that, on the first day of assembly, their praetors, for the omen's sake, should pronounce the names, Jupiter, Apollo, and Hercules; in addition to which, a rule had been made, that, along with these they should join the name of king Philip. After the conclusion of the alliance with the Romans, the herald did not make that addition; on which a murmur spread through the multitude, who would add the name of Philip, and insisting that the respect, due by law, should be paid as before; until at length the name was given out amidst universal approbation. On the encouragement afforded by this favourable disposition, Philocles was invited, who seized in the night a strong post called Larissa, seated on a hill which overhangs the city, and in which he placed a garrison. At the dawn of day, however, and as he was proceeding in order of battle to the forum, at the foot of the hill he was met by a line of troops, drawn up to oppose him. This was a body of Achaeans, lately posted there, consisting of about five hundred young men, selected out of all the states. Their commander was Aenesidemus, of Dymae. The king's general sent a person to recommend to them to evacuate the city, because they were not a match for the townsmen alone, who held the same sentiments as the Macedonians; much less when these were joined by the Macedonians, whom even the Romans had not withstood at Corinth. This at first had no effect, either on the commander, or his men: and when they, soon after, perceived the Argives also in arms, coming, in a great body, from the opposite side, perceiving that their destruction was inevitable, they yet seemed determined to run every hazard, if their leader would persevere. But Aenesidemus, unwilling that the flower of the Achaean youth should be lost, together with the city, made terms with Philocles, that they should have liberty to retire, while himself remained armed with a few of his dependents, in the position which he had occupied. To a person sent by Philocles to inquire what he meant, he only answered, standing with his shield held out before him, that he meant to die in arms in defence of the city intrusted to his charge. Philocles then ordered some Thracians to throw their javelins at him and his attendants; and they were all put to death. Thus, notwithstanding the alliance concluded by the Achaeans with the Romans, two of their cities, and those of the greatest consequence, Argos and Corinth, were still in the hands of Philip. Such were the services performed during that summer by the land and sea forces of Rome employed in Greece.

As a result of Philocles, the king's general, arriving in Achaia, not only was Corinth freed from the siege, but the city of Argos was also betrayed to him by some of the key residents after they first gauged the feelings of the people. They had a tradition that, on the first day of assembly, their praetors, for the sake of omens, would pronounce the names Jupiter, Apollo, and Hercules; in addition, a rule had been established that they should also include the name of King Philip. After the alliance with the Romans was signed, the herald no longer added that name, which caused a murmur to spread among the crowd, who insisted on including Philip’s name, demanding that the respect due by law be maintained as before; eventually, the name was declared to widespread approval. Encouraged by this favorable reaction, Philocles was invited, and he took a strong position called Larissa at night, located on a hill overlooking the city, where he stationed a garrison. At dawn, as he was advancing in formation towards the forum, he was confronted at the foot of the hill by a line of troops set up to oppose him. This group consisted of about five hundred young Achaeans chosen from all the states, commanded by Aenesidemus of Dymae. The king's general sent someone to advise them to leave the city, arguing that they were no match for the townspeople alone, who shared the same sentiments as the Macedonians; even less so when these were joined by the Macedonians, whom even the Romans had not been able to resist in Corinth. Initially, this had no impact on either the commander or his men; and soon after, when they saw the Argives also armed and approaching in large numbers from the opposite side, realizing their destruction was unavoidable, they still appeared determined to face all risks if their leader persisted. However, Aenesidemus, wanting to save the best of the Achaean youth along with the city, struck a deal with Philocles that they could withdraw while he himself remained armed with a few followers in the position he had taken. When a messenger sent by Philocles asked him what he intended to do, he simply replied, holding his shield out before him, that he intended to die in defense of the city entrusted to his care. Philocles then commanded some Thracians to throw their javelins at him and his men; they were all killed. Thus, despite the alliance established by the Achaeans with the Romans, two of their most important cities, Argos and Corinth, remained under Philip’s control. This was the work accomplished during that summer by the land and sea forces of Rome engaged in Greece.

26

In Gaul, the consul Sextus Aelius did nothing worth mention, though he had two armies in the province: one, which he had retained under their standards, although it ought to have been disbanded; and of this, which had served under Lucius Cornelius, proconsul, he had given the command to Caius Helvius, the praetor: the other he had brought with him into the province. He spent nearly the whole summer in compelling the people of Cremona and Placentia to return to their colonies, from whence they had been driven to various places by the calamities of war. While Gaul, beyond expectation, remained quiet through the whole year, an insurrection of the slaves was very near taking place in the neighbourhood of the city. The hostages, given by the Carthaginians, were kept in custody at Setia: as they were the children of the principal families, they were attended by a great multitude of slaves; to this number many were added, in consequence of the late African war, and by the Setians themselves having bought, from among the spoil, several of those which had been captured. Having conspired together, they sent some of their number to engage in the cause the slaves of the country round Setia, and then those at Norba and Circeii. When every thing was fully prepared, they determined, during the games which were soon to be solemnized at the first-mentioned place, to attack the people while intent on the show, and when Setia had been taken in the midst of the slaughter and unexpected turmoil, then to seize on Norba and Circeii. Information of this atrocious plot was brought to Rome, to Lucius Cornelius Merula, the city praetor. Two slaves came to him before daylight, and disclosed to him in order the whole proceedings and intentions of the conspirators. The praetor, ordering them to be guarded in his own house, summoned a meeting of the senate; and having laid before them the information of the discoverers, he was ordered to go himself to the spot, and examine into and crush the conspiracy. Setting out, accordingly, with five lieutenant-generals, he compelled such as he found in the country to take the military oath, to arm, and follow him. Having by this tumultuary kind of levy armed about two thousand men, while all were ignorant of his destination, he came to Setia. There the leaders of the conspiracy were instantly apprehended; on which, the remainder fled from the city; but parties were sent through the country to search them out. The services of the two who made the discovery, and of one free person employed, were highly meritorious. The senate ordered a present to the latter of a hundred thousand asses;[8] to the slaves, twenty-five thousand asses[9] each, and their freedom. The price was paid to their owners out of the treasury. Not long after, intelligence was received, that other slaves, belonging to the remains of the conspiracy, had formed a design of seizing Praeneste. The praetor, Lucius Cornelius, went thither, and inflicted punishment on near five hundred persons concerned in that wicked scheme. The public were under apprehensions that the Carthaginian hostages and prisoners fomented these plots: watches were, therefore, kept at Rome in all the streets, which the inferior magistrates were ordered to go round and inspect; while the triumvirs of the prison, called the Quarry, were to keep a stricter guard than usual. Circular letters were also sent by the praetor to all the Latin states, directing that the hostages should be confined within doors, and not at any time allowed the liberty of going into public; and that the prisoners should be kept bound with fetters, of not less than ten pounds weight, and confined in no other place of custody than the common jail.

In Gaul, the consul Sextus Aelius didn’t do anything notable, even though he had two armies in the province: one he kept under their standards, which should have been disbanded, and he gave command of this army, which had served under Lucius Cornelius, the proconsul, to Caius Helvius, the praetor. The other army he brought with him into the province. He spent nearly the entire summer forcing the people of Cremona and Placentia to return to their colonies, from which they had been displaced to various areas due to the troubles of war. While Gaul surprisingly remained peaceful throughout the year, there was a significant risk of a slave uprising near the city. The hostages provided by the Carthaginians were held in Setia; since they were the children of prominent families, they were accompanied by a large number of slaves. Many more were added because of the recent African war, and by the Setians purchasing several captives from the spoils. After conspiring together, they sent some of their group to join the slaves in the surrounding areas like Setia, Norba, and Circeii. Once everything was prepared, they planned to attack during the games to be held in Setia, when the people would be focused on the entertainment. After seizing Setia amidst the chaos and slaughter, they intended to take Norba and Circeii. Word of this dreadful plan reached Rome, specifically to Lucius Cornelius Merula, the city praetor. Two slaves came to him before dawn and revealed the entire plot and intentions of the conspirators. The praetor had them guarded in his house and called a meeting of the senate; after presenting the information from the informants, he was instructed to go directly to the scene, investigate, and dismantle the conspiracy. He set off with five lieutenant-generals, forcing any he encountered in the area to take the military oath, arm themselves, and follow him. From this hurried recruitment, he assembled about two thousand men, all unaware of his destination, and made his way to Setia. There, the leaders of the conspiracy were quickly captured, prompting the rest to flee the city; teams were dispatched throughout the countryside to hunt them down. The contributions of the two informants and one involved free person were greatly acknowledged. The senate awarded the latter a gift of one hundred thousand asses;[8] to the slaves, twenty-five thousand asses[9] each, along with their freedom. The payment was made to their owners from the treasury. Soon after, news came that other slaves, still linked to the conspiracy, were planning to seize Praeneste. The praetor, Lucius Cornelius, went there and punished nearly five hundred individuals involved in that nefarious plot. The public was concerned that the Carthaginian hostages and prisoners were instigating these plots: therefore, watches were organized throughout Rome in all the streets, with lower magistrates assigned to patrol and inspect. The triumvirs of the prison, called the Quarry, were instructed to maintain a stricter guard than usual. The praetor also sent circular letters to all the Latin states, instructing that hostages should stay indoors and not be allowed public access at any time, and that prisoners must be kept in chains weighing no less than ten pounds and housed only in the common jail.

27

In this year, ambassadors from king Attalus made an offering, in the Capitol, of a golden crown of two hundred and fifty-six pounds' weight, and returned thanks to the senate, because Antiochus, influenced by the authority of the Romans, had withdrawn his troops out of the territories of Attalus. During the same summer, two hundred horsemen, ten elephants, and two hundred thousand pecks of wheat, arrived from king Masinissa for the army in Greece. From Sicily also, and Sardinia, large supplies of provisions were sent, with clothing for the troops. Sicily was then governed by Marcus Marcellus, Sardinia by Marcus Porcius Cato, a man of acknowledged integrity and purity of conduct, but deemed too severe in punishing usury. He drove the usurers entirely out of the island; and restricted or abolished the contributions, usually paid by the allies, for maintaining the dignity of the praetors. The consul, Sextus Aelius, coming home from Gaul to Rome to hold the elections, elected consuls, Caius Cornelius Cethegus and Quintus Minucius Rufus. Two days after was held the election of praetors; and this year, for the first time, six praetors were appointed, in consequence of the increase of the provinces, and the extension of the bounds of the empire. The persons elected were, Lucius Manlius Vulso, Caius Sempronius Tuditanus, Marcus Sergius Silus, Marcus Helvius, Marcus Minucius Rufus, and Lucius Atilius. Of these Sempronius and Helvius were, at the time, plebeian aediles. The curule aediles were Quintus Minucius Thermus and Tiberius Sempronius Longus. The Roman games were four times repeated during this year.

In this year, ambassadors from King Attalus made an offering at the Capitol, presenting a golden crown that weighed two hundred and fifty-six pounds, and thanked the Senate because Antiochus, swayed by Roman influence, had pulled his troops out of Attalus's territories. During the same summer, two hundred horsemen, ten elephants, and two hundred thousand pecks of wheat arrived from King Masinissa for the army in Greece. Additionally, large supplies of provisions and clothing for the troops were sent from Sicily and Sardinia. At that time, Sicily was governed by Marcus Marcellus, while Sardinia was overseen by Marcus Porcius Cato, a man known for his integrity and uprightness, but considered too harsh when it came to punishing usurers. He completely expelled the usurers from the island and limited or eliminated the contributions that were typically paid by the allies to support the dignity of the praetors. The consul, Sextus Aelius, returned to Rome from Gaul to conduct the elections and elected Caius Cornelius Cethegus and Quintus Minucius Rufus as consuls. Two days later, the election of praetors took place, and for the first time this year, six praetors were appointed due to the expansion of the provinces and the empire's boundaries. The elected candidates were Lucius Manlius Vulso, Caius Sempronius Tuditanus, Marcus Sergius Silus, Marcus Helvius, Marcus Minucius Rufus, and Lucius Atilius. At that time, Sempronius and Helvius were serving as plebeian aediles. The curule aediles were Quintus Minucius Thermus and Tiberius Sempronius Longus. The Roman games were held four times throughout this year.

28

On Caius Cornelius and Quintus Minucius becoming consuls, the first business of all was the arrangement of the provinces of the consuls and praetors. Those of the praetors were the first settled, because that could be transacted by the lots. The city jurisdiction fell to Sergius; the foreign to Minucius; Atilius obtained Sardinia; Manlius, Sicily; Sempronius, the Hither Spain; and Helvius, the Farther. When the consuls were preparing to cast lots for Italy and Macedonia, Lucius Oppius and Quintus Fulvius, plebeian tribunes, stood in their way, alleging, that "Macedonia was a very distant province, and that the principal cause which had hitherto retarded the progress of the war, was, that when it was scarcely entered upon, and just at the commencement of operations, the former consul was always recalled. This was the fourth year since the declaration of war against Macedonia. The greater part of one year Sulpicius spent in seeking the king and his army; Villius, on the point of engaging the enemy, was recalled without any thing having been done. Quinctius was detained at Rome, for the greater part of his year, by business respecting religion; nevertheless, he had so conducted affairs, that had he come earlier into the province, or had the cold season been at a greater distance, he might have put an end to hostilities. He was then just going into winter quarters; but, it was stated that he had brought the war into such a state, that if he were not prevented by a intercessor, he seemed likely to complete it in the course of the ensuing summer." By such arguments the tribunes so far prevailed, that the consuls declared that they would abide by the directions of the senate, if the tribunes would agree to do the same. Both parties having, accordingly, left the consultation perfectly free, a decree was passed, appointing the two consuls to the government of the province of Italy. Titus Quinctius was continued in command, until a successor should accede by a decree of the senate. To each, two legions were decreed; and they were ordered, with these, to carry on the war with the Cisalpine Gauls, who had revolted from the Romans. A reinforcement of five thousand foot and three hundred horse was ordered to be sent into Macedonia to Quinctius, together with three thousand seamen. Lucius Quinctius Flamininus was continued in the command of the fleet. To each of the praetors for the two Spains were granted eight thousand foot, of the allies and Latins, and four hundred horse; so that they might discharge the veteran troops in their provinces. They were further directed to fix the bounds which should divide the hither from the farther province. Two additional lieutenant-generals were sent to the army in Macedonia, Publius Sulpicius and Publius Villius, who had been consuls in that province.

When Caius Cornelius and Quintus Minucius became consuls, the first order of business was to assign the provinces to the consuls and praetors. The praetors' assignments were settled first, as this could be done through a lottery. Sergius received the city jurisdiction, Minucius the foreign, Atilius was given Sardinia, Manlius Sicily, Sempronius took charge of Hither Spain, and Helvius of Farther Spain. As the consuls were getting ready to draw lots for Italy and Macedonia, Lucius Oppius and Quintus Fulvius, the plebeian tribunes, intervened, arguing that "Macedonia is a very distant province, and the main reason that the war has stalled so far is that whenever it was just beginning, the previous consul was always recalled. This is now the fourth year since war was declared against Macedonia. Sulpicius spent most of one year trying to find the king and his army; Villius was about to engage the enemy but was recalled without taking any action. Quinctius was held back in Rome for most of his term due to religious matters; however, he managed the situation so well that had he arrived earlier in the province, or if the cold season had been further away, he could have ended the conflict. At that moment he was preparing for winter quarters; it was reported that he had brought the war to such a point that if no one intervened, he was likely to finish it by the next summer." With such arguments, the tribunes succeeded to the extent that the consuls agreed to follow the senate's directions if the tribunes would do the same. Both sides then allowed for an entirely free consultation, resulting in a decree that appointed the two consuls to govern Italy. Titus Quinctius was kept in command until a successor was appointed by a senate decree. Each was granted two legions and ordered to conduct the war against the Cisalpine Gauls, who had revolted against the Romans. A reinforcement of five thousand infantry and three hundred cavalry was ordered to be sent to Quinctius in Macedonia, along with three thousand sailors. Lucius Quinctius Flamininus continued to lead the fleet. Each of the praetors for the two Spains was assigned eight thousand infantry from the allies and Latins, and four hundred cavalry, allowing them to relieve the veteran troops in their provinces. They were also instructed to establish the borders dividing the Hither from the Farther province. Two additional lieutenant-generals, Publius Sulpicius and Publius Villius, who had previously served as consuls in that province, were sent to the army in Macedonia.

29

It was thought necessary, that before the consuls and praetors went abroad, some prodigies should be expiated. For the temples of Vulcan and Summanus,[10] at Rome, and a wall and a gate at Fregellae, had been struck by lightning. At Frusino, light had shone forth during the night. At Asculum, a lamb had been born with two heads and five feet. At Formiae, two wolves entering the town had torn several persons who fell in their way; and, at Rome, a wolf had made its way, not only into the city, but into the Capitol. Caius Acilius, plebeian tribune, caused an order to be passed, that five colonies should be led out to the sea-coast; two to the mouths of the rivers Vulturnus and Liternus; one to Puteoli and one to the fort of Salernum. To these was added Buxentum. To each colony three hundred families were ordered to be sent. The commissioners appointed to conduct them thither, and who were to hold the office for three years, were Marcus Servilius Geminus, Quintus Minucius Thermus, and Tiberius Sempronius Longus. As soon as the levies, and such other business, religious and civil, as required their personal attendance, was finished, both the consuls set out for Gaul. Cornelius took the direct road towards the Insubrians, who were then in arms, and had been joined by the Caenomanians. Quintus Minucius turned his route to the left side of Italy, and leading away his army to the lower sea, to Genoa, opened the campaign with an invasion of Liguria. Two towns, Clastidium and Litubium, both belonging to the Ligurians, and two states of the same nation, Celela and Cerdicium, surrendered to him. And now, all the states on this side of the Po, except the Boians among the Gauls and the Ilvatians among the Ligurians, were reduced to submission: no less, it is said, than fifteen towns and twenty thousand men surrendered themselves. He then led his legions into the territory of the Boians.

It was deemed necessary that before the consuls and praetors left for their duties, some strange events should be addressed. The temples of Vulcan and Summanus in Rome, as well as a wall and a gate in Fregellae, had been struck by lightning. In Frusino, light had appeared during the night. In Asculum, a lamb had been born with two heads and five feet. In Formiae, two wolves had entered the town and attacked several people in their path; meanwhile, in Rome, a wolf had not only entered the city but made its way into the Capitol. Caius Acilius, a plebeian tribune, put forth a measure that five colonies should be sent to the coast; two at the mouths of the rivers Vulturnus and Liternus, one at Puteoli, and one at the fort of Salernum. Buxentum was added to this list. Three hundred families were to be sent to each colony. The commissioners chosen to manage this, serving for three years, were Marcus Servilius Geminus, Quintus Minucius Thermus, and Tiberius Sempronius Longus. Once the levies and other necessary religious and civic duties requiring their presence were completed, both consuls set off for Gaul. Cornelius took the direct route towards the Insubrians, who were armed and had allied with the Caenomanians. Quintus Minucius headed to the left side of Italy, moving his army to the lower sea, to Genoa, where he started the campaign with an invasion of Liguria. Two towns, Clastidium and Litubium, which were part of the Ligurians, along with two states of the same group, Celela and Cerdicium, surrendered to him. Now, all the states on this side of the Po, except the Boians among the Gauls and the Ilvatians among the Ligurians, had submitted: it is said that as many as fifteen towns and twenty thousand men gave themselves up. He then led his legions into Boians' territory.

30

The Boian army had, not very long before, crossed the Po and joined the Insubrians and Caenomanians; for, having heard that the consuls intended to act with their forces united, they wished to increase their own strength by this junction. But when information reached them that one of the consuls was ravaging the country of the Boians, a dispute instantly arose. The Boians demanded, that all, in conjunction, should carry succour to those who were attacked; while the Insubrians positively refused to leave their country defenceless. In consequence of this dissension, the armies separated; the Boians went to defend their own territory, and the Insubrians, with the Caenomanians, encamped on the banks of the river Mincius. About five miles below this spot, the consul Cornelius pitched his camp close to the same river. Sending emissaries hence into the villages of the Caenomanians, and to Brixia, the capital of their tribe, he learned with certainty that their young men had taken arms without the approbation of the elders; and that the Caenomanians had not joined in the revolt of the Insubrians by any public authority. On which he invited to him the principal of the natives, and endeavoured to contrive and concert with them that the Caenomanians should separate from the Insubrians; and either march away and return home, or come over to the side of the Romans. This he was not able to effect; but so far, he received solemn assurances that, in case of a battle, they would either stand inactive, or, should any occasion offer, would even assist the Romans. The Insubrians knew not that such an agreement had been concluded, but they harboured in their minds some kind of suspicion, that the fidelity of their confederates was wavering. Wherefore, in forming their troops for battle, not daring to intrust either wing to them, lest, if they should treacherously give ground, they might cause a total defeat, they placed them in reserve behind the line. At the beginning of the fight, the consul vowed a temple to Juno Sospita, provided the enemy should, on that day, be routed and driven from the field; on which the soldiers raised a shout, declaring, that they would insure to their commander the completion of his vow, and at the same time an attack was made on the enemy. The Insubrians did not stand even the first onset. Some writers affirm, that the Caenomanians, falling on their rear during the heat of the engagement, caused as much disorder there as prevailed in their front: and that, thus assailed on both sides, thirty-five thousand of them were slain, five thousand seven hundred taken prisoners, among whom was Hamilcar, a Carthaginian general, who had been the cause of the war; and that a hundred and thirty military standards and above two hundred waggons were taken. On this, the towns of the Gauls, which had joined in the revolt of the Insubrians, surrendered to the Romans.

The Boian army had, not long ago, crossed the Po River and joined forces with the Insubrians and Caenomanians. They heard that the consuls planned to act with their unified forces, so they wanted to strengthen their position by teaming up. However, when news reached them that one of the consuls was attacking Boians' territory, a disagreement broke out. The Boians insisted that everyone work together to support those under attack, while the Insubrians firmly refused to leave their own land unprotected. As a result of this conflict, the armies split; the Boians went to defend their own lands, while the Insubrians and Caenomanians camped by the Mincius River. About five miles downstream, Consul Cornelius set up camp near the same river. He sent messengers to the Caenomanians' villages and to Brixia, their capital, where he found out that their young men had taken up arms without the elders' approval and that the Caenomanians had not officially joined the Insubrian revolt. He then invited key local leaders to discuss separating the Caenomanians from the Insubrians, hoping they would either leave and go home or join the Romans. He couldn't fully achieve this, but he did get strong promises that, if a battle broke out, they would either remain neutral or help the Romans if the opportunity arose. The Insubrians were unaware of this agreement but felt some suspicion that their allies’ loyalty was shaky. Thus, when preparing their troops for battle, they didn't trust either flank to them, fearing they might desert and lead to a total defeat, so they kept them in reserve behind the lines. At the start of the fight, the consul vowed to build a temple to Juno Sospita if they could defeat the enemy that day; the soldiers cheered, promising to help him fulfill his vow, and then they charged at the enemy. The Insubrians couldn't withstand the first attack. Some historians claim that the Caenomanians attacked their rear during the heat of battle, causing as much chaos as was unfolding in the front lines: overwhelmed from both sides, thirty-five thousand of them were killed, and five thousand seven hundred were captured, including Hamilcar, a Carthaginian general who had instigated the war. They also lost a hundred and thirty military standards and over two hundred wagons. Following this, the Gallic towns that had joined the Insubrian revolt surrendered to the Romans.

31

The other consul, Minucius, had at first traversed the territories of the Boians, with wide-spread ravaging parties; but afterwards, when that people left the Insubrians, and came home to defend their own property, he kept his men within their camp, expecting to come to a regular engagement with the enemy. Nor would the Boians have declined a battle, if their spirits had not been depressed by hearing of the defeat of the Insubrians. Upon this, deserting their commander and their camp, they dispersed themselves through the several towns, each wishing to take care of his own effects. Thus they changed the enemy's method of carrying on the war: for, no longer hoping to decide the matter by a single battle, he began again to lay waste the lands, burn the houses, and storm the villages. At this time, Clastidium was burned, and the legions were led thence against the Ilvatian Ligurians, who alone refused to submit. That state, also, on learning that the Insubrians had been defeated in battle, and the Boians so terrified that they had not dared to try the fortune of an engagement, made a submission. Letters from the consuls, containing accounts of their successes, came from Gaul to Rome at the same time. Marcus Sergius, city praetor, read them in the senate, and afterwards, by direction of the fathers, in an assembly of the people; on which a supplication, of four days' continuance, was decreed.

The other consul, Minucius, initially moved through the territories of the Boians, leading widespread raiding parties. However, once the Boians left the Insubrians and returned home to protect their own property, he kept his troops in their camp, anticipating a formal battle with the enemy. The Boians would have accepted a fight, but their morale was low after hearing about the Insubrians' defeat. As a result, they abandoned their commander and camp, scattering to various towns, each wanting to look after their own belongings. This changed the enemy's approach to the war: no longer expecting to settle things with a single battle, he began again to devastate the land, burn down houses, and attack villages. During this period, Clastidium was burned, and the legions were sent out against the Ilvatian Ligurians, who alone refused to surrender. That state, upon hearing about the Insubrians' defeat and seeing that the Boians were so shaken they didn't dare face a battle, also decided to surrender. Letters from the consuls detailing their successes were sent from Gaul to Rome simultaneously. Marcus Sergius, the city praetor, read them in the senate, and later, as directed by the fathers, in a public assembly, which led to a four-day public supplication being declared.

32

It was by this time winter; and while Titus Quinctius, after the reduction of Elatia, had his winter quarters distributed in Phocis and Locris, a violent dissension broke out at Opus. One faction invited to their assistance the Aetolians who were nearest at hand; the other, the Romans. The Aetolians arrived first; but the other party, which was the more powerful, refused them admittance, and, despatching a courier to the Roman general, held the city until his arrival. The citadel was possessed by a garrison belonging to the king, and they could not be prevailed on to retire from thence, either by the threats of the people of Opus, or by the authority of the Roman consul's commands. What prevented their being immediately attacked was, the arrival of an envoy from the king, to solicit the appointing of a time and place for a conference. This was granted to the king with great reluctance; not that Quinctius did not wish to see war concluded under his own auspices, partly by arms, and partly by negotiation: for he knew not, yet, whether one of the new consuls would be sent out as his successor, or whether he should be continued in the command; a point which he had charged his friends and relations to labour for with all their might. But he thought that a conference would answer this purpose; that it would put it in his power to give matters a turn towards war, in case he remained in the province, or towards peace, if he were to be removed. They chose for the meeting a part of the sea-shore, in the Malian gulf, near Nicaea. Thither Philip came from Demetrias, with five barks and one ship of war: he was accompanied by some principal Macedonians, and an Achaean exile, name Cycliades, a man of considerable note. With the Roman general, were king Amynander, Dionysidorus, ambassador from king Attalus, Agesimbrotus, commander of the Rhodian fleet, Phaeneas, praetor of the Aetolians, and two Achaeans, Aristaenus and Xenophon. Attended by these, the Roman general advanced to the brink of the shore, when the king had come forward to the prow of his vessel, as it lay at anchor; and said, "If you will come on the shore, we shall mutually speak and hear with more convenience." This the king refused; and on Quinctius asking him, "Whom do you fear?" With the haughty spirit of royalty, he replied, "Fear I have none, but of the immortal gods; but I have no confidence in the faith of those whom I see about you, and least of all in the Aetolians." "That danger," said the Roman, "is equal to all in common who confer with an enemy, if no confidence subsists." "But, Titus Quinctius," replied the king, "if treachery be intended, the prizes of perfidy are not equal, namely, Philip and Phaeneas. For it will not be so difficult for the Aetolians to find another praetor, as for the Macedonians to find another king in my place."--Silence then ensued.

It was winter by this time, and while Titus Quinctius had set up his winter quarters in Phocis and Locris after taking Elatia, a serious conflict broke out in Opus. One group called in the nearby Aetolians for help, while the other called for the Romans. The Aetolians got there first, but the more powerful faction denied them entry and sent a message to the Roman general, holding the city until he arrived. The citadel was occupied by a garrison belonging to the king, and they would not leave, regardless of the threats from the people of Opus or the orders from the Roman consul. What stopped them from being attacked immediately was the arrival of a messenger from the king, asking to set a time and place for a meeting. This was granted very reluctantly; not that Quinctius didn't want to see the war end under his leadership, part through battles and part through negotiation, but because he wasn't sure whether one of the new consuls would replace him or if he'd still be in command—a matter he urged his friends and family to work on with all their effort. However, he thought a meeting could help; it would allow him to steer things toward war if he stayed in the province or toward peace if he were removed. They decided to meet on a part of the shoreline in the Malian Gulf, near Nicaea. Philip came from Demetrias with five small boats and a warship, accompanied by some important Macedonians and an Achaean exile named Cycliades, who was well-regarded. The Roman general was with King Amynander, Dionysidorus, an envoy from King Attalus, Agesimbrotus, captain of the Rhodian fleet, Phaeneas, praetor of the Aetolians, and two Achaeans, Aristaenus and Xenophon. Accompanied by these, the Roman general walked to the edge of the shore while the king stood at the bow of his anchored ship. He said, "If you come ashore, we can talk and listen more easily." The king refused, and when Quinctius asked him, "What do you fear?" with a proud royal attitude, he replied, "I have no fear except of the immortal gods; but I have no trust in those I see around you, especially not the Aetolians." "That danger," said the Roman, "is the same for anyone who meets with an enemy if there’s no trust." "But, Titus Quinctius," the king replied, "if treachery is intended, the stakes of betrayal are not the same, namely, Philip and Phaeneas. It will not be as easy for the Aetolians to find another praetor as it will be for the Macedonians to find another king in my place." Then there was silence.

33

The Roman expected that he who solicited the conference should open it; and the king thought that he who was to prescribe, not he who received, terms of peace, ought to begin the conference. At length the Roman said, that "his discourse should be very simple; for he would only mention those articles, without which there could be no conditions of peace. These were, that the king should withdraw his garrisons from all the cities of Greece. That he should deliver up to the allies of the Roman people the prisoners and deserters; should restore to the Romans those places in Illyricum of which he had possessed himself by force, since the peace concluded in Epirus; and to Ptolemy, king of Egypt, the cities which he had seized since the death of Ptolemy Philopater." These were the terms which he required, on behalf of himself and the Roman people: but it was proper that the demands of the allies, also, should be heard. The ambassador of king Attalus demanded "restitution of the ships and prisoners taken in the sea-fight at Cius; and that Nicephorium, and the temple of Venus, which Philip had pillaged and defaced, should be restored as though they had not been injured." The Rhodians laid claim to Peraea, a tract on the continent, lying opposite to their island, which from early times had been under their jurisdiction; and they required that "the garrisons should be withdrawn from Tassus, Bargylii, and Euroma, and from Sestus and Abydos on the Hellespont; that Perinthus should be restored to the Byzantians, in right of their ancient title, and that all the sea-port towns and harbours of Asia should be free." The Achaeans demanded the restoration of Corinth and Argos. Phaeneas nearly repeated the demands made by the Romans, that the troops should withdraw out of Greece, and the Aetolians be put in possession of the cities which had formerly been under their dominion. He was followed by Alexander, a man of eminence among the Aetolians, and, considering his country, not uneloquent. He said, that "he had long kept silence, not because he expected that any business would be effected in that conference, but because he was unwilling to interrupt any of the allies in their discourse." He asserted, that "Philip was neither treating for peace with sincerity; and that he had never waged war with true courage, at any time: that in negotiating, he was insidious and fradulent; while in war he never fought on equal ground, nor engaged in regular battles; but, skulking about, burned and pillaged towns, and, when worsted, destroyed the prizes of victory. But not in that manner did the ancient kings of Macedon behave; they decided the fate of the war in the field, and spared the towns as far as they were able, in order to possess the more opulent empire. For what sort of conduct was it, to destroy the objects for the possession of which the contest was waged, and thereby leave nothing to himself but fighting? Philip had, in the last year, desolated more cities of his allies in Thessaly, than all the enemies that Thessaly ever had. On the Aetolians themselves he had made greater depredations, when he was in alliance with them, than since he became their enemy. He had seized on Lysimachia, after dislodging the praetor and garrison of the Aetolians. Cius also, a city belonging to their government, he razed from the foundation. With the same injustice he held possession of Thebes in Phthiotis, of Echinus, Larissa, and Pharsalus."

The Roman thought that whoever requested the meeting should start it, while the king believed that the one setting the terms of peace should initiate the discussion. Eventually, the Roman said that "his message would be straightforward; he would only bring up the points that were essential for any peace agreement. These were that the king should withdraw his troops from all the cities in Greece. He should hand over the prisoners and deserters to the Roman allies, return the territories in Illyricum that he had taken by force since the peace deal in Epirus, and return the cities he had seized from Ptolemy, king of Egypt, since the death of Ptolemy Philopater." These were the terms he required on behalf of himself and the Roman people, but it was also important to consider the demands of the allies. The ambassador of King Attalus asked for "the return of the ships and prisoners taken during the sea battle at Cius and for Nicephorium and the temple of Venus, which Philip had plundered and vandalized, to be restored as if they had never been harmed." The Rhodians claimed Peraea, a region on the mainland across from their island, which had been under their control for a long time; they demanded "the withdrawal of troops from Tassus, Bargylii, Euroma, and from Sestus and Abydos on the Hellespont; that Perinthus be returned to the Byzantians in recognition of their ancient rights, and that all seaports and harbors in Asia be made free." The Achaeans asked for the return of Corinth and Argos. Phaeneas echoed the Romans' demands, stating that the troops should leave Greece and that the Aetolians should regain control of the cities that were once theirs. He was followed by Alexander, a prominent figure among the Aetolians, who, given his background, was quite articulate. He said that "he had stayed quiet for a long time, not because he thought anything would come from this meeting, but because he didn’t want to interrupt the allies as they spoke." He claimed that "Philip was not negotiating for peace in good faith; he had never fought wars with true bravery. In negotiations, he was sly and deceitful; in battle, he avoided fair fights and regular engagements, instead lurking around to burn and pillage towns, and when he was losing, he destroyed the spoils of victory. Ancient Macedonian kings did not act like this; they determined the outcome of wars on the battlefield and did their best to spare towns in order to control a richer empire. What kind of behavior is it to destroy the very things one fights for, leaving only conflict behind? Last year, Philip devastated more of his allies' cities in Thessaly than all of Thessaly's enemies combined. He inflicted more damage on the Aetolians while he was allied with them than he did once he became their enemy. He took Lysimachia by driving out the Aetolian praetor and garrison. He also completely destroyed Cius, a city under their governance. He had unjustly seized control of Thebes in Phthiotis, Echinus, Larissa, and Pharsalus."

34

Philip, provoked by this discourse of Alexander, pushed his ship nearer to the land, that he might be the better heard, and began to speak with much violence, particularly against the Aetolians. But Phaeneas, interrupting him, said that "the business depended not upon words; he must either conquer in war, or submit to his superiors." "That, indeed, is evident," said Philip, "even to the blind," reflecting on Phaeneas, who had a disorder in his eyes: for he was naturally fonder of such pleasantries than became a king; and even in the midst of serious business, did not sufficiently restrain himself from ridicule. He then began to express great indignation at the "Aetolians assuming as much importance as the Romans, and insisting on his evacuating Greece; people who could not even tell what were its boundaries. For, of Aetolia itself, a large proportion, consisting of the Agraeans, Apodeotians, and Amphilochians, was no part of Greece. Have they just ground of complaint against me for not refraining from war with their allies, when themselves, from the earliest period, follow, as an established rule, the practice of suffering their young men to carry arms against those allies, withholding only the public authority of the state; while very frequently contending armies have Aetolian auxiliaries on both sides? I did not seize on Cius by force, but assisted my friend and ally, Prusias, who was besieging it, and Lysimachia I rescued from the Thracians. But since necessity diverted my attention from the guarding of it to this present war, the Thracians have possession of it. So much for the Aetolians. To Attalus and the Rhodians I in justice owe nothing; for not to me, but to themselves, is the commencement of hostilities to be attributed. However, out of respect to the Romans, I will restore Peraea to the Rhodians, and to Attalus his ships, and such prisoners as can be found. As to what concerns Nicephorium, and the temple of Venus, what other answer can I make to those who require their restoration, than that I will take on myself the trouble and expense of replanting them--the only way in which woods and groves which have been cut down can be restored,--since it is thought fit that, between kings, such kinds of demands should be made and answered." The last part of his speech was directed to the Achaeans, wherein he enumerated, first, the kindnesses of Antigonus; then, his own towards their nation, desiring them to consider the decrees themselves had passed concerning him, which comprehended every kind of honour, divine and human; and to these he added their late decree, by which they had confirmed the resolution of deserting him. He inveighed bitterly against their perfidy, but told them, that nevertheless he would give them back Argos. "With regard to Corinth, he would consult with the Roman general; and would, at the same time, inquire from him, whether he thought it right, that he (Philip) should evacuate only those cities which, being captured by himself, were held by the right of war; or those, also, which he had received from his ancestors."

Philip, irritated by Alexander’s talk, moved his ship closer to the shore so he could be heard better and started speaking very passionately, especially about the Aetolians. But Phaeneas interrupted him, saying that "this issue isn’t about words; he must either win in battle or accept his superiors." Philip replied, "That’s clear, even to the blind," referring to Phaeneas, who had vision problems. Philip had a tendency to make light-hearted remarks that didn't quite suit a king, and he often didn’t hold back from making jokes even during serious discussions. He then expressed strong discontent with the Aetolians for thinking they were as important as the Romans and demanding that he leave Greece; people who couldn’t even define its borders. As for Aetolia itself, a large part of it—comprising the Agraeans, Apodeotians, and Amphilochians—was not even Greek. Do they really have grounds to complain about me for not avoiding conflict with their allies when they themselves have always allowed their young men to fight against those allies, only refraining from officially endorsing it? Moreover, frequently contending armies have had Aetolian soldiers on both sides. I didn’t take Cius by force; instead, I helped my friend and ally, Prusias, who was under siege there, and I freed Lysimachia from the Thracians. But since necessity shifted my focus from protecting it to this war, the Thracians now control it. That’s enough about the Aetolians. I owe nothing to Attalus and the Rhodians; the start of hostilities should be credited to them, not me. Still, out of respect for the Romans, I will return Peraea to the Rhodians and Attalus’s ships, as well as any prisoners we can find. Regarding Nicephorium and the temple of Venus, what can I say to those asking for their return but that I will take the time and expense to replant them—the only way to restore woods and groves that have been cut down—since it seems appropriate for kings to make and respond to such demands." The final part of his speech was aimed at the Achaeans, where he first listed the favors bestowed by Antigonus and then those he had shown toward their nation, urging them to consider the decrees they had issued concerning him, which encompassed all types of honor, both divine and human. He also mentioned their recent decree, which confirmed their decision to abandon him. He criticized their betrayal harshly but told them that, regardless, he would return Argos. "As for Corinth, I will consult with the Roman general and at the same time ask him whether it’s right for me to evacuate only those cities that I captured and hold by the right of war, or also those I inherited from my ancestors."

35

The Achaeans and Aetolians were preparing to answer, but, as the sun was near setting, the conference was adjourned to the next day; and Philip returned to his station whence he came, the Romans and allies to their camp. On the following day, Quinctius repaired to Nicaea, which was the place agreed on, at the appointed time; but neither Philip, nor any messenger from him, came for several hours. At length, when they began to despair of his coming, his ships suddenly appeared. He said, that "the terms enjoined were so severe and humiliating, that, not knowing what to determine, he had spent the day in deliberation." But the general opinion was, that he had purposely delayed the business until late, that the Achaeans and Aetolians might not have time to answer him: and this opinion he himself confirmed, by desiring that time might not be consumed in altercation, and, to bring the affair to some conclusion, that the others should retire, and leave him to converse with the Roman general. For some time this was not admitted, lest the allies should appear to be excluded from the conference. Afterwards, on his persisting in his desire, the Roman general, with the consent of all, taking with him Appius Claudius, a military tribune, advanced to the brink of the coast, and the rest retired. The king, with the two persons whom he had brought the day before, came on shore, where they conversed a considerable time in private. What account of their proceedings Philip gave to his people is not well known: what Quinctius told the allies was, that "Philip was willing to cede to the Romans the whole coast of Illyricum, and to give up the deserters and prisoners, if there were any. That he consented to restore to Attalus his ships, and the seamen taken with them; and to the Rhodians the tract which they call Peraea. That he refused to evacuate Iassus and Bargylii. To the Aetolians he was ready to restore Pharsalus and Larissa; Thebes he would not restore: and that he would give back to the Achaeans the possession, not only of Argos, but of Corinth also." This arrangement pleased none of the parties; neither those to whom the concessions were to be made, nor those to whom they were refused; "for on that plan," they said, "more would be lost than gained; nor could the grounds of contention ever be removed, but by his withdrawing his forces from every part of Greece."

The Achaeans and Aetolians were getting ready to respond, but since the sun was almost setting, the meeting was postponed until the next day; Philip returned to where he came from, and the Romans and their allies went back to their camp. The next day, Quinctius went to Nicaea, the agreed location, at the scheduled time, but neither Philip nor any messenger from him showed up for several hours. Eventually, when they started to lose hope of his arrival, his ships appeared out of nowhere. He claimed that "the conditions set were so harsh and humiliating that he had spent the day figuring out what to do." However, most people believed he had deliberately delayed things until late so that the Achaeans and Aetolians wouldn’t have time to respond to him. He confirmed this by saying that they shouldn't waste time arguing and that the others should step back to allow him to speak with the Roman general. For a while, this wasn’t approved, as it would look like the allies were being sidelined from the discussion. Eventually, when he kept insisting, the Roman general, with everyone’s agreement, took Appius Claudius, a military tribune, and moved to the edge of the shore while the others stepped back. The king came ashore with the two men he brought the day before, and they talked privately for a while. How Philip reported their discussions to his people isn’t well known; what Quinctius told the allies was that "Philip was ready to give the Romans the entire Illyricum coast and to hand over any deserters and prisoners, if there were any. He agreed to return Attalus his ships and the sailors captured with them, and to the Rhodians, the region known as Peraea. He refused to vacate Iassus and Bargylii. He was willing to return Pharsalus and Larissa to the Aetolians, but he wouldn’t restore Thebes, and he would give back not just Argos to the Achaeans, but also Corinth." This proposal didn’t satisfy any of the parties; neither those who would receive the concessions nor those who were denied them; "because with this plan," they said, "they would lose more than they would gain; and the underlying issues couldn’t be resolved without his removing his forces from all of Greece."

36

These expressions, delivered with eagerness and vehemence by every one in the assembly, reached the ears of Philip, though he stood at a distance. He therefore requested of Quinctius, that the whole business might be deferred until the next day; and then he would, positively, either prevail on the allies, or suffer himself to be prevailed on by them. The shore at Thronium was appointed for their meeting, and there they assembled early. Philip began with entreating Quinctius, and all who were present, not to harbour such sentiments as must embarrass a negotiation of peace; and then desired time, while he could send ambassadors to Rome, to the senate, declaring, that "he would either obtain a peace on the terms mentioned, or would accept whatever terms the senate should prescribe." None by any means approved of this; they said, he only sought a delay, and leisure to collect his strength. But Quinctius observed, "that such an objection would have been well founded, if it were then summer and a season fit for action; as matters stood, and the winter being just at hand, nothing would be lost by allowing him time to send ambassadors. For, without the authority of the senate, no agreement which they might conclude with the king would be valid; and besides, they would by this means have an opportunity, while the winter itself would necessarily cause a suspension of arms, to learn the authoritative decision of the senate." The other chiefs of the allies came over to this opinion: and a cessation of hostilities for two months being granted, they resolved that each of their states should send an ambassador with the necessary information to the senate, and in order that it should not be deceived by the misrepresentations of Philip. To the above agreement for a truce, was added an article, that all the king's troops should be immediately withdrawn from Phocis and Locris. With the ambassadors of the allies, Quinctius sent Amynander, king of Athamania; and, to add a degree of splendour to the embassy, a deputation from himself, composed of Quintus Fabius, the son of his wife's sister, Quintus Fulvius, and Appius Claudius.

These statements, passionately expressed by everyone in the assembly, reached Philip's ears even though he was standing some distance away. He then asked Quinctius to postpone the whole matter until the next day; he would either convince the allies or let them convince him. They agreed to meet at the shore in Thronium and gathered there early. Philip began by urging Quinctius and everyone present not to hold onto views that would complicate the peace negotiations; he then requested time to send ambassadors to Rome to inform the senate that "he would either secure peace on the proposed terms or accept whatever terms the senate laid out." No one supported this idea; they argued that he was simply looking for a delay to gather his strength. However, Quinctius pointed out, "Such an objection would make sense if it were summer and suitable for action; given the current situation and the approaching winter, allowing him time to send ambassadors wouldn’t hurt. Without the senate's approval, any agreement with the king wouldn't hold, and this way, they would also have a chance to learn the senate's formal decision while winter brought a halt to fighting." The other leaders of the allies agreed with this perspective. They granted a ceasefire for two months and decided that each state should send an ambassador with the necessary information to the senate, ensuring that Philip could not mislead them. Along with the allies' ambassadors, Quinctius sent Amynander, the king of Athamania, and to elevate the mission’s prestige, he included Quintus Fabius, the son of his wife's sister, Quintus Fulvius, and Appius Claudius.

37

On their arrival at Rome, the ambassadors of the allies were admitted to audience before those of the king. Their discourse, in general, was filled up with invectives against Philip. What produced the greatest effect on the minds of the senate was, that, by pointing out the relative situations of the lands and seas in that part of the world, they made it manifest to every one, that if the king held Demetrias in Thessaly, Chalcis in Euboea, and Corinth in Achaia, Greece could not be free; and they added, that Philip himself, with not more insolence than truth, used to call these the fetters of Greece. The king's ambassadors were then introduced, and when they were beginning a long harangue, a short question cut short their discourse:--Whether he was willing to yield up the three above-mentioned cities? They answered, that they had received no specific instructions on that head: on which they were dismissed, the negotiation being left unsettled. Full authority was given to Quinctius to determine every thing relative to war and peace. As this demonstrated clearly that the senate were not weary of the war, so he, who was more earnestly desirous of conquest than of peace, never afterwards consented to a conference with Philip; and even gave him notice that he would not admit any embassy from him, unless it came with information that he was retiring from the whole of Greece.

Upon arriving in Rome, the ambassadors of the allies were granted an audience before those of the king. Their speech was mostly filled with harsh criticisms of Philip. What impacted the senate the most was that, by highlighting the geographic positions of the lands and seas in that part of the world, they made it clear to everyone that if the king controlled Demetrias in Thessaly, Chalcis in Euboea, and Corinth in Achaia, Greece could not be free; they pointed out that Philip himself, with a mix of arrogance and honesty, referred to these as Greece’s chains. The king's ambassadors were then introduced, and as they began a lengthy speech, they were interrupted with a straightforward question: Were they willing to give up the three cities mentioned? They replied that they had not received specific instructions regarding that matter, so they were dismissed, leaving the negotiation unresolved. Quinctius was given full authority to make all decisions regarding war and peace. This clearly showed that the senate was not tired of the war, and he, who was more eager for victory than for peace, never agreed to a meeting with Philip again; he even informed him that he wouldn't accept any envoy unless it came with news of his withdrawal from all of Greece.

38

Philip now perceived that he must decide the matter in the field, and collect his strength about him from all quarters. Being particularly uneasy in respect to the cities of Achaia, a country so distant from him, and also of Argos, even more, indeed, than of Corinth, he resolved, as the most advisable method, to put the former into the hands of Nabis, tyrant of Lacedaemon, in trust, as it were, on the terms, that if he should prove successful in the war, Nabis should re-deliver it to him; if any misfortune should happen, he should keep it himself. Accordingly, he wrote to Philocles, who had the command in Corinth and Argos, to have a meeting with the tyrant. Philocles, besides coming with a valuable present, added to that pledge of future friendship between the king and the tyrant, that it was Philip's wish to unite his daughters in marriage to the sons of Nabis. The tyrant, at first, refused to receive the city on any other conditions than that of being invited to its protection by a decree of the Argives themselves: but afterwards, hearing that in a full assembly they had treated the name of the tyrant not only with scorn, but even with abhorrence, he thought he had now a sufficient excuse for plundering them, and he accordingly desired Philocles to give him possession of the place as soon as he pleased. Nabis was admitted into the city in the night, without the privity of any of the inhabitants, and, at the first light, seized on the higher parts of it, and shut the gates. A few of the principal people having made their escape, during the first confusion, the properties of all who were absent were seized as booty: those who were present were stripped of their gold and silver, and loaded with exorbitant contributions. Such as paid these readily were discharged, without personal insult and laceration of their bodies; but such as were suspected of hiding or reserving any of their effects, were mangled and tortured like slaves. He then summoned an assembly, in which he promulgated two measures; one for an abolition of debts, the other for a distribution of the land, in shares, to each man--two fire-brands in the hands of those who were desirous of revolution, for inflaming the populace against the higher ranks.

Philip now realized that he had to settle the situation on the battlefield and gather his allies from everywhere. He was particularly worried about the cities in Achaia, a place so far away, and even more concerned about Argos than Corinth. He decided that the best approach would be to hand the former over to Nabis, the tyrant of Lacedaemon, effectively in trust, on the condition that if Nabis succeeded in the war, he would return it; but if anything went wrong, he would keep it for himself. So, he wrote to Philocles, who was in charge of Corinth and Argos, to arrange a meeting with the tyrant. Philocles, besides bringing a valuable gift, also offered a pledge of future friendship between the king and the tyrant, saying that Philip wanted to marry his daughters to Nabis’s sons. At first, the tyrant refused to take the city unless he was invited to protect it by a decree from the Argives themselves. However, after hearing that in a general assembly they had treated his name with not just scorn but even disgust, he felt he had a good reason to loot them and told Philocles to hand him the city whenever he wanted. Nabis entered the city at night without anyone knowing and, at dawn, took control of the higher parts and locked the gates. A few prominent people escaped during the initial chaos, and the properties of everyone else who was absent were seized as loot. Those present were stripped of their gold and silver and burdened with excessive demands. Those who complied quickly were let go without personal harm, but those suspected of hiding any valuables were tortured like slaves. He then called for a meeting where he announced two measures: one to cancel debts and the other to distribute land in shares to each man—two incendiary ideas in the hands of those eager for change, stirring the public against the elite.

39

The tyrant, when he had the city of Argos in his power, never considering from whom or on what conditions he had received it, sent ambassadors to Elatia, to Quinctius, and to Attalus, in his winter quarters at Aegina, to tell them, that "he was in possession of Argos; and that if Quinctius would come hither, and consult with him, he had no doubt but that every thing might be adjusted between them." Quinctius, in order that he might deprive Philip of that stronghold, along with the rest, consented to come; accordingly, sending a message to Attalus, to leave Aegina, and meet him at Sicyon, he set sail from Anticyra with ten quinqueremes, which his brother, Lucius Quinctius, happened to have brought a little before from his winter station at Corcyra, and passed over to Sicyon. Attalus was there before him, who, representing that the tyrant ought to come to the Roman general, not the general to the tyrant, brought Quinctius over to his opinion, which was, that he should not enter the city of Argos. Not far from it, however, was a place called Mycenica; and there the parties agreed to meet. Quinctius came, with his brother and a few military tribunes; Attalus, with his royal retinue; and Nicostratus the praetor of the Achaeans, with a few of the auxiliary officers: and they there found Nabis waiting with his whole army. He advanced, armed, and attended by his armed guards, almost to the middle of the interjacent plain; Quinctius unarmed, with his brother and two military tribunes; the king was accompanied by one of his nobles, and the praetor of the Achaeans, unarmed likewise. The tyrant, when he saw the king and the Roman general unarmed, opened the conference, with apologizing for having come to the meeting armed himself, and surrounded with armed men. "He had no apprehensions," he said, "from them; but only from the Argive exiles." When they then began to treat of the conditions of their friendship, the Roman made two demands: one, that the war with the Achaeans should be put an end to; the other, that he should send him aid against Philip. He promised the aid required; but, instead of a peace with the Achaeans, a cessation of hostilities was obtained, to last until the war with Philip should be concluded.

The tyrant, after taking control of the city of Argos, not considering where or how he had acquired it, sent envoys to Elatia, to Quinctius, and to Attalus, who was in his winter quarters at Aegina, to tell them that "he was in control of Argos; and that if Quinctius would come to him and talk it over, he was sure they could work everything out." Quinctius, wanting to strip Philip of that stronghold along with others, agreed to go; so he sent a message to Attalus, asking him to leave Aegina and meet him at Sicyon. He then set sail from Anticyra with ten quinqueremes that his brother, Lucius Quinctius, had just brought from his winter station at Corcyra, and made his way to Sicyon. Attalus was already there, arguing that the tyrant should come to the Roman general, not the other way around, convincing Quinctius to not enter Argos. However, they agreed to meet near a place called Mycenica. Quinctius arrived with his brother and a few military tribunes; Attalus brought his royal entourage, and Nicostratus, the praetor of the Achaeans, came with a few auxiliary officers. They found Nabis waiting with his entire army. He approached, armed and accompanied by his armed guards, almost to the middle of the open ground. Quinctius was unarmed, along with his brother and two military tribunes; the king had one of his nobles with him, and the praetor of the Achaeans was also unarmed. When the tyrant saw that the king and the Roman general were unarmed, he started the meeting by apologizing for being armed himself and surrounded by armed men. "I have no fears from you," he said, "but only from the Argive exiles." When they began discussing terms of their friendship, the Roman made two requests: one, to end the war with the Achaeans; the other, to provide him with help against Philip. He promised the requested help; however, instead of achieving peace with the Achaeans, they agreed on a ceasefire to last until the war with Philip was over.

40

A debate concerning the Argives, also, was set on foot by king Attalus, who charged Nabis with holding their city by force, which was put into his hands by the treachery of Philocles; while Nabis insisted, that he had been invited by the Argives themselves to afford them protection. The king required a general assembly of the Argives to be convened, that the truth of that matter might be known. To this the tyrant did not object; but the king alleged, that the Lacedaemonian troops ought to be withdrawn from the city, in order to render the assembly free; and that the people should be left at liberty to declare their real sentiments. The tyrant refused to withdraw them, and the debate produced no effect. To the Roman general, six hundred Cretans were given by Nabis, who agreed with the praetor of the Achaeans to a cessation of arms for four months, and thus they departed from the conference. Quinctius proceeded to Corinth, advancing to the gates with the cohort of Cretans, in order that it might be evident to Philocles, the governor of the city, that the tyrant had deserted the cause of Philip. Philocles himself came out to confer with the Roman general; and, on the latter exhorting him to change sides immediately, and surrender the city he answered in such a manner as showed an inclination rather to defer than to refuse the matter. From Corinth, Quinctius sailed over to Anticyra, and sent his brother thence, to sound the disposition of the people of Acarnania. Attalus went from Argos to Sicyon. Here, on one side, the state added new honours to those formerly paid to the king; and, on the other, the king, besides having on a former occasion, redeemed for them, at a vast expense, a piece of land sacred to Apollo, unwilling to pass by the city of his friends and allies without a token of munificence, made them a present of ten talents of silver,[11] and ten thousand bushels of corn, and then returned to Cenchreae to his fleet. Nabis, leaving a strong garrison at Argos, returned to Lacedaemon; and, as he himself had pillaged the men, he sent his wife to Argos to pillage the women. She invited the females to her house, sometimes singly, and sometimes several together, who were united by family connexion; and partly by fair speeches, partly by threats, stripped them, not only of their gold, but, at last, even of their garments, and every article of female attire.

A debate about the Argives was initiated by King Attalus, who accused Nabis of forcibly holding their city, which had been given to him through the betrayal of Philocles. Nabis argued that he had been invited by the Argives themselves for protection. The king called for a general assembly of the Argives to establish the truth. Nabis didn't oppose this, but the king argued that the Lacedaemonian troops should leave the city to ensure the assembly was free, allowing the people to express their true opinions. The tyrant refused to withdraw the troops, and the debate had no effect. Nabis provided six hundred Cretans to the Roman general, who reached an agreement with the praetor of the Achaeans for a four-month ceasefire, and then they left the conference. Quinctius went to Corinth, arriving at the gates with the cohort of Cretans to show Philocles, the city's governor, that the tyrant had abandoned Philip's cause. Philocles came out to talk with the Roman general, and when Quinctius urged him to switch sides and surrender the city immediately, he responded in a way that suggested he preferred to delay rather than refuse. From Corinth, Quinctius sailed to Anticyra and sent his brother to gauge the feelings of the Acarnanian people. Attalus traveled from Argos to Sicyon. There, the state honored the king with new accolades, and in return, the king, having previously redeemed a piece of land sacred to Apollo at great cost, didn't want to pass by his friends and allies without showing generosity. He gave them ten talents of silver and ten thousand bushels of corn, then returned to Cenchreae to his fleet. Nabis, leaving a strong garrison in Argos, went back to Lacedaemon; as he had already looted the men, he sent his wife to Argos to exploit the women. She invited the women to her house, sometimes individually and sometimes in groups connected by family ties, and through sweet-talking and threats, stripped them not only of their gold but ultimately of their clothes and all their feminine attire.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXXIII.


Titus Quinctius Flamininus, proconsul, gains a decisive victory over Philip at Cynoscephalae. Caius Sempronius Tuditanus, praetor, cut off by the Celtiberians. Death of Attalus, at Pergamus. Peace granted to Philip, and liberty to Greece. Lucius Furius Purpureo and Marcus Claudius Marcellus, consuls, subdue the Boian and Insubrian Gauls. Triumph of Marcellus. Hannibal, alarmed at an embassy from Rome concerning him, flies to Antiochus, king of Syria, who was preparing to make war on the Romans.

       *        *        *        *        *

1

Such were the occurrences of the winter. In the beginning of spring, Quinctius, having summoned Attalus to Elatia, and being anxious to bring under his authority the nation of the Boeotians, who had until then been wavering in their dispositions, marched through Phocis, and pitched his camp at the distance of five miles from Thebes, the capital of Boeotia. Next day, attended by one company of soldiers, and by Attalus, together with the ambassadors, who had come to him in great numbers from all quarters, he proceeded towards the city, having ordered the spearmen of two legions, being two thousand men, to follow him at the distance of a mile. About midway, Antiphilus, praetor of the Boeotians, met him: the rest of the people stood on the walls, watching the arrival of the king and the Roman general. Few arms and few soldiers appeared around them--the hollow roads, and the valleys concealing from view the spearmen, who followed at a distance. When Quinctius drew near the city, he slackened his pace, as if with intention to salute the multitude, who came out to meet him; but the real motive of his delaying was, that the spearmen might come up. The townsmen pushed forward, in a crowd, before the lictors, not perceiving the band of soldiers who were following them close, until they arrived at the general's quarters. Then, supposing the city betrayed and taken, through the treachery of Antiphilus, their praetor, they were all struck with astonishment and dismay. It was now evident that no room was left to the Boeotians for a free discussion of measures in the assembly, which was summoned for the following day. However, they concealed their grief, which it would have been both vain and unsafe to have discovered.

Such were the events of the winter. At the start of spring, Quinctius called Attalus to Elatia and, eager to bring the Boeotians, who had been uncertain in their loyalties, under his control, marched through Phocis and set up camp five miles from Thebes, the capital of Boeotia. The next day, accompanied by a group of soldiers, Attalus, and numerous ambassadors who had come from all directions, he approached the city, having instructed two legions of spearmen, totaling two thousand men, to follow him a mile behind. Midway, Antiphilus, the praetor of the Boeotians, met him: the rest of the townspeople stood on the walls, watching the arrival of the king and the Roman general. There were few weapons and soldiers visible around them—the winding roads and valleys kept the spearmen hidden in the distance. As Quinctius neared the city, he slowed down as if to greet the crowd that came out to meet him, but his real reason for the delay was to allow the spearmen to catch up. The townspeople hurried ahead, crowding before the lictors, not realizing the group of soldiers was following closely behind until they reached the general's quarters. Believing the city had been betrayed and captured due to Antiphilus's treachery, they were filled with shock and fear. It was now clear that there was no opportunity for the Boeotians to freely discuss plans in the assembly scheduled for the next day. However, they hid their distress, which would have been pointless and dangerous to show.

2

When the assembly met, Attalus first rose to speak, and he began his discourse with a recital of the kindnesses conferred by his ancestors and himself on the Greeks in general, and on the Boeotians in particular. But, being now too old and infirm to bear the exertion of speaking in public, he lost his voice and fell; and for some time, while they were carrying him to his apartments, (for he was deprived of the use of one half of his limbs,) the proceedings of the assembly were for a short time suspended. Then Aristaenus spoke on the part of the Achaeans, and was listened to with the greater attention, because he recommended to the Boeotians no other measures than those which he had recommended to the Achaeans. A few words were added by Quinctius, extolling the good faith rather than the arms and power of the Romans. A resolution was then proposed, by Dicaearchus of Plataea, for forming a treaty of friendship with the Roman people, which was read; and no one daring to offer any opposition, it was received and passed by the suffrages of all the states of Boeotia. When the assembly broke up, Quinctius made no longer stay at Thebes than the sudden accident to Attalus made necessary. When it appeared that the force of the disorder had not brought the king's life into any immediate danger, but had only occasioned a weakness in his limbs, he left him there, to use the necessary means for recovery, and returned to Elatia, from whence he had come. Having now brought the Boeotians, as formerly the Achaeans, to join in the confederacy, while all places were left behind him in a state of tranquillity and safety, he bent his whole attention towards Philip, and the remaining business of the war.

When the assembly gathered, Attalus was the first to speak. He started his speech by recounting the favors his ancestors and he had shown the Greeks overall, and particularly the Boeotians. However, he was now too old and frail to speak publicly. He lost his voice and collapsed, and for a while, as they carried him to his rooms (since he had lost use of one side of his body), the assembly paused. Then Aristaenus spoke on behalf of the Achaeans and received extra attention because he suggested to the Boeotians the same measures he had recommended to the Achaeans. Quinctius added a few words, praising the integrity of the Romans more than their military strength. Dicaearchus of Plataea then proposed a resolution to form a friendship treaty with the Roman people, which was read; and with no one daring to oppose, it was accepted and approved by all the states of Boeotia. When the assembly ended, Quinctius didn't stay in Thebes any longer than necessary due to the incident with Attalus. Once it seemed that the king's condition wasn't life-threatening but only caused weakness in his limbs, Quinctius left him there to pursue recovery and returned to Elatia, from where he had come. Having now brought the Boeotians, like he had earlier with the Achaeans, into the alliance, and with everything else left peaceful and secure behind him, he turned his full focus toward Philip and the remaining matters of the war.

3

Philip, on his part, as his ambassadors had brought no hopes of peace from Rome, resolved, as soon as spring began, to levy soldiers through every town in his dominions: but he found a great scarcity of young men; for successive wars, through several generations, had very much exhausted the Macedonians, and, even in the course of his own reign great numbers had fallen, in the naval engagements with the Rhodians and Attalus, and in those on land with the Romans. Mere youths, therefore, from the age of sixteen, were enlisted; and even those who had served out their time, provided they had any remains of strength, were recalled to their standards. Having, by these means, filled up the numbers of his army about the vernal equinox, he drew together all his forces to Dius: he encamped them there in a fixed post; and, exercising the soldiers every day, waited for the enemy. About the same time Quinctius left Elatia, and came by Thronium and Scarphea to Thermopylae. There he held an assembly of the Aetolians, which had been summoned to meet at Heraclea, to determine with what number of auxiliaries they should follow the Roman general to the war. On the third day, having learned the determination of the allies, he proceeded from Heraclea to Xyniae; and, pitching his camp on the confines between the Aenians and Thessalians, waited for the Aetolian auxiliaries. The Aetolians occasioned no delay. Six hundred foot and four hundred horse, under the command of Phaeneas, speedily joined him; and then Quinctius, to show plainly what he had waited for, immediately decamped. On passing into the country of Phthiotis, he was joined by five hundred Cretans of Gortynium, whose commander was Cydantes, with three hundred Apollonians, armed nearly in the same manner; and not long after, by Amynander, with one thousand two hundred Athamanian foot.

Philip, on his end, since his envoys didn’t bring any hope of peace from Rome, decided that as soon as spring hit, he would recruit soldiers from every town in his territories. However, he discovered a significant shortage of young men; ongoing wars over several generations had seriously depleted the Macedonian population. During his own reign, many had also died in naval battles against the Rhodians and Attalus, as well as in land battles against the Romans. Therefore, he enlisted young men starting at the age of sixteen, and even those who had completed their service were called back, as long as they still had some strength left. By these means, he managed to build up the numbers of his army around the time of the spring equinox and gathered all his forces at Dius. He set up a permanent camp there and, training the soldiers every day, waited for the enemy. Around the same time, Quinctius left Elatia and traveled through Thronium and Scarphea to Thermopylae. There, he held a meeting of the Aetolians, which had been called to order at Heraclea, to decide how many reinforcements they should send to support the Roman general in the war. On the third day, after learning the allies' decision, he moved from Heraclea to Xyniae, setting up camp on the border between the Aenians and Thessalians, where he awaited the Aetolian reinforcements. The Aetolians were quick; six hundred foot soldiers and four hundred cavalry, led by Phaeneas, swiftly joined him. Then, to clearly signal what he had been waiting for, Quinctius immediately broke camp. After entering Phthiotis, he was joined by five hundred Cretans from Gortynium, led by Cydantes, along with three hundred Apollonians, who were similarly armed; not long after that, Amynander arrived with one thousand two hundred infantry from Athamania.

4

Philip, being informed of the departure of the Romans from Elatia, and considering that, on the approaching contest, his kingdom was at hazard, thought it advisable to make an encouraging speech to his soldiers; in which, after he had expatiated on many topics often alluded to before, respecting the virtues of their ancestors, and the military fame of the Macedonians, he touched particularly on those considerations which at the time threw the greatest damp on their spirits, and on those by which they might be animated to some degree of confidence. To the defeat thrice suffered at the narrow passes near the river Aous, by the phalanx of the Macedonians, he opposed the repulse given by main force to the Romans at Atrax: and even with respect to the former case, when they had not maintained possession of the pass leading into Epirus, he said, "the first fault was to be imputed to those who had been negligent in keeping the guards; and the second, to the light infantry and mercenaries in the time of the engagement; but that, as to the phalanx of the Macedonians, it had stood firm on that occasion; and would for ever remain invincible, on equal ground, and in regular fight." This body consisted of sixteen thousand men, the prime strength of the army, and of the kingdom. Besides these, he had two thousand targeteers, called Peltastae; of Thracians, and Illyrians of the tribe called Trallians, the like number of two thousand; and of hired auxiliaries, collected out of various nations, about one thousand; and two thousand horse. With this force the king waited for the enemy. The Romans had nearly an equal number; in cavalry alone they had a superiority, by the addition of the Aetolians.

Philip, having heard that the Romans had left Elatia, and realizing that his kingdom was at risk in the upcoming battle, decided to give an encouraging speech to his soldiers. He talked about many familiar topics, praising the virtues of their ancestors and the military reputation of the Macedonians. He specifically addressed the concerns that were weighing heavily on their spirits and highlighted what could inspire some confidence in them. To counter the defeat they had suffered three times at the narrow passes near the river Aous, he pointed to the success they had achieved by pushing the Romans back at Atrax. Regarding the earlier losses, he pointed out, "The first mistake was due to those who were careless in keeping watch; the second was the light infantry and mercenaries during the battle. However, the Macedonian phalanx held firm that day and will always be unstoppable on even ground in a proper fight." This unit consisted of sixteen thousand men, the core strength of the army and the kingdom. In addition, he had two thousand light infantry known as Peltastae, consisting of Thracians and Illyrians from the Trallian tribe, another two thousand of similar units, around one thousand hired auxiliaries from various nations, and two thousand cavalry. With this force, the king awaited the enemy. The Romans had nearly an equal number; they had a slight advantage in cavalry with the addition of Aetolian forces.

5

Quinctius, having decamped to Thebes in Phthiotis, and having received encouragement to hope that the city would be betrayed to him by Timon, a leading man in the state, came up close to the walls with only a small number of cavalry and some light infantry. So entirely were his expectations disappointed, that he was not only obliged to maintain a fight with the enemy who sallied out against him, but would have incurred a fearful conflict had not both infantry and cavalry been called out hastily from the camp, and come up in time. Not meeting with that success which he had too inconsiderately expected, he desisted from any further attempt to take the city at present. He had received certain information of the king being in Thessaly; but as he had not yet discovered into what part of it he had come, he sent his soldiers round the country, with orders to cut timber and prepare palisades. Both Macedonians and Greeks had palisades; but the latter had not adopted the most convenient mode of using them, either with respect to carriage, or for the purpose of strengthening their fortifications. They cut trees both too large and too full of branches for a soldier to carry easily along with his arms: and after they had fenced their camp with a line of these, the demolition of their palisade was no difficult matter; for the trunks of large trees appearing to view, with great intervals between them, and the numerous and strong shoots affording the hand a good hold, two, or at most three young men, uniting their efforts, used to pull out one tree, which, being removed, a breach was opened as wide as a gate, and there was nothing at hand with which it could be stopped up. But the Romans cut light stakes, mostly of one fork, with three, or at the most four branches; so that a soldier, with his arms slung at his back, can conveniently carry several of them together; and then they stick them down so closely, and interweave the branches in such a manner, that it cannot be seen to what main stem any branch belongs; besides which, the boughs are so sharp, and wrought so intimately with each other, as to leave no room for a hand to be thrust between; consequently an enemy cannot lay hold of any thing capable of being dragged out, or, if that could be done, could he draw out the branches thus intertwined, and which mutually bind each other. And even if, by accident, one should be pulled out, it leaves but a small opening, which is very easily filled up.

Quinctius, having moved to Thebes in Phthiotis and encouraged by the hope that the city would be betrayed to him by Timon, a prominent local leader, approached the walls with only a small group of cavalry and some light infantry. His hopes were completely dashed, as he had to engage in a fight with the enemy that came out against him. He would have faced a serious battle if both infantry and cavalry had not been rushed from the camp and arrived just in time. Lacking the success he had naively anticipated, he decided to stop any further attempts to capture the city for the moment. He received reliable information that the king was in Thessaly, but since he hadn’t yet found out exactly where, he sent his soldiers throughout the region to cut timber and prepare palisades. Both the Macedonians and Greeks used palisades, but the latter didn’t use them in the most effective way, whether for transport or for strengthening their defenses. They cut down trees that were either too large or too bushy for a soldier to carry easily along with his arms. After they fenced their camp with a line of these, breaking down their palisade was not difficult. The large tree trunks were visible with significant gaps between them, and the numerous strong branches provided a good grip. Two or, at most, three young men could join forces to pull out one tree, and when one was removed, it created a gap as wide as a gate, which could not be easily blocked. In contrast, the Romans cut lightweight stakes, mostly with one fork and three or four branches, allowing a soldier, with his arms slung at his back, to carry several together comfortably. They planted these stakes very closely and intertwined the branches in such a way that it was impossible to see which branch belonged to which main stem. Additionally, the boughs were sharp and tightly woven together, leaving no space for a hand to fit between them. Consequently, an enemy could not grab anything to pull out, and even if one branch could be pulled out accidentally, it would create only a small opening that could be easily filled.

6

Next day Quinctius, causing his men to carry palisades with them, that they might be ready to encamp on any spot, marched forward a short way, and took post about six miles from Pherae; whence he sent scouts to discover in what part of Thessaly the king was, and what appeared to be his intention. Philip was then near Larissa, and as soon as he learnt that the Roman general had removed from Thebes, being equally impatient for a decisive engagement, he proceeded towards the enemy, and pitched his camp about four miles from Pherae. On the day following, some light troops went out from both camps, to seize on certain hills, which over looked the city. When, nearly at equal distance from summit which was intended to be seized, they came within sight of each other, they halted; and sending messengers to their respective camps for directions, how they were to proceed on this unexpected meeting with the enemy, waited their return in quiet. For that day, they were recalled to their camps, without having commenced any engagement. On the following day, there was a battle between the cavalry, near the same hills, in which the Aetolians bore no small part; and in which the king's troops were defeated, and driven into their camp. Both parties were greatly impeded in the action, by the ground being thickly planted with trees; by the gardens, of which there were many in a place so near the city; and by the roads being enclosed between walls, and in some places shut up. The commanders, therefore, were equally desirous of removing out of that quarter; and, as if by a preconcerted scheme, they both directed their route to Scotussa: Philip with the hope of getting a supply of corn there; the Roman intending to get before the enemy and destroy the crops. The armies marched the whole day without having sight of each other in any place, the view being intercepted by a continued range of hills between them. The Romans encamped at Eretria, in Phthiotis; Philip, on the river Onchestus. But though Philip lay at Melambius, in the territory of Scotussa, and Quinctius near Thetidium, in Pharsalia, neither party knew with any certainty where his antagonist was. On the third day, there first fell a violent rain, which was succeeded by darkness equal to that of night, and this confined the Romans to their camp, through fear of an ambuscade.

The next day, Quinctius had his men carry palisades so they’d be ready to set up camp anywhere. He moved forward a short distance and took a position about six miles from Pherae, from where he sent out scouts to find out where the king was in Thessaly and what his plans seemed to be. Philip was near Larissa, and as soon as he heard that the Roman general had left Thebes, he also eager for a decisive battle, advanced towards the enemy and set up his camp about four miles from Pherae. The next day, light troops from both camps went out to take control of some hills overlooking the city. When they were nearly equally distant from the summit they intended to seize, they spotted each other and stopped, sending messengers back to their camps for instructions on how to handle this unexpected encounter with the enemy, waiting quietly for their return. That day, they were called back to their camps without any fighting taking place. The following day, there was a battle between the cavalry near the same hills, where the Aetolians played a significant role, and the king's troops were defeated and forced back into their camp. Both sides faced difficulties during the battle due to the terrain being heavily wooded, the numerous gardens close to the city, and roads that were bordered by walls and blocked in some areas. Thus, the commanders were both eager to move away from that region, and as if they had planned it, they headed toward Scotussa: Philip hoping to get a grain supply there, while the Roman aimed to reach the area first and destroy the crops. The armies marched all day without seeing each other, as a continuous range of hills blocked their view. The Romans camped at Eretria in Phthiotis, while Philip camped by the river Onchestus. However, even though Philip was at Melambius, in the territory of Scotussa, and Quinctius was near Thetidium in Pharsalia, neither side had any certainty about where the other was. On the third day, a heavy rain fell, followed by darkness that was as thick as night, which kept the Romans in their camp for fear of an ambush.

7

Philip, intent on hastening his march, and in no degree deterred by the clouds, which after the rain lowered over the face of the country, ordered his troops to march: and yet so thick a fog had obscured the day, that neither the standard-bearers could see the road, nor the soldiers the standards; so that all, led blindly by the shouts of uncertain guides, fell into disorder, like men wandering by night. When they had passed over the hills called Cynoscephalae, where they set a strong guard of foot and horse, they pitched their camp. Although the Roman general staid at Thetidium, yet he detatched troops of horse and one thousand foot, to find out where the enemy lay; warning them, however, to beware of ambuscades, which the darkness of the day would cover, even in an open country. When these arrived at the hills, where the enemy's guard was posted, struck with mutual fear, both parties stood, as if deprived of the power of motion. They then sent back messengers to their respective commanders; and when the first surprise subsided, they proceeded to action without more delay. The fight was begun by small advanced parties; and afterwards the numbers of the combatants were increased by reinforcements of men, who supported those who gave way. In this contest the Romans, being far inferior to their adversaries, sent message after message to the general, that they were being overpowered; on which he hastily sent five hundred horse and two thousand foot, mostly Aetolians, under the command of two military tribunes, who relieved them, and restored the fight. The Macedonians, distressed in turn by this change of fortune, sent to beg succour from their king; but as, on account of the general darkness from the fog, he had expected nothing less, on that day, than a battle, and had therefore sent a great number of men, of every kind, to forage, he was, for a considerable time, in great perplexity, and unable to form a resolution. Subsequently, as the messengers still continued to urge him, and the covering of clouds was now removed from the tops of the mountains, and the Macedonian party was in view, having been driven up to the highest summit, and trusting for safety rather to the nature of the ground than to their arms, he thought it necessary, at all events, to hazard the whole, in order to prevent the loss of a part, for want of support; and, accordingly, he sent up Athenagoras, general of the mercenary soldiers, with all the auxiliaries, except the Thracians, joined by the Macedonian and Thessalian cavalry. On their arrival, the Romans were forced from the top of the hill, and did not face about until they came to the level plain. The principal support which saved them from being driven down in disorderly flight, was the Aetolian horsemen. The Aetolians were then by far the best cavalry in Greece; in infantry, they were surpassed by some of their neighbours.

Philip, eager to speed up his march and undeterred by the clouds that hung low after the rain, ordered his troops to move out. However, the thick fog made it so difficult that neither the standard-bearers could see the road nor the soldiers could see the standards. As a result, everyone blindly followed the shouts of uncertain guides and became disorganized, like people wandering at night. After crossing the hills known as Cynoscephalae, where they established a strong guard of foot and horse, they set up camp. Although the Roman general remained at Thetidium, he sent out cavalry and a thousand infantry to find out where the enemy was, warning them to watch out for ambushes that could be hidden by the day's darkness, even in an open area. When they reached the hills where the enemy's guard was stationed, both sides, struck by mutual fear, stood still as if frozen. They then sent back messengers to their respective commanders; once the initial shock faded, they quickly engaged in battle. The fight started with small advanced parties, and then reinforcements arrived to support those who were faltering. In this struggle, the Romans, significantly outnumbered, continuously messaged their general that they were being overwhelmed. In response, he hurriedly dispatched five hundred cavalry and two thousand foot soldiers, mostly Aetolians, under the command of two military tribunes, who came to their aid and turned the tide of the battle. The Macedonians, feeling the pressure from this shift, sent a request for help to their king. However, anticipating a battle due to the dense fog, he had sent many men out to gather supplies, leaving him perplexed and unable to make a decision for a while. Eventually, as the messengers kept urging him and the fog began to clear from the mountaintops, revealing the Macedonian forces backed against the summit, relying on the terrain for safety rather than their weapons, he decided to risk everything to save part of his army from losing its support. He sent Athenagoras, the general of the mercenaries, along with all the auxiliaries except the Thracians, joined by the Macedonian and Thessalian cavalry. Upon their arrival, the Romans were pushed off the hill and only turned to fight when they reached the flat plain. The main support that prevented them from being routed in a chaotic retreat came from the Aetolian cavalry. The Aetolians were then the best cavalry in Greece, though in infantry, they were surpassed by some of their neighbors.

8

This affair was represented as more successful than the advantage gained in the battle could warrant; for people came, one after another, and calling out that the Romans were flying in a panic; so that, though reluctant and hesitating declaring it a rash proceeding, and that he liked not either place or the time, yet he was prevailed upon to draw out his whole force to battle. The Roman general did the same, induced by necessity, rather than by the favourableness of the occasion. Leaving the right wing as a reserve, having the elephants posted in front, he, with the left, and all the right infantry, advanced against the enemy; at the same time reminding his men, that "they were going to fight the same Macedonians whom they had fought in the passes of Epirus, fenced, as they were, with mountains and rivers, and whom, after conquering the natural difficulties of the ground, they had dislodged and vanquished; the same, whom they had before defeated under the command of Publius Sulpicius, when they opposed their passage to Eordaea. That the kingdom of Macedonia had been hitherto supported by its reputation, not by real strength; and that even that reputation had, at length, vanished." Quinctius soon reached his troops, who stood in the bottom of the valley; and they, on the arrival of their general and the army, renewed the fight, and, making a vigorous onset, compelled the enemy again to turn their backs. Philip, with the targeteers, and the right wing of infantry, (the main strength of the Macedonian army, called by them the phalanx,) advanced at a quick pace, having ordered Nicanor, one of his courtiers, to bring up the rest of his forces with all speed. At first, on reaching the top of the hill, from a few arms and bodies lying there, he perceived that there had been an engagement on the spot, and that the Romans had been repulsed from it. When he likewise saw the fight now going on close to the enemy's works, he was elated with excessive delight; but presently, observing his men flying back, and that the panic was on the other side, he was much embarrassed, and hesitated for some time, whether he should cause his troops to retire into the camp. Then, as the enemy approached, he was sensible that his party, besides the losses which they suffered as they fled, must be entirely lost, if not speedily succoured; and as, by this time, even a retreat would be unsafe, he found himself compelled to put all to hazard, before he was joined by the other division of his forces. He placed the cavalry and light infantry that had been engaged, on the right wing; and ordered the targeteers, and the phalanx of Macedonians, to lay aside their spears, which their great length rendered unserviceable, and to manage the business with their swords: at the same time, that his line might not be easily broken, he lessened the extent of the front one half, and doubled the files within so that it might be deeper than it was broad. He ordered them also to close their files, so that man might join with man and arms with arms.

This situation was portrayed as more successful than the actual battle results justified; people kept coming one after the other, shouting that the Romans were fleeing in panic. So, despite his reluctance and doubts about the timing and location, he was persuaded to bring his entire force into battle. The Roman general did the same, driven more by necessity than by the favorable conditions. He left the right wing as a reserve, positioned the elephants in front, and advanced with the left and all the right infantry against the enemy. At the same time, he reminded his men that they were about to fight the same Macedonians they had faced in the mountain passes of Epirus, where, after overcoming the natural obstacles, they had defeated and driven them away. These were the same troops they had previously beaten under Publius Sulpicius, when they had tried to block their passage to Eordaea. He emphasized that the kingdom of Macedonia had relied on its reputation, not on real strength, and that even that reputation had finally faded. Quinctius soon reached his troops at the bottom of the valley, and upon the arrival of their general and the army, they renewed the fight and, with a strong push, forced the enemy to retreat again. Philip, with the targeteers and the right wing of infantry (the main strength of the Macedonian army, known as the phalanx), advanced quickly, ordering Nicanor, one of his courtiers, to hurry up with the rest of his forces. Initially, upon reaching the top of the hill, he noticed some weapons and bodies lying around, realizing there had been a battle there and that the Romans had been pushed back. When he saw the fight happening near the enemy's defenses, he felt a surge of joy; however, upon noticing his men retreating and that panic was spreading among his ranks, he became worried and hesitated whether to pull his troops back to the camp. As the enemy closed in, he realized that his forces, in addition to suffering losses while fleeing, would be totally lost if they were not quickly supported. By this time, even a retreat would be dangerous, so he felt forced to take a risk before joining with the other division of his troops. He positioned the cavalry and light infantry that had engaged on the right wing and instructed the targeteers and the Macedonian phalanx to put down their long spears, which were not useful in close combat, and switch to their swords. At the same time, to ensure his line wouldn’t easily break, he reduced the front by half and doubled the ranks behind it, making it deeper than wide. He also ordered them to close their ranks so each soldier could support the next.

9

Quinctius, having received among the standards and ranks those who had been engaged with the enemy, gave the signal by sound of trumpet. It is said, that such a shout was raised, as was seldom heard at the beginning of any battle; for it happened, that both armies shouted at once; not only the troops then engaged, but also the reserves, and those who were just then coming into the field. The king, fighting from the higher ground, had the better on the right wing, by means chiefly of the advantage of situation. On the left, all was disorder and confusion; particularly when that division of the phalanx, which had marched in the rear, was coming up. The centre stood intent on the fight as on a spectacle which in no way concerned them. The phalanx, just arrived (a column rather than a line of battle, and fitter for a march than for a fight,) had scarcely mounted the top of the hill: before these could form, Quinctius, though he saw his men in the left wing giving way, charged the enemy furiously, first driving on the elephants against them, for he judged that one part being routed would draw the rest after. The affair was no longer doubtful. The Macedonians, repelled by the first shock of the elephants, instantly turned their backs; and the rest, as had been foreseen, followed them in their retreat. Then, one of the military tribunes, forming his design in the instant, took with him twenty companies of men; left that part of the army which was evidently victorious; and making a small circuit, fell on the rear of the enemy's right wing. Any army whatever, thus charged from the rear, must have been thrown into confusion. But to that confusion which under such circumstances would be common to all armies, there was in this case an additional cause. The phalanx of the Macedonians, being heavy, could not readily face about; nor would they have been suffered to do it by their adversaries in front, who, although they gave way to them a little before, on this new occasion pressed them vigorously. Besides, they lay under another inconvenience in respect of the ground; for, by pursuing the retreating enemy down the face of the hill, they had left the top to the party who came round on their rear. Thus attacked on both sides, they were exposed for some time to great slaughter, and then betook themselves to flight, most of them throwing away their arms.

Quinctius, having gathered those who had been engaged with the enemy among the banners and ranks, signaled with the sound of a trumpet. It’s said that an incredible shout was raised, rarely heard at the start of any battle; both armies shouted at once, not just the troops currently fighting, but also the reserves and those just entering the battlefield. The king, fighting from higher ground, gained the advantage on the right wing, largely due to the elevated position. On the left, there was complete disorder and confusion, especially when that part of the phalanx that had marched in the rear was arriving. The center was focused on the fight as if it were a spectacle that didn’t directly concern them. The phalanx, just arriving (more of a column than a battle line, better suited for marching than fighting), had barely reached the top of the hill. Before they could organize, Quinctius, even noticing his men on the left wing faltering, charged fiercely at the enemy, first sending the elephants against them, believing that routing one part would lead the rest to flee as well. The situation quickly became clear. The Macedonians, pushed back by the initial charge of the elephants, immediately turned to run; and, as expected, the rest followed in their retreat. Then, one of the military tribunes, formulating his plan on the spot, took with him twenty companies of men, leaving that section of the army which was clearly winning, and making a slight detour, attacked the rear of the enemy's right wing. Any army faced with such a rear assault is bound to be thrown into chaos. But in addition to the typical confusion that would affect any army in that situation, there was another reason for this one. The Macedonian phalanx, being heavy, couldn’t easily turn around; nor would they have been allowed to do so by their opponents in front, who, despite having given way a moment before, now pressed them hard. Moreover, they faced another challenge due to the terrain; by pursuing the retreating enemy down the hill, they had left the top open to those who came around to attack from behind. Thus, attacked on both sides, they endured severe losses for a time, then took flight, most of them discarding their weapons.

10

Philip, with a small party of horse and foot, ascended a hill somewhat higher than the rest, to take a view of the situation of his troops on the left. Then, when he saw them flying in confusion, and all the hills around glittering with Roman standards and arms, he withdrew from the field. Ouinctius, as he was pressing on the retreating enemy, observed the Macedonians suddenly raising up their spears, and not knowing what they meant thereby, he ordered the troops to halt. Then, on being told that this was the practice of the Macedonians when surrendering themselves prisoners, he was disposed to spare the vanquished; but the troops, not being apprized, either of the enemy having ceased fighting, or of the general's intention, made a charge on them, and the foremost having been cut down, the rest dispersed themselves and fled. Philip hastened in disorderly flight to Tempè, and there halted one day at Gonni, to pick up any who might have survived the battle. The victorious Romans rushed into the Macedonian camp with hopes of spoil, but found it, for the most part, plundered already by the Aetolians. Eight thousand of the enemy were killed on that day, five thousand taken. Of the victors, about seven hundred fell. If any credit is to be attached to Valerius Antias, who on every occasion exaggerates numbers enormously, the killed of the enemy on that day amounted to forty thousand; the prisoners taken, (in which article the deviation from truth is less extravagant,) to five thousand seven hundred, with two hundred and forty-nine military standards. Claudius also asserts that thirty-two thousand of the enemy were slain, and four thousand three hundred taken. We have not given entire credit, even to the smallest of those numbers, but have followed Polybius, a safe authority with respect to all the Roman affairs, but especially those which were transacted in Greece.

Philip, accompanied by a small group of cavalry and infantry, climbed a hill that was slightly higher than the others to get a look at the position of his troops on the left. When he saw them fleeing in chaos, with Roman standards and armor shining on the surrounding hills, he retreated from the battlefield. Ouinctius, while pursuing the retreating enemy, noticed the Macedonians suddenly raising their spears. Uncertain of their intentions, he ordered his troops to stop. Upon being informed that this was the Macedonians' way of surrendering, he was inclined to spare them. However, since his troops were unaware that the enemy had ceased fighting or of their general's intent, they charged forward. Many of the front lines were cut down, causing the rest to scatter and flee. Philip hurried away in disorganized flight to Tempè, stopping for a day at Gonni to collect any survivors from the battle. The victorious Romans rushed into the Macedonian camp anticipating loot but found it mostly looted already by the Aetolians. That day, eight thousand enemy soldiers were killed, and five thousand captured. Among the victors, roughly seven hundred were lost. If we are to believe Valerius Antias, who frequently inflates numbers, the enemy death toll that day was forty thousand, with prisoners taken numbering five thousand seven hundred, along with two hundred and forty-nine military standards. Claudius also claimed that thirty-two thousand enemy soldiers were killed, and four thousand three hundred captured. We do not fully trust even the smallest of those figures and have instead relied on Polybius, a reliable source for all Roman matters, especially those that took place in Greece.

11

Philip having collected, after the flight, such as, having been scattered by the various chances of the battle, had followed his steps, and having sent people to Larissa to burn the records of the kingdom, lest they should fall into the hands of the enemy, retired into Macedonia. Quinctius set up to sale a part of the prisoners and booty, and part he bestowed on the soldiers; and then proceeded to Larissa, without having yet received any certain intelligence to what quarter Philip had betaken himself, or what were his designs. To this place came a herald from the king, apparently to obtain a truce, until those who had fallen in battle should be removed and buried, but in reality to request permission to send ambassadors. Both were obtained from the Roman general; who, besides, added this message to the king, "not to be too much dejected." This expression gave much offence, particularly to the Aetolians, who were become very assuming, and who complained, that "the general was quite altered by success. Before the battle, he was accustomed to transact all business, whether great or small, in concert with the allies; but they had, now, no share in any of his counsels; he conducted all affairs entirely by his own judgment; and was even seeking an occasion of ingratiating himself personally with Philip, in order that, after the Aetolians had laboured through all hardships and difficulties of the war, the Roman might assume to himself all the merit and all the fruits of a peace." Certain it is, that he had treated them with less respect than formerly, but they did not know why they were thus slighted. They imagined that he was actuated by an expectation of presents from the king, though he was of a spirit incapable of yielding to any such passion of the mind; but he was, with good reason, displeased at the Aetolians, on account of their insatiable greediness for plunder, and of their arrogance in assuming to themselves the honour of the victory--a claim so ill founded, as to offend the ears of all. Besides, he foresaw that, if Philip were removed out of the way, and the strength of the kingdom of Macedonia entirely broken, the Aetolians would necessarily be regarded as the masters of Greece. For these reasons, he intentionally did many things to lessen their importance and reputation in the judgment of the other states.

Philip, after the retreat, gathered those who had been scattered by the chaos of battle. He sent people to Larissa to destroy the kingdom’s records, so they wouldn’t fall into enemy hands, then withdrew to Macedonia. Quinctius put some of the prisoners and loot up for sale, while he gave some to the soldiers, and then headed to Larissa without having received any clear information about where Philip had gone or what his plans were. A herald arrived from the king, seemingly to negotiate a truce for the removal and burial of the fallen, but in reality to ask for permission to send ambassadors. Both were granted by the Roman general, who also added a message to the king not to be too discouraged. This remark upset many, especially the Aetolians, who had become quite arrogant and complained that the general had changed due to his success. Before the battle, he used to consult with the allies on all matters, big and small, but now they felt excluded from his decisions; he was handling everything based solely on his own judgment and even seemed to be trying to win over Philip personally, so that after the Aetolians endured all the hardships of the war, the Roman could take all the credit for any peace that came. It was clear that he treated them with less respect than before, but they didn’t understand why they were being neglected. They thought he was motivated by the hope of gifts from the king, though he was not the type to give in to such desires; rather, he was rightly annoyed with the Aetolians because of their endless greed for plunder and their audacity in claiming the victory for themselves—a claim that was so unfounded it was offensive to everyone. Moreover, he anticipated that if Philip were dealt with and the strength of Macedonia completely dismantled, the Aetolians would effectively be seen as the rulers of Greece. For these reasons, he intentionally did many things to diminish their significance and reputation in the eyes of other states.

12

A truce for fifteen days was granted to the Macedonians, and a conference with the king himself appointed. Before the day arrived on which this was to be held, the Roman general called a council of the allies, and desired their opinions respecting the terms of peace, proper to be prescribed. Amynander, king of Athamania, delivered his opinion in a few words; that "the conditions of peace ought to be adjusted in such a manner, as that Greece might have sufficient power, even without the interference of the Romans, to maintain the peace, and also its own liberty." The address of the Aetolians was more harsh; for after a few introductory observations on the justice and propriety of the Roman general's conduct, in communicating his plans of peace to those who had acted with him as allies in the war, they insisted, "that he was utterly mistaken, if he supposed that he could leave the peace with the Romans, or the liberty of Greece, on a permanent footing, unless Philip was either put to death or banished from his kingdom; both which he could easily accomplish, if he chose to pursue his present success." Quinctius, in reply, said, that "the Aetolians, in giving such advice, attended not either to the maxims of the Roman policy, or to the consistency of their own conduct. For, in all the former councils and conferences, wherein the conditions of peace were discussed, they never once urged the pushing of the war to the utter ruin of the Macedonian: and, as to the Romans, besides that they had, from the earliest periods, observed the maxim of sparing the vanquished, they had lately given a signal proof of their clemency in the peace granted to Hannibal and the Carthaginians. But, not to insist on the case of the Carthaginians, how often had the confederates met Philip himself in conference, yet that it had never been urged that he should resign his kingdom: and, because he had been defeated in battle, was that a reason that their animosity should become implacable? Against an armed foe, men ought to engage with hostile resentment; towards the vanquished, the loftiest spirit was ever the most merciful. The kings of Macedonia were thought to be dangerous to the liberty of Greece. Suppose that kingdom and nation extirpated, the Thracians, Illyrians, and in time the Gauls, (nations unsubjugated and savage,) would pour themselves into Macedonia first, and then into Greece. That they should not, by removing inconveniences which lay nearest, open a passage to others greater and more grievous." Here he was interrupted by Phaeneas, praetor of the Aetolians, who solemnly declared, that "if Philip escaped now, he would soon raise a new and more dangerous war." On which Quinctius said,--"Cease wrangling, when you ought to deliberate. The king shall be bound down by such conditions as will not leave it in his power to raise a war."

A fifteen-day truce was granted to the Macedonians, and a conference with the king himself was scheduled. Before the meeting day arrived, the Roman general called a council with the allies to hear their thoughts on the peace terms to propose. Amynander, the king of Athamania, stated briefly that "the peace conditions should be set so that Greece has enough strength, even without Roman involvement, to maintain both peace and its own freedom." The Aetolians took a harsher stance; after a few opening remarks about the fairness of the Roman general's actions in sharing his peace plans with allies in the war, they insisted, "he is completely wrong if he thinks he can secure peace with the Romans or Greece's freedom on a solid foundation without either executing Philip or banishing him from his kingdom; both of which he could easily do if he chose to build on his current success." Quinctius responded, saying that "the Aetolians, in giving such advice, were disregarding both the principles of Roman policy and their own past actions. In all the previous meetings discussing peace terms, they never once pushed for the complete destruction of the Macedonians. Furthermore, the Romans had, from the start, followed the principle of showing mercy to the defeated, and they recently demonstrated their leniency with the peace given to Hannibal and the Carthaginians. But without even mentioning the Carthaginians, how many times had the allies met Philip himself without insisting he should give up his kingdom? Just because he was defeated in battle, does that mean their resentment should become unyielding? Against an armed enemy, one should fight with hostility; toward the defeated, the highest virtue has always been mercy. The Macedonian kings were seen as threats to Greek freedom. If that kingdom and its people were wiped out, the Thracians, Illyrians, and eventually the Gauls—savages that weren't subdued—would invade Macedonia first, and then Greece. They shouldn't remove nearby troubles only to create a path for even greater and harsher ones." At this point, Phaeneas, the praetor of the Aetolians, interrupted, stating that "if Philip gets away this time, he will quickly start a new and more dangerous war." Quinctius then replied, "Stop arguing when you should be thinking together. The king will be bound by conditions that won't allow him to start a war."

13

The convention was then adjourned; and next day, the king came to the pass at the entrance of Tempè, the place appointed for a conference; and the third day following was fixed for introducing him to a full assembly of the Romans and allies. On this occasion Philip, with great prudence, intentionally avoided the mention of any of those conditions, without which peace could not be obtained, rather than suffer them to be extorted after discussion; and declared, that he was ready to comply with all the articles which, in the former conference, were either prescribed by the Romans or demanded by the allies; and to leave all other matters to the determination of the senate. Although he seemed to have hereby precluded every objection, even from the most inveterate of his enemies, yet, all the rest remaining silent, Phaeneas, the Aetolian, said to him,--"What! Philip, do you at last restore to us Pharsalus and Larissa, with Cremaste, Echinus, and Thebes in Phthiotis?" On Philip answering, that "he would give no obstruction to their retaking the possession of them," a dispute arose between the Roman general and the Aetolians about Thebes; for Quinctius affirmed, that it became the property of the Roman people by the laws of war; because when, before the commencement of hostilities, he marched his army thither, and invited the inhabitants to friendship, they, although at full liberty to renounce the king's party, yet preferred an alliance with Philip to one with Rome. Phaeneas alleged, that, in consideration of their being confederates in the war, it was reasonable, that whatever the Aetolians possessed before it began, should be restored; and that, besides, there was, in the first treaty, a provisional clause of that purport, by which the spoils of war, of every kind that could be carried or driven, were to belong to the Romans; and that the lands and captured cities should fall to the Aetolians. "Yourselves," replied Quinctius, "annulled the conditions of that treaty, at the time when ye deserted us, and made peace with Philip; but supposing it still remained in force, yet that clause could affect only captured cities. Now, the states of Thessaly submitted to us by a voluntary act of their own."--These words were heard by their allies with universal approbation; but to the Aetolians they were both highly displeasing at the present, and proved afterwards the cause of a war, and of many great disasters attending it. The terms settled with Philip were, that he should give his son Demetrius, and some of his friends, as hostages; should pay two hundred talents[12] and send ambassadors to Rome, respecting the other articles: for which purpose there should be a cessation of arms for four months. An engagement was entered into, that, in case the senate should refuse to conclude a treaty, his money and hostages should be returned to Philip. It is said, that one of the principal reasons which made the Roman general wish to expedite the conclusion of a peace, was, that he had received certain information of Antiochus intending to commence hostilities, and to pass over into Europe.

The convention was then closed, and the next day, the king arrived at the entrance of Tempè, the agreed spot for a meeting. The third day was set for introducing him to a full assembly of the Romans and their allies. On this occasion, Philip wisely chose not to mention any of the conditions necessary for peace, wanting to avoid having them forced out during discussions. He declared that he was ready to agree to all the terms set by the Romans or requested by the allies in the previous meeting and would leave all other matters to the senate's decision. Although he seemed to eliminate any objections, even from his most stubborn opponents, while everyone else fell silent, Phaeneas from Aetolia spoke up, asking, “So, Philip, are you finally giving us Pharsalus and Larissa, along with Cremaste, Echinus, and Thebes in Phthiotis?” When Philip replied that he would not block them from reclaiming those places, a disagreement arose between the Roman general and the Aetolians regarding Thebes. Quinctius argued that it became the property of the Roman people by the laws of war because, before the fighting started, he marched his army there and invited the locals to join them; even though they could have sided with the Romans, they chose to ally with Philip instead. Phaeneas countered that, given their alliance in the war, it was fair for the Aetolians to get back whatever they owned before it began and noted that the initial treaty included a clause stating that the spoils of war would belong to the Romans but that the lands and captured cities would go to the Aetolians. “You,” Quinctius responded, “canceled the terms of that treaty when you abandoned us and made peace with Philip; but even if it were still valid, that clause would only pertain to captured cities. The states of Thessaly willingly submitted to us.” These remarks were met with widespread approval from their allies but were very disconcerting to the Aetolians, ultimately leading to war and many significant disasters. The terms agreed with Philip were that he would surrender his son Demetrius and some of his friends as hostages, pay two hundred talents[12], and send ambassadors to Rome regarding the other agreements. For this purpose, a ceasefire was established for four months. It was agreed that if the senate refused to finalize a treaty, his money and hostages would be returned to Philip. It’s said that one of the main reasons the Roman general wanted to rush the peace settlement was that he had been informed that Antiochus planned to start hostilities and move into Europe.

14

About the same time, and, as some writers say, on the same day, the Achaeans defeated Androsthenes, the king's commander, in a general engagement near Corinth. Philip, intending to use this city as a citadel, to awe the states of Greece, had invited the principal inhabitants to a conference, under pretence of agreeing with them as to the number of horsemen which the Corinthians could supply towards the war, and these he detained as hostages. Besides the force already there, consisting of five hundred Macedonians and eight hundred auxiliaries of various kinds, he had sent thither one thousand Macedonians, one thousand two hundred Illyrians, and of Thracians and Cretans (for these served in both the opposite armies) eight hundred. To these were added Botians, Thessalians, and Acarnanians, to the amount of one thousand, all carrying bucklers; with as many of the young Corinthians themselves, as filled up the number of six thousand men under arms,--a force which inspired Androsthenes with a confident wish to decide the matter in the field. Nicostratus, praetor of the Achaeans, was at Sicyon, with two thousand foot and one hundred horse; but seeing himself so inferior, both in the number and kind of troops, he did not go outside the walls: the king's forces, in various excursions, were ravaging the lands of Pellene, Phliasus, and Cleone. At last, reproaching the enemy with cowardice, they passed over into the territory of Sicyon, and, sailing round Achaia, laid waste the whole coast. As the enemy, while thus employed, spread themselves about too widely and too carelessly, (the usual consequence of too much confidence,) Nicostratus conceived hopes of attacking them by surprise. He therefore sent secret directions to all the neighbouring states, as to what day, and what number from each state, should assemble in arms at Apelaurus, a place in the territory of Stymphalia. All being in readiness at the time appointed, he marched thence immediately; and, without the knowledge of any one as to what he was contemplating, came by night through the territory of the Phliasians to Cleone. He had with him five thousand foot, of whom * * * * * * [13] were light-armed, and three hundred horse; with this force he waited there, having despatched scouts to watch on what quarter the enemy should make their irregular inroads.

About the same time, and according to some writers, on the same day, the Achaeans defeated Androsthenes, the king's commander, in a major battle near Corinth. Philip, planning to use this city as a stronghold to intimidate the Greek states, had invited the main residents to a meeting, pretending to discuss how many horsemen the Corinthians could provide for the war, and he kept them as hostages. In addition to the forces already there, which included five hundred Macedonians and eight hundred auxiliary troops of various kinds, he sent another one thousand Macedonians, one thousand two hundred Illyrians, and eight hundred Thracians and Cretans (who fought for both sides). He also added one thousand Botians, Thessalians, and Acarnanians, all carrying shields, along with as many young Corinthians as were needed to total six thousand armed men—a force that filled Androsthenes with a strong desire to resolve the conflict on the battlefield. Nicostratus, the praetor of the Achaeans, was at Sicyon with two thousand infantry and one hundred cavalry; but recognizing he was outnumbered and outgunned, he stayed within the walls: the king's forces were raiding the lands of Pellene, Phliasus, and Cleone. Eventually, taunting the enemy for their cowardice, they crossed into Sicyon's territory and, sailing around Achaia, devastated the entire coastline. As the enemy, while engaged in this, spread out too much and too carelessly (a common result of overconfidence), Nicostratus saw an opportunity for a surprise attack. He sent secret instructions to all the neighboring states about what day and how many troops from each should gather armed at Apelaurus, a location in the territory of Stymphalia. When the time came, everything was ready, and he marched out immediately; without anyone knowing his plan, he moved quietly by night through the territory of the Phliasians to Cleone. He had five thousand foot soldiers, of whom * * * * * * [13] were light-armed, and three hundred cavalry; with this force, he waited there, having sent out scouts to monitor where the enemy would launch their irregular attacks.

15

Androsthenes, utterly ignorant of all these proceedings, set out from Corinth, and encamped on the Nemea, a river running between the confines of Corinth and Sicyon. Here, dismissing one half of his troops, he divided the remainder into three parts, and ordered all the cavalry of each part to march in separate divisions, and ravage, at the same time, the territories of Pellene, Sicyon, and Phlius. Accordingly, the three divisions set out by different roads. As soon as Nicostratus received intelligence of this at Cleone, he instantly sent forward a numerous detachment of mercenaries, to seize a pass at the entrance into the territory of Corinth; and he himself quickly followed, with his troops in two columns, the cavalry proceeding before the head of each, as advanced guards. In one column marched the mercenary soldiers and light infantry; in the other, the shield-bearers of the Achaeans and other states, who composed the principal strength of the army. Both infantry and cavalry were now within a small distance of the camp, and some of the Thracians had attacked parties of the enemy, who were straggling and scattered over the country, when the sudden alarm reached their tents. The commander was thrown into the utmost perplexity; for, having never had a sight of the Achaeans, except occasionally on the hills before Sicyon, when they did not venture to come down into the plains, he had never imagined that they would come so far as Cleone. He ordered the stragglers to be recalled by sound of trumpet; commanded the soldiers to take arms with all haste; and, marching out of the gate at the head of thin battalions, drew up his line on the bank of the river. His other troops, having scarcely had time to be collected and formed, did not withstand the enemy's first onset; the Macedonians had surrounded their standards in by far the greatest numbers, and now kept the prospect of victory a long time doubtful. At length, being left exposed by the flight of the rest, and pressed by two bodies of the enemy on different sides, by the light infantry on their flank, and by the shield-bearers and targeteers in front, and seeing victory declare against them, they at first gave ground; soon after, being vigorously pushed, they turned their backs; and most of them, throwing away their arms and having lost all hope of defending their camp, made the best of their way to Corinth. Nicostratus sent the mercenaries in pursuit of these; and the auxiliary Thracians against the party employed in ravaging the lands of Sicyon: occasioned great carnage in both instances, greater almost than occurred in the battle itself. Of those who had been ravaging Pellene and Phlius, some, returning to their camp, ignorant of all that had happened, and without any regular order, fell in with the advanced guards of the enemy, where they expected their own. Others, from the bustle which they perceived, suspecting what was really the case, fled and dispersed themselves in such a manner, that, as they wandered up and down, they were cut off by the very peasants. There fell, on that day, one thousand five hundred: three hundred were made prisoners. All Achaia was thus relieved from their great alarm.

Androsthenes, completely unaware of everything that was happening, left Corinth and set up camp by the Nemea River, which flows between Corinth and Sicyon. Here, he dismissed half of his troops and divided the remaining soldiers into three groups, instructing all the cavalry in each group to move separately and pillage the territories of Pellene, Sicyon, and Phlius at the same time. The three groups then set out on different paths. As soon as Nicostratus heard about this in Cleone, he immediately dispatched a large detachment of mercenaries to secure a pass at the entrance to Corinth's territory, following quickly after with his troops organized in two columns, with cavalry leading the way as advance guards. One column consisted of mercenaries and light infantry, while the other included the shield-bearers from Achaea and other allied states, who made up the army's main force. Both infantry and cavalry were soon close to the camp, and some Thracians had engaged scattered enemy groups in the area when suddenly an alarm reached their tents. The commander was thrown into confusion; having rarely seen the Achaeans, except from a distance on the hills near Sicyon when they wouldn’t descend into the plains, he never expected they’d come all the way to Cleone. He ordered the scattered men to regroup by the sound of the trumpet, commanded his soldiers to quickly arm themselves, and led his troops through the gate in thin lines, forming a defensive position along the riverbank. His other troops barely had time to regroup and formations before they couldn't withstand the enemy’s initial assault; the Macedonians overwhelmed their standards in much larger numbers, making victory uncertain for a long while. Eventually, left vulnerable by the retreat of the rest, and pressed by two groups of the enemy from different sides—light infantry attacking their flank and shield-bearers and targeteers in front—they started to give ground. Soon after, under heavy pressure, they turned to flee; many discarded their weapons and lost all hope of defending their camp, making a hurried escape back to Corinth. Nicostratus sent mercenaries in pursuit of these fleeing soldiers and directed the auxiliary Thracians against the raiding party in Sicyon, resulting in significant casualties in both cases, greater than what was seen in the actual battle. Those who had been pillaging Pellene and Phlius, some returned to their camp unaware of the chaos that had unfolded and, without any formation, encountered the enemy's advance guards, expecting to find their own troops. Others, sensing the turmoil around them, fled in panic, scattering and wandering until they were cut down by local farmers. That day, one thousand five hundred fell, and three hundred were captured. All of Achaia was thus freed from their significant threat.

16

Before the battle at Cynoscephalae, Lucius Quinctius had invited to Corcyra some chiefs of the Acarnanians, the only state in Greece which had continued to maintain its alliance with the Macedonians; and there made some kind of scheme for a change of measures. Two causes, principally, had retained them in friendship with the king: one was a principle of honour, natural to that nation; the other, their fear and hatred of the Aetolians. A general assembly was summoned to meet at Leucas; but neither did all the states of Acarnania come thither, nor were those who did attend agreed in opinion. However, the magistrates and leading men prevailed so far, as to get a decree passed, thus privately, for joining in alliance with the Romans. This gave great offence to those who had not been present; and, in this ferment of the nation, Androcles and Echedemus, two men of distinction among the Acarnanians, being commissioned by Philip, had influence enough in the assembly, not only to obtain the repeal of the decree for an alliance with Rome, but also the condemnation, on a charge of treason, of Archesilaus and Bianor, both men of the first rank in Acarnania, who had been the advisers of that measure; and to deprive Zeuxidas, the praetor, of his office, for having put it to the vote. The persons condemned took a course apparently desperate, but successful in the issue: for, while their friends advised them to yield to the necessity of the occasion, and withdraw to Corcyra, to the Romans, they resolved to present themselves to the multitude; and either, by that act, to mollify their resentment, or endure whatever might befall them. When they had introduced themselves into a full assembly, at first, a murmur arose, expressive of surprise; but presently silence took place, partly from respect to their former dignity, partly from commiseration of their present situation. Having been also permitted the liberty of speaking, at first they addressed the assembly in a suppliant manner; but, in the progress of their discourse, when they came to refute the charges made against them, they spoke with that degree of confidence which innocence inspires. At last, they even ventured to utter some complaints, and to charge the proceedings against them with injustice and cruelty; and this had such an effect on the minds of all present, that, with one consent, they annulled all the decrees passed against them. Nevertheless, they came to a resolution, to renounce the friendship of the Romans, and return to the alliance with Philip.

Before the battle at Cynoscephalae, Lucius Quinctius invited some leaders from the Acarnanians to Corcyra, the only state in Greece that had kept its alliance with the Macedonians. There, he devised a plan for a change in strategy. Two main reasons had kept the Acarnanians loyal to the king: one was their sense of honor, which was natural to that nation; the other was their fear and resentment towards the Aetolians. A general assembly was called to meet in Leucas; however, not all the states of Acarnania attended, and those who did were not united in their opinions. Nevertheless, the magistrates and prominent figures managed to pass a decree, albeit secretly, for an alliance with the Romans. This angered those who were absent, and amidst the uproar within the nation, Androcles and Echedemus, two respected men among the Acarnanians, were sent by Philip to influence the assembly. They succeeded not only in repealing the decree for an alliance with Rome but also in condemning Archesilaus and Bianor, both high-ranking Acarnanians who had supported that decision, on charges of treason, and in removing Zeuxidas, the praetor, from his position for having put it to a vote. The condemned men took what seemed like a desperate but ultimately successful path: while their friends urged them to accept the situation and retreat to Corcyra to the Romans, they decided to face the crowd. Their intention was to either win back the people's favor or face whatever consequences awaited them. When they entered a packed assembly, a murmur of surprise rose at first, but soon silence fell, partly out of respect for their former status and partly from sympathy for their current plight. They were allowed to speak, and initially addressed the assembly in a pleading manner; however, as they went on to refute the charges against them, they spoke with the confidence that comes from innocence. In the end, they even dared to express some grievances and accuse the proceedings against them of being unjust and cruel. This had such an impact on everyone present that they unanimously annulled all the decrees raised against them. Still, they resolved to break their friendship with the Romans and return to their alliance with Philip.

17

These decrees were passed at Leucas, the capital of Acarnania, the place where all the states usually met in council. As soon, therefore, as the news of this sudden change reached the lieutenant-general Flamininus, in Corcyra, he instantly set sail with the fleet for Leucas; and coming to an anchor at a place called Heraeus, advanced thence towards the walls with every kind of machine used in the attacking of cities; supposing that the first appearance of danger might bend the minds of the inhabitants to submission. But seeing no prospect of effecting any thing, except by force, he began to erect towers and sheds, and to bring up the battering-rams to the walls. The whole of Acarnania, being situated between Aetolia and Epirus, faces towards the west and the Sicilian sea. Leucadia, now an island, separated from Acarnania by a shallow strait which was dug by the hand, was then a peninsula, united on its eastern side to Acarnania by a narrow isthmus: this isthmus was about five hundred paces in length, and in breadth not above one hundred and twenty. At the entrance of this narrow neck stands Leucas, stretching up part of a hill which faces the east and Acarnania: the lower part of the town is level, lying along the sea, which divides Leucadia from Acarnania. Thus it lies open to attacks, both from the sea and from the land; for the channel is more like a marsh than a sea, and all the adjacent ground is solid enough to render the construction of works easy. In many places, therefore, at once the walls fell down, either undermined, or demolished by the ram. But the spirit of the besieged was as invincible as the town itself was favourably situated for the besiegers: night and day they employed themselves busily in repairing the shattered parts of the wall; and, stopping up the breaches that were made, fought the enemy with great spirit, and showed a wish to defend the walls by their arms rather than themselves by the walls. And they would certainly have protracted the siege to a length unexpected by the Romans, had not some exiles of Italian birth, who resided in Leucas, admitted a band of soldiers into the citadel: notwithstanding which, when those troops ran down from the higher ground with great tumult and uproar, the Leucadians, drawing up in a body in the forum, withstood them for a considerable time in regular fight. Meanwhile the walls were scaled in many places; and the besiegers, climbing over the rubbish, entered the town through the breaches. And now the lieutenant-general himself surrounded the combatants with a powerful force. Being thus hemmed in, many were slain, the rest laid down their arms and surrendered to the conqueror. In a few days after, on hearing of the battle at Cynoscephalae, all the states of Acarnania made their submission to the lieutenant-general.

These orders were issued at Leucas, the capital of Acarnania, where all the states typically met in council. As soon as the news of this sudden change reached Lieutenant General Flamininus in Corcyra, he immediately set sail with the fleet for Leucas. After anchoring at a place called Heraeus, he advanced towards the walls with various siege machines, hoping that the first sign of danger might sway the inhabitants toward surrender. But seeing no chance of success without force, he began constructing towers and shelters and bringing up battering rams to the walls. Acarnania, located between Aetolia and Epirus, faces west toward the Sicilian Sea. Leucadia, now an island separated from Acarnania by a shallow manmade strait, was then a peninsula connected to Acarnania on its eastern side by a narrow isthmus approximately five hundred paces long and about one hundred and twenty paces wide. At the entrance to this narrow passage stands Leucas, positioned partly on a hill facing east toward Acarnania. The lower part of the town is flat, lying along the sea that separates Leucadia from Acarnania. This makes it vulnerable to attacks from both the sea and the land; the channel resembles more of a marsh than a sea, and the surrounding ground is solid enough to facilitate construction. Consequently, in many places, the walls fell, either undermined or destroyed by the ram. However, the spirits of the defenders were as strong as the advantageous position of the town for the besiegers. Day and night, they worked diligently to repair the damaged parts of the wall, blocking up the breaches and fiercely resisting the enemy, eager to defend their walls with weapons rather than rely solely on the walls themselves. They could have easily prolonged the siege beyond what the Romans expected, had it not been for some Italian exiles living in Leucas who let a band of soldiers into the citadel. Nevertheless, when those troops charged down from the higher ground in chaos, the Leucadians gathered in the forum and held their ground for a considerable time in organized combat. Meanwhile, the walls were breached in several areas, and the besiegers climbed over the debris to enter the town. At this point, the lieutenant general himself surrounded the fighters with a strong force. Trapped, many were killed, and the rest laid down their arms and surrendered to the victor. A few days later, upon learning of the battle at Cynoscephalae, all the states of Acarnania submitted to the lieutenant general.

18

About this time, fortune, depressing the same party in every quarter at once, the Rhodians, in order to recover from Phillip the tract on the continent called Peraea, which had been in possession of their ancestors, sent thither their praetor, Pausistratus, with eight hundred Achaean foot, and about one thousand nine hundred men, made up of auxiliaries of various nations. These were Gauls, Nisuetans, Pisuetans, Tamians Areans from Africa, and Laodiceans from Asia. With this force Pausistratus seized by surprise Tendeba, in the territory of Stratonice, a place exceedingly convenient for his purpose, without the knowledge of the king's troops who had held it. A reinforcement of one thousand Achaean foot and one hundred horse, called out for the same expedition, came up at the very time, under a commander called Theoxenus. Dinocrates, the king's general, with design to recover the fort, marched his army first to Tendeba, and then to another fort called Astragon, which also stood in the territory of Stratonice. Then, calling in all the garrisons, which were scattered in many different places, and the Thessalian auxiliaries from Stratonice itself, he led them on to Alabanda, where the enemy lay. The Rhodians were no way averse from a battle, and the camps being pitched near each other both parties immediately came into the field. Dinocrates placed five hundred Macedonians on his right wing, and the Agrians on his left; the centre he formed of the troops which he had drawn together out of the garrisons of the forts; these were mostly Carians; and he covered the flanks with the cavalry, and the Cretan and Thracian auxiliaries. The Rhodians had on the right wing the Achaeans; on the left mercenary soldiers; and in the centre a chosen band of infantry, a body of auxiliaries composed of troops of various nations. The cavalry and what light infantry they had, were posted on the wings. During that day both armies remained on the banks of a rivulet, which ran between them, and, after discharging a few javelins, they retired into their camps. Next day, being drawn up in the same order, they fought a more important battle than could have been expected, considering the numbers engaged; for there were not more than three thousand infantry on each side, and about one hundred horse: but they were not only on an equality with respect to numbers, and the kind of arms which they used, but they also fought with equal spirit and equal hopes. First, the Achaeans crossing the rivulet, made an attack on the Agrians; then the whole line passed the river, almost at full speed. The fight continued doubtful a long time: the Achaeans, one thousand in number, drove back the four hundred from their position. Then the left wing giving way, all exerted themselves against the right. On the Macedonians no impression could be made, so long as their phalanx preserved its order, each man clinging as it were to another: but when, in consequence of their flank being left exposed, they endeavoured to turn their spears against the enemy, who were advancing upon that side, they immediately broke their ranks. This first caused disorder among themselves; they then turned their backs, and at last, throwing away their arms, and flying with precipitation, made the best of their way to Bargylii. To the same place Dinocrates also made his escape. The Rhodians continued the pursuit as long as the day lasted, and then retired to their camp. There is every reason to believe, that, if the victors had proceeded with speed to Stratonice, that city would have been gained without a contest; but the opportunity for effecting this was neglected, and the time wasted in taking possession of the forts and villages in Peraea. In the mean time, the courage of the troops in garrison at Stratonice revived; and shortly after, Dinocrates, with the troops which had escaped from the battle, came into the town, which, after that, was besieged and assaulted without effect; nor could it be reduced until a long time after that, when Antiochus took it. Such were the events that took place in Thessaly, in Achaia, and in Asia, all about the same time.

Around this time, fortune was against everyone, including the Rhodians, who wanted to reclaim Peraea, a region on the mainland that belonged to their ancestors. They sent their praetor, Pausistratus, along with eight hundred Achaean infantry and about one thousand nine hundred auxiliary troops from various nations, including Gauls, Nisuetans, Pisuetans, Tamians, Areans from Africa, and Laodiceans from Asia. With this force, Pausistratus launched a surprise attack on Tendeba, in the territory of Stratonice, which was very advantageous for him, without the king's troops knowing. Just then, a reinforcement of one thousand Achaean infantry and one hundred cavalry, called out for the same mission, arrived led by a commander named Theoxenus. Dinocrates, the king's general, aimed to reclaim the fort and marched his army first to Tendeba and then to another fort called Astragon, also located in Stratonice. He then called in all the scattered garrisons and the Thessalian auxiliaries from Stratonice itself, leading them to Alabanda, where the enemy was stationed. The Rhodians were ready for battle, and since both camps were pitched near each other, they engaged immediately in the field. Dinocrates placed five hundred Macedonians on his right wing and the Agrians on his left, while the center consisted of troops gathered from the garrisons, mainly Carians. He fortified the flanks with cavalry and Cretan and Thracian auxiliaries. The Rhodians positioned the Achaeans on the right wing, mercenary soldiers on the left, and a select group of infantry made up of various auxiliaries in the center. Their cavalry and any light infantry they had were stationed on the wings. That day, both armies stayed by a stream running between them, and after throwing a few javelins, returned to their camps. The next day, still organized the same way, they engaged in a battle that was more intense than expected given the numbers involved—each side had no more than three thousand infantry and about one hundred cavalry. They were equal not only in numbers and weapon types but also in spirit and determination. First, the Achaeans crossed the stream and attacked the Agrians. Soon after, the entire line rushed across the river. The fighting remained uncertain for a long time; the Achaeans, numbering a thousand, pushed back the four hundred Agrians from their position. As the left wing began to falter, everyone focused on the right. The Macedonians held strong as long as their phalanx remained intact, with each soldier holding on tightly to the next. But when they left their flank exposed and tried to turn their spears against the advancing enemy, their ranks collapsed. This disarray led to their own chaos; they turned to flee, ultimately discarding their arms in a panic as they made their way to Bargylii. Dinocrates escaped to the same location. The Rhodians pursued them as long as daylight allowed, then returned to their camp. It’s believed that if the victors had rushed to Stratonice quickly, they could have taken the city without a fight. However, they squandered their opportunity taking control of forts and villages in Peraea. Meanwhile, the morale of the troops stationed at Stratonice began to recover. Shortly after, Dinocrates, along with the troops who escaped from the battle, returned to the town, which then faced ineffective sieges and assaults, unable to be captured until much later when Antiochus took it. These were the events that occurred in Thessaly, Achaia, and Asia around the same period.

19

Philip was informed that the Dardanians, in contempt of the power of his kingdom, shaken as at that time it was, had passed the frontiers, and were spreading devastation through the upper parts of Macedonia: on which, though he was hard pressed in almost every quarter of the globe, fortune on all occasions defeating his measures and those of his friends, yet, thinking it more intolerable than death to be expelled from the possession of Macedonia, he made hasty levies through the cities of his dominions; and, with six thousand foot and five hundred horse, defeated the enemy by a surprise near Stobi in Paeonia. Great numbers were killed in the fight, and greater numbers of those who were scattered about in quest of plunder. As to such as found a road open for flight, without having even tried the chance of an engagement, they hastened back to their own country. After this enterprise executed with a degree of success beyond what he met in the rest of his attempts, and which raised the drooping courage of his people, he retired to Thessalonica. Seasonable as was the termination of the Punic war, in extricating the Romans from the danger of a quarrel with Philip, the recent triumph over Philip happened still more opportunely, when Antiochus, in Syria, was already making preparations for hostilities. For besides that it was easier to wage war against them separately than if both had combined their forces together, Spain had a little before this time, risen in arms in great commotion Antiochus, though he had in the preceding summer reduced under his power all the states in Coele-Syria belonging to Ptolemy, and retired into winter quarters at Antioch, yet allowed himself no relaxation from the exertions of the summer. For resolving to exert the whole strength of his kingdom, he collected a most powerful force, both naval and military; and in the beginning of spring, sending forward by land his two sons, Ardues and Mithridates, at the head of the army, with orders to wait for him at Sardis, he himself set out by sea with a fleet of one hundred decked ships, besides two hundred lighter vessels, barks and fly-boats, designing to attempt the reduction of all the cities under the dominion of Ptolemy along the whole coast of Caria and Cilicia; and, at the same time, to aid Philip with an army and ships, for as yet that war had not been brought to a conclusion.

Philip was informed that the Dardanians, disregarding the weakened state of his kingdom, had crossed the borders and were wreaking havoc in the northern parts of Macedonia. Despite being under pressure from multiple fronts, with misfortunes constantly undermining his plans and those of his allies, he found the idea of being driven out of Macedonia more unbearable than death. So, he quickly gathered troops from the cities he ruled and, with six thousand infantry and five hundred cavalry, defeated the enemy unexpectedly near Stobi in Paeonia. Many were killed in the battle, and even more were slaughtered as they scattered in search of loot. Those who managed to find an escape route, without even attempting to fight, hurried back to their homeland. After this successful campaign, which boosted the morale of his people beyond his previous endeavors, he returned to Thessalonica. The timely end of the Punic war helped free the Romans from the threat of conflict with Philip, but their recent victory over him was even more well-timed, especially since Antiochus in Syria was already preparing for war. It's easier to fight against them separately than to confront them together, and Spain had also recently risen in rebellion. Even though Antiochus had subdued all of Ptolemy's territories in Coele-Syria the previous summer and had settled into winter quarters at Antioch, he did not take a break from his summer efforts. Determined to leverage the full might of his kingdom, he gathered a powerful force, both naval and military. At the start of spring, he sent his two sons, Ardues and Mithridates, with the army ahead to wait for him at Sardis while he himself set out by sea with a fleet of one hundred warships and two hundred lighter vessels, intending to capture all the cities under Ptolemy's control along the coasts of Caria and Cilicia, and at the same time assist Philip with troops and ships, as that war had not yet reached its conclusion.

20

The Rhodians, out of a faithful attachment to the Roman people, and an affection for the whole race of the Greeks have performed many honourable exploits, both on land and sea: but never was their gallantry more eminently conspicuous than on this occasion, when, nowise dismayed at the formidable magnitude of the impending war, they sent ambassadors to tell the king, that he should not double the tribute of Cheledoniae, which is a promontory of Cilicia, rendered famous by an ancient treaty between the Athenians and the king of Persia; that if he did not confine his fleet and army to that boundary, they would meet him there and oppose not out of any ill will, but because they would not suffice to join Philip and obstruct the Romans, who were resisting liberty to Greece. At this time Antiochus was pushing the siege of Coracesium with his works; for, after he had possession of Zephyrium, Solae, Aphrodisias, and Corycus; and doubling Anemurium, another promontory of Cilicia, had taken Selinus; when all these, and the other fortresses on that coast, had, either through fear or inclination, submitted without resistance, Coracesium shut its gates, and gave him a delay which he did not expect. Here an audience was given to the ambassadors of the Rhodians, and although the purport of their embassy was such as might kindle passion in the breast of a king, yet he stifled his resentment, and answered, that "he would send ambassadors to Rhodes, and would give them instructions to renew the old treaties, made by him and his predecessors, with that state; and to assure them, that they need not be alarmed at his approach; that it would involve no injury or fraud either to them or their allies; for that he was not about to violate the friendship subsisting between himself and the Romans, both his own late embassy to that people, and the senate's answers and decrees, so honourable to him, were a sufficient evidence." Just at that time his ambassadors happened to have returned from Rome, where they had been heard and dismissed with courtesy, as the juncture required; the event of the war with Philip being yet uncertain. While the king's ambassadors were haranguing to the above purpose, in an assembly of the people at Rhodes, a courier arrived with an account of the battle at Cynoscephalae having finally decided the fate of the war. Having received this intelligence, the Rhodians, now freed from all apprehensions of danger from Philip, resolved to oppose Antiochus with their fleet. Nor did they neglect another object that required their attention; the protection of the freedom of the cities in alliance with Ptolemy, which were threatened with war by Antiochus. For, some they assisted with men, others by forewarning them of the enemy's designs; by which means they enabled the Cauneans, Mindians, Halicarnassians, and Samians to preserve their liberty. It were needless to attempt enumerating all the transactions as they occurred in that quarter, when I am scarcely equal to the task of recounting those which immediately concern the war in which Rome was engaged.

The Rhodians, deeply loyal to the Roman people and fond of all Greeks, accomplished many honorable feats both on land and at sea. Yet, their bravery was never clearer than in this instance, when, undeterred by the daunting scale of the impending war, they sent envoys to inform the king that he should not increase the tribute of Cheledoniae, a promontory in Cilicia made famous by an ancient treaty between the Athenians and the king of Persia. They stated that if he did not restrict his fleet and army to that boundary, they would confront him there—not out of malice, but because they couldn't support Philip and hinder the Romans, who were fighting for Greece's freedom. At this time, Antiochus was laying siege to Coracesium with his siege works; after capturing Zephyrium, Solae, Aphrodisias, and Corycus, and bypassing Anemurium, another Cilician promontory, he had taken Selinus. All these locations, either out of fear or willingness, submitted without a fight, except for Coracesium, which closed its gates and unexpectedly delayed him. Here, the Rhodians' envoys were granted an audience, and although their message could have stirred a king's anger, he suppressed his resentment and replied that he would send ambassadors to Rhodes to renew the old treaties made by him and his predecessors with the city, assuring them that they shouldn’t be worried about his advance; it would pose no harm or deceit to them or their allies, as he wasn’t planning to break the friendship between himself and the Romans, evidenced by his recent embassy to them and the Senate's honorable responses and decrees. At that moment, his ambassadors had just returned from Rome, where they had been received and dismissed courteously, given the uncertainty of the war with Philip. While the king's ambassadors were addressing this matter in a public assembly at Rhodes, a courier arrived with news that the battle at Cynoscephalae had ultimately determined the outcome of the war. Upon receiving this information, the Rhodians, now free from concerns about Philip, decided to oppose Antiochus with their fleet. They also focused on another important matter—the protection of the freedom of the cities allied with Ptolemy, threatened by Antiochus’s war. They supported some with troops and warned others of the enemy's plans, which helped the Cauneans, Mindians, Halicarnassians, and Samians preserve their freedom. It would be pointless to try to list all the events in that region when I can barely recount those directly related to the war involving Rome.

21

At this time king Attalus, having fallen sick at Thebes, had been carried thence to Pergamus, died at the age of seventy-one after he had reigned forty-four years. To this man fortune had given nothing which could inspire hopes of a throne except riches. By a prudent, and, at the same time, a splendid use of these, he begat, in himself first, and then in others, an opinion, that he was not undeserving of a crown. Afterwards, having in one battle utterly defeated the Gauls, which nation was then the more terrible to Asia, as having but lately made its appearance there, he assumed the title of king, and ever after exhibited a spirit equal to the dignity of that name. He governed his subjects with the most perfect justice, and observed an unvarying fidelity towards his allies; gentle and bountiful to his friends; affectionate to his wife and four sons, who survived him; and he left his government established on such solid and firm foundations, that the possession of it descended to the third generation. While this was the posture of affairs in Asia, Greece, and Macedonia, the war with Philip being scarcely ended, and the peace certainly not yet perfected, a desperate insurrection took place in the Farther Spain. Marcus Helvius was governor of that province. He informed the senate by letter, that "two chieftains, Colca and Luscinus, were in arms; that Colca was joined by seventeen towns, and Luscinus by the powerful cities of Carmo and Bardo; and that the people of the whole sea-coast, who had not yet manifested their disposition, were ready to rise on the first motion of their neighbours." On this letter being read by Marcus Sergius, city praetor, the senate decreed, that, as soon as the election of praetors should be finished, the one to whose lot the government of Spain fell should, without delay, consult the senate respecting the commotions in that province.

At this time, King Attalus, having fallen ill in Thebes, was taken to Pergamus, where he died at the age of seventy-one after reigning for forty-four years. Fortune had given him little to inspire hope for a throne apart from wealth. By wisely and impressively utilizing this wealth, he cultivated a belief, both in himself and others, that he deserved a crown. Later, after completely defeating the Gauls in battle—who were then a frightening presence in Asia due to their recent arrival—he took on the title of king, displaying a spirit worthy of that name. He ruled his subjects with perfect justice and remained loyal to his allies; he was kind and generous to his friends, and loving to his wife and four surviving sons. He established his government on such sturdy foundations that it was passed down to the third generation. While these events unfolded in Asia, Greece, and Macedonia, and the war with Philip was barely over, with peace still not fully settled, a serious uprising occurred in Farther Spain. Marcus Helvius was the governor of that province. He informed the senate by letter that "two leaders, Colca and Luscinus, were in arms; that Colca had the support of seventeen towns, while Luscinus was backed by the strong cities of Carmo and Bardo; and that the people along the entire coast, who had not yet shown their intentions, were ready to rise at the first sign from their neighbors." After Marcus Sergius, the city praetor, read this letter, the senate decided that as soon as the elections for praetors were completed, the praetor assigned to govern Spain should promptly consult the senate regarding the unrest in the province.

22

About the same time the consuls came home to Rome, and, on their holding a meeting of the senate in the temple of Bellona, and demanding a triumph, in consideration of their successes in the war, Caius Atinius Labeo, and Caius Ursanius, plebeian tribunes, insisted that "the consuls should propose their claims of a triumph separately, for they would not suffer the question to be put on both jointly, lest equal honours might be conferred where the merits were unequal." Minucius urged, that they had both been appointed to the government of one province, Italy; and that, through the course of their administration, his colleague and himself had been united in sentiments and in counsels; to which Cornelius added, that, when the Boians were passing the Po, to assist the Insubrians and Caenomanians against him, they were forced to return to defend their own country, from his colleague ravaging their towns and lands. In reply the tribunes acknowledged, that the services performed in the war by Cornelius were so great, that "no more doubt could be entertained respecting his triumph than respecting the ascribing of glory to the immortal gods." Nevertheless they insisted, that "neither he nor any other member of the community should possess such power and influence as to be able, after obtaining the honour that was due to himself, to bestow the same distinction on a colleague, who immodestly demanded what he had not deserved. The exploits of Quintus Minucius in Liguria were trifling skirmishes, scarcely deserving mention; and in Gaul he had lost great numbers of soldiers." They mentioned even military tribunes, Titus Juvencius and Cneius Labeo, of the fourth legion, the plebeian tribune's brother, who had fallen in unsuccessful conflict, together with many other brave men, both citizens and allies: and they asserted, that "pretended surrenders of a few towns and villages, fabricated for the occasion, had been made, without any pledge of fidelity being taken." These altercations between the consuls and tribunes lasted two days: at last the consuls, overcome by the obstinacy of the tribunes, proposed their claims separately.

About the same time the consuls returned to Rome, they held a meeting of the senate in the temple of Bellona and requested a triumph due to their successes in the war. Caius Atinius Labeo and Caius Ursanius, the plebeian tribunes, insisted that "the consuls should present their claims for a triumph separately, as they wouldn't allow the matter to be considered jointly, fearing that equal honors might be awarded despite unequal merits." Minucius argued that they had both been assigned to govern the same province, Italy, and that during their tenure, he and his colleague had shared views and decisions. Cornelius added that when the Boians were crossing the Po River to aid the Insubrians and Caenomanians against him, they had to retreat to defend their own land from his colleague, who was ravaging their towns and territories. In response, the tribunes admitted that Cornelius's contributions in the war were so significant that "there could be no doubt about his triumph, just like there’s no doubt regarding the glory due to the immortal gods." Still, they maintained that "neither he nor any other member of the community should hold so much power and influence that, after receiving the honor he deserved, he could also grant the same recognition to a colleague who unjustly sought what he hadn’t earned. The feats of Quintus Minucius in Liguria were minor skirmishes that barely warranted mention, and in Gaul, he had lost a large number of soldiers." They even cited the military tribunes, Titus Juvencius and Cneius Labeo, of the fourth legion—who was the tribune's brother—who had died in an unsuccessful battle, along with many other brave men, both citizens and allies. They claimed that "fake surrenders of a few towns and villages were staged for the occasion, without any commitment to loyalty being established." These arguments between the consuls and the tribunes continued for two days: eventually, the consuls, defeated by the stubbornness of the tribunes, presented their claims separately.

23

To Cneius Cornelius a triumph was unanimously decreed: and the inhabitants of Placentia and Cremona added to the applause bestowed on the consul, by returning him thanks, and mentioning, to his honour, that they had been delivered by him from a siege; and that very many of them, when in the hands of the enemy, had been rescued from captivity. Quintus Minucius just tried how the proposal of his claim would be received, and finding the whole senate averse from it, declared, that by the authority of his office of consul, and pursuant to the example of many illustrious men, he would triumph on the Alban mount. Caius Cornelius, being yet in office, triumphed over the Insubrian and Caenomanian Gauls. He produced a great number of military standards, and earned in the procession abundance of Gallic spoils in captured chariots. Many Gauls of distinction were led before his chariot, and along with them, some writers say, Hamilcar, the Carthaginian general. But what, more than all, attracted the eyes of the public, was a crowd of Cremonian and Placentian colonists, with caps of liberty on their heads, following his chariot. He carried in his triumph two hundred and thirty-seven thousand five hundred asses,[14] and of silver denarii, stamped with a chariot, seventy-nine thousand.[15] He distributed to each of his soldiers seventy asses,[16] to a horseman and a centurion double that sum. Quintus Minucius, consul, triumphed on the Alban mount, over the Ligurian and Boian Gauls. Although this triumph was less respectable, in regard to the place and the fame of his exploits, and because all knew the expense was not issued from the treasury; yet, in regard of the number of standards, chariots, and spoils, it was nearly equal to the other. The amount of the money also was nearly equal. Two hundred and fifty-four thousand asses[17] were conveyed to the treasury, and of silver denarii, stamped with a chariot, fifty-three thousand two hundred.[18] He likewise gave to the soldiers, horsemen, and centurions, severally, the same sums that his colleague had given.

A triumph was unanimously granted to Cneius Cornelius, and the people of Placentia and Cremona added to the praise for the consul by expressing their gratitude and noting, in his honor, that he had saved them from a siege; many of them had been rescued from enemy captivity. Quintus Minucius gauged how his proposal would be received and, seeing that the entire senate opposed it, declared that by the power of his consulship and following the example of many notable figures, he would celebrate a triumph on the Alban Mount. While still in office, Caius Cornelius triumphed over the Insubrian and Caenomanian Gauls. He showcased a large number of military standards and collected plenty of Gallic spoils in captured chariots during the procession. Many distinguished Gauls were led in front of his chariot, and some sources say Hamilcar, the Carthaginian general, was among them. However, what captivated the public's attention the most was a crowd of settlers from Cremona and Placentia, wearing caps of liberty, following his chariot. He brought in his triumph two hundred thirty-seven thousand five hundred asses,[14] and seventy-nine thousand silver denarii stamped with a chariot.[15] He gave each of his soldiers seventy asses,[16] while horsemen and centurions received double that amount. Quintus Minucius, consul, celebrated a triumph on the Alban Mount over the Ligurian and Boian Gauls. Although this triumph was less prestigious due to the location and the reputation of his exploits, and because everyone knew the funds didn't come from the treasury, it was nearly equal to the other in terms of the number of standards, chariots, and spoils. The monetary amount was also quite similar. Two hundred fifty-four thousand asses[17] were sent to the treasury, and fifty-three thousand two hundred silver denarii stamped with a chariot.[18] He also awarded his soldiers, horsemen, and centurions the same amounts his colleague had given.

24

After the triumph, the election of consuls came on. The persons chosen were Lucius Furius Purpureo and Marcus Claudius Marcellus. Next day, the following were elected praetors; Quintus Fabius Buteo, Tiberius Sempronius Longus, Quintus Minucius Thermus, Manius Acilius Glabrio, Lucius Apustius Fullo, and Caius Laelius. Toward the close of this year, a letter came from Titus Quinctius, with information that he had fought a pitched battle with Philip in Thessaly, and that the army of the enemy had been routed and put to flight. This letter was read by Sergius, the praetor, first in the senate, and then, by the direction of the fathers, in a general assembly; and supplications of five days' continuance were decreed on account of those successes. Soon after arrived the ambassadors, both from Titus Quinctius and from the king. The Macedonians were conducted out of the city to the Villa Publica, where lodgings and every other accommodation were provided for them, and an audience of the senate was given them in the temple of Bellona. Not many words passed; for the Macedonians declared, that whatever terms the senate should prescribe, the king was ready to comply with them. It was decreed, that, conformably to ancient practice, ten ambassadors should be appointed, and that, in council with them, the general, Titus Quinctius, should grant terms of peace to Philip; and a clause was added, that, in the number of these ambassadors, should be Publius Sulpicius and Publius Villius, who in their consulship had held the province of Macedonia. On the same day the inhabitants of Oossa having presented a petition, praying that the number of their colonists might be enlarged; an order was accordingly passed, that one thousand should be added to the list, with a provision, that no persons should be admitted into that number who, at any time since the consulate of Publius Cornelius and Tiberius Sempronius, had been partisans of the enemy.

After the victory, it was time to elect new consuls. The selected candidates were Lucius Furius Purpureo and Marcus Claudius Marcellus. The next day, the following praetors were elected: Quintus Fabius Buteo, Tiberius Sempronius Longus, Quintus Minucius Thermus, Manius Acilius Glabrio, Lucius Apustius Fullo, and Caius Laelius. Toward the end of that year, a letter arrived from Titus Quinctius, informing that he had fought a decisive battle with Philip in Thessaly, and that the enemy's forces had been defeated and routed. This letter was first read by Sergius, the praetor, in the senate, and then, at the request of the senators, in a general assembly; it was decided that there would be five days of public thanksgiving for these victories. Shortly after, ambassadors arrived, both from Titus Quinctius and the king. The Macedonians were escorted out of the city to the Villa Publica, where they were provided with accommodations, and they were given an audience with the senate in the temple of Bellona. Not much was said; the Macedonians stated that whatever terms the senate proposed, the king would accept. It was decided, following traditional practice, that ten ambassadors would be appointed, and that, together with them, the general, Titus Quinctius, would negotiate peace terms with Philip. It was also specified that among these ambassadors would be Publius Sulpicius and Publius Villius, who, during their consulship, had governed the province of Macedonia. On the same day, the people of Oossa submitted a petition asking for an increase in the number of their colonists; it was resolved that one thousand would be added to the list, with the stipulation that no one who had been an enemy supporter since the consulship of Publius Cornelius and Tiberius Sempronius would be included.

25

This year the Roman games were exhibited in the circus, and on the stage, by the curule aediles, Publius Cornelius Scipio and Cneius Manlius Vulso, with an unusual degree of splendour, and were beheld with the greater delight, in consequence of the late successes in war. They were thrice repeated entire, and the plebeian games seven times. These were exhibited by Manius Acilius Glabrio and Caius Laelius, who also, out of the money arising from fines, erected three brazen statues, to Ceres, Liber, and Libera. Lucius Furius and Marcus Claudius Marcellus, having entered on the consulship, when the distribution of the provinces came to be agitated, and the senate appeared disposed to vote Italy the province of both, exerted themselves to get that of Macedonia put to the lot along with Italy. Marcellus, who of the two was the more eager for that province, by assertions that the peace was merely a feigned and delusive one, and that, if the army were withdrawn thence, the king would renew the war, caused some perplexity in the minds of the senate. The consuls would probably have carried the point, had not Quintus Marcius Rex and Caius Antinius Labeo, plebeian tribunes, declared, that they would enter their protest, unless they were allowed, before any further proceeding, to take the sense of the people, whether it was their will and order that peace be concluded with Philip. This question was put to the people in the Capitol, and every one of the thirty-five tribes voted on the affirmative side. The public found the greater reason to rejoice at the ratification of the peace with Macedonia, as melancholy news was brought from Spain; and a letter was made public, announcing that "the proconsul, Caius Sempronius Tuditanus, had been defeated in battle in the Hither Spain; that his army had been utterly routed and dispersed, and several men of distinction slain in the fight. That Tuditanus, having been grievously wounded, and carried out of the field, expired soon after." Italy was decreed the province of both consuls, in which they were to employ the same legions which the preceding consuls had; and they were to raise four new legions, two for the city, and two to be in readiness to be sent whithersoever the senate should direct. Titus Quinctius Flamininus was ordered to continue in the government of his province, with the army of two legions, then on the spot. The former prolongation of his command was deemed sufficient.

This year, the Roman games were showcased in the circus and on the stage, organized by the curule aediles, Publius Cornelius Scipio and Cneius Manlius Vulso, with an exceptional level of splendor, and people enjoyed them even more due to the recent military victories. They were held three times in full, and the plebeian games took place seven times. These were arranged by Manius Acilius Glabrio and Caius Laelius, who also used funds from fines to erect three bronze statues for Ceres, Liber, and Libera. When Lucius Furius and Marcus Claudius Marcellus took office as consuls, discussions about the distribution of provinces began, and the senate seemed inclined to assign Italy as the province for both of them. They worked to include Macedonia in the lot alongside Italy. Marcellus, who was particularly keen on that province, argued that the peace was merely a facade and that if the army were withdrawn, the king would reignite the conflict, which caused some uncertainty among the senators. The consuls likely would have succeeded if Quintus Marcius Rex and Caius Antinius Labeo, the plebeian tribunes, hadn't declared that they would protest unless they were allowed to gauge the people's opinion before moving forward—to see if it was their wish to conclude peace with Philip. This question was posed to the people at the Capitol, and every one of the thirty-five tribes voted in favor. The public had even more reason to celebrate the ratification of the peace with Macedonia since there were grim reports from Spain; a letter was released stating that "the proconsul, Caius Sempronius Tuditanus, had been defeated in battle in Hither Spain; his army had been completely routed, and several prominent figures were killed in the fight. Tuditanus, having suffered severe wounds and being carried off the battlefield, died shortly after." Italy was assigned as the province for both consuls, who were to use the same legions as the previous consuls and recruit four new legions—two for the city and two on standby to be dispatched wherever the senate directed. Titus Quinctius Flamininus was ordered to remain in charge of his province with the army of two legions present at that time. His previous extension of command was considered sufficient.

26

The praetors then cast lots for their provinces. Lucius Apustius Fullo obtained the city jurisdiction; Manius Acilius Glabrio, that between natives and foreigners; Quintus Fabius Buteo, Farther Spain; Quintus Minucius Thermus, Hither Spain; Caius Laelius, Sicily; Tiberius Sempronius Longus, Sardinia. To Quintus Fabius Buteo and Quintus Minucius, to whom the government of the two Spains had fallen, it was decreed, that the consuls, out of the four legions raised by them, should give one each whichever they thought fit, together with four thousand foot and three hundred horse of the allies and Latin confederates; and those praetors were ordered to repair to their provinces at the earliest possible time. This war in Spain broke out in the fifth year after the former had been ended, together with the Punic war. The Spaniards now, for the first time, had taken arms in their own name, unconnected with any Carthaginian army or general. Before the consuls stirred from the city, however, they were ordered, as usual, to expiate the reported prodigies. Publius Villius, a Roman knight, on the road to Sabinia, had been killed by lightning, together with his horse. The temple of Feronia, in the Capenatian district, had been struck by lightning. At the temple of Moneta, the shafts of two spears had taken fire and burned. A wolf, coming in through the Esquiline gate, and running through the most frequented part of the city, down into the forum, passed thence through the Tuscan and Maelian streets; and scarcely receiving a stroke, made its escape out of the Capenian gate. These prodigies were expiated with victims of the larger kinds.

The praetors then drew lots for their provinces. Lucius Apustius Fullo got the city jurisdiction; Manius Acilius Glabrio received the jurisdiction between locals and foreigners; Quintus Fabius Buteo was assigned Farther Spain; Quintus Minucius Thermus got Hither Spain; Caius Laelius was designated Sicily; and Tiberius Sempronius Longus took Sardinia. For Quintus Fabius Buteo and Quintus Minucius, who were in charge of the two Spains, it was decided that the consuls should give them one legion each from the four they had raised, along with four thousand foot soldiers and three hundred cavalry from the allies and Latin confederates; and those praetors were instructed to head to their provinces as soon as they could. This war in Spain started in the fifth year after the previous conflict had ended, which included the Punic War. For the first time, the Spaniards took up arms on their own, not connected with any Carthaginian army or general. Before the consuls left the city, they were ordered, as usual, to atone for the reported prodigies. Publius Villius, a Roman knight, had been struck by lightning on the road to Sabinia, along with his horse. The temple of Feronia, in the Capenatian district, was hit by lightning. At the temple of Moneta, the points of two spears had caught fire and burned. A wolf entered through the Esquiline gate and ran through the busiest part of the city, right into the forum, then made its way through the Tuscan and Maelian streets; and barely getting hurt, it escaped out of the Capenian gate. These prodigies were atoned for with large sacrificial victims.

27

About the same time Cneius Cornelius Lentulus, who had held the government of Hither Spain before Sempronius Tuditanus, entered the city in ovation, pursuant to a decree of the senate, and carried in the procession one thousand five hundred and fifteen pounds' weight of gold, twenty thousand of silver; and in coin, thirty-four thousand five hundred and fifty denarii.[19] Lucius Stretinius, from the Farther Spain, without making any pretensions to a triumph, carried into the treasury fifty thousand pounds' weight of silver; and out of the spoils taken, built two arches in the cattle-market, at the fronts of the temple of Fortune and Mother Matuta, and one in the great Circus; and on these arches placed gilded statues. These were the principal occurrences during the winter. At this time Quinctius was in winter quarters at Elatia. Among many requests, made to him by the allies, was that of the Boeotians, namely, that their countrymen, who had served in the army with Philip, might be restored to them. With this Quinctius readily complied; not because he thought them very deserving, but that, as king Antiochus was already suspected, he judged it advisable to conciliate every state in favour of the Roman interest. It quickly appeared how very little gratitude existed among the Boeotians; for they not only sent persons to give thanks to Philip for the restoration of their fellows, as if that favour had been conferred on them by him, and not by Quinctius and the Romans; but, at the next election, raised to the office of Boeotarch a man named Brachyllas, for no other reason than because he had been commander of the Boeotians serving in the army of Philip; passing by Zeuxippus, Pisistratus, and the others, who had promoted the alliance with Rome. These men were both offended at the present and alarmed about the future consequences: for if such things were done when a Roman army lay almost at their gates, what would become of them when the Romans should have gone away to Italy, and Philip, from a situation so near, should support his own associates, and vent his resentment on those who had been of the opposite party?

About the same time, Cneius Cornelius Lentulus, who had governed Hither Spain before Sempronius Tuditanus, entered the city in a celebratory procession, in accordance with a senate decree, carrying one thousand five hundred and fifteen pounds of gold, twenty thousand pounds of silver, and thirty-four thousand five hundred and fifty denarii in coins. Lucius Stretinius, from Farther Spain, without claiming a triumph, brought fifty thousand pounds of silver into the treasury; from the spoils, he built two arches in the cattle market, at the fronts of the temples of Fortune and Mother Matuta, and one in the great Circus, placing gilded statues on these arches. These were the main events of the winter. At this time, Quinctius was in winter quarters at Elatia. Among many requests from the allies, the Boeotians asked for the return of their fellow countrymen who had served in the army with Philip. Quinctius agreed to this, not because he thought they were particularly deserving, but because, given that King Antiochus was already suspected, he deemed it wise to win over every state in favor of Roman interests. It quickly became clear how little gratitude the Boeotians had; they not only sent people to thank Philip for the return of their men, as if that favor had come from him and not from Quinctius and the Romans, but during the next election, they chose a man named Brachyllas as Boeotarch simply because he had been a commander of the Boeotians who served in Philip's army, overlooking Zeuxippus, Pisistratus, and others who had fostered the alliance with Rome. These men were not only offended by this but also worried about future consequences: if such things could happen while a Roman army was practically at their doorstep, what would happen when the Romans left for Italy, and Philip, so close by, supported his allies and sought revenge on those who had opposed him?

28

It was resolved, while they had the Roman army near at hand, to take off Brachyllas, who was the principal leader of the faction which favoured the king; and they chose an opportunity for the deed, when, after having been at a public feast, he was returning to his house inebriated, and accompanied by some of his debauched companions, who, for the sake of merriment, had been admitted to the crowded entertainment. He was surrounded and assassinated by six men, of whom three were Italians and three Aetolians. His companions fled, crying out for help; and a great uproar ensued among the people, who ran up and down, through all parts of the city, with lights; but the assassins made their escape through the nearest gate. At the first dawn, a full assembly was called together in the theatre, by the voice of a crier, as if in consequence of a previous appointment. Many openly clamoured that Brachyllas was killed by those detestable wretches who accompanied him; but their private conjectures pointed to Zeuxippus, as author of the murder. It was resolved, however, that those who had been in company with him should be seized and examined in their presence. While they were under examination, Zeuxippus, with his usual composure, came into the assembly, for the purpose of averting the charge from himself; yet said, that people were mistaken in supposing that so daring a murder was the act of such effeminate wretches as those who were charged with it, urging many plausible arguments to the same purpose. By which behaviour he led several to believe, that, if he were conscious of guilt, he would never have presented himself before the multitude, or, without being challenged by any, have made any mention of the murder. Others were convinced that he intended, by thus unblushingly exposing himself to the charge, to throw off all suspicion from himself. Soon after, those men who were innocent were put to the torture; and, taking the universal opinion as having the effect of evidence, they named Zeuxippus and Pisistratus; but they produced no proof to show that they knew any thing of the matter. Zeuxippus, however, accompanied by a man named Stratonidas, fled by night to Tanagra; alarmed by his own conscience rather than by the assertion of men who were privy to no one circumstance of the affair. Pisistratus, despising the informers, remained at Thebes. A slave of Zeuxippus had carried messages backwards and forwards, and had been intrusted with the management of the whole business. From this man Pisistratus dreaded a discovery; and by that very dread forced him, against his will, to make one. He sent a letter to Zeuxippus, desiring him to "put out of the way the slave who was privy to their crime; for he did not believe him as well qualified for the concealment of the fact as he was for the perpetration of it." He ordered the bearer of this letter to deliver it to Zeuxippus as soon as possible; but he, not finding an opportunity of meeting him, put it into the hands of the very slave in question, whom he believed to be the most faithful to his master of any; and added, that it came from Pisistratus respecting a matter of the utmost consequence to Zeuxippus. Struck by consciousness of guilt, the slave after promising to deliver the letter, immediately opened it; and, on reading the contents, fled in a fright to Thebes and laid the information before the magistrate. Zeuxippus, alarmed by the flight of his slave, withdrew to Athens, where he thought he might live in exile with greater safety. Pisistratus, after being examined several times by torture, was put to death.

It was decided, while the Roman army was nearby, to eliminate Brachyllas, the main leader of the faction that supported the king. They chose a moment when, after attending a public feast, he was heading home drunk and accompanied by some of his wild companions, who had joined the crowded celebration for fun. He was surrounded and killed by six men, three Italians and three Aetolians. His friends ran away, shouting for help, causing a huge commotion as people rushed around the city with torches; however, the assassins escaped through the nearest gate. At dawn, an assembly was quickly gathered in the theater by a crier, as if it had been planned ahead of time. Many openly accused Brachyllas's companions of killing him, but privately they suspected Zeuxippus as the mastermind behind the murder. It was decided, though, that those who had been with him should be captured and questioned in front of everyone. While they were being interrogated, Zeuxippus calmly entered the assembly to clear his name; he suggested that people were wrong to think such a bold murder could be committed by such weak individuals, and he presented several convincing arguments to support his claims. His behavior led many to believe that if he were guilty, he wouldn’t have appeared before the crowd or even mentioned the murder without being prompted. Others thought that his brazen display of innocence was a ploy to deflect suspicion from himself. Soon after, those who were innocent were tortured; influenced by public opinion as if it were evidence, they named Zeuxippus and Pisistratus, but they had no proof that they knew anything about the crime. However, Zeuxippus, along with a man named Stratonidas, fled to Tanagra at night, driven more by his own guilty conscience than by the claims of people who weren’t aware of any details of the incident. Pisistratus, disregarding the informants, stayed in Thebes. A slave of Zeuxippus had been carrying messages back and forth and was trusted with managing the entire operation. Pisistratus feared this slave would expose them, and that fear compelled him to act. He sent a letter to Zeuxippus, urging him to "eliminate the slave who knew their secret; he didn’t believe him capable of keeping it hidden as he was in carrying it out." He instructed the messenger to get the letter to Zeuxippus as soon as possible, but unable to find him, he handed it to the very slave they feared, believing him to be the most loyal to his master. Overcome with guilt, the slave, after promising to deliver the letter, immediately opened it; upon reading its contents, he fled back to Thebes and reported it to the magistrate. Alarmed by the escape of his slave, Zeuxippus fled to Athens, thinking he could live there in exile more safely. Pisistratus, after being tortured several times, was executed.

29

This murder exasperated the Thebans, and all the Boeotians, to the most rancorous animosity against the Romans, for they considered that Zeuxippus, one of the first men of the nation, had not been party to such a crime without the instigation of the Roman general. To recommence a war, they had neither strength nor a leader; but they had recourse to private massacres, as being next to war, and cut off many of the soldiers, some as they came to lodge in their houses, others as they wandered about their winter quarters, or were on leave of absence for various purposes. Some were killed on the roads by parties lying in wait in lurking-places; others were seduced and carried away to inns, which were left uninhabited, and there put to death. At last they committed these crimes, not merely out of hatred, but likewise from a desire of booty; for the soldiers on furlough generally carried money in their purses for the purpose of trading. At first a few at a time, afterwards greater numbers used to be missed, until all Boeotia became notorious for those practices, and a soldier went beyond the bounds of the camp with more timidity than into an enemy's country. Quinctius then sent deputies round the states, to make inquiry concerning the murders committed. The greatest number of murders were found to have been committed about the lake called Copais; there the bodies were dug out of the mud, and drawn up out of the marsh, having had earthen jars or stones tied to them, so as to be dragged to the bottom by the weight. Many deeds of this sort were discovered to have been perpetrated at Acrphia and Coronea. Quinctius at first insisted that the persons guilty should be given up to him, and that, for five hundred soldiers, (for so many had been cut off,) the Botians should pay five hundred talents.[20] Neither of these requisitions being complied with, and the states only making verbal apologies, declaring, that none of those acts had been authorized by the public; Quinctius first sent ambassadors to Athens and Achaia, to satisfy the allies, that the war which he was about to make on the Botians was conformable to justice and piety; and then, ordering Publius Claudius to march with one-half of the troops to Acrphia, he himself, with the remainder, invested Coronea; and these two bodies' marching by different roads from Elatia, laid waste all the country through which they passed. The Botians, dismayed by these losses, while every place was filled with fugitives, and while the terror became universal, sent ambassadors to the camp; and as these were refused admittance, the Achaeans and Athenians came to their assistance. The Achaeans had the greater influence as intercessors; inasmuch as they were resolved, in case they could not procure peace for the Botians, to join them in the war. Through the mediation of the Achaeans, however, the Botians obtained admission and an audience of the Roman general; who, ordering them to deliver up the guilty, and to pay thirty talents[21] as a fine, granted them peace, and raised the siege.

This murder infuriated the Thebans and all the Boeotians, leading them to harbor intense hostility against the Romans. They believed that Zeuxippus, one of their leading figures, couldn’t have committed such a crime without being prompted by the Roman general. They lacked the strength or a leader to start a war, so they resorted to private killings, which felt like a war to them. They ambushed and killed many soldiers—some as they arrived at their lodgings, others as they roamed their winter quarters or took leave for various reasons. Some were murdered on the roads by ambushers hiding in wait; others were lured to abandoned inns and killed there. Ultimately, these acts were driven not just by hatred but also by a desire for loot, as soldiers on leave typically carried money for trading. Initially, only a few soldiers went missing, but as time went on, larger numbers disappeared until all of Boeotia became infamous for these acts. Soldiers began to venture out of their camps with more fear than if they were entering enemy territory. Quinctius then sent envoys to the states to investigate the murders. Most of the killings were found to have occurred near the lake called Copais, where bodies were pulled from the mud, weighed down by earthen jars or stones. Many such incidents were also reported in Acrphia and Coronea. Quinctius first demanded that the culprits be handed over and that the Boeotians pay five hundred talents for the five hundred soldiers that had been killed. Since these demands were not met, and the states merely offered verbal apologies claiming that these acts were not sanctioned by the public, Quinctius sent ambassadors to Athens and Achaia to assure the allies that his upcoming war against the Boeotians was justified. He then ordered Publius Claudius to lead half the troops to Acrphia, while he took the rest to besiege Coronea. These two forces, taking different routes from Elatia, devastated the territory they passed through. The Boeotians, shaken by these losses and surrounded by fleeing people, sent ambassadors to the camp. When these were denied entry, the Achaeans and Athenians came to their aid. The Achaeans were particularly effective as intermediaries since they were prepared to join the Boeotians in war if peace was not achieved. Thanks to the Achaeans' mediation, the Boeotians were allowed to meet with the Roman general, who ordered them to hand over the guilty parties and pay a thirty talents fine, granting them peace and lifting the siege.

30

A few days after this, the ten ambassadors arrived from Rome, in pursuance of whose counsel, peace was granted to Philip on the following conditions: "That all the Grecian states, as well those in Asia as those in Europe, should enjoy liberty, and their own laws: That from such of them as had been in the possession of Philip, he should withdraw his garrisons, particularly from the following places in Asia; Euromus, Pedasi, Bargylii, Iassus, Myrina, Abydus; and from Thasus and Perinthus, for it was determined that these likewise should be free: That with respect to the freedom of Cius, Quinctius should write to Prusias, king of Bithynia, the resolutions of the senate, and of the ten ambassadors: That Philip should return to the Romans the prisoners and deserters, and deliver up all his decked ships, excepting five and the royal galley,--of a size almost unmanageable, being moved by sixteen banks of oars: That he should not keep more than five hundred soldiers, nor any elephant: That he should not wage war beyond the bounds of Macedonia without permission from the senate: That he should pay to the Roman people one thousand talents:[22] one half at present, the other by instalments, within ten years." Valerius Antias writes, that there was imposed on him an annual tribute of four thousand pounds' weight of silver, for ten years, and an immediate payment of twenty thousand pounds' weight. The same author says that an article was expressly inserted, that he should not make war on Eumenes, Attalus's son, who had lately come to the throne. For the performance of these conditions hostages were received, among whom was Demetrius, Philip's son. Valerius Antias adds, that the island of Aegina, and the elephants, were given as a present to Attalus, who was absent; to the Rhodians, Stratonice, and other cities of Caria which had been in the possession of Philip; and to the Athenians, the islands of Paros, Imbros, Delos, and Scyros.

A few days later, the ten ambassadors from Rome arrived, and based on their advice, peace was granted to Philip under the following conditions: "All Greek states, both in Asia and Europe, should have freedom and their own laws. Philip must withdraw his garrisons from those states he occupied, specifically from the following places in Asia: Euromus, Pedasi, Bargylii, Iassus, Myrina, and Abydus; as well as from Thasus and Perinthus, which were also to be free. Regarding the autonomy of Cius, Quinctius was to inform Prusias, the king of Bithynia, of the senate's decisions and those of the ten ambassadors. Philip was required to return prisoners and deserters to the Romans and surrender all his warships except for five and his royal galley, which was nearly impossible to maneuver, having sixteen rows of oars. He was not to maintain more than five hundred soldiers or any elephants. He could not wage war outside of Macedonia without permission from the senate. He was to pay the Roman people one thousand talents: half immediately, and the other half in installments over ten years." Valerius Antias states that he was also subjected to an annual tribute of four thousand pounds of silver for ten years, as well as an immediate payment of twenty thousand pounds. The same author notes that it was specifically stated that he could not wage war against Eumenes, the son of Attalus, who had recently ascended to the throne. To guarantee compliance with these conditions, hostages were taken, including Demetrius, Philip's son. Valerius Antias further adds that the island of Aegina and the elephants were given as gifts to Attalus, who was absent, along with Stratonice and other cities in Caria that had been under Philip's control, and to the Athenians, the islands of Paros, Imbros, Delos, and Scyros.

31

While all the other states of Greece expressed their approbation of these terms of peace, the Aetolians alone, in private murmurs, made severe strictures on the determination of the ten ambassadors. They said, "it consisted merely of an empty piece of writing varnished over with a fallacious appearance of liberty. For why should some cities be put into the hands of the Romans without being named, while others were particularized, and ordered to be enfranchised without such consignment; unless the intent was, that those in Asia, which, from their distant situation, were more secure from danger, should be free; but those in Greece, not being even mentioned by name, should be made their property: Corinth, Chalcis, and Oreum; with Eretria, and Demetrias." Nor was this charge entirely without foundation: for there was some hesitation with respect to Corinth, Chalcis, and Demetrias; because, in the decree of the senate in pursuance of which the ten ambassadors had been sent from Rome, all Greece and Asia, except these three, were expressly ordered to be set at liberty; but, with regard to these, ambassadors were instructed, that, whatever measures the exigencies of the state might render expedient, they should determine to pursue in conformity to the public good and their own honour. King Antiochus was one of whom they did not doubt that, so soon as he was satisfied that his forces were adequate, he would cross over into Europe; and they were unwilling to let these cities, the possession of which would be so advantageous to him, lie open to his occupation. Quinctius, with the ten ambassadors, sailed from Elatia to Anticyra, and thence to Corinth. Here the plans they had laid down respecting the liberation of Greece were discussed for about three days in a council of the ten ambassadors. Quinctius frequently urged, that "every part of Greece ought to be set at liberty, if they wished to refute the cavils of the Aetolians; if they wished, that sincere affection and respect for the Roman nation should be universally entertained; or if they wished to convince the world that they had crossed the sea with the design of liberating Greece, and not of transferring the sovereignty of it from Philip to themselves." The Macedonians alleged nothing in opposition to the arguments made use of in favour of the freedom of the cities; but "they thought it safer for those cities themselves that they should remain, for a time, under the protection of Roman garrisons, than be obliged to receive Antiochus for a master in the room of Philip." Their final determination was, that "Corinth be restored to the Achaeans, but that a Roman garrison should continue in the citadel; and that Chalcis and Demetrias be retained, until their apprehensions respecting Antiochus should cease."

While all the other states of Greece supported these peace terms, the Aetolians alone quietly criticized the decision of the ten ambassadors. They said, "it's just an empty document dressed up to look like freedom. Why are some cities handed over to the Romans without being specified, while others are named and ordered to be freed without such an agreement? It seems like the intent is for those in Asia, which are safer due to their distance, to be free; but those in Greece, not even mentioned, are to be made Roman property: Corinth, Chalcis, and Oreum; along with Eretria and Demetrias." This accusation had some truth: there was some uncertainty concerning Corinth, Chalcis, and Demetrias because, in the senate's decree that led to the sending of the ten ambassadors from Rome, all of Greece and Asia, except these three, were specifically ordered to be liberated. However, concerning these, ambassadors were told that whatever actions were necessary for the state's needs, they should decide to take in line with the public good and their own honor. King Antiochus was someone they believed would, once he thought his forces were sufficient, cross over into Europe; and they did not want to leave these cities, which would be so beneficial to him, vulnerable to his takeover. Quinctius, along with the ten ambassadors, sailed from Elatia to Anticyra and then to Corinth. Here, for about three days, they discussed their plans regarding the liberation of Greece in a council of the ten ambassadors. Quinctius often insisted that "every part of Greece should be freed if they wanted to counter the Aetolians' criticisms; if they wanted genuine love and respect for the Roman nation to be widespread; or if they wanted to prove to the world that they had crossed the sea to liberate Greece, not to transfer control from Philip to themselves." The Macedonians didn’t argue against the calls for the cities’ freedom, but they believed "it would be safer for those cities to stay under the protection of Roman garrisons for a while rather than have to accept Antiochus as their master instead of Philip." Their final decision was that "Corinth be returned to the Achaeans, but a Roman garrison should remain in the citadel; and that Chalcis and Demetrias be held until their fears regarding Antiochus were resolved."

32

The stated solemnity of the Isthmian games was at hand. These have ever been attended by very numerous meetings, as well on account of the universal fondness entertained by this nation for exhibitions of skill in arts of every kind, as well as of contests in strength and swiftness of foot; as also, because of the convenience of the locality, which furnishes commercial advantages of all kinds by its two opposite seas, and by which it had obtained the character of a rendezvous for all the population of Asia and Greece. But on this occasion, all were led thither not only for their ordinary purposes, but by an eager curiosity to learn what was thenceforward to be the state of Greece, and what their own condition; while many at the same time not only formed opinions within themselves but uttered their conjectures in conversation. Scarcely any supposed that the Romans, victorious as they were, would withdraw from the whole of Greece. They took their seats, as spectators; and a herald, preceded by a trumpeter, according to custom, advanced into the centre of the theatre, where notice of the commencement of the games is usually made, in a solemn form of words. Silence being commanded by sound of trumpet, he uttered aloud the following proclamation: THE SENATE AND PEOPLE OF ROME, AND TITUS QUINCTIUS, THEIR GENERAL, HAVING SUBDUED KING PHILIP AND THE MACEDONIANS, DO HEREBY ORDER, THAT THE FOLLOWING STATES BE FREE, INDEPENDENT, AND RULED BY THEIR OWN LAWS: THE CORINTHIANS, PHOCIANS, AND ALL THE LOCRIANS; THE ISLAND OF EUBOEA, AND THE MAGNESIANS; THE THESSALIANS, PERRHAEBIANS, AND THE ACHAEANS OF PHTHIOTIS. He then read a list of all the states which had been under subjection to king Philip. The joy occasioned by hearing these words of the herald was so great, that the people's minds were unable to conceive the matter at once. Scarcely could they believe that they had heard them; and they looked at each other, marvelling as at the empty illusion of a dream. Each inquired of his neighbours about what immediately concerned himself, altogether distrusting the evidence of his own ears. As everyone desired not only to hear, but to see the messenger of liberty, the herald was called out again; and he again repeated the proclamation. When they were thus assured of the reality of the joyful tidings, they raised such a shout, and clapping of hands, and repeated them so often, as clearly to show that of all blessings none is more grateful to the multitude than liberty. The games were then proceeded through with hurry; for neither the thoughts nor eyes of any attended to the exhibitions, so entirely had the single passion of joy pre-occupied their minds, as to exclude the sense of all other pleasures.

The solemnity of the Isthmian games was upon them. These events had always attracted many attendees due to the nation's love for skillful displays in various arts and competitions in strength and speed, as well as the benefits of the location, which offered all kinds of commercial advantages through its two opposing seas, making it a gathering place for people from Asia and Greece. However, this time, everyone was drawn there not just for their usual reasons but out of a strong curiosity to find out what the future held for Greece and for themselves; many formed their own opinions and shared their thoughts in conversation. Hardly anyone believed that the Romans, despite their victories, would completely leave Greece. They took their places as spectators, and a herald, accompanied by a trumpeter as per tradition, stepped into the center of the theater to announce the start of the games in a formal manner. Once silence was called with the sound of the trumpet, he loudly proclaimed: THE SENATE AND PEOPLE OF ROME, AND TITUS QUINCTIUS, THEIR GENERAL, HAVING DEFEATED KING PHILIP AND THE MACEDONIANS, HEREBY DECLARE THAT THE FOLLOWING STATES ARE FREE, INDEPENDENT, AND SELF-GOVERNED: THE CORINTHIANS, PHOCIANS, AND ALL THE LOCRIANS; THE ISLAND OF EUBOEA, AND THE MAGNESIANS; THE THESSALIANS, PERRHAEBIANS, AND THE ACHAEANS OF PHTHIOTIS. He then read out the names of all the states that had been under King Philip's rule. The joy that spread from the herald's announcement was so immense that the crowd struggled to process it all at once. They could hardly believe what they had just heard, looking at one another in amazement, as if caught in a dream. Each person turned to their neighbors to ask for clarification, doubting their own understanding. Wanting not only to hear but also to see the bearer of this great news, they called the herald back out, and he repeated the proclamation. Once they were sure of the happy news, they erupted into cheers, applause, and repeated the announcement so many times that it was clear that nothing is more precious to the masses than freedom. The games proceeded in a rush, as neither thoughts nor attention were on the performances; their minds were completely consumed by the single joy of freedom, leaving no room for any other pleasures.

33

But, when the games were finished, every one eagerly passed towards the Roman general; so that by the crowd rushing to one spot, all wishing to come near him, and to touch his right hand, and throwing garlands and ribands, he was in some degree of danger. He was then about thirty-three years of age; and besides the vigour of youth, the grateful sensations excited by so eminent a harvest of glory, increased his strength. Nor was the general exultation exhausted in the presence of all the assembly, but, through the space of many days, was continually revived by sentiments and expressions of gratitude. "There was a nation in the world," they said, "which, at its own expense, with its own labour, and at its own risk, waged wars for the liberty of others. And this was performed, not merely for contiguous states, or near neighbours, or for countries that made parts of the same continent; but they even crossed the seas for the purpose, that no unlawful power should subsist on the face of the whole earth; but that justice, right, and law should every where have sovereign sway. By one sentence, pronounced by a herald all the cities of Greece and Asia had been set at liberty. To have conceived hopes of this, argued a daring spirit; to have carried it into effect, was a proof of the most consummate bravery and good fortune."

But when the games were over, everyone eagerly rushed towards the Roman general. The crowd surged to one spot, all wanting to get close to him, touch his right hand, and throw garlands and ribbons, putting him in some danger. He was around thirty-three years old; and along with the energy of youth, the overwhelming joy from his remarkable achievements boosted his strength. The general's triumph wasn’t just felt in that moment but was continuously rekindled by expressions of gratitude for many days. "There was a nation in the world," they said, "that at its own expense, with its own effort, and at its own risk, fought for the freedom of others. And this wasn’t just for neighboring states or nearby areas, but they even crossed oceans for this purpose, ensuring that no unjust power would exist anywhere on Earth, and that justice, rights, and laws would reign supreme everywhere. With a single proclamation from a herald, all the cities of Greece and Asia were set free. To have dreamed of this showed great daring; to have achieved it was a testament to unmatched courage and luck."

34

Quinctius and the ten ambassadors then gave audience to the embassies of the several kings, nations, and states. First of all, the ambassadors of king Antiochus were called. Their proceedings, here, were nearly the same as at Rome; a mere display of words unsupported by facts. But the answer given them was not ambiguous as formerly, during the uncertainty of affairs, and while Philip was unsubdued; for the king was required in express terms to evacuate the cities of Asia, which had been in possession either of Philip or Ptolemy; not to meddle with the free cities, or ever take arms against them, and to be in a state of peace and equality with all the cities of Greece wherever they might be. Above all it was insisted on, that he should neither come himself into Europe, nor transport an army thither. The king's ambassadors being dismissed, a general convention of the nations and states was immediately held; and the business was despatched with the greater expedition, because the resolutions of the ten ambassadors mentioned the several states by name. To the people of Orestis, a district of Macedonia, in consideration of their having been the first who came over from the side of the king, their own laws were granted. The Magnesians, Perrhaebians, and Dolopians were likewise declared free. To the nation of the Thessalians, besides the enjoyment of liberty, the Achaean part of Phthiotis was granted, excepting Phthiotian Thebes and Pharsalus. The Aetolians, demanding that Pharsalus and Leucas should be restored to them in conformity to the treaty, were referred to the senate: but the council united to these, by authority of a decree, Phocis and Locris, places which had formerly been annexed to them. Corinth, Triphylia, and Heraea, another city of Peloponnesus, were restored to the Achaeans. The ten ambassadors were inclined to give Oreum and Eretria to king Eumenes, son of Attalus; but Quinctius dissenting, the matter came under the determination of the senate, and the senate declared those cities free; adding to them Carystus. Lycus and Parthinia, Illyrian states, each of which had been under subjection to Philip, were given to Pleuratus. Amynander was ordered to retain possession of the forts, which he had taken from Philip during the war.

Quinctius and the ten ambassadors then listened to the representatives from various kings, nations, and states. First up were the ambassadors of King Antiochus. Their approach here was much like it was in Rome; just a show of words without any real backing. However, the response they received was clear, unlike before when things were uncertain, and while Philip was still a threat. The king was specifically told to withdraw from the cities in Asia that had been controlled by either Philip or Ptolemy, to stay out of the free cities and never use force against them, and to maintain peace and equality with all cities in Greece, no matter where they were. Most importantly, it was emphasized that he was not to come into Europe or bring an army there. After dismissing the king’s ambassadors, a general meeting of the nations and states was quickly held, and things moved faster since the ten ambassadors had specifically named the states in their resolutions. The people of Orestis, a region in Macedonia, were granted their own laws for being the first to switch sides from the king. The Magnesians, Perrhaebians, and Dolopians were also declared free. The Thessalians were given liberty along with the Achaean part of Phthiotis, except for Phthiotian Thebes and Pharsalus. The Aetolians, who asked for Pharsalus and Leucas to be returned to them as per the treaty, were sent to the senate. Additionally, Phocis and Locris, which had once been part of them, were included by a council decree. The Achaeans got back Corinth, Triphylia, and another city in Peloponnesus, Heraea. The ten ambassadors wanted to give Oreum and Eretria to King Eumenes, son of Attalus; but since Quinctius disagreed, the decision was left to the senate, which declared those cities free and added Carystus to them. Lycus and Parthinia, Illyrian states that had been under Philip's control, were given to Pleuratus. Amynander was instructed to keep the forts he had captured from Philip during the war.

35

When the convention broke up, the ten ambassadors, dividing the business among them, set out by different routes to give liberty to the several cities within their respective districts. Publius Lentulus went to Bargylii; Lucius Stertinius, to Hephaestia, Thasus, and the cities of Thrace; Publius Villius and Lucius Terentius to king Antiochus; and Cneius Cornelius to Philip. The last of these, after executing his commission with respect to smaller matters, asked Philip, whether he was disposed to listen to advice, not only useful but highly salutary. To which the king answered that he was, and would give him thanks besides, if he mentioned any thing conducive to his advantage. He then earnestly recommended to him, since he had obtained peace with the Romans, to send ambassadors to Rome to solicit their alliance and friendship; lest, in case of Antiochus pursuing any hostile measure, he might be suspected of having lain in wait and seized the opportunity of the times for reviving hostilities. This meeting with Philip was at Tempè in Thessaly; and on his answering that he would send ambassadors without delay, Cornelius proceeded to Thermopylae, where all the states of Greece are accustomed to meet in general assembly on certain stated days. This is called the Pylaic assembly. Here he admonished the Aetolians, in particular, constantly and firmly to cultivate the friendship of the Roman people; but some of the principal of these interrupted him with complaints, that the disposition of the Romans towards their nation was not the same since the victory, that it had been during the war; while others censured them with greater boldness, and in a reproachful manner asserted, that "without the aid of the Aetolians, the Romans could neither have conquered Philip, nor even have made good their passage into Greece." To such discourses the Roman forbore giving an answer, lest the matter might end in an altercation, and only said, that if they sent ambassadors to Rome, every thing that was reasonable would be granted to them. Accordingly, they passed a decree for such mission, agreeably to his direction.--In this manner was the war with Philip concluded.

When the convention ended, the ten ambassadors split up the tasks among themselves and took different routes to free the various cities in their areas. Publius Lentulus went to Bargylii; Lucius Stertinius headed to Hephaestia, Thasus, and the cities of Thrace; Publius Villius and Lucius Terentius went to King Antiochus; and Cneius Cornelius went to Philip. After addressing some smaller matters, Cornelius asked Philip if he was willing to listen to advice that was not just useful but also very beneficial. The king replied that he was and would be grateful if Cornelius suggested anything that could help him. Cornelius then strongly recommended that, since Philip had made peace with the Romans, he should send ambassadors to Rome to seek their alliance and friendship. This way, if Antiochus took any aggressive actions, Philip wouldn’t be blamed for having waited for the right moment to resume hostilities. Their meeting took place at Tempè in Thessaly, and when Philip agreed to send ambassadors immediately, Cornelius proceeded to Thermopylae, where all the Greek states typically gather for a general assembly on certain scheduled days. This assembly is known as the Pylaic assembly. Here, he urged the Aetolians in particular to continually and firmly maintain their friendship with the Roman people. However, some of their leaders interrupted him with complaints that the Romans had not treated their nation the same way after the victory as they had during the war. Others more boldly criticized them, asserting that "without the Aetolians' help, the Romans could not have conquered Philip or even crossed into Greece." Cornelius chose not to respond to such remarks to avoid an argument and simply said that if they sent ambassadors to Rome, everything reasonable would be granted to them. Consequently, they passed a decree for such a mission as he directed. This is how the war with Philip came to an end.

36

While these transactions passed in Greece, Macedonia, and Asia, a conspiracy among the slaves had well nigh made Etruria an hostile province. To examine into and suppress this, Manius Acilius the praetor, whose province was the administration of justice between natives and foreigners, was sent at the head of one of the two city legions. A number of them, who were by this time formed in a body, he reduced by force of arms, killing and taking many. Some, who had been the ringleaders of the conspiracy, he scourged with rods and then crucified; some he returned to their masters. The consuls repaired to their provinces. Just as Marcellus entered the frontiers of the Boians, and while his men were fatigued with marching the whole length of the day, and as he was pitching his camp on a rising ground, Corolam, a chieftain of the Boians, attacked him with a very numerous force, and slew three thousand of his men: several persons of distinction fell in that tumultuary engagement; amongst others, Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus and Marcus Junius Silanus, praefects of the allies; and Aulus Ogulnius and Publius Claudius, military tribunes in the second legion. The Romans, not withstanding, had courage enough to finish the fortification of their camp, and to defend it, in spite of an assault made on it by the enemy, elated by their success in the field. Marcellus remained for some time in the same post, until he could tend the wounded, and revive the spirits of his men after such a disheartening blow. The Boians, a nation remarkably impatient of delay, and quickly disgusted at a state of inaction, separated, and withdrew to their several forts and villages. Marcellus then, suddenly crossing the Po, led his legions into the territory of Comum, where the Insubrians, after rousing the people of the country to arms, lay encamped. The fierce Boian Gauls attacked him on his march, and they first onset was so vigorous, as to make a considerable impression on his van. On perceiving which, and fearing lest, if his men once gave way, they would be dislodged, he brought up a cohort of Marsians against the enemy, and ordered every troop of the Latin cavalry to charge them. The first and second charges of these having checked the enemy in their furious attack, the other troops in the Roman line, resuming courage, advanced briskly on the foe. The Gauls no longer maintained the contest, but turned their backs and fled in confusion. Valerius Antias relates, that in that battle above forty thousand men were killed, five hundred and seven military standards taken, with four hundred and thirty-two chariots, and a great number of gold chains, one of which, of great weight, Claudius says, was deposited as an offering to Jupiter, in his temple in the Capitol. The camp of the Gauls was taken and plundered the same day; and the town of Comum was reduced in a few days after. In a little time, twenty-eight forts came over to the consul. There is a doubt among writers, whether the consul led his legions first against the Boians, or against the Insubrians; so as to determine, whether the successful battle obliterated the disgrace of the defeat, or whether the victory obtained at Comum was tarnished by the disaster incurred among the Boii.

While these events unfolded in Greece, Macedonia, and Asia, a conspiracy among the slaves almost turned Etruria into an enemy territory. To investigate and put a stop to this, Manius Acilius, the praetor in charge of handling legal matters between locals and foreigners, was sent in command of one of the two city legions. He managed to subdue a group that had formed, using military force to kill and capture many of them. Some of the leaders of the conspiracy were whipped with rods and then crucified, while others were returned to their masters. The consuls went to their provinces. Just as Marcellus entered the borders of the Boians, and while his troops were exhausted from a full day of marching and as he was setting up camp on elevated ground, Corolam, a leader of the Boians, attacked him with a large force and killed three thousand of his men. Several notable individuals died in that chaotic battle, including Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus and Marcus Junius Silanus, praefects of the allies, as well as Aulus Ogulnius and Publius Claudius, military tribunes in the second legion. Nevertheless, the Romans had enough courage to complete the fortification of their camp and defend it despite an assault from the enemy, who were emboldened by their success in battle. Marcellus stayed in the same position for a while to care for the wounded and lift the spirits of his men after such a disheartening loss. The Boians, a people known for their impatience and quick frustration with inactivity, soon dispersed and returned to their forts and villages. Marcellus then quickly crossed the Po River and led his legions into the territory of Comum, where the Insubrians had assembled and rallied the locals to arms. The fierce Boian Gauls attacked him while he was marching, and their initial assault was so forceful that it made a significant impact on his front lines. Realizing that if his men faltered, they could be driven back, he sent in a cohort of Marsians to engage the enemy and ordered every troop of Latin cavalry to charge. After the first and second charges from these forces stalled the enemy’s furious assault, the other Roman troops regained their courage and moved forward against the foe. The Gauls could no longer sustain their fight and turned to flee in chaos. Valerius Antias reports that in that battle, over forty thousand men were killed, five hundred and seven military standards were captured, along with four hundred and thirty-two chariots and a large number of gold chains, one of which, very heavy, Claudius notes, was offered to Jupiter in his temple on the Capitol. The Gauls' camp was taken and looted the same day, and the town of Comum was captured just days later. Soon after, twenty-eight forts surrendered to the consul. Writers debate whether the consul first led his legions against the Boians or the Insubrians, in order to determine if the successful battle wiped out the shame of the earlier defeat or if the victory at Comum was overshadowed by the disaster faced among the Boii.

37

Soon after those matters had passed with such variety of fortune, Lucius Furius Purpureo, the other consul, came into the country of the Boians, through the Sappinian tribe. He proceeded almost to the fort of Mutilus, when, beginning to apprehend that he might be enclosed between the Boians and Ligurians, he marched back by the road by which he came; and, making a long circuit, through an open and therefore safe country, arrived at the camp of his colleague. After this junction of their forces, they overran the territory of the Boians, spreading devastation as far as the city of Felsina. This city, with the other fortresses, and almost all the Boians, excepting only the young men who kept arms in their hands for the sake of plunder, and had at that time withdrawn into remote woods, made submission. The army was then led away against the Ligurians. The Boians thought that the Romans, as they were supposed to be at a great distance, would be the more careless in keeping their army together, and thereby afford an opportunity of attacking them unawares: with this expectation, they followed them by secret paths through the forests. They did not overtake them: and therefore, passing the Po suddenly in ships, they ravaged all the country of the Laevans and Libuans; whence, as they were returning with the spoil of the country, they fell in with the Roman army on the borders of Liguria. A battle was begun with more speed, and with greater fury, than if the parties had met with their minds prepared, and at an appointed time and place. On this occasion it appeared to what degree of violence anger can stimulate men; for the Romans fought with such a desire of slaughter, rather than of victory, that they scarcely left one of the enemy to carry the news of their defeat. On account of these successes, when the letters of the consuls were brought to Rome, a supplication for three days was decreed. Soon after, Marcellus came to Rome, and had a triumph decreed him by an unanimous vote of the senate. He triumphed, while in office, over the Insubrians and Comans. The prospect of a triumph over the Boians he left to his colleague, because his own arms had been unfortunate in that country; those of his colleague, successful. Large quantities of spoils, taken from the enemy, were carried in the procession in captured chariots, and many military standards; also, three hundred and twenty thousand asses of brass,[23] two hundred and thirty-four thousand of silver denarii,[24] stamped with a chariot. Eighty asses[25] were bestowed on each foot soldier, and thrice that value on each horseman and centurion.

Soon after those events unfolded with such a mix of outcomes, Lucius Furius Purpureo, the other consul, entered the land of the Boians through the Sappinian tribe. He got almost to the fort of Mutilus when he started to worry that he might get trapped between the Boians and Ligurians, so he retraced his steps along the same road he had taken. Taking a longer route through open, safer terrain, he finally reached his colleague's camp. After they united their forces, they rampaged through the territory of the Boians, leaving destruction all the way to the city of Felsina. This city, along with other strongholds, and nearly all the Boians—except for the young men who were armed and had gone into remote woods for the sake of looting—surrendered. The army then set off against the Ligurians. The Boians figured that the Romans, thought to be far away, would be sloppier in managing their troops and would thus give them a chance to attack unexpectedly. With this hope, they tracked the Romans through hidden paths in the forests. However, they didn't catch up. Instead, they swiftly crossed the Po in ships and plundered all the land of the Laevans and Libuans. On their way back with the loot, they encountered the Roman army on the Ligurian border. A battle erupted with more speed and intensity than if both sides had met with their preparations in place. This showed just how much anger can drive people; the Romans fought with such a thirst for bloodshed rather than for victory that they barely left any enemies alive to report on their defeat. Because of these victories, when the consuls’ letters arrived in Rome, a three-day public thanksgiving was declared. Soon after, Marcellus returned to Rome and was granted a triumph by the unanimous decision of the senate. He celebrated a triumph while in office over the Insubrians and Comans. He left the opportunity for a triumph over the Boians for his colleague, since his own campaigns had not gone well in that region, while his colleague's had been successful. A large amount of spoils taken from the enemy were paraded in captured chariots, along with many military standards; also, three hundred and twenty thousand asses of brass,[23] two hundred and thirty-four thousand silver denarii,[24] stamped with a chariot. Each foot soldier received eighty asses[25], and each horseman and centurion got three times that amount.

38

During that year, king Antiochus, after having spent the winter at Ephesus, took measures for reducing, under his dominion, all the cities of Asia, which had formerly been members of the empire. As to the rest, being either situated in plains, or having neither walls, arms, nor men in whom they could confide, he supposed they would, without difficulty, receive the yoke. But Smyrna and Lampsacus openly asserted their independence: yet there was a danger that if what they claimed were conceded to these, the rest of the cities in Aetolia and Ionia would follow the example of Smyrna; and those on the Hellespont that of Lampsacus. Wherefore he sent an army from Ephesus to invest Smyrna; and ordered the troops, which were at Abydos, to leave there only a small garrison, and to go and lay siege to Lampsacus. Nor did he only alarm them by an exhibition of force. By sending ambassadors, to make gentle remonstrances, and reprove the rashness and obstinacy of their conduct, he endeavoured to give them hopes that they might soon obtain the object of their wishes; but not until it should appear clearly, both to themselves and to all the world, that they had gained their liberty through the kindness of the king, and not by any violent efforts of their own. In answer to which, they said, that "Antiochus ought neither to be surprised nor displeased, if they did not very patiently suffer the establishment of their liberty to be deferred to a distant period." He himself, with his fleet, set sail from Ephesus in the beginning of spring, and steered towards the Hellespont. His army he transported to Madytus, a city in the Chersonese, and there joined his land and sea forces together. The inhabitants having shut their gates, he surrounded the walls with his troops; and when he was just bringing up his machines to the walls, a capitulation was entered into. This diffused such fear through the inhabitants of Sestus and the other cities of the Chersonese, as induced them to submit. He then came, with the whole of his united forces, by land and sea, to Lysimachia; which finding deserted, and almost buried in ruins, (for the Thracians had, a few years before, taken, sacked, and burned it,) he conceived a wish to rebuild a city so celebrated, and so commodiously situated. Accordingly, extending his care to every object at once, he set about repairing the walls and houses, ransomed some of the Lysimachians who were in captivity, sought out and brought home others, who had fled and dispersed themselves through the Chersonese and Hellespontus, enrolled new colonists, whom he invited by prospects of advantages, and used every means to repeople it fully. At the same time, that all fear of the Thracians might be removed, he went, in person, with one half of the land forces, to lay waste the nearest provinces of Thrace; leaving the other half, and all the crews of the ships, employed in the repairs of the city.

During that year, King Antiochus, after spending the winter in Ephesus, took steps to bring all the cities of Asia that had previously been part of the empire under his control. As for the others, which were either located in plains or lacked walls, weapons, and trustworthy men, he believed they would easily submit. However, Smyrna and Lampsacus boldly declared their independence. He was concerned that if he allowed them to assert this claim, other cities in Aetolia and Ionia would follow Smyrna's lead, while those on the Hellespont might imitate Lampsacus. Therefore, he sent an army from Ephesus to surround Smyrna and instructed the troops at Abydos to leave only a small garrison and go to besiege Lampsacus. He didn't just intimidate them with military force; he also sent ambassadors to gently protest their actions and criticize their reckless stubbornness, trying to give them hope that they might soon achieve their desires, but only after it was clear to everyone that they had gained their freedom thanks to the king's kindness and not through their own violent efforts. In response, they remarked that "Antiochus shouldn't be surprised or upset if they weren't willing to patiently wait for their liberty to be granted at a distant time." He himself set sail from Ephesus at the beginning of spring, heading towards the Hellespont. He transported his army to Madytus, a city in the Chersonese, and combined his land and sea forces there. With the inhabitants having closed their gates, he surrounded the walls with his troops, and just as he was setting up his siege engines, they agreed to capitulate. This instilled such fear in the residents of Sestus and the other cities of the Chersonese that they also decided to surrender. He then brought all of his combined forces, both land and sea, to Lysimachia, which he found deserted and nearly in ruins, as the Thracians had captured, looted, and burned it a few years earlier. He felt compelled to rebuild such a renowned and strategically located city. Thus, he focused on multiple tasks at once, starting to repair the walls and houses, ransoming some of the Lysimachians who were in captivity, searching for and bringing back others who had fled and dispersed across the Chersonese and Hellespont, and enrolling new colonists by offering them attractive prospects, doing everything possible to fully repopulate it. At the same time, to eliminate any fear of the Thracians, he personally took half of the land forces to ravage the nearest Thracian provinces, leaving the other half and all the ship crews to work on the city’s repairs.

39

About this time Lucius Cornelius, who had been commissioned by the senate to accommodate the differences between the kings Antiochus and Ptolemy, stopped at Selymbria; and, of the ten ambassadors, Publius Lentulus from Bargylii, and Publius Villius and Lucius Terentius from Thasus, came to Lysimachia. Hither came, likewise, Lucius Cornelius from Selymbria, and a few days after Antiochus from Thrace. His first meeting with the ambassadors, and an invitation which he afterwards gave them, were friendly and hospitable; but when the business intrusted to them and the present state of Asia, came to be treated of, the minds of both parties were exasperated. The Romans did not scruple to declare, that every one of his proceedings, from the time when he set sail from Syria, was displeasing to the senate; and they required restitution to be made, to Ptolemy, of all the cities which had been under his dominion. "For, as to what related to the cities which had been in the possession of Philip, and which Antiochus, taking advantage of a season when Philip's attention was turned to the war with Rome, had seized into his own hands, it would surely be an intolerable hardship, if the Romans were to have undergone such toils and dangers, on land and sea, for so many years, and Antiochus to appropriate to himself the prizes of the war. But, though his coming into Asia might be passed over unnoticed by the Romans, as a matter not pertaining to them, yet when he proceeded so far as to pass over into Europe with all his land and naval forces, how much was this short of open war with the Romans? Doubtless, had he even passed into Italy, he would deny that intention. But the Romans would not wait to give him an opportunity of doing so."

Around this time, Lucius Cornelius, who had been tasked by the Senate to mediate the disputes between the kings Antiochus and Ptolemy, stopped in Selymbria. Among the ten ambassadors, Publius Lentulus from Bargylii, and Publius Villius and Lucius Terentius from Thasos, made their way to Lysimachia. Lucius Cornelius also arrived from Selymbria, and shortly after, Antiochus came from Thrace. His initial meeting with the ambassadors was friendly and welcoming, and he later extended an invitation to them. However, when the discussion turned to the mission they were assigned and the current situation in Asia, tensions flared between both sides. The Romans openly stated that everything Antiochus had done since he left Syria was unacceptable to the Senate, and they demanded that Ptolemy be given back all the cities that had been under his control. "As for the cities that had been under Philip's rule, which Antiochus seized while Philip was preoccupied with the war against Rome, it would certainly be an outrageous injustice if the Romans had endured such hardships and dangers, both on land and at sea, for so many years, only for Antiochus to claim the rewards of that conflict. Although the Romans might overlook his entry into Asia as a matter irrelevant to them, when he crossed over into Europe with his entire army and navy, how could this not be viewed as a declaration of war against the Romans? Certainly, if he had advanced into Italy, he would claim he had no such intention. But the Romans weren't going to wait to give him the chance to prove otherwise."

40

To this the king replied, that "he wondered how it was, that the Romans were in the habit of diligently inquiring what ought to be done by king Antiochus; but never considered how far they themselves ought to advance on land or sea. Asia was no concernment of the Romans, in any shape; nor had they any more right to inquire what Antiochus did in Asia, than Antiochus had to inquire what the Roman people did in Italy. With respect to Ptolemy, from whom they complained that cities had been taken, there was a friendly connexion subsisting between him and Ptolemy, and he was taking measures to effect speedily a connexion of affinity also; neither had he sought to acquire any spoils from the misfortunes of Philip, nor had he come into Europe against the Romans, but to recover the cities and lands of the Chersonese, which, having been the property of Lysimachus,[26] he considered as part of his own dominion; because, when Lysimachus was subdued, all things belonging to him became, by the right of conquest, the property of Seleucus. That, at times, when his predecessors were occupied by cares of different kinds, Ptolemy first, and afterwards Philip, usurping the rights of others, possessed themselves of several of these places, but who could doubt that the Chersonese and the nearest parts of Thrace belonged to Lysimachus? To restore these to their ancient state, was the intent of his coming, and to build Lysimachia anew, (it having been destroyed by an inroad of the Thracians,) in order that his son, Seleucus, might have it for the seat of his empire."

To this, the king replied that he was surprised how the Romans were always asking what king Antiochus should do, but never thought about how far they themselves should go on land or sea. Asia was not the Romans' concern at all; they had no more right to question what Antiochus was doing in Asia than Antiochus had to question what the Romans were doing in Italy. Regarding Ptolemy, from whom they complained that cities had been taken, there was a friendly relationship between him and Ptolemy, and he was working to establish a connection through marriage as well. He hadn't tried to benefit from Philip's misfortunes, nor had he come to Europe against the Romans, but rather to reclaim the cities and lands of the Chersonese, which had belonged to Lysimachus and he considered as part of his own territory. When Lysimachus was defeated, everything that belonged to him became, by the right of conquest, the property of Seleucus. Sometimes, when his predecessors were busy with various concerns, Ptolemy first, and later Philip, took control of several of these places, but who could doubt that the Chersonese and the nearby parts of Thrace belonged to Lysimachus? Restoring these to their original state was the purpose of his visit, and he intended to rebuild Lysimachia (which had been destroyed by a Thracian raid) so that his son, Seleucus, could have it as the center of his empire.

41

These disputes had been carried on for several days, when a rumour reached them, but without any sufficiently certain authority, that Ptolemy was dead; which prevented the conferences coming to any issue: for both parties made a secret of their having heard it; and Lucius Cornelius, who was charged with the embassy to the two kings, Antiochus and Ptolemy, requested to be allowed a short space of time, in which he could have a meeting with the latter; because he wished to arrive in Egypt before any change of measures should take place in consequence of the new succession to the crown: while Antiochus believed that Egypt would be his own, if at that time he should take possession of it. Wherefore, having dismissed the Romans, and left his son Seleucus, with the land forces, to finish the rebuilding of Lysimachia, as he had intended to do, he sailed, with his whole fleet, to Ephesus; sent ambassadors to Quinctius to treat with him about an alliance, assuring him that the king would attempt no innovations, and then, coasting along the shore of Asia, proceeded to Lycia. Having learned at Patarae that Ptolemy was living, he dropped the design of sailing to Egypt, but nevertheless steered towards Cyprus; and, when he had passed the promontory of Chelidonium, was detained some little time in Pamphylia, near the river Eurymedon, by a mutiny among his rowers. When he had sailed thence as far as the headlands, as they are called, of Sarus, such a dreadful storm arose as almost buried him and his whole fleet in the deep. Many ships were broken to pieces, and many cast on shore; many swallowed so entirely in the sea, that not one man of their crews escaped to land. Great numbers of his men perished on this occasion; not only persons of mean rank, rowers and soldiers, but even of his particular friends in high stations. When he had collected the relics of the general wreck, being in no capacity of making an attempt on Cyprus, he returned to Seleucia, with a far less numerous force than he had set out with. Here he ordered the ships to be hauled ashore, for the winter was now at hand, and proceeded to Antioch, where he intended to pass the winter.--In this posture stood the affairs of the kings.

These disputes had been going on for several days when a rumor reached them—though it wasn't confirmed—that Ptolemy was dead. This news stalled their discussions, as both sides kept it to themselves. Lucius Cornelius, who was sent to meet with the two kings, Antiochus and Ptolemy, asked for a little time to meet with Ptolemy since he wanted to reach Egypt before any new plans were put in place due to the change in leadership. Antiochus believed that if he acted quickly, Egypt would be his. After sending the Romans away and leaving his son Seleucus with the ground forces to continue rebuilding Lysimachia, he sailed with his entire fleet to Ephesus. There, he sent ambassadors to Quinctius to discuss an alliance, promising him that the king would not make any changes. Then, he sailed along the coast of Asia toward Lycia. At Patarae, he found out that Ptolemy was still alive, so he abandoned his plan to go to Egypt and instead headed for Cyprus. However, after passing the promontory of Chelidonium, he was temporarily delayed in Pamphylia near the Eurymedon River due to a mutiny among his rowers. Once he got sailing again, a terrifying storm hit near the headlands of Sarus, nearly drowning him and the entire fleet. Many ships were wrecked, some were washed ashore, and others sank completely with all crew members aboard. A significant number of his men were lost, including not just low-ranking rowers and soldiers but also some of his closest friends in high positions. After gathering what was left of the wreck, not being in a position to attempt Cyprus anymore, he returned to Seleucia with a much smaller force than he originally had. There, he ordered the ships to be pulled ashore since winter was approaching, and then he went to Antioch, where he planned to spend the winter. This is where the situation with the kings stood.

42

At Rome, in this year, for the first time, were created offices called triumviri epulones;[27] these were Caius Licinius Lucullus, who, as tribune, had proposed the law for their creation, Publius Manlius, and Publius Porcius Laeca. These triumvirs, as well as the pontiffs, were allowed by law the privilege of wearing the purple-bordered gown. The body of the pontiffs had this year a warm dispute with the city quaestors, Quintus Fabius Labeo and Lucius Aurelius. Money was wanted; an order having been passed for making the last payment to private persons of that which had been raised for the support of the war; and the quaestors demanded it from the augurs and pontiffs, because they had not contributed their share while the war subsisted. The priests in vain appealed to the tribunes; and the contribution was exacted for every year in which they had not paid. During the same year two pontiffs died, and others were substituted in their room: Marcus Marcellus, the consul, in the room of Caius Sempronius Tuditanus, who had been a praetor in Spain; and Lucius Valerius, in the room of Marcus Cornelius Cethegus. An augur also, Quintius Fabius Maximus, died very young, before he had attained to any public office; but no augur was appointed in his place during that year. The consular election was then held by the consul Marcellus. The persons chosen were, Lucius Valerius Flaccus and Marcus Porcius Cato. Then were elected praetors, Caius Fabricius Luscinus, Caius Atinius Labeo, Cneius Manlius Vulso, Appius Claudius Nero, Publius Manlius, and Publius Porcius Laeca. The curule aediles, Marcus Fulvius Nobilior and Caius Flaminius, made a distribution to the people of one million pecks of wheat, at the price of two asses. This corn the Sicilians had brought to Rome, out of respect to Caius Flaminius and his father; and he gave share of the credit to his colleague. The Roman games were solemnized with magnificence, and exhibited thrice entire. The plebeian aediles, Cneius Domitius Aenobarbus and Caius Scribonius, chief curio, brought many farmers of the public pastures to trial before the people. Three of these were convicted; and out of the money accruing from fines imposed on them, they built a temple of Faunus in the island. The plebeian games were exhibited for two days, and there was a feast on occasion of the games.

In Rome, in this year, for the first time, offices called triumviri epulones were established; these were Caius Licinius Lucullus, who, as tribune, had proposed the law for their creation, Publius Manlius, and Publius Porcius Laeca. These triumvirs, along with the pontiffs, were legally allowed to wear the purple-bordered gown. This year, the pontiffs had a heated dispute with the city quaestors, Quintus Fabius Labeo and Lucius Aurelius. They needed money; an order had been issued to make the final payment to private citizens from the funds raised to support the war, and the quaestors demanded it from the augurs and pontiffs because they had not contributed while the war was ongoing. The priests appealed in vain to the tribunes, and the contribution was enforced for every year in which they had not paid. During the same year, two pontiffs died, and others were appointed to take their places: Marcus Marcellus, the consul, replaced Caius Sempronius Tuditanus, who had been a praetor in Spain; and Lucius Valerius took the place of Marcus Cornelius Cethegus. An augur, Quintius Fabius Maximus, also died young before he could hold any public office; however, no augur was appointed to his position that year. The consular election was then held by consul Marcellus. The elected were Lucius Valerius Flaccus and Marcus Porcius Cato. Next, praetors were elected: Caius Fabricius Luscinus, Caius Atinius Labeo, Cneius Manlius Vulso, Appius Claudius Nero, Publius Manlius, and Publius Porcius Laeca. The curule aediles, Marcus Fulvius Nobilior and Caius Flaminius, distributed one million pecks of wheat to the people at the price of two asses. This grain was brought to Rome by the Sicilians in honor of Caius Flaminius and his father; he also shared the credit with his colleague. The Roman games were celebrated with great splendor and were held three times in full. The plebeian aediles, Cneius Domitius Aenobarbus and Caius Scribonius, chief curio, put many farmers of the public pastures on trial before the people. Three of these were convicted, and with the fines imposed on them, they constructed a temple of Faunus on the island. The plebeian games were celebrated for two days, and there was a feast in honor of the games.

43

Lucius Valerius Flaccus and Marcus Porcius, on the ides of March, the day of their entering into office, consulted the senate respecting the provinces; who resolved, that "whereas the war in Spain was grown so formidable, as to require a consular army and commander; it was their opinion, therefore, that the consuls should either settle between themselves, or cast lots, for Hither Spain and Italy as their provinces. That he to whom Spain fell should carry with him two legions, five thousand of the Latin confederates, and five hundred horse; together with a fleet of twenty ships of war. That the other consul should raise two legions; for these would be sufficient to maintain tranquillity in the province of Gaul, as the spirits of the Insubrians and Boians had been broken the year before." The lots gave Spain to Cato, and Italy to Valerius. The praetors then cast lots for their provinces: to Caius Fabricius Luscinus fell the city jurisdiction; Caius Atinius Labeo obtained the foreign; Cneius Manlius Vulso, Sicily; Appius Claudius Nero, Farther Spain; Publius Porcius Laeca, Pisa, in order that he might be at the back of the Ligurians; and Publius Manlius was sent into Hither Spain, as an assistant to the consul. Quinctius was continued in command for the year, as apprehensions were entertained, not only of Antiochus and the Aetolians, but likewise of Nabis, tyrant of Lacedaemon; and it was ordered that he should have two legions, for which, if there was any necessity for a further supply, the consuls were ordered to raise recruits, and send them into Macedonia. Appius Claudius was permitted to raise, in addition to the legion which Quintius Fabius had commanded, two thousand foot and two hundred horse. The like number of new-raised foot and horse was assigned to Publius Manlius for Hither Spain; and the legion was given to him which had been under the command of Minucius, the praetor. To Publius Porcius Laeca, for Etruria, near Pisa, were decreed two thousand foot and five hundred horse, out of the army in Gaul. Sempronius Longus was continued in command in Sardinia.

Lucius Valerius Flaccus and Marcus Porcius, on the Ides of March, the day they took office, consulted the Senate about the provinces. They decided that since the war in Spain had become serious enough to need a consular army and commander, it would be best for the consuls to either come to an agreement among themselves or draw lots for Hither Spain and Italy as their provinces. The consul who was assigned Spain would be required to take two legions, five thousand Latin allies, and five hundred cavalry, along with a fleet of twenty warships. The other consul would raise two legions, which would be enough to maintain order in the province of Gaul, as the spirits of the Insubrians and Boians had been broken the year before. The lots assigned Spain to Cato and Italy to Valerius. The praetors then drew lots for their provinces: Caius Fabricius Luscinus received the city jurisdiction; Caius Atinius Labeo got the foreign jurisdiction; Cneius Manlius Vulso was assigned Sicily; Appius Claudius Nero went to Farther Spain; Publius Porcius Laeca was sent to Pisa, so he could support the Ligurians; and Publius Manlius was sent to Hither Spain as an assistant to the consul. Quinctius was kept in command for the year due to concerns about not only Antiochus and the Aetolians but also Nabis, the tyrant of Lacedaemon. He was given two legions, and if further reinforcements were needed, the consuls were instructed to raise new recruits and send them to Macedonia. Appius Claudius was allowed to raise, in addition to the legion that Quintius Fabius had commanded, two thousand infantry and two hundred cavalry. The same number of newly raised infantry and cavalry was allocated to Publius Manlius for Hither Spain, and he was given the legion that had been under Minucius, the praetor. To Publius Porcius Laeca, for Etruria, near Pisa, two thousand infantry and five hundred cavalry were assigned from the army in Gaul. Sempronius Longus was kept in command in Sardinia.

44

The provinces being thus distributed, the consuls, before their departure from the city, were ordered, in accordance with a decree of the pontiffs, to proclaim a sacred spring, which Aulus Cornelius Mammula, praetor, had vowed in pursuance of a vote of the senate, and an order of the people, in the consulate of Cneius Servilius and Caius Flaminius. It was celebrated twenty-one years after the vow had been made. About the same time, Caius Claudius Pulcher, son of Appius, was chosen and inaugurated into the office of augur, in the room of Quintus Fabius Maximus, who died the year before. While people, in general, wondered that, though Spain had arisen in arms, they were neglecting the war, a letter was brought from Quintus Minucius, announcing "that he had fought a pitched battle with the Spanish generals, Budar and Besasis, near the town of Tura, and had gained the victory: that twelve thousand of the enemy were slain; their general, Budar, taken; and the rest routed and dispersed." After the reading of this letter less alarm prevailed with respect to Spain, where a very formidable war had been apprehended. The whole anxiety of the public was directed towards king Antiochus, especially after the arrival of the ten ambassadors. These, after relating the proceedings with Philip, and the conditions on which peace had been granted him, gave information, that "there still subsisted a war of no less magnitude to be waged with Antiochus; that he had come over into Europe with a very numerous fleet and a powerful army; that, had not a delusive prospect of an opportunity of invading Egypt, raised by a more delusive rumour, diverted him to another quarter, all Greece would have quickly been involved in the flames of war. Nor would even the Aetolians remain quiet, a race as well restless by nature as full of anger against the Romans. That, besides, there was another evil, of a most dangerous nature, lurking in the bowels of Greece: Nabis, tyrant at present of Lacedaemon, but who would soon if suffered, become tyrant of all Greece, equalling in avarice and cruelty all the tyrants most remarkable in history. For, if he were allowed to keep possession of Argos, which served as a citadel commanding the Peloponnesus, when the Roman armies should be brought home to Italy, Greece would have been in vain delivered out of bondage to Philip; because, instead of that king, who, supposing no other difference, resided at a distance, she would have for a master, a tyrant, close to her side."

The provinces being organized like this, the consuls, before leaving the city, were directed, following a decree from the priests, to announce a sacred spring. This spring had been vowed by Aulus Cornelius Mammula, the praetor, based on a vote from the senate and a decision from the people during the consulate of Cneius Servilius and Caius Flaminius. It took place twenty-one years after the vow was made. Around the same time, Caius Claudius Pulcher, son of Appius, was chosen and installed as an augur, replacing Quintus Fabius Maximus, who had died the previous year. While many were surprised that, despite Spain being in revolt, they were ignoring the war, a letter arrived from Quintus Minucius stating that he had fought a major battle with the Spanish generals, Budar and Besasis, near the town of Tura, and had won: twelve thousand of the enemy had been killed; their general, Budar, was captured; and the rest were defeated and scattered. After this letter was read, there was less concern about Spain, where a very serious war had been feared. The public's anxiety shifted entirely to King Antiochus, especially after the ten ambassadors arrived. They reported on the dealings with Philip and the terms of peace that had been granted to him, and mentioned that "there was still a significant war to be fought with Antiochus; that he had come to Europe with a large fleet and a powerful army; that, if a misleading sense of an opportunity to invade Egypt, sparked by a false rumor, hadn't turned him to another direction, all of Greece would have quickly been engulfed in war. Even the Aetolians, known for their restlessness and hostility toward the Romans, would not stay quiet. Furthermore, there was another serious threat brewing in Greece: Nabis, the current tyrant of Lacedaemon, who, if allowed, would soon become the tyrant of all Greece, matching the greed and cruelty of the most notorious tyrants in history. For if he was allowed to hold onto Argos, which served as a stronghold over the Peloponnesus, when the Roman armies returned to Italy, Greece would have been delivered from bondage to Philip in vain; because instead of a king, who was merely residing at a distance, she would end up with a tyrant right at her doorstep."

45

On this intelligence being received from men of such respectable authority, and who had, besides, examined into all the matters which were reported, the senate, although they deemed the business relating to Antiochus the more important, yet, as the king had, for some reason or other, gone home into Syria, they thought that the affair respecting the tyrant ought to be more promptly attended to. After debating, for a long time, whether they should judge the grounds which they had at present sufficient whereon a declaration of war should be decreed, or whether they should empower Titus Quinctius to act, in the case respecting Nabis the Lacedaemonian, in such manner as he should judge conducive to the public interest; they left it in his hands. For they thought the business of such a nature, that whether expedited or delayed, it could not very materially affect the general interest of the Roman people. It was deemed more important to endeavour to discover what line of conduct Hannibal and the Carthaginians would pursue, in case of a war breaking out with Antiochus. Persons of the faction which opposed Hannibal wrote continually to their several friends, among the principal men in Rome, that "messages and letters were sent by Hannibal to Antiochus, and that envoys came secretly from the king to him. That, as some wild beasts can never be tamed, so the disposition of this man was irreclaimable and implacable. That he sometimes complained, that the state was debilitated by ease and indolence, and lulled by sloth into a lethargy, from which nothing could rouse it but the sound of arms." These accounts were deemed probable, when people recollected the former war, which had not more been carried on than at first set on foot by the efforts of that single man. Besides, he had by a recent act provoked the resentment of many men in power.

Upon receiving intelligence from such respected authorities, who had also investigated all the reported matters, the Senate, although they considered the situation with Antiochus to be more important, decided that since the king had returned to Syria for some reason, they should prioritize the issue concerning the tyrant. After debating for a long time whether they had sufficient grounds to decree a declaration of war or to authorize Titus Quinctius to handle the situation regarding Nabis the Lacedaemonian in whatever way he deemed best for the public interest, they ultimately left it in his hands. They believed the matter was such that whether it was resolved quickly or delayed, it wouldn’t significantly impact the overall interest of the Roman people. They thought it was more important to find out what actions Hannibal and the Carthaginians would take if a war broke out with Antiochus. Opponents of Hannibal frequently wrote to their contacts among prominent figures in Rome, claiming that "messages and letters were sent by Hannibal to Antiochus, and that envoys were secretly sent from the king to him. Just as some wild animals can never be tamed, this man’s character was seen as unmanageable and relentless. He sometimes expressed concern that the state was weakened by comfort and laziness, lulled into lethargy that could only be stirred by the sound of arms." These accounts seemed credible to many, especially when they remembered the previous war, which had largely been initiated by the efforts of that one man. Additionally, he had recently angered many powerful individuals.

46

The order of judges possessed, at that time, absolute power in Carthage; and this was owing chiefly to their holding the office during life. The property, character, and life of every man was in their disposal. He who incurred the displeasure of one of that order, found an enemy in every one of them; nor were accusers wanting in a court where the justices were disposed to condemn. While they were in possession of this despotism, (for they did not exercise their exorbitant power constitutionally,) Hannibal was elected praetor and he summoned the quaestor before him. The quaestor disregarded the summons, for he was of the opposite faction; and besides, as the practice was that, after the quaestorship men were advanced into the order of judges, the most powerful of all, he already assumed a spirit suited to the powers which he was shortly to possess. Hannibal, highly offended Hereat, sent an officer to apprehend the quaestor; and, bringing him forth into an assembly of the people, he made heavy charges not against him alone, but on the whole order of judges; in consequence of whose arrogance and power neither the magistracy nor the laws availed any thing. Then perceiving that his discourse was with willing ears attended to, and that the conduct of those men was incompatible with the freedom of the lowest classes, he proposed a law, and procured it to be enacted, that the "judges should be elected annually; and that no person should hold the office two years successively." But, whatever degree of favour he acquired among the commons by this proceeding, he roused, in a great part of the nobility, an equal degree of resentment. To this he added another act, which, while it was for the advantage of the people, provoked personal enmity against himself. The public revenues were partly wasted through neglect, partly embezzled, and divided among some leading men and magistrates; insomuch, that there was not money sufficient for the regular annual payment of the tribute to the Romans, so that private persons seemed to be threatened with a heavy tax.

The judges in Carthage had complete power at that time, mainly because they held their positions for life. They had control over every person's property, character, and life. Anyone who displeased one of them found themselves with enemies among all of them, and there were always accusers in a court where the judges were ready to condemn. While they wielded this level of control (as they did not exercise their excessive power according to any constitution), Hannibal was elected praetor and summoned the quaestor to appear before him. The quaestor ignored the summons because he was part of the opposing faction, and since it was common for men to be promoted to the judges' order after serving as quaestors, he was already acting like someone with significant power. Hannibal, very offended by this, sent an officer to arrest the quaestor and brought him before an assembly of the people, making serious accusations not just against him but against the entire order of judges. He pointed out that due to their arrogance and power, neither the magistrates nor the laws had any real effect. Noticing that his words were well-received and that the behavior of the judges conflicted with the freedoms of the lower classes, he proposed a law that required judges to be elected every year and that no one could hold the office for two consecutive years. While this move gained him support among the common people, it also stirred up equal resentment among many of the nobility. He followed this with another action that, while benefiting the people, also earned him personal hatred. Public funds were often wasted due to neglect or embezzled and shared among some influential figures and magistrates, to the point where there wasn’t enough money for the regular annual tribute to the Romans, and private citizens felt they were facing a heavy tax burden.

47

When Hannibal had informed himself of the amount of the revenues arising from taxes and port duties, for what purposes they were issued from the treasury, what proportion of them was consumed by the ordinary expenses of the state, and how much was alienated by embezzlement; he asserted in an assembly of the people, that if payment were enforced of the residuary funds, the taxes might be remitted to the subjects; and that the state would still be rich enough to pay the tribute to the Romans: which assertion he proved to be true. But now those persons who, for several years past, had maintained themselves by plundering the public, were greatly enraged; as if this were ravishing from them their own property, and not as dragging out of their hands their ill-gotten spoil. Accordingly, they instigated the Romans against Hannibal, who were seeking a pretext for indulging their hatred against him. A strenuous opposition was, however, for a long time made to this by Scipio Africanus, who thought it highly unbecoming the dignity of the Roman people to make themselves a party in the animosities and charges against Hannibal; to interpose the public authority among factions of the Carthaginians, not deeming it sufficient to have conquered that commander in the field, but to become as it were his prosecutors[28] in a judicial process, and preferring an action against him. Yet at length the point was carried, that an embassy should be sent to Carthage to represent to the senate there, that Hannibal, in concert with king Antiochus, was forming plans for kindling a war. Three ambassadors were sent, Caius Servilius, Marcus Claudius Marcellus, and Quintus Terentius Culleo. These, when they had arrived at Carthage, by the advice of Hannibal's enemies, ordered, that any who inquired the cause of their coming should be told, that they came to determine the disputes subsisting between the Carthaginians and Masinissa, king of Numidia; and this was generally believed. But Hannibal was not ignorant that he was the sole object aimed at by the Romans; and that, though they had granted peace to the Carthaginians, their war against him, individually, remained irreconcilable. He therefore determined to give way to fortune and the times; and having already made every preparation for flight, he showed himself that day in the forum, in order to guard against suspicion; and, as soon as it grew dark, went in his common dress to one of the gates, with his two attendants, who knew nothing of his intention.

When Hannibal had learned how much money was coming in from taxes and port fees, for what purposes the treasury was spending it, what portion was being used for regular state expenses, and how much was lost to theft, he claimed in a public assembly that if the leftover funds were collected, taxes could be reduced for the citizens, and the state would still have enough money to pay the tribute to the Romans. He proved this to be true. However, those individuals who had been profiting from the public for several years were furious, as if their own property was being stripped away rather than their ill-gotten gains. They stirred up the Romans, who were looking for a reason to act on their hatred of Hannibal. For a long time, there was strong opposition to this from Scipio Africanus, who believed it was beneath the dignity of the Roman people to get involved in the grievances and accusations against Hannibal; to insert public authority into the conflicts among the Carthaginians, feeling it was not enough to have defeated Hannibal on the battlefield but to also act as his accusers in a trial. Ultimately, however, the decision was made to send a delegation to Carthage to inform the senate there that Hannibal, in concert with King Antiochus, was planning to start a war. Three ambassadors were dispatched: Caius Servilius, Marcus Claudius Marcellus, and Quintus Terentius Culleo. Upon arriving in Carthage, at the suggestion of Hannibal's enemies, they instructed that anyone who asked about the purpose of their visit should be told that they were there to mediate the disputes between the Carthaginians and Masinissa, king of Numidia; and this was widely accepted. But Hannibal knew that he was the true target of the Romans; and even though they had granted peace to the Carthaginians, their war against him remained unyielding. He decided to adapt to the circumstances and time; having already made all necessary arrangements for escape, he appeared that day in the forum to avoid raising suspicion, and as soon as night fell, he left in his ordinary clothes through one of the gates, accompanied by two attendants who were unaware of his plan.

48

Finding horses in readiness at a spot where he had ordered, he traversed by night a district which the Africans denominated Byzacium, and arrived, in the morning of the following day, at a castle of his own between Acholla and Thapsus. There a ship, ready fitted out and furnished with rowers, took him on board. In this manner did Hannibal leave Africa, lamenting the misfortunes of his country oftener than his own. He sailed over, the same day, to the island of Cercina, where he found in the port a number of merchant ships, belonging to the Phoenicians, with their cargoes; and on landing was surrounded by a concourse of people, who came to pay their respects to him; on which he gave orders that, in answer to any inquiries, it should be said that he had been sent as ambassador to Tyre. Fearing, however, lest some of these ships might sail in the night to Thapsus or Adrumetum, and carry information of his having been seen at Cercina, he ordered a sacrifice to be prepared, and the masters of the ships, with the merchants, to be invited to the entertainment, and that the sails and yards should be collected out of the ships to form a shade on shore for the company at supper, as it happened to be the middle of summer. The feast of the day was as sumptuous, and well attended, as the time and circumstances allowed; and the entertainment was prolonged, with plenty of wine, until late in the night. As soon as Hannibal saw an opportunity of escaping the notice of those who were in the harbour, he set sail. The rest were fast asleep, nor was it early, next day, when they arose from their sleep, full of the illness of intoxication; and then, when it was too late, they set about replacing the sails in the ships, and fitting up the rigging, which employed several hours. At Carthage, those who were accustomed to visit Hannibal met in a crowd, at the porch of his house; and when it was publicly known that he was not to be found, the whole multitude assembled in the forum, eager to gain intelligence of the man who was considered as the first in the state. Some surmised that he had fled, as the case was; others, that he had been put to death through the treachery of the Romans; and there was visible in the expression of their countenances, that variety which might naturally be expected in a state divided into factions, whereof each supported a different interest. At length intelligence was brought, that he had been seen at Cercina.

Finding horses waiting at a place he had specified, he traveled at night through an area that the Africans called Byzacium, and reached, by the next morning, a castle of his own situated between Acholla and Thapsus. There, a ship, fully prepared and manned with rowers, took him aboard. In this way, Hannibal left Africa, mourning the misfortunes of his country more than his own. He sailed the same day to the island of Cercina, where he found several merchant ships at the port, owned by the Phoenicians, filled with goods; upon landing, he was surrounded by a crowd of people coming to pay their respects. He instructed that, in response to any questions, it be said he had been sent as an ambassador to Tyre. However, fearing that some of these ships might leave at night for Thapsus or Adrumetum and report his presence at Cercina, he ordered a sacrifice to be prepared and invited the ship captains and merchants to the feast. He also had the sails and yards taken down from the ships to create shade on the beach for the dinner, as it was the middle of summer. The feast was as lavish and well-attended as the season and circumstances allowed, and the celebration continued with plenty of wine until late into the night. As soon as Hannibal found a chance to escape the attention of those in the harbor, he set sail. The rest were fast asleep, and it wasn't until late the next morning that they woke up, suffering from the effects of drinking too much; then, when it was too late, they began to put the sails back on the ships and rig the lines, which took several hours. In Carthage, those who usually visited Hannibal gathered in a crowd at the entrance of his house; when it became public knowledge that he was missing, the entire crowd assembled in the forum, eager to learn about the man considered the foremost in the state. Some speculated that he had fled, as was the case; others believed he had been executed through Roman treachery; and it was clear from their expressions that a range of emotions, typical of a state divided by factions with differing interests, was present. Eventually, news arrived that he had been seen at Cercina.

49

The Roman ambassadors represented to the council, that "proof had been laid before the senate at Rome, that formerly king Philip had been moved, principally by the instigation of Hannibal, to make war on the Roman people; and that lately, Hannibal had, besides, sent letters and messages to king Antiochus, that he had entered into plans for driving Carthage to revolt, and that he had now gone no whither but to king Antiochus. That he was a man who would never be content, until he had excited war in every part of the globe. That such conduct ought not to be suffered to pass with impunity, if the Carthaginians wished to convince the Roman people that none of those things were done with their consent, or with the approbation of the state." The Carthaginians answered, that they were ready to do whatever the Romans required them.

The Roman ambassadors told the council that "evidence had been presented to the Senate in Rome, showing that King Philip had, primarily due to Hannibal's influence, waged war against the Roman people in the past; and recently, Hannibal had also sent letters and messages to King Antiochus, revealing his plans to incite a rebellion in Carthage, and that he had now gone only to King Antiochus. He was someone who would never be satisfied until he had sparked conflict in every corner of the world. Such behavior should not go unpunished if the Carthaginians wanted to prove to the Roman people that none of this was done with their approval or the state's consent." The Carthaginians responded that they were willing to do whatever the Romans asked of them.

Hannibal, after a prosperous voyage, arrived at Tyre; where, as a man illustrated by every description of honours, he was received by those founders of Carthage, as if in a second native country, and here he staid a few days. He then sailed to Antioch; where, hearing that the king had already left the place, he procured an interview with his son, who was celebrating the solemnity of the games at Daphne, and who treated him with much kindness; after which, he set sail without delay. At Ephesus, he overtook the king, who was still hesitating in his mind, and undetermined respecting a war with Rome: but the arrival of Hannibal proved an incentive of no small efficacy to the prosecution of that design. At the same time, the inclinations of the Aetolians also were alienated from the Roman alliance in consequence of the senate having referred to Quinctius their ambassadors, who demanded Pharsalus and Leucas, and some other cities, in conformity with the first treaty.

Hannibal, after a successful journey, arrived in Tyre; where, celebrated and honored, he was welcomed by the founders of Carthage as if he were in a second homeland, and he stayed there for a few days. He then sailed to Antioch; where, learning that the king had already left, he arranged to meet with his son, who was celebrating the games at Daphne and treated him very kindly; afterward, he set sail without delay. In Ephesus, he caught up with the king, who was still uncertain and undecided about going to war with Rome: but Hannibal's arrival strongly encouraged the pursuit of that plan. Meanwhile, the Aetolians were also drifting away from their alliance with Rome because the senate referred their ambassadors to Quinctius, who requested Pharsalus and Leucas, along with some other cities, in line with the initial treaty.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXXIV.


The Oppian law, respecting the dress of the women, after much debate, repealed, notwithstanding it was strenuously supported by Marcus Porcius Cato, the consul. The consul's successes in Spain. Titus Quinctius Flamininus finishes the war with the Lacedaemonians and the tyrant Nabis; makes peace with them, and restores liberty to Argos. Separate seats at the public games, for the first time, appointed for the senator. Colonies sent forth. Marcus Porcius Cato triumphs on account of his successes in Spain. Further successes in Spain against the Boians and Insubrian Gauls. Titus Quinctius Flamininus, having subdued Philip, king of Macedonia, and Nabis, the Lacedaemonian tyrant, and restored all Greece to freedom, triumphs for three days. Carthaginian ambassadors bring intelligence of the hostile designs of Antiochus and Hannibal.

       *        *        *        *        *

1

Amid the serious concerns of important wars, either scarcely brought to a close or impending, an incident intervened, trivial indeed to be mentioned, but which, through the zeal of the parties concerned, issued in a violent contest. Marcus Fundanius and Lucius Valerius, plebeian tribunes, proposed to the people the repealing of the Oppian law. This law, which had been introduced by Caius Oppias, plebeian tribune, in the consulate of Quintus Fabius and Tiberius Sempronius, during the heat of the Punic war, enacted that "no woman should possess more than half an ounce of gold, or wear a garment of various colours, or ride in a carriage drawn by horses, in a city, or any town, or any place nearer thereto than one mile; except on occasion of some public religious solemnity." Marcus and Publius Junius Brutus, plebeian tribunes, supported the Oppian law, and declared, that they would never suffer it to be repealed; while many of the nobility stood forth to argue for and against the motion proposed. The Capitol was filled with crowds, who favoured or opposed the law; nor could the matrons be kept at home, either by advice or shame, nor even by the commands of their husbands; but beset every street and pass in the city, beseeching the men as they went down to the forum, that in the present flourishing state of the commonwealth, when the private fortune of all was daily increasing they would suffer the women to have their former ornaments of dress restored. This throng of women increased daily, for they arrived even from the country towns and villages; and they had at length the boldness to come up to the consuls, praetors, and magistrates, to urge their request. One of the consuls, however, they found especially inexorable--Marcus Porcius Cato, who, in support of the law proposed to be repealed, spoke to this effect:--

Amid the serious concerns of major wars, either barely coming to an end or looming on the horizon, a minor incident happened that, while seemingly trivial, escalated into a major conflict due to the passion of those involved. Marcus Fundanius and Lucius Valerius, plebeian tribunes, put forth a proposal to the people to overturn the Oppian law. This law, introduced by Caius Oppius, a plebeian tribune, during the consulate of Quintus Fabius and Tiberius Sempronius, in the midst of the Punic War, stipulated that "no woman should own more than half an ounce of gold, wear a multicolored garment, or ride in a horse-drawn carriage in the city, or any town, or anywhere within a mile's distance; except on the occasion of certain public religious events." Marcus and Publius Junius Brutus, also plebeian tribunes, supported the Oppian law and vowed never to allow its repeal; meanwhile, many members of the nobility debated for and against the proposal. The Capitol was packed with crowds, eagerly supporting or opposing the law; even the matronly women could not be kept at home by advice, shame, or even their husbands' commands, as they filled every street and corner in the city, pleading with the men as they headed to the forum that, given the current prosperity of the republic, when everyone's private wealth was steadily increasing, they should allow women to reclaim their former adornments. This gathering of women grew day by day, as they came even from the rural towns and villages; eventually, they boldly approached the consuls, praetors, and magistrates to advocate for their request. However, one of the consuls was particularly unyielding—Marcus Porcius Cato, who, in defense of the law in question, spoke along these lines:

2

"If, Romans, every individual among us had made it a rule to maintain the prerogative and authority of a husband with respect to his own wife, we should have less trouble with the whole sex. But now, our privileges, overpowered at home by female contumacy, are, even here in the forum, spurned and trodden under foot; and because we are unable to withstand each separately, we now dread their collective body. I was accustomed to think it a fabulous and fictitious tale, that, in a certain island, the whole race of males was utterly extirpated by a conspiracy of the women. But the utmost danger may be apprehended equally from either sex, if you suffer cabals, assemblies, and secret consultations to be held: scarcely, indeed, can I determine, in my own mind, whether the act itself, or the precedent that it affords, is of more pernicious tendency. The latter of these more particularly concerns us consuls, and the other magistrates: the former, yourselves, my fellow-citizens. For, whether the measure proposed to your consideration be profitable to the state or not, is to be determined by you, who are about to go to the vote. As to the outrageous behaviour of these women, whether it be merely an act of their own, or owing to your instigations, Marcus Fundanius and Lucius Valerius, it unquestionably implies culpable conduct in magistrates. I know not whether it reflects greater disgrace on you, tribunes, or on the consuls: on you certainly, if you have, on the present occasion, brought these women hither for the purpose of raising tribunitian seditions; on us, if we suffer laws to be imposed on us by a secession of women, as was done formerly by that of the common people. It was not without painful emotions of shame, that I, just now, made my way into the forum through the midst of a band of women. Had I not been restrained by respect for the modesty and dignity of some individuals among them, rather than of the whole number, and been unwilling that they should be seen rebuked by a consul, I should have said to them, 'What sort of practice is this, of running out into public, besetting the streets, and addressing other women's husbands? Could not each have made the same request to her husband at home? Are your blandishments more seducing in public than in private; and with other women's husbands, than with your own? Although if the modesty of matrons confined them within the limits of their own rights, it did not become you, even at home, to concern yourselves about what laws might be passed or repealed here.' Our ancestors thought it not proper that women should perform any, even private business, without a director; but that they should be ever under the control of parents, brothers, or husbands. We, it seems, suffer them, now, to interfere in the management of state affairs, and to introduce themselves into the forum, into general assemblies, and into assemblies of election. For, what are they doing, at this moment, in your streets and lanes? What, but arguing, some in support of the motion of the plebeian tribunes; others, for the repeal of the law? Will you give the reins to their intractable nature, and their uncontrolled passions, and then expect that themselves should set bounds to their licentiousness, when you have failed to do so? This is the smallest of the injunctions laid on them by usage or the laws, all which women bear with impatience: they long for liberty; or rather, to speak the truth, for unbounded freedom in every particular. For what will they not attempt, if they now come off victorious?

"If, Romans, everyone among us had made it a rule to uphold the rights and authority of a husband over his wife, we would have much less trouble with the entire gender. But now, our privileges, overwhelmed at home by women's defiance, are even here in the forum disregarded and trampled upon; and because we cannot stand firm individually, we now fear their united front. I used to think it was a mythical tale that, in a certain island, all the men were completely wiped out by a conspiracy of women. But the greatest danger can come equally from either gender if you allow clubs, meetings, and secret discussions to happen: I can hardly decide, myself, whether the act itself, or the precedent it sets, is more harmful. The latter especially concerns us consuls and other officials; the former, you, my fellow citizens. Because, whether the measure being proposed to you is good for the state or not, is something you will determine when you vote. Regarding the outrageous behavior of these women, whether it is solely their own doing, or influenced by you, Marcus Fundanius and Lucius Valerius, it undeniably reflects poorly on the magistrates. I am not sure whether it brings more shame to you, tribunes, or to the consuls: certainly to you if you have, on this occasion, brought these women here to incite tribunes' insurrections; to us if we allow laws to be dictated to us by a crowd of women, as was done before by the common people. It was with a heavy heart that I just made my way into the forum through a throng of women. If I hadn’t held back out of respect for the modesty and dignity of some individuals among them, rather than the group as a whole, I would have told them, 'What is this practice of rushing into public, crowding the streets, and talking to other women’s husbands? Couldn’t each woman have made the same request of her husband at home? Are your charms more enticing in public than in private, and with other women’s husbands rather than your own? And even if the modesty of women kept them within the bounds of their own rights, it was still not proper for you to concern yourselves about what laws might be made or undone here, even at home.' Our ancestors thought it inappropriate for women to carry out even private business without supervision; they believed they should always be under the authority of their fathers, brothers, or husbands. It seems we now tolerate them meddling in state matters and inserting themselves into the forum, general gatherings, and election meetings. Because, what are they doing right now in your streets and alleys? Only arguing, some in favor of the plebeian tribunes' motion; others, against the repeal of the law? Will you give free rein to their rebellious nature and uncontrolled emotions, and then expect them to set limits on their own misconduct when you haven’t done so? This is the least of the restrictions placed on them by tradition or law, all of which women bear impatiently: they yearn for freedom; or rather, to be truthful, for complete freedom in everything. Because what will they not try to achieve if they come out of this victorious?"

3

"Recollect all the institutions respecting the sex, by which our forefathers restrained their undue freedom, and by which they subjected them to their husbands; and yet, even with the help of all these restrictions, you can scarcely keep them within bounds. If, then, you suffer them to throw these off one by one, to tear them all asunder, and, at last, to be set on an equal footing with yourselves, can you imagine that they will be any longer tolerable by you? The moment they have arrived at an equality with you, they will have become your superiors. But, forsooth, they only object to any new law being made against them: they mean to deprecate, not justice, but severity. Nay, their wish is, that a law which you have admitted, established by your suffrages, and confirmed by the practice and experience of so many years to be beneficial, should now be repealed; that is, that, by abolishing one law, you should weaken all the rest. No law perfectly suits the convenience of every member of the community: the only consideration is, whether, upon the whole, it be profitable to the greater part. If because a law proves obnoxious to a private individual, that circumstance should destroy and sweep it away, to what purpose is it for the community to enact general laws, which those, with reference to whom they were passed, could presently repeal? I should like, however, to hear what this important affair is which has induced the matrons thus to run out into public in this excited manner, scarcely restraining from pushing into the forum and the assembly of the people. Is it to solicit that their parents, their husbands, children, and brothers may be ransomed from captivity under Hannibal? By no means: and far be ever from the commonwealth so unfortunate a situation. Yet, even when such was the case, you refused this to their prayers. But it is not duty, nor solicitude for their friends; it is religion that has collected them together. They are about to receive the Idaean Mother, coming out of Phrygia from Pessinus! What motive, that even common decency will allow to be mentioned, is pretended for this female insurrection? Why, say they, that we may shine in gold and purple; that, both on festal and common days, we may ride through the city in our chariots, triumphing over vanquished and abrogated law, after having captured and wrested from you your suffrages; and that there may be no bounds to our expenses and our luxury.

"Remember all the rules about women that our ancestors put in place to limit their freedom and make them dependent on their husbands; and still, even with all those restrictions, it's hard to keep them in check. If you let them shake these off one by one, completely break them apart, and eventually stand on equal ground with you, can you honestly believe that they will still be acceptable to you? The moment they reach equality with you, they will become your superiors. Yet, they claim they just oppose any new laws against them: they want to discourage not justice, but harshness. Indeed, their goal is to have a law that you accepted, approved by your votes, and confirmed as beneficial by years of practice, now be repealed; in other words, by eliminating one law, you should weaken all the others. No law perfectly fits everyone's needs in the community: the main concern is whether it is beneficial to the majority. If one person's dislike of a law can dismantle it, what’s the point of creating general laws that can be overturned by those for whom they were enacted? I am curious to know what significant issue has caused these women to rush publicly in such an agitated manner, barely holding back from barging into the forum and the people's assembly. Is it to ask that their parents, husbands, children, and brothers be rescued from captivity under Hannibal? Absolutely not; may such an unfortunate situation never befall the state. Even when that was the case, you denied their requests. But it’s not duty or worry for their friends bringing them together; it is religion. They are here to welcome the Idaean Mother coming from Phrygia, from Pessinus! What reason, that even the most basic decency would allow to be mentioned, is claimed for this women's uprising? They say it is so we can wear gold and purple; so that, on both festive and ordinary days, we can parade through the city in our chariots, celebrating over defeated and discarded laws, having taken your votes by force, and so that there are no limits to our spending and luxury."

4

"Often have you heard me complain of the profuse expenses of the women--often of those of the men; and that not only of men in private stations, but of the magistrates: and that the state was endangered by two opposite vices, luxury and avarice; those pests, which have been the ruin of all great empires. These I dread the more, as the circumstances of the commonwealth grow daily more prosperous and happy; as the empire increases; as we have now passed over into Greece and Asia, places abounding with every kind of temptation that can inflame the passions; and as we have begun to handle even royal treasures: so much the more do I fear that these matters will bring us into captivity, rather than we them. Believe me, those statues from Syracuse were brought into this city with hostile effect. I already hear too many commending and admiring the decorations of Athens and Corinth, and ridiculing the earthen images of our Roman gods that stand on the fronts of their temples. For my part I prefer these gods,--propitious as they are, and I hope will continue to be, if we allow them to remain in their own mansions. In the memory of our fathers, Pyrrhus, by his ambassador Cineas, made trial of the dispositions, not only of our men, but of our women also, by offers of presents: at that time the Oppian law, for restraining female luxury, had not been made; and yet not one woman accepted a present. What, think you, was the reason? That for which our ancestors made no provision by law on this subject: there was no luxury existing which needed to be restrained. As diseases must necessarily be known before their remedies, so passions come into being before the laws which prescribe limits to them. What called forth the Licinian law, restricting estates to five hundred acres, but the unbounded desire for enlarging estates? What the Cincian law, concerning gifts and presents, but that the plebeians[29] had become vassals and tributaries to the senate? It is not therefore in any degree surprising, that no want of the Oppian law, or of any other, to limit the expenses of the women, was felt at that time, when they refused to receive gold and purple that was thrown in their way, and offered to their acceptance. If Cineas were now to go round the city with his presents, he would find numbers of women standing in the public streets to receive them. There are some passions, the causes or motives of which I can no way account for. For that that should not be lawful for you which is permitted to another, may perhaps naturally excite some degree of shame or indignation; yet, when the dress of all is alike, why should any one of you fear, lest she should not be an object of observation? Of all kinds of shame, the worst, surely, is the being ashamed of frugality or of poverty; but the law relieves you with regard to both; since that which you have not it is unlawful for you to possess. This equalization, says the rich matron, is the very thing that I cannot endure. Why do not I make a figure, distinguished with gold and purple? Why is the poverty of others concealed under this cover of a law, so that it should be thought that, if the law permitted, they would have such things as they are not now able to procure? Romans, do you wish to excite among your wives an emulation of this sort, that the rich should wish to have what no other can have; and that the poor, lest they should be despised as such should extend their expenses beyond their means? Be assured, that when a woman once begins to be ashamed of what she ought not to be ashamed of, she will not be ashamed of what she ought. She who can, will purchase out of her own purse; she who cannot, will ask her husband. Unhappy is the husband, both he who complies with the request, and he who does not; for what he will not give himself, he will see given by another. Now, they openly solicit favours from other women's husbands; and, what is more, solicit a law and votes. From some they obtain them; although, with regard to yourself, your property, or your children, they would be inexorable. So soon as the law shall cease to limit the expenses of your wife, you yourself will never be able to do so. Do not suppose that the matter will hereafter be in the same state in which it was before the law was made on the subject. It is safer that a wicked man should even never be accused, than that he should be acquitted; and luxury, if it had never been meddled with, would be more tolerable than it will be, now, like a wild beast, irritated by having been chained, and then let loose. My opinion is, that the Oppian law ought, on no account, to be repealed. Whatever determination you may come to, I pray all the gods to prosper it."

"Often, you've heard me complain about the excessive spending of women— and sometimes of men too; not just of men in private life, but also of magistrates. The state is threatened by two opposing vices: luxury and greed—these nuisances that have caused the downfall of all great empires. I fear these even more as the conditions of our state become increasingly prosperous and happy; as the empire grows; as we have now moved into Greece and Asia, places filled with all sorts of temptations that can ignite our desires; and as we start to handle even royal treasures. I fear even more that these things will lead us into captivity, rather than the other way around. Believe me, the statues from Syracuse were brought into this city with harmful intent. I already hear too many people praising and admiring the decor of Athens and Corinth, while mocking the plain images of our Roman gods that stand at the entrances of their temples. Personally, I prefer these gods—blessed as they are, and I hope they will continue to be, as long as we let them stay in their own homes. In the memory of our ancestors, Pyrrhus, through his messenger Cineas, tested both our men and our women with offers of gifts: at that time, the Oppian law, which limited women's luxury, had not yet been passed; and yet, not one woman accepted a gift. What, do you think, was the reason? It was because our ancestors did not see a need for laws on this topic: there was no luxury that needed to be controlled. Just as diseases must be recognized before their remedies are found, passions arise before laws that set boundaries for them. What brought about the Licinian law, limiting property to five hundred acres, if not the limitless desire for more land? What about the Cincian law regarding gifts and presents, but the fact that the common people had become subservient and taxed by the senate? So, it is not surprising that there was no perceived need for the Oppian law, or any other to curb women's spending, when they refused to accept gold and luxury that was offered to them. If Cineas were to walk around the city now with his gifts, he would find many women in the streets eager to receive them. There are some desires that I can't explain. The idea that you can't have what others can may naturally cause some shame or anger; yet, when everyone dresses alike, why should any of you worry about standing out? Of all types of shame, surely the worst is feeling embarrassed about being frugal or poor; but the law eases your mind about both, since it’s illegal for you to possess what you don't have. This equalization, says the wealthy woman, is precisely what I cannot stand. Why can't I stand out in gold and purple? Why is others' poverty hidden behind this law, which suggests that if the law allowed, they would wear what they cannot currently afford? Romans, do you want to encourage competition among your wives, so that the rich desire what no one else can have; and the poor, to avoid being looked down upon, increase their spending beyond their means? Be sure, when a woman starts feeling ashamed of what she shouldn't, she won't be ashamed of what she should. The woman who can will buy for herself; the one who can't will ask her husband. A husband is unfortunate, whether he agrees to the request or not; because what he won't give, he will see given by another. Now they openly seek favors from other women’s husbands; and, even more, they push for laws and votes. They succeed in getting some; although they’d be relentless about your possessions, or your children. As soon as the law stops limiting your wife's expenses, you will never be able to control them. Don’t think that things will remain the same once the law is repealed. It’s better for a wicked person to never be accused than to be found innocent; and luxury, if it had never been interfered with, would be more bearable than it will be now, like a wild animal stirred up by being chained, and then set free. My view is that the Oppian law should never be repealed. Whatever decision you come to, I pray the gods bless it."

5

After him the plebeian tribunes, who had declared their intention of protesting, added a few words to the same purport. Then Lucius Valerius spoke thus in support of the measure which he himself had introduced:--"If private persons only had stood forth to argue for and against the proposition which we have submitted to your consideration, I for my part, thinking enough to have been said on both sides, would have waited in silence for your determination. But since a person of most respectable judgment, the consul, Marcus Porcius, has reprobated our motion, not only by the influence of his opinion, which, had he said nothing, would carry very great weight, but also in a long and careful discourse, it becomes necessary to say a few words in answer. He has spent more words in rebuking the matrons, than in arguing against the measure proposed; and even went so far as to mention a doubt, whether the matrons had committed the conduct which he censured in them spontaneously or at our instigation. I shall defend the measure, not ourselves: for the consul threw out those insinuations against us, rather for argument's sake than as a serious charge. He has made use of the terms cabal and sedition; and, sometimes, secession of the women: because the matrons had requested of you, in the public streets, that, in this time of peace, when the commonwealth is flourishing and happy, you would repeal a law that was made against them during a war, and in times of distress. I know that these and other similar strong expressions, for the purpose of exaggeration, are easily found; and, mild as Marcus Cato is in his disposition, yet in his speeches he is not only vehement, but sometimes even austere. What new thing, let me ask, have the matrons done in coming out into public in a body on an occasion which nearly concerns themselves? Have they never before appeared in public? I will turn over your own Antiquities,[30] and quote them against you. Hear, now how often they have done the same, and always to the advantage of the public. In the earliest period of our history, even in the reign of Romulus, when the Capitol had been taken by the Sabines, and a pitched battle was fought in the forum, was not the fight stopped by the interposition of the matrons between the two armies? When, after the expulsion of the kings, the legions of the Volscians, under the command of Marcius Coriolanus, were encamped at the fifth stone, did not the matrons turn away that army, which would have overwhelmed this city? Again, when Rome was taken by the Gauls, whence was the city ransomed? Did not the matrons, by unanimous agreement, bring their gold into the public treasury? In the late war, not to go back to remote antiquity, when there was a want of money, did not the funds of the widows supply the treasury? And when even new gods were invited hither to the relief of our distressed affairs, did not the matrons go out in a body to the sea-shore to receive the Idaean Mother? The cases, you will say, are dissimilar. It is not my purpose to produce similar instances; it is sufficient that I clear these women of having done any thing new. Now, what nobody wondered at their doing in cases which concerned all in common, both men and women, can we wonder at their doing in a case peculiarly affecting themselves? But what have they done? We have proud ears, truly, if, though masters disdain not the prayers of slaves, we are offended at being asked a favour by honourable women.

After him, the commoners' tribunes, who had said they planned to protest, added a few words to the same effect. Then Lucius Valerius spoke in support of the proposal he had put forward: "If only private citizens had come forward to argue for and against the proposal we've brought to your attention, I would have patiently waited for your decision since I think enough has been said on both sides. But since a very respected person, the consul Marcus Porcius, has rejected our motion—not just through his strong opinion, which would have carried a lot of weight even if he hadn’t said anything, but also through a long and detailed speech—it’s necessary for me to say a few words in response. He spent more time criticizing the women than addressing the proposal we've made, even suggesting he wasn't sure if the women acted on their own or if we urged them to. I will defend the measure, not ourselves: the consul made those insinuations against us more for the sake of argument than as serious accusations. He referred to cabal and sedition, and occasionally mentioned the women's secession, because they asked you in the public streets—during a time of peace when the state is thriving and happy—to repeal a law that was created against them during a war and in troubled times. I know that these and similar strong words are often used to exaggerate, and although Marcus Cato is generally mild in temperament, in his speeches he can be very passionate and sometimes even harsh. What, I ask, is so surprising about the women coming out collectively for a matter that greatly affects them? Have they never appeared in public before? I could reference your own records[30] and use them against you. Listen to how often they've done the same and always for the good of the public. In the earliest days of our history, even during Romulus's reign, when the Capitol was taken by the Sabines and there was a battle in the forum, wasn't the fighting halted by the women stepping in between the two armies? After the kings were overthrown, when the Volscian legions led by Marcius Coriolanus were camped at the fifth milestone, didn’t the women prevent that army from destroying our city? Again, during the Gallic invasion, where did the ransom for the city come from? Did the women not, by unanimous agreement, bring their gold into the public treasury? In the recent war, without going back too far in history, when there was a shortage of funds, didn’t the savings of widows fill the treasury? And when even new gods were summoned to help with our dire situation, didn’t the women go down to the shore as a group to welcome the Idaean Mother? You might say these examples are different. I don’t intend to find identical cases; it’s enough to show that these women haven’t done anything new. Now, if we weren't surprised when they acted on matters of common concern for everyone, men and women alike, why would we be surprised when they address something that directly affects them? But what have they done? It’s ridiculous to be offended by honorable women asking for a favor when even masters don’t disregard the requests of their slaves."

6

"I come now to the question in debate, with respect to which the consul's argument is twofold: for, first, he is displeased at the thought of any law whatever being repealed; and then, particularly, of that law which was made to restrain female luxury. His former argument, in support of the laws in general, appeared highly becoming of a consul; and that on the latter, against luxury, was quite conformable to the rigid strictness of his morals. There is, therefore, a danger lest, unless I shall show what, on each subject, was inconclusive, you may probably be led away by error. For while I acknowledge, that of those laws which are instituted, not for any particular time, but for eternity, on account of their perpetual utility, not one ought to be repealed; unless either experience evince it to be useless, or some state of the public affairs render it so; I see, at the same time, that those laws which particular seasons have required, are mortal, (if I may use the term,) and changeable with the times. Those made in peace are generally repealed by war; those made in war, by peace; as in the management of a ship, some implements are useful in good weather, others in bad. As these two kinds are thus distinct in their nature, of which kind does that law appear to be which we now propose to repeal? Is it an ancient law of the kings, coeval with the city itself? Or, what is next to that, was it written in the twelve tables by the decemvirs, appointed to form a code of laws? Is it one, without which our ancestors thought that the honour of the female sex could not be preserved? and, therefore, have we also reason to fear, that, together with it, we should repeal the modesty and chastity of our females? Now, is there a man among you who does not know that this is a new law, passed not more than twenty years ago, in the consulate of Quintus Fabius and Tiberius Sempronius? And as, without it, our matrons sustained, for such a number of years, the most virtuous characters, what danger is there of their abandoning themselves to luxury on its being repealed? For, if that law had been passed for the purpose of setting a limit to the passions of the sex, there would be reason to fear lest the repeal of it might operate as an incitement to them. But the real reason of its being passed, the time itself will show Hannibal was then in Italy, victorious at Cannae: he already held possession of Tarentum, of Arpi, of Capua, and seemed ready to bring up his army to the city of Rome. Our allies had deserted us. We had neither soldiers to fill up the legions, nor seamen to man the fleet, nor money in the treasury. Slaves, who were to be employed as soldiers, were purchased on condition of their price being paid to the owners at the end of the war. The farmers of the revenues had declared, that they would contract to supply corn and other matters, which the exigencies of the war required, to be paid for at the same time. We gave up our slaves to the oar, in numbers proportioned to our properties, and paid them out of our own incomes. All our gold and silver, in imitation of the example given by the senators, we dedicated to the use of the public. Widows and minors lodged their money in the treasury. It was provided by law that we should not keep in our houses more than a certain quantity of wrought gold or silver, or more than a certain sum of coined silver or brass. At such a time as this, were the matrons so eagerly engaged in luxury and dress, that the Oppian law was requisite to repress such practices; when the senate, because the sacrifice of Ceres had been omitted, in consequence of all the matrons being in mourning, ordered the mourning to end in thirty days? Who does not clearly see, that the poverty and distress of the state, requiring that every private person's money should be converted to the use of the public, enacted that law, with intent that it should remain in force so long only as the cause of enacting the law should remain? For if all the decrees of the senate and orders of the people, which were then made to answer the necessities of the times, are to be of perpetual obligation, why do we refund their money to private persons? Why do we contract for public works for ready money? Why are not slaves brought to serve in the army? Why do not we, private subjects, supply rowers as we did then?

"I now turn to the issue at hand, regarding which the consul's argument is twofold: first, he's unhappy at the thought of any law being repealed; and second, particularly upset about the law meant to limit women's luxury. His earlier argument, supporting laws in general, was very fitting for a consul; and his stance against luxury aligns well with his strict morals. Therefore, there's a risk that, unless I demonstrate where each argument is weak, you might fall into misunderstanding. While I acknowledge that laws intended to last forever should not be repealed, unless they are proven to be ineffective or current circumstances make them so, I also recognize that laws created for specific situations are temporary and should change with the times. Laws made during peacetime are often repealed by wartime laws, and those made in wartime are often set aside in peacetime; similar to how certain tools are useful in good weather while others are needed in bad weather. Given this distinction, what kind of law is the one we are considering repealing now? Is it an ancient law from the kings, one that dates back to the founding of the city? Or, next in line, was it inscribed in the Twelve Tables by the decemvirs tasked with creating a legal code? Is it a law that our ancestors believed was essential to preserve the honor of women? Do we have to worry that, if we repeal it, we’ll also be compromising the modesty and chastity of our women? Now, is there anyone among you who doesn’t know that this is a new law, enacted less than twenty years ago during the consulship of Quintus Fabius and Tiberius Sempronius? And given that our matrons maintained excellent reputations for so many years without it, what risk is there that they will abandon themselves to luxury if it is repealed? If this law had been intended to limit women's passions, there might be cause for concern about its repeal inciting those passions. But the actual reason for its enactment, as time will reveal, was that Hannibal was in Italy, victorious at Cannae. He had already taken Tarentum, Arpi, Capua, and seemed ready to march on Rome. Our allies had turned against us. We lacked soldiers to fill our legions, sailors for our fleet, and money in our treasury. Slaves were being purchased to serve as soldiers with the agreement that their owners would be compensated at the war’s end. Tax farmers had stated that they would provide corn and other necessities for the war, but only if they were paid upfront. We assigned slaves to row based on our property size and compensated them from our own earnings. We dedicated all our gold and silver, following the senators' lead, for public use. Widows and orphans deposited their money in the treasury. A law mandated that we keep no more than a certain amount of gold or silver in our homes, or exceed a certain limit of coin. At such a time, were the matrons so absorbed in luxury and fashion that the Oppian Law was necessary to curb such behavior? When the Senate ordered the mourning to end in thirty days because the sacrifices to Ceres had been neglected, owing to all the matrons being in mourning? Who doesn’t see that the state’s poverty and distress, which required that every private individual’s money be utilized for public benefit, led to the enactment of that law, intended to remain only as long as the conditions that prompted its enactment were in effect? Because if all the Senate's decrees and the people's orders made in response to those urgent times are to be binding forever, why are we returning funds to private individuals? Why do we contract for public projects with immediate payment? Why aren’t slaves conscripted to serve in the army? Why don’t we, as private citizens, provide rowers as we did then?"

7

"Shall, then, every other class of people, every individual, feel the improvement in the condition of the state; and shall our wives alone reap none of the fruits of the public peace and tranquillity? Shall we men have the use of purple, wearing the purple-bordered gown in magistracies and priests' offices? Shall our children wear gowns bordered with purple? Shall we allow the privilege of wearing the toga praetexta to the magistrates of the colonies and borough towns, and to the very lowest of them here at Rome, the superintendents of the streets; and not only of wearing such an ornament of distinction while alive, but of being buried with it when dead; and shall we interdict the use of purple to women alone? And when you, the husband, may wear purple in your great coat, will you not suffer your wife to have a purple mantle? Shall your horse be more splendidly caparisoned than your wife is clothed? But with respect to purple, which will be worn out and consumed, I can see an unjust, indeed, but still a sort of reason, for parsimony; but with respect to gold, in which, excepting the price of the workmanship, there is no waste, what objection can there be? It rather serves as a reserve fund for both public and private exigencies, as you have already experienced. He says there will be no emulation between individuals, when no one is possessed of it. But, in truth, it will be a source of grief and indignation to all, when they see those ornaments allowed to the wives of the Latin confederates of which they themselves have been deprived; when they see those riding through the city in their carriages, and decorated with gold and purple, while they are obliged to follow on foot, as if the seat of empire were in the country of the others, not in their own. This would hurt the feelings even of men, and what do you think must be its effect on those of weak women, whom even trifles can disturb? Neither offices of state, nor of the priesthood, nor triumphs, nor badges of distinction, nor military presents, nor spoils, can fall to their share. Elegance of appearance, and ornaments, and dress, these are the women's badges of distinction; in these they delight and glory; these our ancestors called the women's world. What else do they lay aside when in mourning, except their gold and purple? And what else do they resume when the mourning is over? How do they distinguish themselves on occasion of public thanksgivings and supplications, but by adding unusual splendour of dress? But then, (it may be said,) if you repeal the Oppian law, should you choose to prohibit any of those particulars which the law at present prohibits, you will not have it in your power; your daughters, wives, and even the sisters of some, will be less under control. The bondage of women is never shaken off without the loss of their friends; and they themselves look with horror on that freedom which is purchased with the condition of the widow or the orphan. Their wish is, that their dress should be under your regulation, not under that of the law; and it ought to be your wish to hold them in control and guardianship, not in bondage; and to prefer the title of father or husband to that of master. The consul just now made use of some invidious terms, calling it a female sedition and secession; because, I suppose, there is danger of their seizing the sacred mount, as formerly the angry plebeians did; or the Aventine. Their feeble nature must submit to whatever you think proper to enjoin; and, the greater power you possess, the more moderate ought you to be in the exercise of your authority."

"Should every other class of people, every individual, benefit from the improvement in the state, while our wives receive none of the rewards of public peace and stability? Should we men get to wear the purple-bordered gown in positions of authority and as priests? Should our children wear purple-trimmed gowns? Should we allow the privilege of the toga praetexta for magistrates in the colonies and boroughs, and even to the very lowest among them here in Rome, the street superintendents; not only to wear such prestigious symbols while alive but to be buried in them when they die, and yet deny the use of purple to women only? And when you, as the husband, can wear purple in your coat, why would you not let your wife have a purple cloak? Should your horse be dressed more impressively than your wife? Concerning purple, which wears out and gets used up, I can understand an unfair reason for being stingy; but when it comes to gold, which, aside from the cost of craftsmanship, doesn't get wasted, what’s the objection? It actually serves as a reserve for both public and personal emergencies, as you've seen. He argues there will be no competition among individuals if no one has it. But the truth is, it will cause pain and anger for everyone when they see the wives of the Latin confederates wearing the adornments denied to them; when they observe those women riding through the city in their carriages, dressed in gold and purple, while they are forced to walk, as if the center of power belonged to those from elsewhere, not to them. This would hurt men’s feelings, and imagine how much more it would affect sensitive women, who can be upset by even trivial matters? Neither public offices, nor priestly duties, nor triumphs, nor badges of honor, nor military gifts, nor spoils belong to them. Elegance, adornments, and clothing are the distinctions for women; they take joy and pride in these things; our ancestors referred to them as the women's realm. What do they set aside during mourning, if not their gold and purple? And what do they just as eagerly put back on when the mourning ends? How do they stand out during public celebrations and prayers, if not by wearing their best attire? But then, one might argue, if you repeal the Oppian law, and want to prevent any of the things currently prohibited, you won’t have that power; your daughters, wives, and even some sisters will be harder to control. Women’s bondage is never lifted without a loss of friends; they themselves shudder at the thought of freedom that comes with being a widow or an orphan. They want their clothing to be regulated by you, not by law; and you should aim to hold them under your care and guidance, not under oppression; to prefer being called father or husband over being called master. The consul just now used some questionable terms, calling it a female uprising and rebellion; perhaps he fears they might take the sacred mount like the angry plebeians did before; or the Aventine. Their delicate nature must accept whatever you decide to impose; and the more power you have, the more restrained you should be in exercising that power."

8

Although all these considerations had been urged against the motion and in its favour, the women next day poured out into public in much greater numbers, and in a body beset the doors of the tribunes who had protested against the measure of their colleagues; nor did they retire until this intervention was withdrawn. There was then no further doubt but that every one of the tribes would vote for the repeal of the law. Thus was this law annulled, in the twentieth year after it had been made. The consul Marcus Porcius, as soon as the Oppian law was abolished, sailed immediately, with twenty-five ships of war, of which five belonged to the allies, to the port of Luna, where he ordered the troops to assemble; and having sent an edict along the sea-coast, to collect ships of every description, at his departure from Luna he left orders that they should follow him to the harbour of Pyrenaeus, as he intended to proceed thence against the enemy with his collective fleet. They accordingly, after sailing by the Ligurian mountains and the Gallic bay, congregated together on the day appointed. From thence they went to Rhoda, and forcibly dislodged a garrison of Spaniards that were in that fortress. From Rhoda they proceeded with a favourable wind to Emporiae, and there landed all the forces, excepting the crews of the ships.

Although all these arguments had been presented against the motion as well as in its favor, the following day the women came out in much greater numbers, surrounding the doors of the tribunes who had opposed their colleagues' measure; they did not leave until the intervention was revoked. It then became clear that every tribe would vote for the repeal of the law. Thus, this law was annulled twenty years after it had been enacted. As soon as the Oppian law was abolished, Consul Marcus Porcius immediately set sail with twenty-five warships, five of which belonged to the allies, to the port of Luna, where he ordered the troops to gather; he also sent an edict along the coastline to collect ships of all types, and upon his departure from Luna, he instructed that they should follow him to the harbor of Pyrenaeus, as he planned to proceed against the enemy with his combined fleet. They then sailed by the Ligurian mountains and the Gallic bay, gathering together on the appointed day. From there, they went to Rhoda and forcefully removed a garrison of Spaniards that were in that fortress. From Rhoda, they continued with a favorable wind to Emporiae, where they landed all the forces, except for the ship crews.

9

At that time, as at present, Emporiae consisted of two towns, separated by a wall. One was inhabited by Greeks from Phocaea, whence the Massilians also derive their origin; the other by Spaniards. The Greek town, being open towards the sea, had but a small extent of wall, not above four hundred paces in circuit; but the Spanish town, being farther back from the sea, had a wall three thousand paces in circumference. A third kind of inhabitants was added by the deified Caesar settling a Roman colony there, after the final defeat of the sons of Pompey. At present they are all incorporated in one mass; the Spaniards first, and, at length, the Greeks; having been adopted into the Roman citizenship. Whoever had, at that period, observed the Greeks exposed on one side to the open sea, and on the other to the Spaniards, a fierce and warlike race, would have wondered by what cause they were preserved. Deficient in strength, they guarded against danger by regular discipline; of which, among even more powerful people, the best preservative is fear. That part of the wall which faced the country, they kept strongly fortified, having but one gate, at which some one of the magistrates was continually on guard. During the night, a third part of the citizens kept watch on the walls, posting their watches, and going their rounds, not merely from the force of custom, or in compliance with the law, but with as much vigilance as if an enemy were at their gates. They never admitted any Spaniard into the city, nor did they go outside the walls without precaution. The passage to the sea was open to every one: but, through the gate, next to the Spanish town, none ever passed, but in a large body; these were generally the third division, which had watched on the walls the preceding night. The cause of their going out was this: the Spaniards, ignorant of maritime affairs, were fond of trafficking with them, and glad of an opportunity of purchasing, for their own use, the foreign goods, which the others imported in their ships; and, at the same time, of finding a market for the produce of their lands. The desire of this mutual intercourse caused the Spanish town to be freely open to the Greeks. They were thus the more protected as being sheltered under the friendship of the Romans, which they cultivated with as much cordial zeal, though not possessed of equal resources, as the Massilians. On this account they received the consul, and his army, with kindness and cordiality. Cato staid there a few days, until he could learn what force the enemy had, and where they lay; and, not to be idle during even that short delay, he spent the whole time in exercising his men. It happened to be the season of the year when the Spaniards had the corn in their barns. He therefore ordered the purveyors not to purchase any corn, and sent them home to Rome, saying, that the war would maintain itself. Then, setting out from Emporiae, he laid waste the lands of the enemy with fire and sword, spreading terror and flight through the whole country.

At that time, just like now, Emporiae was made up of two towns divided by a wall. One was populated by Greeks from Phocaea, which is also where the Massilians trace their roots; the other was home to Spaniards. The Greek town, facing the sea, had a relatively short wall, about four hundred paces around; meanwhile, the Spanish town, further inland, had a wall that measured three thousand paces in circumference. A third group of inhabitants was added when the deified Caesar established a Roman colony there after defeating the sons of Pompey. Today, they are all merged into one community; the Spaniards first, and eventually the Greeks, who were granted Roman citizenship. Anyone observing the Greeks, exposed on one side to the open sea and on the other to the fierce and warlike Spaniards, would have wondered how they managed to survive. Lacking in strength, they relied on regular discipline for protection, which is often kept in place by fear, even among stronger populations. The part of the wall facing the countryside was heavily fortified, with only one gate, where a magistrate was always on watch. At night, a third of the citizens would keep guard on the walls, patrolling—not just as a custom or legal obligation, but with as much vigilance as if an enemy were at their gates. They never let any Spaniard into the city, nor did they venture outside the walls without taking precautions. The passage to the sea was open to everyone; however, no one passed through the gate next to the Spanish town without a large group, typically the third division that had guarded the walls the night before. They went out for this reason: the Spaniards, who were unfamiliar with maritime matters, eagerly traded with them, excited to buy foreign goods brought in by Greek ships and equally interested in selling their own produce. This mutual desire for interaction allowed the Spanish town to remain open to the Greeks. They felt more secure being backed by the friendship of the Romans, which they maintained with as much enthusiasm, although with fewer resources, than the Massilians. For this reason, they welcomed the consul and his army warmly. Cato stayed there a few days to assess the enemy's strength and position, and not wanting to waste even that brief time, he used it to drill his troops. It was the time of year when the Spaniards had their grain stored, so he instructed his suppliers not to buy any corn and sent them back to Rome, claiming that the war would sustain itself. Then, after leaving Emporiae, he devastated the enemy's lands with fire and sword, spreading fear and causing chaos throughout the entire region.

10

At the same time, as Marcus Helvius was going home from Farther Spain, with an escort of six thousand men, given him by the praetor, Appius Claudius, the Celtiberians, with a very numerous force, met him near the city of Illiturgi. Valerius says, that they had twenty thousand effective men; that twelve thousand of them were killed, the town of Illiturgi taken, and all the adult males put to the sword. Helvius, soon after, arrived at the camp of Cato; and as the region was now free from enemies, he sent back the escort to Farther Spain, and proceeded to Rome, where, on account of his successful services, he entered the city with an ovation. He carried into the treasury, of silver bullion, fourteen thousand pounds' weight; of coined, seventeen thousand and twenty-three denarii;[31] and Oscan[32] denarii, one hundred and twenty thousand four hundred and thirty-eight.[33] The reason for which the senate refused him a triumph was, because he fought under the auspices, and in the province, of another. He had returned, moreover, two years after the expiration of his office, because after he had resigned the government of the province to Quintus Minucius, he was detained there during the succeeding year, by a severe and tedious sickness he therefore entered the city in ovation, only two months before his successor, Quintus Minucius, enjoyed a triumph. The latter also brought into the treasury thirty-four thousand eight hundred pounds' weight of silver, seventy-eight thousand denarii,[34] and of Oscan denarii two hundred and seventy-eight thousand.[35]

At the same time, as Marcus Helvius was returning home from Further Spain with a group of six thousand men, which had been assigned to him by the praetor, Appius Claudius, he was confronted near the city of Illiturgi by a very large force of Celtiberians. Valerius reports that they had twenty thousand effective soldiers, with twelve thousand of them killed, the town of Illiturgi captured, and all the adult males killed. Soon after, Helvius arrived at Cato's camp, and since the area was now free of enemies, he sent the escort back to Further Spain and continued on to Rome, where he entered the city with an ovation for his successful service. He brought into the treasury fourteen thousand pounds of silver bullion, seventeen thousand and twenty-three denarii,[31] and one hundred and twenty thousand four hundred and thirty-eight Oscan denarii.[32] The reason the senate denied him a triumph was that he fought under the auspices and in the province of someone else. Additionally, he returned two years after his term ended because after handing over the province to Quintus Minucius, he was held back there for another year due to a serious and prolonged illness. Therefore, he entered the city in ovation just two months before his successor, Quintus Minucius, celebrated a triumph. The latter also brought into the treasury thirty-four thousand eight hundred pounds of silver, seventy-eight thousand denarii,[34] and two hundred and seventy-eight thousand Oscan denarii.[35]

11

Meanwhile, in Spain, the consul lay encamped at a small distance from Emporiae. Thither came three ambassadors from Bilistages, chieftain of the Ilergetians, one of whom was his son, representing, that "their fortresses were besieged and that they had no hopes of being able to hold out, unless the Roman troops came to their assistance. Three thousand men," they said, "would be sufficient;" and they added, that, "if such a force came to their aid, the enemy would not keep their ground." To this the consul answered, that "he was truly concerned for their danger and their fears; but that he had by no means so great an amount of forces, as that, while there lay in his neighbourhood such a powerful force of the enemy, with whom he daily expected a general engagement, he could safely diminish his strength by dividing his troops." The ambassadors, on hearing this, threw themselves at the consul's feet, and with tears conjured him "not to forsake them at such a perilous juncture. For, if rejected by the Romans, to whom could they apply? They had no other allies, no other hope on earth. They might have escaped the present hazard, if they had consented to forfeit their faith, and to conspire with the rest; but no menaces, no appearances of danger, had been able to shake their constancy, because they hoped to find in the Romans abundant succour and support. If there was no further prospect of this, if it was refused them by the consul, they called gods and men to witness, that reluctantly and under compulsion they must change sides, to avoid such sufferings as the Saguntines had undergone; and that they would perish together with the other states of Spain, rather than alone."

Meanwhile, in Spain, the consul was camped a short distance from Emporiae. Three ambassadors from Bilistages, the leader of the Ilergetians, came to see him; one of them was his son. They reported that "their fortresses were under siege and they had no hope of holding out unless the Roman troops came to help them. Three thousand men," they said, "would be enough," and they added that "if such a force came to support them, the enemy wouldn't be able to hold their ground." The consul replied that "he was genuinely concerned about their danger and fears; however, he did not have enough forces to safely reduce his strength by splitting his troops, especially with such a powerful enemy nearby, with whom he expected a major battle any day." Upon hearing this, the ambassadors fell to the ground at the consul's feet and, in tears, begged him "not to abandon them at such a critical moment. If they were rejected by the Romans, whom else could they turn to? They had no other allies, no other hope on earth. They might have avoided the current danger if they had agreed to betray their loyalty and join the others; but no threats or signs of danger had been able to shake their resolve because they believed they would find plenty of support with the Romans. If there was no further chance of this, if the consul refused them, they called upon the gods and men to witness that reluctantly and under pressure they would have to switch sides to avoid the suffering that the Saguntines had endured; and they would rather perish along with the other states of Spain than alone."

12

They were thus dismissed on that day without any positive answer. During the following night, the consul's thoughts were greatly perplexed and divided. He was unwilling to abandon these allies, yet equally so to diminish his army, which might either oblige him to decline a battle, or occasion danger in an engagement. He was firmly resolved, however, not to lessen his forces, lest he should in the mean time suffer some disgrace from the enemy; and therefore he judged it expedient, instead of real succour, to hold out hopes to the allies. For he considered that, in many cases, but especially in war, mere appearances have had all the effect of realities; and that a person, under a firm persuasion that he can command resources, virtually has them; that by that very confidence he was insured in his hopes and efforts. Next day he told the ambassadors, that "although he was afraid to lend a part of his forces to others, and so to weaken his own, yet that he was giving more attention to their circumstances and danger than to his own." He then gave orders to the third part of the soldiers of every cohort, to make haste and prepare victuals, which they were to carry with them on board ships, and that the vessels should be got in readiness against the third day. He desired two of the ambassadors to carry an account of these proceedings to Bilistages and the Ilergetians; but, by kind treatment and presents, he prevailed on the chieftain's son to remain with him. The ambassadors did not leave the place until they saw the troops embarked on board the ships; then reporting this at home as a matter of certainty, they spread, not only among their own people, but likewise among the enemy, a confident assurance of the approach of Roman succours.

They were dismissed that day without any clear answer. During the following night, the consul’s thoughts were troubled and conflicted. He didn’t want to abandon these allies, but he also didn’t want to weaken his army, which could force him to back out of a battle or put him at risk in a fight. However, he was determined not to reduce his forces, for fear of suffering some humiliation from the enemy in the meantime; therefore, he thought it best to offer the allies hope instead of real help. He believed that in many situations, especially in war, appearances can have the same impact as reality, and that if someone is confident they can access resources, they effectively already have them; that very confidence secured his hopes and efforts. The next day, he told the ambassadors that "even though he was hesitant to lend part of his forces to others and weaken his own, he was focusing more on their circumstances and dangers than on his own." He then ordered a third of the soldiers from each cohort to quickly prepare supplies to take on board ships, and that the vessels should be ready by the third day. He asked two of the ambassadors to report these developments to Bilistages and the Ilergetians; however, through kind treatment and gifts, he persuaded the chieftain's son to stay with him. The ambassadors didn’t leave until they saw the troops boarding the ships; then, reporting this back home as a certainty, they spread a confident assurance among their own people as well as the enemy about the impending arrival of Roman reinforcements.

13

The consul, when a specious appearance had been sufficiently exhibited, ordered the soldiers to be recalled from the ships; and, as the season of the year now approached when it would be proper to enter on action, he pitched a winter camp at the distance of three miles from Emporiae. From this post he frequently led out his troops to ravage the enemy's country; sometimes to one quarter, sometimes to another, as opportunity offered, leaving only a small guard in the camp. They generally began their march in the night, that they might proceed as far as possible from the camp, and surprise the enemy unawares; and this practice disciplined the new-raised soldiers, and great numbers of the enemy were cut off; so that they no longer dared to venture beyond the walls of their forts. When he had made himself thoroughly acquainted with the temper of the enemy, and of his own men, he ordered the tribunes and the praefects, with all the horsemen and centurions, to be called together, and addressed them thus: "The time is arrived, which you have often wished for, when you might have an opportunity of displaying your valour. Hitherto you have waged war rather as marauders than as regular troops; you shall now meet your enemies hand to hand, in regular fight. Henceforward you will have it in your power, instead of pillaging country places, to exhaust the treasures of cities. Our fathers, at a time when the Carthaginians had in Spain both commanders and armies, and had themselves neither commander nor soldiers there, nevertheless insisted on its being an article of treaty, that the river Iberus should be the boundary of their empire. Now, when two praetors of the Romans, when a consul, and three armies are employed in Spain, and, for near ten years past, no Carthaginian has been in either of its provinces, yet we have lost that empire on the hither side of the Iberus. This it is your duty to recover by your valour and arms; and to compel this nation, which is in a state rather of giddy insurrection than of steady warfare, to receive again the yoke which it has shaken off." After thus generally exhorting them, he gave notice, that he intended to march by night to the enemy's camp; and then dismissed them to take refreshment.

The consul, once he had shown a convincing front, ordered the soldiers to return from the ships; and as the time of year approached for taking action, he set up a winter camp three miles from Emporiae. From this position, he often led his troops out to raid the enemy's territory, sometimes targeting one area, sometimes another, depending on the opportunity, leaving only a small guard at the camp. They usually began their march at night to go as far as possible from the camp and catch the enemy off guard; this tactic trained the newly raised soldiers, and many of the enemy were killed, making them reluctant to venture beyond the walls of their forts. Once he was fully aware of the enemy's behavior and that of his own men, he called together the tribunes, the praefects, along with all the horsemen and centurions, and addressed them: "The time has come, which you have often wished for, to show your courage. Until now, you have fought more like raiders than regular soldiers; you will now confront your enemies directly in battle. From this point on, you will have the chance, instead of plundering rural areas, to drain the resources of cities. Our forefathers, at a time when the Carthaginians held both leaders and armies in Spain, and we had neither there, insisted on making the Iberus River the border of our empire. Now, with two praetors of the Romans, a consul, and three armies positioned in Spain, and for nearly ten years no Carthaginian has been in either province, we have still lost control of the land this side of the Iberus. It is your duty to reclaim this territory with your bravery and arms; to force this nation, which is in a state of chaotic rebellion rather than organized warfare, to accept again the authority it has rejected." After urging them generally, he announced that he planned to march at night to the enemy's camp and then dismissed them to rest.

14

At midnight, after having given his attention to the auspices, he began his march, that he might take possession of such ground as he chose, before the enemy should observe him. Having led his troops beyond their camp, he formed them in order of battle, and at the first light sent three cohorts close to their very ramparts. The barbarians, surprised at the Romans appearing on their rear, ran hastily to arms. In the mean time, the consul observed to his men, "Soldiers, you have no room for hope, but in your own courage; and I have, purposely, taken care that it should be so. The enemy are between us and our camp; behind us is an enemy's country. What is most honourable, is likewise safest; namely, to place all our hopes in our own valour." He then ordered the cohorts to retreat, in order to draw out the barbarians by the appearance of flight. Every thing happened as he had expected. The enemy, thinking that the Romans retired through fear, rushed out of the gate, and filled the whole space between their own camp and the line of their adversaries. While they were hastily marshalling their troops, the consul, who had all his in readiness, and in regular array, attacked them when in disorder. He caused the cavalry from both wings to advance first to the charge: but those on the right were immediately repulsed, and, retiring in disorder, spread confusion among the infantry also. On seeing this, the consul ordered two chosen cohorts to march round the right flank of the enemy, and show themselves on their rear, before the two lines of infantry could close. The alarm which this gave the enemy, which had been thrown to a disadvantage by the cowardice of the Roman horse, restored the fight to an equality. But such a panic had taken possession of both the cavalry and infantry of the right wing, that the consul laid hold of several with his own hand, and turned them about with their faces to the enemy. As long as the fight was carried on with missile weapons, success was doubtful; and on the right wing, where the disorder and flight had first began, the Romans with difficulty kept their ground. On their left wing, the barbarians were both hard pressed in in front; and looked back, with timidity, at the cohorts that threatened their rear. But when, after discharging their iron darts and large javelins, they drew their swords, the battle, in a manner, began anew. They were no longer wounded by random blows from a distance, but, closing foot to foot, placed all their hope in courage and strength.

At midnight, after paying attention to the omens, he began his march so he could take control of the territory he wanted before the enemy noticed him. After leading his troops beyond their camp, he arranged them for battle, and at first light, he sent three cohorts right up to the enemy's ramparts. The barbarians, surprised by the sudden appearance of the Romans at their rear, quickly grabbed their weapons. Meanwhile, the consul said to his men, "Soldiers, you have no hope except in your own courage; and I've intentionally made sure that's the case. The enemy is between us and our camp; behind us is enemy territory. What is most honorable is also the safest, which is to place all our hopes in our own bravery." He then ordered the cohorts to retreat to entice the barbarians with the illusion of a retreat. Everything went as he had predicted. The enemy, thinking the Romans were retreating out of fear, rushed out of the gate and filled the entire space between their camp and the Roman lines. While they hurriedly assembled their troops, the consul, with all his forces ready and in formation, attacked them while they were disorganized. He ordered the cavalry from both wings to charge first, but the cavalry on the right was immediately beaten back, and as they retreated in chaos, they caused confusion among the infantry too. Seeing this, the consul sent two selected cohorts to move around the enemy's right flank and show themselves in their rear before the two lines of infantry could connect. The panic this caused in the enemy, which had already been set back by the cowardice of the Roman cavalry, evened the fight. But the fear that gripped both the cavalry and infantry of the right wing was so intense that the consul grabbed several soldiers himself and turned them around to face the enemy. As long as the battle was fought with ranged weapons, success was uncertain; on the right wing, where the disorder and retreat had started, the Romans struggled to hold their position. On their left wing, the barbarians were pressured from the front and anxiously glanced back at the cohorts threatening their rear. But when they finished throwing their iron darts and large javelins and drew their swords, the battle essentially restarted. They no longer suffered random blows from a distance; instead, closing in foot to foot, they put all their hope in courage and strength.

15

When the consul's men were now spent with fatigue, he reanimated their courage by bringing up into the fight some subsidiary cohorts from the second line. These formed a new front, and being fresh themselves, and with fresh weapons attacking the wearied enemy in the form of a wedge, by a furious onset they first forced their way through them; and then, when they were once broken, scattered them and put them to flight. They returned towards their camp across the fields with all the speed they could make. When Cato saw the rout become general, he rode back to the second legion, which had been posted in reserve, and ordered the standards to be borne before it, and that it should advance in quick motion, and attack the camp of the enemy. If any of them, through too much eagerness, pushed forward beyond his rank, he himself rode up and struck them with his javelin, and also ordered the tribunes and centurions to chastise them. By this time the camp of the enemy was attacked, though the Romans were kept off from the works by stones, poles, and weapons of every sort. But, on the arrival of the fresh legion, the assailants assumed new courage, and the enemy fought with redoubled fury in defence of their rampart. The consul attentively examined every place himself, that he might break in at that quarter where he saw the weakest resistance. At a gate on the left, he observed that the guard was thin, and thither he led the first-rank men and spearmen of the second legion. The party posted at the gate were not able to withstand their assault; while the rest, seeing the enemy within the rampart, abandoned the defence of the camp, and threw away their standards and arms. Great numbers were killed at the gates, being stopped in the narrow passages by the throng of their own men; and the soldiers of the second legion cut off the hindmost, while the rest were plundering the camp. According to the account of Valerius Antias, there were above forty thousand of the enemy killed on that day. Cato himself, who was certainly no disparager of his own merits, says that a great many were killed, but he specifies no number.

When the consul's men were worn out from exhaustion, he boosted their spirits by bringing up some support troops from the second line. These fresh troops formed a new front, and with their new weapons, they launched a fierce attack against the tired enemy in a wedge formation. They broke through the enemy ranks and, once the enemy was in disarray, scattered them and forced them to flee. They hurried back to their camp as quickly as possible. When Cato saw the complete rout, he rode back to the second legion, which had been held in reserve, and ordered the standards to be raised in front of them. He told them to advance quickly and attack the enemy's camp. If anyone got too eager and moved ahead of their position, he personally rode up and struck them with his javelin, and he also instructed the tribunes and centurions to discipline them. By this time, the enemy camp was under attack, although the Romans were kept at bay by stones, poles, and various weapons. However, when the fresh legion arrived, the attackers gained new confidence, while the enemy fought with increased fury to defend their rampart. The consul carefully inspected every part of the battlefield to find a point where the resistance was weakest. At a gate on the left, he noticed the guard was sparse, so he led the front-line soldiers and spearmen of the second legion there. The guards at the gate couldn't withstand their assault; seeing the enemy inside the rampart, the remaining troops abandoned the camp's defense and discarded their standards and weapons. Many were killed at the gates, trapped in the narrow passages by their own men; the soldiers of the second legion cut down those at the back while the rest looted the camp. According to Valerius Antias, over forty thousand enemy troops were killed that day. Cato himself, who was certainly not one to downplay his own achievements, mentioned that many were killed, but he didn't specify a number.

16

The conduct of Cato on that day is judged deserving of commendation in three particulars. First, in leading round his army so far from his camp and fleet, as to fight the battle in the very middle of the enemy, that his men might look for no safety but in their courage. Secondly, in throwing the cohorts on the enemy's rear. Thirdly, in ordering the second legion, when all the rest were disordered by the eagerness of their pursuit, to advance at a full pace to the gate of the camp, in compact and regular order under their standards. He delayed not to improve his victory; but having sounded a retreat, and brought back his men laden with spoil, he allowed them a few hours of the night for rest; and then led them out to ravage the country. They spread their depredations the wider, as the enemy were dispersed in their flight; and this circumstance, no less than the defeat of the preceding day, obliged the Spaniards of Emporiae, and those of their neighbourhood, to make a submission. Many also, belonging to other states, who had made their escape to Emporiae, surrendered; all of whom the consul received with kindness, and after refreshing them with victuals and wine, dismissed to their several homes. He quickly decamped thence, and wherever the army proceeded on its march, he was met by ambassadors, surrendering their respective states; so that, by the time when he arrived at Tarraco, all Spain on this side of the Ebro was in a state of perfect subjection; and the Roman prisoners, and those of their allies and the Latin confederates, who by various chances had fallen into the hands of the enemies in Spain, were brought back by the barbarians, as an offering to the consul. A rumour afterwards spread abroad, that Cato intended to lead his army into Turditania; and it was given out, with equal falsehood, that he meant to proceed to the remote inhabitants of the mountains. On this groundless, unauthenticated report, seven forts of the Bergistans revolted; but the Roman, marching thither, reduced them to subjection without any battle worthy of narration. Not very long after, when the consul returned to Tarraco, and before he removed to any other place, the same persons revolted again. They were again subdued; but, on this second reduction, met not the same mild treatment; they were all sold by auction, that they might not any oftener disturb the peace.

Cato's actions on that day are seen as commendable for three reasons. First, he led his army far from their camp and fleet to fight the battle right in the heart of the enemy, pushing his men to rely solely on their bravery. Second, he launched his troops against the enemy's rear. Third, he ordered the second legion, while the others got disorganized in their eagerness to chase, to move steadily towards the camp gate in a tight and orderly formation under their standards. He wasted no time capitalizing on his victory; after calling a retreat, he brought his men back, laden with spoils, allowing them a few hours of rest at night before leading them out to raid the country. Their destruction spread even further as the enemy fled in disarray, causing not only the defeat of the previous day but also compelling the Spaniards of Emporiae and the surrounding areas to submit. Many others from different states who had escaped to Emporiae also surrendered. The consul welcomed all of them kindly, providing food and wine before sending them back to their homes. He quickly broke camp, and wherever his army marched, he was met by ambassadors surrendering their states. By the time he reached Tarraco, all of Spain on this side of the Ebro was completely subdued, and the Roman prisoners, along with those of their allies and Latin confederates who had fallen into enemy hands, were returned by the barbarians as an offering to the consul. Later, a rumor spread that Cato planned to lead his army into Turditania, and it was falsely claimed that he intended to move towards the distant mountain tribes. On the basis of this unfounded rumor, seven forts of the Bergistans revolted, but the Romans marched there and brought them back under control without any notable battle. Shortly after, when the consul returned to Tarraco and before moving elsewhere, these same people revolted again. They were subdued once more, but this time did not receive the same leniency; they were all sold at auction to prevent them from causing any further disturbances.

17

In the mean time, the praetor, Publius Manlius, having received the army from Quintius Minucius, whom he had succeeded, and joined to it the old army of Appius Claudius Nero, from Farther Spain, marched into Turditania. Of all the Spaniards, the Turditanians are reckoned the least warlike; nevertheless, relying on their great numbers, they went to oppose the march of the Romans. The cavalry, having been sent forward, at once broke their line; and with the infantry there was hardly any conflict. The veteran soldiers, well acquainted with the enemy and their manner of fighting, effectually decided the battle. This engagement, however, did not terminate the war. The Turdulans hired ten thousand Celtiberians, and prepared to carry on the war with foreign troops. The consul, meanwhile, alarmed at the rebellion of the Bergistans, and suspecting that the other states would act in like manner when occasion offered, took away their arms from all the Spaniards on this side of the Iberus; which proceeding affected them so deeply, that many laid violent hands on themselves; this fierce race considering that, without arms, life was of no value. When this was reported to the consul, he summoned before him the senators of every one of the states, to whom he spoke thus: "It is not more our interest than it is your own, that you should not rebel; since your insurrections have, hitherto, always drawn more mi fortune on the Spaniards than labour on the Roman armies. To prevent such things happening in future, I know but one method, which is, to put it out of your power to rebel. I wish to effect this in the gentlest way, and that you would assist me therein with your advice. I will follow none with greater pleasure than what yourselves shall offer." They all remaining silent, he told them that he would give them a few days' time to consider the matter. When, on being called together, even in the second meeting, they uttered not a word, in one day he razed the walls of all their fortresses; and marching against those who had not yet submitted, he received in every country, as he passed through, the submission of all the neighbouring states. Segestica alone, an important and opulent city, he reduced by works and engines.

In the meantime, the praetor, Publius Manlius, took command of the army from Quintius Minucius, his predecessor, and combined it with the old army of Appius Claudius Nero from Farther Spain as he marched into Turditania. Among all the Spanish tribes, the Turditanians were considered the least warlike; however, counting on their large numbers, they tried to confront the Roman advance. The cavalry was sent ahead and quickly broke through their formation, and there was barely any fighting with the infantry. The veteran soldiers, familiar with the enemy and their fighting style, decisively won the battle. However, this clash didn't end the war. The Turdulans hired ten thousand Celtiberians and prepared to continue fighting with foreign troops. Meanwhile, the consul, worried about the Bergistans' rebellion and fearing that other states might do the same if given the chance, confiscated weapons from all the Spaniards on this side of the Iberus. This action deeply affected them; many resorted to self-harm, as this fierce tribe believed that life was worthless without arms. When the consul learned of this, he summoned the senators from all the states and addressed them: "It is not just in our interest but yours as well to avoid rebellion, as your uprisings have always brought more misfortune to the Spaniards than work to the Roman armies. To prevent this in the future, I know only one way: to take away your ability to rebel. I want to achieve this gently, and I would appreciate your advice. I would gladly follow any suggestions you provide." When they all remained silent, he told them he would give them a few days to think about it. When they reconvened and still said nothing, he demolished the walls of all their fortresses in one day. He then marched against those who had not yet surrendered, receiving the submission of all the neighboring states as he progressed. Only Segestica, a significant and wealthy city, he subdued through siege works and engines.

18

Cato had greater difficulties to surmount, in subduing the enemy, than had those commanders who came first into Spain; for this reason, that the Spaniards, through disgust at the Carthaginian government, came over to their side; whereas he had the task of enforcing their submission to slavery, in a manner, after they had been in full enjoyment of liberty. Besides, he found the whole province in a state of commotion; insomuch, that some were in arms, and others were compelled to join in the revolt by being besieged, nor would they have been able to hold out any longer if they had not received timely succour. But so vigorous was the spirit and capacity of the consul, that there was no kind of business, whether great or small, which he did not himself attend to and perform; and he not only planned and ordered, but generally executed in person such measures as were expedient; nor did he practise a more strict and rigorous discipline over any one than over himself. In spare diet, watching, and labour, he vied with the meanest of his soldiers; nor, excepting the honour of his post, and the command, had he any peculiar distinction above the rest of the army.

Cato faced more challenges in defeating the enemy than the commanders who first arrived in Spain. This was because the Spaniards had switched sides out of frustration with the Carthaginian rule, while Cato had the tough job of forcing them back into submission after they had enjoyed their freedom. Additionally, he found the entire province in turmoil, with some taking up arms and others being forced into rebellion while under siege. They wouldn't have lasted much longer if they hadn't received timely help. However, the consul's determination and skills were so strong that he personally took care of every matter, big or small. He not only planned and organized but also carried out most actions himself. He maintained a stricter discipline over himself than anyone else, living on simple food and working hard alongside the least of his soldiers. Apart from the honor of his position and command, he didn't have any special privileges over the rest of the army.

19

The Celtiberians, summoned forth by the enemy for hire, as above mentioned, rendered the war in Turditania more difficult to the praetor, Publius Manlius. The consul, therefore, in compliance with a letter from the praetor, led his legions thither. The Celtiberians and Turditanians were lying in separate camps at the approach of the Romans, who began immediately to skirmish with the Turditanians, making attacks on their advanced guards; and they constantly came off victorious from every engagement, however rashly undertaken. The consul ordered some military tribunes to enter into a conference with the Celtiberians, and to offer them their choice of three proposals: first, to come over, if they wished it, to the Romans, and receive double the pay for which they had agreed with the Turditanians: the second, to depart to their own homes, on receiving assurance, under the sanction of the public faith, that it should not operate to their injury that they had joined the enemies of the Romans: the third was, that, if they were absolutely determined on war, they should appoint a day and place to decide the matter with him by arms. The Celtiberians desired a day's time for consideration; and an assembly was held, but in great confusion, from the Turditanians mingling in it, so that no resolution could be come to. Although it was uncertain whether there was to be war or peace with the Celtiberians, the Romans, nevertheless, just as though the latter were determined on, brought provisions from the lands and forts of the enemy, and soon ventured to go within their fortifications, relying on private truces, as they would on a common intercourse established by authority. When the consul found that he could not entice the enemy to a battle, he first led out a number of cohorts, lightly accoutred, in regular order, to ravage a part of the country which was yet unhurt; then hearing that all the baggage of the Celtiberians was deposited at Saguntia, he proceeded thither to attack that town, but was unable, notwithstanding, to provoke them to stir. Paying, therefore, his own troops and those of Minucius, he left the bulk of his army in the praetor's camp, and, with seven cohorts, returned to the Iberus.

The Celtiberians, called in by the enemy for hire, as mentioned earlier, made the war in Turditania more challenging for the praetor, Publius Manlius. So, following a letter from the praetor, the consul brought his legions to the area. The Celtiberians and Turditanians were camped separately when the Romans approached, quickly starting to skirmish with the Turditanians and attacking their front lines; they consistently won every engagement, no matter how reckless. The consul sent some military tribunes to negotiate with the Celtiberians, offering them three options: first, to join the Romans and receive double the pay they had agreed on with the Turditanians; second, to return home with a guarantee that their alliance with the Romans' enemies wouldn’t harm them; or third, if they were set on war, to choose a day and place to settle it through combat. The Celtiberians requested a day to think it over, and an assembly was held, but it ended up chaotic due to the Turditanians being involved, preventing any clear decision. Even though it was unclear whether there would be war or peace with the Celtiberians, the Romans, acting as if the Celtiberians were ready for battle, began gathering supplies from the enemy's lands and forts, and soon dared to enter their fortifications, relying on informal truces much like regular trade agreements. When the consul saw he couldn't draw the enemy into a fight, he first sent out several light-armed cohorts, organized to raid parts of the land that hadn’t been damaged yet. Then, hearing that all the Celtiberians' supplies were stored in Saguntia, he went there to attack the town but was still unable to provoke any movement from them. So, after paying his own troops and those of Minucius, he left most of his army in the praetor's camp and returned to the Iberus with seven cohorts.

20

With that small force he took several towns. The Sidetonians, Ausetanians, and Suessetanians came over to his side. The Lacetanians, a remote and wild nation, still remained in arms; partly through their natural ferocity, and partly through consciousness of guilt, in having laid waste, by sudden incursions, the country of the allies, while the consul and his army were employed in the war with the Turditanians. He therefore marched to attack their capital, not only with the Roman cohorts, but also with the troops of the allies, who were justly incensed against them. The town was stretched out into considerable length, but had not proportionable breadth. At the distance of about four hundred paces from it he halted, and leaving there a party composed of chosen cohorts, he charged them not to stir from that spot until he himself should come to them; and then he led round the rest of the men to the farther side of the town. The greater part of his auxiliary troops were Suessetanians, and these he ordered to advance and assault the wall. The Lacetanians, knowing their arms and standards, and remembering how often they had themselves, with impunity, committed every kind of outrage and insult in their territory, how often defeated and routed them in pitched battles, hastily threw open a gate, and all, in one body, rushed out against them. The Suessetanians scarcely stood their shout, much less their onset; and the consul, on seeing this happen, just as he had foreseen, galloped back under the enemy's wall to his cohorts, brought them up quickly to that part of the city where all was silence and solitude, in consequence of the Lacetanians having sallied out on the Suessetanians, and took possession of every part of it before the Lacetanians returned; who, having nothing now left but their arms, soon surrendered themselves also.

With that small force, he captured several towns. The Sidetonians, Ausetanians, and Suessetanians joined him. The Lacetanians, a remote and wild people, still remained armed; partly due to their natural violence, and partly because they felt guilty for laying waste to the allies' territory through sudden attacks while the consul and his army were busy fighting the Turditanians. He decided to attack their capital, not only with the Roman cohorts but also with the troops of the allies, who were understandably angry with them. The town was elongated but not very wide. About four hundred paces away, he stopped and left a group of selected cohorts, instructing them not to move from that spot until he returned. He then led the rest of the soldiers around to the far side of the town. Most of his auxiliary troops were Suessetanians, whom he ordered to move forward and attack the wall. The Lacetanians, recognizing their weapons and standards, and recalling how often they had previously committed various outrages and insults in their territory with impunity—and how they had frequently defeated them in open battles—quickly opened a gate and rushed out in a group against them. The Suessetanians could barely withstand their shout, let alone their charge; and when the consul saw this, just as he had anticipated, he rode back under the enemy's wall to his cohorts, quickly brought them to the part of the city that was quiet and empty after the Lacetanians had rushed out against the Suessetanians, and took control of all of it before the Lacetanians returned. With nothing left but their weapons, they soon surrendered as well.

21

The conqueror marched thence, without delay, to the fort of Vergium. This was, almost entirely, a receptacle of robbers and plunderers, and thence incursions were made on the peaceable parts of the province. One of the principal inhabitants deserted out of the place to the consul, and endeavoured to excuse himself and his countrymen; alleging, that "the management of affairs was not in their hands; for the robbers, having gained admittance, had reduced the fort entirely under their own power." The consul ordered him to return home, and pretend some plausible reason for having been absent; and then, "when he should see him advancing to the walls, and the robbers intent on defending the city, to seize the citadel with such men as favoured his party." This was executed according to his directions. The double alarm, from the Romans scaling the walls in front, and the citadel being seized on their rear, at once entirely confounded the barbarians. The consul, having taken possession of the place, ordered, that those who had secured the citadel should, with their relations, be set at liberty, and enjoy their property, the rest of the natives he commanded the quaestor to sell; and he put the robbers to death. Having restored quiet in the province, he settled the iron and silver mines on such a footing, that they produced a large revenue; and, in consequence of the regulations then made, the province daily increased in riches. On account of these services performed in Spain, the senate decreed a supplication for three days.

The conqueror marched immediately to the fort of Vergium. This place was mostly a hideout for robbers and looters, and from there, they launched attacks on the peaceful parts of the province. One of the main inhabitants deserted the fort and went to the consul, trying to explain himself and his fellow countrymen by claiming that “they didn’t manage the situation because the robbers had taken complete control of the fort.” The consul instructed him to go back home and come up with a believable reason for his absence. Then, he told him, “when you see me approaching the walls and the robbers focused on defending the city, seize the citadel with those who support your side.” This plan was executed as he had instructed. The sudden attack from the Romans climbing the walls in front and the capture of the citadel in the back completely overwhelmed the barbarians. After taking control of the area, the consul ordered that those who secured the citadel, along with their families, be set free and allowed to keep their property, while he commanded the quaestor to sell the rest of the locals, and he executed the robbers. After restoring peace in the province, he managed the iron and silver mines so they generated a significant income; as a result of these regulations, the province gradually became wealthier. For these services performed in Spain, the senate declared a three-day public celebration.

22

During this summer, the other consul, Lucius Valerius Flaccus, fought a pitched battle with a body of the Boians in Gaul, near the forest of Litanae, and gained a complete victory. Eight thousand of the Gauls are said to have been slain; the rest, desisting from further opposition, retired quietly to their several villages and lands. During the remainder of the summer, the consul kept his army near the Po, at Placentia and Cremona, and repaired the buildings in these cities which had been demolished in the war. While the affairs of Italy and Spain were in this posture, Titus Quinctius had spent the winter in Greece, in such a manner, that excepting the Aetolians, who neither had gained rewards of victory adequate to their hopes, nor were capable of being long contented with a state of quiet, all Greece, being in full enjoyment of the blessings of peace and liberty, were highly pleased with their present state; and they admired not more the Roman general's bravery in arms, than his temperance, justice, and moderation in victory. And now a decree of the senate was brought to him, containing a denunciation of war against Nabis the Lacedaemonian. On reading it, Quinctius summoned a convention of deputies from all the allied states, to be held, on a certain day, at Corinth. Whither when many persons of the first rank came together, from all quarters, forming a very full assembly, from which even the Aetolians were not absent, he addressed them in this manner:--"The Romans and Greeks, in the war which they waged against Philip, were united in affections and councils, and they had each no less their separate reasons for entering into it. For he had violated friendship with the Romans; first by aiding our enemies, the Carthaginians; and then by attacking our allies here: and, towards you, his conduct was such, that even if we had been willing to forget our own injuries, those offered by him to you would have constituted a sufficient occasion of war. But the business to be considered this day has relation wholly to yourselves: for the subject which I propose to your consideration is, whether you choose to suffer Argos, which, as you know, has been seized by Nabis, to remain under his dominion; or whether you judge it reasonable, that a city of such high reputation and antiquity, seated in the centre of Greece, should be restored to liberty, and placed in the same state with the rest of the cities of Peloponnesus and of Greece. This question, as you see, merely respects yourselves; it concerns not the Romans in any decree, excepting so far as the one city being left in subjection to tyranny hinders their glory, in having liberated Greece, from being full and complete. If, however, you are not moved by regard for that city, nor by the example, nor by the danger of the contagion of that evil spreading wider, we, for our parts, shall rest content. On this subject I desire your opinions, resolved to abide by whatever the majority of you shall determine."

During this summer, the other consul, Lucius Valerius Flaccus, fought a fierce battle against a group of Boians in Gaul, near the forest of Litanae, and achieved a total victory. It's believed that eight thousand Gauls were killed; the rest, ceasing further resistance, quietly returned to their villages and lands. For the remainder of the summer, the consul kept his army near the Po, at Placentia and Cremona, and repaired the buildings in these cities that had been destroyed in the war. While the situation in Italy and Spain was as it was, Titus Quinctius spent the winter in Greece in such a way that, aside from the Aetolians, who felt their victories did not meet their hopes and were not likely to stay content with peace, all of Greece enjoyed the blessings of peace and liberty and was very pleased with their situation. They admired not only the Roman general's bravery in battle but also his temperance, justice, and moderation in victory. Then a decree from the senate was presented to him, declaring war against Nabis the Lacedaemonian. After reading it, Quinctius called a meeting of representatives from all the allied states to be held on a specific day in Corinth. Many notable individuals from all around gathered for this very full assembly, including the Aetolians. He addressed them saying: "The Romans and Greeks, in the war against Philip, were united in their feelings and decisions, each with their own reasons for joining in. He had betrayed our friendship by first supporting our enemies, the Carthaginians, and then by attacking our allies here; and in his dealings with you, even if we had chosen to overlook our own injuries, the wrongs he committed against you would have justified going to war. However, today's discussion is entirely about you: The question I bring before you is whether you want to allow Argos, which, as you know, has been taken by Nabis, to remain under his control; or whether you think it makes sense for such a historically significant city, located at the heart of Greece, to be restored to freedom and placed on the same footing as the other cities of Peloponnesus and Greece. This issue, as you see, concerns you alone; it’s only related to the Romans in that allowing one city to remain under tyranny prevents us from fully claiming our achievements in liberating Greece. However, if you are not swayed by concern for that city, by the example it sets, or by the risk of that evil spreading further, we will be content. On this matter, I would like your opinions and am prepared to abide by whatever the majority decides."

23

After the address of the Roman general, the several deputies proceeded to give their opinions. The ambassador of the Athenians extolled, to the utmost of his power, and expressed the greatest gratitude for the kindness of the Romans towards Greece, "in having, when applied to for assistance, brought them succours against Philip; and now, without being applied to, voluntarily offering assistance against the tyrant Nabis." He at the same time severely censured the conduct of some, who, in their discourses, "depreciated those kindnesses, and propagated evil surmises of the future, when it would better become them rather to return thanks for the past." It was evident that this was pointed at the Aetolians: wherefore Alexander, deputy of that nation, having first inveighed against the Athenians, who, having formerly been the most strenuous supporters of liberty, now betrayed the general cause, for the sake of recommending themselves by flattery. He then complained that "the Achaeans, formerly soldiers of Philip, and lately, on the decline of his fortune, deserters from him, had regained possession of Corinth, and were so acting as that they might acquire Argos; while the Aetolians, who had first opposed their arms to Philip, who had always been allies of the Romans, and who had stipulated by treaty, that, on the Macedonian being conquered, the lands and cities should be theirs, were defrauded of Echinus and Pharsalus." He charged the Romans with insincerity, because, "while they put forth empty professions of establishing liberty, they held possession of Demetrias and Chalcis by their garrisons; though, when Philip hesitated to withdraw his garrisons from those places, they always urged against him that the Grecians would never be free while Demetrias, Chalcis, and Corinth were in the hands of the others. And, lastly, that they named Argos and Nabis merely as a pretext for remaining in Greece, and keeping their armies there. Let them carry away their legions to Italy; and the Aetolians were ready to undertake, either that Nabis should voluntarily withdraw his forces from Argos, on terms; or they would compel him by force of arms to comply with the unanimous judgment of Greece."

After the Roman general's speech, the various representatives began to share their views. The ambassador from Athens praised the Romans for their generous support of Greece, saying, "They came to our aid against Philip when we asked for help, and now they’re voluntarily offering assistance against the tyrant Nabis without us even asking." He also strongly criticized others who, in their speeches, "downplayed those kindnesses and spread negative predictions for the future, when they should be thanking the Romans for their past support." It was clear he was targeting the Aetolians. In response, Alexander, the representative from that region, first launched an attack on the Athenians, who once were the most passionate defenders of freedom but now betrayed the common cause to gain favor through flattery. He then expressed his frustration that "the Achaeans, who were once soldiers of Philip and just recently switched sides as he fell from power, regained control of Corinth and were trying to take Argos; while the Aetolians, who were the first to fight against Philip, who had always been allies of the Romans, and who had a treaty stating that once the Macedonians were defeated, the lands and cities would be theirs, were being denied Echinus and Pharsalus." He accused the Romans of hypocrisy, claiming, "While they make empty promises about establishing liberty, they still control Demetrias and Chalcis with their garrisons; yet, whenever Philip hesitated to pull his forces from those places, they always argued that the Greeks would never be free as long as Demetrias, Chalcis, and Corinth were under foreign control. Finally, they mentioned Argos and Nabis just as an excuse to remain in Greece and keep their armies here. They should send their legions back to Italy; the Aetolians are ready to either negotiate for Nabis to withdraw his troops from Argos or force him to comply with the collective decision of Greece."

24

This arrogant speech called up, first, Aristaenus, praetor of the Achaeans, who said:--"Forbid it, Jupiter, supremely good and great, and imperial Juno, the tutelar deity of Argos, that that city should be staked as a prize between the Lacedaemonian tyrant and the Aetolian plunderers, under such unhappy circumstances, that its being retaken by you should be productive of more calamitous consequences than its capture by him. Titus Quinctius, the sea lying between us, does not secure us from those robbers; what then will become of us, should they procure themselves a stronghold in the centre of Peloponnesus? They have nothing Grecian but the language, as they have nothing human but the shape. They live under customs and rites more brutally savage than any barbarians, nay, than wild beasts themselves. Wherefore, Romans, we beseech you, not only to recover Argos from Nabis, but also to establish the affairs of Greece on such a footing, as to leave these countries adequately secured from the robberies of the Aetolians." The rest concurring in these censures on the Aetolians, the Roman general said, that "he had himself intended to have answered them, but that he perceived all so highly incensed against those people, that the general resentment required rather to be appeased than irritated. Satisfied, therefore, with the sentiments entertained of the Romans, and of the Aetolians, he would simply put this question: What was the general opinion concerning war with Nabis, in case of his refusing to restore Argos to the Achaeans?" When all had pronounced for war, he recommended to them, to send in their shares of auxiliary troops, each state in proportion to its ability. He even sent an ambassador to the Aetolians; rather to make them disclose their sentiments, which was the actual result, than with any hope of obtaining their concurrence. He gave orders to the military tribunes, to bring up the army from Elatia. To the ambassadors of Antiochus, who, at this time, proposed to treat of an alliance, he answered, that "he could say nothing on the subject in the absence of the ten ambassadors. They must go to Rome, and apply to the senate."

This arrogant speech summoned, first, Aristaenus, the praetor of the Achaeans, who said: “Let’s hope Jupiter, who is supremely good and great, and imperial Juno, the protector of Argos, prevent that city from being gambled as a prize between the tyrant of Lacedaemon and the Aetolian raiders under such unfortunate circumstances, that reclaiming it by you would lead to worse outcomes than its capture by him. Titus Quinctius, the sea between us doesn’t protect us from those robbers; what will happen if they establish a stronghold in the heart of Peloponnesus? They have nothing Greek but the language, and nothing human but their appearance. They live under customs and rituals that are more brutal and savage than any barbarians, even more so than wild animals themselves. Therefore, Romans, we plead with you, not only to recover Argos from Nabis but also to ensure that Greece is secured from the Aetolian robberies.” The others agreed with this condemnation of the Aetolians, and the Roman general said that “he had planned to respond to them himself, but he saw that everyone was so furious with those people that the collective anger needed calming more than provoking. Therefore, satisfied with the views held about the Romans and the Aetolians, he would simply ask: What is the general opinion about going to war with Nabis if he refuses to return Argos to the Achaeans?” When everyone agreed on war, he advised them to send their shares of auxiliary troops, each state according to its ability. He even sent an ambassador to the Aetolians, not necessarily hoping to gain their agreement, but rather to find out their sentiments, which was his actual goal. He ordered the military tribunes to bring the army from Elatia. To the ambassadors from Antiochus, who at that time sought to negotiate an alliance, he replied that “he couldn’t say anything about it without the ten ambassadors present. They needed to go to Rome and consult the senate.”

25

As soon as the troops arrived from Elatia, Quinctius set out to lead them towards Argos. When near Cleonae he was met by the praetor, Aristaenus, with ten thousand Achaean foot and one thousand horse; and having joined forces, they pitched their camp at a small distance from thence. Next day they marched down into the plains of Argos, and fixed their post about four miles from that city. The commander of the Lacedaemonian garrison was Pythagoras, the tyrant's son-in-law, and his wife's brother; who, on the approach of the Romans, posted strong guards in both the citadels, for Argos has two, and in every other place that was commodious for defence, or exposed to danger. But, while thus employed, he could by no means dissemble the dread inspired by the approach of the Romans; and, to the alarm from abroad, was added an insurrection within. There was an Argive, named Damocles, a youth of more spirit than prudence, who held conversations, with proper persons, on a design of expelling the garrison; at first, with the precaution of imposing an oath, but afterwards, through his eager desire to add strength to the conspiracy, he estimated people's sincerity with too little caution. While he was in conference with his accomplices, an officer, sent by the commander of the garrison, summoned him to appear before him, and he perceived that his design was betrayed; on which, exhorting the conspirators, who were present, to take arms with him, rather than be tortured to death, he went on with a few companions towards the forum, crying out to all who wished the preservation of the state, to follow him as the vindicator and author of their liberty. He could prevail on none to join him; for they saw no prospect of any attainable advantage, and much less any sufficiently powerful support. While he exclaimed in this manner, the Lacedaemonians surrounded him and his party, and put them to death. Many others were afterwards seized, the greater part of whom were executed, and the remaining few thrown into prison. During the following night, great numbers, letting themselves down from the walls by ropes, came over to the Romans.

As soon as the troops arrived from Elatia, Quinctius set out to lead them towards Argos. Near Cleonae, he was joined by the praetor, Aristaenus, who brought ten thousand Achaean infantry and one thousand cavalry; together they set up camp a short distance away. The next day, they marched down into the plains of Argos and established their position about four miles from the city. The commander of the Lacedaemonian garrison was Pythagoras, the tyrant's son-in-law and his wife's brother. As the Romans approached, he stationed strong guards in both citadels—since Argos has two—and in any other locations advantageous for defense or likely to be threatened. However, despite his preparations, he couldn’t hide the fear that the Roman presence inspired. To this external threat was added an uprising from within. An Argive named Damocles, a young man more spirited than wise, began discussions with the right people about a plan to expel the garrison; initially, he was careful to secure their loyalty with an oath, but as his desire to strengthen the conspiracy grew, he became less cautious about assessing people’s sincerity. While he was meeting with his conspirators, an officer sent by the garrison's commander called for him to appear, and he realized that his scheme had been exposed. Urging the conspirators present to take up arms with him rather than face torture and death, he moved toward the forum with a few companions, shouting for anyone who wanted to save the state to follow him as the rescuer and champion of their freedom. Unfortunately, he couldn’t convince anyone to join him; they saw no chance of gaining anything and especially no powerful support. While he shouted this way, the Lacedaemonians surrounded him and his group and killed them. Many others were later captured, most of whom were executed, with the few remaining thrown into prison. During the following night, numerous individuals lowered themselves from the walls using ropes and defected to the Romans.

26

As these men affirmed, that if the Roman army had been at the gates, this commotion would not have ended without effect; and that, if the camp was brought nearer, the Argives would not remain inactive; Quinctius sent some horsemen and infantry, lightly accoutred, who, meeting at the Cylarabis, a place of exercise, less than three hundred paces from the city, a party of Lacedaemonians, who sallied out of a gate, engaged them, and, without much difficulty, drove them back into the town; and the Roman general encamped on the very spot where the battle had been fought. There he passed one day, on the look-out if any new commotion might arise; but perceiving that the inhabitants were quite depressed by fear, he called a council concerning the besieging of Argos. All the deputies of Greece, except Aristaenus, were of one opinion, that, as that city was the sole object of the war, with it the war should commence. This was by no means agreeable to Quinctius; but he listened, with evident marks of approbation, to Aristaenus, arguing in opposition to the joint opinion of all the rest; while he himself added, that "as the war was undertaken in favour of the Argives, against the tyrant, what could be less proper than to leave the enemy in quiet, and lay siege to Argos? For his part, he was resolved to point his arms against the main object of the war, Lacedaemon and the tyrant." He then dismissed the meeting, and sent out light-armed cohorts to collect forage. Whatever was ripe in the adjacent country, they reaped, and brought together; and what was green they trod down and destroyed, that the enemy might not subsequently get it. He then proceeded over Mount Parthenius, and, passing by Tegaea, encamped on the third day at Caryae; where he waited for the auxiliary troops of the allies, before he entered the enemy's territory. Fifteen hundred Macedonians came from Philip, and four hundred horsemen of the Thessalians; and now the Roman general had no occasion to wait for more auxiliaries, having abundance; but he was obliged to stop for supplies of provisions, which he had ordered the neighbouring cities to furnish. He was joined also by a powerful naval force; Lucius Quinctius had already come from Leucas, with forty ships; eighteen ships of war had arrived from the Rhodians; and king Eumenes was cruising among the Cyclades, with ten decked ships, thirty barks, and smaller vessels of various sorts. Of the Lacedaemonians themselves, also, a great many, who had been driven from home by the cruelty of the tyrants, came into the Roman camp, in hopes of being reinstated in their country; for the number was very great of those who had been banished by the several despots, during many generations since they first got Lacedaemon into their power. The principal person among the exiles was Agesipolis, to whom the sovereignty of Lacedaemon belonged in right of his birth; but who had been driven out when an infant by Lycurgus, after the death of Cleomenes, who was the first tyrant of Lacedaemon.

As these men confirmed, if the Roman army had been at the gates, this disturbance wouldn't have ended without consequences; and if the camp was moved closer, the Argives wouldn't stay idle. Quinctius sent some lightly armed horsemen and infantry who, meeting a group of Lacedaemonians coming out of a gate at Cylarabis, a training ground less than three hundred paces from the city, engaged them and, without much effort, pushed them back into the town. The Roman general then set up camp right where the battle had taken place. He stayed there for a day, watching to see if any new disturbances might arise; but noticing that the locals were completely overwhelmed by fear, he called a council to discuss the siege of Argos. All the Greek representatives, except for Aristaenus, agreed that since Argos was the main focus of the war, that city should be the starting point for the campaign. Quinctius did not agree with this at all; however, he listened with clear approval to Aristaenus, who argued against the general consensus. Quinctius then added, "Since the war was started in support of the Argives against the tyrant, what could be more inappropriate than to leave the enemy undisturbed and lay siege to Argos? For my part, I intend to direct my forces against the true target of this war: Lacedaemon and the tyrant." He then dismissed the meeting and sent out light-armed troops to gather supplies. They harvested whatever was ripe in the surrounding countryside and destroyed anything green to prevent the enemy from benefiting later. He then crossed Mount Parthenius and, after passing by Tegaea, set up camp three days later at Caryae, waiting for the allied auxiliary troops before he entered enemy territory. Fifteen hundred Macedonians arrived from Philip, along with four hundred Thessalian cavalry; now the Roman general had more than enough auxiliary support. However, he needed to wait for supplies, which he had asked the nearby cities to provide. He was also joined by a strong naval force; Lucius Quinctius had come from Leucas with forty ships, eighteen war ships had arrived from Rhodes, and King Eumenes was operating in the Cyclades with ten decked ships, thirty barks, and various smaller vessels. Additionally, many Lacedaemonians, driven from their homes by the cruelty of the tyrants, came into the Roman camp, hoping for a chance to return to their country; many had been banished by various despots over generations since they first took control of Lacedaemon. The most notable among the exiles was Agesipolis, who had the birthright to the sovereignty of Lacedaemon but had been driven out when he was just a baby by Lycurgus, following the death of Cleomenes, the first tyrant of Lacedaemon.

27

Although Nabis was enclosed between such powerful armaments on land and sea, and, on a comparative view of his own and his enemy's strength, could scarcely conceive any degree of hope; yet he did not desist from the war, but brought, from Crete, a thousand chosen young men of that country in addition to a thousand whom he had before; he had, besides, under arms, three thousand mercenary soldiers, and ten thousand of his countrymen, with the peasants, who belonged to the fortresses. He fortified the city with a ditch and rampart; and lest any intestine commotion should arise, curbed the people's spirits by fear, punishing them with extreme severity, as he could not hope for good wishes towards a tyrant. As he had his suspicions respecting some of the citizens, he drew out all his forces to a field called Dromos, (the course,) and ordered the Lacedaemonians to be called to an assembly without their arms. He then formed a line of armed men round the place where they were assembled, observing briefly, "that he ought to be excused, if, at such a juncture, he feared and guarded against every thing that might happen; and that, if the present state of affairs subjected any to suspicion, it was their advantage to be prevented from attempting any design, rather than to be punished for attempting it: he therefore intended," he said, "to keep certain persons in custody, until the storm, which then threatened, should have passed over; and would discharge them as soon as the enemy should have been driven away, from whom the danger would be less, when proper precaution was taken against internal treachery." He then ordered the names of about eighty of the principal young men to be called over, and as each answered to his name, he put them in custody. On the night following, they were all put to death. Some of the Helotes, a race of rustics, who have been feudal vassals even from the earliest times, being charged with an intention to desert, they were driven with stripes through all the streets, and put to death. The terror which this excited so confounded the multitude, as to deter them from all attempts to effect a revolution. He kept his forces within the fortifications, knowing that he was not a match for the enemy in the field; and, besides, he was afraid to leave the city, while all men's minds were in a state of such suspense and uncertainty.

Although Nabis was surrounded by powerful weapons on land and sea, and given a comparison of his own and his enemy's strength, he could hardly feel any hope; still, he did not back down from the war. Instead, he brought in a thousand selected young men from Crete, adding to a thousand he already had. He also had three thousand mercenary soldiers and ten thousand of his countrymen, along with the peasants from the fortresses. He reinforced the city with a ditch and rampart; and to prevent any internal unrest, he controlled the people's spirits through fear, punishing them harshly, knowing he couldn't rely on goodwill towards a tyrant. Suspecting some citizens, he gathered all his forces in a field called Dromos (the course) and summoned the Lacedaemonians to an assembly without their weapons. He then formed a line of armed men around the assembly and stated briefly that he should be excused if, during such a critical time, he was cautious and guarded against potential problems. He said that if the current situation cast suspicion on anyone, it was better for them to be stopped from attempting anything rather than punished for trying. He planned to hold certain individuals in custody until the threat passed and would release them once the enemy was driven away, noting that they would be less dangerous if precautions were taken against internal betrayal. He then ordered the names of about eighty of the key young men to be called, and as each responded, he had them detained. The following night, they were all executed. Some of the Helotes, a group of rustic serfs who had been vassals for a long time, were accused of intending to desert. They were flogged through the streets and killed. The terror this caused so intimidated the crowd that it deterred them from any attempts to start a revolution. He kept his forces within the fortifications, knowing he was outmatched by the enemy in open combat, and was also too afraid to leave the city while everyone was in such a state of suspense and uncertainty.

28

Quinctius, when all his preparations were now sufficiently made, decamped; and, on the second day, came to Sellasia, on the river Oenus, on the spot where it is said Antigonus, king of Macedonia, fought a pitched battle with Cleomenes, tyrant of Lacedaemon. Being told that the ascent from thence was difficult, and the passes narrow, he made a short circuit by the mountains, sending forward a party to make a road, and came, by a tolerably broad and open passage, to the river Eurotas, where it flows almost immediately under the walls of the city. Here, the tyrant's auxiliary troops attacked the Romans, while they were forming their camp, together with Quinctius himself, (who, with a division of cavalry and light troops, had advanced beyond the rest,) and threw them into a state of alarm and confusion; not expecting any thing of the kind, as no one had opposed them throughout their whole march, and they had passed, as it were, through a friendly territory. The disorder lasted a considerable time the infantry calling for aid on the cavalry, and the cavalry on the infantry, each having but little confidence in himself. At length, the foremost ranks of the legions came up; and no sooner had the cohorts of the vanguard taken part in the fight, than those who had lately been an object of dread were driven back in terror into the city. The Romans, retiring so far from the wall as to be out of the reach of weapons, stood there for some time in battle-array; and then, none of the enemy coming out against them, retired to their camp. Next day Quinctius led on his army in regular order along the bank of the river, passed the city, to the foot of the mountain of Menelaus, the legionary cohorts marching in front, and the cavalry and light infantry bringing up the rear. Nabis kept his mercenary troops, on whom he placed his whole reliance, in readiness, and drawn up in a body, within the walls, intending to attack the rear of the enemy; and, as soon as the last of their troops passed by, these rushed out of the town, from several places at once, with as great fury as the day before. The rear was commanded by Appius Claudius, who having beforehand prepared his men to expect such an event, that it might not come upon them unawares, instantly made his troops face about, and presented an entire front to the enemy. A regular engagement, therefore, took place, as if two complete lines had encountered, and it lasted a considerable time; but at length Nabis's troops betook themselves to flight, which would have been attended with less dismay and danger, if they had not been closely pressed by the Achaeans, who were well acquainted with the ground. These made dreadful havoc, and dispersing them entirely, obliged the greater part to throw away their arms. Quinctius encamped near Amyclae; and afterwards, when he had utterly laid waste all the pleasant and thickly inhabited country round the city, not one of the enemy venturing out of the gates, he removed his camp to the river Eurotas. From thence he ravaged the valley lying under Taygetus, and the country reaching as far as the sea.

Quinctius, having completed all his preparations, broke camp and, on the second day, arrived at Sellasia, by the Oenus River, at the site where it is said Antigonus, the king of Macedonia, fought a major battle against Cleomenes, the tyrant of Lacedaemon. He was informed that the climb ahead was tough and the paths narrow, so he took a detour through the mountains, sending a team ahead to clear a path, and reached the Eurotas River, where it flows just below the city's walls. At this point, the tyrant’s allied troops attacked the Romans as they were setting up camp, including Quinctius himself, who had advanced ahead with a division of cavalry and light infantry. This caught them off guard and caused panic, as they hadn’t expected any opposition during their entire march and had felt as if they were passing through friendly territory. The chaos continued for a while, with infantry calling for help from cavalry and vice versa, both sides lacking confidence. Eventually, the front ranks of the legions arrived; as soon as the leading cohorts joined the fight, those who had recently struck fear into the Romans were driven back in terror into the city. The Romans then retreated far enough from the walls to be out of reach of projectiles, maintaining their battle formation for some time, and when no enemy emerged to challenge them, they returned to their camp. The next day, Quinctius advanced his army in formation along the riverbank, passed the city, and moved to the foot of Menelaus Mountain, with the legionary cohorts at the front and the cavalry and light infantry at the rear. Nabis had his mercenary troops, whom he relied on completely, ready and assembled within the city walls, planning to attack the rear of the enemy. As soon as the last Roman troops had passed, they surged out of the town from multiple points, attacking with as much ferocity as the day before. Appius Claudius commanded the rear and, having prepared his men for this possibility to avoid being caught off guard, quickly turned his troops to face the enemy. A full-on battle ensued, as if two complete lines of soldiers had collided, and it lasted quite some time; however, eventually Nabis's troops fled, which might have been less panicked and dangerous if they hadn't been closely pursued by the Achaeans, who knew the terrain well. They caused a terrible massacre, scattering the mercenaries and forcing many to discard their weapons. Quinctius then camped near Amyclae, and after completely ravaging all the fertile and densely populated areas around the city, with no enemy daring to emerge from the gates, he moved his camp to the Eurotas River. From there, he devastated the valley beneath Taygetus and the land extending to the sea.

29

About the same time, Lucius Quinctius got possession of the towns on the sea-coast; of some, by their voluntary surrender; of others, by fear or force. Then, learning that the Lacedaemonians made Gythium the repository of all their naval stores, and that the Roman camp was at no great distance from the sea, he resolved to attack that town with his whole force. It was, at that time, a place of considerable strength; well furnished with great numbers of native inhabitants and settlers from other parts, and with every kind of warlike stores. Very seasonably for Quinctius, when commencing an enterprise of no easy nature, king Eumenes and the Rhodian fleet came to his assistance. The vast multitude of seamen, collected out of the three fleets, finished in a few days all the works requisite for the siege of a city so strongly fortified, both on the land side and on that next the sea. Covered galleries were soon brought up; the wall was undermined, and, at the same time, shaken with battering rams. By the frequent shocks given with these, one of the towers was thrown down, and, by its fall, the adjoining wall on each side was laid flat. The Romans, on this, attempted to force in, both on the side next the port, to which the approach was more level than to the rest, hoping to divert the enemy's attention from the more open passage, and, at the same time, to enter the breach caused by the falling of the wall. They were near effecting their design of penetrating into the town, when the assault was suspended by the prospect which was held out of the surrender of the city. This however, was subsequently dissipated. Dexagoridas and Gorgopas commanded there, with equal authority. Dexagoridas had sent to the Roman general a message that he would give up the city; and, after the time and the mode of proceeding had been agreed on, he was slain as a traitor by Gorgopas, and the defence of the city was maintained with redoubled vigour by this single commander. The further prosecution of the siege would have been much more difficult, had not Titus Quinctius arrived with a body of four thousand chosen men. He showed his army in order of battle, on the brow of a hill at a small distance from the city; and, on the other side, Lucius Quinctius plied the enemy hard with his engines, both on the quarter of the sea, and of the land; on which Gorgopas was compelled to adopt that proceeding, which, in the case of another, he had punished with death. After stipulating for liberty to carry away the soldiers whom he had there as a garrison, he surrendered the city to Quinctius. Previous to the surrender of Gythium, Pythagoras, who had been left as commander at Argos, having intrusted the defence of the city to Timocrates of Pellene, with a thousand mercenary soldiers and two thousand Argives, came to Lacedaemon and joined Nabis.

About the same time, Lucius Quinctius took control of the coastal towns; some surrendered voluntarily, while others did so out of fear or force. Then, he learned that the Lacedaemonians had made Gythium their main supply hub for naval resources, and since the Roman camp was not too far from the sea, he decided to attack the town with his full force. At that time, Gythium was a stronghold, populated with many locals and settlers from various regions, as well as equipped with all kinds of military supplies. Fortunately for Quinctius, just as he was starting this challenging mission, King Eumenes and the Rhodian fleet came to support him. The large number of sailors gathered from the three fleets quickly completed all the necessary preparations for the siege of such a well-fortified city, both on the land side and the sea side. Covered galleries were erected, the wall was undermined, and at the same time, it was battered with rams. The repeated impacts caused one of the towers to collapse, which in turn brought down the nearby wall on both sides. The Romans attempted to break in, particularly on the side facing the port where access was easier than other areas, hoping to draw the enemy's attention away from the more open route while simultaneously exploiting the breach from the wall's collapse. They were close to succeeding when their assault was halted by a promise of the city’s surrender. However, this hope quickly faded. Dexagoridas and Gorgopas were in charge there, sharing power equally. Dexagoridas had sent a message to the Roman general offering to surrender the city, and after they had agreed on the time and method, he was killed as a traitor by Gorgopas, who then strengthened the city’s defense with renewed determination. Continuing the siege would have been much tougher if Titus Quinctius hadn’t arrived with four thousand elite troops. He had his army positioned on the hillside not far from the city, while Lucius Quinctius pressed hard against the enemy with his siege engines from both land and sea. Under pressure, Gorgopas was forced to do what he had previously executed others for: after negotiating the terms to take his soldiers, he surrendered the city to Quinctius. Before Gythium surrendered, Pythagoras, who had been left in charge at Argos and had entrusted the city's defense to Timocrates of Pellene with a thousand mercenaries and two thousand Argives, traveled to Lacedaemon to join Nabis.

30

Although Nabis had been greatly alarmed at the first arrival of the Roman fleet, and the surrender of the towns on the sea-coast, yet, as long as Gythium was held by his troops he had quieted his apprehensions with that scanty hope; but when he heard that Gythium, too, was given up to the Romans, and saw that he had no room for any kind of hope on the land, where every place round was in the hands of the enemy, and that he was totally excluded from the sea, he considered that he must yield to fortune. He first sent a messenger into the Roman camp, to learn whether permission would be given to send ambassadors. This being consented to, Pythagoras came to the general, with no other commission than to propose a conference between that commander and the tyrant. A council was summoned on the proposal, and every one present agreeing in opinion that a conference should be granted, a time and place were appointed. They came, with moderate escorts, to some hills in the interjacent ground; and leaving their cohorts there, in posts open to the view of both parties, they went down to the place of meeting; Nabis attended by a select party of his body-guards; Quinctius by his brother, king Eumenes, Sosilaus, the Rhodian, Aristaenus, praetor of the Achaeans, and a few military tribunes.

Although Nabis was very alarmed by the initial arrival of the Roman fleet and the surrender of the towns along the coast, as long as Gythium was under his control, he managed to calm his fears with that slim hope. But when he heard that Gythium had also fallen to the Romans and realized he had no hope left on land, where everything was in the enemy's hands, and that he was completely shut out from the sea, he felt he had to submit to fate. He first sent a messenger to the Roman camp to find out if he could send ambassadors. Once he got permission, Pythagoras approached the general with the sole purpose of suggesting a meeting between that commander and the tyrant. A council was called to discuss the proposal, and everyone present agreed that a meeting should take place, so a time and place were set. They approached the meeting spot, with moderate escorts, to some hills in the area between them; leaving their troops in positions visible to both sides, they went down to the meeting place. Nabis was accompanied by a chosen group of his bodyguards, while Quinctius was with his brother, King Eumenes, Sosilaus the Rhodian, Aristaenus, the praetor of the Achaeans, and a few military tribunes.

31

Then the tyrant, having the choice given him either to speak first or to listen, began thus: "Titus Quinctius, and you who are present, if I could collect from my own reflections the reason of your having either declared or actually made war against me, I should have waited in silence the issue of my destiny. But in the present state of things, I could not repress my desire of knowing, before I am ruined, the cause for which my ruin is resolved on. And in truth, if you were such men as the Carthaginians are represented to be,--men who considered the obligation of faith, pledged in alliances, as in no degree sacred, I should not wonder if you were the less scrupulous with respect to your conduct towards me. But, instead of that, when I look at you, I perceive that you are Romans: men who allow treaties to be the most solemn of religious acts, and faith, pledged therein, the strongest of human ties. Then, when I look back at myself, I am confident I am one who, as a member of the community, am, in common with the rest of the Lacedaemonians, included in a treaty subsisting with you, of very ancient date; and likewise have, lately, during the war with Philip, concluded anew, in my own name, a personal friendship and alliance with you. But it appears I have violated and cancelled that treaty, by holding possession of the city of Argos. In what manner shall I defend this? By the consideration of the fact, or of the time. The consideration of the fact furnishes me with a twofold defence: for, in the first place, in consequence of an invitation from the inhabitants themselves, and of their voluntary act of surrender, I accepted the possession of that city, and did not seize it by force. In the next place, I accepted it, when the city was in league with Philip, not in alliance with you. Then the consideration of the time acquits me, inasmuch as when I was in actual possession of Argos, the alliance was entered into between you and me, and you stipulated that I should send you aid against Philip, not that I should withdraw my garrison from that city. In this dispute, therefore, so far as it relates to Argos, I have unquestionably the advantage, both from the equity of the proceeding, as I gained possession of a city which belonged not to you, but to your enemy; and as I gained it by its own voluntary act, and not by forcible compulsion; and also from your own acknowledgment; since, in the articles of our alliance, you left Argos to me. But then, the name of tyrant, and my conduct, are strong objections against me: that I call forth slaves to a state of freedom; that I carry out the indigent part of the populace, and give them settlements in lands. With respect to the title by which I am styled, I can answer thus: That, let me be what I may, I am the same now that I was at the time when you yourself, Titus Quinctius, concluded an alliance with me. I remember, that I was then styled king by you; now, I see, I am called tyrant. If, therefore, I had since altered the style of my office, I might have an account to render of my fickleness: as you choose to alter it, that account should be rendered by you. As to what relates to the augmenting the number of the populace, by giving liberty to slaves, and the distribution of lands to the needy; on this head, too, I might defend myself by a reference to time: These measures, of what complexion soever they are, I had practised before you formed friendship with me, and received my aid in the war against Philip. But, if I did these same things, at this moment, I would not say to you, how did I thereby injure you, or violate the friendship subsisting between us? but that, in so doing, I acted agreeably to the practice and institutions of my ancestors. Do not estimate what is done at Lacedaemon by the standard of your own laws and constitution. There is no necessity for comparing particular institutions: you are guided in your choice of a horseman, by the quantity of his property; in your choice of a foot soldier, by the quantity of his property; and your plan is, that a few should abound in wealth, and that the body of the people should be in subjection to them. Our lawgiver did not choose that the administration of government should be in the hands of a few, such as you call a senate; or that this or that order of citizens should have a superiority over the rest: but he considered that, by equalizing the property and dignity of all, he should multiply the number of those who were to bear arms for their country. I acknowledge that I have enlarged on these matters, beyond what consists with the conciseness customary with my countrymen, and that the sum of the whole might be comprised in few words: that, since I first commenced a friendship with you, I have given you no just cause to repent it."

Then the tyrant, faced with the choice to speak first or listen, began: "Titus Quinctius and all of you present, if I could figure out for myself the reason why you declared or went to war against me, I would have waited silently for my fate to unfold. But given the current situation, I couldn’t hold back my desire to know the reason behind my impending ruin before it happens. Honestly, if you were like the Carthaginians, who don’t consider their alliances to be sacred, I wouldn’t be surprised if you acted with less integrity toward me. However, when I look at you, I see you are Romans: people who treat treaties as the most solemn of religious commitments, and honor within them as the strongest of human ties. Furthermore, when I reflect on my own situation, I am confident that as a member of the community, I am included, along with the other Lacedaemonians, under a very old treaty with you; and additionally, I have recently formed a personal friendship and alliance with you during my war with Philip. Yet it seems I have broken that treaty by taking control of the city of Argos. How can I defend this? By considering the fact or the timing. Regarding the fact, I have a strong defense: first, I took possession of the city in response to an invitation from its inhabitants, who voluntarily surrendered it to me, rather than seizing it by force. Second, I gained it while the city was allied with Philip and not with you. As for the timing, I am justified because at the time I was in control of Argos, I entered into an alliance with you, which involved you asking for my support against Philip, not requiring me to withdraw my forces from that city. Therefore, in this matter concerning Argos, I clearly hold the advantage, both from the fairness of the situation—since I gained control of a city that didn’t belong to you but to your enemy, and I did so not through force but by the city’s own will—and also based on your own acknowledgment; since in our alliance, you assigned Argos to me. However, the title of tyrant and my actions are significant challenges against me: that I call forth slaves to seek freedom, that I remove the needy from the populace and provide them with land. Regarding the title I am given, I can respond like this: No matter what I may be called, I am the same person I was when you, Titus Quinctius, established an alliance with me. I remember that you referred to me as king then; now, I see I am called a tyrant. If I have changed the title of my position since then, I would owe you an explanation for my inconsistency; since you choose to change it, that explanation should come from you. When it comes to increasing the population by granting freedom to slaves and distributing land to the less fortunate, I could also defend myself by referencing time: These actions, whatever they may be, were practiced by me before you formed a friendship with me and accepted my help in the war against Philip. However, if I did the same things now, I wouldn’t need to ask how I harmed you or violated our friendship; I would argue that I am acting in line with the customs and practices of my ancestors. Don’t judge what happens in Lacedaemon by the standards of your own laws and constitution. There’s no need to compare specific institutions: you choose your cavalry based on wealth, and your infantry is also chosen based on how much property they have; your approach allows a few to be wealthy while the majority are subject to them. Our lawgiver didn’t want the government to be in the hands of a select few, as you call a senate; nor did he believe any particular class of citizens should dominate the others: instead, he thought that by equalizing the wealth and status of everyone, he would increase the number of those willing to fight for their country. I admit I may have elaborated more than what is customary for the succinctness expected from my people, and that the essence could be expressed in fewer words: since I first began a friendship with you, I have given you no valid reason to regret it."

32

The Roman general answered: "We never contracted any friendship or alliance with you, but with Pelops, the right and lawful king of Lacedaemon: whose authority, while the Carthaginian, Gallic, and other wars, succeeding one another, kept us constantly employed, the tyrants, who after him held Lacedaemon under forced subjection, usurped into their own hands, as did you also during the late war with Macedonia. For what could be less fitting, than that we, who were waging war against Philip, in favour of the liberty of Greece, should contract friendship with a tyrant, and a tyrant the most cruel and violent towards his subjects that ever existed? But, even supposing that you had not either seized or held Argos by iniquitous means, it would be incumbent on us, when we are giving liberty to all Greece, to reinstate Lacedaemon also in its ancient freedom, and the enjoyment of its own laws, which you just now spoke of, as if you were a rival of Lycurgus. Shall we take pains to make Philip's garrisons evacuate Tassus and Bargylii; and shall we leave Lacedaemon and Argos, those two most illustrious cities, formerly the lights of Greece, under your feet, that their continuance in bondage may tarnish our title of deliverers of Greece? But the Argives took part with Philip: we excuse you from taking any concern in that cause, so that you need not be angry with them on our behalf. We have received sufficient proof, that the guilt of that proceeding is chargeable on two only, or, at most, three persons, and not on the state; just, indeed, as in the case of the invitation given to you and to your army, and your reception into the citadel, not one step was taken by public authority. We know, that the Thessalians, Phocians, and Locrians, with unanimous consent, joined in espousing the cause of Philip; yet we have given liberty to them in common with the rest of Greece. How then can you suppose we shall conduct ourselves towards the Argives, who are acquitted of having publicly authorized misconduct? You said, that your inviting slaves to liberty, and the distribution of lands among the indigent, were objected to you as crimes; and crimes, surely, they are, of no small magnitude. But what are they in comparison with those atrocious deeds, that are daily perpetrated by you and your adherents, in continual succession? Show us a free assembly of the people, either at Argos or Lacedaemon, if you wish to hear a true recital of the crimes of the most abandoned tyranny. To omit all other instances of older date, what a massacre did your son-in-law, Pythagoras, make at Argos almost before my eyes! What another did you yourself perpetrate, when I was nearly within the confines of the Lacedaemonians! Now, give orders, that the persons whom you took out of the midst of an assembly, and committed to prison, after declaring, in the hearing of all your countrymen, that you would keep them in custody, be produced in their chains, that their wretched parents may know that those are alive, for whom, under a false impression, they are mourning. Well, but you say, though all these things were so, Romans, how do they concern you? Can you say this to the deliverers of Greece; to people who crossed the sea, and have maintained a war on sea and land, to effect its deliverance? Still you tell us, you have not directly violated the alliance, or the friendship established between us. How many instances must I produce of your having done so? But I will not go into long detail; I will bring the matter to a short issue. By what acts is friendship violated? Most effectually by these two: by treating our friends as foes; and by uniting yourself with our enemies. Each of these has been done by you. For Messene, which had been united to us in friendship, by one and the same bond of alliance with Lacedaemon, you, while professing yourself our ally, reduced to subjection by force of arms, though you knew it was in alliance with us; and you contracted with Philip, our professed enemy, not only an alliance, but even an affinity, through the intervention of his general, Philocles: and waging actual war against us, with your piratical ships, you made the sea round Malea unsafe, and you captured and slew more Roman citizens almost than Philip himself; and to our ships conveying provisions to our armies the coast of Macedonia itself was less dangerous, than the promontory of Malea. Cease, therefore, to vaunt your good faith, and the obligations of treaties; and, dropping a popular style of discourse, speak as a tyrant, and as an enemy."

The Roman general replied, "We never formed any friendship or alliance with you, but with Pelops, the rightful and lawful king of Lacedaemon. While we were busy with the Carthaginian, Gallic, and other wars one after the other, the tyrants who took over Lacedaemon after him kept it under their forced control, just like you did during the recent war with Macedonia. What could be more inappropriate than for those of us fighting against Philip for the freedom of Greece to become friends with a tyrant, especially one who is the most cruel and violent toward his subjects in history? Even if you hadn't illegally seized or held Argos, we would still have the obligation, while granting liberty to all of Greece, to restore Lacedaemon to its ancient freedom and the enjoyment of its own laws, which you just claimed as if you were a rival of Lycurgus. Should we work to make Philip's garrisons leave Tassus and Bargylii, while leaving Lacedaemon and Argos, those two great cities that were once the beacons of Greece, under your oppression, thus tarnishing our title as liberators of Greece? But the Argives sided with Philip: we excuse you from worrying about that, so you need not be upset with them on our behalf. We've seen enough evidence to know that only two or, at most, three people are responsible for that, and not the state itself; just like with the invitation you received and your acceptance into the citadel, which was not sanctioned by any public authority. We understand that the Thessalians, Phocians, and Locrians collectively supported Philip's cause; still, we granted them freedom alongside the rest of Greece. So how do you think we will treat the Argives, who haven't publicly condoned any wrongdoing? You mentioned that your offers of freedom to slaves and land distribution among the poor have been criticized as crimes; and rightly so, they are significant offenses. But how do they compare to the horrible acts that you and your supporters commit daily in succession? Show us a genuine assembly of the people, either at Argos or Lacedaemon, if you want to hear an honest account of the crimes of the most disgraceful tyranny. To leave out other earlier examples, look at the massacre your son-in-law Pythagoras carried out at Argos almost before my eyes! What about the other massacre you committed when I was nearly within Lacedaemon's borders! Now, order that the people you took from the assembly and imprisoned be brought before us in chains, so their desperate parents can know that those whom they believe to be dead are actually alive. However, you say, despite all this, how does it concern you, Romans? Can you say this to the liberators of Greece; to those who crossed the sea and waged war on land and sea for its freedom? Yet you claim not to have directly violated the alliance or friendship we established. How many examples must I provide to prove you've done so? But I won’t go into a lengthy argument; let’s get to the point. What actions violate friendship? Primarily two: treating our friends as enemies and aligning with our foes. You’ve done both. For Messene, which was allied with us and Lacedaemon, you, while claiming to be our ally, subdued it by force, knowing it was allied with us; and you entered into an alliance with Philip, our declared enemy, even forming a connection with him through his general, Philocles. You waged actual war against us with your pirate ships, making the sea around Malea dangerous, capturing and killing more Roman citizens than Philip himself did; in fact, the coast of Macedonia was safer for our supply ships than the promontory of Malea. So stop boasting about your loyalty and the obligations of treaties; and, instead of speaking in a popular tone, talk like a tyrant and an enemy."

33

Aristaenus then began, at first to advise, and afterwards even to beseech Nabis, while it was yet in his power, and he had the opportunity, to consider what was best for himself and his interests. He then mentioned the names of several tyrants in the neighbouring states who had resigned their authority, and restored liberty to their people, and afterwards spent among their fellow citizens not only a secure but an honoured old age. These observations having been reciprocally made and listened to, the approach of night broke up the conference. Next day Nabis said, that he was willing to cede Argos, and withdraw his garrison, since such was the desire of the Romans, and to deliver up the prisoners and deserters; and if they demanded any thing further, he requested that they would set it down in writing, that he might deliberate on it with his friends. Thus the tyrant gained time for consultation; and Quinctius also, on his part, called a council, to which he summoned the chiefs of the allies. The greatest part were of opinion, that "they ought to persevere in the war, and that the tyrant should be altogether got rid of; otherwise the liberty of Greece would never be secure. That it would have been much better never to have entered on the war than to drop it after it was begun; for this would be a kind of approbation of his tyrannical usurpation, and which would establish him more firmly, as giving the countenance of the Roman people to his ill-acquired authority, and that he would quickly spirit up many in other states to plot against the liberty of their countrymen." The wishes of the general himself tended rather to peace; for he saw that, as the enemy was shut up in the town, nothing remained but a siege, and that must be very tedious. For it was not Gythium that they must besiege, though even that place had been gained by capitulation, not by assault; but Lacedaemon, a city most powerful in men and arms. The only hope which they could have formed was, that, on the first approach of their army, dissensions and insurrections might have been raised within: but, though the standards had been seen to advance almost to the gates, not one person had stirred. To this he added, that "Villius the ambassador, returning from Antiochus, brought intelligence, that the peace was an unsound one; and that the king had come over into Europe with a much more powerful armament by sea and land than before. Now, if the army should be engaged in the siege of Lacedaemon, with what other forces could the war be maintained against a king of his great power and strength?" These arguments he urged openly; but beneath all this there lay a concealed anxiety lest one of the new consuls should be appointed to the province of Greece; and then the honour of terminating the war, in which he had proceeded so far, must be yielded to a successor.

Aristaenus then started by advising and later even pleading with Nabis, while he still had the power and opportunity, to think about what was best for himself and his interests. He mentioned several tyrants in nearby states who had given up their power, restored freedom to their people, and later lived a secure and respected old age among their fellow citizens. After both made and listened to these points, nightfall ended the discussion. The next day, Nabis stated that he was willing to give up Argos and withdraw his troops since that was what the Romans wanted, and he would hand over the prisoners and deserters. If they wanted anything more, he asked them to put it in writing so he could discuss it with his friends. This way, the tyrant bought time for consultation, and Quinctius, on his part, called a council, summoning the leaders of the allies. Most believed they should continue the war and get rid of the tyrant entirely; otherwise, Greece's freedom would never be secure. They thought it would have been better never to have started the war than to abandon it now, as this would seem like an endorsement of his tyrannical control, reinforcing his power by giving him the backing of the Roman people, and it could encourage others in different states to plot against the freedom of their fellow citizens. The general himself leaned more towards peace, realizing that now that the enemy was trapped in the town, a siege was the only option, which would be very prolonged. It wasn't just Gythium they had to besiege; even that place had been taken through negotiations, not by force, but Lacedaemon, a city strong in both warriors and arms. Their only hope was that, upon the army's arrival, internal conflicts and uprisings might arise; yet, even as the standards had advanced almost to the gates, not a single person had stirred. He also added that "Villius the ambassador, returning from Antiochus, brought news that the peace was unstable, and that the king had come to Europe with a much stronger military force by land and sea than before. Now, if the army was tied up besieging Lacedaemon, what forces would be left to sustain the war against such a powerful king?" He made these arguments openly, but underneath, he was anxiously concerned that one of the new consuls might be assigned to Greece, which would mean that the glory of ending the war—a war he had come so far in—would go to a successor.

34

Finding that he could not, by opposition, make any alteration in the sentiments of the allies, by pretending to go over to their opinion, he led them all into a concurrence in his plan. "Be it so," said he, "and may success attend us: let us lay siege to Lacedaemon, since that is your choice. However, as a business so slow in its progress, as you know the besieging of cities to be, very often wears out the patience of the besiegers sooner than that of the besieged, you ought at once to make up your minds to this, that we must pass the winter under the walls of Lacedaemon. If this delay involved only toil and danger, I would recommend to you to prepare your minds and bodies to support these. But, in the present case, vast expenses also will be requisite for the construction of works, for machines and engines, sufficient for the siege of so great a city, and for procuring stores of provisions for the winter to serve you and us: therefore, to prevent your being suddenly disconcerted, or shamefully deserting an enterprise which you had engaged in, I think it will be necessary for you to write home to your respective states, and learn what degree of spirit and of strength each possesses. Of auxiliary troops I have a sufficient number, and to spare; but the more numerous we are, the more numerous will be our wants. The country of the enemy has nothing left but the naked soil. Besides, the winter is at hand, which will render it difficult to convey what we may stand in need of from distant places." This speech first turned their thoughts to the domestic evils prevailing in their several states; the indolence of those who remained at home; the envy and misrepresentations to which those who were serving abroad were liable; that a state of freedom was a difficult one in which to procure unanimity; the want of public funds, and people's backwardness to contribute out of their private property. Their inclinations being thus suddenly changed, they gave full power to the general, to do whatever he judged conducive to the general interest of the Roman people and their allies.

Finding that he couldn't change the allies' opinions by opposing them or pretending to agree with them, he managed to get everyone on board with his plan. "All right," he said, "let's aim for success: let's lay siege to Lacedaemon, since that's what you want. But keep in mind that besieging cities, as you know, often tests the patience of the besiegers more than that of the besieged. You should be prepared to spend the winter at the walls of Lacedaemon. If this delay only meant hard work and danger, I'd suggest you get ready to handle it. However, in this case, we’ll also need a lot of money for building equipment, machines, and supplies for the siege of such a large city, as well as winter provisions for all of us. So, to avoid being caught off guard or abandoning this mission you've committed to, I think it’s essential to write back to your home states and find out how much support and resources they can offer. I have enough auxiliary troops, but the more people we have, the more we’ll need. The enemy's land has nothing left but barren soil. Plus, winter is coming, which will make it hard to get what we need from far away." This speech made everyone think about the issues back home: the laziness of those who stayed behind, the jealousy and misinformation affecting those serving abroad, the difficulty of achieving unity in a free state, the lack of public funds, and people's reluctance to dip into their personal wealth. With their attitudes suddenly shifting, they granted the general full authority to take whatever actions he deemed best for the Roman people and their allies.

35

Then Quinctius, consulting only his lieutenant-generals and military tribunes, drew up the following conditions on which peace should be made with the tyrant: "That there should be a suspension of arms for six months, between Nabis on one part, and the Romans, king Eumenes, and the Rhodians on the other. That Titus Quinctius and Nabis should immediately send ambassadors to Rome, in order that the peace might be ratified by authority of the senate. That, whatever day a written copy of these conditions should be delivered to Nabis, on that day should the armistice commence; and, within ten days after, his garrisons should be withdrawn from Argos, and all other towns in the territory of the Argives; all which towns should be entirely evacuated, restored to freedom, and delivered to the Romans. That no slave, whether belonging to the king, the public, or a private person, be removed out of any of them; and if any had been removed before, that they be faithfully restored to their owners. That he should return the ships, which he had taken from the maritime states; and should not have any other than two barks; and these to be navigated with no more than sixteen oars. That he should restore to all the states in alliance with the Roman people, the prisoners and deserters in his hands; and to the Messenians, all the effects that could be discovered, and which their possessors could own. That he should, likewise, restore to the exiled Lacedaemonians their children, and their wives, who chose to follow their husbands; provided that no woman should be obliged, against her will, to go with her husband into exile. That such of the mercenary soldiers of Nabis as had deserted him, and gone either to their own countries or to the Romans, should have all their effects faithfully returned to them. That he should hold possession of no city in the island of Crete; and that such as were then in his possession should be given up to the Romans. That he should not form any alliance, or wage war, with any of the Cretan states, or with any other. That he should withdraw all his garrisons from those cities, which he should give up, and which had put themselves, and their country, under the dominion and protection of the Roman people; and should take care that, in future, he should restrain both himself and his subjects from molesting them. That he should not build any town or fort in his own, or any other territory. That, to secure the performance of these conditions, he should give five hostages, such as the Roman general should choose, and among them his own son: and should pay, at present, one hundred talents of silver; and fifty talents, annually, for eight years."

Then Quinctius, consulting only his lieutenant generals and military tribunes, laid out the following conditions for making peace with the tyrant: "There will be a ceasefire for six months between Nabis on one side and the Romans, King Eumenes, and the Rhodians on the other. Titus Quinctius and Nabis will immediately send ambassadors to Rome so that the peace can be approved by the authority of the Senate. The ceasefire will start on the day a written copy of these conditions is delivered to Nabis; within ten days afterward, he must withdraw his troops from Argos and all other towns in the Argive territory; all these towns must be fully evacuated, restored to freedom, and turned over to the Romans. No slave, whether belonging to the king, the public, or a private individual, may be removed from any of them; and if any have been removed before, they must be returned to their owners. He must return the ships that he took from the coastal states and may keep no more than two vessels, each operated with no more than sixteen oars. He must return all prisoners and deserters in his custody to the allied states of the Roman people, and to the Messenians, all the property that can be found and owned by their rightful owners. He should also return to the exiled Lacedaemonians their children and wives who choose to follow their husbands, provided that no woman is forced against her will to go with her husband into exile. Mercenary soldiers from Nabis who deserted him and went either to their own countries or to the Romans should have all their belongings returned to them. He will not hold any city on the island of Crete; any he currently possesses must be surrendered to the Romans. He must not form any alliances or wage war with any of the Cretan states or anyone else. He must withdraw all his troops from the cities he surrenders, which have placed themselves and their lands under the dominion and protection of the Roman people; he must ensure that neither he nor his subjects disturb them in the future. He will not build any towns or forts in his own territory or elsewhere. To guarantee that these conditions are met, he will provide five hostages, selected by the Roman general, including his own son; and he will pay, at this time, one hundred talents of silver, plus fifty talents annually for the next eight years."

36

These articles were put into writing, and sent into Lacedaemon, the camp having been removed, and brought nearer to the town. The tyrant saw nothing in them that gave him much satisfaction, excepting that, beyond his hopes, no mention had been made of bringing back the exiles. But what mortified him most of all, was, the depriving him of his shipping, and of the maritime towns: for the sea had been a source of great profit to him; his piratical vessels having continually infested the whole coast from the promontory of Malea. Besides, he found in the young men of those towns recruits for his army, who made by far the best of his soldiers. Though he discussed those conditions in private with his confidential friends, yet, as the ministers in the courts of kings, faithless in other respects, are particularly so with respect to the concealing of secrets, rumour soon made them all public. The public, in general, expressed not so great a disapprobation of the whole of the terms, as did individuals, of the articles particularly affecting themselves. Those who had the wives of the exiles in marriage, or had possessed themselves of any of their property, were provoked, as if they were to lose what was their own, and not to make restitution of what belonged to others. The slaves, who had been set at liberty by the tyrant, perceived plainly, not only that their enfranchisement would be annulled, but that their servitude would be much more severe than it had been before, when they should be again put under the power of their incensed masters. The mercenary soldiers were dissatisfied, because, in consequence of a peace, their pay would cease; and they knew also, that they could not return among their own countrymen, who detested not tyrants more than they did their abettors.

These articles were written down and sent to Lacedaemon after the camp had moved closer to the town. The tyrant didn’t find much to be satisfied with, except that, much to his surprise, there was no mention of bringing back the exiles. However, what frustrated him the most was losing his ships and the coastal towns. The sea had been a major source of profit for him, as his pirate ships had continually raided the entire coast from the Malea promontory. Moreover, he relied on the young men from those towns as recruits for his army, as they made up the best of his soldiers. While he discussed these terms privately with his close friends, like many advisors in royal courts, who are often untrustworthy and particularly bad at keeping secrets, rumors quickly spread. Generally, the public didn’t disapprove of the terms as strongly as individuals did, especially those personally affected. Those who had married the exiles' wives or taken over their property were angered, feeling they were about to lose what they considered their own rather than returning what belonged to others. The freed slaves, who had been granted freedom by the tyrant, clearly saw that their freedom would be revoked, and their servitude would be even harsher than before once they were back under their furious masters. The mercenary soldiers were unhappy too, as a peace agreement would mean an end to their pay, and they also knew they couldn’t return to their own people, who detested tyrants just as much as they despised their supporters.

37

They at first spoke of these matters, in their circles, with murmurs of discontent; and afterwards, suddenly ran to arms. From which tumultuous proceeding, the tyrant perceived that the passions of the multitude were of themselves sufficiently inflamed, and immediately ordered a general assembly to be summoned. Here he explained to them the terms which the Romans strove to impose, to which he falsely added others, more severe and humiliating. While, on the mention of each particular, sometimes the whole assembly, sometimes different parties, raised a shout of disapprobation, he asked them, "What answer they wished him to give; or what they would have him do?" On which all, as it were with one voice, cried out, "To give no answer, to continue the war;" and they began, as is common with a multitude, every one to encourage the rest, to keep up their spirits, and cherish good hopes, observing, that "fortune favours the brave." Animated by these expressions, the tyrant assured them, that Antiochus, and the Aetolians, would come to their assistance; and that he had, in the mean time, resources abundantly sufficient for the maintenance of a siege. The very mention of peace had vanished from the minds of all, and unable to contain themselves longer in quiet, they ran out in parties against the advanced guards of the enemy. The sally of these few skirmishers, and the weapons which they threw, immediately removed all doubt from the Romans that the war was to continue. During the four following days, several slight encounters took place, at first without any decisive result; but, on the fifth day after, in a kind of regular engagement, the Lacedaemonians were beaten back into the town, in such a panic, that several Roman soldiers, pressing close on the rear of the fugitives, entered the city through open spaces, not secured with a wall, of which, at that time, there were several.

They initially talked about these issues in their circles with whispers of discontent; then, all of a sudden, they took up arms. From this chaotic reaction, the tyrant realized that the crowd's emotions were already heated, and he quickly ordered a general assembly to be called. Here, he explained the terms the Romans were trying to impose and falsely added even harsher and more humiliating conditions. As he mentioned each detail, sometimes the entire assembly and other times different groups shouted in disapproval. He asked them what response they wanted him to give or what they wanted him to do. In response, they all shouted in unison, "Give no answer, continue the war!" They began, as crowds often do, encouraging each other to stay strong and maintain hope, noting that "fortune favors the brave." Inspired by these words, the tyrant assured them that Antiochus and the Aetolians would come to their aid and that, in the meantime, he had more than enough resources to sustain a siege. The very idea of peace had disappeared from everyone’s minds, and unable to stay quiet any longer, they rushed out in groups against the enemy's front guards. The charge of these few skirmishers and the weapons they hurled immediately removed any doubt from the Romans that the conflict would continue. Over the next four days, several minor skirmishes occurred, initially without any decisive outcome; however, on the fifth day, during a more organized battle, the Lacedaemonians were pushed back into the town in such a panic that several Roman soldiers, closely following the fleeing ones, entered the city through open areas that weren't protected by a wall, of which there were several at that time.

38

Then Quinctius, having, by this repulse, effectually checked the sallies of the enemy, and being fully convinced that he had now no alternative, but must besiege the city, sent persons to bring up all the marine forces from Gythium; and, in the mean time, rode himself, with some military tribunes, round the walls, to take a view of the situation of the place. In former times, Sparta had no wall; of late, the tyrants had built walls in the places where the ground Was open and level; but the higher places, and those more difficult of access, they secured by placing guards of soldiers instead of fortifications. When he had sufficiently examined every circumstance, having resolved on making a general assault, he surrounded the city with all his forces, the number of which, Romans and allies, horse and foot, naval and land forces, all together, amounted to fifty thousand men. Some brought scaling-ladders, some fire-brands, some other matters, wherewith they might not only assail the enemy, but strike terror. The orders were, that on raising the shout, all should advance at once, in order that the Lacedaemonians, being alarmed at the same time in every quarter, might be at a loss where, first, to make head, or whither to bring aid. The main force of his army he formed in three divisions, and ordered one to attack on the side of the Phoebeum, another on that of the Dictynneum, and the third near a place called Heptagoniae, all which are open places without walls. Though surrounded on all sides by such a violent alarm, the tyrant, at first, attentive to every sudden shout and hasty message, either ran up himself, or sent others, wherever the greatest danger pressed; but, afterwards, he was so stunned by the horror and confusion that prevailed all around, as to become incapable either of giving proper directions, or of hearing what was said, and to lose, not only his judgment, but almost his reason.

Then Quinctius, having effectively stopped the enemy's attacks with this setback and realizing that he had no choice but to besiege the city, sent people to bring all the sea forces from Gythium. Meanwhile, he rode with some military tribunes around the walls to assess the situation. In the past, Sparta didn't have walls; recently, the tyrants had built walls where the ground was open and flat, but they secured the higher and more difficult areas by placing guards instead of fortifications. After thoroughly examining everything, he decided to launch a full-scale assault and surrounded the city with all his forces, which totaled fifty thousand men, including Romans, allies, infantry, cavalry, and naval forces. Some carried scaling ladders, others had torches, and some brought various tools to not only attack the enemy but also instill fear. The orders were to raise a shout and advance all at once so that the Lacedaemonians, alarmed from every direction, would be confused about where to respond first. He divided the main strength of his army into three groups: one was to attack at the Phoebeum, another at the Dictynneum, and the third near a place called Heptagoniae, all of which were open areas without walls. Although surrounded by such a chaotic alarm, the tyrant initially paid close attention to every sudden shout and urgent message, either running himself or sending others to wherever the danger was greatest. However, eventually, he became so overwhelmed by the fear and confusion all around him that he was unable to give proper commands or even hear what was being said, losing not only his judgment but almost his sanity.

39

For some time the Lacedaemonians maintained their ground against the Romans, in the narrow passes; and three armies, on each side, fought, at one time, in different places. Afterwards, when the heat of the contest increased, the contest was, by no means, an equal one: for the Lacedaemonians fought with missile arms, against which the Roman soldiers, by means of their large shields, easily defended themselves, and many of their blows either missed, or were very weak; for, the narrowness of the place causing them to be closely crowded together, they neither had room to discharge their weapons with a previous run, which gives great force to them, nor clear and steady footing while they made their throw Of those, therefore, discharged against the front of the Romans, none pierced their bodies, few even their shields; but several were wounded by those who surrounded them from higher places. And presently, when they advanced a little, they were hurt unawares, both with javelins, and tiles also thrown from the tops of the houses. On this they raised their shields over their heads; and joining them so close together as to leave no room for injury from such random casts, or even for the insertion of a javelin, by a hand within reach, they pressed forward under cover of this tortoise fence. For some time the narrow streets, being thronged with a multitude of their own soldiers, and also of the enemy, considerably retarded the progress of the Romans; but when once, by gradually pushing back the enemy, they gained the wider streets of the city, the impetuosity of their attack could no longer be withstood. While the Lacedaemonians, having turned their backs, fled precipitately to the higher places, Nabis, being utterly confounded, as if the town were already taken, began to look about for a way to make his escape. Pythagoras, while in other respects he displayed the spirit and conduct of a general, was now the sole means of saving the city from being taken. For he ordered the buildings nearest to the wall to be set on fire; and these being instantly in a blaze, those who, on another occasion, would have brought help to extinguish the fire, now helping to increase it, the roofs tumbled on the Romans; and not only fragments of the tiles, but also the half-burned timber, reached the soldiers: the flames spread wide, and the smoke caused a degree of terror even greater than the danger. In consequence, the Romans who were without the city, and were just then making the principal attack, retired from the wall; and those who were within, fearing lest the fire, rising behind them, should put it out of their power to rejoin the rest of the army, began to retreat. Whereupon Quinctius, seeing how matters stood, ordered a general retreat to be sounded.--Thus, being at length recalled from a city which they had nearly taken, they returned to their camp.

For a while, the Spartans held their ground against the Romans in the narrow passes, with armies on both sides fighting simultaneously in different locations. As the battle intensified, it became clear that the contest was not equal: the Spartans used ranged weapons, while the Roman soldiers effectively defended themselves with their large shields. Many of the Spartan attacks missed or were weak because the tight space made it difficult to run up and launch their weapons with full force, and they didn’t have stable footing for their throws. As a result, not many of their projectiles pierced the Romans' bodies, and few even hit their shields; however, several Romans were wounded by those attacking from higher ground. As they advanced slightly, they were unexpectedly struck by javelins and tiles thrown from the rooftops. In response, they raised their shields overhead and pressed them tightly together to protect against random projectiles and javelin throws, moving forward under this protective formation. For a time, the crowded narrow streets, filled with their own soldiers and the enemy, significantly slowed the Romans’ progress. But once they managed to push the enemy back and reach the wider streets of the city, their fierce attack became unstoppable. As the Spartans turned and fled toward higher ground, Nabis was so shocked, as if the city was already lost, that he started looking for an escape route. Pythagoras, showing the determination and leadership of a general, became their last hope for saving the city from capture. He ordered the buildings closest to the wall to be set on fire; as they ignited quickly, those who would typically help put out the flames instead helped spread them. The burning roofs collapsed onto the Romans, and along with debris and half-burnt timber, the flames and smoke created a level of panic even greater than the actual threat. Consequently, the Romans outside the city, who were launching the main attack at that moment, withdrew from the wall. Meanwhile, those inside, fearing that the fire would trap them from rejoining their army, began to retreat. Seeing this, Quinctius ordered a general retreat. Ultimately, the Romans, having almost captured the city, returned to their camp.

40

Quinctius, conceiving greater hopes from the fears of the enemy than from the immediate effect of his operations, kept them in a continual alarm during the three succeeding days; sometimes harassing them with assaults, sometimes enclosing several places with works, so as to leave no passage open for flight. These menaces had such an effect on the tyrant that he again sent Pythagoras to solicit peace. Quinctius, at first, rejected him with disdain, ordering him to quit the camp; but afterwards, on his suppliant entreaties, and throwing himself at his feet, he admitted him to an audience. The purport of his discourse, at first, was, an offer of implicit submission to the will of the Romans; but this availed nothing, being considered as nugatory and indecisive. The business was, at length, brought to this issue, that a truce should be made on the conditions delivered in writing a few days before, and the money and hostages were accordingly received. While the tyrant was kept shut up by the siege, the Argives, receiving frequent accounts, one after another, that Lacedaemon was on the point of being taken, and having themselves resumed courage on the departure of Pythagoras, with the strongest part of his garrison, looked now with contempt on the small number remaining in the citadel; and, being headed by a person named Archippus, drove the garrison out. They gave Timocrates, of Pellene, leave to retire, with solemn assurance of sparing his life, in consideration of the mildness which he had shown in his government. In the midst of this rejoicing, Quinctius arrived, after having granted peace to the tyrant, dismissed Eumenes and the Rhodians from Lacedaemon, and sent back his brother, Lucius Quinctius, to the fleet.

Quinctius, expecting more from the enemy's fears than from the immediate impact of his actions, kept them in constant panic for the next three days; sometimes attacking them, and other times surrounding several locations with fortifications, leaving no escape route. These threats prompted the tyrant to send Pythagoras again to ask for peace. Quinctius initially dismissed him with scorn, telling him to leave the camp; but later, after Pythagoras pleaded and threw himself at his feet, Quinctius allowed him to speak. At first, Pythagoras offered complete submission to the Romans, but this was seen as useless and uncertain. Eventually, it was agreed that a truce would be established based on the terms given in writing a few days earlier, and the money and hostages were accepted. While the tyrant remained trapped by the siege, the Argives, hearing reports that Lacedaemon was about to fall, gained courage after Pythagoras and most of his garrison had left, and now looked down on the small number left in the citadel. Led by a man named Archippus, they drove the remaining garrison out. They allowed Timocrates from Pellene to leave, promising to spare his life due to his gentle rule. Amid this celebration, Quinctius arrived after making peace with the tyrant, sending Eumenes and the Rhodians away from Lacedaemon, and sending his brother, Lucius Quinctius, back to the fleet.

41

The Nemaean games, the most celebrated of all the festivals, and their most splendid public spectacle, had been omitted, at the regular time, on account of the disasters of the war: the state now, in the fulness of their joy, ordered them to be celebrated on the arrival of the Roman general and his army; and appointed the general, himself, president of the games. There were many circumstances which heightened their happiness: their countrymen, whom Pythagoras, lately, and, before that, Nabis, had carried away, were brought home from Lacedaemon; those who on the discovery of the conspiracy by Pythagoras, and when the massacre was already begun, had fled from home, now returned; they saw their liberty restored, after a long interval, and beheld, in their city, the Romans, the authors of its restoration, whose only view, in making war on the tyrant, was the support of their interest. The freedom of the Argives was, also, solemnly announced, by the voice of a herald, on the very day of the Nemaean games. Whatever pleasure the Achaeans felt on Argos being reinstated in the general council of Achaia, it was, in a great measure, alloyed by Lacedaemon being left in slavery, and the tyrant close at their side. As to the Aetolians, they loudly railed at that measure in every meeting. They remarked, that "the war with Philip was not ended until he evacuated all the cities of Greece. But Lacedaemon was left to the tyrant, while the lawful king, who had been, at the time, in the Roman camp, and others, the noblest of the citizens, must live in exile: so that the Roman nation was become a partisan of Nabis in his tyranny." Quinctius led back his army to Elatia, whence he had set out to the Spartan war. Some writers say, that the tyrant's method of carrying on hostilities was not by sallies from the city, but that he encamped in the face of the Romans; and that, after he had declined fighting a long time, waiting for succours from the Aetolians, he was forced to come to an engagement, by an attack which the Romans made on his foragers, when, being defeated in that battle, and beaten out of his camp, he sued for peace, after fifteen thousand of his men had been killed, and more than four thousand made prisoners.

The Neman games, the most famous of all festivals and their most impressive public event, had been skipped at the usual time because of the war's disasters. Now, in a moment of great joy, the state decided to celebrate them with the arrival of the Roman general and his army, appointing the general himself as the president of the games. Several factors added to their happiness: their fellow countrymen, who had recently been taken away by Pythagoras and, before him, Nabis, were brought back from Lacedaemon; those who had fled when Pythagoras discovered the conspiracy and the massacre had already started were now returning home; they witnessed their freedom restored after a long time and saw the Romans, the ones responsible for their restoration, in their city. The Romans waged war against the tyrant solely to support their interests. The freedom of the Argives was also officially announced by a herald on the very day of the Neman games. While the Achaeans felt pleasure at Argos being reinstated in the general council of Achaia, their happiness was significantly tempered by Lacedaemon remaining enslaved and the tyrant still nearby. The Aetolians loudly criticized this situation in every meeting. They pointed out that "the war with Philip wouldn’t be over until he evacuated all the cities of Greece. Yet Lacedaemon was left under the tyrant, while the rightful king, who had been in the Roman camp at the time, and other noble citizens had to live in exile. Thus, the Roman nation became a supporter of Nabis in his tyranny." Quinctius led his army back to Elatia, where he had begun the Spartan war. Some writers claim that the tyrant's way of waging war was not through attacks from the city but that he camped in front of the Romans. After avoiding battle for a long time while waiting for help from the Aetolians, he was pushed into combat when the Romans attacked his foragers. Defeated in that battle and driven from his camp, he sought peace after losing fifteen thousand men and more than four thousand others were taken prisoner.

42

Nearly at the same time, arrived at Rome a letter from Titus Quinctius, with an account of his proceedings at Lacedaemon; and another, out of Spain, from Marcus Porcius, the consul; whereupon the senate decreed a supplication, for three days, in the name of each. The other consul, Lucius Valerius, as his province had remained quiet since the defeat of the Boians at the wood of Litana, came home to Rome to hold the elections. Publius Cornelius Scipio Africanus, a second time, and Tiberius Sempronius Longus, were elected consuls. The fathers of these two had been consuls in the first year of the second Punic war. The election of praetors was then held, and the choice fell on Publius Cornelius Scipio, two Cneius Corneliuses, Merenda and Blasio, Cneius Domitius Aenobarbus, Sextus Digitius, and Titus Juvencius Thalna. As soon as the elections were finished, the consul returned to his province. The inhabitants of Ferentinum, this year, laid claim to a privilege unheard of before; that Latins, giving in their names for a Roman colony, should be deemed citizens of Rome. Some colonists, who had given in their names for Puteoli, Salernum, and Buxentum, assumed, on that ground, the character of Roman citizens; but the senate determined that they were not.

Almost simultaneously, a letter arrived in Rome from Titus Quinctius detailing his actions in Lacedaemon, along with another from Marcus Porcius, the consul, from Spain. As a result, the senate declared a three-day public thank-you for each. The other consul, Lucius Valerius, returned to Rome to oversee the elections since his province had been calm since the Boians' defeat at the wood of Litana. Publius Cornelius Scipio Africanus and Tiberius Sempronius Longus were elected consuls for a second time. The fathers of both had served as consuls in the first year of the second Punic War. The election of praetors then took place, choosing Publius Cornelius Scipio, two Cneius Corneliuses, Merenda and Blasio, Cneius Domitius Aenobarbus, Sextus Digitius, and Titus Juvencius Thalna. Once the elections were completed, the consul returned to his province. This year, the residents of Ferentinum made an unprecedented claim: that Latins applying for a Roman colony should be considered Roman citizens. Some colonists who had applied for Puteoli, Salernum, and Buxentum took this to mean they were Roman citizens, but the senate decided they were not.

43

In the beginning of the year, wherein Publius Scipio Africanus, a second time, and Tiberius Sempronius Longus were consuls, two ambassadors from the tyrant Nabis came to Rome. The senate gave them audience in the temple of Apollo, outside the city. They entreated that a peace might be concluded on the terms settled with Quinctius, and obtained their request. When the question was put concerning the provinces, the majority of the senate were of opinion, that as the wars in Spain and Macedonia were at an end, Italy should be the province of both the consuls; but Scipio contended that one consul was sufficient for Italy, and that Macedonia ought to be decreed to the other; that "there was every reason to apprehend a dangerous war with Antiochus, for he had already, of his own accord, come into Europe; and how did they suppose he would act in future, when he should be encouraged to a war, on one hand, by the Aetolians, avowed enemies of their state, and stimulated, on the other, by Hannibal, a general famous for his victories over the Romans?" While the consular provinces were in dispute, the praetors cast lots for theirs. The city jurisdiction fell to Cneius Domitius; the foreign, to Titus Juvencius: Farther Spain, to Publius Cornelius; Hither Spain, to Sextus Digitius; Sicily, to Cneius Cornelius Blasio; Sardinia, to Cneius Cornelius Merenda. It was resolved, that no new army should be sent into Macedonia, but that the one which was there should be brought home to Italy by Quinctius, and disbanded; that the army which was in Spain, under Marcus Porcius Cato, should likewise be disbanded; that Italy should be the province of both the consuls, and that they should raise two city legions; so that, after the disbanding of the armies, mentioned in the resolution of the senate, there should be in all eight Roman legions.

At the start of the year, when Publius Scipio Africanus and Tiberius Sempronius Longus were consuls for the second time, two ambassadors from the tyrant Nabis came to Rome. The senate heard them at the temple of Apollo, located outside the city. They requested a peace agreement based on the terms settled with Quinctius, and they were granted their request. When the topic of provinces was discussed, most of the senate agreed that since the wars in Spain and Macedonia had ended, both consuls should govern Italy. However, Scipio argued that one consul was enough for Italy and that the other consul should take Macedonia. He warned that there was a real threat of war with Antiochus, as he had already entered Europe on his own. How did they think he would behave in the future when he would be encouraged to go to war by the Aetolians, who were outright enemies of their state, and influenced by Hannibal, a general known for his victories over the Romans? While they debated the consular provinces, the praetors drew lots for theirs. Cneius Domitius got the city jurisdiction; Titus Juvencius got the foreign jurisdiction; Publius Cornelius was assigned Farther Spain; Sextus Digitius was assigned Hither Spain; Cneius Cornelius Blasio got Sicily; and Cneius Cornelius Merenda was assigned Sardinia. It was decided that no new army would be sent to Macedonia; instead, Quinctius would bring the existing army back to Italy and disband it. The army in Spain, under Marcus Porcius Cato, would also be disbanded. It was established that Italy would be the province of both consuls and that they would raise two city legions, ensuring that after disbanding the armies mentioned in the senate's resolution, there would be a total of eight Roman legions.

44

A sacred spring had been celebrated, in the preceding year, during the consulate of Marcus Porcius and Lucius Valerius; but Publius Licinius, one of the pontiffs, having made a report, first, to the college of pontiffs, and afterwards, under the sanction of the college, to the senate, that it had not been duly performed, they resolved, that it should be celebrated anew, under the direction of the pontiffs; and that the great games, vowed together with it, should be exhibited at the same expense which was customary; that the sacred spring should be deemed to comprehend all the cattle born between the calends of March and the day preceding the calends of May, in the year of the consulate of Publius Cornelius Scipio and Tiberius Sempronius Longus. Then followed the election of censors. Sextus Aelius Paetus, and Caius Cornelius Cethegus, being created censors, named as prince of the senate the consul Publius Scipio, whom the former censors likewise had appointed. They passed by only three senators in the whole, none of whom had enjoyed the honour of a curule office. They obtained, on another account, the highest degree of credit with that body; for, at the celebration of the Roman games, they ordered the curule aediles to set apart places for the senators, distinct from those of the people, whereas, hitherto, all the spectators used to sit promiscuously. Of the knights, also, very few were deprived of their horses; nor was severity shown towards any rank of men. The gallery of the temple of Liberty, and the Villa Publica, were repaired and enlarged by the same censors. The sacred spring, and the votive games, were celebrated, pursuant to the vow of Servius Sulpicius Galba, when consul. While every one's thoughts were engaged by the shows then exhibited, Quintus Pleminius, who, for the many crimes against gods and men committed by him at Locri, had been thrown into prison, procured men who were to set fire by night to several parts of the city at once, in order that, while the town was thrown into consternation by this nocturnal disturbance, the prison might be broken open. But this plot was disclosed by some of the accomplices, and the affair was laid before the senate. Pleminius was thrown into a lower dungeon, and there put to death.

A sacred spring had been celebrated the year before during the consulate of Marcus Porcius and Lucius Valerius. However, Publius Licinius, one of the pontiffs, reported first to the college of pontiffs and then, with their approval, to the senate that it hadn’t been properly conducted. They decided it should be celebrated again, overseen by the pontiffs, and that the grand games promised alongside it should be held at the usual expense. The sacred spring was to include all livestock born between the first day of March and the day before the first day of May in the year of the consulate of Publius Cornelius Scipio and Tiberius Sempronius Longus. Following this, censors were elected. Sextus Aelius Paetus and Caius Cornelius Cethegus were appointed censors and named consul Publius Scipio as the prince of the senate, just as the previous censors had done. They only passed over three senators in total, none of whom had held a curule office. They gained a lot of respect from the senate for requiring the curule aediles to provide separate seating for senators at the Roman games, while previously everyone had sat together. Very few knights lost their horses, and no harsh treatment was given to any social class. The gallery of the Temple of Liberty and the Villa Publica were repaired and expanded by these censors. The sacred spring and the votive games were celebrated according to the vow of Servius Sulpicius Galba during his consulship. While everyone was focused on the shows, Quintus Pleminius, who had been imprisoned for his many crimes against gods and men at Locri, hired men to set fire to several parts of the city at night so that, amid the chaos, the prison could be broken open. However, this plot was revealed by some accomplices, and the matter was brought before the senate. Pleminius was thrown into a lower dungeon and executed there.

45

In this year colonies of Roman citizens were settled at Puteoli, Vulturnum, and Liternum; three hundred men in each place. Colonies of Roman citizens were likewise established at Salernum and Buxentum. The lands allotted to them had formerly belonged to the Campanians. Tiberius Sempronius Longus, who was then consul, Marcus Servilius, and Quintus Minucius Thermus, were the triumviri who settled the colony. Other commissioners also, Decius Junius Brutus, Marcus Baebius Tamphilus, and Marcus Helvius, led a colony of Roman citizens to Sipontum, into a district which had belonged to the Arpinians. To Tempsa, likewise, and to Croto, colonies of Roman citizens were led out. The lands of Tempsa had been taken from the Bruttians, who had formerly expelled the Greeks from them. Croto was possessed by Greeks. In ordering these establishments, there were named, for Croto,--Cneius Octavius, Lucius Aemilius Paullus, and Caius Pletorius; for Tempsa,--Lucius Cornelius Merula, and Caius Salonius. Several prodigies were observed at Rome that year, and others reported, from other places. In the forum, comitium, and Capitol, drops of blood were seen, and several showers of earth fell, and the head of Vulcan was surrounded with a blaze of fire. It was reported that a stream of milk ran in the river at Interamna; that, in some reputable families at Ariminum, children were born without eyes and nose; and one, in the territory of Picenum, that had neither hands nor feet. These prodigies were expiated according to an order of the pontiffs; and the nine days' festival was celebrated, because the Hadrians had sent intelligence that a shower of stones had fallen in their fields.

In this year, colonies of Roman citizens were established at Puteoli, Vulturnum, and Liternum, with three hundred people in each location. Colonies of Roman citizens were also set up at Salernum and Buxentum. The land given to them had previously belonged to the Campanians. Tiberius Sempronius Longus, who was consul at the time, along with Marcus Servilius and Quintus Minucius Thermus, were the triumviri responsible for settling the colony. Other commissioners, Decius Junius Brutus, Marcus Baebius Tamphilus, and Marcus Helvius, also led a colony of Roman citizens to Sipontum, in an area that had belonged to the Arpinians. Colonies of Roman citizens were also sent to Tempsa and Croto. The land of Tempsa had been taken from the Bruttians, who had previously expelled the Greeks from there. Croto was inhabited by Greeks. For Croto, the appointed leaders were Cneius Octavius, Lucius Aemilius Paullus, and Caius Pletorius; for Tempsa, they were Lucius Cornelius Merula and Caius Salonius. Several prodigies were reported in Rome that year, along with others from different places. In the forum, comitium, and Capitol, drops of blood were observed, several showers of earth fell, and the head of Vulcan was surrounded by a blaze of fire. It was reported that a stream of milk flowed in the river at Interamna; and in some respected families at Ariminum, children were born without eyes and nose; one child, in the territory of Picenum, was born without hands or feet. These prodigies were atoned for according to the orders of the pontiffs, and a nine-day festival was held because the Hadrians reported that a shower of stones had fallen in their fields.

46

In Gaul, Lucius Valerius Flaccus, proconsul, in a pitched battle near Mediolanum, completely overthrew the Insubrian Gauls, and the Boians; who, under the command of Dorulacus, had crossed the Po, to rouse the Insubrians to arms. Ten thousand of the enemy were slain. About this time his colleague, Marcus Porcius Cato, triumphed over Spain. He carried in the procession twenty-five thousand pounds' weight of unwrought silver, one hundred and three thousand silver denarii,[36] five hundred and forty of Oscan silver,[37] and one thousand four hundred pounds' weight of gold. Out of the booty, he distributed to each of his soldiers two hundred and seventy asses;[38] and three times that amount to each horseman. Tiberius Sempronius, consul, proceeding to his province, led his legions, first, into the territory of the Boians. At this time Boiorix their chieftain, with his two brothers, after having drawn out the whole nation into the field to renew the war, pitched his camp in the open country, that it might be evident that he was prepared to fight in case the enemy should pass the frontiers. When the consul understood what a numerous force and what a degree of resolution the enemy had, he sent an express to his colleague, requesting him, "if he thought proper, to hasten to join him;" adding, that "he would act on the defensive, and defer engaging in battle, until his arrival." The same reason which made the consul wish to decline an action, induced the Gauls, whose spirits were raised by the backwardness of their antagonists, to bring it on as soon as possible, that they might finish the affair before the two consuls should unite their forces. However, during two days, they did nothing more than stand in readiness for battle, if any should come out against them. On the third, they advanced furiously to the rampart, and assaulted the camp on every side at once. The consul immediately ordered his men to take arms, and kept them quiet, under arms, for some time; both to add to the foolish confidence of the enemy, and to arrange his troops at the gates, through which each party was to sally out. The two legions were ordered to march by the two principal gates; but, in the very pass of the gates, the Gauls opposed them in such close bodies as to stop up the way. The fight was maintained a long time in these narrow passes; nor were their hands or swords much employed in the business, but pushing with their shields and bodies, they pressed against each other, the Romans struggling to force their standards beyond the gates, the Gauls, to break into the camp, or, at least, to hinder the Romans from issuing forth. However, neither party could make the least impression on the other, until Quintus Victorius, a first centurion, and Caius Atinius, a military tribune, the former of the second, the latter of the fourth legion, had taken a course often tried in desperate conflicts; snatching the standards from the officers who carried them, and throwing them among the enemy. In the struggle to recover the standards, the men of the second legion first made their way out of the gate.

In Gaul, Lucius Valerius Flaccus, proconsul, decisively defeated the Insubrian Gauls and the Boians in a fierce battle near Mediolanum. The Boians, led by Dorulacus, had crossed the Po River to rally the Insubrians to fight. Ten thousand enemy soldiers were killed. Around this time, his colleague, Marcus Porcius Cato, celebrated a triumph over Spain. He brought back in the procession twenty-five thousand pounds of raw silver, one hundred and three thousand silver denarii,[36] five hundred and forty Oscan silver pieces,[37] and one thousand four hundred pounds of gold. From the spoils, he gave each of his soldiers two hundred and seventy asses;[38] horsemen received three times that amount. Tiberius Sempronius, consul, went to his province and led his legions into the territory of the Boians. At that time, their chief Boiorix, along with his two brothers, had rallied the whole nation for war and set up camp in the open, signaling he was ready to fight if the enemy crossed the borders. Once the consul learned about the large, determined enemy force, he sent a messenger to his colleague, asking him to join him quickly if he thought it was a good idea; he added that he would play defensively and wait for his arrival before engaging in battle. The same reason that made the consul hesitant to fight also encouraged the Gauls, whose spirits rose due to the Roman's reluctance, to attack as soon as possible so they could finish the conflict before the two consuls combined their forces. However, for two days, they did nothing more than prepare for battle, ready to engage if anyone came out against them. On the third day, they charged fiercely at the rampart, attacking the camp from all sides at once. The consul quickly ordered his men to arm themselves and kept them ready for some time; he did this to increase the enemy's overconfidence and to organize his troops at the gates where each side would emerge. The two legions were instructed to march through the two main gates, but at the gates, the Gauls formed such dense groups that they obstructed the entrance. The fighting continued for a long time in these narrow spaces; hands and swords were mostly ignored in favor of pushing with shields and bodies, as the Romans tried to shove their standards past the gates while the Gauls aimed to break into the camp or at least keep the Romans from exiting. Neither side could gain any ground until Quintus Victorius, a first centurion, and Caius Atinius, a military tribune from the second and fourth legions, respectively, tried a strategy often used in tough battles: they grabbed the standards from the officers holding them and threw them into the midst of the enemy. In the scramble to retrieve the standards, the men of the second legion were the first to break out of the gate.

47

These were now fighting on the outside of the rampart, the fourth legion still entangled in the gate, when a new alarm arose on the opposite side of the camp. The Gauls had broke in by the Quaestorian gate, and had slain the quaestor, Lucius Postumius, surnamed Tympanus, with Marcus Atinius and Publius Sempronius, praefects of the allies, who made an obstinate resistance; and also, near two hundred soldiers. The camp in that part had been taken, when a cohort of those who are called Extraordinaries, having been sent by the consul to defend the Quaestorian gate, killed some who had got within the rampart, drove out the rest, and opposed others who were attempting to break in. About the same time, the fourth legion, and two cohorts of Extraordinaries, burst out of the gate; and thus there were three battles, in different places, round the camp; while the various kinds of shouts raised by them, called off the attention of the combatants from their own immediate conflict to the uncertain casualties which threatened their friends. The battle was maintained until mid-day with equal strength, and with nearly equal hopes. At length, the fatigue and heat so far got the better of the soft relaxed bodies of the Gauls, who are incapable of enduring thirst, as to make most of them give up the fight; and the few who stood their ground, were attacked by the Romans, routed, and driven to their camp. The consul then gave the signal for retreat, on which the greater part retired; but some, eager to continue the fight, and hoping to get possession of the camp, pressed forward to the rampart, on which the Gauls, despising their small number, rushed out in a body. The Romans were then routed in turn, and compelled, by their own fear and dismay, to retreat to their camp, which they had refused to do at the command of their general. Thus now flight and now victory alternated on both sides. The Gauls, however, had eleven thousand killed, the Romans but five thousand. The Gauls retreated into the heart of their country, and the consul led his legions to Placentia. Some writers say, that Scipio, after joining his forces to those of his colleague, overran and plundered the country of the Boians and Ligurians, as far as the woods and marshes suffered him to proceed; others, that, without having effected any thing material, he returned to Rome to hold the elections.

They were now fighting outside the rampart, while the fourth legion was still stuck at the gate, when a new alarm erupted on the opposite side of the camp. The Gauls had broken in through the Quaestorian gate and killed the quaestor, Lucius Postumius, nicknamed Tympanus, along with Marcus Atinius and Publius Sempronius, the praefects of the allies, who fought back fiercely; they also killed nearly two hundred soldiers. That part of the camp had been taken when a cohort of the so-called Extraordinaries, dispatched by the consul to defend the Quaestorian gate, killed some who had already gotten inside the rampart, drove out the others, and confronted more who were trying to break in. Around the same time, the fourth legion and two cohorts of Extraordinaries burst out of the gate; thus, there were battles raging in three different spots around the camp. The various shouts coming from them diverted the fighters' attention from their immediate skirmishes to the uncertain dangers threatening their allies. The battle continued until midday with both sides showing equal strength and nearly equal hopes. Eventually, the fatigue and heat overwhelmed the soft, weak bodies of the Gauls, who couldn't handle thirst, causing most of them to give up the fight; the few who remained were attacked by the Romans, routed, and driven back to their camp. The consul then signaled for a retreat, prompting most to fall back; however, some, eager to keep fighting and hoping to take the camp, pressed forward to the rampart, where the Gauls, contemptuous of their small numbers, charged out en masse. The Romans were then routed in turn, forced back to their camp, which they had refused to abandon at their general's command. Thus, victory and defeat alternated between the two sides. The Gauls suffered eleven thousand killed, while the Romans lost five thousand. The Gauls retreated deep into their territory, and the consul led his legions to Placentia. Some historians claim that Scipio, after combining his forces with his colleague's, ravaged and looted the lands of the Boians and Ligurians as far as the woods and marshes allowed; others say that, without achieving anything significant, he returned to Rome to conduct the elections.

48

Titus Quinctius passed the entire winter season of this year at Elatia, where he had established the winter quarters of his army, in adjusting political arrangements, and reversing the measures which had been introduced in the several states under the arbitrary domination of Philip and his deputies, who crushed the rights and liberties of others, in order to augment the power of those who formed a faction in their favour. Early in the spring he came to Corinth, where he had summoned a general convention. Ambassadors having attended from every one of the states, so as to form a numerous assembly, he addressed them in a long speech, in which, beginning from the first commencement of friendship between the Romans and the nation of the Greeks, he enumerated the proceedings of the commanders who had been in Macedonia before him, and likewise his own. His whole narration was heard with the warmest approbation, except when he came to make mention of Nabis; and then they expressed their opinion, that it was utterly inconsistent with the character of the deliverer of Greece to have left seated, in the centre of one of its most respectable states, a tyrant, who was not only insupportable to his own country, but a terror to all the states in his neighbourhood. Whereupon Quinctius, not unacquainted with this tendency of their feelings, freely acknowledged, that "if the business could have been accomplished without the entire destruction of Lacedaemon, no mention of peace with the tyrant ought ever to have been listened to; but that, when it was not possible to crush him otherwise than by the utter ruin of this most important city, it was judged more eligible to leave the tyrant in a state of debility, stripped of almost every kind of power to do injury to any, than to suffer the city, which must have perished in the very process of its delivery being effectuated, to sink under remedies too violent for it to support."

Titus Quinctius spent the whole winter of that year at Elatia, where he set up winter quarters for his army, working on political arrangements and reversing the decisions made in various states under the harsh control of Philip and his deputies, who undermined the rights and freedoms of others to strengthen their own supporters. Early in the spring, he went to Corinth, where he had called for a general meeting. Representatives from all the states attended, creating a large assembly. He addressed them with a lengthy speech, starting from the beginning of the friendship between the Romans and the Greeks, listing the actions of the commanders who had been in Macedonia before him, as well as his own. His entire account was received with great approval, except when he mentioned Nabis; then they expressed their views, saying it was completely out of character for the liberator of Greece to have allowed a tyrant to remain in the center of one of its most respected states, a tyrant who was not only unbearable to his own people but a threat to all the neighboring states. In response, Quinctius, aware of their sentiments, openly admitted that "if the situation could have been resolved without completely destroying Lacedaemon, there should never have been any consideration for peace with the tyrant; however, since it was impossible to defeat him except by utterly ruining this key city, it was deemed more favorable to leave the tyrant weakened, stripped of nearly all power to harm anyone, rather than let the city, which would have perished during the process of its liberation, suffer from remedies too extreme for it to bear."

49

To the recital of matters past, he subjoined, that "his intention was to depart shortly for Italy, and to carry with him all his troops; that they should hear, within ten days, of the garrisons having evacuated Demetrias; and that Chalcis, the citadel of Corinth, should be before their own eyes evacuated to the Achaeans: that all the world might know whose habit it was to deceive, that of the Romans or the Aetolians, who had spread insinuations, that the cause of liberty had been unwisely intrusted to the Romans, and that they had only received as their masters the Romans in exchange for the Macedonians. But they were men who never scrupled what they either said or did. The rest of the nations he advised to form their estimate of friends from deeds, not from words; and to satisfy themselves whom they ought to trust, and against whom they ought to be on their guard; to use their liberty with moderation: for, when regulated by prudence, it was productive of happiness both to individuals and to states; but, when pushed to excess, it became not only obnoxious to others, but to the possessors of it themselves an unbridled and headstrong impulse. He recommended, that those at the head of affairs, and all the several ranks of men in each particular state, should cultivate harmony between themselves; and that all should direct their views to the general interest of the whole. For, while they acted in concert, no king or tyrant would be sufficiently powerful against them: but discord and dissension gave every advantage to those who might plot against them; as the party worsted in a domestic dispute generally join themselves with foreigners, rather than submit to a countryman of their own. He then exhorted them, as the arms of others had procured their liberty, and the good faith of foreigners had restored it to them, to apply now their own diligent care to the watching and guarding of it; that the Roman people might perceive that those on whom they had bestowed liberty were deserving of it, and that their kindness had not been ill placed."

To recap what happened before, he added that "he planned to leave for Italy soon and take all his troops with him; that they would hear within ten days that the garrisons had evacuated Demetrias; and that Chalcis, the citadel of Corinth, would be evacuated in front of their eyes to the Achaeans: so everyone would know who was truly deceiving—was it the Romans or the Aetolians, who had spread rumors that the cause of liberty was foolishly entrusted to the Romans and that they had merely swapped the Romans for the Macedonians as their masters. But they were people who had no qualms about what they said or did. He advised the other nations to judge their friends by actions, not words, and to figure out whom they could trust and whom they should be wary of; to use their freedom wisely: because when freedom is guided by sense, it brings happiness to both individuals and states; but when it goes to extremes, it becomes not only a burden to others but also a reckless and stubborn impulse for those who possess it. He suggested that those in charge and people of all ranks in each state should work together in harmony; and that everyone should focus on the overall interests of the community. Because when they worked together, no king or tyrant would be powerful enough to oppose them: but conflict and disagreement would only help those plotting against them; as the party that loses in a domestic conflict usually allies with outsiders rather than submit to one of their own. He then urged them, since their freedom had come through the arms of others and the good faith of foreign allies had restored it to them, to now diligently safeguard and watch over it; so the Roman people could see that those they had granted freedom were worthy of it, and that their generosity had not been misplaced."

50

On hearing these admonitions, such as parental tenderness might dictate, every one present shed tears of joy; and they affected his feelings to such a degree as to interrupt his discourse. For some time a confused noise prevailed, from those who were expressing their approbation of his words, and charging each other to treasure up those expressions in their minds and hearts, as if they had been uttered by an oracle. Then silence ensuing, he requested of them to make diligent search for such Roman citizens as were in servitude among them, and to send them into Thessaly to him, within two months; observing, that "it would not be honourable to themselves, that, in a land restored to liberty, its deliverers should remain in servitude." To this all exclaimed with acclamations that they returned him thanks on this account in addition to others, that they had been reminded of the discharge of a duty so indispensably incumbent on their gratitude. There was a vast number of these who had been made prisoners in the Punic war, and sold by Hannibal when their countrymen refused to ransom them. That they were very numerous, is proved by what Polybius says, that this business cost the Achaeans one hundred talents,[39] though they had fixed the price to be paid for each captive, to the owner, so low as five hundred denarii.[40] For, at that rate, there were one thousand two hundred in Achaia. Calculate now, in proportion to this, how many were probably in all Greece.

On hearing these admonitions, which reflected the kindness of a parent, everyone present teared up with joy; it touched him deeply, causing him to pause his speech. For a while, there was a mix of voices from those expressing their approval of his words, urging each other to remember those phrases in their minds and hearts as if they had come from an oracle. When silence finally fell, he asked them to actively look for Roman citizens who were enslaved among them and to send them to him in Thessaly within two months, noting that "it wouldn't be right for them to have the liberators of their land still enslaved in a place restored to freedom." Everyone responded with cheers, thanking him for reminding them of their duty, which was essential to their gratitude. Many of these individuals had been captured during the Punic war and sold by Hannibal when their fellow countrymen refused to pay for their release. The sheer number is highlighted by Polybius, who noted that this effort cost the Achaeans one hundred talents,[39] even though they had set the ransom price for each captive at a mere five hundred denarii.[40] At that rate, there were one thousand two hundred captives in Achaia. Now, calculate how many there probably were in all of Greece.

51

Before the convention broke up, they saw the garrison march down from the citadel of Corinth, proceed forward to the gate, and depart. The general followed them, accompanied by the whole assembly, who, with loud acclamations, blessed him as their preserver and deliverer. At length, taking leave of these, and dismissing them, he returned to Elatia by the same road through which he came. He thence sent Appius Claudius, lieutenant-general, with all the troops, ordering him to march through Thessaly and Epirus, and to wait for him at Oricum, whence he intended to embark the army for Italy. He also wrote to his brother, Lucius Quinctius, lieutenant-general, and commander of the fleet, to collect thither transport ships from all the coasts of Greece. He himself proceeded to Chalcis; and, after sending away the garrisons, not only from that city, but likewise from Oreum and Eretria, he held there a congress of the Euboean states, whom he reminded of the condition in which he had found their affairs, and of that in which he was leaving them; and then dismissed the assembly. He then proceeded to Demetrias, and removed the garrison. Accompanied by all the citizens, as at Corinth and Chalcis, he pursued his route into Thessaly, where the states were not only to be set at liberty, but also to be reduced from a state of utter anarchy and confusion into some tolerable order; for they had been thrown into confusion, not only through the faults of the times, and the violence and licentiousness of royalty, but also through the restless disposition of the nation, who, from the earliest times, even to our days, have never conducted any election, or assembly, or council, without dissensions and tumult. He chose both senators and judges, with regard, principally, to their property, and made that party the most powerful in the state to whom it was most important that all things should be tranquil and secure.

Before the convention ended, they watched the garrison march down from the citadel of Corinth, move towards the gate, and leave. The general followed them, along with the entire assembly, who, with loud cheers, praised him as their savior and liberator. Eventually, after saying goodbye to them and sending them off, he returned to Elatia by the same road he had taken to arrive. From there, he sent Appius Claudius, the lieutenant-general, with all the troops, instructing him to march through Thessaly and Epirus and to wait for him at Oricum, where he planned to transport the army to Italy. He also wrote to his brother, Lucius Quinctius, who was the lieutenant-general and commander of the fleet, to gather transport ships from all the coasts of Greece. He then went to Chalcis and, after sending away the garrisons not only from that city but also from Oreum and Eretria, he held a meeting with the Euboean states, reminding them of the state he had found their affairs in and how he was leaving them; he then dismissed the assembly. He went on to Demetrias and removed the garrison. Accompanied by all the citizens, as in Corinth and Chalcis, he continued his journey into Thessaly, where the states needed not only to be freed but also to be brought back from total chaos to some level of order; they had been thrown into disarray, not only due to the issues of the time and the violence and lawlessness of royalty but also because of the restless nature of the people, who, throughout history, even to the present day, have never held any election, assembly, or council without conflicts and uproar. He chose both senators and judges mainly based on their wealth and made that faction the most powerful in the state, as it was in their best interest for everything to be calm and stable.

52

When he had completed these regulations in Thessaly, he went on, through Epirus, to Oricum, whence he intended to take his passage. From Oricum all the troops were transported to Brundusium. From this place to the city, they passed the whole length of Italy, in a manner, like a triumph; the captured effects which they brought with them forming a train as large as that of the troops themselves. When they arrived at Rome, the senate assembled outside the city, to receive from Quinctius a recital of his services; and, with high satisfaction, a well-merited triumph was decreed him. His triumph lasted three days. On the first day were carried in procession, armour, weapons, brazen and marble statues of which he had taken greater numbers from Philip than from the states of Greece. On the second, gold and silver wrought, unwrought, and coined. Of unwrought silver, there were eighteen thousand pounds' weight; and of wrought, two hundred and seventy thousand; consisting of many vessels of various sorts, most of them engraved, and several of exquisite workmanship; also a great many others made of brass; and besides these, ten shields of silver. The coined silver amounted to eighty-four thousand of the Attic coin, called Tetradrachmus, containing each of silver about the weight of four denarii.[41] Of gold there were three thousand seven hundred and fourteen pounds, and one shield wholly of gold: and of the gold coin called Philippics, fourteen thousand five hundred and fourteen.[42] On the third day were carried golden crowns, presented by the several states, in number one hundred and fourteen; then the victims. Before his chariot went many illustrious persons, captives and hostages, among whom were Demetrius, son of king Philip, and Armenes, a Lacedaemonian, son of the tyrant Nabis. Then Quinctius himself rode into the city, followed by a numerous body of soldiers, as the whole army had been brought home from the province. Among these he distributed two hundred and fifty asses[43] to each footman, double to a centurion, triple to a horseman. Those who had been redeemed from captivity added to the grandeur of the procession, walking after him with their heads shaven.

When he finished these regulations in Thessaly, he moved on through Epirus to Oricum, where he planned to catch a boat. From Oricum, all the troops were transported to Brundusium. From there to the city, they paraded the entire length of Italy, like a triumph; the captured goods they brought with them made a train as large as that of the troops themselves. When they arrived in Rome, the senate gathered outside the city to hear Quinctius recount his achievements; with great satisfaction, they awarded him a well-deserved triumph. His triumph lasted three days. On the first day, they displayed armor, weapons, and bronze and marble statues, with more taken from Philip than from the states of Greece. On the second day, they showcased gold and silver, both wrought and unwrought. There were eighteen thousand pounds of unwrought silver and two hundred seventy thousand pounds of wrought silver, consisting of many different vessels, most of them engraved, with several of exquisite craftsmanship; there were also many others made of brass, as well as ten shields of silver. The coined silver totaled eighty-four thousand of the Attic coin called Tetradrachmus, each weighing about four denarii. For gold, there were three thousand seven hundred fourteen pounds, and one completely golden shield: and fourteen thousand five hundred fourteen of the gold coin known as Philippics. On the third day, they carried golden crowns, presented by various states, numbering one hundred fourteen; then the sacrificial animals. Before his chariot walked many notable individuals, captives, and hostages, including Demetrius, the son of King Philip, and Armenes, a Spartan, son of the tyrant Nabis. Then Quinctius himself rode into the city, followed by a large group of soldiers, as the whole army had returned from the province. Among them, he distributed two hundred fifty asses to each foot soldier, double to a centurion, and triple to a cavalryman. Those who had been freed from captivity added to the grandeur of the procession, walking behind him with shaved heads.

53

In the latter part of this year Quintus Aelius Tubero, plebeian tribune, in pursuance of a decree of the senate, proposed to the people, and the people ordered, that "two Latin colonies should be settled, one in Bruttium, the other in the territory of Thurium." For making these settlements commissioners were appointed, who were to hold the office for three years; for Bruttium, Quintus Naevius, Marcus Minucius Rufus, and Marcus Furius Crassipes; and for the district of Thurium, Cneius Manlius, Quintus Aelius, and Lucius Apustius. The assemblies of election to these two appointments were held in the Capitol by Cneius Domitius, city praetor. Several temples were dedicated this year: one of Juno Sospita, in the herb market, vowed and contracted for four years before, in the time of the Gallic war, by Cneius Cornelius, consul; and the same person, now censor, performed the dedication. Another of Faunus, the building of which had been agreed for two years before, and a fund formed for it out of fines estreated by the aediles, Caius Scribonius and Cneius Domitius; the latter of whom, now city praetor, dedicated it. Quintus Marcius Ralla, constituted commissioner for the purpose, dedicated the temple of Fortuna Primigenia, on the Quirinal Hill. Publius Sempronius Sophus had vowed this temple ten years before, in the Punic war; and, being afterwards censor, had employed persons to build it. Caius Servilius, duumvir, also dedicated a temple of Jupiter, in the island. This had been vowed in the Gallic war, six years before, by Lucius Furius Purpureo, who afterwards, when consul, contracted for the building.--Such were the transactions of that year.

In the later part of this year, Quintus Aelius Tubero, a plebeian tribune, following a decree from the Senate, proposed to the people, and they agreed, that "two Latin colonies should be established, one in Bruttium and the other in the territory of Thurium." Commissioners were appointed to oversee these settlements, serving for three years: for Bruttium, there were Quintus Naevius, Marcus Minucius Rufus, and Marcus Furius Crassipes; and for the district of Thurium, Cneius Manlius, Quintus Aelius, and Lucius Apustius. The elections for these positions were held at the Capitol by Cneius Domitius, the city praetor. Several temples were dedicated this year: one to Juno Sospita, in the herb market, which had been vowed and contracted for four years earlier, during the Gallic war, by Cneius Cornelius, the consul; and the same individual, now a censor, carried out the dedication. Another was dedicated to Faunus, the construction of which had been agreed upon two years prior, with funds raised from fines enforced by the aediles, Caius Scribonius and Cneius Domitius; the latter, now city praetor, also dedicated it. Quintus Marcius Ralla, appointed as commissioner for this purpose, dedicated the temple of Fortuna Primigenia on the Quirinal Hill. Publius Sempronius Sophus had vowed this temple ten years earlier, during the Punic war; and later, as censor, had hired people to build it. Caius Servilius, a duumvir, also dedicated a temple to Jupiter on the island. This temple had been vowed during the Gallic war, six years earlier, by Lucius Furius Purpureo, who later contracted for its construction when he became consul. --Such were the events of that year.

54

Publius Scipio came home from his province of Gaul to choose new consuls. The consular comitia were accordingly held, in which Lucius Cornelius Merula and Quintus Minucius Thermus were chosen. Next day were chosen praetors, Lucius Cornelius Scipio, Marcus Fulvius Nobilior, Caius Scribonius, Marcus Valerius Messala, Lucius Porcius Licinus, and Caius Flaminius. The curule aediles of this year, Caius Atilius Serranus and Lucius Scribonius, first exhibited the Megalesian theatrical games. At the Roman games, celebrated by these aediles, the senators, for the first time, sat separate from the people, which, as every innovation usually does, gave occasion to various observations. Some considered this as "an honour, shown at length to that most respectable body, and which ought to have been done long before;" while others contended, that "every addition made to the grandeur of the senate was a diminution of the dignity of the people; and that all such distinctions as set the orders of the state at a distance from each other, were equally subversive of liberty and concord. During five hundred and fifty-eight years," they asserted, "all the spectators had sat promiscuously: what reason then had now occurred, on a sudden, that should make the senators disdain to have the commons intermixed with them in the theatre, or make the rich disdain the poor man as a fellow-spectator? It was an unprecedented gratification of pride and over-bearing vanity, never even desired, and never instituted, by the senate of any other nation." It is said, that even Africanus himself at last became sorry for having proposed that matter in his consulship: so difficult is it to bring people to approve of any alteration of ancient customs; they are always naturally disposed to adhere to old practices, except those which experience evidently condemns.

Publius Scipio returned home from his province in Gaul to select new consuls. The consular elections took place, resulting in the selection of Lucius Cornelius Merula and Quintus Minucius Thermus. The following day, praetors were elected: Lucius Cornelius Scipio, Marcus Fulvius Nobilior, Caius Scribonius, Marcus Valerius Messala, Lucius Porcius Licinus, and Caius Flaminius. The curule aediles this year, Caius Atilius Serranus and Lucius Scribonius, were the first to hold the Megalesian theatrical games. At the Roman games organized by these aediles, senators sat apart from the people for the first time, which, as with any change, sparked various opinions. Some viewed this as "an honor finally given to the most respected group, which should have happened long ago," while others argued that "any enhancement of the senate's prestige undermines the dignity of the people, and such divisions that separate the different classes of society are equally detrimental to both liberty and unity. For five hundred and fifty-eight years," they claimed, "all spectators sat together: what reason has suddenly arisen for senators to reject sitting with the commons in the theater, or for the wealthy to look down on the poor as fellow spectators? This was an unprecedented show of pride and arrogance, never even suggested or initiated by the senate of any other nation." It is said that even Africanus eventually regretted bringing up this issue during his consulship: it is so difficult to get people to accept any changes to long-standing customs; they are naturally inclined to stick to old ways, except for those practices that experience clearly proves to be ineffective.

55

In the beginning of the year, which was the consulate of Lucius Cornelius and Quintus Minucius, such frequent reports of earthquakes were brought, that people grew weary, not only of the matter itself, but of the religious rites enjoined in consequence; for neither could the senate be convened, nor the business of the public be transacted, the consuls were so constantly employed in sacrifices and expiations. At last, the decemvirs were ordered to consult the books; and, in pursuance of their answer, a supplication was performed during three days. People offered prayers at all the shrines, with garlands on their heads; and an order was published, that all the persons belonging to one family should pay their worship together; and the consuls, by direction of the senate, published an edict, that, on any day whereon religious rites should be ordered, in consequence of the report of an earthquake, no person should report another earthquake on that day. Then the consuls first, and afterwards the praetors, cast lots for their provinces. Cornelius obtained Gaul; Minucius, Liguria; Caius Scribonius, the city jurisdiction; Marcus Valerius, the foreign; Lucius Cornelius, Sicily; Lucius Porcius, Sardinia; Caius Flaminius, Hither Spain; and Marcus Fulvius, Farther Spain.

At the start of the year, during the consulate of Lucius Cornelius and Quintus Minucius, there were so many reports of earthquakes that people became tired, not only of the issue itself but also of the religious rituals required as a result. The senate couldn't meet, and public affairs were stalled because the consuls were continuously busy with sacrifices and atonements. Eventually, the decemvirs were instructed to consult the sacred texts; following their findings, a three-day supplication was held. People prayed at all the shrines, wearing garlands on their heads; an order was issued that all members of a family should worship together. By direction of the senate, the consuls published an edict stating that on any day when religious rituals were mandated due to earthquake reports, no one should report another earthquake on that day. The consuls then first, and later the praetors, drew lots for their provinces. Cornelius got Gaul; Minucius, Liguria; Caius Scribonius, city jurisdiction; Marcus Valerius, foreign jurisdiction; Lucius Cornelius, Sicily; Lucius Porcius, Sardinia; Caius Flaminius, Hither Spain; and Marcus Fulvius, Farther Spain.

56

While the consuls supposed that, for that year, they should have no employment of a military kind, a letter was brought from Marcus Cincius, who was commander at Pisae, announcing, that "twenty thousand armed Ligurians, in consequence of a conspiracy of that whole nation, formed in the meetings of their several districts, had first wasted the lands of Luna, and then, passing through the territory of Pisae, had overrun the whole sea-coast." In consequence of this intelligence, the consul Minucius, whose province Liguria was, by direction of the senate, mounted the rostrum, and published orders, that "the two legions, enlisted the year before, should, on the tenth day from that, attend him at Arretium;" and mentioned his intention of levying two legions for the city in their stead. He likewise gave notice to the magistrates and ambassadors of such of the allies, and of the Latin confederates, as were bound to furnish soldiers, to attend him in the Capitol. Of these he wrote out a list, amounting to fifteen thousand foot and five hundred horse, proportioning the contingent of each state to the number of its young men, and ordered those present to go directly from the spot to the gate of the city; and, in order to expedite the business, to proceed to raise the men. To Fulvius and Flaminius were assigned, to each three thousand Roman foot, and a reinforcement of one hundred horse, with five thousand foot of the Latin allies, and two hundred horse; and orders were given to those praetors, to disband the old troops immediately on their arrival in their provinces. Although great numbers of the soldiers belonging to the city legions had made application to the plebeian tribunes, to take cognizance of the cases of such men as claimed exemption from the service, on account either of having served out their time, or of bad health; yet a letter from Tiberius Sempronius banished all thoughts of such proceeding; for in this it was announced that "fifteen thousand of the Ligurians had come into the lands of Placentia, and wasted them with fire and sword, to the very walls of that city and the bank of the Po; and that the Boian nation were looking out for an occasion to rebel." In consequence of this information, the senate passed a vote, that "there was a Gallic tumult subsisting, and that it would be improper for the plebeian tribunes to take cognizance of the claims of the soldiers, so as to prevent their attending, pursuant to the proclamation;" and they added an order, that the Latin confederates, who had served in the army of Publius Cornelius and Tiberius Sempronius, and had been discharged by those consuls, should re-assemble, on whatever day and in whatever place of Etruria the consul Lucius Cornelius should appoint; and that the consul Lucius Cornelius, on his way to his province, should enlist, arm, and carry with him all such persons as he should think fit, in the several towns and countries through which he was to pass, and should have authority to discharge such of them, and at such times, as he might judge proper.

While the consuls believed that they wouldn’t have any military duties that year, a letter arrived from Marcus Cincius, the commander at Pisae, announcing that "twenty thousand armed Ligurians, due to a conspiracy among the entire nation during their regional meetings, had first devastated the lands of Luna, and then, passing through the territory of Pisae, had invaded the entire coastline." In response to this news, consul Minucius, whose province was Liguria, under the direction of the senate, took to the platform and issued orders that "the two legions enlisted the year before should report to him at Arretium in ten days;" and he mentioned his plan to raise two legions for the city as replacements. He also informed the magistrates and ambassadors of the allies, as well as the Latin confederates, who were required to provide soldiers, to meet him at the Capitol. He compiled a list of fifteen thousand infantry and five hundred cavalry, distributing each state's contribution based on the number of its young men, and instructed those present to head straight from there to the city gate; to speed things up, he directed them to start recruiting the soldiers. Fulvius and Flaminius were each assigned three thousand Roman infantry, a reinforcement of one hundred cavalry, along with five thousand infantry from the Latin allies and two hundred cavalry; they were ordered to disband the old troops as soon as they arrived in their provinces. Although many soldiers from the city legions had approached the plebeian tribunes to address the cases of those who claimed exemptions from service—whether due to having completed their time or because of poor health—a letter from Tiberius Sempronius put an end to any such thoughts; it reported that "fifteen thousand Ligurians had invaded the lands of Placentia, laying waste to them with fire and sword, all the way to the walls of that city and the banks of the Po; and that the Boian people were looking for a chance to rebel." As a result of this information, the senate voted that "a Gallic disturbance was ongoing, and that it would be inappropriate for the plebeian tribunes to address the soldiers' claims, as it would prevent them from responding to the proclamation;" they also instructed that the Latin confederates, who had served in the armies of Publius Cornelius and Tiberius Sempronius and had been discharged by those consuls, should re-assemble on whatever day and in whatever location in Etruria consul Lucius Cornelius appointed; and that consul Lucius Cornelius, while heading to his province, should enlist, equip, and take with him all individuals he deemed fit in the various towns and regions he was to pass through, with the authority to discharge any of them, at any time he thought appropriate.

57

After the consuls had finished the levies, and were gone to their provinces, Titus Quinctius demanded, that "the senate should receive an account of the regulations which he in concert with the ten ambassadors, had settled; and, if they thought proper, ratify them by their authority." He told them, that "they would accomplish this the more easily, if they were first to give audience to the ambassadors, who had come from all parts of Greece, and a great part of Asia, and to those from the two kings." These embassies were introduced to the senate by the city praetor, Caius Scribonius, and all received kind answers. As the discussion of the affair with Antiochus required too much time, it was referred to the ten ambassadors, some of whom had conferred with the king in Asia, or at Lysimachia. Directions were given to Titus Quinctius, that, in conjunction with these, he should listen to the representations of the king's ambassadors, and should give them such answer as comported with the dignity and interest of the Roman people. At the head of the embassy were Menippus and Hegesianax; the former of whom said, that "he could not conceive what intricacy there was in the business of their embassy, as they came simply to ask friendship, and conclude an alliance. Now, there were three kinds of treaties, by which kings and states formed friendships with each other: one, when terms were dictated to a people vanquished in war; for after all their possessions have been surrendered to him who has proved superior in war, he has the sole power of judging and determining what portion of them the vanquished shall hold, and of what they shall be deprived. The second, when parties, equally matched in war, conclude a treaty of peace and friendship on terms of equality; for then demands are proposed and restitution made, reciprocally, in a convention; and if, in consequence of the war, confusion has arisen with respect to any parts of their properties, the matter is adjusted on the footing either of ancient right or of the mutual convenience of the parties. The third kind was, when parties who had never been foes, met to form a friendly union by a social treaty: these neither dictate nor receive terms, for that is the case between a victor and a party vanquished. As Antiochus came under this last description, he wondered, he said, that the Romans should think it becoming to dictate terms to him; as to which of the cities of Asia they chose should be free and independent, which should be tributary, and which of them the king's troops and the king himself should be prohibited to enter. That a peace of this kind might be ratified with Philip, who was their enemy, but not a treaty of alliance with Antiochus, their friend."

After the consuls finished the levies and headed to their provinces, Titus Quinctius asked the senate to review the regulations he had established with the ten ambassadors and to approve them if they deemed it appropriate. He suggested that this would be easier if they first listened to the ambassadors who had come from all over Greece and much of Asia, as well as those from the two kings. The city praetor, Caius Scribonius, introduced these delegations to the senate, and they all received friendly responses. Since discussing the matter with Antiochus would take too long, it was handed over to the ten ambassadors, some of whom had talked with the king in Asia or at Lysimachia. Titus Quinctius was instructed to listen to the king's ambassadors along with these others and respond in a way that reflected the dignity and interests of the Roman people. Leading the embassy were Menippus and Hegesianax; Menippus remarked that he couldn't understand the complexities of their mission since they were simply there to seek friendship and establish an alliance. He explained that there are three types of treaties by which kings and states form friendships: the first is when terms are imposed on a defeated people, where the victor decides what rights the vanquished retain or lose. The second type is when equally matched parties agree on peace and friendship through mutual terms, negotiating demands and restitution as needed, adjusting for any confusion caused by the war based on past rights or mutual benefit. The third type is when parties who have never been enemies come together to form a friendly union without dictating or receiving terms, as would be the case for a victor and a defeated opponent. Since Antiochus fell into this last category, he expressed his surprise that the Romans thought it appropriate to dictate terms to him regarding which cities in Asia should be free, which should pay tribute, and where the king's troops, including the king himself, would be forbidden to go. He noted that a peace like this could be ratified with Philip, their enemy, but not a treaty of alliance with Antiochus, their friend.

58

To this Quinctius answered: "Since you choose to deal methodically, and enumerate the several modes of contracting alliances, I also will lay down two conditions, without which you may tell your king, that there are no means of contracting any friendship with the Roman people. One, that, he does not choose that we should concern ourselves in the affairs of the cities in Asia, he must himself keep entirely out of Europe. The other, that if he does not confine himself within the limits of Asia, but passes over into Europe, the Romans will think themselves at full liberty to maintain the friendships which they have already formed with the states of Asia, and also to contract new ones." On this Hegesianax exclaimed, that "this proposition was unworthy to be listened to, as its tendency was to exclude Antiochus from the cities of Thrace and the Chersonese,--places which his great-grandfather, Seleucus, had acquired with great honour, after vanquishing Lysimachus in war and killing him in battle, and had left to his successors; and part of which, after they had been seized by the Thracians, Antiochus had, with equal honour, recovered by force of arms; as well as others which had been deserted,--as Lysimachia, for instance, he had repeopled, by calling home the inhabitants;--and several, which had been destroyed by fire, and buried in ruins, he had rebuilt at a vast expense. What kind of resemblance was there, then, in the cases of Antiochus being ejected from possessions so acquired and so recovered; and of the Romans refraining from intermeddling with Asia, which had never been theirs? Antiochus wished to obtain the friendship of the Romans; but so that its acquisition would be to his honour, and not to his shame." In reply to this, Quinctius said,--"Since we are deliberating on what would be honourable, and which, indeed with a people who held the first rank among the nations of the world, and with so great a king, ought to be the sole, or at least the primary object of regard; tell me, I pray you, which do you think more honourable, to wish to give liberty to all the Grecian cities in every part of the world; or to make them slaves and vassals? Since Antiochus thinks it conducive to his glory, to reduce to slavery those cities, which his great-grandfather held by the right of arms, but which his grandfather or father never occupied as their property while the Roman people, having undertaken the patronage of the liberty of the Greeks, deem it incumbent on their faith and constancy not to abandon it. As they have delivered Greece from Philip, so they have it in contemplation to deliver, from Antiochus, all the states of Asia which are of the Grecian race. For colonies were not sent into Aeolia and Ionia to be enslaved to kings; but with design to increase the population, and to propagate that ancient race in every part of the globe."

To this, Quinctius replied, "Since you prefer to discuss things methodically and list the various ways to form alliances, I will also state two conditions. Without these, you can tell your king that there's no way to establish any friendship with the Roman people. First, if he doesn’t want us to get involved in the affairs of cities in Asia, he must completely stay out of Europe himself. Second, if he doesn’t limit himself to Asia and moves into Europe, the Romans will feel free to maintain the friendships they’ve already established with the states in Asia and also to form new ones." In response, Hegesianax exclaimed, "This proposal is not worth considering, as it aims to exclude Antiochus from the cities of Thrace and the Chersonese—territories that his great-grandfather, Seleucus, won with great honor after defeating Lysimachus in battle and that he left to his successors. Parts of these lands were seized by the Thracians, but Antiochus honorably reclaimed them by force; he also repopulated deserted cities like Lysimachia by bringing back the inhabitants and rebuilt others that had been destroyed by fire and left in ruins at great expense. How can it be compared for Antiochus to be expelled from possessions he rightfully acquired and recovered, and for the Romans to stay out of Asia, which has never belonged to them? Antiochus wants to gain the friendship of the Romans, but in a way that honors him, not shames him." In reply, Quinctius said, "Since we are considering what would be honorable, which should indeed be the main focus when dealing with a people who hold the highest rank among the nations and such a great king, tell me, what do you think is more honorable: to wish to grant freedom to all the Greek cities everywhere or to enslave them? Antiochus believes it brings him glory to enslave those cities that his great-grandfather held by right of arms, but that neither his grandfather nor father owned while the Roman people, having taken on the responsibility of defending Greek freedom, believe it is their duty not to abandon it. Just as they liberated Greece from Philip, they plan to deliver all the Asian states of Greek origin from Antiochus. Colonies were not sent to Aeolia and Ionia to be subjugated by kings; rather, they were meant to increase the population and spread that ancient race across the globe."

59

When Hegesianax hesitated, and could not deny, that the cause of liberty carried a more honourable semblance than that of slavery, Publius Sulpicius, who was the eldest of the ten ambassadors, said,--"Let us cut the matter short. Choose one of the two conditions clearly propounded just now by Quinctius; or deem it superfluous to negotiate about an alliance." But Menippus replied, "We neither will, nor can, accede to any proposition by which the dominions of Antiochus would be diminished." Next day, Quinctius brought into the senate-house all the ambassadors of Greece and Asia, in order that they might learn the dispositions entertained by the Roman people, and by Antiochus, towards the Grecian states. He then acquainted them with his own demands, and those of the king; and desired them to "assure their respective states, that the same disinterested zeal and courage, which the Roman people had displayed in defence of their liberty against the encroachments of Philip, they would, likewise, exert against those of Antiochus, if he should refuse to retire out of Europe." On this, Menippus earnestly besought Quinctius and the senate, "not to be hasty in forming their determination, which, in its effects, might disturb the peace of the whole world; to take time to themselves, and allow the king time for consideration; that, when informed of the conditions proposed, he would consider them, and either obtain some relaxation in the terms, or accede to them for the sake of peace." Accordingly, the business was deferred entire; and a resolution passed, that the same ambassadors should be sent to the king who had attended him at Lysimachia,--Publius Sulpicius, Publius Villius, and Publius Aelius.

When Hegesianax hesitated and couldn’t deny that the cause of liberty looked more honorable than that of slavery, Publius Sulpicius, the eldest of the ten ambassadors, said, "Let’s get straight to the point. Choose one of the two options clearly stated just now by Quinctius, or consider it pointless to negotiate about an alliance." But Menippus replied, "We will neither agree to nor can accept any proposal that would diminish the territories of Antiochus." The next day, Quinctius brought all the ambassadors from Greece and Asia into the senate-house so they could understand the attitudes of the Roman people and Antiochus towards the Greek states. He then shared his own demands and those of the king, and asked them to "assure their respective states that the same selfless enthusiasm and courage the Roman people showed in defending their liberty against the encroachments of Philip would also be used against Antiochus if he refuses to leave Europe." In response, Menippus earnestly urged Quinctius and the senate "not to rush into a decision that could disrupt the peace of the entire world; to take their time and allow the king time for consideration. When he learns of the proposed conditions, he will think them over and either seek some relaxation of the terms or agree to them for the sake of peace." As a result, the matter was fully postponed, and it was decided that the same ambassadors who had accompanied the king at Lysimachia—Publius Sulpicius, Publius Villius, and Publius Aelius—would be sent to the king.

60

Scarcely had these begun their journey, when ambassadors from Carthage brought information, that Antiochus was evidently preparing for war, and that Hannibal was employed in his service; which gave reason to fear, that a Punic war might break out at the same time. Hannibal, on leaving his own country, had gone to Antiochus, as was mentioned before, and was held by the king in high estimation, not so much for his other qualifications, as because, to a person who had long been revolving schemes for a war with Rome, there could not be any fitter participator of his counsels on such a subject. His opinion was always one and the same, that the war should be carried on in Italy: because "Italy would supply a foreign enemy both with men and provisions; but, if it were left in quiet, and the Roman people were allowed to employ the strength and forces of Italy, in making war beyond the limits of that country, no king or nation would be able to cope with them." He demanded, for himself, one hundred decked ships, ten thousand foot, and one thousand horse. "With this force," he said, "he would first repair to Africa; and he had confident hopes, that he should be able to prevail on the Carthaginians to revive hostilities. If they should hesitate, he would raise a war against the Romans in some part of Italy. That the king ought to cross over into Europe with all the rest of his force, and keep his army in some part of Greece; not to pass over immediately into Italy, but to be in readiness to do so; which would sufficiently conduce to the imposing character and the reported magnitude of the war."

As soon as they started their journey, ambassadors from Carthage arrived with news that Antiochus was clearly getting ready for war and that Hannibal was working with him. This raised concerns that a Punic war might erupt soon. Hannibal, after leaving his homeland, had gone to Antiochus, as previously noted, and he was highly regarded by the king, not just for his other skills but also because he was a person who had been thinking about plans for war against Rome for a long time, making him the perfect advisor on the matter. His stance was always the same: the war should be fought in Italy. He argued that "Italy would provide a foreign enemy with both soldiers and supplies; but if it were left peaceful and the Roman people were allowed to use Italy’s strength and resources to fight abroad, no king or nation would be able to match them." He asked for himself one hundred equipped ships, ten thousand infantry, and one thousand cavalry. "With this force," he said, "I would first head to Africa; and I’m confident I could persuade the Carthaginians to start fighting again. If they hesitate, I would initiate a war against the Romans in some part of Italy. The king should take his entire force across to Europe and station his army in some part of Greece; he shouldn’t immediately invade Italy but be ready to do so, which would add to the impressive image and perceived scale of the war."

61

When he had brought the king to agree in his opinion, he judged it necessary to predispose the minds of his countrymen to the same; but he durst not send a letter, lest it might, by some accident, be intercepted, and his plans by that means, be discovered. He had found at Ephesus a Tyrian called Aristo, and in several less important commissions, had discovered him to possess a good degree of ingenuity. This man he now loaded with presents and promises of rewards which were confirmed by the king himself, and sent him to Carthage with messages. He told him the names of the persons whom it was necessary that he should see, and furnished him with secret tokens, by which they would know, with certainty, that the messages came from him. On this Aristo's appearing at Carthage, the reason of his coming was not discovered by Hannibal's friends sooner than by his enemies. At first, the subject was bruited about in their circles and at their tables; and at last some persons declared in the senate that "the banishment of Hannibal answered no purpose, if while resident in another country, he was still able to propagate designs for changing the administration, and disturbing the quiet of the state by his intrigues. That a Tyrian stranger, named Aristo, had come with a commission from Hannibal and king Antiochus; that certain men daily held secret conferences with him, and were concocting that in private, the consequences of which would soon break out, to the ruin of the public." This produced a general outcry, that "Aristo ought to be summoned, and examined respecting the reason of his coming; and if he did not disclose it, to be sent to Rome, with ambassadors accompanying him: that they had already suffered enough of punishment in atonement of the headstrong rashness of one individual; that the faults of private citizens should be at their own risk, and the state should be preserved free, not only from guilt, but even from the suspicion of it." Aristo, being summoned, contended for his innocence; and urged, as his strongest defence, that he had brought no letter to any person whatever: but he gave no satisfactory reason for his coming, and was chiefly embarrassed by the fact which they urged, that he had conversed solely with men of the Barcine faction. A warm debate ensued; some earnestly pressing, that he should be immediately seized as a spy, and kept in custody; while others insisted, that there were not sufficient grounds for such violent measures; that "putting strangers into confinement, without reason, was a step that afforded a bad precedent; for that the same would happen to the Carthaginians at Tyre, and other marts, where they frequently traded." The question was adjourned on that day. Aristo practised on the Carthaginians a Carthaginian artifice; for having early in the evening hung up a written tablet, in the most frequented place of the city, over the tribunal where the magistrates daily sat, he went on board his ship at the third watch, and fled. Next day, when the suffetes had taken their seats to administer justice, the tablet was observed, taken down, and read. Its contents were, that "Aristo came not with a private commission to any person, but with a public one to the elders;" by this name they called the senate. The imputation being thus thrown on the state, less pains were taken in searching into the suspicions harboured of a few individuals: however, it was determined, that ambassadors should be sent to Rome, to represent the affair to the consuls and the senate, and, at the same time, to complain of the injuries received from Masinissa.

When he had managed to get the king on his side, he thought it was important to prepare his countrymen's minds to agree as well. But he didn't dare send a letter, fearing it might be intercepted and his plans exposed. He had found a Tyrian named Aristo in Ephesus, who had shown some cleverness in various minor tasks. He showered this man with gifts and promises of rewards, which the king himself endorsed, and sent him to Carthage with messages. He instructed Aristo on whom he needed to see and gave him secret tokens to confirm that the messages came from him. When Aristo arrived in Carthage, the reason for his visit was discovered by Hannibal's friends just as quickly as by his enemies. Initially, the topic was discussed among their circles and at their gatherings; eventually, some individuals in the senate claimed that “Hannibal’s exile was pointless if he could still scheme from abroad to disrupt the state’s affairs. A Tyrian stranger named Aristo had come with a mission from Hannibal and King Antiochus; certain men were secretly meeting with him, plotting something that would soon erupt and ruin the public.” This led to a widespread outcry that “Aristo should be summoned and questioned about his visit; if he didn’t reveal his purpose, he should be sent to Rome under escort. They had already faced enough punishment due to one person's reckless actions; the mistakes of individuals should not threaten the state’s safety, which must remain free from guilt and even suspicion.” When summoned, Aristo insisted on his innocence, arguing that he hadn’t brought any letters for anyone. However, he failed to provide a convincing reason for his presence, and was mostly troubled by the fact that he had spoken only with members of the Barcine faction. A heated debate followed; some insisted he should be immediately taken as a spy and detained, while others argued that there wasn’t enough cause for such drastic actions, warning that “putting strangers in jail without reason sets a bad precedent, as the same could happen to the Carthaginians in Tyre and other cities they frequently traded with.” The matter was postponed for that day. Aristo then used a typical Carthaginian trick; he hung a written message in a busy part of the city, over the platform where magistrates usually sat, and at the third watch, he boarded his ship and escaped. The next day, when the suffetes began their judicial duties, they noticed the tablet, took it down, and read it. The message stated that “Aristo did not come with a private commission for anyone, but with a public one for the elders,” which was how they referred to the senate. With this accusation directed at the state, less inquiry was made into the suspicions that a few individuals harbored. Nonetheless, it was decided that ambassadors should be sent to Rome to report the matter to the consuls and the senate and to complain about the grievances inflicted by Masinissa.

62

When Masinissa observed that the Carthaginians were looked on with jealousy by others, and were full of dissensions among themselves; the nobles being suspected by the senate, on account of their conferences with Aristo, and the senate by the people, in consequence of the information given by the same Aristo, he thought that, at such a conjuncture, he might successfully encroach on their rights; and accordingly he laid waste their country along the sea-coast, and compelled several cities, which were tributary to the Carthaginians, to pay their taxes to him. This tract they call Emporia; it forms the shore of the lesser Syrtis, and has a fertile soil; one of its cities is Leptis, which paid a tribute to the Carthaginians of a talent a day. At this time, Masinissa not only ravaged that whole tract, but, with respect to a considerable part of it, disputed the right of possession with the Carthaginians; and when he learned that they were sending to Rome, both to justify their conduct, and, at the same time, to make complaints of him, he likewise sent ambassadors to Rome, to load them with suspicions, and to discuss the right to the taxes. The Carthaginians were heard first, and their account of the Tyrian stranger gave the senate no small uneasiness, as they dreaded being involved in war with Antiochus and the Carthaginians at the same time. What contributed chiefly to strengthen a suspicion of evil designs, was, that though they had resolved to seize Aristo, and send him to Rome, they had not placed a guard either on himself or his ship. Then began the controversy with the king's ambassadors, on the claims of the territory in dispute. The Carthaginians supported their cause by a boundary claim, urging that "It must belong to them, as being within the limits which Scipio, after conquering the country, had fixed as the boundaries which should be under Carthaginian rule; and also, by the acknowledgment of the king, who, when he was going in pursuit of Aphir, a fugitive from his kingdom, then hovering about Cyrene, with a party of Numidians, had solicited as a favour a passage through that very district, as being confessedly a part of the Carthaginian dominions." The Numidians insisted, "that they were guilty of misrepresentation with respect to the limits fixed by Scipio; and if a person chose to recur to the real origin of their property, what title had the Carthaginians to call any land in Africa their own: foreigners and strangers, to whom had been granted precariously, for the purpose of building a city, as much ground as they could encompass with the cuttings of a bull's hide? Whatever acquisitions they had made beyond Byrsa, their original settlement, they held by fraud and violence; for, in relation to the land in question, so far were they from being able to prove uninterrupted possession, from the time when it was first acquired, that they cannot even prove that they ever possessed it for any considerable time. As occasions offered, sometimes they, sometimes the kings of Numidia, had held the dominion of it; and the possession of it had always been held by the party which had the greatest armed force. They requested the senate to suffer the matter to remain on the same footing on which it stood before the Carthaginians became enemies to the Romans, or the king of Numidia their friend and ally; and not to interfere, so as to hinder whichever party was able, from keeping possession."--The senate resolved to tell the ambassadors of both parties, that they would send persons into Africa to determine the present controversy between the people of Carthage and the king. They accordingly sent Publius Scipio Africanus, Caius Cornelius Cethegus, and Marcus Minucius Rufus; who, after viewing the ground, and hearing what could be said on both sides, left every thing in suspense, their opinions inclining neither to one side nor the other. Whether they acted in this manner from their own judgment, or because they had been so instructed, is by no means so certain as it is, that as affairs were circumstanced, it was highly expedient to leave the dispute undecided: for, had the case been otherwise, Scipio alone, either from his own knowledge of the business, or the influence which he possessed, and to which he had a just claim on both parties, could, with a nod, have ended the controversy.

When Masinissa noticed that the Carthaginians were envied by others and were filled with internal conflicts; with the nobles being suspected by the senate due to their meetings with Aristo, and the senate being viewed with suspicion by the people because of the information provided by Aristo, he figured this was a good opportunity to assert his claims. As a result, he devastated their coastal territory and forced several cities that were paying tribute to the Carthaginians to pay their taxes to him instead. This area is known as Emporia; it borders the smaller Syrtis and has fertile land; one of its cities, Leptis, used to pay the Carthaginians a tribute of a talent a day. During this time, Masinissa not only ravaged the entire region but also contested the Carthaginians' right to a significant portion of it. Upon learning that the Carthaginians were sending envoys to Rome to justify their actions and complain about him, he also sent ambassadors to Rome to cast doubts on them and discuss tax rights. The Carthaginians were heard first, and their account of the Tyrian stranger caused considerable unease for the senate, as they feared getting drawn into a war with Antiochus as well as the Carthaginians. One reason for the heightened suspicion of foul play was that although they had decided to capture Aristo and send him to Rome, they hadn't secured either him or his ship. The debate began with the king's ambassadors over the claims to the disputed territory. The Carthaginians supported their case by arguing a boundary claim, insisting that "It must belong to them, as it is within the limits that Scipio had set after conquering the region, defining what should remain under Carthaginian control; furthermore, by the king's recognition when he sought permission to pass through that area while chasing Aphir, a fugitive from his kingdom, who was in the vicinity of Cyrene with a group of Numidians, acknowledging it as part of Carthaginian territory." The Numidians argued, "They are misrepresenting the boundaries defined by Scipio; if we look at the true origin of their land ownership, what right do the Carthaginians have to claim any land in Africa as theirs? They were foreigners granted just enough land to establish a city, confined to the area they could cover with a bull's hide. Any territory they claimed beyond Byrsa, their original settlement, was taken through deceit and force; when it comes to this land in question, they can't even establish continuous possession since it was first acquired, nor can they prove they ever held it for any significant period. Control of it has shifted periodically between them and the kings of Numidia, determined by whoever had the superior military power. They asked the senate to leave the situation as it was before the Carthaginians became enemies to the Romans and the Numidian king their ally, allowing whichever party was capable to maintain possession." The senate decided to inform the ambassadors from both sides that they would send representatives to Africa to resolve the current dispute between the Carthaginians and the king. They consequently sent Publius Scipio Africanus, Caius Cornelius Cethegus, and Marcus Minucius Rufus, who, after surveying the area and hearing both arguments, left the situation unresolved, their opinions neither favoring one side nor the other. Whether they acted this way by their own judgment or due to instructions is uncertain, but given the circumstances, it was certainly prudent to leave the disagreement unresolved. Had the situation been different, Scipio alone, either from his own understanding of the matter or from the influence he held, could have easily settled the dispute with a simple gesture.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXXV.


Publius Scipio Africanus sent as ambassador to Antiochus; has a conversation with Hannibal at Ephesus. Preparations of the Romans for war with Antiochus. Nabis, the tyrant of Lacedaemon, instigated by the Aetolians, makes war on the Achaeans; is put to death by a party of the Aetolians. The Aetolians, violating the treaty of friendship with the Romans, invite Antiochus, who comes, with a small force, into Greece, and, in conjunction with them, takes several towns, and the whole island of Euboea. The Achaeans declare war against Antiochus and the Aetolians.

       *        *        *        *        *

1

In the beginning of the same year, Sextus Digitius, praetor in the Hither Spain, fought with those states which, after the departure of Marcus Cato, had, in great numbers, recommenced hostilities, numerous battles, but none deserving of particular mention; and all so unfavourable to him, that he scarcely delivered to his successor half the number of men that he had received. In consequence of this, every state in Spain would certainly have resumed new courage, had not the other praetor, Publius Cornelius Scipio, son of Cneius, been successful in several engagements on the other side of the Iberus; and, by these means, diffused such a general terror, that no less than fifty towns came over to his side. These exploits Scipio performed in his praetorship. Afterwards, when propraetor, as the Lusitanians, after ravaging the farther Province, were returning home, with an immense booty, he attacked them on their march, and continued the engagement from the third hour of the day to the eighth, before any advantage was gained on either side. He was inferior to the enemy in number of men, but he had the advantage of them in other respects: with his troops formed in a compact body he attacked a long train, encumbered with multitudes of cattle; and with his soldiers fresh, engaged men, fatigued by a long march; for the enemy had set out at the third watch, and besides travelling the remainder of the night, had continued their route to the third hour of the day; nor had they been allowed any rest, as the battle immediately succeeded the toil of the march. Wherefore, though at the beginning they retained some vigour of body and spirits, and, at first, threw the Romans into disorder, yet, after some time, the fight became equal. In this critical situation the propraetor made a vow to celebrate games in honour of Jupiter, in case he should defeat and cut off the enemy. The Romans then made a more vigorous push, and the Lusitanians gave way, and, in a little time, turned their backs. As the victors pursued them briskly, no less than twelve thousand of them were slain, and five hundred and forty taken prisoners, most of whom were horsemen. There were taken, besides, a hundred and thirty-four military standards. Of the Roman army, but seventy-three men were lost. The battle was fought at a small distance from the city of Ilipa. Thither Publius Cornelius led back his victorious army, amply enriched with spoil; all which was exposed to view under the walls of the town, and permission given to the owners to claim their effects. The remainder was put into the hands of the quaestor to be sold, and the money produced by the sale was distributed among the soldiers.

In the beginning of the same year, Sextus Digitius, praetor of Hither Spain, engaged in battles with the states that, after Marcus Cato left, had resumed hostilities in large numbers. There were many battles, but none worth mentioning; all were so unfavorable to him that he hardly sent back half the troops he had received. As a result, every state in Spain would have certainly regained their confidence if it weren't for the other praetor, Publius Cornelius Scipio, son of Cneius, who achieved several victories on the other side of the Iberus. His successes instilled such widespread fear that fifty towns allied with him. Scipio accomplished these feats during his praetorship. Later, when he served as propraetor, he confronted the Lusitanians as they were returning home after ravaging the far province, carrying a huge haul of loot. He attacked them while they were on the move, fighting from the third hour of the day until the eighth, with no advantage gained for either side in the beginning. He faced a disadvantage in the number of troops, but he held advantages in other ways: with his soldiers grouped closely, he charged at a long column weighed down by many cattle, and his fresh troops engaged the enemy, who were exhausted from a long march. The enemy had departed at the third watch and, after traveling all night, continued their march until the third hour of the day without any rest, as the battle started right after their exhausting trek. Therefore, although they had some initial strength and threw the Romans into disarray at first, the fight eventually became even. In this critical moment, the propraetor vowed to hold games in honor of Jupiter if he defeated the enemy. Encouraged, the Romans fought with renewed energy, causing the Lusitanians to retreat. In a short time, they turned and fled. As the victors pursued them fiercely, about twelve thousand Lusitanians were killed, and five hundred and forty were captured, most of whom were cavalry. Additionally, one hundred thirty-four military standards were taken. The Roman army lost only seventy-three men. The battle took place close to the city of Ilipa. There, Publius Cornelius brought back his victorious army, filled with spoils, which were displayed under the town walls, allowing the owners to reclaim their possessions. The rest was given to the quaestor for sale, and the proceeds from the sale were distributed among the soldiers.

2

At the time when these occurrences happened in Spain, Caius Flaminius, the praetor, had not yet set out from Rome: therefore these events, as well prosperous as adverse, were reported by himself and his friends in the strongest representations; and he laboured to persuade the senate, that, as a very formidable war had blazed out in his province, and he was likely to receive from Sextus Digitius a very small remnant of an army, and that, too, terrified and disheartened they ought to decree one of the city legions to him, in order that, when he should have united to it the soldiers levied by himself, pursuant to the decree of the senate, he might select from the whole number six thousand five hundred foot and three hundred horse. He said, that "with such a legion as that, (for very little confidence could be placed on the troops of Sextus Digitius,) he would conduct the war." But the elder part of the senate insisted, that "decrees of the senate were not to be passed in consequence of rumours fabricated by private persons for the gratification of magistrates; and that no intelligence should be deemed authentic except it were either written by the praetors, from their provinces, or brought by their deputies. If there was a tumultuous commotion in Spain, they advised a vote, that tumultuary soldiers should be levied by the praetor in some other country than Italy." The senate's intention was that such description of men should be raised in Spain. Valerius Antias says, that Caius Flaminius sailed to Sicily for the purpose of levying troops, and that, on his voyage thence to Spain, being driven by a storm to Africa, he enlisted there many stragglers who had belonged to the army of Publius Africanus; and that, to the levies made in those two provinces, he added a third in Spain.

At the time these events took place in Spain, Caius Flaminius, the praetor, had not yet left Rome. As a result, these events, both positive and negative, were described by him and his friends in the strongest terms. He worked hard to persuade the senate that, since a very serious war had broken out in his province, and he was likely to receive a very small, frightened, and demoralized remnant of an army from Sextus Digitius, they should assign one of the city legions to him. This way, after he combined it with the soldiers he recruited himself, as per the senate's decree, he could select a total of six thousand five hundred infantry and three hundred cavalry. He claimed that "with such a legion as that"—since very little trust could be placed in the troops of Sextus Digitius—he would handle the war. However, the older members of the senate insisted that "the senate's decrees should not be made based on rumors fabricated by private individuals for the benefit of magistrates" and that no information should be considered reliable unless it was written by the praetors from their provinces or brought by their deputies. If there was unrest in Spain, they suggested a vote to have the praetor recruit soldiers from a region other than Italy. The senate intended for this type of soldiers to be recruited in Spain. Valerius Antias claims that Caius Flaminius sailed to Sicily to raise troops and that, during his journey from there to Spain, he was blown off course to Africa by a storm, where he recruited many stragglers who had been part of Publius Africanus's army; he then added these recruits to the ones he gathered in those two provinces and a third in Spain.

3

In Italy the war, commenced by the Ligurians, grew daily more formidable. They now invested Pisae, with an army of forty thousand men; for multitudes flocked to them continually, led by the reports of the war and the expectation of booty. The consul, Minucius, came to Arretium, on the day which he had fixed for the assembling of the troops. Thence he led them, in order of battle, towards Pisae; and though the enemy had removed their camp to the other side of the river, at a distance of no more than three miles from the place, the consul marched into the city, which evidently owed its preservation to his coming. Next day he also encamped on the other side of the river, about a mile from the enemy; and by slight skirmishes protected the lands of the allies from their depredations. He did not think it prudent to hazard a general engagement, because his troops were raw, composed of many different kinds of men, and not yet so well known among themselves that they could rely on one another. The Ligurians depended so much on their numbers, that they not only came out and offered battle, willing to risk every thing on the issue of it; but, from their superfluity of men, they sent out many parties along the frontiers to plunder; and whenever a large quantity of cattle, and other prey, was collected, there was an escort always in readiness to convey it to their forts and towns.

In Italy, the war started by the Ligurians became increasingly serious. They surrounded Pisa with an army of forty thousand men, as crowds kept joining them, drawn by news of the conflict and the promise of loot. The consul, Minucius, arrived in Arretium on the day he had scheduled for gathering the troops. He then marched them in battle formation towards Pisa; even though the enemy had moved their camp across the river, just three miles away, the consul entered the city, which clearly owed its safety to his arrival. The following day, he set up camp on the other side of the river, about a mile from the enemy, and conducted minor skirmishes to protect the allies' lands from being raided. He didn’t feel it was wise to risk a full battle because his soldiers were inexperienced, made up of various groups, and not familiar enough with each other to trust one another. The Ligurians, relying heavily on their numbers, not only came out to challenge him, eager to risk everything on the outcome, but also sent numerous parties to raid along the borders. Whenever they gathered a large amount of livestock and other loot, they always had escorts ready to take it back to their forts and towns.

4

While the operations remained at a stand at Pisae, the other consul, Lucius Cornelius Merula, led his army through the extreme borders of the Ligurians, into the territory of the Boians, where the mode of proceeding was quite the reverse of that which took place in the war of Liguria. The consul took the field; the enemy refused to fight; and the Romans, when no one would come out against them, went out in parties to plunder, while the Boians chose to let their country be laid waste with impunity rather than venture an engagement in defence of it. When all places were completely ravaged with fire and sword, the consul quitted the enemy's lands, and marched towards Mutina, in a careless manner, as through a pacific population. The Boians, when they learned that the enemy had withdrawn beyond their frontiers, followed him as secretly as possible, watching an opportunity for an ambuscade; and, having gone by his camp in the night, took possession of a defile through which the Romans were to pass. But as they were not able to effect this with sufficient secrecy, the consul, who usually began his march late in the night, now waited until day, lest, in the disorderly fight likely to ensue, darkness might increase the confusion; and though he did not stir before it was light, yet he sent forward a troop of horse to explore the country. When intelligence was brought by them of the number and situation of the enemy, he ordered the baggage to be heaped together in the centre, and the veterans to throw up a rampart round it; and then, with the rest of the army in order of battle, he advanced towards the enemy. The Gauls did the same, when they found that their stratagem was detected, and that they were to engage in a fair and regular battle, where success must depend on valour alone.

While the operations were stalled at Pisae, the other consul, Lucius Cornelius Merula, led his army through the far reaches of the Ligurians into the territory of the Boians. The approach here was completely different from that in the Ligurian War. The consul took the field, but the enemy refused to fight. Since no one challenged them, the Romans went out in groups to plunder, while the Boians preferred to let their land be destroyed rather than risk a battle to defend it. After ravaging the area with fire and sword, the consul left the enemy's territory and marched towards Mutina, as if traversing a peaceful region. When the Boians found out the enemy had moved beyond their borders, they secretly followed him, looking for a chance to ambush. They passed by his camp during the night and took control of a narrow pass that the Romans would have to cross. However, they weren't discreet enough, so the consul, who typically began his march late at night, decided to wait until daylight to avoid the confusion of a disorderly fight. Although he didn't move until it was light, he sent out a cavalry unit to scout the area. When they reported back about the enemy's numbers and position, he ordered the baggage to be gathered in the center, and the veterans to build a rampart around it. Then, with the rest of the army ready for battle, he advanced toward the enemy. The Gauls did the same upon realizing their plan had been uncovered and that they would be facing a fair and organized battle where success would depend solely on their bravery.

5

The battle began about the second hour. The left brigade of the allies, and the Extraordinaries, fought in the first line, and were commanded by two lieutenant-generals of consular dignity, Marcus Marcellus and Tiberius Sempronius, who had been consul the year before. The present consul was sometimes employed in the front of the line, sometimes in keeping back the legions in reserve, that they might not, through eagerness for fighting, come up to the attack until the signal was given. He ordered the two Minucii, Quintus and Publius, military tribunes, to lead off the cavalry on the legions into open ground, at some distance from the line; and "when he should give them the signal, to charge the enemy through the clear space." While he was thus employed, a message came from Tiberius Sempronius Longus, that the Extraordinaries could not support the onset of the Gauls; that great numbers had already fallen; and that partly through weariness, partly through fear, the ardour of the survivors was much abated. He recommended it therefore to the consul, if he thought proper, to send up one or other of the two legions, before the army suffered disgrace. The second legion was accordingly sent, and the Extraordinaries were ordered to retire. By the legion coming up, with its men fresh, and the ranks complete in their numbers, the fight was renewed with vigour. The left wing was withdrawn out of the action, and the right took its place in the van. The intense heat of the sun discomposed the Gauls, whose bodies were very ill qualified to endure it: nevertheless, keeping their ranks close, and leaning sometimes on each other, sometimes on their bucklers, they withstood the attack of the Romans; which, when the consul observed, in order to break their ranks, he ordered Caius Livius Salinator, commander of the allied cavalry, to charge them at full speed, and the legionary cavalry to remain in reserve. This tempest of cavalry first confused and disordered, and at length entirely broke the line of the Gauls; yet it did not make them fly. That was prevented by their officers, who, when they quitted their posts, struck them on the back with their spears, and compelled them to return to their ranks: but the allied cavalry, riding in among them, did not suffer them to recover their order. The consul exhorted his soldiers to "continue their efforts a little longer, for victory was within their reach; to press the enemy, while they saw them disordered and dismayed; for, if they were suffered to recover their ranks, they would enter on a fresh battle with doubtful success." He ordered the standard-bearers to advance with the standards, and then, all exerting themselves at once, they at length forced the enemy to give way. As soon as they turned their backs, and fled precipitately oh every side, the legionary cavalry was sent in pursuit of them. On that day, fourteen thousand of the Boians were slain; one thousand and ninety-two taken--as were seven hundred and twenty-one horsemen, and three of their commanders, with two hundred and twelve military standards, and sixty-three chariots. Nor did the Romans gain the victory without loss of blood: of themselves, or their allies, were lost above five thousand men, twenty-three centurions, four prefects of the allies, and two military tribunes of the second legion, Marcus Genucius and Marcus Marcius.

The battle started around the second hour. The left brigade of the allies and the Extraordinaries fought in the front line, led by two lieutenant generals of consular rank, Marcus Marcellus and Tiberius Sempronius, who had been consul the previous year. The current consul sometimes fought at the front and sometimes held back the legions in reserve to prevent them from rushing into battle before the signal was given. He instructed the two Minucii, Quintus and Publius, military tribunes, to move the cavalry forward with the legions into open ground, away from the line, and “when he gave them the signal, to charge the enemy through the clear space.” While he was occupied with this, a message arrived from Tiberius Sempronius Longus, stating that the Extraordinaries were struggling against the Gauls; many had already fallen, and due to fatigue and fear, the remaining soldiers’ enthusiasm had greatly diminished. He advised the consul that if he thought it wise, he should send one of the two legions before the army faced disgrace. Accordingly, the second legion was dispatched, and the Extraordinaries were ordered to withdraw. With the second legion arriving fresh and fully formed, the battle was reinvigorated. The left wing was pulled out of action, and the right took its place at the front. The blazing sun affected the Gauls, whose bodies were not suited for such heat; however, they maintained their ranks, leaning on each other and their shields to withstand the Roman attacks. Noticing this, the consul commanded Caius Livius Salinator, the commander of the allied cavalry, to charge them at full speed, while the legionary cavalry stayed in reserve. This cavalry charge first disrupted and disordered the Gauls, eventually breaking their line entirely; yet they did not flee. Their officers prevented this by striking them with their spears and forcing them back into their ranks, but the allied cavalry rushed in among them, preventing them from reorganizing. The consul urged his soldiers to "keep pushing for a bit longer, as victory was within their grasp; to press the enemy while they were confused and afraid, because if they managed to regroup, they would engage in a new battle with uncertain outcomes." He ordered the standard-bearers to move forward with their standards, and then, with everyone pushing together, they finally forced the enemy to retreat. As soon as the Gauls turned and fled in all directions, the legionary cavalry was sent after them. That day, fourteen thousand of the Boians were killed; one thousand and ninety-two were captured—along with seven hundred and twenty-one horsemen, three of their commanders, two hundred and twelve military standards, and sixty-three chariots. The Romans also suffered losses, with over five thousand men from their own ranks and their allies killed, including twenty-three centurions, four prefects of the allies, and two military tribunes from the second legion, Marcus Genucius and Marcus Marcius.

6

Letters from both the consuls arrived at Rome nearly at the same time. That of Lucius Cornelius gave an account of the battle fought with the Boians at Mutina; that of Quintus Minucius, from Pisae, mentioned, that "the holding of the elections had fallen to his lot, but that affairs in Liguria were in so uncertain a position, that he could not depart thence without bringing ruin on the allies, and material injury on the commonwealth. He therefore advised that, if the senate thought proper, they should direct his colleague (as his war was decided) to return to Rome for the elections. He said if Cornelius should object to this, because that employment had not fallen to his lot, he would certainly do whatever the senate should order; but he begged them to consider again and again whether it would not be more to the advantage of the republic, that an interregnum should take place, than that the province should be left by him in such a state." The senate gave directions to Caius Scribonius to send two deputies of senatorian rank to the consul, Lucius Cornelius, to communicate to him the letter sent by his colleague to the senate, and to acquaint him, that if he did not come to Rome to elect new magistrates, the senate were resolved, rather than Quintus Minucius should be called away from a war, in which no progress had been made, to suffer an interregnum to take place. The deputies sent brought back his answer, that he would come to Rome, to elect new magistrates. The letter of Lucius Cornelius, which contained an account of the battle with the Boians, occasioned a debate in the senate; for Marcus Claudius, lieutenant-general, in private letters to many of the senators, had written, "that they might thank the fortune of the Roman people, and the bravery of the soldiers, that the affair had been successful. That the conduct of the consul had been the cause of a great many men being lost, and of the enemy's army, for the annihilation of which an opportunity had been offered, having made its escape. That what made the loss of men the greater was, the reinforcements, necessary to support them when distressed, coming up too late from the reserve; and that, what enabled the enemy to slip out of their hands was, the signal being given too tardily to the legionary cavalry, and their not being allowed to pursue the fugitives." It was agreed, that no resolution should be hastily passed on the subject; and the discussion was accordingly adjourned to a fuller meeting.

Letters from both consuls reached Rome almost simultaneously. Lucius Cornelius's letter detailed the battle against the Boians at Mutina, while Quintus Minucius's letter from Pisae stated that "it was his responsibility to conduct the elections, but the situation in Liguria was so uncertain that he couldn’t leave without putting the allies at risk and harming the republic. He recommended that if the senate agreed, they should instruct his colleague (since his war was resolved) to return to Rome for the elections. He noted that if Cornelius objected, claiming it was not his responsibility, he would absolutely follow the senate's orders; but he urged them to reconsider whether it would be more beneficial for the republic to have an interregnum rather than leave the province in such disarray." The senate instructed Caius Scribonius to send two senator-level deputies to consul Lucius Cornelius to share his colleague’s letter and inform him that if he did not come to Rome to elect new officials, the senate was determined to allow an interregnum instead of pulling Quintus Minucius from a war that had made no progress. The deputies returned with Cornelius's response that he would come to Rome to conduct the elections. Lucius Cornelius's letter about the battle with the Boians sparked a debate in the senate; Marcus Claudius, lieutenant-general, had privately written to several senators, "that they should thank the fortune of the Roman people and the bravery of the soldiers for the successful outcome. The consul's decisions led to many losing their lives, and the enemy’s army, which they had the chance to obliterate, managed to escape. The greater loss of men was due to the reinforcements that arrived too late to support them during distress, and the enemy managed to evade capture because the signal for the legionary cavalry came too late and they were not permitted to pursue the fleeing enemy." It was decided that no quick resolution should be made on the matter; thus, the discussion was postponed for a more complete meeting.

7

Another concern also pressed upon them, namely, that the public was heavily distressed by usurious practices; and although avarice had been restricted by many laws respecting usury, yet a fraudulent course had been adopted--that of transferring the securities to subjects of some of the allied states, who were not bound by those laws, by which means usurers overwhelmed their debtors by unlimited interest. On considering of the best method for putting a stop to this evil the senate decreed, that a certain day should be fixed on for it, the next approaching festival of the infernal deities; and that any of the allies who should from that day lend money to the Roman citizens, should register the transaction; and that all proceedings respecting such money, lent after that day, should be regulated by the laws of whichever of the two states the debtor should choose. In some time after, when the great amount of debt, contracted through this kind of fraud, was discovered by means of the registries, Marcus Sempronius, plebeian tribune, by direction of the senate, proposed to the people, and the people ordered, that the laws relative to money lent between Roman citizens and subjects of any of the allied states, or Latin confederacy, should be the same as those between Roman citizens. Such were the transactions in Italy, civil and military. In Spain the war was far from being so formidable as the exaggerations of report had represented it. In Hither Spain, Caius Flaminius took the town of Ilucia, in the country of the Oretanians, and then marched his army into winter quarters. Several engagements took place during the winter, but none deserving of particular mention, directed against incursions of robbers rather than of the enemy; and yet with various success, and not without the loss of some men. More important services were performed by Marcus Fulvius. He fought a pitched battle near the town of Toletum, against the Vaccaeans, Vectonians, and Celtiberians; routed and dispersed their combined forces, and took prisoner their king, Hilermus.

Another concern weighed on them: the public was really suffering due to outrageous interest rates. Even though greed had been limited by many laws against usury, a tricky approach had emerged—transferring securities to subjects of some allied states that were not bound by those laws, allowing usurers to burden their debtors with unlimited interest. To tackle this issue, the senate decided to set a specific day for resolving it, coinciding with the upcoming festival of the underworld deities. From that day on, any allies lending money to Roman citizens would need to register the transaction, and all related legal matters for loans made after that day would follow the laws of the state chosen by the debtor. Later on, when the extensive debts incurred through this deceit were uncovered via the registries, Marcus Sempronius, a plebeian tribune, presented a proposal to the people as directed by the senate. The people agreed that the laws regarding loans between Roman citizens and subjects of any allied states or Latin confederacy would be the same as those among Roman citizens. Such were the events in Italy, both civil and military. In Spain, the war was not as daunting as reports had claimed. In Hither Spain, Caius Flaminius captured the town of Ilucia in the territory of the Oretanians and then settled his army into winter quarters. Several skirmishes occurred during the winter, but none significant enough to mention, focusing more on dealing with robber incursions than actual enemies, with mixed results and some loss of men. More notable actions were taken by Marcus Fulvius, who fought a decisive battle near the town of Toletum against the Vaccaeans, Vectonians, and Celtiberians; he defeated and scattered their combined forces and captured their king, Hilermus.

8

While this passed in Spain, the day of election was drawing near. Lucius Cornelius, therefore, the consul, left Marcus Claudius, lieutenant-general, in command of the army and came to Rome. After representing in the senate the services which he had performed, and the present state of the province, he expostulated with the conscript fathers on their not having ordered a thanksgiving to the immortal gods when so great a war was so happily terminated by one successful battle; and then demanded, that they would at the same time decree a supplication and a triumph. But, before the question was put, Quintus Metellus, who had been consul and dictator, said, that, "letters had been brought at the same time from the consul, Lucius Cornelius, to the senate, and from Marcus Marcellus, to a great part of the senators; which letters contradicted each other, and for that reason the consideration of the business had been adjourned, in order that it might be debated when the writers of those letters should he present. He had expected, therefore, that the consul, who knew that the lieutenant-general had written something to his disadvantage, would, when he himself was obliged to come, have brought him with him to Rome; especially, as the command of the army would, with more propriety, have been committed to Tiberius Sempronius, who already possessed authority, than to the lieutenant-general. As the case stood at present, it appeared as if the latter was kept out of the way designedly, lest he might assert in person the same things which he had written in his letters; and, face to face, either substantiate his charges, or, if he had alleged any thing untrue, be convicted of misrepresentation, until the truth should be clearly discovered. For this reason he was of opinion, that the senate should not, at present, assent to either of the decrees demanded by the consul." When he, however, persisted with undiminished energy in putting the question, that a thanksgiving should be ordered, and himself allowed to ride into the city in triumph; the plebeian tribunes, Marcus and Caius Titinius, declared, that they would enter their protest, if the senate passed any decree on the subject.

While this was happening in Spain, election day was getting closer. Lucius Cornelius, the consul, left Marcus Claudius, the lieutenant-general, in charge of the army and headed to Rome. After reporting to the senate about his accomplishments and the current situation of the province, he expressed his disappointment to the senators for not having declared a thanksgiving to the gods after such a significant war was successfully ended by one battle; he then requested that they issue a decree for a public supplication and a triumph. But before they could discuss it, Quintus Metellus, a former consul and dictator, spoke up, saying that letters had arrived simultaneously from the consul, Lucius Cornelius, addressed to the senate, and from Marcus Marcellus, sent to many senators; these letters contradicted each other, so they had postponed the matter to debate it when the authors of the letters were present. He expected that the consul, knowing that the lieutenant-general had written something against him, would have brought him to Rome, especially since it would have made more sense to hand over command of the army to Tiberius Sempronius, who already had authority, rather than to the lieutenant-general. As things stood, it seemed like the lieutenant-general was intentionally kept away to prevent him from personally asserting what he had written in his letters; this way, face to face, he could either back up his claims or, if he had said anything untrue, be proven wrong, until the truth came out clearly. For this reason, he believed the senate should not agree to either of the consul's proposed decrees at that moment. However, when the consul continued to push hard for the matter regarding the thanksgiving and for his own triumphal entry into the city, the plebeian tribunes, Marcus and Caius Titinius, announced that they would protest if the senate made any decision on the subject.

9

In the preceding year, Sextus Aelius Paetus and Caius Cornelius Cethegus were created censors. Cornelius now closed the lustrum. The number of citizens rated was a hundred and forty-three thousand seven hundred and four. Extraordinary quantities of rain fell in this year, and the Tiber overflowed the lower parts of the city; and some buildings near the Flumentan gate were even laid in ruins. The Coelimontan gate was struck by lightning, as was the wall on each side of it, in several places. At Aricia, Lanuvium, and on the Aventine, showers of stones fell. From Capua, a report was brought that a very large swarm of wasps flew into the forum, and settled on the temple of Mars; that they had been carefully collected, and burnt. On account of these prodigies, the decemvirs were ordered to consult the books; the nine days' festival was celebrated, a supplication proclaimed, and the city purified. At the same time, Marcus Porcius Cato dedicated a chapel to Maiden Victory, near the temple of Victory, two years after he had vowed it. During this year, a Latin colony was established in the Thurian territory by commissioners appointed for the purpose, Cneius Manlius Vulso, Lucius Apustius Fullo, and Quintus Aelius Tubero, who had proposed the order for its settlement. There went out thither three thousand foot and three hundred horsemen; a very small number in proportion to the extent of the land. Thirty acres might have been given to each footman, and sixty to a horseman, but, by the advice of Apustius, a third part was reserved, that they might afterwards, when they should judge proper, send out thither a new colony. The footmen received twenty acres each, the horsemen forty.

In the previous year, Sextus Aelius Paetus and Caius Cornelius Cethegus were appointed as censors. Cornelius then completed the lustrum. The total number of citizens counted was one hundred and forty-three thousand seven hundred and four. There was an unusual amount of rain this year, causing the Tiber River to flood the lower parts of the city, and some buildings near the Flumentan gate were even destroyed. The Coelimontan gate was struck by lightning, as were several spots on the walls beside it. Showers of stones fell at Aricia, Lanuvium, and on the Aventine. A report came from Capua about a huge swarm of wasps that flew into the forum and settled on the temple of Mars; they were carefully collected and burned. Because of these unusual events, the decemvirs were instructed to consult the sacred texts; a nine-day festival was held, a supplication announced, and the city was purified. At the same time, Marcus Porcius Cato dedicated a chapel to Maiden Victory near the temple of Victory, two years after he had made the vow. During this year, a Latin colony was established in the Thurian territory by commissioners assigned for that purpose—Cneius Manlius Vulso, Lucius Apustius Fullo, and Quintus Aelius Tubero—who had proposed the settlement order. They sent out three thousand infantry and three hundred cavalry, which was a very small number considering the size of the land. Each infantryman could have received thirty acres, and each cavalryman sixty, but on Apustius's advice, a third of the land was set aside so that a new colony could be sent there later if deemed appropriate. The infantrymen received twenty acres each, while the cavalrymen got forty.

10

The year was now near a close, and with regard to the election of consuls, emulation was more fiercely kindled than was ever known before. The candidates, both patrician and plebeian, were many and powerful: Publius Cornelius Scipio, son to Cneius, and who had lately come home from Spain, having performed great exploits; Lucius Quinctius Flamininus, who had commanded the fleet in Greece; and Cneius Manlius Vulso; these were the patricians. Then there were, of plebeian rank, Caius Laelius, Cneius Domitius, Caius Livius Salinator, and Manius Acilius. The eyes of all men were turned on Quinctius and Cornelius; for, being both patricians, they sued for one place; and they were both of them recommended by high and recent renown in war. Above every thing else, the brothers of the candidates, the two most illustrious generals of the age, increased the violence of the struggle. Scipio's fame was the more splendid, and in proportion to its greater splendour, the more obnoxious to envy. That of Quinctius was the most recent, as he had triumphed in the course of that very same year. Besides, the former had now for almost ten years been continually in people's sight; which circumstance, by the mere effect of satiety, causes great characters to be less revered. He had been a second time consul after the final defeat of Hannibal, and also censor. All Quinctius's claims to the favour of the public were fresh and new; since his triumph, he had neither asked nor received anything from the people; "he solicited," he said, "in favour of his own brother, not of a half-brother; in favour of his lieutenant-general, and partner in the administration of the war; his brother having conducted the operations by sea, while he did the same on land." By these arguments he carried his point. His brother was preferred to the brother of Africanus, though supported by the whole Cornelian family, and while one of the same family presided at the election, and notwithstanding the very honourable testimony given by the senate, in his favour, when it adjudged him to be the best man in the state: and as such, appointed him to receive the Idaean Mother into the city, when she was brought from Pessinus. Lucius Quinctius and Cneius Domitius Ahenobarbus were elected consuls; so that, not even with respect to the plebeian consul, could Africanus prevail; for he employed his interest in favour of Caius Laelius. Next day were elected praetors, Lucius Scribonius Libo, Marcus Fulvius Centumalus, Aulus Atilius Serranus, Marcus Baebius Tamphilus, Lucius Valerius Tappus, and Quintus Salonius Sarra. The aedileship of this year was highly distinguished, namely, that of Marcus Aemilius Lepidus and Lucius Aemilius Paulus. They prosecuted to conviction many of the farmers of the public pastures, and with the money accruing from the fines, placed gilded shields in the upper part of the temple of Jupiter. They built one colonnade, on the outside of the gate Tergemina, to which they added a wharf on the Tiber: and another, reaching from the Frontinal gate to the altar of Mars, to serve as a passage into the field of Mars.

The year was coming to an end, and regarding the election of consuls, competition was fiercer than ever before. There were many powerful candidates, both patricians and plebeians: Publius Cornelius Scipio, son of Cneius, who had just returned from Spain after achieving great feats; Lucius Quinctius Flamininus, who had commanded the fleet in Greece; and Cneius Manlius Vulso, these were the patricians. Among the plebeians were Caius Laelius, Cneius Domitius, Caius Livius Salinator, and Manius Acilius. Everyone's attention was focused on Quinctius and Cornelius; being both patricians, they were vying for the same position, supported by their recent reputations from military success. The situation was intensified by the presence of their brothers, the two most notable generals of the time. Scipio's fame was more radiant, and the brighter it shone, the more it attracted envy. Quinctius’s fame was the most recent, as he had triumphantly celebrated just that same year. Furthermore, Scipio had been in the public eye for nearly ten years, which tended to diminish the reverence for even the greatest figures over time. He had been consul a second time after the final defeat of Hannibal and had also served as censor. Quinctius’s arguments for public favor were fresh; since his triumph, he had neither asked for nor accepted anything from the people. "I’m advocating," he claimed, "for my own brother, not a half-brother; for my lieutenant-general and partner in the conduct of the war; my brother managed the operations at sea while I handled those on land." By these arguments, he succeeded. His brother was chosen over the brother of Africanus, even though he had the backing of the entire Cornelian family and while one from that family oversaw the election, despite the very favorable recommendation from the senate, which named him the best man in the state and appointed him to bring the Idaean Mother into the city from Pessinus. Lucius Quinctius and Cneius Domitius Ahenobarbus were elected consuls, so that even concerning the plebeian consul, Africanus could not prevail, as he backed Caius Laelius. The next day, the praetors elected were Lucius Scribonius Libo, Marcus Fulvius Centumalus, Aulus Atilius Serranus, Marcus Baebius Tamphilus, Lucius Valerius Tappus, and Quintus Salonius Sarra. This year’s aedileship was notable, particularly that of Marcus Aemilius Lepidus and Lucius Aemilius Paulus. They successfully prosecuted many of the farmers of the public pastures, and with the fines collected, they placed gilded shields in the upper part of the temple of Jupiter. They constructed one colonnade outside the Tergemina gate, along with a wharf on the Tiber, and another colonnade stretching from the Frontinal gate to the altar of Mars, serving as a passage into the field of Mars.

11

For a long time, nothing worth recording had occurred in Liguria; but, towards the end of this year, the Roman affairs there were twice brought into great peril; for the consul's camp, being assaulted, was with difficulty preserved; and a short time after, as the Roman army was marching through a defile, the Ligurians seized on the opening through which they were to pass. The consul, when he found that passage stopped up, faced about, resolved to return: but the entrance behind, also, was occupied by a party of the enemy, and the disaster of Caudium not only occurred to the memory of the Romans, but was in a manner represented to their eyes. The consul had, among his auxiliary troops, about eight hundred Numidian horsemen, whose commanding officer undertook to force a passage with his troops, on whichever side the consul should choose. He only desired to be told on which part the greater number of villages lay, for on them he meant to make an attack; and the first thing he intended doing was, to set fire to the houses, in order that the alarm, which this should occasion, might induce the Ligurians to quit their posts in the defile, and hasten to different quarters to carry assistance to their friends. The consul highly commended him, and gave him assurance of ample rewards. The Numidians mounted their horses, and began to ride up to the advanced posts of the enemy, but without making any attack. Nothing could appear, on the first view, more contemptible. Both men and horses were of a small size and thin make, the riders unaccoutred and unarmed, excepting that they carried javelins in their hands; and the horses without bridles, and awkward in their gait, running with their necks stiff and their heads stretched out. The contempt, conceived from their appearance, they took pains to increase; sometimes falling from their horses, and making themselves objects of derision and ridicule. The consequence was, that the enemy, who at first had been alert, and ready on their posts, in case of an attack, now, for the most part, laid aside their arms, and sitting down amused themselves with looking at them. The Numidians often rode up, then galloped back, but still contrived to get nearer to the pass, as if they were unable to manage their horses, and were carried away against their will. At last, setting spurs to them, they broke out through the midst of the enemy's posts, and getting into the open country, set fire to all the houses near the road. They then set fire to the nearest village, while they ravaged all around with fire and sword. At first the sight of the smoke, then the shouts of the affrighted inhabitants, at last the old people and children, who fled for shelter, created great disorder in the camp. In consequence of which the whole of their army, without plan, and without command, ran off, each to take care of his own; the camp was in a moment deserted; and the consul delivered from the blockade, made good his march to the place whither he intended to go.

For a long time, nothing significant happened in Liguria; however, towards the end of this year, Roman affairs there faced serious danger twice. The consul's camp was attacked but managed to hold on with difficulty. Shortly afterward, as the Roman army was moving through a narrow pass, the Ligurians blocked their route. When the consul saw the passage was blocked, he turned around, deciding to retreat, but the exit behind them was also occupied by enemy forces. The memory of the disaster at Caudium flashed in the minds of the Romans, almost playing out in front of them. Among his auxiliary troops, the consul had about eight hundred Numidian horsemen, whose commander volunteered to force a passage wherever the consul wanted. He just needed to know which direction had more villages since he intended to launch an attack there. His first action would be to set fire to the houses to create chaos, hoping the alarm would draw the Ligurians away from the pass to help their allies. The consul highly praised him and promised generous rewards. The Numidians mounted their horses and approached the enemy's forward positions without attacking. At first glance, they appeared utterly unimpressive. Both the riders and horses were small and thin, and the soldiers were unarmored, armed only with javelins. Their horses had no bridles and moved awkwardly, with stiff necks and stretched-out heads. To further fuel the enemy’s contempt for them, they occasionally fell from their horses, becoming subjects of mockery. As a result, the enemy, who had initially been alert and ready for an attack, mostly relaxed, putting down their arms and sitting back to watch. The Numidians often rode close to the enemy, then quickly turned back, all the while getting closer to the pass, as if they couldn’t handle their horses and were being dragged against their will. Finally, they urged their horses on and burst through the enemy positions, reaching the open country where they set fire to all the houses along the road. They torched the nearest village while plundering the area with fire and sword. First, there was the sight of smoke, followed by the cries of terrified residents, and then the old and young fleeing for safety, which caused chaos in the enemy camp. Consequently, their entire army, without any plan or leadership, fled in all directions, each person looking out for themselves; the camp was instantly abandoned, and the consul, freed from the blockade, made his way to his intended destination.

12

But neither the Boians nor the Spaniards, with whom they had been at war during that year, were such bitter and inveterate foes to the Romans as the nation of the Aetolians. These, after the departure of the Roman armies from Greece, had, for some time, entertained hopes that Antiochus would come and take possession of Europe, without opposition; and that neither Philip nor Nabis would continue quiet. But seeing no active measures begun, in any quarter, they resolved, lest their designs might be damped by delay, to create some agitation and disturbance; and, with this view, they summoned a general assembly at Naupactum. Here Thoas, their praetor, after complaining of the injurious behaviour of the Romans, and the present state of Aetolia, and asserting, that "of all the nations and states of Greece, they had been most unhonoured, after the victory which they themselves had been the means of obtaining," moved, that ambassadors should be sent to each of the kings; not only to sound their dispositions, but, by such incentives as suited the temper of each, to urge them to a war with Rome. Damocritus was sent to Nabis, Nicander to Philip, and Dicaearchus, the praetor's brother, to Antiochus. To the Lacedaemonian tyrant Damocritus represented, that, "by the maritime cities being taken from him, his government was left enervated; for from them he had drawn his soldiers, as well as his ships and seamen. He was now pent up almost within the walls of his capital, while he saw the Achaeans domineering over the whole Peloponnesus. Never would he have another opportunity of recovering his rights, if he suffered the one that now offered to pass by. There was no Roman army in Greece, nor would the Romans deem Gythium, or the other towns on the coast of Laconia, sufficient cause for transporting their legions a second time into that country." These arguments were used for the purpose of provoking the passions of Nabis; in order that when Antiochus should come into Greece, the other, conscious of having infringed the treaty of amity with Rome, by injuries offered to its allies, might unite himself with him. Nicander excited Philip, by arguments somewhat similar; and he had more copious matter for discourse, as the king had been degraded from a more elevated state than the tyrant, and more possessions also had been taken from him. In addition to this, he introduced the ancient renown of the Macedonian kings, and the whole world pervaded by the victorious marches of that nation. "The plan which he proposed," he said, "was free from any danger, either in the commencement or in the issue. For he did not advise that Philip should stir until Antiochus should have come into Greece with an army; and, considering that, without the aid of Antiochus, he had maintained a war so long against the combined forces of the Romans and Aetolians, with what possible force could the Romans withstand him, when joined by Antiochus, and supported by the aid of the Aetolians, who, on the former occasion, were more dangerous enemies than the Romans?" He added the circumstance of Hannibal being general; "a man born a foe to the Romans, who had slain greater numbers, both of their commanders and soldiers, than were left surviving." Such were the representations of Nicander to Philip. Dicaearchus addressed other arguments to Antiochus. In the first place, he told him, that "the spoils of Philip belonged to the Romans, but the victory over him to the Aetolians; that none other than the Aetolians had afforded to the Romans admittance into Greece, and that the same people supplied them with the strength which enabled them to conquer." He next set forth the numerous forces, both horse and foot, which they were willing to furnish to Antiochus, for the purpose of the war; what quarters they would assign to his land armament, what harbours for his naval forces. He then asserted whatever falsehoods he pleased, respecting Philip and Nabis; that "both were ready to recommence hostilities, and would greedily lay hold on the first opportunity of recovering what they had lost in war." Thus did the Aetolians labour, in every part of the world, to stir up war against the Romans. The kings, however, either took no steps in it or took them too late.

But neither the Boians nor the Spaniards, with whom they had been at war that year, were as bitter and relentless enemies of the Romans as the Aetolians. After the Roman armies pulled out of Greece, the Aetolians, for a while, hoped that Antiochus would come and take control of Europe unopposed, and that neither Philip nor Nabis would stay quiet. But seeing no active efforts made anywhere, they decided to create some agitation and disturbance, fearing their plans might be stalled by delay. To this end, they called a general assembly at Naupactum. Here, Thoas, their praetor, complained about the Romans' disrespectful treatment and the current state of Aetolia. He claimed that "among all the nations and states of Greece, they had been the most dishonored after the victory they themselves had helped achieve," and proposed sending ambassadors to each of the kings. The purpose was not only to gauge their attitudes but also to encourage them, using incentives appropriate to each ruler, to go to war with Rome. Damocritus was sent to Nabis, Nicander to Philip, and Dicaearchus, the praetor's brother, to Antiochus. To the tyrant of Lacedaemon, Damocritus argued that, "with the coastal cities taken from him, his authority was weakened; he had relied on them for both soldiers and naval support. Now he was nearly trapped within the walls of his capital, watching the Achaeans dominate the entire Peloponnesus. He would never have another chance to reclaim his position if he let this opportunity slip away. There was no Roman army in Greece, nor would the Romans consider Gythium or the other towns on the Laconian coast a sufficient reason to send their legions back into the region." These points were aimed at provoking Nabis’s emotions, so that when Antiochus arrived in Greece, the latter, aware that he had violated the friendship treaty with Rome by harming its allies, might join forces with him. Nicander stirred up Philip with similar arguments, having more material to work with since Philip had been reduced from a higher status than the tyrant and had lost more territory. He also referenced the former glory of the Macedonian kings and how their victorious campaigns had spread across the world. "The plan I propose," he said, "is completely safe, both at the start and at the end. I do not suggest that Philip take action until Antiochus arrives in Greece with an army; and considering that Philip managed to sustain a war against the combined forces of the Romans and Aetolians, what strength could the Romans possibly muster to withstand him when he teamed up with Antiochus, supported by the Aetolians, who were previously far more dangerous foes than the Romans?" He added that Hannibal would be leading; "a man born an enemy of the Romans, who had killed more of their commanders and soldiers than were left surviving." Such were Nicander's arguments to Philip. Dicaearchus presented different arguments to Antiochus. First, he pointed out that "the spoils of Philip belonged to the Romans, but the victory over him belonged to the Aetolians; that it was the Aetolians who had allowed the Romans entry into Greece, and this same group had supplied the strength that made their conquest possible." He then outlined the numerous troops, both cavalry and infantry, they were ready to provide Antiochus for the war, what quarters they would assign for his land forces, and what harbors would be available for his naval forces. He proceeded to assert whatever lies suited him regarding Philip and Nabis; that "both were primed to start hostilities again and would jump at the first chance to reclaim what they had lost in battle." Thus, the Aetolians worked tirelessly all over the world to incite war against the Romans. However, the kings either took no action or acted too late.

13

Nabis immediately despatched emissaries through all the towns on the coast, to sow dissensions among the inhabitants: some of the men in power he brought over to his party by presents; others, who more firmly adhered to the alliance with Rome, he put to death. The charge of protecting all the Lacedaemonians on the coast, had been committed by Titus Quinctius to the Achaeans; they therefore instantly sent ambassadors to the tyrant, to remind him of his treaty with the Romans, and to warn him against violating a peace which he had so earnestly sued for. They also sent succours to Gythium which he had already besieged, and ambassadors to Rome to make known these transactions. King Antiochus having, this winter, solemnized the nuptials of his daughter with Ptolemy king of Egypt, at Raphia, in Phoenicia, returned thence to Antioch, and came, towards the end of the season, through Cilicia, after passing Mount Taurus, to the city of Ephesus. Early in the spring, he sent his son Antiochus thence into Syria, to guard the remote frontiers of his dominions, lest during his absence, any commotion might arise behind him; and then he marched himself, with all his land forces, to attack the Pisidians, inhabiting the country near Sida. At this time, Publius Sulpicius and Publius Villius, the Roman ambassadors, who were sent to Antiochus, as above mentioned, having received orders to wait on Eumenes, first came to Elaea, and thence went up to Pergamus, for the palace of Eumenes was there. Eumenes was very desirous of a war against Antiochus, for he thought that, if peace continued, a king so much superior in power would be a troublesome neighbour; but that, in case of hostilities, he would prove no more a match for the Romans than Philip had been; and that, either he would be entirely removed out of the way, or, should peace be granted to him, after a defeat he (Eumenes) might reasonably expect, that a great deal of what should be taken from Antiochus would fall to his own share; so that, in future, he might be very well able to defend himself against him, without any aid from the Romans; and even if any misfortune were to happen, it would be better for him, in conjunction with the Romans, to undergo any turn of fortune, than, standing alone, either suffer himself to be ruled by Antiochus, or, on refusal, be compelled to submission by force of arms. Therefore, with all his influence, and every argument which he could devise, he urged the Romans to a war.

Nabis quickly sent messengers to all the coastal towns to stir up conflict among the locals: he won over some powerful figures with gifts while executing others who remained loyal to Rome. Titus Quinctius had tasked the Achaeans with protecting all the Lacedaemonians on the coast, so they immediately sent ambassadors to the tyrant, reminding him of his treaty with the Romans and warning him against breaking the peace he had desperately sought. They also sent reinforcements to Gythium, which he was already besieging, and dispatched ambassadors to Rome to report these events. This winter, King Antiochus celebrated the marriage of his daughter to Ptolemy, the king of Egypt, at Raphia in Phoenicia, then returned to Antioch. Towards the end of the season, he traveled through Cilicia, after passing Mount Taurus, to the city of Ephesus. Early in the spring, he sent his son Antiochus to Syria to guard the distant borders of his kingdom in case any unrest arose while he was away, and then he marched with all his land forces to attack the Pisidians living near Sida. At this time, the Roman ambassadors Publius Sulpicius and Publius Villius, sent to Antiochus as mentioned earlier, received orders to meet with Eumenes. They first arrived at Elaea and then went up to Pergamus, where Eumenes' palace was located. Eumenes was very eager for a war against Antiochus, believing that if peace continued, a king so much stronger than him would be a troublesome neighbor. However, he thought that in the case of hostilities, Antiochus would be no more a threat to the Romans than Philip had been; and either he would be completely defeated or, if peace were eventually granted to him after a loss, Eumenes could expect a significant portion of what was taken from Antiochus to come to him. This way, he could better defend himself in the future without relying on Roman help. Even if he faced misfortune, he believed it would be better to endure any twist of fate alongside the Romans than to be ruled by Antiochus himself or be forced into submission through military aggression. Therefore, he used all his influence and every argument he could think of to push the Romans towards war.

14

Sulpicius, falling sick, staid at Pergamus. Villius, on hearing that the king was carrying on war in Pisidia, went on to Ephesus, and, during a few days that he halted in that city, took pains to procure frequent interviews with Hannibal, who happened to be there at the time, in order to sound his intentions, if possible, and to remove his apprehensions of danger threatening him from the Romans. No other business, indeed, of any kind was brought forward at these meetings; yet they accidentally produced an important consequence, as effectually as if it had been intentionally sought; the lowering Hannibal in the esteem of the king, and rendering him more obnoxious to suspicion in every matter. Claudius, following the history written in Greek by Acilius, says, that Publius Africanus was employed in this embassy, and that it was he who conversed with Hannibal at Ephesus. He even relates one of their conversations, in which Scipio asked Hannibal, "whom he thought the greatest captain?" and that he answered, "Alexander, king of Macedonia; because, with a small band, he defeated armies whose numbers were beyond reckoning; and because he had overrun the remotest regions, the merely visiting of which was a thing above human aspiration." Scipio then asked, "to whom he gave the second place?" and he replied, "To Pyrrhus; for he first taught the method of encamping; and besides, no one ever showed more exquisite judgment, in choosing his ground, and disposing his posts; while he also possessed the art of conciliating mankind to himself to such a degree, that the nations of Italy wished him, though a foreign prince, to hold the sovereignty among them, rather than the Roman people, who had so long possessed the dominion of that part of the world." On his proceeding to ask, "whom he esteemed the third?" Hannibal replied, "Myself, beyond doubt." On this Scipio laughed, and added, "What would you have said if you had conquered me?" "Then," replied the other, "I would have placed Hannibal, not only before Alexander and Pyrrhus, but before all other commanders." This answer, turned with Punic dexterity, and conveying an unexpected kind of flattery, was highly grateful to Scipio, as it set him apart from the crowd of commanders, as one of incomparable eminence.

Sulpicius fell sick and stayed in Pergamus. Villius, upon hearing that the king was waging war in Pisidia, continued on to Ephesus. During the few days he paused in that city, he made an effort to arrange frequent meetings with Hannibal, who happened to be there at the time, to gauge his intentions, if possible, and to ease his fears about the danger posed by the Romans. No other matters were discussed at these meetings; however, they inadvertently led to a significant outcome, affecting Hannibal’s reputation in the eyes of the king and increasing suspicions towards him. Claudius, following the account written in Greek by Acilius, states that Publius Africanus was assigned to this mission and was the one who spoke with Hannibal in Ephesus. He even recounts one of their conversations, in which Scipio asked Hannibal, "Who do you think is the greatest general?" to which he replied, "Alexander, king of Macedonia; because, with a small force, he defeated armies that were countless, and because he conquered the farthest regions, the mere visitation of which was beyond human striving." Scipio then asked, "Who would you consider in second place?" and Hannibal answered, "Pyrrhus; because he was the first to teach the art of encamping, and no one has ever shown better judgment in selecting their ground and organizing their positions; he also had the skill to win people over to his side to such an extent that the nations of Italy preferred him, though he was a foreign king, to rule over them rather than the Roman people, who had long held dominion in that part of the world." When Scipio asked, "Whom do you consider third?" Hannibal replied, "Myself, without a doubt." Scipio laughed and added, "What would you have said if you had defeated me?" "Then," Hannibal responded, "I would have placed myself ahead of not only Alexander and Pyrrhus but all other commanders." This reply, delivered with cleverness and unexpected flattery, greatly pleased Scipio, as it distinguished him from the ranks of commanders, placing him in a category of unmatched excellence.

15

From Ephesus, Villius proceeded to Apamea, whither Antiochus, on hearing of the coming of the Roman delegates, came to meet him. In this congress, at Apamea, the debates were similar to those which passed at Rome, between Quinctius and the king's ambassadors. The news arriving of the death of Antiochus, the king's son, who, as just now mentioned, had been sent into Syria, broke off the conference. There was great mourning in the court, and excessive regret for this young man; for he had given such indications of his character as afforded evident proof that, had a longer life been allotted him, he would have displayed the talents of a great and just prince. The more he was beloved and esteemed by all, the more was his death a subject of suspicion, namely, that his father, thinking that his heir trod too closely on the heels of his own old age, had him taken off by poison, by some eunuchs, who recommend themselves to kings by the perpetration of such foul deeds. People mentioned also, as another motive for that clandestine act of villany, that, as he had given Lysimachia to his son Seleucus, he had no establishment of the like kind, which he could give to Antiochus, for the purpose of banishing him also to a distance, under pretext of doing him honour. Nevertheless, an appearance of deep mourning was maintained in the court for several days; and the Roman ambassador, lest his presence at that inauspicious time might be troublesome, retired to Pergamus. The king, dropping the prosecution of the war which he had begun, went back to Ephesus; and there, keeping himself shut up in the palace, under colour of grief, held secret consultations with a person called Minio, who was his principal favourite. Minio was utterly ignorant of the state of all foreign nations; and, accordingly, estimating the strength of the king from his successes in Syria or Asia, he was confident that Antiochus had not only superiority from the merits of his cause, and that the demands of the Romans were highly unreasonable; but also, that he would prove the more powerful in war. As the king wished to avoid further debate with the envoys, either because he had found no advantage to result from the former conference, or because he was too much discomposed by recent grief, Minio undertook to say whatever was requisite for his interest, and persuaded him to invite for that purpose the ambassadors from Pergamus.

From Ephesus, Villius moved on to Apamea, where Antiochus, upon hearing that the Roman delegates were coming, went to meet him. In this meeting at Apamea, the discussions resembled those that took place in Rome between Quinctius and the king's ambassadors. News arrived of the death of Antiochus's son, who, as mentioned earlier, had been sent to Syria, interrupting the conference. There was deep mourning at the court and great sorrow for this young man; he had shown such promise that it was evident he would have become a great and just ruler if he had lived longer. The more he was loved and respected by everyone, the more suspicious his death became, with whispers that his father, fearing his heir was getting too close to his own old age, had him poisoned by some eunuchs who ingratiate themselves with kings through such vile acts. People also speculated that another motive for this secret sin was that, since he had given Lysimachia to his son Seleucus, he had nothing similar to offer Antiochus to send him away under the guise of honoring him. Nevertheless, a facade of deep mourning was kept at the court for several days, and the Roman ambassador, worried that his presence during this unfortunate time might be unwelcome, withdrew to Pergamus. The king, abandoning the war he had started, returned to Ephesus; there, while pretending to grieve, he held private meetings with a man named Minio, who was his favorite. Minio was completely unaware of the status of foreign nations, so he misjudged the king’s strength based on his victories in Syria or Asia, believing Antiochus was not only right in his cause but that the Roman demands were highly unreasonable and that he would be stronger in battle. Since the king wanted to avoid further discussions with the envoys—either because he saw no benefit from the previous meeting or because he was too shaken by his recent loss—Minio offered to handle whatever was necessary for the king's interests and convinced him to invite the ambassadors from Pergamus for that purpose.

16

By this time Sulpicius had recovered his health; both himself and Villius, therefore, came to Ephesus. Minio apologized for the king not being present, and the business was entered upon. Then Minio, in a studied speech, said, "I find, Romans, that you profess very specious intentions, (the liberating of the Grecian states,) but your actions do not accord with your words. You lay down one rule for Antiochus, and follow another yourselves. For, how are the inhabitants of Smyrna and Lampsacus better entitled to the character of Greeks, than the Neapolitans, Rhegians, and Tarentines, from whom you exact tribute, and ships, in pursuance of a treaty? Why do you send yearly to Syracuse, and other Grecian cities of Sicily, a praetor, vested with sovereign power, and attended by his rods and axes? You can, certainly, allege no other reason than this, that, having conquered them in war, you imposed these terms on them. Admit, then, on the part of Antiochus, the same reason with respect to Smyrna and Lampsacus, and the cities belonging to Ionia and Aeolia. Conquered by his ancestors, they were subjected to tribute and taxes, and he only reclaims an ancient right. I would have you answer him on these heads, if you mean a fair discussion, and do not merely seek a pretence for war." Sulpicius answered, "Antiochus has acted with some modesty in choosing that, since no other arguments could be produced in his favour, any other person should utter these rather than himself. For, what similarity is there in the cases of those states which you have brought into comparison? From the Rhegians, Neapolitans, and Tarentines we require what they owe us by treaty, in virtue of a right invariably exercised, in one uniform course, since they first came under our power; a right always asserted, and never intermitted. Now, can you assert, that, as these states have, neither of themselves, nor through any other, ever refused conforming to the treaty, so the Asiatic states, since they once came under the power of Antiochus's ancestors, have been held in uninterrupted possession by your reigning kings; and that some of them have not been subject to the dominion of Philip, some to that of Ptolemy; and that others have not, for many years, maintained themselves in a state of independence, no one calling it in question? For, if the circumstance of their having been once subject to a foreigner, when crushed under the severity of the times, conveys a right to enforce that subjection again after a lapse of so many generations, what can be said of our having delivered Greece from Philip, but that nothing was accomplished by us; and that his successors may reclaim Corinth, Chalcis, Demetrias, and the whole nation of Thessaly? But why do I plead the cause of those states, which it would be fitter that both we and the king should hear pleaded by themselves?"

By this time, Sulpicius had regained his health, so both he and Villius came to Ephesus. Minio apologized for the king's absence, and they got down to business. Then Minio, in a carefully prepared speech, said, "I find, Romans, that you claim to have noble intentions (liberating the Greek states), but your actions don't match your words. You set one standard for Antiochus and follow another for yourselves. How are the people of Smyrna and Lampsacus more deserving of the title of Greeks than the Neapolitans, Rhegians, and Tarentines, from whom you demand tribute and ships as part of a treaty? Why do you send a praetor to Syracuse and other Greek cities in Sicily every year, one with sovereign powers, accompanied by his rods and axes? You can only argue that, having defeated them in war, you imposed these terms on them. Therefore, let Antiochus have the same rationale regarding Smyrna and Lampsacus, and the cities of Ionia and Aeolia. Conquered by his ancestors, they were subjected to tribute and taxes, and he is simply reclaiming an ancient right. I would like you to respond to him on these points if you’re genuinely interested in a fair discussion, and not just looking for an excuse for war." Sulpicius replied, "Antiochus has shown some humility in letting someone else make this argument, since no other justifications could be found in his favor. What similarities can you find in the cases of the states you've compared? From the Rhegians, Neapolitans, and Tarentines, we demand what they owe us by treaty, a right that has always been exercised consistently since they first came under our control; a right that has been continuously maintained. Now, can you claim that, just as these states have never refused to adhere to the treaty, the Asian states have remained under the continuous control of your reigning kings since they fell under Antiochus's ancestors? Haven’t some been subject to Philip's rule, others to Ptolemy's, and haven’t other states maintained their independence for many years without anyone challenging that? If the fact that they were once ruled by a foreign power, during a difficult period, gives you the right to enforce that rule again after so many generations, what does that say about our effort in freeing Greece from Philip, except that we accomplished nothing, and his successors might as well reclaim Corinth, Chalcis, Demetrias, and the whole region of Thessaly? But why am I defending the cause of those states, which should rather be presented by them before both us and the king?"

17

He then desired, that the deputies of those states should be called, for they had been prepared beforehand, and kept in readiness by Eumenes, who reckoned, that every share of strength that should be taken away from Antiochus, would become an accession to his own kingdom. Many of them were introduced; and, while each enforced his own complaints, and sometimes demands, and blended together the reasonable with the unreasonable, they changed the debate into a mere altercation. The ambassadors, therefore, without conceding or carrying any one point, returned to Rome just as they had come, leaving every thing in an undecided state. On their departure the king held a council, on the subject of a war with Rome, in which each spoke more violently than his predecessor; for every one thought, that the more bitterly he inveighed against the Romans, the greater share of favour he might expect to obtain. One animadverted upon the insolence of their demands, in which they presume to impose terms on Antiochus, the greatest king in Asia, as they would on the vanquished Nabis. "Although to Nabis they left absolute power over his own country, and its capital, Lacedaemon, yet it seems to them a matter for indignation, that Smyrna and Lampsacus should yield obedience to Antiochus."--Others said, that "to so great a monarch, those cities were but a trivial ground of war, scarcely worth mention; but, that the beginning of unjust impositions was always made in the case of matters of little consequence; unless, indeed, it could be supposed, that the Persians, when they demanded earth and water from the Lacedaemonians, stood in need of a scrap of the land or a draught of the water. The proceedings of the Romans, respecting the two cities, were meant as a trial of the same sort. The rest of the states, when they saw that two had shaken off the yoke, would go over to the party of that nation which professed the patronage of liberty. If freedom was not actually preferable to servitude, yet the hope of bettering their circumstances by a change, was more flattering to every one than any present situation."

He then requested that the representatives of those states be called in, as Eumenes had prepared them in advance and kept them ready. He believed that any strength taken away from Antiochus would only add to his own power. Many of the representatives came forward, and while each voiced their own grievances and sometimes demands, mixing reasonable points with unreasonable ones, the discussion turned into a mere argument. As a result, the ambassadors returned to Rome without conceding or achieving any agreement, leaving everything unresolved. After their departure, the king held a council to discuss a war with Rome, where each speaker was more aggressive than the last. Everyone felt that the more harshly they criticized the Romans, the more favor they would gain. One individual criticized the arrogance of their demands, asserting they were trying to impose terms on Antiochus, the greatest king in Asia, just as they would on the defeated Nabis. "Even though they left Nabis in complete control of his own country and its capital, Lacedaemon, they seem outraged that Smyrna and Lampsacus are under Antiochus's authority." Others argued that "for such a mighty monarch, those cities were trivial grounds for war, hardly worth mentioning; however, unjust demands often start with trivial matters. Unless it can be assumed that the Persians truly needed a piece of land or a drink of water when they asked the Lacedaemonians for earth and water. The Romans' actions regarding the two cities were a similar test. The other states would follow the example of those that had thrown off the yoke, aligning themselves with the nation that claimed to champion liberty. Even if freedom wasn't necessarily better than servitude, the hope of improving their situation through change was more appealing to everyone than their current state."

18

There was, in the council, an Acarnanian named Alexander, who had formerly been a friend of Philip, but had lately left him, to follow the more opulent court of Antiochus. And as being well skilled in the affairs of Greece, and not unacquainted with the Romans, he was admitted by the king into such a degree of intimacy, that he shared even in his secret councils. As if the question to be considered were not, whether there should be war or not, but where and in what manner it should be carried on, he affirmed, that "he saw an assured prospect of victory, provided the king would pass into Europe and choose some part of Greece for the seat of war. In the first place, the Aetolians, who lived in the centre of Greece, would be found in arms, ready to take the lead in the most perilous operations. Then, in the two extremities of Greece, Nabis, on the side of Peloponnesus, would put every thing in motion, to recover the city of Argos, and the maritime cities, from which he had been expelled by the Romans, and pent up within the walls of Lacedaemon: while, on the side of Macedonia, Philip would be ready for the field the moment he heard the alarm sounded. He knew," he said, "his spirit, he knew his temper; he knew that, (as in the case with wild beasts, confined by bars or chains,) for a long time past, he had been revolving the fiercest resentments in his breast. He remembered, also, how often, during the war, that prince had prayed to all the gods to grant him Antiochus as an assistant; and, if that prayer were now heard with favour, he would not hesitate an instant to resume his arms. It was only requisite that there should be no delay, no procrastination; for success depended chiefly on securing beforehand commodious posts and proper allies: besides, Hannibal ought to be sent immediately into Africa, in order to distract the attention of the Romans."

There was a guy named Alexander from Acarnania in the council. He had been friends with Philip, but recently switched over to the richer court of Antiochus. Since he was skilled in Greek affairs and knew a thing or two about the Romans, the king let him into his inner circle, even confiding in him during secret meetings. It seemed the real question wasn’t whether there should be a war, but where and how it should happen. He stated that "he saw a clear path to victory, as long as the king moved into Europe and picked a spot in Greece for the war. First, the Aetolians, who were in the heart of Greece, would be ready to fight and take the lead in the toughest missions. Then, on one end of Greece, Nabis would stir things up in Peloponnesus to try to get back the city of Argos and the coastal towns from which the Romans had driven him, leaving him trapped in Lacedaemon. Meanwhile, on the other side in Macedonia, Philip would be ready to jump into action as soon as he heard the alarm. He knew Philip's spirit and temper; he understood that, much like wild animals locked away, Philip had been nursing fierce anger for quite a while. He also recalled how often, during the war, Philip had prayed to all the gods for Antiochus's support; and if that wish were granted now, he would not hesitate to pick up arms again. It was crucial to avoid any delay or procrastination since success heavily relied on securing favorable positions and the right allies in advance. Plus, Hannibal should be sent to Africa right away to divert the Romans' attention."

19

Hannibal was not called to this consultation, having income suspected by the king, and not having subsequently been held in any honour, on account of his conferences with Villius, and he had not since shown him any mark of regard. This affront, at first, he bore in silence; but afterwards thought it better to take some proper opportunity to inquire the reason of the king's suddenly withdrawing his favour, and to clear himself of blame. Without any preface, he asked the cause of the king's displeasure; and having heard it, said, "Antiochus, when I was yet an infant, my father, Hamilcar, at a time when he was offering sacrifice, brought me up to the altars, and made me take an oath, that I never would be a friend to the Roman people. Under the obligation of this oath, I carried arms against them for thirty-six years; this oath, on peace being made, drove me out of my country, and brought me an exile to your court; and this oath shall guide me, should you disappoint my hopes, until I traverse every quarter of the globe, where I can understand that there are resources, to find out enemies to the Romans. If, therefore, your courtiers have conceived the idea of ingratiating themselves with you by insinuating suspicions of me, let them seek some means of advancing their reputation otherwise than at my expense. I hate, and am hated by, the Romans. That I speak the truth in this, my father, Hamilcar, and the gods are witnesses. Whenever, therefore, you shall employ your thoughts on a plan of waging war with Rome, consider Hannibal as one of your firmest friends. If circumstances force you to adopt peaceful measures, on such a subject employ some one else with whom to deliberate." This discourse not only affected the king much, but even reconciled him to Hannibal. They departed from the council with the resolution that the war should be undertaken.

Hannibal wasn't invited to this meeting because the king had suspicions about him, and he wasn't held in high regard due to his talks with Villius. Since then, he hadn't shown Villius any signs of respect. At first, he accepted this slight without complaint, but later he decided it was better to find a chance to ask why the king had suddenly withdrawn his favor and to clear his name. Without any introduction, he directly asked what had caused the king's anger. After hearing the answer, he said, "Antiochus, when I was just a child, my father, Hamilcar, brought me to the altars while making a sacrifice and made me swear that I would never ally with the Roman people. Bound by this oath, I fought against them for thirty-six years; it was this oath that led to my exile when peace was made and brought me to your court. That same oath will drive me, should you let me down, to explore every corner of the world where I might find resources to help me locate enemies of the Romans. So, if your advisors think they can win your favor by spreading doubts about me, they should look for ways to boost their reputations without putting me down. I detest the Romans, and they despise me in return. My father, Hamilcar, and the gods can vouch for my honesty in this matter. So, whenever you think about going to war with Rome, regard Hannibal as one of your strongest allies. If circumstances force you to seek a peaceful approach, consult someone else for advice on that topic." This speech not only impacted the king greatly but also reconciled him with Hannibal. They left the council resolved to go to war.

20

At Rome, people in their conversations anticipated, indeed, Antiochus as an enemy, but they had hitherto prepared nothing for such a war but their expectations. Italy was decreed the province of both the consuls, who received directions to settle between themselves, or draw lots, which of them should preside at the elections of the year; and it was ordered, that he who should be disengaged from that business, should hold himself in readiness, in case there should be occasion, to lead the legions any where out of that country. To the said consul, permission was given to levy two new legions, and twenty thousand foot, and nine hundred horse, among the allies and Latin confederates. To the other consul were decreed the two legions which had been commanded by Lucius Cornelius, consul of the preceding year; and from the same army, a body of allies and Latins, amounting to fifteen thousand foot and five hundred horse. Quintus Minucius was continued in command, with the forces which he then had in Liguria; as a supplement to which, four thousand Roman foot and five hundred horse were ordered to be enlisted, and five thousand foot and two hundred and fifty horse to be demanded from the allies. The duty of departing from Italy, whithersoever the senate should order, fell to Cneius Domitius; Gaul, and the holding the elections, to Lucius Quinctius. The praetors then cast lots for their provinces: to Marcus Fulvius Centumalus fell the city jurisdiction; to Lucius Scribonius Libo, the foreign; Lucius Valerius Tappus obtained Sicily; Quintus Salonius Sarra, Sardinia; Marcus Baebius Tamphilus, Hither Spain; and Marcus Atilius Serranus, Farther Spain. But the provinces of the two last were changed, first by a decree of the senate, which was afterwards confirmed by an order of the people. The fleet and Macedonia were assigned to Atilius; Bruttium to Baebius. Flaminius and Fulvius were continued in command in both the Hither and Farther Spain. To Baebius Tamphilus, for the business of Bruttium, were decreed the two legions which had served in the city the year before; and he was ordered to demand from the allies, for the same service, fifteen thousand foot and five hundred horse. Atilius was ordered to build thirty ships of five banks of oars: to bring out, from the docks, any old ones that were fit for service, and to raise seamen. An order was also given to the consul, to supply him with two thousand of the allied and Latin footmen, and a thousand Roman. The destination of these two praetors, and their two armaments, one on land and the other on sea, was declared to be intended against Nabis, who was now carrying on open hostilities against the allies of the Roman people. But it was thought proper to wait the return of the ambassadors sent to Antiochus, and the senate ordered the consul Cneius Domitius not to leave the city until they arrived.

In Rome, people were talking as if Antiochus would be an enemy, but so far, they hadn't made any real preparations for war other than their expectations. Italy was assigned as the province for both consuls, who were told to decide between themselves or draw lots to see who would oversee the elections for the year. It was also decided that whichever consul wasn't involved in the elections should be ready to lead the legions out of the country if needed. One of the consuls was given permission to recruit two new legions, along with 20,000 infantry and 900 cavalry from the allies and Latin confederates. The other consul was assigned the two legions previously commanded by Lucius Cornelius, the consul from the previous year, along with a group of allies and Latins totaling 15,000 infantry and 500 cavalry. Quintus Minucius remained in command of the forces he had in Liguria, and in addition to that, 4,000 Roman infantry and 500 cavalry were ordered to be recruited, along with 5,000 infantry and 250 cavalry from the allies. Cneius Domitius was tasked with leaving Italy wherever the senate commanded, while Lucius Quinctius was responsible for Gaul and overseeing the elections. The praetors then drew lots for their provinces: Marcus Fulvius Centumalus received the city jurisdiction; Lucius Scribonius Libo got the foreign; Lucius Valerius Tappus was assigned Sicily; Quintus Salonius Sarra received Sardinia; Marcus Baebius Tamphilus got Hither Spain; and Marcus Atilius Serranus received Farther Spain. However, the provinces of the last two were later changed by a senate decree, which was then confirmed by a popular vote. Atilius was assigned the fleet and Macedonia, while Baebius got Bruttium. Flaminius and Fulvius continued in command over both Hither and Farther Spain. For the task in Bruttium, Baebius Tamphilus was given the two legions that had served in the city the previous year and was ordered to request 15,000 infantry and 500 cavalry from the allies for the same purpose. Atilius was instructed to build 30 five-oared ships, to bring out any old ships that were fit for service, and to recruit sailors. The consul was also ordered to provide Atilius with 2,000 allied and Latin infantry and 1,000 Roman troops. The intention behind the assignments of these two praetors and their two forces, one on land and one at sea, was to act against Nabis, who was currently waging war against the allies of the Roman people. However, it was deemed necessary to wait for the return of the ambassadors sent to Antiochus, and the senate instructed consul Cneius Domitius not to leave the city until they arrived.

21

The praetors, Fulvius and Scribonius, whose province was the administration of justice at Rome, were charged to provide a hundred quinqueremes, besides the fleet which Atilius was to command. Before the consul and praetors set out for their provinces, a supplication was performed on account of some prodigies. A report was brought from Picenum, that a goat had produced six kids at a birth. It was said that a boy was born at Arretium who had but one hand; that, at Amiternum, a shower of earth fell; a gate and wall at Formiae were struck by lightning; and, what was more alarming than all, an ox, belonging to the consul, Cneius Domitius, spoke these words,--"Rome, take care of thyself." To expiate the other prodigies, a supplication was performed; the ox was ordered by the aruspices to be carefully preserved and fed. The Tiber, pouring into the city with more destructive violence than last year, swept away two bridges, and many buildings, particularly about the Flumentan gate. A huge rock, loosened from its seat, either by the rains, or by an earthquake so slight that no other effect of it was perceived, tumbled down from the Capitol into the Jugarian street, and buried many people under it. In the country, many parts of which were overflowed, much cattle was carried away, and a great destruction of farm houses took place. Previous to the arrival of the consul, Lucius Quinctius, in his province Quintus Minucius fought a pitched battle with the Ligurians, in the territory of Pisae, slew nine thousand of the enemy, and putting the rest to flight, drove them within their works, which were assaulted and defended in an obstinate contest until night came on. During the night, the Ligurians stole away unobserved; and, at the first dawn, the Romans took possession of their deserted camp, where the quantity of booty found was the less, because the enemy frequently sent home the spoil taken in the country. Minucius, after this, allowed them no respite. From the territory of Pisae he marched into that of the Ligurians, and, with fire and sword, utterly destroyed their forts and towns, where the Roman soldiers were abundantly enriched with the spoils of Etruria which the ravagers had sent home.

The praetors, Fulvius and Scribonius, who were responsible for administering justice in Rome, were tasked with providing a hundred quinqueremes, in addition to the fleet that Atilius would command. Before the consul and praetors left for their provinces, a special ceremony was held due to some strange events. A report came from Picenum that a goat had given birth to six kids at once. It was said that a boy was born in Arretium with only one hand; in Amiternum, there was a shower of dirt; a gate and a wall in Formiae were struck by lightning; and, most alarmingly, an ox belonging to the consul, Cneius Domitius, spoke these words: "Rome, take care of yourself." To atone for the other strange occurrences, a special ceremony was held, and the ox was instructed by the seers to be carefully preserved and fed. The Tiber River flooded the city more violently than the previous year, sweeping away two bridges and many buildings, especially around the Flumentan gate. A massive rock, loosened from its place either by the rain or a minor earthquake that went unnoticed otherwise, fell from the Capitol into the Jugarian street, burying several people. In the countryside, where many areas were flooded, a lot of livestock was lost, and numerous farmhouses were destroyed. Before the consul, Lucius Quinctius, arrived in his province, Quintus Minucius fought a major battle against the Ligurians in the territory of Pisae, killing nine thousand enemy fighters and forcing the rest to retreat within their fortifications, which were fiercely attacked and defended until nightfall. During the night, the Ligurians managed to escape unnoticed, and at dawn, the Romans took over their abandoned camp, where they found less booty because the enemy frequently sent the plunder back home. After this, Minucius did not give them a break. From the territory of Pisae, he marched into the Ligurians' territory and completely destroyed their forts and towns with fire and sword, where the Roman soldiers became very wealthy with the spoils from Etruria that the raiders had sent back.

22

About this time, the ambassadors, who had been sent to the kings, returned to Rome. As they brought no information of such a nature as called for any immediate declaration of war, (except against the Lacedaemonian tyrant, whom the Achaean ambassadors also represented as invading the sea-coast of Laconia, in breach of treaty,) Atilius, the praetor, was sent with the fleet to Greece, for the protection of the allies. It was resolved, that, as there was nothing to be apprehended from Antiochus at present, both the consuls should go to their provinces; and, accordingly, Domitius marched into the country of the Boians, by the shorter road, through Ariminum, and Quinctius through Liguria. The two armies of the consuls, proceeding by these different routes, spread devastation wide over the enemy's country. In consequence of which, first a few of their horsemen, with their commanders, then their whole senate, and at last all who possessed either property or dignity, to the number of one thousand five hundred, came over and joined the consuls. In both Spains, likewise, success attended the Roman arms during this year. For, in one, Caius Flaminius, after a siege, took Litabrum, a strong and opulent city, and made prisoner Corribilo, a powerful chieftain; and, in the other, Marcus Fulvius, the proconsul, fought two successful battles, with two armies of the enemy. He captured Vescelia and Holo, two towns belonging to the Spaniards, with many of their forts, and others spontaneously revolted to him. Then, advancing into the territory of Oretum, and having, there also, taken two cities, Noliba and Cusibis, he proceeded to the river Tagus. Here stood Toletum, a small city, but strong from its situation. While he was besieging this place, a numerous army of Vectonians came to relieve the Toletans, but he overthrew them in a general engagement, and having defeated the Vectonians, took Toletum by means of his works.

At this time, the ambassadors who had been sent to the kings returned to Rome. Since they didn’t bring any information that warranted an immediate declaration of war (except against the Lacedaemonian tyrant, whom the Achaean ambassadors also said was invading the coast of Laconia, breaking the treaty), Atilius, the praetor, was sent with the fleet to Greece to protect the allies. It was decided that, as there was nothing to fear from Antiochus at the moment, both consuls would go to their provinces. Domitius took the shorter route through Ariminum into the land of the Boians, while Quinctius went through Liguria. As the two armies of the consuls moved along these different paths, they caused widespread destruction in the enemy's territory. As a result, first a few of their horsemen, along with their commanders, then their entire senate, and finally everyone with property or rank—around one thousand five hundred in total—defected and joined the consuls. In both Spains, the Roman forces also had success this year. In one, Caius Flaminius captured Litabrum, a strong and wealthy city, after a siege and took prisoner Corribilo, a powerful chief. In the other, Marcus Fulvius, the proconsul, won two battles against two enemy armies. He took Vescelia and Holo, two towns belonging to the Spaniards, along with many of their forts, and others surrendered to him. Then, advancing into the territory of Oretum and capturing two more cities, Noliba and Cusibis, he made his way to the river Tagus. Here stood Toletum, a small but strategically strong city. While he was besieging it, a large army of Vectonians came to support the Toletans, but he defeated them in a major battle, and after defeating the Vectonians, he took Toletum using his siege works.

23

At this juncture the wars in which they were actually engaged, caused not so great anxiety in the minds of the senate, as the expectation of one with Antiochus, which had not yet commenced. For although, through their ambassadors, they had, from time to time, made careful inquiries into every particular, yet rumours, rashly propagated without authentic foundation, intermixed many falsehoods with the truth. Among the rest, a report was spread, that Antiochus intended, as soon as he should come into Aetolia, to send a fleet immediately into Sicily. The senate, therefore, though they had already despatched the praetor, Atilius, with a squadron to Greece, yet, considering that not only a military force, but also the influence of reputation, would be necessary towards securing the attachment of the allies, they sent into Greece, in quality of ambassadors, Titus Quinctius, Caius Octavius, Cneius Servilius, and Publius Villius; at the same time ordering, in their decree, that Marcus Baebius should lead forward his legions from Bruttium to Tarentum and Brundusium, so that, if occasion required, he might transport them thence into Macedonia. They also ordered, that Marcus Fulvius, the praetor, should send a fleet of thirty ships to protect the coast of Sicily; and that, whoever had the direction of that fleet, should be invested with supreme authority. To this commission was appointed Lucius Oppius Salinator, who had been plebeian aedile the year before. They likewise determined, that the same praetor should write to his colleague, Lucius Valerius, that "there was reason to apprehend that the ships of king Antiochus would pass over from Aetolia to Sicily; for which reason the senate judged it proper, that, in addition to the army which he then had, he should enlist tumultuary soldiers, to the number of twelve thousand foot and four hundred horse, with which he might be able to defend that coast of his province which lay next to Greece." This enlistment the praetor carried on, not only from Sicily, but from the circumjacent islands; and strengthened all the towns on the coast which lay opposite to Greece with garrisons. To the rumours already current, the arrival of Attalus, the brother of Eumenes, added confirmation, for he brought intelligence that king Antiochus had crossed the Hellespont with his army, and that the Aetolians were putting themselves into such a posture, that by the time of his arrival they would be in arms. Thanks were given to Eumenes, in his absence, and to Attalus, who was present; and there were decreed to him free lodgings and every accommodation; that he should be presented with two horses, two suits of horsemen's armour, vases of silver to a hundred pounds' weight, and of gold to twenty pounds.

At this point, the wars they were actually involved in caused less worry for the senate than the anticipated conflict with Antiochus, which hadn’t started yet. Even though they had sent ambassadors to gather detailed information, rumors, often spread without any solid proof, mixed many lies with the facts. One of the rumors claimed that Antiochus planned to send a fleet to Sicily as soon as he arrived in Aetolia. Therefore, even though they had already sent the praetor, Atilius, with a squadron to Greece, the senate decided that they needed not just military strength but also the power of reputation to ensure the loyalty of their allies. So they dispatched ambassadors Titus Quinctius, Caius Octavius, Cneius Servilius, and Publius Villius to Greece, while also instructing Marcus Baebius to lead his legions from Bruttium to Tarentum and Brundusium, so he could transport them to Macedonia if needed. They also ordered Marcus Fulvius, the praetor, to send a fleet of thirty ships to protect the coast of Sicily, and whoever commanded that fleet would have full authority. Lucius Oppius Salinator, who had been a plebeian aedile the previous year, was appointed to this task. They also decided that the praetor should write to his colleague, Lucius Valerius, warning him that there was reason to believe that Antiochus's ships would move from Aetolia to Sicily; for this reason, the senate thought it was necessary for him to recruit additional soldiers, numbering twelve thousand foot and four hundred horse, to defend the part of his province that bordered Greece. The praetor carried out this recruitment not just from Sicily but also from nearby islands and fortified all the towns on the coast facing Greece with garrisons. The already circulating rumors were bolstered by the arrival of Attalus, the brother of Eumenes, who brought news that King Antiochus had crossed the Hellespont with his army and that the Aetolians were preparing for arms by the time of his arrival. Thanks were given to Eumenes in his absence and to Attalus, who was present; he was granted free accommodations and other comforts, including two horses, two sets of horseman’s armor, silver vases weighing a hundred pounds, and gold vases weighing twenty pounds.

24

As one messenger after another brought intelligence that the war was on the point of breaking out, it was judged expedient that consuls should be elected as soon as possible. Wherefore the senate passed a decree, that the praetor, Marcus Fulvius, should instantly despatch a letter to the consul, informing him, that it was the will of the senate that he should leave the command of the province and army to his lieutenant-generals, and return to Rome; and that, when on the road, he should send on before him an edict appointing the assemblies for the election of consuls. The consul complied with the letter; and having sent forward the edict, arrived at Rome. There was, this year also, a warm competition, three patricians suing for one place: Publius Cornelius Scipio, son to Cneius, who had suffered a disappointment the year before, Lucius Cornelius Scipio, and Cneius Manlius Vulso. The consulship was conferred on Publius Scipio, that it might appear that the honour had only been delayed, and not refused to a person of such character. The plebeian colleague, joined with him, was Manius Acilius Glabrio. Next day were created praetors, Lucius Aemilius Paulus, Marcus Aemilius Lepidus, Marcus Junius Brutus, Aulus Cornelius Mammula, Caius Livius, and Lucius Oppius; the two last, both of them, surnamed Salinator. This was the same Oppius who had conducted the fleet of thirty ships to Sicily. While the new magistrates were settling the distribution of their provinces, orders were despatched to Marcus Baebius to pass over, with all his forces, from Brundusium to Epirus, and to keep the army stationed near Apollonia; and Marcus Fulvius, city praetor, was commissioned to build fifty new quinqueremes.

As one messenger after another reported that the war was about to break out, it was decided that consuls should be elected as soon as possible. Therefore, the senate passed a decree that the praetor, Marcus Fulvius, should immediately send a letter to the consul, informing him that the senate wanted him to hand over command of the province and army to his lieutenant-generals and return to Rome. Moreover, while on the way, he should send ahead an edict scheduling the assemblies for the consul elections. The consul followed the letter's instructions, sent out the edict, and arrived in Rome. This year also saw a fierce competition, with three patricians vying for one position: Publius Cornelius Scipio, son of Cneius, who had faced disappointment the previous year, Lucius Cornelius Scipio, and Cneius Manlius Vulso. The consulship was awarded to Publius Scipio to show that the honor had only been postponed and not denied to someone of his caliber. His plebeian colleague was Manius Acilius Glabrio. The next day, praetors were appointed: Lucius Aemilius Paulus, Marcus Aemilius Lepidus, Marcus Junius Brutus, Aulus Cornelius Mammula, Caius Livius, and Lucius Oppius; the last two were both nicknamed Salinator. This was the same Oppius who had led a fleet of thirty ships to Sicily. While the new magistrates were organizing their provinces, orders were sent to Marcus Baebius to transfer all his forces from Brundusium to Epirus and station the army near Apollonia. Additionally, Marcus Fulvius, the city praetor, was tasked with building fifty new quinqueremes.

25

Such were the precautions taken by the Roman people to guard against every attempt of Antiochus. At this time, Nabis did not procrastinate hostilities, but, with his utmost force, carried on the siege of Gythium; and, being incensed against the Achaeans, for having sent succours to the besieged, he ravaged their lands. The Achaeans would not venture to engage in war, until their ambassadors should come back from Rome, and acquaint them with the sentiments of the senate: but as soon as these returned, they summoned a council at Sicyon, and also sent deputies to Titus Quinctius to ask his advice. In the council, all the members were inclined to vote for an immediate declaration of war; but a letter from Titus Quinctius, in which he recommended waiting for the Roman praetor and fleet, caused some hesitation. While some of the principal members persisted in their first opinion, and others argued that they ought to follow the counsel of the person to whom they of themselves had applied for advice, the generality waited to hear the sentiments of Philopoemen. He was praetor of Achaia at the time, and surpassed all his contemporaries both in wisdom and influence. He first observed, that "it was a wise rule, established among the Achaeans, that their praetor, when he proposed a question concerning war, should not himself declare an opinion:" and then he desired them to "fix their determination among themselves as soon as possible;" assuring them, that "their praetor would faithfully and carefully carry their decrees into execution; and would use his best endeavours, that, as far as depended on human prudence, they should not repent either of peace or war." These words had more influence in inciting them to war, than if, by openly arguing in favour of it, he had betrayed an eager desire for the management of it. War was therefore unanimously resolved on: the time and mode of conducting it were left to the praetor without restriction. Philopoemen's own judgment, indeed, besides it being the opinion of Quinctius, pointed it out as best to wait for the Roman fleet, which might succour Gythium by sea; but fearing that the business would not endure delay, and that not only Gythium, but the party which had been sent to protect the city, would fall into the hands of the enemy, he drew out the ships of the Achaeans.

Such were the precautions taken by the Roman people to guard against every attempt of Antiochus. At this time, Nabis didn’t delay in starting hostilities; instead, he put all his forces into the siege of Gythium and, angered at the Achaeans for sending aid to those under siege, he devastated their lands. The Achaeans were reluctant to enter into war until their ambassadors returned from Rome with news of the senate's opinion. However, once they came back, they called a council at Sicyon and sent delegates to Titus Quinctius to seek his advice. In the council, most members were in favor of an immediate declaration of war, but a letter from Titus Quinctius, which suggested waiting for the Roman praetor and fleet, caused some doubt. While some key members insisted on their original stance, and others argued that they should follow the advice of the person they had asked for help, the majority waited to hear from Philopoemen. He was the praetor of Achaia at the time and was recognized for his wisdom and influence. He first noted that "it was a wise rule, established among the Achaeans, that their praetor, when offering a question about war, should not himself express an opinion," and then he encouraged them to "reach a decision among themselves as soon as possible," assuring them that "their praetor would faithfully and diligently carry out their decisions; and would do his best to ensure that, as far as depended on human wisdom, they wouldn’t regret either peace or war." His words had a stronger impact on pushing them to war than if he had openly argued for it, revealing a strong desire to lead it. Thus, war was unanimously agreed upon, with the timing and method of executing it left entirely in the hands of the praetor. Philopoemen’s own judgment, along with Quinctius's advice, suggested waiting for the Roman fleet, which could provide support to Gythium by sea; but fearing that they couldn't afford to wait and that not only Gythium but also the group sent to protect the city would fall to the enemy, he ordered the Achaean ships to be readied.

26

The tyrant also, with the view of cutting off any supplies that might be brought to the besieged by sea, had fitted out a small squadron, consisting of only three ships of war, with some barks and cutters, as his former fleet had been given up to the Romans, according to the treaty. In order to try the activity of these vessels, as they were then new, and, at the same time, to have every thing in fit condition for a battle, he put out to sea every day, and exercised both the rowers and marines in mock-fights; for he thought that all his hopes of succeeding in the siege depended on the circumstance of his cutting off all supplies by sea. The praetor of the Achaeans, in respect of skill for conducting operations on land, was equal to any of the most celebrated commanders both in capacity and experience, yet with naval affairs he was quite unacquainted. Being an inhabitant of Arcadia, an inland country, he was ignorant even of all foreign affairs, excepting that he had once served in Crete as commander of a body of auxiliaries. There was an old ship of four banks of oars, which had been taken eighty years before, as it was conveying Nicaea, the wife of Craterus, from Naupactum to Corinth. Led by the reputation of this ship, for it had formerly been reckoned a very famous vessel when in the king's fleet, he ordered it, though now quite rotten, and falling asunder through age, to be brought out from Aegium. The fleet sailed with this ship at its head, Tiso of Patrae, the commander, being on board it, when the ships of the Lacedaemonians from Gythium came within view. At the first shock, against a new and firm vessel, that old one, which before admitted the water through every joint, was shattered to pieces, and the whole crew were made prisoners. On the loss of the commander's ship, the rest of the fleet fled as fast as each could by means of its oars. Philopoemen himself made his escape in a light advice-boat, nor did he stop his flight until he arrived at Patrae. This untoward event did not in the least damp the spirit of a man so well versed in military affairs, and who had experienced so many vicissitudes of fortune. On the contrary, as he had failed of success in the naval line, in which he had no experience, he even conceived, thence, the greater hopes of succeeding in another, wherein he had acquired knowledge; and he affirmed, that he would quickly put an end to the tyrant's rejoicing.

The tyrant, aiming to cut off any supplies that might reach the besieged by sea, had assembled a small fleet made up of just three warships, along with some smaller boats, since his previous fleet had been surrendered to the Romans as per the treaty. To test out these newly commissioned vessels and ensure everything was ready for battle, he went out to sea every day, training both the rowers and marines in mock battles; he believed all his chances of succeeding in the siege depended on cutting off all supply routes by sea. The praetor of the Achaeans was skilled in land operations, standing shoulder to shoulder with the most renowned commanders in both ability and experience, but he knew nothing about naval matters. Being from Arcadia, an inland region, he was unfamiliar even with foreign affairs, except for a time he had previously served in Crete as a commander of auxiliary forces. There was an old ship with four banks of oars that had been captured eighty years prior while transporting Nicaea, the wife of Craterus, from Naupactum to Corinth. Drawn in by the ship’s past reputation as a once-renowned vessel in the king's fleet, he ordered it to be brought from Aegium despite its dilapidated condition. The fleet set sail with this ship leading the way, with Tiso of Patrae as the commander on board when the ships of the Lacedaemonians from Gythium came into sight. Upon impact with a fresh, sturdy vessel, that ancient ship, which was already leaking at every joint, broke apart completely, leaving the entire crew captured. Following the loss of the commander's ship, the rest of the fleet hurried to escape as quickly as possible with their oars. Philopoemen managed to flee on a small advice-boat and did not stop until he reached Patrae. This unfortunate event did not dampen the spirit of a man so experienced in military matters, who had faced numerous changes of fortune. On the contrary, after failing in naval operations where he had no experience, he felt even more hopeful about succeeding in areas where he had expertise, declaring that he would soon put an end to the tyrant's celebrations.

27

Nabis, being both elated by this adventure, and entertaining a confident hope that he had not now any danger to apprehend from the sea, resolved to shut up the passages on the land also, by parties stationed in proper posts. With this view, he drew off a third part of his forces from the siege of Gythium, and encamped them at Pleiae, a place which commands both Leucae and Acriae, on the road by which the enemy's army seemed likely to advance. While his quarters were here, and very few of his men had tents, (the generality of them having formed huts of reeds interwoven, and which they covered with leaves of trees, to serve merely as a shelter,) Philopoemen, before he came within sight, resolved to surprise him by an attack of such a kind as he did not expect. He drew together some small ships in a remote creek, on the coast of the territory of Argos, and embarked on board them a body of light-armed soldiers, mostly targeteers, furnished with slings, javelins, and other light kinds of weapons. He then coasted along the shore, until he came to a promontory near Nabis's post. Here he landed; and made his way, by night, through paths with which he was well acquainted, to Pleiae, and while the sentinels were fast asleep, as being in no immediate apprehension, he set fire to the huts in every part of the camp. Great numbers perished in the flames before they could discover the enemy's arrival, and those who did discover it could give no assistance; so that nearly the whole was destroyed by fire and sword. From both these means of destruction, however, a very small number made their escape, and fled to the principal camp before Gythium. The enemy having been thus smitten with disaster, Philopoemen forthwith led on his forces to ravage the district of Tripolis, a part of the Lacedaemonian territory, lying next to the frontiers of the Megalopolitans, and carrying off thence a vast number of men and cattle, withdrew before the tyrant could send a force from Gythium to protect the country. He then collected his whole force at Tegea, to which place he summoned a council of the Achaeans and their allies; at which were present, also deputies from the Epirots and Acarnanians. Here it was resolved, that as the minds of his men were now sufficiently recovered from the shame of the disgrace suffered at sea, and those of the enemy dispirited, he should march directly to Lacedaemon; for he considered that by this measure alone could the enemy be drawn off from the siege of Gythium. On entering the enemy's country, he encamped the first day at Caryae; and, on that very day, Gythium was taken. Ignorant of that event, Philopoemen advanced to the Barbosthenes, a mountain ten miles from Lacedaemon. On the other side, Nabis, after taking possession of Gythium, set out, at the head of a body of light troops, marched hastily by Lacedaemon, and seized on a place called the Camp of Pyrrhus, which post he did not doubt that the Achaeans intended to occupy. From thence he proceeded to meet the enemy. From the length of their train in consequence of the narrowness of the road, they spread over a space of almost five miles. The line was closed by the cavalry and the greatest part of the auxiliaries, because Philopoemen expected that the tyrant would attack him in the rear with his mercenary troops, in whom he placed his principal confidence. Two unforeseen circumstances at once filled him with uneasiness: one, the post at which he aimed being pre-occupied; the other, the enemy having met him in front, where, as the road lay through very uneven ground, he did not see how the battalions could advance without the support of the light troops.

Nabis, feeling both happy about this mission and confident that he didn’t have to worry about threats from the sea anymore, decided to secure the land routes too by placing groups of soldiers at strategic points. To do this, he pulled a third of his forces from the siege of Gythium and set them up at Pleiae, a spot that overlooked both Leucae and Acriae, along the road that the enemy troops were likely to take. While his soldiers were camped there, and most of them didn’t have tents (the majority having constructed huts made of intertwined reeds covered with tree leaves just for shelter), Philopoemen, before he came into view, planned to surprise him with an unexpected attack. He gathered some small ships at a secluded creek on the Argos coast and loaded them with light-armed soldiers, mainly targeteers equipped with slings, javelins, and other lightweight weapons. He then traveled along the shore until he reached a promontory close to Nabis's position. There, he landed and made his way, under the cover of night, through familiar paths to Pleiae, and while the sentinels were fast asleep, not expecting any danger, he set fire to the huts throughout the entire camp. Many men were trapped in the flames before they realized the enemy had arrived, and those who did see it couldn’t help, so a large part of the camp was destroyed by fire and sword. From these two sources of destruction, only a few managed to escape and flee to the main camp before Gythium. Following this disaster, Philopoemen quickly led his forces to pillage the Tripolis region, which was part of the Lacedaemonian territory near the borders of the Megalopolitans, taking away a huge number of people and livestock before the tyrant could send reinforcements from Gythium to protect the area. He then mustered all his forces at Tegea, where he called a council of the Achaeans and their allies, and representatives from the Epirots and Acarnanians also attended. It was decided that since his men had recovered enough from their embarrassment at sea, and the enemy was demoralized, he should march straight to Lacedaemon; he believed this was the only way to draw the enemy away from the siege of Gythium. Upon entering enemy territory, he camped the first day at Caryae, and that very day, Gythium fell. Unaware of this event, Philopoemen moved on to Barbosthenes, a mountain ten miles from Lacedaemon. Meanwhile, Nabis, after capturing Gythium, set out with a group of light troops, hurried past Lacedaemon, and took over a place called the Camp of Pyrrhus, which he believed the Achaeans planned to occupy. He then advanced to confront the enemy. Due to the length of their formation caused by the narrow road, they stretched across almost five miles. The line was secured by the cavalry and the majority of the auxiliaries, since Philopoemen anticipated that the tyrant would attack him from behind with his mercenary troops, who he trusted most. Two unexpected developments suddenly worried him: one, that the post he was aiming for was already occupied; the other, that the enemy was in front of him, where the ground was very uneven, making it unclear how the battalions could advance without support from the light troops.

28

Philopoemen was possessed of an admirable degree of skill and experience, in conducting a march, and choosing his station; having made these points his principal study, not only in times of war, but likewise during peace. Whenever he was making a journey to any place and came to a defile where the passage was difficult, it was his practice, first, to examine the nature of the ground on every side. When journeying alone, he meditated within himself; if he had company, he asked them, "If an enemy should appear in that place, what course ought he to adopt, if they should attack him in front; what, if on this flank, or on that; what, if on the rear; for he might happen to meet them while his men were formed with a regular front, or when they were in the loose order of march, fit only for the road." He would proceed to examine, either in his own mind, or by asking questions, "What ground he himself would choose; what number of soldiers, or what kind of arms (which was a very material point) he ought to employ; where he should deposit the baggage, where the soldiers' necessaries, where the unarmed multitude; with what number and what kind of troops he should guard them, and whether it would be better to prosecute his march as intended, or to return back by the way he came; what spot, also, he should choose for his camp; how large a space he should enclose within the lines; where he could be conveniently supplied with water; where a sufficiency of forage and wood could be had; which would be his safest road on decamping next day, and in what form the army should march?" In such studies and inquiries he had, from his early years, so frequently exercised his thoughts, that, on any thing of the kind occurring, no expedient that could be devised was new to him. On this occasion, he first ordered the army to halt; then sent forward to the van the auxiliary Cretans, and the horsemen called Tarentines, each leading two spare horses; and, ordering the rest of the cavalry to follow, he seized on a rock which stood over a rivulet, from which he might be supplied with water. Here he collected together all the baggage with all the suttlers and followers of the army, placing a guard of soldiers round them; and then he fortified his camp, as the nature of the place required. The pitching of tents in such rugged and uneven ground was a difficult task. The enemy were distant not more than five hundred paces. Both drew water from the same rivulet, under escorts of light troops; but, before any skirmish took place, as usual between men encamped so near to each other, night came on. It was evident, however, that they must, unavoidably, fight next day at the rivulet, in support of the watering parties. Wherefore, during the night, Philopoemen concealed, in a valley remote from the view of the enemy, as great a number of targeteers as the place was capable of hiding.

Philopoemen had an impressive level of skill and experience in leading marches and choosing positions. He focused on these skills not only during wartime but also in peacetime. Whenever he traveled and encountered a challenging pass, he would first assess the ground from every angle. When alone, he would reflect on his thoughts; if he was with others, he’d ask, "If an enemy appears here, what should we do if they attack us from the front? What if it's from one flank or the other? What if they come from behind? We could be caught with our troops arranged in a proper formation or moving in a loose way, which is only good for the road." He would consider in his mind, or ask his companions, "What ground would I choose for my position? How many soldiers and what kinds of weapons (which is a key point) should I use? Where should I store the baggage, the soldiers' necessities, and the unarmed civilians? How many and what kind of troops should protect them? Would it be better to continue the march as planned or to turn back the way we came? What spot should I select for the camp? How much space should I enclose within the lines? Where will I get enough water? Where can I find enough forage and wood? What would be the safest route for leaving camp the next day, and how should the army arrange itself for the march?" He had practiced such thoughts and inquiries so often from a young age that when situations like this arose, no tactic was unfamiliar to him. On this occasion, he first ordered the army to stop, then sent the auxiliary Cretans and the horsemen known as Tarentines ahead, each with two spare horses. He then instructed the rest of the cavalry to follow and took control of a rock overlooking a stream, ensuring a water supply. Here, he gathered all the baggage along with the sutlers and followers of the army, setting up a guard of soldiers around them, and fortified the camp according to the terrain's needs. Setting up tents on such rough ground was tough. The enemy was only about five hundred paces away. Both sides collected water from the same stream, protected by light troops; however, before any skirmish could happen—typical when camps are so close together—night fell. It was clear that they would inevitably have to fight the next day at the stream over access to water. So, during the night, Philopoemen hid as many targeteers as possible in a valley out of sight from the enemy.

29

At break of day, the Cretan light infantry and the Tarentine horse began an engagement on the bank of the rivulet. Telemnastus, a Cretan, commanded his countrymen; Lycortas of Megalopolis, the cavalry. The enemies' watering party also was guarded by Cretan auxiliaries and Tarentine horsemen. The fight was, for a considerable time, doubtful, as the troops on both sides were of the same kind and armed alike; but as the contest advanced, the tyrant's auxiliaries gained an advantage, both by their superiority of numbers, and because Philopoemen had given directions to his officers, that, after maintaining the contest for a short time they should betake themselves to flight, and draw the enemy on to the place of the ambuscade. The latter, pursuing the runaways, in disorderly haste, through the valley, were most of them wounded and slain, before they discovered their concealed foe. The targeteers had posted themselves in such order, as far as the breadth of the valley allowed, that they easily gave a passage to their flying friends, through openings in their ranks; then starting up themselves, hale, fresh, and in regular order, they briskly attacked the enemy, whose ranks were broken, who were scattered in confusion, and were, besides, exhausted with fatigue and wounds. The victory was no longer doubtful; the tyrant's troops instantly turned their backs, and flying with much more precipitation than they had pursued, were driven into their camp. Great numbers were killed and taken in the pursuit; and the consternation would have spread through the camp also, had not Philopoemen ordered a retreat to be sounded; for he dreaded the ground (which was rough and dangerous to advance on without caution) more than he did the enemy. Judging, both from the issue of the battle and from the disposition of the enemy's leader, in what apprehension he then was, he sent to him one of the auxiliary soldiers in the character of a deserter, to assure him positively, that the Achaeans had resolved to advance, next day, to the river Eurotas, which runs almost close to the walls, in order to intercept his way, so that the tyrant could have no retreat to the city when he required it, and to prevent any provisions being brought thence to the camp; and that they intended, at the same time, to try whether any could be prevailed on to desert his cause. Although the deserter did not gain entire credit, yet he afforded to one, who was full of apprehensions, a plausible pretext for leaving his camp. On the day following, he ordered Pythagoras, with the auxiliaries and cavalry, to mount guard before the rampart; and then, marching out himself with the main body of the army, as if intending to offer battle, he ordered them to return with all haste to the city.

At dawn, the Cretan light infantry and the Tarentine cavalry started fighting on the riverbank. Telemnastus, a Cretan, led his fellow countrymen, while Lycortas from Megalopolis commanded the cavalry. The enemy's watering party was also protected by Cretan auxiliaries and Tarentine horsemen. For a significant time, the battle was uncertain since both sides were similar in type and armed alike; however, as the fight progressed, the tyrant's auxiliaries gained the upper hand due to their larger numbers. Philopoemen instructed his officers to hold their ground briefly, then retreat, luring the enemy towards an ambush. The latter, pursuing the fleeing soldiers recklessly through the valley, suffered many injuries and casualties before realizing their hidden opponent. The targeteers arranged themselves in such a way that they could easily create openings in their ranks for their retreating allies. Then, they sprang up, fresh and organized, launching a swift assault on the disordered enemy, who were already exhausted from fatigue and injuries. The outcome of the battle was no longer in doubt; the tyrant's forces quickly fled, retreating much faster than they had advanced, and were driven back to their camp. Many were killed or captured during the chase, and panic would have spread through the camp if Philopoemen had not ordered a retreat to be sounded, as he feared the rough and treacherous terrain more than the enemy. Based on the battle's outcome and the enemy leader's anxious disposition, he sent one of the auxiliary soldiers disguised as a deserter, assuring him that the Achaeans planned to advance the next day to the river Eurotas, which runs close to the walls, to block the tyrant's retreat to the city and prevent any supplies from reaching the camp, while also trying to persuade others to abandon his cause. Although the deserter was not fully believed, he provided a convincing excuse for someone who was already fearful to leave his camp. The following day, he ordered Pythagoras, along with the auxiliaries and cavalry, to guard the rampart while he himself marched out with the main body of the army, as if preparing for battle, then directed them to return to the city as quickly as possible.

30

When Philopoemen saw their army marching precipitately through a narrow and steep road, he sent all his cavalry, together with the Cretan auxiliaries, against the guard of the enemy, stationed in the front of their camp. These, seeing their adversaries approach, and perceiving that their friends had abandoned them, at first attempted to retreat within their works; but afterwards, when the whole force of the Achaeans advanced in order of battle, they were seized with fear, lest, together with the camp itself, they might be taken; they resolved, therefore, to follow the body of their army, which, by this time, had proceeded to a considerable distance in advance. Immediately, the targeteers of the Achaeans assailed and plundered the camp, and the rest set out in pursuit of the enemy. The road was such, that a body of men, even when undisturbed by any fear of a foe, could not, without difficulty, make its way through it. But when an attack was made on their rear, and the shouts of terror, raised by the affrighted troops behind, reached to the van, they threw down their arms, and fled, each for himself, in different directions, into the woods which lay on each side of the road. In an instant of time, the way was stopped up with heaps of weapons, particularly spears, which, falling mostly with their points towards the pursuers, formed a kind of palisade across the road. Philopoemen ordered the auxiliaries to push forward, whenever they could, in pursuit of the enemy, who would find it a difficult matter, the horsemen particularly, to continue their flight; while he himself led away the heavy troops through more open ground to the river Eurotas. There he pitched his camp a little before sun-set, and waited for the light troops which he had sent in chase of the enemy. These arrived at the first watch, and brought intelligence, that Nabis, with a few attendants, had made his way into the city, and that the rest of his army, unarmed and dispersed, were straggling through all parts of the woods; whereupon, he ordered them to refresh themselves, while he himself chose out a party of men, who, having come earlier into camp, were by this time, both recruited by food and a little rest; and, ordering them to carry nothing with them but their swords, he marched them out directly, and posted them in the roads which led from two of the gates, one towards Pherae, the other towards the Barbosthenes: for he supposed, that through these the flying enemy would make their retreat. Nor was he mistaken in that opinion; for the Lacedaemonians, as long as any light remained, retreated through the centre of the woods in the most retired paths. As soon as it grew dusk, and they saw lights in the enemy's camp, they kept themselves in paths concealed from view; but having passed it by, they then thought that all was safe, and came down into the open roads, where they were intercepted by the parties lying in wait; and there such numbers of them were killed and taken, that of the whole army scarcely a fourth part effected their escape. As the tyrant was now pent up within the city, Philopoemen employed the greatest part of thirty succeeding days in ravaging the lands of the Lacedaemonians; and then, after greatly reducing, and almost annihilating the strength of the tyrant, he returned home, while the Achaeans extolled him as equal in the glory of his services to the Roman general, and indeed, so far as regarded the war with Lacedaemon, even deemed him superior.

When Philopoemen saw their army rushing through a narrow, steep path, he sent all his cavalry along with the Cretan allies to confront the enemy guard stationed in front of their camp. The guards, noticing their opponents approach and realizing their friends had abandoned them, initially tried to fall back into their fortifications. However, as the full force of the Achaeans moved in battle formation, they became terrified, fearing they might lose both their camp and their lives. They decided to follow the main body of their army, which had already moved a good distance ahead. Immediately, the Achaean skirmishers attacked and plundered the camp, while the rest pursued the fleeing enemy. The path was such that a group, even without the fear of an enemy, would struggle to navigate through it. But when an attack hit their rear and the terrified screams of their troops reached those at the front, they dropped their weapons and fled, each scattering into the woods on either side of the road. In a flash, the path was blocked with piles of weapons, especially spears, which mostly landed with their points facing the pursuers, creating a sort of barrier across the road. Philopoemen ordered the allies to charge ahead whenever they could after the enemy, who would find it hard to escape, particularly the cavalry. Meanwhile, he led the heavy infantry through more open terrain toward the Eurotas River. There, he set up camp just before sunset and waited for the light troops he had sent after the enemy. They arrived during the first watch, bringing news that Nabis, with a few followers, had made it into the city, while the rest of his army, unarmed and scattered, were wandering throughout the woods. Philopoemen then instructed them to rest, while he chose a group of men who had arrived earlier at camp and were now refreshed from food and a bit of rest. He ordered them to take only their swords and led them out, positioning them along the roads leading from two gates, one toward Pherae and the other toward Barbosthenes, as he suspected that those would be the paths the fleeing enemy would use. He was right; the Lacedaemonians withdrew through the woods using the least visible routes as long as there was any light left. Once it grew dark and they saw lights in the enemy's camp, they kept to hidden paths. However, after bypassing the camp, they thought they were safe and emerged onto the open roads, where they were caught by the ambushers. A significant number were either killed or captured, and of the entire army, barely a quarter managed to escape. With the tyrant now trapped in the city, Philopoemen spent most of the next thirty days plundering the lands of the Lacedaemonians. After severely weakening and almost obliterating the tyrant's strength, he returned home, while the Achaeans praised him as equal in glory to the Roman general and even considered him superior regarding the war with Lacedaemon.

31

While the Achaeans and the tyrant were carrying on the war in this manner, the Roman ambassadors made a circuit through the cities of the allies; being anxious lest the Aetolians might seduce some of them to join the party of Antiochus. They took but little pains, in their applications to the Achaeans; because, knowing their animosity against Nabis, they thought that they might be safely relied on with regard to other matters. They went first to Athens, thence to Chalcis, thence to Thessaly; and, after addressing the Thessalians, in a full assembly, they directed their route to Demetrias, to which place a council of the Magnetians was summoned. There a more studied address required to be delivered; for a great many of the leading men were disaffected to the Romans, and entirely devoted to the interests of Antiochus and the Aetolians; because, at the time when accounts were received that Philip's son, who was a hostage, would be restored to him, and the tribute imposed on him remitted, among other groundless reports it had been given out, that the Romans also intended to restore Demetrias to him. Rather than that should take place, Eurylochus, a deputy of the Magnetians, and others of that faction, wished for a total change of measures to be effected by the coming of Antiochus and the Aetolians. In opposition to those, it was necessary to reason in such a manner, that, in dispelling their mistaken fear, the ambassadors should not, by cutting off his hopes at once, give any disgust to Philip, to whom more importance attached, in all respects, than to the Magnetians. They only observed to the assembly, that, "as Greece in general was under an obligation to the Romans for their kindness in restoring its liberty, so was their state in particular. For there had not only been a garrison of Macedonians in their capital, but a palace had been built in it, that they might have a master continually before their eyes. But all that had been done would be of no effect, if the Aetolians should bring thither Antiochus, and settle him in the abode of Philip, so that a new and unknown king should be set over them, in the place of an old one, with whom they had been long acquainted." Their chief magistrate is styled Magnetarch. This office was then held by Eurylochus, who assuming confidence from this powerful station, openly declared that he and the Magnetians saw no reason to dissemble their having heard the common report about the restoration of Demetrias to Philip; to prevent which, the Magnetians were bound to attempt and to hazard every thing; and, in the eagerness of discourse, he was carried to such an inconsiderate length, as to throw out, that, "at that very time Demetrias was only free in appearance; and that, in reality, all things were at the nod of the Romans." Immediately after this expression there was a general murmur of dissent in the assembly; some of whom showed their approbation, others expressed indignation at his presumption, in uttering it. As to Quinctius, he was so inflamed with anger, that, raising his hands towards heaven, he invoked the gods to witness the ungrateful and perfidious disposition of the Magnetians. This struck terror into the whole assembly; and one of the deputies, named Zeno, who had acquired a great degree of influence, by his judicious course of conduct in life, and by having been always an avowed supporter of the interests of the Romans, with tears besought Quinctius, and the other ambassadors, "not to impute to the state the madness of an individual. Every man," he said, "was answerable for his own absurdities. As to the Magnetians, they were indebted to Titus Quinctius and the Roman people, not only for liberty, but for every thing that mankind hold valuable or sacred. By their kindness, they were in the enjoyment of every blessing, for which they could ever petition the immortal gods; and, if struck with phrensy they would sooner vent their fury on their own persons, than violate the friendship with Rome."

While the Achaeans and the tyrant were fighting the war this way, the Roman ambassadors traveled through the cities of their allies, worried that the Aetolians might convince some of them to support Antiochus. They didn’t put much effort into talking to the Achaeans because they knew about their hostility towards Nabis and figured they could be counted on for everything else. They first went to Athens, then Chalcis, and then to Thessaly; after speaking to the Thessalians in a large assembly, they headed to Demetrias, where a council of the Magnetians was called. There, they had to give a more thoughtful speech, as many important figures were against the Romans and fully backed Antiochus and the Aetolians. At the time, there were rumors that Philip’s son, who was a hostage, would be returned to him, and the tribute owed to him would be canceled, along with other baseless claims that the Romans intended to return Demetrias to him. To avoid that, Eurylochus, a representative of the Magnetians, and others in that faction wanted a complete change in direction with the arrival of Antiochus and the Aetolians. Against that backdrop, the ambassadors needed to argue in such a way that, while dispelling their misguided fears, they didn’t completely crush Philip’s hopes, as he held more importance than the Magnetians in every respect. They told the assembly that, "Greece as a whole owes the Romans for their kindness in restoring its freedom, and so does your state in particular. Not only had there been a garrison of Macedonians in your capital, but a palace was built there so you could constantly have a master in sight. But all of that would mean nothing if the Aetolians brought Antiochus there and put him in Philip's place, making a new and unknown king rule over you instead of the old one you had known for so long." Their top official is called the Magnetarch. This role was then held by Eurylochus, who, feeling empowered by his position, openly stated that he and the Magnetians saw no reason to hide their awareness of the common rumor about the return of Demetrias to Philip; in fact, they believed they were obligated to do everything possible to prevent it. In the heat of the moment, he went so far as to say that "right now, Demetrias is only free in name; in reality, everything is controlled by the Romans." This remark caused a general outburst of disagreement in the assembly; some showed their approval, while others were outraged by his boldness. Quinctius was so furious that he raised his hands to the heavens, calling on the gods to witness the ungrateful and treacherous nature of the Magnetians. This frightened everyone in the assembly, and a deputy named Zeno, who had gained significant influence through his wise actions and by always supporting Roman interests, tearfully begged Quinctius and the other ambassadors "not to blame the state for the madness of one person. Every man," he said, "is responsible for his own foolishness. The Magnetians owe Titus Quinctius and the Roman people not only for their freedom but for everything that is valuable or sacred to humanity. Because of their kindness, they enjoy every blessing they could ever wish for from the immortal gods; if they were to lose their minds, they would sooner harm themselves than betray their friendship with Rome."

32

His entreaties were seconded by the prayers of the whole assembly; on which Eurylochus retired hastily from the council, and passing to the gate through private streets fled away into Aetolia. As to the Aetolians, they now gave plainer indications of their intention to revolt every day; and it happened, that at this very time Thoas, one of their leading men, whom they had sent to Antiochus, returned, and brought back with him an ambassador from the king, named Menippus. These two, before the council met to give them audience, filled every one's ears with pompous accounts of the naval and land forces that were coming; "a vast army," they said, "of horse and foot was on its march from India; and, besides, that they were bringing such a quantity of gold and silver, as was sufficient to purchase the Romans themselves;" which latter circumstance they knew would influence the multitude more than any thing else. It was easy to foresee what effects these reports would produce in the council; for the Roman ambassadors received information of the arrival of those men, and of all their proceedings. And although the matter had almost come to a rupture, yet Quinctius thought it advisable, that some ambassadors of the allies should be present in that council, who might remind the Aetolians of their alliance with Rome, and who might have the courage to speak with freedom in opposition to the king's ambassador. The Athenians seemed to be the best qualified for this purpose, by reason of the high reputation of their state, and also from their long-standing alliance with the Aetolians. Quinctius, therefore, requested of them to send ambassadors to the Panaetolic council. At the first meeting, Thoas made a report of the business of his embassy. After him, Menippus was introduced, who said, that "it would have been best for all the Greeks, residing both in Greece and Asia, if Antiochus could have taken a part in their affairs, while the power of Philip was yet unbroken; for then every one would have had what of right belonged to him, and the whole would not have come under the dominion and absolute disposal of the Romans. But even as matters stand at present," said he, "provided you have constancy enough to carry into effect the measures which you have adopted, Antiochus will be able, with the assistance of the gods and the alliance of the Aetolians, to reinstate the affairs of Greece in their former rank of dignity, notwithstanding the low condition to which they have been reduced. But this dignity consists in a state of freedom which stands by its own resources, and is not dependent on the will of another." The Athenians, who were permitted to deliver their sentiments next after the king's ambassadors, omitting all mention of Antiochus, reminded the Aetolians of their alliance with Rome, and the benefits conferred by Titus Quinctius on the whole body of Greece; and admonished them, "not inconsiderately to break off that connexion by the undue precipitation of their counsels; that passionate and adventurous schemes, however flattering at first view, prove difficult in the execution, and disastrous in the issue; that as the Roman ambassadors, and among them Titus Quinctius, were within a small distance, it would be better, while all hostilities were as yet uncommenced, to discuss, in conference, any matters in dispute, than to rouse Europe and Asia to a dreadful war."

His pleas were supported by the prayers of the entire assembly; at which point Eurylochus hurriedly left the council and fled through back streets into Aetolia. The Aetolians were increasingly showing their intent to revolt; and at that moment, Thoas, one of their leaders whom they had sent to Antiochus, returned with an ambassador from the king named Menippus. These two, before the council convened to hear them, loudly proclaimed grand stories about the naval and land forces that were coming; "a huge army," they claimed, "of cavalry and infantry was marching from India; and in addition, they were bringing so much gold and silver that it would be enough to buy the Romans themselves," knowing this would sway the crowd more than anything else. It was easy to predict how these claims would affect the council; the Roman ambassadors were informed of the arrival of these men and all their activities. Despite the situation nearly leading to a breakdown, Quinctius decided it would be wise for some allied ambassadors to attend that council, who could remind the Aetolians of their alliance with Rome and who might have the courage to speak openly against the king's ambassador. The Athenians seemed best suited for this task because of their state's high reputation and their long-standing alliance with the Aetolians. Quinctius, therefore, asked them to send ambassadors to the Panaetolic council. At the first meeting, Thoas reported on his mission. After him, Menippus was brought in, saying that "it would have been ideal for all Greeks, living in both Greece and Asia, if Antiochus could have been involved in their affairs while Philip's power was still intact; because then everyone would have received what rightfully belonged to them, and the whole situation wouldn't have fallen under Roman control. However, as things stand now," he continued, "if you have enough resolve to implement your decisions, Antiochus will be able, with the help of the gods and the Aetolian alliance, to restore Greece to its former dignity, even though it has been brought down. But this dignity relies on a state of freedom that is self-sustaining and not dependent on someone else's will." The Athenians, who were allowed to express their views next after the king's ambassadors, avoided mentioning Antiochus. Instead, they reminded the Aetolians of their alliance with Rome and the benefits that Titus Quinctius had provided to all of Greece; and warned them, "not to hastily sever that connection through reckless decisions; that passionate and risky plans, no matter how appealing they seem at first, can be hard to execute and end poorly; and that since the Roman ambassadors, including Titus Quinctius, were not far away, it would be better, while hostilities have not yet begun, to resolve any disputes through discussion rather than provoke Europe and Asia into a terrible war."

33

The multitude, ever fond of novelty, warmly espoused the cause of Antiochus, and gave their opinion, that the Romans should not even be admitted into the council; but, by the influence chiefly of the elder members, a vote was passed, that the council should give audience to the Romans. On being acquainted, by the Athenians, with this determination, Quinctius thought it desirable to go into Aetolia; for he thought that, "either he should be able to effect some change in their designs; or that it would be manifest to all mankind, that the blame of the war would lie on the Aetolians, and that the Romans would be warranted in taking arms by justice, and, in a manner, by necessity." On arriving there, Quinctius, in his discourse to the council, began with the first formation of the alliance between the Romans and the Aetolians, and enumerated how many times the faith of the treaty had been violated by them. He then enlarged a little on the rights of the states concerned in the dispute, and added, that, "notwithstanding, if they thought that they had any reasonable demand to make, it would surely be infinitely better to send ambassadors to Rome, whether they chose to argue the case or to make a request to the senate, than that the Roman people should enter the lists with Antiochus, while the Aetolians acted as marshals of the field; not without great disturbance to the affairs of the world, and to the utter ruin of Greece." That "no people would feel the fatal consequences of such a war sooner than the first promoters of it." This prediction of the Roman was disregarded. Thoas, and others of the same faction, were then heard with general approbation; and they prevailed so far, that, without adjourning the meeting, or waiting for the absence of the Romans, a decree was passed that Antiochus should be invited to vindicate the liberty of Greece, and decide the dispute between the Aetolians and the Romans. To the insolence of this decree, their praetor, Damocritus, added a personal affront: for on Quinctius asking him for a copy of the decree, without any respect to the dignity of the person to whom he spoke, he told him, that "he had, at present, more pressing business to despatch; but he would shortly give him the decree, and an answer, in Italy, from his camp on the banks of the Tiber." Such was the degree of madness which possessed, at that time, both the nation of the Aetolians and their magistrates.

The crowd, always eager for something new, strongly supported Antiochus and believed that the Romans shouldn't even be allowed into the council. However, due mainly to the influence of the older members, a vote was passed allowing the council to hear from the Romans. When the Athenians informed Quinctius about this decision, he thought it would be wise to go to Aetolia. He believed that "either he could change their plans, or it would be clear to everyone that the Aetolians would be to blame for the war, giving the Romans just cause to take up arms, both morally and out of necessity." Upon arriving, Quinctius began his speech to the council by discussing the origins of the alliance between the Romans and the Aetolians, pointing out how many times they had broken their promises under the treaty. He elaborated a bit on the rights of the states involved in the conflict and added that, "even so, if they believed they had any legitimate demands, it would be far better to send ambassadors to Rome to argue their case or make a request to the senate than to have the Roman people confront Antiochus while the Aetolians served as the organizers of the battle; this would cause great turmoil in the world and lead to the complete destruction of Greece." He warned that "no one would suffer the dire consequences of such a war sooner than those who first incited it." This warning from the Roman was ignored. Thoas and others from the same group were received with widespread approval, and they pushed through a decree without adjourning the meeting or waiting for the Romans to leave, inviting Antiochus to defend Greece's freedom and settle the dispute between the Aetolians and the Romans. In addition to the arrogance of this decree, their praetor, Damocritus, added an insult: when Quinctius asked him for a copy of the decree, he replied, without regard for Quinctius’s position, that "he had more urgent matters to tend to at the moment, but he would soon provide the decree and a response from his camp in Italy, by the Tiber." Such was the level of madness that gripped both the Aetolian people and their leaders at that time.

34

Quinctius and the ambassadors returned to Corinth. The Aetolians, that they might appear to intend taking every step through Antiochus, and none directly of themselves, and, sitting inactive, to be waiting for the arrival of the king, though they did not, after the departure of the Romans, hold a council of the whole nation, yet endeavoured, by their Apocleti, (a more confidential council, composed of persons selected from the rest,) to devise schemes for setting Greece in commotion. It was well known to them all, that in the several states the principal people, particularly those of the best characters, were disposed to maintain the Roman alliance, and well pleased with the present state of affairs; but that the populace, and especially such as were not content with their position, wished for a general revolution. The Aetolians, at one day's sitting, formed a scheme, the very conception of which argued not only boldness, but impudence,--that of making themselves masters of Demetrias, Chalcis, and Lacedaemon. One of their principal men was sent to each of these places; Thoas to Chalcis, Alexamenus to Lacedaemon, Diodes to Demetrias. This last was assisted by the exile Eurylochus, whose flight, and the cause of it, have been mentioned above, because there was no other prospect of his restoration to his country. Eurylochus, by letter, instructed his friends and relations, and those of his own faction, to order his wife and children to assume a mourning dress: and, holding the badges of supplicants, to go into a full assembly, and to beseech each individual, and the whole body, not to suffer a man, who was innocent and uncondemned, to grow old in exile. The simple-minded were moved by compassion; the ill-disposed and seditious, by the hope of seeing all things thrown into confusion, in consequence of the tumults which the Aetolians would excite; and every one voted for his being recalled. These preparatory measures being effected, Diocles, at that time general of the horse, with all the cavalry, set out under pretext of escorting to his home the exile, who was his guest. Having, during that day and the following night, marched an extraordinary length of way, and arrived within six miles of the city at the first dawn, he chose out three troops, at the head of which he went on before the rest of the cavalry, whom he ordered to follow. When he came near the gate he made all his men dismount, and lead their horses by the reins, without keeping their ranks, but like travellers on a journey, in order that they might appear to be the retinue of the general, rather than a military force. Here he left one troop at the gate, lest the cavalry, who were coming up, might be shut out; and then, holding Eurylochus by the hand, conducted him to his house through the middle of the city and the forum, and through crowds who met and congratulated him. In a little time the city was filled with horsemen, and convenient posts were seized; and then parties were sent to the houses of persons of the opposite faction, to put them to death. In this manner Demetrias fell into the hands of the Aetolians.

Quinctius and the ambassadors returned to Corinth. The Aetolians, wanting to make it seem like they were handling everything through Antiochus and not directly on their own, sat idle while waiting for the king's arrival. Although they didn't hold a council of the whole nation after the Romans left, they tried to come up with plans to stir up trouble in Greece through their Apocleti, a more private council made up of selected members. They all knew that in various states, the prominent individuals, especially those with good reputations, wanted to maintain their alliance with Rome and were satisfied with the current situation. However, the common people, especially those unhappy with their circumstances, wanted a general upheaval. In a single meeting, the Aetolians came up with an audacious plan—to take control of Demetrias, Chalcis, and Lacedaemon. They sent one of their leaders to each of these locations: Thoas went to Chalcis, Alexamenus to Lacedaemon, and Diodes to Demetrias. Diodes was supported by the exile Eurylochus, whose exile and the reasons for it have already been mentioned, since he saw no other chance of returning to his homeland. Eurylochus, in a letter, instructed his friends and family, along with his supporters, to have his wife and children wear mourning clothes. Holding symbols of petitioners, they were to go into a full assembly and plead with everyone not to let an innocent man suffer in exile. The kindhearted were moved by compassion, while the malicious and rebellious hoped to see chaos unfold due to the Aetolian provocations, leading everyone to support his return. Once these initial steps were taken, Diocles, who was the cavalry general at the time, set out with all the cavalry under the pretense of escorting the exiled man, who was his guest, back home. Having traveled a considerable distance that day and the next night, he arrived just six miles from the city at dawn. He chose three troops, leading them ahead of the rest of the cavalry, who he ordered to follow. When he got close to the gate, he made all his men dismount and lead their horses by the reins, mixing like travelers on a journey, so they would appear as the general’s retinue rather than a military unit. He left one troop at the gate to ensure the approaching cavalry wouldn’t be excluded, then, holding Eurylochus' hand, he escorted him to his house through the city center and the forum, amidst crowds who congratulated him. The city quickly filled with horsemen, key positions were taken, and teams were dispatched to the homes of political opponents to execute them. In this way, Demetrias fell into the hands of the Aetolians.

35

At Lacedaemon, the city was not to be attempted by force, but the tyrant to be entrapped by stratagem. For though he had been stripped of the maritime towns by the Romans, and afterwards shut up within the walls of his city by the Achaeans, they supposed that whoever took the first opportunity of killing him would engross the whole thanks of the Lacedaemonians. The pretence which they had for sending to him, was, that he had long solicited assistance from them, since, by their advice, he had renewed the war. A thousand foot were put under the command of Alexamenus, with thirty horsemen, chosen from among the youth. These received a charge from Damocritus, the praetor, in the select council of the nation, mentioned above, "not to suppose that they were sent to a war with the Achaeans; or even on other business, which any one might ascertain to himself from his own conjectures. Whatever sudden enterprise circumstances might direct Alexamenus to undertake, that (however unexpected, rash, or daring) they were to hold themselves in readiness to execute with implicit obedience; and should understand that to be the matter, for the sole purpose of effecting which they had been sent abroad." With these men, thus pre-instructed, Alexamenus came to the tyrant, and, immediately on approaching him, filled him with hopes; telling him, that "Antiochus had already come over into Europe; that he would shortly be in Greece, and would cover the lands and seas with men and arms; that the Romans would find that they had not Philip to deal with: that the numbers of the horsemen, footmen, and ships, could not be reckoned; and that the train of elephants, by their mere appearance, would effectually daunt the enemy: that the Aetolians were prepared to come to Lacedaemon with their entire force, whenever occasion required; but that they wished to show the king, on his arrival, a numerous body of troops: that Nabis himself, likewise, ought to take care not to suffer his soldiers to be enervated by inaction, and dwelling in houses; but to lead them out, and make them perform their evolutions under arms, which, while it exercised their bodies, would also rouse their courage; that the labour would become lighter by practice, and might even be rendered not unpleasing by the affability and kindness of their commander." Thenceforward, the troops used frequently to be drawn out under the walls of the city, in a plain near the river Eurotas. The tyrant's life-guards were generally posted in the centre. He himself, attended by three horsemen at the most, of whom Alexamenus was commonly one, rode about in front, and went to view both wings to their extremities. On the right wing were the Aetolians; both those who had been before in his army as auxiliaries, and the thousand who came with Alexamenus. Alexamenus made it his custom to ride about with Nabis through a few of the ranks, offering such advice as seemed most suitable; then to join his own troops in the right wing; and presently after, as if having given the orders which the occasion might require, to return to the tyrant. But, on the day which he had fixed for the perpetration of the deed of death, after accompanying the tyrant for a little time, he withdrew to his own soldiers, and addressed the horsemen, sent from home with him, in these words: "Young men, that deed is now to be dared and done which you were ordered to execute valiantly under my guidance. Have your courage and your hands ready, that none may fail to second me in whatever he sees me attempt. If any one shall hesitate, and prefer any scheme of his own to mine, let him rest assured that there is no return to his home for him." Horror seized them all, and they well remembered the charge which they had received at setting out. The tyrant was now coming from the left wing. Alexamenus ordered his horsemen to rest their lances, and keep their eyes fixed on him; and in the mean time he himself recollected his spirits, which had been discomposed by the meditation of such a desperate attempt. As soon as the tyrant came near, he charged him; and driving his spear through his horse, brought the rider to the ground. The horsemen aimed their lances at him as he lay, and after many ineffectual strokes against his coat of mail, their points at length penetrated his body, so that, before relief could be sent from the centre, he expired.

At Lacedaemon, the city couldn’t be taken by force; instead, they planned to trap the tyrant through strategy. Even though he had lost the coastal towns to the Romans and was later enclosed within his city walls by the Achaeans, they believed that whoever got the chance to kill him would earn all the gratitude of the Lacedaemonians. The reason they sent for him was that he had long requested their help, having restarted the war on their advice. A thousand infantry troops were placed under the command of Alexamenus, along with thirty selected young horsemen. Damocritus, the praetor in the previously mentioned council of the nation, instructed them, “Don’t think that you’re being sent to fight the Achaeans, or even for any other business that anyone might guess on their own. Whatever sudden task comes to Alexamenus, no matter how unexpected or bold, you are to be ready to carry it out with complete obedience; that is the only reason you are being sent out.” With this preparation, Alexamenus approached the tyrant and quickly filled him with hope, saying, “Antiochus has already come to Europe; he’ll soon be in Greece, bringing men and weapons; the Romans will find they’re not just dealing with Philip: the number of cavalry, infantry, and ships is uncountable; and just the sight of the elephants will frighten the enemy. The Aetolians are ready to come to Lacedaemon with their full force whenever needed; but they want the king to see a strong troop upon his arrival. Nabis should make sure his soldiers aren’t weakened by idleness and staying indoors; they should train under arms, which will keep them fit and boost their courage; practice will make the work easier and might even become enjoyable with a friendly and kind leader.” From then on, the troops frequently gathered near the river Eurotas under the city walls. The tyrant’s bodyguards were usually in the center. He himself, with just three horsemen, one of whom was commonly Alexamenus, rode around in front and checked both wings. On the right wing were the Aetolians, including both previous auxiliaries and the thousand who came with Alexamenus. It became Alexamenus’s routine to ride alongside Nabis through the ranks, giving the most fitting advice, then to join his own troops on the right wing; and after giving the necessary orders, to return to the tyrant. However, on the day he had chosen to carry out the assassination, after being with the tyrant for a while, he went back to his own soldiers and said to the horsemen who had come with him, “Young men, the action we’re about to take is what you were instructed to carry out bravely under my leadership. Keep your courage and hands ready, so none of you hesitates to support me in whatever I do. If anyone doubts and prefers to follow his own plan, he should know there’s no going back home for him.” Fear overtook them, and they recalled the orders given when they set out. The tyrant was approaching from the left wing. Alexamenus instructed his horsemen to lower their lances and keep their eyes on him; meanwhile, he collected his thoughts, which had been shaken by the idea of such a daring act. As soon as the tyrant was close, he charged at him; piercing the horse with his spear, he sent the rider crashing to the ground. The horsemen focused their lances on him while he lay there, and after several ineffective strikes against his armor, their points finally pierced his body, so that before help could arrive from the center, he died.

36

Alexamenus, with all the Aetolians, hastened away, to seize on the palace. Nabis's life-guards were at first struck with horror, the act being perpetrated before their eyes; then, when they observed the Aetolian troops leaving the place, they gathered round the tyrant's body, where it was left, forming, instead of guardians of his life or avengers of his death, a mere group of spectators. Nor would any one have stirred, if Alexamenus had immediately called the people to an assembly, and, with his arms laid aside, there made a speech suitable to the occasion, and afterwards kept a good number of Aetolians in arms, without violence being offered to any one. Instead of which, by a fatality which ought to attend all designs founded in treachery, every step was taken that could tend to hasten the destruction of those who had committed it. The commander, shut up in the palace, wasted a day and a night in searching out the tyrant's treasures; and the Aetolians, as if they had stormed the city, of which they wished to be thought the deliverers, betook themselves to plunder. The insolence of their behaviour, and at the same time contempt of their numbers, gave the Lacedaemonians courage to assemble in a body, when some said, that they ought to drive out the Aetolians, and resume their liberty, which had been ravished from them at the very time when it seemed to be restored; others, that, for the sake of appearance, they ought to associate with them some one of the royal family, as the director of their efforts. There was a very young boy of that family, named Laconicus, who had been educated with the tyrant's children; him they mounted on a horse, and taking arms, slew all the Aetolians whom they met straggling through the city. They then assaulted the palace, where they killed Alexamenus, who, with a small party, attempted resistance. Others of the Aetolians, who had collected together round the Chalciaecon, that is, the brazen temple of Minerva, were cut to pieces. A few, throwing away their arms, fled, some to Tegea, others to Megalopolis, where they were seized by the magistrates, and sold as slaves. Philopoemen, as soon as he heard of the murder of the tyrant, went to Lacedaemon, where, finding all in confusion and consternation, he called together the principal inhabitants, to whom he addressed a discourse, (such as ought to have been made by Alexamenus,) and united the Lacedaemonians to the confederacy of the Achaeans. To this they were the more easily persuaded, because, at that very juncture, Aulus Atilius happened to arrive at Gythium with twenty-four quinqueremes.

Alexamenus, along with all the Aetolians, rushed to take over the palace. At first, Nabis's guards were frozen in shock as they witnessed the act unfold before them. Then, when they saw the Aetolian troops leaving, they gathered around the tyrant's body, where it lay, forming a mere group of onlookers instead of protectors of his life or avengers of his death. No one would have moved if Alexamenus had quickly called the people to an assembly, set aside his weapons, made an appropriate speech for the occasion, and then kept a good number of Aetolians armed without harming anyone. Instead, by a twist of fate that often follows treachery, every decision made only accelerated the downfall of those responsible. The commander, locked inside the palace, spent a whole day and night searching for the tyrant's treasures, while the Aetolians, believing they had conquered the city and wanted to be seen as its liberators, began to loot. The arrogance of their behavior and their disregard for numbers gave the Lacedaemonians the courage to gather and discuss driving out the Aetolians and reclaiming their liberty, which had been taken from them just when it seemed to be restored. Some suggested that, for appearances’ sake, they should include someone from the royal family as a leader of their efforts. There was a very young boy from that family named Laconicus, who had been raised with the tyrant's children; they mounted him on a horse, armed him, and then killed all the wandering Aetolians they encountered in the city. They then attacked the palace, where they killed Alexamenus, who had tried to resist with a small group. Other Aetolians, gathered near the Chalciaecon, the bronze temple of Minerva, were also slaughtered. A few, discarding their weapons, fled to Tegea or Megalopolis, where they were captured by the authorities and sold as slaves. Philopoemen, upon hearing of the tyrant's murder, went to Lacedaemon, where he found chaos and fear. He gathered the leading citizens and gave them a speech that should have been delivered by Alexamenus, uniting the Lacedaemonians with the Achaean alliance. They were more easily convinced because, at that very moment, Aulus Atilius arrived at Gythium with twenty-four quinqueremes.

37

Meanwhile, Thoas, in his attempt on Chalcis, had by no means the same good fortune as Eurylochus had in getting possession of Demetrias; although, (by the intervention of Euthymidas, a man of considerable consequence, who, after the arrival of Titus Quinctius and the ambassadors, had been banished by those who adhered to the Roman alliance; and also of Herodorus, who was a merchant of Cios, and who, by means of his wealth, possessed a powerful influence at Chalcis,) he had engaged a party, composed of Euthymidas's faction, to betray the city into his hands. Euthymidas went from Athens, where he had fixed his residence, first to Thebes, and thence to Salganea; Herodorus to Thronium. At a small distance, on the Malian bay, Thoas had two thousand foot and two hundred horse, with as many as thirty light transport ships. With these vessels, carrying six hundred footmen, Herodorus was ordered to sail to the island of Atalanta, that, as soon as he should perceive the land forces approaching Aulus and the Euripus, he might pass over from thence to Chalcis; to which place Thoas himself led the rest of his forces, marching mostly by night, and with all possible expedition.

Meanwhile, Thoas, in his attempt on Chalcis, did not have the same success as Eurylochus had in taking Demetrias; although, with the help of Euthymidas, a significant figure who, after the arrival of Titus Quinctius and the ambassadors, had been exiled by those loyal to the Roman alliance, and also of Herodorus, a wealthy merchant from Cios who had considerable influence in Chalcis due to his riches, he had persuaded a faction loyal to Euthymidas to betray the city to him. Euthymidas traveled from Athens, where he had made his home, first to Thebes, and then to Salganea; Herodorus went to Thronium. Not far away, near the Malian bay, Thoas had two thousand infantry and two hundred cavalry, along with about thirty light transport ships. With these ships, carrying six hundred foot soldiers, Herodorus was instructed to sail to the island of Atalanta so that as soon as he saw the land forces moving towards Aulus and the Euripus, he could cross over to Chalcis; meanwhile, Thoas himself led the rest of his troops, mostly marching at night, and as quickly as possible.

38

Mictio and Xenoclides, who were now, since the banishment of Euthymidas, in possession of the supreme power, either of themselves suspected the matter, or received some information of it, and were at first so greatly terrified, that they saw no prospect of safety but in flight; but afterwards, when their fright subsided, and they considered that, by such a step, they would betray and desert not only their country, but the Roman alliance, they applied their minds to the following plan. It happened that, at that very time, there was a solemn anniversary festival, celebrated at Eretria, in honour of Diana Amarynthis, which was always attended by great numbers, not only of the natives, but also of the Carystians: thither they sent envoys to beseech the Eretrians and Carystians, "as having been born in the same isle, to compassionate their situation; and, at the same time, to show their regard to the friendship of Rome: not to suffer Chalcis to become the property of the Aetolians; that if they should possess Chalcis they would obtain possession of all Euboea: and to remind them, that they had found the Macedonians grievous masters, but that the Aetolians would be much more intolerable." The consideration of the Romans chiefly influenced those states, as they had lately experienced both their bravery in war, and their justice and liberality in success. Both states, therefore, armed, and sent the main strength of their young men. To these the people of Chalcis intrusted the defence of the walls, and they themselves, with their whole force, crossed the Euripus, and encamped at Salganea. From that place they despatched, first a herald, and afterwards ambassadors, to ask the Aetolians, for what word or act of theirs, friends and allies came thus to invade them. Thoas, commander of the Aetolians, answered, that "he came not to attack them, but to deliver them from the Romans; that they were fettered at present with a brighter chain indeed, but a much heavier one, than when they had a Macedonian garrison in their citadel." The men of Chalcis replied that "they were neither under bondage to any one, nor in need of the protection of any." The ambassadors then withdrew from the meeting, and returned to their countrymen. Thoas and the Aetolians (who had no other hopes than in a sudden surprise, and were by no means in a capacity to undertake a regular war, and the siege of a city so well secured against any attack from the land or the sea) returned home. Euthymidas, on hearing that his countrymen were encamped at Salganea, and that the Aetolians had retired, went back from Thebes to Athens. Herodorus, after waiting several days at Atalanta, attentively watching for the concerted signal in vain, sent an advice-boat to learn the cause of the delay; and, understanding that the enterprise was abandoned by his associates, returned to Thronium from whence he had come.

Mictio and Xenoclides, who were now in charge since Euthymidas was banished, either suspected what was going on or received some information about it. At first, they were so terrified that they thought their only option was to flee. However, once their fear calmed down and they realized that doing so would betray their country and the Roman alliance, they came up with a different plan. Coincidentally, a major festival was being held in Eretria in honor of Diana Amarynthis, which attracted many attendees, both locals and Carystians. They sent envoys to appeal to the Eretrians and Carystians "as fellow islanders, to understand their situation, and at the same time to respect the friendship with Rome: not to let Chalcis fall into Aetolian hands; if Chalcis were taken, all of Euboea would follow; and to remind them that they had suffered under Macedonian rule, but that the Aetolians would be even worse." The Romans' reputation mainly swayed these states, as they had recently witnessed their bravery in battle alongside their fairness and generosity in victory. Therefore, both states prepared for battle and sent their strongest young men. The people of Chalcis entrusted the defense of their walls to them, while they themselves crossed the Euripus and camped at Salganea. From there, they first sent a herald and then ambassadors to ask the Aetolians what reason they had to invade. Thoas, the Aetolian commander, responded that he was not there to attack but to free them from the Romans; that they were currently bound by a heavier, albeit shinier, chain than when they had a Macedonian garrison. The men of Chalcis replied that they were not in bondage to anyone, nor did they need anyone's protection. The ambassadors then left the meeting and returned to their people. Thoas and the Aetolians, who had no other hope than a surprise attack and were not equipped for a proper war against a city so well fortified, went home. Upon hearing that his countrymen were camped at Salganea and that the Aetolians had retreated, Euthymidas returned from Thebes to Athens. Meanwhile, Herodorus, after waiting several days at Atalanta for the agreed signal which did not come, sent a boat to find out the reason for the delay. Learning that his allies had called off the mission, he returned to Thronium, where he had originally come from.

39

Quinctius, having been informed of these proceedings, came with the fleet from Corinth, and met Eumenes in the Euripus of Chalcis. It was agreed between them, that king Eumenes should leave there five hundred of his soldiers, for the purpose of a garrison, and should go himself to Athens. Quinctius proceeded to Demetrias, as he had purposed from the first, hoping that the relief of Chalcis would prove a strong inducement to the Magnetians to renew the alliance with Rome. And, in order that such of them as favoured his views might have some support at hand, he wrote to Eunomus, praetor of the Thessalians, to arm the youth; sending Villius forward to Demetrias, to sound the inclinations of the people: but not with a view to take any step in the business, unless a considerable number of them were disposed to revive the former treaty of amity. Villius, in a ship of five banks of oars, came to the mouth of the harbour, and the whole multitude of the Magnetians hastened out thither. Villius then asked, whether they chose that he should consider himself as having come to friends, or to enemies? Eurylochus, the Magnetarch, answered, that "he had come to friends; but desired him not to enter the harbour, but to suffer the Magnetians to live in freedom and harmony; and not to attempt, under the show of friendly converse, to seduce the minds of the populace." Then followed an altercation, not a conference, the Roman upbraiding the Magnetians with ingratitude, and forewarning them of the calamities impending over them; the multitude, on the other side, clamorously reproaching him, and reviling, sometimes the senate, sometimes Quinctius. Villius, therefore, unable to effect any part of his business, went back to Quinctius, who despatched orders to the Thessalian praetor, to lead his troops home, while himself returned with his ships to Corinth.

Quinctius, after finding out about these events, arrived with the fleet from Corinth and met Eumenes in the Euripus of Chalcis. They agreed that King Eumenes would leave five hundred of his soldiers there as a garrison and would go to Athens himself. Quinctius then went to Demetrias, as he originally planned, hoping that the relief of Chalcis would strongly encourage the Magnetians to renew their alliance with Rome. To ensure that those who supported his plans had some backup, he wrote to Eunomus, the praetor of the Thessalians, to arm the youth. He sent Villius ahead to Demetrias to gauge the people's mood, but with the intention of taking no action unless a significant number were willing to revive the former treaty of friendship. Villius arrived in a five-bank oared ship at the entrance of the harbor, and the large crowd of Magnetians rushed out to meet him. Villius then asked whether they wanted him to consider himself as coming to friends or enemies. Eurylochus, the Magnetarch, replied that "he had come to friends; but he urged him not to enter the harbor and to allow the Magnetians to live in freedom and harmony, without attempting to sway the minds of the populace under the guise of friendly conversation." This led to an argument, not a discussion, with the Roman accusing the Magnetians of ingratitude and warning them of the disasters that awaited them. In response, the crowd loudly berated him, sometimes insulting the Senate and sometimes Quinctius. Unable to accomplish any of his goals, Villius returned to Quinctius, who sent orders for the Thessalian praetor to lead his troops back home while he returned with his ships to Corinth.

40

The affairs of Greece, blended with those of Rome, have carried me away, as it were, out of my course: not that they were in themselves deserving of a recital, but because they constituted the causes of the war with Antiochus. After the consular election, for thence I digressed, the consuls, Lucius Quinctius and Cneius Domitius, repaired to their provinces; Quinctius to Liguria, Domitius against the Boians. The Boians kept themselves quiet; nay, the senators, with their children, and the commanding officers of the cavalry, with their troops, amounting in all to one thousand five hundred, surrendered to the consul. The other consul laid waste the country of the Ligurians to a wide extent, and took some forts: in which expeditions he not only acquired booty of all sorts, together with many prisoners, but he also recovered several of his countrymen, and of the allies, who had been in the hands of the enemy. In this year a colony was settled at Vibo, in pursuance of a decree of the senate and an order of the people; three thousand seven hundred footmen, and three hundred horsemen, went out thither, conducted by the commissioners Quintus Naevius, Marcus Minucius, and Marcus Furius Crassipes. Fifteen acres of ground were assigned to each footman, double that quantity to a horseman. This land had been last in possession of the Bruttians, who had taken it from the Greeks. About this time two dreadful causes of alarm happened at Rome, one of which continued long, but was less active than the other. An earthquake lasted through thirty-eight days; during all which time there was a total cessation of business, amidst anxiety and fears. On account of this event, a supplication was performed of three days' continuance. The other was not a mere fright, but attended with the actual loss of many lives. In consequence of a fire breaking out in the cattle-market, the conflagration, among the houses near to the Tiber, continued through all that day and the following night, and all the shops, with wares of very great value, were reduced to ashes.

The events in Greece, mixed with those in Rome, have thrown me off track, so to speak: not that they were particularly noteworthy, but because they led to the war with Antiochus. After the consular election, which is where I got sidetracked, the consuls, Lucius Quinctius and Cneius Domitius, went to their provinces; Quinctius headed to Liguria, and Domitius took on the Boians. The Boians kept things calm; indeed, the senators with their children and the cavalry commanders with their troops, totaling about one thousand five hundred, surrendered to the consul. The other consul devastated the Ligurian territory extensively and captured several forts. In these campaigns, he not only gained various loot and captured many prisoners, but he also rescued several of his fellow citizens and allies who had been in enemy hands. That year, a colony was established at Vibo, following a decree from the senate and a directive from the people; three thousand seven hundred infantry and three hundred cavalry were sent there, led by commissioners Quintus Naevius, Marcus Minucius, and Marcus Furius Crassipes. Each infantryman was allotted fifteen acres of land, while each cavalryman received thirty. This land had previously belonged to the Bruttians, who had taken it from the Greeks. Around this time, two alarming events occurred in Rome, one of which lasted a long time but was less intense than the other. An earthquake persisted for thirty-eight days; during this period, all business was halted amid anxiety and fear. Due to this event, a three-day supplication was held. The other event was not just a scare but resulted in the actual loss of many lives. A fire broke out in the cattle market, and the blaze spread among the houses near the Tiber, raging all day and into the following night, leaving all the shops with valuable goods reduced to ashes.

41

The year was now almost at an end, while the rumours of impending hostility, and, consequently, the anxiety of the senate, daily increased. They therefore set about adjusting the provinces of the magistrates elect, in order that they might be all the more intent on duty. They decreed, that those of the consuls should be Italy, and whatever other place the senate should vote, for every one knew that a war against Antiochus was now a settled point. That he, to whose lot the latter province fell, should have under his command,--of Roman citizens, four thousand foot and three hundred horse; and of the Latin confederates, six thousand foot and four hundred horse. The consul, Lucius Quinctius, was ordered to levy these troops, that no delay might be occasioned, but that the new consul might be able to proceed immediately to any place which the senate should appoint. Concerning the provinces of the praetors, also, it was decreed, that the first lot should comprehend the two jurisdictions, both that between natives, and that between them and foreigners; the second should be Bruttium; the third, the fleet, to sail wherever the senate should direct; the fourth, Sicily; the fifth, Sardinia; the sixth, Farther Spain. An order was also given to the consul Lucius Quinctius, to levy two new legions of Roman citizens, and of the allies and Latins twenty thousand foot and eight hundred horse. This army they assigned to the praetor to whom should fall the province of Bruttium. Two temples were dedicated this year to Jupiter in the Capitol; one of which had been vowed by Lucius Furius Purpureo, when praetor during the Gallic war; the other by the same, when consul. Quintus Marcius Ralla, duumvir, dedicated both. Many severe sentences were passed this year on usurers, who were prosecuted, as private persons, by the curule aediles, Marcus Tuccius and Publius Junius Brutus. Out of the fines imposed on those who were convicted, gilded chariots, with four horses, were placed in the recess of Jupiter's temple in the Capitol, over the canopy of the shrine, and also twelve gilded bucklers. The same aediles built a portico on the outside of the Triple Gate, in the Carpenters' Square.

The year was nearly over, and rumors of possible conflict, along with the senate's growing anxiety, were increasing every day. They began organizing the provinces for the newly elected magistrates so they would focus more on their duties. They decided that the consuls would oversee Italy and any other location that the senate would vote on, since it was widely known that war against Antiochus was a given. The consul assigned to that province would command four thousand Roman foot soldiers and three hundred horsemen, along with six thousand foot and four hundred horsemen from the Latin allies. Consul Lucius Quinctius was tasked with recruiting these troops to avoid any delays so that the new consul could immediately go wherever the senate directed. For the praetors' provinces, it was also decided that the first lot would include both native jurisdictions and those involving foreigners; the second would be Bruttium; the third would oversee the fleet to sail wherever the senate indicated; the fourth would be Sicily; the fifth, Sardinia; and the sixth, Further Spain. Lucius Quinctius was also ordered to raise two new legions of Roman citizens, totaling twenty thousand foot soldiers and eight hundred horsemen from the allies and Latins. This army was assigned to the praetor assigned to Bruttium. Two temples were dedicated this year to Jupiter in the Capitol; one was vowed by Lucius Furius Purpureo during his praetorship in the Gallic war, and the other was vowed by him when he was consul. Quintus Marcius Ralla, the duumvir, dedicated both. Many harsh penalties were given this year to usurers, who were prosecuted as private individuals by the curule aediles, Marcus Tuccius and Publius Junius Brutus. From the fines imposed on those found guilty, gilded chariots pulled by four horses were placed in the recess of Jupiter's temple in the Capitol, above the shrine's canopy, along with twelve gilded bucklers. The same aediles constructed a portico outside the Triple Gate in the Carpenters' Square.

42

While the Romans were busily employed in preparing for a new war, Antiochus, on his part, was not idle. Three cities detained him some time, Smyrna, Alexandria in Troas, and Lampsacus, which hitherto he had not been able either to reduce by force, or to persuade into a treaty of amity; and he was unwilling, on going into Europe, to leave these behind (as enemies). A deliberation also respecting Hannibal occasioned him further delay. First, the open ships, which the king was to have sent with him to Africa, were slowly prepared, and afterwards a consultation was set on foot whether he ought to be sent at all, chiefly by Thoas the Aetolian; who, after setting all Greece in commotion, came with the account of Demetrias being in the hands of his countrymen; and as he had, by false representations concerning the king, and multiplying, in his assertions, the numbers of his forces, exalted the expectations of many in Greece; so now, by the same artifices, he puffed up the hopes of the king; telling him, that "every one was inviting him with their prayers, and that there would be a general rush to the shore, from which the people could catch a view of the royal fleet." He even had the audacity to attempt altering the king's judgment respecting Hannibal when it was nearly settled. For he alleged, that "the fleet ought not to be weakened by sending away any part of it, but that if ships must be sent no person was less fit for the command than Hannibal, for he was an exile and a Carthaginian, to whom his own circumstances or his disposition might daily suggest a thousand new schemes. Then as to his military fame, by which, as by a dowry, he was recommended to notice, it was too splendid for an officer acting under a king. The king ought to be the grand object of view; the king ought to appear the sole leader, the sole commander. If Hannibal should lose a fleet or an army the amount of the damage would be the same as if the loss were incurred by any other general; but should success be obtained, all the honour would be ascribed to Hannibal, and not to Antiochus. Besides, if the war should prove so fortunate as to terminate finally in the defeat of the Romans, could it be expected that Hannibal would live under a king; subject, in short, to an individual; he who could scarcely bear subjection to his own country? That he had not so conducted himself from early youth, having embraced the empire of the globe in his hopes and aspirations, that in his old age he would be likely to endure a master. The king wanted not Hannibal as a general: as an attendant and a counsellor in the business of the war, he might properly employ him. A moderate use of such abilities would be neither unprofitable nor dangerous; but if advantages of the highest nature were sought through him, they, probably, would be the destruction both of the giver and the receiver."

While the Romans were busy preparing for a new war, Antiochus was also active. Three cities kept him occupied for some time: Smyrna, Alexandria in Troas, and Lampsacus, which he had been unable to capture or persuade to form a friendship treaty; he didn’t want to leave them behind as enemies when he went into Europe. A discussion regarding Hannibal also held him back. First, the ships that the king was supposed to send with him to Africa were being prepared slowly, and then a debate started over whether he should be sent at all, particularly initiated by Thoas the Aetolian. After stirring up trouble across Greece, he came with news that Demetrias was under the control of his countrymen; he had raised expectations in Greece by falsely portraying the king and exaggerating his forces, and now, using the same tricks, he inflated the king’s hopes, telling him that "everyone was praying for him, and there would be a massive rush to the shore where people could see the royal fleet." He even boldly tried to sway the king’s opinion about Hannibal when it was almost decided. He argued that "the fleet shouldn’t be weakened by sending any portion of it away, and if ships must be sent, Hannibal is the least suitable to command them because he is an exile and a Carthaginian. His circumstances or character could lead him to come up with a thousand new schemes daily. As for his military reputation, which made him noteworthy, it was too bright for someone serving under a king. The king should be the main focus; the king should be the only leader, the only commander. If Hannibal were to lose a fleet or an army, the loss would be the same as if any other general faced it, but if success occurred, all the glory would go to Hannibal, not to Antiochus. Moreover, if the war ended up being so fortunate that the Romans were finally defeated, could it be expected that Hannibal would live under a king, subject to anyone at all, especially someone he could hardly tolerate being subservient to in his own country? He hadn’t acted this way from his youth, aspiring for global dominance; it was unlikely he would accept a master in his old age. The king did not need Hannibal as a general; he could be suitably used as an assistant and advisor in war. A moderate use of his abilities would be neither unprofitable nor dangerous; but if one sought the greatest advantages through him, those could likely lead to the ruin of both the giver and the receiver."

43

There are no dispositions more prone to envy than those of persons whose mental qualifications are inferior to their birth and rank in life; because they are indignant both at the merit and the possessions of another. The design of the expedition, to be commanded by Hannibal, the only one thought of that could be of use, in the beginning of the war, was immediately laid aside. The king, highly flattered by the defection of Demetrias from the Romans to the Aetolians, resolved to delay no longer his departure into Greece. Before the fleet weighed anchor he went up from the shore to Ilium, to offer sacrifice to Minerva. Immediately on his return he set sail with forty decked ships and sixty open ones, followed by two hundred transports, laden with provisions and warlike stores. He first touched at the island of Imbrus; thence he passed over to Sciathus; whence, after collecting the ships which had been separated during the voyage, he proceeded to Pteleum, toe nearest part of the continent. Here, Eurylochus the Magnetarch, and other principal Magnetians from Demetrias, met him. Being greatly gratified by their numerous appearance, he carried his fleet the next day into the harbour of their city. At a small distance from the town he landed his forces, which consisted of ten thousand foot, five hundred horse, and six elephants; a force scarcely sufficient to take possession of Greece alone, much less to sustain a war with Rome. The Aetolians, as soon as they were informed of Antiochus's arrival at Demetrias, convened a general council, and passed a decree, inviting him into their country. The king had already left Demetrias, (for he knew that such a decree was to be passed,) and had advanced as far as Phalara on the Malian bay. Here the decree was presented to him, and then he proceeded to Lamia, where he was received by the populace with marks of the warmest attachment, with clapping of hands and shouting, and other signs by which the extravagant joy of the vulgar is testified.

There are no feelings more susceptible to envy than those of people whose mental abilities fall short of their social status and rank; they feel resentful both towards the achievements and belongings of others. The plan for the expedition, which would be led by Hannibal, the only option considered potentially useful at the start of the war, was quickly abandoned. The king, flattered by Demetrias's switch from the Romans to the Aetolians, decided to delay no further in heading to Greece. Before the fleet set sail, he traveled from the shore to Ilium to offer sacrifices to Minerva. As soon as he returned, he embarked with forty ships with decks and sixty open vessels, followed by two hundred transports loaded with supplies and military equipment. He first stopped at the island of Imbrus; from there, he went to Sciathus; after gathering the ships that had scattered during the journey, he moved on to Pteleum, the closest point on the mainland. Here, Eurylochus the Magnetarch and other key Magnetians from Demetrias met him. Delighted by their large turnout, he brought his fleet into the harbor of their city the next day. Not far from town, he landed his forces, which consisted of ten thousand infantry, five hundred cavalry, and six elephants; a force barely enough to claim Greece alone, let alone fight a war against Rome. The Aetolians, upon hearing of Antiochus's arrival at Demetrias, held a general council and passed a decree inviting him into their territory. The king had already left Demetrias, knowing that such a decree was forthcoming, and had traveled as far as Phalara on the Malian bay. There, the decree was presented to him, and he then moved on to Lamia, where the local people welcomed him with enthusiastic gestures, clapping, cheering, and other signs of the wild joy of the masses.

44

When he came into the council he was introduced by Phaeneas, the praetor, and other persons of eminence, who, with difficulty, made way for him through the crowd. Then, silence being ordered, the king addressed himself to the assembly. He began with accounting for his having come with a force so much smaller than every one had hoped and expected. "That," he said, "ought to be deemed the strongest proof of the warmth of his good-will towards them; because, though he was not sufficiently prepared in any particular, and though the season was yet too early for sailing, he had, without hesitation, complied with the call of their ambassadors, and had believed that when the Aetolians should see him among them they would be satisfied that in him, even if he were unattended, they might be sure of every kind of support. But he would also abundantly fulfil the hopes of those, whose expectations seemed at present to be disappointed. For as soon as the season of the year rendered navigation safe, he would cover all Greece with arms, men, and horses, and all its coasts with fleets. He would spare neither expense, nor labour, nor danger, until he should remove the Roman yoke from their necks, and render Greece really free, and the Aetolians the first among its states. That, together with the armies, stores of all kinds were to come from Asia. For the present the Aetolians ought to take care that his men might be properly supplied with corn, and other accommodations, at reasonable rates."

When he entered the council, Phaeneas, the praetor, and other prominent figures introduced him, struggling to make a path through the crowd. Once silence was established, the king addressed the assembly. He began by explaining why he arrived with a force much smaller than everyone had hoped for. "This," he said, "should be seen as the strongest evidence of my goodwill towards you. Despite not being fully prepared in any way, and the season being too early for sailing, I responded to your ambassadors’ call without hesitation. I believed that when the Aetolians saw me in person, they would be reassured that, even without a large entourage, I would provide all kinds of support. But I will also exceed the expectations of those who seem disappointed right now. As soon as the sailing season is safe, I will equip all of Greece with arms, troops, and horses, and its coasts with fleets. I won’t hold back on expenses, effort, or taking risks until I free you from Roman rule and make Greece truly independent, with the Aetolians as the leading state. Together with the armies, supplies of all kinds will come from Asia. For now, the Aetolians should ensure that my men are adequately provided with grain and other necessities at fair prices."

45

Having addressed them to this purport, and with universal approbation, the king withdrew. After his departure a warm debate ensued between two of the Aetolian chiefs, Phaeneas and Thoas. Phaeneas declared his opinion, that it would be better to employ Antiochus, as a mediator of peace, and an umpire respecting the matters in dispute with the Roman people, than as leader in a war. That "his presence and his dignified station would impress the Romans with awe, more powerfully than his arms. That in many cases men, for the sake of avoiding war, voluntarily remit pretensions, which force and arms would never compel them to forego." Thoas, on the other hand, insisted, that "Phaeneas's motive was not a love of peace, but a wish to embarrass their preparations for war, with the view that, through the tediousness of the proceedings, the king's vigour might be relaxed and the Romans gain time to put themselves in readiness. That they had abundant proof from experience, after so many embassies sent to Rome, and so many conferences with Quinctius in person, that nothing reasonable could ever be obtained from the Romans in the way of negotiation; and that they would not, until every hope of that sort was out of sight, have implored the aid of Antiochus. That as he had appeared among them sooner than any had expected, they ought not to sink into indolence, but rather to petition the king, that since he had come in person, which was the great point of all, to support the rights of Greece, he would also send for his fleets and armies. For the king, at the head of an army, might obtain something, but without that could have very little influence with the Romans, either in the cause of the Aetolians, or even in his own." This opinion was adopted, and the council voted, that the title of general should be conferred on the king. They also nominated thirty distinguished men with whom he might deliberate on any business which he might think proper.--The council was then broken up, and all went home to their respective states.

Having addressed them regarding this matter, and with unanimous approval, the king left. After he departed, a heated debate broke out between two of the Aetolian leaders, Phaeneas and Thoas. Phaeneas expressed his view that it would be wiser to use Antiochus as a mediator for peace and an arbitrator regarding the disputes with the Romans, rather than as a leader in war. He argued that "his presence and high status would instill greater fear in the Romans than his military might. In many cases, people choose to give up their claims to avoid war, which they would never surrender under force and arms." Thoas, however, argued that "Phaeneas's real motive was not a desire for peace, but a tactic to hinder their preparations for war, intending to let the king's energy wane while the Romans took their time to prepare. They had ample evidence from their experiences, after so many embassies sent to Rome and numerous meetings with Quinctius, that they could never secure anything reasonable from the Romans through negotiation; they would not have sought Antiochus's help until every hope in that direction was lost. Since he appeared among them sooner than expected, they should not fall into complacency, but rather ask the king, who had personally come to support Greece's rights, to send for his fleets and armies. For the king, at the head of an army, could achieve something, but without that, he would have little influence over the Romans, either in the Aetolians' cause or his own." This opinion was accepted, and the council voted to grant the king the title of general. They also appointed thirty distinguished individuals to discuss any matters he deemed necessary. The council then adjourned, and everyone returned to their respective states.

46

Next day the king held a consultation with their select council, respecting the place from whence his operations should commence. They judged it best to make the first trial on Chalcis, which had lately been attempted in vain by the Aetolians; and they thought that the business required rather expedition than any great exertion or preparation. Accordingly the king, with a thousand foot, who had followed him from Demetrias, took his route through Phocis; and the Aetolian chiefs, going by another road, met at Cheronaea a small number of their young men whom they had called to arms, and thence, in ten decked ships, proceeded after him. Antiochus pitched his camp at Salganea, while himself, with the Aetolian chiefs, crossed the Euripus in the ships. When he had advanced a little way from the harbour, the magistrates and other chief men of Chalcis came out before their gate. A small number from each side met to confer together. The Aetolians warmly recommended to the others, "without violating the friendship subsisting between them and the Romans, to receive the king also as a friend and ally; for that he had crossed into Europe not for the purpose of making war, but of vindicating the liberty of Greece; and of vindicating it in reality, not in words and pretence merely, as the Romans had done. Nothing could be more advantageous to the states of Greece than to embrace the alliance of both, as they would then be always secure against ill-treatment from either, under the guarantee and protection of the other. If they refuse to receive the king, they ought to consider what they would have immediately to suffer; the aid of the Romans being far distant, and Antiochus, whom with their own strength they could not possibly resist, in character of an enemy at their gates." To this Mictio, one of the Chalcian deputies, answered that "he wondered who those people were, for the vindicating of whose liberty Antiochus had left his own kingdom, and come over into Europe. For his part he knew not any state in Greece which either contained a garrison, or paid tribute to the Romans, or was bound by a disadvantageous treaty, and obliged to submit to terms which it did not like. The people of Chalcis, therefore, stood not in need, either of any assertor of their liberty, which they already enjoyed, or of any armed protector, since, through the kindness of the Roman people, they were in possession of both liberty and peace. They did not slight the friendship of the king, nor that of the Aetolians themselves. The first instance of friendship, therefore, that they could give, would be to quit the island and go home; for, as to themselves, they were fully determined not only not to admit them within their walls, but not even to agree to any alliance, but with the approbation of the Romans."

The next day, the king had a meeting with his select council about where his operations should begin. They decided it would be best to make the first attempt at Chalcis, a place the Aetolians had recently tried to take without success. They believed the situation called for speed rather than heavy efforts or extensive preparation. So, the king, along with a thousand foot soldiers who had accompanied him from Demetrias, traveled through Phocis. Meanwhile, the Aetolian leaders took a different route and met a small group of their young men called to arms at Cheronaea. From there, they set out after him in ten decorated ships. Antiochus set up his camp at Salganea while he and the Aetolian leaders crossed the Euripus in the ships. Once they were a little way from the harbor, the magistrates and other prominent people of Chalcis came out to their gate. A small number from each side met to discuss things. The Aetolians strongly urged the others, "Without breaking the friendship that exists between you and the Romans, you should also accept the king as a friend and ally; for he came to Europe not to wage war, but to defend Greece's liberty; and to do so genuinely, not just with words and pretenses like the Romans. There is nothing more beneficial for the states of Greece than to embrace the alliance of both, as this would ensure they are always protected from mistreatment by either, backed by the other’s guarantee and protection. If they refuse to accept the king, they should consider what they will immediately face; the help from the Romans is far away, and Antiochus, whom they could not resist with their own strength, is positioned as an enemy at their gates." In response, Mictio, one of the Chalcian representatives, said, "I wonder who these people are, for whose liberty Antiochus has left his own kingdom and come to Europe. As far as I know, there is no state in Greece that either has a garrison, pays tribute to the Romans, or is bound by a disadvantageous treaty against its will. Therefore, the people of Chalcis do not need anyone to assert their liberty, which they already enjoy, or any armed protector, since, thanks to the kindness of the Roman people, they possess both liberty and peace. They do not take the king's friendship lightly, nor that of the Aetolians. The first sign of friendship they could show would be to leave the island and go home; because as for themselves, they were fully determined not to let them through their gates, nor to agree to any alliance without the approval of the Romans."

47

When an account of this conference was brought to the king, at the ships where he had staid, he resolved for the present to return to Demetrias; for he had not come to them with a sufficient number of men to attempt any thing by force. At Demetrias he held another consultation with the Aetolians, to determine what was next to be done, as their first effort had proved fruitless. It was agreed that they should make trial of the Botians, Achaeans, and Amynander, king of the Athamanians. The Boeotianan nation they believed to have been disaffected to the Romans, ever since the death of Brachyllas, and the consequences which followed it. Philopoemen, chief of the Achaeans, they supposed to hate, and be hated by, Quinctius, in consequence of a rivalship for fame in the war of Laconia. Amynander had married Apama, daughter of a Megalopolitan, called Alexander, who, pretending to be descended from Alexander the Great, had given the names of Philip and Alexander to his two sons, and that of Apama to his daughter; and when she was raised to distinction, by her marriage to the king, Philip, the elder of her brothers had followed her into Athamania. This man, who happened to be naturally vain, then Aetolians and Antiochus persuaded to hope (as he was really of the royal family) for the sovereignty of Macedonia, on condition of his prevailing on Amynander and the Athamanians to join Antiochus; and these empty promises produced the intended effect, not only on Philip but likewise on Amynander.

When the king heard about this conference at the ships where he had stayed, he decided to return to Demetrias for now since he didn't have enough men to take any action by force. In Demetrias, he held another meeting with the Aetolians to figure out their next move since their first attempt had failed. They agreed to reach out to the Botians, Achaeans, and Amynander, king of the Athamanians. They thought the Boeotian people had been unhappy with the Romans ever since Brachyllas died and the aftermath that followed. They believed Philopoemen, the leader of the Achaeans, hated Quinctius and vice versa because of a rivalry for glory in the Laconia war. Amynander had married Apama, the daughter of a Megalopolitan named Alexander, who claimed to be a descendant of Alexander the Great and named his two sons Philip and Alexander and his daughter Apama. When she gained prominence through her marriage to the king, her older brother Philip followed her to Athamania. This man, who was naturally vain, was then encouraged by the Aetolians and Antiochus to hope for the throne of Macedonia, provided he could persuade Amynander and the Athamanians to side with Antiochus; these empty promises worked not only on Philip but also on Amynander.

48

In Achaia, the ambassadors of Antiochus and the Aetolians were admitted to an audience of the council at Aegium, in the presence of Titus Quinctius. The ambassador of Antiochus was heard prior to the Aetolians. He, with all that pomp and parade which is common among those who are maintained by the wealth of kings, covered, as far as the empty sound of words could go, both lands and seas (with forces). He said, that "an innumerable body of cavalry was coming over the Hellespont into Europe; some of them cased in coats of mail, whom they call Cataphracti; others discharging arrows on horseback; and, what rendered it impossible to guard against them, shooting with the surest aim even when their backs were turned, and their horses in full retreat. To this army of cavalry, sufficient to crush the forces of all Europe, collected into one body," he added another of infantry of many times its number; and to terrify them, repeated the names of nations scarcely ever heard of before: talking of Dahans, Medes, Elymaeans, and Cadusians. "As to the naval forces, no harbours in Greece were capable of containing them; the right squadron was composed of Sidonians and Tyrians; the left of Aradians and Sidetians, from Pamphylia.--nations which none others had ever equalled, either in courage, or skill in sea affairs. Then, as to money, and other requisites for the support of war, it was needless for him to speak. They themselves knew, that the kingdoms of Asia had always abounded in gold. The Romans, therefore, had not now to deal with Philip, or with Hannibal; the one a principal member of a commonwealth, the other confined merely to the limits of the kingdom of Macedonia; but with the great monarch of all Asia, and part of Europe. Nevertheless, though he had come from the remotest bounds of the East to give freedom to Greece, he did not demand any thing from the Achaeans, that could injure the fidelity of their engagements with the Romans, their former friends and allies. For he did not require them to take arms on his side against them; but only, that they should not join themselves to either party. That, as became common friends, they should wish for peace to both parties, and not intermeddle in the war." Archidamus, ambassador of the Aetolians, made nearly the same request: that, as was their easiest and safest way, they should stand neuter; and, as mere spectators of the war, wait for the decision of the fortunes of others, without any hazard to their own interests. He afterwards was betrayed, by the intemperance of language, into invectives, sometimes against the Romans in general, sometimes against Quinctius himself in particular; charging them with ingratitude, and upbraiding them, as being indebted to the valour of the Aetolians, not only for the victory over Philip, but even for their preservation; for, "by their exertions, both Quinctius himself and his army had been saved. What duty of a commander had he ever discharged? He used to see him, indeed, in the field, taking auspices; sacrificing, and offering vows, like an insignificant soothsaying priest; while he himself was, in his defence, exposing his person to the weapons of the enemy."

In Achaia, the ambassadors of Antiochus and the Aetolians were given an audience by the council at Aegium, with Titus Quinctius present. The ambassador of Antiochus spoke first, showcasing the kind of extravagance typical of those supported by royal wealth, describing both lands and seas filled with forces through grandiloquent language. He claimed that "an incredible number of cavalry was coming over the Hellespont into Europe; some armored in mail, known as Cataphracti; others shooting arrows from horseback; and they could even hit targets accurately while retreating, with their backs turned. To this cavalry force, strong enough to defeat all of Europe’s armies combined," he added another infantry force many times larger; and to instill fear, he mentioned nations that were rarely heard of before: Dahans, Medes, Elymaeans, and Cadusians. "As for naval forces, no ports in Greece could accommodate them; the right wing was made up of Sidonians and Tyrians; the left of Aradians and Sidetians from Pamphylia—nations that had never been matched in bravery or naval skill. Moreover, when it came to money and other resources for sustaining war, it's unnecessary for me to elaborate. You already know that the kingdoms of Asia have always been rich in gold. Therefore, the Romans are not dealing this time with Philip or Hannibal; one is a key figure of a state, the other limited to the boundaries of Macedonia; but with the supreme ruler of all Asia and part of Europe. However, despite having journeyed from the farthest reaches of the East to liberate Greece, he didn't ask anything from the Achaeans that would compromise their loyalty to their former friends and allies, the Romans. He wasn’t demanding they fight alongside him against the Romans; he only asked that they not align with either side. As true friends, they should wish for peace for both parties and refrain from taking sides in the conflict." Archidamus, the Aetolian ambassador, made a similar plea: that they should simply stay neutral, and, as bystanders, wait for the outcome of the others’ fortunes without risking their own interests. He then went off on a rant, sometimes criticizing the Romans overall and other times targeting Quinctius specifically, accusing them of ingratitude, claiming they owed their victory over Philip and their very survival to the bravery of the Aetolians, asserting, "because of their efforts, both Quinctius and his army were saved. What leadership of a commander has he ever shown? He would see him, sure, in the field, taking omens, sacrificing, and making vows like a mere, insignificant soothsayer, while he himself was exposing himself to enemy weapons in defense."

49

To this Quinctius replied, that "Archidamus had calculated his discourse for the numerous auditors, rather than for the persons to whom it was particularly addressed. For the Achaeans very well knew, that the bold spirit of the Aetolians consisted entirely in words, not in deeds; and was more displayed in their councils and assemblies than in the field. He had therefore been indifferent concerning the sentiments of the Achaeans, to whom he and his countrymen were conscious that they were thoroughly known; and studied to recommend himself to the king's ambassadors, and, through them, to their absent master. But, if any person had been hitherto ignorant of the cause which had united Antiochus and the Aetolians, it was easy to discover it from the language of their ambassadors. By the false representations made by both parties, and boasts of strength which neither possessed, they mutually puffed up each other; and were themselves puffed up with vain expectations: one party talking of Philip being vanquished by them, the Romans being protected by their valour, and the rest of what you have just heard; and that you, and the other states and nations, would follow their party. The king, on the other side, boasting of clouds of horsemen and footmen, and covering the seas with his fleets. The king," he added, "was exceedingly like a supper that I remember at the house of my host at Chalcis, who is both a man of worth, and an excellent conductor of a feast. Having been kindly entertained by him at midsummer, when we wondered how he could, at that time of the year, procure such plenty and variety of game, he, not being so vain-glorious as these men, told us, with a pleasant smile, that the variety was owing to the dressing, and that what appeared to be the flesh of many different wild animals, was entirely of tame swine. This may be aptly applied to the forces of the king, which were so ostentatiously displayed a while ago; that those various kinds of armour, and multitudinous names of nations, never heard of before, Dahans, and Medes, and Caducians, and Elymaeans, are nothing more than Syrians, a race possessed of such grovelling souls, as to be much fitter for slaves than for soldiers. I wish, Achaeans, that I could exhibit to your view the rapid excursions of this mighty monarch from Demetrias; first, to Lamia, to the council of the Aetolians; then to Chalcis. You should behold, in the royal camp, about the number of two small legions, and these incomplete. You should see the king, now, in a manner begging corn from the Aetolians, to be measured out to his soldiers; then, striving to borrow money at interest to pay them; again, standing at the gates of Chalcis, and presently, on being refused admittance, returning thence into Aetolia, without having effected any thing, except indeed the taking a peep at Aulis and the Euripus. Both Antiochus had done wrong in trusting to the Aetolians, and the Aetolians in trusting to the king's vain boastings. For which reason, you ought the less to be deceived by them, and rather to confide in the tried and approved fidelity of the Romans. For, with respect to your not interfering in the war, which they recommend as your best course, nothing, in fact, can be more contrary to your interest: for then, without gaining thanks or esteem, you will become the prize of the conqueror."

To this, Quinctius replied that "Archidamus had tailored his speech for a large audience rather than for the individuals it was specifically directed to. The Achaeans knew very well that the Aetolians' boldness existed mostly in words, not actions; it was more evident in their discussions and gatherings than on the battlefield. He was, therefore, indifferent to the opinions of the Achaeans, fully aware that they understood him and his fellow countrymen well; instead, he aimed to win over the king's ambassadors, and through them, their absent master. But if anyone had been unaware of the alliance between Antiochus and the Aetolians, it was easy to figure out from the ambassadors' speech. Through false claims from both sides and exaggerated boasts of strength that neither side truly had, they inflated each other’s egos and filled themselves with unrealistic hopes: one side claiming they defeated Philip, that the Romans were safe thanks to their bravery, and insisting that you and other states would side with them. Meanwhile, the king bragged about endless armies of horsemen and foot soldiers and how his fleets covered the sea. The king," he added, "was very much like a dinner I remembered at my host’s place in Chalcis, who is both a good man and a remarkable host. After being warmly welcomed by him during midsummer, we were amazed at how he managed to serve such a variety of game at that time of year. Not being as boastful as these men, he smiled and told us that the variety was due to the preparation, and that what looked like the meat from many different wild animals was actually just from domesticated pigs. This can easily be compared to the king's forces, which he had recently flaunted; those different types of armor and many unfamiliar nations like Dahans, Medes, Caducians, and Elymaeans are nothing more than Syrians, a people so lowly that they are more suited to be slaves than soldiers. I wish, Achaeans, I could show you the swift movements of this mighty monarch from Demetrias; first to Lamia for the Aetolian council, then to Chalcis. You would see in the royal camp about two small and incomplete legions. You would see the king practically begging the Aetolians for grain to distribute to his soldiers, then trying to borrow money with interest to pay them; and finally, standing at the gates of Chalcis, only to leave empty-handed after being denied entry, having achieved nothing other than a glimpse of Aulis and the Euripus. Both Antiochus erred in trusting the Aetolians, and the Aetolians in trusting the king's empty boasts. For this reason, you should be even less misled by them and more inclined to rely on the tested and proven loyalty of the Romans. Regarding your non-involvement in the war, which they recommend as the best approach for you, nothing could be more against your interests: for then, without earning gratitude or respect, you will become the spoils of the victor."

50

He was thought to have replied to both by no means unsuitably; and there was no difficulty in bringing an audience, prepossessed in his favour, to give their approbation to his discourse. In fact, there was no debate or doubt started, but all concurred in voting, that the nation of the Achaeans would regard, as their friends or foes, those who were judged to be such by the Roman people, and in ordering war to be declared against both Antiochus and the Aetolians. They also, by the direction of Quinctius, sent immediate succours of five hundred men to Chalcis, and five hundred to the Piraeus; for affairs at Athens were in a state not far from a civil war, in consequence of the endeavours, used by some, to seduce the venal populace, by hopes of largesses, to take part with Antiochus. But at length Quinctius was called thither by those who were of the Roman party; and Apollodorus, the principal adviser of a revolt, being publicly charged therewith by one Leon, was condemned and driven into exile. Thus, from the Achaeans also, the embassy returned to the king with a discouraging answer. The Boeotians made no definitive reply; they only said, that "when Antiochus should come into Boeotia, they would then deliberate on the measures proper to be pursued." When Antiochus heard, that both the Achaeans and king Eumenes had sent reinforcements to Chalcis, he resolved to act with the utmost expedition, that his troops might get the start of them, and, if possible, intercept the others as they came; and he sent thither Menippus with about three thousand soldiers, and Polyxenidas with the whole fleet. In a few days after, he marched himself, at the head of six thousand of his own soldiers, and a smaller number of Aetolians, as many as could be collected in haste, out of those who were at Lamia. The five hundred Achaeans, and a small party sent by king Eumenes, being guided by Xenoclides, of Chalcis, (the roads being yet open,) crossed the Euripus, and arrived at Chalcis in safety. The Roman soldiers, who were likewise about five hundred, came, after Menippus had fixed his camp under Salganea, at Hermaeus, the place of passage from Boeotia to the island of Euboea. They had with them Mictio, who had been sent from Chalcis to Quinctius, deputed to solicit that very reinforcement; and when he perceived that the passes were blocked up by the enemy, he quitted the road to Aulis, and turned away to Delium, with intent to pass over thence to Euboea.

He was seen as having responded to both in a perfectly fine manner, and there was no trouble in gathering an audience, already favorable toward him, to support his speech. In fact, there was no argument or doubt raised; everyone agreed that the Achaean nation would see as friends or enemies those deemed so by the Roman people, and they decided to declare war against both Antiochus and the Aetolians. Additionally, under Quinctius's direction, they immediately sent two groups of five hundred men each to Chalcis and the Piraeus; the situation in Athens was dangerously close to civil war because some were trying to sway the easily influenced populace with promises of rewards to side with Antiochus. Eventually, Quinctius was called there by the Roman supporters; Apollodorus, the main instigator of the revolt, was publicly accused by a man named Leon, found guilty, and exiled. Thus, the embassy from the Achaeans returned to the king with a discouraging response. The Boeotians did not give a definite answer; they only said that “when Antiochus arrives in Boeotia, they would then consider what action to take.” When Antiochus learned that both the Achaeans and King Eumenes had sent reinforcements to Chalcis, he decided to move quickly, hoping his troops would get ahead of them and possibly intercept them on their way. He sent Menippus with about three thousand soldiers and Polyxenidas with the entire fleet. A few days later, he marched out himself at the head of six thousand of his own troops and a smaller number of Aetolians that could be quickly gathered from Lamia. The five hundred Achaeans and a small group sent by King Eumenes, guided by Xenoclides of Chalcis (with the roads still open), crossed the Euripus and safely reached Chalcis. The Roman soldiers, also around five hundred, arrived after Menippus had set up camp under Salganea at Hermaeus, the crossing point from Boeotia to the island of Euboea. Accompanying them was Mictio, who had been sent from Chalcis to Quinctius to request that very reinforcement; when he saw that the passages were blocked by the enemy, he abandoned the road to Aulis and diverted to Delium, planning to cross over to Euboea from there.

51

Delium is a temple of Apollo, standing over the sea five miles distant from Tanagra; and the passage thence, to the nearest part of Euboea, is less than four miles. As they were in this sacred building and grove, sanctified with all that religious awe and those privileges which belong to temples, called by the Greeks asylums, (war not being yet either proclaimed, or so far commenced as that they had heard of swords being drawn, or blood shed any where,) the soldiers in perfect tranquillity, amused themselves, some with viewing the temple and groves; others with walking about unarmed, on the strand; and a great part had gone different ways in quest of wood and forage; when, on a sudden, Menippus attacked them in that scattered condition, slew many, and took fifty of them prisoners. Very few made their escape, among whom was Mictio, who was received on board a small trading vessel. Though this event caused much grief to Quinctius and the Romans, on account of the loss of their men, yet it seemed to add much to the justification of their cause in making war on Antiochus. Antiochus, when arrived with his army so near as Aulis, sent again to Chalcis a deputation, composed partly of his own people, and partly of Aetolians, to treat on the same grounds as before, but with heavier denunciations of vengeance: and, notwithstanding all the efforts of Mictio and Xenoclides to the contrary, he easily gained his object, that the gates should be opened to him. Those who adhered to the Roman interest, on the approach of the king, withdrew from the city. The soldiers of the Achaeans, and Eumenes, held Salganea; and the few Romans, who had escaped, raised, for the security of the place, a little fort on the Euripus. Menippus laid siege to Salganea, and the king himself to the fort. The Achaeans and Eumenes' soldiers first surrendered, on the terms of being allowed to retire in safety. The Romans defended the Euripus with more obstinacy. But even these, when they were completely invested both by land and sea, and saw the machines and engines prepared for an assault, sustained the siege no longer. The king, having thus got possession of the capital of Euboea, the other cities of the island did not even refuse to obey his authority; and he seemed to himself to have signalized the commencement of the war by an important acquisition, in having brought under his power so great an island, and so many cities conveniently situated.

Delium is a temple of Apollo, located five miles from Tanagra overlooking the sea, and the closest point to Euboea is less than four miles away. While they were in this sacred building and grove, filled with the religious respect and privileges typical of temples, known by the Greeks as asylums (with war neither declared nor in full swing, as they had not heard swords drawn or bloodshed anywhere), the soldiers were at ease, enjoying themselves—some exploring the temple and grove, others strolling unarmed along the beach, and many had gone off in different directions looking for wood and supplies—when suddenly, Menippus attacked them in their scattered state, killed many, and captured fifty. Very few managed to escape, including Mictio, who got aboard a small trading ship. Although this incident caused great sorrow for Quinctius and the Romans due to the loss of their men, it seemed to strengthen their justification for going to war against Antiochus. When Antiochus arrived with his army close to Aulis, he sent another delegation to Chalcis, partly made up of his own people and partly of Aetolians, to negotiate again under the same terms as before, but with stronger threats of retribution. Despite the efforts of Mictio and Xenoclides to resist, he easily achieved his aim of getting the gates opened for him. Those who supported the Roman cause left the city as the king approached. The soldiers of the Achaeans and Eumenes held Salganea, while the few surviving Romans built a small fort on the Euripus for security. Menippus besieged Salganea, and the king himself laid siege to the fort. The Achaeans and Eumenes' soldiers were the first to surrender, on the condition that they could leave safely. The Romans fought harder to defend the Euripus. However, even they, when completely surrounded by both land and sea, and seeing the machinery set up for an assault, could not hold out any longer. With this, the king took control of the capital of Euboea, and the other cities on the island quickly submitted to his authority. He believed he had marked the beginning of the war by capturing such a significant island and many conveniently located cities.

       *        *        *        *        *

BOOK XXXVI.


Manius Acilius Glabrio, the consul, aided by king Philip, defeats Antiochus at Thermopylae, and drives him out of Greece; reduces the Aetolians to sue for peace. Publius Cornelius Scipio Nasica reduces the Boian Gauls to submission. Sea-fight between the Roman fleet and that of Antiochus, in which the Romans are victorious.

       *        *        *        *        *

1

Publius Cornelius Scipio, son of Cneius, and Manius Acilius Glabrio, the consuls, on their assuming the administration, were ordered by the senate, before they settled any thing respecting their provinces, to perform sacrifices, with victims of the greater kinds, at all the shrines, where the Lectisternium was usually celebrated for the greater part of the year; and to offer prayers, that the business which the state had in contemplation, concerning a new war, might terminate prosperously and happily for the senate and people of Rome. At every one of those sacrifices, appearances were favourable, and the propitious omens were found in the first victims. Accordingly, the auspices gave this answer:--That, by this war, the boundaries of the Roman empire would be enlarged; and that victory and triumph were portended. When this answer was reported, the senate, having their minds now freed from superstitious fears, ordered this question to be proposed to the people; "Was it their will, and did they order, that war should be undertaken against king Antiochus, and all who should join his party?" And that if that order passed, then the consuls were, if they thought proper, to lay the business entire before the senate. Publius Cornelius got the order passed; and then the senate decreed, that the consuls should cast lots for the provinces of Italy and Greece; that he to whose lot Greece fell, should, in addition to the number of soldiers enlisted and raised from the allies by Quinctius for that province, pursuant to a decree of the senate, take under his command that army, which, in the preceding year, Marcus Baebius, praetor, had, by order of the senate, carried over to Macedonia. Permission was also granted him, to receive succours from the allies, out of Italy, if circumstances should so require, provided their number did not exceed five thousand. It was resolved, that Lucius Quinctius, consul of the former year, should be commissioned as a lieutenant-general in that war. The other consul, to whom Italy fell, was ordered to carry on the war with the Boians, with whichever he should choose of the two armies commanded by the consuls of the last year; and to send the other to Rome; and these were ordered to be the city legions, and ready to march to whatever place the senate should direct.

Publius Cornelius Scipio, son of Cneius, and Manius Acilius Glabrio, the consuls, when they took over their duties, were instructed by the senate, before they made any decisions about their provinces, to perform sacrifices with large animals at all the temples where the Lectisternium was typically celebrated most of the year; and to pray that the plans the state had regarding a new war would end successfully and positively for the senate and the people of Rome. At each of those sacrifices, the signs were favorable, and good omens were found in the first animals sacrificed. Consequently, the auspices gave this response: that through this war, the boundaries of the Roman Empire would expand, and victory and triumph were expected. When this response was reported, the senate, feeling relieved from superstitious fears, proposed this question to the people: "Do you agree and order that war should be declared against King Antiochus and anyone who joins his side?" And if that order passed, then the consuls were to present the matter fully to the senate if they deemed it appropriate. Publius Cornelius managed to get the order approved; and then the senate decided that the consuls should draw lots for the provinces of Italy and Greece; that the one chosen for Greece should, in addition to the number of troops recruited from the allies by Quinctius for that province, according to a senate decree, take command of the army that Marcus Baebius, the praetor, had sent to Macedonia the year before, by senate order. He was also allowed to receive reinforcements from the allies outside of Italy, if necessary, as long as their number did not exceed five thousand. It was decided that Lucius Quinctius, the consul from the previous year, would be appointed as a lieutenant-general in that war. The other consul, who was assigned Italy, was tasked with waging war against the Boians, using whichever of the two armies was led by the consuls from the previous year; and to send the other army to Rome, which were to be the city legions, ready to march to any location directed by the senate.

2

Things being thus adjusted in the senate, excepting the assignment of his particular province to each of the magistrates, the consuls were ordered to cast lots. Greece fell to Acilius, Italy to Cornelius. The lot of each being now determined, the senate passed a decree, that "inasmuch as the Roman people had, at that time, ordered war to be declared against king Antiochus, and those who were under his government, the consuls should command a supplication to be performed, on account of that business; and that Manius Acilius, the consul, should vow the great games to Jupiter, and offerings at all the shrines." This vow was made by the consul in these words, which were dictated by Publius Licinius, chief pontiff: "If the war, which the people has ordered to be undertaken against king Antiochus, shall be concluded agreeably to the wishes of the senate and people of Rome, then, O Jupiter, the Roman people will, through ten successive days, exhibit the great games in honour of thee, and offerings shall be presented at all the shrines, of such value as the senate shall direct. Whatever magistrate shall celebrate those games, and at whatever time and place, let the celebration be deemed proper, and the offerings rightly and duly made." The two consuls then proclaimed a supplication for two days. When the consuls had determined their provinces by lot, the praetors, likewise, immediately cast lots for theirs. The two civil jurisdictions fell to Marcus Junius Brutus; Bruttium, to Aulus Cornelius Mammula; Sicily, to Marcus Aemilius Lepidus; Sardinia, to Lucius Oppius Salinator; the fleet, to Caius Livius Salinator; and Farther Spain, to Lucius Aemilius Paullus. The troops for these were settled thus:--to Aulus Cornelius were assigned the new soldiers, raised last year by Lucius Quinctius, the consul, pursuant to the senate's decree; and he was ordered to defend the whole coast near Tarentum and Brundusium. Lucius Aemilius Paullus was directed to take with him into Farther Spain, (to fill up the numbers of the army, which he was to receive from Marcus Fulvius, propraetor,) three thousand new-raised foot and three hundred horse, of whom two-thirds should be Latin allies, and the other third Roman citizens. An equal reinforcement was sent to Hither Spain to Caius Flaminius, who was continued in command. Marcus Aemilius Lepidus was ordered to receive both the province and army from Lucius Valerius, whom he was to succeed; and, if he thought proper, to retain Lucius Valerius, as propraetor, in the province, which he was to divide with him in such a manner, that one division should reach from Agrigentum to Pachynum, and the other from Pachynum to Tyndarium, and the sea-coasts whereof Lucius Valerius was to protect with a fleet of twenty ships of war. The same praetor received a charge to levy two-tenths of corn, and to take care that it should be carried to the coast, and thence conveyed into Greece. Lucius Oppius was likewise commanded to levy a second tenth in Sardinia; but it was resolved that it should be transported, not into Greece, but to Rome. Caius Livius, the praetor, whose lot was the command of the fleet, was ordered to sail, at the earliest time possible, to Greece with thirty ships, which were ready, and to receive the other fleet from Atilius. The praetor, Marcus Junius, was commissioned to refit and arm the old ships which were in the dock-yards; and, for this fleet, to enlist the sons of freemen as crews.

Things being settled in the senate, except for assigning specific provinces to each of the magistrates, the consuls were instructed to draw lots. Greece was assigned to Acilius, and Italy to Cornelius. Now that each lot was determined, the senate passed a decree stating that "since the Roman people had decided at that time to declare war against King Antiochus and those under his rule, the consuls should command a supplication to be performed regarding this matter; and that Manius Acilius, the consul, should vow the great games to Jupiter, along with offerings at all the shrines." This vow was made by the consul in the following words, which were dictated by Publius Licinius, the chief pontiff: "If the war that the people has ordered against King Antiochus is concluded in line with the wishes of the senate and the people of Rome, then, O Jupiter, the Roman people will, over ten consecutive days, hold the great games in your honor, and offerings will be made at all the shrines, of the value set by the senate. Whatever magistrate organizes those games, at whatever time and place deemed appropriate, let the celebration be considered proper, and the offerings made rightly and duly." The two consuls then announced a supplication for two days. After the consuls determined their provinces by lot, the praetors immediately drew lots for theirs as well. The civil jurisdictions were assigned to Marcus Junius Brutus; Bruttium went to Aulus Cornelius Mammula; Sicily to Marcus Aemilius Lepidus; Sardinia to Lucius Oppius Salinator; the fleet to Caius Livius Salinator; and Farther Spain to Lucius Aemilius Paullus. Troop assignments were as follows: Aulus Cornelius received the new soldiers raised the previous year by Lucius Quinctius, the consul, according to the senate's decree, and was tasked with defending the entire coast near Tarentum and Brundusium. Lucius Aemilius Paullus was directed to take with him into Farther Spain (to reinforce the army he was to receive from Marcus Fulvius, the propraetor) three thousand newly raised infantry and three hundred cavalry, two-thirds of whom should be Latin allies and the remaining third Roman citizens. A similar reinforcement was sent to Hither Spain for Caius Flaminius, who continued in command. Marcus Aemilius Lepidus was assigned both the province and army from Lucius Valerius, whom he was to succeed; and if he deemed it appropriate, he could keep Lucius Valerius as propraetor in the province, which he was to divide in such a way that one portion reached from Agrigentum to Pachynum, and the other from Pachynum to Tyndarium, with Lucius Valerius responsible for protecting the coastal areas with a fleet of twenty warships. This same praetor was also instructed to levy two-tenths of corn and ensure it was transported to the coast for shipment to Greece. Lucius Oppius was also tasked with collecting a second tenth in Sardinia; however, it was decided that it would be sent not to Greece, but to Rome. Caius Livius, the praetor assigned to command the fleet, was ordered to sail to Greece as soon as possible with thirty ships that were ready, and to take over the remaining fleet from Atilius. Praetor Marcus Junius was commissioned to repair and equip the old ships in the dockyards, and to enlist the sons of free citizens as crew members for this fleet.

3

Commissaries were sent into Africa, three to Carthage, and a like number to Numidia, to procure corn to be carried into Greece; for which the Roman people were to pay the value. And so attentive was the state to the making of every preparation and provision necessary for the carrying on of this war, that the consul, Publius Cornelius, published an edict, that "no senator, nor any who had the privilege of giving an opinion in the senate, nor any of the inferior magistrates, should go so far from the city of Rome as that they could not return the same day; and that five senators should not be absent from the city at the same time." A dispute which arose with the maritime colonies, for some time retarded Caius Livius, the praetor, when actively engaged in fitting out the fleet. For, when they were impressed for manning the ships, they appealed to the tribunes of the people, by whom the cause was referred to the senate. The senate, without one dissenting voice, resolved, that those colonies were not entitled to exemption from the sea-service. The colonies which disputed with the praetor on the subject of exemption were, Ostia, Fregenae, Castrumnovum, Pyrgi, Antium, Tarracina, Minturnae, and Sinuessa. The consul, Manius Acilius, then, by direction of the senate, consulted the college of heralds, "whether a declaration of war should be made to Antiochus in person, or whether it would be sufficient to declare it at some garrison town; whether they directed a separate declaration against the Aetolians, and whether their alliance and friendship ought not to be renounced before war was declared." The heralds answered, that "they had given their judgment before, when they were consulted respecting Philip, that it was of no consequence whether the declaration were made to himself in person, or at one of his garrisons. That, in their opinion, friendship had been already renounced; because, after their ambassadors had so often demanded restitution, the Aetolians had not thought proper to make either restitution or apology. That these, by their own act, had made a declaration of war against themselves, when they seized, by force, Demetrias, a city in alliance with Rome; when they laid siege to Chalcis by land and sea; and brought king Antiochus into Europe, to make war on the Romans." Every preparatory measure being now completed, the consul, Manius Acilius, issued an edict, that the "soldiers enlisted, or raised from among the allies by Titus Quinctius, and who were under orders to go with him to his province; as, likewise, the military tribunes of the first and third legions, should assemble at Brundusium, on the ides of May.[44]" He himself, on the fifth before the nones of May,[45] set out from the city in his military robe of command. At the same time the praetors, likewise, departed for their respective provinces.

Commissaries were sent to Africa, three to Carthage and the same number to Numidia, to gather grain to be shipped to Greece, for which the Roman people would pay. The state was so focused on making all necessary preparations and provisions for the war that the consul, Publius Cornelius, issued an edict stating that “no senator, nor anyone with the right to speak in the senate, nor any lower magistrates, should go far from the city of Rome to the point they couldn’t return the same day; and that five senators could not be absent from the city at the same time.” A disagreement with the maritime colonies delayed Caius Livius, the praetor, while he was busy getting the fleet ready. When the colonies were pressed into service for manning the ships, they appealed to the tribunes of the people, who referred the issue to the senate. The senate unanimously decided that those colonies were not entitled to an exemption from naval service. The colonies that argued with the praetor about the exemption were Ostia, Fregenae, Castrumnovum, Pyrgi, Antium, Tarracina, Minturnae, and Sinuessa. The consul, Manius Acilius, then, at the senate's direction, consulted the college of heralds on whether a declaration of war should be made to Antiochus in person, or if it would be enough to declare it at a garrison town; whether a separate declaration was needed against the Aetolians, and whether their alliance and friendship should be revoked before declaring war. The heralds responded that they had given their opinion previously regarding Philip, stating it didn’t matter whether the declaration was made to him in person or at one of his garrisons. They believed that friendship had already been renounced since, after their ambassadors repeatedly demanded restitution, the Aetolians had deemed it unnecessary to make either restitution or an apology. They had effectively declared war on themselves when they forcibly seized Demetrias, a city allied with Rome; besieged Chalcis by land and sea; and brought King Antiochus to Europe to wage war against the Romans. With all preparations now complete, the consul, Manius Acilius, published an edict instructing that the "soldiers enlisted, or raised from among the allies by Titus Quinctius, and who were set to accompany him to his province; as well as the military tribunes of the first and third legions, should gather at Brundusium on the Ides of May.[44]" He himself left the city in his military robe of command on the fifth before the Nones of May,[45] while the praetors also set out for their respective provinces.

4

A little before this time, ambassadors came to Rome from the two kings, Philip of Macedonia and Ptolemy of Egypt, offering aid of men, money, and corn towards the support of the war. From Ptolemy was brought a thousand pounds' weight of gold, and twenty thousand pounds' weight of silver. None of this was accepted. Thanks were returned to the kings. Both of them offered to come, with their whole force, into Aetolia. Ptolemy was excused from that trouble; and Philip's ambassadors were answered, that the senate and people of Rome would consider it as a kindness if he should lend his assistance to the consul, Manius Acilius. Ambassadors came, likewise from the Carthaginians, and from king Masinissa. The Carthaginians made an offer of sending a thousand pecks[46] of wheat, and five hundred thousand of barley to the army, and half that quantity to Rome; which they requested the Romans to accept from them as a present. They also offered to fit out a fleet at their own expense, and to give in, immediately, the whole amount of the annual tribute-money which they were bound to pay for many years to come. The ambassadors of Masinissa promised, that their king should send five hundred thousand pecks of wheat, and three hundred thousand of barley, to the army in Greece, and three hundred thousand of wheat, and two hundred and fifty thousand of barley, to Rome; also five hundred horse, and twenty elephants, to the consul Acilius. The answer given to both, with regard to the corn, was, that the Roman people would make use of it, provided they would receive payment for the same. With regard to the fleet offered by the Carthaginians, no more was accepted than such ships as they owed by treaty; and, as to the money, they were told, that none would be taken before the regular days of payment.

A little while before this, ambassadors arrived in Rome from the two kings, Philip of Macedonia and Ptolemy of Egypt, offering support in the form of troops, money, and grain for the war effort. Ptolemy sent a thousand pounds of gold and twenty thousand pounds of silver. None of this was accepted. They thanked the kings instead. Both kings offered to come with their entire forces to Aetolia. Ptolemy was excused from that obligation, and Philip's ambassadors were told that the senate and people of Rome would appreciate it if he could assist the consul, Manius Acilius. Ambassadors also came from the Carthaginians and King Masinissa. The Carthaginians proposed sending a thousand pecks of wheat and five hundred thousand pecks of barley to the army, and half that amount to Rome, which they asked the Romans to accept as a gift. They also offered to equip a fleet at their own expense and to pay the total amount of the yearly tribute they owed for many years upfront. Masinissa's ambassadors promised that their king would send five hundred thousand pecks of wheat and three hundred thousand of barley to the army in Greece, and three hundred thousand of wheat and two hundred fifty thousand of barley to Rome, as well as five hundred horses and twenty elephants to consul Acilius. The response to both regarding the grain was that the Roman people would accept it as long as they could pay for it. Regarding the fleet offered by the Carthaginians, only ships they were obligated to provide by treaty were accepted; and for the money, they were told that none would be taken before the usual payment dates.

5

While these things were occurring at Rome, Antiochus, during the winter season at Chalcis, endeavoured to bring over several of the states by ambassadors sent among them; while many of their own accord sent deputies to him; as the Epirots, by the general voice of the nation, and the Eleans from Peloponnesus. The Eleans requested aid against the Achaeans; for they supposed, that, since the war had been declared against Antiochus contrary to their judgment, the Achaeans would first turn their arms against them. One thousand foot were sent to them, under the command of Euphanes, a Cretan. The embassy of the Epirots showed no mark whatever of a liberal or candid disposition. They wished to ingratiate themselves with the king; but, at the same time, to avoid giving cause of displeasure to the Romans. They requested him, "not hastily to make them a party in the dispute, exposed, as they were, opposite to Italy, and in the front of Greece, where they must necessarily undergo the first assaults of the Romans. If he himself, with his land and sea forces, could take charge of Epirus, the inhabitants would eagerly receive him in all their ports and cities. But if circumstances allowed him not to do that, then they earnestly entreated him not to subject them, naked and defenceless, to the arms of the Romans." Their intention in sending him this message evidently was, that if he declined going into Epirus, which they rather supposed would be the case, they were not implicated with relation to the Roman armies, while they sufficiently recommended themselves to the king by their willingness to receive him on his coming; and that, on the other hand, if he should come, even then they would have hopes of being pardoned by the Romans, for having yielded to the strength of a prince who was present among them, without waiting for succour from them, who were so far distant. To this so evasive embassy, as he did not readily think of a proper answer, he replied, that he would send ambassadors to them to confer upon such matters as were of common concernment both to him and them.

While all this was happening in Rome, Antiochus was trying to win over several states during the winter in Chalcis by sending ambassadors. Many states sent their own representatives to him, like the Epirots, who acted on behalf of their entire nation, and the Eleans from the Peloponnesus. The Eleans asked for help against the Achaeans, believing that since war had been declared against Antiochus against their wishes, the Achaeans would direct their attacks at them first. A thousand foot soldiers were dispatched to assist them, led by Euphanes, a Cretan. The Epirot embassy showed no signs of being open or generous. They wanted to earn the king's favor while avoiding upsetting the Romans. They asked him, "please don’t rush to make us part of the conflict, as we are right across from Italy and at the frontline of Greece, where we would face the first attacks from the Romans. If you could take control of Epirus with your land and naval forces, the people would gladly welcome you in all their ports and cities. But if the circumstances don’t allow for that, we urgently request that you do not leave us completely exposed to the Romans." Their intention in sending this message was clear: if he chose not to enter Epirus, which they thought was likely, they would not be implicated with the Roman armies while still showing their support for him by being willing to welcome him if he came. On the other hand, if he did come, they hoped to be forgiven by the Romans for aligning with a powerful ruler present among them instead of waiting for help from those so far away. Since he couldn’t think of a suitable reply to this somewhat evasive message, he said he would send ambassadors to discuss matters of mutual concern for both him and them.

6

Antiochus went himself into Boeotia, holding out ostensibly those causes of resentment against the Romans which I have already mentioned,--the death of Brachyllas, and the attack made by Quinctius on Coronea, on account of the massacre of the Roman soldiers; while the real ones were, that the former excellent policy of that nation, with respect both to public and private concerns, had, for several generations, been on the decline; and that great numbers were in such circumstances, that they could not long subsist without some change in affairs. Through multitudes of the principal Boeotians, who every where flocked out to meet him, he arrived at Thebes. There, notwithstanding that he had (both at Delium, by the attack made on the Roman troops, and also at Chalcis) already commenced hostilities, by enterprises of neither a trifling nor of a dubious nature, yet, in a general council of the nation, he delivered a speech of the same import with that which he delivered in the first conference at Chalcis, and that used by his ambassadors in the council of the Achaeans; that "what he required of them was, to form a league of friendship with him, not to declare war against the Romans." But not a man among them was ignorant of his meaning. However, a decree, disguised under a slight covering of words, was passed in his favour against the Romans. After securing this nation also on his side, he returned to Chalcis; and, having despatched letters, summoning the chief Aetolians to meet him at Demetrias, that he might deliberate with them on the general plan of operations, he came thither with his ships on the day appointed for the council. Amynander, likewise, was called from Athamania to the consultation; and Hannibal the Carthaginian, who, for a long time before, had not been asked to attend, was present at this assembly. The subject of their deliberation was in reference to the Thessalian nation; and every one present was of opinion, that their concurrence ought to be sought. The only points on which opinions differed were, that some thought the attempt ought to be made immediately; while others judged it better to defer it for the winter season, which was then about half spent, until the beginning of spring. Some advised to send ambassadors only; others, that the king should go at the head of all his forces, and if they hesitated, terrify them into compliance.

Antiochus went to Boeotia himself, publicly citing grievances against the Romans that I mentioned earlier—the death of Brachyllas and Quinctius’s attack on Coronea due to the massacre of Roman soldiers. However, the real reasons were that the once-great policies of that nation concerning public and private matters had been declining for generations, and many people were in situations where they couldn't survive much longer without a change in circumstances. When he arrived in Thebes, many prominent Boeotians came out to greet him. Despite already starting hostilities at Delium and Chalcis, he gave a speech in a national council similar to the one he delivered at the first conference in Chalcis and the one his ambassadors presented to the Achaeans, stating that he was asking them to form a friendship with him, not to declare war on the Romans. Yet, everyone understood what he really meant. Still, a decree, disguised in vague language, was passed in his favor against the Romans. After winning this nation to his side, he returned to Chalcis and sent letters summoning the key Aetolians to meet him at Demetrias to discuss the overall strategy. He arrived there with his ships on the day set for the council. Amynander was also called from Athamania to join the discussion, and Hannibal the Carthaginian, who had not been invited for a long time, attended this assembly. They focused their deliberation on the Thessalian nation, and everyone present agreed that they should seek their support. The only disagreement was whether to act immediately or to wait for the winter, which was halfway through, until spring. Some suggested sending only ambassadors, while others thought the king should lead all his forces, and if the Thessalians hesitated, intimidate them into agreement.

7

Although the present debate turned chiefly on these points, Hannibal, being called on by name to give his opinion, led the king, and those who were present, into the consideration of the general conduct of the war, by a speech to this effect:--"If I had been employed in your councils since we came first into Greece, when you were consulting about Euboea, the Achaeans, and Boeotians, I would have offered the same advice which I shall offer you this day, when your thoughts are employed about the Thessalians. My opinion is, that, above all things, Philip and the Macedonians should by some means or other be brought into a participation in this war. For, as to Euboea, as well as the Boeotians and Thessalians, who can doubt that, having no strength of their own, they will ever court the power that is present; and will make use of the same fear, which governs their councils, as an argument for obtaining pardon? That, as soon as they shall see a Roman army in Greece, they will turn away to that government to which they have been accustomed? Nor are they to blame, if, when the Romans were at so great a distance, they did not choose to try your force, and that of your army, who were on the spot. How much more advisable, therefore, and more advantageous would it be, to unite Philip to us, than these; as, if he once embarks in the cause, he will have no room for retreat, and as he will bring with him such a force, as will not only be an accession to a power at war with Rome, but was able, lately, of itself, to withstand the Romans! With such an ally, (I wish to speak without offence,) how could I harbour a doubt about the issue; when I should see the very persons through whom the Romans prevailed against Philip, now ready to act against them? The Aetolians, who, as all agree, conquered Philip, will fight in conjunction with Philip against the Romans. Amynander and the Athamanian nation, who, next to the Aetolians, performed the greatest services in that war, will stand on our side. Philip, at the time when you remained inactive, sustained the whole burden of the war. Now, you and he, two of the greatest kings, will, with the force of Asia and Europe, wage war against one state; which, to say nothing of my own fortune with them, either prosperous or adverse, was certainly, in the memory of our fathers, unequal to a dispute with a single king of Epirus; what then, I say, must it be in competition with you two? But it may be asked. What circumstances induce me to believe that Philip may be brought to a union with us? First, common utility, which is the strongest cement of union; and next, you, Aetolians, are yourselves my informants. For Thoas, your ambassador, among the other arguments which he used to urge, for the purpose of drawing Antiochus into Greece, always above all things insisted upon this,--that Philip expressed extreme indignation that the conditions of servitude had been imposed on him under the appearance of conditions of peace: comparing the king's anger to that of a wild beast chained, or shut up, and wishing to break the bars that confined it. Now, if his temper of mind is such, let us loose his chains; let us break these bars, that he may vent, upon the common foe, this anger so long pent up. But should our embassy fail of producing any effect on him, let us then take care, that if we cannot unite him to ourselves, he may not be united to our enemies. Your son, Seleucus, is at Lysimachia; and if, with the army which he has there, he shall pass through Thrace, and once begin to make depredations on the nearest parts of Macedonia, he will effectually divert Philip from carrying aid to the Romans, to the protection, in the first place, of his own dominions. Such is my opinion respecting Philip. With regard to the general plan of the war, you have, from the beginning, been acquainted with my sentiments: and if my advice had been listened to, the Romans would not now hear that Chalcis in Euboea was taken, and a fort on the Euripus reduced, but that Etruria, and the whole coast of Liguria and Cisalpine Gaul, were in a blaze of war; and, what is to them the greatest cause of alarm, that Hannibal was in Italy. Even as matters stand at present, I recommend it to you, to call home all your land and sea forces; let storeships with provisions follow the fleet; for, as we are here too few for the exigencies of the war, so are we too many for the scanty supplies of necessaries. When you shall have collected together the whole of your force, you will divide the fleet, and keep one division stationed at Corcyra, that the Romans may not have a clear and safe passage; and the other you will send to that part of the coast of Italy which is opposite Sardinia and Africa; while you yourselves, with all the land forces, will proceed to the territory of Bullium. In this position you will hold the command of all Greece; you will give the Romans reason to think, that you intend to sail over to Italy; and you will be in readiness so to do, if occasion require. This is my advice; and though I may not be the most skilful in every kind of warfare, yet surely I must have learned, in a long series of both good and bad fortune, how to wage war against the Romans. For the execution of the measures which I have advised, I promise you my most faithful and zealous endeavours. Whatever plan you shall consider the best, may the gods grant it their approbation."

Although the current debate mainly focused on these points, Hannibal, when called upon to share his opinion, directed the king and those present to consider the overall conduct of the war with a speech that went like this: “If I had been involved in your discussions since we first came to Greece, when you were debating about Euboea, the Achaeans, and the Boeotians, I would have given you the same advice I'm offering today regarding the Thessalians. My view is that, above all, we need to find a way to involve Philip and the Macedonians in this war. After all, concerning Euboea, the Boeotians, and the Thessalians, who can deny that they lack strength of their own and will always seek the support of whoever is currently in power? They will use their fears, which influence their decisions, as a reason to seek forgiveness. As soon as they see a Roman army in Greece, they will turn back to the authority they've always known. It's not their fault if, when the Romans were far away, they didn't want to test your strength and the strength of your nearby army. Therefore, it would be much wiser and more beneficial to ally with Philip than with them, since once he commits to the cause, he won’t have an option to pull back, and he will bring a force that won’t just strengthen our battle against Rome but was recently capable of resisting the Romans by itself! With such an ally (and I hope this doesn't offend anyone), how could I possibly doubt the outcome; especially when I would see those who helped the Romans defeat Philip now prepared to fight against them? The Aetolians, who everyone agrees conquered Philip, will join forces with him against the Romans. Amynander and the Athamanian people, who were second only to the Aetolians in providing crucial assistance during that war, will align with us. When you stayed inactive, Philip endured the full weight of the war. Now, you two, along with he, two of the most powerful kings, will wage war against one state; which, aside from my own fortunes with them, whether good or bad, was historically inadequate to face just a single king of Epirus. So, what could it mean for a single state to compete against both of you? But one might wonder what makes me think Philip can be brought into our alliance. First, it's common interest, which is the strongest bond of unity. Secondly, you Aetolians are my sources. For Thoas, your ambassador, when trying to convince Antiochus to engage in Greece, emphasized, above all, that Philip was extremely angry that he had been forced into servitude under the guise of peace terms—comparing the king's frustration to a wild creature restrained and yearning to break free. If that’s his mindset, let’s free him; let’s break those chains so he can unleash this long-held anger on a common enemy. But if our envoy fails to persuade him, we must ensure that if we can’t unite him with us, he doesn’t join our enemies. Your son, Seleucus, is in Lysimachia; if he takes his army through Thrace and starts raiding the closest areas of Macedonia, he will effectively prevent Philip from aiding the Romans and focus on defending his own territory first. That’s my perspective on Philip. About the overall strategy for the war, you already know how I feel: if you had taken my advice from the outset, the Romans wouldn’t be hearing now that Chalcis in Euboea has fallen, and a fort on the Euripus has been captured, but rather that Etruria and the entire coast of Liguria and Cisalpine Gaul are ablaze with war; and, even more troubling for them, that Hannibal is in Italy. Even now, I recommend that you call back all your land and sea forces; let supply ships follow the fleet with provisions, because we are too few for the demands of this war and too many for the limited supplies available. Once you’ve gathered all your forces, divide the fleet: keep one part stationed at Corcyra to deny the Romans a clear passage, and send the other toward the coast of Italy opposite Sardinia and Africa; while you, with all the land troops, head to the territory of Bullium. In this position, you will control all of Greece, making the Romans think you plan to move to Italy, and you’ll be ready to do so if necessary. This is my advice; and while I might not be the best in every type of warfare, I’ve surely learned, through good and bad experiences, how to fight against the Romans. For executing the plans I’ve outlined, I promise you my utmost loyalty and commitment. Whatever plan you decide is best, may the gods bless it.”

8

Such, nearly, was the counsel given by Hannibal, which the hearers rather commended at the time, than actually executed. For not one article of it was carried into effect, except the sending Polyxenidas to bring over the fleet and army from Asia. Ambassadors were sent to Larissa, to the diet of the Thessalians. The Aetolians and Amynander appointed a day for the assembling of their troops at Pherae, and the king with his forces came thither immediately. While he waited there for Amynander and the Aetolians, he sent Philip, the Megalopolitan, with two thousand men, to collect the bones of the Macedonians round Cynoscephalae, where the final battle had been fought with king Philip; being advised to this, either in order to gain favour with the Macedonians and draw their displeasure on the king for having left his soldiers unburied, or having of himself, through the spirit of vain-glory incident to kings, conceived such a design,--splendid indeed in appearance, but really insignificant. There is a mount there formed of the bones which had been scattered about, and were then collected into one heap. Although this step procured him no thanks from the Macedonians, yet it excited the heaviest displeasure of Philip; in consequence of which, he who had hitherto intended to regulate his counsels by the fortune of events, now sent instantly a message to the propraetor, Marcus Baebius, that "Antiochus had made an irruption into Thessaly; that, if he thought proper, he should move out of his winter quarters, and that he himself would advance to meet him, that they might consider together what was proper to be done."

Almost exactly what Hannibal advised was praised by those who heard it, but never actually put into action. Not a single piece of his counsel was followed through, except for sending Polyxenidas to retrieve the fleet and army from Asia. Ambassadors were dispatched to Larissa for the Thessalian assembly. The Aetolians and Amynander set a date to gather their troops at Pherae, and the king promptly brought his forces there. While he waited for Amynander and the Aetolians, he sent Philip, the Megalopolitan, with two thousand men to collect the remains of the Macedonians near Cynoscephalae, where the final battle with King Philip had taken place; this was either to win the favor of the Macedonians and invoke their anger toward the king for leaving his soldiers unburied, or due to a desire for glory typical of kings, which was spectacular in theory but ultimately trivial. There is a mound there made from the bones that had been scattered and were then gathered into a single pile. Although this act earned him no gratitude from the Macedonians, it only angered Philip greatly; as a result, he who had previously planned to base his strategies on the fortunes of war immediately sent a message to the propraetor, Marcus Baebius, stating that "Antiochus has invaded Thessaly; if he thinks it wise, he should leave his winter quarters, and he himself will advance to meet him so they can discuss what should be done."

9

While Antiochus lay encamped near Pherae, where the Aetolians and Amynander had joined him, ambassadors came to him from Larissa, desiring to know on account of what acts or words of theirs he had made war on the Thessalians; at the same time requesting him to withdraw his army; and that if there seemed to him any necessity for it he would discuss it with them by commissioners. In the mean time, they sent five hundred soldiers, under the command of Hippolochus, to Pherae, as a reinforcement; but these, being debarred of access by the king's troops, who blocked up all the roads, retired to Scotussa. The king answered the Larissan ambassadors in mild terms, that "he came into their country, not with a design of making war, but of protecting and establishing the liberty of the Thessalians." He sent a person to make a similar declaration to the people of Pherae; who, without giving him any answer, sent to the king, in the capacity of ambassador, Pausanias, the first magistrate of their state. He offered remonstrances of a similar kind with those which had been urged in behalf of the people of Chalcis, at the first conference, on the strait of the Euripus, as the cases were similar, and urged some with a greater degree of boldness; on which the king desired that they would consider seriously before they adopted a resolution, which, while they were overcautious and provident of futurity, would give them immediate cause of repentance, and then dismissed him. When the Pheraeans were acquainted with the result of this embassy, without the smallest hesitation they determined to endure whatever the fortune of war might bring on them, rather than violate their engagements with the Romans. They accordingly exerted their utmost efforts to provide for the defence of their city; while the king, on his part, resolved to assail the walls on every side at once; and considering, what was evidently the case, that it depended on the fate of this city, the first which he had besieged, whether he should for the future be despised or dreaded by the whole nation of the Thessalians, he put in practice every where all possible means of striking them with terror. The first fury of the assault they supported with great firmness; but in some time, great numbers of their men being either slain or wounded, their resolution began to fail. Having soon been so reanimated by the rebukes of their leaders, as to resolve on persevering in their resistance, and having abandoned the exterior circle of the wall, as their numbers now began to fail, they withdrew to the interior part of the city, round which had been raised a fortification of less extent. At last, being overcome by distress, and fearing that if they were taken by storm they might meet no mercy from the conqueror, they capitulated. The king then lost no time; but while the alarm was fresh, sent four thousand men against Scotussa, which surrendered without delay, observing the recent example of those in Pherae; who, at length compelled by sufferings, had done that which at first they had obstinately refused. Together with the town, Hippolochus and the Larissan garrison were yielded to him, all of whom were dismissed uninjured by the king; who hoped that such behaviour would operate powerfully towards conciliating the esteem of the Larissans.

While Antiochus was camped near Pherae, where the Aetolians and Amynander had joined him, ambassadors from Larissa approached him, wanting to know why he had declared war on the Thessalians. They asked him to pull back his army and suggested that if he felt it was necessary, he could discuss the matter with them through representatives. Meanwhile, they sent five hundred soldiers, led by Hippolochus, to Pherae as reinforcements; however, they were blocked by the king's troops, who had closed off all the roads, and had to retreat to Scotussa. The king replied to the Larissan ambassadors in a friendly manner, stating that he had come to their country not to wage war but to protect and ensure the freedom of the Thessalians. He sent someone to deliver a similar message to the people of Pherae, who responded by sending Pausanias, their chief magistrate, as an ambassador to the king. He expressed similar concerns to those raised on behalf of the people of Chalcis during their first meeting at the Euripus Strait, arguing with even greater boldness. The king urged them to seriously consider their decision before taking action, cautioning that being overly cautious about the future could lead to immediate regret, and then he dismissed him. When the Pheraeans learned the outcome of this meeting, they quickly decided to endure whatever consequences of war might come rather than break their commitments to the Romans. They then worked hard to prepare for the defense of their city, while the king resolved to attack the walls from all sides at once. Recognizing that the fate of this city, the first he had besieged, would determine whether he would be feared or scorned by the entire Thessalian nation, he implemented every possible method to strike fear into them. They initially held up against the assault with great determination, but as time went on and many of their men were either killed or injured, their resolve began to dwindle. After being reenergized by their leaders' encouragement, they resolved to continue fighting but retreated to the inner part of the city, abandoning the outer wall as their numbers had dwindled. Eventually, overwhelmed by distress and fearing that they would receive no mercy if captured, they chose to surrender. The king acted quickly; while the fear was still fresh, he sent four thousand men against Scotussa, which surrendered immediately, following the example set by Pherae, where the people had ultimately yielded after initially resisting. Along with the town, Hippolochus and the Larissan garrison were handed over to him, all of whom the king released unharmed, hoping that such kindness would help win the favor of the Larissans.

10

Having accomplished all this within the space of ten days after his arrival at Pherae, he marched with his whole force to Cranon, which he took immediately on his arrival. He then took Cypaera and Metropolis, and the forts which lay around them; and now every town in all that tract was in his power, except Atrax and Gyrton. He next resolved to lay siege to Larissa, for he thought that (either through dread inspired by the storming of the other towns, or in consideration of his kindness in dismissing the troops of their garrison, or being led by the example of so many cities surrendering themselves) they would not continue longer in their obstinacy. Having ordered the elephants to advance in front of the battalions, for the purpose of striking terror, he approached the city with his army in order of battle, on which the minds of a great number of the Larissans became irresolute and perplexed, between their fears of the enemy at their gates, and their respect for their distant allies. Meantime, Amynander, with the Athamanian troops, seized on Pellinaeus; while Menippus, with three thousand Aetolian foot and two hundred horse, marched into Perrhaebia, where he took Mallaea and Cyretiae by assault, and ravaged the lands of Tripolis. After executing these enterprises with despatch, they returned to the king at Larissa just when he was holding a council on the method of proceeding with regard to that place. On this occasion there were opposite opinions: for some thought that force should be applied; that there was no time to be lost, but that the walls should be immediately attacked with works and machines on all sides at once; especially as the city stood in a plain, the entrances open, and the approaches every where level. While others represented at one time the strength of the city, greater beyond comparison than that of Pherae; at another, the approach of the winter season, unfit for any operation of war, much more so for besieging and assaulting cities. While the king's judgment was in suspense between hope and fear, his courage was raised by ambassadors happening to arrive just at the time from Pharsalus, to make surrender of their city. In the mean time Marcus Baebius had a meeting with Philip in Dassaretia; and, in conformity to their joint opinion, sent Appius Claudius to reinforce Larissa, who, making long marches through Macedonia, arrived at that summit of the mountains which overhang Gonni. The town of Gonni is twenty miles distant from Larissa, standing at the opening of the valley called Tempe. Here, by laying out his camp more widely than his numbers required, and kindling more fires than were necessary, he imposed on the enemy the opinion which he wished, that the whole Roman army was there, and king Philip along with them. Antiochus, therefore, pretending the near approach of winter as his motive, staid but one day longer, then withdrew from Larissa, and returned to Demetrias. The Aetolians and Athamanians retired to their respective countries. Appius, although he saw that, by the siege being raised, the purpose of his commission was fulfilled, yet resolved to go down to Larissa, to strengthen the resolution of the allies against future contingencies. Thus the Larissans enjoyed a twofold happiness, both because the enemy had departed from their country, and because they saw a Roman garrison within their city.

Having achieved all this within ten days of arriving at Pherae, he marched with his entire army to Cranon, which he captured as soon as he arrived. He then took Cypaera and Metropolis, along with the surrounding forts; now every town in that area was under his control, except for Atrax and Gyrton. He then decided to lay siege to Larissa, believing that (either due to fear from the capture of the other towns, or because of his decision to dismiss their garrison troops, or following the example of so many cities surrendering) they would soon give up their stubbornness. He ordered the elephants to move out in front of the battalions to create fear, and approached the city with his army in battle formation. This caused many of the Larissans to feel uncertain and torn between their fear of the enemy at their gates and their respect for their distant allies. Meanwhile, Amynander, with the Athamanian troops, captured Pellinaeus; while Menippus, with three thousand Aetolian foot soldiers and two hundred cavalry, marched into Perrhaebia, where he stormed Mallaea and Cyretiae, and plundered the lands of Tripolis. After completing these tasks quickly, they returned to the king at Larissa just as he was holding a council to discuss how to proceed regarding the city. On this occasion, there were differing opinions: some believed that force should be used, that there was no time to waste, and that the walls should be attacked immediately with siege works and machinery on all sides; especially since the city was in a plain, with open entrances and level approaches all around. Others pointed out the city's strength, which was far greater than that of Pherae, and mentioned the upcoming winter season, unsuitable for any military operations, much less for laying siege and assaulting cities. While the king wavered between hope and fear, his spirits were lifted by the arrival of ambassadors from Pharsalus, seeking to surrender their city. Meanwhile, Marcus Baebius met with Philip in Dassaretia; and in accordance with their joint decision, sent Appius Claudius to reinforce Larissa. Appius, after making long marches through Macedonia, reached the peak of the mountains overlooking Gonni. The town of Gonni is twenty miles from Larissa, located at the entrance to the valley called Tempe. Here, by expanding his camp more than necessary for his numbers, and lighting more fires than required, he led the enemy to believe that the entire Roman army was present, along with King Philip. Therefore, Antiochus, citing the imminent winter as his reason, stayed just one more day, then withdrew from Larissa and returned to Demetrias. The Aetolians and Athamanians returned to their own lands. Although Appius saw that the lifting of the siege fulfilled his mission, he decided to go to Larissa to strengthen the resolve of the allies against future challenges. Thus, the Larissans experienced a twofold happiness, not only because the enemy had left their land but also because they now had a Roman garrison in their city.

11

Antiochus went from Demetrias to Chalcis, where he became captivated with a young woman, daughter of Cleoptolemus. When he had plied her father, who was unwilling to connect himself with a condition in life involving such serious consequences, first by messages, and afterwards by personal importunities, and had at length gained his consent; he celebrated his nuptials in the same manner as if it were a time of profound peace. Forgetting the two important undertakings in which he was at once engaged,--the war with Rome, and the liberating of Greece,--he banished every thought of business from his mind, and spent the remainder of winter in feasting and the pleasures connected with wine; and then in sleep, produced rather by fatigue than by satiety with these things. The same spirit of dissipation seized all his officers who commanded in the several winter quarters, particularly those stationed in Boeotia, and even the common men abandoned themselves to the same indulgences; not one of whom ever put on his armour, or kept watch or guard, or did any part of the duty or business of a soldier. When, therefore, in the beginning of spring, the king came through Phocis to Chaeronea, where he had appointed the general assembly of all the troops, he perceived at once that the soldiers had spent the winter under discipline no more rigid than that of their commander. He ordered Alexander, an Acarnanian and Menippus, a Macedonian, to lead his forces thence to Stratum, in Aetolia; and he himself, after offering sacrifice to Apollo at Delphi, proceeded to Naupactum. After holding a council of the chiefs of Aetolia, he went by the road which leads by Chalcis and Lysimachia to Stratum, to meet his army, which was coming along the Malian bay. Here Mnasilochus, a man of distinction among the Acarnanians, being bribed by many presents, not only laboured himself to dispose that nation in favour of the king, but had brought to a concurrence in the design their praetor, Clytus, who was at that time invested with the highest authority. This latter, finding that the people of Leucas, the capital of Acarnania, could not be easily seduced to defection, because they were afraid of the Roman fleets, one under Atilius, and another at Cephallenia, practised an artifice against them. He observed in the council, that the inland parts of Acarnania should be guarded from danger, and that all who were able to bear arms ought to march out to Medio and Thurium, to prevent those places from being seized by Antiochus, or the Aetolians; on which there were some who said, that there were no necessity for all the people to be called out in that hasty manner, for a body of five hundred men would be sufficient for the purpose. Having got this number of soldiers at his disposal, he placed three hundred in garrison at Medio, and two hundred at Thurium, with the design that they should fall into the hands of the king, and serve hereafter as hostages.

Antiochus traveled from Demetrias to Chalcis, where he became infatuated with a young woman, the daughter of Cleoptolemus. After trying to win over her father, who was hesitant to connect himself with a situation that could lead to serious consequences, first with messages and then through personal appeals, he finally got his approval. He celebrated his wedding as if it were a time of complete peace. Forgetting about his two major commitments—the war with Rome and the liberation of Greece—he set aside all thoughts of business and spent the rest of the winter feasting and enjoying wine, followed by sleep, which came more from exhaustion than from excess. This same spirit of indulgence took hold of all his officers stationed in the various winter quarters, especially those in Boeotia, and even the common soldiers indulged in the same pleasures; none of them put on their armor, kept watch, or did any of the duties of a soldier. So when spring began, and the king arrived through Phocis to Chaeronea, where he had called a general assembly of all the troops, he immediately noticed that the soldiers had spent the winter with the same lax discipline as their commander. He ordered Alexander, an Acarnanian, and Menippus, a Macedonian, to lead his forces from there to Stratum in Aetolia; and after offering sacrifices to Apollo at Delphi, he headed to Naupactum. After consulting with the leaders of Aetolia, he took the route that goes past Chalcis and Lysimachia to Stratum to meet his army, which was approaching along the Malian bay. Here, Mnasilochus, a notable figure among the Acarnanians, was bribed with many gifts and not only worked to persuade his people to support the king but also got their praetor, Clytus, who was at that time in a position of great authority, to agree to the plan. This latter, realizing that the people of Leucas, the capital of Acarnania, couldn't easily be swayed to defect due to their fear of the Roman fleets—one led by Atilius and another at Cephallenia—devised a trick against them. He argued in the council that the inland areas of Acarnania needed to be protected and that all able-bodied men should march out to Medio and Thurium to prevent those places from being taken by Antiochus or the Aetolians. Some argued that there was no need to call out all the people so urgently, as a group of five hundred men would be enough for the task. With this number of soldiers at his disposal, he stationed three hundred at Medio and two hundred at Thurium, intending for them to fall into the hands of the king and serve as hostages later on.

12

At this time, ambassadors from the king came to Medio, whose proposal being heard, the assembly began to consider what answer should be returned to the king; when some advised to adhere to the alliance with Rome, and others, not to reject the friendship of the king; but Clitus offered an opinion, which seemed to take a middle course between the other two, and which was therefore adopted. It was, that ambassadors should be sent to the king, to request of him to allow the people of Medio to deliberate on a subject of such great importance in a general assembly of the Acarnanians. Mnasilochus, and some others of his faction, were studiously included in this embassy; who, sending private messengers to desire the king to bring up his army, wasted time on purpose; so that the ambassadors had scarcely set out, when Antiochus appeared in the territory, and presently at the gates of the city; and, while those who were not concerned in the plot were all in hurry and confusion, and hastily called the young men to arms, he was conducted into the place by Clitus and Mnasilochus. One party of the citizens now joined him through inclination, and those who were of different sentiments were compelled by fear to attend him. He then calmed their apprehensions by a discourse full of mildness; and in the hope of experiencing his clemency, which was reported abroad, several of the states of Acarnania went over to his side. From Medio he went to Thurium, whither he had sent on before him the same Mnasilochus, and his colleagues in the embassy. But the detection of the treachery practised at Medio rendered the Thurians more cautious, but not more timid. They answered him explicitly, that they would form no new alliance without the approbation of the Romans: they then shut their gates, and posted soldiers on the walls. Most seasonably for confirming the resolution of the Acarnanians, Cneius Octavius, being sent by Quinctius, and having received a party of men and a few ships from Aulus Postumius, whom Atilius had appointed his lieutenant to command at Cephallenia, arrived at Leucas, and filled the allies with hope; assuring them, that the consul Manius Acilius had already crossed the sea with his legions, and that the Roman camp was in Thessaly. As the season of the year, which was by this time favourable for sailing, strengthened the credibility of this report, the king, after placing a garrison in Medio and borne other towns of Acarnania, retired from Thurium and returned through the cities of Aetolia and Phocis to Chalcis.

At this time, ambassadors from the king arrived in Medio. After hearing their proposal, the assembly began to discuss how to respond to the king. Some members suggested sticking with the alliance with Rome, while others advised against rejecting the king’s friendship. Clitus offered a compromise that seemed to balance both sides, and it was accepted. His suggestion was to send ambassadors to the king, asking for permission for the people of Medio to discuss such an important matter in a general assembly of the Acarnanians. Mnasilochus and some of his allies were intentionally included in this delegation. They secretly sent messages to the king, urging him to bring his army, deliberately wasting time. Just as the ambassadors set out, Antiochus appeared in the territory and soon at the city gates. While those unaware of the plot were in a state of panic and hurriedly called the young men to arms, he was escorted into the city by Clitus and Mnasilochus. Some citizens joined him willingly, while others, who disagreed with him, felt forced to do so out of fear. He calmed their fears with a gentle speech, and hoping to experience his reported mercy, several Acarnanian states joined his side. After leaving Medio, he went to Thurium, where he had previously sent Mnasilochus and his fellow ambassadors. However, the discovery of the betrayal in Medio made the Thurians more cautious, though not afraid. They firmly told him that they wouldn’t enter a new alliance without Roman approval, then shut their gates and stationed soldiers on the walls. Just in time to reinforce the Acarnanians' resolve, Cneius Octavius, sent by Quinctius and reinforced by a group of men and a few ships from Aulus Postumius—the lieutenant commander at Cephallenia appointed by Atilius—arrived at Leucas, bringing hope to the allies. He assured them that Consul Manius Acilius had already crossed the sea with his legions and that the Roman camp was in Thessaly. Since the time of year was now favorable for sailing, which lent credibility to this news, the king placed a garrison in Medio and other towns of Acarnania before retreating from Thurium and returning through the cities of Aetolia and Phocis to Chalcis.

13

About the same time, Marcus Baebius and king Philip, after the meeting which they had in the winter in Dassaretia, when they sent Appius Claudius into Thessaly to raise the siege of Larissa, had returned to winter quarters, the season not being sufficiently advanced for entering on action; but now in the beginning of spring, they united their forces, and marched into Thessaly. Antiochus was then in Acarnania. As soon as they entered that country, Philip laid siege to Mallaea, in the territory of Perrhaebia, and Baebius, to Phacium. This town of Phacium he took almost at the first attempt, and then reduced Phaestus with the same rapidity. After this, he retired to Atrax; and from thence having seized on Cyretiae and Eritium, and placed garrisons in the places which he had reduced, he again joined Philip, who was carrying on the siege of Mallaea. On the arrival of the Roman army, the garrison, either awed by its strength, or hoping for pardon, surrendered themselves, and the combined forces marched, in one body, to recover the towns which had been seized by the Athamanians. These were Aeginium, Ericinum, Gomphi, Silana, Tricca, Meliboea, and Phaloria. Then they invested Pellinaeum, where Philip of Megalopolis was in garrison, with five hundred foot and forty horse; but before they made an assault, they sent messengers to warn Philip not to expose himself to the last extremities; to which he answered, with much confidence, that he could intrust himself either to the Romans or the Thessalians, but never would put himself in the power of the Macedonian. When it appeared that recourse must be had to force, and that Limnaea might be attacked at the same time; it was agreed, that the king should go against Limnaea, while Baebius staid to carry on the siege of Pellinaeum.

Around the same time, Marcus Baebius and King Philip, after their meeting during the winter in Dassaretia, where they sent Appius Claudius to Thessaly to lift the siege of Larissa, had returned to their winter quarters since the season wasn’t yet suitable for military action. But now at the start of spring, they combined their forces and marched into Thessaly. Antiochus was in Acarnania at that time. Once they entered the region, Philip laid siege to Mallaea, in the territory of Perrhaebia, while Baebius targeted Phacium. He captured Phacium almost on his first attempt, then quickly took Phaestus as well. After that, he pulled back to Atrax; from there, he seized Cyretiae and Eritium, placing garrisons in the towns he had conquered, and then rejoined Philip, who was still besieging Mallaea. When the Roman army arrived, the garrison, either intimidated by their strength or hoping for mercy, surrendered. The combined forces then marched together to reclaim the towns that had been taken by the Athamanians, which included Aeginium, Ericinum, Gomphi, Silana, Tricca, Meliboea, and Phaloria. They subsequently besieged Pellinaeum, where Philip of Megalopolis was stationed with five hundred infantry and forty cavalry. However, before they launched an attack, they sent messengers to warn Philip not to put himself in a desperate situation; he confidently replied that he could trust either the Romans or the Thessalians, but would never place himself at the mercy of the Macedonians. When it became clear that they would need to use force, and that Limnaea could be attacked simultaneously, it was decided that the king would go against Limnaea while Baebius stayed behind to continue the siege of Pellinaeum.

14

It happened that, just at this time, the consul, Manius Acilius, having crossed the sea with twenty thousand foot, two thousand horse, and fifteen elephants, ordered some military tribunes, chosen for the purpose, to lead the infantry to Larissa, and he himself with the cavalry came to Limnaea, to Philip. Immediately on the consul's arrival a surrender was made without hesitation, and the king's garrison, together with the Athamanians, were delivered up. From Limnaea the consul went to Pellinaeum. Here the Athamanians surrendered first, and afterwards Philip of Megalopolis. King Philip, happening to meet the latter as he was coming out from the town, ordered his attendants, in derision, to salute him with the title of king; and he himself, coming up to him, with a sneer, highly unbecoming his own exalted station, addressed him as Brother. Having been brought before the consul he was ordered to be kept in confinement, and soon after was sent to Rome in chains. All the rest of the Athamanians, together with the soldiers of king Antiochus, who had been in garrison in the towns which surrendered about that time, were delivered over to Philip. They amounted to three thousand men. The consul went thence to Larissa, in order to hold a consultation on the general plan of operations; and on his way was met by ambassadors from Pieria and Metropolis, with the surrender of those cities. Philip treated the captured, particularly the Athamanians, with great kindness, in order that through them he might conciliate their countrymen; and having hence conceived hopes of getting Athamania into his possession, he first sent forward the prisoners to their respective states, and then marched his army thither. These also, making mention of the king's clemency and generosity towards them, exerted a powerful influence on the minds of their fellow-countrymen; and Amynander, who, by his presence, had retained many in obedience, through the respect paid to his dignity, began now to dread that he might be delivered up to Philip, who had been long his professed enemy, or to the Romans, who were justly incensed against him for his late defection. He, therefore, with his wife and children, quitted the kingdom, and retired to Ambracia. Thus all Athamania came under the authority and dominion of Philip. The consul delayed a few days at Larissa, for the purpose chiefly of refreshing the horses, which, by the voyage first, and marching afterwards, had been much harassed and fatigued; and when he had renewed the vigour of his army by a moderate share of rest, he marched to Cranon. On his way, Pharsalus, Scotussa, and Pherae were surrendered to him, together with the garrisons placed in them by Antiochus. He asked these men whether any of them chose to remain with him; and one thousand having declared themselves willing, he gave them to Philip; the rest he sent back, unarmed, to Demetrias. After this he took Proerna, and the forts adjacent; and then began to march forwards toward the Malian bay. When he drew near to the pass on which Thaumaci is situated, all the young men of that place, having taken arms and quitted the town, placed themselves in ambush in the woods and roads, and thence, from the higher grounds, made attacks on the Roman troops as they marched. The consul first sent people to talk with them from a short distance, and deter them from such a mad proceeding; but, finding that they persisted in their undertaking, he sent round a tribune, with two companies of soldiers, to cut off the retreat of the men in arms, and took possession of the defenceless city. The shouting on the capture of the city having been heard from behind, a great slaughter was made of those who had been in ambuscade, and who fled homewards from all parts of the woods. From Thaumaci the consul came, on the second day, to the river Spercheus; and, sending out parties, laid waste the country of the Hypataeans.

It just so happened that at that time, the consul, Manius Acilius, crossed the sea with twenty thousand foot soldiers, two thousand cavalry, and fifteen elephants. He ordered some military tribunes, selected for the task, to lead the infantry to Larissa, while he himself went to Limnaea with the cavalry to meet Philip. As soon as the consul arrived, there was an immediate surrender, and the king’s garrison along with the Athamanians were handed over. From Limnaea, the consul went to Pellinaeum. Here, the Athamanians surrendered first, followed by Philip of Megalopolis. When King Philip encountered him coming out of the town, he mockingly instructed his attendants to greet him as king; then, with a sneer that was quite unbecoming for someone of his stature, he addressed him as Brother. Once brought before the consul, he was ordered to be kept in confinement and was soon sent to Rome in chains. All the other Athamanians, along with the soldiers of King Antiochus, who had been garrisoned in the towns that surrendered around that time, were turned over to Philip. They numbered three thousand men. The consul then went to Larissa to consult on the overall strategy; on his way, he was met by ambassadors from Pieria and Metropolis, who offered the surrender of those cities. Philip treated the captured, especially the Athamanians, very kindly to win over their fellow countrymen. He hoped to gain control of Athamania, so he first sent the prisoners back to their own territories and then marched his army there. These prisoners, mentioning the king’s mercy and kindness, powerfully influenced the opinions of their fellow citizens. Amynander, who by his presence had kept many loyal due to the respect for his position, now feared he might be handed over to Philip, his long-time enemy, or to the Romans, who were justifiably angry with him for his recent betrayal. So, he left the kingdom with his wife and children and retreated to Ambracia. Thus, all of Athamania came under Philip’s authority. The consul stayed a few days in Larissa mainly to rest the horses, which had been greatly stressed and worn out from the voyage and the subsequent march. After giving his army some necessary rest, he marched to Cranon. On the way, Pharsalus, Scotussa, and Pherae surrendered to him, along with the garrisons stationed there by Antiochus. He asked these men if any of them wanted to stay with him; one thousand chose to stay, and he handed them over to Philip while sending the others back, unarmed, to Demetrias. After this, he captured Proerna and the nearby forts, then began marching toward the Malian bay. As he approached the pass where Thaumaci is located, all the young men from the area armed themselves and left the town to ambush the Roman troops from the woods and higher ground. The consul first sent some people to talk to them from a distance, hoping to dissuade them from such reckless behavior; but when he saw they were determined, he sent a tribune with two companies of soldiers to cut off their retreat and took control of the defenseless city. The shouts from the captured city could be heard from behind, leading to a great slaughter of those in ambush who fled from all parts of the woods. After leaving Thaumaci, the consul reached the river Spercheus the next day and sent out parties to devastate the lands of the Hypataeans.

15

During these transactions, Antiochus was at Chalcis; and now, perceiving that he had gained nothing from Greece agreeable, except winter quarters and a disgraceful marriage at Chalcis, he warmly blamed Thoas, and the fallacious promises of the Aetolians; while he admired Hannibal, not only as a prudent man, but as the predicter of all those events which were then transpiring. However, that he might not still further defeat his inconsiderate enterprise by his own inactivity, he sent requisitions to the Aetolians, to arm all their young men, and assemble in a body at Lamia. He himself also immediately led thither about ten thousand foot (the number having been filled up out of the troops which had come after him from Asia) and five hundred horse. Their assembly on this occasion was far less numerous than ever before, none attending but the chiefs with a few of their vassals. These affirmed that they had, with the utmost diligence, tried every method to bring into the field as great a number as possible out of their respective states, but that they had not prevailed either by argument, persuasion, or authority, against those who declined the service. Being disappointed thus on all sides, both by his own people, who delayed in Asia, and by his allies, who did not fulfil those engagements by which they had prevailed on him to comply with their invitation, the king retired beyond the pass of Thermopylae. A range of mountains here divides Greece in the same manner as Italy is divided by the ridge of the Apennines. Outside the strait of Thermopylae, towards the north, lie Epirus, Perrhaebia, Magnesia, Thessaly, the Achaean Phthiotis, and the Malian bay; on the inside, towards the south, the greater part of Aetolia, Acarnania, Phocis, Locris, Boeotia, and the adjacent island of Euboea, the territory of Attica, which stretches out like a promontory into the sea, and, behind that, the Peloponnesus. This range of mountains, which extends from Leucas and the sea on the west, through Aetolia to the opposite sea on the east, is so closely covered with thickets and craggy rocks, that, not to speak of an army, even persons lightly equipped for travelling can with difficulty find paths through which they can pass. The hills at the eastern extremity are called Oeta, and the highest of them Callidromus; in a valley, at the foot of which, reaching to the Malian bay, is a passage not broader than sixty paces. This is the only military road by which an army can be led, even if it should not be opposed. The place is therefore called Pylae, the gate; and by some, on account of a warm spring, rising just at the entrance of it, Thermopylae. It is rendered famous by the memorable battle of the Lacedaemonians against the Persians, and by their still more glorious death.

During these events, Antiochus was in Chalcis. Realizing he gained nothing beneficial from Greece aside from a place to stay for the winter and an embarrassing marriage in Chalcis, he strongly criticized Thoas and the misleading promises of the Aetolians. At the same time, he respected Hannibal, not only for being wise but also for predicting all the events unfolding at that moment. However, to avoid further sabotaging his reckless campaign through inaction, he sent requests to the Aetolians to enlist all their young men and gather them at Lamia. He also immediately led about ten thousand infantry (the number made up of troops that had followed him from Asia) and five hundred cavalry. The turnout was much smaller than ever before, with only the leaders and a few of their followers present. They insisted they had done everything possible to gather as many men as they could from their districts but had failed to convince those who were unwilling to serve through argument, persuasion, or authority. Disappointed by both his own people, who hesitated in Asia, and by his allies, who did not honor the commitments that had convinced him to respond to their call, the king retreated beyond the Thermopylae pass. A mountain range here separates Greece in much the same way that the Apennines divide Italy. On the northern side of the Thermopylae strait lies Epirus, Perrhaebia, Magnesia, Thessaly, Achaean Phthiotis, and the Malian bay; while on the southern side, you find most of Aetolia, Acarnania, Phocis, Locris, Boeotia, the nearby island of Euboea, and the region of Attica, which extends like a promontory into the sea, with the Peloponnesus behind it. This mountain range stretches from Leucas and the sea on the west through Aetolia to the opposite sea on the east, densely covered with bushes and jagged rocks, making it difficult for even lightly equipped travelers to find paths. The hills at the eastern end are called Oeta, with the tallest being Callidromus; at the base of one such hill, leading to the Malian bay, there’s a passage not wider than sixty paces. This is the only military route an army can take, even if there’s no opposition. Thus, the area is referred to as Pylae, the gate; and by some, due to a warm spring that rises right at the entrance, Thermopylae. It became famous for the notable battle of the Spartans against the Persians and their even more heroic death.

16

With a very inferior portion of spirit, Antiochus now pitched his camp within the enclosures of this pass, the difficulties of which he increased by raising fortifications; and when he had completely strengthened every part with a double rampart and trench, and, wherever it seemed requisite, with a wall formed of the stones which lay scattered about in abundance, being very confident that the Roman army would never attempt to force a passage there, he sent away one half of the four thousand Aetolians, the number that had joined him, to garrison Heraclea, which stood opposite the entrance of the defile, and the other half to Hypata; for he concluded, that the consul would undoubtedly attack Heraclea, and he received accounts from many hands, that all the districts round Hypata were being laid waste. The consul, after ravaging the lands of Hypata first, and then those of Heraclea, in both which places the Aetolian detachments proved useless, encamped opposite to the king, in the very entrance of the pass, near the warm springs; both parties of the Aetolians shutting themselves up in Heraclea. Antiochus, who, before he saw the enemy, thought every spot perfectly well fortified, and secured by guards, now began to apprehend, that the Romans might discover some paths among the hills above, through which they could make their way; for he had heard that the Lacedaemonians formerly had been surrounded in that manner by the Persians, and Philip, lately, by the Romans themselves. He therefore despatched a messenger to the Aetolians at Heraclea, desiring them to afford him so much assistance, at least in the war, as to seize and secure the tops of the hills, so that the Romans might not be able to pass them at any part. When this message was received, a dissension arose among the Aetolians: some insisted that they ought to obey the king's orders, and go; others, that they ought to lie still at Heraclea, and wait the issue, whatever it might be; for if the king should be defeated by the consul, their forces would be fresh, and in readiness to carry succour to their own states in the neighbourhood; and if he were victorious, they could pursue the Romans, while scattered in their flight. Each party not only adhered positively to its own plan, but even carried it into execution; two thousand lay still at Heraclea; and two thousand, divided into three parties, took possession of the summits called Callidromus, Rhoduntia, and Tichiuns.

With a much weaker spirit, Antiochus set up his camp in the enclosures of this pass, making things harder by building fortifications. After he completely reinforced every section with a double wall and trench, and wherever necessary, a wall made from the plenty of stones scattered around, he was quite sure that the Roman army would never try to break through there. He sent away half of the four thousand Aetolians who had joined him to garrison Heraclea, which faced the entrance of the defile, and the other half to Hypata, believing that the consul would definitely attack Heraclea. He also received reports from several sources that all the surrounding areas around Hypata were being devastated. The consul, after destroying the lands of Hypata first and then those of Heraclea, where the Aetolian units were ineffective, camped opposite the king at the very entrance of the pass, near the hot springs, while both groups of Aetolians barricaded themselves in Heraclea. Antiochus, who had thought every spot was well fortified and guarded before seeing the enemy, now started to worry that the Romans might find some paths among the hills above to get through, remembering how the Lacedaemonians had been surrounded by the Persians and how Philip had recently been surrounded by the Romans themselves. Therefore, he sent a messenger to the Aetolians at Heraclea, asking them to help by taking control of the hilltops so that the Romans wouldn’t be able to cross at any point. When this message arrived, a disagreement broke out among the Aetolians: some argued that they should follow the king’s orders and go, while others believed they should stay in Heraclea and wait to see what would happen. They reasoned that if the king were defeated by the consul, their forces would be fresh and ready to assist their nearby states; but if he won, they could chase the Romans while they were scattered in flight. Each group not only stuck to its own plan but also acted on it; two thousand stayed put in Heraclea, while two thousand, divided into three groups, took control of the peaks known as Callidromus, Rhoduntia, and Tichiuns.

17

When the consul saw that the heights were possessed by the Aetolians, he sent against those posts two men of consular rank, who acted as lieutenant-generals, with two thousand chosen troops;--Lucius Valerius Flaccus against Rhoduntia and Tichiuns, and Marcus Porcius Cato against Callidromus. Then, before he led on his forces against the enemy, he called them to an assembly, and thus briefly addressed them: "Soldiers, I see that the greater part of you who were present, of all ranks, are men who served in this same province, under the conduct and auspices of Titus Quinctius. Now, in the Macedonian war, the pass at the river Aous was much more difficult than this before us. For this is only a gate, a single passage, formed as it were by nature; every other in the whole tract, between the two seas, being impassable. In the former case, there were stronger fortifications, and placed in more advantageous situations. The enemy's army was both more numerous, and composed of very superior men; for they were Macedonians, Thracians, and Illyrians,--all nations of the fiercest spirit; your present opponents are Syrians, and Asiatic Greeks, the most unsteady of men, and born for slavery. The commander, there, was a king of extraordinary warlike abilities, improved by practice from his early youth, in wars against his neighbours, the Thracians and Illyrians, and all the adjoining nations. But this man is one who (to say nothing of his former life) after coming over from Asia into Europe to make war on the Roman people, has, during the whole length of the winter, accomplished no more memorable exploit, than the taking a wife, for passion's sake, out of a private house, and a family obscure even among its neighbours; and now as a newly married man, surfeited as it were with nuptial feasts, comes out to fight. His chief reliance and strength was in the Aetolians,--a nation of all others the most faithless and ungrateful, as you have formerly experienced, and as Antiochus now experiences; for they neither joined him with numbers, nor could they be kept in the camp; and, besides, they are now in a state of dissension among themselves. Although they requested permission to defend Hypata and Heraclea, yet they defended neither; but one half of them fled to the tops of the mountains, while the others shut themselves up in Heraclea. The king himself, plainly confessing that, so far from daring to meet us in battle on the level plain, he durst not even encamp in open ground, has abandoned all that tract in front, which he boasted of having taken from us and Philip, and has hid himself behind the rocks; not even appearing in the opening of the pass, as it is said the Lacedaemonians did formerly, but drawing back his camp completely within it. What difference is there, as a demonstration of fear, between this and his shutting himself up within the walls of a city to stand a siege? But neither shall the straits protect Antiochus, nor the hills which they have seized, the Aetolians. Sufficient care and precaution have been used on every quarter, that you shall have nothing to contend with in the fight but the enemy himself. On your parts, you have to consider, that you are not fighting merely for the liberty of Greece; although, were that all, it would be an achievement highly meritorious to deliver that country now from Antiochus and the Aetolians, which you formerly delivered from Philip; and that the wealth in the king's camp will not be the whole prize of your labour; but that the great collection of stores, daily expected from Ephesus, will likewise become your prey; and also, that you will open a way for the Roman power into Asia and Syria, and all the most opulent realms to the extremity of the East. What then must be the consequence, but that, from Gades to the Red Sea, we shall have no limit but the ocean, which encircles in its embrace the whole orb of the earth; and that all mankind shall regard the Roman name with a degree of veneration next to that which they pay to the divinities? For the attainment of prizes of such magnitude, prepare a spirit adequate to the occasion, that, to-morrow, with the aid of the gods, we may decide the matter in the field."

When the consul saw that the Aetolians had taken the high ground, he sent two consuls, acting as lieutenant-generals, with two thousand elite troops to those positions; Lucius Valerius Flaccus against Rhoduntia and Tichiuns, and Marcus Porcius Cato against Callidromus. Before leading his forces into battle, he called an assembly and addressed them briefly: "Soldiers, I notice that most of you here, from all ranks, served in this same region under Titus Quinctius. In the Macedonian war, the pass at the river Aous was much tougher than what we face now. This is just a gate, a single natural passage; every other route in the entire area between the two seas is impassable. Back then, there were stronger fortifications in better spots. The enemy's army was larger and made up of much better soldiers; they were Macedonians, Thracians, and Illyrians—all fierce nations. Your current opponents are Syrians and Asiatic Greeks, the most unreliable and servile people. The commander then was a king with exceptional military skills honed from a young age in wars against neighbors like the Thracians and Illyrians. But this man—without mentioning his past—has come over from Asia to wage war against the Romans and, throughout the winter, has achieved nothing noteworthy except marrying out of passion a woman from a family so obscure that even their neighbors barely know them; and now, as a newlywed, he comes out to fight, overindulged in wedding feasts. His main support is the Aetolians, a notoriously treacherous and ungrateful nation, as you have experienced before and as Antiochus is finding out now; they didn’t join him in sufficient numbers and couldn’t be kept in camp, and currently, they are bickering among themselves. Although they asked to defend Hypata and Heraclea, they did neither; half of them ran to the mountaintops while the others locked themselves inside Heraclea. The king himself, clearly admitting that he doesn’t have the courage to face us on the open plain, doesn’t dare even to camp outdoors. He has given up all the territory he claimed to have taken from us and Philip and has hidden behind the rocks, not even appearing in the pass as the Lacedaemonians once did; instead, he has retreated his camp entirely within it. What’s the difference in showing fear between this and locking himself behind the city walls to withstand a siege? But neither will the straits save Antiochus, nor will the hills the Aetolians hold. Every precaution has been taken so that you fight only the enemy. You should remember that you’re not just fighting for Greece's freedom; even if that were all, it would still be a great achievement to free this country from Antiochus and the Aetolians, just like you did from Philip before. The wealth in the king's camp isn't the only reward for your efforts; the large supply expected from Ephesus will also be yours; plus, you will pave the way for Roman power into Asia and Syria, and all the rich lands at the far East. So what will the outcome be? From Gades to the Red Sea, we will have no limit but the ocean that surrounds the entire world; and mankind will view the Roman name with a kind of reverence just below that given to the divine. To attain such enormous rewards, prepare yourselves to rise to the occasion so that tomorrow, with the gods' help, we can settle this in battle."

18

After this discourse he dismissed the soldiers, who, before they went to their repast, got ready their armour and weapons. At the first dawn, the signal of battle being displayed, the consul formed his troops with a narrow front, adapted to the nature and the straitness of the ground. When the king saw the enemy's standards in motion, he likewise drew out his forces. He placed in the van, before the rampart, a part of his light infantry; and behind them, as a support, close to the fortifications, the main strength of his Macedonians, whom they call Sarissophori. On the left wing of these, at the foot of the mountain, he posted a body of javelin-bearers, archers, and slingers; that from the higher ground they might annoy the naked flank of the enemy: and on the right of the Macedonians, to the extremity of the works, where the deep morasses and quicksands, stretching thence to the sea, render the place impassable, the elephants with their usual guard; in the rear of them, the cavalry; and then, with a moderate interval between, the rest of his forces as a second line. The Macedonians, posted before the rampart, for some time easily withstood the efforts which the Romans made every where to force a passage; for they received great assistance from those who poured down from the higher ground a shower of leaden balls from their slings, and of arrows, and javelins, all together. But afterwards, the enemy pressing on with greater and now irresistible force, they were obliged to give ground, and, filing off from the rear, retire within the fortification. Here, by extending their spears before them, they formed as it were a second rampart, for the rampart itself was of such a moderate height that, while it afforded to its defenders a higher situation, they at the same time, by the length of their spears, had the enemy within reach underneath. Many, inconsiderately approaching the work, were run through the body; and they must either have abandoned the attempt and retreated, or have lost very great numbers, had not Marcus Porcius come from the summit of Callidromus, whence he had dislodged the Aetolians, after killing the greater part of them. These he had surprised, quite unprepared, and mostly asleep, and now he appeared on the hill which overlooked the camp.

After this discussion, he sent the soldiers away, who, before heading to their meal, got their armor and weapons ready. At dawn, with the battle signal raised, the consul arranged his troops in a narrow formation that suited the terrain. When the king noticed the enemy's flags moving, he also lined up his forces. He placed part of his light infantry at the front, in front of the rampart, and positioned the main strength of his Macedonians, known as Sarissophori, behind them for support close to the fortifications. On the left wing, at the bottom of the mountain, he stationed a group of javelin throwers, archers, and slingers so they could target the enemy from the higher ground. On the right side of the Macedonians, at the edge of the works, where deep swamps and quicksand made the area impassable, were the elephants with their usual guard; behind them were the cavalry, and then, with a moderate gap, the rest of his forces as a second line. The Macedonians, positioned in front of the rampart, withstood the Romans' various attempts to break through for a while; they received significant support from those raining down lead balls from their slings, arrows, and javelins from higher ground. But eventually, as the enemy pressed harder with greater and now overwhelming force, they had to give ground and retreat behind the fortifications. Here, by extending their spears in front of them, they effectively created a second rampart, since the actual rampart was of such moderate height that it provided defenders with a higher position while still allowing them to reach the enemy below with the length of their spears. Many who carelessly approached the structure were impaled; they had to either abandon the attempt and fall back or face heavy losses, had it not been for Marcus Porcius, who came down from the summit of Callidromus after driving out the Aetolians, killing most of them. He surprised them, mostly unprepared and asleep, and now appeared on the hill overlooking the camp.

19

Flaccus had not met the same good fortune at Tichiuns and Rhoduntia; having failed in his attempts to approach those fastnesses. The Macedonians, and others, in the king's camp, as long as, on account of the distance, they could distinguish nothing more than a body of men in motion, thought they were the Aetolians, who, on seeing the fight, were coming to their aid. But when, on a nearer view, they knew the standards and arms, and thence discovered their mistake, they were all instantly seized with such a panic, that they threw down their arms and fled. Both the fortifications retarded the pursuers, and the narrowness of the valley through which the troops had to pass; and, above all, the circumstance that the elephants were on the rear of the enemy. These the infantry could with difficulty pass, and the cavalry could by no means do so, their horses being so frightened, that they threw one another into greater confusion than when in battle. The plundering of the camp also caused a considerable delay. But, notwithstanding all this, the Romans pursued the enemy that day as far as Scarphea, killing and taking on the way great numbers both of men and horses, and also killing such of the elephants as they could not capture; and then they returned to their camp. This had been attacked, during the time of the action, by the Aetolians who were occupying Heraclea as a garrison, but the enterprise, which certainly showed no want of boldness, was not attended with any success. The consul, at the third watch of the following night, sent forward his cavalry in pursuit of the enemy; and, as soon as day appeared, set out at the head of the legions. The king had got far before him, as he did not halt in his precipitate flight until he came to Elatia. There having collected the survivors of the battle and the retreat, he, with a very small body of half-armed men, betook himself to Chalcis. The Roman cavalry did not overtake the king himself at Elatia; but they cut off a great part of his soldiers, who either halted through weariness, or wandered out of the way through mistake, as they fled without guides through unknown roads; so that, out of the whole army, not one escaped except five hundred, who kept close about the king; and even of the ten thousand men, whom, on the authority of Polybius, we have mentioned as brought over by the king from Asia, a very trifling number got off. But what shall we say if we are to believe Valerius Antias, who records that there were in the king's army sixty thousand men, of whom forty thousand fell, and above five thousand were taken, with two hundred and thirty military standards? Of the Romans were slain in the action itself a hundred and fifty; and of the party that defended themselves against the assault of the Aetolians, not more than fifty.

Flaccus didn't have much luck at Tichiuns and Rhoduntia; he failed in his attempts to reach those strongholds. The Macedonians and others in the king's camp, as long as they could only see a moving group of people from a distance, thought they were the Aetolians coming to help. But once they got a closer look and recognized the banners and weapons, they quickly realized their mistake and panicked, dropping their weapons and fleeing. Both the fortifications slowed the pursuers, as did the narrow valley the troops had to go through; but most of all, the elephants were at the back of the enemy. The infantry had a hard time passing them, and the cavalry couldn’t get through at all since their horses were so scared that they caused more chaos than in an actual battle. The looting of the camp also created a significant delay. Still, the Romans chased the enemy that day all the way to Scarphea, killing and capturing many men and horses along the way, and they also killed some of the elephants they couldn't catch; then they returned to their camp. During the battle, the camp had been attacked by the Aetolians stationed at Heraclea, but that bold move ended in failure. The consul sent out his cavalry to pursue the enemy the next night, and as soon as dawn broke, he led the legions. The king had already gotten far ahead, not stopping in his hasty flight until he reached Elatia. There, he regrouped the survivors of the battle and the retreat, taking a small force of half-armed men to Chalcis. The Roman cavalry didn't catch the king at Elatia, but they managed to cut off a large number of his soldiers, either too tired to keep going or lost while fleeing without proper guidance through unfamiliar territory. Out of the entire army, only five hundred made it out alive, who stayed close to the king; of the ten thousand mentioned by Polybius as having come with him from Asia, only a tiny fraction escaped. But what if we consider Valerius Antias, who claimed the king's army had sixty thousand men, of whom forty thousand were killed, and more than five thousand were captured, including two hundred and thirty military standards? The Romans lost a hundred and fifty in the battle itself, and of those who defended against the Aetolian assault, only about fifty were killed.

20

As the consul was leading his army through Phocis and Boeotia, the revolted states, conscious of their defection, and dreading lest they should be exposed as enemies to the ravages of the soldiers, presented themselves at the gates of their cities, with the badges of suppliants; but the army proceeded, during the whole time, just as if they were in the country of friends, without offering violence of any sort, until they reached the territory of Coronea. Here a statue of king Antiochus, standing in the temple of Minerva Itonia, kindled their indignation, and permission was given to the soldiers to plunder the lands adjacent to the edifice. But the reflection quickly occurred, that, as the statue had been erected by a general vote of all the Boeotian states, it was unreasonable to resent it on the single district of Coronea. The soldiers were therefore immediately recalled, and the depredations stopped. The Boeotians were only reprimanded for their ungrateful behaviour to the Romans in return for such great obligations, so recently conferred. At the very time of the battle, ten ships belonging to the king, with their commander Isidorus, lay at anchor near Thronium, in the Malian bay. To them Alexander of Acarnania, being grievously wounded, made his escape, and gave an account of the unfortunate issue of the battle; on which the fleet, alarmed at the immediate danger, sailed away in haste to Cenaeus in Euboea. There Alexander died, and was buried. Three other ships, which came from Asia to the same port, on hearing the disaster which had befallen the army, returned to Ephesus. Isidorus sailed over from Cenaeus to Demetrias, supposing that the king might perhaps have directed his flight thither. About this time Aulus Atilius, commander of the Roman fleet, intercepted a large convoy of provisions going to the king, just as they had passed the strait at the island of Andros: some of the ships he sunk, and took many others. Those who were in the rear turned their course to Asia. Atilius, with the captured vessels in his train, sailed back to Piraeus, from whence he had set out, and distributed a vast quantity of corn among the Athenians and the other allies in that quarter.

As the consul led his army through Phocis and Boeotia, the rebel states, aware of their betrayal and fearing that they would be exposed to the soldiers’ wrath, showed up at their city gates with the signs of supplicants. However, the army continued on as if they were in friendly territory, not committing any violence until they reached Coronea. There, a statue of King Antiochus in the temple of Minerva Itonia sparked their anger, prompting a decision to allow the soldiers to plunder the surrounding lands. Yet, it quickly became clear that, since the statue had been erected by a general vote of all the Boeotian states, it was unfair to hold Coronea solely responsible. The soldiers were immediately ordered back, and the looting was halted. The Boeotians were only criticized for their ungratefulness to the Romans in light of the significant favors recently granted to them. At the time of the battle, ten ships owned by the king, under the command of Isidorus, were anchored near Thronium in the Malian bay. Alexander of Acarnania, who was badly wounded, managed to escape to them and reported the unfortunate outcome of the battle, causing the fleet to hastily sail to Cenaeus in Euboea out of fear for their safety. There, Alexander died and was buried. Three other ships that had come from Asia to the same port, upon hearing about the army's disaster, returned to Ephesus. Isidorus then sailed from Cenaeus to Demetrias, thinking that the king might have fled there. Around this time, Aulus Atilius, commander of the Roman fleet, intercepted a large supply convoy heading to the king as they passed through the strait near the island of Andros. He sank some of the ships and captured many others. The ships in the rear diverted back to Asia. Atilius, with the captured vessels in tow, returned to Piraeus, where he had started from, and distributed a huge amount of corn to the Athenians and other allies in the area.

21

Antiochus, quitting Chalcis before the arrival of the consul, sailed first to Tenus, and thence passed over to Ephesus. When the consul came to Chalcis, the gates were open to receive him: for Aristoteles, who commanded for the king, on hearing of his approach, had withdrawn from the city. The rest of the cities of Euboea also submitted without opposition; and peace being restored all over the island within the space of a few days, without inflicting punishment on any city, the army, which had acquired much higher praise for moderation after victory, than even for the victory itself, was led back to Thermopylae. From this place, the consul despatched Marcus Cato to Rome, that through him the senate and people might learn what had been achieved from unquestionable authority. He set sail from Creusa, a sea-port belonging to the Thespians, seated at the bottom of the Corinthian Gulf, and steered to Patrae, in Achaia. From Patrae, he coasted along the shores of Aetolia and Acarnania, as far as Corcyra, and thence he passed over to Hydruntum, in Italy. Proceeding hence, with rapid expedition, by land, he arrived on the fifth day at Rome. Having come into the city before day, he went on directly from the gate to Marcus Junius, the praetor, who, at the first dawn, assembled the senate. Here, Lucius Cornelius Scipio, who had been despatched by the consul several days before Cato, and on his arrival had heard that the latter had outstripped him, and was then in the senate, came in, just as he was giving a recital of the transactions. The two lieutenant-generals were then, by order of the senate, conducted to the assembly of the people, where they gave the same account, as in the senate, of the services performed in Aetolia. Hereupon a supplication of three days' continuance was decreed, and that the praetor should offer sacrifice to such of the gods as his judgment should direct, with forty victims of the larger kinds. About the same time, Marcus Fulvius Nobilior, who, two years before, had gone into Farther Spain, in the office of praetor, entered the city in ovation. He carried in the procession a hundred and thirty thousand silver denarii,[47] and besides the coin, twelve thousand pounds' weight of silver, and a hundred and twenty-seven pounds' weight of gold.

Antiochus left Chalcis before the consul arrived, first sailing to Tenus and then crossing over to Ephesus. When the consul got to Chalcis, the gates opened to welcome him because Aristoteles, who was in charge for the king, had withdrawn from the city upon hearing of his approach. The other cities of Euboea also surrendered without resistance, and peace was restored across the island within a few days, without punishing any city. The army, which earned more praise for their restraint after winning than for the victory itself, returned to Thermopylae. From there, the consul sent Marcus Cato to Rome so that the senate and the people could learn about their achievements from an undeniable source. He set sail from Creusa, a port belonging to the Thespians at the bottom of the Corinthian Gulf, and headed to Patrae in Achaia. From Patrae, he navigated along the shores of Aetolia and Acarnania to Corcyra, and then crossed over to Hydruntum in Italy. He quickly traveled by land from there, reaching Rome on the fifth day. Arriving in the city before dawn, he went straight from the gate to Marcus Junius, the praetor, who gathered the senate at first light. At this meeting, Lucius Cornelius Scipio, who had been sent by the consul several days before Cato and found out that Cato had arrived first and was already in the senate, walked in just as Cato was recounting the events. The two lieutenant-generals were then escorted by the senate to address the public assembly, where they gave the same account of the accomplishments in Aetolia as they had in the senate. Following this, a three-day supplication was decreed, with the praetor directed to offer sacrifices to the gods he deemed appropriate, using forty large animals. Around the same time, Marcus Fulvius Nobilior, who had gone to Farther Spain two years earlier as praetor, entered the city in celebration. In his procession, he brought in one hundred thirty thousand silver denarii, along with twelve thousand pounds of silver and one hundred twenty-seven pounds of gold.

22

The consul Manius Acilius sent on, from Thermopylae, a message to the Aetolians in Heraclea, admonishing them, "then at least, after the experience which they had of the emptiness of the king's professions, to return to their senses; and, by surrendering Heraclea, to endeavour to procure from the senate a pardon for their past madness, or error: that other Grecian states also had, during the present war, revolted from the Romans, to whom they were under the highest obligations; but that, inasmuch as, after the flight of the king, in reliance upon whom they had departed from their duty, they had not added obstinacy to their misbehaviour, they were re-admitted into friendship. In like manner, although the Aetolians had not followed in the steps of the king, but had invited him, and had been principals in the war, not auxiliaries; nevertheless, if they could bring themselves to repentance they might still insure their safety." As their answer to these suggestions showed nothing like a pacific disposition, and it was evident that the business must be determined by force of arms, and that, notwithstanding the defeat of the king, the war of Aetolia was as far from a conclusion as ever, Acilius removed his camp from Thermopylae to Heraclea; and on the same day rode on horseback entirely round the walls, in order to acquaint himself with the localities of the city. Heraclea is situated at the foot of Mount Oeta; the town itself is in the plain, but has a citadel overlooking it, which stands on an eminence of considerable height, terminated on all sides by precipices. Having examined every part which he wished to see, the consul determined to make the attack in four places at once. On the side next the river Asopus, where is also the Gymnasium, he gave the direction of the works and the assault to Lucius Valerius. He assigned to Tiberius Sempronius Longus the attack of a part of the suburbs, which was as thickly inhabited as the city itself. He appointed Marcus Baebius to act on the side opposite the Malian bay, a part where the access was far from easy; and Appius Claudius on the side next to another rivulet, called Melas; opposite to the temple of Diana. By the vigorous emulation of these the towers, rams, and other machines used in the besieging of towns, were all completed within a few days. The lands round Heraclea, naturally marshy, and abounding with tall trees, furnished timber in abundance for every kind of work; and then, as the Aetolians had fled into the city, the deserted suburbs supplied not only beams and boards, but also bricks and mortar, and stones of every size for all their various occasions.

The consul Manius Acilius sent a message from Thermopylae to the Aetolians in Heraclea, advising them, "At this point, after realizing how empty the king's promises were, you should come to your senses; by surrendering Heraclea, you could seek forgiveness from the senate for your previous mistakes. Other Greek states have also turned against the Romans during this war, despite being under significant obligation to them. However, since they didn’t cling to their bad behavior after the king fled—who they relied on for their disloyalty—they were welcomed back into friendship. Similarly, although the Aetolians didn’t just follow the king but actually invited him and played a major role in the war, if they could find it in themselves to repent, they could still ensure their safety." Since their response showed no sign of willingness to make peace, and it was clear that the matter would have to be resolved through force, Acilius moved his camp from Thermopylae to Heraclea. On the same day, he rode around the city walls to familiarize himself with the area. Heraclea is located at the base of Mount Oeta; the town itself is in the plain but has a citadel on a high point that is surrounded by cliffs. After examining everything he wanted to see, the consul decided to launch his attack in four different locations at once. On the side facing the river Asopus, where the Gymnasium is located, he assigned Lucius Valerius to lead the works and the assault. He tasked Tiberius Sempronius Longus with attacking part of the suburbs, which was as densely populated as the city. Marcus Baebius was given responsibility for the side opposite Malian bay, where access was quite difficult; and Appius Claudius was assigned to the area next to another stream called Melas, across from the temple of Diana. Thanks to their energetic efforts, the towers, rams, and other siege equipment were all ready within a few days. The lands around Heraclea, naturally marshy and filled with tall trees, provided plenty of timber for all kinds of construction; since the Aetolians had retreated into the city, the abandoned suburbs offered not just beams and boards but also bricks, mortar, and stones of various sizes for all their needs.

23

The Romans carried on the assault upon this city by means of works more than by their arms; the Aetolians, on the contrary, maintained their defence by dint of arms. For when the walls were shaken by the ram they did not, as is usual, intercept and turn aside the strokes by the help of nooses formed on ropes, but sallied out in large armed bodies, with parties carrying fire, which they threw into the works. They had likewise arched passages through the parapet, for the purpose of making sallies; and when they built up the wall anew, in the room of any part that was demolished, they left a great number of these, that they might rush out upon the enemy from many places at once. In several days at the beginning, while their strength was unimpaired, they carried on this practice in numerous parties, and with much spirit, but afterwards in smaller numbers and more languidly. For though they had a multiplicity of difficulties to struggle with, what above all things utterly consumed their vigour was the want of sleep, as the Romans, having plenty of men, relieved each other regularly in their posts; while among the Aetolians, their numbers being small, the same persons had their strength consumed by unremitting labour night and day. During a space of twenty-four days, without any time being unemployed in the conflict, their toil was kept up against the attacks carried on by the enemy in four different quarters at once. When the consul, from computing the time, and from the reports of deserters, judged that the Aetolians were thoroughly fatigued, he adopted the following plan:--At midnight he gave the signal of retreat, and drawing off all his men at once from the assault, kept them quiet in the camp until the third hour of the next day. The attacks were then renewed, and continued until midnight, when they ceased, until the third hour of the day following. The Aetolians imagined that the Romans suspended the attack from the same cause by which they felt themselves distressed,--excessive fatigue. As soon, therefore, as the signal of retreat was given to the Romans, as if themselves were thereby recalled from duty, every one gladly retired from his post, nor did they again appear in arms on the walls before the third hour of the day.

The Romans attacked this city more through their strategies than their weapons; the Aetolians, on the other hand, defended themselves with weaponry. When the walls were hit by the battering ram, they didn’t usually try to intercept and deflect the blows with ropes and nooses, but instead charged out in large groups of armed soldiers, with some carrying fire to throw at the Romans’ structures. They also built arched passages through the parapet to make counterattacks easier, and when they reconstructed any parts of the wall that had been destroyed, they left plenty of these passages so they could charge out at the enemy from multiple locations at once. In the early days, while they still had the energy, they pursued this tactic energetically in many groups, but later on, they had to fight in smaller units and with less enthusiasm. The main issue that drained their strength was lack of sleep; the Romans had plenty of men to rotate, but the Aetolians had a small force, which meant the same soldiers were worn out from constant work day and night. For twenty-four consecutive days, they kept fighting against the Romans’ attacks from four different directions without any break. When the consul figured the time and learned from deserters that the Aetolians were exhausted, he came up with a plan: at midnight, he ordered a retreat and pulled all his men away from the fight, keeping them calm in camp until the third hour of the next day. They then resumed the attacks, which continued until midnight, then stopped until the third hour the following day. The Aetolians thought the Romans paused their assault for the same reason they were struggling—extreme fatigue. So, as soon as the Romans received the retreat signal, as if they were being dismissed, everyone happily left their posts, and they didn’t return to the walls until the third hour of the day.

24

The consul having put a stop to the assault at midnight, renewed it on three of the sides, at the fourth watch, with the utmost vigour; ordering Tiberius Sempronius, on the fourth, to keep his party alert, and ready to obey his signal; for he concluded assuredly, that in the tumult by night the enemy would all run to those quarters whence the shouting was heard. Of the Aetolians, such as had gone to rest, with difficulty roused their bodies from sleep, exhausted as they were with fatigue and watching; and such as were still awake, ran in the dark to the places where they heard the noise of fighting. Meanwhile the Romans endeavoured some to climb over the ruins of the walls, through the breaches; others, to scale the walls with ladders; while the Aetolians hastened in all directions to defend the parts attacked. In one quarter, where the buildings stood outside the city, there was neither attack nor defence. A party stood ready, waiting for the signal to make an attack, but there was none within to oppose them. The day now began to dawn, and the consul gave the signal; on which the party, without any opposition, made their way into the town; some through parts that had been battered, others scaling the walls where they were entire. As soon as the Aetolians heard them raise the shout, which denoted the place being taken, they every where forsook their posts, and fled into the citadel. The victors sacked the city; the consul having given permission, not for the sake of gratifying resentment or animosity, but that the soldiers, after having been restrained from plunder in so many cities captured from the enemy, might at last, in some one place, enjoy the fruits of victory. About mid-day he recalled the troops, and dividing them into two parts, ordered one to be led round by the foot of the mountain to a rock, which was of equal height with the citadel, and seemed as if it had been broken off from it, leaving a hollow between; but the summits of these eminences are so nearly contiguous that weapons may be thrown into the citadel from the top of the other. With the other half of the troops the consul intended to march, up from the city to the citadel, and waited to receive a signal from those who were to mount the rock on the farther side. The Aetolians in the citadel could not support the shout of the party which had seized the rock, and the consequent attack of the Romans from the city; for their courage was now broken, and the place was by no means in a condition to hold out a siege of any continuance; the women, children, and great numbers of other helpless people, being crowded together in a fort, which was scarce capable of containing, much less of affording protection to such a multitude. On the first assault, therefore, they laid down their arms and submitted. Among the rest was delivered up Damocritus, chief magistrate of the Aetolians, who at the beginning of the war, when Titus Quinctius asked for a copy of the decree passed by the Aetolians for inviting Antiochus, told him, that, "in Italy, when the Aetolians were encamped there, it should be delivered to him." On account of this presumptuous insolence of his, his surrender was a matter of greater satisfaction to the victors.

The consul ended the attack at midnight but resumed it on three sides during the fourth watch with great intensity. He instructed Tiberius Sempronius to keep his troops alert and ready to respond to his signal, believing that in the chaos of the night, the enemy would rush to the areas where the shouting was heard. The Aetolians who had gone to sleep struggled to wake up, worn out from fatigue and watching; those still awake hurried in the dark toward the sounds of battle. Meanwhile, the Romans attempted to climb over the ruins of the walls through the breaches and others tried to scale the walls with ladders, while the Aetolians rushed in all directions to defend the attacked areas. In one section outside the city, there was neither an attack nor defense. A group stood ready, waiting for a signal to attack, but there was no one inside to stop them. As dawn approached, the consul gave the signal, and with no opposition, the troops entered the town—some through battered sections and others scaling intact walls. When the Aetolians heard the shout indicating that the place had been taken, they abandoned their posts and fled to the citadel. The victors looted the city; the consul allowed it not out of revenge or hatred, but so that the soldiers, who had been restrained from plundering in the many cities they had taken from the enemy, could finally enjoy the spoils of victory in at least one place. Around midday, he called back the troops and divided them into two groups, ordering one to be led along the foot of the mountain to a rock that was the same height as the citadel, appearing broken off from it, leaving a gap in between; the tops of these heights were so close that weapons could be thrown into the citadel from the top of the rock. With the other half of the troops, the consul planned to march from the city to the citadel, waiting for a signal from the group that would ascend the rock on the far side. The Aetolians in the citadel couldn't handle the shout from those who took the rock and the subsequent attack from the Romans in the city; their morale was shattered, and the location was in no shape to withstand a prolonged siege, with women, children, and many other vulnerable people crammed into a fort that could barely hold them, much less offer protection. Thus, at the first assault, they laid down their arms and surrendered. Among those captured was Damocritus, the chief magistrate of the Aetolians, who at the start of the war, when Titus Quinctius asked for a copy of the decree passed by the Aetolians inviting Antiochus, told him that it would be given to him "in Italy, when the Aetolians were camped there." Because of his arrogant insolence, his capture was particularly satisfying to the victors.

25

At the same time, while the Romans were employed in the reduction of Heraclea, Philip, by concert, besieged Lamia. He had an interview with the consul, as he was returning from Boeotia, at Thermopylae, whither he came to congratulate him and the Roman people on their successes, and to apologize for his not having taken an active part in the war, being prevented by sickness; and then they went from thence, by different routes, to lay siege to the two cities at once. The distance between these places is about seven miles; and as Lamia stands on high ground, and has an open prospect, particularly towards the region of Mount Oeta, the distance seems very short, and every thing that passes can be seen from thence. The Romans and Macedonians, with all the emulation of competitors for a prize, employed the utmost exertions, both night and day, either in the works or in fighting; but the Macedonians encountered greater difficulty on this account, that the Romans made their approaches by mounds, covered galleries, and other works, which were all above ground; whereas the Macedonians worked under ground by mines, and, in that stony soil, often met a flinty rock, which iron could not penetrate. The king, seeing that his undertaking succeeded but ill, endeavoured, by conversations with the principal inhabitants, to prevail on the townspeople to surrender the place; for he was fully persuaded, that if Heraclea should be taken first, the Lamians would then choose to surrender to the Romans rather than to him; and that the consul would take to himself the merit of relieving them from a siege. Nor was he mistaken in that opinion; for no sooner was Heraclea reduced, than a message came to him to desist from the assault; because "it was more reasonable that the Roman soldiers, who had fought the Aetolians in the field, should reap the fruits of the victory." Thus was Lamia relieved, and the misfortune of a neighbouring city proved the means of its escaping a like disaster.

At the same time, while the Romans were busy taking Heraclea, Philip was also besieging Lamia. He met with the consul as he was coming back from Boeotia at Thermopylae, where he came to congratulate him and the Roman people on their victories and to explain why he hadn’t participated in the war, as he was unwell. They then took different routes to besiege the two cities simultaneously. The distance between them is about seven miles, and since Lamia is on high ground with a clear view, especially toward Mount Oeta, the space seems very short and everything happening below can be seen. The Romans and Macedonians, like competitors vying for a prize, worked hard both day and night, either on the siege or in battles. However, the Macedonians faced more challenges because the Romans built mounds, covered galleries, and other above-ground structures, while the Macedonians dug mines and often ran into flinty rock in that stony soil, which iron couldn’t break through. The king, noticing that his plans weren't going well, tried to persuade the key inhabitants to surrender by talking to them. He believed that if Heraclea fell first, the people of Lamia would prefer to surrender to the Romans instead of him, and that the consul would claim credit for freeing them from the siege. He was right; no sooner had Heraclea fallen than he got a message urging him to stop the attack because "it was more reasonable for the Roman soldiers, who fought the Aetolians in battle, to enjoy the fruits of victory." Thus, Lamia was saved, and the misfortune of a neighboring city led to its escape from a similar fate.

26

A few days before the capture of Heraclea, the Aetolians, having assembled a council at Hypata, sent ambassadors to Antiochus, among whom was Thoas, the same who had been sent on the former occasion. Their instructions were in the first place, to request the king again to assemble his land and marine forces and cross over into Greece; and, in the next place, if any circumstance should detain him, then to send them supplies of men and money. They were to remind him, that "it concerned his dignity and his honour, not to abandon his allies; and it likewise concerned the safety of his kingdom, not to leave the Romans at full leisure, after ruining the nation of the Aetolians, to carry their whole force into Asia." What they said was true, and therefore made the deeper impression on the king; in consequence of which, he immediately supplied the ambassadors with the money requisite for the exigencies of the war, and assured them, that he would send them succours both of troops and ships. One of the ambassadors, namely, Thoas, he kept with him, by no means against his will, as he hoped that, being present, he might induce the performance of the king's promises.

A few days before Heraclea was captured, the Aetolians held a council at Hypata and sent ambassadors to Antiochus, including Thoas, who had been sent previously. Their main requests were to urge the king to gather his land and naval forces and cross into Greece, and if for any reason he couldn’t do that, to send them troops and money. They reminded him that it was important for his dignity and honor not to abandon his allies and that it was also vital for the safety of his kingdom not to let the Romans have free rein after destroying the Aetolian nation, allowing them to shift their entire force into Asia. What they said resonated truthfully, which impacted the king more deeply; as a result, he quickly provided the ambassadors with the funds needed for the war and assured them he would send troops and ships. He kept one of the ambassadors, Thoas, with him willingly, hoping that his presence would encourage the king to follow through on his promises.

27

But the loss of Heraclea entirely broke the spirits of the Aetolians; insomuch that, within a few days after they had sent ambassadors into Asia for the purpose of renewing the war, and inviting the king, they threw aside all warlike designs, and despatched deputies to the consul to sue for peace. When these began to speak, the consul, interrupting them, said, that he had other business to attend to at present; and, ordering them to return to Hypata, granted them a truce for ten days, sending with them Lucius Valerius Flaccus, to whom, he desired, whatever business they intended to have proposed to himself might be communicated, with any other that they thought proper. On their arrival at Hypata, the chiefs of the Aetolians held a consultation, at which Flaccus was present, on the method to be used in treating with the consul. They showed an inclination to begin with addressing themselves wholly to the ancient treaties, and the services which they had performed to the Roman people; on which Flaccus desired them to "speak no more of treaties, which they themselves had violated and annulled." He told them, that "they might expect more advantage from an acknowledgment of their fault, and entreaty. For their hopes of safety rested not on the merits of their cause, but on the clemency of the Roman people. That, if they acted in a suppliant manner, he would himself be a solicitor in their favour, both with the consul and with the senate at Rome; for thither also they must send ambassadors." This appeared to all the only way to safety: "to submit themselves entirely to the faith of the Romans. For, in that case, the latter would be ashamed to do injury to suppliants; while themselves would, nevertheless, retain the power of consulting their own interest, should fortune offer any thing more advantageous."

But the loss of Heraclea completely crushed the spirits of the Aetolians. Within a few days of sending ambassadors to Asia to renew the war and invite the king, they abandoned all military plans and sent delegates to the consul to ask for peace. When they started to speak, the consul interrupted them, saying he had other matters to deal with at the moment. He instructed them to return to Hypata and granted them a truce for ten days, sending Lucius Valerius Flaccus with them to communicate any proposals they might have and any other concerns they thought appropriate. When they arrived at Hypata, the Aetolian leaders held a meeting with Flaccus present to discuss how to approach the consul. They expressed a desire to focus entirely on the old treaties and the services they had provided to the Roman people. Flaccus urged them to "stop talking about treaties that they themselves had violated and canceled." He told them that "they would gain more by acknowledging their faults and pleading for mercy. Their hopes for safety didn't rely on the merits of their cause, but on the kindness of the Roman people. If they approached in a submissive manner, he would personally advocate for them with both the consul and the Senate in Rome; they would also need to send ambassadors there." Everyone agreed that this was the only path to safety: "to submit completely to the goodwill of the Romans. In that case, the Romans would feel ashamed to harm those who are pleading for help, while they would still have the ability to consider their own interests if a better opportunity presented itself."

28

When they came into the consul's presence, Phaeneas, who was at the head of the embassy, made a long speech, designed to mitigate the wrath of the conqueror by various considerations; and he concluded with saying, that "the Aetolians surrendered themselves, and all belonging to them, to the faith of the Roman people." The consul, on hearing this, said, "Aetolians, consider well whether you will yield on these terms:" and then Phaeneas produced the decree, in which the conditions were expressly mentioned. "Since then," said the consul, "you submit in this manner, I demand that, without delay, you deliver up to me Dicaearchus your countryman, Menetas the Epirot," who had, with an armed force, entered Naupactum, and compelled the inhabitants to defection; "and also Amynander, with the Athamanian chiefs, by whose advice you revolted from us." Phaeneas, almost interrupting the Roman while he was speaking, answered,--"We surrendered ourselves, not into slavery, but to your faith; and I take it for granted, that, from not being sufficiently acquainted with us, you fall into the mistake of commanding what is inconsistent with the practice of the Greeks." "Nor in truth," replied the consul, "do I much concern myself, at present, what the Aetolians may think conformable to the practice of the Greeks; while I, conformably to the practice of the Romans, exercise authority over men, who just now surrendered themselves by a decree of their own, and were, before that, conquered by my arms. Wherefore, unless my commands are quickly complied with, I order that you be put in chains." At the same time he ordered chains to be brought forth, and the lictors to surround the ambassadors. This effectually subdued the arrogance of Phaeneas and the other Aetolians; and, at length, they became sensible of their situation. Phaeneas then said, that "as to himself and his countrymen there present, they knew that his commands must be obeyed: but it was necessary that a council of the Aetolians should meet, to pass decrees accordingly; and that, for that purpose, he requested a suspension of arms for ten days." At the intercession of Flaccus on behalf of the Aetolians, this was granted, and they returned to Hypata. When Phaeneas related here, in the select council, called Apocleti, the orders which they had received, and the treatment which they had narrowly escaped; although the chiefs bemoaned their condition, nevertheless they were of opinion, that the conqueror must be obeyed, and that the Aetolians should be summoned, from all their towns, to a general assembly.

When they entered the consul's presence, Phaeneas, who led the delegation, gave a lengthy speech aimed at easing the conqueror's anger with various arguments; he ended by declaring that "the Aetolians surrender themselves and all that belongs to them to the trust of the Roman people." Upon hearing this, the consul replied, "Aetolians, think carefully about whether you will accept these terms:" and then Phaeneas presented the decree that outlined the specific conditions. "Since you are submitting in this way," said the consul, "I demand that you immediately hand over Dicaearchus, your fellow countryman, and Menetas of Epirus," who had entered Naupactum with an armed force and coerced the locals into betraying us; "and also Amynander, along with the Athamanian leaders, whose advice led to your revolt against us." Phaeneas, almost interrupting the Roman as he spoke, replied, "We surrendered ourselves, not into slavery, but to your trust; and I assume that, due to your lack of familiarity with us, you mistakenly issue commands that go against Greek customs." "In truth," the consul responded, "I’m not particularly concerned right now about what the Aetolians consider proper according to Greek customs, while I, according to Roman practice, have authority over people who just surrendered of their own accord and were previously defeated by my forces. Therefore, unless my orders are complied with quickly, I command that you be put in chains." At that, he ordered chains to be brought and for the lictors to surround the ambassadors. This effectively humbled the arrogance of Phaeneas and the other Aetolians, and they finally understood their predicament. Phaeneas then stated that "as for himself and his fellow Aetolians present, they knew they must obey his commands: but a council of the Aetolians needed to convene to pass appropriate decrees, and for that reason, he requested a ceasefire for ten days." With Flaccus interceding on behalf of the Aetolians, this was granted, and they returned to Hypata. When Phaeneas reported to the select council, called the Apocleti, the orders they had received and the trouble they had narrowly avoided; although the leaders lamented their situation, they concluded that the conqueror had to be obeyed, and that the Aetolians should be summoned from all their towns for a general assembly.

29

But when the assembled multitude heard the same account, their minds were so highly exasperated, both by the harshness of the order and the indignity offered, that, even if they had been in a pacific temper before, the violent impulse of anger which they then felt would have been sufficient to rouse them to war. Their rage was increased also by the difficulty of executing what was enjoined on them; for, "how was it possible for them, for instance, to deliver up king Amynander?" It happened, also, that a favourable prospect seemed to open to them; for Nicander, returning from king Antiochus at that juncture, filled the minds of the people with unfounded assurances, that immense preparations for war were going on both by land and sea. This man, after finishing the business of his embassy, set out on his return to Aetolia; and on the twelfth day after he embarked, reached Phalara, on the Malian bay. Having conveyed thence to Lamia the money that he had brought, he, with a few light troops, directed, in the evening, his course toward Hypata, by known paths, through the country which lay between the Roman and Macedonian camps. Here he fell in with an advanced guard of the Macedonians, and was conducted to the king, whose dinner guests had not yet separated. Philip, being told of his coming, received him as a guest, not an enemy; desired him to take a seat, and join the entertainment; and afterwards, when he dismissed the rest, detained him alone, and told him, that he had nothing to fear for himself. He censured severely the conduct of the Aetolians, in bringing, first the Romans, and afterwards Antiochus, into Greece; designs which originated in a want of judgment, and always recoiled on their own heads. But "he would forget," he said, "all past transactions, which it was easier to blame than to amend; nor would he act in such a manner as to appear to insult their misfortunes. On the other hand, it would become the Aetolians to lay aside, at length, their animosity towards him; and it would become Nicander himself, in his private capacity, to remember that day, on which he had been preserved by him." Having then appointed persons to escort him to a place of safety, Nicander arrived at Hypata, while his countrymen were consulting about the peace with Rome.

But when the gathered crowd heard the same news, they were so furious, both because of the harsh order and the disrespect they had faced, that even if they had been calm before, their intense anger was enough to push them toward war. Their anger grew even more because of how difficult it was to follow the given orders; for instance, "how could they possibly hand over King Amynander?" Additionally, a promising opportunity seemed to emerge; Nicander, returning from King Antiochus at that moment, filled the people's minds with unfounded claims that huge preparations for war were underway both on land and at sea. After completing his diplomatic mission, Nicander set out on his return to Aetolia; and on the twelfth day after he left, he arrived at Phalara, located on the Malian Bay. After transferring the money he had brought to Lamia, he, along with a few light troops, headed toward Hypata that evening, taking familiar paths through the territory between the Roman and Macedonian camps. There, he encountered an advanced guard of the Macedonians, who took him to the king, whose dinner guests had not yet left. Philip, learning of his arrival, welcomed him as a guest, not an enemy; he asked him to take a seat and join the feast; and later, after dismissing the others, kept him back alone, assuring him that he had nothing to worry about. He harshly criticized the Aetolians for bringing both the Romans and then Antiochus into Greece; decisions that stemmed from poor judgment and always backfired on them. But "he would overlook," he said, "all past actions, which are easier to criticize than to fix; nor would he behave in a way that seemed to mock their troubles. On the other hand, it would be in the Aetolians' best interests to finally put aside their hostility towards him; and it would be fitting for Nicander, in his personal capacity, to remember the day on which he had been saved by him." He then arranged for people to escort Nicander to safety, who arrived in Hypata while his fellow citizens were deliberating about peace with Rome.

30

Manius Acilius having sold, or given to the soldiers, the booty found near Heraclea, and having learned that the counsels adopted at Hypata were not of a pacific nature, but that the Aetolians had hastily assembled at Naupactum, with intention to make a stand there against the whole brunt of the war, sent forward Appius Claudius, with four thousand men, to seize the heights of the mountains, where the passes were difficult; and he himself, ascending Mount Oeta, offered sacrifices to Hercules, in the spot called Pyra,[48] because there the mortal part of the demi-god was burned. He then set out with the main body of the army, and marched all the rest of the way with tolerable ease and expedition. But when they came to Corax, a very high mountain between Callipolis and Naupactum, great numbers of the beasts of burden, together with their loads, tumbled down the precipices, and many of the men were hurt. This clearly showed with how negligent an enemy they had to do, who had not secured so difficult a pass by a guard, and so blocked up the passage; for, even as the case was, the army suffered considerably. Hence he marched down to Naupactum; and having erected a fort against the citadel, he invested the other parts of the city, dividing his forces according to the situation of the walls. Nor was the siege likely to prove less difficult and laborious than that of Heraclea.

Manius Acilius sold, or gave to the soldiers, the loot found near Heraclea. After discovering that the plans made at Hypata were not peaceful and that the Aetolians had quickly gathered at Naupactum to stand against the war, he sent Appius Claudius ahead with four thousand men to take the difficult mountain heights. Meanwhile, he climbed Mount Oeta and offered sacrifices to Hercules at a place called Pyra, where the mortal remains of the demi-god were burned. He then set out with the main army and marched the rest of the way reasonably smoothly. However, when they reached Corax, a very high mountain between Callipolis and Naupactum, many pack animals and their loads tumbled down the cliffs, injuring several men. This clearly showed how careless the enemy was for not securing such a difficult pass, which made the journey tougher for the army. He then marched down to Naupactum, built a fort against the citadel, and surrounded the other parts of the city, dividing his forces based on the layout of the walls. The siege was expected to be just as challenging and demanding as that of Heraclea.

31

At the same time, the Achaeans laid siege to Messene, in Peloponnesus, because it refused to become a member of their body: for the two states of Messene and Elis were unconnected with the Achaean confederacy, and sympathized with the Aetolians. However, the Eleans, after Antiochus had been driven out of Greece, answered the deputies, sent by the Achaeans, with more moderation: that "when the king's troops were removed, they would consider what part they should take." But the Messenians had dismissed the deputies without an answer, and prepared for war. Alarmed, afterwards, at their own situation, when they saw the enemy ravaging their country without control, and pitching their camp close to their city, they sent deputies to Chalcis, to Titus Quinctius, the author of their liberty, to acquaint him, that "the Messenians were willing, both to open their gates, and surrender their city, to the Romans, but not to the Achaeans." On hearing this Quinctius immediately set out, and despatched from Megalopolis a messenger to Diophanes, praetor of the Achaeans, requiring him to draw off his army instantly from Messene, and to come to him. Diophanes obeyed the order; raising the siege, he hastened forward himself before the army, and met Quinctius near Andania, a small town between Megalopolis and Messene. When he began to explain the reasons for commencing the siege, Quinctius, gently reproving him for undertaking a business of that importance without consulting him, ordered him to disband his forces, and not to disturb a peace which had been established advantageously to all. He commanded the Messenians to recall the exiles, and to unite themselves to the confederacy of the Achaeans; and if there were any particulars to which they chose to object, or any precautions which they judged requisite for the future, they might apply to him at Corinth. He then gave directions to Diophanes, to convene immediately a general council of the Achaeans, that he might settle some business with them.

At the same time, the Achaeans besieged Messene in Peloponnesus because it refused to join them. The states of Messene and Elis were not part of the Achaean confederacy and sided with the Aetolians. However, after Antiochus was pushed out of Greece, the Eleans responded to the Achaeans’ representatives with more restraint, saying that "once the king's troops were gone, they would consider what action to take." On the other hand, the Messenians dismissed the representatives without a reply and prepared for war. Concerned about their situation, seeing the enemy destroying their land without restraint and setting up camp close to their city, they sent representatives to Chalcis to Titus Quinctius, the one who had secured their freedom, to inform him that "the Messenians were ready to open their gates and surrender their city to the Romans, but not to the Achaeans." Upon hearing this, Quinctius immediately set out and sent a messenger from Megalopolis to Diophanes, the Achaean praetor, ordering him to withdraw his army from Messene right away and come to him. Diophanes complied; he lifted the siege and hurried ahead of his army, meeting Quinctius near Andania, a small town between Megalopolis and Messene. When he started to explain why he had initiated the siege, Quinctius gently reprimanded him for taking on such an important matter without consulting him and ordered him to disband his troops, so as not to disrupt the peace that was beneficial for everyone. He instructed the Messenians to bring back the exiles and join the Achaean confederacy, and if there were any specific concerns they wished to address or any precautions they thought necessary for the future, they could reach out to him in Corinth. He then directed Diophanes to quickly gather a general council of the Achaeans to discuss some matters with them.

32

In this assembly he complained of their having acquired possession of the island of Zacynthus by unfair means, and demanded that it should be restored to the Romans. Zacynthus had formerly belonged to Philip, king of Macedonia, and he had made it over to Amynander, on condition of his giving him leave to march an army through Athamania, into the upper part of Aetolia, on that expedition wherein he compelled the Aetolians with dejected spirits to sue for peace. Amynander gave the government of the island to Philip, the Megalopolitan; and afterwards, during the war in which he united himself with Antiochus against the Romans, having called out Philip to the duties of the campaign, he sent, as his successor, Hierocles, of Agrigentum. This man, after the flight of Antiochus from Thermopylae, and the expulsion of Amynander from Athamania by Philip, sent emissaries of his own accord to Diophanes, praetor of the Achaeans; and having bargained for a sum of money, delivered over the island to the Achaeans. This acquisition, made during the war, the Romans claimed as their own; for they said, that "it was not for Diophanes and the Achaeans that the consul Manius Acilius, and the Roman legions, fought at Thermopylae." Diophanes, in answer, sometimes apologized for himself and his nation; sometimes insisted on the justice of the proceeding. But several of the Achaeans testified that they had, from the beginning, disapproved of that business, and they now blamed the obstinacy of the praetor. Pursuant to their advice, a decree was made, that the affair should be left entirely to the disposal of Titus Quinctius. As Quinctius was severe to such as made opposition, so, when complied with, he was easily appeased. Laying aside, therefore, every thing stern in his voice and looks, he said,--"If, Achaeans, I thought the possession of that island advantageous to you, I would be the first to advise the senate and people of Rome to permit you to hold it. But as I see that a tortoise, when collected within its natural covering, is safe against blows of any kind, and whenever it thrusts out any of its limbs, it feels whatever it has thus uncovered, weak and liable to every injury: so you, in like manner, Achaeans, being enclosed on all sides by the sea, can easily unite among yourselves, and maintain by that union all that is comprehended within the limits of Peloponnesus; but whenever, through ambition of enlarging your possessions, you overstep these limits, then all that you hold beyond them is naked, and exposed to every attack." The whole assembly declaring their assent, and Diophanes not daring to give further opposition, Zacynthus was ceded to the Romans.

In this meeting, he complained about how they had unfairly taken control of the island of Zacynthus and demanded it be returned to the Romans. Zacynthus used to belong to Philip, king of Macedonia, who had handed it over to Amynander with the condition that he allow him to march an army through Athamania into the upper part of Aetolia, during the campaign that forced the Aetolians, feeling defeated, to seek peace. Amynander had given the governance of the island to Philip of Megalopolis, and later, during the war where he joined Antiochus against the Romans, he called Philip to military duty and appointed Hierocles from Agrigentum as his successor. After Antiochus fled from Thermopylae and Amynander was expelled from Athamania by Philip, this man sent envoys to Diophanes, the praetor of the Achaeans, on his own initiative; and after negotiating a sum of money, he handed over the island to the Achaeans. The Romans claimed this acquisition made during the war as theirs, arguing that "it was not for Diophanes and the Achaeans that consul Manius Acilius and the Roman legions fought at Thermopylae." Diophanes, in response, sometimes defended himself and his people; at other times, he insisted they had acted justly. However, several Achaeans testified that they had disapproved of this decision from the start and now criticized the praetor's stubbornness. Following their advice, a resolution was passed that the matter would be entirely up to Titus Quinctius. Quinctius was strict with those who opposed him, but once they complied, he was easy to placate. Setting aside all sternness in his tone and demeanor, he said, “If, Achaeans, I believed that owning that island would benefit you, I would be the first to recommend to the Senate and people of Rome that you keep it. But I see that a tortoise, when it retracts into its shell, is safe from all harm, and when it sticks out its limbs, it feels vulnerable and exposed to danger. Similarly, you Achaeans, surrounded by the sea, can easily unite among yourselves and protect everything within Peloponnesus; but when, in your ambition to expand, you go beyond those limits, everything you hold outside them becomes exposed and defenseless.” With the whole assembly agreeing and Diophanes not daring to oppose further, Zacynthus was handed over to the Romans.

33

When the consul was on his march to Naupactum, king Philip proposed, that, if it was agreeable to him, he would, in the mean time, retake those cities that had revolted from their alliance with Rome. Having obtained permission so to do, he, about this time, marched his army to Demetrias, being well aware that great distraction prevailed there; for the garrison, being destitute of all hope of succour since they were abandoned by Antiochus, and having no reliance on the Aetolians, daily and nightly expected the arrival of Philip or the Romans, whom they had most reason to dread, as these were most justly incensed against them. There was, in the place, an irregular multitude of the king's soldiers, a few of whom had been at first left there as a garrison, but the greater part had fled thither after the defeat of his army, most of them without arms, and without either strength or courage sufficient to sustain a siege. Wherefore on Philip's sending on messengers, to offer them hopes of pardon being obtainable, they answered, that their gates were open for the king. On his first entrance, several of the chiefs left the city; Eurylochus killed himself. The soldiers of Antiochus, in conformity to a stipulation, were escorted, through Macedonia and Thrace, by a body of Macedonians, and conducted to Lysimachia. There were, also, a few ships at Demetrias, under the command of Isidorus, which, together with their commander, were dismissed. Philip then reduced Dolopia, Aperantia, and several cities of Perrhaebia.

When the consul was heading to Naupactum, King Philip suggested that if it was okay with him, he would take back the cities that had rebelled against their alliance with Rome. After getting the green light, he moved his army to Demetrias, knowing there was a lot of chaos there. The garrison, having no hope of help since they were abandoned by Antiochus and not trusting the Aetolians, anxiously awaited the arrival of either Philip or the Romans, whom they had good reason to fear due to their justified anger towards them. In the area, there was a disorganized crowd of the king's soldiers; some had initially been left as a garrison, but most had fled there after his army’s defeat, and many were unarmed and lacking the strength or courage to withstand a siege. So, when Philip sent messengers to offer them a chance of forgiveness, they responded that their gates were open for the king. Upon his arrival, several of the leaders left the city, and Eurylochus took his own life. The soldiers of Antiochus, according to an agreement, were escorted through Macedonia and Thrace by a group of Macedonians and taken to Lysimachia. There were also a few ships at Demetrias, led by Isidorus, who, along with his crew, were let go. Philip then took control of Dolopia, Aperantia, and several cities in Perrhaebia.

34

While Philip was thus employed, Titus Quinctius, after receiving from the Achaean council the cession of Zacynthus, crossed over to Naupactum, which had stood a siege of near two months, but was now reduced to a desperate condition; and it was supposed, that if it should be taken by storm, the whole nation of the Aetolians would be sunk thereby in utter destruction. But, although he was deservedly incensed against the Aetolians, from the recollection that they alone had attempted to depreciate his merits, when he was giving liberty to Greece; and had been in no degree influenced by his advice, when he endeavoured, by forewarning them of the events, which had since occurred, to deter them from their mad undertaking: nevertheless, thinking it particularly his business to take care that none of the states of Greece which had been liberated by himself should be entirely subverted, he first walked about near the walls, that he might be easily known by the Aetolians. He was quickly distinguished by the first advanced guards, and the news spread from rank to rank that Quinctius was there. On this, the people from all sides ran to the walls, and eagerly stretching out their hands, all in one joint cry besought Quinctius by name, to assist and save them. Although he was much affected by these entreaties, yet for that time he made signs with his hands, that they were to expect no assistance from him. However, when he met the consul he accosted him thus:--"Manius Acilius, are you unapprized of what is passing; or do you know it, and think it immaterial to the interest of the commonwealth?" This inflamed the consul with curiosity, and he replied, "But explain what is your meaning." Quinctius then said,--"Do you not see that, since the defeat of Antiochus, you have been wasting time in besieging two cities, though the year of your command is near expiring; but that Philip, who never faced the enemy, or even saw their standards, has annexed to his dominions such a number, not only of cities, but of nations,--Athamania, Perrhaebia, Aperantia, Dolopia? But, surely, we are not so deeply interested in diminishing the strength and resources of the Aetolians, as in hindering those of Philip from being augmented beyond measure; and in you, and your soldiers, not having yet gained, to reward your victory, as many towns as Philip has gained Grecian states."

While Philip was busy, Titus Quinctius, after getting the Achaean council's approval to take control of Zacynthus, crossed over to Naupactum. The city had been under siege for almost two months and was now in a desperate situation. It was feared that if it fell, the entire Aetolian nation would be utterly destroyed. Although Quinctius was understandably angry at the Aetolians for trying to undermine his efforts when he was liberating Greece, and for ignoring his warnings about the disastrous path they were taking, he felt it was his responsibility to ensure that none of the Greek states he had freed were completely destroyed. So, he first walked near the walls to be easily seen by the Aetolians. He was quickly recognized by the front guards, and news spread that Quinctius was there. People rushed to the walls from all sides and, with outstretched hands, cried out to him to help and save them. Although deeply moved by their pleas, he signaled with his hands that they should not expect any help from him at that moment. When he ran into the consul, he said, "Manius Acilius, are you unaware of what’s happening, or do you know and consider it irrelevant to the state?" This piqued the consul's curiosity, and he replied, "Please explain what you mean." Quinctius then said, "Can’t you see that since Antiochus’s defeat, you've been wasting time besieging two cities, as your term is almost over? Meanwhile, Philip, who has never faced an enemy or seen their standards, has added a number of cities and nations to his rule — Athamania, Perrhaebia, Aperantia, Dolopia. Surely, we should be more concerned about preventing Philip's power from growing excessively than in weakening the Aetolians. You and your soldiers still haven’t gained, to reward your victory, as many towns as Philip has expanded into Greek territories."

35

The consul assented to these remarks, but a feeling of shame suggested itself to him--if he should abandon the siege with his purpose unaccomplished. At length the matter was left entirely to the management of Quinctius. He went again to that part of the wall whence the Aetolians had called to him a little before; and on their entreating him now, with still greater earnestness, to take compassion on the nation of the Aetolians, he desired that some of them might come out to him. Accordingly, Phaeneas himself, with some others of the principal men, instantly came and threw themselves at his feet. He then said,--"Your condition causes me to restrain my resentment and my reproofs. The events which I foretold have come to pass, and you have not even this reflection left you, that they have fallen upon you undeservedly. Nevertheless, since fate has, in some manner, destined me to the office of cherishing the interests of Greece, I will not cease to show kindness even to the unthankful. Send intercessors to the consul, and let them petition him for a suspension of hostilities, for so long a time as will allow you to send ambassadors to Rome, to surrender yourselves to the will of the senate. I will intercede, and plead in your favour with the consul." They did as Quinctius directed; nor did the consul reject their application. He granted them a truce for a certain time, until the embassy might bring a reply from Rome; and then, raising the siege, he sent his army into Phocis. The consul, with Titus Quinctius, crossed over thence to Aegium, to confer with the council of the Achaeans about the Eleans, and also the restoration of the Lacedaemonian exiles. But neither was carried into execution, because the Achaeans chose to reserve to themselves the merit of effecting the latter; and the Eleans preferred being united to the Achaean confederacy by a voluntary act of their own, rather than through the mediation of the Romans. Ambassadors came hither to the consul from the Epirots, who, it was well known, had not with honest fidelity maintained the alliance. Although they had not furnished Antiochus with any soldiers, yet they were charged with having assisted him with money; and they themselves did not disavow having sent ambassadors to him. They requested that they might be permitted to continue on the former footing of friendship. To which the consul answered, that "he did not yet know whether he was to consider them as friends or foes. The senate must be the judge of that matter. He would therefore take no step in the business, but leave it to be determined at Rome; and for that purpose he granted them a truce of ninety days." When the Epirots, who were sent to Rome, addressed the senate, they rather enumerated hostile acts which they had not committed, than cleared themselves of those laid to their charge; and they received such an answer that they seemed rather to have obtained pardon than proved their innocence. About the same time ambassadors from king Philip were introduced to the senate, and presented his congratulations on their late successes. They asked leave to sacrifice in the Capitol, and to deposit an offering of gold in the temple of Jupiter supremely good and great. This was granted by the senate, and they presented a golden crown of a hundred pounds' weight. The senate not only answered the ambassadors with kindness, but gave them Demetrius, Philip's son, who was at Rome as an hostage, to be conducted home to his father.--Such was the conclusion of the war waged in Greece by the consul Manius Acilius against Antiochus.

The consul agreed with these comments, but he felt a sense of shame about giving up the siege without achieving his goals. Eventually, the situation was turned over completely to Quinctius. He returned to the part of the wall where the Aetolians had called to him earlier; and as they now pleaded even more earnestly for him to show compassion for their nation, he asked for some of them to come out to him. Phaeneas himself, along with a few other prominent leaders, quickly came and fell at his feet. He then said, "Your situation makes me hold back my anger and my criticism. The outcomes I predicted have happened, and you cannot even reflect that you have faced them without cause. However, since fate has somehow destined me to look after the interests of Greece, I won’t stop showing kindness, even to those who don’t appreciate it. Send envoys to the consul, and let them ask him to pause hostilities for as long as it takes for you to send ambassadors to Rome and surrender to the will of the senate. I will advocate for you with the consul." They followed Quinctius’s instructions, and the consul did not reject their request. He granted them a truce for a specified time, until the embassy could return with a response from Rome; and then, lifting the siege, he sent his army into Phocis. The consul and Titus Quinctius then went to Aegium to discuss matters with the Achaean council regarding the Eleans and the reinstatement of the Lacedaemonian exiles. However, neither issue was resolved, as the Achaeans preferred to claim the credit for the latter, and the Eleans wanted to join the Achaean confederacy on their own terms rather than through Roman intervention. Ambassadors from the Epirots arrived to see the consul, who were known to have not maintained their allegiance faithfully. Although they hadn’t provided any soldiers to Antiochus, they were accused of having supported him financially and did not deny sending ambassadors to him. They asked to continue their previous friendship with Rome. The consul replied that he "didn’t yet know if he should view them as friends or enemies. The senate would decide that. He would not act on the matter but let it be determined in Rome; for that reason, he granted them a truce of ninety days." When the Epirot envoys addressed the senate, they recited a list of hostile acts they hadn’t actually committed, rather than clearing themselves of the accusations against them; they received a response that suggested they had been forgiven rather than proven innocent. Around the same time, ambassadors from King Philip were introduced to the senate, offering congratulations on their recent victories. They requested permission to make sacrifices in the Capitol and to leave a gold offering in the temple of Jupiter, the supreme deity. The senate granted this and they presented a golden crown weighing a hundred pounds. The senate not only responded kindly to the ambassadors but also gave them Demetrius, Philip's son, who was in Rome as a hostage, to bring back to his father. That was how the war waged in Greece by Consul Manius Acilius against Antiochus came to an end.

36

The other consul, Publius Cornelius Scipio, who had obtained by lot the province of Gaul, before he set out to the war which was to be waged against the Boians, demanded of the senate, by a decree, to order him money for the exhibition of games, which, when acting as propraetor in Spain, he had vowed at a critical time of a battle. His demand was deemed unprecedented and unreasonable, and they therefore voted, that "whatever games he had vowed, on his own single judgment, without consulting the senate, he should celebrate out of the spoils, if he had reserved any for the purpose; otherwise, at his own expense." Accordingly, Publius Cornelius exhibited those games through the space of ten days. About this time the temple of the great Idaean Mother was dedicated; which deity, on her being brought from Asia, in the consulate of Publius Cornelius Scipio, afterwards surnamed Africanus, and Publius Lucinius, the above-mentioned Publius Cornelius had conducted from the sea-side to the Palatine. In pursuance of a decree of the senate, Marcus Livius and Caius Claudius, censors, in the consulate of Marcus Cornelius and Publius Sempronius, had contracted for the erection of the goddess's temple; and thirteen years after it had been so contracted for, it was dedicated by Marcus Junius Brutus, and games were celebrated on occasion of its dedication: in which, according to the account of Valerius Antias, dramatic entertainments were, for the first time, introduced into the Megalesian games. Likewise, Caius Licinius Lucullus, being appointed duumvir, dedicated the temple of Youth in the great circus. This temple had been vowed sixteen years before by Marcus Livius, consul, on the day wherein he cut off Hasdrubal and his army; and the same person, when censor, in the consulate of Marcus Cornelius and Publius Sempronius, had contracted for the building of it. Games were also exhibited on occasion of this consecration, and every thing was performed with the greater degree of religious zeal, on account of the impending war with Antiochus.

The other consul, Publius Cornelius Scipio, who drew the lot for the province of Gaul, requested the senate, through a decree, to provide him money for games he had promised during a crucial battle while serving as propraetor in Spain. His request was considered unusual and unreasonable, so they decided that "any games he had vowed, based solely on his own judgment without consulting the senate, should be funded from the spoils if he had saved any for that purpose; otherwise, at his own cost." Consequently, Publius Cornelius held those games for ten days. Around this time, the temple of the great Idaean Mother was dedicated; this goddess was brought from Asia during the consulate of Publius Cornelius Scipio, who later became known as Africanus, and Publius Lucinius, with the above-mentioned Publius Cornelius overseeing her transport from the seashore to the Palatine. Following a decree from the senate, Marcus Livius and Caius Claudius, the censors, had contracted to build the goddess’s temple during the consulate of Marcus Cornelius and Publius Sempronius; thirteen years after this agreement, it was dedicated by Marcus Junius Brutus, alongside games held for the occasion. According to Valerius Antias, dramatic performances were, for the first time, included in the Megalesian games during this event. Additionally, Caius Licinius Lucullus, appointed as duumvir, dedicated the temple of Youth in the great circus. This temple had been promised sixteen years earlier by Marcus Livius, consul, on the day he defeated Hasdrubal and his army; the same person, when censor, had also contracted for its construction. Games were also held for this dedication, and everything was carried out with a heightened sense of religious devotion due to the looming war with Antiochus.

37

At the beginning of the year in which those transactions passed, after Manius Acilius had gone to open the campaign, and while the other consul, Publius Cornelius, yet remained in Rome, two tame oxen, it is said, climbed up by ladders on the tiles of a house in the Carina. The aruspices ordered them to be burned alive, and their ashes to be thrown into the Tiber. It was reported, that several showers of stones had fallen at Tarracina and Amiternum; that, at Minturnae, the temple of Jupiter, and the shops round the forum, were struck by lightning; that, at Vulturnum, in the mouth of the river, two ships were struck by lightning, and burnt to ashes. On occasion of these prodigies, the decemvirs, being ordered by a decree of the senate to consult the Sibylline books, declared, that "a fast ought to be instituted in honour of Ceres, and the same observed every fifth year; that the nine days' worship ought to be solemnized, and a supplication for one day; and that they should observe the supplication, with garlands on their heads; also that the consul Publius Cornelius should sacrifice to such deities, and with such victims, as the decemvirs should direct." When he had used every means to avert the wrath of the gods, by duly fulfilling vows and expiating prodigies, the consul went to his province; and, ordering the proconsul Cneius Domitius to disband his army, and go home to Rome, he marched his own legions into the territory of the Boians.

At the start of the year when those events took place, after Manius Acilius had launched the campaign, and while the other consul, Publius Cornelius, was still in Rome, two tame oxen reportedly climbed up a ladder to the roof of a house in the Carina neighborhood. The priests ordered them to be burned alive, and their ashes to be thrown into the Tiber River. It was said that several showers of stones fell in Tarracina and Amiternum; that at Minturnae, the temple of Jupiter and the shops around the forum were struck by lightning; and that at Vulturnum, at the river's mouth, two ships were hit by lightning and burned to ashes. In response to these strange events, the decemvirs, following a decree from the senate to consult the Sibylline books, declared that "a fast should be held in honor of Ceres, and the same should be observed every fifth year; that the nine days of worship should be celebrated, along with a one-day supplication; and that they should observe the supplication with garlands on their heads; also that consul Publius Cornelius should sacrifice to the appropriate deities, and with the victims specified by the decemvirs." After making every effort to appease the gods by fulfilling vows and addressing the omens, the consul went to his province; and, instructing proconsul Cneius Domitius to disband his army and return to Rome, he led his own legions into the territory of the Boians.

38

Nearly at the same time, the Ligurians, having collected an army under the sanction of their devoting law, made an unexpected attack, in the night, on the camp of the proconsul Quintus Minucius. Minucius kept his troops, until daylight, drawn up within the rampart, and watchful to prevent the enemy from scaling any part of the fortifications At the first light, he made a sally by two gates at once: but the Ligurians did not, as he had expected, give way to his first onset; on the contrary, they maintained a dubious contest for more than two hours. At last, as other and still other troops came out from the camp, and fresh men took the place of those who were wearied in the fight, the Ligurians, who besides other hardships, felt a great loss of strength from the want of sleep, betook themselves to flight. Above four thousand of the enemy were killed; the Romans and allies lost not quite three hundred. About two months after this, the consul Publius Cornelius fought a pitched battle with the army of the Boians with extraordinary success. Valerius Antias affirms, that twenty-eight thousand of the enemy were slain, and three thousand four hundred taken, with a hundred and twenty-four military standards, one thousand two hundred and thirty horses, and two hundred and forty-seven waggons; and that of the conquerors there fell one thousand four hundred and eighty-four. Though we may not entirely credit this writer with respect to the numbers, as in such exaggeration no writer is more extravagant, yet it is certain that the victory on this occasion was very complete; because the enemy's camp was taken, while, immediately after the battle, the Boians surrendered themselves; and because a supplication was decreed by the senate on account of it, and victims of the greater kinds were sacrificed. About the same time Marcus Fulvius Nobilior entered the city in ovation, returning from Farther Spain. He carried with him twelve thousand pounds of silver, one hundred and thirty thousand silver denarii, and one hundred and twenty-seven pounds of gold.[49]

Nearly at the same time, the Ligurians, having gathered an army under the authority of their vows, launched a surprise attack at night on the camp of proconsul Quintus Minucius. Minucius kept his troops inside the ramparts until dawn, staying alert to stop the enemy from climbing any part of the fortifications. At first light, he made a move by opening two gates simultaneously; however, the Ligurians did not retreat as he had anticipated. On the contrary, they engaged in a fierce battle for over two hours. Eventually, as more troops joined from the camp and fresh soldiers replaced the exhausted ones, the Ligurians, already weakened by other hardships and lack of sleep, fled. Over four thousand enemy soldiers were killed; the Romans and their allies lost nearly three hundred. About two months later, consul Publius Cornelius faced the Boians in a major battle with remarkable success. Valerius Antias claims that twenty-eight thousand enemy soldiers were killed, three thousand four hundred were captured, along with one hundred and twenty-four military standards, one thousand two hundred and thirty horses, and two hundred and forty-seven wagons; and that the conquerors lost one thousand four hundred and eighty-four men. While we may not fully trust his numbers, as he often exaggerates, it is clear that the victory in this instance was significant; the enemy camp was captured, and immediately after the battle, the Boians surrendered, prompting the senate to decree a solemn celebration, with large sacrifices made. Around the same time, Marcus Fulvius Nobilior returned to the city in a ceremonial procession from Farther Spain, bringing with him twelve thousand pounds of silver, one hundred and thirty thousand silver denarii, and one hundred and twenty-seven pounds of gold.[49]

39

The consul, Publius Cornelius, having received hostages from the Boians, punished them so far as to appropriate almost one-half of their lands for the use of the Roman people, and into which they might afterwards, if they chose, send colonies. Then returning home in full confidence of a triumph, he dismissed his troops, and ordered them to attend on the day of his triumph at Rome. The next day after his arrival, he held a meeting of the senate, in the temple of Bellona, when he detailed to them the services he had performed, and demanded to ride through the city in triumph. Publius Sempronius Blaesus, tribune of the people, advised, that "the honour of a triumph should not be refused to Scipio, but postponed. Wars of the Ligurians," he said, "were always united with wars of the Gauls; for these nations, lying so near, sent mutual assistance to each other. If Publius Scipio, after subduing the Boians in battle, had either gone himself, with his victorious army, into the country of the Ligurians, or sent a part of his forces to Quintus Minucius, who was detained there, now the third year, by a war which was still undecided, that with the Ligurians might have been brought to an end: instead of which, he had, in order to procure a full attendance on his triumph, brought home the troops, who might have performed most material services to the state; and might do so still, if the senate thought proper, by deferring this token of victory, to redeem that which had been omitted through eager haste for a triumph. If they would order the consul to return with his legions into his province, and to give his assistance towards subduing the Ligurians, (for, unless these were reduced under the dominion and jurisdiction of the Roman people, neither would the Boians ever remain quiet,) there must be either peace or war with both. When the Ligurians should be subdued, Publius Cornelius, in quality of proconsul, might triumph, a few months later, after the precedent of many, who did not attain that honour until the expiration of their office."

The consul, Publius Cornelius, received hostages from the Boians and punished them by taking almost half of their lands for the Roman people's use, where they could later send colonies if they wanted. Feeling confident about his upcoming triumph, he sent his troops home and instructed them to attend the triumph in Rome. The day after he returned, he called a meeting of the senate in the temple of Bellona, where he shared the achievements he had made and requested to ride through the city in triumph. Publius Sempronius Blaesus, a tribune of the people, suggested that “the honor of a triumph should not be denied to Scipio, but postponed.” He stated, “Wars of the Ligurians are always linked with wars of the Gauls; these neighboring nations assist each other. If Publius Scipio had either gone with his victorious army into Ligurian territory after defeating the Boians or sent some of his forces to Quintus Minucius, who has been stuck in an unresolved war there for three years, then the situation with the Ligurians could have been resolved. Instead, he brought home the troops who could have provided significant help to the state, and they could still do so if the senate decided to delay this honor of victory to make up for what was rushed for his triumph. If they were to send the consul back with his legions to help subdue the Ligurians (because unless they were brought under Roman authority, the Boians would never be at peace), there must be either peace or war with both. Once the Ligurians were defeated, Publius Cornelius, as proconsul, could triumph a few months later, following the example of many who only received that honor after their term in office.”

40

To this the consul answered, that "neither had the province of Liguria fallen to his lot, nor had he waged war with the Ligurians, nor did he demand a triumph over them. He confidently hoped, that in a short time Quintus Minucius, after completing their reduction, would demand and obtain a well-deserved triumph. For his part, he demanded a triumph over the Boian Gauls, whom he had conquered in battle and had driven out of their camp; of whose whole nation he had received an absolute submission within two days after the fight; and from whom he had brought home hostages to secure peace in future. But there was another circumstance, of much greater magnitude: he had slain in battle so great a number of Gauls, that no commander, before him, ever met in the field so many thousands, at least of the Boians. Out of fifty thousand men, more than one-half were killed, and many thousands made prisoners; so that the Boians had now remaining only old men and boys. Could it, then, be a matter of surprise to any one, that a victorious army, which had not left one enemy in the province, should come to Rome to attend the triumph of their consul? And if the senate should choose to employ the services of these troops in another province also, which of the two kinds of treatment could it be supposed would make them enter on a new course of danger and another laborious enterprise with the greater alacrity; the paying them the reward of their former toils and dangers without defalcation; or, the sending them away, with the prospect, instead of the reality, when they had once been disappointed in their first expectation? As to what concerned himself personally, he had acquired a stock of glory sufficient for his whole life, on that day, when the senate adjudged him to be the best man (in the state), and commissioned him to give a reception to the Idaean Mother. With this inscription (though neither consulship nor triumph were added) the statue of Publius Scipio Nasica would be sufficiently honoured and dignified." The unanimous senate not only gave their vote for the triumph, but by their influence prevailed on the tribune to desist from his protest. Publius Cornelius, the consul, triumphed over the Boians. In this procession he carried, on Gallic waggons, arms, standards, and spoils of all sorts; the brazen utensils of the Gauls; and, together with the prisoners of distinction, he led a train of captured horses. He deposited in the treasury a thousand four hundred and seventy golden chains; and besides these, two hundred and forty-five pounds' weight of gold; two thousand three hundred and forty pounds' weight of silver, some unwrought, and some formed in vessels of the Gallic fashion, not without beauty; and two hundred and thirty-four thousand denarii.[50] To the soldiers who followed his chariot, he distributed three hundred and twenty-five asses[51] each, double to a centurion, triple to a horseman. Next day, he summoned an assembly, and after expatiating on his own services, and the ill-treatment shown him by the tribune who wanted to entangle him in a way which did not belong to him, in order to defraud him of the fruits of his success, he absolved the soldiers of their oath and discharged them.

To this, the consul replied that "he neither received the province of Liguria nor waged war against the Ligurians, nor did he seek a triumph over them. He was confident that soon Quintus Minucius, after finishing their defeat, would request and receive a well-deserved triumph. As for himself, he sought a triumph over the Boian Gauls, whom he had fought and expelled from their camp; he had secured total submission from their entire nation just two days after the battle and brought back hostages to ensure peace in the future. But there was an even more significant matter: he had killed so many Gauls in battle that no commander before him had faced so many thousands, at least of the Boians. Out of fifty thousand men, over half were killed, and many thousands were captured, leaving the Boians with only old men and boys. So, could anyone be surprised that a victorious army, which had left no enemy in the province, would come to Rome to witness their consul's triumph? If the senate decided to deploy these troops in another province, which option would likely motivate them to embark on a new perilous venture with greater enthusiasm: rewarding them fully for their past efforts and dangers, or sending them off with the hope of rewards rather than fulfilling the promise after having disappointed them initially? Personally, he had gained enough glory for a lifetime on the day the senate recognized him as the best man in the state and tasked him with welcoming the Idaean Mother. With this acknowledgment (even without the addition of consulship or triumph), the statue of Publius Scipio Nasica would be honored and revered." The unanimous senate not only voted for the triumph but also persuaded the tribune to withdraw his protest. Publius Cornelius, the consul, triumphed over the Boians. In this procession, he brought, on Gallic carts, weapons, standards, and various spoils; the bronze items of the Gauls; and led a parade of captured horses along with distinguished prisoners. He deposited in the treasury one thousand four hundred seventy golden chains; additionally, two hundred forty-five pounds of gold; two thousand three hundred forty pounds of silver, some raw and some made into elegant Gallic-style vessels; and two hundred thirty-four thousand denarii.[50] To the soldiers who followed his chariot, he distributed three hundred twenty-five asses[51] each, double to a centurion, triple to a horseman. The next day, he called an assembly, and after elaborating on his achievements and the mistreatment he experienced from the tribune who tried to ensnare him in matters that didn't concern him to rob him of the rewards of his success, he released the soldiers from their oath and discharged them.

41

While this passed in Italy, Antiochus was at Ephesus divested of all concern respecting the war with Rome, as supposing that the Romans had no intention of coming into Asia; which state of security was occasioned by the erroneous opinions or the flattering representations of the greater part of his friends. Hannibal alone, whose judgment was, at that time, the most highly respected by the king, declared, that "he rather wondered the Romans were not already in Asia than entertained a doubt of their coming. The passage was easier from Greece to Asia, than from Italy to Greece, and Antiochus constituted a much more important object than the Aetolians. For the Roman arms were not less powerful on sea than on land. Their fleet had long been at Malea, and he had heard that a reinforcement of ships and a new commander had lately come from Italy, with intent to enter on action. He therefore advised Antiochus not to form to himself vain hopes of peace. He must necessarily in a short time maintain a contest with the Romans both by sea and land, in Asia, and for Asia itself; and must either wrest the power from those who grasped at the empire of the world, or lose his own dominions." He seemed to be the only person who could foresee, and honestly foretell, what was to happen. The king, therefore, with the ships which were equipped and in readiness, sailed to the Chersonesus, in order to strengthen the places there with garrisons, lest the Romans should happen to come by land. He left orders with Polyxenidas to fit out the rest of the fleet, and put to sea; and sent out advice-boats among the islands to procure intelligence of every thing that was passing.

While this was happening in Italy, Antiochus was in Ephesus, completely unconcerned about the war with Rome, believing that the Romans had no plans to invade Asia. This false sense of security came from the misleading opinions and flattering reports from most of his advisors. Only Hannibal, whose judgment was highly regarded by the king at that time, said that he was more surprised the Romans weren't already in Asia than doubting they would come. The route from Greece to Asia was easier than from Italy to Greece, and Antiochus was a much bigger target than the Aetolians. The Roman forces were just as powerful at sea as they were on land. Their fleet had been at Malea for a while, and he had heard that a reinforcements of ships and a new commander had recently arrived from Italy, ready to engage. So he advised Antiochus not to entertain false hopes of peace. He would soon have to confront the Romans both at sea and on land, in Asia, and for Asia itself, and he must either wrest control from those vying for global dominance or risk losing his own territories. He appeared to be the only one able to foresee and honestly predict what was about to happen. The king then set sail with the ships that were ready, heading to the Chersonesus to reinforce the local garrisons in case the Romans approached by land. He instructed Polyxenidas to prepare the rest of the fleet and set out to sea, and sent out scout boats among the islands to gather intelligence on everything going on.

42

When Caius Livius, commander of the Roman fleet, sailed with fifty decked ships from Rome, he went to Neapolis, where he had appointed the rendezvous of the undecked ships, which were due by treaty from the allies on that coast; and thence he proceeded to Sicily, where, as he sailed through the strait beyond Messana, he was joined by six Carthaginian ships, sent to his assistance; and then, having collected the vessels due from the Rhegians, Locrians, and other allies, who were bound by the same conditions, he purified the fleet at Lacinium, and put forth into the open sea. On his arrival at Corcyra, which was the first Grecian country where he touched, inquiring about the state of the war, (for all matters in Greece were not yet entirely settled,) and about the Roman fleet, he was told, that the consul and the king were posted at the pass of Thermopylae, and that the fleet lay at Piraeus: on which, judging expedition necessary on every account, he sailed directly forward to Peloponnesus. Having on his passage ravaged Samos and Zacynthus, because they favoured the party of the Aetolians, he bent his course to Malea; and, meeting very favourable weather, arrived in a few days at Piraeus, where he joined the old fleet. At Scyllaeum he was met by king Eumenes, with three ships, who had long hesitated at Aegina whether he should go home to defend his own kingdom, on hearing that Antiochus was preparing both marine and land forces at Ephesus; or whether he should unite himself inseparably to the Romans, on whose destiny his own depended. Aulus Atilius, having delivered to his successor twenty-five decked ships, sailed from Piraeus for Rome. Livius, with eighty-one beaked ships, besides many others of inferior rates, some of which were open and furnished with beaks, others without beaks, fit for advice-boats, crossed over to Delos.

When Caius Livius, the commander of the Roman fleet, set sail from Rome with fifty warships, he headed to Neapolis, where he had arranged to meet the smaller ships that the allies were supposed to deliver according to their treaty. From there, he went on to Sicily, and as he passed through the strait near Messana, he was joined by six Carthaginian ships that had come to help him. After gathering the ships owed to him by the Rhegians, Locrians, and other allies under the same agreement, he purified his fleet at Lacinium and headed out to open sea. Upon arriving at Corcyra, the first Greek territory he reached, he inquired about the state of the war—since not everything in Greece was resolved—along with the status of the Roman fleet. He learned that the consul and the king were stationed at the Thermopylae pass and that the fleet was at Piraeus. Considering the urgent need for action, he sailed straight to Peloponnesus. While passing, he raided Samos and Zacynthus for supporting the Aetolians and then made his way toward Malea. With favorable weather, he arrived in a few days at Piraeus, where he rejoined the main fleet. There, he encountered King Eumenes, who had three ships and had been uncertain about whether to return home to defend his kingdom, worried about Antiochus gathering a military force in Ephesus, or to stay with the Romans, whose fate was linked to his own. Aulus Atilius, after handing over twenty-five warships to his successor, departed from Piraeus for Rome. Livius, commanding eighty-one ships with beaks, plus many smaller vessels—some unarmed and suitable for advisory roles—crossed over to Delos.

43

At this time, the consul Acilius was engaged in the siege of Naupactum. Livius was detained several days at Delos by contrary winds, for that tract among the Cyclades, which are separated in some places by larger straits, in others by smaller, is extremely subject to storms. Polyxenidas, receiving intelligence from his scout-ships, which were stationed in various places, that the Roman fleet lay at Delos, sent off an express to the king, who, quitting the business in which he was employed in Hellespontus, and taking with him all the ships of war, returned to Ephesus with all possible speed, and instantly called a council to determine whether he should risk an engagement at sea. Polyxenidas affirmed, that no delay should be incurred; "it was particularly requisite so to do, before the fleet of Eumenes and the Rhodian ships should join the Romans; in which case, even, they would scarcely be inferior in number, and in every other particular would have a great superiority, by reason of the agility of their vessels, and a variety of auxiliary circumstances. For the Roman ships, being unskilfully constructed, were slow in their motions; and, besides that, as they were coming to an enemy's coast, they would be heavily laden with provisions; whereas their own, leaving none but friends in all the countries round, would have nothing on board but men and arms. Moreover that their knowledge of the sea, of the adjacent lands, and of the winds, would be greatly in their favour; of all which the Romans being ignorant, would find themselves much distressed." In advising this plan he influenced all, especially as the same person who gave the advice was also to carry it into execution. Two days only were passed in making preparations; and on the third, setting sail with a hundred ships, of which seventy had decks, and the rest were open, but all of the smaller rates, they steered their course to Phocaea. The king, as he did not intend to be present in the naval combat, on hearing that the Roman fleet was approaching, withdrew to Magnesia, near Sipylus, to collect his land forces, while his ships proceeded to Cyssus, a port of Erythraea, where it was supposed they might with more convenience wait for the enemy. The Romans, as soon as the north wind, which had held for several days, ceased, sailed from Delos to Phanae, a port in Chios, opposite the Aegaean sea. They afterwards brought round the fleet to the city of Chios, and having taken in provisions there, sailed over to Phocaea. Eumenes, who had gone to join his fleet at Elaea, returned a few days after, with twenty-four decked ships, and a greater number of open ones, to Phocaea, where were the Romans, who were fitting and preparing themselves for a sea-fight. Then setting sail with a hundred and five decked ships, and about fifty open ones, they were for some time driven forcibly towards the land, by a north wind blowing across its course. The ships were thereby obliged to go, for the most part, singly, one after another, in a thin line; afterwards, when the violence of the wind abated, they endeavoured to stretch over to the harbour of Corycus, beyond Cyssus.

At this time, Consul Acilius was besieging Naupactum. Livius was stuck on Delos for several days because of bad winds. This area among the Cyclades is often hit by storms, with some parts having larger straits and others smaller ones. Polyxenidas, upon receiving word from his scout ships stationed in different locations that the Roman fleet was at Delos, sent a message to the king. The king left his work in Hellespontus, brought all his warships with him, and rushed back to Ephesus, where he quickly called a council to decide whether to engage the enemy at sea. Polyxenidas argued that there should be no delay; "we need to act quickly before Eumenes’s fleet and the Rhodian ships join the Romans; otherwise, even if we have fewer ships, we will have the advantage in every other way due to our ship's agility and other supporting factors. The Roman ships are poorly built and slow, and since they are approaching enemy territory, they'll be weighed down by provisions; meanwhile, our ships, filled only with men and weapons and with friendly ports nearby, will be unburdened. Also, our familiarity with the sea, the surrounding lands, and the winds will be a big advantage; the Romans, being unfamiliar with all of this, will struggle." His advice swayed the council, especially since he would also lead the attack. They spent only two days preparing; on the third day, they set sail with a hundred ships, seventy of them decked and the rest open, all smaller vessels, heading toward Phocaea. The king, not planning to participate in the naval battle, retreated to Magnesia near Sipylus to gather his ground forces, while his ships continued to Cyssus, a port of Erythraea, where they could wait for the enemy more conveniently. As soon as the north wind, which had lasted for several days, died down, the Romans sailed from Delos to Phanae, a port in Chios facing the Aegean Sea. They then moved their fleet to the city of Chios, loaded up on provisions, and sailed over to Phocaea. Eumenes, who had gone to join his fleet at Elaea, returned a few days later with twenty-four decked ships and more open ones to Phocaea, where the Romans were preparing for battle. They then set sail with a hundred and five decked ships and about fifty open ones but were temporarily forced toward the land by a strong north wind. This situation meant the ships had to go mostly one by one in a thin line; later, as the wind died down, they tried to head over to the port of Corycus, beyond Cyssus.

44

When intelligence was brought to Polyxenidas that the enemy were approaching, he rejoiced at an opportunity of engaging them, and drew out the left squadron towards the open sea, at the same time ordering the commanders of the ships to extend the right division towards the land; and then advanced to the fight, with his fleet in a regular line of battle. The Roman commander, on seeing this, furled his sails, lowered his masts, and, at the same time adjusting his rigging, waited for the ships which were coming up. There were now about thirty in the line; and in order that his left squadron might form a front in like direction, he hoisted his top-sails, and stretched out into the deep, ordering the others to push forward, between him and the land, against the right squadron of the enemy. Eumenes brought up the rear; who, as soon as he saw the bustle of taking down the rigging begin, likewise brought up his ships with all possible speed. All their ships were by this time in sight; two Carthaginian vessels, however, which advanced before the Romans, came across three belonging to the king. As the numbers were unequal, two of the king's ships fell upon one, and, in the first place, swept away the oars from both its sides; the armed mariners then boarded, and killing some of its defenders and throwing others into the sea, took the ship. The one which had engaged in an equal contest, on seeing her companion taken, before she could be surrounded by the three, fled back to the fleet. Livius, fired with indignation, bore down with the praetorian ship against the enemy. The two which had overpowered the Carthaginian ship, in hopes of the same success against this one, advanced to the attack, on which he ordered the rowers on both sides to plunge their oars in the water, in order to hold the ship steady, and to throw grappling-irons into the enemy's vessels as they came up. Having, by these means, rendered the business something like a fight on land, he desired his men to bear in mind the courage of Romans, and not to regard the slaves of a king as men. Accordingly, this single ship now defeated and captured the two, with more ease than the two had before taken one. By this time the entire fleets were engaged and intermixed with each other. Eumenes, who had come up last, and after the battle was begun, when he saw the left squadron of the enemy thrown into disorder by Livius, directed his own attack against their right, where the contest was yet equal.

When Polyxenidas learned that the enemy was approaching, he was excited about the chance to engage them. He repositioned the left squadron toward the open sea while instructing the commanders of the ships to extend the right division toward the land. Then, he advanced to the battle with his fleet organized in a standard battle line. The Roman commander, upon noticing this, furled his sails, lowered his masts, and adjusted his rigging as he awaited the arriving ships. About thirty ships were now in line, and to ensure his left squadron could face the enemy in the same direction, he raised his top sails and pushed out into deeper waters, instructing the others to advance between him and the land against the enemy's right squadron. Eumenes followed closely behind, and as soon as he noticed the commotion of taking down rigging, he rushed his ships forward as fast as he could. By this time, all their ships were visible; however, two Carthaginian vessels that moved ahead of the Romans encountered three belonging to the king. Since the numbers were uneven, two of the king's ships attacked one of the Carthaginian vessels, first knocking out its oars on both sides. The armed crew then boarded, killing some of its defenders and tossing others into the sea, taking the ship. The vessel that had been in a fair fight, seeing its companion captured, fled back to the fleet before being surrounded by the three enemy ships. Livius, filled with anger, charged his praetorian ship at the enemy. The two ships that had taken the Carthaginian vessel, hoping for similar success against this one, moved in to attack. Livius ordered the rowers on both sides to put their oars in the water to keep the ship steady and to throw grappling irons into the enemy ships as they approached. By doing this, he turned the fight into something more like a land battle and urged his men to remember the bravery of Romans and not to see the king's slaves as equals. As a result, this single ship easily defeated and captured the two enemy ships, achieving more success than those two had in capturing one. By this time, the entire fleets were engaged and mixed together. Eumenes, who had arrived last, saw the left squadron of the enemy thrown into chaos by Livius and directed his attack against their right, where the battle was still equal.

45

In a short time a flight commenced, in the first instance, with the left squadron: for Polyxenidas, perceiving that he was evidently overmatched with respect to the bravery of the men, hoisted his top-sails, and betook himself to flight; and, quickly after, those who had engaged with Eumenes near the land did the same. The Romans and Eumenes pursued with much perseverance, as long as the rowers were able to hold out, and they had any prospect of annoying the rear of the enemy; but finding that the latter, by reason of the lightness and fleetness of their ships, baffled every effort that could be made by theirs, loaded as they were with provisions, they at length desisted, having taken thirteen ships together with the soldiers and rowers, and sunk ten. Of the Roman fleet, only the one Carthaginian ship, which, at the beginning of the action, had been attacked by two, was lost. Polyxenidas continued his flight, until he got into the harbour of Ephesus. The Romans staid, during the remainder of that day, in the port from which the king's fleet had sailed out, and on the day following proceeded in the pursuit. In the midst of their course they were met by twenty-five Rhodian decked ships, under Pausistratus, the commander of the fleet, and in conjunction with these followed the runaways to Ephesus, where they stood for some time, in order of battle, before the mouth of the harbour. Having thus extorted from the enemy a full confession of their being defeated, and having sent home the Rhodians and Eumenes, the Romans steered their course to Chios. When they had passed Phaenicus, a port of Erythraea, they cast anchor for the night; and proceeding next day to the island, came up to the city itself. After halting here a few days for the purpose chiefly of refreshing the rowers, they sailed over to Phocaea. Here they left four quinque remes for the defence of the city, and proceeded to Cannae, where, as the winter now approached, the ships were hauled on shore, and surrounded with a trench and rampart. At the close of the year, the elections were held at Rome, in which were chosen consuls, Lucius Cornelius Scipio and Caius Laelius, from whom all men expected the conclusion of the war with Antiochus. Next day were elected praetors, Marcus Tuccius, Lucius Aurunculeius, Cneius Fulvius, Lucius Aemilius, Publius Junius, and Caius Atinius Labeo.

In a short time, a flight began, initially with the left squadron: Polyxenidas, realizing he was clearly outmatched in terms of bravery, hoisted his top sails and fled; soon after, those who had engaged with Eumenes near the shore did the same. The Romans and Eumenes pursued them with great determination, as long as the rowers could keep going and there was any chance to attack the enemy's rear. However, finding that the enemy's ships, being lighter and faster, evaded all their attempts, which were hampered by their heavy loads of supplies, they eventually stopped, capturing thirteen ships along with the soldiers and rowers, and sinking ten. Of the Roman fleet, only one Carthaginian ship, which had been attacked by two vessels at the start of the battle, was lost. Polyxenidas continued his escape until he reached the harbor of Ephesus. The Romans stayed for the rest of that day in the port from which the king's fleet had departed, and the next day resumed their chase. During their journey, they encountered twenty-five Rhodian ships, led by Pausistratus, the commander of the fleet, and together they pursued the fleeing ships to Ephesus, where they positioned themselves in battle formation at the harbor entrance. Having compelled the enemy to fully acknowledge their defeat and sending the Rhodians and Eumenes home, the Romans set sail for Chios. After passing Phaenicus, a port of Erythraea, they anchored for the night and the next day arrived at the island, reaching the city itself. After resting there for a few days mainly to refresh the rowers, they sailed to Phocaea. They left four quinqueremes to defend the city and proceeded to Cannae, where, with winter approaching, the ships were pulled ashore and surrounded with a trench and rampart. At the end of the year, elections were held in Rome, where Lucius Cornelius Scipio and Caius Laelius were chosen as consuls, from whom everyone expected an end to the war with Antiochus. The next day, praetors were elected: Marcus Tuccius, Lucius Aurunculeius, Cneius Fulvius, Lucius Aemilius, Publius Junius, and Caius Atinius Labeo.

END OF VOL. III

FOOTNOTES

Footnote 1: £16. 2s. 1d.

Footnote 2: 7s. 9d.

Footnote 3: Hemerodromoi.

Footnote 4: £1033. 6s. 8d.

Footnote 5: Hollows.

Footnote 6: From thumazein, to wonder.

Footnote 7: £9. 13s. 9d.

Footnote 8: £322. 18s. 4d.

Footnote 9: £80. 14s. 7d.

Footnote 10: Pluto, Summus Mamum.

Footnote 11: £1937. 10s.

Footnote 12: £38,750.

Footnote 13: In the original, the number is omitted, or lost.

Footnote 14: £766. 18s. 6-1/2d

Footnote 15: £2551. 0s. 10d

Footnote 16: 4s. 6-1/2d

Footnote 17:£820. 4s. 2d

Footnote 18: £1717. 18s. 4d

Footnote 19: £1115. 13s. 3-1/2d.

Footnote 20: £96,875l.

Footnote 21: £5821l. 10s.

Footnote 22: £193,750l.

Footnote 23: £1033l. 6s. 8d.

Footnote 24: £2331l. 2s. 6d.

Footnote 25: 5s. 2-1/4d.

Footnote 26: Here is a chasm in the original, which is supplied from Polybius.

Footnote 27: It was their office to regulate the feasts of the gods.

Footnote 28: Subscribere actioni is to join the prosecutor as an assistant; and the prosecutors were obliged calumniam jurare, to swear that they did not carry on the prosecution through malice, or a vexatious design. Scipio, therefore, means to reprobate the interference of the Roman state, which could bring it into the situation of a common prosecutor in a court of justice.

Footnote 29: Previous to the passing of the Cincian law, about ten years before this time, the advocates who pleaded in the courts received fees and presents: and as all or most of these were senators, the plebeians are here represented as tributary to the senate. By the above law they were forbidden to receive either fees or presents.

Footnote 30: Alluding to a treatise by Cato, upon the antiquities of Italy, entitled "Origines," which is the word used here by Valerius.

Footnote 31: £549. 14s.

Footnote 32: Osca, now Huesca, was a city in Spain, remarkable for silver mine near it.

Footnote 33: £659. 11s. 9-1/2d.

Footnote 34: £2430. 11s. 3d.

Footnote 35: £8889. 6s. 9d.

Footnote 36: £397. 17s. 6d.

Footnote 37: £17. 8s. 9d.

Footnote 38: 17s. 5-1/2d.

Footnote 39: £19,375.

Footnote 40: £16. 2s. 11d.

Footnote 41: £10,849. 18s.

Footnote 42: £936l. 10s.

Footnote 43: £16s. 1-1/4d.

Footnote 44: 15th May.

Footnote 45: 3rd May.

Footnote 46: Here is, doubtless, some word dropped in the original; so small a quantity could never have been deemed an object for one powerful state to offer to another. Commentators suppose it to have been one hundred thousand..

Footnote 47: £4097l. 16s. 4d.

Footnote 48: The funeral pile.

Footnote 49: This statement has been made before at the close of chapter 21, and is probably repeated here through inadvertence.

Footnote 50: £7,523. 16s. 2d.

Footnote 51: £1. 4s. 2-1/2d.

Download ePUB

If you like this ebook, consider a donation!