This is a modern-English version of Wandering in Northern China, originally written by unknown author(s).
It has been thoroughly updated, including changes to sentence structure, words, spelling,
and grammar—to ensure clarity for contemporary readers, while preserving the original spirit and nuance. If
you click on a paragraph, you will see the original text that we modified, and you can toggle between the two versions.
Scroll to the bottom of this page and you will find a free ePUB download link for this book.
Transcriber’s Note:
Transcription Note:
The cover image was created by the transcriber and is placed in the public domain.
The cover image was made by the transcriber and is in the public domain.

A constant stream of pilgrims, largely blue-clad coolies on foot, passed up and down the sacred stairway
A steady flow of pilgrims, mostly blue-clad laborers on foot, walked up and down the sacred stairway.
WANDERING IN NORTHERN CHINA

FOREWORD
There is no particular plan to this book. I found my interest turning toward the Far East, and as I am not one of those fortunate persons who can scamper through a country in a few weeks and know all about it, I set out on a leisurely jaunt to wherever new clues to interest led me. It merely happened that this will-o’-the-wisp drew me on through everything that was once China, north of about the thirty-fourth parallel of latitude. The man who spends a year or two in China and then attacks the problem of telling all he saw, heard, felt, or smelled there is like the small boy who was ordered by the teacher to write on two neat pages all about his visit to the museum. It simply can’t be done. Hence I have merely set down in the following pages, in the same leisurely wandering way as I have traveled, the things that most interested me, often things that others seem to have missed, or considered unimportant, in the hope that some of them may also interest others. Impressions are unlike statistics, however, in that they cannot be corrected to a fraction, and I decline to be held responsible for the exact truth of every presumption I have recorded. If I have fallen into the common error of generalizing, I hereby apologize, for I know well that details in local customs differ even between neighboring villages in China. What I say can at most be true of the north, for as yet I know nothing of southern China. On the other hand, there may be much repetition of customs and the like, but that goes to show how unchanging is life among the masses in China even as a republic.
There’s no specific plan for this book. I became interested in the Far East, and since I’m not one of those lucky people who can race through a country in a few weeks and learn all about it, I decided to take a leisurely trip wherever my curiosity led me. It just so happened that this fleeting interest took me through what was once China, north of about the thirty-fourth parallel of latitude. Someone who spends a year or two in China and then tries to explain everything they saw, heard, felt, or smelled there is like a young boy who was told by his teacher to write about his visit to the museum in two neat pages. It simply can’t be done. So, I’ve recorded in the following pages, in the same relaxed and meandering way that I traveled, the things that intrigued me the most, often things that others seem to have overlooked or deemed unimportant, hoping that some of these might also interest others. Impressions can’t be fixed like statistics, and I won’t take responsibility for the precise truth of every assumption I’ve made. If I’ve fallen into the common trap of generalizing, I apologize, as I know well that local customs can vary even between neighboring villages in China. What I share can at most be accurate for the north, as I currently know nothing about southern China. On the other hand, while there may be a lot of overlap in customs and the like, that just shows how unchanging life is among the masses in China, even as a republic.
Lafcadio Hearn said that the longer he remained in the East the less he knew of what was going on in the Oriental mind. An “old China hand” has put the same thing in more popular language: “You can easily tell how long a man has been in China by how much he doesn’t know about it. If he knows almost everything, he has just recently arrived; if he is in doubt, he has been here a few years; if he admits that he really knows nothing whatever about the Chinese people or their probable future, you may take it for granted that he has been out a very long time.”
Lafcadio Hearn said that the longer he stayed in the East, the less he understood what was happening in the Oriental mind. An "old China hand" expressed the same idea in simpler terms: "You can easily tell how long someone has been in China by how much they don't know about it. If they know almost everything, they just got here; if they're unsure, they've been here a few years; and if they admit that they really know nothing at all about the Chinese people or their likely future, you can bet they've been around for a long time."
But as I have said before, the “old-timer” will seldom sit down to tell even what he has seen, and in many cases he has long since lost his way through the woods because of the trees. Or he may have other and viiimore important things to do. Hence it is up to those of us who have nothing else on hand to pick up and preserve such crumbs of information as we can; for surely to know as much of the truth about our foreign neighbors as possible is important, above all in this new age. In our own land there are many very false ideas about China; false ideas that in some cases are due to deliberate Chinese propaganda abroad. While I was out in the far interior I received a clipping outlining the remarks of a Chinese lecturing through our Middle West, and his résumé left the impression that bound feet and opium had all but completely disappeared from China, and that in the matter of schools and the like the “republic” is making enormous strides. No sooner did the Lincheng affair attract the world’s attention than American papers began to run yarns, visibly inspired, about the marvelous advances which the Chinese have recently accomplished. Such men as Alfred Sze are often mistaken in the United States as samples of China. Unfortunately they are nothing of the kind; in fact, they are too often hopelessly out of touch with their native land. There has been progress in China, but nothing like the amount of it which we have been coaxed or lulled into believing, and some of it is of a kind that raises serious doubts as to its direction. For all the telephones, airplanes, and foreign clothes in the coast cities, the great mass of the Chinese have been affected barely at all by this urge toward modernity and Westernism—if that is synonymous with progress. As some one has just put it, “the Chinese still wear the pigtail on their minds, though they have largely cut it off their heads.” How great must be the misinformation at home which causes our late President to say that all China really needs is more loans, thereby making himself, and by extension his nation, the laughing-stock of any one with the rudiments of intelligence who has spent an hour studying the situation on the spot. England is a little better informed on the subject than we, because she is less idealistic, more likely to look facts in the face instead of trying to make facts fit preconceived notions of essential human perfection. China may need more credits, but any fool knows that you should stop the hole in the bottom of a tub before you pour more water into it. At times, too, it is laughable to think of us children among nations worrying about this one, thousands of years old, which has so often “come back,” and may still be ambling her own way long after we have again disappeared from the face of the earth.
But as I mentioned before, the "old-timer" rarely sits down to share what he's experienced, and in many cases, he has long since lost his way through the woods because of the trees. Or he might have other, more important things to do. So it's up to those of us who have nothing else going on to gather and preserve whatever bits of information we can; because it’s definitely important to know as much of the truth about our foreign neighbors as possible, especially in this new age. In our own country, there are many misconceptions about China; misunderstandings that in some cases result from deliberate Chinese propaganda abroad. While I was out in the remote areas, I received a news clipping summarizing the remarks of a Chinese speaker touring our Midwest, and his summary gave the impression that bound feet and opium had nearly vanished from China and that regarding schools and similar matters, the “republic” is making huge strides. No sooner did the Lincheng incident grab the world's attention than American newspapers began running stories, clearly inspired, about the amazing progress the Chinese have recently made. People like Alfred Sze are often mistaken in the United States as representative of China. Unfortunately, they are not; in fact, they are often hopelessly out of touch with their homeland. There has been progress in China, but nothing like what we've been persuaded or lulled into believing, and some of it raises serious doubts about its direction. For all the telephones, airplanes, and foreign clothes in the coastal cities, the vast majority of Chinese people have been barely affected by this push toward modernity and Westernization—if that is what we consider progress. As someone recently put it, "the Chinese still wear the pigtail in their minds, even though they've mostly cut it off their heads." How substantial must the misinformation at home be that leads our former President to claim that all China really needs is more loans, making himself, and by extension his nation, the laughingstock of anyone with a basic understanding who has spent just an hour studying the situation on the ground? England is a bit better informed on the subject than we are because they are less idealistic and more likely to confront facts rather than trying to bend them to fit preconceived notions of essential human perfection. China may need more credit, but any fool knows that you need to stop the leak in the bottom of a tub before you pour more water into it. At times, it's almost laughable to think of us, the children among nations, worrying about this one that's thousands of years old, which has so often "come back," and may still be meandering its own way long after we’ve disappeared from the face of the earth.
Though it is impossible to leave out the omnipresent entirely, I have said comparatively little about politics. My own interest in what ixwe lump together under that word reaches only so far as it affects the every-day life of the people, of the mudsill of society, toward which, no doubt by some queer quirk in my make-up, I find my attention habitually focusing. I have tried, therefore, to show in some detail their lives, slowly changing perhaps yet little changed, and to let others conclude whether “politics” has done all that it should for them. Besides, the Far East swarms with writers on politics, men who have been out here for years or decades and have given their attention almost entirely to that popular subject; and even these disagree like doctors. Some of us, I know, are frankly tired of politics, at least for a space, important as they are; moreover, political changes are so rapid, especially in the “never changing” East, that it is impossible to keep abreast of the times in anything less than a daily newspaper.
Though it’s impossible to completely ignore the ever-present topic, I've talked relatively little about politics. My personal interest in what we call politics only goes as far as it impacts the everyday lives of people, especially those at the bottom of society, to whom, for some strange reason in my makeup, I find myself consistently drawn. I've tried, therefore, to detail their lives, which may be slowly changing but are still largely the same, and to allow others to decide whether “politics” has done enough for them. Besides, the Far East is full of writers focused on politics, men who have been here for years or even decades, dedicating their attention almost exclusively to that popular topic; and even they disagree like doctors. I know some of us are honestly tired of politics, at least for a while, important as they are; furthermore, political changes are so fast, especially in the “never changing” East, that it’s impossible to keep up with anything less than a daily newspaper.
At home there are numbers of young men, five or ten years out of college, who can tell you just what is the matter with the world, and exactly how to remedy it. I am more or less ready to agree with them that the world is going to the dogs. What of it? You have only to step outdoors on any clear night to see that there are hundreds of other worlds, which may be arranging their lives in a more intelligent manner. The most striking thing about these young political and sociological geniuses sitting in their suburban gardens or their city flats is that while they can toss off a recipe guaranteed to cure our own sick world overnight, if only some one can get it down its throat, they seldom seem to have influence enough in their own cozy little corner of it to drive out one grafting ward-heeler. In other words, if you must know what is to be the future of China, I regret that I have not been vouchsafed the gift of prophecy and cannot tell you.
At home, there are a number of young men, five or ten years out of college, who can explain exactly what’s wrong with the world and how to fix it. I’m more or less inclined to agree with them that things are going downhill. So what? You just need to step outside on any clear night to see that there are hundreds of other worlds, which might be organizing their lives in a smarter way. The most notable thing about these young political and sociological whizzes sitting in their suburban backyards or city apartments is that, while they can easily come up with a plan that’s guaranteed to heal our troubled world overnight—if only someone could make it happen—they rarely seem to have enough influence in their own little bubble to oust even one corrupt politician. In other words, if you’re curious about what the future holds for China, I’m afraid I don’t have the gift of foresight and can’t tell you.
In the minor matter of Chinese words and names, I have deliberately not tried to follow the usual Romanization, but rather to cause the reader to pronounce them as nearly like what they are on the spot as is possible with our mere twenty-six letters. Of course I could not follow this rule entirely or I must have called the capital of China “Bay-jing,” have spoken of the evacuation of “Shahn-doong,” and so on; so that in the case of names already more or less familiar to the West I have used the most modern and most widely accepted forms, as they have survived on the ground. At that I cannot imagine what ailed the men who Romanized the Chinese language, but that is another story.
In the small issue of Chinese words and names, I purposely haven't tried to stick to the usual Romanization. Instead, I aim for the reader to pronounce them as closely as possible to how they sound, using our limited twenty-six letters. Of course, I couldn't stick to this completely; otherwise, I would have had to call the capital of China “Bay-jing” and mention the evacuation of “Shahn-doong,” and so on. So, for names that are already somewhat familiar in the West, I've used the most modern and widely accepted versions as they've been used on the ground. That said, I can't understand what was going through the minds of the people who Romanized the Chinese language, but that's a different topic.
CONTENTS
CHAPTER | PAGE | |
---|---|---|
I | In the Country We Call Korea | 3 |
II | Korean Scenes and Customs | 23 |
III | Japanese and Missionaries in Korea | 36 |
IV | Off the Beaten Path in Korea | 53 |
V | Up and Down Manchuria | 71 |
VI | Through Sinicized China | 82 |
VII | Zooming across the Gobi | 108 |
VIII | In "Red" Mongolia | 124 |
IX | Holy Urga | 135 |
X | Everyone Is Their Own Diplomat | 160 |
XI | At Home Behind the Tartar Wall | 174 |
XII | Jogging around Beijing | 195 |
XIII | A Trip to Jehol | 230 |
XIV | A Trip to Peaceful Shansi | 252 |
XV | Strolls in the Province of Confucius | 265 |
XVI | Traveling in Shantung | 288 |
XVII | East to Qingdao | 308 |
XVIII | In Bandit-Infested Honan | 330 |
XIX | Westward through Loess Canyons | 349 |
XX | On to Xianfu | 366 |
XXI | Onward through Shaanxi | 387 |
XXII | China's Northwest | 405 |
XXIII | Where the Fish Wiggled His Tail | 423 |
XXIV | In Muslim China | 447 |
XXV | Following the Yellow River Homeward | 468 |
XXVI | Closing the Loop | 485 |
ILLUSTRATIONS
A constant stream of pilgrims, largely blue-clad coolies on foot, passed up and down the sacred stairway | Frontispiece |
FACING PAGE | |
---|---|
Map of the author’s route | 12 |
Our first view of Seoul, in which the former Temple of Heaven is now a smoking-room in a Japanese hotel garden | 16 |
The interior of a Korean house | 16 |
Close-up of a Korean “jicky-coon,” or street porter | 17 |
At the first suggestion of rain the Korean pulls out a little oiled-paper umbrella that fits over his precious horsehair hat | 17 |
Some of the figures, in the gaudiest of colors, surrounding the Golden Buddha in a Korean temple | 32 |
The famous “White Buddha,” carved, and painted in white, on a great boulder in the outskirts of Seoul | 32 |
One day, descending the hills toward Seoul, we heard a great jangling hubbub, and found two sorceresses in full swing in a native house, where people come to have their children “cured” | 33 |
The yang-ban, or loafing upper class of Korea, go in for archery, which is about fitted to their temperament, speed, and initiative | 33 |
The Korean method of ironing, the rhythmic rat-a-tat of which may be heard day and night almost anywhere in the peninsula | 40 |
Winding thread before one of the many little machine-knit stocking factories in Ping Yang | 40 |
The graves of Korea cover hundreds of her hillsides with their green mounds, usually unmarked, but carefully tended by the superstitious descendants | 41 |
A chicken peddler in Seoul | 48 |
A full load | 48 |
The plowman homeward wends his weary way—in Korean fashion, always carrying the plow and driving his unburdened ox or bull before him. One of the most common sights of Korea | 49 |
The biblical “watch-tower in a cucumber patch” is in evidence all over Korea in the summer, when crops begin to ripen. Whole families often sleep in them during this season, when they spring up all over the country, and often afford the only cool breeze | 49 |
A village blacksmith of Korea. Note the bellows-pumper in his high hat at the rear | 64 |
The interior of a native Korean school of the old type,—dark, dirty, swarming with flies, and loud with a constant chorus | 64 |
In Kongo-san, the “Diamond Mountains” of eastern Korea | 65 |
The monastery kitchen of Yu-jom-sa, typical of Korean cooking | 65 |
xivOne of the monks of Yu-jom-sa | 68 |
This great cliff-carved Buddha, fifty feet high and thirty broad, was done by Chinese artists centuries ago. Note my carrier, a full-sized man, squatting at the lower left-hand corner | 68 |
The carved Buddhas of Sam-pul-gam, at the entrance to the gorge of the Inner Kongo, were chiseled by a famous Korean monk five hundred years ago | 69 |
The camera can at best give only a suggestion of the sheer white rock walls of Shin Man-mul-cho, perhaps the most marvelous bit of scenery in the Far East | 69 |
Two ladies in the station waiting-room of Antung, just across the Yalu from Korea, proudly comparing the relative inadequacy of their crippled feet | 76 |
The Japanese have made Dairen, southern terminus of Manchuria and once the Russian Dalny, one of the most modern cities of the Far East | 76 |
A ruined gallery in the famous North Fort of the Russians at Port Arthur. Hundreds of such war memorials are preserved by the Japanese on the sites of their first victory over the white race | 77 |
The empty Manchu throne of Mukden | 77 |
The Russian so loves a uniform, even after the land it represents has gone to pot, that even school-boys in Vladivostok usually wear them,—red bands, khaki, black trousers, purple epaulets | 80 |
A Manchu woman in her national head-dress, bargaining with a street vender of Mukden for a cup of tea | 80 |
A common sight in Harbin,—a Russian refugee, in this case a blind boy, begging in the street of passing Chinese | 81 |
A Russian in Harbin—evidently not a Bolshevik or he would be living in affluence in Russia | 81 |
The grain of the kaoliang, one of the most important crops of North China. It grows from ten to fifteen feet high and makes the finest of hiding-places for bandits | 96 |
A daily sight in Vladivostok,—a group of youths suspected of opinions contrary to those of the Government, rounded up and trotted off to prison | 96 |
A refugee Russian priest, of whom there were many in Harbin | 97 |
Types of this kind swarm along the Chinese Eastern Railway of Manchuria, many of them volunteers in the Chinese army or railway police | 97 |
One of the Russian churches in Harbin, a creamy gray, with green domes and golden crosses, with much gaudy trimming | 100 |
A policeman of Vladivostok, where shaving is looked down upon | 100 |
Two former officers in the czar’s army, now bootblacks in the “thieves” market of Harbin—when they catch any one who can afford to be blacked | 101 |
Scores of booths in Harbin, Manchuli, and Vladivostok, selling second-hand hardware of every description, suggest why the factories and trains of Bolshevik Russia have difficulty in running | 101 |
The human freight horses of Tientsin, who toil ten or more hours a day for twenty coppers, about six cents in our money | 108 |
Part of the pass above Kalgan is so steep that no automobile can climb to the great Mongolian plateau unassisted | 108 |
xvSome of the camel caravans we passed on the Gobi seemed endless. This one had thirty dozen loaded camels and more than a dozen outriders | 109 |
But cattle caravans also cross the Gobi, drawing home-made two-wheeled carts, often with a flag, sometimes the Stars and Stripes, flying at the head | 109 |
The Mongol would not be himself without his horse, though to us this would usually seem only a pony | 112 |
Mongol authorities examining our papers, which Vilner is showing, at Ude. Robes blue, purple, dull red, etc. Biggest Chinaman on left | 113 |
A group of Mongols and stray Chinese watching our arrival at the first yamen of Urga | 113 |
The frontier post of Ude, fifty miles beyond the uninhabited frontier between Inner and Outer Mongolia, where Mongol authorities examine passports and very often turn travelers back | 128 |
Chinese travelers on their way to Urga. It is unbelievable how many muffled Chinamen and their multifarious junk one “Dodge” will carry | 128 |
The Mongol of the Gobi lives in a yourt made of heavy felt over a light wooden framework, which can be taken down and packed in less than an hour when the spirit of the nomad strikes him | 129 |
Mongol women make the felt used as houses, mainly by pouring water on sheep’s wool | 129 |
The upper town of Urga, entirely inhabited by lamas, has the temple of Ganden, containing a colossal standing Buddha, rising high above all else. It is in Tibetan style and much of its superstructure is covered with pure gold | 144 |
Red lamas leaving the “school” in which hundreds of them squat tightly together all day long, droning through their litany. They are of all ages, equally filthy and heavily booted. Over the gateway of the typical Urga palisade is a text in Tibetan, and the cylinders at the upper corners are covered with gleaming gold | 144 |
High class lamas, in their brilliant red or yellow robes, great ribbons streaming from their strange hats, are constantly riding in and out of Urga. Note the bent-knee style of horsemanship | 145 |
A high lama dignitary on his travels, free from the gaze of the curious, and escorted by mounted lamas of the middle class | 145 |
A youthful lama turning one of the myriad prayer-cylinders of Urga. Many written prayers are pasted inside, and each turn is equivalent to saying all of them | 152 |
The market in front of Hansen’s house. The structure on the extreme left is not what it looks like, for they have no such in Urga, but it houses a prayer-cylinder | 152 |
Women, whose crippled feet make going to the shops difficult, do much of their shopping from the two-boxes-on-a-pole type of merchant, constant processions of whom tramp the highways of China | 153 |
An itinerant blacksmith-shop, with the box-bellows worked by a stick handle widely used by craftsmen and cooks in China | 153 |
Pious Mongol men and women worshiping before the residence of the “Living Buddha” of Urga, some by throwing themselves down scores of times on the prostrating-boards placed for that purpose, one by making many circuits of the place, now and again measuring his length on the ground | 160 |
xviThe Mongols of Urga disposed of their dead by throwing the bodies out on the hillsides, where they are quickly devoured by the savage black dogs that roam everywhere | 160 |
Mongol women in full war-paint | 161 |
Though it was still only September, our return from Urga was not unlike a polar expedition | 161 |
Our home in Peking was close under the great East Wall of the Tartar City | 176 |
The indispensable staff of Peking housekeeping consists of (left to right) ama, rickshaw-man, “boy,” coolie, and cook | 176 |
A chat with neighbors on the way to the daily stroll on the wall | 177 |
Street venders were constantly crying their wares in our quarter | 177 |
At Chinese New Year the streets of Peking were gay with all manner of things for sale, such as these brilliantly colored paintings of native artists | 192 |
A rich man died in our street, and among other things burned at his grave, so that he would have them in after-life, were this “automobile” and two “chauffeurs” | 192 |
A neighbor who gave his birds a daily airing | 193 |
Just above us on the Tartar Wall were the ancient astronomical instruments looted by the Germans in 1900 and recently returned, in accordance with a clause in the Treaty of Versailles | 193 |
Preparing for a devil dance at the lama temple in Peking | 208 |
The devil dancers are usually Chinese street urchins hired for the occasion by the languid Mongol lamas of Peking | 208 |
The street sprinklers of Peking work in pairs, with a bucket and a wooden dipper. This is the principal street of the Chinese City “outside Ch’ien-men” | 209 |
The Forbidden City is for the most part no longer that, but open in more than half its extent to the ticket-buying public | 209 |
In the vast compound of the Altar of Heaven | 224 |
Mei Lan-fang, most famous of Chinese actors, who, like his father and grandfather before him, plays only female parts | 224 |
Over the wall from our house boats plied on the moat separating us from the Chinese City | 225 |
Just outside the Tartar Wall of Peking the night soil of the city, brought in wheelbarrows, is dried for use as fertilizer | 225 |
For three thousands miles the Great Wall clambers over the mountains between China and Mongolia | 240 |
One of the mammoth stone figures flanking the road to the Ming Tombs of North China, each of a single piece of granite | 240 |
Another glimpse of the Great Wall | 241 |
The twin pagodas of Taiyüan, capital of Shansi Province | 241 |
The three p’ai-lous of Hsi Ling, the Western Tombs | 248 |
In Shansi four men often work at as many windlasses over a single well to irrigate the fields | 249 |
Prisoners grinding grain in the “model prison” of Taiyüan | 249 |
A few of the 508 Buddhas in one of the lama temples of Jehol | 256 |
xviiThe youngest, but most important—since she has borne him a son—of the wives of a Manchu chief of one of the tomb-tending towns of Tung Ling | 256 |
Interior of the notorious Empress Dowager’s tomb at Tung Ling, with her cloth-covered chair of state and colors to dazzle the stoutest eye | 257 |
The Potalá of Jehol, said to be a copy, even in details, of that of Lhasa. The windows are false and the great building at the top is merely a roofless one enclosing the chief temple | 257 |
Behind Tung Ling the great forest reserve which once “protected” the tombs from the evil spirits that always come from the north was recently opened to settlers, and frontier conditions long since forgotten in the rest of China prevail | 260 |
Much of the plowing in the newly opened tract is done in this primitive fashion | 260 |
The face of the mammoth Buddha of Jehol, forty-three feet high and with forty-two hands. It fills a four-story building, and is the largest in China proper, being identical, according to the lamas, with those of Urga and Lhasa | 261 |
A Chinese inn, with its heated k’ang, may not be the last word in comfort, but it is many degrees in advance of the earth floors of Indian huts along the Andes | 261 |
The upper half of the ascent of Tai-shan is by a stone stairway which ends at the “South Gate of Heaven,” here seen in the upper right-hand corner | 268 |
One of the countless beggar women who squat in the center of the stairway to Tai-shan, expecting every pilgrim to drop at least a “cash” into each basket | 268 |
Wash-day in the moat outside the city wall of Tzinan, capital of Shantung | 269 |
A traveler by chair nearing the top of Tai-shan, most sacred of the five holy peaks of China | 269 |
A priest of the Temple of Confucius | 272 |
The grave of Confucius is noted for its simplicity | 272 |
The sanctum of the Temple of Confucius, with the statue and spirit—tablet of the sage, before which millions of Chinese burn joss-sticks annually | 273 |
Making two Chinese elders of a Shantung village over into Presbyterians | 288 |
Messrs. Kung and Meng, two of the many descendants of Confucius in Shantung flanking one of those of Mencius | 288 |
Some of the worst cases still out of bed in the American leper-home of Tenghsien, Shantung, were still full of laughter | 289 |
Off on an “itinerating” trip with an American missionary in Shantung, by a conveyance long in vogue there. Behind, one of the towers by which messages were sent, by smoke or fire, to all corners of the old Celestial Empire | 289 |
On the way home I changed places with one of our three wheelbarrow coolies, and found that the contrivance did not run so hard as I might otherwise have believed | 304 |
The men who use the roads of China make no protest at their being dug up every spring and turned into fields | 304 |
Sons are a great asset to the wheelbarrowing coolies of Shantung | 305 |
A private carriage, Shantung style | 320 |
xviiiShackled prisoners of Lao-an making hair-nets for the American market | 320 |
School-girls in the American mission school at Weihsien, Shantung | 321 |
The governor’s mansion at Tsingtao, among hills carefully reforested by the Germans, followed by the Japanese, has now been returned to the Chinese after a quarter of a century of foreign rule | 321 |
Chinese farming methods include a stone roller, drawn by man, boy, or beast, to break up the clods of dry earth | 336 |
Kaifeng, capital of Honan Province, has among its population some two hundred Chinese Jews, descendants of immigrants of centuries ago | 336 |
A cave-built blacksmith and carpenter-shop in Kwanyintang where the Lunghai railway ends at present in favor of more laborious means of transportation | 337 |
An illustrated lecture in China takes place outdoors in a village street, two men pushing brightly colored pictures along a two-row panel while they chant some ancient story | 337 |
In the Protestant Mission compound of Honanfu the missionaries had tied up this thief to stew in the sun for a few days, rather than turn him over to the authorities, who would have lopped off his head | 344 |
Over a city gate in western Honan two crated heads of bandits were festering in the sun and feeding swarms of flies | 344 |
A village in the loess country, which breaks up into fantastic formations as the stoneless soil is worn away by the rains and blown away by the winds | 345 |
I take my turn at leading our procession of mule litters and let my companions swallow its dust for a while | 352 |
The road down into Shensi. Once through the great arch-gate that marks the provincial boundary, the road sinks down into the loess again, and beggars line the way into Tungkwan | 352 |
Hwa-shan, one of the five sacred mountains of China | 353 |
An example of Chinese military transportation | 353 |
Coal is plentiful and cheap in Shensi, and comes to market in Sian-fu in wheelbarrows, there to await purchasers | 360 |
The holy of holies of the principal Sian-fu mosque has a simplicity in striking contrast to the demon-crowded interiors of purely Chinese temples | 360 |
Our carts crossing a branch of the Yellow River fifty li west of the Shensi capital | 361 |
Women and girls do much of the grinding of grain with the familiar stone roller of China, in spite of their bound feet | 361 |
An old tablet in the compound of the chief mosque at Sian-fu, purely Chinese in form, except that the base has lost its likeness to a turtle and the writing is in Arabic | 368 |
This famous old portrait of Confucius, cut on black stone, in Sian-fu is said to be the most authentic one in existence | 368 |
A large town of cave-dwellers in the loess country, and the terraced fields which support it | 369 |
Samson and Delilah. This blind boy, grinding grain all day long, marches round and round his stone mill with the same high lifted feet and bobbing head of the late Caruso in the opera of that name | 369 |
xixThe East Gate of Sian-fu, by which we entered the capital of Shensi, rises like an apartment-house above the flat horizon | 384 |
All manner of aids to the man behind the wheelbarrow are used in his long journey in bringing wheat to market, some of them not very economical | 384 |
The Western Gate of Sian-fu, through which we continued our journey to Kansu | 385 |
A “Hwei-Hwei,” or Chinese Mohammedan, keeper of an outdoor restaurant | 385 |
In the Mohammedan section of Sian-fu there are men who, but for their Chinese garb and habits, might pass for Turks in Damascus or Constantinople | 400 |
Our chief cartman eating dinner in his favorite posture, and holding in one hand the string of “cash,” one thousand strong and worth about an American quarter, which served him as money | 400 |
A bit of cliff-dwelling town in the loess country, where any other color than a yellowish brown is extremely rare | 401 |
A corner of a wayside village, topped by a temple | 401 |
The Chinese coolie gets his hair dressed about once a month by the itinerant barber. This one is just in the act of adding a switch. Note the wooden comb at the back of the head | 408 |
An old countryman having dinner at an outdoor restaurant in town on market day has his own way of using chairs or benches | 408 |
A Chinese soldier and his mount, not to mention his worldly possessions | 409 |
Mongol women on a joy-ride | 409 |
Two blind minstrels entertaining a village by singsonging interminable national ballads and legends, to which they keep time by beating together resonant sticks of hard wood | 416 |
The boys and girls of western China are “toughened” by wearing nothing below the waist and only one ragged garment above it, even in midwinter | 416 |
The “fast mail” of interior China is carried by a pair of coolies, in relays of about twenty miles each, made at a jog-trot with about eighty pounds of mail apiece. They travel night and day and get five or six American dollars a month | 417 |
A bit of the main street of Taing-Ning, showing the damage wrought by the earthquake of two years before to the “devil screen” in front of the local magistrate’s yamen | 417 |
This begging old ragamuffin is a Taoist priest | 436 |
A local magistrate sent this squad of “soldiers” to escort us through the earthquake district, though whether for fear of bandits, out of mere respect for our high rank, or because the “soldiers” needed a few coppers which he could not give them himself, was not clear | 436 |
Where the “mountain walked” and overwhelmed the old tree-lined highway. In places this was covered hundreds of feet deep for miles, in others it had been carried bodily, trees and all, a quarter-mile or more away | 437 |
xxIn the earthquake district of western China whole terraced mountain-sides came down and covered whole villages. In the foreground is a typical Kansu farm | 437 |
Kansu earlaps are very gaily embroidered in colored designs of birds, flowers, and the like. Pipes are smaller than their “ivory” mouthpieces | 444 |
It is a common sight in some parts of Kansu to see men knitting, and still more so to meet little girls whose feet are already beginning to be bound | 444 |
The village scholar displays his wisdom by reading where all can see him—through spectacles of pure plate-glass | 445 |
A Kirghiz in the streets of Lanchow, where many races of Central Asia meet | 445 |
An ahong, or Chinese Mohammedan mullah of Lanchow | 448 |
Mohammedan school-girls, whose garments were a riot of color | 448 |
A glimpse of Lanchow, capital of China’s westernmost province, from across the Yellow River | 449 |
Looking down the valley of Lanchow, across several groups of temples at the base of the hills, to the four forts built against another Mohammedan rebellion | 449 |
A Kansu vista near Lanchow, where the hills are no longer terraced, but where towns are numerous and much alike | 464 |
This method of grinding up red peppers and the like is wide-spread in China. Both trough and wheel are of solid iron | 464 |
Oil is floated down the Yellow River to Lanchow in whole ox-hides that quiver at a touch as if they were alive | 465 |
The Yellow River at Lanchow, with a water-wheel and the American bridge which is the only one that crosses it in the west | 465 |
The Chinese protect their boys from evil spirits (the girls do not matter) by having a chain and padlock put about their necks at some religious ceremony, which deceives the spirits into believing that they belong to the temple. Earlaps embroidered in gay colors are widely used in Kansu in winter | 480 |
Many of the faces seen in Western China hardly seem Chinese | 480 |
A dead man on the way to his ancestral home for burial, a trip that may last for weeks. Over the heavy unpainted wooden coffin were brown bags of fodder for the animals, surmounted by the inevitable rooster | 481 |
Our party on the return from Lanchow,—the major and myself flanked by our “boys” and cook respectively, these in turn by the two cart-drivers, with our alleged mafu, or groom for our riding animals, at the right | 481 |
A typical farm hamlet of the Yellow River valley in the far west where some of the farm-yards are surrounded by mud walls so mighty that they look like great armories | 496 |
The usual kitchen and heating-plant of a Chinese inn, and the kind on which our cook competed with hungry coolies in preparing our dinners | 496 |
The midwinter third-class coach in which I returned to Peking | 497 |
No wonder I was mistaken for a Bolshevik and caused family tears when I turned up in Peking from the west | 497 |
The author gratefully acknowledges his indebtedness to Mr. Edwin S. Mills of Peking, China, for the use of the pictures of Urga.
The author sincerely thanks Mr. Edwin S. Mills from Peking, China, for letting him use the pictures of Urga.
CHAPTER I
IN THE LAND WE NOW REFER TO AS KOREA
The traveler from Japan to the peninsula still known to the Western world as Korea has a sense of being wafted on some magic carpet thousands of miles while he slept, a sensation which the splendid steamers bridging the Straits of Tsushima several times a day do not dispel. It is surprising how different two lands separated only by a few hours on the sea can be. A fortnight on a Nippon Yusen Kaisha liner and six weeks of wandering from end to end of the Island Empire gave us a Japanese background against which many of the problems of the Far East stood out more clearly, but it did very little to prepare us for the physical aspects of the “Cho-sen” over which the banner of the rising sun now waves. Those who have listened to the long and heated controversy over the adding of this large slice of mainland to the mikado’s realm must often have heard the apologists’ assertion that the two peoples, Japanese and Koreans, are so nearly alike as to be virtually the same. Perhaps they are; but if so, all the outward evidences the casual visitor must depend upon to form an opinion are deceiving. Superficially, at least, Japan and Korea are as different as two Oriental lands and races could well be. In landscape, customs, costumes, point of view, general characteristics, even in the details of personal appearance, the two shores of the Sea of Japan strike the new-comer as having very little in common.
The traveler coming from Japan to the peninsula still known in the West as Korea feels like they’ve been transported on some magic carpet for thousands of miles while they slept, a feeling that the impressive steamers crossing the Tsushima Straits multiple times a day don’t change. It’s surprising how different two countries can be even though they’re only a few hours apart by sea. Two weeks on a Nippon Yusen Kaisha liner and six weeks exploring the entirety of the Island Empire provided us with a Japanese backdrop that clarified many Far East issues, but it did little to prepare us for the physical aspects of “Cho-sen,” where the banner of the rising sun now flies. Those who have followed the lengthy and intense debate about adding this large chunk of mainland to the emperor’s territory have likely heard supporters claim that the Japanese and Koreans are so similar they might as well be the same. Maybe they are; but if that’s the case, all the visible signs a casual visitor relies on to form an opinion are misleading. At least on the surface, Japan and Korea are as different as two Oriental nations and cultures can be. In terms of landscape, customs, clothing, perspective, overall traits, and even in small details of personal appearance, the two shores of the Sea of Japan strike newcomers as having very little in common.
Perhaps the most outstanding feature of Korea, to any one newly arrived from Japan, is her treelessness. The lack of forests is, with the possible exception of exclamations of incredulity over her extraordinary costumes, almost certain to be the subject of any Occidental’s first paragraph of Korean notes. In our own case this denuded 4aspect of the peninsula was emphasized by the blazing, cloudless sunshine that beat relentlessly down during all our first day of travel northward to the old capital, and on many another to follow. The bare and sun-scorched landscape suggested some victim of barbarian cruelty, who, stripped of his garments, was being tortured to death by slow roasting. Possibly we should have been prepared for this, but we were not. We had heard much of the doings of Japan in Korea; we knew something of the opera-bouffe hats of the men and the startlingly short waists of the women, but no one had ever told us of the curiously pure and molten sunshine of “Cho-sen,” of the vividness of its shadows and the filtered transparency of its air, nor, for that matter, of the incessant heat we must endure because chance allotted us from June to August in what was once the Hermit Kingdom.
Perhaps the most striking feature of Korea, for anyone who has just arrived from Japan, is the lack of trees. The absence of forests is, except for maybe expressions of disbelief over the extraordinary clothing, almost guaranteed to be the first thing any outsider mentions in their notes about Korea. In our case, this bare aspect of the peninsula was highlighted by the blazing, cloudless sunshine that relentlessly beat down on us during our first day of travel north to the old capital and on many more days to follow. The bare, sun-baked landscape resembled someone who had been cruelly stripped bare, enduring a slow, torturous roasting. We might have been ready for this, but we weren’t. We had heard a lot about Japan's actions in Korea; we knew something about the men’s outrageous hats and the women’s strikingly short waists, but no one had ever mentioned the strangely pure and intense sunlight of “Cho-sen,” the vividness of its shadows, the clear quality of its air, or, for that matter, the relentless heat we would have to endure from June to August in what was once the Hermit Kingdom.
Trees as sparse as the hairs of a Korean beard stood out in lonely isolation across the more or less flat lands of all that first day’s journey; beyond these, usually rather near at hand, rose scarred and repulsive hillsides as unsightly as the faces of those countless inhabitants along the way who had been visited by the “honorable spirit” of smallpox. It was not merely the barrenness of a naturally treeless country, a barrenness as dreary as those upper reaches of the Andes to which real vegetation never attains, but one which, like the denuded plains of Spain, visibly complains of the wanton violence of man. To be sure, many of the rocky hills that sometimes rose to be almost mountains were here and there thinly covered with evergreen shrubs which might some day be trees, and even forests. But these, travelers are informed with what becomes tiresome persistency, were planted by the new Government. The Japanese policy of reforestation, we were eventually to know, has already done excellent things for Korea, and that not merely, as those who resent the rape of the peninsula assert, where it will attract the passing tourist’s eye, and it promises in time to accomplish something worth while; but it is an unfortunate Japanese trait to fear that good deeds will not speak loudly enough for themselves.
Trees stood sparse across the mostly flat lands of that first day's journey, looking as lonely as a few hairs on a Korean beard. Beyond them, scarred and unattractive hills rose, as unappealing as the faces of the countless people along the way who had suffered from smallpox. It wasn't just the emptiness of a naturally treeless region, as dull as the high Andes where real vegetation never grows, but a desolation that, like the barren plains of Spain, visibly shows the destructive impact of humanity. Sure, some of the rocky hills that occasionally reached nearly mountain heights were sparsely covered with evergreen shrubs that could potentially turn into trees or even forests. But travelers were consistently reminded that these were planted by the new Government. We eventually learned that Japan's reforestation efforts have already brought significant benefits to Korea—not just in places where they catch the eye of passing tourists, but they promise to lead to substantial improvements over time. However, it seems to be a common Japanese tendency to worry that good deeds won't be recognized without a little extra flair.
The reducing of a once well wooded land to its present nude state is characteristic of the Korean, we were to learn, suggestive of his general point of view. In the olden days the people were often driven to the hills by their savage or demented rulers, and as the rigorous winters that contrast with the tropical summers came on, they not only burned the trees, but as roots make excellent charcoal they dug up even these, leaving nothing that might by any chance sprout again. To replant in better times, to take any serious thought for the morrow, 5would have been un-Korean. The Korean even of to-day who covets the half-dozen cherries or plums on a limb does not usually take the trouble to pick them; he breaks off the branch and goes his way munching the fruit, with never a thought of next year. Translate this improvidence, this almost complete lack of foresight, into all the details of daily life, and the condition and the final fate of Korea become understandable, in fact inevitable.
The transformation of a once lush land into its current bare state is typical of the Korean mindset, as we would learn, reflecting their overall perspective. In the past, people were often forced to retreat to the hills by their brutal or insane rulers. When the harsh winters contrasted with the tropical summers, they not only burned the trees but also dug up the roots, which made excellent charcoal, leaving nothing that could possibly sprout again. The idea of replanting during better times or considering the future seriously would have seemed un-Korean. Even today, a Korean who desires the handful of cherries or plums on a branch usually doesn’t bother to pick them; instead, he simply breaks off the branch and walks away eating the fruit, with no thought for next year. If you translate this carelessness, this almost complete lack of foresight, into every aspect of daily life, the situation and eventual fate of Korea become clear, even inevitable. 5
Woods survive to any great extent in Korea only in two places—about royal tombs and up along the Yalu River which forms the northern frontier. Elsewhere in the peninsula, with minor exceptions, there are only groups of trees planted by foreign missionaries, and rows of pine shrubs set out directly by the Japanese Government, or by local authorities, school children, or private individuals, under Japanese influence. This treelessness is not the unimportant detail many may think; it is the wanton destruction of her forests of long ago that gives the Korea of to-day her mainly mud houses, much of her filth, dust, and swarming flies, and those devastating floods of the rainy season which sweep roads, bridges, fields, and even villages before them.
Woods in Korea primarily survive in just two places—around royal tombs and along the Yalu River, which marks the northern border. In most other parts of the peninsula, with a few minor exceptions, you’ll find only clusters of trees planted by foreign missionaries, along with rows of pine shrubs set out by the Japanese Government, local authorities, school children, or private individuals under Japanese influence. This lack of trees isn’t a minor detail; the reckless destruction of forests long ago is what leads to the mud houses, much of the filth, dust, and swarms of flies we see in Korea today, as well as the devastating floods during the rainy season that wash away roads, bridges, fields, and even entire villages.
There were many other things which gave the Korean landscape its strikingly un-Japanese aspect. Fewer people were working in the larger and less garden-like fields; the village roofs thatched with rice-straw had a flatter, smoother look than the homes of Japanese peasants; the towns themselves seemed to huddle together as closely and inconspicuously as possible, as if to escape, or join in resisting, the rapacious tax-gatherers of the olden days that are not forgotten. Koreans in white, their inevitable color, so rare in Japan, were everywhere, though more often in the shade of villages or rare wayside trees or huts than out in the baking sunshine. The suggestion forced itself upon us that perhaps the fields were larger because the people could not coax themselves to work alone. In Japan it had been unusual to see more than a peasant and his wife in the same field; here work seemed to be done almost entirely by gangs. In spite of the general aridness of the landscape, there were many flooded rice-fields, and in nearly all of them waded a soldier-like line of often a dozen laborers, as many women as men among them. Much of the country showed no signs of the languid hand of man, yet even in the drier sections scattered rows of these peasants, their garments still almost snow-white at a distance, gleamed forth in the otherwise mainly reddish landscape.
There were many other things that gave the Korean landscape its distinctly non-Japanese look. Fewer people were working in the larger, less garden-like fields; the village roofs, thatched with rice straw, had a flatter, smoother appearance than the homes of Japanese farmers. The towns themselves seemed to huddle together as closely and unobtrusively as possible, as if trying to escape or resist the greedy tax collectors of the past that are still remembered. Koreans dressed in white, their typical color, which is rare in Japan, were everywhere, although they were more often found in the shade of villages, rare trees, or huts than out in the blazing sun. It occurred to us that perhaps the fields were larger because people found it hard to motivate themselves to work alone. In Japan, it was unusual to see more than a farmer and his wife in the same field; here, work seemed to be done almost entirely by groups. Despite the generally dry landscape, there were many flooded rice fields, and in almost all of them stood a soldier-like line of often a dozen laborers, with as many women as men among them. Much of the countryside showed no signs of human touch, yet even in the drier areas, scattered rows of these farmers, their clothes still almost snow-white from a distance, stood out in the predominantly reddish landscape.
Similar groups stood in semicircles on earth threshing-floors flailing 6grain in a way that is familiar to the Western world, but which we had never seen in Japan. Nor were there any reminders of the Island Empire in the clusters of women kneeling at the edge of every bit of a stream or mud-hole paddling clothes with a sort of cricket-bat. The ways of life, the very architecture, were strangely reminiscent of lands inhabited by negroes.
Similar groups gathered in semicircles on the grain threshing floors, hitting the grain in a way that's common in the Western world, but which we had never seen in Japan. There were no signs of the Island Empire among the groups of women kneeling by every stream or muddy spot, beating clothes with something like a cricket bat. The lifestyle and even the architecture felt oddly reminiscent of areas populated by Black people.
The most primitive of plows, drawn by bulls, dragged their way to and fro in a field here and there. Along what passed for roads others of these lumbering animals plodded almost hidden under loads of new-cut grain or brushwood, at a pace which seemed to fit the languid temperament of the country. In places a highway, constructed by the new rulers, tried to preserve an unbroken march; but wherever a bridge should have been they almost invariably pitched headlong down into the bed of a stream as waterless as those of summer-time Spain. Even the Japanese, we were to learn before leaving the peninsula, are poor bridge-builders, while the Korean remains true to his natural improvidence in constructing flimsy things of branches and earth, with totally inadequate abutments, which the first dash of the rainy season down the treeless hillsides converts into scattered masses of rubbish.
The simplest plows, pulled by oxen, dragged their way back and forth across fields here and there. Along what could be called roads, other slow-moving animals trudged along, nearly hidden under heavy loads of freshly cut grain or brushwood, moving at a pace that matched the laid-back vibe of the area. In some spots, a highway built by the new leaders attempted to maintain an uninterrupted path; however, wherever a bridge should have been, they often ended up tumbling down into a stream bed as dry as those in summer-time Spain. We would later learn before leaving the peninsula that even the Japanese aren't great at building bridges, while the Koreans stick to their usual carelessness with flimsy structures made of branches and dirt, with support that is completely insufficient, which the first heavy rains of the season wash down from the treeless hills into piles of debris.
All the day long the scene varied little from these first few glimpses. There was a certain rough beauty in the tawny hillsides and the broad stretches of sun-flooded rice lands, but of a similarity that grew monotonous, while the ways of the people, until opportunity should come to see them in closer detail, were such as the fleeting tourist is wont to sum up under the outworn word “picturesque” and quickly lose from between the pages of memory. Korea has often been called a land of villages, and in all the two hundred and eighty miles from the southern point of the peninsula to Seoul there was little more than a frequent succession of smooth-thatched, closely snuggled towns varying, outwardly at least, only in size. Not until later on, and by more primitive means of travel, were we to know of the remnants of bygone civilization, the pine-grove tombs of royalty, the ruined palaces of fallen dynasties, and the welter of modern problems with which the peninsula teems.
All day long, the scene changed very little from these first few views. There was a certain rugged beauty in the golden hills and the vast fields of sunlit rice, but it became repetitive. The behavior of the people, until we had the chance to observe them more closely, was what fleeting tourists typically sum up as “picturesque” and then quickly forget. Korea is often described as a land of villages, and along the two hundred and eighty miles from the southern end of the peninsula to Seoul, we mostly encountered a series of smooth-thatched, tightly clustered towns that varied, at least on the surface, only in size. It wasn’t until later, through more basic means of travel, that we would discover the remnants of ancient civilization, the pine grove tombs of royalty, the ruins of lost dynasties, and the complex modern issues that affect the peninsula.
The Korean wardrobe has so little in common with that of the Occident, and includes so many startling absurdities, that it merits a few words in detail, even though some of its more striking features are fairly familiar to those interested in foreign lands. To begin with the basis of all wardrobes, there is that ingenious contrivance with 7which the Korean gentleman protects his other garments from perspiration during the blazing months of summer. A missionary who carried home a set of these and offered them to any one in his native parish who could identify them recorded forty-two guesses, all equally wide of the mark, which was the simple phrase “summer underwear.” Out of their environment these useful garments look more like primitive bird-cages or light baskets than what they really are. In their entirety they consist of a kind of waistcoat, a high collar of the Elizabethan period, and cuffs so long as to be almost sleeves—all made of small strips of ratan very loosely woven together. That they are effective in allowing the free circulation of air, and at the same time preserve the cloth garments from contact with the perspiring body, one is willing to grant without the evidence of actual personal experience. Now and again one runs across a Japanese petty official who, in an effort to mitigate his midsummer sufferings, has adopted at least the cuffs; but on the whole this ingenious contribution is likely to suffer the common fate of never finding appreciation beyond its native habitat.
The Korean wardrobe is quite different from Western styles and contains many surprising quirks, so it deserves a closer look, even though some of its more notable aspects might be familiar to those interested in other cultures. To start with the core of all wardrobes, there's that clever item the Korean gentleman uses to keep his other clothes sweat-free during the scorching summer months. A missionary who brought back a set of these and offered them to anyone in his hometown who could identify them noted forty-two guesses, all failing miserably, with the actual answer being “summer underwear.” Out of context, these practical garments resemble primitive birdcages or lightweight baskets more than their true purpose. Overall, they consist of a kind of vest, a high collar reminiscent of the Elizabethan era, and cuffs that are nearly as long as sleeves—all made from small strips of rattan loosely woven together. It's easy to believe that they allow for good air circulation while also keeping the fabric garments away from the sweaty body, even without personal experience. Occasionally, you might spot a Japanese low-ranking official who, in an attempt to ease his midsummer discomfort, has adopted at least the cuffs; however, this clever design is likely to remain unappreciated outside its home country.
Over his ratan skin-protectors the Korean gentleman wears a kind of waistcoat-shirt, trousers (if so commonplace a term may be used for so uncommonplace a garment) which are more than voluminous even in use and, when hung out to dry, suggest the mainsails of a wind-jammer, and finally a turamaggie, an overcoat reaching to the calves and tied together with a bow over the right breast. All these articles are snow-white, and in summer are made of a vegetable fiber so thin as to suggest starched cheese-cloth. The mainsail trousers are fastened tightly about the ankles with a winding of cloth, which also supports the carefully foot-shaped and curiously thick white socks, which are thrust into low slippers cut well away at the instep, slippers formerly of leather richly embroidered or otherwise decorated, but now rapidly giving way to the white or reddish rubber ones made in Japan which are ruining the feet of Korea. The crowning glory and absurdity of this de rigueur costume, however, is the head-dress. About the brow is bound, so tightly as to cause violent headaches when first adopted and to leave lifelong marks, a black band about four inches wide and reaching well up over the curve of the head. On top of this sits a brimless cap shaped like a fez with an L-shaped indentation in its front, and finally over all else reigns an uncollapsible opera-hat. Both the hat and the cap beneath it are made of horsehair, or cheap imitations thereof, and are so loosely woven and screen-like in their transparency that facetious and unkindly foreigners are wont 8to refer to them as “fly-traps.” This term is as unwarranted as it is offensive, for the one place in Korea which is free from flies in season is the hat-protected crown of the adult Korean male. One need not take the word of “old-timers,” but will find ample evidence in photographs of a decade or more ago that the opera-bouffe contraption with which the Korean gentleman tops himself off once had brim enough to do duty almost as a real hat. Such utilitarian days are past, however; perhaps it is that universal bugbear of the human family, the high cost of living, which has reduced the brim to little more than a ledge. The fact remains that a fly must walk with caution now in making a circuit which in the good old days he might safely have accomplished after sipping long and generously at the edge of a bowl of sool. However, let there be no misapprehension, no uncalled for sympathy under the impression that this shrinking has worked hardship upon the wearer. The Korean hat was not designed to be a protection for the head and a shade for the face. Its purpose in life is far more serious and is concentrated on one single object,—to protect from evil spirits the precious topknot which is the badge of full Korean manhood. Hence its duty is not merely an outdoor one; wicked beings of the invisible world have no compunction in taking unfair advantage of their victims, so that to this day it is a common practice for the Korean man to lay him down to sleep—on his bare papered floor, using a hardwood brick as a pillow—with his precious top-hat still in place.
Over his rattan skin protectors, the Korean gentleman wears a sort of waistcoat-shirt and trousers (if such a common term can be used for such an unusual garment) that are more than ample even in use and, when hung out to dry, resemble the mainsails of a sailing ship. He also wears a turamaggie, an overcoat that reaches to the calves and is tied with a bow over the right breast. All these items are snow-white and, in summer, are made of a vegetable fiber so thin it looks like starched cheesecloth. The baggy trousers are tightly fastened around the ankles with cloth, which also supports the carefully foot-shaped and oddly thick white socks that are stuffed into low slippers cut low at the instep. These slippers, which were once richly embroidered leather, are now quickly being replaced by white or reddish rubber ones made in Japan that are ruining the feet of Koreans. The final touch of this required outfit, however, is the headgear. Around his forehead is tightly bound a black band about four inches wide, so snug that it can cause severe headaches when first worn and leaves lasting marks. On top of this is a brimless cap shaped like a fez with an L-shaped indentation at the front, and finally, perched on top of everything is an uncollapsible opera hat. Both the hat and the cap underneath are made of horsehair or cheap imitations, and are so loosely woven and transparent that sarcastic and unkind foreigners often refer to them as “fly-traps.” This term, while both unfair and disrespectful, is inaccurate since the one place in Korea that is free from flies during the season is the hat-covered head of an adult Korean male. You don't have to take the word of “old-timers”; abundant evidence in photographs from a decade or more ago shows that the opera-bouffe contraption that tops the Korean gentleman once had enough brim to function almost like a real hat. Those practical days are gone, perhaps due to that universal worry about the high cost of living, which has reduced the brim to little more than a ledge. The fact is, a fly must tread carefully now in a circuit that, in the good old days, it could have navigated after leisurely sipping from the edge of a bowl of sool. However, there should be no misunderstanding or unintended sympathy based on the belief that this reduction has been a hardship for the wearer. The Korean hat wasn’t designed to protect the head or shield the face. Its main purpose is much more serious and focuses solely on one objective—to protect the precious topknot, which signifies full Korean manhood, from evil spirits. Therefore, its function isn’t just for the outdoors; malicious beings from the invisible realm don’t hesitate to take unfair advantage of their victims, which is why it is still common for a Korean man to lay down to sleep—on his bare papered floor, using a hardwood brick as a pillow—with his treasured top-hat still firmly in place.
However, we have not yet completely garbed our yang-ban, our gentleman of the Land of Morning Calm. His hat, being light, almost ethereal, in fact, must be held in place, whether in sleep or in the slightest breeze, for which purpose a black ribbon under the chin serves the ordinary man and a string of amber beads his haughtier fellow-citizen. Add to this the unfailing collapsible fan, and a pipe as long and heavy as a cane, with a bowl the size of the end of the thumb, and you may vizualize in his entirety the proud gentleman who sallies forth from his mud hut and picks his way leisurely between the mud-holes and offal-heaps of any town or city street. The fan is rarely inactive, now dispensing a breeze to the copper-tinted face of its owner, now shading it from the direct rays of a burning sun. The pipe, bowl down, swings with the jaunty aggressiveness of an Englishman’s “stick”; above all else the features remain fixed and unalterable in their serenity, for in the code of the genuine Korean gentleman of the old school there is no greater vulgarity than to show in public either mirth, anger, curiosity, or annoyance. Nothing could be more 9specklessly white than this dignified apparition, for do not his servant-wives spend their days, and no small portion of their nights, in preparing his garments for the daily sortie and mingling with his fellows? Behold him, then, as he joins the latter, in a shop-door or on a shaded street-corner, where he squats with them in that fashion which has caused a row of Korean males to be likened to penguins, letting his spotless starched turamaggie spread out on the unswept earth with a carelessness which seems a boast of his ability to command unlimited female labor.
However, we have not yet fully dressed our yang-ban, our gentleman from the Land of Morning Calm. His hat, light and almost ethereal, needs to be held in place whether he’s sleeping or caught in the slightest breeze, so a black ribbon under the chin does the job for the average man and a string of amber beads serves the more arrogant ones. Add to this the ever-present collapsible fan and a pipe as long and heavy as a cane, with a bowl the size of a thumb, and you can picture the proud gentleman stepping out of his mud hut, carefully navigating the mud puddles and trash heaps of any town or city street. The fan is hardly ever still, now providing a breeze for his copper-toned face, now shielding it from the direct rays of the blazing sun. The pipe, bowl down, swings with the confident swagger of an Englishman’s “stick”; yet, above all, his expression remains calm and unchanging, for in the code of a true Korean gentleman from the old school, showing joy, anger, curiosity, or annoyance in public is the ultimate disgrace. Nothing is more impeccably white than this dignified figure, for don’t his servant-wives spend their days—and many of their nights—preparing his clothes for his daily outings and mingling with his peers? So, see him as he joins them in a shop doorway or on a shaded street corner, squatting with them in a position that has led to comparisons of Korean men to penguins, letting his spotless starched turamaggie spread out on the unswept ground with a casualness that seems to flaunt his ability to command endless female labor.
We must come back again, however, to the incredible hat, as the eyes and the attention constantly will as long as one remains in Korea. If the Japanese are commonplace and unoriginal in their head-dress, certainly their newly captured fellow-subjects make up for it. Set usually at a jaunty angle, whether by design, breeze, or cranial malformation, a jauntiness enhanced by its scarcity of brim, the “fly-trap” hat furnishes Korea half its picturesqueness. Graduates of modern mission or Japanese government schools, self-complacent young men who have been abroad, native Christian pastors, may wear the Panama or the felt of the West above their otherwise national white garb, but the “fly-trap” is still the prevailing head-dress throughout the length, breadth, and social strata of the peninsula. Far and wide, in city or village, in crowded marts or on lonely country roads, indoors or out, awake or asleep, the high hat is seldom missing. It persists to the very edge of the frontier, then disappears as suddenly as it had sprung up at the other extremity of the country. After one has weathered the first shock it does not look so greatly out of place on your city gentleman, but I never learned to behold it with proper equanimity on the heads of porters, plasterers, and peasants. Even the workman without it, however, is still conspicuous. Tattered, soiled, and sun-scorched men wandering across the country with a kind of tramp’s pack on their backs wear the horsehair bird-cage on their heads; perhaps the most incongruous sight of all is to behold a battered old man of the rice-fields solemnly squatting on a garbage-heap in his mud hamlet, with his opera hat perched on guard above his gray and scanty topknot.
We need to return to the incredible hat, as it constantly captures the eyes and attention as long as one is in Korea. While the Japanese may have ordinary and unoriginal hats, certainly their newly acquired fellow subjects make up for it. Typically worn at a stylish angle, whether intentionally, due to the wind, or odd-shaped heads, this stylishness is enhanced by its lack of brim; the “fly-trap” hat gives Korea much of its charm. Graduates of modern missionary or Japanese government schools, self-satisfied young men who have traveled abroad, native Christian pastors, may wear Panama or felt hats from the West over their otherwise traditional white attire, but the “fly-trap” remains the dominant headwear across the entire peninsula, regardless of region or social class. Far and wide, in cities or villages, in busy marketplaces or on quiet country roads, indoors or outdoors, awake or asleep, the high hat is rarely absent. It persists all the way to the border, only to vanish as suddenly as it appeared at the far end of the country. After you get used to it, it doesn’t seem as out of place on a city gentleman, but I never managed to see it with the right mindset on the heads of porters, plasterers, and farmers. Even laborers without it still stand out. Torn, dirty, and sunburnt men trudging through the countryside with a hobo's pack on their backs wear the horsehair birdcage on their heads; perhaps the most absurd sight is witnessing a weathered old man from the rice fields solemnly sitting on a garbage pile in his muddy village, with his top hat balancing solemnly above his sparse gray hair.
Once or twice we caught a glimpse of the light-brown hat formerly worn by all men about to be married, or to add a new wife to their collection of servants; once the custom was wide-spread of painting the hat white in sign of mourning, but to-day black is almost universal, and an excellent foil to the otherwise white garb. Bridegrooms no longer feel compelled publicly to announce their happy status, and there 10is another and more effective means of showing grief at bereavement,—a mourner’s hat like a large, finely woven, inverted basket with scalloped edges, which completely hides the afflicted face of the wearer. As he ambles along under this ample protection instead of blistering beneath a horsehair cage, surely a feeling of gratitude toward the departed relative must pervade the thoughts of the bereaved, particularly as the Korean term of mourning lasts for three years. There is a still more enormous, very coarsely woven, sunshade worn by peasants in the midsummer months, while Buddhist priests, otherwise indistinguishable from layman tramps and beggars, wear a smaller hat of similar shape to that of the mourners, but raised on bamboo stilts well above the head. The horsehair hat is costly, by Korean standards, the better ones even by our own, and, being put together with glue, is frail and perishable. Water is particularly fatal to it. Let the first drop of a shower fall, therefore, and from within the garments of every Korean man appears a hat-umbrella, a little cone-shaped cover of oiled paper or silk, like a miniature Japanese parasol, which is quickly opened and slipped over the precious hat. As to the rest of the male garb, no damage is possible which cannot be repaired by the return of sunshine or a few hours’ labor by the women at home. Thus on a rainy day the black heads above white bodies characteristic of all Korea turn to drenched cheese-cloth surmounted by oily yellow clowns’ caps.
Once or twice, we caught sight of the light-brown hat that used to be worn by all men about to get married or add another wife to their staff; once, it was common to paint the hat white as a sign of mourning, but now black is almost everywhere, providing a nice contrast to the otherwise white attire. Bridegrooms no longer feel the need to publicly declare their happy status, and there's another, more effective way to express grief at a loss—a mourner’s hat, which resembles a large, finely woven, upside-down basket with scalloped edges that completely covers the wearer’s face. As he strolls along under this generous protection instead of sweating under a horsehair hat, the bereaved must feel a sense of gratitude toward the deceased relative, especially since the Korean mourning period lasts for three years. There’s an even larger, coarsely woven sunshade worn by farmers during the summer, while Buddhist priests, who otherwise look just like street people and beggars, wear a smaller hat that is similar in shape to the mourners', but raised on bamboo stilts well above their heads. The horsehair hat is expensive by Korean standards, and even more so by ours; since it’s assembled with glue, it’s fragile and perishable. Water is especially harmful to it. So, as soon as the first drop of rain falls, every Korean man pulls out a hat-umbrella, a little cone-shaped cover made of oiled paper or silk, like a mini Japanese parasol, quickly opening it up and placing it over the precious hat. As for the rest of the male clothing, any damage can be fixed with a bit of sunshine or a few hours of work by women at home. Thus, on a rainy day, the black heads above white bodies common across all of Korea turn into drenched cheesecloth topped with oily yellow clown hats.
It is fitting that the wardrobe of the insignificant sex should be simpler, and more easily described. Except that anything in the way of head-dress is denied them, lest they compete with the decorative male, the garb of the Korean women is in the main a crude replica of that of the men. All reasonably available evidence goes to show that the women are never permitted the luxury of wickerwork undergarments. Trousers, socks, and slippers are similar to those worn by the male; above these is the thinnest and slightest of garments, which barely covers the shoulders, and over the trousers is worn a white skirt fastened well up above the floating ribs. In summer at least that is all, except in a few old-fashioned communities, where a muffling white cloak covering everything except the eyes and the feet is still occasionally seen. That, I repeat, is all, and from our puritanical point of view it is not enough. For the Korean woman insists that the waistline is at the armpits, and makes no provision to have the upper and lower garments contiguous, with the result that she displays to the 11public gaze exactly that portion of the torso which the women of most nations take pains to conceal. Missionaries, who are as prone as the rest of us to lose their native point of view through long contact with other races, assure us that Korean women are extremely modest. In general deportment the statement holds water; but a married lady of Korea, marching down the main thoroughfare of one of our cities in her native garb, would be granted anything but modesty. One might fancy that the costume was prescribed by some lascivious tyrant of olden days; those who have looked deeply into the matter, however, assure us that it is due to the pride of motherhood. The fact remains that, though the precept and example of Western nations have tended to lengthen the upper garment among better-class women of the cities, and particularly among those who have attended modern schools, the great majority of the adult female sex in Korea still wear their breasts outside their clothing. Sun-browned and leather-textured as the face, the plumpness of matrons or the withered rags of age are almost always in plain, not to say insistent, evidence. In fact neither the men nor the women of the masses often succeed in making both garments meet; males below the turamaggie class as habitually display their navels as their wives do their bosoms.
It makes sense that women's clothing should be simpler and easier to describe. Aside from the fact that they're not allowed to wear headgear to avoid competing with the decorative men, Korean women mostly dress in a rough imitation of men's clothing. All evidence suggests that women are never given the luxury of undergarments made of wicker. Their trousers, socks, and slippers are similar to those worn by men; on top of that, they wear the lightest garment that barely covers their shoulders, along with a white skirt that is fastened above the floating ribs. In the summer, that’s pretty much it, except in some old-fashioned communities where you can still occasionally see a white cloak that covers everything except the eyes and feet. Again, that's it, and from our more modest perspective, it doesn't seem like enough. Korean women believe that their waistline is at the armpits and don’t see the need for the upper and lower garments to meet, which results in showing off the part of the torso that women from most other cultures usually hide. Missionaries, like the rest of us, often lose their native perspective after being around other cultures, and they assure us that Korean women are very modest. This may be true in how they conduct themselves generally; however, if a married Korean woman walks down the main street in one of our cities dressed in her traditional attire, she wouldn't be viewed as modest at all. One might think the outfit was designed by some lewd tyrant from the past; those who have delved deeper into the subject claim it has to do with the pride of motherhood. The reality is that, while the influence of Western nations has led to longer upper garments among upper-class women in cities, especially those who have gone to modern schools, the vast majority of adult women in Korea still wear their breasts outside their clothes. The sun-kissed, leathery texture of their faces, the fullness of mothers, or the withered rags of the elderly are usually on full display. In fact, neither men nor women in the lower classes often manage to keep their garments properly aligned; men below the turamaggie class frequently show off their navels just as their wives do their breasts.
White is as universally the color of Korean garments in winter as in summer; the only difference is that they thicken from cheese-cloth to cotton-padded ones as the cold season advances. The incongruous sight of skaters in what looks like tropical garb, of whole towns of people wading through the snow from which they are barely distinguishable, provokes the wonder of winter visitors. The whiteness of a Korean crowd can be duplicated nowhere on earth. Within the lifetime of any one capable of reading these lines the glimpse of a figure in dark or colored garments anywhere in the peninsula betrayed it at once as that of a foreigner. The first record of any variation from this rule was when, a decade ago, the upper classmen of a mission school in Seoul agreed by resolution to adopt dark European trousers, in order to spare their wives or mothers some of their incessant washing and ironing.
White is just as much the color of Korean clothing in winter as it is in summer; the only difference is that the fabric changes from light cheesecloth to thicker cotton-padded stuff as the cold weather sets in. It's a strange sight to see skaters dressed in what looks like summer clothes, while entire towns of people wade through the snow, barely distinguishable from it, which amazes winter visitors. The whiteness of a Korean crowd can't be found anywhere else on earth. Within the lifetime of anyone who can read this, spotting someone in dark or colorful clothing anywhere on the peninsula instantly marks them as a foreigner. The first record of any change to this was about a decade ago when the upper-class students of a mission school in Seoul agreed to adopt dark European trousers to lighten the constant washing and ironing burden on their wives or mothers.
The sounds of these two occupations are never silent in Korea. Stand on an eminence above any town or city of the land, and to the ears will be borne the similar yet easily distinguishable rat-a-tat-rat-a-tat of a hundred housewives busy with one or the other of their two principal duties. How they attain the snowy whiteness required by their unaffectionate masters by paddling their garments at the edge 12of any mud-hole or trickle of sewage is one of the mysteries of the East; yet not a roadside puddle or a hollowed rock but is turned into a wash-tub, and never is the visible result outwardly anything but spotless purity. In contrast to the dull plump-a-plump of washing paddles is this falsetto tone of ironing, prolonged far into every night. Nay, wake up at any hour and it will be strange if you do not catch the sound of some distant housewife putting the finishing touches on the garments in which her lord will strut forth into the world in the morning. For in Korea the hot iron is not in vogue, except a tiny one used along the sewed or pasted seams. Instead, the clothing is folded over a hardwood cylinder and beaten with two miniature baseball-bats, beaten with an endless persistency that suggests an unsuspected durability in the apparently flimsy material, and with a rhythm that has grown almost musical with centuries of practice.
The sounds of these two tasks are never quiet in Korea. Stand on a hill above any town or city, and you'll hear the familiar yet easily recognizable rat-a-tat-rat-a-tat of a hundred housewives busy with one of their two main responsibilities. How they achieve the snowy whiteness their indifferent masters expect by paddling their clothes at the edge of any mud puddle or trickle of sewage is one of the mysteries of the East; yet there isn't a roadside puddle or a hollowed rock that isn't used as a wash-tub, and the end result is always visibly spotless. In contrast to the dull plump-a-plump of washing paddles is the high-pitched sound of ironing, lasting deep into every night. In fact, wake up at any hour and you’re likely to hear some distant housewife putting the finishing touches on the clothes her husband will wear when he steps out into the world in the morning. In Korea, hot irons aren’t commonly used, except for a small one for seams. Instead, the clothing is folded over a hardwood cylinder and beaten with two tiny baseball bats, struck with such relentless persistence that suggests an unexpected durability in the seemingly flimsy fabric, and with a rhythm that has become almost musical over centuries of practice.
Children are often dressed in colors, and unmarried maidens may wear garments of a green or bluish tinge; but all soon succumb to the omnipresent white. Huge hats not unlike those of men in mourning were once universally required for young women not yet sentenced to the servitude of a husband, that their faces might not be disclosed to the male sex. Missionaries by no means gray in the service recall how half-acres of these basket-hats used to lie stacked up before native churches on days of service. But the old order passes, even in the once Hermit Kingdom, and one may travel far afield now and still perhaps look in vain for any survival of this long prevalent custom. As in Japan, the head-dress of the women of Korea is now a matter of hair, in this case drawn smoothly and tightly down over the scalp, like a cap of oily black velvet, and tied in a compact little knot behind, decorated perhaps with a red cloth rosette and thrust through with what looks almost like one of our new-fashioned nickel-plated lead-pencils.
Children are often dressed in bright colors, and single young women might wear clothes in green or blue shades; but eventually, everyone gives in to the ever-present white. Large hats, similar to those worn by men in mourning, were once a standard requirement for young women who weren't yet bound to a husband, so their faces wouldn’t be revealed to men. Missionaries, far from dull in their service, remember how tons of these basket hats used to be piled up outside local churches on service days. But the old ways are fading, even in the former Hermit Kingdom, and one can now travel far and wide and still struggle to find any trace of this long-standing custom. Just like in Japan, women's headwear in Korea has now become a matter of hair, neatly swept down over the scalp like a cap of shiny black fabric, tied into a small, tidy knot at the back, perhaps adorned with a red cloth rosette and pierced with something resembling our modern nickel-plated mechanical pencils.
The Koreans have never been reduced to any such crude expedient as a bachelor-tax to keep up their marriage-rate. Until very recent years all boys wore their hair in a long braid up to the day they took a wife. Even now this custom survives in some outlying districts, though none yielded more swiftly to the influx of foreign influence. As long as a man wore a braid he was rated a minor; when he approached manhood he became more and more a community butt, and shame and ridicule rarely failed to drive him into an early marriage. Girls, too, had powerful reasons for not long persisting in the dreadful condition of maidenhood, not the least among which was the custom, still widely practised, of burying the body of an unmarried woman in the public highway, to the everlasting shame of her family to its remotest branches. Moreover, a Korean woman is not given a name of her own until she has borne a son, after which she is forever known as “Mother of So-and-So.” Before that her title, even to her husband, is “Yea!” or the slightly more honorable “Yea-bo!” which correspond fairly closely to our affectionate “Heh!” or “Heh, you!”
The Koreans have never resorted to a crude tactic like a bachelor tax to maintain their marriage rate. Until very recently, all boys wore their hair in a long braid until they got married. Even now, this custom still exists in some remote areas, although these places were the first to change due to foreign influences. As long as a man wore a braid, he was considered a minor; as he approached adulthood, he became more of a target for jokes, and shame and ridicule often pushed him into an early marriage. Girls also had strong reasons to avoid the unfortunate status of being single, one of which was the still common practice of burying the body of an unmarried woman in the public road, bringing lasting shame to her family for generations. Additionally, a Korean woman doesn't get her own name until she has a son, after which she is forever known as “Mother of So-and-So.” Before that, her title, even used by her husband, is “Yea!” or the slightly more respectful “Yea-bo!,” which are somewhat comparable to our endearing “Hey!” or “Hey, you!”
13When the happy day comes that is to put an end to the ridicule of his fellows and the shame of his parents, the youth transforms his braid into a topknot, a tightly braided, twisted, and doubled mass of hair an inch in diameter and about three inches high, standing bolt upright in the center of his head, and transfixed with a nickeled or silver ornament similar to that worn by the women. Unlike the cue of the Chinese, forced upon them as a sign of alien subjection, the topknot is the Korean’s badge of manhood, his proudest and most precious possession. Thenceforth one of his most serious problems in life is to protect it from the powers of evil. About his brow is placed the painfully tight band that he is seldom again to be seen without this side of the grave, and he sallies forth under his gleaming new horsehair hat with the masterly air that befits a man of family cares and advantages. To its wearers the Korean top-hat must have become, as even the worst eyesores of human costume will with long use, a thing of beauty; for though many are the men, and myriad the youths, who now cut their hair in Western fashion, numbers even of these still cling to the native hat, while shopkeepers with close-cropped heads, or those whom the evil spirits have outwitted and left bald, may be seen squatting among their wares virtually without clothing but with the discredited head-gear precariously perched upon their bare heads.
13When the joyous day arrives that ends the teasing from his peers and the embarrassment of his parents, the young man styles his hair into a topknot—a tightly woven, twisted mass of hair about an inch thick and three inches high, standing straight up in the center of his head, adorned with a nickel or silver ornament similar to what women wear. Unlike the Chinese cue, which was imposed as a symbol of foreign domination, the topknot is a hallmark of manhood for Koreans, their proudest and most cherished possession. From that moment on, one of his main life challenges is to protect it from evil forces. A painfully tight band is wrapped around his forehead, and he is rarely seen without it from that point on, venturing out under his shiny new horsehair hat with the confident demeanor that suits a man with familial responsibilities and advantages. To its wearers, the Korean top hat must have become, as even the most unattractive aspects of human attire do over time, a thing of beauty; for while many men and countless young people now style their hair in a Western manner, even some of them still prefer the traditional hat. Shopkeepers with closely cropped hair or those whom misfortune has left bald can be seen sitting among their goods, often nearly unclothed but with the now out-of-favor headgear precariously balanced on their bare heads.
Once in a dog’s age even now a country youth turns up at a government or a mission school wearing the braid that not long ago was universal among unmarried males, or, since early marriages are still in vogue, with a topknot; but it is seldom that the end of the first week does not find his fashion changed. Pseudo-pathetic stories still come in from the outlying districts of mothers who wept their eyes red at the cutting of a son’s braid, or of conservative old fathers wrathfully driving from home youths who have sacrificed the topknot that stands for manhood. But the shearing goes steadily on, and thus is passing one of Korea’s most conspicuous idiosyncrasies. The bachelor braid down the back yielded swiftly to foreign influence; a generation hence the topknot, perhaps even the stovepipe screen that surmounts it, may 14be as unknown in the peninsula as the pre-Meiji male head-dress is now in Japan.
Once in a while, even today, a rural young man shows up at a government or mission school wearing the traditional braid that was once common among unmarried guys, or, since early marriages are still popular, with a topknot. But it's rare for him to keep that look for more than a week. There are still sad stories coming in from remote areas of mothers who cried their eyes out at the cutting of their son's braid, or of old conservative fathers angrily kicking out boys who have given up their topknot, which represents manhood. But the haircuts keep happening, and thus one of Korea’s most noticeable traditions is fading away. The bachelor braid down the back quickly gave in to foreign influences; in a generation, the topknot, maybe even the tall hat that goes with it, might be as unfamiliar in the peninsula as the pre-Meiji male hairstyle is now in Japan. 14
If one takes heed not to carry the likeness too far, the Korean might be described as a cross between the Japanese and the Chinese. Some of his traits and customs resemble those of one or the other of his immediate neighbors, but a still greater number seem to be peculiar to himself alone. He builds his house, for example, somewhat like those of Japan; he heats it somewhat after the fashion in China, yet in neither case is the similarity more than approximate. Certainly he is content with as few comforts as any race, with the possible exception of the Chinese, that ever reached the degree of civilization to which he once attained. This, of course, is partly due to the centuries of atrocious misrule under which he lived, when it was unsafe for even the wealthiest of men to attract the ravenous tax-gatherers, turned loose upon the kingdom in rival bands by both king and court, by living in anything more than a thatched mud hovel.
If you don't stretch the comparison too far, you could say that Koreans are a mix of Japanese and Chinese. Some of their traits and customs are similar to those of their neighbors, but many are unique to them. For example, they build their houses a bit like the Japanese do, and they heat them somewhat like the Chinese; however, the similarities are only rough approximations. They certainly make do with as few comforts as any group, except possibly the Chinese, who ever reached the level of civilization that Koreans once attained. This is partly because of the centuries of terrible misrule they endured, during which it was dangerous for even the richest people to attract the greedy tax collectors, who were unleashed on the kingdom in competing groups by both the king and the court, by living in anything more than a thatched mud hut.
Thus it is that even the larger Korean cities are little more than numerous clusters of such hovels, huddled together along haphazard alleyways of dust or mud, except where the hand of the new rulers of the peninsula, or of those Westerners who have been striving for more than three decades to Christianize it, show themselves. The typical Korean house, whether of country or town, is made of adobe bricks or odds and ends of stone completely plastered over, inside and out, with mud. Thus the walls remain, until they crumble or wash away, for neither paint nor whitewash is used to disguise their milk-and-coffee tint. Except in rare cases, or a few special localities, a rice-straw roof covers them, a roof so smooth and almost glossy, so low and nearly flat, that a village suggests a cluster of dead mushrooms. The accepted shape of the dwelling is that of the half of a square, though in its poorer form it may be merely a hut somewhat longer than it is wide, and in the more pretentious cases it sometimes completes the whole square. Whether it does or not, it must be wholly shut off from the outside world, usually by a wall or screen of woven straw as high as the eaves and enclosing a wholly untended dust-bin of a yard between the two ells. The well built and spick and span servants’ houses erected by a missionary community near Seoul were unpopular with the domestics because they looked off across a pretty valley to the mountains, instead of being shut in by the customary mat-fence.
Thus, even the larger cities in Korea are mostly just groups of rundown houses squeezed together along uneven dirt or muddy alleyways, except where the influence of the new rulers of the peninsula or the Westerners trying to Christianize it for over thirty years can be seen. The typical Korean house, whether in the countryside or the city, is made from adobe bricks or various pieces of stone completely covered inside and out with mud. As a result, the walls stay that way until they fall apart or wash away, since no paint or whitewash is used to hide their brownish color. With rare exceptions or in a few specific areas, these houses have a smooth, almost glossy rice-straw roof that is low and nearly flat, giving the village the appearance of a cluster of dead mushrooms. The common shape of the home is that of half a square, but in its poorer form, it may just be a hut that's slightly longer than it is wide, while in more upscale cases, it can complete the whole square. Regardless, it is entirely enclosed from the outside, usually by a wall or a woven straw screen that is as high as the eaves, enclosing a neglected yard that resembles a dust bin between the two sections. The well-constructed and tidy servant quarters built by a missionary community near Seoul were disliked by the servants because they overlooked a beautiful valley leading to the mountains, rather than being surrounded by the usual mat fence.
The outside of the half-square has no openings whatever, but 15presents to the world a perfectly blank face. The inside, on the other hand, is little else than openings, across which may be pushed paper walls or doors somewhat similar to those of Japan. Like the Japanese, the Koreans are squatters rather than sitters, so that the three living-rooms of the average dwelling are barely six feet high, and not much more than that in their other dimensions. The floors are raised somewhat above the level of the ground outside, and are made of stone and mud, like the walls, covered with plaster, or sometimes wood, and this in turn by a heavy, yellow-brown native paper of a consistency between cardboard and oil-cloth. None of the thick soft mats of the Japanese, nor of his cushions or padded quilts, soften life by night or day in a Korean home. When sleep suggests itself, the inmates merely stretch out on the floor on which they have been squatting, thrust a convenient oak brick under their heads, and drift into slumber. Rarely do they make any change of clothing at retiring or rising, the men, as I have said before, often wearing their top-hats all night. Shoes, or, more exactly, slippers, are dropped as the wearers come indoors as unfailingly as in Japan on the ledge of polished wood which forms a cross between a porch and a step along the front of the house. To the Western eye the lack both of space and furniture is surprising. In the center of the house, and usually wide open, is a kind of parlor or sitting-room, at most ten or twelve feet long, flanked at either end by two little living-rooms no longer than they are wide, and the house nowhere has a width much greater than the height of the average Western man. Eating, sleeping, the whole domestic life, in fact, is carried on in a constant proximity exceeding that of our most crowded tenements. It looks more like “playing house,” like a building meant for children to amuse their dolls in, than like the actual lifelong residence of human beings. This impression is enhanced by the miniature furniture, usually as scarce as it is small. There are, of course, no chairs, and no tables unless the little tray with six-inch legs on which food is served be counted as one. If there is a student in the family, or the father is engaged in business, there may be a little writing-desk without legs set flat on the floor; probably there is a chang, or legless chest of drawers, and one of the famous Korean chests, both more than generously bound in brass, or even silver if the family is more prosperous than the exterior of the building ever suggests. That is usually about all, except perhaps a little sewing-machine run by hand, and the few trinkets and inconspicuous odds and ends which the women and children gather about them.
The outside of the half-square has no openings at all, just a completely blank facade. Inside, however, it's mostly open spaces, marked by paper walls or doors somewhat like those in Japan. Like the Japanese, Koreans prefer squatting to sitting, so the three living rooms in an average home are barely six feet high and not much bigger than that in other dimensions. The floors are raised a bit above the ground outside and are made from stone and mud, just like the walls, which are covered with plaster or sometimes wood, topped with a heavy, yellow-brown native paper that feels somewhere between cardboard and oilcloth. There's none of the thick, soft mats, cushions, or padded quilts you find in Japanese homes to soften life day or night in a Korean home. When it’s time to sleep, residents just lie down on the floor where they’ve been squatting, put a convenient oak brick under their heads, and drift off. They rarely change clothes when going to bed or getting up, with men often wearing their top hats all night. Slippers are taken off and left on the polished wooden ledge that acts like a porch or step at the front of the house, just as in Japan. To a Western observer, the lack of space and furniture is surprising. In the center of the house is usually a small parlor or sitting room, at most ten or twelve feet long, with two tiny living rooms at either end that are as long as they are wide. The overall width of the house doesn’t exceed the height of an average Western man. Eating, sleeping, and all daily life occurs in constant close quarters that exceed even our most crowded apartments. It looks more like “playing house,” as if it were built for children to play with their dolls, rather than serving as a lifelong residence for adults. This impression is reinforced by the tiny and scarce furniture. There are no chairs and only one table, which might be the small tray with six-inch legs that food is served on. If there’s a student in the family, or if the father is running a business, there may be a small writing desk set flat on the floor; likely a chang, or legless chest of drawers, and one of the famous Korean chests, both generously bound in brass or even silver if the family is wealthier than the exterior of the building suggests. That’s usually about it, maybe with a little hand-operated sewing machine and the few trinkets and small items that women and children collect around them.
16In the ell, flanking one of the little square living-rooms, is the kitchen, with earth floor and the crudest of stone-and-plaster stoves and implements. Next to this, or perhaps across the dusty, sun-baked yard in the other right-angled extension, is a rough store-room, which commonly alternates in location with an indispensable chamber offering much less privacy and convenience than a Westerner could wish. The walls of the floored rooms are usually covered with plain paper, white or cream-colored, though sometimes figured in a way that recalls both Japan and China. In the yard sit half a dozen or more enormous earthenware jars of the color of chocolate. In one or two of these water is kept; others are filled with preserved or pickled food, particularly the Korean’s favorite delicacy, kimshee, a kind of sauer-kraut of cabbage and turnips generously treated with salt and time and rarely missing from the native menu except in the hot months when it is perforce out of season.
16In the ell beside one of the small square living rooms is the kitchen, with a dirt floor and the simplest stone-and-plaster stove and tools. Next to this, or maybe across the dusty, sun-baked yard in the other right-angled extension, is a rough storeroom, which often swaps places with a necessary room that offers much less privacy and convenience than someone from the West would prefer. The walls of the floored rooms are usually covered with plain paper, white or cream-colored, though sometimes they have patterns that remind one of both Japan and China. In the yard, there are six or more large earthenware jars the color of chocolate. Water is kept in one or two of these; others are filled with preserved or pickled food, especially the Korean favorite, kimshee, a type of sauerkraut made from cabbage and turnips, heavily salted and aged, which is rarely absent from the local menu, except during the hot months when it’s out of season.
When it comes to heating his house the Korean takes complete leave of his island neighbor and turns his face westward. Under the stone floor runs a large flue, the entire length of the house, connected with the kitchen at one end and springing out of the ground in the form of a crude chimney or stovepipe at the other. None of this shivering over a hibachi filled with a few glowing coals for the otherwise comfort-scorning Korean; he will have his dwelling well heated from end to end, not merely his k’ang, or stone bed, after the Chinese fashion, but every nook and corner within doors. While the cooking is going on he may lie on the papered floor and toast himself to his heart’s content; or a bundle of brushwood—almost the only fuel left him in his deforested land—thrust into the business end of the flue in the morning and another at night makes winter a mere laughing matter. It is an ingenious scheme, yet not without its drawbacks. In the blazing summer-time, for instance, there is no way of shutting off the kitchen heat, and the house-warming goes as merrily on as in January. Not that the native seems to mind; he is as immune to a hot bed as to a hard one. But many is the foreign itinerant missionary who, having found lodging on a frosty night with hosts who would outdo themselves in hospitality, has gratefully stretched out on a nicely warmed floor and fallen luxuriously asleep—to awaken half an hour later dripping with perspiration, and toss the night through in a vain effort to shake off the nightmare impression of having brought up in that very section of the after-world which all his earthly efforts had been designed to avoid.
When it comes to heating his house, the Korean completely ignores his island neighbor and faces west. A large flue runs under the stone floor for the entire length of the house, connecting the kitchen at one end and rising out of the ground as a basic chimney or stovepipe at the other. No shivering over a hibachi with a few glowing coals for the comfort-seeking Korean; he ensures his home is well heated from end to end, not just his k’ang, or stone bed, like the Chinese do, but every nook and cranny indoors. While cooking is happening, he can lie on the papered floor and warm himself to his heart’s content; or by putting a bundle of brushwood—almost the only fuel available in his deforested land—into the flue in the morning and another at night, winter becomes a mere joke. It’s a clever system, but it has its downsides. For example, during the blazing summer, there’s no way to shut off the kitchen heat, and the house stays just as warm as it does in January. Not that the local seems to care; he is just as comfortable on a hot bed as on a hard one. But many a foreign itinerant missionary, who found lodging on a cold night with hosts eager to show their hospitality, has gratefully stretched out on a nicely warmed floor and fallen blissfully asleep—only to wake up half an hour later drenched in sweat, tossing the night away in a futile attempt to shake off the nightmarish feeling that he has landed in that very section of the afterlife he had tried so hard to avoid.

Our first view of Seoul, in which the former Temple of Heaven is now a smoking-room in a Japanese hotel garden
Our first view of Seoul, where the old Temple of Heaven is now a smoking area in a Japanese hotel garden.

The interior of a Korean house
The inside of a Korean house

Close-up of a Korean “jicky-coon,” or street porter
Close-up of a Korean “jicky-coon,” or street porter

At the first suggestion of rain the Korean pulls out a little oiled-paper umbrella that fits over his precious horsehair hat
At the first hint of rain, the Korean takes out a small oiled-paper umbrella that fits over his prized horsehair hat.
17Like his neighbors, the Korean eats with chop-sticks, but he uses a flat metal spoon with his rice. This grain is the basis of the better-class meal, but is not so highly polished as in Japan; and it is too costly for the common people, who replace it with cheaper grains, especially millet. What may seem a hardship is really a blessing. The poverty which denies them some of the refinements of the table imposes upon the people of Korea a more healthful diet than that of their island neighbors; in the mass they are more sturdily built; if all other signs are insufficient one can usually distinguish a Korean from a Japanese by the excellence of his teeth. Besides his beloved kimshee, no Korean meal is complete without a pungent sauce made from beans pressed together into what looks like a grindstone and then soaked in brine, a sauce into which at least every other mouthful is dipped. Meat is more often eaten than in Japan; fish, as generally. But tea is not widely used; in its place the average Korean uses plain water, or the water in which barley or millet has been cooked, or, best of all, sool, cousin of the fiery sake or samshu of the neighboring lands. Then come a dozen little side-dishes,—pickled vegetables, some strange, some familiar to us, cucumbers cut up rind and all, green onions, and some distant member of the celery family, all immersed in vinegar-and-oil baths, slices of hot red peppers, tiny pieces of some hardy tuber, brittle sheets of seaweed cooked in oil until they look as if they had been varnished, a jet-black kind of lettuce, and other odds and ends for which there are no equivalents in our language. Sugar is hardly used at all, and the adaptable traveler who learns to be otherwise satisfied with a native dinner usually rises to his feet with a longing for a bit of chocolate or some similar delicacy.
17 Like his neighbors, the Korean eats with chopsticks, but he uses a flat metal spoon with his rice. This grain forms the basis of the higher-class meal, but it's not as highly polished as in Japan; and it's too expensive for common folks, who replace it with cheaper grains, especially millet. What may seem like a hardship is actually a blessing. The poverty that keeps them from some of the finer table items gives the people of Korea a healthier diet than their island neighbors; overall, they are more sturdily built; if all other signs fail, you can usually tell a Korean from a Japanese by the quality of their teeth. Besides his beloved kimshee, no Korean meal is complete without a strong sauce made from beans pressed into what looks like a grindstone and then soaked in brine, a sauce into which at least every other bite is dipped. Meat is eaten more often than in Japan, as is fish. But tea is not widely consumed; instead, the average Korean drinks plain water, or the water used to cook barley or millet, or, best of all, sool, a cousin of the strong sake or samshu from neighboring countries. Then come a dozen little side dishes—pickled vegetables, some strange and some familiar, cucumbers cut up with their skin, green onions, and some distant relative of celery, all immersed in vinegar-and-oil mixtures, slices of hot red peppers, tiny pieces of some hardy tuber, crisp sheets of seaweed cooked in oil until they look glossy, a jet-black type of lettuce, and other odds and ends for which there are no equivalents in our language. Sugar is hardly used at all, and the adaptable traveler who learns to make do with a local dinner usually stands up with a craving for a piece of chocolate or some similar treat.
It is curious how geographical names often persist in our languages of the West long after they have become antiquated and even unknown in the places to which we apply them. The name “Korea,” for instance, means nothing to those who live in the peninsula we call by that term; nor for that matter did the word “Korai” from which we took it ever refer to more than a third of the country, and that long centuries ago. Ever since they absorbed the former kingdom the Japanese have striven to get the world to adopt the native name “Cho-sen” (the “s” is soft), a word already legitimized by several hundred years of use. But the world is notoriously backward in making such changes; perhaps it is suspicious of the motives of Japan, and a bit resentful at her attempt to render whole pages of our geographies out of date. Yet 18there is nothing mysterious or tricky in the wholesale alterations in nomenclature which she has wrought in her new possession, though there is often irksome annoyance. Every province, every city, almost every slightest hamlet has been given a new name; but this has come about as naturally as the Frenchman’s persistent obstinacy in calling a horse a cheval. It is a mere matter of pronunciation. A given Chinese ideograph stands, and has stood for centuries, for a given town or village of Korea. The Korean looks at the character and pronounces it, let us say, “Wonju”; the Japanese knows as well as we know the word “cat” that the proper pronunciation is “Genshu”—and there you are. It is hardly a dispute, but it is at least a new means of harassing the traveler. If he is American or English, or even French or German, for that matter, he will find that nearly all his fellow-countrymen resident in the country, mainly missionaries, have lived there, or been trained by those who have, since before the Japanese took possession, and that they know only the Korean names. If he has a guide-book, which is rather essential, it is almost certainly concocted by the new rulers or under their influence, and insists on using the Japanese names. So do the railway time-tables, all government documents, and the like. Thus he discovers that it is almost impossible to talk with his own people, at least on geographical matters.
It’s interesting how geographical names often stick around in Western languages long after they’ve become outdated or even unknown in the places they refer to. The name “Korea,” for example, means nothing to the people living on the peninsula we refer to by that term; and to be fair, the word “Korai,” from which we derived it, only referred to a third of the country, and that was centuries ago. Ever since they took over the former kingdom, the Japanese have worked hard to get the world to use the native name “Cho-sen” (with a soft “s”), a term that’s been in use for several hundred years. But the world is notoriously slow to make such changes; perhaps it’s wary of Japan’s motives and a little resentful of its efforts to make entire sections of our geography outdated. Yet 18 there’s nothing mysterious or tricky about the extensive name changes they’ve made in their new territory, though it can be frustrating. Every province, every city, almost every tiny village has been given a new name, but this has happened as naturally as the Frenchman’s stubbornness in calling a horse a horse. It’s simply a matter of pronunciation. A particular Chinese character has represented a specific town or village in Korea for centuries. The Korean sees the character and pronounces it, say, “Wonju”; the Japanese knows just like we know the word “cat” that the correct pronunciation is “Genshu”—and there you have it. It’s hardly a dispute, but it certainly makes it a hassle for travelers. If someone is American, English, or even French or German, they’ll find that nearly all their fellow countrymen residing in the area, mainly missionaries, have lived there, or been trained by those who have, since before the Japanese took control, and they only know the Korean names. If they have a guidebook, which is pretty essential, it’s almost certainly written by the new rulers or influenced by them, and insists on using the Japanese names. The same goes for railway timetables, all government documents, and similar materials. So, they’ll find it nearly impossible to communicate with their own people, at least when it comes to geographical matters.
“Have you ever been in Heijo?” he begins, with the purpose of pumping a compatriot for information on that second city of the peninsula.
“Have you ever been to Heijo?” he starts, aiming to get some intel from a fellow countryman about that second city on the peninsula.
“Never heard of it,” replies the old resident, with a puzzled air, whereupon the new-comer gives him up as a hopeless recluse and goes his way, perhaps to learn a few days later that this very man was for ten years the most influential foreigner in that very city, but that to him it has always been, and still is, “Ping Yang.” Thus it goes, throughout the length and breadth of the peninsula, so that the man who would mingle with both sides must know that “Kaijo” is “Song-do,” that “Chemulpo” is “Jinsen,” that what the guide-book and time-table call “Kanko” has always been “Ham-hung” to the missionaries, that every last handful of huts in Korea is known by two separate and distinct names, though the erratic slashes with a weazel-hair brush which stands for it in the ridiculous calligraphy of the East never varies. Long before his education has reached this fine point the traveler will have completely forgotten his resentment at finding, as he rumbles into it at the end of a long summer day, that the city he has known since has early school-days as “Seoul” is now officially called “Keijo.”
“Never heard of it,” replies the old resident, looking puzzled, so the newcomer gives up on him as a hopeless recluse and continues on his way, only to learn a few days later that this very man was the most influential foreigner in that city for ten years, but to him, it has always been, and still is, “Ping Yang.” This happens all over the peninsula, so anyone wanting to connect with both sides must understand that “Kaijo” is “Song-do,” that “Chemulpo” is “Jinsen,” that what the guidebook and timetable refer to as “Kanko” has always been “Ham-hung” to the missionaries, and that every last cluster of huts in Korea has two separate and distinct names, even though the erratic strokes created with a weasel-hair brush that represent it in the ridiculous calligraphy of the East never change. Long before the traveler’s education reaches this advanced point, he will have completely forgotten his annoyance at discovering that as he rolls into it at the end of a long summer day, the city he’s known since childhood as “Seoul” is now officially called “Keijo.”
19It doesn’t greatly matter, however, for the chances are that he has always spoken of it as “Sool,” which is the native fire-water, instead of using the proper pronunciation of “Sow-ohl”; and to learn the new name is easier than to change the old. Our own impressions of what was for more than five centuries the capital of Ch’ao-Hsien, the Land of Morning Calm, and is still the seat of the Government-General of Cho-sen, started at delight, sank very near to keen disappointment, then gradually climbed to somewhere in the neighborhood of calm enjoyment. Seen from afar, the jagged rows of mountain peaks that surround it should quicken the pulse even of the jaded wanderer. The promise that here at last he will find that spell of the ancient East which romancers have enticed him to seek, in the face of his cold better judgment, seems to rise in almost palpable waves from among them. Then he descends at a railway station that might be found in any prairie burg of our central West, and is bumped away by Ford into a city that is flat and mean in its superficial aspect, commonplace in form, and swirling with a fine brown dust. But next morning, or within a day or two of random wandering, according to the pace at which his moods are geared, interest reawakens from its lethargy, and something akin to romance and youthful enthusiasm grows up out of the details of the strange life about him.
19It doesn’t really matter, though, because he probably has always called it “Sool,” which is the local term for fire-water, instead of pronouncing it correctly as “Sow-ohl”; and picking up the new name is easier than changing the old one. Our impressions of what was the capital of Ch’ao-Hsien for more than five centuries, the Land of Morning Calm, and is still the seat of the Government-General of Cho-sen, began with delight, dipped close to sharp disappointment, and then gradually rose to a sense of calm enjoyment. Viewed from a distance, the jagged mountain peaks surrounding it could spark excitement even in the most tired traveler. The expectation that here finally he will discover the allure of the ancient East that story-tellers have lured him to find, despite his rational judgment, seems to come in almost tangible waves from among the mountains. Then he arrives at a train station that could be found in any small town in the central West, and is jostled away by Ford into a city that looks flat and shabby on the surface, ordinary in structure, and filled with fine brown dust. However, by the next morning or within a couple of days of casual exploration, depending on how quickly his moods shift, interest stirs from its slumber, and something like romance and youthful enthusiasm begins to grow from the details of the unusual life around him.
There are, of course, almost no real streets, in the American sense, in the Far East; hence only those wholly unfamiliar with that region will be greatly surprised to find that the “many broad avenues” of Seoul, emphasized by semi-propagandist scribblers, are rather few in number and, with one or two exceptions, are sun-scorched stretches of dust which the rainy season of July and August will turn to oozing mud. But the eye will soon be caught by the queer little shops crowded tightly together along most of them, particularly by the haphazard byways that lead off from them into the maze of mushroom hovels that make up the native city. From out of these dirty alleys comes jogging now and then a gaudy red and gold palanquin in which squats concealed some lady of quality, though these conveyances now are almost confined to weddings and funerals; the miserable little mud hovels disgorge haughty gentlemen in spotless white who would be incredible did not the falsetto rat-a-tat of ironing and the groups of women kneeling along the banks of every slightest stream explain them. There is constant movement in the streets of Keijo, a movement that might almost be called kaleidoscopic, were it not for the whiteness of Korean dress; but it strikes one as rather an aimless movement, a 20leisurely if constant going to and fro that rarely seems to get anywhere. Dignified yangbans, that still numerous class of Korea, and especially of the capital, which in the olden days was rated just below the nobility, strut past in their amber beads and their huge tortoise-shell goggles as if they were really going somewhere; but if one takes the trouble to follow them he will probably find them doubling back on their tracks without having reached any objective. In the olden days they could at least go to the government offices where they pretended to do something for their salaries; since Japan has taken away their sinecures without removing the pride that forbids them to work, there is little else than this random strolling left for them to do.
There are almost no real streets, in the American sense, in the Far East; so only those completely unfamiliar with the region will be surprised to discover that the “many broad avenues” of Seoul, highlighted by somewhat propagandistic writers, are actually quite few and, with one or two exceptions, mostly just sun-baked stretches of dust that turn into muddy messes during the rainy season in July and August. However, your attention will quickly be drawn to the quirky little shops packed closely together along most of them, especially along the random side streets that lead into the maze of ramshackle homes that make up the local city. Once in a while, a brightly colored red and gold palanquin will bounce out of these dirty alleys, carrying some lady of status, although these rides are now mostly seen at weddings and funerals; the shabby little mud huts spill out impeccably dressed gentlemen in pristine white who seem unbelievable unless you hear the high-pitched rat-a-tat of ironing and see groups of women kneeling by even the tiniest streams. The streets of Keijo are always bustling, a movement that could almost be called kaleidoscopic if it weren't for the prevalence of white Korean attire; but it feels more like aimless movement, a leisurely yet constant back-and-forth that rarely seems to lead anywhere. Dignified yangbans, a still numerous class in Korea, especially in the capital, once ranked just below the nobility, strut by wearing their amber beads and large tortoise-shell glasses as if they are genuinely going somewhere; but if you take the time to follow them, you'll likely find they are just retracing their steps without any actual destination. In the past, they at least could head to government offices where they pretended to work for their salaries; since Japan has stripped them of their no-show jobs without removing the pride that prevents them from getting actual work, all that's left for them to do is this aimless wandering.
In contrast to this numerous gentry, outdistanced by modern changes, there are sweating coolies lugging this or that, bulls hidden under mounds of brown-red brushwood from some far-off hillside, sleek-haired women slinking by with an almost apologetic air, many of them with the uncovered, sun-browned breasts somewhat less general in the capital than elsewhere, here and there a Korean pony, cantankerous with his full malehood, all streaming to and fro between an unbroken gauntlet of languid shopkeepers in their fly-trap “household” caps, of mangy dogs and dirty children. “Old-timers” will tell you that this was not so long ago all there was to Seoul, except inside the several big palace compounds, now so uninhabited; that walking, still much in vogue among the Koreans, was for the overwhelming majority the only means of getting about the city. Then there were no rickshaws, not over-numerous even to-day after twelve years of wholly Japanese rule; then none of the little dust- or mud-floored tram-cars, now so crowded, bumped along the principal avenues; certainly no battered and raucous-voiced automobiles scattered terror among the placid foot-going population. It is not difficult to picture the comparative silence of that bygone Seoul, with slipper-clad footsteps pattering noiselessly through the dust, or the mild clumping of that cross between the Dutch wooden shoe and the Japanese geta still worn in muddy weather, punctuated now and then by the booming of a mammoth bell, the mild hubbub of passing royalty surrounded by shrieking out-runners, and the incessant accompaniment of the falsetto rat-a-tat of ironing.
In contrast to this large number of gentry, left behind by modern changes, there are sweaty workers carrying various loads, bulls hidden under piles of brown-red brush from some distant hillside, sleek-haired women walking by with an almost apologetic demeanor, many of them with uncovered, sun-browned breasts somewhat less common in the capital than elsewhere. Here and there, a Korean pony, feisty with his full masculinity, moves through an unbroken line of lazy shopkeepers in their fly-trap “household” caps, along with scruffy dogs and dirty children. “Old-timers” will tell you that not too long ago, this was all there was in Seoul, except inside the several large palace compounds, now so empty; that walking, still much favored among Koreans, was the primary way most people got around the city. Back then, there were no rickshaws, which are still not very common today after twelve years of total Japanese rule; there were no little dust- or mud-floored trams, now so crowded, bouncing along the main roads; and definitely no battered, loud automobiles that scattered terror among the calm pedestrians. It’s easy to imagine the relative silence of that past Seoul, with slipper-clad footsteps quietly pattering through the dust, or the gentle thump of that cross between Dutch wooden shoes and Japanese geta still worn in muddy weather, occasionally interrupted by the booming of a massive bell, the mild commotion of passing royalty surrounded by shouting attendants, and the constant background sound of the high-pitched rat-a-tat of ironing.
With the definite coming of the Japanese much of that ancient Seoul has departed. The great wall that enclosed the city has been largely leveled, for the Koreans, according to their new rulers, can only fight behind walls. Only a pair of the imposing city gates remain, and these as mere monuments instead of entrances and exits. The Independence 21Arch built to celebrate the end of paying tribute to Peking stands shabby, cracked, and blistered in a bed of sand in the ragged outskirts. Rubbish and worse litter the dark, wooden-slatted enclosure in which the mighty bell that once transmitted royal commands sits drunkenly and dejected on the ground. Vagabonds build their nests beneath the Oriental roof that shelters the stone-turtle monument of which the city was once so proud; the magnificent Altar of Heaven has become a garden ornament within the grounds of the principal hotel, and is generously furnished with Japanese settees and capacious cuspidors bearing the railway-hotel insignia. Of the three principal palaces one is a mere wilderness of weeds and vacant-eyed edifices; another houses the weak-minded remnant of the once royal family and has bequeathed most of its grounds to museum, botanical, and zoölogical purposes; the third, and most historic, is being completely hidden from the city by a mammoth modern building designed to become the headquarters of the Governor-General.
With the definite arrival of the Japanese, much of ancient Seoul has disappeared. The great wall that once surrounded the city has mostly been torn down because, according to their new rulers, Koreans can only defend themselves from behind walls. Only a couple of the impressive city gates remain, serving as mere monuments rather than actual entrances and exits. The Independence 21 Arch, built to celebrate the end of tribute to Beijing, stands worn down, cracked, and blistered in a patch of sand on the rundown outskirts. Trash and worse clutter the dark, wooden enclosure where the mighty bell, which once broadcast royal commands, now sits drunkenly and dejected on the ground. Homeless people have taken shelter underneath the Oriental roof that covers the stone-turtle monument of which the city was once so proud; the magnificent Altar of Heaven has become a garden decoration within the grounds of the main hotel, furnished with Japanese couches and large spittoons marked with the railway-hotel logo. Of the three main palaces, one is just a wild growth of weeds and empty buildings; another now holds the mentally incapacitated remnant of the once royal family and has turned most of its grounds into a museum, botanical garden, and zoo; the third, and most historic, is being completely concealed from the city by a massive modern building intended to serve as the headquarters of the Governor-General.
One might almost assume that a policy of blotting out the visible reminders of the old independent Korea had been adopted by the new rulers. Yet it is hardly that, I fancy, but mainly the utilitarian sense of modern improvement which is showing such small respect for the monuments of bygone Cho-sen. The Japanese are ardent in their efforts to make Seoul a city in the modern sense—the modern Western sense, I could have said, for their new structures are hardly copied from Japan. Imposing buildings that might have been transported from our own large cities are growing up for the housing of banks and important firms and government offices. There is already one genuinely asphalted street; new parks have been laid out where only wilderness or rubbish heaps were before. Besides the big central one there are adequate branch post-offices in every section of the city; police stations at every turn keep a watchful eye out for new candidates to the mammoth new penitentiary, built on the latest approved model, out near the “Peking Pass.” After their lights the new rulers are steadily improving the material aspect of the city, as of the whole peninsula. It would be too much to expect them to improve certain personal habits and domestic customs beyond the point which the Japanese themselves have reached, so that some forms of uncleanliness and undress, for instance, which a new American colony would quickly be forced to eradicate, have been given no attention.
One could almost think that the new rulers have chosen to erase the visible reminders of old independent Korea. However, I believe it's more about a practical approach to modern improvement, which shows little regard for the monuments of past Cho-sen. The Japanese are passionate about transforming Seoul into a modern city—in the Western sense, I might add, since their new buildings are not really modeled after Japan. Impressive structures that could have been moved from our major cities are rising up to house banks, important businesses, and government offices. There's already one truly asphalted street; new parks have been created where there used to be wilderness or piles of trash. Besides the large central park, there are also sufficient branch post offices in every part of the city; police stations at every corner keep a vigilant watch for potential residents of the massive new prison, built to the latest standards, located near the “Peking Pass.” In their own way, the new rulers are consistently improving the physical aspects of the city and the entire peninsula. It would be unrealistic to expect them to enhance certain personal habits and home customs beyond the level that the Japanese have reached, so some issues of uncleanliness and inappropriate clothing, for instance, which a new American community would quickly address, have been overlooked.
The new rulers once planned even greater changes in the old city. They set about with the apparent intention of virtually moving it, or 22at least the commercial center of it, down nearer the River Han, in a section they called Ryuzan. There they built the railway headquarters and blocks of brick residences for the employees. A stone palace for the mikado’s viceroy was erected, streets laid out, and improvements impossible in the crowded portion of the city were projected. But commerce has a way of choosing its own localities; the Koreans are nothing if not conservative; local gossip has it that when Prince Ito was taken down to see his new residence he remarked to his well meaning subordinates that they might live down there in the swamp if they wished, but that he for one would stay in town. The prince is well known to have been no recluse and hermit who would deny himself the soft pleasures of cities. In the end his choice proved wise, for it is a rare rainy season that does not wipe out scores of native huts down along the Han and encroach upon the unused and isolated palace he rejected. The railway headquarters, residences, and school remain, and trains halt for an exasperatingly long time at Ryuzan station, so near that of Nandaimon to which most travelers are bound, almost as if the officials would vent their pique at having their will thwarted; but even the Japanese residents have preferred the old city. Along its southern edge, under the brow of Nansan Hill, dwell and trade that quarter of the fourth of a million of population which wears kimonos and getas, and the stroller down “Honmachidori” and its adjacent streets, narrow, crowded, busy, and colorful as a thoroughfare of old Japan, could easily imagine himself back in the Island Empire, far from the languid, white-clad throngs of the Land of Morning Calm.
The new rulers once planned even bigger changes for the old city. They seemed intent on moving it, or at least its commercial center, closer to the River Han, in an area they called Ryuzan. There, they built the railway headquarters and brick apartment blocks for the workers. They constructed a stone palace for the emperor’s representative, laid out new streets, and proposed improvements that weren’t possible in the crowded part of the city. However, commerce tends to choose its own locations; the Koreans are quite conservative; and local gossip suggests that when Prince Ito was taken to see his new residence, he told his well-meaning subordinates that they could live in the swamp if they wanted, but he would stay in town. The prince was known for enjoying the comforts of city life, not as a reclusive hermit. In the end, his choice was wise, because it's rare for a rainy season to pass without flooding many native huts along the Han and encroaching on the unused, isolated palace he turned down. The railway headquarters, residences, and school remain, and trains stop for an annoyingly long time at Ryuzan station, which is so close to Nandaimon, where most travelers head, almost as if the officials are venting their frustration at having their plans thwarted. But even the Japanese residents have chosen the old city. Along its southern edge, beneath Nansan Hill, lives and trades a quarter of the city's population of a quarter of a million who wear kimonos and getas. A stroll down “Honmachidori” and its surrounding streets, narrow, crowded, busy, and colorful like a thoroughfare of old Japan, could easily make one feel transported back to the Island Empire, far from the languid, white-clad crowds of the Land of Morning Calm.
CHAPTER II
Korean sights and traditions
It was our good fortune to dwell out over the hills beyond Seoul rather than in the hot and often breathless city itself. The half-hour walk led up past the big granite Bible School, along a little stream with its inevitable clothes-paddling women, flanked the grave-mound of a little prince, then climbed steeply over another half-wooded ridge from which stretched a wide-spreading mountainous view, everywhere deep green except for the broad brown streak of the River Han and here and there a mushroom patch of village. An American mission college was building in a big hilly pine-grove that owed its preservation to the tomb of a king’s concubine. Pines as fantastic and sturdy as any in Japan stood out against the sky-line; here and there a group of stinking chestnut-trees kept them company. Before they were granted this semi-sacred site the missionaries from our almost mythological land of “Mi-guk” had to agree not to build anywhere overlooking the grave; they had already been asked to close a path used as a short cut by students and an occasional faculty member, because it ran along the brow of the hill above the tomb. To look down upon a royal burial site is the height of disrespect in Korea, hence they are all arranged after a fixed pattern designed to avoid this sacrilege.
It was our good luck to live out over the hills beyond Seoul instead of in the hot and often stuffy city itself. The half-hour walk took us past the large granite Bible School, along a small stream with its usual clothes-washing women, along the grave mound of a young prince, and then steeply climbed over another wooded ridge. From there, we had a wide view of the mountains, all deep green except for the broad brown line of the River Han and occasional patches of villages. An American mission college was building in a large hilly pine grove that had been preserved because of the tomb of a king’s concubine. Pines as impressive and strong as any in Japan stood out against the skyline, while here and there a group of smelly chestnut trees kept them company. Before they were allowed this semi-sacred site, the missionaries from our almost legendary land of “Mi-guk” had to agree not to build anywhere that overlooked the grave; they had already been asked to close a path that was a shortcut for students and occasional faculty members, as it ran along the edge of the hill above the tomb. Looking down on a royal burial site is considered extremely disrespectful in Korea, so they are all arranged in a specific pattern designed to avoid this offense.
Out beyond the Todaimon, or East Gate, on the opposite side of the city, is the tomb of a more famous queen; but we preferred what we called our own, which is identical in form and size, and in a solitude much less often broken. Besides, “ours” really contained the mortal remains, while even the finger and a few bones which were all that remained after the brutal assassination and burning of Korea’s last queen were now buried elsewhere. Quite like ours are all the royal graves scattered up and down the peninsula of Cho-sen, in the several regions where succeeding dynasties built their capitals, flourished for a while, and fell, so that leisurely to visit it was worth a hasty glimpse of many others.
Out past the Todaimon, or East Gate, on the other side of the city, is the tomb of a more famous queen; but we preferred what we called our own, which is just like hers in shape and size, and in a quiet place that's disturbed much less often. Plus, “ours” actually held the remains, while even the finger and a few bones that were all that was left after the brutal assassination and burning of Korea’s last queen were now buried somewhere else. Just like ours, all the royal graves are scattered throughout the peninsula of Cho-sen, in the various regions where different dynasties built their capitals, thrived for a time, and then fell, making it worth taking the time to visit even if you just got a quick look at many others.
We could wander up over the pine-clad hill to the grave, for all the 24injunction against it; things are not so strict as all that in Korea, unless something Japanese is involved. But it was more convenient, and not merely more respectful, to approach the sanctuary from the bottom. On a level space in the forest, wholly cleared of trees but thick with grass, there was first of all the caretaker’s residence, a high-walled compound set off in the edge of the woods to the left. In a direct line down the center of the grassy rectangle stood first a torii, a square arch made of three light tree-trunks painted red, the upper crosspiece decorated with crude and fanciful carvings, a gateway without contiguous fence or wall. The Koreans are sensitive about the use of this symbolic entrance to their royal tombs; the caretaker of the little prince’s tomb we passed on our way in or out of Seoul told us one day, when we found that arch newly closed with barbed wire, that we might still pass through the grounds, but not beneath the torii. A hundred feet or more through this isolated entrance to her last resting-place stood the concubine’s prayer-house, so to speak—a large building by Korean standards, with a roof of highly colored tiles and four flaring gable-peaks, along which sat as many rows of porcelain monkeys to guard against evil spirits, as is the Korean custom. Through the many holes that had been torn by time or inquisitive fingers in the oily paper serving as glass between the slats of the many padlocked doors, one could dimly make out a bare wooden floor, scattered with dust and bits of rubbish, and a bare table-like altar on which, no doubt, boiled rice and other foods are at certain intervals offered to the spirit of the dead. It was plain that no such thoughtfulness had been shown recently, for dust and dinginess and faded paint were the most conspicuous features of the edifice, inside and out.
We could hike up the pine-covered hill to the grave, despite any restrictions; things aren't that strict in Korea, unless something Japanese is involved. However, it was easier—and not just more respectful—to approach the sanctuary from below. In a flat area of the forest, completely cleared of trees but dense with grass, there was the caretaker’s residence, a high-walled compound located at the edge of the woods to the left. Right down the center of the grassy area stood a torii, a square arch made of three lightweight tree trunks painted red, with a top crosspiece adorned with crude and fanciful carvings, acting as an entrance without any surrounding fence or wall. The Koreans are particular about using this symbolic entrance for their royal tombs; the caretaker of the little prince’s tomb we passed on our way in or out of Seoul once told us that even though that arch was recently secured with barbed wire, we could still walk through the grounds, but not under the torii. A hundred feet or more through this isolated entrance to her final resting place stood the concubine’s prayer house, so to speak—a large building by Korean standards, featuring a roof of brightly colored tiles and four protruding gable peaks, along which there were rows of porcelain monkeys to ward off evil spirits, as is the Korean custom. Through the many holes worn by time or curious hands in the oily paper serving as glass between the slats of the numerous padlocked doors, one could faintly see a bare wooden floor, covered with dust and bits of trash, and a simple table-like altar where, no doubt, boiled rice and other foods are offered at certain times to the spirit of the deceased. It was clear that no such care had been shown in recent times, as dust, dinginess, and faded paint were the most noticeable features of the building, both inside and out.
Two smaller but similar chapels flanked this main building, behind which the grass-rug-ed ground rose gradually to the burial mound, another hundred feet back and some ten feet high. In front of this plain grass-covered hillock stood a huge stone lantern, like those in Japanese temple grounds, in the opening of which the reverent or the superstitious sometimes place offerings of rice. Directly behind this graceful receptacle rose what we of the West would call a tombstone, a high upright granite slab standing on a big stone turtle and carved with Chinese ideographs briefly extolling the departed lady’s alleged virtues. More fantastic still were the figures about the mound, duplicated on either side. First came two large stone horses, such as might be chiseled by some aspiring but untalented school-boy. Then a pair of stone men, priests, or gods, recalling similar figures in the ruins 25of Tiahuanaco beyond Lake Titicaca, gazed at each other with a sort of smirking, semi-skeptical benignity. Two lions, two rams, and two mythological beasts, even more crudely fashioned than the rest, completed the menagerie, all these last with their backs turned to the mound, out of respect for the departed. Finally an ancient stone wall with tiled roof threw a protective semicircle close about all this at the rear, beyond which the rather thin pine forest, gnarled and bent with age, climbed the hill-slopes across which only disrespectful mortals ever pass.
Two smaller but similar chapels were located next to this main building, behind which the grassy ground gradually rose to the burial mound, another hundred feet back and about ten feet high. In front of this plain grass-covered hill stood a huge stone lantern, like those found in Japanese temple grounds, where the reverent or superstitious sometimes leave offerings of rice. Directly behind this elegant receptacle stood what we in the West would call a tombstone—a tall upright granite slab set on a large stone turtle, engraved with Chinese characters briefly praising the deceased lady’s supposed virtues. Even more fantastical were the figures around the mound, mirrored on either side. First were two large stone horses, resembling something carved by a clumsy schoolboy. Next came a pair of stone men, priests or gods, echoing similar figures from the ruins of Tiahuanaco by Lake Titicaca, gazing at each other with a sort of smirking, semi-skeptical friendliness. Two lions, two rams, and two mythological beasts, even more crudely crafted than the others, completed the collection, all of them facing away from the mound out of respect for the deceased. Lastly, an ancient stone wall with a tiled roof formed a protective semicircle around all of this at the back, beyond which a rather sparse pine forest, gnarled and bent with age, climbed the hillside that only disrespectful mortals ever traverse.
About the only Korean thing which moves rapidly is a funeral, and even this may have been a concession to the incessantly sweltering summer. We met one rather frequently in the streets of Seoul,—a barbarously decorated palanquin in blazing reds and yellows, borne by eight or ten coolies in nondescript garb, who jog-trotted as if in haste to be out of reach of the evil spirit that had laid low the inert burden inside. If the latter had been a man of standing and sufficient wealth, there were two palanquins, the second bearing the actual remains, the first a false bier meant to deceive the wicked beings of the invisible world. The rest of the procession was made up of priests in fantastic robes and flaring head-dresses, leaning back at contented ease in their rickshaws, and a varying string of relatives and perhaps friends, most of them in sackcloth and on foot. Just where these incongruously hurrying cortèges finally brought up we never learned to a certainty until we ourselves moved out over the hills.
About the only thing in Korea that moves quickly is a funeral, and even that might have been a response to the constantly hot summer. We often saw one in the streets of Seoul—a garishly decorated palanquin in bright reds and yellows, carried by eight or ten coolies in plain clothing, who jogged along as if they were in a hurry to escape the evil spirit that had brought down the lifeless body inside. If the deceased was a person of prominence and wealth, there would be two palanquins: the second carrying the actual body, and the first being a fake bier meant to fool the wicked beings of the unseen world. The rest of the procession consisted of priests in elaborate robes and extravagant headgear, reclining comfortably in their rickshaws, along with a mix of relatives and possibly friends, most of whom were in sackcloth and walking. We never really found out exactly where these oddly rushed funerals ended up until we ourselves moved out over the hills.
In a hollow not far from our suburban residence rose the ugly red brick chimney of what we at first took to be a small factory, but which turned out to be one of the several crematories in the outskirts of Keijo. Across the valley below us, by the little dirt road that wandered through the flooded rice-fields, came several funeral processions a day, announcing themselves by the shrieking auditory distresses which the Koreans regard as music. The unseemly pace may have slackened somewhat by this time for it is nearly five miles around the hills by the route that even man-drawn vehicles must follow; but the clashing of colors was still in full evidence, standing out doubly distinct against the velvety green of newly transplanted rice. Now and again a procession halted entirely for a few moments, while the carriers and pullers stretched themselves out in the road itself or along the scanty roadside above the flooded fields. We drifted down one day to one of them that was making an unusually long halt, and found the 26chief mourner, a lean old lady of viperous tongue, in a noisy altercation with the carriers over the price of their services. But those who halted, or indulged in such recriminations along the way were, no doubt, of the class that could not pay for unchecked speed.
In a hollow not far from our suburban home stood the ugly red brick chimney of what we initially thought was a small factory, but which turned out to be one of several crematories on the outskirts of Keijo. Across the valley below us, along the little dirt road that meandered through the flooded rice fields, several funeral processions passed by each day, announcing themselves with the loud wails that Koreans consider music. The pace may have slowed down somewhat by now since it’s nearly five miles around the hills by the route that even man-drawn vehicles must take; however, the vibrant colors were still vivid, standing out even more against the lush green of freshly transplanted rice. Occasionally, a procession would stop completely for a few moments, as the carriers and pullers rested in the road or along the narrow edge of the flooded fields. One day, we wandered over to a procession that was taking an unusually long break, and found the chief mourner, a thin elderly lady with a sharp tongue, in a heated argument with the carriers over the price of their services. But those who stopped or engaged in such disputes along the way were likely the kind who couldn't afford to pay for faster service.
Several times, too, when whim took us to town over the high hill from which an embracing view of Seoul was to be had, we saw processions returning. Then they were quite different. The chief burden, naturally, had been left behind, and the palanquins are collapsible, so that mourners and carriers straggled homeward by the steep direct route as the spirit moved them, the latter at least contentedly smoking their long tiny pipes, and musing perhaps on the probability of soon finding another victim. But the end and consummation of all this gaudy parading to and fro remained to us only an ugly red brick chimney, standing idle against its hilly background or emitting leisurely strands of yellowish-black smoke, according to the demand for its gruesome services.
Several times, whenever we felt like going to town over the high hill that offered a sweeping view of Seoul, we saw processions returning. At that point, they looked quite different. The main focus, of course, had been left behind, and the palanquins were collapsible, so the mourners and carriers ambled homeward by the steep, direct route as they pleased, with the latter at least contentedly smoking their long, thin pipes and perhaps contemplating the likelihood of soon finding another victim. But the grand finale of all this flashy parading back and forth left us with only an ugly red brick chimney, standing idle against the hilly backdrop or releasing slow streams of yellowish-black smoke, depending on the demand for its grim services.
Then one evening curiosity got the better of our dislike for unpleasant scenes, and we strolled out to the uninviting hollow. In it, a little above the level of the plain, sat a commonplace brick building with half a dozen furnace-chambers not unlike those of a brick-kiln. Several Koreans of low class, stripped to the waist, were languidly working about it, now and then producing discordant noises, which was their manner of humming a tune. Close before the principal building stood a smaller one, from which rose the loud chanting of a single voice that would have won no fame on the Western operatic stage. This, we learned, belonged to the priest whose duty it was to give each client the spiritual send-off to which he was entitled by the price of admission to the furnaces. The cost of cremating a body, explained one of the workmen, was twelve yen (nearly six dollars), but it included an hour-long prayer by the priest. The latter was too steadily engaged in his duties to be interrupted, but the cremators were openly delighted at the attention of foreigners, and at the opportunity of helping us make the most of what they called our “sight-see.” Into the ears of the articulate member of our party, born in Korea, they poured the details of their calling without reserve. That, inside the rude straw-mat screen which stood between the house of prayer and the door to the ovens, had come early in the afternoon, they explained, but he was only a poor man and had to give precedence to his betters. We peered over the top of the screen and saw a corpse completely wrapped in straw and fastened to a board with ropes of similar 27material. Did we care to see what was left of the last job? one of the coolies wished to know. It was time that was finished, anyway. He led the way to the back of the furnaces, opened an iron door, and, catching up a crude, heavy iron rake, hauled out half a peck of charred bones and ashes. This, he explained, unnecessarily, as he turned up one still glowing remnant of bone after another, was a rib, that was a piece of what the man walked on, and so forth. It was a rich man, he chattered on—to be rich in his eyes did not, of course, imply being a millionaire—and he had been sent here all the way from Fusan. The dead man’s relatives, he continued, as he carelessly raked the still smoking débris into a tin pan and set it aside to cool, had paid him to keep some of the ashes for them, instead of dumping them in the common ash-heap. Rich people always did that. But it was time to get that other fellow there out of the way, and go home to supper.
Then one evening, curiosity got the better of our dislike for unpleasant scenes, and we walked out to the uninviting hollow. In it, a little above the level of the plain, stood a typical brick building with half a dozen furnace chambers that looked like those in a brick kiln. Several lower-class Koreans, stripped to the waist, were lazily working around it, occasionally making jarring noises, which was their way of humming a tune. Right in front of the main building was a smaller one, from which rose the loud chanting of a single voice that wouldn’t have gained any fame in Western opera. This, we learned, belonged to the priest who was supposed to give each client the spiritual send-off they were entitled to by the price of admission to the furnaces. One of the workers explained that the cost of cremating a body was twelve yen (almost six dollars), but it included an hour-long prayer from the priest. The priest was too focused on his work to be interrupted, but the cremators were openly pleased with the attention from foreigners and the chance to help us make the most of what they called our “sight-see.” To the most talkative member of our group, who was born in Korea, they shared the details of their work openly. That person, who had arrived early in the afternoon, they explained, was just a poor man and had to give way to his betters. We peeked over the top of the screen and saw a corpse completely wrapped in straw and tied to a board with ropes made of the same material. Did we want to see what was left of the last job? one of the workers asked. It was time it was done anyway. He led us to the back of the furnaces, opened an iron door, and, grabbing a crude, heavy iron rake, pulled out half a peck of charred bones and ashes. This, he explained unnecessarily, as he turned up one still glowing fragment of bone after another, was a rib, that was a piece of what the man walked on, and so on. It was a rich man, he chattered on—being rich in his eyes didn’t mean being a millionaire—and he had been sent here all the way from Fusan. The dead man’s relatives, he continued, as he carelessly raked the still smoking debris into a tin pan and set it aside to cool, had paid him to keep some of the ashes for them instead of dumping them in the common ash-heap. Rich people always did that. But it was time to get that other guy there out of the way and head home for supper.
“What did he die of?” we asked, as the straw screen was thrown aside and the planked corpse fully disclosed to view.
“What did he die from?” we asked, as the straw screen was pushed aside and the wooden body was completely revealed.
“Of a stomachache,” replied one of the two coolies, as they caught up plank, straw wrapping, and all, and thrust the last “job” into the furnace, then salvaged the plank with a dexterous twist and jerk. No flames were visible in the depositing-chamber itself; the heat was applied externally, so to speak, perhaps as a sort of survival of the olden days when Korean dead were wrapped in a mat and left to bake and fester in the sun. We were turning away, satisfied for a lifetime with one “sight-see” of that kind, when a sound, so out of keeping with the matter-of-fact tone of the workmen as to be startling, brought us back again. Out of the semi-darkness had appeared a Korean of the peasant or porter class, past forty, lean and sun-browned; and with a wail that had in it something of an animal in extreme distress, he flung himself at the furnace door as if he would have torn it open and rescued the form it had for ever swallowed up. We had never suspected the rank-and-file Korean capable of showing such poignant grief. Nor was it seemly in one of his standing, evidently, for almost at his second wail the three carriers who had brought the body rushed down upon him and demanded forthwith the price of their services. Their strident bargaining rose high above the dismal, discordant droning of the so-much-a-yard prayers that had never once ceased during our stay. The surly porters made it plain that there was no time for vain mourning while the serious matter of their hire was unsettled.
“Of a stomachache,” replied one of the two laborers as they gathered up the plank, straw wrapping, and all, and pushed the last “job” into the furnace, then skillfully retrieved the plank with a quick twist and pull. No flames were visible in the chamber itself; the heat was applied from the outside, so to speak, maybe a leftover from the old days when Korean bodies were wrapped in mats and left to bake in the sun. We were about to turn away, satisfied for a lifetime with that one “sight-see,” when a sound that completely clashed with the mundane work of the laborers caught us off guard and brought us back. From the semi-darkness emerged a Korean man from the peasant or porter class, over forty, lean and sunburned; and with a cry that held an almost animal-like distress, he flung himself at the furnace door as if trying to pry it open and rescue the body it had permanently consumed. We never thought the average Korean could express such deep grief. It seemed inappropriate for someone of his status, evidently, because almost immediately after his second wail, the three carriers who had brought the body rushed down on him, demanding payment for their services right away. Their loud bargaining drowned out the dreary, dissonant chanting of the prayers that had been ongoing throughout our stay. The grumpy porters made it clear that there was no time for pointless mourning while their payment was still unresolved.
“He was my older brother,” wept the man, “the last of my family. Have I any one left? Not one. And now....”
“He was my older brother,” the man cried, “the last of my family. Is there anyone left for me? Not a single person. And now....”
28The unsatisfied carriers were still cruelly bullyragging him when we left, and the sound of their quarreling voices, intermingled with the never ending droning of the priest, came to us through the night after we were well on our way home.
28The unhappy carriers were still harshly harassing him when we left, and the noise of their arguing voices, mixed with the constant drone of the priest, reached us through the night long after we were on our way home.
It is only the Buddhists who cremate by choice in Korea, and by no means the majority of the people are of that faith. Many are mere ancestor-worshipers, or placaters of evil spirits, or have a mixture of several Oriental faiths and superstitions which they themselves could not unravel. The non-Buddhists bury their dead, and thereby hangs, as in China, a serious problem. For definitely circumscribed public cemeteries will not do. The repose of the departed and the fortune and happiness of his descendants depends upon the proper choice of a burial-place, which is by no means a simple matter. It calls for the services of sorceresses, necromancers, and other expensive professionals; it may take much time; and the final indications may point to a most unlikely and inconvenient spot. Green mounds, wholly unmarked except in the rarest of cases, but each known to the descendants whose most solemn duty it is to tend them, cover hundreds of great hillsides throughout the peninsula, to the detriment of agriculture, Korea’s main occupation. The Japanese took the Western utilitarian point of view and ordered prescribed areas set aside for graveyards; but this was one of the most hated of their reforms, and the right to lay away their dead at least in private cemeteries has once more been granted to the Koreans.
It’s only Buddhists who choose to cremate their dead in Korea, and they aren’t the majority. Many people practice ancestor worship or try to appease evil spirits, or they mix different Eastern beliefs and superstitions that they can’t untangle. Non-Buddhists typically bury their dead, which creates a significant issue, similar to what is seen in China. Public cemeteries that are strictly defined won’t suffice. The peace of the deceased and the wellbeing of their descendants rely on choosing the right burial place, which is definitely not straightforward. This often requires the help of witches, necromancers, and other costly specialists; it can take a lot of time, and the final decision may lead to an unexpected and inconvenient location. Green mounds, mostly unmarked except on rare occasions, dot the hillsides across the peninsula, known only to the descendants who feel it’s their solemn duty to care for them, which negatively impacts agriculture, Korea’s main industry. The Japanese adopted a practical Western approach and designated specific areas for cemeteries; however, this was one of the most unpopular reforms, and the Koreans have regained the right to bury their dead, even in private cemeteries.
Tucked away in the pine-clad hills about us were several little Buddhist monasteries. The last word is deceiving, however, for there was hardly anything monasterial about these semi-isolated retreats. In theory the Buddhist monks and priests of Korea live in celibacy; in practice few even of their most devout coreligionists pretend to believe that they do so. About the tile-roofed clusters of buildings, varying mainly in pretentiousness from the thatched homes of laymen, there was no dearth of women and children; and the monks were the last in the world to deny themselves the pleasure of wandering to the near-by city or up and down the country as the mood came upon them. The brilliant saffron robe that distinguishes the followers of the Way in central Asia, and adds so vividly to the picturesqueness of lands farther west, is unknown in Korea. A shaven head in place of the precious topknot is almost the monk’s only difference in appearance from the ordinary layman; when whim or a sincere desire to tread 29in the path marked out by Gautama sends him out into the Korean world, the distinguishing hat of woven ratan may be superimposed, but even the symbolic pretense of a begging-bowl hardly marks him out from his more toilsome fellow-countrymen. For a long period in the history of Korea, Buddhist monks were rated lower in the social scale than even the peasants of the fields, and this attitude toward them has survived, perhaps unconsciously, in a marked lack of deference, almost an indifference to them, except in their official capacity, or among an unusually superstitious minority.
Tucked away in the pine-covered hills around us were several small Buddhist monasteries. The last word is misleading, though, because there wasn’t much “monastery” about these semi-secluded retreats. In theory, the Buddhist monks and priests of Korea are supposed to live celibately; however, in practice, very few even among their most devoted followers pretend to believe that they do. Surrounding the tile-roofed clusters of buildings, which mostly vary in how fancy they are from the thatched homes of laypeople, there was no shortage of women and children. The monks were definitely not ones to deny themselves the enjoyment of wandering to the nearby city or traveling around the country whenever the mood struck them. The bright saffron robe that distinguishes followers of the Way in Central Asia, and adds so much to the charm of lands further west, is absent in Korea. A shaved head, instead of the cherished topknot, is pretty much the only difference in appearance between a monk and an ordinary layperson; when whim or a genuine desire to follow Gautama’s path leads him out into the Korean world, he may wear the distinctive hat made of woven rattan, but even the somewhat symbolic act of carrying a begging bowl hardly sets him apart from his more hardworking fellow countrymen. For a long time in Korea's history, Buddhist monks were viewed as being lower on the social ladder than even the farmers, and this perspective has lingered, perhaps without anyone realizing it, in a noticeable lack of respect—almost indifference toward them—except in their official roles, or among an unusually superstitious minority.
In these monasteries the principal living-room—to use the word very loosely—is floored with the thick oily brownish paper universal in private dwellings, and the scant furniture is of a similar type. Perhaps one of the big half-oval drums that call such of the monks as happen to be within hearing to their not very arduous duties swings from the center of the low ceiling; about the walls may sit a few bronze ornaments or figures of some significance which totally escapes the uninformed visitor. Certainly Gautama himself would not recognize the barbarous gaudiness, the crowds of fantastic figures which clutter the adjoining temples, as having been inspired by his simple teachings. Big golden Buddhas in the center, behind a kind of altar and offering-table in one, are flanked on either side clear around the three walls of the room with hybrid manikins of Chinese mythology and demonology, often of human size, which would outdo the phantasmagoric imaginings of any child in terror of the dark. Fourth wall is there none, but only a long series of double doors, which first open and then lift up to the horizontal, where they are supported by quaint Oriental substitutes for hooks. If the discreet rattling of a few small coins succeeds in accomplishing the complete opening of the doors, the more than dim religious light of the musty interior gives way to the glaring radiance of cloudless Korea, and a myriad of details that are otherwise only suspected, if even that, make their appearance. One discovers, for instance, that in addition to the score or more of large figures in the gaudiest of greens, reds, and all possible clashings of colors there are several times as many figurines, knee-high or less, interspersed among them, as if these queer puppets had their human quota of offspring. Like their adult companions, these little effigies wear expressions varying all the way from that of terrorizing demons to a smirking gentleness which suggests a well spent babyhood. Mere words, however, are useless pigments with which to attempt to picture the color-splashed paintings that cover the walls behind the row of stodgy standing 30figures. All the chaos of Oriental mythology seems to have been thrown together here, in battle scenes, in court processions, in helter-skelter throngs of human beings in garbs that were antiquated long before the Christian era, all fleeing in terror from the mammoth central figure of some wrathful monarch, his wildly bearded face painted jet-black to suggest the horror that his countenance sheds upon all beholders. Every feature of these silent temple denizens, be it noted, are Chinese, not Korean; and history tells us that as late as the Boxer Rebellion it was not so much the European troops as their black auxiliaries who put terror into the hearts of the fleeing Celestials.
In these monasteries, the main living area—if you can call it that—is covered with thick, oily brownish paper commonly found in private homes, and the sparse furniture is similar. A large half-oval drum might be hanging from the center of the low ceiling, calling monks nearby to their not-so-demanding tasks. A few bronze ornaments or significant figures, which completely puzzle an uninformed visitor, might be sitting on the walls. Gautama himself would hardly recognize the garishness and the crowd of bizarre figures cluttering the nearby temples as being inspired by his simple teachings. Grand golden Buddhas sit front and center, behind an altar and offering table, surrounded on all three walls by hybrid figures from Chinese mythology and demonology, often human-sized, that would terrify any child afraid of the dark. There's no fourth wall, just a long set of double doors that open and then lift up horizontally, held by quirky Oriental substitutes for hooks. If the discreet clinking of a few small coins manages to fully open the doors, the overly dim religious light of the musty interior gives way to the bright glare of clear Korean skies, revealing a myriad of details that were otherwise only guessed at. For instance, in addition to the twenty or so large figures in the most eye-catching greens, reds, and every possible clash of colors, there are several times that number of smaller figurines, knee-high or less, scattered among them, as if these odd puppets had their own share of children. Like their adult counterparts, these little figures display expressions ranging from terrifying demons to a gentle smirk that suggests a carefree childhood. Words alone fall short of capturing the vividly colored paintings that cover the walls behind the row of stiff standing figures. It's as if all the chaos of Oriental mythology has been thrown together here, with battle scenes, court processions, and frantic throngs of people dressed in styles long outdated before the Christian era, all fleeing in fear from the massive central figure of some angry ruler, his wildly bearded face painted jet-black to convey the horror it instills in all who see it. Notably, every feature of these silent temple inhabitants is Chinese, not Korean; history tells us that during the Boxer Rebellion, it was not the European troops but their Black allies who instilled terror in the hearts of the fleeing Celestials.
Gautama, the Buddha, as I have said, would puzzle in vain to find the connection between the strange beings which clutter these Buddhist temples and his own gentle doctrine. The medieval Christian, on the other hand, should find himself perfectly at home in certain corners of them, where are depicted such scenes as sinners fastened between two planks in order to simplify the task of assistant devils nonchalantly sawing them down the middle from crown to hips, in exactly the same way that Oriental workmen turn logs into lumber to this day. Perhaps the most surprising thing about these monasteries, to visitors from Christian lands, is the complete lack of sanctity toward the objects they worship which marks the outward behavior of the inmates. Casual callers of other faiths, or of the absence thereof, are as freely admitted to the most sacred corners as the monks themselves. The elaborate genuflections and throaty chantings of a group of bonzes in full barbaric regalia at the behest of a group of peasants come to lay offerings of rice and copper coins before a favorite figure may be followed a moment later by the tossing of a dirty altar-cloth or a dusty old rag over the head of the same god to whom they have just been appealing so grovelingly. Whatever their faults, there is always something charming about the tolerance of Buddhists. No small number of Christian missionaries in Korea spend their summer furloughs in the monasteries of this gentle rival faith.
Gautama, the Buddha, would struggle to understand the connection between the bizarre figures that fill these Buddhist temples and his own gentle teachings. Meanwhile, a medieval Christian would feel right at home in some areas of these temples, where scenes are depicted of sinners being fastened between two planks, making it easier for assistant devils to casually saw them in half from head to hips, just like how workers in the East still turn logs into lumber today. Perhaps the most surprising aspect of these monasteries for visitors from Christian countries is the complete lack of reverence towards the objects of worship seen in the behavior of the monks. Casual visitors of other faiths, or those with no faith at all, are just as freely welcomed into the most sacred spaces as the monks are. The elaborate bows and deep chants of a group of monks in full ceremonial dress, performing at the request of peasants offering rice and coins to a favored figure, can quickly be followed by the tossing of a dirty altar cloth or a dusty rag over the head of the same deity to whom they just showed such submission. Despite their flaws, there's something endearing about the tolerance of Buddhists. Many Christian missionaries in Korea spend their summer breaks in the monasteries of this gentle competing faith.
We struck out one Sunday afternoon over the high hill directly north of us, to visit the famous White Buddha, carved and painted on a great stream-washed rock cliff in the outskirts of the capital. It needs much less of a climb beneath the blazing sun of midsummer Korea to leave one drenched, but the view from the crest soon made that a half-forgotten detail. Of the hills rolling away into mountains on every hand, or the broad brown Han flecked with its rectangular 31junk-sails, little need be said; such scenes are commonplace in Cho-sen. But the complete panorama of Keijo, erstwhile Seoul, beginning at the very base of the perpendicular rock cliffs below us and stretching from the “Peking Pass” to far beyond Todaimon Gate, from ill sited Ryuzan to the section of old city wall along a mountain ridge which the Japanese have permitted to stand, called for a longer breathing-spell. Ancient Chinese-roofed palaces, efforts at modern buildings which somehow still seem unacclimated, the mainly Japanese city to the south of Shoro-dori—that broad street which distinctly separates Keijo into two nearly equal portions—the acres of yellow-brown thatched Korean huts of the northern half so compact as almost to seem a great hayfield, all stand out with the clearness of an illuminated engraving. Most incongruous, as well as most conspicuous, of all the details of the picture are the homes and other structures of the Christian missionaries, of red brick, and standing forth, if the time-worn comparison is legitimate in such a connection, like sore thumbs. Statistics assert that of the quarter of a million dwelling in Seoul only two hundred are Caucasians, a statement which there is no good reason to question, but which nevertheless seems strange from any such point of vantage above the city, for the big twin-spired Catholic cathedral alone, on the commanding site it has been true to form in choosing, seems to imply far more than that number. It was not merely the sounds of washing and ironing coming up to us in a great muffled chorus from the city below on this brilliant Sunday afternoon, however, which reminded us that for all these obvious edifices we were in no Christian country.
We set out one Sunday afternoon over the high hill directly north of us to visit the well-known White Buddha, carved and painted on a large stream-washed rock cliff on the outskirts of the capital. It requires much less of a climb under the blazing midsummer sun in Korea to leave one soaked, but the view from the top quickly made that a minor detail. There’s not much to say about the hills rolling off into mountains all around or the broad, brown Han River dotted with its rectangular junk sails; such scenes are commonplace in Korea. But the full panorama of Keijo, once known as Seoul, starting at the very base of the sheer rock cliffs below us and stretching from the “Peking Pass” to well beyond Todaimon Gate, from poorly situated Ryuzan to the section of the old city wall along a mountain ridge that the Japanese have allowed to remain, called for a longer pause. Ancient Chinese-roofed palaces, attempts at modern buildings that still feel out of place, the mostly Japanese city to the south of Shoro-dori—that wide street which clearly divides Keijo into two nearly equal parts—the stretches of yellow-brown thatched Korean huts in the northern half so tightly packed they almost look like a vast hayfield, all stand out with the clarity of a brightly lit engraving. Most striking and also most out of place among all the details in the picture are the homes and other buildings of the Christian missionaries, made of red brick, standing out, if that timeworn comparison is fair in this context, like sore thumbs. Statistics claim that out of a quarter of a million residents in Seoul, only two hundred are Caucasians, a statement that has no good reason to be questioned, but which still seems odd from any viewpoint above the city, as the large twin-spired Catholic cathedral alone, in its commanding location, suggests far more than that number. However, it was not just the sounds of washing and ironing drifting up to us in a great muffled chorus from the city below on this bright Sunday afternoon that reminded us that despite these obvious buildings, we were in no Christian country.
At the foot of the swift jungle-clad descent to the narrow suburb along the northern highway our ears were suddenly assailed by a great jangling hubbub. We crowded into the little courtyard of the square-forming house from which the sounds arose, and found that we had stumbled upon a sorceress performance. Numbers of men and children and many women were jostling one another along the wall-less fronts of two rooms on opposite sides of the yards, inside which the typical native hocus-pocus was at its height. On the papered floor of each room a sorceress was hopping, posturing, grimacing, and from time to time shrieking, with an activity which at least could not leave her open to the charge of physical laziness. I am no custodian of fancy-dress ball costumes, hence I can do little more than appeal to the vivid imaginations of those better fitted for the task to picture to themselves the incredible regalia in which these two middle-aged females, with the worldly wise faces, were swathed, though I can throw in the hint that 32they would not have suffered from cold six months thence, and that head-dresses which seemed to have been built, and then improved upon and built some more, about sections of stovepipe formed the crowning feature of their make-up.
At the bottom of the steep, jungle-covered slope leading to the narrow suburb along the northern highway, we were suddenly overwhelmed by a loud, chaotic noise. We crowded into the small courtyard of the house where the sounds were coming from and realized we had stumbled upon a sorceress performance. Lots of men, women, and children were pushing against each other along the open fronts of two rooms on opposite sides of the yard, where the typical local magic act was in full swing. On the papered floor of each room, a sorceress was dancing, posing, making faces, and occasionally screaming, showing an energy that definitely ruled out any claims of laziness. I’m not an expert on fancy-dress costumes, so I can only rely on the vivid imaginations of those better suited to the task to picture the incredible outfits worn by these two middle-aged women, who had knowing expressions on their faces. I can add that they wouldn’t have felt cold six months later, and that their elaborate headpieces, which appeared to be constructed, enhanced, and re-constructed around sections of stovepipe, were a standout part of their look.
We gave our attention mainly to the older, more agile, and more demoniacal of the pair. In one hand she swung incessantly a curved knife half as long as herself, and in the other a big clumsy iron three-pronged spear not unlike the one attributed to Father Neptune, one of her principal objects evidently being to slash and prod and swing as near the credulous beings who crowded about her as she could without inflicting actual physical injury upon them. In one corner sat half a dozen dejected-looking men picking at native musical instruments as they howled, and seeming to resent that the despised sex occupied the center of the stage. Several ordinarily dressed women stood or squatted along the walls. These, it was explained to us, had sick children and had come to have the malignant devils that had entered their little bodies exorcised and driven out. From time to time the sorceress called upon them to rise and join in the dance, particularly to posture in the center of the room while she made wild lunges at them with her two weapons. At other times they were ordered to kneel and bow their heads to the mats before what seemed to be imaginary gods or devils behind the displays of food set around the edges of the room. Now and again they ate bits of this, and at certain rather regular intervals the sorceress ceased her hopping, lunging, and posturing to partake copiously of some native drink respectfully tendered her by women of the house, or by those who had come to get the benefit of her ministrations. Through it all the dejected male orchestra, squatted on the floor in a corner, screeched incessantly some incredibly discordant Korean conception of music.
We mainly focused on the older, more agile, and more sinister one of the pair. In one hand, she constantly swung a curved knife that was about half her size, and in the other, she held a large, awkward three-pronged spear, not unlike the one associated with Father Neptune. One of her main goals seemed to be slashing, poking, and swinging as close as possible to the gullible people crowding around her without actually hurting them. In one corner, a few downcast-looking men were picking at traditional musical instruments as they wailed, appearing resentful that the lesser sex took center stage. Several normally dressed women were standing or squatting along the walls. It was explained to us that they had sick children and had come to have the evil spirits that had entered their little bodies exorcised and driven out. Occasionally, the sorceress would call on them to stand up and join in the dance, especially to pose in the center of the room while she made wild lunges at them with her two weapons. At other times, they were instructed to kneel and bow their heads to the mats before what seemed to be imaginary gods or devils behind the displays of food arranged around the room. Now and then, they would take bites of this food, and at certain regular intervals, the sorceress would stop her hopping, lunging, and posturing to enjoy a generous amount of a native drink that was respectfully offered to her by women of the house or those who had come to benefit from her services. Meanwhile, the sad male orchestra, squatting on the floor in a corner, relentlessly screeched some incredibly discordant Korean version of music.

Some of the figures, in the gaudiest of colors, surrounding the Golden Buddha in a Korean temple
Some of the figures, in the brightest colors, surrounding the Golden Buddha in a Korean temple

The famous “White Buddha,” carved and painted in white, on a great boulder in the outskirts of Seoul
The famous "White Buddha," carved and painted in white, on a large boulder on the outskirts of Seoul

One day, descending the hills toward Seoul, we heard a great jangling hubbub, and found two sorceresses in full swing in a native house, where people come to have their children “cured”
One day, as we were heading down the hills toward Seoul, we heard a loud, chaotic noise and discovered two sorceresses in full action in a local house, where people come to have their children “cured.”

The yang-ban, or loafing upper class of Korea, goes in for archery, which is about fitted to their temperament, speed, and initiative
The yang-ban, or slacking upper class of Korea, engages in archery, which suits their temperament, speed, and initiative perfectly.
33Half an hour or more after our arrival the sorceresses simultaneously changed their costumes to something quite different but equally fantastic, and after a deep drink and a long breath each they sprang again into the fray. They had already been at it for hours and might continue until dark. For these ceremonies seem to be rather of a wholesale nature, to which come all those who happen that day to have a devil to be exorcised, and the price of that service available. The bystanders made themselves comfortably at home, as is commonly the custom in the easy-going East, unawed by the great feats that were taking place before their eyes. Children played in and out of the throng; men, and some women too, placidly smoked their long tiny pipes; the sturdy fellow who had brought the paraphernalia of the sorceress calling slept babe-like on the box in which it had come, waiting for the word to carry it away again. Apparently there was nothing to be feared, except by the evil spirits which were being cast forth from within their absent or present victims. For some of the women had brought their ailing children in the flesh and were subjecting them to the noisy balderdash in ways that should have increased rather than diminished the demons of illness within them. How many mothers of sick infants came to that day’s ceremony was only suggested by the dozen or more present at one time. How many worldly-wise women of Korea, some of the most famous of them blind or boasting some other infirmity reputed to increase such powers, win their livelihood and even lay up small fortunes as sorceresses, even the statistics-loving Japanese overlords probably could not tell. One runs across them in wayside villages, in little valleys hidden by brush and rocks out among the hills all over the country—and in nearly every case there is a modern hospital run by missionaries or the Government no great distance away, sometimes, as here in Seoul, right on the road to the performance, where ailing infants would be readily admitted, probably at less cost than the fee of a sorceress.
33Half an hour or more after we arrived, the sorceresses suddenly switched into completely different outfits that were just as outrageous. After taking a deep drink and a long breath each, they jumped back into the action. They had already been performing for hours and might continue until dark. These ceremonies seem to be pretty much open to anyone who happens to have a demon to be exorcised that day, along with the cash to pay for it. The onlookers made themselves comfortable, as is common in the laid-back East, not intimidated by the impressive displays happening right in front of them. Kids were playing in and out of the crowd; men and some women calmly smoked their long, skinny pipes. The strong guy who brought the sorceress's equipment slept like a baby on the box it arrived in, waiting for the signal to take it away again. Apparently, there was nothing to be afraid of, except for the evil spirits being expelled from their absent or present hosts. Some of the women had brought their sick children and were exposing them to the loud nonsense in a way that would likely have worsened the demons of illness inside them. The number of mothers with sick babies who came to that day’s event was hinted at by the dozen or more present at any one time. How many savvy women in Korea—many of them famous for being blind or having another disability thought to enhance their powers—support themselves and even save small fortunes as sorceresses is something even the statistic-loving Japanese probably couldn’t track. You find them in roadside villages, in little valleys hidden by brush and rocks throughout the hills all over the country—and in almost every case, there’s a modern hospital run by missionaries or the government not far away, sometimes, as here in Seoul, right on the way to the event, where sick infants would be welcomed, likely at a lower cost than the fee for a sorceress.
The Japanese are so often accused of having no ideas of their own that perhaps I am mistaken in believing that they did not copy from some other nation their Railway School in Seoul. It is their own impression that the idea originated with the general manager of the Korean part of the South Manchuria Railway, and their opinion ought at least to be worth those of passing strangers. The plan is to recruit young boys after the usual six years of preliminary schooling and gather them together into a kind of railway West Point, where future employees of the railway shall be trained not merely in the immediate and mechanical things of their calling, but in general citizenship, in esprit de corps, in all those things which a body of men charged with so important a job as running a great railway system should have and be. There was already great eagerness to enter the school, though it was only in its third year, since the future for which it prepares is not only moderately bright but is definite and certain. At intervals competitive examinations for admission are given. The latest one had been attended by one thousand and eighty candidates, of whom a hundred and fifty were admitted to the school. The Japanese officials asserted, and seemed sincerely to believe, that, given equal preliminary training, 34Korean youths have equal opportunities for admission to the school and for preferment in what lies beyond. But the bare fact that of the five hundred and thirty-eight students only eighty were Koreans did not make it easy to accept this statement without question. It would scarcely be natural in any nation, let alone one of so tight a national feeling as Japan, to let such prizes get to any extent out of the hands of their own people.
The Japanese are often criticized for lacking originality, so I might be wrong to think that they didn’t take inspiration from another country for their Railway School in Seoul. They believe that the concept came from the general manager of the Korean section of the South Manchuria Railway, and their perspective should at least hold more weight than those of outsiders. The plan is to recruit young boys after the typical six years of basic education and gather them into a sort of railway West Point, where future railway employees will be trained not only in the technical aspects of their jobs but also in general citizenship, teamwork, and all the qualities essential for managing a significant railway system. There was already a lot of interest in the school, even though it was only in its third year, as the future it prepares for is not only relatively bright but also clear and certain. Periodically, competitive exams are held for admission. The most recent one drew one thousand and eighty candidates, of which a hundred and fifty were accepted into the school. The Japanese officials claimed, and seemed to sincerely believe, that with equal preliminary training, Korean youths have the same chances for admission and advancement. However, the fact that only eighty out of five hundred and thirty-eight students were Koreans made it hard to accept this claim without skepticism. It wouldn't be typical in any country, especially one with strong national pride like Japan, to let such opportunities slip significantly from the hands of their own citizens.
The school is a big red-brick building, or compact cluster of them, down at Ryuzan, where the railroad community lives in an orderly, well built town of its own, and it has everything which even the most exacting peoples of the West expect a school to have. The principal is not a railroad man, but an M.A. and a famous pedagogue from Japan, and the whole curriculum is laid out with the idea of giving the future trainmen as broad a training as could possibly be of use to them in the line of work toward which they are heading. All of them take, for instance, six hours of English a week. They are taught the importance of courtesy in its practical as well as its ethical aspects—a point which seems to have been largely missed by the labor-union brotherhoods of the West. To the strictly utilitarian Occident some of the things taught would seem highly fanciful. We would hardly expect our engine-drivers to take fencing, samurai style, as well as jiu-jitsu, however handy these accomplishments might be in ridding their trains of hoboes. But the Japanese idea is to develop health and physique and a well-rounded personality as well as mere mechanical ability, the spirit of fair-play, character and esprit de corps, as well as mere laborers’ qualities, that there may be a railway morale, as there is in most countries an army and a navy morale. Thereby the founder of the school hopes to avoid what he calls “labor-union madness,” and at the same time to have men properly fitted to come into contact with the public; not merely pullers of throttles and takers of tickets. The school, as I have said, is barely three years of age, so that one could scarcely expect any distinctly visible results of the policy as yet in the railway itself, but the scheme strikes even the layman observer as at least one thing Japanese well worth imitating.
The school is a large red-brick building, or a group of them, located in Ryuzan, where the railroad community resides in a neat, well-constructed town of its own. It has everything that even the most demanding people in the West expect a school to have. The principal isn’t a railroad worker, but rather an M.A. and a well-known educator from Japan. The entire curriculum is designed to provide future train employees with as broad a training as possible for the work they are preparing for. For example, all students take six hours of English each week. They learn the importance of courtesy in both its practical and ethical dimensions—a concept that seems to largely escape the labor unions in the West. To strictly utilitarian Westerners, some of what is taught might seem quite unconventional. We wouldn’t typically expect our train drivers to learn fencing in the samurai style, along with jiu-jitsu, even if those skills might be useful in getting rid of unauthorized travelers on their trains. However, the Japanese approach aims to develop not just mechanical skills, but also health, physical fitness, and a well-rounded personality, emphasizing sportsmanship, character, and camaraderie, in addition to basic labor skills, to foster a strong railway morale similar to that found in military forces in many countries. The founder of the school hopes to prevent what he calls “labor-union madness” while preparing individuals to interact effectively with the public, not just as operators and ticket collectors. As I mentioned, the school is only about three years old, so it would be unrealistic to expect any clear results from this policy in the railway system just yet, but even casual observers can see that it is a Japanese initiative worth emulating.
When the Russians and the Japanese grappled with each other a couple of decades ago, the railways of Korea, it will be recalled, were not linked up with those of Manchuria, destined to be the chief battleground. The little islanders pushed them quickly through, first in hastily constructed emergency form for military use, and later in a more finished manner. To this day they are straightening out curves and 35moving higher up from flooding areas that were ill chosen in war-time haste, and here and there along the way lie bits of the old road-bed and the abandoned abutments of a bridge that is gone. Like the railways of Japan, those of Korea are government owned; but they are not government operated. The South Manchuria Railway system, comprising all the Treaty of Portsmouth transferred from the Russians to their victors, has been given, as a private corporation, the complete control of the lines in Cho-sen for a long term of years, so that both comprise virtually one system, and operate as two trunk lines—from Fusan to Mukden and from Dairen and Port Arthur to Changchun, with their various branches. There is nothing of the Japanese model about these railways; they are almost exact copies of those in the United States, with standard gage, American cars with only minor hints of European influence, even the deep-voiced whistle which so instantly carries any wandering one of us back to his home-land. There is no railroad in the world at which the carping traveler cannot now and then find fault, but on few will he be harder put to it to find just cause for grumbling often than on these two systems operated as one from Dairen.
When the Russians and the Japanese clashed a few decades ago, it’s important to remember that Korea's railways weren’t connected to those in Manchuria, which became the main battleground. The small island nation quickly pushed through construction, first with hastily built military tracks and later with more finished lines. To this day, they are still correcting curves and moving tracks away from flood-prone areas that were poorly chosen in wartime haste. Occasionally, remnants of the old roadbed and the ruins of a bridge can be found along the way. Like Japan's railways, Korea's are government-owned, but not government-operated. The South Manchuria Railway system, which took over all lines transferred from the Russians to their victors under the Treaty of Portsmouth, has been privately managed for a long time, giving it total control over the lines in Korea. Essentially, they operate as one system with two main routes—from Fusan to Mukden and from Dairen and Port Arthur to Changchun, including various branches. These railways don't mirror the Japanese model; they resemble the systems in the United States, with standard gauge and American-style cars that bear only slight European influences, including the deep whistle that instantly reminds any of us of home. There's no railroad in the world where a picky traveler can't occasionally find something to complain about, but it's hard to find legitimate reasons to grumble about these two systems that operate as one from Dairen.
CHAPTER III
Japanese and missionaries in Korea
In Korea the traveler who has seen them at home gets a somewhat corrected picture of the Japanese. It is as if they had put their best and their worst foot forward there simultaneously, and cause for high praise lies plainly side by side with reasons for strong censure. Everyone in the peninsula seems to admit that materially Korea is much better off for having been taken over, lock, stock, and barrel, by Japan. Intrigues, the selling of offices, brigands, few and virtually worthless police, catch-as-catch-can tax methods to impoverish the people, a government so corrupt that there was not a breath of hope left in the country or the hearts of its inhabitants—there remained in all the peninsula of Cho-sen little but the most primitive agriculture in an almost wholly deforested land when the Japanese at length took upon themselves the task and the pleasure of administering it. But like our involuntary wards of the West Indies and elsewhere, the Koreans object to being forcibly improved, and it is not, one comes to the conclusion, merely disgruntled, because dispossessed, native politicians who are creating the continued growl of dissatisfaction.
In Korea, a traveler who has seen them at home gets a somewhat adjusted view of the Japanese. It feels like they have showcased both their best and worst sides at the same time, and you can find clear reasons for both high praise and strong criticism right next to each other. Everyone on the peninsula seems to agree that Korea is significantly better off after being completely taken over by Japan. Before this takeover, there were intrigues, corruption in office sales, bandits, a nearly useless police force, random tax methods that left the people poorer, and a government so corrupt that there was no hope left in the country or its people's hearts—leaving behind only the most basic agriculture in a largely deforested land when the Japanese finally took on the task and responsibility of managing it. But, like our unwilling wards in the West Indies and elsewhere, Koreans resist being forcibly improved, and it appears that it’s not just disgruntled, dispossessed native politicians fueling this ongoing dissatisfaction.
For all the admitted improvements they have brought, in spite of a distinct change of policy now under a civil instead of a military government, even the mere passer-by will scarcely fail to hear a long list of Korean grievances against the Japanese, and he is not unlikely to see some of these exemplified before his own eyes. The Japanese make so free with the country, run the complaints; they treat it as something picked up from the discard, with all signs of its former grandeur obliterated, no memory even of a former existence. They always speak of “Japan proper” when they mean their native islands, as if this great peninsula, more than half as large as their Empire “proper” including Formosa, and with seventeen million people who are distinctly not Japanese, were a mere tatter on the garment itself. They change without a by-your-leave not only the form of government but the very names of the provinces; they interfere in the minutest matters of every-day 37life—require people to walk on the left side of the street, for instance. Those who came when the country was first taken over did anything, the complaints continue, took anything, that pleased their fancy or appealed to their appetites, without payment, or at whatever they chose to pay. A new governor chased this riffraff out of the peninsula and a better class is now in evidence; but even these strike the passing observer as “cockier,” more arrogant than the average in Japan—and perhaps somewhat brighter.
For all the improvements they've made, and despite a clear shift in policy now under civilian rather than military rule, anyone passing by will definitely hear a long list of Korean complaints about the Japanese, and they’re likely to see some of these complaints firsthand. The Japanese treat the country as if it's something discarded, completely erasing any signs of its former greatness, leaving no memory of its past existence. They always refer to “Japan proper” when talking about their home islands, as if this vast peninsula, which is over half the size of their “proper” Empire including Taiwan and home to seventeen million people who are clearly not Japanese, is just a small piece of the whole. They change not just the form of government but even the names of the provinces without asking for permission; they meddle in the smallest details of daily life—like requiring people to walk on the left side of the street, for example. The complaints continue that those who came when the country was first occupied took anything they liked without paying or at whatever price they decided. A new governor has driven this unruly crowd out of the peninsula, and a better class is now present; however, even these newcomers seem “cockier,” more arrogant than the average Japanese—and perhaps a bit more assertive.
One is quickly reminded of Poland under the Germans, from whom it might easily be suspected that the Japanese copied almost verbatim in their annexation of what was once Korea. Japanese get the cream of mines, factories, and other concessions; the advantages given the “Oriental Development Company,” in reality a semi-official, strictly Japanese, concern, amount to a scandal. The monopoly bank does about as it sees fit in rates and exchanges; wherever there is a chance for it a Japanese always seems to get the preference over a Korean. Railwaymen, policemen, even the “red caps” at stations, are nearly all Japanese; at such places the Japanese rickshaw-men are given the best stands, with their Korean competitors in the background. I was returning one night from Gensan on the east coast, whence there had just been put on a night train to Seoul, which for some reason had not been found worthy of carrying a sleeper. About twenty minutes before train-time I started through the platform gate, only to be stopped by the gateman, who almost at the same instant promptly punched the ticket of a little man in kimono and scraping wooden getas and let him pass. My training in taking a back seat having been neglected, I pushed past the gateman and followed the sandal-wearer across to the waiting train. From end to end it was half full of Japanese passengers, most of them stretched out on two double seats; and when, just before the train started, Korean passengers were admitted to the platform, there was little left for them to do but to squat on the floor or the arm of a seat here and there or stand up all night.
One is quickly reminded of Poland under the Germans, from whom it might easily be suspected that the Japanese copied almost verbatim in their annexation of what was once Korea. The Japanese reap the benefits of mines, factories, and other concessions; the perks given to the “Oriental Development Company,” which is essentially a semi-official, strictly Japanese entity, are scandalous. The monopoly bank operates with little regard for rates and exchanges; whenever a chance arises, a Japanese individual always seems to have preference over a Korean. Railway workers, policemen, and even the "red caps" at stations are nearly all Japanese; at these locations, Japanese rickshaw drivers are given the best spots, with their Korean counterparts pushed to the background. I was returning one night from Gensan on the east coast, where a night train to Seoul had just been launched, which, for some reason, was deemed unworthy of carrying a sleeper. About twenty minutes before departure, I went through the platform gate, only to be stopped by the gateman, who almost immediately punched the ticket of a small man in a kimono wearing wooden getas and let him through. My upbringing in taking a back seat having been overlooked, I pushed past the gateman and followed the sandal-wearer to the waiting train. From one end to the other, it was half filled with Japanese passengers, most of them sprawled across two double seats. Just before the train left, when Korean passengers were allowed onto the platform, there was little for them to do but squat on the floor or the arm of a seat here and there or stand all night.
I have seen a petty Japanese official keep a public autobus waiting for half an hour while he played with his children or had a last cup of tea with his neighbors. Railway stations are, with few exceptions, miles from the towns they serve, though the line may run almost directly through them. Possibly, as those in authority claim, this is for protection, though I do not know from what; the disinterested visitor finds himself agreeing with the Koreans that it is probably done so that a Japanese town can grow up under more advantageous conditions 38than the old Korean city behind it, as has already happened in many cases, and perhaps to help the Japanese owners of Fords, rickshaws, and hotels. The Japanese hold up and examine mail, whether of Koreans, missionaries, or foreigners in general, at the slightest provocation, often, one suspects, out of mere curiosity. Korean youths who wish to go to school in America or Europe are almost invariably refused passports. Possibly a dozen are granted out of a thousand applications, and it often takes as long as a year to get those. One group of students who applied for permission to study industries abroad were told to study them in Chinnampo instead. To appreciate the joke fully one must have seen Chinnampo. In general the Koreans are virtually prisoners within their own country, and even if they escape from it they are not always safe. Koreans whose land has been taken away from them by force have moved to Manchuria and become Chinese citizens. Even if this prattle of “self-determination” means nothing so far as nations are concerned, certainly the right of an individual to choose his own allegiance should be axiomatic in this day and generation. But the Japanese will not recognize the Chinese citizenship of a Korean. Having taken the country, they claim possession of all its people also, irrespective of their location or personal choice, and send soldiers to round them up on the foreign soil of Manchuria, forcing the Chinese to hold them in their jails, bringing them back to Korea for trial, or shooting them on the spot.
I’ve seen a petty Japanese official keep a public bus waiting for half an hour while he played with his kids or had a final cup of tea with his neighbors. Railway stations are, with few exceptions, miles away from the towns they serve, even if the train line runs almost directly through them. Possibly, as those in charge claim, this is for protection, although I don't know what from; the uninterested visitor finds himself agreeing with the Koreans that it's probably done so a Japanese town can develop under better conditions than the old Korean city behind it, as has already happened in many cases, and maybe to benefit the Japanese owners of Fords, rickshaws, and hotels. The Japanese hold up and inspect mail, whether it’s from Koreans, missionaries, or foreigners in general, at the slightest excuse, often just out of curiosity. Korean youths who want to go to school in America or Europe are almost always denied passports. Maybe a dozen are granted out of a thousand applications, and it often takes as long as a year to get those. One group of students who applied for permission to study industries abroad were told to study them in Chinnampo instead. To fully appreciate the joke, you have to have seen Chinnampo. In general, Koreans are basically prisoners in their own country, and even if they manage to escape, they aren’t always safe. Koreans whose land has been taken from them by force have moved to Manchuria and become Chinese citizens. Even if this talk of “self-determination” means nothing when it comes to nations, the right of an individual to choose their own loyalty should be obvious in today’s world. But the Japanese won’t recognize a Korean’s Chinese citizenship. Having taken the country, they claim ownership of all its people as well, regardless of where they are or their personal choice, and send soldiers to round them up on foreign soil in Manchuria, forcing the Chinese to hold them in their jails, bringing them back to Korea for trial, or shooting them on the spot.
Everywhere the Japanese stick together—another German trait; if they did not know the ropes and have everything in their favor, including the official language, say those who know both races well, the Koreans would outdo them in almost any line. Personally I could not sign so broad a statement, for though I have seen many indications that the Koreans are of quicker and sharper intelligence than the Japanese, they have other weaknesses which largely neutralize this advantage. But the policy in Korea, even in these improved days, seems never to be humanity and justice first, but Japan and the Japanese über alles—and after that whatever may conveniently be added. Koreans of standing say that Japan’s inability to overlook her petty interests for the fulfilment of greater things is her greatest weakness, as her policy of assimilation, of trying to make Koreans over into Japanese, which the experience of Germany in Poland should have taught her not to attempt, is her greatest mistake. The same dominating instinct which insists that even a railway porter shall be Japanese, if one applicant among a hundred is of that race, is manifest in all her political dealings, and this 39over-patriotism may prove her final undoing, where a bit less of it might permit her to continue as an unconquered nation under a single dynasty for another twenty-five hundred years.
Everywhere the Japanese stick together—another trait of the Germans; if they didn’t have the benefits of knowledge and the official language on their side, those who understand both cultures say the Koreans would outshine them in almost every area. Personally, I can’t agree with such a sweeping statement, because while I’ve seen many signs that Koreans have sharper intelligence than the Japanese, they have other weaknesses that largely negate this advantage. However, the approach in Korea, even now, seems to prioritize Japan and the Japanese above all—with whatever else can be included coming afterward. Educated Koreans say that Japan’s failure to rise above petty interests for the sake of greater goals is its biggest flaw. Its policy of assimilation—trying to turn Koreans into Japanese, which Germany’s experience in Poland should have taught not to attempt—is its greatest mistake. The same dominating instinct that requires even a railway porter to be Japanese, if one applicant among a hundred belongs to that race, is evident in all its political actions, and this excess of nationalism might ultimately lead to its downfall, while a bit less could allow it to remain an unconquered nation under a single dynasty for another twenty-five hundred years.
Japan is eager to make Shintoists of the Koreans, to teach them that ancient cult of the mikado as a direct descendant of the gods which has been revived and repaired and strengthened during the last half-century in Japan itself, that his “divine right” may survive even in an age that is so completely in disagreement with such fallacies. Korean school-children especially are subjected to this form of propaganda, so similar to the German school- and pulpit-made Kultur of kaiserly days. The requirement that their children in government schools shall not merely salute the banner of the rising sun at frequent intervals, but shall bow down daily in what is virtually worship, however much the Japanese may deny it, before a picture of the mikado, is one of the sorest points with the Koreans. A modicum of intelligence should tell any people that such methods are out of date and much worse than useless. The new Shinto shrines on hilltops all over Korea, with their newly peeled torii before them, look like late and exceedingly weak rivals of the Christian churches which dot the peninsula.
Japan is eager to convert Koreans to Shintoism, teaching them about the ancient worship of the emperor as a direct descendant of the gods. This belief has been revived, rebuilt, and strengthened over the last fifty years in Japan itself, so that his "divine right" can persist even in an era that completely opposes such outdated ideas. Korean schoolchildren, in particular, are targeted by this type of propaganda, which is reminiscent of the cultural indoctrination during Kaiser Wilhelm's era in Germany. The requirement for their children in government schools to not only salute the rising sun flag regularly but also to bow daily in what is essentially a form of worship—despite Japanese claims to the contrary—before an image of the emperor is one of the biggest grievances for Koreans. A little common sense should tell any nation that such tactics are outdated and far from effective. The new Shinto shrines on hilltops across Korea, with their freshly painted torii gates, appear to be feeble and late attempts to compete with the Christian churches scattered throughout the peninsula.
Until very recently all Japanese officials in Korea, including schoolteachers, wore uniforms and carried swords! Picture to yourself how much more handy the latter would be than a ferule. But Japanese influence on the rising generation would be greater if there were not such a discrepancy in the rights of schooling. With seventeen million Koreans and less than three hundred and fifty thousand Japanese in Korea, the 65,654 Korean children who find accommodations in government schools represent something like one two-hundred-and-fiftieth of the Korean population, while the 34,183 Japanese youngsters in school are one tenth of the sons of Nippon in the peninsula. Yet the Government still hampers to a certain extent private, and especially missionary, schools. The Japanese have brought many improvements, say the Koreans, but for whom?
Until very recently, all Japanese officials in Korea, including schoolteachers, wore uniforms and carried swords! Just imagine how much more practical the latter would be than a ruler. However, Japanese influence on the younger generation would be stronger if there wasn't such a gap in educational rights. With seventeen million Koreans and fewer than three hundred and fifty thousand Japanese in Korea, the 65,654 Korean children attending government schools represent about one two-hundred-fiftieth of the Korean population, while the 34,183 Japanese kids in school make up one-tenth of the Japanese population on the peninsula. Yet the Government still restricts private, particularly missionary, schools to some extent. The Japanese have introduced many improvements, say the Koreans, but improvements for whom?
Silk, tobacco, salt, gin-seng, to some extent beans, and in a certain sense prostitution, are government monopolies in Korea. The Japanese seem to bring immorality and “red lights” and disease wherever they take root, and to adopt a callous, cynical attitude toward this matter which marks them as closely related to the French in at least that one point. Thirty years ago, say missionary doctors, before their war with China brought the islanders to the peninsula in any great number, the diseases of prostitution were virtually unknown in Korea; now they 40are widely prevalent. As is their custom, the Japanese have established yoshiwaras in every city of any size, with Korean as well as Japanese inmates—Chinese also in the zone they control in Manchuria—and while these are not exactly government owned, the protection accorded them, the official regulation of them, and the large income in the form of taxes derived from them makes them virtually so.
Silk, tobacco, salt, ginseng, to some extent beans, and in a certain sense prostitution, are government monopolies in Korea. The Japanese seem to bring immorality, “red-light” districts, and disease wherever they settle, and they adopt a cold, cynical attitude towards this issue, which aligns them with the French in at least that one respect. Thirty years ago, missionary doctors say, before their war with China resulted in many islanders coming to the peninsula, diseases related to prostitution were nearly unknown in Korea; now they are widespread. As usual, the Japanese have set up yoshiwaras in every significant city, with both Korean and Japanese inmates—Chinese as well in the area they control in Manchuria—and while these aren’t exactly government-owned, the protection given to them, the official regulations surrounding them, and the significant tax revenue they generate makes them functionally so.
A Japanese policeman in spotless white summer uniform and sword, relieved by a blood-red cap-band which is said to be symbolical, is to be found in any Korean gathering, even in the utmost corner of the peninsula. The traveler will probably not be in Korea long before he sees one or two such officers driving to prison a Korean with his arms tightly bound with ropes, the loose ends of which serve as reins. This is an old Oriental custom, but one feels that it could, to advantage, yield to something a little more modern and reasonable, a bit less conspicuous. In August, 1919, the police force under an army lieutenant-general virtually independent of civil authority was replaced by a gendarmerie or constabulary directly responsible to the new governor-general, Baron Saito. The latter is widely admitted to be a superior official, with the best of intentions and a high grade of ability. But tales of oppression by subordinates, and cruelties by the police, persist even under his comparatively beneficent rule. The time-honored excuse that “excesses of police and gendarmes do not have the approval of higher authorities” is out of date; if higher officials cannot curb those under them, they are equally to blame. Baron Saito’s Government seems to recognize this and has changed the formula to “It cannot be true that the police still beat prisoners, for there is a law against it.” Definite cases of persecution and torture still turn up from time to time, but the victims are so cowed that they dare not report the matter to higher authorities, and a fluent lie by the police involved settles an investigation, since the word of a Japanese is always accepted over that of a Korean. An American missionary who had reported many cases of persecution to the present governor was asked to bring the next victim in person. But when he suggested to a man who had sneaked in to see him, badly cut up and mottled in black and blue from head to foot, that he go and show himself to the governor-general, the fellow all but fled at the bare suggestion. Word would be sure to get back to the police of his own province, he insisted, and he would be manhandled worse than ever when he went home. True, gendarmes who misbehave are sometimes court-martialed, which sounds to the average civilian like something dreadful, but those of us with a little military experience know how often a court martial is a synonym for a whitewashing, unless it is the sacred army itself which has been wronged.
A Japanese policeman in a clean white summer uniform and sword, accented by a bright red cap band that is said to have symbolic meaning, can be seen at any gathering in Korea, even in the farthest reaches of the peninsula. Travelers will likely spot a couple of these officers escorting a Korean with his arms tightly bound by ropes, the loose ends serving as reins. This is an old Eastern practice, but it seems that it could be improved upon with something a bit more modern and sensible, something less obvious. In August 1919, the police force, previously under an army lieutenant-general who was basically free from civil authority, was replaced by a gendarmerie or constabulary directly accountable to the new governor-general, Baron Saito. He is generally recognized as a capable official with good intentions. However, stories of oppression from his subordinates and police brutality still persist, even under his relatively kind leadership. The old excuse that “the excesses of the police and gendarmes do not reflect the views of higher authorities” is outdated; if higher officials cannot control those below them, they share the blame. Baron Saito’s government appears to acknowledge this and has changed the narrative to “It can't be true that the police still beat prisoners, because there is a law against that.” Specific reports of abuse and torture still emerge now and then, but the victims are so intimidated that they dare not report it to higher authorities, and a slick lie from the police involved usually ends an investigation, as the words of a Japanese are always taken over those of a Korean. An American missionary who had reported several cases of abuse to the current governor was asked to bring in the next victim personally. But when he suggested to a man who had come to see him, severely injured and bruised all over, that he go show himself to the governor-general, the man nearly bolted at the mere suggestion. He insisted that word would definitely get back to the police in his area, and he would face even worse treatment when he returned home. It’s true that gendarmes who act inappropriately are sometimes court-martialed, which sounds quite serious to the average citizen, but those of us with a bit of military experience know how often a court-martial merely serves as a cover-up, unless it is the sacred army itself that has been offended.

The Korean method of ironing, the rhythmic rat-a-tat of which may be heard day and night almost anywhere in the peninsula
The Korean way of ironing, the rhythmic rat-a-tat of which can be heard day and night almost anywhere on the peninsula

Winding thread before one of the many little machine-knit stocking factories in Ping Yang
Winding thread outside one of the many small machine-knit stocking factories in Ping Yang.

The graves of Korea cover hundreds of her hillsides with their green mounds, usually unmarked, but carefully tended by the superstitious descendants
The graves of Korea dot countless hillsides with their green mounds, often unmarked, but lovingly maintained by the superstitious descendants.
41It is not, of course, quite the same to a Korean to be beaten by the police as it seems to us. Flogging has been practised in Korea as far back as records go, and it is not unnatural that Japanese gendarmes should consider this the only sure way of really reaching the intellect or getting the truth out of some Koreans. But they failed to see that while men punished in this time-honored way by their fellow-countrymen might not feel particularly humiliated, might take it almost like a son from his father, they would deeply resent being so treated by Japanese aliens, little men whom they have always heartily despised. Certainly some ugly stories are still afloat, and all indications point to the probability that the torturing of prisoners—and of witnesses—still goes on in the secrecy of some police stations, the perhaps real disapproval of higher authorities notwithstanding. To say that the same thing sometimes occurs in New York is not to make the practice any less reprehensible.
41It’s not quite the same for a Korean to be beaten by the police as it is for us. Flogging has been a part of Korean history for as long as we have records, and it’s not surprising that Japanese officers might think this is the only way to truly get through to some Koreans or uncover the truth. However, they fail to recognize that while men punished this traditional way by their own countrymen might not feel particularly humiliated—almost accepting it like a son would from a father—they would be deeply offended by this treatment from Japanese outsiders, whom they've always looked down on. Certainly, there are still some troubling stories going around, and all signs suggest that the torture of prisoners—and witnesses—still happens in secret at some police stations, despite any real disapproval from higher-ups. Saying that similar things sometimes happen in New York doesn’t make the practice any less wrong.
Once convicted of a crime, it is another matter; but when a man is suddenly arrested without warning and imprisoned for weeks, months and sometimes more than a year without knowing what charge has been made against him, without being allowed to get a word in or out of prison, even to notify some one to communicate with his family or see a lawyer, or to do anything but sit and await the good pleasure of his jailers, which may include being bambooed for two hours daily, the infliction of the “water cure,” the clamping of the fingers, the hanging up by the thumbs, the forced squat, and many other ingenious tortures which are guaranteed to leave no telltale marks on the body, it is not a sign of civilization but a remnant of the barbarism from which Japan tries hard to prove to the world that she has entirely recovered. Once the police get a confession by such methods there is no going back on it, we were told, no matter how innocent the sufferer really may be. His case is turned over at once to the procurator, and only after he has been twice condemned can he have counsel. The French system of considering the accused guilty until he proves his innocence prevails, and the chief of police has often been known to sit behind the judge and virtually to give him his orders as to what is to be done with the prisoner at the bar. Nine months in prison merely as a witness has been the experience of many a Korean Christian. Interpreters, even in important conspiracy cases, where it may be a matter of life and death, 42are reputed to mistranslate testimony in favor of Japanese or in favor of conviction. There is a classic case of an American missionary arrested during the independence movement on the charge of “harboring prisoners,” simply because he did not drive out of his house convert students whom he knew to be innocent and whom the police were eager to torture. Though he was ill at the time, he was refused permission to have a bed brought from his house to the bedless prison, was not allowed even to send word of his whereabouts to his wife, was kept incommunicado for fifteen days, during which he was grilled by a haughty Japanese official who spoke to him only in “low talk,” such as one uses to coolies, and after four trials his punishment was reduced from one year’s imprisonment to a fine of a hundred yen.
Once someone is convicted of a crime, that’s a different story; but when a person is suddenly arrested without any warning and locked up for weeks, months, or sometimes over a year without knowing what they’re being charged with, unable to communicate with anyone outside the prison to tell someone to contact their family or see a lawyer, and forced to just sit and wait at the mercy of their captors—which might involve being beaten for two hours a day, enduring the "water cure," having their fingers clamped, being hung by their thumbs, forced to squat, and subjected to various other painful tortures that leave no visible marks—it’s not a sign of civilization but a remnant of the barbarism that Japan is trying hard to show the world it has moved past. Once the police extract a confession using such methods, we were told, there’s no backing out of it, regardless of how innocent the individual really is. Their case is immediately handed over to the prosecutor, and only after being condemned twice can they have legal counsel. The French system, which assumes the accused is guilty until proven innocent, is in effect here, and the police chief has often been known to sit behind the judge and essentially direct what happens to the person on trial. Many Korean Christians have spent nine months in prison simply as witnesses. Interpreters, even in significant conspiracy cases where lives are at stake, are said to misinterpret testimonies in favor of the Japanese or for securing a conviction. There’s a well-known case of an American missionary who was arrested during the independence movement for “harboring prisoners,” just because he didn’t eject innocent students from his home whom the police wanted to torture. Despite being ill, he was denied permission to bring a bed from his house to the bedless prison, wasn’t allowed to notify his wife about his location, and was kept incommunicado for fifteen days, during which he was interrogated by an arrogant Japanese official who spoke to him in a condescending manner, as one would address laborers. After four trials, his punishment was reduced from a year in prison to a fine of a hundred yen.
Perhaps the most repulsive custom of the Japanese police in Korea, from our Western point of view, is their indifference to domestic privacy. They march even into school-girls’ dormitories or women’s apartments with or without provocation; American missionary women traveling in the interior have often been compelled to admit policemen to their quarters at inns or in the homes of converts not only after they have prepared for bed, but several times during the night, merely to answer over and over again their silly “Who-are-you? How-old-you? Where-you-come-from? Where-you-go?” questions.
Perhaps the most shocking custom of the Japanese police in Korea, from our Western perspective, is their complete disregard for personal privacy. They walk into schoolgirls' dorms or women's apartments with or without a reason; American missionary women traveling inland have often been forced to let police officers into their rooms at hotels or in the homes of converts not just after they’ve gotten ready for bed, but several times throughout the night, just to answer their ridiculous questions like "Who are you? How old are you? Where are you from? Where are you going?"
The many reforms that have recently been introduced into Korea, say its residents, would have been of far more credit to the Japanese if they had thought of them before rather than after the independence movement of March, 1919. The handling of that, by the way, was a typical example of Japanese stupidity. The independence agitation which broke out simultaneously all over the peninsula was merely a demonstration to prove to the outside world that the Koreans had not been so completely and successfully “Japalacked” (as the missionaries, with no unbounded love for the little brown Prussians of the East, put it) as the Japanese at the peace conference led the world to suppose. Their city walls had been torn down; they had no weapons; the native Christians, who were foremost among the agitators, had refused to have anything to do with the demonstration until it was agreed that there should be no violence. If the Japanese had acted with the jovial moderation which their power over the peninsula made quite possible, the movement would very likely have been nothing more serious than a kind of lantern procession on a national scale. There is an anecdote floating about the Far East to the effect that half a dozen British “Tommies,” strolling down the street of a city in India, were met by a 43mob shouting the Hindu version of “Long live Gandhi!” They neither raced back to the barracks for their rifles nor fell upon the crowd with such weapons as they could snatch up; they merely began shouting with the natives, “Long live Gandhi!” Within five minutes the demonstration had broken up in peals of laughter at the antics of the soldiers and their ludicrous Hindustani accent. Whether it is true or not, the story illustrates a great weakness of the Japanese. Almost no nation is so devoid of a sense of humor, as we use the phrase; that is, they are wholly incapable of permitting anything but the greatest solemnity of word or deed concerning their persons, their country, or their “sacred” institutions.
The many reforms recently introduced in Korea, according to its residents, would have been much more commendable for the Japanese if they had thought of them before, rather than after, the independence movement of March 1919. The way they handled it was a classic example of Japanese foolishness. The independence protests that erupted simultaneously across the peninsula were simply a demonstration to show the outside world that the Koreans hadn't been as completely and successfully “Japalacked” (as the missionaries, not particularly fond of the little brown Prussians of the East, described it) as the Japanese led the world to believe at the peace conference. Their city walls had been torn down; they had no weapons; the local Christians, who were at the forefront of the protests, had refused to participate until it was agreed that there would be no violence. If the Japanese had approached the situation with the cheerful moderation their control over the peninsula made entirely possible, the movement would likely have turned into nothing more than a massive lantern procession. There's a story going around the Far East about a few British soldiers strolling through a city in India who encountered a crowd chanting the Hindu version of “Long live Gandhi!” Instead of rushing back to the barracks for their rifles or attacking the crowd with whatever weapons they could grab, they simply joined in, shouting, “Long live Gandhi!” Within five minutes, the demonstration dissolved into laughter at the soldiers' antics and their silly Hindustani accents. Whether this story is true or not, it highlights a significant weakness of the Japanese. Few nations lack a sense of humor as completely; they are entirely incapable of allowing anything but the utmost seriousness regarding their personal dignity, their country, or their “sacred” institutions.
Instead of treating the “Mansei” movement as more or less of a joke, therefore, they acted with incredible childishness, as well as quite unnecessary brutality. Groups of unarmed Koreans gathered on hills overlooking the towns, shouted “Mansei!”—which is merely the Korean form of the Japanese “Banzai!” or “Ten Thousand Years!” and means something like “Long live Korea!”—then scattered. The silly police ran hither and thither, distracted. The honor of their nation, the luster of their military caste, the glory of their god-descended ruler might have been at stake. They arrested sixty school-boys eight years of age because some one among them had shouted the dreadful word, and they kept them at the police station until ten o’clock at night. A high official quizzed a roomful of little girls with such questions as how they could expect liberty, and where they would get money to run the Government, if they had it. When they answered, woman-like, “Oh, we’d get it,” the Japanese on the platform foamed at the mouth and devised ingenious ways of punishing the tots for their temerity. Brutalities like ours in Haiti, and worse, were perpetrated on the population. Students were beaten if they admitted they attended mission schools. They were asked at ferry stations and other points of concentration whether they were Christians, and if they replied in the affirmative they were cut with swords and otherwise mishandled by soldiers and police. If they denied the allegation, even though they were known to be converts, they were not abused, the idea seeming to be to get them to apostatize. Prisoners were tied together and driven on forced marches of sometimes a hundred miles, sleeping on plank floors full of cracks, with no food whatever on examination-day (otherwise known as “torture-day”). Great gangs were marched into Ping Yang from the country roundabout, many of them virtually unable to walk, and with carts of dead ones behind. Women who had shouted “Mansei!” were 44taken to police stations, stripped, and marched around while the police amused themselves by burning them with cigarettes. Whether or not they were violated, they were subjected to every other form of indignity. The Japanese claim that “not a few policemen and their families in isolated stations were ruthlessly massacred,” and that they were therefore provoked to harsh measures. But they neglect to give the exact chronology of the affair, which indicates that they were the first to adopt harsh measures, and that Korean violence was in retaliation for their unnecessarily stern suppression of what probably would have remained a bloodless demonstration. Thus all the complaints, dissatisfactions, and grievances that had been repressed within the breasts of the people of Cho-sen for ten long years broke out at last like the cataract through a broken dike.
Instead of seeing the “Mansei” movement as a joke, they acted with incredible childishness and unnecessary brutality. Groups of unarmed Koreans gathered on hills overlooking the towns, shouted “Mansei!”—which is just the Korean version of the Japanese “Banzai!” or “Ten Thousand Years!” meaning something like “Long live Korea!”—and then scattered. The confused police ran around in all directions. The honor of their nation, the prestige of their military class, the glory of their god-appointed ruler seemed to be on the line. They arrested sixty eight-year-old schoolboys because one of them shouted the terrible word, keeping them at the police station until ten at night. A high official questioned a room full of little girls with ridiculous inquiries about how they expected to achieve liberty, and where they’d get the money to run the government, if they had it. When they answered, as girls do, “Oh, we’d get it,” the Japanese on the platform became furious and came up with creative ways to punish the kids for their boldness. Brutalities similar to those in Haiti, and even worse, were inflicted on the local population. Students were beaten if they admitted they attended mission schools. They were asked at ferry stations and other gatherings whether they were Christians, and if they said yes, they were attacked with swords and otherwise mistreated by soldiers and police. If they denied being Christians, even if they were known converts, they were not harmed, suggesting they were trying to force them to abandon their faith. Prisoners were tied together and forced to march, sometimes up to a hundred miles, sleeping on cracked wooden floors without any food on what was known as “torture-day.” Large groups were marched into Ping Yang from the surrounding countryside, many unable to walk and with carts carrying the dead behind them. Women who shouted “Mansei!” were taken to police stations, stripped, and led around while the police amused themselves by burning them with cigarettes. Whether or not they were assaulted, they suffered every other form of humiliation. The Japanese claim that “many policemen and their families in isolated stations were ruthlessly massacred,” which justified their harsh actions. However, they overlook the timeline of events, which shows they were the first to use brutal measures, and that the Korean violence was in retaliation for their excessively harsh suppression of what likely would have remained a peaceful demonstration. Thus, after ten long years of repressed complaints, dissatisfaction, and grievances, the people of Cho-sen finally erupted like a flood through a broken dam.
Those not friendly to them say that the Japanese police are cowardly as well as bullies, citing such examples as a group of Americans being mobbed only a few yards from one of the innumerable police stations in Seoul during our stay there, without a single white uniform appearing on the scene. Since the establishment of civil government some Koreans have been made gendarmes and otherwise given positions of authority, but as so often happens in such cases, many of them are more cruel to their fellow-nationals, and more itching with curiosity as to the doings of foreigners, than the Japanese themselves. Up to the time of the “Mansei” movement the Japanese scorned to study Korean and tried to force the Koreans to learn Japanese instead, again aping the Germans in Poland. But they have learned the disadvantages of using Korean interpreters and depending on native stool-pigeons for information, so that now they offer five yen a month in addition to the regular salary of those who have a workable knowledge of the native tongue.
Those who aren't friendly towards them say that the Japanese police are both cowardly and bullies, pointing to incidents like a group of Americans being surrounded just a few yards from one of the many police stations in Seoul during our visit, with not a single officer in uniform showing up. Since civil government was established, some Koreans have been made police and given other positions of authority, but, as often happens in these situations, many of them treat their fellow nationals more harshly and are more nosy about what foreigners are doing than the Japanese themselves. Until the “Mansei” movement, the Japanese refused to learn Korean and tried to force Koreans to learn Japanese instead, mimicking the Germans in Poland. However, they've realized the drawbacks of relying on Korean interpreters and local informants for information, so now they offer an additional five yen a month on top of the regular salary for those who have a good grasp of the native language.
The Japanese learned considerable from the uprising of 1919, but they still have something to learn. There are officials yet who advocate fines and flogging for Koreans who refuse to hoist the flag of Japan on national holidays. A modicum of common sense should teach any people that a national flag is a symbol of patriotism the display of which should be only an expression of free will, that patriotism can never be forced into the hearts of a people, and that any false show of it is much worse than worthless. Even shops which close as a sign of protest against certain Japanese doings are compelled by the police to open their doors. When the warship Mutsu anchored in the harbor of Chemulpo, the port for Seoul, every visitor who went on board was 45compelled to salute the common sailor on sentry duty at the gang-plank, who barked like an enraged bulldog at any one who did not perform the ceremony with the deepest solemnity. Until they cure themselves, or are cured, of this ridiculously Prussian point of view on matters pertaining to their national life naturally the Japanese will not be able to see that it is silly to speak of the “wickedness” of trying to change, or even of talking of changing, a given form of government, that as a matter of fact any form of government is no more sacred than an old pair of shoes that has served the wearer moderately well.
The Japanese learned a lot from the 1919 uprising, but there's still more for them to understand. Some officials still suggest punishing Koreans with fines and whipping for not raising the Japanese flag on national holidays. Basic common sense should tell anyone that a national flag is a symbol of patriotism, and displaying it should be a matter of free choice. Patriotism can't be forced upon people, and any forced display of it is worse than meaningless. Even shops that close in protest against certain actions by the Japanese are pressured by the police to stay open. When the warship Mutsu docked in Chemulpo, the port for Seoul, every visitor who boarded was required to salute the common sailor on guard at the gangway, who barked like an angry bulldog at anyone who didn’t show the proper respect. Until they get past this absurdly rigid mindset regarding their national identity, the Japanese won’t recognize how silly it is to condemn the idea of changing, or even discussing, a certain form of government. In reality, no form of government is any more sacred than an old pair of shoes that has just about served its purpose.
We of the West should not forget, however, that the “white peril” has been a much more actual thing to the Japanese than the “yellow peril” ever was to us. Korea was not only a convenient spring-board for Russia and the whole white world behind her, but it was a greater source of danger to Japanese health than Cuba in its most yellow-feverish days ever was to us. Old residents paint a distressing picture of pre-Japanese Seoul—narrow streets plowed up into bullock-cart ruts, no general means of transportation except one’s own feet, however deep the mud, corpses of those dying of cholera left before any “rich” man’s house, forcing him to bury them. The Korean royal family was “liberally provided for” and left in possession of their palaces and their titles in perpetuity on condition that they would not interfere in any way with the new Government or the people of the peninsula. The sop of titles of nobility was thrown to influential Koreans who were likely to make trouble, and seventy-six new peers stepped forth from their mud huts. The Japanese claim that they spend ten million dollars a year on the occupation of Korea, that with its need of schools, roads, trees, sanitation, and many other things the peninsula is a great burden to them. “Though it is treason to say so now,” a high-placed Japanese in Seoul assured me, “Korea will eventually get her independence, as soon as she can stand on her own feet and protect herself—and us—from the north.” Possibly this was mere prattle meant to throw me off the scent, but I have met some Japanese intelligent enough sincerely to believe in this eventual solution.
We in the West should remember that the “white peril” has been a much more real threat to the Japanese than the “yellow peril” ever was to us. Korea was not only a useful launchpad for Russia and the entire white world behind it, but it posed a greater health risk to the Japanese than Cuba did at its worst with yellow fever. Longtime residents describe a grim picture of pre-Japanese Seoul—narrow streets filled with bullock-cart ruts, lacking public transportation aside from walking through the mud, with bodies of those dying from cholera left outside the homes of “rich” men, forcing them to bury the dead. The Korean royal family was “generously supported” and allowed to keep their palaces and titles forever as long as they didn’t interfere with the new Government or the people of the peninsula. Titles of nobility were given to influential Koreans who might cause trouble, and seventy-six new peers emerged from their mud huts. The Japanese assert that they spend ten million dollars a year on occupying Korea, claiming that with its needs for schools, roads, trees, sanitation, and many other things, the peninsula is a major burden for them. “Though it may be considered treason to say it now,” a high-ranking Japanese official in Seoul told me, “Korea will eventually gain its independence, once it can stand on its own and protect itself—and us—from the north.” This could have been just talk to mislead me, but I’ve encountered some Japanese who genuinely believe in this eventual outcome.
The American and European merchants in Korea think that the Japanese did on the whole better than any one else could have done in handling the situation, and that the Koreans cannot possibly govern themselves. So, for that matter, do most of the missionaries. Russia would have forced the Greek church upon the people, they say, but would have left the lowest form of inefficient and unsanitary burlesque 46on government. They would virtually have encouraged the persistence of ignorance and filth that made the Hermit Kingdom in every sense a stench to the nostrils of the world and a land of but two classes of people, the robbers and the robbed. “If Japan were to say to us to-morrow, ‘Here’s your country; run it yourselves,’” said a man who was trained to become prime minister under the old régime, “there are not bright men enough in it to form a cabinet.” The people have sometimes been made to suffer, the merchants go on, in such matters, for instance, as the taking of their land to build roads—for in old Korea as in China to-day highways were mere trespassers on private domain; but on the whole Japan has been no rougher than the United States or England in the countries they have taken over.
The American and European merchants in Korea believe that the Japanese, overall, managed the situation better than anyone else could have and that the Koreans can't possibly govern themselves. Most missionaries agree as well. They say Russia would have imposed the Greek church on the people but would have allowed a poorly run and unsanitary version of government to persist. They would have effectively supported the continuation of ignorance and filth, making the Hermit Kingdom a source of embarrassment for the world, with only two classes of people: the robbers and the robbed. “If Japan were to tell us tomorrow, ‘Here’s your country; govern it yourselves,’” said a man trained to be prime minister under the old regime, “there aren’t enough capable individuals to form a cabinet.” The merchants note that the people have sometimes suffered, such as when their land was taken to build roads—like in old Korea and today in China, highways were often seen as intruding on private property—but overall, Japan has not been any harsher than the United States or England in the territories they have taken over.
The agitation of Koreans for independence, the foreign laymen in the peninsula claim, emanates from self-seekers in foreign lands, and from the young students of mission schools, “especially American mission schools”; and the two “provisional governments,” one in the United States, and one, which has been in existence since the annexation, in Shanghai, do not at all represent the wishes of the Korean people as a whole. As it is, they are ground between the two millstones of the Japanese on the spot and these exiled governments, which send agents to make life miserable for those who fear one or both of them may some day come into power. Even the old politicians and office-holders are content, if we are to believe the men of commerce, now that even the Japanese have discovered that few military chiefs are of a type to make successful colonial governors, and that their subordinates, especially of the lower ranks, are almost always tactless, to say the least. But business men have a tendency the world over to praise anything that tends to keep “business as usual,” and one will probably come nearest the truth by striking a balance between their impressions and those of the missionaries, crediting the latter with somewhat more sincere, because less self-seeking, motives.
The push for independence among Koreans, according to foreign observers in the region, comes from self-interested individuals abroad and from young students in mission schools, “especially American mission schools”; and the two “provisional governments,” one in the United States and the other, which has existed since the annexation, in Shanghai, do not truly represent the desires of the Korean people as a whole. As it stands, they are caught between the pressures of the Japanese on the ground and these exiled governments, which send agents to make life difficult for those who worry that one or both might someday gain power. Even the older politicians and office-holders seem satisfied, if we believe the business people, now that even the Japanese recognize that few military leaders are suited to be successful colonial governors, and that their subordinates, especially those in lower ranks, are usually quite tactless, at the very least. However, business people have a tendency everywhere to praise anything that keeps “business as usual,” and it’s likely that the closest to the truth would be found by balancing their views with those of the missionaries, considering the latter to have somewhat more genuine motives, as they are less self-serving.
Whatever his personal opinion on the usefulness of foreign missions, no one with his eyes half open can set foot in Cho-sen without being impressed by the Christian influence, or at least by the number of missionaries, converts, and churches. He may be highly amused at the many subdivisions of that faith, by reason not merely of minor matters of creed and national lines but of such political cleavages as that caused by our Civil War, so nearly obliterated at home, which bewilder the natives like a countryman in a department-store with the wide choices of salvation offered them by—to mention only some of the 47American varieties—the “Northern” Presbyterians and the “Southern” Presbyterians, the “Northern” and the “Southern” Methodists, the Kansas Baptists and the Oklahoma High Rollers, for all I know, all guaranteed to give equal satisfaction. But the very intensity with which native converts regard these arbitrary lines of division, much slighter among the missionaries themselves, and the care which “Bible women” and country pastors take to keep their charges from wandering into any adjoining heretical sheepfold, is an evidence of the genuineness of their new beliefs.
No matter what he personally thinks about the value of foreign missions, anyone who’s paying attention can’t visit Korea without noticing the Christian influence, or at least seeing the number of missionaries, converts, and churches. He might find it quite entertaining to observe the many branches of that faith, not only because of minor theological differences or national backgrounds but also due to political divides like those from our Civil War, which have nearly faded at home. These divisions can confuse the locals, like a person from the countryside wandering through a department store with the countless options for salvation offered by—just to name a few of the American varieties—the “Northern” Presbyterians, the “Southern” Presbyterians, the “Northern” and the “Southern” Methodists, the Kansas Baptists and the Oklahoma High Rollers, who all promise the same level of satisfaction. However, the strong feelings that native converts have about these arbitrary divisions—much less intense among the missionaries themselves—and the efforts made by “Bible women” and local pastors to prevent their congregants from straying into any neighboring heretical group are clear signs of the sincerity of their new beliefs.
Whether or not Christianity is the one and only true faith, it seems to be an established fact that it thrives under persecution. Protestant mission work began in China in 1808, in Japan in 1859, but not until about 1888 in Korea; yet there is to-day only a scattering of native Christians in the two former countries as compared with the hordes of them in Korea. Many towns, even Ping Yang, second city of the peninsula, are almost more Christian than “pagan”; and the missionary boast that Korea will be a Christian land within a generation or two does not sound so wild as many another statement that drifts to the ear of the naturally skeptical wanderer. There is some evidence to show that this rapid progress is considerably due to those very Japanese who are least eager for the Christian faith to spread. The law of Japan and Korea grants absolute freedom of religious belief and practice, but even the passing layman can plainly detect something very close to persecution of Christians by some of the Japanese authorities in the peninsula, though it be only unconscious and unintentional, which it probably is not. While the Catholics have been there much longer, and have often carried things with a high hand, it is the Protestants in particular, and especially the American missionaries, who seem to have won most of the Japanese ill will. This I believe to be almost more because of the fact that they are Americans than because they are missionaries. As Americans they just naturally resent the lack of human liberty, of “self-determination,” to use the catchword of the hour, which Japanese rule in Korea means. The opposite point of view is bred in their bones. Though they never opened their lips on the subject, their mere unconscious attitude, their negative lack of approval of the existing state of things politically, cannot but seem to the Koreans an approval of their own opposition to the Japanese. Obviously, the study of American history, even of American literature, in the mission schools adds to the discontent of young Koreans with the present status of what was once their own country, even though the teachers lean over backward 48in the effort not to mix academic and political matters. In fact, while the missionaries might deny it, it may be that the Koreans are rallying in increasing numbers about the American sponsored churches as much under the mistaken impression that the Americans are secretly sympathetic to the throwing off of the alien yoke, even by violence if necessary, as from the conviction that the American brands of salvation are the only sure passwords at the celestial gates.
Whether or not Christianity is the only true faith, it’s clear that it thrives under persecution. Protestant mission work started in China in 1808 and in Japan in 1859, but not until around 1888 in Korea. Today, there’s only a small number of native Christians in China and Japan compared to the large populations in Korea. Many towns, including Ping Yang, the second-largest city on the peninsula, have a significant Christian presence, almost outnumbering the "pagan" population; and the missionary claim that Korea will become a Christian nation in a generation or two doesn’t seem as outrageous as some other statements that reach the ears of the naturally skeptical traveler. Some evidence suggests that this rapid growth is largely due to the very Japanese individuals who are least enthusiastic about the spread of Christianity. The laws in Japan and Korea allow complete freedom of religious belief and practice, but even a casual observer can see signs of something resembling persecution of Christians by some Japanese authorities in the peninsula, whether it’s unintentional or not. While Catholics have been in the area much longer and often take a strong-handed approach, it is particularly the Protestant missionaries, especially the American ones, who seem to have stirred up the most resentment among the Japanese. I believe this is more because they are Americans than because they are missionaries. As Americans, they naturally resent the lack of personal freedom and “self-determination,” a phrase that’s quite popular right now, which Japanese rule in Korea represents. A contrary perspective seems ingrained in them. Although they never explicitly express this sentiment, their mere unconscious attitude—an unspoken disapproval of the current political situation—must appear to Koreans as an endorsement of their own resistance against the Japanese. Clearly, the study of American history and literature in mission schools contributes to the growing discontent of young Koreans regarding their current status in what was once their own country, even though teachers may strive to keep academic and political issues separate. In fact, while the missionaries might deny it, it’s possible that Koreans are increasingly gathering around the American-sponsored churches partly because they mistakenly believe that Americans secretly support their struggle against foreign oppression, even if it requires violence, as well as because they think that the American versions of salvation are the only reliable entry points to the afterlife.
At any rate, the Japanese seem to have concluded that American missionaries were behind the independence movement of 1919, and that they are still not to be entirely trusted. Now, I am as certain as I am of anything in this uncertain world that not a single American missionary was in the conspiracy of the “Mansei” demonstration. A very few may have known something about it, at least have felt in the air that something was coming; but it was no business of theirs to turn tattletales and run to warn a Government which had usurped since most of them came to Korea and had not treated them with any notable kindness, besides having what should have been an ample supply of its own spies to pick up such information. But the Japanese have not our way of thinking. They are ready enough to have the missionaries render unto Cæsar what belongs to him by keeping out of politics, but at the same time they seem to expect them to lend a hand to the extent of passing on to the authorities any hints or rumors that may be of use to them.
At any rate, the Japanese seem to have concluded that American missionaries were behind the independence movement of 1919, and that they are still not to be entirely trusted. Now, I am as certain as I am of anything in this uncertain world that not a single American missionary was involved in the conspiracy of the “Mansei” demonstration. A very few may have known something about it, or at least sensed that something was coming; but it was no business of theirs to be snitches and run to warn a government that had usurped power since most of them arrived in Korea and had not treated them with any notable kindness, in addition to having what should have been an ample supply of its own spies to gather such information. But the Japanese don’t think like us. They are quick to expect missionaries to give to Cæsar what belongs to him by staying out of politics, but at the same time they seem to expect them to help out by passing on any hints or rumors that could be useful to the authorities.
However, the independence demonstration and the unwise acts it brought in its train have trailed off into history. The more intelligent Japanese officials seem to have seen the light and acquitted the American missionaries of any active and conscious part in it, and the new governor-general and his immediate aids even sometimes call them into conference to get their point of view on subjects in which they are involved. But there is still an undercurrent of something akin to persecution of the American churches. As in the case of the persistent rumors of police floggings in spite of the new law forbidding them, it is impossible to make certain whether this is due to deliberate disobedience of orders by recalcitrant subordinates, to secret instructions at variance with those made public, or to pure stupidity, of which the Japanese have their liberal quota. In every mission town there is a detective in charge of matters pertaining to missionaries. He attends all services, comes hotfooting it whenever a foreigner stops even for lunch at a mission, demanding information concerning him back to the nth degree of absurdity, asks the future plans of the church almost daily, and other stupid and impertinent questions. In some districts the police still literally hound the church—demand lists of all contributors, send spies to stand at the church door and take note of every Korean who enters, burst noisily in during prayer, order new women converts not to attend services. Even the missionaries strike one as being rather afraid of the police, though this may merely be due to their strenuous efforts to avoid giving further offense and to come more than half-way toward established friendship with the political authorities; it can easily be imagined how native pastors and the simple converts are affected by a brutal attitude.
However, the independence demonstration and the reckless actions that followed have faded into history. The more thoughtful Japanese officials seem to have recognized the truth and cleared the American missionaries of any active and intentional involvement in it. The new governor-general and his close advisors sometimes even invite them to meetings to get their insights on relevant issues. Yet, there’s still a lingering sense of something like persecution against American churches. Just like the ongoing rumors of police beatings despite the new law banning them, it’s hard to tell if this is due to willful disobedience by stubborn subordinates, secret orders that contradict public ones, or pure incompetence, of which the Japanese have their share. In every mission town, there is a detective responsible for missionary-related matters. He attends all services, rushes over whenever a foreigner stops by for even a quick lunch at a mission, demanding information about them to an absurd degree, asks about the church’s future plans almost daily, and poses other dumb and intrusive questions. In some areas, the police still aggressively target the church—demanding lists of all contributors, sending spies to stand at the church door and take note of every Korean who enters, barging in during prayer, and telling new women converts not to attend services. Even the missionaries seem somewhat afraid of the police, although this might just be their effort to avoid causing more trouble and to show goodwill toward the political authorities; it’s easy to imagine how native pastors and the simple converts are affected by such a harsh attitude.

A chicken peddler in Seoul
A chicken seller in Seoul

A full load
A full load

The plowman homeward wends his weary way—in Korean fashion, always carrying the plow and driving his unburdened ox or bull before him; one of the most common sights of Korea
The plowman makes his tired journey home—following the Korean way, always carrying the plow and guiding his unburdened ox or bull in front of him; one of the most familiar sights in Korea.

The biblical “watch-tower in a cucumber patch” is in evidence all over Korea in the summer, when crops begin to ripen. Whole families often sleep in them during this season, when they spring up all over the country, and often afford the only cool breeze
The biblical "watchtower in a cucumber patch" is visible all over Korea in the summer when crops start to ripen. Entire families often sleep in them during this season, as they pop up all over the country, providing the only cool breeze.
49Christian students in government schools often report that they have secretly been ordered to quit the church. There seems to be little doubt that the Japanese foster the student strikes which are increasingly becoming the bane of mission schools, now with demands for a Korean principal in place of an American who has grown gray in that position, now that no teacher be hired who has not been educated in Japan or Korea, or that there shall be no studying of the Bible in school—almost prima facie evidence of Japanese influence. All this cuts both ways in separating the Koreans and the foreigners. When the strikes reach the point of demanding that laboratory or library equipment be improved, notwithstanding that every tack in the school wall is due to American charity toward the strikers, the ordinary human being finds himself wishing that the missionaries would forget their unnatural patience and boot the strikers down the front steps. Permits are required for everything under the sun—to be pastor, to build a new church, even to solicit contributions to mission hospitals. The Japanese meddle with hospitals, schools, and churches in ways which even they could not possibly believe are excusable. The missionaries have to submit to their dictation as to curriculum; they even have to make their school year conform to the Japanese custom and teach in July. Perhaps the greatest hardship the missionaries have to endure is the constant dread that their sick children will be carried off to Japanese isolation wards, on the pretext that contagious diseases cannot be properly isolated in mission hospitals, and there virtually killed by being given only Japanese food, lack of beds, and treatment, while the parents may not even be allowed to see them.
49Christian students in public schools often say they've been secretly told to leave the church. It's pretty clear that the Japanese are encouraging the student protests that are increasingly causing problems for mission schools. They're now demanding a Korean principal instead of the American who's been in that role for years, insisting that no teachers be hired unless they’ve been educated in Japan or Korea, and that there's no Bible study in schools—almost clear evidence of Japanese influence. All this drives a wedge between Koreans and foreigners. When the protests escalate to the point of demanding better laboratory or library equipment, even though every nail in the school wall is thanks to American generosity towards the strikers, the average person finds themselves wishing the missionaries would stop being so patient and just kick the strikers out. You need permits for everything—to be a pastor, to build a new church, even to ask for donations for mission hospitals. The Japanese interfere with hospitals, schools, and churches in ways that even they couldn't possibly justify. The missionaries have to follow their rules regarding the curriculum; they even have to adjust their school year to follow Japanese customs and teach in July. Perhaps the toughest challenge for the missionaries is the ongoing fear that their sick children will be taken to Japanese isolation wards, under the excuse that contagious diseases can't be adequately isolated in mission hospitals, and there they could be neglected, given only Japanese food, with a lack of beds and treatment, while their parents may not even be allowed to visit them.
All books by foreigners must be fully printed before being submitted to the police censor, who will not look at manuscript. Three days before publication two copies of the finished book must be in his 50hands, and if any of the contents is considered objectionable the whole edition is confiscated. Christian schools are often called out to meet officials on Sunday, or teacher’s examinations are given on that day with a frequency that could scarcely be coincidence. The requirement that all children in government schools shall bow down before a picture of the mikado in an attitude of worship is of course a constant thorn in the side of the Christians. The authorities claim that American mission students have no discipline, which is probably true from the Japanese point of view, in that they are not told just what they should think and do on every possible subject and occasion. In their published maps of Korean towns the Japanese rarely give any signs of the existence of Christian establishments, though these are often many years old and the most prominent institutions in the place. On the other hand, when their travels take them out of their own orbit the missionaries almost always go to Korean hotels instead of patronizing the foreign ones under Japanese management, but old custom and the high prices of the latter could easily account for this without including a suggestion of pique.
All books by foreign authors must be fully printed before being submitted to the police censor, who will not review any manuscripts. Three days before publication, two copies of the finished book must be in his 50 hands, and if any of the content is deemed objectionable, the entire edition will be confiscated. Christian schools are often called out to meet with officials on Sundays, or teacher examinations are scheduled on that day with a frequency that can hardly be coincidental. The requirement for all children in government schools to bow before a picture of the mikado in a worshipful manner is, of course, a constant source of tension for Christians. Authorities claim that American mission students lack discipline, which may be accurate from the Japanese perspective, as they are not instructed on how to think and act in every situation. In published maps of Korean towns, the Japanese rarely acknowledge the existence of Christian institutions, even though these often have a long history and are among the most prominent establishments in the area. Meanwhile, when missionaries travel outside their usual circles, they almost always choose Korean hotels instead of the foreign ones managed by the Japanese. However, traditional practices and the high prices of the latter could easily explain this choice without suggesting any resentment.
Personally I came to the conclusion that, while both are in evidence, it is the thick-headedness of the rank-and-file Japanese more than deliberate persecution which causes the continued friction between the two peoples who are doing the most for the regeneration of Korea. I might cite a typical case in point. Over near Gensan on the east coast the missionaries have a private summer resort, half a hundred houses and a beach, all enclosed within purchased grounds. But as the Japanese are very insistent in matters which they conceive to involve the equality of their race to the rest of the world, they refuse to let the missionaries keep the townspeople off their beach. Now, the bathing demeanor of the Japanese, innocent and proper though it may be to those who like it, is decidedly not suited to a place where American women and children come to spend their summers. So by dint of coaxing and explaining their own peculiar point of view, the Americans got the authorities at Gensan to post a notice that no one should bathe on the missionary beach unless arrayed in proper swimming costume. The Japanese of course are notoriously law-abiding. One afternoon when I found time to join my family on that beach a big limousine stood at the edge of the sand, and several dignified middle-aged men who might have been bankers or lawyers from the city were disporting themselves in perfectly respectable bathing-suits. But when I chanced to glance about a little later, one of them stood within ten feet of us, 51stripped stark naked as he calmly and leisurely changed from swimming to street costume, and two others were in the act of disrobing for the same purpose. I feel sure that they had no intention whatever of being offensive toward the dozen or more American women about them; probably their limited minds really thought that they were complying with both the letter and the spirit of the posted order and the desires of those who inspired it by wearing bathing costumes while in the water, and getting into and out of them on the open beach. When I addressed them with an unmissionary vehemence that might have landed me in a police station if they had chosen to make the most of it, they apologized hastily for the unwitting offense and hurried off to the privacy of the limousine. The Japanese in Korea are spending large sums in the effort to make certain of the beaches of the peninsula popular with foreigners, and quite likely some of these bankerly-looking gentlemen were involved in the scheme; but none of them still have any clear conception, probably, of why no beach can ever be popular with foreigners as long as Japanese also have the right of admission to it.
Personally, I've come to the conclusion that, although both factors are present, it's more the ignorance of the average Japanese than intentional persecution that causes the ongoing friction between the two groups working hardest for Korea's recovery. A typical example can be found near Gensan on the east coast, where the missionaries have a private summer resort with about fifty houses and a beach, all within purchased property. However, since the Japanese are very assertive about issues they believe pertain to the equality of their race with the rest of the world, they refuse to let the missionaries keep the local townspeople off their beach. Now, while the Japanese's bathing attire may seem innocent and appropriate to those who appreciate it, it's definitely not suitable for a place where American women and children spend their summers. After a lot of coaxing and explaining their unique perspective, the Americans managed to convince the Gensan authorities to post a notice stating that no one should swim on the missionary beach without wearing proper swimwear. The Japanese are, of course, famously law-abiding. One afternoon, when I finally joined my family on that beach, a large limousine was parked at the edge of the sand, and several dignified middle-aged men—who could have been bankers or lawyers from the city—were enjoying themselves in perfectly respectable swimsuits. But when I glanced around a little later, one of them was standing within ten feet of us, completely naked as he casually changed from his swimsuit to his street clothes, while two others were in the process of undressing for the same reason. I'm sure they had no intention of being offensive to the dozen or so American women nearby; they probably thought they were following both the letter and the spirit of the posted order and the wishes of those who initiated it by wearing swimwear while in the water and changing in the open beach. When I confronted them with uncharacteristic intensity that could have gotten me in trouble if they'd chosen to escalate the situation, they quickly apologized for the unintended offense and rushed off to the privacy of their limousine. The Japanese in Korea are investing large amounts of money to make the peninsula's beaches appealing to foreigners, and it's quite possible that some of these banker-looking gentlemen were part of that effort; yet, they likely still don't fully understand why no beach can ever be popular with foreigners as long as Japanese also have the right to access it.
Missionaries after all are only human beings, as they themselves are the first to admit, and we do not expect the supernatural of them even in such a matter as meekly accepting the abuse of what they more or less regard as a usurping and alien political power over a people the benefiting of whom they consider their life-work. Many of the Americans in the mission field have been in Korea far longer than the Japanese. Some have lived there so long, according to those foreigners of another class who see them as dangers to their precious “business as usual,” that “they think they own the country and can countenance no changes in it, not even improvements. They used to do exactly as they liked, and they hate the least suggestion of coercion.” We should remember that the missionaries had the advantages of extraterritoriality in Korea before the Japanese came, and they cannot but resent the loss of it, the submitting to alien rulers whose ideas of everything, from housing to justice, are so widely different from their own. Moreover, though they readily admit that the Japanese are doing many things for the good of the peninsula, they see them primarily as men with an ax to grind.
Missionaries are just human beings, as they themselves will tell you, and we don't expect them to be superhuman, even when it comes to dealing with the abuse of what they see as an illegitimate and foreign political power over a community they believe is part of their life's work. Many Americans in the mission field have been in Korea longer than the Japanese. Some have been there so long that other foreigners, who view them as threats to their precious "business as usual," claim that "they think they own the country and can't tolerate any changes, even if they're improvements. They used to do whatever they wanted, and they despise even the slightest hint of coercion." We should remember that missionaries had the benefits of extraterritoriality in Korea before the Japanese took over, and they can’t help but resent losing that, having to submit to foreign rulers whose views on everything, from housing to justice, are so different from their own. Furthermore, while they acknowledge that the Japanese are doing many things for the benefit of the peninsula, they mostly see them as people with a personal agenda.
It would be strange, if it were not long since commonplace, to see how sharp national lines remain even among men who think they are working above nationalities, how completely even men of strong ideals succumb to their environment. The American missionaries in Japan say that there is some reason for the Japanese to be suspicious of the 52American missionaries in Korea. They agree with the officials there, who contend that those destined for mission work in the Korean field should first have a year in Japan, that they may judge more fairly the Japanese national point of view. Even those in Korea, after ten to forty years’ residence there, cannot agree on many of the points involved, so how can a mere passer-by be expected to get at the exact truth of the matter? He can merely decide that there is some reason on both sides, with perhaps a private opinion as to which one is most inclined to tamper with the scales, and let it go at that. Friction is gradually decreasing, as the Japanese and Americans become more able to talk together—generally in Korean; and as there is no doubt that Japan has the good of Cho-sen and its people at heart—as an integral part of the Japanese Empire—constant improvement may confidently be expected.
It would be odd, if it weren't already so common, to see how strong national identities persist even among people who believe they're working above national differences, and how completely even those with strong ideals can be influenced by their surroundings. American missionaries in Japan note that there are valid reasons for the Japanese to be wary of American missionaries in Korea. They agree with the officials there, who argue that those going into missionary work in Korea should first spend a year in Japan to gain a more accurate understanding of the Japanese perspective. Even those who have lived in Korea for ten to forty years can't agree on many of the issues at play, so how could a temporary visitor be expected to uncover the full truth? They can only conclude that there are valid points on both sides and maybe form a personal opinion about which side might be more likely to manipulate the situation, and leave it at that. Tensions are slowly easing as Japanese and Americans learn to communicate better—often in Korean; and since it’s clear that Japan has the welfare of Korea and its people in mind—as a vital part of the Japanese Empire—steady progress can be confidently anticipated.
CHAPTER IV
OFF THE BEATEN PATH IN CHO-SEN
Perhaps it is because I was properly “Japalacked” that I was able to wander at will about Korea by train, steamer, Ford, rickshaw, and on foot without the annoyance of that constant police supervision and the incessant showing of my passport of which many other travelers have complained. Once, long ago, when the Japanese were at war with Russia, I was arrested forty-eight times during thirty-six days of wandering through Japan, and while the experience was much more amusing than serious, there was nothing to be gained by repeating it. So I took the trouble this time to satisfy Japanese inquisitiveness at headquarters beforehand, and while I may have been, and probably was, under more or less surveillance during my six weeks in Korea, I am sure that many of my jaunts were known so shortly in advance even to myself that no detective could have kept constant track of me. Certainly no visible attempt was made to keep me from going when and where I chose, and talking with whomever I wished.
Maybe it’s because I was officially “Japalacked” that I was able to freely travel around Korea by train, boat, Ford, rickshaw, and on foot without the hassle of constant police supervision and the never-ending need to show my passport, something that many other travelers complained about. A long time ago, when the Japanese were at war with Russia, I was arrested forty-eight times over thirty-six days of exploring Japan. While that experience was a lot more amusing than serious, there was no point in going through it again. So this time, I made sure to address Japanese curiosity at headquarters beforehand, and while I might have been, and probably was, under some sort of surveillance during my six weeks in Korea, I’m certain that many of my outings were known to me only shortly in advance, so no detective could have kept track of me all the time. There were definitely no visible efforts made to prevent me from going wherever I wanted, whenever I wanted, and talking to whoever I chose.
A missionary Ford carried me off once to the gaunt hills to the east of Seoul. Even the “great roads” in the interior of Korea are much like the caminos reales of Spanish America—“great” or “royal” only in the name they bear. In places there are what the Japanese call “highways,” but even these seldom have bridges worthy the name, some being mere sod-covered logs, others dirt-and-branch foundations under concrete, or nothing at all but the crudest of ferries. In the rainy season whole treeless hillsides wash away and force traveling missionaries to sell their Fords and walk home. Though the weather of Korea is on the whole much better than that of Japan, the floods of summer are naturally severe in a mountainous and deforested country. In Seoul it rained incessantly day after day during much of July and August, sometimes with barely half an hour of cloudy clearness from dawn till dark. Many villages and some thirty miles of railroad were under water, and countless bridges were made at least temporarily impassable. Men waded waist-deep in the flooded rice-fields, raking 54out the duckweed with which these were covered, and which would choke the rice when the water subsided. Clothing and shoes molded overnight. In other parts of the country, such as Ping Yang district, there was less rain than the peasants asked for, though the almost tropical heat was everywhere and incessantly in evidence.
A missionary Ford once took me to the rugged hills east of Seoul. Even the so-called “great roads” in the interior of Korea are similar to the royal roads of Spanish America—“great” or “royal” only in name. In some areas, there are what the Japanese refer to as “highways,” but even these rarely have proper bridges—some are just sod-covered logs, others are dirt-and-branch foundations under concrete, or simply the most basic ferries. During the rainy season, entire treeless hillsides erode, forcing traveling missionaries to sell their Fords and walk home. Although Korea's weather is generally better than Japan's, the summer floods are naturally severe in a mountainous and deforested region. In Seoul, it rained non-stop day after day for much of July and August, sometimes with barely half an hour of cloudy brightness from dawn to dusk. Many villages and about thirty miles of railroad were submerged, and countless bridges became temporarily impassable. People waded waist-deep in flooded rice fields, scraping off the duckweed that had covered them, which would choke the rice once the water receded. Clothes and shoes molded overnight. In other parts of the country, like Ping Yang district, there was less rain than the farmers needed, though the nearly tropical heat was consistently felt everywhere.
Even one of the most fair-minded of guide-book writers speaks of the Koreans as “incredibly lazy”—proof that he saw much more of the old capital and its vacant-minded yangbans than of the country districts. If he had ever toiled for a day in the blazing rice-fields, even driven a bull knee-deep in mud through them, or carried a “jiggy” load along the narrow paths between them, he might have been of a different opinion. In a land where agriculture is the national industry, where four-fifths of the population still remain living among and tilling the hills of their forefathers, their horizon bounded by their own narrow valley and the nearest market town, there can scarcely be general indolence. The Koreans in the mass are not lazy; but life means to them something more than incessant exertion merely for exertion’s sake, and they amble along even at work as if there were never any hurry to do anything or get anywhere, quite the antithesis of the busy little Japanese. With some such foot-note as this to one accusation against them, it is easy to agree with the man who put it so well, that the Koreans “are garrulous yet inarticulate, stolid yet excitable, frugal yet improvident, lazy yet lashed by necessity to strenuous efforts.” A childlike people on the whole, one is likely to conclude from weeks of wandering among them, happy-go-lucky, with little tendency of laying up for a rainy day, a trait in which they are widely at variance with their present rulers.
Even one of the most fair-minded guidebook writers describes the Koreans as “incredibly lazy”—a clear indication that he spent more time in the old capital, surrounded by its vacant-minded yangbans, than in the rural areas. If he had ever worked for a day in the scorching rice fields, driven a bull through mud, or carried a heavy load along the narrow paths between them, he might have thought differently. In a country where agriculture is the main industry, and where four-fifths of the population still lives and works on the land of their ancestors, with their view limited to their own narrow valley and the nearest market town, there’s hardly any general laziness. The Koreans, as a whole, aren’t lazy; for them, life means more than just endless toil for the sake of working. They tend to take things easy, even when they’re working, as if there’s no rush to do anything or go anywhere, which is quite the opposite of the busy little Japanese. With some sort of explanation like this for one of the accusations against them, it’s easy to agree with the person who said that the Koreans “are chatty yet hard to read, stoic yet easily excited, thrifty yet reckless, lazy yet driven by necessity to put in hard work.” After spending weeks among them, one might conclude that they are generally childlike, carefree, and not inclined to save for a rainy day—a characteristic that sets them apart from their current rulers.
In June the peasants were still spreading over the fields the decomposed oak-leaves used as fertilizer, but by early July the transplanting of rice began, soon to be followed by the weeding. Gangs pull up the closely grown seedlings and tie them in bundles, which they throw out across the fields to be planted with an expertness which reminds one that their national pastime, at least in pre-Japanese days, was stone-throwing. The earth-laden roots being much the heavier end, the bundles unfailingly land upright just where the thrower chooses to place them. A line of six to a dozen men and women move slowly across each flooded field, replanting the grasses one by one, and everywhere the green, low, flat country is dotted with hundreds of near-white figures rooting in the soft, flooded earth. That no space may be wasted, beans are often planted on the tops of the dikes between the paddy-fields. 55Frogs sing their lugubrious chorus far and wide, little realizing the unwisdom of betraying themselves to the beautiful ibis which feed upon them. At weeding-time whole villages join together in great gangs, with drums, fifes, brass cans, and all manner of native noise-producers, to make a festival of the task, singing as they weed. The men, stripped to the waist and burned a permanent brown, display leathery skins that glisten red-brown in the sunshine, like a well polished russet shoe. Yet many a peasant uses a yellow fan as he works. Where irrigation calls for the lifting of water from a ditch to the fields, a man leisurely swings all day long an enormous wooden spoon suspended in a little framework. If the work calls for shoveling, one man holds the handle of the implement and two or three others lift it by the ropes attached to the shaft, precisely like the people of the Lebanon far across on the opposite edge of Asia. The Korean is famed for his kindness to his bulls, almost his only draft-animals now that his savage little stallion ponies have become so scarce, and it is the commonest of sights to meet a peasant lugging his wooden plow on his own broad back while the bull strolls lazily homeward before him.
In June, the farmers were still spreading decomposed oak leaves as fertilizer across the fields, but by early July, they started transplanting rice, soon followed by weeding. Groups of workers pull up the densely packed seedlings and tie them in bundles, which they then toss across the fields with a skill that reminds one of their national pastime, at least before Japanese influence, which was stone-throwing. The heavier earth-covered roots ensure that the bundles always land upright exactly where the thrower intends. A line of six to a dozen men and women moves slowly across each flooded field, replanting the grasses one by one, and everywhere the green, low, flat landscape is dotted with hundreds of near-white figures digging in the soft, flooded earth. To maximize space, beans are often planted on top of the dikes between the paddy fields. 55 Frogs sing their mournful chorus far and wide, not realizing the danger of revealing themselves to the beautiful ibises that feed on them. During weeding season, entire villages come together in large groups, equipped with drums, flutes, brass cans, and various homemade noise-makers, turning the chore into a festival while singing as they work. The men, stripped to the waist and sun-baked to a permanent brown, show leathery skin that glistens red-brown in the sunlight, like a well-polished russet shoe. Yet many farmers use yellow fans as they labor. Where irrigation requires lifting water from a ditch to the fields, a man swings a large wooden spoon suspended in a little framework all day long at a leisurely pace. For tasks that involve shoveling, one person holds the shovel's handle while two or three others lift it with ropes attached to the shaft, just like people in Lebanon on the other side of Asia. The Korean is known for being kind to his bulls, which are almost the only draft animals left since his small savage ponies have become so rare, and it’s a common sight to see a farmer carrying his wooden plow on his sturdy back while the bull casually walks home in front of him.
Korea is a land of villages, not of cities, nor yet of isolated peasant houses, so that the broad flooded country is usually unbroken clear to the foot-hills of distant ranges, unless a town, its thatched roofs slicked down to the women’s hair, intervenes. Here stands a stone monument with a roof over it to commemorate the wife who died of grief for her departed husband, or at least refused resolutely to remarry, a noble example, by Oriental standards, to all her sex. Farther on several upright granite slabs flanking the road announce themselves as erected by grateful citizens in honor of departed magistrates, though the deep-cut Chinese characters upon them usually express anything but the real public sentiment toward these village looters. Babies suckling like shotes mothers stretched out on the floors of open houses, babies eating great green cucumbers, skin and all, babies wailing as one seldom hears them in Japan, are among the most constant details of any Korean village landscape. Among the fixed customs of the country is the burning off of the hair over the soft spot of an infant’s head, and most Koreans preserve this little round bald place throughout their lives.
Korea is a land of villages, not cities, and not just isolated farmhouses, so the wide, flooded countryside usually stretches all the way to the foothills of distant mountains, unless there’s a town with thatched roofs flattened down like women's hairstyles in between. Here stands a stone monument with a roof over it to honor a wife who died of grief for her lost husband or at least firmly refused to remarry, a remarkable example, by Eastern standards, for all women. Further along, several upright granite slabs lining the road announce themselves as being put up by grateful citizens in memory of past magistrates, though the deeply engraved Chinese characters on them often convey anything but genuine public sentiment toward these village oppressors. Babies suckling at their mothers stretched out on the floors of open houses, babies munching on big green cucumbers, skin and all, babies crying in a way you hardly ever hear in Japan, are some of the most common sights in any Korean village. Among the traditional customs of the country is burning off the hair over the soft spot on an infant’s head, and most Koreans keep this little round bald spot for their entire lives.
In July lettuce and green onions are everywhere, adding a still greener tinge to the landscape. Men sleep anywhere in the middle of the day, on the narrow paddy dikes, at the roadside, in the road itself, naked to the waist but with their ridiculous horsehair hats still in place. You will find them still working at dusk, however, and before the mists 56begin to rise under the morning sun. Koreans of the masses never seem to sleep, or to eat, all at once. The children have no fixed hours of going to bed, nor beds to go to for that matter, so that they grow up able to doze off anywhere at any time. Like the Japanese, the race shows the effects of poor beds and piecemeal, catch-as-catch-can slumber. One by one each member of the family lies down, still fully clothed, on the brown-paper floor of the house as the whim strikes him, and drifts away into more or less sound slumber, while all the domestic life steps in and out among and over the sleepers. No matter at what hour of the night one passes through a village some of its people will be squatting on their porches or chattering inside. As crops approach the ripening stage, little watch-towers, like thatched dove-cotes, rise high on their pole legs all over the country, and by night he who comes strolling along almost any road will hear some or all the family within beating the little elevated shack with a stick or singing some weird old song as a protection against the myriad evil spirits which roam the darkness.
In July, lettuce and green onions are everywhere, adding a fresh green touch to the landscape. Men nap wherever they can during the day, on the narrow paddy dikes, alongside the road, or even in the road itself, shirtless but still wearing their ridiculous horsehair hats. However, you’ll see them working again at dusk, and before the morning sun brings in the mist. The masses of Koreans never seem to sleep or eat all at once. Children have no set bedtime or actual beds, so they grow up able to doze off anywhere, anytime. Like the Japanese, this group shows the effects of poor sleeping conditions and irregular sleep. One by one, each family member lies down, still fully dressed, on the brown-paper floor of the house whenever they feel like it, drifting into varying degrees of sleep while daily life continues around them. No matter what time of night you walk through a village, some of its people will be sitting on their porches or chatting inside. As crops near ripening, little watchtowers, resembling thatched dove-cotes, pop up on poles all over the country, and at night, anyone strolling along almost any road will hear some or all of the family inside, beating the elevated shack with a stick or singing some strange old song to ward off the countless evil spirits that wander in the dark.
I have said that the national pastime of Korea was—for it seems now almost to have died out—the throwing of stones. In Cho-sen this game more or less took the place of jiu-jitsu in Japan, and in the olden days whole villages lined up on opposite sides, led by their chief bullies and most expert throwers, the women often piling up stones within easy reach of the warriors, and the festivities did not end until several were badly injured, if not actually killed. Koreans still have the reputation of being the most accurate stone-throwers in the world, as more than one unwelcome stranger has learned to his dismay during some dispute with a group of villagers. Under the influence of both Japanese and American residents this faculty is being turned to another account, and Korean baseball teams have already beaten more than once the best aggregations which our countrymen in the peninsula can muster.
I’ve mentioned that Korea’s national pastime was, though it seems to have faded away now, throwing stones. In Korea, this game somewhat replaced jiu-jitsu in Japan, and back in the day, entire villages faced off against each other, led by their strongest fighters and best throwers. Women often collected stones for easy access by the fighters, and the events didn’t wrap up until several people got seriously hurt, if not killed. Koreans are still known to be the most precise stone-throwers in the world, as more than one unwanted visitor has discovered the hard way during a disagreement with a group of villagers. Thanks to the influence of both Japanese and American residents, this skill is being redirected, and Korean baseball teams have already beaten some of the best teams that our fellow countrymen on the peninsula can put together.
One has moments of doubt in Korea about the accuracy of the “survival of the fittest” theory. The Koreans are superior to their rulers in mental quickness, certainly in physique, and probably in some moral qualities. This straighter, stronger-looking race seem big men beside the pushing little dwarfs who have subjected them—though I found that the largest native socks and shoes were nearly two inches too short for my own by no means oversize Caucasian foot. That they are brighter, or at least of swifter mental processes, than the Japanese, I am personally convinced by numerous little episodes within my own 57experience. There was the guide I had in the Diamond Mountains, for instance, only to cite one of many similar examples. He was just an ordinary jiggy-coom, a porter with the Korean carry-all on his back; yet though neither of us knew a word of the same language, we had not the least difficulty in exchanging all the thoughts we needed to during a four-day journey, by signs and gestures. I have yet to see the Japanese who would not have failed dismally under similar circumstances, and not merely because gestures mean nothing to the people of Japan. We arrived one evening at a temple-housed hotel run by the government railways, and the Japanese in charge, though he had much more education than my guide, and spoke considerable more or less English, displayed his racial density to such a degree that I was forced to call in the Korean carrier as an interpreter. Entirely in the language of signs and a few monosyllabic place-names he caught the idea perfectly, and passed it on, in one tenth the time I had already spent trying to drive it through the skull of the son of Nippon.
One sometimes doubts the accuracy of the “survival of the fittest” theory in Korea. The Koreans are definitely quicker mentally, certainly stronger physically, and probably have some superior moral qualities compared to their rulers. This taller, more robust-looking race seems like giants next to the small, pushy figures who have dominated them—although I found that the largest native socks and shoes were nearly two inches too short for my not-so-large Caucasian foot. I am personally convinced, through many little instances in my own experience, that they are smarter, or at least think faster, than the Japanese. Take my guide in the Diamond Mountains, for example, just an ordinary porter with a Korean carry-all on his back; despite neither of us knowing a word of each other’s language, we had no trouble communicating everything we needed during our four-day journey using signs and gestures. I have yet to meet a Japanese person who wouldn't have struggled greatly in similar circumstances, not just because gestures carry little meaning for them. One evening, we arrived at a government-run hotel at a temple, and the Japanese person in charge, despite being much more educated and speaking a fair amount of English, showed such a lack of understanding that I had to bring in the Korean porter as an interpreter. Using only signs and a few simple place names, he understood the idea perfectly and conveyed it in a fraction of the time I had spent trying to explain it to the Japanese man. 57
But while many Koreans possess an alert mentality, this is often offset by superstitions, prejudices, conceit, and the lack of initiative and perseverance. They seem to have been slaves to clan or village opinion for so long that they can seldom assert themselves individually. They learn elementary things quickly, but they are prone to run out of steam in the higher reaches. One gets the impression that they have less self-control, that they are undisciplined, both by training and temperament, compared to the Japanese. Unlike the Chinese, they will fight upon slight provocation, which may be another proof of a lack of self-control as well as of manliness. Such things as school strikes against missionaries who have given them long and unselfish service to the full extent of their resources indicate but little sense of gratitude. Even their most friendly foreign teachers admit that almost any of them will cheat at examinations if given the opportunity. Their cruelty, or at least indifference to the suffering of others, is perhaps as much an Oriental as merely a Korean trait. In the village just over the hills from Seoul near which we made our Korean headquarters an old man was found ill and half starved in a straw hut in the outskirts. If the foreign gentry who pass that way almost every day take no notice of him, the villagers evidently asked themselves, why should we? But the first information the foreigners had of the invalid or his condition was when our host happened one day to see him lying all but naked beside a muddy stream, apparently trying to drink, his skin mere parchment stretched tightly over his bones. The American gave the villagers 58a note to the mission hospital and paid some of them to carry the old man there on an improvised stretcher. Next morning nothing had been done. Called to account, the villagers explained that they had decided not to take him to the hospital, because he would only die soon anyway, and if they buried him themselves it would cost less, they thought, than if the hospital did so and then made the village pay for it.
But while many Koreans have a quick-thinking mindset, this is often balanced out by superstitions, biases, arrogance, and a lack of initiative and perseverance. They seem to have been so influenced by clan or village opinions for so long that they can rarely assert themselves as individuals. They pick up basic concepts quickly, but they tend to lose motivation when it comes to more advanced topics. It feels like they have less self-control and are less disciplined, both in terms of training and personality, compared to the Japanese. Unlike the Chinese, they will react aggressively over minor provocations, which might indicate a lack of self-control and also of strength. Incidents like school protests against missionaries who have provided them with considerable and selfless support show little sense of gratitude. Even their most supportive foreign teachers acknowledge that nearly any of them will cheat on exams if given the chance. Their cruelty, or at least their indifference to the suffering of others, may be as much an Oriental trait as it is specifically a Korean one. In the village just over the hills from Seoul, where we set up our Korean headquarters, an old man was found sick and almost starving in a straw hut on the outskirts. If the foreign visitors who pass that way nearly every day ignore him, the villagers understandably ask themselves, why should we care? But the first time foreigners learned about the sick man or his condition was when our host happened to see him lying almost naked beside a muddy stream, seemingly trying to drink, his skin like parchment stretched tightly over his bones. The American gave the villagers a note for the mission hospital and paid some of them to carry the old man there on a makeshift stretcher. The next morning, nothing had been done. When questioned, the villagers explained that they had decided not to take him to the hospital because they thought he would just die soon anyway, and that burying him themselves would cost less than if the hospital did it and then charged the village for it.
It seems to be Japanese policy to keep deformity out of sight, but Korean instinct and custom work to the same end. The native teachers of a mission school vociferously objected to admitting a particularly brilliant candidate—because he had only one eye! “If this thing goes on,” one of the teachers raged, “we’ll be nothing but a collection of cripples,” and to illustrate the point he sprang up and humped himself across the floor like a paralytic, with the dramatic effect at which the Koreans are adepts. Whatever his opinion of the Japanese in that respect, no one would accuse the Koreans of having no sense of humor, though they are much more solemn of demeanor than the Chinese. An American resident who carries a massive old watch that once belonged to his grandfather drew it out one day as he was leaving a railway station—whereupon a Korean boy wearing the jiggy of the porter’s calling promptly backed up to the watch and solemnly asked if he should transport it. There is less curiosity, or at least less child- or monkey-like inquisitiveness about the Koreans than their immediate neighbors either to the east or west display, more personal dignity, one feels, and the stranger does not collect a following half as easily as even in Japan. It is true, however, that villagers poke holes in the paper walls of any inn-room housing foreigners, and missionary ladies are obliged to carry a complete curtain-room with them on their travels in the interior. Superstitions are still rife, for all the outside influence, and some of them take quaint forms. As in Haiti, it is a common thing to have a pedestrian dash across the road in front of a moving automobile just as it seems to be upon him, the idea being to get rid of the evil spirit which dogs his heels like his shadow, either by having it crushed beneath the wheels or attaching itself to the motorist. In fact, there are many little suggestions of the black man’s republic of the West Indies about Korea—Napoleon beards, little pipes, thatched market-stalls and the tiny transactions they are willing to make, the custom of sleeping peacefully at the roadside or in the roadway wherever the whim overtakes them, the same swing of the women carrying burdens on their heads, a similar carelessness about exposure of the person.
It seems to be a Japanese policy to keep deformity hidden, but Korean instincts and customs aim for the same result. The native teachers at a mission school strongly opposed admitting a particularly talented candidate—because he had only one eye! “If this continues,” one of the teachers exclaimed angrily, “we’ll just be a bunch of cripples,” and to make his point, he jumped up and humped himself across the floor like someone paralyzed, showcasing the dramatic flair that Koreans excel at. Regardless of his views on the Japanese in that regard, no one would claim that Koreans lack a sense of humor, even though they appear more serious than the Chinese. An American resident who owns a hefty old watch that belonged to his grandfather took it out one day while leaving a train station—whereupon a Korean boy dressed like a porter promptly backed up to the watch and soberly asked if he should carry it. Koreans are generally less curious, or at least less childishly inquisitive, compared to their neighbors to the east or west; they seem to carry more personal dignity, making it far less likely for a stranger to gather a crowd like they would in Japan. However, it is true that villagers will poke holes in the paper walls of any inn room where foreigners stay, and missionary women have to bring a full portable curtain with them when they travel in the countryside. Superstitions still abound despite outside influences, and some have quirky forms. Like in Haiti, it’s common for someone to dash across the road in front of a moving car just as it seems they will be hit, to rid themselves of the evil spirit that follows them like a shadow, either by getting it crushed under the wheels or transferring it to the motorist. In fact, there are many little reminders of the West Indies in Korea—the Napoleon-style beards, small pipes, thatched market stalls and the tiny transactions they engage in, the custom of napping casually by the roadside or in the middle of the street whenever the mood strikes them, and a similar ease with which women carry loads on their heads, along with a comparable disregard for modesty.
59It is still an ordinary experience for a Korean bride to discover when she enters her future home that she is only her husband’s “Number 3” wife—yet all the children she may bear him are considered as belonging to Wife Number 1. Nine-tenths of the suspensions from the church, at least among Protestant converts, are for concubinage; most of the rest are for marrying “heathen.” I have already mentioned that the missionaries insist that Korean women are very modest, particularly as compared to their Japanese sisters. They seem not to consider the public display of breasts immodest, for missionaries, just like ordinary people, appear to get used to things which must at first have struck them as “dreadful.” They do not like to have them photographed, however; people at home would “misunderstand.” Women still come to church flaunting this open proof of motherhood, just as men do in their horsehair hats. Yet when Japanese women came into public baths already occupied by Korean men there was so much talk that the authorities were forced to modify a time-honored custom of Japan and order a division of the tubs by sexes. Less than two decades ago no Korean woman of the better class appeared on the streets even of Seoul in the daytime, and servant-girls compelled to do so covered their faces. After ten at night no men were expected to be abroad, for then the women, usually in sedan chairs, with lantern-bearers and followers, came out to pay their calls. In those days young men never smoked in the presence of their elders—at least of the male persuasion. No decent woman could read, but only sorceresses and keesang, the geisha of Korea. To-day things are so changed in some circles that the sewing-woman of a missionary family sent her girls to school first, saying that the boys could take care of themselves; with the result that her daughter became the wife of a vice-consul in Manchuria while her son was still a jiggy-coom, waiting at the station for a job of carrying. Points of view differ, of course, and what we of the West consider quite proper may strike the Korean as highly immodest, as well as vice versa. I remember once coming upon a group of Korean servants in a foreign house all gazing with great curiosity at the cover of one of our cheap high-priced magazines, decorated with a silly, but from our point of view harmless, picture, after the stereotyped manner of our “popular” illustrators, of a boy and girl kissing. The servant who had worked longest for foreigners was explaining to his scandalized fellows that they often did that, and held hands, too—which last dreadful vice he demonstrated by taking a hand of one of the others, by the wrist!
59It's still common for a Korean bride to find out when she moves into her future home that she's just her husband's “Number 3” wife—yet all the children she may have are seen as belonging to Wife Number 1. Most suspensions from the church, especially among Protestant converts, are due to concubinage; the rest are mostly for marrying someone deemed a “heathen.” I've mentioned that missionaries insist Korean women are very modest, especially compared to their Japanese counterparts. They don't seem to view the public showing of breasts as immodest, since missionaries, like everyone else, get used to things that must have initially shocked them. They don’t want these women photographed, though; people back home would “misunderstand.” Women still come to church proudly showing this sign of motherhood, just like men with their horsehair hats. However, when Japanese women entered public baths that Korean men were already using, there was so much discussion that authorities had to change a long-standing Japanese tradition and separate the baths by gender. Less than twenty years ago, no respectable Korean woman was seen on the streets of Seoul during the day, and servant girls who had to go out would cover their faces. After ten at night, no men were expected to be out, as that was when women, usually in sedan chairs accompanied by lantern-bearers and followers, would come out to visit. Back then, young men never smoked in front of their elders—at least, not the male ones. No decent woman could read; only sorceresses and keesang, the Korean geisha. Today, things have changed so much in some circles that a missionary family’s seamstress sent her girls to school first, believing that the boys would be fine on their own; her daughter ended up marrying a vice-consul in Manchuria while her son was still waiting for a job carrying luggage at the station. Perspectives differ, of course, and what we in the West consider completely acceptable might strike Koreans as quite immodest, and vice versa. I remember once coming across a group of Korean servants in a foreign home, all staring curiously at the cover of one of our expensive magazines, decorated with a silly but harmless picture, in the typical style of our “popular” illustrators, of a boy and girl kissing. The servant who had worked longest for foreigners was explaining to his shocked colleagues that they often did that, and held hands too—which he demonstrated by grabbing one of the other’s wrists!
60One should keep in mind, in considering the recent swift changes in Korea, that it was closed to the outside world much longer, tighter, and later than Japan. Yet the quaint old scholar’s cap is now as rare as the old learning. The new generation seems to have lost the poise of the old, and so far to have gotten nothing in its place. The rather flippant youths of the new schools cannot read the classics—for there is a splendid old Korean literature which is forbidden by the Japanese, so that the younger generation is growing up without it—and thus far they are not at home in the modern world that has so suddenly burst upon the ancient peninsula. One of the demands of the thirty-three men who signed the Korean “declaration of independence” a few years ago—the finest types of Koreans, according to the missionaries, and the first of whom were just being released, yellow and thin, when we were in the country—was the freedom to study things Korean, including their history. The idea of an education as the road to a government job and a lifetime of loafing still carries over from the days that are gone. Four fifths of the population is still reported illiterate, too, and even of those eager to go to school hardly one in three can get inside one. The rest can go to—well, to a Korean school of the old type, for instance. Frowsy old men keep them privately, and a dozen or a score of boys come at dawn, seven days a week, to squat on the floor of some dark and miserable little room in a back alley, their slippers in a row along the porch, and rock back and forth all day long shouting incessantly in what would be a chorus if it were not also a chaos of individual noises more often without than with meaning. Not until night falls do they unfold their legs and stumble homeward, and all the day through, as they “study,” the “teacher” in his special form of horsehair hat dozes on his knees at the head of the room, and flies beyond computation in numbers flit hour after hour from boy to boy. The Japanese officials of Korea pay a bounty on flies by the pint, but they do not seem to have done much toward wiping out their breeding-places. Yet, one recalls, while gazing in upon one of these old-fashioned schools, much of the civilization of Japan came from Korea—its culture, writing, Buddhism, pottery—and its smallpox.
60It's important to remember, when thinking about the recent rapid changes in Korea, that it was isolated from the outside world for much longer, more strictly, and later than Japan. However, the traditional scholar’s cap is now as uncommon as the old knowledge. The younger generation seems to have lost the composure of their predecessors and hasn’t really replaced it with anything else. The somewhat careless youth in the new schools can't read the classics—there’s a rich old Korean literature that the Japanese have made forbidden, so the younger generation is growing up without access to it—and so far, they're not familiar with the modern world that has suddenly arrived on the ancient peninsula. One of the demands made by the thirty-three men who signed the Korean “declaration of independence” a few years ago—the finest representatives of Korea, according to the missionaries, and the first of whom were just being released, looking frail and thin, when we were in the country—was the freedom to study things Korean, including their own history. The notion that education leads to a government job and a comfortable life still hangs on from the past. Furthermore, it's reported that four-fifths of the population remains illiterate, and even among those eager to attend school, hardly one in three can actually do so. The rest can only attend—well, an old-style Korean school, for instance. Scruffy old men run them privately, and a dozen or so boys come at dawn, seven days a week, to sit on the floor of some dark, shabby little room in a back alley, leaving their slippers lined up along the porch, rocking back and forth all day while shouting non-stop in what would be a chorus if it weren’t a chaotic mix of individual noises, often without meaning. Not until night falls do they stretch their legs and stumble home, and throughout the day, as they “study,” the “teacher,” wearing his special horsehair hat, dozes on his knees at the front of the room, while countless flies buzz from boy to boy hour after hour. The Japanese officials in Korea pay a bounty for flies by the pint but don’t seem to have done much to eliminate their breeding grounds. Yet, one remembers, while peering into one of these antiquated schools, that much of Japan's civilization originated in Korea—its culture, writing, Buddhism, pottery—and even smallpox.
A Korean church service, too, is a sight worth going to church to see. There are no seats, except perhaps a bench along one of the walls near the pulpit, for the missionaries. All others sit or squat on the floor, covered with straw matting, all in white except some of the smaller children, mainly dressed in pink. Many of the men still wear topknots, and some their “fly-trap” hats, for by Korean standards it is 61impolite to take these off except in one unmentionable place, where it is imperative. The sunburned breasts of women are also somewhat in evidence, though the great majority of the average congregation have adopted Western styles now in both these particulars. There may be a rare man in foreign dress, but even the native pastors almost all wisely cling to the flowing native garb of snow-white grass-cloth, so much more comfortable and becoming to Koreans. The men squat on one side, the women on the other, with the children in front between them, and seldom do they rise at all during the service, but merely bow their heads to the floor to pray. Now and again they sing one of our old familiar hymn tunes, with Korean words, in loud, metallic voices. Dozens of children of from two to six wriggle and talk and race about. From time to time a “Bible woman” squirms out of her place, picks up a few of the eel-like urchins, and returns them to their respective mothers, ordering them to be nursed forthwith, then wriggles back into her place again. There may be quiet during the infant dinner-hour, but the whole act is sure to be repeated several times before the service is over and the snow-white throng pours out between two unnecessarily stern-faced, sharp-eyed men in plain clothes whose habitat is the police station.
A Korean church service is definitely a sight worth attending. There are no seats, except maybe a bench along one of the walls for the missionaries. Everyone else sits or squats on the floor, which is covered with straw mats, all dressed in white, except for some of the younger kids, who mostly wear pink. Many of the men still have topknots, and some wear their “fly-trap” hats because, by Korean standards, it’s rude to take them off except in one unmentionable place where it’s necessary. You can also see the sunburned skin of women, though most of the average congregation has now adopted Western styles in this regard. There might be a few men in foreign clothing, but almost all the local pastors wisely stick to the traditional flowing garments made of white grass-cloth, which are much more comfortable and flattering for Koreans. The men sit on one side, the women on the other, with the kids in front between them, and they rarely get up during the service, instead just bowing their heads to the floor to pray. Occasionally, they sing familiar hymn tunes with Korean lyrics in loud, metallic voices. Dozens of kids aged two to six are wriggling, talking, and running around. From time to time, a “Bible woman” gets up, gathers a few of the squirming little ones, returns them to their mothers, insisting they be fed right away, and then goes back to her spot. There might be a moment of quiet during the baby feeding time, but this whole scene is sure to repeat a few times before the service ends and the crowd in white streams out between two stern-faced, sharp-eyed men in plain clothes, who are from the police station.
There can be no doubt of the many difficulties of mission work in a country where everything is so different from the home-land that an expression sounding almost exactly like “Come on!” means “Stop!” Among the dreadful stories one hears of missionary hardships is that of a man still in the field, who in his early days wished to preach a sermon on the text “Tam naji mara,” which is Korean for “Thou shalt not covet.” But as his command of the language was still somewhat faulty, he made the slight error of giving the text as “Dam naji mara.” Now while “tam” means “to covet,” “dam” means “to sweat,” and when the long service was over a little old Korean lady came up to say timidly to the youthful pastor, “I loved your sermon, dear teacher, but please tell me, how can we help sweating when it is so hot?”
There’s no doubt about the many challenges of mission work in a country where everything is so different from home that an expression that sounds almost exactly like “Come on!” actually means “Stop!” Among the awful stories about missionary hardships is one about a man still in the field, who in his early days wanted to preach a sermon on the text “Tam naji mara,” which is Korean for “You shall not covet.” However, since his language skills were still a bit shaky, he made the small mistake of saying the text as “Dam naji mara.” While “tam” means “to covet,” “dam” means “to sweat,” and when the long service was over, a little old Korean lady approached the young pastor and said timidly, “I loved your sermon, dear teacher, but please tell me, how can we avoid sweating when it’s so hot?”
Northward from Seoul by the railways which, broken only at the Straits of Tsushima, reach from Tokyo to Peking and beyond, lies much the same Korea as to the southward. Kaijo, or Song-do, reminds one that the ancient rulers of Cho-sen knew how to pick beautiful mountain sites for their capitals, for the landscape there rivals that about Seoul, alias Keijo. The first unification of the whole peninsula took place under the Korai—hence the name the West still uses—dynasty, 62which made its headquarters at Song-do and ruled for more than four centuries. When it was overthrown by one of the king’s generals, just a hundred years before the discovery of America, a new capital was established at Seoul and an ancient name for the country was restored—“Ch’ao Hsien,” roughly the “Land of Morning Calm.” The Chinese still call it Koli. Remnants of the groundwork of what must have been imposing buildings lie scattered to the west of the present Kaijo, and a great wall still climbs along the side of the mountain range that shuts it in. But the Song-do of to-day is little more than a large and very compact vista of smooth thatched roofs close beside the railway but an appreciable distance from the station. It has an American mission school famous for the ginghams made by students earning their way—un-Oriental as that may sound—in a factory in charge of a man from South Carolina; and some of the old customs have survived longer than in Seoul, the muffling from head to heels in a white sheet, for instance, of some of the women who glide through the narrow, unpaved streets.
North of Seoul, the railways stretch all the way from Tokyo to Beijing, only interrupted at the Straits of Tsushima, and you’ll find much of the same Korea as you do to the south. Kaijo, or Song-do, shows that the ancient rulers of Korea knew how to choose stunning mountain locations for their capitals, as the scenery there rivals that of Seoul, also known as Keijo. The first unification of the entire peninsula happened under the Goryeo dynasty—hence the name still used in the West—which made its capital at Song-do and ruled for over four centuries. When it was toppled by one of the king’s generals, just a hundred years before America was discovered, a new capital was set up in Seoul and the ancient name for the country was revived—“Ch’ao Hsien,” roughly translating to “Land of Morning Calm.” The Chinese still refer to it as Koli. Remnants of what must have been impressive buildings are scattered to the west of the current Kaijo, and a great wall still climbs along the mountain range that surrounds it. Today, Song-do is mainly a compact view of smooth thatched roofs situated close to the railway but a good distance from the station. It has an American mission school famous for the ginghams created by students working to pay their way—uncharacteristically Oriental as that may sound—in a factory run by someone from South Carolina; and some of the old traditions have persisted longer than in Seoul, such as the way some women wrap themselves from head to toe in a white sheet as they glide through the narrow, unpaved streets.
Then, too, Kaijo is the center of the gin-seng industry of Korea. The root of this plant is credited with miraculous curative powers by the credulous Orientals and reaches prices verging on the fabulous. Cases are scarcely rare of wealthy invalids, particularly Chinese, paying as much as two hundred dollars for a single root no larger than a little forked carrot at most three inches long, though it is the wild mountain-growing species of this originally Manchurian weed that reaches such heights; the cultivated variety is much less esteemed. Throughout the Far East there is hardly a native drug-shop without its carefully hidden supply of this precious tonic, which is said to have some real value for old and weak persons, at least of the Orient; even Chinese physicians admit that it is too heating for Westerners, already too hot by temperament, according to their view. No doubt its celebrity is largely due, like that of many another commodity, to its absurdly high price. One might fancy that the growing of gin-seng would fit the Korean temperament, for it takes seven years to mature, after which the land must lie fallow, or at least free from the same crop, an equal length of time. The fern-like plant dies in the sun; so for a considerable distance along the way through Song-do district there are big brown patches on the landscape which on closer inspection prove to be fields of gin-seng in rows of little beds, each protected by reed or woven-leaf mats forming a north wall and inclining slightly to the south. Here, under the watchful eye of the government monopoly bureau, this delicate 63aristocrat of the vegetable kingdom is tended with far greater care than the babies of Korea, and at last is hidden away in the form of yellow-brown dried roots in the safest places known to native drug-venders.
Then, Kaijo is the center of the ginseng industry in Korea. The root of this plant is believed to have miraculous healing powers by superstitious locals and sells for unbelievable prices. It's not uncommon for wealthy sick people, especially Chinese, to pay as much as two hundred dollars for a single root that’s no bigger than a small forked carrot, at most three inches long. However, it's the wild mountain-growing variety of this originally Manchurian plant that fetches such high prices; the cultivated version is far less valued. Throughout the Far East, there’s hardly a local drugstore without its carefully stored supply of this precious tonic, which is said to be genuinely beneficial for the elderly and weak, especially in the East. Even Chinese doctors acknowledge that it’s too heating for Westerners, who are considered already too hot-tempered, according to their perspective. Its fame is undoubtedly partly due, like many other products, to its ridiculously high price. One might think that growing ginseng would suit the Korean character, as it takes seven years to mature, after which the land must stay fallow, or at least not have the same crop, for another seven years. The fern-like plant can’t handle the sun; therefore, along the route through Song-do district, there are large brown patches on the landscape that, upon closer inspection, turn out to be fields of ginseng arranged in small beds, each protected by reed or woven-leaf mats leaning slightly to the south. Here, under the careful supervision of the government monopoly bureau, this delicate elite of the plant kingdom is looked after with much more care than Korea’s babies and is eventually stored away as yellow-brown dried roots in the safest spots known to local drug vendors.
Farther north are red uplands waving with corn and millet, and at some of the stations mammoth bales of silk cocoons, the worms within which are doomed to die a wriggling death in boiling water as their precious houses are disentangled into skeins in the thatched huts among which they will be scattered, the monopolistic eye of the alien government upon them also. Heijo, which to Koreans and missionaries is Ping Yang, has a somewhat less picturesque location than its two principal successors as capitals, and it bristles now with smoking factory chimneys. Indeed, it is quickly evident that this second city of the peninsula is more industrious than Seoul. Knitting-machines clash incessantly in hundreds of huts; yangbans and high hats and spotless white garments seem conspicuously rare to the traveler still having the capital in mind, and everywhere are evidences that here life has not been for centuries a holiday broken only by occasional languishing in government offices. Then, too, the eighteen thousand Chinese with which official statistics credit Korea are somewhat concentrated in Ping Yang and the north, and the Celestial adds to the industrious aspect of any land. These bigger and more rational-looking men do much of the hard work of Korea, such as stone-cutting and the building either of Christian schools or temples to the ancient gods. The latter seem to be losing some of their popularity in Ping Yang, for Christians are so numerous that the clatter of bells for Wednesday night prayer-meetings is as wide-spread as the sermons of Korean preachers are endless. Yet it is barely fifty years since Ping Yang went down to the river in a body and killed the foreigners who had dared to come in a Chinese junk into the Forbidden Kingdom.
Further north are red hills swaying with corn and millet, and at some of the stations, massive bales of silk cocoons can be found, with the worms inside about to meet a wriggling demise in boiling water as their precious homes are unraveled into threads in the thatched huts among which they will be scattered, all under the watchful eye of the foreign government. Heijo, known as Ping Yang to Koreans and missionaries, is not as picturesque as its two main successors as capitals, and it is now lined with smoking factory chimneys. In fact, it's clear that this second city of the peninsula is more industrious than Seoul. Knitting machines clank away incessantly in hundreds of huts; yangbans, high hats, and spotless white garments are noticeably rare for a traveler who still has the capital in mind, and everywhere there are signs that life here has not been a vacation interrupted only by occasional days spent in government offices for centuries. Additionally, the eighteen thousand Chinese that official statistics report in Korea are somewhat concentrated in Ping Yang and the north, adding to the industrious feel of the area. These taller and more physically capable men handle much of Korea's hard labor, such as stone-cutting and constructing either Christian schools or temples for the ancient gods. The latter seem to be losing popularity in Ping Yang, as Christians are so numerous that the sound of bells for Wednesday night prayer meetings is as widespread as the sermons of Korean preachers are endless. Yet, it was barely fifty years ago that the people of Ping Yang marched down to the river and killed the foreigners who had dared to enter the Forbidden Kingdom on a Chinese junk.
In this metropolis of the north even topknots are rare and clipped heads the rule. It seems to be inevitable with the coming of Christianity to lose the picturesque; but usually the crasser superstitions go with it, and one should not, perhaps, regret the passing of anything which takes these also. Besides, there remain the roofs peculiar to Ping Yang and its region, with their high-flaring corners made of six to eight superimposed tiles, now required by law in place of combustible thatch; and the complicated cobweb of streets in the Korean section still teems with the ancient weazel-hair brushes working from ink-slabs and sounds with the busy, insistent, incessant rat-a-tat of ironing.
In this northern city, even topknots are uncommon and short haircuts are the norm. It seems that with the arrival of Christianity, we lose some of the charm; but typically, the more extreme superstitions fade away with it, and maybe we shouldn’t mourn the loss of anything that takes those along. Besides, the unique roofs of Ping Yang and its area remain, featuring their sharply angled corners made of six to eight stacked tiles, now mandated by law instead of flammable thatch; and the intricate maze of streets in the Korean section is still bustling with the traditional weasel-hair brushes working on ink slabs, filled with the constant, persistent, never-ending rat-a-tat of ironing.
64It is striking how completely Korean Cho-sen remains to its very borders. Even in Yuki, where the coasting-steamer that brought me down from Vladivostok stopped to load logs, town and people were quite the same in appearance, manner, and customs as in Seoul or Fusan—and Japan had just as firm a grip. One might have suspected, from the long array of flags out through the little frontier village, that nearly all the inhabitants were Japanese, but it turned out that all shops, in honor of some mikado-ordained holiday, had been required to put up the rising—or is it the setting?—sun.
64It’s impressive how much Korean Cho-sen holds onto its identity right up to its borders. Even in Yuki, where the coastal steamer that brought me from Vladivostok stopped to load logs, the town and its people looked and acted just like those in Seoul or Fusan—and Japan had just as strong a hold. One might have thought, given the row of flags decorating the small border village, that almost all the residents were Japanese, but it turned out that all the shops had been required to display the rising—or is it the setting?—sun in honor of some holiday decreed by the emperor.
Seishin, a more important port farther southward along the coast, is picturesquely placed among foot-hills, and even has a railway, though this begins miles away behind it. There are no rickshaws for weak-legged passengers either, though little hand-run flat-cars operate on a tiny track, the spinning along on which on the edge of the bay by moonlight is delightful. Few thatched roofs are to be seen along the isolated little segment of the Korean Railways between Seishin and the garrisoned border town of Kainei, but tiled, Chinese-looking houses set down almost out of sight in patches of corn, and many mountains and tunnels, though also some fair valleys. Big chimneys made of hollowed logs of wood sprayed at the top by the fire that sometimes reaches them stand high above every mud-stuccoed dwelling in this region. Even there the landscape is almost treeless, except for a certain growth of small evergreens in patches here and there, though it is not far beyond to the great forests of the upper Yalu. Among them rises the rarely uncovered head of the Ever-White Mountain, and there are genuine tigers of Bengal and other game worthy the best sportsman’s skill in the wooded labyrinth of mountains about it. Kainei itself is quite a large town with many Japanese, thanks largely to the great barracks that seemed to swarm with soldiers. Part of an unambitious wall crawling along the foot of the hills not far north of it marks the ancient boundary between Korea and Manchuria, and in this midsummer season the town was hot beyond description in its pocket among the mountains. There were many little straw-built watch-towers standing stork-legged at the edges of the ripening crops, and up a hillside at the edge of town was a pathetic little Shinto shrine trying to force its way into the life of the people.
Seishin, a more significant port further south along the coast, is beautifully situated among foothills and even has a railway, although it starts miles away behind it. There are no rickshaws available for those who struggle to walk, but small hand-pulled flat-cars run on a tiny track, and riding them by moonlight along the edge of the bay is delightful. Few thatched roofs can be seen along the isolated stretch of the Korean Railways between Seishin and the military town of Kainei, but there are tiled, Chinese-style houses hidden away in patches of corn, along with many mountains and tunnels, as well as some nice valleys. Large chimneys made from hollowed logs, which are sometimes scorched at the top by fire, stand tall above every mud-stuccoed house in this area. Even here, the landscape is nearly treeless, except for some small evergreens that appear in clusters, though just beyond are the great forests of the upper Yalu. Among these rises the rarely visible peak of Ever-White Mountain, and there are genuine Bengal tigers and other game worthy of the best sportsman's expertise in the wooded maze of mountains surrounding it. Kainei itself is quite a large town with many Japanese residents, mainly due to the large barracks that seem to be teeming with soldiers. A part of an unremarkable wall creeping along the base of the hills not far to the north marks the ancient boundary between Korea and Manchuria, and in this midsummer season, the town was unbearably hot in its valley among the mountains. There were numerous small straw-built watchtowers standing on long legs at the edges of the ripening crops, and up a hillside at the town's edge was a small, sad Shinto shrine attempting to become a part of the community's life.

A village blacksmith of Korea. Note the bellows-pumper in his high hat at the rear
A village blacksmith in Korea. Notice the bellows operator wearing a top hat at the back.

The interior of a native Korean school of the old type,—dark, dirty, swarming with flies, and loud with a constant chorus
The inside of an old-style Korean school was dark, dirty, buzzing with flies, and filled with a constant noise.

In Kongo-san, the “Diamond Mountains” of eastern Korea
In Kongo-san, the "Diamond Mountains" of eastern Korea

The monastery kitchen of Yu-jom-sa, typical of Korean cooking
The monastery kitchen of Yu-jom-sa, typical of Korean cooking
65Much of the east coast of Korea is a mountainous wilderness, culminating in one truly Alpine cluster which the Japanese, quite justly, are striving to make better known to the outside world. If there is anywhere in eastern Asia a more marvelous bit of scenery, or a finer place in which to wander away a few summer days or weeks, than Kongo-san, beginning to be known among foreigners as the Diamond Mountains, I have overlooked it. One might enthuse for pages over the cathedral spires, the colossal cliffs, the magnificent evergreen forests clinging by incredible footholds to the gray rock even of mighty precipices, and a hundred other unnamed beauties of this compact little scenic paradise without giving more than a faint hint of the charms it encloses.
65Much of the east coast of Korea is a rugged wilderness, topped by one stunning mountain range that the Japanese are rightly trying to share with the world. If there's a more amazing scene in eastern Asia or a better spot to spend a few summer days or weeks than Kongo-san, starting to be called the Diamond Mountains by foreigners, I've missed it. One could go on for pages about the towering spires, the massive cliffs, the beautiful evergreen forests gripping the steep gray rocks, and a hundred other unseen wonders of this little scenic paradise without even scratching the surface of its appeal.
From Gensan, railway terminus of the branch northeastward from Seoul and principal port on the east coast, a small steamer hobbles southward for half a day to a blistering little town called Chozen, swaps passengers with a diminutive wharf, and hurries away again as if the evil spirits of the mountains were after it. One can walk, rickshaw, or Ford it to Onseiri, five miles inland, where the Japanese have built a modern hotel lacking nothing but freedom from Japanese prices, and where there are several Korean inns which house virtually all visitors. Or, one may leave the train from Seoul long before reaching Gensan, and cover the eighty-eight miles from Heiko to Choan-ji Temple, one of the buildings of which the same Japanese have made over into a pleasant little hostelry, by a highway that will carry even full-grown automobiles whenever the rainy season does not suddenly and bodily wipe out great sections of it. For that matter there are sixty-four miles of a road similar in capacity and subject to the same lapses along a beautiful coast-line from Gensan to Onseiri direct. Everything so far mentioned, however, functions only in the summer season, for from October onward Kongo-san is snow-bound and its monks and simple mountaineers drift back into the bucolic existence they and their forerunners enjoyed for centuries before the noisy, hurrying outside world discovered their enchanted retreat.
From Gensan, the end of the train line northeast from Seoul and the main port on the east coast, a small steamer chugs south for half a day to a hot little town called Chozen, exchanges passengers at a small wharf, and quickly departs as if the evil spirits of the mountains are chasing it. You can walk, take a rickshaw, or drive to Onseiri, five miles inland, where the Japanese have built a modern hotel that only lacks freedom from Japanese prices, and where several Korean inns accommodate nearly all visitors. Alternatively, you can hop off the train from Seoul well before reaching Gensan and travel the eighty-eight miles from Heiko to Choan-ji Temple, one of whose buildings the Japanese have turned into a charming little guesthouse, via a road that can handle full-sized cars unless the rainy season suddenly washes away large parts of it. Additionally, there are sixty-four miles of a similar road along a beautiful coastline from Gensan straight to Onseiri. However, everything mentioned so far operates only in the summer season, because starting in October, Kongo-san is covered in snow, and its monks and simple mountain dwellers retreat into the pastoral lifestyle they and their ancestors enjoyed for centuries before the noisy, fast-paced outside world discovered their magical hideaway.
If the Diamond Mountains were in China, chair-bearers would humor the lazy in their indolence and carry them around the circuit for a most inadequate compensation. Fortunately the Koreans are not so ready to take up the burdens of others, with the result that Kongo-san is spared the sight of the mere tourist, incapable of depending for a few days on his own legs and head. A jiggy-coom, of whose intelligence I have already spoken elsewhere, and whose sturdiness, unfailing good cheer, and knowledge of the mountain paths were on a par with his other good qualities, kept my indispensable belongings within constant reach in spite of the swift pace circumstances forced me to set; 66otherwise my own feet paid the toll for whatever my eyes feasted upon. In fact, we made the circuit in three days, and saw in four everything that other visitors have considered worth making an exertion to see, which is reputed to be a record. But I admit this not in pride, but in contrition, for not to linger, to stroll, to camp for weeks hither and yon among the towering peaks, beside the torrential ravines, away in the scented recesses of the virgin forests of Kongo-san is to commit a sacrilege and to deny oneself one of the good things of life.
If the Diamond Mountains were in China, chair-bearers would indulge the lazy by carrying them around the circuit for a very low payment. Fortunately, Koreans aren’t so quick to take on the burdens of others, which means Kongo-san is free from the sight of tourists who can’t rely on their own legs and minds for a few days. A jiggy-coom, whose intelligence I've mentioned elsewhere, and whose strength, constant good spirit, and knowledge of the mountain paths matched his other great qualities, kept my essential belongings within easy reach, even though I had to keep up a fast pace due to the circumstances. Otherwise, my own feet would have paid the price for whatever my eyes enjoyed. In fact, we completed the circuit in three days and saw in four everything that other visitors considered worth the effort, which is said to be a record. But I share this not with pride, but with remorse, because not taking the time to linger, wander, or camp for weeks among the towering peaks, next to the rushing ravines, or in the fragrant nooks of the pristine forests of Kongo-san is to commit a sacrilege and to deprive oneself of one of life's great pleasures.
There are trails that pant upward for hours more steeply than any stairway built by man, revealing constantly changing vistas of fantastically carved rock pinnacles, of combinations of mountain and forest rarely seen even in the Alps, and, high enough up, glimpses of the sea itself, down into which Kongo-san comes tumbling in mighty cliffs, sheer as the walls of sky-scrapers. There are trails that wander hour after hour down great rock gorges where streams too clear to be described in words leap from pool to blue-green pool, and where the world rears up on either side so swiftly that only an eagle could escape from the ravine except by its natural exit. There are places which only the feet of intrepid and ardent lovers of nature have ever trodden, or, what is still better, ever will, and pinnacles of sharpened rock from the all but unattainable points of which myriads of others like them, yet each utterly different, stretch away in an endless forest of white granite spires among which sunshine and rain and the often swirling mists make new beauties each more beautiful than the last.
There are trails that climb steeply for hours, more challenging than any staircase built by humans, offering constantly changing views of fantastically shaped rock formations, of mountain and forest combinations rarely seen even in the Alps, and, high enough, glimpses of the sea below, where Kongo-san tumbles down in towering cliffs as sheer as skyscraper walls. There are trails that meander for hours through deep rock gorges where crystal-clear streams, too pure to describe, leap from one blue-green pool to another, and where the world rises up on either side so quickly that only an eagle could leave the ravine without taking the natural path. There are spots that only the feet of brave and passionate nature lovers have ever walked on, or, even better, ever will, along with sharp rock peaks from almost unreachable heights from which countless others, each completely unique, extend into an endless forest of white granite spires among which sunlight, rain, and often swirling mists create new beauties, each more stunning than the last.
But we are wasting ink. The most expert weaver of words could not spin a pattern that would be more than a faint and caricature-like resemblance to the reality, even in some of the milder corners and aspects of the Diamond Mountains. Let us acknowledge plain impossibility at once therefore and see what hints can be conveyed by the matter-of-fact pigments at our disposal.
But we're wasting ink. Even the most skilled wordsmith couldn't create a description that accurately reflects reality, even in the gentler parts and features of the Diamond Mountains. So let's accept the plain impossibility right away and see what hints can be shared using the straightforward colors we have available.
It is about fifty miles around the base of Kongo-san and the whole playground of nature covers only an area of seventy-five square miles, but not even in the Andes has the builder of mountains so nearly outdone himself within so limited a compass. A range over which no one has yet found a way divides this into what is called the Inner and the Outer Kongo, each with its endless variety of peerless scenic features. In places the trails crawl along the face of granite precipices by causeways or stairs of logs laid corduroy fashion and held in place by big iron spikes driven into the solid rock. In others there are huge chains by which to drag oneself to the top of some all but inaccessible summit 67that repays a hundredfold all the exertion of reaching it. Twice we had to wade and swim Bambakudo (the “Cañon of Myriad Cascades”) where man-built aids of chiseled rock or chained logs failed us, and where no human legs would have been frog-like enough to carry us from boulder to boulder across the foaming stream. To see the best of the region needs often hands as well as feet, and there are many times when the agility and steel nerves of the steeple-jack and the endurance of the Marathon runner are indispensable to the man who cannot bear the shame of turning back from an attempted undertaking.
It’s about fifty miles around the base of Kongo-san, and the entire natural playground covers just seventy-five square miles, but not even in the Andes has a mountain builder managed to create such incredible features within such a small area. A range that no one has yet navigated divides this into what people call the Inner and Outer Kongo, each with its endless variety of stunning scenic highlights. In some places, the trails cling to the sides of granite cliffs via makeshift paths or stairs made of logs laid like corduroy and secured with large iron spikes hammered into solid rock. In other areas, there are huge chains that you can use to pull yourself up to some nearly unreachable peak, which rewards all the effort of getting there a hundred times over. Twice we had to wade and swim through Bambakudo (the “Cañon of Myriad Cascades”) where man-made structures of carved rock or chained logs didn’t help us, and where no human could jump like a frog from boulder to boulder across the raging stream. To fully appreciate the best of the region often requires both hands and feet, and there are many moments when the agility and nerves of a steeplejack and the endurance of a marathon runner are essential for anyone who can’t stand the thought of giving up on a challenge. 67
If its delicious sylvan isolation and its marvelous scenery were all Kongo-san had to offer, it would be well worthy of world-wide fame; but to these are added about twoscore of Buddhist temples and monasteries so old and so withdrawn from the world that they alone would be worth climbing far to see. Ever since the introduction of Buddhism into Korea, some four centuries after Christ, this chaotic cluster of peaks and abysses has been a kind of holy land of that faith. Converted kings outdid each other in aiding the priests and monks who retired to this secluded region, sending workmen and sculptors to build them temples and cloisters in many and strange places, to chisel images of Buddha in isolated gorges on the faces of immense cliffs, ordering the laymen roundabout the mountains to furnish the recluses sustenance in perpetuity. Tradition has it that there were at one time a hundred and eight separate religious establishments scattered among these compact mountains; but it came to be the kingly custom toward the end of the fifteenth century to persecute Buddhism, and many of the retreats were burned or fell into ruin, while the rest cut themselves off from the outside world as completely as possible. After they were rediscovered, so to speak, some thirty years ago by, strangely enough, an English woman, their almost utter solitude of centuries began to be more and more broken by visitors of the nature-loving rather than the purely pious turn of mind.
If its beautiful, secluded setting and stunning scenery were all Kongo-san had to offer, it would still deserve worldwide fame; but in addition, there are about forty Buddhist temples and monasteries that are so ancient and so hidden away that they alone would make the journey worthwhile. Ever since Buddhism was introduced to Korea, about four centuries after Christ, this chaotic range of peaks and valleys has been seen as a kind of sacred land for that faith. Converted kings competed to support the priests and monks who retreated here, sending workers and sculptors to build temples and monasteries in various unique locations, carving images of Buddha into isolated ravines on the sides of massive cliffs, and instructing the local people around the mountains to provide for the recluses indefinitely. According to tradition, there used to be a hundred and eight distinct religious establishments scattered throughout these compact mountains; however, by the late fifteenth century, it became customary for kings to persecute Buddhism, leading to the burning or ruin of many retreats, while the remaining ones sought to isolate themselves from the outside world as much as possible. After being "rediscovered" about thirty years ago by, surprisingly, an English woman, their centuries of near solitude began to be increasingly interrupted by visitors who were more nature-loving than purely religious.
The largest of the temples of Kongo-san is Yu-jom-sa, in which we spent the night following the perpendicular climb into the Inner Kongo, and it is quite typical of the others. A log bridge led across the acrobatic stream we had been trailing from near the summit, to a cluster of a dozen or more buildings, widely varying in size but all in the rather gaudy yet not unpleasing flare-roofed style common to Korean temples, and more or less so to those of Japan and China. Built of wood throughout, they had a dark and venerable aspect, even though they are credited since their establishment with having been destroyed more than 68forty times by fire—an extremely common affliction to the monkish residents of Kongo-san. Of the multicolored bogies and painted wooden gods within the temples, of the colorful wall scenes which give these background, even of the dainty pagoda rising slenderly as high as the highest roof, with tinkling little bells at each corner of its many stories, I need say nothing in particular, for these are things to be found in any Korean sanctuary. What was less familiar were the great kitchens from which the big establishment and its visitors are fed, or the wooden trough that brings the finest of mountain water down from miles away to a series of huge hollowed logs ranged closely side by side on the slightly sloping space between the two clusters of buildings. Those who wished to drink dipped with a quaint little wooden dipper from the upper logs, those supplying the kitchen took water from a little farther down; hands and faces were washed lower still, and finally came the reservoirs in which kitchen utensils and the like might be rinsed. To say that these descending orders of use were strictly obeyed either by visitors or the monks themselves, however, would be to overdraw any Korean picture.
The largest temple on Kongo-san is Yu-jom-sa, where we spent the night after climbing steeply into the Inner Kongo. It's pretty representative of the others. A log bridge crossed the lively stream we had been following from near the summit, leading to a cluster of a dozen or more buildings. They varied in size but were all styled in the bright, eye-catching flare-roof design typical of Korean temples, similar to those in Japan and China. Made entirely of wood, they had a dark and ancient look, even though they've been destroyed by fire more than 68 times since they were built—something that happens a lot to the monks living on Kongo-san. As for the colorful statues and painted wooden deities inside the temples, and the vibrant wall scenes that serve as backgrounds, even the charming pagoda that rises delicately high above the tallest roof, with tinkling bells at each corner — these are all standard features in any Korean sanctuary. What was less familiar were the large kitchens that feed the temple and its visitors, or the wooden trough that carries the best mountain water from miles away to a series of huge hollowed logs set closely together on the gently sloping area between the two clusters of buildings. Those who wanted to drink used a little wooden dipper to scoop water from the upper logs, while those supplying the kitchen filled from a little farther down; hands and faces were washed lower still, and finally, there were reservoirs for rinsing kitchen utensils and the like. However, to say that these levels of use were strictly followed by visitors or the monks themselves would be an exaggeration of any Korean scene.
Most of the temples and monasteries of Kongo-san supply food, and many of them sleeping-quarters, to all who apply for them, as there are neither inns nor the suggestion of shops or laymen venders in the mountains. A novice met us at the temple end of the bridge and assigned me a room, quite bare until it came time for boys to bring the little table on which I was served in a squatting position, but with the usual brown-paper floor of Korean dwellings. Cleanliness, at least as far as anything came to my eyes, was quite general. We had arrived before sunset, and there was time to see something of the daily life of the place before it retired early for the night. Big piles of cord-wood and brush in back courts testified to quite different weather than this delightful August evening at many hundred feet elevation. Numbers of the younger inmates were playing a medieval kind of cross between tennis and handball when we came; on the edge of the graveled temple terrace that served as court were two crude gymnastic turning-bars on which some of the priests and novices did tolerably difficult feats. A roar of laughter went up when, having been jokingly invited to join in this sport, I had almost to duck my head to pass under the bars that most of the others could only reach by jumping. They trotted out the tallest man in the establishment, and roared again when he proved to be several inches shorter than I; and I am sure I lost the reputation for veracity among them because I asserted that, as people of my country go, I am not particularly tall. There were many boys about the place, but I saw no signs of women, though the recluses of Kongo-san are reputed to obey their vows of celibacy much more in the breach than in the observance. The yellow robe which makes the Buddhist priest so picturesque a figure in some other lands had no counterpart here, at least in their outdoor, every-day wear. They wore almost the ordinary Korean male costume, in most cases of sackcloth, like men in mourning, though there were some white and others with a bluish tint. Heads of course were cropped, and there were no head-dresses of any kind in evidence.
Most of the temples and monasteries of Kongo-san provide food, and many offer sleeping quarters, to anyone who asks, since there are no inns or stores in the mountains. A novice met us at the temple end of the bridge and showed me to a room, which was quite bare until the boys brought in a small table for me to use while sitting on the ground, just like the usual brown-paper floors of Korean homes. Cleanliness, at least from what I could see, was pretty good. We arrived before sunset, so there was time to observe some of the daily life of the place before it settled in for the night. Large piles of firewood and brush in the backyards showed that the weather here is quite different from this lovely August evening at several hundred feet up. Many of the younger residents were playing a medieval mix of tennis and handball when we arrived; on the edge of the gravel terrace that served as a court were two simple gymnastic bars where some of the priests and novices were performing moderately challenging tricks. Laughter erupted when, having been jokingly invited to join in the fun, I nearly had to duck my head to fit under the bars that most others could only reach by jumping. They brought out the tallest man in the place, and everyone roared again when he turned out to be several inches shorter than me; I’m pretty sure I lost some credibility with them when I claimed that, for someone from my country, I’m not particularly tall. There were many boys around, but I didn’t see any women, even though the recluses of Kongo-san are said to break their vows of celibacy more often than they follow them. The yellow robe that makes Buddhist priests so visually striking in other countries wasn’t present here, at least not in their everyday clothing. They mostly wore the typical Korean male outfit, often made of sackcloth, like men in mourning, though some were white and others had a bluish tint. Of course, their heads were shaved, and there were no headpieces of any kind in sight.

One of the monks of Yu-jom-sa
One of the monks of Yu-jom-sa

This great cliff-carved Buddha, fifty feet high and thirty broad, was done by Chinese artists centuries ago. Note my carrier, a full-sized man, squatting at the lower left-hand corner
This massive Buddha carved from the cliff, standing fifty feet tall and thirty feet wide, was created by Chinese artists centuries ago. Check out my carrier, a full-sized man, squatting in the lower left-hand corner.

The carved Buddhas of Sam-pul-gam, at the entrance to the gorge of the Inner Kongo, were chiseled by a famous Korean monk five hundred years ago
The carved Buddhas of Sam-pul-gam, at the entrance to the gorge of the Inner Kongo, were sculpted by a renowned Korean monk five hundred years ago.

The camera can at best give only a suggestion of the sheer white rock walls of Shin Man-mul-cho, perhaps the most marvelous bit of scenery in the Far East
The camera can at best only hint at the stunning white rock walls of Shin Man-mul-cho, possibly the most incredible sight in the Far East.
69The booming of a great bell struck by the end of a suspended log called for gayer and more elaborate garments in which monks and novices sat and rocked as they chanted through the evening service on the papered floors of several of the main buildings. Meanwhile I had been called back to my room and served supper. There must have been at least twenty courses, or, rather, different dishes, to the meal, including no meat, but with more examples of the really excellent performances of the Korean cook than I had ever tasted elsewhere. Even tea was served, though up to quite recent years Koreans never drank it. Best of all, the attendants and idlers did not come to sit and watch me eat, like some wild animal in a cage, but withdrew when I had been served and did not intrude again until I lighted my evening cigar. Then a group of us strolled down to the bridge across the brawling stony river and chatted in the language of signs until night blotted out the evergreen wooded mountains that pile up close on every hand above this delightful refuge from the silly babble of the world.
69The sound of a large bell, struck by a hanging log, called for fancier and more elaborate outfits as monks and novices sat and rocked while chanting during the evening service on the papered floors of several main buildings. Meanwhile, I had been called back to my room for supper. There must have been at least twenty courses, or more accurately, different dishes, in the meal, which included no meat but featured some of the really amazing creations by the Korean cook that I had never tasted anywhere else. They even served tea, although until quite recently, Koreans never drank it. Best of all, the attendants and onlookers didn’t come to sit and watch me eat, like some wild animal in a cage, but withdrew after I was served and only returned when I lit my evening cigar. Then a group of us strolled down to the bridge over the fast-flowing rocky river and chatted using gestures until nightfall obscured the evergreen mountains that loom all around this wonderful escape from the senseless chatter of the world.
It is true that a quartet of Japanese noisily smoked and gambled most of the night away on the other side of a thin partition, but these are afflictions against which Koreans have no effective weapons. My attendants actually left the door open all night; but, oh, the unspeakable hardness of a Korean floor serving as a bed! Breakfast was almost as generous as the evening meal, yet as I recall it I paid, at a roundabout suggestion from my hosts, only two or three yen for the full accommodations of myself and guide.
It’s true that a group of four Japanese people loudly smoked and played cards for most of the night on the other side of a thin wall, but these are annoyances that Koreans have no real way to combat. My attendants actually left the door open all night; but, oh, the unbearable hardness of a Korean floor acting as a bed! Breakfast was almost as generous as dinner, yet I remember that I ended up paying, following a roundabout suggestion from my hosts, only two or three yen for the complete accommodations for myself and my guide.
Sometime during that morning we came upon the mightiest of the carved Buddhas in the Diamond Mountains, in a wild and utterly uninhabited ravine through which we were descending from another slowly attained summit covered with reeking wet half-jungle. The image was cut in deep relief on the face of a cliff, and is so mammoth that my companion, squatting at a corner of it, looks like a fly-speck 70on the picture I took. At noon we were the guests of the score of monks of Makayun-an, the largest of the cloisters, as Yu-jom-sa is of the temples. A useless, perhaps, but certainly a gentle life these sturdy white-clad fellows with the shaven heads lead at the sheer foot of one of the most perpendicular peaks of the Inner Kongo. There are other cloisters far more inaccessible, some which almost never see visitors. One, I recall, on that afternoon down the magnificent Gorge of the Thousand Cascades, was set so sheer on the vertical mountain-side that a post, which seemed to be of iron and was surely a hundred feet long, under a corner of the building was all that kept it from pitching headlong into the abyss along which we scrambled our way far below.
At some point that morning, we stumbled upon the largest of the carved Buddhas in the Diamond Mountains, in a wild and completely uninhabited ravine as we descended from another peak that was slowly covered in damp, half-jungle. The statue was deeply carved into the face of a cliff and is so enormous that my companion, squatting nearby, looks like a tiny speck in the picture I took. By noon, we were the guests of a group of monks at Makayun-an, the biggest of the monasteries, just as Yu-jom-sa is for the temples. These strong, white-clad monks with shaved heads lead a simple yet certainly peaceful life at the base of one of the steepest peaks in the Inner Kongo. There are other monasteries that are far more remote, some that hardly ever see visitors. I remember one, that afternoon, down the stunning Gorge of the Thousand Cascades, which was built so steeply on the vertical mountain side that a post, looking like it was made of iron and easily a hundred feet long, was all that kept it from tumbling into the abyss below as we scrambled our way far beneath it. 70
I have said enough, no doubt, but no visitor to the Diamond Mountains should hurry back to drab reality until he has climbed by finger-nails and eyelids into that maze of white granite crags, like a hundred gigantic Woolworth Buildings designed by no earthly architect, which the Koreans call Shin Man-mul-cho. It rained more or less all the time we were risking our lives and all but bursting our lungs to reach even some of the slighter elevations of this fairy-land, but it would have been a strange offshoot of the human race who would have considered a mere soaking and the day’s toil of a galley-slave a high price to pay for the sights that were conferred upon us. My coolie carrier himself, though he had been there more than once before, was as averse to turning back, even long after it would have been wisdom to do so, as was the bedraggled and ragged Westerner who accompanied him.
I’ve probably said enough, but no visitor to the Diamond Mountains should rush back to boring reality until they’ve climbed through that maze of white granite peaks, like a hundred giant Woolworth Buildings created by no earthly architect, which the Koreans call Shin Man-mul-cho. It rained pretty much the entire time we were risking our lives and almost bursting our lungs just to reach a few of the lower heights of this fairyland, but it would take a strange person to think that getting drenched and working hard like a galley slave was too high a price to pay for the incredible sights we experienced. My coolie carrier himself, even though he had been there more than once, was just as reluctant to turn back, even long after it would have been wise to do so, as the soaked and ragged Westerner who was with him.
Then, if there is time enough left after throwing away the tatters to which any proper excursion into Kongo-san will reduce the stoutest garments endurable there in summer, and the substitution of something less exposing, one should have a glimpse of the Sea Kongo, where islands that are like peaks of the fantastic mountains farther inland dot the route over which ply in the summer season crude conveyances that in real life are fishing-boats.
Then, if there’s enough time left after discarding the rags that any proper trip into Kongo-san will turn even the sturdiest summer clothes into, and after swapping them for something less revealing, you should catch a glimpse of the Sea Kongo, where islands resemble the peaks of the amazing mountains further inland and dot the path that crude fishing boats travel during the summer season.
CHAPTER V
Up and Down Manchuria
The change from Korea to China is not merely abrupt, it is instantaneous. In the exact middle of the big bridge over the Yalu, across which rickshaws trot and pedestrians of all degrees shuttle in two constant, almost silent-footed streams on either side of rumbling trains, stand a Japanese guard and a Chinese soldier, as strikingly unlike as two men of the same profession and rather similar background could well be; and they are typical of the wide differences in customs and costumes, in all the details, if not the essentials, of life on the two shores of the famous river. White gives way to blue denim as the garb of crowds and individuals—for in China, as in Japan, the former is the color of mourning. Pigtails take the place of topknots; tiny bound feet, which the traveler perhaps has never before seen, instantly become general among women of all ages and classes; uncovered breasts die out as suddenly as does the silly horsehair pretense of a hat. Instead of stallions there are geldings; wheelbarrows and oscillating shoulder-poles replace the back-rack known as a jiggy; the Chinese sense of humor, or racial cheerfulness, comes at once to the fore—there was more laughing in an hour in Antung than in a day in Korea or a week in Japan. One could not but be struck by the size of the Chinese as compared even with the Koreans, to say nothing of the dwarfish Japanese, and by their more common-sense air and dress—and at the same time by the horrible sloughs of mud that passed for streets, the diseased beggars wallowing up and down them, the truly putrid conditions of life in the native city.
The transition from Korea to China isn't just sudden; it's immediate. Right in the middle of the large bridge over the Yalu, where rickshaws move and pedestrians of all kinds flow in two constant, almost silent streams on either side of rumbling trains, stand a Japanese guard and a Chinese soldier, looking strikingly different despite sharing the same profession and a somewhat similar background; they represent the significant differences in customs and clothing, in all the details, if not the essentials, of life on both sides of the famous river. White gives way to blue denim as the attire of the crowds and individuals—since in China, just like in Japan, white is the color of mourning. Pigtails replace topknots; tiny bound feet, which the traveler may never have seen before, instantly become common among women of all ages and classes; uncovered breasts disappear as suddenly as the absurd horsehair pretense of a hat. Instead of stallions, there are geldings; wheelbarrows and shoulder-poles take the place of the back-rack known as a jiggy; the Chinese sense of humor, or racial cheerfulness, stands out immediately—there was more laughter in an hour in Antung than in a day in Korea or a week in Japan. One can't help but notice the size of the Chinese compared to even the Koreans, not to mention the short Japanese, along with their more practical appearance and clothing—and at the same time, the appalling muddy roads that serve as streets, the diseased beggars struggling through them, and the truly disgusting living conditions in the local city.
There is a paved and well built Japanese fore-city about the railway station, but even this was essentially Chinese in its human aspects, in spite of the big mat-covered arena that had been hastily thrown up to house the paunchy second-rate Japanese wrestlers who strutted the streets in loin-cloths and fluttering kimonos. The low and ancient “victorias,” that rattled to and from the station, jerked rather than drawn by an emaciated horse or two streaked with mud and perspiration, and loaded to the gunwales often with a full dozen Chinese besides 72the heartless driver, seemed strangely in keeping with the north bank of the Yalu. All trains halt for an hour or more at Antung for the lenient examination of baggage, so that there is time to see all this, as well as the great log rafts floating down the river as its upper reaches are denuded and their forests turned into Chinese coffins. Nor will it be an unusual experience if the traveler is approached by a Japanese gendarme asking to see his passport, to which the proper reply of course is as gentle a reminder as is consistent with the brazen courtesy and one’s individual temperament that China has not yet been internationally recognized as a Japanese colony.
There’s a paved and well-built Japanese fore-city around the train station, but even this has a Chinese vibe in its human aspects, despite the large mat-covered arena quickly set up for the out-of-shape, second-rate Japanese wrestlers who paraded the streets in loincloths and fluttering kimonos. The old-fashioned “victorias” that clattered back and forth to the station were pulled, rather than drawn, by a couple of scrawny horses covered in mud and sweat, often packed to the brim with a full dozen Chinese passengers plus the unfeeling driver, which felt oddly fitting for the north bank of the Yalu. All trains stop for an hour or more in Antung for a relaxed baggage check, so travelers have time to take in all of this and the large log rafts drifting down the river as its upper regions are stripped bare and their forests turned into Chinese coffins. It’s not uncommon for travelers to be approached by a Japanese gendarme asking to see their passport, and the appropriate response is a polite reminder, as gentle as possible considering the brazen courtesy and one’s own personality, that China hasn’t yet been internationally recognized as a Japanese colony.
A few miles northward a serrated range rises close on the right, and there are other groups of hills on the way to Mukden, two or three of them strikingly crowned by ancient temples. But broad rolling fields of corn and millet and kaoliang are the chief impression of this ten-hour journey. There is an atmosphere reminiscent of pioneer America in these broad reaches of Manchuria, so unlike the little diked and flooded paddy-fields of Korea and Japan. Only rarely is there a human being in sight, now and then a lone man in a pigtail and blue denim hoeing corn, or plowing with a thin red ox or a cow. The few houses are as miserable as the huts of Korea, otherwise quite different, being plain and square, thatched with corn- or kaoliang-stalks instead of the hair-smooth rice-straw, and without a suggestion of the picturesque about them. In the midsummer season the landscape is a deep, almost unbroken green, for the few houses are so low that they are all but hidden among the tall crops, and there is the slightly denser green of scrub timber on the constant succession of fair-sized hills. Willows abound; in fact, it would not be difficult to imagine oneself in the hillier parts of Pennsylvania, did not the visibly splendid fertility of the country contrast so strongly with the lack of real houses or any indication of prosperity and comfort. At length high terraced hills become more populous; then the country grows deadly flat, with the soya-bean, king of Manchurian products, lording it over all other crops as one approaches Mukden.
A few miles north, a jagged mountain range rises on the right, and there are other groups of hills on the way to Mukden, two or three of which are strikingly topped with ancient temples. But the main impression of this ten-hour journey comes from the wide, rolling fields of corn, millet, and kaoliang. There’s a vibe that feels reminiscent of pioneer America in these vast stretches of Manchuria, so different from the small, diked, and flooded rice fields of Korea and Japan. Rarely is there a person in sight, occasionally a lone man with a pigtail in blue denim hoeing corn or plowing with a thin red ox or cow. The few houses are as miserable as the huts in Korea, but they are quite different, being plain and square, thatched with corn or kaoliang stalks instead of the smooth rice straw, lacking any charm. In midsummer, the landscape is a deep, almost unbroken green, as the few low houses are nearly hidden among the tall crops, along with the slightly denser green of scrub timber on the consistent rolling hills. Willows are everywhere; in fact, it wouldn’t be hard to imagine oneself in the hillier parts of Pennsylvania, if not for the strikingly rich fertility of the land contrasting sharply with the absence of real houses or any signs of wealth and comfort. Eventually, the high terraced hills become more populated; then the land flattens out completely, with soybeans, the king of Manchurian crops, dominating everything as one approaches Mukden.
The Russian name for the capital of China’s “Eastern Three Provinces” bids fair to persist in Western speech, though to the Japanese it is Hoten and the Chinese themselves now call it Feng-tien. That constant fight for a livelihood, for bare escape from starvation, which becomes in time an accepted feature of life in China, is in evidence even this far north and east, for all the spaciousness of Manchuria. There is a swarming of rickshaws like men set on the 73mark ready to race to any exit where there is the shadow of a promised fare, blocking the way if one attempts to set out on foot, trailing the stroller until walking ceases to be a pleasure. Carriages with a suggestion of Russian ancestry completely surround the man who gives the slightest hint that he may at some time want one, and escape is hardly possible without the vigorous wielding of at least as deadly a weapon as a cane, which leaves the average American handicapped. Both rickshaw-men and drivers are deathly afraid of even the most insignificant Japanese bell-boy, however, and as there is no way of alighting in Mukden except from the west without passing through a cordon of these, assistance may be had against the first fierce onslaught of the over-numerous means of transportation. There are rows of “Peking carts” also, ready to crowd half a dozen hardy and unhurried travelers beneath their blue-denim hoods, and finally, if one chances to be as fond of local odors as of local color, there are the horse-cars, which may conceivably strike some of the more aged visitors from the Occident as vaguely familiar. Just how many years back it is that these same cars jogged up and down Third Avenue in medieval New York I have not the requisite data to say, but they spent quite a number of them earning their livelihood in Tokyo, and there are rumors that their jaunt into the Orient has not yet reached its termination.
The Russian name for the capital of China’s “Eastern Three Provinces” is likely to stick in Western speech, although the Japanese call it Hoten and the Chinese now refer to it as Feng-tien. The ongoing struggle for survival, the constant fight against starvation that has become a normal part of life in China, is evident even up in this far north and east, despite the spaciousness of Manchuria. There’s a swarm of rickshaws ready to race to any potential fare, blocking the way if you try to walk and making it hard to enjoy a stroll. Carriages with a hint of Russian design surround anyone who even slightly suggests they might want one, and escaping is nearly impossible without something as effective as a cane, which leaves the average American at a disadvantage. However, both rickshaw drivers and carriage drivers are terrified of even the smallest Japanese bellboy, and since there’s no way to enter Mukden from the west without passing through a crowd of them, you might get some help against the overwhelming number of transportation options. There are also rows of “Peking carts” waiting to pack a handful of casual travelers under their blue-denim covers. Finally, if you happen to enjoy local smells as much as local sights, there are horse-drawn streetcars that might seem somewhat familiar to older visitors from the West. I can't say exactly how many years ago these same cars used to rumble up and down Third Avenue in old New York, but they spent several years making a living in Tokyo, and there are rumors that their journey in the Orient is far from over.
There is almost nothing Chinese, except these things and those who patronize them, about the red-brick Japanese city with its wide, often well paved streets in diagonal patterns, its typically Japanese monuments and its little khaki-clad gendarmes in blood-red cap-bands, where the traveler by train usually alights in Mukden. But Feng-tien proper is quite thoroughly Chinese, when one does at last reach it by one of the many available but all leisurely means of transportation. There is not merely a massive inner wall surrounding what was the capital of the Manchus before they spread over China and took up their headquarters in Peking, but a mud wall of careless and irregular shape encloses the entire city, down to the last suburb hovel, less as a protection against earthly enemies than to shut out those omnipresent evil spirits of the fervid Chinese imagination. Inside, there is what Spanish Americans would call mucho movimiento, interminable movement, a dodging to and fro of more rickshaws than there are taxicabs in New York, a constant passing of myriads of men and boys, even of women and girls, these often in the fantastic Manchu head-dress, an ever moving multitude on business, pleasure, or nothing whatever bent. Shops offering everything from steamed bread to rolls of copper coins, 74from red paper banners to pulverized deerhorns, line the way thickly, in dense succession. Venders of anything which native Mukden is in the habit of consuming, or of keeping unconsumed, weave their way in and out of the throngs, the muddy side streets, the tight little alleyways, announcing their wares by strange cries or mechanical noises that have come to be accepted for what they purport to be. Yet for all the bustle there is an atmosphere of Chinese calm. Shopkeepers may be eager for trade, but they will not be hurried out of a fitting deportment merely to please clients from the breathless West; hawkers move through the streets and carry on their bargaining as if the commodity we know as time had no appreciable value to them, though they keep industriously at their allotted task of announcing and disposing of as many of their wares as the fates decree. Above all the katydids or crickets singing in their crude little woven-reed cages suspended before house- and shop-door give a sense of bucolic calm that neutralizes any hint of haste in the incessant swarming to and fro of every type of Chinese.
There’s almost nothing Chinese about the red-brick Japanese city, except for these things and the people who frequent them. It features wide, often well-paved streets in diagonal patterns, typical Japanese monuments, and little khaki-clad gendarmes wearing blood-red cap bands. Travelers usually get off the train in Mukden. However, Feng-tien itself feels completely Chinese once you finally get there by one of the many available but all leisurely ways of transport. Not only is there a massive inner wall surrounding what used to be the capital of the Manchus before they expanded across China and established their base in Peking, but a mud wall of uneven shape encloses the entire city, down to the last rundown shack. This isn’t just to defend against earthly enemies but to ward off those ever-present evil spirits from the vivid Chinese imagination. Inside, there’s what Spanish Americans would call lots of movement, endless movement, with more rickshaws weaving through the streets than there are taxicabs in New York, and a constant flow of countless men, boys, and even women and girls, many in the elaborate Manchu headgear, all part of a bustling crowd engaged in business, leisure, or just hanging out. Shops selling everything from steamed bread to rolls of copper coins, from red paper banners to crushed deerhorns, line the streets in dense rows. Vendors offering anything that local Mukden residents typically consume or save for later weave through the crowds, navigating the muddy side streets and narrow alleyways, calling out their goods with peculiar cries or mechanical sounds that people have come to recognize. Yet, despite all the hustle, there’s an atmosphere of Chinese tranquility. Shopkeepers may be keen to make sales, but they won’t rush just to satisfy clients from the frantic West. Street hawkers carry on their bargaining like time has no real value to them, even while they diligently announce and sell as many of their goods as fate allows. Above all, the katydids or crickets chirping in their simple woven-reed cages hanging in front of homes and shops provide a sense of rural calm that balances out any hint of haste amidst the continual flux of every type of Chinese.
Hawkers of this curious breed of Chinese singing-bird wander all the streets of Feng-tien, a score or more of the little cages at the ends of their shoulder-poles, one or two of the green insects, resembling “grasshoppers,” in each cage, and beside them sprigs of grass to feed upon until their support devolves upon a purchaser. We bought one for the diminutive member of our family, cage and all for twenty coppers, which seemed to be about a nickel, though it goes without saying that both as strangers and foreigners we were no doubt grossly swindled. Nor would the captive sing for us, at least long enough to be worth the price, during the day or two we kept him, gay and melodious as he and his companions were in Chinese captivity. Possibly he missed the mellifluous odors of the native city and was drooping with homesickness. When his little alien owner set him free in the park of the Japanese city, there was no great hope that he would enjoy his liberty long, for Chinese urchins were slinking about with a furtive air and an alert demeanor which boded ill for singing insects—unless, as we half suspected, those of China prefer to hang before a shop and chant keepers and clients into harmonious understanding.
Hawkers of this unique type of Chinese singing bird roam all the streets of Feng-tien, carrying a score or more of small cages on the ends of their shoulder poles, each containing one or two green insects that look like "grasshoppers," along with some sprigs of grass for them to eat until someone buys them. We bought one for the smallest member of our family, cage and all, for twenty coppers, which seemed to be about a nickel, though it’s clear that, as strangers and foreigners, we were probably ripped off. The captive wouldn’t sing for us, at least not long enough to be worth the price, during the day or two we had him, despite how cheerful and melodic he and his companions were in Chinese captivity. He might have missed the sweet scents of his hometown and was feeling homesick. When his little foreign owner set him free in the park of the Japanese city, there was little hope he would enjoy his freedom for long, since Chinese kids were lurking around with a sneaky look and alert stance that didn’t bode well for singing insects—unless, as we half suspected, those from China prefer to hang in front of a shop and sing, helping to create a harmonious vibe between the shopkeepers and customers.
The mere “sights” of Mukden in the tourist sense all date back at least three hundred years. There is the Manchu palace within the real city wall, its many structures still impressive in their roofs of imperial yellow tiles for all the dust-covered wrecks they are fast becoming under caretakers interested only in the size of their gratuities. An 75hour’s churning by Mukden’s Russian type of carriage over what the Chinese regard as a road is not too high a price to pay for a stroll through the capacious grounds of the Pei-ling, or Northern Tombs, where the second and last emperor to occupy the palaces in the city lies with his consort under the usual artificial hillock behind elaborate structures roofed also in imperial yellow. For though one is sure to see as many tombs of the famous and infamous in China as cathedrals in Europe, this is by no means the least imposing of them. It takes a bit more courage to jolt out to Tung-ling, the Eastern Mausoleum, a generation older and twice as far away; but there pine-clad hills and rather gentle yet impressive scenery make up for the somewhat less expansive tombs. Then, too, those whose interests are not entirely in the past may wish to run out on the branch line to Fushun, where the Japanese are taking out—by the use of economical Chinese muscle—vast quantities of coal from an open cut that goes down into the earth in steps, like a dry-dock prepared for some mammoth ship many times larger than any sea has ever floated.
The main “sights” of Mukden for tourists all go back at least three hundred years. There’s the Manchu palace within the actual city wall, with its many structures still striking thanks to their roofs made of imperial yellow tiles, despite the fact that they are quickly becoming dust-covered ruins under caretakers focused only on how much tip they can get. A 75 minute ride in Mukden’s Russian-style carriage over what the Chinese see as a road is a small price to pay for a walk through the spacious grounds of the Pei-ling, or Northern Tombs, where the second and last emperor to live in the city’s palaces rests with his consort beneath the usual artificial hillock behind elaborate buildings also topped with imperial yellow roofs. Although you can find as many tombs of the famous and infamous in China as cathedrals in Europe, this one is by no means the least impressive. It takes a bit more bravery to head out to Tung-ling, the Eastern Mausoleum, which is a generation older and twice as far away; however, in that area, the pine-covered hills and gently yet striking scenery make up for the somewhat smaller tombs. Also, those who aren’t solely interested in history might want to take a trip on the branch line to Fushun, where the Japanese are extracting—using inexpensive Chinese labor—huge amounts of coal from an open pit that descends into the earth in steps, like a dry dock made for some gigantic ship much larger than any sea has ever held.
It was at Mukden that we first came into personal contact with the swarms of soldiers—“coolies in uniform” might be a more exact term—with which all China is cursed under its putative republican régime. Chang Tso-lin, the war lord of Manchuria, had just been thwarted in his plan to get control of Peking, and his troops in their muddy-gray cotton uniforms were still pouring back into the city by the train-load. Wagon-trains of ammunition, useful another year, were rumbling through the narrow streets, hauled by dust-caked mules. Troops were stowed away everywhere, in every big yard or semi-public compound, in unsuspected corners, in barracks outside the town. Nowhere could one open the eyes without seeing soldiers, lounging in unmilitary attitude before guarded gates, lolling about the streets and bazaars with the air of conquerors to whom nothing could be denied, drawn in endless files through the Japanese city on their way to the railway station stretched out at ease in rickshaws among their bed-stuffed possessions and grasping in one hand the rifle with the butt of which the great majority of them probably paid the perspiring coolies so incessantly trotting back and forth with them. How much more picturesque life would be with us if our soldiers mobilized in taxicabs, and booted the driver out of the way if he dared to call attention to the taximeter.
It was at Mukden that we first had personal contact with the swarms of soldiers—“coolies in uniform” might describe them better—who plague all of China under its supposed republican regime. Chang Tso-lin, the warlord of Manchuria, had just been stopped in his attempt to take control of Peking, and his troops in their muddy-gray cotton uniforms were still streaming back into the city by the trainload. Wagon-trains of ammunition, useful another year, were rumbling through the narrow streets, pulled by dust-covered mules. Troops were crammed everywhere, in every large yard or semi-public space, in unexpected corners, in barracks outside the town. Nowhere could one look without seeing soldiers, lounging in lazy postures before guarded gates, hanging out in the streets and bazaars with the swagger of conquerors who felt entitled to everything, marching in endless lines through the Japanese city on their way to the railway station, sprawled comfortably in rickshaws with their belongings stuffed all around them, gripping their rifles with the same hands they likely used to pay the sweating coolies who kept scurrying back and forth. How much more colorful life would be for us if our soldiers hailed taxicabs and kicked the driver out if he dared to mention the fare meter.
Scholarly-looking little Chang Tso-lin, in his ugly French-château style of dwelling that seems so inexcusable an intruder among the 76graceful palaces of China, is an enigma, at least to those who have merely met rather than learned to know him. How this outwardly almost insignificant man can hold a great territory in the hollow of his hand, baffling all the cross-currents of intrigue which sweep incessantly up and down the “Eastern Three Provinces,” was a query worth pondering. Virtually a bandit in his younger days, then a lieutenant in the Japanese army during the war with Russia, Chang gathered somewhere the power to rule which made him an autocrat over his own people and won him even among many of the foreigners who breathe the Manchurian atmosphere the reputation of being the “strong man” of China. His methods are drastic and prompt; he is said to depend more on intuition, on “hunches,” than on ordered reflection. Keys to the leg-irons of serious criminals he kept in his own possession, so that they could not buy off in the time-honored Chinese fashion. Just before we reached Mukden two of his generals had been detected in the not unprecedented Chinese feat of putting into their own pockets a few cents a day from each soldier’s pay. Chang had them up on the carpet only after he had undeniable proof of their guilt, and there was nothing left for them to do but to confess and plead for mercy. A curt order to have them taken to the execution-ground beyond the outer city wall closed the incident. On the same day two common soldiers who had indulged in looting in outlying districts were found in the possession of the extraordinary sum of five hundred dollars each, and for three days their bodies were left lying out in front of the Chinese railway station as a hint to others whose plans might be taking similar shape. Cynics, and those foreign residents whose pet among the “strong men” of China is some one else, lay such personal disasters to the simple fact that Chang himself did not get his share of the “squeeze,” but the consensus of opinion seemed to be otherwise.
Scholarly-looking Chang Tso-lin, with his unattractive French-château style house that feels like an unwelcome presence among the elegant palaces of China, is a puzzle, at least to those who have only met him instead of truly getting to know him. The way this seemingly insignificant man can control a vast territory while navigating the constant political intrigue of the “Eastern Three Provinces” is a question worth considering. Once a bandit in his youth and later a lieutenant in the Japanese army during the war with Russia, Chang somehow amassed the power needed to become an autocrat over his own people, earning him a reputation as the “strong man” of China among many foreigners living in Manchuria. His methods are harsh and immediate; he reportedly relies more on instinct and “hunches” than on careful analysis. He kept the keys to the leg-irons of serious criminals with him, preventing them from bribing their way out as is common in Chinese tradition. Just before we arrived in Mukden, two of his generals were caught in the familiar Chinese act of pocketing a few cents each day from every soldier’s pay. Chang only summoned them for a hearing once he had undeniable proof of their guilt, leaving them with no choice but to confess and ask for mercy. A brief order sent them to the execution ground outside the city wall, wrapping up the matter. On the same day, two ordinary soldiers who had been looting in nearby areas were found with an astonishing five hundred dollars each, and their bodies were left on display for three days outside the Chinese railway station as a warning to anyone else who might be considering similar actions. Skeptics and foreign residents who support other “strong men” in China attribute such personal misfortunes to the fact that Chang himself didn’t get a cut of the “squeeze,” but most people seemed to think differently.

Two ladies in the station waiting-room of Antung, just across the Yalu from Korea, proudly comparing the relative inadequacy of their crippled feet
Two women in the waiting room of the Antung station, just across the Yalu from Korea, proudly comparing the shortcomings of their injured feet.

The Japanese have made Dairen, southern terminus of Manchuria and once the Russian Dalny, one of the most modern cities of the Far East
The Japanese have developed Dairen, the southern end of Manchuria and formerly known as the Russian Dalny, into one of the most modern cities in the Far East.

A ruined gallery in the famous North Fort of the Russians at Port Arthur. Hundreds of such war memorials are preserved by the Japanese on the sites of their first victory over the white race
A damaged gallery in the well-known North Fort of the Russians at Port Arthur. Hundreds of these war memorials are maintained by the Japanese at the locations of their initial victory over the white race.

The empty Manchu throne of Mukden
The vacant Manchu throne in Mukden
77The centuries-old Chinese method of execution by the lopping off of heads seems almost to have died out in modern militaristic China, at least in the north, along with such punishments as the slicing or the boxing up of those who win official displeasure. As condemned men cross the bridge to the execution-ground at Mukden, they are politely asked whether they wish to take morphine. Most of them “save face” by refusing it and assuming an outward air of bravery and indifference, perhaps even of gaiety. Sometimes as many as a score kneel on the ground together, their arms tied behind them. A soldier, who gets two “Mex” dollars for each man he despatches, walks down the line and kills as many as he chooses, and when he tires of the sport another soldier quickly takes his place. There are stories of men quarreling violently because the first one killed more than his share. The rifle barrel is placed behind the ear of each victim in prompt succession, the other kneeling men gazing up the line to see when their turn is coming, sometimes even laughing aloud at a bad shot, and as each man falls on his face from the force of the discharge a guard yanks the body out straight and cuts off the leg-irons. One might as well be in a barber-shop so far as any atmosphere of life and death, as we of the West understand it, goes at these frequent execution-parties at Feng-tien.
77The centuries-old Chinese practice of execution by beheading seems to have almost disappeared in modern militaristic China, at least in the north, along with punishments like slicing and boxing for those who incur official disapproval. As condemned prisoners walk across the bridge to the execution site in Mukden, they're politely asked if they want morphine. Most choose to "save face" by refusing and putting on a front of bravery and indifference, sometimes even appearing cheerful. Sometimes, as many as twenty men kneel together on the ground with their arms tied behind them. A soldier, who earns two "Mex" dollars for each person he executes, walks down the line and kills as many as he wants; when he gets tired of it, another soldier quickly takes his place. There are stories of men arguing fiercely because the first soldier executed more than his share. The rifle barrel is placed behind the ear of each victim in quick succession, while the other kneeling men look down the line to see when it will be their turn, sometimes even laughing at a bad shot. As each man falls face-first from the force of the shot, a guard pulls the body straight and removes the leg irons. It might as well be a barber shop in terms of the atmosphere surrounding life and death, as we in the West understand it, at these frequent execution gatherings in Feng-tien.
It must take a certain nerve-control to serve under the “war lord of Manchuria.” Hardly an hour after the two generals so radically cured of grafting had joined their ancestors, another general was asked to step into an automobile and go out to the execution-grounds with two American visitors. There was something about his manner which suggested that the general was under some great strain, but his companions, familiar with despotic rulers only in popular fiction, did not suspect until they reached their destination just why it was so obviously an effort for him to keep his attention on a subject, or even to swallow. But when he saw that there were no armed soldiers on hand to receive him, and that he had really been sent for no other purpose than to act as guide for the visitors, he thawed out so thoroughly that the foreigners carried off a false impression of the expansiveness which a Chinese gentleman displays to casual acquaintances.
It must take a certain level of self-control to serve under the “war lord of Manchuria.” Hardly an hour after the two generals, who had been significantly reformed, passed away, another general was asked to get into a car and head to the execution grounds with two American visitors. There was something about his demeanor that suggested he was under a lot of pressure, but his companions, who were only familiar with tyrannical leaders from stories, didn’t realize until they arrived just why it was such a struggle for him to focus on a topic or even to swallow. But when he noticed that there were no armed soldiers waiting for him and that he had truly been brought there just to act as a guide for the visitors, he relaxed completely, leaving the foreigners with a false impression of the friendliness that a Chinese gentleman shows to casual acquaintances.
Chang himself is evidently not without certain misgivings of a personal nature. When another American, armed with a motion-picture outfit and full credentials, was introduced into the war lord’s residence by one of his most trusted officials, General Chang the younger, his son and commander-in-chief of his armies, came to look things over in person, and even then the father cautiously examined the camera when he appeared, and a dozen of his personal body-guard—to which, rumor has it, no one is eligible who has not killed at least ten men—stood behind the camera-man with rifles loosely slung in the crook of their elbows during the filming. Yet the younger general reads, and to a certain extent speaks, English; his wife wears over her ears the hair-puffs of the Western “flapper”; a graduate of Columbia University is the official interpreter, several Chinese graduates of West Point serve under him, and the general’s favorite car 78comes from Michigan’s best automobile factory—where it was fitted with machine-gun emplacements and straps to keep the guards on the running-boards from changing their minds in times of danger.
Chang clearly has some personal concerns. When another American, equipped with a film camera and all the right credentials, was brought into the warlord’s residence by one of his most trusted officials, General Chang the younger—his son and commander of his armies—came to check it out himself. Even then, the father carefully inspected the camera when he showed up, while a dozen of his personal bodyguards—who, rumor has it, are only selected if they’ve killed at least ten men—stood behind the cameraman, rifles casually held in the crook of their elbows during the shoot. Yet the younger general understands and can speak some English; his wife sports the hair-puffs of the modern “flapper”; a Columbia University graduate serves as the official interpreter, several Chinese West Point graduates are on his team, and the general’s favorite car 78is from Michigan’s top auto factory—it’s even equipped with machine-gun mounts and straps to keep guards on the running boards in place during dangerous situations.
I passed through Mukden four times before my journeys in as many directions from that focal point of Manchuria ended, and often had news from there after we moved on, for the doings of Chang Tso-lin were always of interest to the rest of China. To all intents and purposes this forceful little Chinese had become the absolute ruler of what was the home-land of the Manchus before they usurped the throne at Peking, completely reversing the rôles of the two peoples as they were played in 1644. The influx of Chinese after that date, when the Great Wall ceased to be a barrier between the overcrowded regions inside it and the vast open spaces of the nomad herdsmen beyond, gradually turned these into tilled fields where cultivation had hitherto been as strictly prohibited as had Chinese immigration, and finally swamped the thinly inhabited region entirely. The Manchus conquered China, and China began again in her time-honored way to swallow up the conquerors, until to-day there is no such thing as a Manchu nation, hardly a spoken remnant of the sonorous Manchu language, no one resembling the fierce warriors and hardy horsemen who put an end to the Ming dynasty such a little while ago. For it is barely three centuries since the chief of the “Eastern Tartars” commanded several learned persons of his nation to design a system of writing Manchu, upon the model of that of the Mongols, and not until two decades later that his successor ascended the dragon throne. To-day one meets individuals all over China who consider themselves Manchus, but they are hardly in any way distinguishable from the Chinese among whom they have been completely assimilated. One may travel the length and breadth of Manchuria now without realizing that he is not in China “proper,” and particularly since the rise of its present Chinese dictator it is much more fittingly known by its Chinese name of “Eastern Three Provinces.”
I passed through Mukden four times before my travels in different directions from that central point in Manchuria came to an end, and I often received updates from there after we moved on, since the actions of Chang Tso-lin were always of interest to the rest of China. This strong-willed Chinese leader had effectively become the absolute ruler of what was once the homeland of the Manchus before they took the throne in Peking, completely reversing the roles of the two peoples as they were in 1644. The increase of Chinese migration after that time, when the Great Wall stopped being a barrier between the overcrowded regions inside it and the vast open areas of the nomadic herders beyond, gradually turned those spaces into cultivated fields where farming had previously been strictly forbidden, just as Chinese immigration had been, and eventually overwhelmed the sparsely populated area entirely. The Manchus conquered China, and China started again in its traditional way to absorb the conquerors, until today there’s no such thing as a Manchu nation, hardly any remnants of the once-flourishing Manchu language, and no one left who resembles the fierce warriors and tough horsemen who ended the Ming dynasty not long ago. It’s been barely three centuries since the leader of the “Eastern Tartars” commissioned several scholars from his people to create a writing system for Manchu, modeled after that of the Mongols, and it wasn’t until two decades later that his successor took the throne. Nowadays, you can find people all over China who identify as Manchus, but they’re hardly distinguishable from the Chinese among whom they have completely blended in. You can travel all across Manchuria now without realizing you’re not in “mainland” China, especially since the rise of its current Chinese dictator; it’s more appropriately referred to by its Chinese name, “Eastern Three Provinces.”
Virtually, if not openly, independent under his rule, that vast fertile region may possibly have a new future that will make it worthy of still another name, devoid of any suggestion of dependency. Mukden has its own foreign office; the incomes from the national salt monopoly and the customs, from that portion of the railway to Peking which lies north of the Great Wall, and from other similar sources flow directly into Chang’s treasury. The latest report is that he is making a good and, within Chinese limits, honest use of them. Mukden 79threatens to blossom out soon in widened and paved streets, to increase her school facilities, to send the old horse-cars off again on their wanderings and become the third city of China with electric tramways. Incidentally there is talk of a system of conscription to give Chang’s armies the full supply of hardy young men which this great granary of them under his command is capable of supplying, which will be a line of demarcation indeed from the haphazard, voluntary enlistments so long and fixedly in vogue in China “proper.” There are those who believe that provincial autonomy in place of the tightly centralized form of government of imperial days is not merely the visible development in modern “republican” China but the best thing that could happen to the colossal old empire, and these are watching with interest what they hope is the advancement of Manchuria under its approximately independent rule. But political changes are often swift in what was for so many centuries the unchangeable Middle Kingdom, and which still calls itself by the old name, so that it would be worse than boldness to prophesy whether another year will find Chang Tso-lin the undisputed sovereign of a progressive and well administered Northeastern China or merely another of those innumerable eliminated politicians fattening into dotage over their ill gotten gains in the safety-zones commonly known as foreign concessions.
Basically, under his leadership, that large, fertile area might have a new future that earns it a completely different name, one that doesn’t suggest any dependence. Mukden has its own foreign office; the revenue from the national salt monopoly, customs, the part of the railway to Beijing that lies north of the Great Wall, and other similar sources go straight into Chang’s treasury. The latest reports say he’s using the funds well and, within Chinese standards, honestly. Mukden 79 is set to soon develop broader and paved streets, enhance school facilities, restart the old horse-drawn carriages, and become the third city in China to have electric trams. There’s also talk of a conscription system to provide Chang’s armies with a full supply of strong young men from this significant agricultural area under his command, which will mark a clear shift from the random, voluntary enlistments that have long been the norm in “mainland” China. Some believe that provincial autonomy, rather than the tightly centralized government of imperial times, is not only a visible trend in modern “republican” China but also the best possible outcome for the vast old empire, and they are closely watching what they hope will be the progress of Manchuria under its nearly independent governance. However, political changes can happen rapidly in what has been known for so many centuries as the unchanging Middle Kingdom, which still uses the old name, so predicting whether another year will see Chang Tso-lin as the undisputed ruler of a progressive and well-governed Northeastern China or just another of those countless removed politicians growing old off their ill-gotten wealth in the so-called safe zones known as foreign concessions would be more than just risky.
As the traveler races north or southward from Mukden by the excellent expresses of the South Manchurian Railway, well ballasted and much of it already double-tracked, through towns lighted by electricity and as spick and span as Japanese rule can make them, it is hard to realize that when the present century began the home-land of the Manchus was almost unknown to the outside world in anything but name. Back behind these modern railway cities bulk the old walled towns of China, and in the never distant background the mere passenger glimpses the primitive methods of transportation and of life in general that are in such sharp contrast to his immediate surroundings, fitted with almost everything that civilization has mechanically to offer. In the summer season kaoliang, a species of what our own South knows as sorghum and which bears a considerable resemblance to the Kaffir-corn widely cultivated in Haiti, covers the earth with its deep green to the height of a horseman’s head, often as far as the eye can see for hours at a time—and makes magnificent hiding for bandits. The flatness of Manchuria at Mukden and to the north is made up for by the splendid range of mountains that follows the railway 80not far off on the left all the way to Dairen, great tumbled hills in which the mere tramper or the seeker after old temples and ancient monasteries finds himself equally rewarded. But it was still my lot for a time longer to stick rather closely to the lines of modern travel and to commonplace, if comfortable, modern cities.
As the traveler rushes north or south from Mukden on the excellent trains of the South Manchurian Railway, which are well-maintained and mostly double-tracked, through towns that are illuminated by electricity and as neat as Japanese rule can make them, it's hard to believe that at the start of this century, the homeland of the Manchus was almost unknown to the outside world except by name. Behind these modern railway towns lie the old walled cities of China, and in the ever-present background, the passenger catches glimpses of the primitive transportation methods and general way of life that stand in stark contrast to his immediate surroundings, which offer nearly everything that modern civilization can provide. In the summer, kaoliang, a type of sorghum similar to the Kaffir-corn that is widely grown in Haiti, grows deep green to the height of a horseman’s head, often stretching for miles—and provides excellent cover for bandits. The flat terrain of Manchuria at Mukden and to the north is balanced by the stunning range of mountains that runs alongside the railway on the left all the way to Dairen, with great rolling hills where hikers or those seeking ancient temples and monasteries find themselves well rewarded. But for a bit longer, I was still stuck closely to the routes of modern travel and the typical, though comfortable, modern cities.
Dairen, which the Japanese have made of the Russian Dalny in the leased portion of the Liaotung Peninsula that fell to them as the spoils of war, has all the un-Chinese characteristics of such cities, to enumerate which would merely be to describe in detail any one of a hundred great ports and railway termini in Europe or, with certain modifications, North America. May not therefore the broad macadamed streets, the big brick and stone buildings, the great breakwaters, the mammoth cranes on the docks, and all the rest of the signs of what we call progress, so admirable but so unpicturesque, be taken for granted? We liked Port Arthur, which the Japanese have redubbed Ryojun, better. There life was more leisurely; old buildings constructed by the Russians, streets that broke out every little while into grass- and even weed-grown open spaces, the spaciousness of a place which never grew to be the large busy city its founders planned, gave it something of the atmosphere of an old town of England, or of our South, somewhat off the track of present-day hasty and bustling activity. Ryojun is the seat of government of the Japanese leased territory, while Dairen is merely its metropolis. The old Port Arthur and the new are separated by a rivulet emptying into the splendid landlocked port, and by some hills, of which there are more than the eye can count rolling and piling away across all the landscape of the region. These are by far the most conspicuous features of Port Arthur and vicinity, for there is scarcely a knoll among them that does not bear on its summit a monument. Whether it is merely an unconscious manifestation of their military spirit, strong and continual as far back as history can trace them, or a deliberate parading of their victory over a branch of the white man’s world, the Japanese have marked every spot where a handful of their countrymen fell and have preserved the ruins of every fort out of which the Russian defenders were bombarded, so that the hilly landscape of all the region is littered with mementos to the god of war. Nor is his day over in Port Arthur, for a garrison commander sits ever on the alert against kodaking tourists who would profane his stone-built playthings overlooking the bay. Both at Port Arthur and at Dairen there are beaches that might become the international resorts the Japanese are striving to make them, could their sponsors ever learn that the rest of the world is not so enamoured of the dwarfish Nipponese form in the nude as they seem themselves to be.
Dairen, which the Japanese developed from the Russian Dalny in the leased section of the Liaotung Peninsula they acquired as war spoils, has all the non-Chinese features typical of such cities. Listing them would just lead to a description of any one of many major ports and railway hubs in Europe or, with some adjustments, North America. Can we therefore just assume the wide paved streets, large brick and stone buildings, extensive breakwaters, massive cranes at the docks, and all the other symbols of what we refer to as progress—so impressive yet so unappealing? We preferred Port Arthur, which the Japanese have renamed Ryojun. Life there was more relaxed; old buildings built by the Russians, streets that would occasionally open up into grassy, weed-filled spaces, and the spaciousness of a place that never turned into the bustling city its founders envisioned gave it an atmosphere reminiscent of an old English town or a slower area of the South, somewhat detached from today’s fast-paced activity. Ryojun serves as the government seat of the Japanese-occupied territory, while Dairen is simply its main city. The old Port Arthur and the new one are divided by a small stream that flows into the beautiful landlocked port, and by various hills, more numerous than one can easily count, rolling and stacking across the landscape. These hills are the most prominent features of Port Arthur and its surroundings, as there’s hardly a rise among them that doesn’t have a monument on top. Whether this is just an unconscious display of their military spirit, which has been strong and persistent throughout history, or a deliberate celebration of their victory over a part of the Western world, the Japanese have marked every location where a few of their countrymen fell and have preserved the ruins of every fort from which the Russian defenders were bombarded, leaving the hilly landscape scattered with tributes to their god of war. Nor is this influence gone in Port Arthur, as a garrison commander is always on guard against tourists with cameras who might disrespect his stone structures overlooking the bay. Both at Port Arthur and at Dairen, there are beaches that could become the international resorts the Japanese are trying to create, if their backers could ever understand that the rest of the world isn’t as fascinated by the short Japanese body in the nude as they seem to be themselves.

A Manchu woman in her national head-dress, bargaining with a street vender of Mukden for a cup of tea
A Manchu woman in her traditional headdress haggling with a street vendor in Mukden for a cup of tea.

The Russian so loves a uniform, even after the land it represents has gone to pot, that even school-boys in Vladivostok usually wear them,—red bands, khaki, black trousers, purple epaulets
The Russian has such a strong attachment to uniforms, even when the country they represent has fallen apart, that even schoolboys in Vladivostok typically wear them—red bands, khaki, black pants, purple epaulets.

A common sight in Harbin,—a Russian refugee, in this case a blind boy, begging in the street of passing Chinese
A common sight in Harbin—a Russian refugee, in this case a blind boy, begging on the street from passing Chinese.

A Russian in Harbin—evidently not a Bolshevik or he would be living in affluence in Russia
A Russian in Harbin—clearly not a Bolshevik or he would be living comfortably in Russia.
81Northward from Mukden there are also many reminders of Japanese military prowess, besides the railway itself. Here the line was being double-tracked, perhaps because the diversion of shipping, by fair means and foul, from Vladivostok to Dairen was proving too much for it. The Chinese workmen lived in semi-caves and reed-mat huts, and left a bush or a small tree at the top of a slim pyramid of earth here and there to show how deep they had dug for the new grading. Dense green hills and the unpicturesque, widely scattered huts of Manchuria broke the general landscape of endless fields of beans closely planted, with kaoliang and millet, wheat and corn, demanding their share of the broad open country. Cattle, horses, mules, and donkeys were plentiful, and ungainly black pigs more so. Every little while we passed a large walled town of which we in the West know not even the name, and somewhere not far from each of them was a new Japanese section including the railway station and rows of trainmen’s houses, perhaps schools and a hospital. But for all the advantages showered upon them the migrating Japanese plainly could not compete hand to hand with the Chinese pouring up from the crowded provinces across the Gulf of Chihli. They kept shop, ran the railroad, filled all the higher positions in the enterprises, such as mining, milling, and electric lighting, in which they are engaged, but as actual producers from the soil itself, of overwhelming importance in spacious, fertile, still rather thinly populated Manchuria, they were visibly incapacitated.
81North of Mukden, there are many reminders of Japanese military strength, in addition to the railway itself. The tracks were being upgraded to double track, perhaps because the shift of shipping, by any means necessary, from Vladivostok to Dairen was becoming too much to handle. The Chinese workers lived in semi-caves and huts made of reeds, leaving a bush or small tree at the top of a slender mound of dirt here and there to indicate how deep they had dug for the new grading. Lush green hills and the unattractive, widely scattered huts of Manchuria broke the overall landscape of endlessly planted fields of beans, alongside kaoliang, millet, wheat, and corn, all vying for their share of the vast open land. Cattle, horses, mules, and donkeys were abundant, and clumsy black pigs were even more so. Every so often, we passed a large walled town whose name we in the West do not even know, and not far from each of them was a new Japanese area that included the railway station and rows of houses for train workers, possibly schools and a hospital. But despite all the advantages given to them, the migrating Japanese clearly could not compete with the Chinese coming in from the overcrowded provinces across the Gulf of Chihli. They owned shops, operated the railroad, and held all the higher positions in businesses such as mining, milling, and electrical lighting, but when it came to actually producing from the land itself, which was critically important in the spacious, fertile, still relatively sparsely populated Manchuria, they were obviously struggling.
CHAPTER VI
THROUGH CHINA UNDER RUSSIAN INFLUENCE
The changes which burst suddenly upon the traveler at Changchun would be startling if he were not almost certain to be prepared for them. Unless his memory is short or his age brief he can scarcely be unaware of the fact that the Treaty of Portsmouth on our own New England coast made Changchun the meeting-place of that portion of the Chinese Eastern Railway which remained to the Russians after their trouncing, and that long section of it which their conquerors have made over into the South Manchurian Railway. One steps from what is essentially an American express-train upon the station platform, and from that into an express-train that is European down to its most insignificant details. Cars of the “Compagnie Internationale des Wagons-Lits” offer him the comfort of their separate compartments, brilliantly lighted by frosted bulbs, furnished even with thermometers, roomy with the five-foot gage of Russian railways, on which trains use the right- rather than the left-hand track. The heavy-stacked engine is as different from the one across the platform still panting from its race northward as the densely bearded Russian trainmen are from the alert little brown men of the same calling. Suddenly there were Russians everywhere, and by no means all of them were of a type to make one unduly proud of the white race; some indeed were roustabouts and station hangers-on living by petty graft upon uninformed travelers, such as the latter are never subjected to on the Japanese railways of Manchuria. There was such a mixture of Chinese, Japanese, and Russians at Changchun that one could only surmise who was really in control. It was a Russian who asked me for my passport—and who raised his hat, bowed low, and retired with an almost subservient “Thank you” when I answered that I was American. Booted and spurred Russians in khaki, in woolen trousers and cotton smocks, in the best they could do in the way of an individual uniform, their waists compressed to maidenly slenderness by tight belts, strutted the platforms in long swords with an air that said plainly that they would far rather die than have to work and 83not be able to strut about in uniform, boots, spurs, and sword. European civilians of both sexes, tow-headed women and children, mere Russian farmers, leaned on station barriers or made their way to and from the third-class coaches. One type in particular was very familiar,—the half-subservient, half-cocky, always vulgar Russian Jew, much assured of himself now, since the new turn things have taken in Russia, but still more or less openly despised by the non-Jewish Russians. In our car was one of the most offensive of these fellows, head of the opium ring of Harbin, who acted as if he had purchased the earth from its original owners and was making it a personal plaything.
The changes that suddenly hit the traveler in Changchun would be shocking if he weren’t almost certainly ready for them. Unless he has a short memory or is very young, he can hardly be unaware that the Treaty of Portsmouth along our New England coast made Changchun the meeting point for the part of the Chinese Eastern Railway that remained with the Russians after their defeat, as well as the long section that their conquerors transformed into the South Manchurian Railway. One steps off what is essentially an American express train onto the station platform and then boards a European express train, down to the smallest details. Cars from the “Compagnie Internationale des Wagons-Lits” offer him the comfort of private compartments, brightly lit by frosted bulbs, even equipped with thermometers, spacious due to the five-foot gauge of Russian railways, where trains follow the right-hand track instead of the left. The heavily constructed engine is as different from the one across the platform still huffing from its run north as the bushy-bearded Russian train crews are from the alert little brown operators of the same job. Suddenly, Russians were everywhere, and not all fit the mold to make one proud of the white race; some were indeed laborers and station hangers-on making a living through petty scams on unsuspecting travelers, an experience one wouldn’t encounter on the Japanese railways in Manchuria. The mix of Chinese, Japanese, and Russians in Changchun was so blended that one could only guess who was really in charge. It was a Russian who asked me for my passport—and who tipped his hat, bowed deeply, and departed with a nearly submissive “Thank you” when I replied that I was American. Russians in boots and spurs, dressed in khaki, wool trousers, and cotton smocks, wearing their best attempts at a uniform, their waists cinched tightly by belts, strutted along the platforms with long swords, conveying a clear message that they would rather die than work and not display themselves in their uniforms, boots, spurs, and swords. European civilians of all sorts, blonde women and children, simple Russian farmers, leaned on station barriers or moved between third-class coaches. One type in particular was very familiar—the half-subservient, half-arrogant, always vulgar Russian Jew, now full of himself since the recent changes in Russia, but still somewhat openly looked down upon by non-Jewish Russians. In our car was one of the most obnoxious of these individuals, the head of the Harbin opium ring, who acted as if he had bought the world from its original owners and was treating it as his personal toy.
The train made incredibly long stops at every station, but excellent speed between them, though it burned wood and thereby saved us from soot and cinders. I had a sense of being in an utterly foreign land, many times more so than among the Japanese. For one thing station names were in Chinese and Russian, equally illegible to those of us who recognize a word only in Roman letters, while from Yokohama to Changchun even the most insignificant stopping-place announces itself in English. Hitherto at least the head trainman was almost certain to have a smattering of my tongue; at worst I could produce a few short but highly valuable phrases of Japanese; but these black-bearded fellows were separated from me by an utterly impenetrable linguistic wall. They might quite as well have been Hottentots or Zulus as far as any possibility of communicating with them either by spoken or written word went. Perhaps it was mainly this sense of strangeness that made the air seem surcharged with something ominous, something akin to hopeless political conditions.
The train made super long stops at every station but sped along nicely between them, even though it burned wood, which kept us clear of soot and cinders. I felt like I was in a completely foreign land, even more so than when I was among the Japanese. For one thing, the station names were in Chinese and Russian, equally unreadable for those of us who only recognize words in Roman letters. From Yokohama to Changchun, even the most minor stops announce themselves in English. Until now, at least the lead train person was almost guaranteed to know a bit of my language; at worst, I could say a few short but very useful phrases in Japanese. But these black-bearded guys were separated from me by a totally impenetrable language barrier. They might as well have been Hottentots or Zulus for all the chance I had to communicate with them, either by speaking or writing. Maybe it was mainly this feeling of unfamiliarity that made the atmosphere feel heavy with something ominous, something similar to hopeless political situations.
But through it all the endless plains of corn and beans, millet and wheat, beautiful in their deep green, spread as far as the eye could reach in every direction, hour after hour, all afternoon long. The plodding Chinese peasant, who is the mudsill of all the struggles of rival empires to control this vast rich territory, was still toiling here and there when the sun touched the flat western horizon. But at frequent intervals Russian boys in soldierly caps came running out of yellow brick farm-houses surrounded by a kind of Chinese wall. Many more of them lived in villages, some of which might have been lifted bodily out of European Russia. At these, Chinese and tow-headed venders appeared on the off side of stations, until they were chased away by policemen, offering live chickens, ducks, eggs by the basketful. A wonderful land, Manchuria, whether for cultivating or 84merely for the grazing of stock; no wonder crowded Japan covets this broad, half-wasted region, yet she has already shown that she would exploit rather than people it.
But through it all, the endless fields of corn and beans, millet and wheat, stunning in their deep green, stretched as far as the eye could see in every direction, hour after hour, all afternoon long. The hardworking Chinese farmer, who is the foundation of all the struggles between rival empires to control this vast, rich land, was still working here and there when the sun dipped below the flat western horizon. Meanwhile, at regular intervals, Russian boys in soldier caps came running out of yellow brick farmhouses surrounded by a kind of Chinese wall. Many more of them lived in villages, some of which could have been picked up from European Russia. In these places, Chinese and fair-haired vendors appeared on the far side of train stations until they were chased away by policemen, offering live chickens, ducks, and baskets of eggs. A remarkable land, Manchuria is perfect for farming or for grazing livestock; it’s no wonder that densely populated Japan covets this vast, underdeveloped area, yet she has already shown that she prefers to exploit it rather than settle it.
Rain was pouring when we reached Harbin, and seemed to have been for weeks. At least never in all my wanderings have I floundered through worse sloughs of mud than in the droshke which lost itself in the inky blackness and the downpour in what looked for a time like a vain attempt to get me from the station to a hotel. By morning light there seemed no particular reason for this, for though every street was covered at least with slime, there were enough of them roughly stone-paved to carry all the droshkes with which Harbin swarms. Perhaps it was merely an example of the impracticability of the Russians, of which I was to hear so many more before I moved on.
Rain was pouring when we arrived in Harbin, and it seemed to have been doing so for weeks. At least, I've never struggled through worse muddy conditions than in the droshke, which got lost in the pitch-black darkness and the downpour, looking for a while like a pointless effort to get me from the station to a hotel. By morning light, there seemed to be no good reason for this, because although every street was covered in slime, there were enough roughly stone-paved ones to accommodate all the droshkes that filled Harbin. Maybe this was just an example of how impractical the Russians were, something I would hear a lot more about before I moved on.
At Harbin, though still well inside China, the traveler finds himself back in Europe. Unless his geography is proof against such deceptions, he might easily believe that he had crossed the line into Russia and brought up in one of its most typical cities. Streets, architecture, customs, inhabitants are all on the Russian model. Instead of rickshaws there are two types of carriages,—the droshke, of barouche effect, drawn in most cases by two horses, the shaft animal under a great arched pole and the off one with its head tied down to a level with its knees and twisted well to the outside, thanks to some time-honored Russian idea of style or efficiency; then there is the amerikanka. The “American woman,” as foreign residents facetiously translate the word, is a two-wheeled cart with a plain open box on top, on a corner of which sits the driver, apparently wholly inured to the jouncing with every step of the horse and every unevenness of the road which the passenger or two beside him seldom gives evidence of enjoying. But the amerikanka is ridiculously cheap by Western standards, and the Russian who manipulates it is almost sure to be cheery and pleasant, filled with naïve tales of what is and what he believes is going on inside Russia proper, if one chances to have a companion who can act as interpreter, and in any case a relief merely as a Caucasian after months among squint-eyed Orientals. Already, however, the motor-buses which probably have by this time driven most of the leisurely Russian wielders of horse-whips out of business had begun to appear on the streets of Harbin.
At Harbin, still well within China, travelers find themselves back in Europe. Unless their geography is against such illusions, they might easily think they've crossed into Russia and ended up in one of its typical cities. The streets, architecture, customs, and locals all follow the Russian model. Instead of rickshaws, there are two types of carriages: the droshke, which resembles a barouche and is usually pulled by two horses, with one horse under a large arched pole and the other with its head tied down to knee level, twisted outward, thanks to a time-honored Russian idea of style or efficiency; then there’s the amerikanka. The “American woman,” as foreign residents jokingly translate the term, is a two-wheeled cart with a simple open box on top, where the driver sits on one corner, seemingly used to bouncing with every step of the horse and every bump in the road, which the passenger or two beside him rarely seems to enjoy. However, the amerikanka is laughably cheap by Western standards, and the Russian driving it is almost always cheerful and friendly, full of naive tales about what’s happening in Russia, as long as you have a companion to interpret. It's a nice relief to have a Caucasian around after months with squint-eyed Orientals. Already, though, the motorbuses, which have likely driven most of the leisurely Russian whip-wielders out of business, have started to appear on the streets of Harbin.
The houses have double windows, with a space of two or three feet between the panes of glass; and great cylindrical stoves built into the walls from floor to ceiling, preferably in a corner where they can 85bulge into two, and even four, rooms, are almost as universal as in Russia. In a July heat which left one drenched after a short stroll, even by moonlight, and which made the briefest interview in any of Harbin’s dungeon-like, double-walled offices a kind of “third degree,” it was hard to believe these evidences of long winters during which, barely four months thence, it would often be forty below zero and the wearing of furs indispensable. To its residents and to most of its visitors Harbin, all Manchuria in fact, is a land of snow and ice and bitter gales; to me, who happened to be there in the very climax of the brief summer, it will always bring back memories of a climate compared to which that of the tropics is mild and invigorating. Nor can I remember meeting in all Japan such battalions of flies as helped to make life miserable in summer-time Harbin, with its brief nights and its interminable days.
The houses have double windows with a gap of two or three feet between the panes of glass, and there are large cylindrical stoves built into the walls from floor to ceiling, usually in a corner where they can extend into two or even four rooms, just like in Russia. In July's heat, which left you soaked after just a short walk, even at night, and made a quick meeting in any of Harbin’s cramped, double-walled offices feel like an interrogation, it was hard to believe in these signs of long winters when, just a few months later, temperatures could drop to forty below zero, making fur coats essential. For its residents and most of its visitors, Harbin—and all of Manchuria, really—feels like a land of snow, ice, and biting winds; but for me, being there during the peak of the short summer, it will always evoke memories of a climate that makes tropical weather seem mild and refreshing. Plus, I don’t remember encountering such swarms of flies in all of Japan that made life unbearable in summer Harbin, with its short nights and endless days.
I know at last why one’s hat is always snatched from him when he enters a Russian-Jewish restaurant in New York. In Russia, and equally in Harbin, it is an inexcusable discourtesy to go into an office, even for the briefest instant, wearing, or carrying, hat or overcoat. There are always flunkies waiting to take them away from you outside the door, and obviously they expect to be remembered when you leave. I am overcome with grief to think that, in my appalling ignorance, I so long fancied one of the least beloved customs of our metropolis a mere scheme to extort tips, instead of a transplanted refinement from urbane Russia. Equally Russian is the Harbin practice of shaking hands with the entire personnel, from proprietor to errand-boy, of any shop one enters, however slight the purchase one has in view. Indeed, the more genuinely well bred shake hands all around again before they leave.
I finally understand why your hat is always taken from you when you walk into a Russian-Jewish restaurant in New York. In Russia, and also in Harbin, it’s considered extremely rude to enter an office, even for a moment, wearing or carrying a hat or coat. There are always attendants waiting to take them from you at the door, and it’s clear they expect to be tipped when you leave. I’m filled with sadness to realize that, in my complete ignorance, I used to think one of the least appreciated customs of our city was just a ploy to get tips, instead of being a refined practice borrowed from sophisticated Russia. The same applies to Harbin, where it’s customary to shake hands with everyone in a shop, from the owner to the delivery guy, no matter how small your purchase is. In fact, the more genuinely well-mannered people will even shake hands with everyone again before leaving.
Several gaudy blue, green, and gold churches of the Russian Orthodox faith rise in fantastic domes and puffed-out, cross-surmounted spires above the general level of Harbin, and religious ceremonies imported direct from pre-Bolshevik Moscow may be seen any day in the week. Funerals, for instance, were of more than daily occurrence. Most often they were those of impoverished refugees, and were brief and inconspicuous; but there were frequent processions of the elaborate, typically Russian character. I passed two such within half an hour one noonday. The first was of the wife of the Russian station-master. He had discharged a Chinese employee for negligence and “squeeze,” and the latter had returned to kill him, his bullet accidentally striking 86the wife instead. The second was of the head of the Harbin Gymnasium, or upper school, once a colonel and a man of great wealth in Russia, now so impoverished that his wife and children, on foot behind the hearse, as is the Russian custom, were almost in rags and virtually barefoot. Mummers in fantastic costumes, including long, light-colored robes, walked before and on either side of the deceased, who were carried in canopied vehicles gay beyond anything western Europe or the New World has to offer the dead, even the horses draped from ears to fetlocks in flowing white coverlets fancifully embroidered. But the most surprising, not to say repulsive, Russian feature of the ceremony was the public display of the corpse. In each case the heavy lid of the coffin was laid diagonally off to one side, and during all the miles from church to cemetery, with several stops for the burning of incense and priestly blessings on the way, the yellow face of the departed rolled from side to side as the open hearse jolted over the stony pavements.
Several brightly colored blue, green, and gold churches of the Russian Orthodox faith rise in stunning domes and lofty, cross-topped spires above the general skyline of Harbin, and you can see religious ceremonies brought straight from pre-Bolshevik Moscow any day of the week. Funerals, for instance, happened more than once a day. Most were for poor refugees and were brief and low-key, but there were frequent processions that were elaborate and typically Russian. I passed by two of these in just half an hour one day around noon. The first was for the wife of the Russian station-master. He had fired a Chinese worker for negligence and corruption, and the worker had come back to kill him, accidentally hitting his wife instead. The second was for the head of the Harbin Gym, who had once been a colonel and a wealthy man in Russia, but was now so impoverished that his wife and children, walking behind the hearse as is the Russian custom, were nearly in rags and almost barefoot. Performers in extravagant costumes, including long, light-colored robes, walked in front and on either side of the deceased, who were transported in canopied vehicles far more colorful than anything you’d find in Western Europe or the New World for the dead, even the horses draped in flowing white cloths beautifully embroidered from their ears to their legs. But the most surprising, if not disturbing, Russian aspect of the ceremony was the public display of the corpse. In each case, the heavy lid of the coffin was placed diagonally to one side, and during the entire journey from the church to the cemetery, which included several stops for burning incense and receiving priestly blessings, the yellow face of the departed rolled from side to side as the open hearse bounced over the rough pavements.
It is an old saying that to scratch a Russian is to find a Tartar, but I had taken this to be a mere figure of speech until I came to Harbin and northern Manchuria, where the European and the Asiatic Orientals live side by side. The Chinese and the Russians, one quickly realized there, understand each other better than we of the real West can ever hope to understand either. They have the same complicated Oriental way of thinking, a similar point of view in such matters as “squeeze,” not very dissimilar business methods. In a Russian department-store of Harbin the purchaser gets two checks, one of which he pays at the desk under the personal eye of the owner or manager, getting the other stamped and presenting it, not to the clerk who served him, but to another so far away that collusion between them would be difficult, before he is finally handed his purchase. The mere loss of time on both sides no more worries the Russian than it would the Chinese. At every turn I found myself startled to recognize as another Russian trait what I had fancied was characteristic merely of eastern Asia. Every important house in Harbin had its private policeman, usually a Russian ex-soldier, and wherever one attempted to enter a gate watchmen and domestic hangers-on sprang up from all sides as thickly as at the entrance to a Chinese residence or yamen. Perhaps the greatest surprise was the discovery that the Russian uses the abacus or swan-pan for doing his arithmetic, just like the people of Japan, Korea, and China, except that with him the contrivance is much larger, as if his heavier fingers needed wooden balls worthy of their strength. Mental 87arithmetic seemed to be as impossible to him as to a Chinese shopkeeper or to the subjects of the mikado. On my first visit to a dining-car on the C. E. R., it being two or three hours before dinner-time, I had merely a glass of tea and some Russian form of pastry. The bill of fare announced these as costing 15 and 45 sen respectively—Japanese money is most widely used now in the Russianized zone of Manchuria. The ikon-faced man at his desk in a corner of the car, his mammoth black beard looking like a wig that had fallen from its place on his utterly hairless head, solemnly picked up his counting-board, rattled the balls back and forth for a full minute, and finally wrote down with an air of intellectual triumph the total of the two items on my check before him. No Westerner can ever hope to sandwich himself in between two peoples who prefer the abacus to pencil and paper for their arithmetical problems.
It’s an old saying that if you scratch a Russian, you’ll find a Tartar, but I thought that was just a figure of speech until I arrived in Harbin and northern Manchuria, where Europeans and Asian locals coexist. There, it quickly became clear that the Chinese and Russians understand each other much better than we in the real West could ever understand either group. They share a complex Oriental way of thinking and a similar perspective on things like “squeeze,” as well as business practices that aren’t too different. In a Russian department store in Harbin, customers receive two receipts—one to pay at a desk watched over by the owner or manager, and another that’s stamped and presented to a different clerk far enough away that collusion is unlikely, before finally receiving their purchase. The time lost on both sides doesn’t bother the Russian any more than it does the Chinese. I was often surprised to find what I thought was a trait unique to eastern Asia was actually another Russian characteristic. Every significant establishment in Harbin had its own private policeman, usually an ex-soldier, and wherever one tried to enter a gate, watchmen and staff appeared just as densely as at the entrance to a Chinese home or yamen. Perhaps the biggest shock was learning that Russians use the abacus or swan-pan for their calculations, just like people in Japan, Korea, and China, but the Russian version is much larger, as if his larger fingers needed wooden balls that could handle their strength. Mental arithmetic seemed as impossible for him as it does for a Chinese shopkeeper or the subjects of the emperor. On my first visit to a dining car on the C.E.R., a couple of hours before dinner time, I just had a glass of tea and some Russian pastry. The menu listed them as costing 15 and 45 sen respectively—Japanese money is the most commonly used currency in the Russianized part of Manchuria. The man with the icon-like face at his desk in a corner of the car, his massive black beard looking like a wig that had slipped off his completely bald head, solemnly picked up his counting board, moved the beads back and forth for a full minute, and then proudly wrote down the total of the two items on my bill. No Westerner can ever expect to squeeze himself between two cultures that prefer the abacus over pencil and paper for their math problems.
Yet the Russians are white men, and thereby hang certain problems that are sure to thrust themselves upon the visitor to northern Manchuria in the present days of Russian upheaval. It was a distinct pleasure to find myself again where Westerners were not incessantly stared at, even though it was useless to attempt to speak a word with men and women who would have looked perfectly at home on the streets of any large American city. But it was quite otherwise suddenly to realize that some of the weaknesses of our Western civilization are much more conspicuous, or at least more public, than similar flaws in Oriental society. Neither China nor Japan are model lands in many respects, but during all the time I had spent in the Far East I had not seen a fraction of the open indecency, the unashamed vulgarity, the deliberate flaunting of sexual wares that raged in the several conspicuous café singing-halls of Harbin. It was almost a shock even to see white women again in any number; to find them dressing and behaving as no Japanese geisha, no singsong-girl of Korea or China, would ever think of doing outside her semi-domestic circle, was more impressive, more suggestive of the vices of our civilization, than the average of us would have called to his attention during a lifetime of Western residence. The contrast, added to a little knowledge of the point of view of the Oriental as to the proper place of the sex appeal in life, made such things stand out with the vividness of electric sign-boards. As Westerners we might understand that Harbin, under undefined economic conditions and somewhat chaotic government, with overturned Russia pouring its vices and its hungers down into it, was not a normal sample of the West; to the occasional fat, smug Chinese 88visitors to these blatant places, and through them to thousands of their race, such parading of our vices could do more to give a false impression of Western life and the Western character than a thousand decent Occidentals, working for years to no other purpose, could correct.
Yet the Russians are white men, and that brings certain issues that are bound to confront anyone visiting northern Manchuria during these turbulent times in Russia. It was a distinct pleasure to find myself again where Westerners weren’t constantly stared at, even though it was pointless to try to have a conversation with men and women who would fit right in on the streets of any large American city. However, it was quite another thing to suddenly realize that some of the weaknesses of our Western civilization are much more visible, or at least more publicly displayed, than similar flaws in Eastern society. Neither China nor Japan are perfect places in many ways, but during all my time in the Far East, I hadn't encountered a fraction of the open indecency, unashamed vulgarity, and deliberate flaunting of sexual merchandise that flourished in the numerous eye-catching café singing-halls of Harbin. It was almost shocking to see a substantial number of white women again; observing them dress and act in ways that no Japanese geisha or singsong girl from Korea or China would ever consider outside her domestic circle was more striking, more indicative of the vices of our civilization, than most of us would have noticed after a lifetime in the West. The contrast, combined with some understanding of how Easterners view the role of sexual appeal in life, made these things stand out like electric billboards. As Westerners, we might recognize that Harbin, under vague economic conditions and somewhat chaotic governance, with the crumbling Russia spilling its vices and desires into it, was not a true representation of the West; for the occasional plump, smug Chinese visitors to these overtly sinful spots, and through them to thousands of their countrymen, this display of our vices could create a more misleading impression of Western life and character than a thousand decent Occidentals, working years for the purpose, could ever undo.
Two decades ago, while I was wandering across Asia during the Japanese-Russian War, an English-speaking Hindu expressed to me his great astonishment that the white world should permit the yellow race to show its superiority over even what seemed just then the most widely disliked branch of the Caucasian family. He realized what at least the untraveled bulk of the Occident does not to this day, that every sign of weakness in any white nation, almost in any white individual, is immediately applied by the average Oriental mind to the whole white race. The effect of Japan’s victory over Russia, working like a leaven through the masses of Asia for a score of years, was quite apparent in certain general changes of attitude toward Westerners, some of them fortunate, many of them quite the contrary. Now, with the second catastrophe of Russia flooding Asia with new examples of Caucasian weaknesses, of white men reduced to a lower level than Asia had ever before seen them, one could not but feel that it behooves the Western world in general to look to the impression Russians in China are making for the Caucasian family as a whole, and to know what their treatment is at the hands of the Chinese. For while we may recognize the Russian as essentially an Oriental, really more closely allied to the Chinese than to ourselves, the latter thinks of him entirely as a Westerner, typical in his faults and his weaknesses of that other side of the earth toward which the Oriental attitude is of growing importance. I do not know whether or not the continued supremacy of the white race is best for the world at large; but I have rather strong personal opinions on that subject, and those who are like-minded would do well to look into the question of the present-day conditions of Russians in China, where at least the respect on which much of that supremacy depends is being gradually eaten away.
Two decades ago, while I was traveling across Asia during the Japanese-Russian War, an English-speaking Hindu expressed his shock that the white world would allow the yellow race to demonstrate its superiority over even what seemed like the most disliked part of the Caucasian family. He understood something that most people in the West still don’t grasp today: any sign of weakness from any white nation, or almost any white individual, is immediately perceived by the average Eastern mindset as a reflection of the entire white race. The impact of Japan’s victory over Russia, which had been influencing the masses in Asia for twenty years, was clear in certain general shifts in attitude toward Westerners—some of which were positive, but many were quite the opposite. Now, with the recent catastrophe in Russia showcasing new examples of Caucasian weaknesses, showing white men in worse conditions than Asia had ever seen before, it’s clear that the Western world as a whole needs to consider the impression Russians in China are leaving on the Caucasian family and understand how they are treated by the Chinese. While we may view the Russian as essentially an Oriental, more closely related to the Chinese than to ourselves, the latter sees him purely as a Westerner, embodying the flaws and weaknesses typical of that part of the world, which is increasingly significant in the Eastern perspective. I’m not sure if the ongoing dominance of the white race is beneficial for the world overall; I do have strong personal opinions on the matter, and those who share my views should pay attention to the current situation of Russians in China, where the respect that much of that supremacy relies on is gradually eroding.
Along all the principal thoroughfares of Harbin squatted scores of white beggars, women and children among them, appealing to Chinese as well as to European passers-by. In the market-places of this and of other towns along the C. E. R. I saw many a Russian covered with filth, sores, and a few tattered rags, a noisome receptacle of some kind in his hands, wandering from stall to stall pleading with the sardonic Chinese keepers to give him a half-rotten tomato or a putrid piece of 89meat. Barefooted refugee children roamed the streets, picking up whatever they could find, including some of the nastiest of Chinese habits. Former officers of the czar, and wives who were once the grace of any drawing-room, speaking French with a faultless accent, lived in miserable pens with only ragged cloth partitions between them and their teeming neighbors, eating the poorest of Chinese coolie food, some of them unable to go out unless they went barefoot. In the so-called thieves’ market every conceivable kind of junk, from useful kitchen utensils to useless bric-à-brac of Russian ancestry, was offered for sale; any morning one might see several hundred Russian men and women shuttling to and fro there, trying to sell an odd pair of boots, an all but worn-out garment, a child’s toy, for the price of a handful of potatoes or a measure of kaoliang, or attempting to exchange something they had at last found they could do without for something their fellow refugees still had that seemed to them indispensable.
Along all the main streets of Harbin, there were many white beggars, including women and children, appealing to both Chinese and European passersby. In the markets of this town and others along the C. E. R., I saw many Russians covered in dirt and sores, wearing a few tattered rags, wandering from stall to stall, begging the sardonic Chinese shopkeepers for a half-rotten tomato or a spoiled piece of meat. Barefoot refugee children roamed the streets, picking up whatever they could find, including some of the worst Chinese habits. Former officers of the czar and wives who once graced high-society drawing rooms and spoke French flawlessly lived in grim quarters with only ragged fabric partitions between them and their crowded neighbors, eating the poorest-quality Chinese coolie food, some unable to go outside unless they walked barefoot. In the so-called thieves’ market, every possible type of junk, from useful kitchen tools to useless Russian knick-knacks, was for sale; any morning, you might see hundreds of Russian men and women moving back and forth, trying to sell a mismatched pair of boots, a nearly worn-out garment, a child's toy, in exchange for a handful of potatoes or a measure of kaoliang, or trying to trade something they'd finally realized they could live without for something their fellow refugees still had that seemed essential to them.
The few Americans in Harbin at least were doing what they could to relieve the needy Russians. But it was an even more complicated task than we of the West would suppose, for here again the essential Orientalism of the victims came out. Young men with fine faces, on which the signs of semi-starvation were in plain evidence, would come imploring any kind of assistance, any position that would give them enough to buy bread. “Why,” they would cry, as if they were going the utmost limit in describing their horrible state, “I will even work with my hands!” But this was merely bluff; nothing could make your typical Russian of the class which Bolshevism chased out of the country debase himself to any such degree as that, starve, beg, or steal though he must. With a plethora of hungry, yet still sturdy, Russians of both sexes all about them, it was almost impossible for the American residents to get servants, unless they took Chinese from the native city. They could get innumerable teachers of Russian, almost none of whom had any conception of how to teach, nor the persistence, patience, and punctuality which that calling requires; but when it came to washing dishes and mopping floors chances went begging in the very houses which were being bombarded with frantic appeals for help against incipient starvation. It was not merely that these former well-to-do did not know how to work; they would do anything rather than learn.
The few Americans in Harbin were at least trying to help the struggling Russians. But it was an even more complicated task than we in the West would think, because the inherent Orientalism of the victims was evident. Young men with strong features, visibly showing signs of near-starvation, would come asking for any kind of help, any job that would give them enough to buy bread. “Why,” they would exclaim, as if they were pushing the limits of describing their terrible situation, “I will even work with my hands!” But this was just a front; nothing could make your typical Russian from the class that Bolshevism drove out of the country stoop that low, even if they had to starve, beg, or steal. With so many hungry but still resilient Russians of both genders around, it was almost impossible for the American residents to find servants unless they hired Chinese from the local city. They could find countless teachers of Russian, nearly all of whom had no idea how to teach or lacked the persistence, patience, and punctuality that the job requires; but when it came to washing dishes and mopping floors, offers went unanswered in homes that were being bombarded with desperate pleas for help against looming starvation. It wasn't just that these formerly well-off individuals didn't know how to work; they would prefer anything rather than learn.
Fifteen boys who worked their way across Siberia and were found jobs by the Y. M. C. A. secretary of Harbin all ran away very shortly afterward, taking with them money or clothing, or both, belonging to their employers. One went home all the way across Siberia again to 90find his mother, discovered no trace of her, was caught by the “Red” army, and finally turned up in Harbin once more with frozen feet and looking like an old man, though he was only seventeen. This same secretary had countless appeals for help and at the same time a job of pumping water at his own house, but he was never able to make the two meet. Time after time he offered some hungry young Russian this task, which meant less than two hours’ work a day, at any time of the day that the worker might choose, the salary to be all the food he could eat and $7.50 “Mex” a month—a very liberal offer in China, even for high-priced Harbin. Invariably each applicant for aid bowed low at this offer, assured the secretary that he had saved his life, thanked him in the deepest Russian manner possible, which might include the kissing of the benefactor’s hands—and invariably never turned up again. One case was so obviously deserving that the secretary dug a good suit of clothes out of the bottom of his trunk, had it dry-cleaned, and gave it to the poor fellow, along with the pumping job, from which he discharged the Chinese boy who had recently been filling it very satisfactorily—and the next day, when his water ran out, he found that the man and the suit had gone to Vladivostok.
Fifteen boys who made their way across Siberia and found jobs through the YMCA secretary in Harbin quickly ran away, taking money or clothes, or both, from their employers. One boy traveled all the way back across Siberia to find his mother, but after not finding any trace of her, he got caught by the “Red” army and eventually returned to Harbin, frostbitten and looking aged, even though he was only seventeen. This same secretary received countless requests for help while also having a job to pump water at his own home, but he could never find a way to manage both. Time after time, he offered some hungry young Russian this job, which required less than two hours of work a day, at any time they wanted, with pay covering all the food they could eat plus $7.50 “Mex” a month—a very generous offer in China, even for high-priced Harbin. Each applicant for help would bow deeply, say the secretary saved their life, and thank him in the most dramatic Russian way possible, which often included kissing his hands—but they never came back. One case was so clearly deserving that the secretary pulled a nice suit out of the bottom of his trunk, had it dry-cleaned, and gave it to the poor guy, along with the pumping job, dismissing the Chinese boy who had been doing it very well. The next day, when the water ran out, he discovered the man and the suit had vanished to Vladivostok.
American representatives of such organizations as the Red Cross, who were spending money and energy for the betterment of Russian refugees in Harbin, Kirin, and other towns of northern Manchuria, could not get a man among all the big sturdy fellows they were feeding to build a brick stove, to patch a roof, or to dig a trench for their own benefit; Chinese laborers had to be called in to do all such “work with the hands.” Indeed, the refugees expected their benefactors to hire servants to sweep out and keep in order the buildings that had been found for them. There were some well-to-do Russians in Harbin—more C. E. R. officials than there were positions for them to fill lived there in style, and a few families had escaped from Russia early enough to have been able to bring much of their wealth with them, not to mention others who had long been in business in Manchuria. But these were the last people in Harbin to help their unfortunate compatriots. They might flaunt their own comfort and extravagance in the lean faces of the unfortunate; they were even known to “squeeze” some of the poor devils among the refugees of the working-class who found and accepted work; but they were as Oriental as the Chinese in looking callously on while their own people starved about them, or were succored by men from across the sea.
American representatives from organizations like the Red Cross, who were investing time and resources to help Russian refugees in Harbin, Kirin, and other northern Manchuria towns, couldn’t find a single one of the strong men they were supporting willing to build a brick stove, fix a roof, or dig a trench for their own benefit; they had to call in Chinese laborers to handle all that “manual work.” In fact, the refugees expected their benefactors to hire servants to clean and maintain the buildings provided for them. There were some well-off Russians in Harbin—more C. E. R. officials than there were jobs for them, living comfortably, and a few families had managed to escape from Russia early enough to bring a lot of their wealth with them, along with others who had been in business in Manchuria for a long time. However, these were the last people in Harbin willing to assist their unfortunate compatriots. They would flaunt their comfort and luxury in front of the famished, and some were even known to “squeeze” money from the struggling working-class refugees who found and accepted jobs; yet they were just as indifferent as the Chinese, watching their own people starve while being helped by foreigners from across the sea.
91For a time the Y. M. C. A. secretary helped young Russians to immigrate to the United States under the guise of students, there being some special ruling for these in spite of the new immigration restrictions; but so many of them turned out to be men who had helped to start the revolution in Russia and hoped to do the same in America that the plan proved to be unwise. Those who succeeded in finding tasks to the liking of the hand-sparing fugitives had their own troubles. “Hire a Russian and you have to hire another man to watch him,” was the consensus of opinion among all who had had that experience. Russian ideas of honesty were frankly Oriental; moreover they were idealists, dreamers, with no business sense, no conception of economics or economies, no “go,” not a practical trait in their whole make-up, unless they had some German, Swedish, or French blood in their veins, which the few enterprising ones in Harbin did. For all that they were a most likable people, childlike in their manners as well as their irresponsibility, with nothing of the surliness of the Japanese, nor of the Chinese love of ridicule. They gave one the feeling that they were not fitted to cope with the practical every-day world, that they should not be wandering about it without guardians and advisers. One soon ceased to wonder that the trade of Harbin was almost exclusively in the hands of the Jews and the Chinese; a few days in northern Manchuria were enough to explain why the Jews are so powerful and so hated in Russia, why it has been considered necessary to curb them, almost enough to make clear the incredible success of Bolshevism over common sense.
91For a while, the Y. M. C. A. secretary helped young Russians immigrate to the United States pretending to be students, as there was a special rule for them despite the new immigration restrictions. However, many of them turned out to be individuals who had helped start the revolution in Russia and hoped to do the same in America, so the plan turned out to be unwise. Those who managed to find jobs for these struggling refugees faced their own challenges. “Hire a Russian and you have to hire another person to watch him,” was the general opinion among everyone who had that experience. Russian ideas of honesty were openly influenced by Eastern culture; additionally, they were idealists and dreamers, lacking business sense, understanding of economics, or practicality, unless they had some German, Swedish, or French ancestry, which the few enterprising individuals in Harbin did. Despite this, they were a very likable people, childlike in their behavior as well as their irresponsibility, without the surliness of the Japanese or the Chinese tendency for ridicule. They gave the impression that they were not suited to deal with the practical challenges of everyday life, that they shouldn’t be navigating it without guardians and advisors. It became easy to understand why trade in Harbin was mostly controlled by Jews and Chinese; just a few days in northern Manchuria were enough to shed light on why Jews are so powerful and simultaneously so hated in Russia, and why there has been a perceived need to restrain them, almost enough to clarify the remarkable success of Bolshevism over common sense.
Distinctly a chip of the degenerate old régime was Harbin, inhabited mainly by people whom nothing would drive to manual labor but who were quite ready to spread intrigue and false propaganda against the new rulers in their native land. The Bolsheviks, it seems generally admitted, are at least sincere, wildly impractical as they are in their ideas of human society; these refugees of Harbin, one felt, would be just as bad as ever if once they got back into power, would have learned nothing whatever, thanks to their incapability, their temperamental ineptitude, from their bitter experiences. “Propaganda aside,” said foreign residents who were in a position to know, and who certainly were not friendly to the new order in Russia, “if the bulk of the Russian people were able to vote between the old régime and the present one they would choose the latter as the least of two evils”; and any one who has made even a brief stay in the Russian metropolis of China would probably be inclined to agree with that statement.
Harbin was clearly a remnant of the corrupt old regime, mainly populated by people who wouldn’t lift a finger for manual work, yet were eager to stir up intrigue and spread false information against the new rulers in their homeland. It seems generally accepted that the Bolsheviks are sincere, even if their ideas about society are wildly impractical; these refugees from Harbin would likely revert to their old ways if they regained power, having learned nothing from their harsh experiences due to their inability and temperament. “Putting propaganda aside,” said foreign residents who had the insight to know better and were certainly not sympathetic to the new regime in Russia, “if the majority of the Russian people could choose between the old regime and the current one, they would pick the latter as the lesser of two evils”; and anyone who has spent even a short time in the Russian community in China would probably agree with that sentiment.
92The night life of Harbin, even passing over the vicious part of it, was in great contrast to that of Japan and the adjoining lands I had so far visited. Whatever else they might have to do without, the Russian exiles plainly did not propose to deny themselves the gay times, the mingling together in social concourse, the rivalry of dress and public squandering of money, the joys of good music, which had been so important a part of their life at home. Countless anecdotes floated about Harbin of refugees dressing like lords though they had not a crust left at home, of selling necessary things, even of spending money that had been given to keep them from starvation, to get raiment in which they were not ashamed to appear in the frequent social gatherings. In the park of the Railway Club, to which members and their families were admitted free and passing strangers at a goodly price of admission, there was an immense crowd on the evening I spent there, as there is almost any night of the week, so purely European a crowd that it took a distinct mental exertion to realize that one was still in China. Yet in all the big audience that stood and strolled about the huge shell-shaped sounding-board, from within the mouth of which a large orchestra gave an all-Tchaikowsky program that would have been loudly applauded by music lovers anywhere, there was scarcely a visible sign of straitened circumstances, to say nothing of poverty. Ladies as well gowned as at the Paris races strolled with men faultlessly garbed, by European standards, who swung their “sticks” with the haughty grace of aristocrats to whom the lack of an adequate income had never so much as occurred. Men and women sipping iced drinks on the veranda of the club paid their checks and tipped their waiters with as lavish an air as if the World War had never happened. Not a few men were in a kind of combination smock and uniform, with collars buttoning high about the neck; but these looked as much like an exuberance of fashion as like subterfuges to save shirts or cover the lack of them, just as their tightly belted waists were more of a fad than an open admission of the meagerness of their suppers.
92The nightlife in Harbin, despite its rough edges, stood in stark contrast to that of Japan and the nearby places I had visited so far. No matter what else they might have to go without, the Russian exiles clearly weren’t willing to miss out on having a good time, socializing, showing off their clothes, and spending money publicly. The pleasures of good music, which had played such an important role in their lives back home, remained vital. There were countless stories circulating in Harbin about refugees dressing like nobles despite having little to nothing at home, selling essential items, and even spending money that had been given to them to prevent starvation just to get outfits they wouldn’t be embarrassed to wear at the social gatherings they frequently attended. In the park of the Railway Club, which offered free admission to members and their families while charging passing strangers a decent fee, there was a huge crowd on the evening I spent there, as there is almost any night of the week. The crowd was so distinctly European that it took a conscious effort to remember that I was still in China. Yet, among the large audience that gathered and wandered around the massive shell-shaped stage from which a large orchestra played an all-Tchaikovsky program that would have drawn cheers from music lovers everywhere, there was hardly a visible sign of financial hardship, let alone poverty. Ladies dressed as elegantly as those at the Paris races strolled with men impeccably dressed by European standards, who swung their “canes” with the proud elegance of aristocrats who had never even considered a lack of adequate income. Men and women sipping iced drinks on the club's veranda paid their tabs and tipped their waiters with such flourish, as if the World War had never taken place. A number of men wore a sort of combination smock and uniform, with collars buttoned high around their necks; but these appeared more like a trendy fashion statement than an attempt to save on shirts or cover up the lack of them, just as their tightly belted waists seemed more like a style choice than a clear signal of meager dinners.
It was like such a concert in a Spanish-American plaza, yet in many ways different. The hearers stood during the numbers and walked between them, reversing the usual practice south of the Rio Grande. There was endless hand-shaking; beards were not conspicuously numerous and even mustaches were little in fashion, at least among the younger men, but closely clipped, even shaved, heads seemed to be as much the style as among the modern Chinese, who, now that they are doing away with the pigtail, are doing so with such a vengeance that 93their scalps show white through the bristles. Short hair was not uncommon among the women, too, though less as a fashion, it was said, than because so many had had typhus during their fugitive days. It was strange to see the women all wearing hats, quite aside from the fact that they were almost all new ones; it was strange to see women openly treated with respect, for that matter, and walking arm in arm with their men; strangest of all was the queer feeling of mingling again with thousands of white people, after months of never having seen more than a dozen of them together. Not a few of the girls and young women were more than good-looking, in form as well as face, a fact which many of them seemed to take care not to conceal, for some of the newest dresses were startlingly thin, and rolled stockings barely covering the ankle were almost the rule among the younger set. But Russians do not appear to be prudish about the display of the human form; during July and August great numbers of both sexes, quite of the decent class, bathe together perfectly naked in the muddy water of Harbin’s uninspiring river.
It was like a concert in a Spanish-American plaza, but in many ways different. The audience stood during the performances and walked in between them, going against the typical practice south of the Rio Grande. There was endless hand-shaking; beards weren't very common and mustaches were hardly in style, at least among the younger men, but closely cropped or shaved heads seemed to be just as popular as among modern Chinese, who, now that they are getting rid of the pigtail, are doing it with such enthusiasm that their scalps show white through the bristles. Short hair wasn't uncommon among women either, though it was less about fashion, it was said, and more because so many had suffered from typhus during their time on the run. It was odd to see women all wearing hats, especially since they were almost all new; it was strange to see women treated with respect in public, walking arm in arm with their partners; but the strangest feeling of all was mingling again with thousands of white people after months of seeing no more than a dozen at once. Many of the girls and young women were not just good-looking, both in body and face, a fact that many of them seemed to flaunt, as some of the latest dresses were startlingly sheer, and rolled stockings barely covering the ankle were pretty common among the younger crowd. But Russians don't seem to be modest about showing the human body; during July and August, large numbers of both sexes from decent backgrounds swim together completely naked in the muddy waters of Harbin’s unimpressive river.
I was introduced to princesses in simple but very appropriate garb, to people with strange and with sad stories, to men who had run away from Russia and left their wives to follow—if they could—to women who had performed incredible feats and suffered unbelievable hardships to escape from the blighted land or to join such unworthy husbands, and who in some cases still retained their striking beauty and in many their Russian charm. Yet numerous as were the fine faces in the crowd, it hardly needed the experience of foreign residents to call attention to the fact that in so many instances these looked proud and impractical and—well, inefficient in the matter-of-fact things of life. Now and then there passed through the throng that made respectful way for them old generals still wearing their uniforms, blazing from shoulder to shoulder with decorations, and the same haughty expression of men expecting instant obedience as in their bygone days of power and emoluments. I could not quite get the point of view on some Russian prejudices. Not one of that race with whom I spoke during my journey through northern Manchuria lost an opportunity to curse the Jews, whom they always spoke of as synonymous with the new régime in their native land. Yet the leader of this orchestra was a Jew, and he not only got wild applause at the end of almost every number, even from men who left off vilifying his people just long enough to add to it in the heartiest fashion, but when he raised his baton to start the first number the almost entirely Russian orchestra 94had given him a “rouser” instead, a sudden burst of music entirely different from what they were about to play, which is considered in Russian musical circles the highest honor that can be paid a musical director.
I met princesses dressed simply but very appropriately, people with strange and sad stories, men who had fled Russia and left their wives behind—if they could—to women who had performed incredible feats and endured unimaginable hardships to escape from their troubled homeland or to reunite with unworthy husbands, and who in some cases still showed remarkable beauty and often their Russian charm. Yet, despite the many fine faces in the crowd, it didn’t take long for foreign residents to notice that in many instances these individuals looked proud and impractical, and—well, ineffective when it came to the practical matters of everyday life. Now and then, old generals still in their uniforms, adorned with medals from shoulder to shoulder, passed through the crowd, and the same arrogant expression of men expecting instant obedience from others, as in their days of power and wealth, was evident. I couldn't quite understand some of the Russian prejudices. Not one person from that culture I spoke to during my journey through northern Manchuria missed a chance to curse the Jews, whom they always linked to the new regime back home. Yet, the conductor of this orchestra was a Jew, and he not only received wild applause at the end of almost every piece—even from men who paused their vilification of his people just long enough to join in fervently—but when he raised his baton to begin the first piece, the almost entirely Russian orchestra honored him with a “rouser” instead, a sudden burst of music completely different from what they were about to perform, which is considered in Russian musical circles the highest honor a musical director can receive.
Harbin consists of four towns, each with its individual name. There is the old one where the Russians first settled when they built the Chinese Eastern Railway, now almost deserted but for tillers of the surrounding fields, a makeshift home for orphan refugees, and the like. In Pristan, popularly called “Jew-town,” most of the business is carried on, as well as the far-famed singing-halls. Up the hill from this and separated from it by an open space in which Chinese executions take place is the more commodious railroad town, with important offices, the better-class residences, the garish Russian Orthodox churches which rise like unnaturally gorgeous flowers above the rather drab general level. Lastly, there is Fu-chia-tien, the Chinese city, a mile or more away from the others, as completely Chinese as if there had never been a Russian within a thousand versts of the place. There are many rickshaws in Fu-chia-tien, but not one in all the other three towns, and rarely indeed does a foreigner ride in one, though they are more comfortable on the horrible streets than the droshke, and certainly more so than the excruciating “American women.” The severed heads of bandits hung in cages on several street corners in Chinese Harbin, and many other such touching little details showed that the town clung strictly to its own ways in spite of the many foreign examples so close at hand.
Harbin is made up of four towns, each with its own name. There’s the old town where the Russians first settled when they built the Chinese Eastern Railway; it’s now almost deserted except for farmers working the surrounding fields, a makeshift home for orphaned refugees, and similar folks. In Pristan, commonly known as “Jew-town,” most of the businesses operate, along with the famous singing halls. Up the hill from this and separated by an open space where Chinese executions take place is the larger railroad town, which has important offices, nicer residences, and the flashy Russian Orthodox churches that rise like strikingly beautiful flowers above the otherwise dull landscape. Finally, there’s Fu-chia-tien, the Chinese city, located a mile or so away from the others, completely Chinese as if there had never been a Russian within a thousand versts of the area. Fu-chia-tien has many rickshaws, but there isn’t a single one in the other three towns, and it’s quite rare for a foreigner to ride in one, although they are more comfortable on the terrible streets than the droshke, and definitely more so than the torturous “American women.” Severed heads of bandits are hung in cages at several street corners in Chinese Harbin, and many other such grim little details demonstrate that the town strictly adheres to its own customs despite the many foreign influences nearby.
Until the debacle of the czarist régime in Russia, the three Russian towns of Harbin were entirely under their own rule. Even now, since they have formally taken over the jurisdiction of them, the Chinese still let the Russians largely alone in their municipal affairs, but they are more and more prone to “butt in” and gratuitously assert their authority, just as they have in the Chinese Eastern Railway. This now has a Chinese as well as a Russian president and the whole category of Chinese officials down to the last clerk, in addition to Russian duplicates of the same in the greatly over-staffed offices. Some say the Russian railway officials are deliberately selling out to the Chinese; others claim that they are running this important link in world communication into wreckage and bankruptcy while they and the Bolsheviks quarrel, on paper and at a distance, as to whether it belongs to the Russian Government or merely to the Russo-Asiatic Bank. Meanwhile it staggers along under its top-heavy double staff, paying salaries to 95Chinese who do nothing and to many Russians who do not do much. The latter, old officials cut off for years now from higher authority, avow that they are merely administering the line for the benefit of the czarist régime that appointed them, until such time as this shall recover its rightful place in the world, but in practice they act as if the C. E. R. were the private property of the little clique of reactionary Russians who hold the power and wealth of Harbin. How public-spirited these are is suggested by such actions as their refusing to transport, except at full rates, food and clothing furnished by the Red Cross for the relief of their compatriots in the various towns of northern Manchuria.
Until the collapse of the czarist regime in Russia, the three Russian towns of Harbin were completely self-governing. Even now, since they have officially taken over jurisdiction, the Chinese mostly leave the Russians alone in their local affairs, but they are increasingly inclined to interfere and assert their authority, much like they have with the Chinese Eastern Railway. This railway now has both a Chinese and a Russian president, along with a full complement of Chinese officials down to the last clerk, in addition to Russian counterparts, in the oversaturated offices. Some say the Russian railway officials are intentionally selling out to the Chinese; others claim they are driving this crucial link in global communication to ruin and bankruptcy while they and the Bolsheviks argue, from a distance, over whether it belongs to the Russian Government or just to the Russo-Asiatic Bank. Meanwhile, it limps along under its bloated dual staff, paying salaries to Chinese who do nothing and many Russians who barely do anything. The latter, old officials who have been cut off from higher authority for years, claim they are just managing the railway for the benefit of the czarist regime that appointed them, until it can reclaim its rightful place in the world. However, in practice, they act as if the C.E.R. were the private property of the small group of reactionary Russians who hold the power and wealth of Harbin. Their public-spiritedness is shown by actions like refusing to transport, except at full rates, food and clothing provided by the Red Cross for the relief of their compatriots in various towns of northern Manchuria.
At Versailles in 1919 and again at the Washington Conference two years later the Chinese delegates demanded the abrogation of extraterritorial jurisdiction in China, as a derogation of her sovereign status as a nation. The request was denied, but at the second gathering it was decided to appoint a commission to examine on the spot the assertion of the delegates that the administration of justice in the former Celestial Empire has so far improved that foreign jurisdiction may safely be abolished. Since then certain occurrences in China which have not been testimonials in her favor have caused the commission indefinitely to postpone its coming; but in the meanwhile there is considerable evidence at hand in the treatment of the Russians by the Chinese since the former were deprived of their extraterritorial status.
At Versailles in 1919 and again at the Washington Conference two years later, Chinese delegates requested the removal of extraterritorial jurisdiction in China, arguing that it undermined their sovereignty as a nation. The request was denied, but at the second meeting, it was decided to form a commission to investigate the delegates' claim that the administration of justice in China had improved enough for foreign jurisdiction to be eliminated. Since then, some incidents in China, which haven't been in its favor, have led the commission to postpone its visit indefinitely. In the meantime, there is significant evidence in the way the Chinese have treated the Russians since the latter lost their extraterritorial status.
It is probably not necessary to explain that extraterritoriality, as it is familiarly called, consists, briefly, in the right—or is it privilege?—of foreigners in China to be tried only by their own consuls or judges, under the laws of their own countries. Eighty years ago, closely following the Treaty of Nanking, which ended one of her “opium wars” with China, England forced this concession upon the Chinese Government, the Americans and the French quickly followed suit, and soon there were very few foreign residents indeed who were not protected by treaty from Chinese courts and prisons. This state of affairs remained unbroken until about the time of the Washington Conference, when China took advantage of conditions in Russia to repudiate her treaty with the czarist Government, and the many thousands of Russians in China suddenly found themselves on a par, legally, with the Chinese themselves. A new treaty between China and Germany, in which the latter either inadvertently or purposely left out any mention of extraterritoriality, and lack of treaties with some of 96the other countries on which China declared war at the behest of the Allies has left Germans, Austrians, Bulgarians, and some other nationalities in the same boat with the Russians.
It’s probably unnecessary to explain that extraterritoriality, as it's commonly known, basically refers to the right—or is it a privilege?—of foreigners in China to be tried only by their own consuls or judges, according to their own countries' laws. Eighty years ago, shortly after the Treaty of Nanking, which ended one of England's "opium wars" with China, England forced this concession on the Chinese Government. The Americans and the French quickly followed, and soon there were very few foreign residents who weren’t protected by treaty from Chinese courts and prisons. This situation remained unchanged until around the time of the Washington Conference, when China took advantage of the situation in Russia to reject her treaty with the czarist Government, and many thousands of Russians in China suddenly found themselves in the same legal position as the Chinese. A new treaty between China and Germany, in which Germany either accidentally or intentionally omitted any mention of extraterritoriality, along with the lack of treaties with some other countries that China declared war against at the request of the Allies, has put Germans, Austrians, Bulgarians, and some other nationalities in the same position as the Russians.
Since then life has not been quite the same in Harbin and the other Russian towns of northern Manchuria. On one hand the change has caused some just retribution. In the olden days Russians kicked the Chinese about almost at will; now when a Chinese carriage driver in Harbin gets a good excuse and opportunity, Russian heads are likely to suffer. Russian railway-men used to throw Chinese passengers back into third class or out on the platform, if they felt in the mood, even though they held first-class tickets; now the minions of Chang Tso-lin suddenly levy a new tax and Chinese soldiers go out and “beat up” Russian farmers to such an extent in some cases that ships lie waiting for cargo in Dairen while crops rot in the fields. Unfortunately things do not often stop with mere retribution. The Chinese along the C. E. R. seem sometimes to go out of their way to be insolent toward any Westerner, to jostle and to annoy him without cause; taxes have been levied on the property of foreigners other than Russian, and men arrested in spite of treaties of extraterritoriality still in existence. An Italian woman who complained that her purse had been stolen by a Chinese pickpocket was taken to jail along with the thief, as openly as was a Russian who tried to get back his fur coat, and the latter at least was imprisoned for weeks. You cannot expect the garden variety of Chinese soldier or policeman to recognize a difference in foreigners, and in a town where 98 per cent of these are Russians we others have to watch our steps. Perhaps this inability of their Chinese comrades to distinguish between foreigners without and those still with extraterritorial status is the reason that there are Russian police in Harbin, splashing through its mud in their heavy boots as if they still had the czar’s authority behind them—until the passing of some supercilious Chinese official causes them to snap to attention and salute.
Since then, life hasn’t been quite the same in Harbin and the other Russian towns in northern Manchuria. On one hand, the change has caused some justified payback. In the past, Russians would push around the Chinese almost at will; now, when a Chinese carriage driver in Harbin has a good excuse and opportunity, Russian heads are likely to pay the price. Russian railway workers used to throw Chinese passengers back to third class or even out onto the platform if they were in the mood, even if those passengers had first-class tickets; now, Chang Tso-lin's officials suddenly impose a new tax, and Chinese soldiers go out and “beat up” Russian farmers to such an extent that, in some cases, ships wait for cargo in Dairen while crops rot in the fields. Unfortunately, things often go beyond mere payback. The Chinese along the C. E. R. sometimes seem to go out of their way to be rude to any Westerner, jostling and annoying them without reason; taxes have been imposed on the property of foreigners who aren’t Russian, and men have been arrested despite the existing treaties of extraterritoriality. An Italian woman who complained that her purse was stolen by a Chinese pickpocket was taken to jail along with the thief, just like a Russian who tried to reclaim his fur coat, and the Russian was at least imprisoned for weeks. You can’t expect the average Chinese soldier or policeman to recognize a difference between foreigners, and in a town where 98 percent of them are Russians, we others have to be careful. Perhaps this inability of their Chinese counterparts to tell apart foreigners without and those still holding extraterritorial status is why there are Russian police in Harbin, trudging through its mud in heavy boots as if they still have the czar’s authority behind them—until some arrogant Chinese official passes by and they snap to attention and salute.

The grain of the kaoliang, one of the most important crops of North China. It grows from ten to fifteen feet high and makes the finest of hiding-places for bandits
The grain of the kaoliang, one of the most important crops in North China. It grows to be ten to fifteen feet tall and provides the perfect hiding spots for bandits.

A daily sight in Vladivostok,—a group of youths suspected of opinions contrary to those of the Government, rounded up and trotted off to prison
A common scene in Vladivostok—a group of young people suspected of having beliefs that go against those of the Government, rounded up and taken off to prison.

A refugee Russian priest, of whom there were many in Harbin
A refugee Russian priest, and there were many of them in Harbin

Types of this kind swarm along the Chinese Eastern Railway of Manchuria, many of them volunteers in the Chinese army or railway police
Types like this are common along the Chinese Eastern Railway in Manchuria, with many being volunteers in the Chinese army or railway police.
97Many examples of Chinese oppression of the Russians were common knowledge in Harbin, some of them more serious than others. A young Russian member of the Y. M. C. A. who was putting the shot in a park of the residence town was arrested by the Chinese on the charge of having a bomb in his possession. He spent some hours in jail, finally to be released on bail, the police confiscating what the judge agreed with them was an explosive agent of destruction. The association secretary had to threaten to refer the matter to the American consul before the “bomb” was returned, and when I left Harbin the charge against the “bomb-thrower” had not been dismissed. Then there was the sad case of another member aspiring to athletic prowess, who, in throwing the javelin, hit a dog, though that was complicated by the fact that the injured animal was of Japanese nationality, which made the affair much more serious. Chang and his retainers may have a justifiable scorn for those of us whose governments so habitually turn the other cheek of late in cases of Chinese aggression, but there are several thousand good reasons, all splendidly armed and equipped and right on the spot, why he should respect Japan’s wishes, even if his former lieutenancy and certain allegations of secret allegiances still frequently heard have no weight with him.
97There were many instances of Chinese oppression against the Russians that everyone in Harbin knew about, some more serious than others. A young Russian member of the Y. M. C. A. who was shot putting in a park was arrested by the Chinese for allegedly having a bomb in his possession. He spent several hours in jail, only to be released on bail, with the police taking what the judge agreed was an explosive device. The association's secretary had to threaten to involve the American consul before the “bomb” was returned, and by the time I left Harbin, the charges against the “bomb-thrower” had not been dropped. Then there was the unfortunate case of another member who was trying to excel in athletics; he accidentally hit a dog while throwing the javelin. This was made worse by the fact that the injured dog was Japanese, which escalated the situation significantly. Chang and his advisors might have a legitimate disdain for those of us whose governments often ignore cases of Chinese aggression, but there are several thousand well-armed reasons, right there on the ground, why he should heed Japan’s wishes, even if his past positions and rumors of secret alliances still circulating don’t concern him.
These instances, I admit, are not such as nations should go to war over, but they are just as good examples as are many far more serious ones, which any foreign resident of Harbin can cite, of how misunderstandings alone, if there were the very best will and desire to be just, would make it impossible for foreigners to get justice in China once their extraterritorial privileges were taken away from them. Nor was it a particularly agreeable sight to see a line of Russian men and women waiting for hours, if not for days, the good pleasure of haughty Chinese officials and their gutter-snipe-like underlings in order to get passports to go to another town, or out of the country. The court-room I visited in Harbin was an ordinary brick and plaster building, but chasers of evil spirits climbed its eaves, and dragons sat on the roof, their antennæ waving in the wind. Many Russians were gathered, including a huge lawyer in robes who suggested Gulliver in fear of his life when he bowed and smirked before the diminutive almond-eyed officials. In theory court opened at ten, but there had been fireworks in the Chinese town the night before and his honor was still being patiently awaited at noon. Out in front of the court was a string of bill-boards on which cases were posted in tissue-paper sheets covered with Chinese characters, reminding one that an interpreter to explain what the police had against one would be indispensable under lost extraterritoriality.
These situations, I admit, aren’t something nations should go to war over, but they are just as valid examples as many much more serious ones that any foreign resident of Harbin can mention, showing how misunderstandings alone, despite having the best intentions to be fair, would make it impossible for foreigners to receive justice in China once their extraterritorial rights were taken away. It was also not a pleasant sight to see a line of Russian men and women waiting for hours, if not days, for the whims of arrogant Chinese officials and their petty underlings just to get passports to travel to another town or leave the country. The courtroom I visited in Harbin was a regular brick and plaster building, but spirits chased away evil climbed its eaves, and dragons perched on the roof, their antennae fluttering in the wind. Many Russians were gathered, including a large lawyer in robes who resembled Gulliver in fear for his life as he bowed and smirked before the small, almond-eyed officials. In theory, court was supposed to start at ten, but there had been fireworks in the Chinese town the night before, and the judge was still being awaited patiently at noon. Outside the court was a series of billboards displaying cases on tissue-paper sheets covered with Chinese characters, reminding everyone that having an interpreter to explain what the police had against them would be essential without extraterritoriality.
The judge did come at last, a boyish-looking fellow who sat in splendid, not to say haughty, isolation in his high chair, singsonging something now and then in a half-audible falsetto, and still more often hawking and spitting on the floor, though there were signs all over the court-room forbidding it. On the desk before him was one tissue-paper bordereau, as the French, who use similar loosely bound collections of papers, would call it; but there were no signs of law-books, and the judge seemed to get his precedents, and his opinions, too, one suspected, 98from the not too immaculate clerks and hangers-on who frequently came up to whisper in his ear. Meanwhile a gray-bearded Russian was standing respectfully before him at the rail, droning on and on in his own tongue some sort of complaint, testimony, or defense. The case was not a very serious one, it seemed, there being a mere matter of two or three hundred dollars “Mex” involved; but without going any farther into details, let me put it briefly that, though there was in evidence all the machinery of justice which a visiting commission would wish to see, I should very much have regretted the necessity of expecting justice from this soggy-eyed Celestial youth, bending his ear to this and that whisper from his unkempt, shifty-looking attendants.
The judge finally arrived, looking quite youthful as he sat in his elevated chair, maintaining a proud distance. He occasionally sang something in a barely audible falsetto and more frequently hawked and spat on the floor, despite numerous signs around the courtroom prohibiting it. On the desk in front of him was a tissue-paper bordereau, which is what the French call similar loosely bound collections of papers, but there were no law books in sight. It seemed like he got his precedents and opinions, one might guess, from the not-so-clean clerks and hangers-on who frequently approached to whisper in his ear. Meanwhile, a gray-bearded Russian stood respectfully at the rail, droning on in his own language about some complaint, testimony, or defense. The case didn’t seem very serious, involving only two or three hundred dollars in “Mex.” Without diving deeper into the details, let's just say that, although all the elements of justice were present that a visiting commission would expect, I would have sincerely regretted relying on this overly emotional Celestial youth, who leaned in to listen to whispers from his scruffy, shifty-looking aides.
I visited also the big prison down in Pristan, built by the Russians but now taken over by the Chinese. There were two hundred and seventy-seven Russian prisoners and one German in it, a dozen of them women, among whom was a Jewish member of that sex who had lived for years in “Noo Yoik,” and spoke her fluent English accordingly. The same rules governed the prison as under the Russians, but orders from higher up now came from Chinese, and inmates put their hope, in cases where they had any left, in Chinese courts and officials. Some of the guards were still Russian, but the majority were not, and the sight of white men, clanking with enormous chains, chased about the yard while they cleaned out toilets and did similar menial tasks, by Chinese jailers who openly enjoyed their discomfiture, would not have added to the joy of white nations. Nearly all the prisoners, however, were in groups of six to a dozen in large cells that could be dimly seen through a small slit in each door. Living conditions were those of the old type of Russian prisons, with immense locks, and very thick walls that made the July heat furnace-like; the food was mainly kaoliang and other cheap, coarse grains; there were no shops, or regular work of any kind, and only half an hour’s exercise a day in the open air was allowed, even “in principle.” There were, of course, desperate criminals among the rather pasty-faced but generally big brawny men who peered out the door-slits with expressions uncannily like caged lions and tigers, and from these China must protect herself and those who dwell within her borders. But my American missionary companion, who had lived for some time in Harbin and spoke Russian, knew personally of several men for whose innocence the whole Caucasian community could vouch, who were there merely out of Chinese spite and whose trials had been, or would be, if they ever took place, worse than travesties on justice. The worst hardship of all, according 99to the misguided lady from “Noo Yoik,” was that no one had the least inkling, nor any possible way of finding out, when the Chinese might deign to bring a prisoner to court and air the charges against him.
I also visited the large prison down in Pristan, built by the Russians but now taken over by the Chinese. There were two hundred and seventy-seven Russian prisoners and one German, including about a dozen women, among them a Jewish woman who had lived for years in “Noo Yoik” and spoke fluent English. The same rules were in place as under the Russians, but now orders came from the Chinese, and inmates put their hopes, if they had any left, in Chinese courts and officials. Some of the guards were still Russian, but most were not, and the sight of white men, shackled with huge chains, being chased around the yard while they cleaned toilets and did other menial work by Chinese jailers who openly enjoyed their humiliation, wouldn’t have made white nations feel proud. However, nearly all the prisoners were in groups of six to a dozen in large cells barely visible through a small slit in each door. Living conditions were like the old Russian prisons, with huge locks and very thick walls that made the July heat unbearable; the food mainly consisted of kaoliang and other cheap, coarse grains; there were no shops or regular work of any kind, and only half an hour of outdoor exercise was allowed each day, even “in principle.” There were, of course, desperate criminals among the rather pasty-faced but generally big, brawny men who peered out of the door slits with expressions eerily like caged lions and tigers, and from these, China must protect herself and those living within her borders. But my American missionary companion, who had lived in Harbin for a while and spoke Russian, personally knew several men whose innocence the entire Caucasian community could vouch for, those who were there purely out of Chinese spite and whose trials had been, or would be, if they ever happened, far worse than mockeries of justice. The worst hardship of all, according to the misguided woman from “Noo Yoik,” was that no one had the slightest idea, nor any way to find out, when the Chinese might decide to bring a prisoner to court and reveal the charges against him.
Terms up to forty years were inflicted, but “long-timers” had the privilege, at least in theory, of being transferred to the “model prison” in Peking. Thus far no Russians had been executed, “because of the impression this might make among foreign nations,” according to an official Chinese statement. Of course once those nations give up their extraterritorial rights it will not so much matter what impression is made. Not long after our visit, however, when a thin and effeminate-looking little Russian charged with half a dozen murders in the pursuance of his calling as highway robber, and with whom I talked “high-brow stuff” in his tiny private cell, walked calmly out of the court-room and killed two or three of the policemen who pursued him, the announcement was made that in his case at least, if he were ever retaken, this policy would be rescinded. There is little doubt that this particular “bad man” should be done away with; but when Chinese soldiers get to shooting white men as one of their regular duties, what little prestige our race retains in China will soon evaporate. For what those many untraveled Westerners who feel that China should have complete sovereignty within her borders do not realize is the primitive mentality of the Chinese masses, which includes the soldiers, in such matters as the natural fights of others and the assumption of a low estate in those who are not outwardly honored and protected.
Terms of up to forty years were imposed, but “long-timers” had the privilege, at least in theory, of being moved to the “model prison” in Beijing. So far, no Russians had been executed, “because of the impression this might create among foreign nations,” according to an official Chinese statement. Of course, once those nations give up their extraterritorial rights, it won't really matter what impression is made. Not long after our visit, however, when a thin and delicate-looking Russian charged with several murders while working as a highway robber, with whom I discussed “high-brow stuff” in his tiny private cell, calmly walked out of the courtroom and killed two or three of the policemen who were chasing him, the announcement was made that in his case at least, if he were ever recaptured, this policy would be changed. There is little doubt that this particular “bad man” should be dealt with; but when Chinese soldiers start shooting white men as part of their regular duties, any prestige our race has in China will quickly disappear. What many untraveled Westerners who believe that China should have complete sovereignty within her borders do not realize is the primitive mentality of the Chinese masses, including the soldiers, regarding the natural rights of others and the perception of those who aren’t openly honored and protected.
Though it is trespassing on the future to mention it here, I visited, months later, that “model prison” of Peking. It is just that, a well built, splendidly arranged penitentiary on the most modern, wheel-shaped lines, out in the southwest corner of the Chinese city. The new section recently built for foreigners—which had room for four times as many inmates as had so far been collected—was quite all it should be, with hot and cold baths, reasonable provisions for heating in winter, a kitchen of its own where foreign food was prepared. The workshops of the entire institution were large, airy, and light; there was a Russian as well as a Chinese chapel in which Taoist, Confucianist, Mohammedan, Christian, even Y. M. C. A. speakers appeared on Sundays; the régime of the place was considerate and enlightened; as a prison, in fact, it should make such a place as Sing Sing faint with shame. I saw other “model prisons” in China, notably that in the capital of Shansi, which has never had a representative from the outside world except a Turk 100who was caught peddling opium pills. But these few praiseworthy institutions in the more enlightened centers, and toward which the eyes of an investigating commission would, of course, be carefully directed, are as nothing compared to the unspeakable holes all over China into which prisoners are thrown, and where foreigners also would have the privilege of moldering away while provincial authorities slept, if extraterritoriality were abolished.
Though it’s jumping ahead to mention it now, I visited that “model prison” in Beijing months later. It truly is a well-constructed, beautifully organized facility, built in a modern, wheel-shaped design, located in the southwest corner of the city. The new section, recently completed for foreigners—capable of housing four times as many inmates as those who had been collected so far—was exactly what it needed to be. It featured hot and cold baths, adequate heating for winter, and its own kitchen where foreign food was prepared. The workshops throughout the facility were spacious, airy, and bright; there was both a Russian and a Chinese chapel, where Taoist, Confucian, Muslim, Christian, and even Y. M. C. A. speakers held services on Sundays. The management of the facility was compassionate and progressive; as a prison, it could make a place like Sing Sing look bad. I saw other “model prisons” in China, especially the one in the capital of Shansi, which has never had any representative from the outside world except a Turk who got caught selling opium pills. But these few commendable institutions in the more progressive areas, which an investigative commission would undoubtedly scrutinize carefully, are nothing compared to the horrific jails scattered throughout China where prisoners are dumped, and where foreigners would also find themselves wasting away while local authorities ignored the situation, if extraterritoriality were abolished.
There is no Chinese code of laws; the fate of most prisoners depends on the often poor judgment, the mood of the moment, the devious political machinations, of the judge himself, not to mention wide-spread bribery and Oriental intricacies of which even old residents have only an inkling. Two separate codes, for foreigners and Chinese, would certainly have to be introduced before extraterritoriality could be surrendered. You cannot justly shoot or lop off the head of a Westerner for stealing a suit of clothes or a sack of grain, however necessary such drastic measures may be among a people desperate with habitual semi-starvation and so inured to hardships that ordinary punishments mean nothing, any more than you can justly arrest a foreign merchant because his overcoat has been stolen, and keep him in jail for weeks as a witness. In Chinese jurisprudence torture is a recognized procedure, and false confessions forced thereby are considered legal proof of guilt. Every prisoner is presumed to be guilty, and must prove his innocence, rather than be convicted by the prosecution, no strange point of view to Latin races, but a topsyturvy one to Anglo-Saxons. Not the least disagreeable of Chinese practices is the “doctrine of responsibility,” which means that in any group, be it village, family, crew, or, if the present status were changed, assemblage of foreigners, some one must be punished for the misdeeds of any individual member of it, so that a perfectly innocent head may be lopped off to save the trouble of hunting out the real criminal. Even though the Chinese were to do their best to treat foreign prisoners justly, the very differences in point of view, in customs, in diet even, would make it impossible. The East and the West are so unlike that an American could die of Chinese food and living conditions while his jailers were priding themselves, in their ignorance of other lands, on giving him the best the world affords. Of course Japan is an example of the abolishing of extraterritoriality; but even there the foreigner by no means gets Western justice, and for all the virtues and likable qualities of the Celestial and the often disagreeable traits of the Nipponese, government in Japan is ideal compared to the corrupt, chaotic travesty on it which rules China.
There is no official Chinese legal system; the fate of most prisoners relies on the often questionable judgment, the judge’s mood, their political games, and widespread bribery and complexities that even long-time residents can barely grasp. Two separate legal codes for foreigners and Chinese would definitely need to be established before relinquishing extraterritorial rights. You can't justly execute or behead a Westerner for stealing a coat or a bag of grain, no matter how necessary such extreme actions might be among a population that frequently faces starvation and has become so accustomed to hardship that ordinary punishments carry little weight. Similarly, you can't justly arrest a foreign merchant because his overcoat was stolen and keep him in jail for weeks as a witness. In Chinese law, torture is a standard procedure, and coerced false confessions are seen as valid evidence of guilt. Every prisoner is assumed to be guilty and must prove their innocence, which may not seem strange to Latin cultures but is a completely backwards view to Anglo-Saxons. One particularly unpleasant aspect of Chinese law is the "doctrine of responsibility," meaning that in any group—be it a village, family, crew, or potentially, a gathering of foreigners—someone must be punished for the wrongdoing of any individual member, leading to the execution of an innocent person just to avoid the hassle of finding the actual culprit. Even if the Chinese tried their best to treat foreign prisoners fairly, the fundamental differences in perspective, customs, and even diet would make it impossible. The East and West are so different that an American could suffer from the food and living conditions in China while his jailers, ignorant of other cultures, believe they are providing him with the best the world has to offer. While Japan is an example of abolishing extraterritoriality, even there, foreigners don't receive true Western justice. For all the virtues and likable qualities of the Chinese and the often unpleasant traits of the Japanese, the government in Japan is ideal compared to the corrupt, chaotic parody of governance that prevails in China.

One of the Russian churches in Harbin, a creamy gray, with green domes and golden crosses, with much gaudy trimming
One of the Russian churches in Harbin, a light gray color, featuring green domes and golden crosses, with a lot of flashy decorations.

A policeman of Vladivostok, where shaving is looked down upon
A police officer from Vladivostok, where shaving is frowned upon

Two former officers in the czar’s army, now bootblacks in the “thieves’” market of Harbin—when they catch any one who can afford to be blacked
Two ex-officers from the czar’s army, now working as bootblacks in the “thieves’” market of Harbin—when they spot someone who can afford to get their shoes polished

Scores of booths in Harbin, Manchuli, and Vladivostok, selling second-hand hardware of every description, suggest why the factories and trains of Bolshevik Russia have difficulty in running
Scores of booths in Harbin, Manchuli, and Vladivostok selling used hardware of every kind illustrate why the factories and trains of Bolshevik Russia struggle to operate.
101I traveled from end to end of the Chinese Eastern Railway, including the extension of it from Pogranichnaya to Vladivostok, through what was once, like Korea, Chinese territory. Endless steppes, flat as a floor, covered as far as the eye could see with coarse grass, here and there being hayed, was the general aspect north of the Sungari. Great herds of cattle and sheep, carts drawn by six or eight horses over roads which in the rainy season could not have been passable at all, millions of acres of potential wheat-fields, a great granary of everything, including sturdy youths for Chang Tso-lin’s armies, formed the outstanding features of Hai-lung-chiang, northernmost and largest of China’s provinces. South-bound freight-trains were not only crowded with Chinese soldiers, gambling amid the chaotic messiness that surrounded them in their roofed cars, but the uncovered flat-cars loaded with their paraphernalia, with car-wheels and rusted machinery, were crowded with Russian women and children sleeping on makeshift nests in sunshine or heavy rain. There were cattle-cars with barefooted Russian men tending them, little European box-cars fitted up as homes, sometimes with a still aristocratic-looking young woman suckling a babe in the center of it, impertinent Chinese soldiers looking on. There is no way of computing how many pretty Russian girls, with nothing to live on but the sale of their charms, there were along the C. E. R. from Manchuli to Vladivostok, like the little end of the funnel down through which the miseries of Russia had been oozing for years.
101I traveled the full length of the Chinese Eastern Railway, including its extension from Pogranichnaya to Vladivostok, through what was once, like Korea, Chinese territory. Endless steppes, flat as a floor, stretched as far as the eye could see, covered with coarse grass, with some areas being hayed, characterized the landscape north of the Sungari. Huge herds of cattle and sheep, carts pulled by six or eight horses over roads that would have been impassable in the rainy season, and millions of acres of potential wheat fields—a vast granary of everything, including strong young men for Chang Tso-lin’s armies—made up the prominent features of Hai-lung-chiang, the northernmost and largest of China’s provinces. Southbound freight trains were not just packed with Chinese soldiers, gambling amid the chaotic mess around them in their covered cars, but the uncovered flat cars loaded with their gear, car wheels, and rusty machinery, were crowded with Russian women and children sleeping on makeshift nests in the sun or heavy rain. There were cattle cars with barefoot Russian men tending to them, small European box cars turned into homes, sometimes featuring a still elegant young woman breastfeeding a baby in the middle, while impudent Chinese soldiers looked on. It’s impossible to estimate how many pretty Russian girls, relying solely on the sale of their charms, were along the C. E. R. from Manchuli to Vladivostok, like the narrow end of a funnel through which the suffering of Russia had been trickling for years.
For all the rumors of degeneration of that line, however, the through express was an excellent train, though even more leisurely than that on the branch from Harbin southward, halting interminably at every station, apparently to let the crew talk to the girls who decorated every platform. It had all the comforts of compartment-divided sleeping-cars, with Russian attendants; the dining-car, with its ikon and its abacus, had a boarding-house table the entire length of it, and comely young Russian waitresses, who rolled their socks.
For all the rumors about the decline of that train line, the express train was actually quite nice, even if it moved slower than the branch line heading south from Harbin, stopping endlessly at every station, seemingly to let the crew chat with the girls who were on every platform. It had all the comforts of compartmented sleeping cars, with Russian attendants; the dining car, featuring an icon and an abacus, had a long boarding-house style table, and attractive young Russian waitresses who rolled up their socks.
When I awoke in the morning beyond Tsitsihar, the landscape was silvery with white birches. Large and often pretty towns appeared every now and then among the low green hills or on the broad prairies of this most arctic of the “Eastern Three Provinces,” decidedly Russian towns, with wide unpaved streets, discordantly colored half-Oriental churches of the Greek Orthodox faith rising high above all else, against 102backgrounds that gave above all a sense of vast, wide-open spaces. The Russians have about twelve square miles at each station, and a strip of territory on either side of the railway, where they can rent land for about eighty years, as against only eighteen for foreigners in the rest of China, where none but Chinese can own land, with certain exceptions in favor of missionaries. There were far more Russians than Chinese at the stations of these frontier towns, reminiscent of those of the Dakotas, where every one came down to see the daily train go through. Most of the peasant women were barefoot; in town the girls all rolled their stockings, or went without them entirely. But huge bearskin coats and big fur caps hung out on lines, airing. Hot water was furnished at all the important stations, and bushels of eggs, all manner of food, especially just at this season most magnificent raspberries, were for sale by robust Russian women, often in a substantial booth built for the purpose. But long lines of Chinese soldiers with drawn bayonets still slouched along every platform, besides no end of Russians in uniforms of every swaggering description, as if the dregs of a dozen routed armies had been scattered along the line. Many of these strutting fellows wore swords, and some carried firearms, members evidently of some sort of local or railway police, as the unarmed majority were probably men who had no other garments left. The constant swashbuckling, the incessant parading of deadly weapons, got on the nerves; quite aside from the decided economic loss of so many men withdrawn from production, there was an ominous something about these thousands of young fellows, who had not been old enough to get into the war, now strutting about in its aftermath as if looking for a chance to make up for lost opportunities. The Russians saluted all Chinese officials, even those in civilian dress, raising their hats to them obsequiously if they themselves were not in uniform. At one station a drunken Russian went around forcing Chinese ragamuffins to shake hands with him.
When I woke up in the morning outside of Tsitsihar, the landscape was shimmering with white birches. Large and often charming towns popped up now and then among the low green hills or across the wide prairies of this northernmost of the “Eastern Three Provinces,” clearly Russian towns, featuring broad unpaved streets and oddly colored half-Oriental Greek Orthodox churches towering above all else, set against backgrounds that emphasized the sense of vast, open spaces. The Russians occupy about twelve square miles at each station and have a strip of land on either side of the railway, where they can lease property for about eighty years, compared to just eighteen years for foreigners elsewhere in China, where only Chinese can own land, with a few exceptions for missionaries. There were far more Russians than Chinese at the stations of these frontier towns, reminiscent of those in the Dakotas, where everyone gathered to watch the daily train pass through. Most peasant women walked barefoot; in town, the girls rolled down their stockings or didn’t wear them at all. But huge bearskin coats and large fur caps were hanging out to air on lines. Hot water was available at all the main stations, and bushels of eggs, various types of food, especially the most amazing raspberries at this time of year, were sold by robust Russian women, often from sturdy booths set up for the purpose. However, long lines of Chinese soldiers with drawn bayonets still lounged on every platform, along with countless Russians in uniforms of various styles, as if the remnants of a dozen defeated armies had scattered along the line. Many of these swaggering men wore swords, and some carried firearms, clearly members of some form of local or railway police, while the unarmed majority were likely men who had run out of other clothes. The constant show-off of weapons and the nonstop display of deadly gear were nerve-wracking; aside from the significant economic impact of so many men pulled away from productivity, there was something ominous about these thousands of young guys, who were too young to have gone to war, now strutting around in its aftermath as if searching for a chance to make up for lost time. The Russians saluted all Chinese officials, even those in civilian clothes, tipping their hats graciously if they themselves weren’t in uniform. At one station, a drunken Russian was going around making Chinese ragamuffins shake hands with him.
All northern Manchuria was much troubled by bandits, hung-hu-tze, or “red beards,” they were called, who had devastated far and wide, even attacking the trains and station towns. There were at least a few renegade Russians among some of the bands. The public shooting of hung-hu-tze, in an open space between Pristan and the railway town, was one of the frequent sights of Harbin. But the real curse of Manchuria, as we were to find it of almost all China, were the soldiers. The bandits often paid for what they took, but the soldiers looted openly and carried off their plunder by the train-load within plain sight of 103every one. When they wished to move, away from the railroad, they forced farmers to let their crops go to waste and furnish them transportation for ten-day journeys, feeding the drivers and their animals along the way, but leaving them to find their way home as best they could. If there were no other carts to be had at the end of the ten days, the old ones must go on, twenty, thirty days, and even more. One man I heard of had been away a year, and still could not get back. A few hundred hand-picked, well paid soldiers, perhaps with a few Russians among them to give them starch, could, according to competent opinion, put a stop to banditry in Manchuria. But such coolies in uniform as swarm up and down the C. E. R. accomplish nothing to that end, even when they are not in actual collusion with the bandits. The hung-hu-tze rout whole barracks of them, and prey on the Chinese and the Russian population alike. Yet the Government clings to the fiction that they afford sufficient protection, and will not allow the Russians to go armed, unless they hold some kind of military position under the Chinese. Soldiers and bandits alike abuse all the inhabitants of northern Manchuria, except the Japanese, who have their own troops on the spot.
All of northern Manchuria was seriously affected by bandits, known as hung-hu-tze or “red beards,” who wreaked havoc everywhere, even attacking trains and towns. Some of the bands included a few renegade Russians. Public executions of hung-hu-tze in an open area between Pristan and the railway town were common sights in Harbin. However, the real problem in Manchuria, as we would discover about almost all of China, was the soldiers. The bandits sometimes paid for what they took, but the soldiers looted openly and transported their stolen goods by the trainload right in front of everyone. When they wanted to move away from the railroad, they forced farmers to let their crops rot and provide transportation for ten-day journeys, feeding the drivers and their animals along the way but leaving them to figure out how to get home on their own. If there were no other carts available at the end of ten days, the old ones had to continue on for twenty, thirty days, or even longer. One man I heard about was gone for a year and still couldn't get back. According to experts, a few hundred well-paid, hand-picked soldiers, possibly with some Russians to give them backbone, could end the banditry in Manchuria. But the soldiers in uniforms, who swarm along the C. E. R., accomplish nothing toward that goal, even when they aren't actually collaborating with the bandits. The hung-hu-tze easily defeat entire barracks and prey on both the Chinese and Russian populations. Yet the Government insists that they provide enough protection and won't allow Russians to carry weapons unless they hold some military position under the Chinese. Soldiers and bandits both mistreat all the inhabitants of northern Manchuria, except for the Japanese, who have their own troops on the ground.
Manchuli, on the edge of Siberia and almost on the fiftieth parallel, is a large, prairie-like town of much more Russian than Chinese aspect. Many of its houses are built of logs, yet are not unhomelike; sod hovels like caves half below and half above ground shelter some of the population, among which were many down-and-outs. Cossacks in their big caps, with curiously liquid eyes, roam the wide, if dusty, streets. Russians and Chinese sit joking together; both ride the small sturdy horses of the region; many of the Chinese wear the long, soft, black boots so general among their neighbors, but there seemed to be very few mixtures of the two races. Sturdy fellows indeed were these bearded Caucasian farmers from the north and west, but for that matter the far-northern Chinese, with enough to eat and room to live in, are big and strong, too, real pioneers, used to a different environment than are their overcrowded compatriots farther south, in touch with and more sympathetic toward European civilization. Now and again one of the Chinese spoke to me in Russian and, when I could not answer, announced to his companions that I was a yang gwei, though without any thought of insult in the term, Russians evidently being so numerous and familiar that they are no longer ranked as “foreign devils.” A market-place of scores of makeshift shanties was stocked with enough second-hand hardware to supply half Manchuria. Like those in Harbin and, 104I found later, Vladivostok, these marts were crammed with everything from railroad equipment to hinges, from factory machinery to crooked nails, all more or less rusted, broken, and out of order. It was as if every Russian who had fled before the “Reds” had torn loose and brought with him anything he could lay his hands on, and here was another explanation of why the factories and trains of Soviet Russia have difficulty in running.
Manchuli, on the edge of Siberia and nearly on the fiftieth parallel, is a large, prairie-like town that looks much more Russian than Chinese. Many of its houses are made of logs, yet they're not uninviting; sod huts resembling caves, half buried and half above ground, provide shelter for some of the local people, including many down-and-outs. Cossacks with their big caps and strikingly expressive eyes wander the wide, if dusty, streets. Russians and Chinese sit together joking; both ride the small, sturdy horses typical of the region. Many of the Chinese wear the long, soft, black boots common among their neighbors, but there seemed to be very few mixed groups of the two races. The bearded Caucasian farmers from the north and west are indeed sturdy fellows, but the northern Chinese, with enough food and space to live, are also big and strong—real pioneers, accustomed to a different environment than their overcrowded compatriots further south, and more in touch with and sympathetic towards European civilization. Occasionally, one of the Chinese would speak to me in Russian, and when I couldn’t reply, he would tell his friends that I was a yang gwei, though there was no intent to offend in that term, as Russians are evidently so numerous and familiar that they are no longer considered “foreign devils.” The marketplace, filled with dozens of makeshift shanties, had enough second-hand hardware to supply half of Manchuria. Like those in Harbin and, 104 as I later found, Vladivostok, these markets were packed with everything from railroad equipment to hinges, from factory machinery to bent nails, all mostly rusted, broken, and out of order. It was as if every Russian who had fled from the “Reds” had grabbed anything they could and brought it along, which explains why the factories and trains of Soviet Russia are struggling to operate.
From Manchuli one can easily look across into Bolshevik territory; but that was not China, and the traveler must turn back somewhere. An ancient engine and the most rattletrap collection of cars that ever masqueraded under the name of train was preparing to set out for Chita, wretched-looking women and gaunt, hungry babies among the passengers who occupied the dirty, miserably dilapidated compartments that were lighted only by the candles travelers brought with them. Even those of us for whom hardships have a certain zest could hardly regret that the way lay back the comfortable way we had come.
From Manchuli, you can easily see into Bolshevik territory; but that wasn't China, and the traveler has to turn back at some point. An old train and the shabbiest collection of cars that ever pretended to be a train were getting ready to leave for Chita, with miserable-looking women and skinny, hungry babies among the passengers cramped into the dirty, falling apart compartments lit only by the candles travelers brought with them. Even for those of us who enjoy a bit of adventure, it was hard not to wish we could go back the comfortable way we had come.
From Mukden on to Peking one has a feeling of being in the real China at last. Silver dollars take the place of convenient bank-notes; the chaotic rough and tumble of Chinese crowds unchecked by foreign discipline pervades stations and trains, both swarming with unsoldierly men and boys in faded, ill fitting, gray cotton uniforms, who pack even the dining-car to impassability; here and there a bullet-hole through wall or window of the stuffy coupés into which the half-breed American-European cars, with certain curious native characteristics, are divided reminds one of recent history in the once Celestial Empire. Endless fields, enormous seas, of kaoliang, enough to hide all the bandits in China, flank the way. For that matter the towns as well as brigands hide in it, for the slightly oval-roofed houses of stone and baked mud are barely as high as this tall grain, and as the roofs themselves are often covered with grass, places of considerable size easily escape the eye entirely. In other seasons it is quite different, for once they are denuded the fields are mere wind-swept stretches of bare earth protesting against the habitual scarcity of moisture in North China by sending frequent swirling clouds of dust to envelop any one and anything within reach. Walled towns far from the stations that serve them, iron-riveted cart-wheels hub-deep in the “roads” through which rural transportation laboriously flounders its way, Chinese in long cloaks, almost universally denim-blue in color, naked children and ragged, diseased adults begging abjectly wherever the train halts, were but a 105few of the details that somehow we had always associated with China. Even the towns hidden in the grain seemed to be overrun with soldiers, yet about all pretentious properties were big stone walls that suggested bandits in perpetuity. All these things we saw hazily, through a veil, as it were, for some pseudo-genius has had the unhappy thought of lining nearly all the railways of China with willow-trees, which flash constantly past with exasperating persistence, combining with the inadequate little windows of the stuffy compartments still further to reduce the visibility.
From Mukden to Peking, you finally get a sense of being in the real China. Silver dollars replace convenient banknotes; the chaotic energy of Chinese crowds, unhindered by foreign control, fills the stations and trains, crowded with unkempt men and boys in faded, ill-fitting gray cotton uniforms, even overflowing into the dining car. Here and there, a bullet hole through a wall or window of the cramped compartments, which are divided into strange American-European cars with some unique local traits, is a reminder of recent history in the once Celestial Empire. Endless fields and vast seas of kaoliang, enough to hide all the bandits in China, line the route. In fact, both towns and brigands can hide in it, as the slightly oval-roofed houses made of stone and baked mud are barely taller than the grain, and since the roofs are often covered in grass, sizable places can easily escape notice. In other seasons, it’s quite different; once stripped bare, the fields become wind-swept stretches of dry earth that constantly send up swirling clouds of dust, enveloping anyone and anything nearby in protest against the usual lack of moisture in North China. Walled towns, far from the stations that serve them, with iron-riveted cart wheels stuck deep in the "roads" through which rural transportation struggles, feature Chinese people in long cloaks, mostly denim-blue, naked children, and ragged, sick adults begging wherever the train stops—these are just a few of the details we always associated with China. Even the towns hidden in the grain appeared overrun with soldiers, but around all the notable properties stood large stone walls, suggesting that bandits were always nearby. We glimpsed all these things hazily, as if through a veil, because some misguided genius thought it would be a good idea to line nearly all the railways in China with willow trees, which flicker by with annoying persistence, further restricting visibility through the inadequate little windows of the cramped compartments.
At Shanhaikwan, where the Great Wall clambers down to the sea at last, weary with its three thousand miles over the mountains, soldiers were much less numerous than in towns not so important to the north and south of it. For the warring factions had declared a neutral zone on either side of the colossal ancient rampart, which had become again, after nearly three centuries of no real importance, the dividing-line between what threatens to be an independent Manchuria and China proper. On the beach at Shanhaikwan, or neighboring Pei-tai-ho, where half the foreign residents of North China spend the summer, with turbaned Hindus, white and black soldiers of France, an Italian gunboat, and other reminders of their protective home governments to discount rumors of being in danger, the heat was still too scorching to make an immediate entry into still hotter Peking inviting, though August was well on the wane. Even a week later, when much of the landscape was flooded with the brief rainy season, a cool breath of air night or day was as rare as a Chinese field without a grave. Within the Great Wall, beyond which seems to be considered outer darkness for such purposes, these bare, untended mounds, without even the grass which beautifies those of Korea, dotted the country like spatters of raindrops on a placid yellow sea. As we neared Taku, at the mouth of the river that gives Tientsin its importance and all but washes the walls of Peking, higher, newer conical heaps of earth suggested that many men of importance, or wealth, had recently been buried there. But these turned out to be salt-fields, where the surface soil of a great sea-flooded region is thrown up in mounds and rectangular heaps which gradually wash down from earthy brown to the white piles that are sacred to the government salt monopoly.
At Shanhaikwan, where the Great Wall finally meets the sea after its long journey of three thousand miles over the mountains, there were far fewer soldiers compared to the towns that are not as significant to the north and south. The warring factions had created a neutral zone on either side of this massive ancient structure, which has once again become, after nearly three centuries of being unimportant, the dividing line between what looks to be an independent Manchuria and China proper. On the beach at Shanhaikwan or nearby Pei-tai-ho, where a lot of foreign residents of North China spend their summer—with turbaned Hindus, white and black soldiers from France, an Italian gunboat, and other reminders of their home countries to ease fears of danger—the heat was still too intense to make an immediate trip to the even hotter Peking appealing, even though August was coming to an end. Even a week later, when much of the landscape was soaked from the short rainy season, a cool breeze day or night was as rare as a Chinese field without a grave. Inside the Great Wall, beyond which is seen as outer darkness for such matters, these bare, neglected mounds, lacking even the grass that decorates those in Korea, spotted the countryside like droplets of rain on a calm yellow sea. As we approached Taku, at the river's mouth that gives Tientsin its significance and nearly reaches the walls of Peking, taller, newer conical piles of earth indicated that many important or wealthy individuals had recently been buried there. But these turned out to be salt-fields, where the surface soil of a vast sea-flooded area is formed into mounds and rectangular heaps that gradually wash down from earthy brown to the white stacks that are controlled by the government salt monopoly.
The traveler who lets his friends rush him about the foreign concession of Tientsin by trolley or automobile will get an impression of a comfortable Western community in an Oriental land, but he will carry off very little idea of the real China, or even of the real Tientsin, which 106is a swarming Chinese city, none the less so for having had its wall reduced to a street of boulevard width as a punishment for the Boxer uprising. To those for whom commerce and modern efficiency are everything of importance, the Concession at Tientsin is of more consequence than a whole province of interior China, but I found myself more interested in any one of the ten Mohammedan mosques within the native city, or in the former home of Li Hung-chang, now a tomb in which he is worshiped by his descendants quite like any other prominent bygone Chinese from Confucius to Yuan Shih-kai, than in the whole length of Victoria Road.
The traveler who lets his friends hurry him around the foreign concession of Tientsin by trolley or car will get a sense of a comfortable Western community in an Eastern setting, but he won't have much understanding of the real China or even of the real Tientsin, which is a bustling Chinese city, made no less so by having its wall cut down to a street-width boulevard as a punishment for the Boxer Rebellion. For those who prioritize commerce and modern efficiency, the Concession in Tientsin is more significant than an entire province in inner China, but I found myself more intrigued by any of the ten Mohammedan mosques within the native city, or by the former residence of Li Hung-chang, now a tomb where his descendants worship him just like other notable figures in Chinese history from Confucius to Yuan Shih-kai, rather than in the entire stretch of Victoria Road.
A foreign concession in China, while it serves its purpose of making life more livable and business more possible to the foreign merchants who inhabit it, is altogether too convenient a refuge for the Chinese crooks who choose to make it one. How many of China’s ex-ministers of finance or of communications, how many former office-holders of every graft-collecting grade, have retired to the protection of foreign jurisdiction at Tientsin alone, living in luxury on their loot of office, and how much of this might have been recovered by the Chinese people to whom it rightfully belongs were there no such safety-zones of easy access, is suggested by the magnificent establishments many of these rogues maintain there. Yet the gaunt human horses who toil past them tugging at heavy carts piled high with imports and exports get barely six cents a day in our money, which they wolf in scanty, unwholesome food copper by copper as fast as their tally-sticks amount to one. As mere passers-by we could not but be thankful that, after a brief following of the example of other nations, the United States decided that concessions on Chinese soil were not in keeping with our national policy. The Russians and the Germans and the Austrians have lost theirs now, as they have their extraterritoriality, and it would not be strange if this recovery of sovereignty taken from them for the misdeeds of the Boxers gives hope to the people of China of chasing us all out before the century has grown much older. Where a bare score of Italians can hold a large tract of Chinese territory under their jurisdiction, trafficking in arms and munitions from it with the various factions that are doing their best to make China a continual battle-field, and selling at almost any price they wish to ask what is virtually the protection of their flag to Chinese rascals, it is not to be wondered at if enmity toward “foreign devils” in general does not show rapid strides toward oblivion. Jealousies among the various nationalities which still keep their holdings also make a queer story. Thus as many police forces 107and fire departments are maintained as there are concessions, and one miserable little bridge connects the principal foreign quarter with the rest of China, when getting together would make really efficient substitutions. Tientsin is perhaps a pleasant dwelling-place for those who like it, but we left it without regret one morning soon after our arrival and by noon were rumbling along under the massive walls of Peking, which was to be our home for the unprecedented length of nine months that will not soon be forgotten.
A foreign concession in China, while making life easier and business more feasible for the foreign merchants living there, is also a convenient hideout for Chinese crooks who choose to settle in it. How many of China’s former finance or communications ministers, how many past officials of every graft-collecting level, have retired to the protection of foreign jurisdiction in Tientsin alone, living luxuriously off their ill-gotten gains? How much of this wealth could have been reclaimed by the Chinese people to whom it rightfully belongs if there weren’t such safe havens easily accessible is suggested by the lavish establishments many of these crooks maintain. Meanwhile, the thin laborers trudging past them, pulling heavy carts loaded with imports and exports, earn barely six cents a day in our currency, which they quickly spend on meager, unhealthy food, penny by penny, as fast as their tally-sticks allow. As mere onlookers, we couldn't help but be grateful that, after briefly following the lead of other nations, the United States decided that concessions on Chinese soil didn’t align with our national policy. The Russians, Germans, and Austrians have since lost theirs, along with their extraterritorial rights, and it wouldn’t be surprising if this regaining of sovereignty taken from them due to the Boxers’ misdeeds gives hope to the Chinese people to push us all out before the century grows much older. Where a mere twenty Italians can control a large area of Chinese territory under their jurisdiction, trafficking in arms and munitions with the various factions trying to turn China into an endless battlefield, and selling the protection of their flag to Chinese criminals at nearly any price they set, it’s no wonder resentment towards “foreign devils” in general doesn't disappear quickly. The rivalries among the different nationalities that still hold their concessions create a bizarre situation. As a result, there are just as many police forces and fire departments as there are concessions, and a single miserable little bridge connects the main foreign quarter with the rest of China, while cooperation could create much more efficient alternatives. Tientsin might be a pleasant place for those who enjoy it, but we left without regret one morning soon after arriving and by noon were rumbling along beneath the massive walls of Peking, which would be our home for an unforgettable nine months.
CHAPTER VII
Speeding through the Gobi
In September, when the kaoliang has ripened to its purple-red, there is added beauty to the eight-hour climb from Peking, by leisurely Chinese train, through Nankow Pass and the Great Wall, to Kalgan. Beyond that treeless, mountain-girdled city the railway turns sharply westward, timidly keeping within the outer spur of China’s mammoth rampart, and the traveler to the vast open world to the north must abandon it for a more courageous form of transportation.
In September, when the kaoliang has ripened to its purple-red, the eight-hour journey from Beijing, by slow Chinese train, through Nankow Pass and the Great Wall, becomes even more beautiful as you head to Kalgan. Beyond that tree-free, mountain-surrounded city, the railway veers sharply westward, cautiously sticking to the outer edge of China's massive wall, and anyone wanting to explore the vast open areas to the north must switch to a bolder form of transportation.
Down to the very doors of to-day the camel caravan, drifting along for six weeks or two months, was the swiftest thing from Kalgan to Urga, capital of Outer Mongolia, seven hundred miles away, unless it was sometimes outsped by the forced relays of the Imperial Chinese Post. But the ratio between time and distance has of late undergone violent changes, even in such far-off stretches of the globe. Little more than a decade back mankind was astonished to hear that a venturesome motor-car had fought its way from Peking to Paris; five or six years ago men of more commercial turn of mind took to following this pioneer of swiftness across the Gobi; and to-day it is a rare week that does not see several automobiles, always with room for one more passenger, climb out of Kalgan on their way to Urga.
Down to today, the camel caravan, traveling for six weeks or two months, was the fastest way to get from Kalgan to Urga, the capital of Outer Mongolia, seven hundred miles away, unless it was sometimes outpaced by the quick relays of the Imperial Chinese Post. But the relationship between time and distance has recently changed dramatically, even in such remote areas of the world. Just a little over a decade ago, people were amazed to hear that a daring motorcar had made the journey from Peking to Paris; five or six years ago, more commercially-minded folks started following this trailblazer of speed across the Gobi; and today, it’s rare for a week to go by without several automobiles, always with room for one more passenger, leaving Kalgan on their way to Urga.
How some of these ever reach their destination is one of the innumerable mysteries of the Orient. Our own expedition seemed risky enough, yet it was a mere parlor-game compared to those we met or overtook along the way. In the first place there were but four of us—the Russian Jewish fur-merchant from Tientsin who owned the car, his chauffeur of similar origin, and we two wandering Americans whom chance had momentarily thrown together in the intricate byways of the earth. What with our necessary baggage, the food and beds and arctic garments it would have been foolhardy to reduce, and the cases of gasolene that completed the ramparts which made each ascent to our seats a mountaineering feat, I at least fancied we were heavily laden. Yet we passed on the trail cars with eight or nine Chinese passengers, and on a memorable morning one with eleven, besides all manner of baggage, winter garments, and paraphernalia, somehow packed away in them. They were often old and crippled cars, too, and no wonder, while our own was fresh from the factory, with two gasolene-tanks, a host of reinforcements and accessories, and the right-handed drive befitting left-handed China. Like all those engaged in the Kalgan-to-Urga traffic, it came from Detroit, though not of the breed one first thinks of in that connection, but from the second most popular motor tribe of that habitat. Those who should know say that this is the only car sturdy and at the same time economical enough to endure life on the Gobi Desert.
How some of these ever reach their destination is one of the countless mysteries of the East. Our own trip felt risky enough, but it was just a casual game compared to those we encountered or passed along the way. First of all, there were only four of us—the Russian Jewish fur merchant from Tientsin who owned the car, his chauffeur with a similar background, and the two of us wandering Americans who chance had temporarily brought together in the intricate paths of the world. With our necessary luggage, the food, bedding, and Arctic gear we couldn't afford to downsize, along with the gasoline cases that made climbing into our seats a serious endeavor, I at least thought we were heavily loaded. Yet we passed vehicles on the trail with eight or nine Chinese passengers, and on one unforgettable morning, one with eleven, along with all sorts of luggage, winter clothes, and gear somehow crammed inside. They were often old and beat-up cars, not surprising considering our own was fresh from the factory, with two gas tanks, a range of upgrades and accessories, and a right-hand drive suitable for left-sided China. Like all those involved in the Kalgan-to-Urga transport, it was from Detroit, though not the type one usually thinks of in that context, but from the second most popular motor brand from that area. Those in the know say that this is the only car tough and economical enough to survive life on the Gobi Desert.

The human freight horses of Tientsin, who toil ten or more hours a day for twenty coppers, about six cents in our money
The human freight horses of Tientsin, who work ten or more hours a day for twenty coppers, roughly six cents in our money

Part of the pass above Kalgan is so steep that no automobile can climb to the great Mongolian plateau unassisted
Part of the pass above Kalgan is so steep that no car can make it up to the great Mongolian plateau without help.

Some of the camel caravans we passed on the Gobi seemed endless. This one had thirty dozen loaded camels and more than a dozen outriders
Some of the camel caravans we saw in the Gobi looked endless. This one had thirty dozen loaded camels and more than a dozen riders.

But cattle caravans also cross the Gobi, drawing home-made two-wheeled carts, often with a flag, sometimes the stars and stripes, flying at the head
But cattle caravans also travel across the Gobi, pulling homemade two-wheeled carts, often flying a flag, sometimes the stars and stripes, at the front.
109We honked and snorted and sirened our way through the narrow, dust-deep, crowded streets of Kalgan, as automobiles must in any genuine Chinese city, now blocked completely by the deliberate foot-going traffic, now by languid trains of ox-carts, and always quickly surrounded by gaping and grinning Chinese, to whom a foreigner seems always to remain a rare bird, however many of him may be seen daily. Twice we were halted at ancient city gates by policemen with fixed bayonets. They were somewhat more deferential to us, and more easily satisfied with the credentials we chose to show, than toward our two companions with their big red huchao, large as a newspaper page, by means of which the local yamen had given them permission for their journey. Russians are subject now to Chinese law, and Americans are not, which at times makes a world of difference. Yet it was at one of these same gates that an American resident of Kalgan was killed by one of these same guards not long afterward for refusing to submit to an illegal decree of the local overlord.
109We honked and blared our way through the narrow, dusty, crowded streets of Kalgan, as cars do in any real Chinese city. Sometimes we were completely stopped by pedestrian traffic, other times by slow-moving ox carts, and we were always quickly surrounded by curious and smiling Chinese, to whom a foreigner still feels like a rare sight, no matter how many they see each day. Twice we were stopped at ancient city gates by policemen with fixed bayonets. They were a bit more respectful to us and more easily satisfied with the credentials we chose to show than they were with our two companions, who had big red huchao, the size of a newspaper, which the local yamen had issued to allow them to travel. Russians are now subject to Chinese law, while Americans are not, which sometimes makes a huge difference. Yet it was at one of these same gates that an American resident of Kalgan was killed by one of these same guards not long afterward for refusing to comply with an illegal order from the local overlord.
For about two hours beyond the outer gate we climbed a stony river-bed, wide enough to have carried a stream with ships on its bosom, but merely crisscrossed by a narrow brook bringing down silt from the treeless mountains above. The city abandoned us with reluctance, struggling along for a way in closely crowded shops and dwellings, then straggling more and more until it dwindled to a single row of mud houses on either side, finally to little clusters of huts strung together like loose strings of beads, and breaking up at last into isolated hamlets dug back cave-like into the cliffs of dry fantastic hills that rose yellow-brown above and beyond us. The unpromising route was dense with traffic,—long trains of camels haughtily treading past, strings of ox-carts with the solid, heavily riveted wheels indigenous to China, patient-faced mules and donkeys carefully picking their way through acres of tumbled stones, throngs of cheery, unbelligerent Chinese in blue denims, 110mingled here and there with a more hardy, weather-beaten, hard-faced Mongol, a stray soldier perhaps, with an ancient gun slung over his sheepskin-clad shoulder, or a robust lama in filthy quilted garments that had once been red or yellow. Whenever some of the many obstacles brought us momentarily to a halt these religious tramps came to beg the half-smoked cigarette from between our lips, to feel the car all over, as if it were some new breed of horse, and to hint that a dollar or a dime or a few coppers or even some remnants of food would be more or less gratefully accepted.
For about two hours past the outer gate, we climbed a rocky riverbed, wide enough to have carried a stream with ships floating on it, but only crossed by a narrow brook bringing down silt from the treeless mountains above. The city reluctantly let us go, struggling along through closely packed shops and homes, then straggling more and more until it shrank to a single row of mud houses on either side, ultimately breaking into small clusters of huts strung together like loose beads, and finally giving way to isolated villages dug back cave-like into the cliffs of dry, fantastical hills that rose yellow-brown above us. The uninviting route was busy with traffic—long lines of camels striding past, ox-carts with solid, heavily riveted wheels typical of China, patient-faced mules and donkeys carefully navigating through piles of scattered stones, and crowds of cheerful, non-confrontational Chinese in blue denim, mingling now and then with a tougher, weathered, hard-faced Mongol, possibly a stray soldier, sporting an old gun slung over his sheepskin-covered shoulder, or a sturdy lama in dirty quilted clothes that were once red or yellow. Whenever various obstacles brought us to a temporary stop, these wandering religious figures would come to ask for the half-smoked cigarette from our lips, feel the car all over as if it were a new breed of horse, and hint that a dollar or a dime, or even a few coins or some leftover food would be thankfully accepted.
Where the waterless river tumbles down from the high plateau across which lies nearly all the route to Urga, the slope is too swift even for the sturdiest of motors, wherefore the adaptable Chinese villagers have found a new source of income. Before this steeper section was reached, Chinese along the way began to wave appeals at us, to point out their lean and hungry mules and horses, in some cases even to climb up over our baggage rampart with harnesses in their hands, begging the job of hauling us to the top. Three horses, a mule, and a donkey were at length engaged, after the bargaining indispensable to both races concerned in the transaction, hitched with long rope traces to the front axle of our now silent car, and for more than an hour they toiled upward under the discouragement of three shrieking Chinese drivers and their cracking whips, at a pace which that one of us who chose to walk easily outdistanced.
Where the dry river slopes down from the high plateau that covers almost the entire route to Urga, the incline is too steep even for the toughest motors. Because of this, the resourceful Chinese villagers have found a new way to earn money. Before we reached this steep section, Chinese people along the way started waving at us, pointing to their lean and hungry mules and horses. In some cases, they even climbed over our pile of luggage with harnesses in hand, begging for the chance to haul us to the top. Eventually, we hired three horses, a mule, and a donkey after the necessary bargaining between both groups involved, tying them with long ropes to the front axle of our now silent car. For over an hour, they struggled up the slope under the shouts of three yelling Chinese drivers and the sound of their cracking whips, moving at a pace that one of us, who chose to walk, easily outpaced.
From the chaos of broken rocks where the animals were allowed to abandon us stretched a tumbled brown world not unlike the upper reaches of the Andes. Of road in the Western sense there had been none from the start; there was even less now. Across pell-mell hillocks with rarely a yard of level space between them, among rocks of every jagged and broken form, we plowed for the rest of the morning. Cattle—curiously effeminate-looking cattle, with long ungraceful horns—flocks of sheep and goats intermingled, files of camels under varying cargo, here and there a cluster of black pigs rooting more or less in vain, marked a trail that might otherwise have been less easy to follow. Men in cotton-padded clothing and sheepskins plodded beside their animals, or tramped alone with a worn and faded roll of bed and belongings on their backs; cheery, amused, seldom-washed people smiled at us over the mud walls of their compounds; for some time big ruined towers of what was, or was to have been, another Great Wall, stood at brief intervals along the crest of the bare, yellow-brown ridge beside us. Then came rolling stretches of grain, principally oats, most of it already 111harvested by the sickle and carry-on-the-back method, for all the vastness of the cultivation, and lying in carefully spaced bundles in the fields where it fell, or set up in long rows of closely crowded shocks near the hard-earth threshing floors.
From the chaos of broken rocks where the animals were allowed to leave us stretched a jumbled brown landscape not unlike the higher regions of the Andes. There had been no roads in the Western sense from the beginning; there were even fewer now. We pushed forward for the rest of the morning across hilly terrain with hardly a flat spot between them, among rocks of every jagged shape. Cattle—oddly feminine-looking, with long awkward horns—flocks of sheep and goats mingled, and lines of camels carrying various loads, while clusters of black pigs root around, often with little success, marked a path that might have otherwise been harder to follow. Men dressed in cotton-padded clothes and sheepskins trudged beside their animals or walked alone with a worn and faded roll of bedding and belongings on their backs; cheerful, amused, and often unwashed people smiled at us over the muddy walls of their homes; for some time, large ruined towers of what used to be, or was meant to be, another Great Wall stood at intervals along the crest of the bare, yellow-brown ridge beside us. Then came rolling stretches of grain, mainly oats, most of it already harvested by the sickle-and-carry method, despite the vastness of the cultivation, lying in carefully spaced bundles in the fields where it fell, or set up in long rows of tightly packed shocks near the hard-earth threshing floors.
Bit by bit even this cultivation grew rare and scattered, and finally died out entirely. By the time the speedometer registered eighty miles from Kalgan we were spinning along, often at thirty miles an hour, across high, brown, grass-covered plains, still somewhat uneven, but with little more than a suggestion of hilliness remaining. Flocks of sheep far off on the sloping sides of the horizon looked like patches of daisies; veritable gusts of gray-blue birds of stately flight, suggestive both of cranes and of wild geese, rose in deliberate haste before us and floated away to the rear in a vain effort to outdistance us. Almost frequently we passed long camel caravans, broken up into sections of a dozen animals each, tied together by a sort of wooden marlinespike thrust through their noses beneath the nostrils and attached by a cord to the pack of the animal ahead, the first of each dozen led by a well padded, skin-wrapped man who was more often Chinese than Mongol. Some of these camel-trains seemed endless, with dozen after dozen of the leisurely, soft-footed animals slowly turning their heads to gaze, with a disdainful curiosity that suggested a world-weary professor looking out from beneath his spectacles at incorrigible mankind, upon this strange and impatiently hasty rival that sped breathlessly past them. Now and again a beast shuffled sidewise away from us, uttering that absurd little falsetto squeak which is the camel’s inadequate means of protest at a cruel world; but most of them refused to be startled into undignified activity by any such ridiculous apparition. Once on the journey I counted a caravan bound for Urga which stretched from horizon to horizon across the brown undulating world; and there were thirty dozen camels bearing cargo, and a score of outriders to keep the expedition in order.
Bit by bit, even this farming became rare and scattered, and eventually died out completely. By the time the speedometer read eighty miles from Kalgan, we were zooming along, often at thirty miles an hour, across expansive, brown, grass-covered plains, still a bit uneven, but with only a hint of hilliness left. Flocks of sheep in the distance on the sloping horizon looked like patches of daisies; flocks of gray-blue birds, reminiscent of cranes and wild geese, rose with purpose in front of us and drifted away behind in a futile attempt to get ahead. We frequently passed long camel caravans, divided into sections of a dozen animals each, tied together with a wooden spike pushed through their noses below the nostrils and attached by a cord to the pack of the animal in front, with the first of each dozen led by a well-padded, skin-wrapped driver, who was more often Chinese than Mongolian. Some of these camel trains seemed endless, as dozens of the leisurely, soft-footed animals slowly turned their heads to watch, with a disdainful curiosity that resembled a world-weary professor looking over his glasses at incorrigible humanity, at this strange and impatiently rushing competitor speeding past them. Now and then, a camel shuffled sideways away from us, making that ridiculous little falsetto squeak which is the camel’s weak protest against a harsh world; but most of them refused to be startled into undignified movement by such a silly sight. Once, during the trip, I counted a caravan heading for Urga that stretched from horizon to horizon across the brown rolling expanse; it had thirty dozen camels carrying cargo, and a score of outriders to keep the expedition organized.
We spent the night in a Chinese inn, mud-built and isolated, with the usual stone kang, heatable and mat-covered, as bed and only furnishing. It might have been quiet and restful but for over-zealous watch-dogs and the arrival long after dark and the departure long before dawn of two dilapidated cars with seventeen chattering Chinese passengers. We, too, were off well before daylight, a half-moon lighting the way as we spun across rolling, utterly treeless country with nothing but short, scanty grass giving a touch of life to the brown-green 112landscape over which a cloudless sun at length poured its molten gold. Even the confirmed tramp would have found this an unendurable journey on foot; a motor-car in its prime was scarcely swift enough to avoid monotony, to come often enough on flashes of interest to keep the senses from sinking into slothfulness. Pedestrians and lone travelers had long since disappeared; safety, both from possible violence and from starvation, demanded banding together, and some form of mount. The big shaggy black dogs of Mongolia, filthy in diet as those of Central and South America, but several times more savage, roamed wild across the plains. A woman abroad at sunrise, gathering the offal left by a camping camel-train and tossing it with a bamboo pitchfork over her shoulder into a basket on her back, was the only sign of life for several miles. Such fuel, like the llama droppings of the Andean highlands, is all that is to be had in this barren region.
We spent the night in a Chinese inn, made of mud and secluded, with the usual stone kang, which was heatable and covered with mats, serving as our bed and the only furnishing. It could have been quiet and restful if it weren't for the overly enthusiastic watchdogs and the late arrival and early departure of two rundown cars carrying seventeen noisy Chinese passengers. We were also on our way well before dawn, with a half-moon lighting our path as we sped across rolling, completely treeless land, where only short, sparse grass brought a hint of life to the brown-green 112landscape, eventually drenched in the molten gold of a cloudless sun. Even a seasoned hiker would have found this journey unbearable on foot; a car, even in its prime, was hardly fast enough to escape monotony or to provide enough interesting sights to keep the senses alert. Pedestrians and lone travelers had long since vanished; safety from potential violence and starvation required sticking together and some form of transportation. The large, shaggy black dogs of Mongolia, as filthy in their diet as those in Central and South America but far more ferocious, roamed freely across the plains. A woman out at sunrise, collecting scraps left by a passing camel train and tossing them into a basket on her back with a bamboo pitchfork, was the only sign of life for miles. That kind of fuel, much like the llama droppings of the Andean highlands, is all that’s available in this desolate area.
There were striking reminders of the aborigines of the Andes among the scattered inhabitants of this high plateau. Mongols, distinctive in face, dress, manner, and physique from the Chinese, had the same broad, stolid features to be found along the spine of South America, though they were much more bold and independent of bearing, as if they had never been cowed by alien races. The interiors of their rare clusters of two or three huts recalled the Andes, too—the bare earth for floor, a dozen woolly sheepskins as beds, an extra pair of boots, a couple of aged pots as total belongings. Instead of heaped-up cobblestones without mortar, however, these yourts were made of thick rugs of felt fastened about a light wooden framework into a perfectly round dwelling perhaps ten feet in diameter, the door, invariably facing the south, so low that a man could barely enter upright on his knees. Inside, at least under the wheel-like apex-support of the round and sloping roof, even we Americans could sometimes stand erect—by peering out through the opening for the escape of smoke and the entrance of air in pleasant daytime weather, left by turning back the uppermost strip of felt. At one such tent, where we halted to satisfy a thirsty radiator, only a soil-matted old woman appeared and took to feeling along the ground about it for the vessel that lay in plain sight. She was stone-blind, it turned out, yet to all appearances quite satisfied with life as she knew it, with only her miserable yourt and an uninviting water-hole a few rods away. The Mongol is still a true nomad herdsman, and his round, gray-white dwellings are easily transportable, so that when one little hollow in the plain dries up he has only to pack his house and wander along.
There were striking reminders of the indigenous people of the Andes among the scattered inhabitants of this high plateau. Mongols, clearly different in appearance, clothing, behavior, and physique from the Chinese, had the same broad, solid features found along the spine of South America, though they appeared bolder and more independent, as if they had never been subdued by outside forces. The inside of their rare clusters of two or three huts also resembled the Andes—the bare earth as the floor, a dozen woolly sheepskins for beds, an extra pair of boots, and a couple of old pots as their only belongings. Instead of piled-up cobblestones without mortar, these yourts were made of thick felt rugs attached to a light wooden frame, forming a perfectly round dwelling about ten feet in diameter, with the door, always facing south, so low that a man could barely enter while upright on his knees. Inside, at least under the wheel-like support of the round sloping roof, even we Americans could sometimes stand up straight—by peering out through the opening for smoke to escape and fresh air to come in on pleasant days, which was left open by folding back the top strip of felt. At one such tent, where we stopped to quench a thirsty radiator, an old woman, matted with dirt, was the only one to appear, feeling around the ground for the container that was clearly visible. It turned out she was stone-blind, yet she seemed completely content with her life as she knew it, with just her miserable yourt and an uninviting water hole a few yards away. The Mongol remains a true nomadic herdsman, and his round, gray-white dwellings are easy to move, so when one small area in the plain dries up, he just packs up his home and moves on.

The Mongol would not be himself without his horse, though to us this would usually seem only a pony
The Mongol wouldn’t be himself without his horse, though to us, it might just look like a pony.

Mongol authorities examining our papers, which Vilner is showing, at Ude. Robes blue, purple, dull red, etc. Biggest Chinaman on left
Mongol officials checking our documents that Vilner is displaying at Ude. Wearing blue, purple, dull red robes, etc. The largest Chinese man is on the left.

A group of Mongols and stray Chinese watching our arrival at the first yamen of Urga
A group of Mongols and wandering Chinese observing our arrival at the first yamen of Urga.
113Once every two or three hours we passed a cluster of three or four of these low, movable homes, always at a considerable distance off the trail. There was still no road, yet we made good speed almost steadily. Besides the often dim traces of other travelers there was the guidance of a line of telegraph-poles, carrying two wires but as yet no messages. In the days before the World War word could be flashed by this route from Paris to Peking, even from London to Shanghai, in three minutes; but retreating armies must have fuel even in a treeless desert. Mixed flocks of sheep and goats, slate-colored goats mingled with those fat-tailed sheep of Asia which waddled so ludicrously as they scampered away from us, still found sustenance here and there under the protection of a mounted shepherd or two. It was still too early autumn for wolves, but bands of antelopes, like big pretty rabbits, loping gracefully yet swiftly across the rolling plains, became more and more frequent and immense as we sped northwestward. Before the journey ended, great lines of these, like brown-gray heat-waves, sometimes undulated along the whole horizon, and more than one herd of fifty to a hundred, startled by the sudden appearance of our snorting black monster, all but ran themselves off their legs in a mad dash to cross the trail in front of us, instead of speeding away out of danger.
113Every two or three hours, we passed by a group of three or four of these small, movable homes, always well off the trail. There was still no road, yet we maintained a steady pace. Besides the often faint tracks of other travelers, we were guided by a line of telegraph poles, carrying two wires but no messages yet. In the days before World War I, messages could be sent from Paris to Peking, and even from London to Shanghai, in three minutes; but retreating armies still needed fuel, even in a barren desert. Mixed herds of sheep and goats, with slate-colored goats mingling among those fat-tailed sheep of Asia that waddled comically as they hurried away from us, still found bits of food here and there under the watch of a couple of mounted shepherds. It was still too early in the autumn for wolves, but groups of antelopes, like large, graceful rabbits, loping swiftly across the rolling plains, became increasingly common and large as we moved northwest. Before the journey ended, vast lines of these animals, like brown-gray waves of heat, sometimes rippled along the entire horizon, and more than one herd of fifty to a hundred, startled by the sudden appearance of our loud, black vehicle, almost ran themselves ragged in a frantic dash to cross the trail in front of us rather than just fleeing to safety.
It was about noon of the second day that we gradually entered the real Gobi Desert. Yet it was not a desert in the Sahara sense, of mere shifting sand, but of hard sand and gravel mixed with clay, always covered at least with the thinnest of grass, and often with tufts of a grass-bushy sort, enough to keep even a desert from shifting and blowing. Thus far the weather had been cool but glorious; but no sooner had we come to the Gobi, where, as any teacher of geography can tell you, it never rains, than the sky roofed itself over completely with gray-black clouds and rain forced us to halt and contrive some means of raising the top over our ramparts of baggage. Skeletons of cattle, particularly of camels, became more than frequent, blanching into dust closely beside the trail just where the end of their life’s labors had overtaken them. Buzzards that looked more like eagles vied with the wild black dogs in disposing quickly of the carcasses. Nor were the modern rivals of the camel free from a like fate. Several skeletons of automobiles caught our eye, and they were always scattered piece by piece for some distance, as if they had disintegrated at full speed, or their bones, too, had been picked clean and dragged hither and yon by those savage dogs that roam the Mongolian plains. Floor-flat and wide as it is, and almost as free from the “other fellow” as from “traffic 114cops,” this natural speedway of the Gobi has had a number of fatal automobile accidents.
It was around noon on the second day that we gradually entered the real Gobi Desert. But it wasn’t a desert like the Sahara, just shifting sand; it was hard sand and gravel mixed with clay, always at least covered by the thinnest layer of grass, and often with tufts of bushy grass, enough to prevent even a desert from shifting and blowing away. Until now, the weather had been cool but beautiful; however, as soon as we reached the Gobi, where, as any geography teacher will tell you, it never rains, the sky completely covered itself with dark gray clouds, and rain forced us to stop and figure out a way to raise a cover over our piles of luggage. Skeletons of cattle, especially camels, became increasingly common, bleaching into dust right beside the trail where the end of their lives had caught up with them. Buzzards that looked more like eagles competed with the wild black dogs to dispose of the carcasses quickly. Modern-day rivals of the camel weren't spared either. We spotted several car skeletons, always scattered in pieces over a distance, as if they had broken apart at full speed, or their remains had been picked clean and dragged around by those wild dogs that roam the Mongolian plains. Wide and flat, and almost as free from the “other guy” as from “traffic cops,” this natural speedway of the Gobi has seen its share of fatal car accidents.
Unlike the Sahara, it is not merely the camel that can cross the Gobi. Mules and horses make the journey, and the miles-long camel caravans were rivaled by endless strings of ox-carts, the crudest of two-wheeled contrivances, plodding along across the dry, brown world as if all sense of time or destination had long since been cast aside as worthless paraphernalia. Often, especially in the cold early mornings, we passed caravans camped out, perhaps for a day or two, while their weary animals browsed the stingy hillsides. A denim-blue tent backed by scores or hundreds of bales of hides or wool, if the expedition was China-bound, or boxes of food, cloth, liquor, and oil products, if Urga was its destination, with perhaps more uptilted two-wheeled carts than could have been counted during one of our average halts, usually completed such a picture as we came upon it. At the sound of our unmuffled engine tent-doors became alive with gaping, bullet-headed Mongols, lower orders of whom, or their Chinese counterparts, came to life from beneath what had seemed to be mere bundles of felt rags and sheepskins on the cold hard ground, while the horses tethered about the camp with three feet hobbled together after the Mongol fashion made frantic and often successful efforts to escape from this new terror descending upon them. The horses of the Gobi have not yet learned to behold the automobile with equanimity, and our passing often sent great herds of Mongolian ponies sweeping away in chaotic masses across the plains in a stampede which the dozen outriders were powerless to stem.
Unlike the Sahara, it's not just camels that can cross the Gobi. Mules and horses make the journey too, and the long camel caravans were matched by endless strings of ox-carts, the simplest two-wheeled vehicles, making their way across the dry, brown landscape as if any sense of time or direction had long been discarded as useless clutter. Often, especially in the cold early mornings, we saw caravans camped out, perhaps for a day or two, while their tired animals grazed on the sparse hillsides. A denim-blue tent set against dozens or hundreds of bales of hides or wool, if they were heading to China, or boxes of food, cloth, liquor, and oil products if Urga was their destination, with possibly more two-wheeled carts than we could count during one of our typical stops, usually completed this scene as we came upon it. At the sound of our loud engine, tent doors sprang open with curious, bullet-headed Mongols, and lower-ranking members or their Chinese counterparts emerged from what appeared to be just bundles of felt rags and sheepskins on the cold hard ground, while the horses tied around the camp with three feet hobbled together in the Mongolian way made desperate and often successful efforts to escape from this new threat approaching them. The horses of the Gobi have not yet learned to accept cars calmly, and our passing frequently sent great herds of Mongolian ponies racing away in chaotic masses across the plains in a stampede that a dozen outriders could not control.
Twice during the second day we made out large compact clusters of white buildings on the flank of distant ridges along the horizon—lamaseries in which scores of Mongol monks pass their days in anything but monasterial austerity. Once, when we had seen no other living thing for hours, an old Mongol came loping across the desert on a camel in the teeth of the cold, raging wind, a picturesque figure in the still almost bright-red quilted cloak reaching to his ankles, and his pagoda-shaped fur cap. When we called to him he halted and pulled sharply at the reins attached to the perforated nose of his beast, which thereupon knelt in instalments, front, back, then front again, and rose to follow his dismounted master over to us. Our Russian companions, who managed to make themselves understood in any language, though actually speaking none but their own, passed the time of day in Mongol, the one important word of which seems to be buyna, corresponding to 115the French il y a, but greatly outdoing it in service. The leathery face of the old man was like a boot that had lain out in the elements for years; the two teeth he showed suggested the fangs of a wolf; but his smile was as kindly as that of an Iowa farmer, and while his thankfulness for a cigarette was very briefly expressed, as becomes a nomad scorning or unaware of the formalities of a politer world, there was something distinctly manly in his every movement from the time we first saw him until he mounted his kneeling camel again and rode away into the vastness of the desert. For hours afterward there was nothing to catch the attention, unless it was the compatriot beside me. He was one of those American wanderers in the Orient who have never recrossed the Pacific since coming out to help pacify the Philippines a generation ago, and he still preferred a horse and “buggy” to these new-fangled things fed by gasolene; he had not yet heard of scores of facts and inventions which have become ancient history to us at home; and he passed his idle hours in humming the songs that were popular in our land twenty years back.
Twice on the second day, we spotted large clusters of white buildings on the distant ridges along the horizon—lamaseries where many Mongol monks spend their days in anything but a strict monastic lifestyle. Once, after hours of seeing nothing alive, an old Mongol rode across the desert on a camel, battling the cold, howling wind. He was a striking figure in his bright-red quilted cloak that reached his ankles and his pagoda-shaped fur cap. When we called to him, he stopped and sharply pulled the reins tied to the holes in his camel's nose, which then knelt down in stages—first its front, then its back, and finally its front again—before getting up to follow its dismounted master over to us. Our Russian friends, who could make themselves understood in any language despite only speaking their own, greeted him in Mongolian. The key word they used was buyna, equivalent to the French there is, and it had a much broader application. The old man's weathered face resembled a boot that had been left out in the elements for years; his two visible teeth looked like wolf fangs. However, his smile was as warm as an Iowa farmer's, and while he expressed his gratitude for a cigarette in a brief manner that suited a nomad who disregarded the formalities of a more refined world, every action of his exuded a distinct masculinity from the moment we saw him until he climbed back onto his kneeling camel and rode off into the vast desert. For hours afterward, nothing else caught my attention, except for the fellow traveler beside me. He was one of those American explorers in the East who had never returned across the Pacific after coming to help pacify the Philippines a generation ago. He still preferred a horse and buggy over these modern gasoline-powered vehicles; he hadn’t heard about numerous advancements and facts that have become old news back home, and he passed his free time humming songs that were popular in our country two decades ago.
At length we ran out from under the great motionless canopy of clouds into brilliant sunshine again, though even there the racing wind was almost bitter cold. The Gobi, as I have said, is no Sahara, yet it was beautiful in its many moods as the sea, stretching away in tawny browns or cold bluish grays to infinity, or to scampering lines of antelope along the far horizon. Beyond the mud-walled compound enclosing the telegraph station of Ehr-lien the smooth, grass-tufted desert gave way to a savage country of protruding rock-heaps, peaked heaps of blackish stone outcropping everywhere, as if nature, too, built prayer-piles, like the pious Mongols, who litter their landscapes with conical piles of stones wherever they are available, as appeals to the supernatural powers.
Finally, we emerged from under the vast, still blanket of clouds into bright sunshine again, though even there the gusting wind was almost painfully cold. The Gobi, as I mentioned, isn't like the Sahara, but it was stunning in its many moods, similar to the sea, stretching out in sandy browns or chilly bluish grays to the horizon, or to the darting lines of antelope far in the distance. Beyond the mud-walled compound surrounding the telegraph station of Ehr-lien, the smooth, grass-covered desert gave way to a rugged landscape of jagged rock piles, sharp peaks of dark stone protruding everywhere, as if nature, too, were building prayer piles like the devout Mongols, who scatter conical stacks of stones across their land as offerings to the supernatural.
Nightfall found us midway between two mud-walled telegraph stations, and shelter from the raging wind and the penetrating night air of a more than four-thousand-foot elevation was highly desirable. Two weather-blackened yourts broke the immensity about us, far off to the right. One does not need to look for side-roads on the Gobi; we made a bee-line for them across the plain. But the unsoaped occupants were not willing to double up in one tent and rent us the other, for which I was duly grateful when I had caught a glimpse inside the pen that might have been assigned to us. Several miles farther on, a larger group of nomad dwellings appeared, this time to the left across more 116broken country. By the time we had struggled near to the settlement we were surrounded by Mongols and black dogs, several horses had broken their tethers and were already mere specks on the horizon, and even the camels reclining about the yourts had risen to protest in their ridiculously childish falsetto against this unauthorized disturbance. This time there were half a dozen tents, in much better repair and more nearly resembling human dwellings. Moreover here there was a man of importance to receive us. He was a lama, as his close-cropped head and a kind of bath-robe gown, thickly quilted and still dully red for all its unwashed age, told us; for the Mongol layman wears a cue and more masculine garments, wore a cue in fact centuries before this girlish head-dress was imposed upon the Chinese by their nomad conquerors. But it required the linguistic lore of our Russian companions to learn that he was also a princeling, a kind of tribal ruler of a neighboring region, who had come on a visit to his friend, the family head of this cluster of huts. He was a big brawny man, rather handsome in his own racial style, with a wide, frank, fairly intelligent face, pitted with smallpox. We were invited to enter his own hut, which was round and low and made of thick gray felt, like all those on the Gobi; but the earth floor was also carpeted with felt mats, and about the circular walls were several small chests and other simple articles of household use, not to mention saddles and bridles. The lama gave orders briefly and to the point, more like a commander than a guest. A sort of iron basket on legs was set up in the middle of the tent, filled, by hand, with dried camel-dung, and was soon blazing so merrily that the bitter night wind outside was more endurable than the temperature inside the tent. I know no fuel which outdoes that of the Gobi in quickness and intensity of heat. The Mongols, however, seemed to be impervious to it. Though inured for many generations to the bitter cold of their plateau, they crowded into the hut without removing a single one of their heavy garments, tightly closed the little low door, and squatted about the roasting iron cage with every evidence of keen enjoyment. There is but slight differentiation by sex in Mongol dress, and the men and women alike wore heavy, ungraceful trousers, huge high boots of soft, pliable, black leather with pointed turned-up toes, and a thick quilted garment covering all else from neck to calves, not to mention uncouth fur head-dresses. Even in these desert yourts the reddish faces and garments of the women are often set off by elaborate and fanciful hair-dress and other ornaments; but if these existed here they had been laid away, and the very girls stalked 117about in their oversize sock-stuffed boots like lumber-jacks in midwinter.
Nightfall found us halfway between two mud-walled telegraph stations, and shelter from the howling wind and the biting night air at this elevation of over four thousand feet was definitely needed. Two weather-beaten yourts stood isolated to our right. You don’t need to search for side roads in the Gobi; we headed straight for them across the plain. But the unwelcoming occupants weren’t keen on squeezing into one tent and letting us rent the other, which I was relieved about when I caught a glimpse inside the space that might have been ours. A few miles later, a larger cluster of nomadic dwellings appeared on our left across a more rugged landscape. By the time we got close to the settlement, we were surrounded by Mongols and black dogs, several horses had broken loose and were already tiny dots on the horizon, and even the camels lounging around the yourts stood up, protesting in their surprisingly high-pitched voices against this unexpected disturbance. This time there were six tents, in much better condition and more closely resembling proper homes. Plus, there was a significant person here to greet us. He was a lama, as indicated by his closely cropped head and a thickly quilted bathrobe that was still a dull red, albeit dirty from age; Mongol laymen wear cues and more masculine attire, having adopted this girlish hairstyle centuries before it was forced upon the Chinese by their nomadic conquerors. It took the language skills of our Russian companions to learn that he was also a princeling, a sort of tribal leader from a nearby area who had come to visit his friend, the head of this group of huts. He was a big, sturdy man, somewhat handsome in his own racial way, with a wide, open, fairly intelligent face, marred by smallpox scars. We were invited into his hut, which was round and low and made of thick gray felt, like all the others in the Gobi; however, the earthen floor was also covered with felt mats, and around the circular walls were several small chests and other simple household items, along with saddles and bridles. The lama issued brief, direct orders, more like a leader than a guest. A sort of iron basket on legs was set up in the middle of the tent, filled by hand with dried camel dung, and soon it was blazing cheerfully, making the bitter night wind outside feel more bearable than the temperature inside the tent. I know no fuel that beats that of the Gobi for speed and intensity of heat. However, the Mongols seemed unfazed by it. Though conditioned for many generations to the harsh cold of their plateau, they packed into the hut without shedding a single heavy garment, tightly closed the little low door, and squatted around the blazing iron basket, showing clear signs of enjoyment. There’s little distinction between male and female clothing among the Mongols, and both men and women wore heavy, ungraceful trousers, huge high boots made of soft, pliable black leather with pointed, turned-up toes, and thick quilted garments covering everything from neck to calves, not to mention awkward fur headgear. Even in these desert yourts, the reddish faces and clothing of the women are often complemented by elaborate and fancy hairstyles and other decorations; but if those existed here, they had been put away, and even the girls walked around in their oversized, stuffed boots like lumberjacks in midwinter.
Mongol tea was prepared over the fire-cage and served us in brass bowls; but as the resident of Mongolia puts his salt in his tea rather than on his food, and has other un-Western notions of how it should be concocted, I did not insist on having my bowl refilled. I found my mind frequently harking back to such nights as this on the high Andean plateaus of South America, though there the travel itself had been quite different. Here was the same bare, vegetationless earth round about, the same complete ignorance of, or interest in, cleanliness, similar crowded, comfortless huts, and much the same attitude toward life as among the Indians of the Andes. But these plateau-dwellers were far more hospitable, cheery of manner, and with a live human curiosity which, though it caused them to finger monkey-like any of our possessions they could reach, had a more agreeable effect on the spirits than the sullen dullness of their American prototypes. Now and again, when they became over-troublesome, the lama ordered them outside with a commanding voice and manner which usually was effective at the third or fourth repetition. Yet he, too, was not lacking in fingering curiosity, of a slightly more controllable nature. While we ate we passed out samples of our strange foreign food to the gaping, over-clad semicircle about us. One of my canned cherries, dropped into a gnarled Mongol palm, created a considerable commotion. What was it; and was it safe in a Mongol stomach, even though this other kind of man ate it without misgiving? It passed from hand to hand around the circle, each evidently expressing his opinion of the risk involved, and the consensus seemed to be that it was up to the original recipient to make the venture. He licked cautiously at the fruit for some time after it had been returned to the furrowed hollow of his hand. At length, reassured by the two Russians and urged on by the lama, he bit gingerly into it—and half sprang to his feet with the shock it seemed to give his tongue. More reassurance finally induced him to eat it, and all went well until the stone betrayed its existence, whereupon there was an instant demand to know whether the presence of that foreign substance was normal, or whether his evil spirit was playing new and perhaps destructive tricks upon him. Considering the quantity of foreign substance the average Mongol absorbs with his meals, there seemed to be something absurdly incongruous about this lengthy performance. But then, we of the uninstructed West know little of the myriad methods the teeming evil spirits of the Orient devise to trap their victims.
Mongol tea was made over a fire and served to us in brass bowls; however, since the locals add salt to their tea instead of their food and have other unconventional ideas about how it should be prepared, I decided not to ask for a refill. I often found my thoughts drifting back to nights like this on the high Andean plateaus of South America, though the travel experience there had been quite different. The surrounding earth was just as bare and devoid of vegetation, the same indifference to cleanliness prevailed, the huts were similarly cramped and uncomfortable, and the attitude toward life mirrored that of the Andean Indians. Yet, these plateau dwellers were much more hospitable, cheerful in demeanor, and had a lively curiosity that, although they playfully examined any of our belongings they could get their hands on, uplifted our spirits more than the sullen behavior of their American counterparts. Occasionally, when they became too curious, the lama would send them outside with a commanding voice and manner that usually worked by the third or fourth time he said it. Still, he himself was not without a kind of curiosity, though his was slightly more restrained. While we ate, we handed out samples of our strange foreign food to the eager crowd around us. When one of my canned cherries fell into a weathered Mongol palm, it caused quite a stir. What was it, and was it safe for a Mongol to eat, even if this other kind of person had no doubts? It passed from hand to hand, with everyone clearly sharing their thoughts on the risk involved, and the general consensus seemed to be that it was up to the original holder to take the plunge. He cautiously licked the fruit for a while after it had been returned to the rough hollow of his hand. Eventually, reassured by the two Russians and encouraged by the lama, he cautiously took a bite—and nearly jumped up in surprise at the shock it gave his tongue. After some further encouragement, he finally ate it, and everything went smoothly until he discovered the pit, which immediately sparked a demand to know whether that foreign object was normal, or if an evil spirit was playing new and possibly harmful tricks on him. Given the amount of foreign substances the average Mongol consumes with their meals, this long spectacle seemed absurdly contradictory. But then, we in the uninformed West know little about the countless ways the restless evil spirits of the East try to ensnare their victims.
118A bit of chocolate caused less flurry, though the semicircle around which it disappeared unanimously pronounced it too sweet to be agreeable. A cube of sugar was not a total stranger, and each of the gathering asked the privilege of letting one melt on his tongue. When it came to meat, even from tins, there was no mystery left; mutton and beef form the almost exclusive diet of the Mongols, except for milk and cheese in summer, and their salted tea. Not only are they true nomads, but their pseudo-Buddhist religion teaches that it is wicked—or shall we say dangerous?—to till the soil.
118A piece of chocolate caused less excitement, although everyone in the semicircle where it disappeared agreed it was too sweet to enjoy. A cube of sugar wasn’t completely unfamiliar, and each person at the gathering wanted to try letting one melt on their tongue. When it came to meat, even from cans, there were no secrets left; mutton and beef make up almost the entire diet of the Mongols, along with milk and cheese in summer, and their salted tea. They are not just true nomads, but their pseudo-Buddhist beliefs also teach that farming is wrong—or should we say dangerous?
Though there is little formality in Mongol intercourse, I inadvertently made one faux pas during the evening. Among those who crowded into the overheated hut was what I at first took to be a handsome youth, but who turned out to be, under the heavy, sexless garments of Mongolia, a girl, perhaps of seventeen. When I offered her a tidbit of some sort, she shrank back without accepting it, while the rest of the semicircle looked at me with an expression of mingled wonder and resentment, and a moment later she slipped out through the tightly closed, knee-high door into the night. I should, it seemed, have been more indirect in my methods, handing the donation to the old woman or to one of the men of the family, and hinting that they might pass it on. As it was, I had evidently boldly made an advance, and that publicly, similar to handing my door-key to a chance lady acquaintance in the West. The girl returned, later on, and indirectly accepted a few knick-knacks, but it was evident as long as I remained that I was a man on whom it behooved parents and husbands to keep a watchful eye.
Though there’s not much formality in Mongolian interactions, I accidentally made a social blunder that evening. Among the crowd in the overheated hut, I initially thought I was seeing a handsome young man, but it turned out to be a girl, possibly around seventeen, dressed in the heavy, gender-neutral clothing typical of Mongolia. When I offered her a snack, she recoiled without taking it, while the others in the semicircle looked at me with a mix of surprise and disapproval. Moments later, she slipped out through the low, tightly closed door into the night. It seemed I should have approached the situation more subtly, perhaps by handing the treat to an older woman or one of the men in the family and suggesting they might give it to her. As it was, I had clearly made a bold, public advance, akin to giving my house key to a casual acquaintance in the West. The girl came back later and indirectly accepted a few small items, but it was clear that as long as I was there, I was a man whom parents and husbands needed to keep an eye on.
The tin cans we emptied were, of course, considered great prizes, to be quarreled over and at length allotted by the lama. The old woman begged us to open others and somehow dispose of the food in them, in order that she might still further increase her stock of kitchen utensils. Her curiosity seemed to have reached almost a morbid growth, for though we or the lama drove her several times out of the hut, she was evidently bent on watching these curious beings from another world disrobe. A ragged old man who proved to be the tribal shepherd was equally hard to banish, though for a different reason. He had been accustomed to sleep in the hut we occupied, and he resisted as long as he dared, and quite justly, the demand of the lama that he sleep outside. The lama won in the end, of course, and the shepherd curled up grumblingly in a nest of quilted rags and sheepskins along the outer wall, where his deep bark resounded in the desert stillness all through the night. Heavy colds seem to be quite as common among these 119permanent denizens of the plateau as they were universal with the four of us. The fire-cage was carried outside, but the thick heat remained, in spite of which the lama called to a boy to pull the topmost layer of felt down over the opening left in the top of yourts by day, hermetically sealing the place. But he was right; before morning we would have resented a pinhole in the felt walls. I had indulged in the luxury of bringing an army cot with me, which excited not only the wonder but the admiration of our host. The inventiveness which had produced such a contraption seemed less surprising to him than the courage I displayed in using it; he, said the lama, would be certain to fall off it in the night and seriously injure himself. Instead he stripped to the waist and lay down on a bundle of blankets and skins along the wall, pulling a rough cover of camel’s hair over him. But this was not until the formalities of his calling had been fulfilled. As we were turning in, he called once more to the boy outside, who soon appeared with two brass disks, loosely tied together. The lama squatted on his haunches, clashed the disks once together with a resounding clang, then mumbled for several minutes through his prayers. Then he sat for some time staring from one to the other of us, as if wondering what breed of men were these, who dared lie down for the night without having propitiated the evil spirits which ride the darkness, until at length he blew out the floating-wick lamp and lay down.
The empty tin cans we discarded were seen as valuable treasures, often fought over and eventually distributed by the lama. The old woman urged us to open other cans and get rid of the food inside so she could add to her collection of kitchen tools. Her curiosity seemed almost unhealthy; even though we or the lama forced her out of the hut several times, she was clearly determined to watch these strange beings from another world get undressed. A tattered old man, who turned out to be the tribal shepherd, was also tough to get rid of, but for a different reason. He was used to sleeping in the hut we occupied and resisted, quite reasonably, the lama's request for him to sleep outside. Ultimately, the lama prevailed, and the shepherd ungrumpily curled up in a nest of patched rags and sheepskins along the outer wall, where his loud barking echoed through the desert silent night. It seemed that heavy colds were just as common among these long-term residents of the plateau as they were for the four of us. The fire-cage was moved outside, but the intense heat lingered. Despite this, the lama instructed a boy to pull the top layer of felt down over the opening left in the top of the yourts during the day, sealing it tightly. But he was right; by morning, we would have resented even a tiny hole in the felt walls. I had treated myself to an army cot, which amazed and impressed our host. The inventiveness that created such a thing seemed less astonishing to him than the bravery I showed in using it; the lama said he would surely fall off it at night and hurt himself badly. Instead, he removed his shirt and lay down on a pile of blankets and skins against the wall, pulling a coarse camel-hair cover over himself. But he did this only after completing the formal rituals of his role. As we were settling in, he once more called the boy outside, who soon came in with two brass disks tied together loosely. The lama squatted down, struck the disks together with a loud clang, then mumbled his prayers for several minutes. After that, he spent some time staring at each of us, as if puzzled by what kind of men we were, daring to go to sleep without appeasing the evil spirits of the night, until finally he blew out the floating-wick lamp and lay down.
We were glad, indeed, to see the sun again next morning, when at last it burst up like the exhaust from a puddling furnace over the low, level horizon. Already we had bumped our way back to the “highway,” as worthy of the name as the caminos reales, the “royal roads,” of South America are of theirs, and had sped some distance along it. The eyes suffered most in this glaring light and the incessant strong head wind from which nothing short of entirely wrapping up the head could protect them. The constant bumping and tossing made up for any lack of exercise. Among myriad rock-heaps, natural and prayerful, we crossed the frontier between Inner and Outer Mongolia, marked merely by two huger stone-heaps on either side of the there sunken trail, the summits connected by a wire from which hung tattered bits of cloth prayers and various mementos of the pious, culminating in a weather-beaten straw hat of Chinese make. That was all, except the immensity of the desert, for the frontier-station was still about fifty miles distant. Then the rock-heaps died out, and the earth as far as we could see it was thickly covered with millions of little mounds, like untended 120Chinese graves, with hints of scanty tuft-grass on top of them. At long intervals we passed a caravan, the dull-toned notes of the bell-camels reaching our ears momentarily as we dashed past. The first camel of one long train carried the American flag at his masthead, so to speak, to warn would-be marauders that the hides and wool behind him were under whatever protection our consuls and diplomats in the former Chinese Empire have to offer. Otherwise the world about us was mainly a confirmation of the fact that, while China proper estimates the density of her population at two hundred and twenty-five to the square mile, Mongolia’s is rated at two.
We were really happy to see the sun again the next morning when it finally rose up like the steam from a furnace over the flat horizon. By then, we had bumped our way back to the "highway," which was as deserving of the name as the caminos reales, the “royal roads,” in South America, and had
Were the world not so slow to accept geographical changes, even in these days of the constant remaking of maps, we should long since have ceased to distinguish between Mongolia and China “proper.” Though the Chinese Republic claims, and to a certain extent maintains, the loyalty of that strip of earth bordering her on the north and known as Inner Mongolia, the vast region we call Outer Mongolia cast off Chinese rule a decade ago. More exactly, it never was under Chinese rule, at least in modern times, for barely had their kindred Manchus been driven from the throne of China than the Mongols asserted their independence from the new-formed republic. That was why we Americans had looked forward with some misgiving to our arrival in Ude, which occurred early on this third day. Ude consists of half a dozen yourts and a new mud-walled telegraph station, a desolate spot, owing its location to a near-by water-hole. But it is the place where the merits or demerits of persons entering Outer Mongolia from China are passed upon—passed upon by unpolished Mongols who have little knowledge of, and less interest in, the way such things are handled at other boundaries between the countries of the globe. The Russians had no misgivings; while men of their race would not willingly have traveled to Urga eighteen months before, they were now, as it were, among their own people. But, for reasons which will in due time be apparent, there is just now a certain lack of welcome in Mongolia toward Americans, in which the British and certain other important nationalities share. Less than a month before, two Englishmen in their own car had been halted at Ude and refused admission to the land beyond, eventually giving up lengthy and useless negotiations to have this decision reversed, and returning to China. We had no “papers” calling upon Mongolia to admit us. Our legation in Peking had only been able to tell us that, if our passports were sent to the Chinese foreign office, they would be returned—long afterward—with the information that, 121while Mongolia was still Chinese territory, it was in the hands of rebels—they might even have called them bandits—and since the Chinese Republic could not guarantee the safety of foreigners in that region, they could not consent to our traveling there, even to the extent of giving us a visé. The Mongols themselves have no accredited representative in China, naturally, and while certain other agents in Peking might have smoothed things over for us if they had wished, it is their policy to pretend that they and those they represent have no real power in Mongolia, apparently in the hope of keeping the world ignorant as long as possible of their doings in that region. It is customary, therefore, for those citizens of Western nations who wish to enter Outer Mongolia to pick up their traps and go, regardless of legal permissions.
Were the world not so slow to accept geographical changes, even today, with maps constantly being updated, we would have long stopped distinguishing between Mongolia and China “proper.” Although the Chinese Republic claims and somewhat maintains loyalty over the area bordering it to the north, known as Inner Mongolia, the large region we call Outer Mongolia shook off Chinese control a decade ago. In reality, it never was under Chinese control, at least in modern times, because as soon as the Manchus were driven from the throne of China, the Mongols declared their independence from the newly formed republic. That’s why we, Americans, felt a bit uneasy about arriving in Ude early on this third day. Ude consists of a handful of yourts and a new mud-walled telegraph station, situated in a desolate spot near a water-hole. But it’s where the merits or demerits of people entering Outer Mongolia from China are evaluated—by unrefined Mongols who know little about and care even less for how things are handled at other borders around the world. The Russians had no worries; while their people wouldn’t have traveled to Urga willingly eighteen months ago, they now felt as if they were among friends. However, for reasons that will soon become clear, there's currently a certain lack of welcome in Mongolia towards Americans, which the British and some other significant nationalities also experience. Less than a month prior, two Englishmen in their own car were stopped at Ude and denied entry into the territory beyond, eventually abandoning lengthy and futile negotiations to reverse that decision and returning to China. We had no “papers” asking Mongolia to let us in. Our legation in Peking could only inform us that if we sent our passports to the Chinese foreign office, they would be returned—long after—stating that, while Mongolia was still considered Chinese territory, it was in the hands of rebels—they might have even called them bandits—and since the Chinese Republic couldn’t guarantee the safety of foreigners in that area, they couldn’t allow us to travel there, even to the point of issuing a visa. The Mongols themselves don’t have any accredited representatives in China, of course, and while other agents in Peking could have smoothed things over for us if they wanted, their policy is to pretend that they and those they represent have no real authority in Mongolia, seemingly hoping to keep the world in the dark about their activities in that region for as long as possible. Therefore, it’s common for citizens of Western nations who want to enter Outer Mongolia to just grab their things and go, regardless of legal permissions.
But all our misgivings of being turned back at Ude were worry wasted. The Mongols have a reputation for instability in the conduct of affairs of government, of stiff-necked severity at one moment and great leniency in quite a similar matter the next; for after all they are little more than adult children to whom government is a new and amusing plaything. Moreover it may be that the letter and the bottle of vodka which the chief of our party brought for the Ude functionary had their effect; at any rate he not only did not demand our papers but did not even ask to see us, so that by the time we had breakfasted on our own food and local hot water in a yourt next to the official one we were free to continue to Urga.
But all our worries about being turned back at Ude were unnecessary. The Mongols are known for being unpredictable in their governance, sometimes strict one moment and then surprisingly lenient the next; after all, they're really just big kids who find government to be a new and entertaining toy. It might also be that the letter and bottle of vodka our party chief brought for the Ude official made a difference; in any case, he not only didn’t ask to see our papers but didn’t even bother to meet us. So by the time we had breakfasted on our own food and local hot water in a yourt next to the official one, we were free to head to Urga.
Ox-carts with a single telegraph-pole diagonally across them were crawling northwestward in great trains; new poles and rolls of wire, both from far off, lay here and there along the way near Ude, where we ran into the Dane who had been all summer repairing the line which retreating armies had left a wreck behind them. Within a week, he promised—and his word proved good—messages would again be flashing from Paris to Peking, as they had not in more than two years. Mongols and Chinese now well trained for the task were replacing the last of the thousands of missing poles which forced neglect or the demands of military camp-fires had brought down, and their methods were worth watching. Instead of the sharp spikes at the instep used by our pole-climbers, the Mongols wore on each foot a semicircle of iron about two feet long, with saw-teeth on the inside, which made their climbing suggestive of some tropical spider, and must be taken off whenever they walked from pole to pole. The Chinese, on the other hand, used a method characteristic of their overcrowded, man-cheap 122country—each pole-climber had two coolie assistants, who carried a ladder! Building, or even repairing, a telegraph-line across the Gobi is no effeminate matter of nightly beds and full hot meals. The sole national representative in Mongolia of this Danish enterprise had been weeks at a time even without bread, while the less said in his presence about bathing the greater the popularity of the speaker. Stern methods are needed, too, to protect such exotic assets as telegraph-poles in an utterly treeless and even bushless region. By the “law of the Living Buddha,” as it is called in Mongolia, the cutting down of a telegraph-pole is punishable with death. The Dane and his party had come across a man so engaged not long before, and had tied him up and sent him off to be judged by his fellows; but so effective has the law been that the severed and useless end of a pole will lie until it rots away close beside a trail along which pass hundreds of caravans and groups of travelers to whom fuel is almost a matter of life or death.
Ox-carts with a single telegraph pole diagonally across them were slowly moving northwest in long lines; new poles and rolls of wire, both from afar, were scattered along the way near Ude, where we met the Dane who had been repairing the line all summer, which the retreating armies had left in ruins. Within a week, he promised—and he kept his promise—messages would once again be flashing from Paris to Peking, as they hadn't in over two years. Well-trained Mongols and Chinese were replacing the last of the thousands of missing poles that neglect or military campfires had brought down, and their methods were fascinating to observe. Instead of the sharp spikes used by our pole climbers, the Mongols wore a semicircular iron device about two feet long with saw-teeth on the inside, which made their climbing look like some tropical spider. They had to remove it whenever they walked from pole to pole. On the other hand, the Chinese had a method typical of their overcrowded, low-cost labor country—each pole climber had two coolie assistants who carried a ladder! Building or even repairing a telegraph line across the Gobi is no delicate task involving nightly beds and hearty meals. The sole national representative in Mongolia of this Danish project had gone for weeks at a time without bread, and the less talked about bathing in his presence, the more popular the speaker became. Tough measures are also necessary to protect valuable assets like telegraph poles in a completely treeless and bushless area. According to the "law of the Living Buddha," as it's called in Mongolia, cutting down a telegraph pole is punishable by death. The Dane and his team had encountered a man doing just that not long ago, and they had tied him up and sent him off to be judged by his peers; but the law has been so effective that the severed and useless end of a pole will lie there until it rots away next to a trail frequented by hundreds of caravans and groups of travelers for whom fuel is almost a matter of life or death.
For nearly a day’s journey beyond Ude the desert is so smooth and hard that we could maintain a speed of fifty miles an hour for long stretches, so smooth that riding the roadless plateau was almost like falling through space. Sain-Usu, which is Mongol for “Good Water,” welcomed us for half an hour in one of its three huts, and not far beyond there rose deep-blue above the horizon the flattened peak that marks the site of Tuerin. With such splendid going as nature furnished, it seemed visibly to move toward us; yet the sun was low and the night cold already biting into our bones when we dragged ourselves to the ground before the telegraph station at its foot. This highest point on the trans-Gobi journey, five thousand feet above the sea, is a great fantastic heap of black rocks, many of them large as apartment-houses, piled up one above the other, here as carefully as if by the hand of man, there tossed together in such a pell-mell chaos as to suggest that the Builder had suddenly taken a dislike to his task and knocked it over with a disdainful sweep of the hand. On the further slope lies a large lamasery, where travelers may sometimes find shelter, but not food, for all the quantities of everything which the pious nomads roundabout bring the loafing lamas. Otherwise there is nothing whatever except the yellow-brown plains, sloping away to infinity in every direction.
For almost a day's journey beyond Ude, the desert is so smooth and hard that we could keep a speed of fifty miles an hour for long stretches, so smooth that riding on the roadless plateau felt almost like floating through space. Sain-Usu, which means “Good Water” in Mongol, welcomed us for half an hour in one of its three huts, and not far beyond, we could see the deep blue of the flattened peak marking the site of Tuerin rising above the horizon. With such splendid terrain provided by nature, it seemed to be drawing closer to us; however, the sun was low and the night was already cold, biting into our bones when we finally settled down before the telegraph station at its base. This highest point on the trans-Gobi journey, five thousand feet above sea level, is a great, fantastical heap of black rocks, many as large as apartment buildings, stacked on top of each other—some arranged meticulously as if by a human hand, while others were tossed together in such chaotic disarray that it seemed like the Builder had suddenly lost interest in his work and knocked it over with a careless sweep of his hand. On the farther slope sits a large lamasery, where travelers may occasionally find shelter, but not food, despite the numerous supplies that the pious nomads nearby bring for the idle lamas. Otherwise, there is nothing at all except the yellow-brown plains, sloping away to infinity in every direction.
The last hundred and fifty miles were more like a prairie than a desert, beautiful light-brown folds of earth, everywhere cut on a generous pattern, rolling on and on farther than the advancing eye could ever reach. There was a kind of prairie-dog, too, squatting on its 123haunches and gazing saucily upon us, or dashing for the gravel-banked holes with which it had dotted the plain. These were marmots, of special interest to our Russian companions, since their skins form one of the most important items of export for the fur-traders of Mongolia. Mile after mile they lined the way, whole colonies of them, some of the bluish tint much sought after by dealers, most of them a beautiful gray-brown which flashed for a moment in the brilliant sunshine as they dashed gopher-like for their holes with an impertinent flip of their bushy tails.
The last hundred and fifty miles felt more like a prairie than a desert, with beautiful light-brown rolls of land, all carved out in a generous pattern, stretching on and on farther than the eye could see. There was a kind of prairie dog, too, squatting on its haunches and looking at us cheekily, or darting for the gravelly holes scattered across the plain. These were marmots, which were of particular interest to our Russian companions, since their skins are one of the most important exports for Mongolia's fur traders. Mile after mile, they lined the path, entire colonies of them, some with a sought-after bluish tint by dealers, while most had a stunning gray-brown color that flashed in the bright sunshine as they hurried gopher-like to their holes with a cheeky flip of their bushy tails.
At length women and children, and not merely men, began to appear, riding on camels and horses; camps of hides and wool grew almost numerous; there were more settlements along the way, though all of them were still the round portable huts of the nomads. Great flocks of what looked like plovers swirled up; big brown birds that seemed a cross between hawk and vulture rode by on the wind; wild ducks were so tame and numerous as to have tantalized a hunter. We came out upon a rise with a magnificent view—the yellow foreground fading to brown as the world rolled away before us, then a purplish tint, increasing to a blue that grew ever darker, until the broken ridge along the horizon far ahead blended into the strip of clouds hanging motionless over it. Gradually mountains rose on every hand, the few scrub evergreens along the crests of some of them being the first trees or even brush we had seen since soon after leaving Kalgan. The cold wind that had cut clear through us for days seemed to come forth from the Siberian steppes beyond with renewed savage intensity. Before long the crest-line of trees became a low but dense green forest, covering all the upper portion of what we soon learned was the sacred mountain of Urga, where all furred and feathered creatures are under the protection of the “Living Buddha.” We entered ever deeper into a broad valley, Mongols in their long cloaks becoming more and more numerous, and more disagreeably sophisticated than the simple herdsmen with their long poles and noose-lassos out on the open plain. There the broad-cheeked nomads had been more friendly, had more manly dignity, than the Chinese; here the manliness remained, but there was something surly, almost savage about them, which we were quickly to learn was no mere matter of outward appearances. There came a small river, actually crossed by a bridge, a queer massive wooden bridge with what looked like piles of railway-ties as pillars; and on down the valley a town appeared, the towers of a radio-station rose from among the hills, a long row of barrack-like buildings of a European type grew distinct—and just then our troubles began.
At last, women and children, not just men, started showing up, riding on camels and horses. Camps made of hides and wool became quite common; more settlements popped up along the route, although they still consisted of the round portable huts used by nomads. Large flocks of what looked like plovers flew up; big brown birds that seemed to be a mix between a hawk and a vulture soared on the wind; wild ducks were so friendly and abundant that they tempted a hunter. We reached a rise with an amazing view—the yellow foreground faded to brown as the landscape stretched out before us, then transitioned to a purple hue, deepening to a dark blue, until the jagged ridge on the horizon merged with the strip of clouds hovering above it. Gradually, mountains appeared around us, with a few scrub evergreens at the peaks being the first trees or even bushes we had seen since shortly after leaving Kalgan. The cold wind that had chilled us for days seemed to come from the Siberian steppes beyond with a renewed fierce intensity. Soon, the line of trees transformed into a low but dense green forest, covering the upper part of what we would learn was the sacred mountain of Urga, where all furry and feathered creatures are protected by the “Living Buddha.” We ventured further into a broad valley, with more and more Mongols in their long cloaks appearing, and they were increasingly sophisticated in ways that were less pleasant compared to the simple herdsmen we had met on the open plains with their long poles and noose-lariats. There, the broad-cheeked nomads had been friendlier and had more dignity than the Chinese; here, while they still had that sense of manliness, there was something grumpy, almost fierce about them, which we would soon realize was more than just a superficial impression. A small river came into view, crossed by a peculiar massive wooden bridge that looked like it was supported by piles of railway ties; further down the valley, a town appeared, radio station towers rising among the hills, and a long row of barrack-like buildings of a European style came into focus—and just then, our troubles began.
CHAPTER VIII
In "Red" Mongolia
Across the broken valley at a gallop came two mounted men who turned out to be Mongol soldiers, picturesque certainly, but not otherwise particularly inviting. As they rode, they waved their rifles wildly in the air, and were apparently bellowing to us orders which the raging wind carried away before the sounds reached us. When they drew near, their uniforms proved to be the usual costume of the lower-class Mongol—heavy red knee-boots, pagoda-like fur hats, and a faded, quilted kind of bath-robe gown covering the rest of their iniquities; but on their chests and backs were sewed two cloth patches a foot square on which were several upright lines of Mongol writing, announcing their official capacity. But for these we might easily have mistaken them for bandits, for both their manner of riding down upon us and their air toward us when they had arrived suggested that they had captured booty and prisoners for ransom rather than that they had merely come to escort us to town.
Across the broken valley, two mounted men charged toward us. They turned out to be Mongol soldiers—visually striking, but not particularly welcoming. As they rode, they waved their rifles wildly in the air while seemingly shouting orders that the fierce wind blew away before we could hear them. When they got closer, their uniforms revealed the typical attire of lower-class Mongols—heavy red knee boots, pagoda-shaped fur hats, and a faded, quilted bathrobe-like gown covering most of their clothing. On their chests and backs were two cloth patches, each about a foot square, displaying several upright lines of Mongol writing that indicated their official status. Without those patches, we might have easily mistaken them for bandits, as both their approach and demeanor suggested they had come to claim loot and prisoners for ransom rather than to simply escort us to town.
One of them, it appeared from their actions, must get into the car with us; the other would have to ride in with the horses. Like children who very rarely have the chance of an automobile-ride, they quarreled and argued for a long time, while the biting wind snapped and lashed at us, as to which was entitled to the privilege, meanwhile flourishing their aged rifles with a carelessness that made even such time-honored weapons dangerous. At length one of them won the point and climbed unceremoniously aboard, mopping his muddy feet on our robes, stretching himself out at ease partly on our knees, partly on our most breakable baggage, and poking us, perhaps unintentionally but none the less unpleasantly, in the ribs with the business end of his loose-triggered rifle, while the loser sourly turned away with the horses and the expression of a six-year-old who had been deprived of his toys and driven from the playground.
One of them, based on their actions, had to get into the car with us; the other had to ride in with the horses. Like kids who rarely get the chance to ride in a car, they argued for a long time about who deserved the privilege, all while the chilly wind snapped at us, making the moment feel even more uncomfortable, as they waved their old rifles around carelessly, making those historic weapons seem dangerous. Finally, one of them succeeded in getting his way and hopped into the car without any ceremony, wiping his muddy feet on our blankets, lounging partly on our laps and partly on our most fragile bags, and poking us, maybe unintentionally but still annoyingly, in the ribs with the business end of his loosely triggered rifle, while the other one walked away with the horses, looking sour, like a six-year-old who had just been told he couldn’t play with his toys anymore.
We forded half a dozen stony little streams, for the going had become abominable in ratio as we approached Urga; we were waved 125hither and yon across the valley by other rifle-shaking, vainly shouting soldiers, and finally brought up at an ordinary little round felt hut with a smoking stovepipe protruding from its top. It must have been much more comfortable inside this than out in the bitter wind, for those within showed no haste in braving the outer temperature. Finally, however, two or three Mongols crawled through the low door and demanded our huchao, our Chinese permit to make the journey. There was an interminable argument over this, mainly inside the yourt, which we had not been invited to enter. Then two more bullying soldiers with poorly controlled rifles tumbled into the car and ordered us to drive on.
We crossed several rocky little streams, as the terrain got worse the closer we got to Urga. Soldiers waving rifles and shouting uselessly directed us across the valley until we finally arrived at a simple round felt hut with a smoking stovepipe sticking out of the top. It must have been much cozier inside than outside in the bitter wind, because those inside showed no rush to face the cold. Eventually, a couple of Mongols crawled through the low door and asked for our huchao, our Chinese permit to continue our journey. There was a long argument about this, mostly inside the yourt, which we weren’t invited to enter. Then, two more aggressive soldiers with unsteady rifles barged into the car and ordered us to move on.
Before a yamen that might have been mistaken either for a run-down temple or a well kept stable we were again halted and commanded to dismount. This place, it turned out, was not yet Urga, but the former Chinese merchant section of Mai-Mai-Ch’eng (“Buy-Sell-Town”) some miles away from the sacred city, in which trading was until recently forbidden. Here a veritable mob of soldiers and petty officials poured out upon us, led by an exceedingly insolent youth in a rich, silky, but much soiled light-blue gown topped off by a kind of archbishop’s miter. He demanded our weapons. We dug them and the bit of ammunition we carried out of our baggage, protesting in vain that as this was all to be examined at the next yamen, and armed guards were to conduct us there, this extra labor of disentangling our overloaded car was unnecessary. But it was plain that there were at least two motives for putting us to this gratuitous trouble: the insolent Mongol youth did not wish to lose an opportunity to show his authority to the full, particularly toward men of a race which seldom fell into his hands; and the whole posse was eager to meddle with our belongings as much as possible. They passed our revolvers and my companion’s rifle from hand to hand, each trying his own method of manipulating them. Fortunately—at the time we felt it was unfortunate—we had not loaded them, or several tragedies might have ensued before their curiosity was satisfied and we were allowed to conclude our journey. Then the overbearing youth in charge decided that he must search our persons for weapons, though we had given our word that we carried none. The implied insult would not have mattered so much had not his hands looked as if he had been handling Gobi fuel incessantly from childhood without a pause even to wipe them, and had his manner been less that of the protected bully venting an unaccountable spleen against the whole white race. But cleanliness and common courtesy, we soon 126learned, are the two qualities most foreign to the crowd now ruling Outer Mongolia.
Before a yamen that could easily be mistaken for either a dilapidated temple or a well-kept stable, we were once again stopped and told to get off our horses. It turned out this place wasn’t Urga yet, but the former Chinese merchant area of Mai-Mai-Ch’eng (“Buy-Sell-Town”), a few miles away from the sacred city, where trading had only recently been allowed. A real crowd of soldiers and petty officials rushed out to meet us, led by a very arrogant young man wearing a rich, silky, but dirty light-blue gown topped with a sort of archbishop’s miter. He demanded to see our weapons. We pulled them out along with the small amount of ammunition we had in our bags, protesting in vain that since everything was to be checked at the next yamen and armed guards were supposed to take us there, this extra hassle of unloading our already heavy bags was unnecessary. But it was clear there were at least two reasons for this pointless trouble: the cocky Mongol youth wanted to fully assert his authority, especially over men of a race he rarely encountered, and the whole group was eager to pry into our stuff as much as possible. They passed our revolvers and my companion’s rifle around, each trying out his own way of handling them. Thankfully—at the time it seemed unfortunate—we hadn’t loaded them, or several mishaps could have happened before their curiosity was satisfied and we were allowed to continue our journey. Then the overbearing youth in charge decided he needed to search us for weapons, even though we had promised we had none. The implied insult wouldn’t have bothered us as much if his hands hadn’t looked like he had been handling Gobi fuel nonstop since childhood, without even stopping to clean them, and if his manner hadn’t felt like that of a sheltered bully taking out some unexplainable frustration on the entire white race. But we soon learned that cleanliness and common courtesy are the two qualities most absent from the crowd now in control of Outer Mongolia.
The quarrel as to who should have the privilege of the automobile-ride into Urga was at length decided in favor of all who could pile themselves into and about the car and baggage. How the machine escaped a broken back under the burden was a mystery which even Detroit probably could not have explained. Then there came a delay while the blue-gowned youth found and adjusted a fanciful pair of goggles, in all likelihood filched from the baggage of some previous victim, and without which of course the two- or three-mile ride ahead would have been unendurable. We groaned away at last, rifles and our own weapons covering us on every side, first through a half-ruined town of mud alleys between endless palisades of upright logs of the pine family, then across a stony, barren, wind-swept space with several axle-cracking little streams to be forded. Between bumps we caught glimpses of the several distinctly isolated sections of Urga, its golden temples and black dogs, its one lofty building, and the Tibetan texts in stone on the flank of its sacred mountain across the valley. Then we were suddenly turned into a noisome back yard peopled with shoddy-clad and unwashed soldiers and prisoners, the latter engaged in worse than menial tasks under the bayonet-points of the former; the gate to the outside world was closed and barred, and a new set of examiners fell upon us.
The argument over who would get the chance to ride in the car into Urga was finally settled in favor of everyone who could cram themselves into and around the vehicle and luggage. How the car managed not to break under the weight was a mystery that even experts in Detroit might not have figured out. Then there was a delay as the young guy in the blue outfit searched for and put on a fancy pair of goggles, probably stolen from someone else’s luggage, which made the two- or three-mile ride ahead bearable. Eventually, we creaked away, rifles and our own weapons surrounding us, first through a rundown town with mud alleys bordered by endless walls of standing pine logs, and then across a rocky, barren, wind-swept stretch with several bumpy little streams to cross. Between the jolts, we caught glimpses of the distinct sections of Urga, its golden temples and black dogs, its one tall building, and the Tibetan inscriptions carved into the hillside of its sacred mountain across the valley. Suddenly, we were diverted into a foul-smelling backyard filled with poorly dressed, unwashed soldiers and prisoners, the latter doing more than just menial tasks under the threat of the former's bayonets; the gate to the outside world was shut and locked, and a new group of inspectors came to examine us.
If a gang of young East Side New York rowdies should suddenly get the complete upper hand in the city, I can imagine them going through the belongings of their victims along Fifth Avenue in quite the same way as now befell our own. At a word from a superior who would himself scarcely have inspired a lone lady with confidence on a dark night, there sprang forward from all sides a dozen young men who seemed to have been specially chosen for their gangster-like appearance. In their shoddy uniforms of some nondescript dark color, they looked like a cross between low-class Russians and the scum of the Mongolian plains—which is about what they were, in other words Buriats. The pleasure they took both in putting us to annoyance and in prying minutely into our affairs quite evidently purged their task of any stigma of labor. I have passed many frontiers in my day, but never have I beheld an examination in the slightest degree approaching in thoroughness this one. Every single article, large or small, in our valises, bedding-bags, even our lunch-sacks, was picked out one by one, carefully, 127not to say stupidly, scrutinized, taken apart if that was physically possible, and finally tossed into a heap on the filthy bare ground of the yard. Clean linen must be completely unfolded, stared at minutely on both sides, and crumpled up into a mess from which only a laundryman could rescue it. We were not surprised that such articles aroused the suspicion of the examiners; anything resembling clean linen was quite evidently strange to them. Nor was there any intentional offense meant, perhaps, in mixing our bread and our tooth-brushes with the offal in the yard, for no conscious line of demarcation between these seemed as yet to have been drawn in the minds of the examiners. They did consciously resent our own higher plane of cleanliness, however, when it was called to their attention. I was attempting to rescue my dismembered sleeping-bag from a worse fate by picking it up from the ground where it had been thrown after examination, when one of the rowdies snatched it out of my hand and deliberately tossed it into an especially choice source of contamination.
If a group of young troublemakers from the East Side of New York suddenly took control of the city, I can picture them rummaging through their victims' belongings along Fifth Avenue just like what happened to us. At a command from a leader who wouldn’t have inspired much confidence in a lone woman on a dark night, a dozen young guys rushed in from all directions, seemingly chosen for their tough-guy looks. Dressed in cheap uniforms of some vague dark color, they resembled a mix of low-class Russians and the worst types from the Mongolian plains—which is basically what they were, specifically Buriats. The enjoyment they got from annoying us and poking into our stuff clearly made their job feel more like fun than work. I've crossed many borders, but I've never seen an inspection as thorough as this one. Every single item, big or small, in our suitcases, bedding bags, even our lunch bags, was pulled out one by one, closely examined, taken apart if that was possible, and finally tossed into a pile on the filthy ground of the yard. Clean linens were completely unfolded, scrutinized from both sides, and crumpled into a mess that only a laundryman could fix. We weren’t surprised that these items piqued the examiners' suspicion; anything resembling clean linen was clearly unfamiliar to them. There wasn’t any deliberate offense meant, perhaps, in mixing our bread and toothbrushes with the trash in the yard, as no clear line between these items seemed to exist in the minds of the examiners. However, they did seem to resent our higher standard of cleanliness when it was pointed out. I was trying to save my torn sleeping bag from a worse fate by picking it up from the ground where it had been thrown after inspection when one of the thugs snatched it from my hand and deliberately threw it into a particularly nasty spot.
My shaving-stick was opened with extreme caution, as a possible infernal machine. My safety-razor caused a considerable argument, until a gang-chief ruled that it was not a deadly weapon. The man who picked up an ordinary can of pork-and-beans tore off the label and attempted to unscrew the top in his efforts to examine the contents, and was with difficulty induced to spare me the labor of attacking it with a can-opener. I rescued my exposed films just as they were about to be unrolled, and came very near bodily injury for my interference before our interpreter could get in touch with some one of authority and more or less human intelligence. Thus it went, for more than an hour, through every simplest article we had brought with us. Nor did a single examination of each suffice; whenever anything unusual turned up, which, thanks to the ignorance of the examiners, was often, all of them must satisfy their monkey-like curiosity by thoroughly studying it. It was not that we objected to having our baggage inspected, even with unusual thoroughness—though legally we Americans were not subject to any interference by the local authorities of Mongolia—but at least it would have been a kindness to give the job to men who had some inkling of the paraphernalia of civilization and some hazy notion of why tooth-brushes and offal are not commonly mixed.
My shaving stick was opened with extreme caution, like a potential explosive. My safety razor sparked a big debate until a gang leader decided it wasn't a deadly weapon. The guy who grabbed a regular can of pork and beans ripped off the label and tried to unscrew the top in an effort to see what was inside, and it took a lot to convince him to let me use a can opener instead. I saved my exposed film just as they were about to be unrolled and nearly got hurt for stepping in before our interpreter could reach someone in charge who had a bit of common sense. This went on for more than an hour with every single item we brought. And one check wasn’t enough; whenever something unusual appeared, which happened quite often due to the examiners' ignorance, they all had to satisfy their childish curiosity by examining it closely. It wasn’t that we minded having our luggage checked, even with extra scrutiny—though legally, as Americans, we shouldn’t have been under the local authorities’ interference in Mongolia—but it would have been nice to have this done by people who had some understanding of civilized items and a vague idea of why toothbrushes and trash shouldn’t be mixed.
In the end they kept our weapons and cartridges, our American passports, and all our papers, down to letters of introduction and scribbled memoranda, which had not escaped their erratic attention. They demanded that the tool-box be removed from the car and the spare tire 128opened, as possible hiding-places. That these were the only ones they thought of was due to their ignorance of automobile mechanism. The Russian Jews had more influence than we, however, and after long and vociferous wrangling this order was rescinded. In contrast to the deliberation with which they had been examining it, they insisted that we snatch together our heaped-up property and thrust it pell-mell, filth and all, back into our bags and valises. Long blanks must then be filled out, in Russian, with our personal biographies. These went to an inner office, while we still shivered like hopper-screens in the wintry air outside; and at length a man came out to announce that they must also keep my kodak and films. This required a complete reëxamination of all my baggage, for my word as to the number of films I carried could not of course be trusted. Finally we were taken into the sanctum of the Okhrana or the Ghospolitakran, as it is variously called in popular parlance—the “State’s Internal Guard” would perhaps answer as a poor and inadequate translation in English. This is a genuinely Russian form of secret service and espionage within the country, devised under the czarist régime and continued by its receivers, the Bolsheviki, who had recently imposed it upon Mongolia. The plain bare room of European style contained a rough table and a few chairs, a surly Mongol nearer twenty than thirty, in native garb except for a faded slouch felt hat, who proved to be the ostensible head of the secret service, and an older Russian “adviser” in grayish semi-uniform and quite modern glasses. The “adviser” looked as if he had been familiar with the common forms of courtesy in earlier days, but evidently he had either forgotten them or dared not mix them with his “Red” allegiance, for his behavior was as studiously uncivil as that of the Mongol was naturally rude. We had stood for a long time, with empty chairs plentiful, when the pair deigned to notice our existence. A handsome, courteous little Buriat, greatly contrasting with the rest of the crew, explained our cases at length, with special emphasis on the seizure of my kodak. Uncouth soldiers, Mongol, Buriat, and Russian indiscriminately, lounged in and out, most of them carelessly juggling guns with fixed bayonets, glaring ominously at us from time to time, and picking up and examining any of the official papers on the table which happened to catch their fancy. It is said that there are no ranks in the “Red” army; certainly there was no outward evidence of discipline among the detachment of it in Urga, or among their apt Mongol pupils.
In the end, they kept our weapons and cartridges, our American passports, and all our documents, including letters of introduction and random notes, which had caught their erratic attention. They insisted that the toolbox be taken out of the car and that the spare tire be opened, suspecting them as possible hiding spots. The fact that these were the only places they considered was due to their lack of knowledge about car mechanics. However, the Russian Jews had more influence than we did, and after a long and loud argument, this demand was canceled. In stark contrast to the careful way they had been examining things, they ordered us to quickly gather our scattered belongings and cram them back into our bags and suitcases, mess and all. We then had to fill out long forms in Russian detailing our personal histories. These were sent to an inner office while we stood outside, shivering in the cold air like nervous rabbits; eventually, a man came out to say they also needed to keep my Kodak camera and films. This required a complete re-examination of all my luggage, since I couldn’t be trusted to accurately report the number of films I had. Finally, we were brought into the office of the Okhrana or the Ghospolitakran, as it’s commonly referred to in popular terms—the “State’s Internal Guard” might be a poor and inadequate translation in English. This is a truly Russian form of secret service and espionage within the country, originally developed under the czarist regime and continued by its successors, the Bolsheviks, who had recently implemented it in Mongolia. The plain, bare room had a rough table and a few chairs, occupied by a surly Mongolian man who looked closer to thirty than twenty, dressed in traditional attire except for a worn slouch hat, who turned out to be the nominal head of the secret service, along with an older Russian “adviser” in a grayish semi-uniform and modern glasses. The “adviser” seemed like he used to know proper manners, but clearly he had either forgotten them or didn't want to mix them with his “Red” allegiance, because his behavior was as purposely rude as the Mongolian's was naturally impolite. We stood there for a long time, with plenty of empty chairs around, before they finally acknowledged our presence. A charming, polite Buriat, who stood out from the rest of the group, explained our situation in detail, especially focusing on the confiscation of my Kodak. Clumsy soldiers, Mongolian, Buriat, and Russian alike, wandered in and out, most carelessly handling guns with fixed bayonets, occasionally glaring at us and examining any official papers on the table that caught their interest. It’s said that there are no ranks in the “Red” army; certainly, there was no visible sign of discipline among this unit in Urga or among their eager Mongolian recruits.

The frontier post of Ude, fifty miles beyond the uninhabited frontier between Inner and Outer Mongolia, where Mongol authorities examine passports and very often turn travelers back
The Ude frontier post, located fifty miles past the deserted border between Inner and Outer Mongolia, is where Mongol authorities check passports and frequently deny entry to travelers.

Chinese travelers on their way to Urga; it is unbelievable how many muffled Chinamen and their multifarious junk one Dodge will carry
Chinese travelers on their way to Urga; it's hard to believe how many bundled-up Chinese people and their various belongings one Dodge can carry.

The Mongol of the Gobi lives in a yourt made of heavy felt over a light wooden framework, which can be taken down and packed in less than an hour when the spirit of the nomad strikes him
The Mongol of the Gobi lives in a yurt made of thick felt over a lightweight wooden frame, which can be taken down and packed away in under an hour when the nomadic spirit moves him.

Mongol women make the felt used as houses, mainly by pouring water on sheep’s wool
Mongol women make the felt used for homes by pouring water on sheep’s wool.
129A receipt, in Russian, was finally given us for our confiscated belongings, and about four in the afternoon, ten hours since we had eaten and five after our arrival, we were at last allowed to drag our shivering frames away in quest of lodging. There are no hotels in Urga, and visitors must appeal to the hospitality of one or another of the stray Europeans living there, of whom, excepting of course the numerous Russians, there seemed to be a single sample of each nationality. I was just sitting down to a belated lunch in the home of Norway’s handsome contribution to this international group when a red-clothed native of the better class dropped in, hat and all. He was a young man of unusual attainments for Mongolia, it seemed, educated at the University of Irkutsk, speaking Russian perfectly, and famous as the only Mongol known who spoke English. In the last accomplishment, however, he had not advanced beyond the bashful stage, and consented to display it only when there was no one to interpret his Russian or his Mongol. He was attached to the foreign office, though soon to leave for Moscow as a member of the Communist Congress there; and he had come, mainly out of personal friendship for my host, to warn me of trouble ahead. A telegram, he told the Norwegian in Russian, had just been received from a station out on the Gobi, announcing that two Americans in a motor-car carrying four persons had killed a Mongol on their way to Urga. He had no intention of making unkindly insinuations against me or my companion, he said, but we were the only Americans who had arrived within a fortnight, the only foreigners who had come within a week, and ours was the only car that had reached Urga for two or three days, as well as the only one in a long time with only four occupants. Moreover, we had carried arms.
129A receipt, in Russian, was finally given to us for our confiscated belongings, and around 4 PM, ten hours after we had eaten and five hours after our arrival, we were finally allowed to drag our shivering selves away in search of a place to stay. There are no hotels in Urga, so visitors have to rely on the hospitality of one or another of the few Europeans living there. Aside from the many Russians, there seemed to be only one representative of each nationality. I was just sitting down to a late lunch in the home of Norway’s attractive addition to this international group when a well-dressed native wandered in, hat and all. He was a young man of impressive accomplishments for Mongolia, it seemed, educated at the University of Irkutsk, speaking perfect Russian, and known as the only Mongol who spoke English. However, he hadn't progressed beyond the shy stage in that skill and agreed to show it off only when there was no one around to translate his Russian or Mongolian. He worked in the foreign office but was about to leave for Moscow as a delegate to the Communist Congress there; he had come, mainly out of personal friendship for my host, to warn me about trouble ahead. A telegram, he told the Norwegian in Russian, had just been received from a station out on the Gobi, announcing that two Americans in a motor car carrying four people had killed a Mongol on their way to Urga. He had no intention of making negative inferences about me or my companion, he said, but we were the only Americans who had arrived in the last two weeks, the only foreigners who had come in a week, and ours was the only car that had reached Urga in the last two or three days, as well as the only one in a long time with only four passengers. Additionally, we had carried weapons.
Absurd as the covert charge was—for our revolvers had lain unloaded in our baggage throughout the trip—it was not wholly a laughing matter. My compatriot had frequently fired his rifle at antelope along the way, and there was a very slight possibility that a bullet had carried too far. But worse almost than any question of guilt or innocence was the possibility of becoming entangled in the intricacies of a Mongol court of justice. Its point of view would be quite unlike that of our Western judiciary; certainly haste would not be one of its attributes. All at once the rights of extraterritoriality, to which I was legally entitled in Urga even though forcibly deprived of them, seemed no mere forced concession but the only way of being fairly judged in such a predicament in a land and society so utterly alien to my own. Within an hour or so, the Mongol thought, they would come to arrest us, and 130though he spoke optimistically of the final outcome, he could not recommend even four or five days in prison as a pleasant week-end. I had already heard something of Urga’s place of detention, the earth cellar of the Okhrana where we had been examined, in which a score of Russians and as many Mongols were even then huddled together, without a suggestion of daylight, beds, blankets, human conveniences, or anything that could honestly be called food, with nothing but the cold, damp ground to lie on and a scanty bit of garbage to eat and drink. Judging by the cavalier manner in which we had been treated as unaccused and ostensibly free beings, it was not hard to imagine what those rowdy soldiers about the place would do to us as prisoners. I did all possible justice to the lunch before me, for at least if we were to join the community in the icy cellar I wished to be partly filled up and thawed out before beginning the experience.
Absurd as the hidden charge was—for our guns had stayed unloaded in our bags the whole trip—it wasn't completely a joke. My companion had often shot his rifle at antelope along the way, and there was a slight chance that a bullet might have gone too far. But worse than any question of guilt or innocence was the possibility of getting caught up in the complexities of a Mongol court system. Their perspective would be very different from ours in the West; for sure, quick action wouldn’t be one of its qualities. Suddenly, the rights of extraterritoriality, which I was entitled to in Urga even though they were being forcibly ignored, didn’t feel like a mere forced concession but rather the only way to be judged fairly in such a situation in a culture so completely foreign to mine. Within about an hour, the Mongols would come to arrest us, and while he spoke positively about the final outcome, he couldn’t recommend even four or five days in prison as a nice weekend. I had already heard a bit about Urga’s detention center, the earth cellar of the Okhrana where we had been interrogated, where a bunch of Russians and just as many Mongols were already crammed together, with no hint of daylight, beds, blankets, basic hygiene, or anything resembling food, just the cold, damp ground to lie on and some scraps of garbage to eat and drink. Considering the casual way we had been treated as uncharged and seemingly free people, it wasn’t hard to picture what those rough soldiers nearby would do to us as prisoners. I made sure to enjoy the lunch in front of me because if we were going to join the group in the freezing cellar, I wanted to be at least partly full and warmed up before starting that experience.
A hasty council was convened of the few Americans—all visitors—and the more Western Europeans in town. The seriousness with which these treated the situation was anything but reassuring. Their patent distrust and unexpressed dread of the sinister powers then ruling Urga recalled stories of the terror that filled men’s lives in the worst days of the French Revolution. It was plain that it was not a mere matter of proving our innocence, if the authorities chose to make this a “frame-up” to be rid of unwelcome visitors. In the end it was decided that the best plan would be to forestall the authorities, to go at once to the minister of justice before some of his less intelligent underlings received and carried out the warrant for our arrest.
A quick meeting was called with the few Americans—mostly visitors—and the Western Europeans in town. The seriousness with which they approached the situation was anything but reassuring. Their obvious distrust and unspoken fear of the dark forces currently in control of Urga brought back memories of the terror that haunted people's lives during the worst days of the French Revolution. It was clear that it wasn't just a matter of proving our innocence if the authorities decided to set us up to get rid of unwanted visitors. Ultimately, it was agreed that the best plan would be to take initiative and go directly to the minister of justice before some of his less capable subordinates acted on the warrant for our arrest.
We reached him indirectly through his adviser, who was fortunately a friend of my host. In the late afternoon light of his wholly European study this polished and intelligent man in our ordinary garb looked entirely like a Russian; it was not until next day that his more swarthy tint and the quilted silk robe he wore to office showed him to be a Buriat. He admitted that the telegram in question had been received, and that the warrants would probably be ready within an hour or two—and no doubt served, I reflected, in this leisurely moving world, just in time to drag us out of our beds in the middle of the cold night. But as I had taken the trouble to come and show myself, the Buriat went on, and to explain my movements to his personal satisfaction, he would suppress the warrants for the time being, if all four of us would appear at the yamen of justice, with an efficient interpreter, in the morning.
We got in touch with him indirectly through his adviser, who luckily was a friend of my host. In the late afternoon light of his completely European study, this polished and intelligent man in our casual clothes looked just like a Russian; it wasn't until the next day that his darker complexion and the quilted silk robe he wore to the office revealed that he was a Buriat. He confirmed that the telegram had been received, and that the warrants would probably be ready within an hour or two—and I thought, in this slow-moving world, just in time to drag us out of our beds in the middle of the cold night. However, since I had taken the effort to come and present myself, the Buriat continued, and to clarify my actions to his personal satisfaction, he would hold off on issuing the warrants for now, as long as all four of us showed up at the yamen of justice with a good interpreter in the morning.
For all the absurdity of the whole affair there was a sense of relief 131in having gained at least a respite, and before dinner was over I had almost forgotten the matter. But when I woke once during that otherwise deathly still Urga night, the howling of two or three of her man-eating dogs had a curiously ominous, almost terrorizing, sound. Only a fortnight before, fifteen men, a former prime minister among them, had been shot in a near-by gully and their bodies fed to these dogs, in the cheery Urga fashion. Those had been Mongols, to be sure, but a score of Russians were even then shivering out the night in the cellar-prison, charged with a hand in the same conspiracy, and from thinking of shooting Russians for treason to actually shooting a stray Caucasian of another nationality for some other alleged crime would be no impossible leap for these “Red”-led, self-satisfied nomads. I had to remind myself several times what a fool I was before I turned over and fell asleep again.
For all the craziness of the whole situation, there was a feeling of relief in having gotten at least a break, and by the time dinner ended, I had nearly forgotten about it. But when I woke up once during that otherwise silent Urga night, the howling of two or three of her man-eating dogs had a strangely eerie, almost terrifying sound. Just two weeks before, fifteen men, including a former prime minister, had been shot in a nearby gully and their bodies fed to these dogs, in the typical Urga style. Those men had been Mongols, sure, but a group of Russians were still shivering through the night in the cellar-prison, accused of being part of the same plot. The jump from thinking about shooting Russians for treason to actually shooting a random Caucasian for some other supposed crime wouldn’t be a big leap for these self-satisfied, Red-led nomads. I had to remind myself several times what an idiot I was before I turned over and fell asleep again.
Few things are ever as serious the next morning as when they happened the night before, and I could laugh at my midnight anxieties when I sat down to breakfast. It took some time to get our scattered party together, and a suitable interpreter was not easily picked up, so that it was nearer eleven than ten by the time we found a Russian speaking both English and Mongol and set out for the yamen. But we need not have let a little thing like that worry us. Promptness is neither customary nor welcome in Mongolia; moreover, there are no two timepieces in anything like agreement in all Urga, so that an hour or two one way or the other can always be excused, in the unlikely event of any excuse being expected, on the ground of incompatibility of clocks. What does an hour mean, anyway, in a land where time is merely a vacuum? An American who was just then flirting with the Mongolian Government for an important concession made an appointment with the minister of foreign affairs for ten one morning, and was there on the dot. When he had waited an hour and a half he beckoned to a sub-official and asked whether the minister would be unable to see him that morning, in which case he had other matters requiring his attention.
Few things feel as serious the next morning as they did the night before, and I could laugh at my midnight worries when I sat down for breakfast. It took some time to gather our scattered group, and finding a suitable interpreter wasn’t easy, so it was closer to eleven than ten by the time we located a Russian who spoke both English and Mongolian and set out for the yamen. But we didn’t need to let a minor detail like that stress us out. Being on time isn’t either common or appreciated in Mongolia; besides, there are no two clocks in all of Urga that are even close to being synchronized, so an hour or two one way or the other can always be overlooked, if anyone were to expect an excuse, based on the differing clocks. What does an hour even mean in a place where time just feels like a void? An American who was then trying to negotiate an important concession with the Mongolian government made an appointment with the minister of foreign affairs for ten one morning and arrived right on time. After waiting for an hour and a half, he signaled to a subordinate official and asked whether the minister would be unable to see him that morning, in which case he had other matters to attend to.
“Oh, yes,” replied the functionary, “he will see you; but it is not yet ten o’clock.”
“Oh, yes,” replied the official, “he will see you; but it’s not yet ten o’clock.”
However, to come back to our own affairs; we made our way across the stony, dusty, wind-howling open space between the business and the official sections of the holy city in time to avoid any risk of being charged with tardiness. The yamen of justice was a two-story frame building mainly in European style, built by the Chinese when 132they held the suzerainty over Outer Mongolia, as the flaring roofs, sky-blue façade, dragon-decorated brick screen against evil spirits, palings of crossed sticks to the number of outriders due the prince who once occupied it, and the like, told us without any necessity of inquiring. Two typical Mongol soldiers, resembling Oriental rag dolls that had lain out in the garden for weeks and then been lost for a few days in the coal-bin, lumbered to their booted feet from a fantastic sentry-box in order, as is the habit of their class nowadays, to impress us with their equality and authority by gratuitously delaying us for a few moments, and at last we reached our destination. This was one of the barn-like rooms of the unpretentious building. Near the door rose to the ceiling a big cylindrical Russian brick stove. Around the other three sides of the room ran a raised platform, knee-high and a man’s height in breadth. The reed matting and cushions covering it recalled Japan, but there was nothing Japanese in the way in which the dozen officials stepped upon it from the unswept floor in their heavy boots, all more or less covered with the filth of the streets, and calmly tramped about it or squatted on their haunches. All these functionaries were dressed in Mongol fashion; that is, in long robes of dull red, blue, green, purple, violet, or similar conspicuous color, half obliterated with grease and dirt, topped off with some one of their many fantastic national head-dresses. The latter were never removed, nor were we foreigners expected to take off our hats. In fact there seem to be no social politenesses among this rude nomad people. They neither shake hands, unless they are meeting or aping foreigners, nor bow, like the Chinese, nor use any other gestures of greeting or parting; they stalk into foreigners’ houses in hats and boots; their whole conduct is as if none of the little courtesies and formalities of more highly civilized communities had ever occurred to them, which is probably the case.
However, to get back to our own matters; we made our way across the rocky, dusty, wind-blown space between the business and official areas of the holy city just in time to avoid being seen as late. The yamen of justice was a two-story wooden building mostly in European style, built by the Chinese when they had control over Outer Mongolia, as the pointed roofs, bright blue façade, dragon-adorned brick screen meant to ward off evil spirits, and the crossed sticks marking the number of outriders due to the prince who once occupied it clearly indicated without needing to ask. Two typical Mongol soldiers, looking like worn-out dolls that had been left outside for weeks and then misplaced in a coal bin, awkwardly got to their feet from a strange sentry booth in order to, as is their habit today, try to impress us with their authority by unnecessarily holding us up for a few moments. Eventually, we reached our destination. It was one of the barn-like rooms of this simple building. Near the door was a tall cylindrical Russian brick stove that reached the ceiling. Surrounding the other three sides of the room was a raised platform, knee-high and man-width. The reed matting and cushions on it reminded us of Japan, but the way the dozen officials stepped onto it from the dirty floor in their heavy boots, all caked with street grime, was anything but Japanese; they just stomped around it or squatted down. All these officials were dressed in traditional Mongol attire—long robes in dull red, blue, green, purple, violet, or other bright colors, mostly covered in grease and dirt, topped with their various elaborate national headpieces. They never removed their hats, and we foreigners weren’t expected to take ours off either. In fact, it seemed there were no social niceties among this rough nomadic people. They didn’t shake hands, unless they were mimicking foreigners, nor did they bow like the Chinese, or use any other gestures of greeting or farewell; they just walked into foreigners’ homes wearing their hats and boots; their entire behavior suggested that none of the small courtesies and formalities of more developed societies had ever come to their minds, which is probably true.
The place had electric lights, and from one of the walls hung an ancient European type of telephone, which was frequently jangling or enduring the shrieks of one or another bureaucrat, but which never seemed to bring or transmit any information. Most of the functionaries, big sturdy men who would have looked more at home herding cattle on the plains, squatted near little tables or desks, a foot high, some smoking long pipes with tiny bowls and much silver decoration, others rocking idly back and forth, while their greasy pigtails, swaying to and fro, increased the soiled line they had already drawn down the backs of their gowns. A few were working; that is, writing in their national script, so different from Chinese, on long strips of cheap 133tissue-paper folded lengthwise and opening like an accordion. Their pens were the camel’s-hair brushes common to the Far East, however, of which each man carried two in a silver scabbard hanging from his girdle; their ink was taken from a little flat stone on which they rubbed their pens sidewise, and their writing-desks were thin squares of board held on their left hands. A big dinner-bell in a corner of the room served to call attendants, or to summon prisoners for the next case to be tried. For justice was being dispensed, leisurely but steadily, all the time we were there. In the center of the raised platform, opposite the door and in the chief place of honor, squatted an imposing man who might easily have been taken for an unusually burly Chinaman, in his darker gown, his mandarin cap with a colored button, his oily cue, and his rimless ear-piece glasses. He was fat, and he was fully aware of his own importance in the Mongolian scheme of things. From time to time a group of prisoners was brought in by one of the coal-bin soldiers, always armed with a fixed bayonet. The accused, all ragged, shivering, and visibly hungry, looking as if they had been living for weeks in an underground dungeon and had been periodically beaten half to death, were forced to kneel on the bare floor and bow their heads down to it several times as an obeisance to the haughty judge. If they failed to do so promptly, they were prodded or thumped to their knees by the soldier. The trial consisted merely of the judge’s questioning the cringing prisoner, during which his honor smoked, stretched himself, and spat copiously on the floor in front of the kneeling culprits. When he was done, he growled out something which may or may not have been a sentence, and the prisoners were led away again. Of the score or more tried while we were there none was released.
The place had electric lights, and from one of the walls hung an old European-style telephone, which was constantly ringing or enduring the shouts of various bureaucrats, but it never seemed to provide any real information. Most of the officials, big sturdy men who looked like they’d be more comfortable herding cattle on the plains, squatted near small tables or desks about a foot high. Some smoked long pipes with tiny bowls and lots of silver decoration, while others rocked back and forth idly, their greasy pigtails swaying back and forth, adding to the dirty line they had already drawn down the backs of their gowns. A few were working; that is, writing in their national script, which looked nothing like Chinese, on long strips of cheap tissue paper folded like an accordion. They used camel’s-hair brushes, common in the Far East, and each man carried two in a silver scabbard hanging from his belt. Their ink was made by rubbing their brushes against a flat stone, and their writing-desk was a thin square of wood held in their left hands. A big dinner bell in the corner of the room was used to call attendants or summon prisoners for the next case to be tried. Justice was being handed out, slowly but steadily, the entire time we were there. In the center of the raised platform, facing the door and in the most honored position, sat an imposing man who could easily have been mistaken for an unusually burly Chinese man, wearing his dark gown, mandarin cap with a colored button, oily cue, and rimless glasses. He was fat and fully aware of his own importance in the Mongolian scheme of things. Every so often, a group of prisoners was brought in by one of the coal-bin soldiers, always armed with a fixed bayonet. The accused, all ragged, shivering, and clearly hungry, looked as if they had been living in an underground dungeon for weeks and had been beaten half to death periodically. They were forced to kneel on the bare floor and bow their heads down to it several times as a gesture of respect to the haughty judge. If they didn’t do this quickly enough, the soldier would shove or hit them to make them kneel. The trial was just the judge questioning the terrified prisoner, during which he smoked, stretched himself, and spat a lot on the floor in front of the kneeling defendants. When he was done, he growled something that might have been a sentence, and then the prisoners were led away again. Out of the twenty or more who were tried while we were there, none were released.
Meanwhile other business, such as our own, went serenely on along the side platforms. Some of the scribes or officials wrote on their little boards, some asked questions of an official nature, more chatted and smoked as freely as if they were in a café. Curious individuals dropped in now and then. There was, for instance, a little dried-up Jew with long straggly red whiskers, and a furtive look in his eyes, as if he had been the last survivor of a dozen pogroms. For more than an hour he sat inconspicuously in a corner near the door, holding his aged slouch-hat in his hands, ignored by the contemptuous Mongols, lacking the courage to address them on whatever matter had brought him.
Meanwhile, other businesses, like ours, continued smoothly on the side platforms. Some of the clerks or officials wrote on their small boards, some asked questions of an official nature, while others chatted and smoked as casually as if they were in a café. Curious people dropped by now and then. For example, there was a small, dried-up Jewish man with long, messy red whiskers and a sneakily suspicious look in his eyes, as if he had been the last survivor of many attacks. For over an hour, he sat quietly in a corner near the door, holding his old slouch hat in his hands, ignored by the disdainful Mongols, lacking the courage to speak to them about whatever had brought him there.
Our own case moved as we would have had it, except in speed. When testimony must be written down in Mongol script with a camel’s-hair 134brush on the poorest of paper and the least convenient of desks by an official whose chief code of conduct is never to let any one or anything hurry him under any circumstances, even a simple affair is not quickly disposed of. There was a long argument as to how to turn our extraordinary names into the native hieroglyphics; there were other lengthy discussions during which I found ample time to study not only the scene within the room but the big felt tent of fanciful decoration with a mat-cloth door, in which the minister of justice lived out in the back yard, a true Mongol nomad still, like many of his highly placed fellows. The whole case should really have collapsed like a house of cards, for another telegram had arrived which not merely reduced the crime from the killing of a Mongol man to slightly wounding a Mongol boy in the wrist, but showed that, by the records of our stopping-places, we were at least a day’s travel away at the time; furthermore, the deed had been done at short range with a revolver—on that point the information was insistent—and the most cursory examination of our pistols, in the hands of the secret service department, would have demonstrated that they had not been fired on the way. In fact, it looked rather doubtful whether even the slight crime alleged had been committed; perhaps it was some boyish tale made up to gain sympathy for a scratched wrist. Officially “the incident was closed” almost before we reached the yamen; but that did not hinder us from being three hours there, nor did it make it possible to have the thing written up in its legal form and “deposited in the archives” forty-eight hours later, when the clearing of our reputations was essential to the making of certain other requests with which we were forced to trouble the authorities.
Our case unfolded as we expected, except for the pace. When testimonies had to be written in Mongol script with a camel hair brush on the worst paper at the most awkward desks, by an official whose primary rule was never to let anyone or anything rush him, even a simple matter took ages to resolve. There was a lengthy debate about how to translate our unusual names into the local script; during that time, I had plenty of opportunities to observe not just the room but also the large felt tent decorated in a fanciful style, with a mat cloth door, where the minister of justice, a true Mongol nomad like many of his high-ranking peers, lived in the backyard. The entire case should have crumbled like a house of cards, as another telegram had just arrived, reducing the alleged crime from killing a Mongol man to merely wounding a Mongol boy in the wrist. It also indicated that, according to our travel records, we were at least a day’s journey away at the time; moreover, the crime had supposedly happened at close range with a revolver—this detail was emphasized. A quick examination of our pistols by the secret service would have shown they had not been used during our trip. In fact, it seemed questionable whether even the minor crime alleged had occurred at all; perhaps it was just a boyish story created to elicit sympathy for a scratched wrist. Officially, “the incident was closed” almost before we got to the yamen; however, this didn’t prevent us from spending three hours there, nor did it make it possible to have everything documented in its legal form and “filed in the archives” two days later, when clearing our names was crucial for making several other requests we needed to bring to the authorities.
CHAPTER IX
HOLY URGA
The holy city of Urga squats out on what would be an ordinary Mongolian plain were it not for the rows of hills or low mountains which roll up on either side of it. The landscape is the same yellow-brown, smooth as the fur of the fox, the city, its wide shallow valley, and the rolling hills on the right hand are as utterly devoid of trees or even a suggestion of brush, as the Gobi. Only along the edge, and covering the upper portion, of the range to the west and south, sacred to the “Living Buddha” whose two palace compounds sit at the foot of it, is there any vegetation except the thin brown grass of mountain heights. The soil does not welcome it, for one thing. Even the forests capping the long low sacred mountain, though planted centuries ago and strictly protected, while dense enough, have attained little more than scrub growth. About forty-five hundred feet above the sea and no great distance from the Siberian border, Urga is no tropical haven. They tell me that in summer its middays are sometimes uncomfortably hot; but though it was only the middle of September when we arrived, all the clothing we had brought with us was none too much to shut out the penetrating mountain cold. Five days before, Peking had been sweltering; here the entire population wore heavy quilted garments, from which hardly a bare foot peered among the most poverty-stricken even on the days when a brilliant sun in a glass-clear sky made delightful autumn weather; before the month ended, howling gales of hail and snow swept across the city and blotted out the surrounding hills, to leave them covered with white as far as the eye could see.
The holy city of Urga sits on what would be an ordinary Mongolian plain if it weren't for the rows of hills or low mountains that rise on either side. The landscape is a yellow-brown, smooth like a fox's fur; the city, its wide shallow valley, and the rolling hills to the right are completely devoid of trees or even any hint of brush, just like the Gobi. Only along the edge, covering the upper portion of the range to the west and south, which is sacred to the “Living Buddha” whose two palace compounds sit at its base, is there any vegetation other than the sparse brown grass of the mountain heights. The soil isn't hospitable to it, for one. Even the forests on the long low sacred mountain, planted centuries ago and strictly protected, while thick enough, have only managed to grow into scrub. About forty-five hundred feet above sea level and not far from the Siberian border, Urga is not a tropical paradise. I've heard that during summer its midday heat can be uncomfortable; but even though it was only mid-September when we arrived, all the clothing we brought was barely enough to fend off the biting mountain cold. Just five days earlier, Peking had been sweltering; here, the entire population wore heavy quilted clothing, with barely a bare foot visible among the poorest, even on days when the brilliant sun shone in a clear sky, creating lovely autumn weather. By the end of the month, fierce storms of hail and snow swept through the city, covering everything in white as far as the eye could see.
The city is built in several towns or sections of distinctly different characters, separated by bare, stony, wind-swept spaces. Besides the old Chinese merchant town back up the valley, and the straggling buildings which partly flank the nature-laid road to it, there is the official town of yamens and the like, with two great temple compounds closely allied to it, then the now main business and residential section where virtually all non-Mongols live, and farther on, a little higher up the 136slope of the hills, a whole city completely given up to lamas, with the great sanctuary of Ganden, only high building in Urga, bulking far above it. Then, across the flat valley and several little streams, more than a mile away against the background of the sacred mountain, is the dwelling-place of Bogda-Han, the “Living Buddha,” flanked at some distance by his summer palace on one side and on the other by clusters of buildings housing the things and the men who serve him. Lastly there are scores of yourts, the low round felt tents of Mongolia, scattered at random outside the permanent city, particularly to the north, the homes of true nomads who will not be without the comforts of their portable houses even though they live in the holy national capital.
The city is made up of several areas or sections, each with its own unique character, separated by bare, rocky, wind-swept spaces. Besides the old Chinese merchant town up the valley and the scattered buildings that line the nature-made road to it, there's the official town of yamens and similar areas, along with two large temple complexes closely connected to it. Then there’s the main business and residential section where nearly all non-Mongols reside, and further up the hillside, a whole area dedicated to lamas, featuring the grand sanctuary of Ganden, the tallest building in Urga, towering above everything else. Across the flat valley and a few small streams, more than a mile away, against the backdrop of the sacred mountain, is the home of Bogda-Han, the “Living Buddha,” flanked at a distance by his summer palace on one side and clusters of buildings that house the belongings and people who serve him on the other. Finally, there are numerous yourts, the low round felt tents of Mongolia, scattered randomly outside the permanent city, especially to the north, serving as homes for true nomads who prefer the comforts of their portable houses, even while living in the holy national capital.
For that matter, many of the dwellers in the city itself still cling to the customs and architecture of the plains from which they came. Mongol princes and saints, of whom there is a generous number in Urga, cabinet ministers and judges, may have a rather Russian type of frame house within their compounds, but the chances are that they do their actual living in their felt tent beside it. The yourts are said to be uncomfortably warm in summer, whence the tendency of those who are wealthy by Mongol standards to copy European dwellings; but when the first early frosts come they like the low crowded tent, with its intense dung-fire heat, its sense of coziness, even the smell of the sifting smoke of their pungent fuel, that has come down to them from their hardy nomadic forefathers. The story is told of some high-placed Mongol to whom fell a fine big room in one of the government buildings of the expelled Chinese, who complained that it was as bad as living outdoors and demanded either that another small low room be built for him within it or that he be allowed to conduct his official business in his tent.
For that matter, many of the residents in the city still hold on to the customs and architecture of the plains they came from. Mongol princes and saints, of whom there are quite a few in Urga, as well as cabinet ministers and judges, might have a more Russian-style frame house on their property, but they likely do most of their living in the felt tent next to it. The yourts are said to get uncomfortably hot in the summer, which is why wealthier Mongols tend to mimic European homes; however, when the first early frosts arrive, they prefer the low, cozy tent with its intense dung-fire heat, its snug atmosphere, and even the smell of the smoky fuel that has been passed down from their resilient nomadic ancestors. There's a story about a high-ranking Mongol who was assigned a nice big room in one of the government buildings of the ousted Chinese. He complained that it felt just like living outside and requested either another small low room be added for him or that he be allowed to conduct his official duties in his tent.
Urga is as wholly made up of walled compounds as any Chinese city; but here the walls, instead of being of stone or baked mud, are of upright pine logs, bark and all, some ten feet high and set so tightly together that only here and there can one peer through a crack. Between these frowning palisades, broken for block after block only by identical gates which are a cross between a wooden arch and a Japanese torii with three uncurved crosspieces, and painted a dull red, run, not streets, but haphazard passageways deep in dust, mud, or mere stony soil, according as nature left them—grim defenseless lanes full of the offal of man and beast, of putrid carcasses and gnawed bones, and always overrun with groups of those surly, treacherous big black wild 137dogs of Urga, ready the instant they feel they have mustered sufficient force to pounce upon and drag down the passer-by. Inside, the compounds are bare and unswept yards, for filth means nothing to the Mongol, and the planting of a flower or a shrub is far beyond his stage of civilization. A house or two, even three, perhaps as many felt tents, a tethered horse, a heap of dried dung fuel, and the inventory is complete. A small stream, its banks heaped high with filth and garbage, lined with foraging dogs and squatting Mongols, crossed by half a dozen precarious bridges culminating in the red one sacred to the “Living Buddha,” which is barred against every-day traffic, meanders disconsolately through the gloomy town. For there is a gloominess, an ominousness about Urga which even the great gleaming gold superstructures of its many temples and shrines, so brilliant as to cow the eye on days of clear sunshine, do not dispel.
Urga is just as filled with walled compounds as any Chinese city; however, here the walls are not made of stone or baked mud, but of upright pine logs, with the bark still on, about ten feet high and packed so closely together that you can only see through a crack here and there. Between these imposing palisades, which are broken up for block after block by identical gates that are a mix of a wooden arch and a Japanese torii with three flat crosspieces, painted a dull red, there aren’t streets but random pathways that are deep in dust, mud, or just rocky soil, depending on how nature left them—grim, unprotected lanes filled with the waste of humans and animals, putrid carcasses, and gnawed bones, constantly swarmed by groups of those grumpy, dangerous big black wild 137 dogs of Urga, ready to pounce on a passerby the moment they feel they have enough of a pack to do so. Inside, the compounds consist of bare, unkempt yards, as dirt means nothing to the Mongol, and planting a flower or shrub is far beyond their level of civilization. There might be one or two houses, maybe three, several felt tents, a tied-up horse, a pile of dried dung for fuel, and that’s all there is. A small stream, its banks piled high with garbage and filth, lined with scavenging dogs and seated Mongols, crossed by about half a dozen shaky bridges leading to the red bridge that is sacred to the “Living Buddha,” which is off-limits to regular traffic, winds despairingly through the gloomy town. There’s a gloom, an unsettling vibe about Urga that even the shiny gold structures of its many temples and shrines, so bright that they dazzle the eyes on sunny days, can’t overcome.
A few streets of the central town, to which commerce is confined, are flanked by shops of a hybrid Chinese-Russian character, the great majority of which are inwardly establishments quite like those of China, though often scanty of goods and with a discouraged air in these days of oppressive rule. Then there are numerous open-air markets more worth visiting for their picturesqueness than for their wares. In one wide dusty space Mongolian ponies are put through their paces for prospective purchasers; camels or oxen may be had near-by on certain days; then, there are several blocks lined with displays of furs, mainly of sheep and goats in this season, but now and then offering wild pelts at reasonable figures. Shop after shop is filled from floor to low shack roof with the gaudy boots worn indiscriminately by all Mongols; little portable booths or stands overflowing with every manner of silly and useful trinket, chaotic collections of second-hand hardware spread on the ground, more or less itinerant purveyors of used garments and of the heavy silver ornaments that go with Mongol dress, each strive in their turn to attract and detain the stroller. Almost all these merchants, from horse-dealers to hawkers of lama rosaries and alleged photographs of the “Living Buddha,” are Chinese; the Mongol is frankly a nomadic herdsman and scorns any other occupation. Even in the purulent meat and vegetable market stretching along the carrion-lined stream just outside our window there were but few native venders. The more lowly members of the tribe might consent to slash up and distribute the still bleeding carcasses of cattle and sheep which Urga consumes in surprising daily quantities; even out on the plains that is a necessary and respectable task. But as the 138Mongol considers it unholy to cultivate the ground, the huge carrots, the turnips larger than cocoanuts, the squashes, potatoes, cabbage, lettuce, kaoliang, millet, and corn-meal all came from the truck-gardens of Chinese in inconspicuous hollows about the city and were sold only by them. Millet and kaoliang and rock-salt were about the only non-flesh wares appealing to the natives, anyway, for boiled meat, each mouthful slashed off before the lips with a sheath-knife, as among the gauchos of South America, is almost an exclusive diet with them the year round.
A few streets in the center of town, where most commerce takes place, are lined with shops that have a mix of Chinese and Russian influences. Most of these places feel very much like typical shops in China, though they often have limited stock and an air of discouragement during this time of oppressive rule. There are also many open-air markets that are more interesting for their charm than their products. In one large dusty area, Mongolian ponies are showcased for potential buyers; on certain days, you can find camels or oxen nearby. There are several blocks filled with displays of furs, mostly sheep and goat fur this season, but occasionally you can find wild pelts at decent prices. Shop after shop is packed from the floor to the low ceiling with colorful boots that all Mongolians wear; little portable booths overflow with a mix of frivolous and practical trinkets, while chaotic piles of second-hand hardware lie scattered on the ground. There are also wandering vendors selling used clothing and heavy silver jewelry to go with traditional Mongolian outfits, all trying to catch the attention of passersby. Almost all these merchants, from horse traders to sellers of lama rosaries and supposed photographs of the “Living Buddha,” are Chinese; Mongolians see themselves primarily as nomadic herdsmen and generally disdain other forms of work. Even in the filthy meat and vegetable market that runs along the stream lined with rotting carcasses right outside our window, there were very few native sellers. The lower-class members of the tribe might agree to cut up and sell the still bleeding carcasses of cattle and sheep that Urga consumes in surprising daily amounts; even out on the plains, that’s considered a necessary and respectable job. However, since the Mongol believes it's unholy to farm, the large carrots, turnips bigger than coconuts, squash, potatoes, cabbage, lettuce, kaoliang, millet, and cornmeal all come from the Chinese truck gardens in hidden spots around the city and are sold exclusively by them. Millet, kaoliang, and rock salt are about the only non-meat items that appeal to the locals, anyway, because boiled meat—cut off right before eating with a sheath knife, similar to how the gauchos in South America do it—makes up almost their entire diet year-round.
There is the atmosphere of a frontier town about Urga, for all its age and holiness and costly religious structures. Perhaps it is the great prevalence of mounted people as much as the rough-and-ready style of its architecture and streets which gives this feeling. The poor, and most of the despised foreigners, may or must go on foot, but the true Mongol, male or female, young or old, layman or lama, is by nature a horseman. Even the women, in their incredibly heavy ornaments and cumbersome garments, sit the tight little wooden saddles covered with red cloth as if they were part of the jogging animal beneath them. Children ride as easily and as soon as they can walk. Horsemen are so numerous and so fundamental in the Mongol scheme of things that the pedestrian has only secondary rights in the soft-footed streets of Urga. It is not so much his natural rudeness, nor even his inbred scorn for the horseless, which makes the Mongol so apt to ride down the walker unless the latter sidesteps. Probably it has never occurred to him, any more than to his horse, that all other movable beings should not necessarily always make way for him.
Urga has the vibe of a frontier town, despite its history, spirituality, and expensive religious buildings. It might be the large number of people on horseback, along with the rough style of its architecture and streets, that creates this impression. The poor, along with many of the less liked foreigners, often have to walk, but the true Mongol—whether male or female, young or old, layperson or lama—is naturally a rider. Even the women, dressed in their incredibly heavy jewelry and cumbersome clothing, sit in the snug little wooden saddles covered with red cloth as if they were part of the horse beneath them. Kids start riding as soon as they can walk. Horse riders are so common and essential to Mongolian life that pedestrians have only secondary rights on the soft-footed streets of Urga. It's not just natural rudeness or ingrained disdain for those without horses that leads Mongols to ride over walkers unless they move aside. They've probably never considered, just like their horses, that other moving beings shouldn’t always have to yield to them.
Besides the omnipresent Mongol pony there are strings of haughty camels from, or off again to, the desert; there are oxen and their crudest of two-wheeled carts, and now and again a yak, or a cross between this and the native cattle, identified mainly by its thick bushy tail. It is not only this quaint long-haired animal from the roof of Asia which reminds one of the close relationship between Mongolia and its distant neighbor, Tibet. The lengthwise Tibetan script stands beside the upright Mongolian on the façade of more than one building and on many a monument; not a few of the friendly-looking, darker-tinted natives of the lofty land behind the Himalayas, recognizable also by their different garb, the right arm and shoulder protruding from the cloak, may be met in the market-places; when the visitor begins to poke his nose into religious matters he finds that Tibet is much closer to him than he suspected.
Besides the ever-present Mongol pony, there are lines of proud camels coming from or heading back to the desert; there are oxen pulling their basic two-wheeled carts, and occasionally a yak, or a mix of this and the local cattle, mainly distinguished by its thick bushy tail. It’s not just this quirky long-haired creature from the roof of Asia that highlights the close connection between Mongolia and its distant neighbor, Tibet. The Tibetan script can be seen alongside the upright Mongolian on the front of several buildings and many monuments; numerous friendly-looking, darker-skinned locals from the high land behind the Himalayas, identifiable by their unique clothing with their right arm and shoulder sticking out from their cloaks, can be found in the markets. When visitors start exploring religious topics, they discover that Tibet is much closer to them than they thought.
139Though there are sights of an inanimate nature in Urga that are well worth seeing, it is especially the unique and striking costumes of her people which cause bitter resentment for the confiscation of a camera. The Mongols are as fond of gaudy colors as the Andean Indians, though somewhat less given to barbaric combinations of them. Of a score of laymen often no two wear robes of the same hue; red, purple, blue, green, and all the combinations and gradations between them may be seen in any gathering outside religious circles. Men who pride themselves on their liberality toward the outside world show a fondness for ugly slouch-hats of a cheap quality that quickly fades to a nondescript hue. But these are so few as to be conspicuous among their orthodox fellows, who display a variety in head-dress which I have not the energy to attempt to describe. Suffice it to say that these are all striking, both in color and form, and that the overwhelming favorite seems to be the pagoda-shaped thing with a ball, generally of colored glass, on top, and side-wings of fur. This is common to both laymen and lamas and is said to have been originally copied from a sacred peak of central Asia.
139While there are definitely some impressive sights in Urga that are worth checking out, it's really the unique and eye-catching costumes of the locals that make losing a camera feel especially frustrating. The Mongols love bright colors just like the Andean Indians, although their color combinations are generally less wild. In a group of twenty people, you’re unlikely to find two wearing robes of the same color; you can spot reds, purples, blues, greens, and every mix and shade in between at any gathering outside of religious events. Men who like to show off how progressive they are often choose unattractive slouch hats made of cheap material that quickly fade into a dull color. However, these individuals are rare and stand out among their more traditional peers, who showcase a variety of headwear that I don't even have the energy to try to describe. It's enough to say that all of it is striking, both in color and shape, with the most popular style being a pagoda-shaped hat topped with a colored glass ball and adorned with fur side-wings. This style is worn by both laymen and lamas and is said to have been inspired by a sacred peak in central Asia.
But it would be unchivalrous to expect the men, even of an Oriental race in which the women form the bottom layer of society, to outdo the other sex in effective decoration of the cranium. Until I came to Mongolia I had been laboring under the delusion that in my various wanderings about the globe I had already run across the final word in woman’s head-dress. I humbly apologize, and hereby bestow the leather medal upon the ladies of Urga, without the least fear of ever again having to modify my decision. In intricacy, ugliness, fearsomeness, unportability, wastefulness, absurdity, not to say pure idiocy, their contraption surely outdistances all competitors, at least in our own little solar system.
But it would be unfair to expect the men, even from an Eastern culture where women are seen as the lowest tier of society, to surpass the other gender in stylish headwear. Until I arrived in Mongolia, I was under the impression that in my travels around the world, I had already encountered the pinnacle of women’s headgear. I sincerely apologize and now award the leather medal to the women of Urga, with no fear of ever needing to change my mind. In terms of complexity, unattractiveness, intimidation, impracticality, extravagance, absurdity, not to mention sheer foolishness, their headpiece definitely outshines all others, at least within our own little solar system.
It starts, so I have been assured by those of wider experience and reputation for veracity, often at virtual baldness, which under the circumstances, or under such a head-dress, is not surprising. Over this goes a skull-cap of silver in elaborate designs, weighing, if the eye be permitted to judge what the fingers may not touch, several pounds. I am no ladies’ coiffeur, and I may be getting the cart before the horse, but it is my strong impression that the hair comes next, most of it the hair of some one else, naturally, or at least hair which has ceased to derive its direct nourishment from its wearer. In color and texture, too, it has a way of recalling the tail of a horse, though this may be mere coincidence. First of all the hair forms a wig; then it flares out 140and is wound, in single strands that give it a cloth-like texture, round and round two horns that are thin and flat but wider and longer than those of the water-buffalo, which the lady with these appendages protruding well beyond her shoulders considerably resembles. Across the horns, front and back, at close intervals, run inch-wide bars of silver—replaced by wood or other substitutes in poverty-stricken cases—while from the ends, perhaps as a concession to the timid spectator who cannot rid himself of the fear of being gored, are suspended braids or cords reaching to the waist. A lady of reasonable tastes might conclude that this is enough, but there are innumerable opportunities for adding other silver and colored decorations, and naturally one needs a hat over one’s hair, so that milady of Urga piles on top, at the jaunty angle of a first-year sailor, one of the fur-sided, pagoda-shaped helmets favored by the men, thereby crowning herself in a manner befitting the rest of her costume. Let not the hasty reader get the impression that this ponderous and deeply cogitated head-dress is confined to the consorts of princes and saints, nor relegated to festive occasions and popular hours. The old woman who sold half-decayed fruit opposite our window wore the whole contraption, and all available evidence goes to show that it is as seldom removed as is the fly-trap hat of the Korean male. Indeed, it would be impossible to reconcile daily hair-dressing with the early hours at which many a fully clad woman appears. One easily surmises that this unbelievable millinery was copied from the cattle that have been the Mongols’ constant and chief companions for many centuries; but why hang the horns on the woman? Is it to keep before the mind that she, too, is a dangerous creature, or is it a means of training her in patience and the uncomplaining endurance of lifelong impediments, like the crippled feet of the women of China?
It starts, as I've been told by those with more experience and a reputation for truth, often at a sort of virtual baldness, which isn't surprising given the circumstances or such a headpiece. Over this, there's a silver skullcap with intricate designs that, if the eye can judge what the fingers shouldn't touch, weighs several pounds. I'm not a ladies’ hair stylist, and I might be putting the cart before the horse, but I strongly believe that the hair comes next—most of it being someone else's hair, or at least hair that no longer gets its nourishment directly from the wearer. In color and texture, it has a way of reminding one of a horse's tail, though that might just be coincidental. First, the hair forms a wig; then it flares out and is wrapped in single strands that give it a fabric-like texture around two horns that are thin and flat, but wider and longer than those of a water buffalo, making the lady with these appendages sticking out well beyond her shoulders resemble one quite a bit. Across the horns, front and back, inch-wide silver bars run at close intervals—substituted by wood or other materials in poorer cases—while from the ends hang braids or cords that reach down to the waist, perhaps as a concession to fearful onlookers worried about being gored. A lady of reasonable taste might think this is enough, but there are endless opportunities to add more silver and colorful decorations, and of course, one needs a hat over one’s hair, so the lady of Urga piles on top, at a jaunty angle like a first-year sailor, one of the fur-sided, pagoda-shaped helmets favored by men, thus topping herself off in a way that suits the rest of her outfit. Let not the hasty reader think this heavy and meticulously crafted headpiece is only for the partners of princes and saints, nor just for festive or popular occasions. The old woman selling half-rotten fruit across from our window wore the whole setup, and all evidence suggests it's as seldom removed as the fly-trap hats worn by Korean men. Indeed, it would be impossible to manage daily hair styling with the early hours at which many fully dressed women appear. One can easily guess this incredible hat design was inspired by the cattle that have been the Mongols’ constant and most important companions for centuries; but why hang the horns on the woman? Is it to remind us that she, too, is a dangerous being, or a way to train her in patience and the uncomplaining endurance of lifelong burdens, like the bound feet of women in China?
In ordinary circles the rest of the female costume of Mongolia would attract attention, but under the national head-dress it is almost inconspicuous. It includes big puffed sleeves, for instance, not unlike those of the Western world a generation ago, but filled with something that makes them hard and solid, and lifts the puffs some six inches above the shoulders. Unseemly exposure of the person is not a Mongol fault. Though personal habits of an indescribable nature are constantly in evidence among both sexes and all classes, there is never anything even remotely reminiscent of the freedom of a bathing-beach in more civilized lands. The woman’s thick, quilted, colorful jacket-gown covers her from tonsils to instep; her long sleeves serve her, Chinese fashion, as gloves; though it is known that she wears heavy 141lumber-jack trousers quite like those of her husband, even her trim ankles, if she has them, are never in evidence, for she thrusts her feet into the same mammoth boots which are universal beneath all ages, ranks, callings, and degrees of sanctity.
In regular circles, the rest of the female outfit from Mongolia would grab attention, but under the national headpiece, it’s almost unnoticeable. It features large puffed sleeves, similar to those from a generation ago in the West, but filled with something that makes them stiff and solid, raising the puffs about six inches above the shoulders. The Mongols aren't known for exposing themselves. Even though there are personal habits of a hard-to-describe nature seen among both genders and all social classes, there’s nothing remotely similar to the freedom found at a beach in more developed countries. The woman’s thick, quilted, colorful jacket-gown covers her from throat to toe; her long sleeves double as gloves, Chinese style; and although it’s known that she wears heavy lumberjack-style pants like her husband, even her well-shaped ankles, if she has them, are never visible, as she puts her feet into the same massive boots that are common across all ages, classes, jobs, and levels of respectability.
The Mongol boot, as I may have said before, is knee-high, of soft leather, usually red and most elaborately decorated, the toe turned up like the prow of Cleopatra’s barge, and it is made much too large for the foot, in order that many layers of thick socks may be worn in wintry weather. The extraordinarily slow pace of life in Urga is partly due, beyond a doubt, to the necessity of stalking about like a hobbled prisoner in such boots; but then, they were never made for walking, which is not a natural Mongol means of locomotion. The favorite one is the single-foot pony, with a kind of Indian rawhide reins, stirrups so short that the rider seems to be kneeling, and a tight little red saddle. It is an old joke in Urga that a Mongol would make an excellent cook—if he could ride about the kitchen on horseback. As the women as well as the men ride astride, with the easy abandon of born cowboys, it is perhaps as well that most of them cling to their marvelous head-dress, for without it there is little to distinguish between the sexes.
The Mongol boot, as I might have mentioned before, is knee-high, made of soft leather, usually red, and very intricately decorated, with the toe turned up like the front of Cleopatra’s barge. It’s made quite large to accommodate several layers of thick socks for the cold weather. The incredibly slow pace of life in Urga is certainly partly due to the need to shuffle around like a restrained prisoner in such boots; however, they were never designed for walking, which isn't a natural way for Mongols to move. Their favorite mode of transportation is the single-foot pony, with a type of Indian rawhide reins, very short stirrups that make the rider look like they're kneeling, and a snug little red saddle. It’s a common joke in Urga that a Mongol would make a great chef—if only they could ride around the kitchen on horseback. Since both men and women ride side-saddle with the relaxed confidence of born cowboys, it’s probably a good thing that most of them hold on to their amazing head-dresses, because without them, there’s not much to tell the genders apart.
It is said that almost half the population of Urga are lamas. Certainly there are thousands upon thousands of them, swarming everywhere, in the market-town as well as in their own temple-topped sections, sometimes on horseback, more often plodding through the slovenly streets in their ponderous boots. Their round clipped heads, in contrast to the long cues of laymen, are often bare in any weather. It is visually evident, without asking questions, that they wear no trousers under their long quilted robes, which are similar to those of the marriageable men, yet easily distinguishable from them. Their gowns, originally saffron-yellow or brick-red in color, are well suited to the mahogany tint which the cold of high plateaus gives the Mongol cheeks; but they are so invariably dulled by grease, filth, and rough desert living as to suggest that this is considered the most holy and fitting state for seekers after a pseudo-Nirvana. Cleanliness certainly has no relation whatever to godliness in this unedifying religion of creaking prayer-wheels and barbaric hubbub; laity and lamas alike seem frankly to scorn it. Now and again one saw a prince who had just donned his winter garments, or a group of high lamas rode by in gleamingly new saffron or red robes, the yellow streamers from their 142high hats trailing behind them, clad in the most spotless of beautiful silks. But there is evidently something unmanly about such a condition, for those even of the highest class seem to make haste to reduce themselves to the common dirty drab, as some of our youths “baptize” a new pair of shoes. From high to low the Mongols are an unlaundered people, like so many dwellers in semi-desert lands, apparently never subjecting their clothing to any cleansing process—so filthy in fact that even the Chinese call them dirty!
It’s said that nearly half the population of Urga are lamas. There are definitely thousands of them, everywhere you look, in the market-town as well as in their own temple areas, sometimes on horseback, but more often trudging through the shabby streets in their heavy boots. Their round, shaved heads, in contrast to the long hair of laymen, are often bare no matter the weather. It’s obvious, without asking, that they wear no pants under their long, quilted robes, which are similar to those worn by eligible men, yet can be easily distinguished from them. Their gowns, originally saffron-yellow or brick-red, match the mahogany hue that the cold of high plateaus gives Mongolian faces; but they are so consistently stained by grease, dirt, and rough desert living that it seems this is viewed as the most sacred and appropriate state for those pursuing a false Nirvana. Cleanliness definitely has nothing to do with godliness in this unappealing religion filled with creaking prayer wheels and chaotic noise; both laypeople and lamas seem to openly disregard it. Occasionally, you might see a prince who has just put on his winter clothes, or a group of high lamas riding by in bright new saffron or red robes, their yellow streamers from their high hats trailing behind them, dressed in the finest of beautiful silks. But there’s clearly something unmanly about such a state, because even those of the highest class seem eager to bring themselves down to the common, dirty drab, much like some of our young people “baptize” a new pair of shoes. From the highest to the lowest, the Mongols are an unclean people, much like many who live in semi-desert areas, apparently never washing their clothes—so filthy, in fact, that even the Chinese call them dirty!
Yet these big brawny Mongols of the Gobi, beside whom the Chinese look delicate and harmless, bring history home to the beholder in a striking fashion. It was easy to imagine these fearless nomad horsemen banding together under a Jenghiz Khan and sweeping down upon the rich but weaker people to the southward; once in Mongolia, that breeding-ground for many centuries of new virility for the human race, as it were, it was no longer hard to understand why the timorous but diligent Chinese should have spent such incredible toil to fling a wall across their whole northern frontier, in the vain hope of shutting themselves off from these dreaded barbarians, scorning civilization but ever ready to loot it of its fruits. Now and again I met a prince—not a pampered weakling of a run-down stock, like so many who bear that title in the West, but big powerful fellows who could ride their horses day after day like centaurs, sleep out on the open plain, and master their great herds with the pole-and-noose lasso as easily as any of their herdsmen subjects—handsome Mongol princes with a truly regal poise and dignity, for all the countless grease-spots on their silken gowns, whom one could readily picture in the rôle of another Jenghiz Khan.
Yet these strong, muscular Mongols of the Gobi, next to whom the Chinese seem delicate and harmless, bring history to life in a striking way. It’s easy to picture these fearless nomadic horsemen coming together under a Genghis Khan and charging down on the rich but weaker people to the south. Once in Mongolia, a breeding ground for many centuries of new strength for the human race, it’s clear why the cautious but hardworking Chinese would have put in such incredible effort to build a wall across their entire northern frontier, hoping in vain to shut themselves off from these feared barbarians, who scorn civilization but are always ready to take its offerings. Now and then, I encountered a prince—not a pampered weakling of a faded lineage like so many in the West, but strong, capable individuals who could ride their horses day after day like centaurs, sleep out on the open plain, and manage their vast herds with a lasso just as easily as any of their herdsmen subjects—handsome Mongol princes with a truly regal presence and dignity, despite the countless grease spots on their silk garments, whom one could easily envision as another Genghis Khan.
Speaking of those halcyon days of the Mongols seven centuries ago, there seems to be but little differentiation in the minds of historians between them and the Tartars; but in Mongolia to-day there is a wide gulf between these two peoples. What is known as a Tartar in Urga at least, where a few score of them dwell, is no longer a warrior but has degenerated into a tradesman, a close bargainer wearing mainly European garb, with a little velvet cap always on his head, topped off by one of fur when he sallies forth into the street. He is a Mohammedan, too, and the Mongol certainly is not. Once he seems to have been at home in central Mongolia; now he lives far to the West, scattered through the regions about Bokhara, Kashgar, and Samarkand. In much greater numbers and influence in Urga to-day are two other semi-Europeanized peoples,—the surly Kalmucks from western Mongolia 143and Sungaria, and the Buriats, Mongol by race but grown half Russian during generations under the rule of the czars in an annexed province, and by long intermixture with their more Caucasian fellow-subjects.
Speaking of those peaceful days of the Mongols seven centuries ago, historians often struggle to see a clear distinction between them and the Tartars; however, today in Mongolia, there's a significant divide between these two groups. What people call a Tartar in Urga, at least, where a few dozen of them live, is no longer a warrior but has become a tradesman, a savvy bargainer dressed mostly in European clothing, often sporting a small velvet cap on his head, topped with a fur hat when he heads out into the street. He is also a Muslim, while the Mongol is certainly not. Once, he might have been native to central Mongolia; now he resides much farther west, scattered across areas around Bokhara, Kashgar, and Samarkand. In Urga today, there are two other semi-Europeanized groups that are more numerous and influential—the grumpy Kalmucks from western Mongolia and Sungaria, and the Buriats, who are Mongolian by ethnicity but have become partially Russian over generations under czarist rule in an annexed province, along with extensive mixing with their more Caucasian counterparts.
But though Urga so nearly coincides with that Karakoram which was still the capital of Jenghiz Khan when his vast conquests ended, one feels even there that the power of the Mongol is broken, that with his debauching idolatry and his all but universal taint with one of the most abhorred of diseases, he will never again have the initiative and the energy to band together into a menace to more advanced civilizations. He will do surprisingly well, in fact, if he succeeds in his new attempt to govern himself. The traveler cannot but be struck by the astonishing scarcity of children in Mongolia, especially if he has just come from Japan and China, until he learns that fully a third of the population of the country as a whole are lamas, and notes the prevalence of missing noses among both sexes and all classes in the streets of Urga. The most educated Mongol, in our Western sense, with whom I came in contact declared that within a century his race will completely have disappeared. While there is probably undue pessimism in so flat a statement, there are many signs that the people which once subjugated nearly all Asia and stopped only at the Danube in Europe is to-day on the same swift downward path as the American Indian they in so many ways resemble.
But even though Urga closely aligns with the Karakoram that was still the capital of Genghis Khan when his vast conquests ended, one can sense that the power of the Mongols is diminished. With their corrupting idolatry and widespread affliction by one of the most reviled diseases, they will likely never regain the initiative and energy needed to unite as a threat to more advanced civilizations. In fact, they will do surprisingly well if they can manage to govern themselves. Travelers are often struck by the shocking scarcity of children in Mongolia, especially after coming from Japan and China, until they discover that about a third of the country's population consists of lamas, and they notice the prevalence of missing noses among both men and women across all classes in the streets of Urga. The most educated Mongol I met, in our Western sense, stated that within a century, his race will have completely vanished. While this might be an overly bleak assessment, there are many signs that the people who once conquered nearly all of Asia and stopped only at the Danube in Europe are now on a rapid decline similar to that of the American Indians, with whom they share many similarities.
As befits a holy city, Urga is overrun with temples, shrines, monasteries, and all the myriad paraphernalia of lamaism, that degenerate, repulsive, yet picturesque offshoot of Buddhism, centered in Tibet but clinging with a tenacious hold to all Mongolia. Take away everything concerned with her religion, and the Mongol capital would shrink to a mere filthy village. Most conspicuous of its structures is the shrine or temple of Ganden, towering not only above the lama town about it but over the whole city. A stony and sandy hollow separates this monasterial section from the secular one, but when one has climbed the further slope of this he finds himself wandering through just such another maze of narrow, dunghill streets shut in by high wooden palisades. Here it will be doubly wise to carry a heavy stick, for not only are the savage black dogs that everywhere dot the landscape in and about Urga particularly numerous and ravenous in this log-built labyrinth, but they are accustomed to seeing only lamas in their dirty robes, and foreign garb quickly attracts their unwelcome attention. 144At least in theory there are no women in lama-town, and as lamaism is not a religion calling for congregations, even native laymen are conspicuous in this section by their absence.
As befitting a holy city, Urga is filled with temples, shrines, monasteries, and all the various elements of lamaism, that degenerate, off-putting, yet visually striking offshoot of Buddhism, centered in Tibet but firmly established throughout Mongolia. Remove everything related to religion, and the Mongol capital would shrink to a filthy village. The most notable structure is the shrine or temple of Ganden, towering not only above the surrounding lama town but over the entire city. A rocky and sandy valley separates this monastic area from the secular one, but once you climb the other side, you find yourself wandering through another maze of narrow, filthy streets enclosed by high wooden fences. It's wise to carry a heavy stick here, as the savage black dogs roaming the landscape in and around Urga are particularly numerous and hungry in this wooden labyrinth, and they're used to seeing only lamas in their dirty robes; foreign clothing quickly catches their unwanted attention. 144At least in theory, there are no women in lama-town, and since lamaism doesn't require gatherings, even local laymen are typically absent from this area.
As the stroller comes out upon an open space on the summit of the low, broad hillock, he finds before him not only the great central edifice of Ganden, built in Tibetan fashion of a square stone wall many feet thick, with deep window-embrasures of fortress-like size, topped by three overhanging stories in wood, but also many lower yet no less ornate buildings flanking and surrounding it. From these, in all likelihood, proceed barbarous sounds of drum-beating, the hammering of big brass disks, a cabalistic chanting, and yet more awe-inspiring noises the source of which he cannot identify. Huge cylinders on the high corners of Ganden, many of its absurd outer ornaments, and much of the superstructure of the lower buildings are covered with gold, upon which the cloudless sun gleams richly. If it is “school” or service time, only a score or so of ragged, besmeared beggars, most or all of them lamas, will be in sight, scattered along the outer walls or in the gateways of the religious structures. One of the largest of these is built like a mammoth Mongol tent, with a saucer-shaped roof, and inside, if a lone Caucasian wanderer has the courage to march through the gate and step into the open doorway in the face of hundreds of scowling bullies in once-red robes—for the “orthodox” yellow of more genuine Buddhism is much more rare in Urga—he will behold a veritable sea of lamas, squatted back to back on wide low wooden benches more or less covered with soiled cushions, in rows so close together that a cat could scarcely squirm between them, and stretching so far away in every direction that one must stoop low to see beneath the idolatrous junk suspended from the low rafters, even as far as the dais in the center of the building. Here sits what I suppose we would call an abbot, leading the services or instructing the gathering in the fine points of lamaism. For this is a kind of seminary, a lama university to which sturdy red-robed males come from all over Mongolia and beyond, to perfect themselves in the intricate hocus-pocus of their faith, in which a bit of Buddhism is swamped by the grossest forms of demonology and ridiculous superstitions. The students are of no fixed age; burly men in the forties and sensual-faced old fellows who are soon to feed the dogs are almost as numerous as impudent youths already soiled and begrimed in true lama fashion. For hours at a time this huge gathering rocks back and forth on its haunches, intoning supplications under the lead of the abbot, sometimes chanting its litanies to the accompaniment of a “music” so barbaric as to send shivers up the unaccustomed spine, meanwhile moving the hands in distorted gestures prescribed by the ritual. Their devotions consist mainly of the endless repetition of the same brief prayers, mumbled over and over until the monotony promises to drive the listening stranger to sleep or to distraction. The notion is that this never ceasing iteration of the same scant theme will withdraw the minds of the devotees from worldly things and fix their attention on that nothingness which is the goal of the seeker after Nirvana; it needs but a slight acquaintance with lamas, however, to show that the real effect is to make them mere mumbling automatons, with minds as narrow and as shallow as their monotonous invocations.
As the stroller emerges into an open area at the top of the low, broad hill, he sees not just the impressive main structure of Ganden, built in a Tibetan style with thick, square stone walls, large window openings like a fortress, and three overhanging wooden stories, but also many smaller yet equally decorative buildings surrounding it. From these, likely, come loud sounds of drumbeats, the clang of big brass disks, mysterious chanting, and other awe-inspiring noises that he can't quite place. Towering cylinders at the high corners of Ganden, many of its quirky outer decorations, and parts of the lower buildings gleam with gold under the bright sun. If it's time for "school" or a service, only about twenty ragged, dirty beggars, mostly lamas, will be visible, scattered along the outer walls or in the entrances of the religious buildings. One of the largest resembles a massive Mongol tent with a wide, bowl-shaped roof. Inside, if a lone Caucasian traveler dares to walk through the gate and step into the doorway facing hundreds of frowning figures in once-red robes—because the "orthodox" yellow of true Buddhism is much rarer in Urga—he will see a true sea of lamas, sitting back to back on wide low wooden benches covered with grimy cushions, arranged so closely that a cat could barely squeeze through, stretching far enough that one must lean low to see beneath the clutter suspended from the low rafters, all the way to the platform in the center of the room. There sits what I suppose we could call an abbot, leading the services or instructing the gathering on the finer points of lamaism. For this is a sort of seminary, a lama university where robust red-robed men come from all over Mongolia and beyond to refine their knowledge of the complex rituals of their faith. This involves a blend of Buddhism overshadowed by extreme forms of demonology and ridiculous superstitions. The students vary in age; burly men in their forties and sensual-faced old men nearing death are almost as common as young lads already stained and grimy in the true lama style. For hours at a stretch, this large group sways back and forth on their haunches, reciting prayers under the abbot’s guidance, sometimes chanting their litanies to the accompaniment of music so harsh that it sends chills down the spine of an unaccustomed listener, while also moving their hands in peculiar gestures dictated by the ritual. Their devotions mainly consist of endlessly repeating the same short prayers, mumbled continuously until the monotony threatens to lull the weary stranger to sleep or drive them to distraction. The idea is that this endless repetition of the same brief theme will pull the devotees' minds away from worldly matters and focus their attention on the emptiness that is the goal of the seeker of Nirvana; however, it only takes a slight familiarity with lamas to reveal that the true outcome is to turn them into mere mumbling automatons, with minds as narrow and shallow as their repetitive chants.

The upper town of Urga, entirely inhabited by lamas, has the temple of Ganden, containing a colossal standing Buddha, rising high above all else. It is in Tibetan style and much of its superstructure is covered with pure gold
The upper town of Urga, completely populated by lamas, features the Ganden temple, which houses a massive standing Buddha that towers over everything else. It follows Tibetan architectural style, and much of its upper structure is adorned with pure gold.

Red lamas leaving the “school” in which hundreds of them squat tightly together all day long, droning through their litany. They are of all ages, equally filthy and heavily booted. Over the gateway of the typical Urga palisade is a text in Tibetan, and the cylinders at the upper corners are covered with gleaming gold
Red lamas are leaving the "school" where they sit packed together all day, chanting their prayers. They come in all ages, equally dirty and wearing heavy boots. Above the entrance of a typical Urga fence is a sign in Tibetan, and the cylinders in the upper corners are shining with gold.

High-class lamas, in their brilliant red or yellow robes, great ribbons streaming from their strange hats, are constantly riding in and out of Urga. Note the bent-knee style of horsemanship
High-class lamas, wearing their bright red or yellow robes with long ribbons flowing from their unique hats, are always riding in and out of Urga. Check out the bent-knee style of horseback riding.

A high lama dignitary on his travels, free from the gaze of the curious, and escorted by mounted lamas of the middle class
A high lama dignitary on his travels, away from the watchful eyes of the curious, and accompanied by middle-class lamas on horseback.
145From time to time the immense crowded gathering stops to eat and drink, still squatted in their places, from bowls of tea and of some such grain as millet, which are passed around among them. This is “holy food,” and the young lower-class lamas who bring it growl protests if the stranger comes too near them while they are carrying it. Then the intonations begin again and go on hour after hour, as tediously as such things can go only in the East, until at last “school” is dismissed and red lamas pour forth through the door and gate like wine from a punctured wine-skin, pausing a moment to take advantage of their first escape into the open air in many hours, then stalking away in their heavy oversize boots with that peculiar ball-and-chain gait of the walking Mongol.
145Occasionally, the large crowd takes a break to eat and drink, still sitting in their spots, sharing bowls of tea and some type of grain like millet that are passed around. This is considered “holy food,” and the young lower-class lamas who bring it grumble if anyone gets too close while they’re carrying it. Then the chanting starts up again and continues for hours on end, as only this kind of thing can in the East, until finally “school” is over and red lamas spill out through the door and gate like wine from a burst skin, taking a moment to enjoy their first breath of fresh air in hours, then striding away in their oversized boots with that distinct ball-and-chain walk of the Mongolian.
Nowhere on earth probably, unless it be in Tibet, is so great a proportion of the population exclusively engaged in the unproductive nonsense of saving its souls. Every first son becomes a lama; if a boy recovers from any serious illness, the parents usually take the vow that he, too, shall don the red or yellow robe; there are many other reasons, among them the dread of labor, fear of hunger, hope of more promiscuous favors from the weaker sex, which add to the crowded ranks of lamas. No census is available, but in Urga almost every other person one meets displays the clipped head and collarless gown, while conservative estimators reckon that fully two fifths of the population of all Mongolia live, in the name of religion, on the exertions of the rest. Nor is it possible to conceive of a priesthood—to use the word loosely—more deeply sunk in degradation. Not merely do the lamas live in filth and sloth, engaged only in the pursuit of their own salvation, in no way serving their fellow-men, but they are notorious libertines, moralless panderers, in many cases beggars of the lowest type. The first 146lamas I ever saw were a pair who accosted us at a halt during our climb out of Kalgan, powerful fellows big and sturdy enough to have laughed at the most arduous labor, yet who begged even the sweepings of our wayside lunch and picked up the cigar-butt I tossed away. In Urga lamas bedraggled to the nth degree squatted day after day on busy street-corners telling their beads and monotoning a brief prayer incessantly from dawn to dusk for a few stray coppers and scraps of food.
Nowhere on earth, except maybe Tibet, has such a large portion of the population exclusively devoted to the unproductive task of saving their souls. Every firstborn son becomes a lama; if a boy recovers from a serious illness, his parents usually vow that he, too, will wear the red or yellow robe. There are many other reasons for this, including a dislike of hard work, fear of hunger, and hope for more casual relationships with women, which add to the crowded ranks of lamas. No census is available, but in Urga, almost every other person you meet has a shaved head and a collarless gown. Conservative estimates suggest that about two-fifths of the entire population of Mongolia lives off the efforts of the rest, all in the name of religion. It’s hard to imagine a priesthood—if you can call it that—more deeply entrenched in degradation. The lamas not only live in filth and laziness, focused solely on their own salvation without serving their fellow humans, but they are also known for being immoral libertines and, in many cases, the lowest type of beggars. The first lamas I encountered were a pair who approached us while we were resting during our climb out of Kalgan—big and sturdy enough to handle the toughest work, yet they begged for even the scraps of our roadside lunch and picked up the cigar butt I tossed away. In Urga, lamas in a state of utter dishevelment squatted day after day on busy street corners, counting their beads and monotonously reciting a brief prayer non-stop from dawn to dusk for a few stray coins and bits of food.
However, there are lamas of high as well as of low degree—Jenghiz Khan himself, you may recall, was one. Several of the ministers in the Mongolian cabinet were lamas; some are princes as well, holding vast tracts of land and hundreds of slave-like subjects; among a number who called upon my departing host during my stay I recall a magnificent specimen of manhood who came to buy for his own use all the best furnishings of the house, and a strong-featured older man who brought a thousand silver dollars to make good the debt of a scamp for whom he had gone surety out of mere friendship. Such strict honesty is not customary among the Mongols, though they have something like the Chinaman’s way of keeping promises; hence there was not even the pressure of public opinion, certainly no fear of legal action, to cause him to yield up for no value received what was perhaps a considerable portion of his fortune.
However, there are lamas of both high and low status—Jenghiz Khan himself, you might remember, was one. Several ministers in the Mongolian government were lamas; some are princes too, owning large areas of land and hundreds of people who live under them like slaves. Among those who visited my departing host during my stay, I recall a remarkable example of manhood who came to buy the best furnishings of the house for himself, and a strong-featured older man who brought a thousand silver dollars to settle the debt of a delinquent for whom he had guaranteed payment out of simple friendship. Such strict honesty isn't common among the Mongols, although they do have a way of keeping promises similar to the Chinese; therefore, there wasn't any public pressure, and certainly no fear of legal consequences, to compel him to give up a significant part of his wealth for no return.
Some of the lower orders of lamas engage in worldly occupations, at least intermittently, to keep the wolf from the door; and those who do not live in monasteries may enter into a sort of left-handed marriage, though their wives are always known as “girls.” The higher ranks are in theory celibates, but no such rule actually cramps their personal desires, and the “Living Buddha” himself has led anything but a life of lonely bachelorhood. Among the rank and file of red-robed roughnecks much the same standard of sexual morals seems to prevail as that reached by the lecherous touts of our large cities. It is said to be almost the general practice to reward a lama who has “cured” a young woman by means of his incanted gibberish by granting him the temporary boon of her affections, and foreigners have had experiences in Mongolia which indicate about the same indifference to lack of privacy in the amorous adventures of wearers of the red or yellow robe that prevails in some of their other personal habits.
Some of the lower-ranking lamas take on regular jobs, at least from time to time, to make ends meet; and those who don't live in monasteries might enter into what you'd call a sort of informal marriage, although their wives are always referred to as "girls." The higher-ups are theoretically celibate, but that doesn't stop them from pursuing their personal desires, and the "Living Buddha" himself hasn't exactly lived a life of solitude. Among the ranks of the red-robed roughnecks, it seems the same standards of sexual morals are common as those found among the sleazy hustlers in our big cities. It's said that it's almost standard practice to reward a lama who has "healed" a young woman with his incantations by giving him the temporary benefit of her affection, and foreigners have experienced in Mongolia a similar disregard for privacy in the romantic escapades of those in the red or yellow robes as is seen in some of their other personal habits.
There are no real schools in Mongolia except these choral gatherings of lamas. In them they learn to read and write, not Mongolian but Tibetan, the Latin of lamaism. The laymen boys of better-class 147families get their education, if at all, from private instructors, and in rare cases reach universities over the Russian border. Women have, of course, no need for other teaching than what their parents and husbands can give them, though now and then a prince or a wealthy saint hires tutors for his daughters.
There aren't any real schools in Mongolia, just these choral gatherings of lamas. They learn to read and write not in Mongolian but in Tibetan, which is the Latin of lamaism. Boys from better-off families get their education, if they get any, from private tutors, and in rare cases, some manage to go to universities across the Russian border. Women, of course, only need the education that their parents and husbands provide, although occasionally a prince or a wealthy saint will hire tutors for his daughters.
However, to turn away from the retreating stream of lamas and push onward, even an enumeration of the religious structures and trappings about the great squat “university” would be wearisome. Most amusing or imbecile of them all to the Westerner, according to his mood, are the prayer-cylinders. Why these are more commonly called “prayer-wheels” is a mystery, for they are invariably cylindrical in shape, varying in size from the largest to the smallest sections of sewer-pipe. How many hundreds of these there are, not only in lama-town but everywhere in Urga, could be computed only by a man of energy and patience. Endless rows of large ones, each covered by a kind of sanctified guard-house, stretch along whole sides of the upper town; they line several of the principal streets; there must be at least one, that could better serve as outhouse, for every family in Urga. The small ones are as flies in summer. Each of these upright wooden cylinders contains thousands of prayers, all, if I am not misinformed, the repetition of the same monotonous phrase, written in Tibetan characters on scraps of tissue-paper,—Om mani padme hun, “The Jewel is in the Lotus,” whatever that means. A kind of capstan furnishes half a dozen protruding bars by which to turn the contrivance, and every turn is equivalent to saying as many thousand prayers as the cylinder contains. Every pious passer-by pauses to revolve one here and there; pilgrims, or residents who have sallied forth especially for that purpose, turn them all, one after the other, along the whole row or, as far as is physically possible, throughout the whole town. Thus the creak of prayer-cylinders is seldom silent, though they furnish a great market for axle-grease. Around the lower massive stone walls of Ganden shrine something like a hundred smaller cylinders are so arranged that by a simple twist of the wrist all of them are turned at once, releasing literally millions of prayers—a labor-saving device compared to which the proudest invention of our industrial world is but clumsy and wasteful.
However, to turn away from the receding stream of lamas and keep moving forward, even listing the religious buildings and decorations around the large, squat "university" would be tiring. The most amusing or ridiculous of them all to a Westerner, depending on their mood, are the prayer cylinders. It's strange that these are more commonly called "prayer wheels," since they are always cylindrical in shape, varying in size from the largest to the smallest pieces of sewer pipe. The number of these in lama-town and everywhere in Urga could only be counted by someone with energy and patience. Endless rows of large ones, each topped with a sort of holy guardhouse, stretch along entire sides of the upper town; they line several of the main streets; there must be at least one for each family in Urga that would better serve as an outhouse. The small ones are as numerous as flies in summer. Each of these upright wooden cylinders holds thousands of prayers, all of which, if I’m not mistaken, repeat the same monotonous phrase written in Tibetan characters on scraps of tissue paper—Om mani padme hun, "The Jewel is in the Lotus," whatever that means. A kind of capstan provides half a dozen protruding bars to turn the mechanism, and each turn is equivalent to saying as many thousand prayers as the cylinder contains. Every devout passerby stops to spin one here and there; pilgrims or locals who have come out specifically for that purpose turn them all, one after the other, along the entire row or, as far as is physically possible, throughout the whole town. Thus, the creak of prayer cylinders is seldom silent, even though they create a huge demand for axle grease. Around the lower massive stone walls of Ganden shrine, about a hundred smaller cylinders are arranged so that with a simple twist of the wrist, all of them can be turned at once, releasing literally millions of prayers—a labor-saving device compared to which the proudest invention of our industrial world is just clumsy and wasteful.
Unlike the disciples of the truer and more kindly Buddhism to the east and west, the surly lamas of Urga resent visits by strangers to their sanctuaries, and prevent them entirely to the more holy ones. 148But there happened to be no higher official to forbid it when I stepped through the deep stone door of towering Ganden into a cluttered and musty interior, and the half-dozen young lamas of the garden variety who at first moved toward me in a mass, with a manner almost as threatening as might meet the intruder into a Mohammedan mosque, were softened by a gesture which implied the eventual bestowal of a silver ruble. Closely trailed by them I was permitted to make the circuit of the ground floor, and study from feet to knees the colossal figure of a standing Buddha which takes up almost all the space within Urga’s most lofty building. Then they urged me toward the door, but as I refused to part with the coveted coin for any such slight view they conferred together for some time in hoarse whispers. Finally one was sent to the outer entrance to make sure that none of the higher lamas was likely to drop in unexpectedly, and while two clambered before and three behind me I climbed a steep crude wooden stairway to the second story. This brought me about to the hips of the statue. In the semi-darkness of the building, filled to overflowing with hundreds of small Buddhas, with silk banners and streamers in many colors, with strings of paper prayers, with tawdry freaks of an unclean imagination and all the drab and indecent mummeries of a religion of fear, it was impossible to make out more than that the figure was of slight artistic merit, and that it was completely covered with what had every appearance of being real gold of considerable thickness. A third story on a level with its chest had low doorways at the four corners which opened upon a gallery overhung by one of the massive roofs and gave a far-reaching view of all Urga and its vicinity. Here one might have touched the massive ornamental lanterns, covered with gold, as were parts of the cornices and many of the smaller decorations. Still another half-perpendicular, makeshift stairway led to a higher gallery, carpeted with the droppings of birds and admitting light enough to show that the contents of the building were as soiled and unlaundered as the gowns of my suspicious and worried companions. This was at the level of the Buddha’s face, which resembled nothing so much as a very young “flapper” given to overindulgence in rouge, almost a babyish face, with bright crimson lips a yard long and an immature, affectionate expression that did not in the least befit a being presiding over the sullen and repulsive religion of Mongolia. Two sets of arms, one raised and the other extended in a familiar Buddhist fashion, could be made out in the gloom. Of the weight of actual gold covering the figure from sandals to coiled-snake coiffure there was no means of 149judging, but I would have been prompt to accept it in lieu of any income I could acquire in the course of a natural lifetime. One of the lamas wished to know whether we had anything in the outside world from which I came comparable to their four-story Buddha. Having in mind only ecclesiastical constructions, I could think of nothing that might be mentioned as a rival; but I might have told them of a statue on an island in the harbor of our principal city which just about equals this one in stature, without bringing in the fact that it is of tarnished bronze instead of gleaming gold.
Unlike the followers of the gentler and more compassionate Buddhism to the east and west, the unfriendly lamas of Urga dislike having strangers visit their temples and completely bar access to the more sacred ones. 148 But there happened to be no higher authority to stop me when I stepped through the massive stone door of towering Ganden into a messy, musty interior. The half-dozen young lamas who initially approached me in a group, with an attitude almost as menacing as one might encounter in a Muslim mosque, were calmed by a gesture suggesting I would eventually give them a silver ruble. Following them closely, I was allowed to walk around the ground floor and gaze from my feet to my knees at the enormous standing Buddha that occupies nearly all the space in Urga's tallest building. Then they urged me toward the door, but when I refused to part with the desired coin for such a quick glimpse, they conferred in hushed, raspy whispers. Finally, one was sent to the entrance to make sure no higher lamas would unexpectedly arrive. With two lamas leading the way and three following behind, I climbed a steep and rudely built wooden staircase to the second level. This brought me to about the statue's hips. In the dimness of the building—crammed with hundreds of small Buddhas, colorful silk banners and streamers, strings of paper prayers, tacky oddities of an unclean imagination, and all the dreary and inappropriate rituals of a fear-based religion—it was hard to discern much more than the fact that the figure had little artistic value and was entirely covered in what looked like a significant layer of real gold. A third floor aligned with its chest had low doorways at each corner leading to a balcony beneath one of the enormous roofs, providing a sweeping view of all of Urga and the surrounding area. Here, one could touch the massive decorative lanterns, also covered in gold, as well as parts of the cornices and many smaller decorations. Another steep, makeshift staircase led to an upper gallery, carpeted with bird droppings and letting in enough light to reveal that the inside of the building was as dirty and unkempt as the robes of my cautious and anxious companions. This was at the level of the Buddha’s face, which looked like a very young flapper who had gone overboard with makeup—almost a babyish face, with bright crimson lips a yard wide and an immature, loving expression that did not suit someone overseeing the gloomy and grotesque religion of Mongolia. Two sets of arms, one raised and the other stretched out in a familiar Buddhist manner, could be seen in the gloom. I had no way to gauge the actual weight of the gold covering the figure from sandals to coiled-snake hairstyle, but I would gladly accept it in place of any income I could earn in an entire lifetime. One of the lamas asked if there was anything in the outside world comparable to their four-story Buddha. Thinking only of religious buildings, I couldn’t come up with anything that could compete, but I could have mentioned a statue on an island in the harbor of our main city that nearly matches this one in height, without mentioning that it is made of tarnished bronze instead of shining gold.
It is easier to believe the tales of the old Spanish conquistadores after seeing Urga. If the capital of the Inca empire had half as many “golden roofs and cornices scintillating in the sunshine,” it would have been enough to arouse the cupidity of more saintly men than the followers of Pizarro. Gaze across the holy city of Mongolia in almost any direction, and a golden superstructure is almost certain to strike the eye. The lower story is in every case made of materials less tempting to the light-fingered, and palisades shut them in. But what burglar would not give all the rest of his earthly chances for one short half-hour of feverish, unmolested activity at any of those glittering second stories? That of the holy of holies in the monasterial section to the east of the official yamens, in particular, is of an elaborate massiveness which suggests some unlimited source of the precious yellow metal, and when the unclouded sun shines full upon it the eye can literally not endure the sight. Gold, filth, and superstition—after we have seen Urga even the least bigoted of us can understand more fully, if not completely condone, the high-handedness of a Cortez in overthrowing the heathen idols and burning the unholy temples of conquered “Gentiles.”
It's easier to believe the stories of the old Spanish conquistadors after visiting Urga. If the capital of the Inca empire had even half as many “golden roofs and cornices sparkling in the sunlight,” it would have been enough to stir the greed of even more virtuous men than Pizarro’s followers. Look around the sacred city of Mongolia in almost any direction, and you're likely to spot a golden structure catching the eye. The lower levels are always built with materials that are less tempting for thieves, and barricades keep them enclosed. But what burglar wouldn’t risk everything for just a brief, uninterrupted chance to explore those dazzling upper levels? The one in the holiest part of the monastery area to the east of the official yamens, especially, is impressively massive, suggesting some endless source of precious gold, and when the bright sun shines directly on it, it can almost be blinding. Gold, dirt, and superstition—after seeing Urga, even the least prejudiced among us can understand better, if not totally accept, the forceful actions of a Cortez in toppling the pagan idols and burning the unholy temples of the conquered “Gentiles.”
Along the sloping brown hillside just behind lama-town stands a row of whitewashed brick dagobas, the tombs of saints so holy that their bodies were not disposed of in the customary Mongol fashion. On the ledges of these, as on any projecting place inside the prayer-cylinder sheds, and indeed anywhere on holy edifices where there is room for them and it is permitted, worshipers have laid heaps of loose stones, each representing some appeal to supposedly supernatural forces. Of many another strange device in and about the mammoth temple compounds, there are the prostrating-boards, slightly inclined planks on short legs for the use of the pious during their extraordinary genuflexions before venerated shrines. With that indifference to soiling themselves for which the Mongols are conspicuous, however, the 150bare ground suffices most worshipers, and the boards do no great amount of service. The orthodox prostration so closely resembles one of the movements in great favor among our gymnasium instructors that the sight of a group of devotees, women fully as often as men, repeating it time after time in their ponderous boots and heavy garments threatens to convulse the American, at least, with laughter. Though there is no unison among the worshipers, each one performs the ceremony with a fixed rhythm which could not be more exact if a maltreated piano were pounding out the periods, so that the effect is of individual perfection of movement but utter inability to synchronize the group. The worshiper first stands at attention with his face to the shrine, as nearly like a soldier as “the conformation of the body”—not to mention the abundance of clothing—“will permit,” murmurs a prayer several times over, then bows his trunk to the horizontal, places his hands on the ground, straightens his legs to the rear, and lowers himself to the prostrate, even his nose touching the earth. There he remains a moment, then, flexing his arms until his rigid body rests on hands and toes, he regains the original position by performing the same movements in reverse order, repeating the exercise as long as piety, the weight of his sins, or his dread of evil spirits suggests. I know from experience that it is a genuine exercise even in gymnasium garb; what it is in full Mongol attire, sometimes including even the feminine head-dress, any vivid imagination can picture. No wonder the Mongols are big and strong; and what call is there for our famous gymnastico-religious organization ever to establish one of its Oriental branches in Urga? It may be just as well, perhaps, for us dilettante gymnasts of the West never to challenge a red-robed lama to bodily combat; for I have seen more than one of them make a complete circuit of some holy section of the city performing this prostration at every other step forward, leaving off at the point where night overtook them, and returning to start there again at dawn.
Along the sloping brown hillside just behind lama-town stands a row of whitewashed brick dagobas, the tombs of saints so holy that their bodies weren't buried in the usual Mongol way. On the ledges of these, as well as anywhere else inside the prayer-cylinder sheds and on other holy buildings where it’s allowed, worshipers have piled up heaps of loose stones, each one representing a plea to supposed supernatural forces. Among the many odd items in and around the huge temple complexes are the prostrating boards, slightly slanted planks on short legs for pious individuals during their intense bowing before revered shrines. However, many worshipers are perfectly fine using the bare ground to avoid soiling themselves, which is a common characteristic of the Mongols, so the boards don't get much use. The traditional prostration looks a lot like one of the exercises favored by gym instructors, and seeing a group of devotees—often as many women as men—repeating this in their heavy boots and garments could easily make an American laugh. Though there's no harmony among the worshipers, each one carries out the ritual with a precise rhythm that couldn’t be more flawless if a badly-treated piano were playing the beats. This results in individual perfection but a total lack of group synchronization. The worshiper first stands at attention facing the shrine, as soldier-like as “the shape of the body”—not to mention all the clothing—“allows,” murmurs a prayer several times, then bows down until horizontal, places his hands on the ground, straightens his legs behind him, and lowers himself to the ground, even touching his nose to the earth. He stays there for a moment, then flexes his arms until his rigid body rests on hands and toes, returns to the original position by doing the same movements in reverse, and keeps repeating the exercise as long as his devotion, the weight of his sins, or fear of evil spirits prompts him to. I know from experience that it's a genuine workout even in gym clothes; one can only imagine what it’s like in full Mongol attire, sometimes including the feminine headgear. It's no wonder the Mongols are big and strong; there’s no need for our famous gymnastic-religious organization to set up an Oriental branch in Urga. Maybe it’s for the best that us casual gymnasts in the West never challenge a red-robed lama to physical combat; I’ve seen more than one of them make a complete loop around a holy section of the city, performing this prostration with every other step, stopping only when night fell, and starting again at dawn.
Except in Lhasa, and perhaps Rome, the worshiper in Urga has an advantage seldom to be found on this earth; he may perform his pious antics, not merely before silent shrines and motionless statues, but before a living god in flesh and blood. It is a pleasant tramp for any one with unatrophied legs across the valley to the dwelling-place of the “Living Buddha.” A few small streams block his way, unless he can hit upon the stepping-stone fords of the horseless lower classes. 151But if he is a Westerner, one of the mounted lamas who are constantly jogging back and forth between the palace and the city may, out of mere curiosity to see him at close range, or because all the native benevolence of the nomad herdsman has not yet been steeped out of him by superstition and the misbehavior of other outlanders, carry him across on his crupper. Or, if the stroller is not in a mood for petty adventures, he may take the causeway. This is a road wide as a Western boulevard and perhaps half a mile long, raised on wooden trestles which carry it across the slightly lower part of the valley; but it runs, not from the section where foreigners lodge and carry on such business as is possible under present conditions, but, being designed merely for the use of the “Living Buddha” and his courtiers, it connects his palaces with those of his late sainted brother, and with the shrine topped by that most coveted golden superstructure to which he sometimes comes to be worshiped. Apparently there is nothing sacred about this roadway, however, for any one may use it, and a gang of Chinese was engaged in replacing the logs covered with earth—which spells bridge to the Oriental—of a section that had collapsed. For that matter, it is Chinese workmen who repair, as they probably originally built, the fantastic gates and the flaring tile roofs even within the sacred palace precinct, but for which concession by his holiness and the jealous preservers of his sanctity nothing probably would ever get mended.
Except for Lhasa, and maybe Rome, the worshiper in Urga has an advantage that's rarely found anywhere else on Earth; he can perform his rituals not just before quiet shrines and still statues, but in front of a living god in flesh and blood. It's a nice walk for anyone with capable legs across the valley to the “Living Buddha's” home. A few small streams might block the path unless he finds the stepping-stone fords used by the lower-class folks without horses. 151But if he’s a Westerner, one of the mounted lamas who frequently gallop back and forth between the palace and the city might, out of mere curiosity to see him up close, or because the native kindness of the nomadic herders hasn’t yet been worn down by superstition and the bad behavior of other foreigners, carry him across on his saddle. Or, if the traveler isn’t in the mood for small adventures, he can take the causeway. It’s a road as wide as a Western boulevard and about half a mile long, raised on wooden supports to cross the slightly lower area of the valley; but it doesn’t lead to where foreigners stay and conduct whatever business is possible under the current conditions. Instead, it’s meant solely for the “Living Buddha” and his entourage, connecting his palaces with those of his recently sainted brother and with the shrine topped by that highly sought-after golden structure where he sometimes comes to be worshiped. Interestingly, there seems to be nothing sacred about this road because anyone can use it, and a group of Chinese workers was busy replacing the logs covered with dirt—which means bridge to the Orient—of a section that had fallen apart. In fact, it’s Chinese workers who repair, as they probably originally built, the incredible gates and the eye-catching tile roofs even within the sacred palace grounds, but for which concession by his holiness and the protective guardians of his sanctity, nothing would likely ever get fixed.
The low chaos of roofs within his principal compound, green, yellow, blue, golden, a jumble of Chinese, Tibetan, Russian and hybrid architecture, stands out against the little lines of trees along the foot of the sacred mountains,—evergreen, white birch, and other species, now red or yellow, like the omnipresent lamas, with early autumn. A few guard-houses with a ragged armed Mongol or two lounging before them surround the place, but these picturesque sentinels do not interfere with the movements even of foreigners so long as they do not attempt to enter the sacred precincts. On special occasions non-Mongols have been permitted to pass the gates, but very, very few have ever entered the presence or even the actual dwelling of the “Living Buddha” himself, to whom even the highest of Mongols do not have free access. The elaborate gates have the same demon guards, the same isolated wall as a screen against evil spirits, and all the rest of the flummery common to such structures in China and Korea. Some of the buildings within the compound, however, might have been taken bodily from some 152cheap European, or at least Russian, town, while the confusion of the whole scheme of structures would not awaken delight in the heart of any real architect.
The chaotic mix of roofs in his main compound—green, yellow, blue, and gold—creates a jumble of Chinese, Tibetan, Russian, and hybrid architecture that stands out against the thin lines of trees at the base of the sacred mountains—evergreen, white birch, and other species, now red or yellow, just like the ever-present lamas in early autumn. A few guardhouses with a scruffy armed Mongol or two hanging around them surround the area, but these colorful sentinels don't bother foreigners as long as they don't try to enter the sacred grounds. On special occasions, non-Mongols have been allowed to pass through the gates, but very, very few have actually entered the presence or even the dwelling of the “Living Buddha” himself, to whom even the highest-ranking Mongols don’t have free access. The ornate gates have the same demon guards, the same isolated wall to protect against evil spirits, and all the typical ornamentation found in such structures in China and Korea. However, some of the buildings within the compound could be straight out of some cheap European, or at least Russian, town, and the overall layout of the structures wouldn't inspire any real architect.
The “summer palace” of the human deity, a furlong away, being more fully Tibetan, is less unpleasing to the eye. At about the same distance from the main palace in the opposite direction is almost a town of mainly modern buildings, housing the non-religious belongings and the servants of the Mongol god. His stables contain many horses; his garages have automobiles of a dozen different makes, European as well as American, not to mention the usual proportion of Fords; a Delco system lights his establishment; and most modern inventions are represented in one form or another. The “Living Buddha” buys every new contrivance the West has to offer, merely as playthings, in a vain attempt to make a noticeable inroad in a burdensome income. A foreign business man of Urga who has furnished much of it assured me that he purchases on the average ten thousand dollars “Mex” worth of assorted junk a day, things of every conceivable kind, which are petulantly tossed aside when the owner and his swarms of satellites tire of them. Many of the motor-cars rust away unused, though this modern god does all his traveling to and from his various thrones by automobile, and his chauffeur, a khaki-and-legging-clad Buriat, may frequently be seen speeding about town on the only motor-cycle in Urga.
The “summer palace” of the human deity, just a short distance away, looks more Tibetan and is less unpleasant to the eye. About the same distance from the main palace in the opposite direction is almost a town of mostly modern buildings, which house the everyday belongings and servants of the Mongol god. His stables are filled with horses; his garages hold cars from a dozen different brands, both European and American, including a typical share of Fords; a Delco system lights up his property; and most modern inventions can be found in some form. The “Living Buddha” buys every new gadget the West has to offer, just as toys, in a futile attempt to make a dent in his overwhelming income. A foreign businessman from Urga, who has supplied much of this, assured me that he spends an average of ten thousand dollars “Mex” on assorted items each day—things of every kind, which are carelessly discarded when the owner and his entourage lose interest. Many of the cars sit unused and rust away, even though this modern god does all his traveling to and from his various thrones by car, and his chauffeur, dressed in khaki and leggings, is often seen speeding around town on the only motorcycle in Urga.
In striking contrast to this modernity of his surroundings is the attitude of the Mongols toward their living god. It is something which we of the West can scarcely conceive, and which probably has no precedent among even the most pietistic creeds of the Occident. Second only to the Dalai-Lama of Lhasa in the hierarchy of lamaism, Bogda-Han, to give him one of the many titles by which he is known among Mongols, is worshiped by millions throughout a vast space of central Asia. The attribution of deity with which they invest him is due to the belief that he is a reincarnation of the original Buddha. When a “Living Buddha” dies—of which more anon—the high council of lamaism, by the consultation of certain sacred books and a deal of hocus-pocus which saner mortals would not have the interest to follow, determine where the body into which his soul has been reborn will be found. At first blush it would seem that this must be a new-born babe; but perhaps there is no nursery in the sacred palace, or no lamas of sufficient experience in that line to take charge of a puling infant. Therefore, by something corresponding to poetic license, the signs point to a boy of about nine years of age, who will be found, say, on such a corner of such streets in this or that city, doing so and so at a specified hour. A cavalcade of high lamas travel to the place indicated, which is more likely to be in Tibet than in Mongolia, capture the new and unsuspecting Buddha, and carry him off to a life of deification. It is commonly reputed in the outside world that each Buddha is quietly done away with by what we might call his cardinals at the age of eighteen, his body embalmed, and a new find installed in his place. A Russian professor long resident in Urga has been to some pains to prove that this is not true, that it is in fact mere nonsense; but he admits the curious coincidence that all the “Living Buddhas” up to the present one seem to have died at about eighteen years of age.
In stark contrast to the modernity of his surroundings is the way the Mongols view their living god. It's something we in the West can hardly imagine, and it probably doesn't have any parallel even among the most devout beliefs in the West. Second only to the Dalai Lama of Lhasa in the hierarchy of lamaism, Bogda-Han, one of the many names he's known by among the Mongols, is worshiped by millions across a vast area of central Asia. They believe he is a reincarnation of the original Buddha, which is why they see him as a deity. When a “Living Buddha” dies—more on that later—the high council of lamaism consults certain sacred texts and engages in a lot of rituals that more sensible people would find uninteresting to follow, to determine where the body into which his soul will be reborn can be found. At first glance, it seems like this must be a newborn baby; however, there might not be a nursery in the sacred palace, or no lamas with enough experience to care for an infant. So, through a sort of poetic license, they identify a boy of about nine years old, who will be found, say, at a specific street corner in this or that city, doing this or that at a certain time. A group of high lamas travels to the indicated place, which is more likely to be in Tibet than in Mongolia, captures the new and unsuspecting Buddha, and takes him away to a life of being deified. It's commonly believed in the outside world that each Buddha is quietly disposed of by what we might call his cardinals at the age of eighteen, his body embalmed, and a new one put in place. A Russian professor who has lived in Urga for a long time has made an effort to prove that this is not true, that it's actually just nonsense; but he acknowledges the strange coincidence that all the “Living Buddhas” up to the current one appear to have died around the age of eighteen.

The market in front of Hansen’s house. The structure on the extreme left is not what it looks like, for they have no such in Urga but it houses a prayer-cylinder
The market in front of Hansen’s house. The building on the far left isn’t what it seems, because they don’t have anything like that in Urga, but it contains a prayer cylinder.

A youthful lama turning one of the myriad prayer-cylinders of Urga. Many written prayers are pasted inside, and each turn is equivalent to saying all of them
A young lama spinning one of the many prayer wheels in Urga. Inside, there are numerous written prayers, and each spin counts as saying all of them.

Women, whose crippled feet make going to the shops difficult, do much of their shopping from the two-boxes-on-a-pole type of merchant, constant processions of whom tramp the highways of China
Women, whose injured feet make it hard to go shopping, often buy from the two-boxes-on-a-pole type of vendor, who constantly walk the highways of China.

An itinerant blacksmith-shop, with the box-bellows worked by a stick handle widely used by craftsmen and cooks in China
An traveling blacksmith shop, with the box bellows operated by a stick handle commonly used by craftsmen and cooks in China.
153The present one played in unusual luck. To an even greater extent than his predecessors he took advantage of his position to become the Don Juan of Mongolia, and among his many light-o’-loves there was one to whom he wished to stick—or who decided to stick to him. Being a god is very convenient at times. This one calmly overruled the time-honored law that lamas, and especially “Living Buddhas,” may not marry—though of course this verb does not exactly fit the case—and attached the minx to him for life. She seems to have some such power over men as did the old Empress Dowager of China, an impression borne out by her masterful face in such photographs of her as are extant. Not only did she succeed in saving her paramour from the usual fate in his youth, but she so strengthened his position that he is still on his deified throne at an age variously reckoned at from fifty to sixty. Some explain this survival in another way: there were, they say, to have been a fixed number of reincarnations of the Buddha, of which this is the last, after which, we are led to infer, the stainless soul will pass into Nirvana; and of course a few years more or less of hanging back from that blissful state can do no one any harm, least of all in the Orient, where the sense of time is so nearly paralyzed. Even among those who do not accept this view there are many who claim that there will never be another “Living Buddha” in Mongolia, for political rather than lamaistic reasons.
153This current one experienced quite a bit of luck. Even more than his predecessors, he took advantage of his status to become the Don Juan of Mongolia, and among his many flings, there was one he wanted to stick with—or who decided to stick with him. Being a god has its perks sometimes. He confidently disregarded the long-standing rule that lamas, especially “Living Buddhas,” cannot marry—though the term doesn't exactly apply here—and kept the flirtatious woman by his side for life. She seems to have a hold over men similar to that of the old Empress Dowager of China, a notion supported by her commanding presence in the photos that survive of her. Not only did she manage to save her lover from the typical fate many face in their youth, but she also solidified his position so that he remains on his deified throne, with his age estimated to be somewhere between fifty and sixty. Some explain his continued existence differently: they say there were meant to be a set number of reincarnations of the Buddha, and this is the last one, after which, as we gather, the pure soul will enter Nirvana; and certainly, a few extra years of delaying that ultimate state can’t hurt anyone, especially in the East, where the perception of time is almost suspended. Even among those who don’t share this belief, many assert that there will never be another “Living Buddha” in Mongolia, for reasons more political than spiritual.
The fact is, probably, that while the masterfulness of his consort had something to do with the survival of the present reincarnation, the powerful clique about him has been willing to permit it because of his weakness, which has prevented him from ever grasping any real authority. Since his gallant youth he has been tainted with that dread disease so wide-spread among the Mongols, which not only makes him 154a semi-invalid easily manipulated by the real power behind his pseudo-divinity, but which left him some years ago stone-blind. Because he is too sacred to be touched by impious hands, there was no way of curing him, and now it is too late. Besides, the high lamas preferred him sickly and supine rather than well and strong, not to mention the almost complete ignorance among the Mongols of the real nature of their well nigh universal ailment.
The truth is, likely, that while his partner's skill played a role in the survival of this current incarnation, the powerful group around him has allowed it to continue because of his weakness, which has kept him from ever really taking authority. Since his brave youth, he has been afflicted with that terrible disease so common among the Mongols, which not only turns him into a semi-invalid easily controlled by the real power behind his fake divinity, but which also left him completely blind a few years ago. Because he is considered too sacred to be touched by unholy hands, there was no way to cure him, and now it’s too late. Furthermore, the high lamas preferred him weak and submissive rather than healthy and strong, not to mention the widespread ignorance among the Mongols regarding the true nature of their almost universally shared illness.
Perhaps his blindness increases his divinity in the minds of the faithful, as a sightless witch often wins more followers than one with all her senses intact. At any rate, Mongols of all classes treat their living fetish with divine honors. Pilgrims come from all over central Asia to prostrate themselves on the ground or the prayer-boards outside his compound; on special days they are blessed, not by his actual appearance in person—for visibility often breeds contempt, and the physical labor of being a god should be reduced to a minimum—but by being tapped on the heads with a contrivance in the hands of middle-class lamas to which is attached a rope the other end of which is grasped, hypothetically at least, by the “Living Buddha” seated on his throne inside his central palace. So divine is he that notwithstanding his infirmity the excretions of his body are collected in silver and gold vessels, sealed, and sent out among the credulous as a cure for their infirmities! Foreigners who have chanced to catch a glimpse of him on his way to or from the city temples to pray for rain—he has, of course, the latest and best thing in barometers—or some other ceremony, describe him as being more cleanly dressed than is the Mongol custom, but otherwise quite like any other lama of high class, plus a kind of gold crown. Close inspection might reveal that this alleged pulchritude is an exaggeration—I am skeptical of the possibility of combining cleanliness and Mongol—but that has never been permitted a foreigner.
Perhaps his blindness enhances his divinity in the eyes of the faithful, just like a sightless witch often attracts more followers than one with all her senses. Regardless, Mongols of all classes treat their living idol with divine honors. Pilgrims come from all over Central Asia to bow down on the ground or on prayer boards outside his compound; on special days they receive blessings, not from his actual presence—because being seen often leads to disdain, and the physical demands of being a god should be kept minimal—but by being tapped on the head with a device held by middle-class lamas, attached to a rope that is, hypothetically at least, held by the "Living Buddha" seated on his throne inside his main palace. So divine is he that, despite his infirmity, his bodily excretions are collected in silver and gold vessels, sealed, and distributed among the gullible as a remedy for their ailments! Foreigners who happen to catch a glimpse of him on his way to or from the city temples to pray for rain—he has, of course, the latest and best barometers—or for some other ceremony, describe him as being more neatly dressed than the Mongol custom, but otherwise just like any other high-class lama, plus a sort of gold crown. A close look might reveal that this supposed beauty is an exaggeration—I’m skeptical about the possibility of combining cleanliness and Mongol—but that has never been allowed for a foreigner.
While no manifestos are issued commanding the foreigner to remain within doors and avert his face, as was long the case when the emperor of China made his annual journey to sacrifice to the Altar of Heaven in Peking, armed guards as well as pious fanatics see to it that the divine being is not too nearly approached during his passing to and fro about Urga. No later ago than the month of my visit a group of Americans in an automobile were halted on one side of the unmarked route over which the “Living Buddha” was to return from the temple where he was just then enthroned, and compelled to get out and walk across it. As a special concession to the spirit of modernity, when the insistent guards were reminded that the abandoned machine could not 155advance of its own will, they permitted the chauffeur to climb in again and technically break the divine law by riding across the prospective trail of the blind god.
While there are no official declarations telling foreigners to stay indoors and avoid looking at him, as was the case when the emperor of China made his annual trip to offer sacrifices at the Altar of Heaven in Beijing, armed guards and zealous followers make sure that the divine figure isn’t approached too closely during his travels around Urga. Just last month, a group of Americans in a car was stopped on one side of the unmarked road where the “Living Buddha” was returning from the temple where he was recently enthroned, and they were forced to get out and walk across it. In a nod to modern times, when the persistent guards were reminded that the parked car couldn’t move on its own, they allowed the driver to get back in and technically break the divine rule by driving across the future path of the blind god.
Tibetan, as I have said, is the Latin of lamaism. Even in Peking, where branch clusters of the faith exist, only two or three temples are permitted, by special dispensation, to carry on their services in Mongolian, and there is said to be only one in Asia where Chinese is used. The great stone letters on the flank of the sacred mountain, visible as far off as the eye can reach, are Tibetan characters. From Tibet come numbers of lamas, and orders tending to keep the ritual more orthodox; the Dalai-Lama himself once fled before foreign invaders to Urga. Neither these seekers after Nirvana from Lhasa and vicinity nor the traders from the more northern parts of Tibet make the journey now by the direct overland route. Not only are there bleak mountains and vast morasses, dreary despoblados without a sign of man for days, and the fanatical Mohammedan province of Kansu to cross, but in these settled times there are real dangers from bandits of several nationalities. So the beaten trail of to-day, except for those Tibetan divinities who come by sea, like any tourist, leads down through northern India and across into central China, thence northward through the former Celestial Empire, which still claims, if in vain, jurisdiction over all Outer Mongolia.
Tibetan, as I mentioned, is the Latin of Lamaism. Even in Beijing, where there are branches of the faith, only two or three temples are allowed, by special permission, to conduct their services in Mongolian, and there's reportedly only one in Asia that uses Chinese. The large stone letters on the side of the sacred mountain, visible as far as the eye can see, are Tibetan characters. Many lamas come from Tibet, and there are orders that help keep the rituals more traditional; the Dalai Lama himself once fled from foreign invaders to Urga. Neither the seekers of Nirvana from Lhasa and nearby areas nor the traders from the more northern parts of Tibet now take the direct land route. Not only are there harsh mountains and vast swamps, dreary desolate places without a trace of humanity for days, and the fanatical Muslim province of Kansu to navigate, but in these settled times there are real dangers from bandits of various nationalities. So the common route today, aside from the Tibetan deities who arrive by sea like any tourist, leads down through northern India and across into central China, then north through the former Celestial Empire, which still claims, though in vain, authority over all of Outer Mongolia.
There is nothing more pleasant than a stroll on a brilliant autumn day across the golden-brown rolling plains about Urga, especially to the north and east, where they roll ever higher until all the holy city, to its most distant and isolated clusters of temples, lies spread out before one. No suggestion of modern industry breaks the peaceful quiet, which is enhanced by the law forbidding hunting or any other interference with wild creatures within a circuit of about twelve miles about the residence of Bogda-Han. Great flocks of pigeons fly up in purple-blue clouds only when the stroller has almost walked them down; less charming birds show a similar lack of fear of man; in the low forest along the crest of the sacred mountain roam elk, wild pigs, deer, bears, wolves, some say even moose and reindeer, not to mention many smaller and more harmless animals. Yet there is something ominous rather than tranquil and inviting about the scene as a whole; the Elysian charm is sullied and broken by various repelling things, particularly by the inhuman Mongol method of disposing of the dead.
There’s nothing more enjoyable than a walk on a beautiful autumn day across the golden-brown rolling plains near Urga, especially to the north and east, where they rise higher until the entire holy city, with its most distant and secluded temples, is laid out before you. There’s no hint of modern industry disturbing the peaceful quiet, which is further enhanced by the law that prohibits hunting or any other interference with wildlife within a twelve-mile radius of Bogda-Han's residence. Huge flocks of pigeons take off in purple-blue clouds only when you’re almost upon them; less charming birds show a similar lack of fear of humans. In the low forest along the ridge of the sacred mountain, elk, wild boars, deer, bears, and wolves roam, and some even say moose and reindeer can be spotted, not to mention many smaller and harmless creatures. Yet, the overall scene feels more ominous than tranquil and inviting; the idyllic charm is tarnished by various disturbing elements, particularly the inhumane Mongol practices for dealing with the dead.
This consists simply, except in rare cases of reputed gods or demigods, of feeding the corpses of all to the dogs. There seems to be 156nothing corresponding to a funeral service. Foreign residents say that formerly it was the custom to load the body on a two-wheeled cart and drive pell-mell across the hillocks until it fell off, the driver not daring to look back under penalty of having all the evil spirits which inhabited the dead man enter his own body. Others say they have sometimes seen a kind of procession of lamas and relatives follow the corpse to the hills and stand some little distance off watching its consumption. Certainly in the great majority of cases there is no more ceremony involved than in tossing garbage on the nearest dump. There are no fixed spots for depositing the bodies, but they are thrown hit or miss on the outer edges of the town, often right beside the main trails and especially in the shallow, verdureless gullies breaking up the wrinkled brown country about it.
This mainly involves, except in rare cases involving reputed gods or demigods, feeding the bodies to dogs. There doesn't seem to be anything like a funeral service. People from other places say that it used to be customary to load the body onto a two-wheeled cart and drive recklessly over the hills until it fell off, with the driver too scared to look back for fear that all the evil spirits that inhabited the dead person would enter his own body. Others report having occasionally seen a sort of procession of lamas and relatives following the body to the hills, keeping a distance and watching it be consumed. In most cases, there is no more ceremony than tossing garbage onto the nearest dump. There are no designated places for disposing of the bodies; they’re simply tossed randomly on the outskirts of town, often right next to the main paths and especially in the shallow, barren gullies that break up the dry, brown landscape surrounding it.
One must be on the ground early after a death to find enough of the body left to recognize it as more than a broken skeleton. The big black dogs, covered with long shaggy hair, which dot the landscape everywhere in and about Urga, filling its streets with murderous-looking eyes that keep the pedestrian on the constant qui vive, have learned their task well from many generations of practice. The rapidity with which they can reduce what was a sentient, moving being the day before to a mere sprinkling of broken bones is astonishing. This doubly endears these loathsome beasts to the Mongols, for they believe that the more quickly a body is eaten the better man does this prove the deceased to have been in life. It is especial good luck and proof of unusual sanctity to see the body eaten by birds, but the dogs rarely leave their feathered rivals an opportunity thus to bear testimony to the character of the departed. The birds have their turn after the dogs have given up hope of deriving further benefit from their exertions, and finish off the job by cleaning out the skull and the other morsels for which a bill is needed.
One must arrive early after a death to find enough of the body left to recognize it as more than just a broken skeleton. The big black dogs, covered in long shaggy fur, are everywhere in and around Urga, their murderous-looking eyes filling the streets and keeping pedestrians constantly alert. These dogs have learned their role well through generations of practice. The speed with which they can reduce what was once a sentient, living being into a mere scattering of bones is astonishing. This actually makes these loathsome creatures even more endearing to the Mongols, who believe that the quicker a body is consumed, the better the person must have been in life. It's considered especially lucky and a sign of unusual sanctity to see a body eaten by birds, but the dogs rarely give their feathered counterparts a chance to bear witness to the departed's character. The birds get their turn only after the dogs have given up hope of getting anything more from their efforts, finishing the job by clearing out the skull and other bits that require a beak.
There is nothing either hidden or sacred about these graveless graveyards. Any one may stroll through them, and find them quite as abandoned as any city dump-heap. Dog-nests made of the ragged quilted cloaks in which the bodies are carried out are the only conspicuous feature, except the skulls which lie about everywhere. I wondered at first that there were never any remains of the skeleton except widely scattered and broken bones, until I beheld a dog pick up a rib and carry it off to a comfortable spot on the hillside, there to sit down on his haunches, break it in two, and gnaw the last scrap of nourishment out of it. In the dry desert air the skulls quickly bleach snow-white 157and brittle; only here and there is one still “green” enough to be gray in color, so solid as to pain the toe that kicks it across the plain. These vast bone-yards are no place for the Westerner, living on his over-refined food, to spend the hour before an appointment with his dentist, for his envy of the full sets of perfect white teeth in almost every skull may become overwhelming.
There’s nothing hidden or sacred about these unmarked graveyards. Anyone can walk through them and find them as neglected as any city dump. The only noticeable feature is the dog nests made from the tattered quilted cloaks that the bodies are wrapped in, except for the skulls scattered everywhere. At first, I was surprised that there were never any complete skeletons, only broken and scattered bones, until I saw a dog pick up a rib and take it to a comfortable spot on the hillside, where it sat down, broke it in half, and gnawed the last bit of food off it. In the dry desert air, the skulls quickly turn snow-white and brittle; only a few remain “green” enough to be gray, so solid that if you kick one across the ground, it will hurt your toe. These vast bone yards are no place for a Westerner, who is used to overly refined food, to spend time before visiting the dentist, as his envy of the perfect white teeth in almost every skull might become too much to handle. 157
It seems to be the idea of these putative Buddhists, the Mongols, and of their brethren, the Buriats and Kalmucks, who follow the same custom, that, since all living creatures are brothers, the least a man can do for his dumb fellow-beings is to bequeath them his useless body as nourishment—and thereby, of course, win merit that will improve his reincarnation. The Tibetans do likewise, except that they feed their mountain eagles or condors as well as their dogs, and prepare the food for the latter by mixing it with ground grain. Gruesome as the custom is, there is a thoroughness and promptitude about it which greatly outdoes the Christian mode of burial, a real and visible return of “dust to dust.” I know of no other means of disposing of the dead which gives the corpse so nearly its true value, none which leaves such a true sense of the worthlessness of human remains. Between this and the opposite extreme of an elaborate funeral followed by a showy mausoleum I am not sure but that I prefer the Mongol method.
It seems that these supposed Buddhists, the Mongols, and their relatives, the Buriats and Kalmucks, who follow the same tradition, believe that since all living beings are connected, the least a person can do for their voiceless companions is to offer them their useless body as food—and in doing so, of course, earn merit that will enhance their next life. The Tibetans do the same; however, they also feed their mountain eagles or condors along with their dogs, preparing the food for the latter by mixing it with ground grain. As gruesome as this practice may seem, there is a thoroughness and immediacy about it that greatly surpasses the Christian way of burial, providing a real and visible return of “dust to dust.” I don’t know of any other way to dispose of the dead that reflects the true value of a corpse so accurately, or that conveys such a clear sense of the insignificance of human remains. Between this and the opposite extreme of an elaborate funeral with a flashy mausoleum, I might actually prefer the Mongol approach.
To the Mongols themselves there is no more sanctity about their scattered bones than about any other form of rubbish. Shepherds or others whose calling brings them there wander or sit about the skull-strewn gullies quite as calmly as if they were in a field of daisies. Relatives seldom if ever come to pick up any of the remains; sometimes the rains wash broken bones down the gullies into the edge of town, where they lie until they are covered up with silt and disappear. Most of them simply disintegrate into the semi-desert soil about them. There is never a sign that the Mongol riding by feels any distress at the thought that some day these same surly black dogs that are tearing to pieces the corpse at the roadside will do the same for him. The tops of skulls, especially of higher lamas and men of standing, are sometimes used as drinking-vessels, or as oil-receptacles in the temples, and specially sainted thigh-bones make excellent whistles for use in ritualistic uproars; otherwise no one seems to have thought of the commercial possibilities of the bone-yards. Nor are these strange people, who might punish with death the stranger who forced his way into the presence of their living god, in the least sensitive about the possession of their remains. A high lama dropped in upon my host 158one day and chanced to spy a skull-top that had just been presented by some native admirer. He picked it up, looked it over carefully, held it up to a light, and announced that the original owner had been a very good man, proof of which was the condition of the zigzag joints and the fact that the skull was so thin in one spot that the light showed rosy red through it. Perhaps, he added, as he laid it back on the bric-à-brac table and accepted a cigarette, it had been the skull of his good old friend Lama So-and-so.
To the Mongols, their scattered bones hold no more significance than any other kind of trash. Shepherds or others who come through the area wander around the skull-strewn gullies just as casually as if they were in a field of daisies. Relatives rarely, if ever, come to collect any remains; sometimes the rain washes broken bones down the gullies into the outskirts of town, where they sit until covered in silt and disappear. Most just break down into the semi-desert soil around them. There's never any indication that the Mongol passing by feels any sadness at the thought that one day the same surly black dogs tearing apart a corpse by the roadside will do the same to him. The tops of skulls, especially from higher lamas and respected individuals, are sometimes used as drinking vessels or oil containers in temples, and specially revered thigh bones make great whistles for use in ritual noise; otherwise, no one seems to have considered the potential commercial value of the bone yards. These peculiar people, who could punish a stranger with death for intruding on their living god, are surprisingly indifferent about the handling of their remains. One day, a high lama visited my host and happened to notice a skull cap that had just been given as a present by a local admirer. He picked it up, examined it closely, held it up to the light, and declared that the original owner had been a very good man, as evidenced by the condition of the zigzag joints and the fact that the skull was so thin in one area that light shone through it in a rosy red. Perhaps, he added, as he put it back on the decorative table and took a cigarette, it had belonged to his good old friend Lama So-and-so.
If I may hazard a guess, it is that this to us gruesome custom has grown up among the Mongols because they are nomads. They cannot carry the graves of their ancestors with them, whereas the dogs will follow of their own accord. Their attitude toward these surly black beasts without owners, which roam the plains as well as make every street of Urga a gauntlet, bears out this impression. Though they are as quick as we to beat them off with any weapon when they get too aggressive, they deeply resent a serious injury to or the killing of one of them by a frightened foreigner. Yet the tendency of any Westerner would be to do just that; I know of few assignments that would give me more satisfaction than to lead a regiment to Urga and exterminate her swarming dogs. Most of them seem to have acquired the disease most prevalent among those they feed upon, and one feels that the slightest bite would prove fatal. Luckily they spend the day largely in sleeping and making love, so that the streets are not always as dangerous as they might be. But they easily gather in packs, and especially at night or during the long hungry winters they are a distinct menace not merely to women and children but to the hardiest men. They are really cowards, these man-eating dogs of Mongolia, as the shrinking look in their tigerish eyes when they are effectively threatened proves; yet they are so accustomed to human flesh that man is to them natural prey, and they seem to have developed a knowledge of human anatomy which tells them where to attack most effectively, as well as what tidbits to prefer when they are not especially hungry. Urga is full of stories of the inability of these ugly beasts to await the natural end of their predestined victims. A man making his way late at night across the noisome market-place outside our window had been dragged down and eaten during the past winter. By poetic justice, he was a lama. In the outskirts just back of one of the temple compounds a Buriat woman was pulled off her horse and devoured one cold winter day before those looking on could come to her rescue. A year or so before, a Russian colonel newly arrived dined late with friends, who 159asked him as he left whether they could not give him an escort, or at least lend him a cudgel. No, indeed, replied the departing guest, a Russian officer could not be afraid; besides, he had his sword. Next morning the sword and a few buttons and rags were all that could be found of the colonel.
If I had to guess, this gruesome custom likely developed among the Mongols because they are nomadic. They can’t carry the graves of their ancestors with them, but the dogs will follow on their own. Their attitude towards these cranky black dogs that roam the plains and turn every street in Urga into a hazard supports this idea. While they are just as quick to defend themselves with any weapon when the dogs get too aggressive, they strongly dislike it when a scared foreigner seriously injures or kills one of them. However, any Westerner would likely react that way; I can’t think of any job that would give me more satisfaction than leading a group to Urga to wipe out those swarming dogs. Most of them seem to be infected with the disease most common among their prey, and it feels like even the slightest bite could be deadly. Luckily, they mostly spend their days sleeping and mating, so the streets aren’t always as dangerous as they could be. But they can easily pack together, and especially at night or during the long, hungry winters, they pose a real threat not only to women and children but also to the toughest men. These man-eating dogs of Mongolia are really cowards; the scared looks in their tiger-like eyes when they feel truly threatened show that. Yet they are so used to human flesh that people are just natural prey for them, and it seems they’ve developed an understanding of human anatomy that tells them the best spots to attack, as well as what tasty bits to go for when they’re not especially hungry. Urga has many stories about these ugly beasts not being able to wait for the natural end of their intended victims. A man crossing the filthy marketplace outside our window late at night was dragged down and eaten this past winter. Ironically, he was a lama. On the outskirts, just behind one of the temple grounds, a Buriat woman was pulled off her horse and devoured one cold winter day before anyone could help her. A year or so earlier, a newly arrived Russian colonel had dinner with friends and when he left, they asked if he wanted an escort or at least a club for protection. No, he insisted, a Russian officer shouldn’t be afraid; besides, he had his sword. The next morning, all that was found of the colonel were his sword, a few buttons, and some ragged pieces of clothing.
CHAPTER X
Everyone is their own diplomat.
If I found time to see all Urga during my stay there it must have been due to the fact that it is not, after all, a large city, for most of my waking hours were of necessity spent in the various yamens. First, every new-comer must have a passport to remain in town; then we had to get permission from the war minister to carry them before our guns could be returned to us; there were endless negotiations involved in the matter of my confiscated kodak and films; finally, to mention only the high spots, any one leaving the country must have still another passport and fulfil numerous formalities. All these things would still have left some of my eleven days in Urga free if Mongol functionaries worked with even the deliberate speed of our own. But nowhere in all the Orient itself, probably, is the Oriental conception of time more fully developed, and when it came to shifting from one official or yamen to another a question on which no one wished to assume responsibility, these nomad herdsmen turned ink-daubers could “pass the buck” in a way to make our most experienced army officers green with envy.
If I had time to explore all of Urga during my stay, it’s likely because it isn't a big city. Most of my waking hours were spent dealing with the various yamens. First, every newcomer needs a passport to stay in town; then we had to get permission from the war minister to carry them before we could get our guns back. There were endless negotiations over my confiscated camera and films; and, just to highlight a few, anyone leaving the country must have yet another passport and complete numerous formalities. All of this would have left me with some of my eleven days in Urga free if Mongol officials worked at even the slow pace of our own. But nowhere else in the Orient does the concept of time seem so fully developed, and when transitioning between one official or yamen to another over a question that no one wanted to take responsibility for, these nomadic herdsmen who turned into bureaucrats could “pass the buck” in a way that would make our most seasoned army officers green with envy.

Pious Mongol men and women worshiping before the residence of the “Living Buddha” of Urga, some by throwing themselves down scores of times on the prostrating-boards placed for that purpose, one by making many circuits of the place, now and again measuring his length on the ground
Pious Mongol men and women praying in front of the residence of the “Living Buddha” of Urga, some by repeatedly throwing themselves down on the prostration boards set up for that purpose, and one person making several laps around the area, occasionally lying flat on the ground.

The Mongols of Urga dispose of their dead by throwing the bodies out on the hillsides, where they are quickly devoured by the savage black dogs that roam everywhere
The Mongols of Urga handle their dead by tossing the bodies onto the hillsides, where they're quickly eaten by the fierce black dogs that are found everywhere.

Mongol women in full war-paint
Mongol women in full war paint

Though it was still only September, our return from Urga was not unlike a polar expedition
Though it was still only September, our return from Urga felt a lot like a polar expedition.
161Every American is his own diplomat in Urga, where no nation except Russia has official representatives, so that most of our dealings were with cabinet members, especially with the minister of foreign affairs. He was a typical high-class Mongol, with greasy cue and soiled silk gown, whose qualifications for his office were that he spoke Chinese, though those who know Urga politics say he is a man of ability and the most powerful of the Mongols in the present Government. The prime minister, though a lama and a saint not many degrees below Bogda-Han himself, resembled all the others in appearance, except of course for his missing cue and certain details of dress. All the yamens were much like that of justice, to which we had the first introduction. Scores of booted and quilt-robed functionaries squatted on the cushioned platforms about the rooms of frame buildings that would be described as European, though they were built by the Chinese. An honest day’s work for any one of them seemed to be the scratching full of upright words with a weazel-hair brush of a two-foot strip of flimsy tissue-paper, the more careful copying of which would constitute their next daily contribution. The fastening of a portrait on the flimsiest of passports known to diplomatic circles, by sewing it in with pink silk thread and securing the knot with a wax seal many times heavier than all the rest of the document, left the man who accomplished it a sensation similar to that of the famous village smithy on his way to his night’s repose. The filing of a corresponding caricature of the applicant in the national archives was usually turned over to another functionary, in order to equalize the arduous toil. Then, too, no member of the staff wished to miss anything of interest. Every scrap of letter or document which we presented must be carefully examined by the whole yamen force; if it was in Mongolian, each one, from the assistant minister who would eventually take it in to his chief down to the youth who prepared the sealing-wax and wore over his eyes the black, bandit-like horsehair bandage which is the Mongol substitute for eye-glasses, must read it from end to end, which meant that we were forced to listen to the same meaningless song a score of times, for the Mongol cannot read without singing the words aloud. In my efforts to convince the Government of the harmlessness of the snap-shotting I should do about town if they would be so kind as to return my apparatus, I ran across some copies of the most photographic of our monthly magazines, and carried them to the yamens. These created unrivaled interest. All other work, slight as it always was, invariably was abandoned forthwith, and the combined force took to studying and discussing the pictures, their capped heads crowded closely together. When, hours after our arrival, it came time for the minister to give us his attention, he, too, must spend half the afternoon looking at the magazines, and end by telling us to come to-morrow when he could find time to make a decision. The advertisements won fully as much and quite as serious attention as the genuine photographs in the letter-press, which proved another cause for delay. For I challenge any one to explain in English turned into Russian and finally into Mongolian that there is really no curious race of dwarfs in America in spite of the picture of a merry tot barely exceeding in height the can of soup beside which he has stood for years in so many of our national publications.
161Every American in Urga acts as their own diplomat, since only Russia has official representatives here. Most of our interactions were with cabinet members, especially the foreign affairs minister. He was a typical high-class Mongol, with a greasy braid and a dirty silk gown; his main qualification for the role was that he spoke Chinese. However, those familiar with Urga politics say he’s capable and the most influential Mongol in the current government. The prime minister, although a lama and a holy man just a few ranks below Bogda-Han himself, looked similar to the others, except for his missing braid and some differences in his attire. All the yamens resembled the justice office we first visited. Dozens of booted, quilt-robed officials sat on cushioned platforms in frame buildings that seemed European but were built by the Chinese. It appeared that an honest day’s work for them consisted of meticulously writing upright words with a weasel-hair brush on a two-foot strip of flimsy tissue paper; careful copies of this would form their next daily output. Attaching a portrait to the flimsiest passport known in diplomatic circles by sewing it with pink silk thread and sealing it with a wax seal much heavier than the rest of the document made the person who did it feel something like the famous village blacksmith after a long day’s work. Filing a corresponding caricature of the applicant in the national archives was usually handed over to another official to balance the workload. Additionally, no staff member wanted to miss anything interesting. Every scrap of letter or document we presented had to be thoroughly reviewed by the entire yamen staff. If it was in Mongolian, everyone from the assistant minister, who would eventually present it to his superior, down to the young guy preparing the sealing wax and sporting a black horsehair band around his eyes as a Mongolian substitute for glasses, had to read it aloud, which meant we’d have to listen to the same meaningless tune over and over, as Mongolians can’t read without vocalizing the words. In my attempts to convince the government of how harmless my photography around town would be if they returned my equipment, I stumbled upon copies of our most visual monthly magazines and brought them to the yamens. These sparked unprecedented interest. All other activities, no matter how trivial, were immediately set aside as the whole group gathered to study and discuss the pictures, their capped heads huddled together. When it was finally time for the minister to meet with us hours later, he, too, spent half the afternoon flipping through the magazines, ultimately telling us to come back tomorrow when he could find time to make a decision. The advertisements received just as much serious attention as the actual photographs in the publications, which caused more delays. I challenge anyone to explain in English, which is then translated into Russian and finally into Mongolian, that there’s really no strange race of dwarfs in America, despite the picture of a cheerful little kid who barely exceeds the height of the soup can he’s stood by for years in many of our national magazines.
However, we came to know official Mongolia well, and to find some of these functionaries pleasant and almost lovable fellows underneath their curious garb and their atrophied sense of the value of 162time. Eventually, too, we got results from our endless squatting about the yamens. Exactly a week after our arrival, when we had seen almost every one in ostensible authority in Mongolia except Bogda-Han himself, a soldier came to summon us to the Okhrana, and before the afternoon was gone our guns and cartridges were actually returned to us. True, the strap had been stolen from my companion’s rifle, and we were “squeezed” again in veritable Chinese fashion in the payment of the fees involved, as with our passports, by being forced to pay in “Mex” dollars instead of the legal rubles and copecks; but we had long since lost any inclination to trouble over trifles. Besides, the lumps of silver in which Mongol government employees are intermittently paid do not constitute large salaries. Permission to shoot lead, however, was not the chief motive of my yamen-chasing; I wished to turn my kodak on some of the curious types of Urga. The foreign minister having at length given me verbal permission to do so, I spent a morning in the office of the military staff—a dismal pair of little rooms occupied by a dozen gloomy and shoddy-clad Russian men and women dawdling over maps and translations—and finally interviewed the chief of staff himself. He was a tall, aristocratic-looking Russian who had been a major under the czar, but who held, of course, no rank in the “Red” scheme of things, though a kind of Cossack uniform flapped about his emaciated form and he occupied a position which in other lands would have called for at least a colonel. My hopes rose high, for here at last was a man with human intelligence enough to know that my simple request did not mean treason to the state. When the new supplication I was asked to write had been turned into Russian, he took it personally to the war minister. The interview was long, and though I was not invited to it myself, I knew that my case was being thoroughly discussed, for the minister spent some time in staring at me out of the window. Then the chief of staff returned my request with an annotation by his ostensible superior that the war department was quite willing to grant me the requested permission—if the minister of foreign affairs would also do so! I thought the struggle was won at last and that it was merely a question of awaiting the final papers with Mongolian patience; for had not the foreign minister already given such permission, if only by word of mouth? I no longer took with a grain of salt, however, the statement of my host that he had made twenty-one visits to the yamens for the simple purpose of getting a permit to ship some of his own horses out of the country.
However, we got to know official Mongolia pretty well and found some of these officials to be nice and almost lovable guys underneath their peculiar outfits and their weak appreciation for time. Eventually, we saw results from our endless waiting around at the yamens. Exactly one week after our arrival, when we had met almost everyone in supposed authority in Mongolia except for Bogda-Han himself, a soldier came to summon us to the Okhrana, and before the afternoon was over, our guns and ammo were actually returned to us. True, the strap had been stolen from my companion’s rifle, and we were “squeezed” again in classic Chinese style with the payment of the fees involved, as with our passports, being forced to pay in “Mex” dollars instead of the legal rubles and kopecks; but we had long since stopped worrying about small matters. Besides, the lumps of silver that Mongolian government employees are intermittently paid don’t add up to big salaries. However, getting to shoot lead wasn’t my main reason for chasing through the yamens; I wanted to take some photos of the interesting characters in Urga. After finally getting verbal permission from the foreign minister, I spent a morning in the office of the military staff — a dreary pair of small rooms filled with a dozen gloomy and poorly-dressed Russian men and women fiddling with maps and translations — and eventually interviewed the chief of staff himself. He was a tall, aristocratic-looking Russian who had been a major under the czar, but of course held no rank in the “Red” system, even though a sort of Cossack uniform hung loosely on his thin frame and he held a position that would have required at least a colonel's rank in other countries. I felt hopeful, for here was a man smart enough to recognize that my simple request didn’t mean treason against the state. When the new request I was asked to write was translated into Russian, he personally took it to the war minister. The meeting was lengthy, and although I wasn’t invited to attend, I knew my case was being thoroughly discussed, as the minister spent a while looking at me from the window. Then the chief of staff returned my request with a note from his apparent superior saying that the war department was definitely willing to grant me the requested permission — if the minister of foreign affairs would also agree! I thought the battle was finally won and that it was just a matter of waiting for the final papers with Mongolian patience; after all, hadn’t the foreign minister already given such permission, even if just verbally? However, I no longer took lightly my host’s claim that he had made twenty-one visits to the yamens simply to get a permit to ship some of his own horses out of the country.
163Two days after this appeal to the chief of staff a soldier met me in the street and handed me a Mongol document. Every one having promised me permission to use my kodak again, I called at once at the Okhrana and asked that it be returned to me. The surly, slouch-hatted churl at the head of that institution, after letting me stand the usual half-hour without deigning to acknowledge my existence, looked at me in a queer way and grumbled something about “to-morrow.” Perhaps the document in my hand was not what I fancied it to be. I went out to have it translated.
163Two days after I reached out to the chief of staff, a soldier approached me in the street and handed me a Mongol document. Since everyone had promised to let me use my camera again, I went straight to the Okhrana and requested it back. The grumpy guy in the slouch hat who ran that place made me wait the usual half-hour without acknowledging me. He looked at me oddly and mumbled something about “tomorrow.” Maybe the document I had wasn’t what I thought it was. I left to get it translated.
It is only by the exercise of the sternest self-control that I refrain from quoting that remarkable paper in its entirety. Not that it ranks high as a literary production, nor that it is intrinsically of any particular interest; but there are probably few better specimens of that frankness in diplomatic relations between nations which has been of late so loudly demanded. Written on the usual long strip of tissue-paper folded crosswise and opening like an accordion, it proved to contain a yard or more of perpendicular Mongol script, authenticated at both ends by the big square red stamp of an official seal. A lengthy preamble led up to the statement that, “inasmuch as an individual named S——, calling himself an American consul,” had during a visit to Urga some months before been in conversation with those members of a conspiracy against the People’s Government of Mongolia who had since been executed for treason, he “had made to perish the good name of the great American nation,” and therefore said Government could no longer believe any American, verbally or in writing, wherefore permission was refused me ... and so on, to the length of a treaty of peace. However, a little résumé of recent Mongolian history and politics is essential to the full understanding of this tidbit of amateur diplomacy; for such it was, for all its ostensibly private nature, since it was plain that it had been written in the hope that I would bring it to the attention of our Government, with whom Outer Mongolia had no regular means of communicating.
It’s only through the strictest self-control that I hold back from quoting that remarkable paper in full. Not because it’s a great literary work, or that it holds any particular interest; but there are likely few better examples of the honesty in diplomatic relations between nations that has been so loudly sought after lately. Written on the usual long strip of tissue paper folded crosswise and opening like an accordion, it turned out to contain about a yard or more of vertical Mongol script, authenticated at both ends with a large square red stamp from an official seal. A long introduction led to the statement that, “since an individual named S——, calling himself an American consul,” had, during a visit to Urga some months ago, spoken with those involved in a conspiracy against the People’s Government of Mongolia who had since been executed for treason, he “had tarnished the good name of the great American nation,” and therefore, said Government could no longer trust any American, verbally or in writing, which is why permission was denied to me... and so on, extending even to the length of a peace treaty. However, a brief summary of recent Mongolian history and politics is crucial for fully grasping this piece of amateur diplomacy; because that’s exactly what it was, despite its apparently private nature, since it was clear that it was written with the hope that I would present it to our Government, which had no regular way of communicating with Outer Mongolia.
Soon after the revolution that made China nominally a republic, Outer Mongolia broke the ties which had bound it rather loosely for centuries to the Chinese Empire. The new Chinese Government had other problems on its hands, and for several years nothing serious was done to regain the allegiance of this vast territory, which had declared its independence without being very strict in such matters as completely expelling all Chinese officials. In 1917 there was organized 164in China under Japanese instructors an army-corps of twenty thousand Chinese, who were to take the enemy ships interned in Shanghai, sail for France, and win the war. But the armistice overtook these preparations and left the question of what to do with the troops on which so much training had been spent. Some genius at length suggested that they be made a “Northeastern Defense Corps,” and half the twenty thousand were sent to Urga under command of a general popularly known in China as “Little Hsu,” one of those choice morsels of humanity who had to his credit such actions as having a rival assassinated in his garden after inviting him to luncheon. All testimony seems agreed that these Chinese troops played havoc in Urga and vicinity, particularly after China had deprived Russians of their extraterritorial rights and after the “little worm” of a Russian consul who had been instrumental in having the expedition sent had departed. They began boldly looting and killing Russians as well as Mongols, and it was but a slight shift from that to attacking foreigners still entitled to extraterritorial privileges. Before matters grew serious enough to prod the powers to action, however, word came that a White Russian force was moving on Urga. “Little Hsu” ran away, leaving General Chu in command. The latter planned to kill all the foreigners left, according to his own assertion, then lost his nerve as the Russians drew near, and fled before his army; and when next seen by any of his intended victims he was basking in the hero-admiring smiles of foreign ladies and their escorts at a dance in the principal hotel of Peking.
Soon after the revolution that made China officially a republic, Outer Mongolia loosened its ties with the Chinese Empire that had lasted for centuries. The new Chinese government had other issues to deal with, and for several years, no serious attempts were made to regain control of this vast territory, which had declared its independence without fully expelling all Chinese officials. In 1917, an army corps of twenty thousand Chinese was organized in China with Japanese trainers, intended to seize enemy ships interned in Shanghai, sail to France, and contribute to the war effort. However, the armistice interrupted these plans, leaving the fate of the well-trained troops uncertain. Eventually, someone suggested creating a "Northeastern Defense Corps," and half of the twenty thousand troops were sent to Urga under the command of a general known in China as "Little Hsu," who had a reputation for notorious actions, including having a rival assassinated in his garden after inviting him to lunch. All accounts agree that these Chinese troops caused chaos in Urga and the surrounding area, especially after China stripped Russians of their extraterritorial rights and after the "little worm" of a Russian consul who had assisted in sending the expedition had left. They began openly looting and killing Russians as well as Mongols, quickly escalating to attacks on foreigners still holding extraterritorial privileges. However, before the situation became serious enough to prompt action from the great powers, news arrived that a White Russian force was advancing on Urga. "Little Hsu" fled, leaving General Chu in charge. Chu claimed he planned to eliminate all remaining foreigners, but he lost his courage as the Russians approached and ran away with his army; the next time anyone saw him, he was enjoying the admiration of foreign ladies and their escorts at a dance in the main hotel in Peking.
The Russians under Ungern, justly known as the “Mad Baron,” entered Urga in October, 1920, and with the aid of Mongol troops chased the disorganized Chinese corps over the southern border of Outer Mongolia. It was then that the Paris-to-Peking telegraph line ceased to function for lack of poles. Bleached Chinese skeletons still lay scattered along the road to Kalgan when I made the journey to Urga. Ungern was one of those products of generations of Russian brutality who seem to find their keenest pleasure in bloodthirsty acts. In Urga he grew more and more mad, indiscriminately killing Mongols and Russians suspected of “Red” sympathies, and topping this off one February day in 1921 by a general slaughter of the Jewish inhabitants. Every Russian, he explained, hates a Jew; besides, the Bolshevik régime with which he was at swords’ points was and is still mainly in the hands of Jews, a fact not fully realized in our land because of the muffling Jewish hand on our press, but which it is essential to keep in mind in any study of present Russian problems. So deep was his 165hatred of these people that he refused to waste ammunition on them; they were despatched instead by splitting open their skulls with sabers. Foreigners still living in Urga describe the streets as shambles, strewn everywhere with the corpses of Jewish men, women, and children, even of babies with their brains oozing out amid the dust and rubbish. All speak of the curious fact that many bodies lay for days where they had fallen, without a dog’s coming near them, as if even these brutes had been frightened by the madness of the baron—or had eaten to satiety. As the soldiers reveling in the pogrom depended mainly on a hasty glance to identify their victims, not a few foreigners whose physiognomy was deceiving passed some very unpleasant moments. Such sights as two Mongols and a white woman hanging from the same gatepost, the woman a poor part-witted creature who maintained even in death a ludicrous expression of inane hauteur, are still recalled by the surviving foreign residents.
The Russians under Ungern, famously known as the “Mad Baron,” entered Urga in October 1920 and, with the help of Mongol troops, drove the disorganized Chinese corps over the southern border of Outer Mongolia. It was then that the Paris-to-Peking telegraph line stopped working due to a lack of poles. When I traveled to Urga, I saw bleached Chinese skeletons scattered along the road to Kalgan. Ungern was one of those who, shaped by generations of Russian brutality, seemed to find the greatest pleasure in violent acts. In Urga, he became increasingly unstable, randomly executing Mongols and Russians suspected of having “Red” sympathies, culminating in a mass killing of the Jewish population one February day in 1921. Every Russian, he claimed, hates a Jew; besides, the Bolshevik regime with which he was in conflict was and still is mainly controlled by Jews—a fact not fully acknowledged in our country due to the controlling Jewish influence on our media, but one that is crucial to consider when studying current Russian issues. His hatred for these people was so intense that he refused to waste ammunition on them; instead, they were killed by having their skulls split open with sabers. Foreigners still living in Urga describe the streets as chaotic, littered with the bodies of Jewish men, women, and children, even babies with their brains oozing out amid the dirt and debris. Everyone mentions the strange fact that many bodies lay for days where they fell, with not even a dog coming near, as if even the animals were scared of the baron's madness—or had eaten their fill. As the soldiers, enjoying the chaos, mainly relied on quick glances to identify their victims, several foreigners whose appearances were misleading had some very frightening moments. Images like two Mongols and a white woman hanging from the same gatepost, the woman a poor mentally challenged individual who still wore a ridiculous expression of foolish arrogance even in death, are still remembered by the foreign residents who survived.
At length the Bolsheviks, having first, according to their own assertions, pleaded with the Chinese for several months to join them in the expedition and catch the “Mad Baron” between them, sent an army into Mongolia. The personal amusements of the baron do not seem to have had much weight in bringing about this decision, for the “Reds” themselves have a well developed taste for flowing blood; but they had begun to worry lest the Ungern group become the nucleus of a “White” force large enough to jeopardize their own security. Moreover, being true fanatics, they were eager to bring Mongolia the dismal gospel of their strange faith. The “Reds” entered Urga in July, 1921, and have been there ever since. In those notes for publication with which governments of all colors attempt to fool their neighbors, their own people, and even themselves, the present rulers of Russia assure us that they have only a corporal’s guard in Urga, merely as a protection against a new “White” gathering, and that the Mongols rule themselves without outside interference. Even the handsome and polished Jewish gentleman who under the title of Russian consul represents the Soviet in Urga, will tell you in any one of half a dozen languages, if you take the trouble to call at his perfectly consular office adorned with a large signed portrait of Lenin in a building flaunting a faded red flag, that he is only a lone foreigner in town, like you, and that he has little influence with the Mongol Government. But if he keeps from visibly smiling as he makes this assertion, it is a sign that the urbanity which he displayed at the time of his expulsion from the United States has improved rather than diminished.
At last, the Bolsheviks, claiming they had spent several months trying to convince the Chinese to join them in an expedition to capture the "Mad Baron," sent an army into Mongolia. The baron's personal antics don’t seem to have significantly influenced this decision, as the "Reds" have a strong appetite for violence themselves; however, they were becoming concerned that the Ungern group could form a large enough "White" force to threaten their own safety. Additionally, being true fanatics, they were eager to spread their bleak ideology throughout Mongolia. The "Reds" took control of Urga in July 1921 and have been there ever since. In the propaganda distributed to mislead their neighbors, their own citizens, and even themselves, the current rulers of Russia claim they only maintain a small guard in Urga for protection against any new "White" movement and that the Mongols govern themselves without any outside interference. Even the charming and refined Jewish gentleman, who represents the Soviet as the Russian consul in Urga, will tell you in several languages—if you take the time to visit his impeccably consular office decorated with a large portrait of Lenin and a building displaying a faded red flag—that he is just a solitary foreigner in town, like you, and has little influence over the Mongol Government. But if he manages to suppress a smile while making this claim, it's a sign that his politeness has improved rather than diminished since his expulsion from the United States.
166It is true that there are not more than two or three hundred Russian Soviet soldiers in Urga. Having painted the town “Red,” and seen to it that a Mongolian “People’s Government” of that color was installed, no great force is needed to see that the ideas of Moscow are carried out. The cabinet ministers ostensibly ruling the country are all Mongols, but at their elbow, just out of sight, sits a Russian “adviser” whose advice is never scorned with impunity. I still recall the scene when a Russian subaltern from the military staff brought the foreign minister a document that needed his signature to make it legal. As the minister began perusing it, the expression on the face of the subaltern said as plainly as if he had spoken the words, “Read it, you old beggar, if you want to waste the time, but you will sign it whether you wish to or not.” Thus the “advice” reaching Urga through the telegrams from Moscow that pour in upon the “powerless” Russian consul in a steady if slender stream seeps down through all grades of the “People’s Government” of independent Mongolia.
166It’s true that there are no more than two or three hundred Soviet Russian soldiers in Urga. Having painted the town “Red” and made sure a Mongolian “People’s Government” of that same color was set up, there’s no need for a large force to ensure that Moscow's ideas are followed. The cabinet ministers who are supposedly in charge of the country are all Mongols, but there’s always a Russian “adviser” right nearby, whose advice is never ignored without consequences. I still remember the moment when a Russian officer from the military staff handed the foreign minister a document that needed his signature to make it official. As the minister started reading it, the look on the officer's face clearly said, “Go ahead and read it, you old fool, if you want to waste your time, but you’re going to sign it whether you like it or not.” In this way, the “advice” sent to Urga through the nonstop, albeit thin, flow of telegrams from Moscow seeps down through all levels of the “People’s Government” of independent Mongolia.
It has been a long way around, but we have at last come back again to that example of amateur diplomacy in which my simple prayer was denied, and a backhanded fillip given incidentally to all citizens of “the great American nation.” It is true, even as the document alleges, that an American named S—— did come to Urga a few months before my arrival, and he does not deny that he had conversation with some of the fifteen Mongols, one of them the former prime minister, another a saint high in the lama hierarchy, most of them as splendid fellows as could be found in Mongolia, who were shot a fortnight before I got there, on the charge of conspiring to overthrow the “People’s Government.” That he “called himself an American consul” is not surprising, in view of the fact that our State Department does also, and pays him a salary accordingly. Nor is there any cause for astonishment in the fact that he hobnobbed as much as possible with the most polished Mongols with whom he could come in contact, if only to avoid still greasier robes. In short, S—— is our consul at Kalgan, in whose district all Mongolia is included. Neither China nor the United States, nor in fact any nation except Soviet Russia, has ever recognized the independence of Outer Mongolia. By the law of nations, therefore, so far as any such thing exists, it is still a province of China and a part of one of our Chinese consular districts, where Americans are still entitled to extraterritorial rights and subject to trial only by their own diplomatic or consular officers. Soon after his appointment S—— 167hurried up to Urga to study the situation. The Mongols in power evidently hoped that his visit was inspired by an intention on the part of our Government to recognize their independence. When nothing of the kind followed, they became more and more resentful. The animosity of the “Reds,” who look upon the United States as the chief of the “capitalistic nations” opposed to their sad scheme of things, served to increase this feeling, at least with the “Red” Mongols just now in the saddle; there are many evidences that among the Mongols at large nothing has “made to perish the name of the great American nation.” That any American consul would promise a minority group in a foreign country that he would “put them in touch with the enemy of our people on the east” (by which was meant the Chinese in general and Chang Tso-lin in particular) “and give his assistance in the liquidation of the existing People’s Government of Mongolia and the restoration of the old régime,” as was charged in the reply to my request, is as silly as that document itself.
It’s been a long journey, but we’ve finally come back to that example of amateur diplomacy where my simple request was denied, and a backhanded compliment was given unintentionally to all citizens of “the great American nation.” It’s true, as the document states, that an American named S—— arrived in Urga a few months before I did, and he doesn’t deny that he talked with some of the fifteen Mongols, including the former prime minister and a high-ranking lama, most of whom were really great guys you could find in Mongolia, who were executed two weeks before I got there on the charge of conspiring to overthrow the “People’s Government.” That he “called himself an American consul” isn’t surprising, considering our State Department does too and pays him a salary for it. It’s also not surprising that he tried to mingle as much as possible with the most refined Mongols he could find, if only to avoid appearing too shabby himself. In short, S—— is our consul in Kalgan, which oversees all of Mongolia. Neither China, nor the United States, nor any country except Soviet Russia has ever recognized the independence of Outer Mongolia. By international law, therefore, if such a thing exists, it’s still considered a province of China and part of one of our Chinese consular districts, where Americans still have extraterritorial rights and can only be tried by their own diplomatic or consular officials. Shortly after his appointment, S—— hurried to Urga to understand the situation. The Mongols in power clearly hoped that his visit meant our government was planning to recognize their independence. When nothing happened, they grew increasingly resentful. The hostility from the “Reds,” who see the United States as the leader of the “capitalist nations” opposed to their troubled plans, only heightened this sentiment, especially among the “Red” Mongols currently in power; there’s plenty of evidence that among the broader Mongolian population, nothing has “damaged the reputation of the great American nation.” The idea that any American consul would promise a minority group in a foreign country that he would “connect them with the enemy of our people to the east” (referring to the Chinese in general and Chang Tso-lin specifically) and “help in getting rid of the current People’s Government of Mongolia and restoring the old regime,” as was claimed in response to my request, is as ridiculous as that document itself.
But enough of politics, which to my simple mind is usually a bore. I might add, however, as a personal chuckle, that my case came perilously near causing a ministerial crisis and overturning the Mongol cabinet. Not that this is anything to boast of in these days when cabinets almost daily stump their toes on this or that insignificant pebble and sprawl headlong; but it was some satisfaction to know that, if I could not snap-shot Urga, at least I could put it in an uproar. The cabinet, it seems, deeply resented the action of the upstart Okhrana, both in replying to me direct and in reversing the decision of the ministers, and the question of resigning en bloc as a protest was, I am creditably informed, debated long and vigorously. I could not of course, even as an unofficial representative of the slandered American nation, take such an attack as the Okhrana document lying down. I replied to it sternly, therefore, in proper diplomatic form, addressing myself to the foreign minister, who received my reply in due humility. But my hope that by thus again stirring things up I might still succeed in being the cause of a national crisis did not, according to the latest reports from Urga, materialize.
But enough about politics, which I find usually pretty dull. I should mention, though, for a little humor, that my situation almost led to a ministerial crisis and could have brought down the Mongolian cabinet. Not that this is anything to brag about these days when cabinets seem to trip over minor issues and fall flat; but it was somewhat satisfying to know that, even if I couldn’t take a snapshot of Urga, I could at least cause some chaos. Apparently, the cabinet was really upset with the upstart Okhrana for responding to me directly and for overturning the ministers' decision. The possibility of resigning as a group in protest was, I hear, debated extensively and passionately. I couldn’t just sit back and let the Okhrana document attack go unanswered, especially as an unofficial representative of the wronged American nation. So, I replied firmly in the proper diplomatic way, addressing the foreign minister, who accepted my response with due humility. However, my hope that stirring things up again might lead to a national crisis didn't seem to happen, according to the latest reports from Urga.
There can be no other reason than pique or pure ignorance for refusing any one permission to take photographs in Urga. It has no fortresses or works of defense surrounded with secrecy; as far as the presence of Soviet soldiers and “advisers” is concerned, the lens could catch nothing that could not be told as effectively in words. Simple, 168rather brute-faced young Russians in shoddy gray uniforms with a red star sewed upon them were about the only outward evidences of Bolshevik occupation. Here or there one or two of them stood on guard with fixed bayonets which they were even more careless than the average soldier in flourishing about unoffending ribs. Others, off duty, prowled about singly or in small groups in quest of anything appealing to their rudimental appetites which might turn up. Out toward the wireless station erected by the Chinese, where the Russian soldiers used the war-ruined office of an American mining company as barracks, detachments of fifty to a hundred of them might be met marching in close ranks at a funeral pace and singing in chorus, a rather engaging custom inherited from czarist days. It was evident, not merely from their appearance but by the way any suggestion of authority went quickly to their heads, that almost all these uncouth youths were of the peasant or the lowest city class. Though I had business in the Okhrana several times a day during all my stay in Urga, never once was I permitted to enter it, even when officially summoned, until whatever dull-faced soldier happened to be on guard at the door had halted me long enough to emphasize his authority and his dislike of the class which still dared to wear white collars. What was worse, as in every case of evil example copied by still lower strata of society, was the studied rudeness, the childish yet overbearing insolence of the Mongol soldiers, who were much more numerous, in their efforts to outdo in “redness” their Russian models.
There can be no reason other than frustration or complete ignorance for denying anyone permission to take photos in Urga. There are no fortresses or secret defensive structures; regarding the presence of Soviet soldiers and "advisers," the camera could capture nothing that couldn't be explained just as well in words. The only visible signs of Bolshevik occupation were the simple, somewhat rough-faced young Russians in worn gray uniforms with a red star sewn on them. Occasionally, one or two stood guard with fixed bayonets, being even more careless than the average soldier in waving them around near unoffending people. Others, off duty, roamed around alone or in small groups in search of anything that might satisfy their basic cravings. Toward the wireless station set up by the Chinese, where the Russian soldiers used the war-damaged office of an American mining company as barracks, groups of fifty to a hundred could be seen marching at a slow pace and singing together—a somewhat charming custom inherited from the czarist era. It was clear, not just from their looks but also from how quickly any hint of authority went to their heads, that almost all these awkward young men came from peasant backgrounds or the lowest levels of the city. Even though I had business at the Okhrana several times a day during my entire stay in Urga, I was never allowed to enter, even when officially summoned, until the dull-faced soldier on duty at the door stopped me long enough to assert his authority and his disdain for anyone still daring to wear white collars. What was even worse, as is often the case when the lower classes imitate bad examples set by those above them, was the deliberate rudeness and childish yet overbearing arrogance of the Mongol soldiers, who were much more numerous, trying to outdo their Russian counterparts in "redness."
It was common rumor that there were many “radishes” among the Russians stationed in Urga, which would account for the exceptions to the general rule of simple, plebeian faces among the soldiers as well as among those in more important positions. A “radish,” obviously, is a man who is red on the outside but white within, and the term has of late years become one of every-day speech in Russia. Many former officers of the czar, many a member of the old aristocracy whom one would least expect to find backing the new proletarian doctrine, have no other means of earning their bread than to accept some small position under the Bolsheviks and pretend to be in sympathy with their program. How many of these there are in Russia and adjoining lands who will turn upon their present rulers when they show definite signs of falling is a question not without interest to the outside world, but one which no casual visitor can answer. It is said, also, that men are very glad to be assigned to duty in Urga, where there is at least plenty to eat, in contrast to Russia where nearly every one is more or less starving. 169Yet there are Russian civilians even in Urga who know the pangs of hunger. Such utter poverty and abject beggary as may be seen in Harbin or Vladivostok among refugees from the Bolshevik régime are not found in this bucolic land of comparative plenty, but barefoot children and the leanest faces were never those of the Mongols. I recall in particular the widow of an official wantonly killed by the “Mad Baron,” a young woman who might have been charming under happier circumstances, who dwelt with her lanky little daughter in a kind of two-room hut occupied by at least half a dozen other persons, and who shivered past our window every morning and evening to and from some sort of physical toil that had already given her the hands of a peasant woman.
It was a common rumor that there were many “radishes” among the Russians stationed in Urga, which would explain the exceptions to the general rule of simple, working-class faces among the soldiers and those in higher positions. A “radish,” as everyone knows, is a person who appears red on the outside but is white on the inside, and the term has recently become part of everyday language in Russia. Many former czarist officers and members of the old aristocracy, who you would least expect to support the new proletarian doctrine, now have no other way to make a living than to take some minor job under the Bolsheviks and pretend to support their agenda. The number of these individuals in Russia and surrounding areas who will turn against their current rulers when they start to show signs of weakening is an interesting question for the outside world, but one that no casual visitor can answer. It’s also said that many men are very happy to be assigned to duty in Urga, where there is at least enough to eat, unlike in Russia, where nearly everyone is starving to some extent. 169 Yet there are Russian civilians, even in Urga, who are familiar with hunger. The extreme poverty and abject begging seen in Harbin or Vladivostok among refugees from the Bolshevik regime are not present in this rural land of relative plenty, but barefoot children and gaunt faces were never the norm for the Mongols. I particularly remember the widow of an official who was brutally killed by the “Mad Baron,” a young woman who might have been charming under better circumstances. She lived with her skinny little daughter in a two-room hut shared with at least half a dozen other people, and she walked past our window every morning and evening, heading to and from some kind of labor that had already given her hands the roughness of a peasant woman.
Far be it from me to condemn any honest attempt to work out a new and better form of government, for certainly I should pin no blue ribbons on any which so far exist. But even a few days in Urga under “Red” rule could scarcely fail to convince any one not hopelessly prejudiced in its favor that the “Red” system does not improve human felicity, which after all, though that fact seems almost completely to have been lost sight of the world over, is the only justification for any government. Bad as opposing systems may be, this one was patently worse, if only because it brings the dregs and sediment of society to the top and submerges the purer liquid. It places the ignorant over the more or less instructed, the rude and the malevolent over those who are at least polished enough to be somewhat tolerant; it brings to the surface the residue of savagery in the human race and immerses many of the improvements that have been accomplished by long centuries of effort. I was particularly struck by this aspect of things on the evening when I attended the weekly Spektakl with which European Urga is permitted to attempt to amuse itself. That, like the government which sponsored it, was as if the stokers had come up and taken possession of the cabin and insisted on using only the meager talents to be found in their own ranks, though those who had given their best efforts for generations to providing better entertainment still tarried in the obscure corners into which the irruption had driven them.
Far be it from me to criticize any honest effort to create a new and better government, because honestly, I wouldn’t celebrate any that currently exist. But even just a few days in Urga under "Red" rule would likely convince anyone who isn’t biased in its favor that the "Red" system doesn’t enhance human happiness, which, after all, seems largely forgotten worldwide, is the only valid reason for any government. As bad as other systems might be, this one is clearly worse, mainly because it brings the worst elements of society to the forefront and suppresses the better ones. It places the uninformed above the somewhat educated, the crude and malicious above those who at least have some civility; it reveals the more primitive aspects of humanity and drowns out many of the advancements achieved over centuries of hard work. I was particularly struck by this when I attended the weekly Spectacle that European Urga is allowed to use to entertain itself. That, like the government that supports it, felt like the stokers had taken over the cabin and insisted on using only the limited skills from their own ranks, while those who had dedicated years to providing better entertainment remained hidden away in the dark corners from which they had been driven.
While they might as easily have led these childlike people of the Gobi toward better things, the “Reds” seem only to have improved the natural cussedness of those Mongols upon whom they have had any influence whatever. The two races have, to be sure, many qualities more or less in common, and a history which dovetails here and there. 170The Mongols under Jenghiz Khan defeated the Russians, destroyed Kieff, and made almost all Russia tributary to them. Out on the edge of Urga stands a long row of European barracks built by the Russians in czarist days as a part of their program of training a great Mongol army. In other words, it has been give-and-take between these neighboring races for centuries, and, shading together as they do through the intermediate Buriats and Kalmucks, they seem much more closely allied than Europe and Asia in general. In fact, seeing the two side by side, one was more and more struck with how Oriental are the Russians. They are Oriental, for instance, in their cruelty, and while they can perhaps teach little of that quality to a people who until yesterday placed condemned criminals in stout boxes and left them out among the skulls and dogs to die, they have certainly done nothing to soften their innate barbarism. Surely it is no worse to cut open the body of an executed felon in quest of some organ of fancied medicinal value than to sentence two of the most cultivated and charming young Russian ladies in Urga to serve the “Red” army in Siberia for five years in punishment for the atrocious crime committed by one of them in being the wife of a “White” officer—for “serving” a “Red” army in this sense means something quite different from sewing on buttons by day, something which makes a five-year term easily a life sentence.
While they could have easily guided these naive people of the Gobi toward better outcomes, the “Reds” seem to have only aggravated the natural stubbornness of the Mongols they’ve influenced. The two races do share several traits and have a history that intertwines at various points. 170 The Mongols under Genghis Khan defeated the Russians, destroyed Kiev, and made almost all of Russia pay tribute to them. On the outskirts of Urga, there is a long row of European barracks built by the Russians during the czarist era as part of their plan to train a large Mongol army. In other words, there has been a back-and-forth between these neighboring races for centuries, and, blending together through the intermediate Buriats and Kalmucks, they seem much more connected than Europe and Asia in general. In fact, seeing the two groups side by side makes it increasingly apparent how Oriental the Russians are. They are Oriental, for example, in their cruelty, and while they might not have much to teach about that quality to a people who until recently placed condemned criminals in sturdy boxes and left them among skulls and dogs to die, they have certainly done nothing to soften their inherent barbarism. It is surely no worse to dissect the body of an executed criminal in search of some organ believed to have medicinal value than to sentence two of the most cultured and charming young Russian women in Urga to serve the “Red” army in Siberia for five years as punishment for the terrible crime of one of them being the wife of a “White” officer—because “serving” a “Red” army in this context is something entirely different from just sewing on buttons by day, making a five-year term feel like a life sentence.
Though they were on the whole surly now toward strangers in general and Caucasians in particular, one felt instinctively that this was not natural Mongol behavior. For they are a simple people, close to nature, a race with lovable traits for all their obvious faults. Three years ago, say those who knew it then, Urga was as free as air, a delightful place to visit, for all its filth and superstition. Hardly a Mongol but had a smile and a cheery, jocular greeting for any one, of whatever race, be it only at a chance meeting in the street. If now the atmosphere of the whole place kept the nerves taut, it was rather because of things that had recently been imposed upon them from the outside, things which they might or might not wish, but which they have no choice but to accept. In the olden days the visitor to Urga came and went, carried on business or loafed, and never met the slightest interference with his personal freedom. Now, though the European colony may stroll at sunset a few times back and forth along the noisome stream oozing past the market-place, no one may go out at night without imminent danger of spending the rest of it in clammy durance. This rule, added to the double windows of most 171houses, covered with wooden shutters, Russian fashion, gives the nights a deathly silence, only occasionally broken by the barking of foraging dogs, hoarse-voiced as if they all had heavy colds from sleeping outdoors. A humorous touch may soften this general atmosphere of apprehension, for the “Red” and Mongol idea seems to be that only those who sneak noiselessly along the dark streets can be bent on mischief, and the small non-Russian foreign colony have found it efficacious in returning from their dinner-parties to sing and whoop at the tops of their voices to convince prowling soldiers that they are innocent of any evil intent.
Though they are generally unfriendly toward strangers and especially Caucasians now, it’s clear this isn’t typical Mongol behavior. They are a straightforward people, connected to nature, with charming qualities despite their evident flaws. Three years ago, those who were familiar with it say, Urga was as free as could be—a lovely place to visit, even with its mess and superstitions. Nearly every Mongol would greet anyone with a smile and a cheerful, playful hello, even if it was just a chance encounter in the street. Now, while the whole atmosphere feels tense, it’s largely due to recent pressures from outside that they have to accept, whether they want to or not. In the past, visitors to Urga came and went, conducted business, or relaxed without any interference in their freedom. Now, although the European community can walk back and forth along the foul stream by the market at sunset, no one can venture out at night without the risk of ending up stuck in a damp detention. This rule, along with the double windows of most 171 houses covered with wooden shutters in the Russian style, creates a chilling silence at night, occasionally broken by the barking of scavenging dogs, their voices hoarse as if suffering from colds from sleeping outside. A humorous element may lighten this overall feeling of unease since both the “Red” and Mongol belief seems to be that only those who creep silently through dark streets are up to no good. The small non-Russian foreign community has found that singing loudly and whooping on their way back from dinner parties convinces prowling soldiers they’re not up to anything sinister.
It is risky now even to use the word Guspadin, a kind of Russian “Mr.,” before any name, in any language; one is expected to say Tavarish, meaning comrade. When they first came, the “Reds” showed every intention of introducing the same communism in Mongolia as in Russia. They demanded all title-deeds of real property, announcing that they would rent everything of the kind for thirty years to the highest bidder, no matter who the owner might be. The agents of foreign firms replied that the titles to their company buildings were on file with their legations at Peking, or at the home offices in America or Europe, or gave some other plausible answer, and, though copies of them were demanded, these were returned later with the information that they were of no use. Mongols and Russians, however, have in many cases been made communists willy-nilly, and some have already been stripped even of personal property. Those who have been in both places say that interference with peaceful pursuits is worse in Urga than it ever was in Soviet Russia. Merchants are particularly bitter, because while business is growing steadily better in Russia since the decree legalizing it, here it is being taxed to death. It is difficult to get a frank statement from the mistrusting Chinese merchants, who make up a majority of the trading class; but it is hard to believe that they are any more satisfied with the often confiscatory as well as burdensome methods of the “Red” authorities than are the disheartened foreigners. Every import or export, for instance, must pay a very high duty based on the retail selling price. Fines for technicalities and the often unavoidable breaking of some silly rule are the order of the day, while on top of the cost comes the wasted time and effort caused by the inexperience of the Mongols in matters of government. A caravan of sixty camels bringing in or taking out bales of marmot skins must halt for two or three days while every skin is counted and the bales made up again. When an Anglo-American branch got in a shipment of 172cigarettes, every one of the ninety-eight packages in each of the seventy-two cases had to be counted. Why they did not count each cigarette remains a mystery. The same rule applies to bricks of tea, cakes of chocolate, and the most minute of articles.
It’s risky to even use the word Guspadin, a kind of Russian “Mr.,” before any name in any language; you’re supposed to say Tavarish, which means comrade. When they first arrived, the “Reds” made it clear they wanted to implement the same communism in Mongolia as in Russia. They demanded all real estate title deeds, stating they would rent everything like that for thirty years to the highest bidder, regardless of who the actual owner was. The agents of foreign companies said the titles to their buildings were on file with their legations in Peking or at their home offices in America or Europe, or provided other plausible explanations, and though copies were requested, those were later returned saying they were useless. However, many Mongols and Russians have been turned into communists against their will, and some have already lost even their personal property. Those who have been to both places report that interference with peaceful activities is worse in Urga than it ever was in Soviet Russia. Merchants are especially frustrated because while business in Russia is steadily improving since the decree legalizing it, here it’s being taxed intensely. It’s tough to get a straight answer from the skeptical Chinese merchants, who make up most of the trading class; but it’s hard to believe they’re any happier with the often confiscatory and burdensome methods of the “Red” authorities than the demoralized foreigners are. Every import or export, for example, has to pay very high duties based on the retail selling price. Fines for technicalities and the often unavoidable breaking of some ridiculous rule are common, and on top of that, there’s the wasted time and effort caused by the Mongols’ inexperience with government. A caravan of sixty camels bringing in or taking out bales of marmot skins must stop for two or three days while every skin is counted and the bales are put together again. When an Anglo-American branch received a shipment of 172cigarettes, every one of the ninety-eight packages in each of the seventy-two cases had to be counted. Why they didn’t count each cigarette remains a mystery. The same rule applies to bricks of tea, cakes of chocolate, and the tiniest items.
Not long after their arrival the “Reds” passed a law making the Russian silver ruble legal tender on a par with the “Mex” dollar and requiring every one to accept it as such. When an American firm protested that this meant a loss of 40 per cent on prices, and refused to comply, it was heavily fined. Moreover, the fine was paid, legal rights of extraterritoriality notwithstanding. It is small wonder that foreign stock is scarce in Urga and that important firms are closing their branches there. So far as I was able to find, the “Reds” had introduced only one reform worth while: they had decreed that Mongol women must give up their extravagant head-dress, saying that the silver with which it is heavy could be used to better purpose. Some twoscore head-dresses were seized, but even Bolsheviks learn in time that feminine fashions cannot be decreed by lawmakers; they returned the confiscated contrivances later, and the custom remains. In fact, all the “Reds” in Urga have not done as much for the handful of the human race there as have three brave Swedish girls who are fighting alone the most wide-spread of Mongolia’s physical diseases with missionary zeal and without making any noise about it.
Not long after they arrived, the “Reds” passed a law making the Russian silver ruble legal tender alongside the “Mex” dollar and requiring everyone to accept it. When an American company protested that this meant a 40 percent loss on prices and refused to comply, it was heavily fined. Moreover, the fine was paid, despite the legal rights of extraterritoriality. It’s no surprise that foreign investment is scarce in Urga and that major companies are shutting down their branches there. As far as I could tell, the “Reds” had introduced only one worthwhile reform: they mandated that Mongol women must give up their elaborate head-dress, claiming that the silver it contained could be used better elsewhere. A couple dozen head-dresses were taken, but even the Bolsheviks eventually learned that feminine fashion can’t be dictated by laws; they returned the confiscated items later, and the tradition continues. In fact, all the “Reds” in Urga haven’t accomplished as much for the small population there as three brave Swedish girls, who are quietly fighting the most widespread physical diseases in Mongolia with missionary zeal.
Whatever other forms of violence the Soviet has used in its efforts to make neighboring Mongolia a first convert and a nation after its own heart, it has not dared openly attack the “Living Buddha.” The fanatical Mongols would almost certainly kill all foreigners in the country, irrespective of nationality, if their blind god were molested; though the rumor is rife that the “Reds” have threatened to deal with him as with the former prime minister if he uses his influence against them. Outwardly they try as hard to keep up the fiction that he is the head of the Mongol Government as they do to convince the world that they have no real hand in the latter. The official bulletin, only newspaper in Urga, in announcing the execution of the fifteen alleged conspirators, called attention to the law which decrees that those who try to change the form of government shall be cut up in small pieces, their immediate family banished two thousand versts from the capital, all their property confiscated, and all their relatives sent as slaves to distant princes. There are many such slaves in Mongolia, by the way; Bogda-Han has thousands of them, just as he has of cattle. But, added the official organ, the family and the property of these fifteen were not molested, 173by order of the “Living Buddha!” It is true that the title Bogda-Han means emperor, but he was long since shorn of any temporal power, not to mention the fact that he is said to have no sympathy whatever for the “Reds” or any of their works.
Whatever other forms of violence the Soviets have used to turn neighboring Mongolia into a loyal ally and a nation to their liking, they have not dared to openly attack the “Living Buddha.” The zealous Mongols would almost certainly kill all foreigners in the country, regardless of nationality, if their revered figure were troubled; although there are widespread rumors that the “Reds” have threatened to deal with him as they did with the former prime minister if he uses his influence against them. Externally, they work hard to maintain the illusion that he is the leader of the Mongol Government, just as they try to convince the world that they have no real involvement in it. The official bulletin, the only newspaper in Urga, when announcing the execution of the fifteen alleged conspirators, noted the law that prescribes that anyone attempting to change the government should be chopped into small pieces, their immediate family exiled two thousand versts from the capital, all their property confiscated, and all their relatives sent as slaves to distant princes. By the way, there are many such slaves in Mongolia; Bogda-Han has thousands of them, just like he has cattle. But, the official publication added, the family and property of these fifteen were not harmed, 173by order of the “Living Buddha!” It is true that the title Bogda-Han means emperor, but he long ago lost any real power, not to mention the fact that he is said to have absolutely no sympathy for the “Reds” or any of their actions.
It is common belief that the Chinese will never return to power in Urga. A recent despatch from a Japanese source asserting that Moscow has declared Mongolia a federated state of Russia has not been confirmed, but it might as well be that in name as well as in fact. As I write, a story comes through that the “Living Buddha” is asking China to take charge of the country once more, but that again is from a Chinese source. The hard, cold facts in political matters are difficult to find in such a double-faced realm as the Orient. But the future of Mongolia will be worth watching, as will the apparent tendency of the Soviet to continue the imperialistic thrust toward the south and east which it inherited from the czarist régime.
It’s widely believed that the Chinese will never regain power in Urga. A recent report from a Japanese source claims that Moscow has declared Mongolia a federated state of Russia, but this hasn’t been confirmed. It could very well be true, both in name and reality. As I write this, I hear news that the “Living Buddha” is urging China to take control of the country again, although that news also comes from a Chinese source. The hard, clear facts in political matters are hard to come by in such a contradictory place as the Orient. However, the future of Mongolia is definitely something to keep an eye on, as is the apparent inclination of the Soviets to continue the imperialistic push toward the south and east that they inherited from the czarist regime.
As if they wished to make up for their earlier harshness, the “Reds” made my departure from Urga extremely easy. Perhaps I should see a less flattering motive in their leniency. In any case my baggage was barely opened and shut again, though most travelers find departing a more trying ordeal than arrival, and ordinarily every line of writing leaving the country is rigidly censored. The only unpleasantness that befell us was the failure of the greasy Mongol holding the official seal to reach the Okhrana before noon, though we had been there ready to start since eight. Booted soldiers again rode with us to the far outskirts of the city, halting us at various yamens, so that the sun was well started on its decline before our papers were examined at the last yourt, and we were free to reach if possible the first distant stopping-place before nightfall. Not until the next afternoon, however, when the frontier outpost of Ude passed us without comment, did that sense of apprehension which seems just now to hang like a cloud over Outer Mongolia give way to one of relief and confidence of the future.
As if they wanted to make up for their earlier harshness, the “Reds” made my departure from Urga super easy. Maybe I should see a less flattering reason for their leniency. Either way, my baggage was hardly opened and closed again, even though most travelers find leaving to be tougher than arriving, and normally every piece of writing leaving the country is strictly censored. The only hassle we encountered was the sluggish Mongol with the official seal not making it to the Okhrana before noon, even though we had been ready to go since eight. Booted soldiers rode with us to the outer edges of the city, stopping us at various yamens, so the sun was well on its way down before our papers were checked at the last yourt, and we were free to head toward the first distant stopping place before nightfall. It wasn't until the next afternoon, when the border outpost of Ude passed us without comment, that the sense of unease that seems to hang like a cloud over Outer Mongolia finally gave way to a feeling of relief and confidence about the future.
Long caravans that we had passed a fortnight before were still laboriously making their way toward Urga. Men all but unrecognizable as such under their many sheepskin garments still squatted at trenches dug in the desert, coaxing wind-shielded fires to blaze, or bowed their fur-clad heads to the bitterly cold wind sweeping at express speed down out of the north; and we drove for nearly a hundred miles through fields of snow and ice, though September was not yet gone when we stumbled down the pass into Kalgan.
Long caravans that we had seen two weeks ago were still slowly making their way to Urga. Men, barely recognizable under their layers of sheepskin clothing, squatted in trenches dug in the desert, trying to get wind-protected fires to burn, or bent their fur-covered heads against the harsh cold wind rushing down from the north; and we drove for almost a hundred miles through fields of snow and ice, even though September wasn’t over yet when we finally tumbled down the pass into Kalgan.
CHAPTER XI
AT HOME BEHIND THE TARTAR WALL
It is obvious that this chapter should be written by the head of the house. But any husband, at least of the United States of America, will understand perfectly what I mean when I say that persuasion is often useless and coercion out of date. The housekeeping sex will have to bear with me, therefore, while I do my masculine best with a subject that is manifestly far beyond my humble qualifications. Whatever the other faults I display in the process, I shall try not to be reticent in such matters as the wages of servants and the price of eggs, which I conceive to be those near the housekeeper’s heart the world over.
It’s clear that this chapter should be written by the head of the household. But any husband in the United States will completely understand what I mean when I say that persuasion often doesn’t work and coercion is outdated. So, the homemakers will have to tolerate me while I do my best to tackle a subject that is clearly beyond my modest skills. Despite any other shortcomings I might show in the process, I’ll try not to hold back on issues like servant wages and the price of eggs, which I believe are close to the housekeeper’s heart everywhere.
Neither of Peking’s modern hotels, not so much as to mention the dozen others which are now and then astonished by the arrival of a foreign client, was the place for a boy just reaching the running, shouting, and breaking age to spend eight or nine months, even if his parents had not grown to abhor the very advantages of hotel life. So we turned our attention to the renting of a house. In Peking one does not simply buy a morning paper, check off a hundred possibilities, and make the rounds of them. There is an English-speaking, more or less daily newspaper, two or three of them, in fact; but very few families could live in the available houses which they call to the reader’s attention. Nor are there renting agents, or many invitations to the houseless, at least recognizable to Westerners, to be seen along the streets. One must depend rather on chance hints, above all on asking one’s friends to ask their friends, which is not wholly satisfactory for new arrivals with at most a few letters of introduction and a foolish, perhaps, but ineradicable tendency to cause the rest of mankind as little annoyance as possible. We soon learned, however, that some things are quite proper in Peking which are deeply frowned upon elsewhere, and vice versa.
Neither of Peking’s modern hotels, not to mention the dozen others that are occasionally surprised by the arrival of a foreign guest, was a suitable place for a boy just entering the phase of running, shouting, and breaking things to spend eight or nine months, even if his parents had come to loathe the very perks of hotel life. So we shifted our focus to renting a house. In Peking, you don't just buy a morning paper, tick off a hundred options, and visit them all. There is an English-speaking daily newspaper, or rather a couple of them; however, very few families could live in the houses they highlight. There aren't any rental agents, nor are there many visible invitations for the houseless that would be recognizable to Westerners. Instead, you have to rely on random tips, mainly by asking your friends to inquire with their friends, which isn't entirely satisfying for newcomers armed with only a few letters of introduction and a somewhat foolish, yet unshakeable, tendency to avoid bothering others as much as possible. However, we soon discovered that some behaviors considered normal in Peking are frowned upon elsewhere, and vice versa.
But at least house-hunting in the Chinese capital is not at all the physical labor that apartment-hunting is, for instance, in New York. One steps into the nearest of the rickshaws which swoop down like hungry sparrows upon every possible fare and is borne silently away to the very doors of possible dwelling-places. It is almost always a 175disappointment to prospective residents, this first rapid survey of Peking outside the Legation Quarter, yet at the same time fascinating to all but the most querulous. The narrow, unpaved hutungs are so uneven, if not actually muddy or swirling with dust; they offer so many offenses to the eye, and to the nose; unwashed beggars, runny-nosed children, the first close view of one’s future neighbors, are seldom pleasing even to those most avid of local color. Almost any one with American training will be appalled by the lowness and the apparent crowding together of the houses. The thought of living not merely on the ground floor but literally on the ground itself, since Peking houses have no cellars and rarely even a single step to be mounted, may seem unthinkable. The total absence of front yards, of grass, of even the suggestion of a sidewalk, nothing but blank walls of bluish-gray mud bricks, here and there half tumbled in, patched perhaps for the time being with old straw mats or mere rubbish, close on either hand as far as the eye can see, is likely to bring a sinking to the new-comer’s heart.
But at least searching for a place to live in Beijing isn’t nearly as taxing as apartment-hunting in New York. You just hop into the nearest rickshaw, which swoops down like eager sparrows on anyone who might pay, and you're whisked away to the doors of potential homes. It’s usually a letdown for those looking to settle down, this quick glimpse of Beijing outside the Legation Quarter, yet it remains intriguing to all but the most irritable. The narrow, unpaved alleys, called hutungs, are often uneven, if not downright muddy or filled with dust; they present many eyesores and unpleasant smells. Unwashed beggars and runny-nosed kids—the first close look at your future neighbors—are rarely charming, even for those who love local culture. Anyone with American standards will likely be shocked by how close together the houses are and how low they are. The idea of living not just on the ground floor but literally on the ground, since Beijing homes lack cellars and rarely have even a single step, might seem unimaginable. The complete lack of front yards, grass, or even the hint of a sidewalk—just blank walls made of bluish-gray mud bricks, some half-collapsed and temporarily patched with old straw mats or junk, stretching as far as you can see—might really discourage anyone new to the city.
But he is not long in realizing that China is preëminently the Land of Walls, and that what the streets and the alley-like hutungs lose by being crowded between their mud-made barriers the dwellings along them gain in space and privacy within. Once the heavy door-leaves, bright red in color, with a few big black characters on them calling poetically for blessings upon the inmates, growl shut behind him, he finds the sense of unpleasant proximity was a mere delusion. A short tiled passageway leads, almost certainly at right angles, into the first court, from which another, very likely with a different direction, that evil spirits may be completely nonplussed, opens upon a second, and beyond this, perhaps through a big ornamental gateway with brilliant flare-eared roof, there may be a third and even a fourth courtyard; though this would imply that the ordinary house-hunter might better discreetly withdraw before the matter of price comes up. Usually the brick walls and the tiled roofs of the separate buildings about these courts are of that same blue gray that makes Peking so much more drab than the imagination had pictured it, for all its innumerable palaces, temples, and monuments. But the eaves and the cornices, the doors and the passageways, with their red and green and sky-blue decorations of Chinese motif, the bright blues and reds of the rafter-ends and corbels under the slant of the roofs, the white-papered lattices of the windows, make up for this. Probably, too, there is a venerable old tree rising out of somewhere high above the place; and almost always, winter or summer, there is that bright blue sky overhead which makes Peking so delightful a home. What usually 176troubles the foreigner longest is the lowness of the houses. A child could throw a cat over any of them; they have no basements, no garrets, nothing but the low room or two of each building, generally without even a ceiling, but only the roof-beams, papered or whitewashed, sometimes painted with dragons and other things Chinese.
But he quickly realizes that China is definitely the Land of Walls, and what the streets and narrow hutungs lose in space due to their cramped mud barriers, the homes along them gain in room and privacy inside. Once the heavy, bright red doors, marked with large black characters that poetically call for blessings on the residents, thud shut behind him, he discovers that the sense of being uncomfortably close to others was just an illusion. A short tiled hallway leads, more often than not, at right angles into the first courtyard, from which another one opens, likely with a different layout to confuse any evil spirits, leading to a second courtyard, and beyond that, perhaps through a grand decorative gate with a striking flare-eared roof, there may be a third and even a fourth courtyard; although this implies that a regular house-hunter might want to discreetly step back before discussing price. Usually, the brick walls and tiled roofs of the buildings surrounding these courtyards are that same blue-gray color that makes Beijing seem much duller than one might have imagined, despite its countless palaces, temples, and monuments. However, the eaves and cornices, doors and passageways, adorned with red, green, and sky-blue Chinese designs, the bright blues and reds of the rafter-ends and corbels under the slanted roofs, the white-papered window lattices, make up for this. There is probably an ancient tree rising somewhere above the area; and almost always, whether winter or summer, there is that bright blue sky overhead that makes Beijing such a lovely home. What usually frustrates foreigners the longest is the low height of the houses. A child could throw a cat over any of them; they have no basements, no attics, just the one or two low rooms of each building, usually without even a ceiling, but only the roof beams, papered or whitewashed, sometimes painted with dragons and other traditional Chinese designs.
I have been speaking, of course, of Chinese houses. There are many two- and even three-story dwellings in Peking; there are big compounds full of houses that might have been shipped intact from Massachusetts; but we could see no reason for coming all the way to China just to live inside a little walled-in duplicate of England or America. So we roamed the hutungs. According to treaty all Westerners in Peking still live within the Legation Quarter. But the foreign community has long since outgrown such limited accommodations. Chinese with houses to rent, merchants with goods to sell, every caste and variety of Pekingese who covets some of the contents of foreigners’ plump purses, is glad to overlook this fiction in practice, so that brass name-plates in Roman letters, and flagpoles flaunting various Western colors, are widely scattered within the Tartar City. We found them clustered most thickly in the southeastern, or at least the eastern, part of it, thinning out toward the northwest; but foreigners live even inside the Yellow Wall, as the Chinese call the Imperial City. There seemed to be few if any in the broad Chinese City south of the Tartar Wall, or outside that mighty barrier at all, except for the little suburban community far out at the race-course.
I’ve been talking about Chinese houses, of course. There are plenty of two- and even three-story homes in Beijing; there are large compounds filled with houses that could have been shipped directly from Massachusetts; but we couldn’t see any reason to come all the way to China just to live in a small, walled-in replica of England or America. So, we explored the hutungs. According to the treaty, all Westerners in Beijing still live within the Legation Quarter. However, the foreign community has long exceeded those limited accommodations. Chinese people with houses to rent, merchants wanting to sell their goods, and every type of Beijing resident hoping to tap into foreigners’ deep pockets are willing to overlook this fiction in practice, so brass nameplates in Roman letters and flagpoles displaying various Western colors are scattered throughout the Tartar City. We found them clustered most densely in the southeastern, or at least the eastern, part, thinning out toward the northwest; but foreigners even reside inside the Yellow Wall, as the Chinese call the Imperial City. It appeared that there were few, if any, in the vast Chinese City south of the Tartar Wall, or outside that massive barrier at all, except for the small suburban community far out at the racecourse.

Our home in Peking was close under the great East Wall of the Tartar City
Our house in Beijing was right up against the massive East Wall of the Tartar City.

The indispensable staff of Peking housekeeping consists of (left to right) ama, rickshaw man, “boy,” coolie, and cook
The essential staff of Peking housekeeping includes (left to right) ama, rickshaw driver, “boy,” coolie, and cook.

A chat with neighbors on the way to the daily stroll on the wall
A conversation with neighbors on the way to the daily walk on the wall

Street venders were constantly crying their wares in our quarter
Street vendors were always shouting about their goods in our neighborhood.
177I had gone to Mongolia before we found what we wanted, and therefore can claim no credit either in the quest, the furnishing, or the selection of that numerous personnel without which no foreigner’s household in Peking seems to function. It had been a long search, with certain hitches that would not have occurred across the Pacific. Legally no foreigner can own real estate in Peking unless he is a missionary. Many do, but that is by using Chinese as dummy owners. Some old Chinese houses as yet untouched by foreign hands tempted us to try ours at recreating them in as charming a way as some of our friends had done. But the eight or nine months we could be at home in Peking were already running away, and the process of making livable such old ancestral mansions, where courtyard rambles after courtyard, but where former glories have faded with years of disrepair, would have taken too large a slice out of our time. To rent a house even from the Chinese landlord who had renovated and improved it purposely for the occupancy of foreigners was a complicated process. First of all there was the inevitable bargaining, the landlord starting at perhaps twice what he would accept and the renter at half what he was prepared to pay; for it is still a rare Chinese, even in a city as familiar with foreigners as is Peking, who can honestly name his price at the beginning and stick to it. Nor were these dickerings direct, even though my wife and our prospective landlord might have a language in common. Go-betweens must “save face” on either side in case the deal fell through. The houses for rent by Chinese were never furnished; they usually lacked running water, sewers, bath-tubs, electric light, and similar Western idiosyncrasies, though in cases where the owner had in mind renting to foreigners preparations might have been made to introduce these improvements. But unless he was sure of getting a foreign occupant the landlord did not purpose to go to all this trouble perhaps for nothing; in most cases his proposition was that the renter put in these things at his own expense, with the doubtful probability of having his rent reduced accordingly.
177I had gone to Mongolia before we figured out what we wanted, so I can’t take any credit for the search, the setup, or the choice of the many staff members that are essential for any foreigner's household in Beijing. It had been a long search with some hiccups that wouldn’t have happened across the Pacific. Legally, no foreigner can own property in Beijing unless they are a missionary. Many do, but they use Chinese nationals as nominal owners. Some old Chinese houses still untouched by foreign influences tempted us to try recreating them as charmingly as some of our friends had. However, the eight or nine months we had to spend in Beijing were quickly slipping away, and turning such ancient family homes—where courtyard after courtyard leads to faded former glories that have suffered years of neglect—into something livable would take up too much of our time. Renting a house, even from the Chinese landlord who had renovated it specifically for foreigners, was a complicated process. First came the inevitable haggling, with the landlord starting at maybe double what he would actually accept and the renter offering half of what they were willing to pay; it’s still rare for a Chinese person, even in a city as accustomed to foreigners as Beijing, to honestly state their price upfront and stick to it. These negotiations weren’t straightforward, even with my wife and our prospective landlord possibly sharing a language. Middlemen had to “save face” on both sides if the deal fell apart. The houses for rent from Chinese owners were usually unfurnished; they typically lacked running water, sewage systems, bathtubs, electric light, and similar Western conveniences. In cases where the owner aimed to attract foreign tenants, some preparations might have been made to add these improvements. But unless he was certain he would have a foreign tenant, the landlord didn’t want to go through all this trouble for nothing; in most situations, his offer was that the renter would install these things at their own expense, with the uncertain possibility of having the rent reduced accordingly.
If the two parties did finally come to terms, the inexperienced renter was likely to faint at the revelation of what still lay before him. First he must pay three months’ rent in advance, which did not at all mean that he would not have to pay again before the three months were up. This payment would cover the first and the last months of the occupancy, and the other third of the sum no month at all. It went as cumshaw or “squeeze” to every one concerned in the deal—except of course the man who paid it—to be divided among all those who had in any way taken part—the “boy” of an acquaintance who had pointed out the house, the caretaker who had opened the door, the servant across the street who knew the name of the landlord, the man who had fetched said landlord, on up through all the go-betweens to the landlord himself. Even the most generous of us hesitates to give tips of a hundred or a hundred and fifty dollars, though it be only “Mex.” Then the papers in the case must be sent to the legation of the foreigner involved, which in due time would do to them whatever is customarily done, and pass them on to the Chinese police. In Peking some officials work with unusual promptitude (for China), so that the documents might be complete and back in the hands of the landlord with a celerity that would be vertiginous in the interior of the country—that is, with good luck, so every one told us, within three or four months!
If the two parties finally reached an agreement, the inexperienced renter was likely to faint when he realized what was still ahead of him. First, he had to pay three months' rent upfront, which definitely didn't mean he wouldn't have to pay again before those three months were over. This payment covered the first and last months of his stay, while the remaining third of the amount didn't cover any month at all. It went as cumshaw or "squeeze" to everyone involved in the deal—except of course for the person who actually paid it—distributed among all those who contributed in any way: the “boy” from a friend who showed him the house, the caretaker who opened the door, the neighbor across the street who knew the landlord's name, the person who brought the landlord over, and so on, all the way to the landlord himself. Even the most generous among us hesitates to give tips of a hundred or a hundred and fifty dollars, even if it's just “Mex.” Then, the paperwork needed to be sent to the legation of the foreigner involved, which would do whatever is typically done and pass it on to the Chinese police. In Beijing, some officials work with unusual speed (for China), so the documents might be completed and returned to the landlord with a quickness that would be astonishing in the countryside—that is, if luck was on everyone’s side, within three or four months!
Then all at once there appeared a little Chinese house just about our size, which an American missionary had recently civilized and was ready 178to rent in the offhand fashion of our native land. For a week, coolies—bowed under assorted articles of furniture picked up at auction sales, bargained for piece by piece out in the maelstrom of the Chinese City, in shops scattered elsewhere, and as a last resort made to order by Chinese craftsmen of adaptable ability and very reasonable demands—wandered up the little hutung to our new home. A carpenter produced from a scanty suggestion a four-posted crib with brilliant dragons climbing each post; another stray artist covered the face of the nursery wardrobe with a marvelous blue forest through which China’s most famous actor, in his usual rôle of a willowy lady, strolled with a green deer; most of the furnishings were purely Chinese, adapted as far as possible to foreign use, and our chief regret was that this could be only a temporary, and must therefore be an inexpensive, abode, in which we could not indulge in the real beauties of Chinese trappings. As it was, something between seven and eight hundred dollars had melted away before we were done, and still no one would have mistaken the place for a prince’s palace. But they were only “Mex” dollars, as is always the case when one uses the word in China, and there was a chance that some one might give us back a few of them when the time came to abandon Peking and push on. Besides, either of the hotels would have taken the dollars and not left us even the furniture.
Then suddenly, a small Chinese house appeared that was just about our size, which an American missionary had recently renovated and was ready to rent in the casual way we’re used to back home. For a week, coolies—bent under various pieces of furniture collected from auction sales, haggled for them piece by piece in the chaos of the Chinese City, shopped in stores elsewhere, and as a last stop, had things custom-made by Chinese craftsmen who were skilled and very affordable—strolled up the little hutung to our new home. A carpenter turned a simple idea into a four-poster crib with vibrant dragons climbing each post; another artist decorated the nursery wardrobe with a stunning blue forest where China’s most famous actor, in his usual role as a graceful lady, walked with a green deer; most of the furnishings were distinctly Chinese, adjusted as much as possible for foreign use, and our main regret was that this could only be a temporary and therefore inexpensive place, where we couldn't indulge in the true beauty of Chinese decorations. As it turned out, around seven to eight hundred dollars had disappeared before we were finished, and still, no one would have mistaken the place for a royal palace. But they were only “Mex” dollars, which is always the case when mentioning money in China, and there was a chance someone might return some of them when it was time to leave Peking and move on. Besides, either of the hotels would have taken the dollars and left us with nothing but the furniture.
By the time I returned from Urga we were ready to move in. Our Peking home is out in the very eastern edge of the Tartar City, so close under the East Wall that sunrise is always a little later with us than in the capital as a whole. It is not easily found, for it opens off a narrow hutung of its own, a nameless little lane running head on into the mighty wall, without another foreigner for several minutes’ walk in any direction, and—since we are to cast aside reticence for the information of other householders—the rent is seventy-five dollars “Mex” a month, with no Oriental jokers in the lease. Before I have occasion to mention them again, let me say that, though their value varies daily, the dollars of China averaged a hundred and eighty-seven to a hundred of our own during our winter in Peking. Wherever the words “dollar” or “cent” appear hereafter in these pages they are of this cheaper variety.
By the time I got back from Urga, we were ready to move in. Our home in Peking is located on the very eastern edge of Tartar City, so close to the East Wall that sunrise is always a bit later for us than in the rest of the capital. It's not easy to find, as it opens off a narrow hutung, a nameless little lane that runs straight into the massive wall, with no other foreigners for several minutes’ walk in any direction. And—just to be open with other homeowners—the rent is seventy-five dollars “Mex” a month, with no hidden surprises in the lease. Before I mention this again, let me point out that while their value changes daily, the Chinese dollars averaged a hundred and eighty-seven to one hundred of our dollars during our winter in Peking. Whenever the terms “dollar” or “cent” appear later in these pages, they refer to this less valuable currency.
It was a great change from the carefully tended Legation Quarter, with its macadamed streets and tree-bordered sidewalks, its wide gateways with vistas of one great power after another—though one comes to wonder whether in China of to-day these powers are greater than they are impotent—to cross Great Hata-men Street and strike off into the maze of hutungs to the east of it. But there the joy of a real home was 179impressed upon us; we were living as we had long planned, in a Chinese house among Chinese neighbors in Peking, the spell of the old capital, of the real China, weaving itself all about us. Outwardly the place would not be inviting to American tastes. But once a quick, light tapping of the door-ring brings a “boy” to swing back the heavy halves of the poetic red door we enter a very world of our own, completely shut off from all but the sounds, and occasionally the smells, of the teeming Chinese world about us. Its voices may drift over to us, but what does it know of us within?
It was a huge shift from the well-kept Legation Quarter, with its paved streets and tree-lined sidewalks, its broad gateways offering views of one major power after another—though one might wonder if these powers in today's China are more powerful or more ineffective—to cross Great Hata-men Street and dive into the maze of hutungs to the east. But there, we truly felt the joy of having a home; we were living as we had long dreamed, in a Chinese house among Chinese neighbors in Beijing, the charm of the ancient capital, of real China, wrapping around us. On the surface, the place might not appeal to American tastes. Yet, the moment a quick, light tap on the doorbell brings a “boy” to swing open the heavy halves of the striking red door, we step into a world of our own, completely cut off from everything except the sounds, and occasionally the smells, of the bustling Chinese world surrounding us. Its voices may drift in our direction, but what do they really know about us inside?
A Chinese house turned out to be a very pleasant place to live in. There was pleasure even in having no stairs to climb, especially after being on the top floor of a hotel where the elevator too often bore the sign “No currency”; the delightful feeling of being at home as soon as the red doors closed behind us was more real than we had ever felt it in any of our Western abodes. Ours is a simple dwelling, to be sure, as befits mere rolling stones. It has only one court, perhaps thirty feet square, paved with gray mud bricks and surrounded by four separate little low-browed houses of two rooms each, their roofs of curved tile slanting down in a protective way, as if presaging hot summers or bitter winters. Their bare backs are turned to the neighbors who crowd us on every side, and their windows all face the court, take up all four sides of it, in fact, for on the inside there are nothing but windows. At the top these are lattices covered with the flimsy white paper so general in China, easily renewed and much more adequate against heat or cold than one would think; but foreign influence has put real glass in the lower panes. One is not long in discovering that in Peking the main house always faces south. If the compound is on the north side of the street the best rooms are at the far back of it; if it is on the south side they back up against the street wall, and so on. This most important building almost always has a low wide porch, like ours, with a pergola-roof over which plants rooted in the unpaved strips of earth along the sides of the court can clamber. In summer it is the Peking custom to have the courtyard covered by a pêng, a huge reed mat on pole legs, high enough above the whole establishment to shade it without cutting off the breeze—and always rented, by the way, from the pêng-gild, which refuses to sell. But summer was waning when we moved in, and for eight or nine months a year it would be a sacrilege to shut out the brilliant blue sky that tents Peking, often without the tiniest rent in it for weeks at a time. Even when the dry cold of a Peking winter was at its sharpest we never regretted the separation of our little houses 180which necessitated crossing the court and having another glimpse of that unsullied blue sky and a breath of the outdoor air whenever we went from one room to another.
A Chinese house turned out to be a really nice place to live. It was even a relief not having to climb stairs, especially after being on the top floor of a hotel where the elevator often had the “No currency” sign. The wonderful feeling of being at home as soon as the red doors closed behind us felt more real than we ever experienced in any of our Western places. Ours is a simple dwelling, as suits just wandering souls. It has only one courtyard, about thirty feet square, paved with gray mud bricks and surrounded by four separate little houses, each with two rooms. Their curved tile roofs slope down protectively, almost like they’re anticipating hot summers or harsh winters. The backs of the houses face the neighbors who are close on every side, and all the windows look into the courtyard, in fact, it’s all windows on the inside. At the top, they have lattices covered with the thin white paper that’s common in China, easy to replace and surprisingly effective against heat or cold. However, foreign influence has added real glass to the lower panes. You quickly learn that in Peking, the main house always faces south. If the compound is on the north side of the street, the best rooms are at the back; if it’s on the south side, they face the street wall, and so on. This vital building almost always features a low, wide porch, like ours, with a pergola where plants rooted in the unpaved strips of earth on the sides of the courtyard can climb. In the summer, it’s the Peking custom to cover the courtyard with a pêng, a huge reed mat on poles, high enough to shade the whole place without blocking the breeze—and it's always rented from the pêng-gild, which refuses to sell. But summer was winding down when we moved in, and for eight or nine months a year, it would be a shame to block out the brilliant blue sky that hangs over Peking, often without a single break in it for weeks. Even when the dry cold of a Peking winter was at its sharpest, we never regretted the distance between our little houses, which required crossing the courtyard and getting another glimpse of that clear blue sky and a breath of fresh air whenever we went from one room to another. 180
The collecting of the requisite staff of servants was the mildest task of all. In Peking, as in all China, human beings swarm so thickly that the mere rumor of a desire for services is enough to bring many fold of applicants. The wise thing for the new-comer is to hire his servants through the servants of his friends, or in some such linked-up way. They will no doubt have to pay their informants a certain “squeeze” for the job, but one is protected from fly-by-night domestics whose antecedents and family roots are unknown; though compared with the opportunities which Chinese servants have for fleecing foreign employers they are honesty personified. A staff thus recommended to us lined up for inspection. There was an engaging-looking little cook nearing middle life, a round-faced, too youthful “boy,” who, having once served in a Japanese hotel and learned unpleasant habits, soon departed in favor of a man from the interior of the province, and a tall, handsome Shantung coolie. Then there came a wrinkled old rickshaw-man, one of the swiftest runners in Peking for all his age, and finally, after more careful picking, we chose the only feminine member of the staff, an ama for the most important task of all,—pursuing the younger generation. Then, with a dose of interpreted orders, we were off.
The process of gathering the necessary staff of servants was the easiest task of all. In Beijing, like everywhere in China, people are so numerous that just the hint of needing help is enough to attract a lot of applicants. The smart move for newcomers is to hire their staff through the connections of their friends or in a similar way. They will likely have to pay a little “commission” for this, but it protects them from unreliable servants whose backgrounds and family ties are unknown; although compared to the chances Chinese servants have to take advantage of foreign employers, they are incredibly honest. The staff recommended to us lined up for review. There was an appealing-looking middle-aged cook, a round-faced “boy” who seemed too young and had once worked in a Japanese hotel before leaving due to bad habits, replaced by a man from the province, and a tall, handsome Shandong laborer. Next was a wrinkled old rickshaw driver, one of the fastest runners in Beijing despite his age, and finally, after more careful selection, we chose the only female member of the team, a nanny for the most crucial task of all—looking after the younger generation. Then, with a set of interpreted instructions, we were on our way.
For on one point we were adamant: we would not have an English-speaking servant in the house. Chinese domestics who have even a smattering of the language of their employers, we had already noted, are likely to be impudent, to be experts in the matter of “squeeze,” and to demand what in Peking are fabulous wages. Life is much simpler, too, when one can talk freely without being understood by the servants. But the really important motive was that we wished to learn Chinese, above all to have the son who had lost his second birthday in crossing the Pacific learn it, and not the atrocious Pidgin-English which constitutes the linguistic lore of so many “boys” and amas. Looking back upon it we can testify that there is no more direct road to a speaking knowledge of even the Chinese language than living in the unbroken midst of it.
For one thing, we were clear: we didn’t want an English-speaking servant in the house. We had already noticed that Chinese workers who know even a little bit of their employers’ language tend to be disrespectful, skilled at getting extra money, and demand what are considered outrageous wages in Peking. Life is also much simpler when you can talk openly without the servants understanding you. But the main reason was that we wanted to learn Chinese, especially for our son who missed his second birthday while crossing the Pacific, so he could learn it instead of the terrible Pidgin English that many “boys” and amas speak. Looking back, we can say there's no better way to really learn a language than to live immersed in it.
Down in the Legation Quarter people pay their servants two or three times what is customary in the rest of Peking, to say nothing of the “rake-off” which careless auditing and boastful living give them. Our new staff named their own wages, but they named them on an uninflated 181basis, so that both sides were satisfied. All except the ama considered ten dollars a month a suitable return for their services, though the rickshaw-man, of course, had to have eight more for the use of his shining carriage, housed just within the outer door. The woman stood out for fourteen, something more than the average in that quarter, but she proved well worth it, for not only was hers the most responsible job but the many other tasks that fall to an ama’s lot made her specially valuable. Besides their wages, Chinese servants get nothing, legitimately, except the k’ang they sleep on in their cramped quarters, a basket of coal-balls now and then in the colder months, and sometimes a garment used exclusively in their employer’s service. Their food is their own affair. Thus our staff of five cost us sixty-two “Mex,” or, to put it into American money, about thirty-five dollars gold a month. In addition to this they expected cash presents at our Christmas, their New Year, and when we should break up housekeeping, totaling approximately an extra month’s wages.
In the Legation Quarter, people pay their servants two or three times more than what’s typical in the rest of Beijing, not to mention the extra income from careless accounting and showy lifestyles. Our new staff set their own salaries, but they did it based on a realistic standard, so both sides felt good about it. Everyone except the ama thought ten dollars a month was a fair wage for their work, although the rickshaw driver claimed eight more for his shiny carriage, parked just inside the outer door. The woman insisted on fourteen, which was a bit above average for that area, but she proved to be worth it because not only was her job the most responsible, but the additional tasks that come with being an ama made her particularly valuable. Besides their wages, Chinese servants receive nothing additional except for the k’ang they sleep on in their cramped rooms, an occasional basket of coal-balls during the colder months, and sometimes a uniform used only for their employer’s needs. Their meals are their own responsibility. So, our team of five cost us sixty-two “Mex,” which is about thirty-five dollars in gold per month in American currency. On top of that, they expected cash gifts at our Christmas, their New Year, and when we stopped housekeeping, which added up to roughly another month’s pay.
Chinese servants have their faults, but when these are all summed up I doubt whether they exceed those of domestics even in Europe, to say nothing of our own land. Certainly life runs more smoothly under their ministrations than the most willing and efficient of “hired girls” can make it. Whether it is their natural temperament or merely a pride of their calling, a surly face or manner, the faintest breath of impudence or “back talk,” even when the lady of the house has been alone with them for weeks at a time, have been as unknown in our circle as has a protest against any task assigned them. They have their own ways of doing things, but even these we have succeeded in changing where it was essential to do so. The division of work is left to them, for this is a matter in which one quickly finds it wise not to attempt to interfere. If any of them has ever felt that he was being imposed upon by the others, it was settled among themselves, and the matter never came to our ears. There are no such things as afternoons off among Peking servants; like their fellows, ours work, or at least are on call, twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week. Once in a while the “boy” or the coolie interrupts our evening reading for an instant by asking permission to go out, but we have never known them to be missing when next they are wanted. The rickshaw-man asked perhaps three or four times during the winter to go and have something done to his vehicle, but only in a few cases of misunderstanding was he not on hand when we wished him to trot away with us, until with the coming of the Chinese New Year he decided that he had held a steady job long enough. 182The ama has two small daughters, not to mention a husband and the inevitable mother-in-law, at her home not half an hour away, yet though she has never been discouraged in doing so I doubt whether she has gone to see them a dozen times during the winter, and whenever she does she brings back some gay and not always inexpensive Chinese toy to her appreciative charge, as if to make up for the presumption of leaving him. It is really more than that, of course, like the constant kindnesses of all the servants toward him, for nowhere could a small boy be more royally treated than among the child-loving Chinese.
Chinese servants have their flaws, but when you add them all up, I doubt they’re worse than those of domestic workers in Europe, not to mention our own country. Life definitely goes more smoothly with their help than it does with even the most eager and capable “hired girls.” Whether it’s their natural attitude or just a sense of pride in what they do, we’ve never encountered a grumpy face or attitude, not a hint of sass or “back talk,” even after the lady of the house has spent weeks alone with them. They have their own methods for getting things done, but we’ve managed to adjust them when it was necessary. We leave the division of labor up to them, since it’s best not to interfere in that. If any of them ever felt like they were being taken advantage of by the others, they sorted it out among themselves without it reaching us. There’s no such thing as afternoons off for servants in Peking; like their counterparts, ours work, or at the very least are on standby, twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week. Occasionally, the “boy” or the coolie will interrupt our evening reading briefly to ask if they can step out, but we’ve never noticed them being absent when we needed them. The rickshaw driver might have asked three or four times over the winter for permission to do maintenance on his vehicle, but only in a few misunderstandings was he not available when we wanted him to take us somewhere, until the Chinese New Year came around and he decided he had held a steady job long enough. 182The ama has two small daughters, along with a husband and the inevitable mother-in-law, living not half an hour away. Yet, despite her persistence, I doubt she has visited them more than a dozen times during the winter, and whenever she does, she brings back some colorful and sometimes pricey Chinese toy for her appreciative charge, as if to make up for the fact that she left him. It's really more than that, of course; it reflects the constant kindness of all the servants towards him, because no small boy could be treated more royally than among the child-loving Chinese.
Though we have never gone deeply into the matter, the work of each servant seems to be definitely fixed by custom. The rickshaw-man sweeps the court in the morning, unless he is busy with his chief duty, and keeps an ear on the door-knocker. The “boy” combines the lighter tasks of butler and chambermaid, and in general acts as a buffer between us and the outside world. The coolie does most of the rough labor, including the floors, the stoves, the washing, both of dishes and clothing, and the ironing, producing dress-shirts that would make the best steam-laundries in the United States blush with shame, if they were capable of any such display of emotion, and pressing even feminine evening frills with the deft hand of a French maid. In the time left over from her chief duty the ama does much of the sewing and many of those little odds and ends which in other lands make up the drudgery of a housewife. Since a daughter joined us in the spring she has performed her augmented task with the same ever cheerful efficiency.
Though we have never delved deeply into the subject, each servant's role seems clearly defined by tradition. The rickshaw driver sweeps the courtyard in the morning, unless he's occupied with his main duty, and keeps an ear on the doorbell. The “boy” handles the lighter duties of a butler and chambermaid, generally serving as a buffer between us and the outside world. The coolie takes on most of the heavy labor, including cleaning the floors, working the stoves, washing both dishes and clothes, and ironing, producing dress shirts that would make the best laundromats in the United States look ashamed, if they were capable of feeling such emotions, and pressing even evening gowns with the skilled touch of a French maid. In the time left from her primary responsibility, the ama does much of the sewing and other small tasks that in other countries make up the daily grind of a housewife. Since a daughter joined us in the spring, she has handled her increased duties with the same consistently cheerful efficiency.
The cook is more of a free lance, with very definite duties, including a daily trip to market. In China as a whole the tsoa-fan-ti and the mistress have a frequent meeting over his account-book, but in Peking there is a wide-spread custom euphonistically known as “boarding with the cook.” It simplifies the task of keeping him in hand, especially for a tai-tai speaking a very limited amount of Chinese, to set a fixed price for the day’s food and leave the rest to the Celestial kitchen. We adopted this custom, and have found it not only satisfactory but as economical as our friends report the other method to be. For Rachel and myself we dole out a dollar a day each, and half as much for the youngster. This includes everything that comes to the table except the morning bottle of milk and those nefarious products of France and Italy in similar containers with which I or our guests choose to flout our constitutions and that of our native land. The spenders among the foreign colony of Peking will undoubtedly, if it ever comes to their 183attention, sneer at the paucity of this sum; perhaps those who have deigned to accept our hospitality will say, “I thought so.” But I have promised to be frank. We are simple people, with tastes which do not daily require such viands as are commonly symbolized as quail on toast. As a matter of fact we often do have just that, for there is probably no capital in the world where game is more plentiful and cheaper than in the Peking markets. Certainly we never go hungry, and what that cook can do for a whole day with a sum that would not leave enough for a tip after a single luncheon in a very modest New York restaurant would give an American the false impression that the high cost of living has never come to China.
The cook works more like a freelancer, with clear responsibilities, including a daily trip to the market. In China overall, the tsoa-fan-ti and the mistress often meet to discuss his account-book, but in Peking, there’s a common practice euphemistically called “boarding with the cook.” This makes it easier for a tai-tai who speaks very little Chinese to set a fixed price for the daily meals and let the skilled kitchen handle the rest. We adopted this practice and have found it not only satisfying but also as economical as our friends say the other method is. For Rachel and me, we budget a dollar a day each, and half that for the little one. This covers everything on the table except the morning bottle of milk and those indulgent products from France and Italy in similar containers that I or our guests choose to enjoy despite the impact on our health and that of our country. The spenders among the foreign community in Peking will surely, if they ever realize it, scoff at the smallness of this amount; perhaps those who have accepted our hospitality will say, “I figured that.” But I promised to be honest. We are simple folks whose tastes don’t require lavish foods such as those often represented by quail on toast. In fact, we often do have that, as there’s likely no capital in the world where game is more abundant and affordable than in the Peking markets. We certainly never go hungry, and what that cook can do for an entire day with an amount that wouldn’t even cover a tip after a modest lunch at a New York restaurant would give an American the mistaken idea that the high cost of living has yet to reach China.
We live mainly on Chinese products, augmented by such foreign delicacies as cocoa, coffee, canned milk, imported butter, spices, jam, bacon, and the like, all furnished out of the cook’s stipend. Eggs, I believe, reached the height of an American cent each during midwinter; a chicken of moderate size costs from fifty to sixty coppers, which is not more than sixteen cents in real money. The far-famed Peking duck, which dot with white the moat just over the wall from us, would be a more serious acquisition, being in great demand among Chinese epicures; but squab, plump and tender, sells for the equivalent of a nickel each, and the succession of snipe, pigeons, partridge, pheasants, and wild duck that have graced our board would be luxuries to a war profiteer at home. Vegetables are plentiful in Peking, but the choice of meat is limited. Pork, beloved by all Chinese, foreigners eschew as a matter of course; if they have not seen what Chinese pigs feed on they are sure to have heard. Peking beef has the reputation of being the flesh of animals that have outlived their usefulness as beasts of burden rather than of those raised for food. Now and again, as the hungry militarists have boosted octroi duties at the city gates, the sheep butchers have gone on strike, which is particularly a hardship to Peking’s large Mohammedan population. But fowl, wild and tame, is always on hand to make up for any such catastrophe. We found Chinese corn meal and millet and a native brown but excellent cream of wheat preferable to the breakfast cereals from across the Pacific. Chinese pears, and especially the big golden persimmons which last almost all winter, are no poor substitutes for the California oranges sold in at least one foreign-goods grocery at three for a dollar. Now and then “Ta-shih-fu” takes a flier in desserts. Like all Peking chefs he prefers to make a thing which is fearful and wonderful to behold but which is a trial of temper and skill to the guest who has first to cut 184into it. There is that infamous “Peking dust,” a wall of glacéd fruits enclosing a mound of grated chestnuts of exactly the consistency, though by no means the splendid taste, of sawdust, and doted on, unfortunately, by that member of the family with most influence in the kitchen. Sometimes dinner is topped off with a pastry-and-cake basket, handle and all, full of custard and nuts. But all such weaknesses are amply made up for by the fact that pies worthy of the proudest New England housewife often come from the kitchen, usually labeled in the white of an egg with poetic Chinese characters. These literary effusions are seldom missing on any formal dessert, if there is space to get them in; when our first national holiday came there appeared a brave pink and green iced cake with the greeting “Thanksgiver Day” written boldly across it.
We mainly rely on Chinese products, supplemented by foreign treats like cocoa, coffee, canned milk, imported butter, spices, jam, bacon, and the like, all covered by the cook’s budget. Eggs, I believe, peaked at an American cent each during the winter; a moderately sized chicken costs between fifty and sixty coppers, which is just about sixteen cents in real money. The famous Peking duck, which dot the moat just over the wall from us, would be a more significant purchase, as they are highly sought after by Chinese food lovers; however, squab, plump and tender, sells for around a nickel each, and the variety of snipe, pigeons, partridge, pheasants, and wild duck that have graced our table would be considered luxuries by a war profiteer back home. Vegetables are abundant in Peking, but meat options are limited. Pork, loved by all Chinese, is typically avoided by foreigners; if they haven't seen what Chinese pigs eat, they've certainly heard about it. Peking beef is known to come from animals that have outlived their usefulness as work animals rather than those raised for food. Occasionally, as the hungry militarists raise city gate duties, sheep butchers have gone on strike, which is particularly tough on Peking’s large Muslim population. But poultry, both wild and domesticated, is always available to compensate for such disasters. We found Chinese cornmeal and millet and a local brown but excellent cream of wheat more appealing than the breakfast cereals from across the Pacific. Chinese pears, especially the large golden persimmons that last almost all winter, are decent substitutes for the California oranges sold in at least one foreign-goods store for three for a dollar. Now and then, “Ta-shih-fu” takes a chance on desserts. Like all Peking chefs, he prefers to create something that looks amazing but is a test of patience and skill for the guest who has to cut into it first. There’s that infamous “Peking dust,” a wall of glacéd fruits surrounding a pile of grated chestnuts that has the same texture, though not the delightful taste, as sawdust, and is unfortunately adored by the family member with the most influence in the kitchen. Sometimes dinner concludes with a pastry-and-cake basket, handle and all, filled with custard and nuts. But all such shortcomings are more than made up for by the fact that pies worthy of the finest New England housewife often come from the kitchen, usually inscribed in egg white with poetic Chinese characters. These literary flourishes are rarely absent from any formal dessert, if there’s room for them; when our first national holiday arrived, a lovely pink and green iced cake appeared with “Thanksgiver Day” boldly written across it.
Our cook is noteworthy among his tribe in that he can prepare a Chinese as well as a foreign meal, and two or three times a week this wholly different but no less enjoyable repast adorns our table, chop-sticks and all. In general he is given a free rein in selection, so long as he has a certain balance in menu, and using his excellent Chinese judgment he dines us almost too well, and no doubt, in the time-honored Chinese way, pockets the coppers left over. We do not know that our cook “squeezes” a cent, but if he does not he should be drummed out of the Chinese cooks’ union, if there is such a thing. For it is taken for granted by all foreigners in China that their cooks believe a certain legitimate “squeeze” is attached to the job, and though it takes an American housewife some time to reconcile herself to it, old foreign residents would be much put out to find that the rule is not general. Popular tradition has it that all cooks put into their own pockets a certain percentage of all money given them to spend; 5 per cent seems to be the accepted amount among foreigners in Peking, except in the Legation Quarter, where there are no definite limits. There are innumerable anecdotes illustrating this custom. Missionary cooks, boasting themselves Christians, have laid up small fortunes on their eight or ten “Mex” dollars a month. I know of one who, from the day his service began, made it an invariable rule to take six coppers for every person he cooked for during the day, and he now owns two modern houses which he rents to foreigners.
Our cook stands out among his peers because he can whip up both Chinese and international meals, and two or three times a week, a completely different but equally delightful meal graces our table, complete with chopsticks. Generally, he has the freedom to choose what to prepare, as long as there’s some balance in the menu, and with his excellent Chinese insight, he often feeds us quite lavishly. No doubt, in true Chinese fashion, he keeps the coins that are left over. We don’t actually know if he takes a little extra, but if he doesn’t, he should probably be kicked out of the Chinese cooks’ union—if such a thing exists. It’s commonly accepted by all foreigners in China that their cooks feel entitled to take a little “squeeze” from the job, and while it may take American housewives some time to adjust to this reality, long-term foreign residents would be quite upset to find out it’s not the norm. Popular belief suggests that all cooks pocket a certain percentage of the money given to them for expenses; 5 percent seems to be the standard among foreigners in Beijing, except in the Legation Quarter, where there are no clear limits. There are countless stories that highlight this custom. Even missionary cooks, who consider themselves Christians, have managed to save small fortunes on their eight or ten “Mex” dollars a month. I know one who, from the very beginning of his service, made it a strict rule to take six coins for every person he cooked for each day, and he now owns two modern houses that he rents to foreigners.
We have often wondered just how much our cook manages to lay aside. There is no way of finding out, for the Chinese market-man is ever faithful to his own people in any controversy with the “outside barbarian,” and the custom is so perfectly legitimate in the cookly mind 185that no pricking of conscience ever sullies the frank and smiling face of the king of our kitchen. In overcrowded China it has been the practice for centuries to fee any one who brings a job or a client, and even if the foreigner went to market himself he would not save the “rake-off”; in fact he would probably lose money. For the market-man does not quote a foreigner the price to which a Chinese cook will finally bring him down, and no grocer is going to tell his client when he pays his monthly bill that 5 per cent of it will go to his cook as soon as he comes in when there are no telltale foreigners looking on. Yet supernatural as the Chinese are in slicing off a “cash” or a copper where even a French eye could not possibly detect any such protuberance, we do not see how our cook can have made a fortune on the leavings. Including his six dollars for kitchen fuel he has eighty-one dollars a month to feed us on when I am at home. When we go out to dinner of course he is not the loser; extra money for invited guests gives him a trifle more leeway; possibly he sells a tin can or a bottle now and then to the constantly passing peddlers, though we have never seen any evidence of stooping to such methods. Yet his wages have never been higher than with us, at least since his youthful days as a retainer in the Manchu court, and, for all that, he has educated two of his four boys into fine, upstanding, well dressed young men with enough English to take important positions with foreign firms; the third is already well along the same road, and no doubt the youngest, who romps about all day in a neighboring hutung, will be similarly provided. We have never quite reconciled those grown sons to our little cook, still well on the sunny side of middle age; but in China, of course, the generations succeed themselves swiftly. We may be wronging him in assuming that he does not spend on us all we give him for that purpose, and if so I apologize. If we are not, he certainly is welcome to all he has kept, for he has served us for eight months in an unobtrusive, efficient, and most agreeable manner.
We often wonder how much our cook is able to save. There's no way to find out because the Chinese market seller always stands by his own people in any dispute with the “outside barbarian,” and this practice is so deeply accepted in the cook's mind that he never feels guilty as he smiles with confidence in the kitchen. In crowded China, it's been a long-standing tradition to tip anyone who brings a job or a client, and even if a foreigner goes to the market himself, he won’t save anything; in fact, he might end up losing money. The market seller won’t give a foreigner the same price a Chinese cook could negotiate, and no grocer is going to tell his client that 5 percent of the monthly bill will go straight to the cook as soon as he shows up with no nosy foreigners around. While the Chinese can deftly cut corners where even a French eye wouldn’t see a discrepancy, we can't figure out how our cook could have made a fortune from leftovers. He gets eighty-one dollars a month to feed us when I’m at home, including his six dollars for kitchen fuel. When we go out to dinner, he obviously doesn’t lose out; extra cash for invited guests gives him a bit more flexibility; he might occasionally sell a tin can or a bottle to the peddlers who pass by, even though we’ve never actually seen him do that. Still, his wages have never been higher than what he earns from us, at least since his younger days as a servant in the Manchu court, and despite that, he has managed to educate two of his four sons into respectable, well-dressed young men with enough English to take decent jobs with foreign companies; the third son is already on a similar path, and the youngest, who plays around all day in a nearby hutung, will probably be set up in the same way. We’ve never really accepted those adult sons of our little cook, who is still young enough to be in the prime of life; but in China, generations come and go quickly. We might be underestimating him if we think he doesn’t spend everything he gets from us, and if that's the case, I apologize. If we’re not, then he’s certainly entitled to whatever he’s saved, as he has served us for eight months in a quiet, efficient, and very pleasant manner.
Chinese of standing have let us into a few of the secrets of life among house servants. Most cooks, at least for foreigners, are not Peking men, it seems, but come in from the country. Having no family to support in the capital, those earning ten dollars a month, eating leftovers—though few Chinese servants care for foreign food—and spending perhaps two dollars a month of their own, can send home about a hundred dollars a year. Those with families in Peking have to devise methods for augmenting their wages; therefore they do not consider those methods dishonest. One might ask, why not pay the man a living 186wage to begin with and then expect him to be honest? Alas, centuries of the other plan have made that contrary to the Chinese way of thinking. The moment you pay a servant more than the market price he takes you for a gullible victim or a millionaire and “squeezes” all the more. It is the Chinese system, and many a foreigner has broken his head against it in vain.
Chinese people of influence have revealed some secrets about life with house servants. Most cooks for foreigners, it seems, aren't from Beijing but come from the countryside. Without families to support in the capital, those earning ten dollars a month, eating leftovers—though few Chinese servants like foreign food—and spending maybe two dollars a month can send home around a hundred dollars each year. Those with families in Beijing have to come up with ways to boost their income; as a result, they don't see those methods as dishonest. One might ask, why not just pay the person a decent wage from the start and then expect honesty? Unfortunately, centuries of the opposite approach have made that thinking counter to the Chinese way. The moment you pay a servant more than the market rate, they view you as an easy target or a millionaire and "squeeze" you even more. It's the Chinese system, and many foreigners have struggled against it in vain.
A genuine cook to foreigners owes it to his dignity to have an apprentice assistant, just as he must ride to and from market in a rickshaw. Not long after we settled down, “Ta-shih-fu” asked permission to bring into the kitchen his younger brother, whose profession of torturing a Chinese violin seemed to be in ever decreasing demand. There he has remained month after month, learning the rudiments of foreign cooking, until he has gathered sufficient audacity to go and cook for foreigners himself, thereby making his future secure. But never has it been so much as hinted that we should pay him anything; his wageless standing is perfectly in keeping with the Chinese scheme of things, and no one would be more surprised than he or his brother if we offered him money.
A real chef working for foreigners needs to maintain his dignity by having an apprentice, just like he has to take a rickshaw to and from the market. Not long after we settled in, “Ta-shih-fu” asked if he could bring his younger brother into the kitchen, since his skill in playing the Chinese violin was in increasingly low demand. He has been here month after month, learning the basics of foreign cooking, until he finally gained enough confidence to cook for foreigners himself, securing his future. However, it has never been suggested that we should pay him anything; his unpaid status fits perfectly with the Chinese way of doing things, and neither he nor his brother would be more surprised than if we offered him money.
Whatever we can say for our cook we can testify that the “boy” who has been with us since the second month is honest even in the Western sense. He is, we hasten to admit, different from the rank and file of “boys” to foreigners in Peking; no doubt they would dub him “queer.” He comes from somewhere ’way down the province, well off the railroad, and seems deliberately to refuse to learn the tricks of the capital. Down there he has a wife of seventeen, perhaps forced upon him by his parents in the customary Chinese manner; at least he has never shown any desire to go home, not even at New Year’s. But then, he is past forty. His service is so constant that we have sometimes urged him to go out more often, but he replies with a smile that he has few friends in Peking and nowhere to go. Once or twice a month he calls in a passing barber, and perhaps he has stepped out half a dozen times during the winter on a brief personal errand—except that, as regularly as fortnightly pay-day comes round, he goes to send a letter home. The extent to which Chinese families pool their incomes, with some grandfather or mother-in-law as treasurer, would take almost any American’s breath away. We have many a time caught this extraordinary “boy” carefully avoiding chances to “squeeze,” passing on to the other servants buying errands assigned him, lest we suspect him of taking a commission. Once a tourist couple dropped in for tea, and 187having traveled too fast to orientalize the point of view of their native Chicago, surreptitiously slipped a silver dollar into the “boy’s” palm as he opened the door at their departure. He did not faint; hence we might never have known of that social blunder if the “boy” had not rushed back as soon as the door was closed, his outstretched hand offering us the coin. I warned you he was queer; I am not sure but that the normal “boy” of Peking would not consider him downright crazy. But honesty and diligence, alas, are not always sufficient in this miserable world. When we move on we despair of finding this “boy” another place more than any of the others, for his stock of self-confidence is as scanty as his integrity is unusual.
Whatever we can say about our cook, we can vouch for the “boy” who has been with us since the second month; he's honest even by Western standards. We have to admit, he’s different from the typical “boys” who work for foreigners in Peking; they would probably call him “strange.” He comes from far down in the province, far off the railroad, and seems to intentionally avoid learning the ways of the capital. Back home, he has a seventeen-year-old wife, likely arranged by his parents in the traditional Chinese way; still, he has never shown any desire to return, not even for New Year’s. But then, he’s over forty. He works so consistently that we’ve often encouraged him to go out more, but he just smiles and says he has few friends in Peking and nowhere to go. Once or twice a month, he brings in a passing barber, and he might’ve gone out half a dozen times this winter for a quick personal errand—except that, without fail, every pay period, he goes to send a letter home. The way Chinese families combine their incomes, with some grandparent or in-law as the treasurer, would shock almost any American. We’ve often caught this remarkable “boy” carefully avoiding chances to take a cut, passing off errands to the other servants so that we wouldn’t suspect him of pocketing a commission. Once, a couple of tourists stopped by for tea, and having rushed their trip without adjusting their perspective from Chicago, secretly slipped a silver dollar into the “boy’s” hand as he opened the door when they left. He didn’t faint; we might never have known of that social blunder if he hadn’t rushed back as soon as the door shut, holding out his hand to offer us the coin. I told you he was strange; I’m not sure the typical “boy” in Peking wouldn’t think he was downright crazy. But honesty and hard work, sadly, aren’t always enough in this terrible world. When we move on, we’re more worried about finding this “boy” another job than anyone else, because his level of self-confidence is as low as his integrity is rare.
The normal Peking “boy,” particularly if he knows some English, is usually the general factotum of a foreign household. Many foreigners never speak to their other servants but transmit all orders through the “boy,” or, if the staff is large, through “number one boy.” Some of the older and more experienced of these take on the efficiency and the manner of old English butlers; they can arrange anything, from a dinner-party on Christmas to a picnic out at the Temple of Heaven by moonlight, at a mere hint from their socially busy mistresses. But we much prefer our type of “boy.” Though they may succeed in keeping their own employers in ignorance of that fact, the observant guest can hardly fail to see that these efficient head servants grow scornful toward their subordinates and often despise foreigners in general and the family they serve in particular. Obviously their “squeeze” increases with their importance and their opportunities. Some of them make fortunes out of the peddlers and shopkeepers whose patronage they recommend, and positions under them are not had for the mere asking. The “boy” of an American official in Peking came to his mistress one day and insisted on giving her a present worth easily his year’s salary, saying he had become a Christian and hence was “ashamed for the much money” he had been given by those who sold things to the family and to their many tourist guests—and begged her to accept this customary percentage on his winnings. How the t’ing-ch’ai, or topmost “boy” in a foreign legation, makes use of his opportunities is a story worth telling, but that would be trespassing into the realms of high finance.
The typical Peking "boy," especially if he knows some English, usually acts as the general helper for a foreign household. Many foreigners rarely speak directly to their other staff, passing all their requests through the "boy," or, if the team is large, through the "number one boy." Some of the older, more experienced ones adopt the efficiency and demeanor of traditional English butlers; they can organize anything from a Christmas dinner party to a moonlit picnic at the Temple of Heaven with just a hint from their busy employers. However, we prefer our kind of "boy." While they may keep their employers unaware of this reality, an observant guest can't help but notice that these efficient head servants often become disdainful towards their subordinates and frequently look down on foreigners in general—and the family they work for in particular. Clearly, their influence increases with their status and chances. Some of them accumulate wealth from the vendors and shopkeepers they recommend, and positions under them aren’t easy to come by. One day, the "boy" of an American official in Peking approached his mistress and insisted on giving her a gift worth easily a year’s salary, saying he had converted to Christianity and was therefore "ashamed of the large amount of money" he received from those selling goods to the family and their many tourist guests—and he pleaded with her to accept this customary percentage on his earnings. How the t’ing-ch’ai, or top "boy" in a foreign legation, utilizes his opportunities is a tale worth sharing, but that would delve into the realm of high finance.
The long, handsome Shantung coolie, who laundered dress-shirts and pressed georgette evening-gowns with such amazing skill, turned out to be a contrast to the “boy,” and was destined to depart suddenly 188about the middle of January. At first the tai-tai used to “call the coal,” but Wang had gradually taken over the task and was getting it for as low a price as she—I am sure I am not doing Wang an injury by mentioning his name, any more than I should by specifying an American called Smith. The coal, however, seemed to burn up faster and faster, and each alleged ton piled against the wall of the little back court at the front of our compound looked smaller. One day we questioned its size, and Wang promptly guaranteed to make it last the month out. That would have been physically impossible, yet last it did. Other suspicious little things began to gather about the tall handsome coolie. None of them were definite, however, and Wang might be with us yet but for the other servants, though I fancy he would have hanged himself alone in time. A whisper from the ama caused Rachel to “call” the next ton herself, and to borrow scales from an American friend down the hutung. It was a cold evening when the ton arrived, but we persisted in watching it unloaded, weighed, and carried in. But why were there not sixteen sacks, as the silky Chinese dealer just outside Hata-men had promised, and why did twelve sacks total five hundred chin more than a ton? It took us until next day to find out.
The tall, attractive Shantung coolie, who expertly laundered dress shirts and pressed georgette evening gowns, turned out to be quite different from the “boy” and was set to leave unexpectedly around mid-January. At first, the tai-tai used to handle the coal, but Wang gradually took over the job and was getting it for as low a price as she—I doubt I'm hurting Wang's reputation by mentioning his name, just like I wouldn’t by naming an American named Smith. However, the coal seemed to burn up faster and faster, and every supposed ton stacked against the wall in the little back courtyard of our compound looked smaller. One day, we questioned its amount, and Wang confidently promised it would last the entire month. That would have been physically impossible, yet somehow it did last. Other odd things started to pile up around the tall, handsome coolie. None of them were definitive, though, and Wang might still be with us if not for the other servants, although I think he might have eventually isolated himself. A hint from the ama made Rachel decide to “call” for the next ton herself, and she borrowed scales from an American friend down the hutung. It was a chilly evening when the ton arrived, but we insisted on watching it being unloaded, weighed, and brought inside. But why were there not sixteen sacks, as the smooth-talking Chinese dealer just outside Hata-men had promised, and why did twelve sacks weigh five hundred chin more than a ton? It took us until the next day to figure it out.
The scales, of course, being Chinese, consisted of a mere stick with marks on it; but for the same reason it would have been impossible for them to be as simple and straightforward as they looked. All such scales have two loops by which to suspend them, and Wang assured us that both of these were used at once. That was all. Even the lady down the street who had been using them all winter did not know the difference. When at last we learned the Chinese trick of the scales the missing four bags were easily accounted for; and a little more trouble, mainly for the benefit of foreign residents in general, brought the blackened cart-driver over to confess that Wang had intercepted him just around the corner from us and sold the four bags to a little coal-yard almost behind our bedrooms—the same one, of course, from which he had bought back enough to fulfil his guarantee. The night before, Wang having asked permission to go out and get his hair cut, or something of the sort, we had been startled to have all the other servants irrupt upon us over our evening lamp, smiling nervously, but saying through the cook as spokesman that they could not endure our being misled about the missing man any longer. He was keeping bad company nights, they announced with visible unwillingness; he often brought in friends to sleep on their already crowded k’ang; coppers were sticking 189to his fingers in a way which apparently even a cooks’ union could not approve.
The scales, being Chinese, were just a simple stick with markings on it; but for that reason, they couldn’t be as straightforward as they seemed. All such scales have two hooks for hanging, and Wang assured us that both were used at the same time. That was it. Even the lady down the street who had been using them all winter didn’t know the difference. Once we figured out the Chinese trick with the scales, we easily accounted for the missing four bags; and with a bit more effort, mainly to help the foreign residents, we got the blackened cart-driver to come forward and admit that Wang had stopped him just around the corner from us and sold the four bags to a small coal yard almost behind our bedrooms—the same place from which he had bought enough to honor his guarantee. The night before, after Wang asked to go out for a haircut or something similar, we were shocked when all the other servants rushed in on us while we were reading by the evening lamp, smiling nervously but saying through the cook, their spokesman, that they could no longer stand us being misled about the missing man. They revealed, somewhat reluctantly, that he was mixing with the wrong crowd at night; he often brought friends home to sleep on their already crowded k’ang; and money was sticking to his fingers in a way that even a cooks’ union wouldn’t approve of.
Chinese servants are not in the habit of tattling against one another to their masters, and things must have come to a pretty pass to bring about this unusual scene. But we waited until we had other proof that it was not merely a case of spite; then we spoke gently to Wang as he was stirring the fire in my office next afternoon. There were four bags of coal missing from the ton of the night before, we confided to him, and as we did not wish to have the police mixed up in so small a matter we wondered if perhaps he could trace them. Then we went out to tea. That evening found us without a coolie; he had folded up his bed and departed, and he has never been back to claim the three or four days’ wages due him.
Chinese servants usually don't gossip about each other to their employers, so it must have taken a significant situation to cause this unusual scene. However, we waited until we had more evidence that it wasn't just a petty issue; then we spoke kindly to Wang as he was tending the fire in my office the next afternoon. We shared that four bags of coal were missing from the ton delivered the night before, and since we didn't want to involve the police in such a minor matter, we wondered if he could help track them down. After that, we went out for tea. That evening, we found ourselves without a coolie; he had packed up his bed and left, and he never returned to collect the three or four days’ wages owed to him.
Wang is a handsome youth, to Chinese eyes, and naturally he needed more money than his older stick-at-home colleagues. Besides, he did more hard work than all the others. If he had come to me privately and whispered his troubles, I think I should have been tempted to give him a monthly bonus, if he could have convinced me that the other servants would not hear of it, rather than see him depart; for never again in this imperfect world do I hope to display such gleaming shirt-bosoms as Wang furnished me. The ama promptly introduced her husband as coolie, and he has proved satisfactory, besides being under a watchful eye that completely belies the accepted notions of the position of wives in the Chinese scheme of things. But stiff shirts go to a professional laundry now, and though a new front costs there just one-tenth what it would in New York, they have lost that final touch of perfection, of youth and genius, which Wang put upon them.
Wang is a handsome young man, at least in the eyes of the Chinese, and naturally, he needed more money than his older, more homebody colleagues. Besides, he worked harder than anyone else. If he had come to me privately and shared his struggles, I think I would have been tempted to give him a monthly bonus, if he could convince me that the other servants wouldn’t find out, rather than see him leave; because I'll probably never again in this imperfect world have such sharp-looking shirt fronts as Wang gave me. The ama quickly introduced her husband as a coolie, and he has turned out to be satisfactory, also being under a watchful eye that totally contradicts the usual ideas about wives in the Chinese cultural context. But stiff shirts now go to a professional laundry, and even though a new collar there costs just one-tenth of what it would in New York, they've lost that final touch of perfection, youth, and creativity that Wang brought to them.
But on the whole our Peking servants are good, as human beings the world over go, for all the Wangs among them. I shall have forgotten their faults long before I forget the motherly care they have taken of my family during my long absences, the tasteful little presents they gave my wife on her birthday when I was not there to give her any myself, and the grandfatherly way they have with our small son.
But overall, our servants in Peking are good people, like most humans everywhere, despite a few Wangs among them. I'll forget their faults long before I forget the nurturing care they've shown my family during my long absences, the thoughtful little gifts they gave my wife on her birthday when I couldn't be there to give her anything myself, and the grandfatherly way they interact with our young son.
I should be sorry, however, if I have given the false impression that living is on the whole much cheaper for the foreigner in Peking than at home, thereby causing our no doubt overworked State Department to be bombarded with ten-dollar bills and demands for passports. Whether it is because low prices tempt one to spend more than one could if they were high, or that the absurd cost of certain necessary things physically 190or mentally imported from the Western world mount up faster than seems possible, we find that we are spending quite as much in Peking as we did in New York, and we do not play bridge or the races.
I would feel bad if I gave the wrong idea that living in Beijing is generally much cheaper for foreigners than at home, which might cause our probably overworked State Department to be flooded with ten-dollar bills and requests for passports. Whether it’s that low prices tempt us to spend more than we would if prices were higher, or that the ridiculous cost of some essential things we import from the Western world adds up faster than expected, we find ourselves spending just as much in Beijing as we did in New York, and we don’t even play bridge or go to the races. 190
The Chinese way of housekeeping, as we have pieced it together from bits of information picked up among our native acquaintances, is quite different from that of foreign residents. According to them, middle-class Chinese families usually have two servants—an ama and a cook. The ama does the washing and all the general housework, at least in the women’s apartments. Obviously the Chinese would be horrified beyond speech at the goings-on in foreigners’ houses; the “boy” of our white-haired compatriot down the hutung, for instance, lays out her most intimate garments when he judges it is time for her to change! Such an ama receives from one to two dollars a month, and a “present” of two or three dollars at each of the four principal Chinese holidays. Servants in native families are also given their rice, the monthly rice allowance for the whole household being fixed and the domestics eating the poorest quality. But they must have more income, and that is where gambling comes in. Much of this goes on in the average Chinese home, even among the women and their feminine guests in the afternoons. For every dollar staked ten cents is set aside by custom as cumshaw for the servants. Cigarettes sold at eight coppers a package around the corner cost the family and its guests ten, and so on. But gambling is the important thing. Servants in wealthy or political families, where high stakes are the rule, may get as much as a hundred dollars a month. A trustworthy Chinese informant told us that the one question always asked him by a prospective servant is some form of, “Is there gambling?” Where there is not, it is hard to get and keep good servants. In these days of comparative poverty in Peking those who cannot find places with foreigners, or have not the courage and adaptability such positions require, often have a hard time of it.
The way Chinese families manage their households, based on what we've gathered from conversations with our local friends, is quite different from how foreigners do it. According to them, middle-class Chinese families typically have two servants—an ama and a cook. The ama handles the laundry and all general housework, at least in the women's quarters. Clearly, the Chinese would be shocked by the happenings in foreign homes; for example, the “boy” of our elderly neighbor in the hutung lays out her most personal clothes when he thinks it’s time for her to change! An ama earns between one to two dollars a month, plus a “gift” of two or three dollars during each of the four major Chinese holidays. Servants in local families also receive rice, with the monthly rice allowance for the entire household being set and the servants getting the lowest quality. However, they often have additional income, and that’s where gambling comes in. A lot of this happens in the average Chinese home, even among women and their guests during the afternoons. For every dollar wagered, ten cents is customarily set aside as cumshaw for the servants. Cigarettes sold for eight cents a package around the corner are charged to the family and its guests for ten cents, and so on. But gambling is the main thing. Servants in wealthy or influential families, where high stakes are common, can make as much as a hundred dollars a month. A reliable Chinese source told us that the one question always asked by someone looking to hire a servant is some variation of, “Is there gambling?” Without it, it’s difficult to find and keep good help. In these times of relative poverty in Beijing, those who can't find jobs with foreigners, or lack the courage and adaptability that such positions require, often struggle significantly.
It would not be just, as well as being a sad blow to his pride, to mention Li Hsien-sheng among our servants. Mr. Li is our Chinese teacher. By our own choice he, too, speaks no English, so that our introduction to the language is by the method by which children learn one. He comes for an hour every afternoon, and carries away a ten-dollar bill at the end of each month. Yet he is something of a scholar, even if, like all his colleagues we have so far tried, not much of a teacher. However, I must not be too severe toward those numerous men of Peking who eke out a livelihood by guiding the barbarian within 191its gates into the mysteries of their strange tongue. At least they earn all they are paid, and if one learns to use them mainly as a dictionary, the result may be more worth while than at first seems possible. Nor is this the place to express my opinions, harsh or genial, on the incredible Chinese language. Suffice it for the moment to say that we both soon found ourselves able to express our simple desires to the servants without calling in some more experienced friend, and by midwinter could make ourselves understood to merchants keenly eager to understand us. The more diligent, stay-at-home, and mentally alert member of the family quickly left me in the linguistic background, but even she cannot keep pace with “Ha-li,” as the Chinese call my son and namesake. Though his third birthday is still ahead of him, he is already the family authority on tones and similar bugbears of the adult student of the Celestial vernacular, and I should hesitate to pit myself against him even in a test of vocabulary. I can only plead that it is an unfair advantage in acquiring a new language not to be able to speak any other when the acquisition begins.
It wouldn't be fair, and it would also be a hit to his pride, to refer to Li Hsien-sheng as one of our servants. Mr. Li is our Chinese teacher. By our choice, he also doesn't speak any English, so our introduction to the language is similar to how children learn. He comes every afternoon for an hour and takes home a ten-dollar bill at the end of each month. Still, he is somewhat of a scholar, even if, like all the other teachers we've tried so far, he's not much of a teacher. However, I shouldn’t be too critical of the many men in Peking who make a living helping outsiders navigate the complexities of their unique language. At least they earn their pay, and if you learn to use them mainly as a dictionary, the outcome can be more valuable than it first appears. This isn’t the time to share my opinions, whether harsh or kind, about the incredible Chinese language. For now, it's enough to say that we both quickly found we could express our basic needs to the servants without needing a more experienced friend, and by midwinter, we could communicate with merchants eager to understand us. The more diligent, homebound, and mentally sharp member of the family quickly outpaced me in learning the language, but even she can’t keep up with “Ha-li,” as the Chinese call my son and namesake. Although his third birthday is still coming up, he's already the family expert on tones and other tricky aspects of the adult learner of the Chinese language, and I wouldn’t dare challenge him in a vocabulary test. I can only point out that it’s a significant advantage in picking up a new language not to speak any other language when you start learning it.
Besides, what chance does an overworked father have compared to the opportunities of childhood? When “Ha-li” is not up on the wall discussing with the guardians who live there whatever he and they have in common, or chatting in Chinese with playmates whose mother-tongue may be that of anywhere from Brittany to Odessa, he is listening to the voices of the world outside our compound as they drift over to us. He has already picked up more hawkers’ cries than an adult ear can distinguish, and totes his basket about the courtyard shouting his wares, hand to ear in the Peking venders’ fashion, in tones so exactly those of the original outside that we often wonder what that original thinks of his echo. Daylight brings a never ending succession of these hawkers, from the cereal-man so early in the morning that surely no one could have the appetite to call him in, to the seller of sweetmeats so late at night that none but habitually hungry people could still be thinking of food. Our neighbors probably do some cooking of their own, but they save much fuel by patronizing these itinerant restaurants, the more sumptuous of them push-carts of a very Chinese type, most of them mere baskets oscillating from shoulder-poles. The people about us seem to have no fixed meal-hours, if indeed they keep any track of time at all. They eat one by one as appetite moves them or as coppers are available, and as surely as we leave home we will see a child or two, a woman, or some other solitary member of a large family squatted in the dirty little hutung beside their door engrossed in the contents of a bowl that has 192been rented, chop-sticks and all, from the vender who waits so patiently for the transaction to be completed that he does not seem to realize he is waiting.
Besides, what chance does an overworked father have compared to the opportunities of childhood? When “Ha-li” isn’t up on the wall talking with the guardians who live there about whatever they have in common, or chatting in Chinese with playmates whose mother tongue could be from anywhere between Brittany and Odessa, he’s listening to the sounds of the world outside our compound as they drift over to us. He has already picked up more street vendors’ calls than any adult ear can distinguish, and carries his basket around the courtyard shouting his goods, hand to ear in the Peking vendors’ way, in tones so closely resembling those of the original outside that we often wonder what that original thinks of his echo. Daylight brings a never-ending stream of these vendors, from the cereal man so early in the morning that surely no one would have the appetite to call him in, to the seller of sweets so late at night that only the habitually hungry could still be thinking about food. Our neighbors probably do some cooking on their own, but they save a lot of fuel by using these roaming food vendors, the fancier ones being very Chinese push carts, while most are just baskets swinging from shoulder poles. The people around us don’t seem to have regular meal times, if they even keep track of time at all. They eat one by one as their appetite strikes or as they have spare change, and as sure as we leave home we will see a child or two, a woman, or some other solitary member of a large family squatting in the dirty little hutung beside their door, absorbed in the contents of a bowl that has been rented, chopsticks and all, from the vendor who waits so patiently for the transaction to finish that he doesn’t even seem to realize he is waiting.
Some of the street cries are almost musical, even to our Western ears; some hawkers use instruments to spare their voices. The barber twangs what looks like a gigantic pair of tweezers; the knife- and scissor-sharpener blows a long horn or clashes together half a dozen heavy steel pieces carried only for that purpose; the toy-and-candy man has his gong, the china-riveter his swinging bells, the blind man his reed pipe, or his big brass disk, and his long tapping cane, and the water-seller has, of course, his squeaking wheelbarrow. The croak of the oil-man suggests some superannuated frog; the jolly old fellow who peddles Chinese wine from a beautiful copper urn has a succession of hoarse shouts that never vary; the cabbage-man, the peanut-man, the delicatessen wagon, so to speak, even the rag-picking women, all have their own cries, distinctive, yet unintelligible until one has learned them by rote rather than by meaning, as Peking did generations ago. Even we dull-eared adults know nearly all of them now, and are conscious of something missing if they fail to come at the usual hour, which is a rare lapse indeed. One fellow sings what might almost be a bar from some Italian opera. He is the gramophone-man, carrying his box and his big tin horn, and offering to play his well worn Chinese records for those families that have the coppers to spend on mere entertainment. The seller of fritters also comes near being a singer, with a lilting refrain that stays with one long after he has passed. But all in all the cries are disappointing. Though some start off as music, even though it be of the falsetto kind beloved of the Chinese, they almost invariably bring up somewhere in a sudden raucous shout that spoils them. Perhaps, as even some foreign enthusiasts insist, our Western ears are tuned only to the simplicity of Western music; our scale of eight tones may be crude as compared with the twenty-five gradations of the Chinese. But I doubt it. I have tried to imagine that haunting street-cry which trills through the opera “Louise” ending in a shrill shout. Surely its lyric quality would not thus be improved. Yet all this does not mean that our Peking cries are displeasing. Their fascination is something subtle, and we shall be sorry to move on again out of their orbit.
Some of the street calls are almost musical, even to our Western ears; some vendors use instruments to save their voices. The barber strums what looks like a giant pair of tweezers; the knife and scissor sharpener blows a long horn or clangs together half a dozen heavy steel pieces that he carries just for that purpose; the toy and candy seller has his gong, the china repairman has his swinging bells, the blind man has his reed pipe or his big brass disk, along with his long tapping cane, and the water seller, of course, has his squeaky wheelbarrow. The croak of the oil man sounds like some ancient frog; the cheerful old guy who sells Chinese wine from a beautiful copper urn has a series of hoarse shouts that never change; the cabbage seller, the peanut seller, the delicatessen cart, and even the rag-picking women all have their own calls, distinctive yet unintelligible until one learns them by heart rather than by meaning, just as Beijing did generations ago. Even we, somewhat dull-eared adults, know nearly all of them now and feel like something is missing if they don’t come at the usual time, which is a rare slip-up indeed. One guy sings what could almost be a bar from some Italian opera. He is the gramophone man, carrying his box and his big tin horn, and offering to play his well-worn Chinese records for families that have the spare change to spend on simple entertainment. The fritter seller almost sounds like a singer, with a catchy refrain that lingers long after he has passed. But overall, the calls are a bit disappointing. Though some start out as music, even if it’s in the falsetto style favored by the Chinese, they usually end up in a sudden grating shout that ruins them. Perhaps, as some foreign fans insist, our Western ears are only tuned to the simplicity of Western music; our scale of eight tones may seem crude compared to the twenty-five gradations of the Chinese. But I doubt it. I’ve tried to imagine that haunting street cry that trills through the opera “Louise” ending in a shrill shout. Surely its lyrical quality wouldn’t be improved that way. Still, this doesn’t mean that our Beijing cries are unpleasant. Their charm is something subtle, and we will be sorry to move on again out of their reach.

At Chinese New Year the streets of Peking were gay with all manner of things for sale, such as these brilliantly colored paintings of native artists
At Chinese New Year, the streets of Beijing were lively with all sorts of things for sale, including these brightly colored paintings by local artists.

A rich man died in our street; and among other things burned at his grave, so that he would have them in after life, were this “automobile” and two “chauffeurs”
A wealthy man died on our street, and among other things burned at his grave, so he would have them in the afterlife, were this “car” and two “drivers.”

A neighbor who gave his birds a daily airing
A neighbor who took his birds outside for some fresh air every day

Just above us on the Tartar Wall were the ancient astronomical instruments looted by the Germans in 1900 and recently returned, in accordance with a clause in the Treaty of Versailles
Just above us on the Tartar Wall were the ancient astronomical instruments stolen by the Germans in 1900 and recently returned, following a clause in the Treaty of Versailles.
193There may be a gauntlet a block long of merry but habitually unwashed children, chanting their incessant “Ee mao ch’ien! Ee mao ch’ien!” (“One dime money!”) as often as they catch sight of us, and the daily beggar of our section, with his “Lao yea tai-tai! Lao yea tai-tai!” (“Old gentleman lady!”) that wheezes down the scale in so persuasive a manner, is frequently out-shouted by his poaching rivals; but once the gate of the nearest wall-ramp is locked behind us by the keeper who jogs down at the tinkling of his little bell we are as free from such annoyances as from the dust and the forgotten garbage along the hutungs. For the Chinese are not allowed on the wall. That is, the great rank and file are not, and those of the better class who care that much for physical exercise are few, so that the top of the great Tartar Wall is almost a foreigners’ private promenade. None of our servants, not even those born in Peking, had ever been admitted to it until they appeared at the foot of our ramp with “Ha-li” as a passport. For that matter nearly all those wonderful monuments which even the three-day tourist has visited are closed to them, either by rule or by the high cost of admission. Scandalous, no doubt, from the Western democratic point of view; pathetic when we imbue our servants with our own feelings. But it never seems to have occurred to them that it is unjust—if it is. For to throw open the wall to the general public of Peking for a single week would make it an impassable stretch of filth, sleeping beggars, and jostling coolies; and in a month even what is left of its parapets would have been thrown down for the building of new hovels inside it or out.
193 There might be a long line of cheerful but usually unwashed kids, shouting their endless “Ee mao ch’ien! Ee mao ch’ien!” (“One dime money!”) every time they see us, and the daily beggar in our area, with his “Lao yea tai-tai! Lao yea tai-tai!” (“Old gentleman lady!”) wheezing in a surprisingly persuasive way, is often drowned out by his competing rivals. But once the gate of the nearest wall ramp is locked behind us by the keeper who jogs down at the sound of his little bell, we’re free from such disturbances, just like we are from the dust and discarded garbage along the hutungs. Because Chinese people aren’t allowed on the wall. That is, the general public isn’t, and those from the upper class who want to get some exercise are few, making the top of the great Tartar Wall almost a private walkway for foreigners. None of our servants, even those born in Beijing, had ever been allowed up there until they came to the bottom of our ramp with “Ha-li” as a pass. In fact, almost all those amazing monuments that even a three-day tourist can visit are closed to them, either by regulation or due to high admission costs. Scandalous, no doubt, from a Western democratic perspective; sad when we project our own feelings onto our servants. But it never seems to dawn on them that it’s unfair—if it is. Because allowing the general public of Beijing onto the wall for just one week would turn it into a filthy mess, filled with sleeping beggars and crowded coolies, and in a month, even what remains of its parapets would be torn down to build new shacks inside or outside of it.
When we came at the end of summer the top of the wall was a jungle, in places almost impassable, gay with morning-glories and other flowers, a broad hayfield even in its least fertile portions. By December hay-makers and fuel-gatherers had made it a wind-swept concourse almost fit for an automobile race, half a dozen cars abreast, except for that short piece of it between Hata-men and the gate by which the emperor once came and went, where it is in the hands of the foreign legations below. On the brilliant spring Sunday not long ago that I made the circuit of the wall this autumn’s harvest was already promised in the delicate green that was spreading along it, as it was across the great tree-topped city it encloses. That stroll of twelve or thirteen miles is almost a complete course in Chinese life and history, at least of recent centuries; but what lies outside our immediate neighborhood is another story. From that bit of the wall just above us which is our principal playground there is enough of interest within plain view, from the courtyards of our neighbors below to the distant range of the Western Hills half enclosing the plain of Peking, to make it a loafer’s paradise. The streets down below may seem mere miserable lanes to those of us from 194the West, and the dwelling-places drab and uninspiring; but inside the compounds trees are general, so that Peking from aloft is pleasantly, almost thickly, wooded. Every city, from incessantly grumbling New York to the hillside town with its church- and cow-bells, has a voice of its own, and that of Peking resembles no other I have ever heard. It is made up mainly of street-cries, from venders, rickshaw-men asking right of way, from shouting carriage out-runners, never completely blending together but still retaining a certain individuality, so that from the top of her wall Peking sounds like the tail-end of some great football game, with the victorious rooters still sporadically shouting their pæans of glee as they disperse to the four points of the compass.
When we arrived at the end of summer, the top of the wall was like a jungle, almost impossible to get through in places, filled with morning glories and other flowers, a wide hayfield even in its least fertile areas. By December, hay-makers and fuel-gatherers had transformed it into a wind-swept area almost suitable for a car race, with half a dozen cars side by side, except for the short stretch between Hata-men and the gate where the emperor used to enter and exit, which is now in the hands of the foreign legations below. On the bright spring Sunday not long ago when I walked around the wall, this autumn's harvest was already hinted at in the delicate green spreading along it, just like across the grand tree-filled city it surrounds. That walk of twelve or thirteen miles offers almost a complete overview of Chinese life and history, at least from recent centuries; but what lies beyond our immediate area is another story. From that part of the wall above us, which serves as our main playground, there is plenty of interest in plain sight, from the courtyards of our neighbors below to the distant Western Hills that partly enclose the plain of Beijing, making it a haven for loafers. The streets below may seem like miserable lanes to those of us from the West, and the homes dull and uninspiring; but inside the compounds, trees are common, so Beijing looks pleasantly, almost densely, wooded from above. Every city, from perpetually complaining New York to the hillside town with its church and cow bells, has its own unique sound, and Beijing's is unlike any I’ve ever heard. It consists mainly of street cries from vendors, rickshaw drivers asking to pass, and shouting from carriage outrunners, never fully blending together but still maintaining a certain individuality, so that from the top of the wall, Beijing sounds like the end of some massive football game, with the winning fans still sporadically cheering in joy as they disperse in all directions.
CHAPTER XII
JOGGING IN BEIJING
There are various ways of getting about Peking, even though it lacks the principal one of most large cities in other lands; but of them all I like best riding “Hwei-Hwei.” He is the robust, shaggy-red little Chinese pony I brought back from one of my trips into the interior, and if he has not yet learned to look with equanimity upon a scrap of paper or a wheedling beggar that suddenly springs up at him, at least he can pass an automobile now without filling the timid hearts of all Chinese within gunshot with speechless panic. “Hwei-Hwei” and I have jogged together all over Peking and its surroundings, nosing our way through the hutungs and prancing down the broad streets of the Chinese as well as the Tartar City, exploring every sunken road and meandering path within reasonable distance outside the walls. I am under the impression that this is improper. Though the élite among the foreign residents play polo on the French drill-field and scamper over the broken landscape about the capital on Sunday afternoon paper-chases, even canter solemnly up and down the new cinder track at the edge of the Legation Quarter, each followed at a respectful distance by the mafu who will presently walk the blanketed and almost shaven native imitations of thoroughbreds slowly up and down before some improvised stable, I gather from the glances that are thrown sharply upon us that mere sight-seeing on horseback is not in accordance with the Peking social code. I am heartbroken, naturally, at the thought of infringing that vital document; but the opportunity of indulging in a luxury I have never before dared even to consider has outweighed even that consideration.
There are many ways to get around Beijing, even though it lacks the main one that most big cities in other countries have; but of all of them, I prefer riding “Hwei-Hwei.” He’s the sturdy, shaggy-red little Chinese pony I brought back from one of my trips into the countryside, and while he hasn’t quite learned to stay calm when a piece of paper or a persistent beggar suddenly appears in front of him, at least he can now pass an automobile without causing the fearful hearts of all the Chinese nearby to fill with panic. “Hwei-Hwei” and I have trotted all over Beijing and its outskirts, weaving through the hutungs and prancing down the wide streets of both the Chinese and Tartar City, exploring every sunken road and winding path within a reasonable distance beyond the walls. I get the feeling that this behavior is frowned upon. While the elite among the foreign residents play polo on the French drill-field and race across the rugged landscape around the capital on Sunday afternoon paper chases, they can even canter solemnly back and forth on the new cinder track at the edge of the Legation Quarter, each one followed at a respectful distance by the mafu who will soon walk the blanketed and almost shorn native imitations of thoroughbreds slowly up and down in front of some makeshift stable, I gather from the sharp glances thrown our way that mere sightseeing on horseback isn’t seen as proper according to Beijing’s social norms. Naturally, I’m upset at the thought of breaking that important rule; but the chance to indulge in a luxury I’ve never even dared to think about has outweighed that concern.
The truth of the matter is that keeping a riding-horse is a luxury even in Peking. “Hwei-Hwei’s” complete care and nourishment cost just twice what one human servant does; yet the reflection that this is, after all, only “Mex” and only relative has so far been sufficient to stifle the grumblings of a troublesome conscience. I suppose, too, there is a certain subconscious complacency in looking down, even from “Hwei-Hwei’s” height, upon the throngs with which we mingle in places 196where perhaps no other foreigner, and surely no Chinese, has ever before intruded on horseback. Certainly I must confess that I find pleasure in watching the continuous succession of acrobatic feats with which Pekingese of all ages and degrees remove themselves from the immediate vicinity the instant it is borne in upon them that they are mingling with an animal that I can guarantee not to hurt an infant thrown under his very hoofs.
The reality is that owning a riding horse is a luxury, even in Beijing. Caring for “Hwei-Hwei” costs only twice as much as having a human servant; yet the thought that this is just “Mex” and only a relative concern has so far been enough to quiet my nagging conscience. I suppose there’s also a bit of subconscious satisfaction in looking down, even from “Hwei-Hwei’s” height, at the crowds we mix with in places where perhaps no other foreigner, and certainly no Chinese, has ever shown up on horseback. I have to admit, I do enjoy watching the constant stream of acrobatic tricks that Pekingese of all ages and backgrounds perform to quickly get away the moment they realize they’re mingling with an animal that I can assure won’t hurt a baby thrown right under its hooves.
Outdoor fairs, seasonal markets, temples without number, corners unknown even to our Chinese teacher, have “Hwei-Hwei” and I explored together. But there is a line beyond which his advantages over Peking’s more common means of transportation cease. Even if it is possible to park him outside those ugly buildings in which China’s Parliament flings ink-wells at itself and refuses to draft a constitution even after it has voted itself a daily bonus for attending the sessions, he can scarcely expect admittance to the Forbidden City, or ask an evening hostess to find accommodations for him. When “Hwei-Hwei” must remain at home there are various substitutes, but only one of them is really feasible. Sedan-chairs, in these modern days, are only for brides and mourners, or the emperor himself; there are jolting Peking-carts which it would be infantile yet exactly descriptive to dub “peek-out” carts; mule-litters like gaily decorated cupboards on shafts come in at least from the northeast; on the moats outside the walls there are boats in summer and sleds in winter—except when the men laying up ice in mat- and mud-covered mounds along them deprive their fellow-coolies of this simple source of income; bicycles are not unknown; curious little one-horse carriages with shutters, and an outrunner who clings on behind whenever a corner or a crowd does not bring him running ahead to lead the horse or to shout the road clear, are still the favorite equipage of old-fashioned families of means. But none of these things ply the streets for hire; if they did they would be beneath the dignity of foreigners, and probably of many Chinese unconsciously under their influence. Ordinary mortals cannot call an automobile every time they wish to go around the corner, even if their nerves are proof against the madness of Chinese chauffeurs. Promoted only yesterday from the abject position of coolies, these conceive that they always have the right of way over anything they could best in a collision—an impression in which they are abetted by the police who, with outstretched hand, gaze only at the machine, like men fascinated, as it dashes drunkenly past through the maelstrom of pedestrians and other helpless forms of traffic—and, evidently gaining “face” thereby, 197they delight to make life a constant misery to the passenger by the incessant use of those atrocious horns that seem especially to be exported to China. So it boils down to the omnipresent rickshaw.
Outdoor fairs, seasonal markets, countless temples, and hidden corners even our Chinese teacher didn't know about have been explored together by "Hwei-Hwei" and me. However, there's a limit to the advantages he has over the typical transportation options in Peking. Even if he could park outside those unattractive buildings where China’s Parliament throws ink wells at itself and refuses to draft a constitution—despite voting for daily bonuses for attending sessions—he can hardly expect to get into the Forbidden City or ask a hostess for a place to stay. When "Hwei-Hwei" has to stay home, there are various alternatives, but only one is truly practical. Sedan chairs nowadays are reserved for brides, mourners, or the emperor himself; there are jarring Peking carts that could humorously be called "peek-out" carts; mule-litters, which look like bright cupboards on shafts, are more common from the northeast; in the moats outside the walls, there are boats in summer and sleds in winter—unless the men storing ice on the mud-covered mounds deprive their fellow workers of this simple source of income. Bicycles aren't rare; there are also quirky little one-horse carriages with shutters, and a runner who hangs on behind unless a corner or crowd forces him to lead the horse or clear the path. But none of these transport options are available for hire; if they were, they would be considered beneath the dignity of foreigners and likely many Chinese influenced by them. Ordinary people can’t just call for a car every time they want to go around the corner, even if they can handle the chaos caused by Chinese drivers. Having only just been promoted from being coolies, they assume they always have the right of way in any potential collision—an assumption supported by the police, who only focus on the cars, as if mesmerized by them, while they recklessly zoom through the masses of pedestrians and other vulnerable vehicles—gaining “face” in the process. They seem to take pleasure in making life miserable for passengers by constantly using those awful horns that seem to be specially manufactured for China. So, in the end, it all comes down to the ever-present rickshaw.
We often wondered how many rickshaws there are in Peking, until at length the metropolitan police reported that they had registered 41,553 such vehicles, of which 4,788 are private. Even if this really includes all those within the gates, there are thousands more in the dozen villages clustered close outside them, whence men run to places many miles distant. We still wonder how Peking got about in the imperial days before an American missionary in Japan, wishing to give his invalid wife a daily airing, invented the rickshaw. As late as the beginning of the present century, old residents tell us, this vehicle was unknown in the capital. To-day it is the most numerous, or at least the most conspicuous, thing in Peking.
We often wondered how many rickshaws there are in Beijing, until the city police finally reported that they had registered 41,553 of these vehicles, with 4,788 being private. Even if this actually includes all those within the city walls, there are thousands more in the nearby villages where people travel to places many miles away. We still wonder how Beijing managed in the imperial days before an American missionary in Japan invented the rickshaw to give his sick wife a daily outing. As recently as the beginning of this century, long-time residents say, this vehicle was unknown in the capital. Today, it is the most numerous, or at least the most visible, thing in Beijing.
Who but a man gone mad on the matter of speed would not prefer the rickshaw to the automobile after all? Silent on its pneumatic tires and the soft-shod feet of the runner, it is the most nearly like sitting at home in an arm-chair of any form of transportation. There is no formality about it; even the man who does not keep one for his exclusive use scarcely needs to call one, for it is a strange corner of Peking where a rickshaw is not already waiting whenever he steps out. Once in a rickshaw one can leave it to the runner to arrive at the right place, and turn the mind to the streets and their doings. It is not merely “Ha-li” who is so fond of “widin’ man,” though he is the only one of us who shouts aloud at each donkey and big stone “pup dog” we pass, especially at the camels as they stride noiselessly by along the wall or through a city gate, whenever we ride hither and yon about busy yet good-natured Peking.
Who but someone obsessed with speed would choose a rickshaw over a car? Gliding on its quiet rubber tires and the soft feet of the runner, it's almost like sitting at home in a comfy chair compared to any other way of getting around. There’s no formal process; even someone who doesn’t own one doesn’t really need to book one, because it’s hard to find a spot in Peking where a rickshaw isn’t already waiting as soon as you step outside. Once you're in a rickshaw, you can trust the runner to take you where you need to go and focus on the streets and what’s happening around you. It’s not just “Ha-li” who enjoys riding; he’s just the only one of us who yells “pup dog” at every donkey and big rock we pass, especially at the camels that glide silently by along the wall or through a city gate while we navigate around busy but friendly Peking.
The police go on to say that from sixty to seventy thousand rickshaw coolies earn an average of a hundred coppers a day, of which about seventy are for themselves and their families after deducting the rent of the vehicle. That means a daily income of nearly twenty cents in real money, which is high in Peking. An official inquiry, by the way, reported during the winter that the minimum on which a Chinese adult could support life in the capital is $1.87 “Mex” a month! One particularly cold winter, foreigners, especially women, almost ceased to patronize rickshaws, not so much for their own sake as for that of the poor fellows who sat outside waiting for them, and sometimes froze to death. It devolved upon the police to call their attention to the fact that death by starvation is even more painful, and is likely to include 198the dependents also. I suppose that same omniscient body could say how many persons starve to death in Peking each winter; at any rate they once announced how many hundreds of free coffins they had been called upon to provide since cold weather set in.
The police reported that between sixty and seventy thousand rickshaw drivers make an average of a hundred coins a day, of which about seventy are left for themselves and their families after paying for the vehicle rent. That translates to a daily income of nearly twenty cents in real money, which is considered high in Beijing. By the way, an official investigation last winter stated that the minimum amount a Chinese adult needs to survive in the capital is $1.87 “Mex” a month! During one particularly harsh winter, foreigners, especially women, almost stopped using rickshaws, not just for their own comfort but out of concern for the poor guys waiting outside, some of whom froze to death. It fell to the police to remind them that dying of starvation is even more painful and likely affects dependents as well. I guess that all-knowing group could tell how many people starve to death in Beijing each winter; at any rate, they once reported how many hundreds of free coffins they had to provide since the cold weather began.
Perhaps the constant sight of starvation more or less close upon their heels is the reason that Peking rickshaw-men are such excellent runners. They never slow down to a walk, as the much better paid ones of Japan, for instance, do on the slightest provocation. If the trot from our corner to Hsi-Chi-men station, diagonally across the Tartar City, is too much for one of them he turns his fare over to an unoccupied colleague when he is exhausted rather than disgrace himself by walking. Yet I have almost never seen a well built rickshaw-man in Peking. Their ribs show plainly through their leathery skins, and they are conspicuously flat-chested, in contrast to the men all about China who carry burdens over their shoulders. The belief that rickshaw-runners die young and often is wide-spread, especially in lands that have never seen one. The only personal testimony I can offer on the subject is that during this year in the Orient I have never seen, or heard of, a man dying in the shafts, and that there are many jobs in China that I would quickly refuse in favor of drawing a rickshaw. Certainly many runners, not to mention the vehicles themselves, reach a ripe old age in Peking; and there is evidence that they do not take up the profession late in life.
Maybe the constant sight of starvation, always lurking nearby, is why Peking rickshaw drivers are such fast runners. They never slow down to a walk, unlike the better-paid ones in Japan, who do so at the slightest excuse. If the run from our corner to Hsi-Chi-men station, diagonal across the Tartar City, is too much for them, they hand off their passenger to an unoccupied colleague when they're exhausted instead of walking and risking embarrassment. However, I’ve rarely seen a well-built rickshaw driver in Peking. Their ribs are visible through their tough skin, and they have noticeably flat chests, in contrast to men across China who carry loads on their shoulders. The idea that rickshaw drivers die young and often is common, especially in places that have never seen one. The only personal experience I can share is that during my time in the Orient this year, I've never seen or heard of a man dying while pulling a rickshaw, and there are plenty of jobs in China that I would quickly turn down in favor of being a rickshaw driver. Clearly, many runners, not to mention the rickshaws themselves, live to a ripe old age in Peking; and there’s evidence that they don’t start this line of work later in life.
Some one once wrote asking us to send a copy of the child labor laws of China. When we had recovered from the resultant hysterics I went out to photograph some of the smallest specimens of rickshaw-runners along Great Hata-men Street for the benefit of the inquirer. Unfortunately a good example and photographic conditions never have coincided. I do not wish to be charged with exaggeration, and hence I will not assert that I have seen two boys of six or a single one of eight trotting about town with a big fat sample of the Chinese race lolling at his ease behind them; but I have no hesitancy in reporting that male children of eight and ten respectively may often be seen thus engaged. Perhaps these are house-servants or their offspring, or even members of the family itself, forced into service; more than once I have been sure of a facial resemblance between the perspiring youngsters and the unsoaped old lady who was urging them on. Often a small boy runs behind, pushing, who is hardly as tall as the hub of the wheel, but perhaps that is a form of apprenticeship. Recently there has been some agitation against employing rickshaw pullers under eighteen, 199though apparently only among foreigners. The Chinese of the rank and file bargain for their rides as they stump along, pretending they will walk rather than pay more than they are offering, and naturally they wish to be surrounded by as many clamoring competitors as possible. If the lowest bidder chances to be a child just heavy enough to keep the passenger from toppling over backward, or an old man who looks as if he had been unwisely rescued from the potter’s field, bu yao gin—it does not matter, for the average Chinese hardly distinguishes between real speed and a steady jogging up and down almost in the same spot.
Someone once wrote asking us to send a copy of the child labor laws in China. After we got over our shock, I went out to take photos of some of the youngest rickshaw runners along Great Hata-men Street for the person who inquired. Unfortunately, a good example and the right photographic conditions never seem to coincide. I don’t want to be accused of exaggerating, so I won’t say I’ve seen two six-year-old boys or even one eight-year-old trotting around town with a hefty specimen of the Chinese race lounging behind them; however, I can confidently report that I often see boys of eight and ten engaged in this work. They might be house servants, their children, or even family members forced into labor; more than once, I have noticed a resemblance between the sweaty kids and the unwashed old lady urging them on. Often, a small boy runs behind, pushing a rickshaw, and he’s barely as tall as the wheel hub, but maybe that’s just part of the learning process. Recently, there’s been some push against employing rickshaw pullers under eighteen, though it seems mostly among foreigners. Regular Chinese people haggle for their rides while walking along, acting like they’d prefer to walk rather than pay more than what they're offering, and naturally, they want to be surrounded by as many shouting competitors as possible. If the lowest bidder happens to be a child just heavy enough to keep the passenger from falling backward, or an old man who looks like he was pulled out of a grave, bu yao gin—it doesn’t matter, because the average Chinese person hardly distinguishes between real speed and a steady jog on the same spot.
In contrast to these sorry dregs of the profession are the haughty men in the prime of life who run on a monthly wage for foreigners, or for Chinese of wealth and official position, some of them in livery and with clanging bells and blazing lamps that attest their importance. The tall youth who runs with a physically light-weight young lady of our acquaintance always calls a rickshaw when he wishes to go out on a personal errand. Well fed and not overworked, these private human trotters are often marvels of speed and endurance. I would like nothing better than to enter our wrinkled old la-che-ti in an Olympic marathon—though foreigners who have tried that sort of test find that the men cannot run without their vehicle, which is so balanced as to help lift them off the ground. Like the runners, the rickshaws of Peking range all the way from filthy half-wrecks to rickshaw-limousines. The former are due both to the Chinese blindness to uncleanliness and to the fact that, human fares lacking, they are ready to accept any form of freight, be it even the bleeding carcass of a hog. The vehicle looking tolerable, however, most of us pick our rickshaw-men exactly as we would a horse, except that age is fairly apparent without examining the teeth.
In contrast to these unfortunate leftovers of the profession are the arrogant men in their prime, who work for a monthly wage from foreigners or wealthy Chinese officials. Some of them wear uniforms and have clanging bells and bright lamps that signal their importance. The tall young man who often goes out with a physically petite young lady we know always calls a rickshaw when he needs to run a personal errand. Well-fed and not overworked, these private human runners are often impressive in their speed and endurance. I would love nothing more than to enter our wrinkled old la-che-ti in an Olympic marathon—though foreigners who have attempted that kind of challenge find that the men can't run without their vehicle, which is designed to help lift them off the ground. Like the runners, the rickshaws in Beijing vary from filthy half-destroyed ones to rickshaw limousines. The dirty ones are a result of the Chinese indifference to cleanliness and the fact that, with no human fares, they will accept any form of cargo, even the bleeding carcass of a pig. As long as the vehicle looks decent, most of us choose our rickshaw pullers just like we would select a horse, except that age is pretty obvious without checking their teeth.
Slavery is a dreadful institution, but if millions of the human draft-animals of China were slaves they would at least be sure of a place to sleep and something fit to eat. Yet they are a cheerful, good-hearted, likable lot of fellows, these swarming rickshaw-runners of Peking, amusing in their primitive ways. However much they may arouse sympathy, for instance, there is no surer means of being involved in a noisy dispute than by overpaying them. Find out the legal fare and pay it, and the chances are that your runner will accept it without a word and rate you a person of experience and understanding, for all your strange race. The louder and longer you wish him to dance and shout about you, the more you should overpay him. A soft-hearted old lady arriving in Peking almost directly from America and wishing to 200be just toward the man who drew her from Ch’ien-men Station to the principal hotel handed him a silver dollar. It took three men from the hotel to rescue her from the frenzied runner and kick him dollarless outside the grounds.
Slavery is a horrible institution, but if millions of the human laborers in China were slaves, they would at least have a guaranteed place to sleep and decent food to eat. Despite their situation, the rickshaw-pullers in Peking are a cheerful, kind-hearted, and likable bunch, entertaining in their simple ways. However, one sure way to get into a loud argument is by overpaying them. If you figure out the legal fare and pay it, your rickshaw runner will likely accept it without a complaint and think of you as someone experienced and understanding, despite your unfamiliar background. The more you want him to celebrate you loudly, the more you should overpay him. A kind-hearted old lady who arrived in Peking directly from America and wanted to be fair to the man who brought her from Ch’ien-men Station to the main hotel gave him a silver dollar. It took three men from the hotel to save her from the frantic runner and send him away while keeping her dollar.
The fact is that rickshaws are too numerous in Peking and their fares too low. Even foreign residents grow flabby from so habitually jumping into one rather than walking a block or two, though I confess it is easier to do so than to endure the endless gauntlet of persistent shouting, and even subtle ridicule in the case of “foreign devils” supposedly ignorant of the language, which every well dressed pedestrian must run. Hard-hearted men assert that the oversupply is due to the laziness of the runners also, that coolies would rather wander about with a rickshaw than work all day at some steady labor. What will become of them when the street-cars arrive, for which the French were long ago granted a much-opposed franchise, is a question which men of higher intelligence than the runners themselves cannot answer. Yet they are coming; cement poles are already creeping into the Tartar City from the northwest, and rails are being piled up before the Forbidden City; unless Mukden outstrips her, Peking will be the first to follow foreign-influenced Tientsin and Shanghai by desecrating her streets with the ugliness and clamor of electric tramways. We are glad to have known the inimitable Chinese capital before they came.
The truth is that rickshaws are way too common in Beijing and their fares are too cheap. Even foreign residents become lazy from constantly hopping into one instead of walking a block or two, though I have to admit it’s easier to do that than face the endless barrage of persistent shouting and even subtle mockery aimed at “foreigners” who supposedly don’t know the language, which every well-dressed pedestrian has to endure. Some cold-hearted people say the oversupply is due to the laziness of the rickshaw pullers too, claiming that laborers would rather stroll around with a rickshaw than work all day at a steady job. What will happen to them when the streetcars come—since the French were long ago given a heavily opposed franchise for that—is a question that even those more knowledgeable than the rickshaw pullers themselves can’t answer. But they are on their way; cement poles are already appearing in the northwest part of the old city, and rails are being stacked up in front of the Forbidden City. Unless Mukden gets ahead of her, Beijing will be the first to follow foreign-influenced Tianjin and Shanghai in ruining her streets with the ugliness and noise of electric trams. We are fortunate to have experienced the unique Chinese capital before they arrived.
The slowness of her man-drawn carriages and the dead flatness of Peking give an exaggerated impression of its size; everything seems farther away than it really is. In my school-days we used to hear wild tales about this being the largest city in the world. Perhaps it has a million inhabitants, though eight hundred and fifty thousand seems nearer the mark. There is no “squeeze” to be had out of a census, however, and guesses will probably continue to be the only available information on that point for years to come. A one-story city with the courtyard habit, to say nothing of enormous palaces and monuments that scarcely shelter a human being each, and of big vacant spaces even inside its principal wall, can hardly vie with New York and London, however like rats many of its people may live. In what we foreigners call the Chinese City there is a maze of shops and dwellings outside the three south gates of the capital proper, human warrens here and there, swarming sidewalk markets by night as well as crowded rows of booths by day; but vast graveyards, cultivated fields, even great unoccupied areas take up much of this secondary enclosure, not to mention 201the huge domains of the Temples of Heaven and of Agriculture, playgrounds now of those with the price of admission, with tea and soda-water and pumpkin seeds served almost on the very spot where the Son of Heaven so long held his annual vigil.
The slow pace of her horse-drawn carriages and the flatness of Beijing make the city seem larger than it really is; everything feels farther away than it actually is. Back in school, we heard wild stories about it being the biggest city in the world. It might have a million residents, but eight hundred and fifty thousand is probably closer to reality. There's no reliable census, so estimates will likely remain the only information available for years. It's a one-story city with a lot of courtyards, not to mention huge palaces and monuments that barely accommodate any people, along with large empty spaces even within its main walls, making it hard to compare to New York and London, no matter how densely populated it is. In what we foreigners refer to as the Chinese City, there's a maze of shops and homes outside the three southern gates of the capital, with crowded markets at night and busy booths during the day. However, vast graveyards, farmland, and large empty areas take up a lot of space in this secondary area, not to mention the large grounds of the Temples of Heaven and Agriculture, which are now playgrounds for those who can pay, with tea, soda, and pumpkin seeds served right where the Son of Heaven once held his yearly vigil. 201
Distressing are many of the noble monuments that make Peking justly famed the world over, not merely because of the ruins they are becoming under an anarchistic republican régime, but by reason of the rabble that is permitted to overrun and defile so many of them. Ragged beggars masquerading as caretakers beset the visitor in almost all of them; foreigners, or Chinese with money but without influence, may still be required to pay their way into Pei-Hai and the Summer Palace, but once inside they find themselves jostled and gaped upon by loafing soldiers and ill-mannered roustabouts whom the gate-keepers have not the power or the moral courage to exclude. How long before imperial Peking will be but another Baalbek or Nineveh, for all the busy streets that surround it, is another subject for guessing.
Many of the impressive monuments that make Beijing famous around the world are in distress, not just because of the decay they’re experiencing under a chaotic republican government, but also due to the unruly crowds that are allowed to invade and disrespect so many of them. Ragged beggars pretending to be caretakers swarm around visitors at almost all these sites; foreigners, or wealthy Chinese without influence, may still have to pay to enter Beihai and the Summer Palace, but once inside, they find themselves pushed and stared at by loafing soldiers and rude locals whom the gatekeepers lack the authority or moral courage to keep out. How long until imperial Beijing becomes just another Baalbek or Nineveh, despite all the busy streets surrounding it, is another question altogether.
We found few soldiers in Peking, however, compared with such places as Mukden, and those are still curbed in a way that would bring gasps of astonishment from their fellows in the provinces. Before the Boxer days Peking had no police force in the Western sense; to-day the little stations are as numerous as in Japan, while the white-legginged gendarmes under a Norwegian general stroll the principal streets in pairs, with drawn bayonets and an eye especially to the protection of foreigners. We have tried in vain to impress upon our friends at home that Peking is safer than any city we know of in our own land. A lone woman not even speaking the language, and bespangled with jewels if you like, can go anywhere in Peking, whether on foot or with a rickshaw coolie picked up at random, at any hour of the day or night, without the ghost of a chance of being molested, to say nothing of running any real danger. They are a curious people, the Chinese. They will often starve with riches within easy grasp rather than screw up their courage to an act of violence, as they will display the cheerfulness of contentment far beyond the point where Westerners would have even a transparent mask of it left. There is something uncanny, if we ever paused to think of it, in being so well protected by a police force whose meager wages are many months in arrears; and the petty graft they inflict upon foreign residents may almost be justified. Their task is greatly lightened, of course, by the pacifist temperament of the Chinese; but criminal, even violent, characters cannot be lacking even in Peking. Punishments are still drastic, after the Chinese custom. Out toward 202Tungchow and over beside the outer wall of the Temple of Heaven groups of men are frequently shot, and they are by no means all assassins. When the invasion from beyond the Great Wall was being repelled last spring and bullets were singing across our corner of the city, the police were instructed to punish with summary execution anything suggestive of looting. A Chinese of some standing, friendly with several foreigners of our acquaintance, went up broad Hata-men Street to borrow a few dollars from an exchange-shop that had often favored him with small loans. The proprietor happened to be out, and the youth in charge did not know the client. “Oh, that’s all right,” the borrower assured him; “your master always lets me have small sums when I need them, and I am in a hurry.” He picked up a few dollars, jotted the amount down on a slip of paper, and started away. The youth shouted, the police came running up, and although the proprietor appeared at that moment and identified the prisoner as an old friend who had acted in no way improperly, a headless corpse was left lying in the dust before the shop.
We found only a few soldiers in Beijing compared to places like Shenyang, and they're still restricted in a way that would shock their counterparts in the provinces. Before the Boxer Rebellion, Beijing didn’t have a police force in the Western sense; today, the small stations are as common as in Japan, while the gendarmes in white leggings, led by a Norwegian general, patrol the main streets in pairs, with drawn bayonets and a focus on protecting foreigners. We've tried in vain to convince our friends back home that Beijing is safer than any city we know of in our own country. A woman traveling alone, even without speaking the language and dressed in jewels if she wants, can go anywhere in Beijing, whether on foot or with a rickshaw driver she randomly chooses, at any hour of the day or night, without the slightest chance of being harassed, let alone facing any real danger. The Chinese are a peculiar people. They often choose to starve with wealth easily accessible rather than muster the courage for any act of violence, and they display a level of contentment far beyond what Westerners would ever show, even with a thin façade. It’s a bit eerie, if we stop to think about it, that we feel so safe under a police force whose meager salaries are often months overdue; the petty corruption they impose on foreign residents might even be seen as understandable. Their job is certainly made easier by the pacifist nature of the Chinese people; yet, there are still criminal and violent individuals in Beijing. Punishments remain harsh by Chinese standards. Out toward Tongzhou and near the outer wall of the Temple of Heaven, groups of men are frequently executed, and not all of them are assassins. Last spring, when the invasion from beyond the Great Wall was being fought off and bullets were flying through our part of the city, the police were ordered to impose summary executions for any acts resembling looting. A Chinese man of some standing, who was friendly with several foreigners we knew, went up broad Hata-men Street to borrow a few dollars from an exchange-shop that had often lent him small amounts. The owner happened to be out, and the young man in charge didn’t recognize the client. “Oh, that’s fine,” the borrower said; “your boss always gives me small loans when I need them, and I’m in a hurry.” He took a few dollars, wrote down the amount on a slip of paper, and started to leave. The young man shouted, the police rushed over, and even though the owner appeared at that moment and confirmed the borrower was an old friend who had done nothing wrong, a headless corpse was left lying in the dust outside the shop.
There are incredible contrasts, too, among the scenes past which the pony and I jog on our afternoon jaunts. Legation guards of half a dozen nationalities play their boyish games almost across the street from rag-pickers who are scarcely distinguishable from the garbage-heaps out of which they somehow claw a livelihood. Along “Piccadilly,” as foreigners call what is “Square Handkerchief Alley” to the Chinese, we can easily imagine ourselves in the days of Kublai Khan; and around the corner from it the Wai-chiao-pu is a more modern foreign office, outwardly at least, than London, Washington, or Paris can muster. Beneath the “Four P’ai-lous” motor-cars speed north and south while barbaric funeral processions crawl under them from the west between two long rows of squealing pigs, resenting the cords that bind their four legs together and the discourtesy with which they are tumbled about by sellers and purchasers. City gates like mammoth office buildings tower above long vistas of lowly human dwellings; lotuses bloom on the lake of the Winter Palace, and the visitor thither is pursued by all but naked mendicants—yao-fan-ti (want-rice-ers) the Chinese call them in their kinder language. Sumptuous private cars stand before most modern buildings, and Peking street-sprinklers, consisting of two men and a bucket, with a long-handled wooden dipper, attempt to lay the dust about them. We remember these sprinklers only too well, “Hwei-Hwei” and I, for during the winter the sprinkling turned to ice almost as it fell, and our progress was a kind of equestrian fox-trot. But for them, 203and the water-carriers whose screeching wheelbarrows drip so incessantly, Peking streets would be easy going the year round, for the whole winter’s snow has been but a napkin or two that faded away almost as it fell. Nor have I ever known a genuine Peking dust-storm, though I have seen the air and the heavens, the inmost recesses of my garments and my food, even the contents of locked trunks, filled with those flying particles of her own filth and her surrounding semi-desert which the capital of Kublai Khan has always charged against the distant Gobi. Old residents tell us that this season’s dust-storms have been unusually rare, but my family was vouchsafed one of the first magnitude during my absence. A welcome wind blew all one hot spring night, and only in the morning was it discovered that it had carried volumes of dust with it, so that the sleepers looked as if they had been traveling across Nevada for a week without so much as a wet cloth available, and everything from hair to mattress-covers had to be washed at once, which was particularly difficult with the blowing dust obscuring the sun for several days to come.
There are incredible contrasts among the scenes the pony and I pass by during our afternoon rides. Legation guards from half a dozen countries play their youthful games almost right across the street from rag-pickers who hardly look different from the garbage heaps they scrape a living from. Along “Piccadilly,” as foreigners call what the Chinese refer to as “Square Handkerchief Alley,” we can easily imagine ourselves back in the time of Kublai Khan; yet just around the corner is the Wai-chiao-pu, a more modern foreign office than what London, Washington, or Paris can showcase. Under the “Four P’ai-lous,” cars zoom north and south while funeral processions moving from the west crawl beneath them, flanked by long rows of squealing pigs resentful of the cords tying their legs together and the rough handling from sellers and buyers. City gates like massive office buildings rise above vistas of humble dwellings; lotuses bloom on the lake of the Winter Palace, while the visitors there are pursued by nearly naked beggars—yao-fan-ti (want-rice-ers), as the Chinese kindly call them. Luxurious private cars line up in front of most modern buildings, and the Peking street-sprinklers, which consist of two men and a bucket with a long-handled wooden dipper, try to settle the dust around them. “Hwei-Hwei” and I remember these sprinklers all too well because during the winter, the sprinkling turned to ice almost as soon as it fell, turning our ride into a kind of equestrian fox-trot. Without them, 203 and the water-carriers with their screeching wheelbarrows that drip nonstop, Peking streets would be much easier to navigate year-round, as the winter snow has barely amounted to a napkin or two that faded away almost immediately. I have never actually experienced a real dust storm in Peking, although I've seen the air and sky, the deepest parts of my clothes, and even my food, along with the contents of locked trunks, filled with flying particles of its own grime and the surrounding semi-desert that Kublai Khan’s capital has always claimed from the distant Gobi. Long-time residents say this season’s dust storms have been unusually rare, but my family experienced one of major proportions while I was away. A welcome wind blew all one hot spring night, and by morning we discovered it had carried in massive amounts of dust, leaving us looking like we had just crossed Nevada for a week without a single wet cloth in sight, making it necessary to wash everything from hair to mattress covers immediately, which was especially tricky since the blowing dust obscured sunlight for several days afterward.
Often our way through a city gate or along a narrow street is made disagreeable by passing wheelbarrows filled to over-slopping with the night-soil of the city—sewers being as great a luxury as running water in most Peking households. This is dried along the outside of the city walls and distributed among the vegetable-gardens which, protected from the north by rows of tall reed wind-breaks, take up much of the land immediately outside the city. It goes without saying that the use of chloride of lime is as fixed a habit in the kitchens of foreign residents as boiling our drinking-water. The Chinese cannot understand why Westerners persist in wasting the richest substitute for potash, spending money to have it destroyed instead of gaining money by selling it. Sometimes the foreigners are converted to the Chinese point of view; I know at least one American mission school which supports two of its girls on what it contributes to the fertility of the neighboring fields.
Often, when we pass through a city gate or stroll down a narrow street, we face unpleasantness from wheelbarrows overflowing with the city’s waste—sewers are as much of a luxury as running water for most households in Beijing. This waste gets dried outside the city walls and spread over the vegetable gardens that, sheltered from the north by tall reed barriers, occupy much of the land just outside the city. It’s a given that using chloride of lime is as common in the kitchens of foreign residents as boiling drinking water. The Chinese can’t understand why Westerners continue to waste such a valuable source of potash, spending money to dispose of it rather than making money by selling it. Sometimes, foreigners adopt the Chinese perspective; I know of at least one American mission school that funds two of its girls with the profits from the fertility of the nearby fields.
But it is not difficult to forget all such drawbacks when one looks down upon Peking from her mammoth wall or the lonely eminence called Coal Hill. Obviously “Hwei-Hwei” cannot climb Mei-shan; it is bad enough to have outside barbarians of the human kind looking down upon the golden-yellow roofs of the Forbidden City. This is not especially forbidden now, with more than half of it open to the ticket-buyer, and the rest hardly free from intruding politicians and their protégés. But there still hovers an atmosphere of mystery, of something 204mildly akin to the Arabian Nights or the Middle Ages, about the northern end of the enclosure, within the moat in which coolies gather submerged hay and set up fish-traps, and above which tourists shriek their delights from Peking’s lone hill, even from airplanes. For, sadly shrunken as it is, the imperial Manchu dynasty still holds forth within.
But it's easy to forget all those drawbacks when you look down on Beijing from its massive wall or the lonely peak called Coal Hill. Clearly, "Hwei-Hwei" can't climb Mei-shan; it's bad enough having foreign invaders looking down on the golden-yellow roofs of the Forbidden City. This isn't particularly off-limits anymore, with over half of it open to ticket holders, and the rest hardly free from meddling politicians and their followers. Yet, there still lingers an air of mystery, something somewhat reminiscent of the Arabian Nights or the Middle Ages, around the northern end of the enclosure, within the moat where laborers collect submerged hay and set up fish traps, above which tourists scream their excitement from Beijing's lone hill, even from planes. Sadly diminished as it is, the imperial Manchu dynasty still has a presence inside.
China is, I believe, the only republic on earth with an emperor. It was stipulated in the agreement of 1912 between the imperial court and the republican party that the emperor should keep his title, his imperial abode, and certain other privileges, should receive a large annual allowance from the Government for the upkeep of his court and household, and should “always be treated by the Republican Government with the courtesy and respect which would be accorded to a foreign sovereign on Chinese soil.” Thus the young man who, as a child, abdicated the dragon throne can still go and sit on it any afternoon that it pleases his fancy to do so. Perhaps no such caprices come into his head, for if we are to believe his English tutor he is wise, as well as regally polished, beyond his years, and does not really consider himself emperor. He has lived in the imperial palace of the Forbidden City ever since he was actually Manchu sovereign of China, however, and is still accorded imperial honors there. Any one who rises early enough may meet Manchu courtiers in ceremonial dress, a trifle shabby, their red-tassel-covered hats still not entirely out of place in modern Peking, jogging homeward on their lean ponies from an imperial audience at the unearthly hour at which these have been held in China for centuries.
China is, I think, the only republic in the world with an emperor. The 1912 agreement between the imperial court and the republican party stated that the emperor would keep his title, his imperial residence, and certain other privileges. He would receive a substantial annual allowance from the government to support his court and household, and he would always be treated by the Republican Government with the same courtesy and respect given to a foreign sovereign on Chinese soil. So, the young man who, as a child, stepped down from the dragon throne can still go sit on it whenever he wants. Maybe he doesn't have these whims, though, because if we trust his English tutor, he is wise and elegantly polished beyond his years and doesn’t really see himself as emperor. He has lived in the imperial palace in the Forbidden City since he was the Manchu ruler of China, and he is still given imperial honors there. Anyone who gets up early enough might encounter Manchu courtiers in ceremonial dress, slightly shabby, their red-tassel hats still somewhat fitting in modern Beijing, riding home on their lean ponies after an imperial audience held at the early hour that has been customary in China for centuries.
Most Chinese have several different names, and emperors are no exception to this rule. There is a “milk name” during infancy, a hao, or familiar name by which one is afterward known to one’s intimates, a school name, a business name, finally, but not lastly, in the case of an emperor, a throne name or dynastic title. But though the present occupant of the Forbidden City has such a name, to wit: Hsuan T’ung, even this cannot be freely used; you cannot call a man to the billiard-table by his dynastic title. The names by which we know former emperors of China are really their “reign titles” and not personal patronymics. This left the present head of the Ch’ing dynasty handicapped, for, not being a real sovereign in spite of his legally imperial title, and unable to have a reign title at least until he is dead, there was no name by which he could be properly and generally called, whether to dinner or to an audience. Being a sensible young man, of modern rather than reactionary tendencies and by no means hostile to foreign influence, noting moreover that not only do foreigners who remain 205long in China have a Chinese name but that Western sovereigns have personal appellations, he decided to take a foreign name. The fact that his foreign tutor is an Englishman may or may not account for the fact that he has chosen to be called “Henry.”
Most Chinese people have several different names, and emperors are no exception. There's a "milk name" used in infancy, a hao or familiar name that friends use, a school name, a business name, and finally, for emperors, a throne name or dynastic title. However, even the current ruler of the Forbidden City has a name, specifically Hsuan T’ung, but this name can't be used freely; you can't invite someone to a billiard game using their dynastic title. The names we recognize former Chinese emperors by are actually their "reign titles" rather than personal names. This situation puts the current head of the Ch’ing dynasty at a disadvantage, as he isn’t a true sovereign despite his official imperial title, and he's unable to have a reign title until he passes away, leaving him without a proper name for everyday use, whether for dinner or an audience. Being a sensible young man with modern ideas and not opposed to foreign influence, and also noticing that foreigners who stay in China have Chinese names while Western monarchs have personal names, he decided to adopt a foreign name. The fact that his foreign tutor is English might explain why he chose to be called "Henry."
Those who have seen him describe “Emperor Henry” as a tall, slender young man who is still growing, with the Chinese calligraphy of an artist and some of the poetic gifts of his imperial ancestor known as Ch’ien Lung. Not merely does he wield a wicked brush in both the classic and the modern colloquial Chinese, now and then having a poem published under an assumed name in a Peking paper, but he writes a very legible English with pen or pencil. His English speech is described as slow but correct, with a strong British accent. He reads newspapers voraciously and is said to be unusually well abreast of the times, both at home and abroad, for his years. His greatest single blow to date against tyrannical conservatism, however, and the mightiest example of his progressive tendencies occurred last spring at one fell swoop—he had his cue cut off. The three imperial dowagers and his two distinguished old Chinese or Manchu tutors tore what was left of their own hair in vain. “Henry” was determined to be up-to-date even if he is confined in one end of the once Forbidden City. The result is that for the first time in nearly three hundred years there is hardly a pigtail left within the Purple Wall, though the two old tutors, as a silent protest against what they consider an act of disloyalty to the traditions of “his Majesty’s” house, still wear their cues.
Those who have seen him describe “Emperor Henry” as a tall, slender young man who is still growing, with the elegant calligraphy of an artist and some of the poetic talent of his imperial ancestor, Ch’ien Lung. He not only skillfully uses a brush in both classical and modern colloquial Chinese, often publishing poems under a pseudonym in a Peking paper, but he also writes very clear English with pen or pencil. His English speech is characterized as slow but correct, with a strong British accent. He reads newspapers eagerly and is said to be impressively knowledgeable about current events, both locally and internationally, for his age. His most significant act against oppressive conservatism, and the strongest demonstration of his progressive attitude, happened last spring when he had his cue cut off. The three imperial dowagers and his two esteemed old Chinese or Manchu tutors could only tear at what remained of their own hair in vain. “Henry” was determined to be modern, even while confined to one end of the formerly Forbidden City. As a result, for the first time in nearly three hundred years, almost no pigtails remain within the Purple Wall, although the two old tutors continue to wear their cues as a silent protest against what they see as an act of disloyalty to the traditions of “his Majesty’s” house.
During last winter “Henry” turned sixteen, and it was high time he took unto himself a wife—two of them, in fact. He is reputed not to have wanted two—possibly he is not so ultra-modern as we have been led to suppose—but his retinue insisted. Number one wife would have too many duties to be able to perform them all alone; besides, what would the neighbors say? So they chose him two pretty Manchu girls several months his junior and set the date for the wedding. But “Henry” has a mind of his own, and if he could not go out and pick a bride on his own initiative he could at least exercise the sovereign rights of any citizen of a republic and choose between the two candidates allowed him. Thus it came about that the girl named by the high Manchu officials to be “empress” became merely the first concubine, and vice versa. Some time during the seven weeks of ceremonies between the betrothal rites and the actual marriage “Henry” conferred upon the lady of his choice the name of “Elizabeth.”
Last winter, “Henry” turned sixteen, and it was about time he got himself a wife—actually, two of them. People say he didn't really want two—maybe he isn't as ultra-modern as we thought—but his entourage insisted. The first wife was going to have too many responsibilities to manage on her own; plus, what would the neighbors think? So they picked two pretty Manchu girls, who were a few months younger than him, and set the wedding date. But “Henry” had his own ideas, and even if he couldn't pick a bride on his own, he could at least exercise the rights of any citizen in a republic and choose between the two options given to him. This is how the girl named by the high Manchu officials to be “empress” ended up as the first concubine, and the other girl took her place. At some point during the seven weeks of ceremonies between the engagement and the actual wedding, “Henry” gave the lady he chose the name “Elizabeth.”
The wedding itself took place between the end of November and 206the dawn of December, according to our Western calendar. By republican permission the streets between the lady’s home, out near the Anting-men, and the East Gate of the Forbidden City were covered from curb to curb with “golden sands”—which in Peking means merely the earth we use in a child’s sand-box. At three in the morning the principal bride set out along this in a chair covered with imperial yellow brocade and carried by sixteen bearers, with a body-guard of eunuchs from the palace. The procession was no longer and hardly more elaborate than those that may be seen along Peking streets on any day auspicious for weddings; some of the impoverished Manchu and Mongol nobles, members of the imperial clan, and former officials of the old empire looked, in fact, a trifle more shabby under the specially erected bright lights along the route than do the wedding guests of a wealthy Chinese merchant. But there were some unusual features. The sedan-chair had a golden roof, on each corner of which was a phenix, a design that predominated in all the flags, banners, and mammoth “umbrellas” carried by the hired attendants. Instead of the familiar Chinese wedding “music” produced by long, harsh-voiced trumpets, there were two foreign-style bands, one of them lent by the President of the republic. These played over and over, not in concord one with the other, “Marching through Georgia,” “Suwanee River,” and “When Johnny Comes Marching Home.” It was a memorable night for Peking.
The wedding took place between the end of November and the early hours of December, according to our Western calendar. With the government's approval, the streets between the bride’s home, near Anting-men, and the East Gate of the Forbidden City were covered edge to edge with “golden sands”—which in Beijing means just the dirt we use in a child’s sandbox. At three in the morning, the main bride set off in a chair covered with imperial yellow brocade, carried by sixteen bearers, with a bodyguard of eunuchs from the palace. The procession was about the same length and hardly more elaborate than those seen on any auspicious wedding day in Beijing; some of the impoverished Manchu and Mongol nobles, members of the imperial family, and former officials from the old empire actually looked a bit more ragged under the specially placed bright lights along the route than wedding guests of a wealthy Chinese merchant. But there were some unique features. The sedan chair had a golden roof, with a phoenix on each corner—a design that appeared on all the flags, banners, and giant “umbrellas” held by the hired attendants. Instead of the typical Chinese wedding “music” played with long, harsh trumpets, there were two foreign-style bands, one of which was provided by the President of the republic. They repeatedly played, not in harmony with each other, “Marching through Georgia,” “Suwanee River,” and “When Johnny Comes Marching Home.” It was a night to remember for Beijing.
The chief escorts sent by the emperor to receive his favorite bride rode horses and wore mandarin costume, including the official cap with a peacock plume and buttons of every former rank. Promptly at four in the morning the Phenix Chair, followed by a series of yellow-covered litters containing the ceremonial robes of its occupant, passed through the Gate of Propitious Destiny into the central and most sacred portion of the imperial precincts. Foreign as well as Chinese guests had been admitted as far as the large open space before this, which is used as a parade-ground for the imperial guard and as a place of reception for the camel caravans which still, even in these republican days, bring “tribute” from beyond the Great Wall to the Manchu emperor. With the moon just dropping out of sight in the west the scene was of a pageantry which has almost disappeared from our modern commonplace world.
The main escorts sent by the emperor to welcome his favorite bride rode horses and wore official outfits, including the official cap with a peacock feather and buttons representing different ranks. Exactly at four in the morning, the Phenix Chair, followed by several yellow-covered litters carrying the ceremonial robes of its occupant, passed through the Gate of Propitious Destiny into the central and most sacred part of the imperial grounds. Guests from both foreign countries and China had been allowed to gather in the large open area before this, which serves as a parade ground for the imperial guard and a reception area for the camel caravans that still, even in these republican times, bring "tribute" from beyond the Great Wall to the Manchu emperor. With the moon just disappearing in the west, the scene resembled a spectacle that has nearly faded from our modern everyday world.
What took place beyond the gate that swallowed up the “empress” ordinary people know only by hearsay. This has it that the bride, having been carried over fire—pans filled with glowing coals—as old 207Chinese custom decrees, was set down at the foot of the throne and greeted by the emperor and his first concubine, after which he and all those of the male gender except the eunuchs immediately retired. The concubine had merely walked in without ceremony twenty-four hours before, one of her first duties being to welcome the real bride at her arrival. Gossip has it that she did not make the requisite number of kowtows to her more fortunate rival and that “Elizabeth” took this so to heart that she shut herself up from the emperor for some time. No sane person will vouch for the truth of Peking rumors, however, imperial or otherwise. The fact remains that “Henry” and “Elizabeth” were duly married, the clinching rite being the ceremonial drinking together of the nuptial cup, and the latest report is that they are all three living moderately happily, at least, this long afterward.
What happened beyond the gate that engulfed the “empress” is something ordinary people only know through rumors. The story goes that the bride, having been carried over fire—pans filled with glowing coals—as the old Chinese tradition requires, was placed at the foot of the throne and welcomed by the emperor and his first concubine, after which he and all the men excluding the eunuchs immediately left. The concubine had simply walked in without any formalities twenty-four hours earlier; one of her first tasks was to greet the real bride upon her arrival. Rumor has it that she didn't bow enough times to her more fortunate rival and that “Elizabeth” was so upset by this that she isolated herself from the emperor for a while. However, no sane person will claim to know the truth of the gossip from Peking, whether imperial or otherwise. The fact remains that “Henry” and “Elizabeth” were officially married, with the ceremony culminating in the ritual drinking of the wedding cup, and the latest news is that all three of them are living somewhat happily, at least, even now.
An American girl is tutoring the “empress” in English and Western ways, as she did before her marriage, and the emperor continues to grow, mentally if not physically, under his cued and uncued tutelage. Even the first concubine is said to be fond of learning, and the two no doubt comment on their similarity of tastes with “our” husband. There is probably less friction between the two young ladies than their Western sisters may fancy, now that relative grades are inevitably fixed—with reservations depending on the birth of a son; the most powerful woman in Chinese history, the dowager who long ruled the country under the puppets Tung Chih and Kuang Hsii, was, it is well for the two young ladies to remember, only a concubine. Court etiquette prevents conflicts in their demands upon the husband. By a rule said to be centuries old the emperor is entitled to the company of his empress six times a month, of the first concubine ten, and of the second concubine fifteen, in reverse ratio, of course, to the social demands upon them. “Henry” should by the rules of the game have chosen his second concubine before this, but like all those to whom the Chinese owe money he has not been paid his allowance for years, and there may be excellent reason for putting off this addition to his cozy little household. It is what school-girls call “thrilling” to think of him toasting his toes alternately with his two brides, perhaps of dissimilar temperaments as well as mental and physical charms, and still having every other evening left free for the pursuit of his studies.
An American girl is teaching the “empress” English and Western customs, just like she did before her marriage, while the emperor continues to develop, mentally if not physically, under both guided and unstructured instruction. Even the first concubine is said to enjoy learning, and the two likely chat about their shared interests related to “our” husband. There’s probably less tension between the two young women than their Western counterparts might think, now that their ranks are set — with exceptions made for the birth of a son; it’s worth noting for the two of them that the most powerful woman in Chinese history, the dowager who ruled the country for a long time through the emperors Tung Chih and Kuang Hsii, was only a concubine. Court etiquette prevents any conflicts over their demands of the husband. According to a rule that's been around for centuries, the emperor is supposed to spend time with his empress six times a month, with the first concubine ten times, and the second concubine fifteen times, in that order, depending on their social obligations. “Henry” should have picked his second concubine by now according to the rules, but like all those to whom the Chinese owe money, he hasn’t received his allowance for years, and there might be good reasons to delay adding to his comfortable little household. It’s what schoolgirls would call “exciting” to imagine him warming his feet alternately with his two brides, who might have very different personalities as well as mental and physical charms, and still having every other evening free to focus on his studies.
Misfortune, of course, does not spare even throneless sovereigns. Fire has just destroyed much of that portion of the Forbidden City which the head of the abdicated Manchu dynasty had left him, and has 208given a hint of life within those mysterious precincts. Though the conflagration broke out before midnight nothing worth while was done to curb it until two in the morning. Most of the courtiers have always lived within the Purple Wall and had never seen a disaster of such magnitude, so that when they saw the palace buildings in flames the whole court, including “Henry” and “Elizabeth,” some stories have it, were seized with nothing more effective than frenzied excitement. Partly for fear of looting, partly because no orders were given by their superior officers to break an ancient rule, the guards refused to open the gates to the two Chinese and one foreign fire brigades that offered their assistance. After a lengthy conference these were admitted, but by this time the fire was so far advanced that only by cutting down many old trees and leveling some of the smaller buildings was it finally brought under control at seven in the morning. Even the Chinese admit that almost all the effective work was done by the foreigners; whatever their excellencies the Celestials do not shine during emergencies.
Misfortune, of course, doesn't spare even those without a throne. A fire has just destroyed much of the part of the Forbidden City that the head of the abdicated Manchu dynasty had left him, hinting at life within those mysterious walls. Although the fire broke out before midnight, nothing effective was done to control it until two in the morning. Most of the courtiers have always lived within the Purple Wall and had never witnessed a disaster of this scale, so when they saw the palace buildings ablaze, the entire court, including “Henry” and “Elizabeth,” as some stories suggest, were paralyzed by nothing more than frantic excitement. Partly out of fear of looting and partly because their superiors didn’t give any orders to break an old rule, the guards refused to open the gates to the two Chinese and one foreign fire brigades that offered help. After a long discussion, they were finally let in, but by that time, the fire was so far along that it could only be brought under control at seven in the morning by cutting down many old trees and demolishing some smaller buildings. Even the Chinese admit that almost all the effective efforts were carried out by the foreigners; whatever the Celestials might excel at, they don't shine during emergencies.
Many priceless treasures, and the portraits of many former emperors, were destroyed. The official report had it first that the fire was caused by the bursting of a boiler in the palace electric-light plant, but the more probable truth has since leaked out. The latest assertion is that it was deliberately set by palace eunuchs, disgruntled over the failure to receive their allowances, or to cover up their thefts of imperial treasures. The time was close drawing near for the annual inspection of these when the conflagration occurred. Looking about the next day “Henry” found many precious things gone even from places which the fire did not reach, and incidentally, the story runs, he discovered a plot against his own life. Cynics wonder that the new régime has not hired some one to do away with him long before this. Various eunuchs were handed over to the police, some with bits of loot upon them, but “unfortunately,” to quote one Chinese paper, “the emperor no longer has the power to order their heads off.” When he demanded the arrest of some of the chief eunuchs, however, he found they were under the protection of two old imperial concubines—of Hsien Feng, consort of the famous dowager, and of Tung Chih, her son, respectively, who have been dead sixty-three and forty-eight years! So “Henry” and his two brides ran away to his father, who has a “palace” outside the west wall of the city, and refused to come back until all the eunuchs were discharged. This may have alarmed the old concubines, as the newspapers put it; certainly it frightened the republicans, with no president in office and the country threshing about for want of a head; pressure came from somewhere, the eunuchs went, and “Henry” came back.
Many priceless treasures and portraits of past emperors were destroyed. Initially, the official report claimed the fire was caused by a boiler explosion in the palace’s electric-light plant, but a more likely truth has surfaced since then. The latest claim is that it was intentionally set by palace eunuchs who were upset about not receiving their allowances or trying to cover up their thefts of imperial treasures. The annual inspection of these treasures was approaching when the fire broke out. The next day, “Henry” found that many valuable items had disappeared even from areas untouched by the flames, and along the way, he reportedly uncovered a plot against his own life. Cynics question why the new regime hasn’t arranged for someone to eliminate him long before now. Various eunuchs were handed over to the police, some even carrying stolen items, but “unfortunately,” as one Chinese newspaper put it, “the emperor no longer has the power to order their executions.” When he demanded the arrest of some of the main eunuchs, he discovered they were protected by two old imperial concubines—one from Hsien Feng, the famous dowager’s consort, and the other from Tung Chih, her son—who have been dead for sixty-three and forty-eight years, respectively! So, “Henry” and his two brides fled to his father’s “palace” outside the west wall of the city and refused to return until all the eunuchs were let go. This may have alarmed the old concubines, as the newspapers suggested; it definitely frightened the republicans, with no president in office and the country struggling without leadership. Pressure came from somewhere, the eunuchs were dismissed, and “Henry” returned.

Preparing for a devil-dance at the lama temple in Peking
Preparing for a devil dance at the lama temple in Beijing

The devil-dancers are usually Chinese street-urchins hired for the occasion by the languid Mongol lamas of Peking
The devil-dancers are usually Chinese street kids hired for the occasion by the laid-back Mongol lamas of Beijing.

The street-sprinklers of Peking work in pairs, with a bucket and a wooden dipper. This is the principal street of the Chinese City “outside Ch’ien-men”
The street sprinklers in Beijing operate in pairs, using a bucket and a wooden dipper. This is the main street of the Chinese City “outside Qianmen.”

The Forbidden City is for the most part no longer that, but open in more than half its extent to the ticket-buying public
The Forbidden City is mostly not forbidden anymore, as more than half of it is open to the public who buy tickets.
209The palace eunuch system has always been pernicious and one of the main causes of the fall of the many imperial houses that have ruled China. These have been served by eunuchs ever since the Chou dynasty, more than three thousand years ago. The dynasty might change, but the eunuchs, who were the palace servants and often the confidants of the other inmates, mainly women, stayed on and carried all the vices of the old court over into the new. Each new dynasty began with a hardy, outdoor ruler, but as his successors, thanks to the silly “Son of Heaven” idea, were practically imprisoned for life within the palace among women and eunuchs, they were bound to become weeds in the enervating atmosphere. Thus almost all dynasties petered out within two or three centuries, and in the closing years the eunuchs often became masters; it is well known that Tzu Hsi, the notorious old “Empress” Dowager, who governed China for forty years, was herself ruled by a favorite eunuch, who started life as a shoemaker’s apprentice—though some doubt has always been expressed about his real eunuchhood. He is believed to be more responsible than any other single person for the Boxer uprising, but the only punishment meted out to him was that his wealth, in gold bars said to be worth several millions, was discovered by the French troops upon the occupation of Peking and—no one has ever heard of it since.
209The palace eunuch system has always been harmful and one of the main reasons for the downfall of many imperial families that ruled China. Eunuchs have served in these dynasties since the Chou dynasty, over three thousand years ago. While dynasties may have changed, the eunuchs, who were the palace servants and often close confidants of the women in the court, remained and brought the same vices from one court to the next. Each new dynasty started with a strong, active ruler, but as their successors, due to the foolish “Son of Heaven” concept, were essentially confined for life within the palace surrounded by women and eunuchs, they inevitably became weak in that draining environment. As a result, almost all dynasties faded away within two or three centuries, and in the later years, eunuchs often gained control; it is well-known that Tzu Hsi, the infamous “Empress” Dowager who ruled China for forty years, was herself controlled by a favored eunuch who began his career as a shoemaker’s apprentice—though there has always been some doubt about whether he was truly a eunuch. He is believed to be primarily responsible for the Boxer uprising, yet the only consequence he faced was that his fortune, in gold bars reportedly worth several million, was found by French troops upon occupying Peking—and no one has heard of it since.
Avarice is the chief weakness of the eunuch tribe; and the official who could afford to get a powerful palace servant on his side was sure of preferment, and in time this system made China officially rotten to the core. Masters of intrigue and selfishness, they had to be “greased” from the outer gate to the throne-room even by those who wished to give the emperor himself a “present.” Each palace occupant was allowed the number of eunuchs which suited his rank, the total number being three thousand. They came mainly from Hokienfu, a small city about two hundred miles due south of Peking, where it was the custom for parents to make eunuchs of many of their boys, just as they bound the feet of their girls, for they could place them to still better advantage than a mere girl and thereby improve their own incomes. When “Henry” made this new break with antiquity, however, it was found that there were but 1430 palace eunuchs left, all, it is said, over thirty years old. Orders were also issued to all Mongol and Manchu nobles and princes forbidding the employment of eunuchs, and it is hoped that hereafter no native of Hokienfu will get himself 210mutilated for the sake of a palace job. Unlike bound feet, the system was, of course, by no means confined to China. The papal choir was made up of eunuchs, long since driven by public opinion from the Italian stage, at least as late as the beginning of the present century, and they are still employed as the keepers of harems in Mohammedan countries, being part and parcel of polygamy. Transportation to their homes, temporary lodgings, and a bit of money was allowed those whom this lad of sixteen at last cleared out of the Forbidden City, and it was a picturesque sight to see them leaving the palace with their tawdry belongings, quarreling to the last with the men sent to pay them off. Perhaps that is the end of them in China; but it is the land of compromise, and already the old and crippled eunuchs have been taken back into the palace until they die.
Avarice is the main weakness of the eunuch group; and the official who could manage to gain the loyalty of a powerful palace servant was guaranteed promotions, leading to a system that eventually made China corrupt to its core. Masters of intrigue and selfishness, they had to be “greased” from the outer gate to the throne room, even by those wanting to give a “gift” to the emperor himself. Each palace occupant was allowed a number of eunuchs appropriate to their rank, totaling three thousand. Most of them came from Hokienfu, a small city about two hundred miles south of Beijing, where it was common for parents to make eunuchs of many of their boys, just as they bound the feet of their girls, since they could profit more from a son who could serve in the palace than from a daughter. When “Henry” broke from tradition, it turned out there were only 1430 palace eunuchs left, all reportedly over thirty years old. Orders were also issued to all Mongol and Manchu nobles and princes prohibiting the hiring of eunuchs, with the hope that no native of Hokienfu would resort to mutilation for a palace job in the future. Unlike bound feet, this system wasn’t limited to China. The papal choir consisted of eunuchs, who had long been pushed out of the Italian stage by public opinion, and even into the early 21st century, they are still used as keepers of harems in Muslim countries, being a part of polygamy. Transportation to their homes, temporary lodging, and some money were provided for those whom this sixteen-year-old finally expelled from the Forbidden City, and it was quite a sight to see them leave the palace with their shabby belongings, arguing until the end with the men sent to settle their payments. That might be the end for them in China; however, being a land of compromise, the old and crippled eunuchs have already been taken back into the palace until they pass away.
There are people who believe that “Henry” may again be a real emperor of China, that he has proved himself so strong by some of his recent actions as to suggest that had he been born twenty years earlier China would not now be trying to pose as a republic. Even as modern a young man as our Chinese teacher thinks that a constitutional monarchy is the only feasible relief from the present anarchistic chaos of theoretical republicanism. He puts at ten years, others at from a generation to a century, the time required under such a restraining form of government to prepare for a real republic. Who knows? Perhaps even if the monarchy returns it will not be “Henry” who will head it; soothsayers have been making strange prophecies recently about an entirely new emperor to come out of the provinces. Besides, “Henry” is a Manchu, and China has reverted after nearly three centuries to the misrule of her own people. But he is already on the spot, sitting on the vacant throne as it were, and that is seldom a disadvantage.
There are people who think that “Henry” might actually become a real emperor of China again. They believe he has shown enough strength with some recent actions to suggest that if he had been born twenty years earlier, China wouldn’t be trying to present itself as a republic now. Even our Chinese teacher, who is quite modern, believes that a constitutional monarchy is the only practical solution to the current chaotic situation of theoretical republicanism. He estimates that it would take around ten years, while others say it could take anywhere from a generation to a century, to prepare for a genuine republic under such a governing system. Who knows? Maybe if the monarchy comes back, it won’t even be “Henry” leading it; fortune tellers have been making strange predictions lately about a completely new emperor rising from the provinces. Besides, “Henry” is a Manchu, and China has returned to being ruled by its own people after nearly three centuries. But he’s already in position, sitting on the empty throne, which is usually an advantage.
One of the first obligations of the foreigner coming to China for any length of time is to get a Chinese name. In other countries the people do the best they can, vocally and stelographically, to reproduce the names we already possess; even Japan, by using one of her modern scripts, can write all the but the more L-ish Western patronymics so that they read noticeably like the original. But the Chinese have always insisted that the outside barbarian adapt himself to Chinese ways, rather than the topsyturvy reverse. Besides, Chinese is a monosyllabic language, and naturally any stranger who comes to the country must be translated into words of one syllable. Unfortunately, even syllables are limited among the ideographs available to the Celestial brush-wielder, 211and names which to our notion are obviously of one become polysyllabic, to say the least, before the Chinese translator gets through with them. The result is that they seldom bear even a family resemblance to the original, and the foreigner who can recognize his own Chinese name, whether written or spoken, is already in a fair way to become an accomplished Oriental philologist.
One of the first things a foreigner coming to China for any length of time needs to do is get a Chinese name. In other countries, people try their best to pronounce and write our names as closely as possible; even Japan, using one of its modern scripts, can write nearly all Western names so they sound quite similar to the original. However, the Chinese have always expected outsiders to adapt to Chinese customs instead of the other way around. Plus, Chinese is a monosyllabic language, so anyone coming to the country has to be translated into one-syllable words. Unfortunately, even these syllables are limited among the ideographs available to a skilled Chinese writer, 211 and names that seem obvious to us as one syllable can end up sounding polysyllabic, to say the least, after a Chinese translator is done. As a result, they often bear little resemblance to the original, and the foreigner who can recognize his own Chinese name, whether it's written or spoken, is already on his way to becoming a skilled expert in Oriental languages.
Let me take my own name as an example. Except that it may be racially misleading, I have always considered it quite a tolerable name, not particularly difficult to pronounce, or to remember, by those who choose to do so, and unquestionably monosyllabic. Yet the Chinese scholar to whom it was submitted divided it at once into three syllables, like an expert taking apart an instrument one had always believed to be of one piece and returned it as “Feh Lan-kuh.” The first character stands for “extravagance,” but all the sting is taken out of that false and unjust start by the other two, which mean “orchid” and “self-control” respectively. Only three names are allowed in Chinese; therefore my given names in my own language were crowded into the discard. To the Chinese I am “Feh Hsien-sheng”—Mr. Extravagance; if they wish to go further and find out what particular form my wastefulness takes they respectfully inquire my honorable ming-tze, and are informed that my unworthy personal names are “Lan-kuh,” the Orchid with Self-control. The trouble is that almost any foreigner whose name begins with an F, or even with a Ph, is also Mr. Feh. There are a dozen of them within gunshot of us, surely a thousand in China, most of whose English names are not in the least like our own.
Let me use my own name as an example. Although it might be racially misleading, I've always thought it's quite a decent name—not particularly hard to pronounce or remember for those who choose to—and definitely just one syllable. However, the Chinese scholar who analyzed it immediately broke it down into three syllables, like an expert dismantling an instrument I always believed was one piece, and returned it as “Feh Lan-kuh.” The first character means “extravagance,” but the negative vibe from that misleading and unfair start is softened by the other two, which mean “orchid” and “self-control.” In Chinese culture, only three names are allowed; thus, my given names in my own language were set aside. To the Chinese, I am “Feh Hsien-sheng”—Mr. Extravagance; if they want to delve deeper into what form my wastefulness takes, they politely ask for my honorable ming-tze, and learn that my unworthy personal names are “Lan-kuh,” the Orchid with Self-control. The issue is that almost any foreigner whose name starts with an F, or even with a Ph, is also Mr. Feh. There are at least a dozen of them nearby, certainly a thousand in China, most of whose English names don't resemble ours at all.
A few lucky mortals have names that can be put into Chinese just as they stand, not only leaving them audibly recognizable to their compatriots but saving their given names from the scrap-heap. There is Mr. Fay, of course, Mr. Howe and Mr. May, and obviously Mr. Lee is orally at home anywhere in China, whether the scholarly see him as a “pear” or “clear dawn.” On the other hand there are names that cannot possibly be put into Chinese even faintly resembling themselves,—Messrs. Smith and Jones, for instance. It is quite as necessary to know the Chinese name of the friend you wish to find in China as to be able to speak Chinese; more so, in fact, for while the Celestials are the antithesis of their island neighbors in the rapidity with which they grasp an idea from signs and motions, it is difficult, unless some outstanding personal characteristic is involved, to express a proper name by a gesture. You may go up and down a Chinese city in which he has lived for twenty years shouting for your dear old schoolmate Kelly, 212shepherding a flock of Chinese in the general direction of heaven now, and never find a trace of him unless chance puts you on the track of his new appellation. Luckily there are but a hundred or so family names in all China, and as many characters fit to be used as such, so that one may soon become fairly expert at guessing.
A few fortunate people have names that can be translated into Chinese exactly as they are, making them recognizable to others from their country and preserving their original names. There’s Mr. Fay, Mr. Howe, and Mr. May, and of course, Mr. Lee sounds natural anywhere in China, whether scholars see it as “pear” or “clear dawn.” On the flip side, there are names that can't even vaguely be translated into Chinese—like Smith and Jones. Knowing the Chinese name of the friend you want to find in China is just as important as being able to speak Chinese; in fact, it’s even more crucial because while the Chinese are quick to understand ideas conveyed through signs and movements, it’s hard to express a proper name with gestures unless there’s a notable personal trait involved. You could wander through a Chinese city where your old friend Kelly has lived for twenty years, shouting for him and guiding a crowd of locals toward the sky, and still not find him unless you accidentally discover his new name. Fortunately, there are only about a hundred family names in all of China, with as many characters that can be used, so you can quickly get pretty good at guessing. 212
One must have a Chinese name, not only because one would otherwise be unmentionable, on respectful occasions, even to one’s own servants, but because a plentiful supply of visiting-cards is absolutely indispensable. Fortunately these can be had in China at a fraction of what they cost at home; because not only are cards exchanged on the slightest provocation, but one of those hastily printed scraps of paper is just as important and just as final anywhere within the once Celestial Empire as in South America. Without a card a millionaire in evening-dress is a mere coolie; with one the most disreputable foreign tramp who ever seeped back into the interior from the treaty-ports is a gentleman fit to dine with a Tuchun.
One needs to have a Chinese name, not just because otherwise one would be unmentionable, even to one's own servants on respectful occasions, but because a good supply of business cards is absolutely necessary. Luckily, these are easily available in China for a fraction of the cost back home; cards are exchanged at the slightest excuse, and one of those quickly printed pieces of paper is just as important and final anywhere in what was once the Celestial Empire as in South America. Without a card, a millionaire in evening dress is just an ordinary worker; with one, even the most disreputable foreign drifter who has slipped back into the interior from the treaty ports is seen as a gentleman worthy of dining with a Tuchun.
In the olden days of not so long ago Chinese name-cards were red, the color for happiness. To have a white card meant that one’s father or mother had died within the past three years; those mourning the recent loss of a grandparent had yellow or blue ones. The size of the card determined the importance of the one whose name it bore, or vice versa, so that the card of a viceroy or a generalissimo was of the size of a sheet of foolscap, a blood-red splash that could be seen half a mile away. Colors and size both cost money, however; moreover China has become, in name at least, a republic. White cards are now in quite general use, therefore, and though they still vary in size, I have never been handed one larger than a coat-pocket. Some remain red on one side and white on the other, especially among the formal and the wealthy; the ultra-modern have their English name on one side and Chinese on the other, like foreign residents. The custom of using both sides seems to be an old one. Often the formal or “business” name appears on the front, sometimes with the rank or calling, while on the back, in much smaller characters, are the hao and the yuan-ch’i, the name used only by intimates, and the ancestral birthplace—which even the father of the man represented may never have seen. Not a few Chinese use two different cards. One of them bears the characters meaning, “This is only a friendly exchange-card”; in other words, it has no import in serious or business matters. If a Tuchun graciously gives you his “exchange-card” that does not mean that you can use it 213to give orders to his soldiers or borrow money in his name at a bank, though his official card may still have almost the potency of the signet-ring of a king in the days of ruffles and feathers.
In the not-so-distant past, Chinese name cards were red, symbolizing happiness. A white card indicated that someone's parent had died within the last three years; those mourning a recent grandparent used yellow or blue cards. The size of the card reflected the importance of the person named on it or vice versa, so the card of a viceroy or a generalissimo was the size of a legal sheet, a bold red that could be seen from half a mile away. However, both color and size come at a cost; furthermore, China has now become, at least nominally, a republic. As a result, white cards are now commonly used, and although they still vary in size, I've never received one larger than a coat pocket. Some cards remain red on one side and white on the other, especially among the formal and wealthy; the ultra-modern versions have the English name on one side and the Chinese name on the other, similar to foreign residents. The custom of using both sides seems to be longstanding. Often, the formal or “business” name appears on the front, sometimes along with the rank or profession, while on the back, in much smaller print, are the hao and the yuan-ch’i, the names used only by close friends, and the ancestral hometown—which even the father of the person may never have visited. Quite a few Chinese people use two different cards. One of them states, “This is just a friendly exchange card,” meaning it has no weight in serious or business matters. If a Tuchun kindly gives you his “exchange card,” it doesn’t mean you can give orders to his soldiers or borrow money in his name at a bank, even though his official card may still hold nearly the same power as a king's signet ring during the days of ruffles and feathers.
A play modeled more or less on Chinese lines which went the round of the English-speaking world some years ago has familiarized us with some of the peculiarities of the Chinese theater—or, from their point of view, with those of our own. At least those of us who had the pleasure of attending that performance know that on the Chinese stage a banner held aloft by two coolies at opposite ends of it stands for a city gate, and that when a man has been histrionically killed he gets up, wipes his nose, and saunters off the stage, quite as invisible to the audience as are the property-men incessantly wandering about among the actors with the ultra-bored expression of men more completely surfeited with things theatrical than all the first-nighters and dramatic critics of Christendom rolled into one. But the Chinese stage has other points which were not included in that delightful effigy of it, partly because to make it too Chinese would have been the surest way to drive away any Western audience, partly because invention advances day by day. I enjoy the casual, lackadaisical, “invisible” property-men of the Chinese theater, but I find the man with the thermos bottle still more beguiling. For “props,” dressed not in black, as the imported version of Celestial theatrical life would have us believe, but in the hit-or-miss costume of the Chinese laboring-class, with blue denims very much the favorite, is after all at home in the theater and soon becomes even to the foreign eye as natural a part of the decorations as does the omnipresent coolie in or out of doors. I wonder if their property-men are not really invisible to the Chinese, for do they not always have servants and attendants flocking incessantly about them anywhere, everywhere, on the most solemn as well as the most trivial occasions? But I have never quite gotten used to the thermos-bottle man and able to look upon him with complete equanimity. He is no theater employee, but the personal servant of this or that important actor, which actor often does not remain more than an hour or two at a time in one theater; hence, at least in Peking in the winter season, the man who brings his master his indispensable tea at the climax of every histrionic flight wears overcoat, fur or knitted cap, and all the rest of the midwinter equipment, so that, bursting suddenly but casually in upon a court ceremony or a battle scene set in the color-splashed days to which 214Chinese dramas hark back, he suggests an experienced and unexcitable arctic explorer come to succor with the latest contrivance a group of Martians enjoying an equatorial holiday.
A play inspired by Chinese traditions that traveled through the English-speaking world a few years back has introduced us to some unique aspects of Chinese theater—or, from their perspective, our own. At least those of us who had the chance to see that performance know that on the Chinese stage, a banner held up by two coolies at either end represents a city gate, and when a character has been dramatically killed, he simply gets up, wipes his nose, and strolls offstage, just as unseen to the audience as the stagehands who constantly meander among the actors with the totally bored look of people who are more tired of theatrical antics than all the first-nighters and theater critics in the world combined. However, the Chinese stage has other features that weren’t captured in that charming performance, partly because making it too authentically Chinese would risk losing any Western audience, and partly because creativity evolves every day. I enjoy the casual, laid-back, “invisible” stagehands of Chinese theater, but I find the guy with the thermos bottle even more intriguing. The “props,” dressed not in black as the Western interpretation of Chinese theater might suggest, but in the hit-or-miss attire of the Chinese working class—blue denim being quite popular—fit into the theater seamlessly, becoming as much a part of the scenery as the ever-present coolie, whether indoors or outdoors. I wonder if Chinese stagehands are actually invisible to their own people, since they always seem to have servants and attendants buzzing around them at all times, on both solemn and trivial occasions. But I haven’t quite gotten used to the thermos-bottle guy and can’t view him with complete calm. He isn’t a theater employee but rather the personal servant of some important actor, who often doesn’t stay in one theater for more than an hour or two; thus, at least in Beijing during winter, the man who brings his master essential tea during every dramatic moment is decked out in an overcoat, fur or knitted cap, and all the other winter gear. As a result, when he suddenly but casually bursts into a court scene or a battle set in the colorful days that 214 Chinese dramas evoke, he resembles an experienced, unflappable arctic explorer coming to assist a group of Martians having a tropical vacation.
The thermos bottle was, of course, unknown to those actors of some generations or centuries back who refused to be deprived even for the length of a scene of the national beverage, and at the same time wished to impress upon the audience, itself engaged in satisfying the inner man quite as freely as if seated at home, that they, for all the low rank of players, were just as important, thereby establishing a custom that is all but universal on the Chinese stage. Old-fashioned actors, or those less generously subsidized by the box-office, also have their tea at the end of every crisis; but it is brought, not in the latest triumph of science and by a personal retainer, but by one of the omnipresent “props,” by a disengaged “super,” or by one of the beggarly loafers that seem always to be hanging about behind the scenes—if they can be called such—of a Chinese theater. They, too, sip the uninebriating cup held up to them while half turning their backs or holding an edge of their always voluminous costumes over a corner of the mouth, a conventional pretense which is supposed to make the act invisible to the audience, and which so far as outward appearances go seems actually to do so. Besides, why should an act as general and almost as continuous among the Chinese as breathing attract the attention of a generation that has probably associated it with every dramatic climax since the oldest man among them first paid an admission fee? If so slight a thing as this brought inattention to the play, what would not the orchestra accomplish in the way of distracting from the plaudits due the actors, scattered as it is about the stage itself, maltreating its strange instruments or refraining therefrom in the most casual manner, to light a cigarette, to scratch itself, to ply a toothpick, or strolling individually on or off, in any garb at any moment of the afternoon or evening that happens to suit the individual fancy.
The thermos bottle was, of course, unknown to those actors from previous generations or centuries who refused to be without their national drink, even for the duration of a scene. They wanted to show the audience, who were also enjoying their refreshments as if they were at home, that they, despite being low-ranking performers, were just as significant. This established a nearly universal tradition on the Chinese stage. Old-school actors, or those who didn’t have as much money coming in from ticket sales, also have their tea after every dramatic moment; however, it isn’t served in the latest scientific marvel or by a personal attendant, but by one of the ever-present “props,” a bystander “super,” or one of the shabby loafers often lurking behind the scenes—if you can even call it that—in a Chinese theater. They too sip the non-alcoholic beverage while turning partly away or covering a corner of their flowing costumes with their hand, a conventional act meant to keep it hidden from the audience, and it seems to actually work for appearances. Besides, why would such a common and nearly continuous act among the Chinese—almost as natural as breathing—draw the attention of a generation that has likely associated it with every dramatic peak since the oldest person among them first bought a ticket? If something as minor as this distracted from the play, what would the orchestra do in terms of creating distractions from the actors’ applause, scattered as it is across the stage, mishandling their unusual instruments or casually taking breaks to light a cigarette, scratch themselves, use a toothpick, or wander on or off stage in any outfit at any random point during the afternoon or evening?
There is a theater in the heart of the Tartar City completely Westernized in architecture and general arrangements, yet where perfectly Chinese plays are given; but the foreigner who wishes to get the complete atmosphere must go “outside Ch’ien-men” into the Chinese City. For after all it is the audience and what takes place in front of the stage as much as what goes forward upon it that repays the Westerner for visiting a Chinese theater. In this busiest part of Peking, among the blocks where the singsong-girls ply their popular trade, are scattered many genuinely native playhouses, and farther on there are numerous 215makeshift ones hastily thrown together of boards, mats, and sheet-iron, stretching beyond the T’ien-ch’iao, the “Heavenly Bridge” with its swarming outdoor markets, across which emperors were carried for centuries to the near-by Temple of Heaven. Out there one may hear much of the play and more of the “music” than he cares to, while merely riding past in the afternoon—for genuine Peking theaters are in full swing from about noon until long after midnight.
There’s a theater in the heart of Tartar City that’s completely Western in style and setup, yet they put on authentic Chinese plays. However, if a foreign visitor wants the full experience, they need to go “outside Ch’ien-men” into the Chinese City. After all, it’s the audience and what happens in front of the stage, as much as what’s happening on it, that makes a Chinese theater worthwhile for Westerners to visit. In this bustling part of Beijing, among the blocks where the singsong girls are busy, there are plenty of authentic local playhouses, and further on, there are many makeshift theaters quickly built from boards, mats, and sheet metal, stretching beyond the T’ien-ch’iao, the “Heavenly Bridge,” which has been a busy market area where emperors were carried for centuries to the nearby Temple of Heaven. Out there, you can hear a lot of the plays and even more of the music than you might want, all while just passing by in the afternoon—because real Beijing theaters are packed from around noon until long after midnight.
Perhaps on the whole the visitor will get the most for his money at any of those playhouses lost in the maze of narrow streets not far outside Ch’ien-men, without earning the ill will of his rickshaw-man by driving him ’way out to the Heavenly Bridge. Here he will find himself, though perhaps not without Chinese help, entering what looks much like a warehouse or a wholesale establishment, a roofed court overcrowded with crude, narrow, painfully upright benches black with time and the food and drinks that have been spilled upon them for generations from the little shelves protruding along the back of each for the use of the row behind. The foreigner is so far out of the orbit of his kind in one of these establishments that, though the Legation Quarter is barely a hop, skip, and jump away, just beyond the mammoth Tartar wall, and those two of the Peking railway stations out of which emerge almost all foreign visitors to the capital are still nearer, he will probably not be seated before what looks like a coolie comes to ask his name, preferably to get his card, explaining, if there is any common denominator of words in which to do so, that every wai-guo-ren who enters the place must be reported at once, so that a policeman may be sent to protect him. Yet it is years since a foreigner has needed individual police protection anywhere within the Chinese City half as much as the unpaid gendarme who will keep an eye upon him throughout the performance needs the tip which he will not refuse if it is properly forced upon him.
Maybe overall, the visitor will get the best value for their money at any of those theaters hidden in the maze of narrow streets not far from Ch’ien-men, without upsetting their rickshaw driver by taking them all the way out to the Heavenly Bridge. Here, they will find themselves, though perhaps with some help from locals, entering what looks much like a warehouse or a wholesale shop—a covered courtyard packed with old, narrow, uncomfortably stiff benches that have been stained with time and food and drinks spilled on them for generations, with little shelves sticking out along the back for the use of those seated behind. The foreigner feels so far removed from their own kind in one of these places that, although the Legation Quarter is just a short walk away, right beyond the massive Tartar wall, and the two Peking railway stations from which almost all foreign visitors to the capital arrive are even closer, they will likely not be seated before someone who looks like a laborer comes to ask for their name, preferably to get their card, explaining, if there are any common words to do so, that every wai-guo-ren who enters must be reported immediately so a policeman can be sent to look after them. Yet it’s been years since a foreigner has needed individual police protection anywhere in the Chinese City as much as the unpaid watchman who keeps an eye on them during the show needs the tip they won’t refuse if it’s properly given.
Strictly speaking the foreign visitor does not find himself a seat, any more than he discovers the theater without help. He is, ipso facto, a “possessor of money,” and nowhere that he stirs in China, least of all in a theater, are there lacking men eager to take as much of that commodity away as can be bluffed or wheedled out of him. Hence the conspicuous new-comer is beset from the very entrance by a flock of men in the all too familiar garb of unwashed coolies, each eager to lead him to some different section of the house. If he is easily led he will find himself installed before he knows it in a rickety chair in one of the little pretenses of boxes around the narrow balcony, the only 216part of the house where women spectators may sit. The prices are higher up there, and the inevitable rake-off of his guide correspondingly larger. If he is wise he will insist upon remaining in the pit, not too near the uproarious orchestra and not so close to the back as to interfere with the throwing arms of the towel-men. When at last he has settled down as the protégé of a man who seems suddenly to grow superciliously patronizing toward him the moment he is sure of keeping him in his own section, and has apparently made lifelong enemies of all the others who tried to seat him elsewhere, he becomes at once the prey of the innumerable hawkers of this and that who wallow and shout their way through the audience quite irrespective of a possible interest in the stage. Perhaps it occurs to him that he bought no ticket, and was asked for none at the door. No one does as he enters the purely Chinese theater. By the time each auditor has adjusted himself as well as his bodily bulk will permit to the impossible seats behind the tippy shelves, a man comes to sell him a ticket and to take it up with one and the same motion. Prices are not high, sixty to eighty coppers at most, including the percentage that is almost sure to be added out of respect for his alien condition; even in the Westernized theater within the Tartar City a seat anywhere in the pit or parquet rarely reaches the height of a “Mex” dollar. Then a man who thinks he chose his seat for him must also have his “squeeze,” but this by no means amounts to the sum subtracted by the old ladies who pose as ushers in the theaters of Paris. Long before these formalities are concluded, simultaneously with his sitting down, in fact, the countless dispensers of food and drink are taking his patronage for granted. A tea-cup sadly in need of an hour’s scouring with sand is placed top down on the unwashed seat-back before him, soon to be followed by a tea-pot the spout of which, if he is observant, he has probably seen some unsoaped neighbor sucking a moment before, now refilled with boiling water. Little dishes of shriveled native peanuts, of pumpkin-seeds, of half a dozen similar delicacies which he has often seen along the outdoor markets and in the baskets of street-hawkers without ever having felt a desire to make a closer acquaintance with them, probably also a joint of sugar-cane, will likewise be set in front of him before he can say his Chinese name, unless he waves all these things aside with a very imperative gesture. None of the hawkers catch the meaning of this at once, at least outwardly, and when they finally do their resentment often reaches the point of what sounds unpleasantly like more or less subtle vituperation. Whoever heard of going to a theater without 217sipping tea and cracking pumpkin-seeds? Why does this wealthy barbarian come and occupy a seat if he is going to cheat the men who supply that part of the house out of their rightful and time-honored selling privileges?
Strictly speaking, the foreign visitor doesn't find a seat for himself, just like he doesn't discover the theater without assistance. He is, by that very fact, a “possessor of money,” and wherever he goes in China, especially in a theater, there are plenty of people eager to take as much of that money from him as they can bluff or sweet-talk out of him. So, the obvious newcomer is swarmed right at the entrance by a group of men in the all-too-familiar attire of unwashed coolies, each ready to lead him to a different part of the house. If he’s easily directed, he’ll find himself settled in a rickety chair in one of the small makeshift boxes around the narrow balcony, which is the only section where women spectators can sit. The prices up there are higher, and his guide’s inevitable cut is correspondingly larger. If he’s smart, he’ll insist on staying in the pit, not too close to the noisy orchestra and not so far back that he interferes with the towel-men throwing towels. Once he finally gets comfortable as the protégé of a man who suddenly starts acting all superior now that he’s sure of keeping him in his section, and who seems to have made lifelong enemies of all the others who tried to seat him elsewhere, he becomes instantly prey to the endless hawkers selling this and that who push their way through the audience without any regard for the stage. He might wonder why he didn’t buy a ticket, since no one asked for one at the door. No one does when entering a purely Chinese theater. By the time each audience member has adjusted themselves as comfortably as they can to the impossible seats behind the unstable shelves, a man comes to sell him a ticket and takes it up in one swift motion. Prices aren’t high, sixty to eighty coppers at most, including the percentage that’s likely added out of respect for his foreign status; even in the Western-style theater in the Tartar City, a seat anywhere in the pit or parquet rarely costs more than a “Mex” dollar. Then, the man who seems to have chosen his seat for him must also get his “squeeze,” but this doesn’t come close to the amount deducted by the old ladies who pretend to be ushers in Paris theaters. Long before these formalities are finished, right as he sits down, the countless vendors of food and drink start taking his patronage for granted. A tea cup that desperately needs a thorough cleaning is placed upside down on the unwashed seat back in front of him, soon to be followed by a teapot whose spout, if he’s paying attention, he probably saw some unsanitary neighbor suck on a moment before, now refilled with boiling water. Small dishes of dried peanuts, pumpkin seeds, and a half-dozen similar snacks that he’s often seen in outdoor markets and street vendors’ baskets without ever wanting to try them will also be set in front of him before he can even say his Chinese name, unless he waves all these items away with a very firm gesture. None of the hawkers grasp this immediately, at least not outwardly, and when they finally do, their irritation often escalates to what sounds unpleasantly like more or less subtle insults. Who has ever heard of going to a theater without sipping tea and cracking pumpkin seeds? Why does this wealthy foreigner come and take a seat if he’s just going to cheat the vendors out of their rightful and traditional selling privileges?
By and by one may be able to turn one’s attention to the stage, though one has certainly not been unconscious of it, auricularly at least, since entering the door. The stage is nothing but a raised platform with a low railing on all four sides, such as might have been the auction-place in the days when the building was perhaps the warehouse it looks as if it must have been. Whatever serve as dressing-rooms at the rear, which according to the space there cannot be much, are separated from the stage by an alleyway across which the exiting and entering players hop. The antics on the stage are in no noticeable way different from those at the Westernized Peking theaters regularly patronized by foreigners. The masks and wigs and terrifying costumes are probably cruder, less splendid, and worse adjusted; the lean and bathless coolies who come on at frequent intervals in orderless groups undisguised as soldiers, courtiers, and who-knows-what are if anything a trifle more abject and bovine; there may not appear a single thermos bottle during the whole evening, though there will be as incessant a consumption of what passes for tea among the great mass of the Chinese. Certainly there will be no scenery in the Western sense, though there may be a few curtains half shutting off the inadequate dressing-room space, and some pretenses of city gates, thrones, and the like improvised on the spur of the moment by the bored property-men out of strips of cloth and half-broken chairs. The conventionalized things which take the place of scenery, the strange whips carried by those who are supposed to be mounted, and the something which tells the audience that the bearer is riding in a boat are somewhat the worse for wear, while the cushions which “Props” disdainfully throws out in front of the stars when it is time for them to kneel are almost slippery with the grease of generations. But the tumbling and the juggling which imply that one of the frequent battles is going on will be quite the same, except that it will not be so well done, as inside the main city, and the uproar will be just as constant and if anything a trifle more deafening.
Soon enough, you might be able to focus on the stage, even though you’ve definitely been aware of it since you walked in. The stage is merely a raised platform with low railings on all sides, similar to what might have been an auction place when this building was likely a warehouse. The dressing rooms at the back, which judging by the space can’t be very large, are separated from the stage by a narrow aisle where the actors come and go. The performances aren’t noticeably different from those at the Western-style theaters in Beijing regularly attended by foreigners. The masks, wigs, and scary costumes are probably less elaborate and poorly fitted; the lean, unwashed laborers who enter in disorganized groups, pretending to be soldiers, courtiers, or who knows what, seem a bit more downtrodden and dull. You might not see a single thermos bottle all evening, but there will be a constant consumption of what the majority of Chinese call tea. Certainly, there won’t be any scenery in the Western sense, though there might be a few curtains half hiding the cramped dressing room area, along with makeshift city gates and thrones thrown together on a whim by bored prop handlers using bits of cloth and broken chairs. The so-called scenery—strange whips for those pretending to ride and other signs indicating that someone is in a boat—shows signs of wear, as do the cushions that the prop guys carelessly toss in front of the stars when it’s their time to kneel, which are almost slick from generations of grease. But the acrobatics suggesting that one of the many battles is taking place will be pretty much the same, just not as polished as what you'd find in the main city, and the noise will be just as relentless, if not a bit louder.
One theater outside Ch’ien-men has only female players; but they appear in the same rôles, in exactly the same time-honored plays, as the all-men casts in other theaters, and act as nearly as possible in the same way, equally dreadful even in the atrocious falsetto which is the Chinese actor’s specialty, as noises from the pit of the stomach are of 218those of Japan. There may be many a guttural “Hao!” from the men in the audience for the juggling feats of the stars, winning their battles thus after the time-honored manner of stage generals or emperors; perhaps even greater signs of approval for some fine point skilfully rounded in the old familiar themes, which escapes the foreigner entirely; but there is never a suggestion of the thought of sex, not a hint, except in their general appearance, that the players are women and not men. Some of the unwashed girls who fill out the cast, looking like nothing so much as kitchen wenches in odds and ends of old finery, are quite as clever acrobats, in battle-scene tumbling at least, as the men at other places, though they get less a month than a Broadway chorus-girl spends on chewinggum in a week.
One theater outside Ch’ien-men has only female performers; however, they play the same roles in the same classic plays as the all-male casts in other theaters, and their acting is as close as possible to that of the men, equally dreadful even in the horrible falsetto that Chinese actors are known for, similar to the sounds coming from the pit of the stomach in Japan. There may be plenty of guttural “Hao!” from the men in the audience in response to the stars' juggling feats, celebrating their victories in the traditional way of stage generals or emperors. They might even show more approval for some clever twist skillfully delivered in the familiar plots, which often escapes foreign viewers entirely; but there is never any suggestion of sexuality, not a hint, except for the general appearance that the performers are women and not men. Some of the unwashed girls who round out the cast, looking more like kitchen maids in mismatched old finery, are just as skilled in acrobatics, especially in battle scenes, as the men in other theaters, although they earn less in a month than what a Broadway chorus girl spends on chewing gum in a week.
It will be an imperturbable foreign visitor, however, who can keep his attention fixed on the stage long enough to note all this at once. The goings-on in the audience will probably prove more comprehensible, certainly more amusing. Without going into endless detail it may suffice to say that the climax of all those things which a Chinese audience does and a Western one does not is the demand for hot towels during the performance. One or two towel-men stand over a steaming tub in a far corner; as many as a dozen others are scattered about the hall, though their presence may not be suspected by the inexperienced until the bombardment of towels begins, about the end of the first round of pumpkin-seeds. All at once the air overhead is crisscrossed with flying white objects, which on closer attention prove to be bundles of hot, wet towels tightly rolled together. A man near the tub is throwing them to a colleague somewhere out in the house, who relays them on to others dispersed about, these doling them out along the rows of spectators, collecting them again after they have been used—not to give the ears a respite from the ceaseless uproar but to deceive the face and hands with the ghost of a washing—bundling them together once more to start them hurtling back high over head to the point of origin. The most expert venders of double-jointed Philadelphia peanuts at our national games cannot equal Chinese towel-men in the number of throws and the narrow margins of safety without injury to a spectator. Evidently the towel-service is included in the price of admission, unless the hawkers and the section guards band together to supply their clients this apparent necessity. Therefore the foreigner who gracefully declines this gracious attention, after noting that the returned towels are merely immersed and wrung out again as a bundle and once more sent the rounds, does not win the ill will that would 219accrue to him if there were a copper or two of cumshaw involved, and does no other damage than to block the wheels of progress long enough for information concerning his strange conduct to be relayed back to the tub-men and commented upon at least throughout the section he makes conspicuous by his presence.
It will take a truly unflappable foreign visitor to keep their focus on the stage long enough to catch all of this at once. What’s happening in the audience will likely be easier to understand, and definitely more entertaining. Without getting into endless details, it’s enough to say that the peak of what a Chinese audience does, which a Western one doesn’t, is the request for hot towels during the show. One or two towel attendants stand over a steaming tub in a corner; as many as a dozen others are scattered throughout the hall, although inexperienced observers might not notice them until the shower of towels begins, around the time the first round of pumpkin seeds ends. Suddenly, the air above is filled with flying white objects, which upon closer inspection turn out to be tightly rolled bundles of hot, wet towels. A man near the tub tosses them to a colleague somewhere in the audience, who then passes them along to others spread out in the rows, distributing them to the spectators and then collecting them back after they’ve been used—not to give their ears a break from the nonstop noise but to give their faces and hands the illusion of a wash—bundling them up again to be tossed back overhead to where they started. The most skilled vendors of double-jointed Philadelphia peanuts at our national games can’t match the Chinese towel attendants in the number of throws and the narrow margins of safety without hitting someone. Clearly, the towel service is part of the admission price, unless the vendors and the section guards are working together to provide this apparent necessity. So, when a foreigner politely declines this generous gesture, after realizing that the returned towels are just soaked and twisted together again before being sent out once more, they don’t earn the resentment they would if a few coins were involved, and the only disruption they cause is to slow down the flow of things just long enough for the towel attendants to hear about their unusual behavior, which gets talked about throughout the section they’ve made noticeable by their presence.
The bombardment of towels goes on periodically from early afternoon until early morning, like all the rest of the performance. Where one play ends another begins with barely the interval of a sip of tea, and though some spectators are constantly coming and going, like the casual members of the orchestra and the undisguised “supers,” the endurance of the mass of them is phenomenal. Some time between five and seven o’clock many spectators vary their incessant munching and sipping by ordering a full meal from the runners of the adjoining tea-house, and the click of chop-sticks may now and then be heard above the louder clamor. But the spectacle, both on and off the stage, goes unconcernedly on.
The constant stream of towels continues throughout the afternoon and into the early morning, just like the rest of the show. When one act finishes, another starts with hardly a break for a sip of tea, and although some audience members are always coming and going, like the casual musicians and the obvious extras, the endurance of the majority is impressive. Sometime between five and seven o’clock, many attendees mix up their endless snacking and sipping by ordering full meals from the staff of the nearby tea house, and you can occasionally hear the click of chopsticks over the louder noise. But the spectacle, both on and off the stage, carries on without a care.
It would require much more Chinese than I can so far understand to catch any of the dialogue—if that is the word for it—of a typical Chinese play. The inexperienced Westerner will seldom have the faintest idea what it is all about, or even who the characters stand for, so unintelligible to him are the signs and symbols by which the native spectator recognizes them and their doings. For that matter the average Chinese would not understand much unless he had imbibed all these old stories almost with his mother’s milk. The old, poetic, and often obsolete words in which the Chinese actor speaks—or rather “sings,” to use the misleading Chinese term—would be obscure enough in a sane and ordinary tone of voice; in his successful imitation of ungreased machinery his actual speech is probably of little more import to the hearers than are the words of an Italian opera to a Chicago audience. Like the Japanese the Chinese prefer to hear the same old historical themes and see the same old pageants over and over again, however, or at most to have new variations upon them, generation after century. Hence even the illiterate can often follow a play word by word without understanding a line of it. We have discovered that by having our teacher tell us the story beforehand we can guess the meaning of a considerable part of the action, thereby finding the Chinese theater much less of a bore than most foreigners report it. To every people its own ways; certainly the attempt to ape Western theatricals which was put on during the winter by a club of native élite, with traveled young Chinese of both sexes prancing about the stage in frock-coats and scanty gowns, 220not to mention bobbed hair, was more terrible than anything genuine Chinese actors ever perpetrate. Personally I have even become reconciled to Chinese “music”—in the olden days plays were given outdoors, hence the deafening quality of this—and in certain moods even to enjoy it, briefly, as one sometimes enjoys a crush in the subway or a rough-and-tumble mingling with the Broadway throng; and we have both grown very fond of seeing, if not of listening to, Mei Lan-fang.
It would take a lot more Chinese than I currently understand to grasp any of the dialogue—if that's what you can call it—of a typical Chinese play. Most inexperienced Westerners will often have no idea what it's about or even who the characters represent, as the signs and symbols that native viewers use to recognize them and their actions are completely unintelligible to them. In fact, the average Chinese person wouldn’t understand much either unless they absorbed all these old stories almost with their mother's milk. The old, poetic, and often outdated words that the Chinese actor uses—or rather “sings,” to use the misleading Chinese term—would be pretty obscure even if delivered in a clear voice; in his successful imitation of ungreased machinery, his actual speech probably means little more to the audience than the lyrics of an Italian opera do to a Chicago crowd. Like the Japanese, the Chinese enjoy hearing the same old historical themes and watching the same old performances over and over again, or at best, having new variations of them, generation after generation. As a result, even those who can’t read can often follow a play word for word without understanding a single line. We’ve found that by having our teacher tell us the story beforehand, we can grasp a good portion of the action, making the Chinese theater much less boring than most foreigners report. Every culture has its own ways; certainly, the attempt to imitate Western theater that a local elite group put on last winter, with young Chinese men and women prancing around the stage in frock coats and skimpy gowns, not to mention bobbed hair, was worse than anything genuine Chinese actors ever put on. Personally, I've even gotten used to Chinese “music”—since plays used to be performed outdoors, it has this deafening quality—and at times I can even enjoy it, briefly, like you might enjoy a crowded subway or mingling with the bustling crowd on Broadway; and we have both grown quite fond of watching, if not necessarily listening to, Mei Lan-fang.
Mr. Mei—whose family character means “peach blossom” and who is related to us to the extent of including an orchid in his given name—is China’s most famous and most popular actor. Like his father and grandfather before him he plays only female rôles, and while even his falsettos may grate on a Western ear, many is the foreigner who pursues him from theater to theater merely to watch his graceful movements, his inimitable dancing or simply the manipulation of his beautiful hands. Scrawl the three characters by which he is known on the bill-board or the newspaper space of any theater, inside Ch’ien-men or out, anywhere in China for that matter, though he has no need to tour the provinces, and the man in the box-office has only to order any suggestion of vacant space filled with chairs and lean back in perfect contentment. Mei Lan-fang carries his own troupe, like a Spanish matador his cuadrilla, even his own orchestra, and the arrangement of Chinese performances is such that he can play in several theaters on the same night, from eleven to midnight inside the Tartar City perhaps, where the doors close ridiculously early, the rest of the night among the better establishments outside the main wall. Seldom does he deign to appear earlier than that, unless at some special matinée in the Forbidden City or at the presidential palace, and he is under no necessity of appearing every night merely to keep the wolf from his door. By Chinese standards his income rivals that of any opera singer.
Mr. Mei—whose family name means “peach blossom” and who includes an orchid in his given name— is China’s most famous and beloved actor. Like his father and grandfather before him, he only plays female roles, and while his falsetto might sound strange to Western ears, many foreigners follow him from theater to theater just to see his graceful movements, his unique dancing, or simply the way he uses his beautiful hands. Write the three characters by which he is known on the billboards or in the newspaper ads of any theater, whether in Ch’ien-men or elsewhere in China, and even though he doesn’t need to tour the provinces, the box office manager can just fill any suggestion of empty seats with chairs and sit back completely satisfied. Mei Lan-fang brings his own troupe, like a Spanish bullfighter with his crew, and even his own orchestra. The arrangement of Chinese performances is such that he can perform in several theaters on the same night, perhaps from eleven to midnight inside the Tartar City, where the doors close way too early, and then spend the rest of the night at the more prestigious places outside the main wall. He rarely appears before that, unless it’s for a special matinee in the Forbidden City or at the presidential palace, and he doesn’t have to perform every night just to make ends meet. By Chinese standards, his income is comparable to that of any opera singer.
The Chinese are fond of complications of character in their plays, and some of Mr. Mei’s greatest successes are as a man playing a girl who in turn disguises herself as a man; but there is never a moment in which the basic femininity of the part does not stand clearly forth in the hands of this consummate artist. I had the pleasure of spending an afternoon with him once. His house out in the heart of the Chinese City is outwardly commonplace; but the touch of the genuinely artistic temperament is nowhere missing inside the door. The delicate, almost white-faced man still in his twenties, sometimes looking as if he had barely reached them, proved to be one of the most gracious and at the same time most unobtrusive hosts I have ever met. His manner had 221not a suggestion of the financially successful, the popular idol, as it would manifest itself in the West. He was as simple, as unassuming, as wholly untheatrical as are the objects of Chinese art on which he spends his surplus wealth and time inconspicuous with real distinction. Among his treasures were many thin-paper volumes of classics, of old plays, some of them several centuries old, with annotations in the margins by bygone but not forgotten actors indicating tones, gestures, movements down to the crooking of a little finger. Mr. Mei makes much use of these, though not for slavish imitation. His entourage includes a scholar of standing whose task it is to weave new stories about the old themes, and from them the actor evolves new dances—which is not the word, but let it stand—and new ways of entertaining his crowded audiences without losing touch with the distant centuries to which they prefer to be transported within the theater. Mei Lan-fang does not drink tea on the stage. It is an arrogance of the profession to which his famous family never descended. Nor, one notes, do property-men trip unnecessarily about under his feet when he is performing. I have Mr. Mei’s word for it that the throat does not suffer from the constant unnatural tasks put upon it by his profession; but only from a man of such self-evident truthfulness could I believe it. Certainly there was nothing in his soft home-side speech to belie that surprising statement, as there was nothing in his modest manner to suggest that wherever he plays the streets are filled as far at least as the eye can see by night with waiting rickshaws.
The Chinese enjoy complicated characters in their plays, and some of Mr. Mei’s biggest successes come from playing a girl who then disguises herself as a man; however, there’s never a moment when the fundamental femininity of the role doesn’t shine through in the hands of this skilled artist. I once had the pleasure of spending an afternoon with him. His house in the heart of the Chinese City appears quite ordinary at first glance, but the touch of genuine artistic sensibility is unmistakable inside. The delicate, almost pale-faced man, still in his twenties, sometimes looking even younger, proved to be one of the most gracious and unobtrusive hosts I’ve ever encountered. His demeanor lacked any hint of the typical financially successful or popular idol you might find in the West. He was as simple, unpretentious, and completely untheatrical as the objects of Chinese art in which he invests his extra time and money, standing out with a quiet elegance. Among his treasures were numerous thin-paper volumes of classics and old plays, some dating back several centuries, with annotations in the margins by actors long gone but not forgotten, indicating tones, gestures, and movements down to the crooking of a little finger. Mr. Mei makes good use of these, though not for mindless imitation. His team includes a respected scholar whose job is to create new stories from the old themes, and from these, the actor develops new dances—though that’s not quite the right word, but it'll do—and new ways of entertaining his large audiences without losing connection to the distant centuries they prefer to revisit in the theater. Mei Lan-fang doesn’t drink tea on stage. It’s a professional arrogance that his esteemed family never displayed. Also, one notices that crew members don’t unnecessarily trip around his feet while he’s performing. I have Mr. Mei’s word that his throat doesn’t suffer from the constant unnatural demands of his profession; only someone with such obvious honesty could make me believe that. Certainly, there was nothing in his soft, homey speech to contradict that surprising claim, nor did his modest demeanor suggest that wherever he performs, the streets are filled, at least as far as the eye can see by night, with waiting rickshaws.
Russians have occupied the extreme northeast corner of the Tartar City for centuries. Away back in the reign of K’ang Hsi, to whom all those of the white race were indeed outside barbarians, an army of the czar was defeated in what is now Siberia, and the captives brought to Peking were made into a defense corps after the style of the Manchu-“bannermen.” Gradually the Manchu warriors disappeared from the enclosure that once housed them only, as they grew weak and flabby and penniless under imperial corruption and sold out family by family to the Chinese, until to-day the Tartar City is that merely in name and in memory. But the Russians remain just where the victorious emperor assigned them. Two garish Greek Orthodox structures thrust their domes and spires aloft from within the large walled area which makes that corner of the city somewhat less of an open space given over to garbage-heaps, rag-pickers, and prowling dogs than are the other three. The Son of Heaven was graciously moved to permit his Russian 222bannermen to have their own religious teachers, and the Orthodox priests sent from Russia became not only missionaries to the surrounding “heathen” but the unofficial diplomatic agents of the czar. In time, when the powers saw fit to disabuse the occupant of the dragon throne of the impression that all the rest of the earth was tributary to him, the Russians also established their official minister in the Legation Quarter, with pompous buildings and another Orthodox church within a big compound. To-day, by consent of the Chinese, representatives of the old czarist régime still informally occupy this, while the unrecognized envoy of the Soviet finds his own accommodations, like any other tourist. But the establishment in the further corner of the city survives, boasting not merely a bishop but an archbishop, and numbering by the hundred the Chinese converts clustered in that section.
Russians have occupied the extreme northeast corner of the Tartar City for centuries. Back in the reign of K’ang Hsi, who viewed all white people as outside barbarians, an army of the czar was defeated in what is now Siberia. The captives brought to Peking were made into a defense corps similar to the Manchu “bannermen.” Gradually, the Manchu warriors vanished from the area that once housed them, as they became weak, flabby, and impoverished due to imperial corruption and sold out family by family to the Chinese, until today the Tartar City exists only in name and memory. But the Russians remain exactly where the victorious emperor assigned them. Two bright Greek Orthodox structures rise with their domes and spires from within the large walled area, making that corner of the city somewhat less of a dumping ground filled with garbage, rag-pickers, and stray dogs than the other three corners. The Son of Heaven graciously allowed his Russian bannermen to have their own religious leaders, and the Orthodox priests sent from Russia became not only missionaries to the surrounding “heathen” but also the unofficial diplomatic agents of the czar. Eventually, when the powers decided to correct the occupant of the dragon throne's belief that the entire world owed him tribute, the Russians established their official minister in the Legation Quarter, with grand buildings and another Orthodox church within a large compound. Today, with the consent of the Chinese, representatives of the former czarist regime still informally occupy this area, while the unrecognized envoy of the Soviet finds his own accommodations, like any other tourist. But the establishment in the far corner of the city endures, boasting not only a bishop but an archbishop, and counting the Chinese converts in the hundreds clustered in that section.
A Russian church service with a mainly Chinese congregation is worth going some distance to see. Nowadays the converts hardly outnumber their fellow-worshipers, so many are the destitute Russian refugees who have drifted to that distant northeast corner of Peking. They live thick as prisoners in the stone-walled cells of the old monastery where once only Orthodox monks recited their prayers,—frail women and underfed children as well as men bearing a whole library of strange stories on their gaunt faces. Groups of refugees who came too late or have not influence enough to find room in the cells live packed together in stone cellars, some still wearing the remnants of czarist uniforms, or of the various “White” armies that have gone to pieces before the advancing “Reds,” some still unrecovered from war-time wounds and sundry hardships.
A Russian church service with mainly Chinese attendees is worth the trip to see. These days, the converts barely outnumber their fellow worshipers, thanks to the many destitute Russian refugees who have made their way to that remote northeastern part of Beijing. They live crammed together like prisoners in the old monastery's stone-walled cells, where only Orthodox monks used to pray—fragile women and undernourished children, along with men whose worn faces tell a library's worth of strange stories. Groups of refugees who arrived too late or lack the connections to secure a spot in the cells are packed tightly in stone cellars, some still wearing the tattered remnants of czarist uniforms or the gear from various “White” armies that fell apart before the advancing “Reds,” and some still suffering from wartime injuries and other hardships.
The orchestra which enlivens the nights of the more fortunate foreigners in the frock-coat section of the city huddle together here on improvised beds that would hardly be recognized as such; in these ill smelling dungeons there are men who have not garments enough, even if they had the spirit left, to go forth and look for some possible way out of their present sad dilemma.
The orchestra that brings life to the evenings of the luckier tourists in the frock-coat area of the city gathers here on makeshift beds that barely resemble actual beds; in these foul-smelling dungeons, there are men who lack enough clothing and, even if they had the motivation, wouldn't have the means to seek any possible way out of their current bleak situation.
But one’s sympathy for the dispossessed Russians in China always soon comes to a frayed edge. Their scorn of manual labor even as an alternative to starvation, the unregenerate selfishness of their exiled fellow-countrymen in more fortunate circumstances, their lack of practicality, of plain common sense from the Western point of view, in a word their Orientalism, so out of keeping with their Caucasian exterior, tend to turn compassion to mere condolences which in time fade out to indifference. Perhaps any of us suddenly come down as 223a nation, like a proud sky-scraper unexpectedly collapsing into a chaotic heap of débris, would find ourselves bewildered out of ordinary human intelligence; but it is hard to avoid the impression that these individual weaknesses were there before the debacle, and that they are incurable, at least in the existing generation. A few such enterprises as printing, binding, and leather tanning have been started in the former monastery, but it was noticeable that almost all the actual work was being done by Chinese. Sturdy, even though possibly hungry, young men loafed about their cells and cellars complaining that they could not hire some one to rebuild their simple brick bathing-vat and cooking-stove. Chinese officials, especially of the petty grade, have not been over-kind to the groups of refugees that have fallen into their hands; but they rank at least on a par with the Russian archbishop of Peking, who considers the northeast corner of the city his personal property and demands the abject servility of the Middle Ages toward his exalted person from those of his fellow-countrymen whom he graciously admits to floor-space there in the shadow of his own spacious episcopal residence.
But one’s sympathy for the dispossessed Russians in China quickly wears thin. Their disdain for manual labor, even as a way to avoid starvation, the unrepentant selfishness of their exiled compatriots in better situations, and their lack of practicality and basic common sense from a Western perspective—all of this Orientalism contrasts strangely with their Caucasian appearance, turning compassion into mere condolences that eventually fade into indifference. Anyone of us who suddenly experiences a national collapse, like a proud skyscraper unexpectedly crashing into a chaotic pile of debris, might feel bewildered beyond ordinary human understanding; however, it's hard to shake the feeling that these individual weaknesses existed before the downfall and that they are irreparable, at least in this generation. A few ventures like printing, binding, and leather tanning have been initiated in the former monastery, but it was noticeable that almost all the actual work was being done by Chinese. Strong, even if possibly hungry, young men lounged around their cells and cellars, complaining that they couldn’t find someone to rebuild their simple brick bathing vat and cooking stove. Chinese officials, especially of the lower ranks, haven't been particularly kind to the groups of refugees that have come under their control; but they are at least on par with the Russian archbishop of Peking, who views the northeast corner of the city as his personal property and demands the absolute servitude reminiscent of the Middle Ages from those fellow countrymen he graciously allows to share space there, beneath the shadow of his spacious episcopal residence.
These ostentatious forms of Christianity seem much more in keeping with the Chinese temperament than the austere Protestantism of innumerable sects, which has dotted Peking, as it has all China, with its schools, churches, hospitals, and missions pure and simple. It is not at all hard to find resemblances between the services of the Russians and those in the lama temple a little west of them, in any joss-burning Chinese place of worship, or for that matter between these and high mass at Pei-t’ang to the northwest of the Forbidden City. The Catholics, too, go back for centuries in the life of Peking, to Verbiest and his fellow-Jesuits who served the Sons of Heaven in secular, as well as their subjects in religious, ways.
These flashy forms of Christianity seem to fit the Chinese temperament much better than the strict Protestantism of countless sects, which has scattered schools, churches, hospitals, and straightforward missions throughout Peking and all of China. It's easy to see similarities between the services of the Russians and those in the nearby lama temple, in any Chinese place of worship that involves joss burning, or even with high mass at Pei-t’ang to the northwest of the Forbidden City. The Catholics have also been part of Peking's history for centuries, dating back to Verbiest and his fellow Jesuits who served the Sons of Heaven in both secular and religious capacities.
In the Boxer days Pei-t’ang was scarcely second to the British legation as a place of refuge against the bloodthirsty besiegers; on Easter Sunday, at least, it rivals even in mere picturesqueness any temple in the capital. Red silk interspersed with Maltese crosses in imperial yellow wrapped the pillars; artificial flowers—where real ones are so cheap and so plentiful—added to the Oriental garishness of the interior; the mingled scent of incense and crowded Chinese made the scene impressive not merely to the sight. Mats on the floor held more worshipers than did the benches. The women sat on one side, the flaring white head-dresses of the nuns forming a broad front border to the sea of smooth, oily Chinese coiffures. Near the center hundreds of “orphan” boys in khaki made a great yellow patch. In front, at the foot of the 224choir-stalls backed by the gorgeous altar, the assemblage was gay with French and Belgian officers in full bemedaled uniform, with a scattering of European women—there are other Catholic churches in Peking that are not so far away for most foreigners—their prie-dieus conspicuous in rich silk covers. Even the raised place at one side, theoretically reserved for Caucasians, was crowded with Chinese, hardly a dozen more of whom could have been driven into the church with knouts or bayonets. Yellow faces, high above any casual glance, peered from behind the pipes of the big organ. Chinese acolytes in red wandered to and fro, swinging censers; the music, while not unendurable, was screechy enough to prove the unseen choir of the same race, boys echoing men, with the organ filling in the interstices. Children ran wild among the rather orderless throng; some of the congregation stood throughout the service; large numbers of Chinese men kept their caps on. But a thousand Chinese fervently crossing themselves at the requisite signals from the altar, where two Chinese priests in colorful robes worthy at least a bishop functioned on either side of the white-haired European in archiepiscopal regalia, had about it something no less striking than anything Buddhism has to offer. On week-days old Chinese women, just such bent, shrouded figures as may be seen in any cathedral of Europe, come from the maze of hutungs about Pei-t’ang to bow their heads in silent prayer in its perpetual twilight, with gaudy saints and images of here and there a somewhat Chinese cast of countenance looking down upon them.
In the Boxer Rebellion era, Pei-t’ang was nearly as much of a refuge as the British legation against the brutal attackers; on Easter Sunday, it even rivals the beauty of any temple in the city. Red silk with Maltese crosses in imperial yellow wrapped the pillars; fake flowers—where real ones are cheap and plentiful—added to the colorful extravagance of the interior. The mixed scent of incense and a crowd of Chinese people made the scene impressive beyond just appearance. Mats on the floor accommodated more worshippers than the benches did. Women sat on one side, the bright white head coverings of the nuns creating a clear border to the sea of smooth, shiny Chinese hairstyles. Near the center, hundreds of “orphan” boys in khaki created a large yellow patch. In front, at the foot of the 224 choir stalls backed by the stunning altar, the congregation was lively with French and Belgian officers in full medal-adorned uniforms, along with some European women—there are other Catholic churches in Beijing that are closer for most foreigners—whose prayer desks stood out in rich silk covers. Even the raised area on one side, supposedly reserved for Caucasians, was packed with Chinese, and hardly a dozen more could have been crammed in with whips or bayonets. Yellow faces, well above casual views, peeked from behind the pipes of the large organ. Chinese acolytes in red moved around, swinging incense burners; the music, while tolerable, was screechy enough to reveal the unseen choir—a mix of boys echoing men, with the organ filling the gaps. Children ran around among the chaotic crowd; some in the congregation stood through the entire service; many Chinese men kept their caps on. But a thousand Chinese fervently crossing themselves at the necessary signals from the altar, where two Chinese priests in colorful robes worthy of a bishop served beside the white-haired European in archiepiscopal attire, had an impact that was just as striking as anything in Buddhism. On weekdays, elderly Chinese women, just like the bent, shrouded figures seen in any European cathedral, come from the maze of hutungs around Pei-t’ang to bow their heads in silent prayer in its constant twilight, with vibrant saints and images of somewhat Chinese faces looking down upon them.
Preparations for the Chinese New Year began on the twenty-third of the twelfth moon with the burning of the kitchen god still to be found in nearly every home. Some of our neighbors, especially those whom lack of a courtyard drove out into the hutung for this ceremony, did it half furtively, as if they were pretending, at least when foreigners looked on, that this was only an ordinary wad of waste-paper. But we knew that before he was torn down incense had been burned before the flimsy, smoke-dulled god, with a little straw or kaoliang for the horse that is shown waiting for him, and even our neighbors admitted that they stuck a bit of something sweet on his lips before sending him to heaven, by the fire route, to report on the actions of the family during the year. A little opium serves this purpose still better, or best of all is to dip the whole half-penny lithograph in native wine just before the burning, that the god may be too drowsy or too drunk to tell the truth when he reaches headquarters.
Preparations for the Chinese New Year started on the twenty-third of the twelfth month with the burning of the kitchen god, which is still found in almost every home. Some of our neighbors, especially those without a courtyard who had to step out into the hutung for this ceremony, did it a bit sneakily, as if they were pretending, at least when foreigners were watching, that this was just a regular wad of waste paper. But we knew that before it was torn up, incense was burned in front of the fragile, smoke-stained god, along with a little straw or kaoliang for the horse that's shown waiting for him. Even our neighbors admitted they placed something sweet on his lips before sending him to heaven, via the fire route, to report on the family's actions throughout the year. A little opium works even better, or best of all, is to dip the whole half-penny lithograph in local wine just before burning it, so the god may be too sleepy or too drunk to tell the truth when he arrives at headquarters.

Mei Lan-fang, most famous of Chinese actors, who, like his father and grandfather before him, plays only female parts
Mei Lan-fang, the most famous Chinese actor, who, like his father and grandfather before him, only plays female roles.

In the vast compound of the Altar of Heaven
In the large grounds of the Temple of Heaven

Over the wall from our house, boats plied on the moat separating us from the Chinese City
Over the wall from our house, boats navigated the moat that separated us from the Chinese City.

Just outside the Tartar Wall of Peking the night-soil of the city, brought in wheelbarrows, is dried for use as fertilizer
Just outside the Tartar Wall of Beijing, the city's night soil, brought in wheelbarrows, is dried for use as fertilizer.
225It is a seven-day journey to the Chinese heaven and back, so that people have a little respite from the irksome surveillance of the god of the kitchen. During that week there was a furor of house-cleaning, as the Chinese misunderstand the term; the well-to-do renewed their paper windows; those who could afford it went so far as to have the wooden parts freshly painted. Especially on the last day of the year much shaving, washing, and bathing went on; the baths outside the southern gates of the Tartar City were crowded as they never are at ordinary times, when a two-to-ten copper bath once a month is considered ample. All that last day, too, the chop-a-chop of food, especially of meat dumplings, being prepared for the many guests of the following days, when such work would be taboo, sounded from every house that was not a poor man’s home indeed. Faded old scraps of paper came down everywhere and bright new ones went up, particularly those long upright red slips opposite each door, bearing the four familiar characters for K’ai men chien hsi—“Open door see happiness.” Some of these were put up by the householders themselves, some by poor neighbors who hoped for a slight remembrance from the inmates. One saw them all over China for months afterward. The most miserable little hovels far outside the walls put up new paper gods that made brilliant splashes on doors and mud façades. Perhaps the saddest thing about the Chinese New Year is that all debts are expected to be paid before it breaks, which was particularly hard on what is still recognized abroad as the Chinese Government, months in arrears with every one except its Tuchuns and high employees of special influence. Two men at least I saw next day wandering about with a lantern, a pretense that it is still night and dunning still permissible.
225It's a seven-day trip to Chinese heaven and back, giving people a short break from the annoying watch of the kitchen god. During that week, there was a frenzy of cleaning, as the Chinese interpreted it; the wealthy replaced their paper windows, and those who could afford it even had their wooden parts freshly painted. Especially on New Year's Eve, there was a lot of shaving, washing, and bathing; the baths outside the southern gates of the Tartar City were crowded like never before, when usually a two-to-ten copper bath once a month is considered enough. All that last day, too, the chop-a-chop of food, especially meat dumplings being prepared for the numerous guests in the coming days—when such work would be off-limits—could be heard from every house that wasn't a poor man's home. Faded old scraps of paper came down everywhere and bright new ones went up, particularly the long upright red slips opposite each door that had the four familiar characters for K’ai men chien hsi—“Open door see happiness.” Some of these were put up by the homeowners themselves, while some were posted by poor neighbors hoping for a small gesture of kindness from the residents. You could see them all over China for months afterward. Even the most dilapidated little shacks far outside the walls put up new paper gods that made vibrant additions to their doors and mud façades. Perhaps the saddest thing about the Chinese New Year is that all debts are expected to be settled before it arrives, which was particularly tough on what is still recognized abroad as the Chinese Government, months overdue with everyone except its Tuchuns and high-ranking officials with special influence. I saw at least two men the next day wandering around with a lantern, pretending it's still nighttime and that collecting debts is still okay.
New Year’s day is everybody’s birthday in China; so there is a double reason for new clothes appearing everywhere. Even beggars and rag-pickers seemed to have them, or at least well washed and mended ones, and the populace presented such a sight of approximate cleanliness as it will not until another year rolls by and compels it to change again. A new kitchen god, gaudy on its thin paper, is put up during the first hours of the new year, with a little shrine, and firecrackers and incense welcome him. Firecrackers, indeed, were the most conspicuous part of the celebration. They boomed all night, close under our back walls and all over the city; even “Ha-li” was restless with the incessant uproar. This was partly in honor of the kitchen gods, but largely to frighten off the evil spirits lurking about to contaminate the new year at the start. Among the Chinese there 226was no attempt to sleep that night; even our ama asked permission to go home, and said that she would sit up all night, eating meat dumplings from about two in the morning until daybreak—yet she is a woman of unusual common sense for China, with the utmost scorn for those who still bind their feet.
New Year’s Day is everybody’s birthday in China, so new clothes pop up everywhere for two reasons. Even beggars and rag-pickers seem to have some, or at least well-washed and mended ones, and the people present a level of cleanliness that won’t be seen again until another year rolls around and forces a change. A new kitchen god, flashy on its thin paper, is put up in the early hours of the new year, complete with a little shrine, and firecrackers and incense welcome him. Firecrackers were, in fact, the most noticeable part of the celebration. They boomed all night, right outside our back walls and throughout the city; even “Ha-li” was restless with the nonstop noise. This was partly to honor the kitchen gods, but mostly to scare away the evil spirits that might try to taint the new year from the beginning. Among the Chinese, there was no attempt to sleep that night; even our ama asked to go home, saying she would stay up all night, eating meat dumplings from about two in the morning until dawn—yet she is a woman of uncommon common sense for China, with the utmost disdain for those who still bind their feet.
For the first five days of the new year women are supposed not to leave home or to enter that of another, though in Peking many disobey at least the first half of this ancient rule. The men, on the other hand, go out early and often, not only on the first but on the succeeding days, to call upon all their friends, particularly on the mother-in-law who reigns over each household, to give greetings, and incidentally to fill themselves beyond nature’s intention with meat dumplings. Our teacher was still weary from this ordeal when he again reported for duty. Rachel, however, was strictly enjoined by the ama not to call on a neighbor at whose house she had attended a wedding during the winter; it would be even worse form than not to have a mother-in-law present to receive those who called upon us. As in France, New Year’s is the time for giving presents; no sooner had we distributed a dozen silver dollars in red envelopes among the servants than they despatched the ama to get us presents,—food dainties for us adults, toys for “Ha-li.” Of all the celebration, however, perhaps the detail that looked strangest was to see the shops closed, long row after row of them blank-faced with board shutters where we had never seen them before. Drums and firecrackers sounded inside—some say that gambling goes on apace—whether to scare off devils or merely for the joy of making a noise; probably both motives existed, depending on the individual temperament. Foreigners sometimes accuse the Chinese of laziness because they take as much as a week’s rest at New Year’s, as if this were anything compared with our fifty-two and more holidays a year. Besides, even the shops are in few cases really closed; trust any Chinese merchant not to miss a possible stroke of business. There is almost always a peep-hole, if you know where to look for it, and one man inside who will make a special exception in favor of any one who finds it. Merchants can send their goods to the fairs, anyway; these spring up everywhere, especially in temple grounds, in and outside the city, where every one comes to burn joss-sticks by the bundle, until many a huge urn before the gods runs over with ashes. These are the gayest of markets, with peep-shows, acrobats, coolies, posing for the day as sword-swallowers, story-tellers, and musicians, with amateur and professional theatrical performances indoors and out, with every 227conceivable gambling device, men, women, and children crowded around them, with all manner of playthings for sale,—singing “diavolo” tops reaching almost the size of drums, pink bottles of chianti-shape which reward the blower with a peculiar noise, clusters of toy windmills on one handle that spin in chorus as the holder rides homeward in his rickshaw or his Peking cart, kites of every description, some fully man-size, of bird, beetle, airplane shape. There are no age-limits among the Chinese in the use of New Year’s toys; even solemn old men fly kites all over the city at this season, among the swirls of pigeons following their whistle-bearing leader about the cloudless heavens.
For the first five days of the new year, women are expected to stay at home and not visit others, although in Beijing, many ignore at least the first part of this old tradition. The men, on the other hand, go out early and often, not just on the first day but on the following days as well, to visit friends, especially the mother-in-law who oversees each household, to share greetings and, incidentally, to indulge in meat dumplings. Our teacher was still tired from this tiring experience when he checked back in. However, Rachel was strictly instructed by the ama not to visit a neighbor whose wedding she had attended during the winter; it would be even worse to not have a mother-in-law present to welcome visitors. Like in France, New Year’s is a time for giving gifts; no sooner had we handed out a dozen silver dollars in red envelopes to the servants than they sent the ama to get us gifts—treats for the adults and toys for “Ha-li.” Among all the festivities, perhaps the strange sight was seeing the shops closed, long rows with board shutters where we had never seen them before. Drums and firecrackers could be heard inside—some say that gambling continues—whether to scare away devils or just for the fun of making noise; likely both intentions existed, depending on the person's character. Foreigners sometimes accuse the Chinese of laziness because they take as much as a week off during New Year’s, as if it compares to our fifty-two or more holidays a year. Additionally, even the shops are rarely truly closed; count on any Chinese merchant not to miss a chance for business. There is almost always a peephole, if you know where to look, and one person inside who will make a special exception for anyone who finds it. Merchants can also send their goods to the fairs, which pop up everywhere, especially in temple grounds, both in and outside the city, where everyone comes to burn bundles of joss-sticks until many large urns before the gods overflow with ashes. These are the liveliest markets, featuring peep-shows, acrobats, coolies posing for the day as sword-swallowers, storytellers, and musicians, with amateur and professional performances indoors and out, along with every kind of gambling device, with men, women, and children gathered around them, and all sorts of toys for sale—singing “diavolo” tops nearly the size of drums, pink bottles shaped like Chianti wine that produce a unique noise when blown, clusters of toy windmills on one handle that spin together as the holder rides home in his rickshaw or Peking cart, kites of all types, some as big as a person, shaped like birds, beetles, or airplanes. There are no age restrictions in China regarding New Year’s toys; even serious old men fly kites throughout the city at this time, among the swirls of pigeons following their whistling leader through the cloudless sky.
All this went on for a week or more, though with diminishing ardor; for some soon tire of so long a holiday, and many would starve if they celebrated it all, so that gradually men went back to work, though not a few stuck it out. We hardly noticed a lack of rickshaws even on the first day, and the calls of street-hawkers never completely died out. If our servants went out more than usual we missed none of their usual services, and certainly the cook must have found the markets open. The real New Year’s duty of every Chinese, of course, is to go home, though it be across ten provinces, to put paper “cash,” such as flutter along the route of every funeral, on the graves of his ancestors, and to prepare them special food, preferably duck or chicken, of which they can eat only the “flavor,” leaving three guesses as to what becomes of the rest. Many do go home, but in modern days it is surprising how many find this imperative journey quite impossible. At length the celebration petered out, though crowded carts of people in their best garments could be seen plodding toward the temples outside our East Wall up to the last, and Peking settled down to its industrious seven days a week again.
All of this went on for a week or more, though with less enthusiasm; some people quickly get tired of such a long break, and many would struggle if they celebrated the whole time, so gradually, folks went back to work, although quite a few kept at it. We barely noticed a lack of rickshaws even on the first day, and the shouts of street vendors never completely faded. If our helpers went out more than usual, we didn't miss any of their usual services, and the cook must have found the markets open. The main New Year’s responsibility for every Chinese person, of course, is to return home, even if it’s across ten provinces, to place paper “cash,” like the kind that flutters along funeral routes, on their ancestors' graves, and to prepare special food for them, preferably duck or chicken, of which they can only taste the “flavor,” leaving us with three guesses about what happens to the rest. Many people do go home, but these days it's surprising how many find this necessary journey quite impossible. Eventually, the celebrations faded, although packed carts of people in their best clothes could still be seen making their way to the temples outside our East Wall right until the end, and Peking returned to its hardworking routine of seven days a week once again.
With the republic, China officially adopted the Western calendar, as Japan did long ago; but the masses cling to the old one, with its animal names for the twelve years that are constantly recurring. Like Christianity, the new calendar is considered something foreign, which is quite enough, even leaving the tenacity of old custom aside, to condemn it among many Chinese; and even in official circles the lunar New Year is celebrated more thoroughly than the other. The result is that no government employee has to come to office on the foreign New Year, and no one does on the old one, when even cabinet members go to their ancestral homes or on a spree to Tientsin or Shanghai. Nor is the cult of cyclical animals by any means dead among the Chinese. Almost over our head on the East Wall stand the famous astronomical instruments, 228some of them made by Verbiest himself, which the Germans carried off in 1900 and very recently returned in accordance with a clause in the Treaty of Versailles; and just beyond them is an old temple, the occupants of which include among their duties the annual task of compiling the popular almanac. One may see original or reprinted copies of this everywhere in China, for it is indispensable to the fortuneteller, the geomancer, and all their innumerable ilk, if not to the mass of the people themselves. Here are set forth the lucky and unlucky days for marriages or funerals, for washing the hair, for beginning a new building, for every act of importance in the Chinese daily life. Without it how could match-makers know whether or not the birth-years of possible brides and grooms conflict? Obviously if one was born in the year of the rabbit and the other in that of the dog, or in the years of the tiger and the sheep respectively, the result of an alliance would be a sorry household.
With the establishment of the republic, China officially adopted the Western calendar, similar to what Japan did long ago; however, the general population still holds on to the old calendar, which features animal names for the twelve recurring years. Like Christianity, the new calendar is seen as something foreign, which is enough for many Chinese to reject it, even aside from the strong influence of traditional customs. Even in official circles, the lunar New Year is celebrated more extensively than the Western New Year. As a result, no government employee works on the Western New Year, and no one does on the old one, when even cabinet members return to their ancestral homes or go out to places like Tientsin or Shanghai. The belief in the cyclical animals is certainly not dead among the Chinese. Just above us on the East Wall are the famous astronomical instruments, some made by Verbiest himself, which the Germans took in 1900 and recently returned following a clause in the Treaty of Versailles; and just past them is an old temple where the occupants are responsible for compiling the popular almanac each year. You can find original or reprinted copies of this everywhere in China, as it is essential for fortunetellers, geomancers, and many others, if not for the general public itself. This almanac details the lucky and unlucky days for marriages or funerals, for washing hair, for starting new construction, and for every important action in daily Chinese life. Without it, how would matchmakers determine if the birth years of potential brides and grooms are compatible? Clearly, if one was born in the year of the rabbit and the other in the year of the dog, or in the years of the tiger and the sheep, the outcome of such a union would be a troubled household.
This year the almanac concocted by our priestly neighbors has a pig as “running title” from cover to cover, as well as the frequent recurrence of this motif throughout its pages. For this is the Year of the Pig, which began on our own February 16, and for twelve moons—this year there does not happen to be an intercalary thirteenth—the millions of Mohammedan Chinese must express themselves on that subject by using some such subterfuge as “Black Sheep.” Moreover, it is the end of a cycle of Cathay, the pig being the last of the twelve cyclical animals which pass five times to make such a cycle. This, it seems, presages the worst year of the whole sixty, and the soothsayers enlivened this New Year’s with the most pessimistic predictions. According to the street-side necromancers, who make their livelihood, such as it is, by telling the fortunes of individuals or of nations, much calamity is due China before this Year of the Pig is done. Millions, perhaps, will die of war, pestilence, or famine, or a combination of these—one fellow went so far as to assure his listeners that three fourths of the population of Peking will be wiped out. Great disasters are promised all over the country, particularly in the province of Shensi, which must suffer especially for the privilege of being the birthplace of the next emperor, whom the necromancers assert is already approaching man’s estate there. It is hopeless, therefore, runs the gossip, to expect a settlement of China’s crying difficulties during the twelvemonth of the Pig—some of us wonder if the foreign legations have been imbued with the same spirit. That is the evil of superstitions particularly in a land where the majority is still influenced by 229them; the mere fact that large numbers of people believe all this market-stall nonsense causes at least a psychological depression, and probably increases the likelihood of the beliefs being realized.
This year, the almanac created by our priestly neighbors features a pig as its cover image and has this theme appearing frequently throughout its pages. That’s because it’s the Year of the Pig, which started on February 16. For twelve months—this year there isn’t a thirteenth month—the millions of Muslim Chinese will talk about this using clever phrases like “Black Sheep.” Additionally, it marks the end of a cycle in China, with the pig being the last of the twelve animals that repeat five times to complete the cycle. This is said to foreshadow the worst year of the entire sixty-year cycle, and the fortune-tellers made this New Year’s celebration lively with their most pessimistic predictions. According to street-side fortune tellers, who earn a living telling the fortunes of people or nations, much disaster awaits China before the Year of the Pig is over. Millions may die from war, disease, or famine, or from a combination of these—one person even claimed that three-quarters of the population of Beijing would be wiped out. Great disasters are expected all over the country, especially in the province of Shensi, which is predicted to suffer particularly because it is where the next emperor is supposedly coming of age. Therefore, the gossip goes, there's no hope for resolving China’s pressing issues during this Year of the Pig—some of us wonder if the foreign legations feel the same way. This is the danger of superstitions, especially in a country where most people are still influenced by them; the simple fact that many believe in this market-stall nonsense creates at least a psychological decline and likely increases the chance of these beliefs coming true.
However, these popular oracles go on, after this year conditions will rapidly improve, and it is almost certain that with the new cycle will come a return to order and prosperity. Every friend of China sincerely hopes so, for she certainly needs just that very badly, whether she deserves it or not. No doubt the next cycle of sixty years will bring something of the sort, even though it is difficult to think of China’s calamities abruptly ceasing with this inauspicious porcine year.
However, these popular predictions continue, stating that after this year conditions will quickly get better, and it’s almost guaranteed that with the new cycle will come a return to stability and prosperity. Every supporter of China genuinely hopes so, because she really needs that, whether she deserves it or not. There’s no doubt the next sixty-year cycle will bring some kind of change, even though it’s hard to imagine China’s troubles just ending with this unfortunate Year of the Pig.
There are good as well as unkind things to be said of the Chinese lunar calendar. It is easy, for instance, to tell the time of their month merely by glancing at the sky on any unclouded evening, and no one need ask what day the moon will be full. By the old system of reckoning the Chinese have a whole list of dates fixing changes of weather, and if one year’s experience is a fair test these are more accurate than the prophecies of our highest salaried weather men. Some weeks after the lunar New Year comes the “Stirring of the Insects”; the “Corn Rain” is set for one of the first days of the third moon—that is, late in our April; there are the fixed days of “Sprouting Seeds,” the “Small Heat” and the “Great Heat,” the “Hoar Frost,” the “Cold Dew,” the “Slight Snow” and the “Great Snow”—though the last rarely reaches Peking—and so on around the eternal cycle again. But “Pure Brightness,” otherwise known as Arbor day now, on which the president himself came to plant trees almost next door to us, has come and gone; pengs are springing up everywhere, shading the courtyards, forming whole new roofs and fronts over the better shops, and implying that it is time we were moving on, for the “Great Heat” is no misnomer in Peking.
There are both positive and negative aspects to the Chinese lunar calendar. For example, you can easily tell what phase the month is in just by looking at the sky on any clear evening, and you don't need to ask when the full moon will occur. According to their traditional way of tracking time, the Chinese have a complete list of dates marking changes in the weather, and if one year's experience is a good indicator, these are more accurate than the forecasts from our highest-paid meteorologists. A few weeks after the lunar New Year comes the “Stirring of the Insects”; the “Corn Rain” is expected on one of the first days of the third moon, which is late April for us. There are specific days for “Sprouting Seeds,” “Small Heat,” and “Great Heat,” as well as “Hoar Frost,” “Cold Dew,” “Slight Snow,” and “Great Snow”—though the last one rarely hits Peking—and so on through the eternal cycle again. But “Pure Brightness,” also known as Arbor Day, during which the president came to plant trees almost right next to us, has come and gone; pengs are popping up everywhere, providing shade in the courtyards, forming new roofs and fronts over the better shops, and suggesting that it’s time for us to get moving because the “Great Heat” is no joke in Peking.
CHAPTER XIII
A Trip to Jehol
The Great Wall at its greatest, thirty-odd miles northwest of Peking, with the Ming Tombs thrown in, is well worth the journey, both by train and foot and by airplane—the one in two days and the other in as many hours. There is a Trappist monastery within reach of the capital, and the Western Hills are full of interest to the tramper; in fact merely to name the excursions which the visitor to Peking should not on any reasonable account miss would be to draw up a long list. But there is one of these that had a particular attraction, because it is farther away, over a difficult road devoid of any of the aids of modern times, so ill of repute that certainly not one foreigner in a thousand who comes to Peking ever dreams of really attempting that journey. To cap the climax the Wai-chiao-pu gave official notice just as I was preparing to start that no more permissions to visit that area would be given to foreigners, because it was overrun with bandits. Obviously the antidote of too much comfort and civilization in Peking was the trip to Jehol.
The Great Wall, about thirty miles northwest of Beijing, along with the Ming Tombs, is definitely worth the trip—whether by train, on foot, or by plane—the first taking two days and the last just a few hours. There's a Trappist monastery close to the capital, and the Western Hills are full of interesting spots for hikers. In fact, just naming the excursions that visitors to Beijing shouldn't miss would create a long list. However, one particular trip stands out because it's further away and takes a tough road lacking modern conveniences, so poorly regarded that hardly any foreigner in a thousand visiting Beijing even thinks about attempting it. To top it off, the Wai-chiao-pu officially announced just as I was getting ready to go that they would no longer grant permits for foreigners to visit that area because it was infested with bandits. Clearly, the cure for the excess comfort and civilization in Beijing was the journey to Jehol.
Those who are wise make the outward journey by way of Tung Ling, the Eastern Tombs, thereby doubling the reward. This means that the first stage is to Tungchow, by train or almost any known form of transportation, twelve miles east of the capital, of which it was for centuries the “port.” For it lies on the river that joins the Grand Canal at Tientsin, and the tribute grain from the south was transferred here to narrower canals that brought it to the imperial granaries now falling into ruin almost within a stone’s throw of our Peking home. I might have been disappointed to find the donkeys that had been engaged for me unavailable until next morning if it had not been my good fortune to spend the intervening time with the venerable author of “Chinese Characteristics” and “Village Life in China.” Tungchow itself has nothing unusual to show the visitor of to-day, unless it is that rounded corner of its half-ruined wall. This is a sign of infamy, for it means that some one within was once guilty of the, particularly 231in China, unpardonable crime of patricide. The city which merits four such corners was by imperial law razed to the ground.
Those who are wise take the journey through Tung Ling, the Eastern Tombs, which doubles the reward. This means the first stop is Tungchow, accessible by train or almost any common transportation method, twelve miles east of the capital, which was historically the “port.” It sits on the river that connects to the Grand Canal at Tientsin, where tribute grain from the south was transferred to narrower canals that delivered it to the imperial granaries, now almost in ruins just a short distance from our home in Beijing. I might have been disappointed to find that the donkeys reserved for me wouldn't be available until the next morning, but I was lucky enough to spend the time with the esteemed author of “Chinese Characteristics” and “Village Life in China.” Tungchow itself has nothing notable to show today’s visitors, except perhaps the rounded corner of its half-ruined wall. This is a mark of disgrace, as it indicates that someone inside once committed the particularly unpardonable crime of patricide in China. A city that has four such corners was ordered to be destroyed by imperial decree. 231
Long before dawn, early as that is on the first day of May, the three donkeys reported for duty. They were smaller and leaner than I had hoped, of course, but their owner and driver, deeply pock-marked and already showing the cataract that will in time blind his remaining eye, turned out to be all that a much more exacting traveler could have asked, and a real companion to boot. I wish I could say as much for the “boy” I brought with me from Peking; truth must prevail, however, at all costs. My journey to Jehol was made at a later date than those longer ones subsequently to be chronicled; I had already been eight months in China, entertaining a teacher an hour a day during nearly half that period, and it seemed high time to depend on my own meager knowledge of Mandarin, to make this a kind of test for similar, but more extensive, experiences to come. I had deliberately refused those applicants with a smattering of English, therefore, and hired this single servant for his alleged familiarity with foreign ways, particularly of the kitchen. He might have known even less of what we understand by the word “cleanliness,” for the depths of ignorance in that respect are bottomless in China, and his familiarity was rather of the sort which too indulgent missionaries produce among Chinese of his class. Were the trip to be repeated I would depend upon k’an-lü-di, my companionable “watch-donkey-er” from Tungchow, to do the swearing and bring me boiled water at the inns, and do the rest myself. But at least the “boy” spoke only the tongue of Peking, and from Tungchow back to the capital I had the advantage of hearing not a word of any other except from the two British families in Jehol itself.
Long before dawn, which comes early on May 1st, the three donkeys showed up for duty. They were smaller and skinnier than I had hoped, but their owner and driver, who was deeply pockmarked and already showing signs of cataracts that would eventually blind his remaining eye, turned out to be everything a more demanding traveler could have wished for, and a true companion as well. I wish I could say the same about the “boy” I brought with me from Peking; I have to be honest, though, no matter what. My journey to Jehol happened later than the longer journeys I’ll eventually recount; I had already spent eight months in China, during which I entertained a teacher for an hour a day nearly half of that time, and it felt like it was time to rely on my limited knowledge of Mandarin as a sort of test for the more extensive experiences to come. I had purposely turned down applicants who had a little bit of English and hired this one servant for his supposed familiarity with foreign customs, especially in the kitchen. He might have known even less about what we think of as “cleanliness,” as ignorance on that front runs deep in China, and his experience was more like what overly lenient missionaries create among Chinese of his background. If I were to make the trip again, I would rely on k’an-lü-di, my friendly “watch-donkey-er” from Tungchow, to handle the complaints and get me boiled water at the inns, while I took care of everything else. But at least the “boy” spoke only the Peking dialect, and from Tungchow back to the capital, I had the advantage of not hearing a word of anything else except from the two British families in Jehol itself.
We were crossing the river by chaotic poled ferry by the time the sun was fully up, and jogging away across a floor-flat, fertile plain, intensely cultivated yet almost desert brown, like so much of northern China except at the height of summer, before the first of the many towns along the way was fully astir. It was manure strewing time, and the season when the peasants of Chihli patiently break up the too dry clods of earth covering their little fields by beating them with the back of a Homeric hoe or dragging a stone roller over them by boy-, man-, or donkey-power. Others were hoeing the winter wheat, growing in rows two feet apart, but with kaoliang already sprouting like beans or radishes between them, which it was hard to realize would be above a horseman’s head by August. Green onions enough to have fed a modern army went balancing by from the shoulder-poles of coolies 232passing in both directions. It is as incomprehensible to the mere Westerner why identical produce must change places all over China as it was to understand why onions grown at least to boy’s estate would not be better in a perpetually hungry land than these tiny bulbless ones. But the scent of young onions was seldom absent during our first two days, on which we ran the gauntlet every few hours of a market-town green from end to end with them. Next in number were the coolies carrying two low flat baskets with open-work covers through which could be seen hundreds of fluffy, peeping chicks being peddled about the country. The rare trees were decked out in new leaves; far as the eye could strain itself the brown, sea-flat earth was being prodded to do its best for countless, already sun-browned tillers.
We were crossing the river on a chaotic pole ferry by the time the sun was fully up, and jogging across a flat, fertile plain, intensely cultivated yet almost desert brown, like much of northern China except in the height of summer, before the first of the many towns along the way was fully awake. It was time to spread manure, and the season when the peasants of Chihli patiently broke up the too-dry clods of earth on their small fields by beating them with the back of a large hoe or dragging a stone roller over them with the help of boys, men, or donkeys. Others were hoeing the winter wheat, which grew in rows two feet apart, but with kaoliang already sprouting like beans or radishes between them, which it was hard to believe would reach above a horseman’s head by August. There were enough green onions being carried by coolies to feed a modern army, balanced on their shoulder poles as they passed in both directions. It is just as confusing to a typical Westerner why the same produce has to swap places all over China as it is to understand why onions that were at least the size of a boy wouldn’t be better in a perpetually hungry land than these tiny, bulbless ones. But the scent of young onions was rarely absent during our first two days, during which we passed through market towns filled with them every few hours. Next in number were the coolies carrying two low, flat baskets with openwork covers through which hundreds of fluffy, peeping chicks could be seen being sold around the country. The rare trees were adorned with new leaves; as far as the eye could see, the brown, flat earth was being prodded to do its best for countless, already sun-browned farmers.
At the unprepossessing country town where we spent the night my “boy” came in with a horrified look on his face to report that the innkeeper wanted sixty coppers, which is fully fifteen cents in real money, for the two good-sized rooms, new and well papered, extraordinarily clean for China, which the three of us occupied. A chicken, too, cost a hundred coppers, whereas in Peking it was only seventy! I gave outward evidence of horror at this incredible state of affairs, lest the opposite bring the impression that the customary “squeeze” might be doubled with impunity, and then advised payment rather than a dispute on this, our first day out. Perhaps it was the painful price of chickens that made the town willing to consume some of the things it does, though I believe the same omnivorous tendency prevails throughout this overpeopled country. The squeamish, by the way, should skip the next few lines; but one cannot always be nice and still tell the truth about China.
At the plain country town where we spent the night, my “boy” came in with a horrified look on his face to report that the innkeeper wanted sixty copper coins, which is about fifteen cents in real money, for the two good-sized rooms—new, well-decorated, and surprisingly clean for China—that the three of us stayed in. A chicken also cost a hundred coppers, while in Beijing it was only seventy! I showed my shock at this unbelievable situation to avoid giving the impression that the usual “squeeze” could be doubled without consequence, and then suggested we pay rather than argue about it on our first day out. Maybe it was the ridiculous price of chickens that made the town willing to accept some of the things it does, although I think this insatiable tendency is common throughout this overpopulated country. By the way, the squeamish should skip the next few lines; but one can’t always be polite and still tell the truth about China.
A camel bound to Peking with a train of his fellows had died just in front of our inn. The townsman to whom the carcass had evidently been sold made a deep cut in the throat and then with his several helpers proceeded to dismember it. When I stepped out into the street again soon after dark everything except the head, the tail, and the four great padded feet, cut off at the knees, had been sold as food to the villagers. The hide and these odds and ends were evidently to yield their portion of nourishment also, for they were carried into a neighboring kitchen, while two other men went on disentangling the heaped-up intestines, carefully preserving their contents as fertilizer and to all appearances planning to use the entrails themselves as food.
A camel heading to Beijing with a group of others had died right in front of our inn. The local man who had apparently bought the carcass made a deep cut in its throat and then, along with several helpers, started to dismember it. When I stepped back out into the street shortly after dark, everything except the head, the tail, and the four large padded feet, which were cut off at the knees, had been sold as food to the villagers. The hide and these leftover parts were clearly meant to provide some nourishment too, as they were taken into a nearby kitchen, while two other men continued to sort through the piled-up intestines, carefully saving their contents as fertilizer and seemingly planning to use the entrails as food as well.
There was double excitement in the town that evening, triple, counting the foreigner, a date to be long remembered. Down the road a 233little way from the disgusting front of the inn there was a theatrical performance, not of flesh-and-blood actors, but what might be called a shadow-show. Stage “music” in the Chinese sense was drawing the whole town, less the camel carvers, thither; women hurried slowly through the dust on their crippled feet; the younger generation, with the usual Chinese redundancy of boys, swarmed; staid old men took their own chairs—that is, wooden saw-horses six inches wide—with them. The theater, which had been thrown up that afternoon in a corner of the highway, was little more than a crude platform on poles, partly walled and roofed with pieces of cloth. But it was a complete stage, almost better than a real one, in fact, for there was about it a certain hazy atmosphere of romance that is impossible in the matter-of-fact presence of mere human actors. There were even actual fights on horseback, which the real stage can only pretend by symbols to give; thrones, city gates, battles, petitioners, men shaking their spears and themselves with rage at one another, all the scenes with which the theater-goer in Peking is familiar, and more, were there. Nor was speech lacking; these shadowy personages expressed themselves in the same classical falsetto as do Mei Lan-fang and his colleagues.
There was double the excitement in town that evening, even triple if you counted the foreigner, making it a night to remember. Down the road a bit from the unpleasant front of the inn, there was a performance, not featuring real actors, but what could be called a shadow show. The “music” in the Chinese sense was attracting the whole town, except for the camel carvers; women made their way slowly through the dust on their worn-out feet; the younger crowd, usually full of boys, was everywhere; and the older men brought their own chairs—wooden saw-horses just six inches wide—with them. The theater, set up that afternoon in a corner of the road, was little more than a rough platform on poles, partially walled and covered with bits of cloth. But it was a complete stage, almost better than a real one, actually, because it held a certain hazy romantic vibe that just isn’t possible with ordinary human actors. There were even real horseback fights, something the actual stage can only hint at; thrones, city gates, battles, petitioners, men shaking their spears in rage at each other—all the scenes that theater-goers in Beijing are familiar with, and more, were present. And there was no shortage of dialogue; these shadowy figures spoke in the same classical falsetto as Mei Lan-fang and his colleagues.
When I had mingled for a time with the audience that crowded a whole section of the moon-flooded roadway, interspersed with the inevitable hawkers of everything consumable under the circumstances, I went around behind the scenes to see how these results were achieved with such slight apparatus. You can always look behind the scenes in China without arousing a protest, though you may not be any the wiser for doing so. A flock of boys were hanging about on the pole structure, wholly open at the back, the three showmen appearing to be quite unconscious of them so long as they did not physically cramp their elbows. These men produced their results with a black curtain, three kerosene lamps a foot or more back of it, and a confusion of little colored figures hanging on either side in what might be called the wings. Wearing as bored an expression as any property-man on a real Chinese stage, the showmen picked these figures down as they were needed and flourished them along between the lights and the curtain. To each figure was attached a handle long enough to keep the hand of the holder out of sight from the audience, and as the gaudy, flimsy little manikins dashed and pranced and waddled to and fro, according to their individual temperaments and their momentary emotions, the bored manipulators poured forth the story in the awful voice of the Chinese actor. That was all; yet the whole town stood or sat enthralled 234by the performance, and I could hear the falsetto far away in the moonlight until I fell asleep.
When I had spent some time with the crowd gathered on the moonlit road, filled with all kinds of sellers hawking their wares, I decided to check out what was happening behind the scenes to see how they created such effects with minimal equipment. You can always sneak a peek behind the scenes in China without causing any fuss, though it might not always give you clearer insight. A group of boys were hanging around on the open-back stage structure, while the three performers seemed totally unaware of them as long as they didn’t crowd their space. These men created their acts using a black curtain, three kerosene lamps set a foot or so behind it, and a jumble of colorful figures hanging on either side in what could be considered the wings. With a bored expression like any stagehand on a genuine Chinese stage, the performers took down the figures as needed, skillfully moving them between the lights and the curtain. Each figure had a handle long enough to keep the holder's hand hidden from the audience, and as the bright, flimsy little figures danced and moved back and forth according to their personalities and moods, the uninterested manipulators narrated the story in the dramatic voice typical of a Chinese actor. That was it; still, the whole town was captivated by the show, and I could hear the high-pitched voice drifting in the moonlight until I fell asleep. 234
Beyond Manchow next afternoon cultivation thinned out and bare mountains grew up on the horizon, while round stones of all sizes became incessant underfoot. Walking had really been easier than bestriding my little white donkey, but I had soon found it sympathy wasted to try to make life easier for him. Your Chinese donkeyteer does not believe in letting his animals grow fat with ease, and never did I look around a moment after slipping off the padded back of my hip-high mount that his owner was not already swinging his toes along one or the other side of him. The other two donkeys, bearing our belongings and my “boy” respectively, had, of course, even less respite. Incredible little beasts! Subsisting on a little of nothing and still able to jog incessantly and indefinitely on under loads of almost their own weight, they are the true helpmeets of the industrious, ill fed Chinese countryman.
Beyond Manchow the next afternoon, the cultivation thinned out and bare mountains rose on the horizon, while round stones of all sizes became a constant nuisance underfoot. Walking was actually easier than riding my little white donkey, but I quickly realized it was pointless to make things easier for him. Your Chinese donkey driver doesn’t believe in letting his animals get lazy, and I could never look around for a second after hopping off the padded back of my hip-high mount without seeing his owner already swinging his feet along one side or the other. The other two donkeys, carrying our stuff and my “boy” respectively, of course, had even less downtime. Incredible little creatures! Living on almost nothing and still able to jog nonstop and endlessly under loads that were nearly their own weight, they are the true companions of the hard-working, poorly-fed Chinese farmer.
The usual time from Tungchow to Malanyü is three days, but we had gotten an excellent start each morning and a bit of pressure induced the k’an-lü-di to push on past what most travelers to the Eastern Tombs make their second stopping-place. A gate in the mountains that might almost have been cut by hand rather than by the river that even in this dry season filled all of it except a stony bank, crowded now with cattle and flocks of goats making their way westward, let us out at sunset upon an enormous plain completely enclosed in an amphitheater of high hills. Across this, through the evergreen trees that thickened farther on into an immense forest, we saw far ahead the first tomb of Tung Ling, a golden-yellow roof standing well above the highest tree-tops. For nearly two hours we plodded on among venerable pines that in China at least were thick enough to merit the name of forest, amid scents that are all too rare in that denuded land, foot-travelers to and from the various tomb-guarding villages growing numerous and then thinning out again before we sighted at last the dim lights and aroused the barking dogs of Malanyü. The yard of its best inn was noisy with eating animals, tinkling mule-bells, and the drivers, dogs, and roosters that always make night hideous in such a place, while the best room facing it would hardly be mistaken in any Western land for a human habitation. But that is what the traveler in China expects in almost any town off the railroads where there are no foreigners to offer him 235hospitality. At least, if accommodations are not princely, neither are the charges.
The usual travel time from Tungchow to Malanyü is three days, but we started off strong each morning, and a bit of urgency pushed the k’an-lü-di to move on past what most travelers to the Eastern Tombs usually consider their second stop. A gate in the mountains that seemed almost hand-carved rather than shaped by the river, which even in this dry season filled everything except a rocky bank packed with cattle and flocks of goats heading west, opened for us at sunset onto a vast plain surrounded by tall hills. Across this plain, through evergreen trees that thickened into a massive forest ahead, we saw in the distance the first tomb of Tung Ling, its golden-yellow roof towering above the tallest tree tops. For nearly two hours, we trudged through ancient pines that, at least in China, were dense enough to be called a forest, surrounded by scents that are all too rare in that stripped land, with foot travelers to and from the various tomb-guarding villages becoming numerous and then dwindling again before we finally spotted the dim lights and stirred the barking dogs of Malanyü. The yard of its best inn was filled with noisy animals, tinkling mule bells, and the drivers, dogs, and roosters that always make the night so lively in such places, while the best room facing it would hardly be recognized in any Western country as a human dwelling. But that's what a traveler in China expects in almost any town off the railroads where there are no foreigners to provide him accommodations. At least, if the lodgings aren't luxurious, the prices are reasonable.
While the donkeys drowsed through a well earned but unexpected holiday, I spent half the morning, with the “boy” trailing me, chasing the man who could open the tomb doors for me. Even with two tissue-paper documents daubed with red characters from men of standing in Peking local permission was not easily forthcoming. First there was a hot and dusty ten-li walk to the little garrison town of Malanchen on the very edge of intramural China, where the commander commonly reputed to be stationed in Malanyü read and retained my letters, offered tea, and at length sent a soldier back to the city with us with orders to run to earth the chief keeper of the tombs. He was not easily found and he in turn had to run to earth several subordinates, each of whom lived far up labyrinthian alleyways in the utmost corners of town, and when at length we shook off the throng that kicks up the dust at the heels of any foreigner so bold as to step off the beaten path of his fellows in China, there was still an hour’s tramp back through the thin evergreen forest to the tombs themselves.
While the donkeys enjoyed a well-deserved but unexpected break, I spent half the morning, with the “boy” following me, looking for the man who could open the tomb doors for me. Even with two fragile documents covered in red characters from respected officials in Peking, local permission was hard to get. First, there was a hot and dusty ten-li walk to the small garrison town of Malanchen, right on the edge of intramural China, where the commander, commonly believed to be stationed in Malanyü, read and kept my letters, offered tea, and eventually sent a soldier back to the city with us with orders to track down the chief keeper of the tombs. He was hard to find, and he, in turn, had to find several subordinates, each living deep in the winding alleys in the far corners of town. After we finally shook off the crowd that kicks up dust behind any foreigner bold enough to stray from the well-trodden path in China, there was still an hour’s hike back through the sparse evergreen forest to the tombs themselves.
Though it should be funereal, Tung Ling is one of the most delightful spots in North China, almost atoning for the wastefulness of its two hundred square miles given over to nine tombs. The soughing of the breeze and the singing of the few birds in the scattered but extensive evergreen forest were joys that one almost forgets in this bare land; for China there were comparatively few people within the enclosure, though trail-roads wandered away in all directions among the trees, with donkey-bells tinkling off into the distance; it was particularly a joy to leave even the trails and walk on grass again, strolling at random on and on, to climb the hills, though this is technically forbidden, since the living commonalty should not look down upon the illustrious dead. Whatever they may not have done for their subjects the Sons of Heaven were experts in choosing their last resting-places.
Though it should feel like a place of mourning, Tung Ling is one of the most charming spots in North China, almost making up for the waste of its two hundred square miles occupied by nine tombs. The gentle breeze and the songs of the few birds in the scattered but expansive evergreen forest are pleasures that one almost forgets in this barren land; there were relatively few people present in the area, yet paths meandered in all directions among the trees, with the sound of donkey bells fading into the distance. It was especially delightful to leave even the paths and walk on the grass again, wandering freely and climbing the hills, even though this is technically not allowed, as the living should not overlook the revered dead. Regardless of what they may not have done for their subjects, the Sons of Heaven were skilled at choosing their final resting places.
There was no roaming at will, however, until I had shaken off the procession of keepers and hangers-on whose duty, curiosity, or suspicion did not begin to flag until well on in the afternoon. It is a serious matter to protect an emperor and his consorts even centuries after their death. Every one of the nine tombs of Tung Ling has a walled town in which its guardians and their families, all Manchus, of course, live to the number certainly of several hundred each, if not of more than a thousand. Their support devolves upon the Chinese people, 236through the Government which guarantees, even though it does not fulfil its promises, the upkeep of the tombs, as well as of the survivors, of the Ch’ing dynasty. Before each tomb, which is no mere mausoleum in the Occidental sense but an enclosure many acres in extent, quite aside from the great wooded tract surrounding it, where half a dozen great buildings and a flock of small ones have ample elbow-room, stands a keepers’ lodge. From this, blackened with the smoke of generations of cooking and tea-brewing, emerge as many as a dozen idlers whose sole duty in life is to see that no unauthorized disturbance troubles the royal dead within. No one of these guards is intrusted with power enough to open the tomb alone; there are things inside that would bring pilferers several Chinese fortunes. When the authorized visitor—or, one very strongly suspects, any other capable of clinking silver—appears, shouts arise in the lodge and its vicinity until at length men enough are awakened from their perpetual siestas to make entrance possible. This requires from four to six, sometimes more, bunches of mammoth keys, each of which is in the personal keeping of a single individual or, since man must sleep, a pair of them. When at length the whole unshaven group is assembled, a pair of ordinary coolies is also needed to bring a step-ladder, since the tomb doors are trebly secured with enormous padlocks at top and bottom in addition to the great bolts operated through the ordinary keyholes. The keys of Chinese tombs, by the way, do not turn; they merely push open the crude yet complicated locks. There are often several such doors to be passed, so that the time required to gain admission is much more than the average visitor cares to spend inside.
There was no wandering freely until I managed to ditch the crowd of keepers and hangers-on whose duty, curiosity, or suspicion didn’t start to fade until later in the afternoon. It's a serious task to protect an emperor and his family, even centuries after their deaths. Each of the nine tombs of Tung Ling has a walled town where its guardians and their families, all Manchus, live in numbers certainly reaching several hundred, if not more than a thousand. Their support falls on the Chinese people, 236 through the Government, which guarantees, even though it doesn't always keep its promises, the maintenance of the tombs and the surviving members of the Ch’ing dynasty. In front of each tomb, which is not just a simple mausoleum like those in the West but a large enclosure spanning many acres, aside from the vast wooded area surrounding it, where several large buildings and a bunch of smaller ones have plenty of space, stands a keeper's lodge. From this lodge, blackened with the smoke of generations of cooking and tea-making, emerge as many as a dozen idlers whose only job is to ensure that no unauthorized disturbances disrupt the royal dead inside. None of these guards has enough authority to open the tomb alone; there are valuable items inside that could fetch thieves several fortunes. When an authorized visitor—or, as one could strongly suspect, anyone jingling silver—shows up, shouts echo from the lodge and its surroundings until enough men are stirred from their constant naps to make entry possible. This requires from four to six, sometimes more, huge bunches of keys, each held by one person or, since people need sleep, a pair of them. Once the whole unshaven group is gathered, a couple of ordinary laborers are also needed to bring a step-ladder, since the tomb doors are secured with massive padlocks at both the top and bottom, in addition to the large bolts operated via standard keyholes. By the way, the keys to Chinese tombs don’t turn; they merely push open the rough yet complex locks. There are often several such doors to get through, making the time it takes to gain entrance much longer than the average visitor wants to spend inside.
Fortunately there is really nothing to be gained by having oneself let into more than two of the nine tombs of Tung Ling. The others are so much like these that a passing glimpse is enough. After all, it is the great wooded amphitheater itself, backed by the magnificent sky-line of mountains, and the exterior vista of the tombs, towering in imperial yellow high above not only the towns of their guardians but the enclosing forest itself, that is worth coming so far to see. Besides, by the time one has distributed fees among all the hangers-on of two tombs, and satisfied the flock of attendants who have insisted on coming all the way from town with him, there is another good reason for being content with the exteriors of the others.
Fortunately, there really isn't much to gain from seeing more than two of the nine tombs of Tung Ling. The others are so similar that a quick look is enough. After all, it's the grand wooded amphitheater itself, framed by the stunning mountain skyline, and the view of the tombs, rising in imperial yellow high above not only the towns of their guardians but also the surrounding forest, that makes the journey worthwhile. Plus, by the time you've paid the fees to all the people hanging around two tombs and satisfied the group of attendants who've insisted on traveling all the way from town with you, there’s another good reason to be happy with just the exteriors of the others.
The oldest and the newest are most worth admission, the beginning and the end of the Manchu dynasty as far as Lung Ling is concerned. K’ang Hsi, second of the Ch’ing line, has a fitting mausoleum, its 237approach flanked by mammoth stone figures not unlike those of the Mings, and the softening hand of time has added much, for it is just two centuries since the occupant went in quest of his ancestors. But the most magnificent of the Eastern Tombs, perhaps the finest one in all tomb-ridden China, is more than the world at large would have awarded the notorious old lady who lives within, for she is none other than Tsu Hsi or Tai Ho, known to the West as the Empress Dowager, moving spirit of the Boxer uprising and the greatest single cause of the downfall of the Manchu dynasty. Within the spirit chamber of K’ang Hsi there are five chairs draped in imperial yellow silk, for his four concubines stick by him even in death; but it is quite what one would expect to find the famous Dowager alone in all her glory. For while she had a husband once, who is also buried at Tung Ling, he was of small importance by the time she relieved China of her earthly presence, three years before the downfall of the Manchus, whatever he may have been as Emperor half a century before. Even starting as a mere concubine, Tsu Hsi needed no husband to make herself an empress in fact if not in name. An identical tomb, which the caretakers asserted is that of her sister, stands close beside that of Tai Ho, with a low wall between them; but in her magnificent throne-room there is no suggestion of rivalry. Of the richness of this interior, its walls and ceilings decorated in many colors with innumerable figures large and tiny of the most intricate form, great bronze dragons climbing the huge pillars; of a thousand details, artistic withal, which mean nothing to us of the West but much to the Chinese, words would give but little impression.
The oldest and the newest are the ones most worth visiting, marking the beginning and the end of the Manchu dynasty as far as Lung Ling is concerned. K’ang Hsi, the second in the Ch’ing line, has an impressive mausoleum, its entrance flanked by enormous stone figures reminiscent of those from the Ming dynasty. The softening passage of time has also contributed much, given that it was only two centuries ago that he sought out his ancestors. However, the most impressive of the Eastern Tombs—perhaps the finest in all of tomb-laden China—is more than the world would generally attribute to the infamous old lady residing within, who is none other than Tsu Hsi or Tai Ho, known in the West as the Empress Dowager, the driving force behind the Boxer Rebellion and a major reason for the Manchu dynasty's fall. Inside the spirit chamber of K’ang Hsi are five chairs draped in imperial yellow silk, as his four concubines remain loyal to him even in death; yet, it’s perfectly expected to find the renowned Dowager alone in all her splendor. While she once had a husband, who is also buried at Tung Ling, he held little significance by the time she departed from this world, three years before the end of the Manchus, regardless of his earlier status as Emperor half a century prior. Even starting out as just a concubine, Tsu Hsi needed no husband to effectively become an empress, if not in name. A similar tomb, which the caretakers claim is her sister's, stands right next to Tai Ho's, separated by a low wall; but in her grand throne room, there's no hint of rivalry. The richness of this interior, with its walls and ceilings adorned in vibrant colors featuring countless intricate figures, and great bronze dragons climbing the massive pillars, along with a thousand artistic details that hold little meaning for us in the West but much for the Chinese, defies description.
I had a note of introduction to the head-man of the Manchu village that watches over the Dowager’s tomb. Within its brick wall the populous hamlet was much like any other Chinese town of like size, rather overrun with pigs and children, crumbling away here and there with poverty or inattention, careless in sanitary matters. Few heads of many times greater cities of the Occident, however, could have received a chance visitor with the perfect grace, the prodigal-son cordiality quite devoid of any hint of dissimulation, of the Manchu with whom I was soon sitting at a little foot-high k’ang table laden with Chinese dainties, sipping tea and struggling to express in my scanty mandarin a few thoughts above the eating and sleeping level. As luck would have it the family, which with its ramifications seemed to number at least a hundred, with children for every month as far back as months go, was celebrating the birthday of the mother-in-law. In China only those 238who have reached a respectful old age commemorate their individual birthdays—and they receive many toys among their presents. Over the outer entrance to the rambling collection of houses hung two immense flags, not the dragon banner of the Manchus but the five-bar one of the Chinese Republic. Back in the innermost courtyard the old lady, of a charming yet authoritative manner which attested to long years of efficient rule over the household, was surrounded by all the female members of the family, decked out in their holiday best. The finest silks covered them from neck to ankles—trousers, like bound feet, are for Chinese women—the elaborate Manchu head-dress was made more so by immense and tiny flowers added to it in honor of the occasion, and the faces of the young women were painted with white and red, as formal occasions demand, until they looked like enameled masks. Several of these were evidently the wives of my polished host, and when I asked permission to photograph one of them alone for the details of the gala costume there was no hesitation as to which one it should be: though she was probably the youngest of them all, and for that reason almost obsequious toward the others, she had born her master a son, who must also be included in the picture. Women and men were constantly coming to bend the knee or kowtow to the lady of the occasion, according to their rank. The men with few exceptions wore the complete Manchu court costume, including the inverted-bowl straw hat covered with loose red cords, with various individual decorations. When I at last succeeded in taking my leave without causing a sense of discourtesy, my host insisted that my “boy” carry away for me, in honor of the felicitous occasion, a big box of dien-hsin, assorted Chinese cakes that lasted all three of us the rest of the outward journey.
I had an introduction note for the leader of the Manchu village that oversees the Dowager’s tomb. Inside its brick walls, the bustling community looked like any other small Chinese town—somewhat overrun with pigs and children, showing signs of wear and tear from poverty and neglect, and not particularly careful about hygiene. However, I doubt that many leaders of much larger cities in the West could have welcomed a passing visitor with the genuine grace and heartfelt hospitality of the Manchu man I soon found myself sitting with at a little foot-high k’ang table filled with Chinese delicacies, sipping tea and trying to express some thoughts beyond just basic necessities in my limited Mandarin. As luck would have it, this family, which seemed to branch out to at least a hundred members with children born every month for as long as anyone could remember, was celebrating the mother-in-law’s birthday. In China, only those who have reached a respectable old age celebrate their individual birthdays—and they receive many toys among their gifts. Over the outer entrance to the sprawling collection of houses, two large flags hung—not the dragon banner of the Manchus, but the five-striped one of the Chinese Republic. In the innermost courtyard, the elderly lady, charming yet authoritative, showing years of effective management over the household, was surrounded by all the female family members, dressed in their best holiday attire. They were covered in the finest silks from neck to ankles—Chinese women wear trousers, much like bound feet—the intricate Manchu headdresses adorned with both large and small flowers for the occasion, and the faces of the young women painted in white and red, as is customary for formal events, making them look like enameled masks. Some of them were clearly the wives of my gracious host, and when I asked to take a photo of one of them to capture the details of the festive costume, there was no doubt about which one it would be: although she was probably the youngest, and nearly subservient to the others for that reason, she had borne her master a son, who had to be included in the picture. Women and men were continually coming to bow or kowtow to the lady being honored, depending on their rank. The men, with few exceptions, wore the full Manchu court attire, complete with the inverted-bowl straw hat adorned with loose red cords and various personal decorations. Eventually, when I managed to take my leave without appearing rude, my host insisted that my “boy” take away a large box of dien-hsin, assorted Chinese cakes in honor of the festive occasion, enough for all three of us to enjoy for the remainder of our trip.
There seems to be no ill feeling between the two peoples populating Tung Ling and the vicinity, if indeed they themselves recognize any real dividing-line. In large numbers congregated together one could see a difference between the Manchus and the Chinese; the keepers of the Eastern Tombs were slightly larger, stronger-looking men, a trifle less abject in their manner, than the people about them, a kind of half-way type between the Chinese and the Mongols. The older and poorer of them still wore their cues; the rest had sacrificed to the republic a badge of nationality the origin of which is lost in the prehistoric mists, as the subjected Chinese adopted it three centuries ago at the behest of their Manchu conquerors.
There doesn't seem to be any bad blood between the two groups living in Tung Ling and the surrounding area, if they even recognize any real divide. When gathered in large numbers, you could see a difference between the Manchus and the Chinese; the caretakers of the Eastern Tombs were slightly taller, stronger-looking men, a little less submissive in their behavior compared to those around them, a kind of in-between type between the Chinese and the Mongols. The older and poorer among them still wore their traditional queues; the rest had given up a symbol of nationality, the origin of which is lost in the prehistoric past, as the subjugated Chinese adopted it three centuries ago at the demand of their Manchu conquerors.
239Early next morning we left the inn laboring under the impression that we were returning to Peking, skirted the garrison town by unfrequented paths, and were soon outside the Great Wall, one of the passes of which Malanchen straddles and guards. I had warned my companions not to mention the final goal of our journey, lest the newly promulgated order be cited as an excuse for turning me back, which would also mean the abrupt ending of their jobs. Apparently they succeeded in performing the un-Chinese feat of keeping their mouths shut, for no one came to interfere with my plans. The wall at Malanchen was grass-grown, smaller, and in greater disrepair than at Nankow Pass, where most foreigners see it, even less imposing than where it descends to the sea at Shanhaikwan. Geographically we had passed from China proper into Inner Mongolia, and as if to mark the change the soft level going turned almost instantly to stony uplands that became foot-hills, swelling into veritable mountains so suddenly that all six of us were panting for breath on all but perpendicular slopes scarcely an hour after setting out across the plain now far below. For centuries these mountain ranges behind Tung Ling were an imperial reserve, densely forested and inviolate, meant to preserve the feng-shui of the Eastern Tombs, to protect them from evil influences, which in China always come from the north. The republic, however, opened this great uninhabited region to settlers, with the result that here there may still be seen sights utterly unknown in the rest of China, pioneering conditions completely out of place in that densely populated, intensively cultivated land, and at the same time a demonstration of what must have happened many centuries ago on an infinitely larger scale to make North China the dust-blown, denuded area it is to-day.
239Early the next morning, we left the inn thinking we were heading back to Peking, took less-traveled paths around the garrison town, and soon found ourselves outside the Great Wall, one of the passes of which Malanchen straddles and guards. I had warned my companions not to mention the final destination of our journey, so that the newly issued order wouldn’t be used as an excuse to turn me back, which would also mean the sudden end of their jobs. It seems they managed the un-Chinese task of keeping quiet, since no one interrupted my plans. The wall at Malanchen was overgrown with grass, smaller, and in worse shape than at Nankow Pass, where most foreigners see it, and even less impressive than where it meets the sea at Shanhaikwan. Geographically, we had moved from China proper into Inner Mongolia, and as if to highlight this change, the smooth, flat ground quickly turned into rocky uplands that became foothills, rising into actual mountains so suddenly that all six of us were gasping for air on nearly vertical slopes less than an hour after we started across the plain now far below. For centuries, these mountain ranges behind Tung Ling were an imperial reserve, thickly forested and untouched, meant to preserve the feng-shui of the Eastern Tombs and protect them from negative influences, which in China always come from the north. However, the republic opened this vast uninhabited region to settlers, resulting in sights here that are completely unknown in the rest of China—pioneering conditions that feel out of place in that densely populated and intensively farmed land, as well as a demonstration of what must have happened many centuries ago on a much larger scale to make North China the dust-ridden, barren area it is today.
Settlers poured in from the overpopulated country to the south as air rushes to fill a vacuum. An efficient Government would have seen that the windfall was exploited to the best advantage; in the absence of one it was ruthlessly looted. Precious as are trees and wood in China these great forests hardly a hundred miles from Peking were wiped out as wantonly as those of southern Brazil, as those of virgin Cuba lying in the path of advancing cane-fields. Half-burned trunks littered the hillsides; acres of fire-blackened stumps, wood that might have been turned into lumber enough to supply several provinces felled and left to rot or burn where it lay, men grubbing at slopes that had never before known the hoe were things that could not be reconciled with China. Alpine valleys filled with pink blossoms, of which cued coolies wore a 240cluster behind each ear, untainted mountain streams purling down across the trail, provided here and there with solid timber bridges instead of mats and branches sagging under their covering of loose earth, seemed as out of place in this part of the world as did the pungent scent of burning woodland that carried me back to a rural childhood. It was the most delightful day’s tramp in North China, and hardly once did I think of evicting my one-eyed companion from the white donkey.
Settlers flocked in from the densely populated country to the south like air rushing in to fill a void. An effective government would have ensured that this opportunity was taken full advantage of; without one, it was mercilessly plundered. As valuable as trees and wood are in China, these huge forests barely a hundred miles from Beijing were destroyed just as recklessly as those in southern Brazil, or the untouched ones in Cuba being cleared for cane fields. Half-burned trunks scattered across the hillsides; acres of charred stumps, wood that could have been turned into enough lumber to supply several provinces, were cut down and left to decay or burn where they fell. Men were digging in slopes that had never seen a hoe, a sight that could not coexist with the image of China. Alpine valleys filled with pink blossoms, worn by coolies with clusters behind each ear, and pristine mountain streams flowing down the trails—fitted with solid timber bridges instead of mats and branches weighed down with loose earth—seemed as out of place here as the pungent smell of burning woodland that reminded me of my rural childhood. It was the most enjoyable day’s hike in North China, and hardly once did I think of kicking my one-eyed companion off the white donkey.
But it was China after all, with many of its national characteristics. Streams of friendly, cheerful coolies climbed the defiles with their earthly possessions, consisting of a grub-ax and a few rags, ready for any task offered them, or in lieu of it prepared to gather a bundle of brush and carry it to a market many miles away; they realized that already this new land is so thickly peopled that it has no real openings for them. To see a line of men and boys, elbow to elbow, scratching one of these stony, thin-soiled, more than half-perpendicular hillsides, made the crowding of population a more living problem than a shelf of books could. There were a few pioneer shacks of split rails, but with unlimited logs and mighty boulders everywhere this imported generation of mountaineers built their huts mainly of mud, at best of unshaped stones and sticks. Burnt-log stockades surrounded many of these new homes, for you cannot break the Chinese of their habit of building walls merely by transplanting them to where walls are entirely unneeded. The Chinese birthright of the most laborious forms of labor still prevailed. Plows were home-made affairs drawn by a boy, a woman, or a donkey, and were so crude and small that the man who held them was bent double as he shuffled along. Thousands of roughly squared timbers nearly twice the size of a railroad-tie lay blackening and rotting along the trail, and every little while we met a man with two of these roped to his back picking his way down slopes rougher and steeper than any stairway disrupted by an earthquake. Goiter was more prevalent and reached more loathsome proportions in all this region than I have ever seen it elsewhere. New territory, new homes, new opportunities, all was as new as a new world, except the people, as soil- and custom-incrusted as if they had lived here a thousand years. The thought persisted that these beautiful mountains should have been left clothed in their magnificent forests instead of being enslaved to what can scarcely be called agriculture. At most they offer steep little strips of very stony patches, and the population these support is hardly worth the trees it has displaced. Human beings grubbing out an existence which hardly seems worth the effort may be seen anywhere in China; such primeval forests as have so recklessly been reduced to charred rubbish and clumps of trees only on the most inaccessible peaks and ridges behind Tung Ling are rare and precious there.
But it was China after all, with many of its national characteristics. Streams of friendly, cheerful laborers climbed the hills with their meager belongings, which included a tool and a few rags, ready for any tasks offered, or instead prepared to collect a bundle of brush and carry it to a market many miles away; they recognized that this new land was already so densely populated that it had no real opportunities for them. Watching a line of men and boys, shoulder to shoulder, scraping away at these rocky, thin-soiled, nearly vertical hillsides made the issue of overcrowding feel much more urgent than any shelf of books could convey. There were a few pioneer shacks made of split logs, but with an abundance of logs and massive boulders everywhere, this imported generation of mountain dwellers mostly built their huts from mud, or at best from unshaped stones and sticks. Burnt-log fences surrounded many of these new homes, as you can't break the Chinese habit of building walls just by moving them to places where walls aren't really needed. The traditional Chinese work ethic still dominated. Plows were homemade, pulled by a boy, a woman, or a donkey, and were so crude and small that the person using them was bent over as they shuffled along. Thousands of roughly hewn timbers nearly twice the size of a railroad tie lay rotting along the trail, and occasionally we encountered a man with two of these tied to his back, carefully navigating slopes rougher and steeper than any earthquake-ravaged stairway. Goiter was more common and had reached more disgusting levels in this area than I had ever seen before. New territory, new homes, new opportunities—everything felt as fresh as a new world, except for the people, who were as bound to the land and their customs as if they had lived here for a thousand years. The thought lingered that these beautiful mountains should have been left covered in their magnificent forests instead of being constrained to what can barely be called agriculture. At most, they offered steep little patches of very rocky ground, and the number of people these could support was hardly worth the trees that had been cut down. People struggling to survive, whose efforts seemed barely worthwhile, can be seen anywhere in China; such ancient forests as remain—recklessly reduced to charred remains and clusters of trees only on the most inaccessible peaks and ridges behind Tung Ling—are rare and precious there.

For three thousand miles the Great Wall clambers over the mountains between China and Mongolia
For three thousand miles, the Great Wall climbs over the mountains between China and Mongolia.

One of the mammoth stone figures flanking the road to the Ming Tombs of North China, each of a single piece of granite
One of the massive stone statues lining the road to the Ming Tombs in North China, each carved from a single piece of granite.

Another glimpse of the Great Wall
Another look at the Great Wall

The twin pagodas of Taiyüan, capital of Shansi Province
The twin pagodas of Taiyüan, the capital of Shanxi Province
241Toward the end of the afternoon a kind of cart-road grew up underfoot and carried us over the steepest and last ridge of the day to Hsin Lung Shan. “New Dragon Mountain” is a brand-new pioneer city in the heart of the former reserve, Chinese in its main features, but so fresh and even clean that one might easily have doubted its nationality. The inn itself had not found time to convert its yard into a slough or a dust-bin or its rooms into crumbling, musty mud dens. Imposing shops lined the principal streets; the chief official, with whom I exchanged calls of respect, was a man of culture as well as authority—and he seemed to have had no special orders concerning foreigners.
241As the afternoon came to a close, a kind of dirt road formed beneath us, taking us over the steepest and final ridge of the day to Hsin Lung Shan. “New Dragon Mountain” is a newly established pioneer city in the heart of the former reserve, primarily Chinese in its characteristics, but so fresh and clean that one could easily question its nationality. The inn had not yet managed to turn its yard into a muddy mess or its rooms into crumbling, musty holes. Impressive shops lined the main streets; the chief official, with whom I exchanged polite greetings, was a cultured man of authority—and it seemed he had received no specific instructions regarding foreigners.
Great masses of white clouds drifted through the streets when we set out next morning along the stony river that gives Hsin Lung Shan its setting, and were responsible for a curious illusion. The sun had evidently just topped the mountain ridge close above the town, and the single irregular row of trees that had survived at the crest showed one after the other through a little rift in the moving fog that covered everything else, so that it looked exactly as if the sun itself were having a procession of trees across its surface. A fairly broad valley of palpably fertile virgin soil lasted all the morning and somewhat reconciled one to the destruction of the forests. Here it was less stony, or better picked up, and supported rather a numerous population in reasonable style. The mist continued to play queer pranks until it had been burned away by what remained a blazing, despotic sun. Field boundaries of stone, also of single logs laid end to end, warned the road against trespassing. There were stone-heaps in great number, but no graves to interfere with the husbandman. Four prisoners tied together with ropes and flanked by two policemen in the usual black uniform plodded past toward the new city, implying that this virgin region is after all no sinless Eden. Twice that morning we met strings of camels stepping softly westward, though how they crossed the ranges that shut in the valley on all sides was a mystery which their surly drivers, so unlike the simple, almost obsequious settlers, except in their avoidance of soap and water, would not pause to answer. Many a camel-train stalking with supercilious mien past our Peking home goes on to Jehol, but they take the direct route worn deep with centuries of traffic. In 242this May-time the beasts were ugly with the loss of great wads of hair which made them much worse than moth-eaten, and the drivers had tied networks of string about their necks to keep them from dropping, or being pilfered of, this most valuable of their fur.
Great masses of white clouds floated through the streets as we set out the next morning along the rocky river that gives Hsin Lung Shan its backdrop, creating a strange illusion. The sun had clearly just risen over the mountain ridge right above the town, and the solitary, uneven line of trees that had survived at the peak appeared one by one through a small gap in the moving fog that covered everything else, making it look like the sun itself was hosting a parade of trees across its surface. A fairly wide valley of undeniably fertile virgin land stretched out all morning, somewhat making it easier to accept the destruction of the forests. Here, the ground was less rocky or better cultivated and supported a fairly large population living comfortably. The mist continued to play odd tricks until it was burned away by what remained a blazing, oppressive sun. Stone field boundaries, along with single logs laid end to end, marked the road against trespassing. There were numerous stone piles, but no graves to disturb the farmers. Four prisoners tied together with ropes and flanked by two policemen in their usual black uniforms trudged past toward the new city, suggesting that this virgin land is, after all, no sinless paradise. Twice that morning, we encountered lines of camels moving quietly westward, though how they crossed the mountain ranges that surrounded the valley was a mystery that their grumpy drivers, so different from the simple, almost subservient settlers — except for their aversion to soap and water — wouldn’t stop to explain. Many a camel train, moving with an air of superiority past our home in Peking, continues on to Jehol, but they take the direct route that's been worn deep with centuries of traffic. In 242 this May, the animals looked ragged with patches of hair missing, making them appear far worse than moth-eaten, and the drivers had tied networks of string around their necks to prevent them from losing, or being stolen of, this most valuable of their fur.
The valley narrowed at last and pushed us up over another high range, the third stiff climb of the trip, from the top of which labyrinthian views blue with haze but brilliant with sunshine spread to infinity in both directions. But the land had evidently been reclaimed earlier here, so that there were fewer and fewer pioneering conditions, which on the third day died out entirely. A miserable mountain inn offered me its principal room that evening, though it took up more than half the building reserved for travelers, a flock of evicted coolies picking up their soiled packs and crowding together somewhere else without the hint of a protest. I do not know how much they paid for lodging, but it could not have been any fortune, since the landlord was so eager to replace a dozen of them, with prospects of more to come, by a lone foreigner whose bill hardly amounted to twelve American cents. Woven cornstalk fences increased as the smell of newly cleared land diminished. Twenty-four hours of valley brought us to another steep ling, from the top of which rows of blue ranges faded away on the distant horizon behind. The population had been longer established here and was made up of born mountaineers, simple yet self-sufficient, like mountaineers the world over. Goiter was almost universal, and nearly every one was deeply pitted with smallpox, so that there was rarely a good-looking face of either sex. Round granaries made of wickerwork, of the height of a tall man, lined with mud plaster and thatched with straw, sat in every yard. All memories of the royal forest had disappeared by the third afternoon, and the familiar old China, stony, bare, blowing with dust or reeking with mud, again surrounded us, though ranges of jagged peaks kept us fairly close company.
The valley finally narrowed and pushed us up over another high range, the third tough climb of the trip. From the top, we had maze-like views, hazy blue but bright with sunshine, stretching out to infinity in both directions. It was clear that the land had been reclaimed earlier here, so the pioneering conditions were fewer and fewer, completely disappearing by the third day. That evening, a shabby mountain inn offered me its main room, which took up more than half the building reserved for travelers, while a group of evicted laborers gathered their dirty packs and moved somewhere else without a hint of protest. I have no idea how much they paid for a place to stay, but it couldn't have been much, since the landlord was eager to replace a dozen of them with a lone foreigner whose bill barely came to twelve American cents. Woven cornstalk fences became more common as the smell of freshly cleared land faded away. After twenty-four hours in the valley, we reached another steep ling, from the top of which rows of blue ranges faded into the distant horizon. The population here had been established longer and consisted of native mountaineers—simple yet self-sufficient, like mountaineers everywhere. Goiter was almost universal, and nearly everyone had deep pockmarks from smallpox, so there were rarely any good-looking faces of either sex. Round granaries made of wickerwork, as tall as a man, lined with mud plaster and thatched with straw, were in every yard. By the third afternoon, all reminders of the royal forest had disappeared, and the familiar old China—rocky, bare, blowing with dust or reeking with mud—surrounded us once again, though jagged peaks kept us reasonably close company.
Rain began to fall, putting terror into the heart of my “boy,” convinced like most Chinese, at least of the north, that he was merely a pillar of salt—or is it sugar? But the donkey-man was made of sterner stuff. A positive word was always enough to make him push on, and it was quite immaterial whether the “boy” followed or flung himself over a precipice. This time, however, the shower became a deluge that showed no signs of abating. All the region had fled for shelter. One wrinkled coolie had monopolized a little wayside shrine, in which he sat in the cramped posture of the Buddha, literally in the lap of the gods, serenely smoking his pipe until they chose to let him go on again. 243By the time we were soaked through it was evident that we also must take refuge, and give up the hope of cutting the record from Malanyü to Jehol down to three days.
Rain started to fall, filling my “boy” with fear, convinced like most northern Chinese, that he was just a pillar of salt—or was it sugar? But the donkey-man was tougher. A simple word of encouragement was enough to keep him going, and it didn't matter whether the “boy” followed or threw himself over a cliff. This time, though, the rain turned into a downpour that showed no signs of stopping. Everyone in the area had fled for cover. One wrinkled coolie had claimed a small roadside shrine, where he sat in the cramped position of the Buddha, literally in the lap of the gods, calmly smoking his pipe until they decided to let him move on. 243 By the time we were completely soaked, it was clear that we also had to find shelter and give up the hope of reducing the travel time from Malanyü to Jehol to three days.
The only stopping-place available was a peasant home that offered accommodations to passing coolies. It boasted the name of Hsiao Pai Shu, but then, every spot in China where human beings dwell has a name, and this one after all meant nothing more than “Little White Tree.” If it had been called “Unworthy Human Pigsty” there would have been less reason to quarrel with the man who named it. There was a kind of k’ang in one of the three mud stables, but to have demanded that would have been to drive even my own men out and leave nothing but the bare earth for a score of fellow-refugees to sleep on. I won the whole race of outside barbarians a new reputation, therefore, by setting my cot on the ground at the foot of the k’ang and leaving that free for all the coolies who could crowd upon it. But I paid for my heroism through other senses than those of smell and hearing, for not the slightest movement did I make, not a possession did I withdraw from my baggage, that half a hundred eyes did not delve into the utmost depths of my personal privacy. No Westerner who has not himself had the experience can conceive of the ingenuous meddling which a crowd of low-caste Chinese can inflict upon him; but it is ingenuous after all, and those few naïve remarks of which I caught the meaning made me deeply regret that I was incapable of understanding the respectful chatter that constantly called attention to my innumerable extraordinary idiosyncrasies.
The only place to stay was a peasant's home that provided accommodations for passing laborers. It was called Hsiao Pai Shu, but really, every place in China where people live has a name, and this one simply meant “Little White Tree.” If it had been named “Unworthy Human Pigsty,” there would have been less reason to dispute the person who named it. There was a type of k’ang in one of the three mud stables, but asking for it would have forced my own men out, leaving nothing but bare ground for a bunch of fellow refugees to sleep on. I earned the entire race of outsiders a new reputation by setting my cot on the ground at the foot of the k’ang and leaving that space available for all the laborers who could fit on it. But I paid for my heroism with more than just my sense of smell and hearing, as every single movement I made, and every item I touched in my bags, was scrutinized by a crowd of curious eyes. No Westerner who hasn’t been through it can truly imagine the invasive meddling a group of lower-caste Chinese can impose on him; yet it is innocent in a way, and those few naïve comments I understood made me really wish I could grasp the respectful chatter that constantly pointed out my many peculiarities.
At Hsi-nan-tze, still sixty li from Jehol, a police soldier was sent running for more than a mile after me to ask for my card. It was early, and evidently the town had been slow in waking up to the fact that a foreigner was passing through. Plainly this was an unusual occurrence, but there was no suggestion of detaining me, either here or at the village where we made the usual breakfast-lunch stop from ten to eleven, in which a similar courteous request was made. A visiting-card, as I have said before, has a weight in China out of all keeping with the ease with which any one can have it printed. The fourth hard climb of the trip, up a trench-like trail slippery as new ice from the rain of the day before and almost impassable with pack-animals sprawling and sliding under ungainly burdens, uncovered such a panorama of wrinkled blue mountain ranges entirely around the horizon as even the perpetual wanderer seldom sees equaled. Then we descended among bare foot-hills and plodded the last half-day down 244a wide sandy and stony river valley, with one poled ferry and several wadings across the swollen yellow rivulet which wandered along it. Several earth-and-branch bridges had been partly carried away and were being repaired in the same time-honored, inadequate style; that is, the huge baskets filled with stones that served as almost continuous pillars were having more branches and kaoliang-stalks laid across them and covered with treacherous loose earth. No other nation has the genius of the Chinese for doing some things in the worst way. There was a continual procession, for instance, of carts heavily loaded with grain and drawn by five to seven mules each, the wickedly exhausted animals staggering through the deep sand and the deeper rivulet panting as if they were in the final throes. The Lwan Ho on which the grain is shipped to the coast washes the edge of Jehol, and the boats could as easily tie up at the very foot of the warehouses; but the carters’ gild required them to anchor twenty-five li down the stream! Not even our own labor-unions could exhibit anything to outrival this sacrificing of the general good to the selfishness of a group.
At Hsi-nan-tze, still sixty li from Jehol, a police soldier ran after me for over a mile to ask for my card. It was early, and clearly, the town had been slow to realize that a foreigner was passing through. This was obviously an unusual situation, but there were no attempts to hold me back, either here or at the village where we typically stopped for breakfast-lunch from ten to eleven, where a similar polite request was made. As I've mentioned before, a visiting card holds significant value in China, far beyond how easily it can be printed. The fourth steep climb of the trip, up a narrow trail slick with rain from the day before and nearly impassable with pack-animals sprawling and sliding under awkward loads, revealed a stunning panorama of wrinkled blue mountain ranges surrounding the horizon, a sight even seasoned travelers seldom witness. Then we made our way down through bare foothills and trudged the last half-day down a wide sandy and stony river valley, crossing one poled ferry and several times wading through the swollen yellow stream that flowed alongside it. Several earth-and-branch bridges had been partially washed away and were under repair in the same old, ineffective manner; that is, the large baskets filled with stones that served as almost continuous pillars were being reinforced with more branches and kaoliang stalks, topped with unreliable loose earth. No other nation possesses the Chinese knack for doing some things in such an ineffective way. For instance, there was a constant stream of carts heavily loaded with grain, each pulled by five to seven mules, the weary animals staggering through the deep sand and even deeper stream, panting as if on their last legs. The Lwan Ho, from which the grain is shipped to the coast, runs right by Jehol, and the boats could easily dock at the foot of the warehouses; however, the carters' guild required them to anchor twenty-five li downstream! Not even our own labor unions could showcase anything to rival this prioritization of a group's selfishness over the common good.
Jehol is a compact, unwalled town lying prettily up the slope of a hollow between two foot-hills, brightened by a few spring-green trees here and there above its low gray roofs and surrounded on all sides by beautiful broken ranges. The region is famous for curious natural features, the most striking of which is the “Clothes’ Beater,” a mammoth rock looking precisely like that aid to the Chinese washerwomen who squat at the edges of streams or mud-holes, or an Irishman’s shillalah, standing bolt upright on its smaller, handle end, and visible more than a day’s travel away in almost any direction. But while the scenery is magnificent and the town busy and prosperous, the fame of Jehol is due to the imperial summer palaces and the lama temples that grew up about them, as did the town itself. This whole territory, originally Mongol, was given as the dowry of a Mongol wife to a Manchu emperor of China. K’ang Hsi, who died just two hundred years ago, was the first of the Ch’ing dynasty to visit the region, of which he grew very fond. He hunted throughout it, riding also on an ass—the cost of keeping which is said to have been paid regularly out of the imperial treasury until the revolution! Yung Cheng, who succeeded him, met here the mother of his own successor, the famous Ch’ien Lung, who was born at Jehol. Perhaps I should say the alleged mother, for there has always been a strong suspicion that the brilliant Ch’ien Lung was really a Chinese boy switched at birth for a girl born 245to the empress or concubine in question. At any rate the bare, half-ruined cottage in which he is recorded to have been born is still standing in the wooded hills beyond the imperial summer palace.
Jehol is a small, unprotected town nestled charmingly on a slope in a hollow between two foothills, brightened by a few spring-green trees dotting its low gray roofs and surrounded by beautiful, rugged mountain ranges. The area is known for its unique natural features, the most notable being the “Clothes’ Beater,” a massive rock that looks exactly like that tool used by Chinese washerwomen who sit by the edges of streams or muddy spots, or like an Irishman’s walking stick, standing straight up on its smaller end and visible from over a day's travel away in almost any direction. While the scenery is breathtaking and the town is lively and thriving, Jehol's reputation comes from the imperial summer palaces and the lama temples that developed around them, as did the town itself. This entire area, originally Mongol, was given as a dowry from a Mongol wife to a Manchu emperor of China. K’ang Hsi, who died just two hundred years ago, was the first emperor of the Ch’ing dynasty to visit the region, which he grew very fond of. He hunted throughout the area, even riding a donkey—reportedly, the cost of keeping it was regularly covered by the imperial treasury until the revolution! Yung Cheng, who followed him, met here the mother of his own successor, the famous Ch’ien Lung, who was born in Jehol. Perhaps I should mention the alleged mother, as there has always been suspicion that the brilliant Ch’ien Lung was actually a Chinese boy who was switched at birth for a girl born to the empress or concubine in question. In any case, the simple, half-ruined cottage where he is said to have been born still stands in the wooded hills beyond the imperial summer palace.
This is enclosed within a great wall on a minor scale which clambers over the hills as easily as it stalks across broad flatlands, several miles in extent and still in almost perfect repair. The same can by no means be said, however, of the former palaces inside it. Time, the elements, and particularly the wanton hand of man have reduced them to the saddest state among all the decaying remains of imperial China. The simpler structures near the gates, no doubt built for minor retainers and servants, are occupied by the “Tartar General” and his far-famed “I-Chün” troops, semi-autonomous rulers of this “special area,” and have been more or less kept up accordingly. But the erstwhile palaces scattered beyond the immense half-wooded meadows behind these, to which a soldier guide conducts the few “distinguished visitors” who have credentials, influence, or assurance enough to pass the gates, are synonymous with the word “dilapidation.” A single building has remained comparatively intact, because it is made of solid bronze. Structures that must in their heyday have equaled except in size anything in Peking are mere tumbled ruins of rotten timbers, collapsed roofs, and broken tiles still bearing their glorious Chinese colors. Some of the mammoth gods with which the place seems once to have been overpopulated have survived almost intact in more durable shelters, like the remnants of a fallen dynasty that had their refuges carefully chosen long before the catastrophe came. Others were less fortunate, or foresighted, and, left out in the open by fallen roofs, they are gruesome testimonials that the most brilliant and the most terrifying alike of Chinese gods are but statues of mud. A striking pagoda still stands high above all else except the higher hills within the enclosure, but only the foolhardy climb it now, and the great cluster of temples which seem once to have risen among the venerable evergreens about it have corrupted almost beyond the possibility of identification. A carved stone, in the front rank among Chinese tablets, one whole face of it covered with a Tibetan text, is the only thing that stands erect and defiant against the forces of destruction.
This is surrounded by a smaller-scale great wall that climbs over the hills just as easily as it stretches across wide flatlands, spanning several miles and still nearly intact. However, the same cannot be said for the former palaces within it. Time, the elements, and especially the reckless touch of humans have brought them to the most unfortunate state among all the crumbling remnants of imperial China. The simpler structures near the gates, likely built for minor retainers and servants, are occupied by the “Tartar General” and his renowned “I-Chün” troops, semi-autonomous leaders of this “special area,” and have been somewhat maintained as a result. But the former palaces scattered beyond the vast half-wooded meadows behind them, to which a soldier guide leads the few “distinguished visitors” who have the credentials, influence, or assurance to pass the gates, are synonymous with the word “dilapidation.” One building has remained relatively intact because it is made of solid bronze. Structures that in their prime must have rivaled anything in Peking, except in size, are now just crumbled ruins of rotting wood, collapsed roofs, and broken tiles still showing their glorious Chinese colors. Some of the massive gods that once seemed to fill the place have survived almost completely in more durable shelters, like remnants of a fallen dynasty that had strategically chosen their refuges long before disaster struck. Others were less fortunate or less prepared, and, left exposed by fallen roofs, they serve as grim reminders that even the most brilliant and terrifying of Chinese gods are merely mud statues. A striking pagoda still rises high above everything except the taller hills within the enclosure, but only the reckless dare to climb it now, and the great cluster of temples that once seemed to rise among the ancient evergreens around it have deteriorated almost beyond recognition. A carved stone, one of the top Chinese tablets, with one whole face covered in Tibetan text, is the only thing that stands tall and defiant against the forces of destruction.
Great numbers of the magnificent old trees that once made the parks a forest have been recklessly destroyed, but the velvety stretches of grass survive, and on this graze the descendants of deer brought here long before America had thought of throwing off European allegiance. No one was agreed on the number that dot the enclosure, for statistics 246are not at home in China; but the average of the guesses was about seven hundred, of which I certainly saw half in my stroll through the grounds. There must surely be some powerful superstition as well as mere orders against their destruction, in a land where even dead camels are consumed with such apparent relish. There is a shallow lake within the palace wall, on which some of the sturdier emperors are reputed to have tried their amateur skill at paddling and poling, but one suspects that they spent more time on the little island with its artificial rock hillocks and soughing pine-trees overlooking it. There is a warm spot in this lake which never freezes over, it is said, whence the name Jehol, which means “Hot River,” and, thanks to the often inexplicable Romanization of Chinese which has come down to us from an earlier generation of foreign residents, is pronounced “Jay-hole” by tourists and uncorrected bookworms; others do their best to approximate two guttural Chinese noises which might somewhat better have been spelled “Ruh-Hur.”
Many of the impressive old trees that once made the parks feel like a forest have been carelessly chopped down, but the lush expanses of grass still remain, where the descendants of deer, brought here long before America considered breaking away from European rule, roam. No one could agree on how many are in the enclosure, as statistics aren’t really a thing in China; however, the average guess was around seven hundred, of which I definitely saw half during my walk through the grounds. There must be some strong superstition, as well as strict orders, against their destruction in a place where even dead camels are eaten with evident delight. There’s a shallow lake within the palace walls, where some of the more adventurous emperors are said to have tried their skills at paddling and poling. However, it's likely that they spent more time on the little island with its artificial hills and whispering pine trees that overlook it. There’s a warm spot in this lake that never freezes, supposedly giving rise to the name Jehol, which means “Hot River.” Due to the often puzzling Romanization of Chinese from an earlier generation of foreign residents, tourists and uncorrected bookworms pronounce it “Jay-hole”; others try to mimic two guttural Chinese sounds that might be better spelled “Ruh-Hur.”
The dozen or more great temples scattered along the valley across the river from the palace grounds are still occupied by a few lamas and are in a somewhat better state of preservation. Ch’ien Lung built most of them, beginning just beneath his birthplace and stretching on into the hills, whence delightful views of Jehol and all its region may be had for the climbing. The emperors who summered out here beyond the Great Wall were Manchus, kin to the race of Kublai Khan, and the temples are not Chinese but Mongol, which means a world of difference in spite of many similarities. Lamas who still claim to be Mongol, and who certainly are not purely Chinese either in features or manner, dawdle through their useless lives in them, making out as best they can without the imperial aid that disappeared with the revolution, including such sums as they can wheedle or bluff out of the baker’s half-dozen of foreign visitors a year, including anything, in fact, this side of actual work. In their halcyon days these temples must have been more than impressive; they are still that in their decline. In the “Temple of the 508 Buddhas” that number of life-size wooden images gilded to look like well aged golden statues stretch away down dark aisle after dim musty passageway to approximate infinity. There are fat and merry, thin and esthetic, sour and licentious, imposing and silly Buddhas among these 508 yellow-robed figures seated with their spirit-tablets and incense-bowls before them; every vice and virtue, every mental, moral, and physical characteristic of the human race is 247depicted here as exactly as the art and the breadth of experience with mankind of the Oriental artificers made possible. There is a temple filled with similar figures near Peking, but it is small compared with that of Jehol. Mammoth gold dragons gambol up and down the golden roof of another sanctuary; one entire building is taken up by a gigantic female Buddha riding a dog-like monster; figures that would terrify a nervous child out of its wits glare out from many a half-lighted interior; a man whose tastes and training ran that way could easily find material for a whole fat volume on Tibetan-Mongol art and lamaism within this stretch of a mile or two along the Lwan Ho. The tallest of the temples contains a standing Buddha several stories high, with forty-two hands, each bearing a different gift—whether for mankind as a whole or merely for the lamas was not clear. The figure, said to be made of a single tree-trunk, is larger than that which so often startles tourists at the Lama Temple in Peking, and it is identical, according to the reasonably intelligent chief guardian, with those of Urga and Lhasa. The face is of the same maidenly simplicity as that in the Mongol capital, but the edifice was much less filled to semi-suffocation with the almost gruesome paraphernalia which makes the ascent of Ganden like a peep into the barbaric heart of the Tibetan-Mongol religion.
The dozen or so large temples scattered along the valley across the river from the palace grounds are still occupied by a few lamas and are in somewhat better condition. Ch’ien Lung built most of them, starting right below his birthplace and stretching into the hills, where you can enjoy beautiful views of Jehol and the surrounding area if you’re up for the hike. The emperors who spent their summers out here beyond the Great Wall were Manchus, related to Kublai Khan's people, and the temples are Mongol, not Chinese, which makes a huge difference despite many similarities. Lamas who still identify as Mongol and definitely aren't purely Chinese, either in looks or behavior, drift through their purposeless lives there, doing the best they can without the imperial support that vanished with the revolution, including any funds they can charm or con out of the baker’s handful of foreign visitors each year, avoiding anything that resembles actual work. In their prime, these temples must have been quite impressive; they still retain some of that grandeur in their decline. In the “Temple of the 508 Buddhas,” life-size wooden images covered in gold paint to resemble well-aged golden statues stretch endlessly down dark aisles and musty passageways. Among these 508 yellow-robed figures seated with their spirit-tablets and incense-bowls before them, you’ll find Buddha representations that are fat and cheerful, thin and elegant, sour and indulgent, imposing and silly; every vice and virtue, every mental, moral, and physical trait of humanity is depicted here as accurately as the art and the rich experiences of the Oriental artisans could allow. There’s a temple filled with similar figures near Beijing, but it’s small compared to the one in Jehol. Massive golden dragons frolic along the golden roof of another sanctuary; one entire building is occupied by a gigantic female Buddha riding a dog-like monster; figures that could scare a nervous child out of its wits glare out from many dimly lit interiors. Someone with interests in that area could easily gather material for a hefty book on Tibetan-Mongol art and lamaism just along this stretch of a mile or two by the Lwan Ho. The tallest of the temples features a standing Buddha several stories high, with forty-two hands, each holding a different gift—whether for humanity as a whole or just for the lamas wasn't clear. The figure, said to be carved from a single tree trunk, is larger than the one that often surprises tourists at the Lama Temple in Beijing, and, according to the reasonably knowledgeable chief guardian, it matches those found in Urga and Lhasa. The face has the same youthful simplicity as the one in the Mongol capital, but the building is much less packed with the almost gruesome decorations that make climbing Ganden feel like peeking into the barbaric heart of Tibetan-Mongol religion.
The climax, however, of the sights about Jehol, at least to the average Westerner, is the Potalá, said to be an exact copy, on a smaller scale, of that great heap of buildings in Lhasa which so few white men have seen. It stands just over the river from the palace grounds, a striking feature in a notable landscape. There must be a dozen structures in all, so close one above another as to seem, until one is among them, joined together into one mammoth pile covering a whole hillock. In general color they are pinkish, except where the plaster has fallen off, with the huge square structure at the top a dull, weather-worn red. This is in appearance five stories high, with as many large superimposed shrines and long rows of false windows on the face of it; and, the visitor finds at last, when a dozen lamas with as many bunches of medieval keys have escorted him to the summit of the long climb, it is roofless, a mere wall surrounding the most sacred of the temples. Within, if the seekers after cumshaw who constantly surrounded and kept their eyes upon me are truthful, two services a day have been held without a break since Ch’ien Lung built the Potalá a century and a half ago. Two of the older, half-dignified lamas claimed to have been in Lhasa, and they asserted that even in its minor decorations this was 248an exact replica of the chief temple of the Dalai Lama, pointing out the spots where he stood or sat during ceremonies in the original. The holy of holies, which opened at the gleam of small silver, may indeed be the equal, except in size, to anything in Lhasa; with its remarkable tapestries, its enamel pagoda, golden Buddhas of every size, and all the sacred paraphernalia of lamaism, there is an impressiveness about it that is in keeping with what the imagination pictures the mysterious Tibetan capital to be.
The highlight of the sights around Jehol, especially for the average Westerner, is the Potalá, which is said to be a smaller-scale replica of the impressive complex in Lhasa that very few white people have visited. It stands just across the river from the palace grounds, making it a striking feature in a remarkable landscape. There are about a dozen buildings in total, so closely stacked that they look like one massive structure covering an entire hillock until you’re actually among them. Generally, they are pinkish in color, except where the plaster has chipped off, with the large square building at the top a dull, weathered red. This main structure appears to be five stories high, featuring multiple large shrines on top and long rows of fake windows on its façade. When the visitor finally reaches the top after being escorted by a dozen lamas wielding medieval keys, they find it is roofless, just a wall enclosing the most sacred temple. Inside, if the seekers of cumshaw who constantly surrounded me are to be believed, two services a day have been held without interruption since Ch’ien Lung constructed the Potalá a century and a half ago. Two older, somewhat dignified lamas claimed to have been in Lhasa, and they insisted that even in its minor details, this is an exact replica of the main temple of the Dalai Lama, pointing out the places where he stood or sat during ceremonies in the original. The innermost chamber, which opens at the glint of small silver, might indeed rival anything in Lhasa, except for its size. With its stunning tapestries, enamel pagoda, golden Buddhas of various sizes, and all the sacred items of lamaism, it carries an impressiveness that matches what people imagine the mysterious Tibetan capital to be.
Two emperors of China died at Jehol, and the court fled here when the Allies entered Peking in 1860, as that of the Dowager and her favorite eunuch did to Sian-fu in 1900. Hsien Feng, half-forgotten husband of that notorious old virago of Boxer days, was the second Hoang-ti to die here, just as our Civil War was beginning, and no emperor has ever come to Jehol since the son who succeeded him at four years of age fled a place of such sad memories and evil spirits. Thus the once favorite summer home of the Manchu emperors, tossed aside like a plaything of a petulant child with too many toys, has fallen into the decay in which the rare visitor of to-day finds it.
Two emperors of China died at Jehol, and the court fled here when the Allies entered Peking in 1860, just as the Dowager and her favorite eunuch did to Sian-fu in 1900. Hsien Feng, the largely forgotten husband of that infamous woman from the Boxer Rebellion, was the second Hoang-ti to die here, right as our Civil War was starting, and no emperor has returned to Jehol since his four-year-old son fled from a place filled with such painful memories and bad spirits. Thus, the once favored summer retreat of the Manchu emperors has been abandoned, like a toy tossed aside by a spoiled child with too many playthings, and has fallen into the decline that you see today as a rare visitor.
If there is one thing more than another that arouses my ire it is to be mistaken for a person of importance; yet that is exactly what happened to me in Jehol. Perhaps any foreigner so far off the foreign trail, particularly after he and his kind had been specifically warned to keep away, would have been considered somebody, but to make matters worse I had been officially requested, just as I was leaving Peking, to allow myself to be called a special investigator of the antiopium league. I should not be expected, it was explained, to do anything more than bear the title; no one would dare actually to investigate the mountain recesses beyond Jehol in which every one knows the stuff is grown, let alone a new-comer who could not tell a poppy-sprout from a radish. But the League of Nations wanted to be told that a foreigner had been sent to visit each suspected district, and as no one else seemed to be going that way my name would fill the dotted line as well as any other.
If there's one thing that really gets under my skin, it's being mistaken for someone important; and that's exactly what happened to me in Jehol. Maybe any foreigner so far off the beaten path, especially after being warned to stay away, would have been seen as someone significant. To make matters worse, just as I was leaving Peking, I had been officially asked to accept the title of special investigator for the anti-opium league. I was told I wouldn't be expected to do anything more than hold the title; no one would dare actually investigate the remote areas beyond Jehol where everybody knows the stuff is grown, especially not a newcomer who couldn't even tell a poppy sprout from a radish. But the League of Nations wanted to report that a foreigner had been sent to visit each suspected area, and since no one else seemed to be heading that way, my name would fill the blank just as well as anyone else's.

The three p’ai-lous of Hsi Ling, the Western Tombs
The three p’ai-lous of Hsi Ling, the Western Tombs

In Shansi four men often work at as many windlasses over a single well to irrigate the fields
In Shansi, four men often operate as many windlasses over a single well to irrigate the fields.

Prisoners grinding grain in the “model prison” of Taiyüan
Prisoners milling grain in the "model prison" of Taiyüan
249That would have been the end of the matter if Peking had not notified Jehol that the honorable investigator was coming. When I arrived, therefore, long after my mind had purged itself of any thought of my putative official capacity, I was startled to find that Jehol insisted on taking me seriously, even in the face of the scantiness of my wardrobe and the donkeyness of my escort. A day or two before, the official Chinese investigator also had come, by the direct route, with a fat English-speaking secretary and suitable retinue, in chaotze gay with red pompoms between mules important with jingling bells. He would remain a month or so, though also taking care not to be caught by the inhospitable poppy-growing peasants or their military beneficiaries and protectors up in the hills. We could both make our reports just as well without risking our lives, without ever coming to China, for that matter, so far as any real results through the League of Nations is concerned, so long as one of the nations bulking largest in that league continues to supply China with opium from her principal colony by a roundabout, oval-eyed route, though every poppy-plant in the erstwhile Middle Kingdom were uprooted.
249That would have been the end of it if Peking hadn’t informed Jehol that the respected investigator was on his way. When I arrived, long after I’d stopped thinking about my supposed official role, I was surprised to find that Jehol was determined to take me seriously, despite my shabby attire and the ridiculousness of my escort. A day or two earlier, the official Chinese investigator had also arrived, using the direct route, with a chubby English-speaking secretary and an appropriate entourage, in a colorful chaotze adorned with red pompoms, accompanied by mules outfitted with jingling bells. He would stay for about a month, though he also preferred to avoid the unfriendly poppy-growing peasants and their military supporters up in the hills. We could both file our reports just as effectively without putting ourselves in danger, and honestly, we could have done it without ever setting foot in China, so far as any real outcomes through the League of Nations are concerned, as long as one of the most dominant nations in that league continues to supply China with opium from its main colony via a convoluted, roundabout route, even if every poppy plant in the former Middle Kingdom were uprooted.
But there is centuries-old precedent for feasting all “censors” or special investigators sent out from Peking, and this serious part of the affair Jehol did not overlook. My distinguished Chinese colleague and I had already met across the board before blood-red invitations a foot long confirmed the verbal rumor that we were to be honored with a feast by the “Tartar General” himself. Delightful little Mi Ta-shuai, with his chin-tickling mustache-ends and the inherent good nature that bubbles out even through his formal demeanor, is no more a Tartar than I am a Turk; he is an exact picture of a Chinese mandarin of the T’ang dynasty, in somewhat modernized garb. But the ruler of the special extramural district of Jehol has borne that title for centuries, just as his troops continue to be considered the native I-Chün, though they come chiefly now from Anhwei and Honan. Three of the four brand-new rickshaws that had just introduced that innovation into Jehol delivered the three male foreigners in town at the gate of honor of the former summer palace, more jolted than seriously hurt after all, and the eight or ten most distinguished Chinese officials joined us in one of the score of long low buildings through which the entrance to almost any yamen of importance stretches on and on, like a half-lighted tunnel.
But there is a long-standing tradition of feasting all “censors” or special investigators sent from Beijing, and this serious aspect of the situation in Jehol wasn't overlooked. My distinguished Chinese colleague and I had already met across the table before the blood-red invitations, a foot long, confirmed the rumor that we were going to be honored with a feast by the “Tartar General” himself. The delightful Mi Ta-shuai, with his mustache ends that tickle his chin and the inherent good nature that shines through even his formal demeanor, is no more a Tartar than I am a Turk; he is a perfect representation of a Chinese mandarin from the T’ang dynasty, dressed in somewhat modern clothing. However, the ruler of the special district of Jehol has held that title for centuries, just as his troops continue to be known as the native I-Chün, even though they mainly come from Anhwei and Honan now. Three of the four brand-new rickshaws that had just introduced that innovation to Jehol brought the three foreign men at the gate of honor of the former summer palace, more jolted than seriously hurt. The eight or ten most distinguished Chinese officials joined us in one of the many long, low buildings that lead into almost any important yamen, stretching on like a dimly lit tunnel.
The feast—but why go into unnecessary details? A Chinese feast is just what the name implies, with variations of no importance according to the latitude and the ability of the feaster’s cooks to give it such hints of foreign ways as their master may be able to specify. Suffice it to say that we gathered soon after four in the afternoon and were gone again by seven, that much more food was carried out again than was consumed by a company that did not rise needing a bedtime snack, and that I had no assistance whatever from the other two representatives of the Western world in replying to the toasts that were incessantly 250poured into our slender glasses, though they hailed respectively from Ireland and Scotland. There were several men worth talking with in the general’s suite, too, and all in all my official capacity was more endurable than it might have been suspected as we jolted homeward between unbroken lines of peering yellow faces eager for a closer glimpse of Jehol’s distinguished foreign guest.
The feast—but why go into unnecessary details? A Chinese feast is exactly what it sounds like, with variations that don’t really matter based on the location and how well the cooks can incorporate their own unique styles as directed by their master. To sum it up, we gathered soon after four in the afternoon and left by seven; a lot more food was taken out than was actually eaten, and our group didn’t leave needing a late-night snack. Plus, I got no help from the other two representatives from the West in responding to the endless toasts being poured into our slender glasses, even though they were from Ireland and Scotland. There were several interesting men in the general’s suite, and overall, my official role was more tolerable than one might have thought as we bounced our way home between unbroken lines of curious yellow faces eager to catch a glimpse of Jehol’s distinguished foreign guest.
The “Tartar General” insisted on sending two mounted troopers of the I-Chün with me on the way back to Peking. There was something in the bandit stories, it seemed, and though they were operating well to the north, the scent of a possible foreign hostage might give their legs double speed. No doubt the general knew as well as I that two lone Chinese soldiers, even of his unusually soldierly I-Chün, would be more likely to add two rifles to the arsenal of any respectable gang of brigands than to protect me from them, and he certainly knew that such escorts expect to live on the traveler’s bounty for at least twice as many days as they accompany him; but it would have been unseemly, of course, to let a special agent of the League of Nations, nebulous as that body may be to the mind of a Chinese militarist, depart without suitable honors.
The “Tartar General” insisted on sending two mounted soldiers from the I-Chün with me on my way back to Beijing. There seemed to be some truth to the bandit stories, and even though they were operating further north, the idea of a potential foreign hostage might make them move faster. The general knew as well as I did that two lone Chinese soldiers, even from his unusually capable I-Chün, would more likely add two rifles to the stockpile of any respectable gang of thieves than actually protect me from them. He also knew that such escorts expect to live off the traveler's resources for at least twice as long as they accompany him; but, of course, it wouldn’t look good to let a special agent of the League of Nations, as vague as that organization might seem to a Chinese military leader, leave without proper honors.
The best way back to Peking would have been to float down the Lwan Ho, with its striking cliffs and gorges, to the railway, well north of Tientsin. But low waters made this trip uncertain, and boatmen were too busy with grain to give a lone traveler much attention. I turned regretfully back, therefore, along the direct main route, worn with centuries of travel, by the feet of man and his beasts, though never aided by his hands. The scent of lilacs, white and of the more usual color, filled the air as we left the city. Inconspicuous on the white donkey or on foot beside the troopers astride good horses and beneath their big straw hats, I scarcely caught the eye of travelers drowsing in the mule-litters that passed so often, to say nothing of attracting bandits out of the north. We crossed two passes and forded the Lwan Ho on the first day and on the morning of the second sighted a high cragged range stretching from infinity to infinity across the horizon ahead, with little unnatural-looking promontories, like knobs on a casting, dotting it at frequent intervals. They were the towers of the Great Wall, it turned out, climbing like a chamois from one lofty peak to another, but it was blazing noon before we passed through it at the much-walled town of Kupehkow. Coolies carrying down to Jehol brushwood and even roots had passed us all the first day; naked children were everywhere; 251men, and once or twice, unless my eyes deceived me, women, stripped to the waist toiled in the dry fields, sometimes waded knee-deep in the liquid mud of little patches that in another month would be pale green with rice. Graves grew numerous again inside the Great Wall; half-ruined yentai, “smoke-platforms” from the tops of which news was sent from the capital in olden days, towered above us at regular intervals; the peddlers of fluffy chicks and coolies carrying green onions to market once more appeared; and the caricature of a road became almost a procession of travelers in both directions.
The best way back to Beijing would have been to float down the Lwan Ho, with its impressive cliffs and gorges, to the railway north of Tianjin. But low water made this trip uncertain, and boatmen were too busy with grain to give a lone traveler much attention. So, I regretfully turned back along the main route, worn down over centuries of travel by people and their animals, though never helped by their hands. The scent of lilacs, both white and the more typical purple, filled the air as we left the city. Unnoticed on the white donkey or on foot beside the soldiers riding their strong horses and wearing large straw hats, I barely caught the eye of travelers lounging in the mule-litters that passed by frequently, not to mention attracting any bandits from the north. We crossed two passes and forded the Lwan Ho on the first day, and on the morning of the second, we spotted a high, jagged mountain range stretching endlessly across the horizon ahead, with oddly shaped promontories, like knobs on a mold, dotting it at regular intervals. They turned out to be the towers of the Great Wall, climbing like mountain goats from one tall peak to another, but it was blazing noon before we passed through at the heavily fortified town of Kupehkow. Coolies carrying brushwood and even roots down to Jehol had passed us all the first day; naked children were everywhere; men, and once or twice, unless my eyes deceived me, women stripped to the waist toiled in the dry fields, sometimes wading knee-deep in the muddy patches that in another month would be pale green with rice. Graves grew more numerous again inside the Great Wall; half-ruined **yentai**, “smoke-platforms” where news was sent from the capital in ancient times, towered above us at regular intervals; the sellers of fluffy chicks and coolies carrying green onions to market reappeared; and what was left of a road transformed into almost a procession of travelers in both directions.
It was an atrocious road nearly all the way, plodding along sandy, stony river-beds except where it clambered laboriously over another mountain ridge, the sun beating ruthlessly down upon us from its rising to its setting. Babies with shaved heads apparently impervious to its rays rooted in the dirt with the black pigs, or stood on sturdy legs suckling even more soil-incrusted mothers. There ought to be very few weeds in China; the whole family is incessantly after them, just as every usable form of filth is promptly gathered. The most common sight in China is of men and boys, sometimes women and girls, wandering the roads and trails with a fork or shovel with which to toss the droppings of animals into a basket over their shoulders, whence it will later be spread on the fields. Each night we put into an inn-yard, where the best available room was quickly assigned me; my cot and a foot-high table were set on the oiled cloth with which I covered the k’ang, and after as nearly a bath as can be had in a basin of hot water there was nothing left to do but to wait patiently for whatever supper my not too adaptable “boy” chose to serve me. The escort had reduced itself to one soldier at the first relief, and at noon on the third day it disappeared entirely. At length the stony sand changed to the fertile plain of Peking, though the road was nothing to boast of up to the last, and while rain and two splittings of my little party at forks of the route all but spoiled my schedule, the afternoon of the fourth day saw us filing through one of the eastern gates of the Tartar City.
It was a terrible road almost the whole way, trudging along sandy, rocky riverbeds except where it climbed slowly over another mountain ridge, the sun relentlessly beating down on us from sunrise to sunset. Babies with shaved heads, seemingly unaffected by its rays, dug in the dirt with the black pigs or stood on sturdy legs nursing even more soil-covered mothers. There should be very few weeds in China; the whole family is constantly out to get them, just as every bit of useful waste is quickly collected. The most common sight in China is men and boys, sometimes women and girls, wandering the roads and trails with a fork or shovel to toss animal droppings into a basket slung over their shoulders, which will later be spread on the fields. Each night we stopped at an inn yard, where the best available room was quickly assigned to me; my cot and a foot-high table were set on the oiled cloth covering the k’ang, and after having the closest thing to a bath possible in a basin of hot water, there was nothing left to do but wait patiently for whatever dinner my not-so-flexible “boy” chose to serve me. The escort had shrunk down to one soldier at the first relief, and by noon on the third day, it disappeared completely. Finally, the rocky sand turned into the fertile plains of Peking, although the road didn’t improve at all until the very end, and while rain and two splits in my small group at forks in the road nearly ruined my plans, by the afternoon of the fourth day, we were entering through one of the eastern gates of the Tartar City.
CHAPTER XIV
A trip to peaceful Shansi
It is a simple matter to visit Hsi Ling, the Western Tomb, where all the Manchu emperors not at Tung Ling are buried. A short branch of the Peking-Hankow line sets the traveler down, four leisurely hours from the capital, within strolling distance of the newest of them, housing the remains of the hapless Kuang Hsü. This is quite as extensive and sumptuous as if the imprisoned puppet had been a real ruler, but it is still glaringly new, the trees that will some day form a forest about it barely head-high, for it is only fifteen years since this effigy of an emperor and the powerful Dowager who manipulated him simultaneously made way for the present occupant of the Forbidden City. No doubt he is glad to be so far away from the oppressive old lady at last.
It’s easy to visit Hsi Ling, the Western Tomb, where all the Manchu emperors not buried at Tung Ling are laid to rest. A short section of the Peking-Hankow line drops travelers off just four relaxed hours from the capital, within walking distance of the newest tomb, which holds the remains of the unfortunate Kuang Hsü. This site is as grand and lavish as if the puppet emperor had actually been a true ruler, but it still looks brand new, with the trees that will one day create a forest around it barely reaching head height, since it has only been fifteen years since this representation of an emperor and the powerful Dowager who controlled him made way for the current occupant of the Forbidden City. No doubt he is relieved to be so far removed from the oppressive old woman at last.
Bare hills lie between the older tombs, their roofs of imperial yellow hidden in venerable evergreen forests that seem to know nothing of bustling modern times. Yung Cheng, third Manchu emperor of China, sent men to choose this spot for him in 1730. When his successor, Ch’ien Lung, came to die, however, he expressed a preference for the Eastern Tombs, saying that if he, too, were buried in the west it might become a habit and the first two emperors of the dynasty would remain in gloomy solitude. He instructed his successors to alternate between the two places, and all of them did so except Tao Kuang, who refused to be separated from his father even in death. Five emperors, three dowager-empresses, many fei, or imperial concubines—whose tombs are blue rather than yellow, because they never had royal title—and a host of princesses in clusters within single tombs, lie scattered through the forests of Hsi Ling. Like all royal burial-places in China the site backs up against the mountains, here the Hsi Shan, the Western Hills, which stretch far to the north and south in rugged, clear-cut ranges close behind the tombs. Delightful paths wander through the evergreen woods, where here and there ill fed Manchus forage for firewood to keep the kettles boiling in their dilapidated caretakers’ villages. There are crowds of loafers guarding each tomb, as at Tung 253Ling, quick enough to offer a visitor the ceremonious cup of tea under conditions, invisible to them, which force him to decline it, but too lazy to open all the doors even when their unsoaped palms are crossed with silver, to say nothing of lifting a hand to repair the ravages of time or to cut the weeds and grass that grow everywhere between the flagstones. After all, it is better that way; any suggestion of real care would be out of keeping with the pastoral Chinese setting, and there are sheep and goats enough to keep the places from becoming impassable jungles.
Bare hills sit between the older tombs, their imperial yellow roofs hidden among ancient evergreen forests that seem untouched by modern life. Yung Cheng, the third Manchu emperor of China, had people choose this location for him in 1730. However, when his successor, Ch’ien Lung, was about to die, he preferred the Eastern Tombs, saying that if he were buried in the west too, it might become a habit and the first two emperors of the dynasty would be left in gloomy solitude. He instructed his successors to alternate between the two sites, and all of them did except for Tao Kuang, who refused to be separated from his father even in death. Five emperors, three dowager-empresses, many fei (imperial concubines whose tombs are blue instead of yellow because they never held royal titles), and a number of princesses in clusters within single tombs lie scattered throughout the forests of Hsi Ling. Like all royal burial sites in China, the area is backed by mountains, in this case, the Hsi Shan, or Western Hills, which stretch ruggedly to the north and south just behind the tombs. Pleasant paths wind through the evergreen woods, where poorly fed Manchus occasionally forage for firewood to keep kettles boiling in their rundown caretaker villages. There are groups of idle people watching each tomb, as at Tung 253Ling, quick to offer a visitor a ceremonial cup of tea under conditions invisible to them that make it difficult to accept, but too lazy to open all the doors even when their unwashed hands are crossed with silver, let alone lift a finger to fix the effects of time or to trim the weeds and grass that grow abundantly between the flagstones. After all, it’s probably better this way; any hint of genuine care would feel out of place in the pastoral Chinese setting, and there are enough sheep and goats to keep the areas from turning into impassable jungles.
One may spend all day roaming from forest-buried tomb to mountain-backed mausoleum; the most mammoth solid stone monuments on turtle bases I have ever seen in China stand side by side in the main entrance pavilion—the exit of most visitors; and the other sides of this square are formed by three p’ai-lous, any of which is almost the equal of the famous single one at the Ming Tombs. But I prefer Tung Ling to its more accessible alternative, if only because its caretakers see too few tourists to acquire the manner of street-urchins.
One can spend all day exploring tombs hidden in the forest and mausoleums set against the mountains. The biggest solid stone monuments on turtle bases I’ve ever seen in China stand next to each other in the main entrance pavilion—where most visitors exit; the other sides of this square are lined with three p’ai-lous, any of which is nearly as impressive as the famous single one at the Ming Tombs. But I prefer Tung Ling to its more popular alternative, if only because its caretakers don’t see enough tourists to develop the attitude of street kids.
I stopped off at Paoting, long the capital of Chihli Province and recently the unofficial capital of North China, to see Tsao Kun. But his secretary brought word that the problems of China had given him a headache which had sent him to bed—it was at the height of one of the bandit outrages against foreigners. Those who know this illiterate sword-shaker and how much he cares about China as distinguished from his own gains, will appreciate the unconscious humor of the answer. Before his yamen stood viceregal poles, of cement instead of wood, a hint perhaps of the fancied permanence of his position. Besides this manipulator of the puppets of Peking there is nothing especially worth seeing in Paoting. A few superficial improvements, such as a new garden for the town to stroll and gamble in, to impress the people with their lord’s importance and his love for them, are all that distinguish this from any large old Chinese walled city.
I stopped in Paoting, which has long been the capital of Chihli Province and recently the unofficial capital of North China, to see Tsao Kun. But his secretary told me that the issues facing China had given him a headache, sending him to bed—it was during a peak of bandit attacks against foreigners. Those who know this uneducated thug and how much he cares about China compared to his own interests will find the humor in his response amusing. Outside his office stood official poles made of cement instead of wood, maybe a sign of how he views the stability of his position. Aside from this puppet master of Peking, there’s nothing particularly notable to see in Paoting. Just a few superficial upgrades, like a new garden for the townspeople to stroll and gamble in, meant to show off their leader’s importance and affection for them, are what set this city apart from any other large old Chinese walled city.
The chief impression of the broad flatlands of Chihli in May is the windlassing of water for irrigation out of wells dotting the landscape everywhere, by a man or two with bare brown torso or by a blindfolded mule. The railway cuts ruthlessly across graveyards, perhaps because if it did not it could find no place to run at all; old sunken roads have been turned into gardens, and new ones are wearing themselves down into the pulverous soil. The narrow-gage line that strikes westward from Shihkiachuang into Shansi climbs all morning the bed 254of a clear little river harnessed for work in many little straw-built mills on the banks or astride the channels into which the crowded people have divided it. There is plenty of stone here. Whole towns are made entirely of it; little fields that can produce at most a peck of wheat are held up by stone walls at least as extensive as they. Crows and other destructive birds are as numerous and ravenous as the human population, who paint scarecrows crudely on the stone walls of the terraces, and hang up straw ones that look ludicrously like Taoist priests. Perhaps these are more effective over such evil spirits than laymen scarecrows. In the mountains well-sweeps instead of windlasses aid the irrigators. Seen on a level these terraced hills looked horribly dry and arid, a dreary yellow and brown. But that is the face of the terraces; from above, the fields are countless patches of spring green, so that the effect from the constantly rising train was like those street-signs that change face completely when they are seen at a new angle.
The main impression of the wide flatlands of Chihli in May is the collection of water for irrigation from wells scattered throughout the landscape, done by a man or two with bare torsos or by a blindfolded mule. The railway cuts harshly across graveyards, possibly because it couldn’t find anywhere else to go; old sunken roads have become gardens, and new ones are slowly eroding into fine soil. The narrow-gauge line that heads west from Shihkiachuang into Shansi climbs all morning along the bed of a clear little river, which is used for work in several small straw-built mills on the banks or over the channels that the crowded people have divided it into. There’s a lot of stone here. Entire towns are made from it; tiny fields that produce at most a peck of wheat are supported by stone walls that are at least as big as they are. Crows and other destructive birds are as plentiful and hungry as the human population, who crudely paint scarecrows on the stone walls of the terraces and hang up straw ones that absurdly resemble Taoist priests. Perhaps these are more effective against such evil spirits than ordinary scarecrows. In the mountains, well-sweeps replace windlasses to help with irrigation. From ground level, these terraced hills look dreadfully dry and barren, a bleak yellow and brown. But that’s just how the terraces appear; from above, the fields are countless patches of spring green, so the view from the constantly rising train is reminiscent of street signs that completely change when seen from a different angle.
No longer ago than the time of the Mings, history says, the mountains between Chihli and Shansi were so covered with trees that “birds could not fly through them.” To-day there is not a sprig of wood left, and the patient peasants till every terraced peak to the very top. Faintly the passenger can make out to the north, through occasional openings in the ranges close at hand, one of the five sacred mountains of China, the Wu-t’ai-shan. The whole cluster is shaped like a maple-leaf and resembles the Diamond Mountains of Korea, if not in scenic splendors at least in the temples and monasteries scattered among them. For many centuries that region has been a Buddhist sanctuary, both of the black-robed Chinese monks and the yellow-robed lamas, even the latter more often natives of Chihli or Shansi than Mongols or Tibetans. Emperors used to come to Wu-t’ai-shan, and the Dalai Lama himself was once there.
Not too long ago during the Ming dynasty, history records that the mountains between Chihli and Shansi were so densely forested that “birds couldn’t fly through them.” Today, there isn’t a single tree left, and hardworking peasants farm every terraced peak all the way to the top. If you look closely, you might catch a glimpse to the north, through occasional gaps in the nearby ranges, of one of China’s five sacred mountains, Wu-t’ai-shan. The whole range is shaped like a maple leaf and, while it may not match the scenic beauty of Korea's Diamond Mountains, it has temples and monasteries scattered throughout. For centuries, this area has been a sanctuary for Buddhists, including both the black-robed Chinese monks and the yellow-robed lamas, who are often natives of Chihli or Shansi rather than Mongols or Tibetans. Emperors used to visit Wu-t’ai-shan, and even the Dalai Lama himself has been there.
Beyond the summit of the line, one of the famous passes of China, the narrow but efficient train snaked its way downward through many tunnels, past busy villages and towns of stone, between long irregular rows of cave-dwellings dug in the porous hills, with many a striking view up terraced gorges which unwooded centuries have given fantastic formations. On the whole it was a dreary landscape, but the train was good. These side-lines are better than the principal railroads of China because they are still under foreign management. Frenchmen and Belgians operate this one to the Shansi capital, not merely by giving 255orders from a central office but by riding the trains to see that these orders are obeyed. No dead-heads escaped the sharp eyes of the European inspectors who examined tickets at frequent intervals; the Chinese employees took care not to honor the rules in the breach instead of in the observance. One third-class coach had a compartment marked “Dames seules.” On the main lines this would have been filled with anything but members of the sex for which it was reserved; here the man who dared sit down in it was speedily invited to move on.
Beyond the peak of the line, one of China’s well-known passes, the narrow but efficient train wound its way down through numerous tunnels, past bustling villages and stone towns, nestled between long uneven rows of cave homes carved into the soft hills. There were many breathtaking views up the terraced gorges, shaped into fantastic formations over centuries of exposure. Overall, it was a bleak landscape, but the train was great. These branch lines are better than the main railroads in China because they’re still managed by foreigners. French and Belgian operators run this line to the Shansi capital, not just by issuing orders from a central office, but by actually riding the trains to ensure those orders are followed. No free riders slipped past the keen eyes of the European inspectors who checked tickets regularly; the Chinese workers made sure to follow the rules properly. One third-class carriage had a compartment marked “Dames seules.” On the main lines, it would have been filled with anything but the women it was intended for; here, a man who dared to sit in it was quickly asked to move along.
A Chinese train, on the trunk-lines subject to the Ministry of Communications, is China in petto,—crowded confusion in the third class that makes up nearly all of it, the second only fairly filled, the first almost empty, except for the pass-holders, influential loafers, and important nonentities who congregate there. Petty anarchy reigns, and “squeeze” rears its slimy head everywhere. The passenger is taxed for the loading of his checked baggage, and then virtually required to tip the porters who load it. It is common knowledge that station-masters consider their salaries their least important source of income. Particularly are the trains, like the country, overrun with useless soldiers. They pack the better coaches until the legitimate traveler often can barely find standing-room; they stretch out everywhere, like a Chinese type of hobo, on the floors of the passageways as well as of the compartments; they fill the so-called dining-car to impassability, lying among their noisome bundles on the tables, the seats, the floors, even about the kitchen stove, like sewage that has seeped in through every opening. In theory they have their generals’ permission to travel, and pay half-fare; in practice the soldier who has a ticket at all, let alone one of the class in which he is traveling, is the exception. They not only ride on their uniforms but rent these out to hucksters and coolies who wish to make a journey. Whole flocks of railway officials in pompous garb come through the trains, but exert themselves only against the uninfluential. Soldiers without tickets are sometimes gently instructed to go back into third class, but no one has the moral courage to insist that they do so, and they ride on hour after hour, sometimes day after day. Police with a brass wheel on their arms are in constant evidence, yet control at the stations is almost unknown. Those getting on, and swarms of coolies hoping for a job of carrying baggage, sweep like a tidal wave into the trains before those getting off can escape; the battle for places is a screaming riot. In winter a car never gets comfortably warm before the overdressed Chinese throw open the windows. The cheap joker who mutilated the 256standardized sign to read, “Passengers are requested to report to the Traffic Manager any cases of cleanliness that come to their notice,” replaced an impossible task by a very easy one. The train that is on time is something to write home about, though now and then one sticks surprisingly close to schedule.
A Chinese train, running on the main lines managed by the Ministry of Communications, is China in private—a chaotic mix in third class, which is nearly always overcrowded, second class is only moderately full, and first class is almost empty, except for the pass-holders, influential loafers, and significant nonentities who hang out there. Minor chaos prevails, and “squeeze” pops up everywhere. Passengers are charged for checking their bags, then basically expected to tip the porters who load them. Everyone knows that station masters view their salaries as the least important part of their income. The trains, just like the country, are particularly swamped with useless soldiers. They crowd into the better coaches so much that actual travelers often struggle to find standing room; they sprawl everywhere, like a Chinese version of a vagrant, on the floors of the aisles as well as in the compartments; they overwhelm the dining car, lying amid their smelly bundles on tables, seats, floors, and even around the kitchen stove, like sewage seeping in through every crack. In theory, they have permission from their generals to travel and pay half fare; in reality, the soldier who actually has a ticket, let alone one for the class they are in, is the rarity. They not only ride in their uniforms but also rent them out to vendors and coolies who want to travel. Many railway officials in their fancy uniforms move through the trains, but they only take action against those without influence. Soldiers without tickets are sometimes gently told to return to third class, but no one has the moral courage to enforce this, and they ride on for hours, sometimes days. Police with a brass badge on their arms are always present, yet enforcement at the stations is almost nonexistent. Those boarding, along with swarms of coolies looking for baggage-carrying jobs, surge into the trains like a tidal wave before those getting off can escape; the scramble for seats is a chaotic uproar. In winter, a car never warms up comfortably before the overdressed Chinese fling open the windows. The cheap prankster who altered the standardized sign to read, “Passengers are requested to report to the Traffic Manager any cases of cleanliness that come to their notice,” replaced an impossible task with a very easy one. A train that runs on time is noteworthy, though occasionally one surprisingly sticks to the schedule.
At Peking and the principal terminals the traveler often finds every compartment “Reserved.” Officially this cannot in most cases be done, but any one who knows the ropes can “fix it up,” merely for a tip to the fixer. Door after door down the corridor bears such signs as “Chi Wan-tao and Party,” or “Reserved, Member of Parliament,” and even foreign women may be left to stand in the passageway. Later, if the traveler is sharp eyed enough to see one of these doors unlocked, he will find one or two fat Chinese stretched out in the two seats which placards announce “shall be occupied by eight persons,” and unless he is by nature aggressive this condition may continue during the whole twenty-four-hour journey. At the end of the overcrowded train there is very likely to be a private car surrounded by a respectful throng of soldiers and railway police, which one learns upon inquiry is occupied, to give a single example, by a “minister” to some provincial city, who is “more higher than a station-master.” A sample of the Chinese way of doing things is the announcement in a time-table in French that has appeared in the foreign-language newspapers daily for years that certain “expresses” on one of the most important lines carry first-class, sleeping-, and dining-cars, whereas the best accommodations the unsuspecting traveler who takes this statement seriously can discover is two or three second-class compartments with two bare wooden benches and not a suggestion of heat. The only salvation of the civilized traveler is the daily and biweekly expresses respectively on the two lines between Peking and central China, on which, thanks to foreign pressure, neither passes, uniforms, nor influence can take the place of tickets. Even on these, rumor has it, the militarist overlords have of late found ways to accommodate their henchmen without producing actual money.
At Peking and the main terminals, travelers often find every compartment marked “Reserved.” Officially, this shouldn't usually happen, but anyone who knows how things work can “arrange” it, just by giving a tip to the right person. Door after door down the corridor has signs like “Chi Wan-tao and Party” or “Reserved, Member of Parliament,” and even foreign women might be left standing in the hallway. Later, if a traveler is observant enough to spot one of these doors unlocked, they’ll find one or two overweight Chinese people sprawled in the two seats that the signs state “should be occupied by eight persons,” and unless they’re naturally assertive, this situation might persist throughout the entire twenty-four-hour journey. At the back of the crowded train, there's likely a private car surrounded by a respectful group of soldiers and railway police, which the traveler learns, upon asking, is occupied, for instance, by a “minister” from some provincial city, who is “higher than a station-master.” A typical example of the Chinese way of doing things is the announcement in a timetable in French that has appeared daily in foreign-language newspapers for years: certain “expresses” on one of the busiest routes offer first-class, sleeping, and dining cars, while the best accommodations available to the unsuspecting traveler who believes this statement are only two or three second-class compartments with two bare wooden benches and no hint of heating. The only salvation for the civilized traveler is the daily and biweekly expresses, respectively, on the two lines between Peking and central China, where, thanks to foreign pressure, neither passes, uniforms, nor influence can substitute for tickets. Even on these, it’s rumored that the militaristic overlords have recently found ways to accommodate their followers without requiring actual payment.
It is a relief, therefore, to get off on one of these side-lines which the Chinese do not yet pretend to have taken over, and which are still run like railroads. Shansi has her soldiers, too, but they do not spend their time riding in and out of the province. The simple expedient of requiring every coolie baggage-carrier to pay six coppers for a platform-ticket before he can pass the gates makes an astonishing improvement in the life of the traveler on this sprightly Taiyüanfu line; at the frontier two of the governor’s “model police” board the train in spotless khaki and with soldierly bearing escort it on into the capital.
It’s a relief, then, to take one of these side routes that the Chinese haven’t tried to take over yet, and which still operate like railroads. Shansi has its soldiers, too, but they don’t spend their time coming in and out of the province. The simple idea of making every coolie baggage-carrier pay six coppers for a platform ticket before passing through the gates makes a huge difference in the experience of travelers on this lively Taiyüanfu line; at the border, two of the governor’s “model police” get on the train in clean khaki and with a soldierly presence to escort it into the capital.

A few of the 508 Buddhas in one of the lama temples of Jehol
A few of the 508 Buddhas in one of the lama temples in Jehol

The youngest, but most important—since she has borne him a son—of the wives of a Manchu chief of one of the tomb-tending towns of Tung Ling
The youngest, but most important—since she has given him a son—of the wives of a Manchu chief from one of the tomb-tending towns of Tung Ling.

Interior of the notorious Empress Dowager’s tomb at Tung Ling, with her cloth-covered chair of state and colors to dazzle the stoutest eye
Interior of the infamous Empress Dowager’s tomb at Tung Ling, featuring her cloth-covered throne and colors that would impress even the hardiest of eyes.

The Potalá of Jehol, said to be a copy, even in details, of that of Lhasa; the windows are false and the great building at the top is merely a roofless one enclosing the chief temple
The Potalá of Jehol, claimed to be an exact replica, even in details, of the one in Lhasa; the windows are fake and the massive structure at the top is just a roofless building surrounding the main temple.
257Long before the end of the journey the traveler is reminded that Shansi is one of the world’s greatest deposits of coal, perhaps of iron. From the train could be seen coal-mines, mere surface diggings, but producing splendid anthracite in big chunks large as a strong man could lift. One of these broken in two made a donkey-load, two gave a mule his quota, and long trains of these animals picked their ways down the treeless defiles. Here and there a string of coolies, each with a lump of coal on his back, trailed over the steeper hills. A European who made a diligent investigation of the question reported that the province of Shansi alone has coal enough to supply the world for a thousand years. Thus far it has scarcely begun to be exploited, in the real sense of the word, like so many of the great natural resources, other than agricultural, of China. For one thing, some of the old superstitions that made delving in the earth so unpopular still prevail. Evil spirits guarding these hidden treasures will wreak vengeance on the men who dare to disturb them—and, what is worse, on the entire community. Dragons are still known to spit death-dealing fire upon those who dig too deeply for coal; in other words, there have been cases of fire-damp explosions. According to popular Chinese fancy, dragons, snakes, and tortoises produce pearls, and many of the miners themselves still think that coal will grow again in an empty shaft within thirty years, and iron and gold in longer periods.
257Long before the journey ends, the traveler is reminded that Shansi has some of the largest coal deposits in the world, and possibly iron as well. From the train, you can see coal mines, shallow diggings that yield large pieces of high-quality anthracite, big enough for a strong man to lift. A single piece split in two makes a load for a donkey, while two provide enough for a mule. Long lines of these animals make their way down the bare valleys. Here and there, a group of laborers, each carrying a lump of coal on their backs, make their way over the steeper hills. A European who thoroughly investigated the situation reported that the Shansi province alone has enough coal to supply the world for a thousand years. So far, it has barely been tapped, like many of China’s significant non-agricultural natural resources. One reason is that old superstitions that made mining unpopular still linger. It's believed that evil spirits guarding these hidden treasures will punish those who disturb them—and even the entire community. Dragons are said to unleash deadly fire on those who dig too deep for coal; in other words, there have been instances of gas explosions. According to popular Chinese belief, dragons, snakes, and turtles create pearls, and many miners still think that coal can regenerate in an empty shaft within thirty years, with iron and gold taking even longer.
We came out in mid-afternoon upon the broad plain of Shansi, “West of the Mountains,” two or three thousand feet above sea-level and thickly dotted everywhere with toiling peasants. Here the windlassing of water for irrigation again seemed to be the chief occupation, and this time there were often four men at as many handles over a single well-drum. Yütze swarmed with travelers, for there nearly all the traffic for the south of the province leaves the train, or enters it to return to the capital, toward which the railroad turns as much north as westward. Less than an hour later the twin pagodas of Taiyüanfu rose close at hand on the ridged landscape, and we were set down well outside the walls of the Shansi capital.
We came out in the middle of the afternoon onto the wide plain of Shansi, “West of the Mountains,” at an elevation of two or three thousand feet above sea level, bustling with hardworking peasants. Here, hauling water for irrigation appeared to be the main job, and often there were four men at four handles over one well. Yütze was crowded with travelers since almost all the traffic heading south in the province either gets off the train or gets on it to return to the capital, toward which the railroad goes as much north as it does west. Less than an hour later, the twin pagodas of Taiyüanfu appeared close by on the hilly landscape, and we were dropped off well outside the walls of the Shansi capital.
The police stopped every traveler at the city gate to ask his name, his errand, and other pertinent questions. But there was a courteous atmosphere about the interrogatory which made it seem the precaution of a careful ruler rather than the espionage of a tyrant. Inside, the 258streets were on the whole in better condition, modern improvements in general more numerous, than in most provincial capitals. Yet somehow this was not yet the model city much hearing about it had caused the imagination to picture. The pace of life, too, was noticeably slow, surprisingly so for the capital of one of China’s most important provinces, almost the cradle of the Chinese race and for centuries the home of its great bankers. What was perhaps most exasperating of all to the passing traveler was to find the rickshaw-men the poorest in China, so slow and so untrained for their tasks that it was almost faster and certainly more comfortable to walk. Possibly the altitude of nearly three thousand feet was the explanation, though not the excuse, of their snail-like habits, and their awkwardness could be largely due to the fact that many of them are peasants from the surrounding villages who make rickshaw-pulling a slack-time avocation instead of a profession. But the impression survived that they were merely outstanding examples of the provincial leisureliness of life back here behind the mountains. Residents did not seem to realize that their rickshaw-runners resemble lame turtles, any more than they were aware of the incessant unnecessary racket they create. Custom or some local ordinance has fitted the right shaft of all Taiyüan rickshaws with a kind of automobile horn, and not merely do the runners blow these beyond all reason when in action but amuse themselves like the adult children they are by constant honking while waiting or wandering for fares, so that night and day are an unbroken charivari.
The police checked every traveler at the city gate, asking for their name, purpose, and other relevant questions. However, there was a polite vibe to the questioning that made it feel more like a precaution from a careful ruler than the spying of a tyrant. Inside, the streets were generally in better shape, with more modern improvements compared to most provincial capitals. Yet, somehow, it still wasn’t the ideal city that all the talk had led people to envision. The pace of life was noticeably slow, surprisingly so for the capital of one of China’s most important provinces, which is almost the birthplace of the Chinese race and has been home to its great bankers for centuries. What was perhaps most frustrating for travelers was discovering that the rickshaw pullers were the poorest in China, moving so slowly and lacking training for their jobs that it was almost faster and definitely more comfortable to walk. Possibly the altitude of nearly three thousand feet explained, though didn’t excuse, their sluggishness, and their awkwardness could mostly be attributed to the fact that many were peasants from nearby villages who treated rickshaw pulling as a side job instead of a career. Nevertheless, the impression lingered that they were merely standout examples of the provincial laziness of life back here behind the mountains. Locals didn’t seem to notice that their rickshaw runners resembled lame turtles, nor were they aware of the constant unnecessary noise they created. Some custom or local regulation had equipped the right shaft of all Taiyüan rickshaws with a kind of car horn, and not only did the runners blow them excessively while in motion, but they also entertained themselves like the grown-up children they were by continuously honking while waiting for or wandering in search of passengers, resulting in a non-stop noise fest both day and night.
Taiyüan—its name means “great plain,” and the “fu” so often tacked on to the names of second-grade Chinese cities is as out-of-date now as the word “yamen,” though both survive in popular speech—and the province it governs still retain some of the traits and customs of olden times, long ago abandoned, if not forgotten, in other provinces. Though there is a good modern police force, night-watchmen of the old régime go their rounds every two hours beating a gong to warn thieves of their coming. Surely the origin of this aged custom, whatever tradition may allege, is rooted in the inherent timidity, not to call it cowardice, of the Chinese. Pushed beyond a certain point they can die more easily than Westerners; but the fear of a mere slap, the sight of a stick that would not frighten a normal American boy, is terrifying to the great mass of them. Naturally the night-watchman would rather warn the thieves to move on, or to lay aside their activities until he has passed, than to come to blows with them. A thousand Chinese staring fixedly with their little monkey-like eyes were likely to surround 259the foreigner who does, or has about him, anything suggestive of the unusual, though foreign residents are neither rare nor new. No one has ever succeeded in sounding the depths of Chinese curiosity. When I called inopportunely on the fellow-countryman who was destined to become my host in Taiyüan, he left a class of Y. M. C. A. students of university age, long used to foreigners and their ways, in charge of one of their number while he stepped out to have a word with me; and seven of the fifteen young men left the class and followed him down-stairs to see what he was doing.
Taiyüan—its name means "great plain," and the "fu" often added to the names of second-tier Chinese cities is as outdated now as the term "yamen," though both are still used in everyday conversation—and the province it oversees still holds on to some of the traits and customs from the past, which have long been abandoned, if not forgotten, in other provinces. Even though there's a decent modern police force, the night-watchmen from the old days go around every two hours, beating a gong to warn thieves of their approach. The roots of this old custom, regardless of what tradition might say, stem from the inherent timidity, or perhaps cowardice, of the Chinese. When pushed too far, they may die more easily than Westerners; however, the fear of just a slap or the sight of a stick that wouldn't scare a typical American boy is terrifying for the majority of them. Naturally, the night-watchman would prefer to alert the thieves to move along or pause their activities until he has passed, rather than confront them directly. A thousand Chinese, with their small, monkey-like eyes, are likely to surround a foreigner who has anything about him that seems out of the ordinary, even though foreign residents are neither rare nor new. No one has ever truly understood the depth of Chinese curiosity. When I dropped by unexpectedly to see the fellow-countryman who would become my host in Taiyüan, he left a group of university-age Y.M.C.A. students, who were already familiar with foreigners and their customs, under the care of one of their peers while he stepped out for a quick chat with me; and seven of the fifteen young men ditched the class and followed him downstairs to see what he was up to.
The foreign atmosphere of Taiyüan is almost entirely British. Such American missionaries as work in this province are not stationed in the capital, and England assigned the indemnity exacted for the killing of a large group of her nationals here in Boxer days to education in the province, as we did for the whole country. For ten years Shansi youths were distributed among English universities and technical schools, and now that the preparatory school in which they were groomed for the journey has reverted to the Chinese and become the University of Taiyüan, there are many returned students among the faculty and in important official positions, some of them with English wives. The good and the trivial points of British university life came back with them. They seem to have lost, for instance, the Chinese virtue of early rising. Taiyüan labors under the handicap of three kinds of time,—“railway,” “gun,” and “university” time. The last is considerably slower than either the station clock or the governor’s noon-gun, and rumor has it that it gradually became so because the curriculum included a number of eight-o’clock classes which certain of the most influential faculty members could never quite reach.
The atmosphere in Taiyüan feels almost entirely British. The American missionaries working in this province are not based in the capital, and England allocated the compensation it received for the deaths of a large number of its citizens during the Boxer Rebellion to education in the province, just as we did for the entire country. For a decade, young people from Shansi were sent to English universities and technical schools, and now that the preparatory school that trained them for this journey has returned to Chinese control and become the University of Taiyüan, there are many returning students among the faculty and in key government positions, some of whom have British wives. They brought back both the positive and trivial aspects of British university life. For example, they seem to have abandoned the Chinese virtue of waking up early. Taiyüan struggles with three different time standards—“railway,” “gun,” and “university” time. The latter runs significantly slower than both the station clock and the governor’s noon gun, and it’s said that this happened because the timetable included several 8 a.m. classes that some of the most influential faculty members could never quite make it to.
Yen Hsi-shan, both military and civil governor of Shansi, is known in China as the “model governor.” The mere fact that he has held his position ever since the revolution, while the rest of the country has been like a seething mass, a boiling kettle, of officials of all grades, in which the scum has all too often come to the top, is enough to have given him that title. But he has done more than that to warrant it. Under his rule a number of motor roads have radiated from the capital, and now carry a considerable motor-bus traffic. It is true that these roads are largely due to American famine relief funds under missionary management, and that the principal highway runs about two hundred li northward exactly to the governor’s native village. But they are unusually well kept roads for China, with guards enough to keep the 260sharp-wheeled carts off them, and a species of peon caminero at regular distances whose permanent task it is to keep them in repair. Besides, a branch of that north road goes on, as a kind of afterthought, to a gate of the inner Great Wall, which crosses northern Shansi. Governor Yen has done much toward the establishment of village schools, with the accent wisely on primary and general instead of higher and class education; he has made a certain amount of schooling compulsory for both sexes, though even he would scarcely assert that such an innovation is already effective throughout the province, for after all Shansi is still China. He has actually and visibly taken the beggars off the streets of Taiyüan; and has established a school of trades for them. He has improved outdoor recreation facilities for the people, and has had erected in conspicuous places about town, and in the province, long boards bearing the thousand characters which he thinks every one should learn to read and, if possible, to write. Bandits have been unknown in Shansi for years; the opium which it used to grow more widely than any other province has almost if not completely disappeared. Both these curses of China have been chased over the provincial boundaries. Taiyüan boasts a beginning of an opium-consumers’ refuge, with free keep and treatment for the indigent. Just beyond it, to be sure, there is what the Japanese call a yoshiwara, an officially protected restricted district two by four blocks large, with five hundred women; but every one of the identical courtyards within is in a condition to suggest unusually good sanitary conditions, and a high wall surrounds the entire district, so that no one can be in doubt as to what he is entering. The governor, by the way, was a student in Japan for four years, and both he and his policies bear various reminders of that fact.
Yen Hsi-shan, both the military and civil governor of Shansi, is known in China as the "model governor." The fact that he has held his position since the revolution, while the rest of the country has been like a boiling pot of officials of all levels, where the worst have often risen to the top, is enough to earn him that title. But he has done more than that to deserve it. Under his leadership, several motor roads have been created from the capital and now carry a significant number of motor-bus passengers. It's true that these roads were largely built with American famine relief funds managed by missionaries and that the main highway leads about two hundred li north to the governor's hometown. However, they are unusually well-maintained roads for China, with enough guards to keep sharp-wheeled carts off of them, and there are workers stationed at regular intervals whose job is to keep them in good repair. Additionally, a branch of that northern road connects, almost as an afterthought, to a gate in the inner Great Wall that runs through northern Shansi. Governor Yen has made significant strides in establishing village schools, wisely focusing on primary and general education rather than just higher or specialized education; he has made a certain amount of schooling mandatory for both boys and girls, although even he would not claim that this change is fully effective across the province, since Shansi is still part of China after all. He has visibly removed beggars from the streets of Taiyüan and set up a vocational school for them. He has also improved outdoor recreational facilities for the community and has placed large boards in prominent locations around the town and throughout the province displaying the thousand characters he believes everyone should learn to read and, if possible, to write. There have been no bandits in Shansi for years, and the opium that was once more prevalent there than in any other province has nearly disappeared, if not completely. Both of these social issues have been pushed beyond the province's borders. Taiyüan has seen the beginning of a refuge for opium users, offering free housing and treatment for the needy. Just nearby, however, there is what the Japanese refer to as a yoshiwara, an officially protected area measuring two by four blocks, housing five hundred women; but every courtyard within is notably clean, and a tall wall encloses the entire area, so that there's no confusion about what one is entering. By the way, the governor studied in Japan for four years, and both he and his policies reflect various aspects of that experience.

Behind Tung Ling the great forest reserve which once “protected” the tombs from the evil spirits that always come from the north was recently opened to settlers, and frontier conditions long since forgotten in the rest of China prevail
Behind Tung Ling, the vast forest reserve that used to "protect" the tombs from the malevolent spirits that always come from the north has recently been opened to settlers, and the frontier conditions that have been long forgotten in the rest of China are now present.

Much of the plowing in the newly opened tract is done in this primitive fashion
Much of the plowing in the newly opened area is done in this basic way.

The face of the mammoth Buddha of Jehol, forty-three feet high and with forty-two hands. It fills a four-story building, and is the largest in China proper, being identical, according to the lamas, with those of Urga and Lhasa
The huge Buddha statue at Jehol stands forty-three feet tall and has forty-two hands. It occupies a four-story building and is the largest in mainland China, resembling those in Urga and Lhasa, according to the lamas.

A Chinese inn, with its heated k’ang, may not be the last word in comfort, but it is many degrees in advance of the earth floors of Indian huts along the Andes
A Chinese inn, with its heated k’ang, may not be the ultimate in comfort, but it is far better than the dirt floors of Indian huts in the Andes.
261The governor received me one Sunday morning, with his civil secretary, the British-educated dean of the engineering department of the university, as interpreter. It seemed almost strange to walk so peacefully into his yamen through the same now rather tumble-down entrance at which more than twoscore foreigners were massacred by Boxer-influenced mobs in 1900. The governor prides himself on being a plain man and does not believe in surrounding himself with magnificence or formality. With the single exception of the “Christian General,” Feng Yü-hsiang, he has retained, at least in his audiences with foreigners, fewer of the useless, time-squandering forms of old-fashioned Chinese etiquette than any of the high officials I have met in China. Yet the essential Chinese courtesies were still there; there was no suggestion of a general surrender to Western bruskness. A solid-looking man, in physical as well as the other sense, with a somewhat genial face sunburned with evidence of his personal attention to his outdoor activities, met us with no appreciable delay in a semi-private part of the yamen that was tasteful in the Chinese sense, yet which made no efforts at magnificence in the hope of increasing the impression of the occupant’s importance. Rather a man of plain common sense and perseverance than of brilliancy, a brief acquaintance with the governor suggested; and Heaven knows China needs this type just now much more than the other. His garments were of cotton, not silk, and the simplicity of life this symbolizes has its effect upon his subordinates, at least in his presence. Officials having an audience with him usually also put on cotton clothing for the occasion, lest the governor say, as he has more than once: “Ah, I see you are making lots of money out of your post. Now, there is a famine down in the southwest corner of the province, and ...” He talked freely, yet certainly not boastfully, of his various policies, plain, common-sense policies, like the man himself, but which do not suggest themselves to the Chinese as readily as one might expect. Later I had opportunity to compare actual results with verbal intentions.
261The governor met with me one Sunday morning, accompanied by his civil secretary, the British-educated dean of the engineering department at the university, who served as our interpreter. It felt almost surreal to walk so peacefully into his yamen through the now somewhat run-down entrance where more than twenty foreigners were killed by Boxer-influenced mobs in 1900. The governor takes pride in being a straightforward person and doesn't believe in surrounding himself with extravagance or formality. With the exception of the “Christian General,” Feng Yü-hsiang, he maintains fewer of the outdated, time-wasting rituals of traditional Chinese etiquette during meetings with foreigners than any other high official I’ve encountered in China. Still, the basic Chinese courtesies were present; there was no indication of a complete shift to Western brusqueness. A sturdy-looking man, both physically and otherwise, with a somewhat friendly face that showed signs of sun exposure from his outdoor activities, greeted us promptly in a semi-private area of the yamen. The space was tasteful in a Chinese way, yet didn’t try to appear grand to enhance the occupant’s importance. He came across more as a sensible and persistent person than as a brilliant one, and it seemed clear that China needs more of his kind at this moment rather than others. His clothes were made of cotton, not silk, and the simplicity this choice represents influences his subordinates, at least while he’s around. Officials meeting with him generally wear cotton clothing too, to avoid his remarking, as he has before: “Ah, I see you’re making a lot of money from your position. There’s a famine in the southwest corner of the province, and…” He spoke openly, but certainly not boastfully, about his various policies—simple, practical policies that reflect his character but aren’t as readily apparent to the Chinese as one might think. Later, I had the chance to compare actual outcomes with his stated intentions.
His laws against opium and bound feet would be better enforced, Yen Hsi-shan’s friendly critics agree, if the officials under him were really in favor of such reforms. One man alone cannot cure a whole province, larger than most of our States, of the bad habits of generations. At first the governor was very assiduous on these points. Traffickers in, as well as growers of, the drug were fined and imprisoned, and life made as miserable as possible for those who persisted in consuming it. Inspectors examined the feet of women and assessed a fine of five dollars a year against those who had not unbound them, or who bound those of their daughters. Not a severe penalty from the Western point of view; but this is much money to the average Chinese countryman, and bound feet are most persistent in the rural districts. But the governor’s lee high (severity) is dying out, the people say, and little girls with bound feet may be seen near and even in Taiyüan. The stoutest reformer would be likely to lose heart before the unrivaled passive resistance of the Chinese against even their own best welfare; it needs unbroken generations of radicals to get permanent results. At least the pigtail has virtually disappeared from Shansi!
His laws against opium and bound feet would be better enforced, Yen Hsi-shan’s friendly critics agree, if the officials under him genuinely supported such reforms. One person alone cannot fix a whole province, which is larger than most of our States, of the bad habits built up over generations. Initially, the governor was very diligent about these issues. Traffickers and growers of the drug were fined and imprisoned, and life was made as miserable as possible for those who continued to use it. Inspectors checked the feet of women and imposed a fine of five dollars a year on those who hadn’t unbound them, or who bound those of their daughters. Not a severe penalty by Western standards; but this is a lot of money for the average Chinese farmer, and bound feet are especially persistent in rural areas. However, the governor’s lee high (severity) is fading, people say, and little girls with bound feet can be seen around and even in Taiyüan. The strongest reformer would likely lose hope in the face of the unmatched passive resistance of the Chinese against even their own best interests; it takes unbroken generations of radicals to achieve lasting change. At least the pigtail has virtually disappeared from Shansi!
The “model governor” comes fairly near being a practical man in 262the Occidental sense. The forty automobiles in the government garages include huge streetcar-like buses that make good use of his new roads, and trucks that are run mainly by steam. Gasolene is expensive in Shansi, and coal is cheap. Much of the city is taken up by what resembles immense barracks, and the public is chased many blocks roundabout by the long mud walls enclosing them. But if this gives the appearance of a ruler who considers the capital his private property, it makes possible a great normal school for all the province, where handcrafts are given proper attention, up-to-date soldiers’ workshops, in which everything needed by the army is made, a model prison, and other spacious institutions on quite modern lines. Besides, there was evidently ample room inside the city. The old wall of Taiyüan is in a ruinous state, and any one can climb it, almost anywhere inside and with no great difficulty from without, as if the governor realized that such picturesque defenses are useless against modern attacks, and feels able to cope in the open with the bandits against which city walls still offer a certain amount of protection in many parts of China. There are lakes and broad sheep pastures, and many acres of cultivated fields, within the walls, and only one suburb of any size outside them, without a single smoking chimney except those of the big extramural arsenal standing forth against the distant low hills that half surround Taiyüan. In fact, one whole corner of the city is used as a rifle-range, with the ruined wall as a back-stop, and the soldiers still find plenty of room to throw their dummy hand-grenades and practise their modified goose-step. All this hardly means a prosperous city, were it not for the practical activities of a good governor. His soldiers, by the way, get six “Mex” dollars a month, which is the rate throughout most of China, and his “snappy” model police nine; but unlike so many of his colleagues Governor Yen actually pays his troops, which is one of the great secrets of his success. Unpaid soldiers not only do not drive brigands over the frontier, but they are prone to sell them ammunition and even to join them.
The "model governor" is pretty much a practical person in a Western sense. The forty cars in the government garages include large buses that effectively use his new roads, along with steam-powered trucks. Gasoline is pricey in Shansi, but coal is cheap. Much of the city looks like huge barracks, and the public is often forced to navigate several blocks around the long mud walls that enclose them. While this creates the impression of a ruler treating the capital like his personal possession, it also allows for the establishment of a large normal school for the entire province, where handcrafts are properly taught, modern workshops for soldiers where everything needed by the army is produced, a model prison, and other spacious institutions designed along contemporary lines. Furthermore, there’s clearly plenty of space within the city. The old wall of Taiyüan is in ruins, and anyone can climb it almost anywhere from the inside and with little trouble from the outside, as if the governor understands that such picturesque defenses are ineffective against modern attacks and feels confident in dealing with bandits in the open, where city walls still provide some protection in many areas of China. Inside the walls, there are lakes, wide sheep pastures, and many acres of cultivated fields, with only one sizable suburb outside them, lacking any smoking chimneys except for those of the large external arsenal standing against the distant low hills that partially surround Taiyüan. In fact, one corner of the city is used as a rifle range, with the ruined wall serving as a backstop, and soldiers still find ample space to throw dummy hand grenades and practice their modified goose step. All of this hardly suggests a thriving city, were it not for the practical efforts of an effective governor. By the way, his soldiers earn six "Mex" dollars a month, which is the standard rate throughout most of China, while his "sharp" model police earn nine; but unlike many of his peers, Governor Yen actually pays his troops, which is one of the key secrets to his success. Unpaid soldiers not only fail to drive brigands over the border, but they're also likely to sell them ammunition and even join them.
It was evident that the governor’s progressive administration includes one particular pet scheme, which he is working out as rapidly as possible, quite ready to admit that it takes time to make changes in China. He is gradually introducing a village military system, a kind of National Guard on a provincial scale. Instead of having military parasites from other provinces come to exploit the people or turn bandits among them, he is organizing militia companies for local protection. The chief advantages he expects are that it will thus be easier to maintain 263peace and repel outside invaders, as village soldiers will naturally do their best to protect their own homes; it should eliminate the danger of becoming an offensive force against neighboring provinces, since these soldiers are not riffraff and loafers recruited wherever they can be had but ordinary citizens with proper occupations, who will not care to sacrifice their peaceful living for the sake of a few ambitious militarists; and it does not take them away from their fields or their usual tasks, except for brief periods of training each year. It is not exactly an original plan, at least to the world at large, but self-evident things are not always so to the Chinese, and Governor Yen may be on the track of the very thing to wipe out rapacious militarism and its twin sister, banditry.
It was clear that the governor’s progressive administration has one particular pet project he is pushing forward as quickly as possible, while acknowledging that change takes time in China. He is gradually rolling out a village military system, essentially a kind of National Guard on a provincial level. Instead of having military outsiders come to exploit the people or turn into bandits among them, he is setting up militia companies for local defense. The main benefits he expects are that it will be easier to maintain peace and fend off outside invaders, as local soldiers will naturally do their best to protect their homes; it should eliminate the risk of becoming an aggressive force against neighboring provinces, since these soldiers are not just aimless drifters recruited from anywhere but regular citizens with legitimate jobs, who won’t want to jeopardize their peaceful lives for the sake of a few ambitious military leaders; and it won’t pull them away from their fields or usual tasks, except for short training periods each year. It’s not exactly a groundbreaking idea, at least to the wider world, but obvious things aren’t always so obvious to the Chinese, and Governor Yen might be on to the solution to eliminate greedy militarism and its counterpart, banditry.
The mass of the people of Shansi are convinced that the governor loves them like a father, which is a very essential thing in China even for a virtual dictator, if he wishes to hold out. Yet Yen is a rich man, one of the richest men in China, some say, and he was not born that way. Only the uninformed masses think that he sacrifices everything to their welfare. Any land with China’s pressure of population, family system, and centuries-old, almost universal political corruption from top to bottom would need at least a demigod of which to make a ruler who actually thought of nothing but the public good. Yen Hsi-shan, it is said almost openly, has kept his position so long largely by preserving a strict neutrality even in the payment of “squeeze” toward those high up who might have taken his job away from him. It is almost publicly known that he gave one million two hundred thousand dollars each to Chang Tso-lin and Tsao Kun in the “Anfu” days as “military assistance.” But at least he has made the province he has ruled for twelve unbroken years a better place to live in; his worst enemies do not hesitate to admit that. Perhaps he is, as many Chinese who use their minds assert, a great governor only as a small hill is a mountain on a flat plain; the fact remains that he has some ideas and the will to carry them out, ideas which, if introduced into the other provinces would put the people of China in a much better position to solve some of those pressing problems that seem to be driving them to national destruction. With a score of Governors Yen the dismantled old Celestial Empire might still be no paradise, but the anxious visitor can sweep the country almost in vain for a glimpse of any other force that promises prompt and effectual resistance to the misfortunes that threaten to overwhelm her entirely.
The people of Shansi believe that their governor loves them like a father, which is really important in China, even for someone with almost absolute power, if he wants to maintain his position. However, Yen is a wealthy man, one of the richest in China, and he didn’t start out that way. Only those who aren’t well-informed think he gives up everything for their well-being. Any area in China, with its overpopulation, family structure, and deep-rooted political corruption, would need someone almost divine to rule and truly focus on the public’s good. Yen Hsi-shan has reportedly kept his position for so long by staying neutral, even with “squeeze” payments to those in power who could have taken his job. It’s almost common knowledge that he provided over one million two hundred thousand dollars to Chang Tso-lin and Tsao Kun during the “Anfu” period as “military assistance.” But at least he has improved the province he has governed for twelve uninterrupted years; even his fiercest critics acknowledge that. Some Chinese thinkers suggest that he is a great governor, but only in comparison to a small hill being a mountain in a flat landscape; nonetheless, he does have ideas and the determination to implement them. If his ideas were applied to other provinces, they could significantly help the people of China address some of the critical problems leading them toward national destruction. With a few more governors like Yen, the broken old Celestial Empire might not be a paradise, but the worried observer would struggle to find any other force capable of effectively resisting the overwhelming challenges facing the country.
All up and down the province the happy results of good rule are 264apparent. Village girls, like the boys who come to the various barrack-institutions in the capital, are taught what they are really likely to need in the life that in all probability lies before them, not the often useless stuff of an ideal but imaginary life, to which even American mission schools are somewhat prone. There are still such adversities as famine in Shansi Province, and numbers of its men migrate northward to Mongolia and Manchuria in search of the livelihood their ancestral homes deny them. But even a civil and military governor combined cannot make rain fall. More than one Tuchun of other provinces still thinks he can, and leads his people in processions to the temples of the god of rain, or helps them to plant that delinquent deity, in a brand-new coat of paint as a counter-inducement, out in the blazing sunshine, in the hope that he will think better of the cruel neglect of his duties. One suspects, however, that Governor Yen’s more up-to-date methods are likelier in the end to bring real results. But, alas! safety and modern improvements are not what most beguile the random wanderer with a strong penchant for the picturesque, and a longer stay in the “model province” promised little to make up for the exciting things that might still be in store for me in other parts of the country.
All throughout the province, the beneficial effects of good governance are clear. Village girls, like the boys attending various military schools in the capital, are taught practical skills likely to be useful in their future lives, rather than the often unnecessary subjects of an idealized but unrealistic life, which even American mission schools sometimes emphasize. There are still challenges like famine in Shansi Province, and many of its men move north to Mongolia and Manchuria in search of the livelihoods their hometowns can't provide. But even a combined civil and military governor cannot make it rain. More than one military governor in other provinces still believes he can, leading his people in marches to the rain god's temples or dressing up that unreliable deity in fresh paint as a bribe, hoping he'll reconsider his neglect of duty under the hot sun. However, it seems that Governor Yen's more modern methods are more likely to achieve real results in the end. Sadly, safety and modern advancements aren't what usually attract wandering tourists with a strong love for the scenic; a longer stay in the "model province" promised little to make up for the thrilling experiences I might still find in other parts of the country.
CHAPTER XV
WANDERINGS IN THE LAND OF CONFUCIUS
The chief impression of the long all-day journey from Peking to Tzinan in early spring is of graves. All sizes of them, from mere haycocks to veritable haystacks, take up almost more of the fields than they leave to cultivation, so that the deadly flat landscape, drearily dry brown at this season, looks as if it were broken out with smallpox. In Chihli Province there had been no real snow all winter; but from about the time we entered Shantung onward the shrinking remnants of a recent modest fall of it varied slightly the bare yellowish monotony spread out under a cloudless sky.
The main impression of the long all-day trip from Beijing to Jinan in early spring is of graves. They come in all sizes, from small mounds to large heaps, taking up more of the fields than are left for farming, making the dull flat landscape, which is a dry brown at this time of year, look like it’s covered in smallpox. In Hebei Province, there hadn’t been any real snow all winter; but once we entered Shandong, the fading remnants of a recent light snowfall slightly broke up the bare yellowish monotony spread out under a clear sky.
The old walled city of Teh-chow was the first place of importance over the boundary, and there was nothing visibly different about that from a hundred other walled cities of China. At one end of the long graveled station platform sat an old coffin, and lying on top of it was the stone that had marked its first grave and was needed now for the new one somewhere else. The Chinese are coming to be more easily persuaded by the clink of silver that their ancestors will endure removal, when a railway or a growing mission station or an industrial plant finds it imperative to have more room. A policeman quite as up to date as those of Peking was driving up and down the platform two men who seemed to have known some prosperity before this misfortune overtook them. Ropes tied to their outside arms furnished the driver his reins, and about their necks hung by cords big wooden placards detailing their crimes. The officer saw to it that they forced their way into every group, so that there could be no excuse for any one, in or outside the long crowded train, not to recognize them as rascals, before he drove them back to wherever they waited until the next train called them forth again. It was an anachronism, this ancient mode of punishment amid such modern surroundings; but what would be the effect if our own absconding bankers and sneak-thieves were similarly paraded from suburbs to railroad station, pausing for any one who cared to read? It would at least make their faces more familiar to those who might 266benefit in future by such knowledge. But on second thought our press serves us the same purpose, without physical exertion to criminals or policemen.
The old walled city of Teh-chow was the first significant place across the border, and it didn't look any different from a hundred other walled cities in China. At one end of the long gravel station platform sat an old coffin, with the stone that marked its first grave lying on top, now needed for a new grave somewhere else. The Chinese are becoming more easily convinced by the sound of silver that their ancestors can be relocated when a railway, a growing mission station, or an industrial site needs more space. A policeman, just as modern as those in Peking, was driving two men up and down the platform who seemed to have known some wealth before this misfortune. Ropes tied to their outer arms acted as reins for the officer, and large wooden signs detailing their crimes hung around their necks by cords. The officer made sure they pushed their way into every group, leaving no excuse for anyone in or outside the long crowded train not to recognize them as criminals before he took them back to wherever they waited until the next train called them again. It was an anachronism, this old-fashioned punishment amidst such modern surroundings; but what if our own runaway bankers and petty thieves were similarly displayed from suburbs to train stations, stopping for anyone who wanted to read? It would at least make their faces more recognizable to those who might benefit from that knowledge in the future. But on second thought, our media serves the same purpose without requiring any physical effort from criminals or police.
At Teh-chow the ancient and the modern means of transportation between the Yang Tse and Peking part company. All the way from Tientsin, the railroad which, about a decade back, brought Shanghai within thirty-six hours of the capital is within rifle-shot of the Grand Canal that Kublai Khan merely reconstructed six hundred and fifty years ago. Before we realized that maps and modern conditions are not counterparts in the China of to-day, we had a pleasant dream of houseboating from Peking to the Yang Tse, when it came time for us to move southward. Intuition should have sufficed, but we only learned from inquiry that, since the tribute grain which once came yearly to Peking by hundreds of junks could now come by other means, if any one still gave Peking tribute, the Grand Canal has silted up for long distances, to say nothing of the bandit nests through which it runs in these days of the self-styled republic. Once the railroad meets and crosses it again, at the southern boundary of the province; otherwise the two routes are never in agreement below Teh-chow.
At Teh-chow, the old and new transportation methods between the Yangtze and Beijing diverge. All the way from Tianjin, the railroad, which about ten years ago connected Shanghai to the capital in just thirty-six hours, runs close to the Grand Canal that Kublai Khan merely reconstructed six hundred and fifty years ago. Before we realized that maps and modern conditions don’t match up in today's China, we had a nice dream of houseboating from Beijing to the Yangtze when it was time for us to head south. We should have trusted our instincts, but we only learned through asking around that, since the tribute grain that once arrived in Beijing annually through hundreds of junks can now come by other means—if anyone even still sent tribute to Beijing—the Grand Canal has silted up over long stretches, not to mention the bandit hideouts along its route in these days of the so-called republic. Once the railroad meets and crosses it again at the southern edge of the province; otherwise, the two routes never align below Teh-chow.
The capital of Shantung Province announces itself by its smokestacks about the time the rumbling of the long German-built bridge across the Yellow River awakens the traveler to the fact that the day’s ordeal is over. Flour-mills account for most of these spirals of smoke where ten or fifteen years ago little more than graves grew. Tzinan is an exception to the general rule of Chinese treaty-ports, in that it was opened to foreign trade in 1906 by desire from within rather than pressure from without. The Germans, and after them the Japanese, have built up a fore-city of broad, almost-paved streets, lined by modern buildings that here and there approach the imposing, on the space turned over to the growth of foreign enterprise by the Chinese themselves. Japanese hospitals and schools, buildings that carry the thoughts back to the bridge-heads on the Rhine, here and there a contribution by some other nationality, give quite a manly air to this modern section of Shang-Pu, with its railway stations. But if one’s mind has that queer and no doubt reprehensible quirk which makes the picturesque more interesting than standardized efficiency, the wheelbarrows are strong competitors for the attention. In Peking and the north these are less used, and not at all for passengers. In Tzinan they carry a much larger proportion of the population than do the rickshaws. For while the latter are numerous also, their capacity is limited, and there seems 267to be no exact high-water mark to the number of persons a barrow-man can crowd upon the two cushions flanking his high wooden wheel, with its guards doing duty as seat-backs. Especially when the factory workers are going to or from their mud huts, eight or ten, and even twelve, pairs of little misshapen feet hang over the sides of these patient vehicles, still barely bending the sturdy back of the human packhorse in the shafts. Men ride in them, too, sometimes a pair or a group of coolies whom it would be impossible to distinguish from the man whom they are, one must assume, paying to do their walking for them. A wheelbarrow trip costs but a half or two thirds as much as the same journey by rickshaw; the mere matter of greater speed or comfort is not, of course, of any importance to the rank-and-file Chinese; and the invariable ungreased squeaking of the conveyance, which announces its coming as far off as could a trolley-bell, may easily be soothing music to a people who enter Chinese theaters without compulsion.
The capital of Shantung Province makes itself known by its smokestacks around the time the rumbling of the long German-built bridge spanning the Yellow River alerts travelers that the day’s journey is over. Most of these spirals of smoke come from flour mills, where, ten or fifteen years ago, there were barely more than graves. Tzinan stands out among Chinese treaty ports because it was opened to foreign trade in 1906 due to internal demand rather than external pressure. The Germans, followed by the Japanese, have developed a fore-city with wide, almost-paved streets lined with modern buildings that occasionally reach an imposing stature on the land allocated for foreign business by the Chinese themselves. Japanese hospitals and schools, buildings that evoke memories of the Rhine bridgeheads, along with occasional contributions from other nationalities, give a robust air to this modern section of Shang-Pu, complete with its railway stations. However, if one has that strange and arguably questionable tendency to find the picturesque more captivating than standardized efficiency, the wheelbarrows very much compete for attention. In Peking and the north, these are used less frequently, and not at all for passengers. In Tzinan, they carry a much larger portion of the population than rickshaws do. While rickshaws are plentiful as well, their capacity is limited, and there seems to be no clear upper limit on the number of people a wheelbarrow-man can fit onto the two cushions next to his high wooden wheel, with its guards serving as seatbacks. Especially when workers are commuting to and from their mud huts, eight or ten, or even twelve, pairs of little misshapen feet hang over the sides of these patient vehicles, barely straining the sturdy back of the human packhorse in the shafts. Men ride in them too, sometimes as pairs or groups of coolies who it would be impossible to distinguish from the person they are presumably paying to walk for them. A trip in a wheelbarrow costs about half or two-thirds as much as the same journey by rickshaw; in terms of speed or comfort, of course, none of this matters to the everyday Chinese people; and the constant squeaking of the transport, which can be heard from a distance just like a trolley bell, is likely soothing music to a people who enter Chinese theaters without coercion.
The main stream of squeaks ambles its way into the old native city, doubly surrounded by two rambling walls. There the recent snow had left what passes for streets ankle-deep in mud, except perhaps for a few short stretches paved centuries ago with huge slabs of stone so rounded off now that a rickshaw can scarcely make wheelbarrow speed over them, and which at best are only somewhat less thickly covered with paste-like slime. Foreigners who have lived there half a century say they can see improvements in the native life of old Tzinan, but the new-comer will have to take most of this on faith, and is not likely to carry off many impressions essentially different from those he has had or will have inside the walls of any well populated Chinese city. Merchants in black lounge in skullcaps in constantly repeated little booth-shops on either hand, outwardly indifferent to custom as they sip their tea from handleless cups, smoke their tiny pipes with the often yard-long stems, play chess, checkers, cards, or dice, all of an Oriental kind. Immediate attention comes, however, when a possible client pauses in what would be the doorway if there were a front wall, quadrupled, quintupled if the pauser is astonishingly a foreigner. Here and there several people stand before a counter, and two or three times as many behind it. Street venders paddle through the mud, stridently announcing themselves. Roofless shops on the corners, and everywhere else that there is a bit of space to crowd in, sell steaming balls of dough, bowls of watery chopped-up meat, China’s kind of macaroni, served with worn chop-sticks and accompanied, perhaps, by a constant refrain designed to draw, rather than to drive off, more customers. Beggars in 268costumes which could not have possibly reached such a state without deliberate aid splash along beside the stranger’s rickshaw at a speed to prove health and strength, crying incessantly, “Ta Lao Yea! Ta Lao Yea!” “Great Old Excellency!” in the vain hope that the Chinese compliment of granting old age where it is still not physically due will bring perhaps even silver from the outside barbarian who is in reality still disgustingly youthful. Glimpses at irregular intervals down side streets that are merely poorer examples of the same thing, with more makeshift booths and fewer large shops, more strident venders and fewer hopeful beggars. Once or twice the big weather-beaten gateway to a yamen, with coolies made into soldiers by the superimposing of a faded uniform padded with cotton leaning on their rifles and eying the passing throng with the air of bad boys who are far too seldom spanked. Less shopkeeping and more miserable dwelling farther out, women and girls standing or hobbling about in the mud on their little deformed feet, everywhere a plethora of boys, nowhere a person who could be called clean, almost everything and every one dirty as a pigsty. Then the street shifts a block before it passes out the farther gate—for evil spirits would make short shrift of a city with a straight passage clear through it—and the stranger finds himself in the outskirts, between the great and the outer wall, with a picturesque glimpse along the former of women washing clothes in the tree-lined moat, and ragged boys are pushing his rickshaw from behind over a bridging hump in the stone and mud-slough road in the hope of being tossed a copper.
The main stream of squeaks makes its way into the old local city, surrounded by two winding walls. The recent snow has left what you might call streets ankle-deep in mud, except for a few short stretches that were paved centuries ago with huge stone slabs worn down so much that a rickshaw can barely move over them, and which are mostly just covered with thick, gooey sludge. Foreigners who have lived there for half a century claim they can see improvements in the local life of old Tzinan, but newcomers will mostly have to take their word for it and are unlikely to gain many impressions that differ significantly from those they’ve experienced or will experience in any busy Chinese city. Merchants dressed in black lounge in skullcaps in constantly repeating little booths on either side, seemingly indifferent to customers as they sip their tea from handleless cups, smoke their tiny pipes with often yard-long stems, and play chess, checkers, cards, or dice, all of an Oriental nature. However, immediate attention is drawn when a potential customer pauses in what would be a doorway if there were a front wall, and even more so if that customer happens to be a foreigner. Here and there, several people stand in front of a counter, with two or three times as many behind it. Street vendors wade through the mud, loudly announcing their presence. Roofless shops on the corners and anywhere else there’s space sell steaming balls of dough, bowls of watery chopped meat, and China’s version of macaroni, served with worn chopsticks and accompanied, perhaps, by a constant chant meant to attract rather than deter more customers. Beggars in outfits that couldn't have gotten that way without deliberate aid splash alongside the stranger’s rickshaw at a pace that showcases their health and strength, continually crying, “Ta Lao Yea! Ta Lao Yea!” “Great Old Excellency!” in the vain hope that the Chinese compliment of attributing old age, where it’s not yet physically due, will somehow result in silver from the outsider who is still offensively youthful. Occasionally, there are glimpses down side streets that are just poorer versions of the same scene, with more makeshift booths and fewer large shops, more loud vendors and fewer hopeful beggars. Once or twice, there’s a large weathered gateway to a yamen, with coolies transformed into soldiers by means of faded uniforms padded with cotton leaning on their rifles and watching the passing crowd with the expression of delinquent boys who far too rarely get spanked. There’s less shopkeeping and more miserable living spaces further out, with women and girls standing or shuffling about in the mud on their little deformed feet, a plethora of boys everywhere, and nowhere a person who could be called clean—almost everything and everyone dirty as a pigsty. Then the street shifts a block before it exits through the farther gate—because evil spirits would wreak havoc on a city with a straight path going right through it—and the stranger finds himself in the outskirts, nestled between the grand wall and the outer wall, catching a picturesque glimpse along the former of women washing clothes in the tree-lined moat, while ragged boys push his rickshaw from behind over a bump in the stone and mud-slough road in the hopes of being tossed a copper.

The upper half of the ascent of Tai-shan is by a stone stairway which ends at the “South Gate of Heaven,” here seen in the upper right-hand corner
The upper part of the climb up Tai-shan is via a stone staircase that leads to the “South Gate of Heaven,” located in the upper right corner.

One of the countless beggar women who squat in the center of the stairway to Tai-shan, expecting every pilgrim to drop at least a “cash” into each basket
One of the many beggar women who sit in the middle of the stairway to Tai-shan, hoping every pilgrim will drop at least some cash into each basket

Wash-day in the moat outside the city wall of Tzinan, capital of Shantung
Wash-day in the moat outside the city wall of Tzinan, capital of Shantung

A traveler by chair nearing the top of Tai-shan, most sacred of the five holy peaks of China
A traveler in a chair is approaching the summit of Tai-shan, the most sacred of China's five holy peaks.
269With the example of decent dwellings and habits in plain sight about them in as well as outside the walls, this plodding through filthy streets between dismal mud dens seems to remain wholly satisfactory even to those visibly able to improve their conditions if they chose. Rows of modern two-story stone houses of the missionaries stand on two sides of the city, and with all the efforts of these enigmatical men and women from across the Pacific to jounce China out of her old ruts, it would have been curious to find how slight effect such patent examples have on the daily living of those in constant contact with them, even to the extent of a little increased effort for cleanliness and convenience—if one had not already seen China elsewhere. Just around the corner from the well equipped hospital manned by Americans and English, the Chinese medicine-shops continue to sell powdered fossils for curing diseased eyes, dried frog’s liver for kidney troubles, deer horns ground up into remedies for other ailments, and to send inquirers to native medicine-men who know the hundred and some spots on the human body where sickness can be let out by puncturing with a needle. The mission university with its big campus backed by a splendid landscape and reached by a hole cut specially for it in the main city wall continues to look utterly incongruous in its setting of ignorance and filth. The turnstile of a mission museum filled with graphic illustrations of China’s errors and the simple cures for them records hundreds of thousands of visitors from all the surrounding region and beyond during the pilgrim season alone, yet the callers seem to carry nothing home with them except the honor of having climbed the sacred mountain and worshiped at the shrine of the famous sage a little farther southward. Graphic proofs that deforestation has brought in its train devastating floods, that it contributes to the aridity of the soil on which even the snow, for lack of shade, evaporates before it sinks in, that it is mainly responsible for the locusts which birds might make way with if there were trees for birds to live in, has barely caused the planting of a few shrubs here and there on the mountains that roll up at the edge of the plain on which Tzinan is built—and these will be hacked down and carried off for fuel at the first good opportunity. The people of Shantung’s capital seem to regard as their chief civic asset the big spring that boils up in three mounds of water in the heart of the city and forms a great lake within the walls, through the reedy channels of which they are poled on pleasure-barges, set with tables for their favorite sport of eating, out to island temples where gaudy gods still gaze down upon worshipers unable to recognize the sardonic smirks on their color-daubed wooden faces.
269With decent homes and habits clearly visible both inside and outside the walls, people seem perfectly content to trudge through filthy streets amid grimy mud huts, even those who could easily improve their circumstances if they wanted to. Rows of modern two-story stone houses built by the missionaries line both sides of the city. Despite all the efforts of these mysterious men and women from across the Pacific trying to push China out of its old ways, it's surprising how little impact such obvious examples have on the everyday lives of those who interact with them. There's only a slight increase in cleanliness and convenience—if one hadn't already seen China in other places. Just around the corner from the well-equipped hospital staffed by Americans and English, Chinese medicine shops still sell powdered fossils for treating eye diseases, dried frog liver for kidney issues, and ground deer horns for various ailments, while directing customers to local medicine men who know the various spots on the human body that can be treated by needle punctures. The mission university, with its large campus set against a beautiful landscape and accessible through a specially cut hole in the main city wall, looks completely out of place amidst the surrounding ignorance and filth. The turnstile of a mission museum, filled with vivid illustrations of China's mistakes and their simple solutions, records hundreds of thousands of visitors from the surrounding region and beyond during the pilgrim season, yet they seem to take home nothing more than the bragging rights of having climbed the sacred mountain and worshiped at the shrine of the famous sage further south. Clear evidence that deforestation has caused devastating floods, contributed to soil dryness that leads to snow evaporating before it can be absorbed, and is mostly responsible for the swarms of locusts that could be managed by birds if there were trees for them to live in, has resulted in only the planting of a few shrubs here and there on the mountains that rise at the edge of the plain where Tzinan is built—and these will be chopped down for fuel at the first opportunity. The people of Shantung’s capital seem to consider their main civic treasure to be the large spring that bubbles up in three mounds in the heart of the city, creating a large lake within the walls, where they are paddled on pleasure barges with tables set for their favorite pastime of eating, out to island temples where brightly painted gods look down upon worshipers who fail to notice the mocking smiles on their colorful wooden faces.
South of Tzinan there are low mountains or high hills, bare except for temples and patches of snow that glistened in the moonlight. These culminate in fame, if not in height, in Tai-shan, most sacred of the holy peaks of China, two hours below the provincial capital. I had purposely timed my journey to Shantung so that I could climb Tai-shan with the pilgrims who flock to it during the fortnight following the Chinese New Year. Though he might have been extremely nasty at that season, the weather god evidently approved my plans, for it would be impossible to picture more perfect conditions for making this far-famed excursion than that brilliant first day of March according to our Western calendar.
South of Tzinan, there are low mountains or high hills, bare except for temples and patches of snow that shined in the moonlight. These peaks gain fame, if not height, in Tai-shan, the most sacred of China's holy mountains, just two hours from the provincial capital. I had planned my trip to Shantung so that I could climb Tai-shan with the pilgrims who come during the two weeks after the Chinese New Year. Although the weather might have been pretty rough during that time, the weather god seemed to be on my side, because it’s hard to imagine better conditions for this famous hike than that stunning first day of March according to our Western calendar.
Even in Peking those who should have been better informed had led me to expect strenuous opposition to my refusal of chair-bearers. There was nothing of the kind, though I seemed to feel an atmosphere of 270mingled surprise and prophecy that I should deeply regret it before the day was done, when I asked merely for a coolie to carry my odds and ends. The ability of almost any foreigner in China to afford servants for all his menial tasks gives the great mass of the Chinese the impression that he has no physical endurance of his own, but only untold riches. The coolie who set off with me at sunrise was well chosen, for not only was he all that a coolie and a guide and “boy” combined should be, but he was so quick-witted and so free from the worst crudities of the Shantung dialect that we conversed almost freely on almost any subject in spite of the scantiness of my Mandarin vocabulary.
Even in Beijing, those who should have been better informed had led me to expect strong opposition to my refusal of chair-bearers. However, that wasn’t the case; I felt an atmosphere of mixed surprise and a sense that I would regret this decision before the day was over when I asked simply for a coolie to carry my stuff. The fact that almost any foreigner in China can afford servants for all their menial tasks gives most Chinese people the impression that they have no physical stamina of their own, just endless wealth. The coolie who joined me at sunrise was an excellent choice, as he was not only everything a coolie, guide, and helper should be, but he was also quick-witted and free from the worst roughness of the Shandong dialect, allowing us to chat quite freely on almost any topic, despite my limited Mandarin vocabulary.
The way lay first across a stony plain sloping gently upward, with the compact mass of rocky mountains so close in the cloudless atmosphere that one might easily have been deceived about the exertions that lay ahead, had not common fame more than corrected any such error. Pilgrims were already converging from both directions upon the partly stone-paved route leading out of the north gate of Taianfu, surrounded by its time-blackened walls, and within an hour we were all passing in a single stream through the first great archway. I-T’ien-Men—“First Heaven Gate”—the Chinese call it, and over it hangs an inscription announcing in the brevity of Chinese characters that Confucius took this path when he climbed Tai-shan—enough to make it the accepted one even if there were other feasible ascents. Stone steps soon begin to hint at the obstacle race ahead, though this early they are merely in isolated half-dozens scattered up the gradually more sloping road floored with big irregular stones worn smooth by uncounted millions of feet. Already the beggars who decorate the entire ascent were raising their insistent clamor, and shops and temples and tea-houses and itinerant venders formed an almost unbroken wall on either side. Higher up there were increasingly open stretches looking off across the steep tumbled gorge we were climbing, to the swift rocky mountain-sides that shut us in. Here and there a cluster of rugged, misshapen pines gave as dainty a retreat as if we had been in Japan, but the general lack of cleanliness alone distinctly informed us that we were not. These clumps were rare, too, even on China’s most sacred mountain, otherwise almost entirely of stone, with hardly a patch of earth big enough for the planting of a flower-bed.
The path started across a rocky plain that sloped gently upward, with the solid mass of rocky mountains so close in the clear sky that one might easily have been misled about the challenges ahead, if not for the widespread reputation that corrected any such misconception. Pilgrims were already gathering from both directions on the partly stone-paved route leading out of the north gate of Taianfu, surrounded by its aged, darkened walls, and within an hour we were all moving in a single flow through the first grand archway. I-T’ien-Men—"First Heaven Gate"—as the Chinese call it, and an inscription above it notes briefly in Chinese characters that Confucius took this route when he climbed Tai-shan—enough to make it the preferred path even if there were other possible ways up. Stone steps soon began to hint at the obstacle course ahead, though at this point they were merely scattered in small groups along the gradually steeper road paved with large, irregular stones smoothed by countless millions of feet. The beggars lining the entire ascent were already raising their persistent calls, and shops, temples, tea houses, and street vendors created an almost continuous wall on either side. Further up, there were increasingly open areas with views across the steep, rugged gorge we were climbing, to the swift rocky mountainsides that surrounded us. Here and there, clusters of twisted, rugged pines offered quaint retreats as if we were in Japan, but the general lack of cleanliness made it clear we were not. These patches were rare, too, even on China’s most sacred mountain, which was mostly just stone, with hardly any patch of earth large enough for a flower bed.
This did not make it infertile for its inhabitants, however; rather the contrary. My coolie companion, to whom the ascent was an old, old story, put the number of beggars that lined it at one thousand; but that certainly was over-modest. Surely there were several times that 271number from bottom to top, and just as many from top to bottom. They sat in the center of the great stairs, so that chair-bearers passed one on either side of them, and those who were carried up passed directly over their heads. The top of each little cluster of stairs seemed to be the exclusive territory of one mendicant, or, in the great majority of cases, of one whole family of them, and not one did I see poaching even for an instant on his fellows’ preserves. Just as often as the half-dozen steps were surmounted a beggar was certain to be found squatting in the middle of the topmost, his woven-reed scoop lying invitingly beside him. Where the merely sloping stretches between these steps were more than ten or twelve feet long other beggars were regularly spaced along them; and higher up, where the ascent was all stairs, there was one, or a family group, about every sixth step.
This didn't make it uninhabitable for its residents, quite the opposite. My coolie companion, for whom the climb was an old story, estimated the number of beggars lining the way at one thousand; but that was definitely an underestimate. There were surely several times that number from bottom to top, and just as many from top to bottom. They sat in the middle of the grand stairs, so that chair-bearers passed by on either side of them, while those being carried up moved directly over their heads. The top of each little section of stairs seemed to belong to one beggar, or in most cases, one whole family of them, and not one I saw encroaching even for a moment on another's territory. Every time we reached the top of a half-dozen steps, there was definitely a beggar squatting in the center of the highest step, his woven-reed scoop resting invitingly beside him. Where the gently sloping stretches between these steps were over ten or twelve feet long, other beggars were spaced along them; and higher up, where the ascent was all stairs, there was one, or a family group, about every sixth step.
Sleeker, fatter, more contented-looking beggars I cannot recall having seen anywhere on earth. Red-cheeked children, boys seeming to predominate, were the chief stock in trade, though there were a few adults who were visibly in sad states of health. During the pilgrim season, I was told, hundreds of peasants leave their little farms in charge of one member of the family and the rest establish themselves somewhere along the ascent to Tai-shan, until the spring grows so warm that their other occupation requires their presence at home again. On one side or the other of the climb, seldom more than a few feet from their squatting-place, each group had a makeshift dwelling,—a hut of rocks and grass-mats, sometimes a natural grotto covered over with whatever was available, generally only high enough for the adults on all fours, but carpeted with mountain hay and better than the average homes along Peking hutungs. Mountain water, magnificent air, a far-reaching view across the plain below, if that means anything to them, made the dismal mud dwellings of most Chinese, within the reeking gloom of city, town, or compound walls, nothing to be compared with this life of perfect leisure in such a vantage-place.
Sleeker, fatter, more content-looking beggars I can't remember seeing anywhere on earth. Red-cheeked children, mostly boys, were the main feature, though there were a few adults who looked quite unwell. During the pilgrimage season, I was told, hundreds of peasants leave their small farms in the care of one family member while the rest set up somewhere along the climb to Tai-shan, until the spring gets warm enough that they need to be back home for their other work. On one side or the other of the climb, usually just a few feet from where they sit, each group had a makeshift shelter—a hut made of rocks and grass mats, sometimes a natural cave covered with whatever they could find, typically just tall enough for adults to crawl in, but furnished with mountain hay and better than the average homes in Peking hutungs. The mountain water, fresh air, and wide view over the plain below, if that matters to them, made the miserable mud homes of most Chinese, trapped in the stinking gloom of city, town, or compound walls, seem nothing compared to this life of perfect leisure in such a great spot.
There might have been one serious drawback to all this,—like the “horrible example” of the temperance lecturer, the exhibits could not be kept in proper condition to make the best appeal. The whole mendicant army on Tai-shan, except the small minority that was really ailing, looked so well fed and well slept that only an unusually charitable or exceedingly unobserving Westerner would have yielded to their pleas. He might have been inclined instead to thump the well padded ribs of the woman who here and there, at his approach, stripped suddenly naked the plump youngster she held in her lap, hastily trying to hide its 272thick warm i-shang behind her—for there was still a distinct bite in the air even on this southern slope of the mountain with a brilliant sun beating down upon it. But the visible prosperity of the mendicants seemed to matter little, for the Chinese pilgrims who made up the now almost constant stream of humanity toiling skyward had evidently some superstition that their pilgrimage would not be effective if they did not succor all who needed it along the way, and most of them were taking no chances on passing by a deserving case merely because it looked better nourished and housed than they did themselves. Those who gave confined their gifts almost exclusively to brass “cash”; but there were many scoops an inch or two deep in these cheap coins, occasionally with a real copper standing conspicuously out among them, though the recipients sneaked off to their lairs now and then to hide their gleanings. A whole scoopful of “cash” would not resemble riches to an American “panhandler”; to Chinese of the lower class, however, the pickings of most of the mendicants on Tai-shan, if that day was an average, would seem almost an income of luxury.
There might have been one serious downside to all this—just like the “horrible example” of the temperance speaker, the displays couldn't be kept in good shape to make the best impact. The entire group of beggars on Tai-shan, except for the small number that were actually sick, looked so well-fed and well-rested that only an unusually generous or completely oblivious Westerner would have given in to their requests. He might have been more inclined to poke the well-padded sides of the woman who, at times, would suddenly strip the plump child she was holding in her lap, quickly trying to hide its thick warm clothing behind her—since there was still a noticeable chill in the air even on this southern slope of the mountain with the brilliant sun shining down on it. But the visible prosperity of the beggars seemed to matter little, as the Chinese pilgrims making up the almost constant flow of people heading uphill clearly had some superstition that their pilgrimage wouldn't be successful if they didn’t help everyone in need along the way. Most of them weren’t taking any chances of passing by a deserving case simply because it looked better fed and sheltered than they did. Those who gave mostly offered brass “cash”; however, there were many scoops an inch or two deep in these cheap coins, occasionally featuring a real copper coin standing out among them, though the recipients would sneak off to their hideouts from time to time to hide their earnings. A whole scoopful of “cash” wouldn’t seem like much to an American “panhandler”; but to lower-class Chinese, the typical earnings of most beggars on Tai-shan, if that day was average, would seem almost like a luxury income.
About nine o’clock the descending peasants and coolies had also grown to a constant stream, so that rules of the road—or, more exactly by this time, of the stairway—had to be more or less strictly obeyed if progress was to be made either up or down. There were no pilgrim costumes, such as the Japanese climbing Koya-san, for instance, so commonly wear, though frequent groups of coolies carried triangular flags bearing a few characters, touches of color that livened somewhat the almost invariable blue of the every-day garments of the masses. Unfailingly good-natured, the coolie pilgrims had neither a suggestion of the rowdiness of our popular excursions nor of the rather belligerent self-complacency of their island neighbors to the east. Except for two little Japanese professors from Manchuria, who conversed with me in English and German respectively and with the Chinese by characters scrawled on scraps of paper, I was the only foreigner making the ascent that day. The sight of me on foot did not arouse more than the usual gaping to which any Westerner outside the restricted orbits of his kind is subject anywhere in China—until my coolie made one of his often repeated answers to the question as to what had become of my chair. Even the little Japanese climbed on foot for an hour or more, their chairs trailing behind them, and only a few of the haughtiest and fattest Chinese declined to get out and stretch their legs at all. But that a man not only ostensibly of the wealthy class, but a weak “outside barbarian” into the bargain, should be so foolish as to risk getting himself stranded by undertaking a journey which naturally he could not finish unassisted, changed the mere gaping to excitement. It was all very well, I gathered from such of their remarks and gestures as I could understand, for even a foreigner to win whatever merit was given such beings by making as much of the journey as he could on foot, but he most certainly should have brought along a chair to rescue him when he could no longer climb.
Around nine o’clock, the stream of descending peasants and laborers had become constant, so traffic rules—more specifically, stairway etiquette—had to be followed more or less strictly to make progress either up or down. There weren’t any pilgrim outfits like those typically worn by the Japanese climbing Koya-san, but groups of workers carried triangular flags with a few characters, adding splashes of color to the otherwise standard blue clothing of the masses. Always good-natured, these worker pilgrims didn’t show the rowdiness of popular excursions nor the somewhat aggressive self-satisfaction of their island neighbors to the east. Aside from two Japanese professors from Manchuria, who spoke to me in English and German respectively while communicating with the Chinese through characters scribbled on scraps of paper, I was the only foreigner climbing that day. My presence didn’t elicit more than the usual stares that any Westerner gets outside his usual crowd in China—until my laborer gave one of his frequently repeated responses about my chair. Even the two Japanese walked for an hour or more, their chairs trailing behind, while only a few of the proud and heavy Chinese refused to get out and stretch their legs. However, the fact that a man, not only presumably wealthy but also a feeble “outside barbarian,” would be foolish enough to risk getting stuck by attempting a journey he could naturally not complete without help changed the stares into excitement. From their comments and gestures that I could understand, it seemed acceptable for even a foreigner to earn whatever merit was given to such beings by walking as much of the trek as possible, but he definitely should have brought a chair to save him when he could no longer continue.

A priest of the Temple of Confucius
A priest of the Confucius Temple

The grave of Confucius is noted for its simplicity
The grave of Confucius is known for its simplicity.

The sanctum of the Temple of Confucius, with the statue and spirit-tablet of the sage, before which millions of Chinese burn joss-sticks annually
The inner area of the Temple of Confucius, featuring the statue and spirit tablet of the sage, where millions of Chinese people light incense sticks every year.
273The chairs, by the way, were really not worthy of that name. Instead of the sentry-box-like sedan used in many parts of China to this day, with a carrier or two, or even three, in front and as many behind, these were merely a kind of pole-and-rope hammock, mildly resembling a crude, low rustic arm-chair, in which the carried sat facing forward with his feet hanging over before him, grazing the heads of the incessant beggars in the middle of the ascent, while his rarely more than two carriers walked on either side of him, bearing the contrivance sidewise. Every little distance, when the straps over their outside shoulders became painful, they shifted simultaneously by swinging themselves and the chair around with a swift, almost automatic motion, and continued to toil upward. This was as near as the facts corresponded to the tales so often told of the breath-taking dangers of chairing it up Tai-shan, where, according to the most imaginative tellers, the carriers “just toss you off into space” whenever they change positions. Ever since I first heard this yarn I had pictured thousands of feet of sheer abyss directly beneath the trembling chair-rider, whereas I doubt if he would at any time have dropped more than six or eight feet, exclusive of what he might have rolled, in the unheard-of event of the bearers’ spilling him.
273The chairs, by the way, really didn’t live up to their name. Instead of the sentry-box-style sedan that’s still used in many parts of China today, with one, two, or even three carriers in front and as many behind, these were more like a sort of pole-and-rope hammock, somewhat resembling a basic, low rustic armchair. The person being carried sat facing forward, with their feet dangling in front, brushing against the heads of the endless stream of beggars along the way, while his usually two carriers walked alongside him, holding the chair sideways. Every little while, when the straps on their shoulders became painful, they would shift simultaneously by swinging themselves and the chair around in a quick, almost automatic motion, and keep pushing upward. This was as close as it got to the stories often told about the breathtaking dangers of riding up Tai-shan, where, according to the most imaginative storytellers, the carriers “just toss you off into space” whenever they shift positions. Ever since I first heard this story, I imagined thousands of feet of empty space right below the trembling chair rider, but I doubt he would have ever dropped more than six or eight feet, not counting any rolling he might have done in the unlikely event that the bearers lost their grip.
A little spill would have served the riders right anyway, for most of them were larger and better nourished than the coolies who bore them, needed in fact just such reducing exercises as walking up Tai-shan; and any really two-legged mortal can make the ascent considerably sooner on foot than by chair. On this day at least the carried were decidedly the aristocratic minority, for there was by no means one of them to each hundred of the foot-travelers who shuttled past in two often long unbroken lines. To win full merit for the pilgrimage, evidently, it should be made under the pilgrim’s own steam, though there seems to be no harm in getting a little assistance by the way. Thus most of the women who were painfully toiling upward on their bound feet had each a coolie walking beside her to sustain her faltering 274steps and give her a boost every now and then by the hand in one of her armpits.
A little spill would have been a fitting punishment for the riders anyway, since most of them were bigger and better fed than the coolies carrying them, and actually needed something like the exercise of walking up Tai-shan. Any fully capable person can climb significantly faster on foot than in a chair. On this day at least, those being carried were definitely the aristocratic minority, as there was not even one of them for every hundred foot travelers who flowed past in two often long unbroken lines. To earn full credit for the pilgrimage, it seemed, one should make the trek under their own power, although there’s really no harm in getting a bit of help along the way. So, most of the women who were struggling up the hill on their bound feet had a coolie walking alongside them to support their shaky steps and give them a little boost now and then by the hand in one of their armpits. 274
One by one we came to “Flying Clouds Hall,” to the “Ten Thousand Genii Hall,” where the Emperor Kao-Tsu paused to receive homage during his ascent in 595 A.D., to the “Horse Stopping Place,” and finally to Hui-Ma-Ling, the “Horse Turning Back Peak,” where even an emperor was forced to dismount and resort to some other means of locomotion. All these “halls” were Chinese temples, quite commonplace except for their location, filled with dusty, gaudy wooden gods before whom pilgrims burned joss-sticks by the bundle, heaping the big iron urns with ashes, and with the clamor of begging priests, beating gongs, shrieking their demands, calling upon all passers-by to try their fortune-telling or invest in their tissue-paper prayers. In the courtyards of many of them, too, and on the landing outside all, were venders of tea and dough-balls and other delicacies of the Chinese cuisine, some having permanent establishments with home-made tables and sawhorse benches, most of them men who carried their stock in trade on a pole over their shoulders. The general stoniness of the mountain broke out here and there in mighty boulders and rock-faced cliffs, on which inscriptions had been carved centuries ago in characters sometimes the height of a man. There were fixed resting-places at which not only chair-coolies but my own companion insisted on stopping, though his load was next to nothing. It had only been a lunch-basket and some extra clothing to begin with, and at the bottom of the first cluster of stairs he had hired a boy to carry most of that. At Ch’ung T’ien Men, for instance, approximately half-way up, as its name suggests, there were two or three temples and as many tea-houses, a terrace from which one could gloat over the ascent that already lay below, and a view of the flat plain stretching away interminably from the foot of the mountain; and my failure to stop there for refreshments caused as great astonishment among the custom-shackled throng as did my strange Western garb.
One by one we arrived at "Flying Clouds Hall," then to the "Ten Thousand Genii Hall," where Emperor Kao-Tsu paused to receive tribute during his rise in 595 CE, then to the "Horse Stopping Place," and finally to Hui-Ma-Ling, the "Horse Turning Back Peak," where even an emperor had to get off his horse and find another way to get around. All these "halls" were ordinary Chinese temples, remarkable only for their location, filled with dusty, flashy wooden gods glaring down as pilgrims burned bundles of joss sticks, filling the big iron urns with ashes while the clamor of begging priests rang out, banging gongs and shouting their requests, urging everyone passing by to try their fortune-telling or buy their tissue-paper prayers. In the courtyards of many of these temples, and on the ledge outside all of them, vendors sold tea, dough balls, and other treats from Chinese cuisine, with some having permanent setups featuring handmade tables and sawhorse benches, while most were men carrying their goods on poles over their shoulders. The solid stone of the mountain occasionally broke into massive boulders and rocky cliffs, with inscriptions carved centuries ago in characters that sometimes stood as tall as a person. There were designated resting spots where not only chair-coolies but my own companion insisted on stopping, even though his load was minimal. He had started with just a lunch basket and some extra clothes, and at the bottom of the first set of stairs, he hired a boy to carry most of that. At Ch’ung T’ien Men, for example, about halfway up, as its name suggests, there were a couple of temples and several tea houses, a terrace where one could look back at the ascent already completed, and a view of the flat plain extending endlessly from the base of the mountain; my decision not to stop there for refreshments surprised the crowd accustomed to customs as much as my unusual Western clothing did.
At this point the road descends rather sharply for a furlong or more through a ravine, across which the rest of the climb stands in plainest sight, like a stairway to the sky, a ladder rather, for it seems almost perpendicular, and disappearing high above through the archway of a big red structure famed throughout China as the Nan-T’ien-Men—the “South Gate of Heaven.” This furlong is a relief, not only from incessant climbing but from beggars, none of whom are so needy as to choose a station on this damp and shaded slope. They soon began 275again, however, interminable and insistent as before, at the bottom of the remaining ascent. Some one with more taste for statistics than for scenery has computed that there are six thousand steps on this final stairway to Tai-shan, and no one who has made this upper half of the journey by his own exertions will accuse him of exaggeration. But it is not, as common repute would have it, impossible on foot, either because of the steepness of the stairs, the precarious steps, or the danger that beggars or carriers will push one off into space for not contributing the orthodox amount—all of which one may hear from the lips of educated Chinese as well as foreigners even in Peking. The stone steps are uneven, from six inches to a foot wide, the average perhaps eight inches, and some of them are worn to a distinct slope. When they are wet with melting snow, as many things were that day on the upper part of the mountain, only the foolish would set their feet down carelessly upon them, but that could not constitute a worthy reason for intrusting one’s health to a pair of panting coolies who would double the time of the ascent. The beggars, I had gravely been told by a Chinese lady who had lived abroad in several embassies, would simply not allow me to pass if I did not contribute, and as a last resort they would take my offerings by force, so commanding do they become on the mountain at New Year’s time. They were certainly numerous and sturdy enough to have named their own contributions, and there was no visible force that might have curbed them. But they were Chinese—in other words, timid, passive, submissive, in spite of their blustering manner. In regular succession as often as half a dozen steps were surmounted they raised their voices in what might have been mistaken for demands that could not be refused; but just as often their seeming ferocity oozed quickly away into a meek and helpless, and withal a cheerful, resignation as soon as I passed without contributing. One or two, who were women, snatched at my coat-tail or legs, but the hint of a menacing gesture quickly freed me from their noisome attentions, and most of them seemed to be too well fed and contented to rise and run beside me, wailing the “Great Old Excellency!” so familiar in Peking and most other cities of the North. From the plain to the Gate of Heaven the adult mendicants at least seemed to think it exertion enough to squat beside the little fire almost every group had built in the center of its step, and depend on voice and manner—and of course, most valuable of all, ancient custom—for their gleanings. Indeed, one wise old fellow had resorted to absent treatment, remaining in his kennel across the rocky ravine nearly a hundred yards from his scoop on the stairway, 276beating a gong and shouting to attract attention, and no doubt strolling over now and then to carry home the wealth that rained upon him, which his colleagues made no attempt to appropriate.
At this point, the road drops quite steeply for a furlong or more through a ravine, where the rest of the ascent is clearly visible, resembling a staircase to the sky—a ladder, really, since it seems almost vertical, disappearing high above through the archway of a large red structure famous throughout China as the Nan-T’ien-Men—the “South Gate of Heaven.” This furlong offers a break, not just from nonstop climbing but also from beggars, none of whom are so desperate as to choose a spot on this damp and shaded slope. However, they soon start again, as endless and persistent as before, at the bottom of the remaining climb. Someone who prioritizes statistics over scenery has figured out that there are six thousand steps on this final stairway to Tai-shan, and anyone who has managed this upper part of the journey through their own efforts won't dispute that figure. But it’s not, as common belief suggests, impossible to do on foot, whether because of the steep stairs, the precarious steps, or the risk that beggars or porters will push you off for not giving the usual amount—all of which you can hear from both educated Chinese and foreigners even in Peking. The stone steps are uneven, ranging from six inches to a foot wide, averaging about eight inches, and some are worn into a noticeable slope. When they’re slick with melting snow, as many surfaces were that day on the upper part of the mountain, only the reckless would step carelessly on them; but that hardly justifies handing over your well-being to a couple of panting coolies who would take much longer to make the ascent. I had been seriously informed by a Chinese lady who had lived in various embassies that the beggars would simply not let me pass without a contribution, and if all else failed, they would forcibly take my offerings, as they become quite demanding on the mountain during the New Year. They were certainly numerous and strong enough to have set their own prices, and there was no visible force that could restrain them. But they were Chinese—in other words, timid, passive, and submissive, despite their blustering behavior. In regular intervals, often after climbing just half a dozen steps, they raised their voices with what might seem like irrefusable demands; yet just as often their apparent aggression quickly melted away into a meek and helpless, but also cheerful, resignation as soon as I passed without giving anything. A couple of women grabbed at my coat-tail or legs, but even a hint of a threatening gesture easily freed me from their bothersome attention, and most of them appeared too well-fed and content to rise up and chase after me, wailing the “Great Old Excellency!” so familiar in Peking and many other northern cities. From the plain to the Gate of Heaven, the adult beggars at least seemed to think it was enough exertion to sit beside the small fire nearly every group had made in the middle of its step, relying on voice and demeanor—and of course, most importantly, tradition—for their handouts. In fact, one wise older man had resorted to a lazy approach, staying in his makeshift spot across the rocky ravine nearly a hundred yards from his spot on the stairway, beating a gong and shouting to attract attention, and undoubtedly heading over now and then to collect the donations that fell his way, which his peers made no attempt to claim.
The “Clouds Stepping Bridge” was the last break in the sheer ascent, which thereafter marched straight up to the southern Gate of Heaven, dense blue from top to bottom with cautious coolies picking their way up or down. Sometimes there was a very old man, half carried by his sons; now and then a limp, white-faced fellow whose exertions had been too much for him came down in the chair he had scorned to take, or could not afford, when he set out. Even on this upper stretch of the journey the stairway was broken by landings, and on these even the sturdiest paused for breath more and more frequently as the red archway slowly descended to meet us. Youths loitered about the steepest places and lent a hand to those who looked likely to reward their efforts, unless one drove them off with scornful gestures. Near the top a great iron chain was set in the rock as a kind of hand-rail but was hardly needed by any whose legs had not deserted them. When at last, a trifle more than four hours after setting out from the railway station, I marched in through the archway, it occurred to me that, beggars, pilgrims, and stairs aside, the climb had been very similar to that up the steeper side of Mount Washington, in New Hampshire, both in the amount of exertion required and the rockiness of the landscape.
The “Clouds Stepping Bridge” was the last break in the steep climb, which then continued straight up to the southern Gate of Heaven, a deep blue from top to bottom, with cautious coolies carefully making their way up or down. Sometimes there was an elderly man, half-supported by his sons; now and then, a pale, exhausted person would come down in the chair he had refused to take or couldn't afford when he started out. Even on this upper section of the journey, the stairway was interrupted by landings, where even the strongest people paused for breath more frequently as the red archway gradually descended to meet us. Young men hung around the steepest spots and offered a hand to those they thought might give a tip in return, unless they were shooed away with disdainful gestures. Near the top, a sturdy iron chain was embedded in the rock as a sort of handrail but was hardly needed by anyone whose legs hadn't given out. When I finally walked through the archway, a little over four hours after leaving the train station, I realized that, aside from the beggars, pilgrims, and stairs, the climb felt very similar to the steeper side of Mount Washington in New Hampshire, both in the effort required and the rocky terrain.
A cold wind swept across the summit, in disconcerting contrast to the burning sunshine below the gateway, calling instantly for all the garments my two carriers had brought for me. The climbing was not yet done; in fact it is a good half-mile from the Nan-T’ien-Men to the Taoist temple which crowns the mountain. But this is by a winding, leisurely road passing through several temples in which pilgrims were performing the feats for which they had come. The courtyards of these, neglected by the sun, were littered with heaps of dirty snow, with the ashes of myriad sticks of incense, with the débris of firecrackers and tissue-paper prayers, and as temples they were nothing out of the ordinary, duplicated by hundreds all over China, but famous for their location and the special potencies their gods derive from it. Coolies and peasants made up at least three fourths of the throng kowtowing here, faces touching the ground, burning incense there, lighting big bunches of firecrackers for the edification of some sleepy-eyed god over yonder, rubbing a glass-smooth stone monument from which some form of blessing seems to be extracted by friction; but there were many men 277of the well-to-do and the ostensibly educated classes among them. The scarcity of women and children made each temple compound seem a congress of adult males, and the mixture of Fourth of July boyishness and fishwife credulity with which these men solemnly carried out their superstitious antics would have seemed even more out of place but for their girlish cues and their generally simple, almost childlike manners.
A cold wind blew across the summit, which was a striking contrast to the scorching sun below the gate, instantly making me want all the clothing my two porters had brought for me. The climb wasn’t over yet; in fact, it’s a good half-mile from the Nan-T’ien-Men to the Taoist temple that tops the mountain. But the path winds leisurely through several temples where pilgrims were engaged in the activities they had come for. The courtyards of these temples, neglected by the sun, were scattered with piles of dirty snow, ashes from countless incense sticks, debris from firecrackers, and tissue-paper prayers. As temples, they were nothing special, replicated by hundreds across China, but they were famous for their location and the unique powers their gods gained from it. Coolies and peasants made up at least three-quarters of the crowd kowtowing here, faces to the ground, burning incense there, setting off large bunches of firecrackers for the benefit of some sleepy-eyed deity nearby, and rubbing a smooth stone monument that seemed to yield blessings from the friction. Yet, there were also many well-off and supposedly educated men among them. The lack of women and children made each temple grounds feel like a gathering of adult males, and the mix of childish exuberance and gullible superstitiousness with which these men earnestly performed their rituals would have seemed even more out of place if not for their boyish features and their generally simple, almost childlike demeanor.
Out on the rock knoll before the highest temple, marked with a stone shaft here and there and swept now by wintry winds out of keeping with the unbroken brilliancy of the day, a few stone-cut characters announce that “Confucius stood here and felt the smallness of the world below.” A wide expanse unfolds on every side, with only the heavens above. One can make out Tzinan, and faintly the Hoang Ho, then a lake of considerable size, and the railway stretching like a hair on the glass into infinity in either direction—a brown world rolling away in a myriad of peaks and knobs and salients of what looks like a boiling landscape suddenly struck solid. I have nowhere been able to find why Tai-shan is a sacred mountain, but it was already so twenty-five hundred years before the Christian era began; perhaps its great sanctity had its start among the largely plain-dwelling Chinese simply because of the comprehensive view of the world below from its summit when there is nowhere the hint of a rag of cloud and only the haziness of great distances limits the power of the eye.
Out on the rocky hill in front of the highest temple, marked by a few stone pillars and now swept by chilly winter winds that feel out of place with the clear brilliance of the day, some carved letters proclaim that “Confucius stood here and felt the smallness of the world below.” A vast landscape stretches out in every direction, with just the sky above. You can see Tzinan and, faintly, the Hoang Ho River, then a fairly large lake, and the railway stretching infinitely like a thin line across glass in both directions—a brown world rolling away in countless peaks and bumps, resembling a landscape that has suddenly solidified after boiling. I haven’t been able to find out why Tai-shan is considered a sacred mountain, but it had that status twenty-five hundred years before the start of the Christian era; maybe its great sanctity initially arose among the mostly plain-dwelling Chinese simply because of the sweeping view of the world from its summit, with no sign of a single cloud and only the blur of distant horizons limiting what the eye can see.
There was a surprising change in the human element of the scene when I descended early in the afternoon. Where there had been crowd after crowd two hours before, in every temple courtyard, in every refreshment-shop, where the great stairway had seemed carpeted from top to bottom with shimmering dark-blue, there were now only scattered individuals, and most of these were lolling or squatting inside the buildings. What had become of the vast throng so suddenly was a mystery; as nearly as I could make out from my guide’s answer they had gone home again. Taoist priests in their black bonnet-caps were enjoying siestas along the stone verandas on the sunny side of their courtyards; worshipers, in so far as they remained at all, were sipping tea and wielding chop-sticks, or doing nothing whatever, in the den-like places where their patronage had been so vociferously solicited in the morning. The completest change of all had come over the beggars. Their shallow baskets, barely sprinkled now with “cash,” lay in constant succession in the center of the stairway as before, but in the whole descent I doubt whether as many as a dozen mendicants were there in person to make a vocal appeal. Perhaps the rules of their union 278forbade labor at this hour—which reminds me that the medical mission school in Tzinan can rarely get the bodies of beggars for dissection, numerous as they are in life, because the beggars’ gild insists on giving them honorable burial—and the corpses of criminals, readily furnished by the Government, are useless in the study of the brain, because the modern substitute for the headsman’s sword in China is an officer who steps up and blows the back of the culprit’s head off with a revolver. The general desertion of their stations looked, however, more like the contented retirement of craftsmen whose wants were amply satisfied by a part-day’s exertion. They sat off the trail against sunny rocks or beneath an occasional evergreen, or about the mouths of their huts and caves, gossiping, quarreling, scratching, and otherwise heartily enjoying themselves, especially sleeping in their grass-floored nests, scorning to exert themselves even to the extent of a pleading word or glance at likely passers-by. Their untended baskets were plea enough, if charity was still abroad—and evidently honor is no less among beggars than among thieves, for no one seemed in the least concerned lest some one else appropriate the coins meant for him.
There was a surprising change in the atmosphere when I arrived early in the afternoon. Where there had been crowd after crowd just two hours earlier in every temple courtyard and every refreshment shop, where the grand stairway had appeared covered from top to bottom in shimmering dark-blue, there were now only a few scattered individuals, most of whom were lounging or sitting inside the buildings. What had happened to the huge crowd so suddenly was a mystery; from what I gathered from my guide’s response, they had all gone home. Taoist priests in their black caps were enjoying naps along the stone verandas in the sunniest spots of their courtyards; worshippers, if they remained at all, were sipping tea, using chopsticks, or simply doing nothing in the dim places where they had been enthusiastically welcomed in the morning. The biggest change of all was among the beggars. Their shallow baskets, now barely sprinkled with “cash,” remained in the same spots in the center of the stairway, but during my descent, I doubt there were more than a dozen beggars present to make any vocal appeals. Perhaps their union rules prohibited work at this hour—which reminds me that the medical mission school in Tzinan can rarely obtain the bodies of beggars for dissection, though there are many of them while alive, because their guild insists on giving them a proper burial—and the corpses of criminals, quickly provided by the Government, are useless for studying the brain, since the modern method of execution in China involves an officer who steps up and shoots the back of the criminal’s head off with a revolver. However, the general abandonment of their posts felt more like the satisfied retreat of workers whose needs had been adequately met by a part-day’s efforts. They lounged off the paths against sunny rocks or under the occasional evergreen, or around the entrances of their huts and caves, chatting, arguing, scratching, and otherwise enjoying themselves, especially napping in their grassy nests, not bothering even to make a pleading gesture or look at likely passersby. Their unattended baskets were enough of a plea if charity was still around—and it seemed that honor among beggars is just as strong as it is among thieves, as no one appeared to be the least bit concerned that someone else might take the coins meant for him.
We passed now and then a few descending pedestrians, and two or three going down in chairs. Those who have tried it say that there is the exhilaration of dancing in the descent of Tai-shan in these misnamed contrivances, especially down this upper half of it. For though the stairway is continuous here, it is frequently and regularly broken by landings, and the technique of the chair-bearers, handed down perhaps from remote antiquity, is to trot down each cluster of stairs, then saunter slowly across the landing, perhaps shifting shoulders upon it, before jogging suddenly down the next flight. So the descent is like a rhythmic dropping through space, something suggestive of waltzing by airplane, soothing or terrifying, according to the nerve adjustment of the rider. A few belated pilgrims, mainly women on their pitiful feet, were still laboring upward; but the way was almost clear, and two hours below the summit found us strolling away down the last gentle slope between old cypresses. Once, before we entered the square-walled town of Taian, my companion dragged me aside into a temple to “see something good see,” and one of those mixtures of rowdy and beggar which so many Chinese priests become unlocked a kind of chapel containing an ugly gilded statue that pretended to have human arms and legs, the latter crossed in Buddhist repose. The story has it that a monk sat on this table until he starved himself to death as a short cut to Nirvana, but the thing was a mere dressed-up mummified corpse 279arranged to mulct credulous coolies of their precious coppers. It was an outbreak of barbarism worthy the Catholicism of Latin America and many times more surprising in a land which, whatever else it has to be ashamed of, is not particularly given to this form of savagery.
We occasionally passed a few people walking down and a couple more using chairs. Those who have given it a try say that there's a thrilling feeling similar to dancing when descending Tai-shan in these misnamed contraptions, especially on this upper part. Although the stairway is continuous here, it's often interrupted by landings, and the technique of the chair bearers, possibly passed down from ancient times, is to trot down each set of stairs, then casually walk across the landing, maybe shifting their shoulders, before suddenly jogging down the next flight. So, the descent feels like a rhythmic drop through space, somewhat like waltzing in an airplane, soothing or terrifying depending on how the rider is feeling. A few late pilgrims, mostly women on their weary feet, were still struggling upward; but the path was nearly clear, and after two hours below the summit, we found ourselves strolling down the last gentle slope between old cypress trees. Before entering the square-walled town of Taian, my companion pulled me aside into a temple to “see something good,” and one of those mixed characters, part rowdy and part beggar, who many Chinese priests become, revealed a kind of chapel with an ugly gilded statue pretending to have human arms and legs, the latter crossed in Buddhist repose. The story goes that a monk sat on this table until he starved himself to death as a shortcut to Nirvana, but it was just a dressed-up mummified corpse arranged to trick gullible coolies out of their hard-earned coins. It was an instance of barbarism comparable to the Catholicism of Latin America, and even more surprising in a country that, for better or worse, isn't particularly known for this kind of savagery. 279
Inside the walled city, too, I came upon the first deliberate obscenities I had so far seen in the Middle Kingdom. A great fair was in full swing in the grounds of a temple, and among the large colored photographs which several story-tellers inserted in the double-panel screens they had set up to illustrate their chanted tales, were quite a number depicting such things as women nude to the waist. A slight breach indeed in many another land; but in China, where the subject of sex so rarely receives public recognition, it meant almost an open parading of immorality. But New Year’s season seems to bring a relaxation even of morals, and especially does gambling, quite publicly and without distinction as to age or sex, rage throughout China during that fortnight, as it did not at scores of places within these temple grounds. They were vast, and shaded by magnificent old trees, with a wall as mighty as that of the city itself surrounding them, and still with room to spare, though all the hawkers, traders, and money-changers for many li roundabout seemed to be gathered there. At one end stood a mighty hall, famed for its four colossal wooden statues, which still did not reach the lofty beams of the roof nor seem cramped within the walls on which ancient frescos were still moderately well preserved. Here, as everywhere that a wooden god is housed in this holy land of China, stood begging priests and a receptacle heaped with “cash” and coppers flung at it by passing pilgrims. The latter are no doubt the principal source of income of Taianfu, yet prosperity seemed more at home there than in the great majority of China’s smaller cities. Time was when the people knew prosperity would depart at the building of the American Methodist Mission just outside the walls, but both the mission and the prosperity seem to increase rather than to languish.
Inside the walled city, I came across the first intentional obscenities I had seen in the Middle Kingdom. A large fair was bustling at a temple, and among the colorful photographs displayed by several storytellers on the double-panel screens they set up to illustrate their tales, there were quite a few showing women nude from the waist up. This might be a slight issue in many other countries, but in China, where the topic of sex rarely gets public attention, it felt almost like an open display of immorality. However, the New Year’s season seems to lead to a loosening of morals, and gambling, openly and without regard for age or gender, runs rampant throughout China during this two-week period, especially within these temple grounds. They were vast and shaded by magnificent old trees, surrounded by a wall as impressive as the city itself, with still more space available, even though all the vendors, traders, and money-changers from miles around seemed to gather there. At one end stood a grand hall, famous for its four colossal wooden statues, which still didn’t touch the high beams of the roof and didn’t feel cramped within the walls where ancient frescoes were still somewhat well preserved. Here, as everywhere a wooden god is kept in this sacred land of China, begging priests stood by a receptacle overflowing with cash and coins tossed in by passing pilgrims. These pilgrims are undoubtedly the main source of income for Taianfu, yet it felt more prosperous there than in most of China’s smaller cities. There was a time when the people believed prosperity would leave with the construction of the American Methodist Mission just outside the walls, but both the mission and the prosperity seem to be growing rather than dwindling.
When the Germans, something more than a decade ago, built that portion of the Tientsin-Pukow Railway which runs through Shantung, they naturally planned to have it touch Chufou, sacred to Confucius. But their surveyors insisted that the line must cut across the long cypress avenue between his temple and his grave, and rather than permit such a desecration Chufou did without the railroad. Perhaps it is fitting, anyway, that those who come to honor the great sage should bump by “Peking cart” the twenty li between the station, a short two 280hours south of Tai-shan, and the town; for did not Confucius himself suffer in some such contraption while vainly hawking his wisdom to and fro through the land we now know as China? At least, sinologues assure us that the cart antedates Confucius, and certainly there has been no notable improvement in it since its first appearance, for that would be un-Chinese. Tucked away inside by a solicitous seeker after gratuities who had furnished several pillows by the simple method of stripping a few hotel beds, one expects a “Peking cart” to ride rather well—until the first jolt disabuses him. There may be roads smooth enough to make such traveling comfortable, but they do not grow in China. How many times one side or the other of the vehicle deliberately reached over and severely thumped me here, there, or elsewhere during that six miles across a fertile sea-flat plain which should have been as easy-riding as the labyrinthian road should have been direct I have no means of computing. I do recall, however, wishing a thousand times that the mule who tossed with me would be a little less deliberate and have it over with, only to thank fortune a second later when something, anything brought him to a momentary halt.
When the Germans built part of the Tientsin-Pukow Railway through Shantung over a decade ago, they intended for it to go through Chufou, a place sacred to Confucius. However, their surveyors insisted that the line had to cut across the long cypress avenue between his temple and his grave. To avoid such a desecration, Chufou opted out of having the railroad. Perhaps it's fitting that those who come to honor the great sage have to jostle their way by "Peking cart" the twenty li from the station, just two 280 hours south of Tai-shan, to the town; after all, didn’t Confucius himself endure similar discomfort while trying to share his wisdom throughout the land we now call China? At least, sinologues tell us that the cart predates Confucius, and clearly there hasn't been any significant improvement since it first appeared, as that would be un-Chinese. You'd expect a "Peking cart," stuffed inside with a well-meaning person seeking tips who has created several pillows by stealing from hotel beds, to ride relatively well—until the first bump proves you wrong. There might be roads smooth enough to make such travel comfortable, but they don’t exist in China. I lost count of how many times one side or the other of the vehicle jolted me abruptly during the six-mile journey across a fertile flat plain, which should have been as easy to ride as the convoluted road should have been straightforward. I do remember wishing a thousand times that the mule sharing my ride would just get it over with quickly, only to be grateful moments later when something, anything, caused him to stop for a brief moment.
If Confucius could return to the old town he would certainly be disappointed—or am I imbuing him with a modern point of view to which he could not attain even by reincarnation? Judging by the effect several hundred centuries of his philosophy have had on his countrymen, I doubt on second thought whether he would lose any sleep over the insignificant fact that before he could reach his own compound he would have to wade at least calf-deep in oozy black mud for a mile or so, between mud hovels at which our pigs would curl their tails in wrath, stared upon by a redundancy of people to whom his native soil seems preferred as covering to cotton or wool. At worst he would probably quickly forget it, once inside his own private domain, especially if the thought of the streets and of “Peking carts” were not embittered by the necessity of returning to the station. The wall of Chufou has a circuit of four miles, and a third of the area within is taken up by the temple of Confucius and the residence of his lineal descendant. One steps directly from an unspeakable street into the vast enclosure, broken up by wall behind wall and building behind building in the style common to Chinese construction. First comes a forest of tile roofs, each covering a single turtle-supported stone shaft set up by this or that Chinese emperor. There are several rows of these, with perhaps a dozen in a row, larger and many times better built than the home of the 281average living Chinese. Above them, as through all the subdivisions of the great enclosure, rise old cypress-trees affording the sylvan pleasures of shade, the singing of birds, and the murmur of swaying branches. In the principal courtyard the stump of a pagoda-tree reputed to have been planted by the sage himself is preserved under a little glass-sided temple, a miniature of those in the outer yard. This is popularly believed to take on new life through another sprout as often as one dies, thus bridging all the centuries between the planter and present-day China, and certainly a large old tree of the same variety now leans forth from what seems to be the same root. Beyond is an open temple of kiosk shape where Confucius sat under a plum-tree and taught—even in winter no doubt, for he was probably as impervious to cold and discomfort as are the Chinese of to-day in their cotton-padded garments.
If Confucius could come back to the old town, he would definitely be disappointed—or am I projecting a modern perspective on him that he couldn't grasp even if he were reincarnated? Considering the impact his philosophy has had on his countrymen over several hundred centuries, I wonder if he would really care that before reaching his own place, he'd have to wade through at least calf-deep, slimy black mud for about a mile, passing by run-down shacks that would make our pigs curl their tails in anger, all while being watched by many people who seem to prefer walking around in soil rather than cotton or wool clothing. At worst, he'd probably forget all about it once he got inside his own private area, especially if the idea of the streets and "Peking carts" wasn’t ruined by the thought of having to return to the station. The wall of Chufou stretches for four miles, and about a third of the space inside is taken up by the Temple of Confucius and the home of his direct descendants. You step directly from a horrible street into the expansive enclosure, filled with wall after wall and building after building in the typical Chinese style. First, there's a sea of tile roofs, each covering a single stone pillar supported by turtles, erected by one emperor or another. There are several rows of these, with maybe a dozen lined up, larger and far better built than the average home of a Chinese person today. Above them, as in all the different sections of the grand enclosure, rise old cypress trees that provide the joys of shade, birdsong, and the gentle rustle of swaying branches. In the main courtyard, a stump of a pagoda tree believed to have been planted by the sage himself is kept under a small glass-sided temple, a miniature version of those in the outer yard. It's commonly thought that it sprouts anew every time another dies, connecting the centuries from the planter to present-day China, and there's definitely a large old tree of the same kind that now leans out from what looks like the same root. Beyond that is an open kiosk-shaped temple where Confucius sat under a plum tree and taught—even in winter, since he was likely just as unaffected by the cold and discomfort as the Chinese people today are in their cotton-padded clothing.
The great main temple about which all else centers has often been described in detail, so that all who read of such things should know that it is a hundred and thirty-five by eighty-four feet in area and seventy-eight high, with a portico upheld by nine far-famed stone pillars intricately carved with dragons. What seems to be less widely known is the impressive simplicity of that great structure, especially of the interior, dimly yet amply lighted through paper windows, and as strikingly free from the cluttering of painted idols which crowd most Chinese temples as is the whole enclosure from beggars and sycophant priests. A seated statue of the sage, ten feet high, occupies an alcove in the center of the room, facing the great doors. He wears the ancient scholar costume, culminating in a head-dress from which our mortarboard cap might have been derived, being a flat thing some two feet long, with ropes strung with beads, hanging well down over his face, which greatly resemble the warnings that our railroads hang on either side of low bridges as a caution to their brakemen to duck their heads. Above the alcove a slab of wood bearing four characters boldly announces Confucius the “Master Exemplar of All Ages”; before it stands the spirit tablet, the table on which sacrificial food is offered, and a great iron urn filled with the ashes of countless joss-sticks. On the right and left are the images of the “twelve disciples” of Confucius, a number which seems to have been purposely reached, by including the “boob” among his pupils and the commentator on his Classics who lived during the Sung dynasty—something like adorning the tombstone of Shakspere with the name of some professor who had edited a school 282edition of his works. Yet spaciousness on either hand, and upward to the old painted beams supporting the tile roof, is the impression likely to stay longest with the visitor from the West.
The impressive main temple, which is the focal point of everything else, has often been described in detail, so that everyone who reads about it knows that it measures one hundred thirty-five by eighty-four feet and stands seventy-eight feet tall. It features a portico supported by nine famous stone pillars that are intricately carved with dragons. What seems to be less commonly known is the remarkable simplicity of this grand structure, especially inside, where light filters dimly yet adequately through paper windows. There's a striking absence of the painted idols that clutter most Chinese temples, and the entire area is free from beggars and sycophantic priests. A ten-foot-high statue of the sage occupies an alcove in the center of the room, facing the grand doors. He wears the traditional scholar's clothing, topped with a headpiece that could be the inspiration for today's mortarboard cap—it's a flat piece about two feet long, with ropes strung with beads hanging down over his face, similar to the warnings railroads hang by low bridges to remind brakemen to duck. Above the alcove, a wooden slab with four characters boldly proclaims Confucius as the “Master Exemplar of All Ages.” In front of it stands the spirit tablet, the table for sacrificial food offerings, and a large iron urn filled with the ashes of countless joss-sticks. On either side are the images of Confucius's “twelve disciples,” a number that seems intentionally chosen to include the “boob” among his students and the commentator on his Classics from the Sung dynasty—akin to putting the name of a professor who edited a school edition of Shakespeare on his tombstone. Yet, what will likely leave the strongest impression on a visitor from the West is the spaciousness on either side and the height of the old painted beams supporting the tile roof.
The original temple was built on this spot in 478 B.C., and to realize how slightly Chinese worship of the illustrious dead has changed during all the centuries since, one has only to drop into the former home of Li Hung-chang in Tientsin and note how similar in all its details is the temple in which his spirit tablet is enthroned. With each renovation there came an increase in size, until the shrine of Confucius became the vast cypress-shaded enclosure it is to-day. Many priests are attached to it, but they spend their time in learning the elaborate ritual and intricate forms of ceremony used during the spring and autumn festivals, so that regular and frequent worship, as we who live in Christian lands understand it, is scarcely practised. At stated periods the lineal descendant of Confucius comes to burn incense and offer food before the statue, as every Chinese son is expected to do before the graves of his ancestors. Pilgrims, too, come in great numbers, especially at certain seasons; but there is nothing similar to the daily mass or the weekly service of our churches.
The original temple was built on this spot in 478 BCE, and to see how little Chinese worship of the honored dead has changed over the centuries, just visit the former home of Li Hung-chang in Tientsin and notice how similar the temple with his spirit tablet is in every detail. With each renovation, it got bigger, until the shrine of Confucius became the vast, cypress-shaded area it is today. Many priests are attached to it, but they spend their time learning the complex rituals and detailed ceremonies used during the spring and autumn festivals, so regular and frequent worship, as we understand it in Christian countries, is hardly practiced. At designated times, the direct descendant of Confucius comes to burn incense and offer food before the statue, as every Chinese son is expected to do before the graves of his ancestors. Pilgrims also come in large numbers, especially during certain seasons; however, there’s nothing like the daily mass or weekly services of our churches.
Behind this main temple—which means on the cold north side of it, since every properly constructed Chinese temple faces south—is a smaller, much more severely simple hall containing the spirit tablet of Mrs. Confucius, though just which one is not specified. A spirit tablet, by the way, is a varnished or painted piece of wood a foot or two high, narrow and thin, bearing in three carved and usually gilded characters the posthumous name under which the deceased is honored, and set upright in the place sacred to him. At one side are two other temples, of the parents of Confucius, identically arranged. That is, the father is represented by a statue, in scholar’s costume, and the mother by a mere tablet, in a building following as meekly after that of her lord and master as does the Chinese wife in the flesh to this day. Why not statues of the wife and mother also, I asked the first man of learning willing to strain his understanding to catch my mispronounced meaning, though almost certain what the answer would be. It would be improper, he explained, politely, as to one with the ignorance of a new-born child, indecent, to speak plainly, to have a female statue, particularly in a sacred place. Given the ramshackle, filthy condition of a very large number of Chinese temples, the care with which all these were kept up was striking. But even these were not fleckless, especially those of the wife and the mother, where everything was covered with dust and the 283bare resounding chambers had a lonely air, as if very few ever took the trouble to come and burn incense to mere females.
Behind the main temple—which, in traditional Chinese architecture, faces south—is a smaller, much simpler hall that contains the spirit tablet of Mrs. Confucius, though it's not specified which one. A spirit tablet is a varnished or painted piece of wood about a foot or two tall, narrow and thin, displaying the posthumous name in three carved, usually gilded characters under which the deceased is honored, and it is placed upright in the area dedicated to them. To one side are two other temples for Confucius's parents, arranged the same way. The father is represented by a statue in scholarly attire, while the mother is only honored with a tablet, in a setting that follows her husband’s as submissively as the traditional Chinese wife still does today. I asked the first educated person I found who was willing to decipher my poorly pronounced question why there weren't statues for the wife and mother too, though I was pretty sure what the answer would be. It would be inappropriate, he explained politely, as if to someone who didn’t know any better, or indecent to put it plainly, to have a female statue, especially in a sacred place. Given the rundown and dirty state of many Chinese temples, it was remarkable how well these were maintained. But even they weren’t spotless, particularly the ones for the wife and mother, where everything was covered in dust and the empty echoing chambers felt lonely, as if very few people ever bothered to come and burn incense for mere females. 283
I might, with a little effort or foresight, have come to Chufou properly introduced to meet the present head of the Kung family, which is the one we know by the name Confucius. But he is a mere boy—the prince who long held that position having recently died—and was certain to be in no manner different from a million other Chinese youths of the well-to-do class. Besides, though he passes as the seventy-fourth descendant in direct male line from the sage, he is in plain fact nothing of the sort. For the Confucius family, like many others in China, illustrious or commonplace, has now and then been forced to adopt a son to keep the line unbroken; even if a generation is not entirely sterile mere daughters are wasted effort in preserving a Chinese lineage. T’ai Tsung, nearly fifteen centuries after the death of the sage, bestowed posthumous honors upon the descendants of Confucius for the past forty-four generations, and exempted those to come from taxation, a privilege they still enjoy.
I could have made an effort or thought ahead to meet the current head of the Kung family, also known as Confucius, in Chufou. But he's just a kid—the previous prince recently passed away—and he's no different from countless other upper-class Chinese youths. Plus, while he’s considered the seventy-fourth descendant in the direct male line from the sage, that's not actually true. The Confucius family, like many others in China, whether famous or not, has sometimes had to adopt a son to keep the lineage going; even if a generation isn’t entirely without sons, having only daughters doesn’t help in maintaining a Chinese lineage. T’ai Tsung, nearly fifteen centuries after the sage's death, honored Confucius's descendants posthumously for the last forty-four generations and exempted them from taxation, a privilege they still have today.
It is some two miles from the town itself to the grave of Confucius, by a worn-out avenue of ancient and bedraggled cypresses. “Those with letters of introduction, or persons of distinction,” explains the nearest approach to a guide-book of this region that is to be had, “are the only ones admitted; but others may be by tipping the guardian.” As if any one could possibly have gotten this far afield in China without knowing as much! The custodian was an unsoaped, one-eyed coolie who lay in wait just inside the first ornamental gateway, before which a pair of stone tigers, two lin (sacred animals unknown to natural history), and stone statues of two gigantic gentlemen known as Weng and Chung, stood on guard. A tablet over this, or one of the other several entrances we passed on the half-mile walk that remained to the grave itself, announced it the “Tomb of the All-Accomplished and Most Saintly Prince Wen Hsüan,” a posthumous title by which the sage would scarcely recognize himself. There were fields to be crossed, sometimes along ways lined by trees, a landscape covered far and wide with ordinary graves, a small stream, finally a locked and bolted gateway through a temple-like building, before our walk ended. But when it did it was at a last resting-place that even the Western world would have approved, perhaps have envied. Venerable old trees whispering with last year’s dead leaves rose above the secluded spot, yet not so thickly as to cut off the arch of the blue heavens or to more than filter the brilliant sunshine. Birds flitted here and there. It was such a spot 284as could scarcely be found in any Occidental cemetery, for not even the formality of granite tombstones or graveled walks between the graves was there to mar the sylvan charm. Stones there were, a single plain slab before each of the three mounds, but with only three characters in the old rounded script on each of them, and the softening hand of time, perhaps of centuries, to bring them into harmony with the scene, they seemed as naturally in place as did the old trees stretching their arms above them. Cone-shaped, as is the custom in China, but many times larger than the graves strewn by millions throughout the land, the mounds were simple hillocks, covered now with winter-brown grass. The slightly larger one, the characters on its stone in gold instead of red, was of the sage himself; that on the east covered the remains of his only son, while before the main mound rose a third that caused dispute among the several hangers-on who had accompanied me, so that I have no certain means of knowing whether it is that of the sage’s brother, his father, or his grandson.
It's about two miles from the town to Confucius's grave, along a worn avenue lined with old, tattered cypress trees. "Only those with letters of introduction or distinguished guests are allowed in," says the closest thing we have to a guidebook for this area, "but others can get in by tipping the guardian." As if anyone could have traveled this far in China without knowing that! The caretaker was a scruffy, one-eyed coolie who waited just inside the first decorative gate, where a pair of stone tigers, two lin (sacred creatures unknown to natural history), and stone statues of two large men named Weng and Chung stood guard. A tablet above this entrance, or any of the other several we passed on the half-mile walk to the grave, labeled it the "Tomb of the All-Accomplished and Most Saintly Prince Wen Hsüan," a posthumous title the sage would hardly recognize. We crossed fields, sometimes along tree-lined routes, a landscape scattered with ordinary graves, and finally reached a locked and bolted gate through a building resembling a temple before our walk ended. But when we arrived, it was at a resting place even the Western world would admire, perhaps envy. Ancient trees whispered with last year's dead leaves over the secluded area, but not so densely that they blocked the arch of the blue sky or dimmed the brilliant sunlight. Birds fluttered about. It was a kind of place rarely found in any Western cemetery, for there weren’t even formal granite tombstones or graveled paths between the graves to disrupt the natural charm. There were some stones, a single plain slab in front of each of the three mounds, each displaying only three characters in old rounded script. The gentle touch of time, perhaps over centuries, made them seem perfectly at home alongside the old trees stretching their branches above. Shaped like cones, as is customary in China, but much larger than the graves scattered all over the country, the mounds were simple hillocks now covered with winter-brown grass. The slightly larger one, with characters in gold instead of red, belonged to the sage himself; the one on the east held the remains of his only son, while in front of the main mound was a third that caused disputes among the various companions who had followed me, leaving me uncertain whether it was the sage’s brother, father, or grandson.
Kung Fu-tze, as he is known in his native land, was born some twelve miles eastward from Chufou, in the village of Ni-San, now under the rule of bandits, and has been dead only a little more than twenty-four hundred years. In those days the small states that eventually coagulated into what we know as China were separate principalities, of which modern Shantung alone contained four, Confucius being a native of the one called Lu. He was already teaching at twenty-two, and studied much history. It is hard to avoid the suspicion that there was not much of anything more exciting to do for a young man wading the streets of Chufou twenty-five centuries ago; hence undue credit should not be given this particular youth for frequenting libraries rather than pool-rooms. A few decades of his life seem to have passed without anything particularly worth recording; but what are a few decades in China? Whatever else he passed this time at, there is no question that the studious young man was doing everything in his power, short of overstepping the easy marital laws of Lu, to beget him a son, in which he eventually succeeded. At length he emerges again from obscurity “at the early age of fifty-five,” as a chief city magistrate. The elections seem to have run his way, for we behold him soon afterward the acting minister of state—that unsatisfactory prefix probably being due to the fact, if one may judge by the politics of present-day China, that his appointment was not confirmed by Parliament. As such he “put an end to all crime,” evidently a simple little matter in those days, perhaps because “squeeze” was not included. But the old prince of Lu died 285and the new one abandoned himself to sensual pleasures, and at length Confucius quit the job and went on the road. Once it broke out, he seems to have had as serious a case of wanderlust as any ordinary mortal, for he rambled for thirteen years, looking in vain—so at least he told the story to sympathetic listeners—for a prince who would follow his advice and set up a model administration. The briefest reflection will remind the most thoughtless how times have changed in this matter of reformers since then.
Kung Fu-tze, as he's known in his homeland, was born about twelve miles east of Chufou, in the village of Ni-San, which is now controlled by bandits, and he has been dead for just over twenty-four hundred years. Back then, the small states that eventually formed what we recognize as China were separate principalities, with modern Shantung containing four of them, and Confucius being from one called Lu. He was already teaching at twenty-two and studied a lot of history. It's hard not to think there wasn't much else for a young man wandering the streets of Chufou twenty-five centuries ago; so we shouldn't give too much credit to this young man for spending time in libraries instead of pool halls. A few decades of his life seem to have gone by without anything particularly noteworthy, but what are a few decades in China? Whatever else he was doing during that time, there's no doubt the studious young man was doing everything possible—without breaking the relaxed marital laws of Lu—to have a son, which he eventually accomplished. Finally, he reappears from obscurity “at the early age of fifty-five,” as the chief city magistrate. The elections seem to have gone in his favor, as we soon see him as the acting minister of state—that frustrating prefix likely indicating, based on today’s political climate in China, that his appointment wasn't confirmed by Parliament. In that role, he “ended all crime,” which evidently was a simple task back then, perhaps because “squeeze” wasn’t involved. But the old prince of Lu died, and the new one indulged in pleasures, leading Confucius to leave the position and hit the road. Once he started, he seemed to have had quite the case of wanderlust, roaming for thirteen years, looking in vain—at least according to his account to sympathetic listeners—for a prince who would take his advice and establish a model government. A moment's thought will remind even the most careless how much things have changed regarding reformers since then.
If it were not improper to be critical toward so venerable an old gentleman, one might voice the suspicion that Confucius did not suffer severely from lack of self-confidence, for he repeatedly stated that he would produce a faultless administration and do away with all crime within three years in the domain of any prince who would hire him. Alas, if only he were back, be it only in the principality of Lu! No present member of the human race, unless perhaps a “practical politician,” will have the cynicism to suppose that the offer of this wandering Luluite was not eagerly competed for from the eight points of the Chinese compass. Yet the truth is far worse than that: he found no takers whatever! What was left for him, then, but to come back home and write a book? In fact, during those last three years of his life in Chufou he wrote five books, bringing himself unquestionably into the class with almost any of our modern novelists, though he succeeded in gathering about him only three thousand disciples. Population was scarcer in China twenty-five hundred years ago, of course, and publicity hardly a science at all. However, whatever he lacked in numbers he made up in quality, for no fewer than seventy-two of this handful became “proficient in the six departments of learning.” From these he chose ten as “master disciples,” granting them whatever passed for sheepskins in those days “for attainment in Virtue, Literature, Eloquence, and—and Politics!”
If it weren't considered rude to critique such a respected elder, one might wonder if Confucius indeed lacked self-confidence, given that he repeatedly claimed he could create a flawless administration and eliminate all crime within three years for any prince who hired him. Sadly, if only he could return, even just to the state of Lu! No current person, except maybe a "practical politician," would have the cynicism to think that this wandering Lu native's offer wasn’t highly sought after from all corners of China. The harsh reality, however, is even worse: he found no one interested at all! So what could he do but return home and write a book? In fact, during the last three years of his life in Chufou, he wrote five books, placing himself on par with many of our modern novelists, although he only managed to gather around three thousand disciples. Of course, the population was much smaller in China twenty-five hundred years ago, and public relations was hardly a field of study. Nevertheless, whatever he lacked in numbers, he made up for in quality, as at least seventy-two of that small group became "proficient in the six fields of study." From them, he selected ten as "master disciples," giving them what passed for degrees at the time "for achievements in Virtue, Literature, Eloquence, and—and Politics!"
It is chiefly through these chosen followers, who wrote his “Discourses and Dialogues,” that Confucius became famous—and, like Christ, greatly misconstrued—and laid the foundation of China’s ethical and political life. But he could scarcely have had more than an inkling of the fame that was to accrue to him in later centuries, for his honors have been mainly posthumous, and it was not until twelve hundred and seventeen years after his death that he was made the “Prince of Literary Enlightenment!” Why, then, this hectic eagerness of modern man to attain to fame even before the sod has closed over him? I wonder, too, if the great sage would swell with pride at his achievements 286if he could come back and wander again through the grave-strewn, soiled and hungry, wickedly overpopulated, politically chaotic China of to-day. Surely he could not plead innocence of helping to bring about her present woes, for one of the most famous of his dictums, which have had so much influence on Chinese life for many centuries, runs “He who is not in office has no concerns with plans for the administration of its duties.” Where can be found, in so few words, the explanation of what is mainly wrong with the ancient empire which so erroneously now calls itself a republic?
It is mainly through these chosen followers, who wrote his “Discourses and Dialogues,” that Confucius became famous—and, like Christ, greatly misunderstood—and laid the groundwork for China’s ethical and political life. However, he could hardly have imagined the fame that would come to him in later centuries, as most of his honors have been awarded posthumously, and it wasn't until twelve hundred and seventeen years after his death that he was named the “Prince of Literary Enlightenment!” So, why this intense desire of modern people to achieve fame even before they’re gone? I also wonder if the great sage would feel pride in his accomplishments if he could return and walk through today’s grave-strewn, dirty and impoverished, overpopulated, and politically chaotic China. Surely, he couldn’t claim innocence in contributing to her current troubles, for one of his most famous sayings, which has significantly influenced Chinese life for centuries, states, “He who is not in office has no concerns with plans for the administration of its duties.” Where else can we find, in so few words, the explanation of what is largely wrong with the ancient empire that mistakenly calls itself a republic today? 286
Personally I should have preferred to Chufou the birthplace of Mencius, some thirty miles still farther southward, for there hills rise above the plain, growing larger beyond. Tsowhsien is a more enterprising town, too, with an electric light plant that had just been installed by an American company, and less of the air of making an easy living out of pilgrims than either Taianfu or the home of Confucius. Perhaps it has to thank the lesser fame of Mencius for this more manly attitude, for though he is reckoned second, or at worst third, among China’s sages, not one person in ten, even in his native province of Shantung, seemed to know where he lived and died. Pilgrims do come to Tsowhsien, for it is on the direct line of places of pilgrimage through this holy land of China; but Mencius has only dozens or scores of visitors where Confucius has thousands.
Personally, I would have preferred Chufou, the birthplace of Mencius, which is about thirty miles further south, because there, the hills rise above the plain and get bigger as you go. Tsowhsien is a more dynamic town too, with an electric light plant that was just installed by an American company, and it feels less like it’s just making an easy living off pilgrims than either Taianfu or the home of Confucius. Maybe its less famous connection to Mencius contributes to this more proactive vibe, since even though he’s considered second, or at worst third, among China’s great thinkers, hardly one in ten people, even in his home province of Shantung, seemed to know where he lived and died. Pilgrims do visit Tsowhsien since it's on the direct route of pilgrimage sites in this sacred part of China; however, Mencius only draws dozens to scores of visitors, while Confucius attracts thousands.
The green roof of his chief temple rises among the trees within easy sight from the railway. If the rest of the land somewhat neglects him, his native town bears him constantly in mind, and any street urchin can point out the monument marking the spot where he traded his shoes for a book, or where other typical escapades are immortalized in stone slabs, in spite of the fact that centuries of a swarming population have left them sad, slum-like spots. Chinese celebrities have, of course, an advantage over those of the Occident in being kept before the attention of posterity. Public monuments and dwelling-house museums are all very well, but how much more certain of constant attention Shakspere or Washington would be had they direct male descendants, overlooking an adoption now and then, whose main business in life it would be, generation after generation, to worship at the shrine of these illustrious ancestors and see to it that the things sacred to their memories grow and prosper.
The green roof of his main temple stands out among the trees, easily visible from the railway. While the rest of the land may somewhat ignore him, his hometown constantly remembers him, and any street kid can show you the monument marking the spot where he traded his shoes for a book, or where other typical adventures are carved in stone slabs, despite the fact that centuries of a bustling population have turned them into sad, run-down places. Chinese celebrities definitely have an edge over their Western counterparts by being remembered through time. Public monuments and museums in houses are nice, but how much more attention would Shakspere or Washington get if they had direct male descendants, not counting the occasional adoption, whose main purpose would be to honor these famous ancestors and ensure that the things cherished in their memory continue to thrive.
The present head of the Meng family—for the name of the chief successor of Confucius was really Meng Tse—is a man in middle life, who dwells inside a big high-walled compound across the street from 287that enclosing the temples; and he evidently bears a striking resemblance to less fame-pursued Chinese of his class, for information reached us that he was just then busily engaged in feasting some friends. Except that it is considerably smaller and less imposing, the temple grounds of Mencius are quite similar to those of his more famous forerunner. Aged cypresses and the marks of time give it dignity and a certain charm; the statue of the sage wears the same bead-veiled scholar’s head-dress, and a costume as exactly similar as if it had been copied by a Chinese tailor; behind him is the meeker temple of his consort, containing only her spirit tablet; at one side are the smaller but almost identical shrines of his parents. If there is anything unique about the place it must be the birds nesting in the tall trees in the unoccupied back of the compound, beautifully graceful white birds that resemble both cranes and herons, yet do not seem to be exactly either. The information that they are found nowhere else in China was disputed by some of those who heard it.
The current head of the Meng family—whose name, in fact, is the chief successor of Confucius, Meng Tse—is a middle-aged man living in a large, high-walled compound across the street from the temple area. He noticeably resembles other less-renowned Chinese men of his status, as we learned he was busy hosting some friends for a feast. While the grounds dedicated to Mencius are smaller and less grand than those of his more famous predecessor, they still bear a strong resemblance. The old cypress trees and the marks of age add dignity and a unique charm to the place; the statue of the sage is dressed in the same bead-covered scholar's hat and an outfit that looks as though it was made by a Chinese tailor. Behind him is the simpler temple for his consort, which holds only her spirit tablet; to one side are the smaller yet nearly identical shrines for his parents. The most distinctive feature of the place might be the birds nesting in the tall trees at the back of the compound, elegant white birds that look like a mix of cranes and herons but aren’t exactly either. Some people who heard that they exist nowhere else in China disputed that claim.
CHAPTER XVI
"Traveling" in Shantung
The day was delightful, fleckless and summery as if it had been three months later, and we should willingly have lingered longer among the cypress-sighing shades of Mencius, had it not been beyond the power of man to shake off the influx of childish soldiers, street urchins of all ages, and every inquisitive male of Tsowhsien who caught sight of us in time, that had burst through the opened gate and swirled about us like molten scoriæ wherever we moved. My companion, I have neglected to mention, was a robust American missionary with headquarters away down in the southern corner of Shantung, who was kind enough to initiate me into the devout sport of “itinerating.” From the home of Mencius we were to strike out across country by wheelbarrow. To the man who, before the present century began, had already grown to recognize that as his chief means of locomotion, there was far less thrill in the thought of wheelbarrowing than there would have been in the unusual experience of taking a street-car; but to me it was something entirely new in the field of travel. The passenger wheelbarrows of Shantung are of two kinds,—small and large, city and country, short or long distance, according to the individual choice of dividing line. In town they are merely two cushioned, straight-backed benches on either side of the high wooden wheel, on which six or eight crippled women may ride comfortably, sitting sidewise. But for cross-country work a larger, sturdier breed is used, with room for several hundredweight of baggage and a pair of the owners thereof stretched out upon it, feet forward, like a sultan on his divan. In town one man usually bears the whole burden; out in the country there must be at least another tugging at a rope ahead—unless one be wealthy enough to replace him with a donkey or an ox—besides the fellow gasping between the back handles, with the woven strap between them over his shoulders. For a very long trip, say twenty to thirty miles in a day, it is considered more humane, or at least more certain, to have a third man between the front shafts or handles which the country variety possesses.
The day was delightful, clear, and summery, as if it were three months later, and we would have happily stayed longer among the shady cypress trees of Mencius, if not for the swarm of curious young soldiers, street kids of all ages, and any guy from Tsowhsien who spotted us in time, bursting through the open gate and crowding around us like molten lava wherever we went. My companion, whom I forgot to mention, was a strong American missionary based far down in the southern part of Shantung, who kindly introduced me to the exciting practice of “itinerating.” From the home of Mencius, we were supposed to head out across the countryside on a wheelbarrow. For someone who had recognized this mode of transport as his main way of getting around before the century even started, the idea of traveling by wheelbarrow was far less thrilling than the unusual experience of taking a streetcar; but for me, it was something completely new in the realm of travel. The passenger wheelbarrows of Shantung come in two types—small and large, for the city and the countryside, short or long distance, depending on personal preference. In town, they are simply two cushioned, straight-backed benches on either side of a high wooden wheel, where six or eight disabled women can ride comfortably, sitting sideways. However, for cross-country trips, a larger, sturdier version is used, with enough space for several hundred pounds of luggage and a couple of passengers stretched out on it, feet forward, like a sultan on his couch. In the city, one person usually handles the whole load; out in the countryside, there needs to be at least another person pulling on a rope in front—unless you're rich enough to replace him with a donkey or an ox—along with the guy struggling between the back handles, with a woven strap over his shoulders. For a very long journey, say twenty to thirty miles in a day, it's considered kinder, or at least more reliable, to have a third person between the front shafts or handles that the country version has.

Making two Chinese elders of a Shantung village over into Presbyterians
Making two Chinese elders from a Shantung village into Presbyterians

Messrs. Kung and Meng, two of the many descendants of Confucius in Shantung flanking one of those of Mencius
Messrs. Kung and Meng, two of the many descendants of Confucius in Shantung, standing beside one of Mencius' descendants.

Some of the worst cases still out of bed in the American leper-home of Tenghsien, Shantung, were still full of laughter
Some of the worst cases still out of bed in the American leper home of Tenghsien, Shantung, were still full of laughter.

Off on an “itinerating” trip with an American missionary in Shantung, by a conveyance long in vogue there. Behind, one of the towers by which messages were sent, by smoke or fire, to all corners of the old Celestial Empire
Off on a traveling trip with an American missionary in Shantung, using a form of transport that has been popular there for a long time. Behind is one of the towers used to send messages by smoke or fire to all corners of the old Celestial Empire.
289In the good old days, only a few years ago, in fact, the usual wages for a barrow-man in rural Shantung were five cents a day—and he saved money on that. Now things have reached a pretty pass, for each man may expect as much as thirty cents, though actually to demand that would almost rank him among the profiteers, the radicals, the undesirable element of the working-classes, and to pitch one’s demands too high in China is likely apt to result in losing one’s job to the three hundred and sixty-five other men who are eagerly waiting to snatch it. To be sure, these wages are not so dreadful as they seem, for they are in “Mex,” and nowadays the use of the wheelbarrow is included.
289Back in the day, just a few years ago, a barrow worker in rural Shantung usually made five cents a day—and still managed to save some. Now things have gotten pretty bad, as a worker can expect up to thirty cents, but actually asking for that would almost put them in the same category as profiteers, radicals, or other undesirables in the working class. Asking for too much in China could mean losing your job to one of the three hundred and sixty-five guys ready to grab it. Of course, these wages aren't as terrible as they sound, since they are in "Mex," and these days using a wheelbarrow is included.
Perhaps it was because we generously paid this highest price that our two men bowled along as rapidly as a “Peking cart,” and many times more smoothly, so evenly in spite of the broken foot-path along the pretense of a road we followed that one could read as easily as on any train. But their best possible speed seems to be a characteristic of most of the barrow-men of Shantung, as does a constant cheerfulness that is always breaking out in broad smiles or laughter at the slightest provocation, as if their joy at having another chance to exercise their magnificent calling could not be contained. Unless the passenger is so inexperienced and squeamish that the gasping of his human draft-animal just behind him prickles his conscience, the wheelbarrow of the country variety comes close to being China’s most comfortable form of land travel. It has little of the cruel bumping and vicious jolting of a two-wheeled cart; there is far less labor involved in reclining on an improvised divan than in bestriding an animal; even a rubber-tired rickshaw is given to sudden protests at the inequalities of the surface of China. Besides, two rickshaws can rarely travel side by side, whereas the men stretched out on either flank of a barrow-wheel may discuss religion, philosophy, and the natural equality of man without once straining the ears or losing a word. One might go further and praise the exclusiveness, the sense of Cleopatran luxury, the freedom of route which makes the barrow so much preferable to a train packed with undisciplined soldiers and as many of the common, ticket-buying variety of unbathed Celestials as can crowd into the space these putative defenders of the country graciously leave unoccupied. The train makes more speed, perhaps; but what is so out of keeping with the spirit of China as haste? The minor circumstance that there must be mutual agreement between the two passengers on a wheelbarrow as to when to ride and when to walk might conceivably be a disadvantage, but there is no reason it should be if the one more given to walking will bear in 290mind the plumpness of his companion and its proper preservation. From the distance of the Western world the impression may arise that the barrow-men must consider these fellows, whom they wheel about like the latest pair of twins, rather weak and sorry members of the human family. But this is merely another way of saying that the Occidental can quickly lose his way in the labyrinth of the Chinese mind. The reaction of the sweating coolies seemed to be, not, “I wish this overfed pair of loafers would get off and walk a while,” but a kind of pride at being associated with men of such wealth and standing, mingled with the feeling, built up through many generations, that naturally persons of finer clay should not bemean themselves by tramping like a coolie, and topped off with the impression that if the gentlemen call a halt and take to their feet it is because the wheeling is not entirely satisfactory, which quickly brings in its train the dread that one of those three hundred and sixty-five other men eagerly waiting for such a job will get it next time.
Maybe it was because we generously paid this highest price that our two guys moved along as quickly as a "Peking cart," and much more smoothly, so evenly despite the broken path along the so-called road we followed, making it easy to read as if on any train. But their best possible speed seems to be a trait of most barrow-men in Shantung, along with a constant cheerfulness that often bursts into broad smiles or laughter at the slightest provocation, as if their joy in having another chance to engage in their remarkable job couldn’t be contained. Unless the passenger is so inexperienced and sensitive that the gasping of his human draft-animal just behind him makes him uncomfortable, the country wheelbarrow comes close to being China’s most comfortable way to travel on land. It lacks the harsh bumping and jarring of a two-wheeled cart; it’s much less tiring to lounge on an improvised couch than to ride an animal; even a rubber-tired rickshaw tends to protest suddenly at the unevenness of China's surface. Plus, two rickshaws can rarely ride side by side, while the men on either side of a barrow wheel can discuss religion, philosophy, and the equality of man without straining to hear each other or missing a word. One could go further and praise the exclusivity, the sense of luxurious freedom, and the route flexibility that makes the barrow much better than a train packed with unkempt soldiers and as many of the common ticket-buying Celestials as can fit into the space those supposed defenders of the country graciously leave empty. The train might be faster, but what is more at odds with the spirit of China than rushing? The small detail that both passengers in a wheelbarrow need to agree on when to ride and when to walk might seem like a downside, but it shouldn't be a problem if the one who prefers walking considers the comfort of his companion. From the perspective of the Western world, one might think the barrow-men see these guys, whom they wheel around like the latest set of twins, as weak and pitiful members of the human race. But that’s just another way of saying that Westerners can quickly get lost in the complexity of the Chinese mindset. The reaction of the sweating coolies seemed to be not, “I wish this pampered pair of loafers would get off and walk for a while,” but rather a sense of pride in being associated with men of such wealth and status, combined with a deeply rooted belief that naturally, people of finer stock shouldn’t lower themselves by trudging like a coolie, topped off by the thought that if the gentlemen decide to stop and walk, it’s because the ride isn’t satisfactory, which quickly leads to the fear that one of those three hundred and sixty-five other eager workers waiting for such a gig will get the job next time.
We passed two of the “telegraph” towers of old-time China that afternoon, square-cut stone and mud structures large as a two-story house, from the now crumbling and grass-grown tops of which news and orders were sent from end to end of the Middle Kingdom. Fires were the signals by night and a dense black column of smoke from burning wolf’s dung by day. Particularly were they used when more troops were needed at the capital, and the story runs that one emperor who flashed forth the call for a general mobilization just because his favorite concubine wished to see the discomfiture on the faces of the exasperated soldiers shortly afterward found his rôle in the hands of one of the eager understudies. Cues are still no abnormality in China as a whole, but one is struck by their almost universal retention in Shantung. The Manchus, it is said, ordered cues to be worn not so much because they had worn them for centuries themselves as in order to be able to tell a man from a woman, if some of their rather effeminate new subjects chose to disguise themselves, for both sexes had long hair up to that time. It seems that when orders were given, after the overthrow of the Ch’ing dynasty, that this badge of Manchu servitude be removed, the execution depended largely upon the provincial and local authorities. In some places men were given the choice between losing their pigtails or their heads, and they had less difficulty in deciding upon the relative value of these two adornments than might have been the case had the question been left to an impartial committee. But the military ruler of Shantung during the first years of the republic was a 291monarchist who had no use for this new republican stuff, and who did what he could to return the emperor to the throne; therefore the people under him dared in few cases to remove what amounted to a badge of loyalty. Now that a decade has passed and the making of hair-nets has become one of the principal industries of the province, when even the boy “emperor” in Peking has adopted the Western hair-cut, one would think that the masculine braid would disappear. But personal beauty is a matter of taste, and the Chinese mind is famous for the number of cogs in that section of it devoted to the preserving of established customs—as China goes, the wearing of a cue can scarcely be called an old one—and on the subject of barbering the country seems at present to be about at a status quo.
We passed two of the old "telegraph" towers in China that afternoon, large stone and mud structures about the size of a two-story house. From their now crumbling, grass-covered tops, news and orders were sent across the Middle Kingdom. At night, fires were the signals, while during the day, a thick black column of smoke from burning wolf’s dung conveyed messages. They were especially used when more troops were needed in the capital. There's a story about one emperor who called for a general mobilization simply because his favorite concubine wanted to see the frustrated looks on the soldiers’ faces; he ended up finding his position taken by one of the eager understudies. Cues aren't uncommon in China as a whole, but they’re notably prevalent in Shantung. The Manchus, it’s said, ordered cues to be worn not just because they had worn them for centuries, but also to differentiate men from women, as some of their rather effeminate new subjects sometimes disguised themselves, since both genders had long hair back then. After the fall of the Ch’ing dynasty, when orders were given to remove this symbol of Manchu servitude, the enforcement relied heavily on local authorities. In some places, men were given the choice of either cutting off their pigtails or losing their heads, and they had little trouble deciding the value of these two adornments compared to what might have happened if it were left to an impartial committee. However, the military ruler of Shantung in the early years of the republic was a monarchist uninterested in the new republican ideals, so he did what he could to restore the emperor to the throne; as a result, people under his rule rarely dared to remove what was essentially a symbol of loyalty. Now, a decade later, with hair-net production becoming a major industry in the province and even the boy “emperor” in Peking adopting Western hairstyles, one might expect the masculine braid to fade away. Yet, personal beauty is a matter of taste, and the Chinese mind is known for its dedication to preserving established customs—considering how China sees it, wearing a cue can hardly be called an ancient practice—and currently, the country seems to be at a standstill on the subject of barbering.
It was the sixteenth day of the first moon, our March 3, the last big holiday of the Chinese New Year’s season. Thus, though we had seen endless streams of people, the men as nearly spotless as they would ever be during this Year of the Pig, the women in their gayest garments, which in most cases meant blue or red silk jackets above bright red trousers tapering down to tiny white baby-shoes, ears and glossy oiled hair adorned with their most precious trinkets, the children dolled up like the principal actors in a Chinese drama—though, I say, we had seen many thousand of these pouring into Tenghsien for one of the chief celebrations of the year, there were no people whatever working in the fields, which this far south were quite ready for the first spring tilling. Besides, much of the land in this region is given over to winter wheat, planted in October and now just beginning to tinge with green the vast yellowish brown of the typical North China landscape. When at length we had been wheeled, like a load of bricks, to the gateway of Chung-Hsin-Tien, we paused and dismounted, for it is a gross breach of Chinese etiquette to ride into or through a town where you have friends—or to speak from a vehicle or the back of an animal to a friend on foot. A remnant of this point of view, members of the A.E.F. will recall, survives in American army regulations.
It was the sixteenth day of the first moon, our March 3, the last major holiday of the Chinese New Year season. So, even though we had seen endless streams of people, the men were about as clean as they would ever be during this Year of the Pig, and the women were dressed in their brightest outfits, typically blue or red silk jackets over bright red pants that tapered down to tiny white baby shoes, with their ears and glossy, oiled hair decorated with their most cherished accessories. The children were dressed up like the main characters in a Chinese play—although I must say, we had seen thousands of them pouring into Tenghsien for one of the biggest celebrations of the year, there were no workers in the fields, which in this southern region were all set for the first spring plowing. Plus, much of the land in this area is dedicated to winter wheat, planted in October and just starting to show green against the vast yellowish-brown typical of the North China landscape. When we were finally wheeled, like a load of bricks, to the entrance of Chung-Hsin-Tien, we stopped and got off, since it’s a serious breach of Chinese etiquette to ride into or through a town where you have friends—or to talk to a friend on foot from a vehicle or while riding an animal. A remnant of this attitude, as members of the A.E.F. will remember, still exists in American army regulations.
“Middle-Heart-Inn” was for centuries a place of great importance, being the half-way stopping-place of all travel on the old Peking-to-Shanghai route. Then the railroad came, a decade ago, passing it by without even naming a station in its honor, and it sank to the large miserable village within a long, rambling, broken mud wall which we found it. Moreover, it had been struck by hail the autumn before and the crops just outside its wall had suffered more severely than anywhere 292else in the devastated area. One was in luck, I gathered, not to have been caught out in that storm without an umbrella. The country people of all that region solemnly assert that the hailstones were as large as tea-pots, and American missionaries bravely run the risk of being charged with perjury by asserting that they saw with their own eyes some as big as grape-fruit. One of the stork-heron birds from the compound of Mencius was struck dead, and several severe injuries to people were reported.
“Middle-Heart-Inn” had been a significant spot for centuries, serving as the halfway point for travelers on the old Peking-to-Shanghai route. However, when the railroad came through a decade ago, it bypassed the inn entirely and didn’t even bother to name a station after it, leading it to decline into the large, miserable village we found it to be, surrounded by a long, crumbling mud wall. Additionally, it had been hit by a hailstorm the previous autumn, and the crops just outside the wall had suffered more than anywhere else in the devastated area. It was said to be lucky not to have been caught in that storm without an umbrella. The locals from the entire region insist that the hailstones were as big as teapots, while American missionaries risk being accused of lying by claiming they saw some as large as grapefruit. One of the stork-heron birds from the Mencius compound was killed, and there were reports of several serious injuries to people.
My companion still had left a few hundred dollars from what had been given him for distribution among famine sufferers, and our first act after installing ourselves in the mud hut that served as a mission station and partaking of the heavy repast which a few of the faithful had insisted on providing—and on clashing chop-sticks with us over—was to set out on a visiting tour among those pointed out by the chief local Christians as in urgent need of assistance. I was struck with the thoroughness with which my companion prepared for the coming distribution. He refused to give any aid whatever to cases which he could not personally inspect, and he had lived in China long enough to know most of the tricks of the unworthy. Anywhere in the United States, not even excluding the “poor white” and negro communities of the South, the entire population of Chung-Hsin-Tien would have seemed at a glance to need the assistance of charity. But in China one must be ragged and dirty and possessionless and hungry-looking indeed to stand out visibly from the millions always more or less in the same predicament. Hut after hut we entered to find not a Mexican dollar’s worth of anything within it. A bit of crumpled straw or a few rags of what had once been cotton-padded garments served in most cases as bed, sometimes on a small k’ang that could be heated—had there been anything to heat it with—more often on the earth floor itself. Then there might be from two to half a dozen mud-ware jars and shallow baskets in which the family habitually kept its possessions, and possibly one or two peasant’s tools. That was all, in sight at least; and the people had had no warning that a benefactor was coming. It seemed to be taken for granted that my companion would consider every one a deceptive rascal until he had personally proved himself to the contrary, and not only were there no protests against our entering every hovel, but invitations to do so, in spite of the breach in Chinese domestic customs involved.
My companion still had a few hundred dollars left from what was given to him to help people suffering from famine, and our first act after settling into the mud hut that served as a mission station and enjoying the heavy meal that a few dedicated locals insisted on providing—and on clashing chopsticks with us over—was to go on a visit among those identified by the local Christian leaders as urgently needing help. I was struck by how thoroughly my companion prepared for the upcoming distribution. He refused to give any assistance to cases he couldn’t personally check, and he had lived in China long enough to know most of the tricks of the dishonest. Anywhere in the United States, even including the “poor white” and Black communities in the South, the entire population of Chung-Hsin-Tien would have seemed at a glance to need charity. But in China, you had to be ragged, dirty, without possessions, and looking hungry to stand out visibly from the millions who were always more or less in the same situation. Hut after hut we entered found not a single Mexican dollar’s worth of anything inside. A bit of crumpled straw or a few rags of what used to be cotton-padded clothes served as a bed in most cases, sometimes on a small k’ang that could be heated—if there had been anything to heat it with—more often on the earth floor itself. Then there might be anywhere from two to half a dozen mud-ware jars and shallow baskets where the family kept their belongings, and possibly one or two farming tools. That was all that was visible; and the people had no idea a benefactor was coming. It seemed taken for granted that my companion would consider everyone a deceptive rascal until he personally proved otherwise, and not only were there no objections to our entering every hovel, but there were invitations to do so, despite the breach in Chinese domestic customs.
We felt into every jar and basket, prodded into every corner and nest of rags, to make sure that the family did not have more than the 293handful of grain they admitted. In no case, I believe, was any deception discovered, but my conscientious companion not only continued until darkness fell that Saturday evening, but violated his religious scruples by spending much of the Sabbath afternoon at the same task. Sometimes it was an old man living alone, with literally nothing but a few handfuls of chaff and the hulls of beans to feed upon. More often there was a wife and several children to share such splendid provisions. Not a few lived in yin-tse instead of huts,—holes cut in the ground and roofed over with sticks, straw, and mud, with a crude ladder or notched pole by which we descended through a small opening to the dark interior. The missionary was particularly scrupulous in entering all of these, for they often serve as the rendezvous of gamblers, and he trusted to his experienced eyes to make fairly sure that a cave was not this, but actually a poor man’s dwelling. There was a similar hole in the ground, though uncovered and with earth steps leading down to it, in the yard of the local “mission,” for in the winter it is more comfortable to hold school or gossip in such a place, out of reach of the wind, yet in the sunshine, than in the dreary, unheated mud huts.
We checked every jar and basket, poked into every corner and ragged nest, to ensure the family didn’t have more than the few grains they admitted to. In no case, I believe, was any deception found, but my dedicated companion continued until it got dark that Saturday evening and even broke his religious rules by spending much of the Sabbath afternoon on the same task. Sometimes it was an old man living alone, with literally nothing but a few handfuls of chaff and bean hulls to eat. More often, there was a wife and several children sharing such meager provisions. Many lived in yin-tse instead of huts—holes dug in the ground covered with sticks, straw, and mud, with a crude ladder or notched pole leading down through a small opening to the dark interior. The missionary was especially careful in entering these, as they often served as meeting spots for gamblers, and he relied on his experienced eyes to make sure a cave was not one of those, but actually a poor man’s home. There was a similar hole in the ground, though uncovered and with earthen steps leading down to it, in the yard of the local “mission,” since in winter it’s more comfortable to hold class or chat in such a place, protected from the wind yet still in the sunlight, than in the dreary, unheated mud huts.
Sometimes only the woman and the children were at home, and the only decent way to inquire of her about her husband, according to Chinese etiquette, was to refer to him indirectly as her wai-tou or nan-ren, her “outside” or her “male person.” Perhaps he had gone to Manchuria, with the millions of coolies who set out for there soon after the Chinese New Year, their belongings in a soiled quilt roll. Compared with densely populated Shantung, where ten villages within five square miles is nothing unusual, the “Eastern Three Provinces” are sparsely peopled and wages are correspondingly high. From Chefoo to Dairen the poorest steamers cross in a day, and the railroads offer reduced rates to migrating coolies—furnishing them open freight-cars for their journeys. But there is more snow than work in Manchuria during the winter; moreover, any Chinese with a proper respect for his ancestors will return to his home among their graves at least for the beginning of the new year, so that much time and some wages are lost in traveling to and fro. Sometimes the “outside” was working in another part of the province. There is, of course, no slavery in China; so long-civilized a land would not tolerate such an institution. But many of the “gentry” and landowners of Shantung, and of other provinces, no doubt, profit by the excess of population by paying a man five “Mex” dollars a year and his food for his labor, and making no provision whatever for his family.
Sometimes only the woman and the children were at home, and the only polite way to ask her about her husband, following Chinese etiquette, was to refer to him indirectly as her wai-tou or nan-ren, her “outside” or her “male person.” Maybe he had gone to Manchuria, with the millions of laborers who set out for there shortly after the Chinese New Year, their belongings wrapped in a dirty quilt. Compared to the densely populated Shantung, where having ten villages within five square miles is common, the “Eastern Three Provinces” are sparsely populated, and wages are correspondingly high. The poorest steamers cross from Chefoo to Dairen in a day, and the railroads offer discounted rates to migrating workers—providing them with open freight cars for their journeys. However, there is more snow than work in Manchuria during the winter; moreover, any Chinese who respects his ancestors will return home among their graves at least for the start of the new year, so a lot of time and some wages are lost traveling back and forth. Sometimes the “outside” was working in another part of the province. There is, of course, no slavery in China; such an advanced nation would not tolerate such an institution. But many of the “gentry” and landowners of Shantung, and probably other provinces as well, benefit from the excess population by paying a man five “Mex” dollars a year plus his food for his labor, with no provisions whatsoever for his family.
294But there was no real famine in Chung-Hsin-Tien, my companion concluded. No one was actually starving—though how some of them kept from doing so on their visible means of support was beyond me. Under-nourishment was common; the only plentiful thing in town was children, especially boys, perhaps because of the custom of even the poorest of keeping the girls out of sight. For nature seems to take revenge on the Chinese for their ardent desire for male offspring. How often the traveler who has the audacity to pursue his questions far enough—for Chinese friends do not greet one another with inquiries as to the health of their respective families—will finally unearth the shamefaced answer, “All girls.” Some had sold their land—a mou, or about the sixth of an acre, at fourteen dollars “Mex” perhaps—to carry them over the winter, some their last household goods that would bring a copper; one man who was so far above the lower level as to have no hope of outside assistance answered my joking query as to the price of the most likable of his small sons with a quick, “Take him along!” But none had been reduced to the final necessity of tearing down their miserable houses in order to sell the few sticks of wood in them; hence there were deserving, but not urgent, cases.
294 But there wasn’t a real famine in Chung-Hsin-Tien, my companion concluded. No one was actually starving—though I couldn’t figure out how some of them were managing on their visible means of support. Under-nourishment was common; the only thing in abundance in town was children, especially boys, probably because even the poorest families tend to keep girls out of sight. It seems nature punishes the Chinese for their strong desire for male children. How often does a traveler who dares to ask enough questions—for Chinese friends don’t usually ask about each other's family health—ultimately uncover the embarrassed answer, “All girls.” Some had sold their land—a mou, or about a sixth of an acre, for fourteen dollars “Mex” perhaps—to make it through the winter, while others sold their last household items that might bring in some cash; one man, who was slightly better off but still had no hope of outside help, responded to my joking question about the price of his most likable son with a quick, “Take him along!” But none had reached the desperate point of tearing down their rundown houses to sell off the few sticks of wood in them; thus, there were deserving cases, but not urgent ones.
The native helper had filled a huge sheet of red paper with the names and particulars of each family visited, to the dictation of my companion, who divided them into first-, second-, and third-class cases. The first were the most needy—the utterly possessionless, they would have seemed to Americans at home—who would be given “full assistance,” that is, a “Mex” dollar or two a month per person until the next harvest began to come in. Second class were those who still had something left—a few pounds of corn meal, a chair that might be sold, a job at a few coppers a day—and they would be helped accordingly. To be inscribed third was proof of comparative affluence; it meant that the family had a goat or a pig, perhaps even a donkey; that one of their jars was still half full of corn or millet or kaoliang, or that they had been caught in the act of smoking tobacco or of having a little handful of the weed in the house, prima facie evidence that they were really not suffering from hunger. To these, small distributions would be made if there was anything left over from the more needy cases. The two impressions, aside from the definition of the word “poverty” in China, which this canvassing left with me were, first, the unfailing cheerfulness, the hair-trigger smile and ready laughter, of even the most miserably destitute, and their tenacious clinging to custom in spite of misfortunes. It seemed never to have suggested itself to the poorest 295family in town that it might be well to limit the number of children it brought into the world to share its perpetual nothing; and mothers who did not have a pot or a whole garment to their names still somehow found cloths with which to bind their daughters’ feet. From their point of view of course this last effort was genuine parental sacrifice; for to leave the girl with whole feet would mean almost certain starvation without a husband instead of only partial starvation with one.
The local helper had filled a large sheet of red paper with the names and details of each family visited, based on my companion's instructions, who categorized them into first, second, and third-class cases. The first group included the most needy—the completely destitute, who would appear to Americans back home as having nothing—who would receive “full assistance,” meaning a “Mex” dollar or two a month per person until the next harvest came in. Second-class families were those who still had a little left—a few pounds of cornmeal, a chair that could be sold, a job earning a few cents a day—and they would receive help accordingly. Being classified as third meant some level of relative wealth; it signified that the family owned a goat or a pig, perhaps even a donkey; that one of their jars was still half full of corn or millet or kaoliang, or that they had been seen smoking tobacco or had a small stash of it at home, clear evidence that they were not truly starving. For these families, small distributions would be made if there was anything left over from those in greater need. The two impressions I was left with from this canvassing, aside from the way “poverty” is defined in China, were, first, the unwavering cheerfulness, the quick smile, and the ready laughter of even the most severely impoverished, and their stubborn adherence to tradition despite their hardships. It never seemed to occur to the poorest family in town that it might be wise to limit the number of children they brought into the world to share their constant nothingness; and mothers who had no pot or even a complete garment to their name still managed to find cloths to wrap their daughters' feet. From their perspective, this last effort was a true act of parental sacrifice; for leaving the girl with whole feet would almost certainly lead to starvation without a husband, instead of just partial starvation with one.
Itinerating missionaries in China can scarcely avoid living up to the biblical injunction to “suffer little children to come unto” them. For their first appearance at the edge of town is the signal for a flocking from all directions, not merely of all the boys and as many of the girls as are not restrained, but of a generous collection of men of all ages, and even some of the boldest women. Chinese and Western courtesy are diametrically opposed in some of their characteristics, and perhaps there is no wider gulf between them than the conception of proper behavior toward strangers. We consider it rude to stare; the Chinese consider it almost an insult not to stare. Like the young ladies of Spanish America, who would take it as much more than a slight on their beauty not to be ogled so brazenly that it becomes almost indecency by the young men lined up on either side of their promenade, so the Chinese high official or man of wealth would be seriously hurt by a failure of the populace to flock about him wherever he appears in public. Simple villagers cannot of course be expected to know that Westerners do not consider this attention so essential, and to that is added the most inquisitive temperament among the races of mankind, a curiosity which, though it is no exaggeration to dub it monkey-like, is probably proof of a higher grade of intelligence than that of more stolid and indifferent peoples. But it is a form of intelligence with which most travelers from the West, I believe, would very willingly dispense, for to be stared at unbrokenly hour after hour by a motionless throng becomes at times the most exasperating of experiences.
Itinerating missionaries in China can hardly avoid living up to the biblical command to “let the little children come unto” them. For their first appearance at the edge of town is a signal for kids to flock from all directions—not just boys and as many girls as are allowed, but also a diverse group of men of all ages, and even some of the boldest women. Chinese and Western etiquette are fundamentally different in some respects, and perhaps the biggest divide is how they view proper behavior towards strangers. We consider it rude to stare; the Chinese see it as almost an insult not to do so. Similar to young ladies in Spanish America, who would take it as more than a slight on their beauty if they’re not openly admired by young men lining the promenade, a Chinese high official or wealthy man would feel seriously embarrassed if the crowd didn’t gather around him whenever he appears in public. Of course, simple villagers can’t be expected to know that Westerners don’t regard this attention as essential. Additionally, the inquisitive nature of the Chinese people, which some might describe as monkey-like, likely reflects a higher level of intelligence than that of more indifferent cultures. However, it’s a type of intelligence that most Western travelers would gladly do without, as being stared at for hours on end by an unmoving crowd can become one of the most frustrating experiences.
It is not of course to the advantage of a missionary to drive off the crowds that gather about him, for he has come to China mainly for the purpose of addressing crowds, and every tendency toward exclusiveness is so much set-back in his chosen work. Naturally, too, it is not fitting in the guest of an itinerating missionary to throw cups of tea or mud bricks in the faces of the compact mob through which may be scattered some of his host’s converts, however strong the temptation may become. During all our stay in Chung-Hsin-Tien, therefore, we 296were like kings at a levée—if we are to believe that kings were ever so thickly attended during the exchanging of their nighties for their breeches. There was a gate to the mission yard, and a padlock that fitted it; but the picking of that even from the outside seemed to be the easiest thing the town did. Besides, the yard was invaded so closely on our heels that nothing would have been gained by locking the gate. The door of the mud house that usually served as church, as well as for the sleeping-room of the local pastor and ourselves, was no barrier to the advance. Long before the preliminary tea was poured for us there was a compact wall of humanity drawn so tightly about us that we could barely move our elbows, and the sea of fixedly staring faces stretched away to infinity out through the yard. Now and then an undercurrent of discontent at inequality of proximity surged through the multitude, to break against our ribs or toss smaller urchins in between our legs and over our knees. When at length it came time to open our cots and sleeping-bags, there was still a large audience to such disrobing as we cared to do under such conditions, and it was an hour or two afterward before the most privileged characters had been convinced that they, too, should retire. Nor were we by any means out of bed next morning when there appeared the vanguard of the throng that was to wall us in all that day. It was hard somehow to understand just why a town which often saw foreigners still came to stand by the hour watching with the fixed eyes of a statue our every slightest movement, be it only the tying of a shoe-lace or the buttoning of a coat.
It’s obviously not a good idea for a missionary to push away the crowds that gather around him, because he’s come to China mainly to speak to those crowds, and any attempt at exclusivity is a setback in his work. Naturally, it’s also not appropriate for a guest of an itinerant missionary to throw cups of tea or mud bricks at the tightly packed mob, which may include some of his host’s converts, no matter how strong the temptation might be. During our entire stay in Chung-Hsin-Tien, we felt like royalty at a reception—if you believe that kings ever had so many people surrounding them while changing from nightgowns into pants. There was a gate to the mission yard with a padlock, but even picking that lock from the outside seemed to be the easiest thing for the town to do. Additionally, the yard was invaded so closely right behind us that locking the gate wouldn’t have made any difference. The door of the mud house, which usually served as a church and also as the sleeping space for the local pastor and us, was no barrier against the crowd. Long before the preliminary tea was served, there was a tight wall of people surrounding us so closely that we could barely move our elbows, with a sea of fixed, staring faces extending infinitely out through the yard. Occasionally, a ripple of discontent over unequal proximity surged through the crowd, bumping against our sides or sending smaller kids darting between our legs and over our knees. When it finally came time to open our cots and sleeping bags, there was still a large audience watching us undress as much as we dared under those conditions, and it took an hour or two before the most privileged individuals were convinced that they should leave. We certainly weren’t out of bed the next morning when the first wave of the crowd appeared to surround us for the entire day. It was somehow hard to understand why a town that often saw foreigners still had people standing by the hour, watching our every minor move, whether it was tying a shoelace or buttoning a coat, with unblinking eyes.
A large number of those about us bore famous names. Many a Chinese village is made up almost exclusively of persons having the same surname and the same ancestors, and Chung-Hsin-Tien, being no great distance from the birthplace of either, contains many descendants of both Confucius and Mencius. There was Meng the shopkeeper and Kung the cook, both Christians, right within the mission compound, and it was easy to find in any small crowd others bearing those illustrious names. Once I came upon a Mencius squatting in the dirt at the corner nearest the gate, shoveling away with worn chop-sticks a cracked bowlful of some uninviting food, and so ignorant that he fled in dismay when I suggested a photograph, refusing to have his soul thus taken from him. A little farther up the street a Confucius sold peanuts in little heaps at a copper each. Missionaries in this region say that those bearing the two famous names are so numerous that the difficulty of making converts is increased, because they are so proud of their ancestry that 297they will seldom risk the stigma attached to changing to a “foreign” faith. Yet there was a Confucius from this very town who was now a Presbyterian preacher, and the two names appear rather frequently on the church registers of southern Shantung.
A lot of people around us had famous names. Many Chinese villages are almost entirely made up of people with the same last name and shared ancestors, and Chung-Hsin-Tien, being close to the birthplace of both, has many descendants of Confucius and Mencius. Inside the mission compound, there were Meng the shopkeeper and Kung the cook, both Christians, and it was easy to find others with those notable names in any small crowd. Once, I saw a Mencius sitting on the dirt at the corner closest to the gate, awkwardly using worn chopsticks to shovel a cracked bowl of some unappetizing food and so uninformed that he ran away in fear when I suggested taking a picture, believing it would steal his soul. A little further down the street, a Confucius sold peanuts in small piles for a copper each. Missionaries in this area say that the number of people with those two famous names is so high that it makes converting them harder because they are so proud of their heritage that they rarely want to risk the stigma of switching to a "foreign" faith. Still, there was a Confucius from this town who is now a Presbyterian preacher, and the two names pop up fairly often in the church records of southern Shantung. 297
Of late years at least it is not unduly easy to become an accepted Christian there. My companion spent half that Sunday morning in putting a dozen candidates through a long catechism, and permitted only two of them to join the church at once, baptizing them—from a tea-cup—at the morning service. It was fully as easy, too, to get out of the church as to get into it; one of the hardest and most important tasks of the missionaries is to see that backsliders are dropped from membership. Almost before we had entered the hole in the mud wall that passed for a city gate a rather addle-pated old man had appeared, hugging his well-worn Bible under his arm; and as long as we remained he hovered close about us, grinning at us upon the slightest provocation, as if to say, “We are brethren, far above this common herd.” He was about the first convert in the region—and one of the chief thorns in the flesh of the itinerator. For the latter had been forced to drop him from the church rolls years before because he had taken a concubine, and there was still no prospect of his being granted forgiveness, even though he had advanced the ingenious argument that he had been compelled to the act by his mother, lest the family graveyards be left without attendants. Yet he continued his church-going as religiously as if he were one of the principal deacons. Perhaps it was just retribution that he still had no son, in spite of his lapse from the tight missionary way. I confess that I did not quite follow the reasoning which made it quite all right to admit the concubine herself to church membership, but I have always been dense on theological niceties.
In recent years, it hasn't been particularly easy to become an accepted Christian there. My companion spent half of that Sunday morning putting a dozen candidates through a lengthy catechism, and allowed only two of them to join the church right away, baptizing them—from a tea cup—during the morning service. It was just as easy to leave the church as it was to enter; one of the hardest and most important tasks for the missionaries is to ensure that those who slip away are removed from membership. Almost as soon as we stepped through the muddy hole that served as the city gate, a rather clueless old man appeared, clutching his well-worn Bible under his arm; and for the duration of our stay, he hovered close to us, grinning at the slightest provocation, as if to say, “We are brothers, far above this common crowd.” He was one of the first converts in the area—and one of the main headaches for the itinerant preacher. The latter had been forced to remove him from the church roster years earlier because he had taken a concubine, and there was still no possibility of him being forgiven, even though he had cleverly argued that he was pressured into it by his mother, to keep the family graveyards from being unattended. Yet he continued to attend church as faithfully as if he were one of the main deacons. Perhaps it was just karma that he still had no son, despite his departure from the strict missionary path. I admit that I didn’t fully grasp the reasoning that made it acceptable to allow the concubine herself into church membership, but I’ve always struggled with theological subtleties.
The day was delightful, and services were held out in the yard. Perhaps twoscore men and half as many women, not to mention a veritable flock of children, crowded together on the narrow little benches taken from the mud-hut church, or stood behind them. I could not but admire the endurance of the missionary, and silently congratulate him on the sturdiness inherited from his “Pennsylvania Dutch” ancestors. For it can scarcely be a mere mental relaxation to talk incessantly, earnestly, and energetically for an hour in a tongue as foreign as the southern Shantung dialect, while Chinese urchins by the dozen, from seatless-trousered infancy to devilish early youth, seemed to be doing their utmost to make life about them unbearable; and when even the adults frequently displayed habits that are not usual in our own church 298gatherings. Or, if this is not enough to try any man’s strength and patience, there was the frequent torture of listening to the horrible imitation of our hymns perpetrated, with missionary connivance, by the congregation. Evidently no Chinese can “hold” a tune, but he can do almost anything else to it which a vivid imagination can picture. Why their own “music” cannot be adapted to religious purposes to better advantage is one of those innumerable questions which flock about the traveler in China like mosquitos in a swamp.
The day was lovely, and the service was held outside in the yard. Maybe around forty men and half as many women, not to mention a bunch of kids, crowded onto the narrow little benches taken from the mud-hut church or stood behind them. I couldn’t help but admire the missionary's endurance and silently congratulate him on the toughness he inherited from his “Pennsylvania Dutch” ancestors. It can hardly be just a mental break to talk continuously, earnestly, and energetically for an hour in a language as foreign as the southern Shantung dialect while Chinese kids of all ages, from little ones without proper pants to mischievous early teens, seemed to do their best to make life unbearable around him; and even the adults often showed behaviors that aren't common in our church gatherings. If that isn't enough to test anyone's strength and patience, there was the frequent agony of listening to the awful rendition of our hymns performed, with the missionary's approval, by the congregation. Clearly, no Chinese person can “hold” a tune, but they can do just about anything else with it that a vivid imagination can conjure. Why their own “music” can't be adapted for religious purposes more effectively is one of those countless questions that swarm around a traveler in China like mosquitoes in a swamp.
Evening services of almost as strenuous a nature, and many personal conferences on religious or financial matters, plumply filled out the day, and early next morning, when the last clinging convert had been shaken off without the suggestion of violence that would have planted a little nucleus of discontent in the community, we were away again by wheelbarrow. I am in no position to testify as to how strictly the few Christians of Chung-Hsin-Tien lived up to their faith in every-day life, but they, and no small number of their as unwashed and ragged fellow-townsmen, missed mighty little of the vaudeville performance which the appearance of a foreigner or two in almost any Chinese town seems to be considered by the inhabitants. This time we had three barrow-men, one of them a first-class candidate for famine relief funds, whose insistent smile at this unexpected windfall of a job was less surprising than the mulish endurance he somehow got out of a chaff and bean-hull diet. Less brute strength is required, however, in the handling of a Chinese wheelbarrow than appearances suggest. During the afternoon I changed places for a bit with the coolie between the front handles, and while I would not care to adopt barrowing as a profession while some less confining source of livelihood remains to me, the thing ran, on the level at least, more like a perambulator than the most optimistic could have imagined. The Chinese are adepts in the art of balancing, and the wheelbarrow, like the rickshaw and the “Peking cart,” is so adjusted as to call for less exertion than the sight of it suggests. Ups and downs, sand or soft earth, sheer edges of “road,” and the passing of many similar vehicles where there is no room to pass, however, make an all-day journey no mere excursion even to a team of three barrow-men.
Evening services that were almost as demanding, along with numerous personal meetings about religious or financial issues, filled up the day. Early the next morning, after gently letting go of the last lingering convert without any hint of violence that might stir up discontent in the community, we set off again with wheelbarrows. I can’t say how strictly the few Christians in Chung-Hsin-Tien adhered to their faith in daily life, but they, along with many of their unwashed and ragged neighbors, hardly missed out on the entertainment that the arrival of a foreigner or two seems to bring to almost any Chinese town. This time, we had three barrow-men, one of whom was a prime candidate for famine relief funds. His persistent smile at this unexpected job was less surprising than the surprising stamina he derived from a diet of chaff and bean husks. However, handling a Chinese wheelbarrow requires less brute strength than it appears. In the afternoon, I swapped places for a while with the coolie at the front handles, and while I wouldn’t want to take up barrowing as a profession as long as I have other options, it ran—at least on flat ground—more like a baby stroller than anyone could have expected. The Chinese are experts at balancing, and the wheelbarrow, like the rickshaw and the “Peking cart,” is designed to require less effort than it seems. However, navigating ups and downs, sand or soft earth, rough edges of the “road,” and the passing of many similar vehicles where there isn’t enough room to pass makes for a journey that’s not just a casual outing, even for a team of three barrow-men.
Women and children were scratching about here and there in the fields; the men were bringing manure in two big baskets fixed on a barrow, such as carry the night-soil of Peking out through the city gates, and were piling it in little mounds differing from the myriad 299graves only in size. The New Year season was visibly over, and the incessant working-days had come again. Somehow the name “Shantung” had always called up the picture of a half-wild region, in spite of the protests of reason; I found it instead very thoroughly tamed, as befits one of the most populous regions on the globe—tamed at least in the agricultural sense. When it came to such afflictions as bandits, officials, and the Yellow River there is still much taming to be done in the province of Confucius.
Women and children were rummaging around in the fields; the men were hauling manure in two large baskets attached to a cart, similar to those used to take night soil out of Peking through the city gates, stacking it in small mounds that only differed from the countless graves in size. The New Year celebrations were clearly over, and the regular workdays had returned. For some reason, the name “Shantung” always conjured up an image of a wild area, despite what logic said; I found it instead to be very well maintained, fitting for one of the most populated regions on the planet—well maintained at least in terms of agriculture. When it comes to issues like bandits, officials, and the Yellow River, there's still a lot of work to be done in the province of Confucius.
We passed almost incessantly through villages. High on the tops of the smooth, bare hills that grew up as we advanced were rings of what seemed to be stone, refuges built at the time of the Taiping Rebellion, which came to a standstill in this very region. They were only walls, with perhaps still a well inside, though the suspicion was growing that bandits were finding a new use for them. Once we passed close on the left an isolated stony peak that is as sacred as Tai-Shan, though much less famous. Thousands of country people climb it, especially in the New Year season, either as their only penance excursion, or as a part of their pilgrimage through all the holy land of China. It is a rough and uninviting climb, but nowhere is filial devotion more generously rewarded, if we are to believe the faithful. Therefore one may on almost any day see the son of an ailing father, dressed only in his Chinese trousers, holding his hands with palms together in front of him, a stick of burning incense between them, marching to the top of the mountain without once taking his eyes off the rising thread of smoke before him. A crowd follows close behind, and one of these carries the clothing of the devotee, whose father is certain to recover under this treatment—unless one of several hundred little incidents occur to make the penance useless.
We passed through villages almost non-stop. High on the smooth, bare hills that popped up as we moved were circles that looked like stone, refuges built during the Taiping Rebellion, which had come to a halt in this very area. They were just walls, maybe with a well still inside, but there was growing suspicion that bandits were finding new uses for them. At one point, we passed close to the left of an isolated rocky peak that's as sacred as Tai-Shan, though much less well-known. Thousands of locals climb it, especially during the New Year season, either as their only penance trip or as part of their pilgrimage through the holy lands of China. It's a tough and uninviting climb, but according to the faithful, nowhere rewards filial devotion more generously. So, on almost any day, you might see the son of an ailing father, wearing just his Chinese trousers, with his hands held together in front of him, a stick of burning incense between them, making his way to the top of the mountain without taking his eyes off the rising thread of smoke. A crowd follows closely behind, and one of them carries the devotee's clothing, believing that the father will surely recover with this ritual—unless one of several hundred little incidents occurs to make the penance pointless.
That night, in the mission-owned mud hut of another unlaundered town, my companion preached a long sermon full of energy to a congregation of five, one of whom was part-witted, two often asleep, and another merely one of our barrow-men. Only the village “doctor,” whose training consisted of a year as coolie in a mission hospital, kept his attention strictly on the business in hand, as should be expected of the chief, even though somewhat fragile, pillar of Christendom in the region. There had been an audience of goodly size for such a locality in the early part of the evening. Not only was the hut crowded with the score it would hold, but at least twice as many more blocked the open door or flattened their noses against the single dirty window. But a few rifle-shots had suddenly sounded somewhere off toward the hills. 300Bandits had raided, looted, and kidnapped in this town several times during the year just over; and though there was no sudden exodus—for the Chinese must “save face” under all circumstances—the audience melted steadily away until only the five remained. The itinerating missionary, however, must never let outside influences affect even the tone of the message he is ever seeking to deliver. Whatever his benefits to the field he is cultivating—and a wide experience is needed to acquire any certain knowledge on this subject—he at least still has some of the hardships of early missionary days, which his thousands of well housed colleagues, even in China, only know by hearsay.
That night, in the mission-owned mud hut of another unkempt town, my companion delivered an energetic sermon to a congregation of five: one person was partially mentally challenged, two were often sleeping, and another was just one of our porters. Only the village "doctor," whose training amounted to a year as a coolie in a mission hospital, stayed fully engaged with the message, as should be expected of the primary, albeit somewhat fragile, supporter of Christianity in the area. Earlier in the evening, there had been a decent-sized audience for such a remote location. The hut was filled to capacity, and at least twice that number were gathered at the open door or pressing their faces against the dirty single window. But then, distant rifle shots rang out from somewhere towards the hills. Bandits had raided, looted, and kidnapped in this town multiple times over the past year; and though there was no immediate mass departure—because the Chinese must "save face" at all costs—the crowd gradually dispersed until only the five remained. However, the traveling missionary must not allow external factors to influence even the tone of the message he strives to convey. Whatever benefits he may bring to the field he is tending—where extensive experience is needed to gain any real understanding—he still faces some of the hardships that early missionaries endured, which his thousands of well-situated colleagues, even in China, only hear about secondhand.
Tenghsien seemed to be far enough south to be tinged with the problems and customs of southern China. Its dialect was audibly at variance with that of Peking, even to an ear of slight Chinese training. On the wall of the vault-like passage through the southern city gate hung several time-blackened wooden crates containing the shoes of former magistrates. It is one of the politenesses of the region to stop a departing magistrate at the gate and remove his footwear, as a way of saying, “We hate so badly to see you leave that we will do everything within our power to prevent your going.” How careful such an official may be to make sure that the ceremony is not omitted in his case, even though he has to detail the shoe-pilferers, or whether or not he slips on the oldest footwear in his possession that morning, are of course unauthorized peeps behind the scenery such as tend to take all the poetry out of life. We dropped in at the local pawnshop, with which my host was on good terms rather out of policy than necessity, but it was nothing now but a huge compound of empty buildings, crowded together in almost labyrinthian turmoil. The pawnshop is one of the most important institutions in any Chinese community, with many curious little idiosyncrasies unknown to our own displayers of the golden balls, but it can scarcely be expected to continue to function where, between grasping officials and bandits frequently sweeping in from the hills, neither the ticketed articles nor the cash on hand can be kept from disappearing.
Tenghsien felt far enough south to be influenced by the issues and traditions of southern China. Its dialect clearly differed from that of Beijing, even to someone with only a little Chinese training. On the wall of the tunnel-like passage through the southern city gate hung several weathered wooden crates filled with the shoes of past magistrates. It's a custom in the area to stop a departing magistrate at the gate and take off his shoes, as a way of saying, “We really don’t want you to leave, so we’ll do everything we can to hold you back.” It’s interesting to think about how carefully such an official makes sure the ceremony is observed in his case, even if he has to assign the shoe collectors, or whether he puts on the oldest shoes he has that morning—those are little behind-the-scenes details that tend to strip the poetry out of life. We stopped by the local pawnshop, which my host visited more out of strategy than need, but it was nothing more than a vast collection of empty buildings, crowded in a chaotic mess. The pawnshop is one of the most vital institutions in any Chinese community, with many quirky traits unknown to our own pawn shops, but it can hardly be expected to keep operating when, with greedy officials and bandits frequently sweeping in from the hills, neither the items being pawned nor the cash on hand can be kept safe.
The throwing out of sick babies seemed to be a fixed habit in Tenghsien, though one seldom hears of such cases farther north. Millions of Chinese parents believe that if a child dies before the age of six or seven it is because it was really no child at all, but only an evil spirit masquerading as one; and unless it is gotten rid of in time, woe betide the other children of the family, already born or to come. It is preferable apparently that it be eaten by dogs, but above all it 301must not die in the house. The missionaries of Tenghsien have grown to take this custom as a matter of course. If in their movements about town they came upon a discarded baby still alive, they did what they could to relieve its sufferings, but they did not “register” surprise. The Chinese merely passed by on the farther side of the street. To touch an abandoned child would be to invite the evil spirit to your own house, unless it proved, by getting well, to be merely a sick child, and no Chinese is brave enough to run any such risk as that. Not long before my arrival, the mission “Bible woman” had found a girl of two thrown out on a pile of filth, and even she had dared do nothing more than sit and fan the flies off it, until it died. The missionaries, however, have come to be looked upon as immune from these evil spirits. More than one garbage-heap baby graces the mission kindergarten, and a man of some standing now in the town carries on his face the teeth-marks of the dog to which he was abandoned. It is not all mere superstition either, the missionaries assert, but dread of responsibility, hatred of initiative, often mere selfishness, masquerading as such. Many Chinese may actually fear that the river spirit will get them if they save a drowning person, but many others are merely afraid of wetting their clothes.
The abandonment of sick babies seemed to be a common practice in Tenghsien, although such cases are rarely heard of further north. Millions of Chinese parents believe that if a child dies before reaching six or seven, it’s because it wasn’t truly a child, but just an evil spirit pretending to be one; and if it’s not gotten rid of in time, the other children in the family, both born and unborn, will be in danger. It's seen as better for the baby to be eaten by dogs, but most importantly, it must not die in the house. The missionaries in Tenghsien have come to accept this custom as normal. If they encountered an abandoned baby still alive during their rounds in town, they would do whatever they could to ease its suffering, but wouldn’t express surprise. The locals simply walked past on the opposite side of the street. Touching an abandoned child would be seen as inviting the evil spirit into one’s own home, unless the child got better and turned out to just be sick, and no Chinese person is brave enough to take that risk. Not long before I arrived, the mission “Bible woman” had discovered a two-year-old girl left on a pile of garbage, and even she only dared to sit and fan the flies off her until she died. However, the missionaries are now viewed as being immune to these evil spirits. More than one baby found in a garbage heap now attends the mission kindergarten, and a respected man in town bears the bite marks from the dog that abandoned him. The missionaries argue that it’s not just superstition, but also a fear of responsibility, a dislike for taking initiative, and often plain selfishness, disguised as tradition. While some Chinese may genuinely fear that the river spirit will harm them if they save someone from drowning, many others are just worried about getting their clothes wet.
The Western and the Chinese mind may be similar in construction, but they certainly do not work alike. Let the missionaries take a girl for a year’s training, for instance, or for the temporary relief of her parents, and they are sure to be informed when the period is over that it is their duty to care for her the rest of her life. As it is contrary to the Chinese idea of politeness to mind one’s own business, so their gratitude seems to be of a different brand from ours. Something akin to that feeling is no doubt now and then felt, in otherwise unoccupied moments, for the men and women from overseas who spend their lives trying to instil into Chinese youth such wisdom and right living as they themselves possess; yet rarely does the passing visitor get a hint of anything more than superficial politeness toward the benefactors, and the assumption that they are somehow making a fine thing, financially or materially, out of their labors—otherwise why would they continue them?
The Western and Chinese minds might be similar in how they're structured, but they definitely don't function in the same way. For example, when missionaries take in a girl for a year’s training or to help her parents temporarily, they often find out when that year is up that it's expected of them to take care of her for the rest of her life. Since it's considered impolite in Chinese culture to mind one's own business, their sense of gratitude seems to differ from ours. Occasionally, there might be a vague feeling of appreciation during quiet moments for the men and women from abroad who dedicate their lives to teaching Chinese youth the wisdom and values they hold; however, the average visitor rarely catches a glimpse of anything beyond surface-level politeness towards these benefactors, along with the assumption that these outsiders must be benefiting financially or materially from their efforts—otherwise, why would they keep doing it?
Sometimes Tenghsien buries its children, like those of its paupers who do not belong to the beggars’ gild, in such shallow, careless graves that the dogs habitually dig them up again. These surly brutes sat licking their chops here and there on the outskirts of town, among discolored rags of what had once been cotton-padded clothing scattered 302about little mussed-up holes in the ground. Lepers were treated with a similar policy of abandonment, or “let the foreigners do something about it if they must.” The same American woman who had the highest record for rescuing babies from the garbage-heap had built the only leper-home in Shantung, if not in northwest China, a mile or two outside Tenghsien. As far as the Chinese are concerned lepers run about the country as freely as any one else. They may not be exactly popular—for the people know the horrors of the disease and easily recognize its symptoms—but they can scarcely be avoided. The thirty or more men and boys, who had been gathered together in a two-story brick building many times more splendid than the homes any of them had known before, had that same cheerful, seldom complaining, easily smiling demeanor of the Chinese coolie under any misfortune. Only a few were bedridden, for the greater resistance to disease for which the Chinese are famous seems to spare them some of the more horrible ravages of leprosy. But on one point they were losing their cheery patience. For months they had submitted weekly to injections of chaulmugra oil without any visible signs of improvement. The treatment is painful; they all admitted it, and one fat-faced boy of fourteen was pointed out as “tearing the walls apart with his screams” when it was administered to him. But his quick retort to the charge seemed to be the consensus of opinion: “Oh, please let us live without the needle and go to heaven in peace when our time comes!” Such efforts were being made to build a similar refuge for women—who of course always come second in China—that even the men sufferers were asked to contribute the few coppers they could live without—and when it is finally built, through missionary effort, it will pay taxes to the local authorities, like many other mission institutions.
Sometimes Tenghsien buries its children, like those of its poor who don’t belong to the beggars’ guild, in such shallow, careless graves that dogs routinely dig them up again. These grumpy beasts lounged around the outskirts of town, licking their chops amid discolored rags of what had once been cotton-padded clothing scattered about little messed-up holes in the ground. Lepers were treated with a similar neglect, or “let the foreigners handle it if they have to.” The same American woman who had the highest record for rescuing babies from garbage had built the only leper home in Shantung, if not in northwest China, a mile or two outside Tenghsien. As far as the Chinese are concerned, lepers roam the country as freely as anyone else. They might not be exactly popular—people are aware of the horrors of the disease and easily recognize its symptoms—but they can hardly be avoided. The thirty or more men and boys, who had been gathered in a two-story brick building far more splendid than any homes they had known before, displayed the same cheerful, rarely complaining, easily smiling demeanor of the Chinese coolie in any misfortune. Only a few were bedridden, for the greater resistance to disease for which the Chinese are famous seems to protect them from some of the more horrific effects of leprosy. However, they were losing their cheerful patience. For months, they had endured weekly injections of chaulmugra oil without any visible signs of improvement. The treatment is painful; they all admitted it, and one chubby-faced boy of fourteen was noted for “tearing the walls apart with his screams” when it was administered to him. But his quick reply to that accusation seemed to reflect the general opinion: “Oh, please let us live without the needle and go to heaven in peace when our time comes!” Efforts were also being made to establish a similar refuge for women—who always come second in China—so much so that even the male sufferers were asked to contribute the few coins they could spare, and when it is finally built, through missionary efforts, it will pay taxes to the local authorities, like many other mission institutions.
Under more auspicious circumstances I should have struck off into that labyrinth of mountains occupying the southeastern part of Shantung. But it might have meant a very much longer stay than I cared to make. For years now the mountainous parts of the province have been overrun more or less continuously by what we call bandits. The Chinese call them “hung-hu-tze” (“red beards,” a term evidently originating in Manchuria, where bearded men from the north seem to have been the first raiders, and to have suggested a clever disguise for native rascals) or “tu-fei” (which means something like “local badness coming out of the ground”). But under any name they are a thorn in the side of their fellow-men. In Peking, where the so-called Central Government 303still decorates foreign passports with separate visés for each province, five at a time, even though the provincial authorities rarely look at them, conditions were admitted with a frankness which other Governments might copy to advantage. I had been given permission to travel freely in Shantung—“except in the areas of Tungchowfu, Linchengchow, Tsaochowfu, Yenchowfu, and the regions controlled by the Kiao Taoyin.” In other words, one could go anywhere, so long as one kept within sprinting distance of the two railway lines. As a matter of fact, much of the information of the Central Government was out of date; places it excepted were now peaceful, and others it did not mention were infested with brigands. Yenchowfu, for instance, showed no more ominous signs when I passed through it than any other sleepy old walled town; and the world at large knows how safe the railways themselves were just about this season. Had there been any good reason to run the risk, the chances are that I could have gone anywhere in Shantung without anything serious happening to me; on the other hand, I might have been carried off before I got well into the foot-hills.
Under better circumstances, I would have ventured into the maze of mountains in the southeastern part of Shantung. But it could have meant a much longer stay than I wanted. For years, the mountainous areas of the province have been continuously overrun by what we call bandits. The Chinese refer to them as “hung-hu-tze” (“red beards,” a term likely originating in Manchuria, where bearded men from the north seem to have been the first raiders, and suggested a clever disguise for local troublemakers) or “tu-fei” (which means something like “local badness coming out of the ground”). But by any name, they are a nuisance to their fellow people. In Peking, where the so-called Central Government still issues foreign passports with separate visas for each province, five at a time, even though the provincial authorities seldom check them, conditions were acknowledged with a honesty that other governments could benefit from. I had been granted permission to travel freely in Shantung—“except in the areas of Tungchowfu, Linchengchow, Tsaochowfu, Yenchowfu, and the regions controlled by the Kiao Taoyin.” In other words, I could go anywhere, as long as I stayed close to the two railway lines. In fact, a lot of the information from the Central Government was outdated; places it excluded were now peaceful, and others it didn’t mention were crawling with bandits. Yenchowfu, for example, showed no more ominous signs when I passed through than any other quiet old walled town; and as the world knows, the railways themselves were just about this season. If there had been a good reason to take the risk, I probably could have gone anywhere in Shantung without anything serious happening to me; on the other hand, I could have been kidnapped before I even got into the foothills.
The mountainous sections in which the brigands were operating most freely are merely poorer, less populous parts of the crowded province, where there is little to be seen except smaller editions of what may be found within easier reach elsewhere. Now and then they had entered Tenghsien, the station of my “itinerating” companion; only recently they had posted a warning on the mission gate in Yihsien, reached by a branch-line a little farther south, that unless some large sum of cash was forthcoming within a hundred days the place would be burned. The women and children had been sent to safer stations, and outposts of agricultural and evangelistic work had been temporarily abandoned. It was near Lincheng, the very junction of the Yihsien line, and the next large town south of Tenghsien, that a score of foreign passengers were to be taken from the most important express in China a few weeks later and carried off into these same hills. The brigands, in fact, hard pressed for a way out of their difficulties, debated the wisdom of taking the missionaries of Tenghsien and neighboring stations as the lever they needed against the authorities. It is more in keeping with justice that they finally decided to hold up the express instead and be sure of hostages with wealth and influence enough to assure the world’s taking notice of them, for the missionaries have lived for years in constant danger of such a raid, while most of the passengers were well fed individuals who had left home mainly in quest of experience.
The mountainous areas where the bandits operated most freely are just poorer, less populated parts of the crowded province, where there's not much to see except smaller versions of what you can find more easily elsewhere. They occasionally went into Tenghsien, the station of my “traveling” companion; just recently, they posted a warning on the mission gate in Yihsien, reachable by a branch-line a bit further south, that unless a large sum of cash was provided within a hundred days, the place would be burned down. The women and children were sent to safer locations, and outposts for farming and missionary work were temporarily abandoned. It was near Lincheng, right at the junction of the Yihsien line and the next big town south of Tenghsien, that a group of foreign passengers were to be taken from the most significant express train in China a few weeks later and carried off into these same hills. The bandits, indeed facing tough circumstances, considered whether it would be wise to take the missionaries from Tenghsien and nearby stations as leverage against the authorities. Ultimately, they decided it was more just to hold up the express train instead, ensuring they had hostages with enough wealth and influence to draw the world's attention to them, as the missionaries had lived in constant danger of such a raid for years, while most of the passengers were well-fed individuals who had mainly left home seeking adventure.
When Tenghsien came to be altogether too closely pressed by 304bandits, the authorities fell back upon a scheme to drive them away without bloodshed. The Boxers, it will be recalled, had their origin in southern Shantung, and the method by which they fancied they made themselves immune to injury by their foes is still widely believed there. The authorities therefore, or private individuals with the initiative needed, called in some countrymen with stout faith in the efficacy of this form of protection and paid magicians two dollars each to make them “immune.” This is accomplished by various forms of hocus-pocus, in which the swallowing of bits of paper with certain characters written on them, and the wearing of similar charms, are the chief features. Not only did the countrymen believe that this made them proof against bullets, swords, and bayonets, but, what made the investment really useful, the brigands also believe it. When care had been taken to have word of the ceremonies reach the bandit camps, the “immune” persons were placed in front of the government troops, who moved slowly but steadily out into the hills. The outlaws knew the futility of wasting precious ammunition on men whom it would be impossible to injure; hence they gracefully retreated as far from town as the authorities chose to drive them. There was, of course, the slight danger that some skeptic among the bandits would doubt the efficacy of the charm. But the Chinese are much more given to swallowing their popular beliefs whole than to investigating their worth, and in the case of an unforeseen accident the evidence would be plain, not that the hocus-pocus is ineffectual, but that it was badly performed.
When Tenghsien was being really pressured by bandits, the authorities resorted to a plan to drive them away without violence. The Boxers, as you might remember, started in southern Shantung, and people still believe in the way they thought they made themselves invulnerable to harm. So, the authorities, along with some proactive individuals, called in some locals who firmly believed in this protection method and paid magicians two dollars each to make them “invulnerable.” They achieved this through various tricks, such as swallowing pieces of paper with specific characters written on them and wearing similar charms. Not only did the locals believe this protected them from bullets, swords, and bayonets, but the bandits believed it too, which made it even more effective. Once the word of the ceremonies reached the bandit camps, the “invulnerable” people were placed at the front of the government troops, who slowly but steadily moved out into the hills. The outlaws knew it was pointless to waste valuable ammunition on people they couldn’t hurt, so they wisely retreated as far from town as the authorities wanted. Of course, there was a slight risk that a skeptic among the bandits might doubt the charm's power. But the Chinese are generally more inclined to accept their popular beliefs without question rather than investigating their validity, and if an unexpected incident happened, it would clearly show not that the magic was ineffective, but that it was poorly executed.
Not far below Tenghsien the railway crosses the old bed of the Yellow River, that greatest of Chinese vagrants. As far back as history is recorded this has changed its mind every few centuries and decided to go somewhere else. It is not a believer in the old adage that as you make your bed so you should lie in it, for the Hoang Ho has the custom, not usual even among rivers, of piling up its course until it flows some twenty feet above the surrounding country, puny mankind meanwhile striving feverishly to confine it by dikes which cannot in the end keep pace with the growth of silt between them. No Chinese can be expected to be comfortable on so elevated a bed, much less a river, and when things become altogether too unbearable the Hoang Ho suddenly abandons its course and makes a new one overnight. The last great change of this kind was in the middle of the past century, when, swinging on a pivot near Kaifeng, one of China’s many old-time capitals, it struck northeastward across Shantung to the gulf of Chihli, though it had formerly emptied into the Yellow Sea hundreds of miles farther south, barely touching Shantung at all. Shantung did not want it, but it had no choice in the matter. The provinces which had been so suddenly relieved of so violent an enemy, and at the same time presented with a large strip of land where land is so badly needed, certainly were not going to help, nor even permit, if it could be avoided, restoration to the old bed. Besides, there are both historical and visible evidences that Shantung had harbored the unwelcome visitor more than once before, that the two mountainous parts of the province were probably once islands, and that the Yellow River, washing back and forth between them, has built up the level and more fertile parts of the country. Similar things happened in many parts of the world, but in most cases the job was finished before man appeared, whereas in China it is still going on. The result is that man finds himself very much in the way during the process.
Not far below Tenghsien, the railway crosses the old path of the Yellow River, the greatest wanderer in China. Throughout recorded history, this river has changed its course every few centuries, deciding to flow somewhere new. It doesn’t subscribe to the saying that you should lie in the bed you make, as the Hoang Ho has the unusual habit of building up its path until it flows about twenty feet above the surrounding land, while humans frantically try to contain it with dikes that ultimately can’t keep up with the silt buildup. No one can be expected to be comfortable on such an elevated bed, especially not a river. When conditions become unbearable, the Hoang Ho suddenly changes its course overnight. The last major shift like this was in the middle of the last century when it swung near Kaifeng, one of China's ancient capitals, and headed northeast across Shantung to the gulf of Chihli, even though it had previously drained into the Yellow Sea hundreds of miles further south, hardly touching Shantung at all. Shantung didn’t want the river, but it had no say in the matter. The provinces that were suddenly relieved of such a turbulent neighbor, and were now presented with valuable land where it's greatly needed, definitely wouldn't help—or even allow, if they could avoid it—the river to return to its old course. Additionally, there’s both historical and physical evidence that Shantung has dealt with this unwanted visitor multiple times before, that the two mountainous areas of the province were probably once islands, and that the Yellow River, shifting back and forth between them, has contributed to building up the level and more fertile parts of the land. Similar occurrences have taken place in many parts of the world, but usually those changes were completed long before humans arrived, whereas in China, it’s still an ongoing process. This means that people find themselves quite obstructive during the process.

On the way home I changed places with one of our three wheelbarrow coolies, and found that the contrivance did not run so hard as I might otherwise have believed
On the way home, I switched spots with one of our three-wheelbarrow workers and realized that the contraption wasn't as difficult to push as I had thought.

The men who use the roads of China make no protest at their being dug up every spring and turned into fields
The men who travel the roads of China don't complain when they're dug up every spring and turned into fields.

Sons are a great asset to the wheelbarrowing coolies of Shantung
Sons are a huge help to the wheelbarrowing workers of Shantung.
305Chinese history is full of accounts of the struggle to keep the Hoang Ho within limits. Some emperors are famous chiefly for their struggles against it. For centuries the “squeeze” connected with the building of dikes, or even their maintenance, has been one of the richest perquisites of certain official positions. Perhaps this is why the latest task of wrestling with the Yellow River has been given to an American firm established in China. Two years ago the river broke through its dikes again, though this time within a hundred miles of its mouth, and inundated what to crowded Shantung is an immense area, destroying many villages and withdrawing the land about them from cultivation. Several walled cities, too, were in great peril, particularly Litsing, situated in a bend of the river, and below it; for here as in its former course to the south the stream has gradually silted itself higher and higher, until one crossing it anywhere along its lower reaches must climb thirty or forty feet to the top of the dike from the land side, to descend only ten or twelve to the river. In flood season the waters washed at the walls of Litsing, which in time they must have undermined and broken, drowning out the city. Famine relief funds improved the lot of those who had been driven from their homes, some of whom built new shelters on the broad tops of the dikes, while others scattered, particularly to Manchuria. The dead and the living between them so crowd the land in Shantung that if one patch is taken away there is no other room for those who live upon it. Bids were asked for the task of retaming the river, to be paid for jointly from relief funds and by the province; the American firm offered to do the work at just one 306fourth the price asked by Chinese contractors, and having secured itself against the common misfortune of those working for Chinese Governments by insisting on monthly prepayments, tackled a job that was old when Confucius was a boy.
305Chinese history is filled with stories about the struggle to control the Yellow River. Some emperors are mainly remembered for their battles against it. For centuries, the pressure to build and maintain dikes has been a significant source of benefits for certain official roles. Maybe that's why the latest effort to tackle the Yellow River has been handed over to an American company based in China. Two years ago, the river broke through its dikes again, this time not far from its mouth, flooding a vast area in crowded Shantung, destroying many villages and rendering the surrounding land unusable for farming. Several walled cities were also at serious risk, especially Litsing, which is located in a bend of the river and below it. Here, as in its earlier path to the south, the river has gradually silted up, causing it to rise higher and higher, so that crossing it anywhere along its lower stretches requires climbing thirty or forty feet to reach the top of the dike from the land side, only to descend ten or twelve feet to the river. During flooding season, the waters lapped at the walls of Litsing, and over time, they eroded and broke through, drowning the city. Famine relief funds improved conditions for those who had lost their homes; some built new shelters on the broad tops of the dikes, while others dispersed, particularly to Manchuria. The deceased and the living crowd the land in Shantung so much that if one area is removed, there's no space left for those who depend on it. Requests for bids were made for the job of reining in the river, to be funded jointly by relief funds and the province; the American firm proposed to do the work for just a quarter of the price quoted by Chinese contractors and secured itself against the usual problems faced by those working for Chinese governments by insisting on monthly prepayments, taking on a project that has been around since Confucius was a boy. 306
Clumsy native boats, bringing down rock for the work, as well as coolies and supplies, will carry one from Tzinan to the scene of operations in a day or two; but the more hasty American way is by automobile from Choutsun, two hours east of the capital on the Shantung railway. What is known in China as a motor-road, that is, a raised causeway made entirely of soft yellowish earth, which cuts up into ever deeper ruts, growing impassable with much rain, its steep sides gradually crumbling away until the barely two-car width is reduced to the point when passing is impossible for much of the distance, runs northward to the river, where cars take to the top of the dike. The workmen, strange as it may seem, are not so numerous as the company would like, and recruiting has to be carried on at considerable distances. The proverbial Chinese distrust of the “outside barbarian” has something to do with this; perhaps fear of bringing down upon their heads the wrath of the river gods for interfering with him may deter others; naturally in this season of the lunar New Year many had gone back to their ancestral graves. To put into American dollars and cents the wages paid would be to give a false impression of penuriousness on the part of the company; suffice it to say, therefore, that they are much higher than the average of wages in Shantung, that millet and rice and other essentials are furnished at cost to the employees, thereby saving them from heartless exploitation by their fellow-countrymen of the merchant class, and that reeds and other materials are supplied for covering their lodging-places. These are neither more nor less than holes dug in the earth; but mud dwellings, whether above or below the ground, have been the lot of Chinese coolies for many centuries, at least since the forests were turned into fuel and coffins, and these have the advantage that they can be moved in a few hours with a shovel as the work advances.
Clumsy local boats, bringing down rock for the project, along with laborers and supplies, can take you from Tzinan to the worksite in a day or two; but the more efficient American method is to drive from Choutsun, two hours east of the capital on the Shantung railway. The so-called motor-road in China is a raised causeway made entirely of soft yellowish earth, which gets deeper ruts that become impassable after heavy rain, with steep sides slowly crumbling away until the barely two-car width makes passing impossible for much of the stretch. This road runs northward to the river, where cars can move onto the top of the dike. Interestingly, the workforce isn’t as large as the company wants, necessitating recruitment from considerable distances. The well-known Chinese distrust of outsiders plays a role in this; perhaps the fear of angering the river gods for disturbing them might hold others back; naturally, many have returned to their ancestral graves during the lunar New Year season. If we were to convert the wages paid into American dollars and cents, it would create a misleading impression of stinginess on the company's part; it’s enough to say that they are considerably higher than the average wages in Shantung, that millet, rice, and other essentials are provided at cost to the workers, thus protecting them from exploitation by merchant-class countrymen and that reeds and other materials are supplied for covering their shelters. These are simply holes dug into the ground; however, mud dwellings, whether above or below ground, have been the reality for Chinese laborers for many centuries, at least since the forests were turned into fuel and coffins, and these have the benefit of being easily moved in just a few hours with a shovel as the work progresses.
Here several thousand coolies already, with two or three times as many to come, it is expected, are engaged in straightening out a great crook in the river. The methods are of course those of the Orient, where many men with shovels and baskets, swarming like trains of leaf-cutting ants over the scene of activities, are more economical than snorting steam-shovels and endless strings of rattling freight-cars. In the early spring, when mountains of broken ice from up the river joined that which had covered the flooded region during the short winter, the 307sight was one worth coming many li to see. But that was gone now, even in the middle of March, and the task of taking a kink out of “China’s Sorrow” is on the high road to completion. The plan is to teach the river the way it should go, and then let it scour out its own channel. Western initiative and ingenuity, however, probably can no more cure permanently the vagrancy of the Hoang Ho than did the ancient emperors, and corrective measures will have to be applied to the incorrigible vagabond among rivers at least for centuries to come.
Here, several thousand laborers are already working, with two or three times as many expected to arrive, to straighten out a major curve in the river. The methods being used are, of course, traditional for the region, where teams of men with shovels and baskets, moving around like swarms of leaf-cutting ants, are more efficient than noisy steam shovels and endless lines of rattling freight cars. In early spring, when mountains of broken ice from upstream joined the ice that had covered the flooded area during the brief winter, the scene was truly something worth traveling many miles to see. But that is gone now, even in mid-March, and the effort to fix “China’s Sorrow” is on track for completion. The plan is to guide the river in the right direction and then let it carve out its own channel. However, Western initiative and creativity probably won't be able to permanently solve the unpredictability of the Yellow River any more than the ancient emperors were able to, and corrective measures will need to be taken for this wayward river for at least centuries to come.
CHAPTER XVII
East to Tsingtao
A splendid task for some scholar of unlimited patience and a mathematical turn of mind would be to count the graves in China and compute how many sadly needed acres they withdraw from cultivation. He might offer a thesis on the subject, in exchange for the right to wear the letters “Ph.D.” Unfortunately he could not complete the task in a mere lifetime, or just a century or two, but the undertaking might be handed down, Chinese fashion, from father to son, until data were forthcoming that might in time make an impression even on the Celestial mind. This worshiping of ancestors is all very well, if only the living could also be given a fair deal. The constant sight of undernourished multitudes grubbing out a scant escape from starvation in the interstices between the sacred mounds of earth littering almost every Chinese landscape recalls the story of Bridget tearfully refusing Pat a taste before he died of the roasting pork that smelled so good to him, because it was all needed for the wake.
A fascinating job for a patient scholar with a knack for math would be to count the graves in China and figure out how many much-needed acres they take away from farming. He could write a thesis on the topic in exchange for the right to wear the title “Ph.D.” Unfortunately, he wouldn’t be able to finish the task in just a lifetime—or even a century or two—but it might be passed down, in true Chinese fashion, from father to son, until data were available that could eventually make an impact on the Celestial mind. This veneration of ancestors is nice and all, but it would be better if the living could also get a fair deal. The constant sight of undernourished crowds scraping out a meager existence from the gaps between the sacred mounds of earth scattered across almost every Chinese landscape brings to mind the story of Bridget tearfully denying Pat a taste of the delicious roasting pork before he died, because it was all needed for the wake.
Reflections of this simple nature were inclined to crowd out all other impressions during another of my cross-country jaunts in Shantung, this time northward to an ancient city still popularly called Loa-An. For the way led through Lin-tze, also walled, aged, and dreaming of the past, which in the days of Confucius was in the heart of the kingdom of Chi, as the home of the sage was in that of the neighboring one of Lu. For miles about it, therefore, the princes of Chi lie buried, not under the mere cones of earth of ordinary ancestors, but beneath hillocks and hills, and what sometimes seem across the floor-flat country to be almost mountains. Some are still so respected that the groves of mainly evergreen trees about them, beautifying the usual bare nudity of Chinese graves, have survived to this day, and one or two are guarded at a respectful distance by a standing stone giant who recalls those of Egypt or of the southern shores of Lake Titicaca. Then there are many lesser lights, such as always cluster about a court, and innumerable areas are sacred to other ancient families, the mounds graduated in size and state of repair from the principal one of the collection at the back to 309the small ones so far out in front that the peasants dare to cultivate close about them. Remnants of tissue-paper “money” donated to the dead all over China at the New Year still fluttered from the peak of many a mound, some of which dated so far back, perhaps, that live servants and domestic animals were buried in them, instead of the flimsy paper substitutes for these that are burned at modern funerals, along with papier-mâché automobiles containing a pair of painted chauffeurs and a concubine or two; but more than anything else, even of the sense of antiquity, one was impressed by the endlessness, the uncountability of the grave-mounds of all sizes.
Reflections of this simple nature tended to overshadow all other impressions during another one of my cross-country trips in Shantung, this time heading north to an ancient city still commonly known as Loa-An. The route went through Lin-tze, which is also walled, old, and steeped in history; it was once the heart of the kingdom of Chi during the days of Confucius, just as the sage's home was in the neighboring kingdom of Lu. For miles around, the princes of Chi are buried not under the simple mounds typical of ordinary ancestors, but beneath hillocks and hills, which sometimes appear almost like mountains in the flat landscape. Some are still so revered that the groves of mostly evergreen trees surrounding them, enhancing the usual bare expanse of Chinese graves, have survived to the present day. A few are protected at a respectful distance by a towering stone figure, reminiscent of those in Egypt or on the southern shores of Lake Titicaca. There are also many lesser graves that typically surround a royal court, and countless areas are dedicated to other ancient families, with the mounds varying in size and condition from the main ones at the back to the smaller ones at the front, where peasants dare to farm right next to them. Remnants of tissue-paper “money” offered to the dead throughout China during the New Year still flutter from the tops of many mounds, some of which may be so old that live servants and domestic animals were buried with them, rather than the flimsy paper substitutes that are burned at modern funerals alongside papier-mâché cars featuring painted chauffeurs and a couple of concubines. Yet, more than anything else—even more than the sense of antiquity—what stands out is the sheer number and uncountability of the grave mounds of all sizes.
Draft-animals, if only a cow or a donkey, or the two hitched together, were drawing crude but effective plows and what American farmers call a “drag,” on which the driver stands, raising clouds of dust behind him. But the dodging of graves seemed to be the most serious task of all, far as we rode northward, and one could fancy the undernourished peasants, suddenly struck with Western seeing in place of blind custom, deciding that it is high time these aged mounds are leveled off, or at least planted over. Possibly that miracle will some day come to pass, and China will by a turn of her hand increase her productive land by several provinces, without extending her boundaries or robbing her neighbors of an acre.
Draft animals, whether it's just a cow or a donkey, or even the two hitched together, were pulling simple but effective plows and what American farmers call a “drag,” which the driver stands on, kicking up clouds of dust behind him. However, avoiding the graves seemed to be the most serious task as we rode northward, and you could imagine the undernourished peasants, suddenly inspired by Western perspectives instead of blind tradition, deciding it’s about time to level off these old mounds or at least plant over them. Maybe that miracle will happen one day, and China will find a way to increase her arable land by several provinces without expanding her borders or taking an acre from her neighbors.
This time I used still another of Shantung’s many modes of locomotion,—a bicycle. It has its advantages in a flat country where the roads are often narrow paths, and where a vehicle that cannot be lifted about by hand now and then is limited in its range. But when it chances that a raging head wind blows both going and coming, and the contrivance between one’s aching legs emanates from a Chicago mail-order house, there are certain things to envy the traveler by wheelbarrow. In a way the season was poorly chosen, too, for though the day was cloudless and warm, plowing was on, and while the Chinese peasant leaves unmolested the graves that dot his little field, he often plows up the road. Thus a route which at best was an alternating between the bottom of a ditch deep in dust and a precariously narrow and by no means continuous path often on the sheer edge of it, frequently became a trackless field, plowed by draft-animals or chopped up with the clumsy, sledge-heavy adz-hoe still used in China. Rye and barley, and above all peanuts, were to be the principal crops wherever winter wheat was not already showing its tender green. One does not at first thought closely associate the two, but peanuts and missionaries are likely to lie side by side on the floor of the Chinese coolie’s mental granary. 310The Chinese had a peanut before the missionaries came, and still cultivate it to a certain extent. But it is so tiny and dry that it looks more like the end of a pea-pod, with a pea or two left in it, that has survived several winters in a very dry place—and the taste does not dispel this illusion. American missionaries brought the much more profitable variety from Georgia in an effort to improve the conditions of Shantung, and to-day the American peanuts grown in China probably run into millions of bushels, dotting every market-place and producing oil enough to supply the world with peanut-butter.
This time I used yet another one of Shantung’s many ways to get around—a bicycle. It’s handy in a flat area where the roads are often just narrow paths, and where a vehicle that can't be lifted by hand once in a while has a limited range. But when there’s a fierce headwind both ways and the bike you’re riding on comes from a Chicago mail-order company, it’s easy to envy someone traveling by wheelbarrow. The timing of the season wasn’t great either, because even though the day was clear and warm, plowing was happening. The Chinese farmer usually avoids disturbing the graves scattered through his small field, but he often ends up plowing the road. As a result, a path that was already a mix of deep, dusty ditches and narrow, shaky trails became a trackless field, churned up by draft animals or wrecked by the heavy, cumbersome adz-hoe still used in China. Rye and barley, especially peanuts, were set to be the main crops wherever winter wheat hadn’t started to show its tender green. At first glance, the two seem unrelated, but peanuts and missionaries likely share space in the Chinese coolie’s mind. The Chinese had peanuts long before the missionaries arrived and still grow them to some extent. But the ones they have are so small and dry that they resemble the end of a pea pod, with a couple of peas left inside, that has survived several winters in a very dry spot—and the taste doesn’t help shake that impression. American missionaries brought over a much more profitable variety from Georgia, hoping to improve the situation in Shantung, and today, American peanuts grown in China likely number in the millions of bushels, dotting every market and producing enough oil to supply the world with peanut butter.
Loa-An is no longer officially known by that name, and thereby hangs a typically Chinese tale. Soon after the establishment of what passes in the outside world for a republic, it was decreed that deeds of land-holdings must be registered again, though this had been done quite recently under the Manchus. The registry fee was to be a dollar and twenty cents, of which 70 per cent was to go to the Government and the rest to the local magistrate. Now, a dollar and twenty cents, even in “Mex,” is a lot of money to a Shantung peasant, with the tiny parcel of land which the custom of dividing among the sons of each generation has left him, and a decade ago it was still more so. Moreover, the magistrate should have known that in China government decrees are not necessarily meant to be carried out, at least beyond the point of individual discretion. But he was of the aggressive type of official, sadly needed perhaps but not always successful in China, and his insistence on having the order obeyed to the letter reached the point where he helped to carry it out in person. The wrath of the country-side increased. One day when the magistrate was some forty li out of town in the interest of thorough collections and an honest return of them from his constables, a band of peasants fell upon him and chopped him to death with their hoe-hooks.
Loa-An is no longer officially called that, and here's a characteristically Chinese story. Soon after what the outside world considers the establishment of a republic, it was decided that land ownership deeds had to be registered again, even though this had been done quite recently under the Manchus. The registration fee was set at one dollar and twenty cents, with 70 percent going to the Government and the rest to the local magistrate. Now, one dollar and twenty cents, even in “Mex,” is a lot of money for a Shantung peasant, who has only a tiny piece of land left after generations of dividing it among sons, and it was even more so a decade ago. Moreover, the magistrate should have realized that in China, government decrees aren’t always meant to be followed strictly, at least not beyond individual judgment. But he was the pushy type of official, perhaps sadly needed but often not effective in China, and his insistence on enforcing the order to the letter escalated to the point where he took part in carrying it out himself. The anger of the countryside grew. One day, when the magistrate was about forty li outside of town, focusing on thorough collections and making sure his constables returned the money honestly, a group of peasants attacked him and killed him with their hoe-hooks.
Soldiers were hurried to Loa-An, where they oppressed the population for months in the time-honored Chinese way, and finally lopped off eight heads. None of these had been the leading spirits in the assassination, nor perhaps had any real part in it at all, but they had been the easiest to catch; and, their duty ended, according to Chinese lights, the soldiers withdrew. But the Government saw fit to inflict a heinous punishment on the city of Loa-An itself, for the crime of permitting such a crime within its district. Loa-An means “Rejoicing and Peace,” as nearly as it can be translated; it was ordered henceforth to call itself Gwang-Rao. Does this mean “Bunch of Rascals,” or something of the sort, as we of the West might suppose? It does not; it means FarReaching 311Forgiveness, for, as I have already had occasion to remark, the Chinese mind may have been originally built on the same specifications as our own, but its manner of functioning has grown quite different during the many centuries that separate us. For one thing, it refuses to jar itself by sudden readjustments, and Gwang-Rao is still spoken of as Lao-An in ninety cases out of a hundred.
Soldiers were rushed to Loa-An, where they oppressed the local population for months in the traditional Chinese style, and finally executed eight people. None of them were the main culprits in the assassination, nor did they likely play any real role in it, but they were the easiest to capture; and, fulfilling their duty, according to Chinese standards, the soldiers left. However, the Government decided to impose a severe punishment on the city of Loa-An itself for allowing such a crime to happen in its area. Loa-An translates to "Rejoicing and Peace," but it was ordered to rename itself Gwang-Rao. Does this mean "Bunch of Rascals," or something similar, as we in the West might think? It doesn’t; it means Far-Reaching Forgiveness, because, as I’ve mentioned before, while the Chinese mind may have originally been built similarly to ours, its way of functioning has changed quite a bit over the centuries that separate us. For one thing, it avoids disruptive shifts, and Gwang-Rao is still referred to as Lao-An in ninety out of a hundred cases. 311
As is so often the case throughout China, much of the population and the business of Lao-An have gathered outside the city walls, where there are certain advantages which the American suburbanite will understand. Inside, there is that atmosphere of an old ladies’ home which one feels in an aged New England village off the trail of modern progress—though certainly in outward appearance there are no two things more dissimilar than a New England village and a Chinese walled town. An immense pond or lake takes up a whole corner of the enclosure, licking away at the inner base of the crumbling wall. In its prime this was almost majestic, higher than anything within it, broad enough for a “Peking cart” to drive comfortably upon it, the crenelated parapets armed with small cannon of curious casting which now lie rusting away wherever chance has rolled them. There are other open spaces within the walls, some cultivated, some merely idle, but the town itself is compact enough, with one long trough of dust or mud as a main street, lined by baked-earth houses of one form or another, enlivened only by an occasional hawker marking his leisurely progress by some Chinese species of noise, or a long unlaundered family group enjoying the brilliant sunshine of early spring.
As is often the case throughout China, a lot of the population and the businesses of Lao-An have gathered outside the city walls, where there are certain perks that the American suburbanite would understand. Inside, there’s an atmosphere reminiscent of an old ladies' home that you find in a quaint New England village, far removed from modern progress—though in terms of appearance, a New England village and a Chinese walled town couldn’t be more different. A huge pond or lake occupies one corner of the enclosure, slowly eroding the inner base of the decaying wall. In its heyday, this was quite majestic, taller than anything inside, wide enough for a “Peking cart” to drive comfortably on, with crenelated parapets featuring small cannons of unusual design that now rust away wherever they fall. There are other open spaces within the walls, some cultivated and some just lying idle, but the town itself is compact, with one long strip of dust or mud as the main street, lined by baked-earth houses of various types, brought to life only by the occasional hawker making his slow way through with some sort of Chinese noise or a long-unwashed family group soaking up the brilliant sunshine of early spring.
Outside it is different,—movement, crowding, an uproar of wide-open shops and transient venders, all noisily contending for patronage, dwellings that are almost imposing in their milieu, and, in the outskirts, a large Presbyterian school and mission under an unusually trusted Chinese pastor. His board beds may not have been the last word in comfort, but they were many times nearer that than a passing guest could have found in all the rest of the district. The auditing, counseling, and moral sustenance for which the white-haired missionary I had accompanied made his annual visit to Lao-An, with a brief service by the honored visitor and a few moments in the unheated school-rooms, where full outdoor garb was in order, left us time to go to prison before we faced the head wind again. It was typical probably of most local limbos in Shantung, unless the weekly services which the pastor had been allowed to give there for a year now had remodeled the moral outlook of the prisoners as completely as he believed: cells that were 312larger than the average inmate had at home, and not overcrowded, by Chinese standards, tolerable food and plenty of sunshine, a certain semi-freedom at times in the yards, and in contrast iron fetters about the neck, waist, and ankles in most cases, with clanking chains connecting them. The prisoners got five coppers a day to feed themselves—more than a whole American cent! Yet they lived well, according to the pastor, and could save money. Three coppers paid for a catty (a pound and a third) of millet, and the grain hong saw to it that they got good measure. What average Shantung countryman is sure of a catty of millet a day? Besides, they were paid for their work. The young and spry could earn as much as ten coppers daily making hair-nets, and the older ones, with their more clumsy fingers, half as much weaving dee-tze—girdles, I suppose we would call them, though the Chinese use twice as many of them about their ankles as around their waists. Then Loa-An gets great quantities of a rush the size of a lead-pencil from nearer the mouth of the Yellow River, and from these are fashioned baskets and scoops, and shallow basins for the feeding of animals, buckets for use at wells, winnowing pans, and, strangest of all, a thick winter shoe that looks like an infant Roman galley.
Outside, things are different—lots of movement, crowds, the noise of open shops and temporary vendors, all loudly competing for customers, homes that are almost impressive in their surroundings, and on the outskirts, a large Presbyterian school and mission run by a well-respected Chinese pastor. His board beds may not have been the most comfortable, but they were much better than what a passing guest would find anywhere else in the area. The auditing, counseling, and moral support that the elderly missionary I accompanied provided during his annual visit to Lao-An included a brief service by the esteemed visitor and some time in unheated classrooms, where we needed to wear full outdoor clothing, leaving us time to visit the prison before facing the headwind again. This was likely typical of most local situations in Shantung, unless the weekly services the pastor had been allowed to conduct there for a year had completely changed the prisoners' moral outlook as he believed: cells larger than what the average inmate had at home, not overcrowded by Chinese standards, decent food, plenty of sunshine, and some limited freedom in the yards, contrasted with iron shackles around their necks, waists, and ankles, often connected by clanking chains. The prisoners received five coppers a day for food—more than a whole American cent! Yet they lived well, according to the pastor, and could save money. Three coppers bought a catty (about a pound and a third) of millet, and the grain seller ensured they got a good amount. What average farmer from Shantung can count on a catty of millet a day? Plus, they were paid for their work. The young and agile could earn as much as ten coppers each day making hair nets, while the older ones, with their less nimble fingers, earned half that weaving dee-tze—which we would probably call girdles, although the Chinese use twice as many around their ankles as they do around their waists. Then, Lao-An receives large quantities of a rush that’s the size of a pencil from closer to the mouth of the Yellow River, which is used to make baskets, scoops, shallow basins for feeding animals, buckets for wells, winnowing pans, and, strangest of all, thick winter shoes that look like tiny Roman galleys.
All the romance of hair-nets is not limited to the tresses they confine. Shantung, and to a lesser degree some neighboring provinces, has known some of it. Until Europe went mad, hair-nets were made mainly in France. America, callous upstart, continued to demand them even though the guns were thundering. Some of the materials had always come from China, though the French were much given to the use of horsehair; now it occurred to some genius that the Chinese might be taught to make them on the spot. A small town in Shantung became the center of the new industry; later it gravitated naturally to Chefoo. Every one took to turning discarded cues and combings into nets; children learned to tie them; coolies forced their clumsy fingers to it when nothing else offered; in mission churches women pinned the things to one another’s backs and went on tying the little knots while they listened to the sermon. The making of hair-nets kept many from starvation in famine days, even though the wholesalers took advantage of the situation and paid the hungry toilers as little as possible. Even in the best of times the workers make no fortune. They are paid by the gross of nets; women and children working at odd times can earn from five to ten coppers a day; those who are skilled and put in all their time at it make from thirty-five to fifty coppers—ten to thirteen cents 313gold—when the nets are selling at their highest, five to seven dollars “Mex” a gross. Just now they were down to half that, and with a great oversupply of nets on the market and fashion turning toward the double-strand net, the makers were getting hardly three American cents a dozen.
All the charm of hair nets isn't just about the hair they hold back. Shantung, and to a lesser extent some nearby provinces, has experienced some of it. Before Europe went crazy, hair nets were mainly produced in France. America, the reckless newcomer, kept wanting them even while the guns were firing. Some of the materials had always come from China, although the French often used horsehair; now someone brilliant thought to teach the Chinese to make them on site. A small town in Shantung became the hub of this new industry, which eventually moved to Chefoo. Everyone started turning leftover hair and combings into nets; children learned to tie them; laborers awkwardly tried when no other work was available; in mission churches, women pinned the nets to each other's backs and kept tying little knots while listening to the sermon. Making hair nets saved many from starving during famine times, even though wholesalers exploited the situation and paid the desperate workers as little as possible. Even in the best of times, the workers don’t make a fortune. They’re paid by the gross of nets; women and children working in their spare time can earn between five to ten coppers a day; those who are skilled and dedicate all their time can earn from thirty-five to fifty coppers—about ten to thirteen cents—when the nets are selling for their highest, five to seven dollars "Mex" per gross. Right now, prices were down to half that, and with a huge surplus of nets on the market and fashion shifting toward double-strand nets, makers were getting hardly three American cents a dozen.
Many wholesalers, on the other hand, have quickly gotten rich out of hair-nets. There is a barber, for instance, who is known to have laid up ten thousand dollars in three or four years, a great fortune in China even to men far above the lowly barber caste. But the newly rich are not so kindly treated where class lines are still rather sharply drawn and precedent especially tenacious. His envious neighbors overwhelmed their former hair-cutter with lawsuits, the most common and effective form of Chinese community persecution; though he turned his money into land he can neither live on nor rent it, so virulent is the prejudice against him. With the coming of hair-nets the bicycle trade boomed. This was the only quick way of getting about the country, and the buyers could carry thousands of nets back with them. The Germans of Tsingtao had good Fahrräder to offer at reasonable prices, and made the most of their opportunity. Then came a slump in the trade, hints of the reasons for which in time reached the wholesalers, if not the makers. American girls had taken to bobbing their hair! But this fad had begun to die out again, and already the people of overcrowded Shantung were feeling the effect of this in fuller bowls of rice.
Many wholesalers, on the other hand, have quickly gotten rich from hair nets. For example, there’s a barber known to have saved up ten thousand dollars in just three or four years, a huge fortune in China, even for someone far above the lowly barber class. However, the newly rich don't get treated kindly where class lines are still pretty solid and tradition is particularly strong. His envious neighbors overwhelmed their former hair-cutter with lawsuits, which is the most common and effective form of community harassment in China; although he invested his money in land, he can't live on it or rent it out due to the severe prejudice against him. With the rise of hair nets, the bicycle trade skyrocketed. This was the quickest way to get around the country, and buyers could carry thousands of nets back with them. The Germans in Tsingtao had good Bikes to offer at reasonable prices and really took advantage of the situation. Then a downturn in the trade hit, and hints of the reasons eventually reached the wholesalers, if not the manufacturers. American girls had started bobbing their hair! But this trend began to fade away again, and already the overcrowded people of Shantung were noticing the impact in fuller bowls of rice.
In wandering about Shantung I was constantly coming across coolies who had been to France. One could generally tell them at a glance, from some remnant of uniform, or their way of wearing what they had chosen when that wore out, perhaps by a certain air of something that was not exactly what we popularly dub “freshness,” yet which was more or less distantly related to it. Besides, they seldom waited long on the chance of recognition, but greeted the foreigner with the self-confidence of familiarity and proceeded to impress their fellow-countrymen who had been denied their advantages, and who never failed to gather about in as great a circle as the community afforded.
While wandering around Shantung, I kept running into coolies who had been to France. You could usually spot them right away, from a piece of their old uniform or their style of wearing whatever they chose after that wore out. There was also a certain vibe about them that wasn’t exactly what we call “freshness,” but was somewhat related. They rarely waited long for someone to recognize them; instead, they greeted foreigners with the self-assurance of familiarity and went on to impress their fellow countrymen, who missed out on those experiences and always gathered around in the largest circle available in the community.
The British and, to some extent, the French, took large numbers of coolies overseas for work behind the lines, mainly from Shantung and southern China. Some three hundred thousand went from this northern province, at first slowly and with misgivings, then more eagerly, as propaganda and the reports of those who had gone ahead filtered out through the villages. The French made some arrangement whereby their recruits seem to have been much lower paid, yet to have come home more contented, than those with the British. The latter offered 314them ten Chinese dollars a month in France and an equal amount to their families at home, with of course transportation, food, and clothing. This was so high that at first the coolies would not believe it; these wily foreigners must have something else up their sleeves, they told one another, putting them out in front of the soldiers perhaps, for it was a rare coolie who had ever earned half the amount so glibly offered. But the incredible turned out to be true. Several towns were designated as district headquarters; foreign residents, usually missionaries, were asked to take charge in them, and once a month the nearest of kin of the absent workmen came in and got their ten dollars, in coin. At Weihsien ninety thousand were paid monthly for several years, for the coolies of the labor battalions were not returned until 1920, after the carrying of troops had been completed. Up to that time the Chinese with the British had been quite satisfied. But when they came to draw what they had saved during their years abroad there was an uproar. In the contract made with them “Mex” dollars were specified; there was no mention of francs. But in France they were of course paid in the money of the country, and the amounts they chose to lay aside were credited to them in francs. By the time they came to draw their savings the franc had crashed. Being from China they should have been wiser on the vagaries of exchange than the American “doughboy”; but they insisted that the British had promised to pay them in the dollars of their home-land, and raised such a hullabaloo that the matter reached the honor of being discussed in Parliament, though that was its loftiest attainment. The resentment at what was considered a raw deal by tricky foreigners has somewhat died out in Shantung now, and many a man would willingly go abroad for the British again; but the few wise or lucky coolies who turned their francs back into dollars as they saved them, and then meddled with the exchange in those glorious days when the gold dollar went down to about eighty cents “Mex,” are still the envy of their comrades. In an almost entirely illiterate throng, thousands of miles from home and all its exchange-shops and customs, and filled from childhood with suspicion of their fellow-men, it is easy to guess about how many took advantage of this opportunity.
The British, and to some degree the French, recruited a large number of laborers from Shantung and southern China to work behind the front lines. About three hundred thousand came from this northern province, initially hesitantly and with doubts, but later more enthusiastically as propaganda and reports from those who had already gone circulated through the villages. The French seemed to have offered their recruits much lower pay, yet they appeared to return home happier than their British counterparts. The British provided them with ten Chinese dollars per month in France, plus an equal amount for their families back home, along with transportation, food, and clothing. This pay was so generous that at first, the laborers didn’t believe it; they thought these clever foreigners must be hiding something, suggesting they might be sent to the front lines instead, since it was rare for a laborer to have ever earned half that amount. But the unbelievable offer turned out to be true. A few towns were designated as district headquarters; foreign residents, usually missionaries, were asked to oversee these areas, and once a month, the families of the absent workers came to collect their ten dollars in cash. In Weihsien, ninety thousand were paid monthly for several years because the laborers in the battalions weren't returned until 1920 after the troop transportation was complete. Until then, the Chinese workers with the British were quite satisfied. However, when they returned to claim their savings after years abroad, chaos erupted. The contract specified "Mex" dollars, with no mention of francs. In France, they were paid in the local currency, and the amounts they saved were credited to them in francs. By the time they went to withdraw their savings, the franc had collapsed. Being from China, they should have been more aware of currency fluctuations than the American soldiers, but they insisted the British had promised to pay them in their homeland's dollars and raised such a ruckus that it even made it to Parliament, which was quite a high achievement. The resentment over what was perceived as a bad deal by deceitful foreigners has faded somewhat in Shantung now, and many men would willingly go abroad for the British again; however, the few savvy or fortunate workers who exchanged their francs back into dollars as they saved them, and took advantage of the favorable exchange rates during those times when the gold dollar dropped to about eighty cents "Mex," remain the envy of their peers. In a largely illiterate crowd, thousands of miles from home and all its currency exchange services, and filled with distrust from childhood, it’s easy to imagine how many took advantage of this opportunity.
One suspects that it was from the highest point of honor attained by this painful subject that there originated an attempt to soften the resentment that only resulted in increasing it. Legislative bodies the world over have a reputation for bone-headedness. One day word was sent out over Shantung and beyond that if coolies who had been to France for the British would report back to the centers where they 315had been discharged and paid they would learn something to their advantage. Aha, ting hao! they are going to give us all the money they promised after all, said the coolies, and began to flock in from all directions, often from considerable distances. Some came overland all the way from Tientsin, not being able to afford the railroad. When they arrived they were each given a nice brass medal to hang about their necks, with a likeness of their grateful ex-employer, King Georgie, on one side and words of similar sentiment on the other. Any one with thirty cents’ worth of understanding of the psychology of the Chinese coolie could have told the thoughtful originators of this idea that an extra cumshaw of a dollar or two would have won his everlasting gratitude far more than a medal graced with the vapid faces of all the kings of Christendom—and probably have cost less money. But textbooks on psychology, particularly of far-off “heathen” lands, are not required in a politician’s education. At first some of the coolies thought the things were gold, and raced to the exchange-shops accordingly. When these reported that the gaudy gifts were not even coin at all, men drifted out to mission compounds to inquire what they were good for.... “Is it worth anything?” “Well, I’ll give it to you for fifteen coppers.”
One can assume that at the peak of honor achieved by this difficult issue, there was an attempt to ease the anger, which only made it worse. Legislative bodies everywhere have a reputation for being clueless. One day, a message spread across Shantung and beyond that if coolies who had gone to France for the British reported back to the places where they had been discharged and paid, they would learn something beneficial. Aha, ting hao! They’re finally going to give us all the money they promised, the coolies thought, and began to come in from all directions, often traveling from far away. Some came overland all the way from Tientsin because they couldn’t afford the train. When they arrived, each was given a nice brass medal to hang around their necks, featuring a likeness of their grateful former employer, King Georgie, on one side and similar words on the other. Anyone with even a basic understanding of Chinese coolie psychology could have told the thoughtful creators of this idea that an extra cumshaw of a dollar or two would have earned their lasting gratitude far more than a medal adorned with the bland faces of all the kings of Christendom—and would probably have cost less. But politicians typically aren’t required to study psychology, especially regarding distant “heathen” lands. Initially, some of the coolies thought the medals were gold and rushed to the exchange shops. When these shops revealed that the flashy gifts weren't even currency at all, men wandered into mission compounds to ask what they were good for.... “Is it worth anything?” “Well, I’ll give you fifteen coppers for it.”
Coppers, by the way, are the general medium of exchange in Shantung. Silver dollars pass, though silver fractions of them do not, and bank-notes even of the province have only a limited acceptance. Except in large towns or transactions, every one pays in coppers, the division being the diao. In olden days this meant a thousand “cash” on a string. Now it means forty-nine coppers in most regions. How this decided change came about is only another of the queer stories with which monetary matters bristle in China. One day the Manchu dynasty decided it could get plenty of money to pay its grumbling troops merely by decreeing that thenceforth a diao would be five hundred, not a thousand, “cash.” Every one would be compelled to accept the new rating, on penalty of severe punishment, and the surplus five hundred “cash” would accrue to the Government. As late as the beginning of the present century the brass “cash” was the only money used in the interior of Shantung; in those days my missionary friends had taken an extra wheelbarrow with them to carry their change. Then in 1902 the copper began to be minted. Ten “cash” make a copper; fifty coppers therefore should make a modern diao; but in most places one of them goes to some one, identity unknown but strongly suspected, as the inevitable “squeeze” of all Chinese transactions.
Coppers, by the way, are the main currency in Shantung. Silver dollars are accepted, but silver fractions aren’t, and even local banknotes have limited use. Unless you’re in a big city or dealing with large transactions, everyone uses coppers, with the unit being the diao. In the past, this meant a thousand “cash” on a string. Now it represents forty-nine coppers in most areas. How this significant change happened is just one of the strange stories that surround financial matters in China. One day, the Manchu dynasty decided it could easily gather money to pay its dissatisfied troops by declaring that from then on a diao would equal five hundred instead of a thousand “cash.” Everyone was forced to accept this new value, or face severe penalties, and the extra five hundred “cash” would go to the Government. Up until the beginning of this century, brass “cash” was the only currency used in the interior of Shantung; at that time, my missionary friends even brought an extra wheelbarrow to carry their change. Then in 1902, the copper began to be minted. Ten “cash” make a copper, so fifty coppers should make a modern diao; however, in many places, one of them disappears to someone, whose identity is unknown but is strongly suspected to be the inevitable “squeeze” in all Chinese transactions.
316Probably a majority of the third-class tickets sold on the Tientsin-Pukow line in Shantung are paid for from clothfuls of coppers handed in at the window, the cloth and any excess coins being returned with the ticket. The foreigner who produces a silver dollar when only a few cents are needed will be deluged with a shower of huge coppers sufficient to fill an overcoat pocket. The general run of prices and wages in Shantung is suggested by some of those paid by my missionary companion. Master masons were receiving fifty-four coppers a day, their helpers thirty-six—a copper being approximately half a farthing or the fourth of an American cent. In the good old days of a decade or more back they were satisfied with fifteen and ten respectively, though the copper was then worth 50 per cent more than at present. Country pastors are paid twenty Chinese dollars a month, those in towns all the way from that to forty, “Bible women” eight dollars, “evangelists” (unordained preachers who also work on their farms) receive eleven, teachers from eighteen to forty, and native doctors fifty.
316Most of the third-class tickets sold on the Tientsin-Pukow line in Shantung are bought with handfuls of coins handed over at the window, with the cloth and any leftover change returned along with the ticket. If a foreigner pulls out a silver dollar when only a few cents are needed, they’ll get flooded with a pile of large coins enough to fill an overcoat pocket. The average prices and wages in Shantung can be illustrated by what my missionary companion was paid. Skilled masons earned fifty-four coins a day, while their helpers earned thirty-six—a coin being roughly half a farthing or a quarter of an American cent. Back in the good old days over a decade ago, they were content with fifteen and ten respectively, even though the coin was worth 50 percent more at that time. Country pastors receive twenty Chinese dollars a month, while those in towns earn anywhere from that to forty, “Bible women” get eight dollars, “evangelists” (unordained preachers who also farm) earn eleven, teachers make between eighteen and forty, and local doctors receive fifty.
At Weihsien “Peking carts” are the almost exclusive means of transportation, though forty miles west a similar town has only wheelbarrows. This important half-way station between Tzinan and Tsingtao lies in the heart of what was thirty centuries ago the kingdom of Wei, and the landscape on either side of it is littered with monuments and graves. Shantung is much given to elaborately carved stone p’ai-lous, or p’ai-fangs, as they are more often called in that province, and these imposing memorial arches to virtuous widows or officials more or less willingly honored naturally outlast the mainly wooden ones in Peking and vicinity. Stone horses completely saddled and bridled, stirrups hanging ready for instant use, stood with other less familiar animals before some of the graves, awaiting their riders these many centuries; and groves of evergreens, some of them overtopped by the four reddish upright poles bearing a kind of ship’s crow’s-nest which means that the principal deceased of the group some time in the bygone ages passed the examinations for the highest rank of Chinese scholar, were a little more frequent about them than is general in northern China, though there were still far too many of the one and too few of the other.
At Weihsien, "Peking carts" are almost the only way to get around, while forty miles west, a similar town relies solely on wheelbarrows. This important halfway point between Tzinan and Tsingtao sits in the heart of what was the kingdom of Wei thirty centuries ago, and the landscape on either side is dotted with monuments and graves. Shantung is known for its elaborately carved stone p’ai-lous, or p’ai-fangs, as they are often called in that province. These grand memorial arches to virtuous widows or officials, who were honored more or less willingly, have naturally outlasted the mainly wooden ones around Peking. Stone horses, completely saddled and bridled with stirrups ready for use, stood alongside other less familiar animals before some of the graves, waiting for their riders for many centuries. Groves of evergreens, some topped with four reddish upright poles that bear a type of ship's crow's nest indicating that the main deceased of the group once passed the exams for the highest rank of Chinese scholar, were slightly more common in this area than in northern China, though there were still too many of the former and too few of the latter.
Weihsien is really two distinct cities, each surrounded by a massive stone wall, with a sandy-bedded river between them. But the farther one was not walled until the days of the Taiping Rebellion, and it is still regarded as a suburb of the other. Thanks to spring rain and water-carriers, the streets of both were rivers of mud in which a mule-cart 317was almost indispensable even for the shortest distance, and an ordeal into the bargain. Weihsien had indeed recently imported her first rickshaws, but all three of them were without rubber tires or experienced runners, which made the first jaunts in them by a few of the town dandies an experience to be remembered rather than to be repeated or recommended, and the fear was expressed that these evidences of modern progress would be withdrawn for lack of appreciation. However, the new autobus line to Chefoo starts from Weihsien, and motor-cars have become almost familiar sights to those who have come out to see them at the edge of the suburb, beyond which they cannot penetrate. There should long since have been a branch railway to Chefoo. Ocean communication with that important silk and hair-net center is irregular and uncertain—except from Dairen over in Japanese-controlled Manchuria. But so long as they held the Shantung Railway the Japanese would not permit this extension, lest Chefoo become a serious rival to their beloved Dairen. So the usual raised dirt highway has been built, with frequent guarded barriers to keep others off it, and along this the few still movable contrivances of all sizes and makes which were bought second-hand from the Japanese before they evacuated Shantung stagger in a daily service scheduled to make the journey in a day and a half, with the brick bed of a Chinese inn to break it. The line is under railway management, but one glimpse of the once gasolene-driven wrecks that litter the yard at Weihsien should convince the most foolhardy that to ride behind a Chinese chauffeur is more risky than behind the worst locomotive driver in the Orient. Chefoo, by the way, is unknown to the Chinese; they call it Yentai. Just what misunderstanding on the part of early sailors led to the name by which it is known to all foreigners, including the Japanese, seems never to have been fully cleared up.
Weihsien is really two separate cities, each surrounded by a massive stone wall, with a sandy river running between them. However, the further city wasn't walled until the days of the Taiping Rebellion, and it is still seen as a suburb of the other. Thanks to spring rain and water carriers, the streets of both cities were rivers of mud where a mule cart was almost essential even for the shortest distances, and quite a challenge as well. Weihsien had recently introduced its first rickshaws, but all three of them lacked rubber tires and experienced runners, making the first rides for a few of the local socialites an experience to remember rather than to repeat or recommend, with concerns expressed that these signs of modern progress might disappear due to lack of appreciation. However, the new bus line to Chefoo starts from Weihsien, and motor cars have become nearly familiar sights to those who came out to see them at the edge of the suburb, beyond which they can't go. There really should have been a branch railway to Chefoo long ago. Ocean communication with that important silk and hairnet center is inconsistent and uncertain—except from Dairen in Japanese-controlled Manchuria. But as long as the Japanese controlled the Shantung Railway, they wouldn't allow this extension, fearing Chefoo would become a serious rival to their beloved Dairen. So, a raised dirt road has been built, with frequent guarded barriers to keep others off it, where the few remaining makeshift vehicles bought second-hand from the Japanese before they left Shantung stagger through a daily schedule designed to make the journey in a day and a half, with a stop at a Chinese inn to break it up. The line is run by railway management, but just one look at the once gasoline-powered wrecks littering the yard at Weihsien should convince even the most reckless that riding with a Chinese driver is riskier than traveling behind the worst locomotive driver in the Orient. By the way, Chefoo is unknown to the Chinese; they call it Yentai. The exact misunderstanding by early sailors that led to the name known to all foreigners, including the Japanese, has never really been clarified.
When Tzinan was voluntarily opened to trade in 1906, Weihsien, as well as Choutsun farther west, was also designated as a “port”; but though the Chinese laid out “foreign settlements” in them no one came to settle. A stray German or two is all that the city has to offer in this line, except the missionaries. The Catholics have an imposing church building just outside the walls, and there is an important mission school established by one of the pioneers among American Presbyterians in China, far outside the town, where the bitter hostility of those earlier days drove him. When the school was first founded, pupils had to be paid to attend; to-day there are waiting lists at fifty-eight dollars a year—a great deal of money, let it be kept in mind, in Shantung—of which 318twenty-five dollars pays a year’s board. Millet or kaoliang in a kind of gruel seemed to be the chief diet. Then there was the pickled tuber resembling a turnip that is constantly munched all over Shantung, and which does away with any desire to salt the other food. There were flocks of timid high-school girls in their neat trousers, though missionary influence tends to introduce the skirt, which is surely mistaken zeal for mere change. The trousers are more convenient, more becoming, and certainly many times more modest than the unstable garb of our modern maidens of the West. Formerly many Shantung women of the better class, influenced perhaps by the Manchus, who once had walled towns of bannermen in all this region, wore a skirt over their trousers when they appeared in public, and older missionary ladies can still remember the polite greeting when they reached the home of a Chinese hostess: “Well, take off your skirt and stay a while.”
When Tzinan opened up to trade in 1906, Weihsien and Choutsun, further west, were also designated as "ports"; but even though the Chinese created "foreign settlements" there, nobody came to settle down. Just a handful of Germans are all the city can boast in this regard, aside from the missionaries. The Catholics have a striking church just outside the walls, and there is a significant mission school established by one of the early American Presbyterian pioneers in China, far from the town, where the harsh hostility of earlier times drove him. When the school first opened, students had to be paid to attend; today, there are waiting lists at fifty-eight dollars a year—a significant amount, remember, in Shantung—of which twenty-five dollars covers a year’s boarding. Millet or kaoliang in a kind of porridge seemed to be the main diet. Then there was the pickled vegetable resembling a turnip that is constantly eaten throughout Shantung, which eliminates the need to salt the other food. There were groups of shy high school girls in their smart trousers, though missionary influence tends to push for skirts, which is probably misguided enthusiasm for mere change. The trousers are more practical, more flattering, and certainly much more modest than the unstable clothing worn by modern young women in the West. In the past, many women in Shantung from the upper classes, perhaps influenced by the Manchus, who once had walled towns of bannermen throughout the area, wore a skirt over their trousers when they went out in public, and older missionary ladies can still remember the polite greeting upon arriving at a Chinese hostess's home: “Well, take off your skirt and stay a while.”
The large church of the Weihsien mission was well filled at Thursday evening prayer-meeting and packed at the principal Sunday service. Chinese pastors officiated on both occasions. Though the weather was still distinctly cold, no provision for heating the building was made, and one could only guess what it must be in midwinter. Gradually the stone floor congealed the feet and removed them completely from the realms of sensation, but the Chinese, in their full outdoor garb, caps and all, seemed to be as comfortable as they ever have any need to be. Uncovering the head had become so nearly a dead letter that even the two or three American missionaries in their overcoats usually kept their hats on, even when they rose to pray in fluent Chinese. The feminine portion of the congregation occupied the back part of the church, the boys the front and center, graduating back to youths and men behind and on either side; when prayers were offered all rose to their feet instead of kneeling, and the less said of the bold and stentorian “singing” of hymns the better.
The large church of the Weihsien mission was mostly full at the Thursday evening prayer meeting and packed for the main Sunday service. Chinese pastors led both events. Even though the weather was still quite cold, there was no heating in the building, and one could only imagine what it would feel like in midwinter. Gradually, the stone floor numbed people's feet, making them feel completely disconnected from reality, but the Chinese, dressed in their full outdoor attire, including caps, seemed as comfortable as they ever needed to be. The custom of removing hats had almost disappeared, so even the few American missionaries in their overcoats usually kept their hats on, even when they stood up to pray in fluent Chinese. The women in the congregation sat at the back of the church, while the boys were in the front and center, with youths and men filling in behind and on either side; when prayers were offered, everyone stood up instead of kneeling, and the less said about the loud and boisterous "singing" of hymns, the better.
A few weeks before my visit the Shantung Railway had been turned over to the Chinese, in accordance with the agreement reached at the Washington Conference. But to go back to the beginning: you will recall that two German missionaries were killed in Shantung in 1897 and that Germany quickly made this a pretext for demanding the lease of Kiaochow Bay, and the concession for a railroad from there to the capital of the province. Though it was a generation since the Chinese Government had been able to still popular uproar against such diabolic contrivances only by buying out the first railway in China, running a 319few miles out of Shanghai, and shipping it over to Formosa, there was bitter opposition to this one, ostensibly from the superstitious masses, though it is known now that officials and some of the gentry urged the people on. In fact, the building of the Shantung Railway was very largely responsible for the “Boxer” uprising, which had its beginning, as I have said before, in mountainous southern Shantung. The exasperation was partly due to pure superstition, partly to real grievances which the Germans unwittingly perpetrated. They cut through the hill south of Weihsien which had brought the town all its good luck for centuries, and thereby destroyed its beneficence. This matter of feng-shui, of placating the spirits of wind and water, is of the highest importance, and there seems to be no fixed rule in dealing with them. For instance, there is another peak, west of Weihsien, through the top of which a slot quite like a railway cutting was gashed centuries ago at great labor, in order to neutralize the bad luck it brought the town. When they first came the Germans had to depend upon interpreters, and these of course were true Chinese. They would stroll out when they were off duty, or when no one was watching, and drive a survey stake in the top of a grave, perhaps miles from the projected route of the railroad; and a day or two later they would offer to get the stake removed and leave the grave unmolested if the descendants could raise money enough to “bribe the Germans.” When a railroad is surveyed its proposed turns are marked as sharp angles first and the curve is traced inside this later. The interpreters collected handsomely also from farmers for getting the Germans to remove stakes on the points of these angles—where the railroad had never thought of trespassing. In spite of both passive and active opposition the Germans pushed the line rapidly inland; many Chinese Christians free from the popular superstitions or sustained by the missionaries took contracts to prepare the way by sections, and early in the present century locomotives snorted into Tzinanfu.
A few weeks before my visit, the Shantung Railway was handed over to the Chinese, as agreed upon at the Washington Conference. But let's go back to the beginning: you might remember that two German missionaries were killed in Shantung in 1897, and Germany quickly used this as an excuse to demand the lease of Kiaochow Bay and a concession for a railroad from there to the provincial capital. It had been a generation since the Chinese Government had managed to quiet public outcry against such malicious schemes by buying out the first railway in China, which ran a few miles out of Shanghai and was then shipped to Formosa. There was fierce opposition to this new railway, supposedly from the superstitious masses, although it’s now known that officials and some local elites incited the people against it. In fact, the construction of the Shantung Railway was largely responsible for the "Boxer" uprising, which started, as I mentioned before, in the mountainous southern Shantung. The frustration stemmed partly from sheer superstition and partly from genuine grievances that the Germans unintentionally caused. They cut through the hill south of Weihsien, which had brought good luck to the town for centuries, thereby ruining its good fortune. The issue of feng-shui, which involves appeasing the spirits of wind and water, is extremely important, and there seem to be no fixed rules for managing them. For example, there's another peak, west of Weihsien, where a slot resembling a railway cut was carved centuries ago after much effort, meant to neutralize the bad luck it brought to the town. When they first arrived, the Germans relied on interpreters, who were, of course, native Chinese. These interpreters would sneak out when they were off duty or when no one was watching and would drive a survey stake on top of a grave, possibly miles away from the planned railroad route. A day or two later, they would offer to remove the stake and leave the grave undisturbed if the descendants could come up with enough money to "bribe the Germans." When surveying for a railroad, the intended bends are initially marked as sharp angles, and the curve is then traced inside these later. The interpreters also made a nice profit from farmers for getting the Germans to remove stakes at the angle points—places where the railroad had never intended to encroach. Despite both passive and active resistance, the Germans pushed the line quickly inland; many Chinese Christians, free from the prevailing superstitions or supported by missionaries, took contracts to clear the way in sections, and early in the current century, locomotives rolled into Tzinanfu.
The line still bears many marks of its original nationality. It is a direct descendant of the railways of Germany—excellently built, with stone ballast in exact military alignment along flanking paths of exactly such a width, iron ties of the reversed trough shape, light rails and fourteen-ton bridges—European rolling stock is not heavy by our standards—well-built stations, service buildings, and grade-markers, still here and there bearing a German name, in spite of eight years of Japanese occupancy, the whole railway still lined for much of its length by the quick-growing acacia-trees which the Germans expected to furnish 320supports for their mines. Now that the Chinese have returned, one frequently runs across a station-master who speaks German but no English.
The line still shows many signs of its original nationality. It’s a direct descendant of the railways in Germany—well-constructed, with stone ballast precisely aligned along paths of the same width, iron ties shaped like inverted troughs, light rails, and fourteen-ton bridges—European rolling stock isn't heavy by our standards—well-built stations, service buildings, and grade markers, still occasionally bearing a German name, despite eight years of Japanese control. The entire railway is still lined for much of its length by the fast-growing acacia trees that the Germans planted to support their mines. Now that the Chinese have returned, it's common to encounter a station master who speaks German but no English.
It is said that there was more graft under the Germans than under their successors. German inspectors were conspicuous; Japanese ones blended more or less into the general racial landscape. In German days unrecorded telegrams sped along from station to station, “Inspector coming to-day,” and certain customs were temporarily suspended. On other days passengers often got on without tickets, crossed the hand of the Chinese guard with silver, and the latter gave the high sign to the gateman at the disembarking station, dividing the spoils with him at the first convenient opportunity. Whatever their other faults, the Japanese know how to run a railroad, and under them this sort of thing is reputed to have disappeared. Their influence was still distinctly in evidence. The people are said to have liked the Germans better than their successors because, among other things, they were not so strict—which speaks loudly indeed for Japanese sternness. Part of this strictness was the insistence on order instead of the free-for-all methods so loved by the Chinese. The Germans allowed huckstering at the trains; the Japanese licensed and curbed it. They introduced the innovation of standing in line for tickets, instead of the riot in vogue on all purely Chinese railways. It is said that it took the butt of many a rifle and the flat of many a sword to convince the coolies that they should drop back to the end of a cue when there was plenty of room at the front, but as they became more familiar with the language the Japanese, like the Germans before them, got their results with less violence. Foreigners, especially their somewhat kindred island neighbors, can discipline the Chinese as they never could themselves. The weakest thing in China is discipline, and there is not moral fiber enough in the country—or there is too much gentleness in the Chinese temperament, whichever way you choose to put it—to cure such things from within.
It is said that there was more corruption under the Germans than under their successors. German inspectors were quite noticeable; Japanese ones tended to blend into the general racial background. During the German period, unrecorded telegrams flew from station to station with messages like “Inspector coming today,” and certain customs were temporarily ignored. On other days, passengers often boarded without tickets, slipped money to the Chinese guard, and the guard would signal the gateman at the disembarking station, sharing the profits at the first chance they got. Whatever their other shortcomings, the Japanese know how to operate a railroad, and under them, this kind of behavior is said to have disappeared. Their influence was still clearly felt. People are said to have preferred the Germans over their successors because, among other reasons, the Germans were less strict—which really highlights Japanese strictness. Part of this strictness was the emphasis on order rather than the chaotic methods favored by the Chinese. The Germans allowed hawking at the trains; the Japanese regulated and controlled it. They introduced the practice of standing in line for tickets, instead of the chaos common on purely Chinese railways. It’s said that it took the butt of many rifles and the flat of many swords to convince the coolies to move to the back of a queue when there was plenty of space at the front, but as they became more familiar with the language, the Japanese, like the Germans before them, achieved compliance with less violence. Foreigners, especially their somewhat similar island neighbors, can discipline the Chinese in ways they never could themselves. The biggest weakness in China is discipline, and there isn’t enough moral strength in the country—or maybe there’s too much gentleness in the Chinese temperament, however you want to put it—to fix these issues from within.

A private carriage, Shantung style
A private carriage, Shandong style

Shackled prisoners of Lao-an making hair nets for the American market
Shackled prisoners in Lao-an making hair nets for the American market

School-girls in the American mission school at Weihsien, Shantung
Schoolgirls in the American mission school at Weihsien, Shandong

The governor’s mansion at Tsingtao, among hills carefully reforested by the Germans, followed by the Japanese, has now been returned to the Chinese after a quarter of a century of foreign rule
The governor's mansion in Tsingtao, surrounded by hills that were carefully reforested by the Germans and later by the Japanese, has now been returned to the Chinese after 25 years of foreign rule.
321Foreign residents, including some missionaries, were already complaining of a deterioration of the Shantung Railway under Chinese management. To one who had just come from the other railways of China this seemed rather exaggerated cynicism, for it certainly was superior to those others in many ways, though possibly these were relics of German and Japanese times, which were gradually dying out under the new régime. The almost praiseworthy cleanliness of at least the higher class cars may have been merely a memento of earlier days; also perhaps the brief, businesslike stops at stations. There were “red-caps” instead of the tidal wave of ragged ruffians who fight pitched battles for one’s baggage elsewhere; and the platforms were free from loafers, stragglers, beggars, and false passengers among whom the actual traveler is so completely swallowed up at the average Chinese station that he often despairs of getting on board at all. But with more than half the new personnel in the higher grades graduates of American colleges, some of them with real railroad experience, it hardly seems that the line can go entirely to rack and ruin, nor that it is being made the complete pawn of hungry politicians utterly devoid of ability which some rumors have it.
321Foreign residents, including some missionaries, were already complaining about the decline of the Shantung Railway under Chinese management. To someone who had just come from other railways in China, this seemed like exaggerated cynicism because it was definitely better in many ways, although possibly these were remnants from the German and Japanese eras, which were gradually fading under the new regime. The commendable cleanliness of at least the first-class cars might have just been a holdover from earlier days; the brief, efficient stops at stations could be the same. There were “red-caps” instead of the typical crowd of ragged individuals who fight over your luggage elsewhere, and the platforms were clear of loafers, stragglers, beggars, and frauds that can completely swallow up the actual traveler at an average Chinese station, making it seem impossible to get on board. However, with more than half of the new staff in the higher positions being graduates from American colleges, some with real railroad experience, it hardly seems possible for the line to fall into complete disrepair or become a total pawn of inexperienced politicians, as some rumors suggest.
Until the line is paid for, five to fifteen years hence, there will be a Japanese traffic manager and chief accountant. But there has been sent down to Tsingtao from the Ministry of Communications in Peking an English-speaking superintendent who is notably fitted for the post, and one is struck by the above-the-average of the personnel all along the line. All its telegrams, by the way, are sent in English, which is a hardship on station-masters who spent years learning German. But for telegraphic purposes Chinese characters have to be reduced to numbers which often run into four, if not five, figures, and it is much simpler to wire “Hold six at Fangtze” than to beat out on the keys “5674 8762 9085 4356,” and run the added risk of the code-book being misplaced at either end. It can scarcely be expected that the change from Japanese to Chinese management will be made without a hitch; for one thing, men had to be brought from all the five government railways of China, on all of which, having been first built and operated under different nationalities, rules and practices vary. We would scarcely expect the theoretical “All-American” football team to display perfect team-work if suddenly brought together for a game. Then there is the usual percentage of bone-headedness to be reckoned. On the eve of the Chinese New Year an engineer eager to spend that day at home, but having no orders which gave him a right of way, coupled his locomotive in front of another drawing a freight-train and double-headed westward. Now the folly of running thirty-five-ton American locomotives across fourteen-ton bridges is bad enough; when two of them dash madly out upon one it is not strange if something serious happens. What was left of the two fine big engines still lay on either side of the central pier when we crept across a temporary bridge nearly a month later; but that particular driver will probably prove of much more use to the line as an example to his fellows than he ever was at a throttle.
Until the line is fully paid off, which will take five to fifteen years, there will be a Japanese traffic manager and chief accountant. However, an English-speaking superintendent, who is particularly well-suited for the job, has been sent down to Tsingtao from the Ministry of Communications in Beijing. It's impressive to see that the quality of personnel along the line is above average. By the way, all telegrams are sent in English, which is tough for station masters who spent years learning German. For telegraphic communication, Chinese characters have to be converted into numbers, often four or five digits long, and it’s much easier to send a message like “Hold six at Fangtze” than to type out “5674 8762 9085 4356” and risk misplacing the codebook at either end. It's unrealistic to expect a smooth transition from Japanese to Chinese management. For one, workers had to be brought in from all five government railways in China, each having been built and run under different nationalities, where rules and practices vary. We wouldn’t expect a theoretical “All-American” football team to work perfectly together if suddenly assembled for a game. Plus, there’s always the usual share of foolishness to consider. On the eve of the Chinese New Year, an engineer, eager to spend the day at home but lacking orders for a right of way, attached his locomotive in front of another pulling a freight train and heading west. It’s already reckless to run thirty-five-ton American locomotives over fourteen-ton bridges; when two of them charge out onto one together, it’s no surprise that something serious happens. Nearly a month later, what remained of the two massive engines still lay on either side of the central pier when we crossed a temporary bridge, but that particular driver will likely be of much more use to the line as a cautionary example to his colleagues than he ever was at operating a throttle.
322Foreigners in general, as is widely known, have long been called by Chinese in ugly moods “yang gwei,” which we have more or less correctly translated as “foreign devil.” This particular “yang” really means ocean, and a “gwei” is a spirit of the dead, quite possibly, though not necessarily, a devil in the Western sense. Thus small Chinese are not so far amiss as they sound to the uninformed when they run after foreigners shouting, “Yang Gwei! Yang Gwei! Give me money!” For the spirit of the dead is sometimes benevolent, and even small urchins would scarcely expect charity in return for knowingly uncomplimentary titles. But there is no doubt what the people of Shantung mean by their popular expression for the Japanese, “hsiao gwei,” or “little devil.” Nor need one inquire often or listen hard to get hints of why there is much actual hatred of the efficient islanders, quite aside from the theoretical dislike built up by rumor and propaganda. When the Japanese held it one could not buy tickets on the Shantung Railway with Chinese money; there were exchange-shops on the road to all stations of importance, where it took a “Mex” dollar, and sometimes some coppers in addition, to buy a yen, though the honest exchange was always considerably in favor of the dollar. Shippers may not have had to bribe the station-master to get a car for which they had already paid the official fees, as often happens on Chinese railroads, but they might be perfectly sure that Japanese shippers would always get cars first. It is against Chinese law to melt up current money; the Japanese bought and melted all the brass “cash” in Shantung. There has been much outcry from them in recent years about race equality, yet the Japanese look down upon the Chinese far more than any Californian does upon the sons of Nippon, more than any American does upon our negroes; and apparently the more military and brutal part of the occupation in Shantung was always on the lookout for opportunities to show this supposed superiority forcibly. It may be that the better class, or the non-militaristic party, or the Japanese people in general, thoroughly agreed with the terms of the Washington agreement and were glad to prove the national good will by evacuating Shantung; but if so they should have made greater efforts to curb the spirit of bad boys driven out of the playground which prevailed on the spot. Before they left, the disgruntled among the Japanese occupants slashed up the velvet seat-cushions of first-class coaches, just as the Germans did in the cars they were forced to turn over to the Allies; they carried off indispensable fittings; they left cars and locomotives as far as possible from where they were most needed; during the last months they avoided making 323even imperative repairs. They deliberately flooded the mines at Fangtze; they turned on the faucets in buildings belonging to the railroad, so that they were swimming-pools by the time the Chinese occupants appeared; they carried away, ruined, or wantonly destroyed furnishings, walls, windows; out at the agricultural experiment station on the flanks of Lao-shan they carefully mixed into one useless mess the several kinds of cotton-seed that were to be planted in the spring. An American-trained expert who drifted into my compartment as we neared Tsingtao asserted that more than a dozen bridges had already been found with serious cracks in them filled with putty and painted over. In Japanese days, even those unfriendly to them admit, trains were so exactly on time that clocks could be set by them. The new superintendent explained the growing tendency to be late as due to these wanton hamperings and the necessity of crawling across bridges in bad condition, or too light for the present rolling-stock, and he was preparing a slower schedule to be used until the line had been strengthened throughout. This English-speaking, straightforward official would probably strike any fair-minded observer as an unusually trustworthy Chinese, but he did not mention also the difficulties of making his people believe in the importance of keeping to any exact schedule.
322Foreigners, as many know, have often been called “yang gwei” by the Chinese in less than friendly moods, which we translate as “foreign devil.” The term “yang” actually means ocean, and “gwei” refers to a spirit of the dead, possibly a devil in the Western sense. So, when small Chinese kids run after foreigners shouting, “Yang Gwei! Yang Gwei! Give me money!” they’re not entirely off base. After all, a spirit of the dead can be benevolent, and kids wouldn’t realistically expect charity when using unflattering names. However, there’s no doubt about what the people of Shantung really mean when they say “hsiao gwei,” or “little devil,” about the Japanese. You don’t need to dig very deep or listen hard to understand the genuine dislike for the efficient islanders, beyond the rumors and propaganda. During the Japanese occupation, you couldn’t buy tickets for the Shantung Railway with Chinese money; there were exchange shops at major stations where you needed a “Mex” dollar, often along with some coins, to buy a yen, even though the honest exchange rate heavily favored the dollar. Shippers might not have had to bribe the station-master to get a car they had already paid for, like often happens on Chinese railroads, but they could be sure that Japanese shippers would always get cars first. It’s illegal in China to melt down current currency; the Japanese bought and melted all the brass “cash” in Shantung. There has been a lot of talk from them about racial equality in recent years, yet the Japanese look down on the Chinese far more than Californians look down on the Japanese, or Americans do on African Americans. Additionally, the more militaristic and aggressive part of the occupation in Shantung was always looking for chances to assert this supposed superiority. It might be that the better class, the non-militaristic group, or even the Japanese people in general, agreed with the Washington agreement and were eager to show goodwill by leaving Shantung; but if so, they should have tried harder to control the rowdy behavior of the disgruntled individuals present. Before they exited, the unhappy Japanese occupants damaged the velvet seat cushions of first-class coaches, similar to what the Germans did with the cars they handed over to the Allies; they took essential fittings; they parked cars and locomotives as far from where they were needed as possible; during their final months, they avoided even urgent repairs. They intentionally flooded the mines at Fangtze; they left the taps running in buildings belonging to the railroad, turning them into swimming pools by the time the Chinese occupants arrived; they carried off, ruined, or wantonly destroyed furnishings, walls, windows; out at the agricultural experiment station near Lao-shan, they intentionally mixed different types of cotton seed into one useless mess that was supposed to be planted in the spring. An American-trained expert who joined me in my compartment as we approached Tsingtao claimed that over a dozen bridges had already been discovered with serious cracks filled with putty and painted over. Even those who were not friendly to the Japanese admit that, during that time, trains were so punctual that clocks could be synchronized with them. The new superintendent attributed the increasing delays to these deliberate disruptions and the need to crawl across bridges that were in poor condition or too light for the current trains, and he was planning a slower schedule until the track could be reinforced completely. This English-speaking, straightforward official would likely seem like an unusually trustworthy Chinese to any fair-minded observer, but he didn’t mention the added challenge of convincing his people that sticking to a strict schedule mattered.
Gradually, as it approaches Kiaochow Bay, the train picks up more and more Japanese, the women and children, and a few of the men, in their chilly national dress, with scraping wooden getas and blue noses. The country continues flat and fertile, given over mainly to graves, as far as the old walled town of Kiaochow, forty-five miles by rail from Tsingtao just across the bay. Though this ancient city was well within the hundred li periphery beyond high tide that was leased to the Germans, it remained under Chinese rule, much like the cities of Colon and Panama within the Canal Zone. Then hills grow up on the horizon, and soon rise to a labyrinth of low mountains, the most striking of them across the bay, distant ones to the southeast capped with snow. Wild geese and bustards within easy reach tempt the sportsman. The train more than half encircles the big bay, close on the left, visibly a magnificent harbor, even though larger ships must wait at the entrance for high tide. Bit by bit the many little things which mark a Chinese landscape die out; factories, warehouses, big modern buildings, many of them still flying the rising sun, grow more continuous on either hand, and by the time one’s journey is ended, whether he descend at the Harbor Station or at the terminal, there is little left to remind him that he is still in China.
Gradually, as it gets closer to Kiaochow Bay, the train picks up more and more Japanese people—women and children, along with a few men—dressed in their cold national attire, with wooden getas and blue noses. The land remains flat and fertile, mostly filled with graves, all the way to the old walled town of Kiaochow, which is forty-five miles by rail from Tsingtao, just across the bay. Although this ancient city was well within the hundred li zone beyond high tide that the Germans leased, it stayed under Chinese control, similar to how Colon and Panama are within the Canal Zone. Then hills appear on the horizon and soon rise into a maze of low mountains, with the most striking ones across the bay, and those distant mountains to the southeast capped with snow. Wild geese and bustards nearby attract sportsmen. The train nearly encircles the large bay, which is clearly a stunning harbor on the left, even though larger ships must wait at the entrance for high tide. Piece by piece, the many little details that define a Chinese landscape fade away; factories, warehouses, and big modern buildings, many still flying the rising sun, become more prevalent on both sides, and by the time the journey ends, whether one gets off at the Harbor Station or the terminal, there’s little left to remind them that they are still in China.
324In the days of the Germans Tsingtao was generally admitted to be the model city of the Far East. The Japanese have greatly extended and in certain ways improved it. There could scarcely be a greater contrast within one country than that between this modern European city, with broad macadamized streets and ample sidewalks, block after block of two- and three-story buildings of brick and stone, rolling away over a series of small hills which subside at last along waterfronts that would not be out of place on the Mediterranean, and the flat, low, heavily walled, dismal collections of baked-mud hovels, broken by narrow, reeking lanes, which are typical of China. For even the Japanese have built in their conception of the European model, rather than in the frail style of their home-land, so that one may wander through street after street and get few hints of the Orient except the people who pass to and fro in them. Least Chinese of all, perhaps, are the splendid motor-roads darting off into the country in all directions, and the wide-spread growth of trees upon the hills as far as the eye can see.
324In the time of the Germans, Tsingtao was widely recognized as the model city of the Far East. The Japanese have significantly expanded and, in some ways, improved it. There’s hardly a starker contrast within one country than that between this modern European city, featuring wide paved streets and spacious sidewalks, block after block of two- and three-story buildings made of brick and stone, rolling over a series of small hills that eventually lead down to waterfronts that could easily be found on the Mediterranean, and the flat, low, heavily walled, grim clusters of mud shacks, interrupted by narrow, foul-smelling alleys, that are typical of China. Even the Japanese have constructed buildings in a European style rather than the delicate design of their homeland, so one can stroll through street after street with few hints of the Orient, except for the people moving back and forth. Perhaps the least Chinese aspect of all are the impressive motorways stretching out into the countryside in every direction, and the expansive growth of trees on the hills as far as the eye can see.
It is said that Germans are gradually returning now to Tsingtao, but the little cloven-footed people from the east are much more in evidence. The largely Japanese shops are a trifle mean and small in comparison with the general scheme of things, and boldly demand Japanese money still, as though there had been no change in the status of Tsingtao merely because their troops and officials have sailed away. On the other hand, one might travel far to see another institution as splendid as the Japanese Middle School out among the hills below the governor’s residence, and many another of their establishments is equally as near what it should be. By the terms of the treaty the Japanese are permitted to retain their educational, mission, and similar institutions, and naturally their nationals retain full rights of residence and commerce. Other residents charge them with a certain underhandedness in stretching these rights, and point to block after block of big new residences that have never been occupied, asserting they were built merely that the Japanese might hold that much more land.
It’s said that Germans are slowly returning to Tsingtao now, but the little horned people from the east are much more visible. The mostly Japanese shops seem a bit shabby and small compared to everything else, and they still insist on using Japanese money, as if nothing has changed in Tsingtao just because their troops and officials have left. On the other hand, one could travel a long way to find another institution as impressive as the Japanese Middle School out in the hills below the governor’s residence, and many of their other establishments are just as close to what they should be. According to the treaty, the Japanese are allowed to keep their educational, mission, and similar institutions, and naturally, their nationals still have full rights to live and do business here. Other residents accuse them of being a bit sneaky in pushing these rights, pointing to block after block of large new homes that have never been occupied, claiming they were built just so the Japanese could hold onto that much more land.
The coming of the Japanese in 1914 seems to have brought much the same advantages and misfortunes which they carried to Korea and Manchuria. Under the Germans life had been comfortable, a trifle strict perhaps, sharply divided by caste lines that made it impossible for the wife of an officer to meet the wife of a merchant; but the fact is that the German penetration into Shantung was more of a commercial than of a military nature. Though there are still mighty guns pointing seaward above the concrete underground forts which they dug in the 325surrounding hills, and which show vivid evidences of the Japanese bombardment, Tsingtao was never a Port Arthur or a Gibraltar. The Germans strove rather for the good will of the Chinese, that they might above all sell them more goods. Yet their national efficiency never failed them, and reforms which they felt essential were carried through with as nice a balance as could be preserved between complacency and insistence. There was the matter of squeaking wheelbarrows, for instance. No barrow-man of Shantung would feel that his apparatus was functioning properly unless it emitted a constant screech that can be heard at least a furlong away; to have it cease would give him much the same sensation as the motorist has when he hears a knocking under the hood of his engine. But the incessant screaking got on the nerves of the Germans in general and on those of the governor’s wife in particular. Sein Excellenz, her husband, gave orders that, beginning on the morning of September 16, wheelbarrows should no longer squeak within German leased territory. Old residents, American missionaries among them, held their sides; who ever heard of changing a time-honored custom of the Chinese, especially by a mere proclamation? But the Germans did more than command; they sent out inconspicuous propaganda, giving reasons, appealing to common sense and good will. On the morning of the sixteenth a missionary group was sitting at breakfast, vaguely conscious that something had happened, that things were not exactly what they hitherto always had been. One of them finally stepped to the window, then raised her hands to her ears. The others quickly followed suit. Had they all suddenly gone deaf? The same endless line of wheelbarrows was trundling along the street outside, but not the smallest infant of a squeak was sounding; they passed as silently as a company of wheelbarrowing ghosts; and to this day Shantung’s principal means of transportation is mute within the territory just returned to China after a quarter of a century of alien adoption.
The arrival of the Japanese in 1914 seemed to bring many of the same benefits and hardships they had imposed on Korea and Manchuria. Under the Germans, life had been comfortable, maybe a bit strict, sharply divided along caste lines that made it impossible for an officer's wife to meet a merchant's wife; but the truth is the German presence in Shantung was more about business than military might. Although there are still powerful guns aimed out to sea atop the concrete underground forts they built in the surrounding hills, which clearly show signs of the Japanese bombardment, Tsingtao was never like Port Arthur or Gibraltar. The Germans focused more on winning the goodwill of the Chinese, primarily to sell them more goods. Nonetheless, their national efficiency never abandoned them, and they implemented the reforms they deemed essential while balancing complacency with insistence. Take the issue of squeaky wheelbarrows, for example. No wheelbarrow operator in Shantung would feel his barrow was working properly unless it made a constant screech that could be heard at least a furlong away; if it stopped making noise, he would feel much like a driver does when he hears a knocking sound in his engine. However, the incessant screeching got on the nerves of the Germans in general and particularly bothered the governor’s wife. Her husband, Sein Excellenz, ordered that starting on the morning of September 16, wheelbarrows were no longer allowed to squeak within the German leased territory. Longtime residents, including American missionaries, laughed; who had ever heard of changing a long-standing Chinese custom, especially through a mere proclamation? But the Germans did more than just command; they spread subtle propaganda, explaining the reasons, appealing to common sense and goodwill. On the morning of the sixteenth, a group of missionaries was having breakfast, vaguely aware that something had changed, that things were not quite as they used to be. One of them finally went to the window and then covered her ears. The others quickly followed her lead. Had they all suddenly gone deaf? The same continuous stream of wheelbarrows was rolling down the street outside, but not a single squeak could be heard; they passed as silently as a procession of ghostly wheelbarrows. To this day, Shantung’s main mode of transportation is silent within the territory just returned to China after a quarter of a century of foreign rule.
The methods of the Japanese were quite as coercive, without the softening propaganda. The military party was in full control, and not even Western missionaries were permitted for a moment to forget it. The Japanese closed the American Presbyterian mission school on the charge of “spreading propaganda”; and they continued to collect taxes on it during all the years they used it as a police station. They built several blocks of semi-official brothels under the very eaves of the native church established by this same mission, and by the terms of the treaty of evacuation these are allowed to remain, for Japanese “enterprises” 326in Tsingtao must not be molested. If it were an isolated case, one might believe that the site was chosen merely for its convenient situation; but the yoshiwaras of Korea and Manchuria also show a strong tendency to elbow mission property and American residences with what looks much like the cynicism of the military clique. Japanese gendarmes and soldiers pursued mission “Bible women” until in many cases they had to give up their labors; they made it unsafe for Chinese school-girls to remain in the mission dormitories; they showed the same barbarian disrespect for privacy which one so often heard charged against them in Korea. Let the wife of a missionary neglect to lock the kitchen door, even at noon, and she would probably find a pair of Japanese gendarmes standing in her bedroom when she looked up. They never gave any reasons for their intrusions; they merely implied by their attitude that they were the rulers of Tsingtao and that it was no one’s business where they went, or when. The Japanese—or the Germans either, for that matter—would not allow American physicians to practise within the territory, not even to attend fellow-Americans who were of the same mission or might be in the same house with them. The missionaries, and even their wives, were summoned to court on every possible pretext, and allowed to stand two or three hours among beggars and prostitutes before they were called upon to stand at attention before the haughty judge and testify. The American consul never officially admitted the right of the Japanese to bring Americans before their courts, contending that they enjoyed extraterritoriality in Tsingtao quite as well as in the rest of China; but for some reason he personally advised his countrymen to obey Japanese summonses. Multiply these few and restricted cases of petty persecution by some very large number and it will be clearer why the residents of the Kiaochow territory, except the Japanese themselves, were so pleased to see the rising sun replaced one morning in December by the five-color banner of China, even though they are ready to admit that many excellent things came from Japan.
The methods used by the Japanese were just as forceful, but without any of the softer propaganda. The military group had complete control, and even Western missionaries were not allowed to forget that for a second. The Japanese shut down the American Presbyterian mission school, claiming it was “spreading propaganda,” while continuing to collect taxes on it for all the years they used it as a police station. They constructed several blocks of semi-official brothels right next to the native church established by this same mission, and according to the evacuation treaty, these are allowed to stay because Japanese “enterprises” in Tsingtao must not be interfered with. If it were just one isolated case, one might think the location was chosen purely for its convenience; however, the yoshiwaras in Korea and Manchuria also have a strong tendency to crowd out mission properties and American homes, which seems quite cynical on the part of the military group. Japanese gendarmes and soldiers chased after mission “Bible women” until many had to abandon their work; they made it unsafe for Chinese schoolgirls to remain in the mission dormitories; they displayed the same disrespect for privacy that many often accused them of in Korea. If a missionary's wife forgot to lock the kitchen door, even during the day, she would likely find a couple of Japanese gendarmes standing in her bedroom when she looked up. They never provided reasons for their intrusions, instead implying through their demeanor that they ruled Tsingtao and that it was nobody's business where they went or when. The Japanese—and the Germans too, for that matter—wouldn't let American doctors practice in the territory, not even to care for fellow Americans who were part of the same mission or stayed in the same house as them. Missionaries, and even their wives, were dragged into court on every possible pretext, made to stand for two or three hours among beggars and prostitutes before finally being called to stand at attention before the arrogant judge and testify. The American consul never officially acknowledged the Japanese right to bring Americans into their courts, insisting that they enjoyed extraterritoriality in Tsingtao just as they did in the rest of China; however, for some reason, he personally advised his fellow countrymen to comply with Japanese summonses. Multiply these few and limited instances of petty harassment by a significant number, and it becomes clearer why the residents of the Kiaochow territory, aside from the Japanese themselves, were so glad to see the rising sun replaced one morning in December by the five-color flag of China, even though they were willing to acknowledge that many good things came from Japan.
From the distance of Peking we had heard that Tsingtao was virtually in the hands of bandits; on the ground, there proved to be no truth in this rumor. Things had been really much worse in that respect under Japanese occupation, though they need not have been. There seems to be little doubt that the Japanese tolerated bandits in Shantung, perhaps helped to recruit them and sold them arms. Scores of little hints to this effect reached the ears of even the least suspicious 327residents of the occupied zone. They appear to be able to cite indefinitely cases similar to that of the mission cook, trustworthy beyond all question, who was approached by a Japanese with the promise of an easy life and a large income if he would turn bandit. Guns could be rented, I was assured, from Japanese gendarmes at two dollars a night by any one who wished to create a little disorder; the bandits were often allowed to wear red hat-bands (the distinguishing mark of Japanese soldiers and gendarmes everywhere) and to take refuge in railway or other Japanese property where Chinese soldiers could not pursue them. Whether or not they were actually in the pay of the nation to whom disorder in China is always an advantage, there is little room for doubt that they were unofficially aided and abetted.
From a distance in Beijing, we had heard that Qingdao was basically under the control of bandits; however, once we arrived, we found this rumor to be unfounded. Things had actually been much worse in that regard during the Japanese occupation, although it didn't have to be. It's clear that the Japanese tolerated bandits in Shandong, possibly even helped recruit them and supplied them with weapons. Numerous hints about this reached even the most naive residents of the occupied area. They can recount countless stories, such as that of the mission cook, who was completely trustworthy and was approached by a Japanese man offering an easy life and a high salary if he would become a bandit. I was told that anyone wanting to stir up a bit of trouble could rent guns from Japanese gendarmes for two dollars a night; the bandits often wore red armbands (the identifying mark of Japanese soldiers and gendarmes everywhere) and were allowed to take refuge in railway or other Japanese properties where Chinese soldiers were not allowed to chase them. Whether or not they were actually being paid by a nation that benefits from chaos in China, it’s clear they received unofficial support and assistance.
The military part of the occupation left Shantung in an angry mood; the Japanese hoped to the last that complications would arise that would give them an excuse to remain, and they were not beyond doing their bit to create them. It is the old story of the two opposing factors in the political life of Japan, which her apologists make the most of when they have to explain actions strangely at variance with professions. The ministers of war and the navy are responsible directly to the mikado, not to the premier, as in other lands; hence the Foreign Office may be openly flouted by the military clique. Moreover, these ministers must be a general and an admiral respectively; in other words, there is not the soothing effect of civilian control over the war-dogs which is quite general elsewhere. A bulldog is an excellent defense, but it is an unwise home which allows the bulldog to take command of things.
The military part of the occupation left Shantung feeling really angry; the Japanese were hoping until the very end that some kind of complications would come up to give them a reason to stay, and they weren’t above stirring things up themselves. It’s the familiar story of the two conflicting forces in Japan's political life, which its supporters emphasize when trying to explain actions that seem oddly inconsistent with their stated beliefs. The ministers of war and the navy report directly to the emperor, not to the prime minister like in other countries; as a result, the Foreign Office can be openly disregarded by the military faction. Plus, these ministers have to be a general and an admiral, meaning there’s no calming influence of civilian oversight over the military, which is common in other places. A bulldog is a great protector, but it’s a bad idea for a household to let the bulldog take charge.
Conditions became fantastic during the last few weeks of Japanese occupation. The bandits had their headquarters only twenty miles from Tsingtao, by excellent motor-road, up in the foot-hills of the beautiful Lao-Shan range. They raided the neighborhood at will, and went to town to see the movies whenever the spirit moved them. All they had to do was to stroll down to the Japanese police-box at the edge of the leased territory and telephone a garage in Tsingtao to send them a car. They rode or strutted through the streets like the proverbial walking arsenal; what was worse, they wore uniforms which made them indistinguishable from Chinese soldiers. Once they invited the Chamber of Commerce to ask them to dinner, the Japanese knowing so well about it in advance that they had their secret police among the first arrivals, and instructed that body that the payment of one hundred thousand dollars, the appointment of their chief as garrison commander 328and of one thousand of their number as a police force, were essential to the immunity of Tsingtao from their devastations. Then they picked up the local deputy of the provincial Tuchun and the president of the Chamber of Commerce as hostages and motored back to their headquarters with them.
Conditions became wild during the last few weeks of Japanese occupation. The bandits had their base only twenty miles from Tsingtao, accessible by a great motor road, nestled in the foothills of the stunning Lao-Shan range. They raided the local area whenever they wanted and went into town to catch movies whenever they felt like it. All they had to do was walk down to the Japanese police station at the edge of the leased territory and call a garage in Tsingtao to send them a car. They walked or swaggered through the streets like living weapons; what was worse, they wore uniforms that made them look just like Chinese soldiers. Once, they invited the Chamber of Commerce to dinner, with the Japanese knowing about it so well in advance that they had their secret police among the first guests, instructing them that a payment of one hundred thousand dollars, the appointment of their leader as garrison commander, and assigning one thousand of their men as a police force were necessary to keep Tsingtao safe from their destruction. Then they took the local deputy of the provincial Tuchun and the president of the Chamber of Commerce as hostages and drove back to their base with them.
In the end, apparently, they were given a certain sum of money and more or less official standing, as is the custom in China, the land of compromise. But by the time I reached Tsingtao they had been moved to Fangtze, far outside the former leasehold, and the city was well policed by the men in black uniforms and white leggings with which Peking is so familiar. Hand-picked and trained by a European, these constitute one of the best bodies in China, and they had been scattered along the entire line of the Shantung Railway, poorly equipped at first, but armed now, one and all, with brand-new rifles from China’s government arsenals. The ordinary cotton-clad, ill disciplined Chinese soldier was very little in evidence. Now and then a group of them try to board the trains without tickets to the great detriment of this line also; but station-masters have a way of appealing to their good nature, if not to their patriotism, with the strong argument that unless the line pays for itself within five years the Japanese will come back, and then....
In the end, it seems they received a certain amount of money and some sort of official status, as is typical in China, the land of compromise. But by the time I got to Tsingtao, they had been relocated to Fangtze, far outside the former leasehold, and the city was heavily guarded by men in black uniforms and white leggings that Peking is well-known for. This group, selected and trained by a European, is one of the best forces in China, and they were spread out along the entire Shantung Railway. Initially poorly equipped, they were now all armed with brand-new rifles from China’s government arsenals. The standard cotton-clad, poorly trained Chinese soldier was rarely seen. Occasionally, groups of them would try to board trains without tickets, negatively impacting the line; however, station masters had a way of appealing to their better nature, if not their sense of patriotism, by arguing that unless the line becomes profitable within five years, the Japanese will return, and then...
Bismarck Strasse became Ryojun Machi and in its turn will no doubt be this or that Ta Chieh, perhaps without even the concession of naming it in Roman letters which the Japanese granted to the West. The contrast between the blue sea and the clean red roofs may grow more and more dim under slack Chinese rule, and Tsingtao may sink back into the slough from which Germany rescued it. But it is not likely, for the Chinese are on their metal. True, there is already the curse of useless politicians and military pressure in the highest offices, but a Yale graduate in forestry is in charge of continuing the good work of the Germans and the Japanese in spreading the gospel of reforestation, and other branches of the new Government are in equally competent and progressive hands. There is great need in China for officials to take up economics as a part of government, especially to establish some continuity of plan which will carry on in spite of the disruptions of political changes; and ready-made Tsingtao is an excellent place for them to begin to practise. The people may reassert their centuries of training and pilfer all the trees, as some were already beginning to carry off the brushwood contrary to rules, as they cut even the trees about their graves when hard pressed, for only their 329Confucianism stands guard over the few groves that are left in the land. Or they may, as some of the enthusiastic young officials of the former leased territory announce, make Tsingtao more important than either Tientsin or Shanghai, by pushing new railways back into the interior beyond Tzinan and draining even the Yang Tze of its natural carrying-power. More likely the future will be somewhere between these two extremes, with a certain Chinese indifference to small comforts and strict cleanliness somewhat marring in the eyes of the West a port which in the main will retain much that it has learned during its quarter of a century of sterner foreign tutelage.
Bismarck Strasse became Ryojun Machi and will likely become this or that Ta Chieh, possibly without even the concession of naming it in Roman letters, which the Japanese gave to the West. The contrast between the blue sea and the clean red roofs may fade under weak Chinese governance, and Tsingtao might revert to the state from which Germany rescued it. But that’s not probable, as the Chinese are stepping up. True, there are already the issues of ineffective politicians and military pressure in high offices, but a Yale forestry graduate is responsible for continuing the good work of the Germans and the Japanese in promoting reforestation, and other branches of the new Government are also in capable and progressive hands. There is a strong need in China for officials to incorporate economics into governance, especially to create a consistent plan that can endure despite political upheavals; and ready-made Tsingtao is an excellent place for them to start practicing. The people might resort to their long-standing habit and take all the trees, as some were already beginning to remove brushwood against regulations, cutting even the trees around their graves when they were desperate, with only their Confucianism protecting the few groves that remain in the country. Or they might, as some of the eager young officials of the former leased territory claim, make Tsingtao more important than either Tientsin or Shanghai by pushing new railways into the interior beyond Tzinan and draining even the Yangtze of its natural carrying capacity. More likely, the future will be somewhere between these two extremes, with a certain Chinese indifference to small comforts and strict cleanliness somewhat tarnishing in the eyes of the West a port that will mainly retain much of what it has learned during its twenty-five years of stricter foreign oversight.
CHAPTER XVIII
In bandit-infected Henan
One of our military attachés at Peking purposed to see China’s Far West before the cycle of duties called him home to a regiment, and he consented to have company. At least if it chanced to please the bandits who were just then using that means to coerce the incoherent Government to add us to their growing collection of foreign hostages, there would be some advantage in companionship.
One of our military attachés in Beijing wanted to explore China's Far West before his duties called him back to his regiment, and he agreed to go with someone. At least if the bandits, who were currently using that situation to pressure the disorganized government into adding us to their list of foreign hostages, decided to target us, it would be better to have company.
The major had business in Honan before I could leave Peking, and took the newly captured cook with him, leaving the “boy,” Chang, who maltreated considerable English and was to be our most important link with the outside world, to wait with me for the next biweekly express. Below the junction for Shansi, where daylight overtook us, the landscape was still as flat as about Peking; but there were more trees, bushy as the mango, though thinner of foliage, many trees, indeed, for China. Though it was already late October, the leaves had hardly begun to turn, and that brilliant sunshine and utter cloudlessness which is one of the greatest charms of dry, denuded North China so many days each year made it seem still almost midsummer. The broad, fenceless fields swarmed with people, mainly engaged, as far as a passing glimpse could tell, in picking cotton and threshing peanuts. The cotton was in some places so thin that even the frugal Chinese apparently did not find it worth gathering, while the best of it, on plants scarcely knee-high, was nothing to exhibit at a fair. Women gone cotton-picking had the advantage of trousers, but this was more than offset by the bound feet on which they hobbled from bush to bush. In contrast to those long two-bushel bags the negroes drag behind them through the fertile cotton-fields of our South, a kind of newsboy’s sack at the waist, or a pocketed apron, seemed to be quite large enough here.
The major had business in Honan before I could leave Beijing and took the newly captured cook with him, leaving the "boy," Chang, who spoke a bit of English and was supposed to be our main connection to the outside world, to wait with me for the next biweekly express. Below the junction for Shanxi, where daylight caught up with us, the landscape was still as flat as around Beijing; but there were more trees, bushy like mango but with less foliage, indeed many trees for China. Even though it was already late October, the leaves had hardly started to change, and that bright sunshine and complete cloudlessness, which is one of the biggest charms of dry, bare North China so many days each year, made it feel almost like midsummer. The broad, fenceless fields were crowded with people, mainly busy, from what I could see, picking cotton and threshing peanuts. In some places, the cotton was so sparse that even the economical Chinese didn’t think it was worth gathering, while the best of it, on plants barely knee-high, would be nothing to show at a fair. Women picking cotton had the advantage of wearing trousers, but this was more than outweighed by the bound feet on which they limped from bush to bush. Compared to the long two-bushel bags that African Americans drag behind them through the fertile cotton fields of the South, a kind of newsboy’s sack at the waist or a pocketed apron seemed to be more than enough here.
It was hard to distinguish the many heaps of peanuts from the still more numerous graves. With enough of this baseball and circus delicacy within one sweep of the eye to satisfy a ravenous city on the Fourth of July, there came back to mind the touching story of the fond American 331mother who sent her dear son in China a box of peanuts for Christmas, so that he might for a little while be reminded of home. Even small children were helping to pull them, and to pile the nuts in grave-like mounds of careless cone shape. Of the graves themselves there was literally no end, until the landscape for long stretches seemed to grow nothing else. Yet the land was a veritable market-garden, so great is the individual care of Chinese fields in all their processes. Here and there, in place of the far more common tilling by hand, was a plow, drawn by two or three mules; but naturally you cannot plow to advantage if you must dodge grandfather’s grave every trip across a short field, after that great-grandfather’s, and then that of the father before him, back to more than remote generations. If only the old gentlemen would consent to lie in a row, or even in a companionable cluster, or to be laid away in a real graveyard where the little cones of earth might perhaps be kept green even in China, instead of being rare, rain-gashed heaps of dried mud as hallowed as a pile of peanuts!
It was hard to tell the many piles of peanuts apart from the even more numerous graves. With enough of this baseball and circus treat in one glance to satisfy a hungry city on the Fourth of July, the touching story came to mind of the loving American mother who sent her beloved son in China a box of peanuts for Christmas, so he could be reminded of home for a little while. Even small children were helping to pull them and stack the nuts into grave-like mounds with a careless cone shape. The graves themselves seemed endless, with stretches of land appearing to grow nothing else. Yet the land was a true market garden, showcasing the great care given to Chinese fields in every process. Here and there, instead of the much more common hand tilling, there was a plow drawn by two or three mules; but naturally, you can't plow efficiently if you have to dodge grandfather’s grave each time you cross a short field, then that of great-grandfather, and then that of the father before him, going back to even more distant generations. If only the old gentlemen would agree to lie in a row, or even in a friendly cluster, or to be buried in an actual graveyard where the little mounds of earth could perhaps stay green even in China, instead of being rare, rain-damaged heaps of dried mud as sacred as a pile of peanuts!
Yet sometimes there is a hint of reverence, rather than of mere superstition, about a collection of half a dozen of these untended mounds drifting through the centuries with no other evidence of care than the slender shade of a single tree bent over them, like some faithful old servant still respectfully waiting to do their bidding. A suggestion of this comes now and then even to the disapproving foreigner, aghast at the wicked wastefulness of China’s burial methods; and certainly the peasant himself, the only one after all whom it greatly concerns, develops no spirit of criticism, no thought of revolt. A plow being in most cases inconvenient among his ancestral mounds, he digs away about them by hand year after year, generation after generation, as those same ancestors did century after century. Naked to the waist even in these late autumn days, his body burned to the hue of old polished mahogany, he never disturbs them, and rarely if ever mends them.
Yet sometimes, there’s a sense of respect, rather than just superstition, about a collection of half a dozen of these neglected mounds that have drifted through the centuries, with no other sign of care than the slender shade of a single tree bent over them, like a loyal old servant still patiently waiting to fulfill their wishes. This idea occasionally reaches even the disapproving foreigner, who is shocked by the seemingly wasteful burial practices of China; and certainly, the peasant himself, the one who is truly affected, shows no spirit of criticism, no thought of rebellion. Since using a plow is often impractical among his ancestral mounds, he has been digging around them by hand year after year, generation after generation, just like those same ancestors did for centuries. Bare-chested even in late autumn, his skin tanned to the color of old polished mahogany, he never disturbs them, and rarely, if ever, repairs them.
There were still reminders of the summer’s crops,—sweet potatoes, onions, lettuce, cabbages, carrots; but there was little if any evidence of the house-high kaoliang that stretches for unbroken miles across more northern China, all the north, indeed, of this province of Chihli. Country-women hobbling slowly and painfully about on their crippled feet were everywhere, even the most ugly, weather-beaten, and work-worn of them boasting this fancied form of beauty. Blindfolded donkeys and mules marched patiently round and round hither and yon across the landscape, some about ancient well-curbs, lifting by great 332wooden wheels water for the irrigation ditches that are so widely needed in this deforested, rain-stingy land, others rotating big stone rollers for the hulling or grinding of wheat. Brick-kilns, which the Chinese seal up for long periods with their contents, stood forth like rudely chiseled monuments or artificial hillocks. The earth was worn away around everything, walls, trees, roadsides, monuments, those great slabs of stone, top-heavy with carved dragons, that may be seen anywhere; for great portions of China are half-desert, dry as dust, of a moistureless brown soil ready to wash or blow away at the least provocation, and slavishly dependent upon irrigation. Chinese farming methods, too, increase this erosion. Everywhere men were cutting off the top layer of soil and screening the earth into many little mounds that stretched in long rows across the sunken fields. Later they “spread this between the wheat,” if I understood Chang’s laborious explanation; that is, they use it as a kind of fertilizer, sometimes mixed with the droppings of animals gleaned along the roads, as well as for the building of the many little low field-dikes.
There were still reminders of the summer crops—sweet potatoes, onions, lettuce, cabbages, carrots—but there was hardly any sign of the house-high kaoliang that stretches for miles all across northern China, especially in this province of Chihli. You could see country women moving slowly and painfully on their crippled feet everywhere, even the most weather-beaten and worn-out among them claiming this imagined form of beauty. Blindfolded donkeys and mules walked patiently in circles across the landscape, some near old well curbs, lifting water with large wooden wheels for the much-needed irrigation ditches in this deforested, dry land; others were turning big stone rollers for hulling or grinding wheat. Brick kilns, which the Chinese seal up for long periods with their contents, stood out like roughly carved monuments or artificial hills. The earth was worn away around everything—walls, trees, roadsides, and monuments—those large stone slabs, heavy with carved dragons, that can be found everywhere. Much of China is half-desert, dry as dust, with moistureless brown soil ready to wash or blow away at the slightest disturbance, and entirely dependent on irrigation. Chinese farming methods also contribute to this erosion. Everywhere, men were removing the top layer of soil and shaping it into small mounds that lined the sunken fields. Later, they would “spread this between the wheat,” as I understood Chang’s detailed explanation; that is, they used it as a type of fertilizer, sometimes mixed with animal droppings collected along the roads, as well as for building the many little low field dikes.
Barely over the boundary of Honan, where it thrusts itself in a point that recalls the “gerrymandering” of the West into the two provinces bounding it on the north, is Changte, burial-place of Yuan Shih-kai. A tomb evidently rivaling those of the most powerful emperors, certainly larger and more sumptuous than that of Mencius not far east of here in Shantung, rises among great trees within easy sight from the train. But it is not covered in imperial yellow, for the new dynasty that the occupant hoped to found, and which, if numerous examples in Chinese history still mean anything, would have been the more natural development, failed to materialize, less because of wide-spread republican sentiment, one suspects, than for lack of tact, among the virtues of political sagacity, in the make-up of what might have been the founder.
Barely over the border of Honan, where it juts out in a way that reminds us of the “gerrymandering” in the West that divides it from the two provinces to the north, is Changte, the burial place of Yuan Shih-kai. A tomb clearly rivaling those of the most powerful emperors, definitely larger and more lavish than that of Mencius not far east in Shantung, stands among large trees visible from the train. But it isn’t covered in imperial yellow, because the new dynasty that the occupant hoped to establish—which, if numerous examples in Chinese history mean anything, would have been a more natural progression—failed to happen, not so much due to widespread republican sentiment, one suspects, but because of a lack of tact, among the qualities of political wisdom, in the disposition of what could have been the founder.
Yuan Shih-kai is the father, so to speak, of the curse of swarming soldiers that now overrun China. For it was he who first saw in Korea, when he was a mere officer of the Manchus, the first Western-style soldiers, and who coaxed the Government to start what has become the present military misfortune of China. There were “soldiers” everywhere now—in China one must use the word with a grain of salt, for to put a simple country youth or a mere coolie into a faded gray cotton uniform and hand him something resembling a weapon does not make a real warrior, as the sight of rows of men standing at “present arms” 333and at the same time staring back over their shoulders at a strolling foreigner suggested. These artless, slouch-shouldered fellows lounged with fixed bayonets along the graveled platform of every station; they packed the trains to overflowing; they were drilling in companies and battalions, once or twice, it seemed, in whole regiments, on bare, dusty fields along the way. Had the half of them been genuine soldiers there should not have been a bandit within a month’s march in any direction.
Yuan Shih-kai is basically the father of the problem of endless soldiers that currently overwhelm China. He was the first to notice Western-style soldiers in Korea when he was just an officer of the Manchus and persuaded the government to kick off what has turned into China's ongoing military disaster. Now, there are “soldiers” everywhere—but in China, we have to use that term loosely. Just because you throw a drab gray uniform on a simple country kid or a laborer and give them something that looks like a weapon doesn't make them a real warrior, as evidenced by the sight of lines of men standing at “present arms” while simultaneously glancing back at a passing foreigner. These clumsy, slouched guys would hang out with fixed bayonets on the gravel platforms of every station; they packed the trains to capacity; they were drilling in groups and battalions, and occasionally in whole regiments, on barren, dusty fields along the route. If half of them were genuine soldiers, there shouldn't have been a bandit within a month’s march in any direction.
At Chengchow next morning the head of a man, his long hair carefully wrapped about it, as if that were much more precious than what had been his neck, lay a yard from his trunk, hands and feet rudely tied with ropes, out on the bare space before the station. Perhaps he had really deserved this frequent, casual Chinese fate, and was not the simple coolie substituted for influential or unattainable criminals which his appearance somehow suggested. The curious strolled over to see him, but the eating-stalls just in front lost none of their custom or their cheerfulness; by noon the body was gone, and dogs had licked up the great patch of blood that had spread between head and trunk.
At Chengchow the next morning, a man's head, with his long hair carefully wrapped around it as if it were more valuable than his neck, lay a yard away from his body. His hands and feet were roughly tied with ropes, stretched out in the open area in front of the station. Maybe he had truly earned this frequent, casual Chinese fate and wasn't just an ordinary coolie standing in for powerful or unreachable criminals, as his appearance seemed to imply. Curious onlookers gathered to see him, but the food stalls nearby continued to do brisk business and remained lively; by noon, the body was gone, and dogs had cleaned up the large patch of blood that had spread between the head and the torso.
The major had already gone westward, and it was not until months later that I visited Kaifeng, capital of Honan, long after the “Christian General” had been transferred from there to Peking. Fu Hsi lived there a little matter of 4775 years ago and not only ruled the Chinese but, if we are to believe all we hear, taught them to fish with nets—the Yellow River being but a supernatural stone’s throw away—to rear domestic animals, to use the lute and lyre, in a way, one suspects, that has not changed since, and spent the leisure time left him in instituting laws of marriage and inventing a system of writing by using pictures as symbols. No doubt he played some antediluvian species of golf and lectured on the necessity of large families also, but early history is often careless in preserving “human interest” details. What we do know is that Kaifeng was the capital of China under the Sung dynasty, from 960 A.D. until the court was captured by the Kins nearly two centuries later, a brother of the emperor escaping to Nanking and setting himself up in his place, and remained a kind of capital of the Kins until they were finally overthrown by their fellow-Tartars, the Mongols. Since then the city has apparently been content with its provincial status.
The major had already headed west, and it wasn't until months later that I visited Kaifeng, the capital of Honan, long after the “Christian General” had moved from there to Beijing. Fu Hsi lived there about 4,775 years ago and not only ruled the Chinese but, if we believe what we've heard, also taught them to fish with nets—the Yellow River being just a stone's throw away—to raise domestic animals, to play the lute and lyre, which seems to have remained unchanged since then, and spent his free time establishing marriage laws and creating a writing system using pictures as symbols. No doubt he also played some ancient form of golf and discussed the importance of having large families, but early history often overlooks “human interest” details. What we do know is that Kaifeng was the capital of China during the Sung dynasty, from 960 CE until the court was taken by the Kins nearly two centuries later, with a brother of the emperor fleeing to Nanking and setting up his own ruler there, and it remained a sort of capital for the Kins until they were eventually overthrown by their fellow-Tartars, the Mongols. Since then, the city seems to have settled for its provincial status.
Its wall encloses a mammoth space, much greater than that of Taiyüan, for instance, but with great open spaces within it. Lakes before the “dragon throne” in the center of the enclosure, though in the West they would more probably be called ponds, give the site mildly a suggestion of Peking. In a far corner the tieh-tah, or “iron pagoda,” 334is worth coming to see, though the only iron visible about it is the Buddhas in relief peering out of each opening up its thirteen stories. Of a beautiful glazed color of reddish brown with imperial yellow specking it, one might also call it the world’s largest porcelain. The keeper insisted that it was two thousand years old, but I fear tradition uncorrected by the printed page had deceived him as to the date of the Buddhist invasion of China, to which her pagodas are due.
Its wall encloses a massive space, much larger than Taiyüan, for example, but with vast open areas inside. Lakes located before the "dragon throne" in the center of the enclosure, though in the West they would likely be called ponds, give the site a slight resemblance to Beijing. In a distant corner, the tieh-tah, or "iron pagoda," 334 is worth a visit, although the only iron visible is the Buddhas in relief peeking out from each opening of its thirteen stories. With a beautiful glazed reddish-brown color and imperial yellow specks, it could also be considered the world’s largest piece of porcelain. The keeper claimed it was two thousand years old, but I worry that tradition, uncorrected by written history, may have misled him about the date of the Buddhist invasion of China, which gave rise to these pagodas.
There was a busy, almost a pleasant atmosphere about Kaifeng, with its moderately wide streets, and rickshaw-men almost as fast as those of Peking; though squeaking wheelbarrows for all manner of freight, with women on tiny feet sometimes straining in front of them, were numerous. Feng Yü-hsiang, China’s far-famed Methodist, cleaned up Kaifeng in the Christian sense during the six months he was ruler of Honan there. He drove out prostitutes; the extraordinary sight of soldiers sprinkling chloride of lime with their own fair hands wherever it was needed was but one of many such during his days. The only scandal that seemed to hover about his memory was an inordinate love for ice-cream, which reduced him to the point of sending a soldier for his share on those Sundays when he could not dine with the American missionaries in person. But Feng was evidently too good a Tuchun of Honan to suit his master Wu Pei-fu. The fellow who has taken his place has merely the outward honors of the office; Wu gives him his orders in everything of importance, and has his own auditors on the spot. Meanwhile the figurehead enjoys his opium, his singsong-girls, and his prestige, while the city slips back into the habits of which Feng attempted to cure it, and soldiers now and then run amuck in it. A thousand mere boys drill a month or two in compounds recently walled for them in the very outskirt where the missionaries built in the hope of an un-Chinese bit of quiet now and then, and pass on into the ever-swelling armies to make room for as many of their fellows. Bugles blare seven days a week long before the June hour of dawn, and all day long the recruits do their worst to sing scraps of Western music as they march.
There was a busy, almost pleasant vibe in Kaifeng, with its fairly wide streets and rickshaw drivers who were almost as fast as those in Peking; there were plenty of squeaky wheelbarrows carrying all kinds of freight, with women on tiny feet sometimes straining in front of them. Feng Yü-hsiang, China's famous Methodist, cleaned up Kaifeng in a Christian way during the six months he ruled Honan there. He expelled prostitutes; the unusual sight of soldiers spreading chloride of lime by hand wherever it was needed was just one of many such moments during his time. The only scandal that seemed to linger around his memory was his excessive love for ice cream, which led him to send a soldier for a scoop on those Sundays when he couldn't dine with the American missionaries in person. But Feng was clearly too good a Tuchun of Honan to please his superior Wu Pei-fu. The guy who took his place has only the outward honors of the office; Wu gives him orders on everything important and has his own auditors right there. Meanwhile, the figurehead enjoys his opium, his singsong girls, and his prestige, while the city slips back into the habits Feng tried to eradicate, and soldiers occasionally run amok in it. A thousand young boys drill for a month or two in compounds recently built for them on the very outskirts, where the missionaries hoped for a little bit of peace away from Chinese life, and then move on into the ever-growing armies to make space for more of their peers. Bugles blare seven days a week long before dawn in June, and all day long the recruits do their best to sing bits of Western music as they march.
The chief interest in Kaifeng to the traveler in quest of the unusual, however, is its Jews. The Chinese call them “Yu-t’ai,” which undoubtedly is derived from “Judea,” though whether by word of mouth or merely geographically is not clear. They came many generations ago, just when or why neither their neighbors nor they themselves seem to know. To-day they consist of “seven names and eight families”; that is, there are eight Jewish families who have between them seven family 335names, every one, as I have mentioned before, being compelled by circumstances over which he has no control to adopt one of the hundred and some Chinese surnames when he settles in China. Some doubt whether there are a hundred individuals left; the present head of the clan put the number at “one or two hundred.” They seem to have lost every vestige of Jewish identity, except the name they are all known by, which persistently survives. All those I saw looked less Jewish than do some of the Chinese; certainly their features would not definitely distinguish them from their neighbors, though the “head Jew” boasts that several persons have come to take his photograph “because he has such a big nose.” I ran this man Chao to earth for a somewhat similar purpose, and found him and his son keeping a little shop in a slovenly part of town, stripped to the waist and otherwise conducting themselves quite like Chinese a bit above the coolie class. Their home behind had not an un-Chinese hint about it—unless it was a large photograph of the father and son with a very Russian Jew from New York between them, which occupied a conspicuous place. But they were if anything more friendly, more bubbling over with excitement at a visit from a foreigner and the awe this inspired among their crowding neighbors, than pure Chinese of their class would have been. The merry little father, it seems, has twice been in jail charged with murder, if that really means anything concerning a man’s character in China; the fact that he had gotten out again suggested that there could scarcely have been much evidence against him, for the Jews of Kaifeng are not wealthy.
The main draw in Kaifeng for travelers looking for something different is its Jewish community. The Chinese refer to them as “Yu-t’ai,” which likely comes from “Judea,” though it’s unclear if that’s through direct communication or just geographical reasons. They arrived many generations ago, but neither their neighbors nor the community itself knows exactly when or why. Today, there are “seven names and eight families”; meaning there are eight Jewish families that share seven family names. As I mentioned earlier, each individual has to adopt one of the over a hundred Chinese surnames upon settling in China. Some people doubt there are even a hundred individuals left; the current head of the community estimates there are “one or two hundred.” They seem to have lost almost all aspects of their Jewish identity, except for the name they are still known by, which continues to endure. Everyone I saw looked less Jewish than some of the Chinese; certainly, their features wouldn’t clearly set them apart from their neighbors, even though the “head Jew” claims that several people have come to photograph him “because he has such a big nose.” I tracked down this man, Chao, for a similar reason and found him and his son running a small shop in a run-down area of town, shirtless and seemingly acting just like Chinese who are a bit above the laboring class. Their home had no unmistakably un-Chinese elements—unless you count a large photo of the father and son with a very Russian Jew from New York, which was prominently displayed. Yet, they were even friendlier and more enthusiastic about a visit from a foreigner and the fascination it brought among their curious neighbors than pure Chinese of their class would typically be. The cheerful little father has been in jail twice on murder charges, although in China, that may not say much about a person’s character; the fact that he was released suggests there likely wasn’t much evidence against him, as the Jews of Kaifeng are not wealthy.
They intermarry with the Chinese, and some have even taken up Chinese idol-worship; the rite most insisted upon by orthodox Jewry has not been practised for generations. Formerly they had what they called a synagogue, but about fifty years ago this was completely destroyed, and does not seem to have been kept in repair even until then. There has been no attempt to restore it, and a stone tablet that stood within it is all that is left. On this last relic is engraved a sketch of Hebrew history and the names of the patriarchs. Once it bore also the names of the principal Jewish families in Kaifeng, but these were obliterated in order to throw off the scent those who tried some decades ago to persecute them. This tablet, by the way, is now in the compound of the Kaifeng mission of the Canadian Episcopal Church. No one in Kaifeng, as far as is known, can read Hebrew, and the clan seems long ago to have lost any interest in Judaism. Several portions of Hebrew scriptures have been found on the streets for sale, evidently 336as mere curios. The chief Jew proposed one day, in a talkative mood, that he order all the Jews to become Christian and join the church of the American missionary with whom he was speaking—because he had had a quarrel with the pastor of the other church.
They intermarry with the Chinese, and some have even adopted Chinese idol-worship; the rituals most emphasized by traditional Judaism haven't been practiced for generations. They used to have what they called a synagogue, but about fifty years ago, it was completely destroyed, and it hardly seems to have been maintained even until then. There's been no effort to restore it, and a stone tablet that stood inside is all that's left. This last remnant has an engraving of Hebrew history and the names of the patriarchs. It previously also had the names of the main Jewish families in Kaifeng, but those were erased to mislead those who tried to persecute them a few decades ago. By the way, this tablet is now in the compound of the Kaifeng mission of the Canadian Episcopal Church. No one in Kaifeng, as far as anyone knows, can read Hebrew, and the community seems to have lost interest in Judaism a long time ago. Several parts of Hebrew scriptures have been found for sale on the streets, clearly just as curiosities. One day, the main Jew suggested, while chatting, that he should order all the Jews to convert to Christianity and join the church of the American missionary he was talking to—because he had a disagreement with the pastor of the other church.
The father of two likely-looking Jewish lads who attend the American mission school is a silversmith and has some means, but as a group the Jews of Kaifeng have not yet developed any Chinese Rothschilds or Guggenheims; nor is the wealth of the city in their control. In other words they seem to have become completely “un-Jewed,” if the expression be allowed, which is their chief claim to interest. For the Chinese, I believe, are the only people in the world who have completely broken the racial tradition of the Jews for remaining a distinct race. The slow and patient sons of Han have blotted out the marks that have identified the sons of Abraham for thousands of years, as they have pacifically assimilated race after race that has come into close contact with them, and it should occasion no great surprise if the Jewish colony of Kaifeng were entirely lost within another generation.
The father of two promising Jewish boys who go to the American mission school is a silversmith and has some financial stability, but overall, the Jews of Kaifeng haven't produced any Chinese Rothschilds or Guggenheims; nor does the city's wealth lie in their hands. In other words, they seem to have completely lost their Jewish identity, if that's the right way to put it, which is their main point of interest. The Chinese appear to be the only people in the world who have fully broken the racial tradition of Jews maintaining a distinct ethnicity. The slow and patient sons of Han have erased the traits that have defined the descendants of Abraham for thousands of years, as they have peacefully assimilated various races that have come into contact with them, and it shouldn't be surprising if the Jewish community of Kaifeng completely disappears within the next generation.
Soldiers were particularly numerous on the “Lunghai” line west from Chengchow, for this led to the headquarters of China’s just then most powerful general, Wu Pei-fu. Chang and I fell to talking with some of them in the crowded third-class coach. They were all volunteers—except perhaps as hunger and its allies coerce—enlisted for three years, new soldiers drawing, in theory, six “Mex” dollars a month, old ones, for what our own call a “second hitch,” eight. But in practice none of those with whom we spoke had ever been paid more than three such dollars during a single “moon,” at least, as they put it, “in time of peace.” It would be no great wonder if some of those off now on a furlough to their homes with only that amount to their names should be cogitating some violent means of improving that penurious condition of affairs.
Soldiers were particularly numerous on the “Lunghai” line west of Chengchow, as this led to the headquarters of China’s most powerful general at the time, Wu Pei-fu. Chang and I started chatting with some of them in the crowded third-class coach. They were all volunteers—except maybe, as hunger and its consequences force them to be—enlisted for three years, with new recruits supposedly earning six “Mex” dollars a month, while those on what we call a “second hitch” made eight. However, in practice, none of the ones we spoke to had ever received more than three of those dollars in a single month, at least, as they put it, “in times of peace.” It wouldn’t be surprising if those on furlough to their homes with only that amount to their name were thinking of some drastic way to improve their difficult situation.
One might become an officer within a year, they said, if one proved to be a good soldier, particularly if one were a friend of some friend of the general, or had money to scatter in the right quarter. Company officers seemed to receive about as much as our enlisted men do, with the privilege of buying their own food and clothing; but there are, as every one who has passed a bit of time in present-day China knows, other means by which they, and to a large extent the soldiers under them, often appreciably increase their official stipend.
You could become an officer within a year, they said, if you showed that you were a good soldier, especially if you were friends with someone close to the general or had money to spend in the right places. Company officers seemed to make about the same as our enlisted soldiers do, with the added responsibility of buying their own food and clothing; but, as everyone who has spent some time in modern-day China knows, there are other ways for them, and often the soldiers under them, to significantly boost their official pay.

Chinese farming methods include a stone roller, drawn by man, boy, or beast, to break up the clods of dry earth
Chinese farming methods involve a stone roller that can be pulled by a person, a child, or an animal to break up clumps of dry soil.

Kaifeng, capital of Honan Province, has among its population some two hundred Chinese Jews, descendants of immigrants of centuries ago
Kaifeng, the capital of Henan Province, has around two hundred Chinese Jews in its population, who are descendants of immigrants from centuries ago.

A cave-built blacksmith and carpenter shop in Kwanyintang, where the Lunghai railway ends at present in favor of more laborious means of transportation
A cave-based blacksmith and carpenter shop in Kwanyintang, where the Lunghai railway currently ends, relying on more labor-intensive ways of getting around.

An illustrated lecture in China takes place outdoors in a village street, two men pushing brightly colored pictures along a two-row panel while they chant some ancient story
An illustrated lecture in China happens outside on a village street, where two men move brightly colored pictures along a two-row panel while chanting an ancient story.
337Disarmament, I reflected, is like those long and complicated cures for virulent diseases that are so easily caught. When what we somewhat mistakenly call the most civilized nations of the world set the example of war, of mighty military forces, the infection cannot but spread to what seem to us the more backward races. Like a pebble tossed into a pool, the bright idea is taken up by race after race, country after province, until by the time the advanced nations are on the verge of bankruptcy and ready to quit for a while they must keep the thing up as a protection against the peoples of color and of strange faiths who have been stirred up by their example. In China there is an added complication. Soldiery, and banditry, too, are there largely a phase of the problem of unemployment. If China has the four hundred million inhabitants popularly attributed to her, any one who has traveled even in the less crowded northern provinces has seen that at least a hundred million of them must be perpetually hovering about the brink of starvation. An ambitious politician, or a general who refuses to lose his perquisites as such, himself imbued with the centuries-old dread of becoming one of the hungry, inarticulate masses, gathers about him all the soldiers he can recruit and find any means of keeping in his service. Most of these are simple, boyish fellows gleaned from the farms and villages before they have really taken root in the complicated society and industry of China. If they are discharged, if they are not paid, if the overthrow of their leader makes them fugitives, there is nothing much left for them to do but to turn bandits. Many have served alternately as soldiers and as brigands for years; many know no other trade, and, though they did, it is little less difficult to find an opening in the crowded, ill paid ranks of China’s workmen than to perform the venerable trick of passing a camel through the eye of a needle.
337Disarmament, I thought, is like those long and complicated treatments for highly contagious diseases. When what we somewhat mistakenly call the most civilized nations of the world set the example of war and powerful military forces, the infection spreads to what we see as the less advanced races. Like a pebble tossed into a pool, the idea is picked up by one race after another, one country after another, until by the time the advanced nations are close to bankruptcy and ready to take a break, they feel the need to maintain this military presence as protection against the people of color and different faiths who have been stirred up by their actions. In China, there's an added complication. Military forces and banditry are largely tied to the issue of unemployment. If China has the four hundred million people commonly said to inhabit it, anyone who has traveled even in the less crowded northern provinces has seen that at least a hundred million of them must be constantly on the edge of starvation. An ambitious politician or a general who refuses to give up his perks, and who is himself gripped by the timeless fear of becoming one of the hungry, silent masses, gathers as many soldiers as he can recruit and finds ways to keep them in his service. Most of these are simple, youthful guys taken from farms and villages before they've really become integrated into the complex society and industry of China. If they are discharged, if they don't get paid, or if their leader is overthrown and they become fugitives, there's not much left for them to do but become bandits. Many have switched back and forth between being soldiers and brigands for years; many don’t know any other trade, and even if they did, finding a job in the overcrowded, poorly paid ranks of China’s workers is about as difficult as trying to pass a camel through the eye of a needle.
Thus the same men who, as soldiers, force helpless villagers to make up their arrears in pay, find it no great leap, as bandits, to the torturing of rich Chinese who fall into their hands, until their victims have subscribed enough to drive starvation once more into the background. Raids on towns, invitations to chambers of commerce to save the community from the torch and looting by raising so many thousands of dollars, are the order of the day in many parts of China; and testimony is almost unanimous that most Chinese soldiers are as bad as the bandits. In fact, there are towns which pay the tu-fei fixed sums not only for promising not to loot them but to keep the soldiers from doing so. After all, is there any great difference between the flock of generals or provincial dictators misgoverning various regions 338of China as they see fit, by the use of their private armies, and another leader, who in his day may also have been a general and quite possibly will be one again, whose followers are referred to as bandits rather than soldiers? Often the only real distinction is that the one is strong enough to force recognition from the so-called Central Government, and the other is not, though they may be equally scornful of its commands and desires. How faint is the line of demarcation, even in the minds of the most successful Chinese generals, is shown by the opinion of almost all of them that when a force is defeated in one of the skirmishes of China’s almost constant, if unacknowledged, civil war the victor should take over most of the defeated troops and save himself the job of having later to clear them out of his region as bandits.
Thus, the same men who, as soldiers, force defenseless villagers to make up for their unpaid wages find it easy, as bandits, to torture wealthy Chinese who fall into their hands, until their victims have paid enough to stave off starvation once again. Raids on towns and pleas to chambers of commerce to raise thousands of dollars to protect the community from destruction and looting are common in many parts of China; and testimonies are nearly unanimous that most Chinese soldiers are just as ruthless as the bandits. In fact, there are towns that pay the tu-fei fixed amounts not only to ensure they won’t be looted but also to keep the soldiers from doing so. After all, is there really a significant difference between the various generals or provincial dictators mismanaging different regions of China with their private armies, and another leader, who might have also been a general and possibly will be one again, whose followers are called bandits instead of soldiers? Often, the only clear distinction is that one is strong enough to gain recognition from the so-called Central Government, and the other is not, even though both may equally disregard its commands and desires. How thin the line of distinction is, even in the minds of the most successful Chinese generals, is demonstrated by the near-universal belief among them that when a force is defeated in one of the skirmishes of China’s nearly constant, though unacknowledged, civil war, the victor should take over most of the defeated troops to avoid having to later expel them from his territory as bandits.
China, it is evident, will never get rid of her bandits until she has industries to absorb them, and her excess soldiers also. The latter are commonly “disbanded” merely by some other force coming into the territory they have been holding and driving them out, instead of surrounding and disarming them. Thus when they are forced to turn to brigandage they retain guns, ammunition, and uniforms; and they are helped by every one, including the soldiers. Understandings grow up between the two forces; the bandits bury money exacted from their victims and pass the word on to the soldiers, who pretend to have a great battle against the outlaws, but really dig up the money and bury ammunition in place of it. One can scarcely expect Chinese coolies to risk their lives, or even their skins, merely because they have been enlisted as soldiers. Moreover, banditry has been more or less continuous in China for many centuries. It is a rare play on the Chinese stage in which there is not some reference to the danger of falling into the hands of bandits; brigand chiefs are the heroes of many an old tale, just as they are in the popular legends of Spain; more than one dynasty was founded by some powerful outlaw who outfought his rivals. With industries to absorb the rank and file, who can say how many of the generals and chieftains themselves would not find a better field for their abilities, and a better way to free themselves from the dread of falling below the hunger line, as “captains of industry”?
China clearly won't be able to eliminate its bandits until it develops industries to provide them and its surplus soldiers with jobs. Currently, surplus soldiers are typically just "disbanded" when another force enters their territory and drives them out, rather than being surrounded and disarmed. As a result, when they turn to banditry, they still have guns, ammo, and uniforms; they even receive help from everyone, including fellow soldiers. Connections form between the two groups; bandits hide the money they steal from their victims and inform the soldiers about it, who pretend to battle the outlaws but actually just dig up the stolen money and bury ammunition instead. It's unrealistic to expect Chinese laborers to risk their lives or well-being simply because they’ve been drafted as soldiers. Furthermore, banditry has been a persistent issue in China for centuries. It's rare for a Chinese play not to mention the risk of falling into the hands of bandits; brigand leaders are often the heroes in many old stories, similar to popular legends in Spain; several dynasties have been established by powerful outlaws who defeated their opponents in battle. With industries to engage the common people, who knows how many of the generals and leaders would find better opportunities for their skills and a safer way to avoid poverty as "captains of industry"?
I overtook the major at the headquarters of Wu Pei-fu, with whom he had been an observer during his struggle against the lord of Manchuria a few months before. It took an hour by rickshaw to reach the place from the station, along the most atrocious caricatures of roads I had yet seen, even in China. The route lay through the walled town 339of Honanfu, better known to history as Loyang. Kuang Wu Ti made Loyang his capital shortly before the Christian era, when rebels drove him out of its predecessor, Changan, in what is to-day Shansi. It is a neglected part of China that has not been the capital at one time or another. This one was still the real seat of power not only of Honan Province but of a large portion of the putative republic. Inconsistently it was more miserably unkempt, more overrun with visible human misery, than any Chinese city I had yet come across, possibly because it was thus far the most southerly. Dust and the beggars squatting and rolling in it were all but indistinguishable until the latter were cringing almost under the runner’s feet, beggars as covered with filth as any in India, exhibiting great open sores, men so diseased that they spent their unoccupied moments in picking themselves to pieces.
I passed by the major at Wu Pei-fu's headquarters, where he had observed during the fight against the Manchurian lord a few months earlier. It took an hour by rickshaw to get there from the station, along the worst roads I had ever seen, even in China. The route went through the walled town of Honanfu, which is better known in history as Loyang. Kuang Wu Ti made Loyang his capital shortly before the Christian era when rebels forced him out of its predecessor, Changan, in what is now Shansi. This is a neglected part of China that hasn't been the capital at any time. Yet, it still held real power not just for Honan Province but for a large part of the so-called republic. Inconsistently, it was more poorly maintained and filled with visible human suffering than any Chinese city I had encountered so far, possibly because it was the most southerly. The dust and the beggars sitting and rolling in it were almost indistinguishable until the latter were almost under the rickshaw's wheels, beggars just as filthy as those in India, showing deep open sores, men so diseased that they spent their free time picking at their wounds.
We came at length through clouds of swirling dust to a score of great modern barracks, housing the division with which its now powerful commander has served since his lieutenant days. A formidable series of sentries and functionaries admitted me gradually through a massive gate, across a much flower-bedecked courtyard, through a voluminous anteroom, and finally into the official waiting-room. Three foreigners, who happened all to be Americans, and a baker’s dozen of Chinese were waiting. The major and a politically-minded youth temporarily released from Harvard, who was to accompany us on the outward journey, had just returned from the manœuvers at which the general spends his days on horseback, riding off daily at seven and returning at five, without taking food during that time. But many of the Chinese had been in the waiting-room since morning; indeed, it would have been easy to suspect that callers sometimes have the privilege of waiting overnight, for in the four corners stood as many large beds, canopied, but wooden-floored in the hard Chinese style. A long table occupied the center of the room; several more or less easy-chairs leaned against the wall. Nothing is more discourteous in China than to fail to keep a caller supplied with tea, and several orderlies, taking the leaves out of a familiar tin can in a corner behind a bed and transferring them to the pot in hands that showed no visible signs of recent soaping, kept the little handleless cup before each of us constantly filled and steaming.
We eventually made our way through clouds of swirling dust to a set of large modern barracks, which housed the division that its now influential commander has been with since his days as a lieutenant. A formidable group of guards and staff gradually let me through a massive gate, across a beautifully decorated courtyard filled with flowers, through a spacious anteroom, and finally into the official waiting room. Three foreigners, all Americans, and about thirteen Chinese were already waiting. The major and a politically active young man who had been temporarily released from Harvard, and was going to join us on the journey out, had just come back from the maneuvers where the general spends his days on horseback, leaving at seven in the morning and returning at five in the evening without eating during that time. However, many of the Chinese had been in the waiting room since morning; in fact, it would be easy to think that visitors sometimes get to wait overnight, since there were large canopied beds in all four corners, though they had hard wooden floors typical in Chinese style. A long table took up the center of the room; several more or less comfortable chairs were leaned against the wall. There’s nothing more discourteous in China than to not keep a visitor supplied with tea, and several orderlies were taking tea leaves out of a familiar tin can in a corner behind a bed and transferring them to a pot with hands that showed no signs of being washed recently, keeping the little handleless cups in front of each of us constantly filled and steaming.
Toward sunset there was a stir among the retainers about the anteroom and court yard, half-whispers of “Ta-ren lai-la” (the great man has come) from the Chinese visitors, and a few moments later we foreigners were asked to lead the way across another flowery court to 340a somewhat more sumptuous apartment. A young man in a gown of beautifully figured gray silk, of handsome and strikingly alert features, and speaking almost perfect English, had taken charge of details with the air of an accomplished, yet exceedingly cautious, master of ceremony. At least a score of persons drifted in, all Chinese except the four of us, but from all points of the compass,—politicians down from Peking for a conference, or looking for a chance to get there; correspondents of half a dozen native papers and foreign news services, some widely traveled and speaking English or French fluently; one or two from far southern China who could only converse with their fellow-countrymen through an interpreter or a mutually familiar foreign tongue; and a scattering of men of purely Chinese manners to whom a polyglot gathering was evidently a new experience. The assemblage suggested a king’s levée, with the added touch of costumes ranging all the way from the entirely Occidental to the very Oriental.
Toward sunset, there was a buzz among the attendants in the anteroom and courtyard, half-whispers of “Ta-ren lai-la” (the great man has come) from the Chinese guests. A few moments later, we foreigners were asked to lead the way across another flower-filled courtyard to 340a somewhat more lavish room. A young man in a beautifully patterned gray silk gown, with handsome and noticeably alert features, was in charge of the details, acting like an experienced yet very careful master of ceremonies. At least twenty people drifted in, all Chinese except for the four of us, coming from all over—the politicians traveling down from Peking for a conference or looking for an opportunity to get there; correspondents from several local newspapers and foreign news services, some well-traveled and fluent in English or French; one or two from far southern China who could only communicate with their fellow countrymen through an interpreter or a shared foreign language; and a few men with distinctly Chinese customs for whom a diverse gathering was clearly a new experience. The group resembled a king’s rising, with an added mix of outfits ranging from completely Western to thoroughly Eastern.
While we chatted, Wu Pei Fu slipped in among us almost unnoticed—for an instant,—until the silence of respect of the Chinese for any one who has reached power fell with a suddenness that was startling. The general had laid off his uncomfortable uniform and leather footwear, and was dressed in the long silken gown and cloth shoes of his native land. Small almost to the point of being tiny, he had undoubtedly “personality”; there was something about his vivacious manner and quite evident mental alertness which quickly set him above many of the larger and more stately men in the room. Even the “peanut” shape of his close-cropped head, so frequent in China, seemed to be but an added touch of slenderness; the hands, ladylike yet with closely trimmed nails, were an index to his whole appearance, which might have been summed up in the words “dapper yet strong.” His face was unusually vivid for a Chinese of his type, perhaps because he spends so much time out in the sun, particularly because of the extraordinary brilliance of his eyes, which fairly radiated during the frequent smiles that disclosed a small fortune in gold. Nothing, unless it was the rather stringy black mustache that fell untrimmed over the corners of a firm and slightly sensuous mouth, resembled in the least the oily enigmatical Chinese of our popular fiction. Though we knew him to be fifty, he could more easily have passed for thirty-five, and he spoke with what even I could recognize as the rather slovenly Shantung accent.
While we were chatting, Wu Pei Fu quietly joined us—just for a moment—until the sudden silence of respect that the Chinese show toward anyone in power fell over the room. The general had changed out of his uncomfortable uniform and leather shoes and was now wearing the long silk gown and cloth shoes typical of his homeland. He was small, almost tiny, but he definitely had "personality"; his lively manner and obvious mental sharpness quickly set him apart from many of the taller, more impressive men in the room. Even the "peanut" shape of his closely cropped head, common in China, seemed to add to his slenderness; his delicate hands, with neatly trimmed nails, reflected his whole appearance, which could be summed up as "dapper yet strong." His face was unusually bright for a Chinese man of his type, perhaps because he spent so much time in the sun, especially noted by the extraordinary brightness of his eyes, which sparkled when he smiled, revealing a small fortune in gold. The only thing that, perhaps, did not align with the typical portrayal of the enigmatic Chinese in popular fiction was the rather scruffy black mustache that hung unkempt at the corners of his firm and slightly sensual mouth. Even though he was fifty, he could easily have passed for thirty-five, and he spoke with a distinctly unrefined Shantung accent.
At a slight wave of his hand the gathering sat down at two large round tables set for a Chinese meal, the general apologizing to us foreigners for not placing us at his table, with the explanation that he had 341serious business to talk over with other visitors, evidently the politicians down from Peking. Politics, say those who know Wu as well as an Occidental can know a Chinese, partly bore and partly perplex him; he feels wholly at home only in military matters, but the plane to which his success as a general has raised him makes escape from political affairs impossible. They may be right, or they may never have plumbed below the surface of an unquestionably clever Oriental. The meal progressed like any informal Chinese dinner. Flocks of servants in and out of uniform brought bowl after bowl of the favorite foods of China, from which we fished with our carved ivory chop-sticks in competition with the rest of the circle. As one of the favorite sports of Japanese and Russians, as well as of the Chinese, waxed stronger and left us from the West completely outdistanced, even the staid gentlemen from rural parts, quite evidently unaccustomed to “outside barbarians,” mellowed and grew chatty, in an improvised language made up of gestures, monosyllables, and occasional appeals to the correspondents who spoke English or French. That sport is known in China as gam-bay, and consists of nothing more than tossing off at a gulp, whenever the head of the table gives the signal for a toast, the little porcelain cupful of samshu, sake, or vodka, as the case may be, which servants constantly replenish, then showing the empty inverted cup to one’s fellow-guests about the table. It may be a simple little pastime for those whose gullet has been galvanized by suitable training. But, for a simple person who has never outgrown in some matters a rather puritanical boyhood, it is apt quickly to result in embarrassment at the impossibility of proving enjoyment of hospitality in a way that will be fully understood. From time to time, of course, wet hot towels were passed to the guests, and when appetites flagged at last there came the bowls of lukewarm water in which the Chinese all too audibly rinse their mouths after eating. Our declining both these forms of ablution caused more or less wonder among the swarming servants and orderlies, according to their previous acquaintance with Westerners. Low as most prices are in China, this presumably daily hospitality to his flocks of visitors must make an impression on the never too plentiful funds of any Chinese general in these penurious days. But nothing is so dear to the Chinese heart as food, nothing rated really genuine without a feast attached; and to fail in the first rule of deportment would be a proof of waning fortune and a serious loss of “face.”
With a slight wave of his hand, the group settled down at two large round tables set for a Chinese meal. The general apologized to us foreigners for not seating us at his table, explaining that he had serious business to discuss with other visitors, clearly the politicians from Peking. Politics, as those who know Wu as well as a Westerner can understand, partly bores and partly confuses him; he feels entirely at ease only in military matters, but the status his success as a general has given him makes it impossible to avoid political issues. They might be right, or perhaps they haven’t fully grasped the depth of a clever Oriental. The meal went on like any informal Chinese dinner. Groups of servers, both in and out of uniform, brought bowl after bowl of China's favorite dishes, which we fished from using our carved ivory chopsticks, competing with the others at the table. As one of the favored pastimes of the Japanese, Russians, and Chinese intensified and left us Westerners completely behind, even the serious gentlemen from rural areas, clearly unaccustomed to “outside barbarians,” became relaxed and talkative, using a mix of gestures, monosyllables, and occasional appeals to the correspondents who spoke English or French. That game is known in China as gam-bay, and it simply involves downing a small porcelain cupful of samshu, sake, or vodka whenever the host signals for a toast, with servants constantly refilling the cups, then showing the empty inverted cup to the other guests around the table. It may seem like a simple little game for those whose stomachs have been trained for it. But for someone like me, who hasn’t completely shed a somewhat puritanical upbringing, it can quickly lead to embarrassment over the inability to show appreciation for hospitality in a way that’s fully understood. From time to time, of course, hot wet towels were offered to the guests, and when appetites finally waned, bowls of lukewarm water were brought out for the Chinese to audibly rinse their mouths after eating. Our refusal of both these washing options drew varying levels of curiosity from the bustling servers and orderlies, depending on their familiarity with Westerners. Despite the low prices in China, this daily hospitality to his many visitors likely puts a strain on the already limited budget of any Chinese general in these tough times. But nothing is more precious to the Chinese than food; nothing is considered genuinely true without a feast to accompany it, and failing to follow the first rule of etiquette would indicate a decline in fortune and a significant loss of “face.”
It was out in the waiting-room again that we had anything like a 342personal chat with the general. His tenacious fellow-countrymen having been deftly shaken off one by one, he joined us four Americans about the long, green baize table on which so many hundred gallons of tea a year are impersonally dispensed. His manner was a mingled hint of relief at having at last reduced his callers to those who certainly could not have come to buttonhole him for political preferment, of that respectful cordiality which Chinese in high places usually show toward any and all Westerners, whatever they may really feel toward the West, and of a suggestion of expansiveness apparently due to that fondness for gam-bay-ing which his friends sometimes fear may eventually be his undoing. Through his polished and cautious young interpreter he explained that he had come to us last that he might give us more time and attention, and from this auspicious beginning the conversation ran on through the fixed cycle of Chinese courtesies, we assuring him that we had come expressly to pay him our respects, he replying something to the effect that America has always been China’s greatest and most sincere friend, and so on for many rounds. But there was never a moment in which it was not evident that the general took all this buncombe and froth no more seriously than we; he was not only “democratic” in the way that has become so widely the fashion of late years, but he was plainly supplied with a reasonable fund of common sense, even though it might have Oriental trimmings. Wu Pei Fu is a man of larger background than many of those who have forced their way to the front in modern China, being what corresponds there to a bachelor of arts, as well as a military graduate with a long practical experience in military service. But the powers of evasion inborn in all Chinese do not seem to have suffered seriously from these rude contacts. Though we chatted for some time, nothing really worth recalling issued from the general’s lips, parted through it all by a toothpick, except the astonishing statement that there will be no more civil war in China and that the country will probably be unified within three years, after which he expects to be sent to the United States as an official representative. It may easily be that he considered these remarks mere after-dinner chat and expected us to take them as such. As we bumped back to our lodgings on the other side of the walled city in an asthmatic Ford which the general insisted on furnishing us, I regretted that some of us had not had the courage to ask some direct questions on the subject which just then could not but have troubled his dreams.
It was in the waiting room again that we had anything resembling a personal chat with the general. His persistent fellow countrymen had been skillfully shaken off one by one, and he joined us four Americans at the long, green baize table where so many hundreds of gallons of tea are served each year. His demeanor showed a mix of relief at finally having reduced his visitors to those who definitely couldn’t be there to ask him for political favors, a respectful warmth that Chinese officials usually display toward any Westerners, regardless of their true feelings about the West, and a hint of openness likely because of his fondness for gam-bay-ing, which his friends sometimes worry could eventually lead to his downfall. Through his polished and careful young interpreter, he explained that he had come to us last so he could give us more time and attention. From this promising start, the conversation flowed through the usual cycle of Chinese courtesies: we assured him we had come specifically to pay our respects, and he replied that America has always been China’s greatest and most genuine friend, and so on for many rounds. But it was clear at every moment that the general saw all this fluff and nonsense no more seriously than we did; he was not only “democratic” in the way that has become so popular in recent years, but he also obviously had a reasonable sense of common sense, even if it had some Oriental embellishments. Wu Pei Fu is a man with a more extensive background than many of those who have pushed their way to the forefront in modern China, holding what corresponds to a Bachelor of Arts degree, along with being a military graduate with extensive practical military experience. However, the natural evasive skills inherent in all Chinese people didn't seem to have suffered significantly from these abrupt interactions. Even though we chatted for a while, nothing truly noteworthy came from the general's lips, which were parted by a toothpick throughout, except the surprising statement that there will be no more civil war in China and that the country will probably be unified within three years, after which he expects to be sent to the United States as an official representative. It's possible that he viewed these comments as mere after-dinner chatter and expected us to take them as such. As we rattled back to our accommodations on the other side of the walled city in an old Ford that the general insisted on providing, I wished that some of us had had the courage to ask some direct questions about the topic that surely could not have been far from his mind.
343Briefly, banditry had about reached its pinnacle in this very province where the super-Tuchun held forth—under his very nose, so to speak. Two nights before, a large force of outlaws had entered the walled city of Honanfu, barely two miles from the great barracks housing his division, and, after warning the four thousand soldiers in town not to attempt resistance, had killed one of the principal merchants, evidently because he had refused to pay them tribute, and then had thoroughly looted his establishment and calmly returned to their rendezvous. On the very day of our visit the Protestant missionaries living and working in a great compound outside the walls had received unofficial, indirect word from Wu that they must thenceforth live within the walled town, as he could not otherwise guarantee their safety.
343In short, banditry had nearly reached its peak in this province where the super-Tuchun ruled—right under his nose, so to speak. Two nights earlier, a large group of outlaws had entered the walled city of Honanfu, just two miles from the big barracks where his division was stationed. They warned the four thousand soldiers in town not to resist, killed one of the main merchants probably because he refused to pay them protection money, and then completely looted his business before calmly returning to their hideout. On the very day of our visit, the Protestant missionaries living and working in a large compound outside the walls were indirectly informed by Wu that they had to move into the walled town from now on, as he couldn’t guarantee their safety otherwise.
But these were local matters. What was threatening the general with complete loss of “face,” throughout China and even abroad, was the kidnapping of foreigners from his very region of the country. The bandits seemed to show somewhat of a preference for missionaries, perhaps because they were most available, possibly, as one of them assured his worried friends, because the Lord was purposely offering the apostles this splendid opportunity to convert the wicked. There was no robbery involved, no demand for a money ransom, no more hardships for the captives than were naturally unavoidable in the circumstances. They were allowed to communicate frankly with their friends at frequent intervals; they were made as comfortable as the circumstances of being dragged from hiding-place to hiding-place permitted, though this did not spare them the acquisition of such ills as dysentery and pneumonia during their forced wanderings. The bandits presented one demand and one only,—that Wu Pei-fu, of the Central Government, should enlist them as a part of the army and give them a section of the country to garrison, and to tax! In other words, foreigners whom duty or pleasure took into the interior of China were to be made the pawns in a local political quarrel in which they had neither part nor interest. With all the grievances that exist between different factions in the troubled republic, there would be ample opportunity for every Occidental venturing beyond the sea-coast to get an intimate acquaintance with bandits and their lairs, particularly if this clever little scheme succeeded and won imitators.
But these were local issues. What was really embarrassing the general, causing him to potentially lose "face" both in China and overseas, was the kidnapping of foreigners from his own region. The bandits seemed to prefer missionaries, possibly because they were the easiest targets, or as one of them told his anxious friends, because the Lord was intentionally providing the apostles this great chance to convert the wicked. There was no robbery involved, no ransom demanded, and the captives faced no more hardships than what was naturally unavoidable given the situation. They were allowed to communicate openly with their friends regularly and were kept as comfortable as possible under the circumstances of being moved from place to place. However, this didn’t prevent them from suffering ailments like dysentery and pneumonia during their forced travels. The bandits had only one demand: that Wu Pei-fu, of the Central Government, should recruit them as part of the army and grant them control over a section of the country, and to tax it! In other words, foreigners who traveled to the interior of China for work or pleasure were caught up in a local political conflict in which they had no involvement or interest. With all the tensions between various factions in the unstable republic, there would be plenty of chances for every foreigner venturing beyond the coast to become intimately familiar with bandits and their hideouts, especially if this clever scheme succeeded and inspired others to follow suit.
There were strong suspicions that high officers of the Honan armies, if not Wu Pei-fu himself, were winking at the bandits and their activities, either because these paid in a share of their loot or for other reasons 344too intricate for the simple Western mind to follow. But this impression, while justly taking the super-Tuchun to task for not adopting a vigorous policy against the bandits, for using his influence to coerce Peking while failing lamentably to rule that portion of the country within gunshot of his barracks’ door, it did not, generally for lack of personal knowledge, take due account of the territory in which the brigands were operating. In the pell-mell, tumbled mountains of western Honan they might circle in and out while a whole modern army rarely caught a glimpse of them. Bombing airplanes might be an effective argument, but Chinese armies are poorly supplied with such modern luxuries, and there was the safety of the foreign captives to be considered. In other words, the bandits held the best hand, and about all even a virtual dictator to the Central Government could do was to enter into negotiations with them as if they were a legal and responsible opposing faction.
There were strong suspicions that high-ranking officials in the Honan armies, if not Wu Pei-fu himself, were turning a blind eye to the bandits and their activities, either because they received a share of the loot or for other reasons too complicated for the simple Western mind to grasp. While this impression justly criticized the super-Tuchun for not taking a firm stance against the bandits and for using his influence to intimidate Peking while failing badly to control the area within gunshot of his barracks, it generally overlooked the territory where the brigands were operating due to a lack of personal knowledge. In the chaotic, rugged mountains of western Honan, they could move in and out without a modern army ever catching sight of them. Bombing planes might be an effective tactic, but Chinese armies are poorly equipped with such modern luxuries, and the safety of foreign captives had to be considered. In other words, the bandits had the upper hand, and all a de facto dictator to the Central Government could really do was negotiate with them as if they were a legitimate and responsible opposing force. 344
This, at last, is precisely what Wu did. Though it was not until weeks after our visit to his headquarters, the loss of “face” involved when nearly a dozen foreigners of half as many nationalities, including women and children, had been carried off in his own province, added to slow but moderately stern and concerted measures by the legations involved, not merely toward the fictional Central Government but against Wu Pei-fu himself, forced him at last into effective action. One of the main troubles is that Wu and all his ilk, thanks largely to the supineness of foreign governments which should impress the opposite point of view upon the hit-or-miss rulers of present-day China, have on hand a bigger game, too often of a personal nature, than the rescuing of a few foreigners serving the brigands as pawns in their own little schemes. A loud and certain voice from abroad, as was proved in this case, would probably greatly reduce banditry even in Honan, the centuries-old home of outlawry, and certainly would make the carrying off of innocent foreigners as hostages a less simple and commonplace matter. Government, however, even when it is not ludicrously misinformed on the simplest phases of the situation in China, seems to be much more interested in issuing ten-dollar passports and collecting income taxes from its nationals abroad than of lending them the protection these should involve.
This is exactly what Wu did. Although it took weeks after our visit to his headquarters, the embarrassment of nearly a dozen foreigners from various nationalities, including women and children, being taken in his own province, combined with the slow but firm actions by the involved embassies—not just against the fictional Central Government but also against Wu Pei-fu himself—finally pushed him into taking effective action. One of the main issues is that Wu and his peers, largely due to the passivity of foreign governments that should communicate different viewpoints to the random rulers of modern China, have bigger personal agendas than rescuing a few foreigners who are merely pawns in their schemes. A strong and certain response from abroad, as this case demonstrated, would probably significantly decrease banditry even in Honan, a historic hotspot for outlaws, and would certainly make the kidnapping of innocent foreigners as hostages a less straightforward and ordinary occurrence. However, the government, even when it isn’t ridiculously misinformed about the basic aspects of the situation in China, seems much more focused on issuing ten-dollar passports and collecting income taxes from its citizens abroad rather than providing them with the protection those taxes should guarantee.

In the Protestant mission compound of Honanfu the missionaries had tied up this thief to stew in the sun for a few days, rather than turn him over to the authorities, who would have lopped off his head
In the Protestant mission compound of Honanfu, the missionaries had tied up this thief to let him sit in the sun for a few days instead of handing him over to the authorities, who would have beheaded him.

Over a city gate in western Honan two crated heads of bandits were festering in the sun and feeding swarms of flies
Over a city gate in western Honan, two decaying heads of bandits were rotting in the sun and attracting swarms of flies.

A village in the loess country, which breaks up into fantastic formations as the stoneless soil is worn away by the rains and blown away by the winds
A village in the loess region, where the soil, free of stones, erodes into amazing shapes due to rain and wind.
345In this case all the foreign captives were released, gradually, within a week after the legations began to show real signs of life, not greatly the worse for wear, and with an absorbing after-dinner topic to last them for years to come. But it was easy to guess what splendid arguments stray foreigners are to prove in domestic Chinese controversies, of which they may be as supremely ignorant as uninterested, during perhaps years to come, now that this little scheme of the bandits had been crowned with such signal success. It is easier still to see how much bolder they will grow in gathering such arguments, how much rougher, when it serves their purposes, in the use of them, and how much the self-seeking militarists of China will care how far the acknowledged outlaws go in the matter, so long as a wishy-washy policy, supremely ignorant of the first rules of Chinese psychology, continues to represent the Western world in this matter.
345In this situation, all the foreign captives were released slowly, within a week after the embassies began to show real signs of activity, not much worse for wear, and with an interesting after-dinner conversation topic that would last them for years. But it was easy to imagine what great points random foreigners would make in local Chinese debates, of which they might be completely unaware and uninterested, for perhaps years to come, now that this little scheme of the bandits had been so notably successful. It's even clearer how much bolder they will become in gathering such points, how much more aggressive they will get in using them when it suits their goals, and how little the self-serving militarists of China will care how far the recognized outlaws go in this issue, as long as a weak policy, completely clueless about the basics of Chinese psychology, continues to represent the Western world in this matter.
Just what argument had been brought to bear on the brigands remained for several days a more or less profound secret; but the “old China hand” had his suspicions, which turned out to be fully justified. He suspected that temporizing, compromising, and weakly yielding had been the consecutive orders of the moves, for long experience has taught him the more outstanding features of the Chinese character. When it could no longer be concealed, word seeped up out of Honan that virtually all the demands of the bandits had been granted in full. Their chieftains were given high rank and official titles, and the men themselves were incorporated into the “national army,” whatever that means, any world agreements toward disarmament notwithstanding. Not only that, but their organizations had been left intact and given a corner of the province to rule, particularly to “tax,” instead of at least being split up among other organizations in which some slight curb might be put upon their activities. The Chinese populations involved protested, in so far as they dared, but of course in vain. That is another misfortune of the supine policy of foreign governments, that the law-abiding Chinese masses suffer all the more accordingly. But, after all, perhaps they are more or less responsible for the low state of authority in present-day China, and subject to a corresponding discount of sympathy.
Just what argument had been used against the bandits remained a bit of a mystery for several days; however, the “old China hand” had his suspicions, which turned out to be completely correct. He suspected that delaying tactics, compromise, and weak concessions had been the ongoing strategy, as long experience had taught him the key traits of the Chinese character. When it could no longer be hidden, news started coming from Honan that almost all the bandits' demands had been fully met. Their leaders were given high ranks and official titles, and the bandits themselves were absorbed into the “national army,” whatever that means, despite any global agreements on disarmament. Not only that, but their organizations were left intact and given a part of the province to govern, especially to “tax,” instead of being divided among other groups where some restrictions might be placed on their activities. The local Chinese populations protested, as much as they could, but obviously, it was in vain. That’s another unfortunate result of the passive policies of foreign governments, where the law-abiding Chinese masses suffer even more. But, after all, perhaps they are somewhat responsible for the weak state of authority in present-day China, and this leads to a corresponding reduction in sympathy.
Months later down in Yencheng, the center of the foreigner-capturing brigandage of Honan, I picked up a few details of their calling. Though the outside world hears much more of it, there is hardly, so far, one foreigner carried off by bandits to a thousand Chinese. The usual method is to attack a village and take a man of standing, or his son of fifteen or so, for ransom; but rather than run the dangers of dragging the captive about with them, the outlaws often hand him over to some resident of a neighboring village, perhaps only a woman, with the threat to burn the house and kill its occupants if the hostage is not there when they return for him. Many a helpless family 346is thus left stranded between the devil and the deep sea. Occasionally girls are taken, but the girl or woman who is kept overnight loses her reputation and is not worth ransoming. Therefore they are either returned after negotiations lasting a few hours, or are kept as camp property. When they are after money or material advancement, Chinese brigands do not mistreat women; these suffer more when soldiers run amuck and loot a town. Like banditry, this is old Chinese history; in the days of Kublai Khan, of whom we hear such romantic stories, Mongol Buddhist priests or lamas were given an iron ticket from the emperor which gave them the right to enter any house in China, drive out the men, and install themselves in their place. For a fortnight a year during the Mongol dynasty, popular Chinese history records that the country was given over to promiscuous debauchery; bearing these things in mind one is surprised at the comparative lack of abuse of women by Chinese malefactors.
Months later, down in Yencheng, the heart of the banditry capturing foreigners in Honan, I picked up a few details about their trade. Although the outside world hears a lot about it, there are hardly one foreigner kidnapped by bandits for every thousand Chinese. The usual method is to raid a village and take a prominent man, or his teenage son, for ransom; but rather than risk the dangers of transporting the captive with them, the outlaws often leave him with some local resident, perhaps just a woman, threatening to burn the house and kill everyone inside if the hostage isn’t there when they return for him. Many powerless families are thus caught between a rock and a hard place. Occasionally, girls are taken, but a girl or woman who spends the night with them loses her reputation and isn't worth ransoming. So, they are either returned after a few hours of negotiations or kept as property. When looking for money or material gain, Chinese bandits do not mistreat women; they suffer more when soldiers go wild and loot a town. Like banditry, this is part of old Chinese history; in the days of Kublai Khan, of whom we hear such romantic tales, Mongol Buddhist priests or lamas were given an iron ticket by the emperor that allowed them to enter any house in China, drive out the men, and take their place. For a fortnight each year during the Mongol dynasty, popular Chinese history records that the country was given over to rampant debauchery; keeping these things in mind, one is surprised at the relatively low levels of abuse of women by Chinese criminals.
On the way from the Peking-Hankow main line to Honanfu there had been much of that clay-sandy earth called loess, and in the rambling half-day from there to the rail-head there was more of it. Cultivation, rain, wind breaking this down to varying levels, leave fantastic forms of earth as striking as the rocks of Namur, precarious cliffs in which are cut cave-dwellings, shrines, even temples; indeed, for long stretches there were few other kinds of buildings. Hundreds of little fields, one could see even from the jolting train, were gradually but irretrievably wearing away to a common level that would eventually make cultivation out of the question. A doubly uncertain world this, where one’s home is a hole in the cliff-side that may any day slough off, where one must always walk cautiously along the edge of either field or veranda, lest it at any moment drop from under. We passed through many tunnels, always thankful to find them stone-faced. How this soil ever succeeds in holding together even as long as it does was one of the mysteries that beguiled all that morning’s journey.
On the way from the Peking-Hankow main line to Honanfu, there was a lot of that clay-sandy earth called loess, and during the bumpy half-day journey to the railhead, there was even more of it. Cultivation, rain, and wind break this down to different levels, creating fantastic earth formations as striking as the rocks of Namur, with precarious cliffs cut into cave dwellings, shrines, and even temples; indeed, for long stretches, there were few other types of buildings. Hundreds of little fields could be seen even from the rattling train, gradually but irretrievably wearing away to a common level that would eventually make farming impossible. It was a doubly uncertain world, where one’s home is a hole in the cliffside that could collapse any day, where one must always walk carefully along the edge of either field or veranda, lest it drop from beneath them at any moment. We passed through many tunnels, always grateful to find them stone-faced. How this soil manages to stay intact even as long as it does was one of the mysteries that captivated us throughout that morning’s journey.
At the scattered town of Kwanyintang the railway abandoned us to our own devices. Fortunately the Tuchun of Honan Province, China’s far-famed “Christian General,” did not. All the way from Kaifeng, where the major had gone to visit him, he had sent one of his aides to smooth the way for us. This handsome and intelligent fellow, still in his quilted silky-gray uniform, had once been a lieutenant-colonel but had given up his rank in order to work for social welfare among the soldiers. He carried several bundles of Chinese pamphlets in hectic 347covers, which turned out to be translations of various books of the Bible, to be distributed among the country people. What distinguished him still more from the mass of China’s swarming soldiers was the fact that he insisted on paying his fare. Had not this idiosyncrasy of the “Christian General’s” troops already been familiar to the officials of the Lunghai Railway, it is quite possible that we should have seen a pair of them faint away with astonishment at the door of our unupholstered compartment.
At the small town of Kwanyintang, the railway left us to figure things out on our own. Thankfully, the Tuchun of Honan Province, China’s famous “Christian General,” did not. All the way from Kaifeng, where the major had gone to see him, he sent one of his aides to help us out. This well-dressed and smart guy, still in his quilted silky-gray uniform, had once been a lieutenant-colonel but chose to give up his rank to work on social welfare for the soldiers. He carried several bundles of Chinese pamphlets in vibrant covers, which turned out to be translations of different books of the Bible, meant for distribution among the locals. What set him apart from the many soldiers in China was that he insisted on paying for his fare. If the officials of the Lunghai Railway weren't already familiar with this quirky behavior of the “Christian General’s” troops, it’s very possible we would have seen a couple of them faint from shock at the entrance of our plain compartment.
In the far reaches of China there is a comradeship among all foreigners—perhaps the word “European” or “Caucasian” would be more exact—stronger than that between fellow-countrymen in many parts of the world. Let a rumor drift to a traveler’s ears that there is a wai-guo-ren in town, or indeed within reasonable striking distance of his route, and he feels it as much his duty to call, quite irrespective of the stranger’s particular nationality, as the latter does immediately to offer him hospitality. There was nothing unusual, therefore, in the fact that we were met at the present end of the line by an Armenian, a Greek, and a Rumanian, all members of this Belgian-French railway concession, who at once turned their office over to us as a lodging. Nor was there any reason to be surprised when a Russian Jew, who had just ridden down from Chinese Turkestan in record time, turned up there hoping to sell us his horses. He was true to his race, however, when the question of price came up, and we were not seriously tempted to alter our original plan to leave Kwanyintang in mule-litters.
In the remote parts of China, there’s a strong bond among all foreigners—maybe using “European” or “Caucasian” is more accurate—that’s often stronger than the relationships among people from the same country in many places around the world. When a traveler hears a rumor about another wai-guo-ren in town or nearby, they feel it’s their duty to visit, regardless of the stranger’s nationality, and the newcomer immediately offers hospitality in return. So, it wasn’t surprising that we were welcomed at the end of the line by an Armenian, a Greek, and a Romanian, all part of this Belgian-French railway concession, who quickly offered us their office as a place to stay. It also wasn’t unexpected when a Russian Jew, who had just come down from Chinese Turkestan in record time, showed up hoping to sell us his horses. However, he stayed true to his roots when it came to the price, and we weren’t seriously tempted to change our original plan of leaving Kwanyintang in mule-litters.
It is proof that our aide from Kaifeng was something more than Christian that he had the expedition we required gathered, signed, and sealed before nightfall. The usual system in such cases is to leave the whole matter to some responsible innkeeper. He sets the price, engages mules and whatever conveyances are necessary, and assumes responsibility for the proper carrying out of the contract. In this case, as is also usual, he came bringing a great sheet of flimsy paper daubed with Chinese characters in red—the contract in question—and decorated with several red “chops,” the personal seals of responsible residents of the town, which serve as a cross between recommendations and sureties. He had also come to ask for three fourths of the sum agreed upon, which was sixteen “Mex” dollars per litter for the journey of 280 li to the first town over the Honan-Shensi border. Ten Chinese li, it may be as well to specify once for all, make approximately three miles, though in practice there are “small li” and “large li,” in mountainous country two or three times as many li going as coming, or vice versa, 348and occasionally a complete unintelligence as to road measurements. The innkeeper must have expected that we had taken the trouble to inform ourselves and were aware that at most only half the amount involved is advanced, but the Chinese never risk losing an opportunity to profit by the possible ignorance of a foreigner. When we declined even to pay the customary half until we could inspect the mules next morning, we ran some risk of undoing all the labor of our more than Christian aide; for the sons of Han hate even more to make the slightest rebate on custom than they do not to be able to overreach it a few points. Had we been Chinese, probably negotiations would have halted then and there until the money was forthcoming; but foreigners still have some of their old prestige and reputation in the Chinese Republic.
It's clear that our helper from Kaifeng was more than just a Christian because he had everything we needed for the trip organized, signed, and finalized before nightfall. Normally, in situations like this, you would rely on a trustworthy innkeeper. They set the price, arrange for mules and any other necessary transport, and take on the responsibility to ensure everything goes according to plan. In this instance, as is usually the case, he arrived with a large sheet of thin paper covered in red Chinese characters—the contract we needed—and stamped with several red "chops," which are personal seals from reputable residents of the town that act as a mix of endorsements and guarantees. He also came to request three-quarters of the agreed amount, which was sixteen "Mex" dollars per litter for the journey of 280 li to the first town across the Honan-Shensi border. For reference, ten Chinese li is about three miles, although there are "small li" and "large li," and in hilly areas, it can take two or three times as many li in one direction compared to the other, or sometimes there’s just confusion about road distances. The innkeeper must have assumed we knew better and realized that only half the total amount is typically paid upfront, but the Chinese never miss a chance to take advantage of a possible foreigner's lack of knowledge. When we refused to pay even the usual half until we could check the mules the next morning, we risked jeopardizing all the hard work of our exceptionally competent aide; the Han people dislike making even the slightest concession to customs just as much as they dislike feeling like they missed an opportunity to take advantage. If we had been Chinese, the negotiations would likely have stopped right there until the money was paid; however, foreigners still hold some of their former prestige and reputation in the Chinese Republic.
Our precaution really was hardly worth the trouble, for the night was too black when we began to load to tell a mule from a corpse or a litter from a lumber-pile. A Chinese mule-litter consists of two pieces of telegraph-pole some ten feet long, which are fastened together at either end with a crosspiece that sets into a pack-saddle, and beneath which are two straddling wooden legs to keep the contrivance high enough off the ground when the two animals are taken from beneath it. Between the two poles is looped a network of ropes covered with a straw mat, with sag enough in them to hold the traveler’s baggage and leave him room to spread his bedding and to sit or stretch out at full length upon it. Over all this there is an arched roof of straw matting, not dissimilar in appearance to that of a “prairie-schooner.” My own custom of living on the country during my travels had become so fixed that I had still not adjusted myself to the major’s notions of a proper equipment. We had two army-trunks, one of them very full of canned foods. Folding cots, bedding-rolls, spare garments sufficient even for the wintry weather we expected before the journey was over, and a small mule-load of merely personal conveniences were enough to render speechless a wanderer long accustomed to carry all his possessions on his own back. When to all this was added a “boy” and a cook, and all the equipment necessary for them to function in a fitting manner, I felt more as if I had again joined the army than as though we were merely setting off on a little personal jaunt. It will not be unduly anticipating, perhaps, if I mention now that, while my companion sometimes realized he was not living at home, and solicitous persons back in Peking fancied we were roughing it, memory of many another cross-country tramp made this one seem to me like traveling in extreme luxury; and the worst of it is that I thoroughly enjoyed the change.
Our caution really wasn't worth the hassle, because it was too dark to tell a mule from a corpse or a litter from a pile of lumber when we started loading. A Chinese mule-litter consists of two pieces of telegraph pole about ten feet long, connected at each end with a crosspiece that attaches to a pack saddle, resting on two wooden legs that keep it elevated off the ground when the animals are taken out. Between the two poles is a network of ropes covered with a straw mat, sagging enough to hold the traveler's baggage and allowing space for him to spread out his bedding and sit or lie down fully. Over all of this is an arched roof made of straw matting, somewhat resembling that of a “prairie-schooner.” My usual way of living on the road had become so ingrained that I still hadn't adjusted to the major’s ideas of proper equipment. We had two army trunks, one packed full of canned food. We also had folding cots, bedding rolls, extra clothes even for the winter weather we expected before the trip was over, and a small mule-load of personal items that left me speechless, as I was used to carrying everything on my own back. To all this, we added a "boy" and a cook, along with all the gear needed for them to do their jobs properly, which made me feel more like I’d rejoined the army than that we were just heading out on a little personal trip. It might not be too forward to say that, while my companion sometimes noticed he wasn’t at home and concerned friends back in Peking thought we were roughing it, memories of many other cross-country treks made this one feel like traveling in total luxury to me; and the best part is that I thoroughly enjoyed the change.
CHAPTER XIX
Westward through loess canyons
We were off at six, with the night still black about us. But that did not mean that we actually got started so early, for it would be a strange Chinese journey that began without a hitch. This time it was one of the mules which we had been unable to examine in the darkness. He turned out to be small, gaunt, and ratty, and long before we had passed through straggling Kwanyintang he became so lame and wabbly that there seemed no possibility of his even lasting out the day. Fortunately we were in a position to have our desires heeded. By order of his chief, our aide from Kaifeng had instructed the local commander to furnish us an escort of ten soldiers. We were quite familiar with the ancient jest that having a guard of Chinese soldiers is worse than falling into the hands of bandits; but at least, if they did not succeed in outsprinting the brigands in case of an attack, they could assure them that we were not worth the robbing or holding for ransom. Besides, were we not out mainly if not exclusively for experience? Now the escort proved its worth at the very outset; for even though it may have little influence over large bands of outlaws, such a Chinese guard is useful in prodding simple citizens into prompt action when those they are escorting express a wish. Ours was barely mentioned to the lieutenant in charge of the detail when he slipped off into the darkness as if he meant to make it so “snappy” that even Americans would applaud. That did not prevent the sun from peering with a red and swollen face up over the uneven pile of tile roofs to the southeast of us before he gave any sign of continued existence. But when he did come back there came with him a larger, sturdier mule than any of those already in our service, with its old-fashioned owner—who still wore a cue, which was turning iron-gray—ambling a bit sullenly, we thought, beside him. The transfer was made, and we were soon off in earnest, in a cavalcade that left the throngs of passers-by invariably staring after us.
We left at six, with the night still dark around us. But that didn’t mean we actually got going that early, since it would be a strange journey in China that started smoothly. This time, it was one of the mules we couldn’t check in the dark. He turned out to be small, skinny, and scruffy, and long before we had made it through the scattered streets of Kwanyintang, he became so lame and shaky that it seemed impossible for him to last the day. Fortunately, we could have our requests met. By the order of his chief, our aide from Kaifeng had directed the local commander to provide us with an escort of ten soldiers. We were aware of the old joke that having a guard of Chinese soldiers is worse than falling into the hands of bandits; but at least, if they couldn’t outrun the bandits in case of an attack, they could assure them that we weren’t worth robbing or holding for ransom. Besides, weren’t we out primarily, if not entirely, for experience? Now, the escort proved its worth right away; even if it had little influence over large groups of outlaws, such a Chinese guard is helpful in pushing regular citizens into action when those they are escorting express a wish. Ours was hardly mentioned to the lieutenant in charge of the detail when he disappeared into the darkness as if he meant to make it so “snappy” that even Americans would be impressed. That didn’t stop the sun from peeking up with a red and swollen face over the uneven pile of tile roofs to the southeast of us before it acknowledged its own existence. But when he returned, he brought with him a larger, sturdier mule than any we already had, with its old-fashioned owner—who still wore a cue, now turning iron-gray—walking a bit sulkily beside him. The transfer was made, and we were soon off for real, in a procession that left the crowds of passers-by constantly staring after us.
The lieutenant, it gradually transpired, having found the innkeeper 350who had contracted to furnish us transportation unable to replace the ailing animal at once, had calmly commandeered the first likely one he came upon. This being the chief worldly asset of the helpless owner, he had been forced to come along, to set off on a week’s journey on extremely short notice. Being mere Americans, we could not see why one of the other drivers, of whom there was one to each litter, could not have been intrusted with this extra mule, particularly as they all lived in the same town and were under bond, so to speak, through the innkeeper. But one soon learns that it is far the best plan to let the Chinese get their results in their own time-honored way, and not to peep too much behind the scenes, nor conclude that what is absurd, or unjust, or even cruel to the Western mind is necessarily so to the people of the Middle Kingdom. Each litter and pair of mules, we found in time, without openly showing curiosity, belonged to one man, either the driver who plodded all day long in the dust beside it, constantly quickening the pace of his two animals with an explosive “Ta! Ta!” and a few choice Chinese “cuss-words” which there is no call to add to our Western stock, or to a man who stayed at home and hired some one to muleteer for him. Naturally our declining the lame mule and the substitution of another divided the sum that was paid for that litter, and there was bad blood evident between the two men who trotted beside it as long as the journey lasted.
The lieutenant eventually revealed that, since the innkeeper we had contracted for our transport couldn't provide a replacement for the sick mule right away, he had calmly taken the first suitable one he found. This was the main asset of the unfortunate owner, who had no choice but to come along and start a week-long journey on very short notice. As mere Americans, we couldn’t understand why one of the other drivers, who were each assigned to a litter, couldn’t handle this extra mule, especially since they all lived in the same town and were sort of bonded through the innkeeper. But one quickly learns that it’s usually best to let the Chinese handle things in their own traditional way and not to question too much or assume that what seems absurd, unfair, or even cruel to a Western perspective is necessarily so to the people of the Middle Kingdom. Each litter and pair of mules, we eventually discovered without showing too much curiosity, belonged to one individual, either the driver who trudged beside it all day, constantly urging his two animals on with an explosive “Ta! Ta!” and some colorful Chinese curses that don't need to be added to our own, or to someone who stayed home and hired a muleteer. Naturally, our refusal of the lame mule and the switch to another mule affected the payment for that litter, and it led to some tension between the two men who jogged alongside it for the duration of the journey.
A summery autumn spread over the land, and the ten soldiers who deployed on either side of us soon asked permission to toss their cotton-padded overcoats into the litters. Their low cloth shoes and wrapped trouser-legs, Chinese fashion, were well suited to tramping, especially in the flour-like loess. Besides his fairly modern Mauser rifle and at most a dozen cartridges, each seemed to have a few small personal possessions tucked away about his person, and one middle-aged fellow with a face worthy a “hard-boiled” American “top sergeant” of the old school carried a hooded falcon seated on his crooked arm for the whole thirty sometimes hot and often laborious miles. Merely another example, we supposed, of the Chinese fear of trusting one’s belongings out of sight. Except for one long and somewhat stony ridge, the loess formation was unbroken, and dust swirled to the ears at every step. Beggars, often in a horrible state, rolled in it at the roadside, not only in the towns but at most unlikely spots in the open country. Surely their gleanings could not have totaled even a modest meal a day, and it was this working of such unlikely territory which impressed one particularly with the depths of Chinese poverty.
A warm autumn spread across the land, and the ten soldiers who were deployed on either side of us soon asked permission to toss their cotton-padded overcoats into the litters. Their low cloth shoes and wrapped trouser legs, in the Chinese style, were well suited for walking, especially in the flour-like loess. Besides his relatively modern Mauser rifle and at most a dozen rounds of ammunition, each soldier seemed to have a few small personal items tucked away about his person, and one middle-aged guy with a face reminiscent of a “hard-boiled” American “top sergeant” from old-school days carried a hooded falcon perched on his bent arm for the entire thirty sometimes hot and often laborious miles. Just another example, we figured, of the Chinese reluctance to trust their belongings out of sight. Aside from one long and somewhat rocky ridge, the loess terrain was unbroken, and dust swirled up to our ears with every step. Beggars, often in a terrible state, rolled in it by the roadside, not only in towns but in the most unexpected spots in the open countryside. Surely their meager pickings couldn’t have totaled even a modest meal each day, and it was the sight of such needy places that really highlighted the depths of Chinese poverty.
351Of the pitilessness of it we had had an impressive example before leaving Kwanyintang. In a dust-deep gutter beside its most densely thronged thoroughfare lay, the afternoon before, a boy of perhaps sixteen, a single filthy rag covering him merely from shoulders to navel, several immense surfaces of his exposed body eaten away by some loathsome disease. Evidently he was writhing in real pain instead of more or less pretending it for sympathy’s sake, as did so many of his rivals along the way, for several men had paused to talk with him, and that is an extraordinary mark of solicitude in China toward roadside mendicants. But evidently no one did anything else for him; for as we rode by the spot before daylight next morning, while the night was still bitter cold, there he still lay in the same all but naked state, powdered over with dust, and evidently dead—at least we sincerely hoped so. The poverty of China is so general, and native charity and compassion so slight—for even the minority who are above suffering cannot but be more or less constantly obsessed with the dread of themselves falling into beggary—that even what we would call “very deserving cases” must put forth great efforts to attract attention to their needs. Some of these are so ingenious as to be humorous, as well as pathetic, which may be intentional, for no one on earth enjoys humor more or responds to it more quickly than a Chinese. In one of the deep loess cañons through which we passed, a man whose feet seemed to have rotted away knelt close up against the precipitous earth wall in a spot which gave him just room enough to keep from under the hoofs of animals and the feet of pedestrians passing in such constant droves that he seemed to be bathing in dust. Through this rose his raucous voice in the monotonous sameness of some phrase of distress, accompanied by the ringing of a hand-bell. At regular intervals of at most thirty seconds he ended these sounds by fetching his head down with a terrific wallop on a big stone that lay in the road before him. Pausing to wonder why he did not crack his skull, I gradually became aware of the fact that he always struck the bell in his right hand into the dust in exact synchronization with the blow of his head, thereby of course cleverly increasing the apparent thud and at the same time inconspicuously breaking the blow. But, for all that, his forehead was almost raw with the constant pounding, and the exercise alone must have proved a real day’s work before the day was done. Yet the passing throng, being itself by no means affluent, seldom gave him more than a casual glance. The wicker farm scoop that lay beside him had barely half a dozen “cash” scattered about it, and this was typical of all the 352roadside beggars we passed for days to come. Whenever one of us tossed a copper into such a receptacle amazement overcame even the bystanders; for a copper is worth ten whole “cash,” though it is about the equivalent of one fourth of an American cent!
351Before we left Kwanyintang, we witnessed a striking example of people's cruelty. In a dusty gutter next to the busiest street, there lay a boy who looked about sixteen, covered by a filthy rag from his shoulders to his waist. Several large parts of his exposed skin had been eaten away by a terrible disease. He was clearly in real agony instead of pretending to gain sympathy like many others begging for help; several men had stopped to talk with him, which is a significant sign of concern in China for those begging on the streets. However, nobody actually helped him. As we passed by that same spot before dawn the next morning, while it was still bitterly cold, he was still there in the same almost naked condition, covered in dust, and it seemed that he was dead—at least we sincerely hoped so. The poverty in China is so widespread, and the locals’ charity and compassion are so minimal—for even those who might be considered better off are constantly afraid of falling into desperation themselves—that even what we would call "very deserving cases" need to work hard to draw attention to their plight. Some of these efforts are so clever that they are both humorous and sad, perhaps intentionally so, since no one enjoys humor more or reacts to it more quickly than the Chinese. In one of the deep loess canyons we passed through, a man whose feet seemed to have rotted away knelt against a steep earth wall, just managing to stay out of the way of the animals and the feet of the countless pedestrians who passed by, creating a dusty cloud around him. From there came the sound of his harsh voice, monotonously repeating a phrase of distress, accompanied by a ringing hand-bell. Every thirty seconds or so, he would smack his head against a big stone that lay in the road before him. As I paused to wonder how he didn’t crack his skull, I gradually realized that he always hit the bell in his right hand into the dust at the same time as hitting his head, cleverly amplifying the sound while subtly softening the impact. Still, his forehead was almost raw from the constant banging, and the effort alone must have made for a real day's work by the time it was over. Yet, the crowds, who were hardly affluent themselves, rarely gave him more than a passing glance. Next to him lay a wicker scoop with barely half a dozen "cash" scattered around it, which was typical of all the roadside beggars we passed for days afterward. Whenever one of us tossed a copper coin into such a collection, even the bystanders were astonished; a copper is worth ten whole "cash," which is roughly equivalent to a quarter of an American cent!
For the first few miles there was an endless string of coolies carrying bags of cement and of flour, and less evident supplies for the railway construction-camps farther on. A tunnel a mile long was nearing completion, and grading and cutting continued for some distance. Within a year, optimistic officials hoped, trains would be running to the Shensi border, and in two or three would reach at last the famous old western capital, Sian-fu. Then there were quantities of cotton coming in from the west, and every other imaginable thing bobbing at the ends of those springy poles across coolie shoulders which are so often miscalled bamboos, since they are more nearly hickory, polished and varnished to a mahogany brown. Itinerant craftsmen of every sort, peddlers of anything there is a chance of selling, portable restaurants for the feeding of all this multitude, hundreds of jogging coolies carrying their beds and their few belongings on their quest for work, all use this pole for bearing their burdens, so that the vista as far as the eye can reach was like a river of undulating men and things. Much of the way lay high, and gave us splendid views off across mountainous country fantastically broken as only loess can break, terraced on a hundred different levels, ever falling away at the edges, a world, as it were, that was wearing out. Or again the road, which never for an instant was worthy of any such name, would plunge into one of the chasms it had worn for itself during centuries of plodding through this friable soil, chasms a hundred, two hundred, in places surely three hundred feet deep, which might continue for many miles before there came another glimpse of the surrounding country. To walk in these is like shuffling through a cement-factory; let the least breath of wind blow, and one heartily longed again for a gas-mask. The walls being absolutely sheer and the sunken roads very rarely wider than a single cart, let one of these get ahead of us and we must inhale and swallow its dust for many weary li; while the tasks of passing those constantly appearing from the opposite direction required the patience and the profanity of a Chinese muleteer. Of the joys of fetching up in one of these endless channels at the rear of a camel caravan, probably at least a hundred strong, and many times more famous for raising dust than speed, no mention shall be permitted to sully the pages of what aims to be the veracious story of a perfectly respectable journey.
For the first few miles, there was a never-ending line of laborers carrying bags of cement and flour, along with less obvious supplies for the railway construction camps further ahead. A mile-long tunnel was nearly finished, and grading and excavation continued for quite a stretch. Within a year, optimistic officials hoped trains would be running to the Shensi border, and in two or three years, they would finally reach the famous old capital, Xian. Then there were loads of cotton coming in from the west, and all sorts of things bouncing at the ends of those springy poles on the shoulders of laborers, which are often mistakenly called bamboos, since they're more like hickory, polished and varnished a deep brown. Craftsmen of all kinds, sellers of anything they could market, portable restaurants feeding the huge crowds, and hundreds of hustling workers carrying their beds and few belongings on the hunt for jobs—all used these poles to carry their loads, creating a scene as far as the eye could see that looked like a river of moving people and goods. Much of the path was elevated, giving us amazing views across a mountainous landscape, twisted and turned in ways that only loess can create, terraced at various levels, constantly dropping away at the edges, a world that seemed to be wearing down. At other times, the road, which hardly deserved the name, would drop into one of the deep channels it had carved over centuries of trudging through this loose soil, with some chasms a hundred, two hundred, and in some places even three hundred feet deep, which could stretch for miles before offering another view of the landscape. Walking in these was like moving through a cement factory; with even the slightest breeze, one yearned desperately for a gas mask. The walls were completely sheer and the sunken paths rarely wider than a single cart, so if one of those got ahead of us, we had to inhale and swallow its dust for many exhausting miles; while the challenge of passing those coming from the opposite direction required the patience and frustration of a Chinese mule driver. As for the pleasure of getting stuck in one of these endless channels behind a camel caravan, likely a hundred strong and far more known for kicking up dust than speed, no mention will be made here, as it would tarnish the account of a perfectly respectable journey.

I take my turn at leading our procession of mule litters and let my companions swallow its dust for a while
I take my turn at the front of our line of mule litters and let my friends eat the dust for a bit.

The road down into Shensi. Once through the great arch-gate that marks the provincial boundary, the road sinks down into the loess again, and beggars line the way into Tungkwan
The road into Shensi. Once you pass through the grand archway that signals the provincial boundary, the road descends into the loess again, and beggars line the path into Tungkwan.

Hwa-shan, one of the five sacred mountains of China
Hwa-shan, one of the five sacred mountains in China

An example of Chinese military transportation
An example of Chinese military transport
353However, we were by no means confined to the bottoms of the cañons. A mule-litter, we quickly discovered, resembles many another contrivance in this imperfect world, in that it has both its advantages and its drawbacks. Shaped like a bath-tub, it might perhaps be quite cozy could one merely make it up as a bed and crawl into it. But when it is already half filled with such odds and ends as steamer-trunks and bedding-rolls, there is only a limited space left for the mere passenger. Moreover, the straw mattings are neither sun- nor dust-proof, and while one may in time and with patience learn either to sleep or to read in a litter, in spite of the camel-like motion varied by a sudden disconcerting lurch every quarter-hour or so, when the plodding driver outside concludes that the poles need leveling on one or the other mule, the average traveler is more apt to pass his time drowsily gazing at the plethora of red pompons and trappings on his lead-mule and listening to the monotonous tinkling of his bell. Litter-riding is an art that must be learned. As the rolling motion is prone quickly to unbalance the contrivance, proper bestowal of the body is closely akin to tight-rope walking. If one be of a restless disposition and accustomed to change the lower leg for the upper at certain intervals, one must not let the attention grow drowsy; if one persists in the reprehensible habit of smoking, then in laying down the pipe in the right hand great care must be exercised that the can of tobacco be at the same instant deposited with the left, lest the excess of weight prove fatal. In all our journey my own litter turned over upon me but once, and that was in an inn-yard where assistance was at hand to drag me out from under the trunks, cots, suit-cases, and what not under which the mishap buried me; but if there were ten consecutive minutes when I did not expect it to do so, they were probably during the many times that I was not inside it. We met in the west foreigners of long Chinese experience who did all their traveling in litters, some indeed who lined and carpeted theirs with felt, put a stove inside, and journeyed for weeks at a time, even in the depths of winter, reading many volumes during the journey. But while we are quite ready to admit without controversy the comfort of a mule-litter as compared with a “Peking cart,” I for one found the finest thing about it the fact that one could get out and walk.
353However, we were by no means limited to the bottoms of the canyons. A mule-litter, we quickly realized, is like many other things in this imperfect world; it has its pros and cons. Shaped like a bathtub, it could be quite cozy if you could just make it into a bed and crawl in. But when it's already filled with stuff like steamer trunks and bedding rolls, there’s only a little space left for the actual passenger. Plus, the straw mats aren’t sun- or dust-proof, and while you can eventually learn to sleep or read in a litter, despite the camel-like motion interrupted by a sudden jolt every 15 minutes or so when the driver decides to level the poles on one mule or the other, most travelers are more likely to spend their time drowsily staring at the many red pompons and decorations on the lead mule and listening to the monotonous jingle of its bell. Riding in a litter is a skill you have to learn. Because of the rolling motion, which can quickly throw the whole thing off balance, managing your body properly is similar to tightrope walking. If you’re restless and like to shift your legs every now and then, you have to stay alert; and if you have the bad habit of smoking, you need to be extra careful when you put down your pipe in your right hand while also placing the can of tobacco in your left to avoid tipping the balance. Throughout our journey, my litter only tipped over on me once, and that was in an inn yard where help was nearby to pull me out from under the trunks, cots, suitcases, and whatever else I was buried under; but during the many times I wasn’t inside it, I probably didn’t go ten consecutive minutes without expecting it to happen. We encountered foreigners in the west with extensive Chinese experience who traveled exclusively in litters, some even lined and carpeted theirs with felt, installed a stove inside, and traveled for weeks at a time, reading many books on the way, even in the dead of winter. But while I’m completely willing to acknowledge that a mule-litter is more comfortable than a “Peking cart,” the best part for me was the fact that you could just get out and walk.
This we did early and often, and thereby frequently kept out of the dust-swirling cañons entirely for long stretches. For the constant procession of coolies plodding up and down this route had worn at least one, and often as many as half a dozen, hard smooth paths along 354the brink of the chasm, paths undulating and meandering just enough to be delightful. From them we could look far down the sheer cliffs, seldom fifteen feet apart, upon the endless mule-trains, broken here and there by cumbersome two-wheeled carts, ox or horse drawn, or by a disdainfully leisurely string of camels, all so tiny with the depth sometimes that they seemed a procession of children’s toys. At the same time we enjoyed a brilliant sunshine—often too brilliant, in fact, though October was all but gone—now and then a delicious breeze, and views of the life of the region and landscapes frequently approaching the magnificent, all of which were unknown to the man who was drowsing or attempting to read in his litter far below. The average speed of our conveyances, though they were the swiftest things in the defiles, was scarcely equal to a reasonable walking pace, so that we could here and there wander a bit from the straight and narrow paths for a glimpse of something that seemed worth the deviation.
We did this early and often, which helped us avoid the dust-filled canyons for long stretches. The constant flow of laborers trudging up and down this route had created at least one, and sometimes as many as six, hard, smooth paths along the edge of the chasm—paths that curved and twisted just enough to be enjoyable. From these paths, we could look far down the steep cliffs, often less than fifteen feet apart, at the endless mule trains, occasionally interrupted by bulky two-wheeled carts, pulled by oxen or horses, or by a leisurely line of camels, all appearing so small from the height that they looked like a parade of children’s toys. At the same time, we enjoyed bright sunshine—sometimes too bright, even though October was nearly over—occasionally accompanied by a refreshing breeze, and views of the local life and landscapes, often quite stunning, all of which were unknown to the man dozing or trying to read in his litter way down below. The average speed of our transportation, though they were the fastest options in the narrow paths, was hardly faster than a reasonable walking pace, allowing us to wander a bit from the straight paths for a glimpse of something that seemed worth the detour.
There were places, for instance, where rows of old earthenware jars were set up in ridges of earth and filled with water, often carried from long distances, for the watering of passing animals—trust the people of cruelly crowded China not to overlook any chance to pick up a few stray “cash.” The latter, by the way, were now almost the only money seen, and passing coolies carried a string of them looped over a shoulder or some other convenient projection. Sometimes a row of enormous bowls formed a wall, shutting off a compound, instead of the commonplace structure of yellowish dried mud so generally serving that purpose. Naked children swarming everywhere and men with bronzed torsos bared to the waist working in the fields seemed to give the calendar the lie. Blindfolded animals plodding an endless round, a pair of men, or a man and his crippled wife, manipulating a big, crude windlass, brought up water from the field-wells scattered hither and yon, and unsuspected, if the superstructures were lacking, until one had all but stumbled into them. The vagaries of the loess soil were often fantastic, sometimes incredible. Extremely friable, wholly unstratified, yet surprisingly solid, too, its contrasts were a constant astonishment. There were villages in which it had split and gashed and fallen away into some adjoining rivulet cañon to such an extent that the mud houses seemed to be strewn helter-skelter among a forest of cathedral-spires and Gothic roofs, perched at every possible height and dozing serenely on perpendicular chips of earth which it seemed impossible that the first slight breath of mind should not precipitate in a mere cloud of yellow dust into the terrifying chasm below. Its persistence in standing long after 355it must surely have fallen was one of the wonders of the sunken roads. Here a great slice of it, split wholly free from the main precipice and seeming to hang like a curling wave a hundred feet or more directly above our passing litters, gave every appearance of being on the very point of breaking and burying a score of travelers beneath it, yet somehow it never did, at least in our presence. Innumerable such catastrophes must have come to pass during the long centuries in which this “national road” had become a cañon; but the Chinese way, no doubt, had been for the survivors to plod calmly on over the collapsing earth before the dust had settled, secure in the knowledge that if their own particular godlets held them in favor they were free from similar danger, while, if they were not, precautions were mere wasted breath.
There were spots, for example, where rows of old clay jars were arranged in ridges of earth and filled with water, often brought from far away, for watering passing animals—trust the people of densely populated China not to miss any chance to collect a few stray coins. Speaking of which, those coins were now almost the only money around, and coolies carried a string of them looped over a shoulder or some other convenient spot. Sometimes, a line of huge bowls formed a barrier, enclosing an area, instead of the usual yellowish dried mud structure that typically served that purpose. Naked children were everywhere, and men with bronzed bodies bared to the waist worked in the fields, making it feel like time was standing still. Blindfolded animals trudged in circles, and a pair of men, or a man and his disabled wife, operated a large, rough windlass, pulling up water from wells scattered about, often hidden until you nearly stumbled into them. The quirks of the loess soil were often bizarre, sometimes hard to believe. It was very crumbly, completely unlayered, yet surprisingly sturdy, its contrasts were a constant marvel. There were villages where it had cracked and eroded, falling into nearby stream canyons, causing the mud houses to appear scattered haphazardly among a forest of cathedral spires and Gothic roofs, perched at various heights and resting peacefully on steep chunks of earth that seemed impossible to support without crumbling into a cloud of yellow dust in the terrifying abyss below. Its ability to remain standing long after it should have collapsed was one of the wonders of the sunken roads. Here, a large section had completely broken off from the main cliff and seemed to hang like a curling wave a hundred feet or more above our passing litters, looking as if it was about to collapse and bury a group of travelers beneath it, yet somehow it never did, at least not while we were there. Countless such disasters must have occurred over the centuries as this “national road” turned into a canyon; but the Chinese way, no doubt, was for the survivors to calmly keep moving over the crumbling earth before the dust settled, confident that if their personal spirits were on their side, they were safe from similar dangers, and if not, precautions were simply a waste of breath.
Many a time the paths we followed along the crests seemed to have reached the day when they must spill down the face of the precipice, yet they always carried us safely past. Of cave-dwellings cut far back into these cliffs there was no end, by far a majority of the population having only such homes. But what perhaps was most startling of all the astounding caprices of this strange soil was to come, in a stroll across what gave every appearance of being a flat unbroken field, suddenly upon a great square hole in the ground, fifty or more feet in length and breadth, and as many deep, which was nothing more nor less than a family courtyard. Farm-implements and domestic animals littered its floor; into its side walls, sheer and exact as those of a box, were cut a dozen caves, high arched but with the usual small doors in each mud-bricked front—the dwelling-places of the numerous family, probably of three generations. There was nothing about such a farm-yard different from the ordinary ones all over China, except that the high mud wall surrounding it is the solid earth, with an inconspicuous tunnel often of considerable length connecting it with the outside world. Let this fall in, and there is not a ladder in rural China long enough to bring the hole-dwellers to the surface, on which lie their hard earth threshing-floor and their fields.
Many times, the paths we took along the ridges seemed to be about to spill down the side of the cliff, yet they always safely guided us past. There were countless cave dwellings carved deep into these cliffs, with most of the population living in them. But what was perhaps most surprising about this unusual landscape was what we found while strolling across what looked like an unbroken flat field—suddenly encountering a large square hole in the ground, fifty feet or more in length, width, and depth, which was nothing less than a family courtyard. Farm tools and animals were scattered across its floor; along its sheer walls, precisely cut like a box, were a dozen caves with high arches and the typical small doors made of mud brick—the homes of a large family, likely spanning three generations. There was nothing about this farmyard that set it apart from ordinary ones across China, except for the high mud wall enclosing it, made of solid earth, with a subtle tunnel often significantly long, connecting it to the outside world. If this were to collapse, there wouldn't be a ladder in rural China long enough to bring those living in the hole back to the surface, which sits above their hard earth threshing floor and fields.
The threshing-floors were everywhere busy at this season, beating out the last of the grain with flails or rolling it out with huge stone rollers drawn by languidly ambling animals. Whole families took part in the operation, the more than half-naked children teasing the leisurely beasts to keep on the move; the women, who generally knelt to spare their crippled feet, pawing about through the straw and now and then even helping the men to toss the grain up into the chaff-clearing wind. About the edges of every floor were stacks of hay and straw, 356all plastered over with a kind of clay roof, as seems to be the fashion in Honan.
The threshing floors were bustling this time of year, where people were hitting out the last of the grain with flails or rolling it out with large stone rollers pulled by slowly plodding animals. Entire families were involved in the process, with half-naked kids playfully encouraging the relaxed animals to keep going; the women, usually kneeling to protect their sore feet, rummaging through the straw and occasionally helping the men toss the grain into the wind to separate it from the chaff. Around the edges of each floor were stacks of hay and straw, all covered with a kind of clay roof, which is common in Honan. 356
But the prize sight of all was the terraced fields. I had seen some in the Inca lands of South America that seemed remarkable examples of human persistence, but they are mere children’s pastimes compared with these of western China. Those in the Andes are faced with stout stone walls and run only part-way up an occasional hillside, or bring a too steep valley under cultivation. Here a most remarkable series of terraces, of thirty, forty, even fifty levels, rose to the very summit of every mountain we saw not only for days but for weeks, covering it completely with low steps of endless giant stairways. Yet here stone is unknown; the facing of each field is merely the loess itself, constantly crumbling away upon the field next below. Geologists are more or less agreed, I believe, that the loess regions of North China, covering a quarter of a million square miles, are due to the destruction of the forests centuries ago, a destruction so complete that even the roots were grubbed out for fuel, so that a soil which with its natural share of rainfall and vegetation was all that man could wish has become a powder-like earth ready to break down and fly away at the first breath of wind. If they are right, what a splendid justice it would be to send those who are doing their best to deforest our own fair land to struggle for existence with the hordes of China, where the pressure of population has driven the farmer not only to the very crest of arid mountains but into every tiniest depression in the soil! Absolutely treeless, with never a suggestion even of brush or grass, these loess regions were everywhere for day after day the same bare yellow brown, beautiful enough in the changing phases from sunrise to sunset, but of a monotony that wearies the eye for all the extraordinary forms in which the ages have cast it. In spring and summer perhaps, when the terraces are waving with crops, there may be green enough. But it was hard to believe it in this autumn season, when even the rare remnants of a cotton or a corn field have the same shriveled, moistureless, yellow-brown hue as all the far-spreading and tumbled landscape.
But the most impressive sight of all was the terraced fields. I had seen some in the Inca lands of South America that were remarkable examples of human determination, but they are just child’s play compared to those in western China. The terraces in the Andes are supported by strong stone walls and only climb partway up certain hills or allow some steep valleys to be farmed. Here, an astonishing series of terraces—thirty, forty, even fifty levels—rose to the very peak of every mountain we observed, not just for days but for weeks, completely draping them with low steps of endless giant staircases. Yet, stone is nowhere to be found; the edging of each field is simply the loess itself, constantly crumbling down onto the field below. Geologists generally agree, I believe, that the loess regions of North China, covering a quarter of a million square miles, resulted from the destruction of forests centuries ago, a destruction so thorough that even the roots were pulled out for fuel, turning soil that once had its natural share of rainfall and vegetation into a powdery earth ready to wash away at the slightest gust of wind. If they are correct, it would be incredibly just to send those who are doing their best to deforest our own beautiful land to struggle for survival amidst the masses in China, where the population pressure has pushed farmers not only to the tops of arid mountains but also into every small depression in the soil! Completely treeless, with no hint of brush or grass, these loess regions were everywhere the same bare yellow-brown for days on end, striking enough in their shifting hues from sunrise to sunset but monotonous to the eye despite the extraordinary shapes shaped by the ages. In spring and summer, perhaps, when the terraces are filled with crops, there might be enough green. But it was hard to believe that in this autumn season, when even the rare remnants of a cotton or cornfield had the same shriveled, dry yellow-brown color as the vast, rolling landscape.
But walking always became a perspiring form of locomotion long before noon, and some convenient cañon-mouth or a stretch where the road came to the surface for a breathing-spell found us climbing into our litters. From then on until toward evening our view of the world about us was likely to be confined to the triangular bit of it visible between the red pompons on the lead-mule’s back and the straw roof 357of the litter, often still further reduced by the walls of the narrow ditch which so frequently was the road nearly all day long. Through this we saw more, however, than might be expected. A camel-train, or one of many mule-drawn soldiers’ wagons, loomed up out of a dust-fog so thick that collisions were narrowly averted in spite of our slow speed. Loess soil would not be so bad, at least so far as the traveler is concerned, if only it would lie still, instead of insisting on exploring the innermost recesses of any one or anything with which it comes in contact. Let a breath of air sweep down the road—which was certainly no unusual experience—and we could barely see the next litter before us. Then there was nothing to do but cover the face with a handkerchief and lie listening to the endless dingle-dingle of the little mule-bells and the slight creak of the swaying litter, broken frequently by the “mule-train coughing in the dust”—cough the weary animals did, indeed—and now and again by the vociferous “Ta! Ta!” of the drivers whose footsteps made no sound in the powdered earth, or a long-drawn “Trrrrrrrrrrr!” when they wished to bring the animals to a halt. An old and very experienced traveler is authority for the assertion that the road from Honan to Sian-fu is perhaps the most trying bit of cart-road in China, and, strong as such language is, we were inclined to agree with him. Yet it is a journey I would not have missed for several times its many minor discomforts.
But walking always turned into a sweaty way to get around long before noon, and when we found a convenient canyon entrance or a spot where the road leveled out for a break, we would climb into our litters. From that point until evening, our view of the surrounding world was mostly limited to the triangular space visible between the red pom-poms on the lead mule’s back and the straw roof of the litter, often further narrowed by the walls of the narrow ditch that the road became for much of the day. Through this, we saw more than you'd expect. A camel train or one of many mule-drawn soldiers' wagons would emerge from a dust cloud so thick that we narrowly avoided collisions, even at our slow pace. Loess soil wouldn't be so bad, at least for the traveler, if it just stayed put instead of wanting to invade the inner workings of anyone or anything it touched. If a breeze swept down the road—which wasn’t unusual—we could barely see the next litter ahead. Then all we could do was cover our faces with a handkerchief and listen to the endless dingle-dingle of the little mule bells and the slight creak of the swaying litter, often interrupted by the “mule-train coughing in the dust”—and they did cough, indeed—plus now and then by the loud “Ta! Ta!” of the drivers whose footsteps made no sound in the fine dust, or a long “Trrrrrrrrrrr!” when they wanted the animals to stop. An experienced traveler once said that the road from Honan to Sian-fu is possibly the most challenging cart road in China, and while that’s a strong statement, we were inclined to agree. Still, it's a journey I wouldn't have missed for anything, despite all its minor discomforts.
Sometimes the road escaped from the cañon for several miles, and then there was sure to be plenty to catch the eye. Perhaps it was a little house, temple, or dove-cote at the top of a high slender pillar of earth, for rain and wind may have washed the world away from about it and left an unbelievably frail support. Soldiers we were constantly meeting in great numbers; occasionally we passed large groups of recruits not yet furnished with weapons, simple-faced boys who might much better have been left in their native cave-villages to till the terraced mountains than to add still more to China’s most serious problem. But this draining of the country districts of able-bodied young men goes merrily on all over the republic—and the training of eventual bandits seems to have no end. Our own escort and long files of their armed fellows bound in the opposite direction now and then showed themselves on the sheer edge of the cliffs high above us, they and their guns silhouetted against the cloudless sky. We constantly met veritable crowds of travelers, mainly pedestrians. Endless strings of coolies came and went, their beds and tools and all their earthly belongings in blue denim rolls on their backs, or balancing from the 358swaying pole over their shoulders. I often caught myself wondering why they could not all stay where they were and save themselves all this laborious shuttling back and forth, so exactly alike were the long files of them plodding eastward and going west. There were very few women travelers; compared with the great throngs of men there were almost none, and they were always riding, naturally, since the most they could do otherwise would be to hobble a few hundred yards an hour on their dwarfed feet. Sometimes one of them loomed up out of the dust astride a donkey, always with a man prodding the animal on from behind, his easy stride seeming to emphasize the helplessness of the crippled legs tapering down to all but useless little feet on either side of the biblical animal. Children, swarming everywhere, were rarely on the move along the road, though occasionally we passed the cart or litter of a better-to-do Chinese carrying his family with him. But even if the heavy cloth front door of his conveyance was not closed, we rarely caught more than a glimpse of the peering faces of women and children tucked away behind the man and the driver in what must have been extremely tight quarters.
Sometimes the road would leave the canyon for several miles, and then there’d be plenty to see. Maybe it was a small house, a temple, or a dove-cote perched on top of a tall, narrow pillar of earth, created when rain and wind washed away everything else, leaving behind a surprisingly delicate support. We kept running into soldiers in large numbers; occasionally, we’d pass big groups of recruits who weren’t armed yet—innocent-looking boys who would have been better off staying in their home villages to farm the terraced mountains instead of adding to China’s biggest problem. This draining of rural areas of young, able-bodied men is happening all over the republic, and the creation of future bandits seems endless. Our own escort and long lines of their armed comrades heading the opposite way occasionally appeared on the sheer cliff edges high above us, their silhouettes and weapons against the clear sky. We constantly encountered real crowds of travelers, mostly on foot. Endless lines of coolies passed by, carrying their beds, tools, and all their belongings in blue denim rolls on their backs or balanced on the swaying pole over their shoulders. I often found myself wondering why they couldn’t all just stay where they were and avoid all this exhausting back-and-forth, as the long lines of them trudging eastward and then westward looked so similar. There were very few women travelers; compared to the massive crowds of men, there were almost none, and they were always riding, since the most they could manage otherwise would be to shuffle a few hundred yards an hour on their small feet. Sometimes one would emerge from the dust, riding a donkey, always with a man pushing the animal from behind, his easy pace highlighting the helplessness of the crippled legs that ended in practically useless little feet on either side of the biblical creature. Children, everywhere, were rarely on the move along the road, though occasionally we’d pass the cart or litter of a wealthier Chinese person traveling with their family. But even if the heavy cloth front door of their vehicle wasn’t closed, we seldom caught more than a glimpse of the curious faces of women and children hidden behind the man and the driver in what must have been a very cramped space.
Several times widows in white or sackcloth passed, usually seated alone Turkish fashion on an uncovered cart, as if to make their grief as conspicuous as possible. Some of them were surprisingly young; generally their faces were completely covered; and invariably they rocked back and forth on their haunches and wailed at the tops of their voices, whether in passing through a town or out in the open country, at least whenever there was any one except their plodding driver to hear them. This public display of grief seemed to be a custom of Honan; at least, we seldom if ever saw it farther west. One morning while we were still walking we heard a choral wailing from afar off, and at length came upon the mother, wife, son of six, and baby of a man who had just died, all squatting together on the outdoor threshing-floor at the edge of their village, and all of them, including even the infant, pouring forth their sorrow to the four winds. A pathetic, almost touching scene it was to me—until I chanced to glance back just in time to see the old woman pinch the boy in a very sensitive spot, and thereby redouble the wailing which the sight of a passing foreigner had almost silenced.
Several times, widows dressed in white or black cloth passed by, usually sitting alone in a cart, trying to make their grief as visible as possible. Some were surprisingly young; their faces were mostly covered, and they constantly rocked back and forth on their haunches, wailing loudly, whether they were in a town or out in the countryside, as long as there was anyone around to hear them aside from their slow-moving driver. This public display of grief seemed to be a custom in Honan; we rarely saw it further west. One morning, while we were still walking, we heard a collective wailing from a distance, and eventually came across a mother, a wife, a six-year-old son, and a baby of a man who had just died, all gathered together on an outdoor threshing floor at the edge of their village, all of them, even the infant, expressing their sorrow to the winds. It was a sad, almost touching scene—until I happened to look back just in time to see the old woman pinch the boy in a very sensitive spot, which only intensified the wailing that the sight of a passing foreigner had almost quieted.
Once in a while a bride passed, conspicuous in all her finery, and looking as if she, too, could easily weep the length of her tedious journey, did custom permit it. Then there was the wheelbarrow-brigade, in some ways the most interesting part of all the endless 359procession. The thought of a man wheelbarrowing a heavy load clear across a province or even farther had a mixture of the pitiable and the ludicrous about it—something reminiscent of a nonsensical election-bet. Yet it is doubtful whether any man in all our broad land, with the possible exception of champion athletes at the climax of their exertions, perform such grueling labors as do these Chinese wheelbarrow-men, who passed us in veritable regiments, sometimes in close unbroken file for a mile at a time. Given the weight of the big clumsy, creaking contrivances themselves, an incredibly heavy and often awkward load, a “road” which no untraveled Westerner would recognize as such, with steep hills, cañons ankle-deep in dust, and the constant struggle for right of way on the crowded caricature of a thoroughfare, and it was no wonder that the man straining at the handles, with the stout strap from them passing over his shoulders, all but invariably resembled a marathon runner at the end of his greatest contest. In northwest China the tui-chu is not a passenger vehicle, as in some parts of the country; but this ceaseless one-wheeled cavalcade carried almost everything except human beings. The luckiest seemed to be those whose bulky load was merely cotton; the heaviest burdens, with rare exceptions, were evidently the two to four black-brown bags of wheat, a bit smaller in circumference than our two-bushel sack, but nearly twice as long.
Every now and then, a bride would pass by, dressed in all her beautiful attire, looking as if she could also cry from the length of her tiring journey, if tradition allowed it. Then there was the wheelbarrow brigade, which was in many ways the most fascinating part of the never-ending procession. The idea of a man pushing a heavy load all the way across a province or even further was a mix of both pitiable and ridiculous—something like a silly election bet. Yet it's doubtful that anyone in our vast country, except maybe elite athletes at the peak of their efforts, undertakes such grueling work as these Chinese wheelbarrow-men do, who passed us in literally regimented lines, sometimes in unbroken file for a mile at a time. Considering the weight of the big, clumsy, creaking wheelbarrows themselves, the incredibly heavy and often awkward loads, the kind of “road” that no inexperienced Westerner would recognize, with steep hills, canyons coated in dust, and the constant struggle for space on the crowded, chaotic thoroughfare, it’s no surprise that the man straining at the handles, with a sturdy strap across his shoulders, often resembled a marathon runner at the end of his toughest race. In northwest China, the tui-chu is not a passenger vehicle, as it is in some areas; this relentless one-wheeled parade carried almost everything except people. The luckiest seemed to be those whose heavy load was just cotton; the heaviest burdens, with a few exceptions, were clearly the two to four dark brown bags of wheat, slightly smaller in circumference than our two-bushel sack but almost twice as long.
All possible manner of aids had been enlisted by the sweating men at the handles, though the great majority toiled onward without assistance. Sometimes another man, perhaps a donkey, once in a while a mule, an aged horse, a small ox, pulled in front of the wheelbarrow. More than one man had pressed his son and heir into service, and boys of all ages added their by no means insignificant bit to the drudgery. The detailed picture still stays with me of one child who could not have been more than six, his little bronzed body completely naked except for the red or blue diamond-shaped stomacher which most Chinese consider indispensable to health, steadily tugging away for all he was worth at the rope over his bare shoulder. He and his brawny father behind were plainly many toilsome days away both from home and their destination, yet on the child’s face there was not a suggestion of protest, but more than a hint of joy at this splendid opportunity to see the world. Indeed, the generally contented, not to say joyful, attitude toward their arduous fragment of life of these slaves of the wheelbarrow, of the coolies, of the toiling masses of China in general, is one of the astonishments, and delights, of Chinese travel. Possibly these men were paid the equivalent 360of fifteen American cents a day for their cart-horse exertions, furnishing their own food and lodging on the way; yet a surly face was as rare as a lazy body, and laughter always burst forth upon the slightest provocation. Those who pulled in front, I noticed, no matter how young or how weak, were never reproved or admonished to greater exertions from behind; it seemed to be as natural for them to do their unflagging best as for water to run downhill, and the thought of their slacking or of being capable of more never appeared even to suggest itself to the man at the handles.
All kinds of help had been enlisted by the sweating men at the handles, though most of them struggled on without any assistance. Sometimes another man, maybe a donkey, occasionally a mule, an old horse, or a small ox, pulled in front of the wheelbarrow. More than one man had put his son to work, and boys of all ages contributed their fair share to the hard labor. I still vividly remember one child who looked no older than six, his little tanned body completely naked except for the red or blue diamond-shaped stomacher that most Chinese believe is essential for health, diligently pulling on the rope over his bare shoulder. He and his strong father behind were clearly many exhausting days away from both home and their destination, yet the child’s face showed no signs of complaint, just a hint of joy at this amazing chance to see the world. In fact, the generally content, if not joyful, attitude of these wheelbarrow laborers, the coolies, and the hardworking masses of China is one of the surprises and delights of traveling in China. These men might have earned the equivalent of fifteen American cents a day for their cart-horse efforts, providing their own food and shelter along the way; yet a sour face was as rare as a lazy body, and laughter erupted at the slightest reason. I noticed that those who pulled in front, regardless of how young or weak they were, were never scolded or urged to work harder from behind; it seemed just as natural for them to give their all as it is for water to flow downhill, and the idea of slacking or being capable of more never seemed to even cross the mind of the man at the handles.
Twice, possibly three times, I saw a woman tugging at a wheelbarrow rope, but in each case the load was light and the distance evidently short; it must have been, in fact, for she could not have struggled far on the little goat-like feet and muscleless legs which time-honored custom had left her. I suppose the several brilliant Western “authorities” that are at the moment engaged in “interpreting” China to us would cite as another proof of the ascendancy of esthetic over material things in the Chinese mind the fact that, though her unhampered labor is very necessary to him, the Chinese peasant and coolie still insists on having his wife beautified at the sacrifice of her physical usefulness. On the threshing-floor or in the cotton-fields the women could be worked to somewhat better advantage than on the road, and there one saw more of them. For they could do most of this work kneeling, and nearly all of them, even girls of eleven or twelve, wore thick knee-pads, not unlike the shin-guards of a football-player, to soften a bit the hard lot that had befallen them. In the towns one often saw wives or servants crawling about the dirty earth floors on their knees in the performance of their household duties.
Twice, maybe three times, I saw a woman pulling on a wheelbarrow rope, but each time the load was light and the distance clearly short; it had to be, since she couldn’t have struggled far on the little goat-like feet and weak legs that tradition had left her with. I guess the various prominent Western “experts” currently busy “interpreting” China for us would point to this as more evidence of the focus on aesthetics over practical matters in the Chinese mindset. Even though her unrestrained labor is crucial to him, the Chinese peasant and coolie still insists on having his wife made beautiful at the cost of her physical usefulness. On the threshing floor or in the cotton fields, women could be utilized more effectively than on the road, and there you would see more of them. They could do most of this work kneeling, and nearly all of them, even girls of eleven or twelve, wore thick knee pads, similar to football shin guards, to ease the harsh circumstances they faced. In the towns, it was common to see wives or servants crawling around on their knees on the dirty earth floors while carrying out their household tasks.
The cotton-fields, by the way, were almost endless, though not much else could be said in their favor. The plants, from six inches to a foot high, were of a dead-dry brown, of the same color as all the landscape to the summit of the terraced mountains, and the miserable little bolls that remained did not seem worth even the trouble of such poverty-stricken pickers as here and there still wandered about in search of them. There had been no rain all summer in this region, they told us, and unless some fell within the next two months and saved the winter wheat, there would be another famine as serious as that of 1920.
The cotton fields, by the way, seemed almost endless, though not much else could be said in their favor. The plants, ranging from six inches to a foot tall, were a dead, dry brown, matching the color of the entire landscape up to the tops of the terraced mountains, and the few miserable bolls that remained didn’t seem worth the effort of the poverty-stricken pickers who still wandered around looking for them. They told us there hadn’t been any rain all summer in this area, and unless some fell within the next two months to save the winter wheat, there would be another famine as serious as that of 1920.

Coal is plentiful and cheap in Shensi, and comes to market in Sian-fu in wheelbarrows, there to await purchasers
Coal is abundant and inexpensive in Shensi, and it arrives at the market in Sian-fu in wheelbarrows, waiting for buyers.

The holy of holies of the principal Sian-fu mosque has a simplicity in striking contrast to the demon-crowded interiors of purely Chinese temples
The holy of holies of the main Sian-fu mosque has a simplicity that stands in sharp contrast to the demon-filled interiors of traditional Chinese temples.

Our carts crossing a branch of the Yellow River fifty li west of the Shensi capital
Our carts crossing a branch of the Yellow River fifty li west of the Shensi capital

Women and girls do much of the grinding of grain with the familiar stone roller of China, in spite of their bound feet
Women and girls do a lot of the grain grinding with the well-known stone roller from China, despite having bound feet.
361The first night out of Kwanyintang we slept in the house from which a Greek, and ate in the house from which a Frenchman, both officials of the advancing railway, had been taken by bandits a few weeks before. They were still in captivity among the mountains somewhere to the southwest, the nucleus of the considerable little party of foreigners by whose unwilling assistance the brigands eventually won their way into the national army. In fact we slept on unfurnished beds and were offered unnecessary apologies by our polished French host and Japanese hostess at dinner because of the looting that had taken place at the time his predecessor was carried off. There was still a certain atmosphere of suppressed dread among the few foreign residents, for none of them was sure how soon he might become the next victim; but mankind quickly learns to live without discomfort under many unpleasant circumstances.
361On our first night out of Kwanyintang, we slept in the house where a Greek had lived, and ate in the house where a Frenchman had stayed, both officials of the advancing railway who had been kidnapped by bandits a few weeks earlier. They were still being held captive somewhere in the mountains to the southwest, forming the core of the group of foreigners whose unwilling help allowed the brigands to eventually join the national army. We slept on empty beds and received unnecessary apologies from our polished French host and Japanese hostess at dinner for the looting that had occurred when his predecessor was taken. There was still a lingering sense of fear among the few foreign residents, as none of them knew when they might be the next target; however, people quickly learn to cope with discomfort in many unpleasant situations.
Our soldier escort changed each day, and we were entertained each evening with the long “face-saving” process that took place before the detail could accept the gratuity we offered them. The struggle, which we turned over to Chang as more finely versed in Chinese etiquette than we, was particularly arduous on that first evening, for the commander of the detachment was a real lieutenant, and instead of the thirty-two vociferous and violent refusals which seemed to be required of a mere sergeant or corporal before he accepted what he really had no intention in the world of declining, the lieutenant was still pushing back the detested silver with fine effect when we lost count and went inside. Three Mexican dollars distributed among ten men for a hot and arduous thirty-mile tramp for the possible protection of a pair of unknown foreigners might not strike one of our own “doughboys” as anything to write home about; but for men whose daily pay was nothing like their share of this sum, and who draw their pay much more often in theory than in practice, the major’s insistence that they “have a good feed on us” could not really have sounded so immoral to them as they pretended.
Our soldier escort changed every day, and we were entertained each evening by the long “face-saving” routine that happened before the detail would accept the tip we offered them. The struggle, which we let Chang handle since he was more skilled in Chinese etiquette than we were, was especially tough that first evening because the commander of the detachment was a real lieutenant. Instead of the thirty-two loud and forceful refusals that seemed required from a simple sergeant or corporal before he took what he actually had no intention of turning down, the lieutenant was still pushing back the unwanted silver with impressive skill when we lost track and went inside. Three Mexican dollars split among ten men for a hot and exhausting thirty-mile hike for the possible protection of a couple of unknown foreigners might not seem like much to one of our own “doughboys,” but for men whose daily pay was nowhere near that amount, and who received their pay much more in theory than reality, the major’s insistence that they “have a good meal on us” probably didn’t seem as wrong to them as they pretended.
The second afternoon was still fairly young when we reached the large walled town of what its residents, at least, called Lüngbau. The escort was to stop here, but the sergeant in command thought he could get permission to go on with us another twenty li, or get the next detail to start at once, if we would let him go into town and see the commander, while we continued around the edge of it, as most through travel does in passing crowded walled cities. Near one of the farther gates a soldier sent by the local commandant overtook us. His chief, he said, could not send a detail on such short notice, and he did not 362think it wise for us to go on without one. Bandits had been very active in the immediate region ahead and might even have heard of the “important” foreigners and be looking for them.
The second afternoon was still quite young when we arrived at the large walled town that its residents called Lüngbau. The escort was supposed to stop here, but the sergeant in charge thought he could get permission to continue with us for another twenty li, or get the next detail to start immediately if we allowed him to go into town and speak with the commander, while we went around the edge of it, as most travelers do when passing through crowded walled cities. Near one of the further gates, a soldier sent by the local commandant caught up with us. He said his chief couldn’t send a detail on such short notice and didn’t think it was wise for us to proceed without one. Bandits had been very active in the area ahead and might even have heard about the “important” foreigners and be looking for them.
All this moved us little, for both the major and I knew from long experience that it is always the next stage of the journey that is perilous for the traveler, never the one in which he actually is. Besides, ten straggling, poorly equipped soldiers of the Chinese type would scarcely prevent the bandits from adding us to their collection if they really meant to do so. But we were reckoning without our muleteers. They had already expressed a desire to stop in Lüngbau; the report from the commandant made them doubly anxious to stay. We were pooh-poohing their fears and deciding to order a new start when, following the eye of one of them, I glanced up at the city gate close beside us. It was a picturesque little portal, but that mere fact would not of course have drawn the attention of a Chinese muleteer. What had aroused his interest was two frail crates, thrown hastily together of narrow strips of wood, fastened to the face of the gate on either side just above the arch, and each containing a human head. I had often read of such dainty decorations on Chinese city gates, on those indeed of our medieval ancestors; but they had always seemed far away and long ago, something pertaining to the “good old days,” which a prosaic modern wanderer would never have the privilege of seeing. To come upon them, therefore, in the present year of grace and in the full light of the ordinary, every-day life about us, tacked up against two torn posters depicting the delights and excellencies of a widely known brand of cigarettes, was—well, was at least a pleasant reminder that the picturesque customs of old China had not yet all gone into the discard, that even the modern wanderer, if he wander long and far enough, may still once in a blue moon come upon some of those little details linking the phonographed, sewing-machined world of to-day with the cave-man, which he has so often envied the travelers of bygone centuries.
All this hardly affected us, as both the major and I knew from long experience that it's always the next leg of the journey that poses a danger for the traveler, not the one he is currently facing. Besides, ten ragtag, poorly equipped soldiers of the Chinese type would hardly stop the bandits from adding us to their collection if they really wanted to. But we were forgetting about our muleteers. They had already expressed their wish to stop in Lüngbau; the report from the commandant made them even more eager to stay. We were dismissing their concerns and planning to set out again when, following one of their gazes, I looked up at the city gate right next to us. It was a charming little entrance, but that alone wouldn’t have caught a Chinese muleteer’s attention. What piqued his interest were two flimsy crates haphazardly assembled from narrow strips of wood, nailed to the gate just above the arch, each holding a human head. I had often read about such gruesome decorations on Chinese city gates, and indeed on those of our medieval ancestors; but they always seemed far away and long ago, like something from the “good old days,” which a practical modern traveler would never have the chance to see. So, to encounter them in this current year and in the bright light of everyday life around us, tacked up beside two torn posters promoting the joys and benefits of a well-known cigarette brand, was—well, at least a delightful reminder that the picturesque customs of old China haven’t completely vanished, and that even a modern traveler, if he wanders long and far enough, might still stumble across some little details linking today’s world filled with phonographs and sewing machines back to the cave-man era, something he has often envied in travelers from earlier centuries.
These two bandits, explained the soldier messenger, prompted now and then by the solicitous crowd that always gathers in China about any suggestion of a controversy, or of a foreigner, had been caught four days before in the very town where we must spend the night, if we persisted in pushing on. I suppose the crated heads were what any ladylike person would have called a “gruesome sight,” but I fear they struck me merely as interesting. In China one quickly and unconsciously gets a sense of the cheapness of human life, so that things which would ruin a night’s sleep at home are forgotten around the next 363corner. The heads each lay on one ear in the bottom of their open-work crates, half grinning down upon passers-by. Having a southern exposure, they had already greatly profited by the three or four days they had been separated from their original, evidently rather youthful, possessors to disguise their identity. They were yellow, not the mere yellow of the Chinese, who so far north are scarcely yellow at all, but of the yellow of a pile of crude sulphur, of a ripe lemon; and they were in that state in which even the most careless housewife would quickly send a cut of meat out to be buried—deep. Moreover—and all the writers on head-adorned gates I had ever read had never given me a hint of this little detail—they were swarming with flies, which seemed to consider this a particularly luscious feast.
These two bandits, the soldier messenger explained, occasionally prompted by the concerned crowd that always gathers in China around any hint of a dispute or a foreigner, had been caught four days earlier in the very town where we would have to spend the night if we kept moving forward. I guess the decapitated heads would be what any refined person would call a “gruesome sight,” but honestly, I found them just interesting. In China, you quickly and unconsciously pick up on how cheap human life can seem, so things that would keep you up at night back home are brushed off just around the next corner. The heads lay on their sides in the bottom of their open crates, half-grinning at passersby. With their southern exposure, they had already changed quite a bit in the three or four days since they had been separated from their evidently youthful owners to disguise their identity. They were a yellow—not the regular yellow of the Chinese, who up north hardly appear yellow at all—but the yellow of a pile of raw sulfur, of a ripe lemon; and in that state where even the most careless housewife would immediately send a piece of meat out to be buried—deep. Plus—and none of the writers on heads adorning gates had ever mentioned this little detail—they were swarming with flies, which seemed to treat this as a particularly delightful feast.
We yielded to the reluctance of our muleteers and turned back to a near-by inn. The sun was still high enough for a stroll through the extramural suburb, often the most crowded part of a Chinese town, then across Lüngbau itself, and around a half-circuit of its broad wall, from which we could look down into many of what in other lands would have been domestic secrets. We saw by chance, for instance, that the big sturdy man who had followed us into the inn-yard on his knees, because he had carelessly frozen his feet off one night, had a big family with whom to share the remnant of a roast leg of lamb we had given him. Somewhere among the crowded bazaars some one succeeded in telling us that bandits were worse in this region because it was fairly rich and they could live on the country; but the teeming life of Chinese streets certainly flowed on its even way in complete indifference to those heads upon the gate and to the dangers they stood for. What was still more to the point, there was time to take a leisurely view of the silky-brown terraced mountains that bounded the southern horizon, and to watch the unclouded sun sink into a fiery furnace behind them.
We gave in to our muleteers' hesitation and headed back to a nearby inn. The sun was still high enough for a walk through the outer suburb, often the busiest part of a Chinese town, then across Lüngbau itself, and around part of its wide wall, from where we could look down into many of what in other countries would have been private moments. We noticed, for example, that the big sturdy guy who had followed us into the inn's yard on his knees, because he had stupidly frozen his feet off one night, had a large family with whom to share the leftover roast leg of lamb we had given him. Somewhere in the busy bazaars, someone managed to tell us that bandits were worse in this area because it was relatively wealthy and they could survive off the land; but the bustling life of Chinese streets clearly continued on, completely indifferent to those heads on the gate and the dangers they represented. More importantly, there was time to take a relaxed look at the silky-brown terraced mountains that lined the southern horizon, and to watch the clear sun set into a fiery glow behind them.
But for that more or less forced stop at Lüngbau we should have ended the mule-litter stage of our journey late on the third day. However, that might have interfered with the major’s extraordinary success as a hunter, which was not a commonplace, vulgar matter of quantity, but of a finesse that even a Buddhist could have applauded. We had waded through a considerable mountain pass—at least this wearing down of roads into cañons sometimes appreciably shortens a climb—and had come down a steep incline to the broad flat shores of the Yellow River. Castor oil in its native state grew head-high for some distance along the deep sandy trail; but what roused our genuine interest 364was the fact that the lowland, half a mile wide, between us and the river, was swarming with magnificent wild ducks, and probably geese. The major snatched the shot-gun which some trusting sky-pilot in Peking had unwisely lent him for the journey, and strode out into a forty-acre field literally covered with the birds. Now and again a great flock of them rose and circled in a great curtain across the lower sky, but this mattered little, for there were always more where those came from; in fact, had they all risen at once, the air could scarcely have contained them.
But for that somewhat forced stop at Lüngbau, we would have finished the mule-litter part of our journey late on the third day. However, that might have interrupted the major’s remarkable success as a hunter, which was not just a basic matter of quantity, but a level of skill that even a Buddhist would have admired. We had crossed a significant mountain pass—sometimes the wear on roads creates canyons that noticeably shorten a climb—and had descended a steep slope to the wide flat banks of the Yellow River. Castor oil plants grew as tall as us for quite a way along the deep sandy trail; but what really caught our attention was the fact that the lowland, half a mile wide, between us and the river was teeming with beautiful wild ducks, and likely geese. The major grabbed the shotgun that some trusting sky-pilot in Peking had foolishly lent him for the trip, and marched into a forty-acre field practically covered with birds. Every now and then, a large flock would take off and circle dramatically across the lower sky, but that didn’t matter much since there were always more where they came from; in fact, if they had all taken off at once, the air could hardly have held them.
Nothing of course could be more reprehensible, more dastardly, in fact, than to breathe a breath of criticism upon the marksmanship of a host, as it were, who has risen so high in the profession in which marksmanship is so essential; and fortunately there is not the slightest occasion to do so. For surely the failure to make a perfect score can honestly be accounted for by the fact that the weapon used was already doing service long before our forefathers began to laugh at the idiot who fancied that some day some one would invent a “horseless carriage.” If birds will have the decency to stay where they are until the hunter can step on their tails before firing, such a contrivance leaves nothing to be desired. But wild ducks and geese, even in so rarely hunted a paradise as the Yellow River valley, are not especially cordial to strangers; one might, indeed, almost charge them with aloofness.
Nothing could be more shameful or cowardly, really, than to criticize the skills of someone who has excelled in a field where those skills are crucial; and thankfully, there’s no reason to do that. Clearly, the reason for not achieving a perfect score can be honestly explained by the fact that the weapon being used had already been in service long before our ancestors found it amusing to mock the fool who thought someone would eventually create a “car without horses.” If birds had the courtesy to stay put long enough for the hunter to step on their tails before shooting, this device would be perfect. But wild ducks and geese, even in a rarely hunted paradise like the Yellow River valley, aren’t particularly welcoming to strangers; one might even say they act rather distant.
However, the major did fire at last, both barrels at once, so that at least there would not be a second recoil to embitter his disappointment, and in spite of the fact that he had not succeeded in getting quite near enough to his quarry to make it really worth while to throw the weapon itself after them. Strangely enough, one of the birds gave every evidence of having been struck, or else of having had the scare of its life. For instead of following its myriad fellows into the now teeming air it ran erratically along the ground, with the major and Chang, and, I believe, two or three of the muleteers, possibly even the cook, in hot pursuit. The most fleet-footed of this throng—I chanced at that moment to be hovering between turning and not turning over with my litter, and hence can give no trustworthy testimony on the subject—at length laid hands upon the fugitive. If it had been struck, the shot, naturally, had not penetrated the thick feathers; perhaps it had careened off its lightly clad skull and left it a hazy view of the situation until it was for ever too late. At any rate, the major has the distinction of having captured in perfect health a magnificent specimen of the wild 365duck family, larger than any domestic one and beautiful as a pheasant—with a shot-gun!
However, the major did finally shoot, both barrels at once, so that there wouldn't be a second recoil to add to his disappointment, even though he hadn't gotten close enough to his target to make it worth throwing the weapon after them. Strangely, one of the birds showed every sign of having been hit, or at least having had the scare of its life. Instead of joining its many companions in the now crowded sky, it ran wildly along the ground, with the major, Chang, and I think two or three of the muleteers, maybe even the cook, chasing after it. The fastest among this group—I happened to be deciding whether to turn over with my litter and can't reliably recount the events—finally caught the runaway. If it had been shot, the bullet clearly hadn’t penetrated its thick feathers; perhaps it glanced off its lightly covered skull and left it with a blurred view of the situation until it was too late. In any case, the major proudly captured a stunning specimen of the wild duck family, larger than any domestic duck and as beautiful as a pheasant—with a shotgun!
One of the soldiers carried it the rest of the morning, as another had carried his hooded falcon the day before. Our entourage attempted to convince us that such birds were not fit to eat, but its superiority to a Thanksgiving turkey when it appeared before us again next day suggested that they may merely have been offering, Chinese fashion, to throw it away for us.
One of the soldiers carried it for the rest of the morning, just like another had carried his hooded falcon the day before. Our group tried to convince us that such birds weren't suitable for eating, but when it showed up again the next day, its superiority over a Thanksgiving turkey suggested that they might have just been offering, in a Chinese style, to toss it out for us.
CHAPTER XX
Heading to Sian-Fu
Early on the fourth day we climbed up out of a great road cañon to a mammoth stone archway that marks the boundary between Honan and Shensi provinces, and immediately pitched down again into another chasm of equal depth. Nor was there any improvement in the fragile soil, in the endless lines of coolies going and coming, or in the mangy beggars who squatted, loudly lamenting, in the dust here and there along the sunken road all the way into strongly walled Tungkwan. This important outpost of Shensi Province lies just over the Honan border, on the Hoang Ho, yellow river indeed here at this shallow season, across which one may see the loess hills of the province of Shansi, just then suffering acutely from drouth. The world had worn away from about the massive wall that surrounds the town, as it does from about even a mud shrine in the loess country, so that we had to climb again, rather stiffly, to reach the imposing city gate that admitted us.
Early on the fourth day, we climbed up out of a huge canyon to a massive stone archway that marks the boundary between Honan and Shensi provinces, and immediately dropped down again into another chasm of similar depth. There was no improvement in the fragile soil, the endless lines of laborers going to and from, or in the scruffy beggars who sat, loudly lamenting, in the dust here and there along the sunken road all the way into the heavily fortified Tungkwan. This important outpost of Shensi Province lies just over the Honan border, on the Hoang Ho, the yellow river, indeed here at this shallow season, across which one can see the loess hills of Shansi province, which was then suffering severely from drought. The world had worn away from around the massive wall that surrounds the town, just as it does around even a mud shrine in the loess country, so we had to climb again, rather stiffly, to reach the impressive city gate that welcomed us.
In strict duty, no doubt, the soldiers straggling about it should have demanded our passports, which the Wai-chiao-pu in Peking, whose privilege it is to look after “outside-country people,” had smeared with half an acre of red-ink-stamped characters purporting to be permission to visit five specified provinces, after which they must, officially at least, be returned to Peking for further desecration. But all the soldiers said was “Pien-tze,” and the Chinese visiting-cards we produced in answer to that laconic request were evidently all they wanted as proof of our identity. Since the major’s name chances to begin with Ph, forcing him also to pass as Mr. Fei in Chinese, we were at once taken for brothers, even in the face of decided facial proof to the contrary, and passed on our way unquestioned.
In strict duty, the soldiers wandering around should have asked for our passports, which the Wai-chiao-pu in Beijing, responsible for overseeing “foreigners,” had covered with a bunch of red ink stamps claiming to be permission to visit five specific provinces. After that, they were supposed to be sent back to Beijing for more processing. But all the soldiers said was “Pien-tze,” and the Chinese business cards we showed in response to that brief request seemed to be all they needed to verify our identity. Since the major’s name starts with Ph, making him also go by Mr. Fei in Chinese, we were immediately mistaken for brothers, despite clear evidence to the contrary, and we continued on our way without any questions.
The native pastor of the Fu-ying-tong, as the Chinese call a Protestant mission, was not in town. But in the interior of China any Caucasian passes at face value, at least until he has definitely been proved a counterfeit, and we were soon installed in several dusty, slightly furnished rooms of the rambling, temple-like compound, while 367Chang and the cook explored the kitchen with the caretaker. Had we arrived an hour earlier we might perhaps have gone on at once and reached Sian-fu that same night. For, strange as it sounded, there was a motor-bus line running more or less daily half-way across “Hidden Shensi,” from Tungkwan to the capital. But the buses started early in the morning; moreover, with all our dunnage we should probably need a special car, and there was just then none in town. If we really wished to go on next day, it would be best, they told us, if the major in his official capacity should wire the Tuchun at Sian-fu, to whom this little venture in less sluggish transportation personally belonged. Meanwhile, there was the matter of settling with our muleteers, and deciding how much cumshaw—without which no transaction in China is considered properly closed—we cared to give them. Tungkwan, too, was large and interesting enough, with a wall which clambered for a long way along the crest of a ridge high above us; but there is much sameness to most Chinese cities, and this one seemed to offer nothing unique. But at least there was something of that quality in a leisurely half-day for the ablutions, razor-wieldings, resorting, and repose of which we were in arrears.
The local pastor of the Fu-ying-tong, as the Chinese refer to a Protestant mission, wasn’t in town. However, in the interior of China, any Caucasian is generally accepted at face value, at least until proven otherwise, and we were quickly settled into a few dusty, sparsely furnished rooms of the sprawling, temple-like complex, while 367Chang and the cook checked out the kitchen with the caretaker. If we had arrived an hour earlier, we might have been able to continue on and reach Sian-fu that same night. Odd as it seemed, there was a motor-bus line that ran almost daily halfway across “Hidden Shensi,” from Tungkwan to the capital. But the buses left early in the morning; plus, with all our luggage, we would likely need a special car, and there wasn’t one available in town at that moment. If we really wanted to leave the next day, they advised us that it would be best for the major, in his official role, to wire the Tuchun in Sian-fu, who was responsible for this little venture into faster transportation. Meanwhile, we had to settle up with our muleteers and decide how much cumshaw—which is essential for closing any deal in China—we were willing to give them. Tungkwan was also large and interesting enough, with a wall that stretched for quite a distance along the ridge high above us; however, many Chinese cities feel quite similar, and this one didn’t seem to offer anything particularly special. At least we had some time for the long-overdue ablutions, shaving, relaxation, and downtime that we needed.
It did indeed require a special car for all our expedition, and even at that I was forced to banish to the running-board the chauffeur’s assistant, who habitually fills out the front seat of any public conveyance of this sort in China. His duties seemed to be to crank the car, to attend the wants of a perpetually parched radiator, to tinker with the engine whenever there was the slightest chance to do so, and in general to help the imported chauffeur to reduce the exiled vehicle from a movable to an immovable object as soon as possible. The driver had been brought all the way from Tientsin to grace Shensi’s new enterprise, having been chosen evidently because of what he did not know about automobile engines and their proper manipulation, and therefore sure to be free from prejudice. If we understood rightly, the conveyance had been carried piecemeal through the loess cañons on mule-back, and no doubt some of the parts had been assigned tasks for which they had never been trained. But it is axiomatic that nothing short of total dissolution will prevent a Ford truck from functioning, and less than two hours after this one had been requested to start we were staggering in spasmodic jerks out through the western city gate.
It definitely needed a special car for our expedition, and even then I had to send the chauffeur's assistant to the running board, since he usually crowd the front seat of any public transport like this in China. His job seemed to be cranking the car, catering to a constantly overheating radiator, fiddling with the engine whenever he got the chance, and generally helping the hired driver turn our struggling vehicle into a complete wreck as quickly as possible. The driver was brought all the way from Tientsin to assist Shensi’s new venture, apparently chosen for his lack of knowledge about car engines and how to handle them, so he wouldn't have any biases. From what we understood, the vehicle had been transported piece by piece through the loess canyons on mules, and some parts were likely given roles they were never meant for. But it’s a given that nothing short of complete breakdown will stop a Ford truck from working, and less than two hours after we asked this one to start, we were jerking our way out through the western city gate.
It is 290 li from Tungkwan to Sian-fu, almost exactly the same distance as we had made in mule-litters in more than three days; so that though we never attained breathless speed the journey felt rapid by 368comparison. Once through the massive stone archway that separated city from country, the going did not at first seem to be appreciably better than the alleged road behind us; one gasped at the temerity of any one, especially the timid Chinese, actually setting out on so ideal a route for an obstacle race with the expectation of really reaching a destination nearly a hundred miles away. But in time we came to realize that it was what the Chinese consider an unusually fine road. Loess had for the most part given way to a somewhat more cohesive soil, and there were no real cañons. When he was Tuchun of the province, the “Christian general” had built, mainly with soldier labor—the two words seem incompatible in China—this raised highway beside the old haphazard route all the way from the frontier to the capital. His intentions had been excellent; but his funds were limited, the soil available contains not a hint of stone or gravel, and public coöperation was of course wholly lacking. The general had done his best to replace this last un-Chinese asset by board signs set up at frequent intervals along the way, with a warning that the highroad was reserved for automobiles only, and that any other use of it would be severely punished. His successor had evidently tried to keep in force this unprecedented interference with Chinese freedom of individual action, and his authority was certainly considerable, as witness the fact that only here and there had the sign-boards even yet been turned into fuel. But the Tuchun could scarcely be expected to patrol the famous highway personally, and even at that he could not have kept an eye on all parts of it at once. Therefore it was much more densely thronged than the typical Chinese road down below it. Donkeys, mules, pack-cattle, rickshaws—these often run the eighty-seven miles in less than two and a half days, and make the round trip in five, at a cost to the passenger of about two American dollars—innumerable wheelbarrows, especially coolies in never ending procession, prefer to ignore the sign-boards, if indeed even the slight minority who can read them consider the prohibition as really meant. Worst of all, whole regiments of the Tuchun’s own soldiers were moving eastward, evidently in order to be more immediately available to their real commander-in-chief, Wu Pei-fu, and more than half the carts that carried these and their helter-skelter paraphernalia were themselves frankly disobeying the placarded order. These sharp-tired, two-wheeled contrivances are magnificently designed for ruining a road, particularly one built merely of earth, in the shortest possible time, and the result of the trespassing of even the few thousand we passed during the one day can readily be imagined. Then there were many spots where the Chinese genius for never repairing anything until repair is absolutely unavoidable manifested itself, and here and there some farmer had frankly chopped the highway in two to make a passage for his irrigation-ditch, a privilege as time-honored as China’s written language.
It is 290 li from Tungkwan to Sian-fu, almost exactly the same distance we covered in mule-litters over more than three days. Even though we never went at breakneck speed, the journey felt fast by comparison. Once we passed through the massive stone archway that marked the transition from city to countryside, the road didn’t seem any better than the so-called road we had just left. It was hard to believe that anyone, especially the cautious Chinese, would choose such an ideal route for an obstacle course, thinking they could actually reach a destination nearly a hundred miles away. But eventually, we came to see that it was what the Chinese call an unusually nice road. The loess that had mostly made up the previous path had given way to a soil that held together better, and there were no real canyons. When he was the Tuchun of the province, the “Christian general” had built this raised highway next to the old chaotic route using soldier labor—an odd combination in China. His intentions were good, but his funding was limited, the soil had no stone or gravel, and there was, of course, no public cooperation. The general had tried to replace this lack of contribution with wooden signs placed at regular intervals, warning that the highway was for automobiles only and that any other use would be strictly punished. His successor seemed to have attempted to maintain this unexpected restriction on Chinese freedom, and his authority was clearly significant, as shown by the fact that only a few signs had even been turned into firewood. However, the Tuchun couldn't realistically patrol the famous highway by himself, and even if he could, he wouldn't have been able to monitor all of it at once. So, it was much busier than the typical Chinese road below. Donkeys, mules, pack animals, and rickshaws often completed the eighty-seven miles in less than two and a half days, making the round trip in five for about two American dollars per passenger. Countless wheelbarrows and coolies in never-ending lines tended to ignore the signs, if the small minority who could read them took the restrictions seriously at all. To make things worse, entire regiments of the Tuchun’s own soldiers were moving east, presumably to be closer to their actual commander-in-chief, Wu Pei-fu, and more than half the carts carrying these troops and their chaotic supplies openly defied the posted order. These sharp-tired, two-wheeled carts are excellently designed to quickly ruin a road, especially one made of dirt, and it’s easy to imagine the damage caused by the few thousand we passed in just one day. Additionally, there were many spots where the Chinese knack for avoiding repairs until absolutely necessary showed up, with some farmers outright cutting the road in half to create paths for irrigation ditches—a longstanding tradition as old as China's written language.

An old tablet in the compound of the chief mosque at Sian-fu, purely Chinese in form, except that the base has lost its likeness to a turtle and the writing is in Arabic
An old tablet in the courtyard of the main mosque in Sian-fu, completely Chinese in style, except that the base has lost its resemblance to a turtle and the text is in Arabic.

This famous old portrait of Confucius, cut on black stone, in Sian-fu, is said to be the most authentic one in existence
This famous old portrait of Confucius, carved on black stone, in Sian-fu, is said to be the most genuine one in existence.

A large town of cave-dwellers in the loess country, and the terraced fields which support it
A big town of cave-dwellers in the loess region, along with the terraced fields that sustain it

Samson and Delilah? This blind boy, grinding grain all day long, marches round and round his stone mill with the same high lifted feet and bobbing head of the late Caruso in the opera of that name
Samson and Delilah? This blind guy, grinding grain all day long, walks in circles around his stone mill with the same raised feet and nodding head as the late Caruso in the opera of that name.
369There was a certain satisfaction in seeing Nemesis, in the form of our staggering, stuttering truck and the regular bus we sometimes passed, sometimes dropped behind, overtake these lawbreakers whom neither authority nor public opinion was able to curb. There are few automobiles in Shensi Province, probably never more than ten, and few of the throng along even its most nearly modern road are in a frame of mind to meet one without what the “movie” world calls “registering astonishment.” Most of them register a very exaggerated form of it, which not only affects all the muscles of the body but often manifests itself even in their domestic animals. With their creaking wheelbarrows and a heavy head wind to hamper their hearing, many permitted us almost to step on their heels before they showed any inclination to give us the right of way; but this selfish attitude was more than offset by the alacrity with which they did so when once their minds were made up. At times the road immediately ahead was so crowded with coolies and mule-drivers fleeing wild-eyed at cross-purposes that we were forced to pause and even to halt until the atmosphere had cleared itself sufficiently to make out the ruts again. The conventional line of action was to abandon wheelbarrow, animals, or pole-slung burdens at once and to go, quite irrespective of destination. The road being from six to ten feet above the surrounding country, barely wide enough in most places for one car to run comfortably, with sheer sides and often a deep trench on either hand, the punishment which overtook many of the trespassers almost fitted the crime.
369There was a certain satisfaction in seeing justice served, represented by our clumsy, sputtering truck and the regular bus we sometimes passed or fell behind, as they overtook those lawbreakers whom neither authority nor public opinion could control. There are very few cars in Shensi Province, probably no more than ten at any time, and most of the crowd along even its most modern road reacts with what the “movie” world calls “registering astonishment” when they see one. Many respond with an exaggerated display of shock that not only involves all the muscles of their bodies but often shows up in their pets as well. With their creaking wheelbarrows and a strong headwind that interferes with their hearing, many people let us nearly step on their heels before they even think about giving us the right of way; however, this selfish attitude was more than balanced out by how quickly they moved aside once they decided to. Sometimes the road ahead was so packed with coolies and mule drivers running around in a panic that we had to stop and wait until things cleared up enough for us to see the ruts again. The usual reaction was to drop whatever they were carrying—wheelbarrows, animals, or large burdens—and just take off, no matter where they were headed. With the road raised six to ten feet above the surrounding land, barely wide enough in most places for one car to fit, and with steep sides and often deep ditches on either side, the consequences for many of the trespassers fittingly matched their actions.
The coolies invariably grinned broadly or laughed aloud at their own discomfiture, with that quick and genuine sense of humor which transforms their rude, comfortless lives into a kind of perpetual game and makes them, for all their many less agreeable qualities, almost lovable. The few travelers of the haughtier classes, however, strove to preserve the dignified deportment due their high standing, even in the face of this ridiculous contrivance of inhuman speed from the barbarous outside world. But they did not always succeed in upholding all the precepts of Confucius. Among scores, probably hundreds, who performed extraordinary feats of agility for our beguilement during that day, the prize should be awarded to a man we passed less than two hours out of Tungkwan. He was unusually well dressed, as if of the wealthier 370merchant class, and was also bound westward, seated high above his stout mule on the pile of bedding and baggage in cloth saddle-bags which the well-to-do Chinese long-distance traveler carries between himself and his saddle. The mule under him was jogging comfortably along on the edge of his own side of the road—which in most of China is the left—though not on his own road, leaving us room to pass without more than the hazard to which the brink-loving chauffeur habitually put us. The animal showed every evidence of self-control and the ability to handle the situation without mishap, but he reckoned without his merely human master. We were perhaps ten yards behind them when the man’s ears and brain coördinated and he looked around. His first impulse was evidently to snatch the reins and attempt to better the already perfect behavior of his mount, but the un-Confucian speed with which we were lessening the already slight distance between us confirmed him in the impression that it would be safer to dismount with all seemly haste and leave the animal to its own fate. Without losing an iota of his poise or dignity, or even his position for that matter, the haughty gentleman calmly slipped off his high seat on the ostensibly safe side, still in the right-angled attitude of a sitting person—and admirably maintained that pose until he disappeared, seat first, into a cross between a swamp and a lake which unfortunately bordered the road at that particular place. The chauffeur and I had the exclusive benefit of this portion of the performance; the rest was reserved for those bouncing on our baggage in the truck itself. When the major first became aware of the existence of the haughty trespasser, it was in the form of a mere head, topped by a dripping Chinese skull-cap, protruding from the body of water alongside, and his last view of him as he receded into the horizon was of a water-gushing figure clinging to the edge of the road and shaking his open hand after the disappearing truck in the gesture which the Chinese substitute for shaking the fist, while the mule stood just where he had been abandoned, patiently awaiting the good will of his temperamental master.
The laborers always smiled broadly or laughed at their own misfortunes, showing that quick and genuine sense of humor that turns their harsh, uncomfortable lives into a sort of ongoing game and makes them, despite their many less endearing traits, almost lovable. Meanwhile, a few travelers from the more privileged classes tried to maintain the dignified conduct expected of their status, even in front of this absurd machine exhibiting inhuman speed from the uncivilized outside world. However, they didn’t always manage to uphold all of Confucius's teachings. Among the many, perhaps hundreds, who displayed remarkable agility for our entertainment that day, the top prize should go to a man we passed less than two hours out of Tungkwan. He was unusually well-dressed, suggesting he belonged to the wealthier merchant class, and was headed west as well, perched high above his sturdy mule on a stack of bedding and baggage in cloth saddle-bags that affluent Chinese long-distance travelers typically carry between themselves and their saddles. The mule was trotting comfortably along the left side of the road, which is the norm in most of China, although not on its own designated path, leaving us space to pass with only the usual risks posed by the edge-loving driver. The animal showed clear signs of self-control and the capability to manage the situation without problems, but he underestimated his only human master. We were maybe ten yards behind them when the man’s ears and brain connected and he turned around. His first instinct was clearly to grab the reins and try to improve his mount's already perfect behavior, but the un-Confucian speed at which we were closing the already narrow gap made him think it would be safer to quickly dismount and let the animal manage on its own. Without losing an ounce of his composure or dignity, or even his position for that matter, the arrogant gentleman calmly slid off his elevated seat on the seemingly secure side, still maintaining a right-angled sitting posture—and kept that pose until he vanished, backside first, into a mix of a swamp and a lake that regrettably bordered the road at that spot. The driver and I witnessed this part of the show exclusively; the rest was left for the bumps on our luggage in the truck. When the major first noticed the proud interloper, it was just a head, topped by a dripping Chinese skull-cap, sticking out from the water beside the road, and his last sight of him as he faded into the distance was of a water-soaked figure holding onto the edge of the road and shaking his open hand after the receding truck in the gesture that the Chinese use instead of shaking their fist, while the mule waited patiently where it had been abandoned, hoping for the goodwill of its temperamental master.
With the end of October it had turned distinctly colder, which was fortunate; for the heat of Honan would have made the exertions often required of us much less of a pastime than they were. Though it had been smilingly new when it reached the province three months before, our poor old truck resembled some maltreated, ill fed donkey which even its heartless Chinese owner must soon turn out to die, yet which faithfully toiled on to the very best of its ability. So long as it hobbled 371along beneath him, the alleged chauffeur had not a worry in the world; but whenever the slightest hill or sand a bit deeper than usual brought us to a halt he was as helpless as a Hottentot with an airplane. Having roared the engine almost out from under its hood, as the only antidote suggesting itself to him, he sat supinely back in his seat, at the end of his resources, and waited for some one else to do something about it. Luckily there are always plenty of coolies within call on any important route in China; but their natural timidity increased in the presence of the strange snorting monster that most of them had only seen hastily from a distance, and it required the force of example to get them to approach and exert themselves. Thus it came about that, though we had paid rather generously for the transporting of our expedition from the boundary to the capital of the province, we furnished the motive-power ourselves for a considerable fraction of the journey.
As October came to a close, it definitely got colder, which was a good thing; the heat of Honan would have made the efforts often required of us a lot less enjoyable. Although it had started off in good condition three months earlier, our poor old truck looked like a mistreated, underfed donkey that even its uncaring Chinese owner would soon abandon, yet it still worked as hard as it could. As long as it managed to limp along, the so-called chauffeur was completely relaxed; but whenever a slight hill or a bit deeper sand stopped us, he was as helpless as someone totally out of their depth. After revving the engine almost to the breaking point, which was his only idea for a solution, he slumped back in his seat, out of ideas, and waited for someone else to fix the issue. Fortunately, there are always plenty of coolies available along major routes in China; but their natural shyness made them hesitant in front of the strange, noisy machine most of them had only seen from afar, so it took someone showing them what to do to get them motivated. As a result, even though we had paid quite a bit to transport our expedition from the border to the provincial capital, we ended up providing the power for a significant part of the journey ourselves.
For one short distance there were a few rocks and trees; but we were soon in swirling loess again, dust so thick that it covered our faces as with a white mask. Now and again we passed a high-walled town, usually through the inevitable extramural suburb, a long line of ramshackle mud huts, with men crowded together under the thatch awnings, eating all manner of strange and unsavory-looking native dishes. Even in the rare cases when we entered the city itself there was nothing much more imposing. All morning long Hwa-shan, second only to Tai-shan among the five sacred mountains of China, walled off the southern horizon with its series of jagged ranges, shaped not unlike a mammoth sleeping elephant, their sunless northern slopes like a great perpendicular wall of beautiful blue-gray color, topped by a wonderfully fantastic sky-line. About 2200 B.C. an early emperor of what was China in those days, with this region as a nucleus, used to go to Hwa-shan to offer sacrifices and to give audiences to his subjects, and the range has been sacred in Chinese eyes ever since.
For a short stretch, there were a few rocks and trees; but we soon found ourselves back in swirling loess, with dust so thick it coated our faces like a white mask. Occasionally, we passed a high-walled town, usually through the predictable surrounding suburb, a long line of rundown mud huts, where men gathered under thatched awnings, eating all sorts of strange and unappetizing local dishes. Even in the rare moments when we entered the city itself, there was little that was more impressive. All morning long, Hwa-shan, second only to Tai-shan among the five sacred mountains of China, dominated the southern horizon with its series of jagged peaks, resembling a massive, sleeping elephant, with its shadowy northern slopes forming a tall, beautiful blue-gray wall, topped by an incredibly striking skyline. Around 2200 BCE, an early emperor of what was then China, with this region as its center, would travel to Hwa-shan to offer sacrifices and hold audiences with his subjects, and the mountain range has held a sacred status in Chinese culture ever since.
One might have fancied that a world war was on again, so often were we held up by endless east-bound trains of soldiers, most of them lounging in straw-roofed carts of two wheels, red banners with white characters flying. It was noticeable that no one but the soldiers had horses, of which most of China has been drained by her swarming, autonomous militarists. Companies, even battalions, were busily drilling here and there; two or three times we passed large military camps in tents of wigwam shape, with a modernity about them that looked incongruous against such backgrounds as a great medieval, anachronistic city wall blackened by the centuries. Twice we passed mule-carts 372laboring east or westward with the mails; all day long a distorted line of telegraph-poles bearing a sagging wire or two stretched haphazard into the distance.
One might have thought that a world war was happening again, since we were frequently delayed by endless eastbound trains full of soldiers, most of them lounging in two-wheeled carts with straw roofs, red banners with white characters flying. It was striking that only the soldiers had horses, as most of China had been drained of them by the numerous, independent militarists. Companies, even battalions, were actively training here and there; we passed by large military camps set up in tent-like structures that had a modern feel which looked out of place against the backdrop of a massive medieval city wall blackened over the centuries. Twice we saw mule carts heading east or west with the mail; all day long, a crooked line of telegraph poles bearing sagging wires stretched unevenly into the distance. 372
The country grew a bit more rolling, with even less suggestion of loess, as we neared Sian-fu. For miles the way was lined with countless graves, ranging from dilapidated little cones of mud to immense mounds. Bygone glories lay all over the landscape, monument upon turtle-borne monument, so much more important from the Chinese point of view than passable roads. At length the great east gate of Shensi’s capital rose above the horizon, like some huge isolated apartment-house, and just as the last daylight of October flickered out we roared our jerky way up its broad main street to our destination.
The countryside became a bit more hilly, with even fewer signs of loess, as we approached Sian-fu. For miles, the route was lined with countless graves, from crumbling little mud mounds to massive burial sites. Remnants of the past sprawled across the landscape, monument after monument on turtle-shaped bases, far more significant from the Chinese perspective than usable roads. Eventually, the grand east gate of Shensi’s capital appeared on the horizon, like a giant, isolated apartment building, and just as the last light of October faded away, we bumped our way up its wide main street toward our destination.
To say that I was disappointed in Sian-fu would be somewhat overstating the case. But as nearly as I can recall the preconceived picture, always so swiftly melting away in the glaring sunshine of reality, I expected something more “wild and woolly,” something a bit less like an abridged edition of Peking. Surely the city that was for centuries the chief Manchu stronghold of the west, almost their second capital, which had welcomed the cantankerous old dowager fleeing before the justifiable wrath of the Western world, which had seen such cruel and unnecessary bloodshed during the birth of the republic, which had so often been the outpost on the edge of a great Mohammedan rebellion, might at least have had some faint thrill, some little hint of hidden danger, left to cheer up the jaded wanderer. Instead, there was the same flat, placid city partly within and partly without a mighty stone wall, swarming with the harmless pullulations of petty traders, cheerfully enduring all the time-honored discomforts of China, quite like those which lie scattered like unto the sands of the sea in number over all the vast land that so long gave Peking its undivided allegiance.
To say I was disappointed in Sian-fu would be a bit of an exaggeration. But as I try to remember my initial expectations, which always seem to disappear in the bright light of reality, I was hoping for something more “wild and woolly,” something less like a shorter version of Peking. Surely, the city that was for centuries the main Manchu stronghold of the west, almost their second capital, which had taken in the feisty old dowager fleeing from the justified anger of the Western world, which had witnessed such brutal and unnecessary bloodshed during the republic's formation, which had often been the front line against a major Muslim uprising, might at least have had some hint of excitement, some trace of hidden danger, to lift the spirits of the weary traveler. Instead, it was the same dull, calm city, partially inside and partially outside a huge stone wall, bustling with the harmless activities of small traders, cheerfully enduring all the age-old discomforts of China, much like those found scattered like the grains of sand over the vast land that once gave Peking its unwavering loyalty.
One stepped out of the big post-office compound where most English-speaking foreigners find hospitality, upon that surprisingly broad main street, to find it paved with something that has long since lost the smoothness essential to comfortable rickshaw riding, and lined for much of its length with houses unusual in northern China, being of two stories. Along this one may come upon wood-turners quite like those of Damascus in their methods—a little shallow, frontless shop, a kind of Indian bow with a loose string for lathe, a sometimes toe-supported chisel. Perhaps a householder would find more interesting the long rows of wheelbarrows, filled with huge chunks of that splendid anthracite 373so abundant and so cheap in northwestern China, backed up against the curb and patiently awaiting purchasers. But at the big bell-tower marking the center of the city this broad street contracts to squeeze its way through the resounding, dungeon-like arch, and never again regains its lost breath. Here the paving is of big flagstones, worn so convex that riding is not merely uncomfortable but well nigh impossible, except to those who are inured by generations of such experiences, or to whom the loss of “face” would be fatal. Others, at least new-comers, may rather welcome this unspoken invitation to dismount and stroll. For though there may be nothing in it not to be seen in a hundred other places in China, “sights” are as compact in this busiest street of Sian-fu as if they had purposely been gathered together here as into a museum.
One stepped out of the large post office area, where most English-speaking foreigners find hospitality, onto that surprisingly wide main street, which is paved with something that has long lost the smoothness needed for comfortable rickshaw rides. Lined along much of its length are houses that are unusual for northern China, being two stories tall. Here, you might come across wood-turners similar to those in Damascus, working in a small, shallow, frontless shop with a type of Indian bow and a loose string for a lathe, sometimes using a toe-supported chisel. Perhaps a local resident would find the long rows of wheelbarrows filled with huge pieces of that excellent anthracite, so plentiful and affordable in northwestern China, more interesting as they sit against the curb, patiently waiting for buyers. However, at the large bell tower marking the heart of the city, this wide street narrows as it squeezes through the echoing, dungeon-like arch and never regains its previous width. Here, the pavement consists of large flagstones, worn so convex that riding becomes not just uncomfortable but nearly impossible, except for those who are used to such conditions or whose loss of “face” would be disastrous. Others, especially newcomers, might actually appreciate this unspoken invitation to get off and walk. For while there may be nothing here that can't be found in a hundred other places in China, the “sights” are as densely packed in this busiest street of Sian-fu as if they had been intentionally gathered together like a museum.
This main thoroughfare, and the one crossing it at right angles beneath the bell-tower, cut the Shensi capital into its definite quarters. The one on the right hand, as one comes in from the east, is, or rather was, the Manchu city, given over now largely to great open spaces; for here hundreds of the then ruling class jumped into wells or otherwise violently did away with themselves, or were violently done away with, to a number popularly estimated at more than five thousand, when China last threw off an alien yoke and announced itself a republic. Mere mud walls, with the brick or stone facings gone to serve in some other capacity, mark most of the compounds of what were perhaps for centuries Manchu palaces. Of the palaces themselves there are few traces; dust and bare earth are much more in evidence, though trees have survived to an extent almost suggestive of Peking. Beyond this, filling the northwest quarter, is the Mohammedan section, much more crowded and with few open spaces—with none, perhaps, except they be public or private courtyards. There are towns in western China where Moslems must live outside the walls; but Sian-fu has been more charitable toward her unabsorbable minority, and even during the great rebellion they retained their intramural quarter, suffering little more than constant surveillance, and no doubt occasional reviling. Whether or not they would be driven back into it again if the worshipers of Allah chose to live in some other part of town matters not, for custom is as strong a bond with them as with their fellow-Chinese, and whatever is Moslem about Sian-fu will be found in this quarter, at least when bedtime comes. Here are all the mosques; here are women who have scarcely stepped outside their compounds in a generation, not even with covered faces; from here set forth each morning the water-carriers, 374the muleteers, the common porters who profess the faith of Medina. Outwardly the stroller through this quarter may find it scarcely at all different from that Chinese half of the city which lies to the south of its main thoroughfare. He may note that the skullcaps of men and boys are more likely to be white than black, that he sees only the most poverty-stricken class of women, and not many of those, that many of the passers-by have liquid black eyes and a very trifle more self-assertion, a slightly less lamb-like expression than the common run of Chinese. Possibly it will occur to him, too, that more of the little mutton-shop restaurants wide-opening on the pulsating main street are on the north side of it, and that the men who tend and patronize them also favor white skullcaps and have something intangibly redolent of the Near East in features and manners. But his eye is likely to be caught by more conspicuous things along the stone-hard thoroughfare,—big whitish loaves of bread nearly two feet in diameter and only two or three inches thick, the splashes of color of myriad heaps of ripe persimmons, an occasional woman with natural feet, relics not of Mohammedan but of Manchu custom. There live half a million people within the city walls and as many more in the environs, say unofficial guessers, and about one in ten of these are Moslems and a bare two thousand Manchus, the latter now mainly servants and recognizable to the others by their Peking dialect and the somewhat different dress of the women.
This main road, along with the one crossing it at a right angle under the bell tower, divides the Shensi capital into distinct neighborhoods. The area on the right, as you enter from the east, used to be the Manchu city, which now consists mostly of large open spaces. Here, hundreds of the ruling class at the time either jumped into wells or were violently killed, with popular estimates suggesting over five thousand casualties when China finally freed itself from foreign rule and declared itself a republic. Most of what were likely Manchu palaces are now just mud walls, with the brick or stone facings repurposed elsewhere. Very few traces of the palaces remain; dust and bare earth dominate, although some trees have survived, reminiscent of Peking. Further filling the northwest section is the Muslim area, which is much more crowded and has fewer open spaces—perhaps only public or private courtyards. In some western Chinese towns, Muslims are forced to live outside the walls, but Sian-fu has been more accommodating to this minority. Even during the major rebellion, they kept their place in the city, enduring little more than constant surveillance and, no doubt, occasional disparagement. Whether they would be pushed back into their quarter if those who follow Allah chose to settle elsewhere in the city is irrelevant; tradition binds them just as strongly as it does their fellow Chinese, and whatever is Muslim about Sian-fu is found in this area, especially at night. Here are all the mosques; here are women who haven’t left their homes in a generation, not even to cover their faces; from here set out each morning the water-carriers, muleteers, and porters who practice the faith of Medina. To an outsider strolling through this neighborhood, it may seem hardly different from the Chinese part of the city south of the main road. They might notice that men and boys often wear white skullcaps instead of black, that only the poorest women are visible, and even then, not many; many of the people passing by have dark, expressive eyes and a bit more confidence, with slightly less meek expressions than the average Chinese. They might also realize that more of the small mutton restaurants lining the bustling main street are on the north side, and that the men who run and frequent them typically wear white skullcaps and have traits and mannerisms hinting at the Near East. However, their attention is likely to be drawn to more noticeable things along the hard stone street—big, whitish loaves of bread nearly two feet wide and only a couple of inches thick, splashes of color from numerous piles of ripe persimmons, and the occasional woman with natural feet, a remnant not of Muslim but of Manchu tradition. According to unofficial estimates, about half a million people live within the city walls, with another half million in the surrounding areas, and about one in ten of these are Muslims, with only around two thousand Manchus left, who are mostly servants and identifiable to others by their Peking dialect and the slightly different attire of the women.
I picked up a man of standing in the Moslem faith one morning and strolled out to the chief mosque. Outwardly there was nothing to distinguish it from any Chinese compound, enclosing perhaps a temple, to judge by the typical tile roofs and the tree-tops rising above it. Indeed, the courtyard itself, beautiful with its old trees and buildings, filled with the twitter of birds, which seemed to make it a kind of sanctuary, restful and peace-loving in atmosphere, would not easily have been recognized as containing anything but the usual promiscuous mixture of the Buddhist, Taoist, and Confucian beliefs. There were the same wooden tablets bearing two or three big Chinese characters leaning out from under the eaves; the same curious little figures adorned the upturned gables; there had been a genuinely Chinese indifference about cleaning up after the birds. But closer inspection brought out the underlying Mohammedanism. Not far from the entrance stood a big stone tablet, purely Chinese in form, even to the top-heavy dragon carvings; but the text that covered it was not Chinese but Arabic. Here 375and there were other stone-cut bits of that same tongue; “Yalabi” the not inhospitable group that had gathered about me called it, though one or two murmured something sounding like “Toorkee.” The beautiful little three-story tower of pillar-borne roofs turned out to be the minaret from which a Chinese muezzin singsongs the faithful to prayer. Certainly it was leaving Chinese custom behind to be required, however courteously, to leave my shoes at the door of the mosque itself before I could step through the cloth-hung opening of a building which up to that moment might have been anywhere in China. But inside we had at last left China entirely behind. Not a suggestion was to be seen of those myriad fantastic and demoniacal figures which clutter up the interior of Chinese temples; the Koran’s prohibition of graven images had been obeyed to the letter, and the final sanctuary itself, where the men of Sian-fu’s northwest quarter gather each Friday to turn their faces westward toward Mecca and pray, was as severely beautiful in its Arabic style as if it had been directly copied from the Alhambra.
I picked up a man of significance in the Muslim faith one morning and walked out to the main mosque. On the surface, it looked just like any Chinese compound, possibly housing a temple, judging by the typical tiled roofs and the treetops rising above it. In fact, the courtyard itself, beautiful with its old trees and buildings, filled with the chirping of birds, which gave it a kind of sanctuary vibe, restful and peaceful, wouldn’t easily have been recognized as anything other than the usual mix of Buddhist, Taoist, and Confucian beliefs. There were the same wooden tablets with a few large Chinese characters peeking out from under the eaves; the same quirky little figures decorated the upturned gables; and there was a genuine Chinese indifference to cleaning up after the birds. But a closer look revealed the underlying Islam. Not far from the entrance stood a large stone tablet, purely Chinese in design, even with the weighty dragon carvings; but the text on it was Arabic, not Chinese. Here and there were other stone-cut pieces in that same language; “Yalabi,” the not unfriendly group that had gathered around me called it, though one or two murmured something that sounded like “Toorkee.” The lovely little three-story tower with roof-supporting pillars turned out to be the minaret from which a Chinese muezzin calls the faithful to prayer. It was certainly different from Chinese custom to be required, however politely, to leave my shoes at the mosque door before I could step through the cloth-hung entrance of a building that until that moment could have been anywhere in China. But inside, we had finally left China completely behind. There wasn't a hint of those countless fantastic and demonic figures that clutter up the interiors of Chinese temples; the Koran’s prohibition on graven images had been strictly followed, and the final sanctuary itself, where the men of Sian-fu’s northwest quarter gather each Friday to turn their faces westward toward Mecca and pray, was as simply beautiful in its Arabic style as if it had been directly copied from the Alhambra.
The Islamites of China, or at least of Sian-fu, seem to have lost that fierce inhospitality toward the unbeliever which makes it impossible for those not of the faith even to enter many a famous mosque farther west. Centuries of dwelling among them has given even the intolerant Mussulmans much of the tolerance, or at least of the easy-going, almost indifferent attitude, toward their religious paraphernalia, which is so characteristic of the Chinese. There was no objection, so long as I removed my shoes, to my wandering at will in every part of the mosque, to stepping within the niche in the west wall which takes on much of the sanctity of Mecca, not even to my photographing it. The Chinese Moslems, indeed, seem never to have heard of the Prophet’s implied injunction against permitting one’s likeness to be transferred to paper; any refusal to stand before my kodak among the group that trailed me about the compound was probably due to mere Chinese superstitions, coupled with that dread of giving their fellow-men the faintest opening for ridicule which is one of the strongest traits in the Chinese character. For these fellows were essentially Chinese, for all their religion, their swarthier complexions and more Semitic noses; even the few among them whose features would not have been conspicuous in a throng of Turks or Arabs had all the little mannerisms, and to all appearances the identical point of view, except in their alien faith, of their fellow-countrymen.
The Muslims of China, or at least in Xi'an, seem to have moved past the intense unwelcomeness towards non-believers that makes it hard for those outside the faith to even enter many famous mosques further west. Centuries of living together has made even the strict Muslims adopt some of the tolerance, or at least the easy-going, almost indifferent attitude towards their religious practices that is typical of the Chinese. There were no objections, as long as I took off my shoes, to my wandering freely in every part of the mosque, even stepping into the niche in the west wall that holds much of the sanctity of Mecca, not to mention taking pictures of it. The Chinese Muslims, in fact, seemed to have never heard of the Prophet’s implied warning against allowing one's likeness to be captured on paper; any reluctance to pose for my camera among the group that followed me around the courtyard was likely just due to typical Chinese superstitions and that strong fear of giving others the slightest chance to mock them, which is a key trait in Chinese culture. These individuals were essentially Chinese, despite their religion, darker skin, and more Semitic noses; even the few among them whose features wouldn’t stand out in a crowd of Turks or Arabs had all the little mannerisms, and seemingly the same perspective, except for their different faith, as their fellow countrymen.
Though there is no intermarriage between the Chinese Mohammedans and their neighbors, the blood that runs in their veins is largely 376the same. When the militant faith of Islam swept in upon China from the west, at the time when it was spreading in all directions, and was halted in our own only by the activity of Charles Martel in France, the surest way of escaping the sword was to embrace the new faith; and no one moves more quickly under the inspiration of fear than the Chinese. Then, too, the conquerors needed wives, or at least women, and took them from among the conquered. Perhaps its greatest gains were during the inflow of trade following the victories of Kublai Khan. For a long time it was, and probably still is, the custom to adopt Chinese children into Mohammedan homes. Thus the Turkish or Arabic features of the invaders have been greatly modified, and even the few who have a trace of these left seem to be greatly outnumbered by the purely Chinese descendants of those who embraced the faith under compulsion, so that even within a mosque compound it is often only by inference, or the catching of some slight detail of custom or costume, that the stranger can recognize a “Hwei-Hwei.” Foreigners resident where the Mohammedans are numerous claim to be able to tell one at sight, if only by a faintly more stiff-necked attitude toward the rest of the world, a drawing of the line, beyond which he refuses to be imposed upon, just a trifle closer to his own rights than do his pacific Chinese fellows. Step into a temple at any time, and you will receive nothing but profound courtesies from the Chinese, however unwelcome you may be at that moment, say these experienced Westerners; enter a mosque when a service is in progress, however, and while the customary outward politenesses may not be lacking, the atmosphere will be charged with something that says as distinctly as a placard, “This is not the time to call.” I had a little hint of this myself just before taking my departure. A high dignitary, what we might call a bishop, wearing a strange blue costume and supported as he tottered along by two lesser officials, issued from an inner court on his way to perform some ceremony in a private family. My request to photograph him was declined, not discourteously, but very definitely and very promptly, as if, being a hadji who had made the pilgrimage to Mecca, he was well aware of the ban which the Prophet put on the making of likenesses, whatever might be the general ignorance of it about him; and something gave me the feeling that if I had attempted to act contrary to his wishes the smiling group of his coreligionists about me would have found some unviolent Chinese way of preventing me.
Though there is no intermarriage between the Chinese Muslims and their neighbors, they share a lot of the same blood. When the aggressive faith of Islam came into China from the west, at a time when it was spreading everywhere, it was only stopped in our own lands by Charles Martel’s efforts in France. The easiest way to escape violence was to adopt the new faith; and no one moves more quickly out of fear than the Chinese. The conquerors also needed wives, or at least women, which they took from those they conquered. One of the biggest changes happened during the influx of trade after Kublai Khan's victories. For a long time, and likely still today, it has been customary to adopt Chinese children into Muslim families. As a result, the Turkish or Arabic features of the invaders have been significantly blended, and even those who still show a hint of these features are greatly outnumbered by the purely Chinese descendants of those who converted under pressure. So much so that even within a mosque compound, it’s often only through subtle cues of custom or attire that an outsider can identify a “Hwei-Hwei.” Foreigners living where there are many Muslims claim they can recognize one immediately, usually by a slightly more rigid attitude towards the world, drawing a line beyond which they refuse to be pushed, just a bit more protective of their rights compared to their peaceful Chinese counterparts. Enter a temple at any time, and you will be met with nothing but deep courtesy from the Chinese, no matter how unwelcome you might feel at that moment, say these experienced Westerners; however, step into a mosque during a service, and while the usual pleasantries might be present, the atmosphere is thick with an unspoken message that shouts, “This is not the time for a visit.” I got a small taste of this myself right before I left. A high-ranking official, what we might call a bishop, dressed in a strange blue outfit and assisted by two minor officials, came out from an inner court on his way to perform a ceremony for a private family. My request to take his photo was declined, not rudely, but very clearly and quickly, as if he, being a hadji who had completed the pilgrimage to Mecca, was fully aware of the prohibition the Prophet imposed on creating images, regardless of the general ignorance around him; and I had the feeling that if I had tried to go against his wishes, the smiling group of his fellow Muslims with me would have found some peaceful Chinese way to stop me.
The non-believers among whom they live have, of course, other terms than “Hwei-Hwei” for the Moslem minority, some of them so 377far from complimentary as to be out of usage in any but the lowest society. One of the less unkindly ones is “Pu-chih-jew-roe-ren,” the don’t-eat-meat people. The Mohammedans have a name or two for themselves and their religion so respectful and self-complacent that their fellows decline to use them, so that the middle ground of “Hwei-Hwei” is the one on which the two sections of the community commonly meet. This term means something roughly corresponding to “the associated people,” the single character for hwei meaning, approximately, “association.” The Y. M. C. A. which functioned—under a boyhood friend of the major, from Maine, it turned out—in the quarter of Sian-fu opposite to that of the mosques was known as the “Ching-Nien-Hwei,” which is quite the same as our own abbreviation, except that our third letter, with all that it stands for, is left out. This does not of course mean that the religious element is lacking in the organization as it exists in Sian-fu—quite the contrary seemed to be the case; but to stroll into the purely Chinese compound, with its Chinese buildings, its board placards covered with only Chinese characters, was also not to realize at once that one had entered the precincts of another alien religion. The “Hwei-Hwei” establishments looked outwardly pure Chinese partly because of the fear of persecution in the past; the “Ching-Nien-Hwei,” I believe I am safe in saying, did so mainly because it had been forced to house itself in such quarters as it found attainable.
The non-believers among whom they live have, of course, other names besides “Hwei-Hwei” for the Muslim minority, some of which are so derogatory that they are only used in the lowest social circles. One of the less offensive names is “Pu-chih-jew-roe-ren,” which means “the don’t-eat-meat people.” The Muslims have a couple of respectful names for themselves and their faith that are so self-satisfied that others in the community avoid using them, making “Hwei-Hwei” the common ground between the two groups. This term means something like “the associated people,” with the single character for hwei translating roughly to “association.” The Y. M. C. A., which operated—under a childhood friend of the major from Maine—was located in a part of Sian-fu opposite the mosques and was referred to as the “Ching-Nien-Hwei.” This is similar to our own abbreviation, except that our third letter, along with its meaning, is omitted. This doesn’t mean that the religious aspect is absent from the organization as it exists in Sian-fu—quite the opposite seemed to be true; however, stepping into the purely Chinese compound, with its Chinese architecture and signs covered only in Chinese characters, didn’t immediately convey that you had entered the domain of another foreign religion. The “Hwei-Hwei” establishments appeared outwardly purely Chinese partly due to past fears of persecution; the “Ching-Nien-Hwei,” I think I can safely say, looked that way mainly because it had to settle in the premises available to it.
It would, by the way, be unfair to the score of men and women, a few of them our fellow-countrymen, who are giving their best efforts to educational, medical, and, not disproportionately, I trust, to denominational matters in the several Christian missions scattered in and about the Shensi capital, not to make mention of them, even though they may not vie, in the minds of those of us from the West, in picturesqueness and local color with the mutton-sellers in the market-place. They live unmolested, even befriended now by most of the rank and file and by nearly all the higher officials, and in a comfort befitting modest human beings; but the time is not so far distant as to be by any means forgotten when they came nearly all to being martyrs to their cause. The man who stood all night to his neck in a pond, holding his baby girl in his arms while the rest of his family was murdered by the mob that circled for hours around him, is still there at his post, with a new family to certify that he still has faith in those to whom he has chosen to give his life’s work. Lest neither side forget entirely, however, there is a modern brick Memorial School in the western suburbs, with its bronze tablet in memory of the victims,—one mother, one young man, 378and six children ranging from eight to fifteen. It was no antiforeign feeling, in the accepted use of that phrase, which gave the missionaries of Sian-fu their most dreadful experience; that is, they were not attacked either as missionaries or as Westerners. The revolution that was to bring the republic had come; the hated Manchus were fair prey at last; and while some of the rougher element no doubt took full advantage of their sudden brief opportunity, there was honestly no distinction in the minds of the uneducated masses between Manchus and any other “outside-country people.”
It would be unfair to the many men and women, including some of our fellow countrymen, who are putting in their best efforts into education, healthcare, and, I hope, the religious issues within the various Christian missions scattered around the Shensi capital, not to mention them, even if they might not seem as colorful or interesting to us from the West as the mutton sellers in the market. They live peacefully, often supported by most of the general public and nearly all of the higher officials, in a comfort that suits regular people. However, it’s not long ago that many of them were nearly martyrs for their cause. The man who stood all night, up to his neck in a pond, holding his baby girl while the mob murdered the rest of his family is still there at his post, now with a new family to show he still believes in the work he has dedicated his life to. To ensure neither side forgets entirely, there’s a modern brick Memorial School in the western suburbs, with a bronze plaque honoring the victims—a mother, a young man, and six children aged eight to fifteen. The missionaries in Sian-fu didn’t suffer their most terrible experiences due to any antiforeign sentiment, as traditionally understood; they weren’t attacked as missionaries or as Westerners. The revolution that was supposed to bring about the republic had arrived, and the despised Manchus were finally vulnerable. While some of the rougher crowd undoubtedly took advantage of the brief chaos, there was genuinely no distinction in the minds of the uneducated masses between Manchus and any other "foreigners."
The temple of Confucius out near the south wall was as peaceful, as soothing a spot as could have been come upon within sound of human voices, with that aloofness from the world so befitting the philosophy of the great sage. But here, too, there was something beneath the surface not inherent in the ancient architecture or the rook-encircled tree-tops. A modern touch had been introduced; one suspected the hand, or at least the influence, of Feng Yü Hsiang, the “Christian General,” who had only lately ceased to be Tuchun of Shensi to become that of Honan. Feng’s penchant for anything, ancient or ultra-modern, which will bring the results he seeks is well known. The Confucian Hall had several walls covered with very up-to-date placards in colors, ranging all the way from illustrations of the awful depredations of the fly—it was hard to imagine the Chinese worrying about a little thing like that—to the graphically pictured assassination of Cæsar and such scenes as the Nativity; for Confucius, of course, has nothing of the intolerance conspicuous in Christianity or Mohammedanism. In another section there were portraits of many famous foreigners, Washington, Lincoln, and Franklin being the only Americans among some forty. There is surely nothing reprehensible, though something more than incongruous, in trying to make Confucius a modern teacher and his temple a place of propaganda against the merely physical ills.
The Confucius temple near the south wall was a peaceful, calming spot, one of the most serene places you could find close to human voices, with a detachment from the world that really suited the philosophy of the great sage. But there was something below the surface that didn’t come from the ancient architecture or the trees surrounded by birds. A modern touch had been added; one might suspect the influence of Feng Yü Hsiang, the “Christian General,” who had recently transitioned from being the military governor of Shensi to that of Honan. Feng’s interest in anything, whether ancient or ultra-modern, that would help him achieve his goals is well known. The Confucian Hall had several walls covered with very contemporary placards in various colors, showcasing everything from the terrible destruction caused by flies—it’s hard to imagine the Chinese worrying about something so small—to vividly illustrated scenes like the assassination of Caesar and the Nativity; after all, Confucius doesn’t embody the intolerance often found in Christianity or Islam. In another area, there were portraits of many famous foreigners, with Washington, Lincoln, and Franklin being the only Americans among about forty. There’s nothing wrong, though perhaps a bit more than just strange, about trying to present Confucius as a modern teacher and turn his temple into a place promoting awareness of purely physical issues.
So near the temple of Confucius as to be dully audible from it all day long is the famous “Forest of Monuments.” Centuries ago, you will remember, a Chinese emperor ordered all the classical books to be burned. In order that such a catastrophe should never be possible again, all the important texts in those classics, gathered together from odd volumes that had escaped the flames, or from the memories of old scholars, were carved on scores of stone monuments—hundreds, I believe one might safely say, after wandering through the several long temple-sheds or shed-temples in which they stand close together in long 379rows. There all day long, from the end of the New Year’s debauch of loafing until the New Year comes around again, stand dozens of men taking rubbings of the famous texts. The head-high monuments are covered over with big sheets of what is almost tissue-paper, and coolies and boys, perhaps not one among whom can read a single character of the many thousands about them, pound and pound with wooden mallets until copies, covered with a kind of lamp-black except where the indented characters have left them white, are ready to be added to the stock of shopkeepers near the entrance to the grounds. The consumption of these flimsy facsimiles throughout the Far East is evidently enormous, for the dullish rap-a-rap of many mallets is seldom if ever silent from sun to sun.
So close to the Confucius temple that it can be heard all day long is the famous “Forest of Monuments.” Centuries ago, as you may recall, a Chinese emperor ordered all the classical books to be burned. To prevent such a disaster from happening again, all the important texts from those classics—gathered from surviving volumes and the memories of old scholars—were carved onto numerous stone monuments—hundreds, I believe, after wandering through the several long temple-sheds where they stand closely packed in long rows. All day long, starting from the end of the New Year’s celebrations until the New Year comes around again, dozens of men are there taking rubbings of the famous texts. The tall monuments are covered with large sheets of almost tissue-paper, and coolies and boys, many of whom likely can't read a single character out of the thousands around them, pound away with wooden mallets until copies, blackened except for the white indented characters, are ready to be sold by shopkeepers near the entrance. The demand for these thin copies across the Far East is clearly enormous, as the dull sound of many mallets is almost never silent from sunrise to sunset.
Off by itself in a conspicuous spot stands the Nestorian Tablet, most famous of them all, at least to those from the Western world. For on it is carved the story of the first coming of Christianity to China, long before even the Jesuits included that land in their field of operations. To the ignorant Occidental eye it looks quite like any other turtle-borne stone carved with upright rows of intricate characters, except that above them there is cut a well defined Greek cross. The Nestorian Tablet, I believe, was not considered much of a find when it was first dug up out of a field in the neighborhood of Sian-fu; but the fame of that jet-black slab has since grown so great that the not over-distinct characters are likely to become even less so with the constant taking of rubbings.
Off by itself in a prominent spot is the Nestorian Tablet, the most famous of them all, at least to people from the Western world. It tells the story of the first arrival of Christianity in China, long before the Jesuits included that country in their missions. To the untrained Western eye, it resembles any other turtle-backed stone etched with upright rows of intricate characters, except that above them there’s a clearly defined Greek cross. The Nestorian Tablet wasn’t seen as a significant discovery when it was first unearthed in a field near Sian-fu, but its reputation has grown so much since then that the not-so-clear characters are likely to become even less discernible with all the constant rubbings being taken.
No less ebony black is the stone at the far rear of the same compound on which a few thin white lines sketch what is widely reputed to be the only authentic portrait of Confucius. The austere simplicity of the execution and the not unkindly severity of the portrayed face are at once a contrast and a rebuke to the silly gaudiness of demonology that clutters almost all Chinese temples. Then, before Sian-fu can be left behind, there are the famous stone horses, mere bas-reliefs of galloping steeds done centuries ago, yet so full of life and action as to be the despair of any living sculptor. These race low along the outdoor wall of a corridor in the local museum, and imperfectly now, for a vandal all but destroyed them. He was a Frenchman, and the love of art was so strong within him that he resolved to steal the famous horses of Sian-fu and carry them off to his native land. The big stone slabs were impossible to transport entire; the art-loving Gaul broke each of them into several pieces, of course with the connivance of bribed Chinese, and the carts bearing them were already many miles 380on their way when they were overtaken. It is such little adventures as this, justly distributed throughout China, which make it strange that “outside-country people” are so generally treated with respect by nearly all the four hundred million, and only very rarely as “foreign devils.”
No less black than ebony is the stone at the far back of the same compound, where a few thin white lines outline what is widely believed to be the only genuine portrait of Confucius. The simple execution and the somewhat stern expression of the depicted face stand in stark contrast to the ridiculous decorations of demonology that fill almost all Chinese temples. Then, before leaving Sian-fu, there are the famous stone horses—just bas-reliefs of galloping horses created centuries ago, yet so full of life and movement that they leave any modern sculptor in despair. These sculptures run low along the outdoor wall of a corridor in the local museum, though they are now damaged, as a vandal nearly destroyed them. He was a Frenchman, driven by such a passion for art that he decided to steal the famous horses of Sian-fu and take them back to his home country. The large stone slabs were too difficult to transport whole; the art-loving Frenchman broke each one into several pieces, with the help of bribed Chinese, and the carts carrying them were already many miles away when they were caught. It's small incidents like this, spread out across China, that make it surprising that “foreigners” are mostly treated with respect by nearly all four hundred million people and only rarely seen as “foreign devils.” 380
Perhaps the major would have been detected through his incognito of a man on a purely personal jaunt anyway, but it was that wire from Tungkwan concerning motor transportation that gave the game away entirely. We had barely begun to deplore with our host in Sian-fu the difficulties of filling portable zinc bath-tubs with hot water that must be purchased and carried in from the outside, when two Chinese officials called. One was merely a magistrate, but the other was high up in the “foreign office” of the province, as well as no less fluent in our tongue than in his own. He had come at once to pay his respects, to welcome us to the province, and to bring the startling information that we were expected to lodge in some yamen or palace which the Tuchun’s soldiers had spent all day in preparing in a manner befitting the American military official who was unexpectedly honoring Shensi with his presence. I was not grieved that the delicate task of declining these accommodations fell upon the major’s broad shoulders. We could not, of course, put the Tuchun to any such trouble; we were already installed in the capacious dwelling of the postal commissioner, who not only was British but had innumerable other qualifications to recommend him, who was keeping bachelor hall and was entitled to company, who was a very old friend—the major did have, I believe, a note of introduction to him—and who from time immemorial had been the accepted host of any visitor to Sian-fu whose native tongue was English and whose evolution had passed the eat-with-your-knife stage. There was no necessity of divulging such further facts as the fear that even the Tuchun’s ideas of supreme hospitality would probably include wooden-floored beds, unswept corners, and a perpetual crowding by curious and irrepressible retainers, and that civilized toilet-facilities, effective heating-arrangements, and freedom to come and go without formality were quite as sure to be lacking. The chief emissary, being versed in foreign ways, probably knew that all these thoughts were none the less existent for remaining unspoken, and accepted our declination in what seemed to be good spirit after far less than half the usual number of repetitions required by full-blooded Chinese courtesy.
Perhaps the major would have been recognized as a tourist on a personal trip anyway, but it was the message from Tungkwan about motor transportation that completely gave him away. We had just started to lament with our host in Sian-fu about the challenges of filling portable zinc bathtubs with hot water that had to be bought and carried in from outside when two Chinese officials arrived. One was just a magistrate, but the other held a high position in the province's "foreign office" and was just as fluent in our language as in his own. He had come to pay his respects, welcome us to the province, and share the surprising news that we were expected to stay in a yamen or palace that the Tuchun's soldiers had spent the entire day preparing in a way befitting an American military official who was unexpectedly visiting Shensi. I wasn't upset that the delicate task of declining this hospitality fell to the major. We couldn't, of course, put the Tuchun to any such trouble; we were already settled in the spacious residence of the postal commissioner, who was British and had many other qualifications that made him a great host. He was living alone and entitled to guests, he was a very old friend of the major—who I believe had an introduction to him—and he had historically been the accepted host for any English-speaking visitor to Sian-fu who had moved past the stage of eating with a knife. There was no need to mention concerns like the fact that even the Tuchun's ideas of supreme hospitality would likely include wooden beds, unswept corners, and constant pressure from curious attendants, along with a lack of civilized bathroom facilities, effective heating, and the freedom to come and go without formalities. The chief emissary, being familiar with foreign customs, probably understood that all these thoughts existed even if they weren’t voiced and accepted our refusal in what seemed to be good spirits after far fewer repetitions than are usually expected in full-blooded Chinese courtesy.
381But that did not prevent us from being overwhelmed with official formalities during our stay in Sian-fu. Formality is fully as sturdy and omnipresent a crone in China as in Latin America. It would have been the height of discourtesy, of course, not to make a formal call upon the Tuchun soon after our arrival; this, in the case of so distinguished a visitor as the major, a fellow in arms, had to be returned; there was old precedent for giving us an official feast, which could only properly be reciprocated by getting our host to invite the Tuchun to an elaborate luncheon; the civil governor and the corpulent head of the “foreign office” must at least be honored with a call, which we must be prepared to have retaliated; it would have been discourteous not to return the kindness of our first two callers, even though the magistrate was so low in rank that we could not remain with him more than five minutes; each group of missionaries in town expected us to dinner, or lunch, or tea, or, if worse came to worst, to breakfast; the Chamber of Commerce and other bodies of important citizens expected speeches—fortunately some engagements hopelessly conflicted—and, not to go particularly into details, there was a complete round of farewell calls that could not under any circumstances be omitted. Looking back upon it, I am amazed to realize that we spent only three full days in Sian-fu, and even at that managed to see most of its worth-while “sights”; and that we left it still in tolerably good health in spite of the fact that we accomplished as many as five incredibly heavy meals, not to call them “banquets,” in a single day.
381But that didn’t stop us from being bombarded with official formalities during our time in Sian-fu. Formality is just as rigid and everywhere in China as it is in Latin America. It would have been incredibly rude not to pay a formal visit to the Tuchun soon after we arrived; since he was a highly regarded visitor like the major, who was a comrade, we had to return the favor. There was a long-standing tradition of hosting an official feast for us, which could only be properly reciprocated by inviting the Tuchun to an elaborate luncheon; the civil governor and the hefty head of the “foreign office” at the very least needed to receive a visit, which we had to be ready to return; it would have been impolite not to respond to the kindness of our first two visitors, even though the magistrate was so low in rank that we could only spend five minutes with him; each group of missionaries in town expected us for dinner, lunch, tea, or, if it came down to it, breakfast; the Chamber of Commerce and other groups of important citizens expected speeches—luckily, some engagements clashed hopelessly—and, not to go into too much detail, there was a complete schedule of farewell visits that we couldn't skip. Looking back, I’m amazed to realize that we spent only three full days in Sian-fu and still managed to see most of its worthwhile “sights”; and we left still in reasonably good health despite having five incredibly heavy meals, not to mention “banquets,” in a single day.
This feat was made possible by the fact that Chinese feasts come at about eleven in the morning or four in the afternoon. Thus we could stagger away from either of these just in time to sit down with a deceptive smirk of pleasure at the repast prepared by some of the foreign groups with a special view to assuaging our ravenous road appetites. In anything concerned with the Tuchun at least, we were obliged to save “face” both for him and for ourselves by bumping about town in a “Peking cart” such as all Sian-fu residents of standing regard as one of their most indispensable possessions. In fact, the Tuchun sent his own for us. There were two of them, gleamingly new, but nicely graded as to caste in details invisible to us, yet as plainly publishing to the Chinese the distinction between a great foreign official like the major and a mere traveler like myself as if their blue cloth sides had been daubed with red characters. A huge, well groomed mule drew each of them; they were upholstered, padded, and cushioned not only within but on the sort of veranda where those of lower caste may sit, 382while the two wheels were magnificent examples of that universal to-hell-with-the-public attitude of China which dictates great sharp iron-toothed tires that would destroy any road in record time, yet which have absolutely no justification except swank—and perhaps the fear of skidding on wet corners during the three-mile-an-hour dashes about town.
This was possible because Chinese feasts typically happen around eleven in the morning or four in the afternoon. This timing allowed us to leave one of these meals just in time to enjoy a meal prepared by some of the foreign groups, aimed at satisfying our intense road hunger. Regarding anything involving the Tuchun, we had to maintain “face” for both him and ourselves by navigating the city in a “Peking cart,” which all respected residents of Sian-fu see as one of their essential belongings. In fact, the Tuchun sent his own for us. There were two of them, looking brand new but subtly indicating social status details that were invisible to us yet clearly broadcasting the difference between a high-ranking foreign official like the major and a mere traveler like me, as if their blue cloth sides had been painted with red characters. Each cart was pulled by a large, well-groomed mule; they were cushioned and padded not only inside but also on the section where those of lower status might sit. The two wheels were impressive examples of that typical dismissive attitude towards the public in China, showcasing sharp iron-toothed tires that could ruin any road in no time, with no real reason beyond showiness—and maybe the worry of skidding on wet corners during our three-mile-per-hour trips around town. 382
In calling upon a Chinese official one first sends one’s Chinese card over by a retainer, in order that the great man may be prepared. Within half an hour or so one may follow, presenting another card to some underling who will be found waiting where, in the case of a Tuchun, one might otherwise be casually run through with the naked bayonets which the swarms of soldiers about such a place so generously display. The underling disappears for some time, because the great man is sure to hold forth in the far interior of the flock of buildings filling his long compound, where he could be reached only with difficulty by an unauthorized visitor, even though he knew its devious passages well. In time he returns, and marching before the visitors and holding their cards above his head spread out fan fashion, names to the rear, like a hand at poker, he conducts the way. Gradually more important functionaries take up his task, until the callers are invited to seat themselves in a sort of ante-guest-room by a man who may even be of high enough rank to dare to open conversation with them. This anteroom is usually furnished with a platform built into one wall and upholstered into a divan littered with red cushions, with a somewhat raised space, or a foot-high table, in the center. Tuchuns, however, even of the far interior, have in most cases adopted a foreign style in this as in military uniforms, and one finds oneself instead in a larger and very commonplace room furnished with a long, cloth-laid table surrounded by chairs, with at most a Chinese scroll or two on the walls as the only hints of local color. But a flock of servants and orderlies, setting a little handleless cup of tea before each guest and under no circumstances permitting him to empty it, keep him reminded of his latitude and longitude. If he is of any importance, he is also furnished a cigarette—by having a single one laid on the cloth in front of him—which, if he shows any tendency to consume it, some one lights for him before he realizes it. If he is a man of extraordinarily high rank, such as a military attaché from “Mei-guo” on the other side of the earth, the principal flunky offers him a cigar. This invariably is of some sad Manila brand—the Chinese word for cigar is “Lüüsung-yen,” or “Philippine tobacco”—this time in the box, and usually a full box, 383whether in the hope that he will not be so bold as to disturb the symmetry of the precious contents or because cigar-smokers are so rare in China that the box seldom loses its pristine fullness. At length the great man himself appears from behind a blue cloth door reverently lifted by several soldiers; there is a general uprising about the table; the host and his guests each fervently shake hands with themselves and bow times innumerable, like automatons hinged only at the waist; and at a graceful gesture of the Tuchun’s hand the gathering finally subsides into the chairs and proceeds to converse on things of no importance as fluently as the guests’ command of Chinese or the ministrations of an interpreter permit. If the call is nothing more than that, it ends in the anteroom where it began. After another long series of bows the guests are accompanied to the door, and as much beyond it as befits their rank. This is one of the most delicate points of Chinese etiquette, the one on which the foreigner, at least if he is newly established in the country, is most apt to stumble. For there is an intricate gradation of ranks in society even in “republican” China, with many factors modifying each under different circumstances; and not to see one’s guest far enough is as serious a social blunder as to accompany him beyond the point to which his caste entitles him. In a Tuchun’s yamen—in theory they call such a place gung-shu, or “people’s house,” since the rise of the republic—there may be nearly a dozen doors or openings of some sort between the inner depths and the front p’ai-lou, and at each of them courtesy requires much “you first” stuff and pretended protests from the guest against his host’s going any farther, so that when the final leave-taking is far out on the threshold of the last gate, as in the case of an official representative of great America, a glance at a watch is likely to be startling when one finally does at last break away.
When visiting a Chinese official, you first send your Chinese business card over with an assistant so the important person can get ready. Within about half an hour, you can follow up, presenting another card to an aide who will be waiting where, in the case of a regional governor, you could otherwise be casually threatened by the soldiers nearby, who display their weapons openly. The aide disappears for a while because the important person is likely to be deep inside the complex of buildings in his large estate, which is hard to reach for an uninvited guest, even if they know the tricky paths well. Eventually, he returns, marching in front of the visitors while holding their cards above his head like a fan, names facing backward, similar to a poker hand. He leads the way, and gradually, more important officials take over his role until the visitors are invited to sit in a sort of waiting room by someone who might even be important enough to start a conversation with them. This waiting area usually has a platform built into one wall with a cushioned divan scattered with red cushions, and a low table in the middle. However, even regional governors, especially those from the interior, have mostly adopted a foreign style in their furnishings just like in military uniforms, so you find yourself in a larger, very ordinary room with a long table covered in a cloth and surrounded by chairs, with maybe a Chinese scroll or two on the walls as the only signs of local flair. Yet a swarm of servants brings each guest a little handleless cup of tea and ensures they can’t finish it, keeping them aware of their status. If the guest is important, they also get a cigarette—just one placed on the cloth in front of them—which, if they show any intent to smoke, someone lights for them before they even notice. If the guest is of exceptionally high rank, like a military attaché from “America” far across the ocean, the main servant offers a cigar. This is usually a poor quality Manila type—Chinese for cigar is “Lüüsung-yen,” or “Philippine tobacco”—kept in the box, often a full box, whether in the hope they won’t be bold enough to disturb the contents or because cigar smokers are so rare in China that the box usually remains full. Eventually, the important person appears from behind a blue cloth door held up by several soldiers; everyone around the table stands up; the host and his guests each shake hands fervently and bow repeatedly, like robots that only bend at the waist; and with a graceful gesture from the governor, everyone finally sits down and chatters about trivial topics as smoothly as the guests’ Chinese allows or the interpreter's assistance provides. If the visit is just formal, it ends in the waiting room where it began. After yet another round of bows, the guests are escorted to the door and as far beyond it as their rank allows. This is one of the most sensitive points of Chinese etiquette, especially for foreigners, particularly if they are relatively new to the country. There is a complex hierarchy in society even in “republican” China, with many factors affecting each position under various circumstances; failing to see a guest off properly can be as serious a faux pas as going too far beyond the point their status permits. In a governor's yamen—in theory, they call such a place gung-shu, or “people’s house,” since the republic began—there can be nearly a dozen doors or openings between the inner areas and the front p’ai-lou, and at each one, courtesy demands a lot of “you first” exchanges and pretended protests from the guest about their host going any further. This way, when the final goodbyes happen far out on the last gate’s threshold, like when an official from great America departs, checking a watch can be quite a shock when you finally manage to leave.
Our first call on the Tuchun of Shensi was at his military headquarters in the ex-Manchu quarter of town. Here his predecessor, Feng Yü Hsiang, had turned the largest available open space within the city walls into a drill-field with long rows of modern brick barracks. On the big stone-and-mud wall enclosing all this there were painted at frequent intervals huge Chinese characters. But these are not the shoe and tobacco advertisements the resemblance to a baseball-field might lead the uninformed stranger to conclude; they are some of those moral precepts with which the “Christian General” is famous for surrounding his soldiers. Much of the material for wall and barracks, by the way, was said to have come from the palaces in which the 384Dowager Empress of sinister memory lived with her pet eunuch during the year following her flight from Peking in 1900. The former military governor saw no good reason to keep up this imperial establishment under a republican régime, and now there remains but little more than a field scattered with broken stones where less than a year before our visit there had been something mildly resembling the Forbidden City in Peking. Speaking of the crafty old shrew in question, we no longer wondered so much at her cantankerous disposition when we realized that she rode all the way from Peking to Sian-fu in a “Peking cart,” eating the dust of the loess cañons, and spending her nights at the odoriferous inns along the way, some of which still boast of that fact by their names or decorations.
Our first visit to the Tuchun of Shensi was at his military headquarters in the old Manchu part of town. Here, his predecessor, Feng Yü Hsiang, had transformed the largest open area within the city walls into a drill field featuring long rows of modern brick barracks. On the massive stone-and-mud wall surrounding it, there were large Chinese characters painted at regular intervals. However, these aren’t shoe and tobacco ads, which might lead an uninformed visitor to think; they are part of the moral lessons that the “Christian General” is known for instilling in his soldiers. By the way, much of the material used for the wall and barracks was said to have come from the palaces where the Dowager Empress of infamous memory lived with her favored eunuch after her escape from Peking in 1900. The former military governor saw no reason to maintain this imperial setup under a republican regime, and now only a field scattered with broken stones remains where, less than a year before our visit, there had been something that vaguely resembled the Forbidden City in Peking. Speaking of the cunning old woman, we no longer found it surprising that she had such a bad temper once we realized she traveled all the way from Peking to Sian-fu in a “Peking cart,” inhaling the dust of the loess canyons and spending her nights at the smelly inns along the route, some of which still highlight this fact through their names or decor.
The Tuchun’s dinner in the major’s honor was an exact replica, except in location, of the call of respect we had made the day before—up to the time when we had begun to take our departure on that occasion. This time the whole party began about five o’clock to drift toward the “banquet-hall” at another end of the compound, with as much contention at every portal along the way as if each had been a dead-line upon which a nest of machine-guns had its muzzles trained. The guests included all the foreigners in town—that is, adults of the male gender—even to a Japanese official who had come to collect an indemnity from the province for the killing of a stray cotton merchant from Nippon; and the flock of Chinese officials mingled with them lacked no one worth while in the political circles of Sian-fu. The three provincial military chieftains with whom we dined during our western journey all go in for foreign-style dinners on official occasions, and attain their intentions in this respect as far as local information and the extraneous learning of their cooks can carry them. The result is an entertaining gustatory hybrid resembling its alien parent perhaps a bit more than its Chinese. Of the irrepressible swarming of persistent flies over all the sumptuousness of that lengthy table I really should have said nothing, for it is surely not the duty of a Tuchun to squander his military genius against such insignificant enemies. That the soldiers flocking almost as thickly about us should have passed slices of bread in their hands instead of using a plate was as genuinely Chinese as were their several other minor faux pas, and merely improved the local color. At least the great Oriental institution of gam-bay-ing held its unaltered own, even in the presence of half a dozen Protestant missionaries and a chief guest of honor who lamentably failed to hold up his end of that pastime.
The Tuchun’s dinner in the major’s honor was a perfect copy, except for the location, of the respectful gathering we had the day before—up until the moment we started to leave. This time, the entire group began to make their way toward the “banquet hall” at the other end of the compound around five o’clock, facing as much struggle at each entrance as if each were a deadline with machine guns aimed at it. The guests included all the foreign men in town, even a Japanese official who had come to collect compensation from the province for the death of a stray cotton merchant from Japan; and the group of Chinese officials mingling with them included everyone significant in the political circles of Sian-fu. The three provincial military leaders we dined with during our journey to the west all prefer foreign-style dinners for official events, achieving this based on local knowledge and what their cooks have learned from outside. The outcome is an entertaining culinary hybrid that resembles its foreign parent perhaps a little more than its Chinese counterpart. I really should say nothing about the relentless swarm of persistent flies over the lavishness of that long table, as it is certainly not the responsibility of a Tuchun to waste his military brilliance on such trivial adversaries. That the soldiers crowding around us passed slices of bread in their hands instead of using plates was as authentically Chinese as their other minor faux pas, and only added to the local flavor. At least the great Eastern tradition of gam-bay-ing remained intact, even with half a dozen Protestant missionaries and a chief guest of honor who sadly didn’t contribute much to that activity.

The east gate of Sian-fu, by which we entered the capital of Shensi, rises like an apartment-house above the flat horizon
The east gate of Sian-fu, through which we entered the capital of Shensi, towers like an apartment building above the flat horizon.

All manner of aids to the man behind the wheelbarrow are used in his long journey in bringing wheat to market, some of them not very economical
All kinds of tools and supports for the person pushing the wheelbarrow are used during their long journey to bring wheat to market, some of which aren’t very cost-effective.

The western gate of Sian-fu, through which we continued our journey to Kansu
The western gate of Sian-fu, which we passed through to continue our journey to Kansu

A “Hwei-Hwei,” or Chinese Mohammedan, keeper of an outdoor restaurant
A “Hwei-Hwei,” or Chinese Muslim, owner of an outdoor restaurant
385The privacy of the military governor—and therefore usually the dictator—of a Chinese province must indeed be slight. When he has guests, swarms of soldiers and servants crowd every doorway and fill every window with staring faces, if, indeed, they do not flock into the room itself. Every joke, every slightest scrap of information picked up from the conversation is instantly, and often more or less audibly, passed out into the yard and relayed to the last coolie within the compound. Most Tuchuns have the reputation of double-dealing to feather their own nests; how on earth they ever succeed in privately arranging any of their little deals is a mystery, for there must surely always be some underling about to listen to the conversation. This is not eavesdropping but the frank presence of servants and the like, even of mere strangers struck with curiosity, in situations where the worst bred ignoramus in the Western world would never dream of intruding; and as the Chinese desire for privacy is as slight as their sense of it, such intrusions are not only seldom rebuked but probably in many cases not even noticed. Even a private home is little more respected than a public office. When the Tuchun came to lunch with us his soldiers poured into the house of our host, crowding the doorway of dining-room or parlor and, as we ate or chatted, fingering their Lugers, unconsciously perhaps, but as if they were expecting us at any moment to attempt the assassination of their chief.
385The privacy of the military governor—and usually the dictator—of a Chinese province is pretty limited. When he has guests, a crowd of soldiers and staff fills every doorway and every window, staring in, and often they even come into the room. Every joke, every little snippet of conversation is quickly and often quite audibly passed out into the yard and relayed to the last worker in the compound. Most Tuchuns are known for being two-faced to benefit themselves; how they manage to privately arrange any of their little schemes is a mystery, since there always seems to be someone nearby to overhear. This isn’t just eavesdropping but the obvious presence of servants and curious strangers in situations where even the most ill-mannered person in the West wouldn’t dream of intruding; and since the Chinese have a minimal desire for privacy and an even lower sense of it, such intrusions are not only rarely challenged but probably often go unnoticed. Even a private home doesn’t get more respect than a public office. When the Tuchun came to lunch with us, his soldiers flooded into our host's house, crowding the doorway of the dining room or living room, and as we ate or chatted, they fiddled with their Lugers, perhaps unconsciously, as if they were expecting us to try to assassinate their leader at any moment.
Shensi’s ruler at the time of our visit had been civil governor of the province under the “Christian General.” Upon his own accession to chief power he retained, and apparently honestly attempted to keep up, many of the reforms and policies of his predecessor, though he made no profession of Christianity. Feng, for instance, had abolished the “red light” district and actually driven the inmates out of the province, a very unusual and to most of the population an incomprehensible action. Several times the Sian-fu chief of police had petitioned the new Tuchun to allow these places to be reëstablished, because they brought large increases to the provincial treasury—to say nothing, of course, of the liberal “squeeze” to all officials concerned. His refusal was still apparently genuine at the time of our visit. But pity the poor officials of present-day China who wish to be honest and progressive, and perhaps even moral in the Western sense; a Tuchun must at least have money to pay his troops, must he not? When Feng took over the province of Shensi it had been for some time under the rule of a former bandit, who had followed an honored precedent in collecting all land and other possible taxes for years in advance. This left the 386new Tuchun the rather scanty likin taxes and a few minor sources of income on which to run his government and keep his troops up to their unusually high efficiency. It could not be done; and after he had appealed to the Christian missionaries to show him any possible means to avoid resorting to that extreme, Feng fell back upon the lucrative tax on opium exported from his province or passing through from Kansu beyond, however illegal such traffic is and whatever his personal feelings toward it were. A mere local detail this; but it is symbolical of hundreds of problems facing those who really wish to work for the future betterment of China, and it is not difficult to guess what happens in the case of the many more weak or indifferent men who have attained to some degree of power, with still no vision beyond the universal corruption which sank its roots deep into Chinese society in the old imperial days.
Shensi’s leader during our visit had been the civil governor of the province under the "Christian General." When he took on the top position, he kept and genuinely tried to maintain many of his predecessor's reforms and policies, despite not claiming to be a Christian. For example, Feng had eliminated the "red light" district and actually expelled the residents from the province, a rare and confusing move for most of the population. Several times, the chief of police in Sian-fu had asked the new Tuchun to permit the reopening of these establishments, as they significantly boosted the provincial treasury—not to mention the considerable “squeeze” for all the officials involved. His refusal seemed sincere at the time of our visit. But feel sorry for the officials in modern-day China who want to be honest and progressive, maybe even moral by Western standards; a Tuchun needs funds to pay his troops, right? When Feng took control of Shensi, it had been under the rule of a former bandit for some time, who had followed a long-standing practice of collecting all land and other possible taxes years in advance. This left the new Tuchun with barely any likin taxes and a few minor income sources to manage his government and maintain his troops at their unusually high efficiency. It was impossible; after appealing to Christian missionaries for any possible way to avoid drastic measures, Feng turned to the lucrative tax on opium exported from his province or passing through from Kansu, regardless of how illegal that trade was and whatever his personal views on it might have been. This detail might seem local, but it symbolizes the countless issues confronting those genuinely wanting to improve the future of China. It's easy to imagine what happens to the many weak or apathetic individuals who gain some degree of power, with no vision other than the pervasive corruption that took root deep in Chinese society during the old imperial days.
CHAPTER XXI
ONWARD THROUGH SHANSI
Our good British host of Sian-fu conceived the nefarious project of sending us on to Lanchow in “Peking carts”; but the few unavoidable churnings in those of the Tuchun had firmly convinced us that anything else was preferable. Anything else boiled down to a single choice,—the transformation of pack-mules in the postal service into riding-animals by the simple expedient of disguising them as such with the American army saddles and bridles we had brought with us. For militarists had drained the provinces of horses; good riding-mules could be bought, if at all, only for a fortune, and could not be hired for so long and hazardous a journey under any circumstances. We took two carts also, it is true, a “large” and a “small” one in Chinese parlance, though the difference in size was not great and the three mules of the one hardly better than the two of the other. But these were for the baggage and our two servants.
Our British host in Sian-fu came up with the dubious idea of sending us to Lanchow in “Peking carts,” but the few unavoidable bumps we experienced in the Tuchun's carts had firmly convinced us that any other option was better. That left us with just one choice: turning the pack mules used for postal service into riding animals by simply disguising them with the American army saddles and bridles we had brought along. The military had stripped the provinces of horses; good riding mules could only be found at an exorbitant price, and hiring them for such a long and risky journey was simply not an option. We also took two carts—a "large" one and a "small" one in Chinese terms—even though the size difference was minimal and the three mules in one cart were hardly better than the two in the other. But those were for our luggage and our two servants.
An inventory of the whole expedition may be mildly of interest, not so much for the information of other travelers as to show that the most modest of foreigners can scarcely escape a princely retinue when they travel in the interior of China. The “large” cart exacted forty-four dollars; the small one twenty-seven dollars; each pack-mule sixteen dollars, with a dollar “tea-money” at the end (specified in the contract). This included a driver for each cart, a mafu, or groom, on foot to attend to the riding-animals—for most of the way, it turned out, we had two of them—all self-sustaining, except their mere lodging at inns and, of course, a certain inevitable “squeeze” through understandings with innkeepers. For a journey of fifteen hundred li, or four hundred and fifty miles, the sum total did not seem excessive, particularly as it was merely in “Mex” and but little more than half what it would have been in American currency. The trip, we learned, was usually divided into eighteen stages and could scarcely be made with such an outfit in less than sixteen days. We took the precaution of promising a dollar a day cumshaw to each of the cart-drivers for every day they bettered the ordinary schedule.
An overview of the entire expedition might be somewhat interesting, not so much for other travelers' benefit but to illustrate that even the humblest foreigners can't avoid a lavish entourage when traveling in the heart of China. The “large” cart cost forty-four dollars; the small one cost twenty-seven dollars; each pack-mule was sixteen dollars, plus a dollar for “tea-money” at the end (as stated in the contract). This included a driver for each cart and a mafu, or groom, on foot to look after the riding animals—for most of the journey, we had two of them—all of whom were self-sustaining, except for their basic lodging at inns and, of course, a certain unavoidable “squeeze” through agreements with innkeepers. For a journey of fifteen hundred li, or four hundred and fifty miles, the total cost didn’t seem too high, especially since it was in “Mex” and just a little more than half what it would have been in American currency. We discovered that the trip was usually divided into eighteen stages and could hardly be completed with such a setup in less than sixteen days. We took the precaution of offering a dollar a day cumshaw to each of the cart drivers for every day they exceeded the standard schedule.
388Fifty li beyond Sian-fu the alleged road went down into the broad river-bed of the Wei, a sturdy tributary of the Hoang Ho and in certain seasons several times wider than it was now. Far out at the edge of the water was gathered a mighty multitude waiting for the very inadequate ferry to set them across to the large walled town of Sienyang on the further shore. A typical Chinese ferry is a marvelous example of the worst way to cross a river, and this one was no exception to the rule. Out in the sand close alongside the still broad stream there were densely crowded together, in all the disorder of which the Chinese, who are adepts at it, are capable, carts piled high with all sorts of awkward cargo, mules, donkeys, and a few old hacks of horses, all under cumbersome packs, laden wheelbarrows by the score, and coolies without number, each carrying with him a donkey-load of something or other. All this assortment, not to mention dozens of mere Chinese travelers of less good-natured mien than the coolies, and all sorts of journeying odds and ends scattered through the throng, was lying in wait for one of three clumsy, home-made barges which at long intervals poled and singsonged themselves from shore to shore. Wherever a Chinese crowd gathers there quickly flock those eager to minister to its wants, so that out here on the bare sand there had sprung up several straw-mat restaurants, a shoemaker’s hasty establishment, a blacksmith-shop, which could have been packed up entire in five minutes and carried off over the smithy’s shoulder, for those who wished to take advantage of the delay by having a horse shod or some unavoidable repair done, while the hawkers of everything hawkable to such customers struggled through the chaotic mob chanting their wares in all the tones from diphtheritic hoarseness to the shrillest of falsettos. Then of course there were the inevitable beggars, young and old, sickly and sturdy, slinking in and out through every possible opening.
388Fifty li beyond Sian-fu, the so-called road descended into the wide riverbed of the Wei, a strong tributary of the Yellow River that was much wider during certain seasons than it was now. Far at the edge of the water, a huge crowd gathered, waiting for the inadequate ferry to take them across to the large walled town of Sienyang on the other side. A typical Chinese ferry is one of the least efficient ways to cross a river, and this one was no exception. Close to the still broad stream, on the sand, there were tightly packed carts overflowing with all kinds of awkward cargo, along with mules, donkeys, and a few old horses, all carrying heavy loads. There were also scores of loaded wheelbarrows and countless coolies, each with a donkey-load of something or other. This chaotic mix, not to mention dozens of grumpy Chinese travelers and various odds and ends scattered throughout the crowd, waited for one of the three clumsy, homemade barges that slowly made their way back and forth. Whenever a Chinese crowd gathers, you can quickly find those eager to cater to its needs, so several straw-mat restaurants, a makeshift shoemaker's shop, and a blacksmith shop—easily packed up in five minutes and tossed over the smithy's shoulder—had sprung up in the sand for those wanting to take advantage of the wait to have a horse shod or make some urgent repairs. Meanwhile, hawkers of all sorts weaved through the chaotic mob, shouting about their goods in a range of voices from deep and hoarse to the shrillest falsetto. And, of course, there were the inevitable beggars, young and old, frail and strong, slipping in and out through every possible gap.
It would have been un-Chinese to take turns or conform to any other system that might have made easier the task in hand, so that when the first of the three craft, more overloaded than any American “trolley” in the rush hour, began to show signs of where it purposed to land, there was a helter-skelter in that direction which resulted in many personal discomfitures. Luckily foreigners are usually given a wide berth in such stampedes; whether it is out of sheer respect or merely due to some old tradition of one of these strange-looking “outside-country people” suddenly “making his hand into a ball” and chastising in an unprecedented manner those who were so unfortunate as to jostle him, there is almost always alacrity and generally respectful cheerfulness 389in giving one of them full right of way. Personally we might not have taken advantage of this attitude and made chaos more chaotic by demanding first place; but Chang, like any Chinese in the service of a foreigner, could not resist impressing that fact upon his fellow-countrymen; and before we realized it he had somehow forced our expedition to the front at the spot where the boat at last concluded to ground. For it would not have been conventional to prepare a place where the craft might actually land, any more than it would have been for it to carry a real gang-plank in place of the two warped and writhing slabs that were at length disentangled from the welter of everything on board and slid over the side. For one thing, a real gang-plank could probably not have survived some band of thieves for a single night; for another, how could the swarms of tattered men hanging about either shore earn their meager food if carts and wheelbarrows could be gotten aboard without their assistance? Had there been any suggestion of authority to keep the one throng back far enough for the other to disembark, the boat’s stay might at least have been cut in half. But China is preëminently the land of individual rather than communal liberty, and there ensued something superior by many times to any college rush. That a few who wished to disembark had been swept back again upon the boat, and vice versa, was of course no unusual experience. When at last comparative quiet began to settle down about us, and the half-dozen polemen at the stern took up their weird chantey, we found that while we ourselves and most of our animals were on board none of our carts had won the mêlée. Carts could not get on board under their own natural motive-power, but, having been unhitched, they must be bodily lifted and shouldered up the crazy substitutes for gang-planks.
It would have been un-Chinese to take turns or follow any other system that might have made the task easier, so when the first of the three boats, overloaded like any American bus during rush hour, started to show where it planned to land, there was a scramble in that direction that led to many personal inconveniences. Fortunately, foreigners usually get a wide berth in such stampedes; whether it’s out of sheer respect or just some old tradition regarding these strange-looking “outsiders” suddenly “rolling up their fists” and chastising those unfortunate enough to bump into them, there’s almost always eagerness and generally respectful cheerfulness in giving them the right of way. Personally, we might not have taken advantage of this attitude and made chaos even worse by demanding first place; but Chang, like any Chinese person in the service of a foreigner, couldn’t resist emphasizing that fact to his fellow countrymen; and before we knew it, he had somehow pushed our group to the front at the spot where the boat finally decided to land. It wouldn’t have been conventional to prepare a spot for the boat to actually land, just as it wouldn’t have been to carry a real gangplank instead of the two warped, writhing planks that were eventually disentangled from the mess onboard and slid over the side. For one thing, a real gangplank probably wouldn’t survive a night with some thieves; for another, how would the crowds of ragged men hanging around either shore earn their meager food if carts and wheelbarrows could be loaded onto the boat without their help? If there had been any authority to keep one crowd back far enough for the other to disembark, the boat’s stay might have been cut in half. But China is primarily the land of individual rather than collective freedom, and what followed was a scene far more intense than any college rush. It was certainly not unusual for some who wanted to get off to be swept back onto the boat, and vice versa. When things finally began to calm down around us, and the half-dozen polemen at the back started their strange chant, we realized that while most of us and our animals were on board, none of our carts had made it through the chaos. Carts couldn’t get on board under their own power, so after being unhitched, they had to be physically lifted and shouldered up the makeshift planks.
Though the opposite shore was a stone-paved road close under the city wall, landing facilities were far worse than where we had embarked. For one thing, the craft grounded fully ten feet from shore and could not be coaxed to move in either direction until all the coolies, who made up three fourths of the passenger-list, had been driven overboard, packs and all, and left to scramble as best they could up the stone facing of the bank. Many of them were carrying cotton in loose bundles or in high cone-shaped baskets, and now and then in their shrieking, disorganized struggles a boll or two of the precious stuff fell into the muddy water. The dismay at such a disaster, though only on the part of the owner or carrier, who screamed with excitement until he had rescued the threatened bit of property, was not merely both absurd and pathetic, but a striking commentary on the poverty of 390China’s great masses. Eventually the boat was poled close enough to what should and could easily have been a stone runway so that the frightened animals could be forced to walk the teetering plank without more than two or three of them falling overboard, and some two hours after we had reached the river our own carts were manhandled ashore from a following boat and our expedition was once more organized.
Though the opposite shore had a stone-paved road right by the city wall, the landing facilities were much worse than where we had boarded. For one thing, the boat grounded a full ten feet from the shore and wouldn't budge in either direction until all the coolies, who made up three-quarters of the passenger list, had been pushed overboard, packs and all, and left to scramble up the stone bank as best they could. Many of them were carrying cotton in loose bundles or in tall cone-shaped baskets, and now and then during their loud, chaotic struggles, a boll or two of the precious cotton fell into the muddy water. The panic over such a loss, though only affecting the owner or carrier, who shouted in excitement until he rescued the threatened item, was not just both ridiculous and sad but also a stark reminder of the poverty facing China's vast population. Eventually, the boat was poled close enough to what should have been an easy stone ramp so that the frightened animals could be forced to walk the shaky plank without more than two or three of them falling overboard, and about two hours after we arrived at the river, our own carts were hauled ashore from a following boat, and our expedition was organized once again.
Thousands of people, and probably at least hundreds of carts, cross the Wei at Sienyang every day in the year, and have done so for centuries; yet the several simple little improvements that would make the crossing a brisk matter of routine have evidently never been thought of—except by critical foreigners—much less ever attempted. No Chinese concerned would feel really happy if the thing were not done in the very hardest possible way consistent with its being accomplished at all; that would make him feel out of touch with his worshiped ancestors. Besides, whom do you expect to make those improvements? Not the local authorities, for they probably get more “squeeze” under the present system; not the boatmen, for the longer the boat is in loading the fewer times they will have to pole it across; not, certainly, the flocks of hangers-on who find in the difficulties of embarking and disembarking their only source of livelihood; and surely not the passenger, for his only interest is to get across, not to make it easier for other people, for whose weal or woe he has a Chinaman’s supreme indifference.
Thousands of people, and probably at least hundreds of carts, cross the Wei at Sienyang every day of the year and have been doing so for centuries. Yet, the simple improvements that would make the crossing a quick and routine process have clearly never been considered—except by critical outsiders—much less ever attempted. No Chinese participant would feel genuinely satisfied if it were not done in the most difficult way possible while still being accomplished at all; that would make him feel disconnected from his revered ancestors. Furthermore, who do you expect to make those improvements? Not the local authorities, as they likely benefit more from the current system; not the boatmen, since the longer the boat takes to load, the fewer times they need to row it across; certainly not the numerous hangers-on who see the challenges of boarding and disembarking as their only means of making a living; and definitely not the passengers, as their only concern is to get across, not to make it easier for others, for whom they feel a typical Chinese indifference.
Beyond Sienyang the whole dust-hazy landscape was covered as far as the eye could see with graves, not the little conical spatters of earth to be seen in myriads all over China, but immense mounds by the score, some of them veritable mountains—and nowhere a touch of any color but the yellow brown of rainless autumn. Once perhaps there had been small forests about these tombs, but at most now there was left a rare broken stone horse of clumsy workmanship and perhaps the remnants of a few other more or less mythological beasts. What noble beings had been worthy the heavy task of piling these great hills over their mortal remains, or when they had graced the earth, no one along the way could tell us. Once or twice a day we passed a huge oblong old bell of elaborate design that had once hung in a temple, and was now rusting away in some moistureless mud-hole, like the abandoned sugar-kettles which litter several islands of the West Indies. Perhaps the temples themselves had fallen entirely away again into the dust from which even holy edifices are constructed in the loess country, and left these abandoned bells as the only remembrance of their former 391existence. Sometimes one of these had been rescued, whether out of piety, superstition, or some lucrative inspiration, and hung in the one and only tree of which an occasional larger village boasted.
Beyond Sienyang, the entire dust-hazy landscape stretched endlessly with graves as far as the eye could see— not the tiny conical mounds common throughout China, but vast hills by the dozens, some even resembling mountains. There was no hint of any color except the yellow-brown of a rainless autumn. Once, there might have been small forests surrounding these tombs, but now there was only a rare broken stone horse of crude craftsmanship and perhaps the remnants of a few more or less mythical creatures. What noble individuals were deemed worthy enough to have these massive hills built over their remains, or when they once walked this earth, nobody could tell us. A few times a day, we would pass a huge, elaborately designed oblong bell that had once hung in a temple, now rusting away in a dry mud hole, much like the abandoned sugar kettles scattered across several West Indies islands. Perhaps the temples themselves had completely disintegrated back into the dust from which even sacred buildings are made in the loess country, leaving these forsaken bells as the only reminders of their past existence. Sometimes one of these bells got rescued, whether out of piety, superstition, or a profitable idea, and was hung in the only tree that an occasional larger village could boast of. 391
On the second midday we lunched in a cave, and paid even for the water drunk by the mules, as well as their chopped straw and beans; or at least their owners did. In fact, cave dwellings had become almost universal, and were to remain so for many days to come; villages, whole towns of caves, stretched in row after row up the face of great loess cliffs, like the terraced fields that covered every foot of the mountainous world from river-bottom to the crest of the farthest visible range. In all this tumbled expanse often the only touch of color was the persimmons, like big orange-tinted tomatoes—persimmons by the ox-cart-load; wheelbarrows creaking under their double straw boxes of persimmons; baskets of them hanging from the shoulder-poles of jogging coolies; wandering persimmon-sellers everywhere singing their merits; millions of them for sale, millions more being dried in the sun. Even the dust which covered everything and everybody without distinction could not disguise the persimmons’ splash of color, nor hamper the natives from wolfing them entire as often as their worldly wealth warranted the acquisition of one. Dust and skin aside, we also found them the best thing late autumn had to offer—a drink, a lunch, and a dessert all in one.
On the second noon, we had lunch in a cave and even paid for the water the mules drank, along with their chopped straw and beans; or at least their owners did. In fact, cave dwellings had become almost everywhere, and they would stay that way for many days to come; villages, entire towns of caves, stretched in row after row up the steep loess cliffs, like the terraced fields that covered every inch of the mountainous landscape from the riverbanks to the crest of the farthest visible range. In all this sprawling expanse, often the only splash of color was from the persimmons, resembling large orange-tinted tomatoes—persimmons piled high in ox-carts; wheelbarrows creaking under their double straw boxes of persimmons; baskets of them swinging from the shoulder-poles of busy coolies; wandering persimmon-sellers everywhere singing their praises; millions of them for sale, with millions more drying in the sun. Even the dust that covered everything and everyone didn't hide the persimmons' vivid color, nor stop the locals from devouring them whole whenever their finances allowed. Aside from the dust and dirt, we found them to be the best thing late autumn had to offer—a drink, a lunch, and a dessert all in one.
We crawled out of our sleeping-bags at five each morning and were off at six, except on the few days when we varied that program by making it an hour earlier. With the sun so low that it only overtook us some twenty li away, those daily departures were not only dark but increasingly cold. For though men working in the fields were still sometimes stripped to the waist, at least when the cloudless sun was high, as late as the tenth of November, any suggestion of shadow or of night air became more tinged with serious meaning as the earth underfoot rose higher and higher above sea-level. The roads for the most part were still cañons, sometimes mightier cañons than we had even yet seen; at others they clambered over loess ridges and hills, gashing themselves deeply into these wherever time, traffic, and soil coincided sufficiently to do so. In strict speech there were no roads at all, as there seldom are anywhere in China; not that they were merely atrocious routes of transportation, but because the Chinese scheme of things does not make provision even for a place on which to build a road. Every foot of territory pays a land-tax; the unfortunate landholder on whose property the public chooses to trespass in its strenuous 392struggles to get itself and its produce from one place to another must pay for that which belongs to him only in name. The result is that a road is a homeless orphan, welcome nowhere, driven from field to field, and ruthlessly done away with by plow or shovel whenever an opportunity offers. The attempts of each of China’s myriad tillers of the soil to chase the un-public highway off his own precious little patches of earth, added to the fact that a driver has only a limited control over the wanderings of his lead-mule, and has no training in directness and time-saving himself, make the average Chinese road the most incredible example of aimless wandering on the face of the earth. There are no fences in this land of walls; the Chinese walls in his home, his towns, his country, but never his fields, which would seem to need it most. For traffic has not the slightest consideration for the damage it may do. It marches serenely over newly planted grain or ripening crops whenever there is the least incentive to do so, and the only redress of the owner is some such feeble protest as digging traverse trenches at frequent intervals along the edge of his land in the usually vain hope that carts will be obliged to keep outside them, or to take advantage of some favorable season of slight travel to uproot the pesky road and throw it away entirely.
We crawled out of our sleeping bags at five each morning and were off by six, except on the few days we changed it to an hour earlier. With the sun so low that it only caught up with us about twenty li away, those daily departures were not only dark but also getting colder. Even though farm workers were sometimes shirtless when the clear sun was high, as late as November 10th, any hint of shadow or nighttime air felt more significant as the ground rose higher above sea level. Most of the roads were still canyons, sometimes even greater canyons than we'd seen yet; at other times they climbed over loess ridges and hills, carving deeply into them wherever time, traffic, and soil allowed. Strictly speaking, there were no roads at all, as there hardly are anywhere in China; it wasn't just that they were terrible routes for transportation, but because the Chinese system doesn’t allocate space for building roads. Every square foot of land incurs a tax; the unfortunate landowner whose property the public chooses to cross in its desperate attempts to transport itself and its goods must pay for what is technically his only in name. The result is that a road is a homeless orphan, welcome nowhere, forced from field to field, and ruthlessly removed by plow or shovel whenever the chance arises. Each of China’s countless farmers attempts to push the unmarked road off his tiny bit of land, combined with the fact that a driver has only limited control over where his lead mule goes and lacks training in straight paths and efficiency himself, makes the average Chinese road a remarkable example of aimless wandering. There are no fences in this land of walls; the Chinese have walls in their homes, towns, and country, but never in their fields, which really need them the most. Traffic shows no regard for the damage it may cause, marching indifferently over newly planted grain or ripening crops whenever there's the slightest temptation to do so, and the only response from the owner is usually a weak protest, like digging trenches at intervals along the edge of his land, hoping that carts will have to stay outside of them, or taking advantage of some quieter travel season to uproot the troublesome road and get rid of it entirely.
There were defiles so narrow through the great loess cañons that carts could not have passed a sedan-chair; and through these came such a constant train of traffic that it is strange the lighter west-bound travel moved at all. Ponderous two-wheeled carts, weighing several times as much as our farm-wagons, drawn by six or seven mules, were not uncommon. All had at least three animals, one in the shafts—and many of these shaft-mules were splendid specimens of mulehood—the rest in front in pairs or trios, with perhaps a lone lead-mule setting the pace. Rope traces running through a large iron ring suspended from each of the shafts attached all the animals directly to the axle. A Chinese shaft-mule’s life is no sinecure. At every incessant bump and lurch of the massive cart he is similarly jolted by the two cumbersome logs that imprison him; if the cart overturns he must go with it; and all day long his head is held painfully erect, not by a mere bit, but by a rawhide thong between his upper lip and the gums. The other animals get off little more cheaply, and with the wicked loads of wheat in long slender bags which endlessly poured in past us from the west, the gasping of the animals as they toiled in the deep sand-like loess, particularly when the cañon led steeply upward over the high ridges which 393here and there cut across the route, was like the death-rattle of beasts suddenly stricken down.
There were narrow passages through the great loess canyons that carts couldn't even fit through, and yet, there was such a constant stream of traffic that it’s surprising the lighter westbound travel even moved at all. Heavy two-wheeled carts, weighing several times more than our farm wagons, pulled by six or seven mules, were common. Each cart had at least three animals, one in the shafts—and many of these shaft mules were impressive examples of their kind—while the others were in pairs or trios in front, with perhaps a single lead mule setting the pace. Rope traces hooked through a large iron ring hanging from each shaft connected all the animals directly to the axle. A Chinese shaft mule’s life is no easy task. With each constant bump and jolt of the massive cart, he is jolted by the two heavy logs that confine him; if the cart tips over, he goes down with it; and all day long, his head is held painfully upright, not by a simple bit, but by a rawhide thong between his upper lip and gums. The other animals don’t fare much better, and with the heavy loads of wheat in long narrow bags that continuously poured in from the west, the gasping of the animals as they struggled in the deep, sandy loess, especially when the canyon climbed steeply over the high ridges that occasionally crossed the path, sounded like the death rattle of beasts suddenly struck down.
Under each axle of these carts hung a long bell of cylinder shape, and the dull booming of scores of these could be heard for miles before or behind them. Apparently these wheat-trains traveled day and night. We met them at dawn with all the signs of having already been on the road for hours; all through the night the booming of passing carts could be heard by any one who cared to lie awake; very rarely did we come upon them halted long enough even to feed the jaded animals. There were at least two men on every load, one, whom we suspected to be the driver off duty, stretched out at full length and apparently sleeping as soundly as if the jolting, careening sacks of wheat were a sailor’s hammock. There was really nothing strange in this; the Chinese are trained from birth to sleep under all manner of catch-as-catch-can conditions. With the loess soil constantly swirling about under the least disturbing circumstances, and with a high wind often blowing, the Chinese on their carts, as well as those astride or afoot for that matter, looked ludicrously like an endless procession of clowns with flour-powdered faces, or of mimes wearing death-masks.
Under each axle of these carts hung a long, cylindrical bell, and the dull booming of dozens of these could be heard for miles ahead or behind them. It seemed like these wheat trains traveled day and night. We encountered them at dawn, showing all the signs of having already been on the road for hours; all night long, the booming of passing carts could be heard by anyone who chose to stay awake. Rarely did we find them stopped long enough to even feed the tired animals. Each load had at least two men; one, who we suspected was the driver off-duty, lay stretched out and appeared to be sleeping as soundly as if the jolting, swaying sacks of wheat were a sailor’s hammock. There was really nothing unusual about this; the Chinese are taught from birth to sleep in all kinds of makeshift conditions. With the loess soil constantly swirling around at the slightest disturbance, and a strong wind often blowing, the Chinese on their carts, as well as those riding or walking, looked comically like an endless parade of clowns with flour-dusted faces or mimes wearing death masks.
Here and there the file was broken by some more leisurely conveyance,—a cart with an ox in the shafts and perhaps a steer and a donkey in front, sometimes with still more incongruous combinations. The narrow cañons were often so congested with beast-drawn traffic that the hundreds of wheelbarrows had to join the pole-shouldering coolies and other pedestrians on the paths along the cliffs high above. These tui-chu (push-carts), as the Chinese call them, had every manner of aid, from a child to a donkey, which we had seen in use in the wheelbarrow brigades east of Sian-fu, and one ingenious fellow had rigged up a large sail over his load and was creaking along nicely before the strong west wind. I never ceased to wonder where the never ending stream of coolies was coming and going from and to, and why. Their toilsome tramps to change places, bag and baggage, seemed a mere waste of effort, like carrying sand from one river-bed to another.
Here and there, the line was interrupted by some slower modes of transport—a cart pulled by an ox, occasionally accompanied by a steer and a donkey in front, sometimes with even more mismatched combinations. The narrow canyons were often so crowded with animal-drawn traffic that hundreds of wheelbarrows had to join the pole-carrying laborers and other pedestrians on the paths along the cliffs high above. These tui-chu (push-carts), as the Chinese call them, had all sorts of helpers, from a child to a donkey, similar to what we had seen in the wheelbarrow crews east of Sian-fu. One resourceful individual had even set up a large sail over his load and was sailing along nicely with the strong west wind. I couldn't help but wonder where the endless stream of laborers was coming from and going to, and why. Their exhausting journeys to swap places, bag and baggage, seemed like a pointless effort, akin to moving sand from one riverbed to another.
The coolies of Shensi, or at least most of those we saw in that province, seem to long to be mistaken for scholars—an honor, of course, which would bring joy to any Chinese heart, in contrast to the insult it would often convey in some other lands. Some clever salesman had profited by this strange Celestial longing by selling to more than half the coolies we met a huge pair of rimless spectacles made of plain plate-glass, and of course of no optical value whatever. Had they been 394in the form of goggles, one might have concluded that they were merely a protection from the dust, but there was nothing about them that could by any stretch even of a coolie imagination be considered anything but ornamental.
The coolies of Shensi, or at least most of those we encountered in that province, seem to wish to be mistaken for scholars—an honor, of course, that would bring joy to any Chinese heart, unlike the insult it might mean in some other countries. Some savvy salesperson took advantage of this unique desire by selling a huge pair of rimless glasses made of plain plate glass to more than half the coolies we met, which had no optical value whatsoever. If they had been in the shape of goggles, one might think they were simply a protection against the dust, but there was nothing about them that could be seen as anything other than decorative, even by a coolie's imagination.
Cues have appreciably decreased in China since the fall of the alien dynasty which required them as a badge of submission; but once a custom is established among the conservative Chinese it is harder to eradicate than ragweed, however uncomplimentary may have been its origin. It may be a slight exaggeration to say that every other man we met on our western trip wore a cue, but certainly there is still wound about coolie heads material enough for all the hair-nets that America can consume in another century. Old men, though only a tiny gray braid may be left them, would, it is said, “rather lose their heads than their tails.” In this west country boys are as likely to be adorned with them as not; in any busy street the itinerant hair-dresser may be seen combing out the long black tresses of his coolie clients, calmly seated out of doors even in the depths of winter, and often adding a switch for good measure. Among upper-class Chinese the cue has largely disappeared, but with the masses it is as common a feature in many provinces as the long pipes protruding from the backs of coolie necks when not in use.
Cues have noticeably decreased in China since the fall of the foreign dynasty that required them as a symbol of submission. However, once a tradition is established among the conservative Chinese, it's tougher to get rid of than weeds, no matter how unflattering its origins might be. It might be a bit of an overstatement to say that every other man we met on our trip west wore a cue, but there's definitely still enough hair on coolie heads for all the hairnets America could use in the next century. Older men, even if they only have a small gray braid left, are said to “prefer losing their heads over losing their tails.” In the western region, boys are just as likely to sport them as not; on any busy street, you can spot the traveling hairdresser combing out the long black hair of his coolie clients, calmly sitting outdoors even in the harshest winter, often adding a switch for extra flair. Among the upper-class Chinese, the cue has largely vanished, but among the masses, it's as common a sight in many provinces as the long pipes sticking out from the backs of coolie necks when they're not in use.
A corpse journeying to its ancestral home between two pole-joined mules, the white rooster demanded by ancient custom sitting on top of the ponderous coffin in a little wicker cage, was one of the infrequent, though not rare, sights of the journey. Sometimes we met a long file of black pigs moving slowly eastward under the impulse of several patient men, one marching in front unarmed, the rest with very long but rather harmless whips, and all singing to coax on their charges. It was an addition to my slight knowledge of natural history to learn that hogs are moved by music; but there is no telling what Chinese music may accomplish until it has been tried. We rode, of course, or rested our cramped legs by walking, up out of the cañons as much as possible. Here the variance in the point at which a man or a mule registers dizziness sometimes led to serious differences of opinion between ourselves and our mounts. Along most of the cliffs high above the sunken roads there are several paths, some of them already appreciably wearing down toward the ultimate common level, others narrow ridges of a rather harder streak of earth with barely room on them for two feet at a time. Invariably, whenever there was a choice in paths, the mule would choose the one closest to the edge of the road 395chasm, the very edge of it, if possible, often with a sheer drop of a hundred feet or more directly under the off stirrup—and the loess soil everywhere seeming ready to collapse at any moment. Sometimes a path worked its way out on the face of the cliff before one noticed, to where it would have been as impossible to dismount as to turn about, and the helpless rider could only prayerfully intrust his future to the mule, wholly free apparently from any suggestion of the trepidation which ran in hot sprays up the human spine. Certainly a mule has no worry-bacteria in his system—and probably has fewer troubles in a lifetime than almost any other living creature, which should be food for reflection to worrying humanity. Once I had the hair-lifting experience of seeing most of the rear end of the major’s mule just in front of me go over the cliff with a crumbling bit of path, but the animal never for a moment lost his mulish poise, nor hesitated when the next chance offered to take the most edgy of the paths again.
A corpse making its way to its ancestral home between two mules joined at the poles, with a white rooster perched on top of the heavy coffin in a small wicker cage, was one of the rare but notable sights along the journey. Occasionally, we ran into a long line of black pigs slowly moving eastward, nudged along by several patient men: one unarmed at the front and the others wielding long but harmless whips, all singing to encourage their charges. It expanded my limited knowledge of natural history to learn that hogs respond to music; but who knows what Chinese music might achieve until it’s tried out. We either rode or walked to stretch our cramped legs, trying to ascend out of the canyons as much as we could. Here, the different ways that a man or a mule experiences dizziness sometimes led to serious disagreements between us and our mounts. Along most cliffs high above the sunken roads, there are several paths, some visibly wearing down toward a common level, while others are narrow ridges made of harder earth, barely allowing enough room for two feet at a time. Whenever a choice of paths was available, the mule would invariably opt for the one closest to the edge of the chasm—preferably right at the edge—often with a sheer drop of a hundred feet or more just under the off stirrup, and the loess soil everywhere looking ready to crumble at any moment. At times, a path would unexpectedly wind its way out on the cliff face, making it impossible to dismount or turn around, leaving the helpless rider to prayerfully entrust his fate to the mule, completely free of any hint of the fear that was sending electric chills up the human spine. Certainly, a mule doesn’t have worry-bacteria in its system—and likely has fewer troubles in a lifetime than almost any other living creature, which should give worrying humans something to ponder. Once, I had the terrifying experience of seeing most of the back end of the major’s mule disappear over the cliff with a crumbling piece of path, yet the animal never lost its composure or hesitated when a new opportunity arose to take the most precarious of paths again.
On the evening of the second day out of Sian-fu our muleteers respectfully sent word that they would like us to start “ten li earlier” next morning, “because the road went up-stairs.” That was one of the contrasts between Chinese mule-drivers and those, for instance, of South America. Here they were always ready to start at any hour we named, and sometimes asked us to advance it. We accordingly got up three miles earlier, and before the day was done congratulated ourselves on having done so. All morning the road, freeing itself from loess cañons and taking to river-valleys and ever higher plains, ascended at so gradual a pace that we hardly realized we were rising unless we glanced back at the lower and lower world behind. But just beyond the village where we made our usual hour-and-a-half noonday halt, the earth surged up like some tidal wave suddenly commanded to stand still. The road did indeed go up-stairs; nothing could have been a more exact description of its zigzagging course, which at length, hours after we had left the village, brought us in straggling formation to the summit, four thousand feet above it, then plunged even more swiftly down into the bed of a slight stream which trickled away through a region of huge rocks and a formation for a time more solid than pure loess. But this was only a brief and imperfect respite. The crumbling soil soon monopolized the landscape again, and for many days afterward filled our eyes and nostrils with its stifling and all-penetrating dust. Peculiar sights, indeed, the loess often gives. Fertile enough with sufficient water, one might easily have concluded that not a drop 396of rain had ever fallen here. Mud would have meant more prosperity, but when it does rain these already ankle-deep roads at the bottoms of the great cañons must surely be in close proximity to the infernal regions.
On the evening of the second day out of Sian-fu, our muleteers politely let us know that they would prefer we start “ten li earlier” the next morning, “because the road went uphill.” This was one of the differences between Chinese mule drivers and those, for example, in South America. There, they were always ready to start at any time we suggested and sometimes even asked us to start sooner. So, we got up three miles earlier and by the end of the day felt happy about it. All morning, the road, breaking free from loess canyons and shifting to river valleys and higher plains, rose so gently that we hardly noticed we were going up unless we looked back at the world below us getting further away. But just past the village where we took our usual hour-and-a-half lunch break, the ground suddenly surged upward like a tidal wave that had been commanded to stop. The road really did go uphill; nothing was a more accurate description of its zigzagging path, which eventually, hours after leaving the village, brought us in a scattered line to the summit, four thousand feet above it, then quickly dropped down into the bed of a small stream trickling through an area of massive rocks and solid ground, briefly more firm than pure loess. But this was only a short and incomplete break. The crumbling soil soon dominated the landscape again, and for many days afterward, it filled our eyes and noses with its suffocating and all-pervasive dust. The loess often presents unique sights. Fertile with enough water, one could easily conclude that no rain had ever fallen here. Mud would mean more prosperity, but when it does rain, these already ankle-deep roads at the bottoms of the great canyons must be very close to hell.
Any suggestion of this was spared us, however, as we were denied any hint of the great transformation that spring brings to the loess country, turning it from the delicate light brown that is as unbroken during the autumn and winter as the blue of the cloudless sky overhead to a vernal green which those who have seen it say is seldom surpassed in beautiful landscapes. Such loess cliffs as no words can describe became commonplace, almost unnoticed sights along the way, cliffs falling gradually from sky to abyss so far below as almost to seem bottomless. All the population for long distances burrowed in human rabbit-warrens dug in these cliffs, row above row of caves, like cities of ten- or twelve-story cliff-dwellings. Many of the caves proved at close sight to be ruined and abandoned; usually these were fallen in, with a great round hole in the roof. Of course the former inhabitants had dug a new home elsewhere—unless they were buried in the old one—and the population was not so dense as the myriad holes in the mountain-sides suggested. There was a great difference, too, in the grades of dwellings even among such unlikely homes as these. A cave could be as noisome a hut as any hovel out on a plain; sometimes a mere hole in the cliff looked like nothing in particular, until a closer glance showed it to be the entrance to a long passageway leading to several courts that were surrounded by a dozen or more arched cave-dwellings, perhaps all well below the level of the sunken road. Sometimes the proud family had even gone to the trouble of putting an elaborate inscription over the doorway, and had fitted it with wooden sills. But this was unusual, for with such slight exceptions literally everything was made of the quickly crumbling earth,—the “devil screen” across the way from the entrance (though this very important feature of Chinese architecture was rare in the west), the wall filling up the great arch of the cave, with a small door cut in it, even the k’ang, or stone-hard family bed, inside.
Any suggestion of this was spared from us, however, as we were denied any hint of the great transformation that spring brings to the loess country, changing it from the delicate light brown that remains unbroken during the autumn and winter, just like the blue of the clear sky above, to a vibrant green that those who have seen it say is rarely surpassed in beautiful landscapes. The loess cliffs, which no words can adequately describe, became everyday sights along the way, cliffs that gradually fell from the sky to an abyss so far below that they almost seemed bottomless. The population for long distances lived in human rabbit-warrens dug into these cliffs, with row after row of caves resembling cities of ten or twelve-story cliff-dwellings. Many of the caves turned out to be ruined and abandoned upon closer inspection; these were usually collapsed, with a large round hole in the roof. Of course, the former inhabitants had dug new homes elsewhere—unless they were buried in the old ones—and the population was not as dense as the countless holes in the mountainsides suggested. There was also a significant difference in the quality of dwellings, even among such unlikely homes. A cave could be as foul as any shack out on a plain; sometimes a simple hole in the cliff looked like nothing special until a closer look revealed it to be the entrance to a long passageway leading to several courtyards surrounded by a dozen or more arched cave-dwellings, perhaps all well below the level of the sunken road. Sometimes, the proud family had even gone to the trouble of putting an elaborate inscription above the doorway and had fitted it with wooden sills. But this was uncommon, as with a few exceptions, everything was literally made from the quickly crumbling earth—the “devil screen” across from the entrance (though this very important feature of Chinese architecture was rare in the west), the wall filling up the large arch of the cave, with a small door cut into it, even the k’ang, or stone-hard family bed, inside.
Thus everything, walls, houses, cliffs, terraced hillsides, even the dreary cave-dwellers themselves, had the selfsame monotonous color, and in all the autumn landscape there was nothing to break it, to give it the faintest contrast. A sad place surely was this for man to live, like an aged world that was wearing out and would soon be fit only to be discarded. Indeed, the process of dissolution was going on under 397our very eyes. There were often places where the road had very recently dropped away into a mammoth cañon so deep that to peer over the brink was to catch the breath in what might easily have been a spasm of dizziness; yet heavily laden carts still shrieked and lashed their way along the sheer edge of it, and all the miscellaneous traffic passing the spot where the next crumbling might carry it to perdition gave it no more attention than Chinese give to the open, unprotected, curbless wells that abound all over China like gopher-holes in our western prairies.
So everything—walls, houses, cliffs, terraced hillsides, even the grim cave-dwellers—shared the same dull color, and throughout the autumn landscape, there was nothing to break it or provide even the slightest contrast. This was certainly a bleak place for people to live, resembling an aging world that was wearing out and would soon be fit only for disposal. In fact, the process of decay was unfolding right before 397 our eyes. There were often spots where the road had recently collapsed into a massive canyon so deep that looking over the edge could easily cause a dizzy spell; yet heavily loaded carts still screamed and whipped their way along the sheer edge, and all the random traffic passing by the spot where the next collapse could lead to disaster paid it no more attention than the Chinese do to the open, unprotected, curbless wells scattered all over China like gopher holes in our western prairies.
A world wearing away, and apparently there is no cure for it. The trees which might have held it together with their roots, to say nothing of the rain they would bring, were completely grubbed out centuries ago by those very ancestors whom the wretched modern inhabitants so highly honor. Those short-sighted forebears were all for the past, or at best for what was to them the present; and their living descendants have no choice but to follow the same short-sighted course, for the present is an unremitting struggle for mere existence now, and the future surely holds out little promise. To repair the fatal tree-wastefulness of their revered ancestors would require something like forcing every man in China to plant a tree a week, promptly lopping off the head of any one who cuts one down, and keeping this up as long as their ancestors took to grub out the forests that once graced the land; that is, for hundreds, if not thousands, of years.
A world that is crumbling, and it seems there’s no fix for it. The trees that could have kept it together with their roots, not to mention the rain they would provide, were completely cut down centuries ago by those very ancestors whom the miserable modern citizens admire so much. Those shortsighted ancestors only cared about the past, or at best, what was the present for them; and their living descendants have no choice but to follow the same narrow-minded path, because the present is a relentless fight for survival now, and the future doesn’t seem to offer much hope. To reverse the disastrous tree loss caused by their honored ancestors would take something like requiring every person in China to plant a tree each week, promptly executing anyone who cuts one down, and continuing this for as long as their ancestors took to eliminate the forests that once filled the land; that is, for hundreds, if not thousands, of years.
We think we know something of poverty and physical suffering in America, but in crowded, despoiled China we realize our ignorance. Here are perhaps the lowest forms of human beings, creatures in the image of man who are not merely akin to beasts but a kind of living offal. Nor are the dregs of the population to be found in this more roomy western part of the country; there the poorest might be called a middle class, though they are so poor that they burrow in caves and are out long before dawn and late into the night with basket and wicker shovel wandering the roads ready to fight for the droppings of passing animals. Perhaps there are some of them who take life by the forelock and force it more or less to do their bidding. But though here and there were what we would call “tough-looking characters,” even they seemed to be harmless, at least where foreigners were concerned. We hear much in these days of the anarchy of China, and in so far as a responsible, effective government goes the word is not ill chosen. Yet there is a cohesion, a momentum in Chinese society, in 398the great masses that populate the land, which makes a failure of formal government mainly a surface manifestation, with often scarcely a ripple disturbing the even flow of life in general, as it has gone on for centuries and perhaps will for centuries to come. In all west Shensi we saw hardly a soldier, and almost as little of any other coercive force; yet though there may not have been any bandits left in the province, as its Tuchun boldly asserted, nothing would have been easier than for any group of these thousands upon thousands of sturdy coolies for ever plodding to and fro, or the village crowds which gathered in the inn-yards to watch us eat modest noonday lunches which must have seemed to them princely, to fall upon a few stray foreigners lost in the great sea of Chinese humanity and despoil them of what in this land of utter poverty was their great riches. Not only was there no suggestion of such a thought, not only did they show us all the respect which the most haughty participant in extraterritoriality could demand; they were frankly friendly, neither out of fear nor hope of favor. Given the slightest provocation and they invariably smiled; the men, that is; the cripple-footed women never, and small wonder. Behind us lay a constant trail of childlike comment on our appearance, and especially on the stirrups of our army saddles. The Chinese are so minutely conservative that even to wrap a patch of leather about something which they have always hitherto seen without it is to arouse amazement. Often this amazement expressed itself in a burst of laughter, but never once was there anything about its unforced heartiness which could have been taken for ridicule. Possibly they did find covert ways to make fun at our expense; they nearly always called us moo-sha, for instance, which means missionary. But there was every reason to believe that this startling error was due to pure honest ignorance, perhaps once in a while to a desire to be complimentary; never, I feel sure, was there a deliberate attempt even to be unkindly.
We think we understand poverty and physical suffering in America, but when we see the crowded, devastated areas of China, we realize how much we don’t know. Here, we encounter some of the lowest conditions of humanity, people who resemble humans but are more like living waste. The poorest of the population aren't just found in the spacious western region of the country; there, those in poverty might actually be considered the middle class, even though they live in caves and venture out before dawn and late at night with baskets and wicker shovels, searching the roads for scraps left by passing animals. Some of them might take charge of their lives and manage to get by, but even the tough-looking individuals we encountered seemed harmless, at least toward foreigners. We hear a lot about the chaos in China, and while it’s true there’s a lack of a responsible, effective government, that doesn’t capture the cohesion and momentum within Chinese society. The great masses that inhabit the land maintain a way of life that has persisted for centuries, and likely will continue for many more. Throughout west Shensi, we hardly saw any soldiers or other forms of authority. While the local governor confidently claimed there were no bandits left in the province, it wouldn’t have been hard for any group of the thousands of sturdy laborers constantly on the move, or the village crowds gathering in inn-yards to watch us enjoy our modest lunches, to seize a few lost foreigners wandering through the vastness of Chinese humanity and strip them of what little wealth they had in this land of deep poverty. Yet, there was never even a hint of such intentions; they showed us all the respect that even the most arrogant foreigner could demand, and they were genuinely friendly, not out of fear or hope for favors. With the slightest encouragement, the men would always smile, while the crippled women never did, which was understandable. Behind us trailed a constant stream of innocent comments about our appearance, particularly the stirrups on our saddles. The Chinese are so traditionally conservative that even wrapping leather around something they’ve always seen bare astonishes them. This surprise often led to laughter, but it was never malicious; it was simply heartfelt. They might have found subtle ways to poke fun at us, as they often called us moo-sha, meaning missionary. However, it seemed clear that this misunderstanding stemmed from genuine ignorance, and occasionally a desire to be complimentary; I am certain there was never a deliberate attempt to be unkind.
The major likened the rank and file, the coolies at least, to our Southern negroes, with whom his army experience had given him a considerable acquaintance. There is a certain similarity of temperament; one might, indeed, follow up the thought and find a resemblance between the more morose, yet still Chinese, non-laboring classes and the mulatto or lighter types of negro, who so often have an air of brooding over their intermediate state of heredity. But one could easily carry the thought too far. There is much the same easy-going view of life—laughter easily provoked, often in the face of things which seem rather to call for tears; but beyond that the two races part company. The 399negro still loves his African leisure; if there is any one on earth without a trace of laziness in his make-up, surely it is the Chinese workman—though this be due merely to centuries of bitter competition for existence. Nor do the poorest of our cabin-dwelling blacks suffer anything like the poverty of the toilsome masses of China; even those of Haiti do not approach it. There are worse places in China, but even in this comparatively thinly populated northwest thousands of people quite willing to toil from sun to sun at anything promising them the slightest remuneration live under conditions in which it would literally be illegal to keep pigs in any well governed section of the Occident. You can always get men to do anything do-able, on short notice, in China; there is such an enormous surplus of them. If there is a little stream across the trail, there are sure to be men waiting to set those who are shod across it for a brass “cash” or two; if there is a load too cumbersome or too heavy for a donkey or a pack-mule, you can easily pick up men to carry it. Most of us have the comforting impression that, being inured to them for countless generations, they do not feel their hardships and sufferings as we should. No doubt they do not, for if they did it would be beyond human power to produce that cheerful atmosphere, as wholly devoid of surliness as of melancholy, with which they seem to surround their bitter lives.
The major compared the common workers, especially the coolies, to our Southern Black people, with whom his army experience had given him considerable familiarity. There’s a certain similarity in temperament; one could even think about how the more serious, yet still Chinese, non-working classes resemble the mixed-race or lighter-skinned Black individuals, who often appear to be reflecting on their mixed heritage. But it's easy to take that comparison too far. Both groups share a laid-back approach to life—quick to laugh, even at times that might warrant tears; but beyond that, the two races diverge. The Black person still appreciates their African leisure; if there’s anyone in the world who lacks any trace of laziness, it’s definitely the Chinese worker—though this may be simply due to centuries of harsh competition for survival. Even the poorest of our cabin-dwelling Black people don’t experience the same level of poverty as the hardworking masses in China; not even those in Haiti come close. There are worse places in China, but even in this relatively sparse northwest, thousands are eager to work from dawn to dusk for any small compensation, living under conditions that would be deemed illegal for keeping pigs in any well-regulated part of the West. You can always find people willing to do any achievable task on short notice in China; there’s such a massive surplus of labor. If there’s a small stream along the path, you’ll find men ready to help those in shoes cross it for a couple of brass “cash”; if a load is too big or heavy for a donkey or a pack mule, you can easily find men to carry it. Many of us have the comforting belief that, having endured these conditions for countless generations, they don’t perceive their difficulties and suffering the way we would. No doubt they don’t, for if they did, it would be impossible for them to maintain that cheerful environment, completely free of bitterness or sadness, that seems to envelop their harsh lives.
It was one of the surprises of our journey that feathered game was more than abundant where every other thing, down to the last grass-blade and the tiniest bit of offal, is laboriously gathered and fully utilized, where hunger drives into the pot everything that can possibly be made quasi-edible. Wild ducks and geese all but obscured the sun along every important river-valley; partridge, quail, and beautiful pheasants covering many a bushy slope, often even the planted fields themselves, as thickly as sparrows a barn-yard, were to be had almost for the shooting. Cliff-sides blue with pigeons, the air filled with drapery-like swirls of them, ceased in time even to draw the attention. Were the major less sensitive to the difference between this and big game stalking, I might mention that single shot which brought down eight of these silky-blue birds; though that, to be sure, was before the attempt to coerce a recalcitrant mule with the butt of a not too young and sturdy—not to say borrowed—shot-gun resulted so disastrously. There seldom was a time during all our long journey out through the west that a little exertion could not add wild fowl to our canned larder; yet, as far as we were ever able to discover, the hungry people of that region made no attempt to kill or capture them—nor to destroy the 400swarms of magpies, crows, sparrows, and rooks which it was hard to believe left anything of the crops for the men and beasts who toiled to raise them. The laws had nothing to say on the subject; we saw it proved that there is no prejudice against such food when it can be had, and granted that guns are rare and ammunition too expensive for a Chinese peasant, certainly the race has given proof enough of ingenuity and of accomplishing under difficulties to warrant astonishment at the apparent indifference to what in many regions is the most valuable product still ungathered.
It was one of the surprises of our journey that feathered game was more than plentiful in a place where everything else, even the last blade of grass and the tiniest scrap of offal, is painstakingly collected and fully used, where hunger drives people to cook anything that can be made somewhat edible. Wild ducks and geese nearly blocked out the sun along every major river valley; partridges, quail, and stunning pheasants covered many bushy slopes and often even the planted fields themselves, as thickly as sparrows in a barnyard, were easily available for the shooting. Cliff sides were filled with blue pigeons, the air swirling with them, so much so that they eventually ceased to capture anyone's attention. If the major were less sensitive to the difference between this and big game hunting, I might mention that one shot brought down eight of these silky-blue birds; that, however, was before the attempt to subdue a stubborn mule with the butt of a not-so-young and sturdy—not to say borrowed—shotgun ended so disastrously. There was hardly a time during our long journey through the west that we couldn't add wild fowl to our canned supplies with a little effort; yet, as far as we could ever tell, the hungry people of that area made no effort to kill or catch them—or to eliminate the swarms of magpies, crows, sparrows, and rooks which it was hard to believe left anything of the crops for the men and animals who worked hard to grow them. The laws had nothing to say about it; we saw it proven that there is no bias against such food when it can be obtained, and considering that guns are rare and ammunition too expensive for a Chinese peasant, the race has certainly shown enough ingenuity and ability to cope with challenges to raise questions about their apparent indifference to what in many regions is the most valuable resource still unharvested.
Every few hours we came upon a walled city. I never broke myself of the feeling that romance and the picturesqueness of the Middle Ages were sure to be found within them, a welcome relief from the sordid, filthy monotony outside. Yet invariably, when we had made our way through the long dusty suburb, crowded with outdoor eating-places and miserable shops full of everything to a coolie’s taste, with the din of the eager shouting of wares in our ears, and had passed through the big frowning gate towering above the massive old crenelated wall, we found the same filthy, uneven earth streets lined by the same miserable shops, in fact, shops often poorer and less energetic, conservative old establishments which had grown effete, while the comparative new-comers outside the walls still had the activity of youth. Black swine wandering at will, pariah dogs covered with great open sores, human beings in little better condition, were as common to the enclosed town as to the suburbs. Often the city itself seemed half deserted, with as many ruins and open spaces as occupied mud-dwellings, though its extramural outskirts might be densely crowded. Many towns were so poor and uninviting that our cartmen drove around them—always on the south side, we noticed, close beside the walls—and stopped at inns outside. There was at least one advantage in this, and perhaps one disadvantage. Though the city gates are in theory opened “when the chicken first sing,” as Chang put it, they might still be closed as late as six, and thus hold up our departure until we could rout out several sleepy soldiers with candle-lanterns, present visiting-cards to prove our rights to extra attention, and perhaps not be on our way again until the eastern horizon began to pale. On the other hand, there was, of course, whatever danger existed that bandits coming upon us in the night would have us at their mercy outside the walls. Yet I confess to having ridden through those outwardly mysterious old walled towns whenever it was reasonably possible, and to going for a stroll within them when we lodged outside, always in quest of that romantic something that seemed sure to be found there, yet never was.
Every few hours, we came across a walled city. I could never shake the feeling that the romance and charm of the Middle Ages had to be hiding inside them, a welcome escape from the grimy, dreary outside world. Yet, every time we made our way through the long, dusty outskirts, packed with outdoor eateries and miserable shops catering to every taste imaginable, and fought through the noise of vendors shouting their wares, we would pass through the large, foreboding gate that loomed above the thick, old battlement walls. What awaited us was the same dirty, uneven streets lined with the same sad shops, often worse and less vibrant than those outside, aging establishments that had grown tired while the newer ones outside the walls still had youthful energy. Wild black pigs roamed freely, pariah dogs covered in open sores, and people in only slightly better condition were just as common in the enclosed town as in the suburbs. Often, the city felt half-abandoned, with just as many ruins and empty spaces as occupied mud huts, despite the outskirts being densely populated. Many towns were so poor and uninviting that our cart drivers would steer around them—always on the south side, as we noticed, right next to the walls—and stop at inns outside. There was at least one upside to this, and maybe one downside. Although the city gates are technically supposed to open "when the rooster crows," as Chang put it, they might still be shut as late as six, delaying our departure until we could wake up several sleepy soldiers with candle lanterns, present visiting cards to prove our need for extra help, and sometimes not be on our way again until the eastern sky began to lighten. On the flip side, there was always the risk that if bandits found us at night, we would be vulnerable outside the walls. Still, I admit I rode through those outwardly enigmatic old walled towns whenever it was reasonable, and I would take walks inside them whenever we stayed outside, always in search of that romantic something that seemed bound to be there but never was.

In the Mohammedan section of Sian-fu there are men who, but for their Chinese garb and habits, might pass for Turks in Damascus or Constantinople
In the Muslim area of Sian-fu, there are men who, if it weren't for their Chinese clothing and customs, could easily be mistaken for Turks in Damascus or Istanbul.

Our chief cartman eating dinner in his favorite posture, and holding in one hand the string of “cash,” one thousand strong and worth about an American quarter, which served him as money
Our main cartman is having dinner in his favorite way, holding in one hand a string of “cash” — a thousand strong and worth about a quarter, which he uses as money.

A bit of cliff-dwelling town in the loess country, where any other color than a yellowish brown is extremely rare
A small cliffside town in the loess region, where any color other than a yellowish brown is very uncommon.

A corner of a wayside village, topped by a temple
A corner of a roadside village, crowned by a temple
401The smaller towns and hamlets that lay scattered along the way, and often thickly over the surrounding country, were also monotonously alike, always filthy and miserable, a few women in crippled feet hobbling about the doors of their caves or mud huts, numerous children with running noses and bare buttocks making the most of the dismal world about them, usually a group of the older men squatting in a circle in a sunny corner out of the wind and gambling for brass “cash” with small cards bearing no resemblance to our own. Throughout China it seems to be the convenient custom to dress small children in trousers cut out at the seat, so that they need no attention; and in this northwest country, at least, the people believe in hardening their offspring by exposure. In the depths of winter both boys and girls, between about five and ten, wear nothing but a ragged jacket of quilted cotton reaching barely to the waist, and wander disconsolately about with the lower half of the body naked, chapped, and begrimed, like the mittenless hands of the otherwise fully dressed adults. Undoubtedly this Spartan treatment makes those who survive less susceptible to cold, which is an important asset in the life of the Chinese masses.
401The smaller towns and villages scattered along the way, and often densely packed in the surrounding area, looked pretty much the same—always dirty and miserable. A few women with impaired feet shuffled around the entrances of their caves or mud huts, while numerous children with runny noses and bare bottoms tried to make the best of their gloomy surroundings. Usually, a group of older men would be sitting in a circle in a sunny spot out of the wind, gambling with small cards that bore no resemblance to our own for brass “cash.” Throughout China, it's common practice to dress small children in trousers that are open at the seat so they don’t need any extra care. In this northwest region, at least, people believe in toughening their kids through exposure. In the depths of winter, both boys and girls, aged around five to ten, wear nothing but a tattered quilted cotton jacket that barely covers their waist and wander around forlornly with their lower bodies naked, chapped, and dirty, like the mittenless hands of otherwise fully dressed adults. This tough treatment likely makes those who survive less sensitive to the cold, which is a significant benefit for the lives of the Chinese population.
If something caused one of us to halt a moment in town or village, all the community that had no possessions requiring a watchful eye quickly flocked closely about us,—dogs, boys, youths, men of all ages, and very young girls, though never, of course, the women. Did we chance to scribble in our note-books or fill a pipe, the crowding all but pinned our elbows to our sides. In larger towns or places where market-day had brought a throng, the dust raised by the dense crowd encircling us became a menace to the lungs. Fortunately timidity equals curiosity in such a gathering. Sometimes when suffocation seemed imminent I have sprung suddenly to my feet with a shout, and a kick or a blow that purposely fell short, and the stampede that ensued would wholly clear the vicinity for a hundred yards around in scarcely the time it takes to draw a long breath. It might be that two or three of the dispersed throng were men of higher caste, the town’s most important merchants or its scholars, and these, being more fearful of “losing face” before the common herd than of having an injury done them by the dubious stranger from another world, would retreat to a lesser distance with as leisurely dignity as their legs would permit, and stand there with an expression which seemed to say, “I dare you to maltreat a great man like me as if he were a common coolie, 402though I admit that I will retreat if you attempt to do so.” Then, the atmosphere having been cleared and one’s elbows freed from pressure, one had only to smile, implying that it had all been a joke, to have the crowd instantly roar with laughter at its own discomfiture—and soon close in again as tightly as ever.
If something made us stop for a moment in town or the village, everyone who didn't have anything that needed watching quickly gathered around us—dogs, boys, young men, men of all ages, and very young girls, but never the women, of course. If we happened to jot something down in our notebooks or light a pipe, the crowd almost pinned our elbows to our sides. In larger towns or at places bustling with market-day crowds, the dust raised by the dense gathering around us became a threat to our lungs. Luckily, shyness matched curiosity in such situations. Sometimes, when it felt like we could barely breathe, I'd jump up with a shout, throw a kick or a punch that was just for show, and the stampede that followed would clear the area a hundred yards around us in barely the time it takes to take a deep breath. It might be that a few of those who scattered were higher-caste men, the town's important merchants or scholars, and they, more concerned about “losing face” in front of the common crowd than getting hurt by the strange outsider, would back away to a safer distance with as much dignity as their legs allowed, standing there with an expression that seemed to say, “I dare you to treat someone important like me as if I'm just a common worker, though I will back off if you try.” Then, once the atmosphere was clear and we had room to breathe, all we had to do was smile, suggesting it had all been a joke, and the crowd would instantly burst into laughter at their own embarrassment—only to close in again as tightly as before.
Especially exasperating to the photographer is this tendency of the Chinese quickly to crowd about any one or anything unusual, for it is often impossible to get far enough away to get them in focus. My old trick of looking sidewise into the finder and pretending to photograph something else at right angles to the real victim was also not so effective as among the stolid, solemn, incurious Indians of the Andes. For if the instantly gathering crowd did not cut off the light or obscure the subject, the latter was almost sure to dash forward for a close view of the kodak. More than once, in trying to catch some street scene, I have pretended to be interested elsewhere until all the floating population in the vicinity was packed about me, then, dashing suddenly through the throng, I have sprinted to the spot previously chosen and snapped the shutter; yet in almost every such case there are at least several blurred objects in the foreground of the picture which in real life were Chinese youths or men who led the throng that pursued me.
Especially frustrating for the photographer is the tendency of the Chinese to quickly gather around anyone or anything unusual, making it often impossible to step back far enough to get them in focus. My old trick of looking sideways into the viewfinder and pretending to photograph something else at a right angle to the real subject was also less effective than it was with the stoic, serious, uninterested Indians of the Andes. Because if the quickly forming crowd didn't block the light or obscure the subject, the subject was almost guaranteed to rush forward for a close-up view of the camera. More than once, while trying to capture a street scene, I pretended to be interested in something else until all the people nearby closed in around me, then, suddenly darting through the crowd, I sprinted to the spot I'd picked out and snapped the shutter; yet in almost every case, there were at least several blurred figures in the foreground of the picture that were, in reality, Chinese youths or men who led the crowd that chased after me.
Pinchow was the largest town we saw in western Shensi, evidently a place of bygone glories, for a great wall climbing the crest of a high hill surrounded it, and just beyond stood the largest pagoda we had seen in the province. Terraces and caves were piled high, like mammoth walls, on two sides of it, and the road by which traffic from the east descends had been one of the steepest of all the journey, a dust-swirling gully down a mountain-side reëchoing from top to bottom with the panting, as if in death-throes, of the hundreds of mules still bearing eastward wicked cart-loads of wheat. It was in Pinchow, too, that we were forced to drive a sleeping coolie out of one miserable room and hang a saddle-cloth across the door of another in order to find accommodations in a miserable ruin of an inn, where Chang and the cook had to do their best over a little fire of dung and twigs out in the bare, wind-swept yard. By this time the nights had grown bitter cold, and the broken paper windows of a room did not need an open door to aid them.
Pinchow was the largest town we saw in western Shensi, clearly a place of former glory, as a great wall climbing the top of a high hill surrounded it, and just beyond stood the biggest pagoda we had seen in the province. Terraces and caves were stacked high, like massive walls, on two sides of it, and the road by which traffic from the east descends had been one of the steepest of the whole journey, a dust-swirling gully down the mountainside echoing from top to bottom with the panting, as if in death throes, of the hundreds of mules still carrying heavy cart-loads of wheat eastward. It was in Pinchow, too, that we had to wake a sleeping coolie from one dreary room and hang a saddle-cloth across the door of another to find a place to stay in a rundown inn, where Chang and the cook had to make do with a small fire of dung and twigs out in the bare, wind-swept yard. By this time, the nights had become bitterly cold, and the broken paper windows of a room didn’t need an open door to let in the chill.
Here, too, things came to a head with the owner of our riding-mules. Evidently the man who contracts for the carrying of the mails out of Sian-fu had agreed to furnish us animals and had accepted the advance on them first, and had turned his attention to getting the animals 403afterward. For the first man who accompanied them turned out to be a mere coolie, without money even to buy them food; and when he was overtaken by the owner himself on the evening of the second day, the latter had the unwillingness of one who had been forced to do something against his will. He had with him, in a long sock-like purse worn inside his quilted garments, most of the silver dollars we had paid in advance, the contractor having kept the rest as his commission or “squeeze.” But he hated to transform those dollars into food for his mules, and he was constantly hinting that he should be allowed to take the animals and go home. Just why was not apparent, since we were paying him more than he habitually got for the same journey with loads of mail weighing half again what we did, and which never got off and walked; and of course he had always plodded on foot after his mules just as he was doing now.
Here, too, things reached a breaking point with the owner of our riding mules. Clearly, the guy who arranged for the mail delivery out of Sian-fu had agreed to provide us with animals and had accepted our payment upfront, but then he focused on getting the animals afterward. The first person he sent with them turned out to be just a laborer, with no money even to buy them food. When the owner caught up with him on the evening of the second day, he seemed reluctant, as if he was forced to do something he didn’t want to. He had most of the silver dollars we had paid in advance stuffed in a long pouch worn inside his quilted clothes, with the contractor keeping the rest as his cut or “squeeze.” But he didn’t want to spend those dollars on food for his mules and kept suggesting that he should be allowed to take the animals and go home. The reason for his reluctance wasn’t clear, since we were paying him more than he usually received for the same trip carrying mail that weighed about 50% more than our loads, and he had always walked after his mules just like he was doing now. 403
It was still black night and we were about to leave Pinchow behind when this fellow suddenly fell on his knees in the yard before us, and, bowing to the earth, like a suppliant before a Chinese emperor, implored us to let him go home, for he was losing money on the journey and so on. The average American, I fancy, does not like to be prayed to; in fact his reaction is likely to be what ours was, such a mixture of disgust and anger at such degraded nonsense as to make it difficult to keep from administering a kick. Yet there was a hint of the pathetic about the fellow—until we reflected that of the dollar a day he was getting for each mule he was paying out only a hundred “cash” or so to feed him. He could not spend more on them, he wailed, because he had a family of twenty to feed and clothe. Chinese families, however, are elastic institutions, and we advised him to let a few of his useless dependents starve and feed the mules, who were doing the work. For if he did not give them a reasonable amount, we warned him, we would feed them, and take the cost of it out of what was to be paid him at the end of the journey. This was not a completely effective cure, but at least it substantially increased the share which the animals had in the reward of their labor.
It was still dark night and we were about to leave Pinchow behind when this guy suddenly dropped to his knees in the yard in front of us, and, bowing to the ground like a supplicant before a Chinese emperor, begged us to let him go home, claiming he was losing money on the trip and so on. The average American, I think, doesn’t like to be prayed to; in fact, his reaction is probably similar to ours, a mix of disgust and anger at such demeaning nonsense that makes it hard not to kick him. Yet there was something sad about the guy—until we remembered that of the dollar a day he was getting for each mule, he was spending only about a hundred “cash” or so to feed them. He couldn’t spend more on them, he moaned, because he had a family of twenty to feed and clothe. However, Chinese families can be quite adaptable, and we suggested he let a few of his unnecessary dependents go hungry and start feeding the mules, who were doing the work. Because if he didn’t provide them with a decent amount, we warned him, we would feed them and take the cost out of what he was supposed to get paid at the end of the journey. This wasn’t a perfect solution, but at least it significantly increased the share that the animals got from their hard work.
For many li beyond Pinchow we followed the valley of the King Ho, walled with cliff-dwellers on either side as far as the eye could see. There were persimmon orchards in the rich flatlands close to the stream, the last of the fruit being picked from pole-and-vine ladders, and acres of it drying in the sun by day, with reed-mat covers over them to keep off the night frosts, and little cave-shaped watch-houses near-by to protect them from the omnipresent crop-thieves. Some of the cliffs 404above us were of sandstone, and the caves dug in these were much smaller than those in the loess. Once we passed a big temple carved in the sandstone mountain-side, with huge colored Buddhas smirking at us from the foot of it farther on; and in two or three places the river crowded our side of the valley so closely that the road had dug itself in along the face of the cliff. Donkeys each carrying two huge lumps of what looked like magnificent anthracite coal began to clutter the way, for some of the best of Shensi’s many mines are in this vicinity. Small wonder the traffic of centuries had worn cañons in the soft loess; we passed places that day and the next where cart-wheels had worn gullies axle-deep in solid rock. Let a cart get caught in one of these, and not a wheel of the long procession could move until some means had been devised to drag it out again. Jang-wu—to spell it as it sounded—was a once high-walled and important city which both man and nature seemed to have decided to scrap. It appeared to be mainly Mohammedan, with a mournful, surly atmosphere, and was mostly deserted, except perhaps on market-days, the loess worn away in mammoth moats on both sides of its half-ruined wall, and all about it myriads of graves. Then one morning, almost unexpectedly, we found that we had left the province of Shensi behind us.
For many li beyond Pinchow, we followed the valley of the King Ho, flanked by cliff dwellers on both sides as far as we could see. There were persimmon orchards in the fertile flatlands near the stream, with the last of the fruit being picked from poles and ladders, and large areas drying in the sun during the day, covered with reed mats at night to protect them from frost, while little cave-shaped watchtowers nearby guarded against ever-present crop thieves. Some of the cliffs above us were made of sandstone, and the caves carved into them were much smaller than those in the loess. We passed a large temple carved into the sandstone mountainside, with massive colorful Buddhas looking down at us from farther on; and in a couple of spots, the river edged so closely to our side of the valley that the road had carved itself into the cliff face. Donkeys, each carrying two huge lumps that looked like beautiful anthracite coal, began to block our path, as some of the best mines in Shensi are located in this area. It's no wonder the traffic of centuries has carved canyons into the soft loess; we passed spots that day and the next where cart wheels had worn deep gullies into solid rock. If a cart got stuck in one of those, not a wheel in the long line could move until someone figured out how to pull it out. Jang-wu—spelled as it sounds—was once a high-walled and significant city that both people and nature seemed to have given up on. It seemed mostly Mohammedan, with a gloomy, unfriendly vibe, and was largely deserted, except maybe on market days, with the loess eroded into huge moats on both sides of its crumbling wall, surrounded by countless graves. Then, one morning, almost unexpectedly, we realized we had left the province of Shensi behind us.
CHAPTER XXII
China's Far West
From the moment that it enters the province of Kansu, the most westerly of China proper, the ancient route from Sian-fu to Lanchow is lined by huge old willows, supplanted here and there by a sturdy poplar. A heritage from some far-seeing ruler of the province under the old dynasty, these flank with four rows, and occasionally with six, the wide strip of land on which a road might long since have been built, had it not been in China. But though there seems to be some strong sentiment, probably with fear as its main ingredient, against cutting them down, not a few of the trees are missing; and the many more that stand with their roots indecently exposed explain what befell those that are gone. For how can a tree live to ripe old age in a loess region where the earth is constantly dropping away or blowing out from under it?
From the moment it enters the province of Kansu, the westernmost part of China, the ancient route from Sian-fu to Lanchow is lined with large old willows, occasionally replaced by a sturdy poplar. This is a legacy from a visionary ruler of the province from the old dynasty; they flank the wide stretch of land where a road could have been built long ago, if it weren't China. Although there seems to be a strong sentiment, likely rooted in fear, against cutting them down, quite a few of the trees are missing; and the many more that stand with their roots exposed show what happened to those that are gone. After all, how can a tree survive to old age in a loess region where the earth is always eroding or blowing away from beneath it?
Yet this unusual bit of Chinese forethought arouses a grateful feeling in the passing traveler. In cloudless summer the shade must be a godsend; and though the November sun was so welcome that travelers had already worn paths along the edge of the winter wheat on the south side of the shaded route, the long rows of waving branches were a joy merely to look upon in a region where one may journey for days at a time without catching sight of another tree, or even the slightest living thing of the vegetable kingdom, as far as the eye can reach on either hand. Magpies and crows build great stick nests in these branches, but it was noticeable that boys who will struggle for the possession of a twig or the most unseemly substitute for fuel on the ground below never climb up after the abandoned nests that would make such a fine haul. The reason is probably simple: they are afraid; for while his Western contemporary is constantly risking his neck in hazardous feats which have no economic value, the Chinese boy displays that timidity which habitually remains with him as a man, even in the face of material rewards for a bit of courage.
Yet this unusual bit of Chinese foresight makes passing travelers feel grateful. In perfect summer weather, the shade must be a blessing; and although the November sun was so appreciated that travelers had already worn paths along the edge of the winter wheat on the south side of the shaded route, the long rows of swaying branches were simply a pleasure to behold in an area where one can travel for days without seeing another tree or even the slightest hint of vegetation as far as the eye can see in either direction. Magpies and crows build large stick nests in these branches, but it was noticeable that boys who would fight over a twig or the most unattractive substitute for fuel on the ground never climb up to get the abandoned nests that would be such a great find. The reason is probably simple: they are afraid; because while his Western counterpart is constantly taking risks in dangerous feats that have no economic value, the Chinese boy shows a timidity that usually stays with him into adulthood, even when there are tangible rewards for a bit of bravery.
We found it 430 li from Sian-fu to the border, and crossed it at the village of Yao-tien early on the fifth morning. By this time we were 406up on the plateau which, gradually rolling higher and higher, culminates in the lofty land of Tibet; and though here it may not be more than three or four thousand feet above the sea, this was enough to give appreciable aid to advancing winter. All that day there was a wind fit to blow us off the map, with every promise of a snow-storm to come, and everywhere women and children, and not a few men, were out gleaning the little dead willow branches as they fell, almost in showers. With the sun gone it was bitter cold now, and we were forced to walk almost as much as we rode. It was on this fifth day that we met two Russian Jews with long beards, and a string of carts the first of which flew a makeshift white flag bearing some Chinese characters and the assertion, “Belong Americun firm from New Jork.” Possibly, the misspelling aside, it did, but in these days allegiances are often quickly made by those foreigners in China who would otherwise lose their rights of extraterritoriality and the greater protection for their persons and their belongings which goes with it.
We found it 430 li from Sian-fu to the border and crossed at the village of Yao-tien early on the fifth morning. By then we were 406up on the plateau which gradually rises higher and higher, leading to the highlands of Tibet; and although it may not be more than three or four thousand feet above sea level, that was enough to noticeably enhance the approaching winter. All day, there was a wind strong enough to blow us off course, promising a snowstorm ahead, and everywhere women and children, along with a few men, were out gathering the fallen dead willow branches as they dropped almost like rain. With the sun gone, it was bitterly cold now, and we were forced to walk almost as much as we rode. On this fifth day, we encountered two Russian Jews with long beards, along with a line of carts. The first cart had a makeshift white flag with some Chinese characters and the words, “Belong Americun firm from New Jork.” Maybe the misspelling aside, it likely did belong, but these days, allegiances are often quickly formed by foreigners in China who would otherwise lose their rights of extraterritoriality and the extra protection for themselves and their belongings that come with it.
Some sage has asserted, in the face of ample proof to the contrary, that it never rains but it pours, and on that day at least we were inclined to agree with him. For barely an hour afterward, while we sat eating a cold lunch on the cold k’ang of a miserable little inn, with only hot tea to improve the situation, two more foreigners walked in upon us. They were big sturdy Catholic priests, Hollanders and twin brothers, also in great forests of beards, and wearing cassock-like Chinese gowns that showed signs of long and arduous travel. One had been for thirty years, and the other for three, in Sinkiang, or Chinese Turkestan, and having been ordered to another post in northern China, they had set out in August and been already three months on the road. The natural route to their new station would have been northward from Lanchow, down or along the Yellow River, but bandits were said to be so active along it that they had struck eastward instead. It would be unjust to assume another reason which may not have existed; but personally, if I had lived for thirty years, or even for three, in Sinkiang, I should have gone a little out of my way, bandits or no bandits, to travel on railways and see at least Peking and get a little bit in touch again with the Western world before burying myself once more in the far interior of China. The animation of the padres during our brief conversation in English and French and an occasional word of Chinese proved that they had not grown indifferent to Caucasian intercourse for all their long exile; indeed, they somewhat resembled in manner college boys who have just reached home after a freshman year without vacations. 407The new pope, they said, and we had confirmations of the statement on our western trip, was filling all the posts in a large area of central Asia with German priests, and moving the former incumbents, among whom Belgians predominate, to less strategic positions.
Some wise person has claimed, despite plenty of evidence to the contrary, that it never rains but it pours, and on that day we were ready to agree with him. Just an hour later, while we were having a cold lunch on the chilly k’ang of a sad little inn, with only hot tea to make things better, two more foreigners walked in on us. They were big, strong Catholic priests, from Holland and twin brothers, sporting impressive beards and wearing Chinese-style gowns that looked worn from long travel. One had been in Sinkiang, or Chinese Turkestan, for thirty years, and the other for three. They were being transferred to another post in northern China and had set out in August, already three months into their journey. The most direct route to their new station would have been north from Lanchow, down or along the Yellow River, but because bandits were reported to be active there, they had decided to head east instead. It wouldn’t be fair to assume there was another reason that may not have existed; however, if I had spent thirty years, or even just three, in Sinkiang, I would have made a bit of a detour, bandits or not, to take the train and see at least Peking, getting more in touch with the Western world before retreating back into the depths of China. The liveliness of the priests during our short conversation in English and French, with the occasional word in Chinese, showed they hadn’t become indifferent to interactions with Westerners despite their long exile; in fact, they reminded me a bit of college students who have just come home after a freshman year without any breaks. 407 They mentioned that the new pope, a statement we had confirmed on our western trip, was assigning German priests to numerous posts across a large area of central Asia and moving the current ones—mostly Belgians—to less strategic positions.
In all the sixteen days between the capitals of Shensi and Kansu we did not, unless my memory fails me, meet another traveling foreigner; hence our astonishment at seeing four in one morning. There was, indeed, appreciably less native travel in the new province, though great chunks of coal were still coming out on donkey-back, and wheelbarrows were creaking under all sorts of loads, particularly of huge pears for which the province is famous, and which, persimmons growing rare, constituted our chief dessert all the rest of the journey.
In the whole sixteen days between the capitals of Shensi and Kansu, we did not, unless I’m mistaken, encounter another traveling foreigner; so we were surprised to see four in one morning. There was definitely a noticeable drop in local travel in the new province, although large amounts of coal were still being transported on donkeys, and wheelbarrows were creaking under all kinds of loads, especially the huge pears that the province is known for, which, with persimmons becoming rare, made up our main dessert for the rest of the journey.
Several wandering trails that kept us out of the chasm—though on the plain above the unhampered wind threatened at any moment to lift us from the saddle—came to agreement at last with the road, and we went down a mighty descent, which toward the end was rudely stone-paved, into the populous town of Kingchow. Here the earthquake of two years before, greater reminders of which we were to see farther on, had among other feats neatly broken in two both a high hill and the temple that stood upon it, so that a score of heathen idols in intense discordant colors and devilish postures stood out only half protected from the cold windy world. A church steeple rather incongruously broke the sky-line of the lower town, and in the neat compound beneath it we found hospitality for the first time with those Scandinavian-American missionaries scattered all along our western route. The sturdy couple—sturdiness is an all but necessary asset for inland China mission-fields—who had been cultivating this not too promising human garden since the days of their youth, had had their share of adversities; but the one that came most nearly shaking their faith had happened within the last two years. After decades of struggle with contributors at home and workmen and contractors on the spot, they had at last reached the proud day when their imposing black brick church was not only completed but relieved of its mortgage. While his wife and coworker superintended important operations in the kitchen and dining-room, the pastor sat down to write the glorious news to his religious constituents in America. “At last, dear brethren,” he began, “our church, center of a vast district that has no other, is fin——” “Brrrrum!” came a sudden roaring and cracking of walls and ceiling, apparently even of the ground itself, while pictures swung to and fro from their pegs, and the furniture danced a sort of improvised Virginia reel. It 408was all over before the missionaries had wholly realized that a great earthquake had occurred, but when they went out to look at it the new church was cracked and split and broken, an all but useless ruin.
Several wandering paths that kept us away from the ravine—though on the flat ground above the unrestrained wind threatened at any moment to knock us off our saddles—eventually aligned with the road, and we rode down a steep slope that ended in a rough stone pavement, leading us into the bustling town of Kingchow. Here, we encountered the earthquake from two years ago, whose greater signs we would see later, which had neatly split a high hill and the temple on top of it in two, leaving a bunch of pagan idols in vivid, clashing colors and sinister poses only partly shielded from the harsh wind. A church steeple awkwardly broke the skyline of the lower town, and in the tidy yard beneath it, we finally found hospitality for the first time with Scandinavian-American missionaries scattered along our western route. The sturdy couple—sturdiness being almost essential for mission work in inland China—had been tending to this not-so-promising mission since their youth and had faced their share of challenges; however, the one that came closest to shaking their faith had occurred within the last two years. After decades of struggles with donors back home and workers and contractors locally, they had finally reached the proud day when their impressive black brick church was not only completed but also free from its mortgage. While his wife and co-worker managed important tasks in the kitchen and dining room, the pastor sat down to write the great news to his religious supporters in America. “At last, dear brethren,” he began, “our church, the center of a vast district with no other, is fin——” “Brrrrum!” suddenly erupted, with a roaring and cracking of walls and ceilings, and seemingly the ground itself, as pictures swung back and forth from their hooks, and the furniture performed a sort of improvised Virginia reel. It 408was all over before the missionaries fully realized that a massive earthquake had struck, but when they went outside to see the damage, the new church was cracked, split, and broken—a nearly useless ruin.
The threat of snow was gone next morning, which was calm and bright, with hardly a breeze where the raging wind had been. The route lay up a river valley all the way to Pingliang, and fully half the populace along the way, it seemed, was out sweeping up with their crude bundle-of-sticks brooms the last vestige of leaves and twigs from under the willow-trees. In this all but fuel-less land there is an added meaning to the old adage beginning with something about an ill wind. There were countless half-ruined mud-wall compounds along the valley, from the edge of which sprang the inevitable piles of terraced fields. Strings of donkeys, each with two huge yellow-brown glazed jars filled with smaller ones in straw, looked at a little distance like some curious type of land-crab. We had scarcely seen a soldier since leaving Sian-fu, but now we began meeting long lines of them again, whole armies, at least as the word is used in China, moving eastward in carts, on horses, and on mules, and once or twice on long strings of camels. They were dark, rather surly-looking fellows, I fancied, though this may have been only fancy, or the effect of an outdoor life on men with the higher bridged noses that suggested a considerable strain of Arab blood. In Shensi Moslems are not recruited as soldiers; but in Kansu, the stronghold of the Chinese Mohammedans, there are many thousands of them in uniform; and here they marched freely over the winter wheat, an inch high, with that complete indifference to the rights of the laborious peasants along the way which is typical of bandits and soldiers alike throughout China.
The threat of snow was gone the next morning, which was calm and bright, with hardly a breeze where the raging wind had been. The route went up a river valley all the way to Pingliang, and it seemed like half the people living along the way were out sweeping up the last bits of leaves and twigs from under the willow trees with their makeshift bundle-of-sticks brooms. In this almost fuel-less land, there’s a deeper meaning to the old saying about an ill wind. There were countless half-ruined mud-walled compounds along the valley, from the edges of which sprang the usual piles of terraced fields. Strings of donkeys, each carrying two huge yellow-brown glazed jars filled with smaller ones in straw, looked a little like some strange type of land crab from a distance. We had barely seen a soldier since leaving Sian-fu, but now we started encountering long lines of them again—whole armies, at least as the term is used in China—moving eastward in carts, on horses, and on mules, and once or twice on long strings of camels. They were dark, rather grumpy-looking guys, I thought, though it might have just been my imagination or the effect of an outdoor life on men with higher bridged noses suggesting a strong strain of Arab blood. In Shensi, Muslims aren’t recruited as soldiers; but in Kansu, the stronghold of the Chinese Mohammedans, there are many thousands of them in uniform; and here they marched freely over the winter wheat, just an inch high, with total indifference to the rights of the hardworking peasants along the way, which is typical of bandits and soldiers alike throughout China.
Yet our hosts of the night before had assured us that the soldiers of Kansu were well disciplined; for instance, they cited, they always took off their hats when they entered a church—perhaps, I reflected, as they would expect us to take off our shoes in their places of worship—and let down their cues. For it is as great a discourtesy to come indoors with the cue tied around the head as it is in the old-fashioned parts of China to speak to an equal or a superior without removing the eye-glasses.
Yet our hosts from the night before had assured us that the soldiers from Kansu were well-disciplined; for example, they mentioned that they always took off their hats when entering a church—perhaps, I thought, just as they would expect us to take off our shoes in their places of worship—and let down their hair. It's considered very rude to enter a room with your hair tied up just like it's considered disrespectful in traditional parts of China to speak to someone of the same status or higher without taking off your glasses.

The Chinese coolie gets his hair dressed about once a month by the itinerant barber. This one is just in the act of adding a switch. Note the wooden comb at the back of the head
The Chinese laborer gets his hair styled about once a month by the traveling barber. This barber is currently in the process of adding a hairpiece. Notice the wooden comb at the back of his head.

An old countryman having dinner at an outdoor restaurant in town on market day has his own way of using chairs or benches
An old farmer having dinner at an outdoor restaurant in town on market day has his own way of using chairs or benches.

A Chinese soldier and his mount, not to mention his worldly possessions
A Chinese soldier and his horse, along with his belongings

Mongol women on a joy-ride
Mongol women on a joyride
409The town where we made our midday halt was denim blue with market-day. There were big, upstanding six-foot men whom America would hardly have recognized as Chinese; and some of them, from back in the hills, though they had heard of white people before, had never seen them. These and their hardy, red-cheeked boys timidly crowded nearer and nearer the knock-kneed table which Chang had somehow found and placed for us in a wind-sheltered, sun-flooded corner of the inn-yard, retreating in a pell-mell mass if we rose to our feet or looked fixedly at them. In China market-day is usually a fixed institution, frequently recurring in most towns. Then the wooden-box bellows with a stick handle manipulated by a boy or a coolie, which is indispensable to craftsman or cook reduced to a mainly dung fuel, may be heard thumping by scores or hundreds along the thronged street. The shallow eating-shops, which thrust their customers out of doors to squat on raised strips of board or on their own haunches, steaming bowl and chop-sticks in hand, are so busy that they almost cease to shout for clients. The outdoor hair-dressers for men may sometimes not move their portable paraphernalia from a chosen spot all day long, and take in what to them is a small fortune, though their charges would by no means keep an American barber in soap. Wielding a razor suggestive of a carpenter’s draw-shave, a wooden comb which the maker across the way saws out by hand with a dozen or a score of others from a single round block, and carrying a most scanty supply of other essentials, they all but transform the hirsute countrymen who fall into their hands. For they are not satisfied with mere shaving as we understand it, but wipe out everything the broad blade encounters—down the upper cheek, a stray hair on the nose, the eyebrows, the hair itself, leaving the victim a striking resemblance to a boiled onion, unless he calls a halt with the information that he still considers the cue essential to his beauty and well-being. Even then, they say, the barber sometimes talks him out of the old-fashioned notion—though it is hardly that in Kansu—and he joins the growing ranks of Chinese men, who, having recognized the pigtail as a badge of servitude rather than an honorable adornment, go as far to the opposite extreme as is consistent with a whole—no, often a sadly gashed—scalp. But if the client’s taste is not to be changed by preaching or example, the last rite is the combing out of his often magnificent black tresses, reduced of course in area to about the size of a saucer, and the making of them into a braid which may perhaps not be undone again for two or three moons.
409The town where we stopped for lunch was bustling with the market crowd. There were tall, strong men who you wouldn’t easily identify as Chinese; some of them, hailing from the hills, had heard of white people but had never seen one. These men and their sturdy, rosy-cheeked boys timidly gathered closer to the rickety table that Chang had managed to find and set up for us in a sunny, sheltered spot in the inn's yard, and they would scatter in a rush if we stood up or looked directly at them. In China, market day is a regular event, often happening in most towns. You could hear the wooden bellows, operated by a boy or a coolie, thumping away, vital for any craftsman or cook using mainly dung fuel, echoing along the crowded streets by the dozens or hundreds. The small eatery shops that push their customers outside to sit on raised wooden strips or on their haunches, steaming bowls and chopsticks in hand, are so busy that they almost stop calling for patrons. Outdoor barbers for men might keep their portable setups in the same spot all day, raking in what seems like a fortune to them, although their fees wouldn’t even cover an American barber's soap costs. With a razor that looks like a carpenter's draw-shave and a wooden comb made from a single round block, along with very few other supplies, they basically reshape the countryside men's look. They don’t just stop at shaving as we know it; they go over everything the broad blade touches—up the cheeks, stray hairs on the nose, eyebrows, and the hair itself—leaving the poor guy looking like a boiled onion, unless he insists on keeping the cue, which he believes is essential for his looks and well-being. Even then, the barber might convince him otherwise—though that’s hardly a common take in Kansu—and he might join the growing number of Chinese men who see the pigtail as a symbol of servitude instead of a dignified adornment, taking their look to the other extreme, often resulting in a sadly butchered scalp. But if the customer is set on his preferences, the last step is combing out his often beautiful black hair, which is reduced in size to about the area of a saucer, and braiding it in a way that likely won’t be undone for a couple of months.
But our carts perhaps are creaking out again through the inn-yard gate, and we must ride after them, leaving the hundred other scenes of market-day for some other place, for they are constantly repeated everywhere. Caves and terraces and cañon roads continue; the afternoon is June-like, the leaves of the willows and rare poplars hardly 410beginning to turn, though November is stepping on. Down in the river valley the soil is somewhat harder, so that for a little time we move without being enveloped in a cloud of dust; but the air is so dry that cigars and lips suffer. Passing coolies carry their money in strings of “cash,” a thousand to each string, broken up into hundreds by knots and the ends tied together to make carrying easy. We would hardly call it that, however, if in addition to already mighty burdens we had to plod our way across a thirsty country with ten pounds of money worth less than an American quarter; for in this region the exchange averaged twenty-three hundred “cash” to the “Mex” dollar. This does not, of course, reduce the perforated brass coin of China to anything like the low estate of the Russian ruble or the German mark, but those are of paper and may be printed in any denomination, while the “cash” always remains the single coin, both in weight and bulk. I do not recall offhand any commodity that represents the value of a “cash”; I might say it is worth about one peanut, but that would be true only in China, and only in certain regions during the most plentiful peanut season, certainly never in America, for it takes fully forty “cash” to make an American cent. Perhaps a match comes most nearly being an even exchange, and then the wonder comes up that they do not use those instead, and save weight and some of the difficulties of reckoning, and always have something of real immediate value as well as a nominal and fictitious one. But your Chinese coolie, once out of gunshot of the big cities at least, and even the merchants up to a surprising grade, prefers his money in “cash,” irrespective of weight and all its other drawbacks.
But our carts are probably creaking out again through the inn-yard gate, and we have to ride after them, leaving behind the many other scenes of market day for another time, since they're constantly repeated everywhere. Caves, terraces, and canyon roads continue; the afternoon feels like June, with the leaves of the willows and rare poplars just starting to turn, even though November is approaching. Down in the river valley, the ground is a bit harder, so for a little while we move without being surrounded by a cloud of dust; but the air is so dry that cigars and lips are suffering. Passing coolies carry their money in strings of “cash,” a thousand to each string, broken into hundreds by knots, with the ends tied together for easier carrying. We wouldn’t call it that, though, if we had to trudge across a dry landscape with ten pounds of money that's worth less than an American quarter; in this area, the exchange rate averages twenty-three hundred “cash” to the “Mex” dollar. This doesn’t lower the value of China's perforated brass coin to the level of the Russian ruble or the German mark, but those are paper and can be printed in any denomination, while the “cash” remains a single coin type in both weight and bulk. I can't think of any item that represents the value of a “cash.” I could say it’s worth about one peanut, but that’s true only in China and only in certain regions during peanut season, definitely not in America, where it takes about forty “cash” to equal one American cent. Perhaps a match is the closest thing to an even exchange, which raises the question of why they don’t just use those instead, saving weight and some of the hassle of counting, while also having something of real immediate value alongside a nominal and fictional one. But your Chinese coolie, at least once out of gunshot of the big cities, and even merchants to a surprising extent, prefers his money in “cash,” regardless of weight and all its other drawbacks.
In Peking and the treaty-ports small transactions are usually in coppers, which are worth a whole fourth of an American cent each; and silver ten-, twenty-, and fifty-cent pieces, unknown and unacceptable in Shensi and Kansu, are as frequent there as the “Mex” dollar of which they are fractions. It is no uncommon thing, indeed, for Peking coolies to accept bank-notes, if they are sure of the giver and if the issuing bank is not Chinese but foreign, with a local branch. But, after all, a copper is not much lighter than ten “cash,” and less convenient, having no hole for stringing, and next above that in the west comes the dollar, which is more than many a coolie ever owns at one time, and may turn out to be false anyway; while, as to bank-notes, they are no more current in the interior than Confederate shinplasters are in New York. Our own funds, by the way, we carried in the form of letters of credit issued by the Chinese post-office in Peking and payable 411by the postal commissioner at the several large cities we visited, in which he was either a foreigner or the graduate of a foreign school. But even our cartmen, who were well above the coolie status, lugged strings of “cash,” usually about their persons, and every morning and every noon they unfailingly engaged in a loud and heated controversy with the innkeeper and all his functionaries, down to the ragged fellow who drew water, over the amount that should be transferred from the traveling strings to those that remained behind. Only in a few cases was there a grooved measuring-board to obviate the laborious task of counting the miserable bits of poor brass one by one. For of course no one could take it for granted that there were a hundred “cash” between each knot; and usually he would have been swindled if he did. Aside from the all but universal Chinese custom of short-changing wherever it is possible, in many regions accepted fictions in money matters reign, so that in one town a “hundred cash” is really only ninety, and if you are informed that six walnuts cost a copper you hand over nine “cash”; and perhaps in the next place a string of “cash” is nominally a thousand but really nine hundred and forty, and “nine coppers is ten coppers here, master, only if it is in ‘cash’ it is nine and then a little bit, and so....” And so, while we might have been able to get along without Chang, or the cook either, for that matter, so far as mere eating and the like go, he became indispensable in saving us from insanity in the handling of money.
In Peking and the treaty ports, small transactions are usually in coppers, which are worth a quarter of an American cent each. Silver ten-, twenty-, and fifty-cent pieces, which are unknown and unacceptable in Shensi and Kansu, are as common there as the “Mex” dollar, of which they are fractions. It’s not uncommon for Peking coolies to accept banknotes, as long as they trust the giver and the issuing bank is foreign with a local branch. However, a copper isn’t much lighter than ten “cash” and is less convenient since it doesn’t have a hole for stringing. The dollar, which comes next in the hierarchy, is more than many coolies ever have at one time and could turn out to be counterfeit; and as for banknotes, they’re as useless in the interior as Confederate shinplasters are in New York. By the way, we carried our funds in letters of credit issued by the Chinese post office in Peking, payable by the postal commissioner in the larger cities we visited, where he was either a foreigner or a graduate of a foreign school. Even our cartmen, who were well above the coolie level, often carried strings of “cash” with them, and every morning and noon they would get into loud and heated arguments with the innkeeper and his staff, including the ragged guy who drew water, about how much cash should be transferred from their traveling strings to those left behind. Only in a few cases was there a measuring board to avoid the tedious task of counting the worthless brass pieces one by one. After all, nobody could assume there were a hundred “cash” between each knot, and usually, they would have been cheated if they did. Besides the almost universal Chinese practice of short-changing whenever possible, in many places there are accepted fictions in money matters, so in one town a “hundred cash” might actually only be ninety, and if you’re told that six walnuts cost a copper, you’d hand over nine “cash.” In the next place, a string of “cash” may be nominally a thousand but really only nine hundred and forty, and “nine coppers is ten coppers here, master, but if it's 'cash' it’s nine and then a little bit, and so on...” So while we could have managed without Chang or the cook for basic needs, he became essential for keeping us sane when dealing with money.
Pingliang was the largest city on our route between Sian-fu and Lanchow. In a way it was the most picturesque, too; at least there were few such pictures as that down its swarming, shop- and hawker-crowded thoroughfare seen through the outer gate with the inner one in the middle distance. I reached it somewhat ahead of the others, and as I was worming my way through the second barrier, leading my mule and showing every evidence of having been on the road for a week, a man in the human stream bound in the same direction addressed me. It was not until his second remark that I realized that he was speaking English, and even then I took him to be some inn-runner who was trying to induce me to patronize his miserable establishment. We had looked forward to being spared that fate in Pingliang, for several sets of Protestant missionaries had made us promise to look up their co-workers there. I replied, therefore, still giving my attention to the picturesque chaos about me rather than to the speaker, that I expected to stop with foreigners at the Fu-ying-tong. How 412should I have known that I, suddenly bursting into town in the guise of anything but a reputable person, was informing a total stranger that I expected him to take me in as a guest as soon I could find his house? For it was the first time in my life that I had met a foreigner parading the streets in Chinese garb; besides, the Swedish-American head of the Protestant work in Pingliang happens to be of a physical size not inclined to make him conspicuous in a Chinese crowd.
Pingliang was the biggest city on our route between Sian-fu and Lanchow. In a way, it was also the most picturesque; there were few views like the bustling street filled with shops and vendors as seen through the outer gate, with the inner gate in the background. I arrived somewhat ahead of the others, and as I was making my way through the second barrier, leading my mule and clearly showing signs of being on the road for a week, a man in the crowd headed in the same direction spoke to me. It wasn't until his second comment that I realized he was speaking English, and even then, I thought he was just some inn-runner trying to get me to stay at his shabby place. We were hoping to avoid that in Pingliang, since several sets of Protestant missionaries had asked us to connect with their colleagues there. So I replied, still focusing on the chaotic scenery around me more than on him, that I planned to stay with foreigners at the Fu-ying-tong. How 412 was I to know that, suddenly arriving in town looking anything but respectable, I was telling a complete stranger I expected him to host me as soon as I could locate his house? It was the first time in my life I had met a foreigner walking the streets in Chinese clothing; besides, the Swedish-American leader of the Protestant work in Pingliang happened to be of a build that wouldn't stand out in a Chinese crowd.
Before the days of the republic, I learned later, when in spite of my barbarism we were comfortably installed in his home with the glorious prospect of a hot bath in the offing, he had sported even a blond pigtail, like many of the inland missionaries. I need hardly add that this was removed when, on rare occasions, he visited the “home church” in Ruggles Street, Boston. His son also wore native garb and, being born in Pingliang, could not be distinguished from a Chinaman in the dark, as a native policeman once discovered to his discomfiture. On second thought, when one had recovered from the slight shock involved, of course native dress is the thing to wear in such cases. For one thing, it is many times more economical than foreign garb, which would have to be individually imported. Chinese clothing is much better adapted to Chinese living conditions; and not the least of the advantages in cities of the interior where only two or three foreigners live is that they can go about their business unnoticed in the throng, instead of becoming the center of a gaping, jostling mob whenever they halt for a moment.
Before the days of the republic, I later learned, when we were comfortably settled in his home and the prospect of a hot bath was on the horizon, he had even sported a blond pigtail, like many of the inland missionaries. I don't need to mention that this was taken off when, on rare occasions, he visited the “home church” in Ruggles Street, Boston. His son also wore traditional clothing and, born in Pingliang, was indistinguishable from a Chinese person in the dark, as a local policeman once found out to his embarrassment. After some thought, once you got over the initial shock, wearing local dress is definitely the way to go in those situations. For one thing, it's far more economical than foreign clothing, which would have to be shipped in. Chinese clothing is much better suited to Chinese living conditions; and one significant advantage in cities where only a couple of foreigners live is that they can go about their business unnoticed in the crowd, instead of becoming the focus of a staring, jostling crowd whenever they stop for a moment.
I cannot, naturally, give any testimony as to the efficacy or value of the missionary work of a host of barely twenty-four hours, though I can speak very highly of his hospitality and of the spick and span efficiency of whatever we saw in his two compounds. In one the church was reached through the hospital, which seemed a fitting and sensible arrangement. Pingliang is not well supplied with curative facilities, and naturally the mission hospital is overworked to a point where even charitable foreigners unconsciously grow more or less callous to mere human suffering. Chinese strolling into the place in what to us seemed horrible conditions were such commonplace sights to those who had spent a generation among them that they showed little more feeling over them than over a cut finger. “Oh, been in a fight, I suppose,” was the sum total reply to my anxious inquiry about a man whose face and chest were cut into ribbons and who seemed to be half groping, half stumbling his way toward the hospital. With beggars of both sexes and all ages wandering the town and sleeping out of doors all 413winter in a few fluttering rags that expose far more skin than they cover, their cadaverous faces blue yellow with starvation, it is hardly to be expected that a young man born amid such scenes should lose much sleep over them.
I can't really comment on the effectiveness or value of the missionary work done in just twenty-four hours, but I can definitely praise his hospitality and the spotless efficiency of everything we saw in his two compounds. In one of them, the church was accessible through the hospital, which seemed like a practical setup. Pingliang lacks sufficient healthcare facilities, and understandably, the mission hospital is overwhelmed to the point where even compassionate foreigners become somewhat desensitized to human suffering. For those who've spent years among them, seeing Chinese people enter the hospital in what seemed to us like terrible conditions was such a common sight that they showed little more concern than one would for a minor injury. “Oh, must have been in a fight,” was the total response to my worried question about a man whose face and chest were covered in deep cuts and who appeared to be half feeling his way, half stumbling toward the hospital. With beggars of all ages and genders roaming the town and sleeping outside all winter in tattered rags that cover far less skin than they should, their gaunt faces turning blue and yellow from starvation, it's not surprising that a young man raised in such an environment wouldn’t lose much sleep over it.
Pingliang, I discovered in a stroll about its wall, is not so large as the first impression suggests, being long and narrow, with nearly all its movement in that busy main street by which we passed through it. The suburbs were so crowded, we found, because no Mohammedan is allowed to live within the walls. The soldiers of the local dictator had just been paid, and many of them were sauntering about town with six or eight strings of “cash” over their shoulders, pricing this and that. One had a full ten thousand looped about his neck, a veritable millstone, yet his weighty wealth only amounted to about $2.30 in real money. I have said that interior China has no paper money; hence I must apologize for the oversight. For there are paper “cash” by the millions. Boys were stamping them out of great sheets of a kind of tissue-paper, piled twenty or more thick, so that each blow of the die accomplished something worth while; and great cylinders of the finished coins, still loosely held together, hung shivering in the breeze along the busiest street of Pingliang. But this is dead man’s money, to be burned at his grave along with paper horses and servants and perhaps a “Peking cart” of the same material, so that he shall not find himself penniless and unattended in the next world. The mere living must be content with solid brass.
Pingliang, I found during my walk around its wall, isn't as big as it first seems; it's long and narrow, with almost all the action happening along the bustling main street we used to pass through. We discovered that the suburbs were so packed because Muslims aren’t allowed to live within the walls. The local dictator's soldiers had just received their pay, and many were wandering around town with six or eight strings of “cash” over their shoulders, checking prices. One had a full ten thousand hanging around his neck, a true burden, but his heavy wealth only amounted to about $2.30 in real money. I mentioned earlier that interior China has no paper money; I should clarify that there are actually millions of paper “cash.” Boys were stamping them out of large sheets of a tissue-like paper, stacked twenty or more thick, so that each strike of the die was worthwhile; and big bundles of the finished coins, still loosely tied together, fluttered in the breeze along the busiest street in Pingliang. But this is dead man’s money, meant to be burned at his grave along with paper horses, servants, and maybe a “Peking cart” of the same material, so he won't end up broke and alone in the afterlife. The living have to make do with solid brass.
The soldiers, we noticed, actually paid for what they purchased. Not until they got a day or two out of town, our hosts said, did they dare give only what they chose or drop the word “pay” from their vocabulary entirely. In theory Pingliang and its district are governed from Lanchow, as the latter is from Peking. But the local general had his own soldiers and obeyed the Tuchun ten days westward about as absolutely as the Tuchun did the alleged Central Government. Lanchow had sent out orders to stop the growing of opium. The dictator of Pingliang passed the order on, in the form of a public proclamation, and at a same time issued secret instructions—in so far as anything can be secret in China—to his district rulers to encourage the planting of poppies, to compel it if necessary, since he needed the money to be derived from the traffic. An honest mandarin in Kingchow, refusing to obey secret instructions, effectively put an end to the planting in his district—and barely escaped in the night across the river and through the mountains to Lanchow, disguised as a coolie. 414In a region west of Pingliang, we learned when we reached it, the orders from opposite directions had been so nicely balanced that no one dared either to plant or not to plant, whereupon nature took upon itself the decision and grew nothing. Yet in these very regions poor peasants have been put in cages and left to starve because they dared to let the poppy beautify their fields, and perhaps the very next year some neighbor was prodded into chronic invalidism by soldiers’ bayonets because he had not planted poppies. Thus things go on throughout a large part of China, and opium is probably produced in fully as large quantities as ever, all the noisy demonstrations of burning, in a few of the larger cities, piles of opium-pipes and confiscated opium to the contrary notwithstanding. One large section of Kansu through which we passed was threatened with a famine because Shensi grew opium on the fields where she should grow wheat, and then offered such high prices for Kansu wheat that it all flowed eastward, as we had seen, and left the region that grew it to starve. But China’s many autonomous military rulers must have money, for without money they cannot keep soldiers, and without soldiers they cannot hold sway over their chosen territories; and of all their few scanty sources of revenue the tax on opium is the most remunerative. Naturally few if any of them openly permit the planting of poppies or openly tax the product. Has not China’s Government guaranteed to suppress the opium traffic, and must not even an all but independent Tuchun of the far interior take care what rumors reach that outside country from which protest and pressure and sometimes even military intervention come? The Chinese temperament is always for finesse as compared with boldness or force. In each provincial capital, and in other large centers, there is an Anti-Opium Office, the ostensible business of which is to stamp out the traffic. But the head of it is either appointed by the military ruler or subject to his influence; and if the latter issues secret orders undermining his public proclamations, the Anti-Opium Office collects the taxes and sets them down as fines, and there you are. There are, in fact, many districts where opium taxes are collected for years in advance, and as they are high the peasants have no choice but to plant poppies to recoup themselves.
The soldiers, we noticed, actually paid for what they bought. Our hosts mentioned that it wasn’t until they were a day or two outside of town that they dared to give only what they wanted or completely dropped the word “pay” from their vocabulary. In theory, Pingliang and its district are governed from Lanchow, just as Lanchow is from Peking. But the local general had his own soldiers and followed the Tuchun ten days west about as strictly as the Tuchun obeyed the supposed Central Government. Lanchow had sent out orders to stop growing opium. The dictator of Pingliang passed that order along, in the form of a public announcement, while at the same time issuing secret instructions—insofar as anything can be secret in China—to his district rulers to encourage planting poppies and to force it if necessary, since he needed the money that came from the trade. An honest mandarin in Kingchow, refusing to follow secret instructions, effectively ended the planting in his district—and barely escaped at night across the river and through the mountains to Lanchow, disguised as a laborer. 414In a region west of Pingliang that we reached, we learned that the conflicting orders had been so well-balanced that no one dared to either plant or refrain from planting, and as a result, nature took charge and produced nothing. Yet in these very regions, poor peasants have been put in cages and left to starve because they dared to let poppies bloom in their fields, while perhaps the very next year, a neighbor was forced into chronic illness by soldiers' bayonets for not planting poppies. This cycle continues throughout much of China, with opium likely being produced in as large quantities as ever, despite all the loud demonstrations of burning piles of opium pipes and confiscated opium in a few major cities. One large section of Kansu that we passed through was facing famine because Shensi grew opium on the fields meant for wheat, then offered such high prices for Kansu wheat that it all flowed eastward, as we had seen, leaving the region that produced it to starve. But China’s many autonomous military leaders need money, as they can’t maintain soldiers without funds, and without soldiers, they can’t maintain control over their territories; and among their few meager sources of income, the tax on opium is the most profitable. Naturally, very few, if any, of them openly allow the planting of poppies or openly tax the product. Hasn’t the Chinese Government promised to suppress the opium trade, and doesn’t even an almost independent Tuchun in the far interior have to be careful about what rumors reach that outside world from which protests, pressure, and sometimes even military intervention come? The Chinese mindset often favors subtlety over directness or force. In every provincial capital and other major centers, there is an Anti-Opium Office, whose apparent purpose is to eliminate the trade. However, the head of it is either appointed by the military ruler or influenced by him; and if the latter issues secret orders that undermine public announcements, the Anti-Opium Office collects taxes and records them as fines, and that’s that. In fact, there are many districts where opium taxes are collected years in advance, and since these taxes are high, the peasants have no choice but to plant poppies to recoup their losses.
A day’s journey beyond Pingliang there is a range 2350 meters high, crossed by roads so steep that one marvels how the clumsy two-wheeled carts get over it. Were the animals not hitched in tandem they never would, and even if we had not by this time made concessions to 415what at first strikes most Westerners as the “idiotic” Chinese way of doing their hauling, we must certainly have done so here. Pheasants almost as tame as chickens fed in the kind of heather and brown grass covering the lower slopes by which we approached. Terraces and caves had for a time died out; sure-footed men came down sheer paths with bundles of dry brush that would be an unusual and a welcome addition to the straw and dung fuel of the region. The range itself was made up of bare hills without a sign of bush or tree except the rows of now somewhat stunted willows which still escorted the wildly zigzagging road. There were many short cuts, heart breaking if your mule was so small or so tired that the carrying of the empty saddle up such a slope seemed work enough for him. On foot it was a stiff climb of some two hours’ duration which brought back memories of my Andean days that were not unpleasant. But here there was a constant sense of security, not to say of self-indulgence, in the knowledge that I was closely followed by ample food and a cook, and best of all, by a bed.
A day’s journey past Pingliang, there’s a mountain range that rises 2350 meters, with steep roads that make you wonder how the bulky two-wheeled carts manage to get over them. If the animals weren't hitched in tandem, they definitely wouldn’t make it. Even though we had already adapted to what most Westerners initially see as the “idiotic” Chinese way of transporting goods, we surely had no choice here. Pheasants, nearly as tame as chickens, grazed in the heather and brown grass that covered the lower slopes as we approached. Terraces and caves had mostly disappeared; sure-footed men came down steep paths with bundles of dry brush, which would be a rare and welcome addition to the straw and dung fuel in the area. The range itself was made up of bare hills, with no bushes or trees in sight except for the now somewhat stunted willows lining the wildly winding road. There were many shortcuts, heart-wrenching if your mule was too small or too exhausted, making it a challenge just to carry the empty saddle up such a slope. On foot, it was a tough two-hour climb that brought back memories of my days in the Andes, which weren’t unpleasant. But here, I felt a constant sense of security, not to mention a bit of indulgence, knowing I was closely followed by plenty of food, a cook, and best of all, a bed.
Donkey-loads of joss-sticks in two big square packs to each animal carefully picked their way down from the summit. The view from this showed a gashed and gnarled, a haphazard and truly chaotic world, monotonously yet beautifully light brown in color, to the faint edges of the far horizon. Over the top, coolies carrying whole chests of drawers on the ends of their balancing poles came swinging up the swift descent almost as if it were level ground. Once or twice before we had met the “fast mail” hurrying eastward, and now we came upon it again, jog-trotting over the mountains. Two men in the early prime of physical life, with a bundle of mail-bags at each end of the poles over their shoulders and a square glass lantern lashed on somewhere, are all this consists of in interior China. They carry some eighty pounds each in relays of twenty to thirty miles made at surprisingly good speed and on the second day return with a similar load, all for ten or twelve dollars “Mex” a month, depending on their length of service. Few postal systems are more reliable than that of China; and even though its high officials are mainly Europeans (this time the word is not meant to include Americans) no small credit should be given to the poorly paid coolies who are the chief links in the service in many parts of the country. Letters mailed in Peking a week after we left there were awaiting us when we reached Lanchow—for the coolie “fast mail” travels night and day; and the loss of anything posted is perhaps the rarest complaint heard even from those foreign residents who have developed into chronic grumblers against anything 416Chinese. Other mail-matter, up to a limited weight, may also be sent by letter-post, at increased postage; the bulk of it goes by long trains of pack-mules, such as we had already several times passed, at an average of twenty-five to thirty miles a day.
Donkey-loads of incense sticks in two big square packs on each animal carefully made their way down from the summit. The view from up there showed a cut-up and twisted, disorganized and truly chaotic world, monotonously yet beautifully light brown in color, stretching to the distant horizon. Over the top, workers carrying whole chests of drawers on the ends of their balancing poles swung down the steep slope almost as if it were flat ground. A few times before we had encountered the “fast mail” rushing eastward, and now we came across it again, trotting over the mountains. Two men in the prime of their lives, with a bundle of mailbags at each end of the poles over their shoulders and a square glass lantern somehow tied on, made up the entirety of the service in interior China. They carry about eighty pounds each in relays of twenty to thirty miles at surprisingly good speed and on the second day return with a similar load, all for ten or twelve dollars “Mex” a month, depending on how long they've been working. Few postal systems are more reliable than that of China; and even though its top officials are mainly Europeans (this time not including Americans), significant credit should go to the poorly paid workers who are the main links in the service across many areas of the country. Letters mailed in Beijing a week after we left there were waiting for us when we reached Lanzhou—because the coolie “fast mail” travels day and night; and the loss of anything posted is probably the rarest complaint heard even from those foreign residents who have become chronic grumblers about anything Chinese. Other mail, up to a limited weight, can also be sent by letter-post, with higher postage; the majority is sent by long trains of pack-mules, like the ones we had passed several times, averaging twenty-five to thirty miles a day.
There were a few patches of snow, and a region somewhat more prosperous-looking, in the Chinese sense, over the range, with a more solid, reddish soil, though all was dreary brown and utterly bare with autumn now. Cattle, horses, mules, donkeys, fat-tailed sheep, goats, pigs, and chickens, not to mention blue clouds of pigeons, were everywhere. Yet the people seemed to live as miserably as ever, wholly without cleanliness, comfort, or plenty; and before long we found ourselves surrounded again by broken, swirling loess. Such regions confirmed the theory that man is made of dust; the children looked as if they had just been finished, and not yet polished off.
There were a few patches of snow, and a part that looked somewhat more prosperous, in the Chinese sense, across the range, with more solid, reddish soil, though everything was a dreary brown, completely bare in the autumn now. Cattle, horses, mules, donkeys, fat-tailed sheep, goats, pigs, and chickens, not to mention flocks of pigeons, were everywhere. Yet the people seemed to live just as miserably as ever, completely lacking cleanliness, comfort, or abundance; and soon we found ourselves surrounded again by broken, swirling loess. Such areas supported the theory that man is made of dust; the children looked like they had just been completed, but not yet polished off.
The dreariness, the dismal lifelong existence of the great mass of Chinese seemed only emphasized by such scenes as a pair of blind minstrels entertaining a village by beating together resonant sticks and singsonging endless national ballads or ancient legends. Nothing whatever of the myriad simple enjoyments of more fortunate peoples, not even grass to sit on and trees to sit under, lightens their bare-earth-dwelling lot. Yet few peoples show themselves more contented with what they have, perhaps because discontent increases with possessions and possibilities. Lofty philosophers there are who, though nothing could induce them to spend a night out of reach of a hot bath, commend to us the contentment with little, the patience under deficiencies, of the Chinese. These are virtues, no doubt, up to a certain point; beyond it the traveler far afield in China comes to the conclusion they become a curse, and the Chinese surely have in many things passed this limit.
The gloom and bleakness of the everyday lives of the vast majority of Chinese people seemed to be highlighted by scenes like a pair of blind musicians entertaining a village by clapping resonant sticks together and singing endless national ballads or ancient tales. They lack the countless simple pleasures that luckier people enjoy, not even grass to sit on or trees for shade, which might ease their harsh lives. Yet, few groups appear more satisfied with what they have, perhaps because discontent grows with more possessions and opportunities. There are lofty philosophers who, while nothing could convince them to spend a night without access to a hot bath, praise the Chinese for their contentment with little and their patience with shortcomings. These are indeed virtues to a point; however, as travelers venture further into China, they come to the realization that these traits can become a burden, and the Chinese have certainly surpassed that point in many respects.

Two blind minstrels entertaining a village by singsonging interminable national ballads and legends, to which they keep time by beating together resonant sticks of hard wood
Two blind musicians entertain a village by singing endless national ballads and legends, keeping rhythm by clapping together sturdy wooden sticks.

The boys and girls of western China are “toughened” by wearing nothing below the waist and only one ragged garment above it, even in midwinter
The boys and girls of western China are "toughened" by wearing no pants and just one tattered piece of clothing on top, even in the middle of winter.

The “fast mail” of interior China is carried by a pair of coolies, in relays of about twenty miles each, made at a jog-trot with about eighty pounds of mail apiece. They travel night and day and get five or six American dollars a month
The “fast mail” of interior China is carried by a pair of laborers, in relays of about twenty miles each, made at a jog-trot with about eighty pounds of mail each. They travel day and night and earn five or six American dollars a month.

A bit of the main street of Taing-Ning, showing the damage wrought by the earthquake of two years before to the “devil screen” in front of the local magistrate’s yamen
A part of the main street of Taing-Ning, showing the damage caused by the earthquake two years ago to the “devil screen” in front of the local magistrate’s yamen.
417We came at length to Long-te, surrounded by a big mud wall, but with little except ruins inside. There were great mud buildings spilled into heaps of broken earth, threshing-floors where men and women were tossing grain and chaff into the wind, open fields, many straw-stacks, ponds frozen over, all within the walls, and still plenty of room for the shrunken population. For the earthquake had been serious here. The big city gates were wracked and twisted, sometimes split from top to bottom, in one case overthrown entirely. Mat and cloth tents and makeshift canvas buildings occupied what had evidently once been the business street, and here a market-fair was in full confusion. Some of the toughest, dirtiest coolies I had yet seen were packed in a soiled-blue squirming mass, which seemed to be mainly Moslem, about an improvised gambling-table. Two dice in a porcelain box, which was overturned in a saucer that was twirled, constituted the game. It might have been swift if the evil-eyed promoters had not always waited a long time for more stakes to be laid on the squared and numbered table before lifting the box. Each of these had his coolie valet behind him, who alternately held a cup of tea or the mouthpiece of a long pipe to the lips of his master, who kept both eyes and fingers on the absorbing business in hand. There were grooved “cash” measuring-boards—such as our coolie at home used in washing clothes—to obviate the counting of the money, mainly mere brass, yet totaling large stakes for Chinese countrymen of the poorest class. How intent they were on the whims of fate was shown by the astonishing fact that I stood for several moments packed in with them, without the least notice being taken of me; which did not hinder a mighty mob of men and boys gathering at my heels and raising a great cloud of dust close behind me all over town.
417We finally arrived at Long-te, which was surrounded by a large mud wall, but inside there was little more than ruins. There were massive mud buildings collapsed into piles of broken earth, threshing floors where men and women were tossing grain and chaff into the wind, open fields dotted with straw-stacks, and frozen ponds, all within the walls, still leaving plenty of space for the small population. The earthquake had hit this area hard. The large city gates were damaged and twisted, some completely split down the middle, and one was even knocked down entirely. Makeshift tents made from mats and cloth, along with temporary canvas structures, filled what was once a busy street, and here a marketplace was buzzing with chaos. Some of the toughest, dirtiest laborers I had seen so far were huddled together in a grimy blue mass, mostly Muslims, around a makeshift gambling table. The game involved two dice in a porcelain box that was turned over in a saucer that spun around. The pace could have been quick if it weren't for the shady promoters who always prolonged the wait for more bets to be placed on the numbered table before lifting the box. Each of these men had a coolie assistant behind him, who alternately held a cup of tea or the mouthpiece of a long pipe for his master while he focused completely on the game at hand. There were grooved measuring boards for "cash"—like the ones our coolie uses at home to wash clothes—to avoid counting the money, which was mostly brass but still added up to significant stakes for Chinese countrymen of the lowest class. Their intense focus on the whims of fate was evident as I stood among them for several moments without anyone noticing me; meanwhile, a large crowd of men and boys gathered behind me, kicking up a huge cloud of dust all over town.
Having won the toss during my absence—so severely honest were my companions—I found myself installed, when I reached it, in the star room of Long-te’s best inn. That is, most of my possessions were heaped about the uneven earth floor, and the thigh-high platform covered with a thin reed mat which the Chinese call a k’ang, of a mud room perhaps eight by fourteen feet in size. Chang was always busy enough with other matters to have it understood that we make our own beds. Such inn rooms are made entirely of mud,—walls, k’ang, and all, except for the soot-blackened beams and thatch above. Sometimes they are so small that an army cot would not go even lengthwise on the k’ang, which was usually too narrow to take two, either crosswise or side by side. The Chinese, of course, sleep on the k’ang itself, which is heated, at least in theory, by a crude flue beneath it; but the foreigner with a prejudice against stone-hard beds and, in warmer weather, against those myriad little bedfellows of which the sons of Han seem almost fond, will find a folding cot easily worth its weight in gold on a trip of any length into the interior. It may cost him more for lodging, for half a dozen Chinese could find plenty of room on a k’ang that would barely hold his cot and leave him space to undress and get into it; but as the rent of the whole room will probably not exceed ten cents gold, unless his “boy” lets the innkeeper succumb to his natural inclination to double or treble it out of respect for “rich” foreigners, he may find the extravagance worth the privacy. Even in their homes the overwhelming 418majority of Chinese sleep packed together on just such a more or less heated mud platform, so that a cot would be to them not a luxury but a senseless nuisance.
Having won the toss during my absence—my friends were really honest—I found myself settled, when I arrived, in the star room of Long-te’s best inn. Most of my stuff was scattered around the uneven dirt floor, and the thigh-high platform covered with a thin reed mat, which the Chinese call a k’ang, in a mud room about eight by fourteen feet in size. Chang was always busy with other things to make it clear that we had to make our own beds. These inn rooms are made entirely of mud—walls, k’ang, everything, except for the soot-blackened beams and thatch above. Sometimes they are so small that an army cot wouldn't even fit lengthwise on the k’ang, which is usually too narrow to hold two people, whether crosswise or side by side. The Chinese sleep on the k’ang itself, which is heated, at least in theory, by a simple flue beneath it; but someone used to softer beds and, in warmer weather, those countless little bedbugs that the Han seem to like, will find a folding cot invaluable on any trip to the countryside. It might cost more for lodging since half a dozen Chinese could easily fit on a k’ang that could barely hold his cot, leaving him just enough space to change and get in; but since the total cost of the room will probably not exceed ten cents gold, unless his “boy” allows the innkeeper to give in to his natural tendency to charge double or triple out of respect for “rich” foreigners, he might consider the expense worthwhile for the privacy. Even in their homes, the majority of Chinese sleep packed together on a heated mud platform, so a cot would be seen as not a luxury but a pointless hassle.
The procedure night after night hardly varied in the slightest degree. When we had driven into an inn yard and Chang had found rooms or caves opening off it which he considered fit to house his “masters,” the carts were unhitched and all but our heavier belongings unloaded. The mules had their unfailing roll in the dust, raising mighty clouds of it that penetrated even the k’ang mats, rose and shook themselves surprisingly clean—so effective for them is this substitute for a showerbath which was denied us—and fell to munching their well earned chopped straw and dried peas in their broad, shallow wicker baskets or in the mud mangers. The cartmen perhaps dust themselves with a horsetail or some rooster-feathers mounted on a stick, and take up the important question of getting their own food. This is indeed important even if it consists only of a bowl or two of some cheap native cookery, since with the rare exception of a lump of hot dough or a copper-worth of something else from peddler or shop along the way, and a scanty mid-morning lunch, they have not eaten since the night before. Meanwhile shrieks of “Gwan-shih-ti!” rend the air. The gwan-shih-ti—if a slightly varied pronunciation is easier, “John-dirty” will do quite as well, and be so exactly descriptive as to be no tax whatever on the memory—is the male maid of all work about a Chinese inn, though his title is somewhat more honorable than either his duties or his income. Chang needs the gwan-shih-ti at once to build fires under our k’angs, to bring water, to tell the cook where he can do his cooking, to bring us a pair of those narrow wooden saw-horses which pass for chairs in rural China to sit on outdoors if there is still daylight enough to read by, to do a hundred other errands “quai-quai!” that is, instantly if not sooner, which is the way Chang learned during his Peking service that foreigners always expected to be served. Meanwhile there are reëchoing screams of “Gwan-shih-ti!” from the muleteers, who want this or that, shrieks of “Gwan-shih-ti!” from the innkeeper himself, who has a few errands with which to keep him out of mischief, again perhaps from other newly arrived travelers, who want to know where in —— in the already crowded inn they are going to sleep, until one might imagine that the poor fellow would get flustered, even in spite of being Chinese.
The routine hardly changed at all night after night. After we pulled into an inn yard and Chang found rooms or caves he deemed fit for his “masters,” the carts were unhitched and all but our heavier belongings were unloaded. The mules did their usual roll in the dust, kicking up huge clouds that even got into the k’ang mats, which shook themselves surprisingly clean—this was their effective substitute for a shower, something we couldn’t have—and then they settled down to munch their well-deserved chopped straw and dried peas from their wide, shallow wicker baskets or in the mud mangers. The cartmen might brush themselves off with a horsetail or some rooster feathers on a stick and then focus on the important matter of getting their own food. This was indeed necessary, even if it was just a bowl or two of some inexpensive local dish, since aside from the rare treat of a hot dough ball or a couple of copper coins' worth of something from a vendor or shop along the way, and a light mid-morning snack, they hadn’t eaten since the night before. Meanwhile, the air was filled with screams of “Gwan-shih-ti!” The gwan-shih-ti—or if a slightly different pronunciation is easier, “John-dirty” works just as well and is just as descriptive without being hard to remember—is the male jack-of-all-trades at a Chinese inn, though his title sounds more respectable than either his tasks or his pay. Chang needed the gwan-shih-ti right away to light fires under our k’angs, bring water, inform the cook where to set up, fetch us a pair of those narrow wooden sawhorses that serve as chairs in rural China to sit on outside if there’s enough daylight to read by, and perform a hundred other errands “quai-quai!” that is, immediately if not sooner, as Chang learned during his time in Peking that foreigners always expected quick service. Meanwhile, there were echoing cries of “Gwan-shih-ti!” from the muleteers, who needed this or that, more shouts of “Gwan-shih-ti!” from the innkeeper himself, who had a few tasks to keep him busy, and possibly even from other newly arrived travelers, who wanted to know where in the already packed inn they would sleep, making one think that the poor guy would get overwhelmed, even though he was Chinese.
By this time “Gwan-shih-ti” has probably succeeded in coaxing the straw and dung poked into the k’ang flues to burn; and we have begun bitterly to regret asking to have the k’ang lighted. For any Chinese inn 419in winter is an absolute refutation of the old theory that wherever there is smoke there is fire. How often have we not groped our way into our mud-built lodgings resolved to make up our beds at last or die in the attempt, only to come gasping and clawing into the open air a moment later—and yet have waited in vain for the slightest suggestion of warmth to mitigate all this suffering. K’ang-flues seldom have any vent except the wide-open mouths for the feeding of fuel inside the room itself, and the volume of smoke that can pour forth from them is out of all keeping with either time or combustibles. Yet the Chinese seem content to go on for centuries more in this time-dishonored way, though they need go no farther afield than Korea to copy an example of heating the floor from the kitchen and letting the smoke out of chimneys at the other end of the house, without loss of fuel and without turning their homes into soot-dripping smoke-houses.
By this time, “Gwan-shih-ti" has probably managed to get the straw and dung stuffed into the k’ang flues to burn; and we are starting to deeply regret asking to have the k’ang lit. For any Chinese inn in winter completely disproves the old saying that where there’s smoke, there’s fire. How many times have we stumbled into our mud-built lodgings, determined to finally make our beds or die trying, only to find ourselves gasping and clawing our way back into the open air moments later—yet still waited in vain for even a hint of warmth to ease our suffering? K’ang-flues rarely have any ventilation other than the wide-open mouths for feeding fuel inside the room itself, and the amount of smoke that can escape from them is completely disproportionate to either the time or the materials used. Yet the Chinese seem satisfied to continue this outdated method for centuries, even though they need look no further than Korea for a better way to heat the floor from the kitchen and expel smoke through chimneys at the other end of the house, saving fuel and avoiding turning their homes into dark, smoky places.
Eventually we drove out enough smoke to come in and make our beds. To what had seemed an impenetrable sleeping-bag from Maine I had been obliged to add a sheepskin lining in Pingliang, and under or over this went every coat and blanket, and even my odds and ends of clothing, for barely did the sun set when the mountain cold came down like a blast direct from the north pole. Long before supper was ready it was often so bitter, in contrast to an almost hot day, that we were tempted to get into bed at once; and on the homeward trip we did, eating off our coverlets. But barely were we settled in such cases than Chang took all the joy out of life by appearing with the wash-basin forced upon us by the leader of the “Third Asiatic Expedition”—then in winter quarters in Peking, where such primitive things are not needed—and the canvas bucket of hot water, whereupon “face” at least required us to crawl out and perform ablutions enough to deceive ourselves into thinking that we had removed all that day’s dust and grime.
Eventually, we cleared out enough smoke to come inside and make our beds. I had to add a sheepskin lining to what had once seemed like an impenetrable sleeping bag from Maine while in Pingliang, and on top of or under this went every coat and blanket, along with my random bits of clothing, because as soon as the sun set, the mountain cold hit us like a blast from the North Pole. Long before dinner was ready, it often felt so bitter cold, especially compared to the nearly hot day, that we were tempted to get into bed right away; and on the way home, we did, eating off our blankets. But barely were we settled in those cases than Chang ruined all the fun by showing up with the wash basin forced on us by the leader of the “Third Asiatic Expedition”—who was then in winter quarters in Peking, where such basic items aren’t necessary—and the canvas bucket of hot water, which meant that “washing up” at least required us to crawl out and go through enough scrubbing to make ourselves feel like we’d managed to get rid of all that day’s dust and grime.
Or, perhaps, thanks to our recommendable habit of starting every morning without fail well before daylight, we arrived while the sun was still high enough above the horizon to see something of the native life of the town. We did not need to go out looking for this; it came to us, in all its impurity. Chinese clad in dirty blue and in every stage of undress came with trays of disgusting cooked chickens with their heads fast under one wing and their straddling legs still intact, with boiled sweet potatoes and steaming white balls of dough, with slabs of roasted pork and scores of other native favorites, all equally innocent of even the knowledge that hygiene and cleanliness exist. Not even the Parisians buy as much of their food already cooked as do the Chinese, 420and there was always great wonder shown that we did not fall upon these tempting delicacies at once, at least to bridge over the vacuum until our own curious viands should be ready. The varied conditions under which these were prepared we surmised rather than knew, for we religiously spared our feelings and our appetites by never unnecessarily intruding upon the cook’s domain. The natives did, however, whenever it was possible, and no doubt set down such attempts to approach cleanliness as Chang and the cook actually observed out of our sight to the incredible idiosyncrasies, not so much of foreigners—for some of them had seen Russian refugees eat—as of men of incomputable wealth, which the mere sight of our belongings, or even of our beds, showed us to be. As a matter of fact, we lived largely on the country, and might have done so entirely had we been content with a simpler diet. Chickens, eggs, the principal vegetables, fruits, sugar, and the like could always be had, on the out-journey at least, every two or three days, and now and then there were local specialties in addition. But such delicacies as jam, butter, cheese, chocolate, coffee, cocoa, and their kindred could only be had from our steamer-trunks on the tail-end of the carts, while our bread supply depended on foresight and the kindness of the rare foreigners along the way.
Or, maybe, because of our commendable habit of starting each morning well before sunrise, we arrived while the sun was still high enough in the sky to glimpse some of the local life in the town. We didn't have to seek this out; it came to us, in all its rawness. Chinese vendors dressed in shabby blue and various stages of undress came with trays of unappetizing cooked chickens, their heads tucked under one wing and their legs still attached, alongside boiled sweet potatoes, steaming white dough balls, slabs of roasted pork, and countless other local favorites, all blissfully unaware of hygiene and cleanliness. Even the Parisians don't buy as much ready-to-eat food as the Chinese do, and there was always great surprise that we didn't immediately indulge in these tempting treats, at least to fill the gap until our own unusual meals were ready. We could only guess the various conditions under which these were prepared, as we prudently spared our feelings and appetites by never intruding unnecessarily in the cook's area. The locals, however, did so whenever they could, likely attributing any attempts to improve cleanliness that Chang and the cook actually followed when we weren't looking to the strange habits, not just of foreigners—some of whom had witnessed Russian refugees eating—but of people of immense wealth, as our possessions and even our beds clearly indicated. In fact, we mostly relied on local produce, and could have done so entirely if we had been satisfied with a simpler diet. Chickens, eggs, the main vegetables, fruits, sugar, and similar items were always available, at least on our outward journey, every couple of days, and occasionally there were local specialties as well. But treats like jam, butter, cheese, chocolate, coffee, cocoa, and their relatives could only be retrieved from our steamer trunks at the back of the carts, while our bread supply depended on foresight and the generosity of the rare foreigners we encountered along the way.
It is not a bad idea to bring along a few simple picture-books on such a journey. The boys who drift into the inn-yards are invariably keenly interested in any hints of the strange “outside-country” from which you come, and sometimes quite sharp-witted; so that not only will they get pleasure and instruction out of the pictures, but the traveler will learn many Chinese words from them, which will be of use perhaps some day if he ever finds himself stranded without a “boy” in some town that happens to speak the same dialect. However, all tales as to its narrow limits notwithstanding, we found Mandarin, or Pekingese, or whatever it is that one soon picks up a bit of in the capital, as generally understood on all this journey as could be expected of what was no doubt our atrocious pronunciation. Peasants and local coolies sometimes shook their heads, either because they could not understand us or thought we were speaking some foreign tongue and refused to try; but anything like a real knowledge of the general language, or that very similar one of the masses of Peking, would have been quite sufficient in any of the provinces we visited.
It’s a good idea to bring along some simple picture books on such a trip. The boys who end up in the innyards are usually really interested in any hints about the strange “outside country” you come from, and sometimes they’re quite clever; so not only will they enjoy and learn from the pictures, but the traveler will also pick up a lot of Chinese words from them, which might come in handy someday if he finds himself stuck without a “boy” in a town that speaks the same dialect. Despite all the talk about its limited scope, we found that Mandarin, or Pekingese, or whatever you pick up a bit of in the capital, was generally understood throughout this journey, considering our undoubtedly terrible pronunciation. Peasants and local laborers sometimes shook their heads, either because they couldn’t understand us or thought we were speaking some foreign language and refused to engage; but having a basic knowledge of the general language, or that very similar one spoken by the masses in Peking, would have been more than enough in any of the provinces we visited.
At last supper would be announced, with whosoever’s k’ang that showed any signs of heat as a dining-table, and six-inch-wide saw-horses as chairs. By this time the mountain cold would be like ice-packs 421applied to the marrow of the bones—if that is anatomically possible—and unless we watched the door, if there was one, all manner of Chinese odds and ends, even ladies so consumed by curiosity as sometimes to forget the stern rules of their sex, would gradually replace it by a bank of gaping faces, the boldest of which might even find some poor excuse to come clear inside. Perhaps the police would arrive, though this was rare, with two or three huge and gaily decorated paper lanterns, to ask for our visiting-cards and bow their way ceremoniously out again into the weirdly flickering night. Then one last brief sortie with a toothbrush and into our luxurious beds, perhaps to read and smoke a bit by the American lantern that we succeeded in getting and keeping oil enough to use one night out of three. For however much we paid for oil, it never seemed to be real kerosene, and the Chinese genius for flimsy constructions had evolved in place of a can a slightly baked mud jug that broke at the least lurching of a cart and even seeped through upon the back of the mafu who was finally sentenced to carry it. Sleep always came long before the end of a cigar, however, and never have I enjoyed more sound and satisfying slumber than on most of those Kansu nights, in spite of legs, accustomed to another form of travel, aching from ten or twelve hours in the saddle, and though one might hear the mules just outside munching their hard peas off and on all through the night. The drivers always got up between two and three o’clock to feed them, and then one might hear the steady rump! rump! of the chopping of straw as one man fed it to the big hinged knife everywhere used for this purpose, and another manipulated the knife itself. Sometimes this wicked implement has other uses, as in one village along our route where the peasants captured a bandit and, not caring to make the long journey to the hsien seat, with the risk of his escape or rescue, had calmly beheaded him with a straw-knife.
At last, supper was announced, with whoever’s k’ang that showed any signs of warmth serving as a dining table, and six-inch-wide sawhorses as chairs. By this time, the mountain cold felt like ice packs pressed into our bones—if that's even anatomically possible—and unless we kept an eye on the door, if there was one, all kinds of curious Chinese onlookers, even women so intrigued that they sometimes forgot the strict rules of their gender, would gradually replace it with a crowd of staring faces, the boldest of which might even find some flimsy excuse to step inside. Perhaps the police would show up, though that was rare, bringing two or three large, colorful paper lanterns, to ask for our visiting cards and bow their way back out into the eerily flickering night. Then, one last quick trip with a toothbrush and into our comfortable beds, maybe to read and smoke a bit by the American lantern that we managed to get and keep just enough oil for one night out of three. No matter how much we paid for oil, it never seemed like real kerosene, and the Chinese knack for flimsy constructions had produced, instead of a can, a slightly baked mud jug that broke at the slightest bump in a cart and even leaked onto the back of the mafu who was stuck carrying it. Sleep always came long before I finished a cigar, yet I’ve never enjoyed deeper, more satisfying sleep than on those Kansu nights, despite my legs, used to a different kind of travel, aching from ten or twelve hours in the saddle, and even though you could hear the mules just outside munching on their hard peas occasionally throughout the night. The drivers always got up between two and three in the morning to feed them, and then you could hear the steady rump! rump! of someone chopping straw as one man fed it to the large hinged knife commonly used for that purpose, while another handled the knife itself. Sometimes this wicked tool had other uses, like in one village along our route where the farmers caught a bandit and, not wanting to make the long trip to the hsien seat with the risk of him escaping or being rescued, calmly beheaded him with a straw knife.
But all supreme pleasures have an untimely end, and before the delicious night seemed well begun Chang would come to light the lantern, or the candle, or the string wick floating in the half of a broken mud saucer of thick native oil which Chinese inns furnish, and to break the bitter news that it was five o’clock—or four, as the case might be. Stifling our curses as becomes married men who should at least have reached years of discretion and self-control, we would crawl from the tropical luxuriance of our sleeping-bags into the arctic iceberg of early morning with a pretense of bravery that deceived neither ourselves nor each other, and lose more breath than time in getting inside our icy daytime garments. A hot breakfast larger than the full daily 422consumption of all but the wealthiest Chinese, however, always brought about a great change in our spirits. In and about the yard would rise noisy disputes in which could be heard endless repetitions of the word “ch’ien,” which means money, or, more exactly, brass “cash,” and when at length these had subsided our expedition would trail away again into the darkness. As nearly as I made out, we paid between one and two hundred coppers a night as our share of the inn expenditures, which included our alleged rooms, heat, and light, k’ang space somewhere for our retinue, and various and sundry other charges exclusive of food for the mules and their attendants, which was not our affair. But I defy any Occidental to make head or tail of the intricacies of paying a bill at a Chinese inn. There seemed to be a “straw charge” on our merely human part of the bill, and each kettle of water was so many coppers, and we were expected to pay for the right to let the carts stand all night in the inn-yard; or at least Chang informed us that gentlemen always did and seemed on the verge of tears that might have resulted in loss of “face” for him and loss of our chief link with the outside world for us when we opened for discussion the fact that our contract with the muleteers required them to pay everything having to do with their part of the expedition. Nor was that all, by any means; for the Chinese seem to like nothing better than the utmost complications in money matters. Perhaps this is because so many of them depend for their livelihood on the odd coppers and “cash” that are chipped off in the process of making impossible adjustments in the chaos of exchange and incompatible coins and intricate charges, modified by vociferous bargainings, which are never alike in two parts of the country. Possibly it is merely because they love complexities and gratuitous difficulties for their own sake—as their language, for example, suggests, especially in its written form—and which have grown up during the hundred centuries of social intercourse that lie behind them.
But all great pleasures come to an end, and just when the enjoyable night seemed to be starting, Chang would come to light the lantern, candle, or the string wick floating in a broken mud saucer filled with thick local oil that Chinese inns provide, and he would sadly inform us that it was five o'clock—or four, depending on the situation. Stifling our frustrations like married men who should have developed some self-control and maturity, we would crawl from the tropical comfort of our sleeping bags into the icy chill of the early morning, trying to act brave despite knowing we were fooling neither ourselves nor each other, and we would expend more breath than time getting dressed in our cold daytime clothes. However, a hot breakfast larger than what most Chinese people would typically eat in a day always lifted our spirits significantly. Noisy arguments would erupt in the yard, filled with endless mentions of the word “ch’ien,” which means money, or more precisely, brass “cash,” and once those debates calmed down, our expedition would once again make its way into the darkness. As far as I could tell, we paid between one and two hundred coppers a night as our share of the inn costs, which included our so-called rooms, heat, light, space for our staff on the k’ang, and various other charges not including food for the mules and their keepers, which wasn’t our responsibility. But I challenge any Westerner to untangle the complexities of paying a bill at a Chinese inn. There seemed to be an added “straw charge” for our part of the bill, and each kettle of water cost a few coppers, and we were expected to pay for the privilege of letting the carts stay overnight in the inn yard; or at least that’s what Chang told us, and he looked about ready to cry, as it might cost him “face,” and we would lose our main connection to the outside world when we pointed out that our contract with the muleteers stated they were responsible for all expenses related to their part of the journey. And that was far from all; the Chinese seem to thrive on the most complicated money matters. Maybe this is because so many rely on the small coppers and “cash” that are shuffled around as they struggle with impossible adjustments amid the chaos of exchange, mismatched coins, and intricate fees, all influenced by loud bargaining that varies between different regions of the country. It could simply be that they enjoy complexities and unnecessary challenges for their own sake—as their language suggests, especially in its written form—which have developed over the thousands of years of social interaction that precede them.
CHAPTER XXIII
WHERE THE FISH WAGGED HIS TAIL
Whatever the dreadful hardships of our journey, they would have been increased by at least one had the loess country been as dry and arid as it looked, and thus compelled us to travel by camel-train. For, all trite humor about the ship-like motion of that worthy animal aside, he is an objectionable companion because he is an inveterate and incorrigible night-hawk. Or perhaps that word approaches the slanderous when applied to him, for the cause of his night-hawking is quite the opposite of that of his human prototype. The camel prowls about in the small hours because he can eat only by day and, given that unusual idiosyncrasy, must work by night. Frequently the beginning of our day’s journey was broken by a long camel-train looming up out of the first thin white light of dawn, the dull bells gently booming, each “string” of six or eight or ten camels led by a bearded man of red-brown, slightly surly features that often looked more Arabic than Chinese. This impression was increased by long white sheep- or goatskin cloaks, turned wool in, surmounted by what seemed to be turbans, though at closer sight and in the full light of day these last proved to be the dirty-white skullcaps of felt to which the Chinese Mohammedans are largely addicted, perhaps wound round with a soiled towel of cheap crash that is often the traveling coolie’s only concession to the worship of soap and water. One must take care, however, not to consider white caps and “Hwei-Hwei” as synonymous. For many a Mohammedan wears black, quite like his fellow-Chinese, while a wide white band about the cap is a sign, not of belief in the Prophet of Medina, but of mourning for father or grandfather. But, to come back to the camels: it would have required no great strain on the imagination to fancy oneself in Arabia as these endless lines of silent-footed beasts stalked disdainfully past in the half-lighted defiles, though one would have been forced to overlook such minor details as their two humps instead of one. Often we heard the muffled booming of their bells as they went by in the night; but by day they were seldom seen, unless it was kneeling in crowded 424contentment in an inn-yard or sauntering packless about some hillside thinly dotted with dead-brown tufts of coarse grass, under the care of a cat-napping driver or two.
Whatever the terrible hardships of our journey, they would have been even worse if the loess country had been as dry and barren as it seemed, forcing us to travel with a camel train. Because, despite all the cliché jokes about the ship-like sway of that noble creature, he's an annoying companion due to being a chronic night-walker. Or maybe that term is unfair because his nocturnal habits are quite the opposite of those of his human counterpart. The camel roams around in the early hours because he can only eat during the day and, due to this unusual trait, must work at night. Often, the start of our day’s journey was interrupted by a long line of camels emerging from the first light of dawn, the dull bells softly ringing, each group of six, eight, or ten camels led by a bearded man with reddish-brown, somewhat grumpy features that often appeared more Arabic than Chinese. This impression was enhanced by their long white sheep- or goatskin cloaks worn wool-side in, topped with what looked like turbans, though on closer inspection, in the bright light of day, these turned out to be the dirty-white skullcaps made of felt that many Chinese Muslims wear, sometimes wrapped with a soiled towel of cheap cloth that might be the only sign of any effort to clean up. However, one must be careful not to equate white caps with "Hwei-Hwei." Many Muslims wear black, just like their fellow Chinese, and a wide white band around the cap is a sign of mourning for a father or grandfather, not a belief in the Prophet of Medina. But back to the camels: it wouldn’t take much imagination to think one was in Arabia as these endless lines of silently moving beasts strode past disdainfully in the dimly lit paths, though one would have to ignore such minor details as their two humps instead of one. Often, we heard the muffled ringing of their bells as they passed by during the night; but during the day, they were rarely seen, unless they were kneeling in close comfort in an inn-yard or wandering without loads on some hillside sparsely covered with dead-brown tufts of coarse grass, under the watch of one or two catnapping drivers.
A wide valley we had been following for some time narrowed until it drove the road high up above the river, whence it came down again into another fertile vale containing many graves and the city of Tsin-ching. There was an unusual animation about Tsin-ching. For though it had been more nearly destroyed by the earthquake than Long-te and other gloomy collections of ruins that lay behind us, it had many brand-new buildings, and great gangs of men and boys were rebuilding the city wall, quite irrespective of the fact that it was what should have been a quiet Sunday afternoon. Custom, fear of bandits, of another Mohammedan rebellion, of evil spirits, perhaps of cold winds, and no doubt the laudable desire of the authorities for an opportunity to make some “squeeze” that will be understood by many of our own city dwellers, seem to be the principal causes of this anachronistic repair of city walls; and the strongest of all these, probably, is custom. This one might have inferred from the fact that this one was being rebuilt exactly in the style in vogue centuries ago, with the crenelated top all the several miles around it pierced by thousands of little loopholes convenient in medieval warfare. But in China there is still some practical value to a city wall if it has gates that can be locked and is not so badly ruined that any one with a little diligence can find a place to climb over it. For it is a real protection against bandit raids if they are not too strong, against tough characters in general, and it is not without its use in those quarrels between towns which sometimes become serious. Besides, Tsin-ching seemed to be a kind of anti-Mohammedan stronghold, for there were few Moslems in town—the prevalence of pigs would have told us that, even if the human inhabitants had not—and who can tell when the next Islamite rebellion will sweep over Kansu?
A wide valley we had been following for some time narrowed until it pushed the road high above the river, then it came down again into another fertile valley filled with many graves and the city of Tsin-ching. There was an unusual liveliness about Tsin-ching. Although it had been more severely damaged by the earthquake than Long-te and other grim ruins behind us, it had many brand-new buildings, and large groups of men and boys were busy rebuilding the city wall, completely ignoring the fact that it was supposed to be a quiet Sunday afternoon. Custom, fear of bandits, worries about another Muslim rebellion, concerns about evil spirits, perhaps fears of cold winds, and definitely the authorities' desire to find some way to benefit financially that would resonate with many in our own cities seemed to be the main reasons for this old-fashioned repair of city walls, with custom likely being the strongest motivating factor. One could infer this from the fact that the wall was being rebuilt exactly in the style that was popular centuries ago, with a crenelated top all along it pierced by thousands of little loopholes convenient for medieval warfare. However, in China, city walls still have some practical value if they have gates that can be locked and aren't so badly damaged that anyone with a bit of effort can't find a way to climb over them. They provide real protection against bandit raids, as long as the bandits aren't too strong, and against troublemakers in general, plus they're useful in conflicts between towns that can sometimes escalate. Moreover, Tsin-ching seemed to be a sort of anti-Muslim stronghold, with very few Muslims in the city—the abundance of pigs would have made that obvious, even if the human residents hadn’t—and who knows when the next Islamist rebellion will sweep through Kansu?
The only foreigners in Tsin-ching or for many miles around were two Swedish ladies, one of them from Minnesota, who had recently established a mission station. They had not yet made any converts, but they had brought about a kinder and more tolerant feeling toward themselves, and toward “outside barbarians” in general, by which they hoped in time to profit. One of the richest and most significant men in town, who began as a declared and ruthless enemy, had sneaked over a few weeks before to let the detested missionaries of the despised sex cure him of an injury which neither the herbs of the local druggist nor the hocus-pocus of the local priests had helped, and, though he 425scarcely showed gratitude in the Western sense, rumors of the miracle had begun to have their influence. One of the difficulties these missionary ladies, like the few others we met on our journey, had to contend with was that the Chinese women with whom they tried to come in contact, especially in outlying districts, fled at sight of them because they took them to be men. This was largely due to their unbound feet and their skirts in place of ladylike trousers, but, quite aside from these details, there was, indeed, a wide difference both in appearance and manner between these big, vigorous Nordics and the tame little Chinese women.
The only foreigners in Tsin-ching or for many miles around were two Swedish women, one from Minnesota, who had recently set up a mission station. They hadn't made any converts yet, but they had fostered a kinder and more accepting attitude toward themselves and "outside barbarians" in general, hoping to benefit from it over time. One of the wealthiest and most influential men in town, who had initially been a fierce enemy, had secretly approached them a few weeks earlier to let the despised female missionaries treat an injury that neither the local druggist's herbs nor the local priests' rituals had resolved. Although he hardly expressed gratitude in the Western sense, rumors of the miracle started to spread and had an impact. One of the challenges these missionary women, like the few others we met on our journey, faced was that Chinese women, especially in rural areas, tended to run away at the sight of them because they mistook them for men. This was largely due to their unbound feet and their skirts instead of traditional feminine trousers, but aside from these details, there was indeed a stark difference in both appearance and demeanor between these tall, strong Nordics and the delicate little Chinese women.
Exchange-shops with their huge wooden “cash” signs out in front were more than numerous in Tsin-ching, and perhaps they were all needed. There a Mexican dollar was worth 2500 “cash,” but more or less in theory, since both the silver dollar and the brass coins with square holes in them had largely disappeared from circulation. In place of the former there were taels—irregular lumps of silver requiring a pair—or two—of scales for any transaction in which they were involved—and “Lanchow coppers.” Between these two extremes, as formerly between the silver dollar and the “cash,” there was nothing; and if the American, with his convenient little silver coins of fixed value, his unquestioned paper money, and his check-book, will pause a moment to visualize just what this means, he will understand why doing business is a complicated process, and why the streets seem to swarm with exchange-shops in such communities. Fortunately prices—and certainly wages—were low in Tsin-ching. The missionary ladies, who were their own architects, contractors, and bosses in the construction of their mission, had formerly paid their workmen 500 “cash” a day; but recently, food prices having gone up, this had been changed to 310 “cash” and food. It amounted to about the same thing for the ladies, since the two native meals furnished the gangs cost approximately two hundred “cash” a day per man, but they could buy and prepare the food in quantity at considerably less than the men themselves must otherwise have paid in native restaurants, where meals were less sanitary and nourishing. Native bosses got 400 “cash” a day, with food. Skilled carpenters, who need not have been ashamed of the samples of their work which we saw, were on a salary rather than a mere wage basis, as befits their higher caste; that is, they received, besides their food, 10,000 “cash” a month, in other words, fully two American dollars! Correspondingly, the ladies could buy chickens for the equivalent of our nickel, a leg of lamb for little more, and many other things in proportion. 426On the other hand, they had the task of counting their “cash,” for every string of a thousand was almost sure to be short, perhaps to have only ninety-two or so to the hundred; and even if it was not they had to be sure of that fact before paying the string to some carpenter who might otherwise return half an hour later with visible proof that he had been underpaid. Then recently their troubles had been appreciably increased by the influx of “Lanchow coppers.”
Exchange shops with their large wooden "cash" signs out front were quite common in Tsin-ching, and maybe they were all necessary. There, a Mexican dollar was worth 2500 "cash," more or less in theory, since both the silver dollar and the brass coins with square holes had mostly vanished from circulation. Instead of the former, there were taels—irregular lumps of silver requiring one or two scales for any transaction involving them—and "Lanchow coppers." Between these two extremes, just like before between the silver dollar and the "cash," there was nothing; and if the American, with his easy little silver coins of fixed value, his unquestioned paper money, and his checkbook, takes a moment to imagine what this means, he will see why doing business is a complicated process and why the streets seem filled with exchange shops in such communities. Fortunately, prices—and certainly wages—were low in Tsin-ching. The missionary ladies, who designed, managed, and oversaw their mission's construction, previously paid their workers 500 "cash" a day; but recently, since food prices had gone up, this changed to 310 "cash" and food. This equated to about the same for the ladies, as the two native meals provided for the work crews cost roughly two hundred "cash" a day per man, but they could buy and prepare the food in bulk for significantly less than the men would have paid in local restaurants, where the meals were less sanitary and nutritious. Local bosses got 400 "cash" a day, including food. Skilled carpenters, whose work we were impressed with, were on a salary rather than a basic wage, as suited their higher status; they received, in addition to their food, 10,000 "cash" a month, which is fully two American dollars! Likewise, the ladies could buy chickens for the equivalent of a nickel, a leg of lamb for slightly more, and many other items at similar prices. 426 On the other hand, they had to count their "cash," as every string of a thousand was almost guaranteed to be short, perhaps with only ninety-two or so in each hundred; and even if it wasn't, they had to verify that before handing the string to a carpenter who might otherwise come back half an hour later with clear evidence that he had been underpaid. Recently, their challenges had increased significantly due to the influx of "Lanchow coppers."
Though the proper place for airing that scandal might be Lanchow itself, there were so many evidences of it before we reached there that clarity requires an earlier mention of it. As in other countries of poor transportation facilities and sluggish circulation, the back-waters of China are in many cases chronically short on coins, particularly on small change, for their interminable transactions. The Tuchun of Kansu, hoping to remedy this difficulty—and incidentally further to obviate the possibility of eventually leaving the province a poorer man than he entered it—hit upon what was to him perhaps a highly original scheme. He called in the “cash” and the rather scarce coppers in circulation, had them melted and mixed, and reissued them as new coin. This would not have been so bad, so atrocious, in fact, if he had actually minted the stuff into money. But what he did do was to give men all over the district the right—at 20,000 “cash” royalty a day, gossip whispered—to resmelt the current coins in their little dung-fire, box-bellows forges, mix in great quantities of sand, and pour the molten result into crude molds, from which issued such a caricature of a coin as has scarcely circulated in the civilized world since the last find of Roman money disappeared into the museums. They are light as glass, give out the ring of a hat-check, are barely legible, vary greatly in design and lettering, with misspelled attempts at English on one side of several styles of them, and are so hopelessly mixed with dross, according to experts, that the bit of metal in them can never again be reclaimed. At first they were made as single coppers, worth ten “cash” each; but when it was discovered that the cost of making a coin was three “cash,” the double copper, or twenty-“cash” piece, was substituted, though with but slight changes either in size or other details.
Though the right place to discuss that scandal might be Lanchow itself, there was so much evidence of it before we got there that it makes sense to mention it earlier. Just like in other countries with poor transportation and slow trade, the remote areas of China often struggle with a shortage of coins, especially small change, for their endless transactions. The Tuchun of Kansu, wanting to fix this issue—and also to avoid leaving the province poorer than he entered—came up with what he thought was a quite original idea. He collected the "cash" and the limited amount of coppers in circulation, had them melted down and mixed, and issued them as new coins. This wouldn't have been so bad, or even so horrible, if he had actually minted proper money. But what he really did was give people across the district permission—at a rumored cost of 20,000 "cash" royalty per day—to resmelt the current coins in their small dung-fire, box-bellows forges, mix in a lot of sand, and pour the molten mixture into crude molds, creating a version of a coin that hasn't circulated in the civilized world since the last Roman coins disappeared into museums. They are as light as glass, sound like a hat-check when struck, are barely readable, vary hugely in design and lettering, have misspelled English attempts on some of them, and are so hopelessly mixed with impurities, according to experts, that the metal in them can never be recovered. Initially, they were made as single coppers worth ten "cash" each; but when it was found that making a coin cost three "cash," they shifted to the double copper, or twenty-"cash" piece, with only slight changes in size or other details.
How a Chinese general, steeped as it were in the intricacies of exchange and familiar since childhood with the daily fluctuations of the money he used, could have overlooked the certainty of a swift decline in value of such alleged coins is hard to understand. Perhaps he realized all this, but lost no sleep over it so long as he got his own 427rake-off in real money. At any rate, whereas a “good” or “red” copper was valued in Kansu at two hundred or less to the Mexican dollar, and the new ones announce themselves to be worth the same, the latter had already fallen to about seven thousand to the dollar in the exchange-shops of Tsin-ching. Even if this rate had been uniform throughout the province, the situation might have been endurable. But not only did it wildly fluctuate every day, almost every hour; it varied greatly between towns only a few miles apart, with an upward tendency as one approached Lanchow, where the Tuchun’s power was at its height. Long before the borders of the province were reached this oozed away entirely, at least in so far as his experiments in currency and finance went. His autonomous subordinate in Pingliang had refused point-blank to allow the new coinage to enter his district; Liangchow and most other large towns had followed suit, and only within a certain limited area around the provincial capital itself had the Tuchun succeeded in imposing this substitute for what elsewhere was still “red” coppers and stringable “cash.” Where he actually ruled, it meant a heavy fine or a prison sentence to refuse to accept the miserable stuff; but he had little or no influence over the value set upon it by the money-changers. Any one with even a bowing acquaintance with the science of finance need not be told what disasters this condition of affairs brought upon shopkeepers and business men, especially upon those whose stocks were more or less imported from the outside world.
It's hard to understand how a Chinese general, deeply familiar with the complexities of trade and having dealt with daily changes in currency since childhood, could overlook the obvious drop in value of such supposed coins. Maybe he was aware of it but didn't care as long as he got his cut in real money. In Kansu, a “good” or “red” copper was worth two hundred or less compared to the Mexican dollar, while the new coins claimed to have the same value; however, they had already dropped to about seven thousand to the dollar in the exchange shops of Tsin-ching. Even if this rate had been consistent across the province, it might have been manageable. But not only did it fluctuate wildly every day, almost every hour; it varied significantly between towns just a few miles apart, increasing closer to Lanchow, where the Tuchun’s power was strongest. Before he even reached the borders of the province, this issue had completely dissipated, at least regarding his currency and finance experiments. His autonomous subordinate in Pingliang outright refused to accept the new coins; Liangchow and most other large towns did the same, and only in a limited area around the provincial capital did the Tuchun manage to enforce this alternative to the still-common “red” coppers and stringable “cash.” Where he held authority, refusing to accept these worthless coins could result in heavy fines or prison sentences; however, he had little to no influence over their value as determined by money-changers. Anyone with even a basic understanding of finance knows the disasters this situation caused for shopkeepers and business owners, especially those whose goods were mostly imported from outside the region.
One of the amusing points of the affair was that Liangchow and Pingliang and many another town and district that would not use the stuff themselves were manufacturing vast quantities of the spurious coins and shipping them to Lanchow, without, of course, paying the Tuchun his “rake-off.” It is hard even for the Chinese to outwit the Chinese, and no sooner had the daily royalty rate been set than most coineries within the Tuchun’s influence put on two shifts and worked twenty-four hours a day. Moreover, it is no great task to counterfeit miserable counterfeits, and almost any little cave-village in the loess hills could mold coins to its heart’s content, so long as it could get the bit of copper and brass needed. Transporting the stuff was in itself a problem worthy an expert. “Cash” can at least be strung and hung round the neck, but to carry enough of this new stuff for his immediate wants would have taxed the endurance of any pedestrian above the coolie class. In fact it was a serious matter to others than pedestrians. Every little while we met some traveler, usually a merchant, no doubt, mounted on a mule and followed by a donkey sagging under the weight and noisy 428with the falsetto rattling of “Lanchow coppers”; and it was no uncommon thing to pass long lines of coolies with big bundles of the new coins oscillating at the ends of their shoulder-poles, jogging eastward, as if the false currency were spreading, like a plague. Indeed the towns toward the end of our outward journey sounded like brass check factories perpetually in the act of taking stock. The latest rumor, as we neared the capital of the province, was that the Tuchun had decided to coin dollars also; “and then,” as a merchant sadly put it, “we will have no money at all left.” However, the harassed people might have cheered themselves up with the hope that the day may come when Lanchow’s despised coppers will be worth their weight in gold among numismatists, for coins cast in a mold are a rarity in this day and generation.
One of the amusing aspects of the situation was that Liangchow, Pingliang, and many other towns and districts that had no intention of using the fake coins were producing large quantities of them and shipping them to Lanchow, without bothering to pay the Tuchun his cut. It’s tough for anyone to outsmart the locals, and as soon as the daily royalty rate was announced, most coin producers under the Tuchun’s control started working two shifts and running around the clock. Moreover, it's not hard to counterfeit poor-quality coins, and almost any small village in the loess hills could easily mold coins as long as they could get the necessary copper and brass. Transporting the coins was a problem that required special skills. “Cash” can at least be strung up and worn around the neck, but carrying enough of this new currency for immediate needs would be a strain for anyone above a laborer. In fact, it was a serious issue for more than just pedestrians. Every so often we came across travelers, usually merchants, riding mules and followed by a donkey weighed down and noisy with the clattering of “Lanchow coppers.” It was common to see long lines of laborers with large bundles of the new coins swinging from their shoulder poles, trudging eastward, as if the fake currency were spreading like a virus. Indeed, the towns toward the end of our journey sounded like brass check factories constantly taking inventory. The latest rumor, as we got closer to the provincial capital, was that the Tuchun had decided to mint dollars too; “and then,” as one merchant sadly remarked, “we’ll be left with no money at all.” However, the beleaguered people might have found some comfort in the thought that one day, Lanchow’s unwanted coppers might be worth their weight in gold to coin collectors, since coins made from molds are rare these days.
In a moment of good-hearted thoughtlessness the major sent his card and our respects to the magistrate of Tsin-ching, who was of course of too low rank actually to be called upon. The latter acknowledged the high honor paid him by sending an official to ask whether he could do anything for us, and though we assured him that there was no way in which our contentment with the world could possibly be improved, we found next morning that he had detailed four soldiers to accompany us. Whether this was out of sheer respect for our rank, from actual fear that bandits might attack us, or because the soldiers needed the few coppers which we might, and which he could or would not, give them, was not clear; but we rather suspected the last-named motive. They were a cheery and picturesque detail. No two of them had two garments that were uniform; their rifles bore a resemblance to some harmless substitute for a weapon, hand-made by some very clumsy youth half a century ago, and habitually misused ever since. In place of the usual strap, each had a string by which to hang the gun over his shoulder, and the bore was such that the cartridges, if there were any, must have been of just about the right diameter for our shot-gun. One of these merry protectors was so filled with song, of a strictly Chinese nature, that had he waited a bit longer to abandon me and give his precious protection to some other part of our straggling expedition he would certainly have had impressed upon him the rights and privileges of extraterritoriality. At the noonday halt we told this escort that, while they were men of whom any army might be proud, we could not dream of putting them to the task of tramping through the earthquake country ahead merely to defend our unworthy selves; moreover, we mentioned, we should be glad to give them at once the little present that they would get at nightfall if they continued. This last was evidently a strong 429argument, for we had the satisfaction of seeing them accept the suggestion with thanks and alacrity.
In a moment of carefree thoughtlessness, the major sent his card and our regards to the magistrate of Tsin-ching, who, of course, was too low-ranking to actually be visited. The magistrate replied by sending an official to ask if he could assist us with anything, and although we assured him that our satisfaction with the world couldn't be improved in any way, we discovered the next morning that he had assigned four soldiers to accompany us. It was unclear whether this was purely out of respect for our status, from a genuine fear of a bandit attack, or because the soldiers needed the few coins we might give them, which he could or would not provide; we suspected the last reason. They were a cheerful and colorful addition. No two of them wore the same outfit; their rifles resembled some harmless imitation weapon, crudely made by a clumsy youth half a century ago and misused ever since. Instead of the usual strap, each had a string to hang the gun over his shoulder, and the bore was such that the cartridges, if there were any, must have been just the right size for our shotgun. One of these jolly protectors was so full of traditional Chinese songs that if he had waited a bit longer to leave me and provide his precious protection to another part of our scattered group, he would surely have been reminded of the rights and privileges of extraterritoriality. At the midday break, we told this escort that, while they were men any army would be proud of, we couldn't possibly ask them to trek through the earthquake zone ahead just to defend us. Moreover, we mentioned that we would gladly give them the small gift they would receive at nightfall if they continued with us. This last point clearly had a strong impact, as we were pleased to see them accept our suggestion with gratitude and enthusiasm.
In many parts of Kansu, we learned before we left it, there was much the same old story of the inert weight of military pressure as elsewhere in China. The soldiers in many districts were not paid, but were allowed to shift for themselves upon the population. In theory this escort of ours received four thousand “cash” a month! But they depended much more upon such windfalls as ourselves, upon catching their own people gambling or trafficking in opium and confiscating their belongings, or upon foraging pure and simple among the helpless country people. Those groups which had strength and audacity enough called upon chambers of commerce and similar organizations for “loans” without interest—and of course without principal, so far as the lenders are concerned; others wandered the country until they found similar openings to which their strength was equal.
In many parts of Kansu, we learned before we left that there was a similar old story of the heavy burden of military pressure as in other parts of China. The soldiers in many areas weren’t paid, but had to rely on the local population to get by. In theory, our escort was supposed to receive four thousand "cash" a month! However, they were much more reliant on occasional windfalls like us, catching their own people gambling or dealing in opium to confiscate their belongings, or simply stealing from the vulnerable rural people. Groups that had enough strength and daring reached out to chambers of commerce and other organizations for “loans” without interest—and of course, without principal, as far as the lenders were concerned; others roamed the countryside until they found similar opportunities that matched their strength.
Even before we reached Tsin-ching there had been many signs of the great earthquake that had befallen this district; but in a land naturally so split and gashed and broken beyond repair many of these had passed almost unnoticed. Beyond that battered town, however, the chaotic world on every hand impressed upon us all day long that we were in the heart of the earthquake district, in so far at least as the main route to Lanchow passes through it. Even worse damage was done, people said, in districts off the road, but what we saw was enough to make it clear that the big fish which sits bolt upright and holds the earth between its fore fins had wagged his tail at the wickedness of mankind to excellent advantage. This cause of the tragedy and the Chinese cosmogony it involves were, by the way, firmly and unquestioningly believed not only by our cart-drivers, who were in every-day matters paragons of common sense, but by more than one Chinese of much higher caste. Only Chang, who claimed to be so fervent a Christian as not even to believe in “squeeze,” laughed at this view of the catastrophe; and he could not give any other reasonable explanation for it.
Even before we got to Tsin-ching, there were many signs of the massive earthquake that had hit this area; however, in a land that was already so cracked and damaged beyond repair, many of these signs went almost unnoticed. Beyond that battered town, though, the chaotic landscape surrounding us made it clear all day long that we were in the heart of the earthquake zone, especially since the main route to Lanchow runs through it. People mentioned that even worse damage occurred in areas off the main road, but what we saw was enough to make it obvious that the big fish resting upright and holding the earth between its fore fins had shaken its tail in response to humanity's wickedness to great effect. The cause of this tragedy and the Chinese cosmology it involves were firmly and unquestioningly believed not only by our cart drivers, who were otherwise practical in everyday matters, but also by several Chinese of much higher status. Only Chang, who claimed to be such a devoted Christian that he didn’t even believe in “squeeze,” laughed at this interpretation of the disaster; yet he couldn’t provide any other reasonable explanation for it.
Evidently such things had happened before in this part of the world, for not only does the broken and fissured loess country require some such interpretation but often pieces of old roof-tile protruded from the cliff-sides of the sunken roads a hundred feet or more below the surface. But this was the first quake within the memory of living inhabitants, and apparently within their traditions, though the region, 430and the inhabitants, too, for that matter, have been trembling ever since. The catastrophe came suddenly, without the slightest warning, at 7:30 in the evening of December 16, 1920, and had taken its appalling toll and gone almost before the survivors could catch their breath. Six hundred thousand people at least lost their lives; the official figures are one million, but the Chinese are prone to exaggerate, just as the Mohammedans habitually refuse to give accurate information in anything resembling a census. How many were injured is suggested by the fact that earthquake victims were still wandering into the hospital at Pingliang when we were there almost two years later. But cave-dwelling, especially in so frail a soil as this, is admirably designed to make an earthquake effective, and there is no computing how many were simply buried alive without any actual physical injury being done them.
Clearly, such events had occurred before in this region, as the broken and cracked loess landscape calls for some explanation. Old pieces of roof tiles often stuck out from the cliffs of the sunken roads, a hundred feet or more below the surface. However, this was the first earthquake in the memory of the living residents, and seemingly within their traditions, though the area and the inhabitants have been shaking ever since. The disaster struck suddenly, without any warning, at 7:30 PM on December 16, 1920, and it had devastating effects almost before the survivors could even process what had happened. At least six hundred thousand people lost their lives; official reports say one million, but the Chinese tend to exaggerate, just as Muslims often do not provide accurate census data. The number of injured is hinted at by the fact that earthquake victims were still arriving at the hospital in Pingliang when we were there nearly two years later. However, living in caves, especially in such fragile soil, makes earthquakes particularly lethal, and it’s impossible to know how many people were simply buried alive without suffering any physical injuries.
The missionaries as well as the Chinese of Kansu assert that the earthquake was a blessing in disguise—some of them even recognize in it a direct interference from heaven with earthly designs; for a General Ma and three hundred Mohammedan leaders were killed in a mosque in which, say their antagonists, they were preparing for another great Moslem rebellion, to begin the very next day. Some went so far as to say that an army of many thousand men, ready to begin its work at dawn, was buried hundreds of feet deep in a great ravine in which it was encamped. These things may not be strictly true, but there seems to be little doubt that, but for the earthquake, there would have been a Mohammedan uprising very shortly afterward. Since the great Chinese Moslem rebellion of 1862, in which eighty thousand non-Moslems are reputed to have been slaughtered, and in which certainly large cities and great districts were so devastated that they have not recovered to this day, there have been three smaller revolts against Chinese rule, so that although Kansu may not recall her earlier earthquakes she has by no means forgotten the terrors which this one is credited with having averted.
The missionaries and the people of Kansu say that the earthquake was a blessing in disguise—some even see it as a direct intervention from heaven in human affairs; a General Ma and three hundred Muslim leaders were killed in a mosque where, according to their opponents, they were planning another major Muslim rebellion set to start the very next day. Some claimed that an army of thousands, ready to act at dawn, was buried hundreds of feet deep in a large ravine where they were camped. These claims might not be entirely accurate, but it seems clear that if it hadn't been for the earthquake, a Muslim uprising would have likely occurred shortly afterward. Since the major Chinese Muslim rebellion of 1862, which reportedly resulted in the slaughter of eighty thousand non-Muslims and devastated large cities and regions that have yet to recover, there have been three smaller revolts against Chinese rule. So while Kansu may not remember its past earthquakes, it certainly hasn't forgotten the fears this one is believed to have prevented.
The more pietistic of the missionaries make much of the belief that, while many thousands of the wicked followers of the false prophet were buried in their caves or dashed to pieces in their ravines, not a Christian was killed. One by one, it was said, they straggled into the mission stations with stories of the untold damage that had taken place all about them, but weeping reverently at the miracle by which they and theirs had in every case escaped injury and even property loss. Without a discount for the unconscious exaggerations of overworked and over-pious apostles, such a fact would not be absolute and final proof of 431wrath of God against the Moslems for having picked the wrong faith, for while there are several million of them in the province, the number of Christians would not entirely preclude the possibility of their having been spared by mere chance rather than by divine intercession. In Pingliang, for instance, after thirty years’ work there are fifty baptized Christians; in another district two hundred converts are claimed among two hundred thousand families.
The more devout of the missionaries emphasize the belief that, while many thousands of the wicked followers of the false prophet were buried in their caves or smashed to pieces in their ravines, not a single Christian was killed. One by one, it was said, they wandered into the mission stations with stories of the incredible destruction happening all around them, but weeping with reverence at the miracle that allowed them and their families to escape injury and even losses to their property. Without accounting for the unconscious exaggerations of tired and overly religious apostles, this reality wouldn't be definitive proof of God's wrath against the Muslims for choosing the wrong faith, because while there are several million of them in the province, the number of Christians wouldn't completely rule out the chance that they were spared by luck rather than divine intervention. In Pingliang, for instance, after thirty years of work, there are fifty baptized Christians; in another district, two hundred converts are claimed among two hundred thousand families.
In the stiff, short climb through a ruined world an hour or two out of Tsin-ching, trees that had once shaded the road were hanging so precariously over great abysses that even this fuel-starved people did not dare to try to cut them. Here and there great pieces of the road, big willows, poplars, and all, had been pitched pell-mell over the edge. Yet villages still lived on lumps of earth half broken off from the rest of the world and ready to collapse into mighty chasms below. The mountains had indeed “walked,” as the complicated yet sometimes childishly simple Chinese language has it. Whole sides of terraced peaks had slipped off and carried the road intact, trees and all, half a mile away, had bottled up deep-green unnatural lakes at the bottom of great holes in the loess earth—to become what; a future menace or mere salt?—unless released by the hand of man. Sometimes half a dozen mountains had all danced together and left the brown loess churned up as if it had been boiled, with a new self-made “road” and the telegraph-wire on new poles stretching away across it, yet without the suggestion of an inhabitant, nothing but a deathly stillness for long distances, rarely broken perhaps by a magpie whose gay manners were utterly out of keeping with the desolate scene. Farther to the north, they say, one may still see shocks of harvested grain rotted in the fields, where the population was entirely killed off and none has come to take its place. Sometimes only half the terraced mountain-side had come down to overwhelm the tree-lined highway, or to bury a village as deeply as beneath the sea, the other half still supporting an uninjured hamlet below, as if nothing whatever had happened to disturb this quiet, bucolic existence. Ends of the mud walls of former villages protruding from the yellow chaos were often the only suggestion that human beings had once lived and bred and died there. Sometimes the wide road bordered by its venerable willows ended suddenly against a mighty bank of convulsed earth where the mountain had piled high over it, the new route clambering away over the débris with that indifference of youth to the experiences of old age that keeps the world moving onward instead of crouched at the roadside weeping over 432its disasters. In several places hundred-yard pieces of the old haphazard highway, twenty yards wide, had been gently picked up and set at right angles to its former course, without so much as a crack in its dozen mule-paths and the narrow strips of turf between them.
In the steep, brief climb through a devastated world an hour or two outside Tsin-ching, trees that once shaded the road now leaned so precariously over vast chasms that even this fuel-starved community didn’t dare to cut them down. Here and there, large sections of the road, along with big willows and poplars, had been thrown recklessly over the edge. Yet villages still existed on chunks of land half broken off from the rest of the world, ready to tumble into the massive gaps below. The mountains had indeed "moved," as the intricate yet sometimes childishly simple Chinese language describes it. Entire sides of terraced peaks had slipped away, taking the road intact—which included trees—half a mile away, creating deep-green, unnatural lakes at the bottoms of enormous holes in the loess soil. What would they become? A future threat or mere salt?—unless liberated by human hands. Sometimes, half a dozen mountains had all shifted together, leaving the brown loess churned up as if it had been cooked, forming a new self-made "road" with telegraph wires on new poles stretching across it, yet without any hint of human presence—only a haunting stillness over long distances, occasionally broken perhaps by a magpie, whose cheerful behavior was completely out of place in the desolate landscape. Farther north, they say, you can still see shocks of harvested grain rotting in the fields where the population was entirely wiped out, and none have come to take their place. Sometimes only half of the terraced mountainside had collapsed, overpowering the tree-lined highway or burying a village as thoroughly as if it were underwater, while the other half still supported an unharmed hamlet below, as if nothing had disrupted this tranquil, rural life. Ends of mud walls from former villages sticking out from the yellow chaos were often the only sign that people had once lived, thrived, and died there. Sometimes the wide road, bordered by its ancient willows, ended abruptly against a huge mound of twisted earth where the mountain had piled high, with the new route climbing over the debris, reflecting that youthful indifference to the experiences of old age that keeps the world moving forward instead of crouching at the roadside, grieving over its disasters. In several places, long stretches of the old, disordered highway, twenty yards wide, had been carefully lifted and set at right angles to their former paths, without so much as a crack in the dozen mule-paths and the narrow strips of grass between them.
Up over this broken and wrecked world came toward noon twenty coolies trotting under heavy loads of antlers oscillating from their pole-burdened shoulders. Wapiti and other deer are still found in the high mountains of Kansu, but the Chinese demand for their horns, preferably in the velvet, as medicine, is sure to exterminate them as completely as wanton destruction has the forests, probably pine and hemlock, that once covered all these tamed and terraced ranges. There is something strikingly un-Western, something akin to our own medieval ancestors, about the Chinese temperament in such matters, when they will continue century after century to pay fabulous prices—a good pair of elk-horns in the velvet will bring as much as fifty dollars gold in the large cities—for something of entirely imaginary value, without ever thinking of attempting to find out whether it is really good for anything or not. Their forebears thought so, and that settles the question. If once a custom can get a place with the Chinese, it need have little worry about holding its position, no matter how inefficient, useless, or even harmful it may become.
Up over this broken and wrecked world came toward noon twenty workers trotting under heavy loads of antlers swaying from their pole-supported shoulders. Wapiti and other deer are still found in the high mountains of Kansu, but the Chinese demand for their horns, especially in velvet, as medicine, is sure to wipe them out just as the reckless destruction has done to the forests, probably pine and hemlock, that once covered all these cultivated and terraced ranges. There’s something strikingly un-Western, something reminiscent of our medieval ancestors, in the Chinese attitude towards such matters, as they continue century after century to pay exorbitant prices—a good pair of elk horns in velvet can fetch as much as fifty dollars in gold in the big cities—for something of entirely imaginary value, without ever considering whether it truly has any benefits or not. Their ancestors believed it, and that settles it. Once a custom takes root with the Chinese, it doesn’t need to worry about losing its place, no matter how inefficient, pointless, or even harmful it may become.
Well on in the afternoon we came upon a beautiful blue-green lake imprisoned in a ravine, miles long and with a side arm of unknown length, all in a barren brown world without any other form of water. One might have fancied that the people roundabout would have been delighted to have it, and thank the earthquake for blocking the tiny stream that had formed it; but what do the people of Kansu know of the beauty of water, or of its usefulness, beyond what is required for their own and their animals’ gullets? So, with the help of American relief funds, they had cut a great gap through the fallen hill at the head of the lake—how queer that Kansu had to be paid by people on the other side of the earth for repairing their own land!—to assure themselves against being flooded out by such unnatural lakes when they rise above their barriers or seep away through the loose loess soil.
Late in the afternoon, we stumbled upon a stunning blue-green lake trapped in a ravine, stretching for miles with an offshoot of unknown length, all set in a barren brown landscape with no other source of water. You might think the locals would have been thrilled to have it and grateful to the earthquake for blocking the tiny stream that created it; but what do the people of Kansu understand about the beauty of water or its value, beyond what's necessary for their own and their animals’ needs? So, with the help of American relief funds, they dug a massive gap through the fallen hill at the lake's head—how strange that Kansu had to be funded by people from the other side of the world to fix their own land!—to prevent being flooded by these unnatural lakes when they overflow their banks or drain away through the loose loess soil.
We spent that night at the upper end of this lake in Tsing-kiang-yi, the town worst treated by the earthquake of any along the way. It was split into many fantastic forms, and threshing-floors had grown up in what were merely mighty earthquake cracks. This did not keep the inhabitants, however, from enjoying life in the orthodox Chinese 433fashion. A theatrical troupe had come to set up a makeshift stage of poles and matting on six-foot legs in a corner of a filthy open lot overhanging the mighty gorge into which much of the town had disappeared two years before, and most of Tsing-kiang-yi and the surrounding country stood crowded together in front of it. There is a difference only in degree between the theatrical performances given on such outdoor contrivances at country fairs and on village market-days and those in the most imposing theaters in Peking. The same nerve-racking “music” is torn off in hundred-yard strips by men at one side of the stage, who conduct themselves as freely all through the performance as if they were peanut-sellers in the market-place. There are the same more or less mythological beings in astonishing costumes, somewhat more soiled, surmounted by masked or painted faces, and these in turn by strange creations in wigs and head-dresses poorly joined to the wearers, who saunter out at intervals from the partly concealing mat dressing-room behind the stage proper and screech for long periods in the selfsame distressing falsetto with which Chinese theater-goers everywhere allow themselves to be tortured. The same property-man wanders incessantly about the stage, setting it to rights or bringing anything needed, like a nonchalant coolie at work in a coal-yard; the same unwashed ragamuffins, carelessly stuffed into absurd and multicolored garments which make them generals, gods, court attendants, or anything else the play may call for, are herded on and off in the wooden manner of “supers” the world over. Small boys—not to mention full-grown ones—clamber about the hasty structure in their eagerness to make the most of one of the rare treats of a dismal lifetime, even sitting in the edges of the stage itself, to the annoyance apparently only of a stray foreigner with his own queer notions of stage propriety. Down below, the standing audience may not behave with what the Western world would call rapt attention, but it has its own restless, free-for-all way of showing its delight.
We spent that night at the upper end of this lake in Tsing-kiang-yi, the town that was hit hardest by the earthquake of any along the way. It was cracked into many bizarre shapes, and threshing-floors had formed in what were simply massive earthquake fissures. Nevertheless, the locals didn't let that stop them from enjoying life in the traditional Chinese way. A theater group had set up a makeshift stage made of poles and matting on six-foot legs in a corner of a dirty open lot overlooking the huge gorge where much of the town had disappeared two years ago. Most of Tsing-kiang-yi and the surrounding area were gathered in front of it. There’s only a slight difference between the outdoor performances done on such setups at country fairs and those in the grandest theaters in Beijing. The same frenetic “music” is played in long stretches by men at one side of the stage, who act as casually throughout the performance as if they were selling peanuts in the market. The same more or less mythological characters in astonishing costumes, somewhat dirtier than usual, are topped with masked or painted faces, which in turn are topped by strange wigs and headpieces poorly attached to the wearers, who wander out at intervals from the partly hidden dressing area behind the stage and scream for extended periods in the same distressing falsetto that Chinese theater-goers everywhere endure. The same stagehand moves around continually, fixing things or bringing anything needed, like an indifferent laborer in a coal yard. The same unkempt kids, dressed in absurd and colorful outfits that make them look like generals, gods, court officials, or whatever the play requires, are shuffled on and off in the stiff manner of extras everywhere. Little boys—along with grown ones—scramble around the hasty structure, eager to make the most of one of the rare treats of an otherwise dreary existence, even sitting at the edge of the stage itself, much to the annoyance of a stray foreigner with his own strange ideas about stage etiquette. Down below, the audience may not behave with what the Western world would deem rapt attention, but it has its own restless, free-for-all way of showing its enjoyment.
In Chinese villages theatrical performances are usually a community undertaking, a way of spending the accumulated funds of this or that communal scheme, which it would of course be foolish to squander in building schools or cleaning the streets. Sometimes it is a treat offered by or forced from some prominent citizen, sometimes a sort of fine exacted from a neighboring village with which there has been a quarrel. That Chinese “actors” wandering through the provinces do not live in steam-heated hotels or ride in Pullman cars need scarcely be emphasized; indeed there is a strong suspicion from as far away as the outer edge 434of the audience that time and opportunity and inclination to remove the evidences of long cart-road travel very, very seldom coincide. But then, back in the interior players are still rated almost in the coolie class, however much they may suggest the romance of life to gaping yokels.
In Chinese villages, theater performances are usually a community effort, a way to spend the funds saved for various local projects, which of course would be foolish to waste on building schools or cleaning the streets. Sometimes it’s a treat offered by or extracted from a prominent local figure, and other times it’s a kind of fine imposed on a neighboring village after a dispute. It hardly needs mentioning that the Chinese “actors” wandering through the provinces don’t stay in fancy hotels or travel in luxury train cars; there’s a strong suspicion from the back of the audience that the time and opportunity to clean up after long travels rarely line up. However, out in the countryside, performers are still regarded almost like laborers, no matter how much they might evoke the romance of life for the amazed villagers.
We actually saw a man mending the road next day; that is, he was chopping out pieces of sandstone from between deep ruts in a very narrow gully, though he may merely have been gathering them for his own use. It had been a crisp, brilliant morning, more pleasant to walk than to ride, white smoke rising from a mud town across a great gorge ahead that would otherwise probably never have been distinguished from the brown-yellow hillside on which it hung. Perhaps a distant mule-bell faintly reached the ear, a pair of coolies on the sky-line caught the eye, and that might be all for long distances except the tumbled verdureless immensity. That day we clambered over a two-thousand-meter pass, then caught a great crack in the earth, along the high edge of which the road went until mid-afternoon, prosperous hills on either hand, and tilted farm-yards surrounded by high mud walls, into which we could look down as from an airplane. The earth had grown harder, a bit less friable than pure loess, though still without a suggestion of stone, and casting itself if anything in still more fantastic formations. Boys herding sheep or goats, and muleteers plodding behind their animals, sang on far-away mountain-sides snatches of song that sounded more Western than Chinese. Always a chaotic world of impossibly sculptured cliffs and incredible hollows unrolled itself before us. Now and again the road crawled across some great earth bridge, in constructing which the hand of man had taken no part, over a vast chasm but an insignificant stream; in some places it had fallen away into another of those breathless abysses, to skirt along the sheer edge of which seemed foolhardy even on foot. Yet all manner of Chinese travel, our own carts included, toiled serenely over these spots, apparently quite oblivious of the fact that the outer wheels more than once dropped to the hub down the side of the mighty precipice. Now and again surely some one must have gone over it with a piece of the crumbling road; perhaps the others burned a little joss at the nearest ruined mud temple and dropped a few “cash” into the big bronze kettle-gong the old beggar priest so constantly beats out in front of it, but certainly they did nothing else to be spared a similar fate on their next journey.
We actually saw a man fixing the road the next day; he was chopping out pieces of sandstone from the deep ruts in a narrow gully, though he might just have been collecting them for his own use. It had been a crisp, bright morning, nicer for walking than riding, with white smoke rising from a mud town across a deep gorge that otherwise would probably have blended into the brown-yellow hillside it rested on. Perhaps a distant mule-bell faintly reached our ears, and a pair of coolies on the skyline caught our attention, and that might have been all we could see over long distances except for the vast, barren landscape. That day we climbed over a two-thousand-meter pass, then followed a deep crack in the earth along the high edge where the road ran until mid-afternoon, with fertile hills on either side and sloped farmyards surrounded by tall mud walls, which we could look down into as if from an airplane. The ground had become firmer, a little less crumbly than pure loess, still without any sign of stone, and formed into even more bizarre shapes. Boys herding sheep or goats, along with muleteers trudging behind their animals, sang snippets of songs from far-off mountains that sounded more Western than Chinese. A chaotic landscape of impossibly sculpted cliffs and amazing dips unfolded before us. Now and then, the road crawled across a large earth bridge, which had been formed without any human intervention, over a vast chasm containing just a small stream; in some places, it had crumbled away into another one of those dizzying abysses, and skirting along the sheer edge of which felt reckless even on foot. Yet all kinds of Chinese travel, including our carts, calmly crossed these spots, seemingly unaware that the outer wheels had at times dropped to the hub down the side of the steep drop. Occasionally, someone must have gone over it with a piece of the crumbling road; perhaps others burned a little joss at the nearest ruined mud temple and dropped a few "cash" into the large bronze kettle-gong the old beggar priest constantly beats in front of it, but surely they did nothing else to avoid a similar fate on their next journey.
However, it is not true that the Chinese are utterly incapable of learning by experience. In this earthquake country, where living in 435caves proved so disastrous, they had certainly come out of them. But they were conservative in architecture as in other things, and the new mud huts, set as far out from the dreaded mountain-sides as possible, wherever inhabitants remained, were built in exactly the same shape as the caves, with an arched mud roof and the general appearance of having been dug out of the mountain and carried to the new setting. Such innovations will no doubt continue to be erected in this region until a new generation has forgotten and prefers to tempt fate again rather than go to the extra labor of building houses where it is so much easier to dig them.
However, it's not true that the Chinese are completely unable to learn from experience. In this earthquake-prone area, where living in caves turned out to be so dangerous, they definitely moved out of them. But they were cautious with architecture, just like with other aspects of life. The new mud huts, built as far from the feared mountainsides as possible, wherever people still lived, were designed in exactly the same shape as the caves, featuring arched mud roofs and giving the impression that they had been carved out of the mountain and moved to their new location. These types of buildings will likely continue to be constructed in this region until a new generation forgets the danger and chooses to take risks again rather than putting in the extra effort to build houses where it's much easier to just dig them.
Speaking of building, a very false impression prevails in the Western world as to Chinese structures. Because of their scores of centuries of existence and their tendency to cling to old things, many of us have assumed that the Chinese people build for posterity. Quite the contrary is the case. The Chinese, one is constantly being impressed, have their chief interest in their ancestors, or themselves, not in their descendants. Their coffins are made of mighty slabs of wood that have much to do with the crime of deforestation; they may not only spend all they have for the funeral of a father but often bankrupt themselves for a generation. But their houses are the cheapest possible structures, almost wholly made of the earth of the fields—the only material left, to be sure, in many regions. Mud bricks, mud and straw walls, mud k’angs in place of bed, chair, divan, and table—even the roof-tiles are merely a better baked form of mud. Nor is it only the humble homes that are reduced to this material. The dwellings of men of wealth, the palaces of the bygone dynasties, the very Temple of Heaven in Peking, the Great Wall itself, are impermanent structures largely put together with wet earth which is a sad substitute indeed for cement. It is as if, having an unlimited supply of dirt-cheap labor and a great paucity of good materials, the Chinese find something reprehensible in building too solidly, a waste of valuable substance as against inexpensive toil, perhaps a feeling that to build too well to-day will be unjust to those who will want work to-morrow. This point of view pervades everything, from imperial palaces to the tiniest of children’s toys, from temples and pagodas to water-jars and mud jugs; almost all of them are flimsy or easily destructible, whether by use, time, or the elements. The result is that the country from beginning to end is in a constant state of half-ruin or dismal disrepair, for the average life of most structures is so short that while one is being built up again another is sure to have fallen down.
Speaking of construction, there’s a common misconception in the Western world about Chinese buildings. Because of their long history and their tendency to hold onto the past, many assume that the Chinese build for future generations. In reality, that couldn't be further from the truth. It's clear that the Chinese are more focused on honoring their ancestors or themselves rather than their descendants. Their coffins are made from large slabs of wood, which significantly contributes to deforestation; they may spend everything they have on a father’s funeral, often leaving themselves financially strained for generations. However, their homes are constructed as cheaply as possible, primarily using the earth from the fields—the only available material in many areas. Mud bricks, mud and straw walls, mud k’angs serving as beds, chairs, sofas, and tables—even the roof tiles are essentially just baked mud. This isn’t just the case for humble homes; the residences of the wealthy, the palaces of past dynasties, the Temple of Heaven in Beijing, and even the Great Wall are all temporary structures largely made from wet earth, which is a poor substitute for cement. It seems that, with an abundant supply of inexpensive labor and a scarcity of quality materials, the Chinese feel that building too sturdily is wasteful, perhaps believing that it would deprive future workers of jobs. This mindset extends to everything, from grand imperial palaces to the smallest children’s toys, from temples and pagodas to water jars and mud jugs; nearly all of them are flimsy or easily destroyed, whether by usage, time, or natural forces. The result is that the entire country remains in a constant state of decay or neglect, as the average lifespan of most structures is so brief that while one is being rebuilt, another is already collapsing.
436In contrast to the endless processions of wheat-wagons and the like of a few days before, we met only two carts from dawn to sunset, and not many foot-travelers. Back in the crowded loess cañons it had been a pleasure to watch the expertness with which our chief cartman manipulated his loosely joined mules and awkward conveyance, taking advantage of every little break in the line of traffic, of every hesitation on the part of others to forge ahead, and keeping almost at our heels when such a feat seemed impossible. Here where travel was light his expertness was still needed to escape the many pitfalls of the road, and still the carts came close to keeping the pace we set. This was not breathless, to be sure; ninety li a day almost as regularly as the days dawned—and walled cities or at least large villages seemed to have been exactly spaced to accommodate travel at that rate. Our cartmen might have done their best, anyway, but the promise of a dollar cumshaw each for every day gained on the regular schedule assured it. This obviated arguments, worry, and a dozen other possible difficulties, and if our drivers insisted that it was better to spend the night at such a town rather than attempt to push on to the next we could take their word for it, which of itself was quite worth the extra money. In striking contrast to one of the serious drawbacks to cross-country travel in South America one could depend upon most road information. Ask almost any one how many li it was to such a place, and the answer usually was not only quick but fairly accurate. The finest thing about the Chinese li is that you need not worry about crossing a mountain or any other piece of unusually bad going; the li are shortened accordingly, and so many hours of steady plodding will bring you to your destination irrespective of conditions along the way.
436Unlike the endless stream of wheat wagons we saw just a few days earlier, we encountered only two carts from dawn to dusk, and not many people traveling on foot. Back in the crowded loess canyons, it had been enjoyable to watch our chief cartman skillfully manage his loosely joined mules and awkward cart, taking advantage of every little break in the traffic and any hesitation from others to move ahead, always close behind us even when it seemed impossible. Here, where travel was lighter, his skills were still essential to navigate the many pitfalls of the road, and the carts almost kept up with our pace. This pace wasn’t exhausting, of course; we traveled around ninety li a day quite consistently, and walled cities or at least large villages seemed perfectly spaced for that speed. Our cartmen might have done their best anyway, but the promise of a dollar cumshaw for every day we beat the regular schedule motivated them. This removed arguments, worries, and a dozen other potential issues, and if our drivers insisted it was better to stay in a town rather than push on to the next, we could trust their judgment, which was worth the extra money. In stark contrast to one of the serious drawbacks of cross-country travel in South America, you could rely on most road information here. Almost anyone could quickly and accurately tell you how many li it was to a certain place. The best part about the Chinese li is that you don’t have to worry about crossing a mountain or dealing with other rough terrain; the li are adjusted accordingly, so a few hours of steady trudging will get you to your destination no matter the conditions along the way.
Our road at length went down into the great cañon-bed of a little meandering stream that spent its days, and its nights, too, no doubt, in carrying away the cliffs which towered high above it, as they fell in clouds of dust and dissolved into silt. A few hours along this brought us to the rather striking town of Houei-ning, in a wide spot of the river valley with hills piling high above it close on every side. These and two distinct city walls enclosed what were virtually two towns, one somewhat more open and seeming to harbor an unusual number of religious edifices, the other crowded, with very narrow streets, still further darkened by many fantastic old wooden p’ai-lous. There were suggestions that the first was the Mohammedan quarter. Houei-ning was also repairing its walls, had indeed built a big new gate, and was now topping off the inner and principal defense with cream-colored brick parapets, loopholes and all. Pure mud was the only mortar, except between the topmost bricks, and the “masons” were small boys and old men. Boys barely eight years old were carrying great loads of bricks; those of ten or twelve had already been graduated into bricklayers. Almost all of them had glowing red cheeks, but their faces and hands were worse chapped than any one has ever seen, perhaps, outside China, where long sleeves are the poor substitutes for gloves or mittens, and hands toughened, not to say split and blackened, by exposure not only endure greater cold but water several degrees hotter than can our own.
Our road eventually led down into the wide canyon bed of a little winding stream that spent its days—and nights, too, I’m sure—carrying away the cliffs that loomed high above it, crumbling into clouds of dust and turning into silt. After a few hours, we arrived at the striking town of Houei-ning, located in a broad area of the river valley with hills towering above it on all sides. These hills, along with two distinct city walls, surrounded what were essentially two towns; one was somewhat more open and seemed to have an unusual number of religious buildings, while the other was crowded with very narrow streets, further darkened by many ornate old wooden p’ai-lous. It was suggested that the first area was the Muslim quarter. Houei-ning was also in the process of repairing its walls; they had built a large new gate and were now finishing the main defensive wall with cream-colored brick parapets, complete with loopholes. The only mortar used was pure mud, except between the topmost bricks, and the “masons” were small boys and old men. Boys barely eight years old were carrying heavy loads of bricks, while those aged ten or twelve had already moved up to being bricklayers. Almost all of them had bright red cheeks, but their faces and hands were more chapped than anyone has likely seen outside of China, where long sleeves are poor substitutes for gloves or mittens, and hands toughened—if not cracked and blackened—by the elements can endure greater cold and hotter water than ours.

This begging old ragamuffin is a Taoist priest
This scruffy old beggar is a Taoist priest.

A local magistrate sent this squad of “soldiers” to escort us through the earthquake district, though whether for fear of bandits, out of mere respect for our high rank, or because the “soldiers” needed a few coppers which he could not give them himself, was not clear
A local magistrate dispatched this group of “soldiers” to guide us through the earthquake area, but it was unclear whether it was due to fear of bandits, just out of respect for our high status, or because the “soldiers” needed a few coins that he couldn't provide himself.

Where the “mountain walked” and overwhelmed the old tree-lined highway. In places this was covered hundreds of feet deep for miles; in others it had been carried bodily, trees and all, a quarter-mile or more away
Where the “mountain moved” and overtook the old tree-lined highway. In some areas, it was buried hundreds of feet deep for miles; in others, it had been completely shifted, trees and everything, a quarter-mile or more away.

In the earthquake district of western China whole terraced mountain-sides came down and covered whole villages. In the foreground is a typical Kansu farm
In the earthquake area of western China, entire terraced mountainsides collapsed and buried whole villages. In the foreground is a typical Kansu farm.
437Badly hit by the earthquake, Houei-ning was still full of cracks and chasms and ruins, and the “roads” leading down into or out of it seemed in many cases to drop into pitfalls and sometimes entirely to lose themselves, or at least their sense of direction. There were many times as many dead as living inhabitants. The almost golden-yellow landscape of the verdureless mountain slopes about the town were more thickly covered with graves than I could remember ever having seen before, either in China or Korea; the myriads of little conical mounds suggested spatters of raindrops on a rolling, golden sea. High in the hills close above were what seemed to be a plethora of temples and monasteries, while all the landscape bristled with stone monuments, most of them on the backs of turtles, the rest handsome old ornamental arches of carved stone, all more or less cracked and ruined. Houei-ning must have had something of a history in bygone centuries, like so many now sleepy old towns of China.
437Badly damaged by the earthquake, Houei-ning was still filled with cracks, chasms, and ruins, and the “roads” leading in and out seemed to drop into pitfalls and sometimes completely lose their way, or at least their sense of direction. There were many more dead than living residents. The almost golden-yellow landscape of the barren mountain slopes around the town was more densely populated with graves than I had ever seen before, either in China or Korea; the countless little conical mounds looked like splashes of raindrops on a rolling, golden sea. High up in the hills nearby were what seemed to be numerous temples and monasteries, while the entire landscape was dotted with stone monuments, most resting on the backs of turtles, and the rest were beautiful old decorative arches made of carved stone, all more or less cracked and ruined. Houei-ning must have had quite a history in earlier centuries, like so many now quiet old towns in China.
Now it seemed to be the big market for those crude forked sticks which do duty as pitchforks among the Chinese. All this region made a four-tined one, with a wooden crosspiece let into and tied to the tines and the end of the handle with tough grass, but Houei-ning evidently had a monopoly on those grown in the form of a two-pronged implement. In Honan perfect three-tined ones were grown in abundance, as rose-bushes and the like are trained into fantastic shapes in Japan. The flimsiness of construction which everywhere impresses itself upon the traveler in China is nowhere more noticeable than in such peasants’ tools,—rakes a mere bamboo pole with one end split, spread, and bent over in the form of teeth; woven-wicker buckets for use at open holes in the fields that do service as wells; little bent-willow shovels for the countless thousands of boys and men, and not a few women and girls, who wander the roads with their baskets—for gathering the droppings of animals seems to be the favorite outdoor sport of China; it is a lonely 438trail and a depopulated region indeed where these are left to mingle with the soil. It was in Houei-ning, too, that we saw offered for sale guns that must have been old when the Manchu dynasty began, guns slender as a lance, eight feet or more long, with tiny butts apparently meant to be used against the thumb instead of the shoulder, and some contraption for firing that probably antedated the flint-lock by many decades. A fetching touch of color that increased as the weather grew more bitingly cold were the earlaps worn by nearly every one. In Kansu these are almost always home-made and hand-embroidered in gaily colored designs of birds, flowers, and the like, with much less violation of artistic standards than one would expect.
Now it seemed to be the major market for those crude forked sticks that serve as pitchforks in China. This entire region produced a four-tined version, with a wooden crosspiece inserted and tied to the tines and the handle with tough grass, but Houei-ning obviously had a monopoly on the two-pronged kind. In Honan, perfectly crafted three-tined ones were abundant, much like how rose bushes and other plants are trained into unique shapes in Japan. The flimsy construction that impresses itself upon travelers in China is nowhere more evident than in these peasant tools—rakes that are just bamboo poles with one end split, spread, and bent over like teeth; woven wicker buckets for use at open holes in fields that act as wells; little curved willow shovels for the countless boys and men, and quite a few women and girls, who wander the roads with their baskets—gathering animal droppings seems to be a favored outdoor activity in China; it's a deserted path indeed where these droppings are left to blend with the soil. It was also in Houei-ning that we saw guns for sale that must have been old when the Manchu dynasty began, slender guns like lances, eight feet or more long, with small butts that appeared to be made to be used against the thumb rather than the shoulder, and some firing mechanism that probably preceded the flint-lock by many decades. A striking touch of color that intensified as the weather turned more biting cold were the earmuffs worn by nearly everyone. In Kansu, these are almost always homemade and hand-embroidered with bright designs of birds, flowers, and similar motifs, with much less disregard for artistic standards than one would expect.
All through this region a custom wide-spread in China was very generally practised. That is, almost all boys from perhaps four to twelve years of age wore round their necks an iron chain big enough to restrain an enraged bulldog, and usually fastened together with a large native-forged padlock, though there would have been no difficulty in lifting off the whole contraption. The object of this adornment is to protect the precious male offspring from ill luck—here, perhaps, to keep the big fish from wagging his tail again. If parents have any reason to suspect that evil spirits are on the trail of a son, they hasten to a temple and put him in pawn to an idol, as it were; that is, they have a priest hang a chain, with much hocus-pocus, about his neck, thereby deceiving the powers of evil into believing that he is not their son at all but that he belongs to the temple. In a way this is true, for before he can be “redeemed” again by the parents the priest, who keeps the key of the padlock, must be generously rewarded. Let a boy fall ill, and no time is lost in evoking this sure protection; especially if one dies, his surviving or later-born brother is chained at once. The constant efforts of evil spirits to do injury to a family through the still unmarried sons, of whom ancestor-worship requires posterity, is one of the greatest banes of Chinese existence. Not the least uncommon of the tricks resorted to for the discomfiture of these unseen enemies is to give the boy a girl’s name, for naturally no evil spirit is going to waste his time in trying to injure a mere female.
All throughout this region, a widely practiced custom in China was very common. Almost all boys, from around four to twelve years old, wore a heavy iron chain around their necks, large enough to restrain an angry bulldog, usually secured with a large locally-made padlock, though it would have been easy to remove the whole thing. The purpose of this adornment is to protect their precious male children from bad luck—here, perhaps, to prevent misfortune from striking again. If parents suspect that evil spirits are targeting their son, they quickly go to a temple and essentially put him in the care of an idol; that is, they have a priest ceremoniously hang a chain around his neck, tricking the evil forces into thinking he doesn’t belong to them but rather to the temple. In a way, this is true, as before he can be “redeemed” by his parents, the priest, who holds the padlock key, must be generously compensated. If a boy falls ill, no time is wasted in activating this form of protection; especially if one boy dies, his surviving or younger brother is immediately chained. The constant attempts of evil spirits to harm a family through their unmarried sons, needed for ancestor worship, is one of the greatest struggles in Chinese life. One common tactic to confuse these unseen enemies is to give the boy a girl’s name, since no evil spirit is likely to waste time trying to harm a mere female.
The city gates of Houei-ning do not open until six, after which we went down again into labyrinthian loess gullies, across a broad fertile valley, and finally into a river cañon. Nothing could have been more dull than the long morning through this dreary chasm, in utter silence except for our own noises, and a rare donkey-boy singing his way along 439the top of the cliff far above. But, as if to make up for this dismal stretch, the road clambered early in the afternoon to the summit of a high ridge, with perhaps the most marvelous series of vistas of all our journey. There were crazy-shaped fields at every possible height, ragged little hollows that looked exactly like shell-holes, even their tiny bottoms carefully cultivated, threshing-floors throwing up grain like bursts of shrapnel, clusters of farm buildings of the identical color of all the landscape, and always surrounded by high mud walls, a wildly chaotic yet completely tamed land, utterly bare brown, turned golden by the brightest of suns and the clearest of air, with only the faintest purple haze on the far edges of the horizon. The trail had taken again to one of the pell-mell slopes of a mighty stream-worn crack in the earth and worked its way in and out along the haphazard face of this, across natural earth bridges, over jutting spurs and perpendicular ridges, into pockets where, cut off from the breeze but still in the brilliant sunshine, it was almost uncomfortably warm, and gradually carried us higher and higher on a ridge that swung more and more to the south. The miserable half-ruined mud village in which we found lodging was so high that to step out into the night was like diving into ice-water. Yet we kept to the ridge for hours more next morning before the road abandoned it at last and plunged headlong down into a big valley supporting the ancient town of Ngan-ting. An unusually huge wall of irregular shape, with very fancy high gates, surrounded the same crowds of staring, dirty people, of filthy-nosed, half-naked children and crippled women, all huddled together in the cold shadows instead of spreading out in the sunshine of the open world all about them. Ngan-ting seemed to be an important garrison town, through which we passed just in time to become entangled in some manœver resembling formal guard-mount, amid the barbaric blaring of many Chinese bugles. Our carts meanwhile had scorned the town and were on their way down the widest river valley yet. Along this the avenue of trees, some of their trunks scarred with pictorial obscenities, kept up in a half-hearted way; but scrub-poplar and sometimes almost branchless trunks were poor substitutes for the magnificent old willows farther east. Many of these had been cut down in this region, as huge stumps on a level with the earth showed. Apparently there is nothing that so exasperates the Chinese as the sight of a live tree; it would look so much better shaped as a coffin or turned into temple doors.
The city gates of Houei-ning don't open until six, after which we went back down into complicated loess gullies, across a wide fertile valley, and finally into a river canyon. Nothing could have been more boring than the long morning spent trudging through this dull chasm, with complete silence except for our own sounds and the occasional donkey-boy singing as he walked along the top of the cliff high above. But, as if to compensate for this dreary stretch, the road climbed early in the afternoon to the top of a high ridge, offering perhaps the most amazing series of views of our entire journey. There were oddly shaped fields at every conceivable height, ragged little hollows that looked just like shell craters, even their tiny bottoms carefully cultivated, threshing-floors sending up grain like bursts of shrapnel, clusters of farm buildings the same color as the surrounding landscape, and always enclosed by high mud walls, a wildly chaotic yet entirely controlled land, completely bare brown, turned golden by the brightest sun and the clearest air, with only the faintest purple haze on the far edges of the horizon. The trail had once again returned to one of the chaotic slopes of a massive stream-worn crack in the ground and wound its way in and out along the uneven face of this, across natural earth bridges, over jutting spurs and steep ridges, into pockets where it was almost uncomfortably warm, cut off from the breeze but still basking in the bright sunshine, gradually bringing us higher and higher on a ridge that swung increasingly to the south. The miserable half-ruined mud village where we found shelter was so high that stepping out into the night felt like diving into ice water. Yet we stayed on the ridge for several more hours the next morning before the road finally left it behind and plunged headfirst down into a large valley that held the ancient town of Ngan-ting. An unusually large wall of irregular shape, with very elaborate high gates, surrounded the same crowds of staring, dirty people, filthy-nosed, half-naked children, and disabled women, all huddled together in the cold shadows instead of spreading out in the sunshine of the open world around them. Ngan-ting seemed to be an important garrison town, and we passed through just in time to get caught up in some maneuver resembling formal guard duty, amid the barbaric blaring of many Chinese bugles. Meanwhile, our carts had bypassed the town and were making their way down the widest river valley yet. Along this avenue of trees, some of their trunks marked with crude drawings, the trees held on in a half-hearted way; but scrub poplar and often nearly branchless trunks were poor substitutes for the magnificent old willows further east. Many of these had been felled in this area, leaving huge stumps level with the ground. Apparently, there is nothing that annoys the Chinese quite like the sight of a living tree; it would look so much better carved into a coffin or turned into temple doors.
Suddenly, just beyond Ngan-ting, both sexes and all ages took to making yarn, in the Andean style of twirling a bobbin as they wandered 440about, and to knitting, not merely caps and stockings, but whole suits. We had once or twice been shocked some days earlier at the sight of a camel-driver calmly twiddling his knitting-needles as he strode or rode along, a pastime bad enough in talkative old ladies and tea-party guests who decline to waste their time, and certainly far beneath the dignity of the great male sex! But some missionary, it seemed, had started the craze—for a generation or so ago knitting was as unknown in China as real peanuts or the weaving of woolen clothing—and had neglected to explain its proper segregation. There had been no rain in all this region for a whole year, they said, and we had been advised to buy rain-water only of the Mohammedans, even if they forced us to pay high for it, since that to be had from the mere Chinese might be rank poison even after boiling. Somewhere along the way I had seen a blind youth marching round and round one of those two-stone grist-mills to be found all over China, and most often operated by a blindfolded donkey. His short hair where cues were still the fashion, and a not unattractive young woman watching him from a near-by doorway with an expression that might easily have been taken for a satisfied leer, naturally called up the memory of Samson and Delilah. Indeed, the fellow swung his head from side to side and lifted his feet unnecessarily high at every step in a way to prove that the late Caruso had learned at least one stage trick from real life. But the Philistines in this case were only the filth and lack of care which leave so many Chinese children sightless. There was a little blind boy of five that morning, for instance, carrying a baby brother of two, each wearing a single rag; and the baby was telling the boy where to step, though he afterward ran a bit alone and made the threshing-floor without mishap through many pitfalls.
Suddenly, just beyond Ngan-ting, people of all genders and ages started making yarn, using the Andean style of twirling a bobbin as they walked around, and knitting not just caps and socks but entire outfits. A few days earlier, we had been shocked to see a camel driver calmly knitting as he walked or rode along, a pastime that seemed ridiculous for chatty old ladies and tea party guests who avoid wasting their time, and certainly beneath the dignity of men! But it seemed that some missionary had sparked this trend—knitting had been virtually unknown in China a generation ago, just like real peanuts or wool clothing—and neglected to explain that it should be done separately by gender. They said there hadn't been any rain in this region for a whole year, and we were advised to buy rainwater only from the Muslims, even if they charged us a lot for it, since the water from the locals might be dangerously contaminated even after boiling. At some point, I had seen a blind young man walking in circles around one of those two-stone grist mills that are common in China, usually powered by a blindfolded donkey. His short hair, a style still in fashion, and a rather attractive young woman watching him from a nearby doorway with an expression that could easily be perceived as a smug grin naturally brought to mind the story of Samson and Delilah. Indeed, the guy swung his head from side to side and lifted his feet unnecessarily high with every step, proving that even the late Caruso must have picked up at least one trick from real life. But the real trouble here was the dirt and neglect that leave so many Chinese children blind. That morning, for instance, there was a little blind boy of five carrying his two-year-old brother, both wearing just a single rag; and the baby was guiding the boy on where to step, although he later managed to run a bit on his own and made it to the threshing floor without an accident despite numerous hazards.
In the account of his travels in China a decade ago Professor Ross has a chapter entitled, “Unbinding the Women of China.” One of the professor’s finest traits, however, is over-optimism. Foot-binding most certainly showed no signs of dying out in any of the territory through which we passed in our two months’ journey out into the northwest. A group of little girls from six to eight years old toddling along the road on crippled feet, yet carrying heavy baskets and driven, like calves to market, by a sour-faced old woman whose own feet still seemed to pain her at every step, was no unusual sight. One might easily have fancied they were to be offered for sale—girls can be bought for a mere song in this region. How often we passed a child in her early teens astride a donkey urged on by a man on foot, her little tapering legs ending in 441mere knots, her face so whitened and rouged that she looked like some inanimate and over-decorated doll! Only another bride, or concubine, on her way to the home of a husband or a master she had never seen. Girls certainly not yet ten years old were already shuffling about house- and threshing-floors in their football knee-pads; little girls dismally crying in some mud pen to which they had been banished because they could not suppress such signs of pain from their newly bound feet, or hobbling a few yards along the road with set lips, emphasized the fact that there are far worse fates even than being born a boy in China.
In his travel account from a decade ago, Professor Ross has a chapter titled, “Unbinding the Women of China.” One of the professor’s notable qualities is his excessive optimism. Foot-binding certainly showed no signs of fading away in any of the areas we traveled through during our two-month journey into the northwest. It was common to see groups of little girls, aged six to eight, walking along the road on crippled feet, yet carrying heavy baskets and herded like calves to market by a grumpy old woman whose own feet seemed to hurt her with every step. One might easily think they were up for sale—girls can be bought for very little in this region. How often did we see a girl in her early teens sitting on a donkey, being urged on by a man walking beside her, her little legs ending in mere knots, her face so whitened and made up that she looked like an over-decorated doll! Just another bride or concubine on her way to meet a husband or master she had never seen. Girls not yet ten years old were already moving about the household and fields in their knee pads; little girls crying in some mud pen because they couldn’t hide their pain from their newly bound feet, or hobbling a few yards down the road with tight lips, emphasized the reality that there are far worse fates than being born a boy in China.
Crippled feet would be bad enough in comfort and warmth and with plenty of servants to save steps, as probably most Westerners fancy Chinese women have who are thus “beautified.” But if there is any decrease in foot-binding at all, it is among the well-to-do, the wealthy in large cities who might sit perpetually in cushions and spare their little feet. Your peasant and countryman is most insistent that the old custom be kept up; he would sneer with scorn at the thought of taking a wife with natural feet; he sternly insists that his daughters’ feet be bound. Stumping about their filthy huts, shivering with mountain cold, probably never washing all over once in a lifetime, it is astonishing that these country women do not all die of gangrene or something of the sort. How they keep such feet warm, when they cannot move rapidly, when they ride sometimes all day in a cold so bitter that even we were forced to get off and walk at frequent intervals, is a question I have never yet heard answered. Perhaps the foot becomes a kind of hoof, devoid of feeling and incapable of freezing.
Crippled feet would be uncomfortable enough even with warmth and plenty of servants to save steps, as most Westerners probably imagine Chinese women have to be “beautified.” But if there’s any decline in foot-binding, it’s mostly among the wealthy in big cities who can sit comfortably on cushions and spare their tiny feet. The peasants and country folks are adamant about maintaining the old custom; they would scoff at the idea of marrying a woman with natural feet and firmly demand that their daughters' feet be bound. Stumbling around their filthy huts, shivering in the mountain cold, and likely never washing properly in their lives, it’s surprising that these country women don’t all succumb to gangrene or something similar. How they keep such feet warm while being unable to move quickly, and when they sometimes ride all day in bitter cold that even we had to escape from by walking at intervals, is a question I have yet to hear answered. Perhaps the foot becomes like a hoof, numb and unable to freeze.
At first thought one might fancy that at least a few mothers who had suffered all their lives would spare their daughters similar misery. For, they have told missionary women, their bound feet hurt whenever they walk, and generally they have pains also in the legs and the back as long as they live. Knowing how serious a mere broken arch may be, it is not hard for us to imagine what it must mean to have the arch doubled back upon itself by turning the toes under and squeezing the heel up to meet them, and then insisting that the victim walk. But even if the mothers were devoid of that wide-spread human cussedness which makes misery love company, even if the father did not absolutely insist, there is the economic question. Girls must have husbands—“or they will starve,” as even experienced Peking amas put it. There is no provision in the Chinese scheme of family for old maids. But granting that all these insuperable difficulties have been overcome, there is the 442girl herself with whom to reckon. If she has reached the age—six to seven—when the binding should begin, and it has not begun, she is likely to commence by insisting, and to advance to weeping and tearing her hair unless the oversight is corrected. In other words, girls cry if their feet are not bound; and they certainly cry if they are, so that there is apparently no escape from tears. You would hardly expect a modest American school-girl willingly to consent to mingle with her companions if she were obliged to wear trousers, or to cut her hair boy fashion; and in China “face,” the fear of ridicule and public opinion, is much stronger than in the United States, and customs and precedents are far more solidly intrenched. Naturally the Chinese girl would rather face a little suffering—for at her age she probably has only a hazy idea of the length of the ordeal and the severity of the pain involved—than to be made fun of all her life for her “boy’s feet,” and, worse still, to lose all chance of getting a husband, which she has been taught to think is the most dreadful, in fact the most unsurvivable, fate that can befall her. Once in a while some poor orphan girl is so “neglected” that no one takes the trouble to bind her feet; and she becomes the village slattern and a horrible example to all “decent” girls. For of course she cannot get a husband; she will be unusually fortunate if some one gives her a job as a barn-yard drudge.
At first glance, one might think that at least some mothers who have suffered their whole lives would want to spare their daughters from the same pain. They’ve told missionary women that their bound feet hurt whenever they walk, and they often experience aches in their legs and back for the rest of their lives. Knowing how serious even a broken arch can be, it’s not hard to imagine what it’s like to have the arch bent backward by curling the toes under and pushing the heel up to meet them, all while being forced to walk. But even if the mothers didn’t have that common human tendency to want others to share in their misery, and even if the fathers didn’t insist, there’s still the economic factor. Girls need husbands—“or they will starve,” as even experienced Peking women say. The Chinese family structure doesn’t make room for old maids. But even if all these overwhelming challenges could be overcome, there’s still the girl herself to consider. If she’s reached the age—around six to seven—when foot binding should start, and it hasn’t, she’s likely to start insisting, and then move on to crying and tearing her hair out unless the situation is fixed. In other words, girls cry if their feet aren’t bound; and they definitely cry if they are, so it seems there’s no way to escape tears. You wouldn’t expect a modest American schoolgirl to agree to hang out with her friends if she had to wear trousers or cut her hair like a boy; in China, “face,” or fear of embarrassment and public opinion, is much more significant than in the United States, and traditions are deeply embedded. Naturally, the Chinese girl would prefer to endure some pain—since at her age she probably has only a vague idea of how long the ordeal will last and how severe the pain will be—rather than be mocked for having “boy’s feet,” and even worse, to lose her chance of getting a husband, which she’s been taught is the most terrible, in fact the most unbearable, fate she can suffer. Occasionally, some poor orphan girl is so “neglected” that no one bothers to bind her feet; she then becomes the village outcast and a terrible example to all “decent” girls. After all, she can’t get a husband; she’ll be exceptionally lucky if someone gives her a job as a barnyard worker.
Our hostess at one of the mission stations knew a girl whose feet had not been bound but who turned out to be very pretty. One day an important official happened to see her as he was passing through the district. “What a pity,” he said, “that her feet are not bound, for if they were I would take her as a concubine.”
Our hostess at one of the mission stations knew a girl whose feet hadn’t been bound but who turned out to be really pretty. One day, an important official happened to see her while passing through the area. “What a pity,” he said, “that her feet aren’t bound, because if they were, I would take her as a concubine.”
“Oh, do not let that stand in the way of your desire, your Excellency,” cried the enchanted mother; “give me a year and I will have her ready for you.”
“Oh, don’t let that stop you from what you want, Your Excellency,” cried the enchanted mother; “give me a year and I’ll have her ready for you.”
“But you cannot bind her feet in a year,” replied the official.
“But you can’t bind her feet in a year,” replied the official.
“Only leave it to me, your Excellency, and I shall not fail you,” persisted the mother.
“Just leave it to me, Your Excellency, and I won’t let you down,” the mother insisted.
A year later the girl took the proud position that had been offered her, as concubine to what, to the simple country people, was a very great man; but to this day, though she still keeps her precarious place, she cannot walk a step. For instead of starting gradually, by bending the toes under and wrapping them in wet cloths that shrink, then tying them down more tightly and beginning to draw up the heel the following year, and so on, this mother was working against time. So she literally cut much of the flesh off the girl’s feet, broke nearly every bone in them, 443and by the time the year was up she had made her as helpless a cripple as any mandarin could have wanted for a plaything.
A year later, the girl took the prestigious position that had been offered to her as a concubine to what, for the simple country folks, was a very significant man; but to this day, even though she still holds her unstable position, she can't walk at all. Instead of starting slowly by bending her toes under and wrapping them in wet cloths that would shrink, then tightening them down more and starting to pull up her heel the next year, this mother was racing against time. So she literally cut off much of the flesh from the girl’s feet, broke nearly every bone in them, 443 and by the end of the year, she had made her as helplessly crippled as any mandarin could have wanted for a toy.
The best style of bound feet, it seems, have the bones broken. Exacting men ask if this has been done, and show worth-while approval at an affirmative answer. Feet seem to vary in size and style by localities. In some places on our western trip they were so small that no real foot remained; the leg tapered down without a break to the end, almost as if it had been cut off at the ankle. In fact we often wondered if it would not have been much simpler and far less painful to amputate the feet entirely. In other places the big toe was left, and with it something of the shape of a foot. But under this the tiny shoe was generally fitted with a miniature heel, often red in better-to-do cases, which made walking next to impossible. With no give and take of the leg-muscles, these of course soon dry up, so that the leg resembles a tapering wooden stump and the gait bears out the likeness. Foot-binding is certainly a wonderful scheme to keep the women from gadding about; and in a land where they are seldom expected to leave the compound in which they are delivered to the husband—or mother-in-law—this no doubt is considered a great asset. Earlier writers have told of districts in which the feet are no longer bound because of the sad experiences of fleeing women who could not keep up with their men-folks at the time of the great Mohammedan rebellion. But we never saw any such districts. Probably the experiences have been forgotten, and custom has reasserted itself. The Mohammedans, by the way, are just as bad as the mere Chinese in this matter of foot-binding; if I remember rightly, the Koran has nothing to say against it.
The most desirable style of bound feet seems to involve breaking the bones. Discriminating men ask if this has been done and show their approval when they get a yes. Feet seem to vary in size and style depending on the area. In some parts of our western journey, they were so tiny that no real foot remained; the leg tapered down without any break to the end, almost as if it had been cut off at the ankle. We often wondered if it would have been much simpler and far less painful to just amputate the feet entirely. In other areas, the big toe was left, maintaining a bit of the foot's shape. However, a tiny shoe with a miniature heel was typically fitted underneath, often colored red in wealthier cases, which made walking nearly impossible. Without the flexibility of their calf muscles, these legs eventually shrivel, resembling slender wooden stumps, and their walk reflects that. Foot-binding is definitely an ingenious way to keep women from wandering around; in a place where they’re rarely expected to leave the household where they are given to their husbands or mothers-in-law, this is likely seen as a significant advantage. Earlier writers have noted regions where feet are no longer bound because of the tragic experiences of fleeing women who couldn’t keep up with their male relatives during the great Muslim rebellion. But we never encountered any such areas. The memories of those experiences have probably faded, and tradition has taken over again. By the way, the Muslims are just as strict as the Chinese when it comes to foot-binding; if I remember correctly, the Koran doesn’t specifically oppose it.
As far as we noticed, the missionaries in the northwest did not seem to be making any great effort to reduce this most atrocious of Chinese customs. Some of them appeared to be more eager to save souls than soles, though in general they were men and women of sound common sense, with their own feet on the ground rather than with their heads lost in the clouds. Suffering and misery, immorality and wicked superstitions are so general in China that the mere crippling of the feet soon becomes but one of many possible points of attack. Christian converts are not allowed to bind their feet; if they are already bound, they are expected, in theory at least, to unbind them, though this in the case of older women is not always possible. Girls with bound feet are refused admission to most, if not all, Christian schools; and a few of the best government institutions are commencing to follow suit. The best argument of all against the practice is the plain economic one. If you bind 444your daughter’s feet she cannot marry within the church, the missionaries tell a convert, for Christian boys will not have her. As available husbands of that point of view increase, the girls are of course more and more willing to run the risk of not having themselves adorned with lily feet. But, to be frank, Christianity is not rapidly increasing, and bound feet seem to be as prevalent, at least in northern China, as ever, except in Peking and a few coast cities, where it is against the law, in Manchuria, where it is contrary to custom, in the rather small and scattered Christian communities, and among a few of the more progressive families in the larger cities.
As far as we can tell, the missionaries in the northwest didn’t seem to be making much of an effort to challenge this horrible Chinese custom. Some of them seemed more focused on saving souls than addressing issues on the ground, although generally, they were practical people, keeping their feet on the ground instead of getting lost in lofty ideas. Suffering and hardship, immorality, and harmful superstitions are so widespread in China that the issue of foot binding becomes just one among many problems to tackle. Christian converts are not allowed to bind their feet; if they are already bound, they are expected—at least in theory—to unbind them, though this isn’t always feasible for older women. Girls with bound feet are denied entry to most, if not all, Christian schools, and a few of the top government institutions are starting to do the same. The strongest argument against the practice is the straightforward economic one. If you bind your daughter’s feet, she cannot marry within the church, the missionaries tell converts, because Christian boys won’t accept her. As the pool of eligible husbands who think this way grows, girls are naturally more willing to risk not having their feet bound. However, to be honest, Christianity isn’t growing quickly, and bound feet seem to be just as common, at least in northern China, as ever, except in Peking and a few coastal cities, where it’s illegal, in Manchuria, where it goes against custom, in the relatively small and scattered Christian communities, and among some of the more progressive families in larger cities.
Custom is not only a curiously tenacious weed but often a quick-growing one. I was impressed with the latter thought one morning when, in riding into a town of some size, I caught sight of a woman with natural feet, such as I had not seen perhaps for a week; and the first flash to cross my mind might have been expressed in some such exclamation as, “My, but isn’t she ugly!” The abnormal type is always ugly, and if, in a mere week, a foreigner can become so accustomed to the normal Chinese woman, who tapers down like a sharpened stake, that an uncrippled one strikes him, even momentarily, as a kind of monstrosity, it is easy to understand why the Chinese have come in many centuries to consider this alteration of the human form both an improvement and a necessity. Nor is the custom so universally injurious to the health as the rest of the world naturally supposes. Women with cheeks bright red without the aid of rouge, yet with the tiniest of feet, were no more unusual in Kansu than the filthy, old, and totally unattractive ones who scuttled away into their holes as if they were in imminent danger when two harmless foreigners rode by on travel-weary pack-mules.
Custom is not just a surprisingly resilient weed but often a rapidly growing one. I realized this one morning when I rode into a somewhat large town and saw a woman with natural feet, something I hadn’t noticed in about a week; my immediate thought could be summed up as, “Wow, she’s ugly!” The unusual type is always unattractive, and if, in just a week, a foreigner can become so used to the typical Chinese woman, who narrows down like a sharpened stake, that an uncrippled one seems, even briefly, like a kind of monstrosity, it's easy to see why the Chinese, over many centuries, have come to view this change in the human form as both an improvement and a necessity. Additionally, the custom isn't as universally harmful to health as the rest of the world tends to think. Women with naturally bright red cheeks, without the help of makeup, yet with the smallest feet, were just as common in Kansu as the dirty, old, and completely unattractive ones who scurried away into their hideouts, as if they were in serious danger when two harmless foreigners passed by on their tired pack-mules.
Beyond “Dry Straw Hotel”—most Chinese place names are quaint and simple if you translate them—where we made the noonday halt on the next to the last day of the journey, the hills were no longer terraced, perhaps because they were too steep, but lay piled up in a thousand folds and wrinkles that made them even more beautiful. Wheat was flowing the other way now, toward Lanchow, mainly on donkeys. There was much stone in the soil of the great plain across which we jogged with a growing sensation of eagerness that afternoon, and to the left, hazy under the low sun, the beginning of the high ranges bordering Tibet. Large towns were frequent, though there was no decrease in dirt and poverty.
Beyond “Dry Straw Hotel”—most Chinese place names are charming and straightforward when you translate them—where we stopped for lunch on the second to last day of the journey, the hills were no longer terraced, maybe because they were too steep, but instead were piled up in countless folds and wrinkles that made them even more beautiful. Wheat was now flowing the other way, toward Lanchow, mostly on donkeys. There was a lot of stone in the soil of the vast plain we rode across that afternoon, and to the left, hazy under the low sun, were the first signs of the high ranges bordering Tibet. Large towns were common, but there was no decrease in dirt and poverty.

Kansu earlaps are very gaily embroidered in colored designs of birds, flowers, and the like. Pipes are smaller than their “ivory” mouthpieces
Kansu ear caps are brightly embroidered with colorful designs of birds, flowers, and similar patterns. The pipes are smaller than their "ivory" mouthpieces.

It is a common sight in some parts of Kansu to see men knitting, and still more so to meet little girls whose feet are already beginning to be bound
It’s a common sight in some areas of Kansu to see men knitting, and even more common to encounter little girls whose feet are already being bound.

The village scholar displays his wisdom by reading where all can see him—through spectacles of pure plate-glass
The village scholar shows off his knowledge by reading in a spot where everyone can see him—through clear glass glasses.

A Kirghiz in the streets of Lanchow, where many races of central Asia meet
A Kyrgyz person in the streets of Lanzhou, where many ethnic groups from Central Asia come together.
445Toward sunset we were accosted at the beginning of a defile by two Chinese on sleigh-bell-jingling horses, one of whom handed us a letter. It was from the chief Protestant missionary of Lanchow, a friend of the major’s, to whom he had written from Sian-fu announcing our coming. Rapidly as we had traveled, the coolie-borne fast mail had so far outstripped us that here was the reply, welcoming us to the city and regretting that, since we were to arrive on a Sunday, services made it impossible for the writer to come out and meet us in person. To be met thirty miles out by a host, even by proxy, struck us as real hospitality; and the fact that the messengers had no difficulty in identifying us is all that need be said as to the scarcity of Caucasian travelers in Kansu. Even had they missed us among the labyrinthian paths and gullies, they would not have gone far before some one would have told them that the two foreigners had already passed. In all the sixteen days we saw on the road two pairs of Russian Jews and two Dutch Catholic priests, and had spent the night with two sets of missionaries and dined with a third. One of the messengers was to return to Lanchow post-haste with news of our arrival, and the other was to serve us as guide. They do some things in a regal fashion in the far interior of China.
445As sunset approached, we were approached at the start of a narrow pass by two Chinese on jingling-horse-drawn sleighs, one of whom handed us a letter. It was from the chief Protestant missionary in Lanchow, a friend of the major’s, who had written from Sian-fu to announce our arrival. Despite our rapid travel, the coolie-transported express mail had outpaced us so much that here was the response, welcoming us to the city and expressing regret that since we were arriving on a Sunday, services made it impossible for the writer to come out and greet us in person. Being welcomed thirty miles out, even through a representative, felt like true hospitality; and the fact that the messengers easily recognized us says a lot about how few Caucasian travelers are in Kansu. Even if they had lost us among the winding paths and gullies, they wouldn't have gone far before someone would have informed them that the two foreigners had already passed. In the entire sixteen days we traveled, we encountered two pairs of Russian Jews and two Dutch Catholic priests, and we spent the night with two sets of missionaries while dining with a third. One of the messengers would return to Lanchow immediately with news of our arrival, and the other would act as our guide. They do some things with a royal touch in the remote areas of China.
The last town in which we were forced to pass a night was a miserable collection of filth and half-baked mud, though rich in grain, stacks covering the flat roofs and surrounding the hard-earth floors on which it was still being threshed; though two brand-new temples gleamed forth from the general ugliness. All next morning a half-witted road, evidently bent on outdoing itself as a fitting climax of the journey, wandered along a wide river valley cut up everywhere not only by the meandering stream itself but by hundreds of irrigation ditches. All these were frozen over more or less solidly, with the result that progress was a constant struggle with our mules, already jaded with fatigue and fright and covered with icicles when we climbed at last to the bank and made our way through almost continuous villages by a narrow road. Even here irrigation ditches still made trouble, and strings of carts and camels reduced progress materially, though this did not greatly matter, since there was no difficulty in keeping up with our carts that had been obliged to continue along the river bottom. Pure loess had disappeared some days before, but the soil was merely a bit more solid along the road that had been deliberately cut through a hill beyond which I came out sooner than I had expected upon the Yellow River, here racing swiftly through a deep rocky gorge and rather gray than yellow in 446color. Extraordinary activity had broken out in the large town forty li from the end of our journey, for hundreds of men were building a real embankment, hauling stone from far up the river-bed, and preparing to throw a bridge across the tributary down which we had come. But the enterprise, it turned out, was not the complete nullification of the opinion we had formed of the Chinese inability to accomplish public works, for it was being done with American relief funds under the supervision of the host who was awaiting us.
The last town where we had to spend the night was a grim collection of dirt and half-baked mud, although it was rich in grain, with stacks on the flat roofs and around the hard earth floors where it was still being threshed; however, two brand-new temples stood out against the overall ugliness. The next morning, a poorly maintained road, clearly determined to outdo itself as the perfect ending to our journey, meandered along a wide river valley, which was crisscrossed not only by the winding stream itself but also by hundreds of irrigation ditches. All of these were mostly frozen over, making our progress a constant battle with our mules, already worn out from fatigue and fear and covered in icicles when we finally climbed up to the bank and made our way through almost continuous villages along a narrow road. Even here, the irrigation ditches caused issues, and lines of carts and camels slowed us down considerably, though it didn’t matter much since we could easily keep pace with our carts that had to stay along the riverbottom. Pure loess had vanished several days earlier, but the soil was just a bit more solid along the road that had been deliberately cut through a hill. I unexpectedly emerged onto the Yellow River, which was rushing quickly through a deep rocky gorge and was more gray than yellow in color. A remarkable amount of activity had erupted in the large town forty li from the end of our journey, as hundreds of men were building a real embankment, hauling stones from upstream, and preparing to build a bridge across the tributary we had come down. However, it turned out that this effort didn’t entirely overturn our opinion of the Chinese inability to handle public works, as it was being done with American relief funds under the supervision of the host who was waiting for us.
Tobacco grew all along the last fertile miles of the journey, and the increasing population busied itself in stripping leaves instead of winnowing grain. These were carried home in two-man litters made of matting, while the stripped stalks evidently served as fuel. For some reason, which no one could explain to us, many of the fields were still covered with the grown plants, shriveled and brown from the early winter frosts, and in many cases covered with a kind of straw cap. Then the road thought better of the short respite it had given us and plunged uphill through another genuine loess cañon, where cliffs seemed ready to fall in clouds of dust and camel-trains crowded. Out of this we broke an hour or more later upon a far-reaching view of the wide, open plain walled by mountains, across which, still twenty li distant, lay the capital of China’s westernmost province.
Tobacco grew along the last fertile stretch of our journey, and the growing population was busy stripping leaves instead of harvesting grain. They transported the leaves home in two-man litters made of matting, while the stripped stalks were clearly used as fuel. For reasons no one could explain to us, many fields still had the fully grown plants, shriveled and brown from the early winter frost, and in many cases, covered with a kind of straw cap. Then the road reconsidered the brief break it had given us and began climbing uphill through another genuine loess canyon, where cliffs seemed ready to collapse in clouds of dust and camel trains were crowded. We finally emerged from this an hour or more later to a sweeping view of the wide, open plain surrounded by mountains, where, still twenty li away, lay the capital of China’s westernmost province.
CHAPTER XXIV
In Muslim China
High up above the plain of Lanchow, on the topmost hillock of the partly terraced mountains that bound it on the south, stands a new pagoda. It was built by the wife of the former Tuchun, but as neither he nor she, nor her particular brand of Buddhism, were popular favorites, the people say that their prosperity departed on the day it was completed. Conspicuous as it is from many li away, no one seems to visit it. At least there was not another footstep in the snow that had fallen some days before when I climbed to it one morning, and its three stories, open to all the world, showed not a single recent human trace. The mere fact that it took three hours of steady and not easy climbing, first by a mountain trail to some distant village, then at random up and across terraces where the feet floundered in snow and loose earth, could hardly have accounted for this abandonment; for no holy place in the Orient is too difficult of access for an occasional zealot. No, the pagoda of the Tuchun’s wife was plainly not a welcome addition to the landscape.
High up above the plains of Lanchow, on the highest hill of the partly terraced mountains that border it to the south, stands a new pagoda. It was built by the wife of the former Tuchun, but since neither he nor she, nor her specific brand of Buddhism, were popular, people say that their good fortune left on the day it was finished. Even though it's visible from many li away, no one seems to visit it. At least there were no other footprints in the snow that had fallen a few days prior when I climbed up to it one morning, and its three stories, open to everyone, showed no signs of recent human activity. The fact that it took three hours of steady and not easy climbing—first by a mountain trail to a distant village, then randomly up and across terraces where my feet sank into snow and loose dirt—could hardly explain this neglect; after all, no sacred site in the East is too hard to reach for an occasional devotee. No, the pagoda built by the Tuchun’s wife was clearly not a welcome addition to the landscape.
It was unsurpassed, however, for its bird’s-eye view of Lanchow and its environs; though, to be sure, a steam-heated lounging-room would have improved it at this season. While the capital of China’s most western province is on the thirty-sixth parallel, like Memphis, Tennessee, it is five thousand feet above sea-level, and the wind-swept pagoda was much more so. The snow had now laid the dust that swirled so easily when we rode into the city, but it had not fallen deep enough to hide any important features of the great oval plain stretching from the foot of this southern barrier to the Yellow River, beyond which the world piled itself up again in what would have been the familiar brown, utterly barren tumbled hills of northwestern China but for its light mantle of winter white. The plain was not a mighty checker-board, for the myriad divisions into which the little low mud barriers between its fields marked it were altogether too numerous and fantastic in shape. But as a whole it gave that impression, or, still more exactly, it resembled a mammoth pane of glass that had been shattered into many 448more than a thousand pieces, and then laid together again on a flat surface by some artist in Chinese puzzles.
It was unmatched, however, for its panoramic view of Lanchow and the surrounding area; although, to be fair, a steam-heated lounge would have made it better at this time of year. While the capital of China’s most western province is on the thirty-sixth parallel, like Memphis, Tennessee, it is five thousand feet above sea level, and the wind-swept pagoda was even higher. The snow had now settled the dust that swirled so easily when we rode into the city, but it hadn’t fallen thick enough to obscure any important features of the expansive oval plain extending from the foot of this southern barrier to the Yellow River, beyond which the landscape rose again in what would typically have been the familiar brown, completely barren, rugged hills of northwestern China, except for its light layer of winter white. The plain wasn’t a massive checkerboard, as the countless divisions marked by low mud barriers between its fields were simply too numerous and oddly shaped. But overall it gave that impression, or more precisely, it resembled a giant pane of glass that had been shattered into more than a thousand pieces, then reassembled on a flat surface by some artist in Chinese puzzles.
When we had first ridden across this oasis many slender, misformed trees caught the eye, but from this height these barely relieved the vast expanse of an appearance of total treelessness. On that day we had noticed many fields of gray, a color so out of keeping with an autumn Kansu landscape that we were eager with curiosity until we found that acres after acres had been carefully covered, apparently by hand, with small stones. This was a method of keeping the precious moisture in the ground, which, our host explained, was common to all this region; when the fields are tilled or planted the stones are merely raked away from a small space at a time and then quickly replaced. We resolved to tell the next group of New England farmers we met that there are people who purposely cover their fields with stones.
When we first rode across this oasis, many tall, oddly shaped trees caught our attention, but from this height, they hardly broke up the vast emptiness of what looked like an endless stretch of nothingness. That day, we noticed many fields of gray, a color so out of place in the autumn landscape of Kansu that we were filled with curiosity until we discovered that acres and acres had been carefully covered, seemingly by hand, with small stones. This was a method for preserving the precious moisture in the ground, which, our host explained, was common throughout this region; when the fields are tilled or planted, the stones are simply raked away from small sections at a time and then quickly put back. We decided to tell the next group of New England farmers we met that there are people who intentionally cover their fields with stones.
The snow of course had obliterated these mere variations in color, though it had not disguised the fact that by far the greater part of this fertile flat-land was wasted in graves. Under the thin white layer thousands upon thousands of the little cones of earth that serve as tombstones to the garden variety of Chinese looked like peas, or, let us say, mustard-seeds under a sheet, while the p’ai-lous and stone monuments scattered among these would of themselves have filled a very large graveyard. The huge barracks which had oozed and absorbed soldiers incessantly when we passed it lay half-way or more toward the eastern end of the plain, where we had descended upon it out of the last loess cañon. In the other direction, the eye, sweeping hastily across Lanchow itself, hurdling several clusters of temples and many nondescript heaps of mud buildings, fell at length upon the four big round forts erected on the crests of the ridge shutting in the valley on the southwest, against the next Mohammedan rebellion. During the several uprisings of the Moslem Chinese Lanchow itself has never been taken, but it was at least once so long and closely besieged that cannibalism is said to have flourished within its walls. After the last revolt the defenders saw the wisdom of fortifying this high ridge, from which the city had been so easily bombarded, and which is the last barrier between it and Hochow, the “Mohammedan capital,” only two hundred li away.
The snow had obviously covered up these minor color differences, but it didn’t hide the fact that a large portion of this fertile flatland was taken up by graves. Beneath the thin white layer, thousands of little mounds of earth that serve as tombstones for the typical Chinese looked like peas, or let’s say, mustard seeds under a sheet, while the p’ai-lous and stone monuments scattered throughout would have filled a very large graveyard on their own. The massive barracks that continually absorbed soldiers when we passed it lay more than halfway toward the eastern end of the plain, where we had come down from the last loess canyon. In the other direction, the eye, quickly scanning Lanchow itself, jumping over several clusters of temples and many unremarkable heaps of mud buildings, eventually landed on the four large round forts built on the ridges that enclose the valley to the southwest, ready for the next Mohammedan rebellion. During the various uprisings of the Muslim Chinese, Lanchow itself has never fallen, but at least once it was besieged for such a long time that reports of cannibalism within its walls are said to have emerged. After the last revolt, the defenders recognized the need to fortify this high ridge, from which the city had been so easily bombarded, and which serves as the last barrier between it and Hochow, the “Mohammedan capital,” just two hundred li away.

An ahong, or Chinese Mohammedan mullah of Lanchow
An ahong, or Chinese Muslim cleric from Lanchow

Mohammedan school-girls, whose garments were a riot of color
Mohammedan schoolgirls, whose outfits were a burst of color

A glimpse of Lanchow, capital of China’s westernmost province, from across the Yellow River
A view of Lanchow, the capital of China’s westernmost province, from across the Yellow River.

Looking down the valley of Lanchow, across several groups of temples at the base of the hills, to the four forts built against another Mohammedan rebellion
Looking down the Lanchow valley, past several groups of temples at the foot of the hills, toward the four forts constructed to counter another Muslim uprising.
449From the height of the despised pagoda the several walls of Lanchow, enclosing even its extensive suburbs, look like the graphic design on some large scale of relief-map of an over-ambitious draftsman; for not even those of Peking have as many sections and certainly no such angular afterthoughts. But the city lies well out on the further edge of the valley, as close as possible to the Yellow River, and to get anything more than a general view of it one must come down again from the pagoda. The south gate, nearest this, is the one by which all luck comes into the city, so that no coffin or corpse is ever allowed to pass through it. High up over the portal itself, in the most conspicuous place, is one of those huge wooden placards with a few large characters, bringing to any one who can read them the astonishing information, “Ten thousand li of Golden Soup.” This has no reference, as the first dozen incredibly naked and gaunt yellow beggars to accost the stranger will show, to any unusual abundance of nourishment; it is merely a poetic reference to the river close under the north wall, which one with a poet’s license might find golden, and which easily covers the distance mentioned in its vagrancy from the highlands of Tibet to the gulf of Chihli. Nor is it any great stretch of the imagination to call it soup, here in Lanchow, where every one, rich or poor, native or foreign, drinks it every day of his life.
449From the height of the ignored pagoda, the various walls of Lanchow, which even enclose its large suburbs, look like the detailed design of an overly ambitious relief map; not even those of Beijing have as many sections and certainly no such awkward shapes. But the city is positioned right on the far edge of the valley, as close as possible to the Yellow River, and to get more than just a general view of it, one has to come back down from the pagoda. The south gate, the closest one, is where all the good luck enters the city, so no coffin or corpse is allowed to pass through it. High above the entrance itself, in the most visible spot, is one of those large wooden signs with a few big characters, informing anyone who can read them of the surprising message, “Ten thousand li of Golden Soup.” This has no relation, as the first dozen incredibly thin and frail yellow beggars who approach the newcomer will demonstrate, to any actual abundance of food; it’s just a poetic reference to the river right under the north wall, which with a poet’s flair might be considered golden, and which easily spans the distance mentioned in its wandering from the highlands of Tibet to the Gulf of Chihli. It’s also not a big leap to call it soup here in Lanchow, where everyone, rich or poor, local or foreign, drinks it every day of their lives.
Within the gate one plunges into the chaos of any large Chinese city. Outside the brilliant sunshine floods everything; within is mud and ice and gloom, and only rarely, in the narrow streets, the briefest glimpse of the low winter sun. The Yellow River is incessantly being carried to its consumers in two-bucket lots over the shoulders of tireless coolies, and these perpetually slop street, alley, and noisome lanes with delightful impartiality. The chief north gate of Lanchow, paved at a slight slope with big slabs of stone rounded off by the centuries, is impassable for animals and carts, and almost for pedestrians, during midwinter; for the water-carriers find it their easiest entrance and keep the pavement constantly sheeted with new ice. With Peking in mind the almost total absence of rickshaws would be astounding, had they not already been half forgotten in the long journey across the province in which they are virtually unknown. Bright red “Peking carts” hooded with the omnipresent blue denim and drawn by big sleek mules jolt the well-to-do about town. Officials still use the gaily colored sedan-chairs of viceregal days; some inhabitants bestride native ponies or occasionally a donkey; but the great rank and file, of course, ride shanks’ mare. The streets offer myriad Chinese sights, sounds, and smells, yet little that may not be seen, heard, and smelled in other Chinese cities, so alike have the centuries left this wide-spread race, so different is the land of Confucius from its neighbor, India, where districts a hundred miles apart are often quite diverse. The Chinese themselves assert that “every ten li has new customs,” but they refer to minor 450inconspicuous things which easily escape the attention of the most leisurely traveler.
Within the gate, one dives into the chaos of any large Chinese city. Outside, the bright sunshine floods everything; inside, there’s mud, ice, and gloom, with only occasional glimpses of the weak winter sun in the narrow streets. The Yellow River is constantly being carried to its users in two-bucket loads on the backs of tireless coolies, who indiscriminately splash the streets, alleys, and filthy lanes. The main north gate of Lanchow, sloped slightly and paved with large stone slabs smoothed by centuries, is nearly impassable for animals and carts, and almost for pedestrians, during midwinter; the water-carriers find it the easiest entry point and keep the pavement constantly covered with new ice. Considering Peking, the almost complete lack of rickshaws is surprising, hadn't they already been largely forgotten on the long journey across the province where they are practically unknown. Bright red “Peking carts,” covered with the ever-present blue denim and pulled by large, sleek mules, jolt well-off residents around town. Officials still use the brightly colored sedan chairs from the days of high-ranking officials; some locals ride native ponies or occasionally a donkey; but the vast majority, of course, walk. The streets are filled with countless Chinese sights, sounds, and smells, yet little that couldn’t be seen, heard, and smelled in other Chinese cities; the centuries have rendered this widespread culture quite similar, in contrast to India, where regions just a hundred miles apart can be quite different. The Chinese themselves say that “every ten li has new customs,” but they’re talking about small, subtle things that easily escape the attention of even the most leisurely traveler. 450
Lanchow already boasted the rudiments of electric light and telephone systems which may in time improve beyond the exclusive, embryonic stage. Far more prominent were walking corpses who crawled into garbage-barrels by night and begged by day—before the winter was over Lanchow was throwing these into open trenches in the outskirts as they starved to death—precious padlocked boys, and the dull thump-thump of feng-hsiang, “wind-boxes” serving as bellows for cooks and craftsmen along every important street. The better-class women wore their feet only half bound, which was at least the beginning of an improvement. Manchu girls, we were informed, could be bought for eight ounces of silver each, which would be less than six American dollars; but there were no outward signs whatever of the profligacy which this appalling depreciation in human flesh must surely have abetted, for superficial decorum in some matters is the most outstanding of Chinese traits.
Lanchow already had the basics of electric lighting and telephone systems, which might eventually develop beyond their early stages. More noticeable were the walking dead who crawled into garbage bins at night and begged during the day—by the end of winter, Lanchow was throwing these people into open trenches on the outskirts as they starved to death—valuable locked-up boys, and the dull thump-thump of feng-hsiang, “wind-boxes” used as bellows for cooks and craftsmen along every major street. The upper-class women had their feet only partially bound, which was at least a step toward improvement. We were told that Manchu girls could be purchased for eight ounces of silver each, which is less than six American dollars; but there were no visible signs of the depravity that this shocking drop in the value of human life must have encouraged, as maintaining superficial decorum in certain matters is one of the most prominent traits of Chinese culture.
Many shops had closed, residents told us, because of the dreadful condition of the local currency. To our Western eyes there seemed plenty of them left, and the rattling of the “coppers” which had been forced upon the district made the narrow soggy streets sound like endless chain-lockers overwhelmed by an unprecedented run of business. The former Tuchun had printed paper notes and compelled the people to accept them at par, but the moment he left these had dropped to eight cents on the dollar and were gone now to the limbo of such things. The silver dollar was so rare as almost to be out of circulation, and besides the miserable molded brass and sand impositions of the present lord of the province—or of as much of it as he could reach with his own soldiers—there was nothing whatever but the tael, so that every one handling money must have scales in which to weigh out the irregular chunks of silver, throwing in bits of it resembling buck-shot to make the balance exact. Even then, of course, there were innumerable opportunities for disputes, for it would not be Chinese to have one system of weights, or scales which agreed, or which there was no easy way of manipulating according to whether the owner was buying or selling; and silver of course varies greatly in purity. Thus the people of Lanchow were able to indulge to their hearts’ content in the beloved Chinese pastime of squabbling over money matters, but it was a mystery how merchants could carry on at all.
Many shops had closed, residents told us, due to the terrible state of the local currency. To our Western eyes, it seemed like plenty were still open, and the clinking of the coins that had been forced into circulation gave the narrow, soggy streets the sound of endless chain-lockers overwhelmed by a sudden business influx. The former Tuchun had printed paper money and forced people to accept it at face value, but once he left, it dropped to eight cents on the dollar and soon vanished into oblivion. The silver dollar became so rare that it was nearly out of circulation. Besides the awful molded brass and sand coins from the current lord of the province—or at least from the parts of it he could control with his soldiers—there was nothing left but the tael. This meant that anyone handling money had to have scales to weigh the irregular pieces of silver, often adding bits resembling buckshot to make the balance accurate. Even then, there were countless chances for disputes, as it wouldn't be Chinese to have one consistent system of weights or scales that aligned, or to have a straightforward method that could not be manipulated depending on whether the owner was buying or selling; and silver, of course, varies widely in purity. Thus, the people of Lanchow could engage to their heart's content in their favorite pastime of arguing over money matters, but it was a mystery how merchants managed to operate at all.
Truly the money problem is fantastic in this western country. Our 451host had to send two hundred taels (about $143 in U. S. currency) to pay a week’s wages to the workmen who were building, with the remnant of American earthquake-relief funds, the bridge forty li to the eastward, and as the money had to be in “Lanchow coppers” it required eight pack-mules to get it there. When the great ditch for draining the largest lake we had seen in the earthquake district was being dug, seven tons of “cash” were required on every pay-day for the three thousand workmen.
The money situation in this western country is truly unbelievable. Our 451host had to send two hundred taels (around $143 in U.S. currency) to cover a week's wages for the workers who were building, with what's left of the American earthquake-relief funds, the bridge forty li to the east. Since the money had to be in “Lanchow coppers,” it took eight pack-mules to transport it there. When they were digging the big ditch to drain the largest lake we had seen in the earthquake area, they needed seven tons of “cash” every pay-day for the three thousand workers.
However, what did all this matter to a mere visitor who could spend his time idly strolling the town? As in Sian-fu, access to its great wall was forbidden; but unlike my experience there, where a lieutenant-colonel and a large military escort was furnished me with the Tuchun’s permission to make the circuit of it, which “face” therefore obliged me to do on horseback, Lanchow’s entire “foreign office,” in the person of a gentleman of delightfully uncertain English, made the stroll with me on a brilliant Sunday morning. Half a dozen temples rose in artistic little open-work structures above the general level, two or three of them the minarets of mosques from which at certain hours sounded the voice of the muezzin, hardly to be distinguished from those of street-hawkers. Dyers had enlivened the scene with great strips of drying cloth, overwhelmingly coolie blue in color; on some of the roofs sat huge jars filled with some local delicacy made of pickled vegetables. We were high enough to look across the crest of the ridge on which stand the round forts against revolting Moslems, and to see these apparently unoccupied, though surrounded by a wilderness of cone-topped graves as far as the eye could be certain of what it saw. At regular intervals we passed the little stone and mud houses to be found on any important Chinese city wall, each with two or three soldiers napping or amusing themselves within. Whistling pigeons, familiar even to the residents of Peking, filled the transparent air with a wailing sound, ebbing or increasing as the flocks behind the whistlers circled back and forth over the city, now flashing white and almost invisible, now suddenly changing again to the blue of shimmering silk as the whole swirl of birds turned their backs upon us. The whistle is a feather-weight one of cylindrical shape, and is fastened to the pigeon in such a way that the wind, rushing through it as he flies, makes him and his few whistle-bearing companions a perpetual orchestra. The Chinese purpose in all this seems to be partly musical and partly to gather other pigeons, which flock about the whistlers like children about 452the Pied Piper. Perhaps the birds are eventually used as food, but this seems rather to be an example of that Chinese love for feathered pets which so often sends staid old gentlemen out for a stroll, cage in hand, in order to give birdie an airing.
However, what did all this matter to a simple visitor who could spend his time casually wandering the town? Like in Sian-fu, access to its great wall was off-limits; but unlike my experience there, where a lieutenant-colonel and a large military escort were provided to me with the Tuchun’s permission to circle it, which meant I had to do so on horseback, Lanchow’s entire “foreign office,” represented by a gentleman with delightfully uncertain English, joined me for the stroll on a bright Sunday morning. Half a dozen temples rose in artistic, delicate structures above the general level, two or three of them being the minarets of mosques from which, at certain hours, the call of the muezzin rang out, hardly distinguishable from the voices of street vendors. Dyers had brightened the scene with large strips of drying cloth, predominantly coolie blue in color; on some of the roofs sat huge jars filled with some local delicacy made of pickled vegetables. We were high enough to see over the ridge where the round forts stood against rebellious Muslims and could see them looking seemingly unoccupied, though surrounded by a vast expanse of cone-shaped graves as far as the eye could see. At regular intervals, we passed the little stone and mud houses found on any significant Chinese city wall, each with two or three soldiers sleeping or entertaining themselves inside. Whistling pigeons, familiar even to the residents of Peking, filled the clear air with a wailing sound that ebbed and flowed as the flocks behind the whistlers circled back and forth over the city, occasionally flashing white and almost vanishing, then suddenly changing again to the blue of shimmering silk as the whole swirl of birds turned their backs on us. The whistle is a lightweight, cylindrical object attached to the pigeon in such a way that the wind rushing through it as it flies turns it and its few whistle-bearing companions into a perpetual orchestra. The Chinese purpose in all this seems to be partly musical and partly to attract other pigeons, which flock around the whistlers like children around the Pied Piper. Perhaps the birds are eventually used as food, but this seems to be more of an example of the Chinese love for feathered pets, which often sends respectable old gentlemen out for a stroll, cage in hand, to give their birds some fresh air.
A score or more of big gates tower above the general level of the several-walled city. In the northern and more Mohammedan section we looked down upon a great sheet of blood-pink ice, covering a pond where the Moslems are for ever washing newly slaughtered sheep. The circuit brought us at length to the northern wall, which falls sheer into the Yellow River. The American bridge thrown across this a decade ago, the only one in the west, or, I believe, with the exception of the two on the railways south from Peking, throughout the whole rambling course of “China’s Sorrow,” still looks incongruous against the background of the old walled city or of the heaped-up suburb terminating in a golden-brown pagoda on the further bank. Now and then a train of camels or a herd of wild half-yak come streaming across it, increasing the incongruity. Huddled together in that little perpendicular outskirt at the northern end of the bridge are several mosques and a Moslem school, temples dedicated to Confucius, Lao-tze, and Buddha, nearly a dozen of them piled up the hill at regular intervals as stations on the pilgrimage to the pagoda; and not far beyond these is a memorial hospital bearing the family name of the best known brand of American condensed milk! Not that this is all, of course, for there are also gambling-dens and assorted shops, inn-yards dusty with rolling mules, craftsmen busily engaged in the din of their trades, peddlers of everything shrieking their wares, water-carriers slopping the steep streets with ice, and higher up among the beautiful bare hills that vary with every mood of the unclouded sun one can trace the ruined walls of what was once a Tartar city, long before Lanchow itself was founded many centuries ago. To-day three thousand soldiers were escorting a bright new sedan-chair out along this further bank to meet an emissary of Wu Pei-fu who had journeyed to Lanchow by the northern route, and banners of many colors waved in the breeze that brought the snorting of many bugles to our ears.
A score or more of large gates rise above the overall level of the walled city. In the northern, more Muslim area, we looked down at a vast sheet of blood-pink ice covering a pond where Muslims are constantly washing freshly slaughtered sheep. The route eventually led us to the northern wall, which drops directly into the Yellow River. The American bridge built across it a decade ago, the only one in the west, or so I believe—except for the two on the railways south of Beijing—throughout the long winding path of "China’s Sorrow," still seems out of place against the backdrop of the old walled city or the crowded suburb that ends at a golden-brown pagoda on the opposite bank. Occasionally, a line of camels or a herd of wild half-yaks crosses it, adding to the incongruity. Clustered together at the edge of the bridge are several mosques and a Muslim school, as well as temples dedicated to Confucius, Lao-tze, and Buddha, nearly a dozen of them situated up the hill at regular intervals as stops on the pilgrimage to the pagoda; not far beyond these is a memorial hospital named after the best-known brand of American condensed milk! But that’s not all, of course, because there are also gambling dens and various shops, inn-yards dusty with rolling mules, artisans hard at work amidst the noise of their trades, vendors shouting their goods, water-carriers splashing the steep streets with ice, and higher up among the lovely bare hills that change with every mood of the clear sun, one can trace the remains of what was once a Tartar city, long before Lanchow itself was established many centuries ago. Today, three thousand soldiers were escorting a bright new sedan chair along this opposite bank to greet an emissary of Wu Pei-fu who had traveled to Lanchow via the northern route, while banners of many colors fluttered in the breeze that carried the sound of many bugles to our ears.
Rafts made of blown-up goatskins and a wooden framework come floating down the Yellow River to Lanchow, bringing wheat from the borders of Tibet and travelers from Sining; often a whole stack of hay or straw, which seems to be sitting serenely on the surface of the water itself, glides past. Vegetable oils from hundreds of miles up the stream are landed at the low spot near Lanchow’s picturesque camel-back bridge 453in big bullock- or half-yak hides, still covered with their long hair, which on land quiver at a touch, like living animals. Down in the perpetual shadow of the north wall one of the goatskin rafts on which Kansu does much of its down-stream traveling in warmer seasons was being tied together for a belated trip, and a cluster or two of logs from the Tibetan slopes was being readjusted before continuing its long cold journey, which would not end until the winter was over, to the coffin-shops of eastern China. A great wooden water-wheel at the edge of the river added another medieval touch to the scene; and at length our stroll was brought to a temporary halt at the locked and soldier-guarded gate beyond which the city wall belongs to the Tuchun’s private grounds. I had already seen these, with their rows of barracks, their gardens and artificial-stone grottos, the two pet Kansu wapiti that bugled so fiercely when a foreigner paused to look at them, and the score of buildings that eventually gave way to the main entrance, with its huge devil-screen and gaudy painted demons, opening on the swarming second-hand market.
Rafts made of inflated goatskins and a wooden frame float down the Yellow River to Lanchow, bringing wheat from the Tibetan borders and travelers from Sining; often, a whole stack of hay or straw glides by, seemingly resting on the water’s surface. Vegetable oils from hundreds of miles upstream are unloaded at the low spot near Lanchow’s picturesque camelback bridge 453 in large bullock or half-yak hides, still covered with their long hair, which quivers at a touch like living animals. Down in the constant shadow of the north wall, one of the goatskin rafts used for much of Kansu's downstream travel in warmer seasons was being assembled for a delayed trip, and a couple of logs from the Tibetan slopes were being adjusted before continuing their long, cold journey, which wouldn’t end until winter was over, to the coffin shops of eastern China. A large wooden water wheel at the river’s edge added another medieval element to the scene; eventually, our stroll was temporarily stopped at the locked and soldier-guarded gate, beyond which the city wall belongs to the Tuchun’s private grounds. I had already seen these grounds, with their rows of barracks, gardens, and artificial stone grottos, the two pet Kansu wapiti that bugled fiercely when a foreigner stopped to look at them, and the numerous buildings that led to the main entrance, featuring its massive devil screen and brightly painted demons, opening up to the bustling second-hand market.
In the long open space before the Tuchun’s “yamen”—as they still call it in Lanchow, for all China’s conversion to republicanism—there stand to this day the four high poles, daubed with red and each bearing a kind of seaman’s “crow’s-nest,” which were the symbols of the Manchu viceroy who ruled northwestern China in the old imperial days. From these the military governor still flies four great banners, and it would not be difficult to forget that any change of régime has come over this distant province. The rectangle of public domain between the entrance to the yamen and its farthest devil-screen outpost is the busiest market-place of Lanchow, and swarms from dawn to sunset with as dense a throng of ragamuffins as can be found in one collection anywhere in northern China. For it is made up of the buyers and sellers of all manner of second-hand junk, stuff which in America would be entirely thrown away, of the owners and the clients of outdoor portable restaurants in which the whole menu does not cost more than two or three real cents, of all the odds and ends of Chinese society, among whom Lanchow’s incredibly starved and ragged beggars and her rafts of thieves probably predominate.
In the large open space in front of the Tuchun’s “yamen”—as it’s still called in Lanchow, despite all of China becoming a republic—there stand to this day the four tall poles, painted red and each topped with a type of seaman’s “crow’s-nest,” which were symbols of the Manchu viceroy who ruled northwestern China during the old imperial days. From these, the military governor still flies four large banners, and it’s easy to forget that any change in government has occurred in this distant province. The rectangle of public land between the entrance to the yamen and its farthest devil-screen outpost is the busiest marketplace in Lanchow, bustling from dawn to sunset with as large a crowd of ragged individuals as can be found anywhere in northern China. It consists of buyers and sellers of all kinds of second-hand junk, things that in America would be thrown away, the owners and customers of outdoor portable restaurants where the whole menu costs no more than two or three real cents, and all the various fragments of Chinese society, among whom Lanchow’s incredibly starved and ragged beggars and the numerous thieves probably stand out the most.
Both these latter callings are banded together into gilds, as in most of China. Our host had known well the former head of the thieves’ gild, not because he made a practice of keeping such company, or had any hope of bringing him into the Christian fold, but because all owners 454of important property found it essential to their peace and prosperity to come to some understanding with him. Though he was strictly Chinese, this clever old rascal had been the accepted ruler even of the Mohammedan “three-hand men,” who flourish in great numbers, and who now obeyed the not yet widely advertised chieftain who had recently inherited his power and unfailing emoluments. Among the Moslem Chinese in particular there is as much pride in belonging to this adventurous calling as to any which the country has to offer, though in the nature of the case this pride may not be as freely shouted from the housetops. Mohammedan children are given long and careful training for it, and the fathers in whose footsteps they usually follow show a justifiable delight in any extraordinary professional feat accomplished by their offspring. It is not difficult to understand, therefore, why persons of property find it better to make an agreement with the thieves through their chief than to depend for protection upon officials and police not very distantly related to them. I need scarcely go into details as to how the members of this romantic gild are not only induced to let certain properties alone but to protect them against any outsider, any “scab” thief who does not belong to the union. A single example will be quite sufficient. The innkeeper who held the contract for carrying the government mails in and out of Lanchow paid fifteen dollars a month to the head of the thieves’ gild—through the police at their main station!—and these mails were never molested even in the most desolate parts of the country.
Both of these more recent professions are organized into guilds, as is common throughout much of China. Our host had a good relationship with the previous leader of the thieves' guild, not because he associated with criminals or hoped to convert him to Christianity, but because every property owner found it necessary for their safety and success to reach some kind of understanding with him. Although he was strictly Chinese, this clever old trickster was even recognized as a leader by the Muslim "three-hand men," who are numerous and who now follow the recently appointed chief who inherited his position and steady income. Among the Muslim Chinese, there is considerable pride in being part of this daring profession, as with any other vocation in the country, though this pride isn't openly expressed. Muslim children are given extensive training for it, and fathers, whose paths their children often follow, take pride in any exceptional skills their children demonstrate. So, it's easy to see why people with property prefer to negotiate with the thieves through their leader rather than rely on officials and police who are not far removed from their interests. I hardly need to explain how the members of this adventurous guild are encouraged to leave certain properties undisturbed and to protect them from outsiders, or "scab" thieves, who aren't part of the guild. One example will suffice. The innkeeper who had the contract for delivering government mail in and out of Lanchow paid fifteen dollars a month to the head of the thieves' guild—through the police at their main station!—and these mails were never disrupted, even in the most remote areas of the country.
One little tale, too, will suffice to show how expert thieves belonging to the union must become before they can look for praise within their own ranks. If at any instant during the telling the suspicion of exaggeration should raise its head, let it be borne in mind that the host from whom I have it is both a Britisher and a missionary of the highest standing, and the son of a highly respected gentleman to whom the same statements may be equally applied.
One little story will be enough to show how skilled thieves in the union must be before they can seek recognition among their peers. If at any point during this story you start to feel like it might be exaggerated, remember that the source of this tale is both British and a highly regarded missionary, as well as the son of a well-respected gentleman to whom the same claims can also apply.
A thief who was approaching old age decided to mend his ways before the time came to meet Allah face to face. He opened a mutton-shop on one of the less frequented streets. Next door to him was the large compound of a very wealthy Chinese merchant. One day, as he was separating the carcass of a fat-tailed sheep into its component parts, the ex-thief noticed several young Mohammedans grouped closely together across the way and furtively eying the rich man’s gateway. He recognized these fellows at once as belonging to the organization from 455which he had recently resigned, and their movements were a plain indication to a man of his experience that they were planning to rob his wealthy neighbor that very night. When he closed shop, therefore, he asked permission of the gate-keeper to speak with the prospective victim, whom he told all he knew, even of his own experience in his former profession.
A thief nearing old age decided to change his ways before he had to face Allah. He opened a mutton shop on a quieter street. Next door was the large compound of a wealthy Chinese merchant. One day, while he was cutting up a fat-tailed sheep, the ex-thief noticed several young Muslims gathered across the street, eyeing the rich man’s gate. He immediately recognized them as members of the group he had recently left, and their suspicious behavior told him, based on his experience, that they were planning to rob his wealthy neighbor that very night. So when he closed up his shop, he asked the gatekeeper for permission to talk to the potential victim, sharing everything he knew, including details about his past as a thief.
“But what shall I do?” demanded the man of wealth, as one suddenly stricken might ask for expert advice from a gray-haired lawyer or a septuagenarian physician.
“But what should I do?” asked the wealthy man, as someone who is suddenly overwhelmed might seek expert advice from an experienced lawyer or an elderly doctor.
“That is easy,” replied the ex-thief. “The simplest way of breaking into your compound is for a small and supple man to crawl under your gate, where you have not recently taken the trouble to do any repairing. Hide yourself in the darkness beside this, and when the man’s head appears inside put a brick under his chin and go away.”
“That’s easy,” replied the ex-thief. “The easiest way to break into your compound is for a small and agile person to crawl under your gate, where you haven’t bothered to do any repairs recently. Hide in the darkness next to it, and when the person’s head comes into view, place a brick under their chin and leave.”
The merchant conducted himself exactly as his expert neighbor had advised. When the thieves outside found it impossible to rescue their bricked comrade, and dared wait no longer, they severed his body at the neck and carried it away. In the morning the rich man came to the mutton-shop early and in great agitation.
The merchant acted exactly as his knowledgeable neighbor had recommended. When the thieves outside realized they couldn’t rescue their trapped friend and could not wait any longer, they cut his body at the neck and took it away. In the morning, the wealthy man arrived at the mutton shop early and in a lot of distress.
“See what a pretty plight you have got me into!” he cried. “When I came out to the gate before daylight to see if there was anything the gateman should not see, what did I find but the head of a man, and the blood that had flowed from him when he lost it! Now the police——”
“Look at the mess you’ve gotten me into!” he shouted. “When I came out to the gate before dawn to check if there was anything the gateman shouldn’t see, what did I find but a man’s head, along with the blood that flowed from him when he lost it! Now the police——”
“Do not distress yourself, sir,” replied the mutton-seller. “I will take care of the head, and when your k’an-men-ti speaks to me about the blood, as he is sure to do, I will tell him a newly killed sheep was left there by mistake. As to the gang starting any inquiries about their lost companion, that is the last thing they would dare or wish to do.”
“Don’t worry about it, sir,” replied the mutton-seller. “I’ll handle the head, and when your k’an-men-ti asks me about the blood, which he definitely will, I’ll say a freshly killed sheep was accidentally left there. As for the gang starting any inquiries about their missing friend, that’s the last thing they would want to do.”
All went as the ex-thief had outlined it, but that afternoon, as he was drumming on his chopping-block with a cleaver in the hope of attracting customers for the last morsels of mutton, whom should he see across the way but the same band of ruffians, minus, of course, one of those who had gathered the day before. Their heads were together again, but this time their furtive glances seemed to be turned not so much toward the rich man’s gate as upon the mutton-seller.
All went as the ex-thief had planned, but that afternoon, while he was banging on his chopping block with a cleaver to attract customers for the last bits of mutton, he spotted the same group of thugs across the street, minus one of the guys from the day before. They were huddled together again, but this time their sneaky looks seemed to be directed more at the mutton seller than at the rich man’s gate.
“Aha!” thought the latter, for he was inordinately clever in reading the gestures and glances of his former brethren-in-arms, “they suspect me of thwarting their plans and have decided to kill me.”
“Aha!” thought the latter, for he was exceptionally skilled at reading the gestures and glances of his former comrades, “they think I'm sabotaging their plans and have decided to kill me.”
Therefore that night, when it was time for him to stretch out on his 456k’ang, he placed upon it, instead, a sheepskin that he had blown full of air and covered it over with some old clothes. Then he hid himself in the darkness outside.
Therefore that night, when it was time for him to lie down on his 456k’ang, he laid down a sheepskin that he had inflated and covered it with some old clothes. Then he concealed himself in the darkness outside.
It was exactly as he had suspected. Hardly had he begun to long for a cigarette when several forms slunk past him and entered his hovel. There came the dull sounds of as many blows as each thrust his knife into the sheepskin, followed by an escape of air resembling the pouring forth of blood; then the assassins disappeared again into the night.
It was exactly as he had suspected. No sooner had he started craving a cigarette than several figures slipped past him and entered his place. He heard the dull sounds of blows as each drove his knife into the sheepskin, followed by a rush of air that sounded like blood pouring out; then the attackers vanished back into the night.
Next day, after the briskness of trade had been succeeded by the apathy of the first Chinese meal-hour—for no profession which works by night can be expected to get up early—the former thief saw the same group huddled together across the way, staring at him as at a ghost. At length they straggled over to him, with a contrite and respectful, not to say admiring, air, and a spokesman addressed him with the highest honorifics of which such unschooled fellows are capable.
Next day, after the busyness of trade had been replaced by the lethargy of the first Chinese meal hour—since no job that works at night can be expected to start early—the former thief noticed the same group gathered across the street, staring at him like he was a ghost. Eventually, they shuffled over to him, looking remorseful and respectful, not to mention a bit in awe, and one of them spoke to him using the most formal language they could muster.
“Oh, Great Teacher,” he said, “we recognize in you, our revered Elder Brother, a very clever man, a man much more clever than ourselves. Will you not, therefore, become our leader, for with your cleverness and our agility how could we fail in any undertaking?”
“Oh, Great Teacher,” he said, “we see in you, our respected Elder Brother, a very smart man, someone much more intelligent than us. Will you not become our leader? With your intelligence and our agility, how could we possibly fail in any task?”
“Your agility!” sneered the mutton-seller, meanwhile insultingly continuing his work. “Where have you picked up that false impression? I don’t believe you know the first rudiments of your profession, that you can even climb through the open window of a foreign devil and escape with his watch and wallet without being heard. I, forsooth, become the leader of a gang of clumsy, untrained louts who cannot so much as move a brick with their Adam’s apple! Away with you!”
“Your agility!” scoffed the mutton seller, continuing his work disrespectfully. “Where did you get that ridiculous idea? I don’t believe you know the basics of your profession or that you could even sneak through the open window of some foreign guy and get away with his watch and wallet without making a sound. Me, of all people, to lead a bunch of clumsy, untrained idiots who can’t even move a brick without stumbling! Get lost!”
Lanchow has been called the meeting-place of central Asia. This seemed to us something of an exaggeration, for to be worthy of such a title surely a city must have something more to show than sporadic examples of Oriental tribes and customs all but lost in a great sea of Chinese. But, for one thing, they told us, this was not the season of great markets, to which even princes of Tibet were attracted, and which brought samples of almost everything in the human line that the elder brother among continents has to offer. As it was, I ran across Tibetans, Mongols, Buriats, Kirghiz, and several other individuals who plainly belonged to none of these divisions, merely in strolling the streets. Then there were of course Russian refugees, and Cossacks, and single chance visitors from far-off countries not often represented, such as we 457Americans, for instance. Two or three Russian officers of the old régime were in the employ of the Tuchun, who had fished them from the stream that had been spasmodically flowing down through Kansu for the past four years, and who strutted the soft streets of Lanchow in all the glory of their pre-war uniforms and their disdainful, rather childlike demeanor. Our host and his fellow-missionaries, the active little Belgian who had grown more than gray in superintending the salt monopoly in two provinces, the densely bearded Catholic priest of similar origin, the over-conscientious, English-speaking postal commissioner from Canton, the Tuchun himself, and all the higher officials were constantly being appealed to in behalf of poverty-stricken aristocrats or of pitiful cases of suffering among mere ordinary human beings who had drifted down from the northwest and hoped to better their lot by pushing on to Peking or Shanghai. Just what impression such cases made on the Tuchun, who probably distinguished almost as little between different kinds of Caucasians as do the rank and file of Chinese, the handful of foreign residents were never quite sure; but they did know that he often gave money to Russian refugees—though their real benefactor was the Belgian salt official—and that the provincial Government furnished transportation to the next province for those incapable of making their own way. In fact, almost the only important duty of the “foreign office,” who had discoursed to me more or less in my own tongue on the unworthiness of Lanchow from its wall, was to adjust matters between muleteers and cartmen who did not feel that the Government should force them to carry penniless foreign devils—though of course they did not openly speak of them as such—for the mere pittance it offered.
Lanchow has been called the meeting place of Central Asia. We thought this was a bit of an exaggeration because a city worthy of such a title should offer more than just scattered examples of Eastern tribes and customs almost lost in a vast sea of Chinese culture. However, we were told that this wasn’t the season for big markets, which even Tibetan princes were drawn to, where you could find samples of almost everything that the dominant continent had to offer. As it was, I came across Tibetans, Mongols, Buriats, Kirghiz, and several other individuals who obviously didn’t belong to these groups just by wandering the streets. Then there were Russian refugees, Cossacks, and random visitors from distant countries, like us Americans. A few Russian officers from the old regime were working for the Tuchun, who had recruited them from the ongoing turmoil in Kansu over the past four years, and they strutted through the soft streets of Lanchow in the glory of their pre-war uniforms, displaying a somewhat childlike arrogance. Our host and his fellow missionaries—the active little Belgian who had aged while overseeing the salt monopoly in two provinces, the heavily bearded Catholic priest of a similar background, the overly diligent English-speaking postal commissioner from Canton, the Tuchun himself, and all the higher officials—were constantly approached on behalf of impoverished aristocrats or heart-wrenching cases among ordinary people who had come down from the northwest hoping to improve their lives by getting to Peking or Shanghai. It was unclear what impression these cases made on the Tuchun, who likely couldn’t tell the difference between various kinds of Caucasians like most rank-and-file Chinese, but the handful of foreign residents knew he often gave money to Russian refugees—though their true benefactor was the Belgian salt official—and the provincial government provided transportation to the next province for those who couldn’t make their own way. In fact, the only significant role of the “foreign office,” which had discussed with me more or less in my own language about Lanchow’s unworthiness from its walls, was to mediate between muleteers and cart drivers who felt the government shouldn’t force them to carry broke foreign devils—though they didn’t openly refer to them that way—for the meager payment it offered.
One morning while we were still at breakfast, a little hollow-eyed foreigner in a strange uniform was brought in by the gate-keeper. He was a Polish captain who had once before escaped capture in some brush with the Soviet troops by making his way overland through Asia and back to Poland, only to be forced to repeat the experience. At least, that was what we gathered from a long conversation, in which we could not muster among us more than scattered single words that were mutually understood, and during which both sides were forced to resort mainly to gestures and intuitions. The captain and his wife, he said, were living in a Chinese inn, without money and with no other clothes than those they were wearing. That same day word drifted to our ears of a Russian lady who was offering for sale the carriage and horses in which she had reached Lanchow, and which might possibly do for our 458return journey. I found her a frail, visibly suffering woman probably still really in the thirties, speaking perfect French, and by no means stripped of that air of distinction which generations of well supplied leisure give. She was living in the mud room of an ordinary Chinese inn, facing upon the usual barnyard-and-worse courtyard, and evidently found it difficult even to pay for these accommodations, for the Chinese about the place had a surliness which could scarcely have been due to anything but disappointments in the matter of money. Her husband, a general once high in the czar’s armies, had, during the journey, died of typhus in the very coach that she was offering for sale. There was still with her an adult son in a shock of pale yellow hair, whose manner suggested more haughtiness than ordinary horse sense; and half a dozen Cossacks—at least she called them that—were left from the retinue with which the general had begun his flight. It was not uninteresting to see how these sturdy, peasant-faced fellows in worn and badly assorted civilian clothing snapped to attention when the general’s widow addressed them, and fell over one another in carrying out her order to show me carriage, harness, and horses. But the horses were not visibly different from the Chinese ponies for sale in the gully below the “thieves’ market”; the harness was more massive and intricately Russian than in good preservation; and the carriage would have taken first prize at any American fair as an example of the impossible contrivances which “furriners” inexplicably build for themselves. It was four-wheeled, which alone would have barred it from continuing any further eastward and aroused astonishment that it had been dragged this far; it had all those Russian conveniences which to any other race seem quite the opposite, such as a great yoke over the off horse and a roof which, if it had been repainted some brighter color, would not have looked greatly out of place on a Chinese temple; while the seats had been taken out by the roots, so that the interior of the coach was nothing but a bare wooden floor some six feet long and four wide. Two of us could stretch out on this, with our bedding under us, very comfortably, the lady said, as she and the general had done. The local Government was furnishing “Peking carts” for her party, but she was too ill to travel in those and was holding out for a mule-litter, hoping meanwhile to get together a little money for the long journey still ahead by selling her personal rolling-stock. I regretted that by no stretch of the imagination could we see ourselves making our way back to civilization spread out on the floor of what looked painfully like a hearse and which most certainly could not have been operated on the hundreds of miles of no 459roads that lay before us without a plentiful supply of Russian profanity.
One morning while we were still having breakfast, a little hollow-eyed foreigner in a strange uniform was brought in by the gatekeeper. He was a Polish captain who had previously escaped capture during a clash with Soviet troops by traveling overland through Asia back to Poland, only to be forced to go through it all again. At least, that’s what we gathered from a long conversation in which we could only muster a few scattered words we mutually understood, and during which both sides had to rely mainly on gestures and intuition. The captain said that he and his wife were living in a Chinese inn, without money and with no other clothes than what they were wearing. That same day, we heard about a Russian lady who was selling the carriage and horses she had used to reach Lanchow, which might possibly be useful for our 458return journey. I found her to be a frail, visibly suffering woman, probably still in her thirties, speaking perfect French, and still carrying that air of distinction typical of generations of well-off leisure. She was living in the mud room of a regular Chinese inn, facing the usual barnyard-and-worse courtyard, and it was clear she struggled to even pay for these accommodations; the Chinese around her had a surliness that likely stemmed from disappointments related to money. Her husband, a general once high in the czar's army, had died of typhus during the journey in the very coach she was offering for sale. With her was an adult son with a shock of pale yellow hair, whose attitude suggested more pride than common sense; and half a dozen Cossacks—at least that’s what she called them—were left from the entourage with which the general had begun his escape. It was interesting to see how these sturdy, peasant-faced guys in worn and mismatched civilian clothing snapped to attention when the general’s widow spoke to them, and how they hustled to carry out her order to show me the carriage, harness, and horses. But the horses didn’t look any different from the Chinese ponies for sale in the gully below the “thieves’ market”; the harness was more bulky and intricately Russian than in good condition; and the carriage would have taken first prize at any American fair for being an example of the bizarre structures that “foreigners” inexplicably create for themselves. It had four wheels, which alone would have prevented it from continuing any further east and made it astonishing that it had been dragged this far; it had all those Russian conveniences that seem quite the opposite to any other race, like a large yoke over the off horse and a roof that, if repainted a brighter color, wouldn’t look out of place on a Chinese temple; while the seats had been completely removed, leaving the interior of the coach a bare wooden floor about six feet long and four wide. Two of us could lie on this comfortably, with our bedding underneath, the lady said, just as she and the general had done. The local government was providing “Peking carts” for her party, but she was too ill to travel in those and was holding out for a mule-litter, hoping in the meantime to gather a little money for the long journey still ahead by selling her personal rolling stock. I regretted that there was no way we could see ourselves making our way back to civilization sprawled out on the floor of what looked painfully like a hearse and which certainly couldn’t have traveled the hundreds of miles of no 459roads that lay ahead without a generous supply of Russian profanity.
Fully a thousand such cases a year, said our host, pass through Lanchow; but, like the scattered samples of central Asia to be seen in the streets, they are as nothing in the old familiar thronging Chinese crowd, in filthy quilted garments, hands thrust in sleeves in lieu of mittens, and cold, bluish running noses. It was hard to realize the fact, when some reddish-bearded Moslem, wholly free from Chinese features yet wearing Chinese uniform, came down from those distant regions and directed attention to it, that, far west as Lanchow is, China stretches for many weeks’ travel still farther westward, in a great tongue of land which at length opens out into the broad reaches of Sinkiang, or Chinese Turkestan, even though her assertion of total suzerainty of Mongolia and Tibet be disallowed.
"Every year, about a thousand of these cases pass through Lanchow," our host said. "But just like the random samples of Central Asia you see in the streets, they barely matter among the familiar throngs of Chinese people, dressed in filthy quilted clothes, with their hands stuffed in their sleeves instead of wearing mittens, and noses running a cold, bluish hue. It was hard to grasp the reality when a reddish-bearded Muslim, who had no Chinese features but was wearing a Chinese uniform, came down from those distant areas and pointed it out. Despite how far west Lanchow is, China extends for many weeks’ travel even further westward, in a vast strip of land that eventually leads out into the wide expanses of Sinkiang, or Chinese Turkestan, even if its complete claim of control over Mongolia and Tibet is disputed."
The people of Lanchow struck me as less courteous than those of Peking, but still by no means deliberately unkind to foreigners. They seemed to be but slightly informed on anything more than their own immediate problems, at which of course there was no reason to wonder. For the whole vast province has no newspaper except one flimsy sheet of “official lies” spasmodically published in Lanchow; no students are sent abroad from this province, “because,” to quote a Chinese, “officials are more interested in filling their pockets”; and the “heathen” schools even in the provincial capital are so bad, in spite of some recent improvements, that missionaries feel they must have Christian schools for their converts, quite aside from any question of mere religious faith. There is no discipline left in Chinese schools since the revolution, they assert, and every one, from Tuchun to servants, is more avid for “squeeze” than before the republic was established. On the other hand, the overwhelming majority of the population knows nothing more of the word “republic” than its pronunciation, and “voting” is so frankly a farce that ballot-boxes are calmly filled by order of the authorities days before and brought to “polling-places” from which soldiers exclude all citizens on “election day”; or the boxes are stuffed then and there by the soldiers, under orders from headquarters. Though the respect for foreigners or the fear of them is still so great among the rank and file that the little Belgian chief of the Salt Gabelle had more than once confiscated whole camel-caravans of smuggled salt which he came upon in his travels, it was not so easy to make officials honor either foreign rights or treaties. The Belgian, for instance, had deposited in the official bank six hundred thousand dollars income from the salt monopoly, which is designated by treaty for use in paying off China’s 460foreign indebtedness—and the next thing he knew it had been replaced with promissory notes of the provincial Government; in other words, with worthless paper. Peking has no real power in these back provinces, and even if provincial officials cannot connive with bank employees to their hearts’ content, all the Tuchun, or some Mohammedan general, or any official with audacity enough, has to do is to ask Peking to instruct the “salt man” to give them money, and neither he nor Peking can refuse. In a way China is more militaristic to-day than ever Germany was, but the Chinese are not a fighting race, depending rather upon the subtleties of graft and “squeeze” than upon force. Were they not so docile and passive and so lacking in community spirit, it would not be so easy for military governors, almost always coming from other provinces than the one they rule, to get rich quickly by all manner of tricks and then go home, or, if their peculations have been too notorious, to some foreign concession in the coast cities, where even a strong Central Government could not touch them.
The people of Lanchow seemed less polite than those from Peking, but they weren’t intentionally unkind to foreigners. They appeared to know little beyond their own immediate issues, which wasn’t surprising. The entire province has no newspaper except for one flimsy sheet of “official lies” that is occasionally published in Lanchow. No students from this province study abroad because, as a Chinese person put it, “officials are more interested in lining their pockets.” The schools, even in the provincial capital, are so poor, despite some recent improvements, that missionaries feel the need to establish Christian schools for their converts, unrelated to any issues of mere religious belief. They claim there is no discipline left in Chinese schools since the revolution, and everyone, from the Tuchun to servants, is more eager for “squeeze” than before the republic was established. On the other hand, the vast majority of the population knows nothing about the term “republic” beyond how to pronounce it, and “voting” is such a mockery that ballot boxes are filled by the authorities days in advance and brought to “polling places,” where soldiers keep all citizens out on “election day,” or the boxes are stuffed right there by the soldiers under orders from headquarters. Although there is still immense respect or fear of foreigners among ordinary people—evident when a small Belgian chief of the Salt Gabelle managed to confiscate entire camel caravans of smuggled salt during his travels—it wasn’t as easy to get officials to respect either foreign rights or treaties. For example, the Belgian had deposited six hundred thousand dollars in income from the salt monopoly into the official bank, which is designated by treaty to pay off China’s 460foreign debts, and the next thing he knew it was replaced with promissory notes from the provincial Government; in other words, worthless paper. Peking has no real authority in these remote provinces, and even if provincial officials can’t conspicuously coordinate with bank employees, any Tuchun, a Mohammedan general, or any official bold enough just needs to ask Peking to tell the “salt man” to give them money, and neither he nor Peking can refuse. In some ways, China is more militaristic today than Germany ever was, but the Chinese are not a combative people, relying more on the nuances of graft and “squeeze” than on brute force. If they weren’t so compliant and passive, and if they had more community spirit, it wouldn’t be so easy for military governors, often from provinces other than the ones they oversee, to quickly amass wealth through various schemes and then return home, or if their embezzlement has become too notorious, to escape to some foreign concession in the coastal cities, where even a strong Central Government couldn’t reach them.
There are few outward signs of disagreement between the two divisions of Lanchow’s population, but old residents say that the feeling is far deeper than appears to the casual observer. The Mohammedans also have much of the Chinese temperament, or at least of the Chinese outward attitude, and are inclined to temporize longer before they will fight than do their brethren farther west. They are particularly gentle when they are in a minority, as they are in many towns even of Kansu. But they are more progressive, more interested in outside news, than the mere Chinese, and they stick together, like most minorities. I heard of only one Christian convert from among them, and even the missionaries were not at all sure of him. After a long period of repression the Chinese Mohammedans have to a large extent shaken off the Chinese yoke in Kansu and, being better fighters, there is little doubt that they will win still more from their former oppressors, who are hopelessly divided. Already not only the orthodox headquarters of Hochow but other districts are virtually self-governing, and certain Mohammedan generals rule their sections much as they see fit. The “Hwei-Hwei” have long felt that the province of Kansu is their special domain and that they should be allowed to govern it, either as a part of China with a Tuchun of their own faith, as an independent state, or by joining hands with Sinkiang, its congenial neighbor on the west. During one of their rebellions Yakub Beg ruled the Chinese Mohammedans for ten years, until he was put down by troops sent from Peking. In the 461opinion, at least, of most foreign residents, the Chinese have been stupid in their handling of the Kansu problem, so that whereas, by just and generous treatment when they were powerful, they might have had a strong Moslem province as a more or less autonomous buffer-state on the west, yet still loyal to the rest of the country, now that they are weak they may easily lose a large part of the Mohammedan region.
There aren’t many visible signs of conflict between the two groups in Lanchow’s population, but longtime residents say the tension runs much deeper than what a casual observer might notice. The Mohammedans share a lot of the Chinese temperament, or at least the outward attitude, and tend to wait longer before they decide to fight compared to their counterparts further west. They're particularly gentle when they’re a minority, which is often the case in many towns across Kansu. However, they are also more progressive and more interested in news from outside than the average Chinese person, and they tend to stick together like most minority groups. I only heard of one Christian convert among them, and even the missionaries were not completely convinced about him. After enduring a long period of oppression, Chinese Mohammedans have largely shed the Chinese control in Kansu, and since they are better fighters, it seems likely they will gain even more power from their former oppressors, who are hopelessly divided. Already, not just the orthodox headquarters in Hochow but other areas are effectively self-governing, and certain Mohammedan generals govern their regions pretty much as they see fit. The “Hwei-Hwei” have long believed that Kansu province is their special territory and that they should be allowed to rule it, whether as part of China with a governor of their own faith, as an independent state, or in partnership with Sinkiang, their friendly neighbor to the west. During one of their uprisings, Yakub Beg led the Chinese Mohammedans for ten years until he was defeated by troops sent from Peking. According to most foreign residents, the Chinese have been foolish in how they’ve dealt with the Kansu issue; when they were strong, they could have fostered a loyal and somewhat autonomous Muslim province as a buffer state to the west, but now that they are weak, they risk losing a significant portion of the Mohammedan region.
Yet though one listens one is not so easily convinced. There comes to mind the unfailing suppression of “Hwei-Hwei” rebellions in the past, lighted up by the knowledge, sure to be picked up by any inquiring traveler, that there is much internal friction, not to say combustion, among the Moslems of Kansu themselves. Were they as strictly united as they pretend to be, they could probably now throw off the Chinese yoke entirely. But there are “Turk,” Arab, and Mongol “Hwei-Hwei,” not to mention the still greater number perhaps of purely Chinese Mohammedans, many of whom were “converted” during the rebellions of the last sixty years; some still adhere strictly to the Koran, while new sects hold later traditions or have incorporated elements of Buddhism and Christianity. In fact, all the big Mohammedan rebellions have been due to Chinese interference in “Hwei-Hwei” sect quarrels; that of 1895–96 began over the dispute as to whether or not a man under forty should be allowed to grow a beard! It is the old story of the champion of a beaten wife being fallen upon by both husband and consort. The day may not be far distant, whatever the casual traveler may conclude, when the world will wake up to find on its breakfast-table the news of the founding of a new Moslem nation, in which Chinese features will be in the majority. Meanwhile the “Hwei-Hwei” keep in form by fighting each other and by drubbing the Tibetan tribes along the Kansu border, from whom much of the metal was taken that has reappeared in the miserable “money” which the people have had forced upon them.
Yet even though one listens, it's not so easy to be convinced. One can't help but think of the consistent suppression of “Hwei-Hwei” rebellions in the past, highlighted by the understanding—sure to be recognized by any curious traveler—that there is a lot of internal conflict, if not outright chaos, among the Muslims of Kansu themselves. If they were as united as they claim to be, they could likely throw off the Chinese control completely. But there are “Turk,” Arab, and Mongol “Hwei-Hwei,” not to mention perhaps an even larger number of purely Chinese Muslims, many of whom were “converted” during the rebellions of the past sixty years; some still strictly follow the Koran, while new sects have embraced later traditions or blended in elements of Buddhism and Christianity. In fact, all the major Muslim rebellions have resulted from Chinese involvement in “Hwei-Hwei” sect disputes; the rebellion of 1895–96 started over a disagreement about whether a man under forty should be allowed to grow a beard! It’s the same old story of a champion of a beaten wife being attacked by both her husband and his lover. The day may not be far off, no matter what a casual traveler might conclude, when the world wakes up to find the news of a new Muslim nation being established, where Chinese features are in the majority. In the meantime, the “Hwei-Hwei” stay active by fighting among themselves and beating up the Tibetan tribes along the Kansu border, from whom much of the metal was taken that has reappeared in the poor-quality “money” that the people have been forced to use.
Turks and Arabs can talk with many of the Chinese Moslems without difficulty; which is the chief reason that our host was asked in 1914 by his home Government to sit where he was and keep his eyes and ears open instead of hotfooting it for Flanders. Mysterious delegations of Germans and Ottomans were constantly passing through Kansu while the war was on, and there are certain indications that their aborted plans were bold and carefully laid. But all that is over now, and such interesting similarities of tongue have become again merely of philological interest.
Turks and Arabs can easily communicate with many Chinese Muslims, which is the main reason our host was asked by his government in 1914 to stay where he was and observe instead of rushing off to Flanders. Mysterious groups of Germans and Ottomans were often passing through Kansu during the war, and there are signs that their plans were ambitious and well thought out. But that’s all in the past now, and those fascinating similarities in language have turned back into just a topic of linguistic interest.
Up to the time of the republic even Mohammedans high in the 462government service could only live in the suburbs of Lanchow—whence its many walls. But to-day there is a more tolerant spirit on both sides, at least in every-day, peace-time intercourse. Some of the more reasonable and educated “Hwei-Hwei” make friendships irrespective of faith. There was “Mr. Donkey,” for instance, who was one of our host’s most frequent visitors, though he never sat down at his table. Like so many of his coreligionists, he bore the family name of “Ma,” which is derived from Mohammed, but which also is the Chinese word for “horse”; and, there being a distinct stratum of humor in our host’s make-up in spite of his calling, he had taken a slight liberty with natural history when his Moslem friend asked for the English version of his name. The joke had long since been shared with the victim, but he was still likely to startle foreigners to whom he was being introduced by displaying his entire knowledge of the English language at one fell swoop with, “Sir, I am Mr. Donkey.”
Up until the time of the republic, even high-ranking Muslims in the 462government could only live in the outskirts of Lanchow, which is why there are so many walls. But nowadays, there’s a more tolerant vibe on both sides, at least in everyday, peaceful interactions. Some of the more reasonable and educated "Hwei-Hwei" form friendships regardless of their faith. Take "Mr. Donkey," for example, who was one of our host’s most frequent visitors, even though he never sat at the table. Like many of his fellow Muslims, he had the family name "Ma," which comes from Mohammed but also means "horse" in Chinese. Our host had a sense of humor despite his profession, and when his Muslim friend asked for the English version of his name, he playfully took some liberties with natural history. The joke had been shared with the victim long ago, but he still surprised foreigners when he was introduced by proudly declaring, "Sir, I am Mr. Donkey."
“Mr. Donkey” and a certain Taoist priest were bosom friends and were given to periodic sprees, in which they were now and then joined by a “Living Buddha.” Occasionally this convivial trio had irrupted into the mission compound during the small hours, in the hope that their good friend of still another faith might for once forget his little idiosyncrasies of doctrine and join them. Once news had come to the ears of our host that a “Britisher” had been confined in the Chinese jail; and, being the chief example, if not the official representative, of the British nation in Kansu, he could not of course permit this violation of extraterritoriality to continue. He demanded the immediate release of the prisoner, which his good friend the provincial governor granted at once—and turned over to him an Afghan. What was more natural than that he should have sent this fellow-national, for whom he had made himself responsible, to stay with “Mr. Donkey,” a fellow-Moslem? Being a good host, Mr. Ma promptly brought out a bottle of whisky, whereupon the Afghan, being a good Mohammedan who still took his Koran literally, walloped him severely on the jaw. The Chinese Moslems are more easy-going in these little matters. Many of them drink, and smoke not only tobacco but opium. The one rule to which they cling most fiercely—though even that, it is said, many of them will break if there are no coreligionists to tell on them—is the prohibition against eating pork. They never speak of a pig by its real name unless they are volubly cursing or shriveling up an enemy with an impromptu description of his family tree. If there is no avoiding mention of the unclean creature in polite intercourse, it is referred to as a “black 463sheep.” When the Moslem population of a Kansu town is in the majority, no one in it is allowed to keep or bring in pigs, which naturally tends to a further decrease of the minority. Chinese may eat in a Mohammedan’s house, but the latter cannot accept a return invitation, for fear not so much of being purposely insulted by being offered pork, as of being fed in dishes which have at some time or other been contaminated with pork or lard. The Chinese, when things come to the point where it is worth the risk, tell the “Hwei-Hwei” that their dislike of pork is merely a dread of eating their ancestors; and then the knives come out.
“Mr. Donkey” and a Taoist priest were close friends who often went on drinking sprees, sometimes joined by a “Living Buddha.” This lively trio occasionally burst into the mission compound in the early hours, hoping their good friend from another faith might forget his little doctrinal quirks and join them. One time, our host learned that a “Britisher” had been imprisoned in a Chinese jail. As the foremost representative of the British nation in Kansu, he couldn't allow this breach of extraterritoriality to continue. He demanded the immediate release of the prisoner, which the provincial governor granted right away—and handed him an Afghan instead. Naturally, it made sense for him to send this fellow national, for whom he felt responsible, to stay with “Mr. Donkey,” a fellow Muslim. Being a good host, Mr. Ma quickly brought out a bottle of whisky, prompting the Afghan, who was a devout Muslim and followed his Koran closely, to punch him hard on the jaw. The Chinese Muslims tend to be more laid-back about such things. Many of them drink and smoke not only tobacco but also opium. The one rule they cling to the most—though it’s said many will break it if there are no fellow believers around to tell on them—is the ban on eating pork. They don’t refer to a pig by its actual name unless they’re angrily cursing or describing an enemy’s family tree in a derogatory way. If they have to mention the unclean animal in polite conversation, they call it a “black sheep.” When the Muslim population in a Kansu town is predominant, nobody is allowed to keep or bring in pigs, which naturally leads to a further decline of the minority. Chinese can dine in a Muslim’s home, but the latter cannot accept a return invitation, not so much out of fear of being insulted with pork, but of being served in dishes that may have been tainted by pork or lard at some point. When it comes down to it, the Chinese sometimes tell the “Hwei-Hwei” that their aversion to pork is really a fear of eating their ancestors; and then things can get heated.
“Mr. Donkey” took me to an important mosque in which posters, depicting the Kaaba and similar scenes, and covered with Arabic text, had been pasted in and about the prayer niche. Pilgrims had brought them from Mecca, and the last little “Hwei-Hwei” in the group about me knew what these symbols represented. Yet in all our journey through the northwest I never saw a man bowing down in prayer toward Mecca, though others tell me that this was mere accident. Certainly no such accident would continue throughout a two months’ trip among the Moslems of the Near East. Only once, too, did I see a woman veiled; her face was completely covered with a thin black cloth, a curiously embroidered old-fashioned skirt hid what were no doubt her bound feet; and a small boy was seated close behind her on the donkey she rode, which a man on foot was urging across the country at unusual speed. There are Mohammedan as well as Christian schools in Lanchow, and they seem to rival each other in some of their superiorities to those of the Chinese, though the Moslem ones copy these in hours and uproar. I have seen Moslem children gathering before the sun was above the horizon, and have come upon roomfuls of boys loudly chanting in Chinese, though there was no evidence of a teacher still in attendance, when darkness was creeping over the mosque that raised its flare-roofed minaret above them. A certain amount of “Alabi” is taught in “Hwei-Hwei” schools, and any man who can read the Koran—which it is forbidden to have translated—is highly honored as an ahong, though many know only the sounds of the words they are reading and not their meaning.
“Mr. Donkey” took me to an important mosque where posters showing the Kaaba and similar scenes were plastered all around the prayer niche, covered in Arabic text. Pilgrims had brought them from Mecca, and the last little “Hwei-Hwei” in my group understood what these symbols meant. Yet, throughout our journey in the northwest, I never saw a man bowing down in prayer toward Mecca, although others say that was just a coincidence. Surely, such a coincidence wouldn't last over a two-month trip among the Muslims of the Near East. I also saw only one woman who was veiled; her face was completely covered with a thin black cloth, and a traditionally embroidered, old-fashioned skirt concealed what were likely her bound feet. A small boy was sitting close behind her on the donkey she rode, which a man on foot was urging across the countryside at an unusual speed. There are both Muslim and Christian schools in Lanchow, and they seem to compete with each other in some of their advantages over the Chinese schools, even though the Muslim ones mimic these in hours and noise. I have seen Muslim children gathering before sunrise and found rooms full of boys loudly chanting in Chinese, even though there was no sign of a teacher still present when darkness was falling over the mosque with its flared-roof minaret. A certain amount of “Alabi” is taught in “Hwei-Hwei” schools, and any man who can read the Koran—which is forbidden to be translated—is greatly respected as an ahong, although many know only the sounds of the words they read and not their meanings.
“Hwei-Hwei” and Chinese customs are particularly at variance in the matter of burials. The former believe in a decent interment for all, while the Chinese see no reason why the bodies of mere girls and unmarried women should not simply be thrown out on a garbage-heap or into some convenient gully. Among the non-Moslems actual difficulties 464are often placed in the way of the proper burial of a still-born child or of a mother dying in childbirth, even if the family is willing to go to the expense and trouble. Yet the Chinese consider the “Hwei-Hwei” custom of disposing of their dead the height of barbarism, particularly in the case of male parents. In each mosque is kept one elaborately decorated coffin—without a bottom. When a “Hwei-Hwei” dies the body is bathed at the home, swathed in white cloth on which are written Arabic characters, carried to the grave in the coffin—and buried without it. Naturally such a custom is shocking to a people who are addicted to ancestor-worship and whose massive coffins are the chief cause of an advance of deforestation that is already well beyond the Tibetan frontier. In fact, though wolf, dog, otter, lynx, squirrel, fox, bear, leopard and snow-leopard, deer, and several other skins come down in considerable quantities from Tibet into Kansu and flow on into the rest of China, probably the Chinese resentment at England for abetting the Tibetans in throwing off the rule of Peking is due as much as anything to the fear of the rank and file that their forests will cease to furnish the coffins without which no genuine Chinese can either live or die. During the fighting in Shensi Province in 1911, it was a very common thing to see strings of pack-mules each carrying a frozen “Hwei-Hwei” corpse on either side, wending their way back to Hochow, the Chinese Mecca; but once the corpse has been taken home for burial there seems to be none of the Chinese desire to preserve it as long as possible.
“Hwei-Hwei” and Chinese customs stand in sharp contrast when it comes to burials. The former believe in giving everyone a proper burial, while the Chinese see no reason why the bodies of girls and unmarried women shouldn't just be tossed out with the trash or into a nearby ditch. Among non-Muslims, real obstacles often arise when it comes to properly burying a stillborn child or a mother who dies during childbirth, even when the family is willing to spend money and effort. Yet the Chinese consider the “Hwei-Hwei” practice of handling their dead to be extremely barbaric, especially regarding male parents. Each mosque keeps one elaborately decorated coffin—without a bottom. When a “Hwei-Hwei” dies, the body is washed at home, wrapped in a white cloth with Arabic writing, carried to the grave in the coffin—and buried without it. Naturally, such a practice is shocking to a culture that values ancestor worship, and whose large coffins are a major cause of deforestation that has already gone past the Tibetan border. In fact, while various animal pelts like wolf, dog, otter, lynx, squirrel, fox, bear, leopard, snow-leopard, deer, and others flow from Tibet into Kansu and further into the rest of China, the Chinese resentment towards England for supporting the Tibetans in breaking away from Peking's rule likely stems from their fear that their forests will no longer provide the coffins that define both life and death for a true Chinese. During the fighting in Shensi Province in 1911, it was common to see strings of pack mules, each carrying a frozen “Hwei-Hwei” corpse on either side, making their way back to Hochow, the Chinese Mecca; but once the corpse is taken home for burial, there appears to be no significant Chinese desire to preserve it for as long as possible.
At a genuine “Hwei-Hwei” wedding every one comes on horseback to the bride’s home for the ceremony by an ahong, and then the whole cavalcade gallops back to the house of the groom. There is said to be less infant mortality among the Mohammedans than among their neighbors, not only because girls are perhaps a little less unwelcome, but because of the greater consumption of mutton and milk. “Hwei-Hwei” boys of fifteen often turn muleteers and tramp twenty to thirty miles a day over the mountains and spend much of the night feeding their animals, months on end, while they steadily grow into sturdy men to whom almost any hardship is not even recognized as such.
At a real “Hwei-Hwei” wedding, everyone rides horseback to the bride’s home for the ceremony led by an ahong, and then the entire group rides back to the groom's house. It's said that there’s less infant mortality among the Mohammedans than among their neighbors, not only because girls are maybe a little less unwelcome, but also due to a higher intake of mutton and milk. “Hwei-Hwei” boys at fifteen often become muleteers, trekking twenty to thirty miles a day across the mountains and spending much of the night taking care of their animals for months at a time, while they grow into strong men who hardly recognize any hardship.

A Kansu vista near Lanchow, where the hills are no longer terraced, but where towns are numerous and much alike
A Kansu view near Lanchow, where the hills aren't terraced anymore, but there are many towns that look quite similar.

This method of grinding up red peppers and the like is wide-spread in China. Both through and wheel are of solid iron
This method of grinding red peppers and similar spices is common in China. Both the mortar and wheel are made of solid iron.

Oil is floated down the Yellow River to Lanchow in whole ox-hides that quiver at a touch as if they were alive
Oil is transported down the Yellow River to Lanchow in entire ox hides that shudder at a touch as if they were alive.

The Yellow River at Lanchow, with a water-wheel and the American bridge which is the only one that crosses it in the west
The Yellow River at Lanchow, featuring a water wheel and the American bridge, which is the only one that crosses it in the west.
465The dinner given in our honor by the “copper”-making Tuchun of Kansu was in most points a repetition of that in Sian-fu. This time, in addition to the invitations on red cards, there was sent around a list of the guests, written in Chinese, of course, on a long sheet of similar color, which we were expected to sign in Chinese after our names. If one is not able to come—or perhaps if he finds some of the other guests not to his liking—he makes an appropriate mark in lieu of signing. When the hour for the dinner approached, messengers came to remind us to come; perhaps I should say to warn us not to be late or absent, for this was plainly a custom of viceregal days which still survived out here in the far west. In those days a visit to this same yamen was an event to cable home about, quite different from dropping in to see a military governor who from the Chinese point of view was extremely “democratic.” The man who hoped to live to boast of having been received by a viceroy got into his best dress about the middle of the night and appeared at the yamen toward four in the morning, when he might possibly be admitted to the semi-imperial presence within an hour or two, since viceroys more or less followed the custom in audiences of the court at Peking; or he might have the pleasure of waiting most of the day, and perhaps of coming back again next morning to see another sunrise. If, when at last he was received, he was of high enough rank to be asked to take a chair or its viceregal equivalent, he sat gingerly on the extreme edge of it, like one who knows how reprehensible it is to dare to draw breath in so sacred a presence. But those same old viceroys knew how to rule the Chinese, and their modern successors seem to come most nearly succeeding at the same task when they adopt viceregal methods, for all their up-to-date uniforms in place of flowing Ch’ing dynasty costumes. Then, there was an exact unbroken line of responsibility all the way from the viceroy clear down to the village elder, and things that were ordered done usually occurred, and vice versa. But we all know what a long row there is to hoe between autocracy and anything approaching real democracy.
465The dinner held in our honor by the “copper”-making Tuchun of Kansu was mostly a repeat of the one in Sian-fu. This time, in addition to the red card invitations, we received a list of the guests, written in Chinese, on a long sheet of the same color, which we were expected to sign in Chinese after our names. If someone couldn’t come—or if they found some of the other guests unappealing—they would make a mark instead of signing. As dinner time approached, messengers came to remind us to attend; I should say they came to warn us not to be late or absent, as this was clearly a custom from the days of the vice kings that still existed out here in the far west. Back then, a visit to this same yamen was a big deal, something to brag about at home, very different from dropping in to see a military governor who, from the Chinese perspective, was seen as quite “democratic.” Anyone hoping to brag about being received by a viceroy would dress in their best clothes around midnight and show up at the yamen around four in the morning, hoping to be admitted to the semi-imperial presence within an hour or two, since viceroys generally followed court customs from Peking; or they might end up waiting most of the day and possibly returning the next morning to catch another sunrise. When finally received, if the visitor was of high enough rank to be invited to take a chair or its viceroyal equivalent, they would sit nervously on the edge of it, fully aware how inappropriate it was to breathe in such a sacred presence. But those old viceroys knew how to govern the Chinese, and their modern successors seem to achieve the most success in this regard when they use vice-regal methods, despite their modern uniforms replacing the flowing Ch’ing dynasty costumes. There was a clear, unbroken line of authority stretching from the viceroy down to the village elder, and things that were ordered to be done usually happened, and vice versa. But we all know how challenging it is to bridge the gap between autocracy and anything resembling true democracy.
Long lines of soldiers presented arms as we passed through the various compounds of the yamen in the wake of our visiting-cards, held high aloft as usual. At length there came the period of innumerable waist-hinged bows, attended by the difficulty, now so familiar in China, as to whether hats or caps should be lifted or left undisturbed. For by Chinese custom it is bad form to uncover the head before guests or hosts, even indoors, while the European style is not only quite the opposite but is here and there followed by Chinese who consider themselves progressive, though one can never be sure when or where such alien manners, perhaps including the unsanitary hand-shake, will break out. After the preliminary formalities in the every-day guest-room, we streamed away through the compound of the bugling wapiti and across the now barren garden to a huge room on the edge of the city wall and 466overlooking the Yellow River. Not only was this open and cold but its walls were mainly of glass, which did not improve the temperature. It was not easy to find our places by the red place-cards bearing merely our Chinese names, but when we did we found that America had been signally honored. For on the Tuchun’s left, which is nearest the heart in Chinese custom, sat the major, while a Mongol prince who ruled a tribe in the Kokonor region of Tibet had been relegated to his less important right hand. However, the prince, who was also a lama, and according to some uncertain authorities a “Living Buddha,” cast far into the shade not only the major, but the Tuchun himself, this time in a black gown instead of uniform, to say nothing of the civil governor—in practice merely an underling of the military ruler of any Chinese province and as pale a moon as a vice-president in the shadow of the White House. For his Highness, or whatever familiar title he answered to, wore a brilliant saffron jacket embroidered with dragons, a cap of similar color with a large pink tourmaline—perhaps, for I am no expert in colored stones—a purple skirt, and dull-red Mongol boots! With him had come a princely suite, one member of which, swarthy as a mulatto and with a curiously eagle-like eye, stood between his master and the Tuchun and acted as interpreter. But the prince was anything but talkative, possibly because he was not garrulous by temperament, perhaps because he shared the common dislike of hearing his remarks relayed in a foreign tongue, but most likely for the reason that his attention was fully taken up with the intricacies of what purported to be a foreign meal. The strange eating-tools were evidently quite new to him; but he had the wisdom of common sense as well as the unexcitability of Mongol princes, and by watching the Tuchun at one end of the table and the civil governor at the other he came off very well indeed. How deep was his wisdom is shown by the fact that whenever he was in doubt he merely “passed.” Perhaps he really did not smoke or drink, as he stated with a word and a gesture, but there could hardly have been any religious motives for refusing half the countless courses, beginning with sharks’ fins—no simple luxury this far from the coast—and ending with macaroons, which he plainly avoided as another unknown, and therefore possibly dangerous, form of food.
Long lines of soldiers saluted as we walked through the various sections of the yamen, our visiting cards held high as usual. Eventually, we reached the moment of countless bowing, accompanied by the familiar question in China of whether to lift our hats or leave them on. According to Chinese custom, it's considered rude to remove your hat in front of guests or hosts, even indoors, while European customs are quite the opposite. Some progressive Chinese may adopt these Western practices, including the often-unhygienic handshake, but it's hard to predict when or where such foreign habits might appear. After the initial formalities in the everyday guest room, we moved through the area with the calling wapiti and across the now barren garden to a large room by the city wall that overlooked the Yellow River. Not only was this room cold and open, but its walls were mostly glass, which didn't help the temperature. It was tricky to find our seats marked by red place cards showing only our Chinese names, but once we did, we saw that America had been notably honored. The major sat to the left of the Tuchun, the position closest to the heart in Chinese custom, while a Mongol prince from a tribe in the Kokonor region of Tibet was placed at his less significant right. However, the prince, who was also a lama and, according to some uncertain sources, a “Living Buddha,” overshadowed not just the major but also the Tuchun himself, who was dressed in a black gown instead of his uniform, not to mention the civil governor—merely a subordinate to the military ruler of any Chinese province and as pale as a vice president caught in the shadow of the White House. His Highness—or whatever friendly title he went by—wore a bright saffron jacket with dragon embroidery, a matching cap with a large pink tourmaline—though I'm no expert on gems—a purple skirt, and dull-red Mongol boots! Along with him was a princely entourage, one member of which, dark-skinned like a mulatto and with a distinctly eagle-like eye, stood between his master and the Tuchun, acting as the interpreter. But the prince was anything but chatty, possibly because he wasn't naturally talkative, perhaps because he disliked hearing his words translated into a foreign language, but most likely because he was fully focused on the complexities of what appeared to be a foreign meal. The unfamiliar eating utensils were clearly new to him, but he had the common sense and composure typical of Mongol princes, and by observing the Tuchun at one end of the table and the civil governor at the other, he managed quite well. The depth of his wisdom was evident in the fact that whenever he was uncertain, he simply “passed” on the food. Perhaps he truly did not smoke or drink, as he indicated with a word and a gesture, but there were likely no religious reasons for his refusal of many dishes, starting with sharks’ fins—definitely not a simple luxury this far from the coast—and ending with macaroons, which he clearly avoided as yet another unknown and potentially dangerous type of food.
How the soldier servants, to whom a boy picked up from the dump-heap brought things from the kitchen, handled not only slices of bread but the eating end of forks and spoons without any apparent consciousness of the absence of manicurists in Lanchow need not of course be mentioned. Besides the lama-prince there were Protestant 467missionaries, a Catholic or two, ordinary Buddhists, Taoists, and Confucianists, probably fetishists pure and simple as well as mere pagans, and certainly there were Mohammedans among the soldiers swarming within and about the room, though not, of course, among the guests. Conversation never rose above the gossip plane, and glancing along the table I realized that one possible reason for this, besides custom at semi-public Tuchuns’ dinners, was the fact that there were eight different mother-tongues among the bare score of men about the festive board.
How the soldier servants, to whom a boy picked up from the dump brought items from the kitchen, handled not just slices of bread but also the eating ends of forks and spoons without any awareness of the lack of manicurists in Lanchow doesn't really need to be mentioned. Besides the lama-prince, there were Protestant missionaries, a couple of Catholics, ordinary Buddhists, Taoists, and Confucianists, likely some straightforward fetishists and just plain pagans, and certainly there were Muslims among the soldiers bustling around the room, though not, of course, among the guests. The conversation never went beyond gossip, and as I looked along the table, I realized that one possible reason for this, aside from the custom at semi-public Tuchuns’ dinners, was the fact that there were eight different native languages among the mere twenty men at the festive table.
Night had fallen before the servants had cut up the fruit and distributed it piecemeal, and had snatched away from any unwary guest the cigar laid before him a moment before, slipping it deftly up their sleeves, and we were at length in a position to bid Lanchow an official farewell. The final scene was not without its picturesqueness. When the last polite controversy on precedent at the many yamen gateways and the final bows had subsided, the blue embroidered night turned to a whirlpool of big oval Chinese lanterns, as the chair-bearers gathered in the outer courtyard prepared to take up their masters and trot. Each chair was tilted forward until its owner had doubled himself into it, his cushions were adjusted by ostensibly loving hands, and the curtain which formed the front wall closed upon him. The chief of his carriers shouted out orders that were repeated as well as executed by the others, and each group shouldered its burden in turn and jogged away into the night, its big paper lanterns swinging gently to and fro. Even the Belgian representative of the salt administration was attended by soldiers as well as his four chair-bearers, for high officials cannot overlook the matter of “face” in China merely because they chance to be foreigners. The Mongol lama-prince, like one who deeply scorned any such effeminate form of locomotion, mounted the red-saddled horse led up by one of his rather poorly mounted escort, which clattered away over the flagstones behind him, bugles blowing and scattered groups of soldiers presenting arms, while we simple Americans wandered out and away on foot.
Night had fallen by the time the servants had sliced up the fruit and handed it out piece by piece, stealthily snatching any unattended cigars from unsuspecting guests and slipping them up their sleeves. Finally, we were ready to officially say goodbye to Lanchow. The farewell scene had its own charm. After the last polite debate about the rules at the many yamen entrances and the final bows had settled down, the blue embroidered night transformed into a swirl of large, oval Chinese lanterns as the chair-bearers gathered in the outer courtyard, preparing to carry their masters away. Each chair was tilted forward until its owner had nestled into it, their cushions adjusted by seemingly affectionate hands, and the curtain that served as the front wall closed around them. The lead carrier shouted commands that were echoed and acted upon by the others, and each group took their turn to shoulder their load and jog off into the night, their large paper lanterns swinging gently back and forth. Even the Belgian representative of the salt administration was accompanied by soldiers along with his four chair-bearers because high officials can’t ignore the concept of “face” in China, even if they are foreigners. The Mongol lama-prince, seeming to disdain such delicate means of transport, mounted the red-saddled horse led up by one of his somewhat inadequately mounted escorts. The horse clattered away over the flagstones behind him, with bugles blowing and scattered soldiers saluting, while we simple Americans made our way out on foot.
CHAPTER XXV
Following the Yellow River home
The saddest part of seeing Lanchow was not that we had taken twenty-seven days to reach it, but that it would require fully that amount of time to undo again what we had done. The usual way of returning from the Kansu capital to Peking is simply to float down the Hoang Ho on goatskin rafts to where one can easily reach the advancing Suiyuan railway. We had hoped to do this, but we were prepared for the news that it was impossible so late in the season. November was nearing its last lap, and while the river at Lanchow was still open, big chunks of ice already drifting down it from the Tibetan highlands helped to confirm the general opinion that it would be frozen solid in its broader and more sluggish reaches farther north, where we would be left virtually stranded.
The saddest part about seeing Lanchow wasn't that it took us twenty-seven days to get there, but that it would take just as long to undo what we had done. The usual way to return from the Kansu capital to Peking is to float down the Hoang Ho on goatskin rafts until you can easily access the advancing Suiyuan railway. We had hoped to do this, but we were prepared for the news that it was impossible this late in the season. November was approaching its end, and while the river at Lanchow was still open, large chunks of ice already drifting down from the Tibetan highlands confirmed the general belief that it would be frozen solid in its wider and slower sections farther north, where we would be practically stranded.
We each bought a stout Kansu pony, therefore, and a less lively one for the alleged mafu who was willing to leave the employ of our host and return to his family graves near Tientsin—if we would pay him to do so. Mafus usually walk by day and tend their masters’ horses by night, but we concluded to be generous, and as a result we acquired a troublesome companion rather than a useful servant; for the one thing which the Chinese coolie cannot stand is prosperity. Then we hired two carts, quite like those that had brought our belongings from Sian-fu, which agreed for a consideration of one hundred taels to set us down in Paotouchen in time, with good luck in trains, for us to spend Christmas with our families in Peking. We again set our plans to outspeed the usual schedule if possible, by dangling before the drivers a gratuity of a whole round dollar each for every day they made up.
We each bought a sturdy Kansu pony and a less energetic one for the supposed mafu who was ready to leave our host's service and head back to his family graves near Tientsin—if we paid him to do it. Mafus usually walk during the day and take care of their masters' horses at night, but we decided to be generous, which meant we ended up with a bothersome companion instead of a helpful servant; because the one thing a Chinese coolie can't handle is prosperity. Then we hired two carts, similar to the ones that had brought our belongings from Sian-fu, agreeing on a fee of one hundred taels to get us to Paotouchen in time, with some luck with the trains, so we could spend Christmas with our families in Peking. We planned to beat the usual schedule if we could by offering the drivers a tip of a whole dollar each for every day they made up.
This did not spare us from getting a late start, however, though that did not worry us so much as it would have before we had learned from experience that a delay in the first get-away is no proof that the days that follow will be similarly blighted. The unavoidable formalities of the last moment, such as the cartmen’s vociferous leave-taking 469of the inn that had housed them, made up mainly of shrieks of “Ch’ien!”—which, as I have said before, is the Chinese notion of how the word “money” should be pronounced—were further complicated by the task of getting rid of a man of unknown antecedents whom our experienced host caught surreptitiously slipping his baggage into one of the carts. He merely wished the pleasure of our company, he wailed, kneeling before us in the by no means carpeted street, and he would walk every step of the whole journey. Perhaps he would, but we should have been foolish to harbor in our midst a man who might be in league with the bandits, particularly after the Tuchun had taken the trouble to wire the Mohammedan generals along the way asking for guarantees of our safety. Besides, our expedition was quite unwieldy enough as it was. Thus it was almost nine o’clock when we streamed out across the incongruous American bridge and, striking northward along the edge of the river and that of the suburb which piles into the air behind it, were soon lost among an endless series of bare brown hills.
This didn't keep us from starting late, but it didn't worry us as much as it would have before we learned from experience that a delay in the initial departure doesn't mean the following days will be just as disrupted. The unavoidable last-minute formalities, like the loud farewells from the cart drivers leaving the inn where they stayed—full of shouts of “Ch’ien!”—which, as I've said before, is how the Chinese pronounce “money”—were made more complicated by the need to deal with a man of unknown background who our experienced host caught trying to sneak his luggage into one of the carts. He insisted he just wanted to enjoy our company, begging us as he knelt on the bare street, claiming he would walk every step of the entire journey. Maybe he would, but we would have been foolish to let someone who might be working with bandits join us, especially after the Tuchun had taken the effort to inform the local Mohammedan generals to ensure our safety. Besides, our group was already large enough. So it was nearly nine o’clock when we flowed out across the mismatched American bridge and headed north along the river and the suburb rising behind it, soon disappearing into an endless stretch of bare brown hills.
The homeward trip by the northern route was quite different from that by which we had come. Instead of passing several walled cities almost every day, there were often only two or three dreary little hamlets from dawn till dark, and for days at a time nothing whatever but the single mud compound or two where travelers stopped at noon and at night. There was almost no loess, but instead desolate desert hills or broad plateaus with few suggestions of even summer-time vegetation either on them or on the more or less distant ranges that shut them in. Without loess, there were of course few sunken roads—none worthy the name to any one who had seen the other route—and no cave-dwellings, but in place of them wind-swept mud hovels, sometimes enclosed within high walled compounds.
The journey home via the northern route was a lot different from the one we took to get there. Instead of passing several fortified cities almost every day, we often only saw two or three bleak little villages from dawn until dusk. For days at a time, we encountered nothing but a single mud compound or two where travelers would stop for lunch and at night. There was hardly any loess; instead, we found barren desert hills or wide plateaus with little sign of even summer vegetation, whether on the land itself or on the distant mountain ranges surrounding us. Without loess, there were very few sunken roads—none that would impress anyone who had traveled the other route—and no cave-dwellings. Instead, we came across wind-swept mud huts, sometimes surrounded by tall walled compounds.
The hovels were particularly numerous on the first afternoon in the almost rich grain district that succeeded the first stretch of semi-desert—endless mud-walled compounds that looked like the ramparts of small cities, yet housing only a single family, though in China this may include as many as two score individuals of four, and even of five, generations. Most of the fields were covered with the moisture-protecting layer of stones. These are changed once in a generation, we heard, and the custom becomes more prevalent farther west, where the land grows ever drier until it merges into the Gobi Desert. Groups of peasants were still winnowing grain in the breeze on their threshing-floors, and everywhere sparrows enough to eat it all as fast as it was 470separated from the chaff made the air vociferous with their twittering. We plodded all day and well on into the moonlight across what finally became almost an uninhabited waste; and next day we climbed to an altitude of nearly eight thousand feet through stony, dreary mountains without people, except for one little surface coal-mine, and a rare shepherd, without vegetation except for little bunches of brown tuft-grass. Always there was a new wrinkled mountain range growing up ahead and another slipping away behind, though these usually flanked the broad river valley instead of crossing our trail.
The huts were especially common on the first afternoon in the almost affluent grain region that followed the initial stretch of semi-desert—endless mud-walled compounds that resembled the walls of small cities, yet housed only one family, although in China, this could include up to twenty people from four or even five generations. Most of the fields were covered with stones to retain moisture. We heard these stones are replaced once a generation, and this practice is more widespread further west, where the land becomes increasingly dry until it transitions into the Gobi Desert. Groups of farmers were still winnowing grain on their threshing floors in the breeze, while sparrows were plentiful enough to eat it as quickly as it was separated from the chaff, filling the air with their chirping. We trudged all day and well into the moonlight across what eventually turned into nearly an uninhabited wasteland; the next day we climbed to nearly eight thousand feet through rocky, bleak mountains with hardly any people, aside from one small surface coal mine and the occasional shepherd, and no vegetation except for sparse patches of brown tuft-grass. There was always a new jagged mountain range rising up ahead and another fading away behind, though these typically bordered the wide river valley instead of crossing our path.
We were always well on our way by sunrise, with two hours or more of walking behind us, for it was too bitter cold then to ride; and sunset often found us still in the saddle. On Thanksgiving day, for instance, we were up at four and off at five, for there was a stretch of ninety li without a single human habitation to be crossed before we could even make our noonday halt. A high wind and heavy clouds made riding for long distances impossible, and there was little indeed to keep us in a cheerful mood. A crumpled range of mountains lightly topped with newly fallen snow beautified the left-hand horizon; now and again a group of Gobi antelopes sped away like winged creatures through the kind of sage-brush that recalled Arizona or Nevada, their white flags seeming a saucy defiance to us; and in mid-morning we passed through the Great Wall. It was fortunate that our map showed this, for we might easily have mistaken it for the mud enclosure of rather an extensive field and never have given it a second glance. Instead of the mammoth stone barrier to be seen near Peking, it was a mere ridge of packed earth, perhaps eight feet high and as many wide at the base, with broad gaps in it here and there, through which wander the modern trails. The contractors evidently had something of a sinecure out here in the west where the emperor could not keep an eye upon them.
We always set out by sunrise, already having walked for two hours or more, since it was too bitterly cold to ride then; and often by sunset we were still in the saddle. For example, on Thanksgiving day, we were up at four and left at five to tackle a stretch of ninety li without any towns or villages before we could even take our midday break. A strong wind and heavy clouds made long-distance riding impossible, and there was very little to lift our spirits. A crumpled range of mountains, lightly dusted with fresh snow, decorated the left horizon; now and then, a group of Gobi antelopes darted away like birds through the sagebrush, which reminded us of Arizona or Nevada, their white tails seeming to tease us. In the late morning, we passed through the Great Wall. Luckily, our map indicated this, or we might have mistaken it for a mud enclosure of a large field and wouldn’t have given it a second thought. Unlike the massive stone barrier near Peking, it was just a simple ridge of packed earth, maybe eight feet high and just as wide at the base, with wide gaps here and there, allowing modern trails to cross. Clearly, the contractors had an easy job out here in the west where the emperor couldn’t supervise them.
For miles before we reached the wall the sage-brush plain was piled everywhere with Chinese graves of all sizes, some of them completely covered over with drifted sand; but beyond it there was not a single artificial mound of earth, as if there were no use in being buried at all unless one could find a resting-place within the Great Wall. The vastness of the brown uninhabited world was particularly impressive in the absolutely dead silence which lasted for long periods, unbroken even by the chirping of a stray bird. One might have been in some “death valley,” yet only water seemed to be wanting in what might otherwise have been excellent farming country.
For miles before we got to the wall, the sagebrush plain was scattered with Chinese graves of all sizes, some completely covered by drifted sand. But beyond that, there wasn’t a single man-made mound of earth, as if there was no point in being buried at all unless you could find a resting place within the Great Wall. The vastness of the brown, uninhabited landscape was especially striking in the complete silence that lasted for long stretches, broken only by the rare chirp of a bird. It felt like being in some kind of “death valley,” yet the only thing missing in what could have otherwise been great farmland was water.
471Evidently this lack was increasing, for there were only abandoned ruins left of what had once been a town, big temple and all, at the end of the ninety li. There was one hole in the sandy earth, at which all trails converged, and shepherds, cartmen, and miscellaneous travelers were constantly using the cloth bucket on a stick with which crude troughs about it were filled, and where great flocks of sheep disputed with horses, cattle, mules, and donkeys; but this only water for many miles in any direction was evidently growing insufficient for the demands made upon it. We had a frozen luncheon in the lee of a ruin, from which we could look across a vast section of the plain, dotted in the foreground with the grazing camels of a great caravan that had pitched its tents and piled its cargo within easy distance of the well, to where the yellowish brown turned to purple and rolled up into the wrinkled, snow-topped range that shut off the world on the west. All that afternoon there was the same silent, rolling landscape, which ended at last, just in time, as bitter cold night was settling down, at a single mud compound in a little hollow of the great solitude.
471Clearly, this shortage was getting worse, as all that remained of what was once a thriving town—complete with a large temple—was just abandoned ruins at the end of the ninety li. There was a single hole in the sandy ground where all the paths met, and shepherds, cart drivers, and various travelers were constantly using a cloth bucket on a stick to fill the crude troughs around it, where large flocks of sheep competed for space with horses, cattle, mules, and donkeys. However, this only source of water for miles in any direction was clearly becoming inadequate for the demands placed on it. We had a cold lunch sheltered by a ruin, from which we could gaze out across a vast stretch of the plain, the foreground dotted with grazing camels from a large caravan that had set up camp and stacked its cargo near the well, stretching to where the yellowish brown landscape faded into purple and rolled up into the craggy, snow-capped range that cut off the world to the west. All that afternoon, the same silent, rolling scenery stretched out, finally coming to an end just in time, as the bitter cold of night began to settle, at a single mud compound nestled in a small hollow of the vast wilderness.
The next day, in contrast, was absolutely cloudless, and so were nearly all those of December. We rambled for more than twelve hours across a lifeless wilderness where a human being was a sight to remember and in which two rabbits were the only visible representatives of the rest of the animal kingdom. Deep sand, here and there alternating with a sort of sage-brush, made the progress of our carts exasperatingly slow—until I suddenly discovered the ease and pleasure of reading on horseback, with the result that I devoured every book we had with us and memorized a primer of the Chinese language before the journey ended. Yet two inns just rightly spaced greeted our eyes at noon and at nightfall, as two others did on several similarly unpeopled days. It hardly seemed possible that these had grown up so accurately by mere chance, especially as there was no natural feature to attract and sustain them, and sometimes water had to be brought thirty li or more on donkey-back, so that it cost us twelve coppers each to wash our faces and hands. In every case in which we asked, the proprietor was the son or grandson, born right here in the wilderness, of malefactors or political prisoners who had been sentenced by the Manchu dynasty to keep these inns at certain specified points along this old imperial highway.
The next day, on the other hand, was completely clear, and so were almost all the days in December. We wandered for over twelve hours through a lifeless wilderness where seeing another human was a rare thing, and the only animals we spotted were two rabbits. The deep sand, mixed with patches of sagebrush, made pulling our carts frustratingly slow—until I discovered the ease and enjoyment of reading while on horseback, which led me to read every book we had with us and memorize a primer of the Chinese language before we finished the journey. However, at noon and nightfall, we came across two inns perfectly spaced, just like a few others on several similarly empty days. It seemed unlikely that these inns had appeared purely by chance, especially since there was no natural feature to draw people in, and sometimes water had to be carried more than thirty li on donkey-back, costing us twelve coppers each just to wash our hands and faces. In every case we inquired, the owner was the son or grandson, born right there in the wilderness, of criminals or political prisoners who had been sentenced by the Manchu dynasty to run these inns at specific points along this old imperial highway.
On the sixth day north of Lanchow we reached the great sand-dunes which make what might almost be a possible automobile trail impossible 472even for Chinese carts. Great ridges of pure sand, everywhere given a corrugated surface by the winds that had piled them up during the centuries, stretch from some unknown distance back in the country, perhaps clear from the foot-hills of the western ranges, down to the very edge of the Yellow River. We might easily have fancied ourselves in the midst of the Sahara as we waded for three hours, much more on foot than on horseback, across this effective barrier to wheeled traffic, had it not been for the sight of the Hoang Ho sweeping around it in a half-circle so far below as to look like a mere brook, and the tumbled masses of mountains beyond, culminating in a cone that has smoked uninterruptedly, we were assured, for more then seven centuries. Boats that seemed from this height mere boys’ rafts rather than cumbersome barges capable of carrying two loaded carts glided up and down the stream amid myriad floating chunks of ice; but we strained our eyes in vain to make out, even through this brilliant, moistureless air, anything resembling our own outfit. Beyond the dunes we came down upon a cluster of mud compounds, most of them prepared to pose as inns if the opportunity offered, and just then unusually crowded with west-bound travelers. These were almost all soldiers, Mohammedan in faith and in many cases so Turkish of features that with their big reddish beards they seemed to be actors wearing masks above their cotton-padded Chinese uniforms. They were the escort of a new governor on his way to Eastern Turkestan, and the expedition was so large that though we came upon the vanguard, accompanying some veritable houses on wheels, early in the morning, we passed the last straggling carts and horsemen toward sunset.
On the sixth day north of Lanchow, we reached the massive sand dunes that turned what could have been a feasible automobile trail into an impossible route, even for Chinese carts. Huge ridges of pure sand, shaped into a corrugated surface by the winds that have built them over the centuries, stretched from an unknown distance back in the country, possibly all the way from the foothills of the western ranges, down to the very edge of the Yellow River. We could have easily imagined ourselves in the Sahara as we waded for three hours—much more on foot than on horseback—across this effective barrier to wheeled traffic, if it weren't for the sight of the Hoang Ho flowing around it in a half-circle far below, looking like a mere stream, along with the jumbled masses of mountains beyond, culminating in a cone that has been continuously smoking, we were told, for over seven centuries. Boats that appeared from this height to be nothing more than boys’ rafts rather than bulky barges capable of carrying two loaded carts glided up and down the river among countless floating chunks of ice; however, we strained our eyes in vain to spot anything resembling our own outfit, even through this bright, moistureless air. Beyond the dunes, we came upon a cluster of mud buildings, most of which were pretending to be inns if the chance arose, and unusually busy with west-bound travelers at that moment. Almost all of them were soldiers, Muslims in faith, and in many cases, with such Turkish features that their big reddish beards made them look like actors wearing masks above their cotton-padded Chinese uniforms. They were the escort for a new governor heading to Eastern Turkestan, and the expedition was so large that even though we encountered the vanguard, along with some actual houses on wheels, early in the morning, we passed the last straggling carts and horsemen just before sunset.
This extraordinary demand upon the ferrying facilities brought upon us the dreadful experience of being separated from our commissary and forced to shift for ourselves. The rights of extraterritoriality are one thing, and the joy which Chinese soldiers sometimes take in putting a foreigner to annoyance and delay even without reason when so good an opportunity offers is quite another. The major had known of a colleague who, traveling in Manchuria, had been deliberately held on a river-bank for forty-eight hours because soldiers crossing to his side insisted on sending the boats back empty rather than delay one or two of them long enough for the “outside barbarian” to get his carts on board. With neither of us in evidence, and without even one of the major’s cards in his pocket, no doubt Chang was finding it impossible to prove that ours was an expedition of foreigners 473and therefore in a hurry, whatever might otherwise have been the attitude of these more western Moslems in Chinese uniforms.
This huge demand on the ferry services led to the terrible experience of being cut off from our supplies and having to fend for ourselves. The concept of extraterritorial rights is one thing, but the pleasure Chinese soldiers sometimes take in annoying and delaying a foreigner for no reason when given the chance is quite another. The major had heard about a colleague who, while traveling in Manchuria, was intentionally held on a riverbank for forty-eight hours because soldiers on his side insisted on sending the boats back empty rather than wait for a moment to let the "outside barbarian" load his carts. With neither of us around and without even one of the major's cards in his pocket, Chang was likely finding it impossible to prove that our mission was an expedition of foreigners and therefore urgent, regardless of how the more western Moslems in Chinese uniforms might have otherwise reacted. 473
When our usual lunch-hour was long past, and still no word came from the rest of our party, we mustered Chinese enough to get chopped straw and peas put before our horses, and eventually to obtain for ourselves a bowl of plain rice boiled and served under conditions and amid surroundings that had best not be specifically described, lest the major’s still unsullied reputation be seriously injured. Then we suddenly realized that it was already three o’clock, that the only place where we could possibly spend a night without our cots and our cook was still forty li away, and that this was a walled city where the gates probably closed at sunset. The result was the most speed we had attained since the spasmodic truck had dropped us in Sian-fu more than a month before. In fact, even the several goatskin rafts plying from town to town along an open stretch of the river could hardly keep up with us.
When our usual lunch hour had long passed and we still hadn’t heard from the rest of our group, we managed to communicate enough in Chinese to get some chopped straw and peas for our horses, and eventually we got a bowl of plain rice boiled and served in conditions and settings that should best not be described in detail, to protect the major’s still untainted reputation. Then we suddenly realized it was already three o'clock, that the only place we could possibly spend the night without our cots and our cook was still forty li away, and that this was a walled city where the gates probably closed at sunset. As a result, we moved faster than we had since the chaotic truck dropped us in Sian-fu more than a month ago. In fact, even the several goatskin rafts traveling from town to town along an open stretch of the river could hardly keep up with us.
It was a curiously sudden change to a rich wide valley from the barren unpeopled wastes that lay behind us; yet the only real difference was irrigation. This had been brought to the western Hoang Ho centuries ago by the Jesuits, who had introduced a complete system, still functioning, with great sluices—ornamented in Chinese fashion with fancy water-gates and bridges showing the heads and tails of great fish in stone. What the good fathers probably did not introduce was the custom of turning all the roads into irrigation ditches and making travel virtually impossible whenever the peasants along the way chose to do so; for that one may see just outside the walls of Peking, and listen in vain for any law or even effectual protest against it. Clusters of trees that were almost numerous rose from in and about farm compounds, which grew so frequent before the day was done as to form nearly a continuous town, and every little while we passed a new, or a very well preserved, temple, high above each of which stood two slender and magnificent poplars that recalled the “pencil minarets” of Cairo.
It was a surprisingly sudden transition to a vast, lush valley from the barren, empty lands we had left behind; yet the only real difference was the irrigation. This system had been introduced to the western Hoang Ho centuries ago by the Jesuits, who implemented a complete setup that is still in use today, complete with large sluices—decorated in a Chinese style with elaborate water gates and bridges featuring stone sculptures of fish. What the good fathers probably didn’t contribute was the habit of turning all the roads into irrigation ditches, making travel nearly impossible whenever the local peasants decided to do so; that can be observed just outside the walls of Beijing, where you can listen in vain for any laws or effective protests against it. Groups of trees, which were almost countless, emerged from farm compounds, growing so abundant by the end of the day that they nearly formed a continuous town, and every so often we would pass a new or very well-preserved temple, each topped with two slender, magnificent poplars that reminded me of the “pencil minarets” of Cairo.
But we had no time to spare for mere sight-seeing, nor even for debating the social effects of Jesuit foresight. For fast as we urged our horses on, the sun seemed to outdistance us without effort, like some runner of unlimited speed and endurance and a weakness for practical joking sauntering easily along just in front of his breathless competitors. The so-called roads, too, abetted this red-faced humorist; 474for they would of course instantly have lost their certificates of Chinese nationality if they had marched straight forward even when the goal was plainly in sight, so that they wound and twisted incessantly here on the flat valley just as they had in their random wandering across the uninhabited rolling plains behind us, just as a Chinese road will always and everywhere, though there is no more reason for it than for putting mustard on apple-pie. Even the accuracy in distances that had hitherto been almost praiseworthy had suddenly disappeared, as if still further to worry us. For it seemed at least a dozen times that the same answer was given to our question as to how far we still had to go, though we spaced this at considerable intervals; and the very best we could do, even at the risk of having to give our animals a day’s rest, was to hold our own.
But we didn’t have time for just sightseeing or even discussing the social impact of Jesuit foresight. No matter how fast we urged our horses on, the sun seemed to outpace us effortlessly, like a runner with unlimited speed and endurance, playfully sauntering just ahead of his breathless competitors. The so-called roads didn’t help either; they would have instantly lost any chance of being called roads if they had just headed straight for the clearly visible destination. Instead, they wound and twisted endlessly across the flat valley just like they had meandered across the empty rolling plains behind us, just as a Chinese road always does—though there’s no reason for it, like putting mustard on apple pie. Even the previously somewhat reliable accuracy in distances seemed to vanish, adding to our frustration. It felt like we received the same answer about how far we had to go at least a dozen times, despite asking at significant intervals; and the best we could manage, even at the risk of needing to give our horses a day’s rest, was to maintain our pace.
We arrived at length, however, just as dusk was spreading, to find the gates of Chungwei still open and the sense of direction among its inhabitants so much better than outside the walls that we brought up before the home of the only foreigners in town without mishap and without delay. Fortunately this couple were Americans, in fact, the most American of all the missionaries we met on our western trip, so that there was no more embarrassment on our side than hesitation on the other when we walked in upon them to say, “Here we are, with nothing but the clothes we stand in; please take care of us.” It is a long cry, of course, from auxiliary work among American soldiers in Europe to the establishing of a mission in a town of far western China where foreigners had never lived before, so that we rather flattered ourselves that we, the first visitors this new station had ever known, were almost as welcome as we were made.
We finally arrived just as dusk was setting in, to find the gates of Chungwei still open, and the locals seemed to have a much better sense of direction than those outside the walls. We made it to the home of the only foreigners in town without any problems or delays. Luckily, this couple was American, in fact, the most American of all the missionaries we encountered on our western trip, so there was no embarrassment on our part and only a bit of hesitation on theirs when we walked in and said, “Here we are, with nothing but the clothes on our backs; please take care of us.” It's quite a leap from working with American soldiers in Europe to starting a mission in a town in far western China where foreigners had never lived before, so we felt pretty pleased that as the first visitors this new station had ever seen, we were almost as welcomed as we felt.
Chungwei is an ancient and more or less honorable town which claims eight thousand families within its walls, among whom only three merchants, without families, were Mohammedans. The city has no north gate because there is no more China north of it, the so-called Great Wall being almost within rifle-shot, and beyond that lies Mongolia. The broad plain on which it flourishes is shut in by mountains and sand-dunes, but is divided by the Yellow River, from which all the prosperity of the region comes. For in the autumn, after the harvest, the top layer of soil is cut up everywhere into big mud bricks, held together by the roots of the crops, and of these all buildings, even walls, fences, and most furniture, are made, and still there are always great piles of them left over. Then the river is let in upon the land and covers it once more with a rich silt that produces splendid rice—certainly 475there was no suggestion of a rice country on a cloudy December day with a high wind blowing—wheat and linseed in abundance, millet, kaoliang, buckwheat, potatoes as large as if they had come from America, cabbage enough to keep the population from starving if there were nothing else, magnificent grapes and peaches, and what our host assured us were the finest walnuts in China. In other words, all Chungwei needed to be a land of plenty and comfort, and possibly even of cleanliness, was to be somehow broken of the apparently unbreakable Chinese habit of bringing into the world, in the madness for male offspring, every possible mouth which the land can feed, with an instant increase to take up the slack offered by such improvements as the irrigation projects of the Jesuits.
Chungwei is an old and quite respectable town that claims to have eight thousand families within its walls, among which only three merchants, without families, are Mohammedans. The city doesn't have a north gate because there's no more China to the north of it; the Great Wall is almost within rifle-shot, and beyond that is Mongolia. The wide plain where it thrives is surrounded by mountains and sand dunes but is divided by the Yellow River, from which all the region's prosperity comes. In the autumn, after the harvest, the top layer of soil is cut into large mud bricks, held together by the roots of the crops, and these are used to make all sorts of buildings, even walls, fences, and most furniture, yet there are always large piles left over. Then the river is allowed to flood the land again, covering it with rich silt that produces excellent rice—certainly, there was no sign of a rice-producing area on a cloudy December day with a strong wind blowing—along with plenty of wheat, linseed, millet, kaoliang, buckwheat, potatoes as big as if they were from America, enough cabbage to keep the population from starving if there was nothing else, and fantastic grapes and peaches, plus what our host claimed to be the finest walnuts in China. In other words, all Chungwei needed to be a land of plenty, comfort, and possibly even cleanliness was to somehow overcome the seemingly unbreakable Chinese habit of bringing into the world every possible mouth the land can feed in a frenzy for male offspring, with an immediate rise to fill the gap created by improvements like the Jesuit irrigation projects.
We were luxuriating in the extraordinary experience of lying abed after daylight when there came a scratching on one of the paper windows of the dining-room where we had been accommodated, and we heard with astonishment Chang’s mellifluous voice murmuring, “Masters, what time like start this morning?” Our missing caravan had finally overcome the difficulties of the river passage and had reached Chungwei about two in the morning. Perhaps it was not so entirely out of sympathy for our weary employees as we fancied that we set ten o’clock as the hour of departure and turned over for another nap.
We were enjoying the incredible experience of lying in bed after sunrise when we heard a scratching sound on one of the paper windows in the dining room where we were staying. To our surprise, we heard Chang’s smooth voice saying, “Masters, what time should we leave this morning?” Our missing caravan had finally made it past the river challenges and had arrived in Chungwei around two in the morning. Maybe it wasn’t just out of sympathy for our tired crew that we set ten o’clock as our departure time and rolled over for another nap.
Our host very seriously doubted whether we could keep to our schedule and make Ningsia in four days, particularly with so late a start. But we had little difficulty in doing so, thanks mainly to the fact that the weather had turned bitter cold. For the peasants all along the cultivated part of the river valley had recently opened the irrigation sluices for the customary autumn flooding, and had it not chanced that thick ice formed a day or two ahead of us on all the streams thus created, we should have been at least a week in covering the four hundred and fifty li, as carts coming in from the northeast reported they had been. Even where the alleged road itself had not been frankly used as an irrigation ditch, it wandered and dodged and side-stepped in a sincere but more or less vain effort to keep out of the diked bare fields which in summer cover with green all this rich brown valley from sand-dunes to river. Now there were vast skating-rinks everywhere, doubly troublesome when they were half thawed in the early afternoons. By picking a roundabout way we could have skated much of the way home. But the crowded population of the valley took no advantage of the recreation offered them. Probably there was not a 476pair of skates in the province, certainly not unless they had been brought by a foreigner or some student returned from abroad; and Kansu sends no students overseas. Once in a while we saw a group of children timidly sliding on the ice, with the awkwardness and limited range of Mr. Pickwick, the boys often barefoot, the little girls in their bound feet usually only looking wistfully on. Now and again such road as remained jumped by an arched earth bridgelet over a larger irrigation ditch with an axle-cracking jolt, only to wallow on again through ice and half-frozen mud.
Our host was pretty skeptical about whether we could stick to our schedule and reach Ningsia in four days, especially since we started so late. But we had little trouble making it, mainly because the weather had turned really cold. The farmers along the cultivated part of the river valley had just opened the irrigation sluices for the usual autumn flooding, and thankfully, thick ice had formed a day or two before we arrived on all the streams that were created. If that hadn’t happened, it would have taken us at least a week to cover the four hundred and fifty li, as carts coming in from the northeast reported they had to deal with. Even where the so-called road hadn’t been used directly as an irrigation ditch, it twisted and turned in a sincere but mostly ineffective attempt to avoid the barren diked fields that in summer would turn this rich brown valley from sand dunes to river green. Now there were huge skating rinks everywhere, which were even more troublesome when they were half thawed in the early afternoons. By taking a roundabout route, we could have skated much of the way home. But the busy population of the valley didn’t take advantage of the recreation available to them. There was probably not a single pair of skates in the province, unless they were brought by a foreigner or some student returning from abroad; and Kansu doesn’t send students overseas. Occasionally, we saw a group of kids cautiously sliding on the ice, moving with the clumsiness and limited range of Mr. Pickwick, the boys often barefoot while the little girls with bound feet mostly just watched longingly. Now and then, the remaining road would jolt up and over a small earthen bridge across a larger irrigation ditch, causing an axle-cracking bump, only to plunge back into ice and half-frozen mud again.
As if all this were not bad enough, the peasants here and there were felling big trees squarely across the road, and letting travel drag its way around them as best they could, or wait until the trunk had been sawed up. The traveler in rural China is constantly being reminded that he is an unwelcome trespasser on private domain.
As if that wasn’t bad enough, the peasants here and there were cutting down big trees right across the road, forcing travelers to go around them as best they could, or to wait until the trunk was chopped up. The traveler in rural China is always reminded that he is an unwelcome intruder on private property.
Before we left Lanchow we had been warned that the road would “change gage” at Chungwei, and a day or two before we reached it our cartmen came to ask whether they should fit their carts with other axles there. That of course we recognized as a gentle hint for added cumshaw, which we met with innocent faces and the information that they might reduce their carts to one wheel, or increase them to six, with one under each animal, so far as we were concerned, as long as they made the hundred and some li a day which our schedule demanded. One of them, I believe, did change axles, for I recall that it was only the old opium-smoker with the three ill fed animals whose cart could never reach the two ruts at once. These were made by ox-carts peculiar to this region, their two wheels seven feet high and out of all proportion to the little load of chunk coal or bundles of straw which they carried in the small box between them. In places these cumbersome vehicles monopolized the road, but they were always quick to give us the right of way, even to the extent of climbing high banks or backing into ditches from which it could not always have been easy to extricate themselves. This seemed to be as much due to the natural good nature of the rustic drivers as to a certain fear, not so much of foreigners, since in this part of the journey we were usually so muffled as not to be easily recognized as such, as of an expedition whose equipment showed that it was not of local origin. One is constantly getting little hints that the Chinese feeling toward “outside-country” people may almost as easily exist toward those from another province, even another village, as toward those from foreign lands. Sometimes there were whole trains of these ostrich-legged carts 477crawling together across the uneven country—twenty-two of them in the caravan I counted one morning soon after sunrise, and they were carrying, among them all, about what an American farmer would consider one good load of straw. For some reason these contrivances do not shriek their ignorance of axle-grease anything like so loudly as they should, but instead are almost musical. For beneath the axle of each cart hangs a long bell, of scalloped bottom much like those in Chinese temples, with a clapper in the form of a baseball-bat hanging so far down that only its extreme upper edge strikes the bell, while the lower end gathers some of its impetus by bouncing off every hummock in the middle of the “road.”
Before we left Lanchow, we had been warned that the road would “change gauge” at Chungwei. A day or two before we got there, our cart drivers came to ask if they should change the axles on their carts. We recognized this as a subtle hint for extra tips, which we responded to with innocent expressions and the information that they could reduce their carts to one wheel or increase them to six, with one under each animal, as long as they covered the hundred or so li a day that our schedule required. I believe one of them did change axles, because I remember that only the old opium smoker with the three poorly fed animals could never get his cart to align with the two ruts at once. These ruts were made by the ox-carts typical of this region, with two wheels seven feet high, completely out of proportion to the little load of coal chunks or bundles of straw they carried in the small box between them. In some places, these bulky vehicles completely took over the road, but they were always quick to let us pass, even going so far as to climb high banks or back into ditches, which couldn’t have been easy to get out of. This seemed to depend as much on the natural good nature of the rural drivers as on a certain fear—not so much of foreigners, since we usually appeared so bundled up that we weren't easily recognizable, but of an expedition whose gear showed it wasn’t local. You often get little hints that the Chinese attitude toward “outside country” people can easily extend to those from another province or even another village, as well as those from foreign lands. Sometimes there were whole lines of these ostrich-legged carts crawling together across the uneven land—twenty-two of them in a caravan I counted one morning just after sunrise, and they were carrying about what an American farmer would consider one good load of straw. For some reason, these contraptions don’t loudly announce their need for axle grease as much as they should but instead sound almost musical. Beneath the axle of each cart hangs a long bell, with a scalloped bottom like those found in Chinese temples, and a clapper shaped like a baseball bat that hangs so far down that only its upper edge hits the bell, while the lower end picks up some momentum by bouncing off every bump in the middle of the “road.”
Remnants of the Great Wall frequently appeared, and once the road passed through a half-ruined arch of it, one side still covered with the yellow bricks that had formerly made this gateway at least rather an imposing structure. Walnut and Chinese date-trees, willows and pencil-like poplars, all leafless now and showing their big stick nests of crows and magpies like some sort of tumor, clustered by the dozen about the farm-houses and were scattered here and there across the broad valley; but there were by no means enough of them, and the mountains above were totally bare. Many of the high-walled farm-yards looked at some little distance like great feudal castles, but on closer view the walls always proved to be merely of dried mud, with nothing but the usual dreary misery inside. Sometimes two or three score of these family dwellings were in sight at once, their flat roofs invariably piled high with bundles of wheat or straw, with corn and kaoliang stalks; but there was never any suggestion of comfortable prosperity about the interior or the inmates. Children in a single quilted rag, chapped and begrimed beyond belief on faces and hands and from the waist down, still huddled in sunny corners or ran halfheartedly about at some unimaginative game or other. When the weather is quite too bitter to be borne, they squat or lie upon the more or less heated k’angs indoors, to the injury of their growth and health. The American memorial hospital in Lanchow, by the way, treats many cases of cancer of the hips caused by burns from sleeping on these Chinese mud-brick beds.
Remnants of the Great Wall often appeared, and once the road passed through a partially collapsed arch of it, one side still covered with the yellow bricks that once made this gateway a pretty impressive structure. Walnut and Chinese date trees, willows, and tall poplars, all now bare and showing their large stick nests of crows and magpies like some sort of growth, clustered in groups around the farmhouses and were scattered throughout the broad valley; however, there were definitely not enough of them, and the mountains above were completely barren. Many of the high-walled farmyards looked from a distance like grand feudal castles, but up close the walls always turned out to be just dried mud, with nothing but the usual dreary misery inside. Sometimes two or three dozen of these family homes were visible at once, their flat roofs always piled high with bundles of wheat or straw, along with corn and kaoliang stalks; but there was never any hint of comfortable prosperity about the inside or the people living there. Kids in a single tattered quilted rag, chapped and filthy beyond belief on their faces and hands and from the waist down, still huddled in sunny spots or ran half-heartedly around playing some unimaginative game or another. When the weather gets too harsh to endure, they squat or lie on the somewhat heated k’angs indoors, which harms their growth and health. By the way, the American memorial hospital in Lanchow treats many cases of hip cancer caused by burns from sleeping on these Chinese mud-brick beds.
The Chinese persistence in maintaining the highest possible birthrate in proportion to the available nourishment, and the constant subdivisions of agricultural holdings among the multiplying sons of succeeding generations, makes comfortable prosperity out of the question, whatever the fertility of the soil, the industry of the cultivators, or 478even such improvements as those introduced by the sixteenth-century Jesuits. There is much prattle of education as a cure. If by education is understood, among other things, the teaching that it is unwise, not to say criminal, for even the most poverty-stricken, the lame, the halt, and the blind, the mentally defective and the morally perverted, to marry as early and as often as possible, that there shall be no lack of sons to worship at the family mud-heaps, then it is sadly needed. But is it possible to educate, even to the point required for a republican form of government to function at all, a people whose entire time, strength, and energy are constantly required to keep it from slipping over the brink of starvation, even though that education come from some outside source and be widely adjusted to the problem in hand?
The Chinese determination to keep the birthrate as high as possible in relation to the available food, along with the ongoing division of farmland among the growing number of sons in each generation, makes any idea of comfortable prosperity impossible. This holds true no matter how fertile the land is, how hard the farmers work, or even with improvements made by the sixteenth-century Jesuits. There's a lot of talk about education as a solution. If education means teaching that it’s unwise, if not outright wrong, for even the most impoverished individuals—those who are disabled, mentally challenged, or morally corrupt—to marry as often and as soon as possible, so that there are enough sons to carry on at the family’s struggling homesteads, then that education is desperately needed. But can we really educate a people who spend all their time, strength, and energy just trying to avoid starvation, even if that education comes from outside sources and is tailored to address the issue?
At this season there was no work to be done in the fields, and little anywhere else except the gathering of twigs and dried grass for fuel, or roadway droppings for use in the spring. Hence it was naturally the time for the dedicating of temples and worshiping within them. The attitude of the Chinese toward their gods has been excellently summed up as “respectful neglect”; but the treatment accorded them varies greatly in different regions. There is no means of computing how many religious edifices we passed on our way to Lanchow that were falling or had fallen into decay, that had been abandoned entirely except for a beggar or two posing as priests, or had become noisome dens in which thieves divide their booty and vagrants scatter their filth; that the traveler may see in almost any part of China. But the people in this far western valley of the Yellow River were above the average in piety, treating their gods with much more respect than neglect, perhaps because their good offices are so constantly needed to keep back from one side or the other the sand or the water that would mean quick ruin. At any rate, temples, field-shrines, monasteries, and numerous lesser signs of superstitions were so plentiful that the valley might have been mistaken for holy ground; and not only were those in a state of repair by no means common in China, but new ones were growing up. Early one afternoon we began to meet, first men and women, the latter all astride donkeys or packed into carts, in their gayest raiment and an unusually frolicsome mood, and then dozens of youths carrying furled banners; and at length the auditory tortures of Chinese “music” were wafted more and more painfully to our ears as our animals brought us nearer the focal uproar. A bright little temple, newly built back near the foot-hills, across which a sanddune seemed to be creeping, was being dedicated; and every village, 479every cluster of farm compounds for many li roundabout had come in person to bring their respects and to share in whatever benefits might accrue. It was a Taoist temple, according to Chang, but as he said something later about a statue of Buddha, and as a Confucian scroll was plainly in evidence, no doubt the new building conformed to the general Chinese rule of seating the three spiritual leaders of the race harmoniously side by side, with Buddha, the foreigner, courteously granted the central place of honor. The banners, it seemed, gay with colors and Chinese characters, were brought either to bless or to be blessed, after which they were carried back to their respective villages oozing a kind of deputy godliness. Inside, energetic young men were beating drums and shooting firecrackers to scare off devils—the timid Chinese are always exorcising evil spirits, but never tackle the real ones of graft, banditry, filth, the over-production of children, and all their other real ailments. Long after we had turned the ridge that shut off this corner of the valley, the charivari of droning priests and misused instruments drifted to our hearing.
At this time of year, there was no work to be done in the fields, and little anywhere else except collecting twigs and dried grass for fuel, or picking up road debris to use in the spring. So, it was naturally the time for dedicating temples and worshiping there. The Chinese view of their gods has been well summed up as “respectful neglect,” but the way they are treated varies greatly across different regions. There’s no way to count how many religious buildings we passed on our way to Lanchow that were falling apart or had already fallen into disrepair, completely abandoned except for a beggar or two pretending to be priests, or had turned into filthy hideouts where thieves divide their loot and vagrants scatter their waste; the traveler can see this in almost any part of China. However, the people in this far western valley of the Yellow River were more pious than average, showing much more respect for their gods rather than neglect, perhaps because they constantly relied on divine help to keep the sand or water at bay, which could lead to quick disaster. At any rate, temples, field shrines, monasteries, and many signs of local superstitions were so abundant that the valley could easily be mistaken for sacred ground; not only were those in good repair quite rare in China, but new ones were being built. One early afternoon, we began to see first men and women, the latter riding donkeys or packed into carts, all dressed in their brightest clothes and in an unusually festive mood, followed by dozens of young people carrying furled banners; eventually, the loud and somewhat painful sounds of Chinese “music” reached our ears as our animals brought us closer to the source of the noise. A bright little temple, recently built near the foothills, where a sand dune seemed to be creeping, was being dedicated; and every village and cluster of farms for many li around had come in person to pay their respects and to share in whatever benefits might come their way. It was a Taoist temple, according to Chang, but since he later mentioned a statue of Buddha, and a Confucian scroll was clearly visible, it was likely the new building adhered to the common Chinese practice of having the three spiritual leaders of the culture seated harmoniously side by side, with Buddha, the outsider, given the central place of honor. The banners, bright with colors and Chinese characters, were either brought to be blessed or were blessings themselves, then taken back to their respective villages radiating a kind of delegated holiness. Inside, energetic young men were beating drums and setting off firecrackers to scare away evil spirits—the timid Chinese are always trying to exorcise evil spirits, but never confront the real issues of corruption, banditry, filth, overpopulation, and all their other actual problems. Long after we had turned the ridge that blocked off this part of the valley, the sounds of chanting priests and misused instruments continued to drift into our hearing.
The days had grown so short that we were forced to use both ends of the nights to piece them out. But for a week or more this was no great hardship, as a brilliant moon lighted both morning and evening and gave the landscape touches that were unknown to it by day. Under the rising or the setting sun the wrinkled ranges of rich-brown mountains wrapped the horizon in velvets of constantly varying shades. I recall particularly the heaped-up mass just across the river from an unusually picturesque walled town which we came upon just as the day was fading out, and the tint of old red wine, blending momentarily until it became the purple of the grape itself, seemed a masterpiece which even nature seldom attains. But the town, though it awakened again that hope of the romantic within its walls, was so miserable a den of broken stone “lions” and ruined former grandeur, of comfortless people staring like monkeys at merely strolling strangers, that we were only too glad to accept the hospitality of an inn outside the walls.
The days had gotten so short that we had to use both ends of the night to make them last. But for a week or so, this wasn’t too hard, as a bright moon lit up both morning and evening, giving the landscape touches that it didn’t have during the day. Under the rising or setting sun, the rugged ranges of rich brown mountains wrapped the horizon in velvets of constantly changing shades. I particularly remember the piled-up mass right across the river from a uniquely picturesque walled town we stumbled upon just as the day was fading, and the color of old red wine, blending momentarily until it became the purple of the grape itself, looked like a masterpiece that even nature rarely achieves. But the town, while it reignited that sense of romance within its walls, was such a miserable den of broken stone “lions” and ruined former splendor, with uncomfortable people staring like monkeys at merely passing strangers, that we were more than happy to accept the hospitality of an inn outside the walls.
Beyond this there lay forty li of rolling half sand, utterly uninhabited, then another broad fertile valley with the same oversupply of big mud bricks and Jesuit irrigation works, or more modern but less effective imitations of them. Here there were even more skating-rinks, and incredible clouds of blue pigeons, from which the major easily gathered all the fowl we needed to vary our diet to the end 480of the trip, though much to the dismay of Chang, who whispered in my ear the horrible information that “they home-side pigeon.” The li suddenly grew longer, as they have a habit of doing unexpectedly, so that it was well after dark when we reached Yeh-shih-pu, a “Hwei-Hwei” town where we could not even have our own bacon for breakfast, because the innkeeper would not admit our cook to his kitchen until he had promised to bear in mind his religious scruples. Such mishaps, added to the fact that every article of food containing the slightest moisture was habitually frozen solid, made our repasts less Cleopatran than they might have been. Cold chicken or pigeon with little sheets of ice dropping from between the muscles as the famished traveler tears them apart may not be so bad, but the big Lanchow pears gained nothing by coming to the table as hard as stones, and certainly there is no call to praise the taste of frozen hard-boiled eggs, if they have any. Yet most such dainties, the pears in particular, were far worse if they were thawed out before serving.
Beyond this, there were forty li of rolling, half-sandy land, completely uninhabited, followed by another wide, fertile valley filled with an abundance of large mud bricks and Jesuit irrigation works, along with more modern but less effective copies of them. Here, there were even more skating rinks and amazing flocks of blue pigeons, from which the major easily gathered all the birds we needed to add variety to our diet for the rest of the trip, although this greatly upset Chang, who whispered in my ear the troubling news that “they’re homing pigeons.” The li suddenly felt longer, which often happens unexpectedly, so we arrived at Yeh-shih-pu after dark, a “Hwei-Hwei” town where we couldn’t even have our own bacon for breakfast because the innkeeper wouldn’t allow our cook into his kitchen until he promised to respect his religious beliefs. Such mishaps, combined with the fact that every food item with even a hint of moisture was usually frozen solid, made our meals less opulent than they could have been. Cold chicken or pigeon, with little sheets of ice falling from between the muscles as the hungry traveler tore them apart, might not be so bad, but the large Lanchow pears didn’t improve by arriving at the table as hard as rocks, and there’s definitely no reason to praise the taste of frozen hard-boiled eggs, if they have any at all. However, most of these treats, especially the pears, were much worse if thawed out before serving.
It seemed almost summer again on the brilliant afternoon without wind when an almost good road picked us up and staggered erratically toward Ningsia. Perhaps there was some slight excuse for its vagaries, for much of the plain was covered with ice-fields thickly grown with tall reeds, which were being gathered and carried to town on every type of conveyance from coolie shoulders to giant-wheeled ox-carts. Among the constant processions of travelers in both directions Mohammedans appeared to be in the majority, with white felt skullcaps, or dirty “Turkish” towels worn like turbans, greatly predominating over any other form of head-gear. From a distance the city wall seemed merely a glorified example of those about farm compounds; and high above it, high in fact above the city gates, towered two pagodas against the distant horizon of the inevitable crumpled range of low mountains or high hills, hazy with shade along the base, bright with a slight fall of snow along the top, where the low winter sun could still strike them.
It felt almost like summer again on that bright, windless afternoon when a somewhat decent road picked us up and jostled us erratically toward Ningsia. There might’ve been a slight reason for its quirks, as much of the plain was covered with icy fields densely populated with tall reeds, which were being harvested and transported to town on all sorts of vehicles, from coolies carrying loads on their shoulders to large ox-drawn carts. Among the steady streams of travelers going both ways, Muslims seemed to be the majority, with white felt skullcaps or dirty “Turkish” towels worn like turbans noticeably outnumbering any other types of headwear. From a distance, the city wall looked like an upgraded version of those around farm compounds; and towering above it, even higher than the city gates, were two pagodas against the far-off backdrop of the inevitable, crumpled range of low mountains or high hills, hazy with shade at the bottom and bright with a light dusting of snow on top, where the low winter sun could still reach them.

The Chinese protect their boys from evil spirits (the girls do not matter) by having a chain and padlock put about their necks at some religious ceremony, which deceives the spirits into believing that they belong to the temple. Earlaps embroidered in gay colors are widely used in Kansu in winter
The Chinese protect their boys from evil spirits (girls aren't considered) by putting a chain and padlock around their necks during a religious ceremony, which tricks the spirits into thinking they belong to the temple. Colorfully embroidered earflaps are commonly worn in Kansu during winter.

Many of the faces seen in western China hardly seem Chinese
Many of the faces in western China hardly look Chinese.

A dead man on the way to his ancestral home for burial, a trip that may last for weeks. Over the heavy unpainted wooden coffin were brown bags of fodder for the animals, surmounted by the inevitable rooster
A dead man on his way to his family home for burial, a journey that could take weeks. On top of the heavy unpainted wooden coffin were brown bags of feed for the animals, topped with the ever-present rooster.

Our party on the return from Lanchow—the major and myself flanked by our “boys” and cook respectively, these in turn by the two cart-drivers, with our alleged mafu, or groom for our riding animals, at the right
Our party on the way back from Lanchow—the major and I surrounded by our “crew” and cook, followed by the two cart drivers, with our supposed mafu, or groom for our riding animals, on the right.
481There was nothing really unusual about Ningsia, except perhaps its distance from any other city. The only foreigners we found there—a Scandinavian lady and a Belgian priest who maintained one of the mightiest beards in captivity, bitterly rival propagandists of Christianity—both assured us that the people of Ningsia were a “bad lot,” but we had no personal experiences to bear out the statement. Of the forty-five thousand reputed to dwell within the walls, a generous third were Moslems, as in Kansu as a whole, but as usual they were credited with a more industrious, aggressive character than the others, and a more united front in spite of internal disagreements. The Mohammedan general, who ruled the place, nephew of the powerful Moslem Ma Fu-hsiang, looked and acted quite like any other Chinese official, perhaps because the percentage of Moslem blood that runs in his veins is the same as the proportion of people of that faith in the city and the province. His yamen and his extensive barracks were noticeably spick and span for China, and his soldiers seemed to be well drilled and disciplined, thanks perhaps to the Russian officer or two who were giving the general the benefit of their training. But there was much recent building all about the town; even two elaborate wooden p’ai-lous were in course of construction. These fantastic memorial street arches are without number in China, but it is a rare experience to see new ones under construction, or to find old ones undergoing repairs, for that matter.
481There was nothing particularly unusual about Ningsia, except maybe its distance from any other city. The only foreigners we encountered there—a Scandinavian woman and a Belgian priest with one of the most impressive beards around, both passionate defenders of Christianity—told us that the people of Ningsia were a “bad lot,” but we had no personal experiences to support that claim. Of the forty-five thousand people said to live within the city walls, about a third were Muslims, similar to the broader Kansu region, but as usual, they were thought to have a more industrious and aggressive nature than the others, presenting a more united front despite their internal disagreements. The Muslim general, who governed the area, was the nephew of the influential Muslim Ma Fu-hsiang, and he looked and behaved like any other Chinese official, perhaps because the percentage of Muslim ancestry in him matched the proportion of that faith within the city and province. His yamen and his large barracks were notably clean for China, and his soldiers seemed well-trained and disciplined, likely due to the Russian officers providing him with their expertise. There was also a lot of new construction around the town; even two grand wooden p’ai-lous were being built. These impressive memorial street arches are found all over China, but it’s rare to see new ones being constructed or even older ones being repaired, for that matter.
Chinese, Manchus, Mongols, “and all the thieves and rascals from four directions,” to quote the hirsute Belgian, make up the rest of the population. Mutton-shops and sheepskins were naturally in considerable evidence, though there was no lack of black pigs to be seen from the wall. A slight yet conspicuous detail that we had not seen elsewhere was slats or small poles set upright at close intervals in front of many business houses, evidently as a protection against thieves, which would bear out, I suppose, the assertion as to the make-up of the population. “Lanchow coppers” had quickly died out and were virtually forgotten by the time we reached Ningsia, though in theory its ruler was subordinate to the provincial Tuchun; and “cash” was again everywhere in evidence. A half-circuit of the city wall showed much vacant space, and even some farming, within it. Of the two pagodas standing like lighthouses above the surrounding country, one proved to be far outside the city, toward the wrinkled mountain range beyond which lies the ancient capital of Ala-shan. Many-sided but plain-faced, certainly of no great age, they seemed as high as the Washington Monument, though this may have been an exaggeration of the imagination, and beneath each of them stood a temple covering a great reclining Buddha.
Chinese, Manchus, Mongols, “and all the thieves and rascals from four directions,” as the hairy Belgian put it, make up the rest of the population. Mutton shops and sheepskins were obviously common, although there were also plenty of black pigs visible from the wall. A small yet noticeable detail that we hadn’t seen elsewhere was the vertical slats or small poles set up close together in front of many businesses, clearly intended as protection against thieves, which supports the claim about the population's makeup. “Lanchow coppers” had quickly disappeared and were almost forgotten by the time we got to Ningsia, although theoretically its ruler was still under the provincial Tuchun; and “cash” was once again everywhere. A half-loop around the city wall revealed a lot of empty space and even some farming within it. Of the two pagodas standing like lighthouses above the surrounding area, one turned out to be well outside the city, towards the rugged mountain range beyond which lies the ancient capital of Ala-shan. Multifaceted but plain-looking, certainly not very old, they appeared to be as tall as the Washington Monument, though this might have been a stretch of the imagination, and beneath each of them stood a temple housing a large reclining Buddha.
We spent a whole day in Ningsia, the only one without travel between Lanchow and Peking, and could not see how we should have gained much by staying longer—unless perhaps for years, so that to our superficial impression would be added the detailed experience of 482the “old-timer.” Nor was our attention entirely given to mere sight-seeing and calls of respect. There were our three horses to be shod—though the timid Chinese blacksmiths who wander the streets, shop in hand, refuse to risk their precious lives at the rear end of the most harmless of such animals, even though they are tied hand and foot to stout stanchions. Any American worth his salt at the same trade would shoe any quadruped in China single-handed, behind as well as before, and he certainly would not leave the long, all but untrimmed hoofs which help to make the Chinese pony famous for stumbling, though he would of course throw the first hammer within reach at the man who proposed to pay him only twice as much for one shoe as his Chinese colleague gets for four. Then there was the task of getting rid of our opium-smoking driver without either violently breaking our contract with him or showing undue harshness. For, after all, he had kept up with the other cartman, who was as faultless a driver as one could ask for; and there had been times when his silly grin of doped contentment with life made up somewhat for the sogginess of his intellect during most of the journey. But we were tired of seeing his shaft-horse do all the work, while the two starved mules out in front only now and then staggered taut their rope traces; we were tired of furnishing opium pills for eating and smoking with money that should have been spent in food for beast and man; and we were particularly weary of wondering every time we got out of sight of our caravan whether the “old man” and his miserable animals had at last failed us.
We spent an entire day in Ningsia, the only one without traveling between Lanchow and Peking, and we couldn't see how we would have gained much by staying longer—unless maybe for years, so that our initial impressions would be deepened by the detailed experiences of the “old-timer.” Our focus wasn't solely on sightseeing and making polite visits. We had our three horses that needed shoeing—though the timid Chinese blacksmiths roaming the streets with their tools refused to risk their lives at the rear end of even the tamest of these animals, even though they were securely tied to strong posts. Any American worth his salt in the same trade would handle any horse in China by himself, both front and back, and he definitely wouldn't leave the long, nearly untrimmed hooves that make the Chinese pony notorious for stumbling. Of course, he would throw the first hammer within reach at anyone who suggested paying him only twice as much for one shoe as his Chinese counterpart makes for four. Then there was the challenge of getting rid of our opium-smoking driver without either breaking our contract with him or being too harsh. After all, he had kept pace with the other cart driver, who was as perfect a driver as you could ask for; and there were times when his ridiculous grin of blissful contentment made up a bit for the dullness of his mind for most of the trip. But we were fed up with seeing his shaft-horse do all the work while the two starved mules in front only occasionally strained at their ropes; we were tired of using our money meant for food for ourselves and our animals to buy opium pills for him to eat and smoke; and we were particularly weary of wondering every time we lost sight of our caravan whether the “old man” and his miserable animals had finally let us down.
When it came to a showdown his elimination proved simple and easy. Perhaps the pace of the past ten days had cured him of any desire to keep it up for twelve or thirteen more, over worse going. He had told Chang one night that he might shoot him if he wished, but that he could not go a step farther, though this had proved to be a mere figure of speech. Perhaps there were other arguments, of a monetary nature, such as a commission for selling his part of the contract to some one else; for even jobs are bought and sold in China. But of this we knew nothing, and cared less. For he agreed without argument to resign in favor of the new cartman whom his companion brought in, and thanked us profusely for the cumshaw which no doubt quickly went up in fumes.
When it came down to a showdown, getting rid of him was simple and easy. Maybe the pace of the last ten days had burned him out, leaving him not wanting to carry on for another twelve or thirteen days, especially in worse conditions. He had told Chang one night that he might shoot him if he wanted, but that he couldn't go any further, although that turned out to be just talk. Maybe there were other reasons, like money-related ones, such as a fee for selling his part of the contract to someone else; after all, jobs can be bought and sold in China. But we didn't know anything about that and cared even less. He agreed without any argument to step aside for the new cartman his companion brought in and thanked us a lot for the cumshaw, which no doubt quickly disappeared into thin air.
The new driver, like the one that was left, called our destination home, and had been waiting for sixteen days for a paying chance to return there. Except for a slightly less cheery temperament, he was 483no less excellent a cartman than the other, though only a hired driver; while his companion owned not merely his outfit but an inn at the end of our trail. In the company of such fellows as these, one is struck with the sturdiness of the Chinese character. All about them were moral pitfalls, of which their opium-aged colleague was a striking example. They, too, and millions more like them, could easily get the poppy’s deadly juice and smoke themselves away from their at best dismal reality into the land of beautiful dreams; in fact, most of those whose duty it should be to remove this particular temptation do all they can, short of reducing their own “squeeze” from it, to make the wicked stuff available; yet they had never succumbed to it. Nor is the sturdiness of the Chinese coolie confined to the negative virtues. There was Chang, for instance, born a tiller of the soil in cruelly crowded Shantung, with a bare three years’ elementary schooling, who had taught himself to read, and to write a goodly number of characters, who in a few years as a foreign servant had acquired powers that to his simple parents probably seemed supernatural, who in his two months with us had so improved in poise and the ability to command the respect of his fellow-men that a trained scholar of many generations of similar experiences could scarcely have outdone him, either in deportment or the actual business in hand, when he was called upon to act as interpreter between us and the Mohammedan general, the very thought of meeting whom face to face would probably have set him trembling a few years before. Best of all, he had not let his rise in the world make him ashamed to do the most menial task that came to hand, on the ground that he was no longer a coolie, which is the stumbling-block over which rising young China is so apt to come a cropper. Chang and our cart-drivers were, of course, only individual instances; but I like to think of them—believe, in fact, that I can rightly think of them—as typical of millions of their class, as proofs that, given anything like a decent opportunity, the Chinese coolie can rise to a genuinely higher plane just as well as the American farmer can. If such is the case, it is not too much to hope that China may in time, even though it be centuries distant, advance to real democracy, that the name “republic” by which she now styles herself may some day become a reality and not merely a mockery and a catchword.
The new driver, like the one who was left behind, called our destination home and had been waiting for sixteen days for a paying ride back there. Aside from being a little less cheerful, he was just as skilled a cart driver as the other, even though he was only a hired driver; his companion owned not only his vehicle but also an inn at the end of our journey. Being around people like them makes you appreciate the resilience of the Chinese character. All around them were moral traps, of which their opium-addicted colleague was a clear example. They, along with millions like them, could easily get the deadly substance from poppies and smoke their way out of their often miserable reality into a world of beautiful dreams; in fact, most of those who should be working to eliminate this temptation do everything they can, short of cutting into their own profits, to make the harmful substance available; yet they had never given in to it. The strength of the Chinese coolie isn’t just about avoiding vices. Take Chang, for example, born to be a farmer in overcrowded Shantung, with just three years of elementary education, who taught himself to read and write a good number of characters, and who, in just a few years as a foreign servant, gained skills that must have seemed supernatural to his simple parents. In his two months with us, he had improved so much in confidence and in earning the respect of others that a well-trained scholar with generations of similar experience could hardly have done better than him, both in demeanor and in the actual tasks at hand when he was called to interpret between us and the Mohammedan general, whose mere presence would have likely made him tremble a few years earlier. Best of all, he didn’t let his rise in status make him ashamed to do any menial task that came his way, thinking he was no longer a coolie, which is often the stumbling block for rising young people in China. Chang and our cart drivers were, of course, just individual examples; but I like to think of them—believe, in fact, that I can correctly see them—as typical of millions in their class, as evidence that, given a fair opportunity, the Chinese coolie can rise to a genuinely higher level just as well as the American farmer can. If that’s true, it’s not too much to hope that China may eventually, even if it takes centuries, progress to true democracy, so that the name “republic,” which she currently uses, may one day become a reality and not just a mockery or a slogan.
But to come back to Ningsia, which is still a long way from democracy of even the present imperfect type. Yet more important than matters of horseshoeing and the moral repair of our caravan was the 484question of a bath, which was eventually settled more or less in our favor by the placing of two large tin cans of warm water in our respective rooms. These were in Ningsia’s best hotel; in fact, the best hotel we graced during all our western journey, though that still does not bring it to the forefront of the world’s hostelries. Probably the main reason for its preëminence was the simple fact that it was quite new, and hence had never had an opportunity to grow filthy and unrepaired. Perhaps the Mohammedan proprietor—or should I call him “manager,” since it was several times confided to us that the real owner was Ningsia’s Moslem general?—had something to do with it, for he was so incessantly on the job that we could not push aside the cloth door across the street portal without finding him bowing us his respects behind it, though always without any violation of his Islamite dignity and certainly with no acknowledgment of inferiority. We might have taken only one of the identical rooms at either end of the unoccupied hall backing the long narrow courtyard, but one of the advantages of roughing it is that whenever the least possible excuse offers one can be extravagant without a twinge of conscience.
But to return to Ningsia, which is still far from even the current imperfect form of democracy. Yet more important than our horseshoeing and the moral repair of our caravan was the issue of a bath, which was ultimately resolved more or less in our favor by the placement of two large tin cans of warm water in our respective rooms. These were in Ningsia’s best hotel; in fact, the best hotel we stayed at during our whole western journey, though that still doesn't put it among the world’s top accommodations. The main reason for its superiority was probably just that it was quite new, and therefore had never had a chance to become dirty and neglected. Perhaps the Muslim proprietor—or should I call him “manager,” since we were told several times that the real owner was Ningsia’s Muslim general?—played a role in this, because he was so consistently on duty that we could not push aside the cloth door at the street entrance without finding him bowing to us behind it, always maintaining his Islamic dignity and certainly with no hint of inferiority. We could have taken just one of the identical rooms at either end of the empty hall behind the long narrow courtyard, but one of the perks of roughing it is that whenever the slightest excuse presents itself, you can indulge without any guilt.
The most remarkable feature, perhaps, about the establishment was that it had no earth floors, but that courtyard, hall, and even our rooms were paved in brick. The k’angs were so new that their straw mats were almost inviting; the flue was of some modern improved type which actually gave out more heat than smoke and there was a little baked-mud coal-stove in addition. This detail was important, for the almost summer weather in which we had reached the city had modified the instant we passed through its gate and had disappeared entirely by sunset. I trust it will not unduly shock Western readers to be told that an ox-cart-load of the splendid anthracite coal in huge lumps which is so plentiful in northwestern China sold in this region for about an American dollar, for in that case I should not even dare to mention another kind of coal, evidently of an unusually oily composition, which may be lighted with a match and burns anywhere—on the brick or earth floor, in shallow pans built for that purpose, in an old wash-basin—without smoke enough to be worth mentioning and with a sturdy heat that makes a little of it highly effective. But mankind is never satisfied with his blessings; even missionaries complained that in the good old days a cart-load of coal cost less than half what the wicked profiteers owning ox-carts were now demanding.
The most notable thing about the place was that it had no dirt floors; instead, the courtyard, hall, and even our rooms were all paved with brick. The k’angs were brand new, and their straw mats were almost inviting; the flue was a modern, upgraded design that actually produced more heat than smoke, and there was a small baked-mud coal stove as well. This was important because the almost summer-like weather we experienced when we first arrived in the city changed the moment we went through its gate and completely disappeared by sunset. I hope it won’t overly surprise Western readers to learn that a load of excellent anthracite coal in large chunks, which is abundant in northwestern China, sold in this area for about an American dollar. If that shocks you, I wouldn’t even want to mention another type of coal, which is unusually oily, can be ignited with a match, and burns almost anywhere—on the brick or dirt floor, in shallow pans made for it, or even in an old washbasin—without producing enough smoke to notice and providing a solid heat that makes a little go a long way. But people are never satisfied with what they have; even missionaries complained that in the good old days, a cartload of coal cost less than half of what the unscrupulous profiteers with ox carts were charging now.
CHAPTER XXVI
CLOSING THE LOOP
We might as well have indulged in an extra nap next morning instead of being as exacting as usual on the hour of departure, for the city gate was still closed when we reached it. The rooster that all Chinese inns maintain for the benefit of their watchless clients had already “sung”; but on those moonlight mornings such a timepiece could easily be regarded as out of order, which is no doubt the reason we not only had to waken the soldiers in the little guard-house but that there was a further delay of nearly half an hour while one of them wandered away into the city to get the key, evidently ensconced under the pillow of some other guardian of Ningsia’s safety. All we lacked to make the third act of “La Bohème” complete was a light fall of snow and a more Parisian atmosphere, for not only was there a brazier over which the soldiers warmed their hands, and a collection of countrymen with produce waiting to enter as soon as the gate was opened, but we had, though we did not then suspect it, our Mimi with us.
We might as well have taken an extra nap the next morning instead of being as strict as usual about our departure time, because the city gate was still closed when we got there. The rooster that all Chinese inns keep for the benefit of their clients without watches had already crowed, but on those moonlit mornings, such a timekeeper could easily be seen as faulty. That’s probably why we not only had to wake up the soldiers in the little guardhouse but also faced an additional delay of nearly half an hour while one of them went into the city to retrieve the key, which was clearly tucked under the pillow of some other guardian of Ningsia’s safety. All we needed to make the third act of “La Bohème” complete was a light snowfall and a more Parisian vibe, because not only was there a brazier for the soldiers to warm their hands, and a group of farmers with produce waiting to get in as soon as the gate opened, but we also had, although we didn’t know it at the time, our Mimi with us.
Our new cartman, it seemed, had come from Paotou accompanied by another cart, and its driver had already found a fare for the return trip when this expedition and ours were thrown together in the back yard of the Moslem inn. In fact, the other might have started a week before had his client not been afraid to travel alone through a region with a bad reputation for bandits and thieves. Wholly unknown to us, therefore, we were to constitute the escort of this timid person, of whose existence we were still completely ignorant. We did notice that a third cart left the inn close behind us, and that it trailed us all the way to the gate, but there was nothing suspicious in some other traveler’s happening to pick the same ill chosen hour of departure as we, nor in his setting out in the same direction. Our first hint that something might be suspected was the sight of the third cart still following on our heels through the gate, as if it belonged to our party and was therefore free from paying the twenty coppers required of every native conveyance.
Our new cart driver seemed to have come from Paotou with another cart, and that driver had already found a fare for the return trip when our expedition and theirs ended up together in the backyard of the Muslim inn. In fact, the other driver might have left a week earlier if his client hadn't been scared to travel alone through an area known for bandits and thieves. Unbeknownst to us, we were set to be the escort for this timid person, whose presence we were still completely unaware of. We did notice that a third cart left the inn right behind us and followed us all the way to the gate, but there was nothing suspicious about another traveler picking the same unfortunate hour to leave or heading in the same direction. Our first clue that something might be off was seeing the third cart still tailing us through the gate as if it belonged to our group and was therefore exempt from paying the twenty coppers required of every native vehicle.
486All that morning it stuck to us across a great plain with much ice, here and there covered with tall reeds. There was no doubt that it had invited itself to join us; the only questions remaining were its destination and who it was that lay ensconced behind its heavy blue cloth front door. These mysteries were solved at the noonday halt. A well dressed boy had already appeared on the front platform beside the driver, and the instant the cart drew up in the yard of the inn we had chosen out stepped a Chinese lady still well short of the age when scandal ceases to wag its tongues about members of the attractive sex. She was the wife of a silk merchant of Paotou, we gathered in a roundabout way; the youth was her nephew or something of the sort; and she had evidently joined us for the whole fortnight that remained of our journey.
486All that morning, it followed us across a vast icy plain, dotted with tall reeds here and there. There was no doubt it had decided to join us; the only questions left were where it was headed and who was hidden behind its heavy blue cloth front door. We figured out these mysteries during the midday break. A well-dressed boy had already appeared on the front platform next to the driver, and as soon as the cart pulled up in the yard of the inn we had chosen, a Chinese lady stepped out, still young enough that gossip about attractive women was alive and well. We gathered in a roundabout way that she was the wife of a silk merchant from Paotou; the young man was her nephew or something along those lines; and it was clear she intended to travel with us for the remaining two weeks of our journey.
We both admit that we are not utterly devoid of sympathy or chivalry, but somehow it did strike us that the lady might have gone to the formality of letting us know, at least indirectly, that she was going to grace our expedition. But they do things differently in China; and perhaps this was a less scandalous way than frankly to make the acquaintance of unrelated male traveling companions.
We both agree that we're not completely lacking in sympathy or chivalry, but it did occur to us that the lady could have formally informed us, even indirectly, that she was planning to join our trip. But things are different in China; and maybe this was a less controversial way to get to know unrelated male travel companions.
The three carts never once broke ranks that afternoon as we plodded on across the plain, with another great lighthouse pagoda and more ox-cart caravans with seven-foot wheels. The whole Yellow River valley seemed to have been flooded a bare week ahead of us, and while this no doubt would be repaid many fold in the spring, it would have made traveling a sad experience if everything had not been frozen over. As it was, our cartmen did much wandering in the rather vain hope of avoiding icy roads, for, old as she is, China apparently has never learned to put calks on her horseshoes. We had a hundred li to make that day, which did not seem difficult in the light of the fact that we had once covered a hundred and forty on this leg of the journey, but the li were stretching perceptibly, and what with the zigzagging and the delay at the city gate we were still well short of our goal when night fell. The moon was rising later now, so that we had to feel our way across the plain in utter darkness, for even by day the “road” was often only faintly marked. The stillness of this great valley at night was impressive—and fortunate, for the only thing to guide us was the sound of our carts ahead, silent underfoot but with a constant thumping of the heavy wheels on the loosely fitting axles.
The three carts never broke ranks that afternoon as we trudged across the plain, passing another towering lighthouse pagoda and more ox-cart caravans with seven-foot wheels. The entire Yellow River valley seemed to have been flooded just a week before our arrival, and while this would surely pay off many times in the spring, it would have made traveling a miserable experience if everything hadn't been frozen. As it was, our cart drivers wandered around in the fruitless hope of avoiding icy roads, since, despite being old, China still apparently hasn't learned to put calks on horseshoes. We had a hundred li to cover that day, which didn’t seem tough considering we had once managed a hundred and forty on this leg of the trip, but the li felt like they were stretching, and with all the zigzagging and delays at the city gate, we were still far from our goal when night fell. The moon was rising later now, so we had to feel our way across the plain in complete darkness, as even during the day the “road” was often just barely marked. The stillness of this vast valley at night was striking—and fortunate, since the only thing guiding us was the sound of our carts ahead, silent underfoot but with the constant thumping of the heavy wheels on the loosely fitting axles.
At that the carts got out of our hearing, and for a long time we rode on at random, keeping as straightforward a course as possible, 487until finally we were lucky enough to see rising close before us out of the night an imposing gateway of the walled town of Ping-lo. Our chief impression of this is that if it had as much paving as it has ornamental street arches there would be fewer streets to wade and stumble through, hence less temptation to curse the stupidity of such inhabitants as were faintly visible for not being able to put us on the track of our carts. We found our way at last, however, to the inn-yard where they were already unhitched—to discover that the trousered lady had followed us even there. It had not mattered so much at the midday halt, but with several inns to choose from we were tempted to protest when she clung to us even by night, taking indeed the very next room to us, with a thin mud wall between. We did protest, in fact, though for other reasons than any real fear of being “compromised,” of hearing Peking whisper over its bridge-tables and its cocktails at the club, “What’s this about the major and that fellow bringing a Chinese girl along with them, eh?” While we never got a monosyllable out of her ourselves, the lady had in a high degree that fault more or less unjustly charged against all her sex; and as she slept most of the day, after the fashion of Chinese travelers, to whom the horrors of a “Peking cart” seem to be like the rocking of a cradle, it was natural that she needed to relieve herself by chattering all night, with the youth or innkeepers’ wives as the not unwilling listeners. Now, the Chinese language is anything but musical, and the voices of Chinese women are evidently trained to sound as much as possible like the tightening brakes of a freight-train on a swift down grade, so that even in our most charitable moods we could scarcely have lain silently bewailing the departure of our hitherto splendid slumber for more than the two or three hours we did without attempting to do something about it. The vigorous application of a boot-heel to the mud partition, and a few terse remarks that were probably none the less clear for being only partly couched in Chinese, had a desirable effect, which was made more or less permanent by having Chang explain next day to the third driver, who passed the information on through the youth to the feminine part of our aggregation, certain rules of conduct that were essential to a continued membership in it.
At that, the carts moved out of earshot, and we rode on aimlessly for a long time, trying to stay on a straightforward path, 487 until we finally spotted, rising from the night, an impressive gateway to the walled town of Ping-lo. Our main impression was that if the town had as much pavement as it had decorative street arches, there would be fewer streets to wade through, making it less tempting to curse the ignorance of the townspeople who were only faintly visible and couldn’t guide us to our carts. Eventually, we found our way to the inn-yard where the carts had already been unhitched—only to realize that the woman in trousers had followed us there as well. It hadn’t been too much of a problem at the midday break, but with several inns available, we felt compelled to object when she stayed close to us at night, even taking the room right next to ours, separated by a thin mud wall. We did raise our objections, although not due to any real concern about being “compromised,” fearing whispers in Peking over bridge games and cocktails at the club: “What’s this about the major and that guy bringing a Chinese girl along, huh?” While we never got a word out of her, she had the high tendency of that fault often unfairly assigned to all women; and since she slept most of the day, like many Chinese travelers who seem to find riding in a “Peking cart” as soothing as a baby’s cradle, it was only natural she needed to chat all night with the youth or the innkeepers’ wives, who were more than willing listeners. Now, Chinese is not a melodious language, and Chinese women's voices seem to be trained to sound as much like the screeching brakes of a freight train going downhill as possible, so even in our most charitable moments, we could hardly lie silently lamenting the loss of our previously blissful sleep for more than a couple of hours without trying to do something about it. A firm kick to the mud wall and a few sharp comments, clear enough even though they were only partially in Chinese, produced a satisfactory result that was reinforced the next day when Chang explained to the third driver, who then relayed the information through the youth to the women in our group, some necessary rules for staying in the group.
In the middle of the next afternoon irrigation suddenly ended, and a stony, barren plain, rising into foot-hills on the left, grew up ahead. Some time during the following day we crossed the unmarked boundary between Kansu and Inner Mongolia and left the Mohammedan province behind. From the town where we spent one of those nights 488there is a short cut through the Ordos that takes but half the time required to follow clear around the right-angled bend of the Yellow River, but even if one is sure of being able to cross the river at both ends of that trail there is nothing but an uninhabited desert wilderness between, where a single well is worthy a name on the map, and which is practicable only to camel-caravans. Thus there was nothing to do but let the Hoang Ho force us farther and farther westward, though our goal lay to the east, now by stony roads, now through half-days of the drifted sand of genuine deserts, or by river bars spreading out in great masses of ice which it was not always possible to pass without making a great detour. There was a very good reason why we could not float down the Yellow River, or skate or ice-boat either, for not only was it often frozen over completely for long distances but the ice lay in broken chunks a foot or two thick and so packed together that they sometimes were piled high up on the shore. There were days during which we never sighted the river, though we were always following it; at other times we spent midday or night right on its banks, with it the only water available.
In the middle of the next afternoon, irrigation suddenly stopped, and a rocky, barren plain, rising into foothills on the left, appeared ahead. Sometime the following day, we crossed the unmarked boundary between Kansu and Inner Mongolia and left the Muslim province behind. From the town where we spent one of those nights, 488 there is a shortcut through the Ordos that takes only half the time needed to go around the sharp bend of the Yellow River. But even if you're sure you can cross the river at both ends of that trail, there’s nothing but an empty desert wilderness in between, where a single well is worthy of a name on the map, and it's only passable for camel caravans. So, we had no choice but to let the Hoang Ho take us farther west, even though our goal was to the east, now along rocky roads, now through half-days of drifting sand in real deserts, or by riverbanks spreading out in large masses of ice that weren’t always possible to navigate without a major detour. There was a very good reason why we couldn’t float down the Yellow River, skate, or ice-boat either: it was often completely frozen over for long stretches, and the ice was in broken chunks a foot or two thick, sometimes piled high on the shore. There were days when we never saw the river, even though we were always following it; at other times, we spent midday or night right on its banks, with it being the only available water.
Such a place was the one we reached unusually early one afternoon. In spite of its three-barrel name of Hou-gway-tze it consisted of a single cluster of mud buildings, which took all prizes for their filthy condition. Moreover, every room was packed with more coolies than could crowd together on the k’angs, and several of them were suffering from what might easily have been malignant diseases or dangerous illnesses. It looked as if we would have to commandeer one room by driving the coolies out of it—and then take our lady in with us. But General Ma, the uncle, Mohammedan ruler of all this western district, had very recently built a new inn, with high crenelated walls of bright yellow mud and a generally inviting appearance, a furlong or two beyond the unspeakable hovels that had evidently for centuries been the only housing for travelers at this point. Our cartmen seemed to take it for granted that we would not be admitted to the new compound, for it was not only strictly Mohammedan but had really been built to house soldiers. It took Chang less than five minutes, however, to assure the man in charge that we would not cook or eat pork on the premises, and to talk a soldier out of the only one of the rooms that did not have its k’ang crowded. Evidently the hope of being given a few coppers in the morning, in which he was, of course, not disappointed, or the privilege, unless he was Mohammedan, of disposing of some of the scraps left over from our meals and perhaps of getting 489an empty tin can or two was reward enough for him. Where our feminine companion spent the night is still a mystery, for though she promptly followed us to the new inn we saw nothing of her after her descent from the cart until she crawled out of it again the next noon fifty li farther on.
Such a place was where we arrived unusually early one afternoon. Despite its three-barrel name, Hou-gway-tze, it was just a small group of mud buildings that were in terrible shape. Every room was crammed with more laborers than could fit on the k’angs, and several of them appeared to be suffering from what could easily have been serious illnesses or dangerous diseases. It seemed like we would have to take over one room by pushing the laborers out—and then bring our lady in with us. But General Ma, the uncle, a Muslim leader of this western region, had recently built a new inn, with high, crenelated walls made of bright yellow mud and a generally appealing look, about a quarter of a mile past the disgusting shanties that had clearly served as the only accommodation for travelers for centuries. Our cart drivers seemed to assume we wouldn’t be allowed into the new place, as it was strictly Muslim and was actually built to accommodate soldiers. However, it took Chang less than five minutes to convince the person in charge that we wouldn’t cook or eat pork on the property, and to persuade a soldier to give up the only room that wasn’t overcrowded with a k’ang. Clearly, the hope of receiving a few coins in the morning, which he wasn’t disappointed by, along with the chance—unless he was Muslim—to get rid of some leftover scraps from our meals and maybe a couple of empty tin cans was enough reward for him. Where our female companion spent the night remains a mystery, as although she immediately followed us to the new inn, we didn’t see her again after she got off the cart until she crawled out of it the next noon, fifty li further on.
There was time for a stroll before the sun withdrew its genial companionship. Great masses of crumpled mountains, treeless and velvet-brown, lay just across the river, which here was partly open, with a current of perhaps five miles an hour. No wonder it had to turn out for so mighty a barrier, and double the journey that was left us. On our side of the stream stretches of tall, light-yellow bunchgrass and a kind of sage, of slightly purplish tinge under the sinking sun, were broken by long rows of sand-dunes. In the morning the north sides of these were white with hoar-frost and helped a bit to light the way for us before daylight. Files of coolies who might easily have been bandits—we wondered if many of them were not brigands who had turned in their weapons and disbanded for the winter—were constantly appearing out of the brush and hillocks of this and the other uninhabited deserts beyond. Many of them wore a kind of makeshift turban of pure unspun wool, and all were dressed for cold weather, often in combinations of skin coats and cotton-padded garments that made them picturesque figures. How many hundreds of these we passed on our journey northward there is no way of computing, nor of knowing whether they were followers of some bandit chieftain who would take to the road again in the region ahead, which had been so harassed of late, as soon as the weather made banditry pleasant and travelers plentiful once more. Perhaps they were all what the few we spoke with claimed to be,—men who had taken rafts down the river, or coolies who had worked in Mongolia or Manchuria during the summer and were now walking a thousand miles or more back to their homes, as men do by the millions in overcrowded China.
There was time for a walk before the sun lost its warm company. Large, crumpled mountains, bare and a rich brown color, stretched across the river, which was partly open here, with a current of about five miles an hour. No wonder it had to bend around such a massive barrier, doubling the journey ahead of us. On our side of the river, swathes of tall, light-yellow bunchgrass and a type of sage with a slightly purplish tint under the setting sun were interrupted by long rows of sand dunes. In the morning, the north sides of these dunes were frosted white, providing some light for us before dawn. Groups of laborers, who could easily be mistaken for bandits—we speculated if many were indeed brigands who had laid down their weapons for the winter—were always emerging from the brush and hills of this and the other uninhabited deserts nearby. Many of them wore a makeshift turban made of pure unspun wool, and all were dressed for colder weather, often in a mix of fur coats and cotton-padded clothing that made them striking figures. There's no way to calculate how many hundreds of these we passed on our journey north, nor to know if they were followers of some bandit leader who would take to the roads again in that area, which had been troubled lately, once the weather made banditry appealing and travelers frequent again. Perhaps they were all what the few we spoke to claimed to be—men who had come down the river on rafts, or laborers who had worked in Mongolia or Manchuria over the summer and were now trekking back home for a thousand miles or more, just like millions do in overcrowded China.
We were constantly meeting these hardy fellows far from any other evidences of human existence. Long lines of them, bundled up in all they possessed, emerged from the darkness of early morning, one or two perhaps singing in a mixture of minors and falsettos that recalled the songs of the country people of Venezuela. Occasionally a straggler limped past far out on the dreary plain; but with few exceptions they kept the pace, and the cheerful countenances of perfect contentment. We always came upon a group of them at the single lonely huts that were often the only possible stopping-places during the whole day, 490sitting in a sunny corner sheltered from the wind at noon, perhaps stripped to the waist and diligently searching the seams of their thick padded garments, or already stretched out on the crowded k’angs where we halted for the night; for they seemed to prefer to travel in the darkness of morning rather than of evening. Probably, too, they had in mind the sharp competition for k’ang space, if not also for food and fuel, and the necessity of arriving early if they would be sure of accommodations at these only shelters for forty or fifty li in either direction.
We kept running into these tough individuals far from any signs of human life. Long lines of them, bundled up in everything they owned, would appear from the early morning darkness, one or two maybe singing in a mix of low notes and high voices that reminded us of the songs from the rural areas of Venezuela. Occasionally, a loner would limp by on the bleak plain, but for the most part, they maintained their pace, their faces radiating pure contentment. We often found a group of them at the solitary huts that served as the only possible resting spots throughout the day, sitting in a sunny corner out of the wind at noon, perhaps shirtless and carefully checking the seams of their thick padded clothes, or already laid out on the crowded k’angs where we stopped for the night; they seemed to prefer traveling in the morning dark rather than the evening. They likely considered the fierce competition for k’ang space, along with food and fuel, and knew they had to arrive early to ensure they could get accommodations at these rare shelters available for forty or fifty li in either direction.
The fixed price of lodging for a coolie in these inns seemed to be five coppers; then there was five “cash” or a copper for hot water for their tea, and not more, probably, for each of their two meals than for lodging; so that the innkeeper got about the equivalent of one to three American cents from each guest, depending on whether he stopped at noon or overnight, and the total expenditure of each coolie perhaps averaged four cents a day, besides the bit of food some carried with them. Now and again they no doubt cut down this extravagant figure by skipping a meal or, like the several score we saw streaming away from a temple early one morning, finding shelter at a lower price. Many of these coolies hardly looked Chinese at all, though it might be difficult to decide what other blood had modified their features. In fact, the northern Chinese, especially outside the larger cities, with their strong bodies and sturdy faces, bear little resemblance to the common Western conception of the sly, slender, pigtailed Celestial; I doubt very much whether the American boy whose only acquaintance with the race has been through the “movies” or a rare laundryman from Kwangtung in the far south would have recognized as Chinese our chief driver, with his strong, almost Roman nose, his leather-dark complexion, and his attributes of a real man even in the Occidental sense.
The fixed price for a coolie's stay in these inns was about five coppers; then there was an additional five “cash” or a copper for hot water for tea, and probably not much more for each of their two meals than for lodging. This means the innkeeper made roughly the equivalent of one to three American cents from each guest, depending on whether they stayed for just the day or overnight. In total, each coolie likely spent around four cents a day, not including any food they might have brought with them. Occasionally, they probably lowered this already small amount by skipping a meal or, like the several dozen we saw leaving a temple one morning, finding a place to stay for cheaper. Many of these coolies didn’t look traditionally Chinese at all, though it could be hard to pin down what other ancestry may have influenced their features. In fact, the northern Chinese, particularly those outside the bigger cities, with their strong builds and sturdy faces, bear little resemblance to the common Western stereotype of the sly, slender, pigtailed Chinese person. I seriously doubt whether an American kid whose only exposure to the culture has been through movies or the occasional laundryman from Kwangtung in the far south would even recognize our main driver, with his strong, almost Roman nose, his dark, leathery complexion, and his masculine traits even by Western standards.
Though one seldom finds the doubtful joys of chewing tobacco appreciated outside the confines of the Western hemisphere north of the Rio Grande, it was something of a surprise to discover how many Chinese do not even smoke it. Probably the chief reason is that they cannot afford it, though ten cigarettes in gaily decorated packages can be bought for the equivalent of two cents. This would have accounted for the fact that so many of these coolie groups were abstainers. Those who did smoke used the little pipes with long stems, of about the capacity of half a hazelnut shell, familiar to Korea and Japan as well as to China; and their pale tobacco of the texture of fine hay was so mild as hardly to seem to Western taste derived from the dreadful weed at all. Whenever I distributed a few pinches of a brand widely 491known in the United States the result was a series of sudden coughing spells and the laughing admission that Mei-guo yen is painfully strong. Our cartmen, however, who alternately smoked a larger pipe with a porcelain stem of the size of a policeman’s club, either came to prefer the taste of American tobacco or found it more economical to ask for an occasional pinch from my can than to untie their own strings of “cash.” Several large corporations, all, I believe, British or American, are expending great efforts and vast sums to teach the Chinese the highest possible consumption of cigarettes; and their wares and their “advertising vandalism,” as a more serious-minded traveler has justly called it, are to be found even in the villages and along the main roads of the far interior. But they are hampered by the problem of how to produce a cigarette that can be sold at prices the consumer can afford to pay, even though the wages in their Chinese factories are in keeping with those elsewhere in the country. The fact that the revenue-stamp, which represents so large a proportion of the American’s smoking expenditures, is missing still does not solve the difficulty. Like opium, tobacco was brought to—not to say imposed upon—the Chinese from outside, and not many centuries ago. The weed has not been known in China as long as it has in Europe, to say nothing of America. Long after Sir Walter Raleigh frightened his admirers by causing smoke to issue from his nostrils tobacco was brought to Japan by the Portuguese or the Dutch; from there it crossed to Korea, drifting naturally into Manchuria, and the Manchus introduced it into China along with the cue in 1644.
Though you rarely find the questionable pleasures of chewing tobacco appreciated outside the Western world north of the Rio Grande, it was surprising to learn how many Chinese people don’t even smoke it. The main reason is probably that they can’t afford it, even though ten cigarettes in brightly colored packages can be bought for the equivalent of two cents. This probably explains why so many of these labor groups didn’t partake. Those who did smoke used small pipes with long stems, about the size of half a hazelnut shell, familiar to Korea, Japan, and China; their light tobacco, with a texture like fine hay, was so mild that it hardly resembled the harsh weed favored by Westerners. Whenever I handed out a few pinches of a brand popular in the United States, it resulted in sudden coughing fits and the laughing admission that Mei-guo yen is painfully strong. Our cart drivers, however, who alternated smoking a larger pipe with a porcelain stem about the size of a policeman’s club, either came to prefer the taste of American tobacco or found it more economical to ask for an occasional pinch from my can rather than untie their own strings of “cash.” Several large companies, all I believe British or American, are investing significant efforts and money to get the Chinese to consume as many cigarettes as possible; their products and their “advertising vandalism,” as a more serious traveler has rightly called it, can even be found in villages and along main roads deep in the interior. But they face the challenge of producing a cigarette that can be sold at prices consumers can afford, even though the wages in their Chinese factories are comparable to those elsewhere in the country. The absence of a revenue stamp, which makes up a large portion of the American smoking expenses, still doesn’t resolve the issue. Like opium, tobacco was brought to—if not imposed upon—the Chinese from abroad, and not many centuries ago. The plant hasn’t been known in China as long as it has in Europe, let alone America. Long after Sir Walter Raleigh shocked people by making smoke come out of his nostrils, tobacco was introduced to Japan by the Portuguese or the Dutch; from there it spread to Korea, naturally making its way to Manchuria, where the Manchus brought it into China along with the pigtail in 1644.
Scrub trees rose above the tall light-yellow clumps of tough grass during most of the day beyond the general’s inn. Pheasants flew up here and there in large flocks. Once we passed a Mongol rounding up a herd of shaggy, half-wild ponies. We should have known him by his bent-knee yet cowboy-perfect riding in spite of his Chinese sheepskin dress, by his full-blooded, red face, “like a brewer’s drayman in—England,” as some one has put it, even if he had not been unable to understand Chang when we found the road suddenly missing where the river had licked away the side of a hill to which it formerly clung. Now and then we met a Mongol riding a camel at a trot across the bushy country, and a large scattered group or two of these animals were browsing on the tough yellow grass as if it were delicious. Our horses invariably showed fright at a close view of a camel, perhaps because they could not bear the sight of such ungainly ugliness, for certainly 492the two-humped beasts never gave the least indication either of the desire or of the ability to harm their more graceful rivals in the business of transportation.
Scrub trees towered over the tall light-yellow patches of tough grass for most of the day beyond the general's inn. Pheasants flapped up here and there in large flocks. Once we passed a Mongol rounding up a herd of shaggy, half-wild ponies. We could have recognized him by his bent-knee but still flawless riding, despite his Chinese sheepskin outfit, and by his full-blooded, reddened face, “like a brewer’s drayman in—England,” as someone described it, even if he hadn’t been able to understand Chang when we suddenly found the road gone, where the river had eroded the side of a hill it once clung to. Occasionally, we encountered a Mongol trotting by on a camel across the bushy land, and a large scattered group or two of these animals grazed on the tough yellow grass as if it were a treat. Our horses always spooked at the sight of a camel up close, perhaps because they couldn’t stand the sight of such awkward ugliness, since the two-humped creatures never showed the slightest indication of wanting or being able to harm their more graceful rivals in the transportation department.
Tungkou on the further side of a large bay formed by the Hoang Ho was a town of some importance, evidently a principal port during the season of river traffic, for huge boats built of hand-hewn planks and divided into several partitioned compartments were drawn up in considerable number on the shore. There were half a dozen new fortresses, some of two stories, or with a kind of cupola from which the coming of enemies, such as a force of bandits, could be seen some distance off; and many of the large compounds of the town were also freshly built of the same straw and yellow mud, though there was nothing new or clean about the old familiar, staring, easily laughing inhabitants. In certain moods, such as come at the ends of many long days of hard travel, there is a feeling of loneliness, of indescribable depression, in being long gazed at by multitudes, as if one were a wild beast, or a circus clown. The telegraph line of two wires which serves this region jumped the river at Tungkou in one mighty leap between double and reinforced poles on the two banks and plunged on into a Sahara of high drifted sand-ridges, over which we found our way with difficulty during the first hours of the next morning.
Tungkou, located on the far side of a large bay formed by the Hoang Ho, was a town of some significance, clearly a major port during the river traffic season. There were many large boats made from hand-carved planks, divided into several sections, lined up on the shore. Half a dozen new fortresses stood, some two stories high, featuring a kind of dome where the arrival of enemies, like bandits, could be spotted from a distance. Many of the big compounds in the town were newly built with straw and yellow mud, though the old, familiar, wide-eyed, and easily amused inhabitants had neither a new nor clean appearance. In certain moods, often after many long, exhausting travel days, there's a feeling of loneliness and indescribable sadness that comes from being stared at by crowds, as if you were a wild animal or a circus clown. The telegraph line, consisting of two wires, crossed the river at Tungkou in one bold leap between double and reinforced poles on each bank and continued into a desert of high sand ridges, which we struggled to navigate during the first hours of the next morning.
Then for several days irrigation took the place of desert again, and we passed towns that claimed to be entirely Catholic. After the Mohammedan rebellion a certain order of that faith began work in the almost unpeopled region along this northwesternmost elbow of the Yellow River, copying the irrigation systems of their Jesuit forerunners of centuries before a bit farther south and building up town after town in which none but Catholic converts are really welcomed. As the broad river valley was barely used at all before the priests came, except for grazing, and was but lightly populated, there can scarcely be any criticism of them on that score. San-shun-gung and Poronor were perhaps the most important of the dozen or more of these towns through which we passed, and which appeared with great regularity every forty li, sometimes every twenty. The first named was walled, rather recently and with mud bricks, perhaps because it was the seat of the bishop, whose residence close to the large church, with a belfry building distinct from it, might have looked less imposing in other surroundings than the usual low, mud-built Chinese village. Services were in full swing, with most of the inhabitants audibly in attendance and the streets deserted, when we passed through this place early one morning; 493but Poronor of the Mongol name was a noonday halt and we had opportunity there for a chat with the local ruler. He was a Belgian priest, as in the other larger towns, and bourgmestre, too, as he called it; for the priest is always the town mayor and chief authority, though there may also be a Chinese or Mongol “mandarin.” While we were being entertained with wine and cigars in his laboratory-office—for he took account of the bodily as well as the political and spiritual ailments of his converts—a large group of Mohammedan soldiers left a procession of them that was straggling down from the northeast and gathered in the yard, to peer in at us through the glass windows. They were pestering him to death, the priest said, new groups coming every day to ask him to furnish them carts and animals, and naturally drivers, in which to continue their journey. He had done so several times, but was now refusing the request; and nothing could be better proof of the real authority of the foreign priests of that distant Yellow River valley than the fact that the soldiers did not take transportation facilities by force when he declined to furnish them.
Then for several days, irrigation replaced the desert again, and we passed towns that claimed to be entirely Catholic. After the Muslim rebellion, a certain order of that faith began working in the nearly uninhabited area along the northwesternmost bend of the Yellow River, replicating the irrigation systems of their Jesuit predecessors from centuries earlier a bit further south and building town after town where only Catholic converts were truly welcome. Since the broad river valley was hardly used before the priests arrived, except for grazing, and was sparsely populated, there can hardly be any criticism of them on that front. San-shun-gung and Poronor were probably the most significant of the more than a dozen towns we passed through, which appeared quite regularly every forty li, sometimes every twenty. The first town was walled, relatively recently built with mud bricks, possibly because it was the seat of the bishop, whose residence was near the large church, with a separate belfry that might have looked less impressive in other surroundings than the typical low, mud-built Chinese village. Services were in full swing, with most of the residents clearly in attendance and the streets empty when we passed through this place early one morning; 493 but Poronor, with its Mongol name, was a stop at noon, and we had the chance to chat with the local ruler. He was a Belgian priest, just like in the other larger towns, and also referred to himself as mayor; the priest is always the town mayor and main authority, although there may also be a Chinese or Mongol “mandarin.” While we were being entertained with wine and cigars in his laboratory-office—since he took care of both the physical and the political and spiritual needs of his converts—a large group of Muslim soldiers from a procession straggling down from the northeast gathered in the yard to peer in at us through the glass windows. They were pestering him endlessly, the priest said, with new groups coming every day asking him to provide carts and animals, and naturally drivers, to continue their journey. He had helped out several times, but he was now refusing their request; and nothing could better prove the real authority of the foreign priests in that distant Yellow River valley than the fact that the soldiers did not take transportation by force when he declined to provide it.
On the other hand, any criminal whom the bourgmestre wished to be rid of was turned over to the Mohammedan commanders. The converts were almost exclusively Chinese; for there were naturally no converted Moslems, and only a few Mongol Catholics, who lived in two small villages back toward the hills. In one town where we spent the night the priest was for the moment absent, but this did not hinder us from getting a fairly clear view of his establishment. The large windows of glass—so unusual in western China—along the inner side of the church and the priest’s study disclosed rather bare rooms, the former with a few lithographed saints and benches or kneeling-boards some six inches high and wide, the latter with a rough Chinese-made easy-chair and table and the indispensable paraphernalia of the priestly calling, including a score of rather dog-eared books. Barely had we entered the compound than a flock of boys swooped noisily down upon us. They were “orphans” of the little mud school in a corner of the enclosure, or sons of the townspeople; and they were rather poor witnesses to the advantages of Catholic training, at least in deportment. For not only were they undisciplined but very decidedly “fresh,” and certainly there had been no improvement over “heathen” Chinese children in the matter of wiping their noses and using soap and water. While they were crowded about us the priest’s native assistant appeared and put us through the usual autobiographical catechism required of any lone foreigner surrounded by Chinese, then reciprocated with 494shreds of information expressed in scattered words of Chinese, French, and Latin. Finally he led the way toward, but not into, the schoolroom, for the flock of unwiped noses surged pell-mell ahead of us and when we entered they were all kneeling in their places on tiny benches similar to those in the church, with their forearms on their home-made desks, chanting at the tops of their voices and at express speed some Latin invocation which probably had about as little meaning to them as it had to us. The assistant proudly announced himself the teacher and displayed his few treasures of learning, among which a religious book printed in Latin and Chinese on opposite pages was plainly the most revered. When at length he was moved to silence the chanted uproar, and we pronounced a few of the Latin words at his request, he gave extravagant signs of delight, much as a great scientist might if a colleague unexpectedly confirmed some fine point on which his own experiments had focused themselves.
On the other hand, any criminal the bourgmestre wanted to get rid of was handed over to the Mohammedan commanders. The converts were mostly Chinese, as there were naturally no converted Muslims and only a few Mongol Catholics, who lived in two small villages back in the hills. In one town where we spent the night, the priest was temporarily absent, but that didn’t stop us from getting a pretty good look at his place. The large glass windows—so uncommon in western China—on the inside of the church and the priest’s study revealed quite bare rooms. The church had a few lithographed saints and benches or kneeling boards about six inches high and wide. The study contained a rough Chinese-made easy chair and table along with the essential items for a priest’s work, including a stack of rather worn books. As soon as we entered the compound, a bunch of boys noisily charged at us. They were “orphans” from a little mud school in one corner of the enclosure, or children of the townspeople; and they were not exactly the best advertisement for Catholic education, at least in terms of behavior. They were not only unruly but also rather cheeky, showing no noticeable improvement over “heathen” Chinese kids regarding wiping their noses and using soap and water. While they crowded around us, the priest’s local assistant showed up and put us through the usual autobiographical questions that any lone foreigner surrounded by Chinese faces must endure, then responded with bits of information communicated in scattered words of Chinese, French, and Latin. Eventually, he led us toward, but not into, the schoolroom, as the swarm of unwiped noses rushed ahead of us. When we entered, they were all kneeling in their spots on tiny benches like those in the church, with their forearms resting on their makeshift desks, loudly chanting some Latin invocation at lightning speed that probably meant as little to them as it did to us. The assistant proudly introduced himself as the teacher and showcased his few prized items of knowledge, among which a religious book printed in Latin and Chinese on opposite pages was clearly the most prized. When he finally decided to quiet the chanting, and we pronounced a few Latin words at his request, he reacted with enthusiasm, much like a great scientist might if a colleague suddenly confirmed some fine point that his own research had focused on.
Bound and unbound feet were about equally in evidence in these Catholic towns, as if in such minor matters as this and the use of handkerchiefs converts might do as they saw fit. Nor could we see any appreciable advance in living conditions, though the school-girls of Poronor, in their bright red trousers and jackets, were a picturesque touch which made up somewhat for the annoyance of eating in the presence of as mighty a mob audience as in regions never blessed with Christianity. Chang reported, too, that people along the way told him that the Catholic Chinese were heartily disliked, because they were not only unusually dishonest and rather haughty, but because they might do any mean trick that suggested itself, and the priests invariably upheld them, even to using their influence in resultant lawsuits.
Bound and unbound feet were equally common in these Catholic towns, as if when it came to minor details like this and using handkerchiefs, converts felt free to choose what they preferred. We also didn’t notice any significant improvement in living conditions, although the school girls of Poronor, dressed in their bright red trousers and jackets, added a charming element that somewhat balanced out the inconvenience of dining in front of such a large, rowdy crowd, similar to places that had never embraced Christianity. Chang also mentioned that people along the way told him that the Catholic Chinese were widely disliked because they were not just unusually dishonest and somewhat arrogant, but also because they would resort to any petty deceit that came to mind, and the priests consistently supported them, even using their influence in related legal matters.
The broad valley between hazy and even invisible mountain ranges on one side and, on the other, a river which we hardly saw during the last week of the journey was sometimes a sea of yellow grass high as a horseman’s head and sometimes a big bare plain deliberately cut up by irrigation ditches so wide that there was often no crossing them without many miles of detour. There were times when a compass seemed necessary, so uncertain was the course of the meandering “road,” which even the experienced carters now and again lost completely. Travel was slight, and every few miles a herdsmen’s hut all but hidden in the tall grass was the only sign of population. Thousands of acres of these uncultivated plains had been dug up and burned over, probably by men who make their living by gathering marmot skins, 495though there were no visible evidences of these gopher-like animals, which retire to their holes for the winter. Snow fell during the night that we spent in Hoang-yang-muto—“Antelope Woods,” so named, no doubt, because there is not a tree and certainly not a “yellow sheep” to be seen for many miles roundabout, and all the next morning our horses were hampered by great balls of snow and earth that formed beneath their hoofs, and which we were forced to remove ourselves, for our brave mafu avoided any unnecessary familiarity with his charges. But by the middle of the afternoon the landscape had resumed its brown-yellow coloring and never lost it again during the journey.
The wide valley between hazy, sometimes hidden mountain ranges on one side and a river we barely noticed during the last week of our journey on the other side was occasionally a sea of tall yellow grass, reaching up to a rider's head. At other times, it was a large bare plain, intentionally crisscrossed by irrigation ditches so wide that often we had to take long detours to get around them. There were moments when a compass felt essential, as the winding “road” was so unpredictable that even the seasoned cart drivers sometimes completely lost their way. Travel was infrequent, and every few miles we would see a herdsman's hut mostly concealed in the tall grass, the only sign of life. Thousands of acres of these uncultivated plains had been dug up and burned, likely by people who made their living collecting marmot skins, even though there were no visible signs of these gopher-like animals, which hibernate in their burrows for the winter. Snow fell during the night we spent in Hoang-yang-muto—“Antelope Woods,” a name that probably comes from the fact that there isn’t a tree in sight and certainly not a “yellow sheep” for many miles. The next morning, our horses struggled with large clumps of snow and dirt that built up under their hooves, which we had to clear away ourselves since our brave mafu avoided any unnecessary closeness with his animals. But by mid-afternoon, the landscape had returned to its brown-yellow hues, which stayed consistent for the rest of the journey.
Not long after the Catholics disappeared, big Mongol lamaseries began to rise every few hours above the horizon. These were much more pretentious than anything else between Ningsia and Paotou, the big main building always two and sometimes three stories high and constructed of good modern brick. From a distance they looked like ugly summer hotels that had been foisted upon the simple country, but a nearer view always showed the dozen or more big windows in each wall to be mere bricked-up pretenses of the openings they resembled. Evidently the “Living Buddhas” who graced these establishments had attempted to copy what they considered to be the glories of Shanghai or Tientsin, but could not rid themselves of the notion that a proper dwelling must be as stuffy as a Mongol felt tent. Even the clusters of white houses about these poor imitations of modern Italian villas bore false windows, and only the turnip-shaped dagobas had anything suggestive of the picturesque about them. Swarms of dirty lamas in yellow, red, and purple robes, big stout fellows of every age from boy novices to those whose already almost visible skulls would soon be the playthings of dogs, poured forth from these places if we rode in among the buildings, from which sometimes came ritual noises that were a mixture of the terrifying and the childishly ridiculous. Nor was there any lack of women about these monasteries, in quantities of gaudy jewelry and with real feet.
Not long after the Catholics vanished, large Mongol lamaseries started to pop up every few hours on the horizon. These were much more extravagant than anything else between Ningsia and Paotou, with the main building typically two and sometimes three stories high, made of decent modern brick. From a distance, they looked like ugly summer hotels that had been imposed on the simple countryside, but a closer look revealed that the dozen or more large windows in each wall were just bricked-up fakes of the openings they mimicked. Clearly, the “Living Buddhas” who ran these places tried to replicate what they saw as the splendors of Shanghai or Tientsin, but couldn’t shake the idea that a proper home had to be as cramped as a Mongol felt tent. Even the clusters of white houses surrounding these poor imitations of modern Italian villas had fake windows, and only the turnip-shaped dagobas had anything remotely picturesque about them. Swarms of dirty lamas in yellow, red, and purple robes, big hefty guys of all ages from boy novices to those whose almost visible skulls would soon become dog toys, poured out from these buildings when we rode among them, from which sometimes came ritual sounds that were a mix of terrifying and childishly silly. And there were plenty of women around these monasteries, adorned with flashy jewelry and with actual feet.
The plain had been unbroken for days as far as the eye could see, giving the impression that the country was tilted and that we were for ever riding uphill, when a low mountain rose above the horizon at dawn on Friday which we barely reached by sunset on Saturday. All Sunday we plodded close along the foot of this, here and there passing a cluster of huts within a compound more often than not in ruins, but with the assertion in big characters whitewashed on their 496mud walls that they were “hotels.” Once or twice we stopped at Mongol or Chinese inns, but most of them were still “Hwei-Hwei,” which did not matter so much after the cook hit upon the happy expedient of telling the proprietors that the bacon he served us for breakfast was “American salt beef.”
The plain had been flat for days as far as we could see, making it seem like the land was slanted and we were always going uphill, when a low mountain appeared on the horizon at dawn on Friday, which we barely reached by sunset on Saturday. All day Sunday we trudged along the base of this mountain, occasionally passing a cluster of huts within a compound, often in ruins, but with big letters whitewashed on their mud walls claiming they were “hotels.” Once or twice we stopped at Mongol or Chinese inns, but most of them were still “Hwei-Hwei,” which didn’t matter much after the cook cleverly told the owners that the bacon he served us for breakfast was “American salt beef.” 496
Though we had expected it almost any day on this journey northward, it was not until this last Sunday night of the trip that we could not get a room to ourselves. The isolated inn at which darkness overtook us consisted of one huge room surely a hundred feet long, with an alleyway from door to “kitchen” and a narrow lateral passage to the end walls, otherwise completely taken up by the four k’angs thus divided. These were already crowded with scores of coolies, ox-cart drivers, and similar travelers much more interesting to look upon than as bedfellows. Luckily there was one paper window in a far corner, and there we gave orders to have the last ten feet of the k’ang swept, the walls dusted, and a blanket and the reed mat we did not need hung up as curtains. If there were drawbacks to this improvised chamber, such as listening to the eating, sleeping, and drinking noises of our fellow-guests, the place at least was warm, thanks not only to the bodily heat of the several scores of men but to as roaring a fire as poor fuel could produce in the mud cook-stove that passed its surplus warmth into the flues beneath the general beds. For the last few days inn “kitchens” had been fitted with an immense shallow iron kettle set permanently into the adobe stove, and from this any one who wanted boiled water dipped it. About such inconveniences our cook competed with the flocking coolies who prepared their own humble fare, but it rarely needed even the commanding word of Chang to impress them with the fact that such great personages as ourselves naturally should have precedence over the mere garden variety of mankind.
Although we had anticipated it almost any day during our trip north, it wasn’t until this last Sunday night that we couldn't find a room to ourselves. The isolated inn where we ended up was made up of one large room, probably a hundred feet long, with a walkway from the door to the "kitchen" and a narrow passage to the end walls, which were otherwise entirely filled with four k’angs divided off. These were already packed with dozens of coolies, ox-cart drivers, and other travelers who were much more interesting to look at than to share a bed with. Luckily, there was one paper window in a far corner, so we requested that the last ten feet of the k’ang be swept, the walls dusted, and a blanket along with the reed mat we didn't need be hung up as curtains. If there were downsides to this makeshift room, like hearing the eating, sleeping, and drinking sounds of our fellow guests, at least it was warm, thanks not only to the body heat of the many men crammed in but also to a roaring fire that poor fuel could generate in the mud cook-stove, which radiated extra warmth into the flues under the communal beds. For the last few days, inn "kitchens" had been equipped with a huge shallow iron kettle permanently set into the adobe stove, and anyone wanting boiled water could dip from it. Our cook dealt with the inconveniences while competing with the gathering coolies who prepared their own simple meals, but it usually didn’t take even a commanding word from Chang to remind them that such important people as us naturally deserved to go first over the average folks.
Possibly the anxious reader is wondering how our lady companion met the trying situation of the total lack of privacy on that Sunday night. But there was no such problem. For when we had stepped forth into the darkness at the usual hour on the eighth morning out of Ningsia, the “tai-tai’s” cart was still sitting on its tail, thills in air, with a care-free something about it that should have made our own battered and road-weary wains envious. To our inquiry came the response, with more than a hint at our having been so unjust, that our pace was too swift for the lady, that rather than continue to get up every day long before daylight and ride often until after dark, with never a chance of getting out of her cart except at the noonday halt, she preferred to run the risk of being robbed or ill treated, even killed, by bandits, for she could endure it no longer. We refrained from making the obvious reply that, as far as our moderately tenacious memories informed us, we had never even suggested that she try to keep a foreigner’s pace; and thus we had parted, without an embrace, or even a kind word. Indeed, she had never spoken to us during all that intimate week, though I had caught her once or twice exchanging smiles with the major.
Possibly the anxious reader is wondering how our lady companion dealt with the challenging situation of having no privacy that Sunday night. But there was no issue at all. When we stepped out into the darkness at the usual hour on the eighth morning out of Ningsia, the “tai-tai’s” cart was still standing on its tail, hitch up in the air, with a carefree vibe that should have made our own battered, road-weary carts feel envious. In response to our inquiry, we received more than a hint of our unjustness: our pace was too fast for the lady, and rather than continue getting up every day long before dawn and riding often until after dark, with no chance to get out of her cart except at the noon stop, she preferred to risk being robbed, mistreated, or even killed by bandits, as she couldn’t take it anymore. We held back the obvious reply that, as far as our moderately good memories served us, we had never even suggested she keep a foreigner’s pace; and so we parted ways, without a hug or even a kind word. In fact, she had never spoken to us during that close week, though I had seen her exchange smiles with the major once or twice.

A typical farm hamlet of the Yellow River valley in the far west where some of the
farm-yards are surrounded by mud walls so mighty that they look like great armories
A typical farm village in the Yellow River valley in the far west, where some of the
farm yards are surrounded by mud walls so strong that they resemble huge fortresses.

The usual kitchen and heating-plant of a Chinese inn, and the kind on which our cook competed with hungry coolies in preparing our dinners
The typical kitchen and heating system of a Chinese inn, where our cook competed with hungry laborers to prepare our dinners.

The midwinter third-class coach in which I returned to Peking
The third-class coach in which I returned to Beijing during midwinter

No wonder I was mistaken for a Bolshevik and caused family tears when I turned up in Peking from the west
No surprise I was mistaken for a Bolshevik and caused family tears when I showed up in Beijing from the west.
497Hers was not the only complaint at our speed. The cook, who always sat huddled, nose in collar and hands in sleeves, on the front platform of one of the carts, a striking contrast to the cheery, well washed, and often-shaved driver beside him, confided to Chang one morning that he would not make this trip again, not even if we offered him a hundred dollars a month. As that is from five to twenty times the pay of a Chinese cook, even though he was speaking only in “Mex,” it may be surmised how bitterly he must have suffered during the journey. It never seemed to occur to him, however, that he would suffer less from cold, at least, if he would now and then get off and walk, like all the rest of us. Chang, on the other hand, prided himself on being a “coolie” able to endure anything, as well as having no “face” to lose, and though he visibly showed wear from his constant two months’ service under all conditions, he very seldom failed to produce not only whatever we asked for but a smiling countenance and a cheerful disposition in addition. It is considered bad form in China to show any human interest in one’s servants; in fact, it is usually unwise, as in much of the Orient, and likely to result in deterioration both of deportment and service. With Chang it was fairly safe, however, and I frequently indulged myself to the extent of inquiring whether he and the cook had a comfortable place to sleep. His unvarying reply was the smiling assertion, “Oh, I can sleep anywhere, master”; and the only night on the journey that I actually saw his quarters was this one in the crowded coolie inn. This he spent on a corner of the k’ang opposite our improvised chamber, where he could keep one eye on our belongings and the other on any of our fellow-guests overcome by curiosity to see how these wealthy and exclusive persons from some other world slept on the folding platforms they carried with them—as if the k’ang itself were not good enough for any one.
497Hers wasn’t the only complaint about our pace. The cook, who always sat hunched over, with his nose in his collar and hands tucked into his sleeves, on the front platform of one of the carts, was a stark contrast to the cheerful, well-groomed, and often-shaved driver next to him. One morning, he confided in Chang that he wouldn’t make this trip again, not even if we offered him a hundred dollars a month. Since that’s five to twenty times what a Chinese cook typically makes, even if he was just speaking “Mex,” it’s clear how much he must have suffered during the journey. It never seemed to cross his mind, though, that he would feel less cold if he occasionally got off and walked, like the rest of us. Chang, on the other hand, took pride in being a “coolie” capable of enduring anything, claiming to have no “face” to lose. Even though he showed the wear from two months of constant service under all conditions, he rarely failed to deliver not just whatever we asked for but also a smile and a cheerful attitude. In China, it’s considered bad manners to show any personal interest in your servants; in fact, it’s usually unwise, as it can lead to a decline in both behavior and service. With Chang, it was relatively safe, though, and I often indulged myself by asking if he and the cook had a comfortable place to sleep. His standard response was the smiling claim, “Oh, I can sleep anywhere, master,” and the only night during the journey that I actually saw his sleeping area was this one at the crowded coolie inn. He spent it in a corner of the k’ang opposite our makeshift room, where he could keep one eye on our belongings and the other on any fellow guests who were curious to see how these wealthy and exclusive people from another world slept on the folding platforms they brought with them—as if the k’ang itself wasn’t good enough for anyone.
We covered a hundred and twenty li on Monday, across a stony half-desert, never far from the base of the crumpled range that stuck 498persistently beside us on the left. White Mongol lamaseries clustered here and there well off the road in less accessible places, such as half-way up the face of the mountain wall. Now and again a Mongol high lama and his followers, all in brilliant yellow or a slightly dulled red, rode by with the motionless motion of good horsemen, on sturdy, sweating ponies. Ox-cart-wheels were again small and were usually solid disks of wood, and numbers of them were leisurely bringing in from the rail-head boxes and bales, marked with such names as Hamburg and Shanghai. Once we passed one of the crudest of these conveyances, drawn by two small, gaunt red oxen and driven by a man and a boy, with no other cargo than a dead man on his way to his ancestral home for burial. Over the massive coffin, which left room for nothing else beside it, was thrown a big brown bag or two of fodder, and beside this stood the inevitable rooster, in a willow-withe cage. It was not the pure white cock required by Chinese custom, however, but one almost as red as the big brilliant paper label, daubed with black characters, on the front of the coffin. Probably this was the best color available, for we could not recall having seen white fowls for many days, and no doubt the gods in charge of the souls thus kept united with every Chinese corpse take the difficulties of such a situation duly into consideration. Besides, there were evidences that the journey before the dead man was a long one; perhaps his ancestral home was away down in Shantung, in which case, at this rate of travel, the cock might be bleached to an approximate white by the time the expedition reached its destination.
We traveled a hundred and twenty li on Monday, through a rocky half-desert, always close to the base of the jagged mountain range that stuck 498 persistently on our left. White Mongol lamaseries dotted the landscape off the main road, often perched halfway up the mountain wall. Occasionally, a Mongolian high lama and his followers, dressed in bright yellow or a slightly faded red, passed by, moving smoothly on sturdy, sweating ponies. The ox-cart wheels were small, typically solid wooden disks, and many were leisurely transporting boxes and bales from the railhead, marked with names like Hamburg and Shanghai. Once we passed one of the simplest carts, pulled by two small, thin red oxen and driven by a man and a boy, carrying nothing but a dead man on his way to his ancestral home for burial. Over the heavy coffin, which left no space for anything else, were tossed a couple of large brown bags of fodder, and next to it stood the inevitable rooster in a willow cage. However, it wasn’t the pure white cock required by Chinese custom, but one that was nearly as red as the bright paper label, covered in black characters, on the front of the coffin. This was probably the best color they could find since we hadn’t seen any white chickens for many days, and surely the gods responsible for the souls connected to every Chinese corpse would take such difficulties into account. Moreover, it was clear that the journey ahead for the deceased would be a long one; perhaps his ancestral home was far down in Shantung, in which case, at this slow pace, the rooster might become bleached to near white by the time they reached their destination.
We finished the last seventy-five li on the run, and reached Paotou in time for a late lunch. Towns grew more and more frequent as we neared the city; the mountains closed in and began to push the Hoang Ho southward; a constant stream of traffic, of camels, cattle, donkeys, mules, horsemen, and pedestrians, grew up and increased in volume; our mafu climbed the steps of a little shrine in the wide dusty hollow that passed for a road to offer his thanks for his safe arrival—or for aid in avoiding work and gathering “squeeze” along the way; and at last the first suggestion of a city since Ningsia, twelve days behind, grew up out of the dust-haze ahead. Across the utterly treeless plain a poor makeshift wall climbed away up a barren hill colored with great patches of dyed cotton cloth drying in the sun. Some of this, which here and there brightened the town itself, was lama cloth, of saffron or maroon, contrasting with the blue so universally favored by the Chinese coolie. Perfect weather continued, but dust was thick as a 499London fog when we passed through the simple gate that separated an extensive suburb from the city proper, a gate on which hung the dried head of a bandit and inside which soldiers politely demanded some proof of our identity, such as a visiting-card, perhaps in order to be sure that we were real foreigners and not mere Russians, whom they might bully to their hearts’ content. For the last week of our journey there had been much talk of bandits. Earlier in the autumn many trips out from Paotou had been abandoned for fear of them; two or three times nervous innkeepers announced that tu-fei had been in their very courtyards a night or two ahead of us; several rumors that they were operating in the immediate vicinity reached our ears as we made our way placidly homeward; but that dried head on the gate was the only visible proof we ever had of their existence.
We ran the last seventy-five li and got to Paotou just in time for a late lunch. As we got closer to the city, towns appeared more frequently; the mountains closed in and pushed the Hoang Ho river southward. A steady stream of traffic—camels, cattle, donkeys, mules, riders, and pedestrians—grew in size. Our mafu climbed the steps of a small shrine in the wide dusty hollow that served as a road to give thanks for a safe arrival, or maybe to get out of work and collect “squeeze” along the way. Finally, the first hint of a city since Ningsia, twelve days earlier, emerged from the dust haze ahead. Across the completely treeless plain, a shabby wall climbed up a barren hill decorated with large patches of dyed cotton cloth drying in the sun. Some of this, which brightened the town itself in places, was lama cloth, in saffron or maroon, contrasting with the blue that was a favorite among the Chinese coolie. The perfect weather continued, but the dust was thick as a 499London fog as we passed through the simple gate that divided a sprawling suburb from the city, a gate adorned with the dried head of a bandit. Inside, soldiers politely asked for some proof of our identity, like a visiting card, perhaps to make sure we were real foreigners and not just Russians, whom they could bully without hesitation. In the past week, there had been a lot of talk about bandits. Earlier in the fall, many trips out from Paotou had been canceled because of fear of them; a couple of times, anxious innkeepers mentioned that tu-fei had been in their courtyards a night or two before us. Several rumors about their activity in the nearby area reached us as we made our way home peacefully, but that dried head on the gate was the only real evidence we ever had of their existence.
Paotouchen proved to be mainly a new town, built up by a constantly increasing population as the advance of the Suiyuan railway improves its importance as a trading-center. It is hilly enough so that we could see only portions of it at a time, and even those had nothing particularly new to offer. Moslems were here and there in evidence; Mongols rode silently through the soft earth streets; furs and sheepskins were a bit more numerous than the other wares, comprising everything sold in northern China, with which the principal thoroughfare was lined. Big shops, women with the tiniest of feet, extensive courtyards, some gaudy architecture, singsong-girls and the noisy hotel parties that go with them, and all the other attributes of a Chinese city, as distinguished from a village, even though the village be walled and populous, were to be seen in Paotouchen.
Paotouchen turned out to be mostly a new town, developed by a steadily growing population as the progress of the Suiyuan railway increased its significance as a trading hub. The area was hilly enough that we could only see parts of it at a time, and even then, nothing particularly new caught our eye. Muslims were present here and there; Mongols rode quietly through the soft earth streets; furs and sheepskins were a bit more common than the other goods, making up everything sold in northern China, which lined the main street. There were large shops, women with the tiniest feet, vast courtyards, some flashy architecture, singing girls, and the loud hotel parties that came with them, along with all the other features of a Chinese city, as opposed to a village, even if the village was walled and crowded, were visible in Paotouchen.
But the automobile that used to carry passengers from there to the rail-head was not, so that we had to make a new arrangement with our cartmen to finish the journey. We were off again quite as usual, therefore, at five in the morning for a twenty-third day of travel; though, including stops, we had been less than twenty-one full days on the road from Lanchow, which is seldom bettered. The eastern city gate, unimposing as the opposite one by which we had entered, and not even similarly decorated, opened without great delay at sight of the major’s card, and we struck away across another great plain, fertile, no doubt, but dismally bare except for the few clumps of leafless trees about the mud farm-houses. It was inevitable that a fantastic range should appear close on the left as the darkness faded, and follow us all the rest of the day. A few miles out of Paotou, before daylight, in fact, we found ourselves riding parallel to a railway embankment. 500This was some ten feet high, but quite new and made only of the soft local soil without a suggestion of stone in it, and struck in company with a lone telegraph-wire due eastward across the flat country, quite unaccustomed to such directness. It was easy to imagine what would happen to the embankment when the rains came, to say nothing of the temporary track down on the floor of the plain, which we came upon only seven or eight miles out, with a work-train already using it. For there was the usual refrain of anything or any one connected with the Chinese Government: money was not available to build bridges across the gaps in the embankment and finish the line properly, and it was only in this imperfect form that the Suiyuan railway reached Paotou barely a month behind us.
But the car that used to take passengers from there to the train station wasn’t available, so we had to make new arrangements with the cart drivers to complete the journey. We set off again as usual at five in the morning for our twenty-third day of travel; although, including stops, we had spent less than twenty-one full days on the road from Lanchow, which is pretty remarkable. The eastern city gate, as unimpressive as the opposite one we had entered, and not even decorated in a similar way, opened up without much delay when the major showed his card, and we headed across another vast plain, which was undoubtedly fertile but distressingly barren except for a few clusters of leafless trees around the muddy farmhouses. It was inevitable that a bizarre mountain range would appear close on the left as the darkness lifted, and follow us for the rest of the day. A few miles out of Paotou, in fact, we found ourselves riding next to a railway embankment. 500 It was about ten feet high, brand new, and made of the soft local soil without any hint of stone, stretching eastward across the flat land in a way that was quite unusual. It was easy to picture what would happen to the embankment when the rains came, not to mention the temporary track we encountered only seven or eight miles out, which a work train was already using. The usual story with anything related to the Chinese Government rang true: there was no money to build bridges over the gaps in the embankment and properly finish the line, and it was only in this incomplete state that the Suiyuan railway reached Paotou barely a month after us.
The first station was still sixty li east of it, however, when we returned to civilization, by a bad road full of stones, now between mud field-walls that tried in vain to confine it, now zigzagging across the bare fields. We passed through one large dilapidated town, high above which a striking peak stood out from the range, with a lama temple that looked like some elaborate tourist-resort part-way up it. Then the road became more and more crowded with travel, with sometimes ten or a dozen “Peking carts” in a row taking passengers to the train; but it still skated occasionally across a patch of ice before we came at last, soon after noon, to a lone station congested with travelers, goods, and halted caravans. Acres covered with huge chunks of coal were the most conspicuous of the exports awaiting transportation at that season, but it was easy to see how badly a railway out of Paotou was needed.
The first station was still sixty li east of it, but when we got back to civilization, we found ourselves on a rough road full of stones, moving between mud field-walls that tried in vain to contain it and zigzagging across the bare fields. We went through a large rundown town, high above which a striking peak stood out from the range, featuring a lama temple that resembled some fancy tourist resort part-way up. Then the road became increasingly crowded with travelers, with sometimes ten or twelve “Peking carts” lined up taking passengers to the train; but it still occasionally skated over a patch of ice before we finally arrived, soon after noon, at a lone station packed with travelers, goods, and stopped caravans. Acres filled with massive chunks of coal were the most noticeable exports waiting for transportation at that time of year, but it was clear how badly a railway out of Paotou was needed.
There was, of course, a free-for-all mêlée about the ticket-window, with no attempt by the several men strutting around in new police uniforms to bring a suggestion of order; but we were duly installed in the daily freight and third-class train when it rambled away an hour or so after our arrival. All the expedition was still with us except the two carts and their drivers. For the least reward we could give the pleasant-mannered Kansu ponies that had carried us, except when we walked beside them, 770 miles in three weeks, was a journey to Peking, even though we found when it was too late that their transportation would be higher than the fare charged a mere human passenger in the highest class available, and their accommodations an open car in which boulders of coal might at any moment come down and do them serious injury. Taking the horses meant, of course, that we had to be accessories before the fact in inflicting upon Chihli Province our 501putative mafu; and naturally the cook and Chang must be returned to the place where we had picked them up.
There was, of course, a chaotic scene at the ticket window, with no effort from the several guys strutting around in new police uniforms to bring any order; but we were eventually settled in the daily freight and third-class train when it left about an hour after we arrived. All our gear was still with us except for the two carts and their drivers. The least we could do for the friendly Kansu ponies that had taken us, except when we walked alongside them, 770 miles in three weeks, was to give them a ride to Peking, even though we later found out that their transportation would cost more than what a human passenger would pay for the highest class available, and their spots would be in an open car where boulders of coal could fall at any moment and seriously hurt them. Taking the horses meant, of course, that we had to be complicit in bringing our supposed *mafu* to Chihli Province; and naturally, the cook and Chang had to be returned to the place where we picked them up.
We had covered, we found, when a train seat gave a chance for figuring, 4400 li between the two railways, in other words 1320 miles, all in the saddle except the scant hundred by mule-litter. The hardy Chinese passengers on all sides of us were so warmly dressed in their cotton-padded and sheepskin garments that they kept the windows wide open, even though the car was innocent of so much as the makings of a fire. Our feet in particular suffered, as those of foreigners usually do in North China in winter, and called our attention more closely to the contrivances which the Chinese use to keep theirs warm. Leather there was none, except in a rare pair of Mongol boots, large enough for a dozen woolen socks inside. Felt, often in four thicknesses, sometimes in six, was the material of most shoes; one old man at a cold wayside station had on a pair of Greek tragedy buskins that looked like two hams cut open to admit the feet.
We figured out, while sitting on the train, that we had traveled 4400 li between the two railways, or 1320 miles, all on horseback except for a little bit by mule-litter. The tough Chinese passengers around us were so warmly dressed in their cotton-padded and sheepskin coats that they kept the windows wide open, even though there was no fire in the car. Our feet, like those of most foreigners in North China during the winter, really suffered and made us pay closer attention to how the Chinese kept theirs warm. There was hardly any leather, except for a rare pair of big Mongol boots that could fit a dozen woolen socks. Most shoes were made from felt, often in four or six layers; one old man at a chilly wayside station wore a pair of buskins that looked like two hams cut open for his feet.
That evening we reached Kweihwa, otherwise known as Suiyuan, just in time to transfer to the newly scheduled express to Peking. The major considered it suitable to the dignity of his calling to travel second class—there being no first on this line—and therefore had the pleasure of sitting up all night between two hard wooden bench-backs. Having myself no “face” to lose, I found the third-class coaches big and box-car-like, with plenty of room between the narrow benches along the walls to spread my cot and make my bed as usual. The car was full of men stretched out on the floor, the benches, or their saddlebag beds, but the small iron stove in the center of it did little to change it from a foreign to a Chinese bedroom—for night is the one part of the twenty-four hours when artificial heat is in great demand in wintertime China.
That evening we arrived in Kweihwa, also known as Suiyuan, just in time to catch the newly scheduled express train to Peking. The major thought it was appropriate for his position to travel second class—since there was no first class on this line—and thus had the pleasure of staying up all night between two hard wooden bench backs. I, having no “face” to maintain, found the third-class coaches spacious and boxy, with plenty of room between the narrow benches against the walls to set up my cot and make my bed like usual. The car was packed with men lying on the floor, the benches, or their saddlebag beds, but the small iron stove in the center did little to transform it from a foreign to a Chinese bedroom—since night is the one time in a day when artificial heat is highly needed in wintertime China.
In the cold morning hours I found Mongols, Chinese who had turned Mongols and lamas, women of that race ugly with dirt and jewelry, surly-looking Mohammedans with long red-tinged chin-whiskers and features that seemed almost of exaggerated Jewish type, and every variety of the ordinary Chinese of both sexes, all among my traveling-companions or those who got on or off during the day. Sometimes the distinction was not certain, for in their many raids upon the ancient empire the Mongols carried off so many Chinese women that the northern Chinese and the Mongols often look much alike. We were struck with the fact that there was much less pleasing simplicity here than among the timid country people far from such modern 502things as railroads. The Great Wall, now quite imposing, stretched for hour after hour along the base of the mountain range still on our left; but the Hoang Ho was gone, having turned abruptly southward not far from where we had taken the train, to keep that course to Tungkwan, hundreds of miles away, where we had entered the province of Shensi. Kalgan, already familiar, appeared in the early afternoon, then in due season Nankou Pass, with the best known and most striking section of China’s great artificial barrier, and soon after dark of the shortest, yet in some ways the longest, day of the year our respective families might have been dimly seen striving to identify us beneath the long failure to shave which our hasty home-coming had imposed upon us, as the express discharged its multitude at Hsi-chi-men on the far northwestern corner of Peking.
In the chilly morning hours, I encountered Mongols, Chinese who had become Mongols and lamas, women of that ethnicity who were dirty and adorned with jewelry, grumpy-looking Muslims with long, red-tinted beards and features that almost appeared exaggeratedly Jewish, and every kind of ordinary Chinese man and woman, all among my traveling companions or those who got on and off throughout the day. Sometimes, it was hard to tell the difference, as the Mongols had taken so many Chinese women during their numerous raids on the ancient empire that northern Chinese and Mongols often looked quite similar. We noticed that there was much less charming simplicity here compared to the shy country folks far away from modern 502things like railroads. The Great Wall, now quite impressive, extended for hour after hour along the base of the mountain range still on our left; however, the Yellow River was gone, having sharply turned southward not far from where we had boarded the train, continuing that way to Tungkwan, which is hundreds of miles away, where we had entered the province of Shensi. Kalgan, which we already recognized, appeared in the early afternoon, then in due time, Nankou Pass, with the most famous and striking section of China’s great artificial barrier, and soon after dark on the shortest, yet in some ways the longest, day of the year, our families might have been faintly seen trying to recognize us beneath the unshaven look that our hurried return home had imposed on us, as the express train unloaded its crowd at Hsi-chi-men on the far northwestern corner of Beijing.
TRANSCRIBER’S NOTES
- Silently corrected typographical errors and variations in spelling.
- Retained anachronistic, non-standard, and uncertain spellings as printed.
Download ePUB
If you like this ebook, consider a donation!