This is a modern-English version of Letters from an American Farmer, originally written by St. John de Crèvecoeur, J. Hector.
It has been thoroughly updated, including changes to sentence structure, words, spelling,
and grammar—to ensure clarity for contemporary readers, while preserving the original spirit and nuance. If
you click on a paragraph, you will see the original text that we modified, and you can toggle between the two versions.
Scroll to the bottom of this page and you will find a free ePUB download link for this book.
Steve Harris, Charles Franks and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team.
Steve Harris, Charles Franks, and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team.
HECTOR ST. JOHN DE CREVECOEUR
LETTERS FROM AN AMERICAN FARMER
INTRODUCTION AND NOTES BY WARREN BARTON BLAKE
INTRODUCTION
Hazlitt wrote that of the three notable writers whom the eighteenth century had produced, in the North American colonies, one was "the author (whoever he was) of the American Farmer's Letters." Crevecoeur was that unknown author; and Hazlitt said further of him that he rendered, in his own vividly characteristic manner, "not only the objects, but the feelings, of a new country." Great is the essayist's relish for passages descriptive of "a battle between two snakes," of "the dazzling, almost invisible flutter of the humming- bird's wing," of the manners of "the Nantucket people, their frank simplicity, and festive rejoicings after the perils and hardships of the whale-fishing." "The power to sympathise with nature, without thinking of ourselves or others, if it is not a definition of genius, comes very near to it," writes Hazlitt of our author. And his references to Crevecoeur are closed with the remark: "We have said enough of this ILLUSTRIOUS OBSCURE; for it is the rule of criticism to praise none but the over-praised, and to offer fresh incense to the idol of the day."
Hazlitt mentioned that among the three notable writers from the eighteenth century in the North American colonies, one was "the author (whoever he was) of the American Farmer's Letters." That unknown author was Crevecoeur; Hazlitt also noted that he captured “not only the objects, but the feelings, of a new country” in his vividly unique style. The essayist has a great appreciation for descriptions of "a battle between two snakes,” “the dazzling, almost invisible flutter of the hummingbird's wing,” and the lifestyle of "the Nantucket people, their genuine simplicity, and joyful celebrations after the dangers and hardships of whaling.” "The ability to empathize with nature, without thinking of ourselves or others, if it is not a definition of genius, comes very close to it," Hazlitt writes about our author. He concludes his remarks on Crevecoeur with the statement: "We have said enough of this ILLUSTRIOUS OBSCURE; for it is the rule of criticism to praise none but those who are already praised, and to give fresh compliments to the idol of the day."
Others, at least, have followed that "rule of criticism," and the American Farmer has long enjoyed undisturbed seclusion. Only once since the eighteenth century has there been a new edition of his Letters, that were first published at London in 1782, and reissued, with a few corrections, in the next year. The original American edition of this book about America was that published at Philadelphia in 1793, and there was no reprint till 1904, [Footnote: References may be found to American editions of 1794 and 1798, but no copies of such editions are preserved in any library to which the editor has had access.] when careless editing did all it could to destroy the value of the work, the name of whose very author was misstated. Yet the facts which we have concerning him are few enough to merit truthful presentation.
Others have at least adhered to that "rule of criticism," and the American Farmer has long enjoyed uninterrupted privacy. Only once since the eighteenth century has a new edition of his Letters been released, which were first published in London in 1782 and reissued with a few corrections the following year. The original American edition of this book about America was published in Philadelphia in 1793, and there were no reprints until 1904, [Footnote: References may be found to American editions of 1794 and 1798, but no copies of such editions are preserved in any library to which the editor has had access.] when careless editing did everything it could to diminish the value of the work, and the name of the author was even misstated. Yet, the facts we have about him are limited enough to warrant an accurate portrayal.
I
Except by naturalisation, the author of Letters from an American Farmer was not an American; and he was no ordinary farmer. Yet why quarrel with him for the naming of his book, or for his signing it "J. Hector Saint-John," when the "Hector" of his title-pages and American biographers was only a prenom de faintaisie? We owe some concessions to the author of so charming a book, to the eighteenth- century Thoreau. His life is certainly more interesting than the real Thoreau's—and would be, even if it did not present many contradictions. Our records of that life are in the highest degree inexact; he himself is wanting in accuracy as to the date of more than one event. The records, however, agree that Crevecoeur belonged to the petite noblesse of Normandy. The date of his birth was January 31, 1735, the place was Caen, and his full name (his great- grandson and biographer vouches for it) was Michel-Guillaume-Jean de Crevecoeur. The boy was well enough brought up, but without more than the attention that his birth gave him the right to expect; he divided the years of his boyhood between Caen, where his father's town-house stood, and the College du Mont, where the Jesuits gave him his education. A letter dated 1785 and addressed to his children tells us all that we know of his school-days; though it is said, too, that he distinguished himself in mathematics. "If you only knew," the reminiscent father of a family exclaims in this letter, "in what shabby lodging, in what a dark and chilly closet, I was mewed up at your age; with what severity I was treated; how I was fed and dressed!" Already his powers of observation, that were so to distinguish him, were quickened by his old-world milieu.
Except by naturalization, the author of *Letters from an American Farmer* wasn’t actually American; and he wasn’t just any farmer. But why argue with him about the title of his book or his signature "J. Hector Saint-John," when the "Hector" on his title pages and in American biographies was just a made-up name? We should give some leeway to the author of such an engaging book, the 18th-century version of Thoreau. His life is definitely more interesting than the real Thoreau's—and it would still be, even if it didn't have many contradictions. Our records of that life are quite inaccurate; he himself is not precise about the dates of several events. However, the records do agree that Crevecoeur was part of the minor nobility in Normandy. He was born on January 31, 1735, in Caen, and his full name (his great-grandson and biographer confirms it) was Michel-Guillaume-Jean de Crevecoeur. He was raised fairly well, but with no more attention than his birth entitled him to expect; he spent his childhood between Caen, where his father’s town house was, and the College du Mont, where the Jesuits educated him. A letter dated 1785 and addressed to his children reveals everything we know about his school days; though it’s also said that he excelled in mathematics. "If only you knew," the nostalgic father reflects in this letter, "in what shabby accommodations, in what a dark and cold closet, I was stuck at your age; how strictly I was treated; how I was fed and dressed!" Even then, his keen powers of observation, which would later set him apart, were sharpened by his old-world surroundings.
"From my earliest youth," he wrote in 1803, "I had a passion for taking in all the antiques that I met with: moth-eaten furniture, tapestries, family portraits, Gothic manuscripts (that I had learned how to decipher), had for me an indefinable charm. A little later on, I loved to walk in the solitude of cemeteries; to examine the tombs and to trace out their mossy epitaphs. I knew most of the churches of the canton, the date of their foundation, and what they contained of interest in the way of pictures and sculptures."
"From my earliest youth," he wrote in 1803, "I had a passion for collecting all the antiques I encountered: worn-out furniture, tapestries, family portraits, Gothic manuscripts (that I had learned to read), all held an indescribable charm for me. A little later, I loved walking alone in cemeteries; examining the tombs and tracing their mossy epitaphs. I was familiar with most of the churches in the area, their founding dates, and what interesting pictures and sculptures they housed."
The boy's gift of accurate and keen observation was to be tested soon by a very different class of objects: there were to be no crumbling saints and canvases of Bed-Chamber Grooms for him to study in the forests of America; no reminders of the greatness of his country's past, and the honour of his family.
The boy's ability to observe things accurately and carefully was about to be tested by a very different set of objects: there would be no crumbling saints or paintings of royal attendants for him to examine in the forests of America; no reminders of his country's glorious past or his family's legacy.
From school, the future woodsman passed over into England. A distant relative was living near Salisbury; for one reason or another the boy was sent thither to finish his schooling. From England, with what motives we know not, he set out for the New World, where he was to spend his busiest and happiest days. In the Bibliotheca Americana Nova Rich makes the statement that Crevecoeur was but sixteen when he made the plunge, and others have followed Rich in this error. The lad's age was really not less than nineteen or twenty. According to the family legend, his ship touched at Lisbon on the way out; one cannot decide whether this was just before or immediately after the great earthquake. Then to New France, where he joined Montcalm. Entering the service as cadet, he advanced to the rank of lieutenant; was mentioned in the Gazette; shared in the French successes; drew maps of the forests and block-houses that found their way to the king's cabinet; served with Montcalm in the attack upon Fort William Henry. With that the record is broken off: we can less definitely associate his name with the humiliation of the French in America than with their brief triumphs. Yet it is quite certain, says Robert de Crevecoeur, his descendant, that he did not return to France with the rag-tag of the defeated army. Quebec fell before Wolfe's attack in September 1759; at some time in the course of the year 1760 we may suppose the young officer to have entered the British colonies; to have adopted his family name of "Saint John" (Saint-Jean), and to have gradually worked his way south, probably by the Hudson. The reader of the Letters hardly supposes him to have enjoyed his frontier life; nor is there any means of knowing how much of that life it was his fortune to lead. In time, he found himself as far south as Pennsylvania. He visited Shippensburg and Lancaster and Carlisle; perhaps he resided at or near one of these towns. Many years later, when his son Louis purchased a farm of two hundred acres from Chancellor Livingstone, at Navesink, near the Blue Mountains, Crevecoeur the elder was still remembered; and it may have been at this epoch that he visited the place. During the term of his military service under Montcalm, Crevecoeur saw something of the Great Lakes and the outlying country; prior to his experience as a cultivator, and, indeed, after he had settled down as such, he "travelled like Plato," even visited Bermuda, by his own account. Not until 1764, however, have we any positive evidence of his whereabouts; it was in April of that year that he took out naturalisation papers at New York. Some months later, he installed himself on the farm variously called Greycourt and Pine-Hill, in the same state; he drained a great marsh there, and seems to have practised agriculture upon a generous scale. The certificate of the marriage of Crevecoeur to Mehitable Tippet, of Yonkers is dated September 20, 1769; and of this union three children were the issue. And more than children: for with the marriage ceremony once performed by the worthy Tetard, a clergyman of New York, formerly settled over a French Reformed Church at Charleston, South Carolina, Crevecoeur is more definitely than ever the "American Farmer"; he has thrown in his lot with that new country; his children are to be called after their parent's adopted name, Saint-John; the responsibilities of the adventurer are multiplied; his life in America has become a matter more easy to trace and richer, perhaps, in meaning.
From school, the future woodsman moved to England. A distant relative was living near Salisbury; for some reason, the boy was sent there to finish his education. From England, for motives we aren't sure of, he set off for the New World, where he would spend his busiest and happiest days. In the Bibliotheca Americana Nova, Rich states that Crevecoeur was only sixteen when he made the leap, and others have repeated this mistake. The boy was actually at least nineteen or twenty. According to family legend, his ship stopped in Lisbon on the way; it’s unclear if this was just before or right after the great earthquake. Then he went to New France, where he joined Montcalm. Starting as a cadet, he rose to the rank of lieutenant, was mentioned in the Gazette, participated in French victories, drew maps of the forests and blockhouses that were sent to the king’s cabinet, and served with Montcalm in the attack on Fort William Henry. After that, the record goes quiet: we can less distinctly link his name with the French humiliation in America than with their brief triumphs. Yet it is certain, as stated by Robert de Crevecoeur, his descendant, that he did not return to France with the defeated army. Quebec fell before Wolfe's attack in September 1759; at some point during 1760, we can assume he entered the British colonies, adopted the family name "Saint John" (Saint-Jean), and gradually made his way south, probably via the Hudson River. Readers of the Letters likely don't think he enjoyed his frontier life, nor do we know how much of that life he actually experienced. Eventually, he reached as far south as Pennsylvania. He visited Shippensburg, Lancaster, and Carlisle; he might have lived in or near one of these towns. Many years later, when his son Louis bought a two hundred-acre farm from Chancellor Livingstone at Navesink, near the Blue Mountains, Crevecoeur the elder was still remembered; it’s possible he visited during that time. During his military service under Montcalm, Crevecoeur explored parts of the Great Lakes and the surrounding areas; before his farming experience, and even after he settled into that role, he "traveled like Plato," and even visited Bermuda, by his own account. However, we don’t have clear evidence of his whereabouts until 1764; it was in April of that year that he applied for naturalization papers in New York. A few months later, he settled on a farm known as Greycourt or Pine-Hill in the same state; he drained a large marsh there and seems to have practiced agriculture on a generous scale. The certificate of Crevecoeur's marriage to Mehitable Tippet of Yonkers is dated September 20, 1769; three children resulted from this union. And more than just children: with the marriage ceremony performed by the respectable Reverend Tetard, a clergyman of New York who had previously served a French Reformed Church in Charleston, South Carolina, Crevecoeur is now more definitively the "American Farmer"; he has committed himself to this new country; his children will carry their parents' adopted name, Saint-John; the responsibilities of the adventurer have multiplied; his life in America is now easier to trace and perhaps richer in meaning.
II
One of the historians of American literature has written that these Letters furnish "a greater number of delightful pages than any other book written in America during the eighteenth century, save only Franklin's Autobiography." A safe compliment, this; and yet does not the very emptiness of American annals during the eighteenth century make for our cherishing all that they offer of the vivid and the significant? Professor Moses Coit Tyler long ago suggested what was the literary influence of the American Farmer, whose "idealised treatment of rural life in America wrought quite traceable effects upon the imaginations of Campbell, Byron, Southey, Coleridge, and furnished not a few materials for such captivating and airy schemes of literary colonisation in America as that of 'Pantisocracy.'" Hazlitt praised the book to his friends and, as we have seen, commended it to readers of the Edinburgh Review. Lamb mentions it in one of his letters—which is already some distinction. Yet when was a book more completely lost to popular view—even among the books that have deserved oblivion? The Letters were published, all the same, at Belfast and Dublin and Philadelphia, as well as at London; they were recast in French by the author, translated into German and Dutch by pirating penny-a-liners, and given a "sequel" by a publisher at Paris. [Footnote: Ouvrage pour servir de suite aux Lettres d'un cultivateur Americain, Paris, 1785. The work so offered seems to have been a translation of John Filson's History of Kentucky (Wilmington, Del., 1784).]
One of the historians of American literature has said that these Letters provide "a greater number of delightful pages than any other book written in America during the eighteenth century, except for Franklin's Autobiography." That's a safe compliment; yet doesn't the lack of notable American history during the eighteenth century make us appreciate everything they offer that is vivid and significant? Professor Moses Coit Tyler suggested long ago what the literary influence of the American Farmer was, whose "idealized portrayal of rural life in America had quite noticeable effects on the imaginations of Campbell, Byron, Southey, Coleridge, and provided several ideas for captivating and airy schemes of literary colonization in America, like 'Pantisocracy.'" Hazlitt praised the book to his friends and, as we have seen, recommended it to readers of the Edinburgh Review. Lamb mentions it in one of his letters—which is already a notable distinction. Yet when was a book ever more completely forgotten by the public—even among those that deserved to be forgotten? The Letters were still published in Belfast, Dublin, and Philadelphia, as well as London; the author rewrote them in French, they were translated into German and Dutch by penny-a-liners, and a publisher in Paris produced a "sequel." [Footnote: Ouvrage pour servir de suite aux Lettres d'un cultivateur Americain, Paris, 1785. The work offered seems to have been a translation of John Filson's History of Kentucky (Wilmington, Del., 1784).]
The American Fanner made his first public appearance eleven years before Chateaubriand found a publisher for his Essai sur les Revolutions, wherein the great innovator first used the American materials that he worked over more effectively in his travels, tales, and memoirs. In Saint-John de Crevecoeur, we have a contemporary—a correspondent, even—of Franklin; but if our author shared many of poor Richard's interests, one may travel far without finding a more complete antithesis to that common-sense philosopher.
The American Farmer made his first public appearance eleven years before Chateaubriand found a publisher for his Essay on the Revolutions, where the great innovator first used the American materials that he refined during his travels, stories, and memoirs. In Saint-John de Crevecoeur, we have a contemporary—almost a correspondent—of Franklin; but while our author shared many of Poor Richard's interests, one can travel far without finding a more complete contrast to that practical philosopher.
Crevecoeur expresses mild wonderment that, while so many travellers visit Italy and "the town of Pompey under ground," few come to the new continent, where may be studied, not what is found in books, but "the humble rudiments and embryos of society spreading everywhere, the recent foundations of our towns, and the settlements of so many rural districts." In the course of his sixteen or seventeen years' experience as an American farmer he himself studied all these matters; and he gives us a charming picture of them. Though his book has very little obvious system, its author describes for us frontier and farm; the ways of the Nantucket fishermen and their intrepid wives; life in the Middle Colonies; the refinements and atrocities of Charleston. Crevecoeur's account of the South (that he knew but superficially and—who knows?—more, it may be, by Tetard's anecdotes than through personal knowledge) is the least satisfactory part of his performance. One feels it to be the most "literary" portion of a book whose beauty is naivete. But whether we accept or reject the story of the negro malefactor hung in a cage from a tree, and pecked at by crows, it is certain that the traveller justly regarded slavery as the one conspicuous blot on the new country's shield. Crevecoeur was not an active abolitionist, like that other naturalised Frenchman, Benezet of Philadelphia; he had his own slaves to work his northern farms; he was, however, a man of humane feelings—one who "had his doubts." [Footnote: In his Voyage dans la Haute Pensylvanie (sic) et dans l'Etat de New York (Paris, 1801) slavery is severely attacked by Crevecoeur. His descendant, Robert de Crevecoeur, refers to him as "a friend of Wilberforce."] And his narrative description of life in the American colonies in the years immediately preceding the Revolution is one that social historians cannot ignore.
Crevecoeur expresses mild surprise that, while many travelers visit Italy and "the town of Pompey underground," few come to the new continent, where one can study not just what's in books, but "the humble beginnings and early stages of society spreading everywhere, the recent foundations of our towns, and the settlements of so many rural areas." During his sixteen or seventeen years as an American farmer, he explored all these aspects himself and paints a charming picture of them. Even though his book doesn’t have a clear structure, he describes the frontier and farms, the lifestyles of the Nantucket fishermen and their brave wives, life in the Middle Colonies, and the complexities and horrors of Charleston. Crevecoeur's description of the South (which he knew only superficially and—who knows?—perhaps more from Tetard's stories than personal experience) is the least satisfying part of his work. It feels like the most "literary" part of a book whose beauty lies in its simplicity. But whether we accept or reject the story of the enslaved person hung in a cage from a tree and pecked at by crows, it’s clear that the traveler rightly saw slavery as the biggest stain on the new country's reputation. Crevecoeur wasn’t an active abolitionist like another naturalized Frenchman, Benezet of Philadelphia; he had his own slaves to work his northern farms. However, he was a man with humane feelings—one who "had his doubts." [Footnote: In his Voyage dans la Haute Pensylvanie (sic) et dans l'Etat de New York (Paris, 1801), Crevecoeur strongly criticizes slavery. His descendant, Robert de Crevecoeur, refers to him as "a friend of Wilberforce."] His detailed description of life in the American colonies right before the Revolution is something that social historians cannot overlook.
Though our Farmer emphasises his plainness, and promises the readers of his Letters only a matter-of-fact account of his pursuits, he has his full share of eighteenth-century "sensibility." Since he is, however, at many removes from the sophistications of London and Paris, he is moved, not by the fond behaviour of a lap-dog, or the "little arrangements" carters make with the bridles of their faithful asses (that they have driven to death, belike), but by such matters as he finds at home. "When I contemplate my wife, by my fire-side, while she either spins, knits, darns, or suckles our child, I cannot describe the various emotions of love, of gratitude, or conscious pride which thrill in my heart, and often overflow in voluntary tears …" He is like that old classmate's of Fitzgerald's, buried deep "in one of the most out-of-the-way villages in all England," for if he goes abroad, "it is always involuntary. I never return home without feeling some pleasant emotion, which I often suppress as useless and foolish." He has his reveries; but they are pure and generous; their subject is the future of his children. In midwinter, instead of trapping and "murthering" the quail, "often in the angles of the fences where the motion of the wind prevents the snow from settling, I carry them both chaff and grain: the one to feed them, the other to prevent their tender feet from freezing fast to the earth as I have frequently observed them to do." His love of birds is marked: this in those provinces of which a German traveller wrote: "In the thrush kind America is poor; there is only the red-breasted robin. … There are no sparrows. Very few birds nest in the woods; a solemn stillness prevails through them, interrupted only by the screaming of the crows." It is good, after such a passage as this has been quoted, to set down what Crevecoeur says of the bird kingdom. "In the spring," he writes, "I generally rise from bed about that indistinct interval which, properly speaking, is neither night nor day:" for then it is that he enjoys "the universal vocal choir." He continues—more and more lyrically: "Who can listen unmoved, to the sweet love-tales of our robins, told from tree to tree? Or to the shrill cat birds? The sublime accents of the thrush from on high, always retard my steps, that I may listen to the delicious music." And the Farmer is no less interested in "the astonishing art which all birds display in the construction of their nests, ill provided as we may suppose them with proper tools; their neatness, their convenience." At some time during his American residence he gathered the materials for an unpublished study of ants; and his bees proved an unfailing source of entertainment. "Their government, their industry, their quarrels, their passions, always present me with something new," he writes; adding that he is most often to be found, in hours of rest, under the locust tree where his beehive stands. "By their movements," says he, "I can predict the weather, and can tell the day of their swarming." When other men go hunting game, he goes bee-hunting. Such are the matters he tells of in his Letters.
Though our Farmer emphasizes his straightforwardness and promises his readers a practical account of his pursuits, he experiences his fair share of 18th-century "sensibility." However, since he is far removed from the sophistication of London and Paris, he is inspired not by the affection of a lapdog or the "little arrangements" that cart drivers make with the bridles of their faithful donkeys (which they might have driven to their limits), but by the things he encounters at home. "When I look at my wife by the fire, as she either spins, knits, darns, or nurses our child, I can’t describe the mix of love, gratitude, or pride that fills my heart and often spills over into spontaneous tears…" He is like that old classmate of Fitzgerald's, buried deep "in one of the most remote villages in all England," because if he goes out, "it’s always unintentional. I never come home without feeling some pleasant emotion, which I often ignore as unnecessary and silly." He has his daydreams; but they are pure and generous; their focus is on the future of his children. In midwinter, instead of trapping and "murdering" the quail, "often in the corners of the fences where the wind's movement prevents the snow from piling up, I bring them both chaff and grain: one to feed them, and the other to stop their delicate feet from freezing to the ground, which I have often seen them do." His love of birds is evident: this is true in those regions that a German traveler noted: "In the thrush category, America is lacking; there is only the red-breasted robin. … There are no sparrows. Very few birds nest in the woods; a solemn stillness fills them, broken only by the cawing of the crows." After such a passage, it's good to mention what Crevecoeur says about the avian world. "In spring," he writes, "I typically get out of bed around that unclear time which is technically neither night nor day:" for that's when he enjoys "the universal vocal choir." He continues—more and more poetically: "Who can listen without being moved by the sweet love stories of our robins, shared from tree to tree? Or to the shrill catbirds? The beautiful songs of the thrush from above always slow me down so I can enjoy the delightful music." The Farmer is equally fascinated by "the incredible skill all birds show in building their nests, despite what we might think about their lack of proper tools; their neatness, their practicality." At some point during his time in America, he collected materials for an unpublished study of ants; and his bees provided constant entertainment. "Their organization, their hard work, their conflicts, their emotions always bring me something new," he writes; adding that he is most often found, during his downtime, under the locust tree where his beehive is located. "By their movements," he says, "I can forecast the weather and know when they will swarm." While other men go hunting game, he goes bee hunting. These are the topics he explores in his Letters.
One difference from the stereotyped "sensibility" of the old world one may discover in the openness of Crevecoeur's heart; and that is the completeness of his interest in all the humbler sorts of natural phenomena. Nature is, for him, no mere bundle of poetic stage- properties, soiled by much handling, but something fresh and inviting and full of interest to a man alive. He takes more pleasure in hunting bees than in expeditions with his dogs and gun; the king- birds destroy his bees—but, he adds, they drive the crows away. Ordinarily he could not persuade himself to shoot them. On one occasion, however, he fired at a more than commonly impertinent specimen, "and immediately opened his maw, from which I took 171 bees; I laid them all on a blanket in the sun, and to my great surprise fifty-four returned to life, licked themselves clean, and joyfully went back to the hive, where they probably informed their companions of such an adventure and escape, as I believe had never happened before to American bees." Must one regard this as a fable? It is by no means as remarkable a yarn as one may find told by other naturalists of the same century. There is, for example, that undated letter of John Bartram's, in which he makes inquiries of his brother William concerning "Ye Wonderful Flower;" [Footnote: see "A Botanical Marvel," in The Nation (New York), August 5, 1909.] there is, too, Kalm's report of Bartram's bear: "When a bear catches a cow, he kills her in the following manner: he bites a hole into the hide and blows with all his power into it, till the animal swells excessively and dies; for the air expands greatly between the flesh and the hide." After these fine fancies, where is the improbability of Crevecoeur's modest adaptation of the Jonah-allegory that he applies to the king-bird and his bees? The episode suggests, for that matter, a chapter in Mitchell's My Farm at Edgewood. Mitchell, a later American farmer, describes the same king-birds, the same bees; has, too, the same supremely gentle spirit. "I have not the heart to shoot at the king-birds; nor do I enter very actively into the battle of the bees. … I give them fair play, good lodging, limitless flowers, willows bending (as Virgil advises) into the quiet water of a near pool; I have even read up the stories of a poor blind Huber, who so dearly loved the bees, and the poem of Giovanni Rucellai, for their benefit." Can the reader state, without stopping to consider, which author it was that wrote thus—Mitchell or Crevecoeur? Certainly it is the essential modernity of the earlier writer's style that most impresses one, after the charm of his pictures. His was the age of William Livingston—later Governor of the State of New Jersey; and in the very year when a London publisher was bringing out the first edition of the Farmer's Letters, Livingston, described on his title-page as a "young gentleman educated at Yale College," brought out his Philosophic Solitude at Trenton, in his native state. It is worth quoting Philosophic Solitude for the sake of the comparison to be drawn between Crevecoeur's prose and contemporary American verse:-
One difference from the stereotypical "sensibility" of the past is the openness of Crevecoeur's heart, and that is the totality of his interest in all the simpler kinds of natural phenomena. For him, nature isn't just a collection of poetic props, tarnished from excessive use; it's something fresh, inviting, and full of interest for a living person. He finds more joy in observing bees than in outings with his dogs and gun; although the king-birds eat his bees, he notes they also scare the crows away. Usually, he can't bring himself to shoot them. However, one time, he took aim at a particularly bold one, "and immediately opened its mouth, from which I took 171 bees; I laid them all on a blanket in the sun, and to my great surprise fifty-four revived, cleaned themselves, and happily returned to the hive, where they probably told their friends about such an adventure and escape, as I believe had never happened before to American bees." Should we consider this a fable? It's not nearly as unbelievable as some stories you might find from other naturalists of the same century. For instance, there's that undated letter from John Bartram, in which he asks his brother William about "Ye Wonderful Flower;" [Footnote: see "A Botanical Marvel," in The Nation (New York), August 5, 1909.] and there's Kalm's report about Bartram's bear: "When a bear catches a cow, he kills her in the following way: he bites a hole into the hide and blows with all his strength into it, until the animal swells excessively and dies; for the air significantly expands between the flesh and the hide." After these intriguing stories, where's the improbability in Crevecoeur's humble take on the Jonah allegory that he relates to the king-bird and his bees? The incident is reminiscent of a chapter in Mitchell's My Farm at Edgewood. Mitchell, a later American farmer, describes the same king-birds and bees; he shares the same deeply gentle spirit. "I can’t bring myself to shoot at the king-birds; nor do I actively engage in the battle of the bees. … I give them fair play, good shelter, endless flowers, and willows leaning (just as Virgil suggests) into the calm water of a nearby pool; I’ve even read the stories of a poor blind Huber, who loved the bees dearly, and the poem by Giovanni Rucellai, for their benefit." Can the reader quickly say which author wrote this—Mitchell or Crevecoeur? Certainly, the truly modern style of the earlier writer is what most impresses one, alongside the charm of his imagery. He lived in the time of William Livingston—who later became the Governor of New Jersey; and in the very year when a London publisher was releasing the first edition of the Farmer's Letters, Livingston, noted on his title page as a "young gentleman educated at Yale College," published his Philosophic Solitude in Trenton, in his home state. It's worth quoting Philosophic Solitude for the sake of comparing Crevecoeur's prose with contemporary American verse:
"Let ardent heroes seek renown in arms,
Pant after fame, and rush to war's alarms …
Mine be the pleasures of a RURAL life."
"Let passionate heroes chase glory in battle,
Long for fame, and rush to the call of war …
I'll take the joys of a COUNTRY life."
The thought is, after all, the same as that which we have found less directly phrased in Crevecoeur. But let us quote the lines that follow the exordium—now we should find the poet unconstrained and fancy-free:—
The idea is, after all, the same as what we’ve seen more subtly expressed in Crevecoeur. But let’s quote the lines that come after the introduction—now we should see the poet relaxed and uninhibited:—
"Me to sequestred scenes, ye muses, guide,
Where nature wantons in her virgin-pride;
To mossy banks edg'd round with op'ning flow'rs,
Elysian fields, and amaranthin bow'rs. …
Welcome, ye shades! all hail, ye vernal blooms!
Ye bow'ry thickets, and prophetic glooms!
Ye forests hail! ye solitary woods. …"
"Me to hidden places, oh muses, lead,
Where nature plays in her pure beauty;
To grassy banks lined with blooming flowers,
Heavenly fields, and everlasting groves. …
Welcome, you shadows! all cheers, you spring flowers!
You leafy thickets, and mysterious darks!
You forests greet! you lonely woods. …"
and the "solitary woods" (rhyming with "floods") are a good place to leave the "young gentleman educated at Yale College." Livingston was, plainly enough, a poet of his time and place. He had a fine eye for Nature—seen through library windows. He echoed Goldsmith and a whole line of British poets—echoed them atrociously.
and the "solitary woods" (rhyming with "floods") are a good place to leave the "young gentleman educated at Yale College." Livingston was clearly a poet of his time and place. He had a great eye for Nature—seen through library windows. He imitated Goldsmith and a whole line of British poets—imitated them poorly.
That one finds no "echoes" in Crevecoeur is one of our reasons for praising his spontaneity and vigour. He did not import nightingales into his America, as some of the poets did. He blazed away, rather, toward our present day appreciation of surrounding nature—which was not banal then. Crevecoeur's honest and unconventionalised love of his rural environment is great enough to bridge the difference between the eighteenth and the twentieth century. It is as easy for us to pass a happy evening with him as it was for Thomas Campbell, figuring to himself a realisation of Cowley's dreams and of Rousseau's poetic seclusion; "till at last," in Southey's words, "comes an ill-looking Indian with a tomahawk, and scalps me—a most melancholy proof that society is very bad." It is the freshness, the youthfulness, of these Letters, after their century and more of dust-gathering, that is least likely to escape us. And this "Farmer in Pennsylvania" is almost as unmistakably of kin with good Gilbert White of Selborne as he is the American Thoreau's eighteenth-century forerunner.
The fact that you won’t find any “echoes” in Crevecoeur is one of the reasons we admire his spontaneity and energy. He didn’t bring nightingales into his America like some poets did. Instead, he boldly moved toward our modern appreciation of nature—which wasn’t considered cliché back then. Crevecoeur's genuine and unconventional love for his rural surroundings is strong enough to connect the eighteenth and twentieth centuries. It’s just as enjoyable for us to spend a pleasant evening with him as it was for Thomas Campbell, imagining a realization of Cowley’s dreams and Rousseau’s poetic solitude; “until at last,” in Southey’s words, “comes an ill-looking Indian with a tomahawk, and scalps me—a most depressing indication that society is very bad.” The freshness and youthfulness of these Letters, after more than a century of gathering dust, is something that stands out to us. This “Farmer in Pennsylvania” is almost as closely related to the good Gilbert White of Selborne as he is to Thoreau's eighteenth-century predecessor.
III
It is time, indeed, that we made the discovery that Crevecoeur was a modern. He was, too, a dweller in the young republic—even before it WAS a republic. Twice a year he had "the pleasure of catching pigeons, whose numbers are sometimes so astonishing as to obscure the sun in their flight." There is, then, no poetic licence about Longfellow's description, in Evangeline, of how—
It is time we recognized that Crevecoeur was a modern. He was also a resident of the young republic—even before it officially became a republic. Twice a year, he enjoyed "the pleasure of catching pigeons, whose numbers can be so astonishing they obscure the sun in their flight." Therefore, there is no poetic license in Longfellow's description, in Evangeline, of how—
"A pestilence fell on the city Presaged by wondrous signs, and mostly by flocks of wild pigeons, Darkening the sun in their flight, with naught in their craws but an acorn."
A plague hit the city, foretold by amazing signs, especially by flocks of wild pigeons that darkened the sun as they flew, carrying nothing but an acorn in their beaks.
Longfellow could have cited as his authority for this flight of pigeons Mathew Carey's Record of the Malignant Fever lately Prevalent, published at Philadelphia, which, to be sure, discusses a different epidemic, but tells us that "amongst the country people, large quantities of wild pigeons in the spring are regarded as certain indications of an unhealthy summer. Whether or not this prognostic has ever been verified, I cannot tell. But it is very certain that during the last spring the numbers of these birds brought to market were immense. Never, perhaps, were there so many before."
Longfellow could have referenced Mathew Carey's Record of the Malignant Fever Recently Prevalent, published in Philadelphia, as his source for this mention of pigeons. While it discusses a different epidemic, it states that "among the rural population, large amounts of wild pigeons in the spring are seen as a sure sign of an unhealthy summer. I can't say if this prediction has ever been proven true. However, it's clear that last spring, the number of these birds sold in the market was huge. Perhaps there have never been so many before."
Carey wrote in 1793, the year, as has been noted, of the first American reprint of the Letters, that had first been published at London. Carey was himself Crevecoeur's American publisher; and he may well have thought as he wrote the lines quoted of Crevecoeur's earlier pigeons "obscuring the sun in their flight." Crevecoeur had by this time returned to France, and was never more to ply the avocations of the American farmer. In the interval, much had happened to this victim of both the revolutions. Though the Letters are distinguished by an idyllic temper, over them is thrown the shadow of impending civil war. The Farmer was a man of peace, for all his experience under Montcalm in Canada (and even there his part was rather an engineer's than a combatant's); he long hoped, therefore, that peaceful counsels would prevail, and that England and the colonies would somehow come to an understanding without hostilities. Then, after the Americans had boldly broken with the home government, he lent them all his sympathy but not his arms. He had his family to watch over; likewise his two farms, one in Orange County, New York, one in New Jersey. As it was, the Indians in the royal service burned his New Jersey estate; and after his first return to France (he was called thither by his father, we are told, though we know nothing of the motives of this recall) he entered upon a new phase of his career. "After his first return to France," I have said, as if that had been an entirely simple matter. One cannot here describe all its alleged difficulties; his arrest at New York as a suspected spy (though after having secured a pass from the American commander. General MacDougal, he had secured a second pass from General Clinton, and permission to embark for France); his detention in the provost's prison in New York; the final embarkation with his oldest son—this on September 1, 1780; the shipwreck which he described as occurring off the Irish coast; his residence for some months in Great Britain, and during a part of that time in London, where he sold the manuscript of the Letters for thirty guineas. One would like to know Crevecoeur's emotions on finally reaching France and joining his father and relatives at Caen. One would like to describe his romantic succour of five American seamen, who had escaped from an English prison and crossed the Channel in a sloop to Normandy. A cousin of one of these seamen, a Captain Fellowes of Boston, was later to befriend Crevecoeur's daughter and younger son in the new country; that was after the Loyalists and their Indian allies had destroyed the Farmer's house at Pine Hill, after his wife had fled to Westchester with her two children, and had died there soon after, leaving them unprotected. But all this must, in nautical phrase, "go by the board," including the novel founded upon the episode. Nor can we linger over Crevecoeur's entry into polite society, both in the Norman capital and at Paris. Fancy the returned prodigal—if one may so describe him—in the salon of Madame d'Houdetot, Rousseau's former mistress! He was fairly launched, this American Farmer, in the society of the lettres.
Carey wrote in 1793, the same year as the first American reprint of the Letters, which had originally been published in London. Carey was also Crevecoeur's American publisher; he may have thought about Crevecoeur's earlier pigeons "obscuring the sun in their flight" while writing the quoted lines. By this time, Crevecoeur had returned to France and never again practiced the lifestyle of an American farmer. A lot had happened to this victim of both revolutions during the interim. Although the Letters have a peaceful quality, there's an underlying shadow of an approaching civil war. The Farmer was a man of peace, despite his experiences under Montcalm in Canada (where he primarily acted as an engineer rather than a soldier); he had long hoped that peaceful discussions would lead to an understanding between England and the colonies without any conflict. After the Americans boldly broke away from the home government, he sympathized with them but didn't take up arms. He had his family and two farms to care for, one in Orange County, New York, and the other in New Jersey. As fate would have it, Native Americans in royal service burned down his New Jersey estate; after his initial return to France (which was prompted by his father, though the reasons for this recall are unknown), he entered a new stage in his life. "After his first return to France," I say, as if that was a completely straightforward process. The alleged challenges he faced are hard to describe here; he was arrested in New York as a suspected spy (even though he had secured a pass from the American commander, General MacDougal, and then another pass from General Clinton, allowing him to leave for France); he endured detention in the provost's prison in New York; he finally embarked with his oldest son on September 1, 1780; he faced a shipwreck off the Irish coast; he spent a few months in Great Britain, part of which was in London, where he sold the manuscript of the Letters for thirty guineas. It would be interesting to know Crevecoeur's feelings upon finally arriving in France and reuniting with his father and relatives in Caen. It would be fascinating to recount his heroic support of five American sailors who escaped from an English prison and crossed the Channel to Normandy in a sloop. A cousin of one of those sailors, Captain Fellowes of Boston, later befriended Crevecoeur's daughter and younger son in the new world; this happened after the Loyalists and their Native American allies destroyed the Farmer's house at Pine Hill, after his wife fled to Westchester with their two children and soon died there, leaving them vulnerable. But all of this must, in nautical terms, "go by the board," including the novel inspired by the episode. We also can't dwell on Crevecoeur's entrance into high society, both in the Norman capital and in Paris. Imagine the returned prodigal—if one can call him that—among the guests at Madame d'Houdetot's salon, Rousseau's former mistress! This American Farmer was now firmly established in literary society.
"Twice a week," he wrote, some years after, "I went with M. de Turgot to see the Duchesse de Beauvilliers, his sister; and another twice-a-week I went with him to the Comte de Buffon's. … It was at the table of M. de Buffon, it was in his salon, during long winter evenings, that I was awakened once more to the graces, the beauties, the timid purity of our tongue, which, during my long sojourn in North America, had become foreign to me, and of which I had almost lost command—though not the memory."
"Twice a week," he wrote, some years later, "I went with M. de Turgot to visit the Duchesse de Beauvilliers, his sister; and another twice a week, I went with him to see the Comte de Buffon. … It was at M. de Buffon's table, in his living room, during long winter nights, that I was reminded once again of the grace, beauty, and gentle purity of our language, which, during my long time in North America, had become unfamiliar to me, and of which I had almost lost my grip—though not the memory."
Madame d'Houdetot presented Crevecoeur to the families of La
Rochefoucauld, Liancourt, d'Estissac, Breteuil, Rohan-Chabot,
Beauvau, Necker; to the academicians d'Alembert, La Harpe, Grimm,
Suard, Rulbriere; to the poet-academician Delille. We have in the
Memoires of Brissot an allusion to his entrance into this society,
under the wing of his elderly protectress:—
Madame d'Houdetot introduced Crevecoeur to the families of La
Rochefoucauld, Liancourt, d'Estissac, Breteuil, Rohan-Chabot,
Beauvau, Necker; to the scholars d'Alembert, La Harpe, Grimm,
Suard, Rulbriere; to the poet-scholar Delille. In the
Memoirs of Brissot, there’s a reference to his joining this group,
with the support of his older mentor:—
"Proud of possessing an American savage, she wished to form him, and to launch him in society. He had the good sense to refuse and to confine himself to the picked society of men of letters."
"Proud of having an American savage, she wanted to shape him and introduce him to society. He had the good sense to decline and stick to the select company of writers."
It was at a later period that Brissot and Crevecoeur were to meet; their quarrel, naturally, came later still.
It was at a later time that Brissot and Crevecoeur would meet; their argument, of course, came even later.
Madame d'Houdetot did more than entertain the Farmer, whose father had been one of her oldest friends. She secured his nomination as Consul-General to the United States, now recognised by France; it was at New York that he took up residence. Through the influence of Madame d'Houdetot and her friends, he retained the appointment through the stormy years that followed, though in the end he was obliged to make way for a successor more in sympathy with the violent republicanism of the age. Throughout the years of the French Revolution, the ex-farmer lived a life of retirement, and, if never of conspicuous danger, of embarrassment enough, and of humiliation. We need not discuss those years spent at Paris; or the visits paid, after the close of the Revolution, to his son-in-law and daughter, for his daughter Frances-America was married to a French Secretary of Legation, who became a Count of the Empire. Now he was in Paris or the suburbs; now in London, or Munich. Five years of the Farmer's later life were spent at the Bavarian capital; Maximilian entertained him there, and told him that he had read his book with the keenest pleasure and great profit too. He busied himself in preparing his three-volume Voyage dans la Haute Pensylvanie (sic) et dans l'Etat de New York, and in adding to his paper on potato culture,[Footnote: Traite de la Culture des Pommes de Terre, 1782.] a second on the false acacia; but his best work was done and he knew it. Crevecoeur lived on until 1813, dying in the same year with Madame d'Houdetot, who was so much his elder. He paid a worthy tribute to that lady's character; perhaps we do her an injustice in knowing her only for the liaison with Jean-Jacques. He died on November 12, 1813: member of agricultural societies and of the Academy (section of moral and political science), and of Franklin's Philosophical Society at Philadelphia. A town in Vermont had been named St. Johnsbury in his honour; he had the freedom of more than one New England city. It is, none the less, as the author of Letters from an American Farmer, published in 1782, and written, for the most part, years before that date, that we remember him—so far as we do remember.
Madame d'Houdetot did more than entertain the Farmer, whose father had been one of her oldest friends. She helped him get appointed as Consul-General to the United States, which France had now recognized; he settled in New York. Thanks to Madame d'Houdetot and her connections, he held onto the position during the turbulent years that followed, though eventually he had to step aside for a successor who better aligned with the extreme republicanism of the time. During the French Revolution, the ex-farmer lived a quiet life that wasn't particularly dangerous but was filled with enough embarrassment and humiliation. We won't delve into those years spent in Paris or the visits he made, after the Revolution ended, to see his son-in-law and daughter, as his daughter Frances-America was married to a French Secretary of Legation who became a Count of the Empire. He fluctuated between Paris or its suburbs, London, and Munich. Five years of the Farmer’s later life were spent in the Bavarian capital, where Maximilian hosted him and mentioned that he had read his book with great enjoyment and benefit. He occupied himself with getting ready his three-volume *Voyage dans la Haute Pensylvanie (sic) et dans l'Etat de New York* and adding to his paper on potato farming, [Footnote: Traite de la Culture des Pommes de Terre, 1782.] a second piece on the false acacia; but he knew his best work was behind him. Crevecoeur lived on until 1813, passing away in the same year as Madame d'Houdetot, who was significantly older than him. He paid a fitting tribute to her character; perhaps we do her an injustice by only knowing her for the affair with Jean-Jacques. He died on November 12, 1813: a member of agricultural societies and of the Academy (section of moral and political science), and of Franklin's Philosophical Society in Philadelphia. A town in Vermont was named St. Johnsbury in his honor; he was granted the freedom of more than one New England city. Nonetheless, it is primarily as the author of *Letters from an American Farmer*, published in 1782 and mostly written years earlier, that we remember him—at least as much as we do.
IV
Much remains unsaid—much, even, of the essential. Some of the facts are still unknown; others may be looked for in the biography written by his great-grandson, Robert de Crevecoeur, and published at Paris some eighty years ago. There is hardly occasion to discuss here what Crevecoeur did, as consul at New York, to encourage the exchange of French manufactures and American exports; or to tell of his packet- line—the first established between New York and a French port; or to set down the story of his children; or to describe those last sad years, at home and abroad, after the close of his consular career. There is no room at all for the words of praise that were spoken of the Letters by Franklin and Washington, who recommended them to intending immigrants as a faithful, albeit "highly coloured" picture. We must let the writings of the American Farmer speak for themselves: they belong, after all, to literature.
Much is left unsaid—much, even, of the important stuff. Some of the facts are still unknown; others can be found in the biography written by his great-grandson, Robert de Crevecoeur, and published in Paris about eighty years ago. There’s really no need to discuss what Crevecoeur did as consul in New York to promote the exchange of French goods and American exports; or to talk about his packet line—the first one set up between New York and a French port; or to recount the story of his children; or to describe those last sad years, at home and abroad, after he ended his consular career. There’s no space here for the praises that Franklin and Washington gave to the Letters, recommending them to prospective immigrants as a true, though "highly colored," depiction. We should let the writings of the American Farmer speak for themselves: they are, after all, part of literature.
It was a modest man—a modest life; a life filled, none the less, with romantic incident. All this throws into relief the beauty of its best fruits. Crevecoeur made no claim to artistry when he wrote his simple, heartfelt Letters; and yet his style, in spite of occasional defects and extra flourishes, seems to us worthy of his theme. These Letters from an American Farmer have been an inspiration to poets—and they "smell of the woods."
It was a humble man—a simple life; a life still filled with romantic moments. All this highlights the beauty of its greatest achievements. Crevecoeur didn’t claim to be an artist when he wrote his straightforward, sincere Letters; yet his style, despite some flaws and embellishments, feels fitting for his subject. These Letters from an American Farmer have inspired poets—and they "smell of the woods."
In a prose age, Crevecoeur lived a kind of pastoral poetry; in an age largely blind, he saw the beauties of nature, less through readings in the Nouvelle Heloise and Bernardin's Etudes than with his own keen eyes; he was a true idealist, besides, and as such kindles one's enthusiasm. The man's optimism, his grateful personality, his saneness, too—for here is a dreamer neither idle nor morbid—are qualities no less enduring, or endearing, than his fame as "poet-naturalist." The American Farmer might have used Cotton's Retirement for an epigraph on his title-page:—
In a time focused on prose, Crevecoeur embodied a sort of pastoral poetry; in an era where many were blind, he recognized the beauty of nature, not just through readings of the Nouvelle Heloise and Bernardin's Etudes but with his own sharp perspective; he was a true idealist and, as such, sparked enthusiasm in others. His optimism, his appreciative nature, and his rational mind—here is a dreamer who is neither idle nor gloomy—are qualities that are just as lasting and charming as his reputation as a "poet-naturalist." The American Farmer could have used Cotton's Retirement as an epigraph on his title page:—
"Farewell, thou busy world, and may
We never meet again,
Here I can eat and sleep and pray. …"
"Goodbye, busy world, and may
We never meet again,
Here I can eat, sleep, and pray. …"
but for the fact that he found time to turn the clods, withal, and eyes to watch the earth blackening behind the plough. "Our necessities," wrote Poe, who contended, in a half-hearted way, that the Americans of his generation were as poetical a people as any other, "have been mistaken for our propensities. Having been forced to make railroads, it has been deemed impossible that we should make verse." But here was Saint-John de Crevecoeur writing, in the eighteenth century, his idyllic Letters, while, if he did not build railways, he interested himself in the experiments of Fitch and Rumsey and Parmentier, and organised a packet-line between New York and Lorient, in Brittany. This Crevecoeur should from the first have appealed to the imagination—especially to the American imagination- -combining as he did the faculty of the ideal and the achievement of the actual. It is not too late for him to appeal to-day; in spite of all his quaintness, Crevecoeur is a contemporary of our own.
but because he made time to turn the soil and kept his eyes on the earth darkening behind the plow. "Our needs," wrote Poe, who argued, somewhat half-heartedly, that Americans of his time were just as poetic as any other group, "have been mistaken for our tendencies. Having had to build railroads, it's been thought impossible for us to create verse." Yet here was Saint-John de Crevecoeur, writing his charming Letters in the eighteenth century, while, although he didn’t build railways, he took an interest in the experiments of Fitch, Rumsey, and Parmentier, and organized a packet line between New York and Lorient in Brittany. Crevecoeur should have appealed to the imagination from the very beginning—especially to the American imagination—blending the ideal with real achievements. It's not too late for him to resonate today; despite his quirks, Crevecoeur is relevant to us now.
WARREN BARTON BLAKE.
BRADFORD HILLS, WEST CHESTER, PENNSYLVANIA.
SELECT BIBLIOGRAPHY
Letters from an American Farmer (London), 1782, 1783; (Dublin), 1782; (Belfast), 1783; (Philadelphia), 1793; (New York), 1904; (London), 1908; translated into French (with gratuitous additions) as Lettres d'un cultivateur Americain (Paris), 1784 and 1787; into German as Briefe eines Amerikanischen Landmanns (Leipzig), 1788, 1789. Voyage dans la Haute Pensylvanie et dans l'etat de New York (Paris), 1801.
Letters from an American Farmer (London), 1782, 1783; (Dublin), 1782; (Belfast), 1783; (Philadelphia), 1793; (New York), 1904; (London), 1908; translated into French (with additional content) as Lettres d'un cultivateur Américain (Paris), 1784 and 1787; into German as Briefe eines Amerikanischen Landmanns (Leipzig), 1788, 1789. Voyage dans la Haute Pennsylvanie et dans l'état de New York (Paris), 1801.
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION by Warren Barton Blake
INTRODUCTION by Warren Barton Blake
LETTER
I. INTRODUCTION
II. ON THE SITUATION, FEELINGS, AND PLEASURES OF AN AMERICAN FARMER
III. WHAT IS AN AMERICAN
IV. DESCRIPTION OF THE ISLAND OF NANTUCKET, WITH THE MANNERS, CUSTOMS, POLICY, AND TRADE OF THE INHABITANTS
V. CUSTOMARY EDUCATION AND EMPLOYMENT OF THE INHABITANTS OF NANTUCKET
VI. DESCRIPTION OF THE ISLAND OF MARTHA'S VINEYARD, AND OF THE WHALE FISHERY
VII. MANNERS AND CUSTOMS AT NANTUCKET
VIII. PECULIAR CUSTOMS AT NANTUCKET
IX. DESCRIPTION OF CHARLES-TOWN; THOUGHTS ON SLAVERY; ON PHYSICAL EVIL; A MELANCHOLY SCENE
X. ON SNAKES; AND ON THE HUMMING BIRD.
XI. FROM MR. IW—N AL—Z, A RUSSIAN GENTLEMAN, DESCRIBING THE VISIT HE PAID AT MY REQUEST TO MR. JOHN BERTRAM, THE CELEBRATEDPENNSYLVANIA BOTANIST
XII. DISTRESSES OF A FRONTIER MAN
LETTERS FROM AN AMERICAN FARMER;
DESCRIBING CERTAIN PROVINCIAL SITUATIONS, MANNERS, AND CUSTOMS, NOT GENERALLY KNOWN; AND CONVEYING SOME IDEA OF THE LATE AND PRESENT INTERIOR CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE BRITISH COLONIES IN NORTH AMERICA.
WRITTEN FOR THE INFORMATION OF A FRIEND IN ENGLAND,
By J. HECTOR ST. JOHN, A FARMER IN PENNSYLVANIA
By J. HECTOR ST. JOHN, A FARMER IN PENNSYLVANIA
ADVERTISEMENT
[To the first edition, 1782.]
[To the first edition, 1782.]
The following Letters are the genuine production of the American Farmer whose name they bear. They were privately written to gratify the curiosity of a friend; and are made public, because they contain much authentic information, little known on this side the Atlantic; they cannot therefore fail of being highly interesting to the people of England, at a time when everybody's attention is directed toward the affairs of America.
The following letters are the real work of the American Farmer whose name is attached. They were written privately to satisfy a friend's curiosity and are being shared with the public because they contain a lot of true information that’s not well known on this side of the Atlantic. They’re sure to be very interesting to the people of England, especially now when everyone's focused on the situation in America.
That these letters are the actual result of a private correspondence may fairly be inferred (exclusive of other evidence) from the style and manner in which they are conceived: for though plain and familiar, and sometimes animated, they are by no means exempt from such inaccuracies as must unavoidably occur in the rapid effusions of a confessedly inexperienced writer.
That these letters come from a private conversation can reasonably be inferred (apart from other evidence) from their style and tone: although they are straightforward and casual, and occasionally lively, they are definitely not free from the mistakes that are bound to happen in the quick writing of an obviously inexperienced author.
Our Farmer had long been an eye-witness of transactions that have deformed the face of America: he is one of those who dreaded, and has severely felt, the desolating consequences of a rupture between the parent state and her colonies: for he has been driven from a situation, the enjoyment of which the reader will find pathetically described in the early letters of this volume. The unhappy contest is at length, however, drawing toward a period; and it is now only left us to hope, that the obvious interests and mutual wants of both countries, may in due time, and in spite of all obstacles, happily re-unite them.
Our Farmer had long witnessed events that have changed America for the worse: he is one of those who feared, and has deeply felt, the devastating effects of a break between the mother country and her colonies. He has been forced out of a situation described movingly in the early letters of this volume. However, the unfortunate conflict is finally coming to an end; and now we can only hope that the clear interests and needs of both countries will, in due time and despite all challenges, bring them back together.
Should our Farmer's letters be found to afford matter of useful entertainment to an intelligent and candid public, a second volume, equally interesting with those now published, may soon be expected.
Should our Farmer's letters be found to provide useful entertainment to a thoughtful and open-minded audience, a second volume, just as interesting as those already published, may soon be anticipated.
ADVERTISEMENT
[To the Second Edition, 1783.]
[To the 2nd Edition, 1783.]
Since the publication of this volume, we hear that Mr. St. John has accepted a public employment at New York. It is therefore, perhaps, doubtful whether he will soon be at leisure to revise his papers, and give the world a second collection of the American Farmer Letters.
Since this volume was published, we hear that Mr. St. John has taken a public job in New York. So, it’s maybe uncertain whether he’ll have the time soon to revise his papers and present a second collection of the American Farmer Letters.
TO THE ABBE RAYNAL, F.R.S.
Behold, Sir, an humble American Planter, a simple cultivator of the earth, addressing you from the farther side of the Atlantic; and presuming to fix your name at the head of his trifling lucubrations. I wish they were worthy of so great an honour. Yet why should not I be permitted to disclose those sentiments which I have so often felt from my heart? A few years since, I met accidentally with your Political and Philosophical History, and perused it with infinite pleasure. For the first time in my life I reflected on the relative state of nations; I traced the extended ramifications of a commerce which ought to unite but now convulses the world; I admired that universal benevolence, that diffusive goodwill, which is not confined to the narrow limits of your own country; but, on the contrary, extends to the whole human race. As an eloquent and powerful advocate you have pleaded the cause of humanity in espousing that of the poor Africans: you viewed these provinces of North America in their true light, as the asylum of freedom; as the cradle of future nations, and the refuge of distressed Europeans. Why then should I refrain from loving and respecting a man whose writings I so much admire? These two sentiments are inseparable, at least in my breast. I conceived your genius to be present at the head of my study: under its invisible but powerful guidance, I prosecuted my small labours: and now, permit me to sanctify them under the auspices of your name. Let the sincerity of the motives which urge me, prevent you from thinking that this well meant address contains aught but the purest tribute of reverence and affection. There is, no doubt, a secret communion among good men throughout the world; a mental affinity connecting them by a similitude of sentiments: then, why, though an American, should not I be permitted to share in that extensive intellectual consanguinity? Yes, I do: and though the name of a man who possesses neither titles nor places, who never rose above the humble rank of a farmer, may appear insignificant; yet, as the sentiments I have expressed are also the echo of those of my countrymen; on their behalf, as well as on my own, give me leave to subscribe myself,
Look, Sir, an humble American farmer, a simple cultivator of the land, reaching out to you from across the Atlantic; and daring to place your name at the beginning of my modest writings. I wish they were deserving of such an honor. But why shouldn't I be allowed to express the feelings I've often had in my heart? A few years ago, I stumbled upon your Political and Philosophical History and read it with immense pleasure. For the first time, I reflected on the relationships between nations; I traced the wide-reaching branches of a commerce that should unite us but currently unnerves the world; I admired that universal kindness, that widespread goodwill, which isn't limited to your own country but instead extends to all humanity. As a passionate and compelling advocate, you have championed the cause of humanity by supporting the poor Africans: you viewed these regions of North America for their true potential, as a haven of freedom; the birthplace of future nations, and a refuge for distressed Europeans. So, why should I hold back from loving and respecting a man whose writings I admire so deeply? Those two feelings cannot be separated in my heart. I imagined your spirit guiding me as I studied: under its invisible but powerful influence, I continued my small efforts: and now, allow me to honor them under your name. Let the sincerity of my intentions stop you from thinking that this heartfelt address holds anything but the purest tribute of respect and affection. There is, without a doubt, a hidden connection among good people around the world; a mental bond linking them through similar sentiments: so, why, even as an American, shouldn't I be allowed to share in that vast intellectual kinship? Yes, I do: and though the name of a man who holds no titles or positions, who never rose above the humble status of a farmer, may seem insignificant; yet, because the feelings I expressed are also a reflection of those of my fellow countrymen; on their behalf, as well as my own, allow me to sign myself,
Sir,
Your very sincere admirer,
J. HECTOR ST. JOHN. CARLISLE IN PENNSYLVANIA.
Sir,
Your truly devoted admirer,
J. HECTOR ST. JOHN. CARLISLE, PENNSYLVANIA.
LETTERS FROM AN AMERICAN FARMER
LETTER I
INTRODUCTION
Who would have thought that because I received you with hospitality and kindness, you should imagine me capable of writing with propriety and perspicuity? Your gratitude misleads your judgment. The knowledge which I acquired from your conversation has amply repaid me for your five weeks' entertainment. I gave you nothing more than what common hospitality dictated; but could any other guest have instructed me as you did? You conducted me, on the map, from one European country to another; told me many extraordinary things of our famed mother-country, of which I knew very little; of its internal navigation, agriculture, arts, manufactures, and trade: you guided me through an extensive maze, and I abundantly profited by the journey; the contrast therefore proves the debt of gratitude to be on my side. The treatment you received at my house proceeded from the warmth of my heart, and from the corresponding sensibility of my wife; what you now desire must flow from a very limited power of mind: the task requires recollection, and a variety of talents which I do not possess. It is true I can describe our American modes of farming, our manners, and peculiar customs, with some degree of propriety, because I have ever attentively studied them; but my knowledge extends no farther. And is this local and unadorned information sufficient to answer all your expectations, and to satisfy your curiosity? I am surprised that in the course of your American travels you should not have found out persons more enlightened and better educated than I am; your predilection excites my wonder much more than my vanity; my share of the latter being confined merely to the neatness of my rural operations.
Who would have thought that because I welcomed you with hospitality and kindness, you would think I’m capable of writing properly and clearly? Your gratitude is clouding your judgment. The knowledge I gained from our conversations has more than compensated me for your five weeks of company. I offered you nothing more than basic hospitality; but could any other guest have taught me as much as you did? You guided me, on the map, from one European country to another; shared many amazing things about our beloved mother country, which I knew very little about; its internal navigation, agriculture, arts, manufacturing, and trade: you led me through a vast maze, and I gained a lot from the experience; so the contrast shows that I have more reason to be grateful. The way you were treated at my home came from the warmth of my heart and the shared sensitivity of my wife; what you’re asking for now must come from a very limited understanding: this task requires memory and a range of skills that I don’t have. It’s true that I can describe our American farming methods, our manners, and unique customs with some level of accuracy because I’ve always studied them closely; but my knowledge doesn't go beyond that. And is this basic and straightforward information enough to meet all your expectations and satisfy your curiosity? I'm surprised that during your travels in America you haven’t found people who are more knowledgeable and better educated than I am; your preference amazes me more than flatters me; my only sense of pride comes from the neatness of my rural work.
My father left me a few musty books, which his father brought from England with him; but what help can I draw from a library consisting mostly of Scotch Divinity, the Navigation of Sir Francis Drake, the History of Queen Elizabeth, and a few miscellaneous volumes? Our minister often comes to see me, though he lives upwards of twenty miles distant. I have shown him your letter, asked his advice, and solicited his assistance; he tells me, that he hath no time to spare, for that like the rest of us must till his farm, and is moreover to study what he is to say on the sabbath. My wife (and I never do anything without consulting her) laughs, and tells me that you cannot be in earnest. What! says she, James, wouldst thee pretend to send epistles to a great European man, who hath lived abundance of time in that big house called Cambridge; where, they say, that worldly learning is so abundant, that people gets it only by breathing the air of the place? Wouldst not thee be ashamed to write unto a man who has never in his life done a single day's work, no, not even felled a tree; who hath expended the Lord knows how many years in studying stars, geometry, stones, and flies, and in reading folio books? Who hath travelled, as he told us, to the city of Rome itself! Only think of a London man going to Rome! Where is it that these English folks won't go? One who hath seen the factory of brimstone at Suvius, and town of Pompey under ground! wouldst thou pretend to letter it with a person who hath been to Paris, to the Alps, to Petersburg, and who hath seen so many fine things up and down the old countries; who hath come over the great sea unto us, and hath journeyed from our New Hampshire in the East to our Charles Town in the South; who hath visited all our great cities, knows most of our famous lawyers and cunning folks; who hath conversed with very many king's men, governors, and counsellors, and yet pitches upon thee for his correspondent, as thee calls it? surely he means to jeer thee! I am sure he does, he cannot be in a real fair earnest. James, thee must read this letter over again, paragraph by paragraph, and warily observe whether thee can'st perceive some words of jesting; something that hath more than one meaning: and now I think on it, husband, I wish thee wouldst let me see his letter; though I am but a woman, as thee mayest say, yet I understand the purport of words in good measure, for when I was a girl, father sent us to the very best master in the precinct.—She then read it herself very attentively: our minister was present, we listened to, and weighed every syllable: we all unanimously concluded that you must have been in a sober earnest intention, as my wife calls it; and your request appeared to be candid and sincere. Then again, on recollecting the difference between your sphere of life and mine, a new fit of astonishment seized us all!
My dad left me some old, musty books that his dad brought over from England; but what good is a library filled mostly with Scottish theology, Sir Francis Drake's navigation, the history of Queen Elizabeth, and a few random volumes? Our minister comes to visit me often, even though he lives more than twenty miles away. I've shown him your letter, asked for his advice, and sought his help; he tells me he has no time to spare because like the rest of us, he has to work his farm, and he also needs to prepare for what he'll say on Sunday. My wife (and I never do anything without talking to her first) laughs and says you can’t be serious. What! she says, James, do you really think you can send letters to a big shot from Europe who’s spent so much time in that giant place called Cambridge; where they say worldly knowledge is so plentiful that people just absorb it by being there? Wouldn't you be embarrassed to write to a guy who has never done a day's work in his life, not even chopped down a tree; who has spent God knows how many years studying stars, geometry, stones, and insects, and reading huge books? Who has traveled, as he mentioned, all the way to Rome itself! Just think about a London guy going to Rome! Where won’t these English folks go? Someone who has seen the sulfur factory at Vesuvius and the buried city of Pompeii! Do you really think you can correspond with someone who has been to Paris, the Alps, Petersburg, and has seen so many amazing things throughout the old countries; who crossed the ocean to reach us and has traveled from New Hampshire in the East to Charleston in the South; who has visited all our major cities, knows most of our famous lawyers and clever folks; who has talked with many kings’ men, governors, and counselors, and yet chooses you as his correspondent, as you call it? Surely, he must be making fun of you! I’m certain he is; he can’t be serious. James, you need to read this letter again, paragraph by paragraph, and carefully see if you can catch any signs of joking; something that has more than one meaning. And now that I think about it, husband, I wish you would let me read his letter; even though I’m just a woman, as you might say, I understand the meaning of words quite well, because when I was a girl, my dad sent us to the best teacher around.—She then read it very closely: our minister was there, and we listened to and considered every word: we all agreed that you must have had a serious intention, as my wife puts it; and your request seemed honest and straightforward. But then again, thinking about the difference between our lives and yours, we were all struck with amazement once more!
Our minister took the letter from my wife, and read it to himself; he made us observe the two last phrases, and we weighed the contents to the best of our abilities. The conclusion we all drew made me resolve at last to write.—You say you want nothing of me but what lies within the reach of my experience and knowledge; this I understand very well; the difficulty is, how to collect, digest, and arrange what I know? Next you assert, that writing letters is nothing more than talking on paper; which, I must confess, appeared to me quite a new thought.—Well then, observed our minister, neighbour James, as you can talk well, I am sure you must write tolerably well also; imagine, then, that Mr. F. B. is still here, and simply write down what you would say to him. Suppose the questions be will put to you in his future letters to be asked by his viva voce, as we used to call it at the college; then let your answers be conceived and expressed exactly in the same language as if he was present. This is all that he requires from you, and I am sure the task is not difficult. He is your friend: who would be ashamed to write to such a person? Although he is a man of learning and taste, yet I am sure he will read your letters with pleasure: if they be not elegant, they will smell of the woods, and be a little wild; I know your turn, they will contain some matters which he never knew before. Some people are so fond of novelty, that they will overlook many errors of language for the sake of information. We are all apt to love and admire exotics, tho' they may be often inferior to what we possess; and that is the reason I imagine why so many persons are continually going to visit Italy.—That country is the daily resort of modern travellers.
Our minister took the letter from my wife and read it silently. He had us notice the last two phrases, and we considered the contents as best as we could. The conclusion we all reached finally pushed me to write. You say you want nothing from me except what’s within my experience and knowledge; I understand that well. The challenge is figuring out how to gather, process, and organize what I know. Next, you claim that writing letters is just talking on paper, which honestly seemed like a new idea to me. “Well then,” our minister said, “Neighbor James, since you can talk well, I’m sure you can write reasonably well too. Just imagine that Mr. F. B. is still here and write down what you would say to him. Picture the questions he would ask in his future letters as if he were asking them in person, as we used to say in college. Then, let your answers be thought out and expressed just as if he were present. That’s all he needs from you, and I’m confident it won’t be difficult. He’s your friend; who would be embarrassed to write to someone like that? Although he’s a man of knowledge and style, I’m sure he will enjoy reading your letters. Even if they aren’t polished, they’ll have a rustic charm and be a bit wild; I know your style, and they’ll include things he hasn’t heard before. Some people love new ideas so much they’ll overlook many language mistakes just to get the information. We all tend to admire exotic things, even if they’re often inferior to what we already have, which is probably why so many people keep visiting Italy. That country is a popular spot for modern travelers.
James: I should like to know what is there to be seen so goodly and profitable, that so many should wish to visit no other country?
James: I’d like to know what’s so great and valuable here that so many people would want to visit no other country.
Minister: I do not very well know. I fancy their object is to trace the vestiges of a once flourishing people now extinct. There they amuse themselves in viewing the ruins of temples and other buildings which have very little affinity with those of the present age, and must therefore impart a knowledge which appears useless and trifling. I have often wondered that no skilful botanists or learned men should come over here; methinks there would be much more real satisfaction in observing among us the humble rudiments and embryos of societies spreading everywhere, the recent foundation of our towns, and the settlements of so many rural districts. I am sure that the rapidity of their growth would be more pleasing to behold, than the ruins of old towers, useless aqueducts, or impending battlements.
Minister: I'm not really sure. I think their goal is to trace the remnants of a once-thriving civilization that no longer exists. They spend their time looking at the ruins of temples and other buildings that have very little connection to those of today, which must make it seem like they're gaining knowledge that's pretty meaningless and trivial. I've often wondered why no skilled botanists or scholars have come here; I believe they would find much greater satisfaction in observing the humble beginnings and early stages of societies growing everywhere, the recent establishment of our towns, and the formation of so many rural areas. I'm convinced that the rapid growth they would witness would be more enjoyable to see than the ruins of old towers, useless aqueducts, or crumbling fortifications.
James: What you say, minister, seems very true: do go on: I always love to hear you talk.
James: What you're saying, minister, makes a lot of sense: please continue; I always enjoy listening to you.
Minister: Don't you think, neighbour James, that the mind of a good and enlightened Englishman would be more improved in remarking throughout these provinces the causes which render so many people happy? In delineating the unnoticed means by which we daily increase the extent of our settlements? How we convert huge forests into pleasing fields, and exhibit through these thirteen provinces so singular a display of easy subsistence and political felicity.
Minister: Don’t you think, neighbor James, that the mind of a good and enlightened Englishman would be better off by noticing the reasons that make so many people happy in these provinces? By pointing out the unnoticed ways we expand our settlements every day? How we turn large forests into beautiful fields, and show such a unique display of easy living and political happiness across these thirteen provinces?
In Italy all the objects of contemplation, all the reveries of the traveller, must have a reference to ancient generations, and to very distant periods, clouded with the mist of ages.—Here, on the contrary, everything is modern, peaceful, and benign. Here we have had no war to desolate our fields: [Footnote: The troubles that now convulse the American colonies had not broke out when this and some of the following letters were written.] our religion does not oppress the cultivators: we are strangers to those feudal institutions which have enslaved so many. Here nature opens her broad lap to receive the perpetual accession of new comers, and to supply them with food. I am sure I cannot be called a partial American when I say that the spectacle afforded by these pleasing scenes must be more entertaining and more philosophical than that which arises from beholding the musty ruins of Rome. Here everything would inspire the reflecting traveller with the most philanthropic ideas; his imagination, instead of submitting to the painful and useless retrospect of revolutions, desolations, and plagues, would, on the contrary, wisely spring forward to the anticipated fields of future cultivation and improvement, to the future extent of those generations which are to replenish and embellish this boundless continent. There the half-ruined amphitheatres, and the putrid fevers of the Campania, must fill the mind with the most melancholy reflections, whilst he is seeking for the origin and the intention of those structures with which he is surrounded, and for the cause of so great a decay. Here he might contemplate the very beginnings and outlines of human society, which can be traced nowhere now but in this part of the world. The rest of the earth, I am told, is in some places too full, in others half depopulated. Misguided religion, tyranny, and absurd laws everywhere depress and afflict mankind. Here we have in some measure regained the ancient dignity of our species; our laws are simple and just, we are a race of cultivators, our cultivation is unrestrained, and therefore everything is prosperous and flourishing. For my part I had rather admire the ample barn of one of our opulent farmers, who himself felled the first tree in his plantation, and was the first founder of his settlement, than study the dimensions of the temple of Ceres. I had rather record the progressive steps of this industrious farmer, throughout all the stages of his labours and other operations, than examine how modern Italian convents can be supported without doing anything but singing and praying.
In Italy, everything a traveler observes and dreams about relates back to ancient generations and distant times, shrouded in the mist of ages. Here, on the other hand, everything is modern, peaceful, and kind. We haven’t had wars ruining our fields: [Footnote: The troubles that now convulse the American colonies had not broken out when this and some of the following letters were written.] our religion doesn’t oppress the farmers: we’re free from those feudal systems that have enslaved so many. Here, nature generously welcomes newcomers and provides them with sustenance. I wouldn’t be biased if I claim that the beauty of these scenes must be more enjoyable and thought-provoking than gazing at the crumbling ruins of Rome. Everything here would inspire a thoughtful traveler with the most humanitarian ideas; instead of dwelling on painful and pointless reflections of revolutions, destruction, and plagues, he’d wisely look ahead to the hopeful fields of future growth and enhancement, to the future generations that will repopulate and beautify this vast continent. There, among the half-ruined amphitheaters and the sickly fevers of the Campania, one must confront the deepest sadness while trying to uncover the origins and purposes of the structures around them, and the reasons behind such significant decay. Here, one could contemplate the very beginnings and outlines of human society, which can now only be traced back to this part of the world. I’ve heard that elsewhere, some places are overcrowded, while others are barely populated. Misguided religion, tyranny, and irrational laws oppress and distress people everywhere. Here, we’ve somewhat regained the ancient dignity of our humanity; our laws are straightforward and fair, we are a society of farmers, our agriculture is unrestricted, and as a result, everything thrives and flourishes. Personally, I’d rather admire the spacious barn of one of our wealthy farmers, who personally felled the first tree on his land and was the original founder of his community, than study the dimensions of the temple of Ceres. I would prefer to document the hardworking journey of this diligent farmer through all stages of his efforts than analyze how modern Italian convents manage to exist by simply singing and praying.
However confined the field of speculation might be here, the time of English travellers would not be wholly lost. The new and unexpected aspect of our extensive settlements; of our fine rivers; that great field of action everywhere visible; that ease, that peace with which so many people live together, would greatly interest the observer: for whatever difficulties there might happen in the object of their researches, that hospitality which prevails from one end of the continent to the other would in all parts facilitate their excursions. As it is from the surface of the ground which we till that we have gathered the wealth we possess, the surface of that ground is therefore the only thing that has hitherto been known. It will require the industry of subsequent ages, the energy of future generations, ere mankind here will have leisure and abilities to penetrate deep, and, in the bowels of this continent, search for the subterranean riches it no doubt contains.—Neighbour James, we want much the assistance of men of leisure and knowledge, we want eminent chemists to inform our iron masters; to teach us how to make and prepare most of the colours we use. Here we have none equal to this task. If any useful discoveries are therefore made among us, they are the effects of chance, or else arise from that restless industry which is the principal characteristic of these colonies.
However limited the area of speculation might be here, the time spent by English travelers would not be completely wasted. The new and surprising aspects of our vast settlements, our beautiful rivers, the great opportunities visible everywhere, and the ease and peace with which so many people coexist would greatly interest any observer. Despite any challenges in their research, the hospitality that exists from one end of the continent to the other would make their journeys easier in every part. Just as we have gained the wealth we possess from the surface of the land we cultivate, that surface is all that has been known so far. It will take the hard work of future generations and the energy of those to come before people here can take the time and have the skills to dig deeper and explore the underground treasures that surely lie within this continent. —Neighbour James, we really need the help of knowledgeable people with free time; we need skilled chemists to advise our ironworkers and to teach us how to create and prepare most of the colors we use. Currently, we have no one capable of this task. Therefore, if any useful discoveries are made among us, they are due to chance or arise from the relentless work ethic that is the defining feature of these colonies.
James: Oh! could I express myself as you do, my friend, I should not balance a single instant, I should rather be anxious to commence a correspondence which would do me credit.
James: Oh! If I could express myself like you do, my friend, I wouldn’t hesitate for a moment; I would rather want to start a correspondence that would reflect well on me.
Minister: You can write full as well as you need, and will improve very fast; trust to my prophecy, your letters, at least, will have the merit of coming from the edge of the great wilderness, three hundred miles from the sea, and three thousand miles over that sea: this will be no detriment to them, take my word for it. You intend one of your children for the gown, who knows but Mr. F. B. may give you some assistance when the lad comes to have concerns with the bishop; it is good for American farmers to have friends even in England. What he requires of you is but simple—what we speak out among ourselves we call conversation, and a letter is only conversation put down in black and white.
Minister: You can write as much as you need to, and you'll improve quickly; just trust my prediction, your letters will stand out since they come from the edge of the great wilderness, three hundred miles from the ocean, and three thousand miles across that ocean. This won’t detract from them, believe me. You plan to send one of your kids to the clergy; who knows, maybe Mr. F. B. will help you when the boy needs to deal with the bishop. It’s beneficial for American farmers to have friends in England too. What he asks of you is simple—what we talk about among ourselves is called conversation, and a letter is just conversation written down.
James: You quite persuade me—if he laughs at my awkwardness, surely he will be pleased with my ready compliance. On my part, it will be well meant let the execution be what it may. I will write enough, and so let him have the trouble of sifting the good from the bad, the useful from the trifling; let him select what he may want, and reject what may not answer his purpose. After all, it is but treating Mr. F. B. now that he is in London, as I treated him when he was in America under this roof; that is with the best things I had; given with a good intention; and the best manner I was able. Very different, James, very different indeed, said my wife, I like not thy comparison; our small house and cellar, our orchard and garden afforded what he wanted; one half of his time Mr. F. B., poor man, lived upon nothing but fruit-pies, or peaches and milk. Now these things were such as God had given us, myself and wench did the rest; we were not the creators of these victuals, we only cooked them as well and as neat as we could. The first thing, James, is to know what sort of materials thee hast within thy own self, and then whether thee canst dish them up.—Well, well, wife, thee art wrong for once; if I was filled with worldly vanity, thy rebuke would be timely, but thee knowest that I have but little of that. How shall I know what I am capable of till I try? Hadst thee never employed thyself in thy father's house to learn and to practise the many branches of house-keeping that thy parents were famous for, thee wouldst have made but a sorry wife for an American farmer; thee never shouldst have been mine. I married thee not for what thee hadst, but for what thee knewest; doest not thee observe what Mr. F. B. says beside; he tells me, that the art of writing is just like unto every other art of man; that it is acquired by habit, and by perseverance. That is singularly true, said our minister, he that shall write a letter every day of the week, will on Saturday perceive the sixth flowing from his pen much more readily than the first. I observed when I first entered into the ministry and began to preach the word, I felt perplexed and dry, my mind was like unto a parched soil, which produced nothing, not even weeds. By the blessing of heaven, and my perseverance in study, I grew richer in thoughts, phrases, and words; I felt copious, and now I can abundantly preach from any text that occurs to my mind. So will it be with you, neighbour James; begin therefore without delay; and Mr. F. B.'s letters may be of great service to you: he will, no doubt, inform you of many things: correspondence consists in reciprocal letters. Leave off your diffidence, and I will do my best to help you whenever I have any leisure. Well then, I am resolved, I said, to follow your counsel; my letters shall not be sent, nor will I receive any, without reading them to you and my wife; women are curious, they love to know their husband's secrets; it will not be the first thing which I have submitted to your joint opinions. Whenever you come to dine with us, these shall be the last dish on the table. Nor will they be the most unpalatable, answered the good man. Nature hath given you a tolerable share of sense, and that is one of her best gifts let me tell you. She has given you besides some perspicuity, which qualifies you to distinguish interesting objects; a warmth of imagination which enables you to think with quickness; you often extract useful reflections from objects which presented none to my mind: you have a tender and a well meaning heart, you love description, and your pencil, assure yourself, is not a bad one for the pencil of a farmer; it seems to be held without any labour; your mind is what we called at Yale college a Tabula rasa, where spontaneous and strong impressions are delineated with facility. Ah, neighbour! had you received but half the education of Mr. F. B. you had been a worthy correspondent indeed. But perhaps you will be a more entertaining one dressed in your simple American garb, than if you were clad in all the gowns of Cambridge. You will appear to him something like one of our wild American plants, irregularly luxuriant in its various branches, which an European scholar may probably think ill placed and useless. If our soil is not remarkable as yet for the excellence of its fruits, this exuberance is however a strong proof of fertility, which wants nothing but the progressive knowledge acquired by time to amend and to correct. It is easier to retrench than it is to add; I do not mean to flatter you, neighbour James, adulation would ill become my character, you may therefore believe what your pastor says. Were I in Europe I should be tired with perpetually seeing espaliers, plashed hedges, and trees dwarfed into pigmies. Do let Mr. F. B. see on paper a few American wild cherry trees, such as nature forms them here, in all her unconfined vigour, in all the amplitude of their extended limbs and spreading ramifications—let him see that we are possessed with strong vegetative embryos. After all, why should not a farmer be allowed to make use of his mental faculties as well as others; because a man works, is not he to think, and if he thinks usefully, why should not he in his leisure hours set down his thoughts? I have composed many a good sermon as I followed my plough. The eyes not being then engaged on any particular object, leaves the mind free for the introduction of many useful ideas. It is not in the noisy shop of a blacksmith or of a carpenter, that these studious moments can be enjoyed; it is as we silently till the ground, and muse along the odoriferous furrows of our low lands, uninterrupted either by stones or stumps; it is there that the salubrious effluvia of the earth animate our spirits and serve to inspire us; every other avocation of our farms are severe labours compared to this pleasing occupation: of all the tasks which mine imposes on me ploughing is the most agreeable, because I can think as I work; my mind is at leisure; my labour flows from instinct, as well as that of my horses; there is no kind of difference between us in our different shares of that operation; one of them keeps the furrow, the other avoids it; at the end of my field they turn either to the right or left as they are bid, whilst I thoughtlessly hold and guide the plough to which they are harnessed. Do therefore, neighbour, begin this correspondence, and persevere, difficulties will vanish in proportion as you draw near them; you'll be surprised at yourself by and by: when you come to look back you'll say as I have often said to myself; had I been diffident I had never proceeded thus far. Would you painfully till your stony up-land and neglect the fine rich bottom which lies before your door? Had you never tried, you never had learned how to mend and make your ploughs. It will be no small pleasure to your children to tell hereafter, that their father was not only one of the most industrious farmers in the country, but one of the best writers. When you have once begun, do as when you begin breaking up your summer fallow, you never consider what remains to be done, you view only what you have ploughed. Therefore, neighbour James, take my advice; it will go well with you, I am sure it will.—And do you really think so, Sir? Your counsel, which I have long followed, weighs much with me, I verily believe that I must write to Mr. F. B. by the first vessel.—If thee persistest in being such a foolhardy man, said my wife, for God's sake let it be kept a profound secret among us; if it were once known abroad that thee writest to a great and rich man over at London, there would be no end of the talk of the people; some would vow that thee art going to turn an author, others would pretend to foresee some great alterations in the welfare of thy family; some would say this, some would say that: Who would wish to become the subject of public talk? Weigh this matter well before thee beginnest, James—consider that a great deal of thy time, and of thy reputation is at stake as I may say. Wert thee to write as well as friend Edmund, whose speeches I often see in our papers, it would be the very self same thing; thee wouldst be equally accused of idleness, and vain notions not befitting thy condition. Our colonel would be often coming here to know what it is that thee canst write so much about. Some would imagine that thee wantest to become either an assembly-man or a magistrate, which God forbid; and that thee art telling the king's men abundance of things. Instead of being well looked upon as now, and living in peace with all the world, our neighbours would be making strange surmises: I had rather be as we are, neither better nor worse than the rest of our country folks. Thee knowest what I mean, though I should be sorry to deprive thee of any honest recreation. Therefore as I have said before, let it be as great a secret as if it was some heinous crime; the minister, I am sure, will not divulge it; as for my part, though I am a woman, yet I know what it is to be a wife.—I would not have thee, James, pass for what the world calleth a writer; no, not for a peck of gold, as the saying is. Thy father before thee was a plain dealing honest man, punctual in all things; he was one of yea and nay, of few words, all he minded was his farm and his work. I wonder from whence thee hast got this love of the pen? Had he spent his time in sending epistles to and fro, he never would have left thee this goodly plantation, free from debt. All I say is in good meaning; great people over sea may write to our town's folks, because they have nothing else to do. These Englishmen are strange people; because they can live upon what they call bank notes, without working, they think that all the world can do the same. This goodly country never would have been tilled and cleared with these notes. I am sure when Mr. F. B. was here, he saw thee sweat and take abundance of pains; he often told me how the Americans worked a great deal harder than the home Englishmen; for there he told us, that they have no trees to cut down, no fences to make, no negroes to buy and to clothe: and now I think on it, when wilt thee send him those trees he bespoke? But if they have no trees to cut down, they have gold in abundance, they say; for they rake it and scrape it from all parts far and near. I have often heard my grandfather tell how they live there by writing. By writing they send this cargo unto us, that to the West, and the other to the East Indies. But, James, thee knowest that it is not by writing that we shall pay the blacksmith, the minister, the weaver, the tailor, and the English shop. But as thee art an early man follow thine own inclinations; thee wantest some rest, I am sure, and why shouldst thee not employ it as it may seem meet unto thee.—However let it be a great secret; how wouldst thee bear to be called at our country meetings, the man of the pen? If this scheme of thine was once known, travellers as they go along would point out to our house, saying, here liveth the scribbling fanner; better hear them as usual observe, here liveth the warm substantial family, that never begrudgeth a meal of victuals, or a mess of oats, to any one that steps in. Look how fat and well clad their negroes are.
James: You’ve convinced me—if he laughs at my awkwardness, he’ll surely appreciate my willingness to comply. On my part, I’ll do my best, no matter how it turns out. I’ll write enough, and he can deal with sorting the good from the bad, the useful from the trivial; he can choose what he needs and ignore what doesn't serve his purpose. After all, I’m treating Mr. F. B. now that he’s in London just like I treated him when he was in America under this roof; with the best I have, given with good intentions and the best way I can. Very different, James, very different indeed, said my wife, I don’t like your comparison; our small house and cellar, our orchard and garden provided what he wanted; half the time Mr. F. B., poor man, lived on nothing but fruit pies or peaches and milk. These were things that God gave us, while I and the help did the rest; we didn’t create the food, we just cooked it as well and neatly as we could. The first step, James, is to know what kind of skills you have within yourself, and then whether you can make something of them. Well, well, wife, you’re wrong for once; if I were filled with worldly vanity, your rebuke would be fitting, but you know I have little of that. How will I know what I’m capable of until I try? If you hadn’t spent your time in your father’s house learning and practicing the many aspects of housekeeping that your parents were known for, you would have made a poor wife for an American farmer; you never would have been mine. I didn’t marry you for what you had, but for what you knew; don’t you notice what Mr. F. B. says in addition? He tells me that the art of writing is just like any other craft; it’s developed through habit and persistence. That’s exceptionally true, said our minister, someone who writes a letter every day of the week will find that the sixth one flows much more easily than the first by Saturday. I noticed when I first entered the ministry and began preaching, I felt confused and uninspired; my mind was like parched earth, producing nothing, not even weeds. But through heaven’s blessing and my dedication to studying, I grew richer in thoughts, phrases, and words; I became abundant, and now I can preach easily from any text that comes to mind. It will be the same for you, neighbor James; so begin without delay; and Mr. F. B.’s letters may be very helpful to you: he will, no doubt, teach you a lot; correspondence consists of exchanging letters. Let go of your shyness, and I will do my best to assist you whenever I have the time. Well then, I’ve decided, I said, to take your advice; I won’t send or receive any letters without reading them to you and my wife; women are curious, they love to know their husbands’ secrets; it won’t be the first thing I’ve submitted to your joint opinions. Whenever you come to dine with us, these will be the last course served. And they won’t be the most unappetizing, replied the good man. Nature has given you a fair share of sense, and that’s one of her best gifts, let me tell you. She has also given you some clarity that helps you distinguish interesting things; a warmth of imagination that enables you to think quickly; you often pull useful insights from things that presented none to my mind: you have a kind and well-meaning heart, you love description, and I assure you, your drawing skills for a farmer aren’t bad; you seem to create effortlessly. Your mind is what we called at Yale College a Tabula rasa, where strong and spontaneous ideas are easily expressed. Ah, neighbor! If you had received even half the education of Mr. F. B., you would have been an excellent correspondent indeed. But perhaps as you are, in your simple American attire, you’ll be a more entertaining one than if you were wearing all the gowns of Cambridge. You’ll come across to him as one of our wild American plants, irregularly lush in its various branches, which a European scholar might find misplaced and useless. If our soil isn’t yet known for the excellence of its fruits, this abundance is, however, a strong indicator of fertility, which lacks only the progressive knowledge gained over time to improve and refine it. It’s easier to cut back than to add; I don’t mean to flatter you, neighbor James; flattery wouldn’t suit my character, so you can believe what your pastor says. If I were in Europe, I would be tired of constantly seeing espaliers, trimmed hedges, and trees stunted into dwarfs. Let Mr. F. B. see on paper a few American wild cherry trees, just as nature forms them here, in all her unconfined beauty, with all the expansive limbs and branches—let him see that we are filled with strong, growing potential. After all, why shouldn’t a farmer use his mind like everyone else? Just because a man works doesn’t mean he shouldn’t think, and if he thinks constructively, why shouldn’t he jot down his thoughts in his free time? I’ve developed many good sermons while plowing. When my eyes aren’t focusing on anything particular, my mind is free to form many useful ideas. It’s not in the noisy shop of a blacksmith or carpenter that these thoughtful moments can be enjoyed; it’s as we quietly tend to the land and ponder along the fragrant furrows of our fields, undisturbed by stones or stumps; it’s there that the fresh scents of the earth lift our spirits and inspire us; every other task on our farm is strenuous compared to this enjoyable work: of all the duties I have, plowing is the most pleasant because I can think as I labor; my mind is at ease; my work flows from instinct, just like my horses’; there is no real difference between us in our parts of that task; one of them keeps the furrow, while the other avoids it; at the end of the field, they turn right or left as directed, while I effortlessly hold and guide the plow they are hitched to. So, neighbor, begin this correspondence and stick with it; challenges will fade as you approach them; you’ll surprise yourself over time: when you look back, you’ll say as I’ve often told myself: if I had been timid, I wouldn’t have come this far. Would you strain to work the rocky hills while neglecting the luscious lowlands right at your doorstep? If you had never tried, you would never have learned how to repair and maintain your plows. It will be a great pleasure for your children to tell later that their father was not only one of the most hardworking farmers in the area, but also one of the best writers. Once you start, do it like when you begin turning over your summer fallow; you won’t consider what’s left to do, you’ll only see what you’ve already plowed. Therefore, neighbor James, take my advice; it will go well for you, I’m sure it will.—And do you really think so, Sir? Your advice, which I have long trusted, carries a lot of weight with me; I genuinely believe I should write to Mr. F. B. on the next ship. If you insist on being so reckless, said my wife, for heaven’s sake, let it be a deeply kept secret among us; if it ever got out that you’re writing to a great and wealthy man over in London, there would be endless gossip; some would assert that you’re going to become an author, others would claim to foresee some major changes in your family’s prospects; some would say this, others that: who would want to be the talk of the town? Think this over carefully before you start, James—consider that a lot of your time and reputation is at stake, as I might say. If you were to write as well as friend Edmund, whose speeches I often see in our papers, it would be exactly the same; you’d be equally accused of idleness and vain ambitions unfit for your station. Our colonel would often come here wanting to know what you can write so much about. Some would think you want to become either a legislator or a magistrate, which God forbid; and that you’re telling the king’s men a great many things. Instead of being well-regarded as you are now and living in harmony with everyone, our neighbors would be making odd guesses; I’d rather be as we are, neither better nor worse than the other folks in our area. You understand what I mean, though I wouldn’t want to rob you of any honest enjoyment. So, as I said before, let it be as secret as a serious crime; I’m sure the minister won’t reveal it; as for me, although I’m a woman, I know what it means to be a wife.—I wouldn’t want you, James, to be seen as what the world calls a writer; no, not for a pile of gold, as the saying goes. Your father before you was a straightforward, honest man, reliable in everything; he was one of few words, only focused on his farm and work. I wonder where you got this love of writing? If he had spent his time sending letters back and forth, he never would have left you this fine farm, free from debt. Everything I say is well-intentioned; rich people overseas can write to our townsfolk because they have nothing else to do. These Englishmen are peculiar; because they can live on what they call banknotes without working, they think everyone can do the same. This beautiful country never would have been farmed and cleared using those notes. I’m sure when Mr. F. B. was here, he saw you sweat and work hard; he often told me how Americans worked much harder than the English at home; for there he mentioned, they have no trees to chop down, no fences to build, and no slaves to buy and clothe. And now that I think about it, when will you send him those trees he asked for? But while they may not have trees to chop down, they say they have plenty of gold; they seem to rake it and scrape it from all corners. I’ve often heard my grandfather remark on how they live by writing. Through writing, they send this cargo to us, that to the West, and the other to the East Indies. But, James, you know that it’s not by writing that we’ll pay the blacksmith, the minister, the weaver, the tailor, and the English store. But since you’re an early man, follow your own inclinations; I’m sure you need some rest, so why shouldn’t you use it as you see fit?—But do keep it a big secret; how would you handle being called the writer at our community meetings? If your plan becomes known, travelers will point to our house saying, here lives the scribbling farmer; better yet, they’ll note, here lives the warm, generous family, that never begrudges a meal of food or a share of oats to anyone who stops by. Look how well-fed and well-dressed their slaves are.
Thus, Sir, have I given you an unaffected and candid detail of the conversation which determined me to accept of your invitation. I thought it necessary thus to begin, and to let you into these primary secrets, to the end that you may not hereafter reproach me with any degree of presumption. You'll plainly see the motives which have induced me to begin, the fears which I have entertained, and the principles on which my diffidence hath been founded. I have now nothing to do but to prosecute my task—Remember you are to give me my subjects, and on no other shall I write, lest you should blame me for an injudicious choice—However incorrect my style, however unexpert my methods, however trifling my observations may hereafter appear to you, assure yourself they will all be the genuine dictates of my mind, and I hope will prove acceptable on that account. Remember that you have laid the foundation of this correspondence; you well know that I am neither a philosopher, politician, divine, nor naturalist, but a simple farmer. I flatter myself, therefore, that you'll receive my letters as conceived, not according to scientific rules to which I am a perfect stranger, but agreeable to the spontaneous impressions which each subject may inspire. This is the only line I am able to follow, the line which nature has herself traced for me; this was the covenant which I made with you, and with which you seemed to be well pleased. Had you wanted the style of the learned, the reflections of the patriot, the discussions of the politician, the curious observations of the naturalist, the pleasing garb of the man of taste, surely you would have applied to some of those men of letters with which our cities abound. But since on the contrary, and for what reason I know not, you wish to correspond with a cultivator of the earth, with a simple citizen, you must receive my letters for better or worse.
So, Sir, I've given you a straightforward and honest account of the conversation that led me to accept your invitation. I thought it was important to start this way and let you in on these initial thoughts so that you won't later accuse me of being presumptuous. You'll clearly understand the reasons that prompted me to begin, the fears I've had, and the principles that my hesitance is based on. Now, all I have to do is continue with my task—remember, you need to give me my topics, and I won't write on any others, so you can't blame me for a poor choice. No matter how flawed my writing is, how inexperienced my methods are, or how trivial my observations may seem to you later, rest assured they will all reflect my genuine thoughts, and I hope they'll be appreciated for that reason. Keep in mind that you started this correspondence; you know I'm not a philosopher, politician, theologian, or scientist—just a simple farmer. So, I hope you'll read my letters as they are, not by the strict rules of science that I'm completely unfamiliar with, but based on the spontaneous ideas that each subject inspires in me. This is the only path I'm capable of following, the one that nature has set for me; this was the agreement I made with you, and you seemed to be happy with it. If you had wanted the style of a scholar, the reflections of a patriot, the discussions of a politician, the keen observations of a scientist, or the elegant prose of a cultured person, you surely would have reached out to one of the many writers in our cities. But since, for reasons I don't know, you want to correspond with a farmer, with a simple citizen, you must accept my letters for better or worse.
LETTER II
ON THE SITUATION, FEELINGS, AND PLEASURES, OF AN AMERICAN FARMER
As you are the first enlightened European I have ever had the pleasure of being acquainted with, you will not be surprised that I should, according to your earnest desire and my promise, appear anxious of preserving your friendship and correspondence. By your accounts, I observe a material difference subsists between your husbandry, modes, and customs, and ours; everything is local; could we enjoy the advantages of the English farmer, we should be much happier, indeed, but this wish, like many others, implies a contradiction; and could the English farmer have some of those privileges we possess, they would be the first of their class in the world. Good and evil I see is to be found in all societies, and it is in vain to seek for any spot where those ingredients are not mixed. I therefore rest satisfied, and thank God that my lot is to be an American farmer, instead of a Russian boor, or an Hungarian peasant. I thank you kindly for the idea, however dreadful, which you have given me of their lot and condition; your observations have confirmed me in the justness of my ideas, and I am happier now than I thought myself before. It is strange that misery, when viewed in others, should become to us a sort of real good, though I am far from rejoicing to hear that there are in the world men so thoroughly wretched; they are no doubt as harmless, industrious, and willing to work as we are. Hard is their fate to be thus condemned to a slavery worse than that of our negroes. Yet when young I entertained some thoughts of selling my farm. I thought it afforded but a dull repetition of the same labours and pleasures. I thought the former tedious and heavy, the latter few and insipid; but when I came to consider myself as divested of my farm, I then found the world so wide, and every place so full, that I began to fear lest there would be no room for me. My farm, my house, my barn, presented to my imagination objects from which I adduced quite new ideas; they were more forcible than before. Why should not I find myself happy, said I, where my father was before? He left me no good books it is true, he gave me no other education than the art of reading and writing; but he left me a good farm, and his experience; he left me free from debts, and no kind of difficulties to struggle with.—I married, and this perfectly reconciled me to my situation; my wife rendered my house all at once cheerful and pleasing; it no longer appeared gloomy and solitary as before; when I went to work in my fields I worked with more alacrity and sprightliness; I felt that I did not work for myself alone, and this encouraged me much. My wife would often come with her knitting in her hand, and sit under the shady trees, praising the straightness of my furrows, and the docility of my horses; this swelled my heart and made everything light and pleasant, and I regretted that I had not married before.
As you are the first enlightened European I've had the pleasure to meet, you won't be surprised that I, in line with your sincere wish and my promise, am eager to maintain your friendship and communication. From what you've shared, I notice a significant difference between your farming practices, customs, and ours; everything seems very localized. If we could benefit from the advantages of the English farmer, we'd be much happier, but this desire, like many others, is contradictory. If the English farmer could experience some of the privileges we have, they would be the best in their field globally. Good and bad exist in all societies, and it's pointless to look for a place where those aspects aren't mixed. So, I feel content and thank God that I'm an American farmer instead of a Russian peasant or a Hungarian laborer. I'm grateful for the eye-opening idea, however grim, that you shared about their situation; your observations have reinforced my views, and I feel happier now than before. It's odd that seeing others' misery can make us appreciate our own situation, even though I don’t take pleasure in knowing that there are people so completely wretched. They are undoubtedly as harmless, hardworking, and eager to work as we are. Their fate is harsh, being subjected to a slavery worse than that of our enslaved people. Still, when I was younger, I considered selling my farm. I thought it offered a monotonous repeat of the same work and joys. The work felt tedious and burdensome, while the joys seemed few and dull; but when I imagined life without my farm, I realized the world is vast and crowded, and I began to worry there wouldn't be room for me. My farm, my home, my barn sparked thoughts and ideas in me—they seemed more powerful than before. I wondered why I couldn't find happiness where my father once was. True, he didn't leave me any good books or much education beyond reading and writing; but he did leave me a good farm and his knowledge; he left me free from debts and no tough challenges to face. When I married, it truly made me at peace with my situation; my wife instantly made our home cheerful and welcoming. It no longer felt gloomy and lonely like before; when I worked in the fields, I was more energetic and lively. I realized I wasn't working just for myself, which motivated me a lot. My wife would often come with her knitting, sit under the trees, complimenting my straight furrows and obedient horses; this filled my heart with joy and made everything feel light and enjoyable. I wished I had married sooner.
I felt myself happy in my new situation, and where is that station which can confer a more substantial system of felicity than that of an American farmer, possessing freedom of action, freedom of thoughts, ruled by a mode of government which requires but little from us? I owe nothing, but a pepper corn to my country, a small tribute to my king, with loyalty and due respect; I know no other landlord than the lord of all land, to whom I owe the most sincere gratitude. My father left me three hundred and seventy-one acres of land, forty-seven of which are good timothy meadow, an excellent orchard, a good house, and a substantial barn. It is my duty to think how happy I am that he lived to build and to pay for all these improvements; what are the labours which I have to undergo, what are my fatigues when compared to his, who had everything to do, from the first tree he felled to the finishing of his house? Every year I kill from 1500 to 2000 weight of pork, 1200 of beef, half a dozen of good wethers in harvest: of fowls my wife has always a great stock: what can I wish more? My negroes are tolerably faithful and healthy; by a long series of industry and honest dealings, my father left behind him the name of a good man; I have but to tread his paths to be happy and a good man like him. I know enough of the law to regulate my little concerns with propriety, nor do I dread its power; these are the grand outlines of my situation, but as I can feel much more than I am able to express, I hardly know how to proceed.
I feel happy in my new situation, and where can you find a life that offers more real happiness than that of an American farmer? I have the freedom to act and think as I wish, and I’m governed by a system that demands very little from me. I owe only a symbolic payment to my country and a small tribute to my king, along with loyalty and respect. I recognize no landlord other than the Lord of all, to whom I owe my deepest gratitude. My father left me three hundred and seventy-one acres of land, forty-seven of which are good timothy meadow, plus a great orchard, a decent house, and a solid barn. I feel it is my duty to appreciate how fortunate I am that he lived long enough to create and pay for all these improvements. What are my struggles compared to his, who had to do everything, from the first tree he cut down to finishing his house? Every year, I produce between 1,500 and 2,000 pounds of pork, 1,200 pounds of beef, and a few good sheep during harvest; my wife always keeps a large stock of chickens. What more could I want? My workers are generally loyal and healthy; through hard work and honest dealings, my father earned a reputation as a good man. All I have to do is follow in his footsteps, and I can be happy and a good person just like him. I know enough about the law to manage my affairs properly, and I’m not afraid of its power. These are the main points about my situation, but since I feel much more than I can express, I’m not quite sure how to continue.
When my first son was born, the whole train of my ideas were suddenly altered; never was there a charm that acted so quickly and powerfully; I ceased to ramble in imagination through the wide world; my excursions since have not exceeded the bounds of my farm, and all my principal pleasures are now centred within its scanty limits: but at the same time there is not an operation belonging to it in which I do not find some food for useful reflections. This is the reason, I suppose, that when you was here, you used, in your refined style, to denominate me the farmer of feelings; how rude must those feelings be in him who daily holds the axe or the plough, how much more refined on the contrary those of the European, whose mind is improved by education, example, books, and by every acquired advantage! Those feelings, however, I will delineate as well as I can, agreeably to your earnest request.
When my first son was born, everything I thought changed in an instant; no charm has ever had such a quick and powerful effect on me. I stopped wandering in my mind through the vast world; my adventures since then have stayed close to my farm, and all my main pleasures are now contained within its limited space. Yet, at the same time, I find something valuable to reflect on in every task related to it. I guess that's why, when you were here, you used to call me the "farmer of feelings" in your elegant way; how crude must those feelings be in someone who holds an axe or plow every day, compared to those of a European whose mind is enriched by education, experience, reading, and various advantages! However, I will describe those feelings as best as I can, just as you sincerely requested.
When I contemplate my wife, by my fire-side, while she either spins, knits, darns, or suckles our child, I cannot describe the various emotions of love, of gratitude, of conscious pride, which thrill in my heart and often overflow in involuntary tears. I feel the necessity, the sweet pleasure of acting my part, the part of an husband and father, with an attention and propriety which may entitle me to my good fortune. It is true these pleasing images vanish with the smoke of my pipe, but though they disappear from my mind, the impression they have made on my heart is indelible. When I play with the infant, my warm imagination runs forward, and eagerly anticipates his future temper and constitution. I would willingly open the book of fate, and know in which page his destiny is delineated; alas! where is the father who in those moments of paternal ecstasy can delineate one half of the thoughts which dilate his heart? I am sure I cannot; then again I fear for the health of those who are become so dear to me, and in their sicknesses I severely pay for the joys I experienced while they were well. Whenever I go abroad it is always involuntary. I never return home without feeling some pleasing emotion, which I often suppress as useless and foolish. The instant I enter on my own land, the bright idea of property, of exclusive right, of independence exalt my mind. Precious soil, I say to myself, by what singular custom of law is it that thou wast made to constitute the riches of the freeholder? What should we American farmers be without the distinct possession of that soil? It feeds, it clothes us, from it we draw even a great exuberancy, our best meat, our richest drink, the very honey of our bees comes from this. privileged spot. No wonder we should thus cherish its possession, no wonder that so many Europeans who have never been able to say that such portion of land was theirs, cross the Atlantic to realise that happiness. This formerly rude soil has been converted by my father into a pleasant farm, and in return it has established all our rights; on it is founded our rank, our freedom, our power as citizens, our importance as inhabitants of such a district. These images I must confess I always behold with pleasure, and extend them as far as my imagination can reach: for this is what may be called the true and the only philosophy of an American farmer.
When I think about my wife by the fireplace, whether she’s spinning, knitting, darning, or nursing our child, I can't put into words the mix of love, gratitude, and pride that fills my heart and often leads to tears. I feel the need and the sweet joy of fulfilling my role as a husband and father, with the kind of care and decency that I hope justifies my good fortune. It's true that these beautiful thoughts vanish with the smoke from my pipe, but even when they're gone from my mind, the mark they leave on my heart is unforgettable. When I play with the baby, my imagination races ahead, eagerly picturing his future personality and health. I would gladly peek into the book of fate to see what page holds his destiny; alas! which father, in such moments of joy, can express even half of the feelings swelling in his heart? I know I can’t; and then I worry about the health of those I've grown to love so much, and in their illnesses, I pay dearly for the joys I had when they were well. Every time I go out, it feels unintentional. When I come home, there’s always some comforting feeling that I often dismiss as pointless or silly. The moment I step onto my own land, the bright idea of ownership, exclusivity, and independence uplifts my spirit. Precious soil, I think to myself, what strange custom of law made you the source of a landowner’s wealth? What would we American farmers be without having distinct ownership of this soil? It sustains us, it clothes us; from it, we draw abundant resources: our best meats, our finest drinks, even the honey from our bees comes from this special place. It’s no wonder we treasure this land, no wonder so many Europeans who’ve never been able to claim a piece of land as their own cross the Atlantic in search of that happiness. This once-rough land has been turned into a pleasant farm by my father, and in return, it has secured all our rights; here lies our status, our freedom, our influence as citizens, our importance as members of this community. I must admit I always view these thoughts with pleasure and extend them as far as my imagination allows: this is what can truly be called the genuine philosophy of an American farmer.
Pray do not laugh in thus seeing an artless countryman tracing himself through the simple modifications of his life; remember that you have required it, therefore with candour, though with diffidence, I endeavour to follow the thread of my feelings, but I cannot tell you all. Often when I plough my low ground, I place my little boy on a chair which screws to the beam of the plough—its motion and that of the horses please him; he is perfectly happy and begins to chat. As I lean over the handle, various are the thoughts which crowd into my mind. I am now doing for him, I say, what my father formerly did for me, may God enable him to live that he may perform the same operations for the same purposes when I am worn out and old! I relieve his mother of some trouble while I have him with me, the odoriferous furrow exhilarates his spirits, and seems to do the child a great deal of good, for he looks more blooming since I have adopted that practice; can more pleasure, more dignity be added to that primary occupation? The father thus ploughing with his child, and to feed his family, is inferior only to the emperor of China ploughing as an example to his kingdom. In the evening when I return home through my low grounds, I am astonished at the myriads of insects which I perceive dancing in the beams of the setting sun. I was before scarcely acquainted with their existence, they are so small that it is difficult to distinguish them; they are carefully improving this short evening space, not daring to expose themselves to the blaze of our meridian sun. I never see an egg brought on my table but I feel penetrated with the wonderful change it would have undergone but for my gluttony; it might have been a gentle useful hen leading her chickens with a care and vigilance which speaks shame to many women. A cock perhaps, arrayed with the most majestic plumes, tender to its mate, bold, courageous, endowed with an astonishing instinct, with thoughts, with memory, and every distinguishing characteristic of the reason of man. I never see my trees drop their leaves and their fruit in the autumn, and bud again in the spring, without wonder; the sagacity of those animals which have long been the tenants of my farm astonish me: some of them seem to surpass even men in memory and sagacity. I could tell you singular instances of that kind. What then is this instinct which we so debase, and of which we are taught to entertain so diminutive an idea? My bees, above any other tenants of my farm, attract my attention and respect; I am astonished to see that nothing exists but what has its enemy, one species pursue and live upon the other: unfortunately our kingbirds are the destroyers of those industrious insects; but on the other hand, these birds preserve our fields from the depredation of crows which they pursue on the wing with great vigilance and astonishing dexterity.
Please don't laugh at seeing a simple farmer reflecting on his life; remember, you asked for it, so with honesty, though a bit shyly, I try to share my feelings, but I can't reveal everything. Often when I work my fields, I set my little boy on a chair attached to the plow beam—he enjoys the movement and the horses, and he’s completely happy, starting to chat away. As I lean on the handle, various thoughts flood my mind. I think, I’m doing for him what my father did for me, and I pray he gets to live and do the same for his children when I’m old and tired! I help his mother by keeping him with me, the fragrant soil lifts his spirits, and it seems to do wonders for him, as he looks so much cheerier since I started this routine; can there be more joy or dignity added to this basic work? A father plowing with his child to feed his family is only second to the Emperor of China doing the same as an example for his nation. In the evening, as I walk home through my fields, I'm amazed by the countless insects I see dancing in the sunset's rays. I hardly knew they existed before—they're so tiny it's hard to spot them; they’re making the most of this fleeting evening, not daring to show themselves in the harsh midday sun. Whenever I see an egg on my table, I’m struck by the incredible transformation it would undergo if I had more restraint; it could have become a gentle hen guiding her chicks with a care and vigilance that would put many women to shame. Or a rooster, perhaps, adorned with the most regal feathers, nurturing to his mate, bold and brave, gifted with remarkable instincts, thoughts, memories, and all the reasoning traits we associate with humans. I can’t help but marvel at my trees shedding their leaves and fruit in the fall and blooming again in spring; the wisdom of the animals that have long inhabited my farm amazes me—some of them even seem to have better memories and intelligence than people. I could share unique stories about that. So what is this instinct we tend to belittle and think of so lightly? My bees, more than any other creatures on my farm, capture my attention and respect; it’s fascinating to see that nothing exists without its enemies, one species chasing and feeding on another: sadly, our kingbirds are the enemies of those hardworking insects, but on the flip side, these birds save our fields from crows, pursuing them skillfully and deftly.
Thus divided by two interested motives, I have long resisted the desire I had to kill them, until last year, when I thought they increased too much, and my indulgence had been carried too far; it was at the time of swarming when they all came and fixed themselves on the neighbouring trees, from whence they catched those that returned loaded from the fields. This made me resolve to kill as many as I could, and I was just ready to fire, when a bunch of bees as big as my fist, issued from one of the hives, rushed on one of the birds, and probably stung him, for he instantly screamed, and flew, not as before, in an irregular manner, but in a direct line. He was followed by the same bold phalanx, at a considerable distance, which unfortunately becoming too sure of victory, quitted their military array and disbanded themselves. By this inconsiderate step they lost all that aggregate of force which had made the bird fly off. Perceiving their disorder he immediately returned and snapped as many as he wanted; nay, he had even the impudence to alight on the very twig from which the bees had drove him. I killed him and immediately opened his craw, from which I took 171 bees; I laid them all on a blanket in the sun, and to my great surprise 54 returned to life, licked themselves clean, and joyfully went back to the hive; where they probably informed their companions of such an adventure and escape, as I believe had never happened before to American bees! I draw a great fund of pleasure from the quails which inhabit my farm; they abundantly repay me, by their various notes and peculiar tameness, for the inviolable hospitality I constantly show them in the winter. Instead of perfidiously taking advantage of their great and affecting distress, when nature offers nothing but a barren universal bed of snow, when irresistible necessity forces them to my barn doors, I permit them to feed unmolested; and it is not the least agreeable spectacle which that dreary season presents, when I see those beautiful birds, tamed by hunger, intermingling with all my cattle and sheep, seeking in security for the poor scanty grain which but for them would be useless and lost. Often in the angles of the fences where the motion of the wind prevents the snow from settling, I carry them both chaff and grain; the one to feed them, the other to prevent their tender feet from freezing fast to the earth as I have frequently observed them to do.
Divided by two conflicting desires, I have resisted the urge to kill them for a long time, until last year when I thought there were too many, and I had let it go on for too long. It was during the swarming season when they all gathered on the nearby trees, intercepting the ones that returned burdened from the fields. This made me decide to kill as many as I could, and I was just about to take aim when a cluster of bees, as big as my fist, flew out of one of the hives, attacked one of the birds, and probably stung it because it immediately screamed and flew away, this time in a straight line rather than erratically. It was pursued by the same fearless group, at a distance, but unfortunately, becoming overconfident, they broke formation and scattered. By making that careless decision, they lost the power they had that made the bird fly off. Sensing their disarray, the bird quickly returned and caught as many as it wanted; in fact, it even had the audacity to land on the very branch from which the bees had chased it. I shot the bird and immediately opened its stomach, from which I retrieved 171 bees. I placed them all on a blanket in the sun, and to my great surprise, 54 of them came back to life, cleaned themselves off, and happily returned to their hive, where they probably shared the story of their adventure and escape, which I believe had never happened before with American bees! I take immense pleasure from the quails that live on my farm; they reward me generously with their various calls and unique tame behavior for the constant hospitality I offer them in winter. Instead of taking advantage of their great distress when nature leaves a barren landscape covered in snow, and necessity drives them to my barn, I let them feed without disturbance; it is one of the most pleasant sights in that dreary season when I see those beautiful birds, tamed by hunger, mingling with all my livestock, safely foraging for the little grains that would otherwise go to waste. Often in the corners of the fences, where the wind keeps the snow from piling up, I bring them both chaff and grain; the chaff to feed them and the grain to prevent their delicate feet from freezing to the ground, something I've seen happen too often.
I do not know an instance in which the singular barbarity of man is so strongly delineated, as in the catching and murthering those harmless birds, at that cruel season of the year. Mr.—-, one of the most famous and extraordinary farmers that has ever done honour to the province of Connecticut, by his timely and humane assistance in a hard winter, saved this species from being entirely destroyed. They perished all over the country, none of their delightful whistlings were heard the next spring, but upon this gentleman's farm; and to his humanity we owe the continuation of their music. When the severities of that season have dispirited all my cattle, no farmer ever attends them with more pleasure than I do; it is one of those duties which is sweetened with the most rational satisfaction. I amuse myself in beholding their different tempers, actions, and the various effects of their instinct now powerfully impelled by the force of hunger. I trace their various inclinations, and the different effects of their passions, which are exactly the same as among men; the law is to us precisely what I am in my barn yard, a bridle and check to prevent the strong and greedy from oppressing the timid and weak. Conscious of superiority, they always strive to encroach on their neighbours; unsatisfied with their portion, they eagerly swallow it in order to have an opportunity of taking what is given to others, except they are prevented. Some I chide, others, unmindful of my admonitions, receive some blows. Could victuals thus be given to men without the assistance of any language, I am sure they would not behave better to one another, nor more philosophically than my cattle do.
I can’t think of a clearer example of the sheer brutality of humans than in the way they catch and kill those innocent birds during that harsh season. Mr.----, one of the most renowned and exceptional farmers to ever bring honor to Connecticut, helped save this species from complete destruction with his timely and compassionate efforts during a tough winter. They disappeared across the country, and not a single one of their lovely songs was heard the following spring—except on this gentleman's farm; we owe the continuation of their music to his kindness. When the harshness of that season has worn down all my animals, no farmer enjoys taking care of them more than I do; it’s one of those responsibilities that brings a deep sense of satisfaction. I find joy in observing their different moods, behaviors, and the varied effects of their instincts driven by hunger. I watch their inclinations and the different outcomes of their emotions, which are just like those in humans; the law is to us just like how I am in my barnyard—a bridle and a check to stop the strong and greedy from overpowering the timid and weak. Aware of their strength, they constantly try to encroach on their neighbors; unhappy with what they have, they quickly consume it to have a chance to take what others receive—unless they are stopped. Some I scold, while others, ignoring my warnings, receive some blows. If food could be given to people without any words, I’m sure they wouldn’t treat each other any better or more reasonably than my animals do.
The same spirit prevails in the stable; but there I have to do with more generous animals, there my well-known voice has immediate influence, and soon restores peace and tranquillity. Thus by superior knowledge I govern all my cattle as wise men are obliged to govern fools and the ignorant. A variety of other thoughts crowd on my mind at that peculiar instant, but they all vanish by the time I return home. If in a cold night I swiftly travel in my sledge, carried along at the rate of twelve miles an hour, many are the reflections excited by surrounding circumstances. I ask myself what sort of an agent is that which we call frost? Our minister compares it to needles, the points of which enter our pores. What is become of the heat of the summer; in what part of the world is it that the N. W. keeps these grand magazines of nitre? when I see in the morning a river over which I can travel, that in the evening before was liquid, I am astonished indeed! What is become of those millions of insects which played in our summer fields, and in our evening meadows; they were so puny and so delicate, the period of their existence was so short, that one cannot help wondering how they could learn, in that short space, the sublime art to hide themselves and their offspring in so perfect a manner as to baffle the rigour of the season, and preserve that precious embryo of life, that small portion of ethereal heat, which if once destroyed would destroy the species! Whence that irresistible propensity to sleep so common in all those who are severely attacked by the frost. Dreary as this season appears, yet it has like all others its miracles, it presents to man a variety of problems which he can never resolve; among the rest, we have here a set of small birds which never appear until the snow falls; contrary to all others, they dwell and appear to delight in that element.
The same vibe is felt in the stable; but there I deal with more caring animals, and my familiar voice quickly makes a difference, bringing back peace and calm. With my greater understanding, I manage all my animals just as wise people must manage fools and the uninformed. A rush of other thoughts fills my mind at that specific moment, but they all fade away by the time I get home. On a chilly night, as I speed along in my sled at twelve miles an hour, numerous reflections are triggered by what’s around me. I wonder, what exactly is that thing we call frost? Our minister compares it to needles that prick our skin. Where has the summer’s warmth gone; where in the world does the N.W. keep these vast stores of nitre? When I see a river in the morning that I can cross, which was liquid the night before, I’m truly amazed! What has happened to the millions of insects that danced in our summer fields and evening meadows; they were so tiny and fragile, their lifespan was so brief, that it’s hard to believe they could learn, in that short time, how to hide themselves and their young so effectively to survive the harshness of the season, protecting that precious beginning of life, that small bit of warmth, which if lost would wipe out the species! Why do those severely affected by the frost have such an overwhelming urge to sleep? As dreary as this season seems, like all others it has its wonders, presenting humans with a range of mysteries they can never figure out; for example, we have a group of small birds that only show up once the snow falls; unlike all other birds, they thrive and seem to enjoy that environment.
It is my bees, however, which afford me the most pleasing and extensive themes; let me look at them when I will, their government, their industry, their quarrels, their passions, always present me with something new; for which reason, when weary with labour, my common place of rest is under my locust-tree, close by my bee-house. By their movements I can predict the weather, and can tell the day of their swarming; but the most difficult point is, when on the wing, to know whether they want to go to the woods or not. If they have previously pitched in some hollow trees, it is not the allurements of salt and water, of fennel, hickory leaves, etc., nor the finest box, that can induce them to stay; they will prefer those rude, rough habitations to the best polished mahogany hive. When that is the case with mine, I seldom thwart their inclinations; it is in freedom that they work: were I to confine them, they would dwindle away and quit their labour. In such excursions we only part for a while; I am generally sure to find them again the following fall. This elopement of theirs only adds to my recreations; I know how to deceive even their superlative instinct; nor do I fear losing them, though eighteen miles from my house, and lodged in the most lofty trees, in the most impervious of our forests. I once took you along with me in one of these rambles, and yet you insist on my repeating the detail of our operations: it brings back into my mind many of the useful and entertaining reflections with which you so happily beguiled our tedious hours.
It's my bees, however, that give me the most enjoyable and varied topics; whenever I watch them, their organization, their hard work, their disputes, their emotions, always show me something new. That's why, when I'm tired from work, I like to rest under my locust tree, right by my bee house. By observing their movements, I can predict the weather and know when they will swarm; but the hardest part is figuring out whether they want to go to the woods when they're flying. If they have already settled in some hollow trees, no amount of salt, water, fennel, hickory leaves, or even the finest beehive will make them stay; they'll choose those rough, natural homes over the best polished mahogany hive. When that happens with mine, I rarely go against their instincts; they work best when they're free. If I tried to confine them, they'd stop working and fade away. On these excursions, we only part temporarily; I usually find them again the following fall. Their little escapades just add to my enjoyment; I even know how to trick their incredible instincts. I’m not worried about losing them, even if they’re eighteen miles from my house and hidden in the tallest trees deep in the forest. I once took you along on one of these adventures, and yet you want me to repeat the details of our activities: it brings back many of the useful and entertaining thoughts that you skillfully used to make our long hours more enjoyable.
After I have done sowing, by way of recreation, I prepare for a week's jaunt in the woods, not to hunt either the deer or the bears, as my neighbours do, but to catch the more harmless bees. I cannot boast that this chase is so noble, or so famous among men, but I find it less fatiguing, and full as profitable; and the last consideration is the only one that moves me. I take with me my dog, as a companion, for he is useless as to this game; my gun, for no man you know ought to enter the woods without one; my blanket, some provisions, some wax, vermilion, honey, and a small pocket compass. With these implements I proceed to such woods as are at a considerable distance from any settlements. I carefully examine whether they abound with large trees, if so, I make a small fire on some flat stones, in a convenient place; on the fire I put some wax; close by this fire, on another stone, I drop honey in distinct drops, which I surround with small quantities of vermilion, laid on the stone; and then I retire carefully to watch whether any bees appear. If there are any in that neighbourhood, I rest assured that the smell of the burnt wax will unavoidably attract them; they will soon find out the honey, for they are fond of preying on that which is not their own; and in their approach they will necessarily tinge themselves with some particles of vermilion, which will adhere long to their bodies. I next fix my compass, to find out their course, which they keep invariably straight, when they are returning home loaded. By the assistance of my watch, I observe how long those are returning which are marked with vermilion. Thus possessed of the course, and, in some measure, of the distance, which I can easily guess at, I follow the first, and seldom fail of coming to the tree where those republics are lodged. I then mark it; and thus, with patience, I have found out sometimes eleven swarms in a season; and it is inconceivable what a quantity of honey these trees will sometimes afford. It entirely depends on the size of the hollow, as the bees never rest nor swarm till it is all replenished; for like men, it is only the want of room that induces them to quit the maternal hive. Next I proceed to some of the nearest settlements, where I procure proper assistance to cut down the trees, get all my prey secured, and then return home with my prize. The first bees I ever procured were thus found in the woods, by mere accident; for at that time I had no kind of skill in this method of tracing them. The body of the tree being perfectly sound, they had lodged themselves in the hollow of one of its principal limbs, which I carefully sawed off and with a good deal of labour and industry brought it home, where I fixed it up again in the same position in which I found it growing. This was in April; I had five swarms that year, and they have been ever since very prosperous. This business generally takes up a week of my time every fall, and to me it is a week of solitary ease and relaxation.
After I finish sowing, as a way to unwind, I get ready for a week-long trip into the woods, not to hunt deer or bears like my neighbors do, but to catch bees instead. I can't say this pursuit is very noble or well-known, but I find it less tiring and just as rewarding; that’s really the only reason I do it. I bring my dog along as a companion, although he’s not much help with this venture. I take my gun because no one should head into the woods without one, along with a blanket, some snacks, wax, vermilion, honey, and a small pocket compass. With these items, I head to woods that are far from any towns. I check to see if there are large trees around; if there are, I build a small fire on some flat stones in a good spot. On the fire, I melt some wax; nearby, on another stone, I drop honey in separate drops, surrounding them with small amounts of vermilion. Then I quietly wait to see if any bees show up. If there are bees in the area, the scent of the melted wax will definitely attract them. They will quickly find the honey since they love to take what isn’t theirs, and as they come closer, they’ll inevitably get some vermilion on their bodies. I then set my compass to track their path, which they follow straight home while loaded. With my watch, I time how long it takes for those marked with vermilion to return. Once I know the direction and can estimate the distance, I follow the first bee and usually manage to find the tree where the hives are located. I mark that tree, and with patience, I’ve sometimes found up to eleven swarms in a season. It's incredible how much honey these trees can sometimes produce, depending on the size of the hollow. The bees won’t swarm until it’s completely full because, like people, they only leave their hive when they run out of space. Then I head to the nearest towns to get help cutting down the trees, secure all my bees, and return home with my bounty. The first bees I ever caught were found in the woods by pure chance, as I had no skill back then in tracking them down. The tree was completely sound, and the bees had made their home in a hollow in one of the main branches, which I carefully sawed off and worked hard to bring home, setting it up again in the same position where I found it. This was in April; that year, I got five swarms, and they’ve done very well since then. This whole process usually takes me a week each fall, and for me, it’s a week of solitude and relaxation.
The seed is by that time committed to the ground; there is nothing very material to do at home, and this additional quantity of honey enables me to be more generous to my home bees, and my wife to make a due quantity of mead. The reason, Sir, that you found mine better than that of others is, that she puts two gallons of brandy in each barrel, which ripens it, and takes off that sweet, luscious taste, which it is apt to retain a long time. If we find anywhere in the woods (no matter on whose land) what is called a bee-tree, we must mark it; in the fall of the year when we propose to cut it down, our duty is to inform the proprietor of the land, who is entitled to half the contents; if this is not complied with we are exposed to an action of trespass, as well as he who should go and cut down a bee- tree which he had neither found out nor marked.
The seed is already in the ground; there isn't much to do at home, and this extra honey lets me be more generous to my home bees, while my wife can make a proper amount of mead. The reason, sir, that you found my mead better than others is that she adds two gallons of brandy to each barrel, which makes it age well and removes that overly sweet taste it can sometimes have for a long time. If we find a bee-tree in the woods (regardless of whose land it's on), we should mark it; in the fall, when we plan to cut it down, it's our duty to inform the landowner, who is entitled to half the honey inside. If we don’t do this, we risk a trespassing lawsuit, just like someone would if they cut down a bee-tree they didn’t find or mark themselves.
We have twice a year the pleasure of catching pigeons, whose numbers are sometimes so astonishing as to obscure the sun in their flight. Where is it that they hatch? for such multitudes must require an immense quantity of food. I fancy they breed toward the plains of Ohio, and those about lake Michigan, which abound in wild oats; though I have never killed any that had that grain in their craws. In one of them, last year, I found some undigested rice. Now the nearest rice fields from where I live must be at least 560 miles; and either their digestion must be suspended while they are flying, or else they must fly with the celerity of the wind. We catch them with a net extended on the ground, to which they are allured by what we call TAME WILD PIGEONS, made blind, and fastened to a long string; his short flights, and his repeated calls, never fail to bring them down. The greatest number I ever catched was fourteen dozen, though much larger quantities have often been trapped. I have frequently seen them at the market so cheap, that for a penny you might have as many as you could carry away; and yet from the extreme cheapness you must not conclude, that they are but an ordinary food; on the contrary, I think they are excellent. Every farmer has a tame wild pigeon in a cage at his door all the year round, in order to be ready whenever the season comes for catching them.
We have the pleasure of catching pigeons twice a year, and sometimes their numbers are so incredible that they block out the sun as they fly. Where do they nest? Such huge numbers must need a ton of food. I think they breed around the plains of Ohio and near Lake Michigan, where wild oats are plentiful; although I've never found any with that grain in their crops. Last year, in one bird, I found some undigested rice. The closest rice fields to my home must be at least 560 miles away, so either they must pause digestion while flying, or they fly incredibly fast. We catch them with a net spread out on the ground and attract them using what we call TAME WILD PIGEONS, which are made blind and tied to a long string; their short flights and repetitive calls never fail to lure the others in. The most I've ever caught is fourteen dozen, although much larger numbers have often been trapped. I've often seen them at the market so cheap that for a penny you could take as many as you could carry; yet, just because they're inexpensive doesn't mean they're ordinary food; on the contrary, I think they're excellent. Every farmer keeps a tame wild pigeon in a cage at their door year-round, ready for the catching season.
The pleasure I receive from the warblings of the birds in the spring, is superior to my poor description, as the continual succession of their tuneful notes is for ever new to me. I generally rise from bed about that indistinct interval, which, properly speaking, is neither night or day; for this is the moment of the most universal vocal choir. Who can listen unmoved to the sweet love tales of our robins, told from tree to tree? or to the shrill cat birds? The sublime accents of the thrush from on high always retard my steps that I may listen to the delicious music. The variegated appearances of the dew drops, as they hang to the different objects, must present even to a clownish imagination, the most voluptuous ideas. The astonishing art which all birds display in the construction of their nests, ill provided as we may suppose them with proper tools, their neatness, their convenience, always make me ashamed of the slovenliness of our houses; their love to their dame, their incessant careful attention, and the peculiar songs they address to her while she tediously incubates their eggs, remind me of my duty could I ever forget it. Their affection to their helpless little ones, is a lively precept; and in short, the whole economy of what we proudly call the brute creation, is admirable in every circumstance; and vain man, though adorned with the additional gift of reason, might learn from the perfection of instinct, how to regulate the follies, and how to temper the errors which this second gift often makes him commit. This is a subject, on which I have often bestowed the most serious thoughts; I have often blushed within myself, and been greatly astonished, when I have compared the unerring path they all follow, all just, all proper, all wise, up to the necessary degree of perfection, with the coarse, the imperfect systems of men, not merely as governors and kings, but as masters, as husbands, as fathers, as citizens. But this is a sanctuary in which an ignorant farmer must not presume to enter.
The joy I get from the songs of the birds in spring is beyond my simple words, as their continuous melodies feel fresh to me every time. I usually get out of bed around that vague time that isn't quite night or day; it’s when the whole vocal choir is at its peak. Who can listen to the sweet love stories of our robins, shared from tree to tree, or the sharp calls of the catbirds, without feeling moved? The beautiful sounds of the thrush from above always make me pause so I can enjoy their lovely music. The colorful dew drops hanging on various objects must inspire even the simplest of minds with the most indulgent ideas. The incredible skill all birds show in building their nests, even without the right tools, along with their neatness and practicality, makes me feel ashamed of how messy our houses can be. Their affection for their mates, their constant care, and the special songs they sing to them while she patiently incubates their eggs remind me of my responsibilities—if I could ever forget them. Their love for their helpless little ones is a poignant lesson; and really, the entire way that what we arrogantly call the animal kingdom operates is remarkable in every way. And vain humans, even with the added gift of reason, could learn from the perfection of instinct how to manage their follies and temper the mistakes that this second gift often leads to. This is a topic I’ve thought about seriously many times; I've often felt embarrassed and amazed when I compare the infallible paths they all follow—consistent, fitting, wise, achieving a necessary perfection—with the rough, incomplete systems of humans, not just as rulers and kings, but as masters, husbands, fathers, and citizens. But this is a sanctuary where an uninformed farmer shouldn’t presume to tread.
If ever man was permitted to receive and enjoy some blessings that might alleviate the many sorrows to which he is exposed, it is certainly in the country, when he attentively considers those ravishing scenes with which he is everywhere surrounded. This is the only time of the year in which I am avaricious of every moment, I therefore lose none that can add to this simple and inoffensive happiness. I roam early throughout all my fields; not the least operation do I perform, which is not accompanied with the most pleasing observations; were I to extend them as far as I have carried them, I should become tedious; you would think me guilty of affectation, and I should perhaps represent many things as pleasurable from which you might not perhaps receive the least agreeable emotions. But, believe me, what I write is all true and real.
If there’s ever a time when a person can truly receive and enjoy blessings that lighten the many burdens life brings, it’s definitely in the countryside, especially when one takes in the stunning views that surround them. This is the only time of year when I eagerly savor every moment, so I make sure not to waste any that could add to this simple and gentle happiness. I wander through my fields early in the morning; everything I do is filled with the most delightful observations. If I were to go on about them as much as I would like, I might bore you; you'd probably think I'm trying too hard, and I might describe some things as enjoyable that wouldn’t give you any pleasure at all. But believe me, everything I’m sharing is completely genuine and true.
Some time ago, as I sat smoking a contemplative pipe in my piazza, I saw with amazement a remarkable instance of selfishness displayed in a very small bird, which I had hitherto respected for its inoffensiveness. Three nests were placed almost contiguous to each other in my piazza: that of a swallow was affixed in the corner next to the house, that of a phebe in the other, a wren possessed a little box which I had made on purpose, and hung between. Be not surprised at their tameness, all my family had long been taught to respect them as well as myself. The wren had shown before signs of dislike to the box which I had given it, but I knew not on what account; at last it resolved, small as it was, to drive the swallow from its own habitation, and to my very great surprise it succeeded. Impudence often gets the better of modesty, and this exploit was no sooner performed, than it removed every material to its own box with the most admirable dexterity; the signs of triumph appeared very visible, it fluttered its wings with uncommon velocity, an universal joy was perceivable in all its movements. Where did this little bird learn that spirit of injustice? It was not endowed with what we term reason! Here then is a proof that both those gifts border very near on one another; for we see the perfection of the one mixing with the errors of the other! The peaceable swallow, like the passive Quaker, meekly sat at a small distance and never offered the least resistance; but no sooner was the plunder carried away, than the injured bird went to work with unabated ardour, and in a few days the depredations were repaired. To prevent however a repetition of the same violence, I removed the wren's box to another part of the house.
Some time ago, while I was sitting in my piazza enjoying a contemplative smoke, I saw an astonishing example of selfishness in a little bird that I had previously regarded as harmless. Three nests were almost right next to each other in my piazza: a swallow's nest was in the corner by the house, a phoebe's nest was on the other side, and a wren occupied a little box I had made specifically for it, which hung in between. Don’t be surprised by their tameness; my entire family had long been taught to respect them just like I did. The wren had previously shown signs of disliking the box I'd given it, but I didn’t know why. Eventually, small as it was, it decided to drive the swallow out of its own home, and to my shock, it succeeded. Audacity often triumphs over modesty, and as soon as it accomplished this, it moved all of its belongings into its own box with incredible skill. Its signs of triumph were very clear; it flapped its wings rapidly, and a universal joy was evident in all its movements. Where did this little bird learn such a sense of injustice? It wasn’t equipped with what we call reason! So here’s proof that those two qualities are very closely related; we see the perfection of one mixing with the faults of the other! The peaceful swallow, much like a passive Quaker, sat quietly at a small distance and never offered any resistance. But as soon as the theft was complete, the wronged bird worked tirelessly, and in just a few days, it repaired the damage. To prevent a repeat of this same aggression, I moved the wren’s box to another part of the house.
In the middle of my new parlour I have, you may remember, a curious republic of industrious hornets; their nest hangs to the ceiling, by the same twig on which it was so admirably built and contrived in the woods. Its removal did not displease them, for they find in my house plenty of food; and I have left a hole open in one of the panes of the window, which answers all their purposes. By this kind usage they are become quite harmless; they live on the flies, which are very troublesome to us throughout the summer; they are constantly busy in catching them, even on the eyelids of my children. It is surprising how quickly they smear them with a sort of glue, lest they might escape, and when thus prepared, they carry them to their nests, as food for their young ones. These globular nests are most ingeniously divided into many stories, all provided with cells, and proper communications. The materials with which this fabric is built, they procure from the cottony furze, with which our oak rails are covered; this substance tempered with glue, produces a sort of pasteboard, which is very strong, and resists all the inclemencies of the weather. By their assistance, I am but little troubled with flies. All my family are so accustomed to their strong buzzing, that no one takes any notice of them; and though they are fierce and vindictive, yet kindness and hospitality has made them useful and harmless.
In the middle of my new living room, I have, as you might remember, a fascinating colony of hardworking hornets; their nest hangs from the ceiling, suspended by the same twig on which it was expertly built in the woods. Their relocation didn’t bother them, as they find plenty of food in my house. I’ve left a hole open in one of the window panes, which works perfectly for them. Because of this kind treatment, they’ve become quite harmless; they feed on the flies that annoy us all summer long, and they’re always busy catching them, even landing on my children’s eyelids. It’s amazing how quickly they cover the flies with a kind of glue to prevent them from escaping, and with their catch prepared, they take them back to their nests as food for their young. These round nests are cleverly divided into multiple compartments, each with cells and proper passages. The materials they use to build their structure come from the cottony furze that covers our oak rails; this substance mixed with glue creates a type of strong pasteboard that withstands all weather conditions. Thanks to them, I have very few flies to deal with. My family has gotten so used to their loud buzzing that no one pays them any mind; and although they can be aggressive and vengeful, kindness and hospitality have made them useful and benign.
We have a great variety of wasps; most of them build their nests in mud, which they fix against the shingles of our roofs, as nigh the pitch as they can. These aggregates represent nothing, at first view, but coarse and irregular lumps, but if you break them, you will observe, that the inside of them contains a great number of oblong cells, in which they deposit their eggs, and in which they bury themselves in the fall of the year. Thus immured they securely pass through the severity of that season, and on the return of the sun are enabled to perforate their cells, and to open themselves a passage from these recesses into the sunshine. The yellow wasps, which build under ground, in our meadows, are much more to be dreaded, for when the mower unwittingly passes his scythe over their holes they immediately sally forth with a fury and velocity superior even to the strength of man. They make the boldest fly, and the only remedy is to lie down and cover our heads with hay, for it is only at the head they aim their blows; nor is there any possibility of finishing that part of the work until, by means of fire and brimstone, they are all silenced. But though I have been obliged to execute this dreadful sentence in my own defence, I have often thought it a great pity, for the sake of a little hay, to lay waste so ingenious a subterranean town, furnished with every conveniency, and built with a most surprising mechanism.
We have a huge variety of wasps; most of them build their nests in mud, which they attach to the shingles on our roofs, as close to the pitch as possible. At first glance, these nests look like nothing but rough and irregular lumps, but if you break them open, you'll see that the inside contains many elongated cells, where they lay their eggs and hibernate in the fall. Trapped this way, they can survive the harshness of winter, and when spring arrives, they can break out of their cells and make their way back into the sunlight. The yellow wasps that build underground in our meadows are much more dangerous because when a mower accidentally mows over their holes, they charge out in a frenzy, moving faster than a man can react. They can be quite aggressive, and the only way to protect yourself is to lie down and cover your head with hay since that's what they aim for. There's no chance of finishing that part of the work until you deal with them using fire and sulfur. However, even though I've had to take such drastic measures for my safety, I've often thought it was a real shame to destroy such an intricate underground town, which is built with such amazing skill and offers every convenience.
I never should have done were I to recount the many objects which involuntarily strike my imagination in the midst of my work, and spontaneously afford me the most pleasing relief. These appear insignificant trifles to a person who has travelled through Europe and America, and is acquainted with books and with many sciences; but such simple objects of contemplation suffice me, who have no time to bestow on more extensive observations. Happily these require no study, they are obvious, they gild the moments I dedicate to them, and enliven the severe labours which I perform. At home my happiness springs from very different objects; the gradual unfolding of my children's reason, the study of their dawning tempers attract all my paternal attention. I have to contrive little punishments for their little faults, small encouragements for their good actions, and a variety of other expedients dictated by various occasions. But these are themes unworthy your perusal, and which ought not to be carried beyond the walls of my house, being domestic mysteries adapted only to the locality of the small sanctuary wherein my family resides. Sometimes I delight in inventing and executing machines, which simplify my wife's labour. I have been tolerably successful that way; and these, Sir, are the narrow circles within which I constantly revolve, and what can I wish for beyond them? I bless God for all the good he has given me; I envy no man's prosperity, and with no other portion of happiness than that I may live to teach the same philosophy to my children; and give each of them a farm, show them how to cultivate it, and be like their father, good substantial independent American farmers—an appellation which will be the most fortunate one a man of my class can possess, so long as our civil government continues to shed blessings on our husbandry. Adieu.
I really shouldn't list all the little things that unexpectedly catch my attention while I'm working and provide me with the best sense of relief. These may seem like insignificant details to someone who's traveled through Europe and America and knows lots about books and various sciences; but for me, who doesn't have time for deeper observations, these simple things are enough. Thankfully, they don't require study, they're obvious, they brighten the moments I spend on them, and they energize the hard work I do. At home, my happiness comes from different sources; I focus all my attention on my children's growing minds and their developing personalities. I have to come up with little punishments for their minor faults, small rewards for their good behavior, and various other strategies based on different situations. But these are topics not meant for your reading, and they should stay behind the walls of my house, as they are private matters suited only to the small sanctuary where my family lives. Sometimes, I enjoy inventing and creating devices to make my wife's work easier. I've had some success with that; and these, Sir, are the narrow circles in which I consistently revolve, and what more could I wish for? I thank God for all the good He's given me; I don't envy anyone else's success, and I only wish for the happiness of living to teach the same philosophy to my children; giving each of them a farm, showing them how to cultivate it, and raising them to be like their father—good, solid, independent American farmers—an identity that will be the most fortunate one for a man like me, as long as our government continues to bless our farming. Goodbye.
LETTER III
WHAT IS AN AMERICAN
I wish I could be acquainted with the feelings and thoughts which must agitate the heart and present themselves to the mind of an enlightened Englishman, when he first lands on this continent. He must greatly rejoice that he lived at a time to see this fair country discovered and settled; he must necessarily feel a share of national pride, when he views the chain of settlements which embellishes these extended shores. When he says to himself, this is the work of my countrymen, who, when convulsed by factions, afflicted by a variety of miseries and wants, restless and impatient, took refuge here. They brought along with them their national genius, to which they principally owe what liberty they enjoy, and what substance they possess. Here he sees the industry of his native country displayed in a new manner, and traces in their works the embryos of all the arts, sciences, and ingenuity which nourish in Europe. Here he beholds fair cities, substantial villages, extensive fields, an immense country filled with decent houses, good roads, orchards, meadows, and bridges, where an hundred years ago all was wild, woody, and uncultivated! What a train of pleasing ideas this fair spectacle must suggest; it is a prospect which must inspire a good citizen with the most heartfelt pleasure. The difficulty consists in the manner of viewing so extensive a scene. He is arrived on a new continent; a modern society offers itself to his contemplation, different from what he had hitherto seen. It is not composed, as in Europe, of great lords who possess everything, and of a herd of people who have nothing. Here are no aristocratical families, no courts, no kings, no bishops, no ecclesiastical dominion, no invisible power giving to a few a very visible one; no great manufacturers employing thousands, no great refinements of luxury. The rich and the poor are not so far removed from each other as they are in Europe. Some few towns excepted, we are all tillers of the earth, from Nova Scotia to West Florida. We are a people of cultivators, scattered over an immense territory, communicating with each other by means of good roads and navigable rivers, united by the silken bands of mild government, all respecting the laws, without dreading their power, because they are equitable. We are all animated with the spirit of an industry which is unfettered and unrestrained, because each person works for himself. If he travels through our rural districts he views not the hostile castle, and the haughty mansion, contrasted with the clay- built hut and miserable cabin, where cattle and men help to keep each other warm, and dwell in meanness, smoke, and indigence. A pleasing uniformity of decent competence appears throughout our habitations. The meanest of our log-houses is a dry and comfortable habitation. Lawyer or merchant are the fairest titles our towns afford; that of a farmer is the only appellation of the rural inhabitants of our country. It must take some time ere he can reconcile himself to our dictionary, which is but short in words of dignity, and names of honour. There, on a Sunday, he sees a congregation of respectable farmers and their wives, all clad in neat homespun, well mounted, or riding in their own humble waggons. There is not among them an esquire, saving the unlettered magistrate. There he sees a parson as simple as his flock, a farmer who does not riot on the labour of others. We have no princes, for whom we toil, starve, and bleed: we are the most perfect society now existing in the world. Here man is free as he ought to be; nor is this pleasing equality so transitory as many others are. Many ages will not see the shores of our great lakes replenished with inland nations, nor the unknown bounds of North America entirely peopled. Who can tell how far it extends? Who can tell the millions of men whom it will feed and contain? for no European foot has as yet travelled half the extent of this mighty continent!
I wish I could understand the feelings and thoughts that must stir the heart and come to the mind of an enlightened Englishman when he first arrives on this continent. He must be filled with joy that he lived in a time to witness this beautiful country discovered and settled; he must feel a sense of national pride as he looks at the chain of settlements along these vast shores. When he thinks to himself, this is the work of my countrymen who, when torn apart by factions and suffering from various miseries and needs, found refuge here. They brought with them their national spirit, which is largely responsible for the liberty they enjoy and the prosperity they have. Here, he sees the hard work of his homeland expressed in a new way and traces in their creations the beginnings of all the arts, sciences, and ingenuity that flourish in Europe. He sees beautiful cities, sturdy villages, vast fields, an enormous country filled with decent homes, good roads, orchards, meadows, and bridges, where a hundred years ago everything was wild, wooded, and uncultivated! What a stream of delightful thoughts this beautiful scene must inspire; it is a view that should fill a good citizen with genuine pleasure. The challenge lies in how to take in such a vast landscape. He has arrived on a new continent; a modern society presents itself for his reflection, different from anything he has seen before. It is not made up, as in Europe, of great lords who own everything and a mass of people who own nothing. There are no aristocratic families, no courts, no kings, no bishops, no religious authority, no unseen power giving a few a very visible one; no large manufacturers employing thousands, no extreme luxury. The gap between the rich and poor is not as wide as it is in Europe. With a few exceptions, we are all farmers, from Nova Scotia to West Florida. We are a community of cultivators spread across a vast territory, communicating with one another via good roads and navigable rivers, connected by the gentle ties of fair governance, all respecting the laws without fearing their power because they are just. We are all driven by a spirit of industry that is free and unrestrained because everyone works for themselves. If he travels through our rural areas, he won't see the hostile castle and the proud mansion next to humble huts and miserable cabins, where livestock and people keep each other warm, living in poverty, smoke, and hardship. A pleasing uniformity of modest comfort is evident throughout our homes. The simplest of our log cabins is a dry and comfortable living space. Lawyer or merchant are the highest titles our towns offer; 'farmer' is the only title for the rural inhabitants of our country. It may take him some time to get used to our vocabulary, which lacks many words of prestige and honor. There, on a Sunday, he sees a gathering of respectable farmers and their wives, all dressed in neat homemade clothes, well-mounted or riding in their own simple wagons. Among them, there isn’t an esquire, except for the unlettered local magistrate. He sees a pastor as uncomplicated as his congregation, a farmer who does not exploit others' labor. We have no princes for whom we toil, starve, and bleed: we are the most perfect society currently in existence in the world. Here, man is as free as he should be; and this satisfying equality is not as fleeting as many others. Many ages will pass before the shores of our great lakes are filled with inland nations, or before the vast unknown lands of North America are fully populated. Who can tell how far it stretches? Who knows how many millions of people it will support and hold? For no European has yet traveled even half the length of this great continent!
The next wish of this traveller will be to know whence came all these people? they are a mixture of English, Scotch, Irish, French, Dutch, Germans, and Swedes. From this promiscuous breed, that race now called Americans have arisen. The eastern provinces must indeed be excepted, as being the unmixed descendants of Englishmen. I have heard many wish that they had been more intermixed also: for my part, I am no wisher, and think it much better as it has happened. They exhibit a most conspicuous figure in this great and variegated picture; they too enter for a great share in the pleasing perspective displayed in these thirteen provinces. I know it is fashionable to reflect on them, but I respect them for what they have done; for the accuracy and wisdom with which they have settled their territory; for the decency of their manners; for their early love of letters; their ancient college, the first in this hemisphere; for their industry; which to me who am but a farmer, is the criterion of everything. There never was a people, situated as they are, who with so ungrateful a soil have done more in so short a time. Do you think that the monarchical ingredients which are more prevalent in other governments, have purged them from all foul stains? Their histories assert the contrary.
The next wish of this traveler will be to find out where all these people came from. They are a mix of English, Scottish, Irish, French, Dutch, German, and Swedish. From this diverse background, the group now known as Americans has emerged. The eastern provinces should be noted as they are the direct descendants of English settlers. I've heard many people wish they had mixed more, but personally, I think it’s better as it is. They stand out prominently in this great and colorful picture; they also contribute significantly to the appealing landscape of these thirteen provinces. I know it’s common to criticize them, but I respect them for what they’ve accomplished; for the accuracy and wisdom in how they’ve managed their land; for their decent behavior; for their early enthusiasm for education; for their ancient college, the first in the Western Hemisphere; for their hard work, which is essential to me as a farmer. There has never been a group, in a situation like theirs, that has achieved so much in such a short period with such an ungrateful soil. Do you think that the monarchical elements more common in other governments have cleansed them of all troubles? Their histories suggest otherwise.
In this great American asylum, the poor of Europe have by some means met together, and in consequence of various causes; to what purpose should they ask one another what countrymen they are? Alas, two thirds of them had no country. Can a wretch who wanders about, who works and starves, whose life is a continual scene of sore affliction or pinching penury; can that man call England or any other kingdom his country? A country that had no bread for him, whose fields procured him no harvest, who met with nothing but the frowns of the rich, the severity of the laws, with jails and punishments; who owned not a single foot of the extensive surface of this planet? No! urged by a variety of motives, here they came. Every thing has tended to regenerate them; new laws, a new mode of living, a new social system; here they are become men: in Europe they were as so many useless plants, wanting vegetative mould, and refreshing showers; they withered, and were mowed down by want, hunger, and war; but now by the power of transplantation, like all other plants they have taken root and flourished! Formerly they were not numbered in any civil lists of their country, except in those of the poor; here they rank as citizens. By what invisible power has this surprising metamorphosis been performed? By that of the laws and that of their industry. The laws, the indulgent laws, protect them as they arrive, stamping on them the symbol of adoption; they receive ample rewards for their labours; these accumulated rewards procure them lands; those lands confer on them the title of freemen, and to that title every benefit is affixed which men can possibly require. This is the great operation daily performed by our laws. From whence proceed these laws? From our government. Whence the government? It is derived from the original genius and strong desire of the people ratified and confirmed by the crown. This is the great chain which links us all, this is the picture which every province exhibits, Nova Scotia excepted.
In this great American refuge, the poor from Europe have somehow come together, and for various reasons; why should they ask each other where they’re from? Sadly, two-thirds of them had no country. Can someone who's lost, working and starving, living a life filled with pain and hardship, really call England or any other nation their home? A place that offered them no bread, where the fields provided no harvest, where they faced nothing but the disdain of the wealthy, harsh laws, prisons, and punishments; where they owned not a single inch of this vast planet? No! Driven by various motives, they arrived here. Everything has worked to rejuvenate them; new laws, a new way of living, a new social system; here they have become true individuals: in Europe, they were like useless plants lacking fertile soil and refreshing rain; they withered away, cut down by poverty, hunger, and war; but now, through the power of relocation, like all other plants, they have taken root and thrived! Previously, they weren’t included in any official lists of their country except those of the poor; here, they are recognized as citizens. What invisible force has caused this incredible transformation? The law and their own hard work. The laws, compassionate laws, protect them as they arrive, giving them the mark of belonging; they receive great rewards for their efforts; these rewards help them acquire land; that land grants them the title of free individuals, and with that title comes every benefit that people could possibly need. This is the grand process our laws perform daily. Where do these laws come from? From our government. Where does the government come from? It is rooted in the original spirit and strong desire of the people, endorsed and affirmed by the crown. This is the great connection that binds us all, this is the image every region shows, except Nova Scotia.
There the crown has done all; either there were no people who had genius, or it was not much attended to: the consequence is, that the province is very thinly inhabited indeed; the power of the crown in conjunction with the musketos has prevented men from settling there. Yet some parts of it flourished once, and it contained a mild harmless set of people. But for the fault of a few leaders, the whole were banished. The greatest political error the crown ever committed in America, was to cut off men from a country which wanted nothing but men!
There the crown has done everything; either there weren’t any people with talent, or they didn’t get much attention: the result is that the area is really sparsely populated; the authority of the crown combined with the mosquitoes has stopped people from settling there. Still, some parts thrived at one point, and it had a gentle, harmless community. But because of the mistakes of a few leaders, everyone was expelled. The biggest political blunder the crown ever made in America was to cut off people from a land that only needed people!
What attachment can a poor European emigrant have for a country where he had nothing? The knowledge of the language, the love of a few kindred as poor as himself, were the only cords that tied him: his country is now that which gives him land, bread, protection, and consequence: Ubi panis ibi patria, is the motto of all emigrants. What then is the American, this new man? He is either an European, or the descendant of an European, hence that strange mixture of blood, which you will find in no other country. I could point out to you a family whose grandfather was an Englishman, whose wife was Dutch, whose son married a French woman, and whose present four sons have now four wives of different nations. He is an American, who, leaving behind him all his ancient prejudices and manners, receives new ones from the new mode of life he has embraced, the new government he obeys, and the new rank he holds. He becomes an American by being received in the broad lap of our great Alma Mater. Here individuals of all nations are melted into a new race of men, whose labours and posterity will one day cause great changes in the world. Americans are the western pilgrims, who are carrying along with them that great mass of arts, sciences, vigour, and industry which began long since in the east; they will finish the great circle. The Americans were once scattered all over Europe; here they are incorporated into one of the finest systems of population which has ever appeared, and which will hereafter become distinct by the power of the different climates they inhabit. The American ought therefore to love this country much better than that wherein either he or his forefathers were born. Here the rewards of his industry follow with equal steps the progress of his labour; his labour is founded on the basis of nature, SELF-INTEREST: can it want a stronger allurement? Wives and children, who before in vain demanded of him a morsel of bread, now, fat and frolicsome, gladly help their father to clear those fields whence exuberant crops are to arise to feed and to clothe them all; without any part being claimed, either by a despotic prince, a rich abbot, or a mighty lord. Here religion demands but little of him; a small voluntary salary to the minister, and gratitude to God; can he refuse these? The American is a new man, who acts upon new principles; he must therefore entertain new ideas, and form new opinions. From involuntary idleness, servile dependence, penury, and useless labour, he has passed to toils of a very different nature, rewarded by ample subsistence.—This is an American.
What attachment can a poor European immigrant feel for a country where he had nothing? The ability to speak the language and the love for a few relatives as impoverished as he is were the only ties that bound him: his homeland is now whatever gives him land, food, safety, and status: "Ubi panis ibi patria" is the motto of all immigrants. So who is the American, this new person? He is either a European or a descendant of one, hence that unusual mix of backgrounds you'll find in no other place. I could point out a family with a grandfather who was English, whose wife was Dutch, whose son married a French woman, and whose four sons now each have wives from different nations. He is an American, who, leaving behind all his old prejudices and customs, adopts new ones from the new lifestyle he has taken on, the new government he follows, and the new status he holds. He becomes an American by being embraced by our great Mother Country. Here individuals from all nations blend into a new race of people, whose work and descendants will one day bring significant change to the world. Americans are the western pioneers, carrying with them the vast wealth of arts, sciences, energy, and industry that began long ago in the east; they will complete the grand circle. Americans were once scattered all over Europe; now they are united into one of the finest population systems ever seen, which will eventually become distinct due to the different climates they inhabit. Therefore, an American should love this country far more than the one where he or his ancestors were born. Here, the rewards of his hard work come in tandem with the progress of his labor; his work is grounded in the principle of self-interest: can it have a stronger incentive? Wives and children, who previously begged him for a bit of bread in vain, now, healthy and cheerful, gladly help their father clear the fields from which abundant crops will rise to feed and clothe them all, with no portion claimed by a despotic king, a wealthy abbot, or a powerful lord. Here, religion asks very little of him; just a small voluntary donation to the minister and gratitude to God; can he refuse these? The American is a new person, acting on new principles; he must, therefore, embrace new ideas and form new opinions. From involuntary idleness, servile dependence, poverty, and unproductive work, he has moved to very different labors, rewarded with sufficient living. —This is an American.
British America is divided into many provinces, forming a large association, scattered along a coast 1500 miles extent and about 200 wide. This society I would fain examine, at least such as it appears in the middle provinces; if it does not afford that variety of tinges and gradations which may be observed in Europe, we have colours peculiar to ourselves. For instance, it is natural to conceive that those who live near the sea, must be very different from those who live in the woods; the intermediate space will afford a separate and distinct class.
British America is made up of many provinces, creating a large community that stretches along a coast that is 1500 miles long and about 200 miles wide. I would like to explore this society, at least as it appears in the central provinces; while it may not offer the same variety of shades and nuances found in Europe, we do have our own unique characteristics. For example, it's easy to imagine that people living by the sea must be quite different from those living in the woods; the area in between will create a separate and distinct group.
Men are like plants; the goodness and flavour of the fruit proceeds from the peculiar soil and exposition in which they grow. We are nothing but what we derive from the air we breathe, the climate we inhabit, the government we obey, the system of religion we profess, and the nature of our employment. Here you will find but few crimes; these have acquired as yet no root among us. I wish I was able to trace all my ideas; if my ignorance prevents me from describing them properly, I hope I shall be able to delineate a few of the outlines, which are all I propose.
Men are like plants; the quality and taste of the fruit come from the specific soil and environment where they grow. We are shaped by the air we breathe, the climate we live in, the government we follow, the religion we practice, and the nature of our work. Here, you will find very few crimes; they haven't taken root among us yet. I wish I could clearly express all my thoughts; if my lack of knowledge stops me from describing them accurately, I hope I can outline a few key points, which is all I intend to do.
Those who live near the sea, feed more on fish than on flesh, and often encounter that boisterous element. This renders them more bold and enterprising; this leads them to neglect the confined occupations of the land. They see and converse with a variety of people, their intercourse with mankind becomes extensive. The sea inspires them with a love of traffic, a desire of transporting produce from one place to another; and leads them to a variety of resources which supply the place of labour. Those who inhabit the middle settlements, by far the most numerous, must be very different; the simple cultivation of the earth purifies them, but the indulgences of the government, the soft remonstrances of religion, the rank of independent freeholders, must necessarily inspire them with sentiments, very little known in Europe among people of the same class. What do I say? Europe has no such class of men; the early knowledge they acquire, the early bargains they make, give them a great degree of sagacity. As freemen they will be litigious; pride and obstinacy are often the cause of law suits; the nature of our laws and governments may be another. As citizens it is easy to imagine, that they will carefully read the newspapers, enter into every political disquisition, freely blame or censure governors and others. As farmers they will be careful and anxious to get as much as they can, because what they get is their own. As northern men they will love the cheerful cup. As Christians, religion curbs them not in their opinions; the general indulgence leaves every one to think for themselves in spiritual matters; the laws inspect our actions, our thoughts are left to God. Industry, good living, selfishness, litigiousness, country politics, the pride of freemen, religious indifference, are their characteristics. If you recede still farther from the sea, you will come into more modern settlements; they exhibit the same strong lineaments, in a ruder appearance. Religion seems to have still less influence, and their manners are less improved.
Those who live near the sea eat more fish than meat and often deal with the roughness of the ocean. This makes them bolder and more adventurous, leading them to ignore the limited jobs found on land. They interact with a diverse group of people, resulting in extensive social connections. The sea sparks their interest in trade and the desire to transport goods from one place to another, providing them with various resources that compensate for hard labor. Those who live in the inland areas, making up the majority, are quite different; simple farming enriches them, but the benefits of government, gentle prompts from religion, and the status of being independent landowners inspire feelings that are not commonly seen among the same class in Europe. What do I mean? Europe has no such group of people; the early education they receive and the early deals they strike give them a high level of wisdom. As free individuals, they tend to be litigious; pride and stubbornness often lead to lawsuits, which might also be influenced by the nature of our laws and governance. As citizens, it’s easy to picture them carefully reading the news, engaging in political discussions, and openly criticizing or blaming leaders and others. As farmers, they are diligent and eager to maximize their gains because it all belongs to them. As people from the North, they enjoy a good drink. As Christians, religion doesn’t restrain their opinions; general acceptance allows everyone to form their own beliefs in spiritual matters; laws govern our actions, while our thoughts are left to God. Characteristics of their lifestyle include hard work, good living, selfishness, legal disputes, local politics, the pride of being free, and a lack of religious concern. If you move further away from the coast, you’ll encounter more modern settlements; they show the same strong traits, though in a rougher form. Religion seems to have even less influence there, and their behavior is less refined.
Now we arrive near the great woods, near the last inhabited districts; there men seem to be placed still farther beyond the reach of government, which in some measure leaves them to themselves. How can it pervade every corner; as they were driven there by misfortunes, necessity of beginnings, desire of acquiring large tracts of land, idleness, frequent want of economy, ancient debts; the re-union of such people does not afford a very pleasing spectacle. When discord, want of unity and friendship; when either drunkenness or idleness prevail in such remote districts; contention, inactivity, and wretchedness must ensue. There are not the same remedies to these evils as in a long established community. The few magistrates they have, are in general little better than the rest; they are often in a perfect state of war; that of man against man, sometimes decided by blows, sometimes by means of the law; that of man against every wild inhabitant of these venerable woods, of which they are come to dispossess them. There men appear to be no better than carnivorous animals of a superior rank, living on the flesh of wild animals when they can catch them, and when they are not able, they subsist on grain. He who would wish to see America in its proper light, and have a true idea of its feeble beginnings and barbarous rudiments, must visit our extended line of frontiers where the last settlers dwell, and where he may see the first labours of settlement, the mode of clearing the earth, in all their different appearances; where men are wholly left dependent on their native tempers, and on the spur of uncertain industry, which often fails when not sanctified by the efficacy of a few moral rules. There, remote from the power of example and check of shame, many families exhibit the most hideous parts of our society. They are a kind of forlorn hope, preceding by ten or twelve years the most respectable army of veterans which come after them. In that space, prosperity will polish some, vice and the law will drive off the rest, who uniting again with others like themselves will recede still farther; making room for more industrious people, who will finish their improvements, convert the loghouse into a convenient habitation, and rejoicing that the first heavy labours are finished, will change in a few years that hitherto barbarous country into a fine fertile, well regulated district. Such is our progress, such is the march of the Europeans toward the interior parts of this continent. In all societies there are off-casts; this impure part serves as our precursors or pioneers; my father himself was one of that class, but he came upon honest principles, and was therefore one of the few who held fast; by good conduct and temperance, he transmitted to me his fair inheritance, when not above one in fourteen of his contemporaries had the same good fortune.
Now we reach the outskirts of the great woods, close to the last inhabited areas; here, people seem to be even further removed from the reach of government, which somewhat allows them to fend for themselves. How can it extend to every corner? They ended up here due to misfortunes, the need for a fresh start, the desire to acquire large pieces of land, laziness, frequent financial hardship, and old debts; bringing together such people does not create a very pleasant scene. When there’s conflict, a lack of unity and friendship; when either drunkenness or laziness dominates in such remote areas; disputes, inactivity, and misery are bound to follow. The solutions to these issues are not the same as those in a well-established community. The few magistrates they have are generally no better than the rest; they are often in a constant state of conflict, whether it's man against man, decided sometimes by fights and sometimes through legal means; or man against every wild inhabitant of these ancient woods, from which they seek to drive them out. Here, people seem to behave like higher-ranking carnivorous animals, living off the flesh of wild animals when they can catch them, and when they can’t, they survive on grains. Anyone wanting to see America in its true form, and grasp its weak beginnings and rough edges, must visit our extensive frontier where the last settlers live, to observe the initial stages of settlement and the various methods of clearing land; where people are completely dependent on their innate tendencies and the unpredictable drive of industry, which often fails without the support of a few moral guidelines. There, removed from examples to follow and the restraint of shame, many families display the most unpleasant aspects of our society. They represent a kind of desperate front line, ten or twelve years ahead of the more respectable group of veterans that follows. In that time, some will prosper and improve, while others, driven away by vice and law, will regroup with similar peers and move even further back; making way for more industrious people, who will complete the work, turn the log cabins into comfortable homes, and, thankful that the initial tough tasks are done, will soon transform that once-primitive area into a fertile, well-organized community. Such is our progress, such is the advancement of Europeans into the interior of this continent. In every society, there are outcasts; this troubled segment acts as our forerunners or pioneers; my father was one of them, but he came with honest intentions, and thus he was one of the few who succeeded; through good behavior and self-restraint, he passed down to me his legacy, when not even one in fourteen of his peers was as fortunate.
Forty years ago this smiling country was thus inhabited; it is now purged, a general decency of manners prevails throughout, and such has been the fate of our best countries.
Forty years ago, this cheerful country was populated like this; it has now been cleaned up, a general sense of decency in behavior is common everywhere, and this has been the outcome for our finest nations.
Exclusive of those general characteristics, each province has its own, founded on the government, climate, mode of husbandry, customs, and peculiarity of circumstances. Europeans submit insensibly to these great powers, and become, in the course of a few generations, not only Americans in general, but either Pennsylvanians, Virginians, or provincials under some other name. Whoever traverses the continent must easily observe those strong differences, which will grow more evident in time. The inhabitants of Canada, Massachusetts, the middle provinces, the southern ones will be as different as their climates; their only points of unity will be those of religion and language.
Aside from those general characteristics, each province has its own unique traits based on its government, climate, farming practices, customs, and specific circumstances. Europeans gradually adapt to these significant influences and, over a few generations, become not just Americans in general, but specifically Pennsylvanians, Virginians, or residents of another province. Anyone traveling across the continent will easily notice these distinct differences, which will become more apparent over time. The people of Canada, Massachusetts, the middle provinces, and the southern ones will be as varied as their climates; their only shared aspects will be religion and language.
As I have endeavoured to show you how Europeans become Americans; it may not be disagreeable to show you likewise how the various Christian sects introduced, wear out, and how religious indifference becomes prevalent. When any considerable number of a particular sect happen to dwell contiguous to each other, they immediately erect a temple, and there worship the Divinity agreeably to their own peculiar ideas. Nobody disturbs them. If any new sect springs up in Europe it may happen that many of its professors will come and settle in American. As they bring their zeal with them, they are at liberty to make proselytes if they can, and to build a meeting and to follow the dictates of their consciences; for neither the government nor any other power interferes. If they are peaceable subjects, and are industrious, what is it to their neighbours how and in what manner they think fit to address their prayers to the Supreme Being? But if the sectaries are not settled close together, if they are mixed with other denominations, their zeal will cool for want of fuel, and will be extinguished in a little time. Then the Americans become as to religion, what they are as to country, allied to all. In them the name of Englishman, Frenchman, and European is lost, and in like manner, the strict modes of Christianity as practised in Europe are lost also. This effect will extend itself still farther hereafter, and though this may appear to you as a strange idea, yet it is a very true one. I shall be able perhaps hereafter to explain myself better; in the meanwhile, let the following example serve as my first justification.
As I’ve tried to show you how Europeans become Americans, it might also be interesting to explain how different Christian sects emerge, fade away, and how religious indifference starts to take hold. When a significant number of people from a particular sect live near each other, they quickly build a place of worship where they can honor the Divine according to their own beliefs. No one bothers them. If a new sect appears in Europe, it’s possible that many of its followers will move to America. They bring their enthusiasm with them and are free to convert others if they can, build a community space, and follow their consciences since neither the government nor any outside authority intervenes. If they are peaceful and hardworking, what does it matter to their neighbors how they choose to pray to the Supreme Being? But if the followers are not clustered together and are mixed in with other groups, their passion will fade due to a lack of support, and it will die out eventually. Then Americans become, in terms of religion, what they are in terms of nationality—affiliated with everyone. The identities of Englishman, Frenchman, and European vanish, just as the specific practices of Christianity as observed in Europe do too. This trend will likely continue in the future, and although this might seem like a strange idea to you, it’s very true. I may be able to explain myself better later; in the meantime, let the following example serve as my initial justification.
Let us suppose you and I to be travelling; we observe that in this house, to the right, lives a Catholic, who prays to God as he has been taught, and believes in transubstantiation; he works and raises wheat, he has a large family of children, all hale and robust; his belief, his prayers offend nobody. About one mile farther on the same road, his next neighbour may be a good honest plodding German Lutheran, who addresses himself to the same God, the God of all, agreeably to the modes he has been educated in, and believes in consubstantiation; by so doing he scandalises nobody; he also works in his fields, embellishes the earth, clears swamps, etc. What has the world to do with his Lutheran principles? He persecutes nobody, and nobody persecutes him, he visits his neighbours, and his neighbours visit him. Next to him lives a seceder, the most enthusiastic of all sectaries; his zeal is hot and fiery, but separated as he is from others of the same complexion, he has no congregation of his own to resort to, where he might cabal and mingle religious pride with worldly obstinacy. He likewise raises good crops, his house is handsomely painted, his orchard is one of the fairest in the neighbourhood. How does it concern the welfare of the country, or of the province at large, what this man's religious sentiments are, or really whether he has any at all? He is a good farmer, he is a sober, peaceable, good citizen: William Penn himself would not wish for more. This is the visible character, the invisible one is only guessed at, and is nobody's business. Next again lives a Low Dutchman, who implicitly believes the rules laid down by the synod of Dort. He conceives no other idea of a clergyman than that of an hired man; if he does his work well he will pay him the stipulated sum; if not he will dismiss him, and do without his sermons, and let his church be shut up for years. But notwithstanding this coarse idea, you will find his house and farm to be the neatest in all the country; and you will judge by his waggon and fat horses, that he thinks more of the affairs of this world than of those of the next. He is sober and laborious, therefore he is all he ought to be as to the affairs of this life; as for those of the next, he must trust to the great Creator. Each of these people instruct their children as well as they can, but these instructions are feeble compared to those which are given to the youth of the poorest class in Europe. Their children will therefore grow up less zealous and more indifferent in matters of religion than their parents. The foolish vanity, or rather the fury of making Proselytes, is unknown here; they have no time, the seasons call for all their attention, and thus in a few years, this mixed neighbourhood will exhibit a strange religious medley, that will be neither pure Catholicism nor pure Calvinism. A very perceptible indifference even in the first generation, will become apparent; and it may happen that the daughter of the Catholic will marry the son of the seceder, and settle by themselves at a distance from their parents. What religious education will they give their children? A very imperfect one. If there happens to be in the neighbourhood any place of worship, we will suppose a Quaker's meeting; rather than not show their fine clothes, they will go to it, and some of them may perhaps attach themselves to that society. Others will remain in a perfect state of indifference; the children of these zealous parents will not be able to tell what their religious principles are, and their grandchildren still less. The neighbourhood of a place of worship generally leads them to it, and the action of going thither, is the strongest evidence they can give of their attachment to any sect. The Quakers are the only people who retain a fondness for their own mode of worship; for be they ever so far separated from each other, they hold a sort of communion with the society, and seldom depart from its rules, at least in this country. Thus all sects are mixed as well as all nations; thus religious indifference is imperceptibly disseminated from one end of the continent to the other; which is at present one of the strongest characteristics of the Americans. Where this will reach no one can tell, perhaps it may leave a vacuum fit to receive other systems. Persecution, religious pride, the love of contradiction, are the food of what the world commonly calls religion. These motives have ceased here; zeal in Europe is confined; here it evaporates in the great distance it has to travel; there it is a grain of powder inclosed, here it burns away in the open air, and consumes without effect.
Let's say you and I are traveling; we notice that in the house to the right lives a Catholic who prays to God as he was taught and believes in transubstantiation. He works hard and grows wheat, and he has a large, healthy family. His beliefs and prayers don't bother anyone. About a mile down the same road, his neighbor might be a hardworking German Lutheran who prays to the same God, according to his upbringing, and believes in consubstantiation; this doesn't scandalize anyone either. He toils in his fields, improves the land, clears swamps, etc. What does the world care about his Lutheran beliefs? He doesn't persecute anyone, nor is he persecuted; he visits his neighbors, and they visit him. Next to him lives a seceder, the most enthusiastic of all sects; his zeal is fiery, but because he’s separate from others like him, he has no church to attend where he could mingle religious pride with worldly stubbornness. He also grows good crops, his house is nicely painted, and his orchard is among the best in the area. How does the country or the province benefit from this man's religious views, or even whether he has any? He is a good farmer, a sober, peaceful citizen: even William Penn would be satisfied. This is the visible character; the invisible one is only guessed at and is nobody’s concern. Next lives a Low Dutchman, who accepts the rules laid down by the synod of Dort without question. He views a clergyman merely as a hired hand; if the clergyman does his job well, he will pay him the agreed amount; if not, he will let him go and do without sermons, leaving his church closed for years. Yet despite this straightforward view, you’ll find his house and farm to be the neatest in the region; based on his wagon and strong horses, it’s clear he values this world more than the next. He is sober and hardworking, so he does what’s expected in this life; for the afterlife, he must rely on the Creator. Each of these people does their best to educate their children, but their teachings are weak compared to those given to the youth in Europe’s poorer classes. Their children will therefore grow up less devout and more indifferent about religion than their parents. The foolish vanity, or rather the madness of making converts, is absent here; they have no time for that—the seasons demand all their attention. Thus, in a few years, this mixed community will show a strange religious blend, neither pure Catholicism nor pure Calvinism. A noticeable indifference, even in the first generation, will become clear; it may happen that the Catholic's daughter will marry the seceder's son and settle down away from their parents. What kind of religious education will they provide their children? An imperfect one. If there happens to be a place of worship nearby, let’s say a Quaker meeting; rather than not show off their nice clothes, they will go, and some might even join that group. Others will remain completely indifferent; the children of these passionate parents will not even know what their family’s religious beliefs are, and their grandchildren will be even more clueless. Being near a place of worship often leads them to it, and the act of attending is the strongest proof they can give of their attachment to any sect. The Quakers are the only ones who maintain a fondness for their worship style; no matter how far apart they are, they still feel connected to the society and usually adhere to its rules, at least in this country. Thus, all sects blend together just like all nations; thus, religious indifference spreads subtly from one end of the continent to the other, which is now one of the defining traits of Americans. Where this will lead, no one can tell; perhaps it will create a vacuum suitable for other systems. Persecution, religious pride, and the desire to contradict are the fuel for what the world typically calls religion. These motives have disappeared here; zeal in Europe is contained; here it dissipates over the large distance it needs to cover; there it’s a grain of powder confined, while here it burns away in the open air, consuming itself without any impact.
But to return to our back settlers. I must tell you, that there is something in the proximity of the woods, which is very singular. It is with men as it is with the plants and animals that grow and live in the forests; they are entirely different from those that live in the plains. I will candidly tell you all my thoughts but you are not to expect that I shall advance any reasons. By living in or near the woods, their actions are regulated by the wildness of the neighbourhood. The deer often come to eat their grain, the wolves to destroy their sheep, the bears to kill their hogs, the foxes to catch their poultry. This surrounding hostility immediately puts the gun into their hands; they watch these animals, they kill some; and thus by defending their property, they soon become professed hunters; this is the progress; once hunters, farewell to the plough. The chase renders them ferocious, gloomy, and unsociable; a hunter wants no neighbour, he rather hates them, because he dreads the competition. In a little time their success in the woods makes them neglect their tillage. They trust to the natural fecundity of the earth, and therefore do little; carelessness in fencing often exposes what little they sow to destruction; they are not at home to watch; in order therefore to make up the deficiency, they go oftener to the woods. That new mode of life brings along with it a new set of manners, which I cannot easily describe. These new manners being grafted on the old stock, produce a strange sort of lawless profligacy, the impressions of which are indelible. The manners of the Indian natives are respectable, compared with this European medley. Their wives and children live in sloth and inactivity; and having no proper pursuits, you may judge what education the latter receive. Their tender minds have nothing else to contemplate but the example of their parents; like them they grow up a mongrel breed, half civilised, half savage, except nature stamps on them some constitutional propensities. That rich, that voluptuous sentiment is gone that struck them so forcibly; the possession of their freeholds no longer conveys to their minds the same pleasure and pride. To all these reasons you must add, their lonely situation, and you cannot imagine what an effect on manners the great distances they live from each other has! Consider one of the last settlements in its first view: of what is it composed? Europeans who have not that sufficient share of knowledge they ought to have, in order to prosper; people who have suddenly passed from oppression, dread of government, and fear of laws, into the unlimited freedom of the woods. This sudden change must have a very great effect on most men, and on that class particularly. Eating of wild meat, whatever you may think, tends to alter their temper: though all the proof I can adduce, is, that I have seen it: and having no place of worship to resort to, what little society this might afford is denied them. The Sunday meetings, exclusive of religious benefits, were the only social bonds that might have inspired them with some degree of emulation in neatness. Is it then surprising to see men thus situated, immersed in great and heavy labours, degenerate a little? It is rather a wonder the effect is not more diffusive. The Moravians and the Quakers are the only instances in exception to what I have advanced. The first never settle singly, it is a colony of the society which emigrates; they carry with them their forms, worship, rules, and decency: the others never begin so hard, they are always able to buy improvements, in which there is a great advantage, for by that time the country is recovered from its first barbarity. Thus our bad people are those who are half cultivators and half hunters; and the worst of them are those who have degenerated altogether into the hunting state. As old ploughmen and new men of the woods, as Europeans and new made Indians, they contract the vices of both; they adopt the moroseness and ferocity of a native, without his mildness, or even his industry at home. If manners are not refined, at least they are rendered simple and inoffensive by tilling the earth; all our wants are supplied by it, our time is divided between labour and rest, and leaves none for the commission of great misdeeds. As hunters it is divided between the toil of the chase, the idleness of repose, or the indulgence of inebriation. Hunting is but a licentious idle life, and if it does not always pervert good dispositions; yet, when it is united with bad luck, it leads to want: want stimulates that propensity to rapacity and injustice, too natural to needy men, which is the fatal gradation. After this explanation of the effects which follow by living in the woods, shall we yet vainly flatter ourselves with the hope of converting the Indians? We should rather begin with converting our back- settlers; and now if I dare mention the name of religion, its sweet accents would be lost in the immensity of these woods. Men thus placed are not fit either to receive or remember its mild instructions; they want temples and ministers, but as soon as men cease to remain at home, and begin to lead an erratic life, let them be either tawny or white, they cease to be its disciples.
But back to our frontier settlers. I need to share that there's something quite unique about living near the woods. People are like the plants and animals that thrive in forests; they’re completely different from those that exist in the open fields. I’ll tell you my thoughts honestly, but don’t expect me to provide any reasons. Living in or close to the woods means their actions are shaped by the wilderness around them. Deer often come to eat their crops, wolves come to kill their sheep, bears to attack their pigs, and foxes to catch their chickens. This constant threat puts a gun in their hands; they hunt these animals, and by protecting their property, they quickly become skilled hunters. Once they become hunters, they abandon the plow. Hunting makes them fierce, moody, and antisocial; a hunter doesn’t want neighbors, they actually resent them out of fear of competition. Before long, their success in the woods causes them to neglect farming. They rely on the earth’s natural fertility, so they do very little; their laziness with fencing often lets what little they plant get destroyed; they aren’t home to watch it. To make up for this, they spend more time in the woods. This new lifestyle brings a different set of behaviors, which are hard to describe. These new behaviors mixed with old ones create a strange kind of lawlessness that leaves a lasting impact. The manners of the native Indians seem respectable in comparison to this European mix. Their wives and children live in laziness and inactivity, and with no meaningful activities, you can imagine the kind of education the kids receive. Their young minds have nothing to focus on but their parents' example; like them, they grow up a mixed breed, half-civilized and half-wild, unless nature gives them certain innate traits. That rich, pleasurable feeling that once struck them so powerfully is gone; owning their land no longer brings them the same joy and pride. You must also consider their isolation, and you can’t imagine the impact that the vast distances between them has on their behavior! Take a look at one of the last settlements at first glance: what is it made up of? Europeans who lack the essential knowledge they need to thrive; people who have suddenly transitioned from oppression, anxiety about government, and fear of laws to the absolute freedom of the woods. This abrupt change significantly affects most people, especially this group. Eating wild meat, no matter what you think, changes their temperament: the only proof I can provide is that I’ve seen it firsthand; and with no place of worship available, they miss out on any little community that might have inspired them to take pride in their appearance. Sunday gatherings, aside from the religious benefits, were the only social bonds that could have encouraged them to be a bit more tidy. Is it really surprising to see men in such situations, buried in hard work, start to decline a bit? It’s actually remarkable that the effects aren’t worse. The Moravians and Quakers are the only exceptions to what I’ve said. The Moravians never settle alone; it's always a community from their society that migrates; they bring their traditions, worship, rules, and standards with them. The Quakers don’t start their lives there as roughly; they can always buy improvements, which is a major advantage, since by that time the area has worked through its initial challenges. So, our worst people are those who are half-farmers and half-hunters, and the worst among them are those who have completely shifted to the hunting lifestyle. As old farmers and new residents of the woods, as Europeans and newly made Indians, they develop the faults of both; they pick up the gloominess and brutality of a native, lacking even the gentleness, or the industry at home. If their manners aren’t refined, at least they become simpler and less offensive by working the land; all of our needs are met by it, our time is split between work and rest, and it leaves little time for major wrongdoing. As hunters, that time is divided between the effort of the chase, the idleness of relaxation, or the indulgence of getting drunk. Hunting is nothing but a reckless, lazy lifestyle, and while it doesn’t always corrupt good intentions, when it combines with bad luck, it leads to desperation: desperation fuels the greed and injustice that are too common among needy people, which is a dangerous downward spiral. After explaining the consequences of living in the woods, can we still foolishly hope to convert the Indians? We should actually start with converting our frontier settlers; and if I dare to mention religion, its sweet sounds would get lost in the vastness of these woods. People in this kind of situation aren’t able to accept or remember its gentle teachings; they need temples and ministers, but as soon as people stop staying at home and start living a wandering life, whether they are brown-skinned or white, they stop being its followers.
Thus have I faintly and imperfectly endeavoured to trace our society from the sea to our woods! yet you must not imagine that every person who moves back, acts upon the same principles, or falls into the same degeneracy. Many families carry with them all their decency of conduct, purity of morals, and respect of religion; but these are scarce, the power of example is sometimes irresistible. Even among these back-settlers, their depravity is greater or less, according to what nation or province they belong. Were I to adduce proofs of this, I might be accused of partiality. If there happens to be some rich intervals, some fertile bottoms, in those remote districts, the people will there prefer tilling the land to hunting, and will attach themselves to it; but even on these fertile spots you may plainly perceive the inhabitants to acquire a great degree of rusticity and selfishness.
So, I've tried, in a faint and imperfect way, to sketch the journey of our society from the sea to our woods! But don't think that everyone moving back acts the same way or falls into the same decline. Many families still carry with them their sense of decency, moral integrity, and respect for religion; but these are rare, and the influence of others can be hard to resist. Even among these settlers, their level of depravity varies depending on their nation or region. If I were to provide proof of this, people might accuse me of bias. In those distant areas, if there are fertile plains or rich land, the locals tend to prefer farming over hunting and become attached to it; however, even in these productive places, you can clearly see the residents becoming quite rustic and self-centered.
It is in consequence of this straggling situation, and the astonishing power it has on manners, that the back-settlers of both the Carolinas, Virginia, and many other parts, have been long a set of lawless people; it has been even dangerous to travel among them. Government can do nothing in so extensive a country, better it should wink at these irregularities, than that it should use means inconsistent with its usual mildness. Time will efface those stains: in proportion as the great body of population approaches them they will reform, and become polished and subordinate. Whatever has been said of the four New England provinces, no such degeneracy of manners has ever tarnished their annals; their back-settlers have been kept within the bounds of decency, and government, by means of wise laws, and by the influence of religion. What a detestable idea such people must have given to the natives of the Europeans! They trade with them, the worst of people are permitted to do that which none but persons of the best characters should be employed in. They get drunk with them, and often defraud the Indians. Their avarice, removed from the eyes of their superiors, knows no bounds; and aided by the little superiority of knowledge, these traders deceive them, and even sometimes shed blood. Hence those shocking violations, those sudden devastations which have so often stained our frontiers, when hundreds of innocent people have been sacrificed for the crimes of a few. It was in consequence of such behaviour, that the Indians took the hatchet against the Virginians in 1774. Thus are our first steps trod, thus are our first trees felled, in general, by the most vicious of our people; and thus the path is opened for the arrival of a second and better class, the true American freeholders; the most respectable set of people in this part of the world: respectable for their industry, their happy independence, the great share of freedom they possess, the good regulation of their families, and for extending the trade and the dominion of our mother country.
It’s because of this scattered situation and the surprising impact it has on behavior that the backcountry settlers of both Carolinas, Virginia, and many other areas have long been seen as a lawless group; it has even been dangerous to travel among them. The government can do very little in such a vast country; it might be better to ignore these irregularities than to take actions that clash with its usual leniency. Over time, these issues will fade: as the larger population draws closer, they will reform and become more refined and compliant. While much has been said about the four New England provinces, their history has never been tainted by such a decline in manners; their backcountry settlers have remained within the bounds of decency, thanks to wise laws and the influence of religion. What a terrible impression such people must leave on the natives’ view of Europeans! They trade with them, allowing the worst individuals to engage in what should only be handled by people of good character. They get drunk with them and often cheat the Indigenous people. Their greed, when kept out of sight from their superiors, knows no limits; and with their slight edge in knowledge, these traders deceive them, sometimes even resorting to violence. This has led to shocking violations and sudden devastations that have frequently marred our frontiers, where hundreds of innocent lives have been lost due to the actions of a few. It was because of such behavior that the Indigenous people took up arms against the Virginians in 1774. This is how our initial steps are taken, how our first trees are cut down, usually by the most corrupt among us; thus, a path is cleared for the arrival of a second and better group, the true American landowners—the most respectable people in this region: respected for their hard work, their happy independence, the significant amount of freedom they enjoy, their good family management, and for helping to expand the trade and the control of our mother country.
Europe contains hardly any other distinctions but lords and tenants; this fair country alone is settled by freeholders, the possessors of the soil they cultivate, members of the government they obey, and the framers of their own laws, by means of their representatives. This is a thought which you have taught me to cherish; our difference from Europe, far from diminishing, rather adds to our usefulness and consequence as men and subjects. Had our forefathers remained there, they would only have crowded it, and perhaps prolonged those convulsions which had shook it so long. Every industrious European who transports himself here, may be compared to a sprout growing at the foot of a great tree; it enjoys and draws but a little portion of sap; wrench it from the parent roots, transplant it, and it will become a tree bearing fruit also. Colonists are therefore entitled to the consideration due to the most useful subjects; a hundred families barely existing in some parts of Scotland, will here in six years, cause an annual exportation of 10,000 bushels of wheat: 100 bushels being but a common quantity for an industrious family to sell, if they cultivate good land. It is here then that the idle may be employed, the useless become useful, and the poor become rich; but by riches I do not mean gold and silver, we have but little of those metals; I mean a better sort of wealth, cleared lands, cattle, good houses, good clothes, and an increase of people to enjoy them.
Europe has hardly any distinctions besides lords and tenants; this beautiful country alone is populated by landowners, who own the land they farm, are members of the government they obey, and help create their own laws through their representatives. This is a belief you’ve encouraged me to hold dear; our differences from Europe not only don’t diminish us but actually enhance our value and importance as individuals and citizens. If our ancestors had stayed there, they would have only added to the crowd and perhaps prolonged the turmoil that had troubled it for so long. Every hardworking European who moves here can be likened to a sprout at the base of a large tree; it takes in and benefits from just a small amount of nourishment; if you remove it from the parent roots and transplant it, it can grow into a fruit-bearing tree itself. Therefore, colonists deserve the recognition that goes to the most valuable citizens; a hundred families barely surviving in some parts of Scotland can, within six years, create an annual surplus of 10,000 bushels of wheat here—100 bushels being a common quantity for a diligent family to sell if they farm quality land. Here, the idle can find work, the useless can become useful, and the poor can become wealthy; but by wealth, I don’t mean gold and silver, as we have little of those metals; I mean a better kind of wealth: cleared land, livestock, good homes, nice clothes, and more people to enjoy all this.
There is no wonder that this country has so many charms, and presents to Europeans so many temptations to remain in it. A traveller in Europe becomes a stranger as soon as he quits his own kingdom; but it is otherwise here. We know, properly speaking, no strangers; this is every person's country; the variety of our soils, situations, climates, governments, and produce, hath something which must please everybody. No sooner does an European arrive, no matter of what condition, than his eyes are opened upon the fair prospect; he hears his language spoke, he retraces many of his own country manners, he perpetually hears the names of families and towns with which he is acquainted; he sees happiness and prosperity in all places disseminated; he meets with hospitality, kindness, and plenty everywhere; he beholds hardly any poor, he seldom hears of punishments and executions; and he wonders at the elegance of our towns, those miracles of industry and freedom. He cannot admire enough our rural districts, our convenient roads, good taverns, and our many accommodations; he involuntarily loves a country where everything is so lovely. When in England, he was a mere Englishman; here he stands on a larger portion of the globe, not less than its fourth part, and may see the productions of the north, in iron and naval stores; the provisions of Ireland, the grain of Egypt, the indigo, the rice of China. He does not find, as in Europe, a crowded society, where every place is over-stocked; he does not feel that perpetual collision of parties, that difficulty of beginning, that contention which oversets so many. There is room for everybody in America; has he any particular talent, or industry? he exerts it in order to procure a livelihood, and it succeeds. Is he a merchant? the avenues of trade are infinite; is he eminent in any respect? he will be employed and respected. Does he love a country life? pleasant farms present themselves; he may purchase what he wants, and thereby become an American farmer. Is he a labourer, sober and industrious? he need not go many miles, nor receive many informations before he will be hired, well fed at the table of his employer, and paid four or five times more than he can get in Europe. Does he want uncultivated lands? thousands of acres present themselves, which he may purchase cheap. Whatever be his talents or inclinations, if they are moderate, he may satisfy them. I do not mean that every one who comes will grow rich in a little time; no, but he may procure an easy, decent maintenance, by his industry. Instead of starving he will be fed, instead of being idle he will have employment; and these are riches enough for such men as come over here. The rich stay in Europe, it is only the middling and the poor that emigrate. Would you wish to travel in independent idleness, from north to south, you will find easy access, and the most cheerful reception at every house; society without ostentation, good cheer without pride, and every decent diversion which the country affords, with little expense. It is no wonder that the European who has lived here a few years, is desirous to remain; Europe with all its pomp, is not to be compared to this continent, for men of middle stations, or labourers.
It's no surprise that this country has so many attractions and offers Europeans numerous reasons to stay. A traveler in Europe feels like a stranger as soon as they leave their own country; but that’s not the case here. We don’t really know strangers; this is everyone’s country. Our diverse landscapes, climates, governments, and products have something for everyone. As soon as a European arrives, no matter who they are, their eyes open to the beautiful scenery; they hear their language being spoken, see familiar customs, and frequently hear the names of families and towns they recognize. They see happiness and prosperity everywhere, experience hospitality, kindness, and abundance; they hardly encounter poverty, rarely hear of punishments or executions, and marvel at the beauty of our towns, which showcase industry and freedom. They can’t help but admire our countryside, our well-maintained roads, good inns, and various conveniences; they naturally grow fond of a place that is so beautiful. While in England, they were just another Englishman; now, they are part of a much larger land, seeing products from the North such as iron and naval goods; the provisions from Ireland, grain from Egypt, and indigo and rice from China. They find that unlike Europe, where society is overcrowded, there is space for everyone in America; if they have a specific talent or skill, they can use it to earn a living successfully. If they’re a merchant, they have endless trade opportunities; if they stand out in any way, they will be employed and respected. If they prefer country life, they see lovely farms and can buy what they need to become American farmers. If they are a hardworking and sober laborer, they won't have to look far or ask around before getting hired, enjoying good meals at their employer’s table, and earning four or five times what they would back in Europe. If they seek undeveloped land, thousands of acres are available at low prices. Whatever their skills or interests, as long as they are reasonable, they can fulfill them. I don’t imply that everyone who comes will get rich quickly; no, but they can make a comfortable living through their hard work. Instead of struggling, they’ll find enough food; instead of being idle, they’ll find work; and for those who come here, that’s wealth enough. The rich stay in Europe; it’s mainly the middle class and the poor who emigrate. If you want to travel independently from north to south, you’ll find easy access and a warm welcome at every home; socializing without pretense, good food without arrogance, and every suitable entertainment the country offers at little cost. It’s no wonder a European who has lived here for a few years wishes to stay; Europe, despite its grandeur, can’t compare to this continent for the middle class or laborers.
An European, when he first arrives, seems limited in his intentions, as well as in his views; but he very suddenly alters his scale; two hundred miles formerly appeared a very great distance, it is now but a trifle; he no sooner breathes our air than he forms schemes, and embarks in designs he never would have thought of in his own country. There the plenitude of society confines many useful ideas, and often extinguishes the most laudable schemes which here ripen into maturity. Thus Europeans become Americans.
A European, upon arriving, seems restricted in his goals and perspective; however, he quickly changes his mindset. Two hundred miles once felt like a huge distance, but now it seems trivial. As soon as he breathes our air, he starts to come up with plans and take on projects he never would have considered back home. There, the abundance of society limits many useful ideas and often stifles the most admirable projects, which here develop and flourish. This is how Europeans become Americans.
But how is this accomplished in that crowd of low, indigent people, who flock here every year from all parts of Europe? I will tell you; they no sooner arrive than they immediately feel the good effects of that plenty of provisions we possess: they fare on our best food, and they are kindly entertained; their talents, character, and peculiar industry are immediately inquired into; they find countrymen everywhere disseminated, let them come from whatever part of Europe. Let me select one as an epitome of the rest; he is hired, he goes to work, and works moderately; instead of being employed by a haughty person, he finds himself with his equal, placed at the substantial table of the farmer, or else at an inferior one as good; his wages are high, his bed is not like that bed of sorrow on which he used to lie: if he behaves with propriety, and is faithful, he is caressed, and becomes as it were a member of the family. He begins to feel the effects of a sort of resurrection; hitherto he had not lived, but simply vegetated; he now feels himself a man, because he is treated as such; the laws of his own country had overlooked him in his insignificancy; the laws of this cover him with their mantle. Judge what an alteration there must arise in the mind and thoughts of this man; he begins to forget his former servitude and dependence, his heart involuntarily swells and glows; this first swell inspires him with those new thoughts which constitute an American. What love can he entertain for a country where his existence was a burthen to him; if he is a generous good man, the love of this new adoptive parent will sink deep into his heart. He looks around, and sees many a prosperous person, who but a few years before was as poor as himself. This encourages him much, he begins to form some little scheme, the first, alas, he ever formed in his life. If he is wise he thus spends two or three years, in which time he acquires knowledge, the use of tools, the modes of working the lands, felling trees, etc. This prepares the foundation of a good name, the most useful acquisition he can make. He is encouraged, he has gained friends; he is advised and directed, he feels bold, he purchases some land; he gives all the money he has brought over, as well as what he has earned, and trusts to the God of harvests for the discharge of the rest. His good name procures him credit. He is now possessed of the deed, conveying to him and his posterity the fee simple and absolute property of two hundred acres of land, situated on such a river. What an epocha in this man's life! He is become a freeholder, from perhaps a German boor—he is now an American, a Pennsylvanian, an English subject. He is naturalised, his name is enrolled with those of the other citizens of the province. Instead of being a vagrant, he has a place of residence; he is called the inhabitant of such a county, or of such a district, and for the first time in his life counts for something; for hitherto he has been a cypher. I only repeat what I have heard many say, and no wonder their hearts should glow, and be agitated with a multitude of feelings, not easy to describe. From nothing to start into being; from a servant to the rank of a master; from being the slave of some despotic prince, to become a free man, invested with lands, to which every municipal blessing is annexed! What a change indeed! It is in consequence of that change that he becomes an American. This great metamorphosis has a double effect, it extinguishes all his European prejudices, he forgets that mechanism of subordination, that servility of disposition which poverty had taught him; and sometimes he is apt to forget too much, often passing from one extreme to the other. If he is a good man, he forms schemes of future prosperity, he proposes to educate his children better than he has been educated himself; he thinks of future modes of conduct, feels an ardour to labour he never felt before. Pride steps in and leads him to everything that the laws do not forbid: he respects them; with a heart-felt gratitude he looks toward the east, toward that insular government from whose wisdom all his new felicity is derived, and under whose wings and protection he now lives. These reflections constitute him the good man and the good subject. Ye poor Europeans, ye, who sweat, and work for the great— ye, who are obliged to give so many sheaves to the church, so many to your lords, so many to your government, and have hardly any left for yourselves—ye, who are held in less estimation than favourite hunters or useless lap-dogs—ye, who only breathe the air of nature, because it cannot be withheld from you; it is here that ye can conceive the possibility of those feelings I have been describing; it is here the laws of naturalisation invite every one to partake of our great labours and felicity, to till unrented, untaxed lands! Many, corrupted beyond the power of amendment, have brought with them all their vices, and disregarding the advantages held to them, have gone on in their former career of iniquity, until they have been overtaken and punished by our laws. It is not every emigrant who succeeds; no, it is only the sober, the honest, and industrious: happy those to whom this transition has served as a powerful spur to labour, to prosperity, and to the good establishment of children, born in the days of their poverty; and who had no other portion to expect but the rags of their parents, had it not been for their happy emigration. Others again, have been led astray by this enchanting scene; their new pride, instead of leading them to the fields, has kept them in idleness; the idea of possessing lands is all that satisfies them—though surrounded with fertility, they have mouldered away their time in inactivity, misinformed husbandry, and ineffectual endeavours. How much wiser, in general, the honest Germans than almost all other Europeans; they hire themselves to some of their wealthy landsmen, and in that apprenticeship learn everything that is necessary. They attentively consider the prosperous industry of others, which imprints in their minds a strong desire of possessing the same advantages. This forcible idea never quits them, they launch forth, and by dint of sobriety, rigid parsimony, and the most persevering industry, they commonly succeed. Their astonishment at their first arrival from Germany is very great—it is to them a dream; the contrast must be powerful indeed; they observe their countrymen flourishing in every place; they travel through whole counties where not a word of English is spoken; and in the names and the language of the people, they retrace Germany. They have been an useful acquisition to this continent, and to Pennsylvania in particular; to them it owes some share of its prosperity: to their mechanical knowledge and patience it owes the finest mills in all America, the best teams of horses, and many other advantages. The recollection of their former poverty and slavery never quits them as long as they live.
But how is this achieved in that crowd of poor, struggling people who come here every year from all parts of Europe? Let me explain; as soon as they arrive, they quickly feel the benefits of the abundance of food we have: they enjoy our best meals and are treated kindly. Their skills, character, and unique work ethic are immediately recognized; they find fellow countrymen everywhere, no matter where they come from in Europe. Let me pick one as a representative of the rest: he gets a job, starts working moderately; instead of being employed by an arrogant boss, he finds himself with equals, sitting at the hearty table of a farmer or at a smaller, equally good table; his pay is good, and his bed is a far cry from the one filled with hardship he used to sleep in: if he acts properly and is loyal, he is embraced and becomes somewhat like a family member. He starts to feel a sense of rebirth; before, he had merely existed, but now he feels like a real person because he is treated as one; the laws of his homeland overlooked him in his insignificance; here, the laws provide him with protection. Imagine the transformation that occurs in this man's mind and thoughts; he begins to forget his previous servitude and dependency, his heart swells with pride and warmth; this first swell inspires him with new ideas that define an American. What affection can he have for a country where he was once burdened? If he's a generous person, the love for his new adoptive country will find its way deep into his heart. He looks around and sees many prosperous individuals who were just as poor as he was a few years ago. This gives him a lot of hope, and he starts to come up with some little plans—the first he’s ever created in his life. If he’s smart, he spends the next two or three years learning, mastering tools, understanding farming, cutting down trees, and so on. This lays the groundwork for a good reputation, which is the most valuable asset he can have. He feels encouraged, makes friends, receives advice and guidance, and feels confident enough to buy some land; he spends all the money he has brought over and earned, trusting to the God of harvests to provide the rest. His good name earns him credit. He now holds the deed, granting him and his descendants full ownership of two hundred acres of land along a river. What a milestone in this man's life! He has become a landowner, transforming from a possibly poor German to an American, a Pennsylvanian, a British subject. He is naturalized, and his name is listed with the other citizens of the province. Instead of being a wanderer, he has a home; he is referred to as a resident of a certain county or district, and for the first time in his life, he counts for something; until now, he has been a nobody. I simply share what I have heard many say, and it’s no wonder their hearts are filled with warmth and stirred with a bunch of feelings that are hard to describe. To rise from nothing; from being a servant to becoming a master; from being the slave of some despotic ruler to a free man, owning land with all the municipal blessings it brings! What a change! It is this transformation that makes him an American. This significant change has a dual effect; it wipes out all his European prejudices, and he forgets the mindset of subordination and the servility that poverty had instilled in him; sometimes he might forget too much, swinging from one extreme to another. If he’s a good person, he starts imagining future prosperity, aims to give his children a better education than he had, thinks about how to act in the future, and feels an eagerness to work he never felt before. Pride steps in and motivates him to pursue everything that isn’t prohibited by law: he respects the laws; with heartfelt gratitude, he looks toward the east, towards that insular government from which all his new happiness comes, and under whose wings and protection he now lives. These thoughts shape him into a good person and a good citizen. You poor Europeans, you who labor and toil for the wealthy—those of you who must give so much to the church and to your lords, and have barely anything left for yourselves—those of you who are valued less than favored hunters or useless pets—you who only breathe the air of nature because it cannot be denied to you; it is here that you can grasp the possibility of the feelings I have described; it is here where the laws of naturalization welcome everyone to share in our hard work and happiness, to cultivate untaxed and unowned lands! Many, too corrupted to change, have brought all their vices with them and, ignoring the opportunities available to them, continued in their old ways until our laws caught up with them and punished them. Not every immigrant succeeds; no, only the sober, honest, and hardworking do: fortunate are those for whom this transition has served as a powerful motivator for hard work, prosperity, and the successful upbringing of children born in their earlier times of hardship; children who would have inherited nothing but their parents' rags if not for their fortunate emigration. Others, however, have been misled by this seductive reality; their newfound pride, instead of driving them to work the land, has kept them idle; simply thinking about owning land is enough for them—despite being surrounded by fertility, they waste their time in inactivity, misguided farming, and unproductive efforts. Generally, the honest Germans are much wiser than almost all other Europeans; they hire themselves out to wealthy landowners, and in that apprenticeship, they learn everything necessary. They keenly observe the successful work of others, which nurtures a strong desire to attain the same benefits. This powerful idea never leaves them; they venture out, and through hard work, strict saving, and relentless effort, they usually achieve success. Their amazement upon first arriving from Germany is immense—it feels like a dream; the contrast is striking indeed; they see their fellow countrymen thriving everywhere; they travel through entire regions where no English is spoken; and in the names and language of the locals, they can trace their German roots. They have been a valuable addition to this continent, and especially to Pennsylvania; the state owes a part of its prosperity to them: their mechanical skills and persistence have given us the finest mills in all America, the best teams of horses, and many other benefits. The memory of their past poverty and servitude never leaves them as long as they live.
The Scotch and the Irish might have lived in their own country perhaps as poor, but enjoying more civil advantages, the effects of their new situation do not strike them so forcibly, nor has it so lasting an effect. From whence the difference arises I know not, but out of twelve families of emigrants of each country, generally seven Scotch will succeed, nine German, and four Irish. The Scotch are frugal and laborious, but their wives cannot work so hard as German women, who on the contrary vie with their husbands, and often share with them the most severe toils of the field, which they understand better. They have therefore nothing to struggle against, but the common casualties of nature. The Irish do not prosper so well; they love to drink and to quarrel; they are litigious, and soon take to the gun, which is the ruin of everything; they seem beside to labour under a greater degree of ignorance in husbandry than the others; perhaps it is that their industry had less scope, and was less exercised at home. I have heard many relate, how the land was parcelled out in that kingdom; their ancient conquest has been a great detriment to them, by over-setting their landed property. The lands possessed by a few, are leased down ad infinitum, and the occupiers often pay five guineas an acre. The poor are worse lodged there than anywhere else in Europe; their potatoes, which are easily raised, are perhaps an inducement to laziness: their wages are too low, and their whisky too cheap.
The Scots and the Irish might have lived in their own countries, maybe just as poor, but enjoying better social benefits. The effects of their new situation don’t hit them as hard, nor do they last as long. I’m not sure why there’s a difference, but out of twelve families of emigrants from each country, typically seven Scots will succeed, nine Germans, and four Irish. The Scots are frugal and hardworking, but their wives can’t work as hard as German women, who, on the other hand, keep up with their husbands and often share the toughest fieldwork, which they understand better. They only have to deal with the usual challenges posed by nature. The Irish aren’t doing as well; they like to drink and fight, they’re quick to resort to legal battles, and they often turn to violence, which causes a lot of problems. They also seem to have a greater lack of knowledge about farming compared to others; perhaps their work at home was less focused and less practiced. I’ve heard many stories about how land was divided in that country; their past conquest has really hurt them by disrupting their land ownership. The land owned by a few is leased indefinitely, and the renters often pay five guineas per acre. The poor there live in worse conditions than anywhere else in Europe; their potatoes, which are easy to grow, might encourage laziness: their wages are too low, and their whiskey is too cheap.
There is no tracing observations of this kind, without making at the same time very great allowances, as there are everywhere to be found, a great many exceptions. The Irish themselves, from different parts of that kingdom, are very different. It is difficult to account for this surprising locality, one would think on so small an island an Irishman must be an Irishman: yet it is not so, they are different in their aptitude to, and in their love of labour.
There’s no way to track observations like this without making a lot of allowances since there are many exceptions everywhere. The Irish people, from various regions of the country, are really quite different. It’s hard to explain this surprising diversity; you’d think that on such a small island, an Irish person would be an Irish person. But that’s not the case; they vary in their willingness to work and in their love for it.
The Scotch on the contrary are all industrious and saving; they want nothing more than a field to exert themselves in, and they are commonly sure of succeeding. The only difficulty they labour under is, that technical American knowledge which requires some time to obtain; it is not easy for those who seldom saw a tree, to conceive how it is to be felled, cut up, and split into rails and posts.
The Scots, on the other hand, are hardworking and frugal; they only need a chance to showcase their skills, and they usually succeed. Their main challenge is the specific technical knowledge required in America, which takes time to acquire; it’s not easy for those who rarely saw a tree to understand how to fell it, cut it into pieces, and split it into rails and posts.
As I am fond of seeing and talking of prosperous families, I intend to finish this letter by relating to you the history of an honest Scotch Hebridean, who came here in 1774, which will show you in epitome what the Scotch can do, wherever they have room for the exertion of their industry. Whenever I hear of any new settlement, I pay it a visit once or twice a year, on purpose to observe the different steps each settler takes, the gradual improvements, the different tempers of each family, on which their prosperity in a great nature depends; their different modifications of industry, their ingenuity, and contrivance; for being all poor, their life requires sagacity and prudence. In the evening I love to hear them tell their stories, they furnish me with new ideas; I sit still and listen to their ancient misfortunes, observing in many of them a strong degree of gratitude to God, and the government. Many a well meant sermon have I preached to some of them. When I found laziness and inattention to prevail, who could refrain from wishing well to these new countrymen, after having undergone so many fatigues. Who could withhold good advice? What a happy change it must be, to descend from the high, sterile, bleak lands of Scotland, where everything is barren and cold, to rest on some fertile farms in these middle provinces! Such a transition must have afforded the most pleasing satisfaction.
As I enjoy seeing and discussing successful families, I want to wrap up this letter by sharing the story of an honest man from the Scottish Hebrides who arrived here in 1774. This story will demonstrate what the Scots can achieve wherever they have the opportunity to work hard. Whenever I hear about a new settlement, I make it a point to visit once or twice a year to observe what steps each settler takes, the gradual improvements, and the different personalities of each family, which play a big role in their success. I note their various ways of working, their creativity, and resourcefulness; since they all start off poor, their lives require intelligence and careful planning. In the evenings, I love to listen to their stories as they give me fresh ideas. I sit quietly and hear about their past hardships, often noticing a strong sense of gratitude towards God and the government among many of them. I have often given well-meaning advice to some of them. When I see laziness and a lack of attention, who could help but wish the best for these new countrymen after enduring so much hardship? Who could hold back good advice? What a wonderful change it must be to move from the high, barren, harsh lands of Scotland, where everything is dry and cold, to settle on some fertile farms in these middle provinces! Such a change must have brought immense joy.
The following dialogue passed at an out-settlement, where I lately paid a visit:
The following conversation took place at a remote settlement I recently visited:
Well, friend, how do you do now; I am come fifty odd miles on purpose to see you; how do you go on with your new cutting and slashing? Very well, good Sir, we learn the use of the axe bravely, we shall make it out; we have a belly full of victuals every day, our cows run about, and come home full of milk, our hogs get fat of themselves in the woods: Oh, this is a good country! God bless the king, and William Penn; we shall do very well by and by, if we keep our healths. Your loghouse looks neat and light, where did you get these shingles? One of our neighbours is a New-England man, and he showed us how to split them out of chestnut-trees. Now for a barn, but all in good time, here are fine trees to build with. Who is to frame it, sure you don't understand that work yet? A countryman of ours who has been in America these ten years, offers to wait for his money until the second crop is lodged in it. What did you give for your land? Thirty-five shillings per acre, payable in seven years. How many acres have you got? An hundred and fifty. That is enough to begin with; is not your land pretty hard to clear? Yes, Sir, hard enough, but it would be harder still if it were ready cleared, for then we should have no timber, and I love the woods much; the land is nothing without them. Have not you found out any bees yet? No, Sir; and if we had we should not know what to do with them. I will tell you by and by. You are very kind. Farewell, honest man, God prosper you; whenever you travel toward——, inquire for J.S. He will entertain you kindly, provided you bring him good tidings from your family and farm. In this manner I often visit them, and carefully examine their houses, their modes of ingenuity, their different ways; and make them all relate all they know, and describe all they feel. These are scenes which I believe you would willingly share with me. I well remember your philanthropic turn of mind. Is it not better to contemplate under these humble roofs, the rudiments of future wealth and population, than to behold the accumulated bundles of litigious papers in the office of a lawyer? To examine how the world is gradually settled, how the howling swamp is converted into a pleasing meadow, the rough ridge into a fine field; and to hear the cheerful whistling, the rural song, where there was no sound heard before, save the yell of the savage, the screech of the owl or the hissing of the snake? Here an European, fatigued with luxury, riches, and pleasures, may find a sweet relaxation in a series of interesting scenes, as affecting as they are new. England, which now contains so many domes, so many castles, was once like this; a place woody and marshy; its inhabitants, now the favourite nation for arts and commerce, were once painted like our neighbours. The country will nourish in its turn, and the same observations will be made which I have just delineated. Posterity will look back with avidity and pleasure, to trace, if possible, the era of this or that particular settlement.
Well, my friend, how are you doing? I’ve come over fifty miles just to see you. How’s your new project of cutting and slashing going? Very well, good sir, we’re learning to use the axe quite well; we’ll manage just fine. We have enough food every day, our cows roam freely and come back full of milk, and our pigs are getting fat on their own in the woods. Oh, this is a great country! God bless the king and William Penn; we’ll be doing well soon if we stay healthy. Your log house looks neat and bright. Where did you get those shingles? One of our neighbors is from New England, and he showed us how to split them from chestnut trees. Now we just need a barn, but that can wait; there are plenty of nice trees to build with. Who will do the framing? You don’t understand that work yet, do you? A fellow countryman of ours who’s been in America for ten years has offered to wait for his payment until the second crop is stored in it. How much did you pay for your land? Thirty-five shillings per acre, payable in seven years. How many acres do you have? One hundred and fifty. That’s a good start; isn’t your land pretty tough to clear? Yes, sir, quite tough, but it would be even tougher if it were already cleared because then we’d have no timber, and I really love the woods; the land is nothing without them. Haven’t you found any bees yet? No, sir, and even if we did, we wouldn’t know what to do with them. I’ll tell you sometime. You’re very kind. Farewell, honest man, may God prosper you; whenever you travel toward—, ask for J.S. He’ll welcome you warmly, as long as you bring him good news from your family and farm. This is how I often visit them, carefully checking their houses, their inventive ways, and making them share what they know and explain how they feel. I believe these are experiences you would enjoy sharing with me. I remember your kind-hearted nature well. Isn’t it better to reflect under these humble roofs on the foundations of future wealth and population rather than looking at piles of legal documents in a lawyer’s office? To see how the world is slowly settling, how the wild swamps turn into beautiful meadows, how the rough landscape becomes fine fields; and to hear the cheerful whistling, the rural songs, where there was once only the cries of the savage, the hoots of the owl, or the hissing of the snake? Here, a European worn out by luxury, riches, and pleasure can find a refreshing escape in a series of engaging scenes that are as moving as they are new. England, which now has so many domes and castles, was once like this; a place that was wooded and marshy; its inhabitants, now the favored nation in arts and commerce, once painted like our neighbors. The country will thrive in due time, and the same observations I’ve just described will be made. Future generations will eagerly and happily look back to trace, if possible, the era of this or that particular settlement.
Pray, what is the reason that the Scots are in general more religious, more faithful, more honest, and industrious than the Irish? I do not mean to insinuate national reflections, God forbid! It ill becomes any man, and much less an American; but as I know men are nothing of themselves, and that they owe all their different modifications either to government or other local circumstances, there must be some powerful causes which constitute this great national difference.
Pray, what is the reason that Scots are generally more religious, faithful, honest, and hardworking than the Irish? I don’t mean to suggest anything negative about either nation, God forbid! It’s unbecoming for any person, especially an American. But since I believe people are shaped by their circumstances and that their differences come from government or local factors, there must be some strong reasons behind this significant national difference.
Agreeable to the account which several Scotchmen have given me of the north of Britain, of the Orkneys, and the Hebride Islands, they seem, on many accounts, to be unfit for the habitation of men; they appear to be calculated only for great sheep pastures. Who then can blame the inhabitants of these countries for transporting themselves hither? This great continent must in time absorb the poorest part of Europe; and this will happen in proportion as it becomes better known; and as war, taxation, oppression, and misery increase there. The Hebrides appear to be fit only for the residence of malefactors, and it would be much better to send felons there than either to Virginia or Maryland. What a strange compliment has our mother country paid to two of the finest provinces in America! England has entertained in that respect very mistaken ideas; what was intended as a punishment, is become the good fortune of several; many of those who have been transported as felons, are now rich, and strangers to the stings of those wants that urged them to violations of the law: they are become industrious, exemplary, and useful citizens. The English government should purchase the most northern and barren of those islands; it should send over to us the honest, primitive Hebrideans, settle them here on good lands, as a reward for their virtue and ancient poverty; and replace them with a colony of her wicked sons. The severity of the climate, the inclemency of the seasons, the sterility of the soil, the tempestuousness of the sea, would afflict and punish enough. Could there be found a spot better adapted to retaliate the injury it had received by their crimes? Some of those islands might be considered as the hell of Great Britain, where all evil spirits should be sent. Two essential ends would be answered by this simple operation. The good people, by emigration, would be rendered happier; the bad ones would be placed where they ought to be. In a few years the dread of being sent to that wintry region would have a much stronger effect than that of transportation.—This is no place of punishment; were I a poor hopeless, breadless Englishman, and not restrained by the power of shame, I should be very thankful for the passage. It is of very little importance how, and in what manner an indigent man arrives; for if he is but sober, honest, and industrious, he has nothing more to ask of heaven. Let him go to work, he will have opportunities enough to earn a comfortable support, and even the means of procuring some land; which ought to be the utmost wish of every person who has health and hands to work. I knew a man who came to this country, in the literal sense of the expression, stark naked; I think he was a Frenchman, and a sailor on board an English man-of- war. Being discontented, he had stripped himself and swam ashore; where, finding clothes and friends, he settled afterwards at Maraneck, in the county of Chester, in the province of New York: he married and left a good farm to each of his sons. I knew another person who was but twelve years old when he was taken on the frontiers of Canada, by the Indians; at his arrival at Albany he was purchased by a gentleman, who generously bound him apprentice to a tailor. He lived to the age of ninety, and left behind him a fine estate and a numerous family, all well settled; many of them I am acquainted with.—Where is then the industrious European who ought to despair?
According to the accounts I've heard from several Scots about northern Britain, the Orkneys, and the Hebrides, these places seem largely unsuitable for human habitation; they seem primarily suitable for vast sheep pastures. So, who can blame the people living there for moving here? This great continent will inevitably take in the poorest parts of Europe, especially as it becomes better known and as war, taxes, oppression, and suffering increase back there. The Hebrides seem fit only for criminals, and it would be much better to send felons there than to Virginia or Maryland. What a peculiar compliment our mother country has given to two of the richest provinces in America! England has very misguided notions in that regard; what was intended as punishment has turned into a blessing for many. Some of those who were sent over as felons are now wealthy, free from the desperation that drove them to break the law: they’ve become hardworking, exemplary, and productive citizens. The English government should buy the most northern and barren of those islands; it should send us the honest, hardworking Hebrideans, settle them here on good land as a reward for their virtue and long-standing poverty; and replace them with a colony of their wicked sons. The harsh climate, severe weather, poor soil, and turbulent sea would serve to punish them enough. Could there be a better place to respond to the harm caused by their crimes? Some of those islands could be seen as Britain’s hell, where all evil spirits should be sent. This simple act would accomplish two important goals. The good people, through emigration, would find greater happiness; the bad people would be put where they belong. In a few years, the fear of being sent to that icy wasteland would have a much stronger impact than the threat of transportation. This is not a place of punishment; were I a poor, hopeless, starving Englishman, without the constraints of shame, I would be very thankful for the passage. It doesn't really matter how a needy person arrives; as long as they are sober, honest, and hardworking, they have nothing more to ask from heaven. Let them get to work; they will have plenty of chances to earn a decent living, and even the means to buy some land, which should be the ultimate goal of anyone who is healthy and able to work. I knew a man who came to this country literally without a stitch on; I believe he was a Frenchman and a sailor on an English warship. Discontented, he stripped off his clothes and swam ashore; there, he found clothes and friends and later settled in Maraneck, in Chester County, New York. He married and left a good farm to each of his sons. I also knew another person who was just twelve years old when he was captured on the Canadian frontier by the Indians; upon arriving in Albany, he was bought by a gentleman who kindly apprenticed him to a tailor. He lived to be ninety, leaving behind a nice estate and a large family, all well-established; I know many of them. So, where is the industrious European who should feel hopeless?
After a foreigner from any part of Europe is arrived, and become a citizen; let him devoutly listen to the voice of our great parent, which says to him, "Welcome to my shores, distressed European; bless the hour in which thou didst see my verdant fields, my fair navigable rivers, and my green mountains!—If thou wilt work, I have bread for thee; if thou wilt be honest, sober, and industrious, I have greater rewards to confer on thee—ease and independence. I will give thee fields to feed and clothe thee; a comfortable fireside to sit by, and tell thy children by what means thou hast prospered; and a decent bed to repose on. I shall endow thee beside with the immunities of a freeman. If thou wilt carefully educate thy children, teach them gratitude to God, and reverence to that government, that philanthropic government, which has collected here so many men and made them happy. I will also provide for thy progeny; and to every good man this ought to be the most holy, the most powerful, the most earnest wish he can possibly form, as well as the most consolatory prospect when he dies. Go thou and work and till; thou shalt prosper, provided thou be just, grateful, and industrious."
After a foreigner from anywhere in Europe arrives and becomes a citizen, let him listen to the voice of our great nation, which says to him, "Welcome to my shores, troubled European; cherish the moment you first saw my lush fields, my beautiful navigable rivers, and my green mountains!—If you are willing to work, I have food for you; if you are honest, disciplined, and hardworking, I have even greater rewards for you—comfort and independence. I will provide you with land to sustain and clothe you; a warm fireside to sit by and share with your children how you thrived; and a decent bed to rest on. I shall also grant you the rights of a free person. If you carefully educate your children, teaching them gratitude to God and respect for that government, that compassionate government, which has brought together so many people and made them happy. I will also take care of your descendants; and for every good person, this should be the most sacred, the most important, the most heartfelt wish they can have, as well as the most comforting thought as they face death. Go and work the land; you will succeed as long as you are fair, grateful, and hardworking."
HISTORY OF ANDREW, THE HEBRIDEAN
Let historians give the detail of our charters, the succession of our several governors, and of their administrations; of our political struggles, and of the foundation of our towns: let annalists amuse themselves with collecting anecdotes of the establishment of our modern provinces: eagles soar high—I, a feebler bird, cheerfully content myself with skipping from bush to bush, and living on insignificant insects. I am so habituated to draw all my food and pleasure from the surface of the earth which I till, that I cannot, nor indeed am I able to quit it—I therefore present you with the short history of a simple Scotchman; though it contain not a single remarkable event to amaze the reader; no tragical scene to convulse the heart, or pathetic narrative to draw tears from sympathetic eyes. All I wish to delineate is, the progressive steps of a poor man, advancing from indigence to ease; from oppression to freedom; from obscurity and contumely to some degree of consequence—not by virtue of any freaks of fortune, but by the gradual operation of sobriety, honesty, and emigration. These are the limited fields, through which I love to wander; sure to find in some parts, the smile of new-born happiness, the glad heart, inspiring the cheerful song, the glow of manly pride excited by vivid hopes and rising independence. I always return from my neighbourly excursions extremely happy, because there I see good living almost under every roof, and prosperous endeavours almost in every field. But you may say, why don't you describe some of the more ancient, opulent settlements of our country, where even the eye of an European has something to admire? It is true, our American fields are in general pleasing to behold, adorned and intermixed as they are with so many substantial houses, flourishing orchards, and copses of woodlands; the pride of our farms, the source of every good we possess. But what I might observe there is but natural and common; for to draw comfortable subsistence from well fenced cultivated fields, is easy to conceive. A father dies and leaves a decent house and rich farm to his son; the son modernises the one, and carefully tills the other; marries the daughter of a friend and neighbour: this is the common prospect; but though it is rich and pleasant, yet it is far from being so entertaining and instructive as the one now in my view.
Let historians detail our charters, the succession of our various governors, and their administrations; the political struggles we've faced, and the founding of our towns: let chroniclers enjoy gathering anecdotes about the establishment of our modern provinces. Eagles soar high—I, a weaker bird, am happily content to hop from bush to bush, living on insignificant insects. I'm so used to drawing all my food and pleasure from the surface of the earth that I farm, that I can't, nor do I even want to leave it. So, I present you with the brief history of a simple Scotsman; though it contains no remarkable events to astonish the reader, no tragic scenes to wrench the heart, or poignant tales to draw tears from sympathetic eyes. All I wish to depict is the gradual journey of a poor man moving from poverty to comfort; from oppression to freedom; from obscurity and scorn to some level of importance—not due to any twists of fate, but through the steady effect of sobriety, honesty, and migration. These are the modest paths I enjoy wandering; sure to find in some parts, the smile of newfound happiness, the cheerful heart inspiring joyful songs, the glow of manly pride ignited by vivid hopes and growing independence. I always return from my local outings incredibly happy because I see good living almost under every roof and prosperous efforts in almost every field. But you might ask, why don't I describe some of the older, wealthier settlements of our country, where even an outsider can find something to admire? It's true, our American fields are generally pleasing to the eye, adorned and mixed with many sturdy houses, thriving orchards, and patches of woodlands; the pride of our farms, the source of all we possess. But what I could point out there is just natural and ordinary; for it's easy to imagine drawing a comfortable living from well-fenced, cultivated fields. A father dies and leaves a decent house and rich farm to his son; the son remodels the house and carefully tends to the farm; he marries the daughter of a friend and neighbor: this is the typical scenario; and while it's rich and pleasant, it's far from being as engaging and enlightening as the one I'm focusing on now.
I had rather attend on the shore to welcome the poor European when he arrives, I observe him in his first moments of embarrassment, trace him throughout his primary difficulties, follow him step by step, until he pitches his tent on some piece of land, and realises that energetic wish which has made him quit his native land, his kindred, and induced him to traverse a boisterous ocean. It is there I want to observe his first thoughts and feelings, the first essays of an industry, which hitherto has been suppressed. I wish to see men cut down the first trees, erect their new buildings, till their first fields, reap their first crops, and say for the first time in their lives, "This is our own grain, raised from American soil—on it we shall feed and grow fat, and convert the rest into gold and silver." I want to see how the happy effects of their sobriety, honesty, and industry are first displayed: and who would not take a pleasure in seeing these strangers settling as new countrymen, struggling with arduous difficulties, overcoming them, and becoming happy.
I would rather be on the shore to welcome the poor European when he arrives. I want to see him in his first moments of awkwardness, follow him through his initial challenges, step by step, until he sets up his tent on a piece of land and feels that strong desire which made him leave his homeland, his family, and cross a rough ocean. That’s when I want to witness his first thoughts and feelings and the beginning of a hard work that had previously been held back. I want to see people cut down the first trees, build their new homes, cultivate their first fields, harvest their first crops, and finally say for the first time, “This is our own grain, grown from American soil—this will nourish us and help us thrive, and we’ll turn the rest into gold and silver.” I want to see how the positive effects of their hard work, honesty, and dedication first show up; who wouldn't enjoy watching these newcomers settling in as fellow citizens, tackling tough challenges, overcoming them, and finding happiness?
Landing on this great continent is like going to sea, they must have a compass, some friendly directing needle; or else they will uselessly err and wander for a long time, even with a fair wind: yet these are the struggles through which our forefathers have waded; and they have left us no other records of them, but the possession of our farms. The reflections I make on these new settlers recall to my mind what my grandfather did in his days; they fill me with gratitude to his memory as well as to that government, which invited him to come, and helped him when he arrived, as well as many others. Can I pass over these reflections without remembering thy name, O Penn! thou best of legislators; who by the wisdom of thy laws hast endowed human nature, within the bounds of thy province, with every dignity it can possibly enjoy in a civilised state; and showed by thy singular establishment, what all men might be if they would follow thy example!
Landing on this great continent is like setting out to sea; they need a compass, a friendly guiding needle; otherwise, they'll just end up getting lost for a long time, even with a good wind. Yet these are the challenges our ancestors faced, and they’ve left us with no other records of their struggles except for the land we now own. My thoughts about these new settlers remind me of what my grandfather did in his time; they fill me with gratitude for his memory as well as for the government that invited him here and supported him upon arrival, along with many others. Can I reflect on this without mentioning your name, O Penn! You’re the best of lawmakers; through the wisdom of your laws, you’ve given human nature, within your territory, every dignity it could possibly have in a civilized society; and you’ve shown through your unique establishment what all people could be if they followed your example!
In the year 1770, I purchased some lands in the county of——, which I intended for one of my sons; and was obliged to go there in order to see them properly surveyed and marked out: the soil is good, but the country has a very wild aspect. However I observed with pleasure, that land sells very fast; and I am in hopes when the lad gets a wife, it will be a well-settled decent country. Agreeable to our customs, which indeed are those of nature, it is our duty to provide for our eldest children while we live, in order that our homesteads may be left to the youngest, who are the most helpless. Some people are apt to regard the portions given to daughters as so much lost to the family; but this is selfish, and is not agreeable to my way of thinking; they cannot work as men do; they marry young: I have given an honest European a farm to till for himself, rent free, provided he clears an acre of swamp every year, and that he quits it whenever my daughter shall marry. It will procure her a substantial husband, a good farmer—and that is all my ambition.
In 1770, I bought some land in the county of——, which I planned for one of my sons; and I had to go there to make sure it was properly surveyed and marked. The soil is good, but the area looks quite wild. However, I was pleased to see that land sells quickly, and I hope that when the boy gets married, it will become a well-settled, decent area. According to our customs, which are really just natural, it’s our responsibility to provide for our eldest children while we're alive, so that our homesteads can be passed down to the youngest, who are the most vulnerable. Some people think that the portions given to daughters are a loss to the family, but I find that selfish, and it doesn't match my way of thinking; they can't work like men do; they marry young. I’ve given a respectable European a farm to manage rent-free, as long as he clears an acre of swamp each year, and that he leaves it when my daughter marries. That will help her find a good husband, a solid farmer—and that’s all I hope for.
Whilst I was in the woods I met with a party of Indians; I shook hands with them, and I perceived they had killed a cub; I had a little Peach brandy, they perceived it also, we therefore joined company, kindled a large fire, and ate an hearty supper. I made their hearts glad, and we all reposed on good beds of leaves. Soon after dark, I was surprised to hear a prodigious hooting through the woods; the Indians laughed heartily. One of them, more skilful than the rest, mimicked the owls so exactly, that a very large one perched on a high tree over our fire. We soon brought him down; he measured five feet seven inches from one extremity of the wings to the other. By Captain——I have sent you the talons, on which I have had the heads of small candlesticks fixed. Pray keep them on the table of your study for my sake.
While I was in the woods, I ran into a group of Indians. I shook hands with them and noticed they had killed a cub. I had a little Peach brandy, and they noticed it too, so we decided to hang out together, built a large fire, and enjoyed a hearty supper. I made them happy, and we all lounged on nice beds of leaves. Soon after dark, I was surprised to hear a loud hooting in the woods; the Indians laughed heartily. One of them, more skilled than the others, mimicked the owls so well that a very large one landed on a tall tree above our fire. We quickly brought it down; it measured five feet seven inches from one wingtip to the other. By Captain——I’ve sent you the talons, which I’ve had made into small candlestick holders. Please keep them on your study table for my sake.
Contrary to my expectation, I found myself under the necessity of going to Philadelphia, in order to pay the purchase money, and to have the deeds properly recorded. I thought little of the journey, though it was above two hundred miles, because I was well acquainted with many friends, at whose houses I intended to stop. The third night after I left the woods, I put up at Mr.——'s, the most worthy citizen I know; he happened to lodge at my house when you was there.—He kindly inquired after your welfare, and desired I would make a friendly mention of him to you. The neatness of these good people is no phenomenon, yet I think this excellent family surpasses everything I know. No sooner did I lie down to rest than I thought myself in a most odoriferous arbour, so sweet and fragrant were the sheets. Next morning I found my host in the orchard destroying caterpillars. I think, friend B., said I, that thee art greatly departed from the good rules of the society; thee seemeth to have quitted that happy simplicity for which it hath hitherto been so remarkable. Thy rebuke, friend James, is a pretty heavy one; what motive canst thee have for thus accusing us? Thy kind wife made a mistake last evening, I said; she put me on a bed of roses, instead of a common one; I am not used to such delicacies. And is that all, friend James, that thee hast to reproach us with?—Thee wilt not call it luxury I hope? thee canst but know that it is the produce of our garden; and friend Pope sayeth, that "to enjoy is to obey." This is a most learned excuse indeed, friend B., and must be valued because it is founded upon truth. James, my wife hath done nothing more to thy bed than what is done all the year round to all the beds in the family; she sprinkles her linen with rose-water before she puts it under the press; it is her fancy, and I have nought to say. But thee shalt not escape so, verily I will send for her; thee and she must settle the matter, whilst I proceed on my work, before the sun gets too high.—Tom, go thou and call thy mistress Philadelphia. What. said I, is thy wife called by that name? I did not know that before. I'll tell thee, James, how it came to pass: her grandmother was the first female child born after William Penn landed with the rest of our brethren; and in compliment to the city he intended to build, she was called after the name he intended to give it; and so there is always one of the daughters of her family known by the name of Philadelphia. She soon came, and after a most friendly altercation, I gave up the point; breakfasted, departed, and in four days reached the city.
Contrary to what I expected, I found I had to go to Philadelphia to pay for the purchase and to have the deeds properly recorded. I didn't think much about the journey, even though it was more than two hundred miles, because I knew many friends where I planned to stay. On the third night after leaving the woods, I stayed at Mr.——'s house, one of the best citizens I know; he had stayed at my place when you were there. He kindly asked about your well-being and wanted me to send his regards to you. The cleanliness of these good people is no surprise, yet I think this wonderful family surpasses everyone I know. As soon as I lay down to rest, I felt like I was in a fragrant garden, so sweet and pleasant were the sheets. The next morning, I found my host in the orchard getting rid of caterpillars. I said, "Friend B., I think you're greatly straying from the good rules of the society; you seem to have left behind that happy simplicity for which it has always been known." "Your criticism is quite a burden, friend James; what reason do you have to accuse us like this?" I replied, "Your kind wife made a mistake last night; she put me on a bed of roses instead of a regular one; I'm not used to such luxuries." "And is that all you have to blame us for, friend James? You won’t call it luxury, I hope? You know it comes from our garden; friend Pope says, 'to enjoy is to obey.'" "That’s a fairly clever excuse, friend B., and it should be valued because it’s based on truth. James, my wife hasn’t done anything to your bed that is not done all year round to all the beds in the family; she sprinkles her linens with rose water before she puts them away; it’s her preference, and I have nothing to say about it. But you won't get away with this so easily, I will definitely call for her; you two must sort it out while I get back to what I was doing before the sun gets too high." "Tom, you go and call your mistress Philadelphia." "What," I said, "is your wife called by that name? I didn't know that before." "I'll tell you, James, how that happened: her grandmother was the first girl born after William Penn arrived with the rest of our friends; to honor the city he was planning to build, she was named after the name he intended for it; and so a daughter of her family has always been known by the name Philadelphia." She soon came, and after a friendly discussion, I gave in; we had breakfast, then I left, and in four days reached the city.
A week after news came that a vessel was arrived with Scotch emigrants. Mr. C. and I went to the dock to see them disembark. It was a scene which inspired me with a variety of thoughts; here are, said I to my friend, a number of people, driven by poverty, and other adverse causes, to a foreign land, in which they know nobody. The name of a stranger, instead of implying relief, assistance, and kindness, on the contrary, conveys very different ideas. They are now distressed; their minds are racked by a variety of apprehensions, fears, and hopes. It was this last powerful sentiment which has brought them here. If they are good people, I pray that heaven may realise them. Whoever were to see them thus gathered again in five or six years, would behold a more pleasing sight, to which this would serve as a very powerful contrast. By their honesty, the vigour of their arms, and the benignity of government, their condition will be greatly improved; they will be well clad, fat, possessed of that manly confidence which property confers; they will become useful citizens. Some of the posterity may act conspicuous parts in our future American transactions. Most of them appeared pale and emaciated, from the length of the passage, and the indifferent provision on which they had lived. The number of children seemed as great as that of the people; they had all paid for being conveyed here. The captain told us they were a quiet, peaceable, and harmless people, who had never dwelt in cities. This was a valuable cargo; they seemed, a few excepted, to be in the full vigour of their lives. Several citizens, impelled either by spontaneous attachments, or motives of humanity, took many of them to their houses; the city, agreeable to its usual wisdom and humanity, ordered them all to be lodged in the barracks, and plenty of provisions to be given them. My friend pitched upon one also and led him to his house, with his wife, and a son about fourteen years of age. The majority of them had contracted for land the year before, by means of an agent; the rest depended entirely upon chance; and the one who followed us was of this last class. Poor man, he smiled on receiving the invitation, and gladly accepted it, bidding his wife and son do the same, in a language which I did not understand. He gazed with uninterrupted attention on everything he saw; the houses, the inhabitants, the negroes, and carriages: everything appeared equally new to him; and we went slow, in order to give him time to feed on this pleasing variety. Good God! said he, is this Philadelphia, that blessed city of bread and provisions, of which we have heard so much? I am told it was founded the same year in which my father was born; why, it is finer than Greenock and Glasgow, which are ten times as old. It is so, said my friend to him, and when thee hast been here a month, thee will soon see that it is the capital of a fine province, of which thee art going to be a citizen: Greenock enjoys neither such a climate nor such a soil. Thus we slowly proceeded along, when we met several large Lancaster six-horse waggons, just arrived from the country. At this stupendous sight he stopped short, and with great diffidence asked us what was the use of these great moving houses, and where those big horses came from? Have you none such at home, I asked him? Oh, no; these huge animals would eat all the grass of our island! We at last reached my friend's house, who in the glow of well-meant hospitality, made them all three sit down to a good dinner, and gave them as much cider as they could drink. God bless this country, and the good people it contains, said he; this is the best meal's victuals I have made a long time.—I thank you kindly.
A week after we heard that a ship had arrived with Scottish immigrants, Mr. C. and I went to the dock to watch them disembark. It was a scene that filled me with a mix of thoughts; here are, I said to my friend, a group of people pushed by poverty and other hardships to a foreign land where they know no one. The name of a stranger, instead of suggesting relief, support, and kindness, conveys the opposite. They are now in distress; their minds are troubled by various worries, fears, and hopes. It’s this last strong feeling that brought them here. If they are good people, I hope heaven rewards them. Whoever sees them gathered again in five or six years will witness a much more uplifting sight, which this moment would strongly contrast with. Thanks to their honesty, their hard work, and a benevolent government, their situation will greatly improve; they will be well-dressed, healthy, and possess that confidence that comes with having property; they will become valuable citizens. Some of their descendants may play prominent roles in our future American affairs. Most of them looked pale and thin from the long journey and the poor food they had to eat. The number of children seemed equal to the number of adults; they all paid to be brought here. The captain informed us they were quiet, peaceful, and harmless people who had never lived in cities. This was a valuable group; except for a few, they seemed to be in the prime of their lives. Several locals, driven by goodwill or compassion, took many of them into their homes; the city, true to its tradition of wisdom and kindness, arranged for all of them to be housed in the barracks and provided with plenty of food. My friend chose one as well and took him to his house, along with his wife and his son, who was about fourteen. Most of them had made land agreements the year before through an agent; the others were completely relying on luck, and the one who followed us fell into this latter group. The poor man smiled when he received the invitation and readily accepted it, urging his wife and son to do the same in a language I didn’t understand. He looked around in awe at everything he saw—the houses, the people, the Black residents, and the carriages: everything seemed brand new to him; we walked slowly to give him time to take it all in. “Good God!” he exclaimed, “is this Philadelphia, that blessed city of food and provisions, that we’ve heard so much about? I’ve been told it was founded the same year my father was born; it’s nicer than Greenock and Glasgow, which are ten times older.” “Yes, it is,” my friend replied, “and when you’ve been here a month, you’ll soon see that it’s the capital of a great province, where you are going to be a citizen: Greenock doesn’t have this climate or soil.” We continued to walk slowly when we encountered several large Lancaster six-horse wagons just arriving from the countryside. At this impressive sight, he stopped abruptly and, with great hesitation, asked us what these big moving houses were for and where those large horses came from. “Don’t you have any like this at home?” I asked him. “Oh, no; these huge animals would eat all the grass on our island!” Finally, we reached my friend’s house, who, in the spirit of generous hospitality, invited all three of them to sit down for a good meal and served them as much cider as they could drink. “God bless this country and the good people in it,” he said; “this is the best meal I’ve had in a long time.” “Thank you kindly,” the man replied.
What part of Scotland dost thee come from, friend Andrew, said Mr. C.? Some of us come from the main, some from the island of Barra, he answered—I myself am a Barra man. I looked on the map, and by its latitude, easily guessed that it must be an inhospitable climate. What sort of land have you got there, I asked him? Bad enough, said he; we have no such trees as I see here, no wheat, no kine, no apples. Then, I observed, that it must be hard for the poor to live. We have no poor, he answered, we are all alike, except our laird; but he cannot help everybody. Pray what is the name of your laird? Mr. Neiel, said Andrew; the like of him is not to be found in any of the isles; his forefathers have lived there thirty generations ago, as we are told. Now, gentlemen, you may judge what an ancient family estate it must be. But it is cold, the land is thin, and there were too many of us, which are the reasons that some are come to seek their fortunes here. Well, Andrew, what step do you intend to take in order to become rich? I do not know, Sir; I am but an ignorant man, a stranger besides—I must rely on the advice of good Christians, they would not deceive me, I am sure. I have brought with me a character from our Barra minister, can it do me any good here? Oh, yes; but your future success will depend entirely on your own conduct; if you are a sober man, as the certificate says, laborious, and honest, there is no fear but that you will do well. Have you brought any money with you, Andrew? Yes, Sir, eleven guineas and an half. Upon my word it is a considerable sum for a Barra man; how came you by so much money? Why seven years ago I received a legacy of thirty-seven pounds from an uncle, who loved me much; my wife brought me two guineas, when the laird gave her to me for a wife, which I have saved ever since. I have sold all I had; I worked in Glasgow for some time. I am glad to hear you are so saving and prudent; be so still; you must go and hire yourself with some good people; what can you do? I can thresh a little, and handle the spade. Can you plough? Yes, Sir, with the little breast plough I have brought with me. These won't do here, Andrew; you are an able man; if you are willing you will soon learn. I'll tell you what I intend to do; I'll send you to my house, where you shall stay two or three weeks, there you must exercise yourself with the axe, that is the principal tool the Americans want, and particularly the back- settlers. Can your wife spin? Yes, she can. Well then as soon as you are able to handle the axe, you shall go and live with Mr. P. R., a particular friend of mine, who will give you four dollars per month, for the first six, and the usual price of five as long as you remain with him. I shall place your wife in another house, where she shall receive half a dollar a week for spinning; and your son a dollar a month to drive the team. You shall have besides good victuals to eat, and good beds to lie on; will all this satisfy you, Andrew? He hardly understood what I said; the honest tears of gratitude fell from his eyes as he looked at me, and its expressions seemed to quiver on his lips.—Though silent, this was saying a great deal; there was besides something extremely moving to see a man six feet high thus shed tears; and they did not lessen the good opinion I had entertained of him. At last he told me, that my offers were more than he deserved, and that he would first begin to work for his victuals. No, no, said I, if you are careful and sober, and do what you can, you shall receive what I told you, after you have served a short apprenticeship at my house. May God repay you for all your kindnesses, said Andrew; as long as I live I shall thank you, and do what I can for you. A few days after I sent them all three to——, by the return of some waggons, that he might have an opportunity of viewing, and convincing himself of the utility of those machines which he had at first so much admired.
"What part of Scotland do you come from, friend Andrew?" said Mr. C. "Some of us come from the mainland, some from the island of Barra," he answered. "I myself am from Barra." I looked at the map and, based on its latitude, easily guessed that it must have a harsh climate. "What kind of land do you have there?" I asked him. "It's pretty rough," he said. "We have no trees like I see here, no wheat, no cattle, no apples." "Then it must be tough for the poor to get by," I observed. "We have no poor," he replied. "We’re all the same except for our laird, but he can’t help everyone." "What is your laird's name?" I asked. "Mr. Neiel," said Andrew. "You won’t find anyone like him in any of the isles; his family has been here for thirty generations, or so we’re told. Now, gentlemen, you can imagine what an ancient family estate it must be. But it’s cold, the land is poor, and there are too many of us, which is why some have come here to seek their fortunes." "Well, Andrew, what are you planning to do to get rich?" "I don’t know, Sir; I’m just an ignorant man, a stranger as well—I have to rely on the advice of good people; they wouldn’t deceive me." "I brought a reference from our minister in Barra; can it help me here?" "Oh, yes; but your future success will depend entirely on your own actions. If you’re as responsible as the reference says, hardworking, and honest, there’s no doubt you’ll do well. Do you have any money with you, Andrew?" "Yes, Sir, eleven and a half guineas." "That’s quite a bit of money for a Barra man; how did you get so much?" "Seven years ago, I inherited thirty-seven pounds from an uncle who cared for me; my wife brought me two guineas when the laird gave her to me, which I’ve saved ever since. I’ve sold everything I had and worked in Glasgow for a while." "I’m glad to hear you’re so frugal and sensible; keep it up. You need to go find work with some good people; what can you do?" "I can thresh a bit and handle a spade." "Can you plow?" "Yes, Sir, with the small plow I brought with me." "That won’t work here, Andrew; you’re capable, and if you’re willing, you’ll learn quickly. Here’s what I plan to do: I’ll send you to my house where you can stay for two or three weeks; you need to practice with the axe, that’s the main tool Americans need, especially the backwoods settlers. Can your wife spin?" "Yes, she can." "Okay, as soon as you can handle the axe, you’ll go work with Mr. P. R., a good friend of mine, who will pay you four dollars a month for the first six months, and the standard five after that for as long as you’re with him. I’ll have your wife in another house where she’ll earn half a dollar a week for spinning, and your son will get a dollar a month to help with the team. You’ll also get good food and a comfy place to sleep. Does that sound good to you, Andrew?" He barely understood what I said; honest tears of gratitude filled his eyes as he looked at me, and his lips seemed to tremble. Though he was silent, he said a lot; it was incredibly moving to see a man so tall shedding tears, and it didn’t lessen the high opinion I had of him. Finally, he told me that my offers were more than he deserved, and that he would start out just working for his food. "No, no," I said, "if you’re careful and responsible, and do what you can, you’ll get the support I mentioned after a short time working at my house." "May God repay you for all your kindness," said Andrew. "As long as I live, I’ll thank you and do what I can for you." A few days later, I sent all three of them to——, with some wagons that were returning, so he could see for himself the usefulness of the machines he had admired at first.
The further descriptions he gave us of the Hebrides in general, and of his native island in particular; of the customs and modes of living of the inhabitants; greatly entertained me. Pray is the sterility of the soil the cause that there are no trees, or is it because there are none planted? What are the modern families of all the kings of the earth, compared to the date of that of Mr. Neiel? Admitting that each generation should last but forty years, this makes a period of 1200; an extraordinary duration for the uninterrupted descent of any family! Agreeably to the description he gave us of those countries, they seem to live according to the rules of nature, which gives them but bare subsistence; their constitutions are uncontaminated by any excess or effeminacy, which their soil refuses. If their allowance of food is not too scanty, they must all be healthy by perpetual temperance and exercise; if so, they are amply rewarded for their poverty. Could they have obtained but necessary food, they would not have left it; for it was not in consequence of oppression, either from their patriarch or the government, that they had emigrated. I wish we had a colony of these honest people settled in some parts of this province; their morals, their religion, seem to be as simple as their manners. This society would present an interesting spectacle could they be transported on a richer soil. But perhaps that soil would soon alter everything; for our opinions, vices, and virtues, are altogether local: we are machines fashioned by every circumstance around us.
The more he described the Hebrides in general and his home island in particular, along with the customs and lifestyles of the locals, the more I was entertained. Is the lack of trees due to the poor soil, or is it because no one has planted any? How do the modern families of all the kings around the world compare to the lineage of Mr. Neiel? If we assume each generation lasts only forty years, that adds up to a period of 1200 years; an incredible span for any family to remain uninterrupted! According to his description of these lands, it seems they live in accordance with nature, which only provides them with basic sustenance; their bodies remain free from excess or weakness, which their environment does not support. If their food supply isn't too limited, they must be healthy due to their constant moderation and physical activity; if so, they are well rewarded for their modest means. If they could have secured just enough food, they wouldn’t have left, as it wasn’t due to oppression from their patriarch or the government that they migrated. I wish we had a colony of these decent folks settled in some part of this province; their morals and their religion appear as simple as their way of life. This community would create an interesting scene if they could be placed in richer soil. But maybe that soil would soon change everything; our views, vices, and virtues are all shaped by the circumstances surrounding us.
Andrew arrived at my house a week before I did, and I found my wife, agreeable to my instructions, had placed the axe in his hands, as his first task. For some time he was very awkward, but he was so docile, so willing, and grateful, as well as his wife, that I foresaw he would succeed. Agreeably to my promise, I put them all with different families, where they were well liked, and all parties were pleased. Andrew worked hard, lived well, grew fat, and every Sunday came to pay me a visit on a good horse, which Mr. P. R. lent him. Poor man, it took him a long time ere he could sit on the saddle and hold the bridle properly. I believe he had never before mounted such a beast, though I did not choose to ask him that question, for fear it might suggest some mortifying ideas. After having been twelve months at Mr. P. R.'s, and having received his own and his family's wages, which amounted to eighty-four dollars; he came to see me on a week-day, and told me, that he was a man of middle age, and would willingly have land of his own, in order to procure him a home, as a shelter against old age: that whenever this period should come, his son, to whom he would give his land, would then maintain him, and thus live altogether; he therefore required my advice and assistance. I thought his desire very natural and praiseworthy, and told him that I should think of it, but that he must remain one month longer with Mr. P. R., who had 3000 rails to split. He immediately consented. The spring was not far advanced enough yet for Andrew to begin clearing any land even supposing that he had made a purchase; as it is always necessary that the leaves should be out, in order that this additional combustible may serve to burn the heaps of brush more readily.
Andrew arrived at my house a week before I did, and I found my wife, following my instructions, had given him an axe as his first task. At first, he was quite awkward, but he was so eager, willing, and grateful, along with his wife, that I could see he would do well. True to my promise, I placed them with different families where they were appreciated, and everyone was happy. Andrew worked hard, lived well, gained weight, and every Sunday, he came to visit me on a nice horse that Mr. P. R. lent him. Poor guy, it took him a while to figure out how to sit in the saddle and hold the reins properly. I don't think he had ever ridden such a horse before, but I didn’t want to ask him that question, as it might bring up some uncomfortable thoughts. After being with Mr. P. R. for a year and earning his and his family's wages, which totaled eighty-four dollars, he came to see me on a weekday. He told me he was middle-aged and would really like to have land of his own to secure a home for himself as a safety net for old age. He said that when that time came, he would pass the land to his son, who would then take care of him, allowing them to live together. He asked for my advice and help. I thought his wish was completely natural and commendable, so I told him I would think about it, but he needed to stay one more month with Mr. P. R., who had 3,000 rails to split. He agreed right away. Spring hadn’t progressed enough for Andrew to start clearing any land, even if he had bought some, since the leaves needed to be out to help burn the brush piles more easily.
A few days after, it happened that the whole family of Mr. P. R. went to meeting, and left Andrew to take care of the house. While he was at the door, attentively reading the Bible, nine Indians just come from the mountains, suddenly made their appearance, and unloaded their packs of furs on the floor of the piazza. Conceive, if you can, what was Andrew's consternation at this extraordinary sight! From the singular appearance of these people, the honest Hebridean took them for a lawless band come to rob his master's house. He therefore, like a faithful guardian, precipitately withdrew and shut the doors, but as most of our houses are without locks, he was reduced to the necessity of fixing his knife over the latch, and then flew upstairs in quest of a broadsword he had brought from Scotland. The Indians, who were Mr. P. R.'s particular friends, guessed at his suspicions and fears; they forcibly lifted the door, and suddenly took possession of the house, got all the bread and meat they wanted, and sat themselves down by the fire. At this instant Andrew, with his broadsword in his hand, entered the room; the Indians earnestly looking at him, and attentively watching his motions. After a very few reflections, Andrew found that his weapon was useless, when opposed to nine tomahawks; but this did not diminish his anger, on the contrary; it grew greater on observing the calm impudence with which they were devouring the family provisions. Unable to resist, he called them names in broad Scotch, and ordered them to desist and be gone; to which the Indians (as they told me afterwards) replied in their equally broad idiom. It must have been a most unintelligible altercation between this honest Barra man, and nine Indians who did not much care for anything he could say. At last he ventured to lay his hands on one of them, in order to turn him out of the house. Here Andrew's fidelity got the better of his prudence; for the Indian, by his motions, threatened to scalp him, while the rest gave the war hoop. This horrid noise so effectually frightened poor Andrew, that, unmindful of his courage, of his broadsword, and his intentions, he rushed out, left them masters of the house, and disappeared. I have heard one of the Indians say since, that he never laughed so heartily in his life. Andrew at a distance, soon recovered from the fears which had been inspired by this infernal yell, and thought of no other remedy than to go to the meeting-house, which was about two miles distant. In the eagerness of his honest intentions, with looks of affright still marked on his countenance, he called Mr. P. R. out, and told him with great vehemence of style, that nine monsters were come to his house—some blue, some red, and some black; that they had little axes in their hands out of which they smoked; and that like highlanders, they had no breeches; that they were devouring all his victuals, and that God only knew what they would do more. Pacify yourself, said Mr. P. R., my house is as safe with these people, as if I was there myself; as for the victuals, they are heartily welcome, honest Andrew; they are not people of much ceremony; they help themselves thus whenever they are among their friends; I do so too in their wigwams, whenever I go to their village: you had better therefore step in and hear the remainder of the sermon, and when the meeting is over we will all go back in the waggon together.
A few days later, Mr. P. R.'s entire family went to a meeting, leaving Andrew in charge of the house. While he was at the door, deeply engrossed in reading the Bible, nine Indians who had just come down from the mountains suddenly showed up and unloaded their packs of furs on the piazza floor. Imagine Andrew's shock at this unusual sight! Because of the strange appearance of these people, the honest Hebridean thought they were a rowdy gang come to rob his master's house. So, like a loyal guardian, he quickly retreated and shut the doors, but since most of our houses don’t have locks, he had to use his knife to secure the latch before dashing upstairs to find a broadsword he had brought from Scotland. The Indians, who were good friends of Mr. P. R., sensed his fear and suspicion; they forcefully lifted the door and took over the house, helped themselves to all the bread and meat they wanted, and sat down by the fire. At that moment, Andrew came into the room brandishing his broadsword, with the Indians watching him intently. After a brief moment of reflection, Andrew realized his weapon was useless against nine tomahawks. However, that realization didn’t lessen his anger; in fact, it grew as he watched them calmly devour the family food. Unable to hold back, he yelled at them in strong Scots, demanding they leave. The Indians later told me they responded in their equally strong dialect. It must have been a completely confusing argument between the honest man from Barra and nine Indians who didn’t care about a word he said. Finally, he dared to grab one of them to try to kick him out of the house. Here, Andrew's loyalty got the better of his judgment; the Indian threatened to scalp him with his movements while the others cheered with war cries. This terrifying noise scared poor Andrew so much that he forgot his courage, his broadsword, and his intentions, bolted out, leaving them in control of the house, and disappeared. I heard one of the Indians say later that he had never laughed so hard in his life. Once he was a safe distance away, Andrew soon calmed down from the fears sparked by that terrifying shout and thought the only solution was to head to the meeting house, which was about two miles away. Eager to share his concerns, with fear still evident on his face, he called Mr. P. R. out and urgently told him that nine monsters had come to his house—some blue, some red, and some black; that they had little axes in their hands that smoked; and that like Highlanders, they weren’t wearing any pants; that they were eating all his food, and only God knew what else they would do. “Calm down,” Mr. P. R. said, “my house is as safe with these people as it is when I’m there myself; as for the food, they’re welcome to it, honest Andrew. They aren't very formal; they help themselves whenever they’re among friends. I do the same in their wigwams whenever I visit their village. You should really go back inside and listen to the rest of the sermon, and when the meeting is over, we’ll all head back together in the wagon.”
At their return, Mr. P. R., who speaks the Indian language very well, explained the whole matter; the Indians renewed their laugh, and shook hands with honest Andrew, whom they made to smoke out of their pipes; and thus peace was made, and ratified according to the Indian custom, by the calumet.
At their return, Mr. P. R., who speaks the Indian language fluently, explained everything; the Indians laughed again and shook hands with honest Andrew, who they made smoke from their pipes. This way, peace was established and confirmed according to Indian custom, by the calumet.
Soon after this adventure, the time approached when I had promised Andrew my best assistance to settle him; for that purpose I went to Mr. A. V. in the county of——, who, I was informed, had purchased a tract of land, contiguous to——settlement. I gave him a faithful detail of the progress Andrew had made in the rural arts; of his honesty, sobriety, and gratitude, and pressed him to sell him an hundred acres. This I cannot comply with, said Mr. A. V., but at the same time I will do better; I love to encourage honest Europeans as much as you do, and to see them prosper: you tell me he has but one son; I will lease them an hundred acres for any term of years you please, and make it more valuable to your Scotchman than if he was possessed of the fee simple. By that means he may, with what little money he has, buy a plough, a team, and some stock; he will not be incumbered with debts and mortgages; what he raises will be his own; had he two or three sons as able as himself, then I should think it more eligible for him to purchase the fee simple. I join with you in opinion, and will bring Andrew along with me in a few days.
Soon after this adventure, the time came when I promised Andrew I would help him get settled. For that purpose, I went to Mr. A. V. in the county of——, who I was told had bought a piece of land next to—— settlement. I shared with him all the progress Andrew had made in farming, highlighting his honesty, sobriety, and gratitude, and urged him to sell him a hundred acres. "I can't do that," said Mr. A. V., "but I can do something better. I love supporting hardworking Europeans just as much as you do, and I want to see them succeed. You mentioned he has only one son; I will lease him a hundred acres for whatever number of years you think is best, and make it worth more to your Scot than if he owned the land outright. This way, with the little money he has, he can buy a plow, a team, and some livestock; he won’t have to worry about debts and mortgages, and everything he grows will be his. If he had two or three sons as capable as he is, then I would think it would be better for him to buy the land. I agree with you and will bring Andrew with me in a few days."
Well, honest Andrew, said Mr. A. V., in consideration of your good name, I will let you have an hundred acres of good arable land, that shall be laid out along a new road; there is a bridge already erected on the creek that passes through the land, and a fine swamp of about twenty acres. These are my terms, I cannot sell, but I will lease you the quantity that Mr. James, your friend, has asked; the first seven years you shall pay no rent, whatever you sow and reap, and plant and gather, shall be entirely your own; neither the king, government, nor church, will have any claim on your future property: the remaining part of the time you must give me twelve dollars and an half a year; and that is all you will have to pay me. Within the three first years you must plant fifty apple trees, and clear seven acres of swamp within the first part of the lease; it will be your own advantage: whatever you do more within that time, I will pay you for it, at the common rate of the country. The term of the lease shall be thirty years; how do you like it, Andrew? Oh, Sir, it is very good, but I am afraid, that the king or his ministers, or the governor, or some of our great men, will come and take the land from me; your son may say to me, by and by, this is my father's land, Andrew, you must quit it. No, no, said Mr. A. V., there is no such danger; the king and his ministers are too just to take the labour of a poor settler; here we have no great men, but what are subordinate to our laws; but to calm all your fears, I will give you a lease, so that none can make you afraid. If ever you are dissatisfied with the land, a jury of your own neighbourhood shall value all your improvements, and you shall be paid agreeably to their verdict. You may sell the lease, or if you die, you may previously dispose of it, as if the land was your own. Expressive, yet inarticulate joy, was mixed in his countenance, which seemed impressed with astonishment and confusion. Do you understand me well, said Mr. A. V.? No, Sir, replied Andrew, I know nothing of what you mean about lease, improvement, will, jury, etc. That is honest, we will explain these things to you by and by. It must be confessed that those were hard words, which he had never heard in his life; for by his own account, the ideas they convey would be totally useless in the island of Barra. No wonder, therefore, that he was embarrassed; for how could the man who had hardly a will of his own since he was born, imagine he could have one after his death? How could the person who never possessed anything, conceive that he could extend his new dominion over this land, even after he should be laid in his grave? For my part, I think Andrew's amazement did not imply any extraordinary degree of ignorance; he was an actor introduced upon a new scene, it required some time ere he could reconcile himself to the part he was to perform. However he was soon enlightened, and introduced into those mysteries with which we native Americans are but too well acquainted.
Well, honest Andrew, said Mr. A. V., considering your good name, I will let you have a hundred acres of good farmland that will be laid out along a new road; there’s already a bridge built over the creek that runs through the land, plus a nice swamp of about twenty acres. These are my terms: I can’t sell, but I will lease you the amount that Mr. James, your friend, requested; for the first seven years, you won’t have to pay any rent. Everything you plant, grow, and harvest will be entirely yours; neither the king, the government, nor the church will have any claim on your future property. After that initial period, you’ll need to pay me twelve and a half dollars a year, and that’s all you’ll owe me. During the first three years, you must plant fifty apple trees and clear seven acres of swamp; it’s for your own benefit. Anything you do beyond that during that time, I’ll pay you for at the usual rate in the area. The lease will last thirty years; how does that sound, Andrew? Oh, Sir, it sounds great, but I’m worried that the king or his ministers, or the governor, or some of our important people, will come and take the land from me; your son might eventually say to me, “This is my father's land, Andrew, you must leave.” No, no, said Mr. A. V., there’s no such danger; the king and his ministers are too fair to take the work of a poor settler; around here, we have no important people who aren’t subordinate to our laws. To ease all your concerns, I’ll give you a lease that will protect you from any threats. If you ever feel unhappy with the land, a jury from your own neighborhood will assess all your improvements, and you’ll be compensated according to their decision. You can sell the lease, or if you pass away, you can transfer it, just like if the land was yours. His face showed a mix of clear yet confused happiness, amazed by the offer. Do you understand me well? asked Mr. A. V. No, Sir, replied Andrew, I don’t understand anything about leases, improvements, wills, juries, etc. That’s honest; we’ll explain these things to you later. It must be admitted that those were tough terms he had never heard in his life; by his own account, the ideas they conveyed would be completely useless on the island of Barra. It’s no surprise he was confused; how could someone who has hardly had a say in his life since birth imagine he could have control after his death? How could someone who never owned anything think he could extend his new authority over this land even after he was laid to rest? I believe Andrew’s astonishment doesn’t indicate an unusual level of ignorance; he was an actor stepping onto a completely new stage, and it took a while for him to get comfortable with the role he was meant to play. However, he was soon enlightened and introduced to the complexities that we native Americans are all too familiar with.
Here then is honest Andrew, invested with every municipal advantage they confer; become a freeholder, possessed of a vote, of a place of residence, a citizen of the province of Pennsylvania. Andrew's original hopes and the distant prospects he had formed in the island of Barra, were at the eve of being realised; we therefore can easily forgive him a few spontaneous ejaculations, which would be useless to repeat. This short tale is easily told; few words are sufficient to describe this sudden change of situation; but in his mind it was gradual, and took him above a week before he could be sure, that without disturbing any money he could possess lands. Soon after he prepared himself; I lent him a barrel of pork, and 200 lb. weight of meal, and made him purchase what was necessary besides.
Here is honest Andrew, equipped with all the local benefits they offer; he became a property owner, had a vote, a place to live, and was a citizen of Pennsylvania. Andrew's initial hopes and the future he had envisioned back in Barra were on the brink of being realized; so we can easily forgive him a few spontaneous outbursts, which are unnecessary to repeat. This brief story is simple to tell; only a few words are needed to describe this sudden change in circumstances; but in his mind, it was gradual, and it took him over a week to be sure that he could own land without touching any money. Soon after, he got ready; I lent him a barrel of pork and 200 pounds of meal, and he bought what else he needed.
He set out, and hired a room in the house of a settler who lived the most contiguous to his own land. His first work was to clear some acres of swamp, that he might have a supply of hay the following year for his two horses and cows. From the first day he began to work, he was indefatigable; his honesty procured him friends, and his industry the esteem of his new neighbours. One of them offered him two acres of cleared land, whereon he might plant corn, pumpkins, squashes, and a few potatoes, that very season. It is astonishing how quick men will learn when they work for themselves. I saw with pleasure two months after, Andrew holding a two-horse plough and tracing his furrows quite straight; thus the spade man of the island of Barra was become the tiller of American soil. Well done, said I, Andrew, well done; I see that God speeds and directs your works; I see prosperity delineated in all your furrows and head lands. Raise this crop of corn with attention and care, and then you will be master of the art.
He set out and rented a room from a settler who lived closest to his land. His first task was to clear some acres of swamp so he could have hay for his two horses and cows the following year. From the first day he started working, he was tireless; his honesty earned him friends, and his hard work won the respect of his new neighbors. One of them offered him two acres of cleared land where he could plant corn, pumpkins, squash, and a few potatoes that very season. It’s amazing how quickly people learn when they’re working for themselves. I was pleased to see two months later, Andrew using a two-horse plow and making perfectly straight furrows; the man from the island of Barra had become a farmer in America. Well done, I said, Andrew, well done; I see that God is guiding your efforts; I see success reflected in all your furrows and borders. Focus on this corn crop with care, and then you'll master the art.
As he had neither mowing nor reaping to do that year, I told him that the time was come to build his house; and that for the purpose I would myself invite the neighbourhood to a frolic; that thus he would have a large dwelling erected, and some upland cleared in one day. Mr. P. R., his old friend, came at the time appointed, with all his hands, and brought victuals in plenty: I did the same. About forty people repaired to the spot; the songs, and merry stories, went round the woods from cluster to cluster, as the people had gathered to their different works; trees fell on all sides, bushes were cut up and heaped; and while many were thus employed, others with their teams hauled the big logs to the spot which Andrew had pitched upon for the erection of his new dwelling. We all dined in the woods; in the afternoon the logs were placed with skids, and the usual contrivances: thus the rude house was raised, and above two acres of land cut up, cleared, and heaped.
Since he had no mowing or harvesting to do that year, I told him it was time to build his house. I offered to invite the neighbors for a celebration, so he could have a large home built and some land cleared in just one day. Mr. P. R., his old friend, showed up at the designated time with his crew and plenty of food; I did the same. About forty people gathered at the site; songs and cheerful stories echoed through the woods as everyone split into groups to tackle different tasks. Trees fell all around, bushes were cut down and piled up, and while many worked, others used their teams to haul the large logs to the spot Andrew had chosen for his new home. We all had lunch in the woods; in the afternoon, the logs were set up with skids and the usual tools. That's how the basic house was built, and over two acres of land were cleared and piled up.
Whilst all these different operations were performing, Andrew was absolutely incapable of working; it was to him the most solemn holiday he had ever seen; it would have been sacrilegious in him to have denied it with menial labour. Poor man, he sanctified it with joy and thanksgiving, and honest libations—he went from one to the other with the bottle in his hand, pressing everybody to drink, and drinking himself to show the example. He spent the whole day in smiling, laughing, and uttering monosyllables: his wife and son were there also, but as they could not understand the language, their pleasure must have been altogether that of the imagination. The powerful lord, the wealthy merchant, on seeing the superb mansion finished, never can feel half the joy and real happiness which was felt and enjoyed on that day by this honest Hebridean: though this new dwelling, erected in the midst of the woods, was nothing more than a square inclosure, composed of twenty-four large clumsy logs, let in at the ends. When the work was finished, the company made the woods resound with the noise of their three cheers, and the honest wishes they formed for Andrew's prosperity. He could say nothing, but with thankful tears he shook hands with them all. Thus from the first day he had landed, Andrew marched towards this important event: this memorable day made the sun shine on that land on which he was to sow wheat and other grain. What swamp he had cleared lay before his door; the essence of future bread, milk, and meat, were scattered all round him. Soon after he hired a carpenter, who put on a roof and laid the floors; in a week more the house was properly plastered, and the chimney finished. He moved into it, and purchased two cows, which found plenty of food in the woods—his hogs had the same advantage. That very year, he and his son sowed three bushels of wheat, from which he reaped ninety-one and a half; for I had ordered him to keep an exact account of all he should raise. His first crop of other corn would have been as good, had it not been for the squirrels, which were enemies not to be dispersed by the broadsword. The fourth year I took an inventory of the wheat this man possessed, which I send you. Soon after, further settlements were made on that road, and Andrew, instead of being the last man towards the wilderness, found himself in a few years in the middle of a numerous society. He helped others as generously as others had helped him; and I have dined many times at his table with several of his neighbours. The second year he was made overseer of the road, and served on two petty juries, performing as a citizen all the duties required of him. The historiographer of some great prince or general, does not bring his hero victorious to the end of a successful campaign, with one half of the heart-felt pleasure with which I have conducted Andrew to the situation he now enjoys: he is independent and easy. Triumph and military honours do not always imply those two blessings. He is unencumbered with debts, services, rents, or any other dues; the successes of a campaign, the laurels of war, must be purchased at the dearest rate, which makes every cool reflecting citizen to tremble and shudder. By the literal account hereunto annexed, you will easily be made acquainted with the happy effects which constantly flow, in this country, from sobriety and industry, when united with good land and freedom.
While all these different tasks were happening, Andrew was completely unable to work; it felt like the most solemn holiday he had ever experienced. It would have felt wrong to him to deny it with menial labor. Poor man, he celebrated it with joy and gratitude and shared drinks—he went from person to person with a bottle in hand, encouraging everyone to drink and drinking himself to set an example. He spent the entire day smiling, laughing, and speaking in short words: his wife and son were there too, but since they didn’t understand the language, their enjoyment must have been purely imaginary. The powerful lord or wealthy merchant, seeing the beautiful mansion completed, could never feel half the joy and happiness that this honest Hebridean felt on that day: although this new home, built in the woods, was just a square enclosure made of twenty-four large, clumsy logs fitted together. When the work was done, the group filled the woods with their loud cheers and the heartfelt wishes they made for Andrew's prosperity. He couldn't say much, but with grateful tears, he shook hands with all of them. From the first day he arrived, Andrew worked towards this milestone: this memorable day made the sun shine on the land where he would plant wheat and other grains. The swamp he had cleared lay in front of his door; the essentials for future bread, milk, and meat surrounded him. Soon after, he hired a carpenter, who added a roof and laid the floors; in another week, the house was properly plastered, and the chimney was finished. He moved in and bought two cows, which found plenty of forage in the woods—his pigs benefitted equally. That very year, he and his son planted three bushels of wheat, and they harvested ninety-one and a half; I had instructed him to keep an accurate record of everything he harvested. His first crop of other grains would have been just as successful, if not for the squirrels, which were foes that couldn’t be driven away with a sword. In the fourth year, I took an inventory of the wheat this man had, which I’m sending you. Soon after, more settlers came to that road, and instead of being the last man toward the wilderness, Andrew found himself in a few years right in the middle of a bustling community. He helped others as generously as he had been helped, and I’ve dined at his table many times with several of his neighbors. In his second year, he became the road overseer and served on two small juries, carrying out all the civic duties required of him. The chronicler of some great prince or general doesn’t bring his hero victoriously to the end of a successful campaign with even half the heartfelt pleasure I felt when I saw Andrew in his current situation: he is independent and at ease. Triumph and military honors don’t always come with those two blessings. He is free from debts, obligations, rents, or other dues; the victories of a campaign and the laurels of war come at a very high price, which makes every thoughtful and reflective citizen nervous. From the detailed account attached here, you can easily see the positive results that consistently arise in this country from sobriety and hard work, especially when combined with good land and freedom.
The account of the property he acquired with his own hands and those of his son, in four years, is under:
The details of the property he bought with his own hands and his son's over four years are as follows:
Dollars
Cash
The value of his improvements and lease 225
Six cows, at 13 dollars 78
Two breeding mares 50
The rest of the stock 100
Seventy-three bushels of wheat 66
Money due to him on notes 43
Pork and beef in his cellar 28
Wool and flax 19
Ploughs and other utensils of husbandry 31
—-
240 pounds Pennsylvania currency—dollars 640
The value of his improvements and lease 225
Six cows, at $13 78
Two breeding mares 50
The rest of the livestock 100
Seventy-three bushels of wheat 66
Money owed to him on notes 43
Pork and beef in his cellar 28
Wool and flax 19
Plows and other farming tools 31
—-
240 pounds Pennsylvania currency—dollars 640
LETTER IV
DESCRIPTION OF THE ISLAND OF NANTUCKET, WITH THE MANNERS, CUSTOMS, POLICY, AND TRADE OF THE INHABITANTS
The greatest compliment that can be paid to the best of kings, to the wisest ministers, or the most patriotic rulers, is to think, that the reformation of political abuses, and the happiness of their people are the primary objects of their attention. But alas! how disagreeable must the work of reformation be; how dreaded the operation; for we hear of no amendment: on the contrary, the great number of European emigrants, yearly coming over here, informs us, that the severity of taxes, the injustice of laws, the tyranny of the rich, and the oppressive avarice of the church; are as intolerable as ever. Will these calamities have no end? Are not the great rulers of the earth afraid of losing, by degrees, their most useful subjects? This country, providentially intended for the general asylum of the world, will flourish by the oppression of their people; they will every day become better acquainted with the happiness we enjoy, and seek for the means of transporting themselves here, in spite of all obstacles and laws. To what purpose then have so many useful books and divine maxims been transmitted to us from preceding ages?—Are they all vain, all useless? Must human nature ever be the sport of the few, and its many wounds remain unhealed? How happy are we here, in having fortunately escaped the miseries which attended our fathers; how thankful ought we to be, that they reared us in a land where sobriety and industry never fail to meet with the most ample rewards! You have, no doubt, read several histories of this continent, yet there are a thousand facts, a thousand explanations overlooked. Authors will certainly convey to you a geographical knowledge of this country; they will acquaint you with the eras of the several settlements, the foundations of our towns, the spirit of our different charters, etc., yet they do not sufficiently disclose the genius of the people, their various customs, their modes of agriculture, the innumerable resources which the industrious have of raising themselves to a comfortable and easy situation. Few of these writers have resided here, and those who have, had not pervaded every part of the country, nor carefully examined the nature and principles of our association. It would be a task worthy a speculative genius, to enter intimately into the situation and characters of the people, from Nova Scotia to West Florida; and surely history cannot possibly present any subject more pleasing to behold. Sensible how unable I am to lead you through so vast a maze, let us look attentively for some small unnoticed corner; but where shall we go in quest of such a one? Numberless settlements, each distinguished by some peculiarities, present themselves on every side; all seem to realise the most sanguine wishes that a good man could form for the happiness of his race. Here they live by fishing on the most plentiful coasts in the world; there they fell trees, by the sides of large rivers, for masts and lumber; here others convert innumerable logs into the best boards; there again others cultivate the land, rear cattle, and clear large fields. Yet I have a spot in my view, where none of these occupations are performed, which will, I hope, reward us for the trouble of inspection; but though it is barren in its soil, insignificant in its extent, inconvenient in its situation, deprived of materials for building; it seems to have been inhabited merely to prove what mankind can do when happily governed! Here I can point out to you exertions of the most successful industry; instances of native sagacity unassisted by science; the happy fruits of a well directed perseverance. It is always a refreshing spectacle to me, when in my review of the various component parts of this immense whole, I observe the labours of its inhabitants singularly rewarded by nature; when I see them emerged out of their first difficulties, living with decency and ease, and conveying to their posterity that plentiful subsistence, which their fathers have so deservedly earned. But when their prosperity arises from the goodness of the climate, and fertility of the soil; I partake of their happiness, it is true; yet stay but a little while with them, as they exhibit nothing but what is natural and common. On the contrary, when I meet with barren spots fertilised, grass growing where none grew before; grain gathered from fields which had hitherto produced nothing better than brambles; dwellings raised where no building materials were to be found; wealth acquired by the most uncommon means: there I pause, to dwell on the favourite object of my speculative inquiries. Willingly do I leave the former to enjoy the odoriferous furrow, or their rich valleys, with anxiety repairing to the spot, where so many difficulties have been overcome; where extraordinary exertions have produced extraordinary effects, and where every natural obstacle has been removed by a vigorous industry.
The greatest compliment that can be given to the best kings, the wisest ministers, or the most patriotic leaders is to believe that addressing political abuses and ensuring the happiness of their people are their main focuses. But unfortunately, reformation must be a tough job; it’s dreaded because we hear of no improvements. On the contrary, the increasing number of Europeans immigrating here tells us that the harshness of taxes, the unfairness of laws, the tyranny of the rich, and the oppressive greed of the church are just as unbearable as ever. Will these troubles never end? Aren't the powerful leaders of the world worried about gradually losing their most valuable subjects? This country, meant to be a refuge for the world, will thrive on the oppression of its people; they will become more aware of the happiness we enjoy here and will look for ways to come over, despite all obstacles and laws. What purpose have so many valuable books and wise sayings from past ages served? — Are they all pointless, all useless? Must human nature always be subjected to the whims of the few, with its many wounds left unhealed? How lucky we are to have escaped the sufferings that affected our ancestors; how grateful we should be that they raised us in a place where hard work and dedication are always rewarded! You have likely read several histories of this continent, yet there are countless facts, countless explanations that have been overlooked. Authors will certainly provide you with geographical knowledge of this country; they will inform you about the dates of various settlements, the founding of our towns, the spirit of our different charters, etc. But they don’t adequately reveal the character of the people, their diverse customs, their farming methods, and the countless ways industrious individuals can elevate themselves to a comfortable and easy life. Few of these writers have lived here, and those who have didn’t explore every part of the country or thoroughly examine the nature and principles of our community. It would be an excellent undertaking for a thoughtful mind to delve into the situation and characteristics of the people, from Nova Scotia to West Florida; surely, history cannot present a more fascinating subject. Aware of my limitations to guide you through such a vast maze, let’s closely search for some small unnoticed corner; but where should we go to find one? Countless settlements, each marked by unique features, are evident in every direction; all seem to fulfill the most hopeful wishes a good person could have for the happiness of humanity. Here, they thrive by fishing along the most bountiful coasts in the world; there, they cut down trees along large rivers for masts and lumber; here, others transform countless logs into high-quality boards; and there, others farm the land, raise cattle, and clear extensive fields. Yet, I have a place in mind where none of these activities occur, which I hope will reward us for our exploration; even though it has poor soil, is small in size, inconveniently located, and lacks building materials, it appears to have been inhabited just to showcase what people can achieve when well governed! Here, I can point out remarkable industriousness; examples of natural cleverness without scientific aid; the rewarding outcomes of well-directed persistence. It’s always refreshing to me when, in my review of the various parts of this immense whole, I see the hard work of its inhabitants richly rewarded by nature; when I witness them emerging from initial struggles, living decently and comfortably, and passing on to their descendants the ample sustenance their ancestors rightfully earned. But when their prosperity stems from a favorable climate and fertile soil, I share in their happiness, it’s true; yet, I linger briefly with them, as they demonstrate nothing extraordinary. In contrast, when I come across barren lands that have been made fertile, grass growing where none existed before; grain harvested from fields that previously only yielded brambles; homes built where no construction materials were available; wealth gained through the most unusual means: there, I pause, drawn to the focus of my explorative inquiries. I gladly leave the former to enjoy their fragrant furrows or lush valleys, feeling concerned as I head to the place where so many challenges have been overcome; where extraordinary efforts have led to extraordinary results, and where every natural barrier has been removed through vigorous hard work.
I want not to record the annals of the island of Nantucket—its inhabitants have no annals, for they are not a race of warriors. My simple wish is to trace them throughout their progressive steps, from their arrival here to this present hour; to inquire by what means they have raised themselves from the most humble, the most insignificant beginnings, to the ease and the wealth they now possess; and to give you some idea of their customs, religion, manners, policy, and mode of living.
I don’t want to document the history of the island of Nantucket—its people don’t have a history because they aren’t a warrior race. My simple goal is to outline their journey from their arrival here to now; to explore how they have lifted themselves from the most humble and insignificant beginnings to the comfort and wealth they have today; and to give you a sense of their customs, religion, manners, politics, and way of life.
This happy settlement was not founded on intrusion, forcible entries, or blood, as so many others have been; it drew its origin from necessity on the one side, and from good will on the other; and ever since, all has been a scene of uninterrupted harmony.—Neither political, nor religious broils; neither disputes with the natives, nor any other contentions, have in the least agitated or disturbed its detached society. Yet the first founders knew nothing either of Lycurgus or Solon; for this settlement has not been the work of eminent men or powerful legislators, forcing nature by the accumulated labours of art. This singular establishment has been effected by means of that native industry and perseverance common to all men, when they are protected by a government which demands but little for its protection; when they are permitted to enjoy a system of rational laws founded on perfect freedom. The mildness and humanity of such a government necessarily implies that confidence which is the source of the most arduous undertakings and permanent success. Would you believe that a sandy spot, of about twenty-three thousand acres, affording neither stones nor timber, meadows nor arable, yet can boast of an handsome town, consisting of more than 500 houses, should possess above 200 sail of vessels, constantly employ upwards of 2000 seamen, feed more than 15,000 sheep, 500 cows, 200 horses; and has several citizens worth 20,000 pounds sterling! Yet all these facts are uncontroverted. Who would have imagined that any people should have abandoned a fruitful and extensive continent, filled with the riches which the most ample vegetation affords; replete with good soil, enamelled meadows, rich pastures, every kind of timber, and with all other materials necessary to render life happy and comfortable: to come and inhabit a little sandbank, to which nature had refused those advantages; to dwell on a spot where there scarcely grew a shrub to announce, by the budding of its leaves, the arrival of the spring, and to warn by their fall the proximity of winter. Had this island been contiguous to the shores of some ancient monarchy, it would only have been occupied by a few wretched fishermen, who, oppressed by poverty, would hardly have been able to purchase or build little fishing barks; always dreading the weight of taxes, or the servitude of men- of-war. Instead of that boldness of speculation for which the inhabitants of this island are so remarkable, they would fearfully have confined themselves, within the narrow limits of the most trifling attempts; timid in their excursions, they never could have extricated themselves from their first difficulties. This island, on the contrary, contains 5000 hardy people, who boldly derive their riches from the element that surrounds them, and have been compelled by the sterility of the soil to seek abroad for the means of subsistence. You must not imagine, from the recital of these facts, that they enjoyed any exclusive privileges or royal charters, or that they were nursed by particular immunities in the infancy of their settlement. No, their freedom, their skill, their probity, and perseverance, have accomplished everything, and brought them by degrees to the rank they now hold.
This happy settlement wasn’t built on invasion, forceful takeovers, or violence like so many others; it was created out of necessity on one side and goodwill on the other. Since then, it has been a place of continuous harmony. Neither political nor religious conflicts, disputes with the natives, nor any other arguments have disturbed its peaceful community. Yet, the original founders knew nothing of Lycurgus or Solon; this settlement wasn’t the achievement of prominent individuals or powerful lawmakers trying to control nature through extensive labor. This unique establishment arose from the natural hard work and perseverance common to everyone when they’re supported by a government that doesn’t demand much for its protection and allows them to enjoy a fair system of laws based on complete freedom. The gentleness and humanity of such a government naturally create the trust that drives the most challenging endeavors and long-term success. Would you believe that a sandy area of about twenty-three thousand acres, lacking stones, timber, meadows, or farmland, could boast a nice town with more than 500 houses, possess over 200 sailing vessels, employ upwards of 2000 sailors, support more than 15,000 sheep, 500 cows, 200 horses, and have several citizens worth £20,000! Yet, all these facts are indisputable. Who would have imagined that any people would leave behind a fruitful and vast continent rich in resources from abundant vegetation, fertile land, beautiful meadows, lush pastures, all kinds of timber, and everything else necessary for a happy and comfortable life to settle on a small sandy spot lacking these advantages? To live on a place where hardly a shrub grows to signal spring with budding leaves or warn of winter with falling leaves. If this island had been close to the shores of any ancient kingdom, it likely would have only been populated by a few miserable fishermen, struggling with poverty to even afford small fishing boats, always burdened by taxes or the threat of naval oppression. Instead of the boldness for which the island's inhabitants are well-known, they would have timidly limited themselves to the smallest efforts; fearful in their ventures, they would never have escaped their initial challenges. This island, in contrast, is home to 5,000 resilient people who boldly derive their wealth from the surrounding waters and have been forced by the barren land to look elsewhere for their livelihood. You shouldn’t think, from the recounting of these facts, that they enjoyed any special privileges or royal charters, or that they were supported by specific freedoms in the early days of their settlement. No, it was their freedom, skill, honesty, and determination that achieved everything and gradually brought them to their current standing.
From this first sketch, I hope that my partiality to this island will be justified. Perhaps you hardly know that such an one exists in the neighbourhood of Cape Cod. What has happened here, has and will happen everywhere else. Give mankind the full rewards of their industry, allow them to enjoy the fruit of their labour under the peaceable shade of their vines and fig-trees, leave their native activity unshackled and free, like a fair stream without dams or other obstacles; the first will fertilise the very sand on which they tread, the other exhibit a navigable river, spreading plenty and cheerfulness wherever the declivity of the ground leads it. If these people are not famous for tracing the fragrant furrow on the plain, they plough the rougher ocean, they gather from its surface, at an immense distance, and with Herculean labours, the riches it affords; they go to hunt and catch that huge fish which by its strength and velocity one would imagine ought to be beyond the reach of man. This island has nothing deserving of notice but its inhabitants; here you meet with neither ancient monuments, spacious halls, solemn temples, nor elegant dwellings; not a citadel, nor any kind of fortification, not even a battery to rend the air with its loud peals on any solemn occasion. As for their rural improvements, they are many, but all of the most simple and useful kind.
From this first sketch, I hope my fondness for this island will be clear. You may not even know that it exists near Cape Cod. What has happened here has happened and will happen everywhere else. Give people the full rewards of their hard work, let them enjoy the fruits of their labor in the peaceful shade of their vines and fig trees, and leave their natural industriousness unrestricted and free, like a clear stream without dams or obstacles; the former will enrich even the sand they walk on, while the latter will create a navigable river that brings abundance and joy wherever the land slopes downwards. If these people aren’t known for plowing the fertile fields, they navigate the rough ocean, harvesting its riches with great effort and from vast distances; they go out to hunt and catch the massive fish that, due to its strength and speed, one would think is beyond human reach. This island has nothing noteworthy except its people; here, you won’t find ancient monuments, grand halls, solemn temples, or beautiful homes; there are no citadels or any kind of fortifications, not even a battery to break the silence with its booming sounds on any special occasion. As for their agricultural advancements, they are many, but all are simple and practical.
The island of Nantucket lies in latitude 41 degrees 10 minutes. 60 miles S. from Cape Cod; 27 S. from Hyanes or Barnstable, a town on the most contiguous part of the great peninsula; 21 miles E. by S. from Cape Pog, on the vineyard; 50 E. by S. from Wood's Hole, on Elizabeth Island; 80 miles S. from Boston; 120 from Rhode Island; 800 N. from Bermudas. Sherborn is the only town on the island, which consists of about 530 houses, that have been framed on the main; they are lathed and plastered within, handsomely painted and boarded without; each has a cellar underneath, built with stones fetched also from the main: they are all of a similar construction and appearance; plain, and entirely devoid of exterior or interior ornament. I observed but one which was built of bricks, belonging to Mr.——, but like the rest it is unadorned. The town stands on a rising sandbank, on the west side of the harbour, which is very safe from all winds. There are two places of worship, one for the society of Friends, the other for that of Presbyterians; and in the middle of the town, near the market-place, stands a simple building, which is the county court-house. The town regularly ascends toward the country, and in its vicinage they have several small fields and gardens yearly manured with the dung of their cows, and the soil of their streets. There are a good many cherry and peach trees planted in their streets and in many other places; the apple tree does not thrive well, they have therefore planted but few. The island contains no mountains, yet is very uneven, and the many rising grounds and eminences with which it is filled, have formed in the several valleys a great variety of swamps, where the Indian grass and the blue bent, peculiar to such soils, grow with tolerable luxuriancy. Some of the swamps abound with peat, which serves the poor instead of firewood. There are fourteen ponds on this island, all extremely useful, some lying transversely, almost across it, which greatly helps to divide it into partitions for the use of their cattle; others abound with peculiar fish and sea fowls. Their streets are not paved, but this is attended with little inconvenience, as it is never crowded with country carriages; and those they have in the town are seldom made use of but in the time of the coming in and before the sailing of their fleets. At my first landing I was much surprised at the disagreeable smell which struck me in many parts of the town; it is caused by the whale oil, and is unavoidable; the neatness peculiar to these people can neither remove nor prevent it. There are near the wharfs a great many storehouses, where their staple commodity is deposited, as well as the innumerable materials which are always wanted to repair and fit out so many whalemen. They have three docks, each three hundred feet long, and extremely convenient; at the head of which there are ten feet of water. These docks are built like those in Boston, of logs fetched from the continent, filled with stones, and covered with sand. Between these docks and the town, there is room sufficient for the landing of goods and for the passage of their numerous carts; for almost every man here has one: the wharfs to the north and south of the docks, are built of the same materials, and give a stranger, at his first landing, an high idea of the prosperity of these people; and there is room around these three docks for 300 sail of vessels. When their fleets have been successful, the bustle and hurry of business on this spot for some days after their arrival, would make you imagine, that Sherborn is the capital of a very opulent and large province. On that point of land, which forms the west side of the harbour, stands a very neat lighthouse; the opposite peninsula, called Coitou, secures it from the most dangerous winds. There are but few gardens and arable fields in the neighbourhood of the town, for nothing can be more sterile and sandy than this part of the island; they have, however, with unwearied perseverance, by bringing a variety of manure, and by cow-penning, enriched several spots where they raise Indian corn, potatoes, pumpkins, turnips, etc. On the highest part of this sandy eminence, four windmills grind the grain they raise or import; and contiguous to them their rope walk is to be seen, where full half of their cordage is manufactured. Between the shores of the harbour, the docks, and the town, there is a most excellent piece of meadow, inclosed and manured with such cost and pains as show how necessary and precious grass is at Nantucket. Towards the point of Shemah, the island is more level and the soil better; and there they have considerable lots well fenced and richly manured, where they diligently raise their yearly crops. There are but very few farms on this island, because there are but very few spots that will admit of cultivation without the assistance of dung and other manure; which is very expensive to fetch from the main. This island was patented in the year 1671, by twenty-seven proprietors, under the province of New York; which then claimed all the islands from the Neway Sink to Cape Cod. They found it so universally barren and so unfit for cultivation, that they mutually agreed not to divide it, as each could neither live on, nor improve that lot which might fall to his share. They then cast their eyes on the sea, and finding themselves obliged to become fishermen, they looked for a harbour, and having found one, they determined to build a town in its neighbourhood and to dwell together. For that purpose they surveyed as much ground as would afford to each what is generally called here a home lot. Forty acres were thought sufficient to answer this double purpose; for to what end should they covet more land than they could improve, or even inclose; not being possessed of a single tree, in the whole extent of their new dominion. This was all the territorial property they allotted; the rest they agreed to hold in common, and seeing that the scanty grass of the island might feed sheep, they agreed that each proprietor should be entitled to feed on it if he pleased 560 sheep. By this agreement, the national flock was to consist of 15,120; that is the undivided part of the island was by such means ideally divisible into as many parts or shares; to which nevertheless no certain determinate quantity of land was affixed; for they knew not how much the island contained, nor could the most judicious surveyor fix this small quota as to quality and quantity. Further they agreed, in case the grass should grow better by feeding, that then four sheep should represent a cow, and two cows a horse: such was the method this wise people took to enjoy in common their new settlement; such was the mode of their first establishment, which may be truly and literally called a pastoral one. Several hundred of sheep-pasture titles have since been divided on those different tracts, which are now cultivated; the rest by inheritance and intermarriages have been so subdivided that it is very common for a girl to have no other portion but her outset and four sheep pastures or the privilege of feeding a cow. But as this privilege is founded on an ideal, though real title to some unknown piece of land, which one day or another may be ascertained; these sheep-pasture titles should convey to your imagination, something more valuable and of greater credit than the mere advantage arising from the benefit of a cow, which in that case would be no more than a right of commonage. Whereas, here as labour grows cheaper, as misfortunes from their sea adventures may happen, each person possessed of a sufficient number of these sheep-pasture titles may one day realise them on some peculiar spot, such as shall be adjudged by the council of the proprietors to be adequate to their value; and this is the reason that these people very unwillingly sell those small rights, and esteem them more than you would imagine. They are the representation of a future freehold, they cherish in the mind of the possessor a latent, though distant, hope, that by his success in his next whale season, he may be able to pitch on some predilected spot, and there build himself a home, to which he may retire, and spend the latter end of his days in peace. A council of proprietors always exists in this island, who decide their territorial differences; their titles are recorded in the books of the county, which this town represents, as well as every conveyance of lands and other sales.
The island of Nantucket is located at 41 degrees 10 minutes latitude. It is 60 miles south of Cape Cod; 27 miles south of Hyannis or Barnstable, the closest town on the peninsula; 21 miles southeast of Cape Pogue on Martha's Vineyard; 50 miles southeast of Woods Hole on Elizabeth Island; 80 miles south of Boston; 120 miles from Rhode Island; and 800 miles north of the Bermudas. Sherborn is the only town on the island, which has around 530 houses built using timber from the mainland. They have been lath-and-plaster finished inside, painted attractively, and boarded on the outside. Each house has a cellar made of stones brought over from the mainland too. All the houses share a similar style—simple and lacking any exterior or interior decoration. I noticed just one house made of bricks, owned by Mr.——, but like the others, it has no embellishments. The town is situated on a rising sandbank on the west side of the harbor, which is very safe from all winds. There are two places of worship: one for the Quakers and the other for the Presbyterians. In the center of town, near the market, there is a simple building that serves as the county courthouse. The town gradually rises toward the countryside, and there are several small fields and gardens nearby fertilized annually with cow dung and soil from their streets. There are quite a few cherry and peach trees planted along the streets and in various other places; however, apple trees don't grow well here, so they have planted very few. The island has no mountains, but it is quite uneven. The many hills and ridges create a variety of swamps in the valleys where Indian grass and blue bent, typical for such areas, grow quite well. Some swamps are rich in peat, which the poor use instead of firewood. There are fourteen ponds on the island, all incredibly useful; some run almost across the island, helping to divide it for the use of livestock, while others are filled with unique fish and sea birds. The streets are not paved, but this isn’t much of a problem since they aren’t crowded with country carriages; the few that are in town are mostly used when their fleets are arriving or departing. When I first arrived, I was surprised by the unpleasant smell in many parts of the town; it comes from the whale oil, and it can't be helped—the cleanliness of the people can neither eliminate nor prevent it. Near the wharfs, there are many storehouses where their main product is stored along with countless supplies needed to repair and outfit many whalers. They have three docks, each 300 feet long and very convenient; at the heads of the docks, there are ten feet of water. These docks are built like Boston's, using logs from the mainland, filled with stones, and covered with sand. Between the docks and the town, there's plenty of space for unloading goods and the passage of many carts; nearly every person here has one. The wharfs to the north and south of the docks are made from the same materials and give newcomers an impression of these people's prosperity; there's enough space around the three docks for 300 vessels. When their fleets are successful, the hustle and bustle of business here for days after their arrival leads one to think that Sherborn is the capital of a prosperous and large province. On the point of land that forms the west of the harbor, there is a neat lighthouse; the opposite peninsula, called Coit, protects it from the worst winds. There are very few gardens and farm fields near the town because this part of the island is very sandy and barren, but through consistent effort, using various fertilizers and cow-pens, they have enriched some areas to grow corn, potatoes, pumpkins, turnips, etc. At the highest point of this sandy hill, four windmills grind the grain they grow or import, and next to them is their rope walk, where half of their cordage is made. Between the harbor's shores, the docks, and the town, there is excellent meadow land, enclosed and fertilized at great expense, showing how valuable grass is in Nantucket. Toward Shemah Point, the island is flatter and the soil better, with significant lots that are well fenced and heavily fertilized, where they diligently grow their annual crops. There are very few farms on the island because only a few places can be cultivated without the help of fertilizer and other manure, which is very costly to bring from the mainland. This island was patented in 1671 by twenty-seven owners under the province of New York, which claimed all islands from Neway Sink to Cape Cod. They found the land so completely barren and unfit for cultivation that they agreed not to divide it, since each could neither live off nor improve the plot that might fall to him. They then turned their attention to the sea, compelled to become fishermen, and looked for a harbor. Upon finding one, they decided to build a town nearby and live together. For that reason, they surveyed enough land to provide what is generally known as a "home lot" for each owner. Forty acres were deemed sufficient to meet this dual purpose; why should they desire more land than they could cultivate or even fence in, given they had no trees in the entire extent of their new territory? This was all the land they allocated; the remainder was to be held in common. They realized that the sparse grass on the island could feed sheep, so they agreed that each owner would be allowed to feed up to 560 sheep. By this agreement, the total flock would consist of 15,120; in this way, the undivided parts of the island could be ideally divided into shares, although no specific amount of land was designated since they didn’t know how much land the island actually had, nor could the best surveyor accurately determine this minor share regarding quality and quantity. They further agreed that if the grass improved through grazing, then four sheep would count as one cow, and two cows would equal one horse. This method helped these wise people share their new settlement; this was how they established themselves, which can truly be called a pastoral beginning. Several hundred sheep-pasture allowances have since been divided across those various plots that are now cultivated. The remaining land has been subdivided through inheritance and marriage to the point where it's common for a girl to inherit no more than her starting lot and four sheep pastures, or the right to feed a cow. But since this privilege is based on an ideal, though real, claim to some unidentified piece of land, which may eventually be identified; these sheep-pasture titles convey to your mind something more valuable and esteemed than the simple benefit of having a cow, which in that case would be merely a common right. Whereas, as labor becomes cheaper, and misfortunes arise from their sea adventures, anyone holding a sufficient number of these sheep-pasture titles may one day capitalize on them in some chosen area, as determined by the council of owners to be worth their value; and that’s why these people are very reluctant to sell these small rights and value them far more than one might think. They represent a future freehold, giving the owner a hopeful, albeit distant, aspiration that due to success in the next whale season, he might select some favored spot, build a home there, and enjoy his later years in tranquility. A council of owners always exists on this island, which resolves territorial disputes; their titles are recorded in the county books, which this town oversees, along with every land transfer and sale.
This island furnishes the naturalist with few or no objects worthy observation: it appears to be the uneven summit of a sandy submarine mountain, covered here and there with sorrel, grass, a few cedar bushes, and scrubby oaks; their swamps are much more valuable for the peat they contain, than for the trifling pasture of their surface; those declining grounds which lead to the seashores abound with beach grass, a light fodder when cut and cured, but very good when fed green. On the east side of the island they have several tracts of salt grasses, which being carefully fenced, yield a considerable quantity of that wholesome fodder. Among the many ponds or lakes with which this island abounds, there are some which have been made by the intrusion of the sea, such as Wiwidiah, the Long, the Narrow, and several others; consequently those are salt and the others fresh. The former answer two considerable purposes, first by enabling them to fence the island with greater facility; at peculiar high tides a great number of fish enter into them, where they feed and grow large, and at some known seasons of the year the inhabitants assemble and cut down the small bars which the waves always throw up. By these easy means the waters of the pond are let out, and as the fish follow their native element, the inhabitants with proper nets catch as many as they want, in their way out, without any other trouble. Those which are most common, are the streaked bass, the blue fish, the tom-cod, the mackerel, the tew- tag, the herring, the flounder, eel, etc. Fishing is one of the greatest diversions the island affords. At the west end lies the harbour of Mardiket, formed by Smith Point on the south-west, by Eel Point on the north, and Tuckanut Island on the north-west; but it is neither so safe nor has it so good anchoring ground, as that near which the town stands. Three small creeks run into it, which yield the bitterest eels I have ever tasted. Between the lots of Palpus on the east, Barry's Valley and Miacomet pond on the south, and the narrow pond on the west, not far from Shemah Point, they have a considerable tract of even ground, being the least sandy, and the best on the island. It is divided into seven fields, one of which is planted by that part of the community which are entitled to it. This is called the common plantation, a simple but useful expedient, for was each holder of this track to fence his property, it would require a prodigious quantity of posts and rails, which you must remember are to be purchased and fetched from the main. Instead of those private subdivisions each man's allotment of land is thrown into the general field which is fenced at the expense of the parties; within it every one does with his own portion of the ground whatever he pleases. This apparent community saves a very material expense, a great deal of labour, and perhaps raises a sort of emulation among them, which urges every one to fertilise his share with the greatest care and attention. Thus every seven years the whole of this tract is under cultivation, and enriched by manure and ploughing yields afterwards excellent pasture; to which the town cows, amounting to 500 are daily led by the town shepherd, and as regularly drove back in the evening. There each animal easily finds the house to which it belongs, where they are sure to be well rewarded for the milk they give, by a present of bran, grain, or some farinaceous preparation; their economy being very great in that respect. These are commonly called Tetoukemah lots. You must not imagine that every person on the island is either a landholder, or concerned in rural operations; no, the greater part are at sea; busily employed in their different fisheries; others are mere strangers, who come to settle as handicrafts, mechanics, etc., and even among the natives few are possessed of determinate shares of land: for engaged in sea affairs, or trade, they are satisfied with possessing a few sheep pastures, by means of which they may have perhaps one or two cows. Many have but one, for the great number of children they have, has caused such sub-divisions of the original proprietorship as is sometimes puzzling to trace; and several of the most fortunate at sea, have purchased and realised a great number of these original pasture titles. The best land on the island is at Palpus, remarkable for nothing but a house of entertainment. Quayes is a small but valuable track, long since purchased by Mr. Coffin, where he has erected the best house on the island. By long attention, proximity of the sea, etc., this fertile spot has been well manured, and is now the garden of Nantucket. Adjoining to it on the west side there is a small stream, on which they have erected a fulling mill; on the east is the lot, known by the name of Squam, watered likewise by a small rivulet, on which stands another fulling mill. Here is fine loamy soil, producing excellent clover, which is mowed twice a year. These mills prepare all the cloth which is made here: you may easily suppose that having so large a flock of sheep, they abound in wool; part of this they export, and the rest is spun by their industrious wives and converted into substantial garments. To the south-east is a great division of the island, fenced by itself, known by the name of Siasconcet lot. It is a very uneven track of ground, abounding with swamps; here they turn in their fat cattle, or such as they intend to stall-feed, for their winter's provisions. It is on the shores of this part of the island, near Pochick Rip, where they catch their best fish, such as sea bass, tew-tag, or black fish, cod, smelt, perch, shadine, pike, etc. They have erected a few fishing houses on this shore, as well as at Sankate's Head, and Suffakatche Beach, where the fishermen dwell in the fishing season. Many red cedar bushes and beach grass grow on the peninsula of Coitou; the soil is light and sandy, and serves as a receptacle for rabbits. It is here that their sheep find shelter in the snow storms of the winter. At the north end of Nantucket, there is a long point of land, projecting far into the sea, called Sandy Point; nothing grows on it but plain grass; and this is the place from whence they often catch porpoises and sharks, by a very ingenious method. On this point they commonly drive their horses in the spring of the year, in order to feed on the grass it bears, which is useless when arrived at maturity. Between that point and the main island they have a valuable salt meadow, called Croskaty, with a pond of the same name famous for black ducks. Hence we must return to Squam, which abounds in clover and herds grass; those who possess it follow no maritime occupation, and therefore neglect nothing that can render it fertile and profitable. The rest of the undescribed part of the island is open, and serves as a common pasture for their sheep. To the west of the island is that of Tackanuck, where in the spring their young cattle are driven to feed; it has a few oak bushes and two fresh-water ponds, abounding with teals, brandts, and many other sea fowls, brought to this island by the proximity of their sand banks and shallows; where thousands are seen feeding at low water. Here they have neither wolves nor foxes; those inhabitants therefore who live out of town, raise with all security as much poultry as they want; their turkeys are very large and excellent. In summer this climate is extremely pleasant; they are not exposed to the scorching sun of the continent, the heats being tempered by the sea breezes, with which they are perpetually refreshed. In the winter, however, they pay severely for those advantages; it is extremely cold; the northwest wind, the tyrant of this country, after having escaped from our mountains and forests, free from all impediment in its short passage, blows with redoubled force and renders this island bleak and uncomfortable. On the other hand, the goodness of their houses, the social hospitality of their firesides, and their good cheer, make them ample amends for the severity of the season; nor are the snows so deep as on the main. The necessary and unavoidable inactivity of that season, combined with the vegetative rest of nature, force mankind to suspend their toils: often at this season more than half the inhabitants of the island are at sea, fishing in milder latitudes.
This island provides the naturalist with few, if any, interesting things to observe. It seems to be the uneven top of a sandy underwater mountain, sporadically covered with sorrel, grass, a few cedar bushes, and scraggly oaks. Its swamps are more valuable for the peat they contain than for the meager grazing on their surface. The sloping areas leading to the shores are filled with beach grass, which makes light fodder when cut and cured, but is great when fed fresh. On the east side of the island, there are several areas of salt grasses that, when properly fenced, yield a significant amount of nutritious fodder. Among the many ponds or lakes scattered across the island, some have formed due to the encroachment of the sea, such as Wiwidiah, the Long, the Narrow, and several others; thus, some of these are salty while others are fresh. The salty ones serve two main purposes: first, they make it easier to fence the island; at certain high tides, many fish enter these ponds, where they feed and grow large. At specific times of the year, the residents come together to remove the small bars that the waves continuously deposit. This simple process allows the pond waters to drain, and as the fish return to the sea, the residents catch as many as they need with nets, effortlessly. The most common fish include striped bass, bluefish, tomcod, mackerel, tew-tag, herring, flounder, eel, and others. Fishing is one of the best activities the island offers. At the west end is the harbor of Mardiket, formed by Smith Point to the southwest, Eel Point to the north, and Tuckanut Island to the northwest; however, it is neither as safe nor has as good anchoring ground as the area near the town. Three small creeks flow into it, which produce the most bitter eels I've ever tasted. Between the lots of Palpus on the east, Barry's Valley, and Miacomet pond to the south, and the narrow pond on the west, not far from Shemah Point, there is a significant flat area, being the least sandy and the best on the island. It is divided into seven fields, one of which is cultivated by the part of the community that has rights to it. This area is called the common plantation, a simple but useful solution; if every landholder had to fence their property individually, it would require an enormous amount of posts and rails that must be purchased and brought from the mainland. Instead of private subdivisions, each person's portion of land is included in the general field, which is fenced at the group's expense; within this area, each individual can do whatever they want with their bit of land. This shared community saves significant costs, a lot of labor, and perhaps creates a healthy competition among them, encouraging everyone to take good care of their share. Thus, every seven years the entire tract is cultivated, and after being enriched with manure and plowed, it yields excellent pasture; to which the town's 500 cows are led daily by the town shepherd and just as regularly driven back in the evening. Each animal knows its own home, where they are rewarded for their milk with a treat of bran, grain, or some flour-based preparation, which is a very efficient way to manage resources. These are commonly referred to as Tetoukemah lots. You shouldn't think that everyone on the island is a landowner or involved in farming; most are out at sea, busy with their different fisheries; others are just newcomers who come to settle as craftsmen, mechanics, etc., and even among the locals, few hold definite shares of land. Engaged in sea activities or trade, they are content with a few sheep pastures, which may allow them to have one or two cows. Many have only one, as the large number of children leads to divisions of the original landownership that can be confusing to trace, and several of the most successful fishermen have bought up many of these original pasture rights. The best land on the island is at Palpus, known only for a tavern. Quayes is a small but valuable plot, long ago purchased by Mr. Coffin, who built the best house on the island there. Due to long-term care, its proximity to the sea, etc., this fertile area has been well fertilized and is now known as the garden of Nantucket. Adjacent to it on the west side, there’s a small stream, where they have built a fulling mill; on the east is land known as Squam, which is also watered by a small brook, where another fulling mill stands. The soil here is fine and loamy, producing excellent clover, which is mowed twice a year. These mills process all the cloth made here: with such a large flock of sheep, wool is abundant; some is exported, and the rest is spun by their industrious wives into sturdy garments. To the southeast is a large area of the island, fenced separately, known as Siasconcet lot. It's a very uneven piece of land, filled with swamps; here, they keep their fat cattle or those they plan to fatten for winter. It is along the shores of this part of the island, near Pochick Rip, where they catch their best fish, like sea bass, tew-tag, blackfish, cod, smelt, perch, shad, pike, etc. They have built a few fishing cabins on this shore, as well as at Sankate's Head and Suffakatche Beach, where fishermen stay during the season. Many red cedar bushes and beach grass grow on the Coitou peninsula; the soil is light and sandy and serves as a home for rabbits. This is where their sheep find shelter during winter snowstorms. At the northern tip of Nantucket, there’s a long stretch of land that juts far into the sea, called Sandy Point; nothing grows there except plain grass. This is where they often catch porpoises and sharks using a clever method. In the spring, they commonly drive their horses to this point
This island, as has been already hinted, appears to be the summit of some huge sandy mountain, affording some acres of dry land for the habitation of man; other submarine ones lie to the southward of this, at different depths and different distances. This dangerous region is well known to the mariners by the name of Nantucket Shoals: these are the bulwarks which so powerfully defend this island from the impulse of the mighty ocean, and repel the force of its waves; which, but for the accumulated barriers, would ere now have dissolved its foundations, and torn it in pieces. These are the banks which afforded to the first inhabitants of Nantucket their daily subsistence, as it was from these shoals that they drew the origin of that wealth which they now possess; and was the school where they first learned how to venture farther, as the fish of their coast receded. The shores of this island abound with the soft- shelled, the hard-shelled, and the great sea clams, a most nutritious shell-fish. Their sands, their shallows are covered with them; they multiply so fast, that they are a never-failing resource. These and the great variety of fish they catch, constitute the principal food of the inhabitants. It was likewise that of the aborigines, whom the first settlers found here; the posterity of whom still live together in decent houses along the shores of Miacomet pond, on the south side of the island. They are an industrious, harmless race, as expert and as fond of a seafaring life as their fellow inhabitants the whites. Long before their arrival they had been engaged in petty wars against one another; the latter brought them peace, for it was in quest of peace that they abandoned the main. This island was then supposed to be under the jurisdiction of New York, as well as the islands of the Vineyard, Elizabeth's, etc., but have been since adjudged to be a part of the province of Massachusetts Bay. This change of jurisdiction procured them that peace they wanted, and which their brethren had so long refused them in the days of their religious frenzy: thus have enthusiasm and persecution both in Europe as well as here, been the cause of the most arduous undertakings, and the means of those rapid settlements which have been made along these extended sea-shores. This island, having been since incorporated with the neighbouring province, is become one of its counties, known by the name of Nantucket, as well as the island of the Vineyard, by that of Duke's County. They enjoy here the same municipal establishment in common with the rest; and therefore every requisite officer, such as sheriff, justice of the peace, supervisors, assessors, constables, overseer of the poor, etc. Their taxes are proportioned to those of the metropolis, they are levied as with us by valuations, agreed on and fixed, according to the laws of the province; and by assessments formed by the assessors, who are yearly chosen by the people, and whose office obliges them to take either an oath or an affirmation. Two thirds of the magistrates they have here are of the society of Friends.
This island, as has been previously mentioned, appears to be the peak of a massive sandy mountain, providing some acres of dry land for people to live on. Other underwater ones are located to the south at various depths and distances. This risky area is well known to sailors as Nantucket Shoals; these are the barriers that strongly protect this island from the relentless ocean and push back the force of its waves, which, without these accumulated barriers, would have long ago eroded its foundations and torn it apart. These banks provided the first residents of Nantucket with their daily sustenance, as it was from these shoals that they derived the wealth they now enjoy, and it served as the training ground where they first learned to venture further as the fish closer to shore began to dwindle. The shores of this island are full of soft-shelled, hard-shelled, and large sea clams, which are very nutritious shellfish. Their sands and shallows are teeming with them; they multiply so rapidly that they are a constant resource. These, along with the wide variety of fish they catch, make up the main diet of the inhabitants. This was also the case for the indigenous people whom the first settlers found here; their descendants still live together in well-kept houses along the shores of Miacomet Pond on the island's south side. They are a hardworking, peaceful group, as skilled and enthusiastic about seafaring as their fellow inhabitants, the white settlers. Long before their arrival, they had been engaged in small wars against each other; the newcomers brought them peace, as they came seeking tranquility. At that time, this island was thought to fall under New York's jurisdiction, along with the islands of Martha’s Vineyard, Elizabeth’s, and others, but it has since been established as part of the province of Massachusetts Bay. This shift in jurisdiction provided them with the peace they sought, which their kin had long denied them during the era of religious fervor: thus, both enthusiasm and persecution in Europe and here have fueled the most challenging endeavors and spurred the rapid settlements along these expansive coastlines. This island, having since been incorporated into the neighboring province, has become one of its counties, known as Nantucket, while Martha's Vineyard is recognized as Duke's County. Here, they share the same governmental structure as others, which includes every necessary official, such as sheriff, justice of the peace, supervisors, assessors, constables, overseer of the poor, and so on. Their taxes are aligned with those of the metropolis, levied similarly to ours through agreed-upon valuations as per provincial law, and assessed by the assessors, who are elected by the people every year and are required to take either an oath or affirmation. Two-thirds of their magistrates belong to the Society of Friends.
Before I enter into the further detail of this people's government, industry, mode of living, etc., I think it accessary to give you a short sketch of the political state the natives had been in, a few years preceding the arrival of the whites among them. They are hastening towards a total annihilation, and this may be perhaps the last compliment that will ever be paid them by any traveller. They were not extirpated by fraud, violence, or injustice, as hath been the case in so many provinces; on the contrary, they have been treated by these people as brethren; the peculiar genius of their sect inspiring them with the same spirit of moderation which was exhibited at Pennsylvania. Before the arrival of the Europeans, they lived on the fish of their shores; and it was from the same resources the first settlers were compelled to draw their first subsistence. It is uncertain whether the original right of the Earl of Sterling, or that of the Duke of York, was founded on a fair purchase of the soil or not; whatever injustice might have been committed in that respect, cannot be charged to the account of those Friends who purchased from others who no doubt founded their right on Indian grants: and if their numbers are now so decreased, it must not be attributed either to tyranny or violence, but to some of those causes, which have uninterruptedly produced the same effects from one end of the continent to the other, wherever both nations have been mixed. This insignificant spot, like the sea-shores of the great peninsula, was filled with these people; the great plenty of clams, oysters, and other fish, on which they lived, and which they easily catched, had prodigiously increased their numbers. History does not inform us what particular nation the aborigines of Nantucket were of; it is however very probable that they anciently emigrated from the opposite coast, perhaps from the Hyannees, which is but twenty-seven miles distant. As they then spoke and still speak the Nattick, it is reasonable to suppose that they must have had some affinity with that nation; or else that the Nattick, like the Huron, in the north-western parts of this continent, must have been the most prevailing one in this region. Mr. Elliot, an eminent New England divine, and one of the first founders of that great colony, translated the Bible into this language, in the year 1666, which was printed soon after at Cambridge, near Boston; he translated also the catechism, and many other useful books, which are still very common on this island, and are daily made use of by those Indians who are taught to read. The young Europeans learn it with the same facility as their own tongues; and ever after speak it both with ease and fluency. Whether the present Indians are the decendants of the ancient natives of the island, or whether they are the remains of the many different nations which once inhabited the regions of Mashpe and Nobscusset, in the peninsula now known by the name of Cape Cod, no one can positively tell, not even themselves. The last opinion seems to be that of the most sensible people of the island. So prevailing is the disposition of man to quarrel, and shed blood; so prone is he to divisions and parties; that even the ancient natives of this little spot were separated into two communities, inveterately waging war against each other, like the more powerful tribes of the continent. What do you imagine was the cause of this national quarrel? All the coast of their island equally abounded with the same quantity of fish and clams; in that instance there could be no jealousy, no motives to anger; the country afforded them no game; one would think this ought to have been the country of harmony and peace. But behold the singular destiny of the human kind, ever inferior, in many instances, to the more certain instinct of animals; among which the individuals of the same species are always friends, though reared in different climates: they understand the same language, they shed not each other's blood, they eat not each other's flesh. That part of these rude people who lived on the eastern shores of the island, had from time immemorial tried to destroy those who lived on the west; those latter inspired with the same evil genius, had not been behind hand in retaliating: thus was a perpetual war subsisting between these people, founded on no other reason, but the adventitious place of their nativity and residence. In process of time both parties became so thin and depopulated, that the few who remained, fearing lest their race should become totally extinct, fortunately thought of an expedient which prevented their entire annihilation. Some years before the Europeans came, they mutually agreed to settle a partition line which should divide the island from north to south; the people of the west agreed not to kill those of the east, except they were found transgressing over the western part of the line; those of the last entered into a reciprocal agreement. By these simple means peace was established among them, and this is the only record which seems to entitle them to the denomination of men. This happy settlement put a stop to their sanguinary depredations, none fell afterward but a few rash imprudent individuals; on the contrary, they multiplied greatly. But another misfortune awaited them; when the Europeans came they caught the smallpox, and their improper treatment of that disorder swept away great numbers: this calamity was succeeded by the use of rum; and these are the two principal causes which so much diminished their numbers, not only here but all over the continent. In some places whole nations have disappeared. Some years ago three Indian canoes, on their return to Detroit from the falls of Niagara, unluckily got the smallpox from the Europeans with whom they had traded. It broke out near the long point on Lake Erie, there they all perished; their canoes, and their goods, were afterwards found by some travellers journeying the same way; their dogs were still alive. Besides the smallpox, and the use of spirituous liquors, the two greatest curses they have received from us, there is a sort of physical antipathy, which is equally powerful from one end of the continent to the other. Wherever they happen to be mixed, or even to live in the neighbourhood of the Europeans, they become exposed to a variety of accidents and misfortunes to which they always fall victims: such are particular fevers, to which they were strangers before, and sinking into a singular sort of indolence and sloth. This has been invariably the case wherever the same association has taken place; as at Nattick, Mashpe, Soccanoket in the bounds of Falmouth, Nobscusset, Houratonick, Monhauset, and the Vineyard. Even the Mohawks themselves, who were once so populous, and such renowned warriors, are now reduced to less than 200 since the European settlements have circumscribed the territories which their ancestors had reserved. Three years before the arrival of the Europeans at Cape Cod, a frightful distemper had swept away a great many along its coasts, which made the landing and intrusion of our forefathers much easier than it otherwise might have been. In the year 1763, above half of the Indians of this island perished by a strange fever, which the Europeans who nursed them never caught; they appear to be a race doomed to recede and disappear before the superior genius of the Europeans. The only ancient custom of these people that is remembered is, that in their mutual exchanges, forty sun-dried clams, strung on a string, passed for the value of what might be called a copper. They were strangers to the use and value of wampum, so well known to those of the main. The few families now remaining are meek and harmless; their ancient ferocity is gone: they were early christianised by the New England missionaries, as well as those of the Vineyard, and of several other parts of Massachusetts; and to this day they remain strict observers of the laws and customs of that religion, being carefully taught while young. Their sedentary life has led them to this degree of civilisation much more effectually, than if they had still remained hunters. They are fond of the sea, and expert mariners. They have learned from the Quakers the art of catching both the cod and whale, in consequence of which, five of them always make part of the complement of men requisite to fit out a whaleboat. Many have removed hither from the Vineyard, on which account they are more numerous on Nantucket, than anywhere else.
Before I go into more details about this community's government, industry, and way of life, I think it's important to give you a brief overview of the political situation the natives were in a few years before the arrival of the whites. They are quickly heading towards total extinction, and this may be the last acknowledgment they'll receive from any traveler. They weren't wiped out by deception, violence, or injustice, as has happened in so many areas; rather, they were treated by these people as equals, with the unique spirit of their sect inspiring them with the same moderation seen in Pennsylvania. Before the Europeans arrived, they thrived on the fish found along their shores, and it was from these same resources that the first settlers had to draw their initial sustenance. It's unclear whether the original claim of the Earl of Sterling or that of the Duke of York was based on a fair purchase of the land; whatever injustices may have occurred in this regard can't be blamed on those Friends who bought from people who, without a doubt, had rights based on Indian grants. If their population has now drastically decreased, it shouldn't be attributed to tyranny or violence, but rather to the same causes that have consistently led to similar outcomes across the continent wherever the two nations have interacted. This small area, like the beaches of the great peninsula, was populated with these people; the abundance of clams, oysters, and other fish they relied on had greatly increased their numbers. History doesn't tell us which specific nation the original inhabitants of Nantucket belonged to, but it's very likely they immigrated from the opposite coast, perhaps from the Hyannees, which is only twenty-seven miles away. Since they spoke and still speak Nattick, it's reasonable to assume they had some connection to that nation; otherwise, like the Huron in the northwestern regions of this continent, the Nattick might have been the dominant tribe in the area. Mr. Eliot, a prominent New England minister and one of the early founders of that great colony, translated the Bible into this language in 1666, which was printed shortly after in Cambridge near Boston; he also translated the catechism and many other useful books, which are still common on this island and used daily by those Indians who have learned to read. Young Europeans learn it as easily as their own languages, and thereafter speak it fluently. Whether the current Indians are descendants of the original inhabitants of the island or remnants of various nations that once lived in the areas of Mashpe and Nobscusset in the region now known as Cape Cod is something no one can say for sure, not even they themselves. The prevailing belief seems to be that of the island's more reasonable residents. The tendency for humans to quarrel and shed blood is so strong that even the original natives of this small area were divided into two communities, locked in a longstanding conflict with each other, similar to the more powerful tribes on the continent. Can you guess what started this national feud? The entire coastline of their island was equally abundant with fish and clams; in that regard, there should have been no jealousy or reasons for anger; the land offered them no game; one would think this would foster a spirit of harmony and peace. But look at the strange fate of humankind, often falling short of the more constant instincts of animals, among which individuals of the same species are always friends, even when raised in different environments: they share a common language, they don’t harm each other, and they don’t eat each other. Those indigenous people living on the eastern side of the island had, for time immemorial, sought to eliminate those living on the west; the latter, driven by the same destructive spirit, were eager to retaliate. Thus, there existed a constant war between these groups, with no reason other than the arbitrary location of their birth and residence. Over time, both sides had their numbers so reduced that the few who remained, worried their race would become completely extinct, came up with a solution that prevented their total annihilation. Years before the Europeans arrived, they mutually decided to establish a dividing line that would split the island from north to south; the people on the west agreed not to kill those on the east unless they crossed into the western territory; those on the east made a similar promise. Through these simple arrangements, peace was achieved between them, and this is the only record that seems to give them the title of men. This happy arrangement halted their bloody raids; only a few foolish individuals perished afterward; on the contrary, they began to multiply significantly. But another misfortune awaited them; when the Europeans arrived, they caught smallpox, and inadequate treatment of this disease decimated many: this disaster was followed by the introduction of rum; these are the two main reasons their numbers sharply declined, not just here but throughout the continent as well. In some areas, entire nations have vanished. A few years ago, three Indian canoes returning to Detroit from the falls of Niagara unfortunately caught smallpox from the Europeans with whom they had traded. It broke out near Long Point on Lake Erie, where they all died; their canoes and belongings were later found by travelers passing through the same area, but their dogs were still alive. Besides smallpox and the use of liquor, the two greatest plagues they've encountered from us, there's also a sort of physical aversion that affects them uniformly from one end of the continent to the other. Wherever they live in proximity to Europeans, they become subject to various accidents and misfortunes that always befall them: these include particular fevers, which they had never encountered before, and a peculiar kind of laziness and indifference. This has been consistently true wherever this association has occurred, in places like Nattick, Mashpe, Soccanoket within Falmouth, Nobscusset, Houratonick, Monhauset, and the Vineyard. Even the Mohawks, once numerous and famed warriors, have dwindled to less than 200 since European settlements have encroached on the lands their ancestors had set aside. Three years before the Europeans arrived at Cape Cod, a devastating illness wiped out many along the coasts, making it much easier for our forefathers to land and settle than it might have been otherwise. In 1763, more than half of the Indians on this island died from a strange fever that the Europeans caring for them never contracted; they appear to be a race condemned to fade away and vanish before the dominant influence of Europeans. The only ancient custom that is still remembered among these people is that in their bartering, forty sun-dried clams strung on a string were exchanged for what might be considered a copper. They were unfamiliar with the use and value of wampum, which was well-known to those on the mainland. The few families that remain now are gentle and harmless; their former ferocity is gone: they were early Christianized by the New England missionaries, as well as by those from the Vineyard and other parts of Massachusetts; to this day, they continue to strictly observe the laws and customs of that faith, having been carefully instructed from a young age. Their settled way of life has led them to this level of civilization much more effectively than if they had remained hunters. They are fond of the sea and skilled sailors. They learned from the Quakers how to catch both cod and whales, which is why five of them are always part of the crew required to operate a whaleboat. Many have moved here from the Vineyard, which is why they are more numerous on Nantucket than anywhere else.
It is strange what revolution has happened among them in less than two hundred years! What is become of those numerous tribes which formerly inhabited the extensive shores of the great bay of Massachusetts? Even from Numkeag (Salem), Saugus (Lynn), Shawmut (Boston), Pataxet, Napouset (Milton), Matapan (Dorchester), Winesimet (Chelsea), Poiasset, Pokanoket (New Plymouth), Suecanosset (Falmouth), Titicut (Chatham). Nobscusset (Yarmouth), Naussit (Eastham), Hyannees (Barnstable), etc., and many others who lived on sea-shores of above three hundred miles in length; without mentioning those powerful tribes which once dwelt between the rivers Hudson, Connecticut, Piskataqua, and Kennebeck, the Mehikaudret, Mohiguine, Pequods, Narragansets, Nianticks, Massachusetts, Wamponougs, Nipnets, Tarranteens, etc.—They are gone, and every memorial of them is lost; no vestiges whatever are left of those swarms which once inhabited this country, and replenished both sides of the great peninsula of Cape Cod: not even one of the posterity of the famous Masconomeo is left (the sachem of Cape Ann); not one of the descendants of Massasoit, father of Metacomet (Philip), and Wamsutta (Alexander), he who first conveyed some lands to the Plymouth Company. They have all disappeared either in the wars which the Europeans carried on against them, or else they have mouldered away, gathered in some of their ancient towns, in contempt and oblivion: nothing remains of them all, but one extraordinary monument, and even this they owe to the industry and religious zeal of the Europeans, I mean the Bible translated into the Nattick tongue. Many of these tribes giving way to the superior power of the whites, retired to their ancient villages, collecting the scattered remains of nations once populous; and in their grant of lands reserved to themselves and posterity certain portions, which lay contiguous to them. There forgetting their ancient manners, they dwelt in peace; in a few years their territories were surrounded by the improvements of the Europeans; in consequence of which they grew lazy, inactive, unwilling, and unapt to imitate, or to follow any of our trades, and in a few generations, either totally perished or else came over to the Vineyard, or to this island, to re-unite themselves with such societies of their countrymen as would receive them. Such has been the fate of many nations, once warlike and independent; what we see now on the main, or on those islands, may be justly considered as the only remains of those ancient tribes. Might I be permitted to pay perhaps a very useless compliment to those at least who inhabited the great peninsula of Namset, now Cape Cod, with whose names and ancient situation I am well acquainted. This peninsula was divided into two great regions; that on the side of the bay was known by the name of Nobscusset, from one of its towns; the capital was called Nausit (now Eastham); hence the Indians of that region were called Nausit Indians, though they dwelt in the villages of Pamet, Nosset, Pashee, Potomaket, Soktoowoket, Nobscusset (Yarmouth).
It's strange how much has changed among them in less than two hundred years! What happened to the many tribes that used to live along the vast shores of the great bay of Massachusetts? Even from Numkeag (Salem), Saugus (Lynn), Shawmut (Boston), Pataxet, Napouset (Milton), Matapan (Dorchester), Winesimet (Chelsea), Poiasset, Pokanoket (New Plymouth), Suecanosset (Falmouth), Titicut (Chatham), Nobscusset (Yarmouth), Naussit (Eastham), Hyannees (Barnstable), and many others who lived along the shores stretching over three hundred miles; not to mention the powerful tribes that once resided between the rivers Hudson, Connecticut, Piskataqua, and Kennebeck, like the Mehikaudret, Mohiguine, Pequods, Narragansets, Nianticks, Massachusetts, Wamponougs, Nipnets, Tarranteens, etc.—They are gone, and every trace of them is lost; no signs at all are left of those groups that once populated this land and filled both sides of the great peninsula of Cape Cod: not even one descendant of the famous Masconomeo (the sachem of Cape Ann) remains; not one descendant of Massasoit, father of Metacomet (Philip) and Wamsutta (Alexander), who was the first to grant some lands to the Plymouth Company. They have all vanished either in the wars the Europeans waged against them or have faded away, gathered in some of their old towns, forgotten and ignored: nothing remains but one extraordinary monument, which they owe to the effort and religious zeal of the Europeans—the Bible translated into the Nattick language. Many of these tribes, surrendering to the superior power of the whites, retreated to their ancient villages, gathering the scattered remnants of once populous nations; they reserved certain portions of land for themselves and their descendants that were near them. There, forgetting their ancient customs, they lived in peace; within a few years, their territories were surrounded by European settlements, leading them to become lazy, inactive, unwilling, and unapt to adopt or follow any of our trades. In just a few generations, they either completely disappeared or moved to the Vineyard or this island to reconnect with their countrymen who would take them in. Such has been the fate of many once warlike and independent nations; what we see now on the mainland or those islands can justly be considered the only remnants of those ancient tribes. If I might offer what may be a rather unnecessary compliment to those who once inhabited the great peninsula of Namset, now Cape Cod, with whose names and ancient locations I am well familiar. This peninsula was divided into two main regions; that on the bay side was called Nobscusset, named after one of its towns; the capital was called Nausit (now Eastham); thus, the Indians of that region were known as Nausit Indians, even though they lived in the villages of Pamet, Nosset, Pashee, Potomaket, Soktoowoket, and Nobscusset (Yarmouth).
The region on the Atlantic side was called Mashpee, and contained the tribes of Hyannees, Costowet, Waquoit, Scootin, Saconasset, Mashpee, and Namset. Several of these Indian towns have been since converted into flourishing European settlements, known by different names; for as the natives were excellent judges of land, which they had fertilised besides with the shells of their fish, etc., the latter could not make a better choice; though in general this great peninsula is but a sandy pine track, a few good spots excepted. It is divided into seven townships, viz. Bamstable, Yarmouth, Harwich, Chatham, Eastham, Pamet, Namset, or Province town, at the extremity of the Cape. Yet these are very populous, though I am at a loss to conceive on what the inhabitants live, besides clams, oysters, and fish; their piny lands being the most ungrateful soil in the world. The minister of Namset or Province Town, receives from the government of Massachusetts a salary of fifty pounds per annum; and such is the poverty of the inhabitants of that place, that, unable to pay him any money, each master of a family is obliged to allow him two hundred horse feet (sea spin) with which this primitive priest fertilises the land of his glebe, which he tills himself: for nothing will grow on these hungry soils without the assistance of this extraordinary manure, fourteen bushels of Indian corn being looked upon as a good crop. But it is time to return from a digression, which I hope you will pardon. Nantucket is a great nursery of seamen, pilots, coasters, and bank-fishermen; as a country belonging to the province of Massachusetts, it has yearly the benefit of a court of Common Pleas, and their appeal lies to the supreme court at Boston. I observed before, that the Friends compose two-thirds of the magistracy of this island; thus they are the proprietors of its territory, and the principal rulers of its inhabitants; but with all this apparatus of law, its coercive powers are seldom wanted or required. Seldom is it that any individual is amerced or punished; their jail conveys no terror; no man has lost his life here judicially since the foundation of this town, which is upwards of an hundred years. Solemn tribunals, public executions, humiliating punishments, are altogether unknown. I saw neither governors, nor any pageantry of state; neither ostentatious magistrates, nor any individuals clothed with useless dignity: no artificial phantoms subsist here either civil or religious; no gibbets loaded with guilty citizens offer themselves to your view; no soldiers are appointed to bayonet their compatriots into servile compliance. But how is a society composed of 5000 individuals preserved in the bonds of peace and tranquillity? How are the weak protected from the strong?—I will tell you. Idleness and poverty, the causes of so many crimes, are unknown here; each seeks in the prosecution of his lawful business that honest gain which supports them; every period of their time is full, either on shore or at sea. A probable expectation of reasonable profits, or of kindly assistance, if they fail of success, renders them strangers to licentious expedients. The simplicity of their manners shortens the catalogues of their wants; the law at a distance is ever ready to exert itself in the protection of those who stand in need of its assistance. The greatest part of them are always at sea, pursuing the whale or raising the cod from the surface of the banks: some cultivate their little farms with the utmost diligence; some are employed in exercising various trades; others again in providing every necessary resource in order to refit their vessels, or repair what misfortunes may happen, looking out for future markets, etc. Such is the rotation of those different scenes of business which fill the measure of their days; of that part of their lives at least which is enlivened by health, spirits, and vigour. It is but seldom that vice grows on a barren sand like this, which produces nothing without extreme labour. How could the common follies of society take root in so despicable a soil; they generally thrive on its exuberant juices: here there are none but those which administer to the useful, to the necessary, and to the indispensable comforts of life. This land must necessarily either produce health, temperance, and a great equality of conditions, or the most abject misery. Could the manners of luxurious countries be imported here, like an epidemical disorder they would destroy everything; the majority of them could not exist a month, they would be obliged to emigrate. As in all societies except that of the natives, some difference must necessarily exist between individual and individual, for there must be some more exalted than the rest either by their riches or their talents; so in this, there are what you might call the high, the middling, and the low; and this difference will always be more remarkable among people who live by sea excursions than among those who live by the cultivation of their land. The first run greater hazard, and adventure more: the profits and the misfortunes attending this mode of life must necessarily introduce a greater disparity than among the latter, where the equal divisions of the land offers no short road to superior riches. The only difference that may arise among them is that of industry, and perhaps of superior goodness of soil: the gradations I observed here, are founded on nothing more than the good or ill success of their maritime enterprises, and do not proceed from education; that is the same throughout every class, simple, useful, and unadorned like their dress and their houses. This necessary difference in their fortunes does not however cause those heart burnings, which in other societies generate crimes. The sea which surrounds them is equally open to all, and presents to all an equal title to the chance of good fortune. A collector from Boston is the only king's officer who appears on these shores to receive the trifling duties which this community owe to those who protect them, and under the shadow of whose wings they navigate to all parts of the world.
The area on the Atlantic side was called Mashpee and included the tribes of Hyannees, Costowet, Waquoit, Scootin, Saconasset, Mashpee, and Namset. Several of these Native towns have since turned into thriving European settlements known by different names. The natives were great judges of land, having enriched it with shells from their fish and more, so the settlers couldn't have made a better choice. However, for the most part, this large peninsula is just a sandy pine tract, except for a few good spots. It’s divided into seven townships: Barnstable, Yarmouth, Harwich, Chatham, Eastham, Pamet, and Namset, or Province Town, at the tip of the Cape. Despite this, these areas are quite populated, although I struggle to understand what the residents live on besides clams, oysters, and fish; their sandy lands are some of the least fertile in the world. The minister of Namset or Province Town receives a salary of fifty pounds a year from the government of Massachusetts; the poverty of the locals is such that, unable to pay him any money, each head of a household must give him two hundred horse feet (seaweed) to fertilize his land, which he tends himself. Nothing will grow in these ungrateful soils without this unique fertilizer, as fourteen bushels of corn is considered a good crop. But it’s time to return from this digression, which I hope you’ll forgive. Nantucket is a major training ground for sailors, pilots, coasters, and bank fishermen; as a territory of Massachusetts, it benefits annually from a Court of Common Pleas, with appeals going to the supreme court in Boston. I noted earlier that the Friends make up two-thirds of the magistracy on this island; thus, they own its land and essentially govern its residents. Despite this legal framework, enforcement is rarely necessary. Instances of punishment or fines are uncommon; their jail inspires no fear; no one has been executed here since the town was founded, which is over a hundred years ago. Formal courts, public executions, and humiliating punishments are completely absent. I saw no governors or grand displays of power; no showy magistrates, nor any individuals dressed in unnecessary finery exist here; no artificial constructs of civil or religious authority; no gallows laden with condemned citizens are visible; no soldiers are assigned to force compliance among their fellow citizens. But how can a society of 5,000 people maintain peace and tranquility? How are the weak protected from the strong? I’ll explain. Idleness and poverty, which lead to many crimes, are unknown here; each person seeks honest earnings through their respective work. Their schedules are filled, whether on shore or at sea. A reasonable expectation of fair profits or the assurance of help if they fail keeps them clear of reckless behavior. The simplicity of their ways keeps their needs minimal; the law is always ready to support those who require assistance. Most of them are constantly at sea, hunting whales or fishing for cod on the banks. Some tend their small farms with great care, others engage in various trades, while still others make sure to gather everything they need to repair their boats or take care of unpredictable mishaps, always keeping an eye out for future markets, etc. This is the rhythm of their daily lives, at least the part that is energized by health, spirit, and vigor. It’s rare for vice to thrive in a barren sand like this, where nothing grows without significant effort. How could the common follies of society establish roots in such an uninviting environment? They usually flourish on more abundant resources; here, there’s only what serves the useful, the necessary, and the essential comforts of life. This land must either promote health, moderation, and great equality of conditions, or plunge its inhabitants into utter misery. If the ways of luxurious places were brought here, like an infectious disease they would ruin everything; most wouldn’t survive a month and would have to leave. As in all societies except for that of the natives, some differences must exist among individuals, meaning some are elevated above others either by wealth or talent; and in this case, you can discern the high, the middle, and the low classes; this difference is often more noticeable among those who make their living by sea travel than those who farm the land. The former take greater risks and encounter more adventures; the gains and losses that come with this lifestyle must create more disparity than the latter group, where equitable land distribution doesn’t pave the way for significant wealth. The only differences that might emerge among them stem from hard work and possibly the inherent quality of the land; the distinctions I noticed are based solely on the success or failure of their sea ventures and have nothing to do with education, which is consistent across all classes – simple, practical, and unembellished like their clothing and homes. This necessary difference in fortunes does not, however, lead to the resentment that generates crimes in other societies. The sea that surrounds them is equally accessible to all and offers everyone an equal chance at good fortune. A collector from Boston is the only king's officer who appears on these shores to collect the minimal duties that this community owes to those who protect them, navigating the world under the shelter of their authority.
LETTER V
CUSTOMARY EDUCATION AND EMPLOYMENT OF THE INHABITANTS OF NANTUCKET
The easiest way of becoming acquainted with the modes of thinking, the rules of conduct, and the prevailing manners of any people, is to examine what sort of education they give their children; how they treat them at home, and what they are taught in their places of public worship. At home their tender minds must be early struck with the gravity, the serious though cheerful deportment of their parents; they are inured to a principle of subordination, arising neither from sudden passions nor inconsiderate pleasure; they are gently held by an uniform silk cord, which unites softness and strength. A perfect equanimity prevails in most of their families, and bad example hardly ever sows in their hearts the seeds of future and similar faults. They are corrected with tenderness, nursed with the most affectionate care, clad with that decent plainness, from which they observe their parents never to depart: in short, by the force of example, which is superior even to the strongest instinct of nature, more than by precepts, they learn to follow the steps of their parents, to despise ostentatiousness as being sinful. They acquire a taste for neatness for which their fathers are so conspicuous; they learn to be prudent and saving; the very tone of voice with which they are always addressed, establishes in them that softness of diction, which ever after becomes habitual. Frugal, sober, orderly parents, attached to their business, constantly following some useful occupation, never guilty of riot, dissipation, or other irregularities, cannot fail of training up children to the same uniformity of life and manners. If they are left with fortunes, they are taught how to save them, and how to enjoy them with moderation and decency; if they have none, they know how to venture, how to work and toil as their fathers have done before them. If they fail of success, there are always in this island (and wherever this society prevails) established resources, founded on the most benevolent principles. At their meetings they are taught the few, the simple tenets of their sect; tenets as fit to render men sober, industrious, just, and merciful, as those delivered in the most magnificent churches and cathedrals: they are instructed in the most essential duties of Christianity, so as not to offend the Divinity by the commission of evil deeds; to dread his wrath and the punishments he has denounced; they are taught at the same time to have a proper confidence in his mercy while they deprecate his justice. As every sect, from their different modes of worship, and their different interpretations of some parts of the Scriptures, necessarily have various opinions and prejudices, which contribute something in forming their characters in society; so those of the Friends are well known: obedience to the laws, even to non- resistance, justice, goodwill to all, benevolence at home, sobriety, meekness, neatness, love of order, fondness and appetite for commerce. They are as remarkable here for those virtues as at Philadelphia, which is their American cradle, and the boast of that society. At schools they learn to read, and to write a good hand, until they are twelve years old; they are then in general put apprentices to the cooper's trade, which is the second essential branch of business followed here; at fourteen they are sent to sea, where in their leisure hours their companions teach them the art of navigation, which they have an opportunity of practising on the spot. They learn the great and useful art of working a ship in all the different situations which the sea and wind so often require; and surely there cannot be a better or a more useful school of that kind in the world. Then they go gradually through every station of rowers, steersmen, and harpooners; thus they learn to attack, to pursue, to overtake, to cut, to dress their huge game: and after having performed several such voyages, and perfected themselves in this business, they are fit either for the counting house or the chase.
The easiest way to get to know the ways of thinking, the rules of behavior, and the common customs of any group of people is to look at how they educate their children; how they treat them at home, and what they learn in their places of worship. At home, kids' sensitive minds are shaped early by the seriousness, though cheerful demeanor of their parents; they learn to respect authority based not on sudden emotions or careless enjoyment, but gently guided by a consistent, supportive system that balances softness and strength. A sense of calm exists in most households, and negative examples rarely lead them to develop similar faults. They are corrected with care, cared for affectionately, dressed in simple modesty that their parents consistently uphold: in short, through the power of example, which is even stronger than the strongest natural instincts, more than through direct instruction, they learn to follow their parents’ lead and see showiness as wrong. They develop a taste for the neatness their fathers are known for; they learn to be wise and frugal; even the tone of voice used with them fosters a gentleness in their speech that becomes second nature. Frugal, disciplined, orderly parents, dedicated to their work and always engaged in something useful, will naturally raise children who lead similarly uniform lives. If they inherit wealth, they are taught to save it and to enjoy it moderately and decently; if they have none, they know how to take risks, work hard, and strive as their fathers did. If they don't succeed, there are always resources available on this island (and wherever this community exists), based on the most compassionate principles. In their gatherings, they learn a few basic tenets of their faith; these principles promote sobriety, hard work, justice, and kindness, just like those expressed in the grandest churches and cathedrals: they are taught essential Christian duties to avoid offending God through wrongdoing; to fear his wrath and the punishments he has outlined; while also being encouraged to have a proper trust in his mercy, even as they respect his justice. Each religious group, with their different ways of worship and interpretations of scripture, develops unique opinions and biases that help shape their societal roles; the Friends are no exception, known for their adherence to the law, commitment to justice, goodwill towards all, kindness at home, sobriety, humility, neatness, love for order, and interest in commerce. They are celebrated for these virtues here just as they are in Philadelphia, their American birthplace and pride of their community. In schools, they learn to read and write legibly until they’re twelve; afterward, they typically become apprentices in the cooper’s trade, which is a key local industry; at fourteen, they go to sea, where their peers teach them navigation skills that they can immediately practice. They learn the vital art of managing a ship in the various conditions that the sea and wind require; surely, there’s no better or more practical type of training for that anywhere else. They gradually work their way through roles such as rowers, steersmen, and harpooners; thus they learn how to tackle, pursue, catch, process, and prepare their large catch: after several voyages and mastering these skills, they become ready for either the office or the hunt.
The first proprietors of this island, or rather the first founders of this town, began their career of industry with a single whale- boat, with which they went to fish for cod; the small distance from their shores at which they caught it, enabled them soon to increase their business, and those early successes first led them to conceive that they might likewise catch the whales, which hitherto sported undisturbed on their banks. After many trials and several miscarriages, they succeeded; thus they proceeded, step by step; the profits of one successful enterprise helped them to purchase and prepare better materials for a more extensive one: as these were attended with little costs, their profits grew greater. The south sides of the island from east to west, were divided into four equal parts, and each part was assigned to a company of six, which though thus separated, still carried on their business in common. In the middle of this distance, they erected a mast, provided with a sufficient number of rounds, and near it they built a temporary hut, where five of the associates lived, whilst the sixth from his high station carefully looked toward the sea, in order to observe the spouting of the whales. As soon as any were discovered, the sentinel descended, the whale-boat was launched, and the company went forth in quest of their game. It may appear strange to you, that so slender a vessel as an American whale-boat, containing six diminutive beings, should dare to pursue and to attack, in its native element, the largest and strongest fish that nature has created. Yet by the exertions of an admirable dexterity, improved by a long practice, in which these people are become superior to any other whale-men; by knowing the temper of the whale after her first movement, and by many other useful observations; they seldom failed to harpoon it, and to bring the huge leviathan on the shores. Thus they went on until the profits they made, enabled them to purchase larger vessels, and to pursue them farther, when the whales quitted their coasts; those who failed in their enterprises, returned to the cod-fisheries, which had been their first school, and their first resource; they even began to visit the banks of Cape Breton, the isle of Sable, and all the other fishing places, with which this coast of America abounds. By degrees they went a-whaling to Newfoundland, to the Gulf of St. Lawrence, to the Straits of Belleisle, the coast of Labrador, Davis's Straits, even to Cape Desolation, in 70 degrees of latitude; where the Danes carry on some fisheries in spite of the perpetual severities of the inhospitable climate. In process of time they visited the western islands, the latitude of 34 degrees famous for that fish, the Brazils, the coast of Guinea. Would you believe that they have already gone to the Falkland Islands, and that I have heard several of them talk of going to the South Sea! Their confidence is so great, and their knowledge of this branch of business so superior to that of any other people, that they have acquired a monopoly of this commodity. Such were their feeble beginnings, such the infancy and the progress of their maritime schemes; such is now the degree of boldness and activity to which they are arrived in their manhood. After their examples several companies have been formed in many of our capitals, where every necessary article of provisions, implements, and timber, are to be found. But the industry exerted by the people of Nantucket, hath hitherto enabled them to rival all their competitors; consequently this is the greatest mart for oil, whalebone, and spermaceti, on the continent. It does not follow however that they are always successful, this would be an extraordinary field indeed, where the crops should never fail; many voyages do not repay the original cost of fitting out: they bear such misfortunes like true merchants, and as they never venture their all like gamesters, they try their fortunes again; the latter hope to win by chance alone, the former by industry, well judged speculation, and some hazard. I was there when Mr.——had missed one of his vessels; she had been given over for lost by everybody, but happily arrived before I came away, after an absence of thirteen months. She had met with a variety of disappointments on the station she was ordered to, and rather than return empty, the people steered for the coast of Guinea, where they fortunately fell in with several whales, and brought home upward of 600 barrels of oil, beside bone. Those returns are sometimes disposed of in the towns on the continent, where they are exchanged for such commodities as are wanted; but they are most commonly sent to England, where they always sell for cash. When this is intended, a vessel larger than the rest is fitted out to be filled with oil on the spot where it is found and made, and thence she sails immediately for London. This expedient saves time, freight, and expense; and from that capital they bring back whatever they want. They employ also several vessels in transporting lumber to the West Indian Islands, from whence they procure in return the various productions of the country, which they afterwards exchange wherever they can hear of an advantageous market. Being extremely acute they well know how to improve all the advantages which the combination of so many branches of business constantly affords; the spirit of commerce, which is the simple art of a reciprocal supply of wants, is well understood here by everybody. They possess, like the generality of Americans, a large share of native penetration, activity, and good sense, which lead them to a variety of other secondary schemes too tedious to mention: they are well acquainted with the cheapest method of procuring lumber from Kennebeck river, Penobscot, etc., pitch and tar, from North Carolina; flour and biscuit, from Philadelphia; beef and pork, from Connecticut. They know how to exchange their cod fish and West- Indian produce, for those articles which they are continually either bringing to their island, or sending off to other places where they are wanted. By means of all these commercial negotiations, they have greatly cheapened the fitting out of their whaling fleets, and therefore much improved their fisheries. They are indebted for all these advantages not only to their national genius but to the poverty of their soil; and as proof of what I have so often advanced, look at the Vineyard (their neighbouring island) which is inhabited by a set of people as keen and as sagacious as themselves. Their soil being in general extremely fertile, they have fewer navigators; though they are equally well situated for the fishing business. As in my way back to Falmouth on the main, I visited this sister island, permit me to give you as concisely as I can, a short but true description of it; I am not so limited in the principal object of this journey, as to wish to confine myself to the single spot of Nantucket.
The first settlers of this island, or more accurately, the first founders of this town, started their journey with just one whale boat, which they used to fish for cod. The short distance from the shore where they caught it allowed them to quickly grow their business, and those early successes made them think they could also catch the whales that had previously been left alone in the area. After many attempts and some failures, they eventually succeeded; they progressed step by step, with the profits from one successful venture allowing them to acquire better materials for larger operations: since these came at low costs, their profits increased. The southern side of the island was divided into four equal parts, with each part assigned to a group of six people, who despite being separated still collaborated in their business. In the middle of this area, they set up a mast with several rounds, and nearby they built a temporary hut where five of the members lived, while the sixth kept watch from a high point to spot any whales in the water. Once any were seen, the lookout would shout, the whale boat would be launched, and the crew would head out to catch their target. It might seem odd to you that such a small vessel as an American whale boat, carrying six small individuals, would dare to hunt and attack the largest and strongest fish in the ocean. However, through impressive skill honed by long practice in which these individuals excel beyond any other whalers, by understanding a whale’s behavior after its initial movement, and various other useful observations, they rarely missed their chance to harpoon one and bring the massive creature to shore. They continued this way until their profits allowed them to buy larger boats and pursue whales further away from their coasts; those who were unsuccessful returned to cod fishing, which was their first training and initial resource; they even began to explore the fishing grounds near Cape Breton, Sable Island, and other rich fishing areas along the American coast. Gradually, they ventured to whaling waters around Newfoundland, the Gulf of St. Lawrence, the Straits of Belle Isle, the Labrador coast, Davis Strait, and even as far as Cape Desolation, located at 70 degrees latitude; where the Danes maintain some fisheries despite the harshness of the climate. Over time, they explored western islands, the 34-degree latitude known for fish, Brazil, and the coast of Guinea. Would you believe they have even reached the Falkland Islands, and I’ve heard several of them mention plans to go to the South Sea? Their confidence is immense, and their expertise in this field surpasses that of any other group, granting them a monopoly over this trade. Such were their humble beginnings, such the infancy and progress of their maritime ventures; and now, they’ve reached a level of boldness and activity in their endeavors. Following their example, several companies have been established in many of our cities, where all necessary food supplies, equipment, and timber can be found. However, the hard work demonstrated by the people of Nantucket has so far allowed them to outpace all their competitors; thus, it is now the biggest market for oil, whalebone, and spermaceti in the country. It doesn’t mean that they are always successful; it would be remarkable if a venture like this never faced setbacks; many trips don’t even break even on the initial investment for outfitting. They handle such misfortunes like true merchants, and since they don’t risk everything like gamblers, they try again; the latter hope to win merely by chance, while the former rely on industriousness, sound strategy, and some risk. I was there when Mr.——lost one of his ships; everyone had given her up for lost, but she fortunately arrived back just before I left, after being gone for thirteen months. She faced numerous setbacks on her mission, and rather than return empty-handed, the crew redirected their course to the coast of Guinea, where they fortunately encountered several whales and returned with over 600 barrels of oil, along with whale bone. Those returns are sometimes sold in towns on the mainland for other needed products, but they are most often sent to England, where they consistently sell for cash. When this is planned, a larger ship is outfitted to be filled with oil right at the location where it is found and produced, and then it immediately sails to London. This method saves time, freight, and expenses; from there they bring back anything they need. They also operate several vessels to transport lumber to the West Indies, where they trade for the country’s various products, which they later exchange wherever they find a good market. Being very sharp, they know how to leverage the many advantages that come from combining so many different business ventures; the spirit of commerce, which is simply the mutual supply of needs, is well understood among everyone here. They share, like most Americans, a significant amount of natural insight, drive, and common sense, which leads them to various other side projects that are too numerous to detail: they know the most affordable ways to procure lumber from the Kennebec River, Penobscot, etc., pitch and tar from North Carolina; flour and biscuits from Philadelphia; beef and pork from Connecticut. They can trade their codfish and West Indian produce for items they are always either bringing to their island or sending off to places where they are needed. Through all these commercial dealings, they have greatly reduced the costs of outfitting their whaling fleets, significantly boosting their fishing ventures. They owe all these advantages not only to their national talent but also to the insufficient quality of their land; and to confirm what I have repeatedly stated, look at the Vineyard (the neighboring island), which is home to a people as sharp and clever as they are. Their land is generally very fertile, leading to fewer sailors, although they are equally well positioned for the fishing industry. On my way back to Falmouth on the mainland, I visited this sister island, so let me give you a brief but accurate description of it; I am not so restricted in the main purpose of this journey that I want to limit myself to just Nantucket.
LETTER VI
DESCRIPTION OF THE ISLAND OF MARTHA'S VINEYARD; AND OF THE WHALE FISHERY
This island is twenty miles in length, and from seven to eight miles in breadth. It lies nine miles from the continent, and with the Elizabeth Islands forms one of the counties of Massachusetts Bay, known by the name of Duke's County. Those latter, which are six in number, are about nine miles distant from the Vineyard, and are all famous for excellent dairies. A good ferry is established between the Edgar Town, and Falmouth on the main, the distance being nine miles. Martha's Vineyard is divided into three townships, viz. Edgar, Chilmark, and Tisbury; the number of inhabitants is computed at about 4000, 300 of which are Indians. Edgar is the best seaport, and the shire town, and as its soil is light and sandy, many of its inhabitants follow the example of the people of Nantucket. The town of Chilmark has no good harbour, but the land is excellent and no way inferior to any on the continent: it contains excellent pastures, convenient brooks for mills, stone for fencing, etc. The town of Tisbury is remarkable for the excellence of its timber, and has a harbour where the water is deep enough for ships of the line. The stock of the island is 20,000 sheep, 2000 neat cattle, beside horses and goats; they have also some deer, and abundance of sea- fowls. This has been from the beginning, and is to this day, the principal seminary of the Indians; they live on that part of the island which is called Chapoquidick, and were very early christianised by the respectable family of the Mahews, the first proprietors of it. The first settler of that name conveyed by will to a favourite daughter a certain part of it, on which there grew many wild vines; thence it was called Martha's Vineyard, after her name, which in process of time extended to the whole island. The posterity of the ancient Aborigines remain here to this day, on lands which their forefathers reserved for themselves, and which are religiously kept from any encroachments. The New England people are remarkable for the honesty with which they have fulfilled, all over that province, those ancient covenants which in many others have been disregarded, to the scandal of those governments. The Indians there appeared, by the decency of their manners, their industry, and neatness, to be wholly Europeans, and nowise inferior to many of the inhabitants. Like them they are sober, laborious, and religious, which are the principal characteristics of the four New England provinces. They often go, like the young men of the Vineyard, to Nantucket, and hire themselves for whalemen or fishermen; and indeed their skill and dexterity in all sea affairs is nothing inferior to that of the whites. The latter are divided into two classes, the first occupy the land, which they till with admirable care and knowledge; the second, who are possessed of none, apply themselves to the sea, the general resource of mankind in this part of the world. This island therefore, like Nantucket, is become a great nursery which supplies with pilots and seamen the numerous coasters with which this extended part of America abounds. Go where you will from Nova Scotia to the Mississippi, you will find almost everywhere some natives of these two islands employed in seafaring occupations. Their climate is so favourable to population, that marriage is the object of every man's earliest wish; and it is a blessing so easily obtained, that great numbers are obliged to quit their native land and go to some other countries in quest of subsistence. The inhabitants are all Presbyterians, which is the established religion of Massachusetts; and here let me remember with gratitude the hospitable treatment I received from B. Norton, Esq., the colonel of the island, as well as from Dr. Mahew, the lineal descendant of the first proprietor. Here are to be found the most expert pilots, either for the great bay, their sound, Nantucket shoals, or the different ports in their neighbourhood. In stormy weather they are always at sea, looking out for vessels, which they board with singular dexterity, and hardly ever fail to bring safe to their intended harbour. Gay-Head, the western point of this island, abounds with a variety of ochres of different colours, with which the inhabitants paint their houses.
This island is twenty miles long and seven to eight miles wide. It’s nine miles from the mainland and, along with the Elizabeth Islands, makes up a part of Duke's County in Massachusetts Bay. The Elizabeth Islands, six in total, are about nine miles from Martha's Vineyard and are well-known for their excellent dairies. A good ferry connects Edgartown and Falmouth on the mainland, a distance of nine miles. Martha's Vineyard is divided into three townships: Edgartown, Chilmark, and Tisbury, with a population of around 4,000 people, 300 of whom are Native Americans. Edgartown is the best seaport and the county seat, and due to its light, sandy soil, many of its residents follow the farming practices of Nantucket. Chilmark doesn’t have a good harbor, but the land is excellent, on par with any found on the mainland, featuring great pastures, convenient streams for mills, and stone for fencing. Tisbury is notable for its high-quality timber and has a harbor deep enough for large ships. The island has about 20,000 sheep, 2,000 cattle, as well as horses and goats; there are also some deer and plenty of seabirds. From the beginning, this has been the main school for Native Americans; they live on the part of the island called Chappaquiddick and were early on Christianized by the respected Mahew family, the first owners of the island. The first settler of that name left a portion of it in his will to a favored daughter, where numerous wild vines grew; that’s how it got the name Martha's Vineyard. Over time, this name came to refer to the entire island. The descendants of the original Native Americans still reside here today on lands that their ancestors reserved for themselves, which are diligently protected from any encroachments. The people of New England are known for their integrity in honoring ancient agreements, which in many other regions have been overlooked, causing scandal in those governments. The Native Americans here appear, due to their polite manners, hard work, and cleanliness, to be entirely European and are in no way inferior to many of the residents. Like them, they are sober, hardworking, and religious, which are the main traits shared across the four New England provinces. They often go, like the young men from the Vineyard, to Nantucket to work as whalemen or fishermen, and their skill and expertise in all sea-related activities are comparable to that of the white fishermen. The latter are divided into two groups: the first farm the land, which they cultivate with remarkable care and knowledge; the second, who own no land, dedicate themselves to the sea, which is the main resource for people in this area. Hence, this island, similar to Nantucket, has become a significant training ground supplying pilots and sailors to the many coastal vessels that operate in this extensive region of America. Wherever you go, from Nova Scotia to the Mississippi, you’ll find many natives of these two islands engaged in maritime work. The climate is so favorable for growth that marriage is a goal for every man, and the blessing of companionship is so easily accessible that many have to leave their home in search of better opportunities elsewhere. The residents are all Presbyterians, which is the official religion of Massachusetts; and I must express my gratitude for the warm hospitality I received from B. Norton, Esq., the colonel of the island, as well as from Dr. Mahew, a direct descendant of the first proprietor. The most skilled pilots can be found here for navigating the bay, their sound, Nantucket shoals, or the various nearby ports. During stormy weather, they’re often at sea, watching for vessels, which they board with great skill, rarely failing to bring them safely to their intended harbor. Gay Head, the western tip of the island, is rich in a variety of colored ochres, which the residents use to paint their houses.
The vessels most proper for whale fishing are brigs of about 150 tons burthen, particularly when they are intended for distant latitudes; they always man them with thirteen hands, in order that they may row two whale-boats; the crews of which must necessarily consist of six, four at the oars, one standing on the bows with the harpoon, and the other at the helm. It is also necessary that there should be two of these boats, that if one should be destroyed in attacking the whale, the other, which is never engaged at the same time, may be ready to save the hands. Five of the thirteen are always Indians; the last of the complement remains on board to steer the vessel during the action. They have no wages; each draws a certain established share in partnership with the proprietor of the vessel; by which economy they are all proportionately concerned in the success of the enterprise, and all equally alert and vigilant. None of these whalemen ever exceed the age of forty: they look on those who are past that period not to be possessed of all that vigour and agility which so adventurous a business requires. Indeed if you attentively consider the immense disproportion between the object assailed and the assailants; if you think on the diminutive size, and weakness of their frail vehicle; if you recollect the treachery of the element on which this scene is transacted; the sudden and unforeseen accidents of winds, etc., you will readily acknowledge that it must require the most consummate exertion of all the strength, agility, and judgment, of which the bodies and minds of men are capable, to undertake these adventurous encounters.
The best ships for whaling are brigs of about 150 tons, especially for long journeys. They usually have a crew of thirteen so they can operate two whaleboats. Each boat has a crew of six: four rowing, one at the front with a harpoon, and one steering. It’s necessary to have two boats so if one gets damaged while hunting the whale, the other can rescue the crew. Out of the thirteen, five are always Indigenous people, and the remaining crew member stays on the ship to steer during the hunt. They don't earn a salary; instead, they receive a set share in partnership with the ship's owner, which makes everyone invested in the success of the mission and keeps them alert. None of the whalers are over the age of forty; those past that age are seen as lacking the energy and agility needed for such a risky job. If you consider the huge gap between the whale and the hunters, the small size and fragility of their boat, and the unpredictable nature of the sea, you'll recognize that it takes an extraordinary amount of strength, agility, and judgment from both their bodies and minds to engage in these daring challenges.
As soon as they arrive in those latitudes where they expect to meet with whales, a man is sent up to the mast head; if he sees one, he immediately cries out AWAITE PAWANA, here is a whale: they all remain still and silent until he repeats PAWANA, a whale, when in less than six minutes the two boats are launched, filled with every implement necessary for the attack. They row toward the whale with astonishing velocity; and as the Indians early became their fellow- labourers in this new warfare, you can easily conceive how the Nattick expressions became familiar on board the whale-boats. Formerly it often happened that whale vessels were manned with none but Indians and the master; recollect also that the Nantucket people understand the Nattick, and that there are always five of these people on board. There are various ways of approaching the whale, according to their peculiar species; and this previous knowledge is of the utmost consequence. When these boats are arrived at a reasonable distance, one of them rests on its oars and stands off, as a witness of the approaching engagement; near the bows of the other the harpooner stands up, and on him principally depends the success of the enterprise. He wears a jacket closely buttoned, and round his head a handkerchief tightly bound: in his hands he holds the dreadful weapon, made of the best steel, marked sometimes with the name of their town, and sometimes with that of their vessel; to the shaft of which the end of a cord of due length, coiled up with the utmost care in the middle of the boat, is firmly tied; the other end is fastened to the bottom of the boat. Thus prepared they row in profound silence, leaving the whole conduct of the enterprise to the harpooner and to the steersman, attentively following their directions. When the former judges himself to be near enough to the whale, that is, at the distance of about fifteen feet, he bids them stop; perhaps she has a calf, whose safety attracts all the attention of the dam, which is a favourable circumstance; perhaps she is of a dangerous species, and it is safest to retire, though their ardour will seldom permit them; perhaps she is asleep, in that case he balances high the harpoon, trying in this important moment to collect all the energy of which he is capable. He launches it forth—she is struck: from her first movements they judge of her temper, as well as of their future success. Sometimes in the immediate impulse of rage, she will attack the boat and demolish it with one stroke of her tail; in an instant the frail vehicle disappears and the assailants are immersed in the dreadful element. Were the whale armed with the jaws of a shark, and as voracious, they never would return home to amuse their listening wives with the interesting tale of the adventure. At other times she will dive and disappear from human sight; and everything must give way to her velocity, or else all is lost. Sometimes she will swim away as if untouched, and draw the cord with such swiftness that it will set the edge of the boat on fire by the friction. If she rises before she has run out the whole length, she is looked upon as a sure prey. The blood she has lost in her flight, weakens her so much, that if she sinks again, it is but for a short time; the boat follows her course with almost equal speed. She soon re-appears; tired at last with convulsing the element; which she tinges with her blood, she dies, and floats on the surface. At other times it may happen that she is not dangerously wounded, though she carries the harpoon fast in her body; when she will alternately dive and rise, and swim on with unabated vigour. She then soon reaches beyond the length of the cord, and carries the boat along with amazing velocity: this sudden impediment sometimes will retard her speed, at other times it only serves to rouse her anger, and to accelerate her progress. The harpooner, with the axe in his hands, stands ready. When he observes that the bows of the boat are greatly pulled down by the diving whale, and that it begins to sink deep and to take much water, he brings the axe almost in contact with the cord; he pauses, still flattering himself that she will relax; but the moment grows critical, unavoidable danger approaches: sometimes men more intent on gain, than on the preservation of their lives, will run great risks; and it is wonderful how far these people have carried their daring courage at this awful moment! But it is vain to hope, their lives must be saved, the cord is cut, the boat rises again. If after thus getting loose, she re-appears, they will attack and wound her a second time. She soon dies, and when dead she is towed alongside of their vessel, where she is fastened.
As soon as they reach the areas where they expect to find whales, a man climbs up to the mast head; if he spots one, he immediately shouts "AWAITE PAWANA, here’s a whale." Everyone else stays still and quiet until he repeats "PAWANA," a whale, at which point, in less than six minutes, the two boats are launched, equipped with all the tools needed for the hunt. They row toward the whale with incredible speed, and since the Indians quickly become their partners in this new type of hunting, it’s easy to see how the Nattick phrases became common on the whale boats. In the past, it often happened that whaling vessels were manned only by Indians and the captain; remember too that the Nantucket people understand Nattick, and there are always five of them on board. There are different methods to approach a whale, depending on its specific species, and this prior knowledge is extremely important. When the boats get close enough, one boat holds back as a lookout for the fight; near the front of the other boat, the harpooner stands, and the success of the mission primarily relies on him. He wears a tightly buttoned jacket and a handkerchief wrapped around his head; in his hands, he holds the lethal weapon, made of high-quality steel, sometimes marked with the name of their town, and other times with that of their vessel; a cord of the right length, carefully coiled in the middle of the boat, is firmly tied to the end of the weapon, and the other end is attached to the bottom of the boat. With everything ready, they row in complete silence, leaving the whole operation to the harpooner and the steersman, carefully following their commands. When the harpooner thinks he is close enough to the whale, roughly fifteen feet away, he signals them to stop; maybe she has a calf, which draws all the mother’s attention, creating a favorable situation; perhaps she belongs to a dangerous species, making it safer to retreat, although their eagerness usually doesn’t allow for that; or she might be sleeping, which means he raises the harpoon, trying to gather all his strength for this critical moment. He throws it—she is hit: from her initial movements, they gauge her temperament and their chances of success. Sometimes, in a furious reaction, she will attack the boat and smash it with one swipe of her tail; in an instant, the fragile vessel vanishes, leaving the attackers immersed in the terrifying sea. If the whale had the jaws of a shark and was just as hungry, they would never make it back home to entertain their wives with tales of the adventure. Other times, she will dive and disappear from view; everything must yield to her speed, or they risk losing everything. Sometimes she swims away as if untouched and pulls the cord with such force that it ignites due to the friction. If she surfaces before the entire length of the cord has been used, she is considered easy prey. The blood she loses while fleeing weakens her so much that if she sinks again, it will only be for a short while; the boat follows her almost as fast. She soon reappears; finally tired from thrashing in the water, she tinges it with her blood, and then she dies, floating on the surface. At other times, she may not be fatally wounded, even though she carries the harpoon embedded in her body; she will alternate between diving and surfacing, swimming vigorously. Soon, she reaches beyond the length of the cord, pulling the boat along with astonishing speed: this sudden yank sometimes slows her down, and other times, it only stirs her anger and quickens her pace. The harpooner, axe in hand, is on high alert. When he sees that the bow of the boat is heavily pulled down by the diving whale, beginning to sink and taking on water, he brings the axe close to the cord; he hesitates, still hoping she might ease up; but the moment grows tense, and unavoidable danger approaches: sometimes men, more focused on profit than their own safety, take huge risks; it's remarkable how far these people go in their daring at this critical moment! But it's futile to hope; their lives must be protected, the cord is cut, and the boat rises again. If she reappears after getting loose, they will attack and wound her a second time. She soon dies, and when she does, she is towed alongside their vessel, where she is secured.
The next operation is to cut with axes and spades, every part of her body which yields oil; the kettles are set a boiling, they fill their barrels as fast as it is made; but as this operation is much slower than that of cutting up, they fill the hold of their ship with those fragments, lest a storm should arise and oblige them to abandon their prize. It is astonishing what a quantity of oil some of these fish will yield, and what profit it affords to those who are fortunate enough to overtake them.
The next step is to chop with axes and shovels every part of her body that produces oil; the kettles are heated up, and they fill their barrels as quickly as it's created. However, since this process is much slower than cutting them up, they pack the hold of their ship with those pieces, so that if a storm comes up, they won’t have to leave their catch behind. It's amazing how much oil some of these fish can produce and what kind of profit it brings to those lucky enough to catch them.
The river St. Lawrence whale, which is the only one I am well acquainted with, is seventy-five feet long, sixteen deep, twelve in the length of its bone, which commonly weighs 3000 lbs., twenty in the breadth of their tails and produces 180 barrels of oil: I once saw 16 boiled out of the tongue only. After having once vanquished this leviathan, there are two enemies to be dreaded beside the wind; the first of which is the shark: that fierce voracious fish, to which nature has given such dreadful offensive weapons, often comes alongside, and in spite of the people's endeavours, will share with them their prey; at night particularly. They are very mischievious, but the second enemy is much more terrible and irresistible; it is the killer, sometimes called the thrasher, a species of whales about thirty feet long. They are possessed of such a degree of agility and fierceness, as often to attack the largest spermaceti whales, and not seldom to rob the fishermen of their prey; nor is there any means of defence against so potent an adversary. When all their barrels are full, for everything is done at sea, or when their limited time is expired and their stores almost expended, they return home, freighted with their valuable cargo; unless they have put it on board a vessel for the European market. Such are, as briefly as I can relate them, the different branches of the economy practised by these bold navigators, and the method with which they go such distances from their island to catch this huge game.
The St. Lawrence whale, which I know best, is seventy-five feet long, sixteen feet deep, and has a twelve-foot-long bone that usually weighs about 3,000 pounds. Its tail measures twenty feet across and it can produce 180 barrels of oil; I once saw 16 barrels just from the tongue alone. After overcoming this giant, there are two other threats to fear besides the wind; the first is the shark. This fierce, ravenous fish, equipped with some terrifying weapons, often comes alongside and, despite the crew's efforts, will take some of their catch, especially at night. They can be quite troublesome, but the second enemy is far more dangerous and unstoppable: the killer whale, also known as the thrasher, which is about thirty feet long. These whales are incredibly agile and aggressive, frequently attacking even the largest sperm whales and often stealing the fishermen's catch, leaving no way to defend against such a powerful foe. When their barrels are full—since everything is done at sea—or when their time is running out and their supplies are nearly gone, they head back home loaded with their valuable haul, unless they’ve transferred it to a ship bound for the European market. This is, as briefly as I can put it, the different aspects of the economy practiced by these daring navigators and how they travel such long distances from their island to hunt this massive game.
The following are the names and principal characteristics of the various species of whales known to these people:
The following are the names and main features of the different species of whales recognized by these people:
The St. Lawrence whale, just described.
The St. Lawrence whale, as mentioned earlier.
The disko, or Greenland ditto.
The disco, or Greenland version.
The right whale, or seven feet bone, common on the coasts of this country, about sixty feet long. The spermaceti whale, found all over the world, and of all sizes; the longest are sixty feet, and yield about 100 barrels of oil.
The right whale, also known as the seven-foot bone, is commonly found along the coasts of this country and measures around sixty feet in length. The spermaceti whale is present worldwide and comes in various sizes; the largest can reach sixty feet and produce about 100 barrels of oil.
The hump-backs, on the coast of Newfoundland, from forty to seventy feet in length.
The humpbacks along the coast of Newfoundland range from forty to seventy feet long.
The finn-back, an American whale, never killed, as being too swift.
The finback, an American whale, was never hunted because it's too fast.
The sulphur-bottom, river St. Lawrence, ninety foot long; they are but seldom killed, as being extremely swift.
The sulphur-bottom, St. Lawrence River, ninety feet long; they are rarely caught, as they are extremely fast.
The grampus, thirty feet long, never killed on the same account.
The grampus, measuring thirty feet long, never took a life for that reason.
The killer or thrasher, about thirty feet; they often kill the other whales with which they are at perpetual war.
The killer whale, or orca, is about thirty feet long; they frequently kill the other whales they are constantly battling with.
The black fish whale, twenty feet, yields from eight to ten barrels.
The black fish whale, twenty feet long, produces between eight and ten barrels.
The porpoise, weighing about 160 lb.
The porpoise, weighing around 160 lbs.
In 1769 they fitted out 125 whalemen; the first fifty that returned brought with them 11,000 barrels of oil. In 1770 they fitted out 135 vessels for the fisheries, at thirteen hands each; four West- Indiamen, twelve hands; twenty-five wood vessels, four hands; eighteen coasters, five hands; fifteen London traders, eleven hands. All these amount to 2158 hands, employed in 197 vessels. Trace their progressive steps between the possession of a few whale-boats, and that of such a fleet!
In 1769, they sent out 125 whalemen; the first fifty who returned brought back 11,000 barrels of oil. In 1770, they outfitted 135 ships for fishing, each with thirteen crew members; four West-Indiamen with twelve crew members each; twenty-five wooden vessels with four crew members each; eighteen coasters with five crew members each; and fifteen London traders with eleven crew members each. In total, that amounts to 2,158 people working on 197 vessels. Look at how far they progressed from just a few whale-boats to commanding such a fleet!
The moral conduct, prejudices, and customs of a people who live two- thirds of their time at sea, must naturally be very different from those of their neighbours, who live by cultivating the earth. That long abstemiousness to which the former are exposed, the breathing of saline air, the frequent repetitions of danger, the boldness acquired in surmounting them, the very impulse of the winds, to which they are exposed; all these, one would imagine must lead them, when on shore, to no small desire of inebriation, and a more eager pursuit of those pleasures, of which they have been so long deprived, and which they must soon forego. There are many appetites that may be gratified on shore, even by the poorest man, but which must remain unsatisfied at sea. Yet notwithstanding the powerful effects of all these causes, I observed here, at the return of their fleets, no material irregularities; no tumultuous drinking assemblies: whereas in our continental towns, the thoughtless seaman indulges himself in the coarsest pleasures; and vainly thinking that a week of debauchery can compensate for months of abstinence, foolishly lavishes in a few days of intoxication, the fruits of half a year's labour. On the contrary all was peace here, and a general decency prevailed throughout; the reason I believe is, that almost everybody here is married, for they get wives very young; and the pleasure of returning to their families absorbs every other desire. The motives that lead them to the sea, are very different from those of most other sea-faring men; it is neither idleness nor profligacy that sends them to that element; it is a settled plan of life, a well founded hope of earning a livelihood; it is because their soil is bad, that they are early initiated to this profession, and were they to stay at home, what could they do? The sea therefore becomes to them a kind of patrimony; they go to whaling with as much pleasure and tranquil indifference, with as strong an expectation of success, as a landsman undertakes to clear a piece of swamp. The first is obliged to advance his time, and labour, to procure oil on the surface of the sea; the second advances the same to procure himself grass from grounds that produced nothing before but hassocks and bogs. Among those who do not use the sea, I observed the same calm appearance as among the inhabitants on the continent; here I found, without gloom, a decorum and reserve, so natural to them, that I thought myself in Philadelphia. At my landing I was cordially received by those to whom I was recommended, and treated with unaffected hospitality by such others with whom I became acquainted; and I can tell you, that it is impossible for any traveller to dwell here one month without knowing the heads of the principal families. Wherever I went I found a simplicity of diction and manners, rather more primitive and rigid than I expected; and I soon perceived that it proceeded from their secluded situation, which has prevented them from mixing with others. It is therefore easy to conceive how they have retained every degree of peculiarity for which this sect was formerly distinguished. Never was a bee-hive more faithfully employed in gathering wax, bee-bread, and honey, from all the neighbouring fields, than are the members of this society; every one in the town follows some particular occupation with great diligence, but without that servility of labour which I am informed prevails in Europe. The mechanic seemed to be descended from as good parentage, was as well dressed and fed, and held in as much estimation as those who employed him; they were once nearly related; their different degrees of prosperity is what has caused the various shades of their community. But this accidental difference has introduced, as yet, neither arrogance nor pride on the one part, nor meanness and servility on the other. All their houses are neat, convenient, and comfortable; some of them are filled with two families, for when the husbands are at sea, the wives require less house-room. They all abound with the most substantial furniture, more valuable from its usefulness than from any ornamental appearance. Wherever I went, I found good cheer, a welcome reception; and after the second visit I felt myself as much at my ease as if I had been an old acquaintance of the family. They had as great plenty of everything as if their island had been part of the golden quarter of Virginia (a valuable track of land on Cape Charles): I could hardly persuade myself that I had quitted the adjacent continent, where everything abounds, and that I was on a barren sand-bank, fertilised with whale oil only. As their rural improvements are but trifling, and only of the useful kind, and as the best of them are at a considerable distance from the town, I amused myself for several days in conversing with the most intelligent of the inhabitants of both sexes, and making myself acquainted with the various branches of their industry; the different objects of their trade; the nature of that sagacity which, deprived as they are of every necessary material, produce, etc., yet enables them to flourish, to live well, and sometimes to make considerable fortunes. The whole is an enigma to be solved only by coming to the spot and observing the national genius which the original founders brought with them, as well as their unwearied patience and perseverance. They have all, from the highest to the lowest, a singular keenness of judgment, unassisted by any academical light; they all possess a large share of good sense, improved upon the experience of their fathers; and this is the surest and best guide to lead us through the path of life, because it approaches nearest to the infallibility of instinct. Shining talents and University knowledge, would be entirely useless here, nay, would be dangerous; it would pervert their plain judgment, it would lead them out of that useful path which is so well adapted to their situation; it would make them more adventurous, more presumptuous, much less cautious, and therefore less successful. It is pleasing to hear some of them tracing a father's progress and their own, through the different vicissitudes of good and adverse fortune. I have often, by their fire-sides, travelled with them the whole length of their career, from their earliest steps, from their first commercial adventure, from the possession of a single whale- boat, up to that of a dozen large vessels! This does not imply, however, that every one who began with a whale-boat, has ascended to a like pitch of fortune; by no means, the same casualty, the same combination of good and evil which attends human affairs in every other part of the globe, prevails here: a great prosperity is not the lot of every man, but there are many and various gradations; if they all do not attain riches, they all attain an easy subsistence. After all, is it not better to be possessed of a single whale-boat, or a few sheep pastures; to live free and independent under the mildest governments, in a healthy climate, in a land of charity and benevolence; than to be wretched as so many are in Europe, possessing nothing but their industry: tossed from one rough wave to another; engaged either in the most servile labours for the smallest pittance, or fettered with the links of the most irksome dependence, even without the hopes of rising?
The morals, biases, and customs of a people who spend most of their time at sea are bound to be quite different from those of their neighbors who make a living from farming. That long period of abstinence they endure, the salty air they breathe, the frequent dangers they face, the boldness they gain from overcoming them, and even the push of the winds—they must all contribute to a strong desire for indulgence when they are on land, as well as a more intense craving for the pleasures they’ve missed and will soon have to give up. There are many cravings that even the poorest person can satisfy on land, which remain unfulfilled at sea. However, despite the powerful influences behind all this, I noticed that upon their fleets' return, there were no significant disruptions; no wild drinking parties. Meanwhile, in our continental towns, the reckless sailor indulges in the crassest pleasures, mistakenly thinking that a week of debauchery can make up for months of restraint, squandering in just a few days the fruits of half a year's work. In contrast, here everything was calm, and a general sense of decency prevailed. I believe this is because nearly everyone here is married, having taken wives at a young age, and the joy of returning to their families consumes all other desires. Their reasons for going to sea differ greatly from those of most other sailors; it’s not idleness or recklessness that drives them to the ocean, but rather a deliberate life choice, with a solid hope of making a living. They are introduced to this vocation early because their land is not fertile, and if they stayed home, what could they possibly do? The sea becomes a sort of inheritance for them; they approach whaling with as much enjoyment and calm expectation of success as a farmer does when trying to clear a swamp. The first must invest time and effort to gather oil from the ocean surface, while the second invests similarly to grow grass in previously unproductive marshland. Among those who do not go to sea, I noticed just as tranquil a demeanor as among the people on the continent; here, I found a natural decorum and reservation, so characteristic of them, that I felt as if I were in Philadelphia. Upon my arrival, I was warmly welcomed by those I was introduced to, treated with genuine hospitality by others I met; I can assure you that it’s impossible for any traveler to stay here for a month without knowing the leaders of the main families. Wherever I went, I encountered a simplicity in language and behavior that was more primitive and strict than I expected, which I soon realized came from their isolated situation that kept them from mingling with others. It’s easy to see how they’ve maintained the unique traits that once distinguished this group. Never was a beehive more diligently busy gathering wax, pollen, and honey from the surrounding fields than these community members are; each person in town pursues a specific trade with great dedication, but without the servility often seen in Europe. The craftsmen seem to come from respectable backgrounds, are well-dressed and well-fed, and are held in as much regard as those who hire them; they were once nearly equals; their differing levels of success have led to the various tiers in their community. But this accidental divide has not yet introduced either arrogance or pride on one side, nor meanness or servility on the other. Their homes are neat, practical, and cozy; some accommodate two families since when the husbands are at sea, the wives require less space. They all have substantial furniture, valued more for its practicality than for its decorative appeal. Everywhere I went, I was greeted with warm hospitality, and after my second visit, I felt as comfortable as if I had been part of the family for years. They had as much of everything as if their island were part of the prosperous regions of Virginia; I could hardly believe I had left the nearby continent, where everything is abundant, and that I was instead on a barren stretch of sand, nourished only by whale oil. Since their agricultural advancements are minimal and mainly practical, and since the best of them are quite far from the town, I spent several days conversing with the most knowledgeable locals of both genders and learning about the different branches of their trade; the various focus areas of their commerce; and the nature of their resourcefulness, which allows them to thrive despite the scarcity of necessary materials and goods. This phenomenon can only be understood by visiting the place and observing the national character that the original settlers brought with them, along with their unwavering patience and determination. From the highest to the lowest, they all share a unique sharpness of judgment, lacking any academic training; they all have a good measure of common sense honed from the experience of their ancestors, which is the most reliable guide through life, coming closest to the certainty of instinct. Exceptional talents and academic knowledge would be of no use here, indeed they could be a hindrance; they might cloud their straightforward judgment and divert them from the practical path that suits their circumstances; they could make them more daring, overconfident, and far less cautious, leading to less success. It’s enjoyable to hear some of them recount their father's journeys and their own, through the ups and downs of fortune. I have often shared evenings by their firesides, tracing the entirety of their journey from the very beginning—through their first business venture, starting with a single whale boat, up to owning a dozen large vessels! This does not suggest that everyone who began with a whale boat has reached similar levels of success; far from it. The same randomness and mix of good and bad fortunes that exist in every other part of the world occur here too: hitting it big is not everyone’s fate, but there are many layers of success; while not all achieve wealth, all can attain a comfortable living. After all, wouldn’t it be better to own just a single whale boat or a few sheep pastures; to live freely and independently under a gentle government, in a healthy climate, in a land filled with kindness and goodwill; than to be miserable like so many in Europe, possessing nothing but their toil; tossed from one hardship to another; engaged in the most menial work for the smallest reward, or chained by the most oppressive reliance, with no hopes of improvement?
The majority of those inferior hands which are employed in this fishery, many of the mechanics, such as coopers, smiths, caulkers, carpenters, etc., who do not belong to the society of Friends, are Presbyterians, and originally came from the main. Those who are possessed of the greatest fortunes at present belong to the former; but they all began as simple whalemen: it is even looked upon as honourable and necessary for the son of the wealthiest man to serve an apprenticeship to the same bold, adventurous business which has enriched his father; they go several voyages, and these early excursions never fail to harden their constitutions, and introduce them to the knowledge of their future means of subsistence.
The majority of the less skilled workers in this fishery, including many tradespeople like coopers, blacksmiths, caulkers, carpenters, etc., who are not part of the Quaker community, are Presbyterians and originally came from the mainland. Those with the most wealth today belong to the former group; however, they all started out as simple whalers. It’s even considered honorable and necessary for the son of the richest man to apprentice in the same bold and adventurous business that has made his father rich. They embark on several voyages, and these early trips always help strengthen their bodies and introduce them to the knowledge they will need for their future livelihoods.
LETTER VII
MANNERS AND CUSTOMS AT NANTUCKET
As I observed before, every man takes a wife as soon as he chooses, and that is generally very early; no portion is required, none is expected; no marriage articles are drawn up among us, by skilful lawyers, to puzzle and lead posterity to the bar, or to satisfy the pride of the parties. We give nothing with our daughters, their education, their health, and the customary out-set, are all that the fathers of numerous families can afford: as the wife's fortune consists principally in her future economy, modesty, and skilful management; so the husband's is founded on his abilities to labour, on his health, and the knowledge of some trade or business. Their mutual endeavours, after a few years of constant application, seldom fail of success, and of bringing them the means to rear and support the new race which accompanies the nuptial bed. Those children born by the sea-side, hear the roaring of its waves as soon as they are able to listen; it is the first noise with which they become acquainted, and by early plunging in it they acquire that boldness, that presence of mind, and dexterity, which makes them ever after such expert seamen. They often hear their fathers recount the adventures of their youth, their combats with the whales; and these recitals imprint on their opening minds an early curiosity and taste for the same life. They often cross the sea to go to the main, and learn even in those short voyages how to qualify themselves for longer and more dangerous ones; they are therefore deservedly conspicuous for their maritime knowledge and experience, all over the continent. A man born here is distinguishable by his gait from among an hundred other men, so remarkable are they for a pliability of sinews, and a peculiar agility, which attends them even to old age. I have heard some persons attribute this to the effects of the whale oil, with which they are so copiously anointed in the various operations it must undergo ere it is fit either for the European market or the candle manufactory.
As I've mentioned before, every man gets married as soon as he decides to, and that usually happens pretty early. No dowry is needed or expected; we don’t have marriage contracts drawn up by fancy lawyers to complicate things for future generations or to fulfill anyone's ego. We don’t give anything with our daughters; their education, health, and standard starting expenses are all that many fathers can provide. The wife’s wealth mainly comes from her future ability to manage a household, her modesty, and her skills; the husband’s value is based on his ability to work, his health, and his knowledge of a trade or business. After a few years of hard work together, they usually succeed in making enough to raise and support their children that come with marriage. Kids born by the seaside hear the crashing waves as soon as they're able to listen; it’s the first sound they recognize, and once they dive into the water early on, they gain the courage, quick thinking, and skills that make them great sailors later on. They often hear their dads share stories about their youthful adventures and battles with whales, which sparks in the kids a curiosity and interest in that same lifestyle. They frequently sail across the sea to the mainland and even in those short trips, they learn how to prepare for longer, riskier journeys, so they are rightfully known for their maritime knowledge and experience throughout the continent. A person born here stands out in a crowd because of the way they walk; they exhibit a flexibility and unique agility that lasts even into old age. I’ve heard some people say this is due to the effects of the whale oil they use so generously during the various processes it goes through before it’s ready for the European market or for candle making.
But you may perhaps be solicitous to ask, what becomes of that exuberancy of population which must arise from so much temperance, from healthiness of climate, and from early marriage? You may justly conclude that their native island and town can contain but a limited number. Emigration is both natural and easy to a maritime people, and that is the very reason why they are always populous, problematical as it may appear. They yearly go to different parts of this continent, constantly engaged in sea affairs; as our internal riches increase, so does our external trade, which consequently requires more ships and more men: sometimes they have emigrated like bees, in regular and connected swarms. Some of the Friends (by which word I always mean the people called Quakers) fond of a contemplative life, yearly visit the several congregations which this society has formed throughout the continent. By their means a sort of correspondence is kept up among them all; they are generally good preachers, friendly censors, checking vice wherever they find it predominating; preventing relaxations in any parts of their ancient customs and worship. They everywhere carry admonition and useful advice; and by thus travelling they unavoidably gather the most necessary observations concerning the various situations of particular districts, their soils, their produce, their distance from navigable rivers, the price of land, etc. In consequence of informations of this kind, received at Nantucket in the year 1766, a considerable number of them purchased a large track of land in the county of Orange, in North Carolina, situated on the several spring heads of Deep River, which is the western branch of Cape Fear, or North-West River. The advantage of being able to convey themselves by sea, to within forty miles of the spot, the richness of the soil, etc., made them cheerfully quit an island on which there was no longer any room for them. There they have founded a beautiful settlement, known by the name of New Garden, contiguous to the famous one which the Moravians have at Bethabara, Bethamia, and Salem, on Yadkin River. No spot of earth can be more beautiful; it is composed of gentle hills, of easy declivities, excellent low lands, accompanied by different brooks which traverse this settlement. I never saw a soil that rewards men so early for their labours and disbursements; such in general with very few exceptions, are the lands which adjoin the innumerable heads of all the large rivers which fall into the Chesapeak, or flow through the provinces of North and South Carolina, Georgia, etc. It is perhaps the most pleasing, the most bewitching country which the continent affords; because while it preserves an easy communication with the sea-port towns, at some seasons of the year, it is perfectly free from the contagious air often breathed in those flat countries, which are more contiguous to the Atlantic. These lands are as rich as those over the Alleghany; the people of New Garden are situated at the distance of between 200 and 300 miles from Cape Fear; Cape Fear is at least 450 from Nantucket: you may judge therefore that they have but little correspondence with this their little metropolis, except it is by means of the itinerant Friends. Others have settled on the famous river Kennebeck, in that territory of the province of Massachusetts, which is known by the name of Sagadahock. Here they have softened the labours of clearing the heaviest timbered land in America, by means of several branches of trade which their fair river, and proximity to the sea affords them. Instead of entirely consuming their timber, as we are obliged to do, some parts of it are converted into useful articles for exportation, such as staves, scantlings, boards, hoops, poles, etc. For that purpose they keep a correspondence with their native island, and I know many of the principal inhabitants of Sherburn, who, though merchants, and living at Nantucket, yet possess valuable farms on that river; from whence they draw great part of their subsistence, meat, grain, fire-wood, etc. The title of these lands is vested in the ancient Plymouth Company, under the powers of which the Massachusetts was settled; and that company which resides in Boston, are still the granters of all the vacant lands within their limits.
But you might be curious to ask, what happens to the booming population that must come from such moderation, a healthy climate, and early marriage? You can rightly conclude that their native island and town can only hold a limited number of people. Emigration is both natural and easy for a maritime people, which is why they always remain numerous, even if it may seem questionable. Every year, they head to different parts of this continent, constantly involved in sea-related businesses; as our domestic wealth grows, so does our international trade, which in turn requires more ships and more workers: sometimes they have emigrated like bees, in organized and connected swarms. Some of the Friends (by which I always mean the people known as Quakers), who enjoy a reflective life, visit various congregations that this community has established throughout the continent each year. Through these visits, they maintain a sort of communication among themselves; they are generally good speakers and friendly critics, discouraging vice wherever they see it flourish; preventing any relaxations in their traditional customs and worship. They carry warnings and useful advice wherever they go; and by traveling in this way, they inevitably gather essential observations about the different conditions of particular areas, their soils, their yields, their distances from navigable rivers, land prices, etc. Because of information like this, received at Nantucket in the year 1766, a significant number of them bought a large piece of land in Orange County, North Carolina, located at the various spring heads of Deep River, which is the western branch of Cape Fear, or North-West River. The ability to travel by sea, coming within forty miles of the location, the richness of the soil, etc., prompted them to gladly leave an island where there was no longer enough room for them. There, they established a lovely settlement known as New Garden, next to the well-known Moravian community at Bethabara, Bethamia, and Salem, on Yadkin River. No place on earth could be more beautiful; it consists of gentle hills, easy slopes, excellent lowlands, and various streams that flow through this settlement. I've never seen land that rewards people's efforts and investments so quickly; generally, with very few exceptions, such are the lands that border the countless sources of all the large rivers that flow into Chesapeake or run through the provinces of North and South Carolina, Georgia, and so on. It might be the most attractive, enchanting area on the continent; because while it maintains easy access to coastal towns, in certain seasons, it is completely free from the unhealthy air often found in those flat regions closer to the Atlantic. These lands are as fertile as those over the Alleghenies; the people of New Garden are located between 200 and 300 miles from Cape Fear; Cape Fear is at least 450 miles from Nantucket: you can tell that they have little connection with their small capital, except through the traveling Friends. Others have settled along the famous Kennebec River, in that part of the Massachusetts Province known as Sagadahock. Here, they have made clearing America's most heavily forested land easier by engaging in several trades that their beautiful river and proximity to the sea provide. Instead of completely using up their timber, as we often have to do, some portions are turned into useful goods for export, such as staves, scantlings, boards, hoops, poles, etc. For that reason, they maintain contact with their home island, and I know many of the leading residents of Sherburn, who, although they are merchants living in Nantucket, own valuable farms on that river; from these farms, they derive a significant part of their food supply, meat, grain, firewood, and so on. The ownership of these lands lies with the ancient Plymouth Company, under whose authority Massachusetts was settled; and that company, based in Boston, still grants all the vacant lands within their jurisdiction.
Although this part of the province is so fruitful, and so happily situated, yet it has been singularly overlooked and neglected: it is surprising that the excellence of that soil which lies on the river should not have caused it to be filled before now with inhabitants; for the settlements from thence to Penobscot are as yet but in their infancy. It is true that immense labour is required to make room for the plough, but the peculiar strength and quality of the soil never fails most amply to reward the industrious possessor; I know of no soil in this country more rich or more fertile. I do not mean that sort of transitory fertility which evaporates with the sun, and disappears in a few years; here on the contrary, even their highest grounds are covered with a rich moist swamp mould, which bears the most luxuriant grass, and never-failing crops of grain.
Even though this part of the province is extremely fertile and well-located, it has strangely been overlooked and neglected. It's surprising that the quality of the soil along the river hasn’t led to it being populated by now; the settlements from there to Penobscot are still in their early stages. True, it takes a lot of effort to clear land for farming, but the unique strength and quality of the soil always reward the hardworking owner handsomely. I don’t know of any soil in this country that is richer or more fertile. I’m not talking about that temporary fertility that fades away with time; here, even the highest areas are covered with rich, moist soil that produces lush grass and consistent grain crops.
If New Gardens exceeds this settlement by the softness of its climate, the fecundity of its soil, and a greater variety of produce from less labour; it does not breed men equally hardy, nor capable to encounter dangers and fatigues. It leads too much to idleness and effeminacy; for great is the luxuriance of that part of America, and the ease with which the earth is cultivated. Were I to begin life again, I would prefer the country of Kennebeck to the other, however bewitching; the navigation of the river for above 200 miles, the great abundance of fish it contains, the constant healthiness of the climate, the happy severities of the winters always sheltering the earth with a voluminous coat of snow, the equally happy necessity of labour: all these reasons would greatly preponderate against the softer situations of Carolina; where mankind reap too much, do not toil enough, and are liable to enjoy too fast the benefits of life. There are many I know who would despise my opinion, and think me a bad judge; let those go and settle at the Ohio, the Monongahela, Red Stone Creek, etc., let them go and inhabit the extended shores of that superlative river; I with equal cheerfulness would pitch my tent on the rougher shores of Kennebeck; this will always be a country of health, labour, and strong activity, and those are characteristics of society which I value more than greater opulence and voluptuous ease.
If New Gardens offers a better climate, fertile soil, and a wider variety of crops with less effort, it doesn’t produce people who are just as strong or able to handle dangers and hard work. It encourages too much laziness and softness, as that part of America is incredibly lush, and the land is easy to farm. If I were to start over, I would choose the Kennebeck region over others, no matter how appealing they may be. The river runs over 200 miles, it’s full of fish, the climate is always healthy, and the harsh winters keep the ground covered in a thick layer of snow. Plus, there’s a necessary amount of work to be done. All these reasons make the hardier environment of Kennebeck much more appealing than the easier conditions of Carolina, where people reap too many benefits without laboring enough and enjoy life’s pleasures too quickly. I know many would scoff at my views and think I’m a poor judge. Let them go settle near the Ohio, the Monongahela, or Red Stone Creek, or inhabit the vast shores of that impressive river; I’d be just as happy to set up my camp on the rugged banks of Kennebeck. This place will always be about health, hard work, and vigorous action, which are qualities I value more than wealth and indulgent comfort.
Thus though this fruitful hive constantly sends out swarms, as industrious as themselves, yet it always remains full without having any useless drones: on the contrary it exhibits constant scenes of business and new schemes; the richer an individual grows, the more extensive his field of action becomes; he that is near ending his career, drudges on as well as he who has just begun it; nobody stands still. But is it not strange, that after having accumulated riches, they should never wish to exchange their barren situation for a more sheltered, more pleasant one on the main? Is it not strange, that after having spent the morning and the meridian of their days amidst the jarring waves, weary with the toils of a laborious life, they should not wish to enjoy the evenings of those days of industry in a larger society, on some spots of terra firma, where the severity of the winters is balanced by a variety of more pleasing scenes, not to be found here? But the same magical power of habit and custom which makes the Laplander, the Siberian, the Hottentot, prefer their climates, their occupations, and their soil, to more beneficial situations, leads these good people to think, that no other spot on the globe is so analagous to their inclinations as Nantucket. Here their connections are formed; what would they do at a distance removed from them? Live sumptuously, you will say, procure themselves new friends, new acquaintances, by their splendid tables, by their ostentatious generosity, and by affected hospitality. These are thoughts that have never entered into their heads; they would be filled with horror at the thought of forming wishes and plans so different from that simplicity, which is their general standard in affluence as well as in poverty. They abhor the very idea of expending in useless waste and vain luxuries, the fruits of prosperous labour; they are employed in establishing their sons and in many other useful purposes: strangers to the honours of monarchy they do not aspire to the possession of affluent fortunes, with which to purchase sounding titles, and frivolous names!
Though this busy hive constantly sends out swarms just as hardworking as itself, it always stays full without any useless drones. Instead, it showcases constant activity and new ideas. The wealthier someone gets, the broader their opportunities become; those nearing the end of their journey toil just as hard as those who are just starting out; no one is idle. But isn’t it strange that after accumulating wealth, they never want to trade their barren situation for a more comfortable and enjoyable one on the mainland? Isn’t it odd that after spending their mornings and the prime of their lives amidst turbulent waves, exhausted from their hard work, they don’t wish to enjoy the evenings of their industrious days in a larger community, on some solid ground where the harsh winters are balanced by a variety of more pleasant scenes not found here? Yet, the same powerful influence of habit and custom that makes the Laplander, the Siberian, and the Hottentot prefer their climates, jobs, and landscapes to more advantageous situations leads these folks to believe that no other place on the planet is as aligned with their preferences as Nantucket. Here they’ve built their connections; what would they do far away from them? You might say they would live lavishly, find new friends and acquaintances through their fancy dinners, flashy generosity, and forced hospitality. These thoughts have never crossed their minds; the idea of making wishes and plans so different from their simple lifestyle, which is their standard in both wealth and poverty, would horrify them. They despise the very thought of wasting the fruits of their hard work on pointless extravagance and vain luxuries; instead, they focus on establishing their children and pursuing many other meaningful goals. Unfamiliar with the honors of monarchy, they have no desire for wealthy fortunes to buy prestigious titles and trivial names!
Yet there are not at Nantucket so many wealthy people as one would imagine after having considered their great successes, their industry, and their knowledge. Many die poor, though hardly able to reproach Fortune with a frown; others leave not behind them that affluence which the circle of their business and of their prosperity naturally promised. The reason of this is, I believe, the peculiar expense necessarily attending their tables; for as their island supplies the town with little or nothing (a few families excepted) every one must procure what they want from the main. The very hay their horses consume, and every other article necessary to support a family, though cheap in a country of so great abundance as Massachusetts; yet the necessary waste and expenses attending their transport, render these commodities dear. A vast number of little vessels from the main, and from the Vineyard, are constantly resorting here, as to a market. Sherburn is extremely well supplied with everything, but this very constancy of supply, necessarily drains off a great deal of money. The first use they make of their oil and bone is to exchange it for bread and meat, and whatever else they want; the necessities of a large family are very great and numerous, let its economy be what it will; they are so often repeated, that they perpetually draw off a considerable branch of the profits. If by any accidents those profits are interrupted, the capital must suffer; and it very often happens that the greatest part of their property is floating on the sea.
Yet there aren't as many wealthy people in Nantucket as you might think after looking at their successes, hard work, and knowledge. Many die poor, even though they can hardly blame Fortune for that; others don't leave behind the wealth that their business and prosperity seemed to promise. I believe this is due to the unique costs that come with their lifestyles; since the island provides little to the town (with a few exceptions), everyone has to get what they need from the mainland. Even the hay for their horses and everything else needed to support a family, while cheap in a state as abundant as Massachusetts, becomes expensive because of the necessary waste and transport costs. A large number of small vessels from the mainland and the Vineyard are always coming here to trade. Sherburn is well-stocked with everything, but this constant supply drains a lot of money. The first thing they do with their oil and bone is trade it for bread, meat, and whatever else they need; the demands of a large family are significant and numerous, regardless of how they manage their expenses. These needs occur so often that they continuously take a large portion of the profits. If anything interrupts those profits, the capital takes a hit; and it often happens that most of their assets are tied up at sea.
There are but two congregations in this town. They assemble every Sunday in meeting houses, as simple as the dwelling of the people; and there is but one priest on the whole island. What would a good Portuguese observe?—But one single priest to instruct a whole island, and to direct their consciences! It is even so; each individual knows how to guide his own, and is content to do it, as well as he can. This lonely clergyman is a Presbyterian minister, who has a very large and respectable congregation; the other is composed of Quakers, who you know admit of no particular person, who in consequence of being ordained becomes exclusively entitled to preach, to catechise, and to receive certain salaries for his trouble. Among them, every one may expound the Scriptures, who thinks he is called so to do; beside, as they admit of neither sacrament, baptism, nor any other outward forms whatever, such a man would be useless. Most of these people are continually at sea, and have often the most urgent reasons to worship the Parent of Nature in the midst of the storms which they encounter. These two sects live in perfect peace and harmony with each other; those ancient times of religious discords are now gone (I hope never to return) when each thought it meritorious, not only to damn the other, which would have been nothing, but to persecute and murther one another, for the glory of that Being, who requires no more of us, than that we should love one another and live! Every one goes to that place of worship which he likes best, and thinks not that his neighbour does wrong by not following him; each busily employed in their temporal affairs, is less vehement about spiritual ones, and fortunately you will find at Nantucket neither idle drones, voluptuous devotees, ranting enthusiasts, nor sour demagogues. I wish I had it in my power to send the most persecuting bigot I could find in——to the whale fisheries; in less than three or four years you would find him a much more tractable man, and therefore a better Christian.
There are only two congregations in this town. They gather every Sunday in meeting houses, as simple as the homes of the people; and there’s just one priest on the whole island. What would a good Portuguese think?—Just one priest to guide an entire island and shape their consciences! It’s true; each person knows how to manage their own and is happy to do it as best as they can. This solitary clergyman is a Presbyterian minister with a large and respected congregation; the other group consists of Quakers, who, as you know, don’t have anyone who’s exclusively entitled to preach, teach, or receive certain salaries just for being ordained. Among them, anyone who feels called can explain the Scriptures; besides, since they don’t recognize sacraments, baptism, or any other outward rituals, such a person would be unnecessary. Most of these people are often at sea and have strong reasons to worship the Creator of Nature in the midst of the storms they face. These two sects live in perfect peace and harmony with each other; the old days of religious discord are gone (I hope never to return) when each thought it was virtuous not just to condemn the other, which wouldn’t have been anything, but to persecute and kill each other for the glory of that Being who asks nothing more of us than to love one another and live! Everyone goes to the place of worship they prefer and doesn’t think their neighbor is wrong for not following them; each is busy with their daily tasks and is less intense about spiritual matters, and fortunately at Nantucket, you won’t find idle drones, indulgent devotees, loud enthusiasts, or sour politicians. I wish I could send the most persecuting bigot I could find in— to the whale fisheries; in just three or four years, you’d find him a much more agreeable person, and therefore a better Christian.
Singular as it may appear to you, there are but two medical professors on the island; for of what service can physic be in a primitive society, where the excesses of inebriation are so rare? What need of galenical medicines, where fevers, and stomachs loaded by the loss of the digestive powers, are so few? Temperance, the calm of passions, frugality, and continual exercise, keep them healthy, and preserve unimpaired that constitution which they have received from parents as healthy as themselves; who in the unpolluted embraces of the earliest and chastest love, conveyed to them the soundest bodily frame which nature could give. But as no habitable part of this globe is exempt from some diseases, proceeding either from climate or modes of living; here they are sometimes subject to consumptions and to fevers. Since the foundation of that town no epidemical distempers have appeared, which at times cause such depopulations in other countries; many of them are extremely well acquainted with the Indian methods of curing simple diseases, and practise them with success. You will hardly find anywhere a community, composed of the same number of individuals, possessing such uninterrupted health, and exhibiting so many green old men, who show their advanced age by the maturity of their wisdom, rather than by the wrinkles of their faces; and this is indeed one of the principal blessings of the island, which richly compensates their want of the richer soils of the south; where iliac complaints and bilious fevers, grow by the side of the sugar cane, the ambrosial ananas, etc. The situation of this island, the purity of the air, the nature of their marine occupations, their virtue and moderation, are the causes of that vigour and health which they possess. The poverty of their soil has placed them, I hope, beyond the danger of conquest, or the wanton desire of extirpation. Were they to be driven from this spot, the only acquisition of the conquerors would be a few acres of land, inclosed and cultivated; a few houses, and some movables. The genius, the industry of the inhabitants would accompany them; and it is those alone which constitute the sole wealth of their island. Its present fame would perish, and in a few years it would return to its pristine state of barrenness and poverty: they might perhaps be allowed to transport themselves in their own vessels to some other spot or island, which they would soon fertilise by the same means with which they have fertilised this.
As unusual as it may seem to you, there are only two medical professors on the island; after all, what use is medicine in a simple society where excessive drinking is so rare? What need do they have for medicinal treatments when fevers and digestive issues are so uncommon? Their health is maintained by moderation, emotional calm, frugality, and regular exercise, preserving the strong constitution handed down from parents who are as healthy as they are, conceived in the purest and most loving relationships that nature could allow. However, no place on Earth is completely free from diseases caused by climate or lifestyle; here, they occasionally face illnesses like consumption and fevers. Since the town was established, no widespread epidemics have emerged that cause significant population declines as they do in other countries; many residents are quite knowledgeable about Indian remedies for common ailments and use them effectively. You would be hard-pressed to find another community of the same size with such consistent health and so many elderly individuals whose wisdom reflects their age more than the wrinkles on their faces; this is truly one of the island's greatest blessings, compensating for the lack of the fertile soils found in the south, where digestive issues and fevers accompany crops like sugar cane and delicious pineapples. The position of this island, the clean air, their marine way of life, as well as their virtues and moderation, contribute to their vitality and health. The poor quality of their soil may, I hope, protect them from conquest or the reckless desire for destruction. If they were forced to leave this place, the conquerors would gain only a few acres of cleared and cultivated land, some houses, and a few possessions. The spirit and hard work of the inhabitants would go with them; these qualities are the true wealth of their island. Its current reputation would fade, and in a few years, it would revert to its original state of barrenness and poverty. They might even be permitted to use their own boats to relocate to another spot or island, where they would quickly bring fertility using the same methods that made this one thrive.
One single lawyer has of late years found means to live here, but his best fortune proceeds more from having married one of the wealthiest heiresses of the island, than from the emoluments of his practice: however he is sometimes employed in recovering money lent on the main, or in preventing those accidents to which the contentious propensity of its inhabitants may sometimes expose them. He is seldom employed as the means of self-defence, and much seldomer as the channel of attack; to which they are strangers, except the fraud is manifest, and the danger imminent. Lawyers are so numerous in all our populous towns, that I am surprised they never thought before of establishing themselves here: they are plants that will grow in any soil that is cultivated by the hands of others; and when once they have taken root they will extinguish every other vegetable that grows around them. The fortunes they daily acquire in every province, from the misfortunes of their fellow-citizens, are surprising! The most ignorant, the most bungling member of that profession, will, if placed in the most obscure part of the country, promote litigiousness, and amass more wealth without labour, than the most opulent farmer, with all his toils. They have so dexterously interwoven their doctrines and quirks with the laws of the land, or rather they are become so necessary an evil in our present constitutions, that it seems unavoidable and past all remedy. What a pity that our forefathers, who happily extinguished so many fatal customs, and expunged from their new government so many errors and abuses, both religious and civil, did not also prevent the introduction of a set of men so dangerous! In some provinces, where every inhabitant is constantly employed in tilling and cultivating the earth, they are the only members of society who have any knowledge; let these provinces attest what iniquitous use they have made of that knowledge.
One lawyer has recently figured out how to live here, but his luck comes more from marrying one of the wealthiest heiresses on the island than from his legal work. Still, he sometimes gets hired to recover money that’s been lent out or to prevent issues that the argumentative nature of the locals might cause. He’s rarely hired for self-defense, even less often for offense; they don’t seem to do that unless the fraud is obvious and the danger is urgent. Lawyers are so common in all our busy towns that it’s surprising none of them thought to set up here before. They’re like plants that can thrive in any soil as long as it’s been cultivated by someone else, and once they take hold, they’ll choke out everything else growing nearby. The wealth they accumulate daily from the misfortunes of others is astonishing! Even the least skilled and most clueless lawyer, if placed in a remote part of the country, can stir up disputes and acquire more wealth without effort than the richest farmer can with all his hard work. They’ve skillfully woven their practices and tricks into the laws of the land, or rather, they’ve become such a necessary evil in our current system that it seems impossible to change. It’s a shame that our ancestors, who successfully abolished so many harmful practices and removed numerous errors and abuses, both religious and civil, didn’t also stop the rise of such dangerous individuals! In some areas, where everyone is busy farming and cultivating the land, they are the only ones in society with any real knowledge; let those areas show how they’ve misused that knowledge.
They are here what the clergy were in past centuries with you; the reformation which clipped the clerical wings, is the boast of that age, and the happiest event that could possibly happen; a reformation equally useful is now wanted, to relieve us from the shameful shackles and the oppressive burthen under which we groan; this perhaps is impossible; but if mankind would not become too happy, it were an event most devoutly to be wished.
They are like the clergy were in past centuries for you; the reform that took away the power of the clergy is the pride of that time and the best thing that could have happened; a similar reform is now needed to free us from the shameful chains and the heavy burden we are enduring; this might be impossible; but if humanity wouldn’t get too comfortable, it would be something we should really hope for.
Here, happily, unoppressed with any civil bondage, this society of fishermen and merchants live, without any military establishments, without governors or any masters but the laws; and their civil code is so light, that it is never felt. A man may pass (as many have done whom I am acquainted with) through the various scenes of a long life, may struggle against a variety of adverse fortune, peaceably enjoy the good when it comes, and never in that long interval, apply to the law either for redress or assistance. The principal benefit it confers is the general protection of individuals, and this protection is purchased by the most moderate taxes, which are cheerfully paid, and by the trifling duties incident in the course of their lawful trade (for they despise contraband). Nothing can be more simple than their municipal regulations, though similar to those of the other counties of the same province; because they are more detached from the rest, more distinct in their manners, as well as in the nature of the business they pursue, and more unconnected with the populous province to which they belong. The same simplicity attends the worship they pay to the Divinity; their elders are the only teachers of their congregations, the instructors of their youth, and often the example of their flock. They visit and comfort the sick; after death, the society bury them with their fathers, without pomp, prayers, or ceremonies; not a stone or monument is erected, to tell where any person was buried; their memory is preserved by tradition. The only essential memorial that is left of them, is their former industry, their kindness, their charity, or else their most conspicuous faults.
Here, happily free from any civil restrictions, this community of fishermen and merchants lives without military forces, governors, or any masters other than the laws; and their legal system is so light that it’s barely noticed. A person can go through various stages of a long life, face many challenges, enjoy the good times, and never once during that long period need to turn to the law for help or resolution. The main advantage it provides is the overall protection of individuals, and this protection comes with very modest taxes that are paid willingly, along with the minor fees associated with their legitimate trade (since they hold contraband in disdain). Their local regulations are as straightforward as they come, even though they are similar to those of other counties in the same province; they are more separate from the others, distinct in their ways, and focused on their specific business pursuits, making them less connected to the populous province they belong to. The same simplicity characterizes their worship of the Divine; their elders are the only teachers in their communities, guiding their youth and often serving as role models. They visit and console the sick; when someone dies, the community buries them with their ancestors, without pomp, prayers, or rituals; not a stone or monument marks where anyone is buried; their memory lives on through stories. The only lasting memories that remain are their past efforts, their kindness, their generosity, or their most notable faults.
The Presbyterians live in great charity with them, and with one another; their minister as a true pastor of the gospel, inculcates to them the doctrines it contains, the rewards it promises, the punishments it holds out to those who shall commit injustice. Nothing can be more disencumbered likewise from useless ceremonies and trifling forms than their mode of worship; it might with great propriety have been called a truly primitive one, had that of the Quakers never appeared. As fellow Christians, obeying the same legislator, they love and mutually assist each other in all their wants; as fellow labourers they unite with cordiality and without the least rancour in all their temporal schemes: no other emulation appears among them but in their sea excursions, in the art of fitting out their vessels; in that of sailing, in harpooning the whale, and in bringing home the greatest harvest. As fellow subjects they cheerfully obey the same laws, and pay the same duties: but let me not forget another peculiar characteristic of this community: there is not a slave I believe on the whole island, at least among the Friends; whilst slavery prevails all around them, this society alone, lamenting that shocking insult offered to humanity, have given the world a singular example of moderation, disinterestedness, and Christian charity, in emancipating their negroes. I shall explain to you farther, the singular virtue and merit to which it is so justly entitled by having set before the rest of their fellow- subjects, so pleasing, so edifying a reformation. Happy the people who are subject to so mild a government; happy the government which has to rule over such harmless, and such industrious subjects!
The Presbyterians live in harmony with each other and with others; their minister, as a genuine pastor of the gospel, teaches them the doctrines within it, the rewards it promises, and the punishments it threatens for those who act unjustly. Their form of worship is also free from unnecessary ceremonies and trivial rituals; it could rightfully be considered truly primitive, if the Quakers hadn't come first. As fellow Christians, following the same laws, they support each other in their needs; as collaborators, they work together with goodwill and without any resentment on all their practical plans. The only competition among them involves their sea trips, the skill of preparing their boats, sailing, whaling, and bringing in the biggest catch. As fellow citizens, they willingly follow the same laws and pay the same taxes. But I must mention another unique aspect of this community: I believe there are no slaves on the entire island, at least among the Friends; while slavery exists all around them, this society stands out by lamenting that terrible affront to humanity, offering the world a remarkable example of moderation, selflessness, and Christian charity by freeing their enslaved people. I will further explain the distinct virtue and merit they rightly have for presenting such a positive and inspiring reform to the rest of their fellow citizens. Blessed are the people under such a gentle government; blessed is the government that oversees such harmless and hardworking citizens!
While we are clearing forests, making the face of nature smile, draining marshes, cultivating wheat, and converting it into flour; they yearly skim from the surface of the sea riches equally necessary. Thus, had I leisure and abilities to lead you through this continent, I could show you an astonishing prospect very little known in Europe; one diffusive scene of happiness reaching from the sea-shores to the last settlements on the borders of the wilderness: an happiness, interrupted only by the folly of individuals, by our spirit of litigiousness, and by those unforeseen calamities, from which no human society can possibly be exempted. May the citizens of Nantucket dwell long here in uninterrupted peace, undisturbed either by the waves of the surrounding element, or the political commotions which sometimes agitate our continent.
While we clear forests, making nature look beautiful, drain marshes, grow wheat, and turn it into flour; we also take yearly resources from the sea that are just as essential. If I had the time and ability to guide you across this continent, I could show you an amazing view that is mostly unknown in Europe; a widespread scene of happiness stretching from the shores to the edge of the wilderness: a happiness only disrupted by individual foolishness, our tendency to argue, and those unexpected disasters that no society can escape. I hope the citizens of Nantucket enjoy a long time of uninterrupted peace, free from both the surrounding waves and the political turmoil that sometimes stirs our continent.
LETTER VIII
PECULIAR CUSTOMS AT NANTUCKET
The manners of the Friends are entirely founded on that simplicity which is their boast, and their most distinguished characteristic; and those manners have acquired the authority of laws. Here they are strongly attached to plainness of dress, as well as to that of language; insomuch that though some part of it may be ungrammatical, yet should any person who was born and brought up here, attempt to speak more correctly, he would be looked upon as a fop or an innovator. On the other hand, should a stranger come here and adopt their idiom in all its purity (as they deem it) this accomplishment would immediately procure him the most cordial reception; and they would cherish him like an ancient member of their society. So many impositions have they suffered on this account, that they begin now indeed to grow more cautious. They are so tenacious of their ancient habits of industry and frugality, that if any of them were to be seen with a long coat made of English cloth, on any other than the first-day (Sunday), he would be greatly ridiculed and censured; he would be looked upon as a careless spendthrift, whom it would be unsafe to trust, and in vain to relieve. A few years ago two single- horse chairs were imported from Boston, to the great offence of these prudent citizens; nothing appeared to them more culpable than the use of such gaudy painted vehicles, in contempt of the more useful and more simple single-horse carts of their fathers. This piece of extravagant and unknown luxury almost caused a schism, and set every tongue a-going; some predicted the approaching ruin of those families that had imported them; others feared the dangers of example; never since the foundation of the town had there happened anything which so much alarmed this primitive community. One of the possessors of these profane chairs, filled with repentance, wisely sent it back to the continent; the other, more obstinate and perverse, in defiance to all remonstrances, persisted in the use of his chair until by degrees they became more reconciled to it; though I observed that the wealthiest and the most respectable people still go to meeting or to their farms in a single-horse cart with a decent awning fixed over it: indeed, if you consider their sandy soil, and the badness of their roads, these appear to be the best contrived vehicles for this island.
The behavior of the Friends is completely based on the simplicity they pride themselves on, which is also their most notable trait; and these behaviors have taken on the power of rules. Here, they are strongly committed to dressing simply and using plain language; so much so that even if part of it is ungrammatical, anyone raised here who tries to speak more correctly would be seen as vain or a trendsetter. Conversely, if a newcomer comes here and adopts their way of speaking in its purest form (as they see it), that person would receive a warm welcome and be treated like a long-standing member of their community. They have endured so many impositions regarding this that they are starting to become more cautious. They are so attached to their traditional habits of hard work and frugality that if anyone were to be seen wearing a long coat made of English fabric on any day other than Sunday, they would be widely mocked and criticized; that person would be viewed as a careless spender, untrustworthy, and not worth the effort to help. A few years ago, two single-horse chairs were brought in from Boston, which greatly upset these sensible citizens; nothing seemed more wrong to them than using such flashy painted vehicles, considering the more practical and simpler single-horse carts used by their ancestors. This extravagant and unfamiliar luxury nearly caused a split among them, igniting a lot of discussions; some predicted the downfall of the families that had brought them in, while others worried about setting a bad example; nothing since the founding of the town had alarmed this traditional community as much. One owner of these inappropriate chairs, filled with regret, wisely sent it back to the mainland; the other, more stubborn and resistant, continued using his chair despite all protests, until gradually people became more accepting of it; however, I noticed that the wealthiest and most respected members still go to meetings or their farms in a single-horse cart with a nice awning over it: indeed, considering their sandy soil and poor roads, these seem to be the most suitable vehicles for this island.
Idleness is the most heinous sin that can be committed in Nantucket: an idle man would soon be pointed out as an object of compassion: for idleness is considered as another word for want and hunger. This principle is so thoroughly well understood, and is become so universal, so prevailing a prejudice, that literally speaking, they are never idle. Even if they go to the market-place, which is (if I may be allowed the expression) the coffee-house of the town, either to transact business, or to converse with their friends; they always have a piece of cedar in their hands, and while they are talking, they will, as it were instinctively, employ themselves in converting it into something useful, either in making bungs or spoyls for their oil casks, or other useful articles. I must confess, that I have never seen more ingenuity in the use of the knife; thus the most idle moments of their lives become usefully employed. In the many hours of leisure which their long cruises afford them, they cut and carve a variety of boxes and pretty toys, in wood, adapted to different uses; which they bring home as testimonies of remembrance to their wives or sweethearts. They have showed me a variety of little bowls and other implements, executed cooper-wise, with the greatest neatness and elegance. You will be pleased to remember they are all brought up to the trade of coopers, be their future intentions or fortunes what they may; therefore almost every man in this island has always two knives in his pocket, one much larger than the other; and though they hold everything that is called fashion in the utmost contempt, yet they are as difficult to please, and as extravagant in the choice and price of their knives, as any young buck in Boston would be about his hat, buckles, or coat. As soon as a knife is injured, or superseded by a more convenient one, it is carefully laid up in some corner of their desk. I once saw upwards of fifty thus preserved at Mr.——'s, one of the worthiest men on this island; and among the whole, there was not one that perfectly resembled another. As the sea excursions are often very long, their wives in their absence are necessarily obliged to transact business, to settle accounts, and in short, to rule and provide for their families. These circumstances being often repeated, give women the abilities as well as a taste for that kind of superintendency, to which, by their prudence and good management, they seem to be in general very equal. This employment ripens their judgment, and justly entitles them to a rank superior to that of other wives; and this is the principal reason why those of Nantucket as well as those of Montreal [Footnote: Most of the merchants and young men of Montreal spend the greatest part of their time in trading with the Indians, at an amazing distance from Canada; and it often happens that they are three years together absent from home.] are so fond of society, so affable, and so conversant with the affairs of the world. The men at their return, weary with the fatigues of the sea, full of confidence and love, cheerfully give their consent to every transaction that has happened during their absence, and all is joy and peace. "Wife, thee hast done well," is the general approbation they receive, for their application and industry. What would the men do without the agency of these faithful mates? The absence of so many of them at particular seasons, leaves the town quite desolate; and this mournful situation disposes the women to go to each other's house much oftener than when their husbands are at home: hence the custom of incessant visiting has infected every one, and even those whose husbands do not go abroad. The house is always cleaned before they set out, and with peculiar alacrity they pursue their intended visit, which consists of a social chat, a dish of tea, and an hearty supper. When the good man of the house returns from his labour, he peaceably goes after his wife and brings her home; meanwhile the young fellows, equally vigilant, easily find out which is the most convenient house, and there they assemble with the girls of the neighbourhood. Instead of cards, musical instruments, or songs, they relate stories of their whaling voyages, their various sea adventures, and talk of the different coasts and people they have visited. "The island of Catharine in the Brazil," says one, "is a very droll island, it is inhabited by none but men; women are not permitted to come in sight of it; not a woman is there on the whole island. Who among us is not glad it is not so here? The Nantucket girls and boys beat the world." At this innocent sally the titter goes round, they whisper to one another their spontaneous reflections: puddings, pies, and custards never fail to be produced on such occasions; for I believe there never were any people in their circumstances, who live so well, even to superabundance. As inebriation is unknown, and music, singing, and dancing, are held in equal detestation, they never could fill all the vacant hours of their lives without the repast of the table. Thus these young people sit and talk, and divert themselves as well as they can; if any one has lately returned from a cruise, he is generally the speaker of the night; they often all laugh and talk together, but they are happy, and would not exchange their pleasures for those of the most brilliant assemblies in Europe. This lasts until the father and mother return; when all retire to their respective homes, the men re-conducting the partners of their affections.
Idleness is the worst sin you can commit in Nantucket: an idle person would quickly be seen as someone to pity, as idleness is equated with poverty and hunger. This idea is so widely understood and accepted that, literally speaking, they are never idle. Even when they go to the market, which is like the town’s coffee house, either to do business or catch up with friends, they always have a piece of cedar in hand. While chatting, they instinctively keep busy, turning it into something useful, like making bungs or spoils for their oil barrels, or other practical items. I must say, I've never seen such skill with a knife; even their most idle moments are productively spent. During the long hours they have while at sea, they carve various boxes and pretty wooden toys for different uses, which they bring back as gifts for their wives or sweethearts. They’ve shown me many little bowls and tools made with great care and elegance. Remember, they are all trained as coopers, regardless of what they plan for their futures, so almost every man on this island carries two knives: one much larger than the other. They reject everything considered fashionable, yet they are just as picky and extravagant about the choice and price of their knives as a young man in Boston would be regarding his hat, buckles, or coat. When a knife gets damaged or replaced by a better one, they carefully stash it away in a corner of their desk. I once saw over fifty of these saved knives at Mr.——'s, one of the finest men on the island, and no two were exactly alike. Since their sea trips can be long, their wives must manage business, balance accounts, and essentially run their households in their absence. This situation often repeats, giving women the skills and desire for oversight, which through their prudence and good management, they seem quite capable of handling. These responsibilities sharpen their judgment and rightfully earn them a status higher than that of other wives, which is a key reason why the women of Nantucket, like those in Montreal, enjoy socializing, are friendly, and stay informed about the world. When the men return, tired from the sea but filled with confidence and love, they happily agree to every decision made during their time away, and it’s all joy and peace. "Wife, you’ve done well," is the usual praise they get for their hard work. What would the men do without these loyal partners? The absence of so many of them at times makes the town feel deserted; this sad reality leads the women to visit each other much more often than when their husbands are home. Thus, the habit of constant visiting has caught on with everyone, even those whose husbands don’t go away. The house is always cleaned before they leave, and with particular eagerness, they set off to visit, which involves social chatting, a cup of tea, and a hearty meal. When the husband returns from work, he peacefully goes to find his wife and brings her home; meanwhile, the young men, equally keen, easily discover the most convenient house and gather with the local girls. Instead of playing cards, making music, or singing, they share stories of their whaling journeys, sea adventures, and the different places and people they’ve encountered. "The island of Catharine in Brazil," one says, "is quite the strange place; it's inhabited only by men—women can’t even set foot there; not a single woman is found on the entire island. Who among us isn’t glad it’s not like that here? The Nantucket girls and boys are the best!" At this playful remark, laughter spreads, and they whisper their spontaneous thoughts to one another: puddings, pies, and custards are always served on such occasions because I believe no other people in similar circumstances live as well, even to excess. Since drinking to excess is unheard of, and music, singing, and dancing are equally disliked, they would struggle to fill all their free time without meals at the table. So these young people sit, talk, and entertain themselves as best they can; if someone has recently returned from a trip, he usually takes the lead in conversation for the night. They often laugh and chat together, but they are happy and wouldn’t trade their fun for the most glamorous gatherings in Europe. This continues until the parents return; then everyone heads home, with the men escorting their beloved partners back.
Thus they spend many of the youthful evenings of their lives; no wonder therefore, that they marry so early. But no sooner have they undergone this ceremony than they cease to appear so cheerful and gay; the new rank they hold in the society impresses them with more serious ideas than were entertained before. The title of master of a family necessarily requires more solid behaviour and deportment; the new wife follows in the trammels of Custom, which are as powerful as the tyranny of fashion; she gradually advises and directs; the new husband soon goes to sea, he leaves her to learn and exercise the new government, in which she is entered. Those who stay at home are full as passive in general, at least with regard to the inferior departments of the family. But you must not imagine from this account that the Nantucket wives are turbulent, of high temper, and difficult to be ruled; on the contrary, the wives of Sherburn in so doing, comply only with the prevailing custom of the island: the husbands, equally submissive to the ancient and respectable manners of their country, submit, without ever suspecting that there can be any impropriety. Were they to behave otherwise, they would be afraid of subverting the principles of their society by altering its ancient rules; thus both parties are perfectly satisfied, and all is peace and concord. The richest person now in the island owes all his present prosperity and success to the ingenuity of his wife: this is a known fact which is well recorded; for while he was performing his first cruises, she traded with pins and needles, and kept a school. Afterward she purchased more considerable articles, which she sold with so much judgment, that she laid the foundation of a system of business, that she has ever since prosecuted with equal dexterity and success. She wrote to London, formed connections, and, in short, became the only ostensible instrument of that house, both at home and abroad. Who is he in this country, and who is a citizen of Nantucket or Boston, who does not know Aunt Kesiah? I must tell you that she is the wife of Mr. C——n, a very respectable man, who, well pleased with all her schemes, trusts to her judgment, and relies on her sagacity, with so entire a confidence, as to be altogether passive to the concerns of his family. They have the best country seat on the island, at Quayes, where they live with hospitality, and in perfect union. He seems to be altogether the contemplative man.
So they spend many of their youthful evenings this way; it’s no surprise that they marry so young. But as soon as they go through this ceremony, they stop looking so cheerful and carefree; the new role they take on in society brings them more serious thoughts than they had before. Being the head of a household requires more responsible behavior and attitude; the new wife follows the constraints of tradition, which are as powerful as the pressure of trends; she gradually takes on a guiding role. The new husband quickly goes off to sea, leaving her to learn and handle the new responsibilities she’s taken on. Those who stay at home are just as passive, at least regarding the lower levels of household management. But don’t think that this means the wives in Nantucket are rebellious, hot-tempered, or hard to control; on the contrary, the wives in Sherburn are just conforming to the island’s customs: the husbands, equally compliant with the longstanding and respected traditions of their community, follow along without suspecting any wrongdoing. If they were to act differently, they’d fear disrupting the principles of their society by changing its old rules; thus, both sides are perfectly content, and everything is harmonious. The wealthiest person on the island owes all his current success to his wife’s resourcefulness: this is a well-known fact. While he was out on his early voyages, she made trades with pins and needles and ran a school. Eventually, she started selling more significant items, which she sold so wisely that she laid the groundwork for a business that she has continued to manage with equal skill and success. She communicated with London, built connections, and became the public face of their household, both locally and abroad. Who in this country, and who in Nantucket or Boston, doesn’t know Aunt Kesiah? I should mention she is the wife of Mr. C——n, a respected man who, very pleased with all her plans, relies entirely on her judgment and trusts her insights, allowing himself to take a back seat in managing their family affairs. They have the best country house on the island, at Quayes, where they live with hospitality and in perfect harmony. He appears to be completely introspective.
To this dexterity in managing the husband's business whilst he is absent, the Nantucket wives unite a great deal of industry. They spin, or cause to be spun in their houses, abundance of wool and flax; and would be for ever disgraced and looked upon as idlers if all the family were not clad in good, neat, and sufficient home-spun cloth. First Days are the only seasons when it is lawful for both sexes to exhibit some garments of English manufacture; even these are of the most moderate price, and of the gravest colours: there is no kind of difference in their dress, they are all clad alike, and resemble in that respect the members of one family.
To this skill in managing their husband's business while he's away, the Nantucket wives add a strong work ethic. They spin, or have plenty of wool and flax spun in their homes; they would be forever embarrassed and seen as lazy if their whole family wasn't dressed in good, neat, and adequate homemade cloth. First Days are the only times when it’s acceptable for both men and women to wear some clothing made in England; even then, these items are the most affordable and come in the most subdued colors. There’s no difference in their clothing; they all dress the same, making them look like members of one family in that respect.
A singular custom prevails here among the women, at which I was greatly surprised; and am really at a loss how to account for the original cause that has introduced in this primitive society so remarkable a fashion, or rather so extraordinary a want. They have adopted these many years the Asiatic custom of taking a dose of opium every morning; and so deeply rooted is it, that they would be at a loss how to live without this indulgence; they would rather be deprived of any necessary than forego their favourite luxury. This is much more prevailing among the women than the men, few of the latter having caught the contagion; though the sheriff, whom I may call the first person in the island, who is an eminent physician beside, and whom I had the pleasure of being well acquainted with, has for many years submitted to this custom. He takes three grains of it every day after breakfast, without the effects of which, he often told me, he was not able to transact any business.
A unique custom exists among the women here that surprised me greatly, and I find it hard to understand what originally led to such an unusual practice in this basic society. For many years, they’ve adopted the Asian habit of taking a dose of opium every morning; it’s so ingrained that they wouldn’t know how to live without this indulgence. They would rather give up anything essential than their favorite luxury. This habit is much more common among the women than the men, with only a few men having caught on to it; though the sheriff, who I can call the island's top person and is also a prominent physician I had the pleasure of knowing well, has followed this custom for many years. He takes three grains every day after breakfast and often told me that he couldn’t manage any business without it.
It is hard to conceive how a people always happy and healthy, in consequence of the exercise and labour they undergo, never oppressed with the vapours of idleness, yet should want the fictitious effects of opium to preserve that cheerfulness to which their temperance, their climate, their happy situation so justly entitle them. But where is the society perfectly free from error or folly; the least imperfect is undoubtedly that where the greatest good preponderates; and agreeable to this rule, I can truly say, that I never was acquainted with a less vicious, or more harmless one.
It’s hard to imagine how a people who are always happy and healthy, thanks to the exercise and hard work they do, never weighed down by the gloom of idleness, could still need the artificial effects of opium to maintain the cheerfulness that their self-control, climate, and fortunate situation rightfully deserve. But where can you find a society completely free from mistakes or foolishness? The least flawed one is definitely the one where the most good outweighs everything else; following this idea, I can honestly say I’ve never come across a less corrupt or more innocent society.
The majority of the present inhabitants are the descendants of the twenty-seven first proprietors, who patenteed the island; of the rest, many others have since come over among them, chiefly from the Massachusetts: here are neither Scotch, Irish, nor French, as is the case in most other settlements; they are an unmixed English breed. The consequence of this extended connection is, that they are all in some degree related to each other: you must not be surprised therefore when I tell you, that they always call each other cousin, uncle or aunt; which are become such common appellations, that no other are made use of in their daily intercourse: you would be deemed stiff and affected were you to refuse conforming yourself to this ancient custom, which truly depicts the image of a large family. The many who reside here that have not the least claim of relationship with any one in the town, yet by the power of custom make use of no other address in their conversation. Were you here yourself but a few days, you would be obliged to adopt the same phraseology, which is far from being disagreeable, as it implies a general acquaintance and friendship, which connects them all in unity and peace.
The majority of the current residents are the descendants of the twenty-seven original landowners who patented the island. Among the rest, many others have arrived, mostly from Massachusetts. There are no Scots, Irish, or French people here, unlike in most other settlements; they are a purely English group. Because of this long-standing connection, they are all somewhat related to one another. So, don’t be surprised when I tell you they always refer to each other as cousin, uncle, or aunt. These terms have become so common that no other titles are used in their everyday interactions. If you refuse to go along with this old custom, you’d be seen as stiff and pretentious, which really reflects the atmosphere of a big family. Many people living here have no real family ties to anyone in town, yet out of habit, they use no other terms when conversing. If you were here for just a few days, you’d feel pressured to adopt the same way of speaking, which isn’t unpleasant at all, as it suggests a sense of community and friendship that unites them all in harmony and peace.
Their taste for fishing has been so prevailing, that it has engrossed all their attention, and even prevented them from introducing some higher degree of perfection in their agriculture. There are many useful improvements which might have meliorated their soil; there are many trees which if transplanted here would have thriven extremely well, and would have served to shelter as well as decorate the favourite spots they have so carefully manured. The red cedar, the locust, [Footnote: A species of what we call here the two-thorn acacia: it yields the most valuable timber we have, and its shade is very beneficial to the growth and goodness of the grass.] the button wood, I am persuaded would have grown here rapidly and to a great size, with many others; but their thoughts are turned altogether toward the sea. The Indian corn begins to yield them considerable crops, and the wheat sown on its stocks is become a very profitable grain; rye will grow with little care; they might raise if they would, an immense quantity of buck-wheat.
Their love for fishing has been so strong that it has captured all their attention, even stopping them from making any real improvements in their farming. There are many useful advancements that could have improved their land; there are many trees that, if planted here, would have thrived really well and would have provided both shade and beauty to the favorite areas they have so carefully cultivated. I’m sure the red cedar, locust, and buttonwood would have grown here quickly and to a large size, along with many others; but their focus is solely on the sea. The corn is starting to produce good yields, and the wheat sown on its stalks has become a highly profitable crop; rye grows with little effort; they could easily grow a huge amount of buckwheat if they wanted to.
Such an island inhabited as I have described, is not the place where gay travellers should resort, in order to enjoy that variety of pleasures the more splendid towns of this continent afford. Not that they are wholly deprived of what we might call recreations, and innocent pastimes; but opulence, instead of luxuries and extravagancies, produces nothing more here than an increase of business, an additional degree of hospitality, greater neatness in the preparation of dishes, and better wines. They often walk and converse with each other, as I have observed before; and upon extraordinary occasions, will take a ride to Palpus, where there is an house of entertainment; but these rural amusements are conducted upon the same plan of moderation, as those in town. They are so simple as hardly to be described; the pleasure of going and returning together; of chatting and walking about, of throwing the bar, heaving stones, etc., are the only entertainments they are acquainted with. This is all they practise, and all they seem to desire. The house at Palpus is the general resort of those who possess the luxury of a horse and chaise, as well as of those who still retain, as the majority do, a predilection for their primitive vehicle. By resorting to that place they enjoy a change of air, they taste the pleasures of exercise; perhaps an exhilarating bowl, not at all improper in this climate, affords the chief indulgence known to these people, on the days of their greatest festivity. The mounting a horse, must afford a most pleasing exercise to those men who are so much at sea. I was once invited to that house, and had the satisfaction of conducting thither one of the many beauties of that island (for it abounds with handsome women) dressed in all the bewitching attire of the most charming simplicity: like the rest of the company, she was cheerful without loud laughs, and smiling without affectation. They all appeared gay without levity. I had never before in my life seen so much unaffected mirth, mixed with so much modesty. The pleasures of the day were enjoyed with the greatest liveliness and the most innocent freedom; no disgusting pruderies, no coquettish airs tarnished this enlivening assembly: they behaved according to their native dispositions, the only rules of decorum with which they were acquainted. What would an European visitor have done here without a fiddle, without a dance, without cards? He would have called it an insipid assembly, and ranked this among the dullest days he had ever spent. This rural excursion had a very great affinity to those practised in our province, with this difference only, that we have no objection to the sportive dance, though conducted by the rough accents of some self-taught African fiddler. We returned as happy as we went; and the brightness of the moon kindly lengthened a day which had past, like other agreeable ones, with singular rapidity.
Such an island, as I've described, isn’t the kind of place where lively travelers should go to enjoy the variety of pleasures that the more glamorous towns on this continent offer. It's not that they're completely lacking in what we might call fun and innocent pastimes; however, wealth here results in nothing more than increased business, a higher level of hospitality, better food preparation, and improved wine instead of lavish luxuries. They often walk and chat with each other, as I've noted before, and on special occasions, they might take a trip to Palpus, where there's an inn. But these countryside activities follow the same moderate approach as those in town. They're so simple that they're barely worth mentioning; the enjoyment of going and returning together, talking and walking around, throwing the bar, tossing stones, and so on, are the only entertainments they know. This is all they engage in, and all they seem to want. The inn at Palpus is the main hangout for those lucky enough to own a horse and carriage, as well as for those who still prefer their basic vehicle, which is what most people do. By going there, they experience a change of scenery, enjoy the pleasures of exercise; maybe a refreshing drink, perfectly acceptable in this climate, provides the main indulgence known to these folks on their most festive days. Riding a horse must be very enjoyable for those who spend so much time at sea. I was once invited to that inn and had the pleasure of bringing along one of the many beautiful women on the island (it truly has its share of gorgeous women) dressed in the most charmingly simple attire: like the rest of the group, she was cheerful without being loud and smiled without any pretense. They all seemed happy without being frivolous. I had never witnessed so much genuine happiness combined with such modesty. The day's enjoyment was filled with the greatest energy and the most innocent freedom; there were no grossly prudish behaviors or flirtatious airs to spoil this lively gathering: they acted according to their natural tendencies, the only rules of propriety they knew. What would a European visitor have done here without music, dances, or cards? He would have labeled it a dull gathering and recalled it as one of the most boring days he had ever experienced. This rural outing bore a strong resemblance to those we have in our region, the only difference being that we don’t mind lively dances, even if accompanied by the rough sounds of some self-taught African fiddler. We returned as happy as we had arrived, and the moon’s brightness kindly extended a day that passed, like other enjoyable ones, with remarkable quickness.
In order to view the island in its longest direction from the town, I took a ride to the easternmost parts of it, remarkable only for the Pochick Rip, where their best fish are caught. I past by the Tetoukemah lots, which are the fields of the community; the fences were made of cedar posts and rails, and looked perfectly straight and neat; the various crops they enclosed were flourishing: thence I descended into Barrey's Valley, where the blue and the spear grass looked more abundant than I had seen on any other part of the island; thence to Gib's Pond; and arrived at last at Siasconcet. Several dwellings had been erected on this wild shore, for the purpose of sheltering the fishermen in the season of fishing; I found them all empty, except that particular one to which I had been directed. It was like the others, built on the highest part of the shore, in the face of the great ocean; the soil appeared to be composed of no other stratum but sand, covered with a thinly scattered herbage. What rendered this house still more worthy of notice in my eyes, was, that it had been built on the ruins of one of the ancient huts, erected by the first settlers, for observing the appearance of the whales. Here lived a single family without a neighbour; I had never before seen a spot better calculated to cherish contemplative ideas; perfectly unconnected with the great world, and far removed from its perturbations. The ever raging ocean was all that presented itself to the view of this family; it irresistibly attracted my whole attention: my eyes were involuntarily directed to the horizontal line of that watery surface, which is ever in motion, and ever threatening destruction to these shores. My ears were stunned with the roar of its waves rolling one over the other, as if impelled by a superior force to overwhelm the spot on which I stood. My nostrils involuntarily inhaled the saline vapours which arose from the dispersed particles of the foaming billows, or from the weeds scattered on the shores. My mind suggested a thousand vague reflections, pleasing in the hour of their spontaneous birth, but now half forgot, and all indistinct: and who is the landman that can behold without affright so singular an element, which by its impetuosity seems to be the destroyer of this poor planet, yet at particular times accumulates the scattered fragments and produces islands and continents fit for men to dwell on! Who can observe the regular vicissitudes of its waters without astonishment; now swelling themselves in order to penetrate through every river and opening, and thereby facilitate navigation; at other times retiring from the shores, to permit man to collect that variety of shell fish which is the support of the poor? Who can see the storms of wind, blowing sometimes with an impetuosity sufficiently strong even to move the earth, without feeling himself affected beyond the sphere of common ideas? Can this wind which but a few days ago refreshed our American fields, and cooled us in the shade, be the same element which now and then so powerfully convulses the waters of the sea, dismasts vessels, causes so many shipwrecks, and such extensive desolations? How diminutive does a man appear to himself when filled with these thoughts, and standing as I did on the verge of the ocean! This family lived entirely by fishing, for the plough has not dared yet to disturb the parched surface of the neighbouring plain; and to what purpose could this operation be performed! Where is it that mankind will not find safety, peace, and abundance, with freedom and civil happiness? Nothing was wanting here to make this a most philosophical retreat, but a few ancient trees, to shelter contemplation in its beloved solitude. There I saw a numerous family of children of various ages- -the blessings of an early marriage; they were ruddy as the cherry, healthy as the fish they lived on, hardy as the pine knots: the eldest were already able to encounter the boisterous waves, and shuddered not at their approach; early initiating themselves in the mysteries of that seafaring career, for which they were all intended: the younger, timid as yet, on the edge of a less agitated pool, were teaching themselves with nut-shells and pieces of wood, in imitation of boats, how to navigate in a future day the larger vessels of their father, through a rougher and deeper ocean. I stayed two days there on purpose to become acquainted with the different branches of their economy, and their manner of living in this singular retreat. The clams, the oysters of the shores, with the addition of Indian Dumplings, [Footnote: Indian Dumplings are a peculiar preparation of Indian meal, boiled in large lumps.] constituted their daily and most substantial food. Larger fish were often caught on the neighbouring rip; these afforded them their greatest dainties; they had likewise plenty of smoked bacon. The noise of the wheels announced the industry of the mother and daughters; one of them had been bred a weaver, and having a loom in the house, found means of clothing the whole family; they were perfectly at ease, and seemed to want for nothing. I found very few books among these people, who have very little time for reading; the Bible and a few school tracts, both in the Nattick and English languages, constituted their most numerous libraries. I saw indeed several copies of Hudibras, and Josephus; but no one knows who first imported them. It is something extraordinary to see this people, professedly so grave, and strangers to every branch of literature, reading with pleasure the former work, which should seem to require some degree of taste, and antecedent historical knowledge. They all read it much, and can by memory repeat many passages; which yet I could not discover that they understood the beauties of. Is it not a little singular to see these books in the hands of fishermen, who are perfect strangers almost to any other? Josephus's history is indeed intelligible, and much fitter for their modes of education and taste; as it describes the history of a people from whom we have received the prophecies which we believe, and the religious laws which we follow.
To get the best view of the island from the town, I rode out to its easternmost part, known mainly for the Pochick Rip, where the best fishing happens. I passed by the Tetoukemah lots, which are community fields; the fences made of cedar posts and rails looked perfectly straight and tidy, and the various crops inside were thriving. Then, I went down into Barrey’s Valley, where the blue and spear grass seemed more abundant than anywhere else on the island; from there, I headed to Gib's Pond and finally reached Siasconcet. Several houses were built along this wild shore to shelter fishermen during the fishing season; I found them all empty except for the one I had been directed to. It was like the others, sitting at the highest point of the shore, facing the vast ocean; the soil seemed to consist only of sand, covered with sparse grass. What made this house more interesting to me was that it was built on the ruins of one of the ancient huts used by the first settlers to watch for whales. Here lived a single family without any neighbors; I had never seen a place better suited for quiet reflection—completely disconnected from the outside world and far removed from its disturbances. The ever-churning ocean was all that this family could see, and it grabbed my full attention: my eyes were involuntarily drawn to the endless, moving horizon of the water, always threatening these shores with destruction. My ears rang with the roar of waves crashing over one another, as if pushed by some greater force to overwhelm the spot where I stood. I inhaled the salty air that rose from the foaming waves or the seaweed scattered along the shore. My mind was filled with a thousand vague thoughts, pleasant when they first arose but now half-forgotten and unclear. Who can look at such a unique element without fear, knowing that its power seems to destroy this fragile planet, yet at times it gathers the scattered pieces and creates islands and continents for people to inhabit? Who can witness the regular changes in its waters without wonder—sometimes swelling to flow through every river and opening, aiding navigation; at other times retreating from the shores, allowing people to gather the various shellfish that sustain the less fortunate? Who can watch the storms that blow with enough force to shake the earth without feeling deeply impacted? Can this wind, which just days ago refreshed our American fields and cooled us in the shade, really be the same force that sometimes violently stirs the sea, dismasts ships, and causes countless shipwrecks and widespread destruction? How small does a person feel standing at the edge of the ocean with these thoughts in mind! This family lived entirely off fishing, as agriculture had yet to disturb the dry land nearby; and what purpose would farming serve here? Where can humanity find safety, peace, and abundance, along with freedom and happiness? The only thing lacking to make this a perfect philosophical retreat was a few ancient trees to provide shelter for contemplation in its prized solitude. I saw a large family of children of different ages—the blessings of an early marriage; they were as rosy as cherries, healthy like the fish they consumed, and as tough as pine knots. The oldest were already capable of tackling the rough waves and didn't flinch at their approach; they were beginning to learn the seafaring skills for which they were destined. The younger ones, still timid, played at the edge of a calmer pond, using nut shells and pieces of wood to imitate boats as they practiced navigating the larger vessels of their father through a rougher and deeper sea. I stayed there for two days to learn about their various ways of life in this unusual place. Clams, oysters from the shore, and Indian Dumplings, [Footnote: Indian Dumplings are a unique dish made from Indian meal, boiled in large lumps.] made up their main daily meals. They often caught larger fish nearby, which were their greatest delicacies; they also had plenty of smoked bacon. The sound of wheels announced the work of the mother and daughters; one had been trained as a weaver and had a loom at home, allowing her to make clothing for the entire family. They appeared completely comfortable and seemed to lack nothing. I found very few books among them, as they had little time to read; their most extensive libraries were the Bible and a few school tracts in both the Nattick and English languages. I did see several copies of Hudibras and Josephus, but no one knew who first brought them. It's quite remarkable to see these people, who are supposed to be serious and unfamiliar with literature, reading the former work with enjoyment, as it seems to require a certain level of taste and historical knowledge. They all read it often and could recite many passages from memory, although I couldn't tell if they understood its nuances. Isn't it a bit strange to see these books in the hands of fishermen, who are almost strangers to anything else? Josephus's history is indeed clear and much more suited to their education and tastes, as it recounts the history of a people from whom we have received the prophecies we believe in and the religious laws we follow.
Learned travellers, returned from seeing the paintings and antiquities of Rome and Italy, still filled with the admiration and reverence they inspire, would hardly be persuaded that so contemptible a spot, which contains nothing remarkable but the genius and the industry of its inhabitants, could ever be an object worthy attention. But I, having never seen the beauties which Europe contains, cheerfully satisfy myself with attentively examining what my native country exhibits: if we have neither ancient amphitheatres, gilded palaces, nor elevated spires; we enjoy in our woods a substantial happiness which the wonders of art cannot communicate. None among us suffer oppression either from government or religion; there are very few poor except the idle, and fortunately the force of example, and the most ample encouragement, soon create a new principle of activity, which had been extinguished perhaps in their native country, for want of those opportunities which so often compel honest Europeans to seek shelter among us. The means of procuring subsistence in Europe are limited; the army may be full, the navy may abound with seamen, the land perhaps wants no additional labourers, the manufacturer is overcharged with supernumerary hands; what then must become of the unemployed? Here, on the contrary, human industry has acquired a boundless field to exert itself in—a field which will not be fully cultivated in many ages!
Learned travelers, back from seeing the art and historical treasures of Rome and Italy, still filled with admiration and respect for what they saw, would hardly believe that such a seemingly insignificant place, which has nothing remarkable except for the talent and hard work of its people, could ever be worthy of attention. But I, having never experienced the beauties of Europe, happily occupy myself with closely examining what my home country has to offer: even if we lack ancient amphitheaters, gilded palaces, and tall spires, we enjoy a genuine happiness in our forests that the wonders of art can’t provide. None of us suffer from oppression by government or religion; very few are poor except for those who are lazy, and fortunately, the power of example and ample encouragement quickly create a new motivation that may have been lost in their homeland due to the lack of opportunities that often drive honest Europeans to seek refuge here. The means of making a living in Europe are limited; the army may be full, the navy may have plenty of sailors, the land may not need more laborers, and manufacturers may be overwhelmed with excess workers; so what happens to the unemployed? Here, on the other hand, human industry has found an endless field to thrive in—a field that won't be fully developed for many generations!
LETTER IX
DESCRIPTION OF CHARLES-TOWN; THOUGHTS ON SLAVERY; ON PHYSICAL EVIL; A MELANCHOLY SCENE
Charles-town is, in the north, what Lima is in the south; both are Capitals of the richest provinces of their respective hemispheres: you may therefore conjecture, that both cities must exhibit the appearances necessarily resulting from riches. Peru abounding in gold, Lima is filled with inhabitants who enjoy all those gradations of pleasure, refinement, and luxury, which proceed from wealth. Carolina produces commodities, more valuable perhaps than gold, because they are gained by greater industry; it exhibits also on our northern stage, a display of riches and luxury, inferior indeed to the former, but far superior to what are to be seen in our northern towns. Its situation is admirable, being built at the confluence of two large rivers, which receive in their course a great number of inferior streams; all navigable in the spring, for flat boats. Here the produce of this extensive territory concentres; here therefore is the seat of the most valuable exportation; their wharfs, their docks, their magazines, are extremely convenient to facilitate this great commercial business. The inhabitants are the gayest in America; it is called the centre of our beau monde, and is always filled with the richest planters of the province, who resort hither in quest of health and pleasure. Here are always to be seen a great number of valetudinarians from the West Indies, seeking for the renovation of health, exhausted by the debilitating nature of their sun, air, and modes of living. Many of these West Indians have I seen, at thirty, loaded with the infirmities of old age; for nothing is more common in those countries of wealth, than for persons to lose the abilities of enjoying the comforts of life, at a time when we northern men just begin to taste the fruits of our labour and prudence. The round of pleasure, and the expenses of those citizens' tables, are much superior to what you would imagine: indeed the growth of this town and province has been astonishingly rapid. It is pity that the narrowness of the neck on which it stands prevents it from increasing; and which is the reason why houses are so dear. The heat of the climate, which is sometimes very great in the interior parts of the country, is always temperate in Charles-Town; though sometimes when they have no sea breezes the sun is too powerful. The climate renders excesses of all kinds very dangerous, particularly those of the table; and yet, insensible or fearless of danger, they live on, and enjoy a short and a merry life: the rays of their sun seem to urge them irresistibly to dissipation and pleasure: on the contrary, the women, from being abstemious, reach to a longer period of life, and seldom die without having had several husbands. An European at his first arrival must be greatly surprised when he sees the elegance of their houses, their sumptuous furniture, as well as the magnificence of their tables. Can he imagine himself in a country, the establishment of which is so recent?
Charles Town is, in the north, what Lima is in the south; both are capitals of the richest provinces in their respective hemispheres. You can therefore guess that both cities must showcase the signs that come with wealth. Peru, rich in gold, has a population that enjoys various degrees of pleasure, refinement, and luxury that wealth provides. Carolina produces goods that may be even more valuable than gold because they come from greater effort; it also displays wealth and luxury on our northern stage, which may not match the former but is much better than what we see in our northern towns. Its location is excellent, built at the point where two large rivers meet, which gather many smaller streams along their way and are all navigable in spring for flatboats. Here, the produce from this vast area comes together; thus, it is the hub of the most valuable exports. Their wharfs, docks, and warehouses are very convenient for facilitating this major commercial activity. The inhabitants are the liveliest in America; it is known as the center of our fashionable society and is always bustling with the wealthiest planters from the province, who come here in search of health and enjoyment. You can often see a large number of people from the West Indies seeking to regain their health, worn out by the exhausting conditions of their sun, air, and lifestyles. I have seen many West Indians, at thirty years old, burdened with the ailments of old age; it is quite common in wealthy countries for people to lose the ability to enjoy life’s comforts at a time when we northern folks are just starting to reap the rewards of our work and caution. The social scene and the expenses at those citizens' tables are far beyond what you might think; indeed, the growth of this town and province has been remarkably swift. It is a shame that the narrow land it sits on limits its expansion, which is why houses are so expensive. The heat in the interior parts of the country can be intense, but it is generally mild in Charles Town; although sometimes, when there are no sea breezes, the sun can be too strong. The climate makes excesses of all kinds quite risky, especially with regard to food, yet, unaware or unbothered by danger, they go on living and enjoying a brief but lively life. The rays of their sun seem to push them irresistibly toward indulgence and pleasure; in contrast, the women, by being more moderate, tend to live longer and often have several husbands before they die. An European arriving for the first time must be quite astonished to see the elegance of their homes, their lavish furnishings, as well as the grandeur of their tables. Can he really believe he is in a country that has been established so recently?
The three principal classes of inhabitants are, lawyers, planters, and merchants; this is the province which has afforded to the first the richest spoils, for nothing can exceed their wealth, their power, and their influence. They have reached the ne plus ultra of worldly felicity; no plantation is secured, no title is good, no will is valid, but what they dictate, regulate, and approve. The whole mass of provincial property is become tributary to this society; which, far above priests and bishops, disdain to be satisfied with the poor Mosaical portion of the tenth. I appeal to the many inhabitants, who, while contending perhaps for their right to a few hundred acres, have lost by the mazes of the law their whole patrimony. These men are more properly law givers than interpreters of the law; and have united here, as well as in most other provinces, the skill and dexterity of the scribe with the power and ambition of the prince: who can tell where this may lead in a future day? The nature of our laws, and the spirit of freedom, which often tends to make us litigious, must necessarily throw the greatest part of the property of the colonies into the hands of these gentlemen. In another century, the law will possess in the north, what now the church possesses in Peru and Mexico.
The three main groups of people are lawyers, planters, and merchants; this is the area that has provided the greatest rewards to lawyers, as their wealth, power, and influence are unmatched. They have reached the peak of worldly happiness; no plantation is secured, no title is legitimate, no will is valid unless they dictate, regulate, and approve it. The entire wealth of the province has become dependent on this group, which, far above priests and bishops, look down on the small Biblical share of a tenth. I call to the many residents who, while perhaps fighting for their right to a few hundred acres, have lost their entire inheritance in the complexities of the law. These individuals are more like law makers than interpreters of the law, and they have combined the skills and cunning of a scribe with the power and ambition of a ruler: who can say where this may lead in the future? The nature of our laws, along with the spirit of freedom that often makes us litigious, will likely funnel most of the property in the colonies into the hands of these men. In another century, the law will hold in the North what the church currently holds in Peru and Mexico.
While all is joy, festivity, and happiness in Charles-Town, would you imagine that scenes of misery overspread in the country? Their ears by habit are become deaf, their hearts are hardened; they neither see, hear, nor feel for the woes of their poor slaves, from whose painful labours all their wealth proceeds. Here the horrors of slavery, the hardship of incessant toils, are unseen; and no one thinks with compassion of those showers of sweat and of tears which from the bodies of Africans, daily drop, and moisten the ground they till. The cracks of the whip urging these miserable beings to excessive labour, are far too distant from the gay Capital to be heard. The chosen race eat, drink, and live happy, while the unfortunate one grubs up the ground, raises indigo, or husks the rice; exposed to a sun full as scorching as their native one; without the support of good food, without the cordials of any cheering liquor. This great contrast has often afforded me subjects of the most conflicting meditation. On the one side, behold a people enjoying all that life affords most bewitching and pleasurable, without labour, without fatigue, hardly subjected to the trouble of wishing. With gold, dug from Peruvian mountains, they order vessels to the coasts of Guinea; by virtue of that gold, wars, murders, and devastations are committed in some harmless, peaceable African neighbourhood, where dwelt innocent people, who even knew not but that all men were black. The daughter torn from her weeping mother, the child from the wretched parents, the wife from the loving husband; whole families swept away and brought through storms and tempests to this rich metropolis! There, arranged like horses at a fair, they are branded like cattle, and then driven to toil, to starve, and to languish for a few years on the different plantations of these citizens. And for whom must they work? For persons they know not, and who have no other power over them than that of violence, no other right than what this accursed metal has given them! Strange order of things! Oh, Nature, where art thou?—Are not these blacks thy children as well as we? On the other side, nothing is to be seen but the most diffusive misery and wretchedness, unrelieved even in thought or wish! Day after day they drudge on without any prospect of ever reaping for themselves; they are obliged to devote their lives, their limbs, their will, and every vital exertion to swell the wealth of masters; who look not upon them with half the kindness and affection with which they consider their dogs and horses. Kindness and affection are not the portion of those who till the earth, who carry the burdens, who convert the logs into useful boards. This reward, simple and natural as one would conceive it, would border on humanity; and planters must have none of it!
While everyone is celebrating and happy in Charles-Town, can you imagine that scenes of misery are spreading across the countryside? They've become deaf to the suffering around them, and their hearts are hardened; they neither see, hear, nor care for the pain of their poor slaves, from whose exhausting labor all their wealth comes. Here, the horrors of slavery and the hardships of constant toil go unnoticed; no one thinks compassionately of the sweat and tears that drip from the bodies of Africans, watering the ground they farm. The crack of the whip driving these unfortunate people to work harder is too distant from the cheerful capital to be heard. The favored class eats, drinks, and lives happily while the unfortunate work the land, grow indigo, or husk rice; exposed to a sun just as scorching as their own; without proper food, without any uplifting drinks. This stark contrast often gives me a lot to think about. On one side, you have a people enjoying all that life has to offer without work, fatigue, or even the trouble of wishing. With gold from the Peruvian mountains, they send ships to the coasts of Guinea; using that gold, they create wars, murders, and devastation in peaceful African neighborhoods, where innocent people lived, blissfully unaware that all men were not black. The daughter is torn from her crying mother, the child from desperate parents, the wife from her loving husband; entire families are swept away and brought through storms to this wealthy city! There, like livestock at a fair, they are branded like cattle and then forced to work, starve, and suffer for a few years on the plantations of these citizens. And who do they work for? For people they don't know, who have no power over them except violence, no right beyond what that cursed gold has granted them! What a strange situation! Oh, Nature, where are you?—Are not these black people your children just like we are? On the other side, all you see is widespread misery and wretchedness, unrelieved even in thought or wish! Day after day, they toil on without any hope of ever gaining something for themselves; they must dedicate their lives, their bodies, their wills, and every ounce of effort to increase the wealth of masters, who regard them with less kindness and affection than they do for their dogs and horses. Kindness and affection are not the fate of those who work the land, carry the burdens, or turn logs into useful boards. This simple and natural reward would be a step toward humanity; but planters want none of it!
If negroes are permitted to become fathers, this fatal indulgence only tends to increase their misery: the poor companions of their scanty pleasures are likewise the companions of their labours; and when at some critical seasons they could wish to see them relieved, with tears in their eyes they behold them perhaps doubly oppressed, obliged to bear the burden of nature—a fatal present—as well as that of unabated tasks. How many have I seen cursing the irresistible propensity, and regretting, that by having tasted of those harmless joys, they had become the authors of double misery to their wives. Like their masters, they are not permitted to partake of those ineffable sensations with which nature inspires the hearts of fathers and mothers; they must repel them all, and become callous and passive. This unnatural state often occasions the most acute, the most pungent of their afflictions; they have no time, like us, tenderly to rear their helpless off-spring, to nurse them on their knees, to enjoy the delight of being parents. Their paternal fondness is embittered by considering, that if their children live, they must live to be slaves like themselves; no time is allowed them to exercise their pious office, the mothers must fasten them on their backs, and, with this double load, follow their husbands in the fields, where they too often hear no other sound than that of the voice or whip of the taskmaster, and the cries of their infants, broiling in the sun. These unfortunate creatures cry and weep like their parents, without a possibility of relief; the very instinct of the brute, so laudable, so irresistible, runs counter here to their master's interest; and to that god, all the laws of nature must give way. Thus planters get rich; so raw, so unexperienced am I in this mode of life, that were I to be possessed of a plantation, and my slaves treated as in general they are here, never could I rest in peace; my sleep would be perpetually disturbed by a retrospect of the frauds committed in Africa, in order to entrap them; frauds surpassing in enormity everything which a common mind can possibly conceive. I should be thinking of the barbarous treatment they meet with on ship-board; of their anguish, of the despair necessarily inspired by their situation, when torn from their friends and relations; when delivered into the hands of a people differently coloured, whom they cannot understand; carried in a strange machine over an ever agitated element, which they had never seen before; and finally delivered over to the severities of the whippers, and the excessive labours of the field. Can it be possible that the force of custom should ever make me deaf to all these reflections, and as insensible to the injustice of that trade, and to their miseries, as the rich inhabitants of this town seem to be? What then is man; this being who boasts so much of the excellence and dignity of his nature, among that variety of unscrutable mysteries, of unsolvable problems, with which he is surrounded? The reason why man has been thus created, is not the least astonishing! It is said, I know that they are much happier here than in the West Indies; because land being cheaper upon this continent than in those islands, the fields allowed them to raise their subsistence from, are in general more extensive. The only possible chance of any alleviation depends on the humour of the planters, who, bred in the midst of slaves, learn from the example of their parents to despise them; and seldom conceive either from religion or philosophy, any ideas that tend to make their fate less calamitous; except some strong native tenderness of heart, some rays of philanthropy, overcome the obduracy contracted by habit.
If Black people are allowed to become fathers, this harmful indulgence only adds to their suffering: the meager joys they share come with the burden of their hard work; and during difficult times, instead of seeing their loved ones relieved, they often watch in tears as their partners are even more oppressed, forced to handle the natural burdens—a tragic gift—along with their ongoing labor. How many have I seen cursing this unavoidable instinct, regretting that by indulging in those innocent pleasures, they brought double suffering upon their wives? Like their masters, they are not allowed to experience the profound emotions that nature brings to the hearts of parents; they must suppress those feelings and become indifferent and passive. This unnatural state often leads to their sharpest and most piercing pains; they have no time, like us, to tenderly nurture their helpless children, to hold them on their laps, to savor the joy of parenthood. Their parental love is tainted by the thought that if their kids survive, they'll become slaves like them; they have no time to fulfill their nurturing roles, with mothers forced to carry their babies on their backs while following their husbands to the fields, where they often hear nothing but the voice or whip of the taskmaster and the cries of their infants broiling in the sun. These unfortunate souls cry and weep like their parents, with no hope for relief; even the natural instinct of the animal—so admirable and irresistible—clashes with the interests of their masters; and to that master, all the laws of nature must yield. This is how planters become wealthy; I am so inexperienced in this way of life that if I had a plantation, and my slaves were treated as they are here, I could never find peace; my sleep would be constantly interrupted by memories of the deceptions perpetrated in Africa to ensnare them—deceptions beyond anything a common mind could conceive. I would be haunted by thoughts of their brutal treatment on board ships; their anguish, the despair stemming from being ripped away from their loved ones; delivered into the hands of people who look different and whom they cannot understand; transported in a strange vessel over an endlessly turbulent sea they had never seen before; and finally handed over to the cruel whips and excessive labor of the fields. Is it possible that the force of habit could ever make me ignore these thoughts and become as indifferent to the injustice of that trade and their suffering as the wealthy people in this town seem to be? What, then, is man; this being who takes so much pride in the greatness and dignity of his nature, amid so many perplexing mysteries and unsolvable dilemmas surrounding him? The reason for man's creation is no less astonishing! I have heard it said that they are much happier here than in the West Indies; because land is cheaper here than in those islands, the areas they are allowed to cultivate for their own sustenance are generally larger. Any chance for relief depends on the sentiments of the planters, who, having grown up surrounded by slaves, learn from their parents to look down on them; and they rarely derive insights from religion or philosophy that would ease their plight, unless a strong natural kindness or glimmer of compassion breaks through the hardness instilled by habit.
I have not resided here long enough to become insensible of pain for the objects which I every day behold. In the choice of my friends and acquaintance, I always endeavour to find out those whose dispositions are somewhat congenial with my own. We have slaves likewise in our northern provinces; I hope the time draws near when they will be all emancipated: but how different their lot, how different their situation, in every possible respect! They enjoy as much liberty as their masters, they are as well clad, and as well fed; in health and sickness they are tenderly taken care of; they live under the same roof, and are, truly speaking, a part of our families. Many of them are taught to read and write, and are well instructed in the principles of religion; they are the companions of our labours, and treated as such; they enjoy many perquisites, many established holidays, and are not obliged to work more than white people. They marry where inclination leads them; visit their wives every week; are as decently clad as the common people; they are indulged in educating, cherishing, and chastising their children, who are taught subordination to them as to their lawful parents: in short, they participate in many of the benefits of our society, without being obliged to bear any of its burdens. They are fat, healthy, and hearty, and far from repining at their fate; they think themselves happier than many of the lower class whites: they share with their masters the wheat and meat provision they help to raise; many of those whom the good Quakers have emancipated have received that great benefit with tears of regret, and have never quitted, though free, their former masters and benefactors.
I haven't lived here long enough to become numb to the pain of the things I see every day. When choosing my friends and acquaintances, I always try to find those whose personalities are somewhat similar to mine. We also have slaves in our northern states; I hope the time is coming when they will all be free: but how different their lives, how different their situations, in every way possible! They enjoy as much freedom as their masters, they are as well-dressed and well-fed; in sickness and health, they are cared for with kindness; they live in the same house and are, truly, a part of our families. Many of them are taught to read and write, and are well-educated in the principles of religion; they are our work companions and treated as such; they benefit from many perks, many established holidays, and are not required to work more than white people. They marry based on their feelings; they visit their wives every week; they are as decently dressed as the common folk; they are allowed to educate, care for, and discipline their children, who are taught to respect them as their rightful parents: in short, they share in many of the benefits of our society without having to bear any of its burdens. They are fat, healthy, and strong, and are far from complaining about their fate; they believe themselves happier than many lower-class whites: they share with their masters the grain and meat they help to produce; many of those whom the good Quakers have freed have received that great benefit with tears of regret, and have never left, even though free, their former masters and benefactors.
But is it really true, as I have heard it asserted here, that those blacks are incapable of feeling the spurs of emulation, and the cheerful sound of encouragement? By no means; there are a thousand proofs existing of their gratitude and fidelity: those hearts in which such noble dispositions can grow, are then like ours, they are susceptible of every generous sentiment, of every useful motive of action; they are capable of receiving lights, of imbibing ideas that would greatly alleviate the weight of their miseries. But what methods have in general been made use of to obtain so desirable an end? None; the day in which they arrive and are sold, is the first of their labours; labours, which from that hour admit of no respite; for though indulged by law with relaxation on Sundays, they are obliged to employ that time which is intended for rest, to till their little plantations. What can be expected from wretches in such circumstances? Forced from their native country, cruelly treated when on board, and not less so on the plantations to which they are driven; is there anything in this treatment but what must kindle all the passions, sow the seeds of inveterate resentment, and nourish a wish of perpetual revenge? They are left to the irresistible effects of those strong and natural propensities; the blows they receive, are they conducive to extinguish them, or to win their affections? They are neither soothed by the hopes that their slavery will ever terminate but with their lives; or yet encouraged by the goodness of their food, or the mildness of their treatment. The very hopes held out to mankind by religion, that consolatory system, so useful to the miserable, are never presented to them; neither moral nor physical means are made use of to soften their chains; they are left in their original and untutored state; that very state wherein the natural propensities of revenge and warm passions are so soon kindled. Cheered by no one single motive that can impel the will, or excite their efforts; nothing but terrors and punishments are presented to them; death is denounced if they run away; horrid delaceration if they speak with their native freedom; perpetually awed by the terrible cracks of whips, or by the fear of capital punishments, while even those punishments often fail of their purpose.
But is it really true, as I've heard people say here, that those Black individuals are incapable of feeling the drive to compete or the uplifting sound of encouragement? Absolutely not; there are countless examples of their gratitude and loyalty. Their hearts, capable of such noble traits, are just like ours—they can embrace every generous sentiment and every motivation for action. They can receive knowledge and absorb ideas that would greatly lighten their burdens. But what methods have generally been used to achieve such a desirable outcome? None; the day they arrive and are sold is the start of their labor, which continues without a break; even though the law allows them some rest on Sundays, they must use that time to tend to their small farms. What can we expect from people in such situations? Taken from their homeland, mistreated at sea, and equally mistreated on the plantations they are forced into; is there anything in this treatment that wouldn't ignite all kinds of emotions, plant the seeds of deep resentment, and foster a desire for endless revenge? They are left vulnerable to the overwhelming power of those strong, natural instincts. The blows they receive—do they help to extinguish these feelings or win their affection? They are not comforted by the hope that their slavery will ever end except with their lives, nor encouraged by the quality of their food or the kindness of their treatment. The very hopes offered to humanity by religion, that comforting system so beneficial to the suffering, are never presented to them; no moral or physical measures are taken to lighten their chains. They remain in their original, untaught state, a state where the natural instincts of revenge and intense feelings can easily ignite. They are not motivated by a single reason that could drive their will or inspire their efforts; only terror and punishment are shown to them—death is threatened if they attempt to escape; horrible punishment if they speak freely in their native tongue; constantly intimidated by the loud sounds of whips or the fear of severe penalties, while even those penalties often fail to achieve their intended purpose.
A clergyman settled a few years ago at George-Town, and feeling as I do now, warmly recommended to the planters, from the pulpit, a relaxation of severity; he introduced the benignity of Christianity, and pathetically made use of the admirable precepts of that system to melt the hearts of his congregation into a greater degree of compassion toward their slaves than had been hitherto customary; "Sir," said one of his hearers, "we pay you a genteel salary to read to us the prayers of the liturgy, and to explain to us such parts of the Gospel as the rule of the church directs; but we do not want you to teach us what we are to do with our blacks." The clergyman found it prudent to withhold any farther admonition. Whence this astonishing right, or rather this barbarous custom, for most certainly we have no kind of right beyond that of force? We are told, it is true, that slavery cannot be so repugnant to human nature as we at first imagine, because it has been practised in all ages, and in all nations: the Lacedemonians themselves, those great assertors of liberty, conquered the Helotes with the design of making them their slaves; the Romans, whom we consider as our masters in civil and military policy, lived in the exercise of the most horrid oppression; they conquered to plunder and to enslave. What a hideous aspect the face of the earth must then have exhibited! Provinces, towns, districts, often depopulated! their inhabitants driven to Rome, the greatest market in the world, and there sold by thousands! The Roman dominions were tilled by the hands of unfortunate people, who had once been, like their victors, free, rich, and possessed of every benefit society can confer; until they became subject to the cruel right of war, and to lawless force. Is there then no superintending power who conducts the moral operations of the world, as well as the physical? The same sublime hand which guides the planets round the sun with so much exactness, which preserves the arrangement of the whole with such exalted wisdom and paternal care, and prevents the vast system from falling into confusion; doth it abandon mankind to all the errors, the follies, and the miseries, which their most frantic rage, and their most dangerous vices and passions can produce?
A clergyman moved to George-Town a few years ago, and feeling as I do now, passionately urged the planters, from the pulpit, to ease their harshness; he introduced the kindness of Christianity and tearfully used the wonderful teachings of that system to soften his congregation's hearts and foster greater compassion toward their slaves than had been customary. "Sir," said one of the listeners, "we pay you a respectable salary to read the prayers of the liturgy and explain the parts of the Gospel that the church rule mandates; but we do not want you to tell us how to treat our black slaves." The clergyman wisely decided to stop any further advice. Where does this astonishing right, or rather this cruel custom, come from, since we certainly have no right beyond the use of force? We are told, it's true, that slavery can't be as opposed to human nature as we initially think, because it has been practiced in all ages and in all nations: the Spartans themselves, those famous champions of liberty, conquered the Helots to make them their slaves; the Romans, whom we regard as our authorities in civil and military matters, lived under the most terrible oppression; they conquered to loot and enslave. How hideous the earth must have looked! Provinces, towns, and regions often depopulated! Their residents driven to Rome, the largest market in the world, and there sold by the thousands! The Roman Empire was worked by the hands of unfortunate people who had once been, like their conquerors, free, wealthy, and had enjoyed every benefit that society can provide; until they fell victim to the cruel right of war and unchecked force. Is there no higher power guiding the moral workings of the world, as well as the physical? The same magnificent hand that directs the planets around the sun so precisely, maintains the harmony of the universe with such great wisdom and paternal care, preventing the entire system from descending into chaos; does it really abandon humanity to all the mistakes, the foolishness, and the suffering that their wild anger, and their most dangerous vices and passions can create?
The history of the earth! doth it present anything but crimes of the most heinous nature, committed from one end of the world to the other? We observe avarice, rapine, and murder, equally prevailing in all parts. History perpetually tells us of millions of people abandoned to the caprice of the maddest princes, and of whole nations devoted to the blind fury of tyrants. Countries destroyed; nations alternately buried in ruins by other nations; some parts of the world beautifully cultivated, returned again to the pristine state; the fruits of ages of industry, the toil of thousands in a short time destroyed by a few! If one corner breathes in peace for a few years, it is, in turn subjected, torn, and levelled; one would almost believe the principles of action in man, considered as the first agent of this planet, to be poisoned in their most essential parts. We certainly are not that class of beings which we vainly think ourselves to be; man an animal of prey, seems to have rapine and the love of bloodshed implanted in his heart; nay, to hold it the most honourable occupation in society: we never speak of a hero of mathematics, a hero of knowledge of humanity; no, this illustrious appellation is reserved for the most successful butchers of the world. If Nature has given us a fruitful soil to inhabit, she has refused us such inclinations and propensities as would afford us the full enjoyment of it. Extensive as the surface of this planet is, not one half of it is yet cultivated, not half replenished; she created man, and placed him either in the woods or plains, and provided him with passions which must for ever oppose his happiness; everything is submitted to the power of the strongest; men, like the elements, are always at war; the weakest yield to the most potent; force, subtlety, and malice, always triumph over unguarded honesty and simplicity. Benignity, moderation, and justice, are virtues adapted only to the humble paths of life: we love to talk of virtue and to admire its beauty, while in the shade of solitude and retirement; but when we step forth into active life, if it happen to be in competition with any passion or desire, do we observe it to prevail? Hence so many religious impostors have triumphed over the credulity of mankind, and have rendered their frauds the creeds of succeeding generations, during the course of many ages; until worn away by time, they have been replaced by new ones. Hence the most unjust war, if supported by the greatest force, always succeeds; hence the most just ones, when supported only by their justice, as often fail. Such is the ascendancy of power; the supreme arbiter of all the revolutions which we observe in this planet: so irresistible is power, that it often thwarts the tendency of the most forcible causes, and prevents their subsequent salutary effects, though ordained for the good of man by the Governor of the universe. Such is the perverseness of human nature; who can describe it in all its latitude?
The history of the earth! Does it show us anything but the most atrocious crimes, happening all over the world? We see greed, plunder, and murder equally widespread. History constantly tells us about millions of people left at the mercy of the craziest rulers, and entire nations suffering under the reckless rage of tyrants. Countries are destroyed; nations rise and fall, buried in the ruins created by others; some areas that were once beautifully cultivated return to their original state; the results of centuries of labor, the hard work of thousands, quickly wiped out by a few! If one place enjoys peace for a few years, it is soon subjected to chaos, torn apart and leveled; one might almost believe that human behavior, when considered as the driving force of this planet, is fundamentally corrupted. We are certainly not the beings we naively think we are; man as a predator seems to have greed and a thirst for violence built into his nature; indeed, he regards it as the most honorable job in society: we never talk about a hero of mathematics, a hero of humanitarian knowledge; no, that esteemed title is reserved for the most successful slaughterers of the world. If Nature has provided us with fertile land to live on, she has denied us the inclinations and traits that would allow us to fully enjoy it. Vast as this planet’s surface is, less than half of it is cultivated, and not even half is populated; she created man and placed him in forests or plains, giving him passions that will forever conflict with his happiness; everything is subject to the might of the strongest; men, like natural forces, are always at war; the weak submit to the powerful; strength, cunning, and malice inevitably triumph over unguarded honesty and simplicity. Kindness, moderation, and justice are virtues suited only for the simpler paths of life: we love to talk about virtue and admire its beauty while we are in solitude and seclusion; but when we step into the active world, if we come up against any passion or desire, does virtue prevail? This is why so many religious frauds have exploited human gullibility, turning their deceptions into the beliefs of generations over many ages; and as they fade over time, they are replaced by new ones. Thus, the most unjust wars, backed by the greatest might, always succeed; while just wars, relying solely on their righteousness, often fail. Such is the dominance of power; the ultimate judge of all the changes we see on this planet: power is so overwhelming that it often disrupts the most effective causes and blocks their subsequent positive outcomes, even when intended for the good of humanity by the universe's ruler. Such is the perversion of human nature; who can fully describe it?
In the moments of our philanthropy we often talk of an indulgent nature, a kind parent, who for the benefit of mankind has taken singular pains to vary the genera of plants, fruits, grain, and the different productions of the earth; and has spread peculiar blessings in each climate. This is undoubtedly an object of contemplation which calls forth our warmest gratitude; for so singularly benevolent have those parental intentions been, that where barrenness of soil or severity of climate prevail, there she has implanted in the heart of man, sentiments which overbalance every misery, and supply the place of every want. She has given to the inhabitants of these regions, an attachment to their savage rocks and wild shores, unknown to those who inhabit the fertile fields of the temperate zone. Yet if we attentively view this globe, will it not appear rather a place of punishment, than of delight? And what misfortune! that those punishments should fall on the innocent, and its few delights be enjoyed by the most unworthy. Famine, diseases, elementary convulsions, human feuds, dissensions, etc., are the produce of every climate; each climate produces besides, vices, and miseries peculiar to its latitude. View the frigid sterility of the north, whose famished inhabitants hardly acquainted with the sun, live and fare worse than the bears they hunt: and to which they are superior only in the faculty of speaking. View the arctic and antarctic regions, those huge voids, where nothing lives; regions of eternal snow: where winter in all his horrors has established his throne, and arrested every creative power of nature. Will you call the miserable stragglers in these countries by the name of men? Now contrast this frigid power of the north and south with that of the sun; examine the parched lands of the torrid zone, replete with sulphureous exhalations; view those countries of Asia subject to pestilential infections which lay nature waste; view this globe often convulsed both from within and without; pouring forth from several mouths, rivers of boiling matter, which are imperceptibly leaving immense subterranean graves, wherein millions will one day perish! Look at the poisonous soil of the equator, at those putrid slimy tracks, teeming with horrid monsters, the enemies of the human race; look next at the sandy continent, scorched perhaps by the fatal approach of some ancient comet, now the abode of desolation. Examine the rains, the convulsive storms of those climates, where masses of sulphur, bitumen, and electrical fire, combining their dreadful powers, are incessantly hovering and bursting over a globe threatened with dissolution. On this little shell, how very few are the spots where man can live and flourish? even under those mild climates which seem to breathe peace and happiness, the poison of slavery, the fury of despotism, and the rage of superstition, are all combined against man! There only the few live and rule, whilst the many starve and utter ineffectual complaints: there, human nature appears more debased, perhaps than in the less favoured climates. The fertile plains of Asia, the rich low lands of Egypt and of Diarbeck, the fruitful fields bordering on the Tigris and the Euphrates, the extensive country of the East Indies in all its separate districts; all these must to the geographical eye, seem as if intended for terrestrial paradises: but though surrounded with the spontaneous riches of nature, though her kindest favours seem to be shed on those beautiful regions with the most profuse hand; yet there in general we find the most wretched people in the world. Almost everywhere, liberty so natural to mankind is refused, or rather enjoyed but by their tyrants; the word slave, is the appellation of every rank, who adore as a divinity, a being worse than themselves; subject to every caprice, and to every lawless rage which unrestrained power can give. Tears are shed, perpetual groans are heard, where only the accents of peace, alacrity, and gratitude should resound. There the very delirium of tyranny tramples on the best gifts of nature, and sports with the fate, the happiness, the lives of millions: there the extreme fertility of the ground always indicates the extreme misery of the inhabitants!
In our moments of giving back, we often refer to a nurturing nature, a kind parent, who for the benefit of humanity has gone to great lengths to diversify the types of plants, fruits, grains, and various products of the earth; and has spread unique blessings in each climate. This is certainly a subject for reflection that inspires our deepest gratitude; for those parental intentions have been so uniquely benevolent that where poor soil or harsh climates exist, there she has instilled in the hearts of people sentiments that outweigh every hardship and fulfill every need. She has given the people of these regions a bond with their rugged landscapes and wild shores, unlike those who inhabit the fertile lands of more temperate zones. Yet, if we closely examine this globe, doesn’t it seem more like a place of punishment than one of joy? And what a tragedy that these punishments befall the innocent, while a few pleasures are experienced by the most undeserving. Hunger, disease, natural disasters, human conflicts, and strife are found in every climate; each environment brings with it vices and miseries unique to its location. Consider the frigid desolation of the north, whose starving residents barely see the sun, living and suffering worse than the bears they hunt: and they are superior only in their ability to speak. Look at the Arctic and Antarctic regions, vast emptiness where nothing survives; realms of eternal snow: where winter, in all its terror, has established its domination, halting every creative force of nature. Do you really want to call the unfortunate wanderers in these areas human? Now contrast this cold dominance of the north and south with that of the sun; examine the parched lands of the hot zone, filled with toxic fumes; look at those areas in Asia plagued by diseases that ravage the land; view this globe often shaken both from within and above; spewing from various openings, rivers of molten material, which are quietly creating vast underground graves, where millions will one day perish! Observe the toxic soil of the equator, those filthy, slimy places, alive with dreadful creatures, the enemies of mankind; then look at the sandy continent, scorched perhaps by the deadly approach of some ancient comet, now a land of desolation. Examine the storms, the violent weather of those climates, where masses of sulfur, bitumen, and electrical fire, combining their dreadful forces, constantly hover and erupt over a globe threatened with ruin. On this little sphere, how very few places allow humans to survive and thrive? Even in those mild climates that seem to exude peace and joy, the poison of slavery, the fury of oppression, and the rage of superstition all gang up on humanity! Only a few thrive and hold power, while the many suffer and voice powerless complaints: there, human nature appears more degraded than in less favored climates. The lush plains of Asia, the fertile lowlands of Egypt and Diarbeck, the rich fields along the Tigris and Euphrates, the vast regions of the East Indies in all their various areas; all these must, to a geographer’s eye, look like they were meant for earthly paradises: yet, despite being surrounded by nature’s abundant gifts, despite her kindest blessings seeming to lavish those beautiful lands, we generally find the most miserable people in the world there. Almost everywhere, the liberty so inherent to mankind is denied, or rather only enjoyed by their oppressors; the term slave is a label for every class, who worship a being more wretched than themselves; subject to every whim, and to every uncontrolled rage that unchecked power can unleash. Tears are shed, perpetual groans are heard, where only sounds of peace, joy, and gratitude should resonate. There the madness of tyranny crushes the best gifts of nature and plays with the fate, the happiness, the lives of millions: there, the extreme fertility of the land always signals the extreme misery of its people!
Everywhere one part of the human species are taught the art of shedding the blood of the other; of setting fire to their dwellings; of levelling the works of their industry: half of the existence of nations regularly employed in destroying other nations.—"What little political felicity is to be met with here and there, has cost oceans of blood to purchase; as if good was never to be the portion of unhappy man. Republics, kingdoms, monarchies, founded either on fraud or successful violence, increase by pursuing the steps of the same policy, until they are destroyed in their turn, either by the influence of their own crimes, or by more successful but equally criminal enemies."
Everywhere, one part of humanity is taught the skill of spilling the blood of others; of burning down their homes; of destroying their industries. Half of the existence of nations is consistently spent in the destruction of other nations. "The little political happiness found here and there has cost rivers of blood to obtain; as if goodness was never meant to be the fate of miserable humanity. Republics, kingdoms, and monarchies, built either on deception or successful violence, grow by following the same policies until they eventually fall, either due to the consequences of their own wrongdoings or by more successful but equally immoral opponents."
If from this general review of human nature, we descend to the examination of what is called civilised society; there the combination of every natural and artificial want, makes us pay very dear for what little share of political felicity we enjoy. It is a strange heterogeneous assemblage of vices and virtues, and of a variety of other principles, for ever at war, for ever jarring, for ever producing some dangerous, some distressing extreme. Where do you conceive then that nature intended we should be happy? Would you prefer the state of men in the woods, to that of men in a more improved situation? Evil preponderates in both; in the first they often eat each other for want of food, and in the other they often starve each other for want of room. For my part, I think the vices and miseries to be found in the latter, exceed those of the former; in which real evil is more scarce, more supportable, and less enormous. Yet we wish to see the earth peopled; to accomplish the happiness of kingdoms, which is said to consist in numbers. Gracious God! to what end is the introduction of so many beings into a mode of existence in which they must grope amidst as many errors, commit as many crimes, and meet with as many diseases, wants, and sufferings!
If we take a step back and look at human nature, then move on to what we call civilized society, it becomes clear that the combination of all our natural and artificial needs makes us pay a high price for the little bit of political happiness we enjoy. It’s a strange mix of vices and virtues, along with various other principles, always at odds with one another, constantly clashing, and often leading to dangerous or distressing extremes. So, where do you think nature intended for us to be happy? Would you choose the life of people in the woods over those in a more developed situation? There’s evil in both; in the first, people often resort to cannibalism due to lack of food, and in the latter, they often starve one another because there isn’t enough space. Personally, I think the vices and miseries found in the latter are worse than those in the former, where real evil is rarer, more manageable, and less extreme. Yet we wish to see the earth populated, striving for the happiness of nations, which is said to rely on numbers. Gracious God! What’s the point of bringing so many beings into a way of life where they must navigate through countless mistakes, commit numerous crimes, and encounter endless diseases, needs, and suffering?
The following scene will I hope account for these melancholy reflections, and apologise for the gloomy thoughts with which I have filled this letter: my mind is, and always has been, oppressed since I became a witness to it. I was not long since invited to dine with a planter who lived three miles from——, where he then resided. In order to avoid the heat of the sun, I resolved to go on foot, sheltered in a small path, leading through a pleasant wood. I was leisurely travelling along, attentively examining some peculiar plants which I had collected, when all at once I felt the air strongly agitated, though the day was perfectly calm and sultry. I immediately cast my eyes toward the cleared ground, from which I was but at a small distance, in order to see whether it was not occasioned by a sudden shower; when at that instant a sound resembling a deep rough voice, uttered, as I thought, a few inarticulate monosyllables. Alarmed and surprised, I precipitately looked all round, when I perceived at about six rods distance something resembling a cage, suspended to the limbs of a tree; all the branches of which appeared covered with large birds of prey, fluttering about, and anxiously endeavouring to perch on the cage. Actuated by an involuntary motion of my hands, more than by any design of my mind, I fired at them; they all flew to a short distance, with a most hideous noise: when, horrid to think and painful to repeat, I perceived a negro, suspended in the cage, and left there to expire! I shudder when I recollect that the birds had already picked out his eyes, his cheek bones were bare; his arms had been attacked in several places, and his body seemed covered with a multitude of wounds. From the edges of the hollow sockets and from the lacerations with which he was disfigured, the blood slowly dropped, and tinged the ground beneath. No sooner were the birds flown, than swarms of insects covered the whole body of this unfortunate wretch, eager to feed on his mangled flesh and to drink his blood. I found myself suddenly arrested by the power of affright and terror; my nerves were convoked; I trembled, I stood motionless, involuntarily contemplating the fate of this negro, in all its dismal latitude. The living spectre, though deprived of his eyes, could still distinctly hear, and in his uncouth dialect begged me to give him some water to allay his thirst. Humanity herself would have recoiled back with horror; she would have balanced whether to lessen such reliefless distress, or mercifully with one blow to end this dreadful scene of agonising torture! Had I had a ball in my gun, I certainly should have despatched him; but finding myself unable to perform so kind an office, I sought, though trembling, to relieve him as well as I could. A shell ready fixed to a pole, which had been used by some negroes, presented itself to me; filled it with water, and with trembling hands I guided it to the quivering lips of the wretched sufferer. Urged by the irresistible power of thirst, he endeavoured to meet it, as he instinctively guessed its approach by the noise it made in passing through the bars of the cage. "Tanke, you white man, tanke you, pute some poison and give me." "How long have you been hanging there?" I asked him. "Two days, and me no die; the birds, the birds; aaah me!" Oppressed with the reflections which this shocking spectacle afforded me, I mustered strength enough to walk away, and soon reached the house at which I intended to dine. There I heard that the reason for this slave being thus punished, was on account of his having killed the overseer of the plantation. They told me that the laws of self-preservation rendered such executions necessary; and supported the doctrine of slavery with the arguments generally made use of to justify the practice; with the repetition of which I shall not trouble you at present.—Adieu.
The following scene will, I hope, explain these sad thoughts and apologize for the dark feelings that have filled this letter: my mind is, and always has been, weighed down since I witnessed it. Not too long ago, I was invited to dinner with a planter who lived three miles from——, where he was then residing. To escape the heat of the sun, I decided to walk along a small path that led through a lovely wood. I was casually making my way, paying close attention to some unusual plants I had collected, when suddenly I felt the air stir strongly, even though the day was completely calm and muggy. I immediately glanced toward the cleared ground nearby to see if it was caused by an unexpected shower; at that moment, I heard a sound that resembled a deep, rough voice mumbling, as I thought, a few unclear words. Alarmed and surprised, I quickly looked around and noticed something that looked like a cage, hanging from a tree about six rods away. The branches were filled with large birds of prey, fluttering and desperately trying to land on the cage. Acting more on instinct than intent, I shot at them; they all flew a short distance away with a terrible noise. Then, horrifying to think about and painful to recount, I saw a black man hanging in the cage, left there to die! I shudder to remember that the birds had already picked out his eyes; his cheekbones were bare, and his arms were damaged in several places, with his body covered in wounds. Blood dripped slowly from the empty sockets and from the gashes that disfigured him, staining the ground below. No sooner had the birds flown away than swarms of insects covered the entire body of this unfortunate man, eager to feed on his mangled flesh and drink his blood. I suddenly found myself frozen in fear and terror; my nerves were on edge; I trembled, standing still, involuntarily contemplating this man’s fate in all its grim detail. The living specter, though blind, could still hear and, in his strange dialect, begged me for water to quench his thirst. Any sense of humanity would have recoiled in horror; it would have been torn between wanting to alleviate his suffering or mercifully ending his agonizing ordeal with one blow! If I had had a bullet in my gun, I surely would have ended his suffering; but realizing I couldn’t perform that simple act of kindness, I nervously sought to help him as best I could. I spotted a shell fixed to a pole from some past use by other black men; I filled it with water and, with trembling hands, I guided it to the quivering lips of the poor sufferer. Driven by unstoppable thirst, he tried to reach for it, guessing its approach by the noise it made as it passed through the cage bars. “Thank you, white man, thank you, put some poison and give me.” “How long have you been hanging there?” I asked him. “Two days, and I haven’t died; the birds, the birds; aaah me!” Struggling with the reflections this horrific scene caused me, I found the strength to walk away and soon reached the house where I was supposed to dine. There, I learned that this slave was being punished for killing the plantation overseer. They told me that the laws of self-preservation made such executions necessary; they defended the institution of slavery with the typical arguments used to justify the practice. I won’t trouble you with those now. —Adieu.
LETTER X
ON SNAKES; AND ON THE HUMMING BIRD
Why would you prescribe this task; you know that what we take up ourselves seems always lighter than what is imposed on us by others. You insist on my saying something about our snakes; and in relating what I know concerning them, were it not for two singularities, the one of which I saw, and the other I received from an eye-witness, I should have but very little to observe. The southern provinces are the countries where nature has formed the greatest variety of alligators, snakes, serpents; and scorpions, from the smallest size, up to the pine barren, the largest species known here. We have but two, whose stings are mortal, which deserve to be mentioned; as for the black one, it is remarkable for nothing but its industry, agility, beauty, and the art of enticing birds by the power of its eyes. I admire it much, and never kill it, though its formidable length and appearance often get the better of the philosophy of some people, particularly of Europeans. The most dangerous one is the pilot, or copperhead; for the poison of which no remedy has yet been discovered. It bears the first name because it always precedes the rattlesnake; that is, quits its state of torpidity in the spring a week before the other. It bears the second name on account of its head being adorned with many copper-coloured spots. It lurks in rocks near the water, and is extremely active and dangerous. Let man beware of it! I have heard only of one person who was stung by a copperhead in this country. The poor wretch instantly swelled in a most dreadful manner; a multitude of spots of different hues alternately appeared and vanished, on different parts of his body; his eyes were filled with madness and rage, he cast them on all present with the most vindictive looks: he thrust out his tongue as the snakes do; he hissed through his teeth with inconceivable strength, and became an object of terror to all by-standers. To the lividness of a corpse he united the desperate force of a maniac; they hardly were able to fasten him, so as to guard themselves from his attacks; when in the space of two hours death relieved the poor wretch from his struggles, and the spectators from their apprehensions. The poison of the rattlesnake is not mortal in so short a space, and hence there is more time to procure relief; we are acquainted with several antidotes with which almost every family is provided. They are extremely inactive, and if not touched, are perfectly inoffensive. I once saw, as I was travelling, a great cliff which was full of them; I handled several, and they appeared to be dead; they were all entwined together, and thus they remain until the return of the sun. I found them out, by following the track of some wild hogs which had fed on them; and even the Indians often regale on them. When they find them asleep, they put a small forked stick over their necks, which they keep immovably fixed on the ground; giving the snake a piece of leather to bite: and this they pull back several times with great force, until they observe their two poisonous fangs torn out. Then they cut off the head, skin the body, and cook it as we do eels; and their flesh is extremely sweet and white. I once saw a TAMED ONE, as gentle as you can possibly conceive a reptile to be; it took to the water and swam whenever it pleased; and when the boys to whom it belonged called it back, their summons was readily obeyed. It had been deprived of its fangs by the preceding method; they often stroked it with a soft brush, and this friction seemed to cause the most pleasing sensations, for it would turn on its back to enjoy it, as a cat does before the fire. One of this species was the cause, some years ago, of a most deplorable accident which I shall relate to you, as I had it from the widow and mother of the victims. A Dutch farmer of the Minisink went to mowing, with his negroes, in his boots, a precaution used to prevent being stung. Inadvertently he trod on a snake, which immediately flew at his legs; and as it drew back in order to renew its blow, one of his negroes cut it in two with his scythe. They prosecuted their work, and returned home; at night the farmer pulled off his boots and went to bed; and was soon after attacked with a strange sickness at his stomach; he swelled, and before a physician could be sent for, died. The sudden death of this man did not cause much inquiry; the neighbourhood wondered, as is usual in such cases, and without any further examination the corpse was buried. A few days after, the son put on his father's boots, and went to the meadow; at night he pulled them off, went to bed, and was attacked with the same symptoms about the same time, and died in the morning. A little before he expired the doctor came, but was not able to assign what could be the cause of so singular a disorder; however, rather than appear wholly at a loss before the country people, he pronounced both father and son to have been bewitched. Some weeks after, the widow sold all the movables for the benefit of the younger children; and the farm was leased. One of the neighbours, who bought the boots, presently put them on, and was attacked in the same manner as the other two had been; but this man's wife being alarmed by what had happened in the former family, despatched one of her negroes for an eminent physician, who fortunately having heard something of the dreadful affair, guessed at the cause, applied oil, etc. and recovered the man. The boots which had been so fatal, were then carefully examined; and he found that the two fangs of the snake had been left in the leather, after being wrenched out of their sockets by the strength with which the snake had drawn back its head. The bladders which contained the poison and several of the small nerves were still fresh, and adhered to the boot. The unfortunate father and son had been poisoned by pulling off these boots, in which action they imperceptibly scratched their legs with the points of the fangs, through the hollow of which, some of this astonishing poison was conveyed. You have no doubt heard of their rattles, if you have not seen them; the only observation I wish to make is, that the rattling is loud and distinct when they are angry; and on the contrary, when pleased, it sounds like a distant trepidation, in which nothing distinct is heard. In the thick settlements, they are now become very scarce; for wherever they are met with, open war is declared against them; so that in a few years there will be none left but on our mountains. The black snake on the contrary always diverts me because it excites no idea of danger. Their swiftness is astonishing; they will sometimes equal that of a horse; at other times they will climb up trees in quest of our tree toads; or glide on the ground at full length. On some occasions they present themselves half in the reptile state, half erect; their eyes and their heads in the erect posture appear to great advantage: the former display a fire which I have often admired, and it is by these they are enabled to fascinate birds and squirrels. When they have fixed their eyes on an animal, they become immovable; only turning their head sometimes to the right and sometimes to the left, but still with their sight invariably directed to the object. The distracted victim, instead of flying its enemy, seems to be arrested by some invincible power; it screams; now approaches, and then recedes; and after skipping about with unaccountable agitation, finally rushes into the jaws of the snake, and is swallowed, as soon as it is covered with a slime or glue to make it slide easily down the throat of the devourer.
Why would you assign this task? You know that what we choose to do ourselves always feels lighter than what others impose on us. You insist that I say something about our snakes; and in sharing what I know about them, if it weren't for two unique aspects—one that I witnessed, and the other I got from an eyewitness—I would have very little to report. The southern provinces are where nature has created the greatest variety of alligators, snakes, serpents, and scorpions, ranging from the smallest to the largest type here, which is the pine barren. We only have two that have deadly stings worth mentioning; as for the black one, it is notable only for its cleverness, speed, beauty, and its ability to lure birds with the power of its eyes. I admire it greatly and never kill it, although its impressive length and looks often unsettle some people, especially Europeans. The most dangerous one is the pilot or copperhead, for which no remedy for its poison has been found yet. It is called the pilot because it always emerges from hibernation a week before the rattlesnake in the spring. It has the second name due to its head being marked with many copper-colored spots. It hides among the rocks near water and is extremely active and dangerous. People should be cautious of it! I have only heard of one person getting bitten by a copperhead in this area. The poor guy swelled up in a terrifying way; a multitude of different colored spots appeared and disappeared on his body; his eyes were wild with madness and rage, shooting vindictive looks at everyone around him: he stuck out his tongue like snakes do and hissed through his teeth with incredible force, becoming a terrifying sight for everyone nearby. He combined the pallor of a corpse with the frantic strength of a maniac; they could hardly restrain him to protect themselves from his attacks; within two hours, death freed the poor guy from his struggles and the bystanders from their fears. The poison of the rattlesnake isn't deadly that quickly, so there's more time to find help; we know several antidotes that almost every family keeps on hand. They are very passive, and if not disturbed, they are completely harmless. Once, while traveling, I came across a large cliff full of them; I handled several, and they seemed lifeless; they were all coiled together and remained that way until the sun returned. I discovered them by following the trail of some wild hogs that had eaten them; even the Indians often feast on them. When they find them asleep, they place a small forked stick over their necks, which they hold firmly to the ground, giving the snake a piece of leather to bite; then they pull it back forcefully several times until they see the two poisonous fangs are pulled out. Then they cut off the head, skin the body, and cook it like we cook eels; the meat is very sweet and white. I once saw a TAMED ONE, as gentle as a reptile can be; it would swim whenever it wanted; and when the boys who owned it called it back, it complied readily. It had been defanged using the method I mentioned; they often stroked it with a soft brush, and this seemed to give it a pleasurable sensation, as it would roll onto its back to enjoy it, just like a cat does in front of a fire. A few years ago, one of this species caused a tragic incident that I will share with you, as it was told to me by the widow and mother of the victims. A Dutch farmer in the Minisink went to mow with his workers while wearing boots, a precaution against being stung. Accidentally, he stepped on a snake, which immediately struck at his legs; when it recoiled to strike again, one of his workers cut it in two with his scythe. They continued their work and returned home; at night, the farmer took off his boots and went to bed, soon afterward suffering from a strange stomach illness; he swelled up, and before a doctor could be called, he died. His sudden death didn’t raise much concern; the neighbors were curious, as usually happens in such situations, but without further investigation, the body was buried. A few days later, the son put on his father's boots and went to the meadow; at night he took them off, went to bed, and experienced the same symptoms at the same time, dying in the morning. Just before he died, the doctor arrived but couldn't figure out what caused such a strange illness; still, rather than admit he had no idea, he told the locals that both father and son had been bewitched. A few weeks later, the widow sold off all the belongings for the benefit of the younger children, and the farm was rented out. One neighbor bought the boots, put them on, and got sick in the same way as the others; however, his wife, alarmed by what had happened to the previous family, sent one of her workers for a well-known doctor. Luckily, he had heard something of the horrific incident and suspected the cause, applying oil, etc., and managed to save the man. The deadly boots were then carefully examined; he found that the two fangs of the snake had been left in the leather, pulled out of their sockets by the force with which the snake had drawn back its head. The bladders containing the poison and several small nerves were still intact and stuck to the boots. The unfortunate father and son had been poisoned by putting on these boots, unknowingly scratching their legs with the points of the fangs, which allowed some of that astonishing poison to enter their bodies. You've probably heard about their rattles, if you haven't seen them; the only thing I want to point out is that the rattling is loud and clear when they are angry, but when they are calm, it sounds like distant tremors where nothing distinct can be heard. In dense settlements, they have become quite rare because wherever they are found, people wage open war against them, so in a few years, there will be none left except in our mountains. The black snake, on the other hand, always entertains me because it poses no danger. Their speed is astonishing; sometimes it can match a horse; at other times, they climb trees in search of our tree toads or glide along the ground. Occasionally, they appear half in the reptile state, half upright; their eyes and heads in an upright position look remarkable: the eyes display a fire that I've often admired, and it’s through these that they can mesmerize birds and squirrels. When they lock their gaze on an animal, they become completely still, only turning their heads from side to side, but always keeping their sight fixed on the target. The confused victim, instead of fleeing, seems caught in an irresistible force; it screams; it inches closer and then retreats; after moving around with unexplained agitation, it ultimately dashes into the snake's jaws and is swallowed, once covered in a slime or glue to help it slide easily down the throat.
One anecdote I must relate, the circumstances of which are as true as they are singular. One of my constant walks when I am at leisure, is in my lowlands, where I have the pleasure of seeing my cattle, horses, and colts. Exuberant grass replenishes all my fields, the best representative of our wealth; in the middle of that tract I have cut a ditch eight feet wide, the banks of which nature adorns every spring with the wild salendine, and other flowering weeds, which on these luxuriant grounds shoot up to a great height. Over this ditch I have erected a bridge, capable of bearing a loaded waggon; on each side I carefully sow every year some grains of hemp, which rise to the height of fifteen feet, so strong and so full of limbs as to resemble young trees: I once ascended one of them four feet above the ground. These produce natural arbours, rendered often still more compact by the assistance of an annual creeping plant which we call a vine, that never fails to entwine itself among their branches, and always produces a very desirable shade. From this simple grove I have amused myself an hundred times in observing the great number of humming birds with which our country abounds: the wild blossoms everywhere attract the attention of these birds, which like bees subsist by suction. From this retreat I distinctly watch them in all their various attitudes; but their flight is so rapid, that you cannot distinguish the motion of their wings. On this little bird nature has profusely lavished her most splendid colours; the most perfect azure, the most beautiful gold, the most dazzling red, are for ever in contrast, and help to embellish the plumes of his majestic head. The richest palette of the most luxuriant painter could never invent anything to be compared to the variegated tints, with which this insect bird is arrayed. Its bill is as long and as sharp as a coarse sewing needle; like the bee, nature has taught it to find out in the calix of flowers and blossoms, those mellifluous particles that serve it for sufficient food; and yet it seems to leave them untouched, undeprived of anything that our eyes can possibly distinguish. When it feeds, it appears as if immovable though continually on the wing; and sometimes, from what motives I know not, it will tear and lacerate flowers into a hundred pieces: for, strange to tell, they are the most irascible of the feathered tribe. Where do passions find room in so diminutive a body? They often fight with the fury of lions, until one of the combatants falls a sacrifice and dies. When fatigued, it has often perched within a few feet of me, and on such favourable opportunities I have surveyed it with the most minute attention. Its little eyes appear like diamonds, reflecting light on every side: most elegantly finished in all parts it is a miniature work of our great parent; who seems to have formed it the smallest, and at the same time the most beautiful of the winged species.
One story I have to share is as true as it is unique. When I have some free time, I often walk in my lowlands, where I enjoy seeing my cattle, horses, and foals. Lush grass covers all my fields, which is the best sign of our wealth; in the middle of that area, I've dug a ditch eight feet wide, adorned every spring by nature with wild celandine and other flowering weeds that thrive in this rich soil. I built a bridge over this ditch that's strong enough to hold a loaded wagon; on each side, I carefully plant hemp seeds every year, which grow to about fifteen feet tall, strong and full of branches that look like young trees: I once climbed one four feet off the ground. These plants create natural arbors, often made denser by a yearly creeping plant we call a vine, which always wraps around their branches and provides a nice shade. From this simple grove, I've spent countless hours watching the many hummingbirds that our area is known for: the wild flowers attract these birds, which, like bees, feed through suction. From my spot, I can clearly see them in all their different poses; but their flight is so quick that you can't see their wings moving. Nature has adorned this little bird with its most brilliant colors; the brightest blue, the finest gold, and the most dazzling red are always in contrast, enhancing the feathers of its majestic head. No painter’s palette could ever create something as vibrant as the colors of this tiny bird. Its beak is long and sharp like a coarse sewing needle; like a bee, it has learned to find the sweet nectar in the petals of flowers, and yet it seems to leave everything else untouched, without taking anything our eyes can see. When it feeds, it looks almost still even though it’s constantly in motion; and sometimes, for reasons I don't understand, it will tear flowers apart into a hundred pieces: strangely, it’s one of the most temperamental of all birds. How could so much passion exist in such a tiny body? They often fight with the ferocity of lions until one of them falls and dies. When tired, it sometimes perches just a few feet away from me, and during those moments, I've examined it very closely. Its little eyes shine like diamonds, reflecting light from every angle: perfectly formed in every aspect, it’s a miniature creation of our great creator; it appears to be the smallest and most beautiful of all the winged species.
As I was one day sitting solitary and pensive in my primitive arbour, my attention was engaged by a strange sort of rustling noise at some paces distant. I looked all around without distinguishing anything, until I climbed one of my great hemp stalks; when to my astonishment, I beheld two snakes of considerable length, the one pursuing the other with great celerity through a hemp stubble field. The aggressor was of the black kind, six feet long; the fugitive was a water snake, nearly of equal dimensions. They soon met, and in the fury of their first encounter, they appeared in an instant firmly twisted together; and whilst their united tails beat the ground, they mutually tried with open jaws to lacerate each other. What a fell aspect did they present! their heads were compressed to a very small size, their eyes flashed fire; and after this conflict had lasted about five minutes, the second found means to disengage itself from the first, and hurried toward the ditch. Its antagonist instantly assumed a new posture, and half creeping and half erect, with a majestic mien, overtook and attacked the other again, which placed itself in the same attitude, and prepared to resist. The scene was uncommon and beautiful; for thus opposed they fought with their jaws, biting each other with the utmost rage; but notwithstanding this appearance of mutual courage and fury, the water snake still seemed desirous of retreating toward the ditch, its natural element. This was no sooner perceived by the keen-eyed black one, than twisting its tail twice round a stalk of hemp, and seizing its adversary by the throat, not by means of its jaws, but by twisting its own neck twice round that of the water snake, pulled it back from the ditch. To prevent a defeat the latter took hold likewise of a stalk on the bank, and by the acquisition of that point of resistance became a match for its fierce antagonist. Strange was this to behold; two great snakes strongly adhering to the ground mutually fastened together by means of the writhings which lashed them to each other, and stretched at their full length, they pulled but pulled in vain; and in the moments of greatest exertions that part of their bodies which was entwined, seemed extremely small, while the rest appeared inflated, and now and then convulsed with strong undulations, rapidly following each other. Their eyes seemed on fire, and ready to start out of their heads; at one time the conflict seemed decided; the water snake bent itself into two great folds, and by that operation rendered the other more than commonly outstretched; the next minute the new struggles of the black one gained an unexpected superiority, it acquired two great folds likewise, which necessarily extended the body of its adversary in proportion as it had contracted its own. These efforts were alternate; victory seemed doubtful, inclining sometimes to the one side and sometimes to the other; until at last the stalk to which the black snake fastened, suddenly gave way, and in consequence of this accident they both plunged into the ditch. The water did not extinguish their vindictive rage; for by their agitations I could trace, though not distinguish, their mutual attacks. They soon re- appeared on the surface twisted together, as in their first onset; but the black snake seemed to retain its wonted superiority, for its head was exactly fixed above that of the other, which it incessantly pressed down under the water, until it was stifled, and sunk. The victor no sooner perceived its enemy incapable of farther resistance, than abandoning it to the current, it returned on shore and disappeared.
As I was sitting alone and deep in thought in my simple shelter one day, I heard a strange rustling noise nearby. I looked around but couldn’t see anything until I climbed one of my tall hemp stalks. To my surprise, I saw two long snakes, one chasing the other quickly through a field of hemp. The attacker was a black snake, six feet long, and the other was a water snake, almost the same size. They soon met, and in the heat of their first encounter, they became tightly tangled together; while their tails whipped against the ground, they tried to bite each other with their mouths wide open. What a fierce sight they presented! Their heads were small, their eyes blazed with anger, and after about five minutes of fighting, the water snake managed to break free and rushed toward the ditch. The black snake immediately took a new position, half slithering and half upright, and powerfully chased after the other one again, which took the same stance and got ready to fight back. The scene was unusual and beautiful; they faced each other, biting with all their fury. Despite this show of bravery and rage, the water snake still seemed to want to retreat to the ditch, its natural habitat. The black snake noticed this and twisted its tail around a hemp stalk, grabbing the water snake not with its jaws but by wrapping its neck around it, pulling it back from the ditch. To avoid being pulled down, the water snake grabbed a stalk on the bank, and with that point of support, it could match its fierce opponent. It was strange to see; two large snakes firmly planted on the ground, entwined with each other, stretched out fully, tugging against each other in vain. At their moments of greatest effort, the part of their bodies that was twisted seemed very small, while the rest appeared swollen, occasionally convulsing with strong waves of movement. Their eyes looked like they were on fire, ready to pop out of their heads. At one moment, it looked like the battle was over; the water snake coiled itself into loops, stretching the other snake out even more. The next minute, the black snake’s new efforts gained an unexpected advantage, and it wriggled itself into loops as well, which forced the water snake to stretch even more. Their efforts alternated; victory was uncertain, shifting from one snake to the other, until finally, the stalk that the black snake was holding onto suddenly snapped, and they both fell into the ditch. The water didn’t cool their fierce anger; I could see their movements, even if I couldn’t make out their exact attacks. They soon re-emerged on the surface, twisted together like in their first encounter; but the black snake seemed to have the upper hand, as its head pressed down on the water snake’s, forcing it underwater until it drowned and sank. As soon as the victor realized its enemy could no longer fight back, it let it go to the current and returned to shore, disappearing from view.
LETTER XI
FROM MR. IW—N AL—Z, A RUSSIAN GENTLEMAN; DESCRIBING THE VISIT HE PAID AT MY REQUEST TO MR. JOHN BERTRAM, THE CELEBRATED PENNSYLVANIAN BOTANIST
Examine this flourishing province, in whatever light you will, the eyes as well as the mind of an European traveller are equally delighted; because a diffusive happiness appears in every part: happiness which is established on the broadest basis. The wisdom of Lycurgus and Solon never conferred on man one half of the blessings and uninterrupted prosperity which the Pennsylvanians now possess: the name of Penn, that simple but illustrious citizen, does more honour to the English nation than those of many of their kings.
Examine this thriving state from any perspective you choose, and both the eyes and the mind of a European traveler are equally pleased; because a widespread sense of happiness can be seen everywhere: happiness that is built on a solid foundation. The wisdom of Lycurgus and Solon never granted humanity half the blessings and steady prosperity that the people of Pennsylvania enjoy now: the name of Penn, that humble yet remarkable citizen, brings more honor to the English nation than the names of many of their kings.
In order to convince you that I have not bestowed undeserved praises in my former letters on this celebrated government; and that either nature or the climate seems to be more favourable here to the arts and sciences, than to any other American province; let us together, agreeable to your desire, pay a visit to Mr. John Bertram, the first botanist, in this new hemisphere: become such by a native impulse of disposition. It is to this simple man that America is indebted for several useful discoveries, and the knowledge of many new plants. I had been greatly prepossessed in his favour by the extensive correspondence which I knew he held with the most eminent Scotch and French botanists; I knew also that he had been honoured with that of Queen Ulrica of Sweden.
To show you that I haven't given unwarranted praise in my earlier letters about this well-known government, and that either the nature or the climate here seems more favorable to the arts and sciences than in any other American region, let’s do as you suggested and visit Mr. John Bertram, the top botanist in this new hemisphere, who has become such through his natural talent. This down-to-earth man is responsible for several useful discoveries and the understanding of many new plants in America. I had a strong impression of him due to his extensive correspondence with the leading Scottish and French botanists, and I also knew that he had received honors from Queen Ulrica of Sweden.
His house is small, but decent; there was something peculiar in its first appearance, which seemed to distinguish it from those of his neighbours: a small tower in the middle of it, not only helped to strengthen it but afforded convenient room for a staircase. Every disposition of the fields, fences, and trees, seemed to bear the marks of perfect order and regularity, which in rural affairs, always indicate a prosperous industry.
His house is small but nice; there was something strange about its first appearance that made it different from those of his neighbors: a small tower in the center, which not only strengthened it but also created a handy space for a staircase. The arrangement of the fields, fences, and trees showed signs of perfect order and neatness, which in farming always suggests a thriving business.
I was received at the door by a woman dressed extremely neat and simple, who without courtesying, or any other ceremonial, asked me, with an air of benignity, who I wanted? I answered, I should be glad to see Mr. Bertram. If thee wilt step in and take a chair, I will send for him. No, I said, I had rather have the pleasure of walking through his farm, I shall easily find him out, with your directions. After a little time I perceived the Schuylkill, winding through delightful meadows, and soon cast my eyes on a new-made bank, which seemed greatly to confine its stream. After having walked on its top a considerable way I at last reached the place where ten men were at work. I asked, if any of them could tell me where Mr. Bertram was? An elderly looking man, with wide trousers and a large leather apron on, looking at me said, "My name is Bertram, dost thee want me?" Sir, I am come on purpose to converse with you, if you can be spared from your labour. "Very easily," he answered, "I direct and advise more than I work." We walked toward the house, where he made me take a chair while he went to put on clean clothes, after which he returned and sat down by me. The fame of your knowledge, said I, in American botany, and your well-known hospitality, have induced me to pay you a visit, which I hope you will not think troublesome: I should be glad to spend a few hours in your garden. "The greatest advantage," replied he, "which I receive from what thee callest my botanical fame, is the pleasure which it often procureth me in receiving the visits of friends and foreigners: but our jaunt into the garden must be postponed for the present, as the bell is ringing for dinner." We entered into a large hall, where there was a long table full of victuals; at the lowest part sat his negroes, his hired men were next, then the family and myself; and at the head, the venerable father and his wife presided. Each reclined his head and said his prayers, divested of the tedious cant of some, and of the ostentatious style of others. "After the luxuries of our cities," observed he, "this plain fare must appear to thee a severe fast." By no means, Mr. Bertram, this honest country dinner convinces me, that you receive me as a friend and an old acquaintance. "I am glad of it, for thee art heartily welcome. I never knew how to use ceremonies; they are insufficient proofs of sincerity; our society, besides, are utterly strangers to what the world calleth polite expressions. We treat others as we treat ourselves. I received yesterday a letter from Philadelphia, by which I understand thee art a Russian; what motives can possibly have induced thee to quit thy native country and to come so far in quest of knowledge or pleasure? Verily it is a great compliment thee payest to this our young province, to think that anything it exhibiteth may be worthy thy attention." I have been most amply repaid for the trouble of the passage. I view the present Americans as the seed of future nations, which will replenish this boundless continent; the Russians may be in some respects compared to you; we likewise are a new people, new I mean in knowledge, arts, and improvements. Who knows what revolutions Russia and America may one day bring about; we are perhaps nearer neighbours than we imagine. I view with peculiar attention all your towns, I examine their situation and the police, for which many are already famous. Though their foundations are now so recent, and so well remembered, yet their origin will puzzle posterity as much as we are now puzzled to ascertain the beginning of those which time has in some measure destroyed. Your new buildings, your streets, put me in mind of those of the city of Pompeia, where I was a few years ago; I attentively examined everything there, particularly the foot-path which runs along the houses. They appeared to have been considerably worn by the great number of people which had once travelled over them. But now how distant; neither builders nor proprietors remain; nothing is known! "Why thee hast been a great traveller for a man of thy years." Few years, Sir, will enable anybody to journey over a great tract of country; but it requires a superior degree of knowledge to gather harvests as we go. Pray, Mr. Bertram, what banks are those which you are making: to what purpose is so much expense and so much labour bestowed? "Friend Iwan, no branch of industry was ever more profitable to any country, as well as to the proprietors; the Schuylkill in its many windings once covered a great extent of ground, though its waters were but shallow even in our highest tides: and though some parts were always dry, yet the whole of this great tract presented to the eye nothing but a putrid swampy soil, useless either for the plough or for the scythe. The proprietors of these grounds are now incorporated; we yearly pay to the treasurer of the company a certain sum, which makes an aggregate, superior to the casualties that generally happen either by inundations or the musk squash. It is owing to this happy contrivance that so many thousand acres of meadows have been rescued from the Schuylkill, which now both enricheth and embellisheth so much of the neighbourhood of our city. Our brethren of Salem in New Jersey have carried the art of banking to a still higher degree of perfection." It is really an admirable contrivance, which greatly redounds to the honour of the parties concerned; and shows a spirit of discernment and perseverance which is highly praiseworthy: if the Virginians would imitate your example, the state of their husbandry would greatly improve. I have not heard of any such association in any other parts of the continent; Pennsylvania hitherto seems to reign the unrivalled queen of these fair provinces. Pray, Sir, what expense are you at e'er these grounds be fit for the scythe? "The expenses are very considerable, particularly when we have land, brooks, trees, and brush to clear away. But such is the excellence of these bottoms and the goodness of the grass for fattening of cattle, that the produce of three years pays all advances." Happy the country where nature has bestowed such rich treasures, treasures superior to mines, said I: if all this fair province is thus cultivated, no wonder it has acquired such reputation for the prosperity and the industry of its inhabitants.
I was greeted at the door by a woman dressed very neatly and simply, who, without curtseying or any other formalities, asked me, with a friendly demeanor, who I was looking for. I replied that I would be glad to see Mr. Bertram. "If you’d like to come in and sit down, I’ll fetch him for you," she said. "No, I’d prefer to walk around his farm; I can easily find him with your directions." After a little while, I noticed the Schuylkill River winding through lovely meadows, and soon I spotted a newly made bank that seemed to greatly confine its stream. After walking along the top of it for quite some time, I finally reached a spot where ten men were at work. I asked if any of them knew where Mr. Bertram was. An older man, wearing wide trousers and a large leather apron, looked at me and said, "My name is Bertram. Do you need me?" "Sir, I've come specifically to talk with you, if you can take a break from your work." "Very easily," he replied, "I spend more time directing and advising than actually working." We walked towards the house, where he made me sit down while he went to change into clean clothes. After a moment, he returned and sat next to me. "The reputation of your knowledge in American botany and your well-known hospitality have encouraged me to visit; I hope you won’t find it bothersome. I’d love to spend a few hours in your garden." "The greatest benefit," he replied, "that I receive from what you call my botanical fame is the pleasure of hosting friends and visitors. But our trip to the garden will have to wait for now, as the bell is ringing for dinner." We entered a large hall, where a long table was filled with food; at the far end sat his black workers, then his hired men, followed by the family and myself; at the head, the venerable father and his wife presided. Each bowed their heads and said their prayers, free from the tediousness of some and the showiness of others. "After the luxuries of our cities," he noted, "this plain meal must seem like a significant fast to you." "Not at all, Mr. Bertram; this honest country dinner shows me that you welcome me as a friend and old acquaintance." "I’m glad to hear that, because you are warmly welcomed. I’ve never known how to use ceremonies; they are inadequate proofs of sincerity; our society is, besides, totally foreign to what the world calls polite expressions. We treat others as we treat ourselves. I received a letter yesterday from Philadelphia, telling me you are Russian; what could possibly motivate you to leave your home country and come so far for knowledge or enjoyment? Truly, it’s a great compliment you pay to our young province to think that anything it offers could be worthy of your attention." "I have been richly rewarded for the trouble of the journey. I see the present Americans as the seeds of future nations that will populate this vast continent; Russians can be compared to you in some ways; we too are a new people, new in terms of knowledge, arts, and advancements. Who knows what changes Russia and America might bring in the future; we may be closer neighbors than we think. I observe all your towns with great interest, examining their locations and governance, for which many are now already renowned. Though their foundations are so recent and well-remembered, their origins will confound future generations as much as we are puzzled about those that time has partially erased. Your new buildings and streets remind me of those in the city of Pompeii, which I visited a few years ago; I carefully examined everything there, especially the footpath that runs along the houses. They seemed to be considerably worn by the many people who once walked over them. But now, how far removed; neither builders nor owners remain; nothing is known!" "You’ve been quite the traveler for someone your age." "A few years, Sir, allow anyone to journey across a vast land; but it takes a superior level of knowledge to gather insights on the way. By the way, Mr. Bertram, what are those banks you are constructing? What is the purpose of all this expense and effort?" "Friend Iwan, no form of industry has ever benefited a country and its owners more; the Schuylkill, in its many bends, once covered a vast area, though its waters were shallow, even at our highest tides. While some parts were always dry, the entire region presented only a putrid, swampy landscape, useless for farming or hay-making. The owners of this land are now united; we annually pay a certain amount to the company’s treasurer, which totals more than the losses typically caused by floods or the musk squash. It is thanks to this fortunate arrangement that so many thousands of acres of meadows have been reclaimed from the Schuylkill, which now enriches and beautifies much of the area around our city. Our fellow citizens in Salem, New Jersey, have even perfected the art of banking further." "It’s truly an admirable system, which greatly honors those involved, showing a spirit of insight and determination that is to be commended. If the Virginians would follow your example, their agricultural state would significantly improve. I haven’t heard of any such partnerships in other parts of the continent; Pennsylvania seems to be the unrivaled queen of these beautiful provinces. What costs are you incurring before these lands are ready for harvesting?" "The expenses are quite significant, especially when we have to clear land, streams, trees, and brush. But the quality of these lowlands and the excellent grass for fattening cattle means that the yields within three years pay back all the investments." "Happy is the country where nature has provided such rich gifts, gifts greater than mines," I remarked. "If this beautiful province is cultivated in this way, it’s no wonder it has earned such a reputation for the prosperity and diligence of its people."
By this time the working part of the family had finished their dinner, and had retired with a decency and silence which pleased me much. Soon after I heard, as I thought, a distant concert of instruments.—However simple and pastoral your fare was, Mr. Bertram, this is the dessert of a prince; pray what is this I hear? "Thee must not be alarmed, it is of a piece with the rest of thy treatment, friend Iwan." Anxious I followed the sound, and by ascending the staircase, found that it was the effect of the wind through the strings of an Eolian harp; an instrument which I had never before seen. After dinner we quaffed an honest bottle of Madeira wine, without the irksome labour of toasts, healths, or sentiments; and then retired into his study.
By this time, the working members of the family had finished their dinner and left quietly and respectfully, which I appreciated. Soon after, I heard what sounded like a distant concert of instruments. "No matter how simple and rustic your meal was, Mr. Bertram, this is a royal dessert; what is that sound I hear?" "Don't be alarmed, it's part of your treatment, my friend Iwan." Curious, I followed the sound and went up the stairs, discovering it was the wind playing through the strings of an Eolian harp—an instrument I had never seen before. After dinner, we enjoyed a nice bottle of Madeira wine, without the tiresome rituals of toasts or speeches, and then we went into his study.
I was no sooner entered, than I observed a coat of arms in a gilt frame with the name of John Bertram. The novelty of such a decoration, in such a place, struck me; I could not avoid asking, Does the society of Friends take any pride in those armorial bearings, which sometimes serve as marks of distinction between families, and much oftener as food for pride and ostentation? "Thee must know," said he, "that my father was a Frenchman, he brought this piece of painting over with him; I keep it as a piece of family furniture, and as a memorial of his removal hither." From his study we went into the garden, which contained a great variety of curious plants and shrubs; some grew in a greenhouse, over the door of which were written these lines:
I had barely stepped in when I noticed a coat of arms in a gilded frame with the name John Bertram. The uniqueness of such a decoration in this setting caught my attention; I couldn’t help but ask, “Does the Society of Friends take any pride in these heraldic symbols, which sometimes act as marks of distinction between families, and more often serve as a source of pride and showiness?” “You should know,” he replied, “that my father was French, and he brought this painting with him; I keep it as a family heirloom and a reminder of his move here.” From his study, we walked into the garden, which had a wide range of interesting plants and shrubs; some were in a greenhouse, above the door of which were written these lines:
"Slave to no sect, who takes no private road,
But looks through nature, up to nature's God!"
"Not tied to any specific group, who doesn’t follow a personal path,
But observes nature, seeking guidance from nature's God!"
He informed me that he had often followed General Bouquet to Pittsburgh, with the view of herbalising; that he had made useful collections in Virginia, and that he had been employed by the king of England to visit the two Floridas.
He told me that he had often accompanied General Bouquet to Pittsburgh to gather herbs, that he had collected useful specimens in Virginia, and that he had been hired by the king of England to explore the two Floridas.
Our walks and botanical observations engrossed so much of our time, that the sun was almost down ere I thought of returning to Philadelphia; I regretted that the day had been so short, as I had not spent so rational a one for a long time before. I wanted to stay, yet was doubtful whether it would not appear improper, being an utter stranger. Knowing, however, that I was visiting the least ceremonious people in the world, I bluntly informed him of the pleasure I had enjoyed, and with the desire I had of staying a few days with him. "Thee art as welcome as if I was thy father; thee art no stranger; thy desire of knowledge, thy being a foreigner besides, entitleth thee to consider my house as thine own, as long as thee pleaseth: use thy time with the most perfect freedom; I too shall do so myself." I thankfully accepted the kind invitation.
Our walks and plant observations took up so much of our time that the sun was nearly down before I thought about heading back to Philadelphia. I wished the day had been longer because I hadn't enjoyed such a thoughtful day in a long time. I wanted to stay, but I was unsure if it would seem inappropriate since I was a complete stranger. However, knowing I was among the least formal people around, I directly told him how much I had enjoyed myself and that I wanted to stay a few days with him. "You are as welcome as if I were your father; you are no stranger; your desire for knowledge and being a foreigner gives you the right to consider my home as yours for as long as you wish: use your time with complete freedom; I will do the same." I gratefully accepted the kind invitation.
We went to view his favourite bank; he showed me the principles and method on which it was erected; and we walked over the grounds which had been already drained. The whole store of nature's kind luxuriance seemed to have been exhausted on these beautiful meadows; he made me count the amazing number of cattle and horses now feeding on solid bottoms, which but a few years before had been covered with water. Thence we rambled through his fields, where the right-angular fences, the heaps of pitched stones, the flourishing clover, announced the best husbandry, as well as the most assiduous attention. His cows were then returning home, deep bellied, short legged, having udders ready to burst; seeking with seeming toil to be delivered from the great exuberance they contained: he next showed me his orchard, formerly planted on a barren sandy soil, but long since converted into one of the richest spots in that vicinage.
We went to check out his favorite bank; he explained the principles and methods used to build it, and we walked over the already drained land. Nature's abundant richness seemed fully utilized in these beautiful meadows; he had me count the incredible number of cattle and horses now grazing on solid ground that had been underwater just a few years before. From there, we strolled through his fields, where the right-angled fences, piles of stones, and thriving clover indicated excellent farming and a lot of hard work. His cows were coming home, heavy-bellied and short-legged, with udders close to bursting, as they struggled to relieve themselves of the excess they carried. He then showed me his orchard, which was once planted in barren sandy soil but had long been transformed into one of the richest spots in the area.
"This," said he, "is altogether the fruit of my own contrivance; I purchased some years ago the privilege of a small spring, about a mile and a half from hence, which at a considerable expense I have brought to this reservoir; therein I throw old lime, ashes, horse- dung, etc., and twice a week I let it run, thus impregnated; I regularly spread on this ground in the fall, old hay, straw, and whatever damaged fodder I have about my barn. By these simple means I mow, one year with another, fifty-three hundreds of excellent hay per acre, from a soil, which scarcely produced five-fingers [a small plant resembling strawberries] some years before." This is, Sir, a miracle in husbandry; happy the country which is cultivated by a society of men, whose application and taste lead them to prosecute and accomplish useful works. "I am not the only person who do these things," he said, "wherever water can be had it is always turned to that important use; wherever a farmer can water his meadows, the greatest crops of the best hay and excellent after-grass, are the sure rewards of his labours. With the banks of my meadow ditches, I have greatly enriched my upland fields, those which I intend to rest for a few years, I constantly sow with red clover, which is the greatest meliorator of our lands. For three years after, they yield abundant pasture; when I want to break up my clover fields, I give them a good coat of mud, which hath been exposed to the severities of three or four of our winters. This is the reason that I commonly reap from twenty-eight to thirty-six bushels of wheat an acre; my flax, oats, and Indian corn, I raise in the same proportion. Wouldst thee inform me whether the inhabitants of thy country follow the same methods of husbandry?" No, Sir; in the neighbourhood of our towns, there are indeed some intelligent farmers, who prosecute their rural schemes with attention; but we should be too numerous, too happy, too powerful a people, if it were possible for the whole Russian Empire to be cultivated like the province of Pennsylvania. Our lands are so unequally divided, and so few of our farmers are possessors of the soil they till, that they cannot execute plans of husbandry with the same vigour as you do, who hold yours, as it were from the Master of nature, unencumbered and free. Oh, America! exclaimed I, thou knowest not as yet the whole extent of thy happiness: the foundation of thy civil polity must lead thee in a few years to a degree of population and power which Europe little thinks of! "Long before this happen," answered the good man, "we shall rest beneath the turf; it is vain for mortals to be presumptuous in their conjectures: our country, is, no doubt, the cradle of an extensive future population; the old world is growing weary of its inhabitants, they must come here to flee from the tyranny of the great. But doth not thee imagine, that the great will, in the course of years, come over here also; for it is the misfortune of all societies everywhere to hear of great men, great rulers, and of great tyrants." My dear Sir, I replied, tyranny never can take a strong hold in this country, the land is too widely distributed: it is poverty in Europe that makes slaves. "Friend Iwan, as I make no doubt that thee understandest the Latin tongue, read this kind epistle which the good Queen of Sweden, Ulrica, sent me a few years ago. Good woman! that she should think in her palace at Stockholm of poor John Bertram, on the banks of the Schuylkill, appeareth to me very strange." Not in the least, dear Sir; you are the first man whose name as a botanist hath done honour to America; it is very natural at the same time to imagine, that so extensive a continent must contain many curious plants and trees: is it then surprising to see a princess, fond of useful knowledge, descend sometimes from the throne, to walk in the gardens of Linnaeus? "'Tis to the directions of that learned man," said Mr. Bertram, "that I am indebted for the method which has led me to the knowledge I now possess; the science of botany is so diffusive, that a proper thread is absolutely wanted to conduct the beginner." Pray, Mr. Bertram, when did you imbibe the first wish to cultivate the science of botany; was you regularly bred to it in Philadelphia? "I have never received any other education than barely reading and writing; this small farm was all the patrimony my father left me, certain debts and the want of meadows kept me rather low in the beginning of my life; my wife brought me nothing in money, all her riches consisted in her good temper and great knowledge of housewifery. I scarcely know how to trace my steps in the botanical career; they appear to me now like unto a dream: but thee mayest rely on what I shall relate, though I know that some of our friends have laughed at it." I am not one of those people, Mr. Bertram, who aim at finding out the ridiculous in what is sincerely and honestly averred. "Well, then, I'll tell thee: One day I was very busy in holding my plough (for thee seest that I am but a ploughman) and being weary I ran under the shade of a tree to repose myself. I cast my eyes on a daisy, I plucked it mechanically and viewed it with more curiosity than common country farmers are wont to do; and observed therein very many distinct parts, some perpendicular, some horizontal. What a shame, said my mind, or something that inspired my mind, that thee shouldest have employed so many years in tilling the earth and destroying so many flowers and plants, without being acquainted with their structures and their uses! This seeming inspiration suddenly awakened my curiosity, for these were not thoughts to which I had been accustomed. I returned to my team, but this new desire did not quit my mind; I mentioned it to my wife, who greatly discouraged me from prosecuting my new scheme, as she called it; I was not opulent enough, she said, to dedicate much of my time to studies and labours which might rob me of that portion of it which is the only wealth of the American farmer. However her prudent caution did not discourage me; I thought about it continually, at supper, in bed, and wherever I went. At last I could not resist the impulse; for on the fourth day of the following week, I hired a man to plough for me, and went to Philadelphia. Though I knew not what book to call for, I ingeniously told the bookseller my errand, who provided me with such as he thought best, and a Latin grammar beside. Next I applied to a neighbouring schoolmaster, who in three months taught me Latin enough to understand Linnaeus, which I purchased afterward. Then I began to botanise all over my farm; in a little time I became acquainted with every vegetable that grew in my neighbourhood; and next ventured into Maryland, living among the Friends: in proportion as I thought myself more learned I proceeded farther, and by a steady application of several years I have acquired a pretty general knowledge of every plant and tree to be found in our continent. In process of time I was applied to from the old countries, whither I every year send many collections. Being now made easy in my circumstances, I have ceased to labour, and am never so happy as when I see and converse with my friends. If among the many plants or shrubs I am acquainted with, there are any thee wantest to send to thy native country, I will cheerfully procure them, and give thee moreover whatever directions thee mayest want."
"This," he said, "is entirely the result of my own efforts; a few years ago, I bought the rights to a small spring about a mile and a half from here, which I’ve brought to this reservoir at considerable expense; I throw in old lime, ashes, horse dung, and so on, and twice a week I let it run with this mixture. Every fall, I spread old hay, straw, and any damaged fodder I have from my barn on this ground. By these simple methods, I harvest an average of fifty-three hundredweight of excellent hay per acre from soil that barely produced five-fingers just a few years ago." This, Sir, is a marvel in farming; fortunate is the country cultivated by people whose dedication and passion drive them to pursue and achieve useful work. "I’m not the only one doing this," he continued, "wherever water is available, it’s always put to this important use; wherever a farmer can water his meadows, he’s sure to reap the largest yields of the best hay and excellent after-grass as rewards for his labor. With the banks of my meadow ditches, I’ve greatly enriched my upland fields; those I plan to leave fallow for a few years, I constantly sow with red clover, which greatly improves our land. For three years afterward, they provide abundant pasture; when I want to till my clover fields, I give them a good coat of mud that’s been exposed to the harshness of three or four winters. This is why I usually harvest from twenty-eight to thirty-six bushels of wheat per acre; I raise flax, oats, and corn in the same proportion. Can you tell me if the people in your country use the same farming methods?" No, Sir; near our towns, there are indeed some knowledgeable farmers who carefully pursue their agricultural plans; but we would be too numerous, too happy, too powerful a people if the entire Russian Empire were cultivated like Pennsylvania. Our land is so unevenly divided, and so few of our farmers actually own the soil they cultivate, that they can’t implement farming strategies with the same vigor as you, who hold yours as a gift from nature, unencumbered and free. Oh, America! I exclaimed, you do not yet know the full extent of your happiness: the foundation of your civic order will lead you in a few years to a level of population and power that Europe hardly imagines! "Long before that happens," replied the good man, "we will be resting beneath the earth; it is futile for mortals to make presumptuous predictions: our land is undoubtedly the cradle of a vast future population; the old world is growing tired of its inhabitants, they must come here to escape the tyranny of the powerful. But do you not think that the powerful will, in time, come over here too? It seems to be the fate of all societies everywhere to hear about great men, great rulers, and great tyrants." My dear Sir, I replied, tyranny can never take root in this country; the land is too widely distributed: it is poverty in Europe that creates slaves. "Friend Iwan, since I have no doubt that you understand Latin, read this kind letter that the good Queen of Sweden, Ulrica, sent me a few years ago. Good woman! It's quite strange that she should think about poor John Bertram on the banks of the Schuylkill from her palace in Stockholm." Not at all, dear Sir; you are the first person whose name as a botanist has brought honor to America; it is quite natural to think that such a vast continent must contain many interesting plants and trees: is it surprising to see a princess, who loves useful knowledge, occasionally step down from the throne to walk in Linnaeus’s gardens? "'Tis to the guidance of that learned man," said Mr. Bertram, "that I owe the method that has led me to the knowledge I have now; botany is so extensive that beginners need a proper path to follow." Pray, Mr. Bertram, when did you first want to study botany; were you formally trained in it in Philadelphia? "I’ve never had any education beyond basic reading and writing; this small farm was all my father left me; certain debts and the lack of meadows kept me relatively poor in the early part of my life; my wife didn’t bring any money, her only riches were her good temperament and great housekeeping skills. I hardly know how to trace my steps in this botanical journey; they now feel like a dream: but you can trust what I share, though I know some of our friends have laughed at it." I’m not one of those people, Mr. Bertram, who look for the ridiculous in what is sincerely and honestly expressed. "Well, then, I’ll tell you: One day I was very busy plowing (for you see, I am just a plowman) and feeling tired, I ran under the shade of a tree to rest. I glanced at a daisy, picked it without thinking, and looked at it with more curiosity than typical farmers would. I thought, or something inspired my thoughts, how shameful it is to have spent so many years tilling the earth and destroying so many flowers and plants without understanding their structure and use! This sudden inspiration sparked my curiosity, since these weren’t thoughts I was used to. I returned to my work, but this new desire stayed with me; I mentioned it to my wife, who discouraged me from pursuing what she called my new scheme; I wasn't wealthy enough, she said, to dedicate much time to studies and labors that could take away what little farm wealth remains for an American farmer. Nevertheless, her wise caution didn’t deter me; I couldn’t stop thinking about it, at dinner, in bed, and wherever I went. Finally, I couldn't resist the urge; on the fourth day of the next week, I hired someone to plow for me and went to Philadelphia. Though I didn’t know which book to ask for, I cleverly told the bookseller my goal, who provided me with what he thought was best, along with a Latin grammar. Then, I approached a nearby schoolmaster, who taught me enough Latin in three months to understand Linnaeus, which I later purchased. From there, I began to study the plants all over my farm; soon, I became familiar with every vegetable that grew in my area; I then ventured into Maryland, living among the Friends: as I grew more knowledgeable, I pushed further, and with years of steady application, I gained a pretty general understanding of every plant and tree found on our continent. Over time, I received inquiries from the old countries, to which I now send many collections each year. Having become comfortable in my circumstances, I no longer work laboriously, and I’m never happier than when I’m with my friends. If there are any plants or shrubs I know that you want to send back to your homeland, I will gladly acquire them for you and provide any guidance you might need."
Thus I passed several days in ease, improvement, and pleasure; I observed in all the operations of his farm, as well as in the mutual correspondence between the master and the inferior members of his family, the greatest ease and decorum; not a word like command seemed to exceed the tone of a simple wish. The very negroes themselves appeared to partake of such a decency of behaviour, and modesty of countenance, as I had never before observed. By what means, said I, Mr. Bertram, do you rule your slaves so well, that they seem to do their work with all the cheerfulness of white men? "Though our erroneous prejudices and opinions once induced us to look upon them as fit only for slavery, though ancient custom had very unfortunately taught us to keep them in bondage; yet of late, in consequence of the remonstrances of several Friends, and of the good books they have published on that subject, our society treats them very differently. With us they are now free. I give those whom thee didst see at my table, eighteen pounds a year, with victuals and clothes, and all other privileges which white men enjoy. Our society treats them now as the companions of our labours; and by this management, as well as by means of the education we have given them, they are in general become a new set of beings. Those whom I admit to my table, I have found to be good, trusty, moral men; when they do not what we think they should do, we dismiss them, which is all the punishment we inflict. Other societies of Christians keep them still as slaves, without teaching them any kind of religious principles: what motive beside fear can they have to behave well? In the first settlement of this province, we employed them as slaves, I acknowledge; but when we found that good example, gentle admonition, and religious principles could lead them to subordination and sobriety, we relinquished a method so contrary to the profession of Christianity. We gave them freedom, and yet few have quitted their ancient masters. The women breed in our families; and we become attached to one another. I taught mine to read and write; they love God, and fear his judgments. The oldest person among them transacts my business in Philadelphia, with a punctuality, from which he has never deviated. They constantly attend our meetings, they participate in health and sickness, infancy and old age, in the advantages our society affords. Such are the means we have made use of, to relieve them from that bondage and ignorance in which they were kept before. Thee perhaps hast been surprised to see them at my table, but by elevating them to the rank of freemen, they necessarily acquire that emulation without which we ourselves should fall into debasement and profligate ways." Mr. Bertram, this is the most philosophical treatment of negroes that I have heard of; happy would it be for America would other denominations of Christians imbibe the same principles, and follow the same admirable rules. A great number of men would be relieved from those cruel shackles, under which they now groan; and under this impression, I cannot endure to spend more time in the southern provinces. The method with which they are treated there, the meanness of their food, the severity of their tasks, are spectacles I have not patience to behold. "I am glad to see that thee hast so much compassion; are there any slaves in thy country?" Yes, unfortunately, but they are more properly civil than domestic slaves; they are attached to the soil on which they live; it is the remains of ancient barbarous customs, established in the days of the greatest ignorance and savageness of manners! and preserved notwithstanding the repeated tears of humanity, the loud calls of policy, and the commands of religion. The pride of great men, with the avarice of landholders, make them look on this class as necessary tools of husbandry; as if freemen could not cultivate the ground. "And is it really so, Friend Iwan? To be poor, to be wretched, to be a slave, are hard indeed; existence is not worth enjoying on those terms. I am afraid thy country can never flourish under such impolitic government." I am very much of your opinion, Mr. Bertram, though I am in hopes that the present reign, illustrious by so many acts of the soundest policy, will not expire without this salutary, this necessary emancipation; which would fill the Russian empire with tears of gratitude. "How long hast thee been in this country?" Four years, Sir. "Why thee speakest English almost like a native; what a toil a traveller must undergo to learn various languages, to divest himself of his native prejudices, and to accommodate himself to the customs of all those among whom he chooseth to reside."
Thus, I spent several days in comfort, self-improvement, and enjoyment. I noticed in all the operations of his farm, as well as in the interactions between the owner and the other members of his household, a remarkable ease and respect; not a single word had the authority of command, but rather the tone of a simple request. Even the enslaved individuals seemed to exhibit a level of decency in their behavior and modesty in their demeanor that I had never observed before. I asked Mr. Bertram how he managed to have his workers so content that they approached their tasks with as much cheerfulness as white men. "Although our misguided perceptions and beliefs once led us to view them as fit only for slavery, and traditional practices regrettably taught us to keep them in bondage, recently, prompted by the advice of several Friends and the insightful works they have published on this subject, our community treats them quite differently. Here, they are free. I provide those you saw at my table with eighteen pounds a year, along with food, clothes, and all the privileges that white individuals enjoy. Our society now regards them as partners in our labor; through this approach and the education we've provided, they've generally transformed into a new group of people. Those I invite to my table have proven to be good, trustworthy, and moral individuals. If they do not meet our expectations, we simply let them go, which is the only punishment we impose. Other Christian communities still keep them as slaves without instilling any religious values in them; what motivation aside from fear could they possibly have to behave well? I admit that when this province was first settled, we used them as slaves, but when we realized that good examples, gentle guidance, and ethical teachings could lead them to discipline and respect, we abandoned methods that were so contrary to Christian principles. We granted them freedom, and yet few have chosen to leave their former masters. The women raise families with us, and we grow attached to one another. I taught mine to read and write; they love God and fear His judgments. The oldest of them runs my business in Philadelphia with unwavering punctuality. They consistently attend our meetings and share in our joys and hardships, from childhood to old age, benefiting from all that our community offers. These are the ways we have worked to lift them from the chains of bondage and ignorance in which they were kept before. You might have been surprised to see them at my table, but by elevating them to the status of free individuals, they naturally acquire a drive to improve that helps us avoid becoming debased and immoral." Mr. Bertram, this is the most enlightened approach to the treatment of enslaved individuals that I've encountered; it would be wonderful for America if other Christian groups embraced the same principles and followed such admirable practices. Many individuals would be freed from the cruel shackles under which they currently suffer; with this thought in mind, I can’t bear to spend more time in the southern provinces. The way they are treated there, their poor diet, and the harshness of their work are sights I simply can’t endure. "I’m glad to see you have so much compassion; are there any enslaved people in your country?" Yes, unfortunately, but they are more like serfs than household slaves; they are tied to the land they live on. It's an outdated relic from ancient, barbaric customs established during a time of great ignorance and brutality, continuing despite the persistent cries for justice, the calls for sensible policy, and the demands of faith. The pride of the wealthy and the greed of landowners lead them to see this group as necessary tools for farming, as if free individuals couldn't cultivate the land. "Is that really the case, Friend Iwan? To be poor, to suffer, to be enslaved are indeed hard conditions; life is hardly worth enjoying under such terms. I fear your country can never prosper under such unwise governance." I mostly agree with you, Mr. Bertram, though I hope that the current reign, notable for its many wise policies, will not end without this crucial, necessary emancipation, which would bring tears of gratitude to the Russian Empire. "How long have you been in this country?" Four years, sir. "Why, you speak English almost like a native! What effort a traveler must put in to learn various languages, shed his native biases, and adapt to the customs of all those among whom he chooses to live."
Thus I spent my time with this enlightened botanist—this worthy citizen; who united all the simplicity of rustic manners to the most useful learning. Various and extensive were the conversations that filled the measure of my visit. I accompanied him to his fields, to his barn, to his bank, to his garden, to his study, and at last to the meeting of the society on the Sunday following. It was at the town of Chester, whither the whole family went in two waggons; Mr. Bertram and I on horseback. When I entered the house where the friends were assembled, who might be about two hundred men and women, the involuntary impulse of ancient custom made me pull off my hat; but soon recovering myself, I sat with it on, at the end of a bench. The meeting-house was a square building devoid of any ornament whatever; the whiteness of the walls, the conveniency of seats, that of a large stove, which in cold weather keeps the whole house warm, were the only essential things which I observed. Neither pulpit nor desk, fount nor altar, tabernacle nor organ, were there to be seen; it is merely a spacious room, in which these good people meet every Sunday. A profound silence ensued, which lasted about half an hour; every one had his head reclined, and seemed absorbed in profound meditation, when a female friend arose, and declared with a most engaging modesty, that the spirit moved her to entertain them on the subject she had chosen. She treated it with great propriety, as a moral useful discourse, and delivered it without theological parade or the ostentation of learning. Either she must have been a great adept in public speaking, or had studiously prepared herself; a circumstance that cannot well be supposed, as it is a point, in their profession, to utter nothing but what arises from spontaneous impulse: or else the great spirit of the world, the patronage and influence of which they all came to invoke, must have inspired her with the soundest morality. Her discourse lasted three quarters of an hour. I did not observe one single face turned toward her; never before had I seen a congregation listening with so much attention to a public oration. I observed neither contortions of body, nor any kind of affectation in her face, style, or manner of utterance; everything was natural, and therefore pleasing, and shall I tell you more, she was very handsome, although upward of forty. As soon as she had finished, every one seemed to return to their former meditation for about a quarter of an hour; when they rose up by common consent, and after some general conversation, departed.
So, I spent my time with this insightful botanist—a good citizen who combined the simplicity of country life with useful knowledge. Our conversations were varied and extensive during my visit. I accompanied him to his fields, his barn, his bank, his garden, and finally to a meeting of the society the following Sunday. It was in the town of Chester, where the whole family traveled in two wagons, while Mr. Bertram and I rode on horseback. When I entered the house where about two hundred friends—men and women—had gathered, my instinct from past customs made me take off my hat; but I quickly realized and sat down with my hat on at the end of a bench. The meeting house was a plain square building with no decorations at all; the bright white walls, the comfortable seats, and a large stove that heated the place in cold weather were the only important things I noticed. There were no pulpit, desk, fountain, altar, tabernacle, or organ in sight; it was simply a spacious room where these good people gathered every Sunday. A deep silence fell, lasting around half an hour; everyone had their heads down and seemed lost in deep thought, when a woman stood up and, with charming modesty, announced that she felt moved to speak on a topic she had chosen. She addressed it appropriately as a moral and useful talk, presenting it without any theological show or pretentiousness. She must have been a skilled public speaker or had prepared herself carefully; though it's hard to believe since their practice is to say only what comes from spontaneous inspiration. Or perhaps the great spirit of the world, whose patronage and influence they all came to seek, inspired her with the truest moral insights. Her talk lasted about three-quarters of an hour. I didn’t see a single face look away from her; I had never witnessed a congregation paying such close attention to a speech. I noticed no contortions of body or any showiness in her face, style, or speech; everything felt natural and was therefore refreshing. And I should add, she was very attractive, even though she was over forty. Once she finished, everyone seemed to return to their previous meditation for about fifteen minutes, then they stood up by common agreement, had some general conversation, and left.
How simple their precepts, how unadorned their religious system: how few the ceremonies through which they pass during the course of their lives! At their deaths they are interred by the fraternity, without pomp, without prayers; thinking it then too late to alter the course of God's eternal decrees: and as you well know, without either monument or tombstone. Thus after having lived under the mildest government, after having been guided by the mildest doctrine, they die just as peaceably as those who being educated in more pompous religions, pass through a variety of sacraments, subscribe to complicated creeds, and enjoy the benefits of a church establishment. These good people flatter themselves, with following the doctrines of Jesus Christ, in that simplicity with which they were delivered: an happier system could not have been devised for the use of mankind. It appears to be entirely free from those ornaments and political additions which each country and each government hath fashioned after its own manners.
How simple their beliefs are, how plain their religious system: how few the rituals they go through during their lives! At death, they are buried by their community, without any fuss or prayers; believing it's too late to change the course of God's eternal plans: and, as you know well, without any monument or gravestone. So, after living under the kindest governance, after being guided by the kindest teachings, they die just as peacefully as those who were raised in more elaborate religions, going through various sacraments, adhering to complicated beliefs, and benefiting from a formal church structure. These good people take pride in following the teachings of Jesus Christ in the straightforward way they were given: a happier system for humanity could not have been created. It seems to be completely free from the decorations and political additions that each country and government have shaped according to their own customs.
At the door of this meeting house, I had been invited to spend some days at the houses of some respectable farmers in the neighbourhood. The reception I met with everywhere insensibly led me to spend two months among these good people; and I must say they were the golden days of my riper years. I never shall forget the gratitude I owe them for the innumerable kindnesses they heaped on me; it was to the letter you gave me that I am indebted for the extensive acquaintance I now have throughout Pennsylvania. I must defer thanking you as I ought, until I see you again. Before that time comes, I may perhaps entertain you with more curious anecdotes than this letter affords.- -Farewell. I——N AL——Z.
At the door of this meeting house, I had been invited to stay for a few days with some respectable farmers in the area. The warm welcome I received everywhere naturally led me to spend two months among these wonderful people; I have to say they were the best days of my later years. I will never forget the gratitude I owe them for the countless acts of kindness they showed me; it was because of the letter you gave me that I have made so many connections throughout Pennsylvania. I need to hold off on thanking you properly until I see you again. By then, I might be able to share even more interesting stories than what this letter offers. -Farewell. I——N AL——Z.
LETTER XII
DISTRESSES OF A FRONTIER MAN
I wish for a change of place; the hour is come at last, that I must fly from my house and abandon my farm! But what course shall I steer, inclosed as I am? The climate best adapted to my present situation and humour would be the polar regions, where six months day and six months night divide the dull year: nay, a simple Aurora Borealis would suffice me, and greatly refresh my eyes, fatigued now by so many disagreeable objects. The severity of those climates, that great gloom, where melancholy dwells, would be perfectly analogous to the turn of my mind. Oh, could I remove my plantation to the shores of the Oby, willingly would I dwell in the hut of a Samoyede; with cheerfulness would I go and bury myself in the cavern of a Laplander. Could I but carry my family along with me, I would winter at Pello, or Tobolsky, in order to enjoy the peace and innocence of that country. But let me arrive under the pole, or reach the antipodes, I never can leave behind me the remembrance of the dreadful scenes to which I have been a witness; therefore never can I be happy! Happy, why would I mention that sweet, that enchanting word? Once happiness was our portion; now it is gone from us, and I am afraid not to be enjoyed again by the present generation! Whichever way I look, nothing but the most frightful precipices present themselves to my view, in which hundreds of my friends and acquaintances have already perished: of all animals that live on the surface of this planet, what is man when no longer connected with society; or when he finds himself surrounded by a convulsed and a half dissolved one? He cannot live in solitude, he must belong to some community bound by some ties, however imperfect. Men mutually support and add to the boldness and confidence of each other; the weakness of each is strengthened by the force of the whole. I had never before these calamitous times formed any such ideas; I lived on, laboured and prospered, without having ever studied on what the security of my life and the foundation of my prosperity were established: I perceived them just as they left me. Never was a situation so singularly terrible as mine, in every possible respect, as a member of an extensive society, as a citizen of an inferior division of the same society, as a husband, as a father, as a man who exquisitely feels for the miseries of others as well as for his own! But alas! so much is everything now subverted among us, that the very word misery, with which we were hardly acquainted before, no longer conveys the same ideas; or rather tired with feeling for the miseries of others, every one feels now for himself alone. When I consider myself as connected in all these characters, as bound by so many cords, all uniting in my heart, I am seized with a fever of the mind, I am transported beyond that degree of calmness which is necessary to delineate our thoughts. I feel as if my reason wanted to leave me, as if it would burst its poor weak tenement: again I try to compose myself, I grow cool, and preconceiving the dreadful loss, I endeavour to retain the useful guest.
I long for a change of scenery; the time has finally come for me to leave my home and abandon my farm! But where will I go, stuck as I am? The best place for my current mood would be the polar regions, where there are six months of daylight and six months of darkness in the dreary year: honestly, just seeing the Aurora Borealis would be enough to refresh my tired eyes after so many unpleasant sights. The harshness of those climates, that deep gloom where sadness lingers, would perfectly match my state of mind. Oh, if only I could move my farm to the banks of the Oby, I would happily live in a Samoyede hut; I would cheerfully bury myself in a Laplander’s cave. If I could bring my family with me, I would spend the winter in Pello or Tobolsky to enjoy the peace and simplicity of that land. But no matter if I reach the pole or the antipodes, I can never escape the haunting memories of the terrible things I have seen; thus, I can never be happy! Happy—why even mention that sweet, enchanting word? Once happiness was ours; now it's lost to us, and I fear it won’t return for this generation! Every direction I look presents nothing but terrifying cliffs where hundreds of my friends and acquaintances have already perished: what is a human being, cut off from society, or trapped in a fractured and barely functioning one? He can't survive in isolation; he must belong to some community, bound by some ties, even if they’re imperfect. People uplift each other, boosting each other's courage and confidence; the weakness of one is made stronger by the strength of the group. Before these disastrous times, I never had such thoughts; I lived, worked, and thrived without questioning the foundations of my life and prosperity: I only noticed them when they slipped away. My situation is uniquely terrible in every possible way—as a member of a large society, as a citizen of a smaller part of that same society, as a husband, as a father, and as a man who deeply feels for the sufferings of others as well as his own! But alas! Everything among us is so turned upside down that even the word misery, which we hardly knew before, no longer means the same things; or rather, tired from empathizing with others' sufferings, everyone now only feels for themselves. When I see myself in these roles, tied by so many connections in my heart, I’m overwhelmed with anxiety, and I lose the calmness needed to organize my thoughts. It feels like my mind is about to escape me, like it wants to break free from its weak confines: I try to collect myself again, I cool down, and anticipating the dreadful loss, I strive to hold onto this precious clarity.
You know the position of our settlement; I need not therefore describe it. To the west it is inclosed by a chain of mountains, reaching to——; to the east, the country is as yet but thinly inhabited; we are almost insulated, and the houses are at a considerable distance from each other. From the mountains we have but too much reason to expect our dreadful enemy; the wilderness is a harbour where it is impossible to find them. It is a door through which they can enter our country whenever they please; and, as they seem determined to destroy the whole chain of frontiers, our fate cannot be far distant: from Lake Champlain, almost all has been conflagrated one after another. What renders these incursions still more terrible is, that they most commonly take place in the dead of the night; we never go to our fields but we are seized with an involuntary fear, which lessens our strength and weakens our labour. No other subject of conversation intervenes between the different accounts, which spread through the country, of successive acts of devastation; and these told in chimney-corners, swell themselves in our affrighted imaginations into the most terrific ideas! We never sit down either to dinner or supper, but the least noise immediately spreads a general alarm and prevents us from enjoying the comfort of our meals. The very appetite proceeding from labour and peace of mind is gone; we eat just enough to keep us alive: our sleep is disturbed by the most frightful dreams; sometimes I start awake, as if the great hour of danger was come; at other times the howling of our dogs seems to announce the arrival of the enemy: we leap out of bed and run to arms; my poor wife with panting bosom and silent tears, takes leave of me, as if we were to see each other no more; she snatches the youngest children from their beds, who, suddenly awakened, increase by their innocent questions the horror of the dreadful moment. She tries to hide them in the cellar, as if our cellar was inaccessible to the fire. I place all my servants at the windows, and myself at the door, where I am determined to perish. Fear industriously increases every sound; we all listen; each communicates to the other his ideas and conjectures. We remain thus sometimes for whole hours, our hearts and our minds racked by the most anxious suspense: what a dreadful situation, a thousand times worse than that of a soldier engaged in the midst of the most severe conflict! Sometimes feeling the spontaneous courage of a man, I seem to wish for the decisive minute; the next instant a message from my wife, sent by one of the children, puzzling me beside with their little questions, unmans me: away goes my courage, and I descend again into the deepest despondency. At last finding that it was a false alarm, we return once more to our beds; but what good can the kind sleep of nature do to us when interrupted by such scenes! Securely placed as you are, you can have no idea of our agitations, but by hear-say; no relation can be equal to what we suffer and to what we feel. Every morning my youngest children are sure to have frightful dreams to relate: in vain I exert my authority to keep them silent, it is not in my power; and these images of their disturbed imagination, instead of being frivolously looked upon as in the days of our happiness, are on the contrary considered as warnings and sure prognostics of our future fate. I am not a superstitious man, but since our misfortunes, I am grown more timid, and less disposed to treat the doctrine of omens with contempt.
You know our settlement’s location, so I don’t need to explain it. To the west, there’s a mountain range that stretches to——; to the east, the area is still sparsely populated. We are almost cut off, and the houses are spread out over a large area. From the mountains, we have every reason to expect our terrifying enemy; the wilderness is a refuge where we can’t track them down. It serves as an entry point into our territory whenever they choose, and since they seem determined to wipe out the entire frontier, our doom can’t be far off: almost everything from Lake Champlain has been burned one after the other. What makes these raids even more frightening is that they mostly happen in the dead of night; every time we go to our fields, we are gripped by an involuntary fear that diminishes our strength and weakens our efforts. No other topic of conversation interrupts the various reports of destruction that spread throughout the country, and those told around the fire grow in our terrified imaginations into the most horrifying ideas! We can’t even sit down for dinner or supper without the slightest noise triggering a collective panic that robs us of the comfort of our meals. The appetite that comes from hard work and peace of mind is gone; we eat just enough to survive. Our sleep is plagued by nightmare after nightmare; sometimes I wake up as if the hour of danger has arrived; at other times, the howling of our dogs seems to signal the enemy’s approach: we jump out of bed and grab our weapons; my poor wife, with a racing heart and silent tears, says goodbye to me as if we will never see each other again; she snatches the youngest children from their beds, who, suddenly waking, add to the horror of the moment with their innocent questions. She tries to hide them in the cellar, as though it’s safe from fire. I place all my servants at the windows, and I stand by the door, ready to defend our home. Fear amplifies every sound; we listen closely; everyone shares their thoughts and theories. We stay like this for hours, our hearts and minds tortured by anxiety: what a horrific situation, a thousand times worse than that of a soldier in the thick of battle! Sometimes, feeling a burst of courage, I long for a decisive moment; the next instant, a message from my wife, delivered by one of the children alongside their innocent questions, disheartens me: my courage vanishes, and I sink back into despair. Finally, realizing it was a false alarm, we return to our beds; but what good is a deep, restful sleep when interrupted by such scenes! Safe in your place, you have no idea of our turmoil except through hearsay; no account can match what we endure and what we feel. Every morning, my youngest children inevitably share their terrifying dreams: I try to assert my authority to silence them, but I can’t; these visions from their worried minds, instead of being dismissed as trivial as they were in happier days, are now seen as warnings and certain indications of our future fate. I’m not a superstitious person, but since our misfortunes began, I’ve become more timid and less inclined to dismiss the idea of omens.
Though these evils have been gradual, yet they do not become habitual like other incidental evils. The nearer I view the end of this catastrophe, the more I shudder. But why should I trouble you with such unconnected accounts; men secure and out of danger are soon fatigued with mournful details: can you enter with me into fellowship with all these afflictive sensations; have you a tear ready to shed over the approaching ruin of a once opulent and substantial family? Read this I pray with the eyes of sympathy; with a tender sorrow, pity the lot of those whom you once called your friends; who were once surrounded with plenty, ease, and perfect security; but who now expect every night to be their last, and who are as wretched as criminals under an impending sentence of the law.
Though these misfortunes have come on slowly, they aren't becoming a normal part of life like other random troubles. The closer I get to the end of this disaster, the more uneasy I feel. But why should I burden you with such disjointed stories? People who are safe and out of harm's way quickly tire of sad details: can you join me in sharing all these painful feelings? Do you have a tear ready to shed for the impending downfall of a once wealthy and sturdy family? Please read this with sympathetic eyes; with gentle sorrow, feel for those you once called friends; who were once surrounded by abundance, comfort, and complete safety; but who now brace themselves each night for what could be their last, and who are as miserable as criminals facing a looming sentence.
As a member of a large society which extends to many parts of the world, my connection with it is too distant to be as strong as that which binds me to the inferior division in the midst of which I live. I am told that the great nation, of which we are a part, is just, wise, and free, beyond any other on earth, within its own insular boundaries; but not always so to its distant conquests: I shall not repeat all I have heard, because I cannot believe half of it. As a citizen of a smaller society, I find that any kind of opposition to its now prevailing sentiments, immediately begets hatred: how easily do men pass from loving, to hating and cursing one another! I am a lover of peace, what must I do? I am divided between the respect I feel for the ancient connection, and the fear of innovations, with the consequence of which I am not well acquainted; as they are embraced by my own countrymen. I am conscious that I was happy before this unfortunate Revolution. I feel that I am no longer so; therefore I regret the change. This is the only mode of reasoning adapted to persons in my situation. If I attach myself to the Mother Country, which is 3000 miles from me, I become what is called an enemy to my own region; if I follow the rest of my countrymen, I become opposed to our ancient masters: both extremes appear equally dangerous to a person of so little weight and consequence as I am, whose energy and example are of no avail. As to the argument on which the dispute is founded, I know little about it. Much has been said and written on both sides, but who has a judgment capacious and clear enough to decide? The great moving principles which actuate both parties are much hid from vulgar eyes, like mine; nothing but the plausible and the probable are offered to our contemplation.
As a member of a large society that spans many parts of the world, my connection to it feels too distant to be as strong as the ties I have to my local community. I hear that the great nation we're a part of is just, wise, and free, more than any other on earth, within its own borders; but that's not always the case for its distant territories. I won't repeat everything I've heard because I can't believe half of it. As a citizen of a smaller society, I notice that any kind of disagreement with the current dominant views immediately sparks hostility. It’s amazing how easily people can switch from love to hate and curse each other! I value peace, so what should I do? I'm torn between the respect I have for the old connection and the fear of changes I don't fully understand as they are embraced by my fellow countrymen. I remember being happy before this unfortunate Revolution. I feel that I'm not happy anymore; hence, I regret the change. This is the only way I can reason in my situation. If I align myself with the Mother Country, which is 3,000 miles away, I risk being labeled an enemy to my own region. If I go along with the rest of my countrymen, I find myself opposing our former rulers. Both extremes seem equally dangerous for someone as insignificant as me, whose influence and example hold no weight. Regarding the argument that has sparked this dispute, I know very little. A lot has been said and written on both sides, but who has a mind clear and open enough to make a judgment? The key driving principles that motivate both sides are mostly hidden from ordinary people like me; we only see what's plausible and likely offered for our consideration.
The innocent class are always the victim of the few; they are in all countries and at all times the inferior agents, on which the popular phantom is erected; they clamour, and must toil, and bleed, and are always sure of meeting with oppression and rebuke. It is for the sake of the great leaders on both sides, that so much blood must be spilt; that of the people is counted as nothing. Great events are not achieved for us, though it is by us that they are principally accomplished; by the arms, the sweat, the lives of the people. Books tell me so much that they inform me of nothing. Sophistry, the bane of freemen, launches forth in all her deceiving attire! After all, most men reason from passions; and shall such an ignorant individual as I am decide, and say this side is right, that side is wrong? Sentiment and feeling are the only guides I know. Alas, how should I unravel an argument, in which reason herself hath given way to brutality and bloodshed! What then must I do? I ask the wisest lawyers, the ablest casuists, the warmest patriots; for I mean honestly. Great Source of wisdom! inspire me with light sufficient to guide my benighted steps out of this intricate maze! Shall I discard all my ancient principles, shall I renounce that name, that nation which I held once so respectable? I feel the powerful attraction; the sentiments they inspired grew with my earliest knowledge, and were grafted upon the first rudiments of my education. On the other hand, shall I arm myself against that country where I first drew breath, against the play-mates of my youth, my bosom friends, my acquaintance?—the idea makes me shudder! Must I be called a parricide, a traitor, a villain, lose the esteem of all those whom I love, to preserve my own; be shunned like a rattlesnake, or be pointed at like a bear? I have neither heroism not magnanimity enough to make so great a sacrifice. Here I am tied, I am fastened by numerous strings, nor do I repine at the pressure they cause; ignorant as I am, I can pervade the utmost extent of the calamities which have already overtaken our poor afflicted country. I can see the great and accumulated ruin yet extending itself as far as the theatre of war has reached; I hear the groans of thousands of families now ruined and desolated by our aggressors. I cannot count the multitude of orphans this war has made; nor ascertain the immensity of blood we have lost. Some have asked, whether it was a crime to resist; to repel some parts of this evil. Others have asserted, that a resistance so general makes pardon unattainable, and repentance useless: and dividing the crime among so many, renders it imperceptible. What one party calls meritorious, the other denominates flagitious. These opinions vary, contract, or expand, like the events of the war on which they are founded. What can an insignificant man do in the midst of these jarring contradictory parties, equally hostile to persons situated as I am? And after all who will be the really guilty?—Those most certainly who fail of success. Our fate, the fate of thousands, is then necessarily involved in the dark wheel of fortune. Why then so many useless reasonings; we are the sport of fate. Farewell education, principles, love of our country, farewell; all are become useless to the generality of us: he who governs himself according to what he calls his principles, may be punished either by one party or the other, for those very principles. He who proceeds without principle, as chance, timidity, or self-preservation directs, will not perhaps fare better; but he will be less blamed. What are we in the great scale of events, we poor defenceless frontier inhabitants? What is it to the gazing world, whether we breathe or whether we die? Whatever virtue, whatever merit and disinterestedness we may exhibit in our secluded retreats, of what avail?
The innocent class is always the victim of the few; they exist in all countries and at all times as the weaker ones upon whom the popular illusion is built. They cry out, and must work hard, suffer, and sacrifice, always facing oppression and scorn. It's for the sake of the powerful leaders on both sides that so much blood must be shed; the lives of the people are considered worthless. Major events are not achieved for us, even though they are primarily accomplished by us—through the arms, the labor, and the lives of everyday people. Books tell me a lot but inform me of nothing. Sophistry, the enemy of free people, parades in all its deceptive forms! After all, most people reason based on their emotions; and how can an ignorant person like me decide which side is right and which is wrong? Emotion and feeling are the only guides I know. Alas, how can I untangle an argument where reason itself has given way to violence and bloodshed? What should I do? I ask the wisest lawyers, the best thinkers, the most passionate patriots; I'm sincere in my quest for understanding. Great Source of wisdom! Inspire me with enough light to guide my confused steps through this complicated maze! Should I abandon all my old beliefs, should I reject the name and country that I once respected? I feel a strong pull; the values they instilled in me grew with my earliest understanding and were part of my first lessons in life. On the other hand, should I turn against the country where I was born, against the childhood friends, my close companions, my neighbors?—the thought makes me shudder! Must I be called a traitor, a villain, lose the respect of everyone I love, just to save myself? Be shunned like a dangerous snake, or be pointed at like a monster? I don't have the courage or nobility to make such a huge sacrifice. Here I am, tied down by many strings, and I don't even mind the weight they create; as ignorant as I am, I can grasp the full extent of the disaster that has already befallen our suffering country. I see the great and growing destruction spreading as far as the battlefield reaches; I hear the cries of thousands of families now ruined and devastated by our attackers. I can't count the number of orphans this war has created; nor can I grasp the vast amount of blood we've lost. Some have asked whether resisting this evil is a crime. Others maintain that such widespread resistance makes forgiveness impossible and makes regret meaningless: and by dividing the wrongdoing among so many, it becomes unnoticeable. What one side calls righteous, the other labels as wicked. These opinions shift, shrink, or expand, like the events of the war they stem from. What can an insignificant person like me do in the midst of these conflicting factions, both hostile to people like me? And ultimately, who will be truly guilty?—Surely, those who fail to succeed. Our fate, the fate of thousands, is inevitably tied to the dark wheel of fortune. Why then all these pointless arguments? We are at the mercy of fate. Farewell education, principles, love of our country; all have become useless to most of us: someone who lives according to what they call their principles may be punished by either side for those very principles. Someone who acts without principles, letting chance, fear, or self-preservation guide them, may not fare any better; but they will be less blamed. What are we in the grand scheme of things, we poor defenseless frontier dwellers? What does it matter to the watching world if we live or if we die? Whatever virtue, whatever merit, and selflessness we may show in our isolated corners, what good is it?
We are like the pismires destroyed by the plough; whose destruction prevents not the future crop. Self-preservation, therefore, the rule of nature, seems to be the best rule of conduct; what good can we do by vain resistance, by useless efforts? The cool, the distant spectator, placed in safety, may arraign me for ingratitude, may bring forth the principles of Solon or Montesquieu; he may look on me as wilfully guilty; he may call me by the most opprobrious names. Secure from personal danger, his warm imagination, undisturbed by the least agitation of the heart, will expatiate freely on this grand question; and will consider this extended field, but as exhibiting the double scene of attack and defence. To him the object becomes abstracted, the intermediate glares, the perspective distance and a variety of opinions unimpaired by affections, presents to his mind but one set of ideas. Here he proclaims the high guilt of the one, and there the right of the other; but let him come and reside with us one single month, let him pass with us through all the successive hours of necessary toil, terror and affright, let him watch with us, his musket in his hand, through tedious, sleepless nights, his imagination furrowed by the keen chisel of every passion; let his wife and his children become exposed to the most dreadful hazards of death; let the existence of his property depend on a single spark, blown by the breath of an enemy; let him tremble with us in our fields, shudder at the rustling of every leaf; let his heart, the seat of the most affecting passions, be powerfully wrung by hearing the melancholy end of his relations and friends; let him trace on the map the progress of these desolations; let his alarmed imagination predict to him the night, the dreadful night when it may be his turn to perish, as so many have perished before. Observe then, whether the man will not get the better of the citizen, whether his political maxims will not vanish! Yes, he will cease to glow so warmly with the glory of the metropolis; all his wishes will be turned toward the preservation of his family! Oh, were he situated where I am, were his house perpetually filled, as mine is, with miserable victims just escaped from the flames and the scalping knife, telling of barbarities and murders that make human nature tremble; his situation would suspend every political reflection, and expel every abstract idea. My heart is full and involuntarily takes hold of any notion from whence it can receive ideal ease or relief. I am informed that the king has the most numerous, as well as the fairest, progeny of children, of any potentate now in the world: he may be a great king, but he must feel as we common mortals do, in the good wishes he forms for their lives and prosperity. His mind no doubt often springs forward on the wings of anticipation, and contemplates us as happily settled in the world. If a poor frontier inhabitant may be allowed to suppose this great personage the first in our system, to be exposed but for one hour, to the exquisite pangs we so often feel, would not the preservation of so numerous a family engross all his thoughts; would not the ideas of dominion and other felicities attendant on royalty all vanish in the hour of danger? The regal character, however sacred, would be superseded by the stronger, because more natural one of man and father. Oh! did he but know the circumstances of this horrid war, I am sure he would put a stop to that long destruction of parents and children. I am sure that while he turned his ears to state policy, he would attentively listen also to the dictates of nature, that great parent; for, as a good king, he no doubt wishes to create, to spare, and to protect, as she does. Must I then, in order to be called a faithful subject, coolly, and philosophically say, it is necessary for the good of Britain, that my children's brains should be dashed against the walls of the house in which they were reared; that my wife should be stabbed and scalped before my face; that I should be either murdered or captivated; or that for greater expedition we should all be locked up and burnt to ashes as the family of the B—- -n was? Must I with meekness wait for that last pitch of desolation, and receive with perfect resignation so hard a fate, from ruffians, acting at such a distance from the eyes of any superior; monsters, left to the wild impulses of the wildest nature. Could the lions of Africa be transported here and let loose, they would no doubt kill us in order to prey upon our carcasses! but their appetites would not require so many victims. Shall I wait to be punished with death, or else to be stripped of all food and raiment, reduced to despair without redress and without hope. Shall those who may escape, see everything they hold dear destroyed and gone. Shall those few survivors, lurking in some obscure corner, deplore in vain the fate of their families, mourn over parents either captivated, butchered, or burnt; roam among our wilds, and wait for death at the foot of some tree, without a murmur, or without a sigh, for the good of the cause? No, it is impossible! so astonishing a sacrifice is not to be expected from human nature, it must belong to beings of an inferior or superior order, actuated by less, or by more refined principles. Even those great personages who are so far elevated above the common ranks of men, those, I mean, who wield and direct so many thunders; those who have let loose against us these demons of war, could they be transported here, and metamorphosed into simple planters as we are, they would, from being the arbiters of human destiny, sink into miserable victims; they would feel and exclaim as we do, and be as much at a loss what line of conduct to prosecute. Do you well comprehend the difficulties of our situation? If we stay we are sure to perish at one time or another; no vigilance on our part can save us; if we retire, we know not where to go; every house is filled with refugees as wretched as ourselves; and if we remove we become beggars. The property of farmers is not like that of merchants; and absolute poverty is worse than death. If we take up arms to defend ourselves, we are denominated rebels; should we not be rebels against nature, could we be shamefully passive? Shall we then, like martyrs, glory in an allegiance, now become useless, and voluntarily expose ourselves to a species of desolation which, though it ruin us entirely, yet enriches not our ancient masters. By this inflexible and sullen attachment, we shall be despised by our countrymen, and destroyed by our ancient friends; whatever we may say, whatever merit we may claim, will not shelter us from those indiscriminate blows, given by hired banditti, animated by all those passions which urge men to shed the blood of others; how bitter the thought! On the contrary, blows received by the hands of those from whom we expected protection, extinguish ancient respect, and urge us to self-defence- -perhaps to revenge; this is the path which nature herself points out, as well to the civilised as to the uncivilised. The Creator of hearts has himself stamped on them those propensities at their first formation; and must we then daily receive this treatment from a power once so loved? The Fox flies or deceives the hounds that pursue him; the bear, when overtaken, boldly resists and attacks them; the hen, the very timid hen, fights for the preservation of her chickens, nor does she decline to attack, and to meet on the wing even the swift kite. Shall man, then, provided both with instinct and reason, unmoved, unconcerned, and passive, see his subsistence consumed, and his progeny either ravished from him or murdered? Shall fictitious reason extinguish the unerring impulse of instinct? No; my former respect, my former attachment vanishes with my safety; that respect and attachment was purchased by protection, and it has ceased. Could not the great nation we belong to have accomplished her designs by means of her numerous armies, by means of those fleets which cover the ocean? Must those who are masters of two thirds of the trade of the world; who have in their hands the power which almighty gold can give; who possess a species of wealth that increases with their desires; must they establish their conquest with our insignificant innocent blood!
We are like the ants crushed by the plow; their destruction doesn’t stop future crops. So, self-preservation, the law of nature, seems to be the best guideline for behavior; what good does it do us to put up a futile fight, to make pointless efforts? The calm, distant observer, safe from harm, might accuse me of ingratitude, bringing up the principles of Solon or Montesquieu; he might see me as willfully guilty and call me the most disgraceful names. Secure from any personal risk, his warm imagination, untouched by emotional upheaval, will freely discuss this grand issue; he will see this wide battlefield as just a display of attack and defense. To him, the issue becomes abstracted, the glaring details, the distant perspective, and various opinions unclouded by feelings present to his mind just one set of ideas. Here he denounces one side as guilty and there the other as right; but let him come and live with us for just one month, let him share our endless hours of necessary labor, fear, and dread, let him watch with us, his weapon in hand, through long, sleepless nights, his imagination carved by every intense feeling; let his wife and kids face the dreadful threats of death; let the survival of his belongings depend on a single spark, blown on by an enemy's breath; let him tremble with us in our fields, flinch at the rustling of every leaf; let his heart, the seat of the most touching emotions, be deeply pained by hearing of the tragic ends of his relatives and friends; let him trace on the map the route of these devastations; let his anxious mind predict the night, the horrifying night when it might be his turn to die, as so many have died before. Then observe whether the man will not overcome the citizen, whether his political ideas won’t fade away! Yes, he will stop feeling so passionate about the glory of the capital; all his desires will shift to the safety of his family! Oh, if only he were in my position, if his home were constantly filled, as mine is, with miserable survivors just escaped from flames and scalps, recounting horrors and murders that shake human nature; his state would suspend any political reflection and banish any abstract thoughts. My heart is overflowing and instinctively clings to any idea that offers me comfort or relief. I’m told that the king has the most numerous and beautiful children of any ruler in the world: he may be a great king, but he must feel like we ordinary people do, in the hopes he holds for their lives and wellbeing. His mind likely often soars ahead in anticipation, envisioning us happily settled. If a poor frontier dweller could assume this prominent figure to be the main one in our system, exposed for even just one hour to the intense sufferings we often endure, wouldn’t the safety of such a large family consume all his thoughts? Wouldn’t the ideas of power and the other joys of being royalty disappear in a moment of danger? The royal role, however sacred, would give way to the more powerful, inherently human role of a father. Oh! If he only knew the circumstances of this horrific war, I’m sure he would end this ongoing destruction of parents and children. I’m confident that while he listened to state affairs, he would also heed the call of nature, the great mother; for, as a good king, he surely wishes to create, to save, and to protect, just like she does. Must I then, to be seen as a loyal subject, coolly and philosophically say that for the good of Britain, my children’s brains should be smashed against the walls of the home where they were raised; that my wife should be stabbed and scalped before my eyes; that I should be either killed or captured; or that we should all be locked up and burnt to ash like the family of the B—-n was? Must I patiently await that final point of despair, receiving such a harsh fate from men acting far from the view of any authority; monsters driven by the wild impulses of their nature? If lions from Africa were brought here and set loose, they would surely kill us to feast on our bodies! But even they wouldn’t need so many victims. Should I wait to die, or to be stripped of all food and clothing, brought to despair without remedy and hope? Should those who survive see everything they cherish destroyed and gone? Should the few survivors, hiding in some dark corner, mourn uselessly over the fate of their families, grieving for parents either captured, slaughtered, or burnt; wander through our wilds, waiting for death at the base of a tree, without a murmur or sigh, for the sake of some cause? No, that’s impossible! Such a shocking sacrifice is not to be expected from human nature; it must belong to beings of a lower or higher order, driven by less or more refined motivations. Even those great figures who are so far above the regular ranks of men, those who wield and direct countless forces; those who have unleashed these demons of war upon us, if they were to come here and turn into regular settlers like us, would fall from being the arbiters of human fate to becoming pathetic victims; they would feel and exclaim just like we do, and be just as lost regarding what action to take. Do you truly understand the challenges of our situation? If we stay we are bound to perish eventually; no amount of vigilance can save us; if we flee, we don’t know where to go; every house is packed with refugees as miserable as ourselves; and if we move we become beggars. The property of farmers is not like that of merchants; absolute poverty is worse than death. If we pick up arms to defend ourselves, we’re labeled rebels; shouldn't we rebel against nature instead, if we were shamefully passive? Shall we then, like martyrs, take pride in an allegiance that has now become worthless, and willingly expose ourselves to a kind of destruction that, while it ruins us completely, enriches our old masters not at all? By holding on to this stubborn and morose attachment, we will be despised by our fellow countrymen and destroyed by our former friends; whatever we say, whatever value we claim, will not shield us from those indiscriminate blows dealt by hired thugs, fueled by all the feelings that drive men to spill each other’s blood; how bitter that thought! In contrast, blows received from those we expected protection from erase old respect and push us towards self-defense—perhaps even revenge; this is the path that nature herself points out, both for the civilized and the uncivilized. The Creator of hearts has instilled in them those tendencies from their very formation; must we then endure such treatment day after day from a power we once loved? The fox runs away from or tricks the hounds that chase him; the bear, when caught, bravely fights back; the hen, the very timid hen, fights to protect her chicks and does not hesitate to confront and meet the swift kite in mid-air. Shall man then, with both instinct and reason, remain unmoved, indifferent, and passive, watching his livelihood consumed, and his young either taken from him or killed? Shall imaginary reasoning extinguish the undeniable urge of instinct? No; my previous respect, my previous attachment fades with my safety; that respect and attachment were earned by protection, and now it's gone. Could not the great nation we belong to achieve her goals through her vast armies, through those fleets that cover the ocean? Must those who dominate two-thirds of global trade, who hold the power that wealth can command, who possess a type of wealth that grows with their desires, establish their conquest with our insignificant innocent blood!
Must I then bid farewell to Britain, to that renowned country? Must I renounce a name so ancient and so venerable? Alas, she herself, that once indulgent parent, forces me to take up arms against her. She herself, first inspired the most unhappy citizens of our remote districts, with the thoughts of shedding the blood of those whom they used to call by the name of friends and brethren. That great nation which now convulses the world; which hardly knows the extent of her Indian kingdoms; which looks toward the universal monarchy of trade, of industry, of riches, of power: why must she strew our poor frontiers with the carcasses of her friends, with the wrecks of our insignificant villages, in which there is no gold? When, oppressed by painful recollection, I revolve all these scattered ideas in my mind, when I contemplate my situation, and the thousand streams of evil with which I am surrounded; when I descend into the particular tendency even of the remedy I have proposed, I am convulsed— convulsed sometimes to that degree, as to be tempted to exclaim—Why has the master of the world permitted so much indiscriminate evil throughout every part of this poor planet, at all times, and among all kinds of people? It ought surely to be the punishment of the wicked only. I bring that cup to my lips, of which I must soon taste, and shudder at its bitterness. What then is life, I ask myself, is it a gracious gift? No, it is too bitter; a gift means something valuable conferred, but life appears to be a mere accident, and of the worst kind: we are born to be victims of diseases and passions, of mischances and death: better not to be than to be miserable.—Thus impiously I roam, I fly from one erratic thought to another, and my mind, irritated by these acrimonious reflections, is ready sometimes to lead me to dangerous extremes of violence. When I recollect that I am a father, and a husband, the return of these endearing ideas strikes deep into my heart. Alas! they once made it to glow with pleasure and with every ravishing exultation; but now they fill it with sorrow. At other times, my wife industriously rouses me out of these dreadful meditations, and soothes me by all the reasoning she is mistress of; but her endeavours only serve to make me more miserable, by reflecting that she must share with all these calamities, the bare apprehensions of which I am afraid will subvert her reason. Nor can I with patience think that a beloved wife, my faithful help-mate, throughout all my rural schemes, the principal hand which has assisted me in rearing the prosperous fabric of ease and independence I lately possessed, as well as my children, those tenants of my heart, should daily and nightly be exposed to such a cruel fate. Selfpreservation is above all political precepts and rules, and even superior to the dearest opinions of our minds; a reasonable accommodation of ourselves to the various exigencies of the time in which we live, is the most irresistible precept. To this great evil I must seek some sort of remedy adapted to remove or to palliate it; situated as I am, what steps should I take that will neither injure nor insult any of the parties, and at the same time save my family from that certain destruction which awaits it, if I remain here much longer. Could I insure them bread, safety, and subsistence, not the bread of idleness, but that earned by proper labour as heretofore; could this be accomplished by the sacrifice of my life, I would willingly give it up. I attest before heaven, that it is only for these I would wish to live and to toil: for these whom I have brought into this miserable existence. I resemble, methinks, one of the stones of a ruined arch, still retaining that pristine form that anciently fitted the place I occupied, but the centre is tumbled down; I can be nothing until I am replaced, either in the former circle, or in some stronger one. I see one on a smaller scale, and at a considerable distance, but it is within my power to reach it: and since I have ceased to consider myself as a member of the ancient state now convulsed, I willingly descend into an inferior one. I will revert into a state approaching nearer to that of nature, unencumbered either with voluminous laws, or contradictory codes, often galling the very necks of those whom they protect; and at the same time sufficiently remote from the brutality of unconnected savage nature. Do you, my friend, perceive the path I have found out? it is that which leads to the tenants of the great———village of———, where, far removed from the accursed neighbourhood of Europeans, its inhabitants live with more ease, decency, and peace, than you imagine: where, though governed by no laws, yet find, in uncontaminated simple manners all that laws can afford. Their system is sufficiently complete to answer all the primary wants of man, and to constitute him a social being, such as he ought to be in the great forest of nature. There it is that I have resolved at any rate to transport myself and family: an eccentric thought, you may say, thus to cut asunder all former connections, and to form new ones with a people whom nature has stamped with such different characteristics! But as the happiness of my family is the only object of my wishes, I care very little where we be, or where we go, provided that we are safe, and all united together. Our new calamities being shared equally by all, will become lighter; our mutual affection for each other, will in this great transmutation become the strongest link of our new society, will afford us every joy we can receive on a foreign soil, and preserve us in unity, as the gravity and coherency of matter prevents the world from dissolution. Blame me not, it would be cruel in you, it would beside be entirely useless; for when you receive this we shall be on the wing. When we think all hopes are gone, must we, like poor pusillanimous wretches, despair and die? No; I perceive before me a few resources, though through many dangers, which I will explain to you hereafter. It is not, believe me, a disappointed ambition which leads me to take this step, it is the bitterness of my situation, it is the impossibility of knowing what better measure to adopt: my education fitted me for nothing more than the most simple occupations of life; I am but a feller of trees, a cultivator of land, the most honourable title an American can have. I have no exploits, no discoveries, no inventions to boast of; I have cleared about 370 acres of land, some for the plough, some for the scythe; and this has occupied many years of my life. I have never possessed, or wish to possess anything more than what could be earned or produced by the united industry of my family. I wanted nothing more than to live at home independent and tranquil, and to teach my children how to provide the means of a future ample subsistence, founded on labour, like that of their father, This is the career of life I have pursued, and that which I had marked out for them and for which they seemed to be so well calculated by their inclinations, and by their constitutions. But now these pleasing expectations are gone, we must abandon the accumulated industry of nineteen years, we must fly we hardly know whither, through the most impervious paths, and become members of a new and strange community. Oh, virtue! is this all the reward thou hast to confer on thy votaries? Either thou art only a chimera, or thou art a timid useless being; soon affrighted, when ambition, thy great adversary, dictates, when war re-echoes the dreadful sounds, and poor helpless individuals are mowed down by its cruel reapers like useless grass. I have at all times generously relieved what few distressed people I have met with; I have encouraged the industrious; my house has always been opened to travellers; I have not lost a month in illness since I have been a man; I have caused upwards of an hundred and twenty families to remove hither. Many of them I have led by the hand in the days of their first trial; distant as I am from any places of worship or school of education, I have been the pastor of my family, and the teacher of many of my neighbours. I have learnt them as well as I could, the gratitude they owe to God, the father of harvests; and their duties to man: I have been as useful a subject; ever obedient to the laws, ever vigilant to see them respected and observed. My wife hath faithfully followed the same line within her province; no woman was ever a better economist, or spun or wove better linen; yet we must perish, perish like wild beasts, included within a ring of fire!
Must I then say goodbye to Britain, that famous country? Must I give up a name so old and respected? Alas, she herself, that once caring motherland, forces me to take up arms against her. She herself first inspired the most unfortunate citizens of our far-off regions to think about spilling the blood of those they once called friends and family. That great nation, which now shakes the world; which barely knows the full extent of her Indian territories; which aims for global dominance in trade, industry, wealth, and power: why must she leave our poor borders littered with the bodies of her friends, with the wreckage of our tiny villages, which hold no riches? When I am overwhelmed by painful memories, when I reflect on all these scattered thoughts in my mind, when I consider my situation, and the endless streams of suffering surrounding me; when I delve into the nature of the remedy I’ve proposed, I am shaken—sometimes to the point of wanting to shout—Why has the ruler of the world allowed such indiscriminate evil to exist throughout this poor planet, across all times and among all people? It should only be the punishment of the wicked. I bring that cup to my lips, which I must soon taste, and shudder at its bitterness. What then is life, I ask myself? Is it a precious gift? No, it is too bitter; a gift implies something valuable conferred, but life seems like a mere accident, and of the worst kind: we are born to suffer from diseases and passions, from misfortunes and death: better not to exist than to be miserable.—Thus, I impiously wander, flitting from one erratic thought to another, and my mind, fueled by these harsh reflections, is sometimes driven to dangerous extremes of violence. When I remember that I am a father and a husband, these cherished thoughts strike deep in my heart. Once, they filled it with joy and every delightful exultation; now they overwhelm it with sorrow. At other times, my wife tirelessly pulls me out of these dark musings and comforts me with all the reasoning she can muster; but her efforts only make me more miserable, as it reminds me that she must share in all these calamities, the mere thought of which I fear will shatter her mind. Nor can I bear to think that a beloved wife, my faithful partner in all my local endeavors, the main person who helped me build the comfortable life I recently enjoyed, along with my children, those treasures of my heart, should be exposed daily and nightly to such a cruel fate. Self-preservation is above all political doctrines and rules, and even superior to the most cherished beliefs we hold; a reasonable adjustment to the various challenges of our time is the most compelling principle. To this significant evil, I must find some remedy suited to either remove or lessen it; given my situation, what actions should I take that will neither harm nor insult anyone involved, while also saving my family from the certain destruction that awaits them if I stay here much longer? If I could guarantee them food, safety, and sustenance, not the bread of idleness, but that earned through honest work like before; if this could be achieved by sacrificing my life, I would gladly give it up. I swear before heaven that it is only for them that I wish to live and work: for those I’ve brought into this miserable existence. I resemble, I think, one of the stones of a ruined arch, still retaining that ancient shape that once fit its place, but the center has fallen down; I can be nothing until I am restored, either in the former structure or in a stronger one. I see a smaller one at a considerable distance, but I can reach it: and since I no longer see myself as part of the ancient state now in turmoil, I willingly descend into an inferior one. I will revert to a state closer to nature, free from complex laws or conflicting codes, which often burden those they are meant to protect; and at the same time, sufficiently distant from the brutality of unconnected savage nature. Do you, my friend, see the path I’ve discovered? It is the one that leads to the residents of the great———village of———, where, far removed from the cursed presence of Europeans, its people live with more ease, decency, and peace than you might imagine: where, although governed by no laws, they find in their untainted simplicity everything that laws can provide. Their system is complete enough to meet all of humanity's basic needs and to make him a social being, as he should be in the vast forest of nature. There is where I have resolved to take myself and my family: an eccentric thought, you may say, to sever all former ties and create new ones with a people so different! But since my family's happiness is my only goal, I care little about where we are or where we go, as long as we are safe and together. Our new shared difficulties will feel lighter; our mutual love for each other will be the strongest bond of our new community, providing us with joy on foreign soil and keeping us united, just as the forces of nature hold the world from falling apart. Don’t blame me; it would be cruel of you, and also completely pointless; for when you receive this, we will be on the move. When we think all hope is lost, must we, like timid beings, despair and perish? No; I see a few options ahead of me, even through many dangers, which I will explain to you later. It is not, trust me, a frustrated ambition that drives me to take this step; it is the bitterness of my situation, the impossibility of knowing what better course of action to take: my education prepared me only for the simplest tasks in life; I am just a tree cutter, a farmer, the most honorable title an American can hold. I have no heroic deeds, no discoveries, no inventions to boast of; I have cleared about 370 acres of land, some for farming, some for mowing; and this has taken many years of my life. I have never owned, nor do I wish to own, anything more than what could be earned or produced by my family's combined efforts. I wanted nothing more than to live peacefully and independently at home, teaching my children how to secure a good future based on hard work, just like their father. This has been the path I’ve chosen, and one that I intended for them, and for which they seemed well-suited by their nature and upbringing. But now those promising expectations are gone, we must abandon the results of nineteen years of hard work, flee we hardly know where, through the toughest paths, and become part of a new and strange community. Oh, virtue! Is this all the reward you offer your followers? Either you are just an illusion, or you are a fearful and useless being; easily scared away when ambition, your great opponent, demands, when war echoes with dreadful sounds, and poor helpless individuals are mowed down like useless grass. I have always generously helped the few distressed people I’ve encountered; I have supported those who work hard; my home has always been open to travelers; I have not spent a month being ill since I’ve become a man; I have assisted over a hundred and twenty families in moving here. Many of them I have guided by the hand in their early struggles; far from any place of worship or school, I have acted as the pastor for my family and the teacher for many of my neighbors. I have taught them, as best as I could, the gratitude they owe to God, the provider of harvests; and their duties to fellow humans: I have been a useful citizen; always obedient to the laws, always watchful to see that they are respected and followed. My wife has faithfully walked the same path in her domain; no woman has ever been a better manager, or spun or wove better linen; yet we must perish, perish like wild animals, trapped within a ring of fire!
Yes, I will cheerfully embrace that resource, it is an holy inspiration; by night and by day, it presents itself to my mind: I have carefully revolved the scheme; I have considered in all its future effects and tendencies, the new mode of living we must pursue, without salt, without spices, without linen and with little other clothing; the art of hunting, we must acquire, the new manners we must adopt, the new language we must speak; the dangers attending the education of my children we must endure. These changes may appear more terrific at a distance perhaps than when grown familiar by practice: what is it to us, whether we eat well made pastry, or pounded alagriches; well roasted beef, or smoked venison; cabbages, or squashes? Whether we wear neat home-spun or good beaver; whether we sleep on feather-beds, or on bear-skins? The difference is not worth attending to. The difficulty of the language, fear of some great intoxication among the Indians; finally, the apprehension lest my younger children should be caught by that singular charm, so dangerous at their tender years; are the only considerations that startle me. By what power does it come to pass, that children who have been adopted when young among these people, can never be prevailed on to readopt European manners? Many an anxious parent I have seen last war, who at the return of the peace, went to the Indian villages where they knew their children had been carried in captivity; when to their inexpressible sorrow, they found them so perfectly Indianised, that many knew them no longer, and those whose more advanced ages permitted them to recollect their fathers and mothers, absolutely refused to follow them, and ran to their adopted parents for protection against the effusions of love their unhappy real parents lavished on them! Incredible as this may appear, I have heard it asserted in a thousand instances, among persons of credit. In the village of———, where I purpose to go, there lived, about fifteen years ago, an Englishman and a Swede, whose history would appear moving, had I time to relate it. They were grown to the age of men when they were taken; they happily escaped the great punishment of war captives, and were obliged to marry the Squaws who had saved their lives by adoption. By the force of habit, they became at last thoroughly naturalised to this wild course of life. While I was there, their friends sent them a considerable sum of money to ransom themselves with. The Indians, their old masters, gave them their choice, and without requiring any consideration, told them, that they had been long as free as themselves. They chose to remain; and the reasons they gave me would greatly surprise you: the most perfect freedom, the ease of living, the absence of those cares and corroding solicitudes which so often prevail with us; the peculiar goodness of the soil they cultivated, for they did not trust altogether to hunting; all these, and many more motives, which I have forgot, made them prefer that life, of which we entertain such dreadful opinions. It cannot be, therefore, so bad as we generally conceive it to be; there must be in their social bond something singularly captivating, and far superior to anything to be boasted of among us; for thousands of Europeans are Indians, and we have no examples of even one of those Aborigines having from choice become Europeans! There must be something more congenial to our native dispositions, than the fictitious society in which we live; or else why should children, and even grown persons, become in a short time so invincibly attached to it? There must be something very bewitching in their manners, something very indelible and marked by the very hands of nature. For, take a young Indian lad, give him the best education you possibly can, load him with your bounty, with presents, nay with riches; yet he will secretly long for his native woods, which you would imagine he must have long since forgot; and on the first opportunity he can possibly find, you will see him voluntarily leave behind him all you have given him, and return with inexpressible joy to lie on the mats of his fathers. Mr.——, some years ago, received from a good old Indian, who died in his house, a young lad, of nine years of age, his grandson. He kindly educated him with his children, and bestowed on him the same care and attention in respect to the memory of his venerable grandfather, who was a worthy man. He intended to give him a genteel trade, but in the spring season when all the family went to the woods to make their maple sugar, he suddenly disappeared; and it was not until seventeen months after, that his benefactor heard he had reached the village of Bald Eagle, where he still dwelt. Let us say what we will of them, of their inferior organs, of their want of bread, etc., they are as stout and well made as the Europeans. Without temples, without priests, without kings, and without laws, they are in many instances superior to us; and the proofs of what I advance, are, that they live without care, sleep without inquietude, take life as it comes, bearing all its asperities with unparalleled patience, and die without any kind of apprehension for what they have done, or for what they expect to meet with hereafter. What system of philosophy can give us so many necessary qualifications for happiness? They most certainly are much more closely connected with nature than we are; they are her immediate children, the inhabitants of the woods are her undefiled off-spring: those of the plains are her degenerated breed, far, very far removed from her primitive laws, from her original design. It is therefore resolved on. I will either die in the attempt or succeed; better perish all together in one fatal hour, than to suffer what we daily endure. I do not expect to enjoy in the village of———an uninterrupted happiness; it cannot be our lot, let us live where we will; I am not founding my future prosperity on golden dreams. Place mankind where you will, they must always have adverse circumstances to struggle with; from nature, accidents, constitution; from seasons, from that great combination of mischances which perpetually lead us to new diseases, to poverty, etc. Who knows but I may meet in this new situation, some accident from whence may spring up new sources of unexpected prosperity? Who can be presumptuous enough to predict all the good? Who can foresee all the evils, which strew the paths of our lives? But after all, I cannot but recollect what sacrifice I am going to make, what amputation I am going to suffer, what transition I am going to experience. Pardon my repetitions, my wild, my trifling reflections, they proceed from the agitations of my mind, and the fulness of my heart; the action of thus retracing them seems to lighten the burden, and to exhilarate my spirits; this is besides the last letter you will receive from me; I would fain tell you all, though I hardly know how. Oh! in the hours, in the moments of my greatest anguish, could I intuitively represent to you that variety of thought which crowds on my mind, you would have reason to be surprised, and to doubt of their possibility. Shall we ever meet again? If we should, where will it be? On the wild shores of——. If it be my doom to end my days there, I will greatly improve them; and perhaps make room for a few more families, who will choose to retire from the fury of a storm, the agitated billows of which will yet roar for many years on our extended shores. Perhaps I may repossess my house, if it be not burnt down; but how will my improvements look? why, half defaced, bearing the strong marks of abandonment, and of the ravages of war. However, at present I give everything over for lost; I will bid a long farewell to what I leave behind. If ever I repossess it, I shall receive it as a gift, as a reward for my conduct and fortitude. Do not imagine, however, that I am a stoic—by no means: I must, on the contrary, confess to you, that I feel the keenest regret, at abandoning an house which I have in some measure reared with my own hands. Yes, perhaps I may never revisit those fields which I have cleared, those trees which I have planted, those meadows which, in my youth, were a hideous wilderness, now converted by my industry into rich pastures and pleasant lawns. If in Europe it is praise-worthy to be attached to paternal inheritances, how much more natural, how much more powerful must the tie be with us, who, if I may be permitted the expression, are the founders, the creators of our own farms! When I see my table surrounded with my blooming offspring, all united in the bonds of the strongest affection, it kindles in my paternal heart a variety of tumultuous sentiments, which none but a father and a husband in my situation can feel or describe. Perhaps I may see my wife, my children, often distressed, involuntarily recalling to their minds the ease and abundance which they enjoyed under the paternal roof. Perhaps I may see them want that bread which I now leave behind; overtaken by diseases and penury, rendered more bitter by the recollection of former days of opulence and plenty. Perhaps I may be assailed on every side by unforeseen accidents, which I shall not be able to prevent or to alleviate. Can I contemplate such images without the most unutterable emotions? My fate is determined; but I have not determined it, you may assure yourself, without having undergone the most painful conflicts of a variety of passions;— interest, love of ease, disappointed views, and pleasing expectations frustrated;—I shuddered at the review! Would to God I was master of the stoical tranquillity of that magnanimous sect; oh, that I were possessed of those sublime lessons which Appollonius of Chalcis gave to the Emperor Antoninus! I could then with much more propriety guide the helm of my little bark, which is soon to be freighted with all that I possess most dear on earth, through this stormy passage to a safe harbour; and when there, become to my fellow passengers, a surer guide, a brighter example, a pattern more worthy of imitation, throughout all the new scenes they must pass, and the new career they must traverse. I have observed notwithstanding, the means hitherto made use of, to arm the principal nations against our frontiers. Yet they have not, they will not take up the hatchet against a people who have done them no harm. The passions necessary to urge these people to war, cannot be roused, they cannot feel the stings of vengeance, the thirst of which alone can compel them to shed blood: far superior in their motives of action to the Europeans, who for sixpence per day, may be engaged to shed that of any people on earth. They know nothing of the nature of our disputes, they have no ideas of such revolutions as this; a civil division of a village or tribe, are events which have never been recorded in their traditions: many of them know very well that they have too long been the dupes and the victims of both parties; foolishly arming for our sakes, sometimes against each other, sometimes against our white enemies. They consider us as born on the same land, and, though they have no reasons to love us, yet they seem carefully to avoid entering into this quarrel, from whatever motives. I am speaking of those nations with which I am best acquainted, a few hundreds of the worst kind mixed with whites, worse than themselves, are now hired by Great Britain, to perpetuate those dreadful incursions. In my youth I traded with the——, under the conduct of my uncle, and always traded justly and equitably; some of them remember it to this day. Happily their village is far removed from the dangerous neighbourhood of the whites; I sent a man last spring to it, who understands the woods extremely well, and who speaks their language; he is just returned, after several weeks absence, and has brought me, as I had flattered myself, a string of thirty purple wampum, as a token that their honest chief will spare us half of his wigwam until we have time to erect one. He has sent me word that they have land in plenty, of which they are not so covetous as the whites; that we may plant for ourselves, and that in the meantime he will procure for us some corn and some meat; that fish is plenty in the waters of—-, and that the village to which he had laid open my proposals, have no objection to our becoming dwellers with them. I have not yet communicated these glad tidings to my wife, nor do I know how to do it; I tremble lest she should refuse to follow me; lest the sudden idea of this removal rushing on her mind, might be too powerful. I flatter myself I shall be able to accomplish it, and to prevail on her; I fear nothing but the effects of her strong attachment to her relations. I will willingly let you know how I purpose to remove my family to so great a distance, but it would become unintelligible to you, because you are not acquainted with the geographical situation of this part of the country. Suffice it for you to know, that with about twenty-three miles land carriage, I am enabled to perform the rest by water; and when once afloat, I care not whether it be two or three hundred miles. I propose to send all our provisions, furniture, and clothes to my wife's father, who approves of the scheme, and to reserve nothing but a few necessary articles of covering; trusting to the furs of the chase for our future apparel. Were we imprudently to encumber ourselves too much with baggage, we should never reach to the waters of—-, which is the most dangerous as well as the most difficult part of our journey; and yet but a trifle in point of distance. I intend to say to my negroes—In the name of God, be free, my honest lads, I thank you for your past services; go, from henceforth, and work for yourselves; look on me as your old friend, and fellow labourer; be sober, frugal, and industrious, and you need not fear earning a comfortable subsistence.—Lest my countrymen should think that I am gone to join the incendiaries of our frontiers, I intend to write a letter to Mr.—-, to inform him of our retreat, and of the reasons that have urged me to it. The man whom I sent to——village, is to accompany us also, and a very useful companion he will be on every account.
Yes, I will gladly accept that resource; it’s a sacred inspiration. Day and night, it occupies my thoughts. I’ve carefully considered the plan; I’ve thought about all its future outcomes and the new lifestyle we must adopt: living without salt, without spices, without linen, and with very little clothing; we need to learn how to hunt, adapt to new customs, and speak a new language; we must face the dangers of educating my children. These changes might seem more daunting from afar than they do once we get used to them: what does it matter to us whether we eat well-made pastries or crushed berries; well-roasted beef or smoked deer; cabbage or squash? Whether we wear neat homemade clothes or good beaver fabric; whether we sleep on feather beds or bear skins? The difference isn’t worth worrying about. The difficulty of the language, the fear of significant drunkenness with the Indians; ultimately, my only real concern is the chance that my younger children will be enchanted by that unique allure, which is so dangerous at their young age. How can it be that children adopted by these people when they’re young can never be persuaded to adopt European manners again? I’ve seen many worried parents last war who, after peace was restored, went to the Indian villages where they knew their children had been taken; only to their deep sorrow, they found their kids so fully Indianized that many didn’t recognize them, and those old enough to remember their parents outright refused to follow them, running to their adopted parents for safety from the love their real parents showered upon them! Incredible as it sounds, I’ve heard this reported countless times by credible people. In the village of———, where I plan to go, there were about fifteen years ago an Englishman and a Swede, whose story would move you if I had time to share it. They were adults when they were captured; they fortunately escaped the severe consequences faced by war captives, and were forced to marry the Native women who saved their lives by adopting them. Through habit, they became thoroughly accustomed to this wild way of living. While I was there, their friends sent them a large sum of money to buy their freedom. The Indians, their previous captors, offered them a choice and without any demands told them they had been as free as the others for a long time. They chose to stay, and their reasons would greatly surprise you: an absolute sense of freedom, an easy lifestyle, the absence of the worries and troubles that often plague us; the exceptional fertility of the land they farmed, as they didn’t rely solely on hunting; all these, plus many more reasons I’ve forgotten, led them to prefer a life that we view with such dread. It can’t be as bad as we commonly think; there must be something uniquely appealing in their social structure, far better than anything we can boast of; for thousands of Europeans live as Indians, and we don’t have a single example of any Native willingly becoming European! There must be something more in tune with our natural instincts than the artificial society we inhabit; or else why would children and even adults become so firmly attached to it in such a brief time? There must be something incredibly charming about their ways, something deeply ingrained and marked by nature herself. Take a young Native boy, give him the best education you can, shower him with gifts, even with wealth; yet he will secretly long for his native woods, which you might think he would have forgotten by now; and at the first chance he gets, you’ll see him willingly leave behind everything you’ve given him and joyfully return to the mats of his forefathers. Mr.——, a few years back, took in a young boy of nine, the grandson of a good old Indian who passed away in his home. He kindly raised him alongside his children and treated him with the same care and attention he had for his grandfather, a good man. He intended to set him up in a respectable trade, but in the spring, when the family went to the woods to make maple syrup, the boy suddenly disappeared; it wasn’t until seventeen months later that his benefactor found out he reached the village of Bald Eagle, where he still resides. No matter what we say about them, their supposed shortcomings, their lack of bread, etc., they are just as strong and well-built as Europeans. Without temples, priests, kings, or laws, in many ways, they excel us; the proof is that they live without worry, sleep soundly, take life as it comes, navigating all its hardships with unmatched patience, and die without fear of what they’ve done or what’s to come. What philosophy can give us these necessary qualities for happiness? They are undoubtedly much more connected to nature than we are; they are her true children, the inhabitants of the woods are her unpolluted offspring: those on the plains are her corrupted breed, far removed from her original laws and intentions. So it’s settled. I will either die trying or succeed; it’s better to perish all together in one doomed moment than to endure what we face daily. I don’t expect to find uninterrupted happiness in the village of———; that’s not our reality, wherever we may live; I’m not basing my future happiness on fanciful dreams. Put humanity wherever you want, and they will always have challenges to face; from nature, accidents, their own nature; from seasons, from the troubling array of misfortunes that constantly lead us to new illnesses, to poverty, etc. Who knows, I might find in this new situation an opportunity that could lead to unexpected blessings? Who can arrogantly predict all the good to come? Who can foresee all the hardships that lie ahead? But above all, I can’t help but think of the sacrifice I’m about to make, the loss I’m about to endure, the change I’m about to go through. Forgive my repetitions, my wild, trivial reflections; they come from the turmoil in my mind and the fullness of my heart; going over them seems to lighten the load and uplift my spirit; it’s also the last letter you will receive from me; I want to tell you everything, even though I hardly know how. Oh! In my moments of greatest sorrow, if I could somehow convey to you the whirlwind of thoughts racing through my mind, you would be surprised and doubt their very existence. Will we ever meet again? If we do, where will it be? On the wild shores of——. If it’s my fate to end my days there, I will make the most of them; and perhaps I can even make space for a few more families wanting to escape from a storm that will continue to roar on our shores for many years to come. Maybe I’ll get my house back if it’s not burned to the ground; but how will my improvements look? Likely half destroyed, bearing deep signs of neglect and the destruction of war. Nevertheless, for now, I give everything up for lost; I will say a long goodbye to what I leave behind. If I ever regain it, I will receive it as a gift, a reward for my perseverance and courage. But do not think I am stoic—far from it: I must confess that I feel the deepest regret in leaving behind a home I’ve built with my own hands to some extent. Yes, I might never return to those fields I’ve cleared, those trees I’ve planted, those meadows that once were a terrible wilderness, now transformed by my effort into rich pastures and lovely lawns. If it is esteemed in Europe to be attached to ancestral lands, how much more natural, how much stronger must that bond be for us, who, if I may express it this way, are the founders, the creators of our own farms! When I see my table filled with my thriving children, all bound together in the strongest love, it ignites in my fatherly heart a mix of emotions that only a father and husband in my circumstances can feel or articulate. Perhaps I’ll see my wife and children often troubled, involuntarily reminding themselves of the comfort and abundance they enjoyed under our family roof. Perhaps I’ll see them lacking the bread I now leave behind; faced with illness and poverty, made even harder by memories of past wealth and plenty. Perhaps I’ll be attacked by unforeseen circumstances that I can’t prevent or lessen. Can I picture such scenes without feeling the most indescribable emotions? My fate is sealed; but know that I did not come to this decision without enduring a painful mix of feelings—interest, a desire for comfort, disappointed hopes, and broken dreams—I shudder just thinking about it! Oh, how I wish I had the calmness of that noble philosophy; oh, that I could hold the noble lessons that Apollonius of Chalcis taught Emperor Antoninus! I could then better steer my little boat, which is about to be laden with everything I hold dear on this treacherous journey to a safe haven; and once there, I would be a better guide, a brighter example, a more admirable model for my fellow travelers throughout this new path they must navigate. I’ve noticed, however, the efforts made so far to prepare the major nations against our borders. Yet they have not, and will not take up arms against a people who have harmed them not. The emotions needed to push these people to war cannot be stirred; they feel no desire for revenge, the thirst which alone compels them to shed blood: they are far superior in their motivations to the Europeans, who for just a pittance will partake in the bloodshed of any people on earth. They know nothing of our disputes; they have no idea of such upheavals; a civil conflict in a village or tribe are occurrences unknown to their history: many know they have long been the pawns and victims of both sides; foolishly arming for our sake, sometimes against each other, sometimes against our white foes. They see us as born of the same land and, although they have no reason to love us, they seem to actively avoid getting involved in this conflict for various reasons. I’m speaking of those nations I know best; a few hundred of the worst sort mixed with whites, worse than they are, are currently hired by Great Britain to continue those terrible raids. In my youth, I traded with the——, under my uncle’s guidance, and always traded fairly; some of them still remember it to this day. Fortunately, their village is far from the dangerous proximity of the whites; last spring, I sent a man there, who knows the woods very well and speaks their language; he just returned after several weeks away, and brought me what I had hoped for, a string of thirty purple wampum beads, as a sign that their honest chief will give us half of his wigwam until we can build our own. He told me they have plenty of land, which they don’t covet like the whites do; that we can plant for ourselves, and in the meantime, he’ll get us some corn and meat; that fish is abundant in the waters of—-, and that the village he shared my proposals with has no objections to us living among them. I haven’t yet shared this good news with my wife, nor do I know how to; I’m afraid she might refuse to come with me; the sudden thought of this move might be too overwhelming for her. I hope I can manage it and convince her; my only worry is the strength of her attachment to her family. I would gladly let you know how I plan to relocate my family so far away, but it would be incomprehensible to you since you aren’t familiar with the geography of this region. Just know that with about twenty-three miles of land travel, I can manage the rest by water; and once we’re afloat, I don’t care whether it’s two or three hundred miles. I intend to send all our supplies, furniture, and clothes to my father-in-law, who supports the plan, and to keep only a few essential items; counting on the furs from our hunts for our future clothing. If we foolishly burden ourselves too much with luggage, we’ll never make it to the waters of—-, which is the most dangerous and challenging part of our trip; yet still only a small distance in total. I plan to tell my enslaved laborers—In the name of God, be free, my good lads! I appreciate your past help; go, and work for yourselves from now on; see me as your old friend and fellow worker; be diligent, careful, and hard-working, and you won’t have to worry about making a good living. —To prevent my fellow countrymen from thinking I’m off to join the arsons at our borders, I plan to write a letter to Mr.—- to inform him about our departure and the reasons motivating it. The man I sent to the——village will be joining us as well, and he will be a very helpful companion in every way.
You may therefore, by means of anticipation, behold me under the Wigwam; I am so well acquainted with the principal manners of these people, that I entertain not the least apprehension from them. I rely more securely on their strong hospitality, than on the witnessed compacts of many Europeans. As soon as possible after my arrival, I design to build myself a wigwam, after the same manner and size with the rest, in order to avoid being thought singular, or giving occasion for any railleries; though these people are seldom guilty of such European follies. I shall erect it hard by the lands which they propose to allot me, and will endeavour that my wife, my children, and myself may be adopted soon after our arrival. Thus becoming truly inhabitants of their village, we shall immediately occupy that rank within the pale of their society, which will afford us all the amends we can possibly expect for the loss we have met with by the convulsions of our own. According to their customs we shall likewise receive names from them, by which we shall always be known. My youngest children shall learn to swim, and to shoot with the bow, that they may acquire such talents as will necessarily raise them into some degree of esteem among the Indian lads of their own age; the rest of us must hunt with the hunters. I have been for several years an expert marksman; but I dread lest the imperceptible charm of Indian education, may seize my younger children, and give them such a propensity to that mode of life, as may preclude their returning to the manners and customs of their parents. I have but one remedy to prevent this great evil; and that is, to employ them in the labour of the fields, as much as I can; I am even resolved to make their daily subsistence depend altogether on it. As long as we keep ourselves busy in tilling the earth, there is no fear of any of us becoming wild; it is the chase and the food it procures, that have this strange effect. Excuse a simile—those hogs which range in the woods, and to whom grain is given once a week, preserve their former degree of tameness; but if, on the contrary, they are reduced to live on ground nuts, and on what they can get, they soon become wild and fierce. For my part, I can plough, sow, and hunt, as occasion may require; but my wife, deprived of wool and flax, will have no room for industry; what is she then to do? like the other squaws, she must cook for us the nasaump, the ninchicke, and such other preparations of corn as are customary among these people. She must learn to bake squashes and pumpkins under the ashes; to slice and smoke the meat of our own killing, in order to preserve it; she must cheerfully adopt the manners and customs of her neighbours, in their dress, deportment, conduct, and internal economy, in all respects. Surely if we can have fortitude enough to quit all we have, to remove so far, and to associate with people so different from us; these necessary compliances are but part of the scheme. The change of garments, when those they carry with them are worn out, will not be the least of my wife's and daughter's concerns: though I am in hopes that self-love will invent some sort of reparation. Perhaps you would not believe that there are in the woods looking- glasses, and paint of every colour; and that the inhabitants take as much pains to adorn their faces and their bodies, to fix their bracelets of silver, and plait their hair, as our forefathers the Picts used to do in the time of the Romans. Not that I would wish to see either my wife or daughter adopt those savage customs; we can live in great peace and harmony with them without descending to every article; the interruption of trade hath, I hope, suspended this mode of dress. My wife understands inoculation perfectly well, she inoculated all our children one after another, and has successfully performed the operation on several scores of people, who, scattered here and there through our woods, were too far removed from all medical assistance. If we can persuade but one family to submit to it, and it succeeds, we shall then be as happy as our situation will admit of; it will raise her into some degree of consideration, for whoever is useful in any society will always be respected. If we are so fortunate as to carry one family through a disorder, which is the plague among these people, I trust to the force of example, we shall then become truly necessary, valued, and beloved; we indeed owe every kind office to a society of men who so readily offer to assist us into their social partnership, and to extend to my family the shelter of their village, the strength of their adoption, and even the dignity of their names. God grant us a prosperous beginning, we may then hope to be of more service to them than even missionaries who have been sent to preach to them a Gospel they cannot understand.
You can imagine me under the wigwam; I know these people's main ways well enough that I don’t fear them at all. I trust their strong hospitality more than the agreements I've seen from many Europeans. As soon as I can after I arrive, I plan to build a wigwam similar in style and size to the others, so I don’t stand out or give anyone a reason to tease me, although these people rarely indulge in such European nonsense. I'll set it up close to the land they plan to give me, and I’ll make sure that my wife, kids, and I get adopted shortly after we arrive. By doing this, we’ll truly become members of their village and take up a place in their society that will help make up for what we lost from our own upheavals. According to their customs, we will also receive names from them that we’ll be known by. My youngest kids will learn to swim and shoot with a bow so they can gain some skills that will earn them respect among the Indian boys their age; the rest of us will have to hunt alongside the hunters. I’ve been a skilled marksman for several years, but I worry that the subtle charm of Indian education might influence my younger kids and make them prefer that lifestyle, possibly preventing them from returning to the ways of their parents. I have only one way to prevent this issue: I’ll keep them busy with fieldwork as much as I can; I’m even determined to make their daily food depend entirely on it. As long as we stay occupied with farming the land, I don’t fear any of us becoming wild; it's the hunting and the food it provides that has this odd effect. Excuse the analogy—those wild hogs that roam the woods, getting grain just once a week, stay somewhat tame; but if they have to live off whatever ground nuts and scraps they can find, they soon turn wild and aggressive. As for me, I can plow, plant, and hunt when needed; but my wife, without wool and flax, won’t have much to do—what is she supposed to do? Like the other women, she’ll need to cook us the nasaump, the ninchicke, and other corn dishes typical of these people. She’ll need to learn how to bake squash and pumpkins in the ashes, to slice and smoke meat from our kills to preserve it; she must gladly adopt the ways and customs of her new neighbors, from their clothing to their behavior, in all respects. If we can find the courage to leave everything we have behind, to move so far away, and to live among people so different from us, then these necessary adjustments are just part of the plan. The switch in clothing, when what we bring wears out, will matter to my wife and daughter; although I hope that self-interest will inspire some sort of replacement. You might not believe there are mirrors and paints of every color in the woods, and that the locals put considerable effort into decorating their faces and bodies, fixing silver bracelets and braiding their hair, just like our ancestors, the Picts, did during Roman times. Not that I want to see my wife or daughter adopt those primitive customs; we can live peacefully and harmoniously with them without going along with everything. I hope the disruption in trade has slowed this dressing style. My wife is fully skilled in inoculation; she has inoculated all our kids one by one and has successfully done the procedure on several dozens of people scattered in our woods who were too far from medical help. If we can convince just one family to go through with it, and it works, we’ll be as happy as we can be in our situation; it will also elevate her standing, because anyone who is helpful in any community will always be respected. If we’re fortunate enough to help one family through an illness that’s a plague among these people, I trust that our example will make us truly necessary, valued, and liked; we owe every kindness to a group of people who willingly offer to welcome us into their community, granting my family the protection of their village, the strength of their adoption, and even the honor of their names. God grant us a successful start; then we can hope to be more beneficial to them than even missionaries sent to preach a Gospel they can’t understand.
As to religion, our mode of worship will not suffer much by this removal from a cultivated country, into the bosom of the woods; for it cannot be much simpler than that which we have followed here these many years: and I will with as much care as I can, redouble my attention, and twice a week, retrace to them the great outlines of their duty to God and to man. I will read and expound to them some part of the decalogue, which is the method I have pursued ever since I married.
As for religion, our way of worship won't be greatly affected by moving from a developed area into the heart of the woods; it really can't get much simpler than the way we've practiced it here over the years. I will, as best as I can, pay even more attention and twice a week go over with them the main principles of their responsibilities to God and to others. I'll read and explain to them some parts of the Ten Commandments, which is what I've been doing since I got married.
Half a dozen of acres on the shores of—-, the soil of which I know well, will yield us a great abundance of all we want; I will make it a point to give the over-plus to such Indians as shall be most unfortunate in their huntings; I will persuade them, if I can, to till a little more land than they do, and not to trust so much to the produce of the chase. To encourage them still farther, I will give a quirn to every six families; I have built many for our poor back settlers, it being often the want of mills which prevents them from raising grain. As I am a carpenter, I can build my own plough, and can be of great service to many of them; my example alone, may rouse the industry of some, and serve to direct others in their labours. The difficulties of the language will soon be removed; in my evening conversations, I will endeavour to make them regulate the trade of their village in such a manner as that those pests of the continent, those Indian traders, may not come within a certain distance; and there they shall be obliged to transact their business before the old people. I am in hopes that the constant respect which is paid to the elders, and shame, may prevent the young hunters from infringing this regulation. The son of——will soon be made acquainted with our schemes, and I trust that the power of love, and the strong attachment he professes for my daughter, may bring him along with us: he will make an excellent hunter; young and vigorous, he will equal in dexterity the stoutest man in the village. Had it not been for this fortunate circumstance, there would have been the greatest danger; for however I respect the simple, the inoffensive society of these people in their villages, the strongest prejudices would make me abhor any alliance with them in blood: disagreeable no doubt, to nature's intentions which have strongly divided us by so many indelible characters. In the days of our sickness, we shall have recourse to their medical knowledge, which is well calculated for the simple diseases to which they are subject. Thus shall we metamorphose ourselves, from neat, decent, opulent planters, surrounded with every conveniency which our external labour and internal industry could give, into a still simpler people divested of everything beside hope, food, and the raiment of the woods: abandoning the large framed house, to dwell under the wigwam; and the featherbed, to lie on the mat, or bear's skin. There shall we sleep undisturbed by fruitful dreams and apprehensions; rest and peace of mind will make us the most ample amends for what we shall leave behind. These blessings cannot be purchased too dear; too long have we been deprived of them. I would cheerfully go even to the Mississippi, to find that repose to which we have been so long strangers. My heart sometimes seems tired with beating, it wants rest like my eye-lids, which feel oppressed with so many watchings.
Half a dozen acres on the shores of—-, which I know well, will provide us with plenty of everything we need; I plan to give any extra to the Indians who are most unfortunate in their hunts. I will try to convince them to cultivate a bit more land and not rely so heavily on hunting. To encourage them further, I will give a quern to every six families; I've already built many for our struggling back settlers, as the lack of mills often stops them from growing grain. As a carpenter, I can build my own plow and offer a lot of help to many of them; my example alone may motivate some and guide others in their work. The language barrier will soon be overcome; in my evening talks, I will try to help them manage their village trade in a way that keeps those troublesome Indian traders a certain distance away; they will have to do their business in front of the elders. I hope that the constant respect given to the elders, and the shame of disobeying, will stop the young hunters from breaking this rule. The son of——will soon learn about our plans, and I trust that the power of love and his strong feelings for my daughter will bring him along with us; he will be an excellent hunter—young and strong, he will match the skill of the toughest man in the village. If it weren't for this lucky situation, it could have been very dangerous; although I respect the innocent, peaceful lives of these people, the deep-seated prejudices would make me reject any blood alliance with them: it's clearly contrary to nature's design, which has divided us by so many lasting differences. In our times of illness, we will turn to their medical knowledge, which is well-suited for the simple diseases they face. So we will change from tidy, decent, wealthy planters, surrounded by every convenience our hard work can provide, into a simpler people stripped of everything except hope, food, and the clothes made from the woods: leaving behind large houses to live in wigwams; trading featherbeds for mats or bear skins. There we will sleep peacefully, undisturbed by fruitful dreams or worries; rest and peace of mind will more than make up for what we leave behind. These blessings can't be bought at too high a price; we have been deprived of them for too long. I would gladly go all the way to the Mississippi to find that peace we've been strangers to for so long. My heart sometimes feels tired of beating; it wants rest like my eyelids, which feel heavy from so much wakefulness.
These are the component parts of my scheme, the success of each of which appears feasible; from whence I flatter myself with the probable success of the whole. Still the danger of Indian education returns to my mind, and alarms me much; then again I contrast it with the education of the times; both appear to be equally pregnant with evils. Reason points out the necessity of choosing the least dangerous, which I must consider as the only good within my reach; I persuade myself that industry and labour will be a sovereign preservative against the dangers of the former; but I consider, at the same time, that the share of labour and industry which is intended to procure but a simple subsistence, with hardly any superfluity, cannot have the same restrictive effects on our minds as when we tilled the earth on a more extensive scale. The surplus could be then realised into solid wealth, and at the same time that this realisation rewarded our past labours, it engrossed and fixed the attention of the labourer, and cherished in his mind the hope of future riches. In order to supply this great deficiency of industrious motives, and to hold out to them a real object to prevent the fatal consequences of this sort of apathy; I will keep an exact account of all that shall be gathered, and give each of them a regular credit for the amount of it to be paid them in real property at the return of peace. Thus, though seemingly toiling for bare subsistence on a foreign land, they shall entertain the pleasing prospect of seeing the sum of their labours one day realised either in legacies or gifts, equal if not superior to it. The yearly expense of the clothes which they would have received at home, and of which they will then be deprived, shall likewise be added to their credit; thus I flatter myself that they will more cheerfully wear the blanket, the matchcoat, and the Moccasins. Whatever success they may meet with in hunting or fishing, shall only be considered as recreation and pastime; I shall thereby prevent them from estimating their skill in the chase as an important and necessary accomplishment. I mean to say to them: "You shall hunt and fish merely to show your new companions that you are not inferior to them in point of sagacity and dexterity." Were I to send them to such schools as the interior parts of our settlements afford at present, what can they learn there? How could I support them there? What must become of me; am I to proceed on my voyage, and leave them? That I never could submit to. Instead of the perpetual discordant noise of disputes so common among us, instead of those scolding scenes, frequent in every house, they will observe nothing but silence at home and abroad: a singular appearance of peace and concord are the first characteristics which strike you in the villages of these people. Nothing can be more pleasing, nothing surprises an European so much as the silence and harmony which prevails among them, and in each family; except when disturbed by that accursed spirit given them by the wood rangers in exchange for their furs. If my children learn nothing of geometrical rules, the use of the compass, or of the Latin tongue, they will learn and practise sobriety, for rum can no longer be sent to these people; they will learn that modesty and diffidence for which the young Indians are so remarkable; they will consider labour as the most essential qualification; hunting as the second. They will prepare themselves in the prosecution of our small rural schemes, carried on for the benefit of our little community, to extend them further when each shall receive his inheritance. Their tender minds will cease to be agitated by perpetual alarms; to be made cowards by continual terrors: if they acquire in the village of—-, such an awkwardness of deportment and appearance as would render them ridiculous in our gay capitals, they will imbibe, I hope, a confirmed taste for that simplicity, which so well becomes the cultivators of the land. If I cannot teach them any of those professions which sometimes embellish and support our society, I will show them how to hew wood, how to construct their own ploughs; and with a few tools how to supply themselves with every necessary implement, both in the house and in the field. If they are hereafter obliged to confess, that they belong to no one particular church, I shall have the consolation of teaching them that great, that primary worship which is the foundation of all others. If they do not fear God according to the tenets of any one seminary, they shall learn to worship him upon the broad scale of nature. The Supreme Being does not reside in peculiar churches or communities; he is equally the great Manitou of the woods and of the plains; and even in the gloom, the obscurity of those very woods, his justice may be as well understood and felt as in the most sumptuous temples. Each worship with us, hath, you know, its peculiar political tendency; there it has none but to inspire gratitude and truth: their tender minds shall receive no other idea of the Supreme Being, than that of the father of all men, who requires nothing more of us than what tends to make each other happy. We shall say with them, Soungwaneha, esa caurounkyawga, nughwonshauza neattewek, nesalanga.—Our father, be thy will done in earth as it is in great heaven.
These are the parts of my plan, each of which seems doable, leading me to believe that the whole thing might succeed. However, the risks of educating the Indigenous people keep coming to mind and really worry me; then I compare it to the education of today's time, and both seem full of problems. Logic tells me I need to choose the safer option, which I see as the only good I can manage. I convince myself that hard work will protect us from the dangers of the first option; but I also realize that working just to get by, with barely any extra, won’t provide the same mental limitations as when we cultivated land on a larger scale. Back then, any excess we produced could be turned into real wealth, and while that rewarded our past efforts, it also focused the worker’s attention and filled their minds with hope for future riches. To address this big lack of motivation and to give them a real goal to avoid the negative effects of apathy, I will keep a detailed record of everything gathered, crediting each of them for the amount that could be paid to them in actual property once peace returns. So, even if they seem to be struggling for mere survival in a foreign land, they will have the exciting prospect of one day realizing the sum of their labor as gifts or inheritances that may rival or exceed it. The annual cost of clothes they'd have received at home, which they will now miss, will also be added to their credit; thus, I believe they will wear the blanket, matchcoat, and moccasins more happily. Whatever success they have in hunting or fishing will just be seen as fun; I want to keep them from thinking that their hunting skills are essential. I intend to tell them: “You’ll hunt and fish just to show your new friends that you’re just as clever and skilled as they are.” If I were to send them to the schools that our settlements currently offer, what would they learn there? How could I support them? What would happen to me? Am I supposed to continue my journey and leave them? I could never accept that. Instead of the constant noise of arguments common among us, instead of the yelling that happens in every house, they will find only silence at home and outside: a remarkable sense of peace and harmony is the first thing that strikes you in the villages of these people. Nothing is more pleasing, nothing surprises a European as much as the silence and harmony that exists among them and in each family—except when interrupted by the cursed spirit introduced to them by the wood rangers in exchange for their furs. Even if my children don’t learn about geometry, how to use a compass, or Latin, they will learn and practice sobriety, since rum can no longer be sent to these people; they will learn about modesty and humility, which the young Indigenous people are so noted for; and they will recognize hard work as the most important trait, with hunting being second. They will prepare to take part in small agricultural projects we undertake for the benefit of our community, planning to expand them as each receives their inheritance. Their sensitive minds will no longer be troubled by constant fears; they won’t be made into cowards by ongoing terror: if they pick up any awkwardness in how they act or appear that would make them look foolish in our fancy cities, I hope they will also develop a strong appreciation for the simplicity that suits the farmers well. If I can’t teach them any of those trades that enhance and support our society, I will show them how to chop wood, how to make their own plows; and with just a few tools, how to create all the essential items they need for home and field. If they later have to admit that they don’t belong to any specific church, I shall have the comfort of teaching them that fundamental worship that underpins all others. If they don’t fear God according to any particular denomination, they will learn to worship him in a way that embraces nature. The Supreme Being isn’t confined to specific churches or groups; he is the great Manitou of both the woods and the plains; and even in the shadows and gloom of those very woods, his justice can be as well understood and felt as in the grandest temples. Each form of worship among us, as you know, has its own political bias; here, it only seeks to inspire gratitude and truth: their gentle minds will have no other concept of the Supreme Being than that of the father of all people, who asks nothing from us but what helps to make each other happy. We will say with them, Soungwaneha, esa caurounkyawga, nughwonshauza neattewek, nesalanga.—Our father, may your will be done on earth as it is in heaven.
Perhaps my imagination gilds too strongly this distant prospect; yet it appears founded on so few, and simple principles, that there is not the same probability of adverse incidents as in more complex schemes. These vague rambling contemplations which I here faithfully retrace, carry me sometimes to a great distance; I am lost in the anticipation of the various circumstances attending this proposed metamorphosis! Many unforeseen accidents may doubtless arise. Alas! it is easier for me in all the glow of paternal anxiety, reclined on my bed, to form the theory of my future conduct, than to reduce my schemes into practice. But when once secluded from the great society to which we now belong, we shall unite closer together; and there will be less room for jealousies or contentions. As I intend my children neither for the law nor the church, but for the cultivation of the land, I wish them no literary accomplishments; I pray heaven that they may be one day nothing more than expert scholars in husbandry: this is the science which made our continent to flourish more rapidly than any other. Were they to grow up where I am now situated, even admitting that we were in safety; two of them are verging toward that period in their lives, when they must necessarily take up the musket, and learn, in that new school, all the vices which are so common in armies. Great God! close my eyes for ever, rather than I should live to see this calamity! May they rather become inhabitants of the woods.
Maybe my imagination is exaggerating this distant outlook; however, it seems based on such few and simple principles that the chance of negative events happening isn’t as likely as with more complicated plans. These vague, wandering thoughts that I’m laying out here sometimes take me far away; I get lost in imagining the different situations surrounding this proposed change! Many unexpected issues will undoubtedly come up. Oh! It’s easier for me, filled with worried fatherly thoughts while lying on my bed, to come up with a theory for my future actions than to put my plans into practice. But once we’re away from the large society we currently belong to, we’ll be closer together; there will be less chance for jealousy or conflict. Since I’m not preparing my children for law or the church, but for farming, I don’t wish for them to have any literary skills; I pray to heaven that they may one day become nothing more than skilled farmers: this is the field that has allowed our continent to thrive faster than any other. If they were to grow up where I currently am, even if we were safe, two of them are reaching the age when they must pick up a gun and learn, in that harsh environment, all the bad habits that are so common in armies. Good God! I’d rather close my eyes forever than live to see this tragedy! I’d prefer they become forest dwellers.
Thus then in the village of—-, in the bosom of that peace it has enjoyed ever since I have known it, connected with mild hospitable people, strangers to OUR political disputes, and having none among themselves; on the shores of a fine river, surrounded with woods, abounding with game; our little society united in perfect harmony with the new adoptive one, in which we shall be incorporated, shall rest I hope from all fatigues, from all apprehensions, from our perfect terrors, and from our long watchings. Not a word of politics shall cloud our simple conversation; tired either with the chase or the labour of the field, we shall sleep on our mats without any distressing want, having learnt to retrench every superfluous one: we shall have but two prayers to make to the Supreme Being, that he may shed his fertilising dew on our little crops, and that he will be pleased to restore peace to our unhappy country. These shall be the only subject of our nightly prayers, and of our daily ejaculations: and if the labour, the industry, the frugality, the union of men, can be an agreeable offering to him, we shall not fail to receive his paternal blessings. There I shall contemplate nature in her most wild and ample extent; I shall carefully study a species of society, of which I have at present but very imperfect ideas; I will endeavour to occupy with propriety that place which will enable me to enjoy the few and sufficient benefits it confers. The solitary and unconnected mode of life I have lived in my youth must fit me for this trial, I am not the first who has attempted it; Europeans did not, it is true, carry to the wilderness numerous families; they went there as mere speculators; I, as a man seeking a refuge from the desolation of war. They went there to study the manner of the aborigines; I to conform to them, whatever they are; some went as visitors, as travellers; I as a sojourner, as a fellow hunter and labourer, go determined industriously to work up among them such a system of happiness as may be adequate to my future situation, and may be a sufficient compensation for all my fatigues and for the misfortunes I have borne: I have always found it at home, I may hope likewise to find it under the humble roof of my wigwam.
Thus, in the village of—-, surrounded by the peace it has enjoyed since I can remember, connected to friendly, welcoming people who are unaware of OUR political arguments and have none among themselves; on the banks of a beautiful river, surrounded by woods teeming with wildlife; our small community will hopefully find rest from all our exhaustion, all our fears, our perfect terrors, and our many sleepless nights. Not a word of politics will spoil our simple conversations; whether tired from hunting or working in the fields, we’ll sleep on our mats without distressing wants, having learned to cut out all the unnecessary ones. We’ll have only two prayers to make to the Supreme Being: that He may bless our little crops with nourishing rain, and that He may be pleased to restore peace to our troubled country. These will be the only topics of our evening prayers and our daily thoughts. And if hard work, diligence, frugality, and the unity of people can be a pleasing offering to Him, we will certainly receive His fatherly blessings. There I will appreciate nature in all her wild and vast beauty; I will carefully observe a kind of society that I currently have only a limited understanding of; I will strive to take my place in a way that allows me to enjoy the few but sufficient benefits it provides. The solitary and disconnected lifestyle I've led in my youth should prepare me for this challenge; I am not the first to attempt it. Europeans, it’s true, didn’t bring many families into the wilderness; they went to speculate; I’m going as a man looking for refuge from the devastation of war. They went to study the ways of the indigenous people; I am going to adapt to them, no matter who they are; some came as visitors, as travelers; I come as a sojourner, as a fellow hunter and laborer, ready to work hard to build a system of happiness that will suit my future life and compensate me for all my struggles and misfortunes: I have always found it at home, and I hope to find it under the humble roof of my wigwam.
O Supreme Being! if among the immense variety of planets, inhabited by thy creative power, thy paternal and omnipotent care deigns to extend to all the individuals they contain; if it be not beneath thy infinite dignity to cast thy eye on us wretched mortals; if my future felicity is not contrary to the necessary effects of those secret causes which thou hast appointed, receive the supplications of a man, to whom in thy kindness thou hast given a wife and an offspring: View us all with benignity, sanctify this strong conflict of regrets, wishes, and other natural passions; guide our steps through these unknown paths, and bless our future mode of life. If it is good and well meant, it must proceed from thee; thou knowest, O Lord, our enterprise contains neither fraud, nor malice, nor revenge. Bestow on me that energy of conduct now become so necessary, that it may be in my power to carry the young family thou hast given me through this great trial with safety and in thy peace. Inspire me with such intentions and such rules of conduct as may be most acceptable to thee. Preserve, O God, preserve the companion of my bosom, the best gift thou hast given me: endue her with courage and strength sufficient to accomplish this perilous journey. Bless the children of our love, those portions of our hearts; I implore thy divine assistance, speak to their tender minds, and inspire them with the love of that virtue which alone can serve as the basis of their conduct in this world, and of their happiness with thee. Restore peace and concord to our poor afflicted country; assuage the fierce storm which has so long ravaged it. Permit, I beseech thee, O Father of nature, that our ancient virtues, and our industry, may not be totally lost: and that as a reward for the great toils we have made on this new land, we may be restored to our ancient tranquillity, and enabled to fill it with successive generations, that will constantly thank thee for the ample subsistence thou hast given them.
O Supreme Being! If among the countless planets, inhabited by your creative power, your parental and all-powerful care extends to every individual they hold; if it’s not beneath your infinite dignity to look upon us wretched mortals; if my future happiness doesn’t contradict the necessary effects of those hidden causes you’ve set in motion, please accept the prayers of a man to whom you have kindly given a wife and children: Look upon us with kindness, sanctify this intense struggle of regrets, wishes, and other natural feelings; guide us through these unknown paths, and bless our future way of life. If it is good and well-intentioned, it must come from you; you know, O Lord, that our endeavor contains neither deceit, nor malice, nor revenge. Grant me the energy and resolve that is now so essential, so that I can lead the young family you’ve given me through this great trial safely and in your peace. Inspire me with intentions and guidelines that may be most pleasing to you. Protect, O God, protect the partner of my heart, the greatest gift you've given me: grant her enough courage and strength to face this dangerous journey. Bless the children of our love, those pieces of our hearts; I ask for your divine help, speak to their innocent minds, and fill them with the love of that virtue which alone can serve as the foundation of their actions in this world, and of their happiness with you. Restore peace and harmony to our troubled country; calm the fierce storm that has ravaged it for so long. Please allow, O Father of nature, that our long-standing virtues and our hard work are not completely lost: and that as a reward for the great efforts we’ve made in this new land, we may regain our former tranquility, and be able to populate it with successive generations, who will constantly thank you for the abundant sustenance you have given them.
The unreserved manner in which I have written must give you a convincing proof of that friendship and esteem, of which I am sure you never yet doubted. As members of the same society, as mutually bound by the ties of affection and old acquaintance, you certainly cannot avoid feeling for my distresses; you cannot avoid mourning with me over that load of physical and moral evil with which we are all oppressed. My own share of it I often overlook when I minutely contemplate all that hath befallen our native country.
The candid way I've written must clearly show you the friendship and respect I know you've always believed in. As part of the same community, connected by the bonds of affection and long-standing friendship, you can't help but feel for my struggles; you can't help but share my sorrow over the heavy burden of physical and moral challenges we all face. I often overlook my own issues when I closely consider everything that has happened to our homeland.
The End
The Finish
Download ePUB
If you like this ebook, consider a donation!